001welcome welcome to the meeting everyone welcome welcome to our meeting need somebody to whistle there we go thank you Richard Welcome to our meeting we're glad to see so many people here and are excited to have conversations with some of you and uh hear about the great teaching happening in our district and do some business tonight uh it is Thursday the 19th of December we are meeting in the boardroom on Legacy campus and we will begin with a roll call beginning with Jared Jared black business administrator Jeff neelson board member corer board member Kathy christansen board member Terry rhods board member Roger puls for board member Todd mcke superintendent Brian Chambers board member Randall Bagley board member students do you have students here all right thank you all for being here um I will lead
002us in the pledge would you all please rise IED alce to the of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible for all our mission is to educate students for success in a changing world and now we will begin with our the first section of our agenda which is recognitions and we love this part of our agenda it's so fun we will start with teacher of the year recognitions um and first up we will have Stacy Pew presented by principle D DS from Greenville Elementary [Applause] I'm so honored for this awesome opportunity to do you use a microphone please grab the microphone right over [Music] there all right so I just want to recognize Stacy for the amazing uh things that she does for us at
003Greenville and as I was thinking about what to say um a poem came to mind and I'm just going to read it because I think what um this poem talks about embodies a lot of what Stacy's philosophy is on educating our kids um it's called thus a child learns by wiggling skills through his fingers and his toes into himself by soaking up habits and attitudes of those around him by pushing and pulling his own world and thus a child learns through affection and through love through patience through understanding through belonging through doing and through being day by day the child comes to know a little bit of what you know a little bit more of what you think and understand that which you dream and believe are in truth what is becoming that child as
004you perceive doly or clearly as you think fuzzily or sharply as you believe foolishly or wisely as you dream drably or goly as you bear false witness or tell the truth thus a child learns and I can honestly say that Stacy is that teacher that brings out the very best in our students she is amazing she brings every single day like it's a new day um and treats those kids with the most compassion of scene so Stacy thank you for the amazing job that you do and being such a wonderful teacher and role model to our kids thank you [Applause] get in there [Laughter] D congratulations Stacy thank you for teaching in our district next up we [Applause] have next up we have Jill Hall from bur Creek Elementary who will be presented by principal
005Trudy Wilson [Applause] all right um it is just an amazing opportunity to recognize Jill Hall as Birch Creek's teacher of the year Jill graduated from Utah State University with her Bachelor's in elementary education and before she became a full-time teacher she was a reading aid at sunrise for 12 years she's been a second grade teacher at Birch Creek for eight and she's supported there by her husband her four wonderful children and I'm supposed to say her five amazing grandchildren there's so many things I think of when I think of Jill the biggest thing is she does not like the spotlight and so this is probably complete torture right now with everyone looking at her she goes about her day just silently quietly um her head's down she's doing her work and she loves her kids
006and they love her um teachers and students have said so many wonderful things about her Jill deeply cares about her students she's professional and positive bringing a steady personality that Fosters a sense of calmness to her classroom Jill deserves this award because she puts her students first day in and day out you'll often see parents dropping students off before school or picking them up late because Jill's spending that extra time working with them I had a fun time talking to her kids in the cafeteria today and the common theme was she's really nice she's really patient she's really smart um she gives us fake money she dances around the classroom I want to see that one because I haven't seen that part of Jill yet and several just said she's the best teacher ever so
007it's my complete privilege to celebrate Jill Hall as Birch Creek's teacher of the year congratulations [Applause] congratulations Jill thank you for being part of our team next we have Erica Lyford who teaches at Cedar Ridge Elementary and her award will be presented by principal Amy ivy [Applause] it just keeps disappearing on us wow what a privilege it is to know Erica Linford so and what an honor it is to see so many colleagues here from our school supporting her it's so so awesome so Erica Lyford not only is a nationally board certified teacher but she's a great example to our staff and has been a mentor to many over the years she works her tail off to be the amazing teacher that she is Erica is a teacher who manages her classroom well she wants
008her students to succeed she keeps them on task she's organized with her time and her teaching techniques and she ensures that learning is taking place at all times her students are respectful and walking down the hall her fourth grade team recognizes her as a person who's willing to share and solve problems and someone who has an uncanny ability to make light out of any situation with their students Erica is an example to all that continuous learning is a must she's dedicated to the PLC process and keeps her peers as well as herself accountable she has helped her it's true quit laughing she's I know they're all right here it is kind of really uncomfortable that you're all this close not going to lie okay she's helped her Team Deep dive into the standards and curriculum
009and finds the most vital things that need to be taught she uses data to drive what she teaches is Erica has great Insight she's worked with students in every demographic and when I asked her to try dual language immersion she jumped at the opportunity she um wondered why I'd left her in the SP the same spot for so long she wasn't used to that in other districts she's a great example of being a standards driven um student-driven and highly capable educator so here's a quote I found from Rita Pearson and this describes Erica to a te every child deserves a champion an adult who will never give up on them who understands the power of connection and insists that they become the best they can possibly be please join with cedaridge in celebrating Erica Lyford
0102024 2025 teacher of the year [Applause] thanks Erica we appreciate your work uh last up we have uh Dolores Cortez from Canyon Elementary and her award will be presented by principal lesie Bert [Applause] is it on oh give me a mic all right first of all I want to thank all of our amazing Canyon crew that are here to help support Dolores Dolores is raise your hand if you're here to to give show your support yay Dolores is sort of like a ninja she's everywhere and anywhere in the school and you can find her helping in all those amazing places so I just wanted to share a few words that have been shared with me that truly describe her advocate Caring Heart dedicated genuine a professional team player phenomenal heart and soul amazing was in
011there multiple times and constant and to help and to love Dolores is a phenomenal teacher she is our um special education teacher and she truly does put her heart and soul into these students and she goes in above and beyond and is constantly thinking about each and every student and what they need she's respectful she communicates great with parents with staff with all of those that need that and she's a great advocate for these kids and you see people are drawn to her the littles love her everyone loves her and we are so lucky to have her at Canyon Elementary and in cash district and I absolutely wholeheartedly am pleased to recognize her as our Canyon Elementary teacher of the [Applause] year you don't have to say anything anything you L out thank you Dolores
012I love that you had your son in there because um that's what we're all about right um next up we get to recognize another teacher in our district who has recertified with national board certification and Britney Foster will present Rachel kenning who has finished her [Applause] recertification I'm really excited to recognize Rachel today um I didn't know a lot about national board certification and um I've learned a whole lot about it and Rachel has been instrumental in my learning about it if you're not familiar with it it I have a little bit of notes so I don't forget it's the highest professional certification available to teachers in the United States it represents a commitment to Excellence in teaching and lifelong learning it's a rigorous process and it requires Educators to demonstrate Advanced knowledge effective teaching
013practices and a dedication to improving student outcomes and it really shows the expertise of teachers it signifies about 300 hours initially and then I don't know probably 150 to recertify every 5 years what you say yeah um so she's certified 5 years ago and then every 5 years you have to recertify so she's just recently recertified just signifying what an expert teacher she is and we're so lucky to have her in our district so I wanted to congratulate Rachel [Applause] thank you Rachel for teaching in our district and working so well that is the end of our recognition portion of the agenda can we have everyone who's here supporting one of these teachers please stand [Applause] thank you all for being here um if you want to stay for the business portion of our meeting
014you are welcome to if you want to escape this is the moment to do that it's one page at least that's true oh that's cool no one on um no one for Teacher marit really not one did you think there would be I heard that would be oh really one where or the other so you you must have done a good listening tour because and everybody felt listen to because we're try we're trying this right can I lock off a hunk hunk for hunk yeah right okay moving on in our agenda we get to hear a school report from Ridgeline high school and we appreciate all of the school administrators who come and give us these reports because we learned so much about our Great Schools uh this tonight we get to hear from Ridgeline
