CorpusRecord 255732

Hartland School Board Meeting - January 7th, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Windsor Southeast Supervisory Union
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Windsor County, VT
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,296 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Laughter] what was the where were youing a basket okay so we'll call this meeting to order at 608 we late today um is there any public participation or announcements I think we'll have school related announcements in the administrative report yep um I will announc that there were definitely some parents including myself that were surprised that we didn't have school yesterday show no other people told me on Sunday that have a kid home on Monday well we've had an amazing Dei focused PD day all day that's yeah um so uh any other participation nope okay um any changes or additions to the agenda um okay I'm also not hearing anything okay um so I'll take a motion to approve the minutes of December 3D moved second by Heather um is there any further discussion except the

002fact that I swear these that month was two years ago it just felt like time travel one year ago yeah burned okay okay um I'll take uh oh we don't have to do a roll call because we're all here all those in favor of approving the minutes of uh December 3rd 2024 please say I all those opposed and an exstension for Ryan okay so Ryan's abstaining because he wasn't here last time okay um you're up all right administrative report there we go all right I'm going to start Emily with you and what I'll do is I'll get to this one you tell me when you want me to move the next slide you want to look at this oh that strange sorry stopped sharing I did share weird let try it's like frozen race what

003would you like me to do uh that's on my end that is not on your end I can build difficult we have fa in your race leave and come back e e e okay we're back we're back with technical difficulties can see all right Emily go for it I can't hear should be fixed oh all right good go Emily um first off happy New Year everybody thank you um hope everybody enjoyed the break and December was a great month um we had the the for8 Winter concert which was definitely cut down in time from two years ago's concert that was that needed like a dinner that was very was awesome um yeah that was good like I feel like like it normally is um yeah I put def Spring Concert there was a spaghetti dinner

004don't by e8th grade I have heard very positive things that they really did enjoy doing that I heard that they raised like $3,000 right around they did an awesome job they were great yeah um and then there was the variety show and there was a lot of people who also showed up to watch that and really enjoyed seeing what kids have worked for like I guess towards about to do it well there was also art oh yes thank you Miss steing yeah that com things last I liked that that I was like asking my teachers like what did they do seem so long ago yeah um this month I did or I guess last month I did the sixth grade um they did a project was grapes geography religion architecture politics economics and social structure

005um our Middle School social studies teacher does it with sixth grade seventh grade and eighth grade so we did the Grace Project last year and we did the mommy project last year which is the next project they did and I also heard positive things about that so yeah thank you yeah thank you for the student perspective and I will say my own we went to the eighth grade supper with my own two kids who are seven and three and they thought it was quite literally the best meal they've ever eaten no the no they thought it was the best meal they ever had they keep calling it the restaurant at school so they loved it yeah that was it was it was good um some upcoming events starting tomorrow uh we've got winter activities which

006is exciting yep it it'll be a cold one and we're running on as long as S6 does not cancel themselves we're going um and we will they will give us their thoughts on it tomorrow the 11th we've got a PTO family dance is that five Alexa five o'clock winter activities again on the 15th and no school on the 20th those are some on that yes no school 20th okay right all right okay I'm sorry that's right all right um a short report from me tonight because we're gonna focus on the budget most the meaning but um I wanted to bring back the figure on we talked about last month the printing of the budget book in color it's $10,000 I think that's a big no wa just fine yeah okay just want online is available

007it be available so how many like that's the cost of printing how many budget books uh whatever uh Larry I I don't know but Larry reached out to the town clerk to find out how many they usually print and use that number for um I mean we can easily put a QR code at the entrance to the meeting I know there just ways that we can like cut this in half because we can do half of it like yeah QR code I think if you try to do half of it you people will like like it's hard still a lot but like so we're not prining it at all it just be your regular report bu so there'll be no budget book is what you're saying no we'll have the budget numbers in the town

008report yes as normally in but if you want to see the graph Dynamic and yeah well all the detail will be in the town report like it always is but if you want to see the graphical display it'll have to be online and is that okay can we do that is something yeah well Larry will be on shortly I was just texting him um he's going to be virtual tonight but we can we've never had this before this is the first year oh this is brand new okay I feel like this is just a lot friendlier to understand got it okay I like the other way better show budget y sorry okay these are just reminders I know you know because I saw Heather and Hannah working on their signatures but just want to um

009say publicly that town meeting voting days is March 4th our budget information meeting is the 24th which was a change from the last time we chatted because it's now on a Monday it's on a Monday um and that is because we want um Larry to be able to be there can't be there on Tu yeah he coaches he coaches the Varsity Boys um warning will be posted in all the appropriate places by the 27th and then Heather and um Hannah are up for seats we're still gonna have the Su board meeting that night as well we are is going to start a little bit earlier and I'm going to be excused and so and maybe maybe I'll just so just oh I'm sorry I'm in the wrong month okay February 24th yeah it should be

010in your calendar should have an your calendar that was just to make sure okay um the other thing I I don't I think Nikki may have reached out to you but just wanted to bring to your attention and the Public's attention that our normal march meeting which is the four is election day um we did that last year remember yeah we have another meeting to rior so we're going to just move that meeting to the 11th the following Monday or Tuesday so that we can do a reorganization meeting and that should be in your calendar as well all right I don't think I reached up on that one yet because it was so far in advance that's okay calendars are tricky so um quarterly financials tonight you have in front of you printed they should

011be in the portal as well um so just had a um I worked looked at these with Larry earlier uh yesterday and in general we are in very good shape you can look down at the expenditures we are um in the black in um most categories wages benefits maintenance tuition um and we're over in a couple of areas but so far so good yeah the um tuition um difference of you know half a million dollars plus could be um movein move outs different choices in high school so that's I'm not sure exactly why but those would be the logical explanation for those so um we have not received all our um all the revenue has not come in yet so when you get to the final page page three and you look at the projected

012Revenue it is short of the projected expenditures but please do not panic because all the revenues have not coming yet so we are not concerned at this point I think that might be my last okay so let me just see if Larry has joined I don't know where we went let me close this and see if I can see oh say now so you start okay so just as a reminder these are the same slides from last month but if you're looking for where to find it on the website on the Heartland website to the right hand side FY 26 budget book is where you'll find it oh oh okay [Music] there any questions specifically on the budget book I pulled it up here does anyone have any questions and before Larry gets here um

013just uh so you know we've been working with the budget advisory committee we've met a couple of times they've gone over this with Larry and Lindsay and myself pretty thoroughly um and have helped in making some decisions around the budget for us so we appreciate their and um I think Alexa is here and Trac here and Trac is online and those are the members of the [Music] BAC do you want me to you a look confused all I heard was members of the public the they are members of the public Alex and Tracy are members of the public on the okay and they here tonight hi do you know everyone uh most everyone Larry is here let him get his going we're all gonna be like hyped upar okay do you need thank you all

014right there is Larry Larry we have just started um Lindsay pulled up the budget book I didn't know if there were any places in the budget book where you wanted to highlight or if you just want us to go back to the slides we can't hear Larry I can't hear you Larry Larry he'll figure it out maybe hop off and come back on I find that that's like that's like show it's a reboot button that's like what we do at work all the time right we have one person that's true restart every time he joins a meeting he sounds like a squirrel and then he like has to rejoin but we have to go through that we're just never gonna get through this meeting issues tonight yeah goodness we have a lot of food I

