001you e e e again it's two I'm going to call the agenda review meeting to order uh Miss buy will you please call the role good after afternoon Melissa Mason here jie warart here Pat Bradford I am here Judy Justice Dr Tim Merrick here David Perry here and Pete wior pres all right um we're going to have the invocation by Christian ruford Youth minister at Harbor Methodist Church and co-pastor at Surf church and um after that the Pledge of Allegiance uh bye uh Dr Merck good evening everyone and thank you for this opportunity to open today's meeting and a prayer my name is Christian Rutherford and I'm the youth pastor at Harbor United Methodist Church as well as one of the pastors of surf church here in Wilmington let us pray Jesus we thank you
002so much for this day and this opportunity for us to gather together in this space we ask that you would give us the wisdom and the discernment that we need to make critical decisions that are going to impact the lives of our children and our youth in this city keep our hearts open and our minds open to being receptive give us Grace where we need to be given Grace uh and just allow this meeting to move with fluidity uh and and at peace Lord we just love you we thank you for everything that you are doing and the blessings that you have bestowed upon us Amen to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with libery and justice for all right
003uh I will entertain a motion to approve the agenda Madam yes M I would like to add something to the agenda okay I would like to add under old or new business I don't care a discussion on committee assignments I'll second that any discussion Miss Justice uh yes um I don't think that's appropriate we I mind um we have policies to cover that and um I don't think that it serves any purpose for us to question our policies and that's what it basically amounts to the uh chair is given the ability to make assignments I have worked with good Lord five chairs and they have every one of them has made the assignments and changed the assignments and made them back again without question and believe me there was plenty of times I wanted to
004but since our policy is that way we need here here with it and if there is some reason that there's a disagreement with that policy then we need to send that to the policy committee and change it Dr Merrick yes I I know that some of the discussion was concerned around whether or not it stated those uh committee assignments stated that they were in process I just like to say for the record that every list is in process because the shair has the right to change them at any time so rather than move to have a discussion I would recommend that someone move to change policy and lacking that I say this is not the time or space to bring a Dury laundry to the public Mr Perry I understand M Dr Merck's concerns I
005do to be honest with you I would really like this controversy to uh get behind us so we can move together as a board um however as you said airing a laundry might not be ideal but it's already been out in the news it's already in in public view I don't see any point in delaying this much further because as long as we delay it we're not going to get past it so therefore I am for for a limited discussion on what the I think a lot of our problems is just the what what was communicated to us which swed the seeds of distrust uh maybe speculation by board members on what was going on because we weren't communicated well on what the process of the chair was intended to be and so I'd like
006to give everybody an opportunity to restore that trust and to move forward um I I will tell you that I I am for a reasonable discussion of this topic but if it turns into a circus I'm going to be the first one the motion that we ended any further discussion Miss Bradford um one of my primary uh reasons for bringing it up is as my colleague here said it's been in the media there have been social media reports there have been different agencies commenting and we've had no answers to our questions Among Us which is where it should reside um I've been on this board three times going through this process and this process was different than it's ever been before just yesterday I found out I'd been removed from a committee and um and
007switched on to another one and that's today's the 58th day since we voted on our board chair the 58th day and I think that's too long of a process um it's spred a lot of confusion um and so I think we should have a discussion so I will vote in favor of this okay anyone else all right uh Miss bu please call the rooll Miss Mason no Miss barnhard yes Miss Bradford yes Miss Justice no Dr Merrick decided do not [Music] Mr Perry yes and Mr wbore yes um so that passes four to three where was it going to be put Miss Bradford um either old older new business and what action is set to be taken on that CU usually when we have old business or new business there's an action item and since
008we one have not had time to prepare to deliberate on anything um would suggest it go under information it's not information new business should be fine so what is the action then we're going to have a discussion usually there's a vote under old or new business not always okay any other changes to the agenda I don't have a u Dr yes sorry I don't have an addition to the agenda I have questions about the agenda um we have a review of proposed agenda items but there is nothing on our agenda for what items we'll look at we do have what is what be yes um my question is I know that uh Mr Perry had uh agenda recommendations because he sent them to me and I know that I had recommendations because I sent them
009to you and then you sent them to everyone else I haven't received anything else and so in order for accountability it seems to me that we should all be kept aware of what items were recommended for agenda so that we can make sure that they are on the either this month or next month's agenda respectfully sir that is under the purview of the chair and the superintendent except that by policy it must be in the next two months correct thank you which is where many many items have been placed I'm still looking for a motion to approve the agenda I make motion I may I may I make a request teeing off of what Dr Merritt just said yes mord it might be helpful to me if when we have things on the agenda we
010know who propos them because earlier in the week or last week there were 14 things I thought were going to be on the agenda and then when the agenda comes out there's a whole lot less and I don't know who did what to whom and you know if one board member has four things on there and other board members have none I'd kind of like to know that so um would you have any objection to just putting beside each agenda item who had proposed it or is that in the comments when you drill down and it says who's going to um Bring It Forward should be in the comments I make a motion to approve the amended agenda I'll second that all right uh all those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed
011that that passes 720 moving forward we are going to go through um the February regular meeting agenda so um Miss Barnhart can you keep track of the time for me yes ma'am all right so we have the call to order apologies all right um roll call approval of the agenda invocation um is not yet set okay presentation of colors national anthem uh as of right now Under The Pledge um we don't have anybody is anybody willing to lead the pledge for um I think you did it last time Miss Bradford we lead the pledge uh approval of the minutes Madam chair yes ma'am there are no minutes to approve yet correct they will be there all right um recognitions yesly sign you have that available to you otherwise you right yeah it's yellow usually because
012it has posted to the public yeah but there are no minutes posted correct not yet they will be posted they will be posted um recognitions how long is that going to take 15 okay um student Voice have we heard back from student voice on whether they will be okay yes voice is preparing to present okay uh um teacher voice do we have a teacher set up for that yet okay uh interim superintendent report I know do we have to change that now not yet not yet no not yet official not yet there yes five minutes okay and I will need five call to audience 60 um under information um we don't have anything consensus items change order summary report Miss Bradford Madam chair I would like to on these consensus items I don't want to
013pull anything off but I would like to recognize some of the things that are going on in each one of them because I think they're extremely important um the change order summary again if you click on that little paperclip it's going to tell you what that is and um anytime we're spending the people's money I think it's important to recognize how we're spending the people's money um and you click on the little folder it's going to tell you how we're spending the people's money and um and if you don't know what a change order is it's when we have a contract and then for some reason the amount of money goes up or down then we have to have a change order for it and for example is this the one that has the $110,000
014that we saved on on uh enforcing yeah yeah so sometimes we save money and so these are really good things for people to look at I'm not going to belabor what they are but I just wanted to point that out for that one well that say again okay yes Dr so in today's agenda you're going to see restart School authorization our two restart schools are freemen and Snipes you will then see it again next week under consent agenda you'll hear about it today but I'm saying it so I can my crystal because I'll forget that it'll go into consent agenda for next week because it's listed as information so you guys won't be voting on it today you'll vote on it Tuesday in consent thank you and and I yes M um the budget amendment
015I think it's really important every time we have a budget amendment that it not be just a consensus that we talk about it um there's some serious stuff in here and again I have to ask the same question have we changed the fund balance by um doing these budget amendments we have not thank you um there's a couple in here that are really important um and so if anyone has interest in our finances be a really good place to hang out Madam chair yes Miss V I'd like to shine light on the additional allotments for principal and teacher bonuses um DPI has provided an additional $800,000 to fund bonuses for principles of and based on our test data because we kicked butt across the state so kudos to that $800,000 it's a lot of money
016um and our teachers and our staff deserve it and um the year-to DAT contracts and purchase orders this is when we spend three less than $300,000 you're going to get a report every year that shows us this or maybe even periodically but it's interesting to note the highest one in there is only $1,500 under the threshold but that's where you find out where you we're spending money for the district outside of things that we approve one at a time I'm going to pause because I need to know if anybody has any questions about any of these things other than are we Dr Mar yeah my question would be that you know we'll put them into the consent agenda but we can always uh move to take them off the the next week if we say
017wow $4 million that's a lot who's going to pay for that and we want to talk about it we can always pull it off this is also right now the time if there's any questions or concerns that you have about those items to ask those questions before we approve or should I ask now before we approve ask now okay $4 million who's paying for it that's the point of this meeting yep so that's you know that's obviously a large change now is that coming directly because the county has been you know supplying money for this or do they know it's coming or or are we trying to find it in our budget I'm sorry the $4 million uh change order at new han High School Edie can you talk to the CH that this is
018a report of um chain that have it's already been presented to the board and approved so yes the county had agreed to pay for that and we uh the change so so we're not on the hook for finding another $4 million right now thank you so much Mr Anderson yes it's already all right is there any questions that anybody has for the procurement plan for the Child Nutrition program I would just like to meet the director okay I ran in a request to the superintendent but he ignored me you want to meet the nutrition director yeah sure hey give her a call she's right next door yeah we have don't we have a presentation about that today or is it just as we approving I don't have [Music] okay okay um but I would like
019to meet her yes great thank you um any questions on the year-to-date contracts and purchase orders okay uh contracts extending into fiscal year 2026 any questions on those all right um exemptions from formal qualification based selection for Professional Services any questions on that Mr Perry so [Music] and this is for uh could you say professional uh which is that anything or this is for [Music] thank you um so we're good with keeping consensus items for five minutes okay uh moving on to Hol under policy consensus there are a lot um mror can you comment on great polic meeting today and I do want to thank for ting in that U that meeting it was very very beneficial we got through a lot and U so most of these policies have very small uh changes could
020be anything from word or two to a whole bunch of U uh documentation at the end um we did have several one and really need spend a little bit of time um most of those are um just basically uh very small changes uh if anybody has any questions about any of those I know that M Justice to pull off um 4351 um so we can do that and and have further discussion at that time about that then we also have the um discussion of the uh 95 9125 Mr Perry want to pull that off and discuss it further and then we also had several that we brought forward including the um uh device which I can't find here toen uh 6129 thank you fin found it um and uh I think we've actually come to
021a good conclusion with that one uh the anti-choking devices overall uh the way to handle that our attorneys attorneys were exceptionally helpful in that so I do thank you any may have any questions about any particular Miss Bradford yes um and going right there page 21 from policy 6129 the um our board attorney said he was going to check with our insurance carriers and have you done that not to corresponded by email with them this morning but I don't have a definitive answer okay so I would say we hold that one if we haven't heard by then um moving on page 52 of the policy um 4312 7320 quite interesting that this policy is here because a lot of folks are here today to talk about Ai and here it's talking about Ai and we're
022adding generative AI so those of you who haven't read it might want to read it um because we're we're adding it um just it was just a point of order there on that one moving into policy 3420 um which is sual profession um item F in the policy committee meeting the other day I was reminded under reading camps that are dearly departed Mr mcmanis this was one of his had peeves he wanted all students that couldn't read to go to summer camp so I'm wondering if we can look at the reading camps and there's anything that we can do to tighten that up so that our failing students who can't read can be urged to I know we can't force them to go to reading camps but I would be interested in that coming back
023around as a discussion item um because it was dear to his heart and it's dear to mine if you can't read you know things are not going to go well for you miss barard along the vein of the discussion for that specific policy I know that we have a lot of different interventions that we do with our students and so it might be better suited rather than to talk about changing policy of an optional intervention that we are not allowed to force our students to do um maybe I would offer an alternative suggestion as a presentation of some of the interventions that our schools are actively participating in um so that we can see the for our buck and I know um the biggest struggle in being in the teacher realm is getting kids to
024come to summer school so the reality is sometimes we're not even receiving these children and so there are better ways to intervene that are more effective um to continuously bridge that learning Gap so I I'm not saying I disagree with having it in policy but I don't necessarily want that to be the focus because I know there's active interventions that are happening in our schools and so rather than address summer camps I would rather like to see how we are actively participating with students who are already coming to school and how we're getting them then so um that would be my alternative to that I was going to speak to that a little bit um just in my days as an elementary principal there are a lot of different things that we were able to
025do like we could actually have longer blocks of reading you know really focus on the reading so that that was one possibility uh after school things um you know I know the state as a whole in New York past have tried things like uh mandating a third grade reading camp where if you don't come then you stay in third grade you know but then is that the most effective thing to do is to keep those children back in third grade and keep them you know what what if they don't do in second year then are you going to keep them back in second year so that you know there's a lot of different things that that have been tried uh to to help and obviously I agree 112% as did Mr mcmanis that if we