015High School uh principal bat [Laughter] Bagley don't know whether to hold it or let it sit there like I said is that coming up technology [Applause] okay there we go um I I have the privilege of being the principal at Ridgeline High School this is my second year there just blank again um so uh this year's going a lot better than last year um I've learned a lot and so it takes a little bit to get in the groove of things so just wanted to show a little bit about us um uh there's we currently have 18894 students as of a couple days ago um oddly enough we have 948 males and 948 F females it doesn't I put that in there because I don't think it gets that close to 50/50 very often so
016if we can get rid of three boys we'll be even so um we have 147 faculty and staff 80 teachers six counselors one mental health counselor 20 custodians and sweepers five kitchen staff seven secretaries and 25 AIDS so there is a lot of just adults in our building which is great um starting last year uh it seems like uh we we kind of went through a little bit of an identity crisis I guess to some extent we wanted to really kind of bore down and find out what our core values were as a school what do we want kids to walk away with when they leave our school what do they want us to say about us um years down the road and we came up with a few words growth was a very big
017word that all of our we did this with our faculty and some students but mostly with the faculty growth was a big word that um all of our faculty was um very interested that we grow that we're different um from the time we start a class period to the end of that class period um the end of a day and at the end of the trimester and then certainly at the end of their um tenure at ridgel line so we we wanted to to show growth all the time and then the three places or the three ways we wanted to show it through was through Community resilience and then Integrity um and I think they kind of speak for themselves we had a lot of different words um thrown around and gone through and and
018we feel like all of those descriptors fit under one of those um areas and then kind of unintentionally the CR in the I um spell cry and we've kind of adopted that as our riverhawk cry this is what um we want to integrate in everything we do um as we've started um the process of integrating it we found out certainly as administrators I've talked with my assistants as we meet with with students in our office for various reasons we find out that even in discipline and other things it's either a community problem or we're talking to them about being resilient or maybe they've had an Integrity problem or we talk about ways they can show their integrity better um and it just really covers pretty much all the facets of being a student so um
019we've worked really hard on this and we want to keep um integrating this into everything we do and also use this as a basis for all the decisions that we make um whatever decision we make we want it to fall under one of these one of these areas um here we go in the classroom uh our big focus in the with with teachers we've kind of just taken really one focus and that's on teacher Clarity um we want to post and talk about every lesson every day that we do um three things learning intention which is the what what is students going to learn today the relevance why are they going to learn it and then the success criteria of how will we know when they've learned it and um so we're working really hard
020um doing um trainings and revisiting this all the time we talk about it a lot and different ways to do it um giving teachers some autonomy to do it in their way but finding ways to post this every day talk about it repeatedly throughout the lesson so that um we've found and research shows that being very clear about what we want learned is one of the most impactful things we can do during lessons so this is one of the things we're really focusing on for Teacher clarity um another thing that we we looked at and have struggled with a little bit are are um also research shows us that anytime we transition from one school to another it's always kind of rough on kids and we have an increase in depression and anxiety and grades
021seem to drop we have a lot of those problems so we wanted to be proactive and make sure that we address some of those things this last year one of the things we instituted was riverhawk Academy it's kind of a social em emotional curriculum that we teach we use um some uh graphic Rich um uh lessons what we call habitudes other schools are using this curriculum as well so we've adopted it from Sky View and Green Canyon are doing the same thing and have been for a while so we've adapted this into our um classroom all of our freshmen go through this program through this class uh one of the best things is we we choose two upper class mentors in each class and to be honest that's one of the unforeseen benefits we have
022about 30 mentors that just really took this and ran with it they U students that maybe haven't had a chance to lead or do things um really overtly but they had a chance to do it in class and to teach lessons and to be examples and to create connections with these students and so um we feel like it's made a big impact on what our freshmen have done uh this this isn't necessarily data that that proves that the the our freshman transition is working but just some data that we looked at I compared the first trimester grades over the last four years so the dark blue is 2021 all the way to the lightest green which is this last this last first trimester so just as you look we've in 2024 all of our each
023one of our classes our 9th through 12th graders we've reduced the failing grades and we've also reduced the number of failing students so some of those students have multiple failing grades for our ninth graders for example last year we had 64 students that had 106 FS first trimester this year we had 30 3 students that had 64 FS so we almost cut a lot of that in half um like I say there's not it's hard to draw a cause and effect but I think our freshman transition class where we talked about grades Student Success how to be successful how to talk to teachers how to do all of those things and plan and study made a big impact on that so that's just a little bit of data um showing um to the challenges of
024Ridgeline it's a challenge but it's also a great thing one of the things is our size um we are the biggest high school in the valley um by several hundred students which has its benefits um in some ways there's some programs and some classes that we can offer because we have enough students that have interest in those things so we can do them we have a uh a pilot and anory Pilot Course that we teach and some things like that I think the other schools can't just quite get enough kids interested in doing so there's definitely some some pluses to that but currently right now our our facilities are pretty maxed out in PE weit room our weight room is used every hour of the day by athletes and classes our lunchroom our gyms um
025just really full all the time it's it takes a lot of work and planning to get everyone where they need to be parking is a big issue um we have about 600 student parking stalls for 1900 students we have a little over 800 students just in our Junior and senior class now not all of them drive but we do have a lot of students that Park along the road um and sometimes it seems a little dangerous for some of that so um we could really use some more parking that's one of the the things currently all of our classrooms are full and being used so we are really at capacity um if we grow much more at all we're going to have to start sharing classrooms and and finding ways uh to fit everyone into
026where we are so um as long as we don't grow which we're going to but um we're we're in really good shape but so those are some of the challenges um that we're facing uh just takes a lot of planning and a lot of talking but um there's always something going on at Ridgeland there's always a buzz and it's just a a really great place to be um and so then that's how I prepared so if you have any questions or anything I'm happy to answer questions nice job bardette thank you thanks thank you [Applause] thank you very much bardet we appreciate you being here and your leadership at the school thanks for what you do okay we have arrived at the section of the agenda that most of you are here for I'm guessing
027and that is public input so let me read to you the public input guidelines um those who want to speak have to sign up I have the sign up she sheet here here we have um 20 people signed up for public input and comments will be limited to 2 minutes uh this evening so that we can make sure to hear everyone Personnel comments are prohibited and please remember that your comments are recorded as part of the public record and be respectful so it when you I will um read your name uh when it's your turn to speak please come to the podium and speak into the microphone uh so that um not only we can hear you but everyone in the room can hear you and uh whoever is online can hear as well so
028first up we have Kira Howard and sorry if I don't get the name right but Kira Howard who is a sky view student [Applause] hi um I'm here to express my disapproval of like towards the challenges of um I know why the Cage bird sing by Maya Angelo and the handmaid's tell by Margaret Atwood these books don't deserve to be banned just because difficult topics are brought up difficult topics have to be discussed about because eventually the information will be lost just like in Fahrenheit 451 where the truth is no longer accessible and that's all thank you cara uh next we have Leo steel another Sky student hello I'm a senior at Skyy high school and I am very involved needless to say I strongly care about my school and I also strongly agree with
029the Banning of these two books first Banning these books is unnecessary for this age group when I found out these books were being debated on being banned I did a quick search to find out why I found out the hands mayel was being banned for subject sensitive materials I decided I can handle reading this and I want to read it I paid extra attention to all the things that seemed subject sensitive and none of which went really in depth or seem too descriptive the reason I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings is being banned is for discussing molesting and abusing of an 8-year-old I decided I cannot handle reading about that I would like to say before this gets used against me that that's a really important thing it's a really important point we are
030at an age where we can tell what we can and can't handle and it's not always about maturity but sometimes about life experience the fact is we understand what each person can read and cannot read but it's depending on each student and there is no reason that these should be banned and I would also like to say if a book is making someone uncomfortable books are amazing because you can simply close them I know I've certainly started reading some books that have made me uncomfortable but the amazing thing is I just closed it and moved on which is possible I'd like to point out that these books already went through a review process by parents students teachers and they went through a long checklist and framework if you're personally worried about your child I'd suggest
