001e e e I'm going to call sorry I'm going to call the budget work into order uh Miss buy will you call oh will you call the roll uh here's the roll call Melissa Mason here Josie barnhard Pat Bradford I am here Judy Justice Dr Tim Merck here David Perry Peter wildor pres all right um I will entertain a motion to approve the agenda so Mo second yall could do it all in unon any discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that passes 4 to zero um and I have asked Mr w war to lead us in the pledge today IED to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all
002all [Music] right next on the agenda uh the school budget and fiscal Control Act overview um starting with the fiscal Control Act overview and Mr Aaron Boer goodno apologize for being maybe behind few of you um hopefully not you you'll fine to look forward I know it's kind of awkward to turn around but I'll be speaking from the sides in front of me but um pleasure to be here with you again today um some of you may recall we were here in I believe December did some introductory stuff to you we've been working with your District on an engagement um to kind of look at a number of things so but we were asked today to come in and provide an overview over some of the budget practices but before we get started I will
003have to say and I'm a very honest transparent person but I attended probably over a thousand board sessions in my career and this is the first Friday afternoon session I've ever attended so you all need to be commended for that so that is a Yan's job to come in on a Friday afternoon I know some Saturdays and that are taken but again just want to share some insight with you all today answer any questions you may have and provide some overview um again some of you are aware some of you are new um School operation specialist is made up of a number of people that have prior governmental experience Public School experience uh we cover a broad range of the different operational areas we don't deal with the instructional aspect of the school district but
004we help school districts make themselves or evaluate their efficiency across the board we provide a lot of training mentoring across the state um and again it was very good to be involved in this District um again I'm not going to read you our story and all that um what what we're going to cover today is just some some of the things are very specific to statutes but some of these and I apologize if any of you have heard some of this before um but we don't try to recreate the wheel there's great tools out there across the board gfoa is the um government governing Financial Officer Association for the all government entities they've created great tools uh they've worked with Finance officers all over the country on recommendations of what should be in a very
005eventful smart budgeting process so those are labor intensive they're resource intensive but they're things you need at least have in your mind of what you may be needing to consider as you walk through and you navigate through through your budget process um we'll talk about this a little bit more in general but School business is Big Business and it's a very complex puzzle to put together people think because it's somewhat spended to L it type um Revenue it really is complicated when you look at all the different aspects so again we're recommending a number of things that are in that outline just for you to know that they are available they've already created some great tools but we first and foremost acknowledge those those are difficult on staff to Once once they get implemented it's
006a whole different thing than starting it up from scratch y'all really testing my eyesight from back here um let's see again North Carolina is going through a number of challenges and you all know them you ran for the board you're familiar with a lot of these but we we get to do what a lot of Staff doesn't get to do and I was in the same seat when I was um everything from a CFO to a COO to have served as interim superintendent myself but you're always running in many different directions you don't sometimes you don't get to analyze as much data across the state as you do when you're in other positions so it's one of the liberties we get by working in numerous districts is we get to look at a lot of
007things but it's really mindblowing that ADM across North Carolina is taking a significant decline um even some of your larger more urban areas I mean I hate to always use them as an example but wait County in the early 2000s to the mid 2000s they grew by probably 60 70,000 students in the last 10 years even a Wake County has only grown by 3,000 students I can tell you from having sitting in the seat and you're very blessed to have very very highly skilled Financial staff it's very difficult to manage through reductions in ADM because they don't come in neat packages they don't come with the ability for really any per pupil amount to really be slashed in any direct way um you know State funding in North Carolina there's no other way to say
008it but it's one of very few in the entire country that operate off the model that they operate they give you money to fund positions they give you money to find fund certain car categor categorical allotments they give you program dollars it's really not a weighted student formula I've done some training the last couple weekends for some North Carolina and South Carolina groups and even South Carolina has moved forward with a more weighted student formula method so again some of those intricacies of North Carolina make it a little more challenging a little difficult um the budget timeline in North Carolina again and I'm don't trying to sound like a beating bad beating a dead horse but the budget timeline is awful you have to present we'll go over this in a minute what's in statute
009when it's required of the board and when the superintendent has to submit their stuff but you don't you submit your stuff to the Commissioners by May 15th they normally don't improve it till mid to late June you're waiting on a state budget you have to operate a school year your schools have to hire people they have to replace positions they need to know what resources they're dealing with is with as well as you as across the district so the budget timeline in general in North Carolina is a very difficult timeline and then you add in the complications the last couple years then they go without even approving a budget they approve small budgets they take Little Steps but it's again not the clarity you need to really run an organization this size or issue $
010101 billion of school funding across the state Ian you're F very funding dependent you don't get to raise taxes some states do some states have taxing Authority for school districts North Carolina doesn't so you're always in the position of relying on someone else so you're very funding dep dependent um you're an urban system you know Urban rural have differences they're always trying to make up some of the discrepancies in those areas you have wealthy ver wealthy versus poor you have challenges like everyone else right now staff turnover is hard and finding people to replace that turnover is hard um there's the you know we've been we've been dealing with the charter schools and they lifted the cap on that in 20145 that changed the entire landscape of ADM across North Ghana but now we have
011the voucher issue so again you're always facing facing something new in the equation um what we're going to start out by talking about a little bit just so you know and again if you ever want to help get yourself to sleep any night pull out the fiscal Control Act pick it up as a reading document it'll probably put you out in five minutes but it's very prescriptive on saying how Ashley should do her job um how do barns what our time frames are in there it spells out what you have to use for a chart of accounts when you have to submit your budget um you know from a budgeting standpoint Dr Barnes is required to have to you his proposed budget by May 1st with that budget it has to obtain a superintendent message
012there's a number of things in statute that are said to be part of that budget message that's a little bit vague across the state because student achievement a number of things are written into that statute a lot of districts don't overwhelm the budget process by including that in the budget message they do different reports on different things throughout the year so that the budget message may speak to the current climate to some of the revenue issues so on and so forth but there are other requirements in there after it's approved after it's submitted to you you have to adopt it by May 15 doesn't mean he can't submit it to you before May 1st but you have to adopt it by May 15th and submit it to the County Commissioners by May 15th it becomes
013your budget once you've approved the budget up until that time it's the proposed superintendent budget so as a board you're in that process um again you'll see different districts do it different ways um but then at such time that you've gotten what I believe to be the majority of your resources approved State local Federal then a budget resolution should be submitted to you for approval that is a balanced budget the superintendent's budget at that time is what he's asking for and what you adoped but it's not truly a balanced budget until you reconcile all your revenu and expenditures from all your sources so you'll be presented some people do it in the summer some people wait until they get a state budget it might be an early fall activity there's different timings on that but
014you start the next year's budget process with a budget resolution being approved by the board yes just a question of clarity the budget I bring because this is my first one too the budget I bring to the board as a balanced budget it can be balanced because of the asks we're making to the County Commissioners correct correct so I can say it'll balance if you fund these things okay right and well yes with the unknown that you don't know what's going on with your state budget your federal budget you're you're bringing a balanced budget with everything you know at that time the budget resolution reconciles it to the next stage once everything's basically approved if it's approved and like this year there is no state budget for the entire State on that process and then
015throughout the year the board will be brought budget amendments and the budget amendments are what has changed from the time you approved the budget resolution to what's going on with the Amendments um Ashley can probably confirm some of these the state puts out initial budget figures as soon as they have what they deem to be you know knowledge of the state budget on average the state sends out somewhere between 75 and 85 revisions a year to the budget so you're constantly receiving adjustments for charter schools for virtual public schools for Indian gaming money for this for that so constantly Ashley's having to adjust the budget but you'll receive you're getting Federal money at different times they're dropping Federal allocations so on and so forth but you as a board will be responsible for approving budget
016amendments within that process um some districts spend a lot of time on budget amendments my professional opinion is it's more of a quarterly activity because nothing really changes that's that drastic that you have to bring it every board meeting but those are decisions of the board and of Staff but if you want you do a reconcile budget it may be early fall you bring something in December you bring something in March you bring something year end and then you may have a post year end to really clean up for what they call the 13th period in order to adjust um one thing in line with that it's not really in a slide that I wanted to go over is kind of what's what's the expectation financially budget wise of the school board the superintendent and
017the CFO School Board really is set here to establish priorities for the financial management of the district the school board provides the superintendent with the board priorities in the development of the budget and we'll go through some of this in a minute that again are some tools to help you through that process but you all know it you live in the community you've you've got interest in being on the school board there's many of things tugging at your heart to be priorities of the school system budget so again but you have to help the superintendent in setting your board priorities I know you all conducted some great activities already you got some followup today some of those things are exactly what you need to be doing in order to get collaboration and input on your
