001Mr nutland would you lead us in a flag salute I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Sunshine Law statement all requirements of the open public meetings act have been met for this meeting of the Board of Education of the bur of ell notice of this meeting was filed with the record in town news and all persons requesting such notice Mr Darian would you read the mission statement the ordell public school district is dedicated to the ongoing pursuit of educational Excellence through comprehensive in Innovative curriculum and instruction the district is committed to providing opportunities for social emotional and academic Discovery to Foster curiosity courage and character our goal is to prepare our
002students become lifelong learn ERS who are self-directed resilient productive responsible citizens thank you roll call on the RO Mr Del Greco here Mr Daran here Mrs Downey here Mrs Moran here Mr nutland here Mrs Walker here Mr Walsh will not be here Mrs noran Mrs Nichols here open to the public for agenda items only not seeing any at this time um I would like to invite our auditor Mr Jeff Bliss to present the 24 uh 232 24 order report everyone good thank you good evening everyone thank you for having me here tonight to present the audit um for the year end of June 30th 2024 our main responsibility uh when completing the audit uh and after examining the books and Records is to EXP Express an opinion on your financial statements whether they are fairly
003stated prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles and whether there were any scope limitations in the audit um our opinion was unmodified which means a clean opinion meaning the financial statements are fairly stated that prepared accordance with generally accepted accounting principles and there were no scope limitations in performing the audit we also are required to express Express an opinion on your compliance with major federal financial assistance um this opinion was also unmodified meaning you complied in all material respects with the grant compliance requirements uh unmodified or clean opinions in the school district audit is an absolute must um and the district has achieved unmodified opinions again um this year we noted no material weaknesses in internal controls or no significant deficiencies in internal controls those are findings uh that rise to a very high
004level um we had no reportable findings with respect to government auditing standards or under the single audit act when we did have one General finding which we'll discuss uh after I review fund balance uh we did just have a meeting with finance and went in great detail on fin on fund balance I will review it for the other board members if you want to follow along on page 75 of the cleared covered book is a summary of fund balance just overall uh fund balance is broken down into many sections there's restricted fund balance which is money set aside by board resolution or state statute for specific purposes and must be used for those purposes then we have committed and assigned fund balances um which are set aside by either board action or by management and
005then there's what's the unassigned fund balance the used to be called Surplus free balance uh the first item in restricted fund balance was capital reserve 1,258 628 represents the capital reserve the board has through resolutions put monies aside to fund capital projects in the long range facility plan um the 1,258 628 has not been earmarked for any specific project and is available to fund any future project in the long range facility plan uh we also had capital reserve designated for subsequent year expenditures meaning uh we are utilizing those funds in the 2425 budget the current year you're in to fund a project uh that was 782 312 so those funds are earmarked for specific projects if the funds don't get spent on those projects any unexpended monies will go back to the 1,258 capital reserve
006funds cannot be used for operating expenses can't use them for salaries benefits tuition costs Transportation costs it's earmarked for capital projects in the long range facility plan you also the board uh over the years has um put aside money in maintenance Reserve uh we had 493 157 at the end of the year that has not been earmarked uh for maintenance projects and in addition we had maintenance Reserve that we designated for Subs career expenditures or we're utilizing in the 252 budget of 150,000 again if the 150,000 does not get utilized on the projects that were earmarked for the difference the balance will go back into the 492,000 maintenance Reserve uh like capital reserve can only be used for required maintenance of school facility projects can't be used for capital projects can't be used for operating
007expenses the difference we between a capital project and a maintenance project is capital projects add value to the capital assets and prolong its life so in addition uh a new roof all new windows uh where maintenance projects keep the facilities in their current working order you replace one window you replace one door basically uh you fix the boiler fixtures you put new fixtures on it that's maintenance a new boiler's capital uh again it's put aside by board resolution and can only be used for those purposes uh the district also has emergency Reserve funds of 13,425 which it has not earmarked for any projects or any purposes um emergency Reserve funds can only be used by board resolution to fund unbudgeted health benefit costs that exceed 4% or to use for a security project at the
008time you adopt the budget to use it for any other purpose requires the county uh superintendent's approval to use it um very difficult to get that approval it's funds really set aside if there were no other funds to fund an expense you also had 45,000 of emergency uh Reserve funds that was designated for the sub subsequent years's expenditures again meaning you used it in the 2425 budget that $45,000 is being used for a security project I think it's new cameras but it's a security project so those funds have earmarked for that again if you don't spend the money on all that 45,000 it'll go back to 130 to 13425 far that has not been earmarked we also had an un unemployment compensation reserve of 2,717 uh those are funds set aside to fund your unemployment
009compensation claims uh the district like many other governmental entities in New Jersey funds its unemployment claims on a self-insured basis so you you pay dollar for dollar for claims our experience is this is a much cheaper way to pay your unemployment than to contribute to the state and then they hold the money in their accounts uh there's two sources of money the employees deductions and then the monies that you you put in the 25717 is the district's contribution to that fund next two items excess Surplus in New Jersey uh you're unassigned Surplus or unassigned fund balance can only be 2% of your budget with certain adjustments that you could add to that any amount over that 2% that has not been transferred into any of the reserve accounts must be earmarked as excess Surplus and
010must be used as a revenue Source in the next budget that that the district adopts when we closed the books at June 30th of 24 and we did the trans transfers into the reserve by that were approved by board resolution the district ended up with 300,000 of excess Surplus those funds by Statute must be used as a revenue Source in the 2526 budget cannot be used for any other purpose so they're earmarked when you start the 2526 budget the minimum amount of fund balance you will anticipate is 300,000 can't be used for any other purpose that compares to excess Surplus designated for Subs expenditures of 357 356 th that those were the the funds that were over 2% at June 30th of 23 that are being used in the 2425 budget uh in accordance with