031having a conversation with them because we can talk about Family Matters and family values and we can ask students to maybe not read these but we don't need to get rid of it in the school this needs to be a Family Matter instead of a school matter to conclude I'd like to emphasize that the students of cash County School District are not being harmed by these books and these books are examples of amazing literature thank you next we have Megan Miller who is a parent from Providence first let me say thank you to the school board I know you put in a lot of time outside of me meetings researching these issues and you will spend time tonight listening to all of us that is a great sacrifice of time and energy that often goes
032without notice and without thanks my comment is in regards to the sensitive materials appe pill on tonight's agenda I am speaking tonight as a mother of four children but also as a former educator of 9 years I'm spending time at home with little kids these days but I plan to return to education soon while I am comfortable teaching I'm not very comfortable here but I feel that I must speak because I love reading and I love teaching teenagers I value their intellect their strong opinions and their ability to learn from and empathize with others I spend a couple hours most weeks volunteering in the Ridgeline Library mostly because I missed being in the classroom it is frustrating to care so much about this issue but feel there is little I can do to make a
033difference people like me who love to read and enjoy teenagers and children usually end up as teachers or Librarians so that they can make a daily difference but that position can often keep them from speaking out in a Forum like this one as district and government employees they have to be so careful about what they say the Librarians and teachers here work tirelessly to choose their materials they read hundreds of books and when concerns come forth they investigate thoroughly countless additional hours are now being spent by them and by District level administrators on book challenges hours that would be better spent on curriculum development and teaching these two books have already been read reviewed and retained by the committee that is several hours already spent reading discussing and coming to a decision about this material
034let's not waste their work work by adding to this process I have read both books being appealed tonight and learned valuable lessons from both my Angelou taught me that people can rise above their trauma and use their experiences both joyous and difficult to teach others Margaret Atwood retaught me the joy of words her main character lives under a totalitarian government but the greatest pleasure she finds is in Reading because it brings her strength both books have difficult content and neither book is for every reader but both books are for some readers if you fear the content of a book talk to your own children about not reading that book but don't remove it from students who may have experienced similar traumas or from students who may encounter people in their lifetimes that have experienced similar
035traumas let them [Applause] learn thank you Megan next up we have Cordelia McNab who is a student at Ridgeline [Applause] I'm cord McNab a junior from rideline high school and I've come to talk about the appeal of sensitive materials I was initially hesitant to come today however I think when we have these discussions it is critical to have input from the people most affected in this instance students like the ones that have come here today as a 16-year-old I in a complicated position I simultaneously live in a world where I'm allowed to drive or have a job where I am still limited by the confines of the school I go to I'm supposed to be a well educated and well rounded human ready to vote as soon as I turn 18 but get told that
036other parts of the world are too complicated for me to understand this does not have to be the case however school can and ought to be a place where students learn where students learn about empathy and caring as well as how the world Works Beyond just health class and government class the school library teaches these things as a teenage white girl living in Suburban Utah books allow me to empathize with people from vastly different backgrounds as indivual individuals we cannot and do not of every experience that someone can and therefore cannot grow up with the same values and ideas as every single other person on this planet in reading through though we get to live those life experiences if only for a moment this ability allows us to understand other people just a little bit
037better these two books especially encapsulate this idea by reading these books we can understand the experiences and how other people get their views to better have discussions about them and as a student the easiest place to go to find books is the school Library I don't need to drive or spend money buying a book all I have to do is walk up a flight of stairs during my lunch break to access hundreds of different experiences do not take these books off the shelves doing show limits how students like me are able to learn and grow going against the core purpose of Education thank you thank you Cornelia next we have Rachel Bing burington from who is a the sky VI [Applause] student hello my name is Rachel barington and I am a 17-year-old student at
038Sky View High School as an AP college as an AP student and a College Bound College Bound and AP student I believe that it is necessary to have books that challenge students academically open their eyes to the real world and make people uncomfortable and having diverse literature in our libraries does so I have read both I know why the Cage Bird Sings and the handmaid's tail I have loved both of these books Maya Angelou showed me the harsh reality I wouldn't have known if I hadn't read her books Margaret atwt challenged me to find a deeper meaning in her books which helped me grow and prepare for the AP Lit Test please let the liter Librarians who know the students who come through their libraries best make the decisions about the books on their shelves
039thank you thank you Rachel next we have uh Christina barington who is a mountain crust [Applause] teacher good evening I am a mother of three students enrolled at Spring Creek Middle School Mountain Crest and Sky View high schools I was also a member of the committee to evaluate the handmaid's tail tonight I ask the board to honor the collective hundreds of hours spent by teachers parents librarians and the curriculum experts to retain the books in question in our high school libraries failing to do so sets a dangerous precedent that when a small minority of constituents doesn't like the result of a committee's decision it can be overturned on a whim this process has already monopolized the time and energy of our Librarians and District level administrators at the expense of our students while the small
040minority group may find some content in the books in question to be offensive the content does not violate Utah law nor does it constitute pornography defined by our legislature both novels are modern Classics of literary merit that students should find on the shelves in their school libraries while the minority argues that students still have access to the books via the public library Amazon and Libby it is essential to acknowledge that not all of our communities have access to the public library or the means to purchase books thank you for your thoughtful consideration in this important matter thank you Christina next we have Andrea Thompson who is a sky view and Green Canyon teacher hi yeah so I teach a sky view and just as a teacher I want to say I'm so proud of the
041students who have spoken today can we give them another round of applause you know that's that's what we're trying to do right is teach them to have that voice um and in in that that vein of thinking last year uh some of my students who participate in the We the People The Citizen and the Constitution team uh competition um they wrote they actually spent a few months researching this topic uh and and so I wanted to read you some of their essay after they gave me permission so this is from three 12th graders from Green Canyon High School last year camber Clark Caitlyn Ashman Sarah Maloof and Tessa Wright and they wrote after several months of researching this author of A Banned Book lri Anderson asserts censorship is the child of fear and the father
042of ignorance endorsing this sentiment we agree book Banning and other forms of censorship limit students and teachers freedom of expression and the exchange of ideas schools should use the least restrictive means possible when censoring printed materials censorship of literature limits freedom of speech and expression in the United States Supreme Court president case Board of Education Island Trees Union Free School District number 26 versus picco by Pico the Board of Education removed nine books deemed offensive to their personal beliefs the Court held school boards have secondary jurisdiction over the First Amendment meaning schools cannot restrict literature simply because it addresses a controversial theme with political religious or racial biases Justice Brennan adjudicates that schools are centers for voluntary inquiry and the dissemination of information and ideas School libraries enjoy a special Affinity with the rights of
043free speech and press we we concur restricting books limit students and teachers freedom of expression and the subtleties of thought the exchange of ideas through words is critical to the proliferation of a free Society placing limits on government and maintaining a national identity while a sheld book does not infringe on anyone's rights removing it does thank you thank you Andrea uh next we have Frankie AR arel sorry I'm slaughtering it a sky view student and when you get here please tell me how to say your name Frankie Ariano thank you yeah okay uh I'm a student here at Sky View um these books should not be banned because as many of the people have said before me they're very important and that they're part of history and sorry uh these books would be very important
044to those people who won't be able to buy them on Amazon or just go to the library and pick it up because they're at a school library where it would be easier to access and uh if these books were banned it would be getting rid of history which in the book that we are currently reading at Skyy Fahrenheit 451 these books would be Lost in Translation and they would forget the whole meaning of it thank [Music] you thank you Frankie next up we have Darby Holmes representing cash ligh house [Applause] it's a long walk um I'm really excited to be having this conversation I am here uh for the removal of these books um these books uh clearly meet the bright line rule under house bill 29 um and do not belong in the institution
