001e e e the time is now 5 o'clock the Montgomery County Board of Education board meeting is now being called to order we have um an established cor at this time is there a motion to approve the agenda a motion that we approve the agenda is there a second a second it has been motioned in second all those in favor do so by showing of hands it's unanimous They will receive as information a presentation from hya uh by Dr Joseph and Dr Lee this is in reference to the Montgomery County Board of Education um superintendent search so at this time if you all would come to the P push the button right there we go I got so excited I just I just started going but good evening everybody I'm I'm Dr Sean Joseph and
002I'm the lead consultant for this presentation today I'm here uh with Dr David Lee who who'll introduce himself in a moment but it's a it is a blessing and an honor uh to be here to support you uh in this superintendent search you have a very fine uh school district and I think uh this is an opportunity I think whenever you have a superintendent sech it's an opportunity uh to really Galvanize the community about your shared moral purpose uh to do right by the children that you serve so uh as we walk you through this presentation we hope by the end you'll have a clear understanding of kind of the journey will be on for the next 3 months and and we're here to answer any questions that you uh may have so if we
003can pull the presentation up okay again um the board has an awesome uh responsibility and it's really to understand your your stakeholders desires and to collectively uh come together to communicate uh to the world this is uh what we're looking for in our our next superintendent and it's our job to support you in your effort to find a leader who's the best match for uh the Montgomery uh School Board again I'm I'm Sean Joseph and um I have been in education now since 1996 I actually got into education by by accident I went to Lincoln University which is America's oldest historically black college founded in 1854 up in uh up in Pennsylvania and I actually went to be a medical doctor make a long story short uh I met a student from South Philadelphia High
004School who couldn't read and I couldn't understand how do we put people on the moon but we don't teach children to read in this in this country and that that changed my trajectory so I switched from being a biology major to being an English education major and I went on to become a reading specialist an assistant principal a DEA students I was Maryland state principal of the year uh in in 2009 uh supervised 34 schools all in Montgomery County Maryland uh in right outside of Washington DC and I supervised 34 schools before becoming a superintendent of schools in Delaware then a deputy superintendent in Prince George's County uh then superintendent of schools and Metro Nashville Public Schools before leaving to become the an associate professor at forom University and for the past five years I've
005been at Howard University where I run the urban superintendence Academy and I'm on the tenure track there so so again it is an honor and privilege and and I don't take for granted the great responsibility that we have in this moment uh to get you an extraordinary superintendent I'll turn it over to my colleague Dr Lee to introduce himself thank you and and good evening I share uh the comments with uh Dr Joseph I've been in education I think since the Earth was cooling that's it seems like uh that long but uh I too have uh come through the um the arena as a teacher as a as a principal as superintendent of schools uh Deputy State superintendent for the state of Louisiana um and I am currently a professor of educational leadership at the
006University of Southern Mississippi and uh I train school boards uh we've done extensive research on school boards and uh have a national Center for Schoolboard training and uh uh that that takes a lot of time as you well know but looking forward to working with each of you and going out and seeking and finding you the very best superintendent that's out out there to come in and to and to lead this school district um I do have a grandson right up the road at uh alurn and uh I've got two granddaughters uh one of them is still at the University of Alabama and the other one graduated from the University of Alabama and then my other one graduated from uh South Alabama and and mobile so uh we do have ties right up the road
007to Auburn always good to come over and it's good to be be able to come over and go visit uh when I come but thank you so much for allowing us to do this search with you uh I promise you it' be a great relationship you'll be proud you did and we're going to bring you an outstanding outstanding leader Dr Joseph thank you in addition to Dr Lee and I uh we have uh Miss kib she'll be on the team Misha is currently a a council member in Memphis Shelby County uh she used to be the board president pres in me Memphis Shelby County Public Schools and he's joined the hazard younga Associates team and then we also have Dr Connie Evelyn who'd been a superintendent for over a decade in New York uh and
008now she's written a book on superintendent evaluation and providing support so we brought a you know the uh we think an Allstar team to help you uh both find people regionally and nationally as we go uh across and I think that's what hya does best we have 140 Associates throughout the country uh so when we recruit I think that's where uh we Excel both locally uh regionally and nationally uh we try to look for people very broadly through vast networks uh you know there are a number of superintendence acmy around the country uh there are a number of um State associations across the country we tap every you know we we look through under every uh Rock and every Corner uh to find candidates and tell the story of Montgomery so it's important for us
