CorpusRecord 270806

PSRC Board of Education Retreat: 12/6/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PSRC Boardroom
Date
2024-12-06
Location
Robeson County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
26,840 words · about 150 min
Collected
2026-10-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e I would like to call this um I would like to call this uh Board of Education Retreat meeting to order um first item on the agenda gender we have M Dr Freddy Williamson stages of change and turnaround that should be Pro not good afternoon good afternoon I hope everybody's doing well that lunch was enjoyable and here we are on a Friday afternoon in December if you can believe it December 2024 it's hard to believe that we're at this point I tell people in my church all the time don't take your Christmas lights down cut them off wait a few days flip the switch and you in season it moves that fast I just got back from um superintendent's meeting in Greensboro um I say this because it is it is true the

002public schools of Robinson county is a part of of every conversation not because of one individual but because of the work and the turnaround work that's going on in in the district and I say that in all honesty so I going to start by saying thank you to the board certainly for your support for your work uh for your toughness because when you bring about change it is not easy you have a lot of conversations and you have to fiddle through what's true what's not true there's always the time element because around and Improvement takes time because the first issue is always trying to build capacity in everybody we started the conversation as hard to believe with four years ago with with three major points one was as as we do this work let's get

003the order right and and the order is not transformation first the order is turnaround in the turnaround process trans transformation will happen you'll see things beginning to change and and so your first stage of that is whatever level of success celebrate that but then you have to repeat it right you can't be a one hit wonder you can't be content with growth over one year you you have to celebrate that and then you have to repeat that on the way to sustainability the first effort is predictability can we take the data can we and predict what's going to happen not only from day to day but from month to month and year to year and I know I'm preaching to the choir and so we've had a conversation around is this District a formative District

004every day are we assessing everything that we do for improvement and so one of the statements that we've made um and you have to think about it and process it is that there is no victory in trying harder think about that people often say well I'm working hard that may be true that but there is no victory in being able to say that I am trying on so you need again a plan that Vision all those components that would help that conversation go away and be replaced with we're growing and we're improving and our goal is Within Reach is Within Reach and then the time element of of that so I want to very quickly I've heard the ongoing conversation about time so Mr chair I'm clear on that um I want to start with

005before we started the conversation with principles and with everyone that is R 2 the3 power and this is a simple simple model that we put in place it is a business model in terms of how do you engage everybody how do you make reality building capacity so that in the end our kids are where they need to be obviously we have to have good principal teachers and you'll see that throughout so R to the third power starts with relationships very intentional very that's clear in my view but not relationships built on compromise that will get you nowhere relationships built on facts and the truth and to help people know yes we appreciate you yes we want you part of the process but relationships critical right I've often said that leadership matters but relationships matter just

006as much one of the things I said to the group of superintendent is be relationships with your board and I honored you at that meeting and this board was honored they gave us $2500 to the board for scholarships and so you have to make a decision on on that the the next order is relevance how does everything connect and why does it matter why does it matter for the board for our community for our parents for everyone for our students so the relevance of the work and you'll see we'll have a conversation in a minute about no random acts and the third is rigor and that is a moving Target that does not mean more of that's not what riger is about you can pile on it pile on with riger you would know riger

007by the change in the classroom in terms of kids that's where I look for when we go in and we listen and to the questions when we put our students at a productive struggle do they have to think do they have to process do they have to draw on all those kinds of things but this is where so relationships relevance and rigor matters and that's where we started next please so the second part of it and again it is just so simple but it is powerful when implemented is stages of change this pyramid is tells us a lot so on the left you can see the effect on performance lower part of the triangle is has a negative impact eventually you're going to get to the positive and and so I want to run through

008this of of work look on the right that's important so we go from random act to from very very intentional we want people to understand we're not walking in the classroom to say got you we're walking in the classroom to monitor the work and support so again real simple but powerful when put in place we have moved from having a knee-jerk reaction to everything if you spend your time with a needer reaction you got a lot of work to do you ought to be able to anticipate and predict things that's going to happen so no Random Acts no random act I'll give you example of that not having a Core Curriculum we open the door and allow Random Acts we allow everyone to do their own thing in the classroom to use whatever that's what

009that really really meant the second stage is our journey is north and youve read the literature on a North star where where we're headed so we established meaningful expectations you gonna see that in a minute through our strategic plan that's what that is our vision and those expectations of where we want to be notice though you're still in the negative you're moving but you're still in the ne the next one is barriers and blind spots and they exist they exist how do you deal with the barriers whatever those barriers might be part of that is push back right part of that is traditional folks want to stay do things the way they've always done that those those are barriers is well our job is to push through that so that we can get the work

010done and move our kids and there are blind spots there are blind spots we have to identify though those existing conditions and be honest about and then accept the opportunity to do something about that and then it's the culture separate definition it's the way we do things what is the Robinson County way what is the Robinson County standard what is the Robinson County expectation of the work that we're doing so it's the culture it's the way that we do business in this in this District it aligns people structure and systems in place you'll see that in our strategic plan and then it's been very intentional we're on the plus we believe that we are at state five that we're very intentional that we're not walking into anyone's classroom any building with the mindset of I

011got you I'm looking for what you're not doing we're monitoring and evaluating what is going on and we have systems and structures in place to have real authentic conversations about that so that's the stages of change we think that we're at the top of the pyramid because we are monitor we're very intentional with that any questions on that again they want you to think that we just just started the work without having a clear Simple Plan I met with every principal had this conversation and and said those of us that that's been a part of coaching you've always sort of keep it simple do not complicate what you asking student athletes to do so communication is a big part of the work look at the next sheet please we use this model for managing change

012because that is the key right is communication one of the first things that happened was we moved our PR person into cabinet so that they could be part of every conversation and that we will have an impact of what we ran in our local paper in terms of the work that was going on so so look at what happens and we use this and remind our folks if any stage of this is missing you can see the impact let's start at the bottom what if there is no vision but you have everything else then you have confusion right if there is no vision even the Bible says that where there's no vision what happens people perish and that is true that is true what if the skill says and and miss it what if the

013capacity to do the work is not there and we need to address that when that's the case anxiety people don't know what to expect they make calls and decisions about something that they have not tried and and we've been there that is not a problem got state of course when incentives are missing you get resistance you get push back when folks are not clear why are you doing this why are you changing a curriculum why you changing leadership you get that resistance then if the resources there's frustration great plan great idea great intentions but we don't have the funds to do that look at if we don't have it an action plan F thoughts the worst thing that can happen in a public school system is false starts great conversation great plan great you wrot

014something out you didn't prepare properly and you have to start over now now that is not to be confused with I don't want to change that's not what the conversation is and then finally look what happens and we're at stage five if you go back to the pyramid when all those components are in place terms of managing change and how we communicate you get success at this point we're looking at success with all of the growth student outcomes that we've seen leading to proficiency any questions on that Real Simple Plan Mr Craig Mr Craig okay thank you uh Dr Williamson when some of this was started we had the 10 to 12 people going in classrooms which was um nerve-wracking for teachers right and there was a lot of resistance for that and I and

015and I was one of the ones I that complained about it so we now are down to where it's like two or three people are are going in so what's the response from teachers as far as how that has changed them right our vision of that was we understand and we made it clear we're not checking on you that in a negative way we're monitoring the change has been people are inviting us in their classroom they want us there they want us in the buildings they want to demonstrate the work that they are doing in the classroom and that's always the shift that people are not shocked kids don't react when you walk in and we've seen all of that in a positive way so we're being asked to come in and even we met

016with APS and we're saying we're trying to get into your buildings and the response was come in our buildings and see them about three short from being in every school first semester so um followup is the feedback that that y'all get does that well that you would get do you give that Direct irly to the teachers now or is that given to coach or principal to give to the teacher to to everybody we s the teachers to the coaches to the principles um we can communicate that and and part of that we're g to talk about um in the plan that we have so that real time feedback is what you're talking about and that is our practice that have that conversation before you leave the classroom with the teachers in real time whatever the

017need is to do that last question let's suppose that uh that class that you came into uh for lack of better words it just bombed it wasn't good how is that feedback then given to that teacher you know like quickly where we're not throwing the teacher under the bus at the same time very private but in real time we'll pull the teacher and whisper something to them or we're write a note our intent is never to embarrass someone but to have that conversation we realize that you're not where you said you're going to be in your teaching plan we realize you're not prepared we realize that that this is not your normal behavior whatever it is because we're watching your kids so part of that Craig and that's a powerful question is historically you will

018walk in a classroom and you would look at what the teacher was doing that's not the case that's not what we're doing we walk in a classroom and guess who we're looking at the kids we're looking at what are the kids do the information and data we need is with the kids and so you always know by what the kids are doing it may be midway through before we ever say anything to the teacher thank you yes okay so so the final two parts of the m is this random acts of improvement we all know that cannot happen if it's random if it's all over the place if it's not aligned if there is not a common language you cannot improve so look at this stage we all School Improvement is the key having that

019plan we've modified School Improvement in that we identify those tasks and we plug those tasks into the work so that is really a living document as the intent has always been always been so let's take a look look at this the goals clearly defined that's just having a plan something on paper check done is this a living document in terms of school Improvement so look on the right look at processes all of us recognize that's in the wrong place right if you've implemented something if you gone through something and then you're trying to lay out the process says it is not going to work so that is clearly on the road that's part of the false start look at the arrows all over the place that's random no [Music] alignment pretty clear not going to

020be successful flip to the next one so so then what is an align Act of improvement and that is the mod in terms of that we're Opera in for leadership is an aligned management system all the errors going in the same direction there is a Common Language there's clear expectation there's clear accountability in real time so look on the Li on the left so processes now is where they ought to be that's planning that's organiz and that's having the conversations up front that's being able to anticipate what's going to happen but the process is is in the right place look at the arrows all align this is what's important look on the right that little box you know what that is in every organization in every plan there are variables out of our control weather

021that's a variable out of our control lack of funding that's a variable out of out of our control so those are variables that we cannot control that we have to deal with again I just said to a group of superintendent As Leaders of districts we cannot afford to have a victim mentality I don't care what's we cannot lead if our belief if our mentality is that we are victims of funding if we're a victim of whatever the case might be so you're going to always have those variables but as you move through and improve that box becomes smaller become smaller again nothing complicated this is real real simple but it's in a language and it is a powerful business model that Fortune 500 companies use so stages of change where we are any questions great

022thank you thank you Dr Williamson next we will have the Strategic plan review um by the cabinet we have um Dr Deborah Dallas initiative one good evening or actually good afternoon chairman Lee superintendent Williamson and board members this afternoon we did want to take an opportunity just to provide an update on our strategic plan and progress on our work so far and to Dr Williamson's point this is a document that does show that we do not believe in random acts right this is a document that lines up the processes and procedures it outlines the expectations of our work so that we do have an established common language across the district so initiative one is framework for support and that's basically the main goal is to ensure that all of our staff are prepared to meet

023the needs of our students so one of the main strategies that we look at under this initiative is datadriven professional development there has been a major push to avoid random PD or PD that everybody has to go to when it doesn't really apply to me so we have been working very hard to use data to make decisions about what do we need to do to help our teachers or our assistant or our principles continue to move forward we use achievement data we use observational data we use our classroom walkthrough data we use just conversation we talk to teachers and find out where the struggles are so that's been a major push and a major change some of that Focus PD comes in the form of a Practice Clinic where it might be 20 minutes after

024school it might be during a PLC meeting where you pull a group of teachers together let's say I'm working with kindergarten and I want to address something going on at the teacher table it's a short snapshot we're trying to get away from this long intensive PD where everybody has to attend you don't see a lot of that happening in our buildings we do have to do it for letters but we try to avoid that when we can at all at all possible also really like I said talking to the teachers about what their needs are every time we do beginning teacher training we ask for an evaluation tell us what you think you need what would you like to at the next professional development every time we meet with our coaches or teachers or science

025PLC we're always asking what would you like to see happen next time because we know at the end of the day they know what they need more than anybody else in the building school and district plc's has been a major push trying to define the structures and protocols that should be taking place in a PLC uh they're not social events right they work and they're really trying to be very strategic about what's being discussed we've laid out some planning templates data analysis protocols problem solving we want to make sure that when teachers do have to come to the table to collaborate that it's actually purposeful we've added some additional plc's this year we have an atsi CSI PLC that we pull we have a supervisor PLC when we feel like we need to have people

026come to the table we want to do that because we know that collaboration is really key for our work crucial positions making sure that we do have some support in place um and that includes our assistant principls that includes our career coaches our academic coaches some schools continue to have interventionists all of those staff are critical to the support that we can layer in not only for students but also to layer in that support for our teachers as well had a big push around mtss and relay professional development Dr Bullard will talk a little bit more about mtss professional development later but we're trying to make sure that all of our communication is streamlined when an mtss coordinator hears information about mtss so does the principal so does our district implementation team so that there

027is no Randomness or confusion we want to make sure that all parties are hearing the same thing we want to make sure that they know what the deliverables are because to Dr Williamson's point when that's not there people get confused about what are we doing so we've tried to really work through that as well as relay our relay coach has been providing um professional development we've been doing some Refreshers just for people who kind of want to hear it again but we've also been ensuring that all of our new ilt members are being trained at this time we're happy to say that all of our returning ilt members are completely trained um but like I said we try to continue to support them with some Refreshers and and that's where our coaching comes in and

028finally we have the seven levers um that is really the glue of our work most all of our work focuses around or is attached to one of those levers so when we talk about datadriven instruction that's not just looking at summi of data like a check-in or summi of data like an EOG we're trying to look at data in real time that means we're looking at Exit tickets we're looking at student work we're trying to make decisions before too much time goes by so that we can retach and adjust as needed observation fees back to Mr Craig your point about the coaching Cycles making sure we're giving feedback the culture of coaching has grown so much in this District um to your point in the beginning when we had larger teams going in and a

029lot of that was because we were coaching other people or we were getting coached but at this point you have teachers who they do want you in there and they want to hear what you think which I think is amazing you can feel that in a building when they're they want you there they want your feedback um in some schools they we're still growing that that Comfort level is still growing um but that's been a huge shift for us as well instructional planning we have that in all of our plc's weekly we have a planning template where they look at unpacking the standards we're looking at identifying the productive struggle professional development is another key lever and we talked a lot about that is making sure we have these births of what students need Student

030culture making sure our students know that they're welcomed and they belong at the school and that ties in with staff culture those two are really the foundation if we don't have those it's hard to build those other levers in a school building and finally leading the leaders trying to make sure that our instructional leaders feel comfortable they feel effective in leading their buildings every day initiative two is very related and we've talked a lot about this in the past that principal as the instructional leader making this effort to make sure that principles do not live in a man I'm sorry turn it back on I'm sorry M chrisy Fields this is for initiative one yes ma'am what is PLC for for people who are watching professional learning community so it's a lot of times where

031grade levels come together maybe content people come together but it stands for professional Learning Community iot instructional leadership team that's usually consists of your principal your assistant principal your academic coach sometimes they'll bring in a counselor as needed but that's the core I and what do you mean when you say retach so when I collect data and I realize that I have more than 60% of my class who did not understand something as a teacher I have to make that decision to say okay okay I have to go back and retach it right so I'm going to actually identify where that Gap is and I'm going to try to hone in on that Gap there's sometimes when I get data and I realize it's a smaller population and I might be able to pull them

032off into a small group so we talk about trying to make instructional decisions based on the data do I have to retach the whole class or can I pull a small group or is it something I can reset real quickly so what do you do for the classes where they can't pull a small group who would help them with pulling that small small group if you don't have a second person in the classroom a lot of times when a teacher in her lesson his or her lesson design when you're releasing kids to that independent practice time where you're wanting them to show you what they know that's ideally when a teacher who's in the room by thems will pull that group right because the other kids are working pretty much independently they'll pull that small

033group yeah it's pretty flexible but it can be challenging okay I'm sorry I've jumped on the number two anybody have question questions about one Mr Terry then we're gonna call to Mr C hey Dr Dallas so this is this appears that we're reviewing um where we are on the 23 to 28 strategic plan if I actually pull up the plan under each goal there's objectives and all of those objectives are measurable so for example goal one objective a is by 2028 all schools will increase the percent percentage of teachers who exceeded student academic growth by 5% annually as measured by the evos system and if I go down and look at let's see go one of the objective a by 2028 increase the percentage of students participating in CCP or career in college promise of

