CorpusRecord 263817

Feb 18, 2025 BOE Meeting (End Included)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Randolph County Schools WV
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Randolph County, WV
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,625 words · about 104 min
Collected
2026-07-02

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e the time is now 5 o'clock and I'm going to call this regular board meeting to order we have Miss Betty mcfaden and master Arthur mcfaden that are going to lead us in the plge FL the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation we are going to go a little bit out of order and we're going to um move to um section four informational reports and recognitions and then start with um a Randolph County math uh school math Field Day winners and then uh we'll come back and hit and hit B but we'll go ahead and recognize those winners first um I'm the Middle grades coordinator so I have the six through seventh grade winners so first uh first place for sixth grade is carver weaton

002fromin stand right there uh Second Place sixth grade is Jane mcfaden H Middle School third place sixth grade Eli Curr I believe who's at basketball commit first place for seventh grade Flora Perkins opens Middle School second place 7th grade Clara piles third place seventh grade Nora Lee first place eighth grade Zachary heims El mdle scho second place eighth grade Cadence St El and third place for eighth grade is roxan tuning these guys will be traveling to morgant town to University High School on March 1st to compete in the regional competition good be on County all right I'm going to introduce the fourth and fifth grade math Field Days winners um so for fourth grade we have an alternate golden Humphrey another fourth grade alternate Julian Kelly Zito right over there to the lady M sorry

003third word third word uh hold is from Midland yeah Mason barrows was third place for fourth grade from Third Ward Arthur mcfaden was second place for fourth grade Jennings Jennings Elementary and in first Place avelyn corals J those are our fourth grade so I'm going to move on to fifth grade um you guys can just do you want him to stay up here and get yeah and then we'll get a picture off so just stay and then for fifth grade we have an alternate Brantley Hughes from Third Ward another alternate silus Osborne Third Ward third Ward's taking sleep lots of others Julian Tenny is third place for fifth trade third word you're welcome second place is Colton mullinex Jennings thank you and in first place for fifth grade it is Adeline rhs schol third board

004and once again they will be competing um at the regional math Field Day in Morgantown on March 1st so go get them guys okay now you good good luck to all you students Bean County if anyone needs to leave they're more than welcome to now and you're also more than welcome to stay for the meeting as well but I'll give you guys a second at this time I'll take a um a motion to get school calendar hearing number two on um on the table so moved by Jamie second second okay by Sher okay so we do not have very many updates or comments from the last time I presented to um the board and and basically the comments that we received which were few were were all in the same um preference to draft one

005due to the ending before Christmas break and the comments related to calendar 2 were in preference to the Wednesday start so as those are are two different start dates and end dates for different things um additionally there there was a couple requests about our professional learning days and where we place those in the calendar and whether or not we can combine some faculty Senate dates with those same days so that there's less dis disruptions for students so we did have one in there um on both calendars that was a p day and a faculty Senate day on the same so we will look at addressing possibly another one the trick about faculty Senate days is you have to have one at the beginning of the year and the end of the year and then you

006they also have to occur in October December February and April so when we look at our professional learning days and and the reasons for those are different um it it may not always align to where we could do that every time but we are going to take that into consideration within the committee and Dr Dilly then will be prepared to bring I believe a calendar to the board on March the 4th if there is anybody in the public that would like to comment on the 2526 proposed calendar they may do so now and if not I do not have additional comments said you didn't get very many it's tied 13 to13 you couldn't that okay 2026 do you have the spring break as a guarantee yes ma'am in both calendars that was my only concern

007so at this point we do not vote on that or I mean we will vote on it at the next meeting all right so that moves us to delegations and public comments um so we're just going to go in order in which everybody has signed up here a delegation or an individual may make comments to the board however the board cannot deliberate or take any action on the on any item that is not on the meeting agenda except in emergency situations the board may may only ask clarifying questions of the individual or delegation we also cannot mention student names and even staff names I'm pretty sure Dr Deli are we allowed to mention staff like like specific staff name Nam you just want to be you just want to be cautious when you're mentioning names

008especially around derogatory or um potentially un factual matters but they can mention a staff name they okay and if they are mentioning a staff name in regards to riff and transfer season we're supposed to be unbiased and not hear that information yet so they need to talk in Broad strokes and not about a specific individual you can talk about a program concerns that related but not an exact person because we are supposed to remain unbiased if that person chooses to have a hearing okay I know it seems kind of silly but well and ultimately the appropriate place for them to speak specifically would be at the actual hearing for that individual if they would receive a rift or transfer notice so and I want to um you know protect that employee so if they do

009ask for a hearing that um that we are unbiased so if I stop anybody it's not out of rudess is to protect that um protect that employee too okay and you've got five minutes minutes but you don't need to do all five minutes we'll start with Miner Taylor think that we should keep all the social studies programs at ens middle school because there are teachers there that help students grow and become better people in society and I'm not going to give up on a teacher that's not give up on me thank you sir Miss Chelle Syler good evening I'm here tonight as a teacher of English and language arts at oakin middle school I stand before you tonight in response to the proposed elimination of teams at the middle school and the loss of six

010core teachers as we know Middle School is a crucial time in our children's academic and Social Development these proposed changes would undermine our ability to effectively support our students and significantly harm their educational experience therefore I respectfully urge the board to reject these proposals when they are made I'd like to start with the team concept which is deeply personal to me I attended oakin junior high school before the Implement implementation of teams and I can tell you that I had little to no connection to any of my teachers even when I was bullied I never felt comfortable approaching them with any of my concerns our students today do not face that same challenge each student one our team knows that us as individuals and they know that we genuinely are invested in their success over

011my 16 years of teaching I've built lasting and strong relationships with my students relationships that have continued long after they have left my classroom for instance I still hear from a former student who is going to graduate school in New Hampshire she asked me to look over papers for advice Etc I have former high school students that I still support I go over things with them I talk to them I have one of them with me tonight these relationships enhance our students School experiences and contribute to their ongoing success because they know they have real cheerleaders behind them my now I'm going to turn to the loss of six core teachers because I think this is very important too we're going to lose six teachers three social studies and three science I want to emphasize

012the long-term consequences consequences of this decision the impact will be far-reaching not only will it weaken the education our students receive in these essential sub subjects but also affect math and English instruction science and social studies play a pivotal role in developing well-rounded informed students these subjects teach students to think critically analyze information and inform educated opinions they explore the natural world engage with scientific Concepts and gain an understanding of history geography civics and economics middle school science and social studies serve as a crucial bridge between Elementary and high school education preparing our students to meet the demands of that High School curricula in which both subjects are required for graduation moreover these disciplines demand active engagements with text and vocabulary they require our students to think critically and solve problems our science and social

013studies teachers constantly ask students to write and often and hold them to expectations that align with us English teachers in science students apply math concepts en Hands-On real world scenarios in social studies they utilize graphic organizers interactive notebooks and summarization techniques to deepen their understanding each of our core teachers offers students opportunities to explore create and engage with vital Concepts across the curriculum in closing I ask you to consider the profound impact these proposed changes will'll have on our students the team approach Foster strong relationships and the subjects of science and social studies are indep indispensable to a well-rounded education so I urge you to reject these proposals when they are brought to you and ensure that we continue to provide the best possible education for all of our students thank you next got Miss

014Penelope Shelton I um I came here today to express how I believe it's not an intelligent position to cut so many positions and how it will affect the student bodies of Elkin high school and Elkin Middle School at the middle school there's an average of about 500 students around 800 at the high school a certain vital positions would be cut that would vastly increase the student to teer ratio per classroom according to West Virginia code section 5-1a under chapter 18 education the maximum number of students per teacher for grades four 56 enough is that there's to be no more than 25 students per teacher or instructor if I speaking on National terms the student to teacher ratio for grade six and up is supposed to be 16 students per each instructor now please explain to

015me how we students are supposed to get a proper education if there are 30 or more of us in a classroom CU you cut vital positions how that is my question to you how do you expect the student body to get a proper education with less help and less teachers I understand that some people have no aspirations to go to college or move out of the state but what about those who do I know many of my friends and others plan to go to college or to move out of the state I myself plan to go to college for mechanical engineering so how do you expect me to be properly prepared for college if you cut vital math or science classes that would help my career path this also goes for other vital classes that

016the student body needs and wants when there are more students in a class with only one instructor we students get less IND individualized learning time this also means less or no time times for labs projects presentations and more leaving us with a worksheet I myself find it really hard to focus on find worksheets really hard to focus on and I normally don't retain any of the given information on this worksheet if we are given larger amounts of worksheets or packets due to larger class sizes or shorter class times you are going to see a fast grade downfall this also means test scores will go down attendance and so on this will affect our County even more sometimes in a 42-minute class period we don't even get halfway done with the assignment due to lack of

017time this would be the exactly same issue for the high if the high school had switched the periods now here's my final question to you Dr Deli how how do you plan to fix this problem students and parents and teachers are all getting involved and we all have a cause that we are fighting for and you don't seem to care so tell me how how will you in the board fix this how will you in the board ensure a stable and fulfilling education for our students thank you for your time thank you p Isabelle redwick is next yes Isabelle hello my name is Isabel lwi I am a freshman at Elin High School I also attended midd Elin middle school and Third Elementary I would like to talk to you about you today about the

018proposed pets at our school when the majority of you voted to keep har pick and open you told all students in Randolph County that our education isn't actually priority you knew with that vote you would have to cut teachers as well as programs throughout the county first let's talk about our teachers when you teachers you make class sizes that are not conducive to our learning in a class that has 30 plus students the teachers aren't given are going to be able to give the students extra help if they need it that is unfair to the students that need that little bit to succeed test scores are going to go down second you want to cut classes such as choir technology PE and business are those classes essential no but to many students they might be

019third third I do not feel like switching from block schedule to periods is going to be beneficial to any students 45 minutes per class isn't enough time for the teachers to teach our a lesson do any work and for the teacher to explain things to students who may need that little more time we will then have homework for a classes and our extra PR gies you need to find a different way to find the money to keep teachers in PR rooms thank you thank you Isabelle Michelle hello my name is Michelle edwig I am a current parent of a sixth grader at elins middle school and a ninth grader at alin's high I also have two children that have graduated from rol County Schools um I would like to talk to you today about the

020proposed cuts to teachers to make off the Rand County School deficit cutting all these teachers is going to make class sizes so big that some students are going to fall through the cracks especially at the middle school level the sixth graders are coming from their elementary school and having to learn a whole new way of doing things and expectations then they're going to be thrown in a class with 30 students test scores are going to go down it won't matter how many calls we get to make sure that our students get plenty of breast and need a good breakfast because those scores are not they're not going to be there at the high school level you will not only see test scores plummet your Dropout rates will increase it's proven that students do better when

021they are in a classroom with fewer students I truly believe you need to look at Board office for cuts before you go after the teachers that are actually in the classroom with our students with some research it has been discovered that most um board employees receive supplemental pay we chose eight employees to look at the lowest supplemental pay was $4,950 the largest was $ 32740 in total of these eight employees they are making 97,000 771 in supplemental pay that is only eight out of many a few meetings ago Dr Dilly stated that they couldn't take supplemental pay without decreasing that employees workload with a little bit of research it was found that supplemental pay can be taken away for two reasons a fail Levy which does not apply here an economic shift that would keep

