CorpusRecord 269412

Special Called MPS Board Meeting 12-17-2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Montgomery Public Schools Alabama
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Montgomery County, AL
Material
Transcript
Extent
2,819 words · about 16 min
Collected
2026-07-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e at this time the Montgomery County Board of Education meeting is being special call meeting is being called to order today December 17 2024 at 5:00 p.m. um proper notice has been sent out in a timely manner and all board members have received the agenda for their review um at this time we do have a quum um we at this the next agenda item will be the approval of the agenda is there a motion on the floor to approve the agenda I move to approve the agenda is there a second I second it it has been moved and second is there discussion all those in favor of the of the approval of the agenda do so by the showing of hands it is unanimous at this time we'll receive as information the superintendent

002search um firm RFP proposals and I want board members to know that in this process you have been provided a list of the companies um that put in propos proposals we will vote on the company of our Choosing by showing of hands the company with majority votes will be selected to conduct the national superintendent search for the Montgomery County Board of Education if the votes are 331 for example the company with the least votes will be removed from the list and another vote will be taken again the company that receives majority vote will be selected to enter into contract with the with the ntion for the national superintendent search all right at this time I will call them by letter all those in favor of company a do so by showing of hands and the

003list is madam chair yes yeah do we not have an opportunity to discuss sure go go ahead I'm sorry okay we may I ask are we going to discuss by letter let's just go ahead and do the discussion um not not by letter but just go ahead and go into discussion there may some need to be some clarification on the process okay well of the ones that we're we're looking at right now um candidate C uh has the most affordable uh offering yes candidate B was very EXP expensive I know that we don't just look at the money we don't just look at the funds we you know the old saying you get what you pay for uh I I'm not certain that that's going to apply here because when we look at what is

004being offered by each of the firms then we see that the variance in pricing is to me quite uh expensive two of these were pretty comparable to each other um but when we look at the difference in pricing again and what they have to offer I still think that the most economical is going to be the best way out but that's not the main reason that I want to look at either I also looked at the Consultants that these firms had working with them um firm B has no Alabama or yes I'm not going to say Southern no Alabama ties and so we want to make certain that whoever is doing this search does understand what we're looking for when when it comes to understanding law Alabama Law specifically but we're also concerned about understanding

005our community and the needs of our community I I keep looking at your your list I have to understand the A's and the B's um A and C both had some Alabama ties uh which I thought was good both A and C had gender and ethnicity diversity I think that c had a wider uh diversity footprint but in addition to that burm C has a consultant who has a uh a more indepth experience and understanding I do believe of the culture the demographics the community there's just such a wide and deep knowledge base of who we are and what we might need uh and I think colleagues that we should definitely take those things into consideration as we make this selection thank you Miss Cloud um I'm looking at um see also it's almost like

006they're hacking on extra Financial strains they just don't have a set for what it's going to cost and they they also have um like it's almost as if it would be an attorney with billable hours they spend time they'll charge for phone calls uh and I looked at that and you're right sometimes when you see someone that's on there that might know it they may not have a fresh perspective because things have changed since they had been associated with us so with that being said I think it's there to have a fresh start and that's for that particular one c as far as uh a I really were not was not uh understanding exactly what they wanted to do I I didn't follow what they were saying very closely I mean I couldn't read but

007on B I like the fact that they talked about the board and District responsibilities I think that's so important is they they put it in bullets what we're supposed to be doing now theirs was expensive but it comes down to sometimes you have to pay for what you get and to make it worthwhile because I want this selection to be the very best we can get and that's why I'm leaning uh to discussing no I'm I'm leaning to the clarity of what they said I'm leaning to the clarity of what they said they spelled it out the school systems they represented that is like ours if you'll if you're concerned I I'm flipping back through on page uh that would be B on on the page where they compared the school systems that they have

008served on page 15 um the middle one in the the one in the middle is uh no the one at the top the one at the top is very comparable to ours and if you'll look at what the expenditures are it's very in line with what we've done before because I went and did the research last night till 1:00 in the morning um 25,000 children they serve them they that's the expenditures of that so it's really not that much more than what we've done in the past thank you madam chair I um I'm not certain about the the pricing I can go back and look it up but what I did remember reading was that the 28,000 I think the pricing are you talking about the pricing for which which letter c c had a

009maximum had a a maximum cap um which included the expenses for the Consultants uh I'm not certain where the the the price for that was 28,000 not to exceed that amount and the amount that they gave was like 25 so even if with the things that uh she said about phone calls and adding all of that it would not exceed that amount which was less than that was my understanding the other [Music] two I'm Lisa um Madam president miss Kyle let me get Lisa Madam president um after I looked at these I agreed that c is the most economical but I think you know when you look at what you if we if we listen to what uh Dr Coleman said you get what you pay for I noticed some of the material that they