015know but we have to get through the meeting because once we hit the crash from the Su it's going to beug [Music] is every school making a budget Like Larry is the king of the budget book um yeah he found this tool app program whatever it is um and spent a lot of time building it yeah and it's actually pretty I think it's comprehensive it's transparent it's easy to use and understand so pretty we're pretty happy with it and I see that he's mut muted all right try again you yeah you can go back to the slides I mean unless anybody has any particular questions about the budget okay so the budget itself there were no changes from the current year this year to next year in terms of positions or supplies or anything it

016was um a carryover just just for a starting Place nothing was added so that budget is reflected in the budget book okay so that's what we have we're listening basically at the same budget as last year yes but of course the budget isre increased because of the health care costs St negotiated um contracts Etc so okay all right we'll go back to the slides and Larry you're on so this is um showing the uh tax worksheet so we are yet to receive um version four of the ltw ADM um we're currently on version three version one was not kind to Harland uh it was about 610 now it's as you can see the the second yellow box is 64099 before you go on Larry just for people that are watching this later can you explain

017what that is and why it's good or bad so uh when most people think of enrollment they think of per pupil so think of you know at Hartland for example if there's you know 270 students that are physically there and then maybe a 100 tuition students that go to high school that you pay for and then 270 plus 100 I'm just using round numbers that would be 370 uh but then Vermont takes that 370 and they say well a k6 student would be 1.0 but a high school student would be like 1.1 or 1.2 because the state assumes it costs a little more to educate a high school student than it does a k6 student if k6 is the Baseline then in addition they add you know free and reduced lunch if a student is

018uh on free and reduced lunch they get a little bit more than 1.0 uh interestingly enough prek is negative of a one um so with all those different things an elll is an additional category and so on and so forth that's how you get the 64099 there are not 640 students at Hartland either with the high schools or not um but that's what the state says um Harland has so that's what they use to assess the tax rate so I'm going to go through this go ahead you said this was version four this is version this is version three I expect to get vers for this week um and that could change it should stop at four stop they tell us that it should be four should be the final one and then uh if

019anything more than 64099 benefits Harland so if if version four is 642 64 for example it would be beneficial to Harland um if they come back and it's 6:30 that would be bad um as far as the tax ratees concerned so now I'm going to walk through the tax worksheet so the expenditures that's what's in the budget book 11597 and4 is the current fiscal year 26 budget in the budget book then you take away there's no offsetting revenues so offsetting revenues would be for example if Harland was part of a K12 District like mountney School District where they do receive tuition from towns you could use that as an offsetting Revenue Harland can't do that their tuition money only goes one way so 11.59 s then you have an ltw ADM of 640 that's the

020state provided number you take that number and divide it that's 640 divided by 11.59 million and that's how you come up with net education spending per ltw ADM which is 18,9 to okay so now you have there's no exclusions for Harland the only District in our Su that has an exclusion is we is fed with their bond payment so since there's no exclusions you're still you just carry that number forward 1892 now here's where things get tricky for Harland uh there's an estimated excess spending threshold of 15,928 so what the state says is that uh this threshold went away and now it's back they brought it back after last year and the excess spending threshold says no if you paid more than15 926 per ltw ADM then uh we're going to charge you an extra

021dollar for every dollar over that so Harland is at 1892 the difference between 15,928 and 1892 is 2166 they take that 2166 and they add it to the what they say is the threshold should be and as you can see that increases harland's uh excess spending to uh education spending plus XX spending to 66 then they take the homestead yield which is the December 1st tax letter that came out at 8,553 they take that 20258 you divide it by the 8,553 and you have an equalized homestead tax rate of $236 $236 86 C Larry can I question y um when you say Homestead yield who how do how is that number decided like what is that number and how is it decided that is decided by the tax commissioner so everyone in Vermont or everyone

022yes everyone in Vermont is eight whatever that number is I can't see the whole St yeah to put to put it another way is all the all the boxes that you see that aren't in yellow are have nothing really to do with Harland these are state things so they they set the yield and then we take that yield and that's how we determine the tax rate so basically it's a way of saying there's a Base education spending so they they said they yielded 8553 we divide that by the 20,000 that we want to spend per W ltw ADM and that's how you get a tax rate of $2 3686 then based on last year's Law act 84 some some districts is about I don't know I'm guessing 15ish districts Harland happens to be one of

023them they get a slight discount to help over time um benefit or to to to make less pressure on the ltw ADM system because as you know as as you may know we switched from equalized pupil for about 20 years now for the last two years we've used ltw ADM so we take that four cents we deduct that from the two $236 and that's how you get $232 so if you followed me along so far now I'm down to the third to the bottom the $232 now now we apply the CLA so the CLA uh for Harland went down a little bit um than the prior one this is the final CLA uh that unless they change it it's 89.4% we take that 89% this isn't the direct CLA so this is not comparable to

024last year's CLA it's the Statewide adjustment it's the new Statewide adjustment the new Statewide adjustment is I think it's 74% and they take that 74% and they take and they divide it by heartlands so they take the state one and they divide it by heartlands and that number is 89.4 so using last year's CLA Heartland CLA no I just wanted to say like to anybody that's listening this is not a comparable number to last year's CLA this is a different the state decided to play a shell game and this is the new number that reflects their new shell game which is the second number of this year which is the second number for this year and can I ask sorry you get there Larry the non-homestead tax rate is that why is that untethered from

025the homestead tax rate uh I think that's because of the CLA at Harland I believe so for example harland's an interesting compared to most of our other districts the non-homestead tax rate is actually higher for Mount Ascutney and sorry Windsor West Windsor and uh Weathersfield but at Harland it's actually lower what reason the CLA is not applied to the non- homesteads is that why no the CLA um but so the non-homestead anybody that's not a resident in the state yeah pays um non homested property yeah a set level that the safe levels so it's unrelated to Heartland yeah so because of that Rel with I think they should apply a CLA to it but I don't know if they they they do but this but you're close they do but it's the as you said

026earlier the state sets it and then then they apply the CLA so that so the state sets it and then they apply the CLA now it just so happens that in harland's case uh because their tax rate is 261 it is their homestead tax rate is higher than the non-homestead rate if that makes any sense yeah um I think one of the challenges is if we go back to the argument of like 10 years ago I think Heartland in the last two or three years has shifted from being a receiving town to a donor town like I feel like we're sending money to other communities to fund their schools now where we used to receive money from other schools and I don't know if that's true or not Larry but it's certainly feeling that way

027Harland is still a receiving town uh what I think I think the difference is and I I think the future slides will show this before I finish this slide um and I think it'll be very clear in a second uh you are donor town in the sense that uh any dollar over the excess spending threshold is is double taxed that money goes right into the education fund right in that we we used to receive more money from the state than we gave them is that still the case I don't know if you receive more I could look into that and get back to you on that I you you definitely receive money I whether or not it's more than what you spend I can look into that but it wouldn't feel so it wouldn't feel

