CorpusRecord 2656

NHCS Board of Ed. Regular Board Meeting | Feb 4th, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / New Hanover County Schools
Date
2025-02-05
Location
New Hanover County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
30,909 words · about 172 min
Collected
2026-05-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001to order oh we don't have where's Miss buoy there she   is Miss buoy will you call  the role we can't hear you Mela can we please have order thank you Miss  buy will you call the rle good evening Melissa   Mason here Jayy Barnhart here Pat Bradford I  am here Jud Justice here Dr Tim Merrick here   David Perry and Pete wildbore present thank you  I will entertain a motion to approve the agenda   Madame chair Miss barnhard I'd like to make  a motion to amend the agenda to include under   new business a five minute discussion a letter of  legal action in regards to the power school breach second any discussion uh Mr Perry Miss bernhart thank you madam chair um I  would be happy to draft that so we can also adopt   a letter to DPI with

002further but this the letter  that I sent you all before the meeting started   um is in regards to legal action with py school  in reference to attorney general Jeff Jackson uh   Dr Merrick I just want to make sure that there is  no budgetary impacts of the letter that we're not   actually asking our legal team to do any work  because based on you know policy 2330 if it's   going to cost us any money we have to have it in  the published agenda so I'm not just asking to   make sure that this is not going to our lawyers  for any amount of work Mr Justice she was okay   all right uh and any further discussion on that  Amendment you can put it behind I get an answer   to my question oh uh Miss Bart um Madam chair 

003I believe that this is more Germaine under the   actual discussion of adoption of the letter but  to my knowledge no sir it would be just in pure   dialogue to encourage such thank you thank you  okay uh any further discussion all right uh all   those in favor of adding the letter regarding the  power school brief to the agenda signify by saying   I I any opposed that passes 7 to zero we adding  that is under new business see uh Mr Perry I have   a motion to amend the agenda for approximately 10  minutes to discuss uh a having a town hall before   we make any decision upon the AI pilot program  and what would that go under sir uh either new   business or old business depend whatever the  chair's discretion is I'll second that okay any   discussion Madam

004chair m b just curious about the  time for this discussion uh 10 minutes I believe   Mr said all right so hearing no discussion all  those in favor of adding a discussion about a   town hall regarding the AI is that correct yes  there might be a vote in um signify by saying I   I opposed passes 7 to zero Miss Justice uh yes  I'm I'm actually asking to take something off   the agenda um after consideration and talking to  several people involved I would like to remove the   um ad hoc committee for bus drivers at this time  I'll second at that okay any discussion hearing   none all those in favor signify by saying I  I I any opposed passes 7 to zero uh I will   entertain a motion to approve the amended agenda  so moved second right all

005those in favor signify   by saying I I any opposed that passes 7 to zero  point of clarifications just Mr we we have added   uh the letter discussion so that would be under  C so that' be C and then D would be the AI town   hall is that correct yes that is what I have all  right continuing on um we are going to have uh I'm   going to just announce all of these um first we  will have our invocation that will be done by Sam   Nolan the associate pastor of Port City Community  Church um who will be doing so remotely um and   then we will have presentation of colors which  will be done by the new hover High School ajrc um   under the direction of Captain Lance Gaither and  principal Philip Sutton and the national anthem

006um   by Jose shinos montalvin a student at new  han High School um and he will be doing the   National Anthem with Miss Bradford doing the  pledge so if we could all stand forward the invocation hello my name is Sam Nolan and I am  on staff at Port City Community church and I'm   going to be leading us in a beginning prayer  for today to Bow your heads with me Lord we   just thank you for today Father we thank  you for a chance to be in the spake Lord   for this meeting today and for these people  that are in attendance father God we thank   you for an opportunity to just serve students  and families in new han County God we give this   meeting to you we just pray for just wisdom to  discern Which choice need to

007be made Lord and   which things to go after for the health of our  schools and the health of our teachers father   God we just thank you that we get to do this  every day Lord we get to serve families in our   city Lord God and we just thank you for this  meeting and we pray this in Jesus name amen [Music] March hell I pledge allegiance nope not yet not yet sorry oh say can you see by the dawn's early  light what so proudly we ha at the Twilight   last gleaming who brought stripes and bright  stars through the paral fight for the ramp   parts we watched were so gently streaming and  the rocket red glare the bombs bursting in air G   Faith proved through the night that our flag was  still there oh s does that

008star spangled B yet wave for the land of the free and the whole of the [Applause] Brave I pledge allegiance to the flag of the  United States of America and to the Republic   for which it stands one nation under God  indivisible with liberty and justice for all sorry me than you out [Applause]   just want to make sure we give a  great big round of applause for   this brave brave soul that just  sang the national anthem good job and if I could have the ROC individuals  come back up so we can introduce you I want to see will you stand up right if you could just  say your name and yourself   I am Cadet Lieutenant Colonel Isaiah Allen I'm  the Battalion commander of new hen High School a ajrc I am Cadet staff sergeant holay um

009a  part of a ajrc Cadet first sergeant hallay a   part of the RTC program who I am Cadet Sergeant  Johnson at jltc the program at new High School oh I am con uh Sergeant Janessa Barton at  Newan over jrtc who thank you guys if you   could give another round of applause and then  real quick did I did I brutalize your name or   did I do okay did you want to introduce yourself  again yes uh my name is Jose trino montoon I   in in 11th grader as a junior at New Hanover High School um Jose was asked this evening to um  sing for us he is the only student from our   County who was selected for NC honors course  which is the Statewide honors course [Applause] all right uh I will entertain a motion to approve 

010the minute Madam chair yes M Brad just one item   the last item surely it's a mistake it says  the board meeting ended at 7:35 what which is   a record in case y'all don't know so I moved to  approve all right second all right any further   discussion hearing none all those in favor sign  by saying I I any opposed passes seven to zero recognitions a l gentlemen um I'd like to start this evening   off by inviting Dr Karen suner  to join me at the podium this evening she is the Deputy executive  director for the North Carolina Cent   for the advancement of teaching and she  has something special to share thank you   before I start with this presentation  I have to tell you that this is really   emotional for me 30 years ago I was a first 

011year teacher at New Hanover High School and   it is really it's it's wonderful to be here  so good evening members of the new han County   Schools Board of Education would Kevin  or Janet please come forward at this time woohoo on behalf of the North Carolina Center for  the advancement of teaching it is my privilege to   announce that Kevin o Janet has been selected  as a finalist for the incat 20125 buroughs   welcome fund North Carolina beginning teacher  of the year award this recognition highlights   Mr O Janet's exceptional contributions to the  teaching profession and his remarkable impact   on the students and community here in New  hanor County the beginning teacher of the   year award was established to celebrate  the creativity resilience and dedication   of firste teachers across North Carolina  each year more than 7,000 new Educators in  

012her classrooms Statewide and this award honors  those who exemplify the best of the profession   while addressing the unique challenges of  beginning teachers Kevin o Janet will be   attending a week of professional development  with his fellow finalists in March on March   27th incat will celebrate All finalists at a  recognition event on the campus of UNCC Greensboro   at incap we are committed to advancing teaching  as an art and a profession and we are thrilled to   celebrate Mr ojan as a shining example of this  Mission please join me in congratulating Kevin   o Janet on this outstanding achievement  we are pleased to provide you with this certificate recognizing you as  an incat 2020 2 buroh Welcome   fund North Carolina beginning teacher of the year [Applause] finalist in addition we invite Matt  dominelli on behalf of Empower whose   kids attend

013Porters next school on behalf of  empow to present Kevin o Janet with a check for $250 Empower supports North Carolina Educators in  their retirement investment plans and I'm thankful   for Empower support of Education in North Carolina  thank you for being here tonight to celebrate this   outstanding educator we appreciate New Hanover  County schools for recognizing Kevin o Janet   and the incat beginning teacher of the  year program thank you anywh have you all [Music] hold [Music] [Applause] wo all right we're going to keep this party  going ladies and gentlemen so tonight we're   honored to recognize an extraordinary  educator who has dedicated 20 years   to shaping young minds please join me in  celebrating Hannah Moon from Laney High School Miss moon is the 2025 buroughs welcome fun  Southeast region teacher of the year so we've got   two all

014right so Mrs Moon teaches English 2  English 4 and advanced placement literature   and her impact extends far beyond the classroom  she has served as department chair Mentor Teacher   book club adviser and a partnership teacher for  pre-service educators wow additionally she is a   distinguished member of the 2022 2025 UNCW Master  teacher program recognizing her excellence in   teaching while these accomplish ments are  impressive the true measure of Mrs Moon's   impact is the lasting impression she leaves on  her students one former student Jack Malloy now   studying at Vanderbilt University shared I have  worked with many incredible Educators but none   have rivaled my high school English teacher from  a coastal city in Southeastern North Carolina we   are thrilled to watch Miss Hannah Moon continue  her journey as she competes with eight other   Educators for the North Carolina teacher of 

015the year title best of luck Mrs Moon [Applause] y oh yep yep come on family oh there we go wo one round of applause don't go anywhere just  get get comfortable get comfortable all right ladies and gentlemen tonight we're going  to celebrate the extraordinary accomplishments of   two exceptional student athletes Sophia Cino and  Hannah Davis from New Hanover High School come on down these talented young women  made history by winning the state   championship title for the 4A  in chsaa women's tennis doubles [Applause] and at the behest of  their dedicated and hardworking   coach Jennifer Coleman along with  assistant coaches Troy McGee and   Edward Coleman if they're here we'd like  for them to join us as well please come on Sophia and Hannah formed an Unstoppable  Duo on the court their ability to anticipate   each other's movements and

016communicate seamlessly  LED them to Victory after Victory throughout the   season their trust resilience and teamwork  ultimately secured them the first state   championship title in their program's history we  are incredibly proud of your achievements and the   way you have represented our district with  determination and sportsmanship your legacy   will inspire future generations of student  athletes congratulations Sofia and Hannah [Applause] all right we're going to get all right thank you [Applause] woohoo all right continuing on please  join me in congratulating an educator   who exemplifies dedication and excellence in  gifted education Miss Sarah stansky from the   international school at Gregory our new  hver County School's Aid G teacher of the year Dr L DeWalt director of curriculum  and instruction praised Miss tansky as   dedicated to her students committed  to supporting AIG Specialists and a   key collaborator with all teachers

017at  Gregory to nurture our gifted Learners   every day her students and families Echo  the sentiment seventh grade student and   Turner shared you are my favorite teacher you make  me feel happy welcomed and like I am important   to you you always help me with whatever I  need Miss pansky now has the opportunity to   compete at the state level for the 2025 ncagt  outstanding teacher of the gifted award we   are grateful for her passion and dedication  to the education congratulations [Applause] have to get some tape on the [Laughter] floor all right we're going to continue on and  celebrate a teacher whose passion for experience   iial learning and innovation has earned him a  prestigious Statewide honor please join me in   recognizing Mr Shan Stan from Holly Shelter Middle  School who has been selected as one [Applause] of   come

018on you get to listen to me talk about  you he's been selected as one of the inaugural   Learning Happens here teacher ambassadors by the  North Carolina Department of Natural and cultural   resources Mr stanik is known for his creative  and engaging approach to education he serves as   the faculty adviser for the Surf riters Club and  the coordinator for Natural History Day last year   his students had the incredible opportunity to  compete at the national level in Washington DC   where their work was showcased in the Smithsonian  as a teacher Ambassador Shawn will collab sorry   Shawn will collaborate with dncr to integrate  North Carolina's Rich cultural historical and   natural resources into classrooms across the state  this honor highlights his dedication to public   education and we are confident that his work  will leave a lasting impact congratulations Mr St [Applause]

019all right it is with great pride  that we recognize two outstanding students   Kylie caner from Laney High School and Kaylee  Jones from Wilmington Early College High School   for being selected as state nominees for  the prestigious US Presidential Scholars Program come on down come we get to talk about  you we get to listen to me talk about you   okay so Kylie you exemplify the balance of  academic excellence and athletic dedication   your involvement in dance volleyball flag football  track and swim team alongside participation in the   chemistry Club Science Olympiad and National Honor  Society showcase your incredible talent and drive   Kaylee your leadership in the National Honor  Society and future Business Leaders of America   has demonstrated your commitment to service and  academic Excellence graduating with both a high   school diploma and Associates Degree you have set  a remarkable

020example of perseverance and ambition   we are thrilled to see both of you advance in a  competition at the national level and we eagerly   await the announcement of the US Presidential  Scholars this may congratulations ladies [Applause] congratulations [Applause] woo all right we've  got two more folks but these are they're just   amazing I'm just saying I'm just love this  job all right character is the foundation of   a positive School community and tonight we are  honor honored to recognize Luis a fifth grader   at Mary C Williams Elementary for exemplifying  outstanding character and Leadership Luis is known   for his kindness patience and welcoming Spirit as  a member of the safety patrol he greets students   and families every morning with a smile ensuring  that everyone starts their day on the right foot   in the classroom he leads by example with 

021responsibility and respect he's making his   school a place where everyone feels valued  and included Your positivity and dedication   Inspire those around you congratulations  on receiving the character in action award [Applause] yes oh Family come on up family please come on up okay get everybody in all right yeah looking at [Music] her and we have a treat for you tonight we're  going to show you the video [Laughter] [Applause] I am doing this new thing in school where I  want to talk about more than just being smart   I also want to talk about being a good person  and your names come up over and over again as   someone who works real hard at being a good  person I see Louis every morning helping us   so much get ready for our day um he's part of our  safety

022patrol um greeting families and students to   school and so he's just so consistent and kind  and just a quiet leader behind the scenes and   I love having him here at Williams always got a  smile on his face he is just so responsible and he   just trustworthy everybody enjoys talking to him  working with him are you guys give him a big old hand hello hello every and and just for a quick  little note there wasn't a dry eye in the house   after while we were filming that everyone was very  emotional and very supportive it was an amazing   time all right last but not least Mr Wayne  Dingle tonight we are exceptionally honored   for an exceptional educator whose dedication  to students extends beyond the traditional   classroom Mr Wayne Dingle a retired teacher from  Noble Middle School now

023serves a a as a beloved   substitute teacher at tras Middle School  where he has become an integral part of   the school [Applause] Community Mr Dingle is  known for his kindness reliability and ability   to make every student feel seen and valued he  takes the time to learn every student's name   building meaningful connections and providing  a supportive presence in the classroom his   adaptability and unwaver W in commitment ensure  that every class he steps into remains a positive   and respectful learning environment Mr Dingle  thank you for your commitment and your continued   service and for making a lasting impact for  students and staff alike congratulations [Applause] thank you and before we play his video I  would just like to make note that   this young gentleman was  the teacher of the student   he's the let me back up the student

024that  nominated him he taught not only her but her mother okay so we're going to see his video  real quick teaching is not really just about   subject it's about relationships with kids right  it's about relationships and building them and   knowing how to talk to kids and knowing how to  work with them and that's that's what we want   in our substitute and we really appreciate the  fact that you're willing to give part of your   retirement back to us uh to work with kids because  you we we need every good sub we can and having a   teacher come inide this wonderful having spent  31 years with the state of North Carolina as a   public school teacher I enjoy the students I  enjoy what I do I enjoy the relationships and   it's my chance to get back and

025to be active  I enjoy this school which is very open to me   and I come in everybody knows me here all of the  students all of the teachers and it's it's just a   good place to be a good relationship and it keeps  me active and busy still involved with [Music] youth thank you all for joining us and  celebrating these remarkable individuals   who enrich our schools and communities every  day let's give them one more round of applause [Applause] [Music] okay wait don't go anywhere  we got more Good Vibes coming come back up real quick all right so I'd like to invite  Miss Veronica onu up here to the front [Applause] um Miss onu is a teacher assistant at  Snipes Academy and has worked for new Handover   County school since 2005 she uh is commended  for her

026Excellence as well as being known for   her words she speaks to her faculty and staff  that evoke deep wisdom it was also mentioned   that when she stops and laughs her spirit is  contagious Miss onu has high expectations of her   students expecting their best while giving warm  demands like a mother who cares her colleagues   recognize that she celebrates hard-earned  accomplishments with a hug a smile and   reminder that a healthy struggle is worthwhile  congratulations to Miss Victoria onu for being   this quarter's recipient of the Excellence  exemplified award congratulations [Applause] and I believe she has some some special  people in her life that are here with her   also so I don't know if you'd like for them  to come up and join you with the [Music] picture get on in there congratulations thank you thank you all right

027next  I'd like to ask Mr John Williams to come forward [Applause] Please Mr Williams is a custodian  at cottington elementary he joined new Haner   County schools in August of 2023 he has been  recognized for excellence and has been described   as a magician spreading positivity wherever he  goes it's impressive Mr Williams is the first   to lend a hand take a moment to share a life  lesson and uplift everyone's Spirit he is even   known to share delightfully awful dad jokes that  undoubtedly engag students while creating a warm   caring Pleasant environment at cottington it was  shared by his colleagues that the joy he brings   to staff when we spot those perfectly vacuumed  lines on our rugs is unmatched congratulations   to Mr John Williams for being this quarter's  recipient of Excellence exemplified [Applause] [Applause]   and lastly I just wanted

