001call special meeting of board ofation today's Monday December 16th 2024 and it is 6:38 um I'm GNA start with um attendance Mr benan everyone Dr Christine Baptist Paris M AA Casmir here Mr Willie minina here M Jennifer Paris Mr jce s Mr Mr Woodson and myself here thank you um today first item on the agenda is public comments um we have uh a few people signed up so we're going to start with um we have Jeremy hman when you come to the microphone just um you can restate your name if I mispronounced it I apologize you'll have two minutes and once the two minutes are up um we ask that you just wrap up the public comments click the um button on the podium yes and I'll let you know when it's read good evening
002board members my name is Jeremy hitmark I'm the newly hired assistant principal of Thomas Hooker School a school that until this year did not have the benefit of a full-time assistant principal Thomas Hooker serves a diverse Community including prek Elementary Middle School a new a sass classroom and a newly established rise kindergarten classroom tonight I urge you to table the vote on eliminating the recently hired assistant principles and allow us to work together to address the district's deficit with long-term Sustainable Solutions we have the opportunity to Place Bridgeport in a fiscally stable position without further reducing critical supports for our students and our teachers it's deeply unfortunate the district finds itself in this position due to some previous short-sighted decisions however moving forward with cuts to the aps at this moment would be Reckless as
003we bring more outplaced students back into schools potentially reduce our already limited numbers of guidance counselors and social workers and increase the workload workload on our already stretched staff eliminating these key leadership roles will compound existing challenges every one of my colleagues and I chose to work in Bridgeport because we're deeply committed to supporting staff and students so that they can achieve their full potential two of the most critical needs I filled so far as an AP are serving as an emergency responder for the building security staff can only do so much and aren't equipped to manage like severe behavioral incidents I personally handle major behavioral issues ensuring the classroom teachers can focus on instruction and students remain safe and in a supportive learning environment without my role this burden would fall in already overextended
004classroom teachers disrupting learning for everyone I also work as closely as possible with teachers to enhance their instructional strategies and response to student Behavior directly imp uh impacting student learning outcomes and classroom culture to address the financial challenges I propose moving the elimination of our positions out of phase one and inviting us to serve as an additional committee to work side alongside Dr Avery and the board on cost saving measures since the last board meeting my colleagues and I have identified eight chronic Financial drains that are Apparent from the school level most of which were not addressed in The Proposal from last week and that's just in a couple days if given the chance to remain in our roles we can partner with you to identify practical solutions to fix the systemic Financial issues while
005ensuring our schools continue to improve student outcomes thank you thank you next is Casey Cooper good evening my name is Casey Cooper in the past few years that I've been teaching at Thomas Hooker I've seen the difference between a soulle leader and a team lead with having an assistant principal our assistant principal plays a vital role and works closely with our principal providing support and ensuring that our school climate is safe and runs smoothly our assistant principal Works closely with all of our teachers families and students and has already developed strong relationships with them this year RP has assisted our principal with managing the school's day-to-day operations including discipline primarily of The Middle middle school students scheduling student support services and communicating with students and parents he's been able to assist with fostering effective communication
006and addressing concerns both academic and social emotional ones that are too much for one person to take on themselves due to the large amount of s services that our students require while our overall population is not large we currently have both sore and Rise classrooms which naturally require a large amount of administrative attention he has contributed to building an even more positive School culture and has excellently leadership development part of what makes the AP role especially important are the bridges that they are able to build between school leadership and the groups within our school Community APS have the ability to work more closely with students teachers and families filling in for what the principal cannot always do with an already full plate on their hands it takes a village to reach out connect and help
007the school and City Community which is what our APS do please reconsider taking them away from us especially as far as we are on the school year thank you thank you um next we have Jesse bartlo thank you to the board for the opportunity to speak chronic stress stress that lasts for days weeks or even years causes immense damage on young minds chronic stress is credited to inconsistency instability and insecurity not only the insecurity my adolescent students face every single day but when I use the term I'm speaking about the physical school safety approximately 700,000 is set to be saved this year with the removal of 19 second in commands from our schools $700,000 to decrease student and teachers mental health decrease educational outcomes for students asking to succeed and most importantly decrease the safety
008of our schools our assistant principles offer more than managerial support for teachers they assist with de-escalating students conflict mitigation and standardized test coordination they've run intellectual preps to cater curriculums curriculum to diverse classrooms schoolwide they cover your classroom when you're when you've been holding it for three periods and don't know if you can make it another 20 minutes stripping our assistant principles from our school will disrupt a school year that has been stabilized by the leaders within our schools stability is the goal of every school routines expectations and consequences are what create stability hallway routines although created alongside teachers are established and reinforced with the strong support of the assistant principal schoolwide expectations such as dress code are handled at the administrative level even in a school of 250 students Administration is inundated by students
009needs that fall that should fall on supports that have already been seized from our schools students access to guidance counselors have already been restricted to part-time allowing acute stressors to Fester into chronic stress assistant principles offer support for the students when the guidance counselor is off campus these devoted Educators go above and beyond to better the basic need or better meet the basic needs of our students my ask tonight is to delay the school level changes that will impact consistency security and stability this school year thank you thank you next is giovana Ramos good evening Board of Education members and Dr Avery my name is javana Ramos this is my seventh year as principal at tamas sucker this is not the first time I come before the board to speak on behalf of our resources
010and budget cuts I have dedicated 21 years to Bridgeport Public Schools and I'm proud of the fact I love my faculty my staff my students my families and my Community Partners about 7even years ago I was an assistant principal at Madison school and I was eliminated from my position so unfortunately I know all too well how the newly hired assist principal's feel I was devastated to lose my position as assistant principal the principal and I relied on each other and we had a strong partnership and we were able to do a lot more together than we could as just one this is how I feel about my assistant principal he is such a huge positive asset to my school Community he is hardworking ambitious intelligent caring capable and so much more the student staff and
011our families respect him and see him as an amazing resource to our school prior to my assistant principal starting at Thomas suck I didn't have a full-time AP I'm a prek to8 school I have threeyear olds to 15-year-old students in my building I have two self-contained special education classrooms at the elementary level and all of my support staff and service providers are part-time I need a full-time AP small school less resources unfortunately we are small But Mighty I like to say my AP and I are the administrators daily instructional leaders disciplinarians the nurse twice a week Mental Health Counselors part-time sub to teachers and as needed facilities managers event planners PP chairs 504 chairs cheerleaders at our students events and so much more we do this with professionalism Integrity responsibility knowledge a smile and the
012best customer service we can provide on a daily basis because that is what our school Community deserves and nothing less our scho school Community deserves more they deserve to have two dedicated administrators advocating for their needs daily mental health concerns are growing test scores need to rise classroom instruction needs more rigor School attendance needs to improve students need programming and so much more with all this we should not be looking to compositions that directly impact the classroom this is something I've heard multiple times from Board of Ed meetings that the classroom should not be touched cutting assistant principles affects the classroom in multiple ways please do not eliminate our assistant principles thank you thank you Rebecca Cabrera good evening Board of Education members and Dr Avery my name is Rebecca Cabrera and I'm the principal
013of Madison Elementary School I'm also the co- grievance chair of bcast I come before you tonight to discuss the immense need to keep a full-time assistant principal at Madison Elementary School and to keep our current districtwide APS support staff and sped District level supervisors intact Madison School is the largest pre 6 Elementary School in the district educating 450 6 students and having more students than all prek to six elementary schools and seven prek to8 schools Madison has three classes of each grade level K to six one prek4 and three self-contained classrooms which service a Continuum of students from K to 6 Madison has approximately 60 staff me Members 30 of which are certified staff and are required to be evaluated by the district tal plan that includes multiple observations and meetings with teachers and certified
014staff Madison has seen improvements in student growth on last year's esac was which is an attestment to having a dedicated staff and two instructional leaders that are in invested in continuous growth and the evaluation development and coaching of our teachers and staff due to budget cuts for this year we have already lost valued staff including easy teachers Who provided tier three intervention service for our most struggling students this loss of Staff has shifted increased responsibilities onto classroom teachers and special Area Teachers the proposed budget cuts call for multiple Cuts including 27 positions from bcast and about nine from Bea positions including AP school counselor social workers and our district bed supervisors it has been stated that we don't want to affect our classrooms but cutting these integral staff members at the school and District level
015will have a major negative impact on our schools and classrooms and we will see the workload of many staff members increase many are saving saying is over however the longlasting impact is definitely not and we are experiencing a mental health crisis and many students who are still exhibiting significant academic and social emotional difficulties how in good faith can we cut our most precious resources which is human capital thank you Miss thank you thank you um next is Sarah MOSI hi my name is Sarah maazi don't have a nice Written Letter like everyone else does um but I am a parent I'm also I work directly with the district I run M science if you guys heard of us anyways I am extremely disappointed my son is obligated to have a free education that can support
016him we have gotten taken away this year our social worker who was full-time to two three days a week sometimes two we have an assistant principal that my son comes into school and he says hey Joey how you doing he is absolutely deserved that and you guys we have a preschool now that you know wasn't in our school that requires a lot of Behavioral Health and extra attention we have a self-contained class in our school my son is not going to be getting the education that he deserves like other towns provide there is no room for my scent to deescalate in none of that is given and you guys just keep going and taking more we have a nurse what two days a week what happens that he goes to the office because he's sick
017there's no one there to actually identify what my son's problem is and it's very sad being a homeowner in Bridgeport payt good taxes that you guys want to cut from us and I just think it should be heard and our voices should be considered in these kind of decisions that's all I have to say thank you thank you we have Joseph Bazi next it doesn't make sense that you're taking away everyone you're going to first take away the social worker doesn't make sense she's wonderful she's hardworking and then you're going to take the assistant principal who's going to work for the people who need it think about it we only have about two three people to go to which who are never here nurse and then we have Miss Joiner and Mr H I had
018a problem this morning he he he just cheered me up right away also miss Jor does that she is amazing just like Mr hit Mark and lights lightened up my day like no ever before I could be mad and they make me happy if you take away them it's just going to cause a domino effect of more issues it's clearly going to make it worse and you're just going to keep on going with it that's all I have to say thank you John Garrison before I get started Lynn Evan would like to yield or forfeit her two minutes if possible oh uh before I get started Lynn Evan the following speaker would like to yield or forfeit or two minutes to me if that's possible where is she was that okay you hold your time
019okay y good evening my name is John Garrison and I'm here as an outraged parent of multiple Bridgeport students for far too long this board has sat idly by while the financial mismanagement of our education system has devastated our schools The Staggering amount of money missing from our education budget and the resulting proposed Cuts in this case the assistant principal position are both disgraceful and unacceptable while I hope those responsible are held accountable I'm not here to dwell on the past I'm here to propose a solution this solution will sound simple but it will require effort and unity a city-wide fundraiser to benefit every school and athletic program in Bridgeport a fundraiser that would be open to all businesses whether based in Bridgeport or simply willing to support our efforts if you know a business
020owner ask them to join us if you care about our children Futures now is the time to act this effort is about more than raising money it's about rebuilding Community bonds and saving our educational infrastructure residents would support local businesses businesses would support our schools and together we'd show our children what leadership and Community really look like we would teach them that their education and their opportunities matter this problem won't be solved from the top down it will only be solved from the ground up by the people of Bridgeport our elected officials have squandered resources and now the burden falls on us to protect our children's education and opportunities to get started I've created an email address revive Bridgeport edu at gmail.com I urge anyone interested whether you're a business owner principal assistant principal teacher
021coach parent student or Community leader to email me and let me know how you can help tell me who you are your role and your capacity to contribute my businesses will be partaking and my team and I are committed to working tirelessly with anyone willing to join us this includes going businessto business to invite participation reaching out to the media to amplify our efforts and leveraging every resource we can to make this happen we might not be able to recover every dollar lost but we can make a difference we can saave off further Cuts we can protect vital programs and we can show our children that their Community refuses to give up on them with unity and dedication we can Inspire others to support bridgeport's future and send a powerful message that we will not
022stand idly by our children deserve better our schools deserve better Bridgeport deserves better together we can make that happen that email again is revive Bridgeport @gmail.com I look forward to working with you and serving our community thank you thank you last on the list is Jenny Gaines okay I don't think she's here oh that's okay good evening Dr Avery and members of the board my name is Jennifer Gaines and I come to you today as a concerned parent of in District Discovery magnet school 84 days after speaking at the last board meeting about the school shooting threat two days from the 12th anniversary of Sandy Hook's tra tragedy and now just hours after yet another school shooting in Madison Wisconsin and yet we still have not received any updates about the safety of our school
023since then but once again we find ourselves facing decisions that could profoundly impact the safety and well-being of our children and Educators tonight we are deciding on the fate of dozens of positions within our district positions that directly influence the safety support and structure structure of our schools how can we justify these cuts knowing that we may leave our children and teachers more vulnerable while I fully understand the challenging Financial path ahead I am pleading with you to reconsider these budget cuts particularly those affecting assistant principles as I wrote in the email that I sent you last week assistant principles are in in integral to our school communities assistant principles are the co-pilots of our schools imagine a plane in turbulence with only one person in the cockpit that's a risk none of us would
024want to take without them the flight of a school our children's education becomes not just turbulent but unsafe cutting these positions is not just a loss of leadership it's a loss of connection stability and safety for our students and staff when we cut these these roles we're sending a loud message that we I mean really you all are willing to compromise on the well-being of our children and the selfless Educators that go into to their schools every single day I urge you to prioritize their safety their mental health and their academic success by preserving these critical positions this is not just a budget issue it's a values issue what kind of community do we want to be let's choose one that invests in its people protects its School schools and builds a future where we
025can all be proud of thank you thank you so we're going to go into the second item on the agenda which is a discussion of possible action including but not limited to approval of and authorizing the board chairperson to execute the proposed agreement between the Board of Education and Acting Superintendent Dr Royce Avery um this item does qualify for executive session um if there's a vote for that I move that we go into executive session for discussion okay it was move by Mr covic second by Mr Medina um this would be a executive session with the board and the City attorney Mark anastasi um and who's joining virtually um all in favor say I call vote roll call vote I heard you we'll do a roll call that's ban is Christin Baptist Paris no sakir
026no mrina yes M Jennifer perz yes Mr Joseph s yes Mr R tror Mr Woodson and myself yes seven yes and two no madame chair okay so we'll be in executive session and come back out shortly thank you uh those online um Danielle has sent you a link and e e e all right executive session is ended we it is 8:20 um is there a motion go Mr tror uh Madam chair I move to authorize and direct the law firm of beron Moses to negotiate a final contract with Acting Superintendent Dr Royce Avery consistent with what was discussed in the executive session the motion was made by Mr trayor second and by Mr sovic all in favor or any further discussion all in favor say I I I any opposed any abstentions right the motion
027passes next item on the agenda is a presentation of the bridge Public Schools master plan status update by Mr Garcia who's actually we're having online presenters we have Matt and Pat I me I'm Mr zuba and Patrick online if you guys can introduce yourself please hi it's um I'm Mike zubba with MP Planning Group hi everybody I'm Pat Gallagher principal with MP Planning Group you're muted Pam good evening my name is Pamela babuka and I'm with Studio J you guys can start your presentation thank you I'm I'm just going to share my screen and walk you through about a dozen 15 or so slides that we have for tonight um let me know if you have any problems hopefully um should be o I see it now up on the big screen um so good
028evening everybody I thought we'd start with kind of getting into our Master planning process this is something that we've been working on for several months and I always like to kind of rewind a little bit as part of it and kind of get what into exactly is a master plan um the way we like to Define it it's really kind of a road map for your long-term planning framework um it it helps guide capital investment it helps guide operations um education program delivery um and it's really a good tool to be able to update so many years to typically five or so years where you're taking a look at a lot of different conditions within your community getting a good understanding of those and then being able to craft ahead um short and long-term planning
029options so we really break it down into two main phases we have our Discovery phase um which is really kind of our assessments and that's our looking at our needs um the three major components of the discovery phase are the 10year enrollment projections those are done not only districtwide but by building and by grade um we also do capacity and utilization to really get a good understanding of how you're best utilizing your space in each of your bit in each of your buildings um what are areas that um you may not be utilizing well what are areas that may be experiencing enrollment pressures um just to really establish what those space needs look like and then Pam and her team at Studio Jade really that other major part of that Discovery phase is the facility
030condition assessment um which goes and looks at the overall needs of the buildings um in really that 10-year planning Horizon but really kind of breaks it down into different planning Windows based on priority all of that information gets rolled together um into uh what we call sort of that master plan that Master planning phase where we're looking at different options we're also looking at programmatic needs building needs um potential for realignment potential for redu C in number of schools as well as capital Investments construction um and be able to really kind of guide and lay out how that framework needs to look over the next decade for Bridgeport Public Schools um so this is just a look at our overall master plan project schedule um work for this really begin over the summer um with
031a lot of work being done um throughout June July and August especially on facility walkthroughs facility condition assessments before um the children got back into the building so as you can see um we've checked a lot of the boxes on the Discovery phase we're wrapping up that facility condition assessment which is right around 100% And then as we move into um the remainder of December and in through the new year um we'll really be getting into that Master planning so looking at um different families of options for the uh near-term as well as the longterm and then move those ahead into development of a preferred plan where that'll have public involvement and ultimately lead into um what that Master Plan report's going to look like and give you clear actionable item um actionable items for
