001I call the January 13th 2025 school board meeting to order it is 601 p.m we are in conference room C of the Fisher Administration Building at 12121 West North Avenue Miss Summers please call Mr Morris here Dr Ho here Mr wer here Dr warley here miss hmer Rolland here Mr Meyer here Dr Jessa banger here we have War this evening thank you everyone for being here and those in the audience as well um we begin with an opportunity for public Comon members which host a school board value the input of students parents staff members and community members the boards regularly scheduled meetings provide an opportunity for opinions and concerns to be expressed publicly the board values all comments and will respectfully consider this input in decision-making the board request that individuals limit their comment on
002each item to three minutes following any comments an individual board member May respond on the issue raised however it is not the intent to public comment portion of the agenda for the board to enter into a debate with a member or members of the community because non-agenda items are not publicly posted in advance no action will be taken on public comment regarding non-agenda items this evening uh is uh there any public comment in the room this evening to get us started good evening my name is Troy Woodard I'm a resident a parent and a candidate for Schoolboard seat number two uh thank you very much for everything you guys have done to date I we are entering into a phase of extensive change in very large capital projects so thank you for your consideration and
003detailed review of all the contract documents so that you can set our community up for long-term success Beyond just the limits of maybe this contract or future contract uh I look forward to meeting you all and working with the community to make sure that we're holding everyone accountable for what uh we are asking of them and is s their contracts thank you thank you say my address I thought that was no okay good evening my name is Jennifer Jacobs have three children currently enrolled at WMS and would like to speak tonight on the recent release of building Subs throughout the district I understand that as a district there are cuts that need to be made to make up for the pre previous budgeting errors but I have a problem when the cuts that are made
004are to the detriment of our school and District letting go of letting go of our build building Subs halfway through the school year not only makes it seem as though we don't value our teachers but it also negatively impacts our children's education when a sub is in a classroom it is more often than that a free day for students when leaving lesson plans for a sub the absent teacher has no idea who they are and what their capabilities are likewise the subs don't know the students and vice versa by having a building sub all of those issues are gone and it can be like any other day in the classroom I think it is especially important when Factor in that they already know what the student know the students and what their specific needs are
005I would now like to specifically speak about how it impacts WMS since that is the school I am obviously most familiar with we are on track to receiving our monor certification and with that comes a requirement that all our teachers must be monory certified Miss Issa our phenomenal building sub is currently getting her certification and her job as building sub was counting towards the hours she needs for that certific ation in addition to that I cannot overstate the vital role she plays in our school Community she leads the dance club the green team which is a student-led initiative regarding recycling composting and the effects it has on our planet she is beloved by students staff and parents and I am asking you to immediately reconsider not only her role but that of all the building
006Subs in the intrical part they play in our students education thank you thank you any final bill any final public comment in the room this evening Jamie is there anything online there are no hands raised online with that we will close public comment for the evening we will next move into the consent agenda are there any items on the consent agenda where which board members would like to remove for separate discussion and ACAC seeing none may have a motion it is recommended that the school board approve the consent agenda and ISO move thank you may have a second second thank you uh any board discussion on the consent agenda um my primary comment would be to thank all of the folks who uh provided donations to all Jus School District uh greatly appreciative for your
007gifts um please Mr Morris yes Dr Hoy yes Mr wer yes Dr Worley yes Miss Hammer Rolland yes Mr Meyer yes Dr Jess Binger yes and the consent agenda passes we next move into strategic goal six operations 2025 2026 school year open enrollment SE allocation good evening good evening thank you for the opportunity to go ahead and discuss the recommendation uh for open enrollment seats based on our uh enrollment projection uh and staffing needs for the uh 2025 26 school year uh prior uh to our um uh our meeting this evening I worked extensively uh with Luke and his team related to looking at um our current enrollment um um and then uh projecting what that looks like next year based on some assumptions that we will review um Luke's team in terms of uh
008his Administrative Assistant support staff his special education director have been immensely helpful in putting together these recommendations as I mentioned uh the recommendations are based on um our um uh based on our enrollment projection uh to then prepare Staffing um the average uh JK enrollment um for the past uh seven years has been 308 students uh per year uh that number is down just a little bit from what it was previously uh and that is our projected number for next year um SK is based on our current JK enrollment plus an additional 16% again is that's um that is closest to our Trend and then enrollment projections for the other grade levels um are a straight um rollup of this year so for instance this year's first grade would project next year's second grade uh
009we also based our staffing assumptions um on the class size ranges that you see you uh these are um very minimally adjusted um to what we saw this year uh with our class size ranges and our open enrollment capacity is based on 80% of the class size minimum at grade level using um using those uh class size ranges and assumptions um what this um slide shows is what our predicted um average class sizes by grade level at each of our schools you'll see that I have noted that there are four um sections um across uh three different schools that are at the high end of the ranges um invariably um every year we have um sections that we monitor to see see if they are going to um exceed the class size ranges um or
010if we're going to see some other changes in enrollments um so um again these are the the sections that are that we have already identified to go ahead and monitor um I did go ahead and compute what um the Open Enrollment capacity would be if we were to go ahead and add staff members um to these sections to bring the class sizes down it did not have any change on the Open Enrollment calculation um and uh I felt it was important that if we're going to have a system of using class siiz ranges and en norment projections to actually utilize it um and not um and not forego a conclusion about what our staffing looks like going forward um this past year uh again we used that same process um had sections we were monitoring
011um and uh came out with uh what I think are very reasonable and small compared to our peers class sizes when we look at um our peers in terms of average section sizes um this past fall we were able to go ahead and again look at wosa's class sizes in comparison to um two peer districts in the area um and we are um below average class sizes um across all of those sections and it's important to note that even with those four sections that are at the high end of the ranges as we average those students across all the sections um our average would still remain lower than what we're seeing in other school districts in the area So based on um the directed enrollment uh the class sizes and the number of sections uh
012you can see that um our grade capacity um is such that um uh we are um uh our grade capacity is above what we would take for open enrollment so for instance um um our class size at um sorry our class SI at uh for SK at 17 students requires us to have 18 sections that gives us our grade capacity of 306 but we'd have to be under 260 to go ahead and look to open up open enrollment seats in that space so the recommendation for JK through five um uh open enrollment seats is zero um the average class sizes at Longfellow and Whitman based on the projected sections um you can see what they look like here for next year average class sizes in the Milwaukee area school districts um are these for this
013fall and then the projected uh enrollment sections required and grade capacity shows that there would not be any recommended open enrollment seats in grades 6 through 12 for next year um our JK through 12 um program is not the only area where we need to look at Open Enrollment um we also need to look at our special education services and Staffing again I mentioned that working with M with Miss Stacy Clem uh is integral in terms of looking at our current needs capacity and open enrollment capacity um based on the needs that we have right now as well as um the Staffing to support needs of the students we would not have any open uh student or special education uh space in either cross categorical program or therapy services for next year uh and the
014last slide um is based on our virtual program uh Wisconsin virtual or w a Virtual Academy again based on um our class size ranges um and our enrollment capacity we would not have any open enrollment seats available through wva for next year either um from uh Mr Scott eer um I thought it was also important to take a look at what our history of open enrollment seats has been in the organization uh you can see that for this year um our overall change uh in open enrollment students uh was a loss of 16 students compared to last year and you can also see the forward Trend um for next year for 2025 26 by opening zero seats uh we would be down 136 open enrollment students compared to this year um and Scott has then
015also projected what that would look like um out for five years and that's all I have for you what questions may you have questions and comments from the [Music] board you help my internet um can you help me thank you can you help me uh understand how you come up with the Open Enrollment capacity so open enrollment capacity would be um 85% of the grade capacity capacity being based on the class size and the number of sections and in theory then that number is leaving room for inevitable movein to the district as well thank you any other comments or questions the boards on thank you very much thank you our next item up for strategical six operations discussion of audit request for propal and I'm gonna invite Jess hker to the front to walk us
016through this topic for anyone that doesn't know Jess she's our Director of Finance so kind of the number two in the business office integral part of uh budgetting in uh running many things in the office and recently we learned that um our auditing firm is going to stop auditing school districts so as Scott said uh this past November we were notified by our auditing firm they were no longer going to service the school districts so we prepared a request for proposal we sent it out to 10 um companies and we received four bids um after analyzing the information that came in um looking at the cost proposals which are attached for you we have decided to recommend lauderbach and Ammon um over the course of four years we could potentially save roughly $330,000 by um
017going with them they also meet all the auditing standards they are newer to Wisconsin um but they have already started picking up multiple clients across the district and have worked with multiple clients for the past um two years I believe um do you have any questions about our Auditors was the recommendation um solely based on on the cost comparison they're they're very different the other three are very very similar in price correct it was not based solely on price we actually had two that Rose to the top based off of their proposals um after doing an interview and asking more questions of them the two were equal in all aspects except for Price that's how we decided on lb yeah thank you yes better how much did we pay for our audit like this past
