CorpusRecord 27053

Finance Committee Thursday, January 2 6:30 PM

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bridgeport Public Schools
Date
2025-01-03
Location
Greater Bridgeport Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,560 words · about 109 min
Collected
2026-06-04

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thank you good evening ladies and gentlemen this is a call to order for the first finance committee of 2025 this is Joseph sovic chair of finance committee in attendance we have Committee Member Mr Willie Medina board member Mr Rob tror see anybody online uh we got staff Mr Ino Dr Avery you other St um yes the first order of business is approval of minutes dated November 18 2024 so got a motion to be approved by Mr Willie Medina I shall second um I've read them and I see no issues with them I was was not a member at the time but I did attend the meeting and it appear to be in order do you have any issues with the changes of amendments okay so all in favor of approving the minutes dated of November

00218 iose motion carries down next item on the agenda is goals and objectives for the committee uh some copy then after I read them or anybody should feel free to add or subract from them tell me on my face we need to make this our own finance committee goals and objectives perspective goals and objectives for the 2025 finance committee are as follows the finance committee will endeavor to continue with the adjustments being made to the 2425 budget to reduce the overspending by prior administrations in order to be on more solid footing as we simultaneously prepare for fiscal year 2526 while the work of dealing with two fiscal years normally takes 18 months the committee will seek to accomplish this task in less than seven months which will include tens of millions in potential cuts the

003committee shall be mindful of our fiduciary Dy to properly vet the budget and amend any proposals and ensure that taxpayer dollars are used to carry out the educational mandates of the state the committee shall look at any Cuts in a holistic manner with an eye towards equity and not just see the people in front of us who Advocate but we will consider those who are not privileged enough to be able to use their voice the committee shall understand that this is a board of education and each and every cut hurts children and we shall Endeavor to limit that hurt as much as possible committee should be mindful that every job is important and these are people behind those positions that their work is useful even though the jobs may have to be cut the committee

004should be prepared for some hard work and incredible responsibility and realize that while we work hand inand with the superintendent in Partnership and creating the budget that the ultimate responsibility and decision is in our hands thank you and I'll open up the floor for some thoughts Mr TR any thoughts I'll move on to step I guess I guess not afraid Mr Medina trying to think how I want to focus it I'm still reading as I want to say there is heavy emphasis on cuts and I understand the reason why that we're looking at a 39 to $40 million deficit um and so most normal human beings would say we probably are going to have to make some Cuts this year I get it um but our our goal as as a board is to come

005up with a balanced budget will that involve Cuts well in around the room any sane human being would say yeah unfortunately probably so and we are working on cuts and trying to make some cuts and Savings in the in the B budget that was inappropriately passed this past spring of 2024 when we were not allowed to participate in the making of a budget um and that's what we're trying to address right away um and I get that but there is an undue emphasis in my opinion in this goals and objectives on cut cut cut cut cut and I get it but I'd also like us to focus the positive and I'd like the public to focus and understand that our focus is on how to get more resources uh focused on the needs of our

006children um and there are elected officials in the city and in the state who need to be devoting more resources to the children of our city who have neglected their responsibilities in that area and so I would like us just to recognize in whatever we do whether it's this committee or the board as a whole that everything that we can do to further that goal is going to be in any of our committees or actions so I think that you know without having had a chance to see this until two minutes ago and I must say I haven't even completely read it yet I just heard that word cut a lot um and a lot too much for me because while I re recogniz the importance of being honest and realistic with people and not

007misleading people and that's what we're trying to do is be honest with the public we also want to focus on the need to hold folks accountable who have not been held accountable to the children of our city and frankly cities throughout the state of Connecticut but we're focusing on the children of City of Bridgeport thank you uh you rais a good point um as far as accountability we can that happens at election time we've try that in various ways but your point being that there does need to be an emphasis on a positive because there are some steps we can take and this is an oversight on my port because it's in my head it goes without saying but it doesn't go without saying within the community we need to advocate for more money we

008need to have a strong advocacy plan which is actually part part of my goals and objectives which never made it to writing and thank than you for pointing that out so how about how about adding this so the board will endeavor to create a strong advocacy plan in order to avoid as many of these Cuts as possible good would staff like to weigh in on any of this for me again I I just received these a couple minutes ago as well I didn't know exactly what you know um I think there needs to be a stronger emphasis on the collaboration between Administration and the board committees in order to draft the proposals for uh what we're looking at on the finance side I understand historical perspectives that the board has uh emphasized I mean when

009you look at these goals and objectives you know it it does emphasize historical perspective but I think you know all fairness to you know this current Administration trying to understand and provide guidance to the board regarding Financial ways of being able to um you know fill that Gap you know and we had a comment earlier when you said it's our job as Administration to provide the Gap saving you know plan but there's a there also is a possibility where the board could change that plan and we respect that I think that's part of you know the uh the process that we go through on a day-to-day basis even when we propose policy or to the board the board is the ultimate ones that pass policy but our job is to provide a an Avenue to

010get the work done uh and uh I think we need to make sure that we can balance that a little bit because I think sometimes staff feels you know there's no um consideration for the work that we put in to get the options out to the board when it comes to financial uh what in any of the Committees so I think we have to I think join forces a little bit better and understand the work that's being done and the work that's going to be provided uh and collaborate a little bit more uh and I think that's something that we are are getting ready to start doing to talk a little bit more about you know what's the goal of the Committees you know the finance the policy the Personnel facility we're gonna we're having

011individual meetings with Administration and and the board chair to kind of iron that out a little bit more so I think that's coming uh but again I think this is this is a good first start to be able to look at you know um how we're going to move forward and and the goals for each committee is important as well so again and this is a tough one because we are in the state where we am right now so again I'm hoping that we're going to be able to flush things out a little bit to to really come to a good agreement to propose some things that and they maybe get away from the cut piece uh but we know ultimately that's going to be a good portion of you know trying to recoup $38

012million you're gonna have to do something on the Personnel side and so um that's important so again any other staff member you you guys or you follow at that amount on point do I need to clarify Neer would well as far as I'm concern as far as I'm concerned um the board has due diligence to to fulfill but they also have to realize and recognize you have professionals here with years of experience I mean uh 30 40 35 38 years of experience doing it with a proven track record um with precision and medal mistakes we could make in our career as young people so we're delivering precisely I'm not here to guess whatever I put out there I know where it's going to land I don't shoot to miss I don't second guess I've done

013it been there done that in a bigger scale what has to in my opinion or recommendation take the prop personal recommendation I mean I'm not here for politics know fairness and you know bluntness to everyone I'm here to deliver and do a professional job balance the School District budget in a feasible workable Manner and a productive manner not just put a patch to it but give a permanent solution to stabilizing the bricko school district finances yes thank you and and I'm with you on that and I really appreciate everybody's thoughts and concerns and although your professional isms your careers your education is definitely well respected but when any board member or any member of the community has a question it's not a personal attack on your education it's not an attack on your credentials because

014a budget is a reflection of the values of a community and that's what we nine board members represent we represent the community and it's the community's vision for Education that ultimately should carry the day to to to a certain extent not not not to like get crazy out there but we are elected and put in these seats to implement the wishes of the community and educational interest in the state as our decision making so that respect has to go two ways that you also got to respect that the board members are reflecting the community and if those are some if the Community Values are somehow superseded well we all see what can happen if that happens so because the community is in the driver's seat by electing us we are their representatives you you guys

015got your representatives we hire the superintendent he hires everybody else so there's always always that Dynamic that's going to exist but should be one with mutual respect for each and every one of us in our roles but we just got to understand where we all stand in those roles that the community is the board supervisor the board is the superintendent supervisor and the superintendent is everybody else's supervisor and it's the community that drives me to a certain extent sometimes the community might have not not such a good idea like I see a couple members here it's not such a good idea for youall to be sitting at home and not paying attention right now because we need you out there to come out here and advocate for some funding so we could avoid all these

016Cuts Because by the time the community gets out here and says oh we're cutting this we're cutting that it's too late it's too late you're going to be too late again we got the budget going up to harer right now so we need to start the advocacy piece at the very next meeting be discussing there anything else Mr tror in uh paragraph four um the committee uh shall look at any Cuts in a holistic manner with an eye towards Equity might I recommend that you make that look at any budget might I recommend that you say the committee shall look at any budget H which might include Cuts in a holistic manner since it would we would want the whole budget to be looked at and the all is you know to include Equity okay

017I know you do I know you do this is It's again this focus on cuts it is the budget we want to have Equitable be Equitable and that would include Cuts but we want the whole budget to be equitable and we want the whole budget to be looked at equitably for the whole city so that all neighborhoods are represented fairly and equitably and I know you agree with that so I'm I'm not making that recommendation for any other this is not something that gets approved anyway this is just yes something to get us started to get everybody on the same page focus a statement of purpose or a mission statement type thing yes I get it if there's nothing else on this move on to the piece of the agenda items fisical year 2425 condition

018report Mr Quote us brief update or I'll um I'll pass on what I have passed on before a continuation I can't see is okay um chair I'm going to go over the um Financial condition report which was published it's on the website it's on the bridgeboard public website it was given to the board we talked about it I'm going to go over it again based on the projections the year end projection meaning where we see ourselves the bridgew financial district next year the gross what they call the gross deficit the overall deficit is projected at $38 million however we are going to get some credit from the grants different grants we have in the city in the amount of 36.5 million so the revised deficit is going to be $32 million out of that revised

019deficit of $32 million what we had proposed the superintendent and I which was presented to the board is to use $14 million of the internal service fund which is the rainy day fund um just for clarity the board adopted current year budget 2024 2025 budget with the assumption that they're going to use $26 million of the internal service fund let me explain what internal service fund means it means the rainy day fund which does not get replenished once it's gone is gone once you spend it it's spent not getting replenished not especially not when you're running a deficit so it's my recommendation which I recommended to the board is not to use the 26 million rather let us use $14 million and try to streamline the operation or the ex the operation or the excess

020or through downsizing of the district current year budget or operations by doing operational account free meaning all discretionary spendings will be frozen unless it's extremely important all conferences employee conferences could be done should be attended through Zoom through Zoom or through team meeting and not you know traveling to California coming back with a between hotels and everything with a $5,000 bill for conference so that's that's the proactive approach we we have taken I sent an email to all border employees instructing everyone all the employees that all conferences out of state or hotel conferences have been frozen I don't even approve those request anymore and fortunately people have gotten condition to it so nobody's even in those request in anymore that's just as simple as that so we're going to review all the discretionary expenses and

021some internal operational things we have to do in order to make sure that the house is air tight and no more Lecky roofs if you want to put it that way so then we propos some positions that we hired with s money s money is grant money when we received $144 million grant money to be spent over four years that Grant has expired basically we have to let we have to let those employees go because their funding sources have expired when an employee is hired from a grant money the employee should be let known or the employees are generally they generally are informed that their recruitment to hiring or retention is based on continued grant funding that if the grant is not renewed you don't have a job so the employee be very aware of

022it I mean don't get me wrong some people have been hired on a renewable Grant and done 35 years one that same Grant or an alternative Grant so I'm not trying to say here but everybody knew that covid money was going to be short lived and has shortlived it has expired funding is no longer there so we have to downsize back to our original funding um which is basically laying off all those you know downsizing those positions and scaling things back in order to be fully functional but teachers are not being affected just for clarity specialized services are not being affected just for clarity uh we provide the essential need needed services for our brick for children those are not being affected uh what's being affected are mainly more of administrative higher administrative level positions

023and some positions that we hired just to catch up in fixing some of the you know infrastructures in the school that were neglected so those Services have been fulfilled and accomplished so there's no need for all those retain of all those cost or extra burden if you want to put it that way so based on that we still have with all those assumptions the superintendent and I have implemented the $3.5 million in operational savings the measures we feel comfortable we are going to attain that $3.5 million savings before the end of the fiscal year which ends June 30th there is a $10.3 million that downsizing Personnel downsizing reorganization of personnel realignment of personnel it comes in different forms which the board has to approve we set out a plan we gave the plan to the