009uh to listen deeply uh to what it is that you're looking for because there are lots of people uh who uh want to be superintendent but we know uh a successful superintendent board relationship is like marriage you've got to be able to listen well you've got to be able to communicate well and you've got to understand each other's idiosyncrasies you know so we get down into the details uh to really try to help you find uh that right uh candidate a little bit about hya uh hya is a woman-owned firm it's been in existence for 35 uh years doing executive searches we've done over 1,600 executive uh searches to date about 80 plus searches a year and we have about 130 plus Nationwide Associates with 35% being people of color 49% being women and we
010have a NW work to aggressively recruit uh for uh our positions uh we work to really engage communities deeply you know we we will uh take time and do as many um Community meetings interviews that that you deem is appropriate to truly understand uh the DNA of U Montgomery Public Schools uh so that way when we go out and we look for people we're very clear you know about what it is is that we're looking for uh in your next uh superintendent superintendent uh we'll be very responsive you can see I know uh Eric and I on the phone last night at 9: about 9:45 we you can call us anytime day or night we'll be available and responsive uh to your needs uh we get about a 9 9.4 out of 10 on our
011client satisfaction and we're striving for 10 so so we're trying to figure out where that point 6 where we went wrong so we can get better at it uh because because we believe communities just deserve Excellence period And so we'll we'll strive uh to do that and we use a lot of research and analytics uh as we go through the process and we'll talk to you about that a little bit to make sure again that you we have the right Community superintendent match in your process and uh we're fully backed with an an office and IT staff to help uh Ure that the process is seamless as we we go through and we have Partnerships formal Partnerships with aasa which is the American Association of school administrators uh alas which is the uh Association of
012Latin American superintendents napsi the National Alliance of black school Educators State Affiliates Urban superintendence academies universities the American educational research Association AA spa nsba and other uh candid other superintendent acmy around the country so again we tap and make sure people know that the opportunity is there and we know that our timeline is short here so we have to be very aggressive and assuring that uh people know about Montgomery and we can follow through most recently we're in the process I actually lead the search for uh Clark County which is Las Vegas Nevada so we're in the process of doing that search right now along with a number of others I I supported the Atlanta uh search recently that brought them Dr Brian Johnson and you can see a list of the uh districts that
013we've recently done uh so again we uh understand large complex districts uh and and and and really take time uh to understand what this particular Community wants uh in their in their superintendent that's important to us again that we listen deeply uh to parents to students to board members to the business Community to your politicians uh to be clear about what we are I me I think um you know you have to have Clear Vision you know um to achieve and and get to the destination that you seek uh to get to so you know our goal is always uh to produce for a board a diverse slate of candidates uh to meet the needs of the leadership profile um and and we we think that that is important uh that that we um bring
014you a slate that that is diverse in every aspect of the word diversity uh with Excellence as we look for candidates as we look at our signature process uh we really have four steps in our process Step One is an engage phase that's where we work to understand the desires of your organization step two is our recruitment phase that's where we bring the widest range of candidates that meet the requirements that you seek step three is the select phase and this is the process that we have have that we'll take you through uh to select and arrive at the best match for your particular community and then step four is optional and that is a transition phase where we can support you and the new superintendent in your marriage together again as we look at
015the Timeline right now according to your RFP you'd like to have your superintendent selected uh by sometimes the end of March um so having said that you know again that is an aggressive search it's not an impossible search but it just means Dr Lee and I have our work to do as as we get out uh and and and recruit and and identify candidates but uh the month of January if we were to proceed would be uh we'd launch the orientation process uh for the search uh we'd lock in and the board would vote on whatever optional Services you so desire uh we would uh identify uh the one we do the leadership profile when we do the interviews uh what the interview process would look like I so we' lock all those dates in
016and and publicize that as soon as possible so people are clear uh that that's going to to happen and when it's going to happen uh then the board would have the interviews regarding the desired characteristics so we we'd go through the process of um interviewing board members interviewing community members doing surveys within the community so that way we can come together and going into early February present you a leadership profile which communicates exactly what the community would like and and we bring a draft to you just to ask did we get it right before we finalize it so we don't want the board to just vote on our Our rough draft we put it out hopefully give you community an opportunity to look at it give some feed back and then bring back to the
