001all for being here we are glad you're here we're glad they wow for a study session this is a hefty crowd um we're glad you're all here thanks for being here it is 5:32 on Thursday the 5th of December we are meeting in the boardroom on Legacy campus and Roger pulsifer whoops we'll start with roll call beginning with Brian Brian Chambers board member Randle Bagley board member Terry rhs board member Chris cork board member Jared black business administrator Jeff nson board member Roger P for board member Kathy Christ Johansson board member Todd mcke superintendent thank you for being here uh the Roger pulsifer will lead us in the pledge and the mission statement please stand I ALG to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one
002nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all our mission is to educate students for success in a changing World thanks Roger uh first up we have our monthly Architects and construction update and this is is going to be presented by Steven but I don't see him here so it must be Bruce St probably want to talk to you about the new elementary school we put you in the chair farthest from your normal seat so that everyone could see your new apparatus my comfort zone want to start there we go what if we could dim these lights in the front here there okay so here we are this is at High Park as you can recognize I think last month when I was here we hadn't poured all of these four slabs in here
003they're all they've all been poured now and you can see that uh we're making pretty good progress now with walls going up um do you recall this is the firm that is is out of Wisconsin I want to say that's all these guys do is is uh put up this this foam block so they're they're really making good progress uh you'll notice the difference when I when I jump over to nibbi you'll notice that nibbly were going up two stories the full two stories with the block as as they move across the building these guys are just going to go up the one story as they come around the building the plan being that while they're doing Block in this area here the the steel folks can start putting in floor joists and floor decking
004and get the get the concrete second floor hoard um and then that should be done about the time the block go finish up over in this end of the building and then they can jump back and then take the walls the rest of the way out that way they're only they're not having to go so high into the air they can work a little more efficiently that way and it goes goes a little bit faster um just point of Interest I don't know if you care much about construction methods and the way the building gets assembled but you can see those little black squares occasionally in the top of the block there those are steel plates they have steel studs that project off the back and they when they pour the concrete in the block
005those are locked into the wall and that's what the that's what the second floor is suspended on there'll be an angle iron welded to those and the floor joists will sit on those and so that's that's the way the building is assembled same thing with the roof when we get up to that level the steel roof trestles will hang off of that same kind of system um about the only thing as far as slabs that is isn't poured you can see here where the stage is going to be right there there's a forum that's a recessed area that's not poured yet but other than that um we're we're done with with underground stuff and we're finally coming up in the air not a whole lot of activity with different Subs on the site at this
006point the uh these guys got to get Farther Along we got to get interior walls built and then the electrician and plumber will come back and they can really start start moving along with their with their phase so that's that's really all I have to report on this school if there's any questions before I jump over to nibi um obviously nibi is like I said it's being done a little bit different these guys are going all the way up before they move to the next area Mo most mostly because these guys are masons those other guys I I don't know what else to call them I consider it m that I consider their trade to be masonry but they're really not Masons these guys are so they own all this tall scaffold that's that's the
007way you would typically do masonry is you'd go all the way up and so I think it's because of the equipment they own is why they've chosen to do it the way they're doing it it may look like they're quite a ways behind the progress of the other building but I think if you took the top layer here and set it over there it would appear to be about the same they're moving along about the same maybe not quite as fast they these guys aren't quite as experienced but they're doing a great job work really looks really looks good see we're not quite done with floor slabs but the the goal is by the end of December to have the rest of the floor slabs for so progress is going well here this school um
008happy with the way things are moving along the weather's weather's been great couldn't ask for better better December construction weather we don't don't know how long it will last but trying to take advantage of it while it lasts um I do want to talk a little bit about the new elementary school um this is the the site layout as as it currently stands obviously you can see the where the new school will go we own this property here to the South it will be the main access uh for public um drop off uh loading areas here with with the staff parking this is this is bus access and drop off over right here on the North side um deliveries kitchen deliveries back here parking for kitchen staff up here behind the school and then this
009will be asphalt playground uh this will all be grass play areas over here this is what we anticipate the building is going to look like if you remember we've we've kind of stepped up into the hill this this lower level here is quite a bit smaller because of the Hill here then this upper level will extend back Beyond uh into the the top of the hill uh so looking at the floor plan the this is the first floor with admin area so the public will enter the building from the west down on the lower level we've got classrooms mechanical spaces um resource areas over here and the second floor the multi-purpose gym kitchen it's up on the upper level Media Center more classrooms up on up on the second level so that's that's where we're
010at right now we're pretty well done with the programming the meetings that the architect has been having with with the staff here at the school district to to get all those uh programming issues addressed now it's pretty well in the architect's hands to to work out all the technical details and get the drawings completed we're anticipating our our goal is to have put this out to bid end of February first part of March so they they've got a tall order to to get all these construction drawings prepared during that time and I they're well on their way we're I'm still meeting with them on a weekly basis along with our contractor and all their Consultants as they discuss that I think Gary attends that meeting Spencer attends it as well but uh um moving along
011well quite pleased with with the design they've been very very responsive to our requests and our you know to make the building exactly what we want it to be that's pretty well all I have to report if there's any questions the area wouldd be happy to answer them I was just going to say even though this is the second floor as you go from the gymnasium out those back doors you were on ground level yeah this yeah you exited grade back here so students will will exit this door here to get out to the playground does that mean the roads that come in from the north the one that goes up around it'll climb up to that level as it swings around yeah okay thanks thanks Bruce that's super exciting uh next up we have
012um presented by Gary Thomas the summit Elementary School Land Trust Amendment Amy had a conflict this evening so she asked if I would just sit in for a minute um I think you got a copy of this let me just give a little background on why she's asking for this change they had written into their plan for the plc conference and to take some teachers down there and cover the subs and all of that but if you'll remember the last two years in the elementary we have been focusing on the letters program the phonic uh instruction that is going to go across the state we finished that with our district this last year and then the state has asked principals this year who also went through a a lighter version of the letters program if
