CorpusRecord 27052

Regular Meeting of the Bridgeport Board of Education Monday, January 13

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bridgeport Public Schools
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Greater Bridgeport Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,436 words · about 153 min
Collected
2026-06-04

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening this is a call to order for the regular board meeting the brid Board of Education um today is Monday January 13th and the time is 6:37 we're going to start with the pledge so can everybody please rise I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all and roll call even everyone Dr ban Christine Baptist Paris present Casmir here Mr Willie Medina president M Jennifer Paris here Mr Joseph s president Mr Robert travor Mr Andrew Woodson all right we have Quorum um the first um item on the agenda is going to be student um representative reports so I know we have a few students here can't hear me can you hear me okay

002student represented reports I'll speak louder so I know we have um someone from Central Christian beika you could come right up to this podium I don't think and you're going to press the button with the speaker I can be heard yes okay thank you buddy good evening um superintendent Roy esteemed members of the Board of Education and everyone here I am Christian beika and I am an 11th grader at Central magnet and I'm here to report about the entirety of central successes so far now in October NHS National Honor Society we held a blood drive and we plan to hold one another one in February and we also participated in the strides walk for breast cancer awareness and we collected $2,000 for breast cancer research and had over 50 students participate in the 5K walk

003also then in November Central High School we held a literacy night campaign in November and we will also be holding one in the spring we Le to do it and families they enjoy pizzas sodas and other food also with free clothing and such by the community closet of richport and we have also planned to have a stem night in March to generate interest in scientific education and we are also working with the student the school governance Council which I'm a part of to facilitate the planning of this project and November HOSA which is for the Health Association health associ ation of America for health careers they also generated $520 in their turkey team turkey drive for Thanksgiving and they donated that money for the rescue mission and time for families to receive the turkey for

004Thanksgiving and now in December for sports the CHS cross country sports team they had some students qualify for the state's championship and two students also made it to the Nationals CHS we also held a multiculture night event on December 12th and it's a yearly event that brought the students faculty everyone and families to celebrate the cultures of our students and it was an exciting time and I can personally attested that that it was very wonderful and that a lot of people came and there was a lot of activity generated and revenue as well and December's host officers they were also given a challenge with packaging over a 100 personal care packages with shampoo body lotion Combs ChapStick and many other care items which we wanted they wanted to deliver to the Siri Refugee Center on

005Clinton Avenue and HOSA and Ina Club they also held a toy drive that began at Thanksgiving and they deliver toys to the Toys for TOS drop off on December 18 and over 120 toys were dropped off and Interac and HOSA they're currently collecting new and gently used coats gloves hats and scarves for the Siri Refugee Center on Clinton Avenue again throughout the month of January and our first delivery of coach was made on January 10th and we will be delivering what we collect each Friday of the day for the month of January to them and interact students are also in the middle of promoting a peace campaign throughout the school where they plan to make peace bracelets and hold bake sales to generate more revenue for the school and also promote a general message of

006peace for the for the world and in our school in several languages and there will be a ceremony that there will be a peace wall signed and we also are inviting the Bridgeport Board of Education on the cere when the ceremony date and event is set and the rotary club they're also supporting our efforts with a grant to subsidize the purchase of the peach of the peace poll which you'll be putting up in the school now CHS interact and HOSA they are yet again collecting monetary donations and personal care items as they plan to continue putting together the personal care package for the Siri Refugee Center on Clinton Avenue and in December C HOSA yet again they hold they held their state conference in the small Auditorium where they had a digital platform that gave

007information on any scholarship available for host of students and information about the much larger spring conference and competitions and internships and information that will help them connect with the International Leadership Conference which I found well and in January close here we held our science fair and we had many participate from grades 9 to 12 so several classes participated and they displ their project at the fair as part of their vision of The Graduate Mastery requirement which is sort of the Capstone for our school to graduate and Outdoors Club they also went on their ski trip on January 6th it was a great it was a great success with over 15 students participating and HOSA they had again had guest speakers from SW aack and they came to speak to students about careers in public health

008and they are also returning to work on a project for Valentine's Day for senior citizens and people in St Vincent hospital and throughout their branches and they will also be working with HOSA and the teachers in our health classes at Central to put together a health fair for CHS students students will be running health tables and professionals from our community will also participate in the event and the school counselors which are very well regarded at our school they also held a Fafa workshop for families about financial aid for upper education in college and currently we are focusing on attendance for semester 2 with with the principles and such and for upcoming things the male nursing students from Sacred Heart we know that they'll be there as CHS HOSA to present more information about nursing careers

009academic requirements and the life of a Nursing degree student which will be in February they're still setting the date and in February 25 Yale New Haven Health they'll also be bringing professionals to an open forum for CHS hostal students learn about more information on Medical Careers and college requirements for them it will be open to all students of Central High School as well if they have an interest in the topic and for Black History Month which begins in February the student leadership committee they're in the planning process to bring information and a lot of different diverse activities to the students of Central and we plan to see it all out when the events come and the student governance Council which I'm a part of will set it and that's all for the status of centr

010now thank you thank you few more presenters who's next I come up yeah hello board my name is Eko Atkins I'm a junior at Fairchild wheeler Aerospace thank you for the opportunity to present on behalf of my school uh last time I was here I shared to you about our steam night Expo that would just happened this past Thursday I'm happy to report that the evening was a resounding success for a and the entire campus the students worked in for D the hard work and diligent preparation for the evening by staff and students certainly paid off the dynamic evening involves seniors presenting and completing their Capstone projects uh people did science fairs artwork and even clubs were there to present with the eighth grade students looking to join the school thank you to our Capstone

011teachers Mr kek and Mrs Berto for helping prepare our students thank you to to the staff and student volunteers for supporting the event helping recruit students and showcasing student work and projects best of luck to all of those who will be moving on to the science fair we will be wrapping up our first semester next Friday after our final exams the exams exam schedule was shared by principal Henry and we will have one exam each day next week best of luck to uh my fellow classmates for finals week today Mr Henry learned that Skyler Robinson AOS senior was awarded a $28,000 presidential scholarship this merit-based scholarship from the University of New Haven was awarded to Skyler based on his impressive credentials so great job to him thank you again for the opportunity to present behalf

012of my school thank you come on up good evening members of the board and audience my name is Daniela Gomez and I am a junior from Fairchild wheeler biotechnology this past week has been a very exciting week for Fairchild wheeler due to the fact that on Thursday we had our very own steam Expo night which included an open house for our parents our very own science fair and our senior capsu night at this stem EXO night we also had a stand for our recently purchased anatomage table it was an opportunity for students and parents to be introduced to this wonderful tool that will be used to teach all sorts of subjects from physiology to chemistry some things to look forward to our soccer tournament that will be held tomorrow after school and our finals week

013that will be taking place next week and that's all for biot technology thank you have a good night thank you evening members of the board I'm Jord mole Junior representative for for it at Fair child wheeler on January 9th we simultaneously held our first open house of the year and our students first open first science fair in caps projects parents of interested children visit and explore the IT classes and dynamic many of our presented projects were powered by the it by the It theme with some including difference in rendering softwares virtual reality powered by AI to practice multiple languages and AI composing humanlike lyrics while working along these projects students were also preparing for their final exams and projects for the week of the 20th and begin the new semester on January 27th the anatomist

014table has been recently been implemented into the biotech school all campus will have the opportunity to explore the anatomist table all campus wide thank you thank you any other student reps okay thank you all for coming out to share with us what's happening in your schools um we look forward to hearing more from you the year um next on the do you want to say something thank you madam shair uh just before we can we give big hand to all the student take the time to come here I appreciate it thank you um next we have public comment we have two um folks signed up for public comment we have Jennifer Russell good evening you have uh two minutes um and once you once you say your name the time will start okay my name

015is Jennifer Russell I uh live in Bridgeport work in Bridgeport love this city and I love my students and I love all of our students and I just wanted to make a comment about when we make these Cuts we're making cuts that we think are at the top of the scale or it has no impact on our students St but from the time those students get out of the car to the time at the end of the day everybody in that building and even the ones who aren't in that building are responsible for that child you have administrators who greet their students every day at the door and if they see that there's an issue they immediately take those students and get them the help that they need well we're going to cut some of

016these positions and that means some someone's got to do the work that's still going to be there when all is said and done we're going to have to pick up that extra work but in picking up that extra work we are actually hurting our students by not providing them with the time that's needed because we don't have the staff so I just want us to think that from the person who works Network to the person who answers the phone to the person who is a social worker who sees that child every day from the person who rides the bus to the every single person whether they fix the door is vital for those children success and in this 21st century we need to prepare our kids and by taking things away and not giving them

017the things that they need by making it harder by making things take longer to get we are just setting ourselves up and our students for failure and I know we need to come up with the money and as a citizen I wish we could but we got to figure this out so think about the cuts please thank you the next the next um person is Faith Sweeny uh good evening board my name is Faith Sweeney 184 Huntington Turnpike I have two topics I want to talk about tonight the first one is a question um when w is the superintendent search taking place and how will you inform and include the community in that process process um I didn't mean to sound like I know you're right here but um we I would like to know

018and I'm sure others would too the second one is um I've been asking about board information packets connected to the um agenda items on the board website labeled past agenda and minutes it list agenda minutes from 2011 to 2023 it looks impressive however when you click on links from to November 2017 none of those links work so why are the links up why are why is it up there and then from starting uh December 19th 2017 there is is a link with minutes 2018 to TW uh 19 there the minutes included board votes so we're getting more information or the community is um 2019 20 and 20120 these minutes actually included how members voted they and they had a board packet packets with PowerPoints of budgets graphs charts and related documents for the public to

019view ahead of the meeting to be held 2020 to 21 you there was also public uh packets for the public um and nothing beyond that so please I want to be an informed citizen I want to be able to know what's happening when you guys are having your meetings and it's always given after the fact or not at all please provide minutes thank you thank you information all right thank you to the speakers who came up today um the next item on the agenda we have approval of meeting minutes from um the regular board meeting on December 9th 2024 is there a motion was moved by Mr benan any seconds second seconded by Mr cvic is there any discussion on the board or the meeting minutes all right we'll take a vote all in favor

020of approving the meeting minutes from December 9th 2024 say I I any opposed any abstentions I abstain thank you the next item on the agenda is um the special meeting minutes from December 11 2024 um is there a motion moved by Mr benan seconded by Mr Medina any discussion on this we'll take a vote all in favor approving the M minutes from December 11th say I I any opposed any exensions I abstain thank you and the last approval minutes is from special meeting December 16 2024 moved by Mr benan second by Mr Medina any discussion all in favor say I I any opposed any abstentions I abstain thank you all right so those uh all three were approved um the next item on the agenda is the chairperson's report um I'll start by saying can't

021see what I wrote uh we have uh new committee assignments um that I believe have been posted to the website and if they have not um we'll have that up ASAP um it is up okay um so I'll announce them finance committee um is going to be chaired by Joseph cvic with Willie Medina tahiba Bane as committee members uh facilities committee will be chaired by myself um with Andre Woodson benan personnel and policy will be chaired by Mr Medina with myself and Joseph kic on it and instruction Support Services committee will be chaired by Mr trabber with um Mr Woodson and Mr benan on it um when we uh go through committee reports they'll State the dates that those committees will be held um and times and then there was also um other assignments um

022including Charter School representatives and and K representatives and those will be posted online um also um Dr Avery and I um spoke before the State Board of Education accountability and support subcommittee last Thursday um where we shared our plans for addressing the budget deficit and our plans to um support special education in this upcoming year and as well as um trainings that the board has gone through and will be going through um the state subcommittee has referred us to the state board so we will be meeting um going over um a similar presentation with the state board at a time to be determined and that will be um shared with the board members um when when we find out the date also um I met with uh cab this morning um with uh Nick kusu

023who's worked with us in the past and uh we discussed um kind of had a conversation about um how how Cape can help support the board in in creating different goals and also um just improving um some of our relations and so we actually will have a retreat with cab um they are going to come down on a Saturday February 1st um and we'll have a Saturday morning Retreat um it'll be uh from about 9 to 12 and um Mr kuso as long as another cave member will come down um and have a retreat with us to uh focus on improving our relations as a board and hopefully to um work on goal setting that will be noticed to the public and um that notice will go out this week um that is it for

024my chairperson report any questions for me Mrs bat forz I have a question uh in preparation for meeting with the state did you contact cap to go over the complete list of trainings and conferences that the board attended we we have that um available online so we were uh it was given to us from C yes okay well I asked this question because during the meeting with the state you have held all the conferences that we attended as a board as well as individual training that we've had through cape and so my question for you is why was that information withheld if youd have reached out to cap to get it it wasn't withheld actually gave them a copy of the all the trainings that we attended and conventions with the names of each board

025member who attended each uh convention and uh training so that's what uh the papers I gave the state that's what they received okay so why didn't you announce it during the public meeting I I did I said we attended um various conferences and board trainings individually that meeting is posted online I don't believe that's actually stated but if you did share anything with the state I request and I'm making this publicly that you share it with the full board so that way I could be aware of what you actually shared with the state thank you Daniel can you email that to the board tonight thank you any other questions all right we're going to move on to committee reports and SL referrals so we're going to start with finance committee thank you madam chair the

026finance committee met on January 2nd 2025 and and in addition to the items that are appearing on the agenda by UNAM vote tonight the following occurred and a a consensus was reached on goals and objectives of the committee which are as follows I'll read it into the record finance committee goals and objectives the goals and objectives for the 2025 finance committee are as follows the finance committee will endeavor to continue with the adjustments being made to the 2425 budget to reduce the overspending by the prior Administration in order to be on a more solid footing as we as we simultaneously prepare for the fiscal year 2526 while the work of dealing with two fiscal years would normally take 18 months the committee will seek to accomplish this task in less than seven months which will

027include tens of million dollars in potential cuts and advocacy for more funding the committee shall be mindful of our fiduciary duty to properly vet the budget and amend any proposals and ensure that the taxpayer dollars are used to carry out the educational mandates of the state the committee shall look at the budget in a holistic manner with an eye towards equity and not just see the people in front of us who Advocate but we will consider those who are not privileged enough to be able to use their use their voice the committee shall understand that this is a board of education and every cut hurts children and shall Endeavor to limit the hurt as much as possible the committee should be mindful that every job is important and there are people behind these positions that

028their work is useful even though the jobs may have to be cut the committee should be prepared for some hard work and incredible responsibility and realize that while we work hand inhand with the superintendent in Partnership and creating the budget that the ultimate responsibility and decision is in our hands and we also will um Endeavor to create a strong advocacy plan in order to avoid as many of Cuts coming as possible now to continue on with the report um as Finance shair I would like to say we do have our work cut cut out for us in correcting much of the misinformation being disseminated in the community including from some of our elected officials I won't go too deep into it here but we'll address it further at the committee level but for the record

029there is not $40 million missing from our budget lastly I would like to address the recent narrative that the board is not moving fast enough to approve the superintendent and cfo's recommendation they have both had this information far longer than the board and had time to duly consider it we have had only one finance committee meeting before tonight and are on tracked to about $10.5 million in unaffordable sending spending by prior administration of which both our CFO and the superintendent were part of I'd also like to State for the record that approving any item via rubber stamp without discussion in the name of letting the superintendent do his or her job is how we got into this mess in the first place so long as I chair the finance committee we will continue continue to

030consider consider the superintendent and cfo's recommendations modify add to subtract from any recommendation with the understanding that it is the Board of Education that is ultimately responsible for the final product under the state statute and is liable for any overspending of funds okay now both before I accept referrals be Please be aware that the committee will be meeting as much as necessary and the following is already going to be considered fairly quicker quickly the 5-year Capital plan the 2526 operating budget additional cuts to the central office after perusal of all the executive staff contracts which we haven't seen to date thank you uh the next meeting will be Thursday January 26 2025 45 Lion Terrace room 305 at 5:30 and I've got another one stively scheduled for January 28th 45 Lion terrrace room 305 530

031thank you any referrals any referrals to the finance committee oh Mr tror go ahead yeah I don't I'm sorry I don't have a referral I just was distracted about those dates could you give those dates again about next meetings th Thursday the six 16th and Thursday this Thursday correct and um at what time what time 5:30 and in where 45 Lion terrce 305 correct and then Tuesday January 28th tentatively want to get one more meeting in Tuesday when January 28th 28 same place same time same please thank you all right um instruction Support Services committee good even thank you madam chair um I have nothing to report other than we have set the fourth Wednesday of each month at 5:30 in room 305 to be our regular scheduled meeting time um and so that means

032our first meeting will be on January 22nd um in room 305 at 5 30 any referrals to the instruction Support Services committee Mr benan yeah thank you Madame chair I would like to get a report a a full report of Nutrition Center when I say full report is about AC what is come in what's come out it's a lot of things that we there going on in to send them sorry and I would like to get a report from them also I would like to get get a report for special education because I heard that a kids that the special education are getting suspended with so many days that I believe they breaking the law so I would like to get report what's going on and why they um suspended a special education student with