028to do a um quick  introduction I want to give him a minute   to get up here um we um are very pleased  to recognize um and introduce Mr Travis   Mitchell he probably is a familiar face he's  been with the school district for about 10   years uh previously and Lead mechanic for  maintenance operations roles um as a skilled   trades supervisor and we are delighted um to  um recognize him today as our new assistant   director of Maintenance um with new County  school so congratulations and thank [Applause] you all right continuing on I'd like to  invite our student voice students to come up hello my name is Lan tamadon  and I'm a senior Isaac bear Early   College High School hi I'm Bonnie  F I'm a senior at hoger High School hello my name is Jack Sherer I a

029senior at hogri  high school and my name is Molly matthysse and I'm   also a singor at hogri high school um we want  to wish you a good evening first of all I hope   you guys had a good um past month and enjoyed all  the snow days as always we really appreciate being   able to have the opportunity to speak here um so  I'm just going to get right into it in previous   meetings we briefly discussed our discussed  our examination of policy 7300 which address   the implications of flag Banning in our community  while we recognize the intentions behind this   policy our team brought up concerns regarding its  potential impact on our schools particularly in   how it may affect both teachers and students  abilities to express their identities today   you will hear directly from New Hanover  County students

030who wish to share their   perspectives on the policy and its influence on  our school environment the leaders of the student   ambassadors have instructed the team on how to  properly conduct interviews and gather data in   the past two weeks the team has conducted more  than a 100 interviews with students and teachers   across new hver County Gathering their thoughts  concerns Gathering their thoughts concerns and   opinions on the flag Banning policy um this data  includes perspectives um from teachers across   various disciplines providing a balanced view  of how the flag policy affects both Educators   and students as well um as a range of 9th  through 12th graders um from all the high   schools with some Middle School input as well  this diverse sample allows us to present an   accurate and representative analysis on  how this policy could affect our

031school environment as far as the data collection  process a series of questions were asked   about student and teachers the ambassadors  either had the student or the teacher complete   questions on either in person or by Google form  through this we had over 108 responses from all   four traditional high schools and a as well as  Isaac bear and Mosley and had a select number   of responses as well for middle schools we've  also got perspectives from teachers as well   from across all disciplines and all four high  schools or traditional high schools at least so   providing a balanced view on the flag ban and how  this flag policy will affect both Educators and   students the diverse sample allows us to produce  an accurate account of what things look like   as far as they're concerned and how overall  across the

032schools how people feel about it so now let's let's get to the findings um  after recording the opinions of students all   across new H County 79.6% believe that flag  restrictions should be revised to allow the   display to uh to a larger variety of flags um  additionally when asked about the presence of   flags in schools 72.6% confirmed that some  of the flags being displayed were outside   of the approved flag uh flag list majority of  students also claimed that the flags either had a   positive impact or no impact on them at all  also the remaining 27.4% of students claim that   Flags uh harm the learning environment when asked  about the impact of flag restrictions on teachers   53.7% agreed that such policies negatively  affect their ability to express themselves   and or deliver course content 30.6 believe  that it

033had no effect and 15.7% were unsure the data clearly indicates that for majority  of the students flags have a positive impact   and meaningful representation participants were  also asked to give suggestions on what guidelines   or restrictions are necessary to ensure that  the policy remains respectful and inclusive   for all students majority responded that schools  should ensure that flag displays and symbols do   not promote discrimination exclusion or hate it  was also specified that Flags should not contain   offensive language political endorsements  or historical hate group symbols just as   offensive clothing is restricted inappropriate  or divisive Flags should also be regulated many   participants also feel that this policy is a  First Amendment violation in an unnecessary   restriction they believe that the representation  should be fair and balanced allowing students and   teachers to have the freedom to express their  identity without

034pressure to participate in   any display however expression should remain  respectful non-disruptive and free from harmful intent perhaps more lenient and specific  flag restrictions would be better for the   County's education system um additionally  a reporting system could be added in case   certain allowed Flags prove detrimental  to the learning environment however to   reemphasize we understand the reasoning  Behind These flag restrictions um yet we   still strongly or urge the board to refine  the wording Within These policies to be more   specific and inclusive good this would  allow for Unnecessary confrontation to   be avoided while also protecting the reasonable  expression of diversity and individuality in the classroom in the future we hope to get more  teacher input and highlight student experiences   we were also fortunate enough to meet with  Miss Barnum who connected with us with the   communications team by

035working closely with the  communications team we aim to create content that   is both informative and inspiring ensuring that  students feel heard and represented thank you if   you have any questions we would happily answer  Mr Perry thank you for your uh work um I was   just wondering if there's a report of the survey  findings that you could provide to us so that we   can review what you said yeah we will um share  with you thank you thank you anyone else thank   you guys so much oh hold on Dr Meritt I very much  appreciate not just that you're working hard and   doing things to communicate with your with your  classmates and and and across the district but   you're taking interest in policies and how they  affect you and how they affect the world and so I   appreciate

036you know it's thank you for being good  citizens thank you guys so much oh miss Justice   uh yeah and I'm going to elaborate on that because  once you're always a teacher um you sound like you   are interested in possibly changing this policy  or have it looked at again you have two routs you   can go to this gentleman here this is part of our  policy procedure you can go to this gentleman here   and present that information to him and he could  possibly bring it to our policy committee or one   of us board members and then we could bring it to  the policy committee so I'm just telling you that   if you are interested in changing it to make it  more holistic and practical for the schools which   is what it sounds like you're referring to um 

037those are your options thank thank you guys so [Applause] much and for Teacher  voice we have Emerald Boyd from Mosley I have slides so it's us awkward like  to change the slide because as a teacher I like   to move and have a clicker so I'm not used to  being at a Podium but hi I it's okay I'm going   um I am Emerald Boyd and I'm going to talk about  postsecondary transition planning in action you   can go that's me look cute um so I'm a special  education teacher by trade I have my undergrad   from UNCW and my masters from Western Carolina  University I'm loud I have the teacher voice um   and I also got you can't hear me now better okay  uh and I also am national board certified so just   some fun facts about me

038um I wanted to talk about  my teaching philosophy and I root that in advocacy   um so I believe that advocating for our students  is how all of our students move forward and we   maintain those high expectations for all of our  students including our most impacted students   so I wanted to tell you about my dayto day first  and then I'm going to tell you about something   else that I really love doing as a part of my  teaching program um so I am currently at Mosley   as you heard and I am with our new Handover  County transition program for young adults or   tpy as you'll hear us refer to it quite a bit I'm  not going to read our whole mission statement but   our mission is to get our individuals with  disabilities out in the community be

039that   soft entrance into the community so that they  are members of the community when they leave   us with skills ideally gainful employment and  it's a really really great program this year   we have doubled um so we have doubled in size  and have gone from three teachers to five and   now we support 40 individuals that we are  working to successful transition into the   community so who we serve we serve students in  new han County Schools uh 18 to 21 years old   and they have completed their traditional four  years of high school can you still hear me let   me know um and they are on our extended  content standards so they are working   towards a certificate versus a diploma so  they are really our population that needs   that targeted intervention for transition support  when they leave us

040so and then our curriculum and   Community Based instruction uh we have the luxury  of being in our community almost every single day   we are out and about working on these five  domains so our main domains are independent   living community particip participation goodness  employment functional academics and post-secondary   Pathways so a snapshat of our day we arrive at  school we'll do a targeted lesson on whatever   we're doing in the community that day and then we  are on the city bus getting there and working so   we went to the ability Garden this week to learn  about planting and we actually plant a lot of the   plants that y'all buy plant Sals out in the  community that is our program that supports   a lot of that but at school we'll do a lesson on  that how we get there

041how we safely get there how   what it means to be responsible and why we need to  work and is it something we like CU we need to do   a job we like right um and then we will make our  way back to school debrief and then go about our   day so any of our days might be looking at any of  these different Pathways but our Big Goal really   is that independent living and employment on the  Continuum that students are able to next um we   have lots of Partners in the community and we're  very very happy to have them love to grow them   if anyone ever wants to work with us we're a joy  I promise um but we have Partnerships across the   entire Community we have Partnerships at Kate Fear  Community College UNCW especially within

042Watson   but across their campus we're starting to get into  wck therapy and we work with health and PE and   student services and then broadening we also have  employment placements across the county but also   within our youan County Schools district so we  work within the warehouse and within um some of   our cafeterias our students will be working there  so really great thing so that's that's my day   today that's what I do on a daily basis I support  individuals with disabilities it's a ton of fun I   have the best job in the community don't fight me  I'll win um but we have had lots of opportunities   we love to work with Community Partners we would  love to add to the list so Shameless plug um and   then I wanted to talk about my another part of  my

043teaching that was surprising but something I'm   really really passionate about and really really  enjoy um I am a part of our New Hanover County   emerging leaders and I have been fortunate enough  to get to work through this program and I'm on my   second year so I am developing a pathway project  again Shameless plug applications will be coming   out soon for this and I encourage any educator  who might be interested to do it but as part of   this we get to basically pick a passion project  that we get to focus on I love postsecondary   transition as you saw it's my day-to-day job um  so last year I organized a um family information   night that we hosted 20 agencies and we added  a campus creation showcase on there where um   our different school we had different schools 

044show their school-based Enterprise and what   they were doing and sell them to the community  um it's coming up again the second annual will   be in May and then the second part of this is  I decided hosting an event is great I got to   learn a lot about the agencies but when I was a  beginning teacher I didn't know where to look for   information about agencies in the community other  than agency websites because it's overwhelming and   no one has enough time in their day to be able  to do that so my part two of my emerging pathway   project is emerging leader pathway project sorry  is I have created a hub of online professional   development and each of these that has a hyperlink  on them hyperlinks to a Google doc that teachers   can access and it has

045videos provided by these  agencies about who they serve what they serve and   basically information to help teachers communicate  to parents and family that this is available and   ready to go for them next slide so it's pretty  simple it works like this um there's a video   they watch it they enjoy they do some reflection  and there's additional resources for teachers to   access and then work to get PD credit for it and  through that um these are the local agencies that   have so far been pres or presented for it for  the on demand um professional development and   then we've also had College professors present  and different classroom management to work to   transition because the goal for all teachers  is we want our kids to be successful outside   our classroom so we're working towards that  and it's there

046and it's great and that's it thanks board members did anybody have any question  questions comments Miss Barnhart I just want to   say thank you I'm very passionate when we have a  passionate person like yourself in the district   to be able to um share that information is so is  going to be so impactful not only to the teachers   but our students and our fam so I appreciate  that I love to hearing about you being able to   help grow the program because that means we're  supporting those many those double amount of   kids and so I appreciate uh your leadership on  this I just want to say that Mr will deor and   I would just like to reiterate uh say thank  you also I think you know obviously you are   a passionate teacher we need more like you

047uh  throughout the school system we have some great   great teachers but I mean you know what you do  for those students each and every day uh from   the bottom of my heart all I can say is thank you  it's really fun like I said it's best job in the   county and I I wouldn't argue that either um that  population is has a special place in my heart and   I love every year being able to go to the tpy  graduation it is one of the sweetest graduations   you could possibly go to um and most personal  and so thank you absolutely thank you thanks guys all right moving on our interim  superintendence report good evening   everybody and I'm G to terrify Miss baggie for  a second by going off script before I go to my   uh super

048tennis report we've been here for an hour  and all we've talked about are the amazing student   and faculty here in this County and so that's  what I'm so proud about this District being about   is celebrating the amazing work that's being done  every day in our classrooms and in our schools so   thank you again for for being a part of that  but uh it takes us that long to talk about   the amazing things that we're doing all right so  good evening board members tonight I'm honored to   share the incredible work happening across Newan  County Schools uh first things first I want to   begin by celebrating one of our own assistant  superintendent Julie vno Julie if you canet B hold on folks you don't know what you're  clapping about yet Julie has been honored   with the North

049Carolina Council for exceptional  children distinguished service award and this   recognition reflects her unwavering leadership  and commitment to advancing services for students   with disabilities through her efforts we have  not only improved policies but it have enhanced   the daily experiences of countless students J  congratulations on this well-deserved [Applause] honor we also want to let you know soon we will  be having the exciting privilege of surprising   this year's finalists for this year's North  Car New New Hanover County Schools Rookie of   the Year award this recognition is a testament to  the talent and dedication of our newest Educators   who are shaping the future of our students and  we forward to celebrating them and the passion   they bring to their classrooms this month we  have to recognize several different groups   of people First National School counseling  week is this week

050thank you thank you to our   school counselors for their unwavering supportive  students academic social and emotional well-being feed so I want you guys go home with your hands  hurting um February is also Career and Technical   education or CTE month we celebrate the Hands-On  learning and career ready skills that our CTE   programs provide and the staff that guide students  success I want to remind you that tomorrow is   World read aloud day and it's a reminder to share  the JY of reading and storytelling February of   course is Black History Month and it's a time  to reflect on and celebrate the achievements   and contributions of black Americans in our  schools communities and Beyond next week thank you next week is SCH school bus driver  appreciation week and if you have not   ridden on a bus recently trust me

051you  appreciate these people absolutely   we want to recognize the dedication of  our drivers in safely transporting our   students every day also on February 15th is  national school resource officer day and we   want to thank the sheriff's department and the  officers who help keep our schools safe every day as we continue to plan for the  future we are in the midst of our   budget listening sessions to gather valuable  input that will got our financial priorities   for the next school year this process ensures  that the voices of Educators and stakeholders   are heard as we make strategic decisions for  the district in the coming days we're going   to be engaging with assistant principles  and later this week we will do a similar   budget activity with the board on Friday by  the end of this month I will share

052the key   takeaways and the budget superintendent budget  priorities that emerg from these discussions   finally I want to address the power school  data breach in our ongoing efforts to SPO   those who have been affected to assist impacted  individuals Experian is providing a dedicated call   center to answer questions and guide you through  the enrollment process for protection services   those affected are going to be receiving a  notification letter from power school with   instructions on how to access these resources we  have more up-to-date information if you like it   we encourage families to visit our power school  data breach page under the Community tab at our   website as we move forward I want to thank  each and every one of you for your continued   commitment to students and staff the work we do  every day whether it's in classrooms boardrooms  

053or behind the scenes shapes the success of all  of our district together we are making a lasting   impact on students I'd like to also remind you  that there is a onepage synopsis of all the stuff   we talk about back there on the desk if you'd like  to take that home with you we'd like to have you   dig deeper into some of the things we're talking  about tonight now apparently I invite you to take   a moment to watch the video on your screens which  highlights some of the impactful initiatives we've   been working on across the district this  is our quarter in review [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music]   what [Music] [Applause] [Music] that concludes my report thank you thank you Dr  Barnes um and now we will move on to the board   chair report uh good evening

054I hope everyone  had an opportunity to enjoy the snow um I'm   from New York so it really wasn't that much for  me but um I hope everybody had the opportunity   to enjoy it a few weeks ago four members of the  board including myself and Dr Barnes attend Ed an   ncsba Ethics conference it was a very informative  conference with many opportunities to connect with   board members from other parts of the state and I  was Greatful for the chance to attend this month   um I had the opportunity to visit a few more  schools and I just wanted to share some of the   things that are happening we've heard all the big  things I wanted to talk about and highlight some   of the little things that are happening that  are really not even little they are definitely   impactful

055so my first visit was to Isaac bear um  and I was absolutely delighted to see several of   the amazing teachers we have one that I wanted  to highlight was Miss Talbert who teaches 9th   grade ELA she brought memes into the classroom and  used vocabulary to practice so stud students were   tasked with writing words such as lacad isical  hack needed and abscond on the Whiteboard next   to an applicable meem meme then they were asked  to explain their reasoning and I thought this   was a great way to improve student vocabulary and  apply it to real life um she was just one of the   examples and I just absolutely wanted to highlight  how she made it relevant for our kids my next stop   was to roll in Grace and I I have visited as a  parent but this

056was a different visit as a board   member um and it was delightful to hear from  staff about all the amazing things that are   happening there and one thing that they wanted to  highlight was the Mastery class that happened so   this was developed initially to ensure that our  EC students had the opportunity to participate   in electives they enjoyed rather than solely on  the four content areas that they're tested on   the class occurs 5 days a week for all students  but on Wednesdays there is a schoolwide focus on   various skill development such as organization  note-taking and test preparation the schoolwide   focus has been beneficial to the students who  attend and has provided cons consistency across   the grades and my third stop was to Alderman and  it was on a professional development day which   was great I got

057to watch a fantastic presentation  from staff members to other staff members sharing   strategies and resources and my favorite idea that  they shared was the idea of a secret student where   a student was picked at random the name was  hidden and at the end of the day they kind of   calculated how the behavior was and the next day  if that student had excellent Behavior had done   a great job they got a reward some of it was  sitting in a comfy chair some of it was on a   special desk but I just thought it was a great way  to reward our kids and not have to spend any money   but reinforcing that positive student behavior  um last Thursday three board members including   myself had the chance to watch some amazing  amazing math Scholars as they competed in