017board to refine uh so that way once that profile is out everybody every body feels good and there's a sense of uh cohesion and and Clarity and unity around what you're looking for uh in the next uh superintendent then we have a survey that's optional that we could put out we strongly recommend that you have it because a lot of times people don't always come to the focus groups in the interview processes but they will complete a survey and I think it's really important that you have your students participate in the surveys because they're the client that is most close to um you know receiving the services that you provide so you know having the survey out for at least two weeks to gather information from the community but again we focus on individual interviews
018uh focus groups and Community engagement and then we'd also put the advertisement out the advertisement go live for the month of January and the month of February your leadership profile would be delivered to you uh in February and then in late February we would present to you a slate uh of candidates uh these would be hya would based upon what the community said you desired uh we would look through all of the candidates that applied uh we would recommend to you uh uh this is what we believe is are the candidates that best fit the profile that you identified but it's important for us that you see everything so we give you the folks who we think you should uh interview but then we'd also show you the folks we didn't not include and we
019could talk to you about why this candidate did not go in versus the last candidate and then we'll also say these are the people who just don't you know fulfill the uh Alabama requirements to be a superintendent you always have people who just apply just just to apply you know they never uh they don't have anything on any of the criteria but they just they just won't be your superintendent you know so so we take their stuff in and and we we let you know about it but but it's important that you see everybody and and when we give you the m materials we'll give you the materials to every single person that applied as you go through so know that because again we see ourselves as facilitators of a process it's the board's process
020uh so so we we help you you do that and we can talk more about that as we move through but we present a slate to you in late February and then in March uh we would have uh the interview rounds and we would recommend three rounds of interviews uh a first round interview where people would have an opportunity to present uh to the board uh and Community uh communicating to them what they think strengths weaknesses opportunities are and how they would approach uh the work and allow the board to ask questions then the board would be able to narrow down uh the group um based upon that we can come to a magic number once you know the candidates but then have a second round that's more in-depth uh interviews and then we think
021you can narrow down to more to maybe have uh one or two finalists that come out and you'd have an opportunity to uh have those finalists communicate to the community or um you know there are lots of different ways to do that and part of the initial conversation that we would have is what would be in the best interest of this community on how we go about doing that but you know there are some communities that um well I think because of um your laws in Alabama your um presentations must be public you know but there are some instances where in some states you can have private situations where they might bring in um a small group that signs non disclosure forms to inform the board on information but here it has to be public
022so you know the we discuss how that could be done but we always think it's important that we gather data and information from the community to share with the board as you make this important decision that will affect uh the entire Community but once you select your candidate uh in April the transition uh process would begin Al Hy believes that every child has a right to a quality education and recruiting developing and retaining great leaders is is essential to improving your District's student outcomes you know and so we think it's important for us to have strong relationships so we'll work to build relationships with you as a board you know to hear from us we'll make sure all board members have access to us and and you can you know speak with us and we'll
023clarify any aspect of the process but we work with you work with your your students the candidates uh internal candidates and external candidates and that's something you know as a decision we talk about as as a um as a group you know there are districts that believe that any internal candidate should have an interview there are others that say no firm we'd like you to evaluate them like you evaluate everybody and make a recommendation you know culturally the board would inform us on how you'd like to uh deal with internal uh candidates who decide to Mo to the process but uh no we work with everyone uh because every this is a it's a huge responsibility and opportunity uh to serve uh but this is this is your search so know that at any point
