001okay we'll call the speak to order we'll start with Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the plag of the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible withy and jusice forast I know I'm Church okay roll call let that reflect that we are missing Caroline nto and Kim Seno all else present next is approval of the consent agenda which was provided in your packet everybody could review or move to approve I move to approve the consent meeting thank you support and we have support any questions errors admissions anybody catch anything hearing none we'll bring it to a vote all those in favor please say I I I any opposed okay that carries time for public comments Clayton anything today no no nothing okay committee reports uh
002finance committee just got out of finance committee uh we um reviewed some of the budget amendment numbers which Mark will be presenting a little later in this meeting uh as well as um new cafeteria tables which we hopefully will be approving later in the the packet you'll see that that's coming out of the Food Service budget we reviewed AP general f fund Capital Improvements Bond Capital Improvements and the bond spending right now is a little bit in a l just because we're starting to ramp up from the end of the year last year into I think next month we'll start see a little more action on that so all looks good and thank you very much anybody have any questions okay academic Affairs committee um academic Affairs met and we got um some update on
003policies that are going to be updated to bring um our our policies more in line with mhsaa um especially with the middle school and just um holding our students our student athletes to high academic standards um and so just that language got a little bit cleared up um we got an update from uh John Allen on the elementary special education program um you'll remember that um we approved the hiring of Joe Mets an additional um special education teacher who is running a intensive resource room and that has really U Been a positive impact on the um rest of the staff um and students um especially um so those are the big things we also talked about potential um changes to the calendar the next year um and early release versus half day or full day
004um so have some more fund to come okay thank you very much uh next is Personnel committee I the only one there yeah there were others there but uh they're not here tonight superintend contract yep that's uh both of which are in our uh um agenda for later on but uh with regard to the superintendent contract no real changes but we are reformatting and giving it into the new osss or office of Retirement Services regulations to apply with what they want to see so um and then the superintendent evaluation we just want to take some action on that to officially uh Define how that's going to work going forward with the new state laws and regulations and uh we even talked about there's some push back at the state level and that might change at
005some point in the future so that was that meeting did I cover everything and no student representative tonight we tried I get it yep good thing that is but we still love hearing from them so let's keep trying we'll keep try um okay we'll move on to do business uh item 64 s approval of the cafeteria table purchase Mark or Kurt you want to give the sure in your packet you've got the um after B process the recommendation for the tables um finance committee talked about them uh right before this meeting as Ben said and they they will be uh logoed tables with Norse has kind of matching with the theme of where we're going um with things in the cafeteria so pretty looking and um those are paid for with uh Food Service funds
006I need to purchase to approve the purchase of the cafeteria tables okay motion and seconded any questions hearing none I'll bring it to a vote all those in favor please say I I I any oppos say nay okay that carries item 648 what we're all looking forward to a budget amendment and Mark has a presentation for us give me clicker and some time so I am just talking about general fund today you know there's you guys have a resolution for the special revenues I'm just going to focus all my time on the general fund perfect so you know the general fund Revenue as we talked here's the original budget that you guys prep passed here's what's in the proposed amended we're going to add about $413,000 Revenue it's ironic when I put search piggy bank
007this is what actually popped up um which I don't think we really want to know sorry you know we really don't want to know about the the mask of 2020 um as you can kind of see so we're at $12.9 million which even when I started in 2020 it was a lot more than what we had it's almost a million dollars less than what we actually had in the fy2 24 when you audited uh that's a 7% reduction so oh see the piggy the co piggy bank is gone um so changes in Revenue to kind of make up that updated property values so again we increased $79,000 in property values uh so that's what the state's thinking we're going to get from the town or the city however that's $79,000 reduction in people accounting right
008so it's that's what prop a kind of really runs into interest Revenue Justin Chris are doing a great job so $40,000 more in the general fund for interest act 18 I'm guessing with some of the new changes in the ACT 18 it's um it's the special ed millage from the ISD it brings in like 16 million dollar but the formula is 70% special ed excess cost 30% % or and then the other 30% is based on enrollment my guess is we're actually going to lose money because our excess cost for special ed is lower is increasing at a lesser rate than other districts which is a good thing but you're going to get less reimbursement based on the countywide formula and then all the federal and state grants to match their expenses so we got