058math   counts and let me tell you it was very humbling  to sit there um sitting through the speed round   definitely highlighted the wonderful mathletes  in our district with the winner of the speed   round being a young lady woohoo from Roland Grace  the overall winning team was from Murray Middle   School who will be continuing on to the regional  competition congratulations to all the winners   and lastly I would like to apologize to my  fellow board members for not clarifying the   flexibility in the committee assignment  document I'm not perfect and I'm grateful   for the grace extended to me as I work through  the beginning Growing Pains I look forward to   focusing on the needs of our staff student and  families in this community our duty has been and   will continue to be on the betterment of our  schools

059and while we may not always agree on   the how our goals should always be a stronger  District safer schools and the best education   this concludes my chair report all right  moving forward Ward I'm going to hand it   over to miss Barnhart for the call to audience  thank you madam chair first up is Reverend Dante Murphy members of the board I stand before  you today to demand accountability and transparency and instead of cons  hiring or considering the hiring of   Dr Christopher bnes I want to propose  that you should be discussing his termination it is both strange and  suspicious to me Madam chair point of inquiry   could you please pause the time Miss  Bradford looking at our policy code 23 10   public participation at board members at board  meetings it says under item C complaints about   the

060performance of school Personnel should be  submitted initially for response to the school   system official responsible for the program or  the facility or the superintendent has that been done not to my knowledge excuse me Madam chair if that hasn't been done  then we're we're not following our policy by   making a complaint about one of our Personnel here  in an open meeting without following the proper   procedure Madam chair since I've been interrupt um  I hold on I will allow you to continue to speak so   long as you follow the rules of decorum so um you  can continue to have I'm not making a complaint   against staff I'm making a complaint against V  okay go ahead so what is your determination cuz   I don't want to be violating what Miss Bradford  has raised if you are complain if

061you are talking   about the board then you can go ahead absolutely  are you all right with that Miss Bradford as long   as you don't talk about one of our person one of  our one of our employees okay go ahead uh do I   get my two minutes started over can we restart  the time okay go ahead members of the board   Lord I stand before you today to demand  accountability and transparency instead   of you considering the hiring of Dr Christopher  Barnes you should be discussing his termination   it is both strange and suspicious to me that Dr  Charles fa was deemed unfit to continue leading   this district and we along with us agree with  that decision yet you same adamant to quickly   now turn the system over to the administration  that was handpicked by Dr fa to carry

062out his   deeds furthermore the new head of County board  of education has the lawful right and more   importantly the obligation to investigate subpoena  staff and board members and put them under oath   to to resolve serious allegations that I actually  outlined and sent to each of you in an email these   matters cannot be ignored dismissed or swept under  the road failure to act sends a clear message that   you are no different than top administrators and  former board members who allowed multiple children   over multiple years to be sexually abused by  multiple perpetrators that is unacceptable   the people of this County demand Integrity in  leadership we demand that you reject Dr Barnes   hiring and move to fin a superintendent who is  not tied to Dr Charles fa and put some of this   confusion to rest the choice is

063yours but make no  mistake the people are watching and based on how   you all get along you'll be watching each other  thank you thank you Natasha to Natasha to Leslie posie ex good evening last week you had a  presentation about a security system system that   relies on AI generated information the presenters  made a big deal about how the product doesn't use   facial recognition information but one of the  highlighted features is that the program can   give an alert if there is someone on campus who  isn't supposed to be there how can it know who's   not supposed to be on campus if it doesn't have  a file of who is also facial recognition was on   almost every slide in their presentation since  all of our students have their pictures taken   at some point Point installing that information 

064would be very easy I could go into more detail   but instead I'd like to give you an example  of AI learning Amazon launched the AI device   Alexa in 2014 there were and continue to be lots  of admonitions about how Alexa isn't listening   or learning she only turns on when you say her  name we have an Alexa it's great for music as   in a timer we also know that she listens one of  our favorite authors is scientist Rachel Carson   we even named two family members after her our  daughter Rachel is an environmental attorney   Carson is a dog Miss Carson comes up  periodically in conversations about   a year ago I got an alert from Alexa I found  a new book by Rachel L Carson that you might   like um the scientist Rachel Carson didn't  use a middle

065initial and she died in 1964   so I don't think Alexa found a new book by  her my point is AI is still new AI is still   still learning the presenters last week made  a big deal about not storing information but   as I said facial recognition was on almost  every slide I urge you to think long and   hard before you sign on to Predators I mean  Raptor's product thank you Sandy [Applause] Isles for the past 5 years I've been speaking here  for just about every month advocating for policies   that protect children when I was advocating to  ban the use of seclusion restraint the number   one question I got was what are teachers supposed  to do if they can't seclude kids and now it and   now it's what do we do if we can't suspend them  and

066how will they ever learn accountability those   are legitimate questions and a big part of my  advocacy over the years has been trying to be   solution focused I truly believe that if we do  what's best for children we inherently do what's   best for staff and taking away solution even  a bad one without replacing it with something   better is not what is best for students or staff  which is why I'm so excited that new han County   Schools is rolling out reframing Behavior across  all of our schools so that our staff have a better   solution this trauma informed nor Divergent  affirming and neuroscience-based model not only   helps adults reframe how they support children  but it prioritizes their well-being reframing   Behavior recognizes that adults cannot support  children if they themselves are not taken care of   I understand our staff

067are overwhelmed and  stretched to their Max but I hope that they   will Embrace this evidence-based resource I hope  they will push past any fears or skepticism and   recognize that what we're doing is not working  for them or our students we must do something   different if we want better outcomes and we  must be part of the solution most of all I   want this resource to bring staff hope that  we can improve the culture and safety in our   schools and I want them to feel empowered  when responding to challenging behaviors   this is not not a quick fix it will take  time to see positive results and because   of that I hope that new han County Schools  will invest at least 3 to 5 years into this   model doing so will allow our staff to fully  Embrace and

068master their new skills so that   they can confidently and effectively support  our children thank you thank you miss Karen Clark I am very grateful to the board for  wisdom and to Dr Barnes for continuing as   our superintendent the word of the Lord do not be  afraid for I have ransomed you I have called you   by name you are mine when you go through deep  Waters I will be with you when you go through   rivers of difficulty you will not drown when  you walk through the fire of Oppression you   will not be burned the Flames will not consume  you for I am the Lord your God your savior   you are precious to me you are honored and I love  you for I have chosen you don't be afraid for I am   with you don't be discouraged

069for I am your God I  will strengthen you and help you I will hold you   up with my Victorious right hand everything  I plan will come to pass I have said what I   would do and I will do it those who trust in me  will never be put to shame I will fight those   who fight you and I will save your children no  weapon turned against you will succeed you will   silence every voice raised against you these  benefits are enjoyed by the Servants of the   Lord their Vindication will come from me there  is is nothing compared to what I am going to   do for I am about to do something new see I have  already begun do you not see it thank you Dr Jamie Pond good evening for the past several years  I've attended

070board of Education meetings and   I've participated in call the audience many times  I've seen the call to audience go from the time of   3 minutes to two to a lottery system that we have  right now now there's a discussion about whether   board members should curb groups from taking up  too much time for call to the audience what is   interesting to me when it comes to this issue is  how would this be regulated who is being silenced   based on my observations it appears that the  board is attempting to silence love our children   for at least the past two years I've seen these  speakers advocate for five six and seveny olds   but unfortunately and again it appears to me  that the board hasn't been listening to them   so instead they regularly attend and speak  if it wasn't

071for them I'm sure many people   would not know these concerning practices and  policies in new han County Schools I recommend   that you please listen to their concerns and  allow for call to audience to remain the same   don't infringe upon their rights to organize and  speak and thank you for your time thank you Chris suon I had an entire speech written but I'm  going be completely honest that is absolutely   frustrating that you're going to stop that man  while he's speaking like that Miss Bradford that   is absolutely frustrating go ahead and look at  her go ahead and stop the time go ahead I have   every bit to redress my people this is North  Carolina General statute right here we have   public we have public meetings we're allowed  to speak I understand you've been against call   audience since

072the beginning you took away one  third of our speaking roles you're trying to   take their ability away to speak separately  this is ridiculous over and over y'all keep   doing this to us I had a whole speech about the  AI program and how we need a town hall I tried   discussing stuff with teacher voice allowing  teachers to be up here and sign up and not have   to go through the same call to audience this is  ridiculous you want to talk about following the   policies now you know you know what I'm talking  about this is so frustrating you cannot pick and   choose when to follow our policies even with  this call to audience stuff God what are you   afraid of right now we might have the majority  as conservatives but the fact remains one day   we might

073not be in the majority we might be  the descending voice up here and you should   be doing everything in your power to make sure  that voice is protected you're not doing your   job I'm so frustrated that this just happened  tonight you know how many times I've gotten up   here and said something about Dr F I love Dr  Barnes I don't even agree with him I want him   to be the next superintendent but I will fight  for that man's right to come up here and descent   amicably he sent you an email because I received  it he cced me on the email I am so frustrated I   had I had this whole speech it was going to be  nice we were gonna play real nice hunky dory   tonight this committee assignment stuff if y'all  go on a

074Witch Hunt Watch What Happens I promise   you I'm going to make it my mission to expose  all of the BS drama behind the scenes n Mila   that speaks man who greets with fire I promise  you if y'all turn this into a mudslinging there   will be muds slung back y'all have a good  night thank you Christina Mercer [Applause] good evening whether you believe we live in  a republic or democracy the United States has   always attempted sometimes better than others to  give a voice to minorities over the years one way   minorities have been given a voice is through  having a day week or month of recognition these   observances have helped right the wrong of Decades  of minorities being overlooked for significant   contributions they've willingly or unwillingly  made to the USA in fact many of the contribu   are

075so significant they have found their way into  State and national public school curricula for   example the North Carolina High School American  history curriculum has standards that include   the impact of women and other minority groups on  American society the effects of domestic conflicts   that Target the specific groups of people  and how racism oppression and discrimination   against minorities impacted America in order  to continue to effectively teach our history   we must continue to observe and celebrate our  American minority groups even if we aren't   part of that group some of the most significant  months are African-American history in February   women's history in March arab-american Heritage  in April Asian and Pacific Islander month in May   pride month in June disability pride in July  Hispanic heritage in September and October and   Native American Heritage in November all these  minorities have had

076a huge impact on the shaping   of the United States and observing them should  not be seen as an interruption to learning but   as education itself as a speaker said last month  the new federal Administration is interested in   putting America First recognizing the minority  groups that help to build the nation yet we're   oppressed and often still are oppressed  is the best way to show that America has   placed a priority on recognition and inclusion  May these observations teach everyone about   empathy as well please support the schools as they  participate in these observations thank you Lany Cooper Laney Cooper [Applause] is Carrie Bogart here good evening I'm Caroline Bogard I live  and vote in Hanover County I've attended a   couple of uh board meetings in the past  but this is the first time speaking to the   board I'm

077very concerned about the secrecy  surrounding the seclusion in our schools   and I find it to be very concerning on November  1st 2022 the board revised regulation 4302 on   the rules for the use of seclusion and restraint  in schools the revision said quote as of the year   20124 school year rooms designated specifically  for seclusion will no longer be operational for   seclusion unquote for some reason the board didn't  vote to end the use of seclusion in other words   kids could still be secluded but not in the  locked padded closets so my question for you   tonight is where are you putting the kids  who are being secluded now North Carolina   statute 115c hyen 3911 on the permissible use of  seclusion and restraint states that the space must   be appropriately lighted ventilated heated and  cooled also the space must

078be free of objects   that unreasonably expose a student to harm for  himself or others and most importantly the space   must be approved by the local Education Agency  based on the horrible history of hundreds of   seclusions in New Hanover County in recent years  the public who funds the school system through   taxes and votes for or against you has a right  to know the truth is out there and I hope that   Dr Barnes will share that information at next  month's meeting thank you thank you you twin far here I he my name I'm Sorry  Miss Cooper come on up okay thank you good evening my name is malany Cooper I am  the founder of speak your peace North Carolina   I'm a poet and we create platforms that advocate  for social justice through the Arts and the name  

079of this poem is called stay woke in light of  black history and all of the ugly things that   are happening here in this country and  in this County stay woke we are living   in an age that systemic racism hasn't changed  living in these overt times it's clear no one   on the school board represents black children  here truly it's been over a decade 12 whole   years the numbers always speak 60% of black  children are suspended it's 56 and seven year   olds to be clear and specific when only 18% of  us attend new Handover County Schools is there   something I'm missing for those at home who are  tuning in when you educate your children on the   reality of this system you break the change of  their covert Mission which which is the pipeline   to prison I want

080to take a moment to remember  all the students that never graduated from New   Hanover County schools because they went straight  from the classroom to the pipeline to prison I   encourage everyone to stay woke anyone who is  here who may not be having side conversations   with their children to teach them the truth  Baba Malcolm X said paraphrasing it you're   only a fool will allow for his enemies to educate  your children and we are foolish if we think that   people on this board represent the black voice  stay woke thank you thank you twin far twink bar hello my name is twink bar I taught first and  second grades for 20 2 years I live in Wilmington   and this is my first time speaking to the board  board committees policy 2230 states that the   purpose of committees is

081to conduct thorough  deliberations and investigations of issues and   informing and recommending action to the board as  appropriate well I attended the policy committee   two weeks ago and sat right there and it was clear  that when they discussed short-term suspension   policy 4351 no one had read the policy recently  after a 15minute discussion a final revision   was approved that states principles or their  designes shall attempt to contact parents as   soon as possible when a suspension determination  is made how could no one know that that language   was already in the policy policy 4 4351 already  States the principal or design shall provide the   students parents or Guardian with notice that  includes the reason for the suspension and the   principal or design must give the notice by the  end of the work day during which the suspension   is imposed

082when reasonably possible but in no  event more than two days after the suspension is imposed send policy 4351 back to  the policy committee and have them   actually read it so they can conduct thorough  deliberations and investigations of the issues   before bringing it Reverend coju n Tambo Reverend coju n Tambo am I saying that   correctly I don't know they  here all right Miss Jenny Simmons okay thank you Peter good afternoon I'm Dr Virginia Simmons I've been  an educator for well over 50 years now I've been   a teacher a professor an administrator I've lived  in and worked in three states and nine countries   so what I'm bringing to you is I've earned degrees  those first degrees were in elementary education   English and social studies then the next four  were master's degree and they were in behavior   disorders

083learning disabilities gifted in special  education and then I did a teaching of a second   language I have been honored with the who who in  education for the North Carolina tag and um I have   an honorary degree from my University which  is West Virginia State University which is a   historical black University I live in Wilmington  and this is my first first time getting to talk   to you all and I'm going to look at my notes cuz  I love to talk so I got to stay on on the thing   okay I want to talk about five six and seven  year olds because I've worked with them all   over the world in all sorts of situations first  of all they're good they're good kids and they're   doing the best they can sometimes they make  mistakes like I do

084sometimes they like skills   and have difficulty meeting uh the expectations  of the classroom like I do sometimes the thinking   part of their brain shuts down and it goes into  Pro protection mode in the extreme cases when   a child is in danger of hurting themselves or  others it makes sense to have a trusted adult   highly qualified and certified teacher or school  counselor or someone who's specially trained work   with a child in a specific location in  thank you your time up the school Linda [Applause] harutan good evening my name is Linda  herian and it is my first time uh speaking before   this board I'd like to begin by asking what the  difference is between two sentences principles or   their designes shall attempt to contact parent  Guardians before a suspension determination is   made and the sentence principls or

085their designes  shall attempt to contact parents Guardians as soon   as possible when a suspension determination is  made in the first sentence the parent or Guardian   might speak with an administrator before he or  she has officially decided decided to suspend   the child in the second sentence the parent  or Guardian might speak with an administrator   after he or she has decided to suspend their  child as the mother of three sons one of whom   is differently dis differently abled I would  have wanted to the opportunity to hear what   happened and be able to ask some questions such  as were any positive behavioral Alternatives   tried with my child are there other behavioral  Alternatives that the school could have used with   my child it is even possible that the parent  Guardian has some current information about   their child that sheds

086light on his or her  behavior then at the end of the conversation   the administrator can make an informed decision  that is based on all the available information   information this seems like the only fair and  decent approach to addressing a situation of   this type that is in the best interest of all  involved thank you thank you Bob Boart Bob Bogart evening this is my first  time speaking before the board   the policy consensus is on the agenda tonight  no doubt there'll be some discussion about the   short-term suspension policy here's what I predict  no one will discuss the out of school suspension   data no one will discuss the disproportionate  number of black and special education to children   that are being suspended no one will ask about the  16 stool schools that have zero K to2 suspensions   and how

