CorpusRecord 271140

Jeffco Public Schools BoE Live Stream 2/5/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Jeffco Public Schools Board of Education
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Jefferson County, CO
Material
Transcript
Extent
31,571 words · about 176 min
Collected
2026-10-22

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I would like to call this meeting of February 5th, 2025 to order. And I thank you to our live simultaneous Spanish interpreters for joining us today. We're also live streaming our meeting. Roll call. Please. Miss Zavala. Miss Applegate. Miss Kenworthy here. Miss Parker here. Miss Reed here. Doctor Varda. Please stand and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. And to the republic for which it stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Is there a motion to approve today's meeting agenda? I move to approve today's agenda as presented in board docs. Is there a second? I second. It has been moved and seconded to approve the agenda for today's meeting of February 5th, 2025. As presented. Roll call please,

002Miss Nevada. Miss Applegate. Miss Kenworthy. Yes. Miss Parker. Yes. Miss Reed. Yes. Doctor. Vada. Yes. The agenda is approved at our January 16th and 17th meetings. We studied the following topics. An update from Jeffco Student Leadership Board. Recent legislative activities. Compliance with state student harm reduction measures. Adoption and appropriation of the 20 2425 revised budget and Update on District Monitoring Report 1.1. Every student will demonstrate significant and appropriate academic growth using a body of evidence that includes classroom and standardized summative assessments. And finally, an update on monitoring reports 3.2 and 3.4. Policy, budget and curriculum decisions will be reflective and respectful of students abilities. Socioeconomics, ethnicity, races, religions, sexual orientations, and gender identities. The public can watch the recording to learn more about these programs. You can also visit our board page on the Jeffco

003Public Schools website. There you will find a host of information and links to both board docs and our live stream platforms. Now we will proceed with our study session agenda. We have a change in the order. We will go on to item 2.2, which is associations, negotiations, process and interests. And we are getting an update from, from the team that is here to be introduced in a minute. Okay. It's a little repetitive here with the, the activities with the Jefferson County Education Association and the Jefferson Education Support Professionals Association. Our district negotiation teams engage in a collaborative process with teams from JCA and Jasper that includes practices from both traditional and interest based bargaining. And before I hand this over to our distinguished guests, is there something you'd like to add, Superintendent Dorman? Thank you,

004President Parker. I just want to welcome, our team here today. Thank them for the work that they do at the bargaining table on behalf of the district and hand it over to our chief human resources officer, Miss Prado. Thank you. Thank you, board, for having us this evening. Thank you, Superintendent Darland and President Parker and board of directors. We are happy to be with you this evening. As, Tracy said, my name is Amanda Perez. I am the chief human resources officer, and I would like my colleagues to have an opportunity to introduce themselves to you as well. Hi everyone. I am Jennifer Kempson and I am the executive Director of Labor Relations. Hi, I'm Jen Christianson, I'm the director of labor relations. Hello. My name is Mark Trillo. I am the director of custodial services.

005Thank you everyone. So we have a brief presentation for you this evening to, provide for you an overview of the district negotiations and our interests. You had an opportunity to hear from our colleagues in the Jasper and GCA in both December, I believe, and January. And so, we are happy to present, following their presentations around our perspective of interest. And so we will get started. This is our district Jasper team. We began our Jasper negotiations in December, and, we are joined by a wide variety of, administrators, on the district team from across the different departments that work most closely with our Jasper teammates, including Mr. Cirillo, who happens to be, an expert in, working directly with the, the Jasper, teammates because he has so many, that he supervises under him. Here is our JCA team.

006We just started our JCA negotiation process last Thursday, and I'm very pleased to have this fantastic group of administrators joining us. Many of them are return, candidates, if you will, on the negotiations team. Last year, JCA asked us to consider, continuity of leadership and joining the district team. Just so that they understand the process and know how to engage. And so we took that to heart, and we made sure that, the majority of our, district representatives are returning. And so, you will see probably some very familiar names up there. Beginning with an overview of our Jasper negotiation cycle this year, in the spring of 2025, we are in a full opener, a full opener, as you are aware, means that any article, any appendix is open for conversation and negotiation. With our Jasper colleagues. In

007December, they share interest with us. We share interest back to that with them. We also share proposed solutions, to any of the interests that are open. From there, we begin to go back and forth with exchanging red lines in articles using language that we believe will meet the needs of the proposed solutions and the interests that have been presented, to either team. And so, looking back in our previous negotiation cycles with Jasper, you can see that, I tried to stick with a three year cycle. I have Jacob a little bit more perspective. So I actually have a four year cycle on theirs since they just had a full opener. In the spring of 22 with Jasper, we had three articles that, negotiation cycle ended in a successful completion. The compensation piece of that included a

008two hour, $2 per hour increase on every cell of the salary schedule, which is an average of an 8% increase across all, portions of the schedule. It also included a step advancement. So the total average was a 12.1% increase back in 2022, which then was applicable for the 2223 school year. The reason that that is an average is because, the, difference in steps and grades within the just the salary schedule is variable. We have, as you know, switch the GCA schedule to be more consistent. So it's a 2.5% increase between levels. But for just Jasper, it remains inconsistent. Which is something we do have an interest in considering in the spring of 23, which was applicable for the 2324 school year. There were four articles plus an additional MoU that was presented and agreed to

009that year. We did end in successful completion. There was a $1.40 per hour increase on steps one through seven of the just the salary schedule. As well as adjustment to other cells. There was also seven step advancement that year, which resulted in an average of an 8.6% increase. Just for reference, the reason that we apply sometimes a variable increase to the steps, the earlier steps in one's career is because our Jasper colleagues have an interest in advancing on the salary schedule earlier in their career so they can get to a higher wage, earning, toward the second part of their career with us here in Jeffco. In the spring of 2024, which was just last spring, which was applicable this year. Articles five and eight were brought to the table. Unfortunately, last year's negotiation process did

010result in an impasse, as you're very familiar with. However, at the end of that in-person mediation, we did, get to a 6% Cola for all Jasper employees, as well as step advancement and a one time, 1%, on their, base salary that was paid out to all Jasper employees in November. That was a total of approximately 8.5% to 11% increase. Again, based on the variability, moving on to, the interest that we have shared with Jasper this year are around. Several of the articles that we have open, some of them are shared interest and some of them are interest that we specifically had. The first article is around definitions. This defines all of the language that we use throughout the article. Really important that we are, clear on what it is we're talking about. When we say

011employee, what does that actually mean? What is full time employee mean? And so those are some of the, pieces that we're looking to redefine and clarify this year under article two. This is organizational rates. So this is the rate of the association. We believe that it's really important that we have operational efficiency, both both for the organization and for Jeffco Public Schools as an organization. This includes things like, association leave time so that, our association representatives who exist throughout the district can be, released from their buildings or from their workplace to, represent another colleague to engage in association activities, that kind of thing. This is also where our, where the peace exists around, our negotiations process and the ways in which Jasper engages in that in, article four article for his work assignments. Mark's going

012to talk a little bit more, toward the end of our, Jasper interests about work assignments and why that's really important to us. This is the way in which we hire our Jasper employees. Article six is compensation. This is always of interest to both sides. We want to make sure that our employees are experiencing, that value that we can commit to them through, compensation. Same thing with benefits. Benefits is always, a topic that is brought to the table. We want to ensure that our employees, from Jasper to GCA to GCA and everyone in between, has access to a comprehensive benefits package that is affordable and supports their own personal care. In article ten, article ten is our corrective action article. So this is the ways in which we engage in the disciplinary process. When an employee,

013may be going through, misconduct, when they have violated a policy, when they have, you know, inadvertently or intentionally, broken some type of expectation that we have set for them. And so, we're trying to get really clear on what that looks like and ensuring that we are affording our Jasper employees due process throughout. Article 12 is grievances. So this is the process by which, the negotiation or excuse me, the association can, call to our attention when they believe something from the agreement has been violated. So Jennifer and Jen do a lot of the, grievance. Actually, all of the grievance responses at this point. They support the supervisor in responding at level one. They, engage a neutral administrator at level two, and then they engage our legal team at a level three arbitration. We're looking to get

014really clear on the timelines. Right now, they're kind of all over the place. And so we are hoping to, bring that back into a more coherent system. In article 13, this is the transportation article. Ensuring that our transportation employees have stability in scheduling. That we are promoting safety and of course, that, we are maintaining that transport, that transparency in managing their, their routes, that they are, bidding for, that they are driving, throughout the school year. In article 16, this is our Food Nutrition Services article. This particular article, we are focused on safe working environments for our employees, as well as ensuring that they have adequate resources to, to conduct their work. And then we did propose a new Department of School Safety article. As you are aware, many of our school safety, officers have very,

015specific information that is beyond what a typical employee might have. They have access to, databases that share background searches, background type information. And they also oftentimes are armed. And so it's a very unique set of employees that we want to ensure are, protected. But also, are held to a really high standard because of that. That additional expectation that is on them of, carrying a firearm and being unsafe and of course, having the correct credentials to do so. Before we move on to these meeting days, I do want to give Mark an opportunity to lean in on a couple of these to just share with you, why what his experience has been as a, as a leader and why we might be, interested in some of these that you might want to hear straight from the

016field. And I will do my best to articulate it appropriately. So, yes, as, as Amanda talked about some of the things that we work with in custodial services, and I think a little bit of background is probably a good place to start. In the custodial services department, we have three administrators, that work with approximately 460 employees in the field. We do have four individuals in our office. Spanning a shift from 6 a.m. until 8 p.m., to provide support for both day shift and night shift. Custodial personnel. Four of those people, we really try to focus on being a trainer, mentor, coach, career developers, problem solvers. But then we have the three administrators that get into the the corrective action and some of these things with the hiring process. And for us, what we have experienced

017specifically with articles four, which is work assignments. Article ten, corrective action and article 12, the grievance process is somewhat of a of a moving target is what we're trying to resolve. And so well as department leaders, we are working to honor employee rights and employee experience. We do so within the confines, of course, of of the CBA, and we run into roadblocks quite often. And sometimes those come in the form of a grievance or a difference in interpretation of contract language. And some of what we experience is that those rules will change. We will get a grievance on a hiring, folder where we have made every effort to follow the CBA, for example. We receive a grievance and find out. Well, no, we think you did that wrong. So we'll change a process. Next folder.

018Here comes the grievance. The new process is being grieved. And and we're we're actually on the seventh iteration of that. In the three years that I've been in my chair. So that is one of the frustrations that we're looking to get some specificity into these, these processes with the hiring. Of course, with that many employees, we work with lateral transfers, and we look at placements and we look at, you know, everything from self demotion to promotion. And so we really are working for some clarity there because we, we now have the Equal Pay Act, which is for us a whole new learning curve in this process. And so balancing CBA language that quite honestly may conflict with that act. Again, we just need the specificity very much. So there we find it ourselves getting into

019a situation with, placement. And this is just a very specific example. As it stands right now, currently, corrective action cannot be used as a screening tool in a on a bid folder. For example. And that puts us in a position where we're holding confidentiality and not communicating appropriately with our principals in schools. And so the principal really doesn't know what they're getting in that instance. And so that's one thing. Just one small piece of this is we don't want to damage that relationship for the people that we serve. And our customers, of course, of the employees, the principals, the students. And we're seeing an erosion of those relationships and, and kind of a, a hand tying of the services that we can provide. So that's very much specific around article four. Article ten, corrective action.