018budget the board is responsible for establishing the policies that direct the financial management of the district that's very important to know it's your responsibility to set the policies so if you have dollar threshold limits if you are requiring something different then it needs to be in your policy that again the staff is following as far as their directive and the superintendent on establishing Good Financial practices um the school board should review the budget on a periodic basis and make a um make a make approval to the adjustments as needed the school board should review and approve this is important review and approve contracts at the board threshold and the school board should review but does not have to approve contracts at the threshold of the superintendent's approval those are the normal practices across the state
019you have in policy what needs to be brought to you over a certain amount you are required to approve there should be nothing that goes on in the district that you haven't approved that's at that threshold but the superintendent's threshold normally the practice is it's just brought to you for review of what he has approval for other Schoolboard responsibilities relation to budget the school board approves the approves the decision to ask the voters for to pass a referendum that would be the board's responsibility if you want to move forward with a referendum then you have to give approval for that the school board approves the decision to ask the voters for a bond or a referendum for facility needs and again the school board prioritizes Construction and building renovation needs of the district they work
020with staff again similar to the contract approval you bring you make those recommendations those go into possibly board uh Bond funding uh one-time use of U Revenue so on and so forth but those are really the structure now you may say there's other things but those are really the structures around the board's responsibility within fiscal management the superintendent's responsibility is to prepare a detailed budget BAS based on the board's priorities um parameters along with a budget message outlining those statutory requirements so again then the superintendent takes your priorities what he's gotten from the community and he presents um a budget uh the superintendent should present a balanced budget resolution to the board for consideration and approval the superintendent presents amendments to the board for consideration and approval the super attendant administers the budget assuring the
021expenditures of the district funds are within legal requirements of the budget now again some of that may be delegated to the CFO but that's part of the superintendent's responsibility in the overall oversight of the district and the budget the superintendent acts as a resource to the board within the framework of the district's audit you'll have an independent audit that's done normally it's presented in the November December time frame um asley can probably confirm a number of things I say but you normally want your budget presented to you before the new calendar year you need to know are there any issues what's your fund balance situation before you really get into the spring which is your heavy budget time so an audit presented prior to the holidays prior to the first of the next calendar year
022is usually and again by local government commission it has to be submitted to them by no November 15th they can get extensions but normally if it's getting extensions that means there's some reason why the audit's not being completed um the superintendent makes recommendations to the board about the needs for the amount of a referendum so again you help set the priorities but the superintendent makes recommendations along with staff along those needs um I'm not going to read to you a list of CFO responsibilities but it's really to keep up Good Financial management across all areas of financial activities payroll accounts payable um contract and um Administration fixed assets I mean you could just go on and on and on and Ashley's blessed with a very good staff but again it takes the supervision of the
023CFO to be responsible for those tasks and those things are reviewed within your audit process so on and so forth so those things really tie in relation to what's spelled out statutorily of how your budget should look um again I get to say what I believe is hopefully relevant and important to you you have to be careful as a board I've been there done a lot of thing request there's reasons that they use a chart of accounts the chart of account explains to you how the resources are being allocated actually knowledge of the chart allows you to interpret a lot more information than you think um making individual requests often times pull people way that they're in somewhat the weeds of polling information that may not be as material to the district as relevant again
024you have Liberty to ask anything you want to ask but a lot of times if you focus on the main things and we're going to go through some of those in smart budgeting you just remember if you hear nothing else from me today 85% of every dollar you spend in a school system budget goes to salary benefits so your focus should be on how many positions do you have how how many are you allocating are they funded within your budget do you have adequate resources to cover those positions those are the things that become very challenging for school districts and we're going to go through some those additional challenges so on and so forth um again I spoke to this North Carina is very unique but position categorical program allotments you get State local federal
025capital La Child Nutrition and special Revenue funds um then you have the school funds at the individual School those are really managed by the finance department but under a uh specific in direction of the school principal so there's a lot of resources crossing a lot of different facilities and a lot of different aspects of your District just like any school district I often said when I managed uh Finance nowhere else do you normally have a 5-year-old walking up to a 21y old handing them cash and you have to reconcile that process all the way through in order to have good sound financial management there's just a number of things that have to be looked at you have ball games you have ticket sales so on and so forth um but again and one thing you
026may hear and again you'll be educated by staff on a number of things Charter payments are becoming a bigger and bigger issue across the state as the Charter School enrollment is growing and the public school ADM is either staying flat or declining but you have a special Revenue fund because the revenues that aren't legally required to be paid to Charter Schools go into your special revenue account your indirect cost your interest income your um Medicaid funds your RC reimbursements so you may think why do we have two local funds the reason you do that is anything that goes into your general local current expense budget Revenue wise is subject to payment to the charter schools so as you approve a budget and again we won't go every district has a different percentage when I was
027in Durham I'll share my specifics we had 28% of our population went to Charter Schools so when we asked for a dollar we had to ask for a128 in order to accomplish what we needed because the minute we received a dollar 28% of that went to the charter schools so those things will be presented to you in different forms or fashion so you can understand those as you move through again I'm not going to read all these to you you know that the budget process in order to be really transparent it's difficult um you know it's a it's driven by the spending it's really proactive versus reactive um you know there's been a lot of hard times recently and then when you add the SR spending into the equation we've really not had a realistic
028picture of what school spending across the nation has been on education I may have this wrong but I think North Carolina received over $6.5 billion dollar for Esser funding across the state that was just for North Carolina so again a lot of very crucial needs were met but a lot of spending habits were very unique during that process just to give you some numbers to put on it last year the state increased our funding by several million dollars the local government added several million dollar to our funding we still lost as a district $13 million last year after all the dust settled you know I know that we started with the 20 million the state leaned in a little bit the county leaned in a little bit but the loss we got from the Esser
029funding in the government was so severe that we still came in $13 million less and when you said earlier 85% of your operating budget is salaries and benefits that meant that 85% of that 13 million was people thank you sorry no no problem again what you're going to learn through this and as you become and I know some of you knew some of you experienced on the board a lot of your priorities are set for you you know the state of North Carolina is doing a great thing across the state is trying to bring livable wages in all areas up to a figure that again keeps moving we jumped a couple years ago to $15 an hour but in a lot of school districts there were people making $91 $11 an hour so a jump
030to 15 was a significant increase when you add retirement on top of that at 25% um you know you got Social Security which doesn't changes but hospitalization for an employee at over $8,000 per employee the cost of a $22,000 employee is something like7 $18,000 to provide the benefits you can you know that ramps up as you get higher into the cost so again a $15 wage an hour for Your Child Nutrition department for your after school programs you know keeping up in the community with everyone else you're competing against salary and benefits are going up so again you're having to forecast what is it going to cost over time and again I don't have to say anything that I'm not talking about just the grocery store you have a gentleman that does an excellent job
031over your operations but I guarantee you he can tell you nothing has gone down in price you know nothing has declined I mean cost of tires cost of oil you know cost of insulation everything they need lumber you know you add a hurricane and a fire into that situation it just changes it even more more so again you're always battling some difficult challenges for an entity this large that being funding dependent you have to have some flexibility to adjust and maneuver within that so I just always remind everyone don't ever spend the dollar you've got until you really know your final situation because things can change across the board and number of things can go up and a number of things can go down you know we you all got it I live close to
032the coast you got an unprecedented number you got snow which is unusual but you had cold weather a month of cold weather to a school district can change a utility bill cost by 5 10 15% that you're not normally paying in something this large again there's there's fluctuation just up just want to add that that as people talk about salaries what we try to help our employees understand is there's a difference between what you're paid and what the district invests in you as an employee and we have something on our website where you can actually look at your total compensation but I think pension is something that is going away in a lot of places but is really significant lifelong benefit for educators as well because the cost to the educator of what they put
033in their pension has not changed but even in the last 5 years we put 25.0 4% of your yearly salary The District invests in your pension which is millions upon Millions upon millions of dollars 25% is a I think a pretty high number but as you're as people continue to age out and people are living longer they have to increase the cost of that pension to keep everybody fluid oh you're welcome he's he's the one draining it well not that right sorry about that but reality is that and along those same lines and again sometimes you get Ashley myself get at get labeled to be the you know you know always sharing kind of poor information but we're having to sh share real information but we've already been prived information that you know the state
