001all right good evening the 12 to order for a special meeting of the bridgeboard Board of Education um today is Wednesday January 15 it is 6 6:14 pm and we're at City Hall the conference room 305 uh joining us um I'm Jen PR chair of the board uh we have Mr sovic Mr benan Mr Traer in person m Medina online Miss casir online all right um and get started um today we have a an agenda item of uh the Freedom of Information Act presentation and this training is going to be with Mr Russell Blair the direct he's the Director of Education and Communications for the Connecticut freedom information commission so he right okay um can everyone on the everyone on the computer can hear me right just okay um yes so yeah good evening um
002you know it's really really good to be here um you know I do a lot of these training sessions and um you know I always appreciate when it's an invitation uh because something you may not know is sometimes the commission orders fi trainings and I have to go and kind of do the remedial class when things have gone wrong so you know it's nice when people realize hey we've got some questions we want to have somebody come down and try to help us out so I'm always always happy to do that um and then the other thing I'll just mention in particular here um you know I know there's been some complaints that have been filed um you know today is is training you know we can talk about the issues that have Arisen but
003just so everyone understands um you know we have a process we have cases before the commission we have hearing officers reports so today is not about making any kind of factual determinations about you know if somebody was wrong or something was a violation and all that um you know today we're going to talk about you know the the what the law requires for your public meetings um in particular you know we'll touch on maybe a few things about records requests um you know depending on the timing and all that um but just want to you know mention that off the top as well well um so you know with the Freedom of Information Act one of the things that you know I think is really important to know is that um it can be difficult
004as as you may have have have experienced yourself um you know most people that deal with foi are not attorneys I'm actually not an attorney either a lot of people think you know if you work at the foi commission um you know you must be an attorney but my background is actually in journalism so my experience with with public meetings is covering them as a journalist so I've you know been um at you know many a Board of Education meeting actually that was my first assignment when I started as a young reporter I was working at the record Journal covered the town of Wallingford went to a lot of Board of Education meetings um just a quick little story you might find amusing there was um I remember one meeting where there were all these
005parents there and I was really excited because I was a young reporter and I was like oh there must be this big issue going on all the parents are here um I get the agenda of the meeting and I go oh it's Awards presentation night and they do all the awards then everybody leaves and then it's just me and you know the lonely reporter in the room while they're doing their meetings um you know but um so very familiar with it from that aspect of things um but you know in practice the foi law can be difficult ult so really my role at the commission is to provide training provide education um to be a resource so uh again my contact information you know we can take questions throughout the presentation I find that that's
006easier so if you have a question um you know just kind of raise your hand um you know on on the people virtually um maybe we can just check in a few times throughout or if you know somebody's monitoring it and you see a question just let me know um you know because I I don't want you guys to be mistaken or to keep going on something if somebody has a question and wants a a clarification or anything like that so um you know again with the Freedom of Information Act it is the law um so you know you want to do it correctly and if you have questions tonight if you have questions in the future uh you know please please don't hesitate to reach out um okay not working too far away um
007okay there we go um okay so um you know just another thing I think when I do these presentations I like to just mention sort of briefly is a little bit about the history of the of the foi ACT and um you know one of the things I always like to mention is you see the year up there this is the preamble from the Freedom of Information Act and the law passed 1975 so 50 years ago today or this year we're actually celebrating um the 50th anniversary of the passage of the FI law um and one of the things that you know I think is really important is to kind of understand you know where this law came from and and really if you look at the year there um if you're a student of
008History this was really a post-watergate reform it was you know across the country Connecticut was not unique in in passing a law like this but connec was one of the first to adopt a Freedom of Information law um and Connecticut's law is actually one of the strongest in the country and it still remains uh you know that way today uh Governor El braso was the real champion of um of passing the Freedom of Information Act in in in Connecticut um you know it's about government transparency is it's about allowing the citizens to have access to our records to be able to come to our meetings um really to participate you know in in in our democracy in an informed way you know we want people to to have access to the same information that they
009elected or appointed officials have when they're making decisions so that people can understand you know if they have a concern about the school budget they can get financial information they can figure out you know what programs are being funded they can come to a meeting and they can say Hey you know I think we should put more funding towards this particular program it allows people um to come to meetings to speak to be informed um you know and and and to participate in that way but what makes Connecticut kind of unique and and what I think is one of the you know really the strongest aspects of our foi law is that when the foi law passed back in 1975 along with it was the uh the creation of the foi commission so if you
010don't you know know what the foi commission is um we are a you know state agency but we are really kind of independent and uh you know we're small we only have about 15 or 16 staff members mostly attorneys and really our sole job in in the statute and spelled out our job is to investigate alleged violations of the Freedom of Information Act um so if somebody thinks that something went wrong with a records request if somebody thinks something went wrong with the public meeting um they file a complaint with our office we received an excess of 850 complaints last year so we are quite busy um the good news is a lot of the complaints we do resolve them we have an on budsman program um so we try to you know even when
011a complaint has been filed try to work with the parties to resolve the issues if we can um if we can't resolve the issues we have the the you know the powerold hearings um you know we have other investigatory Powers you know we can request records we can request information we can subpoena Witnesses um really to try to figure out you know what happened and whether or not it was a violation of the Freedom of Information Act um if we find a violation we have different things we can do as I mentioned earlier you know we can order trainings we can also issue fines we don't do that all too all that often but in some instances if we think something was really egregious we have the ability to find um but you know in
012terms of meetings something maybe people don't know about one of the powers of the commission and we don't do this all that often but we can nullify votes that were taken at a meeting so your board could take a vote on something and if somebody filed a complaint and the commission looked at it and we realized that you know the agenda wasn't posted properly or maybe something was done improperly in an executive session we could come back and this could be months later we could say that wasn't done properly we're wiping it out you've got to go back and do it again um and you could just imagine the headaches that that could that could cause so really you know uh with compliance with the foi ACT you know it's important on a number of
013levels one um it's the law right we all want to try to follow the law two we hope that people support the concept we hope people support you know doing our work in public um providing you know public access to records but but really um you know practically speaking if you don't do it right and you wind up with an foi complaint it can just be something that becomes a huge headache it can eat up a lot of time um it can Le up a lot of resources you know you're you're having to have conversations with your attorney having to come to a hearing maybe in Hartford maybe your case has to get continued and you have to go to another hearing you might have to go to a commission meeting it can be something
014that um you know that could just become a bigger issue than it really needs to be and what I find is a lot of times you know through a little bit of Education a little bit of research through you know figuring out what you need to do you can handle most of these that come up um you know without having to worry about complaints or without having to worry about going to hearings and all that so um really today is about you know making you feel comfortable um understanding you know the requirements and also understanding you know if you're not sure about something it's okay to go seek it's okay to get clarification it's okay to ask somebody you know I'm not sure what we do here you know can you please can you please
015help me out um okay so basics of the foi law there's really two parts of it meetings and and Records um we will you know mostly Focus to meetings Provisions but we'll also touch on some of the records too uh with with with records requests um you know I think it's important to note that really the foi laws about providing copies of the records that you keep that you maintain that you've created in the course of your uh you know your your service on the board of education so all the things you receive in your packet all the correspondents you send correspondents that you receive you know the financial information of the school board anything that touches on the public business somebody can request under foi but you don't have to do research or create
016new documents so it is not about having to you know research a question or answer a question or create a new document foi is really sharing information now as elected officials you might go beyond that you might you know have want to do research into something for somebody you might want to answer question from somebody but the distinction with a records request is I can request a record from you and you have to have those records and you're not creating records you're not going to other agencies to get those records if a record exists with the state and not Bridgeport tell the person you've got to go to the State Department of Education you know they've got that data about test scores or something it's not something that we keep and then public meetings this
017is something that um people often ask about the foi law is about attendance at public Mee there's no uh law foi or otherwise that requires boards and commissions to have public comment I heard you guys just mentioning you have public comment on the agenda um you know I think that's good think the commission supports having that as you know available to to to Residents but because it's not required it means that you can put restrictions on public comment you could choose whether to have it or not you can ask the people you know identify themselves their address you can put a limitation on how long people can speak you could ask the people only address items that are on the agenda anything you want to do public comment is up to you you can you
018know unless it's something that's set in a board policy if you don't have a board policy you could change it from meeting to meeting um you know I mentioned earlier I was a reporter you know in the city of Hartford they do it you know their city council I believe the first meeting of has public combat the second meeting of the month doesn't so different cities and town to do it different way so public comment however you want to do that is is up to you and then the Freedom of Information commission we already you know talked a little bit about that but really you know we're kind of the the the people that come in the umpired that try to resolve a dispute and try to figure out um you know if something was
019a violation or not and then if we determined that something was a violation you know we is order and we have different remedies and things that we can do on the records piece you know we can order public agencies to produce uh you know records um if they believe that they have to disclose them we could look at it and say well you know actually those records need to be disclosed um and in some instances you know depending on what happened we may say you know the records need to be disclosed and they can't charge any fees for it so we have different abilities um to to do that so uh sometimes people wonder who's covered by foi uh you know for you all it's pretty simple you know board of education is what is
020called the public the agency under the law I mostly just put the slide up there because I I tend to use that word a lot when I'm speaking so so everyone understands you know a public agency ear ageny could be a division Department um a city city Department um your board of education is a public agency subcommittees of your board of education if you have any on our our public agencies um you had a question just want to know whether you want us to win or ask questions oh if you want to ask questions as we're going that's fine yeah because yeah do you have a question right now yeah we do a lot of public comments and this came up recently um this sort of as we developed the hybrid online participation not online
021we discussed recently people have the right if we have hybrid meetings we actually allow people to watch online now people have the right to come in online so you don't um so our rules say that you can come to the meeting and comment and you can sign up to comment does that allow them to participate from online so um you if you have public comment at your to decide it's up to you yeah it's up to you to decide how to do it so um you know just to kind of give you an example you know I know in some towns what they'll do is they'll say look if you want to do public comment on the zoom meeting we might ask you to email us ahead of time you know and give give us
022your name and stuff so that we can we can add you to the list and we kind of know what to expect you know that sort of thing um you know but but also the way that the remote meetings vision is written if you do public comment in person you're not required to do it to the online people so you could say if you want to comment at a meeting you have to Common person or you could say you know we're going to do it online but maybe we ask you to sign up ahead of time just so we know what to expect you know in terms of um of people commenting but that yeah it's a good question so you could decide you know how how all that works um okay so you know
023back to public agencies um again the one thing you know I think is important for you all to understand is that um this is B there you know a public agency includes any Committee of what created by any other public agency so the bridge for Board of Education you know creates a subcommittee or you know you create full building committee you create a you know whatever it is you know a task force to look at something if you create a committee a task force at subcommittee whatever you call it the name really doesn't matter if you were creating a group that is going to you know basically you're delegating the work of the board to some other group um that group is going to also be subject to uh the Freedom of Information acting know
024regardless of is on it now there's a distinction and we'll get into this when we talk about you know what a meeting is there's a distinction between a subcommittee and you know board members kind of doing work between meetings you know there are ways that you might have sort of these kind of ab groups that get together you know maybe you know somebody said you know Joe and Jen you know before the next meeting can you go talk to people in Stratford and get their numbers about their enrollment and come back meeting and report it to us you're so you're allowed to do some kind of work between meetings um the real thing you can't do is you cannot have you know these little subgroups that are a quorum of your board we'll kind of
025talk about how all thats in a second but um you know generally speaking standing subcommittees if you create a special committee to deal with something uh those those groups are going to follow fi um as well in rare instances nonprofits can be covered under foi um the the Supreme Court case in Connecticut about this actually involves a school which doc Academy if you're at all familiar with that is a private high school up in nor Eastern Connecticut but they serve is a public high school um for students in those in that area because they don't have any public high school so they were you know ruled to be subject to fi but generally it's only through you know arms of of government um so we're going to start uh you know again as I said
026going over the meetings Provisions uh of foi hopefully you won find yourself like this at your board education meetings wondering why you're having the meeting uh but um what I think is really uh key is to look at the definition of what a public meeting is and um I'm going to spend a little bit of time on this because I think it's really um yes are schools fall into um so so a charter school um I my understanding is that is that they do you know they're bard of whatever you know usually they have like a Board of Governors or something like that then you know then then if they're you know if they're if doing basically with with the functional equivalent of a public agency you know are you doing governmental functions and they're
