CorpusRecord 2654

NHCS Board of Ed. Policy Committee Meeting | Feb. 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / New Hanover County Schools
Date
2025-02-12
Location
New Hanover County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,754 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-05-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I send it to weather ch e e e good afternoon all Welcome to our policy meeting uh glad we have everybody here we have two uh I'm going to point out two superstars we have with us today miss May uh thank you for being here uh from Castle Han Elementary School and our principal of the Year Mr Hall from Winter Park so thank you guys for being here and giving us your input uh Mr Hall well the three of us have been together for days now so tomorrow hopefully we'll see you again but we have turnaround task force hopefully some going to be there with me but uh very good um I do have a policy uh adjustment I need to make so um I I don't see Miss Justice here quite yet but I

002will be bringing that up just to let everybody know during the uh after the pledge uh at this point M keski would you please call the role Mr Pete wior present Mr David Perry present Miss Judy Justice all right very good uh at this point we will have our invocation welcome hey good afternoon everyone my name is Inu gang I'm currently serving Ricefield United Methodist Church as an associate pastor it is my great privilege to get to lead us in prayer today let us go before God In Prayer holy and loving God thank you for giving us this new day and we give thanks for this Gathering and for the opportunity to serve our community Through leadership and decision making as this committee Miss to shape policies that impact students Educators and families we ask

003for your wisdom and a spirit of collaboration May the conversations held here be guided by fairness and a shared commitment to the well-being of all students Grant patience in listening Insight in deliberation and a deep sense of responsibility in every decision made bless the Educators who dedicated themselves to teaching the families who entrusted their children to this school system and the student who are growing and learning each day may this work contribute to an environment where all can Thrive we ask for your peace your wisdom and your strength to continue to the good work in Jesus's name we pray amen amen thank you very much um actually miss justice has turn to the pledge her options I will go ahead and Lead that I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America

004and to the Republic for which it stands one under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you and thank you very much thank you for being here today we will carry on uh again the adjustment I do need to make uh this is from the fall um it was brought to my attention uh today that the uh we have two uh policies with the exact same number uh two different things one of them was just passed in February 4th um we have 5150 which is reporting to external agencies and also 5150 relationship with colleges and universities uh the propos the ncsba has proposed US changing reporting to external agencies to 5160 uh I'll will make that motion all right I okay first and second uh any further discussion if not not all in

005favor of changing the reporting to external agencies policy to 5160 please signify by saying I I I all oppose that carries two Z carries two Z all right carrying on hello Mr Justice how are you I I I stole your thunder I I pledge so you will pledge next month okay defin okay um at this point uh we have I would entertain a motion to approve the agenda like make a motion to amend the agenda amend the agenda yes sir uh add discussion of policy 3620 3620 I'll second that any discussion okay we'll put that down as e 3620 let's vote on it first before I put it down uh all in favor of uh adding policy 3620 to our discussion and I believe we do have that paper work in front of us extracurricular

006activities all in favor please signify by saying I I at all poos like sign carries 30 so again we'll add 3620 to e uh again now I will entertain a motion to approve the uh amended agenda so motion uh I will second that any discussion hearing none all in favor please signify by saying I I I all opposed okay we'll carry on with that uh approval of the minutes uh I would entertain a motion to approve the minutes so move thank you ma'am I'll second that any discussion all in favor please signify by saying I I all opposed again par carries 30 we are on fire today guys I like this keep keep it going um let us start with policy 2010 board and superintendent relations going to lead this discussion is that correct if

007that's all right I would look for that too so we have done so much work over the past 6 months sort of talking about what board governance is and what school operations is and I'm on page 17 yeah no kidding right because I took me a long time to get Do It um and so what I wanted to bring to the policy committee and then back to the full board was sort of a information for you guys to help us decide or kind of solidify what those roles are so this is something we developed a few months ago but I wanted to bring it to you guys for discussion and sort of review before I brought it to the full board and it since it's a tie so tightly to this policy policy seemed like

008the best place to bring it just to help me kind of in my new role sort of grow into where the lines drawn to make sure that I'm making sure that I'm staying on my side of it and to help you guys determine uh what the appropriate behavior of a board is versus as a superintendent and help us all work together better so I just wanted to bring it here and let you guys get a look at it and see whether or not you could see anything that you wanted me to look at or change or adapt to it m Justice do you have any recommendations for this I'll start with it's always nice we have with us well this is pretty much things we've gone over I'm blessed or whatever we Haven been on

009the board before and have gone through this Poli this policy in other times um I mean we have pretty much worked it to where it is today I guess that what you're what I'm saying is if you're bringing changes or thoughts to it please do no not changes actually I'm just hoping to solidify what's going on so well right now okay well it was it's been yeah because it really feels like it's been a very collaborative sort of back and forth and so I wanted to make sure we solidified it in a way that quite frankly I've shared this with other superintendents because they've been like how do you um your board is working so well together how do you guys work so well together so I was sort of putting this together sending it

