001testing e e e heard from anybody else okay so mics are starting to go hot that let's go ahead we'll go ahead and call this uh special meeting of the Wayne County Board of Education to order it is 6:34 we may have some others join us but we'll go ahead and get get things started if you'll stand we'll say the Pledge I'll lead us this evening I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the for it stands one nation indivisible with liberty and justice for all the records show that all board members are present in person this evening yes we are and yes you get it the first item on our agenda this evening of course is our legislative Forum so i' just like to say thank you for
002coming and welcome we appreciate your time and uh your effort to come and talk with us about some of our thoughts and concerns about um our County our community our our students and uh we really appreciate you carving out some time in your evening to just come and kind of um create an open dialogue and some give us a platform and also we'd like to hear some of your thoughts and ideas about ways that we can work together and just make the county even better so thank you all for yeah thank you we can uh we can start with some maybe some just general introductions if you want that way everybody in the audience can kind of get to know us we'll start with Mr Fuller Scott Fuller I'm the state senator for uh District
003Five um Wayne County resident and all my kids went to school Wayne County and um a lot of my grandkids go to school in Wayne County so I'm I appreciate yall inviting me up here to to be a part of this thank you Ryan Browning delegate 28th District which is basically Central Wayne County um it's my first term and ready to get to work right I'm Mark mayard I'm a senator for the six district and I represent Wayne ningo McDow mer counties Michael Amos Delegate for the 27th District which is Northern Wayne County Sera Canova West Morland area Spring Valley is my high school up there that I cover um board members if you want to introduce yourself as well we'll start Mr Ross Mark Ross John Jackson Missy Hall Todd Alexander I'm the superintendent
004Ashworth Randy Tran great all right so now that we've got all those formalities out of the way and everybody knows are um we can okay maybe we can get started with just some uh general questions or you guys have anything that you'd like to present to us first or would you like for us to just kind of start with some question and answers and we'll just keep it kind of general and informal if that's okay with you perfect awesome all right um I think if I can speak for the board here I think uh one of our major concerns um is our Rising special education population um we have at least about a 30% ratio of our students that have some type of I AP or 504 or need of some type of of special
005services and if you familiar with our County in the past that's probably we we usually ranged from when I was in school probably a 10 to 15% range um now we're over 30% in our County alone so um Robbie come on up you're welcome come on up to the front R so we we've had a couple couple guests join us one by phone uh Senator Craig Hart has joined us by phone so he's on the speaker phone here and then uh commissioner H Robbie Thompson from the Wayne County Commission is here as well great um so we were just talking about um our special education population and the uh the rise that we've had over the past few years as especially and um we're seeing quite a funding Gap um for those Services um a
006lot of that is coming off of our general budget because we are paying the overages because we're over State formula but my understanding is there's not a lot of of leeway in that formula for these extra services for these kids and I know that there's Federal monies that go along with that but um when you're at a 30% or above population that money gets eaten up really quick so we're were just curious if that you had any ideas or if there's any talk about covering those shortfalls for that special education population well I can tell you I'm I am in the education on the education committee great um again this is my first right term up there so uh but education is really important to me do you do we have any idea what the
007increase how why is a increase in what we're seeing in there's a lot of social emotional issues there's a lot of lot of grandparents raising kids grandparents raising kids drug problems drug babies that are now in the school system um so there's there's a lot of different things I don't know if we can actually pinpoint I didn't know if there was but I will um I that's what I'm here for and and I want you all to know that that any concerns you all have with with the your here in Wayne County let me know and I'll take that to the Committees and and bring it up to them we do for that we we provided you some numbers there at the table the um the the uh line graph uh demonstrates the uh special
008education population in Wayne County going back to 2014 you can see in 2014 there was 1,390 and this year the 202 for school year we have 1,514 as identified a special education now what's interesting about that is is over that same time period there's been a overall loss of student enrollment year after year so in 2017 we had over 7,000 uh kids in the district and this is the first year that we've dropped below 6,000 and if you look at the uh the uh birth rates uh for the area that number can uh projected to continue to drop or overall enrollment will continue to drop for the rest of the decade that's true for the majority of the state I think that there's about four counties uh two to four counties that buck that Trend
009that's in the Eastern Panhandle your Berkeley's your Jeffersons the rest of the state has been losing population and has been losing population for decades and um so that's what makes this especially challenging is what you would think that if our overall enrollment was dropping that our that our special education population would drop as well in in proportion and it's the opposite it's actually rising and what what's challenging with that is that um uh this if you have a student that's identified as an in special ed in not all cases but in some cases the staffing needs of of those students are more intensive and it requires more adults per student than it does with the regular population so that's U it's been Challenge and I believe that you would find that this is true for
010a majority of the districts in West Virginia that although they're losing that overall population that special education population continues to increase that's got to be a that's got to be a burden on on finding enough support teachers and stuff like that too are are you behind like on getting licensed yeah when when you hear about the non-certified areas the special education staff that is our primary problem so out of all of our positions let's say we have 20 positions where they're not filled by certified staff uh 18 of those would be special education positions the falling population is hurting us a lot of different ways I know delegate Dylan there has the same concerns I do about smaller schools the state's probably going to force us because we can't afford it with a falling population
011the money goes down and uh there's two schools in the southern end of the county I'm I fight to try to keep them open right Ag and I know let me just interrupt your here just sorry but I was just trying let's keep it to special education first and then we'll hang on to that that's another point that we want to share with them as well so yes sir um on um and ju just for the record uh we've had a couple additional folks join us Travis Thompson Wayne County Commission and uh and delegate Henry Dyan appreciate you being here yes um on the point of the increased percentage of special ed students to what do you attribute that uh as the you know population drops and that percentage continues to increase I think I
012think and if you look at the line graph a big part of that was the pandemic and schools being shut down as much as they were so if you look at the increase in the numbers from 2020 to the 2025 projections there was a significant increase so there was a there was a significant learning loss that occurred there I think that that's impacting the numbers uh there's other factors as well as was mentioned previously opioid epidemic um unstable home situations that type of thing all of that plays in what what is the percentage of students who are identified as special education uh I can work you up a percentage really quick um in in Wayne County right now that total percentage is and I'm I'm recalling numbers from this morning is approximately 25% now so
013some of some of the uh some of the special education numbers are Communications disorders of speech so if you subtract that that out those numbers drop just below 20% for the entire District yeah and and from what we're hearing from other counties there's a similar Trend going on in other counties as well I don't know does that include our 50 504 plan so if you include those students that number is going to increase so that does not include 54 no so that's a that's a higher number we're pushing the the 30% at that point what percentage of students are on A4 they are not considered special education the uh students on students for special education are on IEPs 504s are not considered to be in special education so add number there on 504 plans I