009title four which that's where Sue and Julia are coming up which 31n 23g 97j 35j there's a 35m coming out so like I put it's like that math problem that no one really understands at some point we got to understand it and this is kind of it it all melts together um Jess and I think we have it all right but you know throughout the year we might have to move uh expenses one way or the other uh state revenue this is kind of the big so our pupil accounting was somehow um the I say the good news with this is they have a category called stabilization so by us decreasing our account we get some money back in a stabilization so we got $669,000 now we lost 319,000 but of that we got 69,000
010bucks back so it's better than stick in the eye uh special ed so they keep updating the formulas um also we spent more last year which is a law we have maintenance of equity maintenance of effort you always got to spend more dollars the previous year than the previous so 51c we got about $40,000 that includes a prior year adjustment I did not expect them to bring back 22l which is a transportation reimbursement so we get an offset $28,000 of a transportation the difference is normally you get reimburse every year for special ed Transportation which we don't have it's a dedicated special ed transportation bus so we can move $28,000 of spe a regular Ed Transportation but now they're starting to reimburse us on the regular Ed so last year when we did it we
011bought vehicles from them right so that's stuff that we don't get reimbursed so we're trying to figure out what's the best way to allocate it at a great where it doesn't hurt us in the reimbursement down the road um and then the fund ORS which is the pension reimbursement changes so when I started there was none of these 147 and now there's I think I mean they're in the F but I some of these got canceled already so 147 A1 and two remain stable those are offsets of the 20% reimbursement uh for that 147a is a new one so we're going to gain $338,000 they say it's a ORS offset um I put a question mark it doesn't really look like a question mark but it's supposed to be a question mark because they the
012state couldn't get their poop in a group so they decided you know what we're going to give you a revenue and then next year we're going to reduce the expense and the revenue because you know it's just easier being counters just love to make it complicated but in reality that 5.75% and what we're getting in Revenue doesn't equate to the reduction of how much if we really took it just right off of our pension rate 147c that's the offset to the DC component of the pension plus phf employees it's paid quarterly that's remaining stable but 147f which is the DC component of the well I don't even know DC component of the DC employees h f you know the premium subsidy place that got eliminated so it's like I'd say let's use I was trying
013to find a parking lot in the winter but that just makes it too logical it's like this people just park wherever they want to or S6 still six the same I just we'll just put it everywhere you guys will figure it out right and it's it's very easy to explain glad see look at that I got Kirk to laugh uh oh uh general fund expenses so we're going to increase 555,000 part of that 200,000 of that is the title four employees that we have for two years for Grant so some of it is misleading in terms of it's just budget how I will say this so if you remember back in the revenue we decreased by 900,000 we we our expenses didn't what that does show is we did really spend well on the co
014we didn't add long-term costs it's just some of this is because if you look at the salary 169,000 benefits a lot of that is those before employees and then just the non-payroll it's they're just normal expenses um here's kind of a difference so the purple is everything not salary and benefits wise So 20% is non people is what I put so the other 80% is people which is normal 75 to 80% if you get a live there and then you take all that 20% Then next like I kind of broke it down how the buckets that I look at right the big bucket that's not people or operations which doesn't shock you cleaning services contracted Services um fixing the HVAC fixing all of that other stuff and then you have the other one big state
015Grant 3% that's never been that big for North mosan the big difference is John Allen got a grant one of the state grants is 35j it's curriculum Improvement expenses so textbooks for a reading so that's over $100,000 of a grant that we were going to have to do at some point we got hopefully for free and we're going to be able to have our staff trained in that and it's all covered so once that Grant falls off that number will shrink and obviously these other numbers will grow so it's just kind of a way to look at it just remember when we talk about what's going to happen next 80% of most School budgets are people or Insurance see so if you really think all that 12 million only $2.7 million is non people so