022a County from being able to pay those supplements that Source was from the West Virginia legislative archive reporting from February 14th 25 the 1:00 session with 5 minutes and 40 seconds left in the recording Randol county is in an economical shift are we not the only department at the board that is on The Chopping Block are four positions in the curriculum Department that are federally funded that doesn't make any sense to me Dr Dilly has said time and time again that he is a Visionary and I truly believe he is I think he's trying to do wonderful things for our County with all the changes taking place if you don't want to take the supplemental pay Why not start at the top riff everyone at the board office repost their jobs for what they should

023be making if they value the work they do and the edge and locational system that they work for they will reapply please don't take our teachers thank you thank you good evening my name is Dave Arman trout and I teach business and special education at Harmon school at a previous board meeting members were asked why did you not close Harmon School four of the five board members have already answered that question by determining that unpredictable road conditions and long bus rides are neither safe nor justifiable options for the Harmon students instead of continually dwelling from Transportation issues attention needs to be refocused to more important aspects of Randolph County's lingering educational issues and how they are going to be addressed for all the schools what are the strategies for addressing these issues at Harmon school

024we in our surrounding communities are taking the Forefront on improving upon and investing in our school's future we have met with State officials written letters to West Virginia state delegates and leaders sought grants held community meetings to develop plans and initiatives to face future obstacles and had individuals speak at the recent State Board of Education meeting Harman school was taking the initiative of fundraising for programs and individuals and businesses outside our community have joined in our efforts plans are being developed to start track baseball archery and soccer and we are looking at developing a new outdoor Athletic Complex Mr Daniels you'll be glad to hear that we have plans of being able to move forward with the greenhouse project as a site has officially been approved Mo most importantly the test scores of our Harmon

025students have increased based upon our recent Benchmark results and the CSI team have met with us to collaborate efforts in developing strategies to continue to improve assessments and I will give you each of you a copy along with Mr Dilly and Mrs Smith and folder when I'm finished containing I ready testing information and key points of the interpretation of results I'm not the best to do that uh one of the teachers that was coming with me tonight had an emergency and she couldn't come as you can see Harmon school is definitely moving forward and you all have asked us to do that one thing that is lacking in this countywide educational dilemma is that remote schools need to be looked at differently from other simply because of their location this applies to all remote schools

026throughout the state more rural schools are projected to be closed than ever before and we have asked that this issue be reviewed and addressed at the state level there has to be a change and recommending closure of our outlying schools is certainly not a quick fix answer to increasing yearly Financial issues unfortunately this plan of action in trying to close our remote quality schools has cre created an unnecessary division between teachers families students and communities We Stand United and devoted in our efforts to keep Harmon school open and dedicated to the education of all students in Rolph County I commend everyone that has had the courage to come to this Podium I've been here three times and face certain scrutiny and criticism to speak for what we feel is right from our perspective and individual

027situations members of the board thank you for listening to our concerns all of our concerns and providing to us that our individ and proving to us that our individual voices are indeed being heard we have got to come back together as a county and focus on addressing the most important issue and that's providing a quality education to all Randolph County students let us move forward Harmon School our communities and our supporters are to voted to making that happen thank you for listening and on a personal note to those of you that are on the Riff and transfer list I have been there I know what it's like I have been on the Riff and transfer in Randolph County twice and I have been on the Riff and transfer list in Grant County and it is

028not easy so I personally can sympathize with each and every one of you that have been on that list and hopefully our County can make a correction and move forward this with with this issue this is a folder that has the testing score information and some key points that we put together leave yours at your desk Smith okay up next we have uh Mr Andrew Carroll so I'll speak on a few items that I think are related to item 7D in terms of the budget discussion um so first I just want to draw attention to a couple legislative updates that I think might be pertinent for all of us as a legislative session is fired up um and one of them I'll go into a little bit more detail on so first is House Bill

0292480 it's about school board consolidations to consolidate from 55 school districts to 11 I've got some comments on that later um and then second for board members I think you should be aware of House Bill 2171 which is moving your board election from the primary election to the general election which I think we can recognize is going to create a really toxic environment when you take the local and you try to mix it with the national divisive conversations and I hope everyone recognizes the real benefit we have that we have nonpartisan School boards that are oftentimes elected outside of the larger National conversation so I think we should all really care about that because we want local issues to be local issues and not to be uh poisoned and tainted by horrific National conversations um

030so second Point here is I want to offer a couple argumentative tax I think in terms of um strategies that as board members we can take when we look towards the legislative session and towards trying to produce a balanced budget and then ask community members things I think we can advocate for and I think some of us have already kind of I've sensed these these things are are existing already so I'm just trying to call attention some things I've thought so I've seen already happening so one is I think I get a real sense that um some of you all are getting real sensitive to unfunded mandates right so for example right to require counties to have a treasure but not really allocate for that and the funny formula seems a little strange and I

031think there are like many many unfunded mandates so I would encourage um that line of argumentation on what is the state requiring us to do but not supporting us in that action to continue to go to kind of bark up that tree um second a couple thought shifts and I've spent a lot of time trying to think about school funding formula and researching and and for those of you that don't know this has been a a long-standing passion of mine since I was in high school I when I went to Governor's Honors Academy and Governor School for the Arts I interacted with some students from morfield high school who wanted to take art class class uh but they were they they their only option for electives were agriculture classes because they couldn't provide that and

032there I was not interested in art but I was able to have theater and photography and painting and and so many other options and I thought well this is really weird but like we're from West Virginia you're only you're only you know an hour and a half away from me this this just doesn't seem fair um so a couple thoughts on funding formulas so one is Shifting we really have to think about I think a per people allocation doesn't work it doesn't work at the scale we have right um and it's causing us to like compound other harms right so when you do a per people allocation and that per people allocation is going to maintain a building for 1,200 students and suddenly you're at you know 600 um you're deferring maintenance and when we

033defer maintenance over and over again those kinds of things um we just we just have long-term harms that we don't stack up so shifting from like a perp allocation to looking at sort of like what is the Baseline education um so I think every student in West Virginia should EAS this this shouldn't be an argument really like it should be given that every Elementary School student you know should have art and music and Library uh and every high school student should have access to band and choir and World languages right there it should be very easy for us to see that that's the case uh that's what we should have but it's not um so then the question becomes is we have finite resources they're always trade-offs um if I've learned anything in in my

034past year of study is that there are trade-offs and there are lots of difficult decisions and the question is is where do you make those difficult decisions and also like if you really sit and stare at something long enough I think you can you can find some interesting things so um in particular and this is where I think is is the most pertinent place to press and I think um and I'm I'm drawing up some plans and working with some folks to try to to do this in a more articulated way but I'll I'll give you guys kind of the back of the little math on this um so I think we're in a really interesting position um to advocate for a pilot Regional School District um so and I and I was shocked when

035I started to kind of poke at this but um you know I didn't recognize rol county is essentially has the highest student enrollment of the counties around us you know Pocas county has about 890 students pin county has about 850 Webster has just over a th Tucker has 900 just over 900 Barbara County has just under 2,000 and upshire has a little over 3,000 um so what I think is and again follow me on this I think we could be in a really interesting position if we move to like an 8C count uh I think that's it yeah a larger like a multi multicounty School District about 12,000 students and then consolidate to you know essentially have one superintendent maybe a couple assistants and then you can move to directors of attendance Child Nutrition Communications

036facilities and maintenance Federal programs Finance information and Technology HR transportation and teaching and learning um and have less administrative directors probably a more efficient system better purchasing power um and I would ballpark kind of back of the envelope math if you Consolidated administrative function right without touching school function you could probably and then you know without factoring and what happens when County boards stop maintaining board offices uh and move to kind of one centralized location which maybe could be an existing building you could probably find I bet across those eight districts uh again just on administrative cost I would say you know probably 800 to like 1.2 Mill million do on savings and you'd move from I think between those counties right now I would say they're probably about 35 County Office directors you could

037move that those 35 positions into probably you know 10 to 12 and so it could be a really interesting interesting shift and I think when we work together as a region and I and I've thought for a long time that a regional approach is a greater benefit to all of us so I think this is the kind of wild outside the box thinking that's going to help us but it's also going to help our neighbors too um because then you can take the the function right now right you know Tucker county has a superintendent who's who's overseeing just under a thousand students um while here we've got one superintendent for 3,500 students like we've got to start to think about these things and so I'm optimistic and when I kind of when I stared at

038the spreadsheet long enough and realized that there was something interesting here I think we can we can do more for our students and you can take those administrative costs and apply them to you know Librarians music art you know the essentials right the essentials that every Elementary student needs the essentials you know high school students need right high school students need great contact with World Lang languages right um English maybe the lingu Franca but you know if we are not speaking something else we're probably missing out on on a lot of the world um so those are the things I would encourage you guys to look for uh and pay attention to right pay attention to what's going on in the legislative session there's some other concerning bills right I do a lot of political

039advocacy I'm concerned about uh there's some bills that they're like uh advocate for school staff not engaging in Poli activity on behalf of their school administration which I'm wondering if I'm like you know if the legislature goes with that am I doing something wrong at this point too but um again I would encourage you all to continue to be transparent and clear decision makers to ask lots of good questions and recognize that even on things that um you may understand as a board member you know that like teaching staff might understand that it's really critical and important to ask questions and and kind of describe those decisions and I think this discussion the discussion I think two weeks ago was really quite nice and I think they're only going to continue to improve and I

040think again we could be in a position to lead the rest of the state and doing something different because um like Dr Dilly said the other week like doing the same thing over and over and over again is not going to not going to improve and I think the the last comment I'll leave with that's really important to think about I think we all need to think about this is that it's one thing to think about improving teaching pedagogy it's one thing to think about all the things you can make change in a classroom to improve student outcomes um but if this our students whether it's in Randol County or Pocahontas County or Tucker County or Webster or Pendleton um if they don't have the same starting ingredients right if they don't have foundational art

041and music and Librarians and like Rich environments in their school to go to um forget trying to improve pedagogy right like it's just it's just not the same so we have to think about what can we do to make sure that our students have that right so if we have a school in this County that doesn't have art that doesn't have music that doesn't have choir that doesn't have the same opportunities for all the students or we have unequal opportunity across our system or unequal opportunity compared to those school systems where students are really thriving we have to figure out what do we do to to anti up or figure out how to consolidate resources in more meaningful way so I'm optimistic that there could be some good change but we all also really need

042to be very cognizant and aware of the world around is because again there there are other proposals in there to add other property tax exemptions uh to expand tax credits uh if people aren't taking a Hope Scholarship to give tax credits to them uh for homeschooling or sending their kids to private school um so we have to realize that public education matters and we have to make sure that we are doing our best to fight for those resources to it and I think that's on all of us thanks guys thank Mr hey Andrew Mr Carol check out Senate Bill 516 yes Che it out hey Mr Carol might all right that concludes um public uh comments and delegation so I will take a motion to get section four informational reports and recognitions on the on

043the table we already did section A so it would just be section B uh Janie and then Phil you good for seconding okay um so move on to uh the attendance updates good evening I'm Melle Chan the attendance director for R County schools and Kim Bonnet our school based probation officer is is joining me and we wanted to present sort of a midyear recap so you can know how we work together and our the of the county so the state had assigned counties the role of making a countywide logo and we had done that and they wanted it more fine tuned so that's why you see that you know attendance matters and we have each school day counts everyone and that is where we first started believe operator so we went for the for five

