001e e I also need to roll call good okay um in attendance today I'm I'm the chair Jennifer Perez we have Mr calovic uh Mr trabber Mr benan um Miss cmir is joining virtually Mr Woodson is joining virtually is that all believe that's all and so we'll have public comment right now um just Resto I'm Jess rro 1110 Jennings Avenue I'd like to congratulate each of you on stepping up into your new roles I truly hope this marks um new beginning of positive and brighter chapter for all of us as someone involved in our community I regularly hear from staff students and parents the feedback I receive from other of I receive often reflects a sense of frustration and distrust especially when it comes to feeling that their voices and needs have been overlooked the
002sentiment unfortunately stems from the past experiences and Community fors where many felt disrespected by the dismissive and dis engaging approach of previous leadership despite these challenges I remain hopeful hopeful for change for growth and for a renewed commitment to transparency and collaboration I recognize that many of the faces I recognize that many of the faces and Leadership positions today are familiar and while that may bring up concerns from past disappointments I see this as an opportunity for Renewal a chance for Redemption and progress one one issue I like to one issue I'd like to highlight is the urgent need to restructure our committees as Miss Sweeny wisely pointed out during the last board meeting we must work together to harness our Collective strengths and a productive and focused way we faced budget challenges before but
003seeing continued unchecked spending while being assured there was nothing to worry about raises serious concerns as the CFO mentioned if the house was clean I wouldn't have been called to sweep it up it's clear that there's been a lack of financial oversight and this needs to be addressed for the sake of accountability and fiscal resp fiscal responsibility the recent vote of no confidence from the teacher of our teachers is a powerful message not just to the superintendent but also to the board we all want to see how those responsible for these CH challenges will make things right accountability must be a priority behind closed doors discussions only serve to increase suspicion and distrust making it hard to rebuild the confidence of the community I urge this board to embrace transparency accountability and open communication we
004need to rebuild trust and that can only happen when the needs and the voices of our students staff and parents are truly heard and prioritized public meetings should be just that public and open to the community thank you thank you the next item on our agenda um is the discussion of possible action including but not limited to authorizing the board chairperson to execute an agreement on behalf of the Board of Education concerning um proposed separation agreement between superintendent Dr Carmela Levy David and the bridgeboard Board of Education this item does qualify for executive session as it discusses first now um so would like anybody like to make a motion Mr Traer Mak a motion to go into executive session I'll second Mr seconding that um okay if we go into executive session our attorney board
005our board attorneys Mr Floyd Dugas and Mr bro and our City attorney Mark Anastasia would join us along with the board I'd like to be acknowledged I'm in attendance I was going there so just one moment and um just for that portion in attendance we have uh Willie Medina and Christine Baptist forz who joined virtually so um we can go ahead and take a vote all in favor say I I any opposed executive session any abstentions okay uh board members who are joining virtually you have a link um and a separate link and you can join that link now we'll be heading to exe executive session now thank you madam chair just in case I have not received that yet so if you can have technical uh take a look at that please we'll do
006thank you e e e all right all right we're g to come back to order um the time is 7:14 um is there any motion Mr trabber Madam chair I make a motion to approve and author uiz the board chairperson to execute on behalf of the board the agreement discussed in executive session concerning the separation of superintendent Dr we the agreement um let me start that over I make a motion to approve and authorize the board chairperson to execute on behalf of the board the agreement this discussed an executive session concerning the separation of superintendent Dr Carmela leevy David I second that the motion was moved by Mr Traer and seconded by Mr benan um do we have any debate on there right we're just gonna go into okay um all in favor say I
007okay there's G to be a roll call thank you m chair T yes approve Miss Christine Baptist Paris be back for her Misha Casmir I'll be back for her Mr Willie Medina yes Miss Jennifer peris yes Mr Robert Traer yes Mr Andre Woodson no going back to Miss Christine Paris Miss Christine Baptist Paris okay can you say her name again Miss Christine Baptist bares uh sorry I lost connection we're taking the vote Yes yeah I approve it sorry she said yes yes okay myself Mr benan yes and Mr Jose S no with a brief explanation I think at this point in time while I do wish the superintendent well and that it's best that we separate service at this point in time I do not agree with the package being offered at this time I
008would not agree with any package being offered to any employee being severed and I wish Dr leevy David well in our future Endeavors and hope of for success in your future life thank you well then shair we have six yes and two no okay the motion passes all right the next item on the agenda is the presentation of the bud of the bridport public schools uh fiscal year4 25 potential budget Gap closing measures and Mr Dr sorry Dr Avery will be presenting on that good evening everyone can I get the presentation um post it oh Danielle Danielle's gonna hand out copies of the presentation to the board members that are present uh Nester is going to email uh the presentation to the board members that are online uh this item was supposed to be an
009executive session but I don't think we have the votes to do that so I want to make sure that every all board members have a copy of it uh uh present uh for the community you'll have an opportunity to have uh uh a view of of my presentation as I go through the presentation um so and then it will also be um I think we can put it on our website as well once we go through the presentation uh so good evening again my name is Dr Royce Avery the acting school superintendent for bridor public schools I I do want to extend a a huge thank thank you to my executive you know leadership team uh we've been working uh behind the scenes trying to kind of get uh budget proposals ready for the board
010uh you know for several weeks now uh it's been you know a very you know tedious process but I think we're we're at a we're at a point where we could we feel comfortable providing some things that we are uh ready and willing to be able to execute uh and so we would like for you to kind of understand the presentation I'm going to have um uh several slides that I will review uh and then Nester has a couple of slides at the end that's going to give you a little bit uh deeper context to the budgetary uh process that we have been through uh so that we can have some clarity to some of the items that I have so n you may have you may go ahead and uh send that email out
011that'll be great board members online uh you should be receiving uh that document shortly uh it's the same document that's going to be presented uh online as well again it's not working you may have to help me here slide's not advancing Perfect all right just to kind of a quick introduction uh there's there's we've been through a the first two phases of this process uh immediate actions things that we can do right now to try to you know uh look at how we can trim the budget and do some things we also have have done a deep dive into the Personnel uh and structural review uh phases three and four um I've decided to I think the board has to have a little bit more vested interest in really going through uh programs that the
012districts are using that that's electronic programs and direct programs and also looking at vendors uh you know contracts that we have across the district and really making sure that those things that we we started back in 2020 when we had erer dollars uh to make sure that we could um you know still need those products or we don't have duplicate duplications of pro of of programs that we um are currently using and and I know in a a the view of that there's a there's some programs that I know that we may be able to kind of combine do away with uh and and I want the board to be able to help go through that process the last phase there phase four is just really looking at strategic initiatives things that as a district
013uh if we collaborate with the community there's things and that we may be able to consider that would be cost-saving measures for uh this District uh they may be very hard decisions to make but I think as a collaborative effort uh we should be able to have some real good opportunities to um um save money streamline things get the community involved in what we're doing and so I'm also going to move those things back to committee uh and I think the board uh will be um very helpful uh in figuring out what that's going to look like so uh I'm very excited to kind of present my my presentation so the first thing that that we've done in this first phase uh it was really looking at you know the internal perspectives of brido public
014schools uh um the team and I looked at you know things that we could do differently in order to be able to um you know uh not add any additional uh dollars to the budget uh again looking at you know non-essential purchases that we were making across the dist District uh some of the recruiting efforts that we were doing really just trying to make sure that we slow down things and really be strategic as to the things that we take on uh in addition to that we we we provided a um uh an internal freeze for um you know certain positions you know within the district we we we did away we stayed away from special education and English language learning positions across the district because those are vital positions that we are uh struggling
015to fill across the across the district uh and I think there's a lot of districts across Connecticut is is dealing with those same kinds of concerns with with the special ed teachers and the English language learning teachers so we tried to avoid that and then back uh on uh November the 8th uh our um uh Chief Financial Officer uh sent email Communications across the district uh in order to make sure that we um um verified and and clarify exactly what that means and so um uh this is a copy of the of the email that went out to staff really un trying to make sure everybody understand of things that we we took on preo and the things that we're that we're dealing with postco making sure that we try to understand all the things
016we purchased back then and where we are now and are we still using those those purchases are still having those staffs on um on staff uh and can we continue to afford continuing those things so we we've done a lot of those internal Lookouts in order to make sure that we could um really you know give this uh the board uh a better idea of how we can save a little bit of money the second phase and this has been a very intense very you know strategic uh very in you know in-depth process so when you when on the first thing here it talks about reviewing hiring since 2020 uh and that's that's right before covid uh when we the do the district had you know several M million dollars that to work with to
017try to make sure that we could do some additional work for kids and staff throughout the district um but we really took a look at uh you know positions that were added uh August 2023 really trying to understand you know uh what was added within the last year year and a half uh in the district then we went through the restructure of central office staff looking at some of the things that has happened with central office staff over the last couple of years uh and uh as you as in in the next couple of slides you'll you'll see a a current you know organizational chart of where we stand right now at Central LA office and the propose that I'm going to be proposing as we transition into a whole new structure uh in um
018central office I think one of the other things that uh I'm I want to really emphasize to the board and to the community is that uh there's been a lot of conversation you know in the community that's gotten back to me that has has gotten to the board about you know salaries of of central office staff um and and one of the things that I think it was you know uh Putin of of of my team we talked about if we're going to do any type of restructuring you know anything that we need to do we need to start at the top uh and so one of the things and one of the suggestions that the team has made is that uh the central office staff my cabinet will take a two week Furlow unpaid
019Furlow uh in order to start this process off uh and making sure that everyone in this community understands that we're we're in it with them uh as as we start you know looking at you know you know budget budget you know cuts and all those things re reshuffling and re um allocating funds across this District we felt we needed to be the ones to start to start this U this process off and so that's where they came up and we suggested that we would do a two two week unpaid Furlow uh for all cabinet members the the next impact that that's really has is going to be a driving force for how we do this restructuring across uh across our district is the impact of the labor contracts the teacher the teacher unions and the