033so many days so that I like I have to get to this two report please all right the nutrition center will go through facilities committee um and then other item Mr TR you have that I do have that okay thank you so you're gonna I'll take you'll take the uh Nutrition Center and we'll do deal with the sped suspensions at uh um instruction and student services thank you any further questions referrals all righty the next uh committee is policy and Personnel Mr Medina thank you madam chair um you want to than thank Joe and Jen for being part of this committee have Ste in their nominations into it um we have not met uh this month we're planning I'm planning to do a special meeting but our meetings are going to be the second Wednesday

034of every month once again the second Wednesday of every month at 5:30 uh location to be determined most likely is going to be 3:05 uh so the next one the the first official one outside of the special one that I call will be February 12th um and a little outline of things that we're going to be looking at policies uh we're going to be reviewing every existing policy that we have uh for potential updates and clarification uh we're going to be discussing and implementing um new policies possibly and based on our needs are current needs because these policies a lot of them uh need to be reviewed we're going to be also addressing um any policies any inconsistencies or gaps I know in while my first year in the board there was things that were

035of contradicting each other and we want to address that I want to address that definitely on the board um I've spoken with the superintendent and I've asked for specific uh policies that we might be able to look at that will be directly affected our work that we have to do right now so that way to put some priority under that but uh all policies are going to be reviewed during my tenur as uh chair of this committee we're also going to have discussion on potential areas that we can actually improve uh whether it's our training or or even our compliance requirements um we also want to develop I would like to develop to make sure that there is a clear uh communication with these plans and the new ones that policies and the updates of

036the policies that way across the board across the district everybody knows about the policies there's not going to be any confusions or anything like that uh also I'm looking forward for the community and staff members feedback uh to get together uh uh regarding all these policies and these changes uh and that's just the beginning so I just wanted to add that specifically today thank you very much and I'll take any referrals mral yes M Mr Min I've already informally sent this to you as a Committee Member um we like to look at the hiring policies as you know um we need some some more checks and balances in our hiring and our contra conts for personnel uh we need to look at all the hiring policies as in a holistic manner as far as the

037new suggested policy that I sent off uh we need to look at the certified hiring policy as well just to see if there's any impediments to moving forward like building principles and teachers that are getting in the way to help staff do a little make it a little easier to thank you thank you anyone else all right Mr TR yes I would refer the matters that were raised by the speaker uh Miss uh Sweeney raised the question of what we're posting online for the public it's become up numerous times and um thank you thank you sir anybody else all right thank you madam chair moving on we have um the uh facilities committee um this committee has not met this month yet um I spoke to Mr Garcia on some items that he would like

038to um present uh monthly and and quarterly at the meetings um that first meeting will be February uh 5th the first Wednesday each month um uh most likely those meetings will be held at room 305 at City Hall um at 5:00 p.m as far as um oh I need referrals I'll take referrals yep all right um oh Mr svic yeah if you can I know we're waiting on the master facilities plan but if you can could we possibly review the fiveyear Capital plan on your committee if you could get to it before I do we'll do thank you all right um the next item is the C report um do you have anything there's a legislative breakfast for C if board members you want to sign up for that um that's going to be uh

039January 28th at 8: am at Staples High School um any other Mr SC go ahead yeah I'll add that I did reach out to our entire State delegation to ask for their attendance because it's been very sparsely attended in the past by our delegation and Bridge Bo need to show up and it will be on my birthday and I will be there so nobody else has any excuse all right um all right moving on um we're gonna have Dr Avery's um a report good evening everyone I have a couple uh different items I'm GNA kind of go through how about down test testing one two three uh Commander lip and your student will you guys come to the podium please it it gives me great pleasure to um introduce you this evening to master chief

040petty officer Jak Lake uh he's a student at bridport military academy he has made history in bridport public schools to become has becoming the first Cadet uh from the academy to be nominated for all four US service acms uh uh Mr lake has received nominations from West Point the Air Force Academy The Merchant Marine Academy the US Naval Academy which are are among the most selective institutions in the country and Commander lip if you want to say a few words we love you love for you to do that uh and we do have a certificate that I would like to present as well fantastic no um chief peny officer lake has just been remarkable in his leadership uh ability and what he's done with the school his Drive determination his sustained Superior performance has made

041him an exceptional candidate and I am not surprised um that he was nominated for all four Service acmy uh he makes us all very proud um just a quick plug on before if if you may want to say something but on Thursday we're going to I send an invite invites to the board uh to come to see our uh inspection and pass and review as some Pomp and circumstan and chief P officer Lake will be one of the uh key players in that event cette Lake you want to say anything he's uh he's just an incredible person I'm so glad he's able to be recognized and do our school proud thank you very much Bor for letting him come here and and uh be acknowledged by all thank you board members that are present could

042we step down and have a certificate to present and take a pH Tim for e just want to acknowledge Miss cmir has joined the meeting in person go ahead Miss to continue to continue uh we had we had a productive meeting with the Connecticut Board of Education accountability and support committee I'm very optimistic that we were able to efficiently provide understanding of our school district it's problems and a show to show a plan that we are confident that we will help steer The District in the right direction we will continue working with stakeholders to address the budget deficit and provide our students with the resources they need to succeed collectively as a team board and superintendent we are willing to fight a little harder to make sure that the students of Bridgewood Public Schools get

043what they deserve in addition to that uh this week we uh well actually last week uh we created a special education task force uh and the goal of the task force is to really assess our current practices in in the area of special education look at and for the to identify ways that we can improve Special Education Service across the district uh and also looking at implementing new innovative solutions to address the needs of our children across the board uh we are currently looking for uh you know 50% of the task force members need to be parents so parents if you're out there please reach out to my office we would love to get you uh uh to have a voice and to be part of this new special education task force uh we had

044our first meeting last week and I didn't have a lot of parents there so I'm soliciting uh you know we've already put out notices to all campus principles uh to solicit to parents that they're that they can recommend to be part of this task force again there is a lot of work around special education and ac across the state of Connecticut and I think we're we could set the groundwork for Innovative practices in in in the area of special education but I think we need to get some voice we need to get community Department par ships in order to strengthen uh what we do and how we do um you know special special education services in our district in addition to that uh there has been a lot of pro uh promotion about attendance task

045force as well uh really focusing on making sure kids are coming to school uh this task force you know is really trying to prevent and to come up with a root cause for chronic absenteeism you know getting parent parents voice trying to figure out exactly how and what and why kids aren't coming to school and why they're coming to school and kind of enhance that a little bit uh really trying to kind of look at the data from the day-to-day aspects of of of schools across the district and looking at some of the some of the ways that some campuses are promoting know good attendance for kids uh and then looking at some of the ways that campuses are also addressing uh this the slight decline in attendance uh in our buildings as well so

046we're looking for we have a a big initiative in the month of January trying to make sure that we can tap into uh what we're doing very well and what we what do we need to do to improve uh attendance across our district uh in addition to that I also had an information session with the city council uh it was invited to come and speak with the city council about uh just really just to answer questions about BRB public schools and the plan in the status of our school district uh you know really trying to make sure that we could connect uh with um what is needed between the city and the school district to to move forward and keep things moving forward I had several board members to uh uh assist me in um

047in that meeting it was again I thought it was a very productive meeting in addition to that there was three different you know public forums that I was part of over the last you know um you know about last four weeks I'm say saying the first first one was uh a a public forum about uh immigrations and making sure that we can ensure our parents of students you know uh you know from other countries that we are very connected with making sure that your children are safe in our school district uh looking at ways that we can enhance uh notifications if if if any attempts are are made within our school buildings to be able to uh you know hinder people just walking in and asking for uh you know certain types of data or

048information about children uh in our district so again there's going to be some additional items added to our website uh for information an informational section of uh the district so parents could reach out to our district uh if there's additional information needed uh we have Community Partners that are willing and ready and able to support families uh so we able to kind of direct those um opportunities for U uh public engagement for other community members and Partnerships as well to make sure their qu their questions are answered uh in addition to that we had a budget Forum um and uh that budget Forum was really giving parents an opportunity or Community an opportunity to understand how we develop budgets across the district and what we need to do that really kind of understands the nuances

049of how a multi-million dollar budget is developed veloped uh and how it's maintained throughout the years uh again it was more it was we did a lot of Q&A questions for parents about uh their questions that they had surrounding budgets uh again I think it was very productive our CFO Mr Nester was able to kind of break down uh the current budget status and being able to give uh more fluid information about how that's working and what we're going to be doing over the next couple of months to uh first of all adopt next year's budget uh as we work with uh the development of that category making sure that we can get towards a a move closer towards a balance balance budget uh just an additional item we have a couple of additional forums

050that will be presented in the next couple of weeks uh the first one is January 16th and that form is going to be is going to talk a little bit more about school safety in our school district uh we have a couple of different keynote speakers uh that will will be assisting me uh on January 6th at 6 p.m. at the Central High School uh to talk a little bit about safety protocols and things that we're doing uh and some of the new things that we're looking at uh moving forward in the future uh for school safety uh in addition to that uh we have a a general um public for January 22nd uh at 6m at the Black Rock library and this is going to be open to any types of questions that parents

051and communities may have and uh again I think one of the biggest things for me is to get out there and engage the community uh and making sure that we have full transparency in what we're doing and why we're doing it uh and we have a long hard road ahead of us and I think it's important that we join forces together uh to be able to kind of be again as transparent as we possibly can as we move this District forward again so uh that's the end of my superintendent report and I'll take any questions any questions for the superintendent Miss bis Perez um yes I have a few questions uh regarding uh the presentation to the state and the community forums about you know the layoffs and the budget uh how many employees have

052we laid off to date uh is where is just a second I have uh Mr Caso coming up to the mic uh two date we've had conversations with 26 of the initial individuals the date we've used for these layoffs is going to be January 31st uh thank you um I have another question uh is the district still participating in a districtwide hiring freeze pursuant to the letter that was sent out on November 8th 2024 yeah yes um except for um special ed and and science teachers I'm sorry that wasn't what was listed in the correspondence from November 8th 2024 that it was going to include that so could you just uh when I was board chair I sat down with Dr Avery and Nest uh Mr unquote sorry Nester for using your first name um

053and so uh that was not included nor was it identified to include that group so can you clarify or do we have a districtwide hir uh hiring freeze uh through Madame chair yes there is a district wise hiring free with the exception of special a students uh special a teachers science teachers and long-term substitute teachers who are going to be helping the children in the class so the interest of the children is what is utmost important to us we cannot jeopardize the the aid or the Assistance or the help that the students need in class so those three categories or those three areas exempt from the hearing phrase okay thank you uh I have a followup question to that why is multilingual services not in included in the hiring phras given that we are not

054in compliance oh true Madam chair keep my mind the ESL is also exempt okay yeah ESL is also exempt yes he specified it on my email when I sent it out but it's skipped my mind yeah we cannot we have to H we have to provide services to multi language students Mr batis Peres I may I clarify as well uh we also talked about the different shortage areas um positions so there may be a few that may be anomalies that positions like you know maybe chemistry or physics or some of the other uh High kns positions that we shortage areas that we needed to address so that could be included as well so the the short answer is the memo is still in effect and it's in in full okay well I I asked that

055because I've been following on Red Rover we have 130 job positions from January 2nd to date we've listed numerous roles that don't fulfill the requirements for seal or special education uh and also I've noticed on Red Rover that we're posting jobs after claiming there's a hiring freeze and our student to teacher ratio districtwide we have approximately 1,400 teachers to our 19,000 students so my my question is why if we're in a budget deficit why are we continuing to post roles like financial management Specialists and that role was originally an internal role but it's been switched to external also in addition in the same like we've posted a role for assistant superintendent of curriculum and instruction and during our last special meeting it was stated that that was going to be an internal transfer but now

056that's a role that's being considered externally so I I'm trying to understand how all these positions are being posted that are not special education that's not multilingual that would be considered a cost savings if we did not F why are they being posted now and why are there 130 job openings if they're not fulfilling what we're calling those High need areas well if I may we're we're posting for the jobs because we want to get quality applicants and so when the hiring frees may be lifted we'll be able to pull from that pool to shut down the job postings and to restart would add to the time that it would take to get the quality applicants just because posting for them doesn't mean that we're we're currently hiring for that position but if Mr niquo

057all of a sudden says that we can hire a uh PE teacher then at least we have applicants that we can pull from so we don't have to start from Ground Zero again so we'll have applicants waiting in the pool for several months for an indefinite period of time hoping that they're going to eventually come to Bridgeport Public Schools when we're not ready to hire them in a deficit it's it's their choice to to apply for the job there's no guarantee when you apply for any job that you're going to get hired so everybody kind of takes that that chance when they when they make an application online why are we posting it if we're not hiring I thought I kind of doesn't make sense in our deficit that we're posting positions post it when

058we're ready I'm I'm gonna move on to another question I have today uh we received a letter with a district uh new hires as well as transfers and resignations um there's one individual in the transfer area that position was posted on Red Rover on January 2nd 2025 it's no longer online did we hire that POS that person for that new position because then that also doesn't seem to fit the uh we're in a deficit and we're not hiring new individuals is that the accountant position yes okay um that was cleared from Finance I'll let Mr Nal address that through Madame chair the finance the accountant accountant position is I hate to really put it this way in the school district you only have Chief Financial Officer and assistant uh assistant Financial Manager running the whole

059District finances with no secretary please there's only so many so much numbers two people can crunch I can only spend so many hours on weekends here we need an accountant to put to bring in cost control measures and monitor things and find out where the loopholes are in the financial system somebody has to be dedicated to do some research and do some analysis I hate to put it the district is losing money because no checks and balances I'm sorry thank you Mr un but I mean when Marlene seagull was our CFO she was able to get it done and I I have an old copy of the org chart and she had Miss St Louis as her deputy there was a financial management uh supervisor an accounting assistant financial management specialist accountant specialist accountant specialist

060and Grant support partner so again it uh are those roles no longer here and then why is that not also being counted towards the the cost savings and again this comes and that role comes after the fact that I asked if we're still in the hiring freeze and for what positions so now this is something defin Madam chair the accountant position was well advertised way long ago the interview was conducted and we were just going through selection process was well advertised long time ago before I even came to the city on this District side it was allocated appr so okay but then I just have a followup question I'm not sure if this is for Mr Castillo but the posting for a financial management specialist is still online and that's a different role from the

061role we're talking about that role was posted early this year um like I said it was for internal applicants only and now it's external that doesn't meet the requirements of the hiring frees in the high need categories have to look at I'm not familiar with the exact posting that you're that you're speaking of I can do some research on that and though it's on Red Rover right now right but I don't have Red Rover job description or job postings memorized so I'd have to look at it and see and I can get you back that that information what information are you getting back it's almost disingenuous to advertise positions that we have no intention for hiring immediately so I'm asking what was the high need we said we're on a hiring freeze and yet I

062see us hiring multiple people and other roles after the board had voted to lay off individuals and so I I am looking for for clarification onto that and so what information are you going to give me like why is it posted well first of all even what the job is I don't know it off the top of my head which what you're asking well how can something get posted if you're not performing oversight of it like who's posting these positions we have a process okay for it to get posted online we have a process where somebody requests a position to be posted that they fill out a form it goes to HR we send it to finance Finance says it's okay there's funds to fund this position you can go ahead and post it that's

063our process so when it comes back from finance that we can post this that's when we post it they look for the funds they say the funds are available this is an allocated position go ahead and post this even in a hiring freeze I it appears so okay I just think that reflects poorly on the district as an employer people will just eventually stop applying if they never hear anything back I mean job boards like inde or glass door but I'm just I'm on the topic report yeah no that's regarding the superintendent report he spoke about what he presented to the state a massive part of that presentation to the state dealt with the layoffs and the budget Gap as well as the community forums discussing the budget Gap and so my questions are really

064delegated towards the budget Gap as well as the notice that he gave the state that we're in a hiring freeze and that we're claiming we're in a hiring freeze but even if I acted like a lay person it going on the website it's completely opposite of a hiring freeze and I think that's disingenuous and I think that's something as a board if we're saying we're in a hiring freeze and there's a gap and there's positions being posted that's that's not okay so I'm glad I was able to to clarify they rep posted but not they're not hiring those positions that was clarified yeah it and and like I said it reflects poorly on a district as an employer to do something like that and so that's what a clarification I was looking for and also

065it's not part of the high needs area um are usually posted for months at a time though that's correct if not like don't you hold it for like a year not necessarily a year but they are posted for quite a while yeah yeah but these are new down these are new postings after the November 8th letter and these are new postings in opposite of the November 8th letter and furthermore when we had Mrs seagull as the CFO those were roles that were where people resigned or left the district those were cost savings and those are not being reported to the board and that's why I requested this information today for board meetings because we haven't seen the movement so now we will have these um every every board meeting will have a movement um we

