CorpusRecord 262780

Special Board Meeting 12/12/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Riverview Media
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Kenosha County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,391 words · about 25 min
Collected
2026-06-29

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001it is 603 so I would like to call this Lake Salem joint one school district meeting to order since our president Mr Hopkins and our vice president Mr Walker are not here per our policy we will need to take a vote on who is running the meeting there's got to be a nomination for it it's just I the policy really isn't state so you just have to have plurality of board members so so someone just say they'll you've got the gav Amy you've got the gav handle it all right so that's two votes and you don't have to even vote for yourself thank you guys you can be modest Amy let's move forward and please stand for the pledge pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for

002which it stands one nation under God indivisible Justice for and we will take roll call Mr Herz yep Mr Gentile present uh myself Amy Regner is present and Mr Walker and Mr Hopkins are not open meetings compliance check yes we posted it perfect and we currently do not have anyone here for public comments okay so um let me just get to the screen we have okay can we see okay we have Jim weed here from PSI again you've all met him and then Scott Gerard is here from school perceptions to take us through the survey results so I'm going to leave it to you guys to take us through the results and um so that we can have a the board can have a discussion all right are you all uh seeing the presentation here

003yes yes okay all right we'll get started um thank you all for having me tonight thanks for coming so this is this is just a little uh preview of the types of information you're going to see throughout the presentation uh we have background information so this will look familiar it's what was on the survey uh we'll look at who responded to your survey the results and Analysis and then at the end time for wrap up in questions little reminder about school perceptions um we were founded in 2002 and we've helped more than 1,000 districts navigate the strategic planning and referendum planning process uh the fun stuff of your survey uh we had a November 25th deadline so we've had a few weeks on from that time to get some mailed surveys and process those and

004enter the data we ended up with 296 respondents for a 15.3% response rate that's right in our average range I would say we usually see the mid teams uh mid to high team so certainly plenty to feel good about the data that we're getting here um because of the number of respondents we have a 5.81% margin of error plus or minus just a number to keep in mind as you're seeing the data uh that's just a factor based on the number of respondents um nothing else uh controls that as far as age of respondents go uh the biggest group of respondents was the 35 to 44 range with 27% uh that's going to be of parents in that age range and then second highest was 65 Plus at 24% of respondents we love seeing them

005in the top couple age groups uh because they're very reliable voters they're going to turn out on Election uh so it's it's good to hear from them and make sure that they're hearing about your plans we ask is your primary residence in the district 87% said yes uh 11% were no those could be uh staff members um um who live outside the district's boundaries open enrolling families things like that 2% not sure as well um we still want to hear from all of those folks but when we're looking at a potential election outcome we need to focus on that 87% because those are the folks who could actually vote on a referendum measure 14% of your respondents were staff and 43% of your respondents were parents and that leaves uh the biggest group both on

006the survey and in your community of non-parents non-staff and so we use those three breakdowns uh when we get to some of the data later is that a good thing for our results with the 50 57% being non um no children yeah this is pretty typical um I would say and we do some waiting of the data that all I'll get into uh in a bit that you know allows to look at what your full voter population is regardless of how it breaks down on the survey I would think it would be good like better um so we do a Communications question we ask folks how they like to receive school and District information uh both your non-parents non-staff and your parents like the newsletters uh that was the the biggest response for non-parents non-staff

007and second biggest for parents your parents also really like the emails um and so this is just good to keep in mind as you're communicating whether it's about uh a potential referendum or or other information uh this is how folks like to receive that information so now on to the fun stuff of the facility plan um so a little reminder about what was in the survey about the facility plan some of the other projects there and what we presented relating to funding support for the facility plan so we asked would you support a $7 million referendum to fund the recommended plan so this slide just shows staff residents so staff who also live within the district's boundaries 84% of those respondents said they definitely or probably would support that referendum the remaining 16% responded undecided

008parent residents at 90% said they definitely or probably would support a $7 million referendum to fund the recommended plan 7% said definitely no and then the uh little really small bar there was undecided with 3% and finally and again this is the biggest group uh in your District uh non-parents non-staff 52% said definitely or probably yes they would support the plan to 37% who said definitely are probably no so this is where that waiting comes in um and so using some data from the Census about 20% of your population are parents and about 80% of your voting population are non-parents non-staff and so what we do is we wait the results of support by those uh demographics So 20% are parents and that corresponds with the 0.20 here and then we multiply it by the