020administrative unions have very unique specific contracts on how you uh you know if you're going to um uh do a reduction in force how you have to do that so there's bumping rights that teachers may have there's bumping rights that administrators may have and they're very intrical uh so as you see some of the the positions that I'm going to be um uh put putting up for considerations uh we we will probably not see the full you know amount of salary savings uh this first year uh because in those Union contracts sometimes it's like a one one year you get a certain amount second year you get a certain amount and the third year get a certain amount so we have to follow those contracts uh and so that's a very intrical part that that
021uh the team human resource offices will have to kind of you know guide uh this work the other part of that is really analyzing the financial ramifications and what that means is that um due to the fact that we're going to reduce staff the work still has to get done you know and so as as you see in my proposal there's about 95 positions that we are looking to consider you know uh eliminating uh and when you do that uh the work still has to get done you know there the accountability of of this district and accountability of of our staff to make sure kids you know are are learning the academic growth of kids that's been and that's kind of what the analyzation of the ramification of what we do uh we can't just
022can't randomly do it you there's there's all kinds of things you have to consider uh as you um you know engage in this type of exercise when it comes to trying to reduce um um to gain dollars to to help you know fund the budget so I would like to move into the current structure of of how we're doing business and and due to the fact that we've we've shuffled some things this is how it looks currently uh you have the Acting Superintendent in the middle uh you know you have the deputy superintendent on one side which is vacant is the position that I came out of and then you have the chief of staff uh down below uh you have the assistant superintendent for school leadership uh and that person currently holds an 093
023to be able to supervise the individuals below them and so you have under under um that direction of that assistant superintendent you have a chief a chief academic officer um you have the chief of special education uh and uh within those the Chief the chief academic officer has eight academic directors that's currently under her uh that position's uh direction also that position has an executive director for school leadership uh and then you have two executive directors for school leadership uh and the the two executive directors for leadership and the the two I mean the one executive director for school turnaround supervises principles so it goes principls the executive directors you know then it goes back up to the academic um uh the chief academic officer and then it goes from the directors back up to
024the uh Chief academic officer as well so the chief academic officer kind of you know you know really spearheads the academic growth of the district uh you know the academic directors are your your math science Ela um I think the is fine arts uh Early Childhood so those those individuals and then we have two uh math directors two science directors and two Ela directors that makes up those eight act School academic uh directors uh in addition to um special ed in academics the the assistant that super assistant superintendent uh governs the communications of the district as well uh on the other side you have the chief human resource officer the chief operating off uh Operating Officer the Chief Financial Officer and the director of data management uh those individuals report directly up to uh the
025superintendent so so when you look at that in the hole that's the the the the upper administrative staff of the district that's how it's being run today uh as we see it the proposed you know and again if just just take another step backwards the the the salaries that are over $100,000 you have two top level administrators the deputy superintendent and the chief of staff then you have the executive level you have the two executive directors of school leadership and then you have the the executive director for special education then you have the three academic directors that will that will be reduced as well with the communications director the the human resource project assistant or the specialist level and then the communication the community facilitator these are the positions that will that you will not
026see in the new uh organizational chart now you take a look at the uh proposed organizational chart uh you have the Acting Superintendent uh you see the two green box is you have the existing assistant superintendent for school leadership and then you have the the the re um um reclassification of the chief academic officer to an assistant superintendent for curriculum and instruction uh and so when you look at that you have uh the assistant superintendent for school leadership uh will be in charge of uh special education uh also Communications and then I will split I'm proposing to split the elementary pre prek-8 schools with some will go to the assistant superintendent for school leadership and some will go to the assistant superintendent for curriculum instruction uh and then when you look at the curriculum instruction
027side we reduced the academic directors to you know five directors you know eliminating one from math uh one math director one science director and one Ela director leaving five directors that so that all content erors will be supported uh as we move forward uh and then the school turnaround uh the assistant superintendent will be uh in charge of that so when you look straight down the middle uh it's the same individuals uh the the chief human resource officer the Chief Operating Officer the Chief Financial Officer and the the director of data management I've changed that position to the Chief Information officer which uh all the data systems in The District in addition to technology will be housed in the Chief Information officer's position in addition to that all of the high schools would report directly
028to the superintendent um and so uh we I had to kind of you know based on eliminating some of those positions but setting the district up in order to have two assistant superintendents with you know uh that will be able to take care of both sides of the house special education side of the house also in in uh the academic side of the house so that that's how the new format will look uh and working from there and now I want to kind of go deeper uh and nestor's in his presentation he's going to kind of give you a a deeper dive into these numbers uh so that you understand how we're and where we're going with these uh so in in my proposal uh the district will save almost $4 million with the cuts
029that we're going to be doing at central office uh you know there's a total of seven s million plus dollars be that will be being um uh you know will be saved uh with the with the first round of of proposed you know uh reductions that that I'm putting out there but I wanted to make sure that uh you understand but again nest's going to go through a little bit deeper dive into the numbers and you know the pre the preer numbers and uh the current numbers and and what we did with the allocations and how we went through the process of eliminating certain positions uh we'll go deeper into that when he makes his presentation uh the second tier of of of Staffing areas that we looked at reducing is on the operations side
030uh again uh you know with the operation savings that we're looking at it's about you know right at a million dollars that we that we're looking at on the operation sides we tried to stay away from you know real Cuts in the area uh the the maintainers cuts are positions that are not necessarily filled yet uh so we were able to kind of put that savings over to um um the staff reduction side because they those positions are not even been uh filled at the moment um and so wanted to make sure we do that and then the third proposal uh is uh looking deeper into the academic and support staff uh and when you look at the numbers there there's not a whole lot of of um of uh recommended you know U areas
031of red of reduction uh you you see five counselors and five social workers uh and we we went back and forth in that area area because uh you know it's we just received a substantial Grant award to to Really support that side of it and so we feel that we we could possibly be able to uh massage that those numbers you know and and make that work so within the with this small bit of the academic piece uh a lot of these positions were central office positions as well uh and so we felt that we were able to kind of save almost $2 million in this area as as well and then you look at the the overall you know um when you see you know those those different tiers of of of reductions uh
032the district has an in ability you know uh to save almost $10 million uh with my proposal uh and and remember uh some of some of the savings we will not see in the first year not even in the second year uh and so you know but and when that third year process goes with with the Union contracts we will be able to uh recoup the full amount of that savings uh and so again it's just you know an area that we feel that we could you know uh you know it's a start and I think that's what I I think that's one of the uh the driving forces for the board to to me as we talked about what are we going to do uh is to be able to have a start uh
033and so I you know it's a small start I mean towards trying to accomplish almost a 30 you know 38$ 39 million you know um downfall for the district uh but we have to start somewhere uh and we felt we needed to start at the top uh and so uh this proposal really you know um supports that uh and uh but I know we're going to have deeper conversations about you know other areas and other opportunities to be able to um to bring this to um um to a a better savings across the board overall again we talked about you know removing phase three and four I think they need to go back to committee uh and really start helping us look at what we're what we're what we're doing looking at you know software
034programs in the district looking at the vendors that we're engaged with in the district cell phone plans that we provide for staff in the district there's a whole lot of different things that I think the board will have a good conversation with our team to be able to kind of look at those the other part of that is is really collaborating with the unions uh I've had several conversations over the last two weeks with unions about you know what c what else could you guys do to help us you know have some ideas coming together so they're also getting back with their members and figuring out you know how do we do that how do we come to the table with suggestions and not just say you can't do this because uh it's happening to
035our members and so that's been very uh very rewarding and very fruitful to to know that they're willing to come to the table with suggestions as well so it's been a good a good uh partnership for us and again I think the other part of that uh the third uh the third bullet there talks about additional fundings I think it's quite time for the state of Connecticut the city of bridgeboard uh and and all the other Federal programs and things to be able to look at sources that we are able to tap into to provide additional resources for this district and for our kids uh the other piece is that we have Grant riding opportunities in this District uh we have the data to be able to reflect the need that I think we could
036do a better job of writing grants and be able to pulling more those dollars back in uh to this district and and one of the things I I talked to Nestor about is we need to set a goal maybe it's a 10 to5 to10 million goal every year that we can pull in by in Grants to support the work that we're going to be doing in this district and is it capable absolutely it is but if you don't write them you can't even you know uh be able to be um uh awarded anything so those are strong conversations that I I think the board and the committee committees uh will be able to support that work uh and raise everybody get together and raise up the sleeves and let's get to work because this is
037the opportunity for that to happen and then when you look at at at um uh phase four and I think this is where I'm I'm I'm going to call on the community to really kind of help us uh understand and you know we can't do this alone we need everybody in this community we want we need the board to kind of you know you know rally rally the teamw work together to make this happen uh and it's talking about you know how do we save money operationally how do we deal with you know uh deficiency in our facilities all the these things are going to be um uh critical conversations that have to be had and uh and we're hoping that this community will be able to step up and help us with that uh