024board the board has to approve it has to be approved if you ask me like yesterday every day every week of delay people are getting paid and we're bleeding basically spending money that we could use to bance next year budget the Board needs to act fast like yesterday let me be very honest and blunt with everyone time is of essence so there's $1.3 million on the table that the board has to act on act on and act on fast or else we're going to use next money we're going to use to balance next year budget to balance this year budget just for everybody's Clarity the district the bridport school district or the school district by state law cannot should not run a deficit at the end of the year at the end of the fiscal

025year neither can the board approve a budget next year next year budget with a deficit what I mean a deficit is it's not plugging in a number you just don't pick a number of the air and say you're going to balance it with $10 million without subst Shing it you just don't pick a number of the air and I I will assure everyone I next on your call will not put a number that is not feasible I have my C certificate on the line I'm a certified Chief Financial Officer I have four degrees higher degrees I am not putting my certification on the line if it's not valid just for everybody's clarity Mr questions um yeah just one I just wanted to make sure I put that put it in the record if my understanding

026is correct we had a budget this year set for by the previous superintendent for $39 million what you're saying with this uh I'll ask the simplest turn what is the projected uh expenditure that was we were heading to for the end of June according to that budget it's going to be $6 million more than what the than what the board adopted but let the board be bear in mind that number that they adopted that budget they adopted $26 million of that it's a one-time Revenue source so for all practical purpose Financial the board adopted an unbalanced budget practically in a practical man yes thank you Mr tror um I understand what you just said which was essentially that in the spring the 300 9 million budget was balanced by spending $26 million of our savings

027that is that is correct um and now uh there's an additional $6 million in expense that have come up can you explain where that additional $6 million in in expenses came from again we we should be aware of is a combination of different factors again special education is a troubling area we don't the district doesn't have control over it because out of placement the state has mandated the state made put up a law what you call unfunded State mandates relative to special education they make the law that you have to do this every child that needs help or challenge or whatever you want to call it that needs special attention you have to have a onet toone t which is an adult with a child in the class but the state is not giving the

028district the money to fund those mandates so we have we don't have a choice but to abide by the state law that's not all it there is also Transportation increase special education Transportation increase in addition to that which we don't have control over because of the placement of these special education students out of the district they have to be transported some of then get transported to Bessel one way back and forth and to very honest with you whether the child decides to go to school that day or not the district is bound to pay for that Transportation whether the child boards the bus or not because we have a contract the the bus company is fulfilling their contract it happens that's not all there were some positions to answer your question and no way there

029are some positions that were you know hired or recommended uh that was not you know quite approved by the board but those things all those things again this is not a pointed place or time for blame like I said from the beginning we are here I'm here it wasn't you know I'm here to really Rectify whatever that was done wrong if anything was G wrong well actually Mr Nico um we would like to know where that six million doll additional expense came from and I recognize I do recognize that some of that are increased unanticipated costs especially in the area of special ed which I hear you say um and accept that as a general area that we all can say whoa special ad and then throw woof huge amount of money in there but

030that doesn't answer my question as you know that just gives us a general I can explain a little bit for you well you can I know you can in one second but I want to be more specific in my question there is a specific accounting which is due to this board of where that $6 million is what it is if it's 1.2 million in specialed transportation costs I get it if it's 1 million 1.5 million in special ed um no um program costs I get it um but that counting has to be provided to the board we want to see that if it's 5 100,000 in additional administrative costs that were spent without a board of approval we want to see that um so we we ultimately do need to see that because it should

031have gone before this board at some point and never did now that's not trying to blame it is trying to be accountable as we should have been all along um and um that's all I'm asking because an overrun of six million in a budget that was already in our opinion way fatter than it should have been um we need to see well I mean um and so as we make the decision to trim we want to make sure that we're trimming in the areas that it ought to be trimmed um and so that's part of what we're looking at so I'm sorry superintendent go ahead let me let me explain because part of my proposal that I res to the board back in December and when you look at the tier one Staffing those positions

032were hired probably within the last year or year and a half $3 million worth of those positions are the the assistant principles that that was placed on this proposal for consideration that the board delayed a little bit so $3 million of of that $6 million was noted in this presentation that I provided so that's that's a big chunk of it uh if you look back at the last proposal that I presented to the board uh the positions that 2911 yes sir 486 yes sir yes sir that that dollar amount that $3 million I just I just rounded it all up a little bit most of the positions that are listed here was added in the last year as well and and so I'm sorry superintendent not those that's really and so I guess what I

033want see at some point as a board member and I'm I'm Mr sakal if I'm going too far in your committee you'll stop um is that in your presentation which was how we can save money in stages it was a it was a legitimate presentation on how we can save money in stages it sort of didn't tell us how we overspent the budget and so now I'm asking the question from the other point of view which is where was it and I hear you that's a you that was that's an excellent answer that okay so 2. 911 486 was for those additional APS that the superintendent chose to add on and you know we all as we agreed that in the end all we could really save this year was about $20,000 so we weren't

034going to save anything this year by eliminating those positions right now right now at the end of the year in the summer we eliminate those positions and we're done and those people may or may not stick around if there's openings in the turnover Etc we get that so we're there but it's worth it to know that that was that and what other administrative positions where we have that conundrum of contractual obligation to pay a higher salary even if they bump down into a lower pay position we would it's still worth it for us to see where that adds up to $6 million in money that we didn't budget for when we voted for a budget last spring um and so we just we know it I I I get it I see it we know

035it and so we can we we understand that yeah when you look at the dollar amount the $6 million most of those POs they they're Staffing positions uh you know that were added so that's how you're going to get majority of your that $6 million is Staffing that was hired within the last year or so so when you look at and the total tier one savings were 6.8 so if you're telling me that that's most of it you know I just want to know that yes sir that is it that is it that is that is that is most of it but that's not all of it okay so that's all I want to know because frankly none of that except for a few positions is sped true too true too and and what nessar

036was talking about is the ex the excess cost of special Act and that's a Hot Topic around Connecticut anyway so huge so we can't and I and I I made note to we can't say that because that's not that's not included in this budget proposal right you know so I'm not even considering that I know there's it's in the back of my head that it's there but I'm talking about Staffing remember 80% of this budget 80 to 85% of any School District budget is Staffing and so the only way you're gonna cut and get money for is going down the line to the Staffing process and that's kind of what we're doing and that's what we're going to have to get deeper into as we work through this budget process so uh great question you

037know6 million over see it the different way because he's explaining we went six million over a budget that we didn't get to talk much of we tried but we didn't get to talk much about last spring so we want to sort of understand what that means can I ask one other question Mr chair um uh the um uh the savings that we began at the last board meeting okay are not reflected in this I'm sorry savings related to which items well we we passed savings at the last board meeting the step the first step in in what is going to be a process that you want us to move faster than we're moving okay of savings this is this this document that you gave us tonight is the document that you gave us before so

038I'm just wondering how much did we chip away at in in your presentation you I know it's not enough it's not fast enough and enough for you and I get that I I feel no insult by you saying that no but I was just curious what what what little bit did we Chip Away by what we did last time from your point of view in this document the savings that the board passed was tier one which was $6.8 million minus $3 million in assistant assistant principles that got deferred so we saved about three million it's about but again that three million has not been implemented because we haven't laid off the employees it have to lay it have to send them it's a process but by the time it kicks in and fully implemented you're

039probably going to save about four months of salary if you're lucky four month of the 3 million which is what which would be how much sir about 2 about $2.3 million but again very excuse me bear in mind that $2.3 million I don't for me it's okay to you know I mean I can reflect when we do the October the December Financial condition report it will be reflected but again with all due respect we said dropp in the bucket okay how big is that dropped can you give me an idea I just told you $2.3 million out of the what we're looking for which is you're estimating 2.3 million yeah okay I just I'm trying to understand the magnitude and and the so I'm just trying to get and and and the public who is

040listening whether they're going to watch this meeting later or they're here tonight with other few people here tonight with us need to understand we can't just be speaking in in general big overwhelming terms we need to begin to understand so me as a board member or somebody in the public who's listening and concerned has to understand what the reality is that you're seeing that's it thank you and and and I appreciate you've been clear to that I think that's that's important I mean being able to understand okay what do we save we only save $2.3 million in in the things that we have thus far we spent hours going through this list and everybody heard the the the magnitude and the human drama of this list yes but in the Great picture of what we're

041trying to accomplish what did we really accomplish with regard to savings this year and then you just put a dollar figure on it thank you very much that's all I want to because we we we're still looking at contractual things that have to be the bumping rights of Contra all those things are in play as well we got work to do L we got a lot of work to do I'm what Mr tror says um to that end I would like to create like an updated presentation at every board meeting how much Cuts we got in it perhaps um some sort of bar chart with a filling going towards our goal of we need $ 36 million that's right fill in right now I got it filled in with 2.3 million and to go yeah

042but and right right yeah like like like a goal like a a visual goal people do very well with visuals and the community we got we got this we we got this much to go to get to our goal and also um it also took payback um I'm quite Disturbed hearing for the very first time that we superseded the $39 million authorized budget now we saying we don't cast blame we don't cast blame but there are nine members of the board myself included and my fellow board members who sat here and approved a $39 million budget who were circumvented without any knowledge coming to now say a $315 million budget is now being expended without our authorization that is very troubling and concerning especially as we go forth trying to get people to advocate for

043more money so we could avoid some of these Cuts we need to regain this community's trust and in order to do that we need a flashlight up our backsides to see what in fact happened where the breakdown was what happened to our internal controls what happened to the board having to authorize line item transfers where is all of that why were we asleep as a board at the switch for the last year I mean we we we're going before Harford for accountability I hope they asked them some of those questions why did you guys approve what you were approved why did you guys have so little discussion on a $39 million budget and I hope I and I hope I answer when Dr Avery and guys get up there that you explain to the state

044when not we're operating that way going forward we will rectify the mistakes of the past we are looking into how those mistakes were made how these controls slipped by the community yes we should be accountable and and there's another agenda item we could get this into this a little deeper afterwards but I I just got to say just here for the first time tonight that we $6 million over budget potentially over budget because it hasn't all been expend we're trying to correct and I agree with that 100% um now also to Mr travers's point I would like to see a breakdown of the line items that did go over budget projected versus actual at the next meeting if you can put that together that would be great so we can start getting a handle on

045what went wrong and where um so much gu I Che for my original question all right now um You you mentioned the people who took jobs under grants uh it's understood that their jobs will be excessed after the grant funding runs out and I really got no no issue with that but we leave it out a very important part Grant funded positions could shift to operational Force fed programs could shift to operational costs so if we're just looking at extra funded positions in cutting we're cutting a social worker in place of a staff member up top who may be being paid from operational course so we got to look at all these things that paid for just say the grand fund position is gone forever we could find savings for everyone else the goal of

046the committee should be also I'm not sure if I mentioned that or not to keep the cuts as far far away from the classroom as possible as a as a very very last resort yes give me give me I got you you'll get a chance Mr Nicole those those cuts go to stay far away from the P yeah we got to keep the cuts from the classroom as much as possible the grant like like for instance kbe is under title for it's not on the operational cost but there are several other things that money could be spent on some psychosocial and other things we got to keep in mind that just because something is grandf funded now I totally agree the SOP funded positions actually should be some of the first to go before anything

047else but in a TI approach to your top round top down so that that being said is it's not just okay to say that's funded by a grant and everything goes away it still needs to be discussed what else could be funded with a grant is this position beneficial to shift over to operating cost and drop something else off of operational cost that might hurt the children less that might hurt the taxpayer less that's where our fiduciary duties lie what's the least harm we could do through these budget cuts yes you may respond now please Mr chair when I say a grand position being unfunded it we do into interrelate between operating budget and Grant positions I I just want to make that clear wherever we can if we get some additional grant money additional