011the statute they're funding expenses in the current year those funds that 357,000 is no longer longer available to fund future expenses it's July 1 it loses its distinction it's funding expenses in the current budget next two item are committed and assigned year-end incumbrances the first one committed 622 564 represents open purchase orders for construction contracts where the board has awarded these contracts but they have not been performed on we don't owe anybody we don't owe any contractor money he has not completed the contract as the contract is completed we will receive an invoice for work completed we will uh vouch that and we will liquidate that purchase order and those funds will be expensed um by this point in time of the year those monies have probably all been spent and all those purchase orders
012liquidated those funds are not available going forward to fund future expenses they're committed to those contracts as those contracts get completed we liquidate those funds that compares to the yearend incumbrances on the assigned fund balance 44150 represents the daytoday type purchases uh Goods or supplies we've ordered they have not been received by the district we don't owe the vendor any money until those goods are received uh um at this point in time again those goods have all been received those purchase orders liquidated those vendors paid um those funds are no longer available going forward to fund future expenses that leaves you with the unassigned fund balance uh many years ago they used to call it free balance uh they used to call it free balance Surplus uh unassigned fund balance of 662 260 represents the
013maximum 2% you're allowed to maintain 2% of your budget plus an additional $373,000 of state aid we received during the year that we didn't budget so you're allowed to keep 2% in there and you're allowed to add the unbudgeted state aid there uh the important thing to note for the amount of the unbudgeted state aid is that the board during the year by resolution can appropriate that portion of unassigned fund balance at 373,000 to to the budget to fund any unbudgeted costs in the budget uh you cannot dip into the 2% when you prepare your 2526 budget uh you have to use the 300,000 of excess Surplus you have no choice if you need additional funds to draw off of you draw off the 66 to 260 overall fund balance uh increased about 128,000 from
0144 mil7 to roughly 4 million uh 871 uh it's basically stable it's very comparable to the last year um a significant amount of the funds are in this in the Construction contract so those funds are not available um but overall the the district is in very stable condition um very good condition um and should have uh continue maintaining those uh Financial stability with respect to recommendations uh we had one recommendation in our management report uh which is the smaller of the two reports and on the last page page 12 is just a summary under School purchasing program uh we had a recommendation regarding the school purchasing procedures uh just need to uh take greater care in making sure we comply with the local public contracts law New Jersey is very restrictive with its purchasing laws
015uh purchases which exceed a certain [Music] amount which is the bid threshold of 44,000 all those purchases must be approved by the board um we had an instance where one purchase was not um certain non biddable contracts with Professional Services must be advertised in the newspaper after you award the contract uh that notice is to just say that we awarded an onbig contract for professional service who the professional is the service service provided in the amount of the contract uh you're not required to bid them but you're required to provide that notice and then we had uh certain uh purchases made through Cooperative purchasing programs Cooperative purchasing programs are other governmental entities that go out to bid for you and you allowed to piggy back off that bid um you don't you're not required to
016bid you're required to award those contracts if they exceed 4 4,000 but as part of the process you have to verify that there is a contract in existence and you need to provide get certain contract documentation from that Co-op and verify that the contract is in existence it has not expired and that the goods and services and the prices that that vendors charging you are in accordance with that contract award um this is not unique to ell uh The Cooperative purchasing programs are becoming more and more popular with government in general um and this seems to be an issue where people to forget to get that documentation and verify that you get in charge the right amounts um that's the only recommendation we had it's overall an excellent report from a financial standpoint as well
017as from a financial position standpoint uh if there's any questions be more than happy to answer Mr Daran uh yes Mr Bliss you mentioned uh for co-ops uh that you have to get additional documentation um in terms of the pricing and that the contract is in place you're referring to the vendor correct so yes the vendor yeah not yeah not not the co-op well you have to get that from the co-op because they the ones who award the contract and then you got to verify it to the vendor's invoices and the vendor proposals because the co-op Awards the contract and they have that documentation okay so you just have to make sure that what the vendor charges you is shown in the co-op as an agreed upon service or product yes and that the prices
018match correct exactly okay you're not required to bid you don't have to advertise anything you just got to get the documentation because some vendors May have other things that are not necessarily approved within the the co-op correct there's sometimes the contract expired and they say oh you could buy it under this contract but it expires and sometimes they charge different prices and they don't give you the goods that were in the contract yeah exactly right is there a limit to when you use the co-op purchasing limit no okay so what if um part of most the majority of the items are in the co-op contract but they there's a few others from the vendor that are not that you should split them separate invoices it would it be a separate project is it no it's
019not a separate project uh you would just have to make sure that the items that are not in a co-op do not exceed the bid threshold and then if they exceed the quote threshold you you may have to get quotes any questions Mrs Walker um so more and more we're using the co-ops for different items that we're purchasing why is that the case cheaper uh it's cheaper because you don't have to provide specs they do that for you they do the whole thing they they you don't have to provide specs you don't have to go out to advertise um you don't have to have the lawyer review the bids if it's like construction um so it is cheap and it's much quicker because you have to to do a bid you have to go out