013you will but now they've asked the principles to put together a plan on Chang management how will you now change what you were doing before with reading instruction to with new instruction with what uh information you've learned through this uh District leadership was in one room my principles were in another room both on state meetings and it was interesting because the first step that we came up with was before we do anything we need to get our PLC process a little more united uh aligned articulated and coordinated across the district funny thing is the principls came out of their meeting and they said we really think before we move too far down this road we need to be aligned with our PLC process so what we did this fall is we brought in someone and
014we brought our entire Elementary staff all of our teachers k6 together to go through this and and kind of get aligned on the PLC process well that trumped what Amy was going to do with her staff this year with the PLC conference and that's why she's asking for a change here and it was a large enough change that's a pretty good chunk of money um and and some changes in budgets that uh I asked her to to bring it before the board and and get your approval before she moves forward yeah her uh Kathy and I were at the school community council meeting where she presented it to them and it totally made sense with what she wanted to do yep well with what she needs to do since she lost her Title One funds
015yes yeah anyone have any questions for Gary all right thanks Gary that was short and sweet the record tonight next up we have uh Brittney Foster and Ashley Addis talking about a sensitive materials appeal at The District's level all right so we had two um we've had a few books um in our libraries be challenged for sensitive materials and two of those books um we've received an appeal from um parents for us to Recon to bring to the board for you to reconsider our um committee's decision so I believe um all the the appeal has been shared with you as have um all of the documents from the committee work so we thought we would share with you um how the Committees the reviews took place and then answer any questions you guys have great
016thank you I'll Ashley talk about it because she's the one that's handled most of the sure yeah the committee work um so we received the two that are in question that are being appealed right now the decision we received those requests over the summer um and then we because it was during the summer um we didn't do the initial um review which is the first step in our procedures until was like the first Friday of the of the school year so we needed to get PD under our belt and all that fun stuff um we did an initial review for plausibility um for I know why the Cage Bird Sings by Maya Angelo and for the handmaid's tale by Margaret Atwood those are the two that are being appealed and um in that initial review
017We and that's where required to be done by two people the executive director of teaching and learning and a teacher librarian or the library media specialist which is me um for plausibility is this a plausible claim so um for that we determined that when we looked at the excerpts and the submit the request that was submitted we we talked um and said yeah there's some plausibility here and we wanted it to go to objective committee um that was for handmaids for Cage Bird we did did not determine that there was plausibility so that sent it for our procedures directly to um subjective review and so then I formed a committee I worked with the um with one of the high schools to form an objective Committee in that objective committee we had an administrator an
018English department head and a parent um look at the objective criteria we wanted to have two parents there but the one parent ended up having a conflict but our procedures require that we have one parent in in that meeting um that group determined they were actually looking at two different books um that group determined that the handmaid's taale did not meet the objective criteria which then sent it to the subjective committee for review so then um in all of this you know we're learning this is our first time going through so um we got together with our Librarians we didn't want this process to be duplicated across all of our schools we wanted to make for and for sensitive materials requests we want to make a districtwide decision um because if it's deemed sensitive materials
019at one high school we felt and the Librarians made this decision they felt that it should be that um meet that criteria for all of our high schools so that's just maybe important background information um formed two committees the Committees were trained on the sensitive materials legislation I've used guidance from USB be they have a really nice flowchart that that we used and we're able to share with the committee just to kind of show walk through where we are in the process and then um they they were tasked with reading the the work as a whole and then meeting so we had um two committees one separate committees for each book and um on the Committees for handmaid taale we had three employees and four parents were're required to have at least one more parent
020than employees and for the Cage Bird we had four employees and five parents and they met discussed um actually many of the parents complimented the process after the and saying I'd be involved in this again and this is well organized um and anyway so the result of the committee's vote I guess um it doesn't have to be unanimous but um I guess majority rules but in both committees it was unan that it did not meet the criteria for subjective sensitive materials and so then I notified both requesters and then now both requesters of those have now submitted appeal to the board so what questions do you have I know I talk fast well I would like to make a comment and and express my appreciation for making sure that um if there is uh um
021a book challenge that it's a district committee that looks at it and it's a districtwide decision yeah because the time it takes um from and the cost therefore the cost to the district to run one of those committees um is extensive so I appreciate you um making sure that that's efficient and effect as well as effective yeah for um the district as a whole so thank you for doing that thank you I would like to add also that the Librarians have done a great job of communicating with each other so when they do come across a book that they feel like isn't appropriate for the libraries it's a team decision and they all pull it from their schools so it's not one librarian's going rogue or you know so they are very United in their
022approach to ensuring we have um good content in our libraries so I think when you presented to um the board leadership yeah did you say that both of those books will not be in the M middle schools no they're only going to be in the high schools um Cage bird was in um the north cach it's it's obviously you know it's it's not a new book we'll just say that um and so it had been in in North cash and I think probably it had been there since it was maybe a nth Grade Center or maybe an 89 Center um anyway the committee did did make the um the recommendation or the set the criteria that it would only it only is appropriate for circulation um or on the Shelf in the library um at
023the high school level So yeah thank you for reminding me to say that were these books required uh reading in classes or were they just available in the great question um no they're they're just available for Choice reading in the library okay how often are these books checked out you know what to be quite honest not that often um there's not your your average high school kid is not looking to pick up Maya Angelo um but we do have to serve a wide variety of of interests and um reading skills we've got kids that are taking AP Literature um that that is their their their excitement about reading they really do like to get into into the more complex literature so we have to serve all ends of that have either of these books been
024challenged in other districts in the state yes I can't I don't know which ones specifically I do know that um Davis has been one that has um but I'm not sure on other districts I can find that out for you if you'd like do we know the outcome of the Davis district on they kept both books kept both so both have been challenged and they were retained in both book in both districts I mean both books were retained in the district which is essentially the decision of the committee of our District's committee cor is that um that they be retained at the high school level okay for Choice reading not not for assignment for whole classwork right got it how are parents and teachers invited to participate in this committee how is that committee processed