016like if there are when when Curt and I when there like we could save 15,000 here yep when you're talking bigger numbers you can only cut so much of this right unless you want to cut cleaning services for a big number if you want to cut like some of the other things changes expense who Staffing like kind Staffing is all updated the N contract got approved last one uh only steps and a $400 off off schedule for employees that did not receive a financial increase increases and health insurance cost there's more to come about that Grant spending as a kind of what I alluded to athletic non-revenue so again I always chck when we get really good at athle Athletics we spend more right because travel um normal annual budget changes we have over 2,000
017accounts in expenses you just update them through overview so again kind of starting so the difference between our starting balance and the original we came in better based on our audit right so our audit was a $500,000 increase our ending fund balance even with that we're still at that 11.79% we always said we're going to ride this Co roller coaster we at one point we don't fall off of it like that one joke that I made that Steve did not think it was funny um but we're still at this 11.79% is more analytical um here's our enrollment enrollment is always a driver so as you can see uh at 9:44 I take out the uh White Lake community aded and the no I leave the White Lake Community aded I take the um newera Christian
018uh shared service so I kind of put that in there um I try to like this is what I think Kurt like the 950 you shall not pass like you got to keep above the 950 like Kurt that's what I kind of picture like that's what you see me I just like you shall not pass like you shall not pass under 950 keep it at 950 right if I could grow a beard like that I think we should try I you should try um okay why is there's a okay so here's another kind of what I took was our highest for our our high school average class size in high school is 76 kids so in the next four years we're GNA have those fall off and if I take DK is kind of why
019I just because they just double up into it K1 two and three average is almost 60 so there's just the nature of how we go there's 16 kid loss every every year for the next four years so again it's just the enrollment driver which by this we all know to keep it school choice becomes more important so as you can see so the green we uh stopped using munetrix which I could always get the losses right I didn't got have time there there's um there's another place you can get I just didn't have so the green kind of stopped where I have it as you can see we're normally around 90 kid lost in school choice as you can see the yellow is all the gains so we chrisy up pulled some stuff so this
020year we're at 40 465 FTE wise of gains and like I told the finance we just hit over 50% of our K12 kids our school choice which 10 years ago we were at 36% so again it just shows shows that school choice when when our catchment I think that's the next slide actually yeah look at that again so this is actually a document that I had um back in 2023 it really kind of shows the catchman area I don't know why that Resident number in 2023 but that number is 610 I believe that's how many kids that are counted by a K12 public entity so if you're homeschooled and you're not counted I can't we don't have any data on that right so if as long as they're going to some sort of school that
021is funded by the state we show a gain or a loss right so if you know how many are right so as you can see our catchment is going down right at the highest 734 kids in 2018 lived in our boundaries now I think we're in 2023 so two Falls ago we were at 610 so that that catchment is starting and I remember when I started in Co was 2020 and we Dro that next year and we all thought it was Co right it could be part of Co it's also our catchment dropped almost 50 kids and we're really good at keeping the kids in our catchment to come to here right so it's always great we're at 90 some percent that actually come here so our bread and butter is our catchment and our
022catchment is shrinking so inherently in order to keep everything school choice has to grow Special Ed I always put man these grafts do not like to show up um special aded so this is kind of a sheet that I show it's more of comp pairing right it's it's the lack not to say that we are overspending special ed it's more of the inequity from skeg County to other counties in terms of special ed funding so the blue box on the top is the non Transportation cost that the general fund pays for for mandated special ed services again I'm not saying that special ed is overspending but the general fund in the budget for 2025 The General fund is going to be paying $93,000 of mandated special ed services and counties to our South like Ottawa
023county is almost fully funded so a district Like Us in Ottawa County we'd be paying zero dollars almost meaning that' be $93,000 93,000 that we would be able to spend on other services or AK to wipe out the deficit so it's just kind of looking at it that's why sometimes it's not as easy to play Apples and orange or to compare apples to apples when you're talking about other schools outside the counties because special is a big driver in in equities looking ahead so the General Revenue com uh conference just came out here's kind of so the big news is we have uh projected 550 almost a half billion dollars of ongoing Revenue that the state now can figure out what they're going to spend it on hopefully it all comes to us right so