026don't if the children don't are not reading uh there's you know there's a high correlation uh to them just not being successful in math reading uh or science social studies any number of activities and in life in general so I think it is extremely important uh Dr bar yeah I think maybe this is a time where the board doesn't rely on its own expertise but looks to the district to bring us options rather than you know coming up with a up or down vote we asked Dr Barnes uh or his staff to come with some of the different Alternatives so a couple things one I want to make sure we think about the fact that we're also highlighting things like chronic absente chronic absenteeism because if we could put 20 or 30 more days in
027those kids schooling in a year we may see some of those numbers need to decline but what I would propose if it's good with the board you need your pen out um is next board work session no I mean excuse me next board agenda review session we can do a presentation on an update on where we are with our reading scores for the mid year because we should have already done the midyear reviews do you think we'd know that [Music] so sort of like a state of the union for where we are with literacy and and some of our thoughts about encouraging summer school we can certainly do that if you'd like at the board's pleasure um are we good with that particular policy no and two more things on that one right there under
028M it says reporting requirements so I was going to ask you if we had done that yet so you just answered that question but flip in the page um under notification to parents are we doing that ma'am ma'am fired by law and it says go home to parents and it also goes into the students um per okay thank you very much all right um I actually had some questions myself uh or a at least one question uh 4334 5035 7345 which is the use of unmanned aircraft or drones um a couple weeks ago um four board members and Dr Barnes went to uh ethics training and they talked about uh different kinds of insurance do we have drone Insurance that's interesting because that was one that they brought up we do not have a separate
029drone insurance policy um as long as we're following the state requirements as far as how high it they have to be and those types of things which we always double check to make sure we're doing that then our in insurance covers that thank you uh anybody uh Miss Bart thank you madam chair I just if the chair policy wouldn't mind speaking to the Federal grant Administration the 8305 the changes in where they came from for that document 8305 it's the bottom of the page there's a heavy blue paragraph and just just to give us some context of where it's coming from 8305 it is the Federal grant Administration page five of six on policy 8305 yes thank you my apologies violations of policy uh this all came from uhcs okay I didn't know if there
030was a issue of employees and implementation of this thank you for that Clarity um Miss Bradford um um looking at policy 5022 registered sex offenders everyone will know that this tightens this policy so that we are even tighter in keeping sex offenders out of our our classrooms and our schools but I'm curious about the exceptions and I don't know who this goes to Dr Barnes if this goes to you or whom maybe Miss Barnum but under policy 5022 item D exceptions it talks about how a person who has been B from the school may be on school property under the following circumstances and it's sort of interesting um and it talks about voters so when voters come onto our campus if they're a sex offender they can come onto our campuses and do we still
031have voting when kids are in the school and they share the space we have tried to eliminate any sort of large voting times like on years like this past year obviously we called that a no day of school um to allow our students to the safety but also allow our adults the a chance to vote as well so you know these are very clear these are not ones that we created ourselves these are from um the general statute but we monitor this is to make sure that we can monitor those exceptions carefully so that we can sort of hem in when those people are there and they're monitored and supervised okay CU it's it's it was concerning language right Municipal elections yeah some communities we do and I would say that also we have a
032very strong system of signin in the office that actually will ping a principle if someone tries to scan their license and they're on a registered list it automatically tells the school and pings the principal and the assistant principles and then also of course we also have our finger printing and background checking as well for volunteers for staff I remember maybe not last year but the year before getting some emails from parents are saying you know why are you having these people in our schools are just wandering our schools on voting day and so that's my concern if they registered sex offenders are coming to vote in a school on the odd years where we have manyi elections how do we tighten that down or how do we stop having school and voting at the same
033time is probably what I'm asking [Music] over theal years [Music] munpe we have been working Collections and change some polling sites to really isolate the voting uh location so I'm thinking of like Masonboro a great example so if you're going to Masonboro to boat you pull in the bus parking lot you go into the multi-purpose room you go out of the multi-purpose room you don't go anywhere inside the school other than the multi-purpose room um and we have achieved that at most all of our schools there are a couple of schools where uh it is a short distance to get to where they're going um like eatting and cottington when you come in you have to go up the hallway and then you're going to turn to the right around the corner so you can't
034enter the multi-purpose room from the exterior you have to come into the lobby um so we've changed some things over at sunset uh how we were doing things elections were held in the media center we've now moved those and changed on that day um some activities that students are having so that um both voters enter and exit the building from the exterior and we're using the multi-purpose room there so we've made a lot of changes and there have been a lot of improvements but as you say ideally we have any voting um when it's um when no students are on campus That's good I've been appointed to the C Mr Harry yeah so just not knowing the uh procedure do we I mean obviously we have a choice when it comes to you know what's
035a you know what's a teacher work day and what which which days are students I have the day off or have a remote learning day or whatever but do we have any choice in in regards to say carington that's where my grandson goes so um do we even have a choice when it comes to allowing them to uh I mean can the Board of Elections just force us to be a ping place or do we have to actually agree to that it is um written into the state law that school or public schools um are available for use by the Board of Elections Madam chair and I think for I'm sorry uh Miss Bart thank you um I I had brought this up to Mr Anderson's attention because of the concern um just like we're
036talking about today of how can we utilize spaces that have a sole entrance and exit so that there's no cross contamination for our students in the event that we have students in school and so this is something that I'm happy with my new board members to come on and continue the conversation with the Board of Elections because we are elected officials public schools by General statute like Mr Anderson said are polling sites um however there's other places that can be opportunities and so working with the school system make sure that the only sites that we are first offering up are those ones with solid entrance and exits that we don't have to walk through any hallways to get to for those voters was a priority in discussion with this but I'm happy to reach back
037out to the Board of Elections with anybody else who wants to continue that conversation um I think it's a good thing that we need to continue to bring up because they're not thinking about that whenever we're um planning and I know for the larger elections school has been closed but Municipal and sometimes early voting dates and I think I think our election that we were in um got postponed and so sometimes things change and so the students are in school when voting opportunities happens but um I'm happy to pick that up with any board member who'd like to continue that conversation um Dr mer yeah I just quickly wanted to amend what you said Dr barn around the checking in and being flagged because I have been in two different buildings where those didn't work
038and so I really do need to make sure that you know if that's being relied upon as one of our defense mechanisms we really need to make sure those card readers uh licensed readers are working in every building that we have oh thank you and if anybody notices that they're not working please let us know Mary say and if I could Mard I'd love to join you in that because um you know in my neighborhood uh we always voted down at the little castle Hane Park uh anex thing and all of a sudden recently it's been changed to Castle V Elementary School which you know it's like well you know why probably because the number of people that come through I would imagine but I think you know having that discussion with the Board of
039Elections to say if we can uh you know avoid that at all possible um you know I know the park is decorated at that little place so that's probably half the reason but U anyway I think that might be a good discussion Mr Justice okay this this is an interesting discussion as a retired history teacher here our public schools are like anchors in communities this is the reason it's in State Statute um I know that there are situations that there's always going to be a situation of danger on campuses and there may be more well there's more people on campus during this time but I personally as a citizen don't want to discourage use of our Public Schools as voting places I know from when I taught Civics it was a great opportunity for me
040to point out to our kids when yeah lessons that this is what they were doing they were coming in and why um and usually they would do it we we have our calendars adjusted around it that's just practical I I mean that's what we do uh but the few days that when I was teaching and it was happening in school simultaneously it was a wonderful teaching opportunity to our students so I mean I know that we're afraid these days of so many things but we also have to be wrap brains around the fact that we also need to have teaching opportunities and be part of or part of this community and embrace that also thank you any further discussion on this particular policy just miss Bradford goad with the history of new han County anything
041we can do to keep sex offenders off our College off our campuses is what we need to do I miss Justice I I just gave facts and there's a lot more to our history than the voting problem in fact I don't think that's ever been an issue I'm sure that we watch and we protect it but there that that history really isn't touched on our voting locations okay um any other policies that people have questions about specifically Miss Bradford no I'm just waiting for 9125 okay um let's go on to 9125 then um did you want to say anything Mr P yes um I this was not a consensus item but I pulled it off at our policy committee because I I believe that the uh given the uh decision in 2023 by the United
042States Supreme Court in the uh cases against UNC and Harvard and the racially based admissions that uh these kinds of schemes uh were were showing favoritism towards one particular ethnic or minority group our violate 14th Amendment and we all took an oath here to uphold the Constitution of the United States of America so yes we also in general should should obey state law and I realize that the state law requires us to have 9125 but I do not believe that we are required to follow unconstitutional laws in in fact I think we have an obligation not to um Miss Justice I would be the first one here to say we have to follow the laws um having that up taught them so often this is an interpretation recent interpretation of the Supreme Court about a
043different type of institution not our Public Schools so uh not at this level so at this point I don't think we're in any position to make that determination and according to the law uh we have to follow state law and federal law so um Mr Perry are you actually asking us not to do this I'm I'm a little confused what what's your ask hold on maybe you can um Dr Merck did you want to she cover okay m Mr Perry did you want to respond yes I I believe that something that's clearly unconstitutional isn't something that we should be following regardless of whether the state law says uh that we should or not because we all took an oath to uphold the Constitution and our system of governance the United States Constitution and our state
044constitution prompts any other state statute uh Mr wbore and then Dr Merck I would ask U ch turn to our attorney to um I can't say I agree with Mr Perry's comment that if a law is deemed unconstitutional by an individual we have to follow it or not I would say that I'm researching right now Mr Perry's question and that is if we eliminate that specific policy do we still have to follow North Carolina state law with respect to minority uh in contract so the broad SW swipe is I don't agree with Mr Perry the more concise uh swipe is that I'm going to look at that so that you guys can make a decision as to whether or not you want to keep policy 9125 I hope that answers your questions Miss Sutton you
045had a comment I want to add um so General statute 143-8 point2 speak speaks to um the requirement of following this policy um if you are to accept state grants or state funding so I think that's um the reason behind why we're following this um why we have that call uh M Bradfords clarification Miss Sutton so you saying if we were to uh vote to remove this from our policy we could no longer get state grants and I think the attorney and and I can research this but according to this General statute it appears to me that it's a requirement of accepting State funds thank you uh Dr Merck yeah um absolutely it should be in the the legal domain and we we need your help uh Mr Kroy uh but David to answer you
046directly I am not interested in Breaking the Constitution but I I Just Disagree that it's clearly unconstitutional I don't think it's clear as mud okay so in the case that we do have state law and then we have a question about constitutionality I would have to go in favor of what is clear in the law so at this point um especially based on funding I'm going to move that we put 9125 uh back into the consensus but point of clarity Madam chair M barart second we're not voting on the policies today this is just openly having the discussion to raise the concern that people were sharing about our policy and so I just wanted I just want to make that aware to our new colleagues um so this is not being voted on today just
047bringing to the attention where the concerns are coming from so that can have the open dialogue I I do believe that this conversation is going to be more gerain at the board meeting and so to pick it up back then I agree Mr old there's an MR on the table in a second Mr will deor okay I was just going to say I think that maybe even the our attorney and miss suon the week to be able to fully research this would give us more clarity one way or the other that's you have a motion Miss Jus I I think he was he was just asking to return it back so we could discuss it next time because remember we had pull that's that's what Justice is your microphone oh sorry about that I'm leaning
048back to I I'm sorry about that um uh I believe that uh Dr Meritt was referring to the fact he just wanted to add it back to that's all not having a vote to on it but they add it back to the moving it back to consensus items okay Miss Barnhart I just have one point of discussion um hearing the conversation couple things we are bound by law to follow all the laws with state and federal guidelines so whether or not we have this policy formally and our policy manual we're still Bound by federal and state law so I just want to point that in as far as whatever it lands Us in any of the state law we are bound by that and I can see I can see and appreciate where my colleagues
049are coming from but I just want to point that out there in the discussion process thank you madam chair any further discussion on the motion Mr Perry I believe we it passed through policy to move towards to thing I think we should continue this discussion at our next meeting and Mr K you can give us a report we can take such vote such action at that time okay so there is a motion on the table um all those in Dr Merrick I appreciate what you're saying Mr Perry and if you would make an amendment to my motion I would uh retract my can you point of V can you please State your motion again the motion was to move 9125 back into the consensus agenda because we had already discussed it here enough but if
050you feel it needs more uh another look in the policy committee I will retract my motion and move that we move it back to policy Mr Perry I I'm saying we should before we vote to um Senate I think we should vote on sending it back to the policy committee at at our meeting next week after Mr KY give us a report oh okay so there is a motion on the table to move policy 9125 into policy consensus Miss buoy will you please call the role Miss Mason um no Miss barnhard no Miss [Music] Bradford no M Justice no Dr Merrick no Mr Perry no and Mr W yes no all right so passes seven to Z as all right is there um moving to yes M Bradford if if Dr mer wanted to make
