001e e e I knew you were good at elementary e good morning everybody Welcome to our um January 21st 2025 policy meeting uh a couple quick things we've had a big big week uh we continue to have a big week I guess but uh of course yesterday was Martin Luther King Jr day uh what a great day um of remembrance and what a wonderful day to focus on uh as we move forward as a school system uh of course yesterday was also inauguration day uh another big day in the life of our country and uh as we look at our uh days and weeks uh ahead we have a weather alert coming our way in just a few hours so uh I do ask everyone please stay safe uh today and in the days and
002weeks to come uh you know especially uh with the possibility of snow we want to keep everyone safe and um so so um please join me in that uh at this point I would turn and ask M petki to please call the role Mr Pete wildbore pres Mr David Perry pres Miss Judy Justice pres thank you all for being here and to everyone else that is here thank you for being here this morning we do have a uh quite a a long list of policies to discuss today as well as uh some other things that may um be discussed so we we are going to be going pretty quickly throughout we will be following Robert's Rules uh as much as possible throughout the day uh next on our agenda we have the invocation which will
003be done remotely today Sovereign God you are our Lord and the keeper of our universe your word reminds us we are your people and the Sheep of your pastor today as the board begins their meeting for devopment of our schools we thank you for the leadership for every teacher every faculty and staff member and particularly for our students we pray for your continued protection over every campus and all of our students we pray specifically that you will grant this board Direction wisdom and Clarity in their decision decision making so that whatever decisions they make will be for the Improvement and betterment of our schools we thank you for your guidiance and your loving kindness may we forever give your name praise amen amen thank you i' ask Mr Perry to lead us in the pledge
004today Perry our pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all that means Miss Justice next Go Round the next year you don't mind okay next go uh our next bit of business is the approval of the agenda do I hear a motion Justice yes I would like to add something to the agenda okay um I would like to add policy code 4351 short-term suspension 43 51 is that correct correct 4351 is there a second I second okay 51 okay any other discussion I have copies for some people I don't have enough but ahead all I would like to also a motion that we at least discuss uh the uh behavioral reports uh request
005uh it that was also submitted I believe in Miss Justice's email requesting that we discuss the topic of of uh setting a policy in regards to us receiving monthly behavioral reports okay uh let's talk about 4351 first is there any other discussion we need on that yeah we need to vote on that something else there any other discussion on that all in favor of adding policy 4351 please signify by saying I I I I all oppose like sign that passes 30 so we'll add 4351 uh at the want see what we can add that down oh there we go uh why don't we add that after our uh section five so that at the end of our policy amendments from s uh ncsba okay all right and now Mr Perry I'm sorry yes there was
006another request I believe in Miss uh Justice's uh email that she she would she wanted to discuss uh devising a policy in and around us rece us as board members receiving uh monthly behavioral reports from the schools that we apparently are not getting anymore just okay I I had sent that initially and I I honestly can we have a discussion whether that should be a policy or whether we should add that to a regular a meeting agenda I want to make sure we do this properly okay why don't we add that right after well we'll vote on of course we have to vote but why don't we add that right 4351 okay and we'll call it Behavior reports is that good yeah that'll work Behavior reports okay we have any other discussion on Behavior reports
007if not all in favor of adding a discussion of the possibility of behavior reports uh please signify by saying I I I I all oppose okay again carries 30 Z anything else all right I would entertain a motion to to approve the agend the amended agenda I motion okay is there a second second okay first and second any discussion hearing none all in favor please signify by saying I I all oppos okay again passest is three 0 3 0 new numbers all right next we have which will be interesting the approval of the minutes um see as none of the three of us were serving on the committee uh I guess we'll just have to trust that they are correct I did read them I did too all right I'll make a motion that we
008approve the minutes as provided and do I need a second I do need second thank you all any discussion all in favor proceeding F by saying I I I all opposed okay passes three again um and again in future we will know have a better handle on that one so very good um carrying on let's go ahead and start with our first policy which is policy 50 5120 relationship with law enforcement uh again this is an unusual one um as provided for us um this is something that was brought up uh I'll just read this to make sure everybody understands a policy 5120 was approved on September 7th 2021 board meeting but with additional uh revisions that were made by board attorney at the time Colin shy these uh addition additional revisions appear in document
009in blue ink the document was inadvertently not forwarded to ncsba for inclusion in the policy online policy manual so uh I'll make a motion that we uh pass policy 5120 is there any is there a second I we'll have discussion then we can we then we have discussion but we need a second second okay you second okay we have first and second any discussion now we now we now we have discussion Mr Perry uh I was just confused by the document uh there there was one sentence uh in section D that was uh highlighted in red and then there's another section that was in highlighted in blue that's looks like it's marked to be deleted is the section in red also marked to be deleted um that's a good question it says I believe the
010beginning says in blue so I'm not exactly sure why the red is there can you I'll turn it over to our attorney and see if I'm not sure was wasn't read to to to remove I might be wrong trying to remember I thought the red sorry red is no that's not the remove I remember red is in blue is out is I think John if you can nod your head or shake your head am I saying that right yeah uhhuh okay red was already approved okay thank you thank you sir so again red is now red was already approved Blue is the part that uh that the board attorney at that time had added and now we have the copies that they made here and they actually say it oh okay there you go I
011was going deleted okay yes sir Mr Perry so okay thank you more um the so we we are not um so we are we are what is the rationale behind deleting um the the notification um to the superintendent oh you think he added it deleted though right here oh I think you're right Julie the blue was added what's over to the right in the deleted box was deleted so the blue says they will inform the superintendent so the Red's being deleted no both red and blue are added what's over in the right hand side of the little box deleted so again red red red was added and approved and then Mr shive had added the blue section um and that's so that's the section I think quite frankly he changed what was in the box
012to the right to the blue section BL section thank you Julie thank you Julie um and so we you will be notified yeah yeah um why is this so confusing I mean I mean why is just they things they just it should have been simp well and probably if it was discussed that fall next the next meeting then probably would have been yeah CU I vaguely remember this yeah it might have been more cleared two years ago when it got put out the beginning yeah yes sir per try this this is not something um that um that I'm moving on but just a general comment uh it mentions and since 7B 21101 has already mentioned and approved as added as you mentioned um and not something that we're adding like or the change that they
013blew um it's just that uh based off the policy in Reading 2101 it seems to me that you know while there are some protections for children who are under 16 so that they they anything they say without a parent or whatever it cannot be used against them no such protections exist for a child over 16 um and most of the time they will probably realize what their rights are at age 16 but there might be a situation with a a child with cognitive disabilities that might not really understand you know that you when that they they have a right to to have their parent there and to have uh to remain silent and to have an attorney president and all that um and I think maybe for the future we should clarify that you know