066have a point of information from Mr Traer goe the November 8th letter was not did not establish our policy so we're you're saying that we're free to continue to hire in a budget deficit no I'm just not sure exactly what the date was for the policy you're referencing November 8 and November 8th was when I believe that you had a meeting with Mr noo and there was a finance committee meeting following that and then later that day um Mr noo sent out a memo to all administrators um that almost went to all employees and that did not establish a board policy because the board had not acted on that policy and I don't recall excuse me Mr TR but I more questions elated towards the super Mr trabber has the floor for a point of

067information make your point Mr tror so that so we're referencing November 8th as if that's the sacred date and that's a date in which a a certain number of things happened that is that resulted in a in a memo going out from Mr noo that did not establish board policy so I'm not quite sure when the board policy was finally established but it was not November 8th okay uh I'm going to move on because I've set that point um it's still going back to the budget deficit um have we looked into employees bumping rights and as well as the city Charter and the state statute for it I'm hearing alleged rumors that there are employees that have been years in the district and they're being laid off for employees that were just hired and so

068I would love some clarification on that sure I'd be happy to give that to you so that's absolutely incorrect um there are people the way our Charter works it's based on classification so if somebody worked in the district for say 30 years and then they change classifications to a different classification only been in that classification for six or seven months their time of hire is from that six or seven months position so to give you an example you have an Affiliated individual who worked in the district for 25 years they take a position that's unaffiliated outside of a union six months ago we have layoffs now they might have 20 six plus years in the district but only six months in their current classification they don't get 26 years of seniority they get their six

069months so yes somebody could be an employee of bridport public schools for longer but it goes by the classification and that's how the charter is read and that's how we just had a conversation with the city attorneys on this exact issue and that's how the charter operates maybe you could share with the full board a memo regarding the conversation with the city attorney so that way as a board we know that we're not creating liability exposure or potential suits against us from employees that may or may not have rights with regards to bumping in notice um now I I have another followup question regarding um regarding uh individuals and new roles are we hiring new ex ex cutive directors no so I I because of confidentiality there's individuals that this board had voted to lay

070off and yet we have not been provided with the individuals that have been laid off like let's just say hypothetically we're going to lay off for I'm going to make up a roll tile installers but there's five or six of them we don't know which one of the four tile installers we're going to lay off but it just so happened that if you look on your emails as a board member and you look at their job descriptions now individuals are executive uh Administrative Assistant to I believe the the chief of special education and so I don't think we've created that role have we no and what what a person puts on their email sign off letter head email sign off it's it's inconsequential what munus has is what we go by so if somebody is

071classified as an Executive Administrative Assistant in munus that's what their job title is you call yourself president of the United States it really doesn't matter in the eyes of Bridgeport Public Schools you are an Executive Administrative Assistant so in the eyes of Bridgeport Public Schools it's okay for low-level admins to post the incorrect job postings while making official Communications for the district that's okay I don't think they're doing job postings oh or are sending out correspondences at the end of the day what you're saying to me is that it's okay for individuals to lie about their role in The District we have a point of order Miss Batista we have a point of order for Mrs cic mam chair this is starting a border on badgering our employee um Mr Mr Costello asks on behalf

072of this superintendent so she seems to have some problem with job performance is not the proper venue for attacking our employes who are under the direction of superintendent internal superintendent Dr Avery so if you have any issues with the employee and the jobless things this employee is making please address them with Dr Avery and give him the right to go into executive session if you wish to critique his performance this this is fundamental to the votes that we and this is I'm going to say we as a board because the full board took a vote and whether the majority voted to eliminate those positions um that's the will of the majority of the board but when we're being deceived and individuals are being moved where are our cost savings and that's the real question for

073Dr Avery where are our cost savings because every member that every individual that was part of Dr lovey David and all of us as a board received the or chart of her cabinet had contracts so I want to know where's the cost savings if there's a buyout provision or if we have to pay someone three to six months where are the cost savings with that and also again there's individuals if you go on the orc chart that we received and the organ organizational chart now individuals have been promoted and again I'm just trying to understand the there but there's no funds but we're elevating we're transferring people into different roles we're we're acting we're posting roles that's beyond the letter that was sent out districtwide I'm trying to understand this budget Gap Dr Avery and

074so could you help me out in my presentation that I presented to the board you know back in I think the last presentation that I made I I I presented a list of uh positions that were to be you know considered for for uh elimination I put the cost measure out to the side of it the amount of the individuals that we were going to be able to look at their benefits in their salaries for that cost savings there's been a lot of you know movement in that in that FAL analysis of that uh we are going to be bringing to uh the finance committee meeting on Thursday uh a detailed uh perspective of the the amount of money that we are going to be saving uh with with those with that first round of

075cuts uh so a little bit more detail will will be provided to the board uh that will be uh also presented to the full board uh uh in addition to that so uh I don't have those individuals because there there was a lot of moving Parts because some of the contracts that were provided you know by the previous superintendent uh and and endorsed by the personnel and contract committee uh had some Provisions in them that allow some additional time uh if there was a layoff uh that I don't think a was very clear as to uh what that time frame was and how much cost was was added to the position if it was eliminated so once these position were eliminated or considered for elimination then we went through the bumping right exercise that caused

076some additional you know shift in things that we had to do before we could do the layoff so again a lot of moving Parts over the last two or three weeks to kind of finalize where we are uh um Miss Newquay was is also going to be uh we're working through some of those right now currently as we speak uh and uh I I would be providing the board on Thursday a little better detailed of those savings uh and remember we did uh we pushed out some of those savings until uh June 30th on the assistant principles uh which was a good chunk of the savings that I first recommended uh and so again there's been again a lot of moving Parts uh a lot of things that we didn't foresee uh that we had

077to go back in and re-evaluate the dollars and the cost uh every member you know uh that's going to be potentially laid off uh they have a PO of having um uh not working with comp but what you got unemployment unemployment unemployment calculations had to also be calculated in that so there's been there's been a lot of those anomalies that had to come together in order for us to uh finalize a initial uh you know cost savings and uh I know uh Mr uh Nu and and myself even late this afternoon was looking at that then trying to figure out and he still had a few more that he had to analyze to uh pinpoint that so again I'm sorry for the the long you know you know explanation but I think it's been uh

078you know you know every day there's been a new Nuance that had to be uh fulfilled in order to look at the final uh analysis on that and you know that thank you Dr Avery because that was actually brought up um in detail with meeting with the state about the assistant principles and I think it should be I I just want to make sure I understand because I I have some of the prior or charts as the former board chair and it's my understanding that you before we had a chief academic officer you oversaw academics and so I see you over the Executive Director of school leadership is that correct you were over overseeing academics before we had a CAO at one point point of my tenure yes early part of the my tenure yes

079okay and so because it's my understanding that you were heavily involved in the the hiring of those roles and I when I when we were up at the state I didn't notice you take any accountability for what necessitated those roles uh when you recommended them as overseeing academics as the deputy superintendent in addition to that I think you as a board chair also had the responsibility to this is not for back and forth I'm just at you were in charge of academics and while I was board chair you referred 18 assistant principles over but during that meeting it would just behoove me as to why a role roles that were recommended by you including roles that are coming up tonight like the executive director of school turnaround are are now being eliminated when those are

080roles created by you can you just clarify that for me in the full board were created by the superintendent as well and there's a point of information on Mr K go ahead hold on M thank you point of information um we can't rewrite history here these positions were tempted to be challenging challenged the board chair silenced the board if we had these conversations before we could have perhaps frame Dr Avery's thinking along the lines we're thinking now I'm glad to see you become a fiscal con conservative now that you're not chair anymore but we Tred to stop everything you have been doing for the past not Madam sh this is not for him to go about mrsic has the floor so you're gonna allow him to make false claims and allegations that's smoke those false

081claims continue now we've attempted to have discussions about the budget my one finance committee was much longer than the total debate on the budget the total positions I called for a special meeting to prevent some of these positions to be placed on here now had that special meeting occurred and we've been able to discuss it Dr Avery's thought process might be different even maybe Dr the former superintendent might be different so for you to come here and attack Dr Avery for decisions that were made when he was in superintendent decisions that you did not even allow to be discussed by the general public is disgusting thank you we're gonna move on so wait no I'm not done and I still have uh questions I I I do want to thank Mr cific for that clarification

082is that it's okay to Badger and harass a superintendent when it's a female Hispanic female but not to do it when it's a black man that was overseeing those actual hires I I appreciate apprciate the misogyny Mr Dr Levy David no I haven't brought super ay respons in charge of administrative hires if she was given recommendations from her staff that's one thing but she was ultimately in charge of administrative hires personnel and policy comme is in charge of personnel policy and contracts committee was in charge of overseeing any hires in executive level or um principles and above and I think believe assistant principles so those came before the Personnel policy and contracts committee went into executive session and did not go before the full board which is not in our policy to do so but

083they went to exective session that's the facts okay was not aware was not aware of all those hires and that's the clarification do you have more questions yes and and and thank you for clarifying that we follow the policy and that it's up to the board member to follow the committee to be a and the contracts were not shown before the for the for the board we have another point of information hold on we did not follow the policy she did not clarify that you followed the policy you did not follow the policy these were not positions approved by the board contracts were not approved by the the board okay um I'm going to move on from that topic I just have another question for Dr Avery do we have any notices of appeals from

084individuals from the city from the 26 that we've given the layoff notice of we have three appeals I'm sorry uh this is Dom Castello we have three Appeals that went to the Civil Service Commission um they are currently working with the city attorneys to determine uh the appropriate actions to take um so that's with the Personnel director of the city and the city attorneys right now but there were three appeals filed with the Civil Service Commission and and just a simple followup if those appeals are successful we won't recognize the cost Savings in those areas correct they would have to they would have to present a case which would that that is correct um but they would have to present a case that would make their terminations uh illegitimate illegal or unethical okay I wait

085board members can we limit side conversations goad Miss B for us um I I just want to say employment contracts are not to be approved uh I I do have a followup though uh regarding um the promotion of Union to non-union and then laying them off uh don't they may they revert back to the union if they're laid off um like do they still get their bumping rights I think there's a lot of Rights for employees that have not been presented to the full board uh before we took these types of actions and the last thing I would want to do is create more exposure and liability for us we have another por of order why are we engaging in this level of minutia these are matters that are being handled by the appropriate departments

086within the board and this is not for the board to litigate um determine or otherwise process we have voted to eliminate certain positions we are entrusting the superintendent and the appropriate Department ments to deal with how to process them we are not here to litigate or determine if they're handling them properly so I don't know why we're engaging in this level of discussion with Miss batist Perez um I do enjoy the fact that we're hearing and learning about contracts that were negotiated without the board's knowledge um and organizational charts that we were never provided but I don't know why we're engaging in these discussions tonight we voted to eliminate positions they made the decisions on the basis of that vote if they did it improperly that person will grieve or otherwise in indulge or use

087their rights under the Civil Service rules of the City of Bridgeport um and that process will go forward why do we need to have a lengthy disc discussion tonight about that process thank you for your point of order comments okay my have questions if the Bo's gonna be ultra crepidarian and lie about what they're doing then just Mr Woodson has the floor open yourself up to liability Mr Woodson has the floor Mr B forz um my question is for Dr Avery what new innovative ways are we looking to improve and change how bridgeboard operates hold on folks Mr can you speak up thank you Dr Avery what new innovative ways are we looking to improve and change how bridgeboard operates a sped program I think for you know for special education service is to kind

088of be re robust and you know um pretty much widespread around how families engage in the special education side of the house I think one of the things is getting the voice from parents uh I think I think we kind of miss that sometimes you know we feel that we can provide services and services and services but we're not really getting the input from families to be able to do things uh there there are there are a lot of different types of special ed services that we may not necessarily be offering kids or we may offer it at a at a certain level than others so really looking at um you know what's the best practices out there and this is what the task force is going to be able to do for us is

089to really kind of get out there and take families and take community members to different communities that are really doing it really well uh and bringing some of those back uh those ideas and uh options back to District to kind of see if we could fulfill that within our system as well uh again I think the other part of that is looking at the types of spaces that we have we have a we have a lot of current uh special education programs that's been in the district this and we've been doing it the same way for a couple years now uh but I think there's other ways to be able to enhance what kids are getting and the training that our teachers are also getting to provide those you know the academic mix opportunities for

090kids so there's a there's a a wide variety of different things that we're going to be able to do and I don't want to just try to dictate which ones are going to happen but being able to get groups of of our community to be able to go out and look at it for themselves and talk to other parents that are actually experiencing some of those those programs and bring those back so again it's just it's a building process uh and if we can see some of the things that are happening just you know real close to around us and in in other districts small districts large districts and mediumsized districts I think we can tap into some of those options that I think will be very beneficial to our kids and our families Madam

091chair I have a point of order what's your point of order uh I just wanted to state that we're engaging in this level of minutia as one board member stated because we're laying people off and this board is acting as highlevel staff and now to turn the Blind Eye to who was responsible Dr Avery was responsible for balancing classrooms in May and yet that was a task that was never done that could have saved the district millions of dollars and now we're here making devastating cuts and we have several roles that's on the agenda tonight that's devastating to the students directly for their opportunities and outcomes in this District what's your point I wanted to clarify that that's my point that's the reason why we're engaging in this because we're required by Statute to be

092responsible for the budget and because we're participating in these layoffs that level of minutia is necessary thank you thank you um yeah go ahead you're off hold on for a point of clarity you know as as the deputy superintendent in my previous position uh along with HR with along with my office along with the superintendent's office our job is to be especially when you when we interview we all are part of those recommendations uh and so as part of the job that we do every day uh no one person is responsible other than the superintendent we work for the superintendent and we provide recommendations to the superintendent and so when those positions came we made recommendations to the superintendent and to the to the to the committee regarding qualified applic that's my job uh and

093and I can tell you the 18 assistant principles that we hired are very very good administrators uh and I wouldn't take that back from anything because they're doing the job that they're that they were designed to do and we're paid to do uh and I'm and I and I take confident confidence in that uh and so doing my job yeah I can do my job and I do my job very well and selecting and making recommendations that was part of my job uh and that's what I did and so having 100% you know responsibility for that you know I can't take 100% responsibility for a good majority of that responsibility yes my responsibility was to provide to sit in interviews and we did a whole lot of them uh and we made recommendations so I

094just want to make sure I'm clear with that that I wasn't the ultimate decision maker for that uh and and yes I take I take responsibility for that for for hiring good people uh and also when you talk take about responsibility you know budgetarily you know that wasn't my total position either but as as a dep I had some things to do with that too so full responsibility and understanding what my job responsibilities are and as a deputy second in charge yes I had some responsibilities with a lot of different things across this District uh and But ultimately sitting in this seat the interim seat that I'm sitting in I am responsibil responsible for making decisions and making recommendations to this board uh and uh and now that I'm sitting in this seat I can

095make better recommendations to the board sitting in this seat Mr Woodson can you continue um I know the cost of special education uh Transportation was a big part of the budget is are we doing anything to address that that is a a big portion of that special education but budget is the transportation piece uh and uh again we have we have children in out of District placements there that I think we have a uh one or two in New York New Jersey uh we we're taking kids I mean we have about 350 plus kids that are are are we have to transport out of outside of the district so when you talk about those opportunities and and uh the TR back and forth every single day or the housing of those kids in a residential

096facility uh and and the escalating cost of those and that's one of the things that we will be fighting for uh as we present uh you know in Hartford regarding uh the excess cost of special education and transportation is a big chunk of that I think we're spending almost 115 million doll just on special ed alone uh out of that so out of that 304 million that that the board adopted $15 million of that a third of that goes to servicing those kiddos that's not even including my bilingual bilingual children or any other even our regular red students so again it's it's a lot thank you Mr Woodson um Miss cmir oh go ahead um the only question that I have Dr Avery is um can we get an update of what you have so

097far for the 40 some odd positions I believe it was that you recommended I would like to know um if there were new positions created for some of those people that were on the chopping block for L lack of a better term to to being laid off um were there new positions created and then then moved into those positions and what's the difference in the salary um or and uh were any of them moved into a position that was already open that they were qualified for so I'd like to know that I'd like to know if there were new positions um added and and this is up to you I mean up to you and your you know your your team as to what's best but I really would love to know um if there

098were people who were scheduled to be laid off but then a new position was created for them and they were moved into to that position or if they were moved into another position in the district that needed to be filled so could we get an update on that I mean at the next meeting or whenever you have time maam sorry yes ma'am we can provide you that but there was no additional positions hired are new positions created to move people into uh but I can provide you a list of the those individuals positions and all that kind of good stuff so if there's any specific Clarity that you want if you know of something you know let me know and I'll can kind of check that out for you as well okay yes ma'am loveing