032implementation so why update the master plan it's you know one of those important documents I mentioned that you know typically districts update them around every 5 years sometimes a little bit longer um the last comprehensive master plan in Bridgeport was undertaken in 2003 um with a minor update in 2008 it really kind of provided the framework and guidance um for your last major School construction program um there's been other projects since then but that was really the big impetus and push um for construction about 15 years ago um it's intended to serve as your long range guiding plan really kind of starting at um when we begin this process so getting input getting an understanding um it doesn't really just begin when that document is provided to the board where that master plan is kind
033of passed over um really we're in the Crux of it now of being able to lay out what that Master Plan looks like um it will inform the next round of school construction and needs um it also will be able to inform um bridgeport's um School closure policy um it's requirement of having an updated master plan to go through any major changes structurally in the school system the updated master plan is really going to be able to provide that right sizing being able to look at your portfolio of schools look at what that current and future enrollment looks like and be able to really help create a plan that right sizes the district to that um for efficient operation and as I mentioned um earlier this is really that short and long-term decision making so
034as part of the process I know the board has been providing us with some draft um guiding criteria um this helps us provide a framework as we begin to start looking at that option development we want to be able to understand what are the most important um areas to be be able to address not only um in the short term but as well as the long term see where those then sync up um so these are really kind of the key pieces that we're going to be going through as we're crafting options and weigh them against these criteria to see whether or not um we're able to meet the desires of the board and the district as a whole um so really kind of you know just not reading through all the bullets but looking
035at the major items um it's going to involve funding strategies how best to be able to pay for um capital renewal and Capital Improvements um how best to be able to move the district forward um through a series of construction renovation and repairs and some instances that involve swing space some instances that's going to involve um unoccupied as well as occupied construction so to be able to lay that out um seek opportunities to consolidate facilities where possible um what we've learned throughout our Discovery phase is to be able to really kind of align the districts buildings the number of seats with the number of children in the most effective manner um that's really going to be one of the key components of this um and to be able to move uh ahead with maintaining facilities
036in really good condition and be able to um align those with what the programmatic needs are of the district as a whole um and then last but not least to be able to get community and stakeholder involvement along the way um with tonight being our real first opportunity to be able to get out in the community um we'll have a short exercise towards the end of tonight's presentation um where we're going to want to hear from everybody within the community and help us really kind of get off um to be able to move ahead with that Community engagement to get input along the way as part of this process so as we move into that real um next part of that Discovery phase the enrollment projections and utilization I'll pass it over to Pat if
037you want to provide the highlights of what we've have compiled to date as part of that that would be great sure thanks everybody so Pat Gallagher with MP Planning Group so the enrollment projections are really the the key um starting point for any master plan because we want to make sure that any decisions around facilities are being made in the context of your current and future student populations so we prepared both districtwide and school specific projections that really help kind of um set the stage for our next phase of work that we'll be moving into in the new year um so this just shows our projected enrollment by grade grouping and I I will take a step back just to provide some context historically um so when we look at our prek-8 enrollment we're right
038now at about uh, 1400 260 uh 14,265 students that's down about 1,800 students from the peak 10 years ago so Elementary enrollment has gone down quite substantially over the last 10 years and we are projecting a modest decrease over the next 10 years um by about 400 students reaching about um 13,800 or so before bouncing back a little bit over the later years of the projections um but what we've seen at the high school is that um High School enrollment has grown at the same time that your um prek-8 enrollment has shrunk um and that's largely due to some bigger cohorts that entered uh the school system about 10 years ago those students are now in high school um and so now we have those big cohorts moving out of the elementary schools and into
039the high school and so this year's enrollment of um almost 6,000 high school students is um among the largest in recent memory and we're projecting that enrollment to stay um at about the same level over the next 3 years before decrease ing in later years of the projections as some of those smaller cohorts in the elementary schools move up um so we're looking at um those enrollment uh pressures at the high school to continue at least um for the next three years before having some relief um as as the enrollment decreases to move on to the elementary schools I won't uh spend too much time on this there's a lot of details here but um we do prepare by school projections um and this is just highlighting um the uh school specific Trends um we
040are seeing overall decrease in enrollment but that's not necessarily the story for every school we're seeing some schools that are decreasing at a faster rate than the districtwide average including a couple schools decreasing by more than 10% over the next five years and then we have other schools that are seeing stable or even increasing enrollment um so the the picture is really school specific and this will help again inform our decisions as we move into the next phase of work so getting into to our elementary capacity um we really looked at the buildings and um developed our capacity around your current operations how you educate students and so when we look at capacity capacity is always changing as your educational program changes and so um as of the summer this was the elementary program that
041you're providing in all of your buildings and as we're developing our capacity we want to make sure that every building has the spaces necessary to provide not just grade level instruction but all the specials uh special education and support services um so that we really do have that parody um from building to building and our focus is really on full-size classrooms those rooms that either are or could be used for grade level instruction um and so that includes rooms that maybe aren't used for um Ka instruction um this year due to the enrollment but may have been used as Ka instruction during the past and the next slide just shows um that in a little bit more detail so we're looking at an over all elementary school capacity of just under 18,000 seats and that
042compares to our enrollment of just over 14,000 um students with an overall utilization of just under 80% um so utilization compares the planning capacity of a building with the enrollment and I'll note here that our planning capacity is really meant to be an ideal operating Target so ideally schools should be um you know approaching 100% utilization our our planning capacity is not the maximum number of students that could fit in the building but rather an efficient and comfortable use of the building while providing all of those um Support Services I showed on a previous slide um and so that um Delta between our planning capacity and our enrollment is our overall seat surplus of about 3600 seats at the elementary level the next slide just shows this in a little bit more graphical format um
043and again as I noted before ideally we want um schools to be in the you know 80 to 100% utilization category what we're calling you know well utilized and moderately well utilized and what this means is that you know all of your classrooms that could be used for grade level instruction are being used for grade level instruction and you may have some Headroom in those existing sections but overall it supports efficient um operations we have currently 13 schools that are in those top two categories and then moving down into our lower two categories we have our underutilized schools so these are schools uh between 70 and 80% utilized these are schools that have um smaller class sizes or they may have some Flex classrooms that have historically been used for grade level instruction um but
044are not being used for that due to enrollment and then our last categories are very underutilized schools so these are schools that are less than 70% utilized um including several that are under 60% utilized and so these are schools again that have um um smaller um class sizes or um lots of space Cas that again could be used for grade level instruction but is not currently being uh used for that purpose due to enrollment and when we look forward um over the next five years when we apply our projected enrollment um we see um additional schools moving into that very underutilized category so um today we have seven schools in that very underutilized category um over the next five years we're expecting that to grow to 10 schools so that again illustrates just the amount
045of um space within the system and we'll again inform our our next phase of work and while the elementary schools um have um space in their buildings that the same story can't be said necessarily for the high school um we know this is an area where um we've seen growing enrollment and enrollment today is higher um than it has been in the recent past and again we prepared school specific projections under a status quo and there's a couple important caveats that I'll just touch on briefly um so we are including um BMA the bridgport military academy that program to align with the enrollment Target in the edge spec for the new bassic which is 250 students um so we are assuming a decrease in the size of that program just based on the available space
046within the new building and then we're also anticipating a continuation of status quo at Fairchild wheeler and that is a school where um we've seen some decreasing enrollment due to um a declining suburb Urban enrollment which in turn decreases the number of seats open to Bridgeport resident students um so this projection here is showing a continuation of status quo Trends but again this is something that we can explore as part of that next phase of work how can we um better utilize space at PA child wheeler what are the different options at our disposal for better utilizing that space and then similarly um that um uh drives more students into your comprehensive high schools and so what we see here is that when we apply our capacities for the high schools um Central and Harding
047um based on their planning capacity are operating at or or above the planning capacity um high schools are a little bit different than elementary schools because um capacity is driven by schedule um and there are opportunities to increase the capacity of a high school building simply by um scheduling it more intensely um typically you know teachers are going to be in their room during their planning period but but um we know several of your high schools have been designed with kind of collaborative spaces that let teachers um move out of their rooms uh during those periods and then they could be used for additional grade level instruction so again something we'll look at um as part of that Master planning phase um but what sticks out here is um is Fairchild wheeler which um is
048only 70% utilized based on our enrollment this year so about 400 students below the design capacity and as I noted before this is largely due to the need to uh maintain 30% Suburban students and as demand from Suburban students decreases that decreases opportunities for Bridgeport residence students so if we apply that same um projected utilization going forward again this illustrates um some of those challenges that I've discussed previously so starting next year we're using the um design capacity of the new bassic high school and then combining enrollment from the current bassic as well as Bridgeport Military Academy um and so we're anticipating that building to open up um slightly above the design capacity and in addition we're anticipating both Central and Harding to continue to operate either at or um slightly above that um planning
049capacity or design capacity uh and again this is largely due to the lack of um the the inability to use that Bas at Fairchild wheeler so if we look at districtwide the high school is going to be about 90% % utilized but you don't necessarily have access to all of those seats at Fairchild wheeler um without maintaining that um 30% sub student enrollment I'll pass to Pam to talk on about facilities thank you so much okay what we would like to do is give you a highlevel review um of what our scope was so you have an understanding of what our goal was so ultimately uh independent architects mechanical and electrical engineers walked through each of your buildings and took a high level review of all the major Building Systems and um equipment and their
050purpose was to identify any major um corrective actions or whether it was replace repair or um renew things that would need work so identifying corrective actions over the next 10 years they were looking for things uh that were again could be any major building system or component it's not intended to necessarily develop um a maintenance list like a work order system it's looking at what are the projected Capital expenditures you could um look at based off of how a piece of equipment our system is currently functioning so so 10 years was the window of time and the building as a whole is what we were looking at it's important to note that we were looking at the existing space conditions okay so Mike and Pat have been talking about um different things related to the
051program and things that might need to be adjusted as far as um space use that's not what our role was our role is just to Simply look at the existing building how it's being utilized and what those conditions are we also looked at accessibility so if a major renovation was to happen at a particular building we looked at and identified what were some accessibility related corrective actions that may need to take place in order to make that um compliant um across the scope we had 37 buildings that we um visited that are listed there by category which equated to just over 3.5 million square feet um we did go through a pretty developed standard session this gives us a framework to make sure everybody that's in the field plus all those on on this side
052within the district had an understanding of what we were looking at and um importantly we developed cost estimates based off of what we see um that are standardized and then we use that information to push out findings and Analysis that ultimately support the development of that Master Plan okay next slide to date we have completed all of the walkthroughs uh that were conducted through July and October of this year for all facilities with all team members we have developed all the individual unit costs uh for each of the corrective actions identified um and they are built in a manner where it's um projected based off of um your the local dollars so a City cost index that's reflective of of Bridgeport but that also takes into consideration some other soft costs that would occur if
053you were to put something out to work out to bid um we um have issued draft reports that um have been uh reviewed by the district and we're still in the process of going through and doing some of that data QA but what you're seeing on the screen is a sample of one of the detailed reports um we do get down into the weeds the data is organized but it is presented in a way where um past this project um it it is information that's released and uh to the district to be able to use it to help better manage and do operations so it's something that should live on well beyond the course of this project next page Perfect all right so moving forward with these those physical on-site field um assessments complete uh
054the next thing that we really have to do U major item is we are going to review what we call the soft cost model um to make sure that there aren't any other tweaks or things that are unique to bridport as far as what we have proposed and what's currently in the drafts so that we can capture those costs and make sure that that is real um and then ultimately once we know that that's locked in we'll re um finalize our data we did want to give you um uh an understanding of where we are right now and this is just preliminary uh again we are going through and finalizing our data QA but we wanted to at least give you a sense of what the data looks like um the top chart on on
055the right side of the slide is 10year forecast By Priority now we're only showing those priorities um in two categories your 0 through five and then your 6 through 10 but in our data we actually uh will break that down into four categories so we have the ability to look at it at a little finer granularity but big picture we do have what we would consider a low range and high range that that gives some room based off of what the projects might be for um complexity uh that might be specific to one and not to another so that gives that's for planning purposes but what you do see on the top line years 0 to five of districtwide across the next everything that's been looked at in the Years 0 to five um 83%
056of the need is is identified for recommended corrective actions based off of good architectural and Engineering experience and what we see and do in the field uh you know you have a lot of need that's sitting in upfront right and then years 6 through 10 it's significantly different um so that's that's one way that we look at the data we don't just look at it districtwide we will look at these things also at a building by building level in the same way that we're looking at capacity and programmatic needs we break the needs down um this way as well the second approach is the one chart on the bottom where we look at things based off of the eight major Building Systems and this helps us understand at either a building level or districtwide where
057those greatest needs are and if I was just to look at it based off of today right so these these will shift a little but from what we see 31% of the costs that are projected right now across 10 years are um targeted towards interior architecture so interior finishes interior construction that's your interior doors that's walls floor ceilings right um right behind it is mechanical system at 28% so this helps um at a district level it helps you understand uh where your needs are big picture but once we look at this on a building byb building basis it also helps you understand um when you're looking at it both the priority and then as well systems it helps you look to see where does that spread out over time and how do we use that
058to strategically make decisions moving forward and that really speaks to the last bullet um you know this again is just one piece of the pie when you're looking at building a master plan so you marry existing conditions and the state of the current building right with with the capacity and utilization and those numbers and you kind of across a matrix look at those things and they all becomes very critical components to developing and strategizing on your master plan there you go Thank you Pam um so that was pretty much a big summary of what we've gotten done today and what we have is kind of our framework of our Discovery phase and our needs assessments all ready to go to be able to springboard off into that next step as Pat and pan mentioned um
059you know we have across the board identified several needs um you know about 17 elementary schools are either underutilized or very underutilized um you we have seven that are well utilized these are primarily our magnet schools with a projected decrease of about 300 elementary students over the next 10 years we know we're going to gain space there Pat provided a little snippet of what the next five years looks like um with the high schools themselves um we know the comprehensive high schools are well utilized um how better to be able to um strategize around leveraging that underutilized space at Fair child wheeler to be able to provide some belief across the board um to the Comprehensive High Schools will be an important strategy um and anytime you have buildings of different vintages varying age and
060conditions um you really need to be able to take a look at those and see how best they really align with the educational models as well as um with the Investments that are necessary to be able to put in those that all gets into that Master planning strategy phase and you know even though it's preliminary and we just looked at it districtwide and we looked at the big picture picture for the capital Improvement needs um between that and capital renewal were anywhere between 560 to 590 million in the next five years um working our way through how to be able to look at a strategic manner to be able to address these items is going to be one of the key components of that Master planning process and you know as I mentioned it's got
061to be both near-term and it's got to be longterm so there's items that you're going to be able to address through yearby year construction and there's going to be other more aspirational items that are going to be in there to be able to help shape Bridgeport move Bridgeport ahead for the future as well as being able to align with what those financial expectations are um for the district itself so you know as we get into the next steps really rolling up our sleeves getting into that Master planning um have continued coordination um on that as we look to wrap up the assessment work um collaboration with the board City in the community um we see that window of February and March being the time where we're going to be able to have discussion around what
062those preferred options look like we still have work to do um especially with the finalization of the facility condition assessment so as those get done we'll have all of our assessment and Discovery work completed um and are looking to be able to get that final master plan out in the springtime um to be able to use for the district to help put um what that framework looks like going forward and what that road map looks like going forward so I think one of the main things we do want to hear from those that are in the audience and watching it on uh wa watching it on the video is that you know there's different opportunities along the way this is our first time giving an update at all on this process we've been at work
063for several months um we've done a lot of analysis we've done a lot of findings giving um a high level summary of the information out there we want to take this as an opportunity um through exchange to be able to get some input from the public as a whole so you'll see the link in the QR up on the screen um this will also be provided as a PDF so don't feel like you need to be able to snip it or snap it now um just being able to pop in it'll take less than five minutes be able to give us some input it'll be part of that initial input and then you'll be able to follow us along with the remainder of the master planning process we're excited um to be able to get
064that input and we're excited to be able to keep moving forward as we move into that Master planning phrase which is really kind of the fun part of the overall process um with that I'll I'll turn it over to the board if there's any questions on anything that we presented tonight we're happy to be able to address those um we're gonna Mrs cic thank you mam chair uh couple of questions F first question as to do with um the near-term planning and long-term planning op option evaluation what what's the projected timeline on getting that that's like 10% so far um since both of those options go hand inand um anything you do in a shortterm is going to have an impact in the long term um we're really looking at that development happening really between