018year or how much have we been paying on average for old auditing company um it was I do not have that in front of me but I can look it up and get back to you it was right in this ball yes very compfortable questions from the board all right we plan on having this on the consent agenda at the next board meeting um there is no official contract there is just an engagement letter that we received from the Auditors in the spring no no contract but there's an understanding on on the fee there's some something in writing yes yes we do have their proposal in writing um and that becomes part of their engagement letter okay that has contractual effect but there's no document that says contract correct our next item is discussion of
019owner's representative contract 2024 capital refering so this is a bit of a repeat for Liz and Jason uh we had a discussion at finance committee about the concept of an owner rep and I would actually invite Liz or Jason to um if you like kind of tell us about the conversation we had there because I think if if you might be able to draw better context than I could sure go ahead so my understanding is uh that the district is going to hire a what are they what are they called an owner's rep an owner rep uh that pretty much is gonna make sure that our contracts that are signed as part of the referendum are held up I wasn't ready I'm sorry I put you on the spot one one of um I I
020should have contacted you again but one of the one of the um ways I'd like to move is um to allow the board members that are at the committee to also kind of present what was there so you're you're doing great here it is um it the recommendation is Building Solutions and they will Pro provide reports to the committee and to the board um and they will they have guaranteed a match or to exceed savings through uh cost savings du contracts that we will sign um the rep will be at mon monly board meetings to give us an update or answer questions and audit reports will also be provided um they're going to help um BJs with uh getting bids and making sure um that all aspects of those um of those bids are met
021throughout the length of the contract and that's the notes I have Jason um yeah I'll add to that just uh in in layman's terms it's uh what was was presented it it looks like we're hiring somebody but if you really look into it um we're we're hiring somebody who is coming in at a zero cost to us so the way it was explained to me was that um they don't get paid unless they are able to uh make they the physical savings uh of our budget so the goal um for them is to do more with less essentially um making sure that VJs and anyone else is being competitive with their bids um I think the example we just said was uh in in the in the last meeting was like if there's a roof
022that needs to be um done DJs may have a preferred vendor they work with um and if if it's something like that the owners rep would step in and say know we should really get competitive bids and let's get those bids and um if they if they find something that will provide what we need for less money and my understanding is the the costs saved from what what it would have been they get paid a percentage out of that is that essentially yeah there's a um there's a guarantee that we will what we pay them we will at least save and generally well they'll they'll speak to this in a second the districts see far more savings than what the owner rep um capture spores for me the main the the couple main things are
023um this this is essentially our agent um that acts on our behalf uh between the architect and the construction manager so it's another set of eyes on the work that's done the bids that are put out um making sure that the the quality of say equipment is actually what we expect things like that so we're getting what we pay for and not not trying to get more than than that um making the most of our money uh yeah and it's in I was going to say to go on top of that um I think you probably just said the same U but it's it's a additional level of oversight that um you know a project this big that spans this amount of time um that's a full-time job just overseeing that and we don't I
024I mean at least myself I would want a third party to make sure that that everything is going smoothly and on time and um you know then we we have other people to turn to when we need to know um who's accountable for one yeah and I have um I think I'll invite Kevin and um the the guys here to come up and briefly explain you know they'll be able explain better than than we could but but I think it was a great exercise and exactly what they do and maybe we already had our kickoff meeting last week so they could talk briefly about that too Mr eer before you leave I do have a question that's just for you man so if we were going to spend $10 and they find $1 in savings
025then we pay them part of the $1 does that well maybe I confess to glossing over this stuff too quickly the the what they get paid what fund does it come from because savings itself doesn't put cash in the all right so it comes from the referendum fun or correct correct oh good that's what I wanted to hear because otherwise we'd be kind of cannibalizing our you know what I'm saying no it all stays within the referendum funding okay um with with obviously the ultimate goal of finishing on time and on budget okay so for what we pay to them we still are using the referendum money so we aren't really saving referendum money for what we're paying to them however we have a quality assurance layer on top of this whole thing so we
026we with the dollars we spend we're getting more value from a risk perspective and quality perspective so that that's that's a big part of it another part is um there's a potential that we they're they're going to be reporting to us on a on a Cadence right um there there's no doubt there's going to be some items on our list that end up over budget and some items on the list that end up under budget um we we we're going to finish on or under budget and I would anticipate we'll be having conversations with the board throughout this referendum process that says um hey the the owners rep has found X Dollar in savings um let's put that in the parking lot for now and as we get towards the end of the referendum the
027board will have some choices to make as far as do we want to put that money towards something something that we weren't able to do or do we want to give that back to the taxpayers so that that's the ultimate is maximizing the available dollars so I would I would argue this really isn't an extra function you're bringing in this is a function that's part of a good process correct yeah that and it's something that should be done as a good practice yeah I don't know if anyone doing a a project this size covering this number of buildings that that would not yeah um have an owner thank you Dr sure so I'm not questioning the concept of owner rep or using one I think it's a great idea um but I am curious to
028know we have a pretty rigorous decision- making process in um that I've seen all of you use in our district um and I'm wondering if the owner's rep will have a similar one and do we have some input we just started with our Net Zero sustainability committee subcommittee last week and um and one of the things that was expressed as part of that is a great interest in being part of the conversations about the referendum projects so I'm wondering if the person or the group organization that you put forward um has provided what their decision-making process will be not just you said it's not just about dollars it's about quality um is it also something that they've worked on in terms of like sustainability and um you know the outcome of are they are they
029working typically in educational environments what what kind of decision-making tool are they using I think if you don't mind all that Kevin I figured you're teeing them up maybe okay sit down you should sit down okay you like me to answer uh your question first great um yeah our experience we primarily so I'm Kurt uh Building Solutions is our company uh where the owners rep um thank you for inviting us back we're involved in your 2018 project uh as your owner's rep as well so it's great to be back here uh yeah our firm primarily Works in K12 environments um Kevin did share that uh the the initiative you guys are looking at as far as energy and efficiency which are think is great um the way from a policy standpoint or or a goal
030standpoint you guys set what those goals are and then we work towards those um and and work off with the analysis of efficiency you know what are the what are the goals that are set by the committee and then as we go through each individual project we see how we can best attain those goals so as far as background and experience on past projects and sustainable projects uh if you're familiar with lead um I'm lead accredited uh myself so I have that um education side and I've done lead projects as well um that's one way you can show sustainability but there's also other ways of just putting targets out there so yes very very um um have the experience and um be excited about that process of being able to uh if there's a Target
031out there trying to hit those targets um and weighing in the different the different pros and cons for each individ idual decision to to get there and I last one followup these list um in this great document where it lists the different things um that you might do uh mentions grants um and potentially could you tell us a little bit about that um and would it potentially include to the sustainability topic do you have any experience with the federal um inflation reduction act yes y great question I appreciate that because you're in uh uh uh did a large solar project 378 um KW pretty large uh project for uh nicolay and probably as you drive down uh uh 43 you probably see all the solar panels on there and that was Uh I spearheaded that
032to get the tax credits associated with that piece so they'll get a couple hundred, back uh as a tax refund which is something new for school districts uh usually if you're not paying taxes you can't get a tax uh a tax refund but in this case because of the inflation reduction act we will get that but um so that's an example uh but we keep an eye out for whatever other grants we can find depending on when it's happening so that's that's something that we will be involved with thank you uh I think an important thing for both the board and the community to know uh as a result of the work the staff did in the last referendum we were under budget over across the whole referendum and as with all things some buildings
033were over some buildings were under but in general we delivered back to the taxpayers everything we said we were going to do at a lower rate and did additional projects that we identified uh that we were not able to cover with our original plan for the referendum all within the referendum parameters we were able to do more for the taxpayers we would have otherwise so um this is something that I think worked really well and I think and on on time as well yeah during a pandemic on time y so um really outstanding work that the staff delivered for the community on the last referendum so thank you any other questions from the board one question um maybe and I know you have the weekly cadences or the cadences at our meetings for updates will
034there be anything that'll be provided uh on the website or your website or any place for the community to keep track of the projects and things that are going on are ongoing yeah great great question so um typically on our projects we will have our architect that we're working with p during the design side provide those monthly updates um so I don't know that we haven't specifically talked about it that I know of with uh with this project yet but that's a common practice that we'll we will encourage because the public wants to know right and be be updated and then when it gets to construction time uh ask our construction manager to do a monthly update that that is in a format that is uh easy onepage summary but keeps every dat spot you
035can put it on the on the website so I would I would expect that to be the case for this project as well thank you um later in the agenda Scott's going to talk about a new transparency website and that's going to have a referendum section in it as well that the board and public will have access to to follow the projects thank you very much thank you you uh the next item on our agenda underneath strategic goals six operations discussion of GSF contract extension Mr eer you're getting your steps in yeah um this I think should be quick GSF is our cleaning company and our contract um has expired with them we've been negotiating since about November on a new contract um I'll say I've squeezed them about as tight as I can um