020I think the in this article, we've been in kind of a transition period with, you know, guidance from the district level and what what is our mission. And we're trying to build a bridge and we're trying to have mutual respect between the employee association and and leadership. And so there again, we need to establish some very clear steps. Specifically there, we need some steps to address employee misconduct that is outside of the disciplinary realm. And that's always traditionally been the letter of expectation. Which is now as of recent been grieved. And so it gives us it gives us a situation where regardless of the action, it becomes craveable. And so it's very hard to hold an employee accountable at any level. When it maybe all we need to do is go out and have a

021conversation, for example, the climate in the field around corrective action. I would describe as unnecessarily adversarial at times. And that's one thing that we really want to come to the table and agree on. These are the steps. This is what misconduct is identified as. We're looking to remove performance improvement from that corrective action article. Because it doesn't seem to fit there's there needs to be a clear delineation between misconduct and performance improvement. So article ten, that's very much from my department's lens. That's our that's that's our goal. And then article 12. I think Amanda touched on it very, very well with the grievance process. But we were looking for clarity around steps and specific to hiring folders. If if a position or a promotion is awarded, we will find ourselves in a situation where that's

022grieved by typically the second place candidate on the folder. Tremendous amount of time and energy goes into that. And we find ourselves in a situation where if we have made a misstep, we have to fix that in some way, and that can be expensive and that can displace another ISP. And so we want to avoid that at all costs. So we're trying to carve out a separate process in the grievance procedure specific to, the hiring process. Engaging the hiring manager, defining who is the hiring manager. I think we came into that with a little bit of of a lack of clarity over who exactly is the hiring manager on each folder, which created problems as to who gets to mediate and solve the dispute. Right. Who do they come to if they have a concern

023type of a thing? So that's one thing that we really want to do there. What we ultimately want to do is through that is is restore. I mentioned that mentoring coaching attitude that we want to have with the workforce, and we want to restore the opportunity for that because it seems like as of late, the climate has been you violated the contract for filing a grievance for violating the. And so we're missing that that coaching dialog with the individual. And having been in the department for 23 years now. We used to have that. And we used to be able to sit down with an employee and explain to them, this is why you didn't get that position. Here's what we can offer you to better yourself. And so we're we're somewhat missing out on that

024opportunity now because of the adversarial positioning. And so I think with some contract language and some clarification, we can rein that in and come to an agreement hopefully, where we're we're getting back on track with that focus of, employee development and building into people's careers. And in my opinion, all three of these articles touch on that. That's our primary focus this school year as a department is, professional growth, personal growth. And we would just like very much to get back to that. So I'll say something out. Thank you. Thank you. Mark. And just, for reference, way Mark's been through seven iterations is because he's very flexible. He's very much wanting to get it right. He thinks of innovative ways in which to improve the hiring process and the way in which we document it. And

025so Mark is always coming to the team with new ideas, with what do you think? We, we use Mark as somebody to give us feedback. We give him feedback. And so, it has really been a great partnership with our custodial services department. With regard to work assignments, and lots of other things. So, these are just for meeting dates. As you can see, there are many, any time we have a full opener. There are often a lot of dates. I think there are 19 up there. Those, times vary. Sometimes we meet in the morning, sometimes we meet in the afternoon, and sometimes we meet in the evening. Our just the employees have a little bit more flexibility, as they don't have to leave sub plans. Although they are leaving a vacancy. They they sometimes do. I

026should say, we do have an ECP who's on the team and she does leave sub plans, and she does a great job of ensuring that her, pre-K kiddos are taken care of while she's absent. During any of these sessions, we do have a joint benefits bargaining session with JCA and Jasper beginning tomorrow evening. And so, that'll be the first time that we've ever done that. And so, it'll be a new process and we will see how that goes. So moving on to JCA, one thing I do want to say about Jasper. I was in the room and heard the advocacy for engaging a third party neutral facilitator. I want you to know that we have not yet done so. And that was an agreement between, their, facilitator and myself. Because at this time, we feel

027as though we are, building the relationship or rebuilding trust. And we're doing, we're doing a good job. Both sides of the table are, like, feeling like we're showing up in a really positive space and a problem solving mindset and inquiry, curiosity, if you will, asking really good questions. And we acknowledge that it's going to get harder and they acknowledge the same. And we have agreed that when we get to that point, then we would may need to engage a neutral facilitator. Jen has already reached out to Fmqs, to be able to have a contact that we can engage just as soon as, we know that might need to happen. And, both sides are very open to it. And so I want you to know that, with regard to GCA. So, GCA, I have, been on

028this process now for three years. Four years. And this is our negotiation cycle. Last year was our full opener. And so in the spring of 21, that was the last time there was a full opener. That one's a virtual, full opener because it was during Covid. They did reach successful agreement, although, there were several articles left open due to the limitations of being able to agree to so many things virtually and not being in person. And, so they did actually agree to opening more articles the following year. That year in 21, it resulted in a 3% Cola plus steps and lanes and a one time 1%. I apologize that I left this off. That is an average increase of 9.1%. And then of course, that additional 1% that was paid in November to the employee

029group, in spring of 22. Again, this was following the full opener. There were multiple articles open that year. It did unfortunately result in a an impact to mediation. However, the result was a new salary schedule, which has, really smoothed out our ability to pay in a more equitable way. And so we did add a lane that year, a lane six for additional education. We also added a new CTE for career and technical education, schedule, which the Warren Tech staff was really instrumental in working with human resources to get that, well developed and understandable for all of our career and technical education, teachers and instructors with industry certification. That also had, the year that we added a 1% title, one stipend to any educator who works in a title one building after that cycle, received a

0301%, additional, pay on their salary each year. That was an average of a 9% Cola increase that year. The reason that that, average varied was because when we reset the entire salary schedule, there was a variable increase in, each cell of the schedule. However, we did ensure that there was a minimum $3,000 increase that year for all employees on that schedule. In the spring of 23, we had seven articles open. We did reach successful agreement that year. There was an average of a 5.25% Cola plus steps and lanes. Which after the reset of the schedule, result in a 2.5% increase. So now, between the lanes or excuse me, rather between the steps, it is a 2.5% increase, between every single step. And then that, total was approximately 7.75% increase on average. And we increased the

031title one stipend that year to a 2% stipend. And then finally, this past spring, we had our next full opener, which was 23 articles, three appendices. And we remember that 230 in the morning finisher very well. And we did reach successful agreement and that resulted in a 5% Cola increase plus caps and lanes. Again, those are 2.5% approximately lanes do provide some variability. Lanes, as you know, is when you move across the schedule based on your additional education. And so, depending on the employees, like where they're at master's degree, PhD, etc., they get a variable increase based on, their lane increases. And then this year they had a one time 2%, which was actually actually a two time 1% each, but it's a one time payment. And we paid that out in 1% in October.

032And one, 1% in April. And the reason we did that is because we wanted well, they asked us to first of all, but we also wanted to make sure that, both new employees who were, employed by September 15th received it, but then also, employees who are hired the second half of the year also will receive that benefit with GCA. And I know that they shared this with you as well. They have shared with us an interest in article eight. This is our, licensed educator, our class size caseload article. Our district interest that we shared with them were both the reduction in force article, as well as our remote and virtual instruction article, and that we'll talk a little bit more about each one of these. And then our shared interests are listed there. I'll go

033through them. Our district interests around article 14. So the reduction in force article is really important to us that we ensure that we are both both sides of the table are on the same page when it comes to the potential of needing to use our language, any time in the future. As you are all aware, we are facing, potential losses in revenue. And so in, in continuing declines in enrollment. And so we want to make sure that that language is tight and that should we have to use it, which we've been fortunate and have not had to use it in, the past several years. We want to make sure that both sides understand, the weight of this language and how it impacts our educators and our district as a whole. For article 23, our remote

034and virtual instruction, it's really important to us that we clarify some things in this article specific to our Jeffco Virtual Academy. So GVA, there are some work hours and expectations that we really want to clarify to ensure that our employees have, more clear guidelines on what is expected and what they what is not expected. Right? We do not want them to be working 12 hour days. That's not the expectation. And so we're just going to clarify that language a little bit. Our shared interests include our article 13 leaves article. We've been working with a collaborative workgroup doctor Kim and I all, spring or. Excuse me, all fall, to explore the possibility of reconfiguring our sick and personal leave, as well as, exploring the possibility of incentives for unused time. Currently, the only incentive that we

035have is when you've reached 20 years of employment in Jeffco, you get a, sick and personal leave payout, a percentage on your, time over. Excuse me? Up to 660 hours. If you've banked that amount of time in check and personal. It's a percentage. It's a very complicated percentage, but, we are looking into what other opportunities might we have to use as incentives for our employees throughout their careers? I mean, article 17, of course, our compensation article always open. One of our, interests in this article is really ensuring that those additional earnings are streamlined. Right now we have, multiple stipends that are paid a title, one stipend, a dual language stipend, additional, accreditations stipend, such as if you are a national board certified teacher. So we really want to find a way to be more, systematic

036and streamlined in those different stipends. The special education article, again, a collaborative work group, has worked throughout the fall semester to, discuss some of this challenges that our special educators are facing with regard to time, Ida responsibilities. Caseloads and of course, any extra duties that they have in meeting the needs of their, obligation under the law. Other shared interests are appendix B is our coaching activity sponsor stipend. We agreed to a three year, roll out of improving our coaching activities, sponsor stipends to better align with our colleagues in our, districts in the Front Range, and to be more competitive in that arena. So we're looking at the second bite of the apple this year and what that's going to look like. Benefits of course, seem similar to, Jasper, always open for conversation around our benefits

037package that we provide to our employees through our employer contribution. And then, appendix E is a post-retirement employment. This actually came up this year in a grievance conversation around, what does that look like to rehire our, retirees and ensure that they are being paid equitably and, are valued for the continued contribution that they are willing to make to the district in the classroom. These are our AJC meeting dates. Looks so much shorter then both Jasper with the full opener and last year's, meeting dates. Those are all scheduled in the evening. So that our educators can be present with their students during the day, with the exception of the February 20th joint benefits. That one is a half day and goes into the evening. And so, we will release our educators from the classroom. That afternoon.

038So our negotiation process, this is just really our, kind of our vision for what this looks like. So in collaboration with GCA and Jasper Partners, we engage in a process that includes practices from both traditional and interest based bargaining. Interest potential solutions and or stories are shared, followed by the exchange of red lines, and revised language proposals and counter proposals. Then a point upon arriving at a satisfactory compromise. We work toward a tentative agreement through a consensus gathering process. It's very technical. Thumbs up or thumbs down, very technical. And then finally, our commitment to, negotiations from the district perspective. We and and, honestly, the, association perspective as well. We are collectively committed to continuous reflection and action toward improvement of learning, leading, teaching and working conditions for the benefit of our students, educators, employees, and

039families across Jefferson County. So we are very pleased to lead that process and be, your designees. We appreciate the trust that you place in us and, the support that you provide us throughout the process. And, of course, any questions we are happy to attempt to answer here. And if we don't have the answer, we will most definitely get it for you. Thank you. Board. Any questions or comments? Thank you so much. I know there's so much time and effort that goes into this outside of the dates that are listed here, along with that time. So thank you all. And to your, fellow folks at the negotiations table. My, I just have one clarifying question. When you were talking about Jasper and you had the additional, piece at the bottom, that is in reference to potentially

040SROs becoming part of our, operating staff because we will be picking up additional costs and funding. Is that accurate? So it's actually our armed patrol officers that we have. So, so, Jeff down at the Or Eli down at the, the main desk is one of these gentlemen. We also have, you know, ladies and gentlemen, throughout the district who are doing the armed patrol. It also would include, our dispatch, who is working, you know, 24 over seven to ensure that, you know, the buildings are safe and, all the cameras are being monitored, this and that. But also includes, our, campus security guards who aren't armed, but they are part of the just the, collective bargaining agreement. And so, some of the language in this new article that we've proposed really does, highlight some of the different

041work that they do in the different ways in which we hire them, vet them, ensure they maintain their certifications and their training, which is a much more intensive process than some of our other certificates. And so those are the employee groups that it currently, includes. We have not considered SROs yet since they're not technically our employees yet. It. Yeah. All right. Thank you. Of course. Can you help me understand a little bit what will be going on at the joint benefits meetings between both Jasper and Jesse? Yes. So, right now, we are, following the, memorandum of understanding for our Benefits Advisory Council. You're all very familiar with the back. As you know, the back entered into, an RFP this year, or rather, Jeffco entered into an RFP and was advised by back, and around an

042RFP committee made up of black members, primarily black members, but also others who, are on the district team and they have gone through you all have approved us moving forward with our two vendors, for our health insurance. And so, what we've talked about is discussing at the negotiations table the structure of benefits. So, as you know, we sent out a survey last May around what is most important to our employees. And that really informed the RFP process. The CAC also, formulated a survey this fall, and we sent that out between November, December and January to gain information around, what they might like to see change in the employer contribution or if they want it to maintain, the way it currently is right now, we have an employer contribution of $640 for any full time employee.