00990% that parents responded there in support we do the same over here the 08 corresponds with 80% being non-parents non-staff multiply that by the 52% support we had from non-parents non-staff what we get to over here is 59.6 that's the number we'd uh estimate uh support you'd see on a ballot for this referendum plan if it were if the election were held today um we did have that plus or minus 5.81% margin of error if you remember so this is above 50% and outside of that margin of error um so that's a a significant level of support we did ask if you are undecided or would not support the capital referendum one of the main reasons this is only showing non-parents non-staff the other two groups had such small proportions um of undecided or NOS

010that uh we really just wanted to to break it down to non-parents non-staff as you can see the top two options the only one surpassing majority uh our tax impact is too large and the pl project is too expensive those are the two highest on survey we do when we ask this question um you know if you're saying no it often relates to the cost uh both to yourself the taxpayer and of the plan as a whole so this result wasn't surprising at all and just the rest of the projects that were uh listed there as you can see at the bottom some of the least chosen ones roof sections HVAC parts Tech infrastructure some of those projects we did also ask some overall satisfaction question questions uh and so in four areas on a

011scale from one to four we asked how is the district doing and then we broke it down by those same groups because it's a one to four scale the median is a 2.5 um and so as you can see the only one at a 2.5 is your non-parents non-staff uh on managing funds appropriately but you're still right there at that median not below it um that one is almost always going to be the lowest uh on these surveys because we just uh talked to them about how you're asking for money and so it's never a surprise to see those scores be the lowest on the overall satisfaction um but otherwise everything is above the median here and your parents and staff scores especially are all above 3.0 uh so in that good to Great range

012another way of breaking that data down is we just take the whole response Set uh we look at the percent that said great or good the average score overall and then how you compare to other districts um and you can see delivering a high quality education you're better than just about everybody uh that uses this survey 96 pertile uh 84th percentile for keeping the public informed uh so solid communication there and you're well above the 50th percentile for both of the other two as well um so you're certainly uh leading in a couple and and doing strong in the others another satisfaction question we ask is on a scale of 0 to 10 How likely would you to recommend the district to a friend or family member your overall score was a 7.93 which is

013the 84th percentile again uh in our comparison pool uh one thing that really stood out to me oftentimes we first look at sort of those top three 8 through 10 those are really often ambassadors for your District folks who will bring up how much they love your District um without anyone asking them what they think uh and as you can see you're over a third at the highest and you're over 50% with just the top two and then nearly at 2third with the top three and so that's really strong uh and you have very few uh who were in that below neutral range so what did we learn um the survey found majority waited support for the $7 million facility referendum this is enough support to put the referendum on the April 20125 ballot and

014let the voters decide in our opinion um this is also some po Cal ballot language that was sent over um by your uh by corals and Brady I believe um but at this point that is the end of my presentation I'd be happy to take questions uh and answer any any that I can so Scott um one of the things I'm looking back at and I know again great results very favorable um but for some reason in my notes when you guys did the initial presentation said we we needed to be around 18 to 20% of respondents and you said we're at 15% which is you know obviously right where you said we want to be but can you kind of explain where you know when we asked initially it was a little bit higher

015versus where we came in at and does that impact the results that we're seeing right no that's a great question 18 to 20% I would say is always our goal okay um we often don't get there I I certainly have presented surveys just over the past couple weeks with 15% and even a couple 13 14 um I what that does is the more you have the lower your margin of error is right and the concern you know 5.81 is generally on the larger side of a margin of error and so the concern is then if you see a 54% response well now you know what do we do with that because it's it's solidly over 50 but it's within that margin of error so I think the reason we shoot for that 18 to 20

016is really to get that margin of error down as much as possible um but given the result still being outside the margin of error I I feel very confident with the 15% response rate yeah no I appreciate the answer and certainly um yeah I agree because obviously coming in at 58% with a 5% margin of error puts you at 53 so you're still above where you now to be which like I said 54 and 5% put you at that 5050 Mark and that's that's that's a different conversation so I appreciate the answer and then you also mentioned that you know you kind of drop the people who are out of District like they they get dropped off the survey entirely when they answer answer that question is that just so I understand that so they're

017not a part of um let me just go back they are a part of the overall satisfaction okay because again especially I think a big portion of those outside of your residents um are going to be saff who live outside the district boundaries we really want to make sure we hear from them about how you're doing in these areas but because they can't actually vote on a referendum we take them out of these specific slides so you drop from the referendum related questions not satisfaction and overall health of the district okay thanks Scott hey Scott uh if if we had a higher response rate closer to that 18 to 20% does that increase the waiting that you put on on some of those statistics or is that the same regardless the waiting is the same

