001[Music] 11th at 4M today we are meeting to consider the opt out of HB um we have the agenda before us is there a motion to approve second a motion by Mr Grimes a second by Mr McCall in favor you unanimous if you're able please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all and please join me for a moment of Silent reflection all right good afternoon everyone thank you for being here today as we consider the opt out of HB 581 we'll begin the hearing with a presentation from staff uh led by Mr Larry Hamill and our superintendent Mr MCH young Larry if you go ahead
002and bring up the first slide I probably should say good afternoon everybody before before I jump right into this um all right so we're here to talk about uh the proposal that we as a staff have made to our Board of Education uh over the opport opportunity to opt out of house bill 581 um and just as just as a as a very brief background in our community uh obviously as a as a member of this community myself for the last 17 years we have seen a a rapid rise in the value of our homes in forye a lot of that having to do with the fact that we live in a very attractive Community we've got a very successful school system uh we know that supply and demand drives prices up and we've got
003a lot of demand of folks that want to live here um in 22 and 23 and that's what really drove us to the point that we're at tonight uh 22 and 23 we had uh historically High reassessment values of our homes that they drove up our property taxes um and the other thing that I think is really important to to point out is our community is really unique in the standpoint that we've got a real imbalance between residential and Commercial when you when you look at us compared to you know some of our competition out there whether it's fton County North Fon County guette County cob County they've got a lot of commercial in our community because we've got uh such a limitation on Commercial our residential folks really carry the burden of um you
004know of our tax of our property taxes Larry uh just want to hit a few points here on our current financial status and there's been a lot of uh there I say fake news that that goes on out there or misleading news and so let me hit this one right out of the gate for scth County schools has and will continue provide a senior school property tax exemption for Homestead owners age 65 plus this exemption has absolutely nothing to do with any of the any of the uh 65 plus senior exemptions that exist out there um currently our uh maintenance and operation millage rate of is 15.208586 values uh including including last year which didn't have a high Spike but but we still up I think about seven 7 and a half% over the previous
005year and in the last three years we have have have lowered our millage rates uh by three full Mills plus some change um mean we have the lowest millage rate that we've had in for scyth County since 2009 we continue to be recognized Statewide and nationally as a as a good Steward of taxpayer resources we maintain a five-star Financial efficiency rating with the state of Georgia a one of only six school systems in the in the country to have a AAA Bond rating and that happens because of responsible financial management uh in the 2024 election for Scythe County voters passed a referendum on House Bill 717 which is a homestead exemption that caps reassessment values at 4% annually that house bill is now once it was was passed in November is the law for Scythe
006County schools and uh so I'm going to talk a little bit about House Bill 717 before we go into house bill 581 before before you move on sure just two main points from that slide one if you're 65 and older you're eligible for a full abatement on your school taxes and no matter what's decided that's not changing I know today there was a lot of post made in senior citizen groups if you're 65 and older and you're exempt from school taxes you will still be exempt from school taxes regardless of the outcome of this of this decision and two effective January 1st of this year because the voters of the county passed this measure by 74% there is already a 4% cap on your taxes that's new and never existed before so the decision before
007us is the decision between two Homestead exemptions which are very very similar and both provide very very similar tax savings benefits to the constituent so just want to be clear about that because there's a lot of information flying around online that's not exactly correct I think also the you back off of that the uh the school board doesn't have the power to get rid of the homestead exemption for 65 and older that actually has to go back to the citizens on a referendum to be voted on by the public so just know that when people go out there and say that we're getting rid of the 65 and older we don't even have the power to do that so just have that information out there and know that there's a lot of misinformation but we
008don't have the power to do that if we wanted to no it's great points great great points okay so how's Bill 717 uh was passed by unanimous resolution by our Board of Education and unanimous agreement by the members of for scyth County State Legislative delegation um a couple of years ago and and again this was we recognized those two spiked years where we had historic High reassessment values and and understood that in addition to lowering millage rates we wanted to give some sort of property tax relief to prevent those those crazy spikes from ever happening again in terms of what we're able to collect and so a floating homestead exemption designed to limit reassess property values increases at no more than 4% annually was the number that we arrived at this was after after the
009folks I just mentioned the Board of Ed the staff here and our legislative delegation looked through all of our historical budgets looked through our projections and and determined that a 4% cap would would keep us tight and our budgets going forward um but would allow us to operate as we need to operate as a school system now this cap is set to expire in 2035 not the other Homestead exemptions there's no expiration date as as Mr McCall pointed out with the 65 and over it's just this new 4% cap that expires in 2020 2035 and what that allows us to do because because we've never had an exemption like this that allows us a 10-year period to see how does it impact us can it be adjusted can it be extended and by the way