027taking in public funds if they're providing public education you know then they're going to be you know part of you know the foi world so um you know that that that's the way the court determine whether or not somebody is subject to foi is you know are you receiving Government funding um are you providing a government service there some kind of you know government oversight which usually you know with most Charter Schools I'm not an expert but there usually is you know there's some kind of no they they called public schools by by law yeah so they are treated covered by a different set of laws than we we are we assign one member of our board just to be a member of their board but I've never seen them post notices or follow Haven
028paid attention so I can't say they don't yet but I've never noticed yeah so I I think that I think what's a little bit I think what's a little bit different with Char yeah um I think what's a little bit different with Charter Schools is sometimes the the governance structure is a little bit different you know it's not a you know like a a board of education like you have here it might be a different you know a different kind of group saying they do yeah I know for for they I've went into some of the TR at the end of last year and I know that they have like an agenda they have minutes and all that you can go back can meet them and all that stuff I was trying to find if
029my name was on the one time and so I saw some of just curious whether they notices of their meetings and all that sort of stuff yeah I mean so you know I'll just say you know without knowing all the specific about the particular school that you're talking about I mean you know I wouldn't be surprised if there's charter schools out there that are not following everything that they're supposed to be doing you know I've investigated that but you know it's possible that they're supposed to be doing it and yeah they're not posting the agendas and but the way um you know really what it comes down to is you know when the commission gets a you know so if you were to seek records about a charter school or you thought the bo wasn't
030doing agendas or whatever you know and somebody were to file a complaint the first thing we would do is we would do that functional equivalence has them here you know I think there's a you know they're providing public education they're taking in public funds you know there's not a you know versus a private school that you know obviously you know you know holy private school Yale University you know you're not going to be able to to do a Foy to Yale University acknowledge that Andre Woodson has also the meeting um all right so you know what is what is a meeting under the law um so a meeting uh really really it's a specific specific uh you know specific thing and um you know the way I try to explain this to folks is there's
031kind of really you know sort of like three triggers that that you uh have to hit and if you do these three things then you know you're in public meeting territory which means you know this should be a conversation happening at a meeting it should not be email it should not be text message it should not be in the hallway before the meeting it should not be in the parking lot after the meeting um and and really the three things are um convening or assembly of a quum of a multi-member public agcy so your board is a multi-member public agency so anytime we have a quum of a multi-member public agency or any communication by or to a quorum of a multi-member public agency whether in person or by means of electronic equipment um to
032discuss or act upon a matter of the public agency has supervision control jurisdiction or advisory power so Quorum is the first part the second part is either we are gathered or communicating in personal or electronically and the third part for short I like to ref refer to it as board business so if we have a quorum of our board members they're either gathered together or they're communicating electronically and they're discussing or acting upon board business then that makes it a meeting so what that means is inherently you cannot have conversations among a quorum or more of your board members about board business now there are some exceptions to this the number one exception caucuses which we can talk about in a second but you know if we had a situation this is a classic you
033know do not do this if uh somebody sends the agenda out to everybody and everyone's copies in an email you don't want members to start jumping in and responding saying hey that agenda item that seems great I think this is super I'm going to vote for this and somebody else says no that's a terrible idea why are we doing this you know you don't want to start your discussion that you would have at the meeting before you get to them that's really the whole idea of open meetings is that your deliberations the dialogue and not just the votes because again a meeting discussion or action not just you know that we didn't vote you talk about things that could be a violation pleas um not get into the exceptions in a minute but um far
034as um getting together and discussing an agenda even if we don't intend to act on anything at a few but possibility that it does fall within our then we talk about we get together as a group of five or six and we discuss what the best test textbooks in the country but there's no textbook on the agenda that's still something that we should um probably noticed corre ex yeah exactly so it's not just about things that are you know things that are on the agenda it's really about again anything you have supervision control jurisdiction or advisory advisory power over so you know I would look at that very broadly because you know like the example you're using about textbooks so maybe there's nothing on the agenda about textbooks but what if you guys have this
035conversation and then you know two months later this item pops up and it says we're going to purchase these textbooks and somebody's like well where did this come from right they never even talked about this and now they're all saying are the greatest textbooks in the world and that's why they're going to buy them so um you know it doesn't matter if it's you know if it's even been something the board has considered yet really if you're talking about things that involve decisions that you make then those conversations need to be happening in public if it involves you know quum or more of your board unless you know there's one of those exceptions we'll touch on thank you um any other questions on that so um again Quorum is really key uh because the Quorum
036is we have enough people to make a decision we have enough people to vote on something that's why we want to avoid those Gatherings because even unintentionally you know I feel that calls from people who have said you know well you know we we weren't really meaning to make a decision we just wanted to feel what out people and get an idea of what might you know what what we could expect to talk about at the meeting um but you know even inadvertently you might start to lean one way or the other once you guys start talking about it you know people may um you know have have made their feelings known and that could influence you know the outcome of what happens at the meeting um real quick because you men that I know
037you look I apologize I didn't have my but at the same time so again the word quum is clear so Board of of nine people it's you know those five y so two of them can get together exactly have a conversation breakfast whatever and just hang out and talk yep exactly yeah the only thing you can't do is there is a we actually had a case on this and and we have called it uh the commission called it a there's a there's a Latin term I can't pronounce but we call it a Serial meeting you can't have a situation where like if the budget was up for a vote the chair cannot call every single member individually and say are you going to vote for the budget are you going to vote for the budget
038are you going to vote because that in in essence is a meeting so you know it's not like you could have breakfast with every member and get them to agree with your one thing that somehow somebody figured that out you know they could say well you know that was intentional to circumvent you know the process but you know if you've got a couple board members who you know have an idea and they want to work on it they want to me discuss absolutely and then they can come to the next meeting and they can report out um you know that's um that that's all fine um um sorry just want to jump in for a little clarification because I don't believe he was here in the beginning of part and I'm going go if it
039applies or not for of a committee so if it's a if it's a subcommittee it's of the members of that subcommittee so if your subcommittee is five people the Quorum is three it's not the quum of the m board and we can't come and we can't come together to discuss that business unless we fall under the focus and on the stuff exemptions on the sub yeah on the subcommittee same thing yeah so so you know the smaller the board than you know the the smaller the Quorum so you know sometimes it can be difficult you know and and you know where this comes up a lot of times you know it's not really a maybe a bridgport problem but uh you know small towns that have a three- member Board of Selectmen you know they'll
040call me and they'll say you're telling me I can't talk to the other Selectmen because that's two of us and you know if it's of the other party really you're not supposed to be you know even even two of the three Selectmen if it's a Republican and a Democrat really should not be talking about you know you know the business of the board which in a board of selectman it's kind of everything because you know It's a Small Town they're sort of in charge so um you know the idea here is not to make it you know impractical or hard to get your work done the idea here is that you do your work in public um you know and and and sometimes those subcommittee meetings you might notice them and nobody might show up
041you know it's 10: a.m. it's in a conference room at the at the high school and it's you and some staff and you're going through something curriculum or whatever it might be and you might never ever have you know somebody from the public that attends but we still do the agendas they're still open meetings we still take minutes um even if somebody doesn't come then we want to read the minut you know when so that they know what issues are going to be brought to the full board you know for their for their approval um okay so uh couple other sort of ground rules for meetings and this is we all meetings you know virtual or not anyone can attend a public meeting not required to to give their name um you know or you
042know sign in or anything like that so in the virtual world some people have asked me do people have to give their name on Zoom um you know our public meeing law says no so if somebody you know calls in and it shows up as a phone number and you say hey who is that on the phone and they won't tell you you know you can't just kick them out of the meeting because they won't identify themselves um you set your ownes for public comment we already talked about that um anyone can photograph record or broadcast a public meeting uh you know I like to say hopefully if you're at a public meeting you wouldn't say anything that you didn't want recorded and it seems like you guys record your meetings anyway um but just
043be mindful the audience is allowed to record a meeting as long as they not being disruptive um and agendas we'll we'll come back to that in a second but um just I I I make a point with agendas um you know to emphasize that you know agendas are really for the public uh to make a decision about whether or not to attend a meeting so you just want to make sure your agendas are are clear um now uh this is kind of an interesting thing I use as an example it actually involves the school board um and you know the other side of the state um there was a school board where they had an agenda item and the agenda item was facilities update um they voted to close an elementary school and there was
044an uproar in the community because you know people looked at the agenda and they saw facility update and they said okay right you know what is that mean know okay and then the board votes to close the elementary school there was uh two foi complaints that were filed against us because they you know alleged the agenda was insufficient and there was such a public blowback they actually reversed the decision and they voted to keep the elementary school open um so the complaints kind of got you mooded because they they they ended up not doing it um but like that would be a classic example of what not to do you know if you're going to vote to close an elementary school presumably there's been a lot of conversation before it and if you're going to
045take the vote put it on the agenda right and people can come to the meeting they can speak out whatever they want to do you know the agenda is there for the benefit of the public so they know what you're doing um you know don't try to OB fisc things by using you know buzzword or or things like that um so email and meetings we we kind of already alluded to this but um you know uh just be careful about your conversations you know email text message uh you know Zoom what whatever it may be um you know if it's among a COR or more board members it's dealing with board business then it's got to be done at a meeting you know except for a few exceptions that we'll that we'll talk um it
046is okay to be discussing administrative type things you know somebody says hey can you put this on the agenda for the meeting um you're trying to schedule a special meeting and see people's availability uh you know you could also share information you know it's not about a one-way communication so if somebody says hey you know there was a you know article in can post I just want to share with everyone you know it was a great you know story about one of our programs you can send those things out to all your board members you know as long as it's not about you know a discussion about what the board is going to do so if you got a letter from a parent and you wanted to share it with the fellow board you know
047the rest of the board and say hey just want everyone to be aware of this communication I received um you know you can you could do that but it should not evolve into a discussion about what you know policies or procedures or action the board is going to take that would happen at your next meeting um you could say hey we got this letter and we've decided you know we do something about it um okay so um the next thing that I want to talk about is uh the differences between a regular and special meeting and you know sort of the requirements in terms of notices and minutes we'll go into a little bit of a deeper detail um in in minutes in a second um but really there's two main kinds of meetings regular
048meetings and special meetings so a regular meeting is a meeting that is on your regular meeting schedule so at the start of every year uh you know probably the end of last year you guys you know developed a regular meeting schedule you vote on it um you you know you submit that and that is your list of regular meetings for the year um so you know that's kind of set those are your regular meetings and um anytime you want to meet outside of your regular meeting schedule you uh you know you hold a special meeting and um really the only thing that makes a a special meeting special is the timing on it um there's a few differences that I'll touch on in a second but you know regular meeting is it was on our
049calendar special meeting is it wasn't on our calendar and that could be that something happens and you have to move a meeting so if your regular meeting gets snowed out um and you move it that becomes a special meeting it could be that you add meetings you know maybe you only meet twice a month but something comes up and you know you need to deal with it you can schedule an a special meeting and also just um to remember too that if you change the time of your regular meeting that also becomes a special meeting so if you normally me you know at at at 7 o'clock but you know I don't know there's a big basketball game that night and you guys want to do it at five o'clock so people can get over
050there afterwards um at the high school you know you could say okay we're going to make that a special meeting we're going to do it at 5 o'clock um so you know for your regular meetings agendas need to be uh need to be filed 24 hours in advance um you know important to note that you know agendas need to be filed when um you know when your offices are open I don't run into this as much with Boards of education but sometimes in town halls you know they might close on Friday or they close early on on Friday or something like that you know if your meeting is on Monday your agenda's got to be filed on Friday you can't you know email to somebody on Saturday or Sunday um you know it would not
051be um you know it would would not be filed in time under the law um so special meeting you know very similar uh you know notice an agenda 24 hours in advance all special meeting agendas do have to be posted to the website 24 hours in advance regular meeting agendas actually do not have to be posted on the on on the website 24 hours ahead of time for for you know municipalities and school boards um I would strongly encourage you to post the agendas in a timely manner you know because that's where people look to this they they're not frequently probably not coming into your office and looking to see the agenda there they're they're going to look on the website first um so you know but but with regular meeting if something happened and