051that motion I would be happy to Second it to move it back to policy I move that we take 91 25 back to policy second okay Miss Justice can we just I thought we were going to okay what we had just agreed to is put it back to leave it as is to leave it as is and then we would discuss it during our next meeting so you're taking a step further back and putting it into policy committee policy okay this is which goes further back but I'm I'm just don't really it just slows it down is this going to have any kind of affec any of our contracts how's that sound or any kind of state funding at this point it it's currently in policy so we are we are following it's it's currently
052if you if you compare the the North Carolina General statute with um policy which one is it 9125 9125 they're almost identical and we are currently following that policy and will continue to follow that policy unless it is modified now if the policy is eliminated we still have to follow the general statute because we do receive state funds our Lottery funds are State funds for construction so we still have and this is this is only dealing with um you know build well primarily dealing with building contracts um my question would be if it goes back to policy what changes are going to be made to the policy Dr Merrick I believe that Mr Perry wanted the legal department to take a closer look and all I'm doing is giving that an opportunity to see the
053light of day I don't expect anything's going to change I think this policy with the minor revision uh is required in in in a lot of ways but I want to give you your time to take a look at it with the lawyers Dr Merck acknowledging my current workload it would uh uh put putting me under a weak deadline to research this law and what I understand is our pros and cons of trying to not follow it uh would take more than a week so with that said um I hope that it gets pushed back to the policy committee for more consideration okay Mr Perry uh given that um given that what what uh Mr KY just said in that um and that he cannot give us a legal analysis by our meeting next Tuesday
054uh then I but I'm guessing that you could give us legal analysis by our next policy committee meeting yes okay okay so then I'm fine with that okay so there is a motion to move policy 9125 uh back to policy um I guess um all those in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed no that passes we lost one for a minute uh 521 all right um policies for first reading generally and you can correct me if I'm wrong Mr will board those are just we're looking at them and then we send them back through right right we've actually changed Madam chair we've uh changed the date of the policy committee to give more time for the public to be able to hear them and to uh give us feedback so yes that
055you are exactly right and um if you could just I know um 5120 was one that the public had brought to our attention um I see that it had been approved by the board in 2021 um and so that's why this is coming back is that it was never sent forward to ncsba for the online policy manual correct the the attorney at the time uh had it and um was not did not bring it forth to us okay one so that is why that is there Dr mayor it's it's not clear to me that it was actually passed is it because if it was passed that's what hold it I thought we heard in policy that no one knew exactly where it was at Dr Barnes I found it it had actually been sent it
056was approved by policy it was supposed to go to ncsba to get it included into our policy manual we pulled it back and said hey double check and make sure this matches our mou and then it never went got back to the lawyers to put in our SBA so it did go through the board completely I just wanted to make sure I floated it back to you guys before I just stuck it into policy because it had been approved yeah it's already been approved right um Miss Justice yeah I just want to put in I think that time during the time that Mr Shai was leaving the firm so that might have been the confusion why disappeared we did approve it I and Dr Merck did you have a comment yeah if it's been approved
057I can imagine why uh stakeholders would be upset with us that we were going to go back and look at it and prove it again that's why it's under policies for first reading it'll go through first reading go back to policy go through second reading and come back to us for approval I understand that but are you saying it was only approved by policy committee or was approved by the full approved by the full board yeah it was so if it's approved by the full board it should be in our policy manual and then we should decide to look at it again if we have questions about it I'm fine I was just want to make sure that I brought it back as transparently as possible to make sure you guys knew that it was
058out there somehow it it we follow the threads of the email to see I don't know is if it's really I think Mr K if you can give them advice I don't know how it whether it needs to go back at all I just want to make sure I've floated it back I think I said last week at the policy meeting that I was not comfortable in approving it or trying to to tell anybody what happened 3 years ago it may have been approved as Miss Justice said but it somehow got Lost in Translation my comfort level would fall with this board approving it and revisiting it if need be by this board um because it doesn't sound like it ever got into our policy because of that that's my opinion I don't know what
059happened it was three years ago Miss barnhard did you have a and I you looked like you did so you don't need no I do I'm there's a lot in this discussion I am fine with keeping this as policies for first reading so we can have open discussion about it because otherwise seemingly it looks like we're being shady when it was a board 3 years ago that didn't get uploaded in process so I think that this is a a good place for landing um my other question Madam chair is under policy um how long do you think this discussion will take for our agenda 4 and a half hours I say 15 minutes Mr willor says 15 minutes just the one right for the whole for the whole policy just for clarity Madam chair 15
060minutes for the whole policy discussion I have um Dr Merck and then DRS I believe there's a difference between having it be approved and having it you know the the clerk putting it into the books there are many policies that are in our manual that were not passed by this board clearly and so if this was passed by the full board my reading of it is that it is now our policy regardless if the clerks put it into uh our policy manual we have stakeholders here saying hey where is it I think we owe the public to say hey if it was passed fine if we have problems with it we review it I move that we uh thank you P I move that we move that we uh put 5120 into the policy manual
061as it stands I'll second there okay uh Miss Justice and then Mr Perry okay uh the reason we even discovered it wasn't in there is because people will finding it being referred to in our policy manual and it was missing um and at this at this point I tend to agree that we've got so many of the things that we need to be looking at fresh new and forward when this has already been done it was approved and we could possibly then have somebody I'm not sure who would and go back to those meetings CU everything is recorded in minutes and find out if it was approved and if if it is then that would give you a good reason we should put it in the manual it was it was yeah well if it's
062if it's been documented and it was then I see no reason why it shouldn't be placed in there Mr Perry if we can prove I'm ageing with Mr CR here if if we can prove for certain that it was approved I got no problem putting it back into the policy committee right now but I think you had some questions as to whether we can actually prove that anything Miss Bradford I am really confused and torn but I'm going to go with the lawyer always generally um because that's what we pay him for you know to advise us to keep us from having problems I don't understand what the controversy is here is anybody objecting to the actual policy are they just objecting to the fact it wasn't in and now we want it in and
063so on somebody clear it up for me because I'm confused Mr w as I understand say it was passed it went to to the other turn not you it was not your your flip up they kind of held it it may have been at a time when we were going between one attorney to another attorney anyway it never got put in but I I'm going to police Dr barnch that he said that it was passed by the former board and I don't think unless we undo what they did I think then we need to I that's why I seconded doctor um thank you thank you going to Dr mck's uh um motion because you know if if you passed by a former board I think it needs to be in the policy manual unless we
064as a as as a policy committee or as a whole board decide it doesn't need to then we can revisit and pull back out but short of that I think it you know it was passed Dr Barnes has done this research and uh he said it's done so um Miss Bradford follow up among the seven of us does anybody have concerns with the actual policy I don't think that I'm hearing that see we're just kind of talking about semantics right corre if you have objections to the policy please say them now and what they are anyone okay Miss Justice than you uh what is you're hearing all of this you've been talking with and it was passed I sure you it was he said he looked it up and it was and it was correct
065I acknowledge what Dr Barnes has said and I'm not trying to undermine Dr Barnes but until I see an official transcript of the minutes of that meeting I'm just I'm I'm hesitant to make one call or the other okay well and that's very valid yeah so is there some way we can pause this until he looks at it and then he can get back to us I mean how can we do this to save time if it's already been done and it's all just a matter of looking up some records and then saying okay let's do this sure I I I didn't want to look so suspicious like all of a sudden T it showed up one day with no explanation so how about I do this I I'm going to verify with you the
066transcript to the minutes and I'm at the board's pleasure I can bring it back to you next week and you guys can put the baby to bed if you want all right so I like that plan thank you we do have a motion on the table to uh move it move policy 5120 um and put it in the policy manual correct but I stated that correctly all right um Madam chair Dr Merck I will amend my motion that Dr Barnes and Mr kumy will verify and if they have no further concerns it does not need to come back to us and they have the right to just put it right into the manual I'll second that okay thank you sir all right so any discussion on the amended motion M just make sure you tell
067us after that happens so we'll all be relieved that's all all right we certainly will okay so the motion on the table is to move the policy 5120 to the policy manual upon confirmation of the of Dr Barnes and um Mr KY of it having been approved okay all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that passes 7 to zero moving on um we have 6129 did anybody have any questions concerns about that it's first reading so okay um K to2 suspensions how long is thate going to take that's under old business is 6129 that's the anti-choking device no one has any questions about anti-choking I just asked and nobody did so okay to two suspensions point of uh order is this the is is this the is this the policy that
068we adopted a policy committee regarding uh suspension notification or is this something else no uh this is just placed here under I believe there was an update Dr Barn correct the K to2 suspensions was there an update that we had discussed you guys had talked about a policy Amendment with some language in it but it's under old business um I assumed that there was going to be discussion about it that's why I put it in their old business gotcha I guess it can be discussed under policy under that either one so we can remove that all right and I will second that um any further discussion on the K2 suspensions being removed hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I I oppose that passes 7 to zero um Dr Barnes and I
069had discussed this and um Miss Barnhart reminded us reminded me as well uh we prior to the new board getting on had been um having New Hanover High School updates um and so I would like to make a motion to add New Hanover High School update to Old business second yeah all right any discussion hearing none all those in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed that passes 7 to zero um Dr bar how long do you think that will take that part of the policy commission I would say the new han High School upate oh five minutes five minutes Eddie can you hit five minutes thank you Mr Anderson sorry all right under new business we have ad hoc committees um I'm going to go one at a time bus driver transportation
070um how Miss Justice how much time were you anticipating that um that possibly 10 10 minutes at the most and I will need input big time from Eddie in past experiences in this uh of this committee and this um concern remember when we worked on this three years ago I think it was four years ago the bus the bus transport exactly are we working on an ad hoc committee to to figure out a way to H to to get more bus drivers basically cuz that the biggest need and bus bust AIDS um we did as I said didn't we do this four years ago it's been a while but we did do this I mean we've been we're constantly doing things to you know improve bus driver uh Recruitment and Retention I don't recall ever
071having an ad hoc committee um we may have Mr Balo was in charge of it is there um I mean we've hired more drivers this year uh than we have and probably previous 10 years we still having short Mr Anderson can you can you speak to what we've done so far to acquire and retain bus drivers and what we've done in the process of making routes safer just well in terms of um you know what we've done to um attract people to become bus drivers the CDL process is cumbersome and it's time consuming m the biggest change that we've made um is to expedite that process so if you come to us uh we will pay all your expenses to obtain your CDL but it still takes a long time so what we also do
072once you go in the first step and and you study and pass the written exam once you do that we'll bring you on as a monitor so that you can start work you're not waiting for a paycheck um Plus we team you with a driver that can help you learn what they're doing um so you're getting some on the job training because the last step is you have to go out with a u DMV official and do the driving test and what we found is that going through this process the success rate of them passing the driver test has imp of the road test has improved because I think they're more com comfortable with it um and you know we we now have more people going through the process and um you know in obtaining
073their um CDL and and coming to work for us permanently whereas before someone may start the process but then not finish it for a month or so and in the meantime they found another job uh so that has probably made the biggest difference um we also have a hiring bonus and a referral bonus so if there's school system employees that uh refer someone to the district and they become a driver I think it's 90 days successfully driving um they get $1,000 bonus plus the new employee gets a $1,000 bonus um we have increased our marketing uh you may have seen on a lot of vehicles not just for drivers but for all of our POS positions there's a QR code you know we're advertising constantly that we're hiring we're attending job fairs uh for new
074Haner County Schools as well as others um so we're doing a lot of things to recruit drivers I think what hurt us mostly this year and last year as I mentioned we've hired more drivers this year or La let's say we hired more drivers last year than we have in previous years but we've also had a lot of retirements so you know it it um the the difference the balance wasn't as good as yeah I'm not sure well you're bringing you're bringing a lot of expertise which is you got more expertise than anybody about what's going on in this District but uh the point of the committee I don't TR to be too loud now was is is the idea and for example in Pender County right above us they're doing some ideas I know
075that in the past that we I believe were trying to apply for Grants through the endowment Forum there's different things there's counties across the state coming up with new innovative ways to try to get drivers and the funding necessary because ultimately when you get down to it our bus service is so limited to our needs we don't have enough drivers is the main reason you told me we have the buses we just don't have the drivers and this is a problem across the state so I was thinking the purpose of the committee would to be bringing all these different ideas from from the different maybe even other states or and try to come up with to apply it to our district and we do have for example as they said the endowment that's one opportunity
076for Grants you know what I'm saying there's other things we could be doing than what we are now just because there's always people with better ideas that we can maybe learn from and get from that's the idea of the committee Dr Merck thanks Mr Anderson um the the phrase that many are retiring might be more gentle than reality I'm wondering whether this is people who have gotten older and have chosen to stop work or if we're losing our bus drivers because of you know maybe it's not an appealing job um we have we of course we have drivers that come to work for us and then drive for a year and say this is just not a good fit for me um but recently we have had a lot of people retire they reach that