014don't have the I don't have the number on 504 plans Missy did you say that these numbers you're not compensated through the school weight formula no there are there are not all of them some of them are if we're over formula if we have let's just just say we're over with our AIDS um and we're 10 over those 10 AIDs that we're over come off of our general budget our our we're fitting the bill for those individuals even though um they're required it may be students that have um severe disabilities and they are in self-contained classrooms who have you know a teacher and four adults for six kids because of the needs of those children so so we have to provide those services for those kids that need them but our budget doesn't always or
015our state aid numbers full-time employees don't always cover those particular individuals even though they're required of us so I think that's where we we go over a lot is with bus drivers because of transportation and AIDS because of the extra services that we have to we have to provide for our students and so the school aid fora does not take consideration the percentage of special ed students in your county right not not for personnel purposes no of course we receive we receive federal dollars for special education services but it does not cover the positions what does it cover because I'm any any uh equipment needs um any uh expenses that go along with those classes any outside Services therapy uh Physical Therapy occupational therapy those type of things there is some funding that covers some
016positions but it's not near enough to uh cover the number of positions that are required especially as our population in the schools drop of course our funding levels drop our full-time funding so we we're having a higher need but we're not able to um fund those with the state a formula because we're losing um student population so do you have any numbers on how many students are transferring across the river into another state you mean transferring away from Wayne County transferring to Kentucky or yes you're talking about in the enrollment loss yes um no we don't we don't have any numbers at our fingertips here this evening but yeah we do track that from year to year would you say it's significant our our most significant loss has been um our most significant losses have
017been homeschool students and students to the Hope Scholarship yeah and sometimes those those are homeschooled students as well so our our current number of homeschooled students is 496 so going back to um and we we traced this back to about 2012 The Homeschool numbers Rose each year by about 50 per year and that uh stabilized right before the pandemic and we had about 350 being homeschooled right prior immediately prior to the pandemic um when schools shut down that number went up significantly went up close to 600 when schools reopened five days a week uh that number returned closer to uh uh closer to uh to the 500 number the 496 that we currently set at uh Hope Scholarship has resulted uh there's been another 231 um Hope Scholarship submittal so we have about 727 students
018uh total that are homeschooled or receiving Services through the Hope Scholarship now some of that number is inflated because students who were already private school students uh they had the ability to come back and enroll in public school and if they stayed there for I believe it was 30 days then they could apply for the Hope Scholarship so we had a number of students that came back for that 30-day period and then withdrew again and uh um the uh so that's that's you know that number prior to the pandemic we were sitting with about 350 students that we had lost out of the educational system for for other choices that number is increased to 727 and uh we're you know we're not we we don't want to argue against school choice or anything like that
019I don't think here this evening that's not the purpose of of what we're talking about what what I would argue is is that we do need to look and you mentioned going across the river um there's a lot of folks that don't know that that Hope Scholarship Money Follows students to out of state institutions and so there are schools in Kentucky um that are receiving Hope Scholarship money uh for their operations um and uh you know we're losing students out of the Fort Gay area U and that money is transferring over into Kentucky and I know that all the Border counties are dealing with that including up in the Eastern Panhandle and the Northern Panhandle um the the one thing that we would ask is and we've heard the governor say that they're you know
020seriously considering broadening those options and that's fine we need to be our best version to keep students here but the one thing that we would ask is that there be a Level Playing filled with that and so for example um it seems to me that it would be something to think about that these schools that are receiving this money should have to go through some type of accreditation process just like the public schools do so so you know and the public knows where that money is going to and that it's being used effectively in in those schools and then also assessment accountability uh the reporting of assessment results so uh parents uh can have a transparent look at the uh uh performance of those institutions as well and again the third concern being some of
021that money is going out of state so I think it would be some consideration to to limit that money to instate institutions oh do you know the dollar figure over the average student in West Virginia 11,000 approximately Jeb is our Treasurer that that number changes each year it's not that high really Jeb the per pupil allotment is close to not Wayne County I'm talking about West Virginia the average in West Virginia correct is 6,000 right around 6,000 now that's State money you're not including Federal money in that state money okay from the school funding formula well I was talking about the the dollar figure that floats over every student's head I think it's about 11 if you count Federal money right that what we concentrate on is the 6,000 from the state so Federal money
022is based on population of school W students in the state no matter who's enrolled where and that comes from the Census as far as I know so Hope Scholarship is like $4,500 is that close to what they get I don't know yeah I think it's I think it's their change or something like that I think it's their state a assignment number that $6,000 assignment number that the district would get I think that that's what goes into that account my question is what happens to all that Federal money for a Hope Scholarship student if I would assume it would stay at the federal level no it comes to the state West Virginia I mean because that's what we get to educate the students and um I can't get an answer to that but it's you know
023definitely West Virginia gets on average 11,000 per student to educate all the school W no matter where it's at or whatever that's just the average total MCE in uh state and federal and so I've heard the argument that there's actually more money for the students for our education system for the students that enroll in Hope Scholarship because there's that big pile of federal money that you know the state isn't having to spend to educate that student that's doing the school choice thing so the only problem with that Senator is the fact that when you get Federal money there's there's guidelines and strings attached I don't doubt it at all and and the way you spend it and where you spend it we have we have no ability or no understanding at all about how that
024could change all we can do is ask for local changes my question is where's that money right do it does it trickle down to the I don't know system do we see any of it I think it's what we're you know Scott used to be a detective maybe he can pretty low that down not to my knowledge but we we will inquire as well going back to the percentages that you guys were talking about with u IEPs and behavioral disorders stuff that I've I've talked to a few um teachers Educators and even some ber of three um instruct or therapists if you want to call them that and they're they're all saying the same thing is that they see an over diagnosis of um behavioral disorders in our region and up to including a certain
025doctor in the region that will do it over the phone without ever even seeing a child wow is there a way that we can kind of combat that and you know have discussions on you know if someone's if someone's being overdiagnosed for something um that we could you know are Avenues what I'm saying is that we can get around that to where saying hey this is this is just a an out for the for the parents to say hey my child is whatever it is put them in IEP now they're protected federally against any type of discipline or anything of that nature and you know are you guys seeing that as much as them but you know these are Wayne County Educators I have spoke to about this and you know we do have our
026own psychologist our own Department that does their um their own um analysis of of these students and if it's Behavior or or yeah so to go go on an IP that data has to be there and has to be legitimate now we do get a lot of um doctor referrals for um different things that might qualify a student for a Student Assistance team plan or possibly even a 504 plan U but wouldn't rise to the level of qualifying for an IEP so usually there's there's um there's some checks and balances in there to to make sure that they're being properly identified yeah you know we've sat meetings uh over the last few weeks and you know the one thing that I I hear up in Charleston from a lot of these Educators coming out there
027talking is discipline you know they're not allowed to go above certain standards of discipline and in some case it's it's disrupting the entire education environment for maybe one or two children in an entire schol school and you know that their complaint was we can't do anything about it because they are diagnosed with these conditions and they are on these plans and so they have to follow these protocols or they get in trouble so you know and it was kind of you know from when all of us went to school backwards thinking as far as how these situations are being handled where it's disrupting the entire school system you know to accommodate a few and if you're telling me now we're at 30% of you know these types of of cases as far as you know