020advertise usually takes a month take a month the bids come back you have to go through the bids the attorney has to review them uh and then you have up to 60 days to award that bid with the co-ops they have done that for you and so if it's a a An approved Cooperative uh vendor you can just legitimately pick the phone up and tell the vendor provide me a proposal of what it would cost to do this and basically you're done except you got to compare what his proposal is to what the contract award information is so I guess depending on who the um Co-op is the larger they are the more benefits you receive correct Ian mean somebody has to make money on these things well I'm sure they I think you have
021to pay and I I will uh direct this to Mr aell I believe you have to join the co-op the board has to approve joining the co-op and I'm sure there's some type of fee that you have to pay no so somehow they're getting paid usually they're like it could be another Board of Education there's the Education Service is commission to it um I don't you know that's a good question I don't know how they get paid I know some of them there is there is a f to Jo we can use a call- for things that are below the bid threshold also right you can use it for anything so I think though when you say it's cheaper it's cheaper if it's over the bid threshold but I think below the bid threshold their
022prices are not cheaper because I think their prices are actually higher you know I think it depends on what you're buying what listen if you're over the quote threshold you still kind of should if you're over the quote yeah definitely I mean no matter what you do if you're buying from a co-op you still should check the prices other venders absolutely the thing is you just don't have to go through the bid process right any questions thank you you're welcome Mr Daren yes uh in regards to our Reserve accounts yes for capital reserve we currently have around 2.2 million of which 782,000 is already allocated this year for projects which leaves 1.3 or 1.4 million what is a good number for a district like ours to have in our capital reserve you know this question
023always comes up it's very difficult to say because it depends what projects you have in your long range facility plan uh the how you prioritize those projects and um what I can tell you is this your long range facility plan total is about 7.4 million okay and you're basically allowed to maintain at the minimum 60% of that which is 4.4 million and at a maximum 7.4 million so you know depending on when you plan to do those projects uh really depends on how much you want to have in capital reserve I think the most important thing for any Board of Education is that if you're going to put money into a capital reserve you should be using it on the projects that you put it away for not just keep stock we have districts that
024have tens of millions of dollars in capital reserves um and they don't use it right so but here I mean you could see you had about 2.1 million you're using almost 800,000 of it and the year before that you use 940,000 of it so and in the end what you're doing is you're saving the taxpayers from going out to referendum debt costs and interest costs um you're using money that came from excess revenues and not spending the budget and putting it away for future use on Capital items and capital items you don't have to budget for them every year but operating costs you do so you know they're what we call the non-recurring type okay thank you you're welcome um I still have other questions our our maintenance Reserve uh we're maxed out currently um
025and uh the emergency Reserve what is the max for that uh in your case it would be 250,000 okay and you were at okay thanks you welcome I have a question on the unemployment compensation Reserve I should have asked you this in our finance meeting um just for procedure wise is that something you must have a reserve for or can you pay it out of you know your operating budget you are not required to have a reserve okay and then so there's no requirement as how you fund it you don't have to fund it yearly monthly with payroll it's whenever we feel it's getting lower and we yes what you have to do is when the claim comes in you have to pay it okay so I know there was a legal requirement when you
026had to okay but first you have first you draw down from the employees deductions and then you draw down from the uh District's contributions okay perfect Mr nutland yes thank you for that report very informative I do have a question on uh you mentioned that there was a reserve account that can only be used for projects that um are for Revenue uh not sure you must it sounded like there was part of the bundles of money that can go that oh oh yes the the excess Surplus right 300,000 okay must be used as a revenue Source an anticipation of fund balance in the next budget so you have have a budget it has expenses then you have revenues and one of the revenues besides taxes and state aid is how much fund balance you're going
027to use to balance that budget the minimum you must use is that 300,000 okay great thank you you're welome any other questions any other questions thank you Mr Bliss thank you we'll be talking to you the next few weeks dur in budget we appreciate your time thank you so much thank you also I'd like to thank Mr aell for keeping us in such a strong financial position this year we appreciate it um at this point at this time we will move to the superintendent report before I begin the district goal update I wanted to provide you with some school highlights tomorrow is officially the 100th day of school but if you look at our admin who are sitting in the audience today they will tell you that last week felt 100 days long um Friday
028was the kickoff to the Hoops season with Miss Cummings and Dr Roth leading the charge this year Hoops is a long-standing Ops tradition but every year we try to make it a little bit better we've added some additional aspects to the program this year we gave teams the opportunity to work collaboratively and negotiate to name themselves we also ask staff to be present for the beginning of the first game they created a tunnel for all teams to run through um we also had prior Ops students come back to volunteer they served as refs they served as photographers and they even wore the panther costume um it was really a great day and something that makes me proud to lead this community every year Hoops isn't about winning it's about supporting each other and we really
029encourage kids who don't love basketball to find a way to help out as well I was speak speak to some students to try to get some more student photographers to help out we are a little short on ref so if any board members who have a basketball background want to volunteer we will definitely um take you up on that offer including any children of board members who might be living on the second floor of their home and have a basketball background as well so last week and again this week we are continuing to hold scheduled data team meetings where grade levels are meeting with the director of curriculum and assistant principles to look at Benchmark data collected notice Trends and plann for tier one lessons and tier 2 interventions Friday was also the annual academics