077retirement age or they even come to work for us after they've retired from another position this is a part-time job form fits well into their schedule because they're working kind of a split shift um so but after a few years of driving they're ready to retire for good uh so we've had some um some retirements for that some retirements for medical issues um that that seems to have been the two biggest issues or or reasons over the past year it's less about retaining our bus drivers because of the job and and you're saying more of them have need to other reasons for leaving yes sir thank you uh Miss Barnhart thank you mam chair I guess in the discussion just kind of what I'm hearing it doesn't sound like our staff is saying this is
078necessary um and I know that because I've had extensive conversations about what we are doing with recruitment so we are recruiting we are paying for referral bonuses we are training up our aids to become drivers an opportunity with that I'll also add that the CDL lure it used to be one individual to approve the Tri County Area when that was brought up to the state level they now have two people to approve it I know it double um uh but these are these are tangible things that have been being done so I appreciate a conversation from four years ago but it sounds like the recruitment is there and I the one question I guess I have are we are we Turning Away people who are Act L pursuing to become a bus driver Mr Anderson
079at this time that's that I I think just speaks to as is saying we do have a good system in place we are actively pursuing to better the opportunities for our bus drivers to keep them here to retain them we've even recruited to our staff so those people who are coaches and who are secretaries have an opportunity to earn potentially time and a half as my understanding at some opportunities to drive buses if need be and so it's actively working we are recruiting we are doing a good job and so I'm just curious you know earlier this meeting we talked about listening to our staff and it sounds like this is not an issue that our staff is saying that we need to address because we're actively engaging our drivers that we have and the
080ones that we're going to continue to pursue and so I'm just confused why this is on the agenda oh miss Bradford I'm good uh Mr wi deor I'd like to revisit the topic discuss so and then Mr Perry and then miss justice so Mr Perry yeah so I think how I this is more of a question for Miss Justice um I mean I'm all for coming up with new ideas and I I got no problem good ideas are great and maybe we can do recruitment a little bit better on this and I think it's an important topic um do you how but do you figure that how long would you figure that this committee would how many times you think it needs to meet um before you can come up with some good ideas uh
081the does this need to be a committee I'm not against the idea creation but unless it's going to be a very big project and I a brainstorming session for ideas I don't think needs a whole committee um Miss Justice then miss Bradford then Dr okay we need bus drivers our community is almost they're just almost giving up and even dealing with this issue has been going on for years and just be because it's and it's not just because because it sounds good you've done everything within your power within the limit not limited everything that you can come up with under what we are looking at now that's the idea of the committee is to throw out that net and find more if you think that this isn't an issue drive around this city when schools
082get open and when they stop look at the cars WRA around the schools because parents aren't putting their kids on buses they don't want to walk I have to I drive my kid for an hour an hour excuse me I drive my kid twice a day actually I make him walk home these days because the weather you know being better uh but in the morning I definitely take him to the community bus stop I see kids walking up to a mile they have to um some of them small some of them big but the point is that all of this doesn't have to happen a lot of it has to do with the fact we just don't have enough drivers that's all there is to it there's no mystery and so to say that just
083because the staff is that is dealing with what they're dealing with now the best they can that there isn't a problem there is a huge problem I would um if I you know Mr Anderson go ahead I would say I agree with you the biggest the biggest impact additional drivers would have on our district is um elimination of all double backs M and we could expand our routes but I do not think you're going to have make any significant impact in the number of people that are taking their children to school and picking them up I I wish that were the case but I don't think it's going to improve that and that's a conversation we also need to have but that's that's a different topic than and I was going to save this to
084the next item but I looked up real quick um board ad hoc committees you'll find that in policy 2230 under C it talks about how as time and situations demand the chair May create ad hoc committees uh with the approval of the board and you can assign the board members and so on and it and it talks like Mr Mr Perry said um they'll all have a chair they'll take and and do minutes they'll have a clear Mission they'll determine the member link and they'll use the universal committee form that we created to recruit people into that commit so just saying I want a committee is a big deal when we created when we created the Safety Committee it took three months just to get a Safety Committee so we're about to talk about another
085ad hoc suggestion for cell phones and I was wondering if somehow can we finish the because I believe no but I'm I'm talking about these all these ad hocs can we not look we have an extra committee that we're all on and we're divided up into two two and three so could you y'all that want a committee could you look at that and say okay well building and grounds could you put school buses under building and grounds is that too much of a stretch and then miss Justice could be put on that committee and then she could you know work it in her committee you could swap you know her from the one she has to you know the next one so that these so that we don't have to create any new committees you
086just work with the Committees that we already have that would be my suggestion okay uh Dr Merck so well I'm going to beat a drum that you guys are going to get quite familiar with me beating and that's good governance now Mr Anderson I I I know you well enough to know that you're working your tail off to get this done but it is our job as a board to oversee what the district is doing and we have a responsibility to the public to take a look at what's going on in the district when there are problems and there is no no question that we have problems with our transportation I'm not saying that Mr Anderson is is is falling down on the job far from it but it is our responsibility to do everything
087we can and it's possible that ad hoc committee comes and says you know what we've looked at everything there's nothing more to be done that's possible but we owe it to the public to find that out and as far as putting it into safety I don't think that's appropriate that that those committees are specifically around safety they are not around on bus transportation so I am going to support Miss Justice's desire to create an ad hoc committee any further comments so we have that at 10 minutes Mr wior shared doc with me shared uh before about policy uh 51 20 uh paperwork shows at on 9 there was a meeting held Adam man Walker and myself were attending attendance the meeting and that it was pass U 70 um so been given that I also
088commend miss farum and miss Brinson on their hard work and uh I don't have any reservations anym thank you feel it could be put into policy all right thank you all right back to looking at ad hoc committee student cell phone use ad hoc committee Miss Justice how long did you um think that needed 10 10 minutes also and um it's obvious this is a huge issue it's been a huge is issue for almost decades now and we really do need to address this in in many many ways so a and I help Comm be very I actually have something that I was going to say um so looking back at um our the this is this has been addressed in one of our committees already um so last year I believe I don't have
089the exact date on this paperwork but um the Safety Committee that was focused on discipline um covered a whole large discussion about self phone use we also um spoke with principls about the the way that things are going and the vast majority of them said we have a plan we have a procedure um now that was in reference to policy but we have start we already have had some discussion on this um as far as the Safety Committee goes Miss Bradford did you want to add anything well and and I kind of remember we were building in grounds but we'd have to double check that because I don't remember but I remember talking about of building we have a committee so you just need to get on that committee and go to town um Mr
090McManus and I were on that committee we worked really really hard we brought a couple proposals to the board we got shot right out of the water I think it's a big issue I think we need to deal with it but we have a committee just get on that committee well I we don't need a new one M will deor I was going to reiterate and and say we also used our town hall time one of the topics onep Miss fart thank you madam chair I I guess when I'm looking at these I guess I just want Clarity it's not not anti- having the discussion of these things but what is what is the purpose is the purpose just to say that what what is the goal behind it is the goal to say we
091don't want cell phone use is the goal to say you know we want to hire x amount of bests drivers more like that for me when looking at this and justifying what is the purpose of the creation that's what I want to know we want to know the end in mind of what problem we're addressing and I don't believe that I have that information as a board member so not opposed to the conversation but I'm confused where we're trying to go with it and that is hard for me to be able to help the framework of the conversation and how we need to get there so miss Justice and that is the purpose of having it on the agenda so I can bring that at that point um as far as the cell phone use
092goes I love the fact that there's already a lot of information about it but this is a particularly contentious Topic in way with a lot of different stakeholders and that's why I think it needs to be moved possibly not possibly out just a Safety Committee and have a separate ad hoc committee um I've since I've been involved in this for over 20 years and I talk regularly I have kids myself I talk regularly to staff members and parents and so this this is not something that that that is easily solved and that's why a committee that would focus on this particular issue is so important and it's basically in schools question about that Dr Mar yeah while campaigning this is interestingly one of the the issues that showed up again and again parents are really
093concerned and rightfully so and again uh I'm not going to beat my drum it is our job as a board to oversee the district now one of the things I kept hearing was that we have policies but that not every principle followed them or there was very inconsistent following of the policy so maybe all the the committee would be doing is saying okay let's get clear about what the policy is and let's go back to Dr Barnes and say let's make sure this is being uh implemented appropriately and if that's the case then we're doing our job as over and answering our parents concerns Miss Bradford um two things um I would request that the staff would provide our new board members with the very extensive list of what every school's what their policies are
094for um for cell phones that's a good place to start um you could go back to the minutes of that but I am more than happy to give you my spot on on uh if Board of chair approval on on discipline so you can we can swap I'll swap you foresee and you can I did it and I didn't get anywhere and I still want to get somewhere so and um discipline is is is you know PE so y'all take it and run under the if the if if the chair says yes rather than form a whole new committee you you could start tomorrow you know you don't have to go through the board process because every time we form a new committee it takes a couple of months to get it to happen I've
095you know I've been on this rap reel before so this is the fastest way you get start looking at at at cell phones just swap you I'll swap you mental health for discipline I don't care um I want you to do it I'm just I exhausted myself on it and I got nowhere so I want someone else to take the ball and run with it Miss Justice I would prefer to stay on Mental Health I have a particularly personally strong reason for that uh as far as discipline goes um the committee Fe referring you please stay on that I I would like to minutes and notes from that I'd like to I mean this is the idea those things are sh yes we do talk about that next week when we talk about putting get
096together that's the whole point okay all right continuing on uh new han County Schools employee performance bonus plan committee um Mr Perry uh how long did you think that you would need for that um depending on questions I'd say 10 minutes 10 minutes okay um you you all have a proposal uh the modified proposal you've had slightly altered go run for longer than that so I I I believe that this is the work of this committee is is big enough where and extensive enough where it really needs an ad hoc committee dedicated to building it because developing standards of how to judge performance barely across all our different employees is going to take multiple meanings it's not something you're going to snap your fingers and get done and we need the import of our employees
097from all over the place so I if you have any questions please prepare them uh and ask me uh I'm willing to work I just like to get this going I think it's a great idea everybody that I've talked to um you know seems to think at least theoretically that it's a great idea uh and I know if we don't uh try to get this done if you know I can't guarantee success in the end but if we don't try we definitely won't succeed and uh and I think our employees are worth it m Bernhard and I just want to um commend Mr Perry this is very helpful in the process of the conversation that I'm that I'm looking for when we're talking about moving forward with the committee so thank you for your diligence
098I know you and I have had conversations and feedback and so I've seen some of the things that we've discussed and some of the changes you've made so I appreciate the um the background that you put into this Sur great uh Miss Bradford and I I agree um you're you you've brought us a big broad proposal you've narrowed it down and you given us goals and purpose and who the members would be and that gives me the ability to then consider voting on it but I did send you a question I think I send it on board and ask you to bring this to us how do you plan to measure this you know you're your your you know it's it's it's a great idea and I'm all for it but how do you plan
099to measure who's accomplishing exceeding expectations um in in a thank you and that's a very important question and I think a lot of this is is what the committee's work is is how to do that fairly uh and you know I think there are some things listed here uh in regarding the uh uh guiding principles and under uh guiding principles of the plan section D um it's you know it's going to differ for different types of employees but some one of the main things is focusing on student growth and that's not always applicable if you're talking about um other positions or a cafeteria worker but you know it may it may not apply to a uh but probably does on teachers but a lot of this is going to is is going to be the
100work of the committee to decide how to fairly judge this and this Justice um yes two things resources we're so strapped from in this District that's what I'm for too so um that's one question Andy the other one is also um the input from the teachers themselves as far as having a policy like this uh this has left off too much in just about everything and this is natural that has happened my experience in this county is we don't listen to the staff from the bottom up enough and what their concerns are so that somehow or the other I don't know if it's from now until next week but if staff have concerns about us having could you why don't if you could describe what exactly it is that you're proposing the staff should hear
101this I think that they they too of anybody needs to be able to put put into this because they're the ones in the classrooms they're the ones that affects and as a retired teacher myself and those up here um I I always would have question about performance bonus as opposed to collaboration which is always a challenge Mr Perry if you can answer that and then Dr so this um just a broadscope uh a summary this is a bonus plan for uh based up to a merit bonus plan for all of our employees at least all of our full-time FES that is the purpose of trying to implement this this is not in any way meant to replace any bit of their salary or wages this is an additional perk that our school system could offer