048Grant award what we do we shift positions from the operating budget into the grant to the extent that the grant guidelines allow so that we do if we weren't getting more grants or shifting operational Personnel to the grant funded grant funding believe it the operating budget will be in more need and much more deficit the Personnel sheets that you were given the board members were given as far as these Cuts is inclusive of management positions that are funded through grants so it's all in inclusive this is not just operating budget just for clarity this is all B employees except Nutrition Center so just for clarity it's inclusive some of these assistant principles are paid with grant money so what's going to happen when we downsize back to original the monies that are being paid with

049we're going to move employees from the operating budget into the grants and pay them from the grants so people will understand it's kind of a flip-flop at the end of the day it's still the same Financial effect yes okay thank you thank you for that Clarity yes um versus now um something Mr trayor mentioned it's been mentioned a couple of times by our various staff members as well the savings is 2.3 .3 for the year um blah blah blah but this budget is not only for this year these cuts are not only for this year these downsizing is not only for this year this is going to flow through the district going forward and eventually the tier one total savings will save the district 75 $7.5 million and instead of a $39 million budget needed

050in say 2728 it'll be a three well it's not 309 is not even good anymore um it be $7 million less of a need in that year so this is a living breathing document that affects each and that's that's why I say when we got to look at things holistically this this this is the holistic approach it's not just this year's savings and it's going to compound over time we going to make us a leaner meanor meaner is actually a proper word District unfortunately but the savings and so so we can't just look at oh it's only going to save us $2,000 this year we can't make this cut we got to think of the future going forward three years as well as far as deficits and as well and um as far as state

051mandates um yeah with all give me a minute I got you um St mandates I definitely we definitely need to have all mandates funded um it's St this it's it's it's hard like I said special education does have overages a lot of years sometimes it was um I know a former CFO used to like put a little cushion about 5 to 10% of unexpected costs and we would come under budget in that area so I'd be likely I would love to see the projected versus the actual on those costs to date because I I I I pretty much know Miss seagull will keep like a five to 10% cushion for those over overages and part of that initially those costs if I'm not mistaken I could be wrong but I'm not lying intentionally but some

052of those costs flowed into the internal service funds preco dollars some some some of those costs that she left as a cushion would be transferred over to the pre-co coures if I if I'm wrong correctly through the chair U for those who do not know uh I was the I was the budget director for the city of bridgew I've worked for the city for quite years so I wasn't no I was handling the I basically was booking the internal service fund meaning the health insurance fund for Board of Education and the city I was literally doing the whole thing the first time that board of education had a surplus in internal service fund was when Essa came into play when Essa funds were provided B never that were actually def in their health insurance account

053what you call the what you call the ibnr for those who know accounting ibnr incured but not reported meaning incured but not reported in accounting it means that an expense has been incured but it has not been reported an employee could be walking and tripped they have incured that expense it workers come expense they've incured it they can tell their boss that they fell they tripped that liability is there that's why it's called him cured but not reported in accounting that liability is there the district owns that liability the employee can down the road 5 years down the road I said guess what you remember that slip that I said I had it came back I'm going on workers count it's very funny but that's just the way it works that's why it's called IBN

054incur but not reported accounting you have to make provision for that liability whated was very deficient in funding that but with the EXA money they caught up and ended up with a surplus in the interal service fund so what I'm trying to say is the internal service fund subplus you have today don't expect it reoccurring oh no are you saying that the the Board of Ed had not set aside the money to cover those incurred but not nope not enough they were deficient okay that's what I'm that was my question sir was is the board of Ved had failed to set aside the sufficient funds to cover those possible costs and those possible costs were determined by fiduciary by the O by the o the Auditors by the Auditors and the by the workers comp

055Auditors yes and theist and so in on because of those AUD Auditors determinations of potential liabilities we were technically in AAR but it's not you were in AAR but it's what it no no I I get it we were technically in because there was the possibility of liability yep we were not in a rear as we're as as any common person would know it no no no we were in a rear because there was the potential liability that is corre so it's sort of like me saying in if my wife gets cancer in 10 years she might cost us more than we could ever afford yeah but if she doesn't we're all right doesn't that is correct okay again just to be clear for any of us plain folk sitting in the room the technicalities

056of these I I get you I I I was a union president for many years I know what you're talking about but I'm just saying in terms of the Board of Ed actually covering its costs the Board of Ed had covered its its actual year-to-year day-to-day costs and had set aside its money into the internal savings fund yes um we just there was now there has been controversy for years between the Board of Ed and the city that you are aware of as to who was covering what cost in insurance and workers come I know there has been controversy I've heard about it myself through my position with the Union so I'm not going to try and dig that all up now but I'm just saying you're saying that in the past until Esther got

057here we were never in proper balance f you weren't youly we weren't fully ound weren didn't we weren't meeting our obligations didn't fully fund I got I got you now let me make let me make it clear here it's not just Board of Education the city side also did not fully fund their own I got you I got you so I don't want meanwhile meanwhile I don't want to get too Tech in the meanwhile without going back through too much fin accting accounting history yeah but just for clarity the state of connect is deficient to the turn of almost $3 billion billion I see the smoking numbers coming off the top of Mr scal ex said as he's going through this right now no no no the state the state is deficient he's more of

058an accountant than I am the state is deficient in funding their ibnr to the turnone of almost $3 billion so it's not it's an accounting terminology what we're trying to just look at is the 309 million plus 6 million3 15 million that we budgeted in terms of real life expenses we were going to incur this past year absolutely um not those I understand why they're real concerns of potential liabilities we might incur because somebody filed a w30 form whatever it is which is the form of worker files when they have an accident of work MH and if they never God willing in you know ever come down with a bad back or a bad you know nothing ever happens and we never incur any liability I get it that is C so and Willie gets

059it too because he was Indian president too um so we get that but right now let's deal with the realm of just the $15 million budget that the superintendent has to deal with um right now PJ getss it too because he's a local president too really you got a few you got a few Union presidents here that have dealt with this issue okay Joe you are you done looking at whatever you were digging through I'm digging up I got the 1920s I gotta go back into 1819 because I'm sure we had a small we transferred five million in fiscal year 1920 1920 correct to 2020 20 19 fiscal year 19 to 2020 that's that was the first year s funding but ESS didn't hit until what 2019 to 20120 correct 21 and ESS Esser didn't

060come in until the following year so we had a $5 million balance it's reflected in the books so we can't we can't I hope these books aren't wrong 192020 fiscal condition as of you're looking at Katherine what are you looking at K I'm looking at our books that have been ordered by the city this that's the audit right and it says transfer to Boe ISF on reserve in the 1920 2020 19 19 2020 budget year okay this was5 million 66 No 5 million 66 as they look at those numbers I just wanted to add to to everyone um that's listening for the simp for us simpler folks like myself I will say myself nobody else for me um just want to make clear that this budget that the superintendent and now the new chair and

061the new chairs of committees this was inherited from the old superintendent and the old leadership of the chair and the old leadership of the chair of the Personnel contracts committee um some of the oversight that was done this is something that we're going to look at myself and my colleagues and the rest of the board we're going to be looking at intensely with the help of the leadership team and uh the committee that I I've been uh put as chair and policies and Personnel to make sure that this won't happen again that um hires and and this overspending uh was not done by the full board this you guys can look at the minutes and you going look at the meeting this was not presented to the whole board uh so myself uh Mr sakovic

062Mr trayor uh believe believe also Albert Ben here we're not part of that committee or we're not let spoke to speak in that committee and hold these people accountable and nothing was brought to the board so I take it very personal when people say the board because I'm part of the board if something happened in committee it happened in committee and is not include the entire board um things are going to get fixed when that we're going to have uh you know meetings to look at these policies look at these instructions to make sure that this will not happen again and this is our responsibility me as chair will be taking a look at that it's going to be a lot of work we're going to need the community's help you know this collabor collaboration

063that we've been talking about is board member to board member it's also the executive leadership team with the board members it's also the staff with the board members it's also the community with the board members you know and then we can look at it even to say with the city city council members and the city and the board members and then even to the top leadership and our mayor with the board members this is why I became a board member this is why I passionately went for this with some of the others to build Bridges to collaborate because this is a a whole city issue and also a whole State issue that we're having with this funding that's why I challenged the leadership team before and said I don't want to hear so much about

064what's going on right now tell me what is the number that we need to go over to the state as a collaborative group with the state and with our city to go over and say you know what we need this to stay afloat you know because we need a number to go up and say we need to fight that way we this situation could rectify with not having all these cuts that we are might be foreseeing because we got to make sure we hold oursel accountable to the budget that we have but also that we can ask for help there's no shame in asking for help and making sure that the funds are allocated to the specific uh areas that it's needed but the state is not going to look if we're not ready so

065that's why I challenge our Administration to say listen I need a number to collaborate with other people to go up to the state and say bridport needs this amount right now that way we can start making the effective need and that way it's not directly affect the classroom as much as it could be I just had a specific question let me just pick back for a minute off I want to stay on point give me a minute okay well I was on point with you about the money yes can I can I do a clarifying Mr P I appreciate you clarifying that I think that's important uh and we will get you that number uh we're going to be able to provide a number for you to make sure that we as we Advocate just

066like you know uh Mr cic said when we Advocate we're going to have that number uh but I think I think the other part of that when you guys talk about you know the board the full board wasn't there some of the people on around my administrative table wasn't involved in those decisions either so I want to put that on the record as well we're trying to provide a fix uh and the best educational fix that we can provide the board moving forward that's what we're doing and we're going to work this thing together it's not going to be an easy thing easy task but we can we can work our way out of this thing but we have to do it together collaborate and I think we're going to be able to do that

067uh and I'm willing to stand in front and and and take the bullets and do what I got to do to make it right you know but I need collaboration from everybody and um uh it's it's this is a tough gig man and I can tell you it's a tough gig and so I mean and you have to have I think I have a team that's going to be able to help do it you know but we we all have to feel that we're all a part of it just like you guys now feel that you're you're you're in the mix now and you're able to kind of make decisions we're going to help you do that and we're gonna get we're gonna lay the groundworks for you to make it happen so we're we're

068we we you know you can't be excited about it but you have to be otherwise it'll get you down uh and so we're trying to be in good spirits uh we know we have long hours to work we understand it we're going to have to do it raise the sleeves up and get it done and we're willing to do that with you guys so join forces is with us to help you do this I I agree 100% with you Dr Avery keep putting it where we're responsible for what we do going forward we are not responsible for the past we are we should be held accountable to any decisions we make in the future right that being said we do need to look back to make sure we don't repeat the mistakes of the past

069and part of that is going to involve looking at some of these numbers and we just went over the internal service fund again and there was there for my recollection there was always a small Surplus going forward due to cushions that were built into the into the budget so um that being said I would definitely like to see the budgeted special education versus the actual special education costs and see where see where that overage is because nor normally I believe there was always there always a small question because that number has always been volatile and I think in the last year if I'm not mistaken we got a higher percentage reimbursement rate for outer District placements than marene had projected for and which should improve the bottom line somewhat a little bit although we're sending

070more it might be a wash because we're sting more people out orc caring more cours so but but that's something the bear is looking at and and any we got to justify both budgets we got to justify that $6 million line by line if we have to I you know Bo like I said I'm willing to meet two three times a month four times a month as long as as much work as it takes I'm here to do it and I think the majority of the board is now here to do it and get to the bottom of things and make sure we don't repeat the same mistakes that we made in the past because as I said it's not only reflecting this year's budget it's reflecting the budgets going forward we as a district

071have Mr trayor yeah I just wanted to clarify the 2.3 million approximate that we anticipate savings from the cuts we've already made um is that an annualized amount or is that that we would save this year that's annualized so okay no no no no that's I it's important so when Mr cic was saying that it it you know it it each year it will compound I just wanted to know if if that wasn't annualized then the compounding would be greater obviously and so since it is annualized then it would be uh you know 4.8 million next year it would be on like that and so I just wanted to make sure I understood what we were compounding and so I get it that's all just want to make sure I understood thank you I I