030Cup in third grade third graders competed against third graders across the world and that's really important because people think it's New Jersey and one thing I hate about the arcademics cup is that you don't know how many teams are competing you just see the top 10 scoreboard but I am proud to say that we had numerous third graders in the top um 10 um in the world and this year we tried something new and we allowed them to stay on site until 6 p.m. these little 8-year-olds were in this Auditorium BL eyed but they showed resilience like you've never seen their computers were running out of charge and they were laying on the floor over here because they were not going to stop so we as I said we did have um three students come
031in the top 10 in correct in a row we had three students come in the top 10 in um most correct over the course of the day and we did have one class Miss pisa's class who placed in the top 10 as a class each of them will win some prizes it's kind of funny it's it's like a Domino's pizza party but it feels like the biggest accomplishment ever because it is something they have built up for and again I always find this one student during our academics cup that isn't on the board but that student has played and played and played and they might not be the most mathematically able student but that's the kid that chose persistent and every year there's one that you just see because they know their score is helping
032their team it's helping their class um and again this year there there was one also I'd like to now move to this tonight's agenda you'll notice on the Personnel agenda that you will be accepting the retirement of Missy warnett as Secretary of Student Records Miss warnett will retire on July 1st with just shy of 30 years of service to Ops while we are sad to see her go we know she has some wonderful adventures ahead and she'll still be getting texts from me every time I have an issue with real time now for the meat of today's presentation I'd like to begin as you requested with a high level overview of the district goals in your folders you will see a document that looks like this and I'm just going to give you some highlights
033of that goal one this year was to meet the needs of all Learners via a differentiated approach to learning as evidenced by the number of students who meet or exceed expectations on the New Jersey student learning assessment with a Target goal of ranking in the top third of comparable districts in mathematics and language arts so if you look at that table you will see the items that have been completed the items that are still in progress and the items that we haven't yet started as I said before um I'm really happy and pleased and did higher with this Focus to ensure that we were putting data team meetings together that we weren't just collecting data but we were actually looking at data to inform Trends and some of the work that's been done with that
034this year is really having teachers not just look at their classes data but also look at their classes data in comparison to their peers data is there an area where your peers might be doing better or not as well as you and what can we learn from that we also have implemented a math screener in grades K through one and the other highlight for me of this year has been our use of intervention manager which if the curriculum committee is interested is something we can share with you more intervention manager is an additional platform with link it that allows us to put multiple um sets of data in and to really triangulate and look at which students really need tier three interventions so we're not making those subjective decisions but we're truly using objective data
035on the front burner right now is we are in the process of also developing a tier one program um that will be a before or after the school day program to Target grades students in grades three through six which also was an item on the action plan goal two was to develop and adopt a s a set of standard operating procedures for all the key Department functions of the district and I will say that this is the goal that we have not made as much progress on and that truly is many things are in progress um our website development and our implementation of the new app and the communication platform has really taken most of my time right now but I have good news the website is almost completely done um I we had an
036alert training recently and now we will move on which is the communication platform and now we will move on to the app we are having a little bit of issue working with apple right now so hopefully we Mr aell is on the charge there and he told me he is going to figure this out and we will get that op and um website up and going my goal is to launch it right prior to Spring Break and the reason is that's a good time if there's any glit glitches it's not a super high pressure time and and the worst thing I felt we could do is launch a new app at the start of the school year when everyone's looking for something so goal three is to improve communication between Educators and families regarding academic
037and behavioral expectations and progress and you will notice everything there from creating an IR inrs flowchart to guide teachers on when parent communication should occur and when to also speak to their um assistant principles you will notice on there reviewing report card comment expectations to ensure that teachers were not just saying well every parent loves to hear that Johnny smile um warms your heart when you he walks into the classroom we really need to make sure that the comments on report cards are geared towards student progress especially the goals set at the goal setting conference and I really believe the true highlight in goal three is the implementation of interim progress reports in sixth grade so we started this year and we really felt since our sixth graders were are more of a middle school
038model that we wanted to start midterm informing parents if their child was not meeting academic expectations so we started that by just drafting a Google doc and having teachers send that home midm marking period and then that's not the most efficient method but we didn't want to make anything more permanent until we knew we were on the right track we then from there have now put those in real time so we have actually put progress reports for kindergarteners through sixth graders in real time we are only currently implementing them with sixth grade with plans to start working downward but the infrastructure is now there for us to do that to ensure that if a student is struggling midterm their parent has clear communication about that and the final aspect on here that is something that's
039really become a talk at our administrative meetings and that is the use of homework how can homework be a communication tool between home and school um what can we add to our homework so it's not just homework for reinforcement purposes or homework for completion purposes but how can homework be a tool of communication of linking home school and our last goal um is near and dear to my heart um it is to work with stakeholders to begin the process of creating a profile of an Ops graduate um as you know uh we launched that survey this week we already have 140 responses from parents so I do hope um Mo most most L current parents and staff I really am hoping and and trying to encourage former parents because I think they have a great