045dedicated to Children uh Utah law clearly gives us guidelines of how to make sure content is acceptable for children and this isn't about book Banning it's about book boundaries uh if if you want to get these books you can get them anywhere else anywhere else just not our institutions where these children are majority of them under 18 so just to reiterate the law Utah law states that when materials meet any of these guidelines any of them they are deemed to have no literary value for minors and should not be in the schools human genitals in the state of sexual arousal acts of human masturbation sexual intercourse or sodomy fondling of human genitals in the pubic region human buttocks or female breasts that is the objective criteria so when we read a description of an erection
046like a corn on the cob and an 8-year-old child is forced to touch that man's erection while he's in the state of arousal that meets the bright line rule that is in I know why the Cage Bird Sings when we read a woman holding down another woman while a man is effing the lower part of her body and when she stands up and the juices run down her leg from that man that constitutes the bright line Rule and those are just two passages these books are filled with this and we are not saying they don't have literary value for adults they do they are very beautiful works of art but not for children and we as cash Cy citizens have boundaries that we will set for the institutions of our children thank you thank you
047Darby uh next we have Carter Hansen who is a teacher at Sky [Applause] View good evening members of the board members of the community um I just wanted to start off by saying again thank you for your time this is really really cool to be here my name is Carter Hansen and I'm honored to teach English in the school district I'm here tonight to oppose the proposed bands of the handmade stale by margard Atwood and I know why the Cage Bird Sings by Maya Angelo these books are not required reading they are Choice novels meaning students and families decide if they wish to engage with him not all books are for all students but for many these works are an essential for growth I know why the Cage Bird Sings provides profound insights into resilience
048and history helping students analyze complex themes and literary techniques the handmade cell encourages critical thinking about societal structures in individual agency both texts Foster academic and Civic skills preparing students to engage thoughtfully with the world around them it's important to recognize once more that these books are Choice books families have the freedom to decide what aligns with their values but removing these Works denies opportunities for others who may find them transformative literature helps students understand perspectives and grapple with real world challenges in a safe environment denying access to these books risks limiting their intellectual and personal growth I'd like to take one more second to express how proud I am of my students that are here tonight it's been so cool to see all of them come up and speak um I just wanted to
049say that they have engaged with this issue very very well in my class we've had a lot of conversations about it um and after studying Fahrenheit 451 they explored the impact of censorship and the importance of intellectual Freedom their support tonight reflects their Readiness to tackle challenging ideas with maturity and respect these books represent education growth and choice let's trust our students and families to make inform decisions while ensuring that those who need stories have access to them I urge you to reject this ban thank you thank you Carter uh next we have Austin bow a sky view student [Music] uh hello my name is Austin I am in the 10th grade at Sky View um I want to express my feelings toward the challenges on I know what the cage sings and by Maya
050Angelo and the H handmaid's tale by margar Atwood I oh these books should not be banned because if any of these books offend someone then why are they reading it I think that if if it offends you then you could just put the book down close it and forget it to even exist and and if really you don't like it you could just tell anybody that you don't like it let them read it let them choose what they want to do um sorry and what really confuses me is the people that are reading it it really offends and the people who don't read it doesn't offend them because they haven't even seen the book or haven't heard the book and the people who read it tell them bad stories about it and they haven't read
051it for themselves and they can't realize what is wrong with it or what they want to tell about it it um but I think that if really oh my that's that's it thank you uh thank you Austin next up we have Hillary PES who is a parent I have a sun at Ridgeline the two books presently being contested have just been a drop in the bucket of the explicit books we found at Ridgeline sadly there seems to be some gray area as to whether pornography should be distributed to minors in our places of Education the process given by law to keep sexually explicit material out of our schools and out of the hands of our kids was clearly violated as was clearly outlined and detailed in our appeals counter to the committee's conclusion no amount
052of good values or compassion they believe the rest of the book taught somehow nullifies the poison placed purposefully within it would you give your kids contaminated food tell them just to eat around it and hope they are unaffected it is a sorry excuse to pretend that the damage is not done once the crude explicit images have been etched into their minds once pornography presents itself in a book similar to any other format you can bet that is what will be playing out over and over and stick in the child's mind long after the book is read that is how pornography works and why it works and how people get rich off addicting our children to it exposing pornography to minors is no trivial thing it should be forbidden no matter what society normalizes and tries
053to desensitize us to there is no innocent reason for an adult to be exposing pornography to minors it is a violation of their dignity and worth they are being violated spiritually mentally and emotionally it's violating their evolving beliefs development and relationships in a similar way that physical abuse does this is not education this has been and always will be abuse by the those who should have been their protectors and Defenders until they reach adulthood if an adult read this material to my children or forced them to read it in class I would identify that adult as a predator or groomer so how is it okay if they purposefully leave it in a place like a school library for trusting students to pick it up and start reading while mom and dad are not around does
054that make it less of a violation we do not have the right to Rob our children of beauty truth peace and innocence thank you thank you Hillary next up is Pamela budge who is a [Applause] parent I want to address the first question you will be considering in the appeal did the committee fail to follow statutory mandates administrative rules and applicable policy in reaching its decision I will be addressing the objective review not the subjective review only because the subjective review is rendered irrelevant if a book never should have pass the objective review in the first place the law is very clear in stating that the standards by which materials are reviewed for being pornographic or indecent are non-discretionary or something that is not left to personal choice the standards are very specific and I'll
055reread one they've been mentioned once but um human genitals in a state of sexual stimulation or arousal in my review of the excerpts of the both books both books contain that kind of description I know why the Cage Bird Sings has several detailed descriptions on pages 78 81 and 83 the fact that a child was involved in these scenes should make an even stronger case for this book failing the first objective review the handmaid's taale has descriptions on pages 93 95 98 Etc the premise of the book is centered on SE sexual intercourse described in a vulgar and crass way that gives you a clear picture of what is actually involved in that act I don't have access to the same documents you do with notes and work of the Committees but I don't believe
056I need them because my review of the book excerpts and the law I can see that the objective review committees failed to follow the statutory mandates therefore the subjective review should not be taken into account because they were not able to make an objective review and were were focused on other review requirements of a subjective review which led to their unanimous decision decision when when you remove the most important criteria from a re a review the final decision is no longer valid and should not be upheld thank [Applause] you thank you Pamela next up is Lauren clerb a parent [Applause] going to read a little excert that is not pornography my red skirt is hitched up to my waist though no higher below it the commander is what he is is the lower part of
057my body I do not say making love because that's not what he's doing copulating to would be inaccurate because it would imply two people and only one is involved nor does rape cover it nothing is going on here that I haven't signed up for there wasn't a lot of choice but there was some and this is what I chose he comes at last with a stifled groan of relief Serena Joy who's been holding her breath expels it the commander who's been propping himself up on his elbows away from our combined bodies doesn't permit himself to sink down into us he rests a moment withdraws recedes reppers he nods then turns and leaves the room I entangle myself from her body stand up the juice of the commander runs down my leg there are tons more
058in all in both of these books and this one Mr Freeman pulled me to him and put his hand between my legs he didn't hurt but Mama Jed into my head keep your legs closed and don't let no let nobody see your pocket book now I didn't hurt you don't get scared he threw back the blanket and this thing stood up like a brown ear of corn and this is not pornography remind you that this is in our schools he threw about the blankets and his thing stood stood up like a brown ear of corn he took my hand and said feel it it was mushy and squirmy like the inside of freshly killed chicken then he dragged me on top of his chest and with his left arm and his right hand was moving