043And currently with GCA, that's a 0.6 or higher, which is 32.75 or higher. They do have an interest in moving that 2.6 for your awareness. And so we've talked about what is the structure look like? They have an interest in us considering a, tiered model. They're referring to it as a percentage based model. So last year, the back presented to the negotiations teams, which is their responsibility. They are supposed to be advising their teams that then bring their, information to the table for us to consider. So last year, they proposed an 80%, 20% split where the district would cover 80% of all, benefits premiums for employees, regardless of the type of, benefits package that they chose, whether that was a, Aetna full family plan or a Kaiser high deductible, employee only plan. They wanted that

04480% coverage regardless of plan choice. As you can imagine that it creates quite a bit of variability. And so we ask the employees, what is it that you are interested in? Do you want to consider this variability in, providing additional funding from the employer contribution to those who are on an employee plus family plan or an employee plus spouse plan? Thus, potentially it has to be negotiated, reducing the employee only coverage and so, we ask those questions, we got back those results. I think we shared them with you in, recent Friday update after Adam and Christina came, and so that information will be shared, tomorrow at the first joint benefits negotiations, session. And what I've been really clear with them is that we will we are open to having a conversation around the structure. So

045if we want to do a tiered model where, the employer contribution might look like this for the employee only coverage, this tier for the employee plus spouse, this tier for employee plus dependents, and this tier for employee plus family, we're open for that conversation. What we can't do, and what I've been really clear with them about, is that we are not willing to negotiate benefits in the contribution separate from compensation, because, as you know, there's one pot of money. And so we need to be really, clear about that and make sure that we are meeting what our employees have, communicated to us. And many of them, unfortunately, we only had about a 10% response rate, about 1400 responses. But many of them have said if I had to choose, I want the money to go

046to compensation. And so, we need to be really thoughtful about the way in which we engage in that conversation. And we we too, will present that data tomorrow evening to make sure that, you know, the both sides understand what our employees, the 10% of them responded, have said. So. I just want to say thank you. I know it's a lot of work. And even just going through and the quick snippets, I know, I know, I will have a lot more questions as we move on, but just a gratitude for the work that you all are doing. We really appreciate it. Thank you. Last year, there was a point where there was a lawyer involved. Is a lawyer planning to be involved? We do not currently have a lawyer planned to join us. Either. And just

047for or GCA. You know, should there be a time where we need to have legal counsel? We're very fortunate to have, our fabulous attorneys on staff who are always willing to consult with us and, provide us like, a really great direction. And certainly, if ever that becomes a need, we can reengage in that conversation with our, with our in-house attorneys as to what our needs are. But currently we do not have that in the plans. So this year it would go if there was a need for help facilitator that would be our first attempt would be, facilitation. Okay. And I just wanted to ask if, on the title one stipends, I think have been here through the years of those increases and I'm so, supportive of those. Is there any interest on either the district

048or, employee side to continue to increase that stipend? Is it. It's not a stipend. It's a, it is a state. Yeah, it's a stipend. Definitely. On the employee side, they have that interest. We also added, and I apologize, I forgot to put this on there. We added a special education, a special educator stipend last year. It's a small amount. And yet, it is a way in which we can start, begin to show, how appreciative we are of the extra work that they do. We also pay them for three additional days of work, for their ID responsibilities. And yet they they have communicated to us an interest in both continuing and, incrementally increasing those stipends as we are able. I've just been we've heard a lot, so much about, turnover at, you know, in this title

049one position. So I think any incentive would to keep folks there would be great. One more and I've forgotten it, but so that's I'm thinking about now. Thank you and best of luck and thank you Susan. We appreciate it. Yes. Thank you so much. That was really informative. And I have one question about, letter of expectations. What can you give me more information on them so I can typically and the way it's laid out in the current contract language, the letter of expectation is a non disciplinary step. And it's it's a way to informally address a concern. I guess a better way to put that would be to formally informally address a concern. Because it becomes it's in writing. It's not part of the, the formal corrective action process, which would start with a letter

050of reprimand at step one, and then move to suspension, demotion and then ultimately termination. Assuming correction wasn't made, of course, but as a supervisor and I can kind of speak through my own lens when I was in that role, the letter of expectation was a tool that I would use if I went in and conducted a fact finding meeting with an employee and genuinely saw that they recognized the error and that they were going to correct it, and it gave me a tool to say, you know what this was? This was this was bad. And we can't have this in a school building. However, I understand it's not going to happen again. So I'm going to use this non disciplinary tool to address it, formally but informally if you will. So it lives outside of

051the corrective action process. But it's an official letter that you can hand somebody go over with them, establish the expectation. Also wonderful wonderful. If the if the behavior repeats because then you have a foundation and it's again, our goal is to is to resolve things at the lowest possible level. And so that letter of expectation gives us an opportunity to resolve it before it becomes career threatening. If that doesn't make sense. So okay. Thank you. Well, really, this was really helpful. And and fingers crossed it continues to go well. And I guess we'll be hearing from you again. Thank you so much. So at this point, we will go back to item 2.01. And this agenda item will allow the board the opportunity to review and discuss recent legislative activities of the 75th General Assembly,

052should the board wish to formally endorse or support legislation, we may also discuss it during this time. And before I hand it over to Mr. Bowdich from Bowdich Castle public Affairs, is there anything you'd like to say? Superintendent Whelan? Thank you, President Parker. I did, share with the board yesterday. Messaging and talking points that I, we provided for Mr. Bowdich as he was down at the Capitol working with legislators on the School Finance Act and specific questions were coming, to, Mr. Bowdich regarding the governor's recommendation that the state remove the enrollment averaging from the School Finance Act. And so if you have not had a chance to see that, it did come in yesterday. And I just want to bring the board's attention to that. I know that's probably a topic that Mr. Bowdich has

053some updates on this this evening. And then of course, anything else that, that is, happening down there and or board members are interested in hearing about. So thanks for your, work to represent our perspective, especially over the last couple of days. And welcome. Thank you, Madam Superintendent and members of the board, and thanks for the schedule adjustment. I appreciate that. I'd like to start by saying when the letter that, the superintendent reference is not well, the letter statement about the importance of enrollment averaging got to me. I sent it out to emailed out to all members of the Jeffco delegation. I got one email back that was so fast. I thought it was a bounce back. And I just want to call out and say, Senator Lisa Cutter got back to me so quickly and

054she said, I stand with the school district and I and I know a bunch of other ones, and they get 500 emails a day, and I'm not saying the other ones don't, but when you have that kind of support, I thought she deserved a special shout out. So I just wanted to go on the record as saying that. And we have a wonderful delegation of other members as well. As you can see, the we're really very light on introduced bills so far. The the library bill has been introduced again this year. I think it's we didn't really engage in that. We have a process. We don't get that many complaints. Things are handled at the school level. But my understanding is that what the bill contemplates, we have in place through policy and practice. Yeah.

055So I think some other school districts will be engaged in that one, but I'm not sure we need to do anything at this point. But talking about funding, there are three issues going on right now. Last year, House Bill 1448, the new School Finance Act, the implementation was supposed to be done over six years. There's additional money each year. Over those six years, all districts benefit. The governor had requested that maybe we do a longer implementation time, meaning we'd get less money each year. But then he rescinded that request. So now we're back to the normal process. Having said that, there were two triggers in the bill that would caused the new School Finance Act to be paused. And one of them said if the March revenue forecast used by the Joint Budget Committee for

056the budget estimates indicates estimates that the income tax diversion to the state education fund will decrease by 5% or more, then the School Finance Act doesn't go into effect for the next year. We are going to hit that trigger, and we're going to hit that trigger in a bit of an unusual way. Last year, the economy legislative staff realized they needed to do a true OP on what should have been transferred to the state education fund. And they, they are authorized to do this on their own. No statutory, no action by the legislature was necessary, but there was about an extra $100 million that went into the state education fund in 23, 24. Well, that means when we get to 2425 the current fiscal year, we're not going to have as much revenue put into

057it. So we're below the 5% threshold. Some people of the capital are saying, well, that's just a technical oddity. Most of the school districts lobbyists are saying those triggers were carefully negotiated, and a 5% threshold is a 5% threshold. And don't talk to us about this being a technical violation. If the legislature wants to change this, the legislature can sponsor legislation to change it, and we'll see what happens. That's the first issue, and that's the implementation of, 1448. Second issue is the declining enrollment debate. The state budget. I think I was out here maybe three weeks ago. In that time, we've got worse news on the state budget. It turns out that the state calculation for allowable Tabor revenues has been undercounting the population. We've never done a true up. And when we do that

058now, we've been over counting the population. So we've actually had smaller population growth very slightly. But that adds up. And all the years we should have given a little more Tabor refund. If you dump that into one pot, we owe another $160 million. So now we're back up above $900 million. In my conversations with the Joint Budget Committee members, they look at me and they say everything is on the table. Absolutely everything. So we're back to having to defend the issue of enrollment averaging. The district CFO gave a fabulous summary as part of a panel put together by case to the joint Education committees. She did a wonderful job representing the district and the importance and why declining enrollment doesn't have anything to do with phantom students. So all of these things are swirling around.

059I think I know the interests of the district in these things. I would guess that you would ask me to work to ensure that 1448 is implemented as originally scheduled in the original agreement over a six year period, not longer, and resist any change in multiyear enrollment averaging. My guess is there's going to have to be some reduction to K-12 somewhere, but I think those two clear pieces of direction would give me solid ground on which to advocate on behalf of the district and the students and the Jeffco community. Are you pausing for questions? Yeah. Yes. Okay. That's what I certainly expected, but I, I it does help me to say that yes, the district does want me to do those things. Yeah. One of the things that I put into the messaging that I

060sent to Ed yesterday was, To consider something like a three year averaging, because at the end of the day, there is the $900 million shortfall. At the end of the day, everything is on the table and the state's going to have to do something. I also just fundamentally believe that a five year averaging allows districts to kick the can down the road in a way that maybe is not helpful for students that are sitting in small schools, which we dealt with. And I saw the effects of here in Jeffco when I visited schools that were under enrolled drastically. And so my goal has been to try to figure out how do you enter into the conversation where you're actually a part of it and not just advocating for something that is probably not realistic given

061the state's budget situation. So just know that that is part of the messaging that I shared with Ed. This, earlier this week, and that is in your inbox from yesterday. And I think that's a very realistic statement to make that they're going to do something and frankly, if they move from 4 to 3 years. This is my a question for superintendent. Do we know about how much that would affect us ish. Not looking for hard numbers. Yeah. I mean I don't know what I can tell you, given some of the very preliminary revenue, estimates that our finance team is running, depending upon what happens, whether they leave the averaging at five years, drop it to four years, then go to three. The next year, eliminate it all together. You know, we could be looking at

062anywhere from a revenue reduction of $4 million to 20 to 25 million. There's the three year. And some of that depends on what the. Sorry I mean just one more thing. Some of that depends on what the state decisions are related to, how they calculate the revenue. And some of that depends upon how our enrollment and how much it drops next year. Those two things, those two things are working together in that and those estimates. And we are preparing for, revenue estimates to come to the board. I don't know when that when we start talking about revenue estimates. Next Friday, I'll be able to share more with you. We're working on it now. And this. But at this point in time, like, everything that happens, the state with the budget, it's going to be a

063range because we don't have any indication of what they're going to do. The other thing that I talk about in the message that I sent to Ed earlier this week was, we've got to have some indication of what the heck is going to happen prior to May like. The timing of this is exhausting. It strains relationships with our associations and our employees. It's unrealistic for a board to turn it around and have meet the legislative deadline of June 30th for their budget approval. And the state needs to figure out a better process to give us some sort of indication of what our revenue is going to be, you know, no later than early April, early to mid April. So that's the other, other piece that I put into the message. That would be great if

064the legislature could settle on that, because there are so many rumors about the budget, in addition to rumors about all the other things going on in society. If we could somehow make the decisions and calm everybody down on the budget, that would help. Well, and I've been I've been each year feeling very, you know, fortunate that we've had a healthy fund balance and we still do. But given that we have tightened things up and provided the compensation increases that you saw earlier tonight with our, bargaining team, I'm not sure that we're going to have the luxury this year of relying on our our fund balances to to get us out of this one. And, you know, it's going to depending upon the revenue, it's going to hit us harder this year or less hard. And

065so we're just going to have to kind of wait and see what the state decides to do with the calculations. Other questions comments. Oh, let's do the funding and then get to the others. I, I have a question. When you were talking about three things that could cause a pause in 1448, does did I say it right? Does a pause mean don't start it? It don't started or I think it means don't continue the next phase of it. As what phase have we done? So we haven't done any of July 1st at this point, it would mean the first year of funding and the first year of of the change would take July 1st. But it this year, unless the trigger is us to do a bill to modify that trigger. At this point I

066don't believe it will go into effect. Okay. So that means that, you said something about the 5% threshold. I understood there's confusion over whether it's just a hard number or if it's, you know, something that you can. Yeah. Discuss. But that seems to be a possible trigger that says, nope, we're not starting it. And then the Tabor. I'm still trying to understand that. Does that mean they don't have to go back and refund Tabor because their population numbers were off? Do they know? But they do have to refund the money that was owed and they'll refund it all this year. So they do have to go back. They do have to go back and refund it. But yeah, so what they would the mechanism would be to do it this year. Okay. So so it

067could be even more going to refunds for Tabor. Right. And so and then so if those two triggers kind of make us not implement 1448 it just it's not going forward. What does that do with this. Averaging that was in 1448 that that goes away their plan for 1440. And then they just vote on whether they're going to go with what the governor wanted. And eliminate it. The enrollment averaging is a related debate to 1448, but it's separate. Okay. If 1448 isn't implementing, we go back to a five year enrollment rate. That's great. That's good. But I'm confident if I were guessing, I think they would try and address this trigger. But the debate about the averaging can be done whether 1448 goes into play or not. Okay. Thanks. So okay, those are my questions

068on the funding. And I guess now we can open it up. Director Kenworthy, did you want to address some of these bills? And, Mr. Bowditch, do you want to address anything else on any of the other things here underneath? No, I really don't think anything on the list is really all that critical that I want to make sure the board weighs in on, but I'm happy to respond to questions about them. Sure. What are you. What are you hearing about the communications devices in schools? Up there, is there a lot of support for that or people trying to avoid it? I'm curious. On House Bill 1135, that is coming from Children's Hospital Colorado, I think because it leaves total flexibility to the school boards, no one is getting too concerned about it. And that Bill

069has a good chance of passing. Okay. And then my other question, I want to lift up for our district actually on the communication devices in schools, is that on our, upcoming agenda that we're going to talk about at the end of this meeting, we're scheduled to get a presentation about cell phone things here, like in June, I think. And I'm wondering if we can get that earlier since we don't currently have a policy in Jeffco about cell phones, but we may need to have one based on if this gets passed. So if we can be, if we as a board can be better prepared with some information, I would know what the timeline is for districts to get something in place of 1135 passes. That is just what I'm looking up right now, on or

070before July 1st, 2026. So heavy. So yeah. Yep. Time. Okay, my other questions. Are about, a comprehensive black history and culture education in K-12. I would be willing for our board to lend support to that if we're interested. If or if we want to wait until it's further down the road to do that, we can and want to partner with some other things that we're going to lend support to. We can do that too. I'm just mentioning it now. That's something I would support and and I might to that bill say you wait until the next time up because I think there's another bill that comes that's coming to similar to that. So then when they're both introduced, you could look at them together. Okay. That's helpful. Thank you. It's it's House Bill 25 1149.