038I think the community needs to be able to voice their likes and dislikes about what happens what's happening in our schools and and uh and and and even provide opportunities and options for us to do things across this district and so those are key pieces uh uh of of how you know my team is and and and what our my team is ready to do uh to take action uh we're very excited about it we know it's hard work uh and it's not it's not you know we're not here to blame anyone we're here to Pro provide Solutions uh and we're we're here to say we're going to stand with this board we're going to stand with this district and we're stand with this community to do whatever we have to do to fight for
039kids uh and fight for good things for kids and so uh we're very excited um you know again like I said on the slide here the top priority is to reduce any impact on uh that's felt to students families uh faculty um you know I think that's important uh and there may be a time in in the next couple weeks in next couple months that we may have to know you know go down to the to the campus level to consider um um um budgetary options but when that comes I I would like to make sure that we have the ne we take the necessary steps and communicate that step to everybody in the community to be able to do it but right now we're talking high level we're talking things we can do right
040now and I want to make sure that we're able to uh stand forward but Nester is going to go he has uh two slides that he wants to kind of do a deeper dive uh and I'll let him come to the podium to uh provide you with some additional information okay good evening everyone um like Dr Avery had indicated the spreadsheet pretty much self explains itself when you look at the F where it says FY FTE those are the total head count of employees for current year where it says FY 20 FTE those are the employee head count in those categories by comparing each job to one another so from 2020 preer they had a total of seven employees in those categories with Esa money those positions we increased to 124 so which is an
041increase of 54 positions well funded with Esa money the esa money has ended so we have to come to the table uh we're not saying because we cannot sustain those positions so what we've done we're proposing to eliminate 50 50 of those 54 positions that we added so four are still there but again when we it can we take it one day at a time or stage by stage not go too deep see how much we can sustain ourselves then how time will come possibly we're going to have to go back to Free as a number but for now we elimin we it's not really it's elimination let me be clear not every of those positions is filled they allocated when when I when you say allocation in budget it means they're budgeted every one
042of them is not filled but for me to justify not filling them if has to be eliminated out of out of the budget because a principal is going to say I have this position allocate it to me why are you not approving it but if it's not budgeted all you have is all you have I mean trying to explain to the principal or anybody or any department head that those monies or those head counts that we allocated we're B an s a money they're not going to understand they don't care where the money came from let me be honest with you all they know is they have this number of employee or position budgeted to them to them they feel they have the right to and they do but unfortunately we cannot afford it so
043we have to scale back downsize reorganize realign whichever word you want to use that's what we're doing any question on that but it translate to $7.5 million Savings in for 12 months let's not forget we are six months into the fiscal year I have to quantify something those positions you seeing there some of them are teachers some of them are administrators because of the contract of the teachers you're not really going to attain that much savings you can you can move them back into the classroom if the administrators you can move them back to the classroom to be teachers from where they we however the teachers contract or managers Teachers Union contract you can't push them down to a lower level and pay them that lower level their contract Pro protects them to that high
044level salary till after so many about a year or so then it will dwindle down so you're going to have to be that cost full cost but the only thing you get them into the classroom to fill vacancies and reduce use of um temporary agency employees so that's which is good at least we'll get qualified teachers in the classroom that's look at it that way to teach so those are the factors of that category the next category where which is um tier two under tier two the same appliance which is maintenance electricians it help desk in 2022 20 positions in total we budgeted in that category in 2025 which is current year 34 positions are budgeted in current year those positions again we are we allocated based on SM money as far as maintainers are
045concerned 10 maintainers were added with EXA money to catch up with remodeling the schools and you know doing Capital Improvement in the schools which lasted for 4 years we did a lot with exra money with Improvement of HVAC the air conditioning system the heating system and remodeling of the bathroom so those maintenance were needed and they came in handy but unfortunately we cannot sustain the maintenance or retention of those positions they're not filled so most of these positions are not filled anyway some of the ones that are filled probably try as much as we can to reduce them through attrition we possible so so all in all 22 positions were added with exra money we we're retaining 20 of them and reducing it by 14 and that will give you $1.1 million savings for a
046full year since we're have into the year you're looking at almost 500 call it about $600,000 however I have to quantify if you lay someone off these are regular employees if you lay them off they have six months to collect unemployment which the city pays directly city the city of the bridport district or city of Bridgewood does not have unemployment insurance they don't contribute is pay as you go every dollar an ex employee collects comes directly out of the district pocket one onone including the city yes if people don't know that I will correct everyone that's that is the fact Danielle pays the bills she knows it's oneon-one any questions I mean some people are looking amazed but that's the fact we're gonna take questions Mr travor yeah I was just waiting for her to
047turn on my mic that's that's all um okay I wanted you to be clear with your language the board pays okay I'm sorry right the board that's what you're trying to say the board pay we would have to pay for that the board would have to pay for that so if we laid off a teacher in January that teacher would collect unemployment and the board would pay for that unemployment that is correct so the savings for us is minimal that is correct okay thank you I just I understand having come over from the city side to the board side that that applies to both employers yes it does so you get you confuse the language but I wanted to be clear for the sake of my understanding and because if you were telling me the
048city had to pay for it and I would say well that's too bad for them um but but I understand I have to apologize it's gonna take me a while to it's GNA take me a while to reprogram myself myself please I I wanted to be clear I also wanted to be clear um what's the difference in cost you said some of these positions aren't filled yep so in a particular facility where there's an open position M and it's being filled right now by a substitute right in some cases a permanent Sub in Cas some cases a nonpermanent sub what's the difference in cost do we do we know that if you relative to let's take first the permanent sub let me just be clear uh Dr Avery or whoever we're looking at over in
049that direction or which which positions are you referring to are the teachers or the regular clerk let's let's take for the sake of my question yep a classroom teacher okay um that position is not filled mhm um and so we have a full-time uh a permanent Sub in that classroom um so if we if we found a permanent a full-time teacher what would be the difference in cost well just this C to when you say a permanent sub meaning a sub from the agency yes okay the only savings you're going to get is the savings by dis opposing or sending that agency sub back to the agency but the teacher is going to fill the position at a much higher salary of the teacher which makes you know don't get me wrong we I think
050we'll get a better quality from a certified that much I can speak to I'm just curious what the actual you're the you're the you're the you're the numbers man right I'm curious what the actual difference in cost is in a year in a year Club from the agency is probably about $50,000 a teacher when you hire a teacher full-time teacher you have to pay the teacher depending on their grade and years of experience you have to pay them their salary per contract you have to contribute the district has to contribute towards their health insurance which runs about $26,000 average and contribute towards the mer so to hire a teacher 10 years old 10 years 10 your teacher you look at $100,000 okay but right now I believe the starting pay is about $50,000 about $53,000
051yes okay so it's the 53 plus benefits plus $26,000 of 26 27,000 in health insurance depending on their class if their class three is much more right plus their Medicare Medicare cost and their and right and their P pension no no the state pays okay the state pays Pion for the teachers we only pay Pion for regular employees okay so we're looking at a difference of about 30,000 yep 30 depending on again depending on the years of experience uh 30 40 I get that you're paying more for an experienced teacher but a starting teacher right okay I got you okay that's I got it thank you so and I I have other questions about this overall but I would rather Mr niquo continue with his presentation and come back to a question about some of
052the other stuff sure okay okay so that's pretty much it the third category which is the academic and students the same scenario 79 positions were allocated in 2020 111 are currently allocated in current year which is a 32 you know 32 headcount increase we're we're eliminating 17 of those so if you compound with three three categories a total of 161 positions were allocated in 2020 fiscal year um with Esa money he got he went up to 269 positions we deciding to we deciding to down siiz Reign or reduce them by 81 still retaining about more Beyond 2020 funded with Esa money again would digest the first phase of our move then we might come back depending because as we got into this whole Gap closing measures we started finding some languages that doesn't really translate
053to money the very first you know within the six months the way we anticipated um and that's what it takes When anybody tells you they're going to close a budget Gap you don't have every every time bomb contract language in your head is when you start flipping Pages you still finding what you can do and what you cannot do what you can get away and what you cannot get away and every Union contract is different and unique yep any more question through with all due respect through in total the 81 positions would translate to 105 million in a year however let me quantify it again the first three categories the I's and the M's and the t's are teachers you can only bring them you know move them to the classroom however the assistant principles
054you still got you still have to pay them their regular salary even if you move them down reduce it by $11,000 that's that's all you're ging so the savings on those three categories for this year is not all there or it's not there in a way if you depends how you want to present it the only savings you have is the other unions which is $3.1 million which is 6 months into the fiscal year which is 1.5 million they're going to collect unemployment for 6 months which is probably another $500,000 before the fiscal year end so you're going to net a million dollar savings but the whole savings kicks in in next fiscal year which is 12 months of next fiscal year but 6 months remaining in this fiscal year there are some prices to
055pay there are some ramifications there some you know some obligation to fulfill and we have to maintain or carry them in the Cobra rate they're entitled to COBRA rate and we have to carry them in Cobra rate about about 60 not maybe about 60 days don't quote me about 60 60 days somewhere around there and that's pretty much so for this year it's going to be a struggle I'm going to be honest with everyone the numbers are now coming out the way numerically ital is up but it doesn't all come into play into savings this year because of timing delay the Nature has to take its course for the wh savings to kick in yeah I mean I I I hope I'm clear as to how it works I mean um Mr sovic thank you
056I got several questions I don't know if it's going to be off off for Nester it's all on his sheet though might have to that's fine go ahead we'll do a combination yeah okay um because all right so the first so the first question I've got is about um central office staff and the two we Furlow uh good majority of central office staff is salaried employees so how would that work would it be a percentage reduction of salary um it will be 3 Che if I may it will be a percent reduction two weeks follow translate about five I think 5.6% of an annual salary that's pretty much what it is um so you're basically getting a pay reduction of 5.6% approximately right for a year but but it's not like not like a run