010to other folks so I thought it would be something you guys wanted to see as well okay um I just have one question I I generally like this um a lot um just about the Strategic uh plan um I I've I've asked a bunch of people and nobody could really tell me what the process was for us to update the Strategic plan so um and that's a really good point because I had updated yeah because right now our strategic plan generally runs for five year cycle and this one I think is till 2027 team is that correct and so normally every year we bring you an update to it and I haven't done that as of yet but I think it's a it's really the time now to talk about do we want to change

011anything in our strategic plan for next year add something to it so I think that's a good part of that question it's where does that live and how often do you guys sort of refresh it and look at it again and does that go through policy does it go how how does it mechanics of it works right right and I think every school system sort of does it their own way um it's sort of like when I was a principle The school Improvement plan this is our school Improvement plan right it's it's the the district guide for that um I certainly can now what we were doing for a while was bringing one strategic goal every couple of months to the board to to kind of review I've been trying to cram a lot of

012that stuff into my superintendent comments I think it's a good question for the board is how do we want to is that something we want to look at during our Retreat is that something we want to sort of talk about uh a pulse check on where we are on those goals I think those are all good things I think you know my thought on that would be you know the retreat are good I don't want to put too much on the retreat so you know you get water down where you have 15 minutes talk about something as important as strategic plan you did steal my thunder though CU I was going to mention that it was just like it is a living breathing document it needs to be it needs to be changed as you

013know throughout you know the seven to five years we have and you know and if the board as a whole feels like we need to go this way or do that or tweak this or whatever else I think that that is I mean that you don't want to put something as we as I did when I started as a principal long time ago you know we had the Strategic or the school Improvement plan and we we did it we really worked hard on it brought everybody together and then put it on the shelf and next year you P it back down we need it needs to be a living working document that we can continue to uh the board has refreshed twice since that was put into place and superintendent has changed as well the

014chief academic officer has changed the HR person has changed oh my goodness so it's and I would ask and if we could ask our two principles I I saw you you look like you want to say something so you okay I'm sorry did you guys have any any inputs you know on on the Strategic plan at all okay all right sorry okay I thought I thought I had that were you on the board when we did this mhm okay so you know how much work went into it oh yeah and it was a community and and District driven plan it wasn't just one stakehold it was everybody so so we started off with a really good basis if we do want to look at changes sure sure and I try to weave it into some

015things like every time we've done one of these budget superintend budget party meetings we've brought that down off the wall and specifically said where does this go fit into this when we look at our department budgets next week that's going to be what we're using as our guiding Focus as well like where does this fit into these these plans so certainly if if that's what we decide to do I can certainly tee up like a a state of the union for the Strategic plan for the budget retrieve sorry the Border treat that's good idea I'm G to write that down so I don't forget it and all of you are writing that down as well good call is there any other discussion about policy um where am I policy 2010 if you guys are comfortable

016with me bringing it to the full board and sort of we can put it as an addendum to the policy or it's just going to help me make sure that I'm running the district in the way that we're still staying as collaborative as we are maybe you know not necessarily A Den but maybe more of a how we you what is it called you know the like a procedure procedures yeah procedures underneath it see you're not really ask tring amendments to this policy so not really I just wanted you guys to see it before I brought it to the full board good idea so you guys could give me feedback or think about it before I brought it to everybody and just seemed like this would the right place to bring in which you really

017put like a reaffirmation or something I guess so or more of like a let's put some solidifying the the lanes together okay thank you all right next we have policy 2610 which is on page sorry page 20 all right and uh main points here to discuss the duties and responsibilities of the board attorney specifically with regard to when they are contacted by a board member to propose an amendment to the policy that states that every board member must be informed uh of the question and response within 24 hours um prior to the board committee meeting whichever comes first or I think well I actually made I just added that sentence to the original one if I want you you two want to you know I pass it out to anybody if you would mind would

018you like to pass this over that way to Mr Perry you and basically his arms out the the sentence that one that someone asked to be put in there um was every board do you want to read the whole thing we don't have to read the whole thing but the sentence that they wanted to add to it was that every board member must be informed of the question and response within 24 hours of prior to any board or committee meeting which ever comes first and this is referring to a question by a board member to uh our Legal Services separate from going to from the Chairman's discussion uh we have yeah go ahead do you have a so what what happens if if there wasn't a response or if the response was I got to

019look into it well then that's what they need to convey any that's a communication that's the whole so then again when they actually respond after you do your research and you get back to them then you say it again oh yeah this is what I figur it out yeah is that what you're saying the whole point is a response the response say I got to look into it that's a response I'm going to ask our attorney what your thoughts on that I mean it's it's the board's um call on this I'll tell you um one thing that you may want to keep in mind is is that if I start doing this and it comes to or any board attorney starts doing this and it comes to routine policy matters that people are being asked