099that yes ma'am I can do that for you madam chair I just would like to piggy back on Mrs casimir's request um M uh Mr tror is next and then I can call on you okay I uh I just wanted to in response to the question from Mr Woodson you may have seen today Mr Woodson there was a press conference in Hartford with five of the mayors that the superintend five superintendents and five Mayors from uh five cities in the state pushing the state for uh uh uh taking down the the uh barriers that are blocking the use of the State Surplus we're having a meeting tomorrow night at who satanic about it for anyone that's interested from 6 to 8 at H satanic Community College but tonight yes this morning there was a press

100conference that M Dr Avery attended uh along with Mar ganam uh and raising this question I believe Stamford Waterbury New Haven and Hartford were also present um raising this question of releasing money from the state um it is a Hot Topic in Hartford to raise to release more money for sped and the earlier mentioned uh somebody somebody mentioned earlier excuse me uh that there is a legislative cave breakfast uh at the end of the month I think the 28th uh in I forget which Staples High School Staples high school thank January 28th a just for anybody in the audience who wants to attend we want to be uh pushing this issue again um all of the communities Urban and Suburban are feeling the the expense of special ed uh but we obviously want to raise

101the cost to the urban communities especially because of the issues that we we're aware of and concerned about Miss batis Perez uh yes I just wanted to add to miss is casimir's uh request I would like to include the name of the employee uh their starting salary their current salary and their official position I take issue with the fact that uh an employee could put in their signature block a title that they do not have in the district to misrepresent to parents community members State members uh what their role is and so I would like that clarification as to all the individ idual to which this board voted to um lay off those four this five that 18 that the names of those individuals and those information uh as well as whether they've been transferred

102or assigned to a different role and I think it's critical that we do have a deadline for this so I would like it before the end of this month thank you Mr Woodson oh Mr Nell Mr Nell and then Mr Woodson right through Madame chair through Madame chair please please the last thing this board will want to do is to get into individual names very deadly very very deadly say spending more 30 almost longterm on the city Side never get into individual name employee names is a no no with all due respect to the board can we have positions that were you could have the position number you could have the positions that's been eliminated but not an employee name it turns out to be very very ugly thank you Mr Woodson put your mic

103back on oh you're off okay we're going to move on to um new business the first item on the agenda for new business is discussion and possible approval to eliminate the position of its District infrastructure operations manager as part of the tier one approval um Dr a are you speaking on that or Mr svic would like to speak I apologize um yeah before we get started I would like to make a motion to keep questions to one at a time let each board member ask a question before the next board member asks because some people we're all sitting here we all have to drive home so everybody should have a chance to ask a question before somebody gets chance to ask 20 that's been moved by Mr cvic seconded by Mr trayor any discussion on

104that I I have discussion on that that's a a vote to restrict speech and to restrict speech of board members that's going to require a super majority vote point of information we're not restricting any speech there's no limit to the amount of questions anybody could ask we're just changing the format of the questions and answers so that's that's if if there's a motion to restrict speech I will frame it as possible I believe enough questions have been asked to make a decision on this issue so I seek a two-thirds vote to end debate and then discussion okay so this is not going to Li limit not going to limit speech we're just going to give one person um everybody will ask one question we'll do a that and then once everybody asked their question then

105you can ask your additional questions point of clarification is that during debate or during discussion Mr sovic during debate or discussion well I've dur during discussion I've always been of the mind that people should ask their questions first before debating so they have all the information available to them but this is something new for so we're going to discover during during discussion okay um we'll take a vote roll call okay Mr benan is a roll call to say your um motion again Mrs SCC motion to limit to one question a piece before asking a second question I thought it it was during discussion just just add that to just withraw it and then just state that the new your new motion just withdraw it and then that way you can clarify with discussion that's during

106the discuss period the same thing that's the same thing it's been prop second I think we could vote on it as is your motion doesn't include and it doesn't State we've already got rules suround debate I'm not limiting debate I am talking about framing the discussion which has already been adequately so Mr benan that Bing she's not here no Christine Baptist Paris no cheir M Jennifer Paris yes Mr Jo Jose kasak yes Mr Robert tror yes Mr Woodson Mr benan yes okay to one that passes six to one we mrina did Mr Medina want to vote sorry my apolog Mr Medina yes all right passes 701 um so go ahead Dr Avery hold on let me get your mic on um one more minute hold on there we go I have uh our director of

107Technology here uh and if there's any questions about this position he will be able to uh clarify for you this position was was orig originated in the the first tier of of cuts that we had it was pulled off uh for further discussion at um uh at the at the committee level uh had a had the detailed uh perspective uh from Jeff and his staff uh at the finance committee on the second uh and it was also at that point referred to the full board for tonight do you have any questions I did I hear one or no okay so I have I do have a question um uh so I know the IT department has um a smaller staff than desired for a district R size um and I know there's a lot of

108um talks of bringing these uh positions back to preco levels but I do also understand that preco we had um well can you clarify how many computers were in a classroom pre-co on on an average you're not on there you go hold on sorry sorry B um you have to bear with me man have like a cold um so uh we have roughly 33,000 mend points right now um we had about 7,000 at the time uh that Co hit that were in production in other words there's like maybe two or three in each each classroom and then we had like older Chromebook carts okay so um so that yeah that I know you guys do way more than just computers so that that's just one area I'm thinking of um pre-co there was a a

109lot less basically you have like was that uh four times the amount now you said 33 roughly yeah so over that um who oh you want oh sorry my is shot right now um so you know I'm concerned because I I do know that the IT department there I I think one of our public speakers made a mention you know even cutting one of those Services could be detrimental to um the district so I'm I'm I'm just concerned about this particular position because of I I know from the past that the department has had um is shorter staff than than Des D um um I I would say that uh the best way for uh me to answer that question is is I think that um you know yes we've grown substantially uh and uh

110when that position was created it was created because at the time we did not have an assistant director we had um the at the last time we had layoffs um I had lost my assistant director position and so what we did was is we had created that position excuse me um to to kind of uh provide a median for uh uh helping me to manage the infrastructure because we have the largest infrastructure in Connecticut um for public school districts and um essentially we now have an assistant director again um that position was restored and uh you know I I would say that in terms of St staing you know we can always use more staff I would never turn that down but I also understand the plate that the district is in and I um

111you know I look at it from the perspective of that uh I'm happy that we have you know as many staff as we have and and I I look at the the larger picture of all the different you know cuts that the district has to make and I'm very mindful of that because I know the effect it's going to have to the kids um and so my my thought on this is is that I don't want to cut any positions I don't think anybody here does because it's one of the reasons that we're having such trouble right now but I also don't think we have a choice given um where we are and you know this is the time to to you know unfortunately roll up our sleeves and and make those tough choices and

112um I would say from a perspective of its um you know in the future if if the district ever found its way to where we could have something like that again I would be greatly appreciative but I think you know I don't I don't want to say that I you know that we don't need to position because we do but it's a scenario where we have an assistant director again um and so hopefully between myself and the ad we can keep that going and so I would say it's the best way for me to answer that I hope that helps to respond thank you Mr trabber take it back okay Mrs cic yeah just real real quick quick excuse me real quick question when was this job created uh like late 2019 is I think

113maybe like uh I say like October I think oh thank you 19 any other questions are there current openings in your department are there any current job openings no uh the the uh we have on the dock at other uh layoffs as well um there are no openings in its um the superintendent um and uh you know the leadership provided us you know to get us to a point where we were much better staff than we were in the past which I'm you know very grateful for uh you know through the collaboration with the unions and stuff like that so um we do not have any open jobs right now thank you any further questions from board members Mr talovic yes um motion to eliminate the its District infrastructure operation manager it's been moved by

114Mrs cvic um seconded by Mr Medina um any debate okay um there's no debate um we'll take a vote roll Call's gon be a roll call vote sorry Mr benam go ahead Christine Baptist Paris pass Check Yes is Jennifer peris no Mr Joseph s yes Mr Robert tror Mr Woodson Mr will Medina yes Mr benan yes Christine Baptist Paris Iain six we have six yes one no one extension thank you next item is a discussion and possible approval of the proposed tier 2 Staffing reductions as presented on the January 2nd uh finance committee um Dr ay did give us um some updates today so you have that in front of you um Miss B I believe was added to the portal right before the meeting um what was added to the portal right before the

115meeting just updates on the um the finance Department the summary of um The Gap closing measures so where we are currently with um what the board has approved up to date and um you know the the amount that we could save with those um those that have passed already no okay so I guess I believe just added to the portal right before the meeting that's I guess that's fine as your chair things can be posted last minute so members don't thank you there is a point information Shor there is no change to the tier 2 staff reductions okay any um Dr Avery go ahead no there was no changes to what was recommended to move from the finance committee to the full board do we have any questions regarding go ahead um Miss btis Perez

116is the proposed tier two Staffing reductions the same that were proposed on December in December during the meeting can you just list out the roles that way yes um it's in the new document that's why I'm asking um they are the same so Dr a you can answer that they are the same positions uh as presented December 16 okay so that's the electrician painter ID its help desk its logic specialist in the maintenance grade one yes ma'am any questions okay um Mr talovic motion to eliminate the proposed tier two staff reductions as presented by Dr Avery was moved by Mrs cvic is there a second second by Miss Medina miss btis you have a question your hand still up we're in debate uh I had a question regarding in discussion I don't I'm not ready

117to use my time for debate the the motion's been made already in seconded so it is debate would you like okay yeah and so have we had preliminary discussions with the individuals in these roles so that would be 18 maintenance workers um that would be the two it it Logistics specialist it help desk assistance one the one painter why oh we're looking to cut three electricians make sure that's correct um that that's the head that's the head count so re I'm sorry what I'll let U Mr Costello answer that thank you well the 10 maintainers the board agreed to uh let those go by attrition so we're not actually cutting those 10 maintainer positions they're not going to be laid off they're just not going to be filled when they when they retire resign whatever

118the case may be uh we haven't had conversations with the others as we were waiting for full board approval before we we discussed these layoffs with these people so see but maintenance grade one is that different from a custodian it is there's two different uh two different bargaining units maintainer one grade one are from asme 1522 and custodians are uh nage typically maintainers are assigned more to the Boe side and custodians are assigned more to uh City side there are custodians in in Boe but it just breaks up a little bit more unevenly with maintainers in Boe and custodians in Cityside and so when we just got notice of a of a res ation that would be applicable to the cost savings for now uh true Madame chair that's the only way to save money

119relative to the maintainers if somebody quits or resigns we are not going to refill it um the danger with deferring all these um Gap closing measures to be very honest with you it could take 4 years of before you really weed out the 10 maintainers so I mean it's symbolic that it's part of Gap Gap closing measures but it really has no might not even have any Financial impact in this current year oh thank you Miss unquote I guess I I agree with that is that we're not laying off and is that applicable to all of these positions in tier 2 is that we're not laying off we're just not going to rehire if they resign um through Madam chair no it's only applicable to the maintainers uh the other next place is applicable is

120relative to the assistant principles which is being deferred till June 30th again whatever dollar value you see as savings Gap closing measures does not exist this current year year so what you're going to be seeing is an inflated inflated number that's really not attainable which is somewhat deceptive or misleading not deceptive misleading to be very honest with everyone so if you look at the summary if the board approves everything that's on this uh charts here first phase tier one tier two tier three plus the other additions they're going to approved the total annual salary is $10.4 million annually however with the deferrals that you're having or the board is approving so let's say 10 million dollar for annual savings we're almost six months or seven months into the year so you've already lost close to

121$6 million if you want to look at it that way then these the remaining five months is being deferred for the remaining five months at the end of the day this $10 million you see here is only worth $2.2 Million by the end of this fiscal year so basically what I'm saying is the gap the deficit has not moved Mr Garcia good evening everyone just want a little clarity uh in terms of the maintainers and through attrition currently our roster has 147 staff of the 160 budgeted the 160 the 160 budgeted takes into account the 10 additional maintainers that were hired during Esser so we can do the math tomorrow to figure out exactly how many maintainer positions are already gone but the attrition has started we haven't hired there has been the freeze so

122so you are starting to see the the the um the actual layoffs happen through attrition um but we can get that number tomorrow I work with Nester so you guys have exactly how many maintainers have already been gone that are not on the roster currently okay is it still your time yeah okay so I guess my follow-up question is are there 10 maintainers in mind for this or is it any 10 that may resign or leave for whatever reason we're not going to rehire him it's not specifically the ones that were hired during or with Esser funds yeah Mr no it's um um as folks leave because we do have a a good amount of turnover um in in in the facilities Department as those folks leave we won't rehire them um you know we

123have a hardworking staff uh you know they they're the was paid unfortunately of of the staff members in the border of Ed so we want to at least give them the grace to to to do this through attrition where it's not hurting families we understand the goal and the need so we are steadfast in in in the fact that we have to make these reductions but these reductions will be done through attrition and I'm I'm willing to bet that we're more than halfway there already and we'll get those numbers to everyone and so when you say we're more than halfway there the information provided to us today may not be fully accurate in terms of people resigning or leaving from the maintenance side I'm not sure because some of these positions have been gone for

124some time now so due to the hiring process and and and and and everything else we've had vacancies so those vacancies will be taken into account as part of the 10 maintainers that we're going to be giving up and Mr Garcia while I have you here can you just tell us what do the maintain MERS do building to building um maintainers play the the almost the same role as a custodian um they can open close buildings um you know they do day-to-day custodial work uh work in exterior buildings do snow help with litter uh you know it's uh you know our staff does everything um uh and that includes the maintainers so that's that's what they do day-to-day uh custodial work and so my understanding is that with exception of one facility in minda has

125three custodians uh we have on average one custodian per building how would that impact each facility if are you trying to is that implicating that we'll have buildings without custodians do we have enough for all 39 facilities so we we do have enough staff to cover all of our facilities obviously facilities has been the first place for any Cuts over the years um you know we'll be reporting on that at the facilities committee meeting through our stewardship report will give you the 10year trends of hiring budget everything so you have a very clear picture on um you know what's happened in facilities over the years um you know we know that we need 170 custodians to cover every shift we know we're not there um right now the edict to the team is that we

126have to rewrite every schedule in the district um this is more work on top of more work that was given to these folks over the years do through uh cuts um but once again we're doing everything in our power to bring in the the kind of equipment that that shaves a little bit of time off of the end of the workday to help reshape how we operate and how we're going to deliver the best product that we possibly can there will be pain in this because at the end of the day there's more work than than people to do the work um with that said we have a dedicated staff of folks that work hard every single day they show up they do what they got to do um but once again there's a ramification

127to everything that's on this list and uh we will do our best to make sure that we can deliver the best product that we can to the students and the staff and how many electricians do we have in the district we currently have four we're going to be getting rid of one of the four so that means each electrician will be responsible approximately for 11 buildings each uh more or less okay I have walk some of the buildings will will any of these Cuts be the dumbar like is or do we have any resign res resignations to that school I mean you know uh part of the practice is that we've got to workload every single building um you know we've got to look at the the the scheduling we have to look at the

128programming within the building because some some schools have specific programming that that create a little more work than the regular workflow so there's a lot of work ahead of ahead of um the management team over the next couple of weeks to sort of drill this down now that we're at this juncture um and we'll be reporting back to the board at our facilities committee meeting um you know sort of giving the historical data and some of our short and long-term plans on how we're going to address uh the deficit in bodies thank you Mr Garcia Miss Baptist as your 10 minutes is up we're going to move on and have another chat next we have Mr Woodson okay um questions for Dr Avery um I hear that that the savings like some of the savings

129that we're going to be that we're planning for is not going to be um fulfilled till like two three years is the state okay with us you know uh not saving any money right away like you know you saving money 2 three years down the line is that going to help us with the state uh from being taken over well point of clarity there's no takeover happening as of now so M Dr goad just for clarity I think I think the district has to be very cognizant of the deficit that we have so we can't grab the dollars to save now we we won't be able to adhere to the deficit so it's important as we as we look at positions and things to to cut or save in a district we need to do

130that urgently now so I mean we're the the cuts we're making we won't see for a couple of years right like when we make cuts to if we make cuts to teachers and stuff like that because of because of uh like uh unemployment and stuff like that we won't we won't really see any savings for like you you you will see through the process there's a lot of things will be you know as we bring positions and we're getting ready to look at a at a um a process of programmatically look bringing things to the board you could save there uh with looking at contractual things that we have in the district you can save there uh but there's there's going to be some you initial savings when you first cut but then there's some

131other things that have to there some residual things that will take place if there's uh unemployment those types of things uh that we would have to take into consideration as well so you may not see 100% of the of the savings but you may see 80 to 90% of the savings it just depends but the state but the state is going to be okay with us as long as we're showing that we showing that we're promoting savings they're going to be okay with that I think I think again I think the the biggest part is that we don't uh there there's some statutory requirements for districts not um approving a deficit budget so we have a a short timeline to to do that in order to be in compliance so that's really the goal for