036and the recommendation at the next board meeting will be to accept the contract with GSF I will say Kevin and Kevin the Kevin in our office that um run the bildings and grounds Department have really worked hard over the last 12 months to um get get the right number of GSF workers in the right places at the right times and and um that that gives me great comfort with this going forward that we now have we essentially a we've right sized that that um contract questions so if if I'm reading this right that contract is roughly 2.4 and then 2.5 million the next next two uh years is that um and and I'm asking because I I genuinely don't know pre pandemic what was what was the annual budget like for similar Services I'm just
037curious as to whether or not that we're still on kind of on par or um are we doing more now that we're we've gone through that experience um or or were we doing more during it and have pulled back kind of like you know maybe a little more detail on the contract on the squeeze would it would it be right if I brought that to either the finance committee or the board I because I I don't have the experience to know what we were paying before I imagine at one point we probably employed our own staff of uh cleaners or custodians or something like that I don't know what year we would have made the shift was was anyone on the board at at that point Mr oh um 10 11 years ago wasn't it
038yeah years ago we did um before that we did Food Service then we did cleaning stuff and some maintenance stuff as well and it was those are very hard decisions as we out basically we outsourced right so I I'll provide to the board um essentially kind want say fiveyear history of those costs yeah I mean really and Fin meeting that's totally fine I just I just wanted a rough picture of kind of here here's where it was pre pandemic here's where it was during and here's here's what we're aiming for now are we like where are what kind of curve are we looking at now what's the the gist of the question about the way we used to do it has to do with cost savings or no what I certain of wasn't following where
039you live um yes uh I if we're looking at two roughly two and a half million dollars of a that's a little over 2% of our budget that's a big percentage I'm just curious as to um whether it's consistently been 2% or has it been kind of all over the board or I don't I don't know we don't have I don't have access to those numbers when those roles were employees cost were significantly more that's a relative statement you know when you're looking for a dollar here a dollar there everywhere you know it matters uh and it's not just the salaries it's there's number of employees you have to manage from an HR perspective there's um oh what's it called when someone's injured and they workers compensation sorry right there's all kinds of stuff we
040don't have to deal with my question wasn't uh wasn't about us bringing it in house it was related to since we've started using a vendor what does it what does it look like I I just okay so from that starting point what are the trends as close to that starting point as possible really okay sure com on up two and a half years ago uh District did this out again previous to that the firm that they had previous GSF participated in that bid they lost GSF was chosen so I would imagine boss were competitive at that time and then now we're in that stage right now where their increase uh was a option for either for us to uh engage them on uh negotiating their their increase for an additional two years okay so there
041has been competitive bidding on but I'll provide the yeah I I completely understand what you're wondering the finance me thank you any other board questions in this setem thank you Mr waler for your questions I one question um maybe in that research there um I know they've that their inclusions and the things that are baked in maybe there's some detail there if this is a consumption model or a value model based on I know we're in the cleaning or chemical business to buy our own stuff but I know sometimes companies of looks like they're fairly large in our region on there uh are we paying for stuff that's on a truck that may go to other places or is it all everything that we're consuming is all ours we can account for every about bit
042of it so all the equipment they purchase and maintain and then the chemicals uh GSF use I forget the exact terminology but they make the chemicals in the facilities okay with pure tap water through some sort of electrical process so that they can ionization and that kind of thing um so they make four basic chemicals uh for four uh the four basics of cleaning disinfectant general cleaning window cleaning that kind of thing um so it's all produced here it's safe um and EPA registered excent okay there one other thing uh I did just to make sure it's known it's it's both cleaning and also uh snow removal and and salting is is part of the inclusion which is kind of a you never know here are we going to get 15 snowstorms or the GSF
043is is simply uh cleaning the facilities in the document it says snow removal and Sal entrances of entrances so here's an example it snows tonight and there's an activity like the school board meeting the GSF staff person aside of this building the responsibility is to keep That Sidewalk clear within the vicinity of the parking lot okay the rest the majority of snow removal will be on our staff okay so they're just you know so our staff will be out here plowing getting most of the sidewalks they're just there to kind of treat the sidewalk in the immediate vicinity of the doorway right so it's not a substantial part of their work and I'll point out like Mr Meer said that we used to have our own staff that worked the buildings at night and they
044represented while was hos um GSF we kind of look at them the same way it's a partnership with them they are the people that everybody sees that everybody visits their building students staff parents they're the first point of contact a lot at nights and on weekends they staff the building to keep them open so we consider them an extension of our staff they do provide a really good service within interaction at all yes thank you that will be back on consent cor right uh next item is discussion of new transparency website um Tim I'm GNA ask you for the best way to approach this this is actually live on our website right now I don't can I just navigate from here I would minimize I it okay and then share I can p okay oh
045look at that okay so we've been talking um for several months we you might remember we created an initial sort of Gant chart of a trans transparency page that said hey here's some benchmarks we're going to get to and one of those benchmarks was launching a uh more robust transparency page so as of this morning um this is now live on our website and I just want to show it to you how to access it um how the public can go in and play with and download data and um just you know access essentially whatever they want so it's housed under the business office or finance and operations and for a long time oops I'm making people dizzy um we've had a financial transparency tab here so uh yesterday had you clicked here you would
046have got that Gant chart um today it's going to open up to the this our transparency page and this is provided by this software as a service from a company called cleargov uh we um they service about 1,200 school districts or 1,200 um local governments um and you can see that it's kind of like a dashboard so people can click through there's multiple tabs at the top each has a little bit different information um you sometimes there's breakdowns available so here we're looking at our students if you want to see more data there's a link for a [Music] breakdown and so when I click that now I can see student enrollment by grade level uh I can go back various years and see um where we had students what the cohorts were here you can
047see our um kind of different cohorts broken out I do want to point out for the purpose of this transparency page the peer group that we're using is different than the peer group I would normally use with say salaries so for salaries we need to be competitive in the metro Milwaukee area the peer group that we chose to use with this are the districts um most Like Us in terms of student FTE so they're more across the state but when it comes to comparing things like number of Staff members um it it's um that seems more relevant than you know someone in the metro area that might have 200 staff members uh if we wanted to say view the analysis it'll even show you then um the districts that are part of uh this peer
048group so in this case we're looking at um I think this is students with uh low income so we can see at least in this peer group of like size peers um we're relatively we we have a lower percentage of low-income students uh and in this group the two highest would be West Dallas and Wasa for instance okay um I I'll demonstrate expenditures I think that's a little more fun than the revenue side um there's just more to kind of go through so again uh options for multiple years here um we are seeing a breakdown in a p chart but you could if you if someone prefers a bar chart you can simply choose bar chart um everything is downloadable uh so there's a button to see if I click this yep here we have
049you see actually by account and you can download um the data by account number and you can see the actual amount spent um that' be in the prior year versus the budget for the current here okay um if you wanted to see this by say something other than fund you can choose different categories of how to view it one thing I really like is it also Compares our spend uh on a per student basis so to kind of give some relativity to um to this the employee side has collected all of our employees and then for instance Compares them with the peer group we chose and the state average so you know here really quickly we can see here's our student to teacher ratio compared to the state average then we have um some ratios
050relative to this peer group so uh salaries for instance were 1% lower than the the this peer group again that's different than the Metro peer group um you can see we are in terms of number of employees and then by employee group even so here's our licensed profession licensed professionals per student compared to the peer average and the state and then just how we Trend it over time even finally um dashboards these are things we can customize so this is where the capital referendum um data will exist when we have more I don't think I have anything in here right now yeah just some rationale but as we uh right here I just have the full list of projects linked but as we complete projects I'll be able to put in here um essentially charts
051by building and what we spent on I've got all of it broken down so let's say say Eisenhower Ada project um deferred maintenance project or the there's going to have to be a bucket for both you know it's a combined project but people will be able to track what we spent on those different projects by building as well so again it's it's live right now um we're we're a little bit trying to find that balance between keeping the essential things here sometimes it's it's easy to go overboard I'm putting too much and then people are confused about where to go for what so um Jesse Tuttle our new communications director and I are working on finding the right places for the right things but we're really excited about this Mr my where is the database
052sure so um we send our data from our Erp system our financial system to cleargov um they run it through their proprietary software and so this is software as a service um today I had a data update for them so we um we moved a few dollars from account a to account B I sent them the like I just load to a secure site the the new budget and I don't know an hour later it was updated so they host the data correct and we interface the data to them mhm so we just have a a batch point to point over a period of time yeah it's not that sophisticated is not doing an overnight download or anything just when we have material changes I send them to them okay so it on demand a
053batch file of some sort and so the database activity is against their database in the cloud wherever and not against ours correct so we don't have login exposures right everything here is St it's all up in their in their world well that's nice yeah so right it's essentially read only right and there is no one no one's coming in through our firewall correct do this okay that's nice stole one of my my questions there second question and uh if I can remember it now nope can't remember so let know if he was the first I'm an integration consultant so that I was so that's not necessarily a question but more of a comment in the last two minutes it I was able to download spreadsheet from 2025 with over 100,000 lines of transactions um you're