040insight into oral public and we do have some former par future parents that have completed it as well um some of you don't know but when I interviewed to be Superintendent at orell public I spoke about a profile of graduate because I truly believe that this can be the district's Northstar it becomes our common vision of what we want for the children of Ops and this North Star then becomes the jumping off point for our protocols where do we want to spend our money what do we want to add to our curriculum so instead of doing a peace meal approach if we have a solid profile of a graduate every time we want to do something we look back and say how does this align with what we decided was what we want for all
041children when they leave sixth grade and I will be honest I look every single morning to see what the responses are because I'm really excited to do the next step which as you see here will be to look at the data collected and begin to see which words could go together um you know what's the graphic that we are going to use to represent this vision and the one thing I want to be incredibly clear about about profile of a graduate is it doesn't mean academics don't happen um there is one District that their profile is a pyramid and I think this is a really smart way to think of it the bottom level of their pyam pyramid are are academics no one is saying a solid Educational Foundation is not our first priority but
042what more do we want so that concludes my report do you have any questions I have a question on the academics did all the third graders was it wasn't required obiously go to school how many oh all all five third grade classroom classes participated during the day and all five classrooms teachers also stayed after school it was up to a parent whether they wanted their child here and oh there were children everywhere so most stay did yes they stayed to different times some left some didn't stay some stayed till 4: and there was a group that at 5:50 we were like okay it's time to pack up we got to take your laptops upstairs good any questions on the goals Mrs Walker just I think this is very comprehensive thank you and helpful in us
043as we look over each of the goals that we've had and where you've achiev them so thank you for that yeah this is a lot of information so obviously take it home look at it and if you have questions bring it back for next meeting okay uh moving forward we're going to move to Mr ell's report good evening I just wanted to bring your attention to d8 this is the resolution awarding the HVAC system upgrade uh we had gone out the bid this is the regular operating District Grant the rod Grant so the state will be providing 40% of uh the costs they will be funding that so we'll get 40% in Aid and the balance comes out of our capital reserve that's already been designated and assigned in this year's budget uh I just
044wanted to highlight that because this will be a major project this Summer that concludes my report thank you moving to Minutes review of January 22nd any questions or comments please email Mr iell we have approval of January 7th minutes do I have a motion I motion to approve do I have a second I'll second second by Mr nutland any questions call a question on the rooll Mr Del Greco yes Mr Daran abstain Mrs Downey yes Mrs Moran yes Mr nutland yes Mrs Walker abstain Mrs Nichols yes committee reports buildings and grounds Mr Del Greco I'd like to introduce B1 use of school facilities and I also would like to either now or after this meeting set a date for our next B&G meeting just some issues I guess some things we talk up do I
045have a second on the motion first second second by Mrs Walker you want to meet after the meeting with your committee is thatone here who's not here oh yeah the whole committee is here yeah any questions uh yeah I have a question uh B1 item number three can we um if I think this is what I I think it is can we uh votee on that separately um yeah we can vote on it you would have to amend your a motion to we would make it B1 um one and two and we'll make it B2 which will be item number three so it's up to you if you want to amend your motion yeah I guess I can amend the can amend it to be B1 and B2 and B2 will be that number three
046so for B2 would just be separate for item number three on that chart so do I have a motion that second a second second any questions call the question on the roll Mr Del Greco yes Mr deren we're talking B1 right B1 one and B2 for B1 yes B2 no it's for both you understand that Mr we're yes we're rting okay thank you wait so we're talking about B1 and B2 yes okay but you can vote separately Mrs Downey uh B1 yes B2 no Mrs Moran um B1 yes B2 yes Mr nutland B1 yes B2 no Mrs Walker B1 yes and B2 yes Mrs Nichols B1 yes B2 abstain curriculum Mrs noran is not not here um Mrs Walker would you like to take that sure um let's see I'm not prepared okay curriculum I'd
047like to present C1 do I have a second I'll second second by Mr Del Greco any questions on the rooll Mr Del Greco yes I didn't call it Mr Darien didn't call the roll call yes Mrs Downey yes Mrs Moran yes Mr nutland yes Mrs Walker yes Mrs Nichols yes Finance Mr Daren uh yes before I introduce these items I just want to review what we've discussed at our subcommittee meeting our first meeting was uh January 29th and our second subcommittee meeting was today just before this meeting so on the 29th we kicked off our budgeting uh process and um you know we talked a lot a lot about the well first we started with the dates we we created a calendar of dates that we were going to meet uh between now and may
048which is when our public hearing will be uh we discussed uh upcoming um these are airds they're um HVAC units uh we have a a a bid that's going to be on on this agenda tonight um we were reviewing what the um the bid results were at that time uh we discussed some technology issues and we talked about healthc care costs our debt service and what's commonly refer refer to as Bank cap which is just um in the amount above the standard 2% that we do annually but uh those were just conceptual discussions because we usually talk about those at the end of the budget season uh tonight we went a little further into um uh the rod Grant we talked a little bit about uh some other big ticket items and uh we went
049into our first look at uh the largest cost items um in the bu budget um so with that um on the agenda tonight we have uh D1 through d8 do have a second second second by Mrs Walker we like to thank the uh PTA for almost $5,000 to their programs listed under D7 any questions Mr n uh yeah what um what brand or program interactive boards were we looking at I know mimo and promethium I think are the two big ones we're using Ben Q boards um we had one of our sixth grade teachers who utilized a Promethean board in her prior District we got a Promethean board from them and we tried it out in the sixth grade science class for three months because they'll give you a board for you for three months
050I then asked her to because I've been very interested in the BenQ products I asked her to try the BenQ board for 3 months thinking she was going to immediately tell me the Promethean board was better because that's what she was used to she immediately told us that the Ben Q board was better so it actually is also a little bit cheaper and I'm really happy with the service we're getting so we are um installing six uh Ben Q boards um in the probably the next month okay what was the price difference about I'll have Mr iell get back to you on that because I'm not actually sure cool um Mrs Walker will there be training for those teachers which is very important I think we change yeah it's actually well they don't actually have