018regardless because this uh this 20 and 80 is based on uh the American Community survey which is part of the census u based on their population estimates for your District specifically um and so that's how we determine that waiting and we we would use these numbers regardless of the response rate thank you do you guys have any other questions so I want to take you to the can you go to the resolution language because this isn't something I shared ahead of time because I just got it today so I think it's important for you to take a moment to read this because this is the Crux of right like making sure that it's understandable enough um because this is this is what you will vote on on um Tuesday Kim can you read it out

019loud sorry I didn't bring my glasses hopefully my oral fluency is good I'd be happy to read it if I mean I can see it perfect from here I'm okay okay sh The Joint School District number one Village of Silver S Salem Lakes Kenosha County Wisconsin be authorized to issue pursu pursuant to chapter 67 of the Wisconsin statutes General obligation bonds and an amount not to exceed $7 million for the public purpose of paying the cost of a district districtwide school facility Improvement project consisting of Renovations including to the main entrance and classrooms Capital Maintenance building infrastructure safety security and site improvements and acquisition Furnishings fixtures and equipment the only thing that we have to check before we last Tuesday is um I always making sure that that name is the legal name and so

020I don't know that it is but I didn't have time to check with to get Sue's thing on there but we'll change that [Music] the school the name hasn't changed so our attorney did not know like exactly and I didn't have time to get to look at the do we have the previous resolution that we did three years ago or what two years ago or whatever years because I would assume that I'm saying we've got a record somewhere it's the way nor Jo Silver Lake Salem that's what I'm saying so I think last time or this time really oh okay yeah OB is a confusing name she probably just you know we have 17 names and it's confusing still to me so I always ask you have it Silver Lake your Silver Lake jt1 your

021Silver Lake Salem Joint School District your Riverview I mean amongst a million other things this was written by our lawyers cim obviously or was this written by the be group no it was written by corals and Brady not by um Bon Bron corals and Brady does a lot of this kind of work for districts okay so I mean I'm sure that they have to have those first three lines on there but that to me is confusing to the public you know like it's just a lot of language but I'm sure that has to be the only thing I'm just G to be honest obviously and I know we've got till next week with our formal meeting is that name right there is very confusing to voters I think I just the whole the way we

022have to be registered like is there a way to put that River viiew in there somewhere you know legally I don't know no I'm just saying even parentheses like you does that make it that if we ever did want to change our name to River School they would help us with that see and I think that you would have to do it that way beforehand I don't think that I just I mean even being on the school board when I read Joint School District number one Village of s Lakes it's like who who are we voting for can we put in like parentheses or does that make it I'll ask um just identify who we are tomorrow I'll probably email her back and uh well s just remind tomorrow tell me for sure the name

023send to me an email because I never heard us called Joint School District number one yeah that Brian always that's our name Silver Lake Salem joint number one I thought it was Silver Lake Salem Joint School District number one so I'll ask her if we can put riverv [Music] viiew hashtag I'm sure that would go to deny that real quick you throw hash um so I guess the bigger question because that's legal ease is do you is it this this part of the um language fitting to what you think needs to be on the ballot the capital maintenance part makes me a little lering why is that Joe because it's nonspecific you're more worried about being too broad I'm worried about Capital maintenance being perceived as freefor all whatever we decide we want to do

024with it rather than open up as fluff correct yeah it doesn't give it doesn't give to me the notion that it's a necessity it seems like that's just my Jim do you want to weigh in a little bit on that from from a Layman's perspective you know you guys can do whatever you want a lot of school districts keep it that way so that if there is you're not tied to exactly these four five six items that it is broader that we can get a lot of projects done under this um capital mainten yeah and Jim you and I talked about that a little bit and and and I I I understand that just concerns me I mean obviously we want a little bit of wiar room but it does just concern me just based

025on the number of respondents that we had that were possibly no you know it's like and and the reasons for that is because they think that we're already not managing our funds properly so to me those people the notion of giving us unfettered access to funds that they don't know what are being used for could we put like Capital Equipment including and like mention a couple the problem with that is you guys correct me if I'm wrong the more specific you are the more tied down you are with what we spend the money on and I think that I remember that from dealing with John that if you say you're going to do clever touchboards you have to do clever touchboards if you say not like going to but I think being I do think

026being vague and I think that's where it's our job as board members and you know Kim and staff to help us educate what does that mean right what are the projects that we're looking to do um because I think again the more specific you are the more hamstring you are really because if we open something up that opens a can of worms that we have to fix if we if we're very specific about it our hands are tied now we're going into general fund money to go pay for that versus using the money that we just as taxpayers right just wondering Renovations takes care a lot of correct I was wondering if we can't if we can't word it in a way that includes some project but also leaves room for vness for additional product