054G have a busy night so no well the the comment that I'm I want to make towards it is does this help in any way alleviate um like open records requests from your department or um Andor like it is are we gonna are we going to make life easier there on that front I I think in many ways we will because when we get an open records request right now that's looking for this information um often we have to download it from our system and then send it out so if someone's requesting something that's available here now the response can just be I'll send them the web link and they can go get the data so absolutely what is the cost of this service yeah the board approved it a few months ago H I'm
055gonna ballpark it's like eight grand this is amazing yeah it's it's um there's a phase two that I'll be launching later this year we can um create a digital budget book from it as well so um my goal is when we do our preliminary budget this summer in addition to the paperbook there's also a digital one that many of the graphs work like this for instance so um I'm sorry I thought I was I didn't want to interrupt but I'm will only be around for four more months so I just to try to look through a crystal ball um I put a imagine that the consumers of this might find things that will help us doing a lot of data analysis and whatever maybe some suggestions for us and on the other hand it could
056be used to make people overly sensitive about variances or maybe spending more in one building than another something well beyond what Dr means would ever intend to do so I I would just ask the bo Be watchful that it's it's used for you I'm all about open government and transparency and um but I could also imagine that it could be used to try to bully people around in a sense and that if if too much too much data is used for things that are not in furtherance of open Effective Government just in furtherance of just disrupting us I think we'd be a long ways from that but who knows the unintended consequences you know I do think this this data is terribly fun for people who like data I I I mean it it could
057really really help us see things you know the kind of brain power it takes the brain power and the time I'm sure you could do everything Mr eer but takes time to look at stuff so all right so just to put that out there be we need to Be watchful of unintended consequences and how we might have to put some guardrails on this somehow some way but I don't see I can't see it right now but everything somehow turns out to be something it didn't intended to be good and bad so okay thanks Mr record in in our Pure districts how many do you know of any that are using this or doing anything of this level we're one of the few in Wisconsin White Fish Bay was using it um I can't find that
058they are anymore so I don't know if anyone else in Wisconsin using it right now there's a difference between making data transparent and then in public policy people having opinions on how the money's being used we can't right we can't solve that nor candidly do we want to we we stand by how we've allocated information I think as Miss heimr Rollin referenced there the Staffing report has been on the website for the last two years and so if people there's still allegations that we we under staff one side of town over the other which is not accurate that information is on the website how people interpret how we utilize the dollars is different than having access to it and so we're very proud of the fact that there's access now there's also healthy public policy
059conversations around if that's where the the the information and the resources should be allocated that that's for the Public Square to have those those dis discussions but from a from a staff perspective we're very proud of the fact that this this alleviates and and eliminates the allegation that information isn't available it is available um then then it is up to the public to form their own perspective yeah um I just want to thank Mr eert because when you came onto the board it was I'm sorry into the district um you were not coming into an easy situation um and I think you've done more than anyone could have expected when you started so I want to say thank you I think we're we've talked about in finance probably one of the if not the most
060transparent school district with our finances now and the um different things that you have implemented since you started so I just want to say thank you that that's nice um I I appreciate it no no no I'm sorry I I don't take compliments well um what's going through my head is I no sorry what was going through my head is I want to make sure I thinkk my staff who um some of some of whom are here but um I I guess I'm up here today but it's in large work because of what they've been able to do also in our office so I want to make sure that I get that word across them more eloquently than I did just now so thank you any other board questions sure I comment I would suggest
061you make this available to the um um certification schools for student projects well you know the um in the you know the business manager lens your courses they're required to do oh I sure sure I mean this is just a wonderful set of data for people to practice on how to manage and to come up with ideas so I would yeah even with even Within our own school you know I I I would encourage you to partner with just me talking I mean what what certification programs are left a lot of them have ended you know closed and things like that but this is just a wealth of good data for people to practice thinking about managing education I think that's a really really good good thing you know I don't want to I don't
062want to be heard as expressing any doubts or NE netives about this I think it's a really really great idea um so I would but when I was taking my classes I wish there had have been something available to do a seminar project or sure something like that I like that idea thank you do um is there any additional information on the multi-year budget projections that's a separate topic I know just leading into oh I'm ready for that topic if you so you have to get I'm off the humor is not um any other questions from the board um Mr AK thank you for your work on this I know there's a lot of work going into communication I know the FI my colleagues in the finance and operations committee thank you for your continued
063work on this as well um tonight we uh approved the audit recommendation uh and accepted the audit as a board uh so lots of things coming together uh could change make sure there's good Financial overs sites thank you thank you uh with that we will move into our multi-year budget projections Mr eer Perfect thank you the floor remains your is making the transition to the the next presentation I I think it's I want to just emphasize what Miss heimr Rollins shared we asked Mr eer to run a Sprint immediately when he came on board well candly before he started um and uh he has met every Challenge and so I on behalf of the board again Mr eer and your team deserves a lot of credit this next item 4 f is critical to ensuring
064that whatever budgets we deal with and whatever challenges we have in front of us in terms of budgeting we know what they are ahead of time a good organization has the ability to have a multi-year um budget projection out ahead of itself Mr eer has taken on the challenge I've been in districts where we typically do a three-year projection U what you're going to hear tonight is a fiveyear projection um now I think you're going to also hear from him that it is critical that we don't hold these numbers um true going out four five years but at least we know what's ahead of us for the next few years and we can candidly um from a governance standpoint and from an operational standpoint make good decisions and so we're really excited to present this
065um this this um presentation to you so Scott the floor is yours sure thank you um and I think I'll preface by saying um the finance committee has had uh not not a preview into the projection but we had some significant conversation at the finance committee about the assumptions that would be used for the projection is that any kind of projection or scenarios are only as good as those assumptions and um those are those are detailed here as well um but first I want to just talk about the difference between a a forecast versus a budget and in in my prior role working um with with school business officials and superintendents and school boards um those those two things are related but I often times found my peers confusing a project ction with a budget
066and um they're two very different things they they work together but I want to make sure that we're clear on what each of these is and I want to point out a little bit what the the differences of those are and so today we're focused on on a forecast and the reason we need a forecast is to to guide our future decision- making um so that we can make um good relevant decisions based on where we think we're going to be uh relative to finances um as opposed to a budget which is really marked to be a point in time normally 12 months and it's about sticking to a precise plan so a forecast you'll see there's going to be multiple projections based on what ifs uh we can modify that frequently over the course
067of you know the five years in this case that's very different from a budget where that's a a there's certainty with that or there should be and um is not as fluid by Design as a forecast um I talked about time frame uh level of detail obviously is different uh we're not going to produce a forecast um Jason said he downloaded 100,000 line items right um that that's a budget um we're it would be impossible to create a forecast for five years with a 100,000 line items so I'm not forecasting um like say right now let's pretend we have five social studies teachers I'm forecasting we'll still have five social studies teachers they may not be the exact same people um when we actually build the budget I'm putting in who those five people are
068at a level of granularity so I know exactly what they're going to cost that would be an example of a a difference there um same thing with say um utilities are a good example um I tell you what I got my utility bill at home the last month and I was surprised by by we um but I am projecting utilities at a certain rate based on historical practice that's something that likely will will get updated year-over year as we have more information so the assumptions used um in in kind of the Baseline of these scenarios uh we we have three main categories revenues uh enrollment and expenses so our revenues um our revenues at anytime we are ending a bium are the hardest things to predict because because there we don't know what the state's
069going to do so I've always found best practice to be to use the current state statute um there's even more assurances I guess this year than many given the governor's line at envido a couple years ago um that cast forward the per people increase for I believe it was 400 years I you know that's unlikely to stay there for 400 years but there's more certainty with that next year than there has been in Prior by anym um there's a lot of talk about what could happen with special education Aid certainly it would help our district um immensely if special education aid went up I don't think it's prudent though to build a forecast based on something other than forign State Statute uh I do want to point out the third item down this property tax
070exempt Aid we received this you might recall for the first time last fall and it's about $1.4 million it's unclear in statute whether that was a one-time payment to school districts or is going to be an ongoing payment at this point I'm recommending that we assume we won't get this again build our budget eventually we'll pivot the budget um and until we have certainty of whether we're getting that money or not I'd rather have this as a good surprise later than account for Revenue we may not get so that's my kind my conservative nature there uh on an enrollment standpoint we're using a fiveyear cohort survival rate so the way that we calculate that is I'll look back uh over five years and I'll say um how many first graders on average make it to