057under the mill for well they'll be off for those two weeks they'll be still working but at a 5% reduction if you're giving somebody two weeks follow you can stagger the days off over 6 months without jeopardizing the operation of the central office ideally that's the way is done managerially that's a more prudent way to do it you give them six months to exercise use their um you know 10 days I mean it would be very unfair to not pay somebody for two weeks and have them for for the 10 days that's like pushing the envelope but again I've done it before don't get me wrong but you know okay my next question has dollarwise or percentage wise it's it's approximately about I think $75,000 savings that will be given back to the district is
058is is my understanding total yes sir 70 about 70 to 75,000 you know um you really don't um PR Che you really don't have a whole lot of people not in the union for now you can only do it by getting away with people not in the union per se whatever two weeks follow you you're gonna have to talk to the union agree with the Union pretty much yeah yeah than yes I still got a few more um um couple more questions um actually a bunch because some might come to me it seems that some of our positions are being scaled back a little further than the SR dollars for instance and the last update we got is uh for the 23 24 Physicians that it'll be reduced I believe this was the 23 24
059budget presentation we had nine assistant principles that was said to be eser are are we shifting more positions because more positions were shifted 2 from the year 2324 I mean it's from 2223 into 2324 budget was there an accounting ENT journal entry or we're using U TR Madame chair we're using 2020 as the base which is preet positions were added interim 21 22 23 incrementally with EXA money so the best thing is to go back to your original base that's m because if you don't go back to your original base and use a diluted base yes you're using an you know a wrong base to begin with right so okay so so assistance principles are currently at 46 and we was at 27 so 19 additional we added since then and we're going to ss8
060so we will have one more we still have one more one more assistant principle yep yep yep and what metrics are we going to use to decide which schools lose their assistant principles HR can answer that for you good evening everybody so when it comes to the assistant principles we're just gonna be following the contract uh the language of the contract to a t we're just going to go from seniority after the cuts are made by seniority then we're going to look at the district as a whole and see where we might have to reassign uh assistant principles from one school to another to make up for you know inadequacies that happen because you might be cutting the the least senior might be three from one school but you can't leave that school with you
061know two assistant principal so we might have to move one from another school over so we'll have to after these cuts are made we'll have to look at the schools and see what the needs are and move them around that that point okay for for those of you who weren't here last around one of the considerations was schools under 500 was one of the first to L right and for the you know in just six months ago we just added you know 12 assistant principles to schools who never had any assistant principles so those will be you know one of the first considerations to be looked at and are all these assistant principles have do they all have um time within the district and bumping rights so the way and I'm glad you brought that
062up because I just wanted to clarify on the on the bcast contract so the way the contract reads is that if an administrator is displaced is is laid off and there's no position below them that's open or that they can bump into they can go into a teaching position and as long as they're in the certification so for instance if an assistant principal one of these new 12 assistant principles uh who don't have much time in the district uh have a math certification well they can go down to an open position in a school that may have a math teaching position and they can they can go back into the classroom if that's what they choose to do not many will have bumping rights although there will be some that will have bumping rights because
063they've been in the district for a little longer or they have teaching experience prior to being moved to assistant principal so they'll be able to bump but with the open amount of teaching positions throughout the district my best guess is most will be able to go into the teaching positions if they want to okay thank you so so so B basically what you're saying is somebody who's just coming coming into the district from another district will not be able to bump a two-year teacher they won't be able to bump no they'll they'll be able to go into an open position and we're call it unfortunate fortunate position where we have so many openings and BAC that they'll be able to go into that and as as Nester was explaining just to give you a little
064clearer view so for that first year they'll still make the same salary they are now they'll just be minus $1,000 the second year they'll be 25% less the difference between the teaching and the uh administrators pay and then the third year is when they'll go into the teachers contract right right and as opposed to the central office non-represented employees those will be pure savings immed they yes and um yeah and those bumping rights those basically hold through through all the contracts so every contract's a little bit different um with when you're talking about the non-certified contracts the language is a little bit different um is it you know in senority even between say ask me 1522 and nage the definition of senority is different between the two so yes everybody has bumping rights um the
065majority of the positions that uh Dr A has presented here our entry level so there really wouldn't be much bumping going on um but when you get up to those those levels yes there would be bumping and I've got another question of course um we're looking at um I'm looking at facilities again facilities there's a proposal to yeah we had seven and 20 and now 25 we're looking to eliminate that's probably from mqu um 18 positions and with 15 remaining positions now if these positions um I believe Mr the TR raised up and he brought it into a comparison with the school teachers but all these all the jobs being filled on a PDM basis from an outside Revenue Source have Point clarification those are 18 positions that were added from um right 20 to
06620 uh right from 2020 to now so those are not eliminated so 15 25 okay you're right thank you thank you ma'am uh two St ructions proposed tier two Staffing reductions yeah so we're looking looking at a revised headcount of 10 are those positions currently being worked by by whether by by Madam chair I had indicated that those okay let me clarify it in 2020 they had they had seven maintainers get well there was a reclassification make a long story short there are 18 maintainer positions added we only downsizing we're only reducing 10 out of those 18 make a long story short those 10 we are downsizing we are strictly added with s some money but are those bodies in building no they're not I had indicated earlier those are mainly vacant positions for maintainers
067even if somebody's there we're going to have to do it through attrition right um not too many most of them are beg through you Mr superintendent may I hear from the director of facilities George and he's free to answer the questions whether you like his no problem thank you uh yeah Mr Garcia um we know that we know the extent of the district we know that that the buildings we know that the buildings are in disrepair where you know you don't have enough people to cover your square footage as it is um do you foresee being able to upkeep the square footage with these reductions or proposed reductions it's going to be a challenge you know I'm not going to sit here and say that you know everything is going to be perfect um we
068put some Provisions in place we've uh made strategic Investments during the eser dollars that came through we've bought in some additional equipment to help automate the operation of the department um 10 positions are hurt like you know just like the rest of this list you know there's going to be pain throughout the whole entire district and and we understand that we have to be part of this of the solution here um the 10 positions went above and beyond the 150 that we were budgeted in the past during eser we're given additional 10 I believe that that was bought to the board at the time time that we needed to increase the workforce um we didn't bring anyone else new on after that 10 uh maintainer allocation but you know we're going to do the best
069we can to maintain the district we've invested in our people through training and certification uh We've automated from end to end everything that we do now is uh you know on a system where we can manage in a different kind of way um but it's going to be a challenge yeah and and Madam chair I think I think one of the things uh Mr Garcia and I talked about is making sure or that you know we have to shift if we need to shift we have to provide more if we have to provide more but that's just going to be that those those those baby steps that we take as we move through because every department is going to be impacted in some form of fashion at some point in time in the ne in
070the near future so we have to you know again as long as we feel that we're we're working as a team to make it work if we have to adjust we'll do that that's just part of what we do you know and and everybody is willing to do and and and step out there and say hey what is it going to take for for us to stay alive I think that's that's important and so again we've talked about that we we understand the needs on the facility side uh and um it again it's it's it's GNA hurt like he said and he knows that and and we and we've talked about that you know you know tily and so uh but we know we have to do what we have to do and uh we
071G to make sure that we um we do the best we can on that and and I want to make one thing clear um part of the plan is that we're not going to lay these folks off this is through attrition to ensure that you know we're not hurting the worker because end of the day these folks they're really putting in a tremendous amount of work as we know now so the last thing we want to do is discourage the folks that are working very hard in the district currently we had uh some time to spend with all of our custodians today along with our nutrition workers and you know when you see these folks and you feel the energy for what it is that they do and the work that they put in we
072don't want to eliminate a job and take a job from someone but if we have to do this we'll do it through attrition right yeah while while while I'm concerned with the jobs and the people behind them I'm a bit more concerned with the upkeep of the facilities because we've got we've basically had with the school closures and the school facilities Master plans we've got buildings that were deteriorating so so much because your staff is stretched so thin already as it is that we are contemplating closing buildings not because but because they are so I don't want to say poorly kept but it it is poorly kept but through no fault of your own through the thin stretch of the resources that we have I forget what you told me the optimal number of square
073footage to maintenances but you're way below that ideally it's 171 to cover every schedule uh you know obviously we have to do things through overtime um but you know once again where we're trying to be as Innovative as we possibly can to close the gap but there is a gap right my my my my concern is that we'll end up with more Hall Edison's what's the third one Bryant's that are considered for closing later down the line because of possibly deferred maintenance that we cannot get around to so in in my mind cuts to this department is almost counterintuitive I mean I I first in my decision Matrix what I think of is first PR preserve academics at all costs this is going to be a close second because of what we just went through
074and what we are going through and what we are about to go through with the poor poor condition of some of our facilities where our children got to learn so I that would behoove us to think really carefully about this one okay yeah thank that that's that's all I got for can I have a point of clarification those positions the 10 are not filled right now as from what Mr no said um I'm not sure if all of the positions are filled um we've got to reconcile the numbers in terms of what is filled and what isn't um if they are I you know my recommendation would be that we don't eliminate the position it happened through attrition over time just because we need a Runway to be able to solidify some things out in
075the field we have to do some reshuffling we're going to have to do um we have to look at every sing single schedule in the district redo every schedule in the district based on the new number so there's some work to be done um but you know I have the complete faith of the folks that are doing to work every day out in the field and and I think also um once we have the facility Masters plan we could probably have a better picture we need and that's going to be in like stage four from what and I think that's going to be that conversation where you know the board will direct direct us to shift where where you feel we need to shift and I think that's going to be important as we that