051interactive boards in third these are going one is going into sixth grade science and the other five are going into third grade so they actually do not have interactive board so it won't be changed necessarily to a different product it will be implementing a product and they've actually asked for it so one of the things that I was a little bit sold on on BenQ and specifically the vendor we're using is when they showed it to us they sent us a trainer and told us the levels of training they would be willing to provide us so I'm I'm confident and we've also tasked a few staff members to become teacher leaders in this as well because you know the vendor is not here when you have a problem and you need some people on site
052that can help you and I've noticed that with my student teachers how they've improved using the boards uh the smart boards and what whatever the uh the manufacturer is and the more they use them the more familiar they become so you really need to have teacher training to make use of these things because they're wonderful yeah I I agree and one of the reasons I really like the Ben keyboards is they have the capacity to um when we use a Smartboard in the classroom the teacher presents onto the Smartboard right the benc boards have the ability for students to through chomecast on their Chromebooks to present on the Smartboard it also has um when you first saw saw smartboards only one or two people could touch at one time this can have 40 Touches at
053the same time so you can have multiple people working at the same time it really has some some great features and so the training is super important because otherwise you only use two of those features and you don't realize how much else you can do and they can also save their work so that they can use it again for another yeah session or lesson it's it's actually one of the cool things about Ben key boards if we were a middle school with rotating classrooms um every user gets a a scan card and your scan card can go from room to room and so your your stuff if you're the World Language teacher and you're teaching in four rooms can go with you which again like there there's some really cool stuff um right now with
054it so I'm I'm glad I've been looking at BenQ um for probably over a year now and it wasn't one of the names we were hearing as much about what I like about the company is promethian is just boards and Epson is just projectors BenQ does it all so I feel like they were a little more open to showing you all different possibilities I have two comments uh I just wanted to State uh D5 our correction action plan is a very minor thing that we had to do uh this happens to be with the you know the co-op even though the co-op was approved we should have had a board appr Pro anyway but um and and uh so I just wanted to make a comment that while we have a corrective action plan it
055was very minor um and then secondly on D7 I know Mr iell had mentioned this um but I just wanted to um oh I'm sorry d8 I'm referring to the HVAC upgrades on d8 um I I just wanted to reinforce that the funds for this $725,000 is coming out out of our capital reserve so you know this is um you know a multi-year trend now where we're spending between 700 and 900,000 each year for Capital Improvements and these things are not being put off um you know and lumped together and then gone out to the community with a referendum to bail us out so um you know this is just another example of um you know utilizing the capital res Reserve in in the way it's was designed uh we also are getting you know
056a 40% co-pay with the state and um currently within the um the subcommittee we're also looking at other upgrades to our HVAC through a new program which we may get up to 80% uh co-pay with the state so um you know I I just wanted to call that out publicly so that's all I have any other comments call a question on the rooll Mr Del Greco yes Mr Darian yes Mrs Downey yes Mrs Moran yes Mr nutlin yes Mrs Walker yes Mrs Nichols yes um Personnel Mrs Walker yes thank you um I'd like to present F1 but beforehand just a quick review of what we discussed last week at at our Personnel meeting and basically uh we had a lengthly discussion on the school calendar for next year uh 2526 um and that's still in
057the stages because there was very much an animated discussion about certain days that we didn't like this year or that we thought we maybe could revamp it and thank you for those uh different recommendations that were sent to us um on the different districts that surround us um and what they're doing on say uh Mar Luther King Day or are they starting maybe earlier in the school year than September one um and then also the oea agreement we are still in the process of um negotiating with our administrators on different points of interest that they might have have and we will be continuing our discussion and um sta autonomy apparently there is we had some questions about what was going on with the songfest and uh sing along was it and we will be continuing
058to go over ways to make sure that everything runs very smoothly because it is a lovely way to have the kids celebrate pre holidays and with that in mind I'd like to present F1 do I have a second I'll second Mr Del grea with a second any questions or comments call a question on the roll Mr delgreco yes Mr Daran yes Mrs Downey yes Mrs Moran yes Mr nutland yes Mrs Walker yes Mrs Nichols yes policy Mr nutland hi uh looking to plan a meeting for uh next week I'll be uh emailing my my colleagues uh I present G1 I have a second second second by Mrs Walker any questions call a question on the role Mr Del Greco yes Mr Darian yes Mrs Downey yes Mrs Moran yes Mr nutlin yes Mrs Walker yes
059Mrs Nichols yes public relations Mrs Downey um so we had a meeting and we discussed the profile of a graduate survey and the Website Layout website's looking good at this time we'll open to the public you can just state your name for the record sure my name is Karina savano and my name is Vanessa vonz and if you could just write it in the book so we have it sure for okay um I'm G to read off the text message excuse me um as concerned parents we want to ensure that there is a clear and effective crisis management protocol in place to protect our students as well as teachers it's important to make sure that that crisis management protocol aligns with the existing bullying framework and is made public so that students and parents understand
060that these kinds of issues are taken serious and are dealt with using a structured approach while the school may have a protocol in place it's unclear to parents and students what are the reporting the reporting protocols for a child to self-report we are unclear about the response actions from an investigative lens we also are curious about what type of support plans are in for children and teachers impacted as well as any sort of measures from a disciplinary action point of View and then further to that a communication plan during incident and post so it is our recommendation to see if there is an opportunity to implement a framework as such thank you no problem thank you hi Jen Allen 954 Wildwood Road um I was really glad to read about and then receive the portrait