052it didn't get posted would not be a violation but a special meeting if it was not on the website 24 hours before the meeting then then you know the meeting will not be properly noticed and you have question um you said um must be filed when the offices are open so it should be filed before if the office closes at five it's got to be filed by yes yeah exactly um not 6:30 at night because the meeting is at 6:30 on Monday no it's got to be it's got to be filed while they're open because the idea is and again this is probably more applicable in the town hall but the laws you know applies the same um you know the idea would be if somebody were to come to the board offices before you
053close on Friday they should be able to see the agendas for any meetings that are happening on on on Monday and and that doesn't apply to the weekend so if our meeting regular meeting is Monday at 6:30 it's got to be filed by Friday at 5:00 exactly because with you know specifically what the agenda what the agenda says is what the law says with the agenda is is they need to be filed and publicly available so you know I would argue if you if you email it on the weekend or after hours well it's not really filed and you know but then I've had some people say well what if somebody stays late and they stamp it in at 6:30 okay maybe it's filed but it's not publicly available right you know unless you guys
054are deciding to keep you know the the office is open late so somebody could come in you know but but so just again yeah close a business the day before your meeting and also remember holidays you know I don't know when you guys normally meet but you know if you if you meet on Tuesdays you got to really be mindful of those Monday holidays because you know you know you may say well we just do it on Monday normally but if it's Martin Luther King Day or something then you have to be doing it the Friday Frid before the Monday holiday because Saturday Sunday Monday they're all closed now and we had several instances in the past year where we actually missed a notice never got posted I mean the schedule that we submitted to
055the state for our meetings on Friday night the notice just never got posted it seems to me that that's wrong yeah so you know what I would say in those instances is if if if that you know it can be really frustrating but if that happens I really think the best advice is not to move forward with the meeting um because didn't move forward with the meeting I'm saying it's wrong that the public was anticipating a meeting oh I see noce was just that the agenda agenda so the meeting never happened yeah you know again that that would you know that I can understand the flip side of why it would be frustrating for the public for that to happen but um you know it you know people make mistakes you know we're all human
056we forget to do things we you know we forget about a holiday or something like that but but um you know if you move forward with a meeting where the agenda was never posted you know it's kind of a Surefire you know uh opening for somebody to bring not asking we move forward I'm just saying it was intentionally done and so is there any sort of like if you don't do hold a meeting with the meeting is supposed to be held is there any sort of um so yeah there really isn't you know foi doesn't um it's kind of interesting you know because the the law is all predicated on people getting to meetings so um you know it like sometimes people will call you know call me and ask me because this is kind
057of like cancellation people sometimes ask you is there a proper way to cancel a meeting um you know there really our law doesn't really address that so you know it would be like similar to you know you had a meeting date you get there and we don't have a quorum and somebody's sick and whatever and then we just can't have a meeting because we don't have a quum um you know frustrating for everybody involved but you know you can't have a meeting without the quum so you know not really you know because our you know our violation is somebody can't get to the meeting so if the meeting never happens then there's no you know there's no recourse with with with foi um Qui quick follow up on that thing you said um can't have
058a meeting without a forum this meeting was noticed for a while we had four people here could that meeting not still be held and broadcast well um information yeah I shouldn't say that you can't you know you can't have a meeting you can't vote on anything so you know you could you could still be here you know today it doesn't really matter because I'm not voting on anything I don't think so um you know it's not like oh because we we don't have a quum we all have to go home home and and tell Russell to drive back to Hartford um you know but um but you can't vote on anything if you don't if you if we had action items like public comments and committee reports we would be able to do that and
059get that out the way but just wouldn't be able to vote on EX yeah ex exactly so you know what happens in some instances where you know what some towns will do is is if they they're in a situation like that and they don't have a quum you know it's technically not a meeting it's one of these gatherings of lesson quum you know sometimes they'll just proceed with things like you mentioned and then some sometimes they'll even still submit minutes even though it wasn't formally a meeting we're just going to you know submit the minutes of whatever we did you know just so people know what happened and then at the next meeting we're going to have to take up the items that we couldn't get to because we couldn't you know we couldn't vote
060on them awesome thank you um okay so um you know the other difference between a regular meeting versus a special meeting is that at a regular meeting you can by a two-thirds vote you can uh vote to add items to the agenda so you know you often have new business you can go around does anyone have any new business and um you know somebody could add something to the agenda and you guys could discuss it and you could potentially act on it if you wanted to at a regular meeting at a special meeting you cannot add any new business to the agenda so tonight if you know something came up and somebody said hey you know we got this other thing that somebody raised we want to talk about it um you would not be
061able to add a new item for discussion uh today because we're at you know special meeting so um just you know important to remember special meeting agendas just double check everything's on there you know if somebody comes in late with something it would you know unfortunately you wouldn't be able to take up um at that meeting um and a committee meeting is considered a special meeting for those purposes cor right uh the subcommittees yes um um unless they submit a regular meeting schedule so a lot of subcommittees will just always we'll just only do special meetings but if you knew at the start of the Year hey are you know we're doing a major High School renovation project and the school building subcommittee is going to meet twice a month you could put those out
062and do a regular meeting schedule and have regular meetings but you know if it's something where you know they just kind of meet as needed then they would all be special meetings and so we would have to do the filing requirements with the same filing requirements we do for the regularly scheduled meetings for the subcommittee if you wanted to have regular meetings yeah but you could also just operate with only special meetings because some of your subit thinking about add agenda items sometimes things will come up before the meeting but if we got the regular one scheduled we can add by two3 but if we don't have a schedule we can't Ed it by yeah you can thing so I think you know maybe what you know what I would say is you know you
063look at you know different subcommittees you might have and if you know there are ones that are going to need to meet frequent you know you because you could always cancel meetings so you could always put a regular meeting on the calendar every month for a subcommittee and then if they don't need to meet that month you just put a notice hey you know that subcommittee meeting for this month is canceled yes right we have established committees we have four established committees right now and we have just set a regular meeting schedule for those four committees okay so on this Wednesday of the month my committee is going to meet so is that a regular meeting or a special meeting regular meeting because you you put a year schedule lost their speci their special meetings
064okay I can confirm that with I believe no a little more clarity on that but it's only filed on our website is not filed with the secretary no so it doesn't um okay yeah the the the statute is a little bit confusing so the the secretary anything to go to the secretary of state is only for state agencies so for you it is your it's your it's your office you know it's making sure it goes to your board office goes on your website yeah goes to city clerk um so it would need to be filed with the city clerk as a regular meeting if they're not with the city clerk regular meetings they well I mean they're bylaw say they special meetings I'm I'm well under under so your bylaws can call them special meetings
065under foi if it appears on our annual meeting schedule it's a regular meeting so but so if it appears on an annual meeting schedule then that for it to be proper that has to be filed with the city clerk that's how we would do it I know we don't go to the Secretary State yes yeah so you would file so what's your what's your subcommittee or your committee instruction and student support okay so if you file at this at the start of the year you know these are the monthly meetings for the instruction and student support committee um then those are regular meetings you know we are going to meet the third Wednesday of every month and you put all those out there and then now those are regular meetings um so you could add
066something to you know and again it doesn't mean you know that will override their bylaws well if there's so um if there's a conflict between bylaws and state statute then you know I would go by you know under our statute it just called a regular meeting if you put it on an annual meeting schedule so but real quick to that we could um disend our by loads by yeah so I mean yeah I mean I would say if you're if in the future you're clean up bylaws maybe that's something to take you know what I have told my curiosity I'm not yeah what I've told people in different scenarios is you know if you're going through your bylaws and you're you know you're doing meeting stuff I mean you know I'm not a bylaw expert
067but I would think you could just kind of say we will hold our meetings in accordance with the foi law you know like that you know it's not like you have to you know we have a law that deals with public meeting so unless you want to go beyond that some places they want to be stricter you know if you want to say look we want to put it in our bylaws that we do public comment we want to put it in our bylaws that we're always going to have remote access you know you can you can make stricter bylaws but you know everyone has to follow follow foer um okay so the last thing and we'll talk more about you know what goes in the minutes in a second but it's just a small
068distinction uh you get uh regular meeting minutes need to be file within seven calendar days of the meeting and um special meeting minutes you get seven business days so uh you get a little bit more time to do the minutes for tonight um again I don't know why they made that distinction but uh seven calendar days regular meeting seven business days special meeting uh there is a third type of meeting it doesn't come up all that often and it is called an emergency meeting and um you know the name sort of explains it right it's only in the event of an emergency and um our Supreme Court uh actually looked at this issue in uh a case involving the town of Ridgefield a number of years ago and what our Supreme Court said was you
069know basically you know an emergency meeting is an unnoticed meeting there's no notice and there's no agenda so um you know what is an emergency while our Supreme Court said it's got to be something that is unexpected in demands immediate action that makes it impossible to give a 24-hour notice for a special meeting so really uh you know we are thinking about situations of you know a lot of times it's going to be you know maybe there's a major weather event there's some kind of safety issue you know maybe during covid when there were decisions having to be made very quickly about you know remote learning or closing schools it's something where you know the issue is so pressing that we cannot wait 24 hours um to hold a a special meeting so uh it
070is an option you know should really be used sparingly and if you do have an emergency meeting then uh the minutes of the emergency meeting need to be filed within 72 hours of the meeting they have to be posted online and you have to State the reason for the Emergency um in the minutes so again it's an option that's available if something really uh you know really dire comes up but but you know really reserved for you know those sort of situations that again you know if we wait 24 hours there's going to be some sort of consequence you know there's you know 4et of snow on the roof of the school and we have to hire a contractor to come out here and you know clear it off or the roof is going to
071flaps or something like that um okay so and then we kind of alluded to this a few times but uh this is uh what I like to call when is a meeting not a meeting so earlier we talked about you know Quorum is really kind of the key thing so there are a few times when that really doesn't apply so there are some instances where you would be allowed to have a quorum or more of your board members uh talking about things that that uh you know may pertain to board business um you know in couple of these these instances so the the the first one I'll talk about is caucuses because that's the one that comes up most frequently so um a caucus is actually defined in the foi law and there's two different
072types of caucuses the first is uh you know members of the same Board of the same political party so you know Democrats on the board of education they are a caucus no matter how many of them there are they can meet uh even if it's a majority and they can discuss whatever they want under the sun because the law doesn't limit what you can talk about in a caucus um you know my uh understand understanding of this is that the reason we have this caucus exemption is really that when the general assembly was passing the foi law somebody said hey wait a second what about our caucuses right if you've ever spent any time up at the capital you know they're caucusing all the time um I used to be a reporter as I mentioned
073you know I would cover the capital sometimes and you know you'd look at the calendar and oh you know the house is going to come in at 10:00 a.m. and they wouldn't take up any bills until about noon because they'd be in caucus for two hours so um you know it applies to them it also applies to you um so so you know members of the same board and same political party the other option is if you have a majority of a board that maybe is made up of you know it might be the Democrats and maybe there was a petitioning candidate or there was an unaffiliated candidate that was you know endorsed by the Democrats or a minor Party candidate or Working Families whatever it might be um if somebody is not you know
074within the same party as the other people in the caucus then the law does require you to register your caucus and say you know for the term on the board of education you know the majority caucus is you know the four Democrats and the one you know Working Families member and then you register that and then for the purposes of foi those people are allowed to caucus and even though one of them is from a different party they can be in on those those conversations yes so if they are registered Democrats but got their seat on the board through a third party independent or working family is that the same thing or if there it goes by party affiliation so if you are a registered Democrat then you can cus with other registered Democrats if
075you were registered Working Families you know then you would have to f just to say you know I am working families but I'm reg I'm going to caucus with the Democrats on the board of education to throw a quick scenario to get some clarity or something say say we are a five member board which we are not and all five of us sitting here and we happen to be all we happen to be all Democrats some some there no minority party representation say we don't want Mr Benin and her caucus can the four of us caucus without the fifth Democrat so um yes so I mean I think that I think you could you know that that becomes more of an issue of um kind of you know like I don't think you could prohibit
076him from joining your caucus if you guys wanted to be mean and decide not to invite him you know to your caucus um it wouldn't be an foi you know violation you know it's not like every member has to has to be there but you know I think he would have a right to participate it's not like you could tell him no you have to go away you know you can't be here you know if he's part of the caucus then you know he can participate in in in the discussions but if you know somebody gets left out um you know that wouldn't be a you know be a violation do we have any obligation to tell this B um I mean that you know it's kind of outside the scope of the foi doesn't
077you know it's not really addressed so you know it's your you know I've gotten that issue before though there in some towns you know people have asked me you know you know actually got calls from people you know saying can we caucus without one of our members because we don't want to have the person there but um you know that's a that's a board inter a personal political kind of thing so let's follow up on that does the caucus saying include committees as well um so you're saying could the members of committee caucus correct um yes so the members of a committee could could caucus but what I think is you want to be careful of is you cannot have caucuses across you know different boards so what I'm you know what that means is