025turn yeah great question so um our Librarians have each individually had um book review committees usually they'll use um their Community Council or some some combination of community council and interested parents um so we had I had some parents that the Librarians gave me um their contact info just because they'd been involved in committee work um either with the library or in other capacities at the high schools before um but then at the beginning of the year in the parent memo um Britney put in a form for parents to apply to um basically request to be involved in oh in this work in the sex ad curriculum and the new planning of the sixth grade for the anyway so they these parents opted themselves in to be involved I yeah and you said that the
026decisions were unanimous on both of them okay did you you say your wife has read this read either of these books she started reading handmaid tell okay cuz she's teaching she's teaching language arts she's the language arts teacher originally right okay she's lovely too so if if you don't have any more questions about the books I did want to point out in your materials you should have received a memorandum from Kurt McCrae M given that the board is is an appellant body and um it's likely that other appeals may come from other areas he's tried to craft some guidance for you to whether accept or or reject as you're considering these appeals as they come forward and it's looking at ensuring that we followed all of our policies procedures State statutes that we have made
027a good faith effort uh that there hasn't been any external internal influences that have maybe jaded the process that we haven't abused our discretion in any way in coming to a decision or exceeded our Authority um and it gives you the the allowance to accept that as guidance um and make a determination um if you feel like we have maybe overstepped in any of those areas uh you could take this on yourself or you could simply turn it back to the district we could form new committees and go through that process again as back finding so I just want to clarify that for the board I know that this is a new new process um and thinking about your role as an Appel body so if I hear you if I understand you correctly and
028after reading Kirk's memo um we have three options we can act as a body of appe or as a committee of appeal and just and review the um process and make sure that it was done correctly um or we can become a uh book review committee and re-review the books and make our own decision or we can turn it back to the district are those the three options that you just said so as a board what would you like to do do you want to re-review the books yourselves it sounds like there's been pretty thorough review yeah I think already I don't know if it's necessary do you want the district to put together another committee to re-review it I don't think they need to do that again so that leaves us to the last
029item the last um possibility which is that we just become a board of appeals and then at our next meeting after reading through all of the information then we will come to a decision about whether the process was followed correctly and um the six or seven questions that Kirk um put in his memo that we need to make sure that we can answer um in the affirmative that everything was followed properly so is that's what I would lean towards okay anybody you're exceptionally quiet you complimenting me on that gratified no no you just look like you're thinking very deeply and so I I'm I mean I think as an appellate panel the the issue is were were the guidelines of the of the legislation not followed in some way I mean in other words is
030their grounds based on how the procedure was followed and so I just completely concur with everybody because that that really is the question I mean I I think that's why it's not that great of an idea to re-review because you know that that's what an appell body does is it it it just tries to ensure that the law was followed basically and so the the grounds for the appeal should point out why they feel like the procedure wasn't followed and and we that's that's what we should be weighing not the decision of the you know the review panel itself if that makes sense mhm totally Randall any thoughts no I agree completely okay so then I have heard from each of you that you want to act as an appellate body and we will do
031that at our next meeting which will be our business meeting on the 19th correct awesome okay great thank you both for coming to present that to us we appreciate your work thank you thank you okay next up on our agenda we have presented by superintendent mcke teacher Merit P yes thanks for your email to help us get prepared for that absolutely um hopefully it was helpful uh as you may recall the legislature this past session passed a SB 173 uh which was the market-based incentive program for teachers we've spent a lot of time in the district looking this over there's been a lot of Engagement with the center for schools of the future at Utah State University trying to understand this we felt like it was really important to bring the board up to speed
032as we have to make a decision by the end of this month of whether or not we intend to participate and so um I want to first and foremost thank my staff The District staff overall um there's been a lot of time a lot of energy spent on this as we've gone back and forth and looked at it very carefully and very closely um so I want to thank them first and foremost publicly for their all their input and their efforts around this um we've engaged uh schools leaders ship around this as well to try to get their their input and we intend to move forward as we'll talk for uh later here about engaging our staff because it really comes down to impacting them uh but to start this off I thought uh it
033would be best for Tim maybe to spend a few minutes unpacking the bill so that the board had full understanding of what's in the in the legislation and then I'll follow up with some of our thoughts in terms of our concerns uh some of our best thinking around this and then talk about next steps okay I apologize there's a for those of you with your back to the screen there's a little bit of a PowerPoint I think it's um easier to go through some of this so Senate Bill 173 title was market-based compensation uh it's been renamed by the center for the School of the Future as a teacher merit award program and so that's what they're referring to it now the actual Senate Bill had two components to it um many of our schools
034uh or teachers in our district get comp extra compensation if they're in math science or special education it's currently called a tssp program uh that's being changed to a What's called the shine program and it's administered by the state right now but will'll move to districts next year so we'll be coming and visiting with you about that portion of Senate Bill uh 73 at a later time uh the other half of the legislation has to do with this teacher merit award system so um let's just start with what the intent of of that teacher merit award system um it's a pilot program its stated intention of the program is to increase teacher retention especially in high poverty schools and to increase recruitment of new teachers so that's that's the basic intent of the bill the
035legislature allocated $150 million to this pilot program that's about a 3% addition on the wpu but this is one-time money it's not ongoing funding uh it's to be administered by the center for the School of the Future at Utah State University so that's um just right here under our own umbrella here um and the center by the by the way has done a a good job in providing information sessions to school districts I've attended a couple of those as they um try to unpack this bill and help us understand uh a little more about where they're headed with with the bill itself but I'm going to just walk you through the fundamentals of the bill and not go into a a great deal of detail but give you the kind of an overview so basically