014uh there should be some exceptions based off of the mental capacity of the student uh even in the over 16 category because if there I had a development of disabled sister who just died in 2023 and she was 49 going on 12 and if you told her that if somebody had told that she would not have understood you know her rights in that particular situation so I don't think it would be fair to use it against her and even if she was 17 or 18 um but I'm not since it's already been approved I'm not makinging any motion I just think that we need to be cognizant of the rights of our our students and and don't just assume that you know all 16 year olds are are going to fully comprehend their their rights
015and I will say is as school officials they act in local parenes and principles that I have worked with in the past if there is a situation like that they will adjust accordingly and I was basically going to say the same thing um and local paren that means we stand in for the parents legally but if you're working into school with students you know this especially if you're an administrator you know the situation you're going to protect the rights of your child because it's your child technically okay thank you we have a motion in a second to pass this on to the board finally all in favor please signify by saying I I I all oppose ask the attorney is there a way that that can go to the board at second reading and just
016be passed and gone or does it need to go through the same cycle what's the question because it has gone before the board before can it go on as a second reading and then get pass or does it need to go through the same cycle I think we should follow the same cycle because I'm not sure what happened two years ago okay all right fa enough so we'll put policy 5120 as a first reading for next meeting carrying on with our second policy which get back to it life act age um I'm going to turn it over to our attorney because he has done a lot of this work for us uh and if you would share with us your thoughts on policy uh 61 uh 6129 please um I've drafted uh chair wbore a
017a proposed policy to address the lifeback emergency choking devices and their use in our schools there are a lot of considerations that come with this device um you know I was able to find in between the last board meeting two board meetings ago this I was able to find that the Red Cross and advisory Council has approved its use following the heick maneuver and and and back blows so it is starting to gain some traction within the medical community that said right now I can't find any other big medical associations that do approve and support its use with that said um I don't see why it could not be something in our emergency response team's repertoire the hurdles that we would have to overcome is that we'd have to Vol find a volunteer who on
018that emergency team who would uh want willingly voluntarily do the training state law prohibits us from being able to force people to take emergency training um and so I think if we found the volunteers we found people who would step up to use it I think we could find a means to get it into into our repertoire of uh of of devices that are on hand if the back blows don't work if the himlet doesn't work and we have that Personnel here we could pull it out of the closet where it's being stored um we have to make sure that it's not you can't you got to have training first and um there are some issues I need to still investigate with Insurance liability and also whether the Department of Public Instruction approves its use
019we don't want to do something that might be counter to DPI but where before I I think my choice of adjective was I'm ambivalent about it I'm I'm starting to lean towards okay we can find a way to to to add this into our our repertoire thank you sir and I I provided I have that proposed policy for us if anyone wants to look at it yeah those those can be passed around p take the whole one second here quick going that way going that way here oh this is in our packet too on page 21 and I have I have a couple questions and I'll go to Mr Perry okay so this is already in here here it's on page 21 oh okay first ask uh Miss Barnum Andor Mr Anderson how many devices
020per school do we have how many do we have to so there's a we have a total of 138 units and they are currently wow uh on pallets being stored in our warehouse okay so what's the do we have a plan on how many we would give to per school at that point to per school I would say uh I would say two per school and then we'll save the others in case they get broken and we we can put some at local like all of our other sites like you know cbrc and 6410 and that okay okay very good can I can I ask a question I'm just going to run that I'll get him then you um I did notice on on the proposed policy I I don't think we should have a
021comma after accessible which is a minor thing um I'm wondering if we can't do very much like the bloodborne pathogens where everyone is trained has a has an idea of it um in that kind of thing I do you know I'm going to say this I've said this repeatedly I'm going to say this again I'm not a medical professional in any form fashion I did use to I there was a time that I actually did all the CPR training for uh the school I was at in new han County I also was a wsit and lgit so I do know a bit about it but I'm not a medical professional uh but you know um I do think this is a valuable device because if there is a person choking we can't get oxygen in
022uh we we have to find some way to do that my last question and then I'll turn it over to other people to to ask questions um is there any possibility that for for the people that uh do if we do do like a bloodborne pathogens but if we don't if we have just some volunteers that they could get renewal credit is that a possibility the training that I saw was very very small it doesn't really reach a renewal credit space like you have to have a certain number of hours to get that and the training is fairly quick okay okay I'll turn to Mr Perry thank you Mr Alor um I did read your proposed policy uh for this um I guess um you talk about in the policy that only trained Personnel of
023the um from the emergency I guess response team would be eligible to use that how does that work right now I mean I want to know that there's enough people that in a choking situation you know that are going to be trained to use this I mean you know if a kid is choking you know to death and but we've only got two people in the school that uh that are on the Emergency Response Team and they're they're having lunch somewhere this doesn't help us very much does it so I'm just trying to get a gist of how many people are on the Emergency Response Team and would it be sufficient to handle any choking emergency presumably in the cafeteria or anything great question and I would actually just add and and I'm let you
024answer that but I would add you know like our aeds you know say I'm not trained on AED but I go use it you know why why would that not fall under the Good Sam maritan Law but sir um for one thing the law protects our Personnel when they're providing emergency care or aid treatment or life saving techniques the law also says that I'll read it no employee shall be required to administer drugs or medication or attend life saav techniques program so we can't force people to take the training um I don't have a solid handle on how many emergency response providers we have in every team that would be Dr barnes's answer um we'd have to have people volunteer that's what I would I would suggest again ask what the difference between that and
025an a would be you know say I wasn't trained in a but I go use the A and try to save somebody I I believe I'm protected I would be protected under the goods maritan law but what would be the difference between the AED and the life act I don't think there is a difference I think they're protected giving emergency Life Care okay jul answer that just yeah well I honestly don't think we'd have a lot of trouble having volunteers to do this doesn't sound like it's very extensive especially cafeteria workers but then teachers would probably this is why people are in schools they want to protect the kids and healthy kids and if it was done like saying School opening and maybe you know a half hour training it doesn't sound like it's expensive
026at all sounds like something that they would voluntarily we probably have more than enough people to be willing you don't have to just be on the team right that's my take on it so the the number of Staff trained in emergency response of course varies by school and of course because our School nurses who are public health nurses provide that training part of their nursing license requirements is that they determine somebody to be fit so the person needs to be Vol needs to uner to be a part of emergency response and then the nurse determines when they're training them if this is somebody that can carry this out and and has um adequate skills so in our elementary schools sometimes that team of emergency responders is going to be smaller but in our middle and
027high schools it's much larger all of our coaches are required to have training in CPR first aid AED response so they are much higher trained but they are required to be trained as a part of their coaching duties to be trained in those basic life saving measures but those have to fall under the American Heart Association so um from your policy proposed policy will you were you limiting it the use of it only to the emergency response teams or as M yes um war in an emergency anyone could Any teacher who even if they're not in the Emergency Response Team could could use it question I don't have the answer I would lean towards only the Emergency Response Team oh same with defibrillators and and uh you know it's uh that the policy that I