020about for example tobacco policy change and I'm that's not the greatest example of it in the in the world but the response on something like that would be a public record um you know it would be something that would be subject to the public records act it's a little bit different from the ordinary type of attorney client privilege legal advice you give that would deal with say a litigation matter um I'm trying to think of a a a an easy way to do this so that we don't feel like that we're working in the post office um and trying to meet every policy in the world by responding to everything like that I don't know if there's a you know particular form is not an email list um for example might be the best way

021to do it I I prefer not to put things in writing like that very often for that very reason it becomes subject to a public records request um and sometimes people don't want that but that's a that's a decision for you guys as board members to make we can live with it either way okay I mean it's you know it's what you want to do so to clarify if this passes what you're saying this would be subject to the uh Records request open because you're conf you're conveying it to all seven members of the board yes ma'am some of the things now you know for example if you were to pick up the phone and ask me hey where does you know we have a a slip and fall at one of the schools where

022does the lawsuit on that stand or where does the disciplinary action for so and so or this hearing that we've got coming up for a student reass assment things like that obviously those would not be public records because there are other reasons that they're Exempted from the public records laws but just general policy questions would be now they are already um but all of the questions and answers that that we give typically don't come up because many of them are verbal um I'll give you an example somebody asked me last month about um the change in emergency board meetings in remote attendance whether you could vote or not at one of them and that's the typical kind of question we get you know sometimes I'll say hold on let me take a look and I'll

023call you back in a few minutes about it to go take a look or sometimes you can answer it right off the top of your head but that's the typical kind of response it's nothing um shocking or anything like that now we do sometimes get ones that deal with Personnel matters mhm um to or U you know because we're going through some um of a change with the superintendent hunt and all those you know there were a whole lot of U questions and answers that we probably would not have wanted to be reduced to writing um for you know everyone to to see because that kind of defeats the purpose of it but that's Personnel matter anyway so that wouldn't that would be subject to right that that would not have been it would have

024been exempt for another reason um I mean it's it's like I said a sure choice now you know I'll tell you the the typical drill we have and I think I've repeated this I I don't know if you I know earlier on I had said it my view of it is we don't keep secrets from people um about what we get called about if someone else calls and ask asked hey did so and so talk to you or ask you about X Y and Z I don't mind telling them now if if it's a personal gripe about someone else another board member well someone said was a jerk at the last meeting obviously we're not going to repeat that but the policy type questions the the board business questions yeah we do um you know

025and there's some board members who call more than others um but uh it's it I will tell you that has dramatically decreased since August September maybe and I think part of that is because of the you know the the um relative calm we've had in the superintendent change over and all that that was a pretty chaotic time um but yeah we get dramatically less calls now at least I do um I the ones that I get are primarily Dr Barnes which wouldn't be covered by this policy because that's not a board member um but most of my communications now probably are with the chair I think it's important for us to know what um that there' be some kind of knowledge base of the the attorneys work for all of us and not just the

026chair and um so in addition to the change that we're talking about hear about responses I wanted to also add it uh in addition to get rid of um everything from on the third paragraph from the chairperson of the board normally will decide for board members when to seek legal advice Etc um I think we should all have a right to contact uh the all of us board members should have a right to contact our attorneys um but I do believe in transparency so I think there should be some kind of a if not a email or maybe some kind of a documentation if you have a verbal communication with them I mean a one or two sentence summary is good enough I mean unless they unless somebody asked for more I mean I I

027don't want you to have to spend an hour writing down a complete summary of what what you told somebody over was a phone um but some ideas that is a concern I will tell you that is a concern it takes it eats up time and time is money on it um just as a practical as an administrative way of handling that um it would almost be easier I would almost suggest that you designate two people um to other people uh that you want us to call to tell I mean and I don't care who they are it's just that that way you realize you know you're guaranteeing one that other and standing designations are fine but you know I I um my assumption is there's a concern about U some people aren't aren't finding out

028or some people maybe aren't being told and frequently I I I don't mean to hurt anybody's feelings by saying this that's CU they don't ask um but you know that's one way to to deal with that without creating this monster of having to sit down and type things up all the time um whenever I get a quick phone call about something um but that's just my take on it I you know it's I go back you had said something in there and then are you making yeah I'd like to make a motion to um uh amend the motion to add Miss Justice's um uh changes to add taking out everything from the chairperson of the board normally in the third paragraph all the way through uh all the way to um get out individually with

029the attorney period that that sentence two sent three so you're saying just make sure I'm understanding correctly chairperson board normally will decide for board members when to seek legal advice or assistance on school matters if an individual member of the board desires to consult directly with the attorney the board member must notify the chairperson of the legal information is sought legal assistance is necessary has not been sought previously for the matter the board member will be directed to consult individually with the attorney correct y whole second all right is there a second on that let's go to that one well do a second so we can have a discussion okay a second first and second all right why don't we discuss that part first we'll come back to all right like to discuss that section