059so fast his heart was going so fast that I feared he would he would die I felt a small soft lump under my thigh began to move it twitched against me and started to harden then he pulled me hard to his chest sit still stop squirming but all the time he pushed me around on his lap then suddenly he ran he stood up and slipped down to the floor he ran to the bathroom these should not be in our [Applause] schools thank you Lauren next up is Daniel cler Bor another parent I'm here for the removal of the previous mentioned books I want to address the Pres harm this material can C our teenagers and why it's imperative to act responsibly in protecting their development explicit contents can normalize harmful behaviors and attitudes a study
060published in the Journal of adolescence found that exposure to sexual violence in media is linked to increased acceptance of rape meths and reduce empathy for victims when students read biographic scenes involving abortion or abuse such as the ones described on these books it risks it risks desens desensitizing them to violence and prating and healthy Norms about content and power dynamics City shows City shows the exposure to sexual sexually explicit material even briefly can shape attitudes and behaviors for example a study published in the in P Pediatrics found that adolescence exposed to sexual content in Media or more lik to engage in Risky sexual behavior psycholog psychological research demonstrates that negative experience or contents are more memorable and impactful than positive ones this is known as the negativity bias where harmful elements can overshadow the rest
061of the content in the content of a book even a small portion of explicit material can dis appropriately influance to readers perspective and to take away half my life ago I read a book called The Kite Runner I was back in high school the only thing I can remember is the boy having a bigger boy back him up into a corner rape him and then this boy waddled home bleeding out of his anus that's all I remember no other positive messages explicit content and educational settings under Minds The efforts to teach respect empathy and healthy relationships it contradicts the values and many the values many parents and educ to strive to instill by allowing such materials in schools we message please conclude [Applause] thanks thank you Daniel next up we have deian Ashby who is
062a parent [Applause] good evening and thank you for the opportunity to be able to speak today hopefully I will hold it together I'm on the opposite side I'm on the side of of abuse because of pornography because of those kind of things our family has personally been affected by the ability of explicit books given to Children both in and out of school public libraries and even personal collections from Kid to Kid you know what kids do they show other kids to say that the erotic pornographic pornographic depictions acts explicit descriptions of rape pedophilia incest domestic violence and graphic violence will chemically alter that child's brain they are still in frontal lob development there's not one person in this room who hasn't been affected by pornography in some way not one unless they are a child
063keep our kids safe it is up to us I was abused multiple times throughout my life and I am here to tell you on the opposite end of the spectrum I will be a warrior for the ones who have yet to be affected and there are many out there who have yet to be affected by pornography I was abused by both my brothers who received pornography and acted upon that behavior as well as a teacher in my school at the age of 14 I was groomed by Steve Michaels at the age of 14 who shared this information with me time is up if you can please conclude thank you I ask for you to please reconsider thank you Dean uh next up we have Megan lunberg who is a student [Applause] hello pornographic materials damage
064the brain so that the body reacts and produces a high that makes teenagers whose prefrontal cortex are not fully developed yet they don't fully develop until the age of 25 the prefrontal cortex is the part of the brain that is responsible for making decisions and you expect us to make the decision that we can handle these books when these books describe things that are happening in real life but are also encouraging those things which happen in real life this I have read many of these types of books and it has damaged me so bad I was not able to see any of it until recently when I was diagnosed with depression and AD or and ADHD and anxiety and many other disorders I finally got on a medication and got help and unfortunately many of
065my fellow teenagers and students can't see this from their perspective they need help they need to be able to be free from this cuz I will never get the Innocence back that I had and I will never be able to be a child again that was taken away from me because I was recomend mended books by teachers and and Librarians and fellow students it was everywhere and it was encouraged and it led me to act that way it led me to be like that and I wanted to be a better person and it has destroyed that possibility it destroyed my life and I don't want it to destroy fellow other students is thank you [Applause] thank you Megan next up is Julie Caster who is a skyb [Applause] teacher thank you very much board members
066um thank you very much community members I'm speaking to you this evening as a language arts teacher but more importantly as a community member um I am deeply invested in the educational development of all of our students and of our community and I believe that our school Library resources in the cash County School District are incredibly valuable to everyone um I'm aware of this discussion and have been for some time um I respectfully urge you to maintain your initial decision to retain these literary works as an educator and as a community member I'm entrusted with fostering critical thinking skills empathy and intellectual curiosity in my students the books in question question though they do explore complex social issues personal identity and very difficult historical contexts offer invaluable opportunities for students to engage with difficult yet
067essential topics students will encounter issues like this in the real world um books and works of literary merit serve as Windows mirrors and doors for our students if we want our students to be active and civically engaged it is important that they know how to Grapple with these complex issues have critical thinking skills that will help them in their future endeavors your decision to initially keep these books was a reflection of a well- balanced and very thoughtful approach to education in our community by providing access to a range of literature we all Empower our students and our community to make informed decisions develop our own opinions and gain deeper understanding of the world around us removing these books would not only limit our students intellectual growth but send a message that we're unwilling to have
068these difficult conversations conversations that our students will face as they move into adulthood and navigate a world that is very multifaceted we want our students to grow and develop and works of literature allow them to do that thank you thank you Julie next up is Dave [Applause] fliff boy I'm not going to be nearly as articulate as a lot of these people I was a teacher at SkyV for 30 years now I'm just a member of the community um you know I really appreciate um the time and effort that parents put into uh thinking about what they kids are learning um so I disagree wholeheartedly with with a lot that's been said tonight um but I appreciate their effort um but to pause for a minute I don't know how we got here I don't
069we we we don't live in orban's Hungary we don't live in Lenin's um Russia we don't live in Hitler's Germany we live in the United States if you don't want to read it don't uh but don't tell me what I want now my grandkids to be able to have access to um and it was stated by a student tonight you know what a wonderful thing books are close the cover engage with your kids teach them values and if they're reading something which violates your values close the book this is not hard this is not hard so anyway thank you and appreciate all your effort one other thing I do wish we would put a little bit more effort um instead of banning books and thoughts maybe let's figure out a way to stop having kids
070get killed weekly in schools let's put some more effort into that [Applause] thank you Dave uh last up is Julianne duffen a parent from [Applause] Ridgeline hi um thank you again for allowing us to share our own personal opinion for everyone we appreciate that a lot for the time um I am a mother of six and I wish to speak in opposition of banning books um freedom freedom of speech is a constitutional right which includes literature and books um books that address issues like historical and cultural awareness and diversity and racism and sexuality and addiction or mental health are often tools for understanding and for addressing problems avoiding can perpetuate ignorance and exposure to controversial doesn't mean the student necessarily will adopt them but maybe instead it can equip them to think critically and evaluate
071perspectives when students encounter challenging topics through literature it allows them to process difficult subjects in a safe guided environment rather than encountering them unprepared in real life avoiding content doesn't make it go away it Fosters people who are ill-prepared for navigating these real situations um once we start down this path of restricting a certain criteria where do we stop uh what is next and what will be left Banning books creates fear discourages new thought-provoking ideas and limits overall quality of Education I understand the desire to protect children from inappropriate content and harmful ideas but this can be done in beautiful discussions within individual families and their according to their belief systems as has been said different families and individuals have varying standards for what is acceptable and schools serve divers communities not just those from
072a particular cultural moral or religious background removing a book from the library shelf eliminates that choice for everyone including families who want their children to access access diverse perspectives Banning books imposes one group's values on everyone else and denies students the opportunity to learn question and grow so instead of censoring content schools and parents can provide context open dialogue and critical thinking tools to help students engage thoughtfully with challenging materials thank [Applause] you thank we thank you Julianne thank you all for your comments we have uh duly noted those and uh we are at the end of our public input section of our agenda next up we have our consent agenda and um I will take an a motion to I take a motion to am to accept or amend the consent agenda as printed