034program or Advanced uh placement courses by 3% annually so my question is is there going to be any updates in this system on where we are with those in your presentation is there any updates as far as where we are with each of the items in the Strategic plan that's measurable so right now we're been going to be reporting out mainly on our strategies and action so the ones that are in the Le hand section that talk about an annual goal or a baseline goal that's data that we're currently collecting for that first one like evos data that's actually just released we just got our teacher growth data probably a couple weeks ago if not less so right now we're really working on where are we at with the implementation of the strategies and the

035actions but that is something that we will be working on so you're saying it's um this plan was for 20 23 through 2028 it's too early for us to receive any information regarding the measurables so at this point tonight we're going to be discussing more the strategies and actions and that's something that our team will'll be working on is pulling all of the data to match it up against each goal that does have an annual or more of a quantitative percentage change and when will we get that information that's something that we'll have to schedule the the norm is on strategic plans two and a half years into it is when you respond we do uh show the data at that time okay we have to set a Baseline and so it wouldn't be feasible

036to share that data at this point with an established Baseline you'll get it thank you Mr Curry um I think we've used these terms interchangeably but um we got career coaches we got academic coaches and we got interventionist interventions now our schools now do they all have academic coaches yes K12 we currently have two two vacancies but yes but academic coaches is what we call them at our schools now yes sir okay do we have career coaches we have almost is it 10 career coaches we have or eight because we okay and intervention partner we partner just for the career coach we partner with RCC so they're more house at our upper at our high schools okay okay interventionists a lot of those work mainly with our elementary that's oftentimes um funded out of Title

037One um so that's a hit or miss not every school made the decision that they needed an interventionist some of them utilize more of their instructional assistance so that's more of a site based decision so um a school could have since everybody has academic coaches a school could have two it been a high school could be nobody would have three of these year would have three academic coach have three a career coach academic and an interven they would they have we have anybody has all three so our high schools are the only ones that have career coaches and most of our high schools do not have interventionist so most often it would be two it might be an interventionist and a coach more in our elementary M or at the high school it might be

038a career coach and an academic coach and um and all of these are to provide assistance to all teachers or that's on that campus yep okay and students and okay last question now uh if you can Dr Dallas or if this is a Miss ER question uh how what funds are they paid out of so they're paid out of different funds ones I'll let Miss Erica explain the reason I'm asking this it has been part of this has been brought to me and part of it I bring later to misser but what kind of funds do we pay these people from so the academic coaches are paid mostly from their Title One funds um the career coaches as Dr Dallas mentioned is in a collaboration with RCC so RCC pays for half they actually pay

039all of them they're employed by RCC and then we reimburse RCC on a monthly basis for half so we pay for four and RCC pays for four we use dssf funds to pay for those to reimburse RCC for the um coaches and then the interventionalists can be either out of Title One or low wealth funding Mr chair if I may to Mr Craig's Point um there was a lot of conversation from Principal that I have to use my Title One funds to pay for academic coaches that was true uh what happened ER if you step back we had a $1 million cut in Title One money correct we had a million dollar cut in title one as well as 069 funding yes sir so the only place to do that we've already planned and organized

040when we look at our class sizes now they're small and so our intent next year um because we're probably going to have to maintain that cut is we'll take a look at our 01 positions because that's what it really is as a means of funding those academic coaches in buildings that will not change our class sizes that would stop us from doing that so we've already made plans of of how to take that conversation but it was that $1 million that we didn't know until the last minute that created that issue for us and one more followup and Miss Eric and I spoke about this but I'm Master to mention it again um the we have tutoring going on during the school day at schools the after school tutoring uh changed this year so you

041mentioned the 069 yes sir U just share with everyone again about the fuel how that was taken care of of that now we're not doing that yes sir so we've had that conversation from July August through with our principles that our 069 funding would be cut and one of the areas we had to cut was the allotments to the schools 069 is where the schools would use to pay for the fuel and bus driver costs to have those after school tutoring programs so we again had that communication with our principles about moving to a during the day focus with interventionalists so you eliminate the need to have those additional expenses after school or talk with them about if they offer after school an alternative funding source through either PTO PTA or parents being able to

042pick up children and they can do after school tutoring but the parents have to be responsible for picking up children because there's no trans other kind of fundraiser or use School funds to pay those fuel bills and the bus driver costs yes sir okay great question Erica the dollar amount cut to 69 was also was also a million dollars yes I love those questions because I don't want anyone to think that we just cut or we stopped something it's a funding issue and thanks for asking the questions about everything so a million dollar cut in both areas something had to change and it has happened doing today thank you thank so initiative two as we started with principles as instructional leaders like I said this is an initiative that we have spent a lot of

043time talking about hearing from our principles with the shift of moving away from managerial work to more of an instructional focus and one of the things that I love and that will really determine or help you help you determine if somebody's thinking is changing or their their content knowledge is changing is by the types of questions that people ask you and our principles the types and the levels of questions that they are asking about instruction has grown exponentially it is no longer about the basics of a lesson design but they want to know more detail about what should this look like when I'm in a word work station what should I do when this happens so they are growing and it's evident by the conversations that they're having it's evident in the planning sessions that

044they're leading the data meetings that they're leading and the type of feedback that they are providing to our teachers um also I think we've dealt with our ilts our instructional leadership teams as a not just growing them individual individually making sure our AP is growing our coach is growing but making sure that they are growing as a team um so that has been a lot of work this year and we're seeing a lot of dividends for that and finally to Dr Williamson's Point earlier it's it's about expectations that are being set in a building nobody wants to go to work and have a culture of compliance or a culture of metoc right our expectations in these buildings are of high expectations making sure that all of our students can learn to the level that they're

045capable of so things like providing real-time feedback holding people accountable accountability conversations having a Common Language those are all very instrumental in our buildings questions about initiative [Music] two that thank you okay kid hello Miss Christy Fields so we have a culture of high expectations and we're holding the the teachers and staff accountable what are we doing with the students to ensure the safety of everyone and to make sure that they understand their being held accountable as well right so I think that starts first in the classroom most often it is about our teachers teaching procedures and routines the beginning of the year we have what we call like a rollout it's a minute by- minute plan that we kind of teach students what things look like and what this Behavior looks like in the

046cafeteria what does it look like when I'm a bus so that's the first thing then if we start to see that there's a higher level of need that's where we start layering different supports is there another conversation we need to have does a counselor perhaps need to support but we want to make sure that yes all of our students are safe and that all of our students feel safe in our buildings and our employees and our employees absolutely yep because at any time if a student doesn't feel safe they're going to shut down and we always talk about maslo and Bloom's hierarchy like maslo is more about your socially emotional we need to make sure that kids feel safe at school before they even want to entertain mean I have to learn this and same

047with our staffs they have to feel a sense of belonging they have to feel like somebody cares about them for them to want to come in and show up at work every day yeah Miss Melissa o okay so in that regard um Dr Dallas I have a a question basically regarding the way we transition um Elementary school kids to to Middle School okay and they're um socio emotional growth and health um I think I know we have like a transition day where they go out they meet teachers they meet the staff um and most Schools they're placed in a separate building I know as at South Robson sixth graders are in one building the rest of kids are in a different building I think that's great because they don't right now need to be integrated

048um but I do think that that an expectation should should be set with the staff to understand that these are still they're still kids yeah they're they're they just came com fresly out of middle school I'm sorry Elementary School and the expectation for them to have grown up over the summer right is not obtainable so I feel like not to say I know we have to let them grow up they're I mean they're going to grow into it they're going to by second semester they're normally into the swing of things but I think there should be some type of transition class or transition where the staff is trained properly and the kids are given a a set expectation because you can't just throw these kids into middle school and automatically expect them to have Middle

049School Behavior when they were just with in an elementary setting with teachers that were nurturing and now they're thrown in like just just thrown out there it's it's a a tough change and a lot of them get into the mindset they don't want to go um they're making up EXC they're getting sick every day so they don't have to go it's just it's an ongoing thing so I think that's something that we should look at as a district for these kids because Middle School can either make make or break you that's where kids normally decide if they're G to continue past to the ninth grade or till they get 16 middle school is hard yeah and I I totally agree the transition years whether you're leaving a K3 school going into fourth grade or you're

050leaving a K5 school going into a larger Middle School experience but we also see that transition when they go to nth grade at the high school right right the size of the school it's very easy for a student to get lost in the shuffle because it is a bigger experience so we do have some transitions that's where our counselors are absolutely critical and making sure that our students like picking up those signs making sure that students have an outlet but the transition piece is critical and I I totally agree that's something that we will continue to look at yeah I think our C some of our councilors are missing missing the mark when it gets when it comes to those kids yeah I got you thank you good good afternoon and to add to Dr

051Dallas's conversation about the supports that are offered in the classrooms either through interventions um how to redirect Behavior what we implemented about four years ago was a districtwide um discipline code of conduct so students at every school uh has to adhere to the same code of conduct and that is shared with principles and administrators and uh teachers and students throughout the district so again everyone singing from the same song book is a reason that can support those discipline issues in the building Bobby Bobby if I may and and I want to make it clear I am not going to tolerate students putting their hands on a adults I don't tolerate that um kids are not going to be in the buildings if they're to a point that they think they can put their hands on

052on the door unacceptable I never have I never will I'm G be clear about that and so what my my first conversation for today is about initiative three and is equity and as Dr Dallas was speaking I think all of her conversation in initiative one and two can be summed up in the action to take place in initiative three and that's Equity because as she stated prior to um the work we begin kids were exposed to different curriculums across the the district and is that fair to all of our students is it fair as Mr Craig has stated this several times is it fair for me to be at school a and receive this I move and go to school B and I get something totally different so when I think about when I think

053about this initiative in terms of equity are we being fair and just and so one of the first uh strategies within Equity is teaching the intended curriculum so that's the reason we established a Core Curriculum throughout the district so that we would uh we would not have those inequities from kids from building to building classroom to classroom because again we all knew prior to the core different teachers were doing different things within the classroom to what they believ the standards were now with a Core curriculum it is clear what the standards are and what those standards that need to be taught within the classroom uh also another initiative that kind of came up came about through our work but also we had to be more intentional in our funding because as Miss ER just stated

054we lost $2 million last year so we had to be we had to establish norms for how we allocated our funds funds and how those funds were being spent so we created a list of District resources what we've also done over the last few years excuse me is we have been able to provide through rester funds technology in all of our buildings so now all of our buildings are one to one so again kids are not sitting in one classroom in one building having access to technology and then move to another building and not have that access so again um we've also provided what we uh have a list of V vetted programs that teachers in schools are to choose from so as Dr Dallas stated earlier we just don't have random acts of hey

055I want you to go to this math PD I want you to go to this science PD or I want to buy this program because the salesman came by and dropped off a cake to me today no we're using this program because we know it works and we know it's going to support our Core Curriculum also when we think about equity in years past it was are we being equal was everybody getting the same thing and we know that doesn't work we have to have different level of supports again I'm going to drop go on Dr Dallas's entire conversation there are some teachers in the building that need more support to those academic coaches there are going to be more kids in the building that need more support through either the academic coach interventionist or

056career coach so again we are putting people in the building so that every child has the opportunity to be successful at the end of the day and at the end of the school year and at the end of the graduation so equity in terms of How It's addressing the student the uh strategic plan for us it is our desire to meet every child where they're at and move them forward and then members in terms of equity and budgeting we practice in Erica you may want to address this zerob based budgeting meaning that we do not automatically roll something over because it was funded this year if it did not meet the plan that they have to submit outcomes then we evaluate that but there is no automatic roll over of funding that's correct we have

057that as part of our cabinet meetings and all of our other um Summer Leadership as we go through the talking about the next year um and a lot of times we do it without knowing what our budget is as you all know we don't normally have a budget over the summer but we still have those PL planning meetings to discuss you know what work what is something that the teachers feel like we need to have in place um by departments everybody has a voice there at that table to talk about um looking forward to the next year all right miss kryst chrisal you got Chris um this is just like I guess for the whole thing is what happens when the teachers um leave in middle of the school year how are the subs or

058them student getting the teaching and on level as the other kids that have a full teacher in the class does that make sense Dr Dallas want to address that please so in some cases depending on the experience of the sub it's somebody that's been subbing previously understands the curriculum the ideal thing is that they get plugged into that pre professional learning community so as we're planning as a team right they're hearing that they're planning with us that's the ideal situation in some situations depending on the sub if we can and the class size allows it sometimes we'll disperse and break down a class and make sure that kids can move between different teachers who are there um so we do it in a variety of ways depending on the situation we really have to look

059at who the sub is what the experience of is and what's the context of the classroom that we have and also will you address one of the advantages of having curriculums that has already done that design work that is stripted to some degree that help with those subs they don't have to create and try to figure out how to teach the standards you simply need to follow what's already in design great question but that makes a difference so number number four modern and Innovative learning environments and systems uh I think on the agenda it has cabinet there but we played rock paper scissors and I was chosen to get up here and speak but all my fellow cabinet members please chime in so uh goal number one is ensure every student receives a personalized experience

060and a blend learning Blended learning environment again I already mentioned this earlier part of this we could not do this unless children had devices so early on when we received our ESA funds we knew there were schools uh that did not have a device for every child to put in their hands so uh we spent our erra funding to provide iPads for K1 and Chromebooks for all K2 all 213 students also uh did staff had uh ensure that staff has instructional material and support for that Blended learning going back to to our curriculums our curriculums allow for those integration of standing up face to face but also giving the child the opportunity to turn around and do work with the technology using the technology to enhance their learning in the classroom So Co did bring

061bring about the use of canvas and so all of our teachers have been trained in canvas and how to use that as a learning management system so goal number two is sorry before you move from goal one that address technology let me ask Erica we're in the process of evaluating our one toone devices how do we replace technology devices um first of all Erica to replace what kids have now would cost us how much we talked about six million I was going to say at least five but six is probably a better number um judging the fluctuation and price of technology and how you know most technology is no longer the most recent thing after 18 months so you're looking at a short timeline there of replacement right so and I'm sorry so in our

062conversations and our planning meetings around technology because we probably have about a year left I think we did it stand Bobby um on on our contract Service contract right for some devices anyway we think we have a year before we're really going to be faced with that and so at some point we'll look at a least to own option as a way of upgrading the devices that our kids have that's going to be the only option because again it would take six million plus to put a new device in every student and teachers hand so that's going to be the only option um that we have but just to make you aware we always planning and having that conversation and the Google license was also extended on for our Chromebooks so we thought we were

063going to have several that were at end of life and with uh Google a year I believe go go up to 10 years have no expect of the device correct a Chromebook is not going to last 10 years but at least with the license so we did have some Chromebooks that we thought regardless if they were still um being able to be used the license would go dead on those Dev devices and have to be renewed but Google has given us up to 10 year extension there and we do have a plan through technology that was a five or six year plan on phasing in and out by school and location to include Chromebooks clear touch boards all of that we're in that yes hold on hold on one second Mr Bobby um Bradley Mr

064Bradley Phillips then we got Mr Terry do we currently have a dollar figure roughly of what a lease option would look like versus purchasing no sir I don't have that that data right now but I mean we can look at at that option but again we'd have to go back to the plan and and see year by year how many we would have to cycle in and out but we can get that information all right Mr Terry I was uh recently contacted by someone from T-Mobile and uh this individual is interested in um providing either uh anywhere from 100 to a th000 iPads um and with the devices for free as long as we would pay like the the cellular service or whatever is that something that we'd be interested in engaging in or is

065that something that we've done in the past as far as connectivity and devices now all of that funnels through e rat so all of that's locked into contract so we wouldn't be able to differentiate that and just go with T-Mobile we'd have to do another um like through our rap program and put that out for bid because right now Spectrum has um the connectivity and that is their eate funding gotcha so that would um from what I can gather I think it would be their first thing with the on the state of North Carolina so it would be correct okay gotcha and none of our devices have cellular I mean I'm sure T-Mobile was just talking about internet connectivity but no nothing has cellular data our none of our iPads have cellular data Mr Curry

066I think M might have mention now we're we're talking about possibly leasing that six million figures if we replaced everything at one time corre correct cor okay have we are you looking at um and I don't know how you would get to which places which ones okay if we do a third next year and do a third the following as far as purchasing has anything like that been looked at as far as cost that's the what you were talking about then okay that's what I want to make I can't say Mr Craig actually in like a third I can't give that percentage but we have the schools in place that are in line next for um the upgrades could do the upgrades it wouldn't cost the Six Million it would be l no no sir