076data source is coming to the board within the next month or so so again when we talk about not fing the position you know you know until you know I mean through attrition that gives a little leway before anything is finally done and remember we when when when I spoke and when Nester spoke we talked about you're not going to realize these savings all of all of a sudden that's where this comes to play you know and we know that I think the board knows that uh we're going to have to shift along the way uh because the need may be somewhere else I mean if we have one of the know the steam borers go out I mean we have to look at facilities and sites and all we just have to shift and
077and we know that you know some of those things are very very old uh and it could happen tomorrow I hope not but uh it could so shifting is part of what we're ready to do and I think that's going to be something that the board's going to help us again I think that's that that three and four phase is is going to get deep conversation about that so I'm excited about that as well all right and um I think this probably be my final question before a statement we've got um I think it may be a typo on commity community facilitator is um that that Community facilitator is is a person that um works with uh oh no yeah I know what the position is it just says fiscal year 251 20 minus one
078and then it says Gap reduced head count oh wait because the position didn't revised it says R revised head count one right because the position last year is when the position was added and so we just got it I'm sorry yeah so we're taking away no okay we're taking away the position added so we feel that we did we could we could do that okay no that's my that's my mistake I'm sorry it's not technal that's okay and I would like to just finish off by making this what what are you looking for tonight to to for are you looking for approval of the tier one you know go ahead I mean toam chair I think what we're here is basically presenting to the board the first tier of the plan and to let the
079board know that yes the $6 million that I presented the very first night to be attend through layoff is not out there because of the intricacies of the contract and what that means since it's not out there this here yes it will balloon or come into production or fulfillment next year what that means because it's not out there this year that means we're going to have to tap into using additional internal service fund and if you use additional inter internal service fund to balance current year budget you're creating a bigger ho for next year so you're looking for basically looking for we're basically asking to go proceed Full Steam actually yeah question that's correct and and I would like to conclude by saying for the first time since 2019 when I saw all this stuff
080coming I could see a way forward and a way out true and have some have some hope for the future yeah and and and and I appreciate you saying that because that's one of the things that we've been behind closed doors talking about you know yes we understand where we are yes we're we're not here to blame anybody but we we're here to provide a plan this plan right here will get us in a good direction to you know have deeper conversations and I think that's the important part because I can tell you looking into this issue it's it's going to go deeper than just this level right here guys it's going to go all the way down to the classroom in order for us to to to get out and so it it's it's
081crucial conversations it's tough conversations you know but it's conversations that are needing to be had now and and and we can't you know fight amongst each other about what needs to happen you know you have professionals that are are have been through this process give us the opportunity to make the recommendations uh and we going give you the facts behind the recommendations uh and if you support us we're going to try to see the plan out that's what we do and I'm I'm very you know passionate about that uh and I just need an opportunity to kind of show you know what we can do to kind of help you know improve budgetary means for district because if we don't our kids are going to fail you know and we're going to stand right beside
082and felon if we don't try this is our chance to try let's get let's get together and let's try to make this bad baby work uh I'm very excited about it uh you know we just need some blessings here uh and and will the plan work 100% probably not but I can tell you we're gonna we're g to try really really hard you know you have some very competitive individuals around the table here uh we're excited to do the work uh and we just need to join together and make it happen so thank you going go some board members who haven't had a chance to speak yet um Miss cmir oh yeah hi um can you guys hear me yes hear you oh okay um I just wanted to clarify for the parents in the
083community that don't know what the word attrition means because it's been thrown around a lot so I just wanted to kind of back up and um just so I understand when um Mr Garcia says attrition that means that happens when employees retire they resign or um does that mean this just that the that position is just not replaced is that correct or no true Madame chair that is correct that's what atricia means okay I just wanted to make sure just so for people who don't know what the meaning of that word is thank you very much that's it that's all I had thank you um we're gonna go to Mr benan thank you madam chair um this this situation stress me out Bradley because I know all this position is very important I know this
084situation we going through but I'm just look um Dr I the financial anal the section one I know you can work with that but when you go those section two that hurt me a lot because I know a lot of people this position take care a student very well and then facility and everybody know a very different facility because these people without them our school's not going to be ready it's not going to be open and know they always short of staff and I know situation they cutting on facility how that U Mr Garcia and the staff they're going to be working because sometime when it's um day off or lay off or holidays this gentleman is everyone because I'm a witness I see it they work so hard or anything happen one of the
085schools and some they short and they never say no to Mr Garcia and then our schools have to be ready to open it I know how teachers and everybody when they come to school how the schools is open how they clean uh boiler light especially the snow look at how bad is raining right now we don't know later they're going to call Mr Garcia Mr Garcia we have a problem in the basement we got a a flood of something like that so hurt me so much especially know we got literacy painting we know we know we got pain oh my God we know how many it's one one and a half right umcia two right um you know especially the school counselor the associate work on you know these people work so hard with the
086student we have in each school I'm a witness very well so if we have to be careful in this part and set you to Dr ever you have to take care of that because you know I'm not agree to be special um um facility these people work so hard something they short one person sometime work like a three a thre man job I'm a witness of that so I just wanted that for the record you know I know we had to work about the budget I understand but with section one you can take that part Dr but the section two we have to be careful in that area because I'm not happy what you know what this situation going on I know we have to say I understand the process but we don't want to
087go crazy because I don't want somebody do the job of three or four at the same time yes sir and I respect that Madam chair I respect that and I think that's going to be an important task that we've done uh to be able to be very sensitive to every single position in the district uh and again you I've had I've had an opportunity to talk to several PE people that's that's positions that are on this list uh and it's not a it's not a a joyful thing to be able to say hey your position may be eliminated you know uh even even even at the top level I've had to do that you know over the last you know two days and that's difficult in itself so so again even at at staff members
088at at the lower level as a custodian or or what that's that's difficult in itself and and this is a time of year where it's it's it's even more sensitive that you have to be very careful in timing and the things that we do and so we tried to do that you know in a way to where it's it's a little bit more manageable U but this is a tough gig when it comes to trying to eliminate things and so we will we will make sure that we we take that initiative and make sure that we we we pause when we need to and take a different direction when we need to be as well so again that's everything that we we've been doing and that's why it's been so difficult and it's taken so
089long to even get here uh and even getting here we've had knockout drag out fights behind the scenes trying to figure out no not me not my I mean we've done all of that you know and it's a great exercise for us because a lot of us had never done that before uh and so it's it's and we know we have deeper conversations that's coming you know that we're going to have to be able to say okay let's do this and then we're going and then when we bring it to the board it's going to be even more conversations tough conversation that needs to be had so I respect that I know I know we can do it Dr but I just don't want to I don't want the kids stff and parents get hurt
090yes sir thank you mad chair Madam Chief you want to add something yeah if I may clarify uh for board member Benham just for clarity between the social workers and the council we have about 95 95 of them and 15 of them we added with exra money to T or control the trauma that you know happened during covid and we're only reducing nine out of the 15 that we added meaning we still have we still have you know a lot more there between social workers and counselors we have 95 we budgeted for 9 5 15 of those 95 was added with exra money we only reducing between the two categories nine position so we're still retaining some of them that were budgeted with extra money the big question is can we afford those retentions that's
091what we have to face down the road that is a big question down the road we might have to revisit because the way things are going I'm not trying to scare anyone but going back to FY 2020 level might if you cannot afford it you cannot afford it and let's not forget that four years has gone by from 2020 cost of living increase has been added each of those four years so just even if you retain your head count from 2020 between cost of living increase health insurance MF pension increase wage increase the District budget at minimum goes up by 10 12 million every year when you add all those components of cost of living each year we have not been getting 102 million increase between the state between the city and the state we've
092only the district has been sustaining those increases cost of annual cost of living increases they've been sustaining it with exra money which has dissipated but the cost of load increase did not go away you can't be carrying a load that you were using some other money to carry it's not feasible so what I'm trying to say here cutting back to 2020 level head count you still have cost of Liv living increase that has accumulated over four years compounded effect that your Bas increase did not go up by can't do Miracles I'm being blunt and honest thank you I mean that's the fact sorry I heard that audience and he can he can um uh Dr I just a point of clarification and then we'll get to miss Baptist Perez um we do have the LifeBridge
093Grant and that we're hope you're are you hoping to use that towards social work and school counseling yes we're working with them now on how we're going to transition you know that piece out in addition to that they are also looking for additional staff members to bring on uh and so they're going to work with us you know with with with with these staff members to to try to recoup uh a few of them to come over to work with them as well I'm not sure the number of those but we're working with them them you know uh in collaboration to make sure that we our kids will get those funding because they're they're going to be really integrated into our schools and so uh I think that's going to be a little relief there
094uh that we're excited about thank you uh Miss Baptist Perez uh my first question is what impact of laying off executive staff will have on closing the educational Gap can can you rephrase that what impact will it have laying off executive staff what will be the impact on closing the educational Gap what would be the impact for laying off executive staff to the academic impact you know CL the educational Gap closing the educational Gap again I think you know in in in my professional opinion you know I think it will have an impact on it you know but but you also have to look at the need of the district to even survive to be able to to do that internally and so I think you have to kind of balance that out a little
095bit uh you know because you know do we want to fix the problem internally or you want the state to come over to take over the district then we would have no Authority on on trying to close that Gap uh and and as you look at historical things across the district you know um you know over the years I mean there has been a a substantial um limited impact to uh the educational gra Gap in the district and so I think um again trying to figure that out uh you know is this plan going to be able to do that I'm not 100% sure because we've cut a lot of executive staff with this proposal you know and it was it was really the push from you know several members of the board to make