036the bill um seeks to reward the top 25% of your teachers in your District um and differentiate their compensation based on that that performance and so you can see they have these categories along the left hand side Master exemplary and recognized so if you're in the top 5% your merit award would be $10,000 6 to 10% $55,000 and 11 to 25% $2,000 unless you happen to be in a high poverty school and then those amount would be doubled we do not have any schools in the cash County School District that meet the criteria for a high poverty School the uh even though we have Title One schools the threshold is they either um I think it's 20% maybe it's 30% of intergenerational poverty the closest school we have to that about 6% most of our
037schools are 2 to 3% and then the other threshold is a 70% uh of the population on free and reduced lunch the closest we come to that is just over 40% in a couple of our schools so we're not close to reaching those thresholds in any of our our schools um the proposed criteria by the legislature that we're supposed to measure teacher Effectiveness onor our top 25% are the um student achievement and growth data professional evaluation of the teacher parent survey or they leave this category an optional category open for um other criteria that we could use these two additions down here were uh suggested by the center for the School of the Future they're not in the legislation itself and neither is the waiting there's nowhere in the legislation that says how these criteria
038should be weighted but as the center for the School of the Future Has unpacked that this is the waiting that they are recommending um for the bill and you can see there's a great deal of waiting on student achievement and growth data um which is purposeful because that's one of the only areas you can you can use a problematic in for several reasons which um we'll talk about which um in a few minutes so so the bill def finds those kpis over there that's that that is you're a business guy kpis yeah okay people don't know what those are are but that is what that the bill does Define that uhhuh okay yeah y all right so um realizing that a lot of weight's going to be put on the student um achievement and growth
039data uh the center for the School of the Future has hired a third party to help them with what's called a value added growth model and without getting into the weeds um the basic premises is you got a long the bottom here A K through five scenario an achievement on your vertical axis here and students should be making expected progress as they move up between grade levels and the basic value added model says if a teacher makes uh makes growth up here then they they fall into that 25% they'd come up with the modeling and the calculations to calculate that and teachers that are doing better at moving the needle on that growth that growth model does that make sense that's probably a they've done a good job laying this slide out for just a
040simple explanation of that I want to jump um into the timeline just a little bit um because it it helps you understand how this bill lays out because it's kind of unique so basically we have until um December 31st to decide as a school district whether we opt into the pilot okay and it's a one-time opt-in and a you can see out here on the end dates we're into 28 29 so it's a one-time optin for um about a three-year project in the spring the school district would lay out its plan for um how we would measure student or teacher Effectiveness based on those criteria what what we're going to use as our metrics um we've already and so is the center for the con School of the Future conceited with that with Val validity
041and reliability issues probably the only thing we're going to be able to look at is tested subjects we just don't have enough developed as far as valid and reliable measures for our untested subjects so that right there becomes problematic because you leave a lot of teachers out of the the ability to compete for these These funds um so that's problematic already but that's something I think both groups conceding going into this uh somewhat with the short timeline that the legislature has given us can I ask a question right there so isn't the bill focused on English Math and Science no it's not the the the portion of the bill that's focused on those three is the extra compensation if you go into those fields that already not it's already in place yeah yep so then
042um once we get our system in place we will spend the the 26 27 school year measuring teachers both with the their student achievement what their uh professional evaluations look like what parent surveys might look like and any other criteria that we propose and basically in this year we identify what teachers we consider our 25 top 25% we submit those to the state once the state approves those um teachers the money starts flowing in this year and then the basic premise of the study which I I believe is also problematic is um they're going to basically compensate those teachers for those three years and then determine you remember what their premise was that this will include it will um increase student or teacher retention and recruitment those are hard variables to isolate that this compens
043ation is the causal relationship for why we're retain or even correlational is going to be difficult in this environment because there's so many reasons that teachers um move and and do those types of things so so Tim how does it sustain after the fact you said it was onetime money right yep and so at the end then we're just hoping that there's going to be more money or yeah it's a pilot program to see if they move the need and and that's really at the discretion of the legislature on when CSF reports back to them whether they continue to fund that and that's one of the it's one of the problems with the legislation is it's the funding is volatile yeah so so one other question on if you go back to the kpis is
044the is the the waiting on the Delta on the the the student achievement or is it on the overall score meaning that if if there was an improvement during the year that that happened are they just looking at the Delta Improvement or are you looking at the how much more are they up on the with the score test scores yeah if you know there's a whole formulaic thing behind our current growth models that look at putting kids in cohorts and doing some of that work and to get into the weaves of how the value added model is going to to look at that I don't I don't have that at this time I guess the reason if I was a teacher then I'm posturing myself for a certain group of kids right I mean that's
045how I'm going to be successful is if I if I get a certain group but if I'm if I'm The Unlucky One for lack of a better word you know then that that's not that could be problematic also yeah you're not going to want any sped kids you're not going to want any English language Learners you're not not going to want any kids who have problems at home you're going to want the cream of the crop it's it's hugely problematic because that that kind of Assortment in classes is not random no at all and and all the this entire model assumes that you have random assortment basically okay sorry Tim go ahead that no you're fine you are very astute because um I'm going to just step through some common Arguments for um and there's
046a lot of text on the screen but I want you to to focus on what I've kind of highlighted in in bold and that'll help before you on can I make a comment too so my experience has been that usually the really great teachers they the however they schedule it they put those harder kids with that teacher as well which would make another problem yeah yeah there's all kind of confounding variables in this in this so you're absolutely right um all right I'm just going to go through some common Arguments for because I think it's important to to see both sides of this issue and why why States there's several States moving to this um type of a model or have tried it and uh to varying degrees of of success uh the idea that
047Merit can incentivize teachers so that incentive uh culture of continuous Improvement and motivate teachers so there's that whole motivational incentivizing uh feature of the bill uh tying compensation to focus on improving student achievement and an outcome driven approach um that's that's a common kti business model is you're you're working on an outcome approach so um that's one of the arguments for um attracting top teaching Talent um if you look at some countries like um Finland or Singapore who have raised the overall salary of teachers with the idea that if you raise the overall salary of teachers you're going to attract more to the profession that's what they're going for here as well on the on the recruitment aspect of this um the difficulty is it's your you know it's not your entire system they're raising