061of the Ops graduate survey I strongly believe that involving all stakeholders is essential to building trust and collaboration I was a bit disappoint pointed to open the survey and simply see a list of traits asking us to identify five that we believe are the most important or asking if we had any others in mind IID hoped that this process was going to be more of a deep dive into strategic planning that involved all stakeholders similar to what many other districts including riverdell and River Edge just uh were a part of that River Edge just released their Five-Year Plan that came from several Community meetings that their Town engaged in I'm hopeful that there is a plan to engage in that level of deep and end in mind backwards planning and that the decision to have
062parents in the community vote on a list of traits wasn't to make it look as though there was some input from stakeholders in a surface way because I would find that a bit insulting at the end of August just before the school year began I participated in one of the parent focus groups that was offered to discuss key topics and gather feedback about how Ops could continue to improve the school Community with Coach Jim Stroker and principal Holly I appreciated very much being given this opportunity I'd hoped that this too was a launching point for more strategic planning more transparency and more involvement for multiple stakeholders in key decisions something that I think is very needed here especially because we are a one- school school district unfortunately there hasn't been much further that has been
063shared after that opportunity during this opportunity I shared something that I believe is relevant to the portrait of The Graduate initiative and necessary prior to identifying the portrait of an Ops graduate or our hopes for the Ops graduate your North Star at every board meeting you begin with a mission statement the ordell public school is dedicated the ongoing Pur of educational Excellence through comprehensive Innovative curriculum and instruction I don't need to recite it to you you all have it you read it each each time you're here this is from 2019 well adopted from 2019 so I would assume it's from the product of a process the board and I would hope multiple stakeholders engaged in the year or so prior if that was a process I I don't know what the process was if that's
064the case how many members of this board were involved in that mission well I know her school has multiple siblings the kids that began in 201819 are currently sixth graders on their way out I know this isn't the same staff I know this isn't the same leadership team from 201819 either so much has happened since 20189 we've experienced a global pandemic which impacted education greatly and taught us all a great deal we have quite a bit of educational research since 201819 that our district needs to be responsive to and our kids deserve to benefit from in addition to the mission not being reflective of the current stakeholders I don't really know what this Mission means to teaching and learning at Ops and I can't find a vision a mission is why you exist a vision
065is how you accomplish those goals as an educator and parent I believe that a vision and Mission should remain in drafts or at least being reviewed and revised yearly as it's what should be driving all decisions in a school from goals to budget alignment program decisions to curriculum to assessment all the way down to datto day teacher planning daily structures and routines uh and a schoolwide homework policy and philosophy which I'm glad to hear you raise tonight the vision and Mission are what should be driving decisions that ensure there are consistent practices within a grade level and coherent practices across the grades while your portrait of a graduate can serve you in some of these ways a vision and Mission most importantly should provide all of us with a clear understanding of how Ops believes
066students learn best I've been a parent here for three years now and a Community member in ordell for eight years I attended board meetings when I was pregnant with my now 8-year-old with former superintendence despite my involvement and I'm usually Here solo so you know I am involved and my attendance here I don't know how you believe students learn best I do know that my children have had amazing teachers in this school that I highly respect they've had past amazing teachers they have current amazing teachers every time I'm at this Podium I say this is not a teacher level issue but it impacts teachers and it impacts my kids so I do care very deeply are we a school that believes students learn best when they have direct explicit instruction are we a school that
067believes in inquiry first in a more problemsolving approach does it depend on the subject matter are we a school that believes children to work flexibly in groups and Partnerships and therefore small group work is the majority of my kids day I don't know that are we a school that believes everything we do needs to support students executive functioning skills in development and therefore every lesson at Ops begins with what we're doing and why and ends with a reflection and along the way the teachers talk about their planning and time management for kids are we a school that believes children's need think time and to discuss first and therefore before they go to independent practice they articulate their plan to a partner are we a school that believes in repetition and practice and that they're essential
068even in homework so with that in mind we highlight games versus color all theth red or cut and paste numbers I don't know how Ops beli students learn best and I believe I should I don't believe we should be creating a portrait of a graduate without engaging in a much deeper analysis and really identifying the vision and mission of Ops I believe in real Community engagement and I hope this board does as well thank you um Kristen geni I want to speak directly about the um author publication um most of you don't know me I have a first grader and an incoming kindergartner if I ever finished his registration paperwork um my husband and I moved to idell in November of 2022 after six years in a very Rural and Southern Maryland community but we
069were both born and raised in northern New Jersey I'm from hbor heits originally um orell is a community I have come to love and love living in though I sometimes struggle with the perception of privilege and making sure my children know that this isn't typical um everyone in this room is different from the other in many or most ways but two things are true of all of us we're parents and we love our children um that's something I think that we all truly have in common we all also have the right to teach our children what our own beliefs are and to raise them in the manner that we want whether it's the popular vote or not everyone is entitled to their opinions and I'm not here to change what anybody thinks feels or what
070they choose to teach their children as parents our voices are very loud they are the ones our children should be listening to what we need to remember is that our voices are not just loud at home but they're loud to all of the kids in our community we're coaches we're troop leaders we're parents of parents to the our kids friends um we're class parents we hand out pizza on Wednesdays to like really happy little kids who just want pizza um for the bulk of us in here our children are young and they don't really know themselves yet do we really want their Foundation to be one of thinking that they don't belong in our school and in our community there's a lot of talk about banning books and I think that really shines a light