028I I mired the the E epipens for this this draft policy tried to mirror that the EpiPen use um but I don't have an answer to to whether or not it's permissible right now for members you have any any anybody as opposed to people on our Emergency Response Team in my mind I think we'd want the Emergency Response Team only J that's a pretty small group compared to the overall school and the people are going to be around kids while they're eating and it's just like you were talking about the the device ad what is that called it's over here somewhere in the wall yeah uh yeah you know the Good Samaritan law um I I personally would think that limiting it just to the emergency response team which is a small group of people
029within a school compared to everybody that's going to be around kids while they're eating can eat all day long in all kinds of places um I think we if we struck the one two three four the first line and the fourth um paragraph that would take care of um that that would open the door a little bit on that and so that the first line then would be the Principal should make reasonable efforts to notify other school staff members as I mean maybe train other schools I guess you have to take that whole paragraph out cu right now it's kind of saying only that those people would be but Mr Jones is the only person who trained to do it so he's only allowed to do it but I don't think we have the same
030if you take the for um a yes well if you take the first sentence out though that's that could be still broad the second sentence compared to the first the first sentence sounds limiting but the second sentence could be just anybody that's been trained voluntarily right which as I said I think that that you get quite a bit of response I don't think the training is exensive either it's not no so obviously and I want to make sure I say it again since we're uh being broadcast my only concern with the life back is making sure it protects our employees St no problem with using it so I was wondering if I think the only concern about emergency trained Personnel using the device is correct me if I'm wrong Mr KY but the Good Samaritan
031law says As Long as You Follow you're approved in training so I think the only thing for our emergency trained Personnel is if they're trained in CPR they have to follow those procedures to be covered by the good Samaritan law so I was wondering if there couldn't be that sentence could change to say like maybe you scale it to say that these devices should be used until adequately trained medical personnel arrive so like what I don't want to have is a teacher then saying to the nurse no I've got this you you're good right like is there a way to say and and when Emergency Management arrives they should take precedence over the nurse so is there a way that you could scale it so that this is used until other life-saving techniques or trained
032Personnel arrive do you know what I mean then it could be for anybody to use it until like a a a trained person gets to the scene if that makes sense I was reading how it operated and I think it's only they say it's the first or second time after that you don't want to keep doing it so whoever on the scene first you know you might not have a chance to wait true and I I mean and I understand that this was based on the EP epic but I wonder if it wouldn't be better to be based off the AED cuz like you say in AED if you don't the aeds Le the ones I've used in the past um and I've never used it on a real person I'll say that but I
033mean you know with mannequin and stuff it actually tells you what you know the little boys have you know put pads on do blah blah blah blah I mean so this will not do that but I wonder if um you know that you shouldn't have maybe based on that where you're trying your best I I think as I've read that and I I don't mean to disagree but I think it's the way that I interpreted the goods Mar law is if I'm trying my best to try to save the person that I'm protected even if I don't even if I it's like for instance I think the reason for the my personal non-legal uh idea on this is that if I'm if I try to do CPR on somebody I break your ribs trying to
034save you you can't turn around consume me because I broke your ribs I'm trying my best so if I'm trying my best with this you know this thing maybe I I got trained two years ago and I still try my best that you are protected am I correct on that let me speak on that okay yes please if you use the he lick you can break people's ribs what everything I found says back thrust or back Clow first chest thrust which is the H second as a last resort use this I I'm aware of the Good Samaritan law I I provided in the packet to the board this past meeting General statute 115 c-375 one when you read the second paragraph and I'll read it out loud any Public School employee authorized by the Board
035of Education or it's designated to act under Section I dou I or triple I above shall not be liable in civil damages for any authorized act or for admission um and it goes on talks about liability I feel that if we're going to authorize their use we should mandate or we should say hey in order to use these you need training first I don't feel they should be offered to the general staff all the teachers you need to have training first this is not like this is not back I mean hitting the kid in the back and get them to cough up a grap is different than using a device and if if we're going to put a device out there I feel that in order to have that liability coverage that protection of this
036law that I just cited and I gave you guys copies I think we do need to train those people that we don't want people who don't know how to use them to deviate from the back blows and the and the highway okay any other discuss yeah Mr Perry yeah my my my my one concern I mean my main concern besides the fact that the we don't have a a number of you know as many people on the emergency response team as as we do cafeteria work etc is also that it is my understanding that the Emergency Response Team since which would would have to be trained by our nurses which we get from the county who have told us in no uncertain terms that they don't authorize or they're not they don't want their nurses
037doing this so so you know this is I don't want to end up in a situ and and it seems because like you said people start to come around in the medical community with this but sometimes all the FDA and all the rest of these people have a slow time catching up here so but I mean I think our kids' lives are on the line you you you got to forget about bureaucracy and think of what's best for the kids here so um I just don't want it to be a bureaucratic means in order to not have it because if the nurses are going to be in charge of training the Emergency Response Team they're going to be using these devices and the nurses won't do it then what have we done right let's actually
038if I could ask Mar respond to that yeah so my communication with the um School nurses has been related to their specific training in American Heart Association basic life saving training and in in discussion with the health director and then the state school nurse consultant in trying to get some direction on how we can make sure our staff are trained and comply with our policies and general statute um the concern from the state school nurse consultant was that that um life fact is not FDA approved and then the question remained which couldn't be answered necessarily because I guess nobody's carrying a list or we can't find somebody with a list that um she referenced General statute the same general statute that um Mr cromy was discussing um that allows our staff to perform first a
039or life saving techniques in which the employee has been trained in a program approved by the state board of education but I asked okay well where where's the list of these that have been approved and nobody's able to give me that answer yet we don't even know but because it's not FDA approved the school nurse consultant um said that it wasn't something that they could support but they said they didn't have the list oh she was saying because of FDA approval that was her reason so who would then let me ask you the question who would be in charge of would that be the principal of the school then be in charge of uh training or who would be in charge of you know like we say if we're going to say we need to
040have some train you know bu stops with the principal's office I know I the training appears to be a f minute video really easy but you do need to have it first I think we offer our our Personnel if you you know take the five minute course online and it'll be you know a third tier emergency device for US stick with the HCK stick with the back thrust back blows as you're you know most people know that but if there is someone that that has that training that's a third you know something try to use then can we put in the policy that tearing that you're sort of talking about that it scales with as more professional medical help arrives do you know what I mean is there a way to sort of scale that