024if I take the just a simple the ongoing of of f a half a billion dollar of at the balance sheet at the end of the year divide that by the number of kids that they're counting effective next year it's a 3 $43 per pupil increase that'd be awesome right that'd be a $381,000 assuming that our enrollment stays the same and assuming none of that uh the not onetime money so the three almost a third of a billion dollars doesn't come to us however there's always a catch right like there's always a catch um the couple lame duck bills that didn't pass there's always some of stuff that might come p12 so the amount of money that the employer pays on the behalf of the employee for health insurance it only went up 0.2% but
025the rates all went up seven eight %. right so the employees are bearing a lot more cost of the of that there was a bill that died it's still dead right now from the governor's side that would increase that cost to us decrease the cost to employee that could come back if they want to give us hey we're going to give you all this extra money but hey by the way you're going have to pay another $100,000 of cost or I'm still thinking or still has to figure this out they're always they always lag behind more and more people are retiring not enough people are coming back to fill those roles that's why they have all these laws about retirements coming back you know that's why it's always great they're going to make superintendent and
026other non-affiliate people paying in the butts for their salary contracts just to force them to retire basically but there's no one to fill their holes so the less people that means less people are paying in which they're going to start to create ORS problem which then inherently they're going to increase the ORS rate which AKA cost the entire District more money any questions I know I bring so good news today it's like a dream kill I should I try put like Darth Vader like a dream killer or something but any questions more of a comment Mark and and you touched on it but I just want to reiterate it it when we started to get the CO funds we talked about that roller coaster that was for us and that's where we're that's where we're
027coming out of now and and the reality is that we we wanted to try to end the roller coaster ride fairly close to where we started it and that's what we've done the thing that that the other reality that's hitting us though is we obviously can't continue negative $400,000 very long so as we look at next year's budget um we're going to have to look at everything and um we can't can't continue to live the way we're living right now with with those funds being gone so um while we did what we tried to do and I I feel really good about that um now comes some tougher decisions as some grants go away and and the dollars with them so more to come on that but that was kind of a we did what
028we wanted to but there's still some work to do kind of a comment and to these guys we're not the only disrespect most if not all districts around are running deficits it's it's the co money for four years that we got and all some people had great plans some people didn't have great plans I like I agree with I think we had a great plan we're riding that roller coaster but it's not like we're the only District that's running into issues some have already started laying off this year because they locked people they locked the dollars and the people they obviously can't that anymore yeah many more conversations without next year's budget C I have a question so we're we're losing 16 a year so we're coming up coming up we lost more than that
029previously so we're actually fighting with a birth rate that's smaller so we're actually cannibalizing other school districts or okay school choice kids come exactly school choice kids come from somewhere else yes um the reality is that there's less um kids in the boundaries of North mosan Public Schools um so if we're going to maintain a similar enrollment that has to come from either School of Choice or we can make other decisions and you know one of the slides showed a class or a cohort you know around you know the 55 number or so well that makes it really hard because we can't really do two you could do two classes but they'd be bigger classes so it forces us to look at the potential of teacher well we can't do that very often without crushing
030our budget because the revenue is not there to help it so um when we talk about school of choice being a bigger factor for us part of that's going to be there might be classes where we don't take in kids because we're at a number that we don't want to go five more because then it puts us in you know we might have 50 simple example we have 50 well we might not want to take any school choice kids in that one because if we take you know say five or six now we're in that might need a third teacher thing which is is a a cost problem so yeah I think we're in a school district though that people School of Choice they want to come here because of because of the education get
031at norn spe yes y y we got a good problem our okay um my only commentary is I'm never real pleased to be approving big deficit budget than we already approved but uh it is the reality of the situation currently um and so yeah like Kurt said we've got to start asking some tougher and tougher questions about going forward how we eliminate any deficit spending in the future so so with that said uh I will entertain a motion to approve the amended budget to approve the amended budget as support okay motion second any further questions for Mark Finance hearing none all those in favor please say I I can anybody oppose please say name okay budget is ratified all right superintendent contract Amendment um yeah I mean I kind of touched on it earlier and