087they're able to keep their kids learning  in school school no one will discuss the research   that shows how suspensions harm children  no one will discuss the Positive Behavior   Support Alternatives that can be used instead of  suspensions someone will remind everyone how hard   it is to reach parents on the phone someone will  say that using the word before instead of as soon   as possible will take away the authority of the  principles it's not true some members will not   acknowledge that the proposed language is already  part of the current policy some members will   recognize that five six and seven-year-old are  developmentally different from 15 16 and 17 year   olds and that actually two different suspension  policies are needed hopefully someone will make   a motion to send a policy back to the committee  where they can have thorough

088deliberations and   investigations of this important issue thank you  thank you Reverend Kelly weed Rivers [Applause] hello all my name is Reverend Kelly wheat rivers  from the unarian Universalist Congregation of   Wilmington I'm here to speak about policy  4300 and out of school suspensions as   Unitarian universalists we actually have a lot  of different beliefs but we have shared values   love is the power that holds us together and is  at the center of our shared values our deepest   common theological Foundation is love student  Behavior policy 4300 States Student Admin School   administrators will utilize Positive Behavior  Support alternatives to suspensions and only   use outof School suspensions as a last resort on  the topic of out of school suspensions I've been   thinking about the 16 schools that had zero out  of school suspensions for five six and seveny olds   during

089the first half of this year so my question  is which Positive Behavior Support alternatives   are those schools using and which Alternatives  have been the most effective can these be   evaluated and implemented more universally  instruction in conflict resolution individual   or small group sessions with the school counselor  and restorative practices sound much more loving   than kicking out our youngest Learners  sometimes kids fight as a mom I'm very   aware of that when they're only five six  or seven years old it makes more sense to   help them in school where our professional  staff there can provide support and services   to address their social emotional and  behavioral needs a little more love   could go a long way towards helping these  kids learn and Thrive thank you thank you Carla Johnson Carla Johnson hi everyone good evening my name  is KLA

090Johnson and this is my first time   speaking before the board consider the  sentence principles or their design shall   attempt to contact parents or Guardians  before a suspension determination is made   which part of that sentence jeopardizes an  administrator's ability to create a safe   and effective learning environment first the  principal attempts to contact the parent or   Guardian a reasonable number of attempts might  be two phone calls a phone call and a text maybe   two phone calls and a text if the administrator is  successful there's a conversation with the parent   or Guardian at the end of which he or she decides  if a suspension is the appropriate consequence   policy 4351 currently says that the principal or  design has the authority to impose a suspension   now if the administrator is unable to contact the  parent or Guardian after two

091or three attempts he   or she decides if a suspension is the appropriate  consequence but without that conversation don't   be afraid of the word before it simply provides  the possibility that the parent or Guardian will   talk with an administrator before a suspension  determination is made again consider the sentence   principles or their designes shall attempt to  contact parents or Guardians before a suspension   determination is made good communication with  parents or Guardians will help to create a safe   and effective learning environment thank you  for your time thank you Veronica McLaren Brown Veronica this month love out children NC is  celebrating four years of advocating for the   end of exclusionary discipline we are a nonprofit  organization dedicated to improving School Board   policies so that all children can stay in school  where they can learn and Thrive we're grateful to  

092all the individuals and organizations that take  the time to speak on behalf of our five six and   seven year olds we use research and data to  inform policy recommendations we also listen   to Educators parents students other community  members and even Schoolboard members and the   interim superintendent we recently reviewed the  K2 out of school suspension data for the first   semester with Dr Barnes and Mr willber and others  we appreciate the progress the principles the   teachers and staff have made towards reducing the  number of suspensions of our five six and seven   year olds as love our children We Begin it as love  our children begins its fifth year of advocacy   we believe that there will be more opportunities  to share data and exchange ideas we also believe   that the policies should set the high Bar for our 

093students for what's best for all of our students   policy should focus on student Achievements not  their failures high standard of performance for   students should be non-negotiable a lack  of funding a lack of resources or a lack   of personnel should not determine what's in a  policy a lack of funding a lack of resources or   lack of personnel should not determine what's in  a policy policy should be B based on our highest   expectations for our children and the teachers  and staff that serve them thank you Nelson Boer good evening in 2018 the Trump Administration  implemented the barbaric grotesque Act of   separating the children of immigrants from their  parents the president did so by his own admission   as an act of deterrence so if you think the idea  of ice in our schools is abstract you simply have  

094not been paying attention this is the not messing  around Administration I was plead I was pleased   to read in a recent article that Dr Barnes is  gathering information before implementing policy   but it's the board's job to set policy so here is  some information that might help you do so some   while you gather information might insist that you  must assist in federal law enforcement immigration   that you risk criminal and civil exposure by not  doing so and this is of course patently absurd I   would uh refer Dr or Mr Perry to uh prince versus  us which said would stated very clearly that the   the state of Texas did not have to enforce federal  gun law some will tell you you lose critical   funding if you don't comply but again this is  absurd if you look at 2012

095uh Cil uh nfib versus   silius you'll see that the federal government has  no way to use its Federal funding power to induce   action on your part these cases and countless  other precedents make it clear the choice to   allow immigration enforcement into our schools is  100% yours it won't be Trump's fault it won't be   isa's fault it will be yours and it will be your  responsibility Miss Justice Mr Merck I asking you   to put this issue on the agenda and answer and  answer a simple and direct question will you   allow ice to conduct immigration enforcement  operations on new Handover property schools   unless you don't want to mess with the agenda I'd  remind you that in May of this past year you put   a flag item on an agenda for something  that happened a 100 miles away

096Angie KY last Friday the North Carolina Supreme Court  unanimously ruled that the look back window of   the safe child Act is constitutional giving adult  victims of sexual assault two more years to file   charges against their abuser this is a win as it  allows us to move forward in pending cases and   because this is the same act that gave a voice  to the majority of Michael Kelly's victims in   the previous civil suit against New Hanover County  School for protecting pedophiles over students the   same school system that perpetuated Decades of  abuse by ignoring red flags and complaints then   challenged whether too much time had passed by for  victims to be able to share their testimony and   seek Justice fortunately those Brave survivors  continued to fight and their courage was a key   factor that led to this Court's

097ruling many of you  will say well I wasn't here then it's not my fault   but you are here now and you are responsible  for the push back against Title 9 work done   previously and moving for forward in an effort to  make our school safer the strides that were made   to improve title n and protect students are now  being attacked in your perverse quest to Target   lgbtq plus kids you would rather inflict harm on  marginalized students than to keep students safe   this was the goal of the victims in the settlement  to prevent a repeat of this trauma yet you seemed   set on another multi-million dollar lawsuit the  number of title n cases have not decreased they're   being diverted back to the schools which is what  led to these scandalous sexual assaults to begin   begin with and

098you continue to ignore Title 9  federal law I applaud Miss Mason for attempting   to be objective in assigning committees but  perhaps appointing people in the community   that have actually advocated for title n rights  and sexual assault victims and have knowledge   of prevention from experience my guess is that  the district doesn't like the transparency and   accountability that their voices would bring in  the next round at least we have the safe child   act intact and strong case law from the Kelly  case to protect students and allow the window   for them to process the trauma inflicted by  school this school's negligence thank you Peter WT first I want to acknowledge our Elementary  School principles Educators and staff for the   excellent work they have done to reduce out of  school suspensions for five six and seveny olds   for the

099first half of the school year two weeks  ago Dr Barn shared some data with Veronica and   me it is the best K2 data we have seen to date  well done I hope you will continue to offer your   staff training that promotes the use of Positive  Behavior Support alternatives to suspensions and   I also hope your budget for next year includes  money for additional teachers teachers teacher   assistants school counselors social workers  and highly qualified and certified in school   suspension teachers oh yeah the pay pay raises  and and I worry about your prek their staffs   have been gutted money is needed to rehire prek  teachers for the positions that were cut and   you must address the endless disparity between  suspensions of black black students and their   white peers next I want to publicly acknowledge  that Mr wildbore has

100met with Veronica and me   three times during the past four years for  respectful conversations and an exchange of   ideas thank you finally this school board has one  of the best call to the audience opportunities   of any County in this state it's 60 Minutes has  up to 25 speakers it's early in the evening and   most importantly it's before any policy vote  is taken don't silence our voices thank you   thank [Applause] you going back around to who is  not here in Atasha to and Reverend coou nen Tambo   all right all right thank you uh  board would we like a five minute   motion yet break all right we are in  a five minute break please return by 653 thank you is this the sign you guys use for e e e board members if you could  return to

101the dis please   board members return to the dis and Dr Barnes board members please return to the Das there's only four three that we don't have a   we don't have a form can't  complain about me this time we don't have a quorum so Dr Merrick Miss Bradford  Miss Justice Mr wildor and Dr Barnes all right we have a quorum uh we are  back in session um moving on to consensus   items in the agenda Mo to approve the  consensus items okay do I have a second   can you please repeat can you repeat make a  motion to approve the consensus items motion   to approve the consensus items yeah I'm I'd  like to pull a couple before but go ahead   see if you get a second then we'll talk I  will second it and we can have discussion  

102um Dr Merck yes I would like to pull  uh a C and D for individual discussion a can you repeat those a c a c and d d d d as in dog d as in dog okay perfect all right  um Mr Mr Perry I'd like to pull G for a very brief comment all right Miss Barnhart I will make a  motion to adopt b e and f from the consistes items   second all right any further discussion hearing  none all those in favor signify by saying I I I   any opposed those pass three sorry 7 to nothing um  going through in order we'll we'll start with a Dr   Merck yeah I see that we're looking at spending  another half million dollars on the Ashley track   and I love the idea of having a a beautiful

103uh  Athletic Field Etc at Ashley and I think uh our   students deserve it but I feel very strongly  that with the fields uh at at nor at new han   High School being what they are that I think the  public needs to hear again and maybe again and   maybe again why there's so much discrepancy and  why would be spending an extra half million doll   another half million dollar on the track as a as  a change order when the situation at New Hanover   is what it is Mr Anderson yes um sir this is  a change order uh report so these have already   been done the the board approved the funding  change order was processed and the work has   been completed I will say on this one the the  reason for the half million doll change order   was

104it had to be constructed in phases so  the the all along the total of the project   was approximately what was it 800 $829,000 so that  that's what was anticipated but because the way it   was funded a change order had to be executed for  the second phase I appreciate that and I want the   work to be done I just want the explanation  to the public of what will happen you know   that to reassure the public that New Hanover  high school is going to be getting a track as well uh can no I cannot assure that we'll  take up that on another meeting right uh   see the 2025 budget amendment Madam chair oh  should we vote on one by one we can do that I'm   I'm thinking because otherwise all right do I hear  a motion to

105approve a I have so move exactly all   right any further discussion all those in favor  signify being by saying I I I any opposed that   passes seven to zero budget amendment Dr yes Miss  bner I just just wanted to speak to I know our   board was really intentional about making sure if  we found money which I'm grateful that we did to   put it back into the classroom and so this really  highlights the allocations for teachers full-time   assistant um sixth grade guidance counselor some  bus monitors and this was done as a result of   listening to our staff and being responsive most  responsive to the needs that were currently being   presented and so I just want to say thank you that  was 1.1 million going back into the classrooms um   appreciate it as a board member happy

106to pass this  budget mment Dr Merck yeah I was just confused   I'm looking for more information and that's why I  wanted to pull it off the consent agenda it looks   like um uh $3.6 million uh has been reduced from  the uh restart budget am I reading that correctly   and some of it's being put back in but 3.6 million  is being taken out by DPI and we're getting what   you know 1.2 million back M yes so DPI is normally  late in providing the money to the restart but we   know that that money is going to come in so we  went ahead and budgeted it in that state1 um so   that restart could go ahead and start running  their school and doing the things that they   needed to do so when that restart money came in  we

107budgeted that in the right program but we had   to reduce the extra budget we had in 01 since we  knew that money wasn't actually going to come in   so it's just an adjustment that we made to our  original budget estimate in total it was pretty   close to the same but it was just in the wrong  program so this is us making that adjustment I   love how you guys push money around and then make  it work I don't know how you do it but thanks for   doing it all right uh I will entertain a motion to  approve the 2025 budget amendment move I'll second   all those in favor signify by saying I I  any opposed passes seven to zero continuing   on year-to-date contracts and purchase  orders Dr Merck this was also you yeah   we're looking at

108um a lot of uh expenditures  here uh some that we've seen some that we've   talked about um and I don't expect us to to to  understand all of what you do but it seems like   with this many expenditures shouldn't we have  maybe had a quick little uh rundown with that   so that we would understand these more Mr Perry  um I was just excuse me sorry Mr not my job um   yes I I was actually going to wonder if in  future reports uh whether you could have a   column with a couple sentence explanation of what  the expense is or maybe a link to the document so   that we can there's a contract so that we can  see it um Mr Merck is correct these are all   between $100 and $300,000 but if you add them  up

109it's several million dollars or so it's not   small change and for future reference to our  newer board members when these things come up   the agenda review would be the perfect time if  you have questions or concerns regarding any   of them um to absolutely ask every single  one of those questions generally speaking uh Miss barard Madam chair I was just curious  um and hearing the discussion of my colleagues   if moving forward if we wanted to either have  a consistent report or perhaps if we wanted   to vote on grants that were under a certain  threshold I I just engage in the conversation   don't know if that's if that's where the  concern is for this um the chairwoman just   spoke to speaking at it during agenda review  but I didn't know if there was concern about   the amounts

110of being approved without  board approval if we wanted to revisit   that um but I'd like to pose that to  my colleagues now since we're on the topic Dr Merck yeah I'm just looking at this  as a this is our fiduciary responsibility to   be watching over our expenditures and I I look at  this list and go boy I'm kind of stupid I don't   know what any of this is and I'm not in any way  saying that any of these expenditures are wrong   but that as board members we have a responsibility  to know where the money's going that that's really   all I'm saying absolutely um and I was just  pointing out Mr Justice had her hand oh well yes   um miss barnhard here just brought up a point so  this would be a change in policy as

111far as we did   change the approval limit uh not that we want to  I'm just saying that this is what you're referring   to is possibly we need to look at that if we have  the concern on the board is this what you were   clarifying go ahead Miss Bard you can answer that  thank you madam chair yes just hearing hearing   from the colleagues it sound like there was  concern with that so I said perhaps that's where   the justification was coming from a different  amount is it am I correct in understanding these   are all of the amounts for the entire year  this not just this month right okay I just I   I thought I knew the answer I just wanted to say  it out loud um but these are all of the different   vendors who have been

112approved in the last year  so I'm grateful to since July okay that's good   to know too since July I'm grateful that we get  a list um but I would be interested as a single   board member to potentially have policy take that  up to revisit the threshold amount so we can be   more knowledgeable than that M Bradford um I would  just like to reiterate what the chair thank you   madam chair what you had just said we have these  for a couple of weeks we can click on that link   we can look at them if we have a question about  something we can email email either Dr Barnes or   the department head we can get all these questions  out of the way before we come to this meeting so   if you remember I went through every one

113of  them on the agenda review and you didn't have   any questions so that's where we do this part of  this that's what we have agenda review for and   you're you're you're you're allowed to ask all the  questions you want we and the board wants you the   the staff wants you to have all the information  you can possibly need and then if there's   something on there you want to pull off then we  we also so we we let the board and the staff know   so they're prepared when they come to this meeting  for us just to do it as a consensus and it's just   a housekeeping thing you guys are brand new except  for Miss Justice she already knew this and even   though the agenda review is new um but it's it's  this isn't the place

114for it um it was last week   Mr Perry I had one other just small thing and um  it's not really related to the previous discussion   um in on our assembly it says this reports to  provide the board with a report on all contracts   and purchase orders exceeding $100,000 but less  than $300,000 approved by the superintendent   or design from July through December um I am  looking at just one of these contracts which   I happen we voted on in December which is the  one uh which is NC uh sound for $127,000 change   uh that was actually a um one that we  approved we had to approve because there   was no competitive bidding process and  so my question is should that be on this report your mic is off um yes we have reached  our time on this

115item um so I am going to ask   if we need an extension of time we do have uh a  lot to cover for the rest of the meeting as well   as one other discussion uh under consensus  so I would at this point entertain either a   motion to continue discussion or a motion to  approve I move to adopt D and G as presented   I'll second all right Miss Justice okay I was  this is discussion I was hearing what you were   saying it was just a simple explanation we  are new to this process in ways we didn't   have the agenda review before even though I  wanted it um so if we just could move this   at least to answer his question because I was  interested in finding out what the answer was   instead of cutting it off

116right in the  middle of the question well we do have   a motion on the table to approve D and  G um is there any further discussion on that hearing none all those in favor of approving  D and G signify by saying I I I any opposed nay   nay okay that passes five- two Dr bares also it  pleased the board I know that Friday we're having   a budget uh work session I can ask Ashley to put  together a real brief explanation of how these   policies get approved and when and why that is the  way it is because I know that as a board you don't   want to slow down the work of getting the things  done but if we can help you with sort of a rundown   actually if you can pull that together by Friday