041I'm hesitant to start crafting policy that dictates terms for emergency life saving techniques in those situations you just have to know it and pray to God and do it I'm I'm not that's not terribly yeah well I'm not I'm not sure I would want us to start telling our personnel what life-saving techniques to do in certain situations I just think we should offer this device as a like I said a third tier emergency choking you do your back back blows first the him Li second and if if that's not working obviously you're calling EMS right away and do we spell all that out then now we're starting to lay down I mean we would be laying down policy that could be argued it's against the f da or or DPI I just think we should
042offer these I'm not sure we should spell out all these variables or try to spell out all these variables but wouldn't part of training be when is it appropriate to use I mean you wouldn't well just leave it up to employe I want to do it well in that situation you'd have a lot of medical groups saying we don't approve these I mean so that's what my concern is that we we're laying down policy against the do the himik and then do this but if we're not training those people that this is the proper way to do it then the proper proper sequence then I don't like the idea of us creating policy that is against a number of large medical groups the FD a our local County Health Department is not in favor of
043these devices I'm not sure we want to do that but that's up to you guys but do we have that you know and I'm going to look back at you because you're the one who been talking to the the local you know have they actually come out and said we don't approve of this yes Mr chair w i I spoke to the um I think it was our nurse manager or the supervis they are not they don't support it the nurses will not be able to use this they will not be able to train this they will not be able to touch this that's a consideration for us we're using a device or we have a device on hand that is not I don't want to use the not not even close to being fully
044supported by the medical community a a small sliver of the medical community says yeah we can try this as a as a last resort that's it so that's why I'm I'm I'm not I don't feel it's proper for us to try laying out policy you look at the the the legal terms of willful and uh you know gross negligence wanting conduct or intentional wrongdoing what I'm hearing is hey can we enact policy that could be adverse or contradictory to what all these medical groups are saying if we start laying down when to use it how to use it I think we offer it that's it that's my take we offer training it's online line through the company manufacturer we offer people if you want to go and get this training as in addition to supplement
045your Heim lick and your your your back blows we'll have a couple of them but I'm not I'm not anywhere near supporting we allow anybody to use it that may that may that may cross the line of intentional wrongdoing or gross negligence or wantan in conduct when we're telling people who have no training to use this medical device I'm not in favor of that I I I almost have to lean on what Mr Perry said I think that you know if I have a child that's life's on the line and this is the one chance that they have I mean I'm sorry I guess I take on the the world to save that that child and I mean this is an opportunity to do that so uh with all du respect I I got to
046disagree with you and I think you also have said that the uh America Red Cross actually is come out now and said well a councel an advisory counsel of the American Red Cross so okay well I'm going to I'm going to stop our conversation at this point why don't we do this why don't we tweak this why don't we bring it to the whole board my suggestion would be I'm only one of three of us we'll bring it to the whole board let the whole board have further input we have we have two board members here by the way thank you guys for being here today appreciate that very much why don't we bring this to the whole board let the whole board discuss it um if if that's okay so my my corrections I
047would like to make uh obviously we have and I have no problem with your numbering unless somebody else has a problem with the 6129 as as a number let's leave it there the number uh the question you had there for first is I I'm understanding two devices per School uh I would like to take out easily accessible the comma there we don't need that comma it should be easily accessible locations board members we have have any other uh tweaks to this this was the one you mentioned before to make sure that it's just not limited to emergency response for okay so cut deleting that yeah one two three fourth first line and the fourth mhm let's let's delete that so the third the third paragraph will be deleted fourth one two 3 fourth paragraph first
048line okay so that does we're not telling but I I I don't want to take out the training I just don't want it to be limited to that little sub oh yeah no okay but it says uh each so one or more so I think that does give us the opportunity to have if the whole staff comes in and says hey we want to be trained in this they could all be part of it correct that's correct um and I'll also check with our Insurance liability carriers make sure we get their position on this device okay okay is Justice yeah and I briefly because everybody was talking about it and I had just come on the board I did do a little research and it is conflicting but getting better as far as the groups
049approving it it's got like a 94% success rate that's pretty impressive if you got child dying as you mentioned it was my kid yeah you know it saves one child to me it's it's well worth it Mr per you have your hand up I'm sorry far and I'll direct my folks to go ahead and get them prepped and sort of divided up I know one of the concerns has been the length of time it's been taking to get that so Eddie if you could have the purchasing folks kind of get them grouped up and ready to go in case so that way once the board does make a full decision we'll be poised to move either way and I would ask you if you wouldn't mind I I don't know if if you're going to
050have a principal meeting between now and then especially with all the stuff going on but would you uh kind of Just Bounce us off with the principles and see what their thoughts are it depends on when you bring it to the board the next principal meeting I'll have will be after the next board meeting you mind but I can certainly pull so that must be difficult yeah I can pull them and and sort of get them up to speed thank you I appreciate that thank you so much all right all right so I make a motion that with the changes we we add we move uh policy 6129 onto the full board is there a second second first and second any further discussion if not all in favor please signify by saying I I I
051all oppos okay 6129 as the amended version will be moved on as a first reading uh at our next meeting thank you everyone for all that very intense and uh profitable discussion all right let's see what we have next page 43 everybody it's a jump so I figured that thank you yeah all right P 43 don't just do it this way all right so our next policy for discussion and I'm going to kind of go through these policies um a lot of them I noticed and maybe you concur hopefully you do a lot of them have just a very small amount of change um you know there some of them just have a letter A jot a tit added uh throughout the uh thing but otherwise if there's any discussion so I'm going to go
052through it if you if you'd like to further discuss it we will stop and do that if not we will carry on so first policy we have uh was 3225 is there anyone that wants to discuss that Dr I'm me Mr Perry um the I just wanted to I I don't have any uh major uh this seems to be minor revisions but just uh the uh I do have some concerns about the general policy particularly about um revolving around disciplining students for private uh websites the might be R running that in the superintendent or the school administration even if it's not done on site that somehow they can be disciplined for what they do for the website that they run at home so but I don't have any objections to the current language I think
053that's a further policy discussion for another meeting okay thank you sir anything else okay all right uh so our first policy is 3225 I'll move it on to the board for a re let's let's go ahead and take a vote 3225 we we'll do one by one if you don't mind we could do the whole thing whatever you'd rather do but we'll go ahead and do one one by one 3225 uh I'll make a motion we carry that on for first reading or excuse me for the existing policy up in the right up right all in favor please signify by saying I is there a second second thank you all in favor please signify by saying I I I all oppos he 3225 moves on 3227 web page development anyone I make a motion we