028like more I'm asking Larry if we were under the threshold yeah then I'm going to get that's the next slide so just so just so everybody's aware of how we came to the 261 this is the worksheet and that's the 261 and I think the next slide I really nail down the difference on um the excess spending threshold so if we could go forward okay so now I'm really highlighting the tax rate so the homestead tax rate that you just saw the 261 and the non-homestead rate so using the excess spending threshold you can see at the 25 homestead tax rate was 230 the 26 with no changes to your budget at this current time is 261 that's a difference of 30 cents or a 13.3% increase with the excess spending threshold you see a

02913.3% tax increase without the ex spending threshold it would be a 1% tax increase so if so so your budget's up 5.91% and if there was no excess spending threshold your taxes would go up 1% for that 5.91 but be due to the excess spending thresold in the double taxation of that 20 some od100 it was your taxes are going up with no changes would go up 13.3% sorry Larry I I think I need you to explain that to me again so the ex the excess spending threshold is find how this year by the law but no right but here I'll take a stab at it so if we go back a slide um we are proposing to budget $188,900 yeah per Lum whatever I see I see I see so it's the state says

030we're only allowed to spend 15.9 thank you so we're over thank you I just I miss that the state's not saying you're only allowed to spend their saying you can spend whatever you want but we're going to double tax any dollar over that which that number seems kind of nuts but can I ask a question about tuition students so when we go to pay for kids who are going to whatever High School how much like what's the average charge for them because if that's over the 15,000 it's well over it's well so we are getting double taxed on kids who are like that's not fair because that's the weighted don't forget that's a weighted value whereas the tuition is per child right so that 15 if you go back a slide that that 18,000 that

031we're spending is actually based on 641 students Which is higher than the actual number of bodies whereas a tuition payment for one body is greater than but it is greater than 15,000 all our high school but our high schoolers are might be worth 1.2 so really it's still part you divided the tuition by I'm I'm just curious like what think what we penal like we're being penalized to send kids to high school which we have and the high schools can set their rights and that's what we P yeah did they cap that yet no were they going to we'll see how they put a threshold on one and not on the other like how can they not say oh because everybody on the education committee is from chitton County and none of them do that

032is why I I do I still think it's a little dising like these are not these are not comparable like this is a weighted value this is a weighted cost per child whereas tuition is a they still have sympathy for communities than that may be true but I think it I don't know that it's just the tuition like no I'm not saying that it's just the tuition but it's interesting to me and I would be interested to see like how much it actually costs if we waited and all like all the Like Larry are you able to look up what a high school student is on the ltw ADM we can answer this uh it's what do you mean do you mean per it's the extra I think it's like 1.1 so if a student

033goes to Harford High School it they count it as a 1.1 I I I might be off by half a percent but uh or by rounding ER it's either 1.1 or 1.2 it's not 1.5 it's not 1.7 it's it's like 1.1 it costs a little bit more because there's some more busting probably involved uh they have um the the theory is that right they have science labs they have Athletics they have there's more that goes on at a high school 16 oh what number did you use as your tuition what's the average high school tuition oh no I used the 15926 * 1.1 uh you for example using uh the tuition table that's in the uh the budget book um we are we are budgeting and these are estimates that in 25 you had 144

034those are actuals we know those kids um and that we're estimating for 26 you'll have 141 so you have fewer kids going to high school but because of what we budget for the high schools and which high schools they're going to uh you're Heartland spends out of 11.6 million roughly 3.25 million for tuition for 26 so okay so our weighted number is 641 what's our actual student number tuition plus no no high school plus like K12 K you want a K12 number so it's what so what what do you have right now for enrollment Lindsay and then add that number to 141 and that's what you got I can if you give me less than two minutes I can get the exact number for you but it's around we're around probably 255 2 6 here

035and then another 141 so it's about 400 so the truth is like we our we're about 1.6 is about the Heartland weighted no it doesn't work like that it works on a per I see what you're trying to do but it it it doesn't work it's it's on like a per student basis so they say you have 200 let let's say and I know you don't but let's say you had 260 kids and they were all k6 and there was nothing else and there was no free reduced they were all paid it would be the number would be 260 right but but they break it out on a per student basis so if there's an elll student they count as four and the higher the number is what you want right you want a high

036oh yeah I know from a tax perspective I think my point is that we're saying that our high school students only count as 1.1 but I am sure that some of our high school students count as more than 1.1 learner who which probably gets you close to about 18,000 which gets you close to about what we're paying in average for tuition no nowhere near well what's like over harford's tuition is over over's 25 or 26 we're budgeting we're we're budget we're estimating budgeting we haven't seen all the numbers yet as they come out I firm them up but we are estimating 23,100 for Hartford uh at 73 students that's 1. 686 Mill ion Windsor we're budgeting 2,879 that's $76,000 Woodstock we're budgeting 2,287 Hannah was 24590 uh so you're talking in the 20s the only

037one that's below that is um well fford Academy 2,85 actually so I'm trying to find one that's below and if it's an independent school it's the state average right yes which is 18,900 right yeah 189 that's crazy I know yeah so it's it's frustrating that there's no accounting for the cost of schooling on this side of the state and well if the state averages also the cost the student is $8,000 yeah we're only allowed to spend only allow to 15 that's czy making yeah okay so we probably can't change that though right yeah right so we let's so let's assume so that's what it is yeah so if we move forward in the slides I think so I I just wanted to make it clear to the Harland school board and I think this slide

038kind of does that with the excess spending threshold this is what with no changes to the budget this is the tax increase with what we know today without excess spending threshold it would be a 1% is tax increase um that our budget needs to be 10.2 million yeah yeah so then if we move forward to the next slide Larry can I ask one question yeah back sorry when you say a 1% tax increase are you saying that like 1% of 2.3 that's that's a good question I'm saying I'm saying the difference that's a good question I'm saying the difference between the fy2 homestead tax rate and the difference between the FY 26 homestead tax rate would be if the excess Bay threshold didn't exist would be 1% higher oh like that's for everybody like everybody

039is paying 1% more than they did last year if all things being equal in their house value yes okay yeah got it which would be like 2.3 Larry do you want me to take over or do you want to run yeah I think we were asked to come up with I mean my understanding is the administration was task has to come up with uh ABC reductions I guess BCD reductions a being no changes and uh I think Lindsay could take it from here because it speaks more to the education aspect but those numbers that you see here for the tax increase and the dollar amounts are current as of today and Alexa and Tracy um just so that you know this changed slightly since the since we met um not by much but from then

040until now it's changed slightly okay so to get to a 10.2 tax increase the following would thanks racy the following would need to be reduced winter activities some teacher supplies the to be hired PE teacher would not be hired furniture and fixtures would remove 5,000 and repairs and maintenance and that does not take away all of repairs and maintenance just a piece of it at 12,000 for a total reduction at 171 655 if you wanted a 10.2% tax increase question Lind um where in this where is the line of no penalty or is none of this we have to cut none of this 1.4 million we're talking about less than the most we get is yeah okay we are Nikki Nikki's correct to be under the penalty currently it'd be 1.4 million roughly okay and