044and there were two reasons why the committee had decided to do that we wanted the younger kids to focus on 5 days a week uh which is kind of ironic with this weather you know we don't get five days a week uh so you know you want to be here every day that you can but the main reason for the stri for five is because you want to miss 5% or less states of school that gives you 95% attendance so that was the reason for the strive for five this will work first sent home at the beginning of the year uh the image on the right and it's a guide that parents can use to track attendance put the dates that students are absent and let them know when it starts getting to be a

045concern uh 18 days absent whether no matter what the reason is is considered chronic absence and that is what the state judges us on so the goal is to focus on what we can control we can't control Co or flu or bronchitis but you know the absences going to a a place or a certain appointment that you could avoid those are the things we need to focus on because the state doesn't care if it's an excused absence or an unexcused absence they want the students to be in school and the reason for that is when students aren't in school then they're not getting the curriculum the information that they need so the next step that the state implemented and that we have implemented this year are called SOS plans a system of support plans I

046it correlates with what K gum does of putting students on teers to help them improve their dependence so every school has developed and have started implementing those SOS plans there's a tier approach tier one is what you're doing schoolwide um talking about attendance the bullettin boards the rewards then there's tier two when you're looking at students who are more at risk you know what can you do to help them do they need some supports at home do they need some classroom supports and then that tier three is the more targeted group of students that maybe they need some help with some outside agencies uh and something to help them and their bands and a big part of this SOS plan is to have meaningful contact with families so what schools are doing is they are

047calling and contacting the families after three unexcused absences to see you know what's going on how can we help you so the regular attendance is 95% being here that's nine or fewer absences chronic absence is the label that you get once you hit 18 days or more no matter what the reason so this year reports like you see here have started going home um and it's an a student attendance report and green is good you want to see the green and it lets families know how their child is doing as far as their absences in that fronted yellow sort of like the traffic light because of the students are at risk and then the next one is red and that lets you know that it is a concern that um academics may not be achieve

048because of attendance issues I'm sorry are these the actual numbers for these particular schools these are student reports student reports I'm sorry okay so each student can get a report so I put a handout up at your seats and this data comes from Friday the 14th if you look at the Randol County Schools yearly data we're at 94.12% that has Us in the yellow uh that's a little bit better than we were last year and then our chronically absent for the county is 14.45% again that has Us in the hello another thing that the zoom West Virginia data does is it will let you look at your attendance for the last 30 days and we've had a really crazy last 30 days U but you can see that data on your handout also on which

049I think it's on your page too I broke it up by school so you can see their percent of attendance and their chronic absence we read yellow and green secondary is more of a challenge um the next sheet that I put in your hand out and is not on the PowerPoint uh is I wanted to break up some of the data so you can see by grade level The Chronic absences if you look kindergarten first grade fifth 6th 7th 8th 9th 10th 11th and 12th are all above 50% chronic absence or needs attention so that's pretty high the middle part of that sheet shows that we have 16% of our students in the county who are chronically absent 30 I think it's an 8% needs attention so that LE just 47% of our students who

050do not have attendance concerns so getting our students to school is obviously an issue that the schools need to address and with this SOS plan they are uh the very bottom graph show you that we are improving from last year so that's good because we had improved last year from before um and that's what the state looks at they want to see that we're making the growth every year and so we are that's a good thing I guess not good enough but we're getting better so all right Dr D so now I'm going to let Kim let you know what she does because I'm telling you without her in her program I don't know what we would do it's a valuable asset to Randolph County uh especially like I feel like with my role with

051doing home school and Homebound and technolog G and weas that there's no way that I could do in depth what she does so I'm going to let her talk about her program bye are you well so I'm a Terri public speaker and I'm losing my voice so bear with me and if you can't hear me let me know um so prior to this year I sent out all the notices three day 5 day 10 day um and so a lot of times parents would receive a call or a letter from me and that was their very first contact with the school system and that was a problem the state noticed it we noticed it um and so with these SOS plans the school is the very first Contact parents want their teacher their principal someone

052from the school level that they know and they trust to call and say hey why is your child missing so that's been a huge improvement over previous years um I do still send out the five and 10 day letters I do all the initial meetings all the calls and when there's no follow through I do the home visits um there is a very select group of kids that I work with um on my toury diversion program in an attempt to keep them out of the court system we have lots of reasons why kids are absent some home situation some mental health and so we refer out Services we provide support sometimes it's on their alarm clock so I I make that call in the morning hey are you up are your feet on the floor

053and just that is enough to kind of get them in the right direction we make sure they have tuner Services they're getting what they need homes for his food um so it's different with every kid and and if they do go in through the court system you attend Court as well then actually um does if we do have to take one of the try diversion kids to court it is a team effort it is not a sneak attack it is something that parents are very aware is going to happen we've done X Y and Z we've put all these services in place and this is not working for us so this is what happens next and it becomes you know a team meeting with the parents and the children and everyone kind of knows that

054that's the next step it's it's not a surprise or an attack I know takes on how we do that we do not um so yeah something any questions out of the 16% what do you think the major reason is that those kids don't attend school why are they absent the main reason just one um really I think there's two um some of our children are behind and instead of saying I'm behind and I don't understand we just don't come it's easier to not show up and just say I can't do something especially our middle schoolers also mental health um mental health has become a huge issue for our teenage population in the last two or three years significantly worse we have kids on weight list for six or seven months and luckily I have some

055connections and can kind of bump my kids but I can't bump everybody I can't get everyone in to see accounts the next guy who needs it and so those are things that we're facing as a community not just as a school system thank you thank you and that takes us to section five consent calendar would anybody like to get that on the table Sher is second by Jamie all right um Dr Dilly did you receive any um concerns or questions regarding just uh just request for clarification around the funding mechanisms for the 18 uh D desktops and the 50 new line interactive boards and that is our schools for tools money that is the restricted funds specifically um required for spending to purchase those particular devices for supporting technology in their classrooms and that money

056if not used just we lose it and would not have any effect on um Personnel we're not we cannot use it for person right so we're not buying computers and not Staffing is that a grant that we apply for every year or is it just a program that we are a part of it is uh the Tools for Schools we get allocated per student every year and it has very specific things basically just equipment that we can use to purchase that we can't uh use software or anything it's very focused so we have focused on trying to make sure that our classrooms have the technology that we need and so that's what's on the agenda tonight is it federally funded is it Federal program I believe it's a state yeah and what's on the agenda

057tonight the new line boards our prometheum boards that teachers are using are very old uh so the schools are getting those updated with a new type of board that's more user friendly and easier for the teacher to use and then the desktops have a lot more power because it's been many years since those have been replaced we sort of keep a cycle of replacing equipment and they're on their last legs are they going to every school every school is getting some amount uh every school is getting the desktops and then the school submitted what they needed for the to replace the prometheum board so some schools might get five some schools might get 10 uh with this we're able to purchase 50 we we actually need more than 50 but I'm hoping we can use

058some of next year's Tools for Schools to get what we couldn't get this year at the state level I haven't seen that on The Chopping Block anywhere with stuff I've been reading so hopefully I haven't either um you know hopefully that yeah yeah well speech and debate uh trip looks um pretty exciting and um everything looked like it was in line anybody questions with um E I know that um there's a lot of concern um if you want to talk about um change in the school calendar snow days and where we're going from here so ultimately we have to make up we're required to make up days after we exceed our five uh snow days and we're at that point so for this evening for consideration is the uh inclusion of uh changing those dates

059over uh to take away the spring break excluding The Good Friday and then one day to the end of the school year but again this does not include the recent snow day so there would be one more additional day that we'd have to go back to uh to the other end of the year is there any way that it is some of the early outs or anything like that to take the to take those away yeah we've already explored all of that I know there's been some suggestions about PL days and different things but but those are instructional days so there they count in our 180 days so this is about the only options we have the only if you wanted to give spring break you'd have to add all these days to the end

060of the calendar well the challenge traditionally what I've seen in all the districts of anytime you go get excessive you get less and less attendance and you get attendance issues and a a lack of people showing up after only about the second week of June you really get people not showing up I think we're have the same problem taking away spring break yeah are there any limits on the two-hour delays do the two-hour delays yeah they don't affect they don't affect anything minutes at some point in time there were minutes that had to be yeah there's yeah the acude instructional time is what you're thinking about yeah and there's some layers that but it doesn't it gives us what they do what those additional minutes do allow us to have those five snow days and

061five uh non-traditional instructional days so that's what's given us basically 10 days that we don't have to make up but having as many 2hour delays or or three-hour delays or whatever we you know the delays don't add they don't really play into that part and what is our what was our end of the school year what was our day uh right now this is the 30th in May but it would be it would also have to add one more day because of uh and then it doesn't look like there may be another day this week potentially on the weather and maybe some next week so that's why I'm a little weary to to say because we do something exactly that's why I went ahead and put it on this evening because I think we need

062to get clarification for folks to make decisions I don't like it uh I think no matter what we're going to have attendance issues because people have trips planned and I know that we put in there that um you know this is the first time in a long time that we I don't know if I remember my time was taking was I remember at some point my kids were but I was I have Denise how did you assure in the calendar I didn't over that the next year we used of calendar days and those are guaranteed days like that's what we did for Good Friday this year and as Rachel just indicated in my time here we have not had to do this and take spring break away but because this happened this year we looked

063at you know utilizing those days differently what it does is every day that you put an OD day it just puts your calendar a day longer because those are guaranteed days so we've played with this many ways um it it's just you have have to make those days up somewhere so if if if we put 0 days for spring break next year it adjusted that time that's why if you see on those calendars were going a little bit longer at the end of the year not a lot but a little bit Yeah because according to these calendar for next year it looks like the drafts are are going into well it's have OS days June 11th and June 9th so basically snow days would be put onto that and be going into to that cuz

064as of right now technically I guess it looks like the first part of June is the last day for students yes for the draft days yes all those in favor of section five consent calendar pleas signify by saying I I any opposed and that passes and then can we um start informationally blasting all the new information dates still here don't be calling parents this speak um up next is six U minutes agreements and contracts um can I get a motion to get that on the by Genie a second second um by Sher um this looks pretty straightforward just like our lovely minutes do such a good job on you ready for a vote all right all those in favor section six minutes agreements and contracts please signify by saying I I and that passes and

065then uh 5 Z and then uh up next is financial um section seven can I get a motion to get that on the table Phil okay so Jamie and then Phil second okay Financial uh Dr Dilly did you have any I just if you would go ahead and vote through a through C and then we can do the discussion at D we we've done the last couple meetings Okay um does anybody have any questions about a through C most stre forward Brad did you get any questions or concerns right all those in favor of a through C please signify by saying I I and that passes 5 Z and then that leaves us to um D the discussion discussion regarding balancing 25 26 budget all right as you recall from the last meeting we've been

066kind of bringing different segments of our budget uh this evening we have special education here going to be presenting this evening I believe they have majority of their team here this evening uh because I think it's increasingly important that this board understand the the uh impact of special education just because we have I believe nearly 24% of our kids identified receiving services and the challenges with those uh is obviously funding that surrounds and supports those mechanisms that support our kids with the various needs and so I will turn it over to the experts and let them talk about it and then chime in may be Aion so good evening for those of you who don't know me I'm April synic I'm the director of special education for Rand County Schools um we have a team