030do I get first go ahead yes sir go ahead I I just again I just believe that this is um the board attorneys work for all of us uh I think from what I was understanding by talking to miss Justice this is something that was put in the previous board I don't think there should be Gatekeepers for our attorneys we we're all equally elected uh and members and we should be able to consult with the our board attorneys without getting Mission first so um that's where I'm coming from on this as far as but I do believe in transparency afterwards that so that's my my my rationale for wanting this language talk and I'm going I'll next with M but I would say the only concern I have with this is the fact that we

031end up you know we sit there and have time and say well the attorney CL too much and actually our new attorneys don't cost us too much but um you know they cost us way too much but you know and I mean you know honestly every time you pick up the phone and say Hey you Mr blch should I have a concern you know U then it becomes you know that you know the clock starts so it's kind of that something we have to keep it in the back of our minds that you know we we do pay a lot of money for our attorneys and might very knowledgeable folks but you know it will you know the money's got to come from somewhere well and I'll tell you attorneys or an overhead expense like

032the light bill or the water bill and it's job to minimize it um I I don't I I'm happy when people I don't mind I don't want to use the word happy because sometimes I groan when I get the phone calls but um I don't want anybody to be discouraged from calling but at the same time there is a you know you as a board um do kind of need to um control how much because you know it is a product that people are using on that section okay well I was here when they they put that section in about the chairperson controlling it the gatekeep and roll and and that was a gatekeeping roll intentionally um you could do compromise of notify the chair and then they can just and what your concern is

033and then they can and you you should have the open communication with the chair and then they could disseminate whether or not this question has been asked before but the chair doesn't have the ability to say no you can't call them or whatever I mean that would sort of be a compromise because the chair should know what's been going on and say well somebody already ask and this is what happened so they don't have to make the call I think that's a real practical part of that section but whereas the gatekeeping section was put in there intentionally and I remember all that was going on at the time and it was very it just added more to more dysfun at the time more dysfunction on the board uh sadly that was under the that's s

034it was under the previous EV from our perspective it would if we or report in about every you know the inquiries we get it would make it easier to designate hey you need to either call you need to call the chair um every time you get an inquiry from someone other than the chair and let them notify everyone else that that makes it easy that's one phone call I got to make you know one and and I it's like that or I may be talking to them later in the day um that way I think I talked to U Miss Mason earlier today very briefly but it might two or three days you know three or four days sometimes a week between when we speak so I I think I I I think there is

035a legitimate concern here that somebody could overuse the attorney or um but I think that that that's that's s I'm assuming records are kept when you talk to me or anybody else uh and and those show up somewhere in the bill and or maybe a report that we get um and if somebody if one board member is monopolizing your time or spending all kinds of sorts of time that might be time for the chair to investigate and put limitations or curb or have a little chitchat with a board member like hey you're costing us a lot of money um but I don't think that could be something after the fact I don't think you need to then if you see the abuse then deal with the abuse if you using way too many hours then

036the chair can deal with that problem after the fact and try to curb it I don't think we need this whole checkin with the chairperson thing before we before you're allowed to talk if there's a problem they can deal with it later if they're using it too much that's my conern is there any sort of situation about the fact that you're the attorney for the board not for individual board members is that a thing at all because I think we need to remember that as individuals you don't have really any The Authority you have as a board and that is certainly true I want to and I'm going to try to stress this to people even though we're called the board attorney technically my my client is the agency now as a practical matter that

037means my client is the board but my client is really the agency not the board so if all of you guys collectively say decided that you were going to take a million dollars and go to Las Vegas is you know I would have to report you because my client is the agency not the board um and I use that strange example just because that's you know that illustrates who my client is um so you're right I and I am answering to board members but my duty does not run to a board member or even collectively the board it's the agency um so and I I suspect I probably harp on that too much that your duties as board members run to the agency and the agency only um so not students not teachers not voters

038the agency and that's what you took the oath for and I'm kind of in the same boat with you I serve the agency I just report to you well at this point let's go ahead and vote on the amendment that Perry brought up then we'll vote on the uh amendment that was justified so uh all in favor of leaving the word or adding the words deleting the words that's uh from the chairperson all the way to the attorney uh would you please callot roll Judy what say that one more time okay let me read the whole thing so so totally clear all we're voting on now is whether to delete the words the chairperson of the board normally will decide for board members when to seek legal advice or assistance on school matters if an

039individual member of the board desires to consult directly with the attorney the board member must notify the chairperson of the legal information to be sought if it is determined the legal assistance is necessary and has not been previously sought previously on this matter the board member will be directed to consult individually with the attorney so we're just talking about that deleting that section right now Judy Justice delete it so you're saying yeah yes no Pete wero yes David Perry yes okay so that passes 30 all right and then the second section uh this is every board member must be informed of the question and response within 24 hours or prior to any board or committee meeting whichever comes first are we still on discussion on this yes um what's the question from Blanchard um if