065now through January um to be able to get out there in February and start to get some input on what the preferred options going to be looking like so it's really a process of putting together a bunch of different options see what those pros and cons are how they align um with the guiding criteria how they align with the larger objective so you know that work is underway now we're just finalizing the fcas to be able to use them at the um individual School level um really getting into that more specific planning so um I think the simple answer is that's underway and we'll be having development throughout the month of January into February uh okay another question I see 24 25 school year seem to be the highest and then we're declining in enrollments
066how how has these numbers arrived at because our City's going to be opening a couple of new housing projects and our downtown is kind of growing a little was that taken into consideration or you just looking at historical Trends um no we've um Tracked Down what we'll call the housing pipeline so in our larger more detailed report we've Tracked Down um Housing Development that's in um the planning approval as well as construction phase looking at what potential student generation looks like coming out of that so that gets built into it we also do look at historical Trends but really kind of one of the keys is um housing it's a big driver especially um new development um so that gets included in that 10-year projection thank you and this next one I think is going
067to be a hybrid question between yourself and our facilities team the last the last update we got on enrollment vers capacity shows an approximately 7,000 7,000 7,000 underutilization and this is showing approximately 36 3740 counting that where's the disconnect am I misstating any of the numbers um we're showing about 30 600 surplus of seats at the elementary level um let me do some quick math at the high school level I believe um that between our planning capacity and our enrollments about a, about 1,00 so um what would that be about 4700 um is what we're showing 4700 deficit in total um Surplus in total Sur okay I saw all right some 4700 now the last one we got we got like it's probably about 3,000 seat seat what what's the difference between our projections our
068historical projections and the projections you came up with is there a different criteria you looked at than that we were looking at if so please explain um I think the probably the difference is um and I don't know if it's projections that you're looking for just capacity maybe um we we're available we're using design capacity so those numbers are very similar um where it may deviate a little bit as how we're tallying up um full-size classrooms and um reserving rooms that are fulls sizee classrooms but are not loaded to your instructional level that you have at the grade level so um we built a space program I'm not sure if that was done as part of the prior capacity work where um we're allocating um appropriate resource rooms um intervention spaces and support spaces um
069into each building um to be able to support the um support the enrollment there so that could be a slight difference versus saying every single full-size classroom can be used for grade level instruction um that's not the approach we take we take more of a approach around the education happening within the buildings themselves um without getting into the details of that past work I that's probably the the best explanation I can give right now on what those differences may be yeah so Mr calic I think I could answer that for you so for us it when we look at capacity which is a little different we take the Ed spack and we just look at the general numbers so whatever that edpc number says for instance if it says 750 children we're not looking at
070um classrooms or classroom capacity or you know how many specialed students what we're saying is this building says 750 students and we only have 400 at this point then that end number that we're left with that's what we have from a capacity standpoint um when we're speaking of Fairchild wheeler each building was 500 so when we look at that we're just saying 500 we're not talking about classrooms or any existing space that 500 when we look at and we say wow we only have 1100 we're just in the district's math it's just we have space for 400 the reality is um can we fit the 400 in the classrooms most of the time the answer is yes but when you start bringing in special ed programs when you start bringing in other programs inside of
071there those class sizes go down so that capacity level now is not really that capacity level that um you have anymore because for a special ed class whether you have 10 kids well the class is big enough for 29 but we can only have 10 children in that classroom which kind of brings that down so the numbers are going to skew a little bit but I think from them they're looking at from their study every single classroom space sizes programs are in the classroom whether it be a bilingual whether it be special ed what type of special ed and that's the methodology that they're taking um based on their projections right than thank you that that that's very clarifying and this information is going to be definitely important going forward because going from a thought
072process that had us with about 7,000 empty seats to one that only has 3700 it's going to basically inform on moving the schools around moving whatever around and we got to keep that in mind that we don't have as many seats CU seeing the 7,000 n SE over time is like for years and years of 6,000 7,000 in our in my head anyway it's like look at all the space we got using we could con possibly contract so maybe now the thought process got to be we don't have to contract as much because we really don't have as much space as we thought we did right and I think for us we we have asked MP planning to also look at it from a quadrant perspective so the north to south the east to west
073and take a look at where those programs are where are they sitting um are they are they positioned into areas where we don't have to take a bus from one side of town all the way to the other side of town a lot of how classes used to be I mean George and I we try to make it more of a science now on where children are going but if there was open space and there was a program they'd say up we want that and it didn't matter if a child had to travel you know all the way from the North End to the West End it was we have a classroom and that's where we're going I think with the study it's going to be able to show you where these programs are Li
074you know where they lie right now and what we can do from a position of uh moving them where we really need to transition these programs so that they are in neighborhoods now they're in schools where um parents and uh students alike can go to those programs rather than busting them all the way across town to be able to do things so strategically we're really looking at the map to give you guys um you know a a breakdown of where the bilingual programs are where our special ed programs are there's been a lot of work um inside to be able to give MP planning a breakdown of all those programs so when the initial plan comes out and when they start bringing it out some of those things in the plan they're all going to
075be out for you to kind of take a look at and dissect and really look at where we are um where those programs lie and possibly where we could move them to make it a little bit better not only for the schools but a little bit parent perspective to be able to get to those programs rather than busing them across down thank you Mr tabber thank you madam chair um just following up on what I understood Mr scovic to be asking and it was a question in the presentation that I was curious about um I think I I need to have a greater understanding and I'm hoping after the holidays that we're going to hear more about why the projections are that we be declining in student populations um because I'm not quite clear as
076to why you predict those declines um and I'm sure that you're quite competent in your professions but I'm sort of concerned about why we think the the student populations will be declining I can think of a lot of different reasons it might be the case um some of which worry me and some of which um worry for bad reasons and I'll give you a couple of examples and discussions I've had recently with with different people who are concerned about the Health and Welfare of our community um are we losing students because uh of the uh health and and condition of our schools are we losing students because of the unaffordability of our housing are we losing students because of the inability of people toine decent affordable housing are we losing student you know there's a
077variety of things going on in this community over the immediate next three to five years and certainly over the next five to 10 years so I i' i' like to have a deep deeper conversation uh on this uh projection that you've just put out there as to why we think we're going to be losing students and then as you did that and as PJ just made reference to why we where we see that happening within the city and the neighborhoods in the city um I didn't catch in your presentation that the magnet schools um seem to have suffered less uh than the neighborhood schools um so I'm curious about how that is um I know that we originally used to only have three magnet schools now we have more magnet schools and I'm I'm curious
078about how that has affected it um I know other cities and communities in Connecticut over the last um 30 years uh 35 years uh went in a different direction than Bridgeport in the 990s um with creating more magnet schools throughout their cities uh in an effort to offset some of that um educational Direction uh so I I just think that I'd like to spend spend more time hearing what your uh educational standards were um of best practice um and where you see us going with those best practices um I I also wanted to uh follow up with what PJ said about um this notion of a blank uh building versus programs in the building uh capacity versus um what the reality is in the building having walked in the last week or two into a
079classroom where there were no students for a while and then the classroom filled up with five or 10 students because it was a a a specialized classroom um and so it was being used for different purposes in that building um so I think we need to look at what programs we have as we look at that and not just the and I'm sure you did take that into account in projections and planning and so we do need to look at that and I know that PJ has talked about it in his presentations to us in the past um as we look at what we're offering throughout the city toize and maximize uh programs we're offering our populations throughout the city I think that's all I want to leave it at right now okay um well
080thank you for the presentation we will be having further um meetings of this in the Mr benan you have a question okay thank you madam chair um looking and reading everything you present us um I don't see bris Learning Center and they have all schools and I don't seec so I just want to know the reason please sure so I I could touch on that so we do have um that school we did as space inventory we have a um a number there given the specialized nature of the programs there they didn't fit well within the kind of neat capacity buckets that we had for the Elementary in high school um but we'll certainly be including BLC we can we can issue a followup with that building um and certainly we'll be looking at them
081as part of our master plan okay thank you no more question Madam chair thank you I can make a comment good um through the chair so as we uh continue to work on this plan you know it's it's it's a plan that's evolving as we uh move through time here uh we are looking at the options that are coming out of this plan so there will be a couple things that we'd love to bring to facility sooner than later um there's some Concepts on uh what we think we can do to fill the Gap in some areas throughout the city uh there's uh potential sites that we' like to discuss with the board uh that uh we think that the delegation can take to the state that may have uh a good effect on what
082it is that we're doing here educating these youngsters in Bridgeport the potential of uh bringing dollars back into the district uh sort of consolidating some things to sort of uh eliminate the Gap uh in education based on Old buildings versus new buildings so um just wanted to put that out there that we're hopeful to have a facilities committee meeting soon so we can uh sort of present that to the board and potentially get this uh data out to the to the delegation because I know that their session is going to be starting up and as we all know with uh the fiscal Outlook we have to look at every single angle and provide every bit of detail and now that we have data to drive that I think Now's the Time got the date on
083my calendar thank you Mr Gracia um with that said we are going to move on to the next item thank you for presenting um and we look forward to hearing more about it oh miss miss I had a question I have one question Miss cmir yes very quickly um I just wanted to address um the decline in enrollment I know part of it not all of it but part of it is um the OBGYN departments at the hospitals uh around the state are reporting that births are a lot lower than they have ever been in years people are just not having babies um like they have been having uh so I just wanted to mention that that's all thank you all right thank you we look forward to hear more um uh from M all
084righty um the next item on the agenda is um the discussion and possible action on the budget Gap closing measures Miss who's gonna do Dr sorry Dr a good evening I want to uh provide an update on couple of couple of the slides that I presented to you last Wednesday I wanted to kind of go through a couple of those if I can get the presentation uh posted you don't mind let's go to the last week yeah it's the last week I do have a copy of the presentation if you need it um online the packet is in the portal from the last special meeting presentation mode please it's the same I have a couple of updated slides I'm going present on uh the PowerPoint if I can get your attention to um the phase
085two just the overview of the personnel and structure just want to kind of remind the audience that the focus of of how we provided this proposal is really to look at uh the the hiring since 2020 with the focus of the additional s of August 2023 really looking at restructuring of central office kind of working through that piece of it labor contract both teacher and administrative contracts and just really looking at the the financial ramification of this particular proposal I want to also emphasize you know one of the changes um in the Wednesday proposal I recommended two executive level positions to be eliminated uh after consideration and looking at uh the need of if some of the possibility of of like reducing the assistant principles providing additional support for these principles um by only eliminating
086one of those positions um so I wanted to kind of make that that that note known so moving from two reducing two executive School leaders of school leaderships to only one of them so when you look at I kind of restructured this proposed organizational chart as well uh just to kind of show how that one executive U executive director of school leadership will will support all three levels of principles uh still the same you know assistant superintendent model with principles but then the executive uh director of school leadership will be able to support uh all three levels or all two levels of principal as well again also if you look at this particular slide uh I wanted to emphasize that I also reduce the number of executive directors for school leadership that's that moving from
087two to one at the top of the screen there also if you go down to um the the district supervisors of specialized Services it should be highlighted uh we're moving from reducing having four reductions on Wednesday to only two uh I think the discussion that we had was really trying to get away from reducing uh the special education division uh any more than what we did and so again taking out four supervisors from special education we're only going to be taking out two supervisors and also keeping the special education on bondsman uh uh and keeping that on the table for because this person you know really looks at working with parents that may not necessarily have the means to Advocate uh and we want to make sure we put that back into play uh so
088that the district can also utilize that so if you go back to this page the reduction of the amount of money that we're going to save reduces down to about 9,926 uh 446 uh so those are the only changes in The Proposal uh and so at this point I will but remember we talked about moving um phase three and phase four back to the board committee for discussion and consideration to really kind of help the the school leadership to be able to decide on these partic these specific uh you know cost saving measur especially when it comes to uh phase four because we're talking about the facility master plan study we just completed that those options also falls in in in four in addition to that we also talked about other options to consider uh
089so if we if if the board will con will entertain the phase one proposal that I provided to you uh this evening uh for consideration for elimination uh phase two and three of that plan that that talks about the maintenance group and the Social Work group that impacts campuses to to take those back to committee as well so tonight my only ask is to kind of consider uh the phase one which is this phase here for consideration for tonight the other two phases we can move it back to um to the Comm committee for the further discussion along with at three and four and at this time I'll take questions um can I just ask it's about under 10 million in this uh proposed uh tier one uh reductions in the phases three four 2
090three and four do you project that there will be 28 million or are we going to cut 10 million and then really because we have a 38 million deficit if I'm not mistaken right ask ask the question again so are in the additional tiers do you think we'll have we'll find 28 million in cuts and how you know how realistic realistically I don't think we're going to be able to from those two additional you know options phase three and phase four okay I got you definitely understand you so option one it's for tonight option two and three the prop is is this proposed here this this almost $10 million that is and I call them tears my apologies for that that that is a little bit confusing yeah the options one two and three yes
091that's the total between you got the academic and student support staff the Operational Support staff and then you have most of central office staff those three options will save the district approximately you know almost $10 million now we won't see all $10 Million Ne you want to come up U this first phase I mean right out of the box because because of the bumping rights for contractual for teachers and administrators we won't see all those savings all at one time good so just to address the the bumping rights I know there's been some confusion on that um what happens is due to the collective bargaining agreements for say the assistant principal position um if there's an assistant principal who is if we do have a reduction in for and they are eliminated from that position
092they will move to a vacant teaching position where there's probably a long-term sub or a substitute in or if they have seniority they'll be able to bump a teacher in their certification now the proposal we have there's not a lot of seniority in these assistant principles so there's not going to be a lot of bumping going on it would more or less go to open vacant positions now if they go to the open vacant position they get their current salary minus $1,000 so the initial savings is not a big number because you're basically paying the whole salary just minus $11,000 you do get some you know supplemental savings on you're not paying a substitute for that class but as far as the big savings in year one that won't come from the the layoffs due
093to bumping okay um good go ahead okay like I said earlier the other day the only tangible savings that you can harness at within the six months assuming this plan is executed within 6 months before the fiscal year ends it's only the clerical that you're going to gain I think it's which is tier three 1.1 million is it 1.1 tier three is 1.8 million you're going to lose about half a million dollar between unemployment and supporting them with their Cobra rate Cobra rate is the insurance that we have to maintain when somebody exits employment by law if they choose to we have to maintain their Cobra rate they will co-pay but we still be carrying the main cost of the cost of insurance so when you net half about half a million dollars between unemployment
094and Cobra rate you're only going to gain a million dollar in six months the teachers are just basically trickling down to positions so you're really not gaining anything they're just filling vacancies the principle I'm saying filling vacancies you're going to gain small money from The Substitute that you know long-term substitutes or substitutes that they're filling their and lo substitutes are paid at a very much lower rate so for this year for all practical purpose the 9.9 that you're seeing there you'll be lucky if you get $2 million in 6 months on a net net savings basis when you discount all the variables the only time you really get to see the 9.9 is next fiscal year next budget year so where that leaves us today is that the deficit we started with when you it
095started with $38 million then we're going to get $6 million credit $6.5 million credit from Grants that brings you down to $32 million deficit I proposed taking $14 million out of out of the internal service fund to reduce that 32 million then 12 million 6 million is going to come from this Cuts but that 6 million is only trans you know basically coming down to 2 million because of the timing so 4 million out of that 6 million that was put in the Gap closing measure does not exist what it means we have to deep more into the internal service fund to make up that 4 million that doesn't exist this year thereby creating a deeper 4 million doll whole next year deficit I'm sorry deficit next year so whatever we don't do today whatever
096we done gain today we're rubbing we're rubbing today to pay tomorrow that's pretty much in a nutshell basically compounding our problems and time is money when I mean time is money every week that goes by we're losing money by not implementing this program time is of essence we have to move fast all now let's not forget in the plan that I proposed to close the gap this year there's a hanging fruit of $7.8 million gap still remaining that was not closed it's hanging in there now we're losing the numbers that we assumed was going to materialize so in all all in all we're creating $8 million plus $4 million you basically def curing $12 million deficit into next year that's what we're doing compounding it a lot more which is which is very very dangerous
097and very unmanageable to be very honest with everyone thank you Mr sakovic yes thank you madam chair um yeah we're about to embark on the most important thing we do as a board it's one of our three basically one of our three things that we need to do um a board we need to really consider all these positions um as a whole I'm I'm looking at the proposed staff reductions I know there's going to be back and forth on a lot of these uh I think the cleanest way to do this is for me to make a motion to consider these Cuts line by line and vote on them line by line this way we could anybody could ask questions about them and we could TI them off one by one rather than have a
098whole long drawn out conversation with edits and a amendments it may take a little time but the people whose jobs who may not be here anymore deserve the benefit of that time so I move to can I answer prior to that can we ask general questions and then you can we have the motion like if well we can still ask the questions okay so seconded by Mr trabber any discussion on the motion to go line by line Miss batist Perez line by line with regards to all the phases the post staff reduction phase um phase one phase one tier one tier one my hand wasn't up for that but I think there's a plethora of questions to ask regarding all the all the phases that they don't have to stop I'd rather ask the questions