072I think we got a good basically road map of what we need for the next meeting and going forward uh I would like to move on to the next agenda I know there's nothing else on this portion that's it we're going to's my agenda uh that was a conditional report discussion and possible referral to the full Board of additional position eliminations and programming Cuts in All Phases beginning with phase one I would like to begin this one with the position where we left off we did not cut it it was referred to committee it was I believe the position for for its District EV was that that position and I believe Mr pelowski has something to present to us no that light went on oh can't see it okay all right uh how would you

073like me to answer the question did you want me to discuss what the position provides or okay uh yeah yeah right yeah yeah yeah because the doar reason it wasn't excess is because nobody knew what the job does and if it's and how all jobs are critical but how critical and where does it fall on The Matrix in our decision-making process to keep Cuts away from the classroom as much as possible understood uh this position is the position that assists in managing the upkeep of uh the uh District infrastructure and that could include um our data centers our uh uh wireless network and things of that nature uh it it acts as the point person um it was a position that was created I want to say either just before covid or somewhere in that

074range um and uh it essentially was to assist in you know that specific area uh prior to that time period uh its only had a director and an assistant director prior to that um that initial position being open and or filled um who was doing that work uh so we honestly prior to that time period didn't have an infrastructure uh size in a way that um for lack of a better way of putting it uh couldn't be handled by uh the director and the assistant director so the idea was is that at the time that was the goal um and you know it was uh it was actually primarily the responsibility of the assistant director to do that and we still have an assistant director at this point we do yes we do are they

075able to still to do that work and to be assigned uh those duties because if the district needs that work being done someone needs to do it we just want to find out if you know yes how the team feel yeah I mean the assistant director will uh uh will be able to fulfill those duties um I I have no questions and to the who's occupies this position right now um like I got I gotta see the humanity of the position but these Cuts un necessary unfortunately therefore I'll make an motion I'll entertain a motion to refer ref to the full board to eliminate the position of its District infrastructure operations manager for a savings of $136,900 any further discussion all in favor pushing this stff for board I I motion cares thank you Mr

076P now continuing with this item um I would like to look take another look back at tier one uh before we move on to TI two and three this is um Su Drive can you pass tror please and these these were papers provided to us by um the quot at the last meeting I just shared the first page with some scribbles on it um because a lot of these positions are still there some executive positions and some of them were Crea post Esser and it would be um it would be irresponsibility me to move down before we finish at the top um okay the first item you'll see t920 we've got one additional principle what does that additional principle do where are they and what are their responsibili okay I'm do you have a copy

077of this yes it's principle is you got um Bisal year 2020 you got 27 we added one principal from 2020 to 2025 what is that principles duties I'm not I'm not 100% sure I see what you're saying there there was one principle that added between the 20 and 2025 I see the one position here in in the actual uh worksheet but again I don't know who exactly who that principal is if it's a principal that principal should be at a campus level right now so it should be one of the you know 29 campus you know principles that we have uh again it could have been a number of different and I wasn't here for that but is there a way that we can pinpoint who that one last principal is probably it's we can

078come back right what what I'm basically getting that is there one principal somewhere or POS we don't have any schools with two principles no no principal well that's principles there three different principles I don't we can research it was a it was the dean right it was a sorry it's three principles with one assistant principal at fch child wheeler it's the setup as the administrative you know task at fch child wheeler right I'm I'm pretty informal at the committee meetings if we're discussing something if somebody jumps in unless it's somebody's stepping on somebody else I'm not I'm not gonna disu conversation but I may tell you to hold up if I if I got a point or somebody else needs a point that I need to hear so uh if Dr Avery's comfortable with his

079staff speaking up and all that I'm I'm comtable with it as well yeah I'm good with that that one principle we can identify who that is and we can figure out where the location give you a little bit more detail on that yeah because if it's a principle on special assignment or something like that that not knowled that we don't know about got it that's something that could be looked at yes so so that's the first one if yall could look at look into that and get back to us at the next meeting yes sir all right now we got um I'm sorry Mr yeah um on the same same section under under the G total if you go down to um 00001 it states High School principal um it doesn't give me a number

080but it says seven to seven but there's an added that corate there's an added cost that's he Associated there or am I wrong um I I think I see what you do because I did the same thing if you add up the number of High School principles and the number of the other principles high school and Zer 28 on top no this the seven 77 seven plus the elementary and other principles I hold that specific is in high school though correct there were seven and 20 and seven and 25 so that a net of zero right there was not a change okay so so the the the 29 princip the 28 principles are just at elementary andeven the seven exctly Camp yes are we count are we counting the director of as a as a

081principle it's not it's not I was like I was getting more Central magnet not a principal the director of Aqua is is called director of of director of Aqua but it's a principal's position okay that's where Dave Henry used to be and Maggie is in that position right now uh and so it's it's the same as a principal that's called director though just just a quick point please please please please can we avoid the use of names yes I I got yeah I just wantan to as we we've got to do this without personalizing it I mean we got to keep in mind that they are human beings yes but also we've got it I mean because when when you start personalize things some biases that can come in what have you sure that these

082cuts are made in a dispassionate logical way to the extent possible because there's gonna be plenty of motion coming down the line later okay so that Mr does that have any question about the principal okay now I would like to look at dean of students there two additional positions from 2020 at a cost of 282,000 $849 I I know they got one a fair child where's the other one one at Harding and one at right now there is no more at oh [Music] Fair they they are acting as syst principal one is at far and the other one is at party baram and Harding okay and when did baram and Harding have Dina students prior to that that I've been addressing with the Union as far sunsetting that position entirely out because it was created

083last years good Mr I'm sorry I see what is in both situations is there a human being occupying the position right now no sir don't omem me so automatically so in both cases there is a human actually going to work right now in yes and both of those position are Grant funded positions as well they've added those positions through their school Improvement grant opportunities that's that was one of the only one of the ways that they were able to add an additional support for administration but with a dean of a dean of students added so when when these campus became I think sigs you know they got Sig grant money at one point in time in the process of trying to get school improvement dollarss from the state they petition the state to say okay

084if we get the money we're gonna add this position which is an administrative position as a dean of dean of students for the clarity that's why there's two campuses both of those campuses were sit campuses so they were able to use their additional dollars got they got from the state to provide additional support and how many other City campuses do we have yeah but remember individual City campuses choose they get to choose how they spend their dollars and this these two particular campuses decide to spend their dollars with additional administrative help and those those positions are locked in for until the end of the grant or when yeah if they no longer gets the funding then that position will go away and kind of work it that way just like and that's usually the way

085it when you talk about being funded from a grant you know you you automatically put that that that that criteria on it that okay once there's no more funding then the position goes away and kind of work from there so okay so so touching those positions will have no impact on the operating budget in the near future unless the campus petitions the district to to pay pay out of operation operating funds to keep that position all right thank you so I think um for your agreement I think we leave that one alone because it's going to have no impact on the budget uh um principal on special assignments got one one 0202 $629 we have to pinpoint who that is what they do yes um trying to De for how to say this without giving

086any information away on um just the jum function well the general function is uh overseeing um the annex classical studies Studies have an AP classical studies it was one of the aps that was added and what did the annex do before this position was created to me I don't know I'll have to research that for you yes can we get that before before the next meeting because that's behind special assignments H let's see any questions on that Mr Medina all right 0027 director of Athletics at a cost of $141,100 this position was added in the last few months probably one of our newest positions I think it's what three months old four months old yeah that position has been it had been posted for a long time trying to make sure that we can get

087kind of get a replacement for that position um and it didn't come forth in the first round because we figured probably end up coming down the line you know due to the fact that we've been trying to establish an athletic program in this District you know being the largest school district in the state of Connecticut and we have no athletic foundation for our kids we just felt they let's just kind of keep that hold for now until we can figure out options to be able to better serve uh you know that population uh you know my understanding athletic was has used to be one of the highlights of this this community and uh and to move away from that not trying to kind of you know revive it would be a detriment to uh the

088young student athletes that we serve in the district right now and so they've been without for years and we figured we would probably give them a chance to kind of rebuild that but that's just again that's an administrative you know uh conversation being you know how I know that's a huge part of young kids perspectives while they're in high school right now are growing we don't have a middle school program to grow these kids and so we this person has a lot of Middle School experience to be able to build the program from the Middle School up uh and yes it was hired you know three to four months ago uh but we felt it was a an opportunity for us to build upon that so yeah it's not easy no this this is definitely

089not easy these are one of the cuts that do affect children they all affect children um this position was created was higher three months ago we've got we've had an athletic director in the past that was accessed in 200 18 I believe or 18 right along along side all the power professionals and it was one of the unkindest cuts one of the what one of the unkindest cuts because yes Sports does have its place and it does help children but so does every single thing we do in this District our students are still playing sports our students went to championships in the last few years as well we have not maybe maybe we not have arrived without the position but we have survived and our children have overseen we just recently approved the program for

090our middle middle school sport if we have a director of Athletics why wasn't the director of Athletics coordinating that I don't believe that this is the time that we should have a dir of Athletics added to the budget because that's going to eventually be subtracted from the classroom that's two or three social workers that position we Tes hundreds and thousands of kids and I believe unfortunately that's a position that we really got to consider not having at this time our kids got to learn I mean some of the things in this community yes Sports is important but I grew up in the South Bronx and a number of times I heard my peers say the only way we could get out is through sports or entertainment our kids got other avenues our kids we got

091smart smart children that we need to show up their academics the interventions I mean we need to have them be able to thrive going forward in the academics because they got a 99.9 % better chance of getting out and succeeding through something that's not Sports I I mean it's a it's a numbers game I mean I hate that we have to do this and then I even have to suggest that and I'll be repeating this with several other Cuts coming down the line but we're not gonna this this would not be a good decision for children but it wouldn't be the worst decision it wouldn't be the most harmful decision uh um yeah before I move on and continue talking does anybody have anything else well I can definitely understand um Joe's position and looking

092at every single one um because for me from the beginning I've always said you know we're running a district right now um that many have spoke about looking for um outcome and looking at the scores and looking at the scores over and over but they were never looking um with with a mic microscope that we're missing teachers in our classrooms in a high amount uh meaning certified teachers in both regular and specialed uh certified staff so when I look at numbers like this and looking at you know 15040 $130,000 I think about how many teachers can now can that cover to make sure that you know 70 80 classrooms that are being covered by substitute or permanent or or temporary Subs can't get uh a a certified staff you know teaching and educating inside the

093classroom where that would help with growth which would help in achievement um but people were haven't been talking about that so I understand Joe's you know concern about every single dollar and every single number and every single position how would it affect the district overall considering that you know education the classroom is our number one uh objective uh but when you look at the entire District you know I know what these students have done on the field with or without an athletic director and we need to have I think more discussion about it um and you know and open that you know maybe we can look at this in another week or two I don't know I don't know what we can afford like you know our financial uh advisor and our leader with with

094our finances uh Mr NCO um said you know every single week every single day is money going out um and we can only spend money as my KAG always says Mr Joseph C one time once we spend it we can't spend it again you can't all of a sudden just say Okay I want to spend it again no we can't do that um so delay is going to cost us or we act now and try to you know uh put a Band-Aid where we can right now and that's those are the tough decisions we got to make or move forward towards uh the full board to vote on yeah I I um I said what I said when we went through the the the debate on um Kay um the other morning I was at

095the uh um ceremony at the Roberto Clemente did uh for down at Seaside Park uh for Willie Matos um and uh John Torres spoke to me again about wanting to discuss C eBay um and he wrote me today um wanting to sit down and discuss got eBay uh I remember when we reinstituted Middle School sports uh I was still teaching and it wasn't a fancy program uh kadbe does a phenomenal job with their kids and students there's no denying it um for those of you that don't understand uh I've been coaching for 27 years for free unpaid um how much money do you get nothing how many years 29 there are a lot of us that do it for free I know Willie coached with me in soccer Albert coach with me in soccer um