024you tell us how you'd like the process to go if anything needs to change we can be as you know efficient or you know extend things we we'll constantly ask you uh ultimately it's your decision you know we will'll structure things for you but we want you to know it's your process because you understand your District needs uh we'll try to help you stay focused on your strategic plan and the goals that you have aligned within your strategic plan and we'll follow the timeline uh that you feel is best for this community and again we strive to customize uh for you so you know lots of things once you tell us what you want then it's our job to make sure we execute on on what it is you say you would like to achieve
025uh and then again you know we have no sitting uh current superintendent working for us so everybody you know I did that five years ago no plan on going back Dr Lee's done it for a while because you know we we don't want any uh issues there you know we we uh you know uh we focus on uh supporting you and your district and in your interest again we've been doing this for 35 years and we've got a lot of folks uh who we've worked with uh we agre we aggressively recruit and again we want to make sure everything is pristine for you as we move through uh the process uh you know for us it's really important uh that we understand your district and that we uh take again time really researching uh looking
026working with your tee uh to get things right for uh the community but we uh will take time to look at the board strategic plan if you have one uh we will definitely interview each board board member individually for about an hour uh those would be individual uh board meetings we work with the board and your team to identify who in the community should we go to and you know I think we make recommendations to you because sometimes um you know every board doesn't have the greatest relationship with the community uh and sometimes it's great to have a surrogate uh to go on your behalf so we we talked to you about that are there Community groups that you might want to co-sponsor activities with to bring people out for a focus group uh to
027get information um you know we we'll use your expertise and your Insight uh to help us identify which groups should be formed and and where those Community forums should take place and we'll do community forums interviews and focus groups virtually or in person uh as many as You' like whatever works best for your community U so you just have to let us know what you prefer as you do that then the uh package that we proposed you would have a total of 32 uh individual or focus groups or Collective meetings that are a part of that package and then anything more um would be something customized that we talk about but we find uh 32 meetings tend to be more than enough uh to really get rich uh information from from the community as you
028go through and in addition uh we have the stakeholder survey that really provides invaluable feedback uh to you helping you understand the perceptions of the district from multiple uh stakeholder uh viewpoints Al so we serve to be your ambassadors uh we work to listen deeply and we work to validate constituent perspectives as we go through uh the process as I said in terms of your meetings uh we're very versatile in for format we can do face tace meetings Zoom meetings or any type of mode other than Zoom uh you know but we can go to various locations and We Gather feedback we tend to find uh lots of people email us communicate with us as we're going through the process and we keep the board updated and and establish a process to make sure that
029when that information comes in uh it's responded to appropriately uh we can have flexible meeting time so we'll meet whenever is best for you morning afternoons uh or evenings uh we're happy to be here weekdays or weekends uh in terms of focus groups uh we give you a recommended list we definitely think it's important that you at minimum uh have your high school students uh interviewed as a part of the process but also parents uh certified staff support staff administrators business partners other businesses Civic groups booster clubs PTO and others Community groups recommended uh by uh the board again I can tell you in in Clark County which is America's fifth largest district and I'm serving I'm doing that uh search uh we had about 86 uh focus groups because again very large you know
030they have 300,000 students the largest relative right but so they they decided to have about 86 uh focus groups and in their particular process uh morning noon and night all throughout the the the the the the county so that was that was a busy time but just know we're flexible and can do whatever the board uh wishes uh for us uh to do and then also uh we uh seek diversity and inclusion so we seek to reach all community members and stakeholders and uh coordinate for various languages so we we do have the capacity to put out um written materials in any language that you need them uh put out in and we work with you our local community agencies um if you need multiple languages uh within the community uh forums we have a
031research based stakeholder survey that we uh put out uh was powerful about the survey is that it allows you to understand uh the perspectives people have of your District in multiple domains uh from their perspectives and you get a um report that looks something like this where each bullet represents a different stakeholder group so you can see the differences and perspective people have within your Community I think that's extremely important um because sometimes we you know we see the world uh through our perspective and sometimes we we think one thing but students might think something totally different parents might think something totally different and that helps you as a board in terms of your leadership steps and it'll definitely uh be good feedback for uh your aspiring superintendent to understand the complexity and nuances of