040that were to say 48 hours or or prior to a a board committee meeting whichever is first would that help you yeah but also it would yes yes s you know again it would the easiest route would be to designate you know every question that comes from someone other than the chair has to go back to the chair or you know I have to tell them and have them tell you um that that makes it easy that that keeps me having one person to report to at any given time now I realize that you have individual board members have different concerns they may think well if chair doesn't tell me that they get a phone call um and and and I hate to say let me play Devil's ADV could say last night at 10:00

041a board member called Mr Blanchard and said hey we got a question about blah blah blah blah does that mean that you would have get on the phone at 8:00 this morning and call all the board members because it says whichever comes first so I'm concerned about that whichever comes first cuz that would put them in in a precarious position if you know if Pete wbore called you know Mr Blanchard last night about a question about policy committee and I happen to get him at 8:00 last night you know now we're saying that well before the today's meeting he would have to stop everything else he's doing and contact us all or contact Miss Mason and have her contact well I mean that to me that that puts us in in a you know kind

042of puts us in a shoe box here you know that's which you know like I say prior to any board or committee meeting so that means there' be many of time that that we're going to put Mr Blanchard or any of his colleagues in a in a shoe in a shoe box that you know they have to stop everything they're doing and get on the phone call everybody um you I think I think we need to have some flexibility in there um yeah so I mean I think the I I think the idea behind the before the meeting thing is just so somebody doesn't get sandbagged okay so um you know and this can happen and we um and so oh oh you know all of a and then the person that they who's on

043the opposite side of being sandbagged doesn't know what the legal opinion that the other person just saw and and puts them at a competitive disadvantage when it comes to the actual meeting um so I mean I think just everybody wants to it to be fair play here so um the so uh that's my only concern uh whether it's 48 hours or or before the meeting or you want to put some kind of Reserve clause in there in case situations like you just mentioned that's fine but um I mean sometimes we could do it expeditiously because the the language now just doesn't give a timeline whatsoever maybe you know maybe maybe you know I would I would you know speaking for myself again not for anybody else but maybe every board member must be informed of

044the question response within 28 24 hours and just leave it at that you know and yeah you that would take care of the situation or 36 hours whatever you want to say but that would they you know that way they're that we would all be informed but it may not be you know within 8 hours or 12 hours if if there's a board meeting coming up you know in case somebody say somebody called them right before a board meeting you know what he you know I ha say it you know you know say Miss Mason called you know Mr Blanchard on the way to the you know to a Board of Education meeting happens all the time by the way yeah and says hey I got a question about blah blah blah blah you know

045how you know we're putting our attorney in a situation like he's got a you know what how how would he fulfill this and if we're putting something in writing that we're saying you have to do you know there's no flexibility in here so that's what my one of not one of my concerns with this but I mean it's a situation like I say Miss Mason calls him on the way over hey I got to go over some three or four important things with you how is he gonna you know how is he going to do that yes sir is that something that you could if if you got the call like on the way to the meeting is that something you could just disclose at the beginning of the meeting so that everybody knows and

046that happens from time to time if if you really want to know I mean it it I'll get a question and run over and tell the chair right before hey I got a call that blah blah blah you know this is what I what I told them um one thing that may help in a short notice situation I mean if you want want us to send an email out to just say hey we got a question from board member X about why come talk to me when I get there then you know what we're I mean you know what we're talking about and I don't have to put what the response was in writing every time because a lot of times you know there'll be a fairly lengthy response on something well here's a factor

047here's a factor here's a factor and I mean you know that's like wri in a book chapter um to to you know tell people what got said um I think the topic may be a bigger concern to address the legitimate concerns of board members hey we want to know what what's being discussed I'm happy to say you know here's you know got got a question about this topic um if you're interested call me and find out I'm pitching that out as a as a possible um that's not really policy language that's an interpretation one way to to get that done you know what I mean yeah and a lot life is a bad interpretation I mean truly um the whole reason for this was because it can be abused we've discovered sadly I I hate

048to see people using these kinds of behaviors is on our team but this stuff does happen and it has been since I came on another board in 2018 so this is just basically to to try to waylay people's behav Behavior not doing this and and you know there are ways around and I totally see what you're saying but he is offering an opportunity to to do a workaround on what you're concerned about well I I would you know I'm going to make a see you made a motion so you're amended so I can't I Would S my suggestion I'll say it that way um why don't we let Mr Blancher and I work together on you know seeing the best way we can go use this the wording we have deleting that section uh and