117I  can give it to you guys then that works all right   continuing on to policy I'm going to hand it over  to Mr wior all right well I make a motion that we   approve uh all the items under policy consensus  second discussion Miss Bradford I'd like to pull   one off of the consensus um policy 42 431 4351  okay any others okay so uh motion was made to   approve policy consensus without 4351 all those  in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed that   passes 7 to zero going back to 4351 Miss Bradford  um not responding to audience comments because I   was prepared for this but I found it ironic and  pleasantly that um twink bar pointed out that we   don't read as well as we could but policy 4351  says no student under the

118age of eight or under   grade three will be suspended out of school  except in response to inst instances violating   uh involving violations of policy 4325 four  reasons there are only four reasons we can   suspend children of this age out of school four  reasons do you know what they are they are drugs   and alcohol they are assaults and threats they are  weapons bombs bomb threats terrorist threats clear   threats to safety did I miss one those are grave  offenses and that's the only reason we can suspend   a little person out of school so to say that we  need love and understanding and all of these other   points but when a child has a weapon or a bomb or  a bomb threat or a tra threat we need to allow our   principles and our superintendent to do their

119job  and I'm not done um if you look at the law on this   which is um anual statute 115c specifically 288  there's powers and duties of the principal a to   grade and classify pupils come all the way down  to e to discipline students and assign duties to   teachers with regard to the discipline General  well-being and medical care of students I would   say to you that if we have a child who brings  a bomb to school or makes a bomb threat or has   assaulted or threatened another person or has  a gun or Dr drugs and alcohol then you need to   consider that it is in the best interest of the 99  students in the classroom that the one be removed   without having to jump through a bunch of Hoops  I hear constantly and I heard in

120the um in in in   in in the climate survey that we as a board don't  listen to our teachers and our principles enough   and on this one I'm going with the principles and  the superintendent I'm not interested in changing   it to anything else it it's the one part that  nobody bothers to read they read everything else   and say before you know after during whatever but  if you've got a a bomb in the school I don't want   to take the time to call the parent while I'm  dealing with the child and I'm sorry if that's   offensive but we have to look after the well-being  of our students and our teachers and the rest of   of of the entire School environment and if a child  is threatening something like this or has a weapon   weapon um or

121as assaulted or threatened a teacher  or a student no no I'm not going to vote in favor   of any more changes to this policy and I've heard  it this has the been on the board two years and   two months and this is the third time it's come  before us thank you Dr Merrick with respect to   my colleagues concerns about 4351 we have other  policies already on the books to deal with a child   who has a weapon and whether or not they can be um  uh held or whether they can be you know uh bound   so that the weapon can be removed we have policies  to protect children and staff that have nothing   to do with 4351 now 4351 also says a child will  not be sent home before the end of the day so if  

122that's the case what are we doing with that child  we don't think they uh they're they're not safe   to be with other children so I'm guessing they're  in the principal's office they are somewhere so in   other words we have time to talk to the parents  those children are somewhere being kept so that   they are not a danger to themselves or others and  so we have all the time in the world till the end   of the day to contact those parents or to try and  if we have to send them home because we haven't   yet I mean we're not going to send them home a  five 5-year-old you're going to kick them out   of school go home little boy boy no we can't  do that so if you cannot contact the parents   by the end of

123the day you send them home you're  still going to have to call the parents and say   don't send them to school tomorrow you're going  to have to have a conversation with those parents   or Guardians why in the world wouldn't you have  that conversation first that's all I got to say uh   Miss Justice Miss Barnhart and Mr Perry all right  having been a principal in these situations I can   tell you right now a lot of it's left even though  this sounds really definite bomb threats terrorism   assaults a lot of this is interpretation of what  goes on in the classro it's not that cut and dry   um so part of that is so the principal will have  to make a decision about what his final outcome   will be you've been there too and and I'm you know 

124and we're not even there yet in this discussion   because I'm going to definitely promote you should  be contacting the parents first cuz for all you   know that child's brother had been shot that night  before when they came in all freaked out um so   this is I'm not saying that's going to happen  but there's a lot of factors that you need to   put into effect if you're the principal with that  responsibility making these decisions and thus all   we're trying to do is actually ask to help the  principal it isn't all cut and dry it isn't all   black and white when you're talking about five  six seven year olds and these kinds of this is   what you're supposed to do according to what they  do because what they do is is still left up to   interpretation Miss

125Barnhart thank you madam chair  I wanted to discuss a little bit because this had   come over conversation when I was on policy and  the conversation became about before a decision   is made so there was some conversations that  I've had with um some individuals from love our   children about the conversation and parents being  brought into the conversation and what's actually   happening so we had discussions about discipline  Matrix and how that comes into play how we get   our staff feedback and there's a scaffolded as  scaled of if these kind of um instances happened   this is the recourse if this happens this is the  recourse and there's natural mechanisms built in   that address behavior in a scaffolded way of  support in hopes that the student Behavior   changes to be in a positive direction um that is  something we

126we approve constantly my concern with   a with adding the word before lies in regards  to consistent expectation and in our school   district we should have consistent expectation um  we saw overwhelmingly with the staff survey that   discipline was one of the biggest concerns for  our staff and not feeling like they're supported   in discipline and I have pointed out and I have  criticized we should not look at the end result   and say our staff is doing something wrong but  rather we should say we trust our staff to follow   policy which is a scaled intervention intentional  consequences when there are specific levels of   rightfully so disciplinary responses that the  school district has but it's everybody came   together to create what that looks like so that  we can have consistent expectations and I hear   what my colleague is saying

127too I absolutely agree  that we have children who are experiencing things   that unfortunately I don't believe that children  should experience in in many instances but there's   still an expectation when they're at school and  so I I do hear and understand but I I disagree   with um my colleague to the left though to say  you can absolutely call before a child is sent   home and have a conversation with a parent but it  can be after the decision is made because when we   start bringing parents into the process of saying  can you help decide what the consequences Li and   I'm try I'm I'm not trying to laugh um but when  we say I I know my parenting style is different   from um my friend's parenting Styles and I can  only imagine the stories that principles would   get

128to say well let me tell you what I think the  consequence should be for my child from the easy   extreme to the hard extreme in both directions and  I don't want to see that I want to have consistent   expectations and to be able to support our staff  and I believe that this policy does that I has   it has a scaled response it has contact with the  parent is absolutely written in here um and so I   support this policy Mr Perry being on the policy  committee and we had this discussion about this   and I thought and I was the one who proposed this  this language uh where attempt the contact uh and   as soon as possible uh which I think differs from  the current thing it's where it's the end of the   day uh we're imagining

129that this needs to happen  quickly I mean you might you might need to make   a suspension determination right away but pretty  soon after within minutes maybe you you need to   be notifying the parent or attempting to notify  the parent I think all three of us miss Justice   and Mr will deore and I think Dr Barnes kind  of agreed on the on the language that we we   we chose we re this is why it's a consensus item  from policy we believe this language is the best   of all worlds um would I like some general just  from my own personal thing would I like to maybe   change some language about a suspension  determination can't we just call it a   prejudgment and then because right now what  we do is there's a suspension determination   made and then the

130parent gets the right to appeal  but uh now we're talking semantics though really   because they get to appeal if they want to I mean  could we say they make to make a predetermination   and then then there's a real determination after  there's a hearing I don't know but we that's a   bigger disc discussion I think for right now right  here right now I think this is the best language   that that uh equals out all the interest that  we have and our a warning to be able to reach   out to parents as soon as possible during these  situations uh Mr W deore no I've been biting   a lip here long enough um so yeah I agree with  Mr Perry he he and I were part of that group as   well as M Justice and I will say

131um that I have  met with the love our children group repeatedly   uh and I do I will say this I want to keep all  our children in school at all times that's where   they learn that's definitely it but I've also sat  in the principal's chair and had to make those   tough decisions when you have a child in front of  you that's bleeding because another child has has   hurt them uh when I met with the when Mr MC Manis  and I met with the love our children's group they   actually took we actually have the wording in our  policy that they that I proposed and that then   they uh came in with the uh the C ATS that are in  this policy um yeah I'll be honest I I said when I   was a principal when I

132was a sister principal you  know you'd love to have a dime for every parent   that came in and said well I want to know what  you did with the other kid we can't you can't do   that we can't do that before uh you can't have a  a situation I don't think where you have you know   you can definitely talk to that parent let the  parent know what's going on but a lot of times   a parent will advocate for their child which  they should do absolutely 100% my child would   never do that well I have a child here well can  I question that child no you can't question that   child I think there's a lot of areas where get  we would get into if we uh said we we have to do   that before the area

133before the determination was  made so I think we need to trust our principles   we think I think we need to trust our assistant  principles and I think the language that we have   right here is is the best language that we can  come up with um and I think it is sound I think   it is it's definitely within uh General statutes  in fact it's probably a little bit more um lenient   than General statutes are in certain areas uh so  I think it is in my my in my professional opinion   uh and I think Mr mcmanis I've I've chatted with  him in the past about the same policy and he also   as a as a principal uh said that you know that  this needs to be as it is so so we are coming   up on um

134just about time I wanted to kind of  make a brief comment um I know that we've been   discussing this policy for a long time um and in  that discussion we did pull in principles we did   talk to them about what was happening and more  often than not and actually every principal that   I spoke to um they are contacting parents  throughout the process they are already in   contact with parents um they are already aware of  and communicating with the parents that they can   access um we also need to remember that there are  parents that we can't access sometimes they may   not have cell phones or their numbers may have  changed or they may have moved um and so to tie   the hands of our tie the yeah tie the hands of  our our principles um to

135to that is concerning so   at this point I will entertain either a motion  to continue discussion or a motion to approve   motion to continue second oh that was the same  time point of order what's the motion I was Miss   Mr wior I'm I I make motion we call a question  second we we already had a question here about an   okay point of order we have a motion to continue  we have a motion to call it happen at the same   time they were simultaneous chair you'll have to  decide right I am going to go with the motion to   uh approve and there was a second with that if  not I second um because we are at time uh Miss   buoy could you please call the role Mr Perry  I miss Justice no Miss barnhard yes Miss

136Mason yes Mr wildor uh Dr Merrick no and Miss  Bradford yes all right that passes five   to two Madame chair I make a motion to  extend discussion for five minutes so we   can get through the policies for first reading  do I hear a second second okay uh all those in   favor signify by saying I I I any opposed that  passes and you asked for five minutes chair   Miss Bradford regarding the policy that we've  just left board members have said that we've   discussed this we've discussed it through two  generations now um really it's the third time   that I remember it coming forward we've done a  lot of due diligence on it and so I move right   now that this policy 4351 not come before this  board again for a period a minimum period of 12 months

137do I hear a second second okay discussion Miss Justice I'm not even sure  that I'm not even sure we have that Authority   that's a new one on me there's nothing in  policy about that you got your attorneys there left uh Miss uh have you ever heard of  something the attorney either of the attorneys   I'm stomped but just as an aside I'm trying to  think if someone who voted in favor could always   vote to reconsider yeah you you could I mean there  are ways you can work around if if if there's a a   need to revisit an issue um I I don't know that  there's a way that you can completely foreclose it for a 12-month period I just I'll I'll  withraw that would be an airtight I mean it I I would agree with that

138if the board votes  today to not discuss this or pick it up for   12 months but then next month we decide in  a unanimous vote to pick it up I think it   would be back on the table um not sure what  to say about the initial motion then okay so   there is no longer a second or is there I got to  look on okay that motion fails moving to to uh   propos policy 6129 Mr bore me again okay good  um I had such a great time last time you want   to say um we this is just a policy for first  reading it is about the anti-choking devices   uh I think it does answer all the questions  that we had about them um I would entertain   any questions that we could you know we did cross 

139through such trained Personnel because we do want   um it to be you know anyone that can use it  there is a very simple um training uh module   that you would do just so you know what you're  doing with it um I think that again I'm going to   just keep uh trying to tell or or recommending  that folks you know across the board very much   like the bloodborne pathogens training that we  used to have I think we still have they they   still have I don't have anymore but they still  do I mean just a overall overarching training   and again I think this is good because it also um  you know it was brought up that there are several   I think Mr Perry brought up that there are um  the uh Red Cross now approves this as

140part of   its training regiment our local heart the heart  association am I correct Mr Perry I think I'm   right I can't recall on that one okay I believe  that's what you had told me was that the the Heart   Association does not and that's what our nurses  are under but is that correct all right all right   thank yeah I should ask I forgot what you do I'm  apologizing I apologize for that you know she yeah   but um I mean and and as I said before and I'm  going to say it again if this you know if these   devices save one child over the years well worth  it if if they save a lot of children even better   or adults or as uh we've had you know a person  come up and talk about you know maybe

141a heavy   set child or something or a child in a wheelchair  there's just so many things that um you know it   could it could help uh in addition to you know the  black the back blows and the homic maneuver and   stuff so it's not saying one or the other this is  a an addition to and Dr Merck did you want to we   only have one minute so no I make a motion that  we send it back to policy so we can go through   the second reading and do all whatever we got to  do we don't this is first reading this the first   reading yeah we can approve it as is we don't no  no we have it at the end of the month we do it   next month it's automatic it's automatic aoma I  withdraw

142my motion Dr as uh attorneys as you know   my only concern was this is that this identify and  protect the staff members as well do you feel like   this policy does both of those things allows us  to utilization with kids and protects our staff   I think so I think it cover both sides of concerns  that we have thank you all right okay so and again   it's only a first reading so we don't have to do  anything with it we just did what we have to do   with it I guess perfect thank you there we go  all right um update on New Hanover High School Renovations thank you madam chair I'm gonna turn  it over to Miss Lawrence uh to give a five minute   update on the work at new H Hospital why do I  only

143get five I have a lot of good things to   talk about thank you for this opportunity um and  I will try to keep it brief um Eddie has a cane   behind under the chair is to P me aside if I I be  escorted out even better um So currently the work   that's underway is what we refer to as phase 2A it  was a change order that was approved by the board   in December and that if you recall is for the  removal and replacement of the eastern and western   flanking walls those walls were Beyond repair so  we were obligated to replace them if you visit the   site you'll see the vast majority of those wall  structures removed and then in the next couple   of weeks you'll see the new wall construction  occurring I'm happy to report

144that that work   is on schedule and for phase 2A and slightly under  budget so that's good news on the heels of that we   will begin repairs of the South elevation wall  That's the wall running parallel with Market   Street that faes market that is a part of what we  will refer to as phase 2B of the construction and   phase 2B will include all work that is necessary  between now and August for us to complete all of   the repairs interior improvements that will allow  us to reoccupy those classrooms for the start of   the school year and I will be bringing to you a  change order for approval for that phase 2B in   an upcoming board meeting but I would like to note  that the phase 2B work is a part of the funding is   already included in

145the funding that we've already  received from the County Commissioners um I would   like to touch on for a moment the security vestule  project because I don't think we've talked about   it yet if you'll recall last spring we brought to  you for approval a contract for construction of a   new security vestibule that work began this past  summer in 2024 as we encountered encountered the   structural issues we had to hit the pause button  on that security vesb project we have a contractor   a separate contractor who's under um contract  to perform that work that contractor and our   construction manager who's overseeing all of  the repair work they have been collaborating   and what uh the agreement that we've reached  is the contractor for the security vestibule   project in May of this year will recommence that  construction and will work

146through the summer   so that um for the start of school we will not  only have repairs to the class mushrooms and all   the structural repairs will be completed but the  security vestibule project will also be completed   and that's an incredible facelift for the interior  of that space there'll be new Organization for the   office and the guidance area um it's going to be  fantastic and it's going to be the icing on the   cake as we reopen um this portion of the campus  in addition to the ongoing repair work we also   in parallel are in the process of conducting the  facility assessment and the uh Master planning   for Handover as funded by the County Commissioners  so for the past few um weeks the design team The   Architects and Engineers have been scouring the  campus they've been through

147all of the buildings   conducting very in-depth analyses um for of all  the buildings we've also conducted a number of   meetings with various District departments um  maintenance technology Child Nutrition safety   Transportation Athletics so we've been holding  meetings at the school at all of these meetings   Mr Sutton and Mr Haney are an integral part of  that they invite to those meetings any members   of their staff that are important in that process  um for example when we met with maintenance they   invited the head custodian um he participated in  the meeting and he was an an incredible Resource   as we discuss the day-to-day operations of the  campus um we are also Al scheduling meetings   I'm working right now in the Pro uh to schedule  meetings with um instruction and curriculum and   CTE to talk about the vision for the

148programs of  the campus as we look toward the future um one of   the things I wanted to touch on was very important  is later this month we've targeted February the   27th as a date when we will be engaging holding a  community engagement event um detailed information   regarding the times for this will be be published  within the next week or so um this will be held   at the Princess Street Gym um we're targeting  late afternoon to early evening um a as a window   of time when we will invite parents um community  members um alumni you as the board members of the   county commissioner um the County Commissioners  will also be invited to come and participate in   giving us um information and input on the future  of Handover that same day we will hold student   engagement sessions