010along the way if even with that cap we are getting more than what we need in terms of being able to operate budgetarily then then we can roll Mill rates back and continue to lower those so that can continue to happen as well yeah and that's actually a good point today there was posts made all over the place that said that one bill versus the other would allow the school board to raise taxes faster taxation is determined by the Mage rate and this this either one of these bills doesn't affect the school board's ability to raise or lower the Mage rate so that's just trying to provoke anxiety in people yeah um the last 3 years the board of education has lowered the millage rate more than anybody in this state so um we want
011to do the right thing and we've been trying to do the right thing over the last few years well lowering the millage rate and increasing the mill rate should be a local control decision we work hard through this budget to make sure it's balanced I as a board member want the ability to lower millage rate and it should be decided at a local level not the state level yep and that's a great segue in the next bullet point House Bill 717 in the in the um local floating homestead exemption that we're talking about this this 4% cap was developed based on fory County Schools Local Economic realities and that's really important just to kind of put a mark next to that when we get into house bill 581 uh ours was was passed at the
012local level um it then went on was passed in the general assembly 2024 it was approved by our for Scythe County voters in this previous election uh by almost 74% and it took effect and is in effect right now and is guiding our financial planning as we get get ready to go into next year's budget season Mr Hamill uh I what I do think and and this I'm not sure this may be just conjecture on my my part but I I believe that our bill when it hit the general assembly raised eyebrows of legislators throughout the general assembly and the idea caught on of having a a a homestead exemption to cap reassessment values just my just my thoughts but what we do know is after hours there was suddenly talk throughout the state and
013that's what led to House Bill 581 which was a a Statewide cap on reassessment values and again I'll go into that in just a minute the concerns I have with a state issued cap versus a locally developed cap is it doesn't take into account local realities and local expectations that our that our taxpayers and quite frankly the parents of our school children have I won't go through any of these but but unlike for South County Schools not every system in the state of Georgia provides what we provide which includes that senior property tax exemption for homeowners age 65 and over um that most places don't have their own cap already in place uh we've got this is one that that raises eyebrows when I say this but we have school resource officers in every one
014of our schools here that is not something that's paid for by the state of Georgia that is a local expectation local decision made that's funded locally and I think in the day and age we're living and most people will look at that as a no-brainer we've got to we've got to have that again I won't read through the list of everything but but um these these things that you see up there are just sort of a smattering of things that our families and parents of of school AG children have come to expect okay so that's 717 uh our local uh self-imposed cap on on property tax reassessments then you have House Bill 581 all it too is a floating homestead exemption design the limit uh Homestead Property Tax Bill increases if homes home values rise
015faster than inflation and they use instead of a fixed cap where ours was set at 4% they determined to use a an inflationary measure that you would you would call prob we're assuming is going to be Consumer Price Index uh it's yet to be determined by the Geor Department of revenues commissioner um and and I'll talk about some concerns we have but but what that means is in short you're that's going to vary from year to year House Bill 581 not only applies to school districts but to counties Consolidated governments municipalities to be clear if we opt out of 581 that is just for school taxes the County Commissioners have this before them they can still opt out a 581 regardless of whether we do or not and that will apply to that will apply
016to the taxes that they collect uh for their operations when it when it when it comes to the County government House Bill 581 has no expiration date it it's a permanent fixture school systems have a one-time opt out opportunity in law that was that was provided us that must be completed between January 1 and March one of this year uh passed by the Georgia General Assembly in 2024 and the November election it was approved by a Statewide referendum and locally received about 69 almost 70% of the vote uh a little bit less than our local one um if both of these are in effect whichever one helps the home taxpayer the homeowner more is the one that is applied all right so I want to make sure I say that so that nobody thinks I'm
017I'm trying to sit back on that that that is true but I'm going to explain why I still don't think that's best for our school system in in just a second so House Bill 581 took effect in January one and we are now in the in the opt out process to potentially make a decision to opt out of that y that you mentioned which I think merits repeating perhaps unintentionally the general assembly is requiring us now to make an a choice on these bills and they still haven't told us what the rate is based on we still don't even know whether we opt in or opt out what are we opting in or opting out to yeah that's a great point we have a general idea but and and that Segways right into the first