099now and then if we have to go line by line do so any other discussion on the motion yeah I would just like to say this does not forall any of the questionings we have on plan on oh God phase two three and four tier two three and four thank you Mr tror um th those those should be dealt with in a separate motion because all Dr Avery asking is for tonight is a decision on tier one and then we could send the rest back to committee we could do it through a separate motion or what have you but it will be thoroughly discussed as well later later in the future I believe any other discussion on the motion um I don't G get to the questions but let's do the motion first um Miss
100bz are you on the are you raising your hand for the motion yeah nothing's been presented by the full board as to we're only going to vote tonight on phase one that was only a suggestion from Dr Avery so right now it's just to go line by line with with each role for phase one although the board hasn't approved that we're only going to make a decision on phase one correct is there any other is there any other discussion on the motion yes go ahead Miss cimer um I think I just wanted to get clarification um because if I read this right in um chapter 10 section 151 of the states statue it talks about um when you lay off like and again I'm I'm sorry if I'm not saying this right the right words
101but if you lay off people in academics like um there's a law that says that those cut positions like you can't fill them for one whole year if I'm reading it right and if somebody else knows what I'm talking about chapter 10 section 151 of the state statute please help me out but if you um we have to operate without those cut positions for one year and I believe it's anybody in in academics and and I just wanted to get some clarification on that for somebody who who knows more about this than I do please if you could help me out go ahead okay so I don't know exactly what 10151 says with regards to that but typically when you have a layoff there's a recall list so if that position Comes Back available you
102have to make it available to the person that you laid it off and that's pretty much standard for all layoffs so I don't know exactly what 10151 says but with regards to layoffs we will have to do a recall list and if these positions open back up or we do put them back onto the budget we would have to give the person that was removed from that position the first right to take it back if that answers your right but right it does but you can't get give that person a position back for one year though according to the statute right I'm not sure about that I'd have to do some research into that okay yeah so let's let's find that out for sure but I I just wanted to get that you know for
103somebody to somebody else who knows more about it than me thank you miss this is a vote for the motion now is that what you want do are you have a debate for the motion point of personal privilege I can't hear him and we're on a live meeting so can you turn his mic on go ahead um I thought that we were going to have a general discussion come back to the motion later I'm happy to vote on the motion now either way I had my hand up for general questions I thought we were having discussion on this and so since we were entertaining general questions I wanted to get to my general questions so I go either way you you prefer Madam chair all right let's take the vote that Miss casar do you
104have your hand raised still or is it from the last time okay I'm sorry that's from the last time I'll take it down gotcha let's take the vote please the roll call call yep we have the roll call where yeah just because it's easier to know we're voting on The the vote is for line by line um going through the list line by line the proposed staff reductions page line by line goad Mr Ben thank you that's a ban yeah Miss Christine b is Paris no because we shouldn't be restricted to phase one given especially public comment how these roles have direct impact on the classroom mrir pass Mr William Medina yes M Jennifer perers pass Mr Joseph suet yes Mr Robert travor I vote Yes because it makes this discussion simpler and we can
105still um vote decide on the other areas Mr Woodson going back to um isir no Miss Jennifer Paris yes and myself yes so general question it passes six to three so we'll ask general questions now go ahead um Mr Woodson was next and then yeah yes I have a question for Mr Eno now where do you think if we wanted to save money where do you think is the best way where we could where where do you think we should start to get the best bang for our buck we want to save money tomorrow good through Madam chair the best way to get the bank for your money is to implement the proposed Capital measure that's where you get the bank for your money fully fully and not partially he said to implement the measures
106but I heard you I heard you say in a me in a previous meeting that if we cons you know uh if we have better control of our teacher to student ratios in the classroom you said if we you know we get and and and K through 8 we get one teacher to 29 students right okay go ahead and in high school we get one teacher to 24 students right okay so if we you know consolidate we had maximize a classroom every every teacher had 29 and 24 students MH you don't think that's the best way to save money again to implement that your 6 months or half of the school year so whatever savings you're thinking of if you consolidate or try to consolidate classes you have to really know the population of the
107students in each class and see which ones to consolidate uh the teachers that you're going to be reassigning is basically going to be fing spots you're really not laying them off again it's a triple we don't want to lay people off I know but what I'm saying it's a triple effect the best you can get out of it is if you consolidate the classes the best you can get out of it is the higher professionals or the long-term substitute which are less paid and the six month savings andem is not a whole lot is still not going to close the 7.8 million doll Gap this year that still has not been touched it's nowhere close Okay so nowhere close where what if we have you you said if we have like 15 students in a
108class okay and we have one teacher we're not we're not benefiting the the the the district is not maximizing this dollar right that's correct so why why wouldn't we push for that that is where again if you look at the Gap closing measures that was put out there $3.5 million was factored in for operational operational frees and reassignment of other programs we haven't even talked about it we cut up or stuck up on $6 million and projected savings for personnel alone there are like three components that will close the gap we have a $32 million gap and it's teered up in three different ways $3.5 million was earmarked for operational savings and program re rearrangement 6 million was earmarked for personnel savings for10 million was earmarked to be taken out of the internal service fund
109with all those three companies that just broke down $3.5 million operational savings all these things happen happen have to happen in 6 months for $ million has to be taken from the internal service fund 6 million has to be saved by Personnel realignment you still have $7.8 million gaps that we have not even touched to close the gap this year now we've dwindled down in the 6 million we're down to at the time the board is done we are down to maybe $2 million savings out of the6 million in 6 months which we just kick the bucket down of $4 million from this year to next year okay so we're going around in circles let me be very blunt and honest with everyone we just going around in circles if we if we close schools
110and move teachers that can't oh sorry Madame chair it's too with hard respect I don't think it's feasible to close schools middle of the school the time is not ideal no no I I of course we cannot close a school in the middle of the school and then train of course but I'm just I'm just saying you know if we want to see money saved we don't want to see money saved three years from now I mean I I don't know if that make a difference but it does it does it make a difference we're saving money three years from now than saving money and we could be saving to of Tomorrow we're talk we're talking about today I know and again the boad do whatever they want but what I'm all I'm saying is
111whatever actions that's taken we're just kicking the can down next year what what do you what do you suggest is the best way to save money you're the you're you're the financial expert I'm just repeating myself but I will again the board should adopt the plan the three- tier plan the way it's been presented we W yes but that but he still said You know6 million is really $2 million that we say but at least we have to start somewhere to get there I mean we're nibbling on the $2 million to get straight to the point what is here trying to nabble on that 2 million that's left by going line by line and taking things out whatever they take out they're impacting that 2 million that's what I'm saying we're going in circles yeah
112any more questions M won Miss Bane um no never mind it's okay that was my question well I just want to say this how you say we keep going around in circles how do we is this first tier in phase one is going to keep us from going around in circles or is the first step to come it's GNA help and not compound compound a problem less okay all right that's what I need to know yeah thank I'm going to go back and forth routin online and in person so I'm going to go with um Miss bti Perez thank you uh I want to first start off that we were told we were going to have more than one option and we really haven't we've only been presented with one um I had wrote down
113a question because uh I heard something from Dominic and I know that's regarding the directors you know if they were to go back into the classroom uh they would um we would only see like a 1ou $1,000 reduction in their salary but our executive directors are making 100 to 12 to anywhere between $120,000 to $170,000 so what's being proposed is teachers making $9 to $169,000 my follow-up question is I'm under the impression that the second year is only a reduction of $2,000 so we're not really looking at minimizing or making any savings within two years is that correct thank you no the second year for anybody in the bcast union it would be the difference of 25% between what they were getting paid what their teacher salary would be it'd be 25% of the difference
114so it wouldn't just be $1,000 it would be 25% of the difference between uh what they were getting paid as a administrator what they would qualify for the um teacher salary whatever scale that they were on they would get 25% minus the difference all right my my next question is really what are the goals for the district and without taking in into consideration what I was under the impression is that we have a 24mon instructional priorities uh I want to understand how these Cuts will help with building teacher capacity building culturally responsive instructions and guaranteeing tier one instruction in the classroom I think one of one of the things Miss Baptist Perez that we talked about is that you know really trying to trying to have a good start and every every position that we're
115considering in every position that we will consider in the future it's going to make it's going to have a an impact either positive or negative you know on student outcomes uh you know but we have to start somewhere and so again this is a proposal uh and we're the uh my me and my staff are at the will of the board whatever the board wants to take off this list and put it back into play we're very happy to do that so that's and but but it's going to limit what the savings is going to be so we're open for discussion and I think that's why we're having this discussion uh and so if there is not a clear perspective on this let's push it back to committee I'll give you you know let's let's
116go back to the board that you guys figure out what that's going to be but in my professional opinion you know again in my professional opinion you know of of school leadership superintendency this proposal proposal is my best you know um opportunity for the board to get in the right direction uh and again I'm open to suggestions um I I can't no I I understand that part Dr AB I want to go back to just asking some more questions at this time um Miss B Perez um I think you mentioned um that these executive positions will go back into the class rooms and take a reduction but some of these positions are non-union positions um so um these would be cuts um oh yeah I understand that the um audience so goad continue yeah so
117we don't have a performance arts program in our high schools so my my question and also in Connecticut Fine Arts falls under the humanities so I'm not understanding why there wasn't a proposal to cut the director of Visual Arts and performances since our literacy directors would be able because they're under the they're under Humanities to cover to absorb that role and responsibility so I don't think there's been enough of consideration in terms of the roles of our directors especially um given that they're part of the humanities wouldn't that be fair to say it's fine I I I think I think it's pretty fair also our directors of literacy and our directors of math they're right now writing the curriculum and so you know in terms of looking at departments that's not being fully utilized then
118where we can see overlap I I'm I still don't understand why we're going to make a cut for our literacy directors our math directors when there's areas where they can absorb where we don't actually have the program available in our schools right now well I we we do have programs and maybe they're not fully you know know vetted out it's not for credit I I'm not talking about an after school program I'm talking about like actual credits and and then still the literacy directors uh they're under the human that falls under clarification high schools do have banned and there's only one high school in the district with banned so you're talking about when you're looking at Fairchild BMA you're looking at basset you're looking at hard you're talking about one school only two okay two
119schools and then still it falls under the humanities yeah but I think for clarity I think for for when you talk about you know the the Fine Arts piece there's there's all types of you know Fine Arts opportunities for kids in the district there's art there's digital you know art there is you know a number of different things I I can remember just a few months ago when we tried to get get rid of the fame program uh and the families and and districts uh teachers across across the district came out to to to petition against that and uh you know previous I'm not suggesting get rid of that program what I'm saying is that our directors who are writing the curriculum they that falls under the humanities so why would we get rid of
120directors writing the curriculum that's responsible for k through eight literacy when they can absorb an additional role so we get to keep our writers of our curriculum and they'll be also taking on additional responsibilities with the Arts and that was something that I don't see on this chart being under consideration is that you know and um thank you for for sending over the organizational chart but uh I I'm not saying to cut the programs what I'm saying is that our directors have multiple dual roles our directors are performing uh professional development our directors are writing the curriculum when there's an issue in the curriculum it's the teachers that are reaching out to the directors and saying hey there's a problem with the link if we have one director whether it's a director for math or
121a director for literacy they're going to be responding anywhere from 5 to 700 teacher emails so when I when I looked at the organizational chart and who's under it and what falls under Connecticut Law in terms of you know the humanities and and just focusing on the communities right now that's an area that was not considered that can be absorbed and it keeps our directors and gives it may give the directors a little bit more work but I think that's something reasonable that should be put under consideration and I and I I appreciate that recommendation I think that's important but what we tried to do in this first round of cuts is to try to maintain at least one director in the five different areas uh we we looked at that to try to keep
122the district hold uh there's going to be additional an analysis of areas that we may need to look at and and and really prioritize to cut so I can think I can I will actually put that into consideration into play as we look at additional rounds of of cuts to be able to look at all different aspects of programs be it Humanities social studies math science and so and Ela to really you know know streamline that a little bit so I I appreciate that that that clarity and what we need to be able to do and I will uh rally the team around that I I think that's uh that's critical also I think it's critical for the board to know in terms of the directors where their expertise are so you know if we
123have a we can't have one literacy director and and I'm just throwing this out as like a hypothetical that's only responsible for Literacy for the high school level we Prov you know we need a literacy director for K through 8 and I don't know if this individual where is saying a cut of one and leaving us with one literacy director is going to cover all that basis let alone the workload so that's why again going back to um the overlap I did want to point out something else too now that we actually have all the organizational charts uh I didn't realize any cuts to you know human resources or the deputy human resource officer that was another position that wasn't mentioned um on this list and again I'm thinking about how the day-to-day impact on
124the school environment and especially given the content that was expressed by um the various letters we received and and advocating for our assistant principles um you know there's there's definitely other offices that could be um in consideration that's not presented here um I'm going to go to my my next question is what happens to employees that fall under a chief of a department if the chief position is being eliminated are you referring to the chief academic officer ma'am no uh no I've moved on from acade uh for now I've moved on from academics so there's been uh few Chief positions me mentioned or directors um mentioned and I'm and then you say you're going to remove that role but they're responsible for a team of individuals under them and so what happens because that's that's
125not clear on your chart let me get the let me get the organization chart up and I'll see if I can explain for you you're talking about this this organizational chart oh you just provided that one today so I didn't really have a chance to look at it but um let's see you're talking about the so what I did is with what the information you provided to us in terms of the current organizational chart that you provided on our last special meeting um can't remember the date right now to the proposed organizational chart one of the positions in the staff that you're listing or recommending that's cut as let me go back to the page I believe it's one of the roles is director of communications director of communications is in charge of a of
126Staff what's happening to the staff if you're eliminating the director's role that position will be reporting to the assistant superintendent uh of of leaderships and services so there is a couple of individuals that's still in that staff uh and that will be directly reporting to the assistant superintendent it looks different on this chart uh that's on the screen right now uh and it shows where that person reports to and actually since we're looking at this chart I'll ask a question that I had on my paper version uh I have a question the the term assistant superintendent for leadership and services that doesn't currently exist in our district we have a superintendent for social emotional learning and comprehens of health and student affairs but I don't even know who this assistant superintendent is and then that
127leads to my follow-up question is in your proposed organizational chart you're talking about another assistant superintendent aren't you adding a role I'm changing the role ma'am I'm changing but then you've already implemented a change currently no I have not well no no no I'm asking only because the it says assistant superintendent of leadership and student services is that different from the social emotional learning and Comprehensive Health and student affairs it's the same one it was it was it yes ma' it's the same position okay that's what I needed clarification on because the title's different so that's where the confusion is when you're talking about in the proposed one you have assistant superintendent of curriculum and instruction that's correct so that's another assistant superintendent yes that's a name change ma'am is a title Change Is there
128going to be an elevation in Pay absolutely not just more duties okay and now I let see what I have oh well Mr Woodson already touched on this in terms of looking at classroom sizes um which it doesn't sound like it was done so my question is what what's going on with teachers on assignments now we have vacancies in the district I I just need to understand why nothing was done with regards to teachers on assignment and I want to understand why nothing was done in terms of looking in classroom sizes cuz we have classrooms that are regular Ed as the way I'm going to phrase it it's not special education C class and yet we only have five students in the classroom with regard to the teachers on assignment um those specific individuals are
129assigned to different departments we have uh two of those actually in uh Human Resources who take care of the team uh program for the state and they're instrumental in going through and mentoring new teachers and and making sure that the new teachers don't uh wash out and and their job is to basically make sure that these teachers are acclimated and moving along and thriving in the in the Board of Education uh there are a number I think there's a total of seven uh teachers on special assignment uh a number of them are in our it Department uh helping with compliance and our special ed Department helping with our compliance all those teachers are instrumental in what they're doing uh it would be very difficult to move them back to a classroom and have them still
130maintain the jobs that they're doing um that are extremely needed throughout the district uh it would just require us to hire additional Personnel to fill these positions if we were to put these teachers back into the classroom you thank you um for answering that but with regards especially with special education don't we have a shortage with special education teachers we do we do have a shortage and we are actually working on a number of different proposals to try and uh fill that shortage uh we're going to be sending five I believe um individuals to uh University of Hartford and they'll become daap eligible from day one so we'll start to fill those positions if these particular budget cuts happen that would move quite a few of these individuals who are certified in special education to
131become special education teachers and to help fill that need throughout the district but you're absolutely correct that special education is a big need in the district um but so is compliance and making sure that the the board of education is compliant with um state regulations well I I guess my question is uh when we have a teacher on special assignment um do they have their same like hours as a teacher that's in the classro the same vacation the same pay the same time but instead of spending their time in the classroom they're spending their time in Human Resources uh well my people are would be in Human Resources but they're not actually sitting in Human Resources they're at the different schools talking to the new teachers uh up to two years they're in this team
132program so uh the people that report to me are actually out in the schools uh talking to the new teachers mentoring coming up with different programs um just to you know mention my two people Mike and Steve they've been instrumental in bringing a number of programs uh to the district that's going to give us quite a few cross certifications and special education teachers that we are in dire need of with regards to the other departments um I would have to look to them to see what their hours are um or what kind of capacity they're being used in I just know that they're being used for compliance and it compliance as well I I have a question what is our current overall shortage in terms of teachers in the CL of in classrooms uh exact