032uh the um opportunity the challenges that lie ahead uh leading the Montgomery uh schools and a little bit about hya and and I think what gives us an advantage to some of the other uh search firms that are local and national uh you know we have about 2,100 uh 21,000 excuse me 380 enroll subscribers to our monthly newsletter that goes out and so this job will be in that newsletter that goes out to all of those people throughout the country uh we have about 44,000 unique users on our website looking for jobs you know we put on our website all of the superintendent jobs that are out in the country not just the ones that hya uh do and the reason we do that is we want to draw people to be a One-Stop shop
033uh to if you're looking for a job you come there because whether we're doing it if somebody else is doing it you can find it uh so strategically that that gets us 44,000 people uh looking at our site when we put things up there uh we have a candidate profile system with 7,000 people who specifically registered for hazard Yan Associates uh to say keep us updated if there's a search that comes in and you know they put their state in uh they put where they'd like to look for a superintendency so as we do the initial filters and push out it's easy for us to push out and touch a thousand people or multiple thousand people very quickly uh well we know uh the work of superintendent as a result of our strategic planning equity
034and Executive coaching uh collaborative so you know hya is much more than a executive Search firm uh we do lots of other things that you know we can talk about at other times but but because we are deeply working in school system on multiple levels we meet con great people uh throughout the country uh as we're doing the work you know people who are on cabinet level uh and other uh positions our Associates lead Urban superintendent Academy such as myself and aspiring superintendent emies and our founding members of Alas and napsi and 130 practicing Associates experts in education with strong networks to candidates and we attend uh many state and national uh conferences you know hya excels at navigating the needs of the needed confidentiality uh to attract C top candidates uh in complex Dynamic
035political challenges and board Dynamics while promoting the strengths and capabilities of the districts and candidates again we work with some of the largest most complex districts in the country so so we understand complex you know you I guess you know in complex situations and and we uh I think candidates are are um eager to collect collaborate with us because we know we keep the confidentiality and nature of of the work um you know to to ourselves as we work to ensure that the board has a great shot in attracting and retaining a highquality uh candidate hi Associates have access to applicants from every search through a Frontline to assist with recruiting uh and uh we also create a candidate profile system uh with a dashboard we'll be able to give the board access to a
036dashboard uh that has all of the information that that guides you through the process so we give you a One-Stop shop electronically and we'll also give you a set of PDFs if you need that I know everybody doesn't like to get on there clicking you know so so for the old school folks we got something for you and if if you if you like to just have everything and be paperless we can we can meet your needs uh pretty seamlessly and then as it relates to transition uh we have a transition phase that's optional to guide uh the communication of your critical work together with your new superintendent and we definitely will support you in debriefing the superintendent search process and assist with transition uh we can mentor and support superintendents after placement U you
037know a perfect example when uh the search was done uh for the superintendent in the school district of Philadelphia three years ago you know they uh I worked directly with with uh Dr Tony watlington uh for his transition into the superintendency in the school district of Philadelphia and and worked with his 100 day plan his transition team uh working with the board uh establishing their strategic plan and and having kpis and and dashboards to communicate to the public clearly and effectively about performance and how you were move they were moving forward as they were going through so we have the capacity uh to support uh those efforts and and provide um you know Executive coaching not just for a superintendent but supporting the board's work and establishing the goals of the superintendent uh the board's
038goals the board's plan how's the board's plan aligned to the school improve the Strategic plan all of those details that can be uh important um we also take time to document what was learned during the search process hopefully you know this will be the last search process you'll have in a decade I mean that's that's the goal uh so you don't have a constant uh churn uh but we'll definitely communicate accountability uh to the board and the community and Define School quality based upon the prior priorities of the board and the community and uh we do give a dashboard for you for free for the first year uh why they do it for the first year because they want to try to charge you afterwards this full disclosure right by the first year they give