018concern that we as a staff have presented to the board 581 is tied to Consumer Price Index which is that could be a national index that could be a state index that could be an an Atlanta metro IND we just don't know and we we we're not we're not certain about that what we do know is is ours is tied to our local realities um House Bill 581 creates uncertainty for the budgeting process from year to year you know it it's really important for us in a growing County like ours to have some ability predict with with some reasonable level of prediction um what we're going to have coming in at us from year to year when it comes time to hiring teachers and building schools and and so forth um 581 has no expiration
019date which is which is sold right now is a is a positive from the school standpoint I I look at that as something that that's that that's really scary because if this has major league negative effects there's no adjustment to it that's in place and it it it's not going to go away um and 581 as I said has has an opt out opportunity Mr Hamill so just to kind of show you historically uh and these are just estimated uh but historically you've got three columns there um that that show uh what what what uh CPI would be and um I'm sorry you know what this is I think this is the the older one we we've got another one with a third column in there we had one for an Atlanta metro but I'll
020I'll just go with the national one on this is that yeah check real quick no this is fine so House Bill 581 the con House Bill 581 CPI for previous year this is really built on on the national CPI we've got another one that we'll post out there that shows you just for the Atlanta area it's it's very similar there there's not much difference at all um but as you look from 2018 to 2024 you can see how it fluctuates how it goes from 2.1 to 2.4 down to 1.8 down to 1.2 then it hops up to 4.7 then on up to eight and then back down to four for us in trying to manage and Steward our taxpayers dollars and provide the services for our school system you can look at the next column
021where it says House Bill 717 and what it would look like if we had a cap on that and and in the previous years that's where that cap uh you know that cap would sit at now the actuals if you if you go to two coms before that that shows you the actual so if our 4% cap had been in place you can see that it would have saved the taxpayers dollars every single year on this on this chart for the last eight years you know in 2018 instead of 9.86 it would have been capped at four instead of 8.6 and so on and so forth Claire let me see if it's in here oh that's okay you can stay up with that slide okay yep next slide there we go okay so just just
022as a point of comparison and on our website we've got a a nice sidebyside chart that shows you the two and as and as chairman Val says it's not there's not a huge difference between them but the little differences are there are are very impactful in the school system um House Bill 581 was the Georgia General assembly's approach to solving a local challenge with a one-size fits-all state ordered solution all right ours was a local challenge with a local solution developed collaboratively with our local delegation of Representatives and our local school board 581 is tied to inflation which is unclear it's volatile it it makes it much more challenging and to to do a a an annual budget uh projection uh 717 with the fix cap allows us a lot more predictability 581 was designed
023specifically to blunt the rise of property tax reassessment values and that's the sole purpose and I just want to hit this this is probably the biggest difference if you can if you can understand the lens of what we're looking through is 581 was absolutely designed to give property tax owner relief when it comes to reassessment values we not only agreed with that we were the ones that led the charge on this okay but ours was designed to do two things one was to bunt the rise of property taxes but to do it in a responsible manner that also allows us to provide Educational Service and safety needs for the students of fory County House Bill 581 is aimed at municipalities and and counties and school systems and there's really really no thought giving to school
024system needs I I will I will tell you I'm I'm biased I work for the school system but uh we've got the best school system in the state of Georgia and it requires some resources to keep that going and um so this was done very responsibly to make sure we give property tax relief that in a way that we can continue to provide these services and um that's all I have to say about that Larry all right and I'm just I won't read through this slide but I do want to drive home what we did responsibly ahead of everybody else was come up with a local solution okay local government right finding a local solution to a local Challenge and what five 81 has done is take a Statewide challenge to to a problem that
025looks very different Community to community okay um these guys get tired of me hearing that hearing me say this all the time but one of the things that makes for scyth County schools and my mind so special is that we really do model what it means to work with your community to work with your state representatives Your Business Leaders we we have this formula that we think is is is what made our school system so effective and that's the model of collaboration Innovation and accountability and we collaborated in order to come up with a very Innovative approach to this Challenge and one that holds us accountable and um and I think this is the 717 is is the solution that that allows us to provide relief as well as continue to provide great services to
026our community in in terms of Education um so right now I won't read through these but this is just the opt out requirements set in place by law of which we are at hearing number three out of the three required hearings and there's the timeline with that I turn it back over to you chairman Valdes can I make one point real quick to one of the first slides um what I want to point out historic inflation uh I think one of the reasons that the state went with 581 was these 21 and 24 rate even though those particular rates are unique to forze those same rates were across state of Georgia in similar fashion almost for every County for the state of Georgia so it's just not us that had a high the entire state