071And I guess I had one question just on the modifications to Cora. What type of that? What are those modifications considering? It would be giving public entities more time to respond to Cora requests. So right now, I believe it's three days to respond to Cora requests. This bill would move it to five days, with the exception of requests from media, the media would still be under the original deadline. And then if there are extenuating circumstances, I believe it's a five day limit. This would move it to ten. And and there are a lot of public entities that are supporting that bill. I'm the only one that's opposing it is the Colorado Freedom for information Coalition. And I understand those folks. They don't want any modification to Cora, but they've been involved in every discussion with,

072Senator Kemp. Thank you. Are there any, sponsors of these bills that are asking for our support? The one that I did see was about the, tax credit for eligible teachers. House Bill 1037. We've seen this one before, I think, given that the state's Tabor refunds are not going to be voluminous this year, the legislature's not going to adopt many, if any new tax credits. So I think this one is probably going to not make it through anyway. They tried last year, too. It didn't make it through, in the number of years in a row. Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, I guess it's still early in the legislative process, and I know lots of changes get made to these bills, so it seems at this point we can just keep monitoring them. Okay. Any other questions?

073Oh, well thank you very much. Appreciate. Thank you always. And actually, I think based on timing and when our next presenters are expecting to come, we will take a short break right now. It is. Yeah. 535. So we'll be back in about ten, 15 minutes. Thanks. One of the key responsibilities of the Board of Education is policymaking. We create and adopt policies that shape how our schools operate. Everything from curriculum decisions to policies that ensure every student feels a sense of belonging. Our policies help ensure consistency, fairness and excellence across all district schools. We work hard to ensure they reflect our community's values and serve students best interests while following state and federal laws. And. In. This. For our next agenda item for study this evening, the board will receive information about the status of

074the curriculum adoption process for secondary English language arts. In accordance with district policy and the Jeffco curriculum adoption cycle. Instructional resources that are recommended to be added to the Catalog of Approved Instructional Resources are voted on by the board. In September 2024, a request for proposals or RFP process was initiated based on recommendations from key curriculum and instruction stakeholders, following extensive input provided by central office staff and a broad representation of school based stakeholders, which we will hear more about tonight. Following the competitive process into literature service, my Perspectives and McGraw Hill Study Sync were chosen as the finalist Core Curriculum Options for grades six through 12 by the district. Before I turn this over to Miss Otis, is there anything you'd like to add, Superintendent darling? Thank you, President Parker. I've had the pleasure

075of being in multiple classrooms over the last month. Where the secondary English language arts curriculums are being used. And not just one, but multiple of the the list. That they're being piloted. And I just want to thank you all for the work that you've done to do this. And I believe the pace at which we're doing it is allowing for teacher voice to be part of, the work and in particular, when we shift in from elementary resources into secondary resources, that content expertise that our teachers have and bring with them, and the passion for the content they teach is incredibly important to them and to us. So giving ourselves time to think, about their feedback for them to provide the feedback after using the curriculum has been really important and will continue to be important.

076And so thank you to the team for doing it in that way. I have seen the the resources being used. I think they're having an impact on access and exposure to grade level standards and rigor and appreciate that. So cathodes, thanks for being here this evening. And I'll let you introduce the guests who you've brought with us for the presentation and discussion. Thank you. Superintendent Norlin. President Packer, members of the board, I'm Renee Nick Otis, the chief academic officer here. And Jeff co happy to see you all again. When I also introduce my friends that I have here, I'm really more excited for you to hear from all of them tonight about their experience so far with the resources that we're here to talk about with you. Robinson, director of K-12, Ela, Social Studies and

077Libraries. Catherine Driscoll, I'm a sixth grade teacher at Creighton Middle School, and this is our second year using each image. Emily Josie, instructional coach at Carmody Middle School. It's our first year using each image, and we're all six, six, seven, and eighth grade. And Jen Pinnell, principal of Dunston Middle School. This is our first year using each image, and we are all into grades six through eight. So I'm especially grateful that our school folks are here to join us this evening and want to thank them again for taking the time to be here. So we are here to talk about our current work. In accordance with district policy, IJA, and, instructional resources that we're looking for your approval, to adopt as part of our approved Jeffco list. And so we are specifically asking for approval

078from the board to add h h into literature service. My perspectives and McGraw-Hill studies sync to our list of approved resources for instruction in our Jeffco secondary classrooms. We're also here to ask you to approve the purchase of, our our director of purchasing to go into a contract with these vendors to purchase these materials for our schools. Just a reminder, this is in alignment with our work around instructional excellence, in particular for our learners, our future, and ensuring that they have high quality, engaging, rigorous instruction. It provides an extraordinary student experience and instructional excellence. This is also an alignment with the board, and statement that every student will be taught using evidence based instructional materials that reflect the global diversity of the world in which students live. We interpret this to mean that all state,

079Jeffco students will experience instruction that's grounded in high quality instructional material, as well as practices that are aligned to research and data, as measured by our process, to review and select high quality instructional materials according to a set of criteria that we identify in collaboration with our teachers. Our adoption and implementation of those materials. Professional learning supports the strong implementation and then available and coherent instructional resources, along with the feedback to support teachers to use them effectively with students. So this is just a high level overview of the steps that are outlined in district policy around the adoption of core resources to be added to our approved list. So we meet with our staff, our teachers, and get clear on what are our priorities, what are the things that we are looking for and the

080resources that we select for our teachers to use. So once those priorities are identified, we create a request for proposal, an RFP that outlines the things that we are looking for in our materials. Once we get proposals from different vendors, we go through a series of committees, that review the proposals as well as the materials that rise to the top. We usually end up with three that rise to the top after, a review process that goes through a more intensive, review, which we'll go through, with you in just a few minutes. We also have public comment opportunities, with, along with the committee review. And then we were here tonight to, share with you with the results of all these conversations that we've had. I would also like to take a moment just to introduce, two

081members of my secondary Ela team, who are here with us as well tonight. Robin Keyhole Ramsey and Tiffany Wright. A lot of what I'm going to talk about and share with you is due to a lot of their work. Really engaging teachers throughout this process. So on this slide, you'll see, what Ela teachers to our instructional leaders group have identified as really our guiding principles that, we want our secondary Ela teachers to be anchoring to, as they think about and plan high quality instruction. So the process in which we came up with these principles, with our ILS was we just asked them to begin to consider ways that, some of these instructional practices show up in their work and in their classroom. And then we asked them to discuss and share ideas about what that's

082looking like. And this was a much bigger list. And as conversation kind of developed and evolved, we asked them to kind of revise, delete and then add, and then we kind of took a draft form back to our instructional leader group and asked them to finalize and improve that. This, that these principles would be the anchor to which we want to form our instruction and our vision around secondary instruction. So. Sorry. Thank you. The other thing I just wanted to add that, our instructional leaders meet every month and in addition to coming up with some guiding principles that we could anchor all of our secondary Ela teachers to, some of our topics this year have been unit level essential questions. Were these tasks, how how are we supporting and really understanding what grade level questions

083and tasks look like for our students? And how are we really intentionally integrating reading and writing in those tasks? As a thank you. As part of our work with our pilot schools, we currently have 15 schools who are engaged in our Ela resource pilot, and you'll see them here on the slide. We have many schools who are piloting in the literature. We have three schools piloting service, my perspectives and two McGraw-Hill studies, I think. And it's varied because schools had a choice in which resource they were going to select, and that was all based on teacher feedback, input and where teachers really felt like the resource aligned with the practices that currently existed in their school and what values they had, when they were looking at a resource. Thank you. So on the side, you

084know, and we have some educators here today who will be able to share their personal experiences. But and part of our work with our pilot schools, we have invited pilot teachers, and this was at the request of our instructional leaders to come and speak, to our instructional leader groups. And we have this bi monthly. And again, it was at the request of our ILC. They really wanted to hear like real time experiences from our pilot schools teachers and how that's involved evolved since the beginning of the school year. But I think they really wanted to have an understanding of what is this journey and what does this look like. So we also want to share some of these comments from our teachers. And you'll notice that, if you look at them closely, you'll see that

085the majority of these comments are positive. And so one might ask, are there any negative, to this work? And sure, yes, there are. And the reason why you don't see, many negatives is because really the feedback has been overwhelmingly positive. Most of the negative and I don't even want to characterize them as a negative, but I would say challenges that teachers have expressed, which you'll probably hear from our guests today as well, has just been around implementation, you know, change of practice, change of planning. And, you know, for many teachers engaging in a digital platform is hard. And but what we have really seen is a lot of resilience from teachers and them really leaning on their teammates, who have a strength in technology. While their teammate might carry the weight and something else in

086a resource. Yeah. I just wanted to share a quick story. I, the instructional leader groups are made up, I think around 3035, teachers, and we have a representative. They're all Ela teachers, and there's one from each school, middle and high school that are part of the group. And they meet twice a month, sometimes once a month. But I wanted to that when we invited the pilot school teachers to join their monthly instructional leader meeting in November, I wanted to join. I asked if I could if I could get in on that, and I would just be a fly on the wall. And because I really wanted to hear, warts and all, how was it going? And I really was bracing myself for, I'm sure it's hard. First year implementation is always challenging, and I was

087shocked at how positive the teachers responded to the materials that they were using. And we truly, And I kept asking, it's okay. Just because I'm here as a chief academic officer, you don't have to sugarcoat it. Tell me the truth. What's been challenging? This helps us support teachers with the challenges that that you're experiencing. But it was overwhelmingly positive and especially positive response from our newest teachers who are so grateful to have these resources. So I just wanted to share that that story. And I guess I would just add that we haven't seen a lot of pushback because, all of the teachers that are doing this work, it's because they've initiated it, it has all been grown within the building, and it has been requested by the teachers in the building and the pilots. And

088so I think because they have been willing partners, we just haven't experienced, a lot of negative experiences and, we've really tried to work with them in allowing those loops for feedback. Miss Nicole told us, Miss Paulson, who is our executive director and myself, offered a couple listening sessions, in November, December, where we invited teachers from pilot schools to just, share their experiences with us. And we really asked we started out with what's been hard, and again, really predominantly other than logistical challenges or, kind of navigating what it means to have a resource that really people did not have negative things to say about it. And really felt more empowered as a teacher, felt like there was choice and creativity. And they mentioned levels of engagement from their students that they had not seen. And so

089just really powerful experiences. And so I think with that, I would just like to take an opportunity to, have our guests kind of share their experiences. And so, if you don't mind, I'm just going to start with a question for them to start from. Okay. Hi. So, whoever wants to start first, but could you maybe share a little bit about how high quality instructional materials have impacted your school and teachers and students? I think for Dunston, it has created significant alignment. We appreciate having when you guys sorry, when you guys talk, just get the mic like close to you. Sure. That'll help everybody here, including. Thank you. Okay. You got it. Okay. And Dunston has really helped to have everyone in. So all of our language arts teachers are involved in this, and that helps,

090everyone feel like that sense of camaraderie as you're trying something new. And that has been helpful for certain. It is a very meaty resource. And so it takes time to learn all the different levels and intricacies of it. And it I have really encouraged our teachers. There has been a time I remember when they were a little bit stressed about it, and they were expressing that, and they were questioning, well, why is it put together this way and that sort of thing? And I said, you know, having been a principal of a school, elementary school and secondary, and having implemented other resources before, sometimes it will take you a full calendar year, like full year of implementation before you understand the way that the resource is constructed and why it's constructed that way. And so

091please, like, be patient with yourselves. And I really applauded them for taking the risk and being brave. And I think because all of them have been in together, that has helped build that sense of camaraderie, and they're sharing their ideas and what they're learning about the resource. And so that has become really, inspiring and kind of infectious across the whole, six through 12. So, I mean, six through eight. So that has been fun to see that happen. Yeah. But that has helped. It's helped with the quality and the texts that students are enjoying. Most definitely. And the teachers still have a little bit, you know, where they can add certain things as well. And they have enjoyed that too. So, we're really working well together and working hard to give them structures such as in

092their PLCs, to sit there and share what it is that they're learning about the resource. And that way we're growing the collective knowledge within the organization of how do we do this, how do we implement it? And it really is about the intricacies and then getting to know it because it's such a meaty resource. So that's where we're coming. Coming at it. But it's been fun all the way across. Okay. I'm going to start by saying Hlah has been a breath of fresh air for our teachers. It's been a resource that's given teachers more time, more time to actually engage in how they're going to differentiate for their students, rather than spending hours looking for texts that are, looking to support all their multilingual learners that are going to be engaging, that are going to