073I move that we approve the consent agenda I second it's been moved and seconded that we approve the consent agenda as printed any discussion seeing none we will vote electronically voting is closed and the motion to approve the consent agenda passes unanimously thank you Jared uh moving on we have our action agenda and first up on the action agenda is the Sumit Elementary School's Land Trust Amendment uh for principal Amy mcneel she presented that to us two weeks ago and um does anyone have any questions or concerns about her request she's here too any questions for Amy she's here all right I will take a motion on that action item I make a motion to approve appr Summit Elementary School Land Trust Amendment second it's been moved and seconded that we approve the summit Elementary
074School Land Trust Amendment uh seeing no other discussion requests we will vote electronically voting is closed and the motion to approve the suggested changes to the summit Elementary School Land Trust plan passes unanimously thank you Jared uh next on the action agenda is the sensitive materials appeal for two books to be removed from the uh School libraries any discussion I just raise one point of order um I think during the public comment at least once uh part of the Utah code was read That's relevant to this but it wasn't the entire code um so the definition of nudity was read and and I think I'm sorry was it is it Pamela that raised a point you know which is worth considering you know should we should we uh be voting on the process if the
075process wasn't followed and part of that was based on that definition of nudity but keep in mind in the house build uh you know it alludes to state code regarding pornography and nudity is not the only um nudity is not the only Criterion so other words nudity is defined but I think it's important just for the record you know for those who who read that definition that um pornography has you know a specific def definition in Utah code and this is the definition any material or performance is pornographic if the average person applying contemporary Community standards finds that taken as a whole it appeals to puent interest in sex so in other words something that's gratuitous and not um not included for uh a reason to like say uh teach a moral lesson for example
076second it is patently offensive in the description or depiction of nudity now this is where the nudity definition comes in and that was red sexual conduct sexual excitement satom masochistic abuse or excretion and c and this is key taken as a whole it does not have serious literary artistic political or scientific value so uh in other words um I appreciate that the code was read relevant just to nudity but I just want to make sure especially since uh you know Pamela the parent who publicly commented kind of raised that point that we address that that um that uh was it's not just the definition of nudity which is defined in another part of the law this is the definition of pornography here and that's what the house bill was based on basically so anyway thanks
077any other comments discussion I feel the same as Chris in looking at the code which if anybody wants to reference 1203 as well as 7 1227 so I concur thank you I just want to add a comment too um as I I read the individual quotes from the books that were um part of the challenge um they were um disturbing I thought but I wanted to read the context in which it was put so I got the books and um when I read the sections that had these in there wasn't anything erotic there wasn't anything titillating there wasn't anything um sexually arousing and so my viewpoint is that that's not pornography thanks I I want to concur with uh Kathy you know of course we have a lot of English teachers here context matters the
078famous example is the Sun let's eat Grandma without any commas in it um you know if you put the punctuation in the right place well it changes the entire meaning of the sentence and so context absolutely matters and that's why that's why Utah law takes this into account taken as a whole it does not have any serious literary artistic political or scientific value and also the you know the instances of those kinds of descriptions um uh does it appeal to a prent interest in sex or not you know in other words is it gratuitous um I I think I I just want to underscore what you just said context matters a lot and and I want to thank the committee uh that was appointed and our our Librarians for um making that assessment as as
079has been said this took an extraordinary amount of time for them to review and and so I want to thank them for doing their jobs for helping us to kind of adhere to to Utah law and to make sure that we understand context you know on top of uh on top of content um as I spoke with different parents on the two committees I and uh administrator I uh one of the questions that I asked them was whether they had felt like they had been pressured into making the decision they did for each of the books and um in 100 % of or every person that I spoke with said absolutely not because everyone filled out their own Pages um you've you've seen all of those pages and um they felt like they were uh
080and I know personally two of the parents who were selected although I didn't know they had been selected until I saw their names on the committee and I appreciate the fact that they are parents who uh for for lack of a better term I'll say they have backbone and will uh would definitely stand up to um administrators or teachers if they felt like um they were that something was was happening wrongly um so I appreciated that input from the parents and administrator that I spoke with um who served on those committees I'd like to make one other comment and that is um I I would suggest as a board that we maintain these books in the libraries but that they do have to have a a parent sign out that way each family would be
081responsible as to whether um they felt comfortable in having their child check the book out or not is that a motion um yes I'll make that motion okay I would second that it's been moved and seconded that we is if I understand you right we will retain the books um requiring parental permission to check out the books is that what you meant so it's been moved and seconded that we retain the books with um requiring parental permission in other discussion does that mean just in the high school we in the high school M and that would include the two books that are debate that we're debating tonight is that any other books or how how would books be added to that um well we're only discussing the appeal of those two books in this action
082item is this even an option that's available to us I mean yes yes yes there's precedent throughout the state in other school districts as I I um visited with other school districts in uh the decisions they had made on different uh book reviews and appeals that this is an option yes what would be the process for that a kid comes to check out a book so they have to set it aside and email the parents and wait for the parents to like what is the process for that our our purpose is the decision the process will leave up to the Librarians and they are great team players so they'll all work together to make sure that happens correctly just as a point of record I mean can we because this came up in the last
083meeting but I I think it would be worth mentioning here how many times collectively in the district were those books checked out over the course of the past I don't know say five years there Library I know when I spoke with one of the Librarians uh the book had not been checked out three years they actually removed the book but after being on the committee they put the book back on because they recognized the value to some students I I would just like to respectfully uh just as a part of the discussion speak out against that motion I feel like you know Librarians and teachers are burned enough already um you know this process is demonstrative of that um you know I I I know that we're allowed to do it but that wasn't anything
084that was you know included in the house bill and I feel like it adds a level that kind of over complicates the lives of of teachers and Librarians uh I I just feel like that opens a huge can of worms in terms of how these things are dealt with in the future it makes it very easy to you know for us to I'm sorry what yes and there's nobody checking it out this is a this is our uh a board meeting not a meeting of the public and you had your turn to speak um so uh at any rate I I don't like leaving a middle option that will um that will add you know additional processes that are owner to Librarians and teachers can we have can we have the district review it and
085have the Librarians discuss and then maybe come back in another board meeting and share options or allow us to think about a little bit more how that process would work mhm or if it's even if it even makes sense as Chris was sharing but you said there's precedent right Terry that's the yeah I agree with your first statement where you know the board will make a decision and then they can iron out how the process works okay so do you want to vote that we have a motion and a second on the table do you want to vote on this or do you want to Brian are you suggesting we table it as we talk about it I think it'd be wise to have the district maybe come up with some solutions perhaps that this
086is an option in this or not or not not if if somebody's checking out a book from the library that book comes up on the computer system and there could be a flag or a warning that says librarian check with parent first before checking this out if that's an option maybe that would be an easy thing to do uh but I don't know and I I trust our Li Librarians I think they've done a great job through this process and I'd be interested to see what they had to say so maybe wait would be my recommendation to have further discussion with them so do you want to table this this U motion I think so yeah um we have we already have a motion on the table though that's been seconded you need to vote
087on it okay so let's vote on the motion the uh original motion of retaining uh requiring parental permission it's been moved and seconded all in favor vote can we have like some additional discussion about that though because again we have no idea what the process would involve so we're voting on something that we've kind of um you know just thrown out there but we don't know you know how that would work and and what what would be required we do have um a libraryi in here several L of yes okay I I actually would like to hear your U thoughts on this because I haven't really thought it out that far if you're gonna if but if you're going to answer then you need to come to the microphone so Terry you're right we could