096sure that we do this uh but in again in my professional opinion the last three weeks we tried to kind of balance that out with the hopes that it's not going to impact uh the Ed educational Gap no more than what previous years have have done so again it's it's the hope of of of of what we're doing to try to balance that out a little bit I can't I don't I can't quantify that you know at the moment all I can do is is kind of gauge this see how things are going to work over the next couple of months okay so I'll simplify it do you believe it's going to have a negative impact or is it going to maintain the status quo I'm hoping it's going to maintain at least at least
097the the status quo and that's the status quo in terms of academics excuse me and that would be in terms of academics is it these Cuts will just maintain the status quo well I'm hoping to supersede that but again I'm I'm hoping to at least maintain uh and and again I'm not for sure if it's going to even do that based on you know you know the Outlook of what what I see uh so if we don't have a substantial impact in everything that we do you know when it comes to uh you know teaching and learning across the district uh it it may not have any impact on it so but again if we can you know figure out ways to be able to to impact academic you know uh environment in brid public
098schools there's there's there's a possibility of of a greater impact uh my next question uh is uh it was brought up regarding the life Bridge g a grant I know when I was chairing working with Dr Carmel leby David she applied to over $97 million in Grants when when we start to hear back about receiving them life Bridge was one of them and I based off of the substantial amount of numbers and Grant applications she accomplished when are we gonna start hearing back do you have any updates in terms of the grants like life bridge that she applied and got for our district and when we'll have any outcomes the the Grants Department is in nest's division n you have any update on um no I have a meeting with the grants director on Friday
099um to be very very honest with you we've been busy doing this financial it was not an easy puzzle to solve because you pick it up here you find this obstruction you find this you know hindrance and you have to refine it to make sense so we've consumed ourselves with this financial data that you're seeing here for the last week so Friday I will be meeting with the grants director the goal I'm going to set a a new standard a new goal as to how much Grant is expected of the Grant Office in a year because we need all all hands on deck for clarity live Bridge we basically the district basically co-signed the application for live Bridge the application was the Grant application was done by live Bridge Company we just co-signed for them
100for just for clarity yeah know I mean we've had I mean I've spoken to the past with Dr I mean with Mr Garcia with facilities like partnering with other organizations that's how we received the environmental grant for I believe Moren and Johnson School my my next comment and I think I'm just going to transition because I did bring up Mr Garcia um uh while serving uh I had the opportunity to sit down with other academically successful districts and it was just their motto and they have academic success that they were okay with cuts to their facilities Department um in order not to make cuts to their director of literacy director of math director of science uh director of communication like the cuts that we're about to make I want to say that it's a bit
101of the bo of a consequence for the board for operating outdated and empty facilities uh especially after the most recent Crystal report was released uh um my my next question is uh I was unfortunately driving uh with the initial report can someone explain to me where in this new chart is the chief academic officer I can do that the chief I have repositioned that position to the assistant superintendent for curriculum and instruction same same position you know uh different title and then my my next question is where's the deputy role now my understanding is that you're Acting Superintendent while Dr Carmel Levy Davis out on um medical leave or on on leave so it there's a process for the board with interim and so I'm looking at this and you've look like you've made an
102executive decision that you're going to keep the role but that's something that the board ultimately has to have so where's the deputy role it's on the it's on the screen now I I don't see it in the proposed organizational uh where's your role G to be in the proposed in the new chart you're eliminating your position right I'm eliminating the position it's vacant but that's that's a discussion that the board will need to have so when I go back to my position the position will be there and but if we don't again remember I said that the the savings is is a very fluid thing you're going to see some of that now and you may not later so again that's an option that can be discussed at Personnel contract committee with the board and
103be and so if the board feel okay let's make sure he gets his position back it's going to be there and it's not going to be able to be added to uh that salary so so I'm not trying to make you know ins situation that you know that position is never not going to be there it's a recommendation it's a proposal uh and I'm very open to the direction of the board my next question is what are the proposed dates for these stages especially when it comes to stage four stage now stage one and two are pretty you know pretty you know um urgent I think we need to do that as soon as possible three and four will start in January when January February when the facilities plan come out we are also when
104the first committee meeting for the board uh whenever they reorganize the Committees we will shift those uh those topic areas uh here go back we we will shift these areas the software software programs I have the department chairs working through all the different programs that we purchase in the district all the all the curriculum puras that we're purchase in the district they've given me a list of all cell phones I have a list of all vendors uh contracts that we have in the district and that's going to go in a deeper conversation with the board committees uh and so until and so so again and that's a that's a very tedious process so that's going to take a little bit so starting in you know January I think we'll have you know a better time
105frame when the board give us a direction of what they want us to eliminate or you know are the recommendation we bring to the Committees of what to eliminate so again it's it's a a very fluid process so it's going to take a little bit uh so I can't really put a timeline on that uh the other point the number phase four is those um uh you know initiatives to talk about if it's if we need to bring up school closures and things like that and that and those cost-saving initiatives that's that's something that the board's going to have to give us uh we can't close schools you know this year because there's no time to do that uh and so you may the board may say okay if we do this or if we
106close schools we're going to put a time of 2026 or January 2027 uh so it depends so I I would I would love to get that feedback from the board as to putting a timeline to it and could you clarify what roles fall into the Urgent category again I'm just looking at the chart and so might be just easier for you to tell me what are the roles that you're categorizing as urgent technically all three of those all three I call I call the um if you go back to the presentations uh those three areas uh go back it says prop Pro proposed staff uh reductions if you're changing it on your side it's not showing on teams so if you're changing the slides it's not showing these prop these proposed staff reductions all these
107positions here next slide says tier two which is all of these positions and all these positions to end up with that approximately $10.5 Million worth of savings knowing the fact that we have to initiate these in order to even kind of get close to that $10 million cost savings so let me go on my side and see yeah I'm I'm not going to lie I'm concerned especially given the content that was discussed in executive session regarding the cost of special education do you believe it's wise to cut the executive director of special education or anything from that department including multilingual Learners I I think it's wise to kind of look at exactly how uh we are looking at restructuring the special education division uh in order to be able to kind of you know uh
108streamline the services that we've that that we're using and doing within the district uh so again it's one of those processes that we're going to have to be able to do to kind of to work through all of that uh there may be an an opportunity for me to go back to the board to talk about additional positions in special education in order you know if we're able to kind of save in certain areas be able to come back to help with that restructuring of special education I think one of the other things with uh the the the extensive cost of special special education services in the state of Connecticut uh there's there's several superintendents across Connecticut that are going to be joining forces to really look at and push the state of Connecticut to
109help support that excess that excess cost for special education services uh in each of our districts uh to be able to hope to be able to pull and get a little bit more support in saving some of those dollars we have neighboring school districts that are bringing uh special education services back to their District I think Sheldon is one I think Waterbury is another one uh they're doing some really Innovative small skilled opportunities that I will be engaging with those superintendent and board members uh over the next couple of you know days and weeks uh to be able to look at that because you're right special education it is just it's draining districts uh and we have to be able to kind of manage that a little bit can you clarify what do you mean
110by streamlining services to special education well just really trying to look at what we're paying for you know spee services and um occupational Services Social Services right now we have vendors that are like providing services at all different types of rates we have tons and tons of different contracts at different cost all across the uh the district and streaming streamlining that is to we should have or go out go out with for an RFP for speech services or language services and and be able to say we want we we want to be able to provide our companies to come in and provide a bid for those services at a very standard rate not all these different you know prices for different Services based on someone submitting uh you know um a contract to the district
111so again there's a lot of streamlining to try to save money in that division uh and we just have to kind of work through uh trying to make that happen can you just clarify again I thought that was already in process when I was working with Dr Levy David that we were in the process of at least trying to streamline and to issue rfps has that that hasn't started and not to my knowledge you know I think one of the one of the conversations is we've been talking with legal uh our special at legal staff trying to figure out trying to trying to work on the contracts for special education and so that's kind of what we've been doing and vetting and kind of working and I think they're at a stage right now where
112they have at least a contracts where especially for all these out of District uh placements that we have we have a single contract that now hopefully starting next year that every vendor that we send kids out for out of District placements they're using our contract and we're not using their contract so there's just a lot of little you know nuances that we have to get the legal department into in order to streamline things a little bit uh it started but it just really hadn't really finalize in a way okay and then I mean again I just couldn't missed it while driving is there anything in this plan regarding balancing classrooms I know that was something that was also supposed to start already uh districtwide you know we can't have schools where some teachers are overburdened
113with near capacity 29 students in other schools where there's seven kids in one classroom and it's not a special education classroom that have we started that because I know that was also another initiative that should have taken place that should have yielded some cost savings yes ma'am that is that is that is something that I know PJ and his offic are are constantly working on so we're we're we're we're I think we're waiting to the January time frame to to to initiate some of those uh and I think one of the things that um um we started is to really look at the high school level and I know he is working with a team of individuals that's gonna do some optimizations to those schedules and being able to kind of help us streamline that
114a little bit so we're looking forward to some of that happening uh and be able to kind of streamline and getting uh those those classroom balance so yes that started and I think we're we're looking for the January time frame to bring those back into play again as well yes ma'am as it as it since it's already started do we have any projections in terms of savings I I may have just missed it like I said uh unfortunately I was driving um how much in savings are we looking with balancing classrooms I I don't I don't have a number for you uh but I can get with uh staff and see what we can do for you to get you some numbers of we are I'll get with Nester and PJ and we can uh