028where they could go through this process and disrupt a classroom setting and no wonder people are pulling their kids out of school I mean I if I had a child in school and I know that they're not getting the education that they need because there's all these disruptions and there's all these things going on I would probably pull them out as well um so I think that we need to figure out a way to combat the um disciplinary problems going on and you know give the teachers the power that they need to discipline these kids or go through the process of disciplining these kids and getting them away from the the rest of the classro get an education they deserve yeah there's there's a percentage of IEPs that would come with behavioral issues but it's
029a it's it's a small percentage of the overall number so a a number of those IEPs would be like learning disabilities things like that those are kids that behave as normal where the struggles came for the state and for the for the teachers is when when you were in school and when I was in school you didn't see that at the elementary level right and that's changed we we deal I heard at the elementary I would go so far as to suggest that when we were in school um we faced a certain number of consequences you know if we exhibited certain behaviors and uh I would suggest that in more modern years um consequences have been either deferred or routed a different way or watered down or uh we we found all sorts of different
030Avenues or labels to place on the behaviors to avoid consequences for actions but at the state level in our code we don't really provide our teachers with the tools to enforce those consequences and um uh you know I'm not even referring necessarily to corporal punishment necessarily but uh something that the the children will understand and respect and when we're dealing with Early Childhood in particular children of that age don't understand deferred punishment they they don't understand you know detention a few days from now they understand I did this now and this is a bad thing that happened to me and I didn't like that so I'm not going to do this anymore and that's what across the state I think we're missing that support for the districts and the schools to be able to implement
031immediate and understandable consequences that you know uh pre-operational children can understand um again I don't want to preach and harp on corporal punishment but there has to be something some negative consequence that they don't appreciate or enjoy when they do something that's inappropriate in a classroom setting and I would go so far as to suggest that the PBIS system which has some success um over the long term is going to disappoint I I think we need something other than just positive behavioral uh you know supports and and rewards for things done well that that's important but especially in that early childhood if they don't if you don't ingrain that in the in the psyche of a child before they're 10 years old or eight years old or nine years old by the time they get
032to Middle adolescence you're in trouble I mean to piggy back on on that do you see do you see a lot of you know like we're having a hard time or difficult time filling our our teachers positions or whatever do you see that as a deterrent for people wanting to become teachers because you know I I equate that with u law enforcement for example the change that overcame our society with law enforcement it was the lack of accountability for those who cause an issue and I could see because you know being a teacher as you know Missy I've got I've got teachers in my family and I hear the the horror stories that that they have to go through and it's just um you know as a teacher you want to do the right thing
033but you're handcuffed it seems like to be able to no like like U well Scott that all came about number one Society changed and what he was talking about delegate Browning yeah parents were different then you got in trouble at school you got in trouble at home too true that's not happening so much now and which really requires more to and this other stuff came about the lack of corporal punishment stuff because of litigation people get sued and and I never did when I was teaching I didn't want to hit anybody else's kid that was up to their parents I'm getting at is specifically in the younger grades the teachers need to have the ability to correct students without worrying about their own jobs not only to correct that particular student but to make the
034other students andag and so they canenu uh and and um you know 25% on an i is is it's high and I understand that you're mostly diagnosing those students there at the school I certainly don't want to say that anyone shouldn't have an IEP that's not what I'm saying at all but I also wonder to pick up on the gentleman's point about the hardships on the teacher if teacher has multiple preps or multip day and they have multiple individualized learning plans to make individualized modifications how individualized modifications is that teer don't know they're going you don't know if you're get 10 of them or maybe of them of school year how many teachers want to sck around for thats the uh doctor of Education there stated if we don't have the ability to correct these
035children at a younger age Senator fer yeah I just wanted to you know again I think that is when you go back and you look at it and again I'm not an educator although I did go to school to be a teacher but I'm not an educator so I'm I'm I'm trusting you know that you all you know what I'm talking about but it just seems like that the root of the of all the problems that we're having in well school which bleeds over Society in general what is the fact that we don't hold children accountable for their actions and it's and kids are you know again I have kids so I I I can speak on this pretty uh Ally if you don't if you don't tell them something's wrong and you keep appeasing
036them it's going to make it so much harder to get them to do just that's kind of if you can get that down I believe that you could get the rest of the issues would be handled like a trickle down effect uh I just I just feel like I I don't and I don't know maybe youall can explain why why do we not have the discipline in schools like we used to have that is a legislative issue that needs to be addressed is that something that AB I do know there is a discipline bill that you probably worked on last year that they've tweaked that will be coming up again this year so and we all know that if a teacher says that a child does something and they tell their parents their little darling
037wouldn't do that most of them not all of them but a lot of them right you know they won't take the teacher's side they take the child's side right part of general family breakdown I mean it is yeah it is it it's amazed me since I've been on the board to realize that I mean in some of these broken homes people are doing great great jobs are doing the best they can but I was blessed 100 years ago when I was in school you know had a stable home life and most of the other kids did did and I know that's not the situation now it is a it's a very complicated problem um and one of the reasons it's so complicated is because that behavior has moved down to such a young age yeah
038so you take a kid in kindergarten and you know these kid these kids have have been born with opioid in their system they they have psychological issues um there's been trauma in the home that type of thing so you we we can tighten up the discipline and and I agree with you that that needs to occur but you you send that kid home right right and then he's home for five days that's right and then he's and then he's back the problem is I think that that I think that the majority of the districts are having is is finding out you know what changes that Behavior because the more the kids out of school the worse the worse Behavior becomes yeah it doesn't improve the worse it becomes and the further behind and then society's
039going to be dealing with them at some point I believe society's dealing with them at that point they're in a classroom with 20 other students students are dealing certainly an imp on students and I would say that if they having part of the time along the classroom it's not on those students in fact I would say from my own experience it's making a very negative impa on students delegate Dyan Senator to build on top of that also you have the contagion effect in which uh other students see well this student uh acted out and didn't see any meaningful consequences so I'm gonna try the same thing and it kind of spreads from there but um I'm wondering if maybe one of our board members or the superintendent could uh speak to the current policy on
040um recess and what measures you can take because my understanding of the law right now is that you're limited severely on how much recess time that you can restrict as a punishment for you know bad behavior or whatever and that that changed I don't know how many years ago but yeah you're not supposed to take away recess time yeah makes those changes I'm sorry didn't just ask I don't want to misspeak I'm pretty sure that that was a that I'm pretty sure that was a state board of education thing but I I'll get back with you on that to to clarify so so my my thought there is you know I I'm the last one to want to take away activity time from kids because they need to be up and moving around and everything