027like for repair of specific Roofing sections and similar projects but I also have the tendency to overthink wording on things soing it probably on the right path of that's part of our like listening sessions and getting out in the public and Sam like Capital Improvements is these types of things Grassroots in it where we just go along and verbalize it instead of having it written in the contractual language of the I just I just think if we're I mean you know again if we're if we're looking at doing a a project of this scope and magnitude um as much as I don't want to sit here and say I like the idea of having an open checkbook but you know again and I'll use you as an analogy right what happened at the restaurant when

028you took one wall down right you found a whole another project if we decide to do that in the office and we open up a can of worms and we were very specific now we're again we're we're in fund 10 we're taking money out of our general ledger we're increasing our deficit which means we're going to operational referendum faster um I just think the the vagueness is probably better keeping it vague in general it allows us to do what we need to do and then we can pivot and and again it's going to be you know going to the village board meetings it's going to be getting people in the building to have listening sessions it's going to be coffee at skullies to talk to the community members and senior citizens those type of things

029is where we're going to be able to help sell it um verse because again you if it's black and white it's black and white I I just don't think that's the right approach for us my my personal gut I do agree I do agree with that perspective through our through our referendum work they'll know EX exactly the projects we're doing we'll we'll bring that out to the community and they'll know so they're not going to get to this point of voting in the booth and be scared off by this question okay yeah I think if we've all done our job nothing should be a surprise when we get to April 1 right I mean you know if we if we we as a board decide to go forward next week and and you know put

030this on the ballot come April 1 if we've all done our jobs you know the support folks that are helping us can us as a board and and nothing should be a surprise when someone steps in on April 1 okay do you guys have any other questions for those two no I think we just for them no I think the legal name is obviously we what that is yeah well Sue and I I'll work on that tomorrow getting Alice in that and then I'll ask her about putting parentheses Riverview yeah does that make it not legal I don't know I would imagine that there's no way we would have enough time to do anything before we get this on but we should seriously consider looking into truncating it changing it and making it you know

031Universal for everything that we're doing I know because you have it's not just through the county you probably have to go through the state as well that's what I thought we were A1 J1 I thought you said now like we got another name that's like holy crap we got another name all right um Jim thank you very much for um Coming and Scott and um Merry Christmas to both of you uh Jim I will be in touch with you to let you know what the board decides we'll talk tomorrow we have our call great great data tonight we appreciate thank you very much thank you Happy New Year merry Christmas Happy New Year it it's not a super big comfortable margin of no Victory but it's it's gonna be a close one again at least

032it's over what they're plus or minus last time what 16 vs 15 15 16 vots was texting Andre and John but there's also a lot of people that didn't you know hopefully or did take the survey hopefully um you know in January we can kick off a more robust campaign so I'm meeting with them tomorrow and uh we'll start setting things up you're meeting with PSI tomorrow or the whole the whole the communications team and PSI so is that that Daren lady again or whatever her name was right Doran yeah lots of work to do yeah I met with Jim this past week and I mentioned you he's got a pricing sheet for us that is way way more easier to yeah I have that as an update for on the next board meeting okay

033so it's way more what Joel easier to understand yeah because their last you guys saw their last pricing list I think they shared with you it's really difficult to understand how they broke down a lot of their cost and where they did it yeah I thought you were pointing that out yeah yeah so I guess we're we'll go over that one next week yeah okay just uh this will be just really quick um We are continuing to update the budget um but this I I wanted to bring this forward to the board tonight I likely will have to talk about it next week as well um as the forecast model is um as we're revising things the forecast model is sort of changing a little bit but you can see where we are this year

034is in green and then sort of built out um it does take into account 3% raises and 10% increase in um healthare um so I there are some number adjustments again for this year um that I will talk about in January um but even with a bigger deficit the numbers still play out very similarly um I think that this is going to help as we're continue to talk about benefits and postretirement things and all of those things so this is part of the information I just wanted to give it to you a little bit ahead of time um before next week um the other thing I wanted to point out but now I can't remember oh the only other thing I will say is that uh we built in 10% I think that's a very

035like I think it's G to be much higher for benefit increases um so it's hard to know what going to be um two area school districts had 20% and we've had big claims this year so I'm I'm not it it's going to be um it's going to be a challenge in the spring to look at where we're going to be again this is what we know today we also don't have an idea of what the B banial budget's going to do and where that money is going to go however there is conversation at the federal level of um disbanding the federal the Department of Education which could lead to Cuts in title money so that is about probably a $200,000 swing if that happens um depending on if flow through is cut because that's the