132us trying to get there as quickly as we possibly can uh we are in a legislative session uh this this uh this uh through the end of beginning of June so if there's some additional dollars that the state and will provide us uh that could offset some of the deficit as well so that's why the advocacy movement is to get out there and advocate for additional dollars so again there's a lot of things in play uh as we look at some of the long-term options that we have uh after after we go through the facility studies those are some additional uh opportunities for savings that may come in year two and year three uh as we you know move to close the budget Gap okay but I just don't want us planning on getting money

133from the state because they're they're not reli they're not reliable we we we've been through this before I mean we we had need in the past the need in the from two three years ago is the same need as we as we have today so you know I just I don't want people you know putting every all their cards on oh we're going to get money just because we got five five other cities that always needed money too at the same time so I mean I don't know like I said I don't know why we never came together ahead of time before this now I mean now is kind of urgent urgent so I'm hoping that it works but I don't I don't think that I hope that we're not planning on getting that money

134and putting that in in our like budget I know we're not but I just hope you know people don't get their hopes up and we just be responsible with the money that we have that's it thank you Mr Woodson um Mr sakovic thank you madam chair yes um yeah I'm definitely concerned about the cuts to facilities especially with um the condition of the facilities having to um close schools possibly to rehab maintenance getting away from us deferred maintenance is definitely not a thing if we do in fact find additional funds I think that should be one of the first points we bring back is to make sure our facilities never ever get in the same positions that they are in the same conditions and I would like to address a little bit about the budget

135and how it works um the say cost savings are basically unknowable it could be anywhere from when you talk about the teacher level and level with the bumping rights to that from that position for one year if the person does choose to stay but the person could always choose to leave which would make it a complete savings um and even if it's not a complete savings for this year our budget is a living do a living breathing document that transcends years decades so if we don't see the savings of x million dollar this year we'll see it in year three and we won't have to worry about it in year three and we'll have a more manageable budget where we don't have to keep going out for money um we're not really and see some

136from some of the questions and some some of the comments in the media I don't think we're doing a good enough job of explaining exactly what's happening with this budget and we we need to better explain how this is a holistic document and this works step by step and it's going to be a moving document the numbers that we have today are not going to be the same numbers we have tomorrow because we'll have more information tomorrow than we had today so that's that's why I want us to get all on the same page and I would basically beg the entire board to come sit in the finance committee where we could have these deeper discussions and be knowledgeable because a lot of the questions I hearing asked today we answered at the finance committee

137level and it's kind of redundant to ask the same questions two or three times we all need to participate in especially the finance committee especially the facilities committee especially all four committees we signed up to do a job we should have this information we should not be re rehearsing over and over and over again the same conversation because a lot of these questions they have been answered I I would just like to support these Cuts even though I don't like them so that's all I have Miss cmir thank you Mr um I'm sorry my question was already answered thank you Mr tror yes thank you madam chair um with regard to the question that Mr Woodson asked um we're not getting State approval yet we had a hearing in Hartford where the state asked us

138questions we'll be going back and talking with the state further uh our budget is subject to the normal uh requirements of state law um and needing to Bal offer a balanced budget at the end of the year as Mr noo spoke to earlier and Miss seagull has spoken to in past years um and that's what we're working towards in this discussion and we have sort of two concurrent discussions going on now which is oftentimes confusing people one is we're trying to um deal with problems in this year's budget that we incurred because last year's process was so flawed last year's process was flawed because the budget wasn't started effectively until March uh normally it would be started right around the holidays a little before a little after and we would have had a budget by

139February that we would have gone out into the community and had in vigorous discussion and with the city and with the state about how much money they're going to give us and there would have been great debate and everything none of that occurred last year um and so we got nothing from the state that we wanted we got didn't get from the city that we wanted we ended up taking a lot more out of our savings account than we wanted and then as we found out recently we ended up $6 million over that budget uh we had about a two-hour debate on that budget of$ 309 million so we are now trying to reconcile all the flaws in last year's budget that never should have been passed the way it was passed anyway um and

140uh it's a it's it's a significant problem to fix and the state didn't approve that budget per se we met the legal requirements technically because we took so much of our money out of savings now if the state had been looking more closely as they suggested last Thursday up in Hartford they probably would have said oh is that a wise thing to do that's probably not a good thing to do but they weren't looking closely now they're looking a little more closely because oh our past chair Mr tror yes on filed a complaint um and so verification I didn't file a complaint if you're GNA make false allegations at least you know be truthful you're you're lying all that point I disagree but I'll rephrase my comment because a letter was submitted by our past

141chair while she was in her last week of office we're in debate the purp hand I am debating the point at hand I'm responding to a point made by another member of the board it seems like you're pontificating amongst yourself I didn't call on you about State oversight continue and that state oversight is directly related to a letter that was submitted by the you okay Mr tror and so that state over site is now looking more closely at whether we're being prudent in dealing with next year's budget and prudent in dealing with this year's budget and one of the problems with this year's budget is that we cannot exact certain savings because we have contracts that we didn't approve we have the those contracts that don't give us immediate savings because of people's bumping rights

142um so that uh an assistant principal position that was created at the end of this year at the beginning of this year uh that person gets to bump back into the bargaining unit um at their higher rate of pay so we won't realize that savings until a a later period of time so all of those things are affecting our ability to achieve immediate savings um and so uh we will have to delay the the savings that we can achieve in this year's budget so as Mr nio just pointed out we may have have $12 million worth of savings proposed in a package out of which we will only realize a couple of million dollars worth of savings in this year's budget unfortunately it would be nice if we could realize more savings by doing the

143things that we're doing but we can't and so we're going to try and Achieve as much savings in this year's budget as we can without directly affecting what's going on in our children's classrooms and that's the goal we've set out to achieve and it's not easy and we look at each little item as we are doing and I'm going to disagree with Mr sakovic in a few minutes on a couple of the other proposals that are on the table tonight so we are going to argue and disagree and debate as we did in his finance committee meeting last week and as we go forward we will probably have more of those disagreements it's not an easy thing and the state is said to us last week oh we're now looking more closely because we were

144not very responsible in the past year and so the state is saying we're going to look a little more closely at what we're doing this year it it hasn't just been in the past Mr wson hasn't been Mr Woodson we're gonna keep order because we weren't very prudent in our past year in setting up the budget for the that we're currently living with um and so we're trying to realize say savings um in dealing with that budget and what is confusing a lot of people and I know it came up at the library last week is we are trying to trim costs in this year's budget at the same time we're trying to create a budget for next year two different things going on at the same time none of which are easy the trimming

145of cost this year or the setting of the budget for next year both of which are EX extraordinarily challenging because they involve a great deal of money all of which will directly affect our children one way or another whether it's the type of question that we were asking Mr pelowski a moment ago in the IT department or the kinds of questions we were just asking Mr Garcia in his department they all directly or indirectly affect the quality of Education that we're providing our children and so we are some of us hoping that we can take advantage of the uh the extra money that the state finds itself having and getting some more money from the state which has always been stingy with giving our cities and our distressed communities in this state we're hoping to

146get more money out of them this year than we normally get and quite frankly hoping to get a little more money out of the city than we would normally get that's one other option we either make Cuts or we get more Revenue that Revenue can come from Grants or it can come from the those other government the city and the state government as well as the US government now given the recent electoral results nationally I'm not counting on getting a lot out of the national government the federal government this year either so I think our best chances are the state and the city government and the city cannot fix our problem even if were choosing to be as generous as they we would like them to be the best chance we have is with the

147state and so that's where I'm putting my my best efforts um but you may not have the optimism that I have but I I am going to fight everywhere I can to get the most money we can from other places so that we don't have to make the kind of draconian guts that we would need to make to achieve a balanced budget that we're required by law to make as a board Miss casimer um Mr Garcia uh I just wanted to know how the um summer intern program is going and the workplace program I and uh especially with these Cuts coming and um I've talked to you oneon-one about this stuff a couple times before uh and I know uh the situation that the um that your department is in financially um with these Cuts

148so I just wanted to ask I know that they're not electricians and Painters yet but for the you know for for the kids and and for the young people um that I know that you guys were were hiring through the city and also in the uh summer intern program just wanted to know like is that still up and running is are are those students can they help um you know the the plumber and electrician like with anything that doesn't have anything to do with being licensed just wanted to know that so we did have the uh summer internship program this this season um you know we had several youngsters come through um it was funded 100% by the workplace um we started conversations now that that that summer internship program had had elapsed we started

149having uh conversations about other programs that the workplace has where we can get um 12mon employees to help paid for through the workplace but there's a conflict now uh with us laying off um I'm not sure if we'll have the ability to bring those uh folks in due to the fact that we'll have layoffs and we cancer plant the work so it's something that you know we've got to do a little more research on the workplace still is very interested in uh doing placement here we discussed four to six um you know uh youngsters to come into the district and help out but we just don't think we're going to be able to pull that off now due to the budget cuts okay if there's anything that I can do to help with that just

150let me know okay thank you right thank you Mr benan I have a question for Mr Dominic um anyone is in the union you to be short that the first one will be calling back because of contract right yes yes we're obligated in most collective bargaining well really with all these positions if they're if we do put those positions back on we have to recall them now whether they take it or not that's on them but you know they are entitled to recall rights um because I know we had to do lay off it's not the point we want to we don't have no choice but I know the all the employees they will do extra hours they will be I'm paying over time so what's going on with that party if they they pay

151over time if you're trying to save money that would be more of a more of a question for netor but please as far as the recall yes these these people if the superintendent decides that you know hey we need to bring these people back we need to add these positions because we cut a little bit too deep we'd have to go through a reappointment list and go in that order but as far as theost through Madam chair um relative to overtime to be honest with everyone mathematically sometimes is the same price to pay somebody over time than hiring a new person in other words when you add the cost of the fringes the health insurance the Medicare the accumulated vacation the person is going to have you pay the you rather pay it time and

152half in overtime for that short time frame and call it a day instead of carrying the load for extended time if you run the numbers together you find out it's the same thing you might as well pay I don't want to make it public sometimes it's a little cheaper to pay overtime and that's the end of that service you're not carrying that load for the longest time okay thank you sir no more question Madame chair thank [Music] you question okay so you're asking another question okay so um first you uh Miss Baptist Perez your second yeah your second question or your second round of questioning I I just want to clarify because it's a myth and there tends to be individuals with extreme short-term memory this deficit existed preco the covid Arps or funds delated

153and and we're at this point now and so the allegations or uh implications that it's happened just within this past year is false um and I'm really concerned that what I'm hearing and what I heard from Mr Garcia is that we're cutting these uh you know maintenance workers electrician a painter a these are all lowlevel and he just said one of the lowest paid roles and yet we have the interim superintendent just State publicly that we spent $150 million half of our budget on special education alone that's almost possible like we're being asked to lay off our lowest paid employees that are already overworked when we're wasting half of our budget and my concern again follows up with the past delegation are you saying wasting half I have a point C are you saying you

154have a you're wasting half your budg he said what he said $150 million publicly is being spent on special education and that's higher than what we were informed 115 and I don't think he said wasted I think that was your 115 million so budget there's a point of order no this is my time so that's going to pause my time I pause your time already Mr sakic has a point of order point of order under the rules we've been using for the last year it's 10 minutes in total debate time up to two times Miss Baptist Perez has already expended her two 10 minutes speaking no I have not my start time you actually did the first time around you spent um no 30 seconds it's up to two times this is my second time

155to speak and if you're just going to fact that you're being asked to lay off low-level employees when $15 million is being spent or sped that shows the state needs to take over this school board because we have not historically taking care of our children all right miss the fact that you think that that's okay your time was up no my time wasn't given but that's okay he said that information that was an executive session thank you you can there's an increase in special education costs that you tell it to the state the increase in the special education cost o sign back in um Mr svic yes ma'am um thank you madam chair um I have you have about three minutes so so you know okay no worries it's not going to be long um

156yeah we're talking about 10 position the 10 positions through attrition elimination um we're looking for we're pretty much looking for immediate savings to the extent possible what are we going to do if we don't get enough resignations anybody Dr Avery or we are um looking to provide some additional uh cost-saving measures uh hopefully by Thursday when we come back from for the finance committee bringing some additional um opportunities for the board to consider at that meeting right no well let me let me let me clarify a bit further because didn't really hit my point um say we get eight does say does eight% after you look at the positions you see there's eight positions we're authorizing 10 position eliminations from the budget those two will they be subject to layoff immediately to impact this year's

157budget or will they be carried throughing just way wait what if they never resign again the ball is in the in the B Court my understanding is that the legislative intent of the board is that these positions will will be a Tre meaning that until they voluntarily leave employees voluntarily leave that could be two years that could be three years from now again yeah that was my understanding of the legislative intent unless you're saying it's otherwise that's what I understood the board said yeah correct me if I'm wrong I I believe the actual motion is the elimination of 10 positions off of the budget through with no clarification only reason I bring up the attrition is because attrition was mentioned yeah okay I mean that's so that that's what I want to clarify I think

158I think the clarity is is uh well taken and I think we could we could be able we will be able to kind of move forward with that George do you want to speak to that point yeah so like I said right now our last roster count yesterday I mean this morning was 147 of 160 budgeted let us take a look we may be there with the 10 uh maintainers already um you know we definitely we have a a different break breakup in terms of Staffing is custodial janitress and maintainer but I'm willing to bet that we're very close to that 10 and um like I said we have constant turnover so this is not a longterm one year twoyear span this is shortterm we'll get to r10 Mr but we will give you a

159number ASAP I'll work on that first thing in the morning Mr Woodson um I have here I'm looking at I'm looking at the meeting from January 2nd when Mr Eno mentioned on how the best way to save money and I brought it up at the last meeting how the best way to save money is to reduce reduce the uh uh you know the the the teacher student ratio and increase it rather now what what changed since this last meeting on uh January 2nd um through through Madame Madame chair the student teacher ratio what it does actually you got to access the teachers into by not you know by not advertising or filling bacon positions that's all it does meaning that you're going to consolidate the classes to have higher classes however we have to be

160very careful we went through the whole Generations today um so magnet schools conditions of the grant or building the magnet school you cannot exceed certain St student t-shir ratio does that contrad does that contradict the contract our contract that we have with the Bea as far as has nothing it has nothing to do with Bea it has to do with the condition of accepting a magnet no but we have we we have an agreement with Bea that they that that that we have uh 29 and the and uh I understand it kind of contradicts it if you want to put it that way this is a state law I I think it has to do with Discovery magnet school I think the T go ahead Mr tror for a point of information it's not contradicting

161it it's since the ratio in the magnet school is lower than 29 it's not a violation it's actually so what about the other 30 schools well they're they're not as good that the school is superior what about the other 30 schools far as filling up the classrooms terms of of maximizing I mean yes putting more students per class that's a question of us reviewing I think that have to do sorry can I jump in I think that would have to do like with further discussion on I was answering your contractual question yeah so so when the study comes out next month and it says that a that a school may be you know endangering endangering the health of a of a of a student and we have to close it and we may have to

162close it you know what should is do we have to readjust or should we just leave it open and leave leave the kids exposed what should we do Dr ay I think once we get the uh condition report from the facility study those are conversations that you know we will have with the community and with this board uh and the the financing I mean the facilities committee as well regarding those options because if if children are in danger it's it's our we have to do our due diligence to make it right uh and I think we will have uh the factual information about the conditions of those buildings uh and I think hopefully the community will drive some of those decisions and conversations around do we keep it open or not but I don't want

163to count on the community again because sorry because in the past past superintendents that wanted to do what was right this the community stepped up the schools wasn't closed and now we're looking at a now we're looking at a $30 million deficit you know someone it has to be a point in time where somebody got to put the foot down and make a stand you know I mean we can't just keep saying oh we're saving a million here we're saving a million there but that has to add up to it to you know to we don't want to be taken over by the state that's not the goal no are We Are we more Are we more loyal to the to to our Union contracts are we you know more loyal to the students I

164mean I I I I I don't know thank you just want to make a a point of clarity um uh two things one person mentioned a Takeover in the media there's right as of now there is that is not on the table right now we're there's still um things that have to go the process has to be happen first and there's that's not on the table right now um a second point of um Clarity I just want to like I heard it said that we're wasting 150 million on special education special education not a waste um all students deserve a free appropriate public education and that was um I'm hoping that's not what was meant by that Mr treyb um your time you have about like a minute left on your time yeah I I

165want to reinforce there is no no effort underway for a state takeover um and so that's that's a false narrative out in the public uh right now um so let's leave that where it is for a second the state is looking to see what they can do to help us is my understanding from the state officials that I've talked to um two um uh the public H has every right by our policies to be involved in any discussion about any question about what we do with any school facility in the city that is Bridgeport Board of Ed policy and what our previous superintendent did was choose to ignore that so we will do and follow policy about whatever we do with the Facilities Review report that we are about to start engaging in a discussion