096kbe does a crackerjack job it cost a lot of money to do as nice a job as they do we can't afford that Cadillac program I'm not sure we can afford a Chevy program right now um and that's the hard decisions we'll be making uh I'm happy to sit down with John and talk about it uh but that's why I was proposing that we hold that for a minute while we look at all the big pictures um and then I heard we hired an athletic director this fall I didn't know that because it was never presented to the board um and when this Middle School sports program was started here in BR in in in the schools um 10 15 years ago it was school teachers working at uh there's a contractual provision in their

097contract for if they stay after they get paid a nominal amount of money and at blackham it was track because there were a bunch of teachers willing to help coach track and there were different middle schools doing different sports around around the city and they had their fun and it didn't cost a lot of money I don't even know if we can afford that anymore but all this stuff is valuable I played High School football in Los Angeles one of the poorest and biggest and most well I won't say um districts urban districts in the country um but all that stuff is important and we all need to to look at it uh but all this stuff comes under the gun all this stuff comes under the microscope I should say this this spring and

098this is one of them and so I don't disagree with your what being said and uh we're gonna have some hard choices to make so I understand why Joe uh Mr scovic has this on the list we didn't know anything about it um I will say one other thing about two weeks ago two and a half weeks ago for those of you that have been around Bridgeport for a while uh Bob Keeley came to my house former State Rep from Bridgeport for many many years uh I believe he was a cross country Runner when he was in high school um and uh he runs a program on the east side of Bridgeport uh and the boys and girls club there and he wanted to know why the Board of Ed wasn't giving some money because

099he lets them use the gym on the east side of Bridgeport at his boys and girls club and I said Bob we don't have any money to give you and don't be coming by my house and begging me for money everybody thinks we got money to hand out for worthwhile programs it's not there so I support you on this um so I think I'll entertain a motion to bring before the full board the elimination of the director of Athletics second favor I post motion cash I have any all right next up director of seal and student affairs can somebody tell me when that position was hired and what they do please position was hired about eight months ago uh it is a position that takes care of all of the uh required seal requirements from

100the state state has also put mandates down regarding seal uh they oversee the leak program uh also support the restorative practices across the district as well fill those duties before eight months ago I don't think that I don't think there was anyone in the district that was fulfilling those duties uh but those duties have just been um required by the state within the last month uh there's some additional requirement ments from the state that's going to be this person is going to be in charge of uh but if it's a position that the board is duly adamant to to remove we will we'll do what we have to do to to remove that so if you feel that's necessary uh well we're open to suggestions on that as well question are the duty is it

101the duties that are mandated or the positions for instance do we have we have um I believe we still got a director of psychology or something like that or director of psycho Services is one US yeah so so um just add to what Dr every was sharing you know the um director of SEO and student affairs um oversees anything social emotional um learning related um to to the district including the work um working with with our school counselors making sure that there's training available for our counselors has been assisting with um our school social workers as well um anything including our attendance campaign and this is the same person who who's in charge of that going into next year a position that is going to be mandated by the state like Dr David was referencing

102is going to be the district climate specialist this individual will also be um in that role so um they were um a ple of of different hats bit bit of a historical perspective for those of you just joining the district um we used to get our reports from I believe it was the director of social work or Psy psychology we used to get reports on seal social emotional learning they would take that it would be under the umbrella I believe if I'm not mistaken it was under the director of psychology that we got all the social emotional learning and all this stuff and we did have some grant funding from what's uh the color thing that that position was eliminated there's no longer that position in the district no no director social work I mean

103um psychology it's on this list director social Psychological Services yes we do have that 79 at a cost 162,000 I me say if that's a report that you would want moving forward that's definitely a report that can be provided definitely B for the discussion at the bo at the board level put put together something a little more comprehensive for us to look at regarding that particular position okay I I'll will do that motion to push it towards the full board first refer to the full board the director of SEO and students fear possible reduction and cut of that now second any further discussion Mr tror yeah I just I'm seeing that that this did not exist in 2020 we used to have an seal director um prior to 2020 now am I imag things that

104there's just nobody here that would know that I don't know if it was enough of an administrative position to show on this radar or if this was a teacher on special assignment it might have been a teacher on special assignment but there was a woman who would go around to Wednesday trainings and do inservice training on seal before I retired who I mean I don't know what her title was I'm not sure that's why I'm asking the question sort of vaguely and I'm using the term in you know vaguely no I don't okay yeah I think I know what you're referring to the we had we had the gr when it started I can't remember her name I remember she came around and did trainings inal um and would come into classrooms if teachers so

105asked to do further training in service training if you know she'd come in then she was very good but just so yes so so if if you could look into that position and see if the duties be not too much of a lift that's another that's that's another position we could look at because I recognize the importance of seal I don't I don't know but I guess the second part of my question is what is student affairs so I understand director ofal what is student affairs kids you know keeping kids in school making sure kids are the CTIC aism all those things is student services and so so when you when you when when you refer this to the full board Mr sakovic I'm going to refer it back to my committee you understand this

106I hope you understand why we could why can't we discuss that at the regular full board and get a Clarity B Mr quo emphasize that time is of Ence by the time your committee meeting comes will be another six months down the road couple of months it won't be six months down the road but it does impact student that's why I mean I'll be sitting down with these gentlemen tomorrow but it seems to me that what you're now saying is that this impacts there's there's going to be a presentation tomorrow in the public that talks about this this attendance initiative that we doing across the district and this person is very instrumental in getting that out there you know through impact keeping kids in school so again entertain any cuss that the four of WS

107but I like the justification to go into a little bit more because it does in its own way you know we're the experts in the field we're dealing with the thing and so I want to make sure that we're transparent the role the impact the kids we have an issue right now with kids not pling go and that's chronic aism hug in this district and so we can cut every position on this list if y'all want to and I will agree with you if you choose to do that because we got a big deep I get it but there's certain things that we're trying to stay away from and that's one of them and that's why I did not believe that on the first round some of these positions here on this list right here

108is is a consideration that I was looking at second round and third round and Final Round if you want to see it be it that way as well but which we just Tred to get the first ones you know and that's what we put on the first list but answer that was a feacher on special assignment I asked that question yes I yes okay yeah and and you know and and just to add to what Dr David was saying briefly um in terms of student services student affairs that's anything that student facing this individual plays a part so for example if there's any kind of Misfortune or tragedy in the district that's the first person to go to that building that's like the the go-to person when it comes for social emotional learning or anything

109that impacts students to me that's like a a very very important position just because of um um this particular individual has regular FaceTime with students but in large scale um so again that's and like Dr Avery said we'll I I'll be able to if you'd like me give you a more formal um presentation about that particular role I can at the board meeting um I can do that as well thank you um yes a bit of followup on the attendance did we am I misremembering or did we just not add a few attendance officers through a grand funded position to so um the when we we don't have attendance officers we do have like leap home visitors which is something completely different that's grown funded by the state um so the state did um does

110give funding to um districts um throughout the state to Target chronic absenteeism specifically so through the LEAP program we have leap home visitors who actually go out into the community and meet with families and um try and encourage students to come back to school so so it's not like we'd be leaving attendance by the wayside we've got something something in place to also but even that needs monitoring so part of that monitoring does also come from and does that take a specialist to model out to supervise oh no of course not but that's just one of just you know several right social emotional which jobs better perhaps is a good fit for a psychologist supervisor to because psychology is basically deal dealing with emotions I'm gonna have to discre you on that because the the

111psychologist and the director of of psychology they deal they're dealing with testing across the district and providing those services to kids and so I don't want to take them away from that duty to to give them some some other duties that is not relevant to what they should be doing so I I want to I want to balance this a little bit you know but I also want to make sure that you don't tap into something that you guys are not understanding the day-to-day role of these individuals so give us the give us us the uh the flexibility to provide the necessary push back to you as well because you pushing back at us we're going to push back at you as well so I think it's important to be able to the psychologist we

112we're dealing with so many more issues and I don't want to take them away from that I'm not seeing a psychologist um um overseeing I'm I'm I'm reflecting my age but in the 1970s I was going out to visit families in their homes um as as a volunteer Tru and officer in New Haven I'm I'm not seeing a psychologist spending his or her time um and her with her her educational background overseeing that kind of program um I just think that's a waste of resources yeah you I'm sorry let me just uh so C you off because you're conf you're conflating something I said I wasn't suggesting a psychologist do over I see the attendance offices I asked Dr I thought you were suggesting the director psycholog does any assume do you need a specialty

113to oversee the attendance officer and his answer was no oh okay so so only pie I'm assuming the director of psychology is would be the social it's a psychologist herself and that would be a a misuse of resources because they're dealing with highly complex psychological needs the state's providing this District a million dollars for that LEAP program and I need someone to oversee that program so unless somebody else wants to come and do that then I would I would highly recommend that we give you a thorough detail of what the position does give you a little bit more something the chew on and then you guys can make I I've got no problem getting more information than decisions but just keep in mind if we access every single employ discuss that's going towards the full

114board right now your central office staff is still probably about 40% bigger than Central office staff that existed in 2019 that were doing all these all these functions so you're recommending that we cut 40 more 40% more of central office staff is what you're recommending suggesting that the work can be done and it has been done in the past um all the all these things were done home visits were done we did cut attendance offices in one of the last rounds of cuts but um when we initially went for Dr resta joh the prior superintendent Dr resta Johnson she functioned with one assistant in her office and couple of U directors and they all spread out the work and yes it was hard it was very difficult it started coming back slowly um after that

115Mr testani Ed the deputy superintendent position but he didn't have all he didn't have all these assistant superintendant I mean we got down to one assistant superintendent and basically a couple of directors who were running the whole district is it optimal no it's not but when you come into a or District like Bridgeport that skill set of Administration has to be as such that they could take on multiple tasks and multiple roles and very less superintendent we did not hire with the understanding that all these positions would be hired to make up for the inability to carry out all these functions as the district existed in that point in time the superintendent that we hired were hired to meet our district as it is and run our district as it is I mean so I

116don't want to cut every single step I'll get that wrong the some I skipped over here if anybody support one on the list to discuss I'd be more than happy to but I I just these are just the ones that popped out to me in particular I think we can get some savings with mineral disruptions because they weren here eight months ago and the majority of the work was being done another way shape or form was it easy no it was not none of this is gonna be easy once we get down to this next phase we're talking three four social workers that could be saved for this position for this one position no two no two two if you're lucky two if you're lucky two if you're lucky and what would be the social

117workers case loan they would have a they would have a significant impact that's what I say we got to look at this holistically when we get down there those two c what's the least powerful impact not I'm not even saying we're going to save those two social workers but I'm saying by Saving this position those two social workers are almost guaranteed be gone because we cannot spend that money twice we got to spend the money once and yes no no I'm sorry I wanted to make sure you were done good and I'm simply asking you for the chance in my committee to get a fuller explanation for this position and what there are some positions that have been created since 2020 that came along with other money from the state that offer value to the

118students and student affairs and my committee is looking at instruction and support services and this sounds like one of those positions if it's not I'm with you well why if it's not I'm with you but I haven't heard an explanation tonight and I don't I am asking that it be referred to my committee at you know it'll go to the full board and I'll ask that it be referred to my committee where I get a chance to look at this thing first um you know and I don't even know you know I'm I will this is the first day of the first chance we've had to look at this stuff in functioning committees tomorrow I have a chance to sit down with Dr Avery and and and um um uh saki tomorrow thank you um