048the level of Employments they're just raising it for 25% so um that it would encourage teachers to pursue professional development again that's that motivation to focus on results get better uh Drive accountability a results oriented approach to teaching and school management uh motivated teachers would be motivated to try uh Innovative teaching methods it creates a school culture that values and rewards Excellence um I think that's in our value statement as a district we want we value excellence that's certainly something we believe in as a school district uh a performance-based pay system can build trust and confidence among parents in the community by demonstrating schools are investing and hiring in and rewarding high quality teachers that's definitely an an argument for as well can you go back to that slide actually I mean I I don't
049think anybody would argue with any of those bll points I mean of course you know a merit-based system is going to incentivize you know if you have incentives aligned then performance is going to improve I mean there's no question um but what we don't have in that list of bullet points is the how you know I I mean uh I know we're going to talk about the way that um that CSF is making the recommendation you know the the structure of that the scaffolding you know their their strategy but but it's the how that matters you know all of that is true but I I just don't want to get blinded by the fact that you know that's all true the question is the how you know is is the CFS is the CSF plan
050adequate to do that I just want to make sure we're clear on that because you know I don't want to use these bullet points which are all absolutely true as a smoke shield for what is actually going to be implemented yeah yeah then that's a great great Point Chris is um as you look at the fors and againsts that's only a part of the picture um the methods that are used and and those types of things and even if you get even take it a step further to the to the consequences of some of those methods um along the way is important to kind of consider as well so I'm just going to run through these common arguments against um accurately evaluating teacher Effectiveness is complex um often subjective common measures like uh student test
051scores can be inconsistent and may not fully capture a teacher's impact um there's some studies out there that that show that um test scores really measure relatively a small percentage of a teacher's impact on a student depending on what factors you're looking at student outcomes are often influenced by factors beyond a teacher's control um socioeconomic status parent involvement individual learning differences uh can be difficult to ensure the Val validity and reliability of standardized measures that's tough in and of itself just for the standardized measures we have imagine trying to then lay this over the untested subjects with um content areas that are much more difficult like PE and Ceramics yeah PE or the art and and the amount of Labor that that would be required to come up with measures that are valid and reliable
052is is a challenge as well uh May unintentionally encourage teachers to teach to the test um in many subjects students are taught by different teachers so you don't have the same English teacher the same math teacher for the entire even a course sometimes so how do you differentiate which teacher added value um to that student so those are those are problematic as well uh limitations of using a value added model for high-stake decision making um there's a lot of um research out there to suggest these value added models are really problematic when it comes to measuring teacher Effectiveness and so um a lot of this is going to be based on one of those valid uh value added models well this value you said earlier this is a business model that's pretty common and it
053works for circuit boards when that's your output but we're not making circuit boards we're building kids good point uh you're limiting 25% of the district's teacher will benefit from this funding and if you take that and cut that even further if we have to narrow the focus on tested subjects you're limiting that group group even further um who gets to participate uh can discourage and this is one I've heard from teachers um as causing a lot of concern is discouraging teamwork and sharing of resources and ideas and an overall culture of collective e efficacy um some of the strongest um effects sizes in education is that idea of collective efficacy and if you're all of a sudden competing with one another for resources um that Collective e efficacy can become Pro problematic and you saw
054that the center for the School of the Future on those other factors added collaboration is maybe another um criteria that they would suggest we add and I think that's plain to that idea that you don't want to deinen divize people collaborating because that's a pretty powerful tool for us in education as well um teachers may feel demoralized if they perceive it's unfair it's um again it's really hard to to lay a blanket over a system that's as complex as a school system and to make this fair for the subject you happen to teach the type of students you happen to work with uh because what you chose to go into if you're a special ed or an ESL teacher um that's that's a pretty hard needle to move for some of our most challenged kids
055and yet those those teachers work harder I would say than the a lot of our teachers just in the clientele they serve on a daily basis uh encourages teachers to want to be selective this is this is one that really I think plays to my heart a little bit is um when we and one of you mentioned that when we start having teachers be selective of the students they want to teach or students be selective of the teachers they want um can become problematic as too and really tie the hands of Administrators who uh we already see that in our our tssp program when teachers are getting compensated for teaching math and they won't they don't want to take on another class that's outside of that because they lose compensation for that and so those
056those kind of things are problematic um they require robust data collection evaluation processes expensive and timec consuming to administer effectively and then the one that um you mentioned Jeff about funding sources Maybe be unreliable and again to be fair to the legislature this this is stated as a pilot program but um it's a significant amount of money for a pilot on the wpu and then to try to sustain that Beyond um this project is just looking down the road that that can be problematic as well well you think about how much money money and time you're going to invest just to establish the system right and then if we don't have a way of maintaining it after the fact you've invested all this time and money into that establishment and if it doesn't go forward
057what do we gain um there's there's a state study that's been um that's out there we can put into your hands that uh indicates um varying levels of success different states have had with implementing Merit based systems um some have been more successful others we don't have a lot of some of them they don't have enough time in it to to really make some judgments of where they're at so there's there's a guide book that the center for the School of the Future puts out um that's the high poverty definition but I'll turn the time back over to the superintendent to kind of add some additional thoughts thank you Tim I appreciate um you unpacking that and uh you know he's he's done I think a fairly nice job of pointing out the arguments for
058and against I I hope you can see that this is a significant change um in the working conditions and what we are asking of would be asking of teachers it would put the district in a situation where we would start to rank order teachers across the district to determine how how if they would fall into this Merit pay um that that's that's a big Challenge and and I I think that we need to be very cautious and thoughtful about this um it was interesting that the legislative auditor put together a report in preparation for this bill and in their audit report there were a number of recommendations that the Auditors pointed out um first and foremost it was interesting that the bill is is its objective is retention Recruitment and incentives and the auditor specifically