071Second Grade that might be 98% it might be 102% but I'll do that grade by grade um and find the fiveyear average that how how many normally make it from first grade to to second grade and that becomes um our enrollment estimate the good news with our enrollment estimate is it doesn't impact our Revenue very much frankly because of our size district and we're that we're in declining enrollment now um if we go up by 100 students or down by 100 students it's not going to impact our Revenue now those changes potentially could impact the Staffing plan right so on the expense side it would it would impact things but um if we were at a district that had 600 students in the whole district and they go surprisingly go down by say 20 students
072that can have a drastic impact on a district like that um so I just want to point out if if if we end up being off five students from the projection that that's not going to have an impact on Revenue uh we just heard about Open Enrollment but that's also built in uh the reduction of essentially seniors graduating out and not backfilling them on the Personnel side um right now it's built as a flat staffing plan um with the exception of we I've built in a reduction of 15 FTE to offset the Open Enrollment loss of Revenue as far as salaries and benefits go I really want to move us um to considering sories and benefits as a total Compensation Plan so we we we have to make sure that we are budgeting our benefits
073as well as our salaries as a as a in totality um to do one without the other uh leads to surprises frankly like we had this fall with health insurance so um right now the uh assumption is a 4.42% total comp that equates to a 4% health and 8% I'm sorry 4% salary 8% health insurance increase if health insurance were to be 10% we would need to say what can we do with salaries to still get to 4.42 um likewise if health insurance were only 6% that would give us more room with salaries and then finally other expenses have all been built in with just a 3% inflationary increase so that's all the assumptions there any questions about these does the compensation um does that include the 8 million that was set aside in the
074operational referendum for increases for staff what we can afford is 4.42 and that does it meets the the everything that might be on the next slide actually maybe there's a different way my intent was to uh my intent was to include it here everything that we are required to do by the operating referendum is included as part of these objections okay you boasted something very different so I want to make sure there's Clarity so you asked the question does that $8 million just get earmarked as funding for compensation that's not what Mr Ecker just said correct so help me understand that because that was specifically how we said out in the referendum how we chose that specific amount so here's how I'll answer that I don't know what the board would have given as an
075increase had there not been a referendum um so that number is somewhat arbitrary be because it could have been a cellary freeze so $8 million over a salary freeze certainly is accounted for um so I don't I don't know what the beginning point was which is why I I can confidently say we're living up to what the referendum requires us to do I'll say it another way yeah no I think understand what you're saying I just I mean if if what we were I mean I don't know I guess we didn't we weren't that granular about what were we intending in my mind it was here's where we're at for compensation we're taking that and we're taking this extra eight million if the referendum passed and we're dispersing it appropriately to staff not we're starting
076at zero if if we didn't have the referendum I would be coming now and saying our total comp should be 2% 1% salary 8% health so I I I'm not trying to skirt the question um the hard part is we don't know how many people we'd even have here had the referend not passed and again we don't know what the starting point was we we said yes we would use some for salaries but we don't know what the Baseline was for salaries yeah so maybe a different way of asking that U the $8 million we we would have been short $8 million next year right is that oh if the referendum had not passed we'd be short $14 million next year um just so the the op my I'm trying to what I'm trying to
077I guess ask is the funds from the operating referendum they need are kind of like their own fund right like they they're they're going to get dispersed where they need to be to align with the budget that we approved right yeah so um maybe here's another way to look at it or or maybe I'm get to confus and more I don't I don't know um right now we have I have to scroll down to see exactly but I I think it's a little over a million dollar Surplus that we hopefully can maybe build back into fund balance if we weren't um committed to giving that extra salaries I could come to the board today and say hey let's put $3 million into fund balance next year I can't do that because we're committed to paying
078that out in salaries is that maybe a fair way of saying that how much of an increase will we see in the amount of money going towards compensation from last year to this year recognizing there's a whole lot of moving Parts who have a a ballpark number uh let's see I I had it a few months ago for it um I I don't want to I don't I don't want to say something and then I'm wrong and I absolutely can get it to I can probably go to the transparency site right now figure it out I think that that's and I think the the goal of the referent was to prioritize and contining to increase teacher compensation ways that would make us continue us to move beyond the being we were well under a in
079salary not in benefits but in salary we are now what you're articulating is it is wisest for us to look at total compensation benefit costs as well as uh salary of the teacher the teacher level and that we need to continue to move that and invest more resources there this is doing that at a 4% increase over last year um that includes both money to continue to stabilize cost of benefits primarily health insurance but everything else it's in there too and then a 4% increase in salary correct and that that will be how that really shakes out as we get closer to budget season is where where's our our health insurance and other insurance cost trending because we're self insured and what's the balance could be that hirees out the less we pay in Insurance
080costs the more we can give the salary question I have is as we give more in salary so if this year we were able to give 5% because our health insurance costs are down we're then committed to that year over year correct and then next year comes out health insurance is 12% what is I'm c one of the things I'm curious about and we'll be curious to hear whether it's this board or the next board is once we've committed to higher salaries it's such a large percentage of our budget we can't peel back from that so there there's a balance of like as a board I've heard pretty consistently we want to pay our teachers born teachers are the life blood of the organization and how can we do that in a way that's sustain
081and so I think that will be really important information for the board to Grapple with as we move forward not just in this year what does it look like because it's a it's a long-term commitment ideally we may be committing to a teacher for 15 20 years that we hope yeah we want we want long-term relationships th trickly the greates can you clarify what you mean by if we give them if they get a 5% increase we have to do that the next year what do you mean by that one the the increase is going to once we're committed to that 5% increase it's increasing all of our salaries that much more year-over-year and it is difficult to continue that pace of increases when maybe you have to invest in other places so it gives
082you less flexible spending it's not a a one-time investment in resources and so I just I think it's really important we're gonna there's going to be some the boards in the future will have some challenges because we will also be shrinking the organization so how we shrink the organization is we divest enrollment because the students will drift out of the secondary schools last but in some ways the secondary schools have the most flexibility and Staffing and so there's a there's a complicated nature to to Grapple with this and I know they smart people thinking about this but it'sot there's not stability in the organization in the short term there's a lot of dynamic opportunities here well I there's going to be change stability maybe is a little bit different word for change I know what
083you're saying but I I'd say let's start off for sure and say there's going to be change in some significant fundamental parameters but we could take a stable path into it or an unstable path into it and the community has given an Incredible Gift of investments in education so my so all things considered my my guess is that you prefer the word change over instability there will not yeah there won't be stability there won't be yeah you said there won't be well there could I'm trying to help help your argument here I I would prefer the word there's there's we're not going to be static we're going to change and if we change if we manage or change well we will be stable if we don't manage or change well we could risk instability or
084not stable so uh I guess just because I've heard a lot of different things to to clarify um so what you're saying is that that you're you're using the Assumption of an overall compensation per employee basis of 4.42% year-over-year and to what Eric was saying um that we are committing to that that's the difference is if I get a 4.42% raise this year versus a 4. 42 42 the 4.42% bonus there's a there's a big difference in that I get the same amount of money for the next year but um when I get a bonus I'm my the employer is not not on the hook for paying that same amount the following year or years after if I get the raise um unless unless someone does something to affect performance or change position you can't
085you can't from an HR perspective you can't just um take the money away unless there's about reason from you can't you can't reduce someone's salary unless there's a valid reason that that's I think my understanding and it one one of the items that the the the teachers union asked MOSI and I when when we started working on veloping an actual teacher salary schedule is to make sure the compensation was visible so that's the first word visible it wasn't visible before there was no schedule the second term that they used was predictable so I think what Dr Jess of anger is sharing is that when it is not a bonus but it's a compensation package that's built on the previous year that is visible because you can predict and see is visible and in terms of
086what you can see it's going to happen from year to year and it's predictable what Mr Ecker is stating is that in order for us to have a better control of our finances long term we can't continue to talk about this in silos of here's teacher salary and here's the cost for insurance that prior to act 10 we talked about compensation this way of for educators all the time in terms of total compensation package it allows a governing board and an Administration to better manage and and and predict what we had to pay for so I I think we're all we're throwing a lot we're throwing out a lot of different concepts but to try to bring it all in house we are meeting the needs of the Union when we met with them they
087wanted it to be they wanted compensation to be visible and predictable we're doing it I think what Mr eer is stating and I think what the community has shared with us is they also need to have something that is predictable because if it is the the the will of the governing board to go above 4.42% then we just need to know and then we'll have to make subsequent cuts to go above that um and I think a lot of the number one question that I received um leading up to the referendum was does this end it does this end the need for us to continue to to go beyond what the taxes um are going to call for it may not if the goal is to go above the 4.42% U for total compensation it
088may not if the state legislature continues to underfund public education so there's a lot of variables that Mr eer would say in his fiveyear plan that he can't control um but the 4.42% at least gives us a starting point yeah can I can I um this this is the conversation with that sort of start to bleed into budgeting um and and I completely understand it um but I just want to reinforce we there'll be a separate board meeting where we propose raises and the board hasn't approved a staffing plan yet um these These are simply Baseline assumptions so we have an approximation of where we'll be three years from now four years from now five years from now with lots of decisions for the board to make between now and then so I agree and