133number I'm not 100% sure I'm sorry I could get that information to you yeah but if we if we have teachers on special assignment we could bring them back into the classroom and that could immediately help with anything now um with regards to to balance in oh has anyone looked at the numbers of you know the student to teacher ratio I know I already heard Nester answer on it and I I don't want to kick the can too much on it but has any work been done on it and if not why not I'll turn that over to PJ for that okay so yes um Miss Baptist Perez there has been work on it um probably in August um we did uh take a look at uh class size uh towards October um we also
134are looking at it again in January um since Marlene is not here anymore uh we take care of the projections so we will be projecting into next year while we're looking at the class sizes um student to teacher ratio uh if we do have some classes that can be consolidated uh what we'll do is take those teachers and they'll be um basically reassigned to uh a classroom uh that's in need of a teacher so that we don't have to have a substitute anymore uh but those are being looked at we look at it every day um so we do know that there are some classes that can be Consolidated right now but we usually wait and try to do it two times a year we did initially have 19 teachers that we Consolidated and beginning
135of the year um we did find that um we were able to move 19 teachers the uh right now when we go look in January we're sure we're going to find a few more that we can consolidate classes bring them in and put them into um classrooms that are vacant uh and that's pretty much the process of what we do okay thank you PJ no problem my next uh my next question is really about the laying off of uh social workers and site supervisors uh with regards to special education um it can we just clarify whether we're laying off site supervisors social workers the social um I'll clarify site supervisors the site coordinator and social workers we're we're looking to lay off those positions not all those positions are being considered for the first round
136uh that the social workers and counselors are in the third phase of my proposal that's going back to the uh um committee for consideration you said the social workers and what say that again please social workers and counselors the the two that you identified just now will be going back for to but also if you go back to my proposal this evening I talked about at the bottom of the screen it has District supervisors of specialized Services we in on Wednesday proposal I recommended to to Rel four of those positions tonight I'm looking at adding two of those positions back to only consider two and then also keeping the um the ossman uh position as well okay you know I'm I'm very concerned about any Cuts in special education or even keeping teachers out who
137are qualified to be in that role because you know we know the state of special education in Bridgeport and so that's something I don't even think in any phase we really have the flexibility to touch um because we're legally mandated to provide those services and it would only cause an additional strain on the district uh I I guess my question for you is what is the status of the curriculum but again going back to the directors what is the status of the curriculum has has the third quarter been written yet they're in the process of writing that curriculum now ma'am and so in your opinion do you think it's wise to let go of directors if they're in the process of writing the third quarter curriculum you know in the best of the district to
138kind of move it forward to kind of find dollars it's okay to do it as long as I have enough people that's going to be able to help write that curriculum we're also looking at bringing teachers in to support the writing of that curriculum and trying to figure out how we can in you know engage teachers in that writing process as well it's it's it could be done in different ways uh and this is one of the ways that we are currently considering uh to be able to moving forward okay I guess my next question is isn't there don't we have additional funds and right to read you're asking if the district is getting additional funding for no if we have funds not receiving additional funds but we have funds to use and right to
139read I'm done that is's a grant funded uh opportunity for the district and I'm don't know exactly how much money that is I think we are getting something from the state of Connecticut uh but I would have to kind of you know um you know bring that total back to you and uh I don't know off top of my head so and shouldn't we have that number before we even look at cutting vendors right remember that is in phase three all the programs and um curriculum and contracts that we have will be presented to the board at committee for discussion and and determination so I think we can have a deeper conversation with that uh and we'll have that number for you at the time as well I the motion that went forward was regarding
140you know consideration of line by line of you know your your phase one but I still want to ask questions regarding the other phases because so I'm going to um we're looking at the tier one on proposed staff reductions the other phases will be going through committee can you read the motion that was passed for rum please it was it was proposed um a motion to can you I don't have it in front of me um the line by line um I'm saying it wrong Joe go ahead the motion that was approved was to consider the superintendent phase one tier tier one Cuts line by line all this stuff we could talk about we could keep talking for hour is about phase two three and four but right now for tonight it's going to be
141discussed again so you just okay so okay just don't add lip just read me what was the motion passed I believe that's the job of the secretary the the the motion is proposed staff reductions line by line so that's the page that you're seeing on the screen right now that not we're looking at wait waiter three we were supposed to do something with the motion so that's why I'm asking to just please read me the motion what is the motion the motion was proposed staff reductions line by line looking at reducing proposed go ahead Joe yeah I'd like to make a motion to close debate on this issue and move on to we're not we're not in debate I I made a motion to move on from this it take two thirds there's no main
142motion on the floor your motion passed I'm asking for what was the language in your motion the motion is to End discussion to End discussion which requires two3 to restrict somebody's right to speak You're Gonna End discussion and then what what's the motion if anything you should just reach out to the parliamentarian regarding this we're talking about proposed staff reductions the the the page that's on the screen right now okay that's we're talking about that's the line by line we're going through we're not going to fa to tier two or tier three on either slides the positions that are on the table right now are right in front of us on the screen the rest of the items will go back to committee when we send if we want to send that to committee let's
143make a motion right now go ahead Mr tber I would move Madam chair that we move that all other items besides phase one tier one staff reductions be referred back to the finance committee seconded by Mr Medina all in favor no we're now in debate we're now in debate there's been a motion go ahead you need it was seconded was a second and then then it was to refer all the remaining phases into it so we're now in debate she's had her 10 minutes Madam chair no because we're not in debate de a different item that was a different item we hear you time to speak on it it's only you know two times for 10 minutes while in debate if we're not in debate and we're just asking questions then we're free to ask
144questions so now cic point a clarification what is the main motion on the table the motion is to move um phase to move on phase one tier one and move all other items to committee to finance committee and to and for the record the point the motion to commit is only debatable to the merits of committing it not going into the point of clarification the chair is the one to call it you're not the parliamentarian of the board and here's the book where it says it again you're not the chair Mr sakovic thank you Miss batist Perez for that clarification is it this one the motion to commit and refer or recommit appending question is what was your point to that only debatable as to the merits of whether we should commit it or not
145okay and as we said before since it's Mr tr's motion you can speak go ahead Mr tror may I speak to my motion sure yes I what's the motion on the table I I I said it already I'll call on you when you have your chance go ahead Mr tror yes um we have sat here for the last significant period of time discussing all of the questions that Miss batist Perez has about this economic package and it is important I get I agree with her on the other hand I am constantly struck at the minutia that Miss batist Perez is aware of that we have been not given in the last year um and it continues to strike me that she is aware of information that we weren't um point of order if you're G
146to make up stuff the the class to be called on yeah the I'm going to call for a point of order in terms of caring each other with professional dignity the Manu is coming from your end because there was already suggestions to close delapidated buildings there were suggestions to balance classrooms that would have saved millions of dollars but now we're in this position here where we're talking about getting rid of our curriculum writers firing our assistance assistant principles which is completely unacceptable so if it's a creative minutia I'm sure it's coming from you that's why we're going into line by line right now and again so Mr trer do you have something on your motion it's not it's not only I'm still speaking to my motion it's not only minutia we were not given and
147not made privy to it's also inaccurate information that we are still being uh given by Miss bais Perez about Manu uh curriculum writers and the absence of curriculum writers teachers were not included we were bought curriculum programs the curriculum writers weren't used um so I'm I'm point of clarification what decade are you talking about because they're writing the curriculum now and that's what Dr Avery just said Miss Baptist perz I you be you have to be called Mr tror um it was a point of clarification Mr tror I continue to be shocked at the narrative that is being laid out um and when we were not allowed to ask questions we were not allowed to question or disagree about these things uh but now we get interrupted and a narrative gets out that is completely
148different than we experienced that not withstanding I do support everybody being allowed to speak and we have been patiently listening to a variety of questions which reflect the different reality than we experienced tonight we are here to decide on as was laid out to us earlier this evening by the Acting Superintendent a new proposal to discuss tier phase one tier one proposed staff reductions and I have had my hand up since he said that earlier this evening with a question about one of those proposed staff reductions and have yet to be able to ask my question about one of those proposed staff reductions and so we now have a motion on the floor to move all of the other items into the committee where he suggested they be moved for future discussion and and Analysis
149uh and we have propose that we I deal with each of the items in the phase one tier one proposed staff reductions that are on the screen that are on the screen before us so that we can move forward tonight and get home at a reasonable hour tonight um and we will discuss each of those but I do have a question on one of those when we get to this motion um I would like to ask my one question that I have yet to be given a chance to ask about tonight so um I'm speaking in favor of this motion so that I get to ask my one question about one of these items any other thank you madam chair thank you um we go ahead and uh take the vote if there's no further
150questions I'm sorry can you clarify where in the role that is because Miss Casmir had her hand up I'm sorry you didn't see I can't see the screen from my um see Miss cmir yes thank you and I'll make this quick and let me know if this is not tier one and it's not phase one I'm just going to throw it out there um so I just wanted to make a comment that um oh you know no I wanted to ask who right now is in charge of bringing us up to compliance with PPT with with IEPs would that be teachers on special assignment or somebody else so there's a point of order Mr tvic point of order the motion on the floor is to whether to commit tier 2 three4 it's not going into
151the other motions yeah so we can um save that question for after this motion Miss I'll call you right after this motion we're in debate okay um and then my next question is um no questions oh no questions no no oh okay debating on ph I'm moving phase one tier one into um I'm sorry moving the other items to committee except your one gotcha okay m Mr Woodson um thank you Mr s yes okay committees are where the majority of the work is done especially with Finance we should be having in-depth consump conversations at the committee level where any board member can participate before we bring it to the board traditionally for the past I guess 20 30 maybe even 40 years the budget has been presented early discussed that committee amended debated brought before
152the full board to give the budget and the people of bridgew what they deserve for the P we've got very little time due to the Past budget process over the last year and a half F we were presented very little time to debate and now we're already into two hours of debate and we haven't even went into it so we need to send this back to committee where it gets the respected deserves where these people's positions we are talking about get the respect it deserves where our children get the respect they deserve where we could weigh these options and have an intelligent conversation with time not of an Essence so I do support the motion to commit Miss btis forz I don't support the motion to commit for the following reasons there are proposed reductions
153in the other phases that we can take into consideration tonight that could save our assistant principles there are additional um considerations in the other phases that could be considered tonight that can save our literacy directors as they are right the curriculum um again what's being proposed right now didn't take into a account that our directors of literacy we don't know what their qualifications are whether all grade levels are going to be serviced like K through 8 as well as 9 through 12 uh we don't have in front of us um the information with regards to other roles I'm sorry what are you speaking one cuts and the the motion on the floor is to commit phase phaso tier two three and four and that's what we should be restricting our comments to not what the
154literacy director the math director no no that I am in debate and I am stating why during my 10 minutes it should not be restricted and those other positions should be considered for directly impacting the schools you we've had people during public comment talk about the roles of the assistant principles I well although I'm not there in person and I didn't get to see who was speaking it sound like there was a child speaking about their daytoday and how their assistant principle impacts their day-to-day what we're doing right now is limiting ourselves to actually firing and impacting people that affect the daytoday of our kids and ignoring other roles that could potentially be cut now I don't see how and I I don't want to put it between this person or that person but we
155have difficult cuts to make but if you're asking about you know our assistant principles or directors of literacy and a someone else you know those all should be considered at the same time because it can still add up to a number that we need according to Nester so I don't see why we're limiting ourselves to what's been proposed right now when we can get to the number while trying to reduce the biggest harm towards the educational quality that we're giving our kids so that's why I don't think that we should limit ourselves if there's something that we can save some of our assistant principles now or our directors now because there's been a role that hasn't been considered this is the time to hatch it out it isn't the time to limit ourselves and ignore
156the other phases I'm sure that's probably coming because I'm the one that's saying it but you got to think about the harm that you're doing to children and the harm that is going to come that's going to impact the middle of the school year losing support you know the impact that we haven't finished right in the third quarter of the curriculum and we don't have the fourth quarter of the curriculum but we're going to fire the coaches are you that thank you anyone else Mr trabber yes I'd like to uh just say that uh we have a proposal in front of us to deal with immediate staff reductions and while I can respect that uh Miss batist Perez is concerned about some others she doesn't have anything in particular in mind it's rhetorical and uh
157I think we need to deal with what's in front of us right here and now and when we get to the Committees we can look at whether or not there are other changes that could have been made and we'll deal with those when we get there um I find it somewhat ironic given we couldn't have more than a two-hour debate on a $310 million budget proposal last spring okay let's take a vote on this all in favor to movees two three and four back to committee we will do a roll call Mr benan start with Dr ban Christina Paris point of clarification is Christine Baptist Perez and I'm voting no Baptist Perez that's what I say no you said Christina my name is Christine my vote is no Mr Aisha Casmir no Mr William Medina
158yes Miss Jennifer peris yes Mr Joseph suak yes Mr Robert tror Mr Woodson Mr benan yes that's six yes two NOS two yeah thank you Mr svic okay now move moving on I would like to make a motion to approve line one executive director of special education for elimination there is been a motion to approve uh for elimination executive director special education by Mr svic it was been seconded by Mr Medina do we have any um discussion on that debate on that um yes Mr you can go first yes um Dr Avery could you just briefly decide describe the role of the position and the impact of the savings immediate savings on the district oh apologize go ahead this this person is under the chief uh of special education uh we're also wanting to kind
159of you know look at the possibility of of lowering this position down to a director's position uh in order to continue to support uh with the emphasis of uh special education uh and the needs of special education we felt it may be an opportunity to rethink this a little bit as well uh the position is a lower salary position um that would also be able to still support the actual um um supervisors of special education so I think it's it's it's it's a good move uh in order to save a little bit of money so there is a a little impact there on the financial side that would be beneficial to us as well so you'd be eliminating the position but not the the staff will still be working in a different position absolutely correctly
160Miss bti Perez can you clarify how that's a cost savings if we're going to to eliminate a position move them over into another one does that position already exist that you're looking to demote them to and what would be their pay no it would the position is is a a unionized position this this executive director of sped position is a non-union position the position for director of special education is a union position uh we have to petition the union before we would even consider uh to be able to move the position the title down the POS we would have to Poe for that position because it's a unionized position so the person in the position has the ability to apply for the position you know at the lower level but it's not an automatic automatic
161demotion to the position if I'm clear Don clear on that yes that's Dom going to clarify okay yes that uh thank you that's accurate um this position currently doesn't exist we wouldd have to negotiate this with the Union uh get their agreement to make this director of special education position and then come up with the parameters for the qualifications and the salary uh go through a whole negotiation process once the the union if they do agree to it agrees to it it would be posted and then we would have to fill it according to Union guidelines okay so within that realm of hypotheticals right um if it was to become a unionized position we're not going to realize much of a savings because the position would come back as a union position and so we're
162not really going to realize a $24,000 savings maybe I'm just I'm throwing numbers out there because I don't know what it'll be but maybe a 50,000 but it doesn't seem like it's much of a cost savings if you're just going to going to move it over um to a Union position uh correct I'm sorry I didn't mean to cut you off I'm sorry so that would be correct it wouldn't be much of a cost savings correct it would be the difference between what the current salary is and what the new salary for the director would be that would be your cost savings and how would that help with the situation with special education currently in the district removing a position and then waiting to create an alternative at a lower cost how is that going
163to help with special ed well I think in a variety of different ways you may be able to get know a leader with a different skill set that may be able to be more targeted to the needs that we uh you know will you know kind of look into really looking at you know the person in the position the person that we're going to hire for the position and a new direction that we're looking to move all of these positions in when it comes to special education again there's a lot of work around this topic of of delivery of services for for special education students moving forward and so we just really wanted to give oursel an opportunity to kind of look at the skill sets of individuals to fill the void and is the
164current executive director of special education in charge of um of I guess instructing staff with regards to PPT like what what is this role that we're looking to eliminate I need it more thoroughly explained that that we're looking to not make much of a cost savings on I explain this role well again the executive the the district supervisors this person really kind of supervises them but also looks at the ppts and helps manage the compliance pieces across the district really this person can do uh professional development to with teachers a special education and a variety of different things as well and so uh I think it's just more being able to kind of find the skill set for this person to be able to kind of support the additional needs uh I think Dr saki
165is gonna walk up to the m and talk a little bit more about that as well um and yeah thank you Dr ay and um I'll say just to um add to that I think you know um part of what um we all looking to do um special education obviously um is a big portion of our budget um and so ensuring that we are able to reorganize it similar to what um Dr Avery was sharing um we do have um uh you know our chief of special education we have our special education supervisor so the chief in collaboration with the executive director or director will be supporting um not only the um special education supervisor but school teams um I think part of the restructuring of um special education is what's going to be um
166the big piece moving forward um and shifting from the executive director role to the director role is what's going to help us start that process also want thank you for I also want to add something as well um because Mr had asked about immed savings or whoever maybe it was you miss Baptist perz I apologize uh immediate savings it is important to remember that these administrators as far as executive directors do have administrator contracts that administrator contract pays them a severance of six months salary lump suum and six months of health insurance as well so I just want that to be out there so so you all have the complete information in front of you okay so to follow up to that if we were to let this person go the executive director of special