049bring it back to our next policy meeting it's not something that's got to be done I don't think today or tomorrow and that way there we can bring it to the whole the whole board after that I don't think there a maor p point of order yes sir so are we going are you suggesting that we vote on uh at this point just deleting the section that I that I made the motion on and we agree to or we just saying uh table in the whole discussion I would say table the whole discussion bring the whole instead of bringing it to my my thought answer your question Mr Perry is I mean instead of bringing it to the whole board and then bringing it to the whole board the second month in a row with

050other changes why don't we get it the way we want it as a policy committee and then we can bring it to the whole board um at one time instead of having you know us have policy 2610 for our March meeting and then have it again for our April meeting why not let's get it EXA right we'll vote on it in our March meeting and then bring it to the is that okay M all right I make that I make that motion second okay all in favor I I I okay Mr chair could I add one yes sir just as a practical matter in the interim before this is cleared up if any of you have looking at the policy as it's written right now if you'd like for me to send out an email

051just to say hey I got a call about X and if you want to know what's going on you know you want to find out call me that's that's fine me that' be good that's fine now that that will I um that that will solve the now I'd prefer not to do that with with the chair's situation because the chair you know is is the person I'm supposed to be talking to and I don't want to report every conversation I have with whoever the chair is but I'm talking about other board members what until we actually change it wouldn't that be a violation then no you've got you've already got it in here that that you know if it's determined that legal advice yeah yeah I see what you're saying yes yeah I'm I'm trying

052to I'm trying to I can't you guys you understand that when I get a phone call I'm going to answer your phone call unless I'm directly told by the chair not to or you um that puts me in a ticklish situation but it's not a ticklish situation for me to Pipe up and say hey everybody ask called about this that's a legitimate expectation from other board members to to be privy to what the other person right that's already in that part's in there m one question I get to you Mr Mr should I would that be you and I or Mr KY and I who I I'm I'll I'll speak with you I I I do a lot more board work than he does so far okay we'll leave all right but you're no different

053from any other public board and you know that from being on another one it's same you get the same issues everywhere oh yeah in different forms so as you know I over the weekend I sent our next topic which is uh 4320 okay copy of that o over to you uh or actually to Mr cromy Excuse me uh and oh could you have a look at this so I guess I technically didn't go through the chair so I guess I'm in violation but well I told the chair about it an hour again okay so let's go ahead uh with that in mind so again just to make it official we voted to keep policy 2610 in committee we'll discuss it and bring it back to the March meeting to um vote on so we got

054that there next we have the policies um uh 4320 and we're going to combine the two of them uh 5026 and 7250 uh we'll start with Mr Perry Mr Perry yeah I I I just thought this came through as an ncsba some minor adjustments but uh but the adjustments kind of really conflated the word the towards tobacco product and do all gamut of things that no necessarily contain tobacco which I thought was poor language uh and confusing and uh I don't think substant uh any of the changes that I'm proposing here changes anything that what we our policy uh other than maybe explicitly you know um making sure that uh you know stop somebody can use nicotine patch or hinges if they're trying to quit smoking or um and then there was one on the

055uh uh excuse me uh let make sure I got that this is the student one and on the uh 5026 there was I put one thing in because um on on 5026 number one at the bottom I I mean if somebody's going through a security thing they say to your pockets I don't think we should be considering that a display of of of of product if if they're forced to take it out you know I don't want them violating policy simply because the security guy told them to empty their pockets but um other than those two things everything else I believe in here is just um part for the course it's just using different language and you know differentiating between a nicotine product a a tobacco product and a vaping product so thank you sir

056um I'm going to look to my legal counsel because they we also met and talked about it so right I was going to say we when and for the other two board members we had a discussion about that the other day and I think everybody and and from speaking with Miss Mason earlier today I think everybody's on the same page and Dr Barnes had mentioned this we want to make sure that this policy you know it's not just cigarettes that we're trying to stop with this it's those I think you use example of Zen or one of those packets actually Mr KY did yeah right those things um Dr Barn pointed out to me that it and my computer's moving slow now but um CBD and um like Delta 8 Delta 9 products those gummies

057and everything they're already covered by um our drug policy um even the ones that are not considered um controlled substances are already covered it covers specifically THC container and CBD containing products so that was the the issue I I really like I thought the edits you had were good edits um one minor thing on the um the um comment about a FDA approved smoking secession product you may want to just add in that um you know as prescribed by a physician or something like that you know I think you're you mentioned a concern that um you know people will sometimes wear three of those patches or whatever or you know patches that aren't there that they shouldn't be you know having um that's not the doctor's advice way of doing it so and that does

058you know that does raise concern like even with the nicotine gum you know if I'm using to get rid of get off smoking that's that's fine but if I'm using it to get a little euphoric thing going on that's a different situation again I'm going to look over at our principles what are your thoughts on this whole situation any thoughts at all I know we have two Elementary folks here so I don't know that there's a lot hopefully not yeah I would disagree with that Miss Justice I'm totally agreement yeah I'll be listening to all of this I make a motion sir I I'll motion to amend uh both uh 4320 and 5026 uh section under definitions in nicotine product which are the same in both um uh the last sentence of nicotine products any2