115come up with some uh dollars for you my I'm going back to stage three since you said that's approximately in January which is about three weeks uh are we looking at vendors in terms of our academic vendors that we're going to renegotiate with so for example some of our online programs or programs that give students access to additional support while at home absolutely I it's it's everything just really there I think there may be some duplicate you know programs that are being utilized right now uh and I think it's just really trying to look at a deeper look at you know all programs in the district again you have to understand the renewal process for some of those programs are at different stages uh so we may end up needing to be able to uh
116come up with you know $700,000 in June because the contract ends and so if the contract ends do we have a similar program that that we can use or that we are using that we may not necessarily have to have that cost so those are deep conversations that again uh the the academic you know um um committee would should be able to have a deeper dive into as well uh and just not let you know uh Administration just cut cut cut cut we have to have a a very thorough process and conversation around each of those programs and what do they do and how does they impact what's the usage of them because we we're paying for things that we may not even be using you know so why are you going to repay for
117why you going to keep that up again so those are the those are the the the analysis things that we have to do to to look at those programs so I I I would say every program that we have in the district that we have a contract for needs to be on the table for consideration to to look at uh and compare with the other again like usage and those types of things I mean my only followup comment to that is um with regards to substituting qualities in the past this district has participated with vendors that were not research-based and and so it was yes a cheaper program but our kids were used as labrats in test dummies to be quite Frank and so my followup to that is that are we going to be
118looking at substituting quality just for pricing um especially given that what I asked earlier about the cuts on executive staff will maintain the status quo I want to make sure that children actually have access when they're home to materials that will actually help them academically grow absolutely I think one of the other things I I I would like to emphasize is that uh I have been reaching out to the state of Connecticut state of Connecticut has has a lot of programs that are free to school districts that we may not be tapping into uh and that is going to be another way that we're going to be able to save uh and and and if the state of Connecticut is providing free uh uh softwares and programs to the district or to districts in Connecticut
119I think they've been vetted by the state they've been recommended by you know um individuals across the state and so I I think we need to look at that as a district to see if we can tap into some of those that uh maybe doing some of the same things that the programs that were paying for uh and so again I think that's something you know that we may have not done in the past uh and um because I know there's a some some of the things that over the last three weeks that that has been come to my to my attention that I don't think we do right to read some of the other things that I know we're not you know utilizing within the district that are as being funded by the state
120of Connecticut that we have to just at least consider uh my next question so stage four I didn't really get a clear date but will that include our facilities master plan and demographic study and I thought that was supposed to be available February yes ma'am you know I'm trying to kind of push them to get this out sooner uh and so I'm hoping to um um you know be able to you know they're they're they're getting close uh I think our next um facilities meeting is the 16th I'm thinking of am I right yes the 16th uh and uh they're going to do a combined presentation at the facilities committee uh to give the board a an overview of where they are and what how much more they have to do so I I'm hoping
121to to really kind of get that you know end of January beginning of February you know trying to make sure we get that and stay on that Target date too so yes ma'am that's going to be a huge part of those that that that that that tier three and four that the board's going to engage in uh and then engaging the community in that as well all right uh I don't have any more questions at this time thank you uh Mr Medina yes I'm not sure if I can be heard at this moment you heard okay thank you I'm not sure because I'm using a different headphone um I don't have many questions but I definitely have a few comments and um knowing that you know this has been layers of layers of layers that
122been you know in the process I just want to say thank you for the AC superintendent Mr Avery for your Valor um and also that goes beyond words I I don't have everybody's names in front of me but um and to your team you know thank you again for helping us so we can actually have their information and the uh data and to sit down and have honest conversations to be able to help our district as a whole um I like the info that was put forward you know but I definitely would like to hear sooner than later you know because I want to prepare with other people to Advocate at the state level you know to to give us kind of like sooner than later not right now um just to a number that
123will help us you know make sound decisions moving forward not only in this year but also in next year because you know uh you know we have been in many conversations with the community and with other leaders in other uh cities and towns and uh with Educators with superintendents with legislators with um you know board members and we know that we have a problem in our state and we're trying to come col collectively to make resolutions and not just excuses so thank you again for answering our questions uh I know they've been all over the place and they've been challenging you but you've been knocking it out of the park so I appreciate your honesty I'm sorry do you have any more questions who's that me yeah do you have any do you have um
124any questions or actually I said I didn't have any questions I just had yeah so um so again um thank you I know it's been a tough three weeks and you've been you know you've came up with this right now and it's been with a um and we look forward to hearing more because we want to be part of every single step uh and that that you're alone but that we're going to be working together to you know handle these matters okay because this is will be coming to to us as a board and um and we definitely going to have some more questions once we dissect all these numbers and information because I need help um so I'll be meeting with whoever is able to you know have time to sit down and go
125through this so I appreciate your time and um and your staff also that's been helping you in this time thank you thank you Mr tror uh thank you madam chair um let me start with a question that I didn't understand an answer to earlier what is going on with the chief academic officer position it's going oh I'm sorry it's going to be moved to an assistant the assistant superintendent for curriculum and instruction uh okay I I I do want to Echo what has been said a couple of times which is it this is like the first time in a long time that we've seen an organizational chart I've been asking for over a year two years maybe to see an organizational chart and it's nice I'm just trying to some this is a little confusing
126the way you've laid it out but it's still something to work off of and try and understand sort of what we look like now um somebody asked me for one a couple of months ago and I said I don't know uh let me see if I can get one um so I'm trying to understand your proposal tonight and I feel like I I heard Joe ask at the end sort of what is it you're hoping to do or get out of this and I'm I'm I'm not quite sure what we're going to do tonight U I feel like we're sort of rushing into things um because this is an hour hour and a half discussion that has a 10 million price tag on it $10.5 million price tag so though it's a lot to take
127into account um I do appreciate the work that yall have put into it uh because I know the severity of the problem that we're confronting um but it's also a whole lot of proposal you're put in there and I'm not I you know sometimes I hear the word exciting and think it's not exciting it's devastating um because the future is as Yogi used to say ain't what it used to be um we have a lot of termoil ahead of us so I I I do know that what you're doing is not um work that we want to see done um we would love to be spending more money and seeing our program and uh I know some of the folks here from Faith ax and I and uh Jen now have talked about what we
128need to do to get more res resources so that our children have the same opportunities as children in wealthier school districts um so I I know I'm I hope hope and pray that we get there someday uh and we're not having these kinds of discussions all too often uh but um I did have some other questions uh the I did I heard Miss batist Perez ask about the executive director of sped I sort of was looking at your chart and wondering I what didn't understand the difference between the chief of special ed and the executive director of sped um so I I I sort of understood do we need two different positions I didn't understand what the difference was I'm not even going to ask tonight because I know that what you're doing is trying
129to sort of make a little more sense out of this I don't even understand what's the difference between the director of communication internal and external Communications I and I'm just looking at this finally I'm seeing what we supposed have and a lot of it just doesn't make any sense to me at all um and so as we go through this I want to learn and understand more about what is this that we have and that's what we haven't seen in a long time and I I as we put the Committees together and start analyzing what these structures are and why we have them I know we will be asking you a lot more questions about why do we need this what is this um why why can't we do something over here and so I
130I think that's where Joe's looking at it and from his uh you know point of view that's more much more aligned with what nestor's is um my point of view which is not aligned with either of you um but it's all a healthy balance uh I understand what Miss batist perz is asking uh those questions are legitimate and helpful in terms of what she thought was going on and going to happen um so I think that we are moving in a in a good direction it's not in an exciting Direction but it is one that we need to move towards I did not see in this at all um what I thought I was going to see and so I want to ask about it um I see the preco co you know where we
131are now presentation throughout this um I thought we were going to see um the what we added this year from last year and I don't see that in here um because we had great debates last winter to this winter about what we were adding to this year's budget that we thought we shouldn't have been adding at all and so I thought I was going to see in here items that were added to this budget that we opposed adding um uh and I just thought that we would I understand why you're looking at 2020 I I do understand that when we got the eser money that gave us the opportunity to spend a lot of money that we didn't have before and I understand why that's so important and that's the Esser Cliff that everybody all
132over the United States has been dealing with this year when the money expired this September um and that's the real problem that districts all over the nation are dealing with um but we in Bridgeport are also dealing with a problem which was created this year when we started spending more money than we should have in this year's budget that many of us thought should not have been spent this year because we knew the eser cliff was coming this year and we had wisely saved money in our you know in our ISF um because we knew the eser cliff was coming and one of the first things that you said Mr nicoel when you came here was Whoa We dipped a little heavily into our savings and we shouldn't have dipped so heavily into that savings
133and we agreed with you some of us and so I thought we were going to see some of where we spent that money um the one that comes to mind immediately is that our relay program is now gone um and um we're we've We've Ended that contract we've gotten out of that contract um some of us thought we never should have gotten into the contract and so luckily we're not in it anymore and I believe there are other contracts programs and expenses that we incurred um and so some of these positions I know that you're eliminating are positions that were created that never should have been created and they're being eliminated and so that's correct and so I I just thought we were going to see that a little more clearly that we're eliminating some