167education we're going to give them a severance package then repost the position so wouldn't that mitigate our cost savings that's correct but my my best guess is that this position would not be filled uh By the time negotiations and everything occur with the union and posting and interviewing would probably not be filled within the next six months anyway I just don't see how cutting from one of our most areas largest areas of concern is going to be helpful or beneficial towards the district especially hearing several times that it's not going to be of a cost savings benefit that's all I have Mr Traer yes just a point of clarification there you're saying that these positions were created with a six-month severance package yes they were and that's been in the district for for a few
168years now they all signed administrator contracts that the language of them says if they're eliminated due to layoff that they get a six-month Severance lump sum plus six months of health insurance covered by the district and when were they created uh it was prior to my I mean it's my understanding it's been here for a couple of years wow just want to make sure everybody has all the information in front of them any other questions on this item line one so let's take a vote um I have a follow-up question based off of what Dominic said all these roles have a six-month provision or which roles have the six-month provision the executive director nonaffiliated positions have this administrator's contract so you're talking about executive director of special ed the ex itive director of school leadership
169and that's it I believe that's it okay and any of the provisions are they available to any of the director's roles I just want to make sure we no I keep on cutting you off I'm Sorry Miss btis forz um the director's role simply follow the bcast contract so they are allowed to bump down into open positions but uh they don't have this severance package like the executive directors do okay and then just to to clarify okay um the list that's in front of me says the executive director SP Dr a you had said something earlier regarding the director of school I'm going to assume that's leadership or executive School leader that's the next item we're gonna get there we're still no no no I just want to make sure that that those two are
170the only thing that's in front of us where it's going to be a a six months Severance that's correct okay and then why is it highlighted yellow again just just for my knowledge we I moved from two eliminating two of those positions to one of those positions and that I just I showed the change from Wednesday's presentation to today's presentation okay thank you that would have been helpful to look at in advance okay that's all I have G take a vote on this item roll call vote okay uh the roll call is going to be on the executive director of special ed um to eliminate or keep the position Christine this sparis absolutely not especially that it's in the area of special education given the dire need in the district the exposure to liability I
171will not be voting to remove this position Aisha Casmir no Mr Willie Medina yes M Jennifer Paris pass Mr Justice Chate yes Mr Robert trer yes Mr Woodson is Jennifer Paris yes Mr benan yes the I'm here just so you guys know oh sorry oh yeah no I don't I don't agree with that right the four Madame chair the next item for going on line by line isor director of school leadership Mr svic motion to approve the director of the elimination of director of school leadership as presented by Dr Avery with a reduction of from two to one seconded by Mr trabber any further debate on this item we'll take a vote I have my hand up it might be helpful if you ask Jeff for one of the computers so you can see who
172hands are up your hand wasn't up when I asked your hand just went up so go ahead all right Dr ay can you just explain to me what's the role of the executive director School leader yeah yeah those executive directors are they supervise principles and they support principles in a variety of different ways uh they also do provide training for all administrators in the district uh and so as we shift over to new um supervision models the the assistant superintendent will be supporting principles and also the superintendent will be uh supporting principles uh but also that one executive director can also support those campuses that may be losing assistant principles so if that if the assistant principal's uh removal or elimination uh takes place that gives an extra extra support for um you know the
173assistant principles and principles without those leaders within their buildings so if if it if the the assistant principal stays then you can eliminate both of those executive directors for school leaderships uh again that's the will of the board can you explain that math to me because what I'm looking at is an executive director's savings is 27 thou uh $27,000 we just keep it simple and so they're providing the support aren't they the ones providing the evaluations um the coaching and assistance to the school principles you know currently they are but as you move through a different so how's a assistant principal going to do that to a principal excuse me if the executive directors are the one that are coaching principles and they're the one evaluating principles and they've just finished evaluating the principles for
174the first quarter H how are you going to put the evaluation on the assistant princip to do on the principal that just doesn't make sense to me I I didn't say that okay thank you but again why are you putting those two ju supposing those two options next to each other please clarify why are you putting the executive director School leadership up against our assistant principles there's a list of different roles what I'm saying is that they will be able to support the campuses that do not have assistant principles so a lot of times what happens if there's a principal out in those campuses that do not have assistant principles you know central office has to provide a backup for that principal if that principal's sick or there is an emergency need some additional administrative
175help there uh these that executive director can go in support that principle yeah but let's say two two principles are out then what and we will have to pull another administrator from central office to be able to support that campus all right so theoretically if there was a bad case or a breakout of covid and we had principles out I don't think there's enough people in your new uh central office that can cover it you're talking about the elimination of 18 assistant uh assistant principles it's 10 well we can we can sit here and do hypotheticals all night but it's still we I will find someone to be able to step into support you can you can look at 92s and 93s to support across the district we could move assistant principles from mult that
176may have mult campus that may have multiple assistant principles and use one of those assistant principles to fill in so there's a variety of different scenarios that we can kind of look at to make it work just just who's going to do the evaluations of the principles if they're gone you'll have assistant superintendence that will be able to provide that support I'm sorry repeat that you would have assistant superintendance that will provide that evaluation support I have no further questions at this time Mr tror Miss cmir uh yes just clarification that um this proposal is to cut one of the executive director School leader positions am I right correct okay that's all I had thank you thank you Mr Woodson um well getting rid of directors and assistant principles put us out of compliance with
177uh um ppts or no it would not okay Miss cmir do you still have your hand up or I'm so sorry I keep forgetting put it down no I don't have my hand up I want to make sure all right are we ready for the vote all right the vote is um for roll call elimination of executive director of school leadership that's a b pass Christine Baptist Baris no Mr yes Mr William Medina M Jennifer perz yes Mr Joseph Sak yes Mr Robert trer Mr Woodson Mr Ben yes go back to miss ban Dr Bane yes 7 to2 that motion carried 7 to2 next item is Deputy superintendent Mr calovic like to make a motion to eliminate the position of Deputy superintendent as proposed by Dr H second the motion was seconded by Mr Medina
178are there any is there any debate on this one miss uh Baptist Perez I think the position of Deputy superintendent has been a luxury that this District cannot afford for a long time there was no Deputy superintendent it was just a superintendent with executive directors um and so I'm in favor for the elimination of this position you know we can't afford to have luxury positions and not be focused on student outcomes and being able to have direct contact with uh implementing changes thank you um any further debate just oh let's take a vote roll call elimination of Deputy superintendent position um Mr tror has a question go ahead not a not a question Madam chair but it came up I just want to be clear uh there was some question earlier about the uh $244,000
179um figure I do want to point out that the chart is Crystal Clear if you look at the column heading it does say salary plus Fringe benefit which was questioned earlier um and it says that in the earlier pack we got last week too Point clarification I think this is referring to will enough perz no s pointed out to the public have floor this was discussed you don't have the floor the floor now this was discussed in executive session we are not going to discuss that right now I did not mention anything about ex discussed earlier and it was disced I didn't say where we'll continue to we'll just continue with the vote roll call vote you violated that confidence Miss paty we're gonna stop there Mr benan go ahead thank you that's ban yes
180Christine Baptist FIS yes Mr benan yes M aesa Casmir yes Mr William Medina yes Mr Jennifer peris yes Mr Jose Su yes Mr Robert tror Mr Woodson all right the item carries 81 mother here next item is Chief of Staff Mr sakovic motion to approve the elimination of the chief of staff as presented by Dr Avery second the motion was made by Mrs cvic seconded by Miss Perez um any discussion that Miss uh Casmir yeah um Can somebody very very quickly remind me of what the chief of staff is responsible for or what what their role is a good question Dr ay or Dominic go you got hit the button I cleared it by accident the chief of staff was a very very new position um in the last few months uh where we didn't
181really have a set criteria of who the chief of staff was supervising um they've been working in Communications uh kind of overseeing that for the past uh couple of months but as far as a well- defined plan we didn't have one for the chief of staff that's what I thought thank you very much Miss batis Perez oh Dr maybe did you have something oh dr's gonna add just a point of clarity that position was created by Dr Ley David uh in the last six seven months uh she was shifting some things that she wanted to be able to uh Provide support for her for her division so it was added Miss btis Perez is there any cost savings associated with this role or will this uh person that filled this seat roll over into another
182position in Human Resources there is no as far as I'm aware there is no plan for that the the cost savings would be the salary plus the benefits a okay and then something point of clarity as well we are actually looking for another position to kind of cross trck this position this uh this person into if possible uh but we still ironing out those things uh and we'll be bringing that to the board uh and committee as well I just in general any position that was going to be brought back at any point in time should just be presented to the board in advance because there's not really much of a cost savings being presented if you're going to just change the role wait a few months pay a person out we're actually losing money
183you know I I'm not hearing any guarantee that we're not going to rehire or repost this in in six months so someone theoretically could be terminated from position paid out and then back working in the district and so that's why it's very critical like if we're reducing a role we expect to see these cost savings and so it I mean I have a follow-up question because it was mentioned that it was O this uh this position was overseeing Communications if this position is eliminated are we well you know what it it everything intertwines because that's where I went back earlier and my general questions was if a chief is eliminated does the department get eliminated as well but again I don't see any cost savings with this if we're just going to do a bait
184and switch and then say we're going to eliminate a role and then bring the role back we're not realizing much savings at all and I think that's very deceptive to the public I have nothing else to say on this did you have okay Mr travor yeah I I think that's critically important that we be informed of any positions that are created ated it's too bad we weren't told about this one any other discussion on that all right let's take the vote on elimination of Chief of Staff Roll Call vote it'll be a roll call vote that Bane um yeah absolutely well if it's okay so I have a question well no I don't yes we can eliminate it never mind so it's yes yes thank Youk yes thank you Christine Baptist Paris yes the role
185should be eliminated in its entirety and not being brought back so we can actually have a savings Mr benan said yes mrir yes Mr William Medina Miss Jennifer Paris yes Mr Justice s yes Mr Robert trer yes Mr Woodson ni to see you madam chair thank you the next item is director of literacy Mr talovic motion to approve the elimination of the director of literacy one position the director of literacy as presented by Dr to Avery second seconded by Mr Medina any debate Miss Baptist Perez again what is the qualification of the one director of literacy that we're keeping if the person is not qualified for K through 12 I think this is a critical flaw also again as mentioned you know directors of literacy are right now writing the curriculum we don't have the
186curriculum completed the directors of literacy are the ones that's going out and they're answering teachers questions they're going out and Performing professional development they're answering questions if there's an issue in the curriculum whether a link doesn't work there's the ones looking at survey feedback from teachers you know as mentioned with regards to Fine Arts that's something that was not presented and that's something that the directors of literacy can absorb and so I I really don't see why we're going to remove both when we don't know the qualifications of either that we're looking to eliminate right now it just doesn't make sense uh and then we haven't been presented with everybody's salary in terms of actually making a comparison as to where the greater the greater cost savings would be with regard to the director of
187literacy there's no names up there just position so we would have to look at who the most qualified 4 K through 12 is and make the cut based on that and so we don't know who the most qualified person is the curriculum's not done but we're going forward with voting to remove a position is that's that's what's going on that's correct Miss cmir yes um I agree um I I I want to advocate for both of these positions and um the reason why is um similar to what uh Miss Baptist Perez said um we have one English language arts director that or you know literacy director or whatever you want to call it that doesn't know prek through 8 only 9 through 12 as far as as far as I understand if I'm wrong please
188correct me but um I from what I understand um the 9 through 12 director went to the state and told them that she didn't know prek through 8 so um again if that is not correct please I I don't mind you correct to me I just um I want to Advocate strongly for this we're at the bottom the bottom of the um reading scores and then the math scores and um and that's all I wanted to say but please again love to be educated I don't mind being corrected um but but this is really really scary like we need prek through 8 as well as 9 through 12 that's all I wanted to say all right and I I want to clarify that Dr in terms of the the um curriculum you mentioned that you're
189hoping to bring teachers in experienced teachers and who can support these directors in finishing the curriculum again oh one minute go ahead again as we as we explore remember let me let me kind of take a step back at the beginning of this school year we had one director in each content area we added the second one mid year due to the fact that we wanted to make sure that we had some more additional support for the academics so again it's important to note that as we look at at the whole package of academics that we have we're trying to kind of just minimize the the impact that the the layoffs would would be so we kept one academic director in each of the of the content areas again it it wasn't to try to
190look at which you know person we haven't even have a name on this it was just more of the position we will look at there's a there's a couple different you know bumping writes that HR will be taken taken in consideration for the elimination of the one position so we'll look at all of that uh and and I think the the the original person that was hired for the position because prior to that there was no one in the position so again we're going to keep it you know somewhat whole by just eliminating one of them Miss bat for us oh uh I mean I understand the adding of additional support for the whole package because we're a failing District you know we were failing with one so we added another one and now we're
191going to get rid of it before we even see any results being yielded I don't again I just don't see how this makes any sense at all know yeah we used to have one we were failing district and we're continuing down the same trajectory the only question is we're already at the bottom in certain areas so it's almost like how lower can we go Miss Bane yes thank you I I kind I agree with um Christine Baptist Perez um for the simple fact that you um we we need direct of literacy and math and science our kids need to have as much support as they can get in these subjects and if we you yourself just said Dr Avery we didn't have any then we had one and then we just B in another one
192and we the bringing in of the of the of another um director is crucial because of the simple fact that if you only had one it wasn't doing our students any good it didn't help our students Elevate and raise up in their scores um so we I I think that Dr Levy David bringing them in was to to help and Advance our students and if we're taking them away directive literacy and then going to have teachers or subs or whatever to try to fill in we're we're we're going backwards we're not going forward and I I I agree with Christine on that and I don't think that we should eliminate any of these directors there I really don't because um we need them we need those directors our district needs those directors because one can't
193do it all by themselves and they need help that's why she hired someone else to help because we have a larger district and like she said if you if one does not have the CR the um credentials from 9 from prek to from only from 9 to 12 and not pre k to8 then we're doing our CH our our um children a disservice because how could one if she went to if what um Miss Casmir said is true that she went to the state herself and said she doesn't have the qualifications for that particular set of um from 8 to 12 I mean prek to um I mean 9 to 12 or prek whichever one she doesn't have the qualifications for then how do we know that and why would we even chance doing that
194to our children if this is really all about the children then I think we need to give our children a better chance I don't have a problem with Chief of Staff if they don't have a staff to Chief over it that's fine um but the literacy and the math and the science I kind of have I have a I have an issue with because my sons went to this school district and I promise you the district wasn't doing wasn't doing well and if we didn't have any and we bought in one and we we needed to bring in another one it's for a reason so I I agree with I agree with Christine on that Miss casir yeah just my last comment you know this might fly in a much smaller District of a lot
195less kids but we need at least two of those um dist you know director of literacy like Miss Bane said director of math director of science that that's all I wanted to say you have to consider the size of the district as well well we're going to go ahead and um Miss uh bti I think you spoke twice already on this motion so we're going to go ahead and do a vote on this one roll call all righty roll call on director of literacy eliminating the director of literacy one director of literacy uh per personel Dr ban no because I think I believe that our children need it and we shouldn't try to do un we shouldn't try to undo everything Carmela put in place just because we can if it's needed I think it
196needs to stay and I think director of literacy director of math and director of science both need to stay Christine Bap Baris no 80.1% of our students are below Ela profession see an esack the average SAT score for the 2324 school year in ela was 412 these test scores show that reducing down to one would cause educational harm to children okay cheir no this will continue to cause further harm to our children absolutely not Mr William minina yes is Jennifer parz yes Mr Jose Sak Mr Robert trer Mike I vote Yes because there is absolutely no proof that there's any correlation between what was just said and the test scores forget the fact that there's no correlation between the test scores and what's happening with our kids but having that extra director of literacy is
197not what the problem is Mr Woodson sorry five yes madame share and three no apologize five yes and four that one passes director of math is next Mr calic motion to approve the elimination of one director of mathematics as proposed by superintendent do Acting Superintendent Dr Avery second seconded by Mr Medina is there any debate on this item Miss bapti pres I want to raise my hand no uh uh I think this is again a critical area uh our students 87.7% of our students are below esack math the average SAT score in math for bridgport public high schools is 391 so it's below 400 anyone that thinks that there is no correlation to the people that are writing the curriculum that's writing the curriculum towards the test preparing the students towards the test I can't
198understand how uh the directors don't have a role when they're the ones writing the curriculum when they're the ones providing the professional support when they're the ones that's answering the questions and inquiries when they're the ones being invited to the schools uh to do the PDS you know our our our directors are are supposed to be our support staff so our buildings are actually instructional leaders so that way we can instruct our students towards success and so cutting one of these positions and then burdening it on one person to be over 500 plus teachers the district has 1,414 teachers in the district and only one director of math and right now this board has already approved one director of literacy and they're going to be the one person writing a curriculum that hasn't been completed
199for the third quarter or the fourth quarter I I just can't understand how people don't put the correlations as to when we don't invest in the resources it does not trickle down to our kids miss Bane okay um Dr bang here speaking um I just want to say that I don't I don't some of the stuff I agree with and some of the stuff I do not agree with but director of math and director of science director of literacy those three positions need to stay with the two and not the one but I know that this is um the majority vote is already had their hands in pulling out who needs to go so I'm going to put my vote out for no already that I don't want it to pass but it's not going
200to help because every because we all know who helped write this who helped pick this out so um I'm I'm I'mma sign off after this have a good night all right any further debate on this item Mr tror yeah I I just I I just think we're simplifying one director two directors it's a lot more than that and while uh the soap box is beautiful and we've been listening to the lectures from the soap box for the last year the issue is much much more complicated than what Miss batist Perez would have us believe so I'm just I yes the correlation is just not so simple and it's much more comp comp Lex and our children deserve owe so much more than the simple lecture from the soap box thank you we're going to take