059called out and said that as a state not necessarily districts but as a state we don't appear to have a retention problem problem so right there it begs that question what are we trying to achieve what's what problem are we trying to solve you know does it does it really help us with recruitment it it may you know Tim I think did a nice job pointing out that as you increase salaries that recruits more in right um but yet this doesn't do it across the board this this puts us in this situation where teachers are now having to compete uh and when they start to compete somebody loses in any competition and I think we have to be really thoughtful of that the other idea is this idea that incentivizes good teaching and I think
060you know this is I I think to Chris's point we don't argue with the what in many regards but the how the how is always the key and do do we get there with the how in this particular situation um a couple of things that um the Auditors went on and pointed out that you know in order to do this they identified kpis the Auditors made suggestions that we have problems even with those kpi and how we should as a state try to address those so first and foremost there is a lot of uh variance in how districts evaluate teachers um it pointed out that uh surveying parents is problematic and is not always transparent and it was interesting that the Auditors themselves even said that the state data that we use to measure growth
061may be really insufficient and is actually lacking in many areas across across the board before looking at all of our teachers and they made some recommendations that we we start to look at that I found it interesting that the response to address those recommendations those concerns was in the scaling you'll notice if we were to go back to the scaling we there was a heavy emphasis on growth and a minimizing of evaluation parent input and other factors I I don't know that that I to me um seems to we need to seem to unpack that a little more because you know Tim pointed out there's some states that have tried this this has actually been tried quite a bit across the country and failed AC for many for many years with really really mixed results
062and even this concept of you know the state Tim pointed out that state tests aren't always the best measure of teacher impact that there are a lot of other things that are actually contributing to that score even the statistical model that they're trying to use has real problems and it's troubling to me that if we were to push into this a teacher could be identified in the first year but in the very next year they would go from exemplary to not rating at all and it and it's interesting that teacher only has to qualify once that they're not looking at ongoing exemplary behavior right that that's that's problematic at the model for me um a couple of couple of things that really jumped out to the leader ship team as we process this you know
063that um first and foremost in terms of our values as a district the lack of equity that we can't look at exemplary teaching across the board that it really at this initial stage pushes us into looking at only tested subjects because of the waiting we all recognize that are they exemplary teachers outside those tested subjects and they're often times their impact is not felt until years down the road right that teaching the outcomes of teaching are emergent and and we lose sight of that that's where this is really different than I think a more business model where you have cause and effect to outcome and it's much easier to then to incentivize outcome because there's cause and effect is much much more difficult to to to identify cause and effect in a learning process that
064is so iterative iterative and um you know it's not a linear necessarily linear progression for every child uh so Equity is a big one the reliability or unreliability of the data that you could qualify one year and not qualify the next year based off simply the composition of your class you know and the third is we're really concerned about how this impacts our culture we've spent a lot lot of time talking about culture uh Tim pointed out that we already are struggling with differentiate differentiated pay where where teachers are qualifying for extra pay from the state for math science special ed and we're having principles are having a hard time getting those teachers to take on the more challenging kids because those classes don't qualify for the extra pay that's that's a huge concern to
065you know how it's it's hard to say we're putting students first in that case you know our culture it's interesting that as I've had conversations over the last several weeks with with teachers and and administrators and our team you know I this is something we should celebrate in Cash Valley that in 2008 when the recession hit and the district was forced to make cuts that teachers vote that we would take those cuts equally across the board rather than go through a riff that there was this idea that we're all in this together and then a couple of years ago when it came back and the legislature said we're going to give an extra 8% just for teachers and as a district we made the decision that wasn't good enough we're we are going to do
066that for all employees right so that this this I think really will challenge this idea of our culture of being collaborative and being a community and I want to I want to make sure we're really thoughtful about going forward with this Our intention at this point is we want to make sure that you're fully aware we want to make sure that we get your input if you have thoughts on this but Our intention is now to make sure that teachers have the opportunity to learn because it's such a significant amount of money the last thing we want to do is deny any teacher additional compensation they all deserve additional compensation but we want to make sure that they're aware of the consequences and ramifications of this and elicit their feedback before we make a final
067decision by the 31st questions comments that you might have those of those of us that have taught school understand what it's about and your class class is not the same every year the students you get are different uh you know so it's hard to say well you're exemplary teacher right now but then next year you get the class that nobody wants and every school has those kids and that makes it hard to compete against others you know out of total fairness Tim brought this up you know what what we would hear on the other side is that the statistical modeling is trying to look at growth and that tries to to minimize that that variance from year to year but yet the evidence that's out there even the most recent systematic reviews of the evidence
068have shown that this is still problematic that the statistical modeling is not sensitive enough to to adjust and to isolate those variables I I don't think it would help with retention I think it would make it worse you'd have teachers who have just worked their guts out all year and have been exemplary but they don't get the money so now I'm not staying here if they don't appreciate me yeah you're incentivizing 25% disincentivizing 75% I mean seems absurd yeah it it it there are instances around the country New York City is one Los Angeles has attempted this Tennessee others there another outcome potential outcome is it's increased the stress on teachers and has actually driven them out to your point in the Los Angeles example is really interesting because I read about that and the
069Los Angeles Times decided to publish the rank order list of teachers and it turned out that it could the analysis couldn't even be replicated and and so you know but but on once you know once that kind of harm has been perpetrated then you know talk about the proverbial putting the toothpaste back in the tube then just just like you pointed out um Tim then uh there's been this massive misclassification which leads to you know kind of these perverse choices that that students and parents start making well again that I think underscores just the fundamental nature of teaching is different than you would find in say engineering or or any other professional field right that there's a collective effort a collective impact you know if you think on the secondary level the measure if you're
070looking at student outcomes around writing or reading it's very difficult to nail down was that the social studies teacher that was really into literacy that was helping that student or was the the ELA teacher to determine that is it gets really Tri tricky at the elementary level we we're starting to see you know within grade level teams teachers are saying hey you're the you're the best math teacher let's let's rotate kids through and you teach the math I'll teach the science yeah that would end that would end it would totally like this a lot of what the work the work has been around collaboration and trying to focus in on what what's best for kids and turn the focus more on how do I make sure I'm getting compensated the best I can again we