119to talk about what that committee is going to do and when we're going to finally take get a chance to sit down so that I can start looking at programs and other things that may need cutting and this may be one of them I don't disagree with you but what I heard tonight was enough to make me want to pause for a week or two or three until the next board meeting where it may get cut so that's all yeah I understand your concerns and the motion on the floor is to refer to the full board and Dr Dr there's nothing I can do to vote against that right and Dr Avery is going to bring it to us to the full board with that full explanation hopefully of what the job does and either

120it it'll be approved or it will fail based on that information could even change my mind because I don't have all the information I need to make theut so so on the floor is to bring it to the poll committee Dr Avery presents a little on that and any further discussion I would call the question but I can't I'll call it um all the favor I okay motion carries right so we got some potential Cuts what else I got on here the supervisor of magnet school I believe you mentioned that that was um very last one on the page which is where central magnet okay I think they need a separate person there what do you think Mr Central magnet always had is had for quite a long time I don't believe I I believe

121the title's the title has changed I think but there's always been a separate person over a central magnet am I correct yes so so I'm good on that um does anybody else see anything I I only got one page of the list because this is just like one of the ones oh now there's a position that's not on any of these lists that I want to take a look at um the director oh Chief turn around officer that was just recently added from Grants yes and the reason I want to look at that is because that's one of those positions that are Grand funded correct is funded is funded through the Grant and like all grants this money can be spent elsewhere now I hear Harding High School has suffered Ed a loss in some

122student programming due to the fact that the funds are being redirected from a grant to pay a salary that's for a position that's never been utilized before if and and right even even if you can't track it to school turnaround money I'm sorry what's the name of the ENG School turnaround funds can be used for a petora of improvements in the school if we're spending upwards of I don't know the salary off off hand if we're expending Grant funds upwards of that amount of money on a basically an overseer of the program that we've never had before and we're taking it away from children's programming that's a poor use of resources because we've never we've never had that before it was always overseen by one of the superintendent's staff members that existed even in 201

12319 which I keep alluding to which had a approximately a four I'm just making up the 40% number but it might not be correct or accurate but with a much leaner administrative staff they were over they were overseeing that with the principles in the school so that that that's a position I would also like to look towards and and as you know some of the school Improvement Grants they could be shifted around um maybe work some accounting magic with the where allowable would use the grant funds to make a line item shift in the budget to does anybody have any questions about the yes Dr Dr I'm not a doctor quot you're going to be by the time this is over well M quick through the Cher I'm just trying to get a clarification as

124to directive as to what the committee is going this school turn around you want me to put it on the list I don't know I'm just well on once once I get once I get a motion it takes it takes a motion to it takes a motion and push towards the full board for further discussion we can't make any decisions here okay here's here's here's remember this district is is unders schooled turn around okay we are an alliance district and how long have we been that way for years now so if we don't make an impact and how we turn around schools guys then we're never going to we haven't made academic growth in years we you're saying that we we had $144 million from covid funds that we didn't put the dent in academics

125you know prior to having this position you have to focus on what is going to help turn the path we're going to cut all the position at central office we're not going to be able to sustain the work that needs to be done to support the campuses that we have and the needs at the campuses that we have everybody at this sitting around my table as in in the in in my office trying to figure out a game plan to as we cut how we're going to feel back F how we're going to support kids at the campus level we're cutting everybody at central office we're never gonna we're not g to have enough support to support them guys help us understand the turnaround the state is going to be looking at us that's what

126we met with them about the first meeting that we had we have a a beginning of the year meeting with the state accountability Department about how we're going to turn around we have to set a plan of how we're going to do that that's what we did the commissioner made the made the reference regarding having a conversation about not having enough funds to get everything done in general I'm having to go back to justify on January the 9th the plan how am I going to have a plan I'm not gonna have anything to do it with so bear with me a little bit the turnaround we have 13 campuses that's in school turnaround right now we we added one this year one additional campus we have to have a focal point on that to be

127able to help turn around so me as a superintendent as the acting super of this school district I'm going to say I would like you to avoid cutting that position because I know what has to happen there's requirements there's reports that have to be given to the state and I have no one to do that they can't do that you know who was do who was doing it before because if we were in violation of State Statute and state law not saying not saying that we were not saying that we were was getting the work of the turnaround schools were getting done without the additional I mean who who get wasn't here so I don't know who was doing that right you know so a year ago and we've never we've never been found in

128violation of the school turnaround any school turnaround programs as far as I know um what's what's the salary on the position is what 1757 175 what's our hourly rate for tutoring yeah how many how many hours of tutoring could we get for $175,000 would that be more impactful in student outcomes than having a director fill out information on a application and a form it's it's more than that it's more than that Mr yeah yeah I understand it's a lot more than that guys yeah yes I understand we do we will do whatever you got that's want to do if you want to cut that the full for the conversation you could um because like I said some schools the programming suffer we can't say that we're taking 1785 from a school Improvement Grant Pool of

129money is not directly directly impacting students Services which is our end is our end goal that that 178,000 500 that's tutoring that's socialice that's like I said we we got to balance we've got to balance this budget we've got to get there we're not going to get there without we're not even down where we're going to cut so we're going to say you need this part this position 178,000 but at these very same schools saying sorry we gota get can I make can I make a recommendation can I make a recommendation yes sir why don't the board go through all the positions and you guys tell us the position that you would like for us to consider cutting then and then that point we can we can say yes yes no no and then and

130then we have a little bit more because we need to start somewhere I get it so let's I think well I think we're spending too much time if you have a position that you won't cut just tell us we'll we'll consider and put it on the list and say okay these are good no um this is what's wrong with that statement right now I need to hear from you I need to hear other point of views okay the last board for the last year just been doing yeses and NOS with no discussion no I do not want to make a mistake I need to hear your point of view I need to hear your push back and I need to either take it in or discount it um I don't understand what this position does

131I understand what you're saying about the states telling you they gotta like see something and I we've had turnaround schools for a long time a long time and so the state wants to see that we're reporting on them well and we're filing the paperwork properly and I get that um and I have no idea whether this person who's filling this position is really good at it or bad at it or does whatever she does well um or he does well I don't even but the you know do we need an executive director of school turnaround at 178,000 to submit and do the paperwork are they doing something special at that rate are are they mobilizing the forces and troops well to make everything function right how are they helping us make our school turnaround schools

132better uh you know that's really what I need to hear because somehow before a year ago we had turnaround schools who were moving forward under some sort of supervision and direction from Administration um and uh somebody decided having a a designated a you know director that was uh to be in charge of overseeing them was going to make them perform better it's hard for me to imagine frankly that that's true um uh but somebody decided that was true um uh it strikes me more as a flack runner for the state um and that I don't believe works well I think one of the things that the person does the coach principles to do things differently in the building uh you know and if you look at if you look at you know turn around research

133on how school districts and campuses get out of turnaround it's it's the working within leadership within the buildings to do things differently looking at data differently a number of different things that we did not do previously so when you look at applying some of the turnaround strategies of how schools get out of it quicker this is one of those ways of being able to do it uh it hadn't been tried in the past but I think with the focal point of this person coming in with the 13 campuses then it's easier for them to pick up some of those strategies quicker to be able to get out of the turnaround piece we have we we've have gotten campuses out of turnaround but they fall right back into it because they don't have that support to

134keep them afloat on on the way so again it's just a different strategy that's being taken in the way of being able to get others you know getting these campuses back on a regular path and not a turnaround path so again that's that's that's you know we're at the will of the board we'll whatever you guys want to do we will support that but again I'm just giving you my justification for you know keeping it remember what I said I gave you guys the tier one the the tier one cuts tier two tier three we're going to have to do dive deeper at central office you know at Midway through from central office to the campus level we're going to do all those things and so this is a it's a good exercise it's an

135exhausting exercise you know but we can expedite things faster by with my recommendation we I'm okay with that you know but I think it's important for us to be able to get some dollars back to the to the positive side so we can get this budget taken care of and I know that's what you're trying to do and that and I get that but I think we can still work through this the process Faster by giving me a list and say hey I'm looking at these positions here I'm not clear with it can you justify it really quickly then we give it to the board but you look at it and then say okay we're going to recommend these things to to be cut and we can expedite things faster is what I'm saying I'm

136a suggestion we already have a list of positions in tier two and tier three in order to simplify things again that's the way I look at it the committee can vot and get that done just look at the list agree with it we get it done then we can get on to additional I think that's much more quicker and smoother way to do it at least whichever one we know we know action has been taken done we have to send out um we have to have level relations set out a date of sending people you know their combination or separation letter at least we get it done absolutely I I do not disagree the portion I'm having trouble with is potentially with the cuts that we discussed tonight when we get to those level two

137three fours if all these cuts are passed I think we're about half a half a million dollars less damage than we got to on the bottom so I'm not willing to explore the next two levels until we finish the first level of potentials because like I said it's a holistic approach once we say no to this and we don't do this we're saying absolutely not to the social workers psychologists par professionals who actually take care of our k kindergarten children that we got one in every two classrooms that we were able to BR bring back only due to a pandemic millions of people had to die for our Stu for our students to get funded to have help in their classrooms this is what we're dealing with we're not we're not it's not gonna be

138it's not gonna be easy I want to protect the classroom in the bottom WR once we spend the dollar somewhere we cannot spend it somewhere else and like I said in the onset I'm not comfortable moving to the other tiers this is the last this is the last I mean we're going to move on the other tiers tonight um I would hope I mean this is this is not going to be a fast process this shouldn't be a fast process this should be painful it should be a difficult conversation we should not be having easy conversations here if we're having an easy conversation we're not giving a due care to our jobs that we are considering these Cuts we are not performing our fiduciary duties if we do not have thorough discussions if we do

139not have these back and forths and I respect everybody at these tables at this table and I'm not sure did we have a motion to put this to the full board yet I just want to say further discussion before you ask for further discussion that I I think I W to make sure that everyone understands that this is being moved to the full War for a vote it's not cutting these positions so I think the conversation um and I want to clap back to what M Dr Avery said you know give me a list and let me look at it and I can find out okay these jobs I can do you know I can do this here do that here to make sure these position thing and I understand and then with nle where

140Mr nle said just now is let's try to see if we can tackle which I've been trying to figure out I've been already looking at tier two to get some of those savings right now if we can um that way we can give uh a list to uh Dr Avery on other possible things that we want to see and consider to see what are these positions come back to us and tell us what the positions thing can you work without those positions or how you know what's the scale of you know dynamics that it was going to hurt him to do his job because I do not I'm not here to or superintendent whatsoever um and I think that he wants to voice out to us give us name and other positions and I understand

141so know that we're not cutting these prisions right now we just say we want them you guys to come back to us as a full board and make another presentation and talk to about those positions how would it affect you because I I Need You full body and mind I can't have you with one arm because then that means we're working without an arm I can't have you without one leg that means we're working without a leg so definitely we want to hear from you so I just want you to understand that I heard you earlier and I feel you we don't that's not our intentions and if that becomes the thought or the feeling from you please let us know that we can sit out and have more conversations but I understand what you're

142saying so I just want to make it clear that we're not trying to cut these positions at this level we're just trying to open it to the full board for we can hear again um but I understand what you just said can we get a list can you get a list from him from the full board from the chair from all of us to figure out where can we make cuts that it can be feasible doable you know because again we don't want to ourselves they crippled Us by adding so much that it hurt us but now we can't cut and I agree with you we can't cut so much that we can't do the work or you know you know have you be at the best position to succeed you know we want to

143set you up for success but we know that we inherited this lack of of of transparency and accountability with these funds which hurt us right now and I know it's going to hurt overall so I don't want to discourage you and make sure that you know that you know we're here to work with you um but we need to get some of these theves done because it falls on us as as a board these every single dollar falls on our so Soldier soak shoulders and the last thing that I remember that will stay from all last year that kept over my head was when somebody came and told us from C and training that if we go if we fail maliciously on this budget they can come down on us as a board and I