093give choice, going to give agency, going to be culturally relevant. The announcement time, because all those resources are there for them. They can spend time of how am I going to teach us in the classroom? How am I going to give all my students individualized feedback? And that's been true for all of our grade levels, which has been really great. So for sixth, seventh and eighth grade, it's really given all of our staff and for our team coherence, a sense of belonging, and also a sense of consistency. And I really think it's been because of the implementation. So starting with coherence, it's really been about the investment. We actually started this process back in April. And what that looked like was introducing it to our Ela team in a PLC. And what that meant was

094bringing in text. Tiffany came in with us. Tiffany. Right. She came in and gave text. We explored the resource. What is the format look like? What do assessments look like? And it gave teachers a sense of relief of this is what it is. I have time to digest it. I have time to look and see what are going to be potential barriers. And it gave our teachers a sense of, belief from leadership team as well, that they were able to express the barriers and how can we overcome them over the course of the year. So with that slow roll introduction, then we as a school, as a learning lab school, we've committed to planning labs. So in May of 2024, we actually had a planning lab or all of our Ela teachers came in and

095we sat down and created, After the leadership team met, we came in and we had consistent expectations among all the grade levels. What does fidelity look like at Carmody? And then teachers were able to share suggestions, come up with kind of agreements and types and clarity for a whole school. So it didn't go into August and they had a new resource, didn't know what to do. It was, kind of a breath of fresh air to repeat that. So moving into consistency, that has been true for our leadership team because of our partnership with each MH. So we actually have biweekly coaching cycles where each image comes in with our leadership team and we go through the classrooms non evaluative really just a sense of what is fidelity look like. How are we checking in our

096cultural goals, our instructional goals? What are the team needs? What are areas of success that we can share with our teachers, and what are the next steps for implementation with these next steps? We've actually had a partnership with Tiffany where we were able to. She's been at all of our planning labs over the course of the year and coming in and saying, well, we need more time focusing on one of the online tools. Can you give us a PD on that? And then our teachers came in with questions, and it's been like such a great partnership to for our teachers to feel valued that they're going to be learning along the way. I think it was emphasized that it's a continuum there. You're not going to learn everything at once. It's going to be growth

097over time. So with that and then with, as a first year coach really pushing in and doing these quick, short coaching cycles has really allowed teachers to feel that it's not just how what they're teaching, but it's how you're teaching it. How are you giving your students feedback? How are you using this lesson, internalization in your classroom, where you can really focus in on one high leverage question and give feedback for that. And the last is a sense of belonging. We really have had a partnership with our families, our students, as well as our entire community. Back in 2024, we actually introduced this to our PTSA, our parent teacher student association, and we told them that H is coming. This is what it looks like, kind of a brief introduction and really opened up for

098questions and answers from our families. And they were able to express their concerns. What would honors look like for their student, as we did dissolve honors because each image does have all the differentiation, differentiation embedded within, as the standards are not different for freely it's all embedded within. And so that gave our parents a sense of relief going into the new year. This curriculum is going to be put out. What does that look like for my child? With that, once our teachers were settled, actually, last week, January 31st, we hosted a coffee and conversations in the morning where families came in and we gave an introduction. And what is differentiation? Differentiation look like? What is implementation look like? We, get packets and handouts and then ended up emailing to families as well. So they really

099had a chance to give questions, answers, to really help feel that partnership, the student perspective. We actually did interviews with students. Renee was also part of those interviews at one point, and we were able to get that student voice. How is it different? How is it the same? How are you learning? Students are engaged. Students love it because they feel much more connected to it. Is it hard? Yes. It's much more rigorous than the, learning that we had before. But we know it's grade level and teachers don't have to spend time looking for those grade level texts. And then we have students that are then pushed to go beyond those academic standards. But then we also have our, learning specialists working with these techs to help support students to get to grade level. This was

100actually the first time in many years that we saw our students with IEPs grow more on our maps tests, our map scores this past, winter than in the past and up over our general population of students. So it was a huge success and honor to that too. So I just wanted to say that Hlah has really given our Carmody itself coherence, belonging and consistency and high. So I'm a sixth grade teacher. I came from elementary, so I had used, in the past a long time ago, then moved to mom. We did not have, resource moved to comedy, didn't have a resource. We were making everything all by ourselves. And then we started to delve into this 22, 23, and our AP brought in five different resources, and our whole entire department went through every single

101resource. We did it for weeks, and we decided that age was definitely what our school needed. A lot of it had to do with the diversity that we had, or that they offered also, differentiation for, for our highest students and for our lower students. I myself have three team talk classes and one regular ed class. So, it's really important to have that that piece for our students. Some of the really great things is, our scores. We went from being an improvement plan school and, 2023 to we are now our prior art performance school. As of last year. And that was only one year of using it. And we saw huge growth and our free reduced lunch students and our students on IEPs. And again this year, second, our middle of year math scores have really

102increased, especially with our IEP students. It seems like that's where it's really, really hitting home for them. So, and kind of what you said, it's it's really good to have something already there that's at grade level that you can differentiate, but you're still teaching at grade level with our students. I just really enjoy it. I really the kids are loving the stories. Last year we went through we made the, the decision that we would just go through and really learn the resource. And so we didn't do any of the long reads. And this year we are implementing their long reads. We had just finished or we're about to finish one and the kids are absolutely loving it. So, the yeah, you didn't you didn't ask what was not good. Yeah. Right. Okay. The one thing

103that I do think that that we as teachers don't like is the workbooks and how they have, like, these little tiny lines down the side. So we've decided as we have them right on online piece of paper, we just have it kind of put in with the pages. We actually pull the pages out and put them into a binder so that they have the what they need with the pages. Because we really want them writing. I think students have really gotten out of the habit of actually writing. Now, we do have students that are on IEPs that do need to do the typing piece, and we allow them to do that. But, really getting them to write and write about what they're reading about is so important. And I feel like after Covid, a lot

104of that went away. And we're kind of bringing it back now, and it's really good to see that being implemented, implemented, and then being able to rise to the occasion to do that as well. So we did invite, some of our educators utilizing the other two resources. But however, you know, it's a busy time of year and, many people have evening commitments. So they could not join us this evening, but many felt very strongly about being able to share their experiences. So we do, have some teachers who wrote up, some things so we can share that with you when we're done here. I just want to also say, and if you would go to the next slide, please. This has been a really long runway. We have been doing the work with our teachers since

1052022. And so in 2022, teachers started asking, are we going to get a resource? Can we have a resource? And so a response. So that was kind of an efficacy survey. And through that survey, you know, one of the biggest things we still hear from teachers is, they just needed more support and resources for tier two. And so how do they support those differentiated needs in their classroom? And then I would say that through that efficacy survey, roughly two thirds of the teachers who responded said at that time that they would consider and definitely wanted to learn more about how high quality instructional materials, what impact them as a teacher and, and in their classrooms. The first and formal curriculum review occurred in the spring of 2023. And, it was advertised in a newsletter inviting

106people to, to join. And at that time, there were ten teachers that reviewed six resources. And from that, that group developed additional criteria from their feedback around what would they be looking for? And, and a resource, and some of the things they came back with were diverse texts, flexibility and planning, and that the resource offers teachers and students some choice. And then fast forward to last winter, January and February of 2024, the secondary Ela team hosted several virtual and in-person open house sessions to enable teachers, coaches and admin to learn more about some possible options for a pilot. Because I think at that time, people just weren't quite ready to say what we want to do this. And so we really wanted to offer an opportunity to let people try it out. And so that's

107kind of where the pilot was born out of. And then, following that, to narrow down from the multiple, the six resources had another curriculum review committee invited teachers, admin and coaches. And that's how they came up with the resources for the pilot. So, through this RFP than this year, you'll see that policy dictates that we have multiple review committees. And so, here's a slide that kind of talks about which what roles represented the committee. And you might say, why are there only two teachers? This resource review. So when we put out a call, to involve people and engaging in this process with us, they had a choice in which committee they wanted to be on. And so once we give them the purpose of each committee, many of them chose to be part of the

108content review because when you look at the resource review questions, really, the purpose of that group was to really look at is it developmentally appropriate? Is a challenging, the quality of the resources, are they affirming? Are they diverse? Can they meet the needs of a wide variety of learners? And then what opportunities are there for student application of learning? So the content review committee, that is definitely more where our teachers really wanted to be able to have a voice. And so, you can see we had a pretty big group for our content review committee member, membership. And I think behind that is because we were really looking at, if you want to switch to the next one, please, we are really looking at alignment. Is it aligned with standards? Is it aligned with Jeffco strategic

109plan? Is it aligned with the guiding principles that are I al group created what support for students learning is there around content specific practices assessments. That has been a big request from teachers is we want a resource that has assessments already built and made and editable. And then also, are the resources accurate and grounded and research and, really we also as we were selecting materials for the pilot and then even to bring forward with the RFP part of that process was just checking and reports and making sure that they had been reviewed and researched and met, a high quality standard for recommendation to receive a green rating. And ET reports. So you'll see just some of the reviewer feedback trends from all of the resources. And this was really just around what teachers had identified

110where their criteria, when they were looking at the resources. So you'll see teacher friendliness, student engagement, and then curriculum quality. So you can just spend a second and kind of read via those bullet points. And then ultimately, after we had had the three different committee recommendations, here's kind of where things balanced out. So the top is Chavez, and then and McGraw Hill and, you know, McGraw Hill had more mixed reviews. I think for a variety of reasons. And, I think some of it was in the review, it wasn't clear to reviewers, teachers and instructional coaches and admin, the role novel study had in the resource. And and Jeff co novel study is a big part and our secondary Ela classrooms and that just wasn't as evident. I think for some of our teachers. And then

111I would also say that I think, on the surface for McGraw Hill, the print resources are kind of difficult to navigate. And so I think just the approachability for teachers kind of gave more negative reviews. However, you know, I think especially for our middle school teachers, it it is very appealing to our high school teachers, just in general. Yeah. Vibe. What is the yellow it says recommend with our observations. So really all three resources, have some similarities. Overall, they all have a full, well aligned standards based curriculum, middle school through high school. There's thematic units. But the central questions a variety of genres with both. You mentioned the short and long reads. They all have digital tools that accompany them with assessments. There's much more content in any of the resources than any teacher could

112ever use in a school year. So it provides a lot of choice, flexibility and autonomy that our teachers are looking for. And because there has, it has so much more content there. We've had many of our like our learning specialists, our interventionist being being able to pick up the core materials and pre teach or pull the extra things out to do intervention work or some pre teaching a vocab gallery. And so they can also use it in those ways. And it stays aligned to core instruction. One thing I would say is we have had concerns from some teachers about this, this notion of scripted curriculum and how it does take that flexibility and autonomy away. I think you heard clearly here that there's many ways that teachers can approach the use of these resources. So

113that's not lost for them. I think one of the greatest benefits with all three is that it does provide a variety of genres. It is highly engaging, and it provides a well paced scope and sequence for teachers to follow. But it does give them much choice and how they approach the instruction with their students, how they make it come to life. Quite honestly, we know that our universities don't prepare our teachers to be curriculum designers. They don't have a single class and curriculum design and developing scope and sequence that is not their their skill set. They are great at delivering instruction and building relationships and students, and creating engagement and robust learning experiences that are matched to student needs. And that's what having these materials allows them to do. It is the floor. It is

114not the ceiling. So we are working closely with the teachers here and others to really understand their experience so that as we make these recommendations, we can come up here tonight with all of you and make them with full confidence. And while there may be some questions or observations, there's not a perfect resource. None of our resources are going to have every single thing that our teachers need. And as you go through and you learn the resource, you realize that there are places where we might need to supplement, our places that we feel like this isn't that valuable for our students. But I will tell you that, and you heard a few comments about it tonight, that one of the places where it is so important for students to have high quality curriculum, resources are

115students from, most economic backgrounds, because often those families aren't able to supplement students background knowledge and make up for a lack of rigor and alignment that occurs when teachers are building things on their own, in isolation, or just in one grade level, and one school that's not vertically aligned to a scope and sequence that builds in complexity over time, that creates gaps for students, and some of our more disadvantaged students and families aren't able to make up for that, with visits to a museum or family vacations to Egypt or things that provides a lot of that background knowledge and content, rich experiences that are there so students can overcome some of those gaps when they're created in our schools, when we don't have that alignment. And so some of our most disadvantaged students benefit the

116most from having these resources. And so we are here tonight to really advocate for what our students need the most. It's important that we create the magic for our teachers so they can create the magic for our students. But truly, my concern and our concern is making sure our students are getting what they deserve. And they deserve a well planned, thoughtfully paced, standards aligned, rigorous, relevant, and meaningful learning experience. And no single teacher can provide that completely and consistently over time. So. Here on the slide, you'll see what we are proposing to move forward. As a system, we're very focused on continuing to implement, secondary Ela materials in our middle schools next year. I think we've got 20 of our 25 middle schools that are asking us to move forward with all of their grades

117at the middle level. We are not imposing this on any school. This is purely choice in we are making this available. Providing the supports for the people that are opting in. Teachers aren't ready yet or would like to see more evidence or visit classrooms of people that are using these materials. We're providing those opportunities because readiness is critical. Our teacher readiness and mindset around this is critical. And when we're ready to support that for as long as we need to, with the expectation that kids are getting what they deserve and we're we, we are ready to provide it. And you can kind of see how we're looking at doing this over time. With cohorts of schools coming on each year. Okay, so just to wrap up, I'll give some time. I'm sure you have some