201a vote on the director of Math Miss Perez I have my hand up it's my second time to speak during debate go for it okay thank you um so it's not a soapbox when we have teachers coming up and they in the area of math in one of our high schools requesting the print from a website that hasn't been vetted when we have teachers that are talking about they're experts but yet their children's are their children they're failing the test we have to provide the resources so that they can be successful in the classroom and we need to create that those resources and so that's part of the role with having more than one director of math because one person can't do it all with the amount of teachers in the district and one person
202can't be spread soin but yet that's why we have teachers printing out worksheets and then we wonder why our SATs scores are 30 and 391 in math that's why we are at the absolute lowest in the state in esack math we need to provide the resources the directors were doing that but we're going to reduce the directors and so I'm going to utilize my voice and voice that this is why it is harming children and you may not agree but I don't think you serve children because we should be providing them the educational outcomes that will guarantee them success richport shouldn't have to be a second chance City if the Board of Education gave children their first chance and cutting these roles or reducing a child's first chance to be successful out of school there's
203other school districts being sued right now in this state because they have graduates that can't read but we pushed through the system we shouldn't be one of those and we need to have our directors in order to make sure that our kids are ready but at the state of these test scores that's indicating something opposite when we have teachers wanting to print out worksheets that's opposite that's all I have Mr tror yeah I I'm I'm I won't prolong this it's late but I have spent the last 16 months but especially the last year here listening to Miss batist Perez abuse her position as chair of the Board of Ed to lecture us about her opinions and her personal point of view on education it is so far from the reality that I'm aware of and
204that most teachers are aware of who would disagree with her positions disagree with her view of education and what matters in education so I will leave it at that simply at that but it is not correct with regard to proper education and I will leave it at that thank you we're going to take a vote on elimination of director of one of the director of math roll call Dr Bane no Christine Baptist Paris no but because in the real world I don't know what reality some people live in our kids are failing and they're failing terribly in math and we should get them the outcomes they deserve because they can do it if given the proper resources and materials Miss aesa Casmir no the kids deserve better Mr William Medina yes Miss Jennifer Paris yes
205Mr Justice yes because the position the money to save could be used for th basically thousands of hours of tutoring which probably be more impactful on test scores Mr Robert tror yes because there are oh so many other things we could do for our children and they deserve oh so much better than and what they've been getting Mr Woodson no because our our our students deserve much better than what they had in the past getting the same thing and then five to four moving on to the director of science life skills Mr sakovic motion to eliminate the direct one director of science life skills as presented by Dr Avery is there a second seconded by Mr Medina do we have any debate Miss Baptist pres I mean for the same reasons that were stated in
206literacy and math I mean the the focus of using money to pay for tutoring tutoring is tier three instruction our students are already receiving tier three instruction that's why that could be part of the reason why we have poor performance and so investing in directors that are going to create the curriculum and the support system for tier one instruction the first time around so that tutoring Services aren't needed is the reason why we should keep the directors and science is one of those areas where our students have not been teaching to toward uh have not been taught in preparation for the test it's one of the areas that I've heard in my time on the board where we've had middle schools where there were no science teachers and parents were inquiring how they were going
207to get their kids into a magnet program if we didn't provide them with science in middle schools in middle school so again for the same reasons iterated you know we can't take away substitute tier one quality instruction for tier three tutoring because that's just a setup for failure Jaber um just to continue this mini debate and only because it's the first time in the year we've had a chance teaching to the test is not education education is so much more than teaching to ATT test our country for almost 25 years has been doing this teaching to the test so just we've been listening to to this narrative for over a year teaching to the test is not teaching any further debate I'm sorry I thought I clicked my hand up but I do have one
208uh something to say you know this whole thing about oh there's a problem teaching to the test we can't even with the way we're providing instruction Although our children can they are not passing the test and then what kind of teaching is going on if worksheets are just being printed out what kind kind of qualities and job opportunities are we really producing for our students for science since this is the topic that's up where are stem programs if we don't even have the science teachers there the same thing goes back to the curriculum if we're going to teach at least teach towards the test because that is our Benchmark as to how we're compared to other districts at least prepare them because going to be tested but what what are they learning if that's the
209case if we can't prepare them for the minimum Benchmark for the state then what are we teaching them the worksheets that's being printed for free you know it again it just goes back to providing low quality and then we end up spending more money on tier three tutoring to come in to try and make up for the fact that we haven't provided tier one instruction for the fact that we didn't have a curriculum for the fact that we haven't finish the curriculum you have to explain why there's a gap you can't be an honors student and then not make the minimum requirements for the state there's a disconnect will'll take the vote to call vote eliminate one director of science life skills Mr benan go ahead that Bane no for the same reasons Christine has
210a very valid point and um I know for fact that our students has been failing Mo long for a very long time and I think that we need to give them opportunity to the resources of a like she said tier one as opposed to tier three and I think we're doing a very dis doing a disservice by removing these people oppositions Christine Baptist Paris no for the reasons articulated in debate mamir no Mr William Medina St Miss Jennifer Paris yes Mr Justice Sak Mr Robert tror Mr Woodson Madam shair on 5 to4 that one passes next item is director of communications Mr zovic to eliminate the position of director of communications second second by Mr Medina Mr sovic would like to speak to that yes director of communications is a position we haven't had in
211decades If Ever I don't remember the last time we had one hasn't been during my tenure this is yet another position that was added in I think the last last year or so um we could get a long fine with the superintendent traditionally has communicated the needs of the district and if the commun if the superintendent is an effective Communicator the position of director of communications is obsolete Mr Woodson if we get rid of the director of communications who's going to Pro who's going to provide those duties all right go ahead we still have two additional people people in that division that will continue to work um prior to this year we had one person in that division doing the work uh and there's been another one a lower level position added this year as
212well to support the work so there's been three people in that department on top of the consultant okay Mr Woodson Miss Baptist Perez of I understand part of the the role of the direct of communications was to support the rebranding of the district you know the turning around of bridgport public schools so we can rise together toward success I know we've ended the the contract with the consultant but if we're going to just make decisions that go back to the status quo there's nothing to Reb brand and the same uh stigma that goes along with Bridgeport Public Schools uh will continue to exist you know there's no point in having someone Rebrand if we're going to just brand failure any further questions we're going to take a vote on the director eliminating the director of
213communications roll call vote that b she left the call sorry she left okay Christine bapti Paris no Mr Ben yes M Aisha Casmir I have stain Mr Willi Medina M Jennifer Paris yes Mr Joseph s yes Mr Robert tror it's Woodson seven yes yes one no one Obion one no one was yeah six yes was it six yes six yeses yeah um the next item so that motion passes the next item is Administrative special assignment administrative can you speak to that one what is that position so that's a position that's been um developed in the last couple of years typically um they're acting more or less as assistant principles in these schools um we have two that are acting as more or less assistant principles and one that is acting as the um executive director
214of internal and external communication I believe is the the the title but those are the three they're they're members of bass but they are uh assigned throughout the district where they're needed Miss casir yes I have a more of a question um so if there's an administrator on special assignment and they any what given of those positions are being eliminated or like when a an administrator an administrator on special assignment is given an opportunity to go back and teach in the classroom I wanted to clarify this like the first year whether it's a $1,000 reduction 25% reduction let's just say whichever it is and then the second year whether it's 2,000 or another 25% I don't you know for for for these purposes it doesn't matter but when the third year comes do they go
215back down to the teacher salary you know at the regular salary where they're teaching in the classroom is that how that goes that's correct so they would go onto wherever the salary scale that they fit in on the teachers contract would be um if they're after the third year correct in the third year they'd go back to the teachers contract on the salary scale okay just so I understand thank you any other questions on this one Mr sakovic yeah uh motion to eliminate one administrator on special assignment as proposed by Dr Avery second seconded by Mr Medina um Miss Casmir do you still have a question yeah did he say eliminate one administrative special assignment position or are we eliminating four I just want a clarification it sounded like Mrs sakovic said one I'm sorry
216they one I realized their microphones weren't on they um it was one so there is a proposal to eliminate one administrator on special assignment am I correct yes the proposal was to limitate only one so okay thank Miss Baptist Perez okay any further um debate on this item okay we can go ahead and take that vote roll call vote go ahead Mr benad Miss Christine b Baris pass mrir yes Mr William Medina see M Jennifer peris yes Mr Joseph sag yes Mr Rob Trevor Mr Woodson M Christine Baptist Paris I had to think about it I'm going to vote no because there again there's no really significant cost savings when you think about it we have to wait three years to see anything of impact mam sh St Jon want know thank you um the
217next item is um the discussion on assistant principles I actually goad Mr tror um Madam chair I uh want to move that we um defer on this item until the end of the year that we move to not eliminate these positions until the summer of 205 that we eliminate we I move that we eliminate these positions in the summer of 25 I guess I'll second is there a debate on this item it's been moved by Mr trayor seconded by Mrs kvic um Miss Baptist Perez I don't think this should be terminated this is decision now regarding the budget now if there's going to be cost savings um and after the facility's master plan comes out and let's just say hypothetically a building's empty and dangerous then there's no reason to eliminate these roles because those
218excuse me that amount that amount it would theoretically be the cost of Utilities in one of the buildings so if we're going to look to anything we should just table it for further consideration at the end of the school year because there's going to be other methods and and that's just based off of the facilities presentation that we had today where we have several empty buildings and back to yeah the motion is to to to table it until the end of the school year terminate them at school year I don't think they need to be terminated at the end of the school year you know Mr trabber yeah I'm the maker of the motion do I get to speak on my motion before batist Miss batist Perez goes go ahead thank you um it's my
219understanding from what we have heard today that there is no savings other than the $1,000 per position am I correct that's correct for the the first 12 calendar months 12 first year the the savings that we're going to realize this year is approximately $188,000 for the full year this in during this school year correct um and that if at the end of this school year um these positions um if the the individuals in these 18 positions are uh elect to leave the district voluntarily that we incur no other costs than that $188,000 they're not going to bump into a bargain unit position if they're higher salary they have voluntarily left the system and we have now realized the savings of that lost position if on the other hand an opening occurs within their bargaining unit
220the administrative bargaining unit then they will stay with our system feeling grateful that we didn't eliminate them position in the middle of the school year that's correct sir and so we will have a happy employee who is happy to still stay in the Bridgeport School System but I not be inaccurate yes sir okay so I it seems to me it's a win-win situation for us if we keep that position in place till the end of this Academic Year and if they choose to go on and pursue their administrative careers in another District this coming summer we've lost that Resource as we've lost so too many but at least at least we have kept that position to help in the position they are now for the rest of the school year and we have not saved
221$18,000 um a small cost to pay for keeping that position in the valuable place that it is now correct so that's why I make this motion as I've made it um it's a small price to pay for keeping that position where it does the most good for the rest of of the school year and if we lose them over the summer we lose them over the summer for that small price do you does that make sense to you too Mr Nel I mean for employee morale fine if that's what the board wants to do I mean at this point we we lose them we lose them over the summer we haveen we don't have to continue paying those added administrative costs as mandated by state law um and we if they bump into the bargain
222unit stay in the bargaining unit then they're going to be earning that additional cost doing a an administrative job if we lose them voluntarily um but the one if there's any residual that didn't live on their own or didn't take any administrative job we still have then we will incur that cost not having only lost $1,000 this year yes yes okay but maybe nro will take his but I see that as a win-win for us it is maybe nature will take its course that you know they might voluntarily leave and I mean again it's up to the employee decision okay yeah so that's the purpose of my making this motion Madam chair Mrs yeah thank you um yeah just a point of clarification on what Mr Traver said the motion is not to table the
223motion is to implement the cuts in the beginning of at the end of 2024 school year and I do support that it does make a lot of sense because rather than have people holding on and bumping teachers they may be in the interim looking for positions elsewhere with more stable employment and be able to land easier on their feet and save the district additional dollars rather than throwing them out to the Wolves today and we got to incur that for the next year as they bump everybody I think it would be much less disruptive to do so that way Mr Medina m CER so just so I understand if we vote to I guess prolong this or whatever word you want to use until the summer what if I'm just saying hypothetically speaking what if
224none of them decide to leave for another job then they would automatically get terminated is that what happens no going to be eliminated anyway right I [Music] mean yes so where we would be is exactly where we are today um in that we would start the clock ticking um at the end of the next school year they would be able to take a open teaching position and we'd start $1,000 less salary at that point okay thank you any Mr chamber Miss cmir I'm I'm banking on the fact that these are qualified administrators who if they want to continue to pursue their administrative careers would start looking at the end of the school year for an administrative position elsewhere if there was not an option available in the district and that's why I'm asking the question
225to The Experts that that know about this I'm just asking a hypothetical question as for your additional explanation I didn't need it I I didn't need it I understand you and I didn't need it and that's why I had asked the HR person or Mr niquo or whoever was doing this but thank you anyway but that's why I'm explaining that was what I was hoping that we we come out got it got it got it got it all righty so do we we have a motion on table to um say your motion again Mr tror put mik on my motion is that we um we uh I move that we eliminate the ad assistant principal positions um in tier the 18 administr uh assistant principal positions in Phase One tier one um effective the summer
226of 20125 okay any further debate on this item so the summer 2025 I just I just need clarification are we talking about the fiscal year or the end of the school year at the end of the fiscal year June June 30th end of the fiscal year okay roll call vote okay Miss Christine bapti Paris pass Mr Ben yes mrir pass Mr W Medina Miss Jennifer peris yes Mr Joseph suak yes Mr Robert trer yes Mr Woodson M Christine Paris I'm G vote no because I don't want any of the roles to go I mean I understand the human dignity part to it and building morale but they're they're a critical component in the building and so that just means the 25 26 school year will not be positive for children so that's why I'm voting
227no missir it's going to pass anyway let's delay the inevitable I'll say yes the next item is the supervisor of alternative education Dr Avery just want to make sure a point of clarity this this position is another name for an assistant principle so if you would apply that same concept to June 30th that would be appropriate it's uh an assistant principal of the um DET the Detention Center okay Mr shabber Mr stalic all thank you uh motion to approve the elimination of one supervisor of alternate education effective at the end of the fiscal year second second and by Mr Medina do we have debate on this item Miss cmir yes uh I just wanted to say so for years from what my understanding is is there was no building administrator at all as a matter
228of fact I hadn't even known that the Bridgeport Board of Education was responsible for the kids over at Juvenile Detention so I remember us taking a tour over there um when Dr Levy David was here and there was no building administrator over there at all um so I understand the kids are locked up uh you know but just one you know and we're eliminating that that one right because the supervisor it's just one yeah I I just I don't agree with that but but that's all I wanted to say can I ask Dr ay who like what what um if we eliminated this position who's kind of going to be in charge of that that role in the in the past they have um used the split so it would be somebody who does it
229part-time basically they'd be an assistant principal at one school and overseeing the jdc at the same time okay and we're we're responsible for funding that given that it's in bridport even though I believe that's Grant those are Grant funded I believe so and a lot of those students are not or not a lot but a lot of those students either come from bridgport or not from Bridgeport and we're we're covering the cost yes yes I think the state provides additional dollars for that and so in in that grant funding there's administrative cost that can be allocated to you know where you it's like a shared cost so if we have assistant principle that may go and supervise that building you know twice or three times a week uh then we have a cost savings where
230we can kind of allocate that cost to that particular salary of that particular AP they been doing it that way for years okay that's all my questions I got it thank you Miss batis Perez I guess I'm thinking long term it just because that's how it was done in the past doesn't mean it necessarily gave you know the students their second chance and then it's only one position and then if we're looking at the 25 26 school year and we're getting rid of APs based on the last vote and we're going to eliminate this position I just don't see what's the point in spreading it so thin we have a grant writer why don't we apply for additional grants I don't I don't see why cutting this one rle is necessary missusa cic and then
231I'll go to miss I'll go back to um oh thank you apologize just want to make sure nobody get skipped um Dr Avery how many students are in D deten Detention Center at any one time uh I think it it fluctuates from day to day a lot of the students are there three or four days until they're you know uh processed to either another facility or they processed to go back home to be served at their particular um uh District so I would say the time I visited approximately you know 20 to 25 students and are those all bridgeboard students no they're all uh students from across the the region thank you Miss Casmir yeah so the reason why they're not all Bridgeport students is because students outside of Bridgeport get in trouble and the
232facility itself self is located in Bridgeport that's the reason why the Bridgeport Public School System is in charge and secondly Dr Avery do you do you have any idea of the how those kids are doing with test scores like even though they're locked up over there are is it the same pretty much like failing scale that we have for the rest of the district do you see any difference yes no just wanted to I was wondering about that what happens is those those test scores go they go directly back to that individual campus they may take the test there uh and the test will follow that kid back to the district that they're they're coming from so it just depends on how you equate that depending on if there's like five or 10 kids you
233know from a different spe specific District or campus uh it follows them back so I can't I don't really have that data in front of me to cleare that for you gotcha okay thank you tror yeah I the um it's not even it's primarily Fairfield County but it's not unique to Fairfield County when I was in there there was a student from out of state um so it it it it's really the test scores go back to this to the students District um so it just will vary um and sometimes they're not in just from Fairfield County they could be from New Haven County who happen to be down here for some particular legal reason so it's just we take care of them because as you said Miss Casmir they're sitting in our in our
234city um so we have teachers that go in there to teach them but um they can be from all over and our the test scores are not at all tied into our district other than our students that's exactly what was just said yeah that was exactly what was just said thank you Mr Medina thank you madam chair some people say uh assumptions make people look like a fool so I'm going to ask this question um knowing that the supervisor of alternative education will be voted on today that this doesn't mean because this will be voted out this position that we're going to be leaving them without the resources of the support correct that is correct thank you very much all right let's take a vote on this item roll call it's going to be roll