149during this during the day  and then immediately after dismissal we will   have a staff engagement um event so that will be  a a very comprehensive day where we look forward   to getting input from the community from the  students from the staff I'm currently working   with Mr Sutton on the structure and timing of the  student and staff portion um but if you'll pencil   in the 27th as a date to participate in that  Community engagement we'd very much appreciate   it and um we will have detailed information that  will be published in the very near future so that   concludes my update if you have any questions  I'd be happy to answer them Miss Bradford I just right now all that scaving up it just it's  just so encouraging that something's happening   you know before dirt and so on

150it was a little  discouraging but it's really you can feel the   change and it's it's good for all of your hard  work I'm very very pleased to be a part of this   process Miss barnhard thank you madam chair I  also just want to Echo thanks to you I'm going   to say it out loud because you found us money that  we could save from the last phase so hoping that   happens but just really highlighting not only are  we going to be able to have the repairs done but   the best ofal done before the start of next year  that is so phenomenal I I mean the start of this   year was hectic and that's a nice word to say  it for new Handover students and so just really   grateful for the team keep working hard save us 

151some money thank you to the County Commissioners   for being diligent in this process because it's  needed and we are being responsive to the needs   and thank you for keeping on track with them  any other questions Mr W not a question but   again just to reiterate I do thank you for your  hard work uh when I went over the other day and   you gave me a great tour of everything and every  everything's going thank you so much you're on   top of everything you're leading the way thank  you for doing it my pleasure Dr Merck amazing   you know when it comes to construction you don't  R you rarely hear that we came in under budget   that's that's just so thank you uh hopefully  it continues um do you have a a estimate for   when the facilities assessment

152will be complete  we are we will have the the goal is by the end   of April we will have a completed um assessment  that will include uh the master planning imagery   as well as a cost estimate um and between  now and then we will be having a series of   meetings with senior staff and um the staff at  Handover to receive additional input we we're   going to keep plugging in maintenance technology  um transportation Child Nutrition safety all of   the teams that are part of the operation of  the campus we're going to continue to engage   them as we go through this master planning  process but the end of April is when we will   tie a bow around all that information I I sure  hope we'll be able to get very soon to like the   the the locker

153rooms the shower rooms that are  so bad that they're not even used they're now   storage rooms and our athletes and our uh gym uh  students don't take showers at new han high school   we need to I can't wait for us to be able to we  did that as well and we we that was one of the   topics of conversation when we met with Dr Morgan  and focused on the Athletics so there's a lot of   room and a lot of love that we can give to this  campus any other questions thank you so much thank   you continuing on to new business uh student cell  phone use ad hoc committee Miss Justice i' like over here which makes it a little hard for me  to talk so if I start coughing or anything um   the purpose of

154this is that for example uh it's a  fact that we've known this the last couple months   kids reading MTH skills are worsening new test  scores reveal people are asking is it co they   go back in time and they so say no um these test  scores started to follow a couple years before   Co even hit and looking generally at research um  it ties in very strongly with self overuse of the   schools I can go into a lot more detail for that  but I'll just use the teachers words the teachers   are making it's making it harder and harder for  teachers to try to teach the kids are also being   damaged and this is a fact too they've done Tons  Of Studies have been damaged sexually emotionally   um because of the use of cell phones and social  media

155in the schools during the day uh it's an   addiction and it's concerned and are I actually  live to and it concerns them they speak about it   they know that it's hurting they have trouble  talking face to face with each other um let Al   not listening and classroom teachers are trying  to teach so a couple years ago coule years back   you were talking about and I was in the board  previously about setting up a committee stum that   never came to consideration but now with things  getting worse I think it's is time for us to put   a committee together and let me read what the  proposal is just one page the is only H great   detail this is a proposal to create an ad hoc  committee to revise new H County Schools policy   number 4318 use of

156wireless communication devices  in our schools the goal is to limit the impact of   cell phones and other wireless communication  devices due to disruptions of the learning   environment and also limit their contributions  to our students worsening mental health the   objective is to improve concentration learning  to improve mental and physical health and reduce   pressures caused by social media on our children  all right the committee and this is I said this is   not really huge detail it's pretty straightforward  the committee composition and operation voting   members will be all committee members I've worked  on committees before I know a lot of times here   with the school board they say well it should just  be the board members I think in this situation   where we're going to decide on a everybody should  have a stake in it and have a

157final say um the   members will consist of those that most that are  most impacted by the use of wireless communication   devices in their schools the committee will  be limited to 12 members anything over that   going have trouble getting work done uh the two  school board members were act as chair and vice   chair I was ask the two school board members and  the two school board members and then we need a   recording secretary that would be provided by the  superintendent's office the following how many   people would serve as members two Schoolboard  members I mentioned that already two classroom   teachers from the secondary two parents of  students two students from the secondary one   school administrator involved in school discipline  at the secondary one school guidance counselor   from the secondary one school resource officer  from the secondary level

158and one school social   work the committee will meet this is my goal I  hope our goal the committee will meet five times   location and time be determined between now  and the July policy committee meeting they   will then present their findings to the policy  committee for further discussion and approval   revised policy number 4318 will then be moved  out of policy through the usual methodis to   the full board and hopefully approval um earlier  today U Mr Perry mentioned that should be should   be doing this committee through policy I think  it's too big of a challenge what's going on in   our district and the meetings will will be  very detailed um several years ago we went   through um a committee that actually decided on  our our current address code which actually is a   very dress very good policy

159I could say something  about enforcement but the policy itself is there   uh and it was F and structured around this kind  of set mainly that the policy people with the   policy holders on at stay are the ones that  come up with the decisions and they ended up   doing a lot of research so that's why I'm bringing  this to you now it worked very well then you the board um so I'd like to do this with our uh Mr wior well uh Mr Justice I well excuse  me not say it that way fellow board member over   there I I couldn't agree with her more I mean I  think it's very uh sound I mean I think we do you   know we we've had this problem with cell phones  for this board last board I do want

160to remind the   board we had currently have a uh committee one  of the safety committees uh that actually has   a cell phone SL discipline so that may be another  area we already have we kind of already have that   covered actually and I do want to remind uh and  let the board members know that that may may not   have been at the Town Halls both the uh last  summer uh town hall and the um more recent one   I believe it was in October um we actually that  was one of the three topics that were talked about   were cell phones supposed to be cell phone  discipline I was actually on at that table and   it was cell phones and the time was was ended  every time because it is such a big concern   for folks that you

161know that you know and I'll be  honest you know as we heard from from the parents   uh and from the administrators uh more from the  parents as I remember I don't have my notes in   front me I was checking to see if I had them but  um you know from the parents they were very split   you know some parents were out adamant you will  not take my child's cell phone you will not ever   take my child's cell phone I want to be able to  contact my parent my my child at any time on the   other side of the equation we had a lot of parents  that said just as Miss Justice did you know it's   a distraction it goes off then you have conflict  between the teacher and the student so there's a   lot of

162concern there I don't think there was any  teachers that said hey I really think you know   there was a time I'll be honest as a principal  there was a time we needed that technology in   the classroom we don't need that technology in the  classroom anymore so um whether the board wants   to continue with the the current way we have it  with the uh with the committee the safety commit   safety Assi discipline SL cell phone or if we  want to do a separate ad hoc committee you know   that's up to the board but I just you know want to  remind everybody we do already have that you know   as part of another committee right Miss Barnhart  thank you madam chair I love this idea and I know   we're coming close to time on this I'm I'm

163in  favor of having a tiered system of expectation   definitely getting the input from our staff and  our students is important I'm going to take this   a step further I said this I've said this before  to miss Bron over there of making sure we have   a tiered expectation just with technology  in general because for a K2 year-old that   expectation should look very different from  a senior in high school and so I think that   this would be something absolutely worthwhile  to explore I agree with my sentiment um from   my fellow board member to my left saying that we  do um have a Safety Committee that specifically   deals with cell phones so I'm not anti this  idea but I think to continue this discussion   it might be a good idea to bring this back  under old business um

164next month too to H   hammer out some more details and have some more  conversation but I I would take it a little step   further to not just cell phone devices but just  technology use and talk about the best practices   for our children because I think that's important  um as we go through this process thank you madam   chair uh Dr Merck so I appreciate my colleague  here who says we already do have a committee   but I was piqued by your uh concern about how  the committee was structured and I really like   the idea of bringing in uh a lot of staff and  SRO and you know all the the stakeholders that   really matter so my question my question would  be whether or not uh the structure of the Safety   Committee the cell phone discipline would work

165in  terms of structure to bring in all the the people   that I I agree we need on that committee um I'm  that was a question question I'm GNA allow her to   answer and then I'll have you go Miss Bradford  well the reason that I think this would be a   standal committee because uh the issue is so huge  and it's not just safety and dis it's a lot more   than just that I was talking about students  mental health students learning environment   being able to learn um there we could use the  information they have already masked we can   move it into the committee and that could be  part of the information that we'll be used to   make our final determination that's great that  they've done all that work that's going to save   us some work and the

166final outcome that's what my  take would be sorry about the allergies um we are   at time so I'm going to make a motion to extend  the conversation for five minutes okay we had a   second all those in favor signify by saying I I  any opposed that passes uh Miss Bradford thank   you madam chair um first I want to say I am 100%  in agreement with the goals I am in 100% with the   objectives absolutely 100% in agreement however I  listen to what my colleague to the right said um   in terms of of a possibility putting it up under  safety and again when we create a new committee   there's a lot of steps involved that keep from  getting right to work if you stick it under uh   under one committee we already have you're at it 

167right then however let me put out another option   um the past two years we have held a board retreat  during the first 60 to 90 days of every first part   of the year and we haven't done that yet and so I  would would would move you to consider that we get   a board retreat scheduled put it on the calendar  and then put cell phones on that agenda to have   this broader discussion about this committee  then in addition to a couple other things that   we really need to talk about at length and I can  make that in the form of motion if anyone would   like to Second it okay there was a motion is  there a second yeah okay terrible um I want to   make sure that everybody that hasn't spoken has an  opportunity to speak

168and Mr Perry has not yet had   an opportunity to speak so I'm going to allow him  to speak I'm just wondering um since reading uh   the proposal which I am for all the goals too  this needs to be worked out and it's uh and I   think maybe some kind of dedicated committee is  in order um but since since since it says right   in it that uh it reports to the policy committee  I was wondering if we could adopt it as an ad   hoc of subcommittee of the policy committee  since it's going to report there anywhere so miss Justice I want to clarify um we need to  do this as soon as possible the reason I put the   July date was because of upcoming school year um  we can't keep pushing it away as far as

169discussing   it in a treat that'll take more time if I hadn't  have gone through and I'm going to use this as an   example if I hadn't gone through the um best C  policy sit with the committee I I wouldn't feel   confident that we can't do this and I'll tell you  why because it took a lot of work on our part the   the school board members part and I ended up  carrying most of the work and I think I worked   with some of the office people in the office  to but it work but whoever's on that committee   has to know it is going to be working you have to  keep focusing on that you can't let it slide you   have to go you have to find people that have to  apply you have to just constantly

170follow up but   it will work and I want to get this stuff I want  to get this done I don't want to keep it keep it   you know w waiting and waiting because we we've  got a big problem our kids have got a big our   teachers are challenged uh Dr Merck we only have  about two minutes I understand that we're actually   discussing the motion on the floor to do it during  a retreat is that what I'm hearing at this point   okay thank you I like the idea however a board  retreat does not bring on the stakeholders that   we need and the experts that we need and so I'm  going to go back to uh what we I asked before the   structure that Miss justice has suggested brings  in the stakeholders and the experts that we

171need   and so a board retreat wouldn't accomplish that  although I think we could we could discuss it   at a board retreat 100% okay uh Miss Bradford we  have one minute and let me clarify my suggestion   to take it to the board retreat was to have this  same discussion in dep about how the committee is   formed and follow the the steps that Miss justice  has outlined I'm not saying um uh just to discuss   it at the board retreat and then just be done  with it it's a much bigger issue than that and   I would remind the chair that I could swear we  sat in with principles and they gave us their   advice last year or the year before um but the  other thing I want to point out and I'm going to   point it out here

172and again in a minute is we have  one Focus right now between now and April 15th   and I'm not going to come off this bar we have to  approve a budget that is going to be acceptable to   all of the people all of the families all of the  County Commissioners we have that between now and   April and I don't want to really clog us up with  a whole lot of other stuff until that task is off   our plate to just remind you okay um and we have  a motion on the table to have a board retreat to   discuss this ad hoc did you have anything you  wanted to add Dr Barnes if I can if we can also   appoint someone from or if I can be allowed to  appoint someone from cabinet to provide support  

173for that as well to make sure yeah thank you  okay so the motion on the table is to hold a   board retreat to discuss the cell phone ad hoc  committee uh Miss buoy will you call the role   point of clarification to discuss that and other  things that and other things have a time we just   have to plan it we would have to send that out  we'll have to this spoy m Bradford uh yes Dr Merck   no Mr wior yes Miss Mason uh yes Miss Barnhart yes  Miss Justice no and Mr Perry yes and that passes 5-2 all right so uh we will send out some  possible dates Miss burnhard can you grab   me top to my marker um continuing to the next  next ad hoc committee uh new han County Schools   employee performance bonus plan

174committee Mr  Perry yeah good evening um I think we are all   appreciative of our employees and the outstanding  work that they do uh they are the lifo of our   school system they what's make it go what makes  it work um the and we need to Value them uh not   just with our appreciation and our honors but  with with our dollar signs and I believe that   especially when it comes I think our County does  an excellent job compared to other counties as far   as supplementing their wages and salaries however  uh uh compared to a lot of other counties is it   ever enough probably not but I'd like to also  reward all of our employees with the opportunity   for a merit based performance-based uh bonus in  the future at some point so if they go above and  

175beyond expectations that they're rewarded for  that uh now this is a huge job I think most of   the people that I've talked to like this idea but  this is not something we can snap our fingers and   get done in a in a in a couple of couple sessions  of the policy committee it is a huge job in order   to determine how to judge that performance  fairly across whole different spectrums of   employees within our school district how do you  judge performance for a special needs students   teacher versus a Jad teacher versus a custodian  or a principal or a teacher Aid it all differs   there are some things in here um as far as some  general you know ideas as far as uh under guiding   principles of the plan um that I want to go over  this

176is not a replacement for salary this is an   addition and above and beyond as an extra perk  that is going to give us the ability to recruit   develop and aain the highest quality employees  this will give us if we were to implement this   plan this will give us a competitive advantage  over all one other4 school districts in North   Carolina that won't have this which means we  get to keep our teachers now there um and like   I said so it's not a replacement and I do think it  has to be you know there's going to be budgetary   restraints and we're going to have to work through  those but it has to be something substantial it   can't be a couple hundred bucks otherwise it's  not going to do the job um and and it needs to be  

177every employee and the biggest thing about fairly  measuring performance this is the bulk of the work   that this committee is going to have to do and yes  should it be focused on student growth Innovation   but it's going to differ a little bit for each  different type of employee and a lot of the work   of that that's going to take many sessions is  to get input from our employees get their Buy   in I want them Staffing our committee coming  in and giving us their input I want to be able   to take guest employees who like to present to us  uh not necessarily have a c audience but let them   schedule with this committee a time to come in and  tell us what they think about this because without   their buyin it's not going to work so

178I'd like  to try to get this going I think it's going to   probably you know take at least a Year's worth of  meetings and i' like to get it an organizational   meeting going next month but just to figure out  who we need on on that committee not a full-blown   meeting I want to work with Dr Barnes to get the  right kinds of you know representative sample of   our employees on that so we can get great advice  on what how to fairly judge performance and then   we can wait two months until after the budget  process for us start working in Earnest so um   I'm happy to answer any questions Mr wior first  of all Mr Perry I I keep saying the same thing   but I think this is an outstanding idea I mean I  think this

179is a great idea anything we can do to   get more money for our teachers teacher assistants  bus drivers uh cafeteria workers everyone I think   it's a great idea um I would have a couple  suggestions uh I've really been looking over   your your proposal I think it's great overall  well written um but I would suggest maybe the   one thing we we have to have you know we we could  have this great plan that we going to do all this   stuff we don't have the money we can't do it so  I would I would recommend that we actually put   this as a subcommittee under Finance and I would  say U and I'm I'm kind of did some looking at our   policies and stuff finance committee currently has  two members on it from the board uh it says

180two or   three in our policy so we could add Mr Perry to as  a third person in there and he could have that you   know CU Miss um I'm not going to brag my colleague  to the left I got to work on this my colleague to   the left my colleague way over there to the left  but she's put together a great thank you she put   together a great uh thank you all right anyway she  put together a great uh panel a great uh committee   that has a lot of folks that are from the uh that  would be very helpful in that whole area and as   you said Mr Perry I think that really getting  this thing off and running hard you know because   what is the finance commit I can point that way  finance committee

181doe after the budget is passed   and done well there's not a lot for them to do at  that time this would be a great thing for them to   run you running your committee under uh and you  know working with those those folks you could   maybe use some of those folks from the finance  committee to help you with that um I'm going to   I I've said this to you before I really really  really really really think we need to have folks   with boots on the ground as part of this committee  and not bring them in here and then have them back   out or call them when as your proposal said um  I that's one thing I don't agree with I think we   need to have you know I would say like the teacher  of the year