118questions that you'd like to ask us, but we are seeking approval to add these resources to our approved list, and to authorize our director of purchasing to go into contracts so that we can purchase for cohort one next year. Questions? Can we answer for you? Yeah. All right. First, thank you so much. And, Renee, you know that this has been near and dear to my heart from the moment I stepped onto this board. And I did have a chance to review the materials that we have for our high schools. And, I really do think that for our high school teachers who may be feeling, a bit worried about it, it is absolutely recognizable. Ela curriculum. They will look at it and they will go, yeah, this this is this is what we do. And and

119what we'll see is that it what it does is it provides that consistency. And, the consistency in the experience and the standards. And I think that that's going to be a really important thing. And also the alignment, you know, the fact that we've aligned everything, you know, by the time we finish with this will be aligned. K12, which we haven't been in decades, and yet, I think is really important. I will say that when I have done my school visits and I've asked in schools that are piloting how they feel about it, this this was not the first time I heard the workbook concerns. And, and the reason that I kind of want to bring that up is in my 30 years of teaching, we went through umpteen different workbooks for different things and generally

120did not find them helpful, and often just ended up spending a fortune on them and then not using them. So, if it turns out that these are just extra stuff that really, is a distraction and not helpful, does it work without them? Is that something that teachers could ultimately say, I'm going to opt out of this, or is it really critical and they just need more time to work it out? I'm curious about that. Yeah. I'll let Kathryn talk about her experience with the workbooks as well. But, one of the things we've talked to our vendors about, I think all of them, all of the materials are available digitally. There are black line masters. And so, yes, the school could opt to pick and choose what they want to copy or print or load into

121Google Classroom. I think ultimately when you compare it to cost student workbooks, are about $6.50. And so most of our vendors have said if you use, at least 40% of the workbook, it equates to the cost, by copying costs. And so I think Catherine can kind of share how they have adapted to use the workbook and, and why they are still valuable. So we actually just talked about this in our PLC is on Tuesday. We were talking about the use of the workbook and we are really pushing in on, you know, making notes. And what is the one annotating? Thank you. Annotating, and making sure the students know how to annotate. You know, you have those students that will highlight every single thing. And I said, if you highlight everything, nothing's important. And so really

122teaching them what the important things are to annotate, is all part of the lesson as well. Annotating is actually taught in a time age. And then also having them write the little note so that they know why they highlighted it. So really getting them used to doing that. So we did decide, even though we're not using the little lines for them to write, because it's just not enough. We use line paper. We have a ton of it. We're not making copies that way. And the kids are learning how to take notes as well. So they're annotating their answering those, like, analysis questions that come with the reading. And then at the end, there's also like five analysis questions that they have to do text analysis, that are really end up. And then they can use

123what they've already written, from those side side notes in the, in the book, to help them with those bigger questions, longer, answers and things like that. So we did choose to keep it, keep the keep the book. Oh, good to know. And part of it for me was that I didn't have a chance to look at those, workbooks and, when I was teaching, we actually purchased, like, cheap versions of books to teach annotation to our students, and to teach them not to highlight everything, and that you actually do have to write something in the margin or the highlighter is of no use to you. So, so no, I'm it is helpful to know that that's the purpose of that. That helps a lot. I'm also wondering, were there any other themes in those recommended with

124reservation yellow sections that we saw? Were there were there some fairly common reservations that showed up? Yes. And I think, some of them were, I think around usability. I think some of some of the workbooks, felt like it was a lot. And how would they prioritize what to use and when. And then I think some of the reservations were around, the long reads. And when does that fit in? What does that look like if this is the unit? And really, all of the vendors have the same approach, which is you just extend the unit to include a long read. And then I think the other, I just lost it. I'm sorry, was I don't know if Robin and Tiffany want to jump in and jog my memory. Yeah. What we found was that a lot

125of the reservations had to do with the fact that this was a first introduction, to these high quality instructional materials. So some of that was like that disorienting feeling of not being able to find, exactly what it was that they were looking for within that time period of the review committee. As Jennifer said, it's meaty. Right. And so, without training attached to those committees, many if they had had the training, many of those reservations maybe would have gone aside. So there was some of that, like disorienting that happened. And so also with that, just understanding the design of the resource, two of the resources are designed in a very and similar kind of way. And studies in particular, has just had a different structure that really speaks to our high school teachers. And it didn't

126speak as well to our middle school teachers. However, I think over time, with appropriate implementation, you begin to understand the design and those reservations would also go away. Other questions? Yep. I would like to add just a little bit something that we're talking about as we wrap up this pilot this year is working with our pilot school teachers to really understand the elements within each resource that they want to recommend to the next cohort of teachers and bring it on, as they must use to really help us lift up the components they felt like were really critical, important and valuable for their students and then others where they felt like it or not. Maybe something you want to consider supplementing. So we're really going to be leaning into these folks, and helping us make the

127rest of the recommendations to the rest of the system as new teachers come on board. Thank you. I'm I'm actually excited when we get to have conversations like this about social studies. But, I'm curious about, you know, you have three different options that you've presented here, and, why three? Why is it not just one or why isn't five? Why are there five resources? Can you help me understand that? Maybe I think I've wondered two. Because I think, but what came through from teachers was choice. And so I think through the pilot, we've really learned a lot about what makes up each resource. And so I think when Tiffany and Robin, they've been doing a lot of, visits to schools and bringing all the resources, and so they're able to tap in, like, what are your

128values here? And so that kind of starts the conversation and how they enter into a resource. And so I think ultimately it just came down to choice. Yeah. Is there an idea that maybe some of these options are going to lean more middle school and other options are going to lean more high school? Yes. For example, because we still have a lot of questions about studies, I think at the middle school level and particular, and that's where it's been less embraced. We are not going to have that included for middle schools next year. Because we feel we only have two schools pilot at only one is a middle school. And so we just need to learn more before we can comfortably say to a school, that's why this might be a good fit for you.

129And my other question is, is that, as you mentioned, an already approved list, we want to add these three resources to an already approved list. Can you just review for me? What else is, yeah, I wasn't talking about secondary Ela necessarily, but just overall for our core resources, we have the list that you've approved over time that we would add this to with the other like for math okay. Okay. Excellent. Thank you. And then my my last question is I remember going to curriculum night at Carmody. With my seventh grader being super excited that they were going to have a choice between two, not a novel, read. Whether it was the habit and something else. And clearly I knew what my option would have been if I got to vote on it. But I'm wondering

130how much space there is for variation between teachers in the same building. If you have two seventh grade or three seventh grade teachers, are they all going to ultimately end up teaching the same novel? Reader? Is there space for them to do variation and still they're still going to be addressing? I know, state standards and and various things, but I'm just wondering around variation, and if that ever extends in the future to, school using two curriculums and having someone use an eighth grade and one is in seventh grade, my hope is that on a grade level they would be using similar resource. But, I just want to know a little bit about how having three options means that we have variation, across our, in our schools or across the district. I think I'd like Miss

131Pinnell to, to speak to this as well, but I would also, share that I wouldn't. We're thinking a lot about, continuity for students. And if we think about our, our elementary schools within certain articulation areas using and to reading in to reading for elementary, I would be apt to recommend at the middle level for continuity for those students, especially in our dual language schools. A big driver for the elementary adoption was the diverse texts and the translanguaging that was available within each to our lectura and arriba lectura for each. And so some of those nuances we want to consider it best to let our principals know of their elementary feeders that are using a specific resource, so they can take that into consideration. I would never really recommend using a different resource by grade, like

132within a school, just for continuity sake, but I know there is room for supplementing novels. Within the Green Mountain area. Our elementary schools are using MH, and I think they're a couple years into their implementation. So I would agree that you need to stick with the similar resource. And I wrote down as you were talking just that consistency and coherence piece for student learning. And if you have, say, two seventh grade language arts teachers and two teachers at each grade level, you want the kids coming out of that with similar learning experiences where it's equitable across both teachers, having experienced similar resources, they may have different styles or approaches, which I think this resource absolutely allows for that kind of freedom, for sure. But similar learning, conceptual learning, I think that leads to just that

133consistency for the kids across, grade levels and across teachers. So we value that. And our teachers, within our school, really value that aligned plan planning time together, including our learning specialist too, so that it's all across all together. I could I just can I follow up on that? I'm sorry. I just want to make sure I really understand. I appreciate all of the work you guys are doing. And for the non educator up here, sometimes it comes a little off of my head. So if. Could a teacher, so could both teachers decide. Hey, we really love this novel. That's going to meet the same requirements of the curriculum but isn't list in the curriculum. Could they use that? I will say that all resources have, pretty extensive novel lists, so it's not like there's one.

134Right? And so, schools can choose their novels. And I think just back to your question, Director Kenworthy, I think, yes, there is choice. And I think a teacher could choose multiple novels for their long read and have small groups. Because really, what we need it, we want it to be is aligned to the essential question of the unit. And so and even if there was a whole class reading the same novel, most middle schools, I think, also have an independent reading novel that kids that are reading, often in parallel or after, you know, that, you know. So yes, there's a lot of opportunity for choice. I think we would recommend that as a grade level, you know, can you choose novels that you want to teach, which I think already happens? But I mean, I

135think ultimately, I have a seventh grade student as well. And, I what I have learned about his, middle school Ela experience is that, nothing is guaranteed. It's not in Jeffco, you know, without high quality instructional materials. I could if you went to Carmody, he probably would have read a different novel. Not anchored to an essential question and had a totally different experience and how they approach. And, so I think that, for example, you know, his experience was read a novel and, from October to January, he's been in the unit. That's a long time. So, you know, again, I, I just think this quote is so powerful from a teacher as teachers should be pilots, not engineers. They give the plane direction and manage the crew. They don't need to be fixing engines and designing planes.

136Yeah. I'll I'll come back. I, I kind of had a similar question. I was just curious, because I've heard some teachers talk about, how they're evaluated related to the curriculums. And so I just wondered, like, how are teachers evaluated, related to the curriculum, especially observations of how they're implementing them, say, in the classroom and, and do they get penalized? You know, you've said there's some degrees of freedom. Do they get penalized for going further out on those degrees of freedom than other teachers? Does go ahead. I know that when we're doing walkthroughs in terms of gathering information around fidelity of implementation, it's definitely not evaluative. And it's always, connected to what our teachers asking for the feedback on and then what feedback do they want to go to the next step? As a former principal

137who implemented a resource, you know, part of the rubric talks about using curricular materials that are aligned. And and so, you know, that is really the only place connected in the rubric, in terms of also planning. And so I don't know that, for me, there's a space in evaluation to evaluate a teacher, implementation of a resource. And that is certainly what, we've been working with our school leaders and the pilot around. And, you know, Jennifer, as a principal, can speak to the practice at Dunston, but, we would say that that is not best practice. And that, you know, it needs to be non evaluative and qualitative to help ensure fidelity. Otherwise what's the point of a resource? I say Aspen? Because some folks have said, oh it's canned. So if they there. But I think

138what you're saying is it's not a best practice, but they are not. There's no penalty for a teacher to flex on how they implement or use the curriculum, or the resource can I I think that varies depending depending on the building agreements. Most schools are working with their school academic leadership team to decide, you know, this is our instructional program. These are our instructional agreements. This is what we're committing to. We're bringing this this resource on. Here's our expectations and what how we're going to hold ourselves accountable. So if if there's been an agreement like that at the school, which I would hope for and expect, then I would expect that teachers would be honoring that agreement. Obviously there's, you know, support needed, hopefully reaching out and asking and feeling safe to do so certainly

139isn't an expectation that it's perfect at all. But obviously going along with that, school agreements and commitments. So, I've actually had a chance to look at the materials, and I think that, people who are saying that it's canned are people who haven't actually looked at it yet and they're making assumptions because there is such variety, even around an essential question, you have several different choices of stories that you can choose from. You have several different activities that you can choose from, and you can mix and match within that to the way that fits your style and your students. So I think some of the concern, I think people just are assuming that it's the old fashioned basal reader where you, you know, you have this story and you have these seven questions and that and

140it is not like that at all. So I think when people have a chance to really dig into it, they're going to find it's not the scripted thing that they think it is. So if and this might be more a question for Superintendent Dahlen. So if we have three options they can pick from, and we know we're bringing in 12 schools, how are we deciding which how many of each to buy or have schools already indicated to us from a purchasing standpoint? Yeah. We've been engaging in interest. So after we had had the review committees on January 6th on the teacher work day, we, had a day long open house, and invited interested school staff, teachers, coaches, principals to come and review all the materials. Tiffany and Robyn were on hand to answer any questions.