059any pres doctor prescribed FDA approved smoking sensation product that contains should not be considered nicotine product adding the words doctor prescri prescribe and I almost have to think about that because what you know then then we open the door if we say doctor prescribed what about if a PA describes sub prescrib medical provider medical provider I think that's might be better sounds good to me okay all right so that's a motion I will second that all in favor please signify by saying I I I all oppose that carries 30 so that will be uh amended the amended policy will be brought to the board for next uh in March point of order yes sir I think we have have to vote on the whole thing we just voted on my all right all right you

060all right sir let's vote Let's uh vote on 4320 bringing 4320 amended and 7250 to the full board all in favor please signify by saying I I I all opposed like sign passes 3 to zero 7250 all right carrying on we have our addition which I got to go back here it didn't show my computer yes we have our addition at this point which is 3620 Mr Perry excuse me take your time oh we already got at the end well we have uh you know the policies for second reading but yeah we added this as e so um just trying to find my 3620 I know she included it yeah should be right here be top top is it right there under am I missing you don't have it here it is it's just hiding

061um [Applause] the reason I wanted to bring this up today is because um my original intent was has always been because I'm a big advocate of protecting the Free Speech rights of our students and um I originally was contemplating that some uh amendments to our display policy in order to explicitly um you know protect student initiation Free Speech however having having some discussions with other board members it it I concluded that there's a prerequisite problem that we need to deal with is if we were to open the floodgates for free speech for students we would actually actually as far as displays go that would also include student groups and so this is why I wanted to look at 3620 because we need to ensure that if we allow the free expression of our students students

062that is truly their free speech and they're not simply paring what uh somebody else is uh wanting them to say or coercing them to say so and then looking at 3620 uh one thing comes to mind which is under uh section B additional rules for specific activities and we have two sections one for school clubs and organizations which seem to be official ones and then there's student under three we have student initiated non-curriculum related student groups at the secondary level it seems from the school clubs that there is a sponsor and that sponsor faculty member has a lot of sway or at least not very many restrictions and whereas on three when you have a student initiated group it's pretty well spelled out that this person is there to supervise only and not to lead

063or coer or that it is a student uh truly student Le group um so I wonder why I'm I'm I'm here to ask Dr Barnes and others who can uh put some insight into it you know what why we have a different role and you know which kind of clubs do we have that are considered official clubs versus uh initiated because I just want to make sure uh that this is you know uh um there's not too much influence on the students free speech and that it's truly their speech and not somebody pursuing their political activism through our students Justice it's already in there uh if you're talking about the student initiated non-curricular related student groups at the secondary level right but number two above it doesn't have the same kind of restrictions number two

064student clubs and organizations is different oh you're saying you'd like to have that added to the student Club well I'm not sure I want some explanation okay I think part of the reason for number three is to make sure that we're clearly delineating the separation of church and state so some clubs may be generated by student interest but are not our staff can't necessarily lead those in the same way so clubs that are sponsored by the school are things like your your Beta Club or your um Student Government things like that non student initiated non-curriculum related clubs are your chess club or your lgbtq club or your something where the kids are initiating it but it's not sponsored by a staff member who can't sponsor things like this in the school building does that Mak

065sense I I'm just wondering because it seems like the definition of what a school club could be for uh is if you look at under two uh that it's um reading two number five number establish aims which are educational or of the school or Community interest I mean that could be almost anything in the community interest I think the three is in there to not limit kids from having clubs of their own interest I think that's what I think three is supposed to open the door it's not supposed to close it if that makes sense I guess my question if I'm hearing very correctly is why don't we have the same know second section of Section 3 and section two why would we have somebody that is going to leave you know basically what and

066What scenario would you have an employee that is you know in the Beta Club that's that's kids all working together yes there's a a sponsor that you know but they're not necessar you know bringing their own point of view on certain things to you know to to the thing it's supposed to be for the good the betterment of all the students but not you know I guess am I correct I I don't me to speak to yeah it seems like there's restrictions on three like you know School Employees may not promote lead or participate in student initiative meetings meetings but be present at meetings to maintain order and discipline protect the well-being but it doesn't say that of the sponsor for under School clubs and organizations it seems like they could just really lead it

067themselves well I I mean and and just to piggy back on that if I'm correct and I'll go toj this your hand um but you know say for instance the SBA you know I think SDA is wonderful I think it's a great group but you know if I was in charge of the SDA at blah blah blah school and I came in said well if you're not a Republican or you're not a Democrat you're you're horrible that would be wrong that would bead had but there's nothing in section two which would be under section two that would preclude a person from doing or is there yeah there there's several other policies that mandate that work 7,300 basically I think two is is sort of your and I'm I'm it's been a while since I was