182the principal of the Year those folks   need to be part of the permanent solution I'm  going to uh part of the permanent committee so   that we can have you know a teacher saying hey  this is what I think and so otherwise if you   bring somebody in one meeting and then they're not  there next meeting they got to get up to speed um   and I think you know teacher of the year principal  the year all those people you know they they were   elected by their uh their colleagues as teacher of  the year principal of the Year etc etc so I think   those would be great people if we could have them  or someone else but I mean I think it is really   important to pursue the funding first because we'  really really you know really like

183to have a great   I I think this is AB absolutely wonderful but I  mean if we don't have the funding we'd have the   best plan in the world with no no funding so again  100% behind you on this one I think it's great uh   but I think you know working with the finance  committee would be a good thing too uh Dr Merck   well my colleague to the right with less hair  than me oh my goodness oh my goodness by immed   Anyway said he's t i I Echo his sentiments I think  it's a great idea anything that we can do to show   our teachers and staff that we appreciate them  that they're doing a great job I'm all for it   you know it occurs to me that you know if you're  talking about giving like uh

184a $5,000 you know   award or $3,000 award I bet your committee could  do a lot of work in the public sphere and go out   and find corporate sponsorships for for your uh  bonuses and it would be the C Cola award to you   know for higher learn whatever right so funding  is important I think it can be done I support I   support you setting up this committee whether  it's in finance I I'm interested to hear what   you say um did you you have not miss brenford has  not had a chance to speak so I'll have her I had a   concern under F of The Proposal on our screens and  you know and printed about just that um the last   the board May instruct the committee to attempt to  secure funding of the plan Somewhere In My

185Memory   I remember and so I would ask you madam chair if  you would ask the board attorneys are we as board   members or committees allowed to raise money or  go out and secure money my opinion is no but I'd   love to hear legally and solve that problem right  now I'm going to pause that really quick because   we are at time for this um so I will make a  motion to extend time for five more minutes all those in favor signify by saying I I any  opposed okay that passes five or seven to zero   oh my goodness I I think we can get an answer  on that rather quickly probably within a day   and and pick the law out I I I tend to agree with  M Bradford's concern right now okay I was I was

186oh   mford because I am on the pl committee and this is  no idea um I would temper what my colleague to the   right said oh my gracious all right all right as  adoc under and then let Mr Perry you got to put Mr   Perry on that committee which is fine then let him  run the ball oh yeah under those circumstances but   not not not engage the group that we currently  have for the tasks that we're currently doing   it would it you know you could pull the staff you  maybe could pull the same teachers and principls   and so on but they were assembled for this task  and and and and and it's a it's a different group   of people so I I I like the idea um and I would  support it and then put then

187put Mr Perry on the   committee and then let him have his ad hoc under  then I would support that um I'm not asking to be   on your ad hoc either um but you know um you can  get at I'm sure but ideal on your ad hoc um she'd   be good too um I think that structure-wise that  would work and then we wouldn't have to go through   the whole process of getting it approved and the  language approved and inserting into the policy   thing talks about committees and all that we just  he he could he could start with ad HW ad hwks are   like that yes um Miss Justice hasn't had a chance  and then on Mr Perry okay I'm going to speak with   a different voice I've been in education over  30 years and worked in

188many different settings   my favorite people are Educators in this world  except for the kids and I know that the the most   effective teachers are always collaborative this  is how we learn um one of the things that's really   difficult is the state itself gives bonuses  according to Performance and there is so many   concerns about how they judge what performance  is we're really asking to do something that is   very it's almost impossible in ways and I myself  have always been a big cheerleader and proponent   of collaboration as our most Educators because  that's where we do the best in our schools our   biggest challenge is not having enough funding for  our Educators or be able to hire the resources to   support them it would be great if we had lots of  money but to the fact is we

189don't and in fact we   were really underfunded so I I applaud the idea  I think it's great this would work Wonderful in   the business world but educating kids is not  a business these aren't widgets and teachers   working together are are really their teams and  competing amongst each other is something they   don't do comfortably and as I said how you do how  you going to measure this and where you're going   to get the money is huge so I applaud Mr Perry  for trying to improve and and and and recognize   are hardworking teachers I think I think there's  so many hardworking teachers out there and not   just teachers other staff members this is going  to be hard um Miss Barner hasn't had a chance so   I'll let her go thank you madam chair I know we're  coming

190up on again on extended time here um I love   the idea and concept what I have learned is when  you are discussing with people of asking for money   they do not want a half coocked plan and so the  idea behind this of getting the input getting the   and creating what I would think a rubric of sorts  um so that we can have some clear expectation and   an opportunity for all to to earn that is is a  unique thing that I think would Peak the interest   in different different Revenue resources that we  as a board if we have one once this plan this is   this is an idea and then the plan and the work  will happen probably for months and months and   months if I'm being realistic here understanding  and I know I shouldn't say

191the BND d word but um   you know if 26 we have a bond on the ballot we're  going to be asking for a lot of money and just   being very direct here and so I don't know if 26  is you know the idea to take a pilot and Implement   something like this but potentially looking at  the year after but if we have a plan a thoughtful   plan of support of indepth uh discussions and  opinions I agree with that and I agree with my   colleagues of uh and I'll make a motion if I need  to do this make a motion to create this under an   ad hoc committee under Finance so that this can  be explored explored all right do I hear a second   do that motion I'll second that okay um we are at  time

192for this we also uh have I just calculated   approximately 40 minutes more of discussion items  as well as a closed session I know three moment   so Madam chair we need to be cognizant of that  time um Mr wior just real quickly I'm wondering   if we don't want to just delay this discussion and  maybe have it at the board retreat so we have more   time to do that um so that we don't you know we we  could jump on it right now take a vote and do that   or we could discuss it more in depth at that time  because we are running out of time Miss Barnhart   did you want to I'll amend to I will my motion  to say to postpone this discussion until the   board Retreats we can give I'll second okay all  any

193we we're out of time we yeah um all those in   favor signify by saying I I I I any opposed that  passes seven to zero resp continuing on um the   timing of call to audience um this was brought to  my attention to the superintendent's uh attention   um and just wanted to kind of bring the discussion  forward to the board uh about the possibility of   adjusting the timing of call to audience so I will  uh open the floor for anybody who has any jump in   if I could uh Mr woodor well um I'll be honest I  was one of those that was definitely 100% against   uh moving it changing it doing anything like that  uh you know you think about it when Miss Justice   and I were on it before we actually at one point  split

194it and then um you know had the important   or the things relevant to that meeting at the  beginning uh actually at the time we did uh uh the   Clos session at that point so people would come  in they wouldn't know exactly when they should be   there and then uh you know we had some folks that  kind of stretch their their topic so that it could   maybe be at um you know 5:30 or 6:00 in instead  of you know a lot of times Miss Justice you I   mean person to my right over there but she would  agree I'm sure that a lot of times it was 11:30   at night that we were uh trying to figure out  you know people you know weren't saying because   it really didn't make any sense to try to say at 

19511:30 to be heard so that made no sense uh we have   really improved that whole um that whole thing  you know we we we will probably be done tonight   unless we add a lot more time by 9:00 um and I so  I went out and talked to some folks talked to some   teachers I also talked to some parents I've not  talked to extensive numbers but I have talked to a   legitimate number of folks and got their opinions  um and you know five you know right now we we have   our call to audience somewhere between 5 and 6 o'  um and you know they say said to me very quickly   and very honestly well number one we can't get  there because of the uh rush hour but that's not   the most important thing we can't come

196because  uh you know I have to have my child's dinner   you know they need to be fed they need to be put  to sleep so we can't come we want to be there we   can't speak because of the timing our current  format for our um call for our meetings would   make it very clear you know that this the call to  audience would be from 8: to 9:00 um we could try   it my my suggestion would be and totally I'm like  I said I'm still not 100% on one side of the other   but um I think you know we try for 3 months if  it's after 3 months we say nope nobody's coming   it's horrible it's the worst thing in the world  you know then then we go back to what we're doing   if we on

197the other hand try it for 3 months and we  do see some of the parents from the students that   are actually coming here some of the teachers  that you know I put my children to bed but now   I'm able to come you know afterwards um I I  don't know like I said I'm not I'm not 100%   sure I don't know if that would fix the problem  and I don't know that there is a problem please   understand that we know we do as somebody uh  mentioned today we do you know give more time   than either Brunswick or Pender County I know  we had somebody that mentioned that before I   don't think splitting it is ever a good idea  because then all that does is have people have   to stretch the you know whatever they say but 

198I mean I wouldn't be opposed to trying an 8 to   n for two months 3 months or whatever else  uh you know we would know that it was that   that solid time so and nobody would be has to be  out here at 11:30 tonight uh to do it so that's   my thoughts Dr Merck uh I have really strong  feelings and I hope that I will actually be   able to sway you since you're not you're on the  T on the table right there after com you said   I don't know all six uh candidates for the the  board this time round ran on accountability and transparency we publish an agenda 48 hours  before this meeting and so our public   stakeholders only have 48 hours and then they  get to come here and and talk about and give

199us   their opinions and give us their concerns  about the things that we're going to vote   on if we put them at the end of the meeting  then we've already voted what we've told our   public is you know what thanks but no thanks  now I also have talked to a lot of teachers   who and I know this is changing and I give great  credit to our interim superintendent Dr Barnes for   this but a lot of teachers could come but they  are afraid to come the the idea that there has   been a culture of Retribution in this district  has kept our teachers from speaking up and I   know that it's going to change we are Dr Barnes  being in the school letting them know he wants   to hear them that's going to change I think  we'll start

200to see them even with our current   CTA timing Miss Bradford um I like what  my younger yeah that's right remember that this meeting is to conduct the business of  the board and it's a proven fact that at least   five of us have problems once we get to having  been here for a certain amount amount of time   8:00 seems to be a really convenient time for  some of us to start calling the other people   by the wrong name and things like that um no  names mentioned there and I want some clarity   from from um from one comment are you saying put  it at the end of the meeting or you saying it   putting it right after we conduct the business  of the board we have new business we have old   business so if you're saying that

201then I I could  be in favor of that um and I and I and I I differ   with the whole transparency because we we have  called audience not everybody speaks to anything   that's on that agenda but we also now have this  new fangled Contraption called email and we get   all these emails from everybody the day of five  minutes before throughout the week throughout the   month so we have a much bigger ability to contact  all board and the superintendent any time of the   day or night which wasn't there when the state  created policy uh the the legislation 115 which is   this is set out in there um and we would have to  amend our policy to do it um but we have so many   ways for people to reach us now that I don't think  it

202has to be before we conduct the business of the   board and it would be nice to try it like Mr wior  said and and and see how the conducting to the   business part goes with the called the audience  after that not before the other things that are   on the the agenda but but after the business of  the board new business and old business that would   be my suggestion Miss Barnhart thank you madam  chair um with respect to building the agenda it   is the board chair's job to do that and so you  have the authority to reorganize this agenda   however you want I do appreciate the one hour  called audience this goes looking at districts   across the state very large ones they have 30  minutes tops um I appreciate the Lottery system   because there was a

203period in time that it was a  first come first serve and I think that everybody   should have the opportunity I know um miss Ma and  I have even discussed translator options to bring   that in so we can get advanced notice if people  are needing services for translating whether that   be hearing impaired or a different language um a  different oral language spoken so I I also kind   of echo the sentiment when we come together  to do the business of the board it is our D   due diligence to be at our best when we're making  decisions and I think that um I think that taking   care of that business first is imperative and I  do want to say because when we were streamlining   the policy so that we had consistent expectation  for agenda posting the regular board

204meeting is   posted uh 5 days in advance and 48 Hours as  a general statute so this is not something   that we're just half-heartedly doing it's We are  following law when we are doing that which we are   sworn in to uphold and so I um have zero desire  to shorten the call to audience of a on- hour   time frame but I would say with respect to if it  does get moved in the agenda I think it should be   before close session because I know that was a big  frustration um in previous administration that um   called a audience was after a closed session and  I think that part was extremely disrespectful but   I do believe that we have uh really improve to be  diligent about following the timelines listed on   their agenda that used to also not

205be the case  um we now currently have time so you can kind   of get a really accurate estimate of when things  are supposed to be happening thank you ma'am um   where are we at time one minute one minute so I'm  going to make a motion to extend this discussion   for five and only five minutes okay all those  in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed no   okay sorry no what that passes four to three  good hearing okay let go ahead um wow thank   you Mr wildor for bringing up the fact that there  is another life after getting right off of school   um there's I have my two con that my main concern  is with what Dr Merck said is the fact that the   public wants to speak before we make decisions and  that's

206why it's logical to hold call the audience   first I also appreciate the fact everybody that's  up here that went through the process when I was   on the board previously that was horrible in fact  they intentionally put it after a Clos session to   Hope people would leave which was not fair or  right and so I Mr wildbore fought to do it the   way it is now so now we've got a conundrum because  I do believe it is true that there are probably   parents and people in school that want to go home  feed their kids put them to bed and then come you   know that can't come down um to me though I think  it's more important that the public get heard   before we make decisions so I have a tendency  to feel that that's probably the

207priority over   because if they really want to come they will get  their kids watched taken care of fed or whatever   because you know if you want to have something to  say before decisions are made that's the only way   you're going to do it it's for that night so  there is a conundrum here but I do appreciate   you bringing that up and I am glad that we're  having this discussion something that did not   happen on the previous board thank you and we are  at time for that I we just had five minutes was it   five minutes sorry I wrote it I wrote it wrong  Mr Perry sound like I would like to talk um I   I'm I'm I would be okay if we had two segments but  apparently Mr wo doesn't like that idea um because  

208I I agree with Miss Justice and Mr Merck that  we need to hear from the people about any agenda   item items that we are talking about if they're  talking about something that isn't on the agenda   I don't mind it being later you know that's fine  that's fine for it if we would have two sessions   like that but if if there's something that's on  the agenda we need to hear from them first this   is supposed to be government of the People by the  people and for the people so we need to listen to   the people thank you um and I am I have not had  an opportunity to say anything um I have have   to say you know listening to my colleagues and  the discussion that um I do hear the that there   are some parents

209that may not be able to come  at the earlier time um I also hear that if we   were to move it um that it would be after all of  the decisions are made and there would be um no   opportunity for the community or Li limited  opportunity for the community to publicly um   communicate their concerns with whatever we  were discussing whether it be policy or these   committees um and that that to me is is a little  concerning I know that we can use email um but   just so that the public can hear what other  people's concerns are so that if they have   them they know maybe they're not alone in that um  so that would be my my big concern I could I lean   toward not changing the timing of it to be quite  honest uh

210simply for that reason but also hearing   that if there is if there are families that  are unable to make it um that maybe we should   consider some sort of alternative way for for that  to happen I I I think it's it's worth discussing   um and getting more feedback from families  parents um teachers as a board to hear what   um what their thoughts are that's my to sents we  have one minute I will be very quick I I counted   no less than six uh teachers or administrators  in the audience tonight and every single board   meeting we have parents of our Color Guard we  have parents of our awardees we have teachers   taking pictures of their students who are involved  timing is not an issue to get teachers and parents   and and students here okay um um

211and mad chair  Miss Bradford would it be possible to move this   to our board retreat I'll second that point of  order Madam chair with respect policy outlines   you have the ability as chairperson to set the  agenda in the order you want so I appreciate   the dialogue but it is your responsibility to set  the agenda that's my point okay there was a motion   to put it on the board retreat and a second  uh all those in favor signify by saying I no   any opposed no Miss buoy can you call the role on  that one Mr Perry the motion motion is to put the   call the timing of call to audience on the board  retreat I miss Justice Miss Barnhart no Miss Mason no Mr wbore yes Dr Merrick no and Miss Bradford  yes all right that

212motion does not carry fails   continuing to the next topic um Miss Bradford  brought forward uh the grouping of call to   audience comments so I wanted to make sure she had  her opportunity to be able to talk about that and   I was just simply saying that we have a policy  that says if and and I do believe the the board   chair uh M Mar her correct me the board chair  can do this without a board vote um but when we   have nonprofits that come with the same topic week  after week month after month year after year that   perhaps those other people who didn't make the  lottery or who just felt like I I don't even need   to try because it's going to be the same people  saying the same things or if not you talk new  

213people into to coming and saying the same thing  um that that that it could be grouped when I go   to the County Commission and there's a group of  people that want to speak on one topic the board   chair will will designate one person to speak and  the group gets to actually the group gets to pick   who the one person is to speak and I just wanted  to consider that possibility so that we allow more   more people to speak I don't want to change the  amount of time we have I don't want to do any of   that I just want more people to come before us  and share what's on their heart so that it's not   taken up by just one topic or two topics every  single board meeting okay thank you Mr Perry I   understand