071want every teacher to be compensated well we don't want to Dy any of them but it starts to pit these things against each other and that undermines culture can I just make a couple comments for the group on the statistical part of this um you know putting aside all these other issues which are as are more important than just the data analysis itself um you know I'll I'll uh I guess invoke my expertise you know because I am PhD level data scientists that's what I do for a living and the statistical model that's being used here is appalling absolutely I mean can you go back to that slide with the uh with the AI generated woman pointing at the graph I mean this plot e even though uh you know the CSF report you know
072that you distributed um sort of waves their hands at the complexity of these models but this plot itself kind of explains why this is so problematic I mean of course at the end of the plot you see this nice Green Dot the actual versus the expected but what if the year is one of the gray dots that's below the line I mean that that that's that's the randomness that that really would create such a disincentive because you know as Roger and Kathy have rightly pointed out and I think Tim you as well I mean there's a huge luck of the draw here uh that that is impossible to isolate now I know that in theory you know these value added models they claim that you can isolate that but as you pointed out you cannot
073I mean my Professional Organization the American ciso Association came out with a statement about this back in 2014 where they were talking about value added models and uh and they pointed out that you know uh they uh I guess Collective research suggests that only like somewhere between 1 and 14% of that that kind of performance can be can be isolated to a teacher I mean that is a tiny percent of the variability in student achievement and so you basically are subjecting teachers to a a lottery you know more or less because you know teachers across the district are outstanding they're great so you're trying to distinguish between people who are all like you said Cathy they're all striving they're all doing their best and so really this is boiling down to you know which batch
074they got that year because we don't have you know extensive enough data to isolate that kind of impact but the second thing that is a huge concern about the csfs um report that they came out with is that they want the district to make a decision by December 31st uh but in their report when they talk about the statistical methodology itself which again comprises at least 55% of the waiting um and you know I mean I I don't I don't want Gary to lose any bets today so I won't poke any more holes in it but there are a lot so but but just putting aside you know uh putting aside whether whether the model is even accurate which it's not and I say that as emphatically as I can I mean it's a very
075poor approach in terms of you know uh some sort of uh statistical analysis that would objectively help you to identify these effects um but but even if it did um the CSF has has proposed that they release more information about it after December 31st so in other words they they kind of did some hand waving in the report and and I I I don't you know they're trying to respond to the legislature and so I I don't want to sound like I'm being dismissive or anything but it's a huge concern when this is going to impact lives in in meaningful real ways and yet don't worry you can opt in by the 31st but we'll give you more detail about it you know in the new year so we don't even have um you know
076we don't have even have all the detail available in terms of how SAS by the way you know SAS is a very respected um company out of ker South Carolina they're a juggernaut they they create uh you know for years they've been the purveyors of statistical software that's very widely used in data science now they provide a lot of Consulting Services as well um software is of service and so on so they're a behemoth and and they're the ones who are kind of the third party that's been hired um uh there's one guy there who's worked at SAS for a long time a statistician who is the expert in this value added model thing um but he he's the one who drove this whole corner of of the SAS companies kind of Consulting in this
077this area but statisticians by a large outside of SAS you know who have paid serious attention to value added models um have deep deep concerns which are summarized in that in that American cisal Association report and so you know you're right Tim you're absolutely right in pointing out that well here in our case we have data specific to cash County School District so SAS is going to come in and put that through the sausage maker but we have no idea you know what the inputs are going to be um and what you know how how the these models are going to be calibrated at all um because that's stuff that's going to be shared after you know the district actually opts in I mean how many of us would go to a doctor you know
078who would say well I'm scheduling the surgery for this date and I'll explain to you what I'm doing after I I mean it it makes no sense whatsoever and so while I know that the timeline they're under a lot of pressure because the timeline's abbreviated um because of the nature of the leg legislation they're putting the cash County School District in a very difficult position by having them make decisions based on very complex things that uh you know that can't clearly be explained to a lay person um you know in time for us to actually make a a rational decision about it the other point too that concerns me is we have worked so hard with this school board to build a culture where teachers feel appreciated and loved and we care about them and
079we want to help them and we appreciate them and we're going to give all of you an equal bonus because we love each one of you so much and in my opinion this will wreck all of that how many years have we been at least a decade that I know how many years have we been trying I'm looking at Gary have we been working to get the PLC process to work well at least uh 13 or 14 because I my last two years were when it started yeah you say that's about right yeah well over a decade well over yet in some schools you'll have a grade level or a department that can do it well and yet the next grade level or the next Department May struggle uh you have some schools that better
080than other but yeah it's an ongoing process but we've put a lot of blood sweat tears into collabor developing that process of collaboration whether it's in grade levels at the elementary or in subject teams at the secondary level um this would in my mind this would throw that out the window I really wish that we had a little more latitude to determine the incentives and our incentive structure would incentivize that kind of work and teachers that want to get national board certified that are working in lots of different ways that we know impact student outcome differently because I believe that would get us much farther down the road than what this potentially will do and how much more work does this create for the district it will shift it will shift our work sub stantially
081in terms of how we evaluate how we assess it'll impact instruction and and assessment we'd have to build new systems out if we're really believing that this is about we need to include every teacher which we do we'd have to somehow come up with um reliable valid student growth measures in all subjects how do you do that in PE if K starts out at five push-ups at the beginning of the tri that's why I always say run a run a 12-minute mile and that's an EAS are what are the options then you we either are in or we're out and the 130 million stays with this program there's no chance it's going to change it wouldn't come to us we the decision is are we going to be part of the the pilot or not
082okay got it that's that's the decision all right so we need to have that vote at our next meeting yeah is that the the board making a decision to vote Yes yes can you um between now and that meeting have information because you said you wanted to talk with teachers yes so can you have that information by then I believe we can have that in time let me explain that process a little bit because you know surveying is challenging um and particularly when you're trying to get meaningful results of that so we're looking at um we need a certain response rate to even have a meaning make a meaningful decision from that we set a threshold of 80 arbitrarily and we've said within that 80 80% resp 80% 80% response feel like we had a