034health plan that funds number of state employees across the state is losing hundreds of millions of dollars and I've been in at 30 plus years and the employer has never had to pay into their hospitalization they're talking about that may have to be something down the road we not only do you pay for spouse coverage family coverage but you may have to start paying a some amount in for the the individual coverage and again those things just because you again you don't control them but think of how many employees you've got most districts right now are projecting from right around $8,100 per person employer cost for hospitalization budgeting about $88,500 if something else hits that that's a probably $400 or $500 increase for every employee you have across this District that's a full-time equivalent or
03575% or above so again all that says is in any budget process you're going to want to set priorities you're going to get a lot of things pulled at you that are you know weighing heavy on you as a board member for your part of the community but you just have to know there's a lot of what we call fixed cost that really drive the the the overall budget um again you got charter school you got vouchers um and then again we've talked about the yeser um yes sir you had mentioned before a a figure percentage of the charter schools can we know what ours is about please please think 8% we yeah 8% um we really don't have as many charter school students as what he was County 2100 I believe currently thank you
036you and unfortunately that number is usually growing most places but just some something as you review ADM review your numbers you review didn't have to do that 105 years ago but you got to review the charter numbers simultaneously to your numbers to okay what are we projecting that up I mean again when the cap was lifted in 20145 it went from 100 across the state to now there's over 200 you can get a charter approved and next thing you know you can have one opening up for 6 7 800 kids in the triangle area there's some that open up almost overnight within a six month period again I usually like to give specifics but one opened up immediately in the Apex area with 2,000 students they had 6,000 kids on a wait list wow so
037that's bigger than probably 40% of the school districts across the state as far as overall EDF so and again what we're going to start to cover now just some things for you to keep in your mind we're not going to go into a lot of detail about this but again you have to spend your time wisely really concentrate on what's a value to the district that you can be helping the district evaluate review but again I first and foremost say it you don't do staff jobs for them staff is paid to do their job staff is paid to manage the budget staff is paid to bring you a balanced budget um I don't want to privy anything we've been looking at things in the district but you all have an outstanding process for tracking who
038you have and where it's paid that doesn't exist in a lot of places it sounds trivial but that is a huge component to success so again don't want to get ahead of anything you got to have good policies those policies will dictate a lot of the good work that goes on you have expectations of the superintendent you have expectations of the district financially you're going to want to say what does it take for us to be financially prudent there's a strong push across the state where County Commissioners want School boards to be totally dependent upon County Commissioners they don't want them having their own fund balance that's not a healthy situation in my opinion so again you as a board certain board set policy around what is the threshold what do they want to see
039in a fund balance doesn't mean you can always obtain it but if you don't have a goal then it becomes even more challenging across the board um review relevant and meaningful data um budget detail can be valuable but it can also be summarized you know how many of what you're paying how many custodians how much your utility bills are you want to focus on the big things you know I used to get a lot of requests that always wanted to pull down to travel or workshops and those are important expenditures but they make up probably about 0.002% of a District's budget so yes you have to monitor those you have to have practices in place but you have to be looking at the important stuff and again don't want to privy anything but you've got
040excellent budget documents being provided to you being put on your website it's a matter of understanding those documents understanding the relationship and then ultimately what are they meaning across the district for providing resources um I've already said this it's a very menial kind of training but often times you do a training on the chart of accounts so you see what does the number one mean what does the number it mean State funds number two means local funds because you'll pull up documents and you in your world we live it every day but you're going to get something presented to you and you think oh what is that mean how do I differentiate that how do I know what I'm spending on teachers how do I know what I'm spending on custodial clar there's way to
041summarize it if you understand what the numerical coding within that chart means um Ashley and them are actually way above a lot of the States they're implementing new and additional digits within that they've already implemented those so they've already gone a step ahead of most districts in being where the district is pushing where the state is pushing those requirements um spend time on the big things Personnel contracts who you do business with with and what your historical Trends are School budgeting is not rocket science there a lot of pieces coming together for a lot of things but if you see Trends what have we spent for the last three years what have we spent most times you can't go five years back what makes your job right now a little more difficult is what you're
042looking at is really not relevant unless you pull out the federal eser dollars because it's distorted so much of that puzzle right now but in a normal time period you can look at something and say hey hey if it's gone up 10% each of the last 5 years then it's probably going to go up another 10% if it's gone up 15% or if it's stayed flat those are the type of things you need to look at and again you're doing it by approving your threshold contract amounts but you know who do you do business with who have you committed to a lot of those commitments are not singular in years they're multi-year contracts for academic purposes for financial purposes so on and so forth so those four buckets alone can allow you to see and
043handle a huge part of the aspect again you all have a lot of great things going on previously and you're working toward enhancement of those I'm not going to go through these but you know again any good process just has to have the right steps you have a strategic plan that strategic plan again is a road map for your District it drives the priorities it sets those goals and bench marks within each priority they usually come at a cost so often times while you're reviewing your strategic plan you're using your budget at the same time to say can we advance that I mean you have the normal steps within your strategic plan but there as you all know there's a lot more detail to the Strategic plan that outlines what you're trying to do I've
044talked about this don't lose sight of the complexity of the puzzle um we work in over a dozen districts almost simultaneously they rotate a lot I've never in my career seen the challenges that Finance officers are facing right now managing all the different aspects managing the decline in ADM managing the uncertainty around Revenue you I don't want to put anyone into a Fear Factor but a week and a half ago every finance officer in the state got a letter saying hey federal funds are frozen it was two days before payroll so I mean again things like that you have to adjust to on the Fly you have to have money to make sure that ended up becoming somewhat of a lot of nothing about something at the point but as a person getting ready to
045click Send on payroll you wanted to be able to afford all your employees across the state you know these things I'm not going to go over them with you but if you just sumarize this in a picture form you know Safety and Security your buildings your Athletics of course your academics is the purpose of what you're here for your transportation when you start setting priorities and you have limited new money to really allocate based upon other priorities or fixed costs that are driving the budget you just have to be smart you have to realize how and what are we doing um you know sat in the seat of being over operations for the district districts across the country for a good reason have spent billions upon billions in Safety and Security do they make our
046schools any more safe we don't know but again do do you not do it do you do it do you invest in changing entrance ways putting cameras in changing you know access points all those things come at a cost that you've got to prioritize in helping the superintendent set those District priorities knowing that you have limited resources to tap um one of the things you can't lose sight of and again we don't we're working with the staff but operational efficiency means more money you can put in the classroom so you're always trying to not streamline it where you're making the services not of value to the district but are you really running those efficiently because again part of the reason we have a lot of business is because a lot of districts struggle with this
047they're turning over key staff that learning how to run a Child Nutrition program is not something you learn overnight learning how to run a District transportation program learning how to run maintenance managing the dollars and the revenue associated with your exceptional Children's Program all of those things are key components that if you're not doing well then all of a sudden you're spending resources that you really need in order to prioritize the academic achievement of this district and again I say that as a business person I'm not prioritizing academics is our number one goal and the number one function of every school system but the ability to know that your District does these things well is a huge aspect to how the how the district is doing um again not going to go through but we're
048going to hit on some things quickly know that whether it's your school administrators your District administrators and superintendents especially they're putting out fires by the hour they're putting them out by the minute they normally can't sit through a meeting without three or four things raising to the top of their email that's really priority across the district so again you always just have to be sensitive to what is the timing um you know reviewed again a lot of documents here but you all have a very good budget calendar it outlines the activities this is not just a one two-month activity it starts in the fall it goes through the year you review it through the summer you come back and evaluate all those are key components but again finding time for all groups to be involved
049that need to be involved you know School level Personnel Community Personnel I mean I'll give you credit you're doing a great thing you've started a budget advisory committee it's difficult to educate the public on your budget because everyone sees it as the biggest drain or the biggest expense in every Community but by having other constituents understanding argue on your behalf you're taking a very very crucial step in something that's very beneficial to the process you know I'm just going to say it and you can take it for what it's worth on the whole thing every school district their central office is called the ivory Palace you know it's called the place where everyone goes to make the big it doesn't want to be in the schools that's not the case you have to evaluate the
050organizational structure of the central office what's the services that are being provided and sometimes we think and this is part of what you'll learn and some of these tools as you use them in the future you think okay we're going to cut 20% of our central office those people may be a prek director that's you know generating funds for that program and I'm going to pick on prek but you start slashing assistant director positions in departments they're responsible for helping run the efficiency that so as a board you don't make the decisions on staff you only help hire a superintendent but you're asking the superintendent and again you all are very transparent you print your organizational charts you list the people you're taking all those steps to say that hopefully you've evaluated what they're doing