134positions and programs and expenses that we created for this Academic Year the 24 25 year that are being eliminated um um and so I thought we would see some of those expenses being reduced can just I can explain a little bit for you on if you look at the the central office savings that number on yes sir the proposed staff reduction slide can you put that up on the screen please I can savings there is probably I would say 80 to 90% of of the positions that were you know um so when you look at that line where it talks where it says assistance assistant principles when that $2 million price tag there is is probably close to that 12 the 14 15 APS that we uh that we hired over the last year I'm
135sorry two two million where over you see the assistant principles that you know we we added oh okay so you're talking the aps yes right so you that 2 million 900 almost $3 million was just that staff category in itself so when you look at that savings right there that and some of the other positions that were placed takes care of of what was pretty much you know what we hired in in at least one year or close to it they may there there's some there's a few that's not there but we can we can go back and provide that for the board you know uh and we can bring that to the finance committee uh as we move forward I think that's important but that number there that 4,3 357,000 uh is is probably
136what I say 80 to 90% of that of that price tag right there is the is the positions that we put in uh year year and a half probably over until a year okay you know to be clear I mean we can we can vet some of those positions out that we're we're not but I I understand those are positions an additional director of literacy additional director of of ela addition director of uh of science a director of communications uh you know the the human resource project assistant uh uh the district teacher development specialist the three of them last year uh you know so again I would say a majority of these positions were added last year so okay and but there were programs added this year too I I know that we I know
137that we debated on programs too some of which we may not be able to get out of I'm deferring the programs to the further down the line I get that so so you're going to be able to see the relay contract in that you're going to be able to see this is only staff you know uh and and what we what we spent on you know uh the Staffing side of the house uh because the programs are deep and we spent a lot of money on curriculum academic curriculum that was needed uh and so those are the things that's going to Bubble Up at at the U at the programs and contracts uh uh conversation when you say Dr Avery that was needed um I I guess that I want to sort of I don't
138want to spend a great deal of time on it because we'll come back to that later as you said down the line yeah um but my recollection it was needed because we waited till the end of the year to decide on it um you know my I'll leave it at that because we're going to come to it later absolutely again I'm not here to blame timing no no no no no I'm not blaming just saying my recollection is we dealt with it in June um some of that yeah yes sir um so uh and I guess I'll leave it at that for now because we are asking us tonight to decide on authorizing i g make a point of we're not there's no action items tonight there's presentation okay there'll be another meeting for Action
139that's fine then I'm I'm comfortable with that I didn't want I wanted to be clear about the action item this is a presentation because so much thank you it I don't have the agenda in front of me so um I'm G know to a board member who hasn't spoken yet Mr Woodson and then I'll go back to um Miss Baptist perz okay Mr Woodson yes I might just have a comment I'm just you know I know a lot of information is being given out but you know like Mr inqu said you know time is of the essence you know we don't really have time to be trying to figure out how much this dollar and that dollar of of course you know this is very important but you have people who are professionals doing these
140numbers sitting down spending hours and hours to make sure that these numbers are correct so I just hope that the members of the board are you know soaking up this information as much as they can and hopefully we'll be able to make a decision you know the sooner we make a decision you know the less of a impact that it's going to have on our students on our teachers and then the rest of our staff thank you Miss btis harz thank you Mr hson I had a followup question regarding the special education services um with regards to um are in this presentation are we looking to to bring students back I I don't have that specific you know um Target point in the district but we're currently bringing students back as we speak uh and
141so um that's always a timing because you have your your your your uh PPT meetings that will uh dictate when and how these kids are coming back uh again when I when I talk about contracts that that has a lot to do with as well when we start writing contracts contract renewals then we have um uh an opportunity to kind of bring kids back if we have services in the district for them uh that's the only real reason why we would even want them to come back that we have the necessary programmatic things in the district that we could serve them instead of having them being served outside the district uh yeah that's that's my number one concern is because we have haven't been able to provide it I know we're obligated you know with
142fake to provide a free and appropriate public education and so if we don't have those resources I don't see how we can actually bring the students back or how cutting contracted special education services would actually help out um my next question is just more regard with regards to phase three with the academic vendor I was just curious as to why we went forward with Ingenuity when there were free options like Apex available and I know prior to having an academic officer you were in charge of academics was that like a district plan or I I just want to understand or is uh or is it back on like I guess consideration well it's my understanding that the district has been using As anity for years uh and so I want to make sure that um
143um we just continue that the utilization of that I was just brought up to speed regarding uh a program that uh the state has that that the state offers in order for us to kind of um be able to consider looking at that program but you but you but one of the one of the tricky things you have to consider is when you leave program that you've been using for the district for years into a new one it's a whole new training process you know the district has accept the the technology to be able to work with that program there's a lot of different things there but uh since it's a new it's a free program from the state uh I think that's something that we need to consider looking at uh and if our
144technology uh in the district and our our te technology department has the the means of being able to uh Monitor and manage that uh again so yes I think it needs to be an option that uh the Board needs to consider and then we can make that recommendation hey we have this program it costs nothing as genuity that we're currently using is you know $100,000 being able to kind of work from there yes yeah no I'm I was just asking because I know that there's other free programs like Apex that we not considered and so you know that $100,000 for the last school year could have been part of the savings um I I just want to follow up with regards to um you mentioned that you're meeting with other superintendents do you or could
145you just share with us what districts who you are planning to meet with who you've met with with regards to the special education savings or advocacy yeah I'm I just today I've had a conversation with a board member from Sheldon uh and he was kind to giving me a little bit more information about it so I'm I'm I gave him my contact information so we're going to hopefully in the next couple of weeks uh have a a chance to go and visit uh uh their new facility uh and it's right next door here so I think it's important for us to kind of tap in uh had several conversations with other superintendent just I was at a um u a breakfast this the other day uh talking to a couple of superintendent I think it
146was um uh is Weston um a couple I can't remember remember the exact super superintendent District's name whatever but again that's just opportuni as I start to uh talk with others um again I I'll make sure that you know the board is aware of some of the things and some of the opportunities that some of you guys may want to go with the with with the team uh on some of those visits so I definitely tap into you guys as well uh I guess my question is how is that different from The Proposal last school year with return with regards to a special education center because I believe yourself was included but there was a trip to Springfield Massachusetts to look at a suspension Center and there's been talks with other superintendent so um with
147regards to it and yeah Shelton's w we were at the C Conference uh statford started their own Enfield there's been several districts um since last year that got started and so I know that that was something that was already commenced now so I I just need some clarification as to what else you're looking for um with regard to that and then what are the resources we're having because again if I go back to the Chart it just doesn't make sense to me if we're going to try and provide those services that one of the positions any of the positions being cut is special education Mr T perz I would love to get your recommendations and so if there's other districts that you've already had conversations with feel free to share I'll be glad you that
148you you were a deputy and so and this is a plan that came out last year so I I just feel like this is being repetitive like there there was already a plan already conversations you were there and in those conversations so that should almost be FastTrack not say we're going to start all over again and me meet with other districts but you know this is just a presentation um there's some cuts that are just too critical um at this stage and that's all I'm going to say for now thank you Mr Woodson your hand is still up I don't know if you have another question no not at this time sorry about that thank you I want to make a point um I think as a board we put a Hal to the bringing
149special ed back because we' never actually followed through with a plan for the school closures um so I just want to make a point for there for that as well so [Music] um do does anybody have any other questions all right so this was a presentation of the budget uh Gap closure plan there is going to be some action that needs to be taken um and we will have another meeting to yeah we will have another meeting to take action Mr trabber go ahead um I have a point of personal so when you're done wrapping this up I wanted okay yeah so um uh we'll we'll um get an agenda together and a meeting time um sooner than later make sure we take action on this on and and and there you'll have board members
150you can have time to really digest this information and and hopefully work with uh Dr ay next week when we when we have the meeting where we can decide if you know certain things shouldn't get cut or um to go through with the plan um so that is all I have Mr tror you have a point of personal privilege yes ma'am um I apologize I meant to raise U couple of these items on Monday um we lost in Bridgeport on Monday uh this past weekend uh a State Rep a former State Rep uh Jack Hennessy um and I just wanted to uh mention it at our meeting uh this was a person who worked hard uh represent presed the City of Bridgeport for 18 years um and uh was a veteran um and Veteran politician
151who did a lot for our city and I thought it was appropriate that we pay tribute to that and recognize his Service uh he died All Too Young um and um so I wanted to mention that um and take a moment of silence for Jack um if we could just bow our heads for a moment I'm not into wasting using a lot of time on that but I want to just mention that he he left us too you too early thank you I also wanted to mention that at the same time I didn't get a chance to get up there because of of my schedule but we also lost in the last few days a little not quite as young but still too young uh a gentleman named Mark waxenberg and none of you will
152probably know who he is but he uh was a giant in the education field in Connecticut the former director of the CA and I will tell you that were it not for him we would not have elected Board of Ed members in the City of Bridgeport um he was the director of the ca who came forward and gave us the support we needed when mayor Finch tried to take away our right to vote for the Board of Ed um and uh he provided the resources along with the American Federation of teachers uh to run a campaign against the charter change revision that would have allowed the mayor to appoint all nine members of the Board of Ed um and he died too young this week um uh so you will not know who he was
153but he passed away too in the last few days um and he was responsible for bringing me into a meeting in Hartford and saying can you guys run a campaign down in brid support to block this change and stop it from happening and I said yeah I think we can do that and we ended up making sure that we still retain the right to vote for the Board of Ed in Bridgeport Connecticut so I just wanted to raise that and the last one a real Personal Privilege my daughter had a baby girl this afternoon congratulations congratulations congratulations thank you right um if there's no other business at the moment um I can entertain a motion moved by Miss batist Perez second all in favor say I I opposed all right motion to adjourn the time
154is 9:25 have a great night