067of folks with us here this evening and I will probably speak in special education jargon I'm going to apologize in advance I will try not to do that so what I want to focus on mainly this evening um we'll look at the number of students that we're serving and why we have to serve those students um the the laws that we work under and then the funding that is available for escal students so I'll talk a little bit about eligibility so there are 15 eligibility criteria um for special education established under policy 2419 there are only 13 in ibea so the discrepancy of the two exceptionalities gifted and exceptional gifted are included in 2419 so that's a West Virginia initiative they're not considered disabilities under Ida so they fall under 2419 for us so if

068a student is going to be eligible for special education services they have to meet the three prong eligibility um criteria that we talk about in our eligibility or EC meetings and so those criteria would be number one they have to meet the criteria that's established in chapter 4 of 2419 under each disability so each disability has a specific sort of set of definitions that the student must meet to qualify for those services in that in that area the second prong is that they have to experience an adverse effect on their educational performance and then the third would be that they need specially designed instruction and we say that because we work on under two different programs we work under IEPs and we work under 504s so a student could have a disability they may not

069need special education services they may only need accommodations and we can um provide those accommodations through a 504 in our County so when we look at eligibility for special education services we determine that at that initial meeting for the student and then we're required to look at that eligibility for those Services every 3 years um for as long as long as the student is in the program to determine if they continue to meet their criteria for their services so right now as of February 17th rof County schools has 826 active IEPs and we have 124s that we manage compliance for in our office here at the the county office um I have broken down the exceptionalities um by number I did give you guys a print off so I'm not going to and read the

070number I will point out that we are um sort of on Pace with the rest of the state when you look at the number of students receiving special education services typically the specific learning disability or sld category does have the highest number of students and we have 284 of those students in our County that were serving under s we also offer related Services through special education and I want to talk a little bit about the difference so a student student can qualify for a specific learning disability in special education but they can also um qualify for a related service a related service could be speech it could be occupational therapy physical therapy and then we Vision or hearing can either be a primary exceptionality or it can be offered as a related service it depends

071on the the need of the student so when we look at our speech numbers we have something like 130 something kids receiving speech but we have an additional 178 students that are receiving speech as a related service in our County so they could be LD as their primary but they also have speech services on their IEP um we also have students that were serving um related Services under a 504 so two of the related Services occupational therapy and physical therapy are not Standalone Services meaning that a student can't qualify for an IEP if they only need occupational or or phys physical therapy so if those are the only needs for that student we would offer that student those Services through their 54 plan right now in addition to the um 826 IEPs that we have

072open we still have um about 28 open referrals I've broken those referrals down by um disability category so those are students that have been referred by the Student Assistance team or the SAT team in their building and in the process of testing those students and then once we complete that testing we'll hold the eligibility committee meeting to determine if they meet the criteria for special education services and we've not hit what in special edland we call referral season yet so referral season for us in special ed season is typically going to be that very late February to March um because that's about the time that it takes for schools to identify students um get them through the that process collect interventions do their progress monitoring and determine are they going to make that recommendation for

073the referral for special education services so we do anticipate that more referrals will come into our office within the next couple of weeks we don't cut referrals off um at the end of the school year or any time during the school year but we like to give principles a deadline to say if you would like your 80-day timeline resolved by the end of the school year you need to get your referral To Us by this time so we can ensure that we get all of the testing done we write the report and then you can hold your eligibility and then IEP meeting if needed so once we look at that eligibility process and a referrals made and we get what what we call consent in our office so permission to evaluate the child for the

074parent we are required to resolve that within 80 days so we complete the testing we write the report court and then we get the information back to the schools to their eligibility committees and they must hold that eligibility meeting within that 80-day timeline we're monitored on that federally and we have to get 100% compliance with every referral and I'm I'm happy to say in eight years we have never missed a referral never missed the compliance deadline um for the 80-day timelines even through Co we were not forgiven we still had to meet the those timelines we set up a tent in the back of the parking lot behind the board office we screened we took temperatures we interviewed families we determined where families had traveled and then we entered into the empty boardroom and we

075did testing um through plexiglass during that Co period so we could meet our 80-day timeline and R off down okay so throughout the last couple of meetings I've heard some information and I've got some questions about gifted and exceptional gifted so I just wanted to clear up and maybe answer some questions um about gifted and and what is included in gifted services so again I'll go back to gifted is not a disability so it is not covered under idea but it is part of West Virginia 2419 so it's under our state policy in policy gifted is for students in grades one through eight that is all that is in included so gifted with a few exceptions does not carry over into the high school level so I wanted to talk a little bit about what

076gifted is um so students meeting the criteria for gifted um they're going to get that service and it's an like an acceleration in grades one through eight as students leave the gifted program or exit the gifted program in their eighth grade year per policy we have the opportunity to determine are they um eligible for exceptional gifted exceptional gifted can be offered in grades 9 through 12 but there are certain criteria that you have to meet to be considered exceptional gifted the first criteria is that you have to also meet the criteria for one of the um disability categories in 2419 so that might look like um a student could have other health impairment and they could also be gifted that would make them eligible for exceptional gifted they could have an Autism diagnosis they could

077have a learning disability in one area but be gifted in another um so those are things that would qualify um exceptional gifted the second is they would have to meet the definition to be economically disadvantaged they would meet the definition for underachievement based on their intellectual excuse me intellectual ability and then the last criteria was that they would have to meet the definition for a psychological adjustment disorder as documented by a comprehensive psychological evaluation so those are kind of the differences between the gifted for one through eight that any student meeting that eligibility criteria would be offered and then what could be offered for exceptional gifted in grades 9 through 12 how many you get most your referrals for so all referrals can all referrals will originate at the school level so those referrals can

078be initiated by the classroom teacher they could be initiated by the parent or they can be initiated by by the principal but any referral for any special education service including gifted originates at the school I just I mean wise I've seen our gifted numbers go down and I'm wondering if we're just not doing doing a great job in recognizing those kids maybe because of socioeconomic reasons um because not everybody's got a you know the go you know what I mean advocating um for those but um especially at George Ward um that's our largest Elementary and we you know just statistically there's got to be somebody we do and we do get gifted referrals and we do test um we test every gifted referral that is submitted to our office whether we think it's a good

079referral or not and when I say whether we think it's a good referral or not we might look at their I ready scores and see that someone's been referred and they're only in the you know 75th percentile where they should be in the 90th or above we know that that's One Moment One snapshot in time maybe the student had an off day that day maybe you know they were distracted by something outside maybe it's not something they would interest they were interested in doing so we don't screen out gifted referrals based on that we we test every student but you do have to score within that 97th percentile on that intellectual ability um testing and it it is difficult and and we're seeing that decline as as special ed directors that conversation is Statewide it's

080it's not just our County so it is it's disappointing it's concerning that we're seeing that mind statistically there's got to be some there got to be somebody for those referals the students do unfortunately in West Virginia we only recognize reading a map as our two you know so unfortunately if you're music or art gifted we don't recognize uh those but um and you have to do the IQ portion and the achievement portion and score high enough in both of those to move on correct so um but it just saddens me you know we just don't have the numbers that we that we used to I think we have three open Gifted referrals right now three three left to test now that's not to say that some additional ones may not come in in the next

081few weeks but right now we have three how many of you do you know how many you had so far this year in general I won't hold you exactly I'm looking at my school psychologist who does all of our testing I would say less than 10 easily less than 10 it seems we have 34 total yes one one through eight we do not have any students receiving exceptional gifted right now how many gifted teachers we have one gifted teacher that's itinerate in our County and she Serv most of the elementary students um and then we have one gifted teacher at elen middle but unfortunately her case load is lower so she is actually certified to do gifted and special education um she's doing both and and our it tener elementary teacher is certified um that

082way as well and she's also helping to provide some special education um services to our students at the ALS with Federal funding is that hurt in your department well gifted is not covered under Ida so we are not allowed to use any federal funds towards gifted services or supplies for the gifted teachers we have to use the smaller amount of State funding that we receive so um we're going to talk about special education salaries um you know as we progress through the presentation but that that's when we talk about an unfunded mandate that's a county salary um because we can't paper with IB G so I wanted to talk a little bit just what gifted is and gifted is um it is a service um it's not a separate class it's not a separate grade

083um and even for students in grades 1 through eight it's differentiated instruction so the information in the PowerPoint and I provided all of you guys a copy of 2419 with the gifted and exceptional gifted definition and all of the criteria and what the service might look like um so you can read that in full um but I wanted to touch on at the high school level and hearing a lot of the concern about gifted not being offered at high school gifted is not a separate class it's not a weightbearing class um while our gifted students are encouraged to take honors and AP and dual credit and those higher level courses it that's not gifted and even if they were receiving exceptional gifted Services there those are two very separ things so if if we think

084about um a high school teacher that's certified to teach dual credit biology that's not your gifted teacher so your gifted teacher would be certified to provide those gifted Services they wouldn't necessarily hold that certification to teach those up upper level courses and in the same token that teacher who's teaching that upper level course may not hold a certification to teach gifted I know it's presented test there is no more options after each grade and now myself many others are concerned that um you know we were told you know your IP is done you're you're moving on there's plenty of things for you to there's plenty of things for you to take and now we're facing the fact that there might not be those things um for them to take and and honestly now I feel

085a little duped for my own you know um um I don't know what I I mean but I was told there was no option um IID is done well I mean it's correct there's no option if you don't meet the criteria for exceptional gifed so if if you don't meet one of those criteria that's correct there's no option moving forward the IEP um is concluded at the end of the eth grade year seems like just and and now I don't know there's just going to be less um and I feel like we're not serving those students either but I'll so when we look at the 8 126 IEPs and the 1254 and all of the services um it does take a great deal of Staffing to support those students so this is a current snapshot

086of what we um where we are today in ROV County we have 41 full-time special education teachers we have four halftime special education teachers we have 10 related service providers and we have 16 special education needs we have seven preschool special needs teachers and four preschool special needs AIDS and then we have one school psychologist one Behavior specialist one IEP specialist we have a special education secretary and then a special education director we also have to contract because the list that you just saw looks significant but when you look at services that are were required to provide within the IEP we also contract out outside for services because we don't have enough staff to cover those here in the county so Interim HealthCare provides very specialized healthare to a to medically fragile students um best

087life therapy is an agency that we use and they also provide occupational therapy we have right now 41 students that no 48 students I'm sorry that our full-time occupational therapist serves and we have 31 students also receiving Services through outside contracted because the number is just too large for one person to serve for that that service sorry ises that come out of your title or your I I'm not title I I'm Ida um and so those Services right now come out of carry over special education funds keep keep that in mind they they come out of carryover yeah all of these are paid through federal or or state funds Mountainside behavior um adaa services so for some of our students with the most significant Behavior needs um we work with board certified Behavior analysts and

088that's through Mountainside behavior um we have WBU um cdrp so that's uh orientation and Mobility Services so those would be services for students who are visually impaired who um will need to be trained to use a white cane will need to be trained to maneuver in society as their Vision progresses and and becomes worse that's what those orientation and Mobility Services are um we we don't those services are very rare and mo excuse me most school districts have to contract out for that service we also have um a few students that we may need to contract out for an audiologist um we don't employ an a ologist in the county um it's rare that we have to do that but we average about ,200 to $1,500 a year that we might have to work with