051for the district and again size value and responsibilities are all key I've been there done it you can have a lot of central office people that may not be worth what you're paying them but there's a lot that are probably worth three people's salaries so you always have to evaluate yes and in regards to balancing that support we give to schools our central office is 52 people smaller than it was last year we cut 15% of our central office because we didn't want all those Sesser dollars to get communicated directly to schools that's that's the next bullet you you know for everything that's being cut Oh no you're great no that's you got to put reality to these things I mean we're I'm just sharing but what is its level of support and what's the
052purpose of the position so cutting them then what was its value what is it you know you might be going without something I mean just as we talked about Staffing is not easy right now the terminology used for is a BT for a beginning teacher a beginning teacher needs more support normally than a veteran teacher do you have things in place that support people do that provides services you know principles are a lot younger than they used to be um used to be you serve 10 15 years in the classroom you serve seven or eight as an AP and you might serve seven or eight in the last third of your career as a principal now principles are being put into position seven eight years into their career period they need support they they don't
053have the overall experiences you all seeking qualified candidates it's a challenge but again all those pieces and parts doesn't automatically you say you size up a central office to say one number fits because some Central offices are doing a much better job providing services and support that ultimately help Drive The District in some of its most crucial areas and then again unfortunately it's a world we live in but there is so much compliance and reporting that some of the people do nothing but submit reports that are required to be sent to someone else um you know it's it's overwhelming I mean even in the Finance Arena alone it's almost every month a survey sent out where the legislators want detail on this want backup for that want support for this so you just have to
054remember too if you don't have those people you don't want to go being non-compliant because you'd put some of your funding in Jeopardy so on and so forth um and then again it's not you have expectations of what the people are doing they have job descriptions you know the superintendent evaluating those the hierarchy within the organizations evaluating the people that are under them but again there's expectation that those people are delivering um fund balance you're going to hear a lot about fund balance or you have as a board member fund balance and you know it's you always told be careful what terminology use to explain it but it's really what money do you have left savings after you've taken away your you know your revenue and expenses for a year your assets minus your liabilities
055sometimes you commit fund balance for certain things that roll into the next year but unassigned fund balance really describes how much resources do you have for what it says it's unassigned for some other purpose and what is available to the district should an emergency come up should you have a hurricane in this area um so on and so forth you even from a facility standpoint you know you can have a boiler go down you can have a chiller go down you can have a major roof issue you don't need your fund balance so low you will hear this more times than not you'll go to training across the state and some of your experience experienced board members can speak to this everybody wants to know what's the percentage we should keep in fund balance local
056government commission clearly defines it for County government it's between 8 and 25% they've got a retired debt so there's a rationale that they maybe should have more money on the books for their fund balance because they're floating debt for number of buildings across the county so on and so forth but it doesn't mean the school system should be at 0 2% or 3% most Auditors will tell somewhere between 8 and 10 you should have maybe 3 months worth of Revenue on hand all those things again have to be evaluated as you look at your own financial position yes sir can you just restate who it is that's recommending the 8 to 25 because we clearly have issues around our fund balance and having it you know decrease so much over the last many years and
057this is a conversation that has to come up with the county you know to allow us to maintain a little bit of a fund balance who who's recommending the 8 to 25 no that's for County governments a local government commission recommend their amount that they require of County governments and County governments have to go for what's called uh AAA rating in order to it's basically taking out a mortgage for the county and that's kind of what's built into their requirement structure because you don't have taxing Authority you can't really obtain debt on your own it's not as clear as it is for the county but that's a restriction of the local government commission for County Government but again and I'm seeing this we're seeing it everywhere County governments and I don't know if they attended
058a workshop or what but they're all pushing school systems to spend down their fund balance that's not good fiscal management thank you that's not proper you need the ability to run your District you are a huge organization and a huge part of New Hanover County that the amount you have and you you can go back and review your last year's audit it's not significant for a district this size to be in that position this may um yeah I was lucky enough to be here when we had a really healthy fund balance and then Co hit and ours was brought down and now how much did you say between you say three and 8% is what we should have in our fund balance but normally you should have somewhere about 3 months worth of operating Revenue
059but normally it equates to somewhere in the reference of about 8% is when you do the math compared to the the numbers it's usually in that realm well I remember when Florence hit and we were probably one of the few school districts in the state that were able to handle it really effectively it wonderful actually and then Co hit and then our County Commissioners they're the ones because of Co situation that has forced our fund balance down that could be what's going on across the state right now as a response to the federal money and then this change in the finances of the schools that's just a supposition but we had a really healthy one and it was wonderful and we have and this is some of the numbers I'm going to share with you
060a little bit later as well but our four-year average of what we have taken out of our fund balance and put into our operating budget is $6 million so every year in the last four we took an average of $6 million out of our fund balance to balance our operating budget corre and what's the percentage of our operating of our fund balance right now it must be like 2% 1% oh 2.1 million right right yeah but it's it's pretty it's it's well under 8% yeah it's closer to 2 or 3% out of 300 plus million 2 million doesn't go very far it wasn't like that up until about four years ago so as what was the what was what was the County Commission they passed the thing that said resolution or whatever in the last
061maybe four five six months that said if you spend down your fund balance you promise but they made some sort of promise that they would come to our Aid quickly or what we got into agreement with them that they are going to pay for any damage due to weather or hes or right we we pay 500 I think 500,000 and then they'll pay right so we reached an agreement with them because they wanted us to pay fund so yeah maybe there was a memo to all of the County Commissioners somewhere that said do this but if you hear nothing else again I try to make point of the relevant information the only entity within any organization that can approve approve the use of fund balance as the Board of Education superintendent can recommend it to
062you but you have to approve the use of fund balance so it may come to you in the form of the budget resolution when he brings you his balance superintendent's budget he may say we're using you know the 6 six and six for the last four years he might say hey I need 500,000 but again you have to approve the use of fund balance because you're ultimately saying hey we're committing our savings to either something that's one time or reoccurring expenses that we need to balance that year but again I try to keep things simple in my world not try to it's not rocket science you can't spend more than you get and at some point it's going to run out in you know any of those equations but you'll hear different terminology committed assigned
063you know something may not have been completed in one year and you're rolling it over to the next year Ashley may have it on the audited books it says committed you may have started a technology purchase you may have done something it it may be committed you may be taking care of facility needs that were because of a storm you committed resources that you approved during the previous year that roll over in those form of fashion but unassigned is where you have the balance state federal well Federal has a couple places have carryover but state gets zeroed out it's not the most productive spending in the world because that's where the majority of your funding comes from but state allocations are basically spend it or lose it there's one or two small parts textbooks technology
064and some of your remediation money that carries over but everything else if you haven't maximized it it goes away at June 30th so again just some challenges some productivity within that process again we've talked about this and I'm not going to harp on it key benchmarks what percentage of the budget uh revenue and expense you can't only think expense you have to look at your revenues you don't have a large number of additional revenues but again hopefully you're generating some of your EC dollars for Medicare Aid Services hopefully you're billing appropriately for your RC and none of them are significant but you you have to monitor all those other you charge indirect cost on your federal programs a lot of districts were able to grow their fund balance over the last four years because they
065were charging indirect cost on federal programs thus having some more money to carry them through some lean years you all were having to make major reductions and thus really not building that up to the level probably most districts were just cuz again different challenges different places um and then again 3 years with or with without Co is usually normal to see what those Trends were go back 5 8 10 years sometimes things change too much in that period I always say a three-year Trend and even looking forward a three-year Trend and that's something again Dr Barnes and them do a phenomenal job from what we've seen but you have to get your Commissioners to understand there's some dollar amount amount that every year is a required amount just to maintain and keep the district moving
066at its current level without reductions without whatever if salaries are going up 3% if retirement's going up a half a percent if hospitalization is going up utilities are going up insurance is going up you have to get them to understand that it I'm just going to use a round figure it may be a $3 million figure a year you get anything more than 3 million yes you might be able to do something additional and new you get less than 3 million then you're continuing to try to rightsize your district with less resources and again the state can give you allocations that all of a sudden they reduce increase whatever but it's it's a lot of unknowns but the trends will tell you a lot but I I just and again it's labor intensive but it's
067not that hard to carry out a couple of those big ticket items to say hey what's our salary and benefit cost for the next 3 years if a 3% raise goes into place if retirement goes up a half a percent each year here just so you have some idea your utilities you take those five or good 10 big buckets project those out um just for a hint we're projecting 2.6 million forecasted increases in BS is that District 2.6 million 2.6 covers like raises and benefits our increase to our liability insurance and an increase in our um utilities how about Healthcare is that a separate budet that's that's tied to that rais benefit um again I'm not going to but just know as another thing as a board and the staff again it's their responsibility but