141I think we had more than 30 educators attend that open house and review the materials. And so, after that, we then had a principal informational meeting, on January 27th, where we really shared the logistics, the readiness, asking principals, is your staff ready for this? Have you done the work to build the why together? Why do we want this? And we have been very, very, vocal about, like, you can't do this if your teachers are on board. It's not going to we learned it's not going to work. And so, really supporting principals as needed. And we've also offered them multiple entry points in terms of you choose between the two resources. And if you have one grade level who is on board, start with that grade level. And so principals have been able to work with

142their staff about who's ready. And so and then we've asked for a commitment. And so far, we have, I think six schools committed for next year, about half and half, and seventh. And then through that we've just asked, how many sections do you have, 25, 30 for a class set. And then I think for a pilot schools as well. We're not going to order materials, they're not going to use. And so also giving them some we want this, but we don't want to use this. And knowing that some things are bundled and we don't really have control over. But no, that's really helpful. My last one is maybe more of a thought. I'm very impressed with the amount of work that Carmody did to educate parents and teachers and and bring everyone together. Is that,

143like a best practices that you're sharing with other schools that are piloting? That's a great question. And actually is, something that we've had multiple middle schools now reaching out. Emily Jobson, who unfortunately can be your chair, our principal, created this model last year when it's her first year. Principal kind of created this model to use. And we've actually implemented with our science curriculum as well. We took on twig, and implemented it mid-year. So January, our science team was so jealous, you would say, of our Ela team and our math team for having a curriculum. It's like, well, you have time to actually spend on how you're going to teach your students and how you're going to differentiate for them. So it has been a model that we're using, and we are continuously sharing and always

144open doors. So yeah that's great. Thank you. We're trying to promote those as well here in the guidebook or a playbook as far as best practices around a curriculum implementation. As we learn and get better at this, we're trying to lift up those things to. Well, a lot of questions have been asked and answered, so I appreciate that. Just a couple quick things. We did get a few emails and we did get the, idea or the question about whether it's banning books is, is, a an essential book, then could that be because up to this point, the teachers didn't have a curriculum that they had to follow. And so they have their favorite books, and now they're thinking, oh, I can't use them anymore. I believe that's a lot of it. Autonomy is alive and

145well, and it is a deeply held value in Jeffco. And there's nothing wrong with that. The more we do this, the more we understand that and know that we need to leverage teacher voice and autonomy and choice throughout this process. And we're getting we're getting smarter about that. I know Catherine was talking earlier tonight about how she spent thousands of her own dollars every year, buying books for her classroom and building out units on her own time. There's there's a lot of investment when you put in that kind of, you know, time and money and your heart. And so it's hard to let go of those things. And so we, we respect that and honor that where people are. So yeah, I think that's a lot of it. Thank you. There was another comment by

146several, people that emailed us about wanting a neutral third party to do the evaluation. Has the district ever used third parties? I would refer them to Ed reports, where that is a neutral third party that reviews, all of the resources in the curriculum that we had, available for teams to review. That's one resource. We also brought in Johns Hopkins University researchers, a few years, not 3 or 4 years ago, to review when we were looking at curriculum adoption for the elementary school. And they did do a review at that time for us. So we have brought people in, in the past to do those things for us. But there are a lot of external reviewers out there already that are reviewing curriculum that we do resource and pull from. Okay. Thanks. And the last question

147is, the, cost of the three that you have listed on, slide 19, is that based on what you said, people six school have signed up and and so there are like all these resources similar in their price. It's just the number of schools that would be using them. Yes. Yeah. And then since this is still on a kind of pilot ramp up phase, then eventually we'll be paying more each year because more schools will be using them. Yes. I think some of our, vendors who have been very close partners with us, have offered, you know, in exchange for because novels for experience, for example, one of our vendors is giving us two novels per teacher classes. And so, you know, we want to make sure that teachers have their choice of novels and then that

148we're also, going to support them and that so that schools really are not bearing any costs for this. And again, also evaluating, I think from the pilot and then the next cohort to inform, do we want to continue, supplying workbooks and when the, if the cost does ever go back to the school that they can prioritize to and really know, what do we want to make sure, that we have the budget for? Okay, great. Sorry, I didn't really get to ask all of my questions. I have a couple of elementary school teachers have mentioned, I don't know what the right word is like there. Well, they, they the phonics section of it and kind of displeasure with that area and looking for alternatives to it. Have you all heard this and what's your what are

149your thoughts on the Sonics? I'm assuming you're talking about the elementary level yet all elementary. Yeah. It's interesting timing. When we mentioned to reading was adopted several years ago when CDE came out and required all school districts to adopt a comprehensive core literacy resource that was on their approved list, and they, of course, have their own committees and vetting process and review of reviews. And at that time, it was just before the science of reading all of that started to come out. It was just before, months before. And so we had just gone to the CCDs approved list. We've done our review process, decided we would bring on each image, purchased each image, and then all of the science of reading stuff kicked off and our teachers were taking the training. We had just adopted

150this resource that was aligned to past practice of balanced literacy, and all of the curricular resources at that time were aligned to balanced literacy. And so it took all of our publishing, our vendors to, revise their resources so that it was aligned to the science of reading practices, which is also down. And so they now have a new foundational skills. It's called structured literacy. Section. That is much better. It's it's based on letters, if you may or may not be familiar, but letters is one of the, trainings that teachers can do that can take the place of the science of reading training because it's very high quality as far as foundational skills. And so I mentioned to reading at the elementary level that foundational skills was, much more based on a reader's workshop and balanced

151literacy approach. And it's now been revised to align very well the science of reading. It's much more stirring. It's much better than it used to be. So we are recommending it to our schools moving forward, and so we can move away from kind of what I call a patchwork quilt, of the ways we approach instruction. So and just providing schools the support they need to, to do that. Two of the teachers that spoke to me about it were from this year. So talking about the use of it this year just in may not be using the new one yet. The structured literacy. Many schools had already started using Arden Gillingham OG for your foundational skills instruction because the original for me wasn't solid and the schools that were doing that were very happy with that

152approach and we didn't push them to change that. They felt like they were getting results with that approach. And so we didn't ask them to change. Some of our schools did change. We had some schools take on the new, structured literacy component of MH, but we left that up to schools to decide. And now continuing that conversation ongoing, and it sounds like some are going more towards OG training more at least give them one example. Yeah. And it's high quality pedagogy is not meant to be a core instructional piece. It can tend to be too slow for some students. It is meant to truly be an intervention it was designed for originally for students with dyslexia. To really support that intensive intervention need it can be used and has been revised as well to be

153more of a core program. But now that structured literacy with MH has become so much stronger, we're recommending that if you're a schools ready, do that because you also have this, additional cost. With OG, it's really expensive. It's 1500 and $2,000 per teacher to train for that. And if you have a teacher leave and now that's your core approach. You've got to find the dollars every year to retrain staff to be able to use that as your core program, where you wouldn't have that additional cost. So there's a sustainability component with doing OG is your core foundational skills. That's also, not as realistic for some schools. And I had one principal tell me they went to OG and that just become better. So yeah, yeah, I just wanted to say I've also heard about the

154workbooks. But one teacher said that she has like a tool that draws the lines, you know, she got like on Amazon. It, it it just like on blank pieces of paper, you can make the lines. So that's one way they've adjusted the workbook. But and I was looking because one of the emails we got, they said, you know like where's the research on this. And I'm a researcher. So I was looking at all peer reviewed, journal articles and there's just almost nothing. And I was so shocked, like, why is there no one doing, you know, this peer reviewed research? I'm sure these other firms are. But it was funny, I did when you were talking about writing, I did find an article and I just pulled it back up. It says The Science of, reading

155is incomplete without the science of writing. And so things about writing and the need for that as well. So when you mention that, it reminded me of one of the articles I brought, I saw, but I really can't find like peer reviewed, articles. A lot of people aren't studying these particular curriculums, more like curriculum in general. And, you know, randomized trials and things like this, but not really. It's very difficult to find anything on any one of these. Yeah. Okay. Well, thank you very much. This is, very informative and it looks really exciting. And as, director Reed said, it's very wonderful that we have something now at the, secondary level and, that it's got some good consistency. So thank you. All right. For our next agenda item this evening, the board will receive a presentation

156regarding the district's work related to long term planning recommendations for the Jefferson Junior Senior Articulation Area. On January 28th, 2025, the district held its first of four planned community engagement meetings to discuss the Jefferson Articulation Area. Small secondary student population, with a specific emphasis on expanding opportunities for Jefferson area students. Before I turn this over to Mr. Lou and Mr. Carr, is there anything you'd like to add? Superintendent Dawson, I just want to, thank director Reed for being with us last week at the community meeting where this same information was shared with the Jefferson junior senior community. It was, not an easy meeting. But I do believe it was an honest and respectful meeting. We did a lot of listening. We did a lot of presenting to try to explain some of the ideas we

157were bringing forward to the community for consideration, and then we did a lot of listening. And so thanks for being there, to hear and listen as well. And, as for Lou and Mr. Carr, I'm going to hand it over to you to share the presentation and and lead the discussion. Thank you for having us this evening. And I'm going to hand this over to, Claire to car. Is our executive director of strategy, and she is going to take you all through the presentation that we presented, to the Jefferson community last, Tuesday night, I believe it was, I do want to just say thank you to all of our, Jefferson area principals who came and supported, their communities and answered questions. And then a special thank you to our Wheat Ridge principals who also attended and

158were able, especially, Mr. Mayor Hannah and Miss Juliette, who were able to address, the, some questions about their schools and how they could potentially be welcoming, to Jefferson families. So we still have a lot of work to do. We're right at the very beginning of this process. I do want to say, as, Mr. Carr will present to you all, you know, in the past, we've had to go into a community and tell them that the work was urgent and we didn't have time to make decisions together. We do have time in this instance. With the help of Flow Analytics, who did our boundary study, we were able to really take a look and closely understand what's happening in our communities and give ourselves the runway to have these types of conversations that we haven't had

159the opportunity to have in the past, so that I'll hand it over to Claire. Thank you. As, Mr. Lee was, naming we had this presentation with community, last Tuesday on January 28th. And I'll echo what she shared with the community, which is we have the opportunity to, engage with community in a different kind of discussion. And still the content in this presentation, just to acknowledge, can be difficult. There's a lot of information. We've done our best to lay out the data that we have and lay out the, you know, how declining enrollment can cause some of the dynamics and programing that we see at the school. And, this is still a school that students love and that staff pour their hearts out at every single day. And leaders lead with a great deal of integrity

160and vision. And so as we have this with community, we're looking forward to multiple meetings so that we can have time to process the information and time to acknowledge that, it may have an emotional impact as well as, even if it comes with the opportunity to make a plan together. There's still some processing and most importantly, what we shared with the communities that we, we, we believe we share the same goal, which is that for students who attend Jefferson Junior senior, for every single student in the Jefferson articulation area, we want to provide the best opportunities that Jeffco can offer. And this plan is an opportunity to come together with community and figure out how we can do that. In an area where enrollment declines have been particularly acute. So the objectives of the community

161information session that we facilitated on January 28th were, first, just to provide some context in history, we know that not every family member looks at enrollment projections every year, for example. And so we wanted to make sure that we were providing all of that contextual information. We also wanted to share information about enrollment in particular, and share the draft plan that we came to community with as an idea to help move forward. And we wanted to make sure that community members understood that this was an information session. Yes, we we've titled it that specifically so that, if folks would recognize that this is a time to hear information and ask questions and get clarity. And in future meetings, we are designing agendas that are really high on engagement and hearing community voice and solving problems

162together. And we wanted to make sure that we had an opportunity to answer questions about the draft plan, about any of the information that we've presented so far. So this is the schedule for community engagement. January 28th was that information session, as I mentioned, on February 11th, March 3rd and March 31st, we'll be facilitating these co-design sessions. Again. These are places where we want community to understand that these are places to share ideas and come up with solutions. We're going to have chart paper and sticky notes and dots and find ways to, have conversations about this draft plan in terms of and then we'll, recap what we've heard through these co-design sessions and share next steps on April 30th. And so that would be more like an information session where we're sharing back, and answering

163questions in terms of a timeline for board action. If we find that there support for this plan, that we can build something with community that there's genuine excitement about and momentum for, then in that case, district staff would follow policy fkb and we would, bring something to the Board of Education as a recommendation, likely in June or in August of 2025, regardless of when, we would bring that recommendation, it would affect the 2627 school year. So there's a pretty significant runway here to contemplate. Next steps in engage community on these questions. So getting into some of the the context, one thing that is, very apparent, from our community conversation and from if you've spent any time in the schools that there's a very proud history in the Jefferson articulation area. It's been a school, since

164the 1950s doing some deep reading. I think it actually might have been a school that was created through a merger with another high school. And they've very proudly educated generations of saints. They have what I understand as a best in class wrestling program, and an incredibly vibrant and proud community. And our present challenge is the declining enrollment trends that have affected our entire district. Now, after decades of declining enrollment, the Jefferson Articulation Area is serving the fewest number of students in Jeffco. Ten years ago, there were over 2200 students, PK 12, in that articulation area, and today it's over 1400. So the decline has been pretty significant. And it's our smallest articulation area. As we've looked at this over the last couple of years, we've engaged with, some external researchers to help us understand the

165trends, help us understand what's going on. And, both of those studies came to the same conclusion, which is that the enrollment declines will continue in the Jefferson area. The first study was done by the Colorado Futures Center in May of 2023. This was a joint session with the Edgewater City Council and our Board of Education. And the second one was our boundary study, which, completed in June of 2024 by our partners, Flow Analytics. And in that boundary study, our partners in looking at the Jefferson Articulation Area, raised some really serious concerns about its sustainability and sustainability to us. So one of the recommendations in that boundary study was that we should look at our October cap this year. And if we saw evidence that the enrollment, declines were in line with what Flow was predicting,