041but my question would be is there a way maybe through state code that we can increase the total amount of activity time and then we can have you know uh part of that time where we have more latitude to take away and that way we would have a punishment measure there and also we would be working out some of that excess energy at the same time get love that received because I would be strongly in favor supporting legislation on that as well increasing time to allow kids to be kids is Inc take away or toad let me me and will take care it and we know that exposure to actual outdoor sunlight has extremely positive effects on psychology and mood and that's going to filter through you know to to behavior as well let me
042let me say real quick and I want to say one final thing about um homeschool there was a t there was a time where the homeschooling assessments had to be turned in at every grade level and that has that changed and I'm not sure when it changed um within the last decade decade or so but the assessments from from homeschool amilies are due on third grade fifth grade e8th grade and 11th grade and I would just propose to you from from um from my end of things that we would like to see that on an annual level where we can see those kids progress to make sure that education is actually happening um there there is a lot of good homeschooling families I know some of them personally have some of them that live on
043my street that do a fantastic job I see a number uh that are registering their kids uh for homeschool to avoid truancy charges and because their kid is getting in trouble at school all the time and they're tired of dealing with the administration or dealing with the teacher on the discipline issues and then they're they're pulled out and I believe that there's little to no education going on in in a significant percentage of those cases so just for your consideration yes sir Senator wol yes okay okay you're on speaker now experience profal experience and if that student finds success outside the traditional brick and morar school perhaps in home school or perhaps in in military school I'm always excited to see that but I I noticed that if we perhaps if we take these kids
044that don't want to be in school and we force them back into school that may not exactly alleviate problems that you're having in school in fact I would say that be fuel on your fire it may get you a few more dollars but um you certainly want wouldn't want to run everyone else all um from a professional point of view for being in the classroom for my adult life as opposed my entire life growing up as a public school kid that might be something to consider that if students are finding success elsewhere and sometimes that's hard to gauge academically though it should be but sometimes the total success of the student isn't just seen and solidified learning that's that's measured on a Scantron sheet and there's the there's the idea that if a 16-year-old young
045man doesn't want to be there may make everyone else Miserable as well and you may lose more students because of that underline that I I see is that parents often I want my kid out of school because so and so kids is ruining it for everyone okay do you have any suggestions on that yeah well you know that's a tough one and you hit you know the family structure and what not is often not there however I have found that typically speaking in my own professional those families that don't care let me this the overwhelming amount of families who send their kids to public school every day care and love their kids and want the best for their kids however those parents who simply do not care and do not want their kids around are
046the first ones to put their kids on that bus to get them over there so we can watch them them in student who home school sometimes sometimes maybe it's not the best situation and maybe it's better than they are in school but to just say we think that Johnny somewhere isn't living up to his full potential and algebraic equations therefore we must severely punish all parents all people choice may not be the best answer that might be a little knee I understand it's it's difficult to see a student leave and not be able to track their performance but there might be a whole lot more play and things to consider than what first me and especially when it starts coming to a high schooler a 17y old young man that doesn't want to and Nightmare
047else in that classroom now that may not be so in your schools but I can tell you for the last 15 20 even how long I've done this it's been the case that I've seen can I can I uh it sounds to me like all these there's a lot of problems a lot of things a lot of I think the number one thing that we need to do as legislators and as as as as a state uh in general is we need to prioritize our education we need to make it better for you all to be able to so that we can make all these other things we can do if we prioritize and I just don't think we have I mean I know people say that it's a priority just like they say you
048know police or priority or whatever talk is cheap to me and if you really want to have a topnotch education system in the state of West Virginia we have to prioritize it and throwing money at a problem doesn't always fix that problem no but but prioritizing it is is prioritizing it from every angle financially you know legislatively all those things are going to help the system I know I know at the legislature they share some of the economic numbers with you and I know you know West Virginia is ranked last or or next to last in Workforce participation rate um as you move into Southern West Virginia that number is is even worse than the than this than the state's number and so as as you know we're trying to uh it you know it
049all funnels into the economic development and the success of the education system but I I will be here I will venture to say that you fix the economic system by building a better education system absolutely like to do with law enforcement you know no one's going to come to this this state if they don't feel like they can number one keep their business safe and number two if they're the workforce if we can't provide a a a education system that's appropriate for people coming here to work I mean they're just not going to do it and I think all that is you know it's a bundle of things that you have to do but you can't you you have to prioritize what I think are the most important things and again it's like you can't
050get the cart before the horse you're not GNA get these big you know jobs if we are not prioritizing the most important things to families and that's education and safety I think laws have been passed with good intentions like uh that 16y old he was talking about in order to keep them in schools somewhere down the line the legislature said okay you can't get a license you can't drive unless you're in school yes is that something you think should be changed that if a student is not in school U that may be like other states we allow them to participate in the workforce or somewhere else or within their family and be able to obtain that driver's Li the movement is to see CTE you know Community Technical education anyway so if he's not interested
051the academics and he can get into a job where he gets some training and some uh education some trade he would be better off there because he could be a productive citizen make a living for himself my big problem is when when that don't happen and I'm afraid that down the road with so many of them going to home schooling and stuff and us not knowing what level they're working on stuff that we're going to have a lot more of them that are un unable to provide for themselves that's a worry I mean I look at it from a past law enforcement experience and also as an educator and and uh it worries me you know you give Sol you give testing solidified education testing those students who are perhaps your more of your concerned
052that they're not getting an education are you seeing a big increase in their learning and outcomes on a a standarded test between the AG of 16 and 18 in school I know that I was the biggest pain a lot of people have this idea I'm the biggest now imagely terrible and you certainly didn't want me in your clom and that may be the case for a very small minority of our students and I can tell you that if you put one dangerous student not saying that dangerous one dangerous student in your classroom or in your school for every 200 kids you would change the culture of that school I mean you it is palatable when you walk through the door well you know one of the things again you know we talk about prior it's
053all about prior prioritization and people say we don't have the money that's the first thing you hear we don't have the money to pay teachers this way we don't have the money to pay you know law enforcement whatever I guarantee you if I went down that budget I could find multiple things that are nice to have but they're not they're not as important so when when I'm talking about prioritizing something I mean you may have to do without some nice to have things way down the bottom of that that state budget but if you're really serious about fixing the problems we have in West Virginia and make it a a a place where people want to come we already have I'm telling you we've already accomplished the fact that people love our state I mean
054we're getting a lot more people moving in I know the birth rate may be uh low but there's more people moving in the state of West Virginia per capita than anywhere else good so we've got that you know people know it's a great state great people but now we this is a prime opportunity for us to keep them here keep their kids here right and we're not doing it and again you know people want to talk about priori uh prior prioritizing things that are important and I will be the first one to say that education and and security are two of the things that people want and want to have absolutely and so that's why I think as legislators need to go up there I here yes sure okay I'm sorry I'm sure I interrupted