068your ADM drives just about everything your membership in your school schools you have to track it they track it right down to the school level to the grade level that's how everything is generated formulas are at the state when you got 18 kindergarteners you get a teacher when you have 16 first graders you get a teacher those things fluctuate they change but you can see based upon this chart and it's a little bit old but North Carolina ADM in total has been dropping you would not think that these are the five districts that grew the most over the last five or the last 10 years or these were the districts that declined the most over that time period when you start putting a Durham a Guilford or you know into the most the large again
069this is this is number this is not percentage of your District so you can always make a number a lot of different ways as far as how but but again track those and you're going to often times hear and I'm just going to preface this everybody as they have declining ADM has to look at consolidation but closing a school is nowhere near the savings for the cost of that school on an annual basis it's somewhere between 15 and 20% of what you spend on a school is what you save because your kids are still being move somewhere else your your your salary and benefits is the majority of that cost so really all you save when you close I'm not saying you don't consider closing the school but the majority of savings comes about from
070a little bit reduced Transportation cost some insurance reduction saving utilities you might be able to cut some clerical staff custodial staff but again that's a small small percentage that people want to say oh you're running X number of schools and yes you all have some small schools but it doesn't mean if you're spending 4 million right now you're going to save $4 million if you close it because you're still going to have to educate whether it's 300 kids 700 or th000 and again people like myself and in operations we're very number specific it's changed but there was a point in time that it said an elementary school wasn't self-sufficient unless it had over 800 kids but again in order to work within the state allotment process in order to get the teacher an assistant principal
071isn't allotted till you get a th000 kids so for every small school you're usually investing more than what it really takes to run the school from a again from a not a weighted student formula process but from a allotment that's very position driven dollar driven so on so forth so again figures don't drive everything but you have to look at things as you make considerations in budget Pat do you have a question or yeah what was that percent you can for what you save usually it's between 10 10 and 20% of what you save in closing the school yes ma'am um I'm just trying to clarify your chart here when you have it in parenthesis that's how much you have lost L yes okay um and as far as a school allotment coming from the
072legislature that's pretty what I guess you're not able to answer because maybe a lot of people don't where do they get their justification for having such out of sync allotments with reality have sorry that's just such a good way to say it yeah really it is uh where do they get with their justification are year I mean maybe you're closer to the source of being able to understand why they come up with these very unpractical a it's they use their own trend but no one can predict live birth rates no one can predict the impact of homeschooling of charter schools of vouchers but they look at historical Trends they try to analyze but it's like you're saying it's very numerically driven versus really something that's relevant to a lot of the individual school districts you
073know some parts of the county I mean again there's 13 dying counties in North Carolina which means there's more people dying than are moving into them you all live in a community that has a lot of growth but they can't say that all the people that are coming here are they attending Public Schools are they making that choice just because the growth um you know I used to try to it was the most important number I helped try to generate in the districts I worked in and I worked in two of the 15 largest districts in North Carolina during my career but again live birth rates in the community all those things drive at it that eventually you hope they're going to be kindergarteners for your district and you know we want a right siiz
074schools but people think that well if I had 600 kids in my School this year then you should have lot me 600 well you could have a big fifth grade class graduating and a small kindergarten class coming in or vice versa so they're juggling it and again I don't want to preface anything but they do a phenomenal job tracking their positions to their schools their funding source and the numbers so that's just a huge variable that even with all the uncertainty allows you the ability to know that you've got things covered in your budget well you answered the ADM question I think your question question was the allotment formula itself is wrong right absolutely and I think that's where we struggle because and I and I can agree with you I think a little bit
075yes the smaller the school the greater amount of overhead and the you're starting to see that we're having the share like our smaller schools you're going have to share art you're going have to share music you're have to share a social worker because the formulas are wrong not the ADM components are wrong now do we have places we could maximize maybe but that's not in and of itself the only problem either good good clarification and I always take credit for someone clarifying what I said incorrectly but but no it's the size of the school again is because we're in an allotment process right and districts are having to resize that a social worker a counselor a media person the art the music you know and it's hard you you try to have X number of
076grades but they you know if you only got two classrooms per grade and they don't make that number no no one wants to hear the word combination class or those very challenging aspects but those are the things that don't come in neat packages but now and again Dr Barnes knows this better than K3 class size was a great initiative but it was not fully funded so they do that a lot with a lot of things so that's all I remind you as you said again I'm not going to bore you with numbers but this is your ADM alloted history from the state from 1997 98 to current they changed the way they did this this current year and moving forward you're now funded the next year's allocation based upon your second month ADM of your
077current year so if all of a sudden you grow like crazy from your second month of this year to what you project for next year you're fighting for those resources they had to bring the general assembly back into town for them to address growth money and you know the charter schools were fighting for it and the public schools but it almost didn't get approved and it wasn't proportionately funded to what numbers they had across the state right now again you're projected to go down small amount you all kind of hit a peak right before covid you've trended down the last four or five years um during that time period but again these things Drive every one of those position allocations that you get from the state so I just put together one example and again
078you have staff that does this thousand times better than I do Aaron before you go off if you'll go back back to that um previous SL because I just want to share with the board because um you know ADM changes every day so depending on who's running the report and what we're talking about you see different numbers and I know it gets confusing so you know this slide is showing how the state funded us but in a slide that you'll see when Dr Barnes and I do a presentation I I'm showing where our student ADM numbers were at the end of that fiscal year and then I'll show and then I'm showing you for the next year what what we're projecting the number will be so that's why sometimes there's differences um and so like
079in 2022 there's a big difference you know is showing here 26,000 students but when I show you a chart later I'm going to have 24,62419 our kids were at 24,000 we were still getting money like we had 26,000 so I just wanted to clarify that because you'll see different numbers later I didn't want that to be confusing thank you this next slide please please don't I know I shouldn't once you put a number together it's a number that someone's going to confirm but this is just a brief example of what's now projected as your 2526 enrollment versus your 2425 enrollment and what it will do to just your teacher allocation this don't yeah I've kind of but don't hold me to this this is just to give you an example of right now if they
080hold you to your second month ADM you drop a little bit right off the top you're cutting 13 teachers so you have to write size your district and again you have hundreds of thousands of teachers but it's always a moving Target and again I don't want to ever speak for Ashley but every finance officer will tell you growth is easier to manage than decline so just going up even a small amount each year but when you're ticking down and you're trying to run the same number of schools utility bills don't drop insurances don't drop you got the same number of custodial clar it becomes harder and you don't you're going to hear protect the classroom but you're going to lose funding that's directly Associated to the classroom along with some other allocations as ADM is
081the driver of that factor and if you can you go back for slide please I'm sorry thank you when you look at all those grade levels that loss of 13 teachers kids don't come in buckets of the same number so what happens is you can lose two or three in each grade level you still have to have the same number of teachers because there are class siiz mandates and so what happens is it doesn't always balance itself out that way and so that's why sometimes you have to see some moving of a teachers around in the beginning of a school year we try to get really close but like Jen knows we'll get to August and you've got 12 in your kindergarten classes and this school over here has 20 so how do we move
082and balance that is a real delicate sort of dance really because if you look down that column of the decrease there's not a significant material number in any of that column even though it adds up to a few you got to divide that across all your classrooms at that grade level across the entire District if one school was losing that 100 students then yes you can cut five teachers from that one school but when it's three four 7 six as Dr bar stated all and again this all relates to to the complexity issue people think oh you just have teachers the same number of school you operate you give all of it's a changing moving Target and it's driven off of membership and numbers um again how do you begin this you all have already
083begun it you're all in the throws of doing it you started back in the fall you presented some things right before the break you presented things after I can tell you you're on a good track for what you've already done to get yourself but we've got to remember it's basically coming up on mid-February superintendent's budget being presented to you by April he's going over today priorities things have to move very quickly in a very tight time frame no matter how much youve spread this out um in other time frames you all are doing a great job as much collaboration as you can get the better the more people that have input but it's hard I mean you can do surveys but you can get a thousand different opinions you can get a lot of different
084inform um framing the process explaining what you're trying to do and again keeping things at a summary high level helps um determine your Baseline for performance um and encourage engagement by all stakeholders um School principles need to be involved but School principles again usually have Arguments for their school for their situation doesn't mean you don't involve them I'm married married to a principal so I'm taking that putting that in context so but again School principles argue as they should for their school their needs their desires you have to look holistically at the whole District what we're not going to go through today but I just want to make you aware and there's there's unbelievable information again I'm the first to acknowledge it's labor intensive it's a struggle but you have to have some understanding in