041that's why like that's why I'm ready to explode because it just seems like it's not cuz as each one of these Cuts y impacts our ability to meet State Standards yep and if we cut 1.4 million we don't meet any standards like so I don't know I I'm quite mad right now at the maybe just to clarify winter ities would not necessarily go away but it would not be funded by the by school and then to keep going to the Hope though sorry would be that we would potentially ask the town the rec department to take that over no we would probably go back to um families on grants or whatever there might be grants available and assistance from other avenues that we would certainly explore but you know as we sit here right now

042and none of those are G what does just so I know what does S6 provide any support for right now for winter activities it's discounted but it's discounted the same way as it is for all kids in the state it's like a season that's 109 or 100 and maybe it's rais a little this year I can't remember somewhere just over a 100 for kid and transportation would be would need to be families home we'd have we would get them there the bus was there Y and would not get them home okay so then well I'm sorry I'm sorry we did we used to run a bus back to school for those kids that needed to take the bus home they had a shortened they had shortened mountain time I believe that I think that's really

043I don't have Rec yeah I could be wrong to get to a 7.9% tax increase it is everything that is on the left building upon that it would then be an elementary teacher position and that is a retirement um and that number that you see there is salary and benefits just to to be very clear for everyone watching that's not just a salary and um sorry can we go back to the to be hired PE teacher we currently have one PE teacher yep and we're using a sub to fill the other pieces of it for now and so if we didn't have if next year there was only one PE teacher how would we meet the state requirement that what it might end up we'd have to figure out what that looks like with scheduling

044we would have to make sure that we still meet educational quality standards but where I anticipate the struggle being right now our middle school students are able to have electives as well as uh two times a week PE it's very likely that both of those things would not be able to happen with one PE teacher covering k through eight we also would lose health because we use our PE teacher like we don't have health this year which is a quality standard because we only have one PE teacher so it's that certified right because our PE teachers are generally certified cross- certified in health so we are not doing currently meeting that quality standard you you would have to meet it in a different way which means um because some some of our schools don't have

045health certified PE teachers and um it's not perfect by any means but it the way the local wellness policy reads it can be Health can be taught within the science class or the nurse can go in and teach someone I mean it would not be to the Quality that okay have that but but it would Hannah to answer your question that to be hired PE teacher would have an impact on students absolutely all of this yeah every one of these will and so then you want what well what furniture and fixtures wouldn't we be what was on the duck in repairs and maintenance then like is there anything specific that we're not doing Larry can you answer that one I know you met with um Jim yeah I met with Jim and um his feeling

046that the budget as outlined before these reductions uh was to keep Heartland afloat and uh keep the building in working order obviously things come up from time to time that must get done that we can't uh some we can't anticipate and some you can't but when I suggested these numbers as reductions Jim felt that it was doable like this was a number that could continue to repair the school as things come up um and the furniture and fixtures I don't know if there was anything in specific other than the fact that there was 5,000 I I believe that completely takes it out I think furnes and fixtures might be zeroed out with that 5,000 be you're right Larry and for this fiscal year we used $55,000 to purchase new chairs for our Middle School can

047I ask a question about repairs and maintenance I know we've talked about like the capital reserve and is that something that like if something pops up we can is can we use the capit a capital reserve for voted on but like can we you cannot use it called an emergency meeting I think that's the way it's um okay in Heartland it's it's a vote in March it's on the war it's on the um warning but if there was an emergency I think you could probably schedule a meeting to allocate those funds can you can you just out of curiosity can you allocate funds and then if you don't use them just they go back so like for example if we're like well we're going to cut $122,000 of that can we go to the the

048voters and say we're going to put can we take $12,000 out of our capital reserve in case of and then if we use it we use it if we don't it gets returned is that like is that a thing I'm gon have to ask leg okay I don't know if that's like just so that I think it would get returned like it it could get returned fure we' have to we'd have to Define exactly what those repairs and maintenance off yeah it's not just like waiting for something to break okay that's that was my okay and so then can we talk about um what it looks like if we don't fill the retirement the elementary school teach yeah that's the middle one yeah can we talk about what that looks like for staff so what

049that would look like for Staffing is we would have to look at class sizes and figure out are there um there are some in the older grades that would still fall under what education quality standards Define as class size um but that it would push it closer to that number wouldn't push it over it but it would push it closer to it um but it it would look like something like instead of two classes it's one for one of the grades so seventh grade is already one right yep we at and it wouldn't really be possible in the Middle School just because they're already they already only have four core teachers so it would be more so yes I mean the the middle school would remain the same correct it's more the elementary probably Upper

050Elementary based on what the numbers are if you look at grade numbers um the younger grades based on their total grade size number wouldn't necessarily dictate based on educational quality standards trying to combine you couldn't combine those lower corre education I don't think it's best practice at the younger grades either so you'd be talking about having like a single fifth grade or a single fourth grade class potentially and the hope would be to keep the Staffing whoever's here and shift assignment clashing ass so I just ran the numbers just so people know the average tuition that we're projecting is 22,900 it's actually it's $33 short of 23,000 so that's what our average high school tuition is and the state says that assuming that the kid is not a poverty or an Ela that the average

051like if we were to take that 15,000 and convert it to the 1.1 that would be 175 so that is what is destroying us say it again so the 15 92 times 1.1 is 175 okay got it and our average tuition is just under 23,000 yeah so we are getting burned by High School tuition yeah just destroyed dble times two like it's not just the one cost D this is this is one state needs to cap high schools because or get some control over or not double penalize it CU I mean yeah or don't penalize the tuition portion of our budget right okay unless get that changed before March 4th is very low I know I mean again talk for messaging in terms of you know which of these we propose um so so 7.9

052so 10.2% increase is a tax rate of 2.5 is that right lar you have that those figures 2 what do you mean what do you mean 2.5 like the tax rate is 250 yeah so if I did if I did the 171 adjustment um with my little tax rate calculator here on a different screen it would be your tax rate would go to for Homestead obviously we're talking about $254 and then 248 for the 7.9 248 would be uh so that would be this one the middle option that would be uh that would be 248 that's correct and then the last option would be um 241 and that'd be a 4% tax increase year-over-year okay can we hear about this the the world language like what that looks like for the school cut now we

053have one World Language teacher and that would remove all language no language education in the school yeah and removing a custodian would leave us with one during the day and one at night two two at night one can I ask a question or not a question maybe a comment question um I've been at 80 million budget meetings and last night at the Woodstock one their the board's goal was anything that was not student basing was what got cut so meaning like like teachers came last it seemed like and you know and so I was wondering like what you know like is there anything that is not student facing that First Column I know exactly well no there's a no there's a there's a PE teacher right there that's student facing right like but the things

054that we can cut winter activities teach us supplies furniture and repairs so I get that but like and again it sucks to say things like this but like the custodian for example again I'm not interested in cutting anything but if we were to like go with student facing things if the custodian moved over there into that tax you know into the furthest column and the PE teacher moved if they swap places again I don't want to talk about any of this but we have to um like what is that you do the numbers I think one of the one of the things we focused on um one of the considerations in these Cuts especially in the first two rows nobody's going to lose their job okay y because those positions are not fil and again

055I'm not interested in yeah anything you know hurting anybody give you the rational no I no I totally I totally get that um is yeah so it would affect electives as well because the electives are the PE teacher will play a role in the electives and that would have to come out World Language teacher does play a role in electives that would come out that would come out they would they would we would not have that person to support the elective program agree yes so it's it's besides losing Spanish we would also be losing another person supporting an elected program for middle school if the World Language disappears I have really I am really concerned about cutting World language in this in this part of the world to be honest right I mean we are