166so I I want to reassure everybody that we intend to follow policy as we should have done last year when it was Eng engaged in so those two things are out there we will we will follow policy and we will work cooperatively with the state in whatever way they choose to help us but there's no takeover discussion in this community thank you and I'm not sure if Mr Woodson meant just last year's um conversation about school closing because they think this have been an issue for um over a decade in terms of different school closing so but I I do think committee input is important for that with that said I believe um unless Mr benan or Miss Medina have any further questions everybody else has asked two rounds of questions so we're going to

167go ahead and take a vote on this um guess all in favor of the proposed cuts for tier two say I I any opposed would you like a roll call you're you're we haven't we haven't made called yet to vote you haven't been called yet to vote you could come on up and send your seat and when you're called on you can make your point okay all righty Mr benan go ahead Christine M Paris let me put your mic on that $15,000 well maybe if you didn't kick me off the first time to completely forgo my OPP you had your 10 minutes no you had just explain your vote the right to explain you do so if you could just be quiet for a second miss you can make vot okay pass good got a

168here I didn't hear you she's staining Miss Jennifer Paris yes Mr Joseph saket yes Mr Robert tror yes Mr Woodson Mr Willie Medina yes Mr Jennifer Paris yes Mr benan yes you have to take her vote too six oh you you said no already you have to take my vote you said no already you have to take my vote I have passed you said no when you first in you ran said no I said roll call vote you said it's fine listening is a a skill um I'm going to vote no because $15 million on special education is a waste of District resources when children are not being taken care of properly and so that indicates to me because we were given information and in comparison that is a $15 million increase and I want

169to know where is that going to actually take care of our children we're cutting the lowest set of Maintenance workers now with 39 dangerous facilities because my time was cut we have 709 million dollars in growing in the facilities master plan and yet we're going to make cuts to facilities knowing that we weit we spend a third of our budget probably overidentifying our children of color and sending them out of district and so no that's why I vote no because it seems that there is very counterintuitive Common Sense approaches to this District that we're going to posting jobs that was explanation thank you thank you all right that one passes the next item on the agenda is the discussion and possible approval of the proposed tier three staff reductions as presented as the January 2nd

1702025 Finance commit is there any discussion on this one Dr ay go ahead this uh proposal is exactly uh the same proposal that was presented um at the December 16th meeting thank you any discussion on this one Mr Woodson so I'll make a motion you have question go ahead um yes I just wanted uh some clarity about the bilingual Le to the micrphone it's a little thank you she want to get some clarity about the um bilingual liaison business and office teacher is this the same position that I'm not sure if it's the same position I'm thinking of but is this the person that goes out to um non-english speakers like for instance like Spanish um speakers goes out to their house to help them like find an apartment because there's a language barrier and

171she goes to meetings with them is this the same you want to confirm that well you're saying no they're saying so what's the answer J she is I'm sorry uh she is assigned to the bilingual Department she meets with families who are new to the district that are not english- speaking um she runs Community forums uh is involved with Siri to um acclimate and get them the assistance they need right but it goes deeper than that like doesn't she help them sign make sure they understand the leases that they're signing when they can't find like there's a language barrier like she does a lot in the community for these families just to be able to have their kids come to school and have like the you know like ma maso's hierarchy of need like that's

172who takes care of that right for those families she is involved in that yes she's the one who coordinates the the forums and and um community events for the non-english speakers who are coming into the district okay so who's going to do that work if her position is being cut who's going to do that work that would have to be through the director again just so the board is is clear on on this HR does not decide who what what these cuts are okay we facilitate them but as far as the making of the cuts that's that's not an HR function I can provide to you you know what these people do but as far as the plan of what's going to happen from here right no I get it it's not your it's not

173you know you're in power I would say to explain to the the parents and to the public that how how um you know how important that this position is that's all I was doing and I wanted to make sure that I had Clarity I think one of the things that we're whenever we're looking that cutting positions at the higher level one of the things that's that's key that I've tried to do is look at who's going to replace to to provide those services and one of the things that we're looking to do right now is opening up a welcoming Center uh and parents will be able to come to one location to provide assistance in a lot of different areas so um uh we are we have a couple of meetings with honic and with

174uh University of bridgeboard to find a location to be able to do that that that opportunity where we can bring in you know families that are in need of you know those types of services uh working with our bilingual Department working with a special a department to where it's one of a One-Stop shop we used to have something like that in the district it's what you know so really being able to expand upon that uh you know because we need to service our families and provide an a one shop area where they can go to ful to fulfill some of those or ask questions on how and then working with our partners uh we have a lot of Community Partners that are willing to provide those additional services at no cost to the district uh

175in order to be able to kind of work through a lot of our community partment Partners know that we're in a in a financial State uh they've been reaching out trying to figure out what else could they do to expand the services for our families and so that's a good thing and I and I welcome that so again as we look at these these positions I have to figure out how we're going to how we how are we going to you know um transition away from these staff members into still providing or enhancing the services that we provide yeah so that's good that there is a plan to help with the with the you know the new Parenting Center that's going to relaunch but between this person leaving and that happening are the Community Partners

176going to step in there's an influx of Spanish-speaking families that you as you know that are coming in every week absolutely and it's like okay so who's going to take care of that from the time this person if the board votes on this person to get cut who's going to take care of that from the day that person leaves until we launch this parent Center that you just talked well I I think that's that's another you know opportunity for me to engage in the director of Bal services and looking exactly how that's going to transition uh and the case load are the op the options and opportunities that this person person has over the next couple of months and make sure that we have that coverage uh and that's just with everyone but but I

177I I definitely understand where you're coming from I think that's important uh and we do have other people that will be able to you know um uh pass the Baton and kind of help out a little bit in the inum and I think that's going to be the important piece too because I'm looking to hopefully to have this um newcomer centers up and running by the time we start school next year so that means getting a a good clean Runway come June and July to where we so we can start welcoming these parents into the center so again we're talking about a small month a couple of months to where I'll make sure that we have that that coverage thank you Mr Woodson um I think us being a board of mostly minorities you know

178we we should table this decision until you know we find out a plan until until we uh no cuz Spanish speaking uh is really important in our district right now got to be able to communicate that helps the kids come to school so Mr Woodson has made a motion to table this conversation M Baptist Perez has moved to Second it I second in that conversation that motion I'm sorry um any debate on that oh we can't debate that item sorry um so let's take a vote on that was going be a roll call vote to table the proposed tier three Stafford reductions the motion was to uh table the tier three proposed tier three staff and reductions correction I want to make sure that he makes it correct I don't think he was referring to

179the whole tier three but I want to make clearity oh Mr won were you referring to all tier three or just that first item the first item oh back it up we're then the motion is to table the bilingual liaison business and office teacher uh cup I'm sorry I'm looking at two lines the bilingual liaison position so the motion is to table the bilingual liaison position seconded by Miss bapti Perez thank you for the clarity you're ready Christine M Paris yes I vote to table it as we have six schools out of compliance in multilingual education and this person is significant in the services that we provide including but not limited to going to immigration hearings with families and that when we're considering these roles we should actually have people who are their direct oversight

180that know their day-to-day and all the functions that they're truly doing instead of individuals that will undermine and not express it not debating this is not that's my reason for my vote and which I'm pursuant to Robert's rules to express thank you cheir Miss Jennifer peris pass Mr Joseph I vote no because we got to have this discussion sooner or later it's just going to delay the inevitable whether we pass it or not Mr robber tror no Mr Woodson Mr will Medina do you watch your mic too yeah I vote no to table it because again we're going to get here eventually and I'm confident in the superintendent the staff that we have Plus I'm very confident in the community that we have and our partners that we can reach out a helping hand to

181them as and they will reach out to us and I know there's many people that would help out in this field and I know their staff that will step up to uh to do this bilingual work and I know I'm a volunteer myself if needed so we do have Partners so I vote no is Jennifer Paris Mr benan now I two Mr yes i' like a make a motion to approve the proposal TI three Staffing reductions as presented by Dr Avery okay that motion has been moved by Mr um calic and seconded by Mr Medina is there any debate maker the motion yes um yeah I would like to address um all of these none of these cuts are Pleasant um since we just had a little bit of a discussion on a b bilingual

182lay Zone and we do have some Community Partners I'd like to remind us that we are a board of education our core Duties are to provide services around education some of the duties listed and mentions are more like social services that the city could be providing and our partners could be providing and if we keep on a position to provide services that other people could provide and other actually the city's probably more required to provide these services and helping people with their resumés and do these job and find jobs and find housing reading reading their leases our job is to provide them with access to education explain their education rights and regulations that's as far as our obligations as a board of education is to deal with the education of the students the education of

183the parent may be more fitting to be carried out by an outside agency or the city gu whole other line with Department of Social Work that they could put that onto thank you Miss bapti pz can you click your mic you go what good okay and so the time now is 9:32 so that way uh individuals know my clock and I have 10 minutes to speak I want to start off with saying that we're a board of education not a board of Delegation we continue keep saying that there's other organizations that's going to take on the role of educating our students in Bridgeport and yet our board fails to do that and we failed the students of Bridgeport that's why the states participating in oversight that may hopefully one day lead to a takeover our

184current SAT scores in high school the average is 412 out of an 800 yeah we're looking to cut a literacy coach we don't know the full role of the multilingual liaison yet we're willing to make that cut knowing the devastation also part of what the multilingual liaison does is ensure that multilingual students are actually coming to school so when multilingual students are absent that deals with our alliance Grant we don't even know which particular Grant These funds are coming from so we've made cuts to the director of literacy we've made cuts to our executive directors those are all funded by our alliance Grant and it only indicates to me that there may have been some movement in funds that all of a sudden we're making changes to our alliance grants when we told the state

185that our goals are literacy math and absenteeism getting rid of this particular role when it comes to the literacy coach goes against our alliance Mission which we tell the states that we have the state that we have three particular goals when we're cutting the multilingual liaison knowing that we're out of compliance in six schools we're not providing services to about 700 students knowing that we are going to cut the person that actually goes with them through the process especially in the change of this country's Administration to ensure that they have citizenship and that they're not scared to come out of their house goes to show the amount of negligence in this board and the failure to understand the source of the funds and I don't know how many trainings we have to go through with

186cab but we're not looking at each and every every single role and the impact that it has on our students and families on the dayto day this is going to severely impact I heard this whole conversation regarding um we're going to address the absenteeism okay so let's fire the person that makees sure that our newcomers to the city and to our school district don't show up because that's going to help chronic absenteeism that seems very asinine backround backwards and it doesn't help the situation I'm going to beat this horse because when you hear $15 million out of a $4 million budget something is severely wrong our kids are smart our kids are brilliant our kids can do anything and yet we're how many kids are in special education have we looked at the identification process

187no probably not why because we're just going to continue to go and beg to the state that somehow is their responsibility that this district has failed and it it hasn't failed overnight it didn't fail last year it's been failing for about 25 years so generations of failures let me look at the other roles that we're we're looking to cut that will severely harm children oh we're going to cut the ma math coach again that goes towards the three Alliance goals that we have for the district and I question where where are the sources of these funds and when have the funds been moved because the directors for literacy the director for math the directors for science were all 100% Alliance Grant so for us to make those grants means someone had to move the money

188somehow into operations and how much was moved into operations because how again is that going to help the children of Bridgeport cutting these roles knowing that our SAT scores in math is a three the fact that it's in the threes is already deplorable and knowing that our average SAT score and somebody says oh it's not all about the test scores yet you have to take a test to be a doctor a lawyer a nurse you have to take exams in order to be a plumber all the day-to-day roles every day in life is a test yet somehow this board of education always fails to neglect the education part and then say we're going to see Community Partners that's part of the re the problem is that we keep delegating out someone else is going to

189take over this issue we're going to seek another organization that's why bridor has an overpopulation of nonprofits because it's easy to profit off of our children not receiving the services that we're supposed to give them let's see we're going to cut the social workers they're the ones that actually perform the ppts so again I don't see how that fits our special education goals so we're going to cut the social workers that perform the ppts among a plethora of other services the literacy coaches oh I forgot multilingual also is in charge of testing to see whether our multilingual students are able to go into an English setting classroom as well as go into our needs additional Services there's just a plethora that goes into the this particular tier and all the Staffing cuts that just points

190back to not only the nine of us but the nine that have sat in the past in these seats and that the fact that we're making these Cuts again I believe will severely harm children uh let's see multilingual literacy coach I I I want to know where in the grant this money is coming from what where in the funds how is this all operational when they were originally designated as Alliance when I was chair that's fine did you guys think about it because you know I I noticed when I was at home there was an issue ironically with math and keeping time and and that would kind of correlate to a third grade esack level in which the majority of our students are not at grade level but I still believe that they can but

191this district is not providing them with the resources that demonstrated well look at this 9:32 and it's 9:38 that's a math question of how much time I have left and this is still my first time speaking I think these cuts are wrong what's been presented we were told and Mr Woodson can attested this is that there would be other options no other option was presented to us this district is being lied and deceived by the interim Acting Superintendent and I I don't agree with this cut I don't agree with the majority of these Cuts especially when a simple Act of balancing classrooms at the end of last school year would have saved tens of millions we have classrooms in this district with is 14 five kids them a one to five ratio and yet we

192still see the deplorable test scores something is systematically wrong with this school district and I thought that if we had a qualified superintendent come in that that would change it it only has opened my eyes up to the plethora of problems which is why I had to report an informed to state but I mean if if you guys I I go I could go back I mean when are we going to expand how much is it going to cost for this One-Stop shop where is it going to be located we already have 700 million doar in uh what debt because that's the cost to actually repair our buildings to just have it at the status quo the crystal report notified us that about 15 of our schools are about half empty so where is this

193money going to come from to have this new welcome center and when is it going to happen you're talking about where is that money coming from I'm I'm I'm waiting to know where is this money coming from because it's always a pretty picture at the end but the reality right now is this nothing pretty about it I I heard this wonderful plan that we're going to have a welcome s how much is that going to cost and where's the money coming from oh I guess No One's Gonna answer you want Dr answer that oh yeah I I I'll leave my two minutes but once minutes is done I I would like to know where that money is coming from that's going to fulfill all the services that this board has not been properly reported on

194you're 1 minute and 23 seconds left okay well I'm waiting for my answer in one minute 23 seconds and no one better go over mam chair we are actually working for a looking at a a partnership with them at no cost to the district to be able to have a facility for us to take our own additional our staff into the facility to run the the facility so right now it's we're on the preliminary stages of it we have a meeting on Thursday to kind of work out to take us over to look at the site for possibility of being able to use the site if it's uh adequate enough for us to be able to use so we will um work out some of those things here uh over the next couple of days

195uh and be able to bring back again this was a concept that I was working with um Mr karfa on uh We've finally got them to give us a date to come together to have a deeper conversation uh and so again those things are going to be worked out and we're sorry the University of Bridgeport University of Bridgeport I need my mic on the last conversation I heard is that was with honic this seems to be very very preliminary how can you guarantee that have not gotten back with us on so this is very preliminary then because the as of probably the other day it wasatonic and now I'm here in University Bridgeport and that's my time and I will not be wasting it I have another opportunity to speak Mr Medina it's very interesting

196how all these different things in oversight are being brought forward now but while people were in position to have to put things in oversight but yet then create messes and throw things up at the fan into the wind and give no oversight to this entire board and accountability to this entire board all of a sudden wants to throw up all these hypotheticals and all these questions and questions people's positions and their jobs and what they're trained to do and their qualifications but while they're qualified they can't do the job that they're qualified to do or supposedly do so again this oversight you know let's just start with the budget the budget itself was set up for $39 million but under the uh the ex superintendent and those board that the board chair and the chair

197of the committee has overspent more let with no oversight whatsoever with this board but yet once to bring forth people to try to do the work that we were able and willing to do but yet they want to talk about the mess that they created that we're trying to fix now so I I employ the community to really get together with us and and to work together with us we know that you guys are out there that are willing to do the work we know that there's staff in our schools that are willing to do the work that needs to be done we have capable people right now that are just need a chance and before everybody was calling for a chance but yet when we're trying to ask for a chance with an open

198floor an open community and being as open as we can no board is perfect no educa everybody's dealing with this issue across the state everyone's dealing with this issue with shortfalls with education for oh like we said we're looking at our rate our our raises for special ed is going up but we're never getting enough money to C cover the the the exit cost every year that is coming into our district but yet nobody wants to talk about that and say that's the cause of the problem yes money doesn't create the answers for everything but when you're trying to build a house and you're trying to build a house with $10 compared to $100 what is the difference in that house you can tell the difference I sat down with multiple people in organizing and