144remember that that we sounded huge to me because I can't afford that I got a daughter in college right now can't afford to be paying another $100,000 out of my pocket which I don't have okay so I just want you know make sure that our chair and yourself uh Dr Avery know that you know I heard you and I suggest that we you know take a little pause maybe to make sure that we can think but this is not saying we're cutting these positions we're saying that we want to bring it before the full board for you guys can speak to us that way we can hear from you and say listen this is this is a a this is going to hurt us bad I need to cut somewhere on C and B to

145make sure it doesn't hurt us to move forward together you know saying and the a that's that front line that you need you know I need you to have this support we want to make sure you shine and like I used before knock it out of the park and I can't have you do that if you don't have a bat you know so I want to make sure you had the bat that you need so let us know please yes um have a motion to refer position of Chief turnaround officer to the full board for potential of elimination second yes any further discussion thank you make make a motion to repeat that please to remove the position of executive director of Chief General School T second any further discussion all in favor I oppos motion

146carries it will be referred to the full board um next up next up I need to take care of a little housekeeping can I get a five minute recess while you're recessing you know one of the problems I I I want to mention just because we're at recess it's not on the record well I don't care whether it's online or not why I'm not going to say anything volatile e e e ladies and gentlemen we're back in uh back in second um next up on the was still on um cuts one two three four tier TI two right now we're going on tier two proposed to two Staffing reductions which contain the title maintainer electrician painter itss help direct desk assistant its logic specialist specialist for a total TI two Savings of 1.73 m455 now

147unfortunately the director of operations is not here um I would like to hear from him before making these cuts but an interest the time um C push it to the full board for a discussion in front of the full board I have no issue with that but I do have some reservations of cutting cut no no no I mean any staff production in fac in fac in facilities but I I would definitely like to hear from Mr Garcia how he's going to let me hear yeah I'm G hear from Mr present first and again what you see here on this pH two was Ved out with these department heads and they know the situation of the district they know the severity of the financial situation of the district so it compromise has already been made

148before we got to this head C here is what I'm trying to say but compromises were made I mean 18 MERS were added you know with covid money only 10 is been taken out so it's somewhat a compromise compromises were made it's not like this department heads or we are never consulted war compromis is made so I just want that to be clear yeah I'll clear on that Mr tror I'm sorry M me Mr tror yeah that's I ra my hand um my recollection of U Mr Garcia's presentation is is or all through attrition um so I'm not you know I just wanted to remind the chair that when he made his presentation at the full board meeting the 25 Main maintainers were through attrition I mean the the I'm sorry 10 maintainers were through

149um attrition over the course of the time that's correct yeah like I said I'm just concerned about the condition of our facilities over time but that being said also that buildings don't teach buildings don't educate no matter I mean they do they do lend PR they our kids deserve a perfect learning environment but if um we're still in better shape that we were in 2020 as far as the staff Staffing levels 25 21 yeah so so we're just basically reverting back to where we were in 2020 is my reasoning for the other positions that we were doing and um I can some well and what I was the end of my point was is that that this is all going to be um viewed in the through the frame of the Facilities Review that we

150saw the beginning of at the last board meeting and that will'll be I assume taking a close closer and closer look at over the next month or so uh at the facilities meeting now that we've separated finance and Facilities thought that was it right so so I have no issue of moving this to the full board I just have concerns but I'm gonna have concern about any c you are separating aren't you Mr chair it with it's all it's all all it's all I know it's all here too we have the IT people here though oh Mr Garcia is not here you can't speak to the IT people no if I may just for clarity I just want to bring to Comedia attention that for facilities we spent a lot the district spent a lot

151of money with covid money buy Ultra Modern buffers and equipment that makes work easier whereby you can cover a whole lot more square footage both on custodia end and maintenance end so we they spend a lot of money on technology and modern equipment so it's not like the olden days where you know you respect a custodian is mopping the floor you know all night here you just can bust through with the machine and goes through you know you just got to move the chairs and it Buffs the whole floor much faster much easier you cover a lot a whole lot of areas in the cafeteria say or in the kitchen so it works out much faster and less stressful to the back pretty much so we spend money on technology througha so you should pay

152off at the end of the day thank Mr pelowski uh the list I was given I guess is this one is this did you want me to go down so in The Proposal provided by Dr yes uh absolutely so oh okay that makes a little more sense to me so thank you very much I appreciate it um yeah so the IT Help Desk assistant position uh was created um uh to act as our help desk person uh to answer the phones when the calls come in um prior to uh uh covid that responsibility was shared amongst uh uh well it's important to give a little context its underwent a large uh restructuring as part of our uh MPP that we had with the state of Connecticut so all of the positions that we have are

153are basically laid out out and arbitrated the way that they are um this particular position is the one that handled that type of work um which is again answering the phones working with people helping them remotely things of that nature so that is why that position came into existence as part of that arbitration excuse me in in eliminating that position now you still have enough staff that you can do kind of like the same thing to to to assist each other within the team that you have so I think that the best way for me to describe this you know given you know the situation is I think that for all of us that are you know having to go through this I mean there's no question that to me every position is really important

154and I think that um I would be doing it to service to my staff and the other people that I work with if I didn't say that I think that you know the key thing at the end of the day here is is that you know we have to make difficult uh Cuts as you know Mr svic had mentioned and I think that you know in a situation like this when I have to look at my staff which is roughly you know if you compare us to Hartford you know we have one quarter of the staff that like a Harford has right but we're we're always under staffed so again we'll do the best that we can with the scenario um and we'll adapt as we need to you want me to speak to the

155next one or no yes please so I was going to say that I was going to leave the room I was reading the room okay next position that is the it Logistics and Specialist or specialist yep so that position is something that its has always needed if you note there it shows that the headcount is two and the proposed headcount reduction is one we cannot not have at least one person doing that we we couldn't barely handle it before when we didn't have that person and when I say like that became a continual Union issue over and over and over again this solved that that's why in our arbitration with the state that's why that came into existence so again there to say that the amount of effort into rearching its you know was a

156massive undertaking and so you know this particular position um you know would bringing it down to that is is manageable is better to have to I mean there's no doubt but obviously again we have to make the choices so that's my T if I could thank you very much no problem any other questions a motion to put put forth to the full board the proposed tier two Staffing reductions as presented by staff this evening for a total of 1.73 million 455 don't move je hi hi e e e I pretty much know what most of these positions do but could somebody come to the microphone and explain explain briefly while I step out of the room what each these positions do three yes you want all the positions okay sure so bilingual liaison uh Works

157previously worked out of the newcomer uh Center in central when bilingual was uh stationed there uh they have since moved over to 45 L Terrace um this person is stationed there uh runs Community forums with our uh non-english-speaking families uh works with Siri which is the state Agency for um immigrants and refugees uh puts together Community forums for particularly Portuguese and Spanish speaking uh students and their families and next business and office teacher there's four of them throughout the district um I believe one at the jdc and two at bassic I'm not 100% sure where the other one is I can find out though uh literacy coach they work with the director of literacy and principles um to work directly with students who are having problems with literacy uh kind of like a a tutor

158to some respects um school counselor does anybody need a description of that or School social worker I think we're all pretty familiar with those math coach same thing as literacy coach except for uh they're dealing with math issues throughout the throughout the district and yes neeter might have a better idea than that the chair they were add with money about oh no yes yes they were all added with Asa money in total 2021 yeah first yeah so what happened what happened there I think they added a total of 15 we only reducing nine of 10 no no between the social worker and the counselors between the school counselors and the school social workers a total of combined increase of about 15 19 we're reducing only nine of them nine of the 15 yeah I was

159in counselors only yep got you yep yeah and then in school social workers yep we're going to uh revise it and reduce it by four yeah y instead of nine instead of n instead of nine that was increased so we're still living some we're still living some extra bodies that we are funded with that's some money there ad yes right then math coach I think is next cor math coach right so it's uh technically the same well basically the same thing as the literacy coach works with the director of math and principles throughout the district to give students who need a little bit extra attention uh throughout the district and then finally unlisted non-teaching assignment uh those are scattered throughout the district uh we have a number we have two in HR who help us

160to do the teams program which is a state program so that the new um teachers have mentors and they're responsible for setting up the mentors they also handle our par up teacher programs uh we have a couple in it I I you know quite honestly I don't know what they do in it but we do have it here and we have a couple that are in uh special education and they help with compliance and issues like that we went up about through the chair went up by eight and we're reducing it by three so we still have you know five there and as for everybody's uh edification here 10 of those positions one is actually that's how the union president is classified as a teacher on special assignment the these These are the toughest on

161this this is way Clos yeah when I look at school counselors and social workers especially with theie we were just discussed on the trauma enforcement Le the trauma that our students space I mean and we're already under represented I'm not saying as again a CO cut um position added was still in better shape than preco but kind that's why I keep emphasizing these positions and the other positions as a comparative but one other add to that though we we've also just received several grants to support the social work piece to kind of help support this change and so we want to make sure that we can you know we're going to have to cut somewhere so again we we took we didn't really want to take all of them back from the co whatever because

162our kids need it and we know we're going to we're we're looking for additional support in this area to help make sure that we can keep things rolling as well so yeah I mean I'm having a I'm having like a flashback moment I just had a flashback before was the director of sports I voted to cut that job before the literacy coaches and the math coaches I voted to cut these jobs before I we keep going the same way people come out Advocate get us some more money so we could stop making these Cuts By the time y'all wake up and read the paper tomorrow or mon or at the regular meeting when these cuts are finalized it's too late for you to come to the microphone it's too late we're failing as a city

163we're failing our children we're failing to Advocate properly we failing to put pressure on our elected officials to give us the money we need to operate a district like they do in Greenwich like they do in Stanford like they do in almost any other District you can name but five people wake up by the time you come yell at us for cutting these positions it's way too late because the money is not there right now we're just touching on the 24 TW 2425 budget yep we still gota look at the 2526 budget yep we still haven't even got there yet we don't know what's going to happen then yet we're GNA hopefully get to that at the next meeting at least at the beginning of the discussion so we could get a little semblance of

164where we may be and if we need to come back to this page and these other pages and go back again so people wake up you want to get mad at me for telling y'all the public that you're not doing your job advocating properly for your money come yell at me at least you at least I know you're awake and paying attention guys I'm sorry that's end my point of personal y anyway um that being I said I don't like what I'm about to say but I will entertain a motion to move one second Mr tber please it's proposed to three Staffing reductions as presented this evening to the full board for I messed up that motion again I move to refer to the full board the proposed tier three Staffing reductions as presented this

165evening by Dr Avery no more second and Mr tror you had your hand up you want to discuss further yeah I amum one I'm going to say this uh the bilingual Ison is a great concern right now um you're a little vague on where that position is um and what it's doing uh and we obviously have great concerns uh that I will be going into in my committee about how we're going to be handling the The increased anxieties and real fears of our immigrant population in this town under the new Administration um and that's uh eliminating that position is is going to exacerbate the problem um so I have concerns on that one um so I want to say that upfront um I I don't know what one literacy coach and one math coach does

166in Bridgeport uh when I taught at blackham it was pathetic that we had two and a half literacy coaches and one and a half math coaches at a school that big um so I don't know what one literacy coach and one math coach does for the entire District um uh so I I don't mean to minimize what these individuals are doing whoever they are but I don't know what that position does um I I the counselors and social workers are already overworked I know this I know them I don't know and you mentioned the unlisted non- teing assignment uh I know some of them I don't know all of them and I don't know which positions you're proposing to cut so I can't speak to those um but the counselors and social workers are obviously

167of concern and this bilingual ason will in a similar vein caus us a great deal of problems uh so I just want to raise those concerns as we start to look at this because I think one of the things that we're going to be looking at in my committee is the support services that we're going to need to be able to offer and I know that it's been raised already what we're going to be doing or need to be doing in this coming year to help um our students and their families um with this new Administration so that was it sorry I can try to rehearse what the committee voted on what I have here so we I suppose we all in agreement excuse me the very first one is um director ofcl on student