214uh where you're coming from and I think  uh because some people individual speakers might   feel like they got to their chances of winning  the lottery are not as good when you when a lot   of group members are doing it but I believe  that this is an unenforceable thing we cannot   ask people if they are a member of an organization  it's unconstitutional you can ask the lawyers um   we cannot ask for a membership list so my proposal  and the alternative is let's favor new speakers   that we could have two pools of people people  haven't spoken in the last three months they   get top priority and then the rest and this will  give uh new speakers an opportunity and advantage   to to speak for us to hear from them that way  we don't have to get into

215this whole dynamic   about you know trying to Who's Who belongs to a  group and who doesn't Dr Merck first amendment is   pretty important here and you know there might be  one person who says I want to talk about 4351 and   here's my reasons why we could someone else that  says I want to talk about 4351 but for a different   reason and we have a third person who says I  want to keep 4351 just exactly as it is right   so now we've got three different people for three  different reasons who want to talk about the same   thing and every single person's voice is valid how  can we try to shut down the First Amendment rights   of people to come out and tell us what is in their  heart so I don't think that it's either legal  

216nor moral to shut them down um I Believe Miss  Justice then miss Barnhart and Mr wamore um yes   um we're not even doing the lottery anymore very  rarely do we have this problem things have calmed   down a lot a lot of it has to do with it comes and  it goes and waves um so I don't think that that's   a although you know as a good suggestion that'd  be very difficult to do um also I am concerned   about the First Amendment there is also already a  provision in our policy that says if the speaker   and I'm not even sure how that would work I mean  if the chair decides to put people together okay   but I haven't even seen that come up and since  they put that in there years ago when I was on  

217the board I personally think we should leave it  the way it is it's a lottery system if you need to   be which hasn't happened very much at all lately  in fact things seem to be a lot calmer these days   so that's my say thank thank you again um this is  in policy so if this is something that we do not   agree with as a board then my suggestion would  be um the policy committee to take this up Mr   respectfully Mr chairman of the policy committee  so we can adjust that um again it is at your   discretion as the chairwoman to enforce the policy  um but that would be my suggestion if we don't   like the policy then we change it especially if it  is not legal as my colleague to my is claiming so   Mr

218wi deore well as you took my thunder as it says  um but it says in in policy if an usual number of   people request speak a majority of the board may  decide to request designation of a spokesperson   for each group of persons supporting or opposing  the same positions so again that's not it's   actually not her responsibility it's the board's  responsibility if we choose to do so thank you   if not as you said um Miss Barnhart we can we  can change policy of course but that's we need   to follow our own policy and obviously this was  vetted by a lawyer before and it's not against the   First Amendment so with all due respect to anybody  who said it was it's not um I haven't had the   opportunity to speak so I'm going to say just um

219I  was also looking at policy and seeing that but it   also says if an unusually large number of people  request to speak it doesn't say from a group it   just says an unusually large number of people  request to speak and you're referring back to my   on the right um we have had we haven't had the  lottery we haven't needed the lottery the number   the maximum number of speakers is 25 tonight  we had 21 I believe um and so we haven't even   hit that Max and it is the majority of the board  that does make that decision Miss Bradford did   you want to add anything I would just like to have  Madam chair I would like for you to ask the board   attorneys um to render their opinion on the First  Amendment and the legality of

220the policy that   we have and so on because we've had some things  said here tonight that could be misconstrued and   I agree with Mr wildbore uh with you I was going  to tell you first the the policy that we've got   that allows the the board to um set reasonable  rules and to designate a spokesperson tracks   North Carolina General statute 115 c-51 the  statute allows that one of the interesting   things about it is that the right to speak for  the public at one of these meetings isn't a First   Amendment right it's set by Statute just like the  general assembly doesn't have to allow people out   of the you know audience to stand up and speak  during their sessions you don't have to either   North Carolina General statutes what does it  but to Dr Merck's point and

221and I think also   one of the other some of the other members pointed  that out once you do start allowing the comments   you know then the first amendment comes into play  and and the issues about Viewpoint discrimination   but you are allowed to set reasonable rules to  govern these things that's why for example you   can govern for decorum and tell people that  you can't make personal attacks on on folks   when you speak and I thought a couple of times  we got close to that line tonight um but um when   it comes to the designation of a spokesperson  again the statute seems to allow that and it's   it's not so much Viewpoint discrimination  is it is a a time management issue um   to your point though you couldn't say everybody  in favor or oppos to policy B

222you're limited to   you know three minutes but everybody uh everybody  else who wants to talk about I don't know uh some   change to the curriculum you're allowed to you  know have as many folks as you want to it just   your rules need to be reasonable and even handed  but you are allowed to manage for time and I did   want to point out one other thing that question  you stomped me a minute ago on the Roberts rules   and Miss Justice you were correct uh Google AI  verified that there's no direct way under Robert's   rules to postpone something you know to say you  can't reconsider it but one kind of workaround on   it is that you can postpone something to a Time  certain for reconsideration so you could say you   know right um now the thing about

223that though is  that you've put it on to be reconsidered at that   time um so you gotta you got to think about that  anyway I just I did want to clear that up for you   that we and we are at time for that um continuing  uh the summaries of call to audience comments Dr Merrick thank you um what  I've noticed is that oh yeah   we have a trust deficit with the public we  have a reputation problem and you'll notice   that a great number of the call to audience uh  Folks up here are not telling us what a great   job we're doing they're concerned they don't  like what they see now I voted yes for interim   vice president be U inter superintendent  to become king no I mean superintend you know but the public was very

224very upset they feel  we we pulled the rug out from under them with that   decision and did not give them a chance to speak  what I'm asking for is so simple and it's so   little is that when someone gets up to do a call  to audience as is done in many many many different   municipalities we simply have the minutes  described very very briefly they talked about   policy 4,300 and they recommended this okay I gave  you an example uh in the in the documentation and   the reason I'm doing it is because as an executive  coach I do a lot of conflict resolution and we   have conflict with our general public they don't  think they're being heard they get up there and   they say I saw you looking down or laughing  or talking to your friends you

225weren't even   listening to me and by putting it in the minutes  we're letting them know this is what we heard and   in conflict resolution what can happen is the  they come back and they say that's not what I   said and I'm not I'm not I'm not opposed to that  I think that's actually a healthy thing that they   say what I actually said was this and then we can  we can amend the minutes in a matter of 30 seconds   and if they don't like that we can do it again but  that's how conflicts become resolved is that you   listen to each other until you know you've been  heard so while putting it in our minutes they know   they were heard it's simple yes it will take I'm  Sorry Miss buoy it'll take you a few extra

226minutes   to write down the basics I did it tonight by the  way it didn't take long so my recommendation is   that we ask our minutes to include what has been  said very very briefly by our call to audience   members and what their recommendations  are um Mr Perry and was there a motion that didn't sound like a motion did it no I make  a motion for all of what I just said that's a   very long motion can you yes I make a motion  that we uh Empower uh our secretary to include   a very brief description of of what is said in  cult audience with with whatever they recommend   and that's part of our minutes I second that okay  Mr Perry I actually agree with your sentiment and   why you want to do this we should be

227listening  and I just don't know if we want to send the   right message that we're listening but I don't  understand how a summary written by Miss buoy is   telling us that we're listening it just tells  the public that Miss buoy is listening so I   would suggest if we're going to do this at all  and I'm not saying we should I think maybe we   should take turns at doing it ourselves and uh  once every seven months thank you Miss Barnhart   thank you madam chair I appreciate the sentiment  um and I am going to disagree with my colleague   on the right we are listening but the reality  is when we're making decisions we have to get   input from everybody and that just doesn't even  come to an agreement all the time on this board   um so just

228because there's a disagreeance  does not mean that somebody was not hurt   it means given all the information that we  have access to as elected officials that   are the decision makers here which is what our  minutes are supposed to represent is the decision   and The Business of the board um by adding the  conversation of the call to audience into the   minutes with the concept of maybe they're going  to constantly be amended month after month or   time after time oh that's not what she said not  it takes away and distracts what we are here to do   which is the business of the board and so  absolutely hearing from the public is part   of the process but is not the only part of the  process um so I just want to say that I do agree   with the

229sentiment but I did I was reading and  I appreciate the documentation I enjoy reading   and prepping for all of the meetings but in  here there was an allegation saying some may   misconstrue that maybe we're breaking the law by  not putting the public comment into the meeting   minutes and so Madame chair if you so um feel  feel so inclined for our attorneys to address   that if we are breaking the law of not having  a record of but that that's kind of yeah Mr   generally speaking you could use just the video  recording for your minutes because it does give   an accurate you know Rec so no I don't think and  as an aside um you do have the video of these   things so you have a a perfectly accurate recount  of what people said that's one of

230the problems if   they want to characterize their speech it seems  like their their um call to the audience signup   sheet would be a place to um for them to put that  in their own words and then you can review their   the think that would be my take on it but um I  believe also someone on staff told me that we have   close captioning I believe on the on the video  minutes which helps for people that are um hearing   impaired um for example just a thought but yeah  we're allowed we're certainly compliant um it's   a policy choice for you guys so we are at time  so let's vote and there is a motion on the table sorry I'm sorry just uh in regards to the  motion the board can't direct Miss Buie   to do something um

231they would have to direct me  to do it I'm not really willing to have someone   else characterize those mints if you board  as the board decides to do that then that   will be something I do myself my concern  with that is if I hear something that's   erroneous or incorrect putting something in the  minutes that is wrong is one concern and two I   I don't feel comfortable with our staff  being sort of badgered by you you didn't   summarize me correctly so thank you um hearing  that Dr Merck would you like to amend your motion I'd like to amend my motion by saying  the sign up sheet should include the person's   name a a brief description of the topic and a  third column which is recommendations and and   then it all fits right into the minutes and 

232they they get a little bit more of a chance   to tell us what they feel I'll second  that and then it's in their own votes   well I think you already second but can  point of clarity Madam chair the motion   that we're voting on now is it literally just  to copy and paste the the signup sheet into   the minutes that it's already done we're  already doing that but into the into the   minutes correct that's what you're suggesting  okay with the additional those additional columns I second that somebody has second okay  sorry Dr BR is taking my candy um Miss buy will   you please call the role want a clarification  I motion is thank you read the motion is to add   another column to our signup that has actions that  need to be taken or recommendation recommendations  

233recommendations and more space for not just the  a one-word topic okay right but a description of   their call to audience and the recommendation  okay so the motion is to add another column   with recommendations and extend the ability to  describe their comment to the sign up Miss buoy   would you call the role Mr Perry I Miss Justice  yes Miss Barnhart yes Miss Mason yes Mr Vore   yes Dr Merrick yes M Bradford no all right that  passes six to one all right that's good moving   on to the letter of legal action regarding Power  School Miss Barnhart thank you madam chair um as   I informed you all uh and we had the discussion  of having a letter of legal action so this letter   is drafted there was some small syntax errors  and I did want to bring up

234one thing because a   colleague had mentioned it but I didn't feel good  about striking it without full board discussion um   but basically this is attorney this is addressed  to the Attorney General Jackson to pursue legal   action against Power School and the data breach  that has affected tens of thousands of individuals   in our County alone but across the state of North  Carolina did not think that it was most prudent   for us to use our attorney dollars to try to Sue  and per and take legal action however since this   affects the mass populace of North Carolinians  I think it is absolutely necessary and so if you   look at the third column it talks about urging  into investigating um legal action and so the   items where is it to address with the attorney  general um that we seek

235legal ramifications   to hold Power School accountable for their  negligence and to secure appropriate remedies   for the hundreds of thousands of individuals  affected across our great state we believe   that power school should provide comprehensive  identity protection and credit monitoring for   all affected individuals for at least 48 months  we further request that your office for excuse   me stricter vendor requirements to ensure timely  breach notifications and stronger cyber security   safeguards mandate improv security metrics to  prevent future breaches and ensure Power School   complies with all applicable data privacy laws  including fura and so what a colleague had brought   to my attention is power school is offering two  years of credit monitoring and currently that   process is taking place by Power School directly  as notifying the individuals of that breach um for   me personally I could go either direction however 

236I think it sends a message to our attorney general   understanding I don't like two years personally  so I think if we are in agreeance that we want to   push for something excuse me something stronger  for our constituents that we're obligated to do   that I do believe that if we take the charge in  this I think that other boards will try to pick   this up because this is a massive data breach  this was outside our control we are mandated by   DPI to utilize power school and it's absolutely  devastating um and we are going to be doing our   best to be responsive to the situation however  I'm trying to be remain professional here I do   believe this is the best way forward to have a  Target Focus so that we can get I mean the biggest   bang

237for your buck if you will a going after a  huge um massive breach that is affecting hundreds   of thousand people across the state so I would  make a motion to adopt this I'll okay I second   um because we are coming real close to time um is  there any discussion can we keep it I'll second   call question point of order Miss Bradford um this  isn't I don't think the final letter it doesn't   have the date on it Miss barnhard and it doesn't  have those changes that you told me that you were   going to make in terms of housekeeping the ey the  we and the date so I don't think it's the final copy or is it my apologies Madam chair I there  was three syntax issues board members that I   addressed and I will resend to

238make sure that the  most updated copy as we all see one was dealing   with having a date which would be February 4th  2025 the second syntax issue instead of saying   I am writing on behalf it says we are writing on  behalf of the new han County Board of Education   and in the last paragraph um there was some  dotted lines those just got took out because the   formatting wasn't wasn't um was not working with  me so um I will resend that right now to everybody   okay so so I would make a motion to adopt the  letter as amended with those small syntax errors   second okay all those in favor signify by saying I  I I any opposed that passes 7 to zero um Town Hall   regarding the AI I make a motion to postpone this  discussion

239to the next meeting because we have   close session do I hear I added this to the agenda  we voted to add it to the agenda do I hear a   second um you need a super majority to postpone it  postpone it till the next meeting to bring public   in talk about could I offer a substitute a motion  to move it to the board retreat we're going to be   busy okay so there was anybody want to put it to  the board retreat rather than wait a whole month   isn't this Moote okay we have I should have hold  on a motion on the floor we need longer discuss we   have 12 minutes so the motion on the floor was it  seconded Miss Barnhart motioned that we postpone   this till next month was there a second I make  a

240point point of order I need a second and I'm   waiting for a second second you wanted to point  of order um does this Mr Perry hang on I'm sorry   I may have misspoken I thought I was seconded Mr  Perry Miss barnhard I'm waiting for I I withdraw   my I'm waiting for a second hearing none Mr Perry  it's not postponed okay just quickly and I'll try   to make this quick I just this is a very momentous  decision as far as this a AI pilot program it's my   firm belief that once once AI comes into through  our schools it isn't leaving and we need to get   the input of our parents our teachers and our  community whether we're going to do something   this is a generational type decision this is  not something we should enter into quickly

241so   I'm asking that we host a town hall we can get  the community's input ask the folks from everan   to come if they answer the questions of our  community so that we can make a wise decision   on this we were from my understand we talking  Mr wior we already have one scheduled for March   maybe we could just move that one up and use that  I'll second is there was that a motion was yes the   motion can you restate it please I motion that  we have a a a expedited Town Hall uh on the AI   pilot as soon as possible with evidon Personnel  being there and to delay any vote upon approving   ever as our AI pilot program until after that I  second that I second M Bradford I love the idea   but I don't want

242to follow the three table  format we've been following for that um Mr   Perry's suggesting that we have public in and  so on so I I I I don't want to follow the the   typical Town Hall we've been doing this last year  or so I don't think that's the right format for   that I'm open to any format you like so with with  some discussion on how the format goes I would be   in favor of this okay just a point of order just  a reminder that the board chair sets the format of   that that's not something we do correct all  right call the question I'll second that okay   we're going to vote on calling the question that  requires a super majority so all those in favor   signify by saying I I any opposed passes 7 to  zero

243now the motion is to have an expedited Town   Hall regarding a i all those in favor signify  by saying I I I any opposed that passes 7 to Z um anyone have any correspondence announcements uh the Board  of Education will hold a board budget work   session on Friday February 7th at 1 uh general  public will have the option to view remotely   on YouTube the policy committee will meet Tuesday  February 11th at 1 um general public will have the   option tow remotely uh on YouTube both of those  are occurring at the here Board of Ed Center the   board Capital outlay committee will hold a a  meeting on Friday February 21st at 1 pm here   at the Board of Education Center uh Board of  Education will hold an agenda review meeting   on Tuesday February 25th at 2m

244here at the board  of ed Center and the general public will have the   option to view remotely the Board of Education  will hold a board budget work session on Friday   February 28th at 1 p.m. here at the board of  ed Center general public will have the option   to view remotely the Board of Education will hold  the March regular board meeting on Tuesday March   4th at 5:00 pm here at the board of ed Center  the general public will have the option to view   remotely on YouTube and yes Miss Bradford finance  committee was again on the 26th February the 26 okay okay all right I will now entertain a motion to go into  close session second pursuant to General statute   43-31 18.1 C I'm not reading it all tonight  y'all it's long uh we have a mo

245a first and   a second all those in favor signify by saying I I  any opposed that passes 7 to zero we are en closed you e e e I'll second all those in favor signify  by saying I I any opposed passes four to   nothing we are adjourned all right folks  have a good night good luck tomorrow dri

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.