089an outside audiologist um contracted school psychologist so when we talk about these numbers and we talk about the number of referrals that we get and our 80-day timeline requirements keep in mind we're in school and students are in school for 180 days so when we're looking at testing 120 130 or 140 kids and most of that testing would be more concentrated into the spring one person cannot get all of that testing done now we have not had the contract out for school psychologist yet this year but um we have a situation that will um make it necessary for us to contract out for the rest of the year as our school psychologist will be out um happy situation um as our school psychologist will be out probably we're hoping that she makes it through April

090we're optimistic um but those Services last year cost a little over $1,000 and then I mean real costs for us are the evaluations or the protocols that we have to evaluate students so you know we spend anywhere from three to almost $5,000 depending on what we have to purchase um and it's we can't shop around for those if we're looking for intellectual ability we have to use what is provided by Pearson or what is provided and they're they just cost what they cost unfortunately and those assessments are very expensive so we just talked about um the reported cost for contracted services so those costs um that you see were from July 1 of 2024 to present so we will um expand upon those costs as we progress through the school year they are being paid

091out of special education carryover funds once those carryover funds are depleted as County carryover funds can be depleted those costs will transfer to the county and the county will have to pick those costs up so those aren't optional Services those are services that are built into IEPs for students so we just can't simply say we don't have the money to pay for OT we don't have the money to pay for health care services um and staff salaries um there are Direct Services um and again the the one difference on that sheet some of the contracted School psychologists um can be paid with available State funds and I'll get to that in just a minute so we we look at Staffing requirements so we have a very stringent list of requirements from 2419 and they Encompass

092different areas of special education so the first area would be case management assignments that basically means how many students can a teacher write and hold IEPs for throughout the school year so for our prek special needs teachers it's 20 they can't they can't do more than 20 for our gifted and speech therapists they cannot have more than 50 and then other special education teachers serving those um autism LD those typical um special education exceptionalities we can't exceed 30 and so that's the case load so that's merely the number of IEPs that they'll write and hold for the year the family that they'll contact the the information they'll check on students with other teachers so when we're looking at direct instruction the the services are different so special education services um are based on service needs

093the majority of our students are level one service needs some are level two service needs and so you can see the ratios for those for a K1 and two group of students it's one adult to six students we can't exceed that ratio for 3 four five it's one adult to eight students and 6 through 12 is one adult to 12 students now in our level one and level two needs we can go to 12 students in those environments if we put a second adult in the room so so we can but 12 is going to be our maximum at that level regardless so like if you put an eight in there if we put an exactly yeah so our students with level three those are our most significant needs the students with the most significant

094behaviors the most significant Health needs the students with the most significant cognitive disabilities those that really need that extra care and we're typically looking at students who would be in a self-contained classroom those ratios are a little bit different they are one to four and we're not supposed to exceed eight in those classrooms so those classrooms with those students we are seeing a need for those classrooms to increase um eight years ago when I started here in the county office we had one self-contained classroom at Elkin's Third Ward we had one autism room at Elkin's Third Ward we had one class at elen middle and one class at elen's high we have grown to one room at elin's Third Ward for our self-contained life skills students the medically fragile students we are nearly at capacity

095in two autism rooms at Elkin Third Ward um we are on the verge of meeting two rooms at elen's middle and then as those students move up um we also have a room at elen's high we are in desperate need and excuse me and have started to expand one classroom at TAG ble so keep in mind as the needs of those students increase the number of staff to address those needs will also increase Miss Sonic will you explain to them about the mixed if you have like a level two and and with a bunch of level ones what happens to the ratio so that they can understand or level three in that same room so you go to the you fall back to the most restrictive so if I am the special education teacher at

096elin's Third Ward and I have a group of students for resource English that I'm pulling out and I I need to combine my 2 three4 group I have to fall under the two grade two ratios instead of the 3 four because I have those younger students within my my environment the same aing on the side of caution airing on the side of caution more more service more eyes needed more more hands needed and and I will say every teacher in this County and in every state in the country is is undervalued and that's that's my opinion but when you walk into those self-contained classrooms in any of our building if you could see the level of work and attention and what's required in those classrooms it's unbelievable what those teachers and AIDS are doing every

097day the next area one more um we have to look at minimum enrollment in integrated classrooms and an inclusion classroom an integrated classroom is a regular classroom in any school building and it's going to have one teacher teaching the content but it's going to have special education students in the room that's they're going to be receiving accommodations or modifications we cannot exceed 30% of the enrollment in that classroom and then if we change that to an inclusion classroom meaning the content teacher is in the room but we're also pushing in with a special education teacher we can't exceed 50% enrollment in that classroom so those are the requirements for Staffing that we have to work within in special education here's a picture of special education salaries in Randolph County Schools over the last several years

098um if you'll pay attention to the um last number Mr Smith um created that number or or gave me that number I guess um and so we're we're right now anticipating um you know just under $4 million um then contrast to that my idea funding is a little over 1.1 million so Randolph County picks up the POR the remaining portion of those salaries so that's that's what I get um our funding our ad funding you can advance the FL um is based on our December one count each year it does not include gifted so gifted students are not included in that count and as I said um you know the dollars that we get we apply towards the salaries but Randol County school you know they pick up the balance so as far as like

099the behavior Behavior specialist that have specialist are they includ salaries as well they are I specialist they get the work okay I'll let yep we also do receive a small portion of funding from state aid so we call that our state aid money um it is a smaller pot of money and it is based on our October one p gifted students do count in that um pot of money but state aid fluctuates from year to year and it's never guaranteed one of the things that makes state aid kind of difficult if a student with an IEP is placed in an outof State placement by our court system not recommendation from the school nothing to do with the school but placed out of state by our court system I lose $27,600 per student that is placed

100out of state so they give us our pot of money and then that's what we have to give back if we exceed the number of um state aid dollars that we would get for example if something would happen and the circuit courts would Place five or six students out of state not only do we not get that state aid the county has to pay the state back what we we would owe them which is almost like yes so we we always keep that in the back of our mind um and there are lots of counties that end up paying the State back every year we're very fortunate we we have um as you can see the number of students in out ofate placement has decreased throughout the years we anticipate next year with next year's

101funding hopefully there were only two out during that count um but that will cost me almost $60,000 in state aid funding okay so again to just reiterate our idea on our federal funding we use that almost exclusively for staff salaries and contracted services now again we do have that Federal carryover but it is rapidly disappearing oh I'd say we disappear rapidly yeah do it say how good is your it is not so we can float another year and that's about it it would depend on the amount of services that we would need for students and the additional Staffing that would be required based on do you have concerns from the from what's coming down federally we have not we we everyone right now in our special ed world we feel like our funding is protected

102um idea depart well you know idea is federal law so I don't know that that could go away unless they repealed a federal law and unfortunately if it does go away and the federal law does not go away we would still be responsible for following federal law and no funding at all so there's a lot of questions sounds like we're going to be we we've not had any concern that our Ida funding is going away so it's not included in the title now tomorrow that could change but as of today we don't have those concerns for the inadequate F funding that we're getting absolutely um um if you'll go back just one slide so I I will talk about we do use our state aid funding um we are required to provide extended school year

103services to those students who um would require them and that is in 2419 so we would use that funding to help support those Services um we pay professional stiens we often do try to help with tuition embur reimbursement so if we have a special education teacher for example that doesn't have an Autism endorsement and it's needed for their position they would have to go back and take those additional classes we try to at least reimburse a portion of what they're paying out of pocket to help um offset those costs um we would pay for professional development we can do some contracted Services um we do pay staff travel um and we off that's how we would buy all of our special education supplies for our students and staff and when I say special special education

104supplies for students um you know we have students who may need an assisted technology device to speak those can cost $6 to 8,000 um if we have a student who would need a standing frame or a gate trainer um those are in the neighborhood of $8 to $10,000 those are pieces of equipment that we would be required to purchase for those students in need um I'll talk a little bit about itinerate providers in our County we have 22 itinerate service providers in our County and when I say itinerate service that would include our speech pathologists our OT our PT um our heart of hearing and vision teacher our Behavior specialist and behavior AIDS our bus AIDS our gifted teachers and we have one itinerate preschool special means teachers those teachers are in sometimes four to

105five different buildings a day every day of the week because they're traveling to meet the needs of those students who are in different parts of our County we are required to pay them for their travel we have one County vehicle in special education and we do sign that out so our our people sign it out but have one car and 22 people moving in different directions so we try to utilize that mode of transportation as much as we can um our tenant travel in our County from August to January is $669 65 is what we've paid for those providers to move from building to building out of County travel per for professional development for all special education providers so that might include our school psychologist who has to go to the school psychologist convention to

106get the number of hours for for continuing credit u Behavior type things um we've spent $1,169 12 so far this year so aside from serving our students a major part of what we do every day is IEP compliance IPS are legally binding documents that we are required to follow in the county and we have to make sure that what is what is on that piece of paper is right so the one IEP specialist that we have um so far and and keep in mind I'm talking about 180 days of school um we are anticipating that we will have around 875 IEPs at the end of the school year to date 792 reviews of the documents have been completed resulting in 420 corrective actions meaning they come to us at the County office they're reviewed we

107send them back to the teachers to make the corrections to to to keep us in compliance due to special education staff shortages um we have long-term Subs in a lot of our positions the IEP specialist has also written 26 IEPs and she's done 83 amendments to keep our IEPs in compliance so far this year um often students will have more than one IEP in the school year so we estimate last year we were at 1490 around 1,500 reviews will take place in the 180 days that we're in school with students to make sure that our IEPs remain in compliance and then each service review requires any service that's on the IEP has a piece of data entry that's um associated with it so every one of those documents that comes through our door has to

108be entered into the weas data system for every service that's on the I questions well let me just add quick part of the um because I know there's been questions around the value of the IEP writer and and just speaking from other districts did not have this position you end up in what's referred to as a due process hearing we never win those because often the language that's placed in there somehow ties our hands whether it's requiring us to add positions and we almost always pay court cost one of those court costs or not excuse me not court costs the attorney fees excuse me they're usually about 14 Grand a piece and so it's really an insurance policy in in the grand schemes of things so I personally I would not ever remove this because

109I've gone through some of those due process hearings I've dealt with some of challenges of teachers placing AIDS and other language in uh that would add positions and really that's against state code because there's only one person or one phys in West Virginia code that can obligate funds on behalf of the board and that's the the superintendent so you have to get all this language cleaned up and clear and one of the things that can challenge this is inconsistency in language and so those can be used against you when you do end up in these due process hearings and dealing with uh disputes over services and things of that nature so it's incredibly important having somebody evaluate and look at these carefully to make sure that we're doing this one other point I wanted to

110make is some of these positions that we're talking about here tonight are the positions people are arguing that should be cut out of the central office because they don't realize that they are countywide functions and do a variety of different things within the central office so I think it's important people educate themselves about what actually positions are here and those positions that are actually functioning and what services they provide so I think it's important as people continue to criticize things that they don't fully comprehend I think they need to understand that there are lots of compounding implications for positions and functions of roles within our system not only in this building but in all buildings ail is it kindergarten first grade well students students are eligible for special education services from ages 3 to 21

111so students in um preschool can meet the criteria for developmental delay so when we say a preschool special needs we're talking about a student who has a developmental delay and they can also qualify for speech OT PT vision and hearing so those related Services they can qualify for those services at that age I just want to congratulate special ed Department I know you guys don't get a whole lot of who laws and everything because you know we're usually the bearers of bad news but um just just being in the state with different boards and different counties and stuff like that usually when you hear of counties that are having problems it's always inp special so and that's one thing that I don't think Rand county is having a problem with not knock on wood we