083substantial enough participation to make a a a decision of this magnitude and the Ian you know my practice has been whenever you're doing a large uh systems change you need at least 66% in the affirmative to move forward so what we've suggest said is we need to have a really really high threshold of response to have a make a meaningful decision and within that response at least 66% of the teachers would have to indicate this is where we need to go to move forward and to understand what they're even on yeah that's what I that's pretty complicated to have to teach all that in a couple days and then do your survey and get results back let's do a one day vam Workshop well we we've we've tried to we recognize that because when when
084you just talk about dollars people it's easy to to glance over everything else and say oh yeah everyone wants to increase their pay um we're we're trying really hard to get the word out uh there's an email that's already been crafted the letter that you have is going out there are documents for and against as well as an explanation of the bill we're frontloading this with school leadership tomorrow so that they can be fully aware before teachers even see it next week how how are the teachers going to see it it'll come as an email from my from my account okay that that even by itself is kind of onerous it is you know because then they have to read it in December right and you're a teacher and all you're trying to do is
085like do your job and and do it well and now you've got to actually you know spend hours reading something right I mean what are you going to like I mean value added models are at least 55% of this evaluation crit what what are you going to do spend a whole weekend immersing yourself in that so I I mean it just seems like a lot of responsibility to to to actually ask people to weigh in on something that is going to so directly impact them that uh I don't know well we certainly can think about that differently between now and the next board meeting um I do know that there is already a bit of a buzz among in the schools as we've gone out and have done our listening sessions this fall we've we've
086gone out to we're going out to every school we have we're not quite done yet but many of the schools have started to bring up questions about maripe what is this help help us understand so we know the words getting out there but is it sufficient to say that they're well informed to make give us input um we'll we'll think about that even more on how we give its due diligence so teachers are um making the best decision they can can I just make one suggestion that might be maybe kind of pie in the sky but something we want to explore going forward um and and you kind of alluded to this earlier I mean there are different ways of incentivizing good performance because any any good manager knows that people on your team have
087different strengths that often complement each other and this you know plays to a particular strength that that may or may not even be measured in a valid way you know but but we can think of lots of I mean you listed a couple you know certifying a certain area like things that have to do with professional development or growth that that you know make you a better teacher um we we talked about one you know a couple of meetings ago as we reward teachers who are uh maybe willing to teach a slightly larger class for a year I mean there are different ways of incentivizing productivity Y and and you know uh I guess performance that will be really impactful for students and so I I think you know I don't think anybody again argues
088with any of the pros of meray I mean that that's fantastic but it may be that that to you know to kind of honestly be Innovative about this in the future and pursue that goal it might be nice to have a larger strategy in the district that actually recognizes those different strengths those different Pathways different contributions that people make and and ensure that there are Pathways for you know because I you know part part of you is kind of like oh so you're leaving you know how many X number of hundreds of thousands of dollars on the table is for cash County District or a couple million but the damage that that money could do I mean it's it's like the bag of 30 pieces of silver I mean you're you're trading away huge potential
089uh benefits just for a short-term financial gain for a relative handful of people for only three years yeah and so in the long run it might be it might be a great strategy to just make sure that we're innovating in in a way that's responsive you know to important stakeholders in the state you know people in the legislature and parents and so on that that that that we are and the teachers are incentivized because they know that maybe there's not just one way of defining that we we'd love the idea of finding other ways to incentivize our teachers and the work that they're doing is don't know that this is the right way to do it yeah so in other words to kind of diversify those those incentives would be extremely positive I just going
090to give kudos to Britney's team they're working on I mean not only the instructional coaching that we've done and then they're working on the national board certification cohort this year and some of those things are already in progress to to kind of up um the level of expertise of our employees and and have been going on for a while and and now other programs that are being developed so I think we're doing some good things anything else that we can address for you this evening we've had some heavy discussions not unless Gary had the over he lost does every District in the state have this opportunity every okay every every district and every Charter something that I just to make sure I'm clear on this all the districts when they have their top 25% they
091pull them all together in one big lump sum and then s up for future schools whatever you state schools of the future then they then they rank them again so say we have somebody that's top 5% when we put them into the whole state maybe they're 10% or 5% so there's no guarantee that we'll have you know 5% of just our district well the other thing that Tim didn't mention with this bill is that Charters are first they get to opt in first and then districts um according to how that um bill is written and there are 250 charter schools in the state the other thing too The Waiting once everything is submitted the school Utah state will then average out everything so we might say we want 55% just in student assessment but when
092they average everything out maybe it changes to 65% so it's very different than what we they've already come out and stated it will be 68% 68 so there's yeah they're mandating how can so many people think so crazy sorry 60 once you submit your your group so if we were to say to your point you know students uh growth is 55% we we create this pool of teachers we submit it they'll go through and rank all them based off their own uh criteria and student growth is 68% yeah and and why do they even give the option in a 55 to 75 I don't know but I mean you know like I said fundamentally and this is a huge statistical problem there is complete non-randomness here and and so Charter Schools yeah because Charter Schools
093already are an optin yeah so it's an opt-in within an opt-in and so you know the the the results are going to be so wildly inaccurate I guarantee that if they hired another third party to come and and replicate this it would be not replicable at all I mean it just won't be um and so uh so anyway once you start including self- selected samples well you know then then you you B basically have a garbage in garbage out problem y thank you I appreciate your uh your input it's been a great conversation so uh we'll continue to work on this and get you information prior to the board meeting of the night tape great anyone else have something they want to say our District's awesome I really like you know we've had some really
094um intense conversation it's been really really healthy because everyone's been focused on I believe the right things which is about students yeah and our staff so hurry over to my house for our party so can laugh and eat last chance before I say see we have reached the end of our agenda we will adj