067it wouldn't looking at that compared to leasing which one would be our best option is correct what we're g to be looking at yes sir okay thank you Mr chair I'm may add to that conversation and so in our planning meeting we were faced with what we asked for this year for current expense that was $6 million that would get us locally $1,000 per child compared to where we are now at 650 the bottom and state and so when we looked at our push and what we going to ask the board to support is the $6 million current expense money over even technology that led us to Let's explore the lease plan we probably could afford that per year but what we really we've got to have is current expense now of the Six Million

068we've got how much already one point 1.3 we've been allotted and has been included since we began receiving our July Appropriations we get those monthly so 1.3 of that six million has already been funded and what was said to us from the commission is once they went through the Ral finished that process we set down in the new year to see if we can get at least half this year and then half year two that's where we are waiting to see what we can get balance up for this year but I I want to be clear why we even considered a lease because current expense takes precedent over anything else that we have facing us at this point we cannot continue to operate 650 local per child Mr um Miss er uh best of my

069recollection I think you gave us a figure of 374,000 a year for damage repair 368 last year last school year it was 368 368 $368,000 so in a lease program the lease company would incur those charges am I correct you can have that buil into your lease that would be so they would give you several price points if you wanted to layer in insurance and all of that but typically in a lease option that's a requirement to have the insurance so that'd be a major factor in the reconsideration yes and sometimes depending on the device like I know when we looked at uh iPads they would have a buyback value that you could then funnel into new devices okay go go number two ensure that students and staff demonstrate Mastery of D digital literacy skills

070so we have employed um digital teaching and learning coaches at all of our schools to assist staff members with this but also at the beginning of the school year we offer training for both students and staff on Internet safety and digital or technology protocols uh we also have our students and staff sign off on the technology agreement at the beginning of every school year and uh the state is supporting go Guardian for this year so we currently have Gaggle as a system that will notify us if students make a threat or have um inappropriate items through their email it could be a picture of a gun it's going to notify the principle to go investigate that so we do have measures in place to ensure or to help ensure that our students are uh using

071technology appropriately and lastly goal number three was deliver mobile and flex fible access to Business Systems so uh I'm going to go back to a very very old terminology uh that was used when computers first came out and it's G goo so that's garbage in garbage out so part of our initiatives over the last couple of years has been to clean up all of our systems to ensure that we have accurate data in there and that is going to be even more crucial this year as we transition from Power School to Infinite Campus to ensure that all of our student D student data is accurate and up to dat because again that is the starting point for all of our funding and uh other programs as we move throughout the district okay thank you good

072afternoon everyone I'm here to discuss initiative 5 excellent professionals we have two goals under that particular initiative the first goal is to ensure high quality professional development process or cycle so one of the things that we're great we feel great about is that we make sure that there is an alignment with our professional development so at the district level we have planned our calendar throughout the year so teachers know that we have this these designate times um to do professional development we're asking the same thing from our schools to go through and set their professional development dates as well and so a part of it is looking at the comprehensive needs of each school that they decide what what is what is a need for that school as it relates to professional development at the

073district level we're doing the same as that thing and so you have an alignment there so there's no random act as relates to what people are getting as a home uh next we want to continue to strengthen and expand our professional um learning communities so a part of that is um doing more planning and data meetings within our plc's and really um settling what those plc's actually look like and the function of our plc's so when they come these are not wrting sessions but these are actually problem solving sessions trying to get to the root of student learning to improve student learning and look at what we what we need to address for as misconceptions in the learning process to address it to make sure we improving our student outcomes we were also um looking

074at ongoing professional development within um the schools on mtss Dr bullet and her team um they're constantly um meeting with our mtss coordinators those mtss coordinators are meeting with their schools regularly um at least once or twice a month discussing strategies data meetings um problem solving techniques to ensure that we are doing all we can to make sure we are closing gap of student learning goal two will focus on the recruit development support and retain divers and talented professionals one of the things we're going to discuss later on that we have in the psrc the most diverse talented um team in our state and probably I compare it to even the country our numbers as it relates to diversity is high and so I feel very great about that being a part of the psrc

075we have our annual recruitment there that's held in the spring um we're also increasing and strengthening our Partnerships with our local colleges and universities we'll be actually um psrc has been asked to host um a round table uncp on some um action goals that they working on and so the cni department along with HR will be participating with our UNC Partners on that Round Table discussion leading those things uh utilizing our TA to teacher program those that's a state program in which we're having Tas teacher assistants who want to become teachers last year we had um five Tas to participate now that's through the state program but I will say this we actually had over 15 Tas become teachers this school year and that number is set to increase again so that tells you a

076lot that the psrc is on the move and we are building and growing our own people um we're also assigning mentors our beginning teachers um last year our um beginning teacher program that is overseen by Mr keia mcka our beginning teacher coordinator um actually received several Praises on our beginning teacher program and one of the parts that they received praised on was the our beginning to receiving academic coach support which me the academic coaches are going there and coaching our beginning teachers on instructional practices and so that was a very highlight of what we're doing well in the psrc with our beginning teachers we're also utilizing signon bonuses to um for hard to fill areas and so we uh our such as KC um K sit math science Ela English language learning teachers they receive

077a $1,500 sign on bonus um exceptional children's um teachers receive a $3,000 sign on bonus and psychologists receive a $5,000 sign on bonus and that is split between fall and spring semester we also reimburse those teachers who are going through initial lure so all our first year teachers who are coming in who need to obtain a license they can receive up to a $2,000 reimbursement per year to complete their license here we're always um each year we're reviewing our turnover data and our Trends as relates to employment um to to Really gauge on our staff movement and lastly we are collecting our increas in our efforts to collect um ex interviews and I know Mr Craig we mentioned um at our last board meeting about that and so what we started doing is um now

078that is an electronic process and so um when we have individuals to the part that're receiving that link immediately to conduct those ex interviews so we can collect that dat at the end of the year to review that as well and so that is our district initiative five as we to excellent professionals all right U we got two questions on um first go Miss christe Fields then I'm g go Bradley then I'm go Mr h so let's be realistic we know that everybody doesn't do all things well so what if you've been doing to identify your weak areas or areas that need additional attention to make them better as teachers or I'm just well you you said excellent professional so well that's that's the title that's the goal of the title so once again with

079our academic coaching um that we're providing our teachers each year each day we're making sure that we when we go into those classroom that we are increasing our capacity of our teachers to make sure they're really paying attention to student learning as relates to overall we want to make sure um that we are aligned with our district initiative so therefore when we're at the human resource department the C Department the maintenance department that we're all gearing towards making sure that we are doing everything we can do to improve our capacity on our professional jobs and so those are things we're always constant in communication in our cabinet meetings looking at what we're doing can we can we do better what areas do we do better in so we're always constantly reviewing that that information of

080what what are we doing as far as our practice each day in each department so yes ma'am all right Mr Bradley you said a a link is sent for exit interviews who's that sent to so the yes so any individuals who are resigning um or retiring they receive a link um for the complete several questions about whether they're U why they're leaving uh their thoughts on the current job um will they consider coming back those are type of questions they might receive when they ex interviews and then that comes to my department okay that was my next question where where it went so if I'm the employee the link comes to me not my principal no no no no one else receive that link but that individual and no one else has access to it

081except for my department um how's your followup depending on or is it Case by case you what you get back in that and it could be Case by case and some typically like said um some people tell us the reasons for for they're leaving yeah um they're not required to and others might and then we that could result in a followup um by my department if they be okay thank you Mr Mr Henry ter you next on the uh professional development piece uh Dr Dallas is is this in alignment with um like you were saying you were interacting and the teachers are looking for the coach uh from the cabinet members to come in is that uh professional development in alignment with this with the needs of each particular school or the system how how

082is that monitored um so most most of the time when we're working with schools they are identifying the needs within their own school so they're developing a professional development kind of calendar within their own school or along Ong the way they identify like I said gaps in they targeting and deciding we'll do a practice clinic or we need to come back and revisit this so that's done and we do that as well at the district level because when we go in and out of classrooms we're collecting data and as relay coaches we sit down and we talk about what we're seeing when we bring in our CIA supervisors we're talking about what we're seeing and that's how we're trying to identify the needs and as well as talking so it's all lined up like his

083BT program is lined up with what we do in fact most of our academic coaches help support that and deliver the professional development there do we ever pull resources to come to us for um professional development well you would think about like we have Ashley Harris from Eureka right she is somebody that works with them and we do utilize her to push into our plc's during the summer she did some math one training so we do utilize um some of our vendors as far as with our curriculum so mainly with this year it's been Eureka and then we also have some support for our CSI schools that we have some um L staff that come in and help and support ilts within schools so once again that that's tailored to what that school needs it's

084not this is what we do everywhere they're tailoring the professional development to that school I'm sorry m one more question um the curriculum that we are using now do they have any resources to give any uh professional development oh absolutely so so those those companies can provide that to us right like so Ashley Harris she works with Eureka she's the one that worked with our original roll out right she knows that in and out our teachers love her because she's established a relationship with them they trust her so we utilize her a lot like I said to push into specific grade levels once again it's not everybody getting the same thing it's pushing into seventh grade and making sure they understand the content for their grade level so we do utilize them Mr chair if

085I may before you yes go to Terry Mr H your question is a conversation we've had how do we resolve our capacity issue how do we grow our employees and we made a conscious decision you think about it is we can't depend on external to solve our internal issues so we became very intentional and growing and building capacity internally to sustain it great question that's been our plan and it's been trem sucessful and we put in a tremendous amount of training but if we're going to resolve our issue it has to happen internally great question Mr ter so Mr C you mentioned the $2,000 incentive for someone to be licensed who's uh who's that for so those those are who who are need initial licensed teachers so those teachers who who did not go through

086a actual teacher program undergrad who are coming in Jamal Campell want to teach um science at a school and I have a four-year degree but I need to obtain my actual teaching license I can actually um get the $2,000 reimbursement each year to complete to complete my my for my certification for my teaching license those are individuals who receive that reimbursement is that same uh is that same incentive available for um the for TAS that want to be teachers so once again so we you have the TA you have the TA the teacher program that we can actually um H put them in for that as well but um I'll have to get um the T teacher program that's through the state right yes yes sir okay so what are we doing here for our

087TA the teachers so we have two parts um we have the state ta teacher program which this year for the first year became a reimbursement program previously we would get allotted $4,600 per ta and I think we have would have five so we get an allotment and we'd spend from that um now it's a reimbursement basis but we also in our title 2103 budget had a process the same process in place for an additional five employees so we're using our title two funds to to D doubled amount um of ta to teachers that can participate in that program um our uh Tas that become teachers are also eligible for the sign on bonus we used to have a provision where you couldn't have been employed with us in a certain amount of time but we've

088changed that to say you couldn't been employed as a teacher so if they come in part of T teachers they become a teacher and one of those hardto staff areas they qualify for the sign on bonus um we the $4,600 is to help them pay any cost um at the college they're attend in for tuition um and then we also would pay for their uh practice test their first test so those are some of the things we're doing so you said something about uh your supporting five five from the state and five from title 2 okay that's how much we budget for there's an application process and an interview process that HR goes through um to bring in those that are interested so at this point we may not have a total of 10 that

089are participating currently they'll look at that program again I think you do it twice um in the fall to start for in the fall and then they look at a spring cohort as well yeah um my my uh I'm I'm just sitting here wondering if there's um if there's a number of Tas that would like to participate in that program that maybe we don't have funding for based on the application process and the interview process there hasn't been more than 10 at any time that want to come in and that are eligible and go through that process there has not been more than 10 at a time that showed an interest not saying they're not there they just didn't come forward during those processes and just F FY Terry of that process is actually we

090sent out I think M Jessica sends out an email um at the beginning of the year alerting those invers who want to um be a part of that program we have a deadline that we have to um um U submit to but that is Wild broadcast so that any who wants to be a part of that program they can um come forward and um see if they're eligible to participate in that program yeah if there's ever a time that we run into some we run into more than 10 that want to participate in that you need any kind of board support uh to increase that number I'm sure that that we would try to support those initiatives thank you uh Miss christe Fields one question will you define hard to fill areas what is what

091is how is that defined so hard to fill area such as our science math Ela exceptional children those are our some of our top areas that are hard to feel meaning um they typically have the most vacancies um typically you know U there's a lot of people may not actually go into those particular areas initially such as EC and so we try to incentivize individuals who possibly want to actually teach in those areas to come with us at the psrc in those areas thank you good afternoon everyone bring you greetings from the Communications Department Miss Jennifer could not be here today so I'll be presenting on initiative six communication and Community engagement um communication we are always looking to improve our communication um modes and um we want to be clear consistent and concise with

092our communication and like some Old-Timers in Robinson County would tell you I can show you better than I can tell you so I'm gon walk you through some things um goal number one Ensure High Performance communication everybody's pretty familiar with our thrill share call out system correct we use that to communicate with our parents we text and we call um we also send out our newsletters monthly through that system um did anybody know about the parents Corner are you pretty familiar with the parents corner on our website I'm gonna take you there Cole has already clicked it for me um Miss Brenin helped put this together and she could not be here today for um personal matters um so any parents that have questions they can go directly to our website if you're watching robinson.

093k12.nc.us and under the banner that shows our video you will see parents corner you can click that button and all of this information here is accessible to you free of charge any any question you have I mean scroll all the way up for me Cole if you would there's a vast amount of information on here from calendars to um resources our parent guide to student achievements on there as well and some some things to do with registration um and then ncdpi our welcome letters on there as well so there's a lot of resources our parents can access here um and that is such a vital component to us with our public and our parents so they know what's going on um also if field transition back Co um when I came on as a one

094woman Department I realized I need a little help so I um was able to purchase meltwater it is a social media management software where I can crosspost and I can um mind my data from all of the the Twitter Instagram um Facebook all of the um channels and that also shows us our mentions as well so I'm able to streamline um the process and know what's going on know where we're being mentioned know where we can improve and um I get feedback pretty quickly through that and I'm able to shoot out our messages about our board meeting board meetings easily there and other information to our publics um so that's another big thing that I use also if you look on the right that's going to be one of the um ways that we measure

095our progress through the meltwater software um so hang with me um we also use our internal staff newsletters you get those weekly they've had a break since I've been on leave but I will start that back up this week um for our staff to know what's going on and in that's a little calendar so they know all the little things that we observe every month and also our external monthly newsletters have basically all of our stories and things that we've put in under our news um section we send that out through our thrillshare um system every month to our parents they can go on there and see everything that's been posted everything that's been going on with psrc um so that is goal number one again we always strive to improve and there's always communication

096you never really arrive at communication because you always have changes and you have to act fast think proactive not reactive and it's it is a challenge for sure um goal number two BO boost excuse me boost stakeholder engagement um are strategies so some of these Faller Miss Jennifer um we have parently Liaisons at our schools and they help bridge the gap between um the school and the home they really work to coordinate things and they speak with our parents and keep everybody informed um also they plan I think they help plan the parent nights at those schools as well communication tools we talked about that we talked about our um call out system we talked about our social media as well and you know just Empowering Families celebrating all the good stuff going on hey

097we want you to be part of our um we want you to be part of our system we want you to be part of our children's um education because you matter it starts at home education starts at home so we want you to be involved D and that's such a big part of the communication is connection right um Family engagement nights are such a vital component to that Miss brindel and or family engagement uh specialist is over that and planning those and she falls under Miss Jennifer's Department we have seen a giant leap in um those events they're more interactive exciting and we have one coming up uh this month actually so also our resource list we have various resource lists if you went back to that parent um Corner the parents corner where we

098were at there was resources up at the Top If You just scroll to the top parents if you're watching make sure you um hit this up and see what's going on here and you can um access a lot of information right to your fingertips here um so to measure progress we want to utilize milk water like I talked about to track our social media trends and engagement I think I gave you guys a report last year on that and it showed you know that we're Rising with our engagement and our public um interacting with us also so this is a draft um but we it's in progress sending out an annual communication survey to identify areas for growth so that is I do have a draft and um that is something that I think is