112have gone eight years without a state complaint and that's to be commanded for in your in your all yes absolutely I I'll pay for that tomorrow any other questions if you hear anything from federal or state level changing let us know us know it seems like it's always there's I mean I'm making myself a little crazy call stuff yeah we'll definitely keep you informed and I think part of what we wanted to do is just convey sort of the deficit that it is when we're required to provide these Services when we're talking about unended mandates special ed is probably one of the most costly unfunded mandates that the federal and state government puts on schools and burdens schools with and so I think it's part of an piece of advocacy that we'll have to continue

113to push and promote and try to bring additional dollars to the table but again that's going to be a challenge for us how many open special ed positions do we have currently four at Elkin middle one at Elkin High one at Beverly one at T fley and that is just we're not getting qualified public so there is um on top of teaching every day um there is a tremendous amount of paperwork associated with being a special education teacher and when we talk to the special education teachers that LE even go to general education it is because of the the paperwork that's required and those paper the paperwork is not required through our office it's through Federal compliance you know the things that we have to do but it's a tremendous responsibility any questions speak evening

114as well I'll have a few points well it will not be good news yeah um so I do what I what I've been trying to to to accomplish is showing how our funding has been affected by this by the loss of students and how some items have been masking what is happening um I apologize for not having anything to hand out to you I was working on this up until about 4:00 but what I do want to say is in 2021 the funding we received for personnel was roughly $19.4 million the funding that we anticipate receiving this year through the state aid formula is 21.6 million which is uh quite an increase on the surface what we have to look at is why that funding increased and what do we have to do with the

115money that that we got because of that there were two 5% increases in that time period for employee pay that's roughly $1.8 million um more in state funding that we get that is immed immediately just put right back out to our employees um also the third grade success act began bringing more service Personnel into the county for us also with additional funding that is roughly 700,000 I think per year so when I look at fy21 and FY 26 and I take out um the raises and the staff that we brought in as ecat AIDS and the funding that came with those we are left with in in 21 we were left with 19.4 million where we started if you back out those raises and you back out the E the money for the ecad AIDS

116I only have 17.8 million in 2026 to pay the bills and to try to make up gaps that are happening in special ed in 21 we spent 3.2 million on special ed out of the county this year I expect 3.9 million that's a $700,000 increase in two years so even there we have to look if it's not required we're not going to be able to have it we have to look for efficiencies to make things better because I don't know how much more money we're going to be able to put into that program uh we're going to have to you try to look at different things um in that time we're down 25 professional positions we are up 20 service positions roughly the ecad AIDS account amount to 11 positions per year so we should

117be up 33 service but we're only up 20 and that's because we're losing and kids so we're really down we would be down 33 kids if ecat if the third grade success had not happened we would be down roughly 33 service um and 25 professionals so where I'll use Dr Ferris I always refer to he always talked about Big Rocks we need changes to the state aid funding formula to address the rising Ed costs um I know that those are being looked at um sub costs are grossly underfunded and I've talked about that many times um so and I think you know Dr dly had talked about last meeting you know we just have we have to look at everything we have to become more efficient um if it's not required you know if we

118want it what are we going to cut that that's where we really are are with everything that we're doing I know um I've talked with Senator Morris um I emailed back and forth with delegate Kyle today multiple times there is some growing support according to delegate Kyle on the remote School support act I don't remember what that bill number was you know any if that money comes in certainly that helps free up do to address other issues so we are really at a point where we need to try to get the state to make changes to help us with our particular situation we're unlike any other County we have U issues with mountains distances weather that most counties don't have to deal with and we've got them all um so I I really wanted to

119you know to point out those things um I have heard that you know you're getting more money you're getting more money and we are but it's tied directly to a couple big rocks that that we cannot use it for anything else and you know this was this was a very rough um these are you know I pulled actual numbers and there are fluctuations within the different steps in the funding formula but service Personnel funding in 21 was 4.5 million for salaries it's now 6.3 million so it is backing up what I'm saying um we brought in roughly 1.8 million in additional money but it's at the cost of additional positions that we have to have so um our our professional salaries are up as well but we've also and in both of these cases had

120two 5% raises in this time per so yes those numbers should go up um but where we are where we are struggling is is the backside of it it is masking the loss of dollars to run the county pay the electric bills to have a fourth grade teacher to have that extra Aid to have uh professional development that's needed all of those things are being squeezed immensely uh at this point and um I will continue to to talk with um any of the legislators that would um like input U I know delegate K has asked me to uh perhaps help him write some points on the U on the remote schools um and I will do that um so that that's kind of my big rock type picture uh I think Denise passed down the

121budget calendar this is what I anticipate I give this to you all every year um it's kind of it's colorcoded uh and it's uh there's bolded sections um what you'll see is on March 3rd the county assessor will um issue the certificate evaluation that kind of kicks me off being able to do my budget that is the local share dollars um on March 18th you're going going to see how much we expect to uh receive locally um a very uh a point I want to make about that is the more we receive locally the less we leave uh receive in State dollars the formula says we're getting X number of dollars if we get more local it just decreases to State um there uh I've highlighted in in brown publication and submission dates those are

122um dates that I will be getting different items to the newspaper um for publication uh when I have to have things submitted to the state uh the Bold um items are meetings where you all will be uh seeing different pieces of the budget uh I'm anticipating um one trick very tricky thing um this year is it's an election year most years the legislative session ends in mid-march and it takes the state about 10 days to get me final comps that way I can really begin the preparing the budget so that means in early April I normally have those comps and I have um I plan to have a final budget to you all on May 6th that normally gives me a little more than a month or so to do that because we are in

123a uh election year the regular 60-day session is not going to end until April 12th and the state does not project having final comps to me until April 25th um I have about 10 days to get a budget knocked out I will be working on the budget I have to wait on all of the Personnel actions to be worked through to determine all the different tumbles because I have to take you know if fifth grade is a riff because of a transfer in and then that person becomes second grade somewhere else and that ultimately bumps a person then I have to um with HR we have to track all that through so I can have the proper person in the budget um so as soon as those hearings are over I'm going to begin that

124work waiting on the the final comps from the state they often do not change much however there is a lot on the table this year in the legislative sessions and we do have a lot of members of the public who have who have um been doing talking for us and so forth so hopefully this all this push does change things it does flow more dollars into us and these extremely tough decisions you're having to make become easy because we have we are one of only 11 counties without a excess ly so our size topography and no l it's we're in a tough spot um we also you know there's so many unknowns at the federal level right now I feel that the dollars will flow down to the state but how will they then flow

125to the counties um School choices is very popular right now so if those federal dollars do flow down to us will they flow down at the same rate as they being given to us now we don't know that is there any indication on a federal timeline of money so I mean I haven't heard anything yeah I've been trying to get some clarification on those positions uh because obviously we have lots of concern around those positions that are supported by federal funds we have not gotten or received any guidance whatsoever uh the state has not received anything either I think there's just such a lack of clarification of what the future of the US Department of Education looks like or exist um and even if they do settle something when and if those funds would flow

126to us is's a big question mark is there a usual timeline I mean like I'm just going to say like you know by June 1st you know what your title one or federal monies are is that is there a normal timeline not I mean most years they tell me with with title and with special ed use last year's number to Budget and then they sh it up over time um I know that um numerous times we've been December January getting those six and seven months after the year starts still getting adjustments on now they may be small they may be you know they could be as small as a couple hundred dollar but sometimes they're $10,000 worth of adjustment or more um but I don't anticipate a lot well and I think it's important to

127note because working with the superintendent organization uh our legislative representative was at a meeting this past week where the governor had shared that he was looking at a 1.5% cut to state aid for schools districts that would equate to about $320,000 in uh reductions for us and so when and and well I think without going into too many details if the governor has given a lot of authority over those federal funds I don't believe we will benefit greatly from that he's publicly said he's making this the most school choice you know school choice and and um expanding on Hope Scholarship and and and I mean it's no s I mean he's not hit it right and my our concern is there's going to be less restrictions around those federal funds that would be coming down

128and it would be determined by state by state and there they could actually find a lot of that or all of that into uh school choice options and then I was excited to see that they were looking at reviewing the state like the state formula like per student and stuff like that but then it looks like they're just redistributing money to give more money to the Hope Scholarship like it's it's not the restruct I was hoping for so um it didn't it did I was like oh yes they're finally looking at this but I it wasn't it beneficial for us correct at least my understanding so far it did not appear like it was going to give us any additional monies per student or set aside money for a treasure set aside money that's required

129set aside money extra money for special ed or anything like that not that I've seen either and I'll share a little bit of legislative update here in a little bit but you have any questions just all prop now I'm gonna have just a whole kind of different uh Direction in the beginning of the school year in July we talked about um land that the school board owns that we were looking at whatever has that progressed any on we well we've sort of had our hands full but I me I there's only I think one or two pieces of property that would be um that we could potentially do but I don't anticipate any great grand monies from those that would solve any major issu parts but I would agree that yeah I mean that part

130yeah we do anticipate trying to get that we're trying to get through Personnel season and then once we get through Personnel season we're going to try to jump back on raising uh those outs for auction so that we can actually like said acquire whatever funds we can from that that land perfect thank you but none of that is going to give us millions of dollars no and just for people's sake what those are sort of remnants of years gone past back when there were one room schoolhouses dotted all over the county uh there's a couple remnants properties that just sort of really don't have any significance s functionality for us as a school district so let's we're going to just see if who can't potentially um get some revenues back from those properties and some

131of those when you do look at the agreements they would return to the family we right so not even all of them and a lot of them are like these weird landlocked pieces of I think there were five total that were still but it think Dr D is right I think it's only two that we could potentially do something with and it might it's a half acre somewhere so I don't want public think and we'll probably wind up in argue with the neighbor saying that's my land and I bought it all right so we already voted on the we already voted on the okay so we can move on to Section 8 Personnel if everybody's ready can I get a motion Shar all right um Dr D did you have any questions or concerns no

132I did not receive any questions I don't have any concerns to mention I would like to make a motion to go into executive session for personnel please oh second all those in favor of executive session please signify by saying I I and it is now 7 o'clock and this word sits an executive session for e e e to come out of executive session all those in favor of coming out of the executive session please signify by saying I I and it is uh 7:32 we are out of executive session and no decisions were made in executive session we we are on Section Eight personnel and um anybody have any questions concerns it's kind of standard stuff but all right is everybody ready for a vote all those in favor of section eight Personnel please signify

133by saying I I any opposed 5 Zer and now we were at superintendent reports all right I have a few different things for you this evening the first I just uh shared with you a legislative update I've been working as Mr Smith has as well with our local Representatives as well as some other organizations trying to support So this I have done some analysis for you to to look at on some of the proposed house legislation and Senate side uh there are lots of concerns I'll put it that way and I don't know that um there's any good path forward with some of these but some of these things have some legitimate implications for schools I haven't really stepped outside of Education bills at this point but I think we're going to continue to Advocate

134one of the ones that I think has some potential real concern for me is Senate Bill 199 it's the elementary behavior and intervention and safety uh there's language in that is troubling to me because it doesn't have the necessary checks and balances to protect students it also violates Federal idea laws and um 504 uh requirements and so there's a lot of questions around that so i' created this analysis to try to help both our Senators and representatives uh to work in through some of those things um there's also concerns with a variety of these with a school aight formula there was one I think it's House Bill 2480 which is kind of proposing to make us into 11 districts across the state uh as I think was shared this evening I've actually talked about that