010gave us seemed to be I can say it it just didn't it it wasn't it was kind of chopped I mean example page 11 where they have all the little paragraph things and the questions that they ask on there they're just they just need to some of it was just I needed to it was just so generic and and let's face it if you look at the leadership I I love I mean I actually love the leadership but part of their leadership is somebody that has done work for us before and served right here with us and I I want to move forward I mean I I want to move forward and it so I I just feel like C is the same o same o status quo um I really I thought the better

011of the two for me was a because it was just a step up it was you know it was a couple more thousand but when you look at what all you're getting with um B and I I I know uh Dr Coleman said something the only one that didn't deal with Alabama that that if you look at what they said here it says um Group C does not Place superintendent nor do we decide who the board interviews we recruit candidates that are a match with the district's leadership profile and that was very clear the candidates uh I would think when it goes out there that they'll there'll be a lot of Alabama uh candidates and that will be up to us to choose if we want to do Alabama but I do think you get

012what you pay for we don't I'm going to say this we don't mind giving raises and uh and and all these things not to teachers but to central office but we can't spend the money for our children I just have a problem with that and after Dr Keith we have Miss cloud and you Dr Coan okay thank you and then you okay thank you and also I meant to say this earlier the search team I have read books two by one of them and one by another one about superintendent and board relationships so they know they have an in-depth knowledge of what that means and and to help what looks for because the they helped me at the beginning when I was on the board understand a lot of what the interaction is and what

013needs to happen they're they know what to look for I I don't know them personally but their their work speaks for itself and it's just real funny that I've read without them you know without knowing this was going to be a firm that we would consider these two are very Dynamic researchers and they know what to do for the collaboration of the board and the superintendent I did say I do know that for a fact because I've got the books M excuse me Madam chair I'm not going to try to hog the discussion um one of my colleagues earlier um spoke about the Innovation uh as a part of the characteristics for the uh these Consultants we are not looking these are firms to go out and search we're not looking for these individuals who

014would be our Consultants to serve as our superintendent so um it it's not as if we are looking for someone to come in and do the job we're looking for them to come in communicate with our community uh develop a relationship with us develop a relationship with uh our our partners uh talk to our students talk to our parents talk to our teachers uh help get the information uh disseminate uh all of the uh information understand what the surveys are asking for and bring us as one of my other colleagues mentioned a a a Cadre a a list of people uh who would be the on serving as the superintendent and so you know please don't think that I was not aware that there might be some concerns about the familiarity with um one of

015the Consultants but I think that would be the gift if we went uh in that direction the gift would be someone who understands us enough to collaborate with us get the information and get it out and publicized you know I'm not lobbying necessarily for any firm I don't know anything um about those I did have two I think I Ruled one out uh but I had two that were very close and when I made that comment I knew you know I have been warned often that you don't just get the cheapest because it's the cheapest you get what you pay for but when you look at what we are trying to do to pay almost double for a search firm to just do the leg work to bring in candidates I think we are not

016being as um as safe with our District's money as we could be um I I want us to be responsible both A and C are in a Range where I think it just makes sense uh that kind of money we don't mind spending and the fact that testing much better thank you the fact that we did have uh at least two firms here that understand who we are in Alabama uh what we are looking for uh because as they get these in they will make some decisions and determination about who to bring to us and we don't want someone to bring us for four or five candidates and we not like any and we have to do the search all over again but miss clown thank thank you that's assuming a lot but that's okay

017I think what you're saying is that if you look at who's in these firms and look at their work then they know what they're doing and I think we're a different board I think we're a different C I think we're a different school system than we were three or four years ago we've moved forward so I want I like to see something fresh and different because when you've had some familiarity like you said you sometimes have a skewed Vision I want a brand new with the surveys they'll get what they want to see about us and have a clearer picture just like when we used the curriculum audit people um it was painful it but they showed us what we need to do and we've been striving to do those things so no we're not

018looking for them to be the superintendent but we're looking at their credentials to help us find the right one and you can have a predisposed even if you're away for three or four years you can still have a predisposed concept of what you think we know I want a fresh look to because we're different than we were three or four years ago and that's thank you Dr keyth I'm just one sentence the the you know I'm I don't feel like I have a a iron and the fire but you know we keep using the argument with Alabama one's one's Illinois one's Nebraska and uh the other one's Iowa so I'm I'm you know I'm baffled by how any of those would know Alabama I just got to put that out there is there any further

019discussion I want to say that um thank you I do hear I think we all hear each other which is good uh we hear the passion and we hear the wanting to have the best firm to do the search for one of the best for a good superintendent for such a time as this and um I hope the public hears the passion and you tell there was a lot of studying of the firms so that we can arrive to who we feel will be the best suited for the job that we need to be done so thank each of you board members for sharing your thoughts and um we go move into the voting if you all already um at this time if you are selecting um firm a if you would do so by