099time to do again we sent out a survey um from brindan a couple years ago to gauge how parents like to receive information from us and how they like for us to communicate with them and we were able to get some really good information from that so we will be sending out a survey in the future to identify our growth and also um lastly uh we monitor communication improvements and stakeholder engagement um increases each year and again that is one of the modes we will do so um anybody have any questions yes ma'am Dr Emanuel I don't have any questions I have a comment okay maybe something you could consider you in this superintendent uh is highlight of parent maybe somewhere in some of your activities that maybe a parent from a community Maybe started

100a new business or received an award or something that to make it a little more personal if you can I think that would be cool okay again always looking for new ways to improve always looking for new story ideas too to put out there that would make it personal and uh I think parents would really like that maybe try to get someone from each district each month maybe or each week I don't know you wouldn't have time to do it every week but put a picture in your PR corner or something okay cuz people like to be recognized and that would make it a little more personal maybe they would read it more just to see who made it yeah absolutely think about that idea and see if you like it you're the superintendent absolutely

101and we we try to send out new stories about the exciting things our kids do their awards are staff members um just try to to celebrate as much as we can and yeah we're certainly open to parents to be stroke ped on the back too absolutely absolutely thank you and and um advisory councils too um You probably see that under the um actions as far as um councils but anyway we are in draft of doing a superintendent advisory Council we already have a parent advisory Council for the parents watching please email Miss brindan Brenin thompson. robinson. k12.nc.us and get involved we want you to be involved in our students education in your students education and you know we want to be transparent we want you to to join us in in that Journey um and

102and Miss Jennifer also mentioned a principal advisory Council to help um as well as we try to um improve our communication to our public any more questions Mr Terry Mr Jessica um do you have any idea why um it seems like over the past couple years the our our coverage in terms of meetings um has decreased in the roban well one way to combat that I have started doing the board meeting highlights on our website and I try to every meeting and I've been out you know leave but I'm back now every meeting I try to put the high points of what we covered and I try to mention you know the celebrations recognitions and and photos but um yes we have no notic that but um again trying to I share that on social

103media I share that in our monthly newsletters and on our websites so um they they are our media are being U made aware every week as you see um when we send out those announcements or every month as we send out those announcements that they are more than welcome to come we encourage our news media to come from The fiable Observer to News 13 to robesonian they're all welcome to come um and again if they have any questions about meetings they can call us I think part of that is you know we're streaming YouTube now and it's easy for them to hop on and hear better on there um so that could be a part of it but again trying to combat that is um putting out the board meeting highlights um trying to do

104that every meeting thank you Miss Jessica all right thank you thank you m Jessica um I think um we need a break we need about a 15 minute break anybody want to make a don't need okay well let's do a 15 minute break e e e good afternoon again just uh want to uh board members if you will on Tuesday night the psrc holiday committee has decided has decided to do uh have a reef contest per department so either before the board meeting or during the break on Tuesday night we will have the reef set up we would just like for you guys to judge those reefs and we'll announce a winner on Wednesday but we will have a reath from each department representing the work that we do and just if you guys please

105just judge those reefs for us on Tuesday night so uh next on the agenda is the Civil Rights CTE review um DPI selects a minimum of two to three schools per year to review the facilities at the high school or places where we have offer CTE courses so all of our high schools were were visited this school year with the exception of early college early college would fall under the umbrella of RCC whenever they do their visit and since we are in the process of building the new CTE building they did not visit the career center but they did visit our five Traditional High School so what I would will do for you very briefly today so that you have an understanding of the findings of those reviews as walk through the report that was

106shared with us you should have a long document that was placed on you I did not title it but just across the top it says School general site findings of non-compliance and location so as we shared in our finance and construction meeting the other tonight this is one of those requirements that does not come with a funding source with it other than our own funding so what I'm going to walk through first are just minor findings and when I classify these as minor findings these are things that we can fix within our buildings with minimal cost and hopefully be able to uh absorb under the work of our maintenance department so please understand as our maintenance department so Department uh Department are working on these things that will take them away from other things that

107are occurring in the school so you're going to see kind of the same language as it flows to this whole report I'm not going to walk through every page of this report but I will pick on Fairmont quite a bit because they are the first uh School listed so you're going to see drinking drinking fountain not accessible so if you look on page one of the report third down it tells us that the water fountain in the fieldhouse in locker room locker room number two at the baseball field is not Ada accessible so that means we need to replace that water fountain with an ADA accessible water fountain okay and you're again you're going to find that language at every site it's just not one on all of these they're going to be Universal across

108all of our campuses so the uh second you're going to see is Ada uh signage if you will look on on page five number three on page five at Fairmont it's going to say toilet rooms are not accessible uh there is no directional signage to the nearest accessible restroom so again we're going to have to go to each restroom that is not ADA Compliant place a sign there that says nearest restroom and I'm again using Fairmont may be hallway a or building a room three so again although it sounds easy easy of saying all we have to do is Place Ada signage at these locations where the bathroom's not Ada accessible no each sign's going to have to be unique because it's going to have to point to a specific direction or to a specific

109location within the building so sink Heights and exposed drainage if you will look again page seven um at the bottom it tells us that the Lis sync measures 37 and 38 and it lists all the places that these sinks are out of compliance in terms of height so we will have to go in and replace at least one sink at every location to meet ADA compliance and also the other syns that are in there on page eight if you will flip over says Loris sink did not have covered pipe so anywhere we have a a sink or any Plumbing fixture we have to ensure that the pipes are covered if they're exposed in case someone with a wheelchair decides to right uh use that sink and hit the hit the piping or whatever next we

110have student seating and I'm going to back up on this one if you will look at page um [Music] two the last one on that page for Fairmont and actually it goes over to page three as well we have two good examples here so it says uh student seating measures approximately 48 41 inches above Phenix floor those tables are not adjustable in that classroom so we're going to have to provide adjust a a certain percentage at least one table in that classroom that meets the uh required height where an a where they are ads access uh another example is on page three the first one where we have fixed Deb so again we're going to have to remove a certain portion of those desk out of the classroom replace them with tables so they become

111a accessible toilet and urinal Heights if you will look on page six at the last one on page six so it says the lowest urinal is approximately 21 in above we have to adjust that urinal to meet ADA compliance and just um the next one tole and soap dispenser height if you want to look at example of that on page eight and nine it gives us the measurements of the current tile and soap dispensers that are in the restrooms and it's just a matter of adjusting those Heights and we can simply go in and replace those with new ones so some of this work can be done and will be done by our maintenance department depending upon the lifting of uh installing new toilets new sinks that maybe we have to reach out to a

112contractor Pro well during the time of this finding we did we had already um contracted with a a a vendor to begin to go around to the schools and replace water fountains in the schools already so some of that work is currently being done uh prior to us knowing about this particular um f or our particular findings here now Cole if you will flip to the next slide so here's where some of the uncertainty lies and these are going to be our big ticket items that we've kind of given been able to get an extension on beyond having completed by August of 25 or December of 25 and these are the ones that we are uncertain about the amount of money that is going to cost us to fix fix these findings within our buildings

113as I stated at the previous slide these are mandates that we are required to do with no additional funding and Barbie Let's point out this is not the result of someone not doing something M it this is the result obviously of old buildings that at the time they were accessible and met the law but has since changed that's what we're having conversation about old buildings correct hold on one second um Mr Bradley hey U Mr BR just quick question where it says your timeline column is that a timeline that we've determined or is that a timeline that um CTE have determined for that particular incident so the whole the entire document in terms of timelines I'm going to say we were violent told about those timelines okay I'm asking like there was like on page

114two there's one that says 2030 I didn't know if that was when we determined that so there was some so there was some negotiating here we were originally told we had 10 years to spread all of these task out then they came back and said no you don't have that much time to do all of this work so some of them is hey go ahead and get it done immediately others we understand your budg budget constraints and we understand the dollar amount tied to making this particular repair or fix so yes we will give you extended time so it's a combination of hey we think we can get this done now but then there also they came back and said no you need to back some of this stuff up sooner okay thank you Mr

115Melissa how often are these reviews done Mr Bobby before these things have been so outdated and speaking with Mr Herman he said his recollection the last time that we probably went some through something similar to this was over 25 years ago so again the DPI only selects two districts per year so the likelihood of us being selected again uh unless we got some very very young folks in here is highly unlikely Mr Henry that was G to be my question uh Mr Bobby who actually came in and done the inspections was it County or was it the state no so miss state it was a State team it was under the direction of the state where there were CTE directors from across the state that came in and so when you see some of these

116measurements it was actually these guys walked in or folks walked in with measuring sticks and said let me put this at the door frame let me put this at the sink let me put this at the table and get an exact measurement this is not hey I think this table's 50 inches above the of the ground so uh ma major findings if you will look on P one the last one there it says there's no audio amp amplification system and this is at Fairmont High in the gymnasium you're going to find that at uh I think if it's at all of our schools this is not a PA system this is a system in which a an individual who is death the heart of hearing uh can come in we give that individual a device

117that individual that individual at that time is able to hear what's happening in the in the gym for whatever program we have going on at that particular time we have reached out to several vendors through coal and we have not been able to obtain a price for what that would cost us so again that would be something that would have to be placed at all of our all of our schools um next you're going to see this throughout uh configuration of our parking lots a lot of the language you're going to see is there's no accessible path between the parking lot and the school so a lot of our schools do not have signage in in the appropriate number of spaces so if we will Co can you get to Fairmont High and I walk

118through font high is um a an example so what the what the group came in and did is they had us to identify student parking versus faculty parking versus visitor parking so one of the things you can see here for Fairmont High and I'm sorry I did not let you know where that was at on page three three and Page four the last one on page three and the first three or four on page four so it's an individual finding per uh per currence at each school so one of the things they've said is at Fe High everybody's been to Fairmont High will you understand that this is the student parking lot this is a big hill that comes up to the school uh I think over here we have a couple of visitors parking

119spaces and there may be one or two handicap accessibles over there I can or identified handicap accessibles so we got um cited for not an appropriate number of student handicap accessibles there's not an accessible handicap path from either Park from the parking lot to the school so if anybody knows anything about Fairmont High this is a heel this is a heel so in order to obtain an accessible path you have to have a certain incline per so many feet and so on in order to meet that so one of our Solutions and this is where we're going to have to get uh have conversations with a with an outside individual because we're required to have ex I think it's seven we have to have four parking spaces and two of those have to be van

120so there's no way we could build an accessible ramp from down here to up here so we're going to have to convert this little parking lot here to handicap so again you know that's going to change the operation because when I was at Fairmont 20 years ago everybody want this was office parking up here so now this is going to have to change so that we can meet the requirement of having an appropriate number of ADH parking spaces at Fair High and I just wanted to show you this as an example we're going to have to go through every every parking lot at every school and identify um handicap parking and ensuring we have an accessible path from that parking lot to the school for students and so that may mean at some places we

121have to pave a a sidewalk going up to the building there are different things that we we have to do in order to make in order to uh correct some of the things that nobody's fault just were not made may not have been in place when like this parking lot was was built but we are trying our best to minimize of course we know we don't have the money to go build another parking lot at any school but in order to reconfigure parking lots that are currently there to meet the requirements within the findings Mr C on Mr Bobby Mr Curry I was just comment from further back Mr Bobby where all these um the water fountains whatever is going to have to be adjusted uh I think that probably will be some painting that

122will have to be done and uh so that's probably going to be an expense well I know that we will occur because if not we're gonna have some bad looking places yeah and so that was the reason again prior to this we contracted with an individual because they would come in because in some instances we're going to have to move piping we may have to change some electrical stuff so again that individual would come in of course we're providing the water fountains they come in install and everything is a term key job that's good yeah and again we're not let me make this clear we are not replacing every water fountain so if there's a water fountain that remains in place that's not handicap accessible again going back to my signage that I mentioned earlier

123we have to place a sign at that water fountain saying the nearest ad accessible water fountain may be down in the hall at room 100 and Mr Bobby um just reiterate again that we're not no money no funding for this is there no funding that we can go after to do all of this is that correct that is correct these are an unfunded mandate all right everything that you see in this document we are not getting any additional Capital outlay funds to complete what you see in this Pro in these in these findings okay and the last big ticket item and I want to be clear when I say this this does not mean that anything is wrong with the bleachers at any of these three facilities it just means that these three facilities the

124current bleacher system uh does not have handicap accessibility at them so again based upon the time frame these bleachers were put in uh they were not required to have handicap accessibility at that time so in talking with our bleacher representative that's been in the county for the last few years or at least since I've been in this position and talked to him about modifying some of these he has kind of said in his experience that um once you touch that set of bleachers you have to get all of it up the code you just can't go there and cut out a section make it handicap accessible you didn't have to go to the side you have to go to the top everything has to be redone and what he has found is cheaper or more

125economical not cheaper more economical to replace the bleachers than to try to go and bring it up to code piece by piece so at some point in time throughout this we will have to address uh bleachers at Fairmont High Red Springs High St Paul's high and if you want to see the statement that they have uh for font High it is page number two the first one and the reason that we again the part of part of this part of the study or walk through was to say that all children have access to everything within the building so weid these these three schools only identify the gym as the as the place where they would have student meetings and so as this being the only place that every student in the building would come to

126at one time means that we have to modify this place so that children in wheelchairs or uh who have some type of physical disability would have access to the gym but again just want and and uh again we don't have a firm dollar amount on all of this it's just we're just going to have to kind of play it play it as we go but we do know at some point in time there are big ticket items in this that we're going to have to address all right Mr Craig and I think we'll be that's be the last one oh I'm sorry I just can't resist uh another unfunded mandate from whoever and folks we just periodically get these did they say you got to do this got to do that and there's some good

127things here but they don't provide any funds to do it and it happens it will happen periodically Mr chair if I may and so from our construction and finance meeting we had conversation unfunded which means this becomes our capital projects for this year I know Dr man you had a list the other night and we said hold on this is what we were talking about hold on but this is our prior to we timeline that we have this is our capital projects for this year all right Mr Schwarz thank you um these are these are mandates that have been around for for quite a while from the federal government and under state and federal regulations um to deal primarily with accessibility issues for disabled people um it is while it's an unfunded mandate there is

128a mandate that your County Commissioners Supply the funds to meet your Capital needs and these are not only Capital needs they're requirements so all right thank you thank you uh hold on got one more I didn't see you br I'm sorry just came about so going off what Dr Schulz just said does our County Commissioners have any clue of this yet that anybody knows of to my to my knowledge no we have not in the New Year we start budget talks and okay start that conversation all right next we have School Board governance by Richard Schwarz I'm just getting my [Laughter] book I'll get my book out stand inside of hun I we cut that mic off talk hour without I got my timer on test test okay uh oh okay just working okay walk

129okay which is clearer make a difference okay all right good afternoon everybody um I've got uh a presentation prepared that is designed it's designed initially for new board members um but it's a real good refresher for uh ongoing board members I'm not going to say old board members um and I asked that you also bring your uh statute books and I want to point out a couple things that you've got in your statute book for those of you who may not be that familiar with it the general statute is the Govern School laws primarily are in chapter 115c of the general statutes and that's half of this book the other half of the book after you get through with chapter 115c are selected Provisions from the state constitution and selected provisions from other laws from

130other chapters of the general statutes that deal with public schools and so um sometimes you might see a reference to another statute um that's in chapter 14 which are the criminal laws for example or any other section of the general statutes and that may or may not be in the back of your book but um a lot of folks don't realize that this is more than just chapter 115c which are the public school laws also you've got an attachment of handouts and what I've done is I've selected different board policies that deal with board governance uh and we'll refer to them throughout this presentation so um without without any further Ado I will get moving along on this um this training is an overview it's not exhaustive and um I want to focus primarily on

131board authority and duties and so your different responsibilities as a board and your responsibilities as individual board members and I want to talk to you about before we even talk about um this General um you are V you are VIPs okay you are very important people without insulting anybody you are not very important persons okay and what I mean by that is as an individual although you're an elected School Board member you have absolutely no Authority whatsoever with regard to the public schools of Robertson County as a body of school board members you have a lot of authority all right so keep in mind the difference between the authority that you don't have as an individual and the authority that you do have as a public body so as an individual you have nothing so

132keep that in mind all right um so if you look in your Himel uh your public school law book at 115 c47 um that's the board's powers and duties and that statute goes on for a lot a lot of pages and it's got 78 different subsections you might look at it and say well wait a minute if I get to the end of it it's got 68 but you might see two 68s are there and a whole bunch of other subsections so there are 78 different subsections in that statute and if you go to the end of that statute you you'll see the legislative history you'll see that gets added to almost every single time the general assembly comes to town um almost every time every they come in and they add something to the