089take your argument well that 100 students isn't a big deal unless it's 100 down three years in a row that it starts to be a a bigger deal than a not big deal that has not happened we were oh 5650 57 5800 resident students now we're below 5500 so we're a couple hundred less than we we had been if that stays where it is well talking forecasting what direction is are things going in right so if that direction continues to go in a way that we don't like that has to be noticed somehow another thing is as we wind down open enrollment the average state aid for a student in front of a teacher will increase right over the next four or five years that's a a good direction for the wind to be blowing
090for that the um premise of open enrollment was to increase revenue from buildings because buildings were cost centers and so you really really are using open enrollment to cover building costs because like you said teachers are a variable cost more or less students right so um we should fundamentals are kind of going in the right direction because we're reducing open enrollment but there's going to be some transition cost and we funded that with referendum I would think you know I'm assuming this Jump Ahead to the um operating referendum has to be renewed uh theoretically but if we come to the community three four years from now and say okay we had an oper operating referendum of X dollars four years ago we've done all these things to make it better so we still need an
091operating referendum but it's only this percentage of what the last one was so you know make that case with the community it'd be you know so things are looking good um for 20 years Elementary enrollment has been stable and if you look at it year in and year out we you know with the rollups from second to third third to Fourth some years you win some years you lose it's you can't really but if you look at it for 20 years you say well it's still pretty much the same for 20 years same thing within the Middle School same thing Within the high school um but we always had an increase between Elementary to middle school and middle school to high school we did we haven't had such big increases from middle to school to
092High School the last couple of years so of course that increase if it's an average of 40 a year and we don't get that 40 for 4 years well that's 160 right 160 students and now you're starting to talk real money but I just always looked at it like whatever was happening if it if it was different next year no big deal we watch it for two three four years to see what happened so i' I'd say just watch how that goes see you know on the big 25 you have 25 years of data four years from now if we have a new normal well we have a new normal and if we're increasing from middle school high school if it if it bounces back well now we know that if it doesn't bounce back
093now we know that we're still going to have the same number of high schools who just have to add year and year out budget our teachers so it does look positive for what you're saying why don't um let's I I want to talk about some of the priorities because you're you're as we move along you're going to see uh early years of the projection we have small surpluses later years the projection we have deficits so I I just kind of want to ground ourselves in sometimes having additional money is as is as challenging as not having enough because when you have additional everybody wants it and so I I just want to ground ourselves a little bit in here's some of the priorities that will be that are challenges for us right um and frankly
094no school district is ever going to say they have enough money and and we don't have enough to offset every challenge we have um so I I just want to remind the board we have the in some ways competing interest here even of rebuilding the fund balance um we we have a I'll say we have a temporary solution to our deferred maintenance issue via the referendum um unless our solution every five years is going to be a capital referendum we don't have a real solution to deferred maintenance so we still have that to Grapple with um and I'm including there things like equipment replacement Cycles I I have not been able to find a equipment replacement cycle I can for technology but not for things like I I'll give you an example we just had
095some rigging that we need to fix in our theaters we don't have a replacement cycle for things like that um we we're always going to want Equitable access for students to you know resources one of our top priorities we talked about is recruiting and maintaining high quality staff um we we will be right sizing budgets um some need to go up some need to come down and then um we need to honor prior commitments too so all of these things are going to be rolled into uh both forecasting and uh budgeting when we get to that so the remaining variables that are still out there we talked about special ed reimbursement the per increase that's unlikely to change enrollment is one of those we're keeping an eye on obviously and then I mentioned the $1.4
096million in uh for that property tax uh exempt so I built three scenarios um I you know one thing I always coached my clients on with with forecasting is um I would tell them there's a 100% chance if you built one scenario that it's not going to happen like that that's the one thing we know for sure um it's impossible that a forecast is going to be to the dollar three years out so um I think it's important to build multiple scenarios um especially as you're looking in the out years and knowing hey here's the range of possibilities based on some of these things that we're talking about so um there's various scenarios here and you can see the assumptions used for those and then here's kind of the I guess this would be the
097the takeaway is you can see our current year right is to the to the far left so that's showing our roughly 9.44 million fund balance expenditure right now we're projecting uh a surplus of about 1.8 million dollar next year again that accounts for everything required by the referendum it doesn't account for putting any money into any of these competing interests right now so that's what will be when we when we pivot the budgeting these are some of the things we're going to be talking about relative to um that 1.8 million the second year of the banum we're also in very good shape by the third what I was going to see say the third year of the bium that would be a different bium by the third year of the forecast um we're we're starting
098to see us using up all of our resources so so we know um yeah I I almost hesitated to to bring uh to include the scenario one which is the worst case because I know it's it's our duty um as a cabinet and as a board to not let things get there but what I wanted to show is if we make no changes at all over the next four years that's what we'd be facing so Mr Meers point for instance as we decline in enrollment we'll have to look at our staffing so that we make sure we don't uh end up at that at that point okay so I just want to show this is what your status quo would be and then knowing we need to make changes where we'll be um and then
099finally you can see in 2030 that's the first year of non- referendum money so we had a non-recurring referendum that's good through 2028 29 that money will evaporate from The District in 2930 which will leave us with um a few options so here's my recommendations right now as we pivot into budgeting um I I would recommend that we not make any increases to expenses when when PIV budgeting that go beyond one year so you know onee adjustments to fix things kind of like you're talking about that that might be on a it be on payroll it could be on capital projects um but you know if we choose to fix theater rigging we only have to do that one time hopefully and then we can scale back the next year so those as I'm thinking
100about what i' be presenting the board later it's to the extent we even decide to spend money and not put it all in the fund balance it's going to be these these one-time expenditures um I I just want to emphasize beyond the current bium you know projections become muchly predictable so while I want to provide A Five-Year Plan um frankly I'm really focused on next year in the year after that as I mean that's where my effort will go and every year we update the fiveyear plan and to balance in 2930 we will have to do some combination of uh additional staff Cuts School consolidation there I said there could be a change in state law that's not up to us uh Andor refer to replace the expiring referendum perhaps some combination of all those
101and finally on my to-do list um and this is sort of the Holy Grail uh for school districts is developing some kind of scientific evaluation per um uh process to evaluate um our spending essentially what what is called academic return on investment so what kind of return on investment are we getting for um things that we're implementing or things we've always been doing and this is the last side this is just about that transitioning from projections to budget um will be and you can see in the circles uh all of these things in the circles will essentially or eventually get finalized and we'll just be providing board updates uh throughout that process as each of these things get final we're able to make our budget more granular and eventually present that preliminary budget uh to
102the board in the summer and then the final budget to the board in the fall please can you go back to your four five years of bar charts there yeah there so if you look at like four years from now before the the bars all go downhill where will we be we will have um be a long ways towards the elementary buildings being k6 fundamental change we will be a long ways towards much higher percentage of students in front of the teachers in those Elementary buildings being um resident students gener ating more Revenue we they won't generate more Revenue well of our of our Revenue yeah more will be from the state than from local taxpayers all right thank you for the correction but we'll we'll be in a a better place as far as
103fundamentals when we go to make decisions that and can our our teaching organization would have had four years of our Sal our our salaries benefit structure we developed in this era will will be a a very a lot of things will be set and known and well liked in theory you know um we will had the benefit of the Deferred maintenance having been done so it looks like we're just holding our own over those three years where the bars are pretty short but actually we're accomplishing quite a bit yeah well said right right um the board made really significant decisions last fall that will be able to implement that we wouldn't have be able to implement otherwise and um and and we're in in large part in good shape as we move forward with that
104yes so it almost seems like you can't look at these bars in a as a in a silo you have to look at the context and it looks like well we're just holding our own and nothing got too much significantly better but actually the organization itself changed in a profile way and will arguably be a much stronger steadier organization then so without spending more money we would have accomplished great things in that per yeah I don't want to ever say that we have right enough staff I think there will always be an argument at conversations today it depends on your perspective there will always be someone that will say there's not enough staff there will also be people who will say this is a sad conversation to have because we don't have enough time to
105determine if the staff that we have can sustain the positive trajectory that we have but without an injection of more or different revenue streams right there will eventually become a time where we will have to look at the existing Staffing and say we have to reduce it or the community will have to come to grips with the fact that maybe we need another injection uh of of Revenue this current board made the determination based on the Strategic plan specifically I think it was 4.4 of the Strategic plan that said we want to make sure I think the actual line was we want to have our teaching staff being the top 10% of the Milwaukee metropolitan area knowing that the the timeline to have a CommunityWide conversation uh around a referendum was in the the long
106term the the the the administration and board decided that the shortterm strategy would be to use the healthy fund balance I think we didn't in retrospect in terms of continuous Improvement one thing that I could have done a better job in is continuously every time we had a meeting remind the community this is where we are um and the decisions that we were making were not made in isolation but if there was a strategy um and so I think whoever's on the board moving forward will have to continue to look at the history of what the this board did and then decide what do you want to do moving forward there's no guarantee that a future board wants to make the type of commitments that the Strategic plan laid out um but there there were