056sending a very uh homogeneous population of kids into a school and I think that is you know you guys spent yesterday on Dei in service right I mean I think giving them that bit of exposure to um to things outside the world they know is really essential and I I think it would be a really really big disservice shutting down oh no shutting down cancel cancel you might hit the board you know I I think that there's no way we can get through this budget cycle without making Cuts I think everybody gets that right um and I think proposing a um 13 % increase [Music] um is going to really create a lot of backlash um so I think we we need to sort of be thinking somewhere between that 8 to 10% um the

057budget that that leads to an 8 to 10% tax increase so I don't think people are GNA I don't well can we just so when say a certain percentage like in my mind when people are listening to this they're not necessarily understanding if you have a house that's worth $200,000 what are your taxes then going to be in these three scenarios because in my mind if my taxes are a $25 difference between a 10% increase and a 4.6% increase I'll pay the $25 you know like so I think trying to have it a little clearer so folks can understand what it really me means of what they're going to pay around and it s right so it's like and we'll do that I think we can't but I'm saying we need to do it now

058I'm like when in these discussions because if people are going to listen to this that's harder math than I I'm gonna do right now I mean I'll go home and crunch it and figure out what my tax bill will be like but I don't think that necessarily that everyone would do that and understand really what the span of their tax rate might look like is that in hopes that between this meeting if tonight you're going to get feedback from the community to help you make the decision is that what your hope is best uh no my hope is that they can understand of like what the difference if we make have a 10% increase versus a 4.3 truly what the amount of money it means out of their pocket versus we're cutting two whole teacher

059positions like that's a significant student Impact versus oh I need to pay extra $ can we do that you know like is it like what's the Impact versus your own pocketbook um and I'm I'm interested I'm with you on that and I'm also interested like if we just stick with a 13.3 like what that even like what's the difference between the 13.3 of like not doing every anything not cutting anything just leaving things the way they are versus this is what Larry has right up okay yeah Larry I'm ready so with the current budget as it is with no changes the 13.3 that we're talking about that 26103 for a $250,000 house the annual difference is $766 annually so so your taxes are going to go up $766 from what they are now so I

060guess being able to compare those three scenarios like basically run the num the try to get those numbers for each one of those scenarios because if that 10% only reduces it by $25 is it worth it like you know is it worth the pain um because right now it just then it just be I could I I could do that give me one second uh I can do that but I I can't it's not gonna be able to be in one table so what scenario would you like to see the middle scenario or the first scenario yeah so do the do 248 with the with the the 171,000 the $300,000 reduction that gets so the middle one all right so the middle one would be a tax rate of 24853 so if I go to

06124853 2 dot 4853 and then I and then I'm going to copy that down here so all the ones have it it would be for $250,000 house $454 so roughly what what was it $300 is per annual so you can you do it with the 10 um point2 Larry just to see okay one second 10.2 so if we go to a 10.2 with the 171 count that was 25400 so now I go back to my table and I go 254 00 and I go this will be in the budget book by the way we we were hoping to get once a number was picked we could have this table for everybody the difference would be would be 590 to seven right so it's roughly $150 per per year difference 150 or 300 I'm picking a

062$250,000 house is the Baseline you know I'm just picking yeah I don't think that exists any no but okay yeah so with that option if the tax rate goes up 10.2% it's about $236 per $100,000 of house per person increase right yeah yes yeah yeah I don't remember the original number but it was seven something right it was so the original number was 26103 so so remember remember this number 590 26103 and 766 so 766 minus what the number I just said9 5907 590 so what did I say $150 that's about right right 160 17676 $170 yeah divided by 12 or what you know if you ask grow you know don't have to decide tonight but you do have to decide by the next meeting we set I mean at the next meeting we need

063to make a decision which I think we said was um uh can I ask I have a few more clarifying questions um I know no one can predict the future but what are there any chances that the state is changing things are again yes they're changing we're all going to email Elizabeth right now so well so if that is true like what we decide on tonight there is a large possibility that when the numbers change we could be like wait a minute we wanna like can we go back and revisit if if you don't approve the budget tonight yes we can revisit it but if we approve a budget tonight we cannot we can cancel it like we did last year yeah resend it we can resend it but then because we're early in the

064game when we're not early no so when when is our budget actually due to it goes to the print I think January yeah has to be warn by the 27th and go to print by around the 20th so like if we so if we decide on something tonight and then in a few days the numbers change and we have another meeting can we say I think you just wait if you're not gonna I I can't make a decision I'm just not um and but then we'll have the final number we should have the final number this week but it that could change too because no what we're being told is this will be the last round of ltw ADM we had to certify a bunch of data over the break so that they could get

065okay the final the state is recognizing that it creates a problem and a hardship when they keep changing the numbers really it' be great to have in December right so they have said this would be the last round correct Larry my understanding is version four is supposed to come out this week that's what I'm hearing uh and then they they want the business managers to sign off on it and then once I sign off on it it's the final number unless they change the law which could happen but I think two years I think that we've all learned after last year's experience hopefully um so what's about that having the threshold level like where does that extra money go if you're basing like oh I know this question I asked this one like does it

066just go to like a kitty it goes to the education I think it goes to the the education fund and it gets dispersed and then it gets redistributed to receiving towns it's it's kind of messed up but they're doing it they're doing it as an attempt to control budgets right theoretically but what if everybody had was under the threshold then and there wasn't any EXT said money then what's the like it would probably adjust the yield or something in that formula so that everybody you know gets what they need this is this is welcome seems like the excess spending threshold is doing the job that the legislature want to do which isra budgets this is like major of baseball what are we the New York Yankees like I don't yes yes we are there are

067there are districts in the state that spend well under $15,000 per student which is which is fine right but they're the ones that are crushing us right because I don't know I don't it's districts districts thatlingon and because they have more more students have more divor yes their their number is huge their EDM number is huge compared to ours right you complaining about that doesn't no but here's where I do think that we need to email the legislators because we're paying on average just under 23,000 for our high school students and the state says that we're supposed to be able to pull this off at around 18 no 15 well no that's we do all the the difference for how many high school students we have is $750,000 yes which is pretty close to 1.2

068I mean we cut maybe winter activity and yeah and so it just it feels like it feels like we're being penalized for something that we which we've always said that like we tuition is not something that we can control but this year in particular this just feels like a slap in the face so if we're not going to make a decision tonight which I don't think we should should then we just have to have another meeting in two weeks or whatever we have a meeting scheduled I think it's next week on the wednes calar uh we have a meeting scheduled for the 15th as a tenative so we'll just warn that um and Christine who's gonna go to that one because there's a weather seal one at the same time um well there's there's a

069six o'clock here and a 6:30 weather field so hopefully okay you make the decision I'll probably be one will be remote in one location yeah okay we're saying January 15th January 15th at six o'clock six o'clock okay so Christine have you heard anything at the legislative level about tuition changes there was supposed to be a cap I mean it's come up but they no one hasen't done anything no I mean I know the future Commission on the future of public education gave their report they didn't want them to be called recommendations I don't think they just it was a report that I read um but High School yeah I mean it's being talked about there are lots of things being talked about yeah I mean because it just seems like if we're we cannot cut