055at least one or two people there but I've been listening uh the whole time I couldn't get out there tonight and I told Missy that but um so I'd love to be there but I I tuned in promptly at 6:30 and I've learned a lot already but I just wanted to add a couple thoughts uh one uh to say that in my 10 sessions uh if you need the money they always find the money uh for for priorities so I'm going to end on what Scott Fuller just said which is uh if first of all this the first priority of government is the public safety so we we deal with that first but then you get to a fundamental constitutional right under our state constitution to an education for these children so uh I'm not
056saying we put the whole budget there but there uh there is money they're always they always find money leadership does it's a priority and thank you for letting me let speak to that thank you Mike that's That's Mike you're exactly right when they formed the state constitution public education was a big part of it yeah so it's in the Constitution as a priority so why don't we as a legislative body make these people Force us to make it a priority but that's going to take people from all it's not going we're not going to be able do it just ourselves it's going to take parents going and saying that we this is what we want because you may not be able to have this so and I think you know to build off that uh
057when we discuss making education priority uh we need to sort of clarify and Define what we mean by that and um oftentimes I've seen that in this discussion around education and educational leadership we hear talk of stakeholders and we hear talk of uh the educa of the business community and economic development and and all these things which are you know important things but I think we need to do a better job of collecting useful data and experiences from the students themselves because I think we're losing a little bit of sight of what that daily experience is like for Johnny or Susie and who is going back to mom or dad and saying you know what uh if there's any other option here I think I'd like to take it and I'm not really enjoying or
058I'm not really into what we're doing at school in this experience we need to better understand that I don't know if we have the tools right now in place to do that at the state level I think we need to work on uh quantitative studies and qualitative studies um you know I have a few things I'm working on to that effect but we need to get a grasp on what it's like in 2025 because we're still thinking about what it was like in I don't know for some of us you know 1980 whatever or 1970 whatever or you know you know but a lot of things a lot of things have changed a lot of times you know as uh as adults we think back to the times you know that we experience and that's
059what we compare things to and we make assumptions that children today are having a similar experience maybe they are maybe they aren't but I think we need to place a a greater focus on you know understanding where they're coming from totally agree with that but it starts with money right you gotta do you got to have money to do these things in order for you get money it has to be a state priority you know go ahead just to build on what Dr D meth if you want to build a traditional America you have to build a traditional adult and to build a traditional adult you must provide them a traditional schooling a traditional education a traditional moral compass and you know we speak of our state constitution and it does it does have uh
060public education written right into it but also has morality itself written into it and it points towards God now that may be a fine line to walk but we should certainly be striving to walk towards morality especially when it concerns our elementary students as someone may not be and if you have someone who has a moral compass that's a little out of whack if you have a child that goes to a school and sits there and sits under artificial lighting all day and Hears A bunch of just how do I want to put this that child may not be a happy child need to create happy children we need to have children that have traditional education they need to be able to enjoy their time at school they need to have recess they need to
061feel safe from their other classmates and they certainly need to feel like their teacher is Happy teaching them and they're not overwhelmed making individualized plans not not just for one student for perhaps 50 to 75% of the students in their classes we need to make sure that there's quality education for every child and if we're hitting numbers at 25% I'm concerned now I'm not saying that any of those students don't need an IEP but if we're hitting 25% of the general population and then we throw on a 504 plan on top of that are we potentially having teachers who 100 individualized plans that they have to make on a daily basis and how much time could they possibly put into the joy of teaching and pushing traditional pedy out until students you know um money
062is important I can tell you money is important but if we don't get the basics right we're not going to have anything besides a disaster and that's exactly what we've been going through for the last generation it's only getting worse and I may remind you that if you don't focus on what you want well it's very easy to focus on how we do things I think we need to focus on why we do things and make adjustments as needed if that makes sense I I I think the legislature needs to do what they can to fund the schools that the legislators need to find what needs to be taken away that's holding the schools back and I want way count I want all the schools to be the shining star of Education in the state
063of West Virginia I think that's where education needs to be uh it's written into Constitution but to Simply throw money at something and I just keep thinking that if I have 25% of my students with an i and possibly another 25% with a 504 I couldn't comprehend teaching seven different preps with that many modifications I don't think I can do $300,000 that Senator Senator this this is uh delegate Dylan um it if I might try to sum up what you're getting at there are you suggesting that we need to consider starting with the end of in mind and uh what the purpose of education is before we you know enact the next round of investment um or you know uh deploy more resources toward education that's exactly in a nutshell what I'm suggesting okay well
064here's my and I I'm not arguing with that but what I'm saying is all those things it's not just Financial when you're talking about about priorities it's not just the money it's prioritizing education whatever it's going to take now some of it's going to be money some of it's going to be you know further I don't know I'm not a teacher but you know it's all that encompassed it's you know people want to be quick to jump on everything when you say priority it means money yes it's going to take it's going to have to take money because you have to operate but that's not all it takes there's there when you when you're prioritizing something you give it all the resources you can and that comes from every and that's what that's a true
065prioritization and we are not doing that in state of West Virginia we look at Ohio and I you get tired of hearing the whole fact that Ohio's got great school systems but they're you know they got more money they got this and they got that they got a bigger population too I you know and there's a lot more kids there a lot more schools that they got to pay for you know we can't keep using that as an excuse to say that you know we don't have those re we don't have we don't have because we do we have to do without other things and but we can't keep using that as an excuse and expect everything to fix itself because it's not working and until we Department Front Street Ohio to reinforce your point
066doesn't have nearly as many tentacles hands on on public education system in Ohio they allow the teachers and they allow the schools to do their jobs our Department of Education has Department ever heard in my I don't know about I'm just saying it's it's all all I'm saying is we get compared you know to Ohio Pennsylvania you look at all those even Kentucky I mean you know we have got to make a decision as a state it to say we're we're tired of being down here at the bottom of the of the of the pile and when we've got good teachers we have great we got Marshall which is one of the best uh teaching education uh universities in the country it's right here in our backyard and we're letting those teachers walk out the
067door and go somewhere else North Carolina you know wherever and because we can't pay them what we can what other states can pay him and that's an important part of it so when you talk about financing when you say you're going to keep the teachers here one of the things we have to do we have to buy them the benefits that they deserve the pay that they deserve and they can walk right across the river and make a whole lot more money or go to Maryland you're talking about the Eastern Panhandle they can go over to Maryland or or Virginia wherever and make more money and so obviously to me that's not a priority we look at that and say well other other states are doing it and we can't keep using we have a