085time what are you doing to trade off different things because you're not always going to get new money you're going to have to have tools in place to for the superintendent to and he does to have evaluated things to bring to you things that not only you adding but you may be reducing for the budget you're projecting more than one year you have a road map that looks not only at expenses but Revenue you know and it's a hard slide to put before Commissioners but those same Commissioners that may want to see your fund balance spent down Dr Barnes will do a great job showing them that it's going to cost almost $3 million a year and an increase moving forward to do nothing new do you know so again each thing is unique to
086a school system um it's called strategic abandonment but you have to be smart about what you get rid of because often times in government entities 10% cut across the board well sometimes you're losing some of the most productive things you're doing in the school system you're not right sizing it to what's making a difference what's working what's actually benefiting the district it's really challenging to get into the the detail to say that that strategic abandonment has made people and again worked with a ton of central office people some of the greatest people in the world but their job is defend to defend what they do so there's a lot of job justification to the programs to the services but when you're having to right size it and the number of cuts you all have made
087here the last couple years then all of a sudden you have to really say when we get rid of this what's the Impact versus getting rid of that or if we're doing this program cuz it's you stick around education long enough things come around about every 78 years but it's really pretty much the same concept under a little different name and a little different technology but education can't change but so much and a lot of things have been tried but most people weren't around seven or eight years ago to know that it's already been kind of worked through so again all I do is introduce to you today there's great tools within these resources of creating some of those spreadsheets they're a finance person's dream if that's all they've got to do but your person
088has a lot to do in a department that's already doing a lot to get a lot of things out but as you all move forward are you tracking what's working successfully all those things again it's not rocket science so each one of them has the tools the description um some outlines of what they do and they even provide you the resources um again just in conclusion remember your resources go to your schools I believe this and I really mean it you all have a school centered budget you don't have a district centered budget you have a school centered budget which means you're putting the resources in the hands of the schools it's making allowing them to have the resources they need to be successful um again you have Staffing ra ratio allocations hopefully in time
089the state's going to look at some sort weighted student formula there's been talk of that there's been you know some conversations around that it's they came out with a chart about three years ago and everybody went haywire because it it took from the poor and gave to the rich in their chart so that basically cut it off but at the same time somebody's going to have to be adjusted somewhere in that when you start so but there is conversation and then always know the cost of your operations again there's current steps you all are in the throws of it but just get quick wins you have a great PR department budget isn't the most glorified thing in the world but a lot of times the successes that go on financially need to be highlighted just
090like anything else so that the district has credibility around what you do feels good about how you manage your resources and it takes time mean I always said couldn't get to sleep most nights because there was so many things running through my mind of what was going on operationally financially you can spend your entire career working towards success and it can be torn down basically overnight or in one year you know so it doesn't take much to Trend in the wrong direction when you're going in the right direction and if you go through what you are budget should align with a lot of your strategic things that should be parallel they shouldn't be running separate you all have a number of those tools already in place that are working I believe successfully so final recommendations
091around some things that you need just it's probably as much of a catchphrase word as there is is a transparent budget process but transparent doesn't mean a 600 page budget book it means relevant budget information that the person can interpret to what are the priorities of the district I've seen a lot of districts put out 600 page budget books and they take a lot of pride in those but no lay person is pulling much information out of that I'm not saying it needs to be five pages but you have to be really putting transparent information out there again and you all know it and I'm it's in your current documents and it's done as well as anywhere we've ever seen you track your positions on an annual basis if you had X number last year
092how many do you have this year how many do you have three years ago that's in historical information that's on your website you know again that's the number one driving Factor at your budget um again review your contracts and vendors you're going to hear people tell you to do zerob based budgeting that may be something you can do if we ever get to weighted student funding but even at that there's certain things that you have to start with what's needs-based what actually exists you're not going to get rid of teachers you're not going to get rid of bus drivers you're not going to get rid of custodians so you really can't say that you're starting at zero um I mean I've fought that argument for years of what how do you get there why don't
093you do zero base budgeting because 90% of my resources or 70% of them come prescribed for something that's already outlined um you've done a great service to your community you've started a budget advisory committee you have a very strong budget calendar and within the budget process there's never enough time to deal with budget but you have to work smarter not harder you really just have to work smarter in getting that information um going going at it appropriately so glad to answer any questions um I think you all have great great things that you've got to look forward to but you've got challenges can't lose sight of that I was actually wondering you shared in the beginning the roles of the board the roles of the superintendent and the roles of the CFO would that be
094possible for you to share that with us like in email or some form that'd be greatford well I was could you repeat that I'm sorry for some reason I did hear what you ask I'm sorry sorry you're fine the roles of the board the roles of the superintendent and the roles of the CFO that's what I'm asking for yep heard that Miss Bradford so where are you in your process with us and Consulting with us are you done almost done and we're significantly close to finishing and we're working with staff bring about some of those final pictures so I don't think it's too far off in having that report finished from our standpoint so could you or Miss Sutton Enlighten us where we stand in terms of the analysis of Revenue and how we're doing
095and was there any that you found for savings that we can hope for every district has potential for saying but I don't think you till we kind of lay out the whole thing operationally I don't think we want to really name figures at any point and those figures still have some work to be done in order to realize them but again staff does a wonderful job and some of those things we helped look at but again I think when you see the final report you'll feel very good that the thing you have to remember is so many districts are struggling across the state and you may have been there at one point in time but you have the structures in place for success Mr Mayor so I appreciate the timeline I think it's really important
096for us to kind of grab that and say stay with it with it and um I know that we are to expect something from the superintendent by May 1 would really like that to be January you but just kind of wondering if you have any sense about when we might get that budget I'm going to be able to share with you what I think our budget my superintended budget priorties are today um and then yeah and then the rest of the operating budget I have to spend this month working with departments going over their specific needs and asks as well course so I'd be able to share with you up to this point all the work I've done with talking to our stakeholders and bringing you together what I feel like is a focused budget
097School focused budget based on what the Stak said they need so you'll have that today as far as May 1st think that it will come in under that uh we committed I asked that we give our County Commissioners our budget on April 15th so that's the that's a current date I'm shooting for we're all doesn't it go first from you to us and then go yes you guys approve my budget recommendations and then I carry to the County Commission saying all of us together this is where we are thank you and we're going to talk a little more about that thank you appreciate than you yeah that was interesting after you guys need us yeah I'd like all right we are really cring on time so just a couple minutes and I'll bring you guys
098back I we extend time so you can have I have limited time today I can't extend too much I will accelerate this is my AP class so we'll be good e e e [Music] can we share this oh CRA okay so I can extend about 15 and that's about it is this the last thing that we do this is your card oh oh you Gra e some classified staff meeting with directors meeting with parents um I think there was several more other was I met with the turnaround task force um so I met with just stakeholder groups throughout the district yeah so what I'd like to do is walk you guys through the same exercise because I think it's important for you guys to experience sort of the challenges that that our staff had as
099well so to start off what I've did is each of you has a card and each of our cabinet members has a card and if you guys can group together based on your like card please vill are here so you may have to move your seat werewolf werewolf villagers you want us to come over there come on over here I have my my own speaker the werewolf oh wait everyone has villager there's two of us yeah there there should be one person has the same card as you one no both have oh for heaven's sakes I tried to board members go sit with a Cabinet member I don't care which one it is I'm coming J so I've lost I need a [Laughter] obviously I obviously I am smarted myself so if one of you
100would go with da if one of you would go with Robin and the other one go with Eddie worked I was done and you can I'm sorry this uh not really okay good on the game I want to remind you I called you the advaned class before we went to the on break so let's bring it back all right you got this all right all right people Mr mer Mr Merck Dr mer Robin Jen somebody anybody all right we don't get part of what I want to share with you is sort of the conversation that I want to have with our County Commissioners and part of this conversation is talking with our stakeholders about what I'm calling Roi which is important for all of our stakeholders to feel that whatever we put into our budget
101this year over and above what we already have has to be based on what's a return on the investment for children it was hard because I I would look at a group of teachers in the face and say I know you guys are exhausted I need you to push through that to what do we want to focus on student outcomes because I think that's what's going to engage our community it's what's going to engage our commissioners as well for me and I think I told you this yesterday Mr mer Dr Merck for me the argument about who is supposed to Supply the water when our house is on fire doesn't help me put out the fire while I know that the county commissioner leans in in a lot of ways they also adds sro's they