070enough at the elementary level to make up to get under the threshold to get under the threshold like I mean what you proposed is really rough can I just ask is there an impression that the high schools are charging the tuition students more than they are spending per student cuz I mean I I mean I don't and there is I hate to make those high schools the enemy is the other thing right like I think I mean it's yes I think that they are like tuition students are you know they a little extra money they're a gift I mean but they have to pay back if they overcharge there's a law right Larry if they overcharge more than 3% yeah but if they if they undercharge we just receed bills from Windsor Central because they

071under charged for each of our districts goes both ways well I think that's the other frustration is that that average number that we're being held to doesn't account for the fact that it generally costs more on this side of the that's the issue that threshold has yeah and so that threshold we're trying to reach that's why I brought it up because I feel like the tuition but you know from somebody who said to me well Portland does have school choice right we could we could eliminate school choice we could eliminate school choice and we would eliminate this problem but wouldn't we still have to pay like let's say we sent our pay 21,000 you wouldn't pay anything well you would pay through your taxes but you wouldn't pay any extra costs for example if a

072student is a eth grader at Windsor high at Windsor school and they cross the threshold and they go to the high school the there's no tuition money changing hands right it's no different than a stu a seventh grade student or actually in your situation it be no different than a fifth grade student going to middle school at Heartland because you guys control the whole ball of wax k through eight you don't control it K through 12 like Mount of scy does so there would be your tuition would be zeroed out if we said we wanted everyone to go to Hartford yeah would it be the you have to merge You' you'd have to merge with Hartford right and in this scenario you couldn't just send all your kids to Har you could but if you

073send all your kids to Hartford you're still paying tuition you'd have to merge with Hartford or Windsor I should say you just said that the cost of educating a student in Windsor is around 22,000 that is higher than 18 it's it's what it's it's what Windsor charges for tuition it's not w m scny school districts uh equalize uh education spending for ltwm is significantly it's under the threshold it's 15,000 yes if we chose a different place if we sent someone out of District all of us out of District we would have to pay tuition but because we are a part of Windsor Southeast and Windsor is the high school of Windsor Southeast we would not we would just be what I'm saying is that the tuition is supposed to be set within a certain range

074and so it is still going to cost 22,000 to educate a student at Windor High School it wouldn't it wouldn't it would be a lesser yeah and not only that Nikki it would be zero right as far as a a number that expenditure tuition is what it costs like you just said that tuition has to be within the a certain percentage of what it costs to educate that student it's really you would it's not like our tuition line would disappear no but the line would disappear yes yeah it would be high school if we joined with it would be one budget it would be one exactly exactly it would be but my point is that cost 22,000 to educate a high schooler but you would have cost savings if you had one budget because you're

075sharing resources across all schools it would so my point is that my point that the state to educate a high schooler and in Windsor it's costing 21 or 22 for a tuition student but why would a tuition student cost like I guess in if they're billing us 21 or 22 it has to be around that you have to beud AR ltw ADM would be significant exactly so that you gota you got to remember the other side of the divisor is the ltw ADM so for example you are 640 right and then and and mount scny school district is like 99 90 so if you you if if they merged I'm not saying this should happen I'm just saying mathematically if they merged it would be 1550 can you imagine what that would do to your

076tax rate because now the ltw ADM is so much higher it would lower your taxes just like it did for as this gets brought up as a you know as people bring this up to us can Windsor High School absorb Harland Elementary School students um I think under act 46 there was right there was a a plan to merge potential plant emerge Weathersfield Heartland West Windsor and Mountain Windsor all into one district one supervisory Union and there was a plan and there would be cost savings and there was a plan to build addition on to the high school to or a new high school I don't remember exactly I can't High School Windor high school as as constructed has uh an additional how do I say it has an has the ability to build an

077additional Wing above the mass science Wing uh would just straight up another Flor and and that would do it according to what the ACT 46 one of the things they looked at but Windsor high school as it stands with no further cost could not currently absorb her like it's not like that's a re how many kids is it well again if it if it was like if it was like um if it was like the M West Windsor merger it would be you'd grandfather the stud so nobody would be nobody would be pulled from Woodstock or pulled from hard we nobody would be pulled from those schools those students would be grandfather it would be your current like seventh graders so and then every class after that so yeah I think probably yes for for

078a year for a couple of years but then then there would have to potentially be an addition on the school oh I don't I guess I still don't understand I mean I know that the cost would go down but I still don't understand that Windsor's charging us 22,000 but doesn't cost 22,000 to educate a student that's where I'm stuck it's really that number it's it's really the ltw ADM yeah you're I think you're confusing like what uh the when it's all started some one I think it was Nikki it might have been Beth who said you know the the difference between enrollment and ltw ADM and I think where we're getting hung up on is when we discuss a high school student we're talking about enrollment a body I agree a body a body um

079we're not talking about ltw ADM but where I am is that high schools are supposed to be charging us what it costs to educate our student but our student is greater than one right because of ltw ADM so it's again it's this it's this like trying to compare the cost per body and the cost per ltw I totally agree but the state if you look at like I'm not I'm not saying that we're trying to educate our high school students for 15,000 like let's up it to 18,000 that's still 4,000 more than what's being charged less than less than what's being charge like and there's no there's no limits right now for the schools to set their tuition rates each district sets the rate and that's what I'm what I'm trying to say is that

080like well here okay so so um the state average high school tuition is 18,900 and there are no schools in this side of the state that can meet that level well one yeah exactly so one thing we being penalized for being on this side the state could decide I'm not an attorney but the state could decide uh we're gonna make everybody have the state average and the parents come up with a difference they could do that I I don't I don't know if that's constitutional but they could do that and I I don't but I've never seen that happen I've never I've seen it talked about I don't think it's part of the current legislation I think a cap is I feel like if they're going to charge if they're saying students the average is

08118,000 then it's 18,000 like they need to cap it because it's too like we're getting crushed by we're getting crushed we're getting crushed by by School tuition because there's no cap and they just keep spending so again last night at Woodstock meeting they decided one way that they could not have to cut more is if they rais the tuition rates so they rais the tuition rates $1,500 so now any kid that goes to Woodstock is now on top of whatever they were is now another $1,500 so that they don't have to cut another half of a math teacher right so that's what they did right so the state isn't controlling it then because they just decided to raise fre we're never going to get because it didn't didn't cost $1,500 more no they they could

082just rate I mean like well it will cost them 15 what 100 more because your budget's higher right to meet your budget yes exactly so it was I know it totally is I mean I hate to I hate to blame all my kind and me but the issue here is the constant rise of health care costs in America I seriously that is the issue is that like the American healthare system is so broken we're gonna blame you no seriously I mean it's not and trust me the doctors and nurses are not making the money right it's the insurance companies right I mean what is driving up our budget health insurance costs for teachers and that's what goes up every single year 12.4 this year right so people want to know like it's not costing more