235called for the elimination of the supervisor of alternative education at the end of this fiscal year Mr ban thank you Christine me peris pass Mr benan yes Mr kak Amir no Mr Willie Medina Miss Jennifer peris yes Mr Joseph sik yes Mr Robert travor yes Mr Woodson Miss Christine Baptist Paris no the next item is for director uh supervisor of something Dr AB yes I'm sorry the vote on that um five yes five yes three no it passes the next item can you clarify what that position is yeah District district supervisor specialized Services specialized Services okay um okay so this item is District supervisor specialized Services anybody have any discussion on this item two positions Miss cmir just so I understand these are people who work in special ed specialized services mean special ed or
236is it something different that is correct thank you and then this one is the revised one where we're not limiting four you're limiting two that's correct Mr calovic thank you motion to approve the elimination of what is it three two two positions for district supervised specialized as presented by Dr Avery all right the Motions been made by Mr cvic is there a second second second by Mr Medina we're in debate Mr skic do you have anything no thank you Miss Baptist Perez against special education is one of our most vulnerable areas as a school district I don't support eliminating any position from special education you know we we're behind and so eliminating any numbers to the support staff there and then saying that people are going to work overtime that has not worked in the
237past and it will probably more than likely not work in the future any other comments on this one all right we could take a vote on the elimination of two positions for roll call vote special ed District supervisor for special ed um roll call Mr benan go ahead Christine Bap Paris pass Mr benan yes Mr Kisha camir no Mr Willam Medina Miss Jennifer Paris I'm pass this one Mr Justice ugly yes Mr Robert travor Mr Woodson is Christin Bap Paris no and Miss Jennifer Paris I'm abstaining from this one give me one second four three and one exstension yes the motion carries next is the its District infrastructure operations manager is there a motion Mr sakal has a motion motion to eliminate the its District infrastructure operations manager as presented by Dr a motions been
238made by Mr sovic there a second second Mr Medina second as a maker in motion do you have anything for that uh yeah could you just describe the position for us please Dr Avery this position isn't it uh it's a technology position that uh this person kind of helps manage the infrastructure of the district and I'm not sure if Jeff is here to give you a little bit more detail on that he's not um so PJ P PJ is gonna take this one um she provides Network infrastructure support uh I know that she has um yeah she has a few uh staff members under her right now but that's all I can give you that's that's all I really know yeah in talking with Jeff it was a one of the positions that he felt
239you know he could you know manage without and then re redistribute the work yeah I could speak to that that uh when we spoke to Jeff he certainly said that he can re redistribute that work um that that position wasn't necessarily um needed at that point so he felt he can give the work out to other people Miss B bre is this the position where the person's going to be placed in a different role or is this an actual elimination it's my understanding it's going to be an elimination I just don't feel comfortable eliminating a role when I don't have a full understanding of the role or its impact on the district and so it would have been helpful for the decision and discussion tonight that we would have been provided with at least the
240duties the qualifications of each one of these roles before making such an important decision than you thank you thank you is there any other discussion on this one um I I actually can we you already made a motion but I'm see referring this one to committee because that is a department that is spread then just so we get more knowledge but if there's already a motion already a motion we've got a dispose of that motion first whether it passes or not then we could recommit it would you consider taking back your motion or do you want to go with the vote uh I would like to hear the vote go the vote Yes ma'am all right we'll go with the vote roll call vote roll card Christin bapti Paris yes Mr kameir no Mr William
241Medina see Jennifer Paris no Mr jce s you want the mic yes Mr Robert tror Mr Woodson and Mr B yes m FIS no the motion fails I want to make a motion to refer the its District infrastructure operation manager back to committee to so we get a um bigger picture of what that would look like seconded by Mr tror um all in favor say I no we're back in debate any debate on that seeing no debate all in favor roll call vote we're GNA roll call that one we didn't we didn't it was there was no debate so all in favor I roll calling um sending this back to committee Mr benan one second oh you're on Bap Paris missir yes back to committee Mr William Medina see M Jennifer peris yes Mr Justice
242s yes Mr Robert tror Mr Woodson M Christine Baptist Paris abstain Mr benan yes six yes one no and one St mam chair it passes then next item is the district teacher development specialist point out Clarity the yes these positions were uh just created maybe what four months ago uh and they are a another name for instructional coaches and there's three of them that we're asking for elimination how are there there's three of them what um are they they're at the office like central office level and are they in the schools what are they doing no they're they're H they're um they assist the director their housed at 45 Lion Terrace and and what are their what's their role their role is to help with PD for the teachers throughout the district what would be
243the plan for professional development if we limited these positions a combination of the directors the assistant superintendent you know variety of everybody I mean we're all going to have to do um dual roles to kind of support the work for the academic side uh and so those would definitely be uh areas that we can kind of um divide and conquer with to provide the additional support that's needed um questions from board members Mrs calic yeah I'd like to make a motion to eliminate the three positions of District teacher development specialist as presented by Dr Avery that was Mo made motion made by Mrs calic it was seconded by Mr Medina Mrs scovic do you have anything for that no ma'am any debate Miss Baptist Perez all right so we just fired a director of math
244literacy and Sciences uh what areas are these teacher development specialists in and what grades I'm not 100% sure exactly what grade uh in what departments I mean most of the times with coaches they can do a variety of different uh content areas uh it's like a mix um um you know opportunity to be able to kind of provide that generalized uh support in the area that is needed were they helping with the curriculum I'm thinking they are they were helping with curriculum in some fashion I'm not 100% sure exactly what that role is or was okay so again we're looking to let go positions and we don't know what they're doing we haven't been given information to it they're working on a curriculum that's not completed and we've already eliminated directors it can you just
245make it make sense for me how it's going to get done and how that's going to help the educational outcomes for students how are we going to close the gap if we keep firing the people that's supposed to help us close it point of information Mr scal has a point of information yes we're not firing anybody we're making layoffs firing has a different connotation than layoffs so okay great how would laying off these individuals who will no longer be available help with closing the educational Gap and why weren't we provided with their roles and what they're specifically doing so we can make an informed decision Mr Traer we're trying to address a budget shortcoming that we've been anticipating for a while some of us have been predicting this for years and it was ignored over
246the last year and a half and so now we're trying to address it so I I can understand why you're a little confused about it but that's what we're trying to address and it doesn't look good because we shouldn't have been doing some of the things we've done now you you raised the question of um development Specialists um and wondered we've added these positions in the fall I'm assuming they started before the school year started that these positions were in place and yet I heard the horror stories about the training that we didn't provide to teachers this fall um so I'm wondering what they did to help make that such a wonderful process for the teachers this fall but that's not the point we're looking at here what we're looking at and seems to be
247ignored by you Miss bati Perez is that we have a 40 million doll deficit we're looking at next fall and so what we're trying to get ahead of is that curve that's coming down the pike and so you want to ignore it but we're looking at it and and it's not a pleasant curve so I get why you're confused but it's coming and so some of these things are going to be quite unpleasant and we've gone through it before six years ago 12 years ago and it's not going to be pleasant next fall when we can't provide any service to the students Mr Woodson well we we all understand why the cuts have to be made but a couple weeks ago when you had the people from kbe here and they were in front of
248you and they were making demands of you and you caved right in front of them I didn't you caved I did not will crying we're gonna go back to he believed Mr Mr we're gon go back to the actual motion we're gonna go V mron the motion is to eliminate Mr tror Mr Glon the motion is to eliminate three positions I I have my hand Miss I got you miss Baptist I mean it thank you for me that it's existed for for years the failure in this District we wouldn't be an alliance District if we weren't failing for years and I I I guess I'm starting to finally see your reality your reality must be a board of education doesn't have to provide an education we just have to balance a budget uh because I'm
249more focused on the educational quality and creating educational opportunities so our students can be successful leaders for the future and so like I've mentioned there's just been other areas that have not been considered and yet we've cut and we've cut and we've cut we don't even know what these District teacher development Specialists are doing we haven't been given clarification on their roles we know that they're assisting with the curriculum we already know that we've cut the people that write the curriculum such as the liter one literacy director knowing that they could have uh absorbed another role that was not put up for consideration so uh I I thank you for helping me realize your reality is a board of education not focused on education Mr tror as long as we're going to allow this charade
250to continue and having listened to it for the last year um the reality is that we have not seen anybody providing an education from this board for the last year and whether it's last week when or the last year we have watched the soapbox and the soapbox continues this is not a board that is interested in has not been a board that's interested in providing an education to our children it is a board that has been doing a dance around that question um so what we're now looking at is an economic reality that is going to come on like a sledgehammer in the next year and it scares the beesus out of me because this is going to be scary next year I was here when we had to eliminate all of the kindergarten Paras
251that affects education and I don't know if you understand how serious that is this is minor compared to what we're looking at next fall um and this is the beginning of what we're going to be looking at next fall so you can describe it any way you want Miss bati Perez but I am just terrified about what we're going to be looking at with our parents in the community next fall and the kibbe thing was was just a joke and and unfortunately it got through no matter what I tried to do but this is the beginning of a scary scary year and you're still not coming to grips with it any further comments Mr kic thank you madam chair yes um to Mr tra's point and to the point of all these budget cuts right
252now we are at approximately if this one is approved we are about $6 million in cuts which is approximately half of the escalated costs we have so it's so we're not we're not we we got half a dent in escalated course are we in a much better position than we were a month ago yes because we got right now we're tapping into the internal service fund at approximately $6 million less at the best at the worst we will save this money three years from now which we still need the savings three years from now we need to keep these savings throughout the district until we can secure more money thank you seeing no further questions for the bate um we'll take a vote on this roll call vote the roll call vote for elimination of
253the three Specialists Mr benan thank you Christine mat peris pass Mr benan yes Mr Aisha Casmir no Mr William Medina see M Jennifer peris yes Mr Joseph Sak yes Mr Robert tror yes Mr Woodson is Christine Baptist Paris no the next the I the motion carries three no five yes five to three the next item is community facilitator Dr second can you explain that please goad Dr saki um yes good evening the uh the community facilitator um is um someone who actually helps us with our chronic absenteeism um the focus is on the leap home visitor and the um leap coordinators who support the leap home visitors um individual also works um with helping to um support some of our mentoring programs so that's the particular position um this position half of this position was
254through um a grant the other half was through um District funds um so we're able to cover it for half of the year and not for the second half of the year can I ask um who would be um covering the chronic aism so um our director um ofcl and student um Services um will be um picking up um that task okay thank mrsic motion to approve the elimination of the community facilitator as presented by Dr Avery I turned my mic off seconded by Mr Medina Mr sakalik yeah just really really fast quick Qui quick question when was this position created um this position was created at the beginning of this year um through um the leap Grant we had some flexibility in terms of how some of that money was spent um and so
255you know the understanding again was that half would be through the Grant and then the other half through the District budget right and there's other avenues that the grant funding could be spent upon correct um most justce position rather than just this position I see Mr nodding his head yes can you repeat it I don't think he heard what you said you didn't know Grant Madam chair the grant money can be apply towards retention of some of the positions that is not been eliminated thank you Miss Casmir uh yes uh Dr saki can can you repeat for me how they plan to fill the shoes of this position like what's going to happen with it again um so our um director of um and student services um will be assisting um in collaboration with the
256leap facilitators um obviously whenever you um eliminate a position and you put the um the workload on someone else it just adds more um so the again the director of um and student services in collaboration with the leap home visitors who be assistant with this oh okay because they do have to be outside of the school a lot because you got kids that are just not coming to school and so they go into the neighborhoods and they knock on the door and they you know try to find out what's going on so that's why I had wanted clarification um for that thank you yes thank you Mrs Baptist perz what's the rate of absenteeism in bridor public schools right now and have we seen a change since the creation of this role um I'll say
257um when we first um looked at the data from last year um you know I'll say Statewide um we probably showed um the biggest drop um this year we did change the structure of our LEAP program um I can get you the exact numbers I don't um know those off the top of my head I can get you the the specific numbers um between the start of school and now it had remain um flat um we're looking to do some more um rebranding in terms of advertising of the importance of school in addition to what we're doing with our leap facilitators as well as the support that's being given to the school attendance teams um to hopefully help um continue to bring that number down any further questions thank you we go ahead and take
258that vote roll all right we're gonna do a roll call um tristine Baptist Perez Yes Albert benan stepped out Aisha cmir no Willie Medina yes Jennifer PR J Joseph cvic yeah Robert Traer Andre Woodson Christine Baptist Perez no it carries 53 uh 43 next item Executive Administrative Assistant looking to eliminate three administrative assistants executive level administrative assistants Mr calovic to approve the elimination of three Executives Administration exist administrative assistance as presented by Dr Avery it's been seconded by Mr Medina Miss Casmir Madam shair oh I'm sorry Mr svic you have the floor first then we'll go to miss Cas yes two quick questions when were these positions made and all these executive director I mean these um administrative assistance assistance to some of the people we already voted to get rid of I mean um
259Le off I apologize for the choice words getting tired this is a new newly created position within the last year uh that these Executive Administrative assistance um have been have been added uh they do support uh some of the people who will be eliminated or um rebranded throughout the district correct that's correct Miss casimer um my question is is one of these positions the position of the executive assistant that is for the board just for the board only no that's interwined in this it is not okay that's what I wanted to know thank you I believe you're talking about Miss uh Miss kashan yes yes no that is not her that is not her position okay thank you Miss Baptist forz and what areas are these executive administrators or Administrative Assistant are they in the
260office of the superintendent the office of the Deputy superintendent um they are currently stationed in the off of the superintendent uh the office of the chief academic officer as well as the uh executive director of uh School leadership any further questions from board members we're going to take a vote on it it's going to be a roll call vote um for the three executive administrative assistants Miss Baptist Perez pass Miss cmir abstain um Mr Medina Miss Perez yes uh svic Mr svic Mr trabber Mr Woodson yes Miss benan is back go ahead Miss Baptist Perez abstain all right so that one carries with one two 3 four five six yeses and two extensions the next item is human resource project assistant go ahead you had to okay Mr talic yeah I make a motion to
261remove the human resource project assistant as presented by Dr Avery second and by Mr um Medina do we have any debate uh Mr sovic do you have anything no thank Miss cimer yes just um warning to can someone give me a couple of examples of what projects that the human resources project assistant works on or has worked on I just want to get a better sense of the role sure the main thing that the project assistant worked on was the transition from Frontline to Red Rover it's our uh job posting system as well as our absence um system so it was a rather large project to switch over from Frontline to Red Rover uh the human resources project assistant um that would be what I would classify as her biggest project that was going on
262um she has been involved in other it things as far as the website for HR um but that would be her biggest contribution thank you Miss bis Perez are we fully integrated into Red Rover we are about 75% integrated into Red Rover um and I don't particularly know if we'll get any much further than the 75% because we are going to be switching over at some point to Microsoft Dynamics which will integrate everything and it'll be more of a one-size fits-all kind of program well the moving over to Microsoft require an assistant that will help with the integration process as to what was done with Red Rover no I think we we could be we could do it without this particular position um I I don't see the reason why this position would um be
263needed for that project does this position assists with onboarding I know that's critical for your department it is and it this position really does not do that it um it originally was involved in that when we were making the transition from front line to red brover but since other members of the department have taken over the onboarding and when when she was involved in onboarding it was a very small uh portion of her duties um it's been dispersed amongst other people in the office right now any further questions all right there's a roll call requested for this so we'll take the vote for elimination of the human resource project assistant Mr benan your mic is on there Christine Baptist Paris pass is Ben yes Mr here AB Mr William Medina Miss Jennifer Paris yes Mr
264Joseph Sak yes Mr Robert Traer Mr Woodson M CHR Paris yes okay seven yes seven yes one obain zero seven yeses one exstension that carries next item is is the typist one that's for one typist Mr calovic motion to eliminate one position for the title of T typist one as presented by Dr Avery is there a second seconded by Mr Medina Mr Sak do you have any questions are there any other questions for debate Miss Baptist pz and which department is the typist the IST is basically a school it's like a secretarial position um not crazy about the the title of the job but um these typists are doing secretarial work in the schools uh this is a nage Affiliated position um and these typists have been around for a while so this particular typist
265uh would be able to bump to another position um either in the city or the Board of Ed and so if they bump to another position in the Border B do we have a cost savings no I I misspoke they would they could potentially uh go to a typus but we would be eliminating the least senior Board of Ed typist so they would be able to bump in the city because actually there's qu uh there's open positions in the city now for typist one any further questions we have take a vote if requested a roll call go ahead Christine M Paris pass airain Mr will Medina Mr benan yes M Jennifer Perez yes Mr Jose S yes Mr Robert tror yes Mr Woodson Mr CHR Paris next all right to obain Madame shair one two
266three four five six six yeses two abstentions that one passes the last one is clerical assistant for 12 months six positions are on the table Mr sakovic motion to eliminate clerical assistant 12mth positions as presented by Dr Avery is there a second seconded by Mr Med is there um do you have anything on that Mrs cic any other uh debate Miss Baptist Perez can we have a description as to what departments they're in and what they're doing sure so again this is another secretarial type of position they're scattered throughout the district uh as far as the different departments so um special education um payroll benefits uh and the others are located at schools So when you say special education is that like the assistant that's in charge of making sure we're submitting paperwork to the
267state that we're in compliance like that kind of Secretarial duties no these would be very basic secretarial duties phone answering taking notes those types of Duties that's what's in their job description that's what they should be doing okay so can you just tell me more about the special education one like so if a parent has an inquiry as to a PPT and they call that's who they'll be talking to yes and actually that position is actually open right now so that wouldn't be filled and that's been open [Music] for a few months now so um we just wouldn't fill that and that would be part of our our positions that are eliminated okay so we we don't even have someone picking up the phone for parents when it comes to special education and so we
268wouldn't even bother to place for that okay no further questions Dr Avery you good okay um any further debate it's gonna be a roll call vote Mr benan Christine M Paris pass this AA Casmir abstain Mr will Medina M Jennifer Paris yes j s yes Mr Robert tror Mr wson Mr Ben yes M Baptist peris uh I would have voted yes but I had I take an issue with anything involving cuts to special education so I'm going to vote no thank you five yes two no one M Madam chair five yes two no one abstention that one passes is's any further discussion tonight all right motion to adjourn don't move moved by Mr benan seconded by Mrs kvic all in favor say I I any opposed opposed all right it passes have a good night
269Merry Christmas everybody and happy holidays drive safe in this weather we're ending at 1222 what