071this book in particular that people are speaking about um it shines a light on the children of the lgbtqia community and the message we're sending these kids is that they don't deserve to be part of our community whether you realize it or not whether that's what your intention is or not it's what the message is to them they will grow up thinking that something is wrong with them when there's not their is existence is as important as yours mine and everyone not in the lgbtqia community if this is something you don't believe in don't sign your child up for this but please don't teach children that these other kids in this large community are less than us or anybody else Banning a book puts us on a horribly slippery slope this is where it begins
072but where does it end we're living in very tumultuous times regardless of where you stand and the world can be a very scary place um before I sit back down I just want to share a story I said before that my husband and I lived in southern Maryland for six years we were in a really beautiful town on a very narrow strip between the Chesapeake Bay and the pent River there to get to us you had to go over a bridge called the Solomon's Island Bridge the views were absolutely stunning and the sunsets were like no sunsets I've ever seen our neighbor's son's best friend a senior in the high school my own children would have attended had we not moved back home his name was Andrew suam and he jumped off of that bridge
073on October October 28th 2021 he was gay and he was ostracized by the community very much to my knowledge they still have not recovered his body and his parents are obviously suffering as are the people who loved him um again this is not about me changing anybody's philosophical views but it all starts here and now and we're laying the groundwork for our children I think keeping out an entire population of people is not what we want in the profile of an Ops graduate I think inclusivity is really important and whether we believe in it understand it get it or not we shouldn't be excluding people and we should be teaching our children to just be inclusive thank you thank you anyone else Miss boses do you want to uh speak on profile of a graduate
074at all since sure um first of all thank you you for your feedback because it was incredibly eloquently stated and I mirror every single thing you said um you have two different ways to go and you do strategic planning this board did do strategic planning and I was looking around and I was thinking that there's probably four members of this board that were there and it was open to parents it was over four nights it was probably in the spring of 2018 and it was an abysmal failure frankly because no one showed up and that's part of the problem so that's why I think that that specific strategic plan never really gravitated the last day of that strategic plan was creating that mission statement the reason I chose to and superintendents have two different ways
075to go some do strategic plan first I am actually mirroring riverdell riverdell did profile of a graduate last year and are now doing their strategic plan based on the profile they created this year one area that I chose to do a little differently is their Prof file was comp completed in a room with one representative from each stakeholder group so there were two parents two students I was there as the orell Public School Superintendent I wanted to provide the larger community so my intention was never to feel that picking five words was trit that was a starting point and we will continue to have stakeholders involved in the process and I do hope that this will launch us into a strategic IC plan that is anchored in something and I would like it anchored in
076the north star that we create because I do want very much so that every single person that comes through here um knows what Ops stands for that if I see somebody on the street I want to be able to say what's ops known for and I want it to be more than sharp I want it to be that it's it's a community that believes in this type of learning just like you so I ask that you give me a little bit of patience right now as we work through this process and I do promise you that there will be more stakeholder involvement I just ask that those of you sitting here today and those who might be watching the video show up because otherwise it's flat and I love that you love your teachers but
077they get nervous about sitting in a room and doing stakeholder work with you so I ask that you show up and you be open-minded and we be flexible and we use this as a launching pad to create something really great for our community because no matter how different we view different things we all want the same thing what's best for the children of idell moving on to old or new business have any Mrs Walker um I just noticed in one of um our superintendent uh weekly reports she uh talked some something about the enrollment in the school presently is 8115 students maybe lost one or two or gained one or two in the last two weeks why has it increased so much in the past couple of years do you have so a lot of
078that has to do um with covid we saw a lot of people leaving more um dense populated areas for some green space and so our enrollment the year right after Co did go up 40 so we had a net difference of 40 that year so that was a start and then we had an anomaly last year the districts around us Ed up cutting a kindergarten section while we were adding a kindergarten section so maybe orell has a really great reputation right now maybe that's where the house market was um what I also shared in that newsletter is what we are seeing is actually not mirroring New Jersey New Jersey birth Trends continue to go down but it hasn't impacted us now our our based on our current kindergarten registration and those that are almost registered
079um we're probably um looking at a decrease but we've just we've had some people move in and I use our current sixth grade as a perfect example when they started um in kindergarten they had 111 students they gained 24 net change between between kindergarten and sixth grade to have 135 sixth graders including nine students that moved in between fifth and sixth grade I people are just flocking to idell so and we're just going to keep making it better so they'll just keep moving in thank you any other old or new business excuse me so technically it's closed but I'll allow it come to the mic confused about the vote that happened because it seemed like to us because we it's hard to hear back there that there were three yeses and three Nos and then
080one abstains so we thought it was tied so if it's tied then shouldn't somebody vote we didn't know if the motion passed or not it's tied motion fails okay I can't get into the subject but I will tell you that the that's what we want to know the board is going to get be getting more information on um the uh PTA author visits thank you any other old or new business okay we do need to go into a closed session I need someone to make a motion for a Clos session for student issues uh safety security issues and a special ed legal issue if anybody wants to make that motion I'll make the motion motion by Mr Del Greco do I have a second second second by Mrs Walker uh roll call on the role
081Mr Del Greco yes Mr Daran yes Mrs Downey yes Mrs Moran yes Mr nutlin yes Mrs Walker yes Mrs Nichols yes we'll be going to close session we will not be taking action after so meeting is over