036largest like Federal funding piece we get so lots up in the air but some decisions have to probably be made around um moving forward with the district before we have every detail in place anyway so we changed uh just looking at that 2627 shows 22.6% based on current forecast model right we changed our fund balance at 25 yeah so if nothing changes with the banial budget we'd be having very tough conversations in 26 27 not operational essentially yeah I mean again TW even you know you could go to 20% and still be okay that always you're trying to not have short-term B borrowing things uh it's the word in the state is I mean it's being very lobbied very hard to get increase in funding because especially around special ed funding um we're one of

037the lowest states in the country in our reimbursement um that's going to have unintentional consequences as well I can just imagine what's going to happen in districts now because of that but um there has to be there has to be something that gives because districts can't keep asking taxpayers and um we districts I don't know how you're going to continue to afford 20% increases in insurance so do we have a and we may have gone over this and I don't recall do we have any type of stipulation where employees can opt out of yes and receive a compensation yeah with cash yeah I mean because you know maybe maybe the route is to start educating a little bit better you're not seeing cash and L you're saying where they don't take our plan and they

038no instead of instead of taking our plan we we provide a compensation for not taking that plan which would be lower than what the plan cost is and then allow individuals to go out and seek through own insurance and I know that that makes people kind of weer at first but but in reality the cost for individual insurance is far more affordable 99% of the time than Group Insurance is there's a fear behind it because it's a comfort level that staff have with having always had it not having to go out and seek that but the cost benefits to not just the district but to the individuals themselves could be significant individual plans are always more affordable because they're more competitively shopped and group plans are I mean that's just a that's just a standard

039for insurance are you talking about through the marketplace yeah so my understanding but I'm not 100% sure on this is that if you work for an employer that offers Insurance you cannot get into the marketplace no that's not correct at all not if you have not well I I shouldn't say that I don't know about for a public institution but in a private organization absolutely if you provide you can provide a a basically a compensation for an employee opting out of the employee Insurance they're allowed to go into the go into the marketplace and purchase their own I would be shocked if I'd be shocked if that doesn't exist in in the public school especially Wisconsin because you don't have to be a union member as a future so I will tell you that we

040had an employee who was looking to to do that and she was told you you can't get insurance to the marketplace because your work offers it so I I will check into that because I can ask Ken um and I don't know if it was because it was public private I just know that she came to me asking me about it I think but I think the way you're saying it is essentially we offer family plan or an individual plan and we pay $10,000 we give an employee 7,000 to not take our insurance and they can go shop for themselves like is that what you're kind of like I'm just trying to tr understand they do it in the private they do it in the private Market all the time it's a standard practice most

041companies that have huge insurance plans do it because they prefer the individual to take their own plan because they still pay for it essentially but it's it's a it's a more affordable cost for the organization to buy an employee out of them taking the insurance package and generally speaking the individual will be able to go out and find better coverage for that $7,000 than what they're getting for the $10,000 us through through us because you're just not getting the same rates in a group plan that's kind of the misconception about insurance that that I've dealt with a lot in my my multiple companies when you're in a group plan it is far more expensive for the individual than on an individual plan that youve s of yourself in the private Marketplace well have I could

042be mistaken I will um I'll find out I don't think that I am I think I think that that's a misconception that somebody had somebody was told that they couldn't do that I don't think that's right especially if we're offering compensation to op out of the insurance okay but I always reserve the right to be stupid I will uh into it but regardless well regardless just showing you where at this moment in time where we are without that's all we can make decisions on right because there's tons of variables that happen so um it's better than the district that said 11 million deficits so feel good about that okay you gotta find it posi I didn't find our previous resolution and it's Joint School District number one Village of Silver Lake Town of Salem kosha

043County Wisconsin yeah that's it's even longer than what was on there just so you know yeah it's longer than what was on long it's longer than what you have up there yeah it lot of words to get Riv it says be it resolved by the school board of The Joint School District number one Village of Silver Lake Town of Salem Kenosha County Wisconsin I don't know if is that your area to dig into is that your area to dig into on how to go about because I think that's something that we should seriously consider I think it's long overdue we all feel the same way it's absurd it's confusing to the confusing to the residents it's confusing to people sitting who are on the Schoolboard admin and staff it's just else um nope our next

044meeting is Tuesday the 17th and we need a motion make a motion we adjourn second all those in favor I I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.