133authority and the powers and duties of the local Board of Education um so that's in5 c-47 if you look to the top um of those pages you'll see the statute numbers um 115 C40 is an Al is also an important statute if you don't know about it says that the board is a corporate body so the board of education is a public corporation and you are the Board of Trustees of that Corporation so the board has a separate corporate identity all right so in in North Carolina School boards are public corporations and that's and that's the uh that's the identity that's important because a corporation has a separate legal existence just as an individual has a separate legal existence and then 115 c36 is kind of a catchall statute that says that while while you've

134got all these different 78 different subsections telling you what the board's Authority and Duties are under 115 c47 if there's something else that deals with the public schools that is not enumerated in 115 c47 or any other law then it's your responsibility if it's not assigned to some other body and it deals with the public schools then you're responsible and that's what 115 c36 stands for um we've got different board policies that address this as well and they're laid out here I'm not going to go through them but for your homework assignment um you can go through the index to handouts and look at these board policies that are up here um on the uh on this particular slide and I want to I do want to call your attention to policy the last one

135that's listed there in the first section policy 2100 board member legal status and that's the one that tells you that you don't have any Authority as an individual board member um you only have authority when the board is taking action as a corporate body in a legally called meeting under the open meetings law so if six of you get together in an open meeting and take and and vote to take action by majority vote then you've got Authority at that point you are very important persons okay and at that point is when you have authority um by majority vote all right so take a look at in in board policy 2100 the one I just mentioned to you um one of the things it says is board members have authority only when acting as a

136body duly called in session they have no authority over school Affairs as individual or as groups of individuals so none of you for example could go into a school and tell a principal what to do okay um and uh or or tell anybody what to do uh tell the groundskeeper what to do um go to that slide that Bobby had up there at Fairmont High School in that football field and go to the groundskeeper and say oh my God you guys got to get out here and fix this football field um all right board policy 2010 um board and superintendent relations we're going to talk about that but that's um that's a very important policy to deal with um with regard to the superintendent but if you look at 2010 um and it's um in

137this index to handouts at page six um one of the things that it says is that um all directions for Action shall be given to the superintendent by the board acting in official meetings no member of the board May individually give orders or directives to the superintendent except AC as expressly authorized by the board so again that's the difference between a very a not very important not very important person and very important people um you only have authority as a group um if you look at policy 2220 official School of spokespersons your board policy says the official spokespersons for the district are the chairperson and anyone he designates and the superintendent and their authorized designes and anyone who speaks as an official uh in their official capacity as spokesperson for the board speaks from the

138standpoint of the best interest of the district not expressing their own personal feelings delegation of board authority can be done by the chairperson or by the superintendent to their designes uh standards for behavior for board members there used to be a statute 115 c39 that was repealed back in 2007 that actually would that had a process for removing school board members who misbehaved that was only used three times in the whole time it was over on the books I did two of those cases they weren't very much fun um but it um that statute was repealed because it it probably violated due process Provisions um and so it hasn't been replaced by any particular statute but we do have a policy 2116 dealing with removal from office and it basically recites to the new statute

139that was uh the school board members were added to 14- 230 that's up on there uh up on this slide and that's a criminal statute any statute that begins with chapter 14 is a criminal statute and it it's it's entitled willful failure of school board member to discharge the duties of their office so if a Schoolboard member willfully omits neglects or refuses to discharge any of the duties of their office then that can be a Class one misdemeanor it's a criminal offense and if the finding is that uh it was uh not only willful but corrupt um discharge from office then the judge hearing the case can remove the school board member from office so that um is a statute that has not yet been used since it was revised several years ago to add

140school board members there's also an old common law Doctrine called a motion that's one word a m o t IO n and that deals that deres back from the common law of England and there have been a couple of uh members of boards of County Commissioners who have been removed from office under a motion for a motion um a a procedure for a motion uh that deals with a school board member uh not complying with their duties excuse me not school not Schoolboard member County Commissioner not complying with their duties and that could be applied to a school board member as a practical matter there's very little opportunity to remove a school board member and the opportunities for uh dealing with non-compliant School Board member call for things like a censure or um uh they

141could be removed from uh uh positions of leadership or committees um or restricted from um uh retaining receiving board funds for uh things like going to conventions and that sort of thing um so let's talk about other standards of behavior for board members there's a statute that was added to that first one I mentioned to you that's got the 78 different subset sections um 115 c47 subsection 57 requires Boards of Education to adopt a code of ethics that complies with another statute 16883 and you've done that and it's board policy 2120 um the code of ethics for school board members if you haven't reviewed that lately you need to review that um so look at policy 2120 it's in your index to handouts um the code of ethics for school board members and uh another

142homework assignment you have is to study that uh for for future reference and I'm going to refer to a couple of provisions of that as we go along there's a statute 115 C50 that requires that board members get training so when you go to the school boards Association Convention for example or this session today for example you get credit for the training that you're getting today so board members are required to get 12 clock hours of training every two years and you're also required every time you're elected or reelected or if you were appointed um as soon as you're appointed um you have to get at least two hours of Ethics training um and that can be included in the 12 hours of clock 12 o'clock hours of training but you're required to get those

143two hours of Ethics training upon your election or appointment and then again upon the reelection so every four years you would have to get that training for in ethics and the board clerk in your case under the under your board policy it's the superintendent has to maintain a record of that training for um the board hours and the ethics training has to be done within 12 months of your election even so it starts when you're elected and that election is certified even though that's before you're actually sworn in okay anybody have any questions on the training requirements all right um moving right along let's go on to um conflict of interest um there's a term that's used in the conf conflict of interest statutes and in your board policies it's called pecuniary interest and basically

144what that means is you're getting money um or you're getting something of value um in exchange for something else so um you're you are you are not allowed to have a pecuniary interest in any public contracts and again you'll see a statute that begins with 14 so this is a criminal law it's 14234 um that prohibits public officers or employees from benefiting from public contracts so again this is a Class one misdemeanor for violating the statute and the statute prohibits board members from getting a direct benefit from any contract with the school system and a direct benefit includes getting income or property from a contract or if your spouse has more than a 10% ownership interest um if they're getting any benefit from that um you uh if you have an interest in a company

145um that is trying to do business with the school system you need to excuse yourself from any consideration dealing with that at all that matter at all that doesn't mean you just recuse yourself if it comes up for a vote okay it means that if there's been any discussion about this at all in a committee or any discussion at the board level or any discussion about putting out an RFP for the contract uh or anything whatsoever dealing with it make sure that you stay uninvolved and make sure that you declare what your interest is publicly you have to publicly announce what your interest is um and why you are excusing yourself from any consideration in the contract if you have any question about it if in doubt ask okay ask before the fact not after

146the fact because after the fact means you may have already committed a violation all right and we have a board policy 2121 that spells out in much more detail uh the board member conflict of interest so uh if you have any question that's the place to go uh another one that deals with uh the standards of behavior for board members is again a different statute it's not in chapter 115 C and it's not in the criminal statutes um even though the violation of this would be a misdemeanor would be a criminal law so this is General statute 133-35 gifts and favors being regulated the basic rule is it's illegal for you to get a gift from any current recent or prospective contractor with the board um and there are certain exceptions for getting um if

147you go to a a convention for example and an Architects group is sponsoring a meal the the luncheon for the entire convention that's an exception um if it's U the architect group offering to take you out to dinner that's not an exception okay um same thing with the Schoolboard attorney um so um that would be uh that would be a violation uh there are also certain exceptions for um uh uh Souvenirs of nominal value uh so if somebody's handing out um u a uh spongy Apple um saying support public education that would be okay for you to get um a little trinket or something like that um family members and nepotism we have board policy 7100 if you're looking for a policy dealing with nepotism um that's where it is it's 7100 which deals with

148Recruitment and selection of personnel and um what that what that provision stands for is if you're getting ready to hire or promote or um deal with a Personnel report that has a family member on it you should say to the board members my family members on this Personnel list and I can't vote on it um and you also can't be in within the school system family members can't be in direct supervisory relationships of each other uh the family members go down to in-laws and um uh grandparents uh children uh uh step step relationships and so on um so you should be you should Rec recuse yourself from voting and we have a board policy 2342 voting methods um and so if you have a conflict of interest or an inability to remain impartial if you're

149in a board hearing for example and you've already made up your mind you should say I need to be recused from voting in this matter um because I have a conflict or because um there might be concerns about my impartiality uh in this due process hearing if you're in a hearing for example um so you should State the reasons for recusal prior to um uh taking any action or deliberating on uh any matter where you've got a conflict and U then you would be removed from voting um confidentiality I ter I plugged in the term confidential into your um board policies and they got 37 hits so that'll tell you it's in a lot of our board policies on requirements dealing with confidentiality the main ones are listed up here um board policy 2125 7

1507350 confidential information um which is in the index to handouts that you have and also in your code of ethics for board members um subsection B5 subsection B contains the commitment of board members and it says that board members will have make a commitment to respect the confidentiality of information that's privileged under applicable law and refrain from unauthorized disclosure of confidential Andor privileged information that is discussed in closed session so closed session is like going to Vegas okay if it happens in closed session it stays in closed session all right anything that comes up in closed session is confidential by law it stays in closed session um so for student information you may recall the motion that we have when we go into Clos session cites um some of these statutes so we go into

151Clos session if we go into close session to discuss confident information that's confidential under law the motion to go into Clos session has to stay what law makes it confidential and for um student information General statute 115c 402 is the statute that deals with confidentiality of student information student records and we have board policy 4700 that deals with student records and it's a really long policy it's attached in your index to handouts and it tells you all the different things that are included in student records and student information that are kept confidential we also have federal law us code 1232g is furpa the family educational rights and Privacy Act and furpa is a really long detailed um statute but the regulations under furpa are much longer and more detailed than the statute is and so

152it goes on and on and on about what is considered confidential student information the bottom line for any of you board members is if it's any information about a student keep it confidential all right that's as simple as I can put it Personnel files we also um go into Clos session to discuss confidential Personnel information and Personnel information is kept confidential under General statute 115c 319 so there are three statutes primarily that deal with Personnel files there are some others that that are scattered throughout the general statutes as well but the the main statutes dealing with Personnel files are 15c 319 320 and 321 and 319 the first one of those says that any information about an applicant an employee or a former employee so anybody who ever tried to get employed here was employed

153is employed here or was employed here that information and in the statute says wherever located and in whatever form so if it's in a personnel file or if it's on somebody's desk or if it's in the glove compartment of the principal's car um or it's in a waste basket or it's in a computer file someplace okay wherever located or in whatever form it's exempt from the public records law and is considered confidential the next statute 115c 320 says however notwithstanding that first statute some information is public and that's basically name rank serial number type stuff it's directory type information how much a person is making where they're employed um and that sort of thing um and their current employment status but not the reasons for their current employment status so if they're suspended without pay

154for example um because um of a they're being sanctioned or if they're um uh suspended with pay because they're they're being investigated they the fact that they are suspended with pay and the date they were suspended with pay is public the reason they were suspended with pay is not all right and then 115 c321 the third of those statutes says who has access to a the confidential personnel file and that statute allows for board members to have access to the contents of a personnel file individual board members um as well as the person themsel about about uh who who file we're talking about their representative um the board attorney would have access to it anybody with a court order subpoena um and so on um there are some uh Provisions in that statute that um

155uh make it a Class one misdemeanor to violate the confidentiality of the information that's contained in a personnel file um if you copy it or reveal it um there are criminal sanctions for um uh for doing so um uh when we go into closed session that we have a statute a policy rather 2321 um there's our board policy for going into closed session attorney client communication is also privileged um so anytime we go in and I give you legal advice uh inclosed session or I talk about a pending matter inclosed session that's confidential um mean you shouldn't be revealing any of that um one thing I want to call your attention to is there's the North Carolina court of appeals case involving the Burke County Board of Education from November of 2018 um and I

156want to tell you about that case for just a minute what happened in that Ma in that case was um a couple of people came up to well one person came up to speak in public comment and started talking about uh some matters that the board considered to be um sensitive and confidential and so the board chair said we'd like you to put that in writing to us instead of telling us about it you know put it in writing you can give it to us confidentially and so that person and another person then submitted um sealed envelopes to the school board and marked them confidential and the information that was contained in that uh confidential communication dealt with um allegations of an affair between the superintendent and a School Board employee and so one of

157the school board members then felt well the superintendent is entitled to this information U because it's a complaint about the superintendent in his performance of his duties and shared that information and the school board attorney shared that information not me with the uh with the superintendent who then shared that information with the school employee um with whom he was alleged to be having an affair well the um uh superintendent's contract was bought out the school employee um then resigned and then she turned around and sued the two individuals who had submitted these um allegations for interference with contract the two individuals who had submitted these materials said look we were assured that if we submitted this it would be kept confidential and it wasn't and so they sued the school board and the school board

158tried to get the action dismissed um it was not dismissed and the jury found in favor of each of the two plaintiffs who were suing the school board to the tune of $250,000 each plus plus plus uh costs so um and that was upheld on appeal by the North Carolina court of appeals so there can be some serious consequences for promising confidentiality where you can't really guarantee it all right some other standards of behavior for school board members that I want to call your attention to 2120 policy 21-22 deals with the role of board members in handling complaints and um I want I've got a couple of excerpts from this that are in here that I want to refer you to it says individual board members will refrain that's mandatory will refrain from taking actions

159on complaints other than referring to the appropriate School administrator or to the superintendent and when appropriate advised of complaint procedures available board members may also refer the complaintant to the board attorney in accordance with policy 2 610 which says that you should first go through the chairman um to determine whether they refer to the board attorney individual board members will refrain from taking individual action with regard to complaints other than referring them to the proper administrative employee so um board members can put the board in a very difficult situation if you try to help um and and board members so you often don't think about this and this is also I want to warn the new board members the newer board members um this is something that uh new board members sometimes fall into the

160Trap of you've been elected to the board you want to help people and people come to you thinking that you can help them and so lots of times new board members say well I'm I'm a board member now I can go help so you take it upon yourself to go check things out well don't do that you refer it to the superintendent or to the proper administrator involved rather than take any individual action um uh also want to call your attention back to the code of ethics and two other commitments that are in the code of ethics at section B12 and B15 and it says that board members commit to refrain from investigating or attempting to resolve complaints received personally but instead direct the complaintant to follow the board's complaint or grievance process to resolve

161concerns so we've got processes in place administratively and through board policy we've got several different types of grievance procedures we've got bullying and harassment complaints we've got grievance procedures dealing with violations of state or federal law we've got just a general complaint procedure if it's not covered under any other specific policy we've got Title Nine complaint procedures dealing with sex discrimination or sexual harassment um so we got a bajillion types of complaint procedures refer any person who's got a complaint to the appropriate complaint procedure or the appropriate administrator and then section B15 in the code of ethics says that a board member shall take no private action that will compromise the board or administrators so I'm dealing with the case right now with another school system where a board member went out to the school

162after hearing complaints about a school one of the administrators at the school went out to the school and started meeting individually with with individual teachers all right and principal was ultimately removed and is now suing that board member as an individual okay so that's a public case I'm not I'm not telling you anything that's confidential um board policy 1742 um also deals with is a general policy called responding to complaints so if we don't if it doesn't fall within any of our griev many any of our many grievance policies that we have for different types of complaints we've got a catchall policy called responding to complaints that's any kind of complaint okay okay if um uh Miss Patty um likes to use um paper clips and Dr Williamson says I hate paper clips um use

163binder clips and and miss Patty says I don't like binder clips because they bother my thumbs and I'm not going to use binder clips well she can make a complaint under that b policy about it I mean it's it covers anything you can possibly think of all right so um and then we've got the superintendent's contract and there's a provision in the superintendent's contract that I want to call your attention to it's under the superintendent's duties and it says the superintendent shall shall is mandatory okay it's not might or may it's shall superintendent shall anytime I any I always tell people anytime you're reading the statute if you see the word shall shout it out it'll help you understand the statute better it's mandatory the superintendent shall have charge of the administration of the schools