078you know uh if um I so I think in the committee it probably wouldn't apply but like I'll give you another example of you know so people ask about this it's the same board meeting like you cannot bring the Democrats on the city council to the Board of Education caucus of the Democrats because we're all Democrats um you could have a caucus on your subcommittees you know might be smaller but yeah same same rule would apply there um you know but yeah you don't want to be Crossing other boards bringing other people in um you know you can't be bringing in the town chair chairman or anything like that you know because unless that person is on the board but if they're not on the board then you know they are not a um party
079of the caucus thank thank you y um so and then there's a couple other instances where you know you guys maybe potentially would be involved in in discussions that would not have to take place at a public meeting uh the first is a Personnel search committee so uh you know this comes up most often in the context of uh you know for school boards of of a looking for a superintendent so uh you can create a Personnel search committee and the board can you know pick whoever they want to be on that personel search committee in some cases the board will make the board the personel search committee and you're allowed to do that so you could say all of us board members we are the personel search Comm committee and while you were meeting
080as a Personnel search committee or while the Personnel search committee you've created is meeting um they don't have to notice the meetings they don't have to do agendas or minutes or any of that um but the only thing that they're supposed to do is come up with a recommendation for a candidate or candidates for that position and then those candidates go through the normal process you know of the board with you know an interview maybe and a public vote and all that so A search committee can can meet outside of foi but the only thing they're supposed to do is you know come up with candidates for that position it should not be an opportunity to discuss other issues that might be pending before the board um strategy or negotiations related to collective bargaining you
081know this basically means that you know if there was an instance where you know the whole board wanted to sit down with the union leaders to to talk about a contract they could do that if they wanted to uh you know it doesn't mean that you can only have meetings you know to discuss collective bargaining with you know smaller groups of the board the whole board wanted to be in one of those meetings they would be allowed to do that um you know if it pertained to strategy or negotiation uh you certainly again like voting on a contract you know those are votes that you have to to take up at your at your regular um you know meetings to the normal course of business um staff meetings that just means that you know a
082meeting of public agency staff is not a public meeting so meetings of school staff are not public meetings um and then chancer social meetings what this means is you know the law recognizes and allows that you know there might be times when a quorum of of a board is going to be at you know some sort of event and they're going to be gathered there together um and the event is not not for the purposes of discussing board business you know it might be that you guys go to the high school graduation you go to a high school football game you know you go to a whatever it is you community event that's going on um the key thing though is everything we talked about with not discussing your board business you know within with
083among a forum still applies so the whole board of education is sitting up there you know on the stage at graduation they shouldn't be passing notes back and forth about the budget or something like that um does anyone have any questions on any of that yeah um Rec got um some Community fors I believe that ask about this now it's it's run by the superintendent but can a board member or should a board member participate as a public participant and ask questions or yeah so so sometimes people ask about this you know sort of like in the context of um you know sometimes where it comes up is like meetings of other boards and can I go and can I speak at public comment and and the way I try to look at it is
084um you know you don't lose your right as kind of like a citizen just because you're on a board so if there's a public meeting there's a event that you want to go to and you want to speak um you know even if you want to speak as a board member you know I I I don't think there's any issue with that the issue would be you know if you do this forum you know get to know the new superintendent kind of thing and all the board members want to go to Just support the program that's that's fine but you wouldn't want to all be sitting in the back row and talking about you know other board business while you're in while you're in that setting so it's not that you can't go to those
085types of meetings it's not that you couldn't speak in public comment you know at at at a meeting like that that it's really about the discussion among the board members so you know if you were to ask a question of the superintendent and you get an answer and then you go back to your seat and you're talking with everyone else about what the superintendent said you know that would be where the issue would be not that you're asking a question at the at the public meeting sure go ahead yes you said at like the The Forum your example Joe that um he could speak as a board member is that correct did yeah I mean I'm just saying that him him as one board member speaking about wars business does not make a meeting that's
086what I'm saying I'm saying you may think it might not be proper according to whatever you know your determination is but from an foi perspective he could speak as a board member but not on behalf of the board is kind of like what yeah yeah that's kind the policy yeah know yeah not not saying that he's representing the board but he can he can go and he can say you know hi I'm Joe I'm on the board of education I'm here tonight you know to support our new superintendent as a whole yeah but that's a again that's not Pi understood clearly yeah yeah um you know again everything I say you can and can't do it's about foi you guys may have other things about um you know what you would like you know board
087members to do or you know or not do um like I know a lot of times you know uh you know they'll they'll per if somebody you know writes to a board member they'll you know they'll funnel it to the chairperson the responder they'll get It'll ask superintendent you know to respond to what they're supposed but the communication to the board member is not you know it's it's not improper for someone to email one Board of Education member and ask them a question or something how how the response happens might be your you know the way that you handle it but representing what the board's doing at that time is not making board business yeah no superintendent is speaking about the the the budget process and a board member who speaks to that process is
088not doing for there's no no and even if it was it's only one member so it's yeah it's not you know uh it so I think again the thing with with those types of events is you know you um you know you can go you can ask questions whatever you want to do but you but if if there was a forum or more board members there you know they could not be discussing what you know let's say the event let's say the event went really poorly they should not all be out in the hallway afterwards saying oh my God you know what's going on with this person you know we got to do something we had an executive session and talk to him about what's got you know like that would be what you wouldn't
089want to do if you go and you observe and you listen and you ask a question or you speak to people you know that's the kind of of the line is there um okay so you know those are the the sort of the car V outs to to um to the meetings provisions of foi um minutes so uh with minutes what I think is really important to uh you know to know is that minutes do not need to really be a uh you know re-encapsulation of the entire um you know the entire meeting um and I mean no disrespect to our to our minutes Tak Akers but um you know really the the legal requirements for minutes are very very sparse uh really the minutes are meant to be a record of the votes so
090legal minutes all you have to have is a recording of you know who voted for what or for whom so you do need to identify you know how members voted so something is not unanimous you know you want to identify uh you know who the Nay votes were um in the in in the minutes there um you do have to include the attendance of the board members so you know who was in attendance at the meeting um you know also if you do have you know HB meetings like this uh you you should uh note you know who participated remotely you know in the meeting um and uh you know other than that um if you have an executive session you need to include anyone who attended the executive session besides the board members so
091really the content of the meeting how much detail you go into is really up to you the most important thing is you have to get the minutes filed within seven days so most people are pretty good about finding the balance of where you know they can can achieve something that is you know is representative of the meeting um but they get it done in a in a timely uh you know timely manner um you know if your minutes were you know super super detailed and they were 12 pages single spaced and they really were you know really really great but they were filed three weeks after the meeting you know the foi commission would say well we're sorry but you know these are great minutes but they were late so the number one thing with
092minutes is you want to get them in on time um interestingly enough uh you know I think I might have mentioned this earlier with the agendas it's the same thing for minutes the law does not actually require U minutes of of um Municipal boards and commissions to be posted on the website um I will say that is where people look for them so again you know try to post them on the website in a timely manner um you know but I've had people who have called me and they say look you know there was a meeting last week the minutes aren't on the website how do I file an fi complaint and the first thing I tell them is did you call you know the board office because they might be there you know it
093might be that they're in the office they're available they just haven't gotten posted to the website and that would be okay um but you know try to post them on the website um you know in a in a timely manner uh minutes are still required even if there's a recording of the video available uh you know even if it's a virtual meeting and you record it you still do minutes we do minutes for every meeting if there's a recording you know the minutes might be might be shorter because you could always put a link to the recording in the minutes you know for example if you wanted to um so our law doesn't really address the approval process of minutes but sometimes people ask about that I find that you know the best way to
094do it uh at least in my my opinion is um put them on the agenda for the next meeting um discuss them there uh make you know if there need to be any changes that are made you can you can to to make the changes adopt the minutes and then in that set of minutes from that meeting you could you know note that they were adopted with the following you know the following changes um you know we talked earlier about you know discussions with board business um I've get this question sometimes you know even discussing changes to the minutes is is actually board business so you know if you're approving the minutes it should be at you know on the agenda at the evening it should not be something done you know over email um
095you know and taking a vote or anything that way um anyone have any questions on minutes um so electronic and remote meetings uh what I usually tell people with this is you know there's a couple things I want to highlight but if you have you know if you have other questions you know happy to to entertain them but if you really want to get a deep dive on our website we have um what is called our remote meetings primer and it really kind of goes into uh really sort of painstaking detail about the provisions in the law about remote meetings and um you know the remote meeting section of the law they tried to take into account all the different you know uh scenarios that could happen so there's things in there that I really
096won't get into a lot of detail about but you know it's like things like what do we do if we lose the internet connection and we get it back and you know we have to reboot the meeting and you know uh what happens if you know a member loses their connection you know but we didn't lose a quum you know do we have to wait for the person to get back so there's all these different things that are kind of all spelled out in there and again if people have questions you know happy to answer them once we go through this but um I'm just going to highlight a few of the things that I think are important to know the first is if you to have you know whether or not you want to
097have remote meetings is up to you that is a policy decision uh it is not required that you have remote access to your meetings um I will say as you probably well know I think people got used to this during covid and I think people kind of like it I think people like that they can either go and watch the recording afterwards or they can you know watch along from home while it's ongoing um you know board members probably like it too you know get provides for flexibility um you know if they can't make it on a particular evening they have child care issues whatever it might be you know they can still participate if something himself um but it is up to you how you have your meetings so you can have iners meetings
098you can have hybrid meetings you can have fully virtual meetings um really the way I you know I want I want you all to think about it is if we want to do electronic meetings there's just some extra rules that we have to follow um so the first is if you're going to have one of your regular meetings so one of your regular monthly board meetings is going to be either hybrid or fully remote there's going to be some sort of the law calls it electronic access there's going to be some kind of electronic access to the meeting um 48 hours before the meeting uh again this goes with the same thing we talked about with the 24 and the filing and all that but this is 48 um you have to uh post a
099notice that uh has the instructions on how somebody can attend that meeting electronically so essentially the link to how people can get it the WebEx the zoom whatever the virtual option is that information needs to be out there 48 hours ahead of time the reason for that is that the law has a period of time where if somebody does not have you know access to technology and they can't get to you know maybe it's a solely remote meeting and they don't have the technology the public agency is suppos to make accommodations for that person so that could be something where you tell them hey you know you can go to the library and you can watch the meeting there or you know you can come to our offices and we'll have somebody there with a
100laptop and you can watch the meeting um you know whatever it might be obviously if there's an iners option then um you know people can always just come in person so you know that's that doesn't you know pose as much of an issue so I feel like hybrid seems to be kind of a good middle ground people seem to like that um people sometimes ask about recording of meetings you know do we have to record our virtual meetings the only meetings that you have to record uh in terms of of virtual meetings are um online only regular meetings so if you decided you know for for one month your regular board meetings were only going to be online you know let's say it's February and we've got a lot of snow and you're just thinking
101well let's just do these meetings online so we can make sure they don't get cancelled um if you did that then you would have to make sure those meetings get recorded and you would have to post that recording on your website within seven days and the recording would have to remain available on your website for at least 45 days so if you want to record meetings other than those you know solely on online regular meetings you could certainly do that um that's up to you um but it's not required by by the law um you still submit minutes even if a recording is available you know minutes again are the permanent record of of what transpired at the meeting um so you want to make sure that you submit your minutes and then the last
102thing I I always try to share on on remote meetings is um that you know if people are being unruly or they're being disrespectful or they're acting up online uh you know you have the right to run an orderly meeting and that means that you know if people are talking talking talking and you can't hear yourself think you could mute them you could kick them out you know maybe give them a warning first but you know people do not have the right to interrupt your online meetings uh you know it's the same way at an in-person meeting if people were you know yelling and screaming and they wouldn't stop talking and you guys couldn't do your business you know sometimes I I don't know if this has ever happened hopefully not but you know I
103I know of meetings where they've had to get the police involved you know they've had to get the police in there to escort somebody out because they wouldn't you know they were so agitated about something uh in the online world it's a lot easier because we just kind of click the button and and they go away um so you know again uh you know if if something gets gets out of hand you know you have the right to run an orderly meeting there um does anyone have any questions on on electronic meetings here it's not electronic I missed the minutes per and it's triggered by this ComEd or how long minutes required to be available so um minutes are are supposed to be kept indefinitely doesn't mean on the website forever but um the records