102that none of the other 114 school districts in the state offer which would give us a competitive advantage AG with the goal of recruiting developing and retaining the best quality employees uh you know our employees are the lifeblood of our school district and we need to reward them when they do an excellent job and go and exceed expectations as they often do and Dr mer I appreciate anything that we can do to honor our teachers our staff it's a big ask right because first of all you have to figure out how to measure then you have to figure out who's done it then you have to figure out how you going to fund it but I recognize that you ran on this this was a big item that you ran on when you were uh
103campaigning and you got elected so somewhere it tells me that there's something there that our that our voters and our parents want to see too it's a lot of work but I support your effort to do it thank uh Miss Barnhart Madam chair just for clarity if this if this committee passes and um next week's board meeting this would be a committee to research the idea not a fully approval of adoption and so again this follows the line of looking through the concept and if the concept is worth investing in not necessarily that we have the money in hand to do it however if this is something that the board wants to pursue and looking at then then after that input is gathered with this committee leading the charge after that input is gathered that
104would be where the board would help facilitate those conversations to pursue the sustainable funding for it okay me all right moving on call to audience um the timing of call to audience that was brought forward and I'm there's no document for either of those two so timing was the request of a board member to move call to audience to a later time in the agenda um how long do we think we need to discuss that I think that's a point of work Madam chair you set you're the chairwoman and you set the agenda so it was wherever you well I didn't know if the board would have strong or strong feelings and so if so then we need to add more time to that um Dr mer well she had her handle Miss Justice all
105right so this this was the first time I had heard that there was a concern as when I saw this come across you know um we did this in the past and this is what I'm confused about we we have tweaked that particular policy seems like every new board does it um and I'm just really concerned that we're doing it again and it was good the way we had worked at it so I'm it it just really bothers me that here we go again it's it and and one of the things that was very obvious during the last process is that if you move moved the call to the audience to the end which it had been for many years and that's why they brought it forward it makes it really hard for people to
106actually be able to participate so I'm confused why we're trying to stop more audience or more Community participation because to me whenever you do that move it back again it's obvious that you're try to me this is my personal experience and having gone through this multiple times is that you're that you're trying to make it harder for the community to have input into our into our decision- making and you do it at first one of the main reasons we did it at the beginning was because if we were making decisions we had a chance to listen to the public before we made decisions Mr wior and I can't say that I'm for or against uh this this decision but with all due respect to my colleague over here a lot of things have changed we
107Mr just you know my colleague you know as well as I do we used to have meetings that end at 11:30 12:00 at night our meetings now have to end at 9:00 so if it is a decision of the board to move it 800 to 9:00 would very evident to everyone when they need to be here wouldn't be like oh my goodness do I show up at 11:30 do I show up at 10:30 do I show up at 9:30 when do I show up I have no idea you know we we have uh in the last year or two years restructured our whole meeting so that we are done in 4 hours uh so that we can you know so it is a very clear time for that you for that group to be here
108so um you know I'm not again I'm not saying I'm in favor or against it I'm just saying that it is a different situation uh vastly than when you you and I were on the board before because you know I you know I I wasn't really excited to be here at 11:30 yeah yeah I think we have to ask ourselves what the purpose is we are not checking boxes here I have a motion that hopefully we'll get to eventually uh probably next board meeting around not voting on things that the public doesn't know about we publish an agenda and the reason we do that is so the public is part of the process if we have call to audience moved after the actions of the board it precludes them from being able to be part
109of the process and therefore they would have to be speaking to us about what's going to be happening the next month and of course they don't know about next month until 48 hours before so we have a real duty to our stakeholders we are a public board we answer answer to them and we need to honor their input so the question you ask is how much time I've got some real strong feelings about this so I think you know it probably be a longer time than a shorter one you m I'm just going to call that attention this is not the time to have the discussion about the timing of the call audience just how much time you think is needed for the discussion so I'm going to more than five minutes is my suggestion
110I'm going to delegate 10 minutes um um and with that same idea um a board member brought forward uh when there are multiple speakers of on the same topic grouping those um those comments that was asked to be discussed and I'm going to say Mr Perry go ahead uh under that same topic of grouping um I I would would like to bring an alternative measure in addition to what the proposed one was in regards to uh there there's no proposed well we were having a discussion about grouping so what I'm saying is so Mr Perry that that discussion is going to happen next week right so what all I'm saying right now is I have an alternative idea so I think it might take a little bit longer to okay get through this section than
111you were initially anticipating 10 minutes okay Bradford I would just point out but on that one it's written in our policy so it' be really great if everyone could read the policy before we have the discussion and I printed it out it's just a matter of where I put it um so if you're wondering which policy it is 2310 to look up all right uh summary of call to audience comments um Dr Merck how long do you think you'll need for that um speaking of a lot of documentation for a very very simple ask uh I I would say this is about a four minute deal all right I'm going to give it five just so you know to be look you you know give you a little extra minute there um okay correspondence five
112minutes announcements five minutes um close session and adjournment Miss Barnhart do you have the calculation for 205 so 3 hours and 25 minutes all right now um continuing on thank M chair yes M Bradford could we just quickly Mr brought it up we have changed so many things from the way they used to be and we have new board members and so they've not been with us through this twoyear journey of evolving these meetings and how we do things and the fact that we if we don't get to the last thing on the agenda and the bell rings then we go home and we don't deal with that so that's why we're checking the amount of time for everything because at that time limit the chairperson is going to say we're out of time do
113we want to extend the time so everyone speaking six times on every issue is going to put us back back here till 11:30 at night we made a policy that says we can't go past 9:00 without extending the time so it's done differently than it used to be and I just want everyone to get really excited about that because the staff has to stay here the public has to stay here we all have to stay here for hours and hours and hours and the whole point of having this meeting was to get some things done so that we didn't have to do it and stay here till 11:30 at night because our policy doesn't allow it any longer all right I will entertain a motion to go into close session pursuant to General statute 143
114d318 11 C for the following purposes to prevent the disclosure of information is privileged confidential pursuant to General statute 115 c-402 and not considered a public record with within the meaning of chapter 132 of General statutes to prevent the disclosure of Student Records rendered confidential under the family educational rights to consult with attorney in order to preserve attorney client privilege between the attorney and the board and to consider the qualifications competence performance character Fitness conditions of appointment or conditions of initial employment or an of an individual employed or considered for employment within the school system or to hear or investigate a complaint charge or grievance by or against any individual employee do I hear such motion second okay all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed that passes 70 we are now
115in closed session e e e I have jelly beam seeing as everybody's [Music] B all right we are back in Open Session um we have the Personnel report do I hear a motion to accept person second okay um all those in favor of approving the Personnel report signify by saying I I any opposed passes 7 to zero all right now on to the Google to Microsoft presentation oh do we do we need to make an adjustment to the agenda for Mr Worthington to go first or are we yeah we we need to make a motion all right so um he's you are restart yeah all right and I will second that any further discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed that passes Mr Worthy I once said that I
116was not going to allow my kids schedules to dictate mine and that's the biggest croc of nothing that I have ever said I'm now entering the stage where two kids and both are involved in practices and so I appreciate you guys accommodating and making a change for me this evening uh good afternoon uh Jared wory time the executive director of school support one of my jobs is to supervise uh principles and schools in our districts including uh Freeman and Snipes Academy Freeman and Snipes Academy are two schools that are listed as restart schools 7 years ago new han County Schools opted to allow Snipes and freemen to opt into uh a restart model this is part of North Carolina's reform model of schools uh the restart model simply allows those schools to have a little
117bit of flexibility that other schools don't in a couple of different ways one of those is primarily the budget and so I'm going to let U Miss Miss Sutton explain very briefly how their budget is a little bit different than the other schools in our in our district sure and it's really good timing so there was actually a budget amendment in your packet that will you'll approve um next week that talks about the transfer and so the flex budget flexibility that these schools have is that there's a state per pupil um dollar amount that we are required by state law to transfer to those two schools into a different pot of money so based on their student enrollment um and once it's in that pot of money they have flexibility being the principal to use
118that money however they want to so we of course work with them and we say you know these are our local funding formulas So based on this formula you would get this many teachers you know this uh media specialist so forth so forth but they get to decide if they would choose to use that money differently um and they and they're able to do that so that's the flexibility um and then um they're not locked down into specific categories how the state locks us down in our other funding sources so and let me know if you have any questions on that thank you Miss Sutton it's it it's really just comes down to these two schools have a little bit more flexibilities and how principles make determinations within their buildings on their campuses uh the
119other primary flexibility that we use for restart is calendar flexibility these two schools have the ability to open a little bit earlier during the calendar year uh and they can extend some of their inter session time so that they have breaks for teachers to attend PD uh breaks to allow for certain things to happen on their campus uh right now Freeman as an example has a communities and schools program where they are offering a plethora of really cool opportunities for families to come on campus to learn things uh for kids to be on campus after school uh so this is a program that we have requirements to meet with the state uh in the fall the state met with myself and the principles of both Freeman and Snipes uh and stated that we were eligible
120to ask for five more years uh we have asked for those five more years from the state the state said yes the next step would be uh that you approve us to receive authorization to operate as a restart School uh at both Freeman and Snipes for five more years uh there is uh the only condition is really that they have to stay in it for 5 years they being the state we can opt out if we decide to at any point by uh riding to the North Carolina State Board of Education and receiving uh the exit for it so that information is going to be provided to you in consensus next week and you'll have an opportunity to vote on it uh again it's a it's a really simple program that just allows us to
121have a little bit more flexibility in two of our uh higher priority schools I'll stop there and if you have any questions happy to answer Dr May how are Freeman and Snipes specifically chosen um if we look at overall performance they might not be the same and there might be other schools that you know Snipes might be doing better than some other schools what what's the rationale for those two schools sure so original label for any reinform model which restart is one of uh comes with a stipulation that a school will be continuously low performing at the beginning and at that point any school in any District can apply uh these two schools have applied for it uh then and for the record originally it was a 5year term but because of Co they extended
122it two years so they receiv received seven years uh so that's why they it it's coming up now so technically any school that's labeled as continuously low performing could opt into and receive restart status uh we usually would leave that up to the the current School administration to make that call we have actually hit our five minute Mark um for this M Bradford I would move that we take some of the things under information a e and f and move them to another meeting um but we're also going to have to extend time we've hit our time for this meeting second moving goes to an Alterna Mr w war a the Google to Microsoft e update on foreign languages F open meeting law and if anybody else that's presenting for information isn't here by any
123chance then we could add that one but I don't want to ask somebody that's come to to meet with us to to not get to do that today um but we we obviously we need to do B Miss Justice well we've already got the staff here and I was unable to attend the earlier meeting uh for our personal ucation on what was going on with our our introduction to um the Microsoft program and it might be even better chance for you guys to be able to get immediate feedback what I'm saying is I don't think we should put a off I really don't I would like to go ahead and discuss it now okay any further discussion chair did I make that in the form of a motion I did didn't I okay thank you
124okay am her a motion um what was that so I was amending her a motion you're wanting to make an amendment Amendment to the emotion the other I guess she was doing the and E put so you're making make a motion to amend amend her a motion I'll second it okay um do we have any further discussion so this is on the amendment yes are we done with Mr worington yes there's no action necessary no not at all it'll be in consensus next week than you're looking good today too it alwayss you came today a good day for guys dressing up thank that's nice so the motion is an amendment to miss Bradford's and that is to keep um a but to remove E and F for for today um all those in favor of
125the amendment uh signify by saying I I oppos no so that fails so the original um the original motion is to table a not table a is to postp postpone a e and f to the next meeting to the next meeting agenda meeting all those in favor signify by saying I I I think actually we should probably do this uh Mr recall the role Madam chair may I ask for clarification of which meeting you said next meeting so agenda the next agenda would be okay so that would be in February correct and then miss Mason no Miss barnhard yes Miss Bradford yes Miss Justice yes Dr Merrick Mr Perry yes and Mr wbore yes all right that passes so we will postpone our discussion of a e and f um moving forward the AI pilot
126presentation so good afternoon I think when we've mentioned the AI pilot program coming from the state you guys requested that um evid and the vendor come in and do a presentation for you so we have brought them here and they've brought um their partner Raptor also to be able to share with you um what the what they're proposing um for the pilot program I got the quick good so good afternoon uh pleasure to be here and speaking to you all this afternoon uh in regards to the uh artificial intelligence pilot program my name is Bob Johnson I'm a Solutions engineer with raptor Technologies I've been with raptor uh 6 and A2 years and actually installed Raptor in 2007 at a school district outside of Chicago where I live and work um and again pleasure to