054car 54 sorry page 54 thank you sir 3227 I make a motion we carry it on a second second thank you guess you guys are like all right all in F any other discussion hearing none 3227 all in favor please signify by saying I I I all oppos good hope this is the way to do it uh 3420 student promotion and accountability page 60 I got that okay uh any discussion hearing none I make a motion We Carry On 3420 to the full board uh all in favor please uh any discussion no all in favor please signify by saying I I I all oppos 3420 carries on I don't think I got a second on that was there a second on that I'm sorry I did not get a second I'll second actively yeah I'm
055trying to keep this straight uh 3460 I've actually asked Dr Barnes to walk us through that Dr Barnes or I guess maybe yeah and I'm I'm going to ask Robin to speak to some of this these are changes to our graduation requirements that are created by DPI and the State Board of Public Instruction page 68 sorry I falling asleep on the job Robin do you want to speak to any of these things specifically well most of the most of the graduation requirements are shifting a little bit in regards to math um they have also talked about students who come into for the first time in ninth grade are required to have one Arts education course that used to be voluntary is now mandatory I love it right and that starts with the 25 26 students
056entering ninth grade correct that's sort of the biggest change there's also some that requires students to excuse me leave 8th grade with a u a plan in place for graduation so they have to have a um sort of a a a scale and plan for their High School time wasn't that in the that was in 3420 that was that in the first one sorry sorry and students used to the CTE students used to have the career development plans but now this is for all students and parents are notified of that they do have access to the portal in which is in but it's really just to help guide students and ensure that we're providing the right opportunities for them that aligns with their interest and their postsecondary um plans board members Mr yeah um the
057uh the only question I have on this is the uh is how specific are these uh plans as far as having a having a career plan um are they very specific like are are incoming ninth graders are expected to know exactly what professions and make a very detailed precise oh well I want to be this because we all know they're going to change their mind about eight times before they graduate so and when I was a high school principal every year a kid updated that plan as necessary so sometimes the kid's like boy I really like that cooking class that's what I want to do you you pivot on those generally all the time correct it is fluid based on their continual assessment of their interest and to give them those experiences so that they
058can have exposure to various interest and yeah when they're entering it there's a whole process where they they're introduced a lot of different uh possibilities and opportunities the eth grade is a good place to focus towards going towards high school and then to renew it at 10th I mean it's it's all they're not being blindsided and we're not making the decisions totally without their input and I just don't want our students kind of pigeon hold into a career at ninth grade we don't do that okay any other questions not uh I'll make a motion that we pass 3460 onto the full board is there a second second any discussion hearing none all in favor please signify by saying I I I all opposed passes 30 next we have 4320 78 no 4320 page 78 okay
059there we go 4320 any yes sir this is about 4320 and uh uh 5026 7250 I mean I guess it's two different policies but they're related because it seems like it's the same language change in addition in both defining what is a tobacco product to include anything with nicotine in it that doesn't uh necessarily even have tobacco actual tobacco in it M and uh you know I there are and I'm not here trying to say that we should have vaping products in our schools but it to me the language being used is you're conflating the two and it's not precise language and I'm always like to have oh uh you know you know they defining anything with nicotine such as a VAP that might not have any tobacco in it as a tobacco product but
060at the same time a nicotine patch or the gum or the loes has nicotine in it too but that's okay but that's not a backr so it's and uh so I am I'm going to ask that these two well I guess at this point only on this one is that we table this uh for the next meeting so maybe we could come up with language that would be more along the lines of uh tobacco and vaping policy versus trying to conflict these terms because I don't think it's I think it's important to be precise in our language and not to just go along because it's easier to just lump them together I think it causes more problems if we if we don't use the real I mean calling something a tobacco product that doesn't have
061any tobacco in it doesn't seem like it's a good thing to do here would you like to make that motion sir yes okay and so you're basically talking about and I think you can you know lump the two of the two uh policies together for 4320 and uh 50 26 SL 7250 and you're making a motion we table those two cor yes sir is there a second well second the terminology is is the issue okay so we have a motion to table 4320 and 7250 to have uh our I guess our attorney to look at over and maybe come up with a better um more succinct verbage any further discussion no I I agree with u Mr Perry that there's a product got a lot of guys playing hockey using zins it's like a pouch
062I think it has salt with nicotine on it and uh I'm not sure this would cover that I I I think we do need to address this and make sure we cover all the uh possible chemicals that are out there that wow awesome people are dipping now one thing to check on I know these came from the SBA but I don't know if this is tied specifically to a line in general statute so I would check to make sure of that because the board can create policies that are more restrictive than General statute but not class maybe we consider the the label of the policy 4320 instead of calling a tobacco products called tobacco and nicotine products and that would cover any concerns and we'd allow we could that would fit down below all that
063blue blue stuff and we could this policy would pass instead of changing the the language is change the label tobacco and nicotine products Mr Perry would you be okay with that or it seems though that the actual language defines tobacco of the addition here defines tobacco as these things so just changing the top label I don't think it's sufficient all right we do have a motion and second in front of us to uh whole 4320 5026 and 7270 in in policy all in favor please signify by saying I I I all oppos um that passes 30 so that will be held in policy and in policy yes ma'am yeah I wanted a little discuss okay s well when when um when he looks at the nicotine and tobacco terminology house being used remember too that
064we do have kids that are addicted to nicotine and they wear patches or they you gum and they we're trying they're trying to get off of it so you can figure that one out but there you know so putting just nicotine and saying that that's you can't when there could be a health reason maybe you should put that in the policy Mr can I can talk about that work that one over it sounds like next next time um carrying on we have 43 34 5035 7345 which is on page oh yeah which is on page I was looking at the general statute for you guys it's on Mr chair Mr chair yes sir um point of could we take uh can I make a motion to take a five minute sure sure absolutely um we
065will we will uh re uh we'll come back together at 11:00 okay 5 minute break e e e 11 welcome back everyone thank you there work other things um we're going to on with our next point of order yes sir um did we vote on uh 4334 the drones 4334 5035 5 7345 use of unmanned aircraft I have on [Music] my my last I on my list after 4320 would be 4334 43 I'm looking at assmbly here I'm trying to figure it out 4334 is all right we got 43 [Music] 34 oh I'm I'm off sorry might be better that way I'm not too sure 43 34 50 uh 35 and 73 45 use of unmanned aircraft drones anyone have any discussion on that Mr Perry these seem to be minor changes I don't have
066a problem with uh the my obviously there's been a lot of people concerned about drones in the news lately so I do when we you you it's just more of a question for Dr Barnes when we use these things do we use these drones in our on our schools or just we have a class m a class okay but as far as like surveilling the schools or anything do we use these things no we don't use them for any kind surveillance sometimes our Communications Department will use it to take like a beautiful picture of the school grounds going but we're not using it to monitor students thank you yeah okay all right any other discussion if not I'll make a motion we pass 4334 5035 and 7045 onto the full board is there a second
067I'll second thank you ma'am uh any discussion hearing none carry on uh with uh all in favor please signify by saying I I I all opposed carries on to the full board 30 vote uh next is 5025 registered sex offenders any discussion if not i' make a motion we've carried on to the full board is there a second I'll second thank you sir uh any discussion hearing none again uh all in favor please signify by saying I I All oppos Passes three 0 5022 we've already discussed 5026 and that's going to be held so we'll carry on to 5051 reporting to external agencies 5150 what did I say 50 51 oh I'm sorry 5150 my mistake 5150 I I'll get that down eventually 5150 any discussion hearing none I make a motion we carry that