068lot less population than some of these other states I understand that but again we're going to keep spinning our Wheels until we make a commitment so that's what we want to do and that's going to be the launching pad for us to get economic growth to the rest of the state of West Virginia because we are right now um we're not in a position to be able to recruit these these businesses in here we're working on some of that stuff on this side of it but we have to get the the education part of it hammered out so I'm all for you guys I mean I'm gonna do you know what I can to to go up there and and hold their feet to the fire you're going to campaign on being education being a
069priority well then by God you're going to make it a priority because that's what I'm wanting to do it is a priority to me and I'm going to go up there and I'm G to you know top of my lungs I'm G to you know scream out that we need to make it a priority bet you they're going to say well we really don't have the funding let's go down that budget find Miss but are we trying to hit test scores are we trying to hit students who are not lashing out are we trying to uh get rid of some of this regulation I I go through regulation in the state that is so burdensome that I don't teach anywhere near as much as I have form are we going to pay the teachers are
070we going to take the students who are in danger out the classrooms are we going to go in and start giving kids recess are we going to have a traditional school or are we going to go straight into stem more computers and just haveed inside all the time and claim structural time is the most important well I think that's going to be decided have some studies as to what we want to do in the state of West Virginia and what the experts want to do and what the people Wayne County want do may be very different and I would side with the people of Wayne County over the experts any day we okay I want to interrupt here just a second we've got a parent that would like to speak and we have a delegate
071that would like to speak iocus [Music] brur I agree and that that is going to be that is a priority see that's the difference and that is a priority for us but here's the problem we you were recruiting team uh businesses to come here there's a lot of what they look at and as a police officer Denis could probably tell you the same thing I can remember businesses coming in coming to our Police Department wanting to look at the police reports what the crime rate was that was a priority for them see they have priorities too and if we don't meet their priorities because that's our job is to make sure these businesses we meet their priorities that's education and saf and I I'll just say this you know on the southern end of the
072county everyone knows what we've been dealing with and Senator Maynard's been working hard on this and I've been working hard on this you're not going to have businesses where they can't have reliable infrastructure like water that you know can be used in the business true and so you know that's a thing that that's a huge challenge that we need to address this year which doesn't directly pertain to education but it kind of does because you know you're a huge consumer of water first of all um you know secondly uh you know there's a meeting tomorrow morning um you know in Mingo County at the at the commission to you know for Mingo PSD to raise rates and um yeah yeah so half of Wayne County is going to be dependent upon that decision that comes
073out of Mingo County so that's where I'm going to be in the morning tomorrow I'm going have to take uh I guess time off work or whatever but um um you know things like that have to be in place because you just can't go out you know pitch into a company come you know we have water 30 weeks out of the year yeah yeah you know just bring a bucket there that's true you take for granted so yeah I understand the concern what what is a regulation or a piece of legislation or even just a rule from the board of education at the state level what can we take away to give you all you all seem like you're competent to be able to get this done right what is standing in your way that
074would allow you to do what you want without needing more money but just what are the hurdles that we could remove funding flexibility would be funding flexibility right our our funding comes earmarked in a lot of ways um you know different steps can only be used for different certain things and I know that there's one issue that we have later down as a question I'm not sure where it's at but the Step seven funding we're size of our County and stuff right now and Mr Alexander can explain it a little better probably I I know about it but uh the way that we're funded is uh student teacher ratios and whatnot so Tod I mean Mr char g if you don't care go ahead yeah that that's becoming more of a challenge so you have
075a you have a sheet in front of you that is the U PR up at the top it says preliminary computations Public School Support Program Personnel ratios per a thousand students and so um this this lists the entire State and then it gives you a state average at the bottom of the page so under the school funding formula for professional Educators um this uh indicates the number of positions that we will be provided per thousand students now we have approximately 6,000 students so you can take that number there for Wayne the 72.4 five you can multiply that by six and that would tell you how many positions they would give us now if you look in the second column the 8014 that's the number that we actually employ that we have on the books these
076are teachers these are these are professional Educators teachers counselors so the difference the difference between those numbers equates to about 45 45 positions um so that's about 45 positions that were out of formula that we have to pay for out of out of local tax dollars out of local tax Collections and then if you go on the right you see the service Personnel you see the ratios there and so the the oral schools I think I heard the news media report that there were more school closures this year than in reported history and ever and what's happening is what we were discussing earlier you have all these counties losing enrollment 51 52 53 you have all these counties losing enrollment and so they're trying to operate smaller and smaller schools under their under the funding
077formula but the funding formula is based upon your total enrollment it it's it doesn't separate them by school or anything like that so what happens is is if you keep these small schools open you go more and more over formula 85 to 90% of our budget is spent on personnel and the higher that we go over formula that we're having to pay for out a local tax dollars if you get around 90% or higher in in that in that number you're not going to be able to sustain so that's why you're seeing these districts have to shut down these schools so this year I had spoke with the board about Genoa and dunow which is our two smallest schools both are sitting with an enrollment approximately 50 or so um 50 students 50 students yeah
078two of the smaller schools in the state and um as we continue to and it's not so much about their enrollment as it's about the district's overall enrollment and again that's projected to go down for the rest of the decade just on birth rates alone not counting any other factors that we've discussed here this evening so if if that enrollment continues to drop it it's going to be financially unsustainable that we're going to have we're going to have to shut down those schools to be able to uh to keep the uh budget balanced so the question came up um during some of those meetings that we were having discussing those schools what could be be done with the state funding formula to help uh keep those smaller schools open if you look at the bottom
079of the page you see the State numbers and you'll see the actual net enrollment so the the average county in the state is has 77.9 five positions per a thousand students even though they're only being funded for 72.4 five the average has 77.9 five and then you see the numbers on the right for service the average the average county in the state is uh 61.5 service positions per per thousand students if the state funding formula was based upon the averages of the entire state that would make that would decrease our numbers over formula and would would make it um more likely that we would be able to keep smaller schools open repeat that just that last little part you just said the average numbers that are the state average it's based on the state average
080instead of the county average if it's based upon the state average in instead of just looking at each uh County independently if if the funding formula was based upon for example for the professional Educators if the if the number that they used was 77.9 five right instead of the 72.4 five that they're currently using right well instead of being 45 positions over formula we'd be about 15 positions over formula we can work with that say that's much more comfortable that's U doable that's yeah for us it's doable with County funding with our County levies and whatnot we can do that and whenever I started talking about this round table thing that was the biggest issue that that I wanted to address because the legislature can change that formula we've talked about it before it's ever
081gotten very far but when they see it as a Statewide issue hopefully you know with you guys up there if you'll advocate for that that maybe we can get that looked at as a Statewide and everybody will join in and see what we're talking about because you know I don't want to close duno and I don't want to close janola I want to keep them there as long as we possibly can but with the way that this the state has this funding formula set up it's putting a choke on us I mean it's just yeah and so the first column in each the one for professional again the state average 72.4 five for service Personnel that state average 54.3 for the more those numbers climb towards that state average than the more positions that that