127be talking to you today I'll hand it over to Mark hi Mark Stevenson with raptor Technologies happy to be here today hello Mia bud I am the Strategic partnership manager for Evan and I'm from Greensboro North Carolina hello thanks for having me today I'm Hall I'm the head of uh Big Data Ai and Edge deployments for evid and USA and I'm going to be the one presenting to you first today so um I think with that we'll just go ahead and get started um can we go to got right here all right so we're going to skip over this real quick we we made some quick adjustments because of timing uh before we send it over but I don't think the uh agenda got uh set up right so but we are going to go
128on an introduction we'll do a quick you know what the AI technology is we're trying to deploy uh we're going to talk about our partner Raptor and how it's going to integrate into the solution as well and then we'll wrap that up with kind of a general project plan how it should run so we're from EV and USA which is a subsidiary of atos there's a lot of small companies that we have bought in a conglomerate but we work mainly out of the USA um I came from a small company that was acquired so does a lot of companies that were within that the technology that's being developed is developed around the world in the US in Europe in Canada um we have sites all over the places where it's deployment all over the world
129so we've been doing this for roughly 25 years um we've been partners with the Olympics for since like 1982 and have been providing cyber security and video security surveillance systems for for them um we're in lots of universities we're in lots of airports Railways train stations government facilities anywhere that requires very secure systems where they need to constantly monitor their cameras and AI systems these are just a few of the references that we have so uh recently we started deploying to JFK Airport uh here in the US um we're setting up camera systems uh there we're also in the baps uh Temple system they have over 600 cameras there that we've been deploying our VI Suite uh system to but we're also again in universities all over the world um depending on where you look
130you know we're probably there if you go through an airport we're proba probably there um we have a lot of a lot of places all right my part my favor part the technology so I I don't know how many of you are familiar with uh video artificial intelligence but it's been used since like the 1950s and one form or another you've seen them on you know cam cameras going down the freeway for traffic cams um lots of different systems recently the technology has really improved um video a AI systems with new neural network Works can now identify objects and things as you go through so what happens is this is a subset well this is a subset of a lot of AI you've probably heard of like chat GPT right so that's llms and that's
131a different subset of AI as where as well as the gener of AI that creates pictures and images so that that the students can use in school um this is called computer vision AI which is it's a neural network training of objects so computers can recognize what it's looking at from a video image will you repeat that please yes please computer computer what the computer vision mition again I wanted to oh yeah so so so the computer vision AI is a it's a training of objects so a computer can identify them from a video platform so I always like it akin to when if you have a four-year-old and you teach them what an orange looks like you're like this is an orange and if that's and and you show them an orange for the
132longest time you look up you'll show them an apple that well that's an orange like no that's an apple or apple so you show them another orange this is an orange that's an Apple so this is an orange finally after showing them you know lots of different versions of that orange like this is an orange and they know what that one orange is they may not know what all the other fruits are but when they see an orange they're like that's an orange so that's basically what we're training the computer to do is we pre-train it we show it thousands and thousands and thousands of pictures and then it knows that when it sees an orange that's an orange uh and all this occurs in the lab so this is just one occurrence so one
133of the use cases that we have is for like slip and fall detection so we teach it to understand what a person looks like and we teach it what it means when a person falls so you have like a plane uh that you walk on which is the floor and we teach the AI that when the person is standing upright that's that's that's correct and then as it person falls we teach it to understand when a person is going down and they're laying on a floor so this is great in situations where maybe you have medical emergencies someone's after school and they fall down and they can't get up and no one's seeing them uh someone gets injured on the playground or situations um but the way that we train this is we put thousands
134and millions of images into this to try to identify when this event happens and then we put rules around it to try to determine if it's true or false if it actually happens so if someone just Falls and then quickly gets back up and they don't stay down then we can determine that's not an actual fall or nothing's done so we just ignore that situation so a lot of the use cases that we've set up that you guys have requested um are for you know slip and fall fire detection smoke detection um Mass crowd movement which is so let's say you're in a cafeteria and all of a sudden everybody runs to the right side of the cafeteria it understands that behavioral analysis of a lot of people moving um also weapon detection so uh
135like anything it's a weapon's an object it's any object so a weapon is just an object we've trained on millions of weapons so if it sees that weapon it's going to say hey I saw a weapon it's going to put a little box around it and it's going to send an alert out to the Raptor system system this alert then gets sent to somebody in you know somebody that can respond to either a 911 call or uh in the middle person that can say yes that's really a weapon it's not a false alert and they can push a button and move on so the reason we do this is because in the ma majority of systems most cameras are put in as a uh a reactive type process it's like something happened so we're going
136to go back to the camera system and see what happens so we can try to fix in the future we're try you never hire enough people to sit there and watch the cameras um after like 35 seconds the the amount of information that the human will will ingest is it gets lower it drops by like 75% and after 40 minutes that's even less than that as far as watching just one camera on a screen so when you have 100 cameras or a th000 cameras or 15,000 cameras the more you get the worse it gets because there's so much information it's impossible to watch it not only is it impossible to watch it this 8 to5 but you know if you have to watch it 24/7 it's really really hard to do so we inject AI
137into this because the AI can watch the camera every single day in real time and be able to alert on these events when they happen uh this system complies with all of all the current security uh policies it complies with furpa P all pii is stored locally our system is deployed on premise so every school gets its own Edge server all the data stays inside the school on the edge server it never goes outside of the school uh we don't actually store any information it's processed in real time so instead of uh we get a stream from the camera it's called an rtsp stream it looks at that image a couple seconds of that image it analyzes it it decides whether or not an alert needs to get sent out and then it deletes that
138that that footage all the all the video footage that you still have is going to still exist on your existing camera systems just not in the as AI system this is just an intermediary to tell you if something happened and should we on it um so no pii stored in that information we're not show doing any like facial tracking inside of that information we're not doing any uh you know collecting of information it's only collecting something about an event so if it sees somebody fall it's going to say I saw somebody fall on this camera and then we're going to send an alert to whoever we're supposed to send that alert to all right uh this kind of goes into some of the school use cases that you can so depending on the schools and
139the orientation uh that you have there there's a lot of different use cases that you can do so similar to like outside you can have perimeter detection outside in front of the school around crosswalks around uh you know Bus Parking you can have uh detection in schools as far as hallways you can do slip and fall smoke detection weapon detection at staff entrances you can be looking just for adults walking into the building um you know all the perimeter around the playground fences you can set up perimeter detection so if somebody walks into a perimeter that's not supposed to if maybe they jump a fence it'll notify that someone jumped a fence either coming in or out so you can say hey some kid climbed the fence in the back and is trying to play
140hookie for the day or someone came into the school it's not supposed to uh you'll be able to identify those perimeter detections in real time and it'll send a response and somebody can respond to that I'm trying to keep this short in the matter of time so um and what this does is it creates live alarm so instead of being react reactive or being proactive as soon as we see it we send an alarm and we notify a team whether it's EMS police uh local response team at the school school nurse whatever uh we're able to give them that alarm and have them respond to it and then we can generate reports off of this how many alarms per week are doing are we picking up a lot of good you know positives are we
141keeping any false negatives um and how many of these events are occurring from school to school so maybe we have a lot of perimeter intrusions at one school and we need more cameras or we don't have any in another and you know everything's good we're we're able to report off those and create nice dashboard for you that way like I said uh the things that we want to track for you guys right now uh are threat detection the smoke and fire obviously slip and fall intrusion detection crowd and I think we went over this loitering loitering is kind of an extension of the perimeter or the the perimeter inection it basically tells you if someone's in an area they're not supposed to be um um I always I always use it Ain to you know
142if someone goes into a hallway where there's not a camera and they're trying to smoke in the hallway or doing something they're not supposed to you can say this person went into the hallway for 5 minutes they've been there and they never exited it maybe someone fell in there maybe they're doing something they're not supposed to be maybe someone should go check on them because that hallway has never been they're not supposed to be just standing in that hallway in between classes or hiding out okay so and then all these alerts that go into uh a notification system called Raptor raptor is a close partner with ours they've been working with schools around the nation they're in thousands of schools um they do everything from notification to uh drill managers to a lot of a
143lot of other things that's not not included in this I'm going to hand this over to Bob right now and let him talk about Raptor thank you so Raptor uh our involvement with uh this project is affording you not only um the notification element of what signal gets sent from Evan uh to Raptor but also the complete Raptor Emergency Management and Suite of products um raptor is a Houston based company um we are only in K12 schools that is our sole purpose we work with uh no other customers other than K12 schools um we're in well over 40,000 schools across the country and over 7600 school districts um we partner with again with many uh Safety and Security platforms like Evan rapid SOS for 911 Integrations as well as the I love you guys which
144is a Foundation uh that helps uh schools and uh districts handle emergencies their standard response protocol their standard reunification method so again uh the partnership with raptor uh and eviden is that when there is a signal in eviden uh evident for the cameras detecting a situation as what was described on that earlier slide that will trigger a notification workflow in Raptor to trigger notifications out to uh the parents princip the assistant principal the nurse or a building-wide emergency again depending on the configuration uh with your Safety and Security team now Raptor alert is the platform for making those notifications Raptor alert is a device agnostic so no matter what device a school uh sta school you know is staff member is on Chromebooks laptops Etc they can receive notifications um as well as issue notifications
145out outside of the uh detection from the evidence system right um uh and again we have a broad um uh scope of other partners that we work with so not only will a trigger from eviden uh trigger an alert in Raptor it will also then allow 911 to be notified through our partnership with rapid SOS as well as again even notifications out to uh your local fire police and EMS now once that uh emergency has been triggered that will then begin the process of what's called accountability now these are all parts of the Raptor Emergency Management platform so again um the Raptor alert we're talking about accountability the next phase of that emergency where you need to account for people with that are within the building real time updates on where your staff are where
146where the students are um First Responders will also have access to this information again real time dashboards to know are there any injuries in the building who is injured where they are that next phase of the emergency is called reunification so heaven forbid there is an emergency that requires um your students to be moved to an off-site location this is where Raptor reunification comes into play so again working with your uh Safety and Security team establishing that off-site location now the communication from your Comm Communications team can go out to the parents and the Guardians of where they need to pick up their students and they will file follow a preset process with uh the I love you guys and the standard reunification method for accounting for those uh parents that have arrived at the
147reunification site and only authorized uh parents and Guardians will be able to pick up those students part of the reunification once that reunification has been made all the other Guardians will receive a notification letting them know that the parent has picked up that student and then finally Raptor drill manager Again part of the Raptor Emergency Management Suite which is part of this pilot for your schools the ability for you to practice these emergency preparedness drills right um this builds muscle memory it follows everybody through the process of what happens when an alert is made so again whether it's a uh detection by the evidence system for uh someone that fell in the parking lot that needs medical assistance which is what we would consider a lower level situation notifying certain people or if there is
148a weapon detection then notifying the entire building to follow your preset protocols for that type of an emergency with that I think we're towards the end going back to experience yeah one more quick so just as far as wrapping up the project uh to do this the way that we would deliver this is we' choose we'd like to choose at least three schools within the district usually an elementary a middle school and a high school uh usually district has its own needs and concerns and every district is kind of unique as far as what's important as far as uh what type of security they need and what what what's happening in those District especially from each one of the schools so uh we choose each one of those so we can come up with the
149correct procedures and the correct events and places that want to be monitored and alerted on and then we start to roll that across the rest of the schools so we'll work with uh School administrators we'll work with that your security teams will work with uh you know you know your project managers whoever is in that process to Define which schools are next and how fast we can roll this out across the schools to minimize any disruption uh to anything going on so um after that it just goes into uh kind of a support mode everything's set up everything's configured um the hardware is you know under warranty for 3 years it's 24/7 support uh the software is licensed for two years for both the Raptor and uh the vi Suite so it provides you just
150a whole unified package and support for the two years of the pilot uh and with that I guess any thank you for listening to our quick presentation any questions um so we've gone a little over on our time so I am going to make a motion to extend our discussion of this because I know we have a lot of questions by 10 minutes all right um all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed right that passes so we now have 10 extra minutes to ask questions and I know that there are a lot uh Mr wemore um well and just to be totally transparent I receiv phone call from davidon County U and chat with the count from up there um and I guess May the question not necessarily for you but