020show hands firm a all right firm B firm B farmacy all right thank you those votes have been recorded sorry at this time the board the majority of the board has selected firm C Hazard young adaah and Associates all right we'll move into receive as information um I will make the recommendation for the superintendent search firm but I'll confer to the lawyer to make sure that I'm in order when I do this I will make the recommendation for the search firm okay at this time is there a motion well I'm recommending um Hazard young aah and Associates is there a motion to appro to approve this this recommendation I make the motion to approve the um a y hya sorry Hazard I've already put my my thing up but H young and atina a aena

021I make the motion to accept the recommendation all right the recommendation Madam chair yes I'm sorry point of order I I'm not understanding we in the section for receivers information and even though we did carry I am so sorry thank you for pointing that out you're right okay I'm so sorry we're GNA move back I skipped over Mrs Erica thank you Brenda pow attorney Powell you're up next I kind of got ahead of myself thank y'all for being patient attorney pal good evening Madam chair board members um I'm presenting to you um to receive as information the law clerk position I've had conversations with with you um individually ually regarding this um the law clerk position is a a support staff position for the uh General counsil and pargal and uh the law clerk is

022generally a law student that uh may be getting uh credit for as an externship it is also um an hourly position it just depends on that particular student most law schools will not allow students to work Beyond 20 hours a week um and if it's an externship then the students do not work for pay they work for credit hours which is determined by their um law school um the position Duties are similar to The paralal it um includes and I'll just read some of it you all have the copy of the job announcement um the position would assist the general counsel in gathering information materials documents reports and evidence from various departments in response to employment and student action um in preparation for proceedings they will um prepare for meetings and hearings mediations arbitrations any

023type of legal proceedings and work with general counsel in communicating and working with outside Council for any legal issues or matters that may arise within the district um this position as I mentioned is for a law student who is generally a second or third year student most law schools will not allow the first year students to um um who have a job unless they are in like the part-time law school or part-time law program but generally um second or third year law students are allowed to work at up to 20 hours per week um the D the duties of this position would also include um answering and returning phone calls voicemails things of that nature and um it would require that the law student had as proficient Le legal research and writing thank you thank

024you attorney BR um is there are there any questions Dr key Madam president so so point of clarification you do have a paralal or this is serving as your paralal so technically no I do not have a paralal the paralal job announcement um was posted maybe about 32 days ago um there were some te technical difficulties as far as the job posting being discoverable online so there have not been any um application submissions as of yet uh so this particular role uh would be in addition to the paralal and and the pet there's not pay it's just that she's getting or he or she would be getting a college hours for for an externship so um based off of the legal budget there the it could potentially be a um a pay position uh which

025would be be part-time and temporary so it's usually a semester but some students um will do it as an externship kind of like an internship and so in that instance it would not be paid all right the superintendent will do the uh consider for approval thank you Madame President up for consider for approval superintendent search firm RFP ISC h h y b it is Hazard young Adia and Associate h y the superintendent has made a recommendation um is there a motion to accept the recommendation sorry did she recommend hya I didn't okay then I then I um make the recommendation to accept it You Move Motion I'm sorry make the motion to accept it all right it has been moved I mean I'm sorry there's a motion is there a second a second it has

026been moved and second is there any discussion hearing none um if you are in favor um of h y AA do so by a showing of hand well because all right it was I didn't could you show your hands one more time I'm sorry I have to count on all right five one all right our next order of business super it will go back to inter superintendent Wilson Madame President up for consider for approval I recommend law Kirk job announcement all right the superintendent has made a recommendation is there a motion to accept this recommendation Madame President I motion that we accept the recommendation of the superintendent is there a second I second it it has been moved and second is there any discussion heing none are we ready for the vote if so do

027so by showing the hands if you are in favor of the superintendent's recommendation all right it looks unanimous all right the next order of agenda will be um brought To Us by the interim superintendent yes under consider for approval I recommend Personnel report classified Personnel superintendent has made a recommendation is there a motion to accept the recommendation Madam chair I move that we accept the superintendent's recommendation for approval of personnel report classified Personnel is there a second I second it it has been moved in second if you are in favor of the superintendent's recommendation do so by a showing of hands it's unanimous all right Madam president I'm sorry I know what you meant thank you madam superintendent um Madam president under consider for approval I recommend Personnel report classified Personnel addendum uh the superintendent

028has made a recommendation is there a motion to accept the recommendation mam president I make a motion to accept the superintendent's recommendation is there a second I second it it has been moved in second all those in favor of the superintendent's recommend do so by a showing of hands it is unanimous all right at this meeting is now adjourned thank you our next meeting date is Tuesday January 14th for the regular board meeting and Tuesday January 14th immediately following that board meeting will be the board's work session thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.