164under the direction of the board he shall direct and assign teachers and other employees in the schools under his supervision shall organize reorganize and arrange the administrative and super supervisory staff shall select all Personnel subject to the approval of the board and we're going to talk about that a little bit more in a minute all right um the board individually and collectively so individual board members and you as a body okay um individually and collectively shall promptly refer all criticisms complaints and suggestions called to its attention to the superintendent for study and recommendation and shall refrain from Individual interference with the administration of school policies except through board action so again that's telling you as an individual don't do anything except through board action okay um in addition to referring uh criticisms and complaints to

165the superintendent board members or to refer persons having complaints or criticism to the teacher principal or administrative staff member Who's involved um so excessive involvement by board members in complaints could implicate due process procedures that might arise later on if we're dealing with um action that Personnel action that's taken against somebody and it gets appealed to the board you might have to excuse yourself from being involved in that same thing with the student matter that might get appealed to the board so please don't make it necessary for the board or the board attorney to intervene and anything like that bottom line is stay in your lane as a board member um and remember your role um only only occurs on the board um for individual board members again board is a corporate body and the

166members of the board have authority only when acting um as a board uh legally in session uh and uh uh board policy 2122 deals with board members role in handling complaints we already talked about that um for school visits I want to talk you about school visits for a second this is not expressly in your board policies some boards have a policy excuse me that says this but you don't have this in your board policy but board members are encouraged to visit schools to find out what's going on in the schools uh and to inform yourself and get a better understanding of things but when you do that before you don't just show up at the school and say hi I'm a board member here would you have somebody Park my coach um in the

167back um don't show up at the at the school without advanced notice um call the superintendent let let him that you're going to the school um call the principal let the principal know that you're going to be there or ask the superintendent better better yet ask the superintendent to call the principal and let them know that you're going to be there um and um you know in matters that are related to your own children um you are a parent and you have all the rights of a parent um to go into that school just as any other parent does but you have no more rights than any other parent does to go into that school and again you check in at the school um and you check in at the office just as any other

168parent does and you um deal with this just as any other parent would um you have no responsibility or um uh authority to give directives to school staff and that's in board policy 2010 it's explicitly spelled out in board and superintendent relations um for information requests um if you want to ask for any information about a school or a policy or what's going on make that information request to the superintendent all right and that's um not you don't go to the school and ask the principal to write you up something explaining something um you you don't have any authority to give directions to the superintendent uh to to the principal you also don't have any authority to give directions to the superintendent as an individual the board gives directions to the superintendent not board members

169so if you have a request you can make that request known to the superintendent but you can't give any directives to the superintendent again don't make it necessary for the board or the board attorney to intervene um certain rules of conduct let's talk about the uh Personnel matters Administration um in Personnel matters General statute 115 c47 that one that we looked at in the beginning with the 78 subsection subsection 18 says that you can make rules dealing with the conduct of employees and the kinds of reports they shall make um you select the superintendent and that is the only person you select as an employee of the school system on your own it's in general statute 115 c271 um the uh again we look we looked at the policy dealing with board and superintendent relations

170um and 7420 is the job description of the superintendent it lists all the responsibilities of the superintendent and it's in your index to materials I'm not going to review that right now but for hiring Personnel other than hiring the superintendent which you as a board do on your own every other employee in the school system is is governed by these statutes that are up on the board right now um so um for all of those statutes it says that the board comma upon recommendation of the superintendent shall hire these people for assistant associate superintendents principls and supervisors um uh and teachers and all other school Personnel but it always says upon the recommendation of the superintendent so unless and until the superintendent makes a recommendation the board can't hire anybody you can't say I re

171I make a motion that we hire somebody to be um Joe blo to be the principal of Red Springs High School somebody makes a second Allin favor I you don't have authority to do that without the recommendation of the superintendent okay um so keep that in mind that there is a um uh uh a uh check and balance on that um you don't have to approve the superintendent's recommendation but you have to at least consider the superintendent's recommendation um and then you can vote it up or down um but uh then when it comes time to make another consideration for that person if you voted them there you got to wait for the next recommendation from the superintendent um I once sat through a board meeting where the superintendent recommended 15 different people for a

172middle school principal ship um and the board voted the 15 of them down four to three because the board had their own candidate in mind and the superintendent wanted to make the point that he thought there were 15 other better qualified people than the one that the board wanted um and so um after 15 of those the superintendent finally came up with the right name and that name was approved four to three and I met with the superintendent afterwards and I said what were you doing out there and he said you'll see and two weeks later he was announced as the superintendent in a much bigger school system in a different state for about twice the salary he was making um so um he he had a pretty good idea what he was doing um

173uh assignments and transfers are the prerogative of the superintendent under your board policy and under his contract um he has the authority to direct and assign and transfer uh all School Employees um let's talk about individual liability for board members um there's something called qualified immunity um for public officers and you are all public officers all right for state for state law torts um a tort is basically a personal injury if somebody gets injured um in the school system you've got qualified immunity and in North Carolina we don't wave that immunity unless we purchase insurance and if the school system chooses to purchase insurance then we have waved immunity up to the limits of coverage of our insurance all right I'm going to talk about that in just a second um there's also qualified immunity

174for constitutional violations and people can sue for um violations of rights that are guaranteed under laws under this federal law 42 us code section 1983 um if it's a violation of uh if you if you are a person and a a board of education is considered a person for this statute you're a public corporation um if you're a person or if you're who acts with the authority of the state or appears to act with the authority of the state so if you're an individual board member and you try to take some action that you're not authorized to take even though you you weren't authorized to take it if somebody reacts or responds to you or thinks you have authority because you're a school board member then it could be that you appear to have the

175authority of the state so you'd be potentially liable under this law which says every person who acting under color of law that is with the actual Authority or appearing to have the authority acts in a way that violates somebody else's rights or privileges or immunities guaranteed by the Constitution or laws then you're liable all right now you have certain immunity if the actions taken by the board if it's not clear that that was a violation okay so if there's an untested area of the law for example um and the courts haven't ruled definitively on it and you guessed wrong as a board um then you wouldn't be held liable you'd have qualified immunity for that um there's a statute General statute 115 c43 that deals with the defense of members and employees and it provides

176that if an employee is or a current or former employee or a current or former board member is sued um for something that you did while you were um on the board excuse me then there's a procedure to go through to determine whether or not the board will provide a defense for you or pay for your attorney fears or even pay a judgment against you um either before during or after after um the uh the trial takes place um you have a board policy 7610 that deals with defense of board employees but it doesn't apply to board members and you don't have a policy that would apply this to board members the statute would still be out there but some school systems have um include board members in this policy you you don't um so

177you might want to um decide whether or not you want the policy committee to consider that um you don't have insurance um as a school board for uh uh for uh constitutional violations you don't have insurance for um tort violations personal injuries and such um but we are members of the north Conor school board's trust the school board's trust is a risk sharing organization but it's not insurance it's regulated by the north Carina department of insurance so the board hasn't waved its immunity except to the extent that the school board's trust has purchased insurance and so that's a kind of a funy um uh analysis but um the scoreboards trust uh uh has insurance for matters that are above 150,000 and up to a million dollars of liability so if a claim is less than

178$150,000 then we haven't waved our immunity by being members of the school board's trust um if you ever have any questions about any of this seek the advice of your board attorney all right seek the advice of legal counsel on this by going through the the chair um public records law North Carolina has an extremely broad public records law and the definition of a public record is extremely Broad and as office holders um here in North Carolina anything that you say or do or get any record that you get um in uh connection with your activities as a school board members is considered a public record and it doesn't matter how you get it okay if you get it in anything that can be maintained as a record um then it'll be covered so that

179includes email and it doesn't have to be on your board member email account it can be on your private email it doesn't have to go through the school system server okay so if it's on your Gmail account and it deals with the board's business or the Public's business it's a public record all right if it's on your um chat and some of you are on your phones right now okay um if you're on if you got a chat um or text message um it's a public record so it doesn't matter whether it's a personal or a private account it doesn't matter whether it's a personal or a school system device it doesn't matter whether it goes through the school system server or um something that Elan musk owns um it is a public record all

180right um so uh keep all of that in mind uh in the open meetings law is also very Broad in North Carolina we've got a board policy 2341 dealing with quorums um and if you've got a quorum of the board present any place don't discuss board business okay you can all get together for a Christmas party you can get together at a football game you can get together on any other occasion but if you got a quorum with the board president at the same time in the same place don't dis and don't discuss the board's business when you have a quum with a board president um committees are public bodies so any committee appointed by the board is a separate public body in and of itself and it's required to comply with the open meetings

181law in terms of giving notices and in terms of keeping minutes um and we've got a board policy 2300 that deals with all of this for board meeting agendas the ultimate goal is to have effective and efficient board meetings and the agenda is prepared by the superintendent and the chairperson according to your board policy 2330 which is included in your materials um if a board member wants to make a request for something be on the agenda it needs to be received six business days in advance and the same thing by individuals or groups from the public um if they want something to be considered um they need to make a request at least six days in advance um and that's in board policy 2310 public participation to board meetings the agendas are supposed to be

182distributed at least four business days in advance of the meeting um and um that's in the board policy that's the last one on this slide um all right so adding to the agenda at the board meeting um it you want you want to leave some flexibility for the board to act on new matters especially if something comes up and there's no need to delay or there's something that was unexpected that comes up and there's a need for the board to act promptly or it's a non-controversial item or an informational item um you can add that to the agenda uh by majority vote or without objection the chair can add it um to the agenda and say for example um absent objection will'll add this to the agenda as item um you know 3C or whatever

183it may be um as a courtesy to fellow board members the staff and the public um try to avoid um adding things at the last minute and minimize surprises once the agenda has been adopted you have a motion to adopt the agenda um once the agenda has been adopted at a board meeting it takes a two-thirds majority vote of the board to add anything after that okay um consent agendas you don't operate with a consent agenda but that's a something you might want to consider um for con non-controversial items um or items that have been thoroughly vetted by committees um or if you have a work session if if for example in this board retreat we had considered something um and you consider this a work session basically you could add that to the consent

184agenda and then anything that's on a consent agenda any individual board member can say I'd like that removed from the consent agenda um and considered separately um as a separate item um work sessions business meetings you generally don't operate with work sessions you mostly have business meetings but you could add work session if you wanted to um parliamentary procedures um you you follow your Rules of Order that are laid out in policy 2340 and for anything that's not followed there you go to Robert's Rules of orders the chairperson entertains en rules on matters um uh a parliamentary procedure with the advice of the board attorney um and those are designed to all of this is designed to enhance professionalism in the Corum that your board me um and then you also allow public comments at

185your board meetings you're required to have those at your at at least one regular board meeting if you have one regular board meeting per month in a month yes got a question how many boards have you worked for that have used like electronic agendas in how many they have used what like electronic like electronic agendas instead of us getting this the pack instead of getting the packet um a lot like see like like use assembly yes yeah I'm not a big fan of assembly um um but a lot of boards do use it quite a few okay um all right let's talk about abstaining from voting um your vote your policy on voting methods allows for abstention without a vote um and uh a lot of boards don't a lot of boards have a policy

186that says if you fail to vote your vote is counted in in the majority but you allow for extensions in your board policy and that's fine and well and good um and consistent with Robert's rules um you have policy 2302 dealing with remote participation in board meetings and um there was a recent court of appeals decision um from a couple of months ago um that said that if you have a quorum of the board you can't establish a quorum of the board if um you don't have a quorum live and in person um so you can't have remote meetings except if there's a declared state of emergency um you allow for remote participation by individual board members for these reasons if a board member is prevented from physically attending due to illness or travel or

187unexpected lack of child care or if a family member is ill or has a family emergency um weather conditions military service employment obligations scheduling conflict or a declared state of emergency but not for the board member's own convenience or to avoid attending a particular meeting in person it's because you don't want to be here all right so if you've got any of those reasons you're allowed to participate remotely um your policy says no more than three times per calendar year with some exceptions built into the policy um it's not allowed for a board hearing you can't participate remotely in a board hearing if you're conducting um a student discipline hearing or a teacher dismissal hearing for example um you couldn't do that um and you have to notify the board chair and the superintendent at

188least four hours in advance of the meeting um you have in within that policy there is a provision dealing with electronic messaging and it says that the chair shall remind all members that all chats instant messages text or other written Communications between members of the board regarding the transaction of board b b business during the meeting including those kinds of communications between or among members who are participating remotely are public record okay so if you're picking up your phone and you're communicating across the table with another board member or you're communicating with the board member who's participating remotely keep in mind anything you're saying in that text message or chat or whatever is public record all right yes2 also members will participating remotely of course does not count to the form but also count cannot

189vote an AC right um and and that is um that's in that court of appeals case that's the Anon County case and that's being appealed that's on appeal to the Supreme Court um the court of appeals said that um but they didn't sight any Authority for that um so that's kind of controversial uh so we'll see what happens with that once um Supreme Court gets done with it should we approve for now um You may have to go go back and change it yeah um okay so close session yes EXC excuse me um Chris got a question Chris fields on uh 21 on your slide 21 you said four business days can you tell us can you define business days yeah business day is is a for school for a school calendar it's a it's

190a day it could be a teacher work day it's not a student day it's a day that on your school calendar you're included as uh um as people are coming to work so on our school calendar satday and Sunday's not inclusive correct which means we should be getting our board packet on Wednesday technically business days yeah yep thank you sorry Patty all right um board meeting protocols one more question one more question excuse Mr Henry I'm sorry in relation to what Mr Bobby said uh that was a recommendation from DPI so we should follow their Direction at this time it was a recomend ation from the school boards Association not a required one it's not a required implementation um you can follow you can follow that you don't have to follow that but that's the

191current state of the law it is on appeal okay all Mr John boy pack I know before the new members came on when I was chairman where I did it uh the agenda that's what we sent out in the place of that can it be that or does it have to be the package itself y um it's it's I believe the policy says meeting materials um let me take a look agenda 2335 yeah it's it's uh on page 29 it's the proposed agenda the minutes of previous meetings and any supporting information or materials that resist the board members um so it's the board packet basically um now if this is if if you're you know if the way you've been doing it is working for you you could always change the policy too um if

192if if that if that works um whichever you want to do um okay so where were we M Chris you have another question before we move on but right now into the policy change it's for business days which means Wednesday yep yes correct okay um closed sessions um we go into Clos session under under the open meetings law and it's permitted for certain topics only uh the motion has to specify the reason why we're going into closed session um anything that's discussed in closed session stays in closed session remember it's confidential um and then we maintain closed session minutes that are supposed to provide a general account which is less specific than your Open Session minutes of what went on in closed session board meeting protocols um we've got board policies um uh dealing with

193the adoption of board policies so um they're inol board policy 2400 and uh we provide for two different readings of boards uh proposed board policies or revisions at two separate meetings um before approval but that policy can be waved by majority vote by suspending um that the policy requiring two readings um if it's if it's a you know simple revision or if there's no need um to leave it open for consideration um and a lot of boards do that um rather routinely um another first function of the board is um you are a quasi judicial uh board uh so you have you primarily have a legislative function that is adopting policies and making sure that they're properly implemented by delegating that authority of the superintendent and holding him accountable for that um so that's your

194legislative function as a board but you also serve as a Judicial body sometimes that is you sit as the as the jury um essentially in a lot of different types of hearings so you could have student appeals um you could have grievance appeals um and you could have um teacher dismissal Appeals um there are a variety of different ways in which that happens and those are all covered under policy 2500 in general statute 115c 45C under 115c 45C there are four different types of um matters that can come up to the board where there's a right to a hearing before the board for if if it's an appeal from a final administrative decision so if it's gone up through the through the uh through the ranks there's been a final administrative decision then there are

195four different types of things that can be appealed to the board for um hearing with where there's a hearing as a matter of right and those are things like long-term suspensions or expulsions for a student or any claim of a violation of a right that's guaranteed by law or or state board policy or local board policy state or federal law or any decision affecting the employment rights um of an employee or any other matter for which there's a right of appeal but not a specific stat stat saying what um how that appeal right is carried out if it's anything else there's not a right of appeal to the board but people can petition the board and ask the board in your discretion are you willing to hear from me and then the board can either

196say yes or no or the board can say we'll consider whatever you have to say in writing but we're not going to Grant you a hearing it's completely up to the board um if it's not a matter of appeal is a matter of right um School reassignment requests can be appealed to the board um under the different board policies that are up there student and parent grievances can be appealed to the board and certain due process uh matters can be appealed to the board whether they're student um hearings or um employee hearings uh for employees you've got um uh different grievance procedures again the hearing can be mandatory or discretionary and um keep in mind whenever you are serving in your quasi judicial role you have to stay impartial you have to your your obligation