068on to the uh entire board uh is there second second thank you uh first and second any discussion hearing none all in favor please signify by saying I I all opposed 5150 goes on 3 0 6120 5150 get that one on uh 6120 student health services any discussion I'll make a motion we carry it on to the full board is there a second second thank thank you I'm going have to pull ass pull yeah we're just going to run through them here but all uh all in favor of 6120 being carried to the full board please signify by saying I I I all opposed 6120 goes on to the full board 6140 student wellness any discussion hearing none I'll make a motion we carry 6140 on to the full Board second second all right look
069at that thank you all right 6140 uh we have a first and second all in favor please signify by saying I I I all opposed carries 30 8305 um is there any discussion hearing none um I make a motion we carry 8305 onto the full board is there a second second thank you uh any discussion hearing none all in favor please signify by saying I I I all opposed carries 3 9025 9125 let's get him right um any discussion yes sir Mr Perry I I believe that this we should I would like to make a motion that we just um eliminate this policy I believe it's discrimination um codified in our policy uh we should be I would be fine with encouraging local businesses small businesses but discriminating uh our local vendors based off the
070power of the skin just seems to me to be wrong and uh I don't think we should play into it and uh you know I think we should judge each business that wants to contract room by their merits and not by any of this other stuff okay is there a second no oh I have discussion well let's get to we first we have okay all right if you want to go let's go to discussion go ahead Justice uh this isn't just about color of skin it has to do also oh my gosh there's plenty of minorities out there uh it says right here you have women Native Americans asian-americans those of Hispanic descent um I mean I was a history teacher my God there is definitely an an equality in the way our our structure
071of our society is set up right now and this is just trying to rectify it so that all people have the opportunity to catch up with what historically and it's a fact there has been an extreme discrim there has been discrimination and so we're trying to eliminate discrimination by giving this opportunity open so I think we do need to bring this to the full board if this is you know if if um if you want to discuss it that's great but I I personally think we'd like to move it through here and then go further there there's a disagreement um and I I since since we have one on either side of the the equation here um I I would almost say that I think the whole board should hear it and and discuss it
072I think it is a very valuable discussion uh whether we want to continue this or not but I don't know that the policy Committee in it in itself should be the body to uh eliminate this policy so I would um I would concur that we should bring it to the whole board if if the whole board decides to eliminate this policy uh then we then we need to eliminate it but at the whole board I think that's why we have seven on the board and not only three so um I'm going to concur with um Miss justice as far and in in the point we do bring it to the entire board for discussion uh and then the the entire board can decide whether or not to follow Mr Perry's advice as to eliminate and
073I'm sorry I'll go to Mr uh Miss Sutton and then I'll go right to you R yes I did want to share this is State purchasing law is the reason it's in our board policy so this isn't just us this is coming from the state thank you okay back to Mr Perry thank you very much for that it was more of a point of procedure uh so what you're saying M uh Mr W deore is that uh if if we if we were that you're recommending that we recommend uh if we recommend that that the whole board discusses that it would be put on put on the agenda for our next meeting oh yeah this this will will be com in front and then we can just what I would what we would do is
074we would just to uh to let you know what we would do is you would actually pull this one off because it would be on a consent agenda you'd say uh I'd like to pull off 9125 for further discussion and then we'll take it off we'll discuss it as a board and the board as a whole can discuss it thank you thank you and I guess but just I guess I need to look at you e both of y'all is this something that we have to have in policy I mean yes sir that's my understanding it is something we have to have in policy okay all right all right well we have a Miss Justice yeah could the the legal expert just like he just said because for my understanding is we have we have
075to follow state regulations and that's so we really don't have a lot of choice in this legally that's why I was asking uh attorney here for his look at okay well and like I say if we bring it to the whole board then we'll have you'll have an opportunity if you would sir to look at it and then and you can ad us at that time okay so um I would entertain a motion to pass 9125 onto the entire board I second okay I guess I made the motion I've been doing it so okay uh any further discussion point of procedure I had made an original motion to oh yes you did yes you did I'm sorry yes yes you are 100% right so we do need to is there a second to eliminate the
076policy cuz we can you know we can do that you know take you know I can I just can I just withdraw my motion you may sir okay I'll just do that thank you sir I appreciate that um so at this point I'll make a motion we carry 9125 on please not as part of the uh consent agenda or policy consent agenda I I'll go ahead and pull it off now so we're going to be further discussed um is there a second for that second okay first and second all in favor of carrying 9125 onto the full board please signify by saying I hi I pass is 30 0 okay 9125 um unless you have unless someone has a reason we need to pull off any of the these all have minor changes I'm going
077to list out the whole group if there's anything that we want to pull out uh in the in the interest of time to discuss further we can do that if not we can just pass all these on to the board uh so uh 6200 uh 71 30 911 10 91 sir yes 9110 you want to you want to pull 90 you want to pull 9110 okay so we'll pull 9110 for further I make a motion we accept all the others except for 9110 to be moved moved on to the entire board is there a second second okay I who got that one pretty close all right all in favor please signify by saying I I I all opposed passes 30 Mr Perry 9110 you want to discuss most of our contracts go through a competitive
078bidding process my understanding is that Architects Engineers surveyors are not required by state law to go through a competing process there an exception to the rule but I I don't think that that's mandated that we do it that way I think we should have a competitive Bing process for those positions as well uh simply because we don't have to doesn't mean we can't have a competitive buing process from my understanding of the law on this but our attorney would advise us otherwise Mr C you have I have no comment on this right now I have to look at this okay um I would just say the wording is set up to align with State um purchasing policy but we can certainly be more restrictive than State purchasing policy would you like to make a motion
079that we hold 9110 in policy yes i' like the we table it until we get some answers from our uh last and I'll second that we hold 9110 in uh in committee further discussion hearing none all in favor of holding 9110 in policy please signify by saying I I I all oppos I passes three okay now the things we have added I think we're done with our uh regular agenda we have added 4351 to our discussion so we will take that up at this time Miss Justice you were the one to ask to I believe M Justice asked hold or to discuss 4351 possibility we can get that on the board yes yeah that's what I was hoping for cuz I make copies but not that many and we need to look if anybody wants
080a couple physical copies do anybody go okay go I got I also yeah I also have the two items that have been repeatedly requested to be added and I think at this point if we're not familiar with this I don't know where we've been for the last couple years but I'm going to pass these out only made sorry I didn't make enough copies but this is what the request was I come these down this direction for the changes the shortterm suspension I head some down this way all right um uh policy code 4351 short-term suspension as we all know we've had repeatedly over the last year at least if not longer uh the love our children group uh come in and just want to codify what we have um been doing and from what I