151for for our team here um we do have to select the same one as or how that whoever choose first oh I'm sorry I think I may need to speak to B Dr yeah I sorry I emailed you guys today and I you may guys not have all caught up to with the Davidson County Superintendent yesterday um their camera um uh pilot got all the way to their consent agenda it did get pulled off of their consent agenda and they're back in some of the same discussion phase So currently it is not approved in Davidson County at this moment in time thank um question system only alerts when a weapon is brain so I know that Mr Anderson went and looked at another one that actually would somehow protect a weapon that was not branded
152but it is corrected that the D would have to be a weapon would have to be out it it it doesn't have to be out it can be it just has to be in visual range right so if the weapon is under a jacket or in a backpack it's not going to detect that because it's a visual it's a visual tool for detecting that so if it sees it if it sees it out if it sees a partial partial Port of a weapon out if it's you know part of a weapon coming out of the back of a coat it has the possibility of detecting that yes and I hate to ask this question but I think it was very important to ask uh is this the same system that was used in Davidson County
153Kentucky whether was last no it's not okay um and that's the end of my questions thank Dr mer first of all thank you for the presentation and for for all we're glad to be here um you'd mentioned earlier that there was no uh identification of individuals and yet many of your slides do mention facial recognition yes so of course and this is less for you and more for us uh I'm very concerned about uh profiling and individuals uh faces and and and privacy matters I think there's a lot of concern about that um so that's something for us to talk about so and I can answer that a little bit there's there's different types of Technology when it comes to facial recognition and the amount of power it would take to do profiling and identifying
154anything isn't built in the system and this isn't that type of Technology anyway the way this technology works like what this would do is that you would collect a database say a database of sex offenders in the district if you have you know your tier one sex offenders they can be loaded into it and it would learn just those faces but that's all it knows and then it's doing a matching based algorithm once it learns those faces and says yes I see this and then all it does is say I saw I think I saw this person and then it puts it down it doesn't know if if you've never been loaded in the system it doesn't know who you are you're just a couple of pixels and it says I don't find a match
155and all it's trying to do is do that matching so it does not recognize students no um the next question sorry really quick is with all of these systems there's got to be a false positive and false negative rate what do you got for us that's that's really hard to answer because it's very variable it varies from camera to camera it varies because cameras have different specs to them it depends on how far away it is it depends on the resolution the camera and it depends on the lighting in the building so it varies great greatly um our solution to that to help that is we have a very intricate rule-based system in in a system to help identify that so we can we can look at something and identify something and then we can
156add other rules on top of it so we can say in the instances like if somebody uh you know crosses a perimeter but they only stay there for 5 seconds and they're not there and they leave that perimeter we can say don't alert on that um that way you're not getting you know false false things or if you see something comes in and it doesn't look like a person in the perimeter maybe it's just a dog uh it won't alert on that so we can say only alert on people that inside the perimeter and the same goes for all the rules in that so it's a it's a nice and then it's a drag and drop rules based engine where you pull little boxes and you say do this do this do this and if
157this then alert then what happens is it gets sent to the Raptor system and they can look up the actual system so in the event of like a weapon you may want to just alert on everything and false alerts are good sometimes because what we do is the false alerts we can go back and we we can request those false images and we can train those back into the system to make the system even better the more false alerts you can get the better the system can get if you never get false alerts you never know what to train off of and until what it's not doing right so what we're trying to do is we're trying to make it better by doing that but it doesn't yeah we use that rules based engine to
158try to eliminate that as much as possible Miss Justice did you have any questions no I'm I'm enjoying their qu not enjoying but they're asking good questions so I'm just leading to them so I would just like to say um in the past we've had some situations at various schools and the reunification component of this I think is fantastic um that it notifies parents it notifies Guardians and you have to have a signature capture and a date and time stamp that added that adds that safety component to it and so I I just wanted to comment that that reunification would be extremely helpful um in situations like we've had in the past so miss barnhard did you have thank you I I think one of my colleagues is going to speak to some of the
159security safety of storing information and stuff because I think that's important not only to us but just to our individuals listening one of the things you kind of touched on is that Raptor you guys are partners with the I love you guys and this is one of the standard protocols we use when we're in either a secure or hold lockdown so this is already an organization that our community is familiar with and has been well received to be very honest rather than just saying your child's in lockdown to know that your child's insecure because of an issue going on outside of their school is kind of heart palpitations for a parent to say I appreciate that communication because that's the worst thing is when a parent hears from social media that something might be happening
160at your school and they then this calls start coming in the texts start coming in so to be able to have a good form of communication so this guy can help do his job better to say this is what's going on this is how we're proceeding and going forth so I just wanted to point that out because I think it's important to know that we do have familiar with you guys um and I I wrote it down and I asked you to repeat it computer vision AI because artificial intelligence sounds like a scary thing and I have to break it down to understand for what's actually happening because there's a learning technology where you're teaching it to do something with the information you're given versus an identification factor and what you are sharing and you
161are proposing for us to use is an identification Factor tool is that correct we're not teaching it to learn things and to do something with that it's very similar and with technology you already use dayto day right so it's uh if you have one of those uh Amazon you know doorbells or something like that that that usually does two things for you either says there's a person at my door there's a package at my door or I saw movement right so movement just means the frame change I my mind goes off when the lights change outside because say though something changed but if someone drops a package it'll say there's a package at the door so and that's all it knows it doesn't know anything else that's going on it's it's it's just trying to
162tell you when something actually happened and do it in real time versus you know you can go back and look oh yeah somebody came into my school like 14 hours ago but most schools don't have the staff to to watch their cameras and be able to identify that so we're trying to decrease that time uh you know that time to response and I and that's what I think I'm going with this is in the general statute it outlined a bunch of things that your company has the ability to do we had to look for companies that had the ability to do all of these things but here in our local level we have the flexibility to choose the things we want it to do and the things that you are advising or recommending that we
163have flexibility with are threat detection smoke and fire detection slip and fall detection intrusion detection crowd Panic detection and lering detection those are the sixs that you are proposing for us to consider yes ma'am just just want to verify thank you Miss Bradford did you have any questions yes um and just to clarify did I hear you say that this is the same AI as the ring doorbell technology it's it's not the same AI but it's the same type it's in the same category right it's a computer vision AI so we have our own we have our own data scientists we we have over 150 PhD data scientists that that create their own AI and their own things to do this so we have lots of smart people working on this problem trying to create
164the best system to do that um Amazon does their own Google does their own everyone has their own you know their their own flavor to this but this is our own system that we've developed I'm going to pause you right there for a second because we are coming up on we only have one minute left of this time so I will I want to make sure everybody has the opportunity to ask all the questions so I would like to make an make a motion to extend 10 more minutes second right all those in favor signify by saying I I any opposed passes 70 we know 10 more minutes okay go ahead I'll make it quick you had said I have see here license plate recognition and it was had a little arrow by the school
165bus so can you explain what that license plate recognition would be doing um if you decide to implement it and again that's that's an if it's it's part of the system but just like facial recognition which is part of the system you don't have to Implement that thing um for most of the schools you know when your RFP came out it said you were interested in these certain areas um so while it's capable of that you can have a camera out front and it can identify a license plate and it's the same as the facial recognition right so it's not tracking all the license plates that come through but it's going to look for specific ones that you that you want it to look for so you can put in certain license plates and say
166I know that this person you know is not supposed to be around the school and we know their license plate number so it can specifically look for them and tell you if that vehicle pulls up to the school same for buses if a bus pulls up to the school and you want to know that bus 36 has come up you know we can identify that and say hey this bus has come up because we see the license plate and we know this is this is associated with Bus 36 or it's you know left the building okay and you had said that the technology couldn't identify a weapon that was under your jacket or something like that only when it's coming out yes ma'am what's the time span between the coming out and the alarm Bells
167going off um I haven't seen seen in between it coming out it's milliseconds so from the instance so the instant it sees that it takes roughly like 01 milliseconds for it to do the actual analysis and then it kicks off a trigger to the Raptor system which is is super fast as well so talking one to two seconds we will receive the trigger and then that will send the notification to the people in the building administrators or your you decide who gets notified it's within couple thank you and and I do want to com on your license plate question uh there is no external data that's coming into the system so the system doesn't know any you know additional information like you can't identify this license plate number is to this person because it's not
168connected to any data source to tell you who that is unless you tell the system who that license plate belongs yeah so this is defined as an edge an edge based AI so all the processing is done at the school itself nothing goes to the cloud nothing goes anywhere else it's all at the school on that one system the only thing that's going out to raptor is I saw something that happened on this camera go tell somebody uh it doesn't get any more information than that God bless you yeah I I was just I was just daydreaming could it help our Carline situation we you can talk about that yeah there are solutions and ideas around improving that too so that that's always you know an option Mr Perry I'm trying to give a bunch
169of Rapid Fire questions here so let's start with kind of more the um companywide thing um this isn't about you Raptor Tech this is about avidon uh your parent company atas is in France uh I've read news reports that um that your parent company's in financial difficulty and may be seeking bankruptcy in under the French government uh if they go down H H how how secure are we going to know that you know you're going to be here next year no so so that's all been repaired so they did have some Financial issues in the past there are two divisions of atos which is our division which is evident was the big data and AI division which has always been profitable um and in the event that that happened like three years ago when they
170were really serious about that they were rolling us off into an entirely different company which is why we became evident um right now uh they've secured financing through the government uh uh to keep certain portions of it going and through private Equity so everything's stable they've also been lifted up I think they're back up to like a b credit rating yeah but a lot of it was from Legacy business that we had in the past uh that they've been cutting off and getting rid of so the company is stable now and moving forward uh at least for the next 10 years thank you uh next question uh you mentioned uh universities uh other airports I know this is a pilot in North Carolina but are there any other us school systems that are using the
171avidon product right now um university in the US not not really not in the US we have more around around the world but it's relatively new to the US most AI systems are new new to the US so this is just in general AI systems are new okay uh getting on the more Technical and I'm a it uh guy I'm not a I I do not claim to be an AI guy uh but I have been in software engineering for about the last 30 years so I know a little bit about what I'm talking about um the uh and one of the things that you know generally you know what's you're calling this Ai and generally with the as opposed to with just a nice algorithm um a a nice bit of programming with some
172nice features but most people at least I think that the difference between AI is that it learns and how can it learn without data you're telling us that there is no data how does it learn from Once you you said you taught it in the lab I guess but then how you know if there's a false positive you know how does it learn again or how does it learn uh if you're not collecting this data secondly if you're not collecting this data if you're not doing facial recognition not keeping biometric information on our students and our teachers how do you do intruder alert how do you know who's not supposed to be there if you don't know who is supposed to be okay so I I think there's a there's a couple questions in there
173that I'm going to try to answer um so AI so first around the AI and the training so the AI in general most training is called supervised training so you collect a lot of data and then you train that model on that data and then when it runs it's running in what's called an inference mode which is similar even your chat gpts and your other systems are learning in what's called an inference mode so what happens is after you've trained it to know how to do a lot of things you can ask it things and it knows everything that it's learned how to do um when it first came out you could ask chat GPT know tell me you know if if you ask it tell me what the weather is and Bo you'd say
174I don't know because my data is from two years ago so it learned how to you know it can tell you things about history and what had happened and everything that's going on but it never learned uh how to look up what current data is because it had no idea how to do that uh newer Technologies around that allow it to build algorithms to do that so it's starting to learn how to do that so there is some learning in there that allows it to know how to build build code so it could call an API which is a a programming thing to go pull information from like a weather database so that that's that's how those systems learn in Vision systems there are some systems that can do that there is like real-time learning
175systems but this is just a subset this is this is a pre-trained model for object detection so yes it doesn't know exactly who is and who is not supposed to be here unless you're going to go through and give it a picture of everybody in everybody in the school uh but it does know that uh from the hours of 5 to you know 10:00 that no one should be climbing the of the school right or no one should be entering this room into the uh the boiler room or somewhere else in the school it knows those things right um the same thing with weapons it knows that you're not supposed to have a weapon so if you pull out a gun in school that's not supposed to be there so it's going to detect that
176and send that um we're not collecting biometric data because I mean by law you know parents don't want you know their children being tracked they don't want that biometric we have to comply with HIPPA laws we have to comply with pii laws and we have to comply with furpa so this system was designed to not track that biometric it because it it's not supposed to be I did see a a a a video uh this is uh on your YouTube site which kind of gave a little bit of a demo or I don't know if it's a demo or what you want to call it and it says you know it showing these neat little pictures where student positive the identified you know possible Intruder you know again how do you know that that's the