083because we're paying teachers more it's not costing more because we're doing big updates on the school it's costing more because the cost of providing health insurance to teachers is going up and that is going up because and their wages are going up which wages went up yeah their wages are going up 11% their wages are going insurance cost going up and and unfortunately in the state of Vermont we have then tethered property taxes to education cost and education costs are Tethered to health insurance cost and so property taxes are going up because of health insurance cost and then oh by the way that's the only thing you get to vote on all the rest of the taxes are set by other people right and so who what happens is this is exactly it is that

084we're fighting with other we're trying to blay blame at the feet of other Educators who are just trying to educate right like you know I'm I'm not I don't mean to say that but like the issue is here that like it's like it's an inflationary climate with increasing health care costs and we've like at some point there has to be an untethering of the property taxes to the education fund is not a school problem it's not a school problem it's not a school problem we are not overspending we're so my question is next Wednesday we have a meeting yeah yeah so what is back then between I mean we can piss and moan all we want because it's not like we currently are not changing anything between them now and then you know yes everyone

085contact your state representatives um but what what do we need to do do you need prepare ourselves prepare the prepare anything for you for do you want to hear from your vac reps as a perspective from a Community member do you guys have anything I know we saw this what a week or two ago so I was prepared for that conversation um I don't have anything more to add I do just worry about presenting this to the community I mean I do think that it's not going to be taken well um I worry that they're not even going to think about the people in the position just that lower tax rate so that's just my worry it's not really hopeful but it is a worry um and I've been and the high school choice has

086always been a thing it's always been a thing um yeah I I don't have any more to add I just am in agreement that it stins yeah yeah it's hard it's hard really enjoy picking around high schools always it's one of the reasons that I'm here in Heartland I went to yeah I went K through 12 and it was great but there's a reason that I'm here in Heartland for the choice yeah and and people move here for that but there is a cost guess totally yeah yeah that's why Ryan's here can did you have anything you wanted to add to the conversation as a community member um no I think you guys are right on I know so many of you I know that you know what a difficult decision is this is and

087I hear the right tone which is this is completely out of our hands and it's completely unfair to ask us to be penalized for um having a bill that we have to pay in terms of High School tuition that we aren't being fairly reimbursed for at the state level um so I'm just here to support you all support Lindsay in this really difficult decision if anybody wants to chat I will be um at S6 tomorrow or the first day of ski if we have it and um I think one of the primary things I'm hearing from all of you is providing a kind of forward push on clarifying where these costs are and I'm hearing from a lot of you that we really do need to have these bigger discussions at the state level that

088our reimbursement rate for High School tuition doesn't compare to the actual cost of sending our kids to high school and that's something that is completely out of our hands and lies with our state level representatives and our education committee so I would love to be able to turn that pressure away from all of you who are stuck between a rock and a hard place and shine that light on where the changes actually have to take place which is Way Beyond little tiny Heartland uh and our you know handful of stop signs and our two uh corner stores so um just wanted to say I know this is really hard one of the things I reached out to Lindsay about was what I found more palatable was not anybody lose their job so people who were

089already in the building staying in the building and not having to say goodbye to those people um but this all sucks and um I'm I'm really sorry that we're all here and we're continuing to have these discussions many of you have my emails or my phone numbers please reach out if there's anything else I can do to help support you in the next couple weeks thank you Tracy thanks Tracy and thank you guys for the work on this yes um yeah thanks for doing this can we time not that keeps the World Language teacher but Cuts everything else just to see add the custodian to the middle essentially okay Larry you could do that right now could you do that right now Larry your handy all right so what's what do we want to do

090now hold on hold on a lot of people talking once what what's the question add the custodian reduction to column two so we know what the text uh increase would be the custodian reduction to column two okay one second I'm going to ask tough question with brown in my mouth to make it entertaining yeah is there any is there like is there anything else that is like not student facing that can go and again I'm like I don't want anything to go but like are you saying almost in replace of one of yep of something nothing that's going to have would have the amount of dollar impact so the question is the the question is if we moved the custodian position to the middle column it would and and uh kept everything else that was

091in the middle column correct trying to that would be a 6.6% increase thank you yep is there a number that you think we need to get to like a percentage percentage increase I think people are hoping there's no increase at all yeah I think that 1% is looking really great to people I know I know it's not going to happen but like I I don't I don't think I think that we are going to have a large group of people yeah who are going to be like well why can't you make it happen like make it happen just make it happen um and so we have to be prepared to say like again here's why we can't make it happen so I know last year we were like here's the reason why we can't bring

092our budget here because we would only have 10 teachers left in the building and and we're not that difficult from that 1.4 million that's that's 14 I so I think you you put forth the budget you believe in and you stand behind and you explain it communicate it and voters voters make their decision and if and hopefully that's yes and if it's not we come back to the table we do it like we did last year what was our record last year four four okay let's see if but we know how to do it we've done it we done it yeah about communicating pretty clearly I think I heard Hannah's request of bringing back something that looks similar to this that would get you to the 6.6 the way Larry just described yeah and then

093I think I mean I think I think um I think it would be helpful to to describe what things would have to be cut to get to the 10.2 million to get to the 1% tax increase y I think being able to put a label on those cuts so people know that P a picture of what it would look like with those yeah we're losing art music gym pal well we already don't have he's already gone but we're losing art music right I mean presumably you have to cut to cut a million dollars we're talking 10 teachers that are getting cut roughly and are you looking for the number that gets you to where we're not double tax is that just what you're getting million I think 10, 28,40 million is what I got it's

09414 1.4 and that would keep us at 15,000 and so I think just I think that people will need to see that yeah but what I learned from last time and I'm going to say this super nightly is that like some people I don't want to say don't care but again their thought is is like my taxes last year went up 24% like so now you're going to put another 8% on this year like that's a lot like I hear you like I'm like cringing at my tax bill already this year like well and I know families that are middle income families that are now skimping on groceries yeah there are kids in the school who are buying Less groceries because of their taxes and that hurts it it hurts and these are middle like

095these are yeah and these are families that we know in the school and it like I don't know part of me feels like if we're going out 5.9% that we aim for a 5.9% tax increase because I don't think that we can get to zero or one no I don't think so either I don't think so unless the legis but I think if we don't if we don't demonstrate if we don't demonstrate some Cuts right um I think it it will be seen that that there's not been appropriate effort at protecting people from the burden of increased taxes so I think there have to be there there have to be cuts and I'm not going to disagree with that my only fear is is if we put like we're gonna play the game right and

096we put it all out on the table then if it comes back no like and we've cut everything we possibly can then we you know then go back you can go back and do the same budget again yeah that's what we did yeah I mean I see your point that you want your starting negotiation to be something you don't want to like give your y but I think I mean I just know I hear you so for for us for next week to be to come prepared you would like to see a budget that that um reflects a 5.9 increase I that's my proposal I I not 5.9 exactly like I mean I could hear six six% yeah right and that was basically what we would get to if we added the custodian to the

097unfilled PE and back filling retirement and the 6.6 oh 6.6 another per in there which would be about how many dollars Larry 70 another 72 72000 I'm just like like that feels palatable but well I mean it feels it feels defendable it feels like okay well the school budget's going up by 5.9% we're increasing our school like your taxes are going to go up by 6.6% I like I I agree I mean another thing that really really really needs to be demonstrated is that the increases are not coming from anything being done in this building yeah that it's that this is about like no it's we're cutting our budget we're not increasing our budget right that the taxes are going up despite the fact that the schooling is spending less money well it's changing in