135very notion for a long time that it is would be a logical next step in reducing cost for producing education but where I shied away from that is is the challenges of it should be most brought around more urban uh or population centers and based on that uh because it would make sense uh to uh try to work within those particular Lo locals rather than an artificial County Line because what the proposal was suggesting is basically five counties well there's a lot of questions about how that would be done in a fair way in representation from both the local level as well as the authorities of different roles and different things but I have said you know that there there could be some different levels of cooperation and absorption I do think it is going

136to be a necessity at some point but I think the the written bill as it is right now is pretty naive and incomplete uh for my opinion I think there's a whole lot more analysis that would need to be done to do that so I would just encourage you to look through these I'm going to continue to try to work through some of these as I go forward and continue to try to help Advocate and inform folks but uh what I've done here just for the folks out there and we can actually put this online if you want to I'll have relle put this for folks listening uh I do have things where it's addressing federal and state laws as well as budgetary concerns uh any potential uh recommendations for fixing it uh potential concerns

137around um misallocation or ad ministrative burdens uh just a variety of different aspects I've tried to create a standardized format as far as the protocol that I've been doing this analysis and hopefully that'll help you all as well uh and I'll continue to do that and I have like I said shared this with uh our representatives in Charleston as well so that they could have this information and look at trying to move this forward uh the biggest things things like House Bill 2512 school bus operator job titles and pay scales that's creating different class for buses and again drivers based on years kind of like we have for custodian 1 2 and three they were talking about doing the same thing I'm not opposed to it but you have to fund it don't do it

138as an unfunded mandate and that's kind of some of the questions I have with some of these things are who's funding these things just like the Senate Bill 199 the reason I mentioned that is because it is around student Behavior and the concerns well one of the areas that we need is we don't have adequate funding is our Alternative Learning programs for young children and uh this this bill doesn't necessarily address the funding requirements for that and so these are some of the aspects that we have to really start advocating helping people in Charleston understand but it's very evident to me there's a lot of folks that don't understand what's existing in law too as well so there's a lot of implications and uh elements of these proposals that are contradictory towards current laws and

139situations so I have that there for you guys and if you have any that you see coming up let me know and I'll be glad to try to do the same analysis for those particular ones but these are the ones that I've um you haven't moved it Advanced it for me yet so they're not seeing what I what I'm oh I didn't know was on there sorry uh so so these are the ones I've done so far and I hope to try to continue like I said do that but uh we hope to uh make that available I have you make this available as well uh on the website so if folks want to look at this analysis and again I'm no legal expert or anything like that I've been trying to utilize some uh

140AI tools and some varieties in creating this analysis but I think it's been the things that I've verified in here have looked really really good from my perspective but I will say again it's just uh an initial analysis and really short period of time so there could be some elements of this that may be different interpreted or elements of that way but I think it's important that we start to advocate for these changes if they're going to go forward all right looking at uh some of the obviously there's a lot of folks passionate this evening about um collaborative planning and block scheduling or the team concept at the middle school and what this really comes down to isn't the matter of quality it isn't a matter of the benefits it's a matter of can we

141afford it and the answer is we really can afford it based on our current situation and and yes there's been numbers thrown out there and the reason there numbers have been thrown out there is basically some of the basically determinations around uh What uh can be done with switching from adding an additional course back to existing teachers without having minimal impact to students and I'll explain a little bit more here what that is but this is the the cost or approximate cost based on what we would consider the average teacher salary with fixed cost a lot of folks think that's high but when you start paying retirement insurance and all the other fixed costs associated with each position that is about the average teacher salary for us according to based on budgetary uh reasons and

142so that total comes to about $1.1 million between the Middle School Elkin Middle School Elin high school and Tiger's Valley uh Middle High and so ultimately I would love to be able to keep these folks But ultimately I don't know there's no choice of finding Cuts we have to reach to balance the budget we have to make those cuts and so I'm using the example here of Elkin High School currently if uh zoomi is correct West Virginia zoomi is a access to data sometimes it changes it's not always matching everything else but so elkens high school has 44 staff and with 44 staff those staff can re uh currently teach 264 classes or sections per year so that is where we basically offer this year 264 classes uh based on what they can offer if

143we move to the the period schedule 266 classes can be taught by 38 teachers and what that is doing is actually just adding another section on to each of those teachers without reducing the number of classes or options for students they would be delivered differently uh but again it comes back to we can't afford to not do these things uh as we are looking at uh many program cuts and a variety of different things I think it's important that we look at there's three different types of actions that we're looking at this this year in Personnel season it is probably going to be one of the one for the history books as the number of actions uh and Denise is going to need all kinds of medication and and therapy after this uh season because

144of all the challenges but what we have is our traditional annual year-to-year uh cuts and Rifts and transfers that we have to based on where students are moving uh for example moving in fourth grade moves up to fifth grade so we have to make those changes so we have those standard uh traditional Cuts we also have enrollment loss that we have to make changes for then we also have the 32 positions that we have to find uh the reduction in uh Staffing to do that or equivalent cost oh did you not calling back no I'll pause then would you like me to continue second okay hey sorry that's my fault I didn't call you back okay all right go ahead do so so the third just to kind of catch maybe fill back up there

145briefly we have the standard uh annual uh RI R and transfer process that we have to do to meet student demands and needs then we have the second bucket of transfers and and Rifts that we'll have to discuss uh which is for the 32 positions that we have to address to balance the budget for next year and then we have the third challenge which is the uncertainty around our federal programs funding and what we are looking at or concerned with is at this point we don't know if and we will have any funding at all for our federal programs and what people need to understand is we only have one one time a year that we can make these changes in Personnel action and so therefore The Prudent thing for us to do is assume

146the worst case scenario because otherwise we would be required to pay these positions if we did not receive these funding and where would we get that funding from we essentially would not be able to make payroll next year and that is not something we want to do so Title One positions um title two title four title five positions CSI is also federally funded even though it's traveled to a grant um and then the other positions connected to U our federal funds we will should be looking at uh putting those folks on Rift and transfer until we have such confirmation that we actually have federal funds because at this point we don't know that we will have any federal funds um and nobody is able to provide us at the federal level or state level any

147confirmation of such so uh we can just to remind people also though if we do get confirmation we can quickly unwind those particular cuts and we can do it clear till August 1st but our hope is we would have confirmation obviously people need stability in their things but at at the same time we can't pay people with imaginary money either and so it's important that we realize that we also have some State granted funded positions that are up in the air CIS positions or community and schools positions spokes funding which is adult uh our CTE math Ela Academic Program funding or adult education are also state grants that are unclear if they're going to be funded for next year these traditionally have the spokes the CTE and the adult education all have been pretty traditionally

148supported but the first time in my well this and this is an unusual year traditionally they've always been recommended by the state that we should do this but we've always had some level of guarantee that we will get funding for the following year I'm not getting any guarantees at this point because I think there's just question marks about what state aid formulas will be impacted and what funding formulas will be impacted by these and these are separate I think it's important to recognize these spokes CTE and adult education and CIS are paid from separate funds than our general fund that we've been talking about so they are different and separate than the 32 positions that we're talking about but if we did not get that funding not we would have to pay for it out

149of the general fund yes so that's why I say this yes so this is going to be a very very difficult season for us for all parties involved and and I I hate that we're in this position but again there's no way we could have anticipated this level of federal uh change I'll put it that way uh and uncertainty around those particular issues so we have a lot of folks that are going to be impacted this year and so as we move into next year we have to you will be seeing a lot of proposals Around The Prudent nature of trying to be very proactive and making sure we can balance the budget for next year because the people that are left deserve to be paid and so and if we don't balance the budget

150that is what we're talking about not paying people the the salaries that they have earned can I ask a quick question before we move on because you're going into facilities and I want to kind of get back to the the Block versus the eight period day sure would it what type of difference would this seven period day propos well the seven period day would essentially leave you at 26 sections requiring you say 44 staff so it doesn't save you any staff because they can still only teach six sections per year or six courses so you have to move to the eight period day to actually do the savings on paper then you have just left less adults in general it will increase the class size is not as large as some of the folks because

151we have been looking at that but just less hands on Des correct it there is cost to it but again it's not a choice we have now because without the closures and without facilities being shut down we have to save that funding somewhere and this is one of the places that would be um considered an extra and and I I hate that we're even having to have this conversation but it is one of the choices that we have to do and one of the places that we uh can cut with limiting the impact of students I will not say that it's impact but I'm saying it will limit the Impact versus some of the other Alternatives any other questions on that okay one of the other areas I wanted to address this evening is the

152comprehensive educational facilities plan I've gotten a lot of questions a lot of concerns about why did we deviate from the comprehensive or the cfp as it's often referred to uh based on what was existing and I think think it's important to first start back with some of the goals and looking at the objectives of those goals and I'm not going to sit and read all of this this evening but I think one of the things that it's important when we're looking at this is the existing plan followed these objectives and the proposed plan that I suggested to this board previous to this year pre earlier this year also meets these same objectives but I think one of the things that I wanted to point out in this is looking at these goals and grade configurations

153uh when we're looking at the goals of the cfp we cannot meet some of these right now and we won't be able to meet them unless we change our configuration as a system and this C1 for example operate and maintain the number of facilities required by efficient and effective educational programs and I'll show you some data to back that up shortly based around our enrollment projections and some of the challenges but we have to annually review the facilities and projected enrollments and so we are looking at annual implication and changes and again I'm not talking about uh criticizing what was done because I think it's important to understand the original cfp was done in 2019 know there's a whole lot of changes that have heard happen since then and so uh one of the things

154also for the community to understand the cfp is a planning document that's all it is is a planning document it's amendable it's amend to evolve with changing local conditions and it's why they can uh request amendments it's only a planning document in the sense of trying to meet the needs of the community and the school system that it that it's providing for also changing leadership and board configuration will influence the goals of the cfp so you will get sometimes board members that come on or a new superintendent it has different ideas about what it should shape it as changing conditions Co Hope Scholarship local employment trends should be changing what we have because it's moving people out it's affecting what we should be providing to our students in schools uh legislative and Congressional implications for

155schools obviously we talked about a lot this evening about those particular implications but then a lot of the unfunded mandates or mandates coming down as well also will affect what we should be doing within our facilities one of the areas that I think is important too also looking at postsecondary and Workforce demands for students exiting rof planning schools we should be looking at that aspect as we are uh planning our facilities and moving forward towards what I would consider a future ready school system one of the things I think is important to also look at is myself and I'm very different than my predecessor and other predecessors that were at prior superintendents that were here I've worked in five separate districts and one International District and that has changed because I've seen a lot of

156different models within the state and then also internationally how those structures and so that has influenced my thinking about how we utilize our facilities I also grew up in the construction field so I know a lot more about facilities than a lot of my uh superintendents throughout the state I could actually draw a blue plan if I had to I'll put it that way and most of them can't even read them so um I've work construction jobs both here in West Virginia and South Carolina so I've worked for framing Crews I've worked for a variety of different U elements so I have a lot of understanding about what it means to do this uh and keep buildings up to date spent six years in residential and commercial sales and as a store manager for that