197in order to provide due process to somebody in a hearing is to act fairly and impartially and what that means is um you're supposed to consider the evidence that's been that is presented in the hearing and make your decision based on that evidence in a fair and impartial way it doesn't mean as a board member you have to be completely ignorant of the matter that's coming before the board okay as a board member you're going to get information about things and you're expected to be informed so merely because you've heard about this matter that's coming before the board whether suppose it's a teacher dismissal case okay or a student uh discipline appeal if you've heard something about it that doesn't mean that you are infected and you can't hear and decide the case in a

198fair imp partial manner but you should consider whether you have been so affected by what you've heard that you can't be fair and impartial and in that case you should recuse yourself and the case the the main case on that that I want to talk to you about is Eddie Ray Crump versus the Hickory City Board of Education it's a case from 1990 and in that particular case the attorneys in the teacher dismissal case um asked the board members at the beginning of the hearing before the evidence was presented they went around and and they were allowed to question the board members can you know Dr Emanuel can you hear this case and decided based on the evidence presented or have you heard too much and made up your mind so that you can't be

199fair to poor Ed Ray over here and Dr Emanuel says yes I can be fair and I'll make up my mind well in this particular case it wasn't Dr Emanuel in this particular case two of the board members said yes I you know I can hear the case and I haven't made up my mind but in the meantime they had told you know some people elsewhere out in public we're going to give Eddie Ray a fair hearing before we hang him um and um they you know basically said we're going to take care of old Eddie Ray when he comes before us and so while Eddie Ray's dismissal was upheld Eddie Ray the school the school board members and by the time the case was resolved um school board members were on the hook for

200six figures okay so um uh keep keep in mind you've got an obligation to tell the truth about any prior knowledge that you have and make decisions based solely upon the evidence that's um presented um so if anything's LEL to come up lots of times you might hear about something suppose a uh an employee has been suspended and there's an investigation going on if you hear about that or if it's told to you in a board meeting um inclosed session that we've got this matter going on this person's been suspended one of the things we'll tell you and you've heard this in close session is stay clear of this don't get involved if you hear anything about it or anybody wants to come talk to you about it just say I can't talk to you

201about that it may come before the school board okay I can't even listen to you about that I don't want to know anything you have I appreciate you coming to me but I can't hear anything you have to say all right and then also word to the wise if anybody comes to you and tries to talk to you about that assume you you know even if you know the person really well you trust the person you never know when you're being recorded all right um so stay clear of it um don't have any individual involvement that will compromise the board later on um all right so we're going to end with final tips on good boardsmy and being an effective board member effective leadership by the board inspires the staff to do their best dfun

202leadership can demoralize the staff and lead to a talent rain um Quality boards elicit community support and poor boards are not trusted or supported um trust is vital and it's the glue that keeps your board together um so try to avoid um uh hidden agendas we're going to talk about some rules to live by first respect the Public's trust respect Foster and promote good relationships with other board members and with the superintendent recognize the integ of your predecessors and your peers and the Merit of the work that was done by them know your subject matter and don't fake it if you don't know it learn about it and ask questions but ask questions at the appropriate time the appropriate time is usually in advance of a board meeting not to try to learn about stuff

203that you should have done your homework on at the board meeting so do your homework so that you can make informed decisions and don't make promises or commitments that you can't keep um remember lots of times people will come to you and they'll tell you their version of events their side of the story keep in mind there's almost always another side of the story all right so when they come to you and say here's what happened can you do anything about this and you hear and you say yes absolutely I'll take care of this all right well don't make that commitment all right wait until you find out the rest of the story and don't make that commitment anyway wait until you because remember what what Authority and power do you have as an individual

204ual board member absolutely none all right um do again uh don't make promises and commitments don't make commitments without full knowledge and respect the majority's rule um avoid unofficial meetings unofficial meetings are also a polite way of saying illegal meetings under the open meetings law okay um take take don't take any private action that will compromise the board or the administration respect confidentiality of information that's privileged avoid all conflicts of interest and avoid even the appearance of a conflict of interest all right um be open fair and honest and that means don't have a hidden agenda don't sneak up on board members at a board meeting with your own private agenda um and and then throw it out there and nobody's heard this before um don't ambush people look and act professional listen carefully and

205that's different than just sitting there and hearing okay listening carefully is active involvement and listening and engagement as opposed to I'm just hearing this in the background while I'm looking at my phone um and that goes back to looking act professional if you're on your phone during a board meetings or you're texting or you're looking down people will see that and it and it doesn't it doesn't work well for the board um respect other people's time um I've got I've got I've got one board where I the the board meetings go two hours extra every single night because one board member talks that long um thoughtfully consider the opinions and positions of others um a good school board member understands that the board sets the standards for the district through board policy and understands the

206difference between government governance which is the board's Providence and management which is the administration's responsibility um board members don't manage the district on a day-to-day basis and the board makes decisions as a team by majority vote again individual board members can't commit the board to any action and other board members have the right to their opinions and ideas that differ from your own no matter what you think of those ideas okay um decisions are made by majority vote and should be supported by all board members once the decisions decisions been made um decision should be made only after the facts have been presented and discussed there is a chain of command and problems arise um whenever the chain of command is not followed so problems or complaints should be referred to the proper administrative office

207and through the appropriate channels or the appropriate grievance process you have to comply with the open meetings law and you have authority to make decisions only at official board meetings um it's essential that all board and District business be ethical and honest and that you receive confidential you're going to receive confidential information that cannot be shared the superintendent is your advisor and he should be present at all meetings except when the board's considering superintendent's evaluation contract or salary the board's take action only after hearing the superintendent's recommendation the board member should not use your membership for personal or family gain or Prestige announce conflicts of interest before the board action is taken or before any consideration on a matter that's coming up before the board personal or family problems should not be brought into board

208consideration don't drag your kids into something um some board members attempted to say Well when my child did this and my child was evaluated and determined that my child had this you know was ADHD and on a 504 plan blah blah blah don't do that to your kids and don't do that to everybody else okay keep your family stuff out of it you can go you can use examples without saying it's my family member the staff deserves respect and consideration as skilled professional employees you all treat your staff with respect at board meetings um I I dealt with a board one time when um the board members used to have they set up on a on a a stage a constructed stage in the boardroom and they were nine feet above everybody else they had

209to climb up a ramp to get up to their seats and people would come sit in the well and they would look up at the board members like this and board members would talk down to the bo to the people that there in the administrators and berate them um and um a new superintendent came in and the first thing he did was cut that stage down six feet okay um it was not a pretty pretty board meeting um so anyway uh the staff deserves your respect and you generally treat them with respect personal criticism of District oper operation should be presented to the superintendent not to individual District staff um at a board meeting uh the public has the right to attend and observe board meetings of course and the right to be informed about

210District decisions and school Personnel decisions um review the board operation sections of your board policy manual that's the sections 1,000 and 2,000 know your board member code of conduct that's your code of ethics review pass board meeting minutes to become familiar with issues being discussed by the board that's a general advice I give to new board members um if you haven't been actively following the board meet with the superintendent to get a clear understanding of the district's budget um so if you if the budget is a bunch of confusing numbers to you and you need to understand it better then go into the superintendent and say I'd like a tutorial on the budget um and I'm sure he'll be happy to have Erica meet with you um and confuse your f no um and elucidate

211you I should say um uh on that U assume your position with an open mind abandon preconceived notions and hidden agendas including any opinions that you've had about um staff you're going to be making decisions that affect the children of your district and always keep their best interest in mind and recognize that you don't know everything and capitalize on every opportunity to learn um expect that you're going to be in the minority on some decisions um at some times and um um uh accept the majority decision graciously the time to voice your opinions about anything is before the vote is taken once the vote is taken it's the act of the board and deal with it graciously um some tips for new board members accept some board decisions to be unpopular remember you only have

212one vote and your issues or whatever your passions are you can only be successful if you can convince other board members to vote with you um don't surprise your superintendent or your Administration or your fellow board members at a public meeting with with unexpected um comments or requests be flexible be willing to compromise be a good listener um and um others can help you learn more about your job and what you have to do for your new board members um Your Role is to establish policy and set goals and it's up to the superintendent to manage the district and get it to where the board says it needs to go you set policy he implements it and takes you where you need to be and learn your District's chain of command and refer all complaints

213to the proper people so anybody have any questions I Mr ter thank you Mr Von thank you Mr Schwarz I just got a quick question if we receive information in our in our packets um maybe for example like a like a budget it's on paper like a what I'm sorry like a budget okay on paper and it's 60 pages and we're GNA be asked to vote on it um is there a problem or is is there any statute that says that that information can't be shared electronically beforehand no that can be shared electronically beforehand thank you yep appreciate it y um and you know if if you get that there's a good chance it's gone through the finance committee um and the finance committe if you're on finance committee that's fine and well and good

214if you're not on the finance committee you can attend their meetings right um and a lot of that you operate with a committee structure and if something comes out of committee under Robert rules it doesn't require a second because in order for it to come out of committee you already have two board members who have supported it all right so um if um one of the one of the reasons you operate by committee is you trust the committee to do the vetting in the detail work and um if you got any question you can still ask your question but um uh you know you you tend to to trust the work of your committees but the information that you shared about um uh about uh creating agendas for meetings is that information also translate to

215subcommittees uh no it um that's that's for your board meeting agendas only okay so is there is there a a process for for how um agendas are created for subcommittees no you don't have anything in your board policy for that thank you okay you could add it if you wanted to but that's up to you CH if I may please uh while while we can transfer files there's a risk factor tied to that in terms of hackers getting in um virus getting into our system um we need to make sure certainly we're not sending a SES spreadsheet that somebody can go in and change so we need to Define how we would do that and make sure there's a need but a lot of systems about themselves because they transferred files um get lock down

216out so we have to look at that uh Miss Christie Fields then we're going to have Dr M I'm sorry next I appreciate you being so thorough since I'm new to the board what I would like to know since I'm new to the board is what policies or procedures are in place to assist the board with oversight of leadership actions and addressing concerns about the potential abuse of power as it relates to the school leadership since we are a governing body a corporation where is that in this book well the board has authority over the management of the school over the governance of the school system if you have concerns about um those things um you know it'd be appropriate for the board to consider that consider that or address it directly with the superintendent

217and and are we able to address it with you provided I go through the chair if yes there's a that's in that's in the slides if you have uh concerns about complaints that need to be forwarded um about the administration then you can address that with the chair and and go to the board attorney if you need to so let's just assume that chairman leech doesn't like me but he does and he doesn't want me to send you a question then what do I as a board member what option do I have um uh at that point I would suggest that you request the chair to confer with me about that thank you and I'm sure he would D may I guess I want to goodbye to and this is not putting anybody on spot

218maybe Mr Terry what is the need for getting it digitally when you have it hard copi and I can understand uh the point about data being shared online and this and which you know numbers can be changed I'm just curious what is the need for getting it digitally I'm just that's just a curiosity question Mr T if we're if we're being asked to vote on something um that's 60 pages long something that's so extensive extensive as an annual budget um I'm not a budget expert I'm not a person that's has any formal training in finance but I know a lot about Excel and I know a lot about data and I know a lot about looking at trends for example we vote on the the the monthly budget every month we vote on it every

219month and if you have that information in an electronic format as a board we can look at Trends and we can look how how things are going over time whether or not you know any anything about budgets um that's not even an issue but if you have information that you can track over time you can start to look at Trends I do not feel comfortable voting on an annual budget when it's on paper in 2024 um for for a system such as this and I'm not saying or I'm not implying that I don't trust anyone here uh but I am um concerned that there's a u that there seems to be a lot of apprehension about access to information and when we come to board meetings and we're getting 100 150 pieces of paper we're

220voting on things um sometimes it's uh sometimes it can appear that we may not be fully informed about everything that we're voted on well can I do a followup follow tell tell me the difference in getting it by paper five days before the meeting and getting it electronically five days before made and what's the difference for me yeah for me the I don't I don't feel comfortable uh voting on something uh that I only received on paper that's very very extensive uh that when we had the opportunity uh to analyze it and be more informed by doing our own um and Mr Schwarz talked about doing homework that's part of my process in doing my homework homor and he he said he's Mr Schwarz has advised us to do our homework to go through our

221policies and and take all the extra steps that that we need to take and that's just part of my process so you see I guess I'm not clear you get the same information the same timeline by paper or digitally I guess I'm trying to understand Mr ter what's the difference help me understand that if I have it electronically I can sort it I can add it I can find averages I can look at codes I can make comparisons and if we have it over time you can track this information from month to month to month all right well um we're gonna have Miss Melissa then I'm G say one thing and then we're gonna we're gonna move on I'm finished oh I'm sorry that's okay I'm finished so I don't really have a preference paper

222digital my only issue with the paper is that I have stacks of these at home like lots and lots of it and my issue is at that point is confidentiality and US maintaining these records at home when when is it appropriate to disregard these records because there there may be things that you need to refer back to and in paper form I got to go back through God knows how many sheets of paper to find it where it's easier for me to find it digitally just go back to it and then I have a whole side of a room with these packets so when is it acceptable to throw this stuff away I I want to dispose of it I don't want to throw it away because it has people's personal information on it but

223I also don't want to have it in my house for every all right this Mr you you can you can take it to you can take it back to the superintendent and ask for the the board to dispose of it nothing wrong with doing that that's all right M Mr Mr Craig there there will always be a record of it here with the board's records Mr Curry thank you uh Miss oan answering yours I I keep stuff I'm just for me I keep it at the house for a certain length of time and if it's six months or whatever when maybe some of it a year and I'm where I can burn it that's the way I get rid of it I burn I don't have a shredder but I burn after a year I

224will burn anything I got so I'll just tell you that Mr Terry to to those of you I'm not computer literat I don't want to see this on spreadsheet Excel because I'm not one that can deal with it but now if it can be put out either way you know I don't have a problem with it but mine is give me the paper and where again I said I might keep it six months or a year when I go home with this board packet this is just the method for Craig I'll put on their December 20 24 me too I'll keep it for six months to a year and after that I'm gonna get rid of it like you said not carrying it to the dumpster I'm GNA burn it and uh as long if

225I need to refer back but now I will say this me personally I've found out after eight years every once in a while I have to go back I don't have to go back that much that's that's just me but again if if it's not a problem to do it both ways or if it is but now me I'm fine with getting a paper copy and if we need to look at policy I know it's had on there for Wednesdays for a while and we got the agenda at one time ahead of time and then we'd get to pack it on Friday now for me personally whichever way this board decides to go with it I'm fine but I'm fine with getting it on Friday if we need to adjust the policy if I get

226mine on Friday and I I got enough time between now and Tuesday to read it but uh again I will say this if it's in policy we need to do what's in the policy and just get that part cleaned up all right uh Mr Terry then we uh we're got to be over after this go ahead you know in education we talk about learning styles and learning preferences so um some some person uh some some people's learning styles or learning preferences may be on on paper but my learning style and my learning preferences um is electronic so when I can um have this information in electronic format I can create charts analyze Trends and look at these codes and look at these figures and I can come up with a a lot more meaningful information

227than I can uh by receiving it on paper uh just like you can by looking at it on paper my learning preference is to have it in a spreadsheet well you know we uh we appreciate all of this discussion and stuff about about the budget about Finance but I would encourage anybody you know Miss Erica just sit down Miss Erica just come have a meet with Miss Erica and sit down with her and I think it to take some of this it'll be a whole lot easier for all all of us just come down and sit down Miss Erica and have a conversation with her I think she'll be open to it thank you all right we got them Richard PR you only took you had 90 minutes you took 80 so proud of you

228start good job good job what we next on the my agenda I think you took M next we have Mr Jamal uh Jamal Campbell a teacher employment dy I took my stuff good afternoon there you go is it on good afternoon um board members chair Dr Williamson um so I what I have for you today is that tracking our teacher movement from August 20123 through July 2024 and you have that big spreadsheet um before you many times the board members you know you get your board pack you each month and it tracks resonations retirements things of that nature and so I decided to put it on a spreadsheet so you can see what occurred last year um last school year with the teacher movements the attached reporting document records teacher movement within the district from