088figure it out um my hesitancy is that we're here to vote on these two books and the process that was followed to decide whether they should be banned or not if we decide that we're going to put a limit on checkout do we need to rewrite our policy for um review is my question because is this going to be the next step in every single book that is approved through committee and then put up for appeal and then does the school board then need to go through this with every single book because I think we will see that books that are put through committee even if they're unanimously approved I think we will see every single one of those go to appeal so I just think that you're right we're opening a can of worms
089and I think the decision needs to be made whether we retain or not retain books um I just I think we're adding another level that we're not prepared to add unless we change the entire review process would be my input thank you okay I'm at Ridgeline High I think you're making all students opt in instead of maybe opting out I think I can see if a parent approached me at the first of the year and said none that would be okay but if every student comes up and we they have to the contact would have to be made I think that's an opt-in versus an opt out which would be a perhaps a different way of looking at it um I think we're all very good at high school and middle school libraries of when
090a student checks out a book that has that we're aware has some problems we are always and I always tell the kids this book has some content that might be disturbing be prepared if you do not if you're would like to shut that book please do and when your mama calls I'm going to tell her we had this conversation and I hope they have that conversation with you as well thanks Bonnie oh I'm sorry go ahead how do we how do we cancel the well we can we can vote it down can amend the motion vot we could vote it down either way okay so the motion on the table is that we retain with parental permission it's been seconded um but board docs only allows us one electronic vote so you'll have to vote
091verbally instead for this one for this motion okay if there's going to be another motion made just uh one other point of discussion about this before we vote on the amendment verbally um you know if we if if we a board decide to extra legislate you know in other words we go beyond what the state legislature is asking us to do then that's kind of the can of worms I'm talking about I mean I know that maybe other districts have found this and and you know made an honest effort at a Middle Road um but that's not what the that's not what our elected legislators have asked us to do necessarily they've stated cly what our responsibility is and so um that's why I feel like to keep this to simplify this you know especially
092for the sake of the process and our Librarians our great teachers that we stick with what we're being asked to do and not try to you know amend the legislation by creating another class or category any other discussion to this motion parents get to say anything you said yours Li we were asking staff for their counsel a question um no this is a meeting of the board and we are in discussion right now I appreciate Chris's comments I appreciate the librarian comments I don't know how you reverse the motion to have a vote but having this discussion is valuable and I think we need to have more of it but I don't know well if you don't want the motion to succeed you just vote no sure and and then we go to the V
093and then you vote to some then you make a new motion so we have a motion on the table to retain with parental permission it's been seconded all in favor say I I'll oppose say no no no no okay so that motion fails now is there a new motion or do you want to um wait and make this decision at a different board meeting after gaining more information from staff I I would like to vote on the appeal I mean it's on the agenda so I don't see so are you going to make a motion yes I I move that we vote on the sensitive materials appeal and on what and so what's your motion uh well that that we it depends on how this comes up electronically because yay means we uphold the appeal
094and nay means we don't uphold the appeal is that right Jared it would be however the motion is phrased so you phrase the motion so I'm I'm going to be careful about a double negative then I I guess I would say I I move that we um deny the sensitive materials appeal is there a second I second it it's been moved and seconded that we deny the sensitive materials appeal as it's written as they're both written any discussion to this motion who seconded that I'm sorry I didn't catch that thank you so a yay V will mean that we retain the books is that correct yes yes okay and also it's entirely possible to come back and consult about process you know if there's if there's some other uh extra legislative you know path that
095people want to take I mean that that still is possible um but uh I just want to kind of point that out okay any other discussion to this motion just one quick thing for the parents who are here uh and all the students who showed up uh I think I just want to say prior to this vote how much we appreciate you showing Jo up and uh you know the the passion that's expressed but at the same time in a very civil um you know discourse it's actually very inspiring when we have Schoolboard meetings like this where we have a lot of people show up and people are respective and they're respectful and they're able to uh convey you know their feelings in a way that is respectful of of neighbors and friends in the
096community so I I want to thank everybody who cares about this enough to to show up um obviously it's um these kinds of issues are a big deal and so we appreciate people on both sides being willing to share their feelings and their experiences anyway thanks okay we have a motion on the table to deny the sensitive am materials appeal which means that we would retain the books according to the committee decisions the two committee's decisions on these two books it's also been seconded any other discussion okay we vote electronically [Music] voting is closed and the motion to deny the sensitive materials appeal passes unanimously thank you Jared next up on our action agenda we have uh teacher Meritt pay presented by superintendent mck two weeks ago at our study session and um we have
097uh had some discussion about that two weeks ago so we will have a little more do you want to present anything else certainly um thank you board first first and foremost thank you for the deliberate careful process that you've been going through I'm also grateful to the community on either both sides of this the situation with the books it says a lot about Cash Valley in the community that we're able to have these civil conversations around difficult matters and it only makes us better as a school district so I'm grateful to everyone um for their participation this evening uh hark back two weeks ago I presented to the board um uh Senate Bill 173 which was the Merit teacher merit award uh program uh which was a an attempt by the legislature um to um
098incentivize retain and recruit teachers through Merit pay uh We've looked at that very carefully we shared a lot of information with you back in that meeting uh since that time we have um elicited input from our staff so with approximately 11 I think it's about 1100 certified staff in our district we heard back from over 700 of them um asking them specifically their opinions of the program as it was outlined whether they felt like um it was something that was worth pursuing as a district uh knowing that teacher specifically would potentially benefit from this it was uh overwhelming 92% um opposed um so we feel um going forward in the best interest of our teachers and our district the collective culture that we have tried to cultiv uh cultivate for several years in our schools
099um that this is something that at this time is not right for the cash County School District I will share with you just one other point you know in our survey of the staff uh we opened up at the end of the the opportunity for them to give us open comment and it was interesting we received over 50 pages worth of comments from from staff uh I went through every one of them uh what was really interesting to me was that at least three of our teachers that are currently in our in our district have worked in other districts outside the state of Utah where they had a merit pay system all three of them recognized um that this this can really undermine a school district and a school culture I want to highlight just
100one in particular this this teacher um mentioned wanted to be very clear that um she was one that benefited from the program financially outside the state when she was participating in it uh but she noted that the pressure and stress affected everyone's health and relationships students even by Administration became numbers not people it was a matter of this student could pass the test so let's help them versus the student while they can grow won't pass so teachers were told to focus on the ones that could pass even observation reports so administrative observations were were biased and res and resentment grew resentment was what widespread in the district and it was a negative environment the teacher turnover was high and those coming in often left within a couple of years this type of program takes the
101humanity out of teaching you know that that really struck me that oftentimes we're talking about outcomes and the outcomes we're really dealing with are human beings their children um and we don't ever wanted to reduce them to to a mere number and my fear is with this type of incentive program we take the focus off the growth of children and we put turn it onto a profit mod uh incentive and when that becomes more important than the child I think we we're definitely going down the wrong path anyone have questions or comments for the superintendent um does someone want to make a motion to opt us out of I'll make the motion to opt out of the teacher Merit for this year I second it's been moved and seconded that we opt out of the
102teacher Merit program uh currently being offered by the legislature any discussion to that all right uh seeing none we will vote electronically voting is closed and the motion to opt out of participation in the State Legislative teacher Barrett program passes unanimously hey can I just ask a question for the record so superintendent there are 40 how many districts 41 districts 41 and how many have made an official decision so far public we were we were looking at that just the other morning I I believe there's probably close to 20 is that Tim no there's 10 11 11 districts Charter s Charters so 11 but I mean there're still like two weeks before the deadline right so corre they have until the 31st yeah so how many of those have opted in do you know 11