104retention schedules uh this State library is in charge of records retention it's kind of you know similar to Foya but it's not us you know we can't do anything about records retention but um the state does say minutes you're supposed to keep forever so um you know a copy of them doesn't mean every one of you has to keep the minutes forever but the district should retain a copy of the minutes doesn't mean it's on the website you know it's not like you have to keep your minutes from 12 years ago on the website but um you know they should be filed somewhere where somebody could um thank you or somebody could get that I I'm fine want to make sure if he wants water thank you he's sitting up there talking the whole time
105um you know it's funny I actually did this uh for the city of bridport this morning so this is my my second that was that was virtual your second run here my second my second run through the city doesn't do it we we do all our meetings online and they're available on YouTube for people to watch after the meeting so the city doesn't do that yeah I mean I I you know I do think that um you know having having the virtual you know having reportings accessible is is a good good um is a good idea you know but again it's not required so it's a decision you know you you get to make there um but I do know a lot of You Know Places invested in all this equipment during covid so my
106argument has always kind of been well you know if you bought all this stuff and you were doing it you know you can still do it I think it does provide a level of access that well a lot of people Avail themselves though knowing that they can watch our meeting later and so they they they either go online don't come to our meetings but know they can watch them from home or they watch them later knowing that they're work and they watch the meeting later so it's that you actually can watch the number go up of who's viewed the meetings yeah um yeah and so you know it as I said right now you know there's not a requirement that you have to do it but um you know there there's been um you know
107there's been some discussions at the legislature not necessarily about mandatory online meetings but you know some of these things about remote meetings may change because I think we're all kind of still learning as we're going I know now it's been hard to believe we're coming up on five years you know since Co but I think we still are sort of figuring out you know what works best what do people like um so you know that's something that you guys can kind of develop as you go you know what what seems to be the best way to do it um any other questions on electronic meetings all right so executive session this is uh this is probably the part of foi in terms of meetings that is really the most difficult and that is because it
108really requires uh the most the most judgment you know some of the other things are really cut and dry you know agenda is either filed or not filed minutes or seven days or you're late um you know executive session sometimes it can require discretion you know to decide does this fit in you know can we do this in an executive session uh that's a very common you know call that I get from people is you know someone ask me hey you know this is what we want to do can we do this in the executive session or not um so what I'll say just for starters is you know really the idea of executive session is you know we are talking about something in a closed session for you know really a good reason not
109because it's embarrassing not because it's a difficult conversation not because you know we don't want the public to know about this uh really you know as we go through these and we talk about them I think you kind of understand the idea is really a lot of times it's for the benefit of the district and for the the residents you know you don't have to talk about your legal strategy in public you don't have to talk about sensitive school security matters in public you know it's really kind of about protecting the interests of of the district it's not about avoiding those tough conversations or or or or having to you know giving you the ability to do make decisions and things like that without without public knowledge um so you know really if you think
110about it executive session is contrary to the whole idea of foi right the whole idea of foi is everything done in public um you know but the legislature recognized there might be certain things that you know makes more sense to discuss it in a closed session um the other thing I like to know uh you know with this is that um you know executive session is an option so it doesn't mean you have to talk about these things in an executive session um you know if there was some sort of personnel issue and it was so urgent and so big of a thing you could decide that we want to talk about it you know in in in public you know that there was some issue that happened that everyone knew about it was all
111over the newspaper you know you could say we're going to talk about it in public because everyone knows what happened or because we think it's important or we want to be transparent so um it doesn't mean that if it is one of these things you have to talk about it in the executive session it's an option to you more often than not you probably choose that but um I just just mentioned that so uh the first thing you can talk about in an executive session you can talk about Personnel matters and um you know this can be Personnel matters you know is discussion of uh you know an employee or it could also be um a public officer so it can also be about a board member um so the things you know what does
112a Personnel matter well it's discussing the appointment uh the employment the evaluation uh the health uh or the dismissal of of any you know employee or board member and um what's really important is if you're going to discuss somebody in an executive session you have to notify the person and the reason for that is that under the law they have the right to uh to basically demand that the discussion happen in Open Session instead and if that happens uh the board has no choice they have to if they're going to proceed with the item they have to proceed in public session um so you know if there was a disciplinary matter involving you know a teacher and it came before your board and you have you know you tell the teacher hey you know Mr
113Jones you know there something's going on you know there's an investigation involving you you know you're we want you to come to the executive session to talk about what happen if Mr Jones says no I would prefer that we do that in public then the board would have to talk about it in public um so that is Personnel matters uh yes you said it twice and but I read it differently and what it says there person being discussed can request Open session so technically is can demand Open Session because if they that's a better term yeah yeah maybe maybe if should say demand instead of request but yeah if they ask for it then it has to it has to be done yeah get a choice yeah exactly um but on the flip side they
114can't demand executive session no no they cannot demand executive session it's up the board you know again if there was something happened that was really bad and you said well everyone already knows and we want to do it in public the person can't come to you and say you have to talk about me in executive session uh you know different people have different rights under the foi law and really what that is is it's a right extended to public employees to say you know your boards can't talk about you privately without you kind of giving them an an okay yes you correct me from Ron the way you said that you talk about any staff but the staff decide no let's do it in public cannot say no we got we need we got to
115take the section right no you cannot yeah so if the person requests if the person says I want it in public then you have to do it in public but if we say no we have to do a secet section because the situation and we de decid like you said just few minutes ago what is the different because we say no we have to be second section because you know this situation that's that can um if it if it if it's about a Personnel matter then then they they have the ability to request the Open session so doesn't mean these other things you know like so if it's a security issue it doesn't mean somebody can come in and say no you have to talk about a security issue in public session it's more about
116if you're talking about you know my job then I get to decide whether you get to do that in public or you know whether you do that you know behind closed doors or not um you know is is essentially how it works so all right thank online question Mr wson yes have a quick question can can a board can a board member um request that um person who is an employee of the district can we request that like see they have a point an employee of the district has um has an uh a clause in their contract where it has to they have to have a meeting an executive session can the a board member request that it be in public so so somebody has a clause in their contract that they have that what
117needs to be done in executive whatever discussion has to be done in the con session um I mean I I guess if the board I mean you know I think I think if the board approves the it's kind of like the board approved the contract and they've tied the hands of the board and potentially maybe a a future board um you know I I I I I'm not an expert in contract law but you know I I I think think if the board agreed to that then you know I think it couldn't be the inverse you know I think that you you know if somebody had in their contract that said you know you have to discuss my employment matters in executive session then you know I I I again I'm not an expert in
118contract law but you know I I I you know I I think that would be you know it would force the board to do it you know our law doesn't require you to do it now you've got a contract that's requiring you to do it now I don't know if the contract is like a foul of foi and that's I don't want to make a legal determination about that but you know you could not have the inverse that says you know that you know you're you're going to you know deny somebody the opportunity to talk about it in public if they make that you know before you say anything We're Not Gonna specifically talk about anybody's contract just talking about We're Not Gonna specific General Andre do you still have yes I have I have
119another I have another question um Can a board member like go to the go to the state board meeting and and speak as a speak as a a member of the board like as representing the board so that would I mean that's kind of outside the scope of foi you know that's not really something that you know it's not a violation of our law in any way but you know certainly you guys might have policies or procedures or you know somebody might not think it's a good idea but but it's not an foi issue it might be an issue elsewhere uh but it would not be you know our law doesn't really address whether you know it's allowed or not so it's not an issue for f any other questions Woodson thank you I just
120don't want to I just don't want to forgive my question and a contract supersede fo for instance if there is a contract that has language that has to be discussed in executive session can you go into exec session with less than two3 of a vote so you can't go into an executive session with less than two-third of vot no matter what that is that is State Statute and and I I don't I don't believe that you could have a contract that would override you know that would override that I what what I'll say is that um and this is kind of um you know this is an issue that has come up but this is sort of larger and and the and this is at the state level and this is not the local level
121there have been times at the state level where our legislature has approved contracts and there had been Clauses that have superseded you know the foi law but that's because they're the state legislature so they the state legislature can you know if they wanted to approve a this came up with the state police there was a contract that was approved um I think it has since been changed but they had a provision in their contract that said um that they would not disclose any internal investigation reports where there was not a finding of wrongdoing um so that was counter to the foi law but because the state lawmakers passed it it was a supersedence of of the foi law but I don't believe that you could locally have a contract or an ordinance or a rule
122or anything that says you know we can go into executive session less than a two3 well right and and uh on the same vein this actually has more to do with records and other types of contracts like say say a vendor or somebody wanted to say you can never disclose the cost of our contract um you can never so so there is an exemption you know and we could talk about some of this when we get to records there is an exemption for something it's called the trade secret that may potentially fall under that depending but you would be the ones to make the Judgment you know the company can say we think this is a trade secret and it might be a trade secret under foi but there's kind of an analysis that has
123to happen and you guys would be the ones to make that determination but but but in in general if we buy textbooks and it cost $3,000 or professional development yeah in general it's not in general it's not going to be cost amounts it's it's more likely that you know it might come up the context of like intellectual property or um you know really trade secret you know somebody's kind of sharing you know proprietary information about their products about their services you know those uh you know those kind of things that somebody is um you know again that you're not you know providing the intellectual property of of a business you know to somebody under Foya their competitors cannot you know foi the the details about their products that they're sharing with you because you're a
124customer maybe something like that but I don't think a cost um you know like the cost to the district you know what the district paid you know those types of things would be um you know would would probably not you know be a trade secret you know if for some reason the company shared financial information about how they're doing you know hey look at all this money we're making and this is our balance sheet you know maybe that's a trade secret right they share that with you or something um but we can touch on that so just to get back to the reasons for executive session Personnel we covered that um pending claims or litigation the keyword in there is is pending um so really you know this is either something has been filed or
125it could be the board is considering taking some kind of legal action um you know but but it is not you know Freer range sort of legal Q&A um you know pending claims or litigation if that is on the agenda it you know it means that there should be you know something has been filed you've received a demand letter you know maybe somebody has you know intimated they're going to sue the district they sent a letter they're asking for something if they they're saying if they don't get it they'll go to court um could be an foi complaint you know chro complaint um and again it could also be the board you know considering the board is going to go to Court over something and they want to talk about whether or not they're going
126to file a lawsuit or something uh you know they could uh they could talk about that in the executive session you can have an executive session to discuss security matters if you are concerned that a public discussion would would compromise the security issue um you know unfortunately this came up a lot at Boards of Education after Sandy Hook there were a lot of conversations you know uh hard conversations about security measures and cameras and all the things we were doing to protect the students um obviously makes sense right we don't want to have that done you know publicly because you know a bad actor potentially could could could hear what we're doing to you know protect the students and use that to to commit some sort of uh you know crime or or active violence
127so security matters you can talk about that in executive session you can discuss the sale lease of property um if there's a concern that publicity would impact the price point um you know the way to think of this is you know maybe uh there's a piece of land you know on the market that you guys look at it and you say gee you know we need to build a new athletic complex and this place seems like it would be really good and you know you haven't made the offer yet and you know really the idea is you're not tipping off other people in the community that the city is about to put in an offer to buy this land you know if you had to talk about it everything in public before you put the
128offer in then you know somebody else could come in and they could put the offer in the price goes up because now you're in a bidding war with you know a business or something like that um and then the last one is really the broadest exemption you can discuss any records that are exempt from foi in an executive session which makes sense right if we wouldn't have to disclose it under Foya you know required to publicly you know discuss and debate it you know in in a public session um you know where this comes up a lot in the context of school districts obviously you guys know furpa you know so if you're ever having any you know any conversations or sessions or dealings with you know it particular student information um you know sometimes
129this comes up like with expulsion hearings you know it is it's it's a proceeding but it's done in a closed session because you know necessarily you're having to uh disclose and share you know identifying information about um you know about a student it could also be attorney client PR you you receed the legal communication from your your attorney and you want to have an executive session to review that uh you know you could you could discuss that um we'll talk more about you know different exemptions in a second but if it's something that you wouldn't disclose under Foya you could discuss it in in an executive session in a me this quick question about explosion here is we used to post them and notice them but we haven't in quite a while so I think