098a negative way because we we are reducing our programming right right Staffing is going down activities activity offerings are going down yeah and so the the scenarios will be uh we've got the 6.6 that's so we'll just Choice be will be around 6% and then additionally so another I don't know if you're able to answer this quickly so the 6.6% tax increase would be a budget of how much okay standby I'm sorry he's the number guy wish I had control Ed gave me control last year Larry it's probably about 11 point the tax C something he gave me all the spreadsheets so I could gain what budget what's our budget this year like 10.6% so the the budget would be 11.29 219 11.21 n you're literally and what's this year's budget 10.95 we're literally going

099up less than half a million dollar like that's ridiculous like that's bar that's nothing yeah everything else is going I'm do you think in your own from your own perspective eliminating those two teachers is it going to be taxing enough on the people that then have to pick up all the time that is you know that they that the gym teacher does and PE and stuff that it's so stressful for those other teachers that they decide you know screw this I'm going down the road or great question honestly hard to know what I can tell you though is any of these will have an impact on kids that I can answer yeah and I mean and there we could definitely lose teachers so don't want to be reassigned to a certain grade and they're like

100I don't want to change y I'll go look for same grades so I I we should demonstrate this I don't know if I exactly right but I think with that 6.6% tax increase that's associated with a budget increase of Two and a half% so that just to make that point again that the the actual increase budget significantly lower percentile than the tax increase right yes yeah okay so then Hannah just so we're all on the same page Christine and I and Larry will come with those budget increases but additionally what I can show you is a a separate slide that talks about what levels of what it would look like if you were to attempt to cut to the 1. just more the perspective like this y that's gonna be um probably anxiety provoking for

101staff just just gonna put that out there because they will I mean they will see it yeah I don't know but I I I know I mean I think I think the taxpayers need to see it the exercise I mean yeah we can do that the purpose of it from my perspective is to is stand in of the staff right and I know what the staff knows and I mean are any of us comfortable putting forth a budget that is you know no cuts at all 13.3 no percent increase no okay I mean just no are we could we absorb just the like I mean how about the First Column like is that is that enough I don't know we don't even know what the real number is yet we still don't even have number

102whatever so I feel like it's a complete moot discussion at this point because we don't actually have all the accurate information we need so so I guess do we leave that what is right now I can reshare the screen so wonder is do we leave the First Column for the next me meeting we leave that and then Christine and I and Larry show you the other two scenarios or do you add a third column in there that is what Hannah suggested with out the World Language so there's the 10.2 7.9 6.6 then 4.6 yeah then and then and then a one so it's five columns which shows this two slides are you are you also to the the PE teacher being in the First Column is that because it's less impactful than an elementary school

103teacher but either is that elementary school teacher that's not yes so yeah so like which of those is more impa so if that's what I'm so like the elementary teacher isn't as big of a deal but you really need electives and PE and heal I mean like would we swap them having multiple options for us to decide that like show us different numbers because I mean that would even be less that would be like 9.9 because you you're adding another 30,000 to that first budget which is under 10 which is still sucks but is we can show that we can show those options yep right that one yep we'll just have multiple slides giv different scenarios and Christine is there any talk about um because the one thing we haven't talked about is the Su

104part of this right we haven't even talked about because like what that's going to do yeah we have so is that gonna is that going to like is the Su changing anything the Su okay so it passed and done yeah okay can I just just specify I think is the reason the elementary teacher is so much more because that's someone who has been here much longer and it's attached to the actual it is position that's here now the first year teacher yes who happen to be the fiz that teacher corre right yes hire someone it depends on if somebody takes benefits single plan no benefits family plan I mean that's all factored in but these are actual numbers we have to use the actual people we are for budgeting purposes yeah yeah because we're comparing

105year to year the Su budget was 9% increase from last year some Su budget was admin and Ops was up 3% and special up 5.9 6% so all in it was 9.3 3.3% for non-sp special ed and 6% for special ed and Nod special ed we did cut an administrative position at the Su did I see that the one who gave Nikki all the control and now we know why they were all right so a motion that we table this discussion until our next meeting on January 15th second yeah so I think that that's consensus by everybody um so yeah so I think we'll have hopefully we'll have definite yeah and then I and then uh point of or I think just on the 15th once the School District board you know authorizes a budget

106number then I'll have that table that I showed you that's not currently in the budget book that'll be in the budget book that shows how much you know if you have a $250,000 house a 350,000 450,000 so on how much would be because then we'll have more definite what your tax rate's going to be right now as you can see the tax rate is changing with every scenario we choose to look at you know and Larry will the um tax worksheet be in the budget book as well yes yep and I'm gonna have I'm gonna have it I I I'm working on it with weather seal and I'm gonna copy it over to Heartland with with their numbers and basically it's going to show everything you just saw in Lindsay slide but on the right

107hand side I'm going to have notes where I'm going to attempt to explain what lcw ADM means what education planing plus ex EXs threshold means etc etc so it should be kind of like a primer for the voter I would think hopefully and in terms of the um I mean before you got here I shared the cost of printing the budget book so we're not going to do that but we're just we're going to have the regular Town Report with some of the pages from the budget book or all of them so what's going to happen is uh I'm going to deliver as a in PDF form it'll be all the Su budget information including all the letters from the the Su board chair and the curriculum office and so on so forth and then

108and then heartlands and that that'll be one big PDF and then we're going to give that to the town of Heartland and they're going to print it do you um include a a QR code so people can get to it or or some way for people to know how to get to it electronically digitally I I can do that can I um can we do one more thing I know last year a big thing was like comparing us to weather's field if they've got their numbers can we see what that is they I mean we have it's right there it's right there on the budget the budget book you can if you're in the budget book you can click the electronic version the pdf version but the electronic version you can click right on weatherfield

109and a Heartland citizen can go right and see weather Field's information right there and vice versa do they their budget's about $2 million less to that's correct they they are underneath the threshold and they pay for tuition yeah I know roughly the same of students element they have what roughly the same Elementary KK population Arland has more high school students roughly they only had 100 high school students last year and we had 150 your Millions yeah exactly I'll go to Woodstock I love them all I do they're great okay I think we're uh I think I'm good we were GNA allow for some public participation after done oh we have public participation okay um is there any public par we are not precipitation precipitation um Okay We're Not Gonna vote on a budget today which

110is clear um is there any public that wants to speak up about what we said that snu away and I that's how fun our discussion was okay um so setting the next agenda I have nothing on my brain budget budg adoption yeah but that's the are you thinking February yeah we usually go to February but okay let me pull it up but for the next one that's what it's going to be just budget just budget for February we had um administrative report which would include the student growth report yep the second time and then we've got um we should have a Wy be working on the budget information session run through which we're going to limit this year with less yeah just we're going to get to the budget um okay budg make sure you

111put like on every slide like a really adorable kid face with an adorable teacher doing something adorable okay um I assume we not need an executive session there you go we bunny uh I will take a motion Beth moves I second I thought Heather seconds she's like we're all in person those in favor of a journey thank you Larry Larry thank you Larry I don't know what it is with

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.