039it to you they'll populate it and and help you if you choose to use it or or or you want it for uh your District or your schools uh to help with transparency as we move forward so that's all I have this time and I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have yes go ahead miss good evening turn on my mic um I listened to everything you said I think it's very important that we include the parents throughout this that the parents are the ones that in in give us their children to educate yes and to keep safe and to go forward in their lives for their next level of Education a partnership with PTA would be most beneficial so I want to include that organization in our whatever rounds or the the
040inperson or whatever that they they need to be included because they're the ones that are the boots on the ground day to day with our p with our ptas and our parents yes ma'am I'm a former PT president so I said yes yes ma'am thank you thank you are there any additional question I'm Dr Joseph is just want to say I'm pleased to have you here thank you um and with Dr Lee when you got up and spoke I thought of the movie Waiting for Superman which was filmed right here in Montgomery part of it and one of my uh people at the state Dr Tony ther was in the movie and I didn't know him then and I couldn't I wanted to go up and meet him and say hey I saw the movie
041because that was like like my birthday present to myself and the day I met him I met him at a actually a party at the lake and he told the story about this kid that wanted to be a doctor and that's all and he said that's all I he goes I taught him biology and all this and he kept saying I want to grow up and be a doctor and I want to and all of a sudden Tony backer had these tears and it was the the the doctor that said I want to be a teacher and when I when you were talking I was like it's him I know it wasn't but the fact that you turned in the fact that you gave up um being a physician and to be a teacher um
042I don't know it's awesome and I and what I've heard about y'all what you've said the fact that you're going to work with us and I think you already have I I I'm not a part of this but from what I've heard there are people sitting on this board right now I've been I'm the oldest person on this board I've been meaning I've been here the longest and we've never we just listen and I feel like we've been rubber Stampers I feel like somebody comes in and says hey you know um this is what it is this is what the contract says y'all want it or you don't and and we just we go okay we want it and from what I've heard has happened in the just last couple weeks is y'all do negotiate
043you do hear us um I didn't under I honestly I do I do real estate as a side thing and negotiate that all the time I didn't ever think you could negotiate and when I heard that you have negotiated and how you negotiated and the fact that you want to bring parents and even the students in I feel safe with y'all I and I I just U and uh Dr Lei and I think from Southern Mississippi that's where my first first husband was from which is not a bad thing you know but he played football for Southern Miss so I I feel I feel at home with y'all so I really I really appreciate y'all being here I feel safe Miss Miss btis has I have one question excellent presentation uh I like Lisa I
044like the the part of the presentation where you told us what we're responsible for and and that's ownership but I do have one question I know in past searches um Community was asked for their feedback and but I'm not I never came away really understanding how the board and the committee would get the feedback when you when we invite people out and ask their feedback how would they how would you get that information back to us so two things we um provide a summary of each of the focus groups that are done uh so we'll say you know the focus grp group at TH Marshall Middle School 34 people there here were the themes that came and we can include that in the leadership profile uh as as part and then also as you go
045through uh you know you you get to the the phase where they're interviewing uh we can set up you know QR codes you know for example for people to be able to write feedback about how they think candidates are collect that information and then we can share that with the board so then the board can see the reactions to candidates as well as part of the deliberation okay Miss CLA has a question the Strategic plan is important for you to look at but to me another piece that's important is the curriculum audit that we went through that really is intent on what our purpose is for our children that's where we do everything uh for them to be able to excel in learning yes that I'd like to for you to have that piece also
046the curriculum audit yes and know anything that you give us you can share you can choose to include the curriculum audit as an addendum to the leadership profile so anybody who's seeking the position can also see here are things that are very important to us in addition thank we'll definitely look at it as well thank you additional questions or comments all right thank you so much thank you great presentation at this time um the board will consider for approval the hya associates contract the board chair will be making the recommendation so I am recommending that we approve H the hya contract for the superintendent search um is there a motion Madam chair I move approval of the hya contract as presented there it has been Motion in second uh all those in favor of approving
047the contract do so by showing of hands is unanimous all right our um before we adjourn I just want to make one announcement our next meeting date is January Tuesday January the 14th at 5:00 same location it will be a regular board meeting in this room followed by that immediately followed by that we'll have um our work session I think it should be flop flipflops but it'll be the work session no I'm right board meeting in work session sorry I had a little L of memory there um but at this time our meeting is now adjourned