130it depends on um so this is kind of something that you know I'm not an expert on it but I know in the education statutes there's kind of a couple different ways that you can do an expulsion hearing I think it might depend on how you do it because I think it's either you can do like a panel or you can like have assign somebody as a you know as the person to do it um um I I I think you know I I can check on that for you and get you the exact answer because I'm not I'll I'll be I'm not I'm not certain I I do see them in some in some districts I see them in other ones I don't and you know my understanding was I think it kind of
131depends on you know how how you do it um and also it may depend on you know the number of people that are there you know if it's less than a you know if it's only one or two board members that yeah so so it might yeah I I I generally you know it's one of those things where it's a closed session anyway so um you know I I can check on that for you but I think just curious yeah because the expulsion hearings are kind of you know the other thing that comes up sometimes is sometimes when things are really you know created and addressed in other statu um they kind of don't fall within our our jurisdiction uh you know like this is kind of an interesting one that I we learned about
132recently so you may know there's an exemption in the F or it's actually not in the foi law there's an exemption in the education statutes that's that talks about how um you know teacher evaluations are not foilable um so I actually learned a little bit more about this it's actually that they're not considered public records under the law um so you know we've got a case ongoing right now that's actually kind of interesting where it's it's somebody who worked in a school district and is trying to get a copy of his own evaluation and they are not giving it to him for some reason and he brought a complaint to the FI commission it might get dismissed because it's not even a public record even to even though this person worked in the district they're
133not giving it to him but we can't do anything because it's outside of our scope so the expulsion hearings I think that might be something that is kind of outside of our outside of our scope you know they're they're not a public meeting it's an expulsion hearing according to those proceed you know those statutes so thank records exempt from foa are draft documents exempt like yeah that is an exemption y we yeah we'll talk about that in a second um okay um so you know some of the just some other things that you know quickly on Executive session um you know need a two-thirds vote to go into executive session so make sure you do that make sure you record that in the minutes you cannot vote in executive session you know hopefully we all
134know that um you can invite in anyone that you want to assist you into the executive session um provided that they're there providing their opinion they're providing their testimony they're answering their questions um we had a case recently involving a school board where we said that even the superintendent if the superintendent comes into the executive session but they're not participating even the presence of the superintendent is is not allowed so um anyone you bring into the executive session they should be there you know as an active participant they're listening they're asking questions they're offering you opinion expertise advice whatever it might be um and they might be there for the whole time potentially if you need them there for the whole time but if you don't need the person there any longer you really should
135ask them to to to leave with with everyone else um you know uh we in in the case I just talked about our hearing officer had a good quote that I stolen and she said that you know executive session is not a spectator sport it is meant for the board members it meant for you to be able to deliberate on issues if you need the assistance of people to do that that's okay but you know if you don't need somebody there any longer and it's really just a discussion among the board members it should remain a discussion um among the board members and then last but not least with executive session uh just just a quick thing on agendas um try to be specific you know avoid just having you know a one or two
136word item on the agenda the commission has had cases where we've said you know if you just put executive session Personnel if you just put executive session security um that that is a violation of of the the notice provision so better agenda items you know um you know discussion of um you know security upgrades to Harding High School discussion of you know the performance of a high school principal this you know uh you know discussion of you know potential acquisition of land for recreation Fields you know something that is a little bit more than just a one or a two word uh answer you mentioned a discussion of U performance of a high school principal do you have to name the particular principal so you don't NE you don't have to identify the the specific
137individual um you know obviously like if it's the superintendent then you know people you only have one superintendent so people are going to know you know know who it is um you know but but yeah you want to the idea you know what I try to tell people is the topic is kind of fair game people get to know you know generally what the topic of an executive session is or they should know if you do the agenda correctly they don't get to know who said what or what is being discussed about that um you know I mean generally I think you know if we see a performance on an you know executive session you know we're going to think it could be bad but it could be good right it could be that the
138person's doing really well and you want to I don't know give them a raise or something right you're talking to them about how they're doing a good job you know but it it doesn't mean that you're going to have to identify the person or specifically say you know what the specific issue and I saw I think you had a question too right again just want to touch on it for myself uh must uh must be voted two3 to go into second session if there's not a two3 and there is still in second session meaning that is brought you're brought to or either electronically or in person and they go um what are the issues that can you know like what could the commission do in a case like that um yeah so you need to
139have the two-thirds vote so you know what sometimes what the commission does when there's when you know something is done improperly in executive session we could do a couple things you know we can um we could go back you know I I talked earlier about the Nullification so you know potentially the commission you know we could look at this and we could say you know whatever vote you know you have this executive disc discussion you voted on something we're going to wipe out the vote because you know that wasn't done properly what we could also do is um in some instances we have said you know if you if you discuss something in executive session it should have been discussed public session um we can issue an order and ask you to create minutes of
140the executive session you know to the best of your ability you're ordered to create minutes disclose what happened in that executive session because that conversation should have been done um you know in a public session it was not permissible to go into executive session to to to do that so it's a couple things there you know that that could happen saw my eyes D because you mentioned the word vote and I thought there's no voting in the second session no no I'm saying that you know but potentially if if you know if if the executive session discussion preceded a vote on something you know the commission could consider you know whether or not that vote you know that vote was proper or not because you know the whole discussion should have happened in public and
141then they voted on something so um you know but I've seen the minutes thing too you know again like we can order you to disclose what you did in the executive session and I'll just say you know foi complaints about executive sessions are you know they can be very difficult because um you know obviously people don't want to disclose what was said in the executive session but you know you're under oath at the foi commission you're going to have to answer questions kind of about you know what was said in gen you know it might even be in generalities but it's a very it could be a very difficult thing so you know if you're doing executive session make sure you you do it the right way and and make sure that you're going in
142for you know Val a valid reason um any questions on Executive session um all right so um we'll do a little bit here on on on records I know you've got the whole packet there so I want to cover you know really kind of the basics talk a little bit about dealing with records request and some of the exemptions we're not going to have time to get through every um every exemption in detail but you know if people have questions um you know I'll save a little bit of time at the end um you know for that um for that as well um so kind of like when we started off by looking at you know the the definition of a public meeting um I think it's important to look at the definition of what
143a public record is under the foi Act and the reason I think it's important is that you see how broad it is any recorded data or information relating to the conduct of the Public's business that is what makes something a public record if it relates to the conduct of the Public's business does it have to do with Schoolboard business that is what makes it a public record it doesn't matter excuse me um what kind of record it is it could be digital it could be hard copy could be a video could be an email um and also uh you know important to note that it's not just things you create it's also all the stuff that you receive you know somebody writes a letter to the Board of Education that is a public record then
144um also you don't see anything on there about the device that it exists on and this is where you know we run into the issue sometimes with personal devices now it is not an foi violation to use a personal device for board business and you know as in my experience dealing with a lot of boards it's almost you know it has to be done right this you know the city or the school board is not going to buy you all cell phones to give to you to you know to serve on the board so you're going to be using your personal cell phones um you know some districts you might have a board email uh that you might use some places they don't um but if you're sending emails or text messages and they pertain
145to board business and they're being sent from a personal device those are still public records now it doesn't mean that somebody gets to go looking through your personal device that's usually the first thing people get nervous about um but what it does mean is it means that somebody could make an foi request for example you know I want all the text messages between the chair of the board and superintendent you know about the um bomb threat you know that we had on on Thursday or whatever and somebody could make that request and then the chair would have to go through her messages and she would pull out any responsive records that she had and she would you know provide those to whoever's going to help facilitate the foi request so doesn't mean your phone becomes
146open for public inspection but the records that you create emails text messages and the like um you know are are still public records if they deal with public business now you know if uh you know two board members are friends or their kids go to the same school or something and they're talking socially you know that's a different story so again it doesn't just mean that you know every time you communicate with a board member it's automatically a public record it still does have to be about um you know about board business but uh you know I would just say uh that the the person who had this job before me for a number of years Tom henck um he he got it as a gift and he actually left it for me I have
147a little thing on my desk that says when end doubt don't press send um I just think that's something that you know is important for everyone to remember you know if you're serving on a board or committee and you send emails those are public records um you know and uh I've run into situations uh you know maybe not something that's you know come up here before but you know there are people who if they feel they're grieved by an agency they'll go and make a request and they'll say I want every email with my name in it and if you were writing emails about somebody and you were using their name and you were saying things that weren't nice you know they they're going to have to they might get those emails you know under
148foyer um so you know just to remember that you know if we're if we're talking about public business and we're talking about the the the the ongoings of the school district um those are public records whether it's on a personal device whether it's on your city email whether it's on City device um you know it doesn't really matter and you know the the the presumption under the foi law is that if it is a public record dealing with the you know Public's business then it is you know it is um available for inspection and available for for uh copies except as otherwise provided by any federal law or state statute so that one sentence there in the second paragraph really does a lot of heavy lifting and what it means is that you know if
149there are other laws that say something is confidential the teacher evaluations we talked about furpa we talked about um or there are exemptions that are right in the foi act you know attorning client privilege draft documents Safety and Security we we'll go through some of the the highlights with those um in a second so you know unless there is a law to the contrary the record has to be disclosed so what I try to tell people is you know if you are going to deny somebody's uh request for information or if you're going to redact things from a document there really needs to be some kind of statutory basis to do that you know you can't not give somebody information because we don't like this person or you can't you know deny an foi request
150because um you know we're worried about what the person is going to do with this information the law really is kind of um you know it doesn't look at the motive of the requestor it really doesn't matter you know quite frankly they don't have to tell you why they want the information and even if they told you hey I'm getting this information and I'm going to write a newspaper article and I think you guys are doing a lousy job that doesn't matter you know doesn't pertain to whether or not they get the information or not what you know what matters is is it a public record or not and then are there any exemptions or exceptions um to disclosure of that particular record um does anyone have any questions on any of that think kind
151of that determines what it is if it falls under one of those exemptions um so you know that that is kind of a you know different agencies do it differently polies that who say who polices it yeah so um you know that's something the commission often looks at you know typically what'll happen is you know you might get a you know if an fi request comes into the district you know they're going to prepare the documents they're probably going to have an attorney look through it review it you know see if there's exemptions that need to be made and then they're going to give it to the request if the requestor thinks that you know exemptions were made imp or um redactions were made improperly or things were withheld improperly that person can file a
152complaint with our commission and then what would happen is we would order the district to give us the full and complete unredacted records and then we would review them on of our attorneys would review them confidentially and then make a determination about what needs to be disclosed and what doesn't need to be disclosed um yes yeah follow follow when probably in the same vein um just try to get ahead of something right here because be discussing contracts employee contracts m not outside the bargaining unit um executive level contracts is it okay to redact the names on a contract or should the whole contract be discussed I I wouldn't think you would redact the name of of some title and position everything is should really be disclosable for yeah I mean I think a contract for
153a public employe I don't think there would be a lot in there that would be you know things that would be redacted um you know with with Personnel files which that would fall under you know the the standard you know we can talk more in detail about this in a second is you don't have to disclose anything that would be an invasion of personal privacy but I don't imagine there would be a lot in a contract that would be an invasion of personal privacy I mean if there were you know I don't know if there were references in there to how many children somebody had or something like that you know your health plan will cover you your spouse and your PO kids you know maybe information about somebody's family or something like that but
154you know the the the contract about what they're getting from the district you know they're being paid this they get a stien they get a card they get a retirement allowance you know all that kind of stuff you know is going to be Public public information yeah I I would think the contract there's not going to be a lot of redactions that that are going to be made that's not personal um okay so um what are we right here so uh next we'll move on to just kind of an overview of some of the different aspects of public records part of the law um the last point there I mentioned it earlier but you know just Bears repeating again foi request it's about providing information that we have kind of at our fingertips that's available