082allows for us me how's it going to affect like um like a Hancock County you know say it's got 91 85 and some some biger it's going to help them as well it's gonna yeah it's going to drop their num numbers helps everybody yeah it would it would help every County regardless so basically it's going to be that per thousand no matter what county you're correct okay I've had this concern and and uh when we were're going to close schools a couple two or three years back you know when you close schools in a community like J or dun you're affecting that Community you're affecting the identity of that community and and everything else so it needs to be there but we need help so we can keep those little schools open right go ahead
083Senator I'm cut in and out's fault uh I understand to adjust the uh the equation so everybody gets more money I feel well first want our community schools to be open we need to have the Community Schools open for the community we don't need to have kids uh riding an hour and a half each way to school that's not productive and it just adds to the disciplinary problems there a multitude of reasons that we need to keep these schools open is there perhaps something that we can add into the law that focus on our community schools and that may come at a lower price tag you know to keep are at risk Community Schools in place and operating but maybe not changing that entire equation for everyone throughout the entire State now that it would
084hit every Community School throughout the entire state but it might come in at a lower dollar amount yeah understand the question you're posing I I don't have an answer for that um um if if I might to interject there um you know there there are a couple issues that that come into play here and uh one is I think the Department of Education uh when you go through and you look at their budget and I think last year was something like 4.2 billion something to that effect and um you look at all the different directions in which they divert money uh pet projects and and you name it and then they have the you know I'll just say the audacity to come and say well you need to shut down Genoa or you know you
085need to shut down dunlo because of a you know formula um when they need to recognize that that experience we were talking about just a little bit ago the student experience that is Central to um instructional strategy that is an instructional strategy to look at a student's daily experience in a particular school and try to understand how that impacts their overall Learning and Development and there's research out out there that indicates that in particular for lowincome uh communities consolidation impacts those completely differently from upper income communities and um students from those lower income communities they really struggle in the larger School sizes whereas students from the higher income communities don't struggle in fact oftentimes they do even better in the larger school if they're already starting out from the higher sces uh position so I
086said all that to say this that we need to put the onus and um give a mandate I believe to the Department of Education to reprioritize and reconsider the value proposition of these smaller schools so we're not putting all the burden on you know the counties to try to figure it out on their own and so that you know that's kind of my focus uh as it pertains to this and that's where my thoughts have been with we agree completely I mean that's one of our our I think we're probably one of the last counties with two schools that have 50 or less students in them you education unfortunately I don't have to sit through those meetings this year but but uh no I'm not on the committee but uh I'm working with people who
087are and people who aren't you know and we've been discussing uh ways to address this and um I think we can I think we can do a quite a bit without having to necessarily add any more financial burden to the state just working within what's already going to the Department of Education um I think we can are you by chance on the education committee I figured [Laughter] that I'm a little white because I come from an area of the county that my smallest school is probably a couple hundred students I believe probably Vincent one of the schools or Kell there a couple hundred students so do these schools they operate completely independently like my larger schools in the north they have principal secretary oh yeah yeah teachers for every grade and and there's only 50
088students well they got split grades some of them it kind of goes back to where when I grew up I went to a one room Schoolhouse for four right so we had four years grade and there was a bunch of us that ended up with college degrees and and things like that but you still had to have Administration there on the local scene janitors and janitors and you had to have a certain number of people to have the school there but if you take it away it's detrimental to that community and those students more than more over than and I know there's more administrative duties now than look I graduate I went first seven years in school I went to Wilson Elementary they closed it in 1968 we had about 50 some students then and
089a lot of them did very well later in life we believe look half a dozen years ago we gave considerate well it came up a proposal to consolidate Jano and dunow and I'll tell you how the vote went we were all against it we don't want to see those smaller schools close if we can avoid it if we get in a financial straight jacket we have no choice that's what we're trying to avoid and we're we're close we need help I think the rest of the nation is going back to what you're talking about right but as long as West Virginia's funding formula is this way yeah it I'm saying it's just going against what the trend is thing just like delegate Dylan said it's an experience for these people for these kids you know
090that's their home that's their Community that's their school and they identify there and that's guts out of the community if you close that school and when you do that you on scho bus longer each day going and coming which is a burden on them and the their family and the school system too so uh right there's Jus need to be dat I I think the legislature needs to take action because the State Board of Education they do things trying to please the legislature but they throw their own little things in there too you know uh that's another conversation too we can pass all the rules but the thing of it is follow they both all groups need to get together and come to some kind of understanding what's going to be the best let me
091address that point just for a second because that we've had that discussion this has been put out before the public like the legislature has no control over the State Board of Education when if you read the constitution of West Virginia it says they shall perform such duties as may be prescribed by the legislature it's very clear in black and white there and I'm not exactly sure how keep getting away with it to change state constitution that it's already in the consti allow Senator mayor the rule making Authority though doesn't have to come before the legislature so they can pass the rules and we have no say in it can you overrule over no no we have unless we legislated the next year St decises it's just it's just terrible story decisis [Music] theator correct how're
092proceeding he is correct but I would say that is horrific story decisis and how to get over that without an amendment is a different story but the senator is correct Virginia school system is probably the most regulated school system in the country yes but everybody has a fault in that you know the state board and the legislature and the courts right right they've all brought that something court rulings cause it state board to put out directives which burden the local counties it's a big mess it it needs to be worked out I think any uh any law which is passed is presumed constitutional unless it's challenged and overturned so I think you go ahead and I think you pass whatever you think is the right policy into code to enforce and then if someone wants
093to challenge it if the State Board wants to challenge it let them do so but you go ahead and you do the right thing first and then you deal with the consequences you lead we need leadership ched the Department of Education will have given the voters the reason to pass Amendment they will hand them the reason there's one final thing I wanted to mention I don't have a I don't have a suggestion or anything but I'll just tell you a problem that we're dealing with is that the construction cost per square foot on any construction projects that we're doing has skyrocketed right uh we we have went from uh we have went from $300 a square foot prior to the pandemic to our latest project that's underway right right now is over $600 per square
094foot um and we're getting ready to try to build a buffalo k through eight to keep that community school there and to put that Elementary replace that Elementary put it with the middle school and I'm worried to death about uh you know the the budget for that project you know we we we got a significant Grant from the state to do that project but we've got to make it fit within the budget and uh the the cost is uh is just crazy right now then you know so if anything comes before you while you're in session regarding that if there's anything you can do to help you know we're we're looking at some things ourselves to try to work on those designs to you know help get those within cost but if anything comes up