103of the 41 11 out of the 41 have oped in okay is that 11 districts or 11 including the charter that's 11 school districts and then we there are several dozen uh Charters that 30 Charters any other questions about that we already voted yeah thank you Jared for that report um you're up again Jared we are moving on to the reports agenda uh to First up in the reports agenda is the monthly fin financial report for November 2024 okay uh just a couple of of things I wanted to comment on that are in the the monthly report that I submitted to you we are participating in a a new audit um we didn't actually receive an audit letter and so it was a little bit surprising but we had uh some Auditors from the uh
104legislative audit office show up they're doing a Statewide audit on school construction and so they wanted to look at uh our projects and and we provided some information and and kind of showed them around so uh things went well there we we don't have any indication if of if there will be follow up on that but but again that's a Statewide audit um the Auditors did reach out to Bruce and scheduled the time to come up with him but we've not received an official audit letter so I'm I'm looking into that a little bit uh we did get uh this last month our our midyear updates on our budget from usbe and uh last year we had a slight decline in our funding mid year this year we have a slight incline uh which we're
105happy about and the majority of that is is for um the full day kindergarten sections that were added this year that wpu funding doesn't show up until this time of year when those sections have kind of been built in so we were expecting some of that uh and then the other thing I wanted to mention the the of course discussions are beginning um regarding the the upcoming legislative session the preliminary uh estimates um are showing not not a stellar year for for new funding in the state so we're not expecting uh big increases but the potential for possibly a a 4% wpu and growth funding might be what we're looking at if if things turn out in line with what the current projections are just just to give you an idea of of kind of
106what's being discussed there um did you finally get a closing letter for on that usbe sped audit we have not I have contacted that man three times um yeah there there's a little bit of a story there I could talk to you about but but I think he's moving to uh a different employer at the right now so there's there's a little transition in I guessed that was that was going to happen okay talk with you about that after okay thank you uh thanks for that report Jared uh next we have board member reports anyone um I will report that the um cash Education Foundation um Jared correct me if I'm wrong but they earned about $40,000 at the Christmas tree Jubilee um and that's what they fund their Tools for Schools with uh their
107tools for Tools for Schools grants and we are deeply grateful to our supporters which um are uh we have a few few supporters who donate a lot and then a lot of supporters who donate a little and we are grateful to all of them but uh most especially to those who who donate a lot so do we know how or what the difference was between this year's to tree thing in last year's was this A Better Way um what did you think Brian well he wouldn't know this was my first time going so I that's right sorry um so I went uh midday to uh so it was a dayong event rather than um and and visited with the Committee Member the committee chair for that particular project and she felt like Monday was not
108the best day of the week to have a dayong event so she hopes that um they will move that event to a Saturday next year um so that uh a Saturday during as the holiday season begins so that um people will be more apt to come it was uh there wasn't a lot of traffic midday uh when I was there there might have been uh maybe 10 Shoppers that you would consider Shoppers so in the past you've been before a bunch of people wandering around it's a dinner with a siland auction and things that you can look at beforehand and that type of thing this year they put um long tables down the ballroom um space of so like four long tables in in lines down the ballroom this way and then they had donors
109who had created these amazing tiny trees so think something 2 feet to 4 feet and with different themes and things like that so that they were trees that because you know the trees in the past sold for thousands of dollars because they were big um gorgeous themed trees but in this this year they wanted to make it open to more people to participate so those smaller trees were any started at $75 and went up to $500 and you could just buy one you didn't have to bid on it you could just buy a tree and then um so that's what I saw midday they also had um uh little things that you could buy for stocking stuffers and things like that or you could just donate at a table so then I will pass it
110off to Brian because you went to the evening part and you can explain what happened there so in the ballroom they had the trees around the perimeter of the room they had the small trees a number of those they had wreaths for lower dollar amount then they had the large trees as well most of the larger trees went between i' say $1,500 and $3,000 I didn't feel like the the crowd was it wasn't a packed room there there was a decent number but there were a lot of empty seats um those that were there to support the cash Education Foundation they did a great job they continued to buy trees and so the trees were beautiful and for those people that were there I thought it was a nice event if we had a few
111more biders I think you know it gets competitive and it's fun but applaud the people that put it on it was really a great event okay that answer yeah okay thanks so we'll see what they decide to do next year with that committee um the committee chair seems pretty excited about it and trying it again and adding some things and um so changing the day maybe yeah changing the day to a Saturday so we'll see how that see what happens um so I guess that was my board president report sorry I jumped ahead without telling you and uh so we'll move on to the superintendent's report okay just a couple items for the board uh just to keep you in informed of where we're at I appreciate all those that have submitted names for our
112facilities advisory committee U I'm still in need of two names um but I have received the other five just to make you aware we've been working with the demographer who's who's now going through and creating heat Maps across the District of where students currently are and they're also working with um all of our municipalities to identify areas of growth and new buildings so that we can start to project future growth grow um that work is is taking a little bit longer than we projected and and unfortunately we're not going to be able to kick this off before February so he's he's telling me it's probably end of January 1st of February before we have the data available for us uh so we're in intending to start the committee work in February once we we come
113back from the holidays um and we'll keep you informed on that and and how we uh progress with that the the first item on the agenda for that committee will be boundaries and that's that's going to be an intense little process as we're getting ready for the new builds and opening of schools secondly I want to update the board on the calendar a month ago we asked that we table the calendar conversation that's currently going through another round of process and we're getting really good feedback from each of our schools we intend to bring a a formal request to the board for a new calendar in January so just so that you're aware uh third I want to if you haven't um haven't noted or been informed yet about legislative assignments the legislature kicks off
114middle of January and we start that whole process over uh two of our legislators in particular play an important role in education so Senator Chris Wilson has been assigned to the education committee so if you know Senator Wilson um he's certainly someone to reach out to and and and share with him um the needs of the district the other is a new representative so Jason Thompson uh of River Heights uh formerly the mayor of River Heights is the new representative taking Dan um Johnson's position he's my to my understanding on the education Appropriations Committee and so he he again is someone that I think we need to make sure we keep informed as to our needs they both have been very responsive to the district they've reached already reached out to us prior to the
115to the legislative session um to understand where we're at and what concerns we might have and so that that's a relationship we want to continue uh to grow over the the course of the several next several months lastly I I want to thank uh both Ashley and Britney in particular you know that they have put their heart and soul into into doing the right thing and they've carried quite a bit of Burden for the district just to make sure that we're running the process is exactly um into the letter as the as the board has outlined in terms of looking at these books um I it can get really challenging uh because the passions can be on both sides as as we witnessed uh tonight there are strong feelings on both sides and we recognize
116and respect those um but that can take a toll and I just really am appreciative of them and their professionalism and their commitment to doing what's right last I want o thank the board because I know that uh these kind of weighty matters um weigh on you I know that that behind the scenes you have been doing a lot of thinking and research and And discussing with committee members to make sure that you're well informed to make the best decisions I am grateful to work for a district and for a community uh that values Community input and looks at these things uh through a critical eye and is very careful and deliberate because in the end it's all about the kids our focus is about kids and we have we have a duty to them
117to prepare them for their future and I'm just grateful for your work and with that I hope everyone has a wonderful holiday well deserved holiday all right anyone else want to say anything on the board I think we need to tell thanks to Chris here we appreciate all you've done and we're going to miss you absolutely oh yes this is your last you for this portrait enjoy that picture I just want the public to know that the role of this portrait in my family will be to Grace the home of my favorite child from month to month they'll just rotate and they can proudly display it and that will be great motivation to them to show me love and kindness and respect but thank you thanks everybody all right on that note seeing we have
118arrived at the end of our agenda we will adjourn