157as well I've also LED over $30 million in school renovation projects so I've had a lot of experience in that I've also been as a transportation director and Facilities director so I don't think there's a superintendent in West Virginia that has that level experience and I'm not saying that boastfully I'm just saying it changes your perspective and understanding of when you're looking at your facilities and how those facilities support the educational needs of our students and we'll shift back to some of the data I you've seen this particular data in the in the past but as you uh we the population Trend between 2010 29 the orange area just kind of highlighted there just is the kind of the projections um so you'll see that throughout consistently the orange area being projections so you can

158see this the Randol County's population trend is continuing to move downward and isn't expected to continue to decline over the next 5 years one of the things the changing conditions thought it was important to do this you have seen this one as well and this is kind of the past enrollment Trends here for Randol County but notice the decline here with Co see what it has done with our particular population and then you see sort of the 21 to 23 area there uh 22 to 23 excuse me sort of a flatline but then Hope Scholarship arrives and look what it has done so my counterparts in 2019 could have never anticipated these particular realities affecting our enrollment and affecting uh projections about where because when I look at the projections in the cfp they're nowhere

159close to the actuals that we have right now and so there's no way to have uh anticipated the level of aspects of what they were wanting to try to do one of the things I also spent a little time and I created this new one um and I've sort of created sort of the end of the cfp line here this sort of lighter green and then a lighter blue there the origal projections throughout all these charts so you'll see these lines to help you I projected our enrollment projections out through 2045 so this would be for Randol County schools and if these projections hold true which again there's a lot of unknowns between now and 2,235 students so that's a loss of a significant amount of students but when we are talking about building a

160facility or maintaining a facility we have to think about the long term because the building is going to be there 15 20 25 30 50 years and so where we're investing our money we need to be thinking about where those populations will be going and where they're being supported and how we will be supporting them and again all of this will probably be well after all of our time but we should be setting the foundation for them as we go forward to ensure that they're successful when they reach this point and they're not being faced with the difficult decisions we are right now uh with some of the I think uh different thinking that uh that I'm suggesting that we consider also like I know that our birth rate at the hospital from my time

161here cut in half like what we have per year almost I mean it's been a dramatic decline so I mean I've seen it from that side and then you know and then from here um and I know I mean our cfp does get adjusted a lot just most of the time people don't don't notice it um all take notice of it more you know what I mean take notice of those things more um but you know certainly they get adjusted well and what I would and I would say this is a criticism of cfps being that I've been in five separate districts is they're very shortsighted from my perspective um they're not thinking about that 15 or 20 or 25 year uh plan for where the population is and and where it will be and

162I think that's some of the stuff that I I wanted to share with you this evening is part of this and as I kind of jump to this next one I do have up here um long-term investment facilities so part of what I'm suggesting is part of we need to be looking at where we're investing and at the last meeting I shared the notion that you know there will be a time that Elkin High School will probably be Elken High Middle High well if you look at this particular projections around enrollment the capacity of Elin High School is 1,118 students by 2034 that could be a reality because there be these projections show 1,17 I'm not saying it will be C certain that that'll happen but anticipated that could be a reality by as early

163as 2035 um and it may be a Pruden action by this board at some point to do that and so when well but I'm just saying by this board whether you're on this board or not but but the board itself as a whole but again I have up here also the proposed values of the uh cfp Investments and I think one of the things it's important to recognize and I didn't put it on this slide is those are 2019 numbers well 2019 numbers definitely aren't accurate today because of uh inflation so you're probably talking a 15 or 20% increase in those cost but these are also incorporating School building authority uh funds which we know we will not get at this point based on our current circumstances so there's no chance of getting these funds

164at this point but what I'm suggesting is we should be thinking about if we're going to invest money somewhere it would make sense to invest in elens high school because of the long-term role of it being longterm and uh looking at it part of our system moving forward and looking at and I also shared about George Ward excuse me and Tiger's Valley being uh looking at it as a tiger Valley being pre 12 building and so if you look at these projections again capacity of taret Valley is 850 uh which uh that would be 571 total in 2034 so we could easily accommodate those but that was also part of what the proposed action steps was this year was to build some additional uh just because they have the capacity doesn't necessarily mean they have

165the right classrooms and design and layout and that was part of what the SBA proposal was this year was to play lay the foundation for this particular step in the future so when we look at buildings like Harmon because there's been a lot of question about that so my question is how's it's difficult for me to justify the investment over $2.5 million for a projection by the end of the cfp of being roughly 69 students and again do I want to see something beneficial happening to that location and for those students absolutely I just don't have tools within our current Arsenal without the legislative support to make that happen but my I don't see how we can justify $2.5 million even if we could get those funds going into a building for uh 69 students

166by the end of this C FP cycle the same goes for Pickin it had proposed $632,500 um by the proposed end of this cfp if the current trends uh proposal works out it would be about 11 students in that facility and I'm all for small rural schools but I don't know how you can justify with our current funding formulas how this can make sense to invest any dollars uh Beyond just operational at this point because of that I think really talking with what Mr Carol was saying what would make sense in my opinion is Rock cave uh Webster County and upshire County all build a school somewhere out in that location to be supported by all three areas that is the only way a rural School in that area would make sense and and so

167it's until the legislature and everybody gets on board but there's there is laws that allow us to do that right now there's actually the SBA would jump at an opportunity to do that but there's a lot of complic because of who's in charge and all of that stuff that hasn't been sorted out yeah Glenville and I'm trying to think Lewis County I think are the two that have really struggled but the problem is too though it was very it was buil overbuilt for the number of students that's having so they're really struggling with the enrollment issue there as well right now so again if we're not going we have to understand that uh in this case 14% utilization doesn't allow us to capture the funds within the current constructs of what we're trying to do

168as far as the economies of scale that the SBA looks at so it pretty much prevents us from getting access to these dollars and so that's part of where I think we have to look at a different model um moving forward but I also wanted to bring in some of the Intown schools just because some of the in town schools were looked at um as well and as many of you are aware of the proposal talked about consolidating these uh into two uh local schools and I don't see justifying putting money into Beverly Elementary or Colton at this point either because of those long-term projections and based on where we're at now you can see they're looking pretty relatively flat but again if you're not aware sorry guys I just I meant to mention this

169earlier but we did get some damage over the weekend uh some wind damage at Elkin High School uh was impacted some of the out building some of the bleachers and things got blown around and some damages there we're still trying to get all that we had a wind that was left unlatched and it blew open with a bunch of water inside um but the Beverly gy roof is probably our worst situation right now where it actually lifted the majority of that roof and we're hoping that the insurance company will actually address that because that's only about a 2-year-old roof but it literally pulled 5 in uh screws out of the material I mean I don't know how it what happened there but I think there's some installation issues but uh we have been working on

170trying to get that addressed swiftly because the weather is not our friend right now trying to fix the the roof there looking at Jennings Randolph and Midland Elementary you can see here also uh Jenning staying relatively flat based on projections again Midland still declining a little bit but we also know that some of Midland's decline is also been some of the changes in um uh our zoning and some of that stuff over the years and so uh but as far as a final location but but as the building itself was not worth saving in my opinion I think it's worth considering building that's complete separate School building that will last longterm for us as we consider moving forward with kind of a proposal North Elementary and third W Elementary again uh slightly declining uh part

171of what I wanted to get to was sort of this combined enrollment uh based on this what we were looking at is in the cfp had actually had the proposal for a new school to be built uh for this but what was originally proposed was one Elementary School and I've never been a fan of that model because it just if you look at this projection it's 1,248 elementary students in one building and that creates a lot of issues in itself programmatically a lot of things and I don't know that the state would actually approve that they prefer those to be smaller than that I've actually worked at Kaiser Elementary or Primary School in in Mineral County is about was about 660 students when I was there as superintendent and it created some challenges it was

172manageable with the right leadership and the right folks but the building design also helped us because it had a prek wi it had a pre K1 wing and so it was really divided yeah and so so it can be done but that was sort of The Proposal was around two schools that would be around that 600 uh 650 range which would maximize the economies of scale would maximize those types of things and part of what again if I'm again dreaming I would love to make these Net Zero schools and for those people not familiar with that term Net Zero is essentially for riding whether it's wind uh uh or whatever uh solar or other means to produce enough electricity that it operates itself and so I'm a big fan of geothermal which I've been able

173to do in another District that saves money long term because Brad not to put you on the spot but what do we pay roughly in utilities per year for the county so I mean even if we're saving 2 to 300,000 per building that's 2 to 300,000 that could be invested back in kids differently the cost is upfront so for if we can get enough community support and we could get enough um support from the school building authority we could have some great schools that longterm could invest and we could put that money because we know energy costs aren't going down so think in the lifetime of the building how much money we could compound and save now granted there are some trade off with management of some of the panels and things like that but

174with geothermal it's actually a huge Advantage because the the the loops that they put in for school districts and for school buildings there's a 50-year guarantee on the loop that's put in the ground so that has a 50-year guarantee there's nothing else that we install in schools that has a 50-year guarantee and basically what you have on the inside of the building from those Loops is two electric motors and two um control panels that are redundancy because basically it typically uses just one of those Motors but when high demand or pick the second one on but the first one fails the the one's always run and you're able to do it so it's a it's a great redundant system that costs a lot up front but longterm saves a lot of cost and can be

175reinvested back in our schools and so um questions at this point some different things for you to think about again I think it's important that we're looking at the long-term perspective as we are making decisions about the cfp about the decisions that we have to move forward with we know we have a rough Personnel season but I don't think that should prevent us from looking at what's next for us as a County as well I do not that leaves us oh do you want to do I guess up school no nothing at this time and then um you talked about the bages at and so Insurance even with the stuff at alin's high Insurance involved yes we've we've submitted it all to brim our insurance carrier and we're waiting to see back uh the aspects

176of that but they've been busy on it um we also had stuff blow off the roof with the Elin Middle School which we yeah yes um but our our some of our staff went over and and the principal I think even helped clean some of that up it was just some small remnants that they didn't take care of so we do thank people that got involved and and stepped up and tried to do all of that but we've they have had their hands full this week with everything going on but the Beverly uh roof right now is kind of the big question mark about how to fix it uh so that it can be temporarily at least get to see well that's why I suggest to me a insulation issue is what I think but

177that's just my perspective cuz I mean the glues either they've used a bad batch of glue or some method of that apdm roof well I won't get into the details of how that process works but ultimately to me there's and so we have went back to the architect as well they're also following up with um so the company has come back up to try to help us but the problem is is the roof's partially frozen it's it's it's a mess right now um but they are trying to keep this building inside safe and dry as best they can and then do we need to set some hearing plans okay so hearing dates how many are you thinking that we need and what we well I think we're looking at three nights is what we're suggesting

178U majority of these actions will be related to professional Personnel so we probably anticipate doing service Personnel initially first and then proceeding with professional positions U that remainder of that evening and then remainder of the two days I think it's lofty but I think we I don't know we don't have to use yeah we can all yes absolutely we can after what yes sir uh it's like the 24th 24 25 26 27 of March I'll working I'll i' sa front load like Monday didn't if be cancer they cancer Thursday obviously or we don't need it then don't don't be Thursday yeah 530 start 5:30 is that okay with everybody okay all right um so we um go ahead and schedule those and then rates that's just like a five minute ahead of that thank you

179yes I have those all right anything else for the vement of the board 318 and then 415 and that's and that's just like five minutes earlyer J second by Sher all those in favor please signify by saying I I it is 811 and this U meeting ised

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.