068the principal um number two is sort of your school sponsored specific clubs three is to make sure that any kid with an interest can create a club they still need to have an adult there for supervision purposes but they're not there to run the the the in announcement Justice well basically I was going to repeat what you were saying like a lot of clubs like Beta Club Osa clubs and s clubs like this they already have their Charters and they have to follow those uh so they already have that instruction in place or that that Concept in place and specific sponsors and sponsor and requirements for sponsors and things like that sir if you'd like to know the the difference practically the Free Speech difference between number two and number three on school sponsored groups

069like that Spanish club the um Beta Club things like that the agency the school the government is actually allowed to direct what you know the content of their speech and what ideas they espouse you know the group does I mean the official position of the group on these other ones number three the ones that fall in there that'd be like Fellowship of Christian athletes for example might be one there um the concern that you had pointed out about the separation of church and state concern I think is probably the accurate way to say it that you're trying to um make clear that you are not compelling or coercing speech on those things that are not school sponsored official School groups you know so you're not going in and telling the um you know the the

070Muslim Students group hey you have to agree with X or the you know the Jewish students group that you have to agree with Y or the Fellowship Christian athletes that hey this is a better theological Viewpoint um so that that's the difference between the two the level of of government control over number two is allowed to be much higher higher than it is over number three over number three you have to be content neutral and just you know if you're going to provide a forum for one group there you know for the for the um you know for the snake handling you have to allow the let me give you a different example um every few years um there's Magic the Gathering or Yu-Gi-Oh there's a there's a club playing game that kids do Dungeons

071and Dragons things like this this just typifies that we can't say yes to one student group and no to another one here's the clear understanding of what we expect you to put forth someone to monitor it so supervise it but this opens the door and chalks the doors open to say any kid can make a club if he has a group of sponsor and and a way to support it so it it just allows more flexibility for the kids to do things that interest them that change over time do Mr per could you give us um a list of the different of school clubs and if any of them have a Viewpoint that they espouse when it comes to public opinion things that could be not necessarily religious but political or goalwise boy I'd rather

072not because that sort of says that no Ian far as our official clubs Oh you mean number two yeah oh okay I thought you meant number three I'm sorry uh yeah I don't yeah but that's I mean it's yeah okay I I mean obiously chess okay yeah apparently I have last year's yeah this Farm has left oh you're handy can you send that to the the board please thank you it's coming right now okay thank you so um so let's uh I guess uh you have my concerns I don't have I I'll look at those that you sent me I don't want to take up any more time on this we do have one more item um and but after after see what what groups What official uh groups number two uh that uh we

073have then uh perhaps we can table this discussion so can I make a motion to table this discussion until next month you can I'll second that we can pick it up thanks you got yeah oh yeah that's a nice thing any other discussion on tabling hearing none all in favor of tabling discussion on policy 3620 until our March meeting please signify by saying I all right I all oppos carries 30 so that will be held in committee I'll write that on here very 620 that's also for March okay that's done all right so our final second to final bit of business is policy 6129 anti-choking device has any board member gotten any uh feedback any emails anything that we'd like to discuss yes sir I don't have anything that I personally get but I I

074heard somebody say that that perhaps our attorneys had a some further uh few points on it I I I think Brian if you I was going to say I think Brian had had been tracking this one down and you know his view of it was he didn't see any real downside to the uh lifeback adoption oh good and after sir last Tuesday when Brian was able to say that he feels like he's identified and protected our staff in it we're I'll go quit the two very good so that will be up for the uh second reading in March um I will make that motion any SEC do I he a second second can I make a go ahead um well I guess it's more of a point of inquiry go ahead um I I I

075don't want to delay this too much because we all recognized the last month when we talk about this you know every month we wait the uh you know could be a child that we're not saving um the uh I'm assuming at the next meeting that uh we we the board could vote to uh bypass uh the second reading go to third reading we don't have a third reading so the second reading then it will be put in okay y so if we have a second reading and there may be speakers to speak to it um you know at our March meeting but uh short of that uh we vote to uh begining in his policy great great okay um that's all I have so I will entertain a motion to adjourn oh do we need

076to vote on that yeah we do yep second okay I entertain so you you would you make motion please oh you're entertaining it I I move that we adjourn okay meeting of the policy we didn't vote on the point of order yes we didn't vote I had a question on the point of inquiry oh it's right we had a first second you I'm glad you're over there keep me straight he's learning yeah yeah well so I I had yes I made a motion you seconded to to carry that on to Second reading all in favor please signify by say hi hi thank you sir now you made a motion to adjourn I'll second it okay first and second to adjourn all in favor signify by saying I I I we are adjourn okay wait we're

077done no we're not done we you stay here we'll we'll all be leaving for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.