032everybody's seen it um it's it's a Bas it's it's not basically it's my old contract reformatted um to hopefully align better with the new ORS guidance um the numbers are the same it's formed differently um and uh it's still you know sits uh on our web page so when this is adjusted this will go on page it's public information it's the same thing just reformat it and then I'll touch on the next topic which is the evaluation um you guys have all seen that we just never took action on it and that really it's superintendent evaluation impacts all of us because of the new process um and so it it moves that um training and everything else to next to next school year not that we're not evaluating me this year it's just not the
033formal state state required process um I'll make comment when we get there on that also um but let's take uh approval of the uh super tendent contract amendment I move that we approve the superintendent contract Amendment as presented okay um do we have to uh amend every budget individually I've always been usually do the general f School Rue I won't do all of them us okay let's uh let's back up to item 648 will motion all budget amendments as presented okay we have motion at second this is a roll call vote start with Lisa yes yes yes yes okay motion carries okay thank you for clarifying that and US keeping to Robert's Rules or whoever whoever decides we have to roll call all right back to uh approval of the superintendent contract Amendment we'll start
034over I need a motion on that I Mo that we approve the superintendent contract Amendment as presented okay we have a motion in a second any questions all those in favor please say I I any opposed please say nay motion carries all right the only other thing I want to add everybody has it in their packet about the superintendent evaluation process two things Kurt just pointed out we will still still be doing something it just won't be to the state standards because we because of his previous two uh evaluations we are allowed to skip their requirements this year one of those requirements are that we all get trained and this is the goofiest thing simultaneously by a um what is it called a Raider a rider reliability training um and so what we suggested in
035one of our committee meetings is we're going to see if maybe we could get a person to come to the bo Retreat for an hour and knock it out at the board retreat this summer so but that being said we still need to take the action that is in your packet so anything further um no it's it's the same document just updated um you were you received it via email um back several months ago and then the updated version recently it just it says exactly what Steve just said for following the law because of my previous evaluations and doing our own thing this year and then back on track with the state's requirements next year which allows us the time to get everybody trained and me all those requirements okay take a motion I move
036to approve the superu pick one and one okay any further questions okay all those in favor uh please say I I any oppos say name okay that is all Now we move to board comments start with Lisa okay and then this Lisa not going Weir I lose too much so no um thank you Mark for the um great presentation um I mean indepth presentation is not great information but you know you know yes U uh for breaking that down uh for us and being so Vigilant um I also want to thank the and acknowledge um the math night that happened at the elementary um uh you know the the staff and um parents just such a had such a great evening I stopped by and walked through each grade level and the teachers had really
037fun math it was just such a festive atmosphere um it reminded me of like the carnival nights um that the PTO put on and the kids were in each grade in DK through fifth grade playing games with their parents and parents were asking questions it was great in the second grade room um the parents were like having a math lesson and learn so much and just so engaged and it was really great to see youself thanks to um you know everybody that participated um I don't have much thank you Mark you did an all right job I guess I know um gotta keep you down yeah uh and speaking as someone who has already gone through the rider reliability training boy are you in for a treat this summer gang good there can't wait to
038do that again um that's it I hope everyone's having a good year um nothing more other than thank you Mark and um staff for pulling together that budget amendment and hopefully the next one will be Surplus budgeting and uh then we can have more laughs and Giggles in those presentations but I will try my best yes thank you for all you do too that's it yeah it's always a pleasure to hear uh the finance team the business management team explain manua behind the numbers but know that was uh well done well presented I feel confident the board member that we're getting you know the information and the transparency that we in the public should have um and just you know on the bright side we still have a bond that we have a lot of
039money in that will be spent aggressively so that's uh and that's all to the for the school right so I'm looking forward to those continued improvements coming down the plate speak I'd like to remind everybody that we're norsman and we can and will survive absolutely stole a little my thunder I uh I I actually have spoken plenty tonight so all I was gonna say is even with a rough budget presentation and some T decisions that are going to come up a great day to be nor thank you everybody meeting adur thank you everybody