095like that just know it's a problem for us I'm sure it's been a problem for the County Commission as well very much so yeah now when you talk about is that done by like is are those jobs bid through State contractors do they have to have a be a a State Contractor to yeah they have to be licensed in the state of West Virginia well like like what I'm saying like federal government says you can't you can't purchase like you can't go out and get shair or a computer or something it's or anything even building things you know there are contractors that you have to that's why everything's so high in federal government when go to do things is the state are they burden by that or can you go out and get the lowest
096bid or not the lowest necessary but the best bid for like building a school yeah we're we're required to take the lowest bid as long as they have the um capacity to perform the job so you go you could go out there and and and choose yeah we advertise solicit yeah that's great because a lot of you know like the federal government you're bound by but a lot of times that's not a good idea either to go with the lowest bid no no that's I mean I'm just saying fromal govern that but with the state most qualified we State we do we have to go with what's the impus for consolidating the elementary school and the middle school is the elementary school ran down or something oh oh wow it's a what's the issueing or
097it's said flooding it's it's older I went to elementary school there yeah we had to do I can imagine that school flooding well it's kind of deceiving we we fixed it yeah there was drainage issues it's it's a me it's a metal panel on a concrete slab it was a temporary building that was put up that wasn't meant to be up near as long as you know it's just poor construction they need they need a new school it was our biggest need so we've secured some funding to do that and hope hopefully we can follow through get it finished is the kindergarten it I spoke with you like a few months ago the kindergarten not being used or is it over at the elementary school or the uh the they've had a loss of enrollment
098so they used to have a kindgarten building across the road right there was some danger with that so they moved the kindergarten over into the main building So currently it's being used by our technology people yeah the U but anyway keep that in mind I I do I do want to say that I want to brag about um the uh teachers and the and the staff and and service Personnel Wayne County Schools um if you look at some of the national ranking sites we're we're ranked 15th in the state of West Virginia out of 55 school districts and um we have actually our ranking right now is as high the only other time we were ranked as high was in 2018 and that repeated itself last year and know we've got a lot of work
099and as you know the education results in West Virginia aren't where they need to be so um what we're focused on is trying to get into the top 10 our teachers and our our principles everybody out in the school is doing a fantastic job and uh uh we're we've seen some good results and but we need to see better so everybody's focused on that but I wanted to let you know that your system here um is is doing a is doing a pretty good job and we're striving to do more they are working hard Mr superintendent I had a complaint that you guys don't have the flexibility to alter bus runs easily is there any truth to that uh the that's a Personnel law thing so once a run is Bid And established and again
100that's not my area I'm gonna I'm telling you what I know I can follow up with you on it once a run is better established it can any change you make to it can only be a certain length of time like let's say 20 minutes if if it impacts the route more than 20 minutes you can't do it now is that uh annually or how often can you yeah it would be annually if you would want to change the route you would have to go through the reduction in force process during Personnel season then you could eliminate it and then repost it however you wanted you can change it annually but to change it in the middle of the year is difficult unless it's a small change and so you do that annually I guess
101you you change them yes as needed yeah gentlemen we really appreciate you being here yes can I ask one more question kind of a question kind of a a request we have um any more our teachers the newer teachers that are starting I've I've introduced the bills before that when I was started we were able to save our sick time that actually meant something when we retired we could use it for years of service we could use it for insurance somewhere in between the time I started and the time I retired most of our teachers lost that Robbie I can still use mine I believe if I'm not mistaken I think it's if you were hired 2015 or later yeah uh you can't really use it for anything so my request for this delegation if
102you would to try to look into trying to get that bill moving that our teachers so we don't have the the massive amounts of absenteeism that we have because they get 15 days and it's kind of like you use them or you lose them so what are you going to do so I've had a bill for a couple years to convert uh unused sick dates to cash value um and that's that's something that's been asked of Me by teachers I used mine for years of service yeah yeah um there's no reason not to use them I me it's part of it's almost seen as part of your compensation package as uh Mr Ross said there I have a question we can get to and uh when let let me say this and then you ask
103your question if you don't care Mr or Senator Hart um one of the issues I've seen with that is uh particularly with administrators who might have uh you know hundreds of days uh but they can't get any cash value out of those days that they they've accumulated so what they do then is they may take off a year or two-thirds of a year and then you have a school without a a leader with a substitute administrator for the biggest part of the year and the school flounders now I'm not I don't I'm not speaking to any specific in you know situation Wayne or Mingo County I'm just saying that I've seen it and and they get leave while they're on that taking that time off they gain more sick times and so all those benefits
104just keep going and you can't hire anybody in their place right you're good to go Senator and that's don't blame an administrator for that at all if that administrator was my father I would encourage them to spend time with their family and get that cash um so that's that's a legislative that's a rule problem that's a disaster and that's not individual administrative Problem by any means anywhere it may happen it's happen across the state until it's fixed now dunow issu is kind of near deared my heart as I was a victim of consolidation and after graduation my principal was brought up to me or my former principal that almost all their disciplinary issues came from a certain school that had been Consolidated which made perfect sense because it was made up of a different culture
105with different needs that were not being addressed as specifically within a classroom so kind of BL out to the entire school now of course I was part of that student body that was Consolidated in the problem um but we weren't a problem when we were in our area we weren't a problem when we in our community so it's it's a whole other bag of worms or can of worms that I think the Department of Education is too blind to see so my question is and and I don't expect this anytime you know this week or anything like that is outside of just changing the overall formula for the the schools and everyone's school for the teacher funding formula you all could look at or I don't want to give anyone a big job here that
106they're not an expert at but I feel like the superintendent's probably an expert at this if you could look at some cheaper ways that we can save our community schools be that Wayne County mdow wherever they may be across our state that we can allocate some teachers and some resources and some Administration that would be um widely accepted or at least widely enough that we can get this through I know that Senator mayard has been working uh to try to keep these schools and we want to keep them we want to keep them so if plan a doesn't work maybe if we have a plan B right there ready to go uh that could be a little bit cheaper for the state to manage especially as we're looking at some shortfalls um greatly appreciate because
107if I sit down and get plan it may not be anywhere near thank you thanks for the offer absolutely all right anyone else well thank you again for thank you bringing your I think we we had a great discussion and may not have solved a a lot of problems but at least we're headed in the right direction addressed we're all on the same page so I appreciate it yeah appreciate all of you coming to your evening with us you know what before you adjourn okay I got a suggestion and I've attended a meeting like this in Mercer County and they will look at the code and see the problem that is affecting them and it helps instead of just telling us your problem to actually find it in the code and then you do your
108own Bild drafting you draw a line through the portion of the code that you don't like you add in what you do like Mark can probably attest to this do that it help help can we affort you committee to do that Mark that's a great idea yeah because that way you know because we at least from my perspective the more you can help me to help you then right I think the better off we are because I think everyone here is wanting to help and make us make us I think that's great idea thank you all right very much we want to Jour Mark oh Mark made the motion second oh you need to beat you sorry I don't know beat me to a Jour all in favor anyos motion carries zero thank you Senator
109har it's nice meet you I'm sorry you didn't get to speak up more you had big mouths Like Me Oh shot I'm so sorry