027was seeing race like changes like that yeah yep you Larry thank you Larry Larry is our CFO by the way okay back to you chairman V thank you Mr Young and Mr Hamill so I'm going to open up the floor in a second for the um public hearing portion of the of the evening or the afternoon just something I've said in the last couple hearings that I think merits repeating we're the decision today is the decision between two Homestead exemptions so at the end of this process there will be a homestead exemption on your school taxes something that has never existed in FY County if you're a senior citizen 65 and older eligible for a homestead exemption total abatement of your school taxes under no circumstances is that changing okay the we've run many simulations
028and the tax savings difference between the two measures is measured in the hundreds not in the thousands or in the tens of thousands okay like some some folks have said online um the tax saving difference between the two bills is a averages about 1% of 40% of your home's value so the taxation on that amount so as you can see it's reduced to a pretty small number um both measures are going to provide robust protection so that we don't see these big swings anymore in our taxes and and in reality over the last 10 years the 4% fixed cap would have been more beneficial overall to the taxpayer so it's all about how things are framed and the decision today is the decision between or not today next week is the decision between two robust
029tax saving measures both of which accomplish the same things and the difference between them is measured in the hundreds of dollars over a 10 or 20 year per period not in the tens of thousands of dollars or even thousands of of dollars so I want I want everybody to take that with you because there's a lot of things that are said online and this is a complicated subject but um the decision is between two great bills and this is a good problem to have I think in in our community that we're picking between two good tax saving measures um so with that nobody signed up tonight to speak but if you're here and you would like to say something I'm glad to allow you to come up and uh and take some some time to
030or if you have any questions or short story before we do that um either the super CFO from what I I know we've seen a lot this is not just a fory county opt out issue this is Statewide and I get that you know to me I think 581 served you know the heart behind it was probably good but I think a lot from my understanding a lot of school districts have seen the same issues that we have kind of seen in this bill so we are not the only ones you know going through this opt out process um and the last I heard was over 100 school districts across Georgia doing this and I just didn't know if that's still that are going through the the opt out process Mr Grimes I had a
031CFO meeting last week uh which is mostly North metresa and I know everybody North North metresa is opting out of my understanding I do know there's some counties in South World Georgia that get a lot of Equalization money through kebe and there don't get a lot of the uh they get more money from the state than they do their Lo local property tax and some of those Counties have are opting in to do it uh some of those counties get as much as 72% of their revenue through the QB formula uh because the way it's set up uh there is a county in North Georgia uh P I'm sorry Pickins a burke I think it is and they get only five or 10 Perc of their budget from QBE so they're definitely opting out of
032this uh the few that are opting in though seem to be the counties that get a huge percent of the money from the KB formula though and if nobody knows what that is that's the quality B basic education formula on how the state funds you how about you share our contribution to that program uh we right now only get about 45% from the state of Georgia to fund the school system so so when it comes to when you when you share with them Equalization it that really is generated from counties like ours that give the first five Mills worth of our of our tax collections back to the state correct so last year I think to Mr McCall's Point how much last year our millage rate is 15 uh 308 but the first five Mills
033of that goes to the state for for other counties and how much did that amount to last year the uh state of Georgia um took 90 almost 99 million do out of the state funds that we were going to get uh to go back to the state as our five mil contribution yeah so so that's important yeah just it's important because for the taxpayers to know is that the first $99 million that we collect as a school system from the taxpayers goes to the state of Georgia and we don't see any of that it never comes back and and I'm and personally that's a lot of money I give it give it yeah so basically we donate a 100 you guys donate $100 million that get sent to Atlanta and gets distributed to other school
034systems and never comes back here because we're a rich County so we don't see any benefit from that money so the first 100 million that's collected here locally goes to the state never comes back it is techically we don't actually send it to the state it stays with us deducted from the state money we could get right they they deduct it from what we're getting right y That's Right y um that's totally within the power of the general assembly to to change that um they they've not opted to do so um the idea of fixing any kind of tax taxation rate to to CPI I mean the general assembly could also do that for our income tax I don't know about you guys but I pay a lot more in income tax than I do
035property taxes so if we're trying to save taxes I mean that's another another way that we can do it um yeah so I'll open up the floor again if anybody that's here would like to ask a question or say something or or or whatever we we'll open up the floor no okay well yeah so seeing as how there's no participants we will go ahead and uh and close the public hearing we will hang out here if you guys want to talk but we'll go ahead and end the official public hearing portion so I'll seek a motion to adjourn a motion by Mrs Hoy a second by Mr Grimes all in favor unanimous thank you guys the the hearing is adjourned but we'll we'll stay here if you guys want to talk or whatever we we'll
036be here h