168affairs I have that committee voted to take it out the next [Music] one director of Athletics committee voted to take it out that's going to going to the full book committee voted to cut it and take it to P pretty much eliminate it District infrastructure manager some voted to eliminate that eliminate executive director of school turnaround finance committee approved it tier three tier two the committee cut the whole 1.73 million doll that's proposed in this tier three tier two spreadsheet that's presented uh the committee also voted to approve the entire elimination of tier three as presented in spreadsheet in the amount of total amount of a, 89,000 that's what I have okay you got tell no no no no no no okay at least I I have everything I generally like to rehar what the

169committee so there will be un understanding Danielle's online and she's taking notes as to which ones and what referrals so she I just I just text show we'll have all that yeah and now the last item on the agenda discussion and possible action of a forensic audit or internal investigation included but not limited to internal controls hiring purchasing contract Awards magnet schools and aquaculture Lottery processes the reason I put this so we've been for years they've been calling the community has been calling for forensic boarding this last year of spending exposed serious serious deficiencies in the board oversight of the processes a lack of check and balances according to hiring uh contract Awards um and this is really disturbing and tonight I found out even worse another six mil million dollars was spent without even

170being brought for the board we need to look at this to find out how we went so very very very wrong I mean not cast in blame in the past but Dona isn't the current administration's issue and it's Dona not the new border leadership's issue that caused this problem but if we don't look at it and we don't address it anything happens at this point forward that we could have stopped is on our plates so we need to do some sort of deep deep dive into what happened how it happened and this is in part of this will be part of gaining back the community's trust I mean how do we have jobs with six Monon exit separation Clauses in contracts that were never brought before the board how is that acceptable it is not

171and these cuts are even made worse by that and compounded by the problems we have now we're going to go up to the state trying to get beg for money please help us save money they're going to think what are you going to do with it we need to show that we're taking positive efforts we need to show we taking positive efforts to rectify the problems very our heads in the sand and pretended it never happened is not feasible it's not a good strategic plan to gain the people's trust get them to trust us with their taxpayer dollars to spend it wisely to get it to the classroom and another thing that goes to trust is um the magnet school and aquacultural Lottery processes we got to make sure especially with our ENT district schools

172that all rules and regulations and policies are being followed we had public speakers come up to us and make accusations that they weren't really totally thoroughly addressed I had to account for my own son's Lottery process there's an email Trail there's an application Trail every board member or employee that gets the child in a lottery system they filled an application there should be an application in the system with a Tim stamp every board member or employee should have a time stamp application I'm pretty sure maybe it could work a little magic and ensure the whole student body matches up to an application and if there's any deficiencies that could be brought up to us as a board in the executive session possibly in the beginning to see to see if anything doesn't Jael up but

173people have been saying for years that the lottery process is weak we need to get trust in that Lottery processes well my child got into Fair child wheeler I'm looked at a scance but my child got into F wheeler because he went to Discovery and he went to Discovery in eighth grade I had to pull my child out of his seventh his last year from his graduating class because he was getting ridiculous list numbers in the beginning we applied every single year kindergarten first second third fourth fifth here list number 400 500 300 200 100 he got in he was number two he didn't get to graduate with his class because of my desire as a parent to get my child into a school I had to yank him away from his friends all our

174schools should be magnet schools all our schools should be the same caliber of our magnet schools for Equity purposes to have to make that choice to separate from my son is was this to is all about if we had all that if we had the money to properly do our schools we wouldn't have to worry about backing schools we won't worry about having these separate Elite schools so I just want people to know that if the lottery process is fair can it be circumvented can a child be placed in a m lottery in a lottery School outside the lottery process is that possible possible to get on the roles without being on a lottery process and justifying those numbers would be there so um I would like to call for a forensic audit of all

175these things but I know the money is going to be a lift but I would like to Pro propose it to the full board because perhaps the mayor will step up like he did with the facilities master plan and fund it I believe it would be a wise investment from the city to invest in a forensic audit and maybe they could join up with us and do a forensic audit of their own books because we do we do fair to be fair we get ordered every year but also to be fair how many years has the same firm been ordering us Mr I mean how about at least a decade about 10 10 years at minimum about decade so and and and it's not a forensic one it's just like um it's it's like a

176a cursory regular reg regular order forensic order will do the Deep Dives and and if we could find ways to secure our internal controls maybe find waste in certain areas it could pay for itself and I believe that would be a good investment for the city to make in education so Mr ganal if any of people are watching help us out with this one so anybody have anything to say to say on this subject yes Mr TR I mean there are um I believe it'll be um Mr Medina's committee that'll be looking at policies that will help protect uh the public that watches will remember that our troubles with the previous superintendent began when we tried to discuss proper procedures for spending money with the previous superintendent and she did not enjoy being told that

177she had to follow procedures um there are procedures in place that should be followed um and we need to make sure they are followed and if more policy um needs to be changed or policy needs to be firmed up that will be what Mr Medina will be looking at I'm sure um I W to Echo what I have said before and what Mr sakovic was saying in the midnight uh 1994 uh in in the fall in in the summer of 93 we applied to get my daughter into a magnet school we were weight listed at Multicultural Magnet we wanted her to be bilingual um we were disappointed to be we listed um but it was the blck of the draw um in the spring of 94 our neighbor who was a parot high Horizon came

178home and said you know there's an opening for a white girl and back then the magnet schools which were the result of a racial desegregation case there were eight white kids eight black kids eight Latino kids four of them boys four of them girls in each class um so there was an opening for a white girl at high Horizon where she was a parah and my wife called downtown and the administrator in charge said oh yes ma'am we were just going to give you a call my backside you were they were going to hold that opening and give it away to somebody politically connected that summer and that's the way Bridgeport operates and that was in 1994 uh and if it wasn't for our neighbor my daughter would have not gotten into a magnet school

179and I knew that we were blessed to get her in back then uh I have seen the new Lottery system and the numbers that people get and how you know I know Mr sakovic kept a record of every Lottery his son ever got so that he would if he was questioned by a member of the public he could show them exactly what his son got which is what he should be required to do um and um I think any public official should be accountable to the members of the public I received calls from people last year who wanted to know how the previous superintendent got her child into a magnet school when she didn't even get on the final list until after the deadline had passed um and when I raised that question or other

180people raised that question we were attacked um that stuff is legitimate questioning um back in the 90s I wrote a letter to the editor in the post saying approximately what Mr scovic just said it is unfortunate that we have a system of Education in Bridgeport where a few people win a lottery and their child gets better education than the rest of the folks we should all get the same education in this town every child in Bridgeport deserves that and unfortunately we live in a state where that's not the case and we're still working to correct that problem um but in the meanwhile nobody should get a special advantage in that Lottery and any elected official in this city or anybody that's politically connected should be required to prove that they did not get an advantage

181because of their political connections that they live by the same rules as everybody else in this town and if their child got into a school it was because they followed the same rules and anybody in town should be allowed to ask them but I had parents who asked me how did she get in how did her child get in and they were afraid to challenge it because they were afraid of retaliation that's not right it should be right up there on the screen like everything else and that's the kind of policies that I'm hoping Mr Medina and his committee will ensure are in place so that no parent has to fear questioning whether or not their child got a fair Shake um I second and third uh these discussions about you know especially the lottery

182process and things because there was spend a lot of questions throughout this last year um but also you know want to remind the public um that uh bringing forward these things um and some of the things that we're talking about when we talking about cutting and the reason why we're cutting and and holding people name and accountability for the past administration ation uh leader and also the chair and the chair of the committee is because accountability needs to be accountability it's a must accountability does not stop us from moving forward I was SE I would I would double down and say that accountability propels us forward can now the public can trust us more the state can trust us more because we're going to hold accountable those that failed not only with uh with uh

183with the the law but also in public opinion because these elected officials that failed our community and failed the cons situates and our city and above all our students need to held accountable to know that they failed and they failed miserably and as Mr nle said you know we're looking at six over $6 million and I remember that number even to be slightly higher because I kept on hear him in the last board meeting we had and he says we haven't even touched a seven million something you know like and I kept on hearing them like three times saying and it was like it was a Gong in my ear because I'm like we're not talking about exactly what he just said we're just touching the surface we've been going over and this is why

184we want to have accountability with an audit to find out whether it's internal whether there somebody else that we need to hire the investment as think is going to prove itself uh forward but we need to at least put it forward to the board and for put put it forward to the ears of our superintendent that we need to figure out what can we do because we need to hold accountable those that uh we can still hold accountable even though they're not they might not be in their positions or their roles within the district um so if there's nothing else I would like to move forward to the make a motion to move forward uh possible action of a forensic atic or internal investigation including but not limited to internal controls hiring purchasing contract Awards

185magnet school and agricultural Lottery process to the full board respectful Mr Med I'm not gonna second that I would like to propose an alternative motion go ahead um I'd like to refer to the full board issuance of an RFP for a forensic audit to ex that would include but not limited to exploration of internal controls hiring purchase Contra contract Awards magnet schools and aquacultural loty processes I second that and I know why right a little a little discussion yeah outside ey vote yeah discuss discuss outside outside eye looking in will be more beneficial to us as we go forward when if if we say if we go look at ourselves and we say hey we did right did we got a compl the H it's not going to be as as as goodwi with Community

186yes I appreciate that because any good superintendent coming into a new district will do will recommend to the board anyway to do an audit of of the finances because remember you know new people coming in didn't have anything to do with past practices of board nor superintendent and so it's it's a combination uh and so if that's something uh the cost is extremely expensive uh so if you can get support from the city to help you you know meet in the middle somewhere it would be a good you know good d to to to get that support if if you can do that uh if there is not the funds to be able to do it we can also look at the possibilities of an internal you know process of looking at policies and procedures

187to kind of do some checks and balances that way the state's going to need to know that as well because the three things that they're wanting us to kind of discuss is one is special education and providing fate for kids the second is budget and then the other the third one is the leadership of the board uh or the leadership of the district so those are the things that I will be presenting to the state and have conversations around so we look at budget we're looking at doing some things to to do some checks and balances I think it's important uh and um um in my previous experience you know as a new superintendent coming in you know there was a there was an audit on the finances on the curriculum on a whole number

188of different things in order for you have a clear picture of where you're moving to you know and what path you're going to take when you get into that District as a new leader so it's important uh and again that gives everybody a a really good road map including the board because remember a lot of you guys have been in you you were in seats where you didn't get the you didn't get the Buy in from previous administration to help you understand where we are in the state of the district at the time so I think this would be able to do that for you and I think you know even for administrators around this table that are new to the roles it's it's it's a great way of saying okay we're internal we got

189some things we got to tweak and fix but I think we're in a good place and so I think that's important for everybody in the community as well so and further the discussion along maybe give you a little historic this has been brought up before and failed to receive a bid back because we put a we put a cap on the price and nobody I think it was 50,000 75,000 or something something low really right so so I I would suggest leaving a cap off and see what btes we get and how much it costs so we could actually compare some numbers and get some bids this time around the subject and then go from there trying to secure funding and stuff for with what comes back any further wait first second any further discussion

190yes I'm pretty much about the CES that's agult agricultural aqu does not have a lot that is true right this is CES Rob C so it doesn't have no Lottery Aqua Aqua doesn't have Lottery that's correct but what what what if all the seats are filled what if there's excess people over seats at Aqua yeah what if it never has never since the existing but there's got there's got to be some sort of selection process if you got a capacity come us we don't run it okay all right did I did I include ESS motion did so I'll take a I'll make a motion to amend to remove the language of the aquacultural Ling process it uh all in favor of the amendment I I motion as amended is now now refer to the PO

191Board of forensic audit including but not limit to internal controls hiring purchases contract Awards and on Magnet School processes by issuing an RFP without a number attached I see yes move the second now we just need to vot I I any know motion carries good all right I'm going to entertain a motion to adjourn Mo good and no second all in favor I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.