155to us we're not doing research we're not creating records that don't already exist um with research uh you know I like to say you have to search you don't have to do research what's the difference well research is really when somebody is asking you to kind of make evaluations about something you know if somebody sends you an foi request you know they could ask for you know copies of test scores they can't tell you you know can you tell me you know why the reading scores went up this year can you explain to me why you know this number went to this number can you tell me why you know you you you decided to change this in the budget you know you don't have to answer questions you're not required to do research it's
156really providing access to records it's not about making determinations it's not about answering questions it's not about making evaluations um you know you might have to search for records and determine you know what what is within the scope of a request that is not research you know somebody ask for emails for a particular date and you have to pull up the thing and search for the date you know that's a little bit different but um but you don't have to do research um how can somebody make an fi request there's no requirement that they use a specific form so if you have a preferred way to do it you can have a form or you could have a link on your website or an email um you know you ask people to send it to
157but really any written request uh for for records is an foi request um so that could be an email you know could be a letter it doesn't really matter how it comes in um just a little bit about fees for public records so if somebody wants to inspect public records They are allowed to make request to inspect public records so it means that they don't necessarily have to always request a copy they could ask to come you know to the to the district offices and ask to view a file um if they do that there's no charge um for electronic records there's there's generally not going to be charges for electronic records except in in in really kind of special circumstances um you know what the law allows is that if somebody requests an electronic
158copy of a record and you can reasonably make them that electronic copy and deliver to them electronically you're obligated to do that so if somebody is asking you to email them a report or something like that and you can email it to them there's not going to be a charge for that if somebody requests a lot of records and it's so large maybe you can't email it and you have to put it on a flash drive or a dis you could charge the cost of that flash drive or dis um you know the universal paper records is really shrinking but if you still have records that are on paper um you don't have to digitize them you can make photoc copies and then you could charge somebody uh 50 cents a page for for for
159photo copies um of those records um uh there is a provision in the law that allows people to use a handheld scanner to to scan their own copies of Records if they want to do that um then they have to pay $20 fee you see in there it says not cell phone and that's just because uh kind of a cork in the way the law is written uh is that it defines handheld scanner in such a way that it cannot include a cell phone um you could allow someone if they wanted to to use a cell phone to take pictures if you decided you thought that was appropriate you could allow them um sometimes they do that and then they ask the people to pay the $20 fee but you could also tell people if
160they take their phone out and start taking pictures you could say Hey you know we prefer that you don't take pictures if you want copies we'll charge you you know the 50 cents a page and we'll we'll make you the copies um so that's kind of an overview of just sort of different you know things there with the fees and and any of that have any questions on on anything there and again most of this is probably not you know things that you might be handling in your in your day-to-day one thing I will mention just you know you might want to know as board members there are a few instances where public agencies have to wave fees and one of them is if you are a board member so if you're requesting information as
161a board member that you need for the purposes of your service on the board um really for many you know it could also be from the city doesn't necessarily just mean the the the board of EDS so if you request information from the city uh they're supposed to provide it to you at no cost because you're a board member and you're using it for your your board work um okay how long do I have to fulfill an foi request this is probably the number one uh question that uh that I get from people and um you know the hard part is there's really not a specific time frame the standard is is promptness um and we'll talk about that there is one well I I should step back there's one specific time frame and that
162is you have to acknowledge a records request within four business days of receiving it so it's really important you know as board members you know it may be that there's other people who deal with foi and it may not be a responsibility of you but if you get an foi request if someone sends an fi request to you as a board member you want to make sure somebody responds to them within four business days you know you don't want to say well I'm a board member I'm not in charge of this I'm just going to let it sit in my mailbox um you know if somebody made a request to the chair of the board and the chair didn't respond or you nobody from the district responded within four business days that would be considered
163a denial of that person's request even if you didn't intend to deny it even if you said yeah we're going to get to it you know we're just really busy right now you never respond to the person they have no way of knowing that you know you're um you know that that that you're working on it they have no way of knowing that you've received it so they could file a complaint after those four days so first things if you get an fi request just make sure you get back requestor and you respond um and then after that you know how long until they get the information well as I said the standard is promptly and it's not defined in statute um so we had this advisory opinion that the commission uh came up with
164going on 40 plus years ago and we look at all those different factors that you see there in that last bullet point so we look at the size and scope of the request how many records have been requested the amount of personnel time necessary to comply with the request um recognizing larger and more complex requests you know you're going to be allowed more time to get them done we also look at you know uh really kind of information the requestor may or may not give you in the request do they say anything about the time frame by which they need the records or do they say you know how important it is to them to obtain the records um or the information contained within the records what that means is you know if if if
165you got two foi requests on the same day and you know somebody um you know had some sense of urgency or gave you a deadline or something it's just some it's a factor to consider and you might say well you know this person is uh you know um saying that you know they really need this information by the start of February I think you can get it done let's work on this let's get this done by the beginning of February maybe we've got another foi request we've been working on for a while it's a lot larger let's put that one to the side for a minute we're going to work on this other one so it's just something to consider um doesn't mean that if somebody asks you to do something by a certain deadline
166that you you know if you don't do it that you're going to be in violation it's still you know is meant to be this balance it's really a balance between the rights of the requester under foi and and and you know all the work that you guys have to do to make sure that that that things um are running smoothly in the school district um you know you see it up there the importance of the public of completing other agency business without losing Personnel time to complying with the request and also time constraints that you may be under to to complete other work um you know example that comes up a lot in school districts is you know if somebody were to make an foi request near the end of a school year that's a
167very busy time for the district you know they've got all these graduations they're doing all the year-end data you know there's all these things going on and it may mean that if somebody makes an foi request the last week of school it might take the district longer to get back to the person because they've got all this stuff they've got to get done you know we get to the end of June into July okay we're taking a breather now we've got more time to work on your request um it is meant to be you know this balance really as I said it's meant to be a reasonableness standard um you know my advice is that you know if if you're dealing with an foi request at all you're dealing with requesters I just think communication
168is really really important um I just think that you know sometimes I I think you know we're afraid to tell people bad news you know we're afraid to tell them hey you know this is going to take a while or you know hey there's 15 another foi requests that we got to get done before we can get to yours um you know my advice would be I think it's better if you're upfront and you're transparent and you just kind of explain you know what you're doing um and also if somebody checks in along the way and they're asking for updates you know you're not required to give them updates but I think if you can it never hurts um you know I I one of the things I do with the commission is I um
169I review the complaints that we get in and and help to assign the utsman uh to the complaints and you know the number one thing I see where somebody files a complaint after a record request is usually when they don't get any response they might get an initial acknowledgement you know but then months go by they're asking for follow-ups they just saying hey what's going on you know just checking in you know haven't heard from you um and they don't get any response for months and months and months and then eventually they get frustrated enough that they you know start looking around and they you know lined up with the commission they file a complaint so um I I think a dialogue with the requestor giving documents on a rolling basis I think that's something
170that sometimes gets gets overlooked is if somebody asks for you know a lot of information you years worth of financial information you know maybe you you you go through the reports month by month and you're giving them the information you know every week you're going to give them you know months of worth of reports that you've had a chance to review um you know rather than wait until the end when you've looked through everything and then give it to them all at once yes quick question we talk we talking about timeline extended delays and this and that um is there anything wrong with responding promptly to a recular request if you have it in your possession for instance if we have a document that was discussed at a board meeting that's in every single board
171member's possession that we used to make a decision and somebody asked for it and you got it easily available anything wrong with sending them no I mean I I would argue you know those types of cases I I think that would be something that hopefully you turn around and do it you know very quickly especially if it was something that was like in the packet or was discussed at the meeting um you know those sorts of things uh you know the the you know my my sort of general rule is you know look if it's an easy foi request if it's simple um I would say try to get those ones you know just try to get those off your plate if it's more complex and it requires more time I would let the requestor
172know hey you know this is going to involve furo we're going to need you I know it's about your son or daughter but we're going to need you to go through the process for furo or you know we've got to talk with our attorney about this because there's information in here we need to you know we need to redapt or or or um you know BL black out or just just to go a step further even if it's a draft document that's been discussed extensively by the board and isn't all the boards position possessions there's so um we you know we'll talk about draft drafts in a second um you know if if it's a I would argue you know I think generally if it's in the board's possession and they've been discussing it for
173a long time it may not be a draft under foi anymore I mean you you make consider it to be a draft but if if you've been publicly discussing something then then not an yeah if you're publicly discussing something then it kind of the draft thing kind of goes away you know the the way the commission looks at drafts is once it go once the decision makers are involved and they're starting to do what they do with it then it becomes you know something that would need to be disclosed now it might be a draft when the district is preparing it you know District staff might be coming up with recommendations to give to you guys and while it's kind of still at the district you haven't received it back yet then it would you
174know potentially be exempt but once it goes to you in your packet and you guys are starting to talk about it and make decisions based on it um I think at that point you know would have to be disclosed thank you uh okay so again that's promptness um exemptions and exceptions so there are exemptions and exceptions to the uh you know to the foi law um there are exemptions that are in our law in section 1210 there are exceptions that are in other um you know other state statutes um some of these we talked about furpa you know some of these other statutes we've discussed as well you know public school teacher evaluations um and just you know I gave a couple other examples there to site um so this is a uh not comprehensive
175list of some of the exemptions that are right in the FI law and um I'm gonna kind of go through these um a little bit of a of of a lightning round um but just touch on a few things I think are important for each of them and then if anyone has any questions on any of those um feel free and then there's just one other thing I want to just get to um before we wrap up so uh preliminary drafts and notes we kind of already touched on this one there is an exemption for that um you know preliminary draft again really means predecision it means the the records and things you know reports and and and things that you might ask for um that you know before they're given back to you to
176make a decision about them you know if you were asking the district to um you know give you you know enrollment numbers maybe there's a you know consideration of consolidating schools or something like that and they're pulling all the data together and maybe it's not all complete yet and they you know they need to wait until you know the last day that people can enroll because people might have moved here and they're waiting to get the counts and they're working on this and you know but maybe it was mentioned at the at a that this report was asked for and some reporter the next day says oh I want the report I want the report well if it still is with the people who aren't going to make the decision they're still developing it um
177you know it might be exempt as a as a draft document um with draft documents I will just say though that um there there needs to be a um a public interest in withholding the document that outweighs the public interest in disclosure so even if it's a draft there needs to kind of be a reason hey we're gonna it's a draft we can't give it out because of you know whatever the reason may be um and as long as it's a valid reason the commission is not going to you know second guess your judgment there but just keep that in mind if it's a draft you know there's got to be some kind of reason that we're withholding this as a draft you know we don't want to cause confusion we we we need to
178talk to other people before we can complete this report you know whatever the the issue might be do you have a question okay um all right so um Personnel or medical files that would be an invasion of privacy if disclosed so um you know this is again this is pertaining to Personnel files of employees um you know what I say when I do this for you know groups of public employees is you know I tell them well if you didn't know you know now most of the information in your personnel file is public really the things that are not going to be disclosed are are really kind of medical personal you know family related those kind of things things about your conduct as an employee you know good good good bad or indifferent you know
179are going to be public records uh obviously there's an exemption for evaluations of teachers um you know but but uh that doesn't pertain to disciplinary investigations that was a you know they they made that clear in that statute you know disciplinary investigations are still public um you know resumés when people apply for jobs you know that goes in a personnel file that's public uh you know letters that you get related to different things you know I got a letter because I they found out they were overpaying me and I had to pay back the state some money there's a letter about that in my personnel file you can Foy that if you want to um you know so there uh really Personnel files um you know there's a lot of accessibility in there um but
180there is a protection if it's a privacy issue and if there is a privacy concern the law does say kind of like the executive session you go to the employee you ask the employee and if the employee says you know I think this is a privacy issue then you don't release the record and then the person can go to the commission and ask the commission to look at the matter if they would like I I I got a question of clarification for employee discipline hearings um I think we've probably been doing this wrong for decades and I've seen somewhere where it says the evidentiary portion of the hearing should be in public but the discussion could be in ex um I think I know what you're I think I know what you're referring to and