107some difficult decisions that needed to be made in order for that plan to be in place I think what Mr Ecker and I are now in a position of deciding I think this is again I want to start where where we where I started in kicking this off with Mr eer about a half hour ago I'm used to a three-year plan like this I'm I'm almost concluding year four this is the first time I've had this um that I've had this type of tool let alone the board I think we can be very strategic now um and the the decisions that we will make I'm not going to say that they're going to be easy but I think they're easier and they're more transparent and clearer because we have this type of tool so thank
108you Mr and more to come have uh one question back on your scenarios slide um uh number four said um we can't use fund balance as a way to offset deficits so scenarios two and three will have to be avoided but you also said we you were hesitant to put scenario one on here so um that just seems conflicting with me I think there's another slide if Tim is driving or whoever I think what Mr wer speaking to it's another slide not this slide two slides down number four number four there I just I'm confused I think I should say one and two okay yeah typo thank you okay that is confusing we can't let the blue or red happen that's the right I think what I'll just conclude um because I know we have
109other items we committed in this past summer to being more transparent and being being more strategic uh these are the types of tools that allow not only the board but the community to monitor what we're doing um and to to watch us um and so we we we don't we we welcome people to not only monitor where we're going but also to give perspective and I'm thankful again to the entire business office team for creating these tools these should be the governing tools that now the board wrestles with and and and how you leverage it and how you um you move the valves if you will will then give us Direction on how we can then um operate and and run the school system so thank you any final board question not that will move
110us into the final item in the section overview of account structure structure and move far I know Mr Meers is excited about this agenda item I don't know about anyone else um the often often there will be community members who will say can can we have access to your budgets and then these are people who are highly skilled um in the private sector and other places and then they'll come they'll come to Mr eer and I say this doesn't make any sense this is what what is this public sector accounting is just different than other types of accounting and and so Mr eer is going to give us a an exciting dive into what public sector accounting looks like for public schools the exciting part is this is intended to be fast well we can
111fix that um the the the finance committee had said hey maybe it' be helpful to just have a primer on that that the board could go to when needed to um understand codes a little better so I I included uh a couple downloads here for you one is a Word document that just explains what each code is so that instead of you know you probably know fund 10 is the general fund but what does that mean so you can find it quickly and there's a brief explanation of what that is um object 400 is Supply is uh n Capital objects that that doesn't mean anything to most people so if you scroll and find that on the word document it's going to give us more detail about what that is so that's um item number
112one did you say the other one was the most unique PowerPoint you've received I think that's then this one the cipher right so when when I first got into school districts I had no idea what these codes meant and and frankly most of our teachers and a lot of our administrators don't either because it's not it's not that important to them um and it shouldn't be uh but I I I I try and make it easy for people to understand just what it is we're looking at because otherwise it's a series of numbers that just mean nothing to most people so essentially the code is a cipher um and each number just means something okay so this is what our typical uh looks like it's broken up into five parts and each part each number
113translates to some kind of verbage okay the the first part is our fund and I always like to think of that is I I which bank account am I spending from or which credit card am I using so kind of highest level the next is location at schools that's pretty easy it's is it Eisenhower is it Wilson is it that that's probably the easiest one for everyone understand the third piece is object I like to think of this as what are we buying right at home it would be these types of things at school districts the white the what would be it could be people it could be benefits it could be a service we're buying uh utilities that's the what the next area is called function that's the who so in school districts the
114who is social studies music department you could think of the function almost as Department okay the two things that matter most to people are usually the object what are we buying we're buying food who's buying the social studies right so those those are the two things most important that that help you understand everything and then finally there's three digits at the end these are almost never used um and the reason is because they're reserved primarily for Brands so um you're when you're looking at a report you're almost always going to see like if you see a project at all is going to be z00 Z that's the essentially the we use for non project and if there's a number in three digits it's going to be almost always a grant so Esser for instance we
115track that by its project number so every um piece of the code then means something so in this case piece one is 10 the general fund 401 right this is just a madeup school district okay I know we don't have a Washington High School um but that's the the location in this case would be Washington High School 411 the third piece tells me it's a supply 124,000 if I had my Cipher I'd look that up and I would say oh that's the math department so the math department was buying supplies at this high school and there was it's not from a grant hey may I go ahead okay may Sor all right this is exactly how you does all budgeting okay and no doubt finance committee has seen this I've seen this makes me nuts
116you get the um spend reports for the month there is Amazon all these dollars what or there's the purchasing card from a department director pays to the bank what's it for you five years ago you had to go pull the paper documentation figure out what are we buying and does that blind spot is that addressed here somehow or can it be addressed is it or can it be though so so so um woar is a requirement from the state so that the state can track every every school district expenditure kind of Benchmark themselves um and it says if you buy paper for there's certain requirements so if you buy paper from Staples that counts as a supply okay um that's the level of granularity we report to the state on um I I'll kind of
117take this back to question earlier about to what extent will the new transparency site help with open records requests if the open records request is hey Scott tell us how much I'll say West High School not Washington tell us how much West High School spent on supplies our transparency site will allow them to get that okay if they say how much did West High School spend at Amazon that's a whole different Hall of wax I don't want to know what they spend at Amazon I want to know what they spent on supplies and some of that will be from Amazon correct correct okay so will it help us there I mean I get my own you know if you have a I don't want to plug for any vend or whatever but some places if
118you use their purchasing card their debit card they'll give you like 6% off off or something now you get your in monthly invoice and there's no detail on what you bought when I used the other purchasing card it tells me exactly what the vendor was and I know from my monthly statement what it was I bought and who in the household bought it but with Amazon I just get it's all am Amazon Amazon what did I spend oh oh I I I understand the question in in so we have two answers to that in our Erp system okay we we don't just code it as Amazon on so there it says whatever they bought potit I don't know um and the account we have with Amazon we can go to Amazon and and can get
119it you can see from Amazon and I can see in my Amazon I can do the dump of my purchases and I can see exactly what it is but if I'm looking at my monthly statement for my Prime card I can't really see and that is a problem I had when I was working on the finance committee and before the finance committee when I talked to two business managers AG go can I see a payables report for the for the month and it was oh these purchasing cards somebody's using this purchasing card a lot and I asked the business manager what's this for well we don't really know from the business manager and it's like that's the kind of thing I know you don't want and I know Dr me doesn't want we need to
120know where people are spending money so if you're saying well you know you're buying all this stuff on Amazon if we went direct to like Staples and bought it directly from Staples inste through Amazon we'd save money but if you can't see what we're buying on Amazon you can't know what it is that maybe you can get a better price if you buy direct from the the manufacturer itself that's kind of what am I making sense you are I I won't speak for the well I will speak for the person that was here here before whoever that was I don't want to criticize any I know I know you're not I they were probably trying to say I don't know right now exactly what that is because I don't have the itemized list in front
121of me but yeah yeah well but that's a lot to do I mean that was a a problem 15 years ago board member say I want a report on this and superintendent would take staff offline to produce his custom report I like this clear gobut clear gobut cleargov where somebody can efficiently run a report without spinning all kind of Staff people into producing the report that's what does this help us is there a way you can leverage this to help the finance committee with that kind of thing and help you as well you're talking back to the website no I'm talking back to I'm spending X dollar at Amazon and I don't know whether how much of that Amazon stuff is supplies where if I bought direct from a school supply company like a Staples
122or someplace maybe I get a better price so yeah so the process um when when somebody places an order through Amazon It's usually the school directly they log in they say I want buy these three things then they code their own transaction to Amazon we in the business office are not quoting it we're not saying oh everything from Amazon is going to go to this account the schools know what they're purchasing and they're coding it so it's up to them to find their the best price do they want to purchase it from Amazon or do they want to purchase it from um staes any any let's not to promote anybody or Diss anybody just to say you have vendor choices yes and because each school is in charge of their budget local um school budget
123is it is in their best interest to find that best price and not just spend money at Amazon because they can it's always in somebody's best interest to be smart but yes they don't always do it which is why we manage them Mr May are you asking if the new system will allow us to see what people are buying from Amazon like yeah that's I think answer is no to that unless Mr eer pulls that data separately but that's not going to be available for my understanding on the transparency website no I I don't even necessarily wanted on the website I would like the board and the administration to be able to see more specificity in this I think the administration right now can you can pull any report and see what exactly we bought
124we can yeah we can see what purchases are going through Amazon we we we can we have all the data it if if the question is is the chart of accounts or clear gov going to make it any easier if a board member were to say where exactly what what exactly do we buy on Amazon and was there a better price at Staples the or anywhere else the answer is no that that is still going to be manual work that's the problem and if it doesn't solve this when I've written a chart of accounts for a business the standard chart of accounts usually didn't let the the owner of the business manag according to way he looked at the business it was more for the standard accounting board people and it wasn't a cost accounting