102also help with nurses they help with our pre program but I have very limited ability to move the federal government or the state in funding the only people I can look at in the face and say I know you care about our kids are the five County Commissioners and the Seven of you so I have to push where I feel like I can get movement so some of our ass I'm not really saying it should be some person's job or another person's job to fund it what I'm bringing to you is what our kids need today to be successful and interesting you you'll see that the ask we come to is almost exactly the amount of fund balance we are no longer using because I think that's a significant Point as well this is the
103first year in 5 years that we have not touched our fund balance and it affected children so to that start this is a idea or an activity designed to help us focus our thinking on outcome measurements not what we feel like we need but what we can prove that we can move right so the first step is what I want you to do is think to yourself what is the one thing that our kids don't have that they need or what is the biggest thing that's stopping us from moving forward the one thing I'm going to ask you to do is don't put Staffing as the problem now Staffing may be the solution to the problem but I want us to focus on what is the problem of student learning because the solution may be
104we need a person to fix that problem right but what is the actual problem problem staff staff now staff may be the vehicle by which we fix the problem right and generally will what's the problem and I'll give you some and I know it's hard because you only have one index you only have one post note I will say that there are things that have come up some things that have been I'll just give you a couple of like examples student Behavior has been one steing chronic attendance and absenteeism has been one safety has been one graduation rate has been one those are just some ideas to spark your thinking I tried really not to give those ideas out to the stakeholders though because I didn't want to skew the results so when I I
105just opened it wide open what do you think is the biggest issue in problem facing us today and to inform your thinking I'll give you step two to inform your thinking your next step is to tell me what data point connects to it the closest so make sure you pick a problem that you can then give me a data point that goes with it sir no Mr willber I know you you don't have any friends the only [Laughter] [Applause] probably okay as you guys are focusing again I'll give you a hint on step two which is what data point connects to it what data point connects to that problem okay for those of you that are ahead yes I know sometimes sometimes teachers go close to certain students to help progress the class I want
106you to take your index card please I mean take your post note please and put it on the Strategic goal that you think can connect closest to we're gonna Laine it right now all right are we ready yeah you put that on theeg goal that most clely align [Music] all right I can see that I can see why group activities don't always AR always enjoyed by teacher so I will tell you yesterday I taught all the fifth graders at Blair all the boys how to tie a tie this is going about as well yes okay I had then I came oh then I went to the count then I went to the chamber thing all right okay here's what here's what you guys came up with I see challenging student Behavior that's hand I student
107student engagement individual support and student achievement again safy Behavior trauma and behavior and suspensions and student teacher ratio awesome because all of this is exactly what your principal say oh good almost almost perfect so here's the next step these cards have been seen by hundreds of people I'm going to give thousands Okay thousands of people not as many as the snow video but you know can you pass one along okay this is a way for me to help isolate your thinking a little bit so oh my goodness your goal or objective you put down the main problem the main problem I'm just going to pick one up here challenging student Behavior okay right I know right cuz that's what I'm it's it's so important that you said that because I'm trying to find a way
108to dodge that right but that's really what it is it's about funding but I think funding because my concern is if I go to the community and say we have to work really hard I don't know if that resonates as much as we want your child to be indiv ually individually grown with a teacher who can help them at the level they're at that says it differently right or we want to address challenging student Behavior so that there is less trauma and violence in our schools that affects people differently then boy we need more help right right all right so one the goal problem you need to turn your problem into a goal maybe you put the word reduce or increase or individualize whatever you guys put as your goal up there so your goal
109might be yes work on trying to find a way to put that into a statement that's going to be a tough one to get a data point for no we have we have okay we we've got through it when you look at step two no it's no you're fine finish what your finish what your thought is far going yeah go ahead I don't want to leave you guys behind again number two is is for sort of the simplest one for us to get what are the barriers that are stopping at I'm not worried about us coming with number two I've got those but number three is where you put your data point okay number three is how does this change kids because what I'm trying to do is build a snowball that by the time
110it gets to the County Commissioners is so big that everybody knows about it all of our talk now all my superintendent comments all my visits are going to be focusing on these priorities because when the County Commissioners do receive our budget I want them to go gief I've heard about this a hundred times already we we can't not focus on this three so one yeah you jump I've got two so you can skip two you success okay [Music] sir you guys can do one together it's fine you can use one for the two of you uh you can have up to three up to three clear data points number number three sir step two step two is to go to number three oh no no not that but the step two before was the okay
111why do you think that the data point is critical to have as a part of this process why do you think that the data point is critical to have as a part of the process it's got to be measurable why is the measurement piece important so we can I'm thinking not about this budget cycle with our County Commissioners I'm thinking about next year oh I'm thinking about next year when I go back to them and said we asked you for this money I'm here to report what that money did and how it resulted in student outcomes because that's going to be the vehicle I hope which manages an increase in further funding that once we start building momentum we can show that the money they're spending is worthwhile and how it's being spent does that
112make sense ma'am right but these budget these specific budget parties are additions to our budget not currently what we have now yeah this is what I'm asking for guidance for is the additional things we're going to ask so the last thing I'm going to ask you guys to do because we are short on time is looking at step number five if you look at number five on your cheet it asks what you're going to do what steps would you take what do you need to make that goal happen most student test for because that's what they got have [Music] nice [Music] not look for for resources so you can also go just we're done yeah I'm just trying to send this email to everybody with the with the submission thing up [Music] okay if I
113can bring your attention back for a minute this when I say I'm not going to talk until everyone's quiet you hear [Laughter] MEAP coyote okay Ashley's going to come and collect your cards a little bit so I can have them to review you oh yeah you can go back to your seats if you want would you like to card yeah yeah yeah here I'll pass this around just stick your cards back at them can you collect the cards on that side of the table oh thanks Jen here you go do we have to separate you two go back to really is not any better over there either get a t-shirt says trouble I'm we pass those out all right Dr Barnes thank you those were mine Eddie moved my stuff stuff is this I already
114have it all right people so I want to bring as at our next budget work session since we did get short on time I'm going to ask Ashley to give to you today what we use as a copy of our local allotment formulas and the state allotment formulas so you can get a sense of the differences between the two I will tell you that it's this is how we aot positions to schools we do do some revision on it as we go one example is um several years ago one of the funding changes that we made is uh turning the ISS position at middle schools from certified to classified the high schools were already classified so sometimes you'll see minor changes like that and some are based on student need not on number namely social
115workers and things like like that EC students that kind of thing but we want to give you copies of those to take home with you because that's going to be what we queue up first next time because as he said 85% of our budget lives inside the allotments I will give you just a brief example of that cost of of addition increase that happens every year this past year I think we had custodians we had to cut 10 of them and our bottom line cost was the same as the year here before the increases 8 10 of those positions and that's really what I'm trying to come at with you folks as a board and then with the County Commissioners next is I've ordered all the pizza we can afford and if we want to
116have everyone have more pizza we either have to get more pizza or less people eat it because we can't afford more and I think the question is we are at a sub um subsistence level we are at our basic level of services now and that's my concern is I can't find anywhere else to cut now a couple of things I want to just put in your head I want you just to write down a couple of numbers so that you can lay awake at night as much as I do I for thanks for that you're welcome over the last four years our average draw out of our fund balance has been $6 million 5.9 which means Even in our height of Esser funding we were still taking $6 million do in and I think there
117were some people that would say even then we weren't serving our schools enough with the needs that they have we have now lost not only the Esser funding but with the budgeting that Ashley has done is and and our work with the with HR is created a year where we haven't touched our fund balance but it could it puts us in this subsistence level that this is as low as we can possibly go so there are a couple of other numbers I need you guys to be thinking about as we go forward one is that we will see a reduction in our what's called saf light Revenue safe light is a city of Wilmington program where if you ran a red light you got a ticket apparently you can now just run them whenever because
118they're stopping that that was $1.4 Million based on the last average of the last three years yes ma'am you just said um this proposal are you meaning the what we've been doing in 242 I get so M up 2 2425 that subsist sub subsistence or 2526 is going to be subsist right now we're at the this is our subsistance level right so 2425 yeah okay and you and you things that we have less than even last year yes and things we're less next year I don't mean to I'm sorry I don't mean to uh make this sound any worse than it already is but it seems to me that we are sub subsistence at this point when we have crowded classrooms trailers you know on and on and on how can we actually even say
119that we're at kind of Baseline it seems to me that we're a little underwater already M I agree with that I don't want to minimize the work to adapt that our principles and teachers and staff members and schools have done though we are serving children we are serving children to the extent that we are my concern is is that this is the I I can't go lower than I am now and we can argue about whether or not now is too low or not I'll be all behind that too statement but I think my concern is is that I have people coming in every day and getting the job done whether or not they're all doing jobs they shouldn't have done before some of that is I think a misnomer I will tell you that