181and I think it's something to do um again I think that's kind of in the education statutes issue thing because there's um but but what you're saying to me is is what I recall I don't remember the specifics of it but I I think there's yeah there's there's a requirement that part of it be done in public and part not I can look into that more to yeah you know send me an email or something and I can I can find it because I think it's something that's not in foi it's an education statute thing that you know there's part that's done publicly and part that's done privately and then you know also with disciplinary hearings too you know this kind of outside the scope of foi but sometimes you know collective bargaining agreement spells
182out you know how things how certain things are done and obviously you have to follow that you know as as as well so you have a question no I'll wait to find that out I think I don't think I agree with him but that's right yeah so I think I think there's something I I don't know which way it works but what you're saying brings a bell with me but it's just not something that comes up all that often but I I can look into it and and let you you know know because I I feel like I looked into this for somebody else so I can try to find that um yeah I don't I don't want to be definitive on that because I'm not sure okay so certain law enforcement records um you
183know there's there's a lot of exemptions for law enforcement uh you know things like witness statements you know identities of juveniles juvenile arrest records you know information about victims uh and so on records relating to um pending claims or litigation you know this is really about you know maybe there's a lawsuit and there's a proposed settlement agreement or something like that it's shared with the board uh for their consideration you know that would be exempt uh Trade Secrets this goes back to what we talked about earlier you know where um you know I think you you had said you know a company telling you you know hey you can't disclose this information um well you know if it's a trade secret you wouldn't have to disclose it you know but I don't believe that would
184be the cost of the textbooks you know to the district it doesn't seem like you know that would that would arise to a trade secret but maybe you know specific information about the content of the textbooks depending you know I I I don't know what you know what they consider to be proprietary um you know the idea is that um you know you're not required to disclose things that would put that business at a competitive disadvantage you know so um if you know something about their product because you guys you know are in a contractual relationship with them you know it might they're competitor can't necessarily come in and ask for the information that you know they will be disclosing to you because you're a you know you're buying textbooks from them or sometimes it's
185that you're a you know that you're serving in some kind a regulatory role or something like that um so test questions scoring keys and other examination material this is um not about you know the math test but it's about employment um you know applications uh so you know you you can't foi the interview questions you know for an interview or something like that you know and also if um you know comes up in police departments and fire departments a lot you know that there's a there's a you know lieutenants exam and there's a way that it gets scored and there's a key and they this gets weighted this way and this gets weighted this way you know those records are not um you don't have to be disclosed you know to protect the Integrity of
186the hiring process um real estate appraisals while an acquisition of property pending that's pretty straightforward records Reed to related to collective bargaining strategy and negotiation you know similarly we talked about how you can do that in executive session also this is you know would cover the records so if there were you know emails or other you know draft of a of a you know proposed you know wage agreement or something like that you know if it's strategy if it's negotiations back and forth um you know that could be something that wouldn't have to be disclosed attorney client privilege um you know really the key thing there is you know it's it's communication with the attorney you know for the purposes of legal advice it could be that the attorney's giving you legal advice it could
187be that you're giving information to the attorney to to to provide legal advice you know it doesn't matter which way it's going you know that would be um something that would be protected by attorney client privilege um you know the next two don't really come up all that often you know information obtained by use of illegal means whistleblower complaints ad adoption records um you know there's some availability to people who you know maybe are involved with the adoption depending on the situation but you know those are not generally available uh plans and records that pose a sa a security risk it's just important with this one to know that there's a process where um you know if an agency wants to claim this exemption they have to go seek a security determination so for cities
188and towns um what you would do is you know you would probably run it up your internal system to your superintendent or security person to try to help make this this determination if and if they think a valid security issue essentially if you think disclosing the records you know would put somebody In Harm's Way or you know reveal you know sensitive security information about you know building or facility um you go to the State Police the state police would review the situation they have attorneys there who do this and um you know they would make a determination and say yes you know you guys don't have to disclose that record it would be a security issue the reason you consult with somebody else one it's required by Statute but two um if there's an foi
189hearing then those security people would come to the FI hearing so it would not just be bridgport Board of Education it would be bridgport Board of Education and the state police testifying about why there's a security issue here um and the commission is going to give a lot of weight you know to the testimony of those Security Experts because they're really the experts to to make those types of judgments um and then last but not least um there's an exemption in the law it's a little bit of a newer one you know not not new new but it you know maybe within the last you know 10 or 15 years um dealing with responses to uh bids or RFP and what does is it allows for the records to remain confidential until the contract is
190awarded and because of that it means that as a board you guys can go into executive session to review responses to an RFP or to review bid documents that you've received um so you could you could have an executive session to review them you could invite the biders in to meet with them in the executive session once you award the contract everything becomes public so once we pick somebody you know to to to put the new roof on the school then all the bids you know including the people who lost all that information becomes public or if we decide that we don't like any of the proposals and we go out to bid a second time then once we are done with that round we're ending negotiations then the records of those um those bids
191would need to be disclosed so it's it's a limited exemption only for that period of time it's a little bit unique in in how that works um but again it allows you to have an executive session if you wanted to to review bids for something before you award a contract um so again those are you know it's not every exemption in the F law there's about 26 or 27 um you know another one pertinent to school districts just to to to mention is that um you know names and addresses of students enrolled in public schools there's an exemption for that so you know somebody's not allowed to ask for the roster of you know students at a particular school um you know the big one though is not an fi and that's fura you know
192which you might be familiar with um you know obviously you can't disclose you know identifying information about the individual students parents want information there's a process through F how they can get that information um um does anyone have any questions about any of these exemptions or any other records that you're kind of wondering if they're if they're exempt or not um records related this has come up in the past few board meetings as far as um board packets being posted online posted for public availability before the meeting and said that we're the only District in Fairfield County that doesn't post our board materials for public viewing before the meeting so um there is not a there's no requirement under foi to post the the materials um ahead of the meeting there was during covid a
193period of time where there was an executive order where it was required because the meetings were remote so the idea was well people can't go to to you know the Board of Education Office to get the information you know or everyone's working for home from home so put it all on the website um so you do not have to post your meeting materials ahead ahead of the meetings on the website um I think if you can you know I I I would say what's the harm right you know if you prepare a board packet and you have it available you know and you can put it on the website you know I would say why not just do it so somebody if they're following along from home or whatever they can you know look at
194the agenda they can look at the items as as people are going through it um but it is not required by uh you know by the FI law um I don't think it pertains to board packets and this is something that is is separate from our laws I I know there are some education statutes I think it's about contracts I don't know if anyone if this is ring a bell with anyone no um so there is a I think there's a and I can look into this more there was something that was done recently not in foi but it was done in the education statutes requiring Board of Education to post certain materials to their website and I believe it was like the contracts for I think just like a teachers contract and superintendent's contract
195or something like that I don't think it was the the meeting materials um so sometimes there are requirements about what needs to go on your website not in foi but for our for meeting materials you don't have to do that um you know again if you can I don't think it's a bad idea um but you know if if you're running off the packets you know an hour before the meeting then you might not have time to you know post them uh you know on the website sometimes not everything is ready for the you know you get you might walk in here and that's you know that's when you you get part of the agenda or something I don't know but um it's not the part thank you um any other questions anyone have about
196any of these exemptions okay um and then last but not least um you know we already talked about these and probably went through all those details I'm just going to end on this uh slide um because people sometimes ask about this um you know what do we do if we have somebody who you know we we think has gone too far they're making too many fi requests you know they're starting to become really really maybe vexatious um so what I'll say a couple things about this is that um the term vexatious is not defined in the statute um the way it works is kind of like with promptness we've got these different factors that we consider so we look at the number of requests that have been filed how big those requests are the the
197nature content language of the requests or any other Communications to the agency and really what we're looking for is a pattern of conduct that amounts to excuse me an abuse of Rights uh granted under the foi so what can happen is if this if there's somebody who meets this standard uh the district would file a petition with with us and say look we've got somebody who we believe is a vexatious requestor um and we would look at the petition and if we think there's enough there uh to move forward we would hold the hearing we would bring you we would bring in person they would have an opportunity to defend them M themselves you have an opportunity to tell us you know why they're being such a jerk um and what we could do is
198the commission could say that you guys need to no longer entertain any foi request from that person for a one-year period um we do take this really seriously you know we are the foi commission we don't want to you know restrict people's rights to request information but um you know when it when it goes too far when it becomes you know about abuse about harassment when it becomes intimidation of public employees threatening language you know when it gets to the level of where it is not somebody asking for information any longer it's really somebody trying to interfere with the agency operations uh you know those those sorts of things um then that would be when I would say that you know this might this might be applicable but but people are allowed to make a
199lot of foi requests there's no limit on how many foi requests somebody can make they can make large foi requests so I think this is really you know it's it's a it's the volume but it's also the condom um you know it's one of those things where you know again I I I kind of think of it as the break blast in case of emergency of foi right you know this is really kind of a last resort option I think um you know commendably I think most districts and and cities and towns you know work with the difficult people pretty pretty good because we don't get a lot of these I think people try to work with people if they're looking for information they're trying to figure out what happened but you know if you've
200got somebody who you know you're trying to work with them you you've tried it's not going well you know you're running out of options then this is you know a tool that that is available um that you could potentially pursue um anyway me question so just going to go all the way back to the beginning um for anyone who didn't get it before to my uh email and phone number um you know please please don't hesitate to reach out you know if you've got any issues in the future um you know uh sometimes you know a two-minute call to foi could save you a huge headache um you know and uh I do try to be accessible um you know I understand sometimes you're having to make these decisions you know and there's time element
201to it so um you know when people email me and call me I really try to get back to them and you know as quick as I can um you know I'm out a lot doing a lot of trainings so you know I sometimes tell people if you call me and I don't get back send an email um because sometimes I'm checking that a little bit more frequently but um you know we've covered a lot and as I said at the beginning I know there were some issues here and some complaints and that sort of thing but you know I hope now everyone you know has gotten an understanding of what the requirements are and you know I just can't emphasize enough that you know with Fi because it's the law we want to do
202it right if you're not sure it's it's really okay to ask questions whether that's to us whether that's to you know your attorneys or you know even if you have people in the district that have been around a long time that have done it for a long time um you know the law has changed in some ways but a lot of this has been the same for a long time so um I would just say lean on the resources that you have because you know you guys are all um you know volunteer board members you all bring different expertise to the board you know chances are you're probably not an expert in F and that's okay we want people who have different expertise and different knowledge and and bring different things to a Board of
203Education you can always you know I was at another meeting and I was telling people you know look you can always learn foi I can always teach you how to do foi I can't teach you to be a good business person I can't teach you to have been a teacher for 20 years whatever background whatever expertise you bring to the board um is is really important you know and and we can always be here to help with foi so um I really appreciate all the uh good questions and the invitation and um you know if if you need me uh for anything else you know you know want to reach me and also if you wear another hat you know you and you think hey this training was great you know I'd like to see
204it done at whatever you know you work at City Hall in Stratford and you want me to come there um you know just reach out and I'm always happy to come so I really appreciate uh you know the invitation and all the questions thank you all right good night thank you we are gonna move on we have one more item on the agenda which is public comment and one speaker um Joseph be time thank you madam chair my name is Joseph s the 334 brunford Avenue I'm speaking now as a member of the public I think it would be appro to sit to sit on the to sit as a board member to speak about this ex call for appoint information on I didn't say he just continue um yeah I this this evening came
205about because of the foer complaints this settles the last two foyer complaints I filed against against the Board of Education and for and the former chair I felt to move on as a board in a New Direction that this board will no longer be running a file of the Freedom of Information Act and we moving for we will be moving forward in a transparent man I'd like to thank presenter very very good very very informative and I'm glad we got this settled and I hope to move forward as a board in a more transparent Mar than we have in the past the next item on the agenda is um moov by Mr benan second by Mr Duna all in favor I oppos time is 88:18 have a great night1 no