125driven chart of accounts I mean I know for myself I go on these umbrella purchasing sites and I know I'm paying more but I'm lazy that day and I don't care so I'm going to pay 20% more for this thing because I don't want to take the time to price shop around it's my decision with my money but if it happens a lot I I know I know I know you're not saying this um but I'm I'm compelled to say it because I've I've now spent 15 years in school districts and 10 years working for the private sector um at at least the private sector companies I worked for I hope our employees don't spend like the private sector um companies I worked for I have found in every District I've worked in um you
126know one it might be because why people get into education but I have found the frugality of of uh School District employees to be beyond anything I would have expected before I came to work for school districts to to the point that there's some things in some districts that I've said we can't do anymore things like sharing hotel rooms because they want to save money um things like people going to a conference and not thinking that they can take a bag with them uh because that's going to cost $10 more um that that is but that's kind of the general level of regality that I I see I'm not trying to cast exper on anybody but the reason you're here is to manage costs and if you can't see it you can't manage it so
127these these buckets always make me unhappy they make me unhappy at home with my own personal stuff and make me unhappy here and it's just the way the world works there's stuff you just just don't have the visibility to and we do the best we can and I was hoping somehow this could fix it but so it doesn't a way that we are managing it is um we have an Amazon business account so we get better pricing than me as the consumer purchasing it for my home use so we have um yeah right right I but we've tried to implement a policy of I don't want to call it it's not a formal policy a guideline of a teacher can't buy a supply for them themselves and then get reimbursed they need to go through
128our purchasing process through our Amazon account to get that better pricing rather than right okay taking the the lazy I was just it's easier to just buy it myself it's it's a wonderful thing and I was hoping it was more than it is but I always hope it's more than it was and you were warned by Dr means that I would be all crazy excited about these questions and here I was so I'm okay I'm done thanks I was just going to say that I I encountered that policy this afternoon um uh my one of my history teaches was talking about buying a book for the classroom and was talking about how that something get sent off sent off to administrators they take a look at it um they do some reviews and then they
129send back and then maybe at that point you can get reimbursed but I maybe misr the details on that so um I'm looking at 100,000 line export these there's a column that has these codes in it so what you're you're outlining here is a key for what those accounts would be doesn't it doesn't look like they they just have a description so they don't have what you have there which you could break it down by school um supplies and you could compare all the different like if you knew all of those you could write a program or a spreadsheet or something to be able to compare the math department than what they spent on paper across the different schools to look for an anomaly if that's if that if that's what you're into and what
130you want to spend your time on great um so that's that's all there I guess my my question is um do we have in addition to to the demo there do we have a a key um and that someone could actually do that translation if they wanted to and is that on on the public website I'm assuming it's not on clear go because so that's software as a service and you get we get what we what we have there right so this is kind of that give and take of what do we put on our website versus elsewhere DPI has on their website an Excel downloadable exactly what you're talking about so but what um in the in the finance section of our website if we just put a link to DPI to get like
131to right next to the track link like if you want more information about these codes here's where you go and I guess I mean I'm not I wouldn't be worried about overloading our website servers um for people downloading the this but uh it's more the me managing it or someone managing it but the idea of a link is pretty simple sure but I I I think your your unique slideshow should go on the website if I'm I have my preference it's okay I think we've gotten deep yes ask we might want change you to XX conversation who are not on the operations and finance committee would like to attend to ask some of these questions I encourage you to do so Wednesday but I'd like to move you jinxed Us by saying this would be
132a quick item you P it sorry never again you P it exitement um Mr you have been there for a long time thank you for you and your staff's work there was it I forgot about gonna say we are done with you this evening uh thank you for your work and your reports this evening I'm gonna ask that we take a five minute uh break before we move into uh policy um okay and that then we'll be back in about five minutes well standing thanks everybody who's stuck with us um we are on second readings had our action to approve policies we've got two different policies this evening to take a look at uh and then uh several first readings as well I turn over to my esteemed colleagues alte all right first one up
133policy 2510 second reading adoption of textbooks primary curricular resources and basically in here from our most recent uh committee meeting on 1216 uh it was a recommendation for basically legal keeping the suggested language as in as is to align with Federal requirements let it is recommended that the school board approve policy 210 adoption of textbooks primary curricular resources and ISO move may have a second second you Dr um board questions or discussions on this see n Mr Morris yes Dr Ho yes Mr wer yes Dr Wiley yes M hmer Rolland yes Mr Meyer yes Dr Jess anger yes and that item passes um we also have second reading on a second policy all right second policy of policy 2521 selection of instructional materials and Equipment Supply equipment supplemental to curricular resources uh similar same case
134that we have for 2521 uh Neil recommends uh keeping the suggested language as is to align with Federal requirements want here uh it is recommended that the school board approve policy 2521 selection of instructional materials and Equipment supplemental curricular resources and ISO move may have second second thank you any board questions or discussion on the see now please call the Mr Morris yes Dr Ho yes Mr wer yes Dr Bley yes Miss Hammer Rolland yes Mr Meyer yes Dr Jessa anger yes this item also passes thank you um and then we have several first ratings uh no action taken this evening but there's no substantive updates uh it'll go on the consent agenda if now it'll come back for a second right okay uh first reading policy 54 5410 motion placement and retention and so
135far our previous notes Here the policy was brought to us uh for review at our December 16th policy committee meeting and from that we basically had noted that from our consultation with Dr zimon noted that by law we must have the pro this promotion policy for students in grades for I just had a question [Music] um if uh there's discussions I was I'll just say why um did you consider having part e as the policy to have the principal as the final responsibility for determining the promotion it it sounds like it's always a group of professionals making the decision so what happens if they can't come to consensus for a students's promotion that's a good topic to bring back to policy committee I think yeah you're jump I think I think I've seen some policies
136where there's a final operater of some sort where so we we can let us talk as a team and we can bring him back is it the case that whatever the decision is somebody needs to sign one person is that what could that be what this is that the the principle you know I'm hearing from mmer understand yeah y that the current way that the policy language is reading is that it relies and Depends silently on consensus and at some point the polic may need to have a final aler of some sort so I think that's a really interesting perspective to put on the table yeah I I only say this you know as the role of board clerk for example you signed things you aren't the one who's doing the deciding on the calculations
137and the such but somebody's got to sign it yeah okay but maybe that's not the case I don't we'll bring it minut moving on to First gring of policy 5420 reporting student progress I was just going to say though back to that one is that um could this be the difference te means between a policy and administrative guideline should the policy have a determinant but yes that would just be my question in reading that second list or more about administrative guidelines and we might have that in administrative guidelines and El but it's worth the discussion it's worth the discussion because when you're having the conversation about promotion the the more clarity you can create in the policy for better it might be I agree morning like it thank you all right 5420 reporting student progress
138uh our prior committee me it's a current policy it's just updated for current standards uh moving forward to First reading of policy 5421 grading another here that's current policy updated for current standards usually when we say current standards that means the wording mostly these what you see in green it's just using a new current wording moving on to policy 5451 student recognition said there for the current wording current policy updated for the current standards through our current wording 54 51.1 Wisconsin academic Excellence scholarship I you have a question about this one go ahead um are these specific um requirements to qualify are these set out by the state of Wisconsin or these are okay I can see Dr Marvel not yes well that's unfortunate because I don't like them so for for our most recent
139meeting there the notes for their senior sta refers to a student who in who has been in attendance for two semesters in junior year and the first semester in the senior year we talked about this a little bit I think you wer weren't the only one can work on advocacy on we had quite a discussion on the seventh semester further we'll move on to 54 51.0 two technical Excellence higher education scholarships same here for the most recent uh committee meeting on 1216 current policy updated for current standards in our wording moving on to policy 5463 credits from non-public schools so for the most recent meeting uh our current policy was updated for current standards and students transferring in from non-public schools will not count toward uh their our district GPA and then see 113 you
140go there I have a question about that why aren't those grades um considered as their GPR class ranking um the discussion we had at policy committee was that um for some of non-public schools rating can look a lot different um the standards that there are um assessed against they don't necessarily need to follow the the standards that are settled by the state is this what's typical in Wisconsin schools or public schools right moving on to policy 5505 acemic integrity and then most recent here uh this is one where the policy this policy replaces the recently resented policy final one first reading of policy 6236 Community Services fund fund 80 oh we added language to see the policy 2450 for community and adult education something that was asked previously like several months ago to the thank
141you all very much um sounds like most of these will come back um we now are at the point of adjourning into second CL session Dr it is recommended that the school board adjourn into executive Clos session pursuant to Wisconsin statute 19.85% to Wisconsin statute 1985 BR one BR e the deliberating or negotiating the purchasing of public properties the investing of public funds or conducting other specifi public business whenever competitive or bargaining reasons require a closed session specifically to deliberate regarding the terms of a charter school agreement between the Board of Education and W the stem Incorporated and ISO move M second [Music] second Mr Morris yes Dr Ho yes Mr wer yes Dr Bley yes Miss hmer Rolland yes Mr Meyer yes Dr Jess Banger yes thank you all for those of you who
142will be departing have a wonderful evening and get home safe and we will move safe session