229August 2023 until July 2024 the document examines the data for Teacher hiring resignations retirements in District work site changes or transfers for individual schools the document also states that the number of teachers that sended their resonations or retirements lastly the document details those that decline to accept teaching positions after they were board approved to start based on the psrc teacher data chart U that I provided to you several major Trends can be observed first for for hiring and turnover Trends we saw over 373 teachers were hired across the district indicating a strong recruitment effort 99 teachers transferred within the district suggesting opportunities for internal Mobility 182 teachers resigned which is comparable to districts within our region and they resigned for various reasons such as teaching another Lea or another state out career change family or

230health issues or unknown reasons 46 teachers retired um and those are individuals who achieved um retirement age we had a net gain of 135 teachers hired for the District also I want to highlight we often times talk about teachers who left but we actually had 39 teachers who came back to our District 39 teachers came back to the psrc we also saw some um Trends uh as right to some particular schools um wton High School had the highest number of new hires with 27 once again when you look at our hiring um practic some of those um positions were vacant for multiple years and so we saw a lot of hiring take place last year R Springs High School saw 13 resonations um but and but hired 20 new staff members in the process and

231then St Paul's high school had 13 resonations but 19 were higher once again when you SE trans like that that means there were positions that were vacant probably for a year or two and then those princes were able to hire retention efforts nine teachers resented their resonations which could be seen as a positive sign of retention efforts and positive relationships with administrators and staff only one teacher resented their retirement similar results are occurring in our region with other districts those who are reaching the age of retirement are choosing to do so and other observations very few teachers uh we had nine terminated one were n renewed indicating stability and employment for most 23 teachers declined positions which suggest um compet competition from other districts or career options and once again we only had one teacher

232had licensure issues showing strong credentialing among the staff EXC excuse me Mr Jamal I don't mean to cut you off but um looking at the DAT looking at all this data and information that Jamal has put together do anybody have any any questions any any questions for Jamal yes all right um put your M hit your button hit your button Dr men you haven't he it yet I don't it's not it's not coming up on my end I scroll up oh here go now I got you now it just it down yeah I got you brother Mr Jamal yes you haven't looked at it like this but is there a correlation between test data and turnover or anything that you've been able to ascertain or not being able to fill positions with this information thank

233you for that wonderful question Dr Emanuel answer my darling I will so we we have seen um your younger beginning teachers who have typically not the best test scores typically are the ones who are resigning um those teachers who are five years or more who are more stronger and their testing areas are state so yes you you do see a correlation between those teachers who have usually one to three years if they're in a tested subject area typically um are not staying with within teaching they're typically um doing career changes all right U Tre we got Mr are you finished I'm sorry yes sir I'm Mr Trey I'm just sorry I didn't mean to catch you off Mr M I've already told you because we've had this for a little bit this is pretty good

234information did a good job with it um I got two things one I'd like to get this annually make this annual thing you know what I'm saying and then number two can you do the same thing for bus garage maintenance and that sort of thing and get it to us I will work with that thank you sir so but but to your first question yes sir um I've already discuss with Dr Williamson we will make sure we have this angle for you guys to track those Trends uh Miss uh Christy Fields so your your young teachers you said that typically five years or less they're in a testing area or leaving is there something we can do to retain them is there additional support can we can we give them a mentor in the class

235to help them job shadow to make sure that we've done everything possible to help them to succeed not point out what they're not doing that's right and I'm not saying that you're doing that I'm just saying I can understand how that would be a lot for someone new entering into a classroom with the weight of a testing or eemg which the district has nothing to do with that is just required so what can be done to help retain them since we don't have a flood of people trying to come into the teaching profession thank for that question as well so we as ear I highlighted our academic coaches which we praised when we had our beginning teacher uh um site visit last year our district was praised because of that that we actually have coaches

236in each building to assist and support those teachers um your instructional leadership team which consists of your principal assistant principal academic coaching also provide that support we have our curriculum um inst instruction supervisors also in those buildings provide that additional support um our principles Miss Fields do do allow our teachers to um visit other teachers with whether whether it be in their schools and some have actually allowed them to go to other schools to observe as well so we do all those components to try to make sure we're supporting our teachers the best so we can to keep them um but we are seeing so that's that particular um St that I I answer when I answer for Dr Emanuel that's not something we just saw for psrc but that is a trend we're seeing

237um Statewide but um we are doing our very best um as much as we can to support our beginning teachers to make sure we can grow and development that's that's the word we want to make sure to grow and develop our teachers all right is uh Mr Curry you got um you got something all right I'm sorry there you go U Mr M do we have in place written we used to have mentors that went around do we have anything written or Unwritten in place at Red Springs middle that a first second or third year teacher has a mentor on that campus they Mentor is academic coach well forget that academic coach I'm saying that we got a teacher that's on that campus that's a veteran teacher is helping this first so also have teacher

238buddies that we call them so U each princi as as they're tearing their teachers of support um far as those beginning teachers that also pair them up with veteran teachers whether it be in that same subject area or grade level or sometimes because some schools are small they don't have a teacher in that same grade level or subject area but at least a veteran teacher was on that staff so yes so you have the academic coach um that's their direct Mentor then you have teacher buddies that are assigned by that principal to those beginning teachers and that's countywide we got that everywhere I will check to okay thank you all right Mr Trey Brit Mr Craig kind of asked the same question I was going to ask but in the way to it um is

239that principle or are we able to give I hate to use the word but I know we're in the type budget but stifen per se if that teacher were to take somebody on is that still available was that ever a thing or am I just imagining that or it was like $100 or something it was like $100 or something am I right we do like that uh Mr Mr Terry got one then you can respond next so we do in our title two budget have a $100 a month stien for our buddy teachers and that is an effect right that is an effect yes correct Mr Terry Dr B you go you can go ahead while we're on this same conversation because I will switch gears okay yeah yep was ter yes say something was

240brought up a few minutes ago about security of uh security and and handling documents I just want my colleagues around the table to to to note that in in some cases um with this with this packet uh on paper there's there's Personnel information in there and sometimes it's left on a porch so I just want you to to think about that and and and in relation to the information that I was asking for which is public so um let's think about that over the weekend I know it's a Friday afternoon um anytime I ask for something and and and somebody's real apprehensive about giving it that that really causes me especially when it's public information it should cause everyone caution and say and be asking the question why not all right thank you Mr Terry

241anybody got any more questions from Mr Jamal um thank you Mr Jamal um next we going to go thank you you for so I will go straight to the staff no no no no not yet okay um we got to got to switch up U Miss Erica got to go um she we're going to let her talk we got to switch up I got got to switch the RO I got you thank you chairman leech superintendent Dr Williamson I really appreciate you guys let me switch my um son is playing a game at Ashley high school tonight and I would really like to be able to attend so I really thank you for allowing me to move up a little bit um and I don't really have a lot to to provide tonight again I

242was hoping you guys would give me um like the questions is there something specific you want me to delve into on the budget I did put a couple sheets on at your desk because I noticed when I was running my uh formulas to to key this in once it's approved there's a part that's on the budget but it wasn't included in my formula so there's a $25,000 difference in local and I put those sheets to replace on your desk and I updated the operating budget um so it's pages three and four and 29 and 30 if you'll replace that in your budget and then I gave you a new operating summary to show that it was it's already printed there it just wasn't in my formula count and I caught that so I just wanted

243to update those documents and answer any questions anybody can anybody has we got um uh Trey Britt and um Dr man you next I got a I guess it's a question and there maybe something needs to be looked into okay I'm going hit you on page 20 okay um where it has vehicle repair parts okay my question is Lumberton high school has an issue with the white buses right now we got two that are down and obviously it's the biggest school in the county and we need them and the fund as far as fixing those buses I know is independent on that school to have the funds to fix and my question is with the vehicle repair parts of $700,000 there's no room whatsoever to no sir because that's PRC 056 which is transportation so

244you can only use that for yellow school buses yellow school bus yellow school buses they're very specific about that that was my question and you answer it thank You' yes sir thank you Dr Manel I know this is an impossible question but I must ask it uh as soon as you can is it possible to get us some kind of cost estimate with the CTE audit so we can request some other options to be considered about some things that we need done at schools absolutely yes ma'am that's our that's our priority that's our Focus we're going to start looking at that in the phases um ma what maintenance can do versus contracted that's got to be soon on our agenda like hitting it new year January is where we're gonna focus on that yes ma'am

245we appreciate that thank you and I just wanted to remind everybody the budget is a living document once the budget's approved I'll be coming back and bringing amendments we always get changes in funding or decisions can be made to make changes to this budget it is a live in breathing document so once it's it's approved it's not set in stone any changes can be made to it as long as we're in that fiscal year thank you so much all right um I think that's it anybody got any more questions from Miss Erica I thank you Miss Erica drive safe that thank you thank you all right now next we're going to have let's go back to the top i l yes now you my uh uh student employee and demographic by Mr Bobby and um

246and Jamal so um board members I wanted to present to you um the demographics of our district of all fulltime employees this is all fulltime employees I'm not going to go into detail uh with you but I giving you that breakdown um after this so for as it relates to Hispanic or Latino full-time staff that make up about 3% of our staff which is 90 me 90 individuals total and most are teachers or Tas within that area our nonh Hispanic or non Latino males comprised of 20% of our overall fulltime staff which represents 56 th employees next our nonh Hispanic or non Latino females which represents 77% of our overall fulltime employees which is 2,200 employees um which means that we have um 254 staff members fulltime staff members 47.8 of that are teachers and

247full-time staff includes principles assistant principls all teachers school counselors psychology Personnel media coordinators Consultants supervisors of instruction teacher assistants clerk secretaries service workers skilled workers Craftsman craft women laborers professional staff District staff which includes officials administrators and managers the public school cson County staff Democrats show a diverse workfor Workforce with some notable trends number one a high representation of American Indian staff 45.8% of the total staff which includes 38% females 7.8 males identify American Indian this significantly is higher than the national average and reflects the County's large Native American population which should be duly noted number two strong gender diversity 77% of our staff are female which is consistent with national Trends and education this High representation of women in education is common across the United States three racial diversity the staff includes significant proportions

248of white which make up 21% of our staff black 27% of our staff and an American Indian which makes up 45.8% of employees with small percentages of Hispanic which is 3% in Asian 2.5 this diversity is a positive trend compared to National Data as many school districts struggle with racial representation now an area that we can improve on um 3% of our staff is Hispanic or Latino as compared to our student population which is around 22% so this is the area of opportunity for improvement to uh for staff Recruitment and Retention number five uh balanced male representation across races among nonh Hispanic males there's relatively even distribution between whites blacks and American Indian staff members these demographics indicate the public school off and County have made strides in creating a diverse Workforce particularly representing the

249local American Indian population the high level of diversity among staff can provide students with a wide range of role model and perspectives which is a positive trend compared to many districts nationally and that is our fulltime staff demographics for the public schools of Robson County anybody got any oh sorry say anybody got any questions good evening again um wanted to share with you our demographic trends for students over the last three years did not put uh did not put this where we're currently at in this slide because all of these numbers here represent where we closed school at for the last three years so you can see that our largest number of students in our buildings of course are American Indians we have approximately uh we closed last school year with a Asian students our

250growing population in our district right now are definitely our Hispanic grouping you can see that trend line moving forward uh our black population is relative L remain the same over the last um three years our white population is declining we're also seeing an increase in two or more but just to give you a snapshot of currently where we're at at this particular moment um we have approximately 7,400 American Indian students in our district at the current moment our Hispanic population has bypassed our black population um we currently have a uh 40 approximately uh Hispanics with about 4650 um blacks our white population is about 1960 with our two or more representing about, 1500 again th that will change over the course of the school year so this is just raw numbers of the number of

251students that ended the building last that ended in the building last year again wanted to share the end of year numbers with you because as Miss Erica stated at our Finance uh meeting the other night that calculations for budgets are calculated on that final ADM so this is going to match numbers that we were funded on next slide Cole so just to give you a breakdown of the percentages so again this is just uh to give you another ideal or different representation of how the students or the percentage of demographics in our building so again you can see our American Indian students are our largest uh our Black and Hispanic population probably by the end of the year may flip back and forth some depending on enrollments and how we end the school year next

252code and just wanted to give you a fiveyear snapshot did not do a fiveyear on the uh as in terms of demo in terms of demographics but wanted to give you a five year in terms of total student enrollment you can see we closed 20 with over 21 ,000 students and again we know that's the end of where covid came in and everybody knows what happens when we decided when we decided to open school back up we lost a tremendous amount of students approximately 400 students that following year we lost an additional about additional four the next school year then we saw an increase um but last year we saw a slight decrease as well so this is just a representation of our student body again over the last three years in terms of E

253groups but this gives us an idea of where we're at uh gives us an idea of where we close and currently our enrollment as of today uh is down about 93 students with 20452 and these n that number does not include our preas students all right do do anybody got any questions from Mr jamala um Mr Bobby we got Dr man this this is I'm trying to put it together what Bobby said what Mr Bobby said what Mr Jamal said so is our are our demographics excuse me for our students and our employees and our leadership is it in sync with each other okay like you're saying I thought I heard you say Native Americans and Hispanics and the Caucasians and the whatever the other groups or our employees and our leadership teams being Central

254office be principles are we in sync with our demographics is what I'm you all gave a report but you it's disjointed because you said something Bobby said something but I can't tie it together because you said y'all were different you you put it differently how in sync are those numbers the only one that's out of sync are our Hispanic staff versus the student population everyone else is relatively in sync but like said we have 3% as much to um Hispanic staff members full-time staff members compared to like 22 23% you said staff members is that leadership like principls assistant principles uh central office staff administr all entire all fulltime staff members um druel is that what you're saiding with from your aspect too here students right yeah so our students as you can see here

255our Hispanic students are going to average about 23% of our current population so we do not currently have 23% of our staff represented in the um employment data so that difference of the 20% would filter in between Native American and the other racial groups so there is a disparity between staff members in that one particular group as far as uh as it compares to our student population thank you is that it okay one more Miss Christie so what is a are doing in particular to ensure since we do see a trend we see a shift in our student population and we don't have the adequate staff on hand who are bilingual and who can relate to our Hispanic population what are we doing to mitigate that g Gap and to close it and to make

256sure that our student population as well as our employment population compare or comparable yes so as as that that one particular area um it is an ongoing struggle I have to be honest M fields on that particular because once again we have to have a p a talent pool we can pull from and in our region we're seeing a similar Trend there there's not that many to pull from to balance out that Trend we're seeing far as staff um numbers and student numbers so there's a it's a it's an ongoing conversation within our region uh when I when I say our region the school districts within this area and with in the state far is trying to get more um our Hispanic population into those teaching positions um or even just staff positions overall let

257me ask you let me just throw this out there have has the district thought about sending teachers back to learn Spanish as a second second language to help in the classroom I'm just throwing that out there and so and all of those and I get what you're saying all of those also um we we've have we've had teachers who go back to be EC teachers as well so yes those are those all can be components that can be discussed as well I would also say that is one of the benefits of our Epi staff the multi language within our building that's just really had an impact so in almost every building we do have someone that can speak that native language and and to that point Dr Williamson um thankfully with with our Epi program

258over the past couple years we've saw increase of bringing more multilingual teachers in um I can get you the specific numbers um at the next board meeting but we saw increase in that uh Miss Phils um to help support that area any more questions thank you um Mr Barby and Mr Jamal you can to um Bo add to our board yeah um at this time um Mr I make a motion go ahead dram before you make the motion we still have Dr bullet and so we will move her to our board meeting tonight bring her up first to share the information so we add her to the agend good thank you sir make a motion that we adjourn hold up before um a motion a motion being made the Jour a second a motion being

259made by Mr Trey brck a second being made M Mista ocean now we got some comments by Mr Craig U I know the motion's been made and passed but I disagree with it because she sit here all afternoon I agree yeah yeah I do I do I do agree I do no it's she's going to be first she's going to be first and stuff in agenda we said she's going to be first in okay all right thank you m got one other thing uh Mr leech uh folks I observed this the other day and a lot of you might know it or you might not bus going down I95 Just for information our buses do not go down I 95 in Robinson County um and was Hampton was able to identify and also our buses

260do not go down 4 Lane 74 from my understanding so if you see that where 74 is 4 if you see it please call Dr Guzman and let him know yeah especially if you can get a bus number yes oh yeah a mo a motion is been made by U Mr Trey Brit The The J and second my ocean all in favor all oppose ah motion meet

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.