199and painted as a little kid with crayons and markers what Ideal school looks like and then we wanted to talk about okay stop you already painted it you already drew it now what's inside the school and that's what we trying to make sure that we can protect those things that are inside the school and we have people out here we have shining stars in this community that been doing some of this work and when everybody wants to talk about these position some of these position were not even here in the district back in 2020 2020 so postco they weren't around so we were doing this work we were some people were doing this work and I know that we can't do better together and we're trying to ask the community to be patient with us

200we're trying to fix the issues that were not taking care of while other people in Authority in POS leadership position could have taking care of this and look at this we tried I've been in this board since December 11th we tried to ask the questions you guys can go back to the film just like my colleague did go back to the film and go back to the recording where we ask to sit down and talk about every position we could have done some of these cuts and some adjustments already that way we won't be in the position we're in right now but yet while we were in this position of wondering how are we going to budget this 309 that we did have budgeted at that point in time without oversight they continue to spend

201money in excess of six to S million over without oversight of this board whatsoever and that was done by the ex-chair that was done by the super ex superintendent and was done by the ex-chair of the finance and personnel and policy uh chair so I just want to make sure go ahead ma'am there is a point of order m b for us the the point of order is um there's again false allegations when the deficit existed uh about five superintendent ago and it's been held off by Arps or funds and so this continuous overspending allegation is not only is it false but it shows that people can be elected to this role and not know the history of the board or its finance and show that they're limited so that's my point of clarification thank

202you are you done thank you it's interesting how people want to say limited math is math the numbers don't lie M numbers don't lie guys if you want the numbers come and see me come and see us we have it all out there okay it's clear uh our our our CFO clearly said it many many times we're just trying to fix the problem that way we can actually breathe and then start building together that's all we're asking back us up one minute let's let's do this together I'm talking to the whole board I'm talking to the community I'm talking to the leadership but we need more from everybody including this board thank you thank you um I do want to make a you know I I will say there has been a lot of tax

203on the previous chair and previous chair of the finance it takes five votes so there's a lot of us that are accountable to that that budget so that what happened in the past we passed the budget as a board you know and we can't we have to stop calling out we we already know what happened in the past let's move forward what's the plan forward um Mr Woodson and that includes my vote I I I was a part of that vote so Mr Woodson yeah I think it's really important that we just established where the where did Deb started I don't want to keep talking about the debt like I said I just want to you know get P not even get past I want to handle it like a like a responsible Citizen and

204you know if it if it calls for like Mr sakovich he was calling for an audit a couple of month a couple of weeks ago you know hopefully you know we're moving forward with that but you know we need to we we we need to stop definitely accusing people of stuff but if it's if you're going to accuse somebody son at least let it be true you know like I said this the debt is been there that hasn't just got here let's stop saying that you know stop stop trying to make people on this board look bad because the truth is that the the damage was done years ago and somebody was the person one of the people that was s that was on the board was sitting in the crowd a couple of couple

205hours ago you know he's gone but you know that's the those are the people that we should be talking to Joe Joe was on the board we should be asking him you know what's what's going on you know it's not our fault so I just want to make that clear thank you Mr trayor um unquestionably Bridgeport Public Schools have been underfunded for Generations um and we have been through Harsh Times um and eliminated all of our coaches I mean this this literacy coach or math coach at black Malone we had three literacy coaches and two and a half math coaches now for the district we have one literacy coach and one math coach I mean that's just it's sad every school had math coaches and literacy coaches and tutors on top of it Title One

206help paid tutors uh it's it's it's it's a sad situation that we're in um and those cuts have occurred 12 years ago we eliminated all kindergarten Paras with the help of the Esser money we replaced some of those and we will be looking in next year's budget at can we keep those kindergarten pairs that we hired back we're going to be in some really tough decisions over the next few months month month and a half as we start talking about next year's budget this is just what can we trim out of this year's budget but the reality is and so I want to be clear when we talk about the irresponsibility all I'm talking about is we had many arguments and we were stifled we didn't we we weren't given the full opportunity to have

207our say last year UNP spending new money when we knew this time was coming we knew that we were coming to the Esser Cliff as it's called when everybody was going to run out districts all over the United States were going to run out of their extra money they were getting from the federal government because of covid and that was going to expire last summer end of September around that time for distri all over the United States and for us we ran out of it at the end of September we knew that was coming and we knew that we had been wise in the allocation of setting aside money into our savings account called the internal service fund ISF and we wanted to keep that money there but last year's budget ended up using up

208almost all of that money and we used we were arguing a year ago in the winter let's not spend $8 million on relay let's not spend this much money on that other programs that we were spending it on because we won't be able to afford this next year and that's the part of the budget that we're talking about not that Bridgeport hasn't historically had funding problems we have and I sat in these Halls it was actually the aqua Center when superintendent Ramos said we can't honestly pass a budget we think we'll be able to educate the children of Bridgeport and that was the last time the state took over that's when the state took over before when they didn't think they could pass a budget that would educate the children of Bridgeport and we are

209going to be in that same position this summer you me and the other seven members members of this board of having to pass a budget that we hope will be able to educate the children of this city so one way or the other we have to get there this summer all right so anyone who hasn't spoken yet all right we're going to go back to um Miss batist Perez all right so again I'm going to go back to this budget I'm surprised that the implication that individuals don't know our alliance goals there's been numerous meetings with the prior superintendent with a group of four that the fact that the failure to ask those questions a reflection of those members again we're make we're giving individuals promotions and increase in elevations in stat in titles I

210want to know where that money is coming from or is it just a title change um do you want that answer no I don't right now I'm talking so please don't interrupt unless it's a point um you know there was a plan there was a plan because we have students attending a facility that was built 30 years after the end of slavery and never renovated never modified and yet that school can house about 500 kids give or take I'm going off of memory and yet only 20 students attend the facility while paying the full price uh that that that was proposed in the plan for that facility to close uh we also have facilities over 100 or near and 100 years old with mold asbestos on the floor that imagine a maintenance worker just using

211the power mop on it that that creates a health hazard that's publicly available and that has been made public and this board voted to keep those empty old elaborated schools open point of information we'll pause you oh hold on then I'm not g to waste my time I'm he she has her time but she's she is expressing misinformation that is not there was a plan out edu.net pa Rising together where thei toay out excuse approach Mr the floor and I'll get back to you Mr okay so that's not part of my time not you're paused all right great well how much time do I have left by the way eight minutes and 19 seconds Mr 19 seconds thank you there was a plan that was promulgated in violation of board policy that she is is

212expressing and she is engaging in exaggeration to support that plan um there was not mold and his bestus being W mopped up off the floor by the custodian um so I object to her uh descriptions actually and I think that's out of line and she should not be allowed to do so miss btis RZ yes okay and so any member of the public I would suggest you do it tonight because it may not be available on the website even within the next 10 minutes uh to go to Bridgeport edu.net Rising together there's a phase approach to the plan that was going to save the district $36 million as I mentioned earlier on May 2024 um the deputy Superintendent at the time was tasked with balancing classrooms because we have an extreme out of proportion our

213teachers are contracted to teach 29 and I'm not advocating for to teach at their Max but when we have classrooms with five students in it and it's not a sped or a sore or any kind of special need class it's just that the building's empty that's an indicator of fiscal mismanagement and the deputy willingly did not follow orders and that would have been a plan where if we did have to go about that that would have resulted in Educators having the summer to find a new position what PA you for a minute what's my time 7:16 did you stop it right there yep 716 Mr CH Christine Baptist Perez I've sit here and have you accuse me of some things that are false and I'll take offense to it how dare you you know all

214I've tried to do since I've got to this district and prior to you know the change of leadership you and I had a pretty good relationship but for some odd reason things has changed and so for you to sit there and act like that you had nothing to do with anything that happened in this District you know it's just a sad sad day you know I respected you for the professional that you were and that you are and for you to come at me the way you've been coming at me the last three four board meetings it's just it really is not acceptable you know and I and I take offense to it so if you want me to be and I've been very polite to you I've been very cordial to you I have

215not disrespected you one bit and so if you want that war we can do it because I am not going to sit here for you from an African-American man to an African-American woman for you to treat me the way you treat me enough enough I've done nothing to you all I've tried to do since the day one I sit foot in this district is to do good things for kids and for you to do what you're doing I'm done click your mic again miss miss baty fores click click on your mic one more time my time started go ahead okay when you have someone that's under you they have a job they're given a job the job wasn't performed and that cost the district millions of dollars and that costs individuals time uh you know

216what I just got to say what I have to say that the truth hurts and right now our kids are hurting Miss B I pause you all right what's my time 659 tror we're again allowing Miss batist Perez to engage in character assassination and exaggerations that are uncalled for and unnecessary and just not on point to the debate that we're having Mr TR Miss bz can you speak to the proposed tier three Cuts please speak to the proposed uh tier three Cuts I'm gonna put your mic on one second go ahead okay so my debate with the proposed tier three Cuts in the same line and order is it's unacceptable and and you know we we have these Notions that these roles are actually filled and I think it's actually elcer and a lot of

217these roles haven't been filled and we're being told that we're being they're being cut in as a cost savings and so uh I also I do have the right during debate I have someone that's come towards my character and there were a lot of cost savings as you're aware and that's about $36 million had we balanced at least two class rooms in every in every building that could have been around what $6 million you know one of the questions we failed to ask as a board is how much are teachers making we have about 1,400 teachers to about 1900 1,900 and uh I mean the number just fluctuated and went up to students in the district but that still gives us a 1 to 14 ratio in the district we were told that in order

218for teachers to earn their weight we needed around a one to 20 ratio yet that wasn't done and that could have been done in a time where everybody could have win we could have closed the unsafe facilities we could have looked into the bouncing and the bumping all those are very time driven efforts and yet again we're here looking at cutting rolls that severely impacts our families with hypotheticals and dependent on other or organizations to do it for us for free when we haven't looked at how we're going to bring our kids back we had the facilities master plan next month we haven't even spoke about closing those same facilities this is not the first the last superintendent wasn't the first Super intended to propose closing those schools or to take those same efforts so

219to sit back now and then to just keep going oh relay relay was Arps or funds there's a complaint about using relay $2 million for teacher training when we look at the test scores there's some disconnect so we spend money on teacher training but yet there's no discussion about the $7 million in Arps or funds that we spent on a science program that was never opened and used in our school district so there's been quite a waste of funds that have happened through the change of superintendent and so the the complaints about $2 million teacher professional development because something needs to be done to train our children or to better teach them and ensure that they have the tools that they need in the classroom someone needs to be talking about why the $7 million

220in Arps or funds were wasted on a science program that was never used I'm just coming about this in a very common sense approach because we use money with hand over to see if we were going to get a return on investment in the programs that we've purchased and when you think think about $7 million for an unopen science project that if you go to bridgeportedu.net risen together you can see the unopened science project uh a science program covered in feces and you can see the conditions of these 100- year old buildings so you're talking about up that is the deficit and there were school districts like Harford that closed their buildings prior and what Bridgeport did and what this board this board did was intentionally delay and now we're here back cutting essential jobs

221we're cutting jobs that affect students uh on their family levels we're impacting jobs that directly affect our goals as a district and I again it's just it's it's almost Preposterous that this is the conversation and because the plan was given and I'm hearing from the same people that posted on Facebook superintendence for dummies now telling me to listen to experts when they went through their own barrage with with absolutely no facts and attacked a woman of color and I'm just stating that those were the objectives and the initiatives that I know as board cheer that were never done that could have saved money but now we're here looking at these low-level cuts and our our children continue to suffer and I mean board of education is not a board of Delegation I don't see much

222education happening this is just to keep us in the in the black I I don't see how these Cuts help with improving student outcomes in every single role we need to see how does these Cuts help student outcomes and they don't thank you um I do also wanted to CL clarify if it was dr's a Dr A's responsibility to re uh reassign um balance was to balance classrooms if he wasn't doing his job his Superior should have brought that before the board we we oversee the superintendent we oversee the superintendent the superintendent oversees her staff his or her staff we don't oversee depues and assistants we're overseeing the superintendent that's the board's job go make your point hold on so that was tasked May 2024 it wasn't done over the summer like plan the next

223um meeting I had with the former superintendent that was to be done by September 2024 when you think about the timeline and the notice of going out on leave that's in October and when I met with the former superintendent by October there was notice that the job wasn't done as required by September and May and then she was out and now we're here today thank you all right Mr calovic you're on your second time yes thank you madam chair um a couple of things I want to address um Mr Woodson call me by name as a longstanding member and I do believe I could provide some of the Insight he needs on historical historical basis prior to my arrival in the board about approximately 2014 2015 we initiated a series of cuts that raised up

224to 241 cuts my first two years on the board I voted to cut some of the positions some of the very positions that have made their way back the first year I did not have to make Cuts due to the severe underfunding by the state local and federal government to our budget was 20 9 that was due to the benefit of covid that was the co Silver Lining our students finally got students finally got onetoone devices our students finally got extra psychologists extra social workers extra things that I know it's been said that we shouldn't have spent money on staff um but that's like selling a star in person if they find $100 don't buy any extra food because you're just going to be hungry again tomorrow these were important funds now that being said

225there was a plan put in place by Michael J Sani in 2019 2020 along with the board understanding that these positions would go away with the exploration of Esser funding they would go away with the exploration of Esser funding this plan was supported by the next superintendent Miss Alicia perin after that it was understood this money would be evaporating and it would have to be some positions could be moved to operating budget but that was not wise because we were operating at a deficit anybody who has been paying attention to the budget for the past four years they can see that we were operating at a structural deficit that was being helped along by the co funds that we did not have to make those cuts because some positions in the operating budget were shifted

226over to the Esser budget as allowable by law as allowable by contracts line item transfers made from like a psychologist that was on the operating budget it was moved into the Esser budget now our our grants can be used for more than one thing we've got a lot of things to do in the districts we got to decide what what is the most least damage that we could do to our students going forward now these positions here that are on the staff three Staffing reductions if you look at them we still have additional positions that did not exist in 2020 we're still in better shape than we were in 2020 following the plans put in place not even following the plans to the full extent because there's still extra couple of positions in some of

227these areas that did not exist in 2020 that we were supposed to be drawing down so I implore the board to pass these unfortunate Cuts because the next round of cuts we're not into the 25 26 school year budget yet we're setting up for that we're going to have to revisit all of this and maybe even cut even deeper here because we are not legally allowed to operate at a deficit hopefully people could Advocate explain the budget a little better so we don't get the misinformation out there about $40 million in missing money so we can get back to the plan as presented two years ago and basically thrown in the garbage over the last year instead of decreasing spending we accelerated spending instead of decreasing jobs we added jobs this is what we got

228to get back to we got to get back to the plan that was logical sensible financially feasible thank you Mr Woodson well no it's some tough decisions that need to be make and I know you know some people on this board have alliances know with certain certain uh memberships or whatever but you know if we can't make the hard decisions that it take to move forward and and and progress then the May the mayor suggested that we can't make the decision we should step down so if you think if you think that you have a problem you know making a tough decision going against what you believe that you know the M thinks that you should step down so you know if you're if you're too if you're too aligned and you can't you know

229you feel you can't you can't make a change you should you should just resign let's go on debate on the yeah just stick to the tier three reduction that's what I got to say you can't make the decision step down tror um thank you madam shair um the uh I the his the history the revisionist history that we have been um presented with tonight is nothing short of stimulating and and entertaining um but it is important to note that one of the problems that we experienced in the past year is that we have a set of policies and procedures which um go through a committee and are presented to the board and get voted on by the board um and those policies and procedures tell us how we are to conduct ourselves and do business

230uh and those policies and procedures spelled out very clearly how we are to go about considering and deciding how we do things like Clos schools um and that was not followed last year so the public reference here to a plan that was dropped out of nowhere on the district last year was in complete violation of those policies and procedures those rules are like laws I enjoy the fact that a lawyer explains to us that this Mr Mr tror does not engage in the personalities continue on the tier three thank you I will I I enjoy the fact that we are being told that a plan was presented to us that we should have followed when we hadn't followed our rules we teach our kids that they are to abide by the rules of the school

231and class as we teach them um and yet as an example or as a role model we presented them a plan that didn't follow the rules of our district um and people objected to not being given the proper notice and respect that those rules were required um that was to be expected and anyone that expected to get a reaction otherwise made a bad judgment um and so now we are going through a process which is good for the district using the census track to do a demographic study and using the additional money as Mr Garcia has said to do a Facilities Review that we hadn't done in well over a decade um so it is a good process that we're going through now and we will see where that leads us with regard to our

232facilities and whether or not that's a good or a bad idea um I would point out too that it does you can Google maps of Bridgeport and see that the east side of bridge the East End of Bridgeport the three demographic areas where we were going to close schools are the fastest growing areas of our city so it is not necessarily a good plan to close three out of the four schools in the fastest growing demographics of our city so I there a point of clarification I just want to say that we are not necessarily Mr trabber pause pardon me there's a point of clarification go ahead uh according to Bridgeport edu.net Rising together there was not a phase to close the a dunar school was to be converted to a adult education Hub so