081understand and this makes common sense is what principles do is that when a child the young ones or any child actually they better be doing this a child is suspended from school that uh they immediately are as soon as possible try to contact the parent or guardian and uh then the child is suspended but it's not codified anywhere it's not written down to add that that the administrator should be calling uh now the point is that sometime and I know this and you know this from experience a lot of times and you know this from experience a lot of times you can't get hold of the the parent or Guardian but making the attempt and I know I worked in a school district where they I worked inuring public schools and I was an administrator
082and one of the things they did is they did have a codified and that made a big difference as far as in your headp space you knew you sure better try to get hold of them and so just the fact it was written down helps cuz you can get extremely busy crazy stuff can go on and who knows what you know but when it's C by the just makes a bigger statement that you need to to contact the parent of the that's why I would like to have this add in M Jus just let you know Dr in case you don't know Dr Barnes and myself will be meeting with the uh love with Mr BT uh tomorrow um and I guess some other folks uh about this very thing my my you know my
083my only quam I mean I've I've been a supporter of of their group in a lot of ways over years met with repeatedly I know it was not brought up the other day but anyway we'll get past that uh but um you know is is the is the word that um principales shall contact K2 parents before a suspension termination is made I mean uhuh my my thing before you know if if two you know a child just beats a SN out of another child you know I have to I have to as a principal I would have to contact that parent first and say is it you know it's almost like the principal is being asked is it okay with you you know and that's my big thing is you know principal shelf contact what
084you're saying I don't I agree with 100% principal shall contact K2 parents uh during a suspension termination or after suspension termination but but the word before is my is the only the only you can we can do so attempt um make make sure that the attempt is definitely made we can't I mean realistically we know no you can't get hold of the parents a lot of the times that's one of the sad parts about the situation but the attempt is made and messages are left um then at least you've you've gone as far out of the way as you possibly can you're right though you've got a child over here that's really having a you know they need counseling they're working with you know they're all the office and you can't get hold of the
085parent so by the end of the day you may not even have the parent respond I mean we know all of this but the attemp the attempt really has to be made and I think being CAU it really makes a difference Dr bar would you like to speak to what you a couple things jul pull up the code of conduct where we change that language um first off every good principal and every well-meaning adult in this District wants to minimize suspensions period and start my concern is that's balanced against the principal's ability to create a safe and effective learning environment for me what I put into the language of the code of conduct is that principles will have have made conduct with a parent before a student reaches the escalated phase of an out of
086school suspension I'm going to just read it for you if you don't care because I wanted to respond to the concerns that they had so I made it a clear to the principales in a principal meeting and by email that minimizing suspensions is their role and then I added to our range of student consequences that parent communication is embedded throughout the range of consequences as seen through the leveled corrective responses it's the expectation that parents and school personel work collaboratively to decrease the likelihood of challenging student behaviors unless there is a need for an emergency removal parents can expect contact from school administration prior to reaching the response of a suspension from school and that my goal there is to embed the parents in collaborative nature with the principal before we reach an out of
087school suspension and that's excellent my concern is the word before if you change that word to when then I think that we're already we're doing that and if I could add something else and I was going to share this so I don't know if you tomorrow or not but I think honestly as as important as the wording that we have here which is is important and I agree if we change that to win I'm I'm 100% on board is as a former administrator and I think you would agree I think as as important but probably almost more important is when that child comes back to school that we have that meet if we don't sit down with as a principal as an administrator with that child on the way back in okay you know like
088I say I have had situations as a principal where parent says well my kids going to be home and and B I can't take care of my child all that kind of thing which is you know that's neither here or there it is very important obviously but um you know thinking through that whole process but the other piece is when that child comes back how are those behaviors is going to change unless we counsel them unless we sit down with them whether it be the administrator whether it be the counselor whether it be the administrator and the counselor working with that child uh you know if if a child with IEP maybe having the EC teacher sitting in there that's really as important as as all this discussion because you know you know I I'll
089be honest I was not not that I was a a good you know a perfect administrator but I remember I had one of the schools I was at as an sister principal we actually made together I made an a team and it was the students that got suspended on a on a regular basis we met regularly I took them out of class for just a little bit of time to try to help them figure out ways you know how how not to get suspended how not to get themselves in those kind of trouble I think that's as important as you know this kind of word but you know you know I I don't think that you know I I would you agree to you know principal sh shall contact day2 students when at suspension Comm
090is that okay well that is what we're asking and and here's you know what and we can discuss this further but I agree totally and this is what I tried to do also just like you and we did have teams and you mean honestly our biggest problem is lack of resources we need to have some kind of system within the school so kids that have these chronic situations have possibly special situ you know settings that they can get the support they need because obviously there's something going on with this child that needs this kind of support and we don't have the resources right now to actually bring in the staff to be able to do that but in lie of that I mean of course it would it maybe we should visit this about having
091you know the parents need to come with the child when they return and have a meeting with the staff to to set up a proper you know positive re-entry plan especially with a small child that's also I know that I sent I'm sorry go ahead Mr go sorry um could I just make a motion to amend the language to say principals shall attempt to contact parents as soon as possible uh when a suspension determination is made and let's get rid of the K22 this should be happening for all of our students not just K22 okay you you repeat that motion please sir U make Amendment amend the proposed language to say principles shall attempt to contact parents uh as soon as possible uh when a suspension determination is made okay is there a second well
092can we I guess I I'll second it so we can discuss then we discuss okay the U the reason that this is 4351 has to do with um the age of the child because I agree with you I think it should be across the board for older children too but this one specifically is for the younger kids is I mean this is why we created this particular policy so if we could do that right now and then that that and then the re-entry plan too these are some things we do we could be focusing on that could just make it better for our kids and their families so they can be successful this policy is for all short-term suspensions okay well then excuse me buil in it for kids under AG when in P is
093specific but it's the it's the whole Gambit oh okay well then I think yeah I like that I second it I agree Dr Barnes a couple of things um I agree with Mr Perry that anytime that we suspend a child out of school there needs to be a contact with a parent I would ask that it's say an administrator rather than a principal because sometimes assistant principles do a lot of that work as well and in a high school imagining a poor principal having to call everyone I would I would welcome a friendly amendment of such but administrator should shall contact parents when a suspension determination is made I think is reasonable or attempt to absolutely okay all right so we have a motion and we're going to go with administrator you good with that
094you good with that principal or designate that sounds smarter or designate okay cor perfect okay I guess could be a um what they calleda students yeah exactly or one of the guidance counselors work with Okay and again this would have to go in front of the whole board just making sure everybody everybody understands we have to go in front of the whole board a motion a second to uh change the wording say it one more time please Mr Perry did we go with principles and or their design go administrators I can't remember what you principal or design would be better uh principls or the design shall attempt to contact parents uh uh as soon as possible when a suspension determination is made okay all right all in favor please signify saying I I all oppos