177positive student unless it has some idea of what that looks like um the finally but I know that we're running out of time uh and also it's just to follow up on that it says you're powered by Azure uh when you go online we talk about you but then you're saying everything's going to be local okay uh but um so but you can answer that question next the more the more the last thing is is just the uh you know do we have any Effectiveness rates on there do we know how many of these shooting incidents are coming from brandish weapons versus unbranded weapons apparently there was an incident in Nashville Tennessee last week where a kid brought a school concealed in his jacket into the cafeteria went right by the AI system and he
178shot somebody in the cafeteria so okay so and response to your question sir um so first off is you know how do we know it's a person you can see a student well in those videos those Stu those students were trained so it knows how to identify those students right so it knows they're in the database and this is who we're trying to identify so we're showing that capability um as far as the Azure there were two programs that we were running one was a program with Microsoft through Azure called Vis uh it was a program but it was very it was cloud-based and that was not well well recepted because it was cloud-based um it was also subsidized by Microsoft at one point but that's been deprecated because um we found that the the
179technology is improved enough that we can pull it to the edges in schools and we can conserve the data a lot better plus it becomes a lot more effective this way uh and cost effective this way thank you um and oh we've got so we are at our our time I we have a question from board member who didn't get an opportunity we have a question from the superintendant and we have a question from Eddie um Mr Anderson so um I would like to make a motion to extend for five more minutes second second all right all those in favor signify by saying I I I opposed passes 7 to Zer so um I'm going to go board member and then so miss Justice oh yes how long is the state home for this um
180program so they they've allocated funding for the first two years of the program so through if we started this year it' be through what is it 256 like early 27 so it depends on when we start but we've the RFP that we gave back to the district was for 2 years 24 months and how much would we have to be paying after the program the states through paying for it estimate roughly cost about 20% for licensing and support after that and that's just for the licensing and support of the software the hardware is all up front so all the hardware is purchased up front so you own the hardware um the licensing and software is all purchased up front except for Raptors the SAS product so they're constantly updating so they they have a year
181to year but that's in the first two years and then support of the V VI Su which is the AI stuff is roughly 20% roughly 20% of the licensing just because there's we're retraining models constantly we're improving the system we're giving you updates you're getting new versions you're getting support so you have all that support that's build around but how much would we be paying an estimate sorry I couldn't hear you so how much would oh sorry that's right I'm sorry how much would we be paying I mean I just heard all of that I I think it comes into like 300 to 400k a year oh really okay and does it have to have a Microsoft system in place in The District in order to operate no okay um Mr Anderson yeah not not
182really a question I just had a couple of comments I mean first of all recognize there is not one single system that will solve the safety issues in schools Across America or anywhere else in the world so in terms of weapons detection what I like about this system is that if someone gets out of their car and pulls a weapon out of the trunk I know about it as as a principal and put that school in lock down before he gets halfway across the parking lot now if they have a handgun inside a jacket and they walk into the building this system may not detect that until the weapon is brandished but then we have other weapons detection systems all of these things have to work together and there it's even working together it's not
183a guarantee it is you know the most important thing in all of this ultimately boils down to people their awareness their situational awareness our training and all of us and all of these systems working together um as far as the the facial recognition I want to clarify something there if I pulled up a camera in a school and I click on a person student staff visitor it doesn't know anything because it's not connected to anything however I really would like the ability if I have a person that violently attacked a staff member I would love the ability to put that person's picture into the system and it alert me when they show up on campus so that I can lock those doors before they ever get in and it it does have that ability it
184only has the ability to recognize someone if you give them give the the system you know their picture and I think that's I think that's a really um you know very very proactive thing that I can do to help protect my building if I'm the school principle okay Dr BS just a real quick first for you folks this is not a question of your of the ability of the program or anything else our board is wrestling with the legal the ethical and the safety issues that that all these things bring around together so obviously safety is a critical issue for all of us we are trying to build a multi-layered system of support that addresses behavior and addresses violence on lots of different fronts um couple of things that you had said I think Eddie
185you mentioned about the ability to make our Administration more proactive rather than reactive which is sec in a place where seconds count but I also wanted to ask you guys the features that you know there's a sort of a la list of features you can turn on and off we can turn off features and then lock those right so they can't be so that there's a district designation of someone who may have 100% so we are able to sort of control some that's even been requested in the past right so if they don't want certain features we'll just give you the licensing for certain features so it only unlocks those certain features and then the rest of it you know if you if you ever want in the future you just have to request a
186new licensing bundle so it does that and that's that that's you know once you've have a a package that's free to do that you can push it down or up as much as you want thank so we've hit our time again we've hit our time again okay so um thank you so much well thank you for having us great meeting you um is there a way if there are any further questions that we have is there a way to contact you yeah I I will leave my card um I'm Raptor will as well and then you can uh if you want to collect that information just have one person send it it's easier for us to do it because a lot of times if a lot of people not new emails our email system they
187get missed or they get filtered out into the spam so I want to make sure that we get get all the questions you would like to send your questions to Eddie Mr Anderson he will I'd be happy to work with anyone and get all those questions answered for you thank you so much no thank you very much all right uh continuing on in the agenda service and and or therapy dogs Dr Barnes I can beat your 15 minutes uh I can name this song in three notes I want to make a real clear distinction that there is a significant difference between a service animal and a therapy animal or a comfort animal I want to make sure it's clear that we follow the ADA accommodations in regards to service animals that's federal law I do
188know that there was questions about having therapy dogs in schools a few years ago I have reached out to those people and set up a time to meet sit with them and some of my staff to talk about some of the legalities of having that as available I just wanted to make sure I cleared up that there is a difference between therapy animals and Service Dogs uh there are some legal and insurance things that need to be worked out but I have reached out to those people and offered to have a chance to talk with them M chair yes M for clarification Dr Barn you're talking about service animal programs in our schools correct no individual students who require or staff who require service animals as a part of their with Disability Act are that
189federal law and those are allowed and we have specific criteria for those but you're talking about getting us information on bringing service animal programs into this therapy therapy thank you right any other questions look at that to the last item on the agenda committee assignments uh Miss Bradford since you added that um why don't you go ahead uh there was no time allotted to this but as of right now we have 10 minutes left of this meeting okay um just to let you know the reason I left the room I was having allergic reaction it's my second one tonight um so I have to deal with that um and I was over there listening so my cognitive is not real good right now but I was extremely frustrated to go 58 days without committee assignments
190I'm still frustrated with the committee assignments um I asked to be on committees I invested in them last year I wanted to continue the work I was doing um the process was uh flawed and I hope that we never repeat it again um I I I can appreciate the complexity of the situation but it did not seem to be as Fair as I would have appreciated um and it and it had a lot of bumps in it and I feel like we need to talk about it because it was on social media it was on uh uh platforms it was in the media itself and we didn't have any conversation if I chose not to engage in social media then I had no dialogue if I chose not to speak to the media then I
191had no dialogue and I felt that was extremely unfair um and there's just been a lot of confusion and a lot of swirling um and and I would like uh because Mr wildor was our chair for the last two years I'd love to hear him address how we did it last year and how we did it the year before because maybe my memory is defective but I remember how it went and so I'd like to clear that up and I'd like to clear up I mean just this to yesterday I got a new committee assignment and um and while that that's lovely I was taking off a one and added to another it's it's it's not a lot of fun when it's happening to you so I'm just going to quit with that in the
192sake of time but it's been very upsetting for me um we're 58 days into this cycle there's only 12 months in every year and so we've missed a lot of time where we could have been working um in these committees and getting things done thank you so I'm going to speak to this um as I have the authority to do um we've lost Focus the fact that we are focusing on committee assignments instead of on students and teachers and the things that we need to do is a little disturbing to me from the start I communicated with this board um there was a comment made earlier that was stated that I did not communicate well with this board I communicated with this board from the beginning um I expressed that my goal goal and intention
193for each board member was to be in at least one committee that they were passionate about and at least one committee that would stretch them that was my goal I informed the entire board before I asked for anything and then we I moved from there I attempted to send out a committee assignment request but with the change to Microsoft it didn't work but I still compiled everybody's requests and I sat down and I looked through every single one and I made sure to put every person on at least one committee that they were passionate about and at least one committee that they either were was going to stretch them or that they had never experienced before that was my goal I stated it from the start I have since communicated along the way with every
194single board member whether through email text message or via phone call to get feed back from each of you because this is a collaborative process I feel that the changes I made reflect that feedback I have sent emails to every single individual or talked to every single individual that has changed so I did send an email to my colleague on the right uh prior to handing the committee assignments out so that is absolutely FAL um and honestly like I said I think we've lost Focus I think we've lost Focus we want to talk about past procedure respectfully I am not Mr wildbore so I am going to do things differently and there were there have been changes in previous years that have occurred maybe not as many but there have been changes in previous years
195that have occurred um and I do have the doents from the past two years so there have been changes so this is not brand new this is something that is a has always been a work in progress and continues to be a work in progress the collaboration of the board because it is not just me was absolutely imperative and I wanted to be sure that all of the voices all of the voices were heard before I made final decisions the main focus and the main people that person that got moved the most was myself I moved myself so that I did not inconvenience any other member of this board and that was my task to do I took that and um I really truly do not appreciate the demonstration of a lack of respect for
196my Integrity um and I am I am pretty disappointed that that this continues to be an issue when we have so many other more important things to discuss Dr Merrick first of all I want to commend you because I think that the the requests that you made of us to to describe what we would like and what we could use uh was novel I think it reflects your desire to work across the board all of us together as a committee and it was one thing that made me feel that we're all working together so I want to commend you on that and I also want to uh second in a sense what you've said this is petty we need to be working on our kids we need to be working on our schools we need
197to be working on our budgets and our funding and if you don't like the way Miss Mason has done it let's elect someone next year thank you Miss Justice having been in previous boards as I said previously it's changed every time I was on one board where the chair probably changed it a dozen times within three days um and it's in policy and she has that right I do appreciate the fact that she looked at all of our interests and all of our strengths and all of our desires to maybe go into another Direction and she did it fairly I do not appreciate the political behavior that has happened around this I said for two years when I came up to the call to the audience constantly the biggest problem with this board was the
198political influences that were distracting us from our schools and our kids and this is another example of it let us move on work together as a team do what we can do with our strengths The Madam chair did put us in the right positions I think and it's already working as far as I can see so let us please just go forward positively and stop being political Please Mr Perry I I first want to say that I think you as far as your uh Communications I think you did communicate uh what what how you were going to approach as far as what you were looking for and what criteria you you were using to to play place people on the committies I don't think that's any in any doubt in my mind I as far
199as uh the only part of communication uh that I think that you uh failed to communicate properly was was that the list that you gave us at the January 7th meeting uh has since been described as a draft when it was not labeled as a draft or a proposal um and there's a there's a difference between a list that is sub change and a draft I ended up making a Facebook post thanking you for your confidence in me in making me the chair of the policy committee uh you changed your mind on that and that is your prerogative uh but had I known it was a draft I certainly would have made that post so uh I just think it's important to acknowledge that sometimes we get it wrong not because you intended any evil
200we all fall short so that's all I'm saying uh we have one minute left Miss Barnhart um I just want to say I understand the passion and I want to remind us of the board ethics having this discussion in my mind is actually nothing what my colleagues have said right now I just want to make sure that we are all on the same page of where we are going because if I say so and so needs to be reached out to for Title 9 or for policy I want to be accurate with my information I think it's imperative that as elected officials we are sharing consistent information and I think that's going to help us as a board and so um that that was my the conversation turned differently um from the discussion at the
201table but that was my intention to have this open conversation because this is how we have to do business is in an open form together so it's not coming from a place of I absolutely agree it is your in policy it is your job as chairwoman to assign committee assignments and I want to ensure that I'm not telling people that I'm on something different than I'm supposed to be on and and with everybody else this is public information so I just want to make sure that it's consistent public information that we are sharing so I'm going to end with that thank you ma'am we are at time at this point um second any discussion all those in favor signify by saying I I I any opposed passes 70 we are adjourned