233that way we could stop paying rent to the dicese and that was that adult our adult education fund or school is actually a profit uh also on our last Crystal report that was sent out approximately the entire student body of dumbar could fit with probably plus or minus 25 kids and entirely inside of Tisdale also I would just uh for clarity refer to the content that's in the demographics study in terms of the growth within the city thank you Mr chaer thank you madam chair so in any case we need to follow our policies and procedures and so I'm glad to see that we are going to do so now and I'm sure the parents and the members of the community in those neighborhoods will be happy to see that done too thank you there

234any Mr B you spoke twice already um anybody else like to speak we're gonna go ahead and take the vote it's going to be a roll call vote Paris I you check Askia uh the proposed tier three staff introductions no M Jennifer Paris yes Mr Justice saket yes Mr Rober tror yes Mr Woodson Mr Medina yesel yes Miss Christine Baptist Paris I about no because there still hasn't been any presentation regarding those unsafe facilities and whether they're going to be open again and that's not even being projected what's being presented is that we're going to keep all 39 facilities whether empty or not open and that's not fair and it's a big cut and it's devastating to our students especially our multilingual families um who rely on the services and the help and the need

235and I'm sorry for the big disrespect especially with the change in the presidential um uh Administration that this District that is known for its immigrant population will not be serving those people or those students and families that one passes next item on the agenda is discussion possible um approval to eliminate the position of director of Athletics as recommended by and approved by the finance committee on January 2nd 205 and Madam chair go ahead um I'd like to make a motion to move items d and e um to move them um let me think how I want to say this I've hit that point tonight I'd like to refer them to my Comm committee on uh instruction and support services for discussion at the committee level before we act on them can I get a second

236to that motion can I request that you add item F to that motion as well if not I'll make the motion um yes you can amend ask me to amend it and I will add item D andf to be referred to instruction and support services committee meeting on the 22nd for discussion there's a point of order Miss I'm sorry go for it okay so Mr Traer is making a motion and it hasn't been seconded yet for him to amend it so he still has time now whether or not to add or make the motion that is referred out to a particular committee because he has not been properly seconded okay thank you so the motion was made to um move items D andf to the instruction of Support Services committee is there a second seconded

237by Mr Medina did you second it okay Mr Medina um is there any discuss uh debate on this Mr talovic has some debate discussion it's debate because of me I just need I would like to number the the positions that we're speaking of please um the position director of Athletics uh the position of SE and student affairs and the position of executive director of turnar around thank you yeah Mr Woodson do you have a question any other will take the vote Mr cvic a little more discussion the same holds true as the last time we brought this up um we've got to we've got to make these Cuts we could have a discussion otherwise we're going to coming back again with the same thing possibly when we could put this to bed tonight either yay

238or nay and get the information presented to us that would be presented at the teaching and learning committee I mean at the student Support Services committee anyway thank you I'm going to my reasoning for um requesting this to be moved to the committee is because these were present these w't um proposed by the superintendent so really he he set a proposed um list of Staffing reductions where they were able to figure out how they were going to reallocate you know the duties at this point I don't think we've given him enough time to really prepare how he would reallocate a director of Athletics or the position atal and student affairs so that's why I would love to go back to committee where they have time to actually vet these out more um these these weren't

239made by these recommendations were not made by the superintendent Mr as the maker of the motion yeah you have the right to speak first go for it thank you um partially I I did inform Mr sakovic at his meeting last week that I was going to do the ask for this um with regard to the position ofal and student affairs because I was concerned about how this would impact um uh support instruction and support services um and wanted to have a further discussion of this these are new new cuts that had not been proposed in the original proposals made by the superintendent and so I wanted to have a greater discussion about how this would impact um the provision of of support services in particular um so I I understand Mr civic's urgency um but

240I also wanted to have a longer discussion um and so that's why I wanted to move it to my committee before the next board meeting to have that discussion at my committee meeting next week um and I uh in a discussion since then um with the chair um we had a discussion about the athletic director position Visa the uh heated debate that we had uh a short while ago about the Middle School athletic program and sort of how that might be impacted by cutting the athletic director um the existence of the lack of existence of a Middle School athletic program and whether or not the athletic director position could be something that would help us um continue to or reestablish a Middle School athletic program for our children um and so I wanted to have

241that discussion before making a decision as to whether or not that position should be eliminated um and and um I know what the chair I'll let the chair speak to her addition of the school turnaround I know what we discussed at the finance committee meeting about school turnaround um and the chair can speak to that issue because um she's the one that wanted to add that to this motion here tonight um like I said I just these were positions that weren't brought before us before by the superintendent so I would like uh greater Clarity on on the positions and how they would affect really affect um the district if if they were cut Miss Baptist Perez you're next oh no I I think it's actually a good idea that it's referred back to committee I

242don't think the position especially for the athletic director needs to be cut uh in particular that we have uh two of our schools uh that produce the most um NFL NBA athletes that are not part of a conference for over a decade uh that precludes students from the opportunity for Scouts being recognized for All State um by by the very nature of not being part of a conference uh there's a little issues um with regards to the building to building management I attended the basketball game at Hardon High School um this past Saturday uh only half the bleach teachers were open and when I had a discussion and I won't name the individuals in the schools that I spoke with but Administration the key was lost and the key has been lost for over a

243year and you know is it Beyond role is that really something we should expect our teachers to be spending time with or the athletic director districtwide is like the principal for athletics and talk about building opportunities for students I had the opportun to actually talk to him know the potential for getting into more competitive conferences the discussion about a swim program um all these ideas that not only make Bridgeport more competitive more marketable but also it engages our students to want to stay to stay in school come in school and stay along the entire Journey um because we do have a lot of kids that and I've met a lot of parents that stated that by the time it's time for high school they're looking for alternative routes for Education whether it's outside of the

244district charter school private school Regional Technical Schools um because there's not a lot of opportunities being presented and and when you think about it 2third of our our major schools because you got to think about the children that goes the Fairchild will go to their District school for sports um preventing them from those academic uh those athletic opportunities severely hurt them um because athletic is a way for students to deal with coping with all kinds of stress and and I've met plenty of people that talk about how Sports kept them in school that the the thought of cutting the athletic director when there's some really Petty small issues building to building that keeps our students not only from playing the game but actually just sitting down in a safe place to watch it uh in

245my eyes it further necessitates the role and if that needs further fleshing out it may be helpful to actually have the individual there to talk about what they're doing and I'm focusing on on Athletics um and maybe this is something the board should do for all the roles is you know what they're doing their source of funding uh how that impacts the district especially with sports um because they think about it academics were're not really hitting uh we have an after school program for the Arts and then where are we with sports and again I think one of the biggest sense of Pride for Bridgeport is uh all the great athletes that it's produced and a lot of our great athletes that are poached off to other districts to play for like St Joe's or

246Notre Dame or Kobe and if we can keep our students here and engag that also bring builds a sense of student Pride so i' really like for us to focus in on athletic directors the other roles as well I mean I have my own opinion with the executive director of turnaround but I can save that for the committee meeting thank you thank you um Mr Woodson oh I'm sorry I'm out of order here he hasn't gone yet Mr Woodson you went already right yeah I just wanted to say that I had a conversation with a principal from bridport public schools and they reiterated the the extra responsibilities that not having a athletic director would oppose on them you know I don't I don't I don't mean to get anybody in trouble hope I'm not getting

247anybody in trouble but I'm just letting you know they just said you know it's just more responsibility pass time you know and and and they recommend having a a a athletic director that's totally committed to you know seeing make sure our our kids have a conference to play in and the games are scheduled and every game is not on Saturday and you know I just wanted to run at it but yeah this important thank you Mr wison Mr talic yes thank you yeah as I said before all the jobs are all the jobs and positions are important and they do bear discussion I have well I would rather have the discussion tonight I'm not opposed I would like to actually for the record correct a bit of disinformation that I gave at the finance committee

248with regards to the position of director of Athletics while we did eliminate it in 2017 it came back for a period of a couple of months in 2023 or 24 and before it was eliminated again I believe it wasn't eliminated but there was an opening few mon it was the person was moved and then it wasn't filled or something like that is that correct that's correct thank you yeah I think it's important when we give a piece of information is to ired as soon as possible and own it and give responsibility because how do how are we to be trusted otherwise um yeah and I for the following reasons stated before I object to putting this back on the committee just because we're going to have to have further discussions and come back and I

249would implore in the interim while it appears appears I'm going to lose on this side of the vote that um Dr Avery something you mentioned is how how are you supposed to do the work I implore you to reach out to your legacy staff and see how they did it before perhaps reach out to Dr Jenkins because our our directors and staff and they've had multiple hats in the past so in anticipation just in case the board does impr approve this you could get a lot of help and a lot of advice to people I don't know how you gain your trust to actually come out of the woods to have those conversations with you but um it has been done in the past and it can be done in the past I I would

250I would suggest even reaching out to Dr Jenkins because she wore multiple hats and one of her responsibilities was one of these positions and the seal staff was just recently shifted around as well and they had multiple hats as well so all all the work in those positions was being done before before the positions even existed thank you that's all I have we'll go ahead and take the vote um all I got it all in favor I any opposed one opposed any extensions all right so it has been U moved back to committee the next item on the agenda is the discussion of possible approval of the issuance of an RFP for a for a forensic audit that would include but not be limited to Declaration of internal controls hiring purchases contract Awards and magnet

251schools as recommended and approved by the finance committee on January 2nd 2025 that was moved by Mr Medina is there a second Mr sakovic Seconds it um Mr Medina you have the right to debate no debate anybody else want to chat about that I got Mr Sali yes this is this is imperative um there's a lot of misinformation going on around our budget a lot of mistrust that was gained over the last year we've for goodness sakes we've had the mayor of the City of Bridgeport say there's a missing $40 million that he don't know where it went well the mayor certainly know where it went because these are the two audits carried out by the city which we got a clean belt of Health on in June 20 June 30th 2024 we got a

252clean bill of health that this firm did not say there's any million missing 4 million if this firm missed a a material action like that it should be raised up the purpose that I proposed this forensic audit for was not necessarily to find fraud now is there a possibility there may be some may or may not be some that we uncover maybe is it likely no the purpose of this forensic order is even if we could find 1 to 2% efficiencies every 1% of efficiency we can find within our budget translates to approximately $3 million so if we find 2% we find $6 million in operating efficiencies and it's also to help us Shore up our internal controls now if you read the report of the if you read the if you read the report

253of the audit to the extent discussed and within the parameters that the city set they found no problems with our internal controls but over the last year we've had the same entity in charge of contracts in charge of Personnel in charge of hiring we've got several things we need to tighten up on because we haven't seen contracts we got contracts with six months payouts that the board never seen we've got policies that were never approved policies on contracts that were never approved of the board as per the current existing policies we need to find a way to ensure this never ever happens again and I think outside entity looking at it looking at this will be very beneficial to us and it will pay for itself even if the city doesn't pay and I personally

254I think the city should um join up with us and we look at the whole all the whole books of the entire city and the state because if um mayor Joe ganam thinks this $40 million his orderers didn't cover uncover in our $300 million budget what about the city's $600 million budget what did they miss there and as far as um we could also look into the mayor's allegations of hiring friends and family I don't I don't know anybody's friends and family in there but it might behoove us to have them look for which friends and family were hired and if they're not qualified we send them packing so I mean I mean I think it was highly irresponsible for that false narrative to be put by the mayor and the only way we Conta

255contradict that is through an audit by an outside entity not the same one that has audited the books for the past 10 years thank you Miss Baptist forz all right quick question who's paying for the audit we don't know yet it's just the RFP okay and how far back is the audit supposed to go how far back would you like the audit to go that hasn't really been discussed extensively but I was do it should be at least three to five years and and how much does a forensic districtwide audit cost about approximately with the ballpark well it it will be over I'm assuming it'll be over $100,000 because last time we put it out we put out $100,000 cap and we got no return but as I said the return on an investment even

256if 1% we're talking about $3 million so even if we pass this motion to have an audit we don't have the funds to actually conduct it or necessitate further Cuts oh you turned off sorry I see Dr AB shaken said I don't know if he's tired of me which he probably is or if he's shaking his head yes that he agrees with me it can be actually both at this point it's can someone clarify because the record doesn't read headshakes odds Dr go ahead it's probably going to be in the 200 to $300,000 you know price tag uh but again we don't we haven't discussed exactly how that's going to be I think Mr kic has made a made mention that we would ask the city for the cost uh to take over the cost

257but there's no guarantee for that either and so wasn't that putting the cart before the horse I mean we're fighting tooth and nails for for these cuts and that somehow we would have to theoretically come up with the funds if the city doesn't I'm not opposed to the audit but uh is it $300,000 to look at the prior year or is it $300,000 look per year and so that's a that's a answer we don't know because if we're looking at five years and it's $300,000 per year you multiply that and that's about 1.5 million I would just ask that we secure the funds uh in advance know that there's some commitment from the state uh from the city ask the state while we're at it like I would rather have the funds secure the parameters

258secure as to what we're looking at um we may even have to post some additional guidelines so that airp s funds are not convoluting the audit that we're looking at and so um again I'm not opposed to the audit is just uh moving forward for something right now when we're cutting such critical roles it just it I see how it can be helpful but if we're looking at the audit for a Learning lesson we should probably do it after we've taken care of our initial Cuts or like offs do you want to answer question oh yes and then I'll get to you um yeah as I said it's an invest let's say the $300 $300,000 number is accurate and we find 1% of savings that's $3 million the reason why it's imperative that we move

259quickly with without regard to funding is because our fee process turnaround time takes at least three to six months for bids to come back and for us to approve them and then we could um look at the funding piece after now this is an investment there's very few Investments we can make as a board of education that could actually have a positive impact so let's let's say the low end comes in that we've achiev $1 million in suggested savings that don't require any Cuts just just efficiencies that's $3 million we do not have to cut in the in the following fiscal year so it's a wise investment investment that needs to be made quickly in order to find these operating efficiencies and other efficiencies where we may find some funds to stop the bleeding Mr

260tror yeah I guess the question that I have is is for the sake of this motion there is no expense involved is there so to put out the RFP we're not spending any money it's so the questions that are being asked now are if we do get uh a a a proposal from a bidder then we need to decide whether it's worthwhile spending the money but for tonight's motion all we're doing is deciding to put out the request the rfps so can we call the question and look there's a point of clarification this is normally a Mr pyus question I don't see he's on line oh hey to Mr pyus uh don't we have to put the amount that we're seeking to pay any organization on the actual request to see if they're going to

261um for lack of a better term take the bid uh good evening yeah yes there is a section of the RFP that requires us to divulge whether or not the money has been budgeted for uh and where the money is coming from for the uh to pay for the service and it also requires us to put some some sort of a range of of an amount we we can leave it blank if you like but uh we would definitely disclose if it's budgeted or not I don't have the floor but that's a critical fact is that and I've seen it before is that we normally have to and just to further clarify Mr pyz if it's blank and in your experience does that encourage people to go forward with this type of RFP well they'll

262they'll generate some questions and we can certainly say look you know just give us a proposal and and then and we'll see where it lands but um you know it'll limit it the amount of respondents that we will get in my in my professional opinion thank you Mr chamber do you have any your mic's still on that's why yes no I I I'd like to call the question all right you need two is there anybody else who wants to say anything read okay you second that all right all in favor to call the question say I I any abent or NOS any extensions all right so we're ending debate we're going to take a vote on this does anybody want to like amend it to put a number if not we'll take the vote m

263b you have your you want we we can just make a statement that it's budgeted the operating budget we don't have to put a number on it and then we'll see what kind of response we get once we have the values re in the response then we can make a determination as to whether or not it's affordable whether you want to proceed whether you're not want to proceed whether you want to solicit those funds from from another source uh we might want to go to the city afterwards saying look you know we have a response it's a half a million dollars do you want to chip in do you want to pay for it okay there's GNA be a roll call that all sounds good Mr pyrus one minute um Mr sovic go to the

264vote go to the vote okay Mr benan oh that was a yes sorry oh you're saying doing the roll call now we're doing the roll call you want you have something to say yeah yes go for it before you go no no no no I don't have anything to say was confused okay we're dooll call we're doing the roll callr Paris what did you say m oh sorry I am going to vote no at this time because we don't have the funds and I don't agree that we should say it's going to come from the operating budget I feel that's just as deceptive as posting jobs that we don't have any intent to hire the individual okay Shir Jenifer Paris um yes Jess s yeah yes Mr Robert tror yes Mr Woodson Mr William Medina

265yes Mr kameir yes Mr benan yes Carrie 62 is there any other business is there any other business there's been a motion to adjourn seconded by miss casir all in favor I any opposed all right have a great night the time is 10:47 e e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.