095okay so let me find the right spot on this see it's right here 50 where am I 50 help me out 43 4351 sorry I should know that one that's the amendment ble so okay and the last discussion we had was Behavior point of point of order yes sir we we voted on my amended that you have to vote for the main thing it's I don't think so because this that was the wording that we CU that policy was not up for review until you guys brought it up so you you made that motion we we voted on that we'll change we'll bring the policy to the whole board uh as an amended policy thank you actually it goes up here in the top um 51 all right so that goes up there and then
096we have Behavior look can yes ma'am um the word before do we have the word before in there no did we put that be attempt before just to make sure I said I said as soon as possible as soon as possible during I didn't say after I just said I like before the deter I mean you may not be able to reach him but be so you could have at least a discussion with the parent hope maybe over the phone before you make the determin if he can't reach him he can't but before you make that determination that was not what was brought up so yeah we can we can have further discussion on that I guess yes okay so I would like to add an amendment to have the word before added okay is
097there a second our second discussion okay it's just a term but that just it makes it feel bad because you know that you're calling the parents how about before or or in order to um in order to allay uh Dr br's concerned how about before or as soon as practically possible well yeah and again that that was my objection to the thing to be begin with so uh you know I'm just going to let everybody know I'm not going to be uh voting to amend it will take 2/3 which is a super majority which so we need to have um that first we'll vote to have the discussion uh of the amended discussion of 4351 so all favor of having a further discussion of 4351 gives the word before pleas signify by saying I I
098no okay will not okay I also vote no I just wanted to clarify something yes goad okay so we can still take this to the board and when we discuss this this could be added at that time absolutely y all right um so the last discussion topic we had today I believe that came I'm not sure Mr Perry why don't you discuss it Behavior report right there you go so this was a another love our children request uh although I think it's in the is in the uh you know transparency is you know one of the important things in my mind and uh apparently we have not been getting these monthly reports like we used to as far as uh suspension data behavioral data U from my understanding is if I can find the report
099is that that we used to get student Support Services M well that's that this says to the board right so um the I'm just discussing this so um we used to get this so the number basically apparently we're not getting these now all these not monthly anyway is that correct M far so the student services monthly report was created um for district administrators to view metrics um before we had other avenues such as a who knew it dashboard and before we used other dashboard U methods now I will say um that report because it's a collection of lots of different Vital Signs um on the district whether it's mcken vento um numbers B School fasta compl comption Dropout counts bullying reports threat assessments that kind of thing um the amount of time it takes to
100create those and with the staff reductions at the central office the bandwidth isn't there to create that level of report and in talking to our decision makers um our district level staff they've said they have ways to get that in other ways rather than us creating one um giant report that you know probably takes 20 to 30 hours a month to complete so um because that data is available other places say that report wasn't created but that was not a report that was created to send updates to the board those monthly updates were provided um interdepartmentally and among District leaders so they could um support problem solving and school Improvement efforts within schools thank you I sent you guys I think a month ago an update about the number of kindergarten first second grade students
101who' been suspended it's also on the docket for our office hours this month to dig into them individually my focus for this report was to find out from the schools what are we doing differently for students who have received more than one out of school suspension to change their environment and that's stuff I was going to bring to you in a smaller session because I think that's where that gets more valuable I do think that the number of suspensions you see are so rare enough that I can provide those to the board in an update in the month if you guys would like that information that information however is so individualized in some cases uh I'll just off the top of my head 16 of our elementary schools have had zero so of those nine
102several of those have only had one student I am concerned with the level of specificity that has that's why I would rather share those individual things with you in a in a way that doesn't necessarily cross over into notifying kids I will tell you and I know this something we brought up before I've got no problem with doing something like that I question the need for a policy that requires me to do something that is a reasonable thing for you guys to ask for me to do for the board anyway if that makes sense uh and and I want to tell you that I just wanted to bring the topic up I am not 100% certain we need a policy one of the question although I don't I when it comes to agregate data like
103this that's non- student specific uh doesn't you know out our student students or any of that sort of thing I mean it's not just us that should be seeing it I mean it's the public that should be seeing it I agree and um and one of the questions I guess I is M prin Miss Brinson is not here today is that Don donon uh I mean how difficult it would it be to have some of this reporting available on our website um I and and but colleague is here so would you um that wouldn't be a problem for us I think the only concern I I I'm hearing is that we don't want to make it you know at at this school this child you know we've had three people suspended and the schools a
104school of you know 535 kids all of a sudden we know who that child is that right we do have a risk of um personally identifiable information being accidentally released when you have a really small number in your population for example when we report out our accountability measures our achievement data we cannot report to the public a number under 10 with with regard to um achievement scores like who made a level two three four five if it's under 10 it's a less than 10 and so these numbers are really small um and if you disaggregate them to the school level and you're potentially and especially if it's one you're potentially um outing the kid so to say by it um and the the definition and I didn't have it ready but the definition of um
105personally identifi identifiable information is if there is anybody involved that could um that would reasonably know who that kid is then you have released confidential information second I I think that this is a question to some extent about board governance um it's part of your job to ensure that I'm doing my job right I don't know where the public fits in with that specific instance my job is to minimize suspensions ensure safe environments for schools you guys partnering with me in that makes sense to me that being a public event do we also publish grades do we also publish everyone's GPA do we like where does that level stop if this was statistically relevant information I would say maybe one thing but we're seeing less than 20 students in the entire fall semester that have
106been affected I I am concerned that that is fairly specific data that I would rather have the board see I don't see where it turns into a public event what I would I get a chance to speak I would like to recommend is why don't we think about this why don't we bring this back to our next policy meeting why don't we have the meetings with Dr Barnes this week we can hear what we need to hear and if we you know again this is not a dead subject so we can bring it back to our next policy meeting and that way there we can you know if if we need to have a further discussion we have a further discussion is that okay sounds like a good idea actually more knowledge I one those
107one more knowledge to every once in a while yeah every once in a while is that okay okay if everybody's good with that um last bit of information that I have on my list is adjournment oh wow would somebody like to make that motion well I guess I be a motion again I beat him on that dis all right we have a motion second to adjourn all in favor please signify by saying I I thank you everyone for being here we are adjourn