120part of the reason that Ashley and I have worked so hard to build this committee to build a transparent process is because next year we know that we have the potential to ask for a bond and that bond is part of the we can't fix some of the problems we have even if the County Commissioners open their doors completely to some of the major problems that we are experiencing stuff like new an high school stuff like the overcrowding at Laney those things are Bond issues what I want to sort of do now is rebuild consumer confidence in the work that we do as a board the work you do with the superintendent because it's our platform for next year going with a bond does that make sense so a couple other things sorry I don't
121want to get lost so that safe light Revenue even at the subsistance level we're at now we're going to be $1.4 million less next year based Bas on the elimination of that program right we also have to forecast and I know this is something that we talked about briefly before the forecasted cost increases which you're going to see in things like utilities liability insurance and benefits and raises just that number alone is 2.7 million and that is just to keep us at our subsistance level where we're at now okay so uh yeah 4.1 here's what I I'm trying to tee up as a superintendent budget priority and they're not there yet but here's sort of the the areas that we're circling around we sort of have had two and interestingly enough you guys landed on
122the same two that our principles did that our staff did one is a question of safety so there are safety and and the principles are interestingly enough have been talking about intrinsic and extrinsic safety meaning sometimes violence happens at a school where a kid is making a choice to be violent sometimes violence happens at a school where a kid is either run out of or never learned effective coping mechanisms to deal with stress how do we fix both problems at the same time one is do we look at fully funding this um safe and civil schools process to help regulate our kids better when they're younger so they never have these issues when they're older and how do we ensure that parents send their kids to a safe school so one of our goals is
123going to focus around that sort of a a multi like a two-pronged attack on that the other thing we're talking about asking for is quite frankly every school every Department everybody has faced a cut there's not a school that hasn't lost people and when I talk to principles the thing they're missing the most is the ability to be agile and move intentionally with a small group of high-profile needs right so what I'm talking about is high schools lost their graduation coach elementary schools lost their mtss coach everybody lost their instructional coaches and so what I want ask for is the ability for every school to have basically I'm trying to build the budget so that every school maintains what they have right now every school maintains where we don't go any further underwater okay than
124we are right now and then ask for an addition of one position per school and that position the role and responsibility of that position is generated by the school Improvement plan and by the school Improv Improvement team at each individual school because it's hard to say you need this at your school but you need this at your school and so build it in a way that is a part of their school Improvement plan and they attach goals and responsibilities to it so that I can monitor whether that position is doing what it's supposed to do and we've sort of come up with sort of zones for that position because you can't just say law do whatever you want with it it has to be there has to be bumpers up right so we're thinking of
125things like is it academic remediation is it academic extension is it Behavior controls is it graduation rate there's going to be four or five specialities that we're going to ask them to focus it in on and maybe they can do one or two depending on the group but what the schools need and what the principls need is a little bit of agility because when a child and we'll just use behavior when when we have to empty out a classroom because a child has is run out of their effective coping V is Ms we don't just hurt the learning of that child we are hurting the learning of all the kids in that room if there was one person in a building who could be designed to help with that what would it look like if
126JC row or Lake Forest had one position that transition with that kid back to their regular school to ease them back into their environment successfully what if we had one person at hogard whose only goal it was was to get kids across the graduation line we've cut to the place where we don't have that my goal and I know it seems a little fuzzy but we used to use $6 million of our fund balance I'm not asking to I'm asking to keep my budget require requests under that number but these are things that we had before we had 80% of our schools meet and exceed growth and then we cut resources and supports for those schools I've got to find a way to Le lean them back in but also keep hold of some sense
127of accountability because I do think the County Commissioners deserve to know and you guys deserve to know whether those positions are working or not so that's sort of the what it looks like um I don't have exact numbers yet and I want to but I want to make sure that I'm I'm giving you guys at least a theory of where we're going at least where my budget priorities are going to come to you at what questions or thoughts kind of revolve around that Mr I'd like to start out with you know what if the principal said something like I need a person that can be multitask like an sistant principal that would be able to jump in when a child is having a meltdown but also helping another area on top of that I want
128to be careful that that position doesn't add into the administration I think it's going to be a certified position so it would be like a teacher or a teacher is but I'm going to ask schools to focus on one or two goals cuz if you if you sort of spread them out too thin excuse me if you spread them out too thin it's hard to measure whether it worked or not does that make sense and I really want to make sure it doesn't feel like we're just adding to the top right Dr Merck well somebody that has watched Dr Merck did you have something you wanted to say that's okay I'm hoping we all have a chance to ask a few questions I know we're running late I know that the schools are really big
129on data thank you I'm not really very good at keeping track of that kind of stuff but what I you know what I really want to know is that we are able to show that those positions are effective and I know that it's not going to be seen right away and so I'm just saying whatever ask we have there's got to be right there's got to be some flexibility that says you have to give us a couple years to prove this that make sense just I'm hugging you from over here my ask is going to be a two-year ask because it will take time to show and I'm not asking for this two years because I think the County Commissioners should be necessarily the ones who should be giving it to it I'm asking for
130the two years so I can continue to lobby at the state level for these unfunded mandates that are put into our school to be addressed I'm hoping that within two years the state will be picking up the responsibility for this position but so I'm asking for I'm asking for a little bit of Running Room if that makes sense Miss Justice well we are a very wealthy County and honestly we should stop being afraid of asking for what we need are our kids are going to suffer we've got to acknowledge that I mean seriously uh we the the amount of effort that goes into funding our schools is something like 70th out of the 115 distri districts it's statistically been proven so we've got to be brave with the County Commissioners because it's in their best
131interest and all of our best interest to have our kids educated properly otherwise we're going to keep spending money on things like law enforcement um you know housing food problems because people can't do it on their own because they're not getting proper education so we really need to start taking that tack instead of being afraid of of if you want to say increasing taxes or asking for bonds I'm so glad we're finally doing that but I mean as a as a board the board has to do that that's why I mean as a board you know this is something that we need to be discussing we should be discussing it in public too because that's part of our responsibility but we we need to fight for our kids and we've got the resources in this
132County to do it and our County Commissioners were elected and they're good people I know some of them so we could we we'll be able to do well some we should be able to do this to go all together yep and that's where I think bringing you guys a budget uh you guys will have to approve it I need to make sure that I bring you something that I can one manage effectively and that speaks with the voice of the staff and the students and the principles and so luckily I think we we'll be able to have done that motion that we I have one more thing for you guys one more thing is that okay yes okay that ends our formal meeting of the budget I wanted to just preview for you guys one
133thing real quick that I just emailed you if you want to open up your email everybody's sorry you can see it on here it's easy it's it just got sent to you yeah um needed i s it to you as well I did or did I not you did look at me beautiful I quite frankly get sometimes hundreds of emails a day and I'm sometimes having track keeping up with board agenda request items so what I've done is send you a link that disappeared it's gone it was it was great while it lasted it's still there it's just I got okay there we go you got it I am not singing all right the sentence that starts the board chair and superintendent apparently I never finished I will finish that but if you go if
134you go down there um see as it signed in it says hi I need a baggie so it knows who it is all you do is click on the the drop down menu for board member name you put your name in one again you weren't David Perry as far as I can tell and it knew that that's why it stopped how about this you guys look at Thea email it's fairly simple but it's I'm I'm I'm losing track of making sure I catch all them all so what I will do is when the date closes I'm not trusting it when the date closes to have submitted requests I can get a print out from this form we can decide which is agenda review which is agenda and then I will send that to all seven
135of you so you'll know everything that's going to be on the upcoming agenda a week ahead of time and that way I don't have to worry that I've missed something okay yes sir I'm I'm still confused about whether we send uh policy changes to the agenda review or we send them to policy committee or policy actually policy uh oh here he goes yeah uh uh 2410 outlines the whole thing yes yes I ask question if this works well I'll do one for policy as well thank you okay that perfect guys I will tell you that that we've sat through budget processes before I've never felt as good as I do right now about the relationship between the board the cabinet the superintendent and the budget process I feel like we're all working together going the
136same direction so thank you I agree this is a whole lot different than last year we were so stressed out and it just kept getting worse well maybe I'll maybe I'll relax once I've done it 11 times but for now I want us to be building on what we're doing next year I want us to be building on the year after that because I want to see a new Handover our high school we done I want to see a new trash so that Laney is less crowded I want those things for this District but if we don't restore confidence in the community in our budget process we're not going to get it so okay that was all I had Dr I'm done I'm so sorry we we heard from the consultant I'm sorry I don't
137know his name that okay bouer that that and of course I know that it's the board's responsibility to bring the bond but I think that the board will do well to have cabinet and superintendent input uh we need your direction your your boots on the ground a lot more than we are we may or may not agree but we need your input and we have our our sort of our top 10 list already and already priced out for you guys okay appreciate there there was a motion to adjourn a little bit ago and M Bradford is seconding it all those in favor signify by saying I I we are aour I didn't hit it