166that we should engage the community in a conversation about what the future could look like for the Jefferson Articulation area. When we look at this area kind of going deeper to each school, we see that at the elementary level, enrollment is stable. So the two elementary schools are Lumberg and Edgewater, and they both have, you know, relatively stable enrollment. This is largely due to the closure and consolidation of more home into Lumberg Elementary as part of phase one. So this year we see that Lumberg is serving over 500 students, and they're using, you know, a lot of, a lot of space in their building. And so we can say that they're they're pretty steady. Edgewater, the other elementary school, is serving over 300 students, and they also have what we'd call a healthy utilization, nearly

16780%. Thank you. We're going to get the cursor back on the slide. So my clicker works. Well. Thank you. Yeah. Great. So the elementary enrollments looks stable. However, when we look at the, junior senior, Jefferson, junior senior, it is the lowest enrolled secondary school in Jeffco. And we're expecting that it will have fewer and fewer students every year. This is both based on Coe's internal projections as well as the projections at those two external firms. Help us to look at through those external studies. So the enrollment history is pretty interesting. There was a time, in the 20 1415 school year where the school was still a 912. And so 912, that enrollment was pretty low, 489 students at that time. There was a decision made to reconfigure it into a 712 support, the declining enrollment

168at that time. And so in the 20 1516 school year, enrollment jumped up to 731 students, 712 versus 912, as of last Tuesday or two Tuesdays ago when we, presented this to the community, it served 629 students, grades seven through 12. And when we look at our enrollment projections, we expect that in four years, enrollment projections will only it'll only serve 447 students in grades seven through 12. So it's a very, very small secondary school. And the result of this declining enrollment is that Jefferson Junior senior just has reduced programing options compared to other high schools, other middle schools and other multilevel schools. So its current model is what we would call a comprehensive high school program. And comprehensive high school programs are really designed to offer a wide range of academic, elective and activities

169to students. And they can do that typically because they've got lots of students, 1500 students. And so because they have so many students, they can offer lots of options. With the current model, Jefferson Junior senior doesn't have enough students to offer all the programing options that students typically desire. And so illustrating this, if you think about academic and elective classes, any given class requires a certain number of students to run. So if a school is small, there might not be enough students who are interested in less common electives. And so as a result, that elective is an offered and students don't have that opportunity. This is also true for athletics and activities. Sports band clubs often require, you know, a certain number of students in order for it to be engaging. A good example is

170a basketball team, right. There's a opportunity to run a girls basketball team, but there's only seven girls on the school who are interested. If you know one of them is sick and the other one sprained ankle, then that's tough for the season. And so that is part of what Jefferson Junior senior is experiencing. And they're able to offer fewer course options and fewer, athletics activities than other schools. And we do see this reflected in families enrollment decisions too. So when we look at our choice out data. So this is, you know, examining every student who lives in the Jefferson junior senior boundary. We see that nearly half of families are choice, enrolling in a different middle school or high school. Looking deeper at that data, most of the families who are choosing a different school

171are choosing larger middle or high schools that are nearby, such as Wheat Ridge and Lakewood. Over years, the district has been providing additional resources, but these additional resources haven't solved this core problem caused by declining enrollment. So, out of its, student based budgeting formula, Jefferson receives additional district funding for at risk students. I received funding for alternative education and career and technical programs, and from state and federal sources. It's received over $7.8 million in additional dollars over the last decade, including title one, to help support Jefferson's programing and outcomes. These resources haven't, reversed the enrollment declines. And so the patterns that we've that I've just spoken about have continued. We also know that the community has called for change. So over the last decade and more, we've heard calls for shifts at Jefferson to to

172address some of these issues. Once our boundary study was published in June of 2024, the Edgewater Collective responded to it and said, you know, without blaming the staff and schools without blaming hardworking educators, we need to acknowledge that Jefferson needs renovation and redesign, naming that incremental changes simply haven't worked. And so we recognize that these patterns are not the fault of anyone. They're not the fault of anyone in the schools, not the students, not the staff. And yet change is needed, because the current trajectory is putting the school, at a place where it might be too small to function. So Jeff Coe's response to the community is really embedded in this process. That, that we're discussing, we know in the past, couple of years, Jeff just closed 21 schools due to very, small size due

173to declining enrollment. At that time, the problems were so urgent that we didn't have the opportunity to engage with the community about what to do with the problem. Now, because we have the foresight, we've been studying this and we've been looking ahead. We do have some runway where we can engage with the community about a conversation about their interests, how we could design a solution together. And we don't have an infinite amount of time. We know that enrollment declines will continue. We also don't have an infinite number of resources. We have to be extremely clear about what's sustainable and what we can ensure that we're standing up to support students for a very long time. So we are exploring this idea with community. We are facilitating these three co-design sessions that I mentioned earlier so

174that we can work on a plan together. And then on April 30th, we'll come back to community and share what we've heard and some next steps. So our hope through this process is that, families and students will see some of the ideas that we've come up with. They'll talk with each other and, and they'll catch fire. Right. There's going to be so much excitement about some of the opportunities that we have, and we're ready to put in front of students that they're ready to move forward with us. And in that case, will incorporate the community's ideas and feedback into our draft plan and bring that back to, you, the Board of Education, to take action. And in that case, Jefferson Junior-Senior would change its programing. And as a result, students will have access to more

175opportunities. On the other hand, the fear is that nothing changes if we, can't align on a draft plan that reflects the community's interests and, and allows us to move forward, then Jefferson Junior senior will, remain as it is and continue to rightsize its staff and programing to match the number of students it has. And because we're projecting continued enrollment declines, that might lead to a place where Jefferson Junior senior grows increasingly unsustainable and there might come a time where we need to take more urgent action in the future. So let's talk about the vision, right? These ideas that we are hoping, the community will fall in love with to. So our vision for the Jefferson Articulation Area is that we can maintain and strengthen elementary programing that we can provide for every single student in

176the Jefferson area. A magical middle school experience for students in grades six through eight, and that every single student will have access to a robust and comprehensive high school experience for grades nine through 12. In addition, we want to invest in an innovative and local, community driven and career focused high school option where students, if they are interested and excited, they could choose to go there to have access to some of these really unique opportunities. And as a result, every student in Jefferson is getting more of these amazing opportunities as a result of this draft plan. So the draft plan that we've proposed for the community is to merge the Jefferson and Wheat Ridge articulation areas. So this means that in the 2627 school year, all Jefferson students would have guaranteed enrollment at Lumberg or

177Edgewater based on their address. And this would be for grades preschool through fifth grade. The schools are currently preschool through sixth grade. All students would have access to Everett Middle School, for grades six through eight with transportation eligibility, and then all students in grades nine through 12 would have guaranteed enrollment at We Ridge High School with transportation eligibility as well, so that every student has guaranteed access to, these opportunities. I've named. In addition, as soon as the 2728 school year, we would, open an option to attend a high school focused career connected learning experience that's operating out of the junior senior facility. So we'd be putting a high quality and innovative option in students backyards so that they can access this as well. So the timeline would be the 2526 school year, would be the

178final year for the 712 program at Jefferson Junior Senior. It would also be the final year for sixth grade at Lambert and Edgewater. In the 2627 school year, Lumberg and Edgewater would serve students in grades preschool through five. Everett Middle School would serve students in grades six through eight, and We Ridge High School would serve students in grades nine through 12. Then, during the 2627 school year, we would likely, depending on what we put in the building, we would likely need time to do some renovations and time to plan, for that school. So Jefferson Junior Senior Facility would be close in the 2627 school year, with the goal to open as soon as the 2728 school year. So in terms of we've talked about this high school option in the Jefferson facility, we have been

179looking at some school models that could fit a couple of design criteria. And so this is what we'll start talking with community about on February 11th, is understanding their interest in some of these models that I'll, that I'll show you. So with support of researchers, we explored some models across the country that are delivering high quality instruction and extraordinary experiences. We prioritize models that are high quality and aligned with our strategic plan. Whatever we put in front of community, community, we want to make sure is aligned with the direction of the district as a whole. We also wanted to make sure that the models are designed for the number of students we have. So like I mentioned, with the comprehensive high school model, it's really designed for many students. And, we don't want to put

180a model into a community where there's declining enrollment that banks on the idea that we're going to draw in hundreds of more students in order to be sustainable. We want something that's going to be small by design and sustainable by design. That ties into our third, priority, which is we want something that we know we can sustain using the resources that we have. We also want something that's ready to implement. We want, to look at models that we can see across the country. They don't necessarily have to be, right next to us, but they should exist somewhere so that we can know that they work for students, and they know that they work for the students that, we have in Jefferson. And, you know, we don't really want to look at exploring school models and

181seeing if they'll work for students. We want to make sure that we have something that's ready to go and ready to deliver high quality outcomes. And the last thing, is connected to community interest, which is what we're excited to explore and hear from community is do these models do these programs that we have in mind aligned to what you hope for your students, and do they align with students hope for themselves, so that we can make that match? When I say high quality programing, what we really mean by that is something that is career connected and we're looking for programing that prepare students for a high demand career with a livable wage, programing that allows opportunities to earn industry credentials or college credits, something that ensures students are, doing hands on learning, building skills, technical

182skills, academic skills and durable skills. Through high quality instruction. And also we're looking for programing that, provides work based learning through formalized industry partnerships. This is something that our, pathways team in the district does a lot of research on to try to make sure that we're finding programing that hits all of these metrics and aligns with student interest. And so part of what we're going to explore, in this process is what are students interested in, what is community interested in. And we're going to work with our internal teams to align that to where do we also have great industry partners? Right. Where do we also have really strong pathways with aligned college credit that we can make sure we're putting the best possible quality programing in the junior senior facility. So the two, models that

183we found and matched against our our criteria and believe that they're viable as a CTE campus and an academy model. So a CTE campus is a school that students would attend part time. So they'd be enrolled in a home high school and if there's a program that aligns with their interest, they would, enroll part time in that program to do learning. This is like Warren tech. Warren Tech isn't the only way that we could organize this school, or the only type of programing we could offer. But this is it's similar to the concept where students would have a home high school and they would, attend the CTE campus part time to engage in this type of learning. The second option is the Academy model. And so this is similar to the Public Safety Academy that

184the district is, looking at in Arvada. And this would be full time enrollment. So students would not be enrolled in a comprehensive high school like, like Wheat Ridge. Instead, they would be enrolled full time in the academy, and they would be, engaging and learning in a particular focus area. So, yeah, very commonly there's academies focused on public safety and there's aligned pathways to that concept. In this case, students would engage all of their classes at the academy and they would, have core content aligned to their area of interest, to help reinforce this, learning that they're doing. In either model, whichever one appeals to families, whether they're they like the idea of their student going to another facility to do this at hands on, learning side by side with an industry professional, or whether they're really

185excited about an academy model or their student is is really focused on their future career in either case, we could choose programing that, provides the high access to the high demand, high wage jobs, that we know Colorado needs and students often thrive in. And so some ideas that we want to explore with community are health care pathways, automotive tech. We know that there's a car wrapping program at Jefferson Junior Senior currently that is much beloved, clean energy and cybersecurity and technology. As you may know, there's a quantum hub that I believe is located in Jeffco. And so the idea of connecting with industry partners, where students are able to learn side by side, is is an alluring concept. And, and, you know, make, connections with potential future employers. So with this vision, we have these

186goals for students. And we know that community and staff, like we have questions about what this draft plan would mean, some of those implications. So I won't go through all of these now. But I will just say that we know that, in asking the community to engage in this process with us, there's some ambiguity and there's, there's some, questions that will be important to families, particularly if the draft plan goes forward. And so we know and are currently working on, working with our principals, working with staff to understand the implications on questions such as what would this mean for the current high school students at Jefferson Junior, senior, if they're transitioning during their senior year, what does that mean for their for their graduation? How do we support students through that transition? What does this

187mean for our elementary schools and helping students transition after fifth grade instead of transitioning after sixth grade? How can they, support students to make that shift? What does this mean for retaining our staff and taking care of them? How do we support students who are in the SSN center program and where would they where would that relocate? And, what would this mean for the Wheat Ridge community? How could we engage in the process of bringing two communities together to ensure that every student, every family feels that sense of belonging that, we know is so important and also, you know, acknowledging that there are likely students who have already experienced the closure of mall home who could potentially be impacted again through this plan. So all of these are important and happy to, address any specific

188questions you have with these? I will say we have a webpage, dedicated to this project, specifically where we are keeping up to date facts. I think it's now I pulled it into a word document. It's now 12 pages of all the questions that we got, from the 28th, these, you know, the answers that we are, getting to these questions and we are, as we receive questions, we are doing our best to answer them so that community members have all the information that they that they might need as they engage in this process with us. So I'll end, here, which is just a reminder of our, our, our cadence. So up next is a co-design session on February 11th. We'll have a second one on March 3rd, and then our final co-design session on March 31st

189through this will be asking community for their input and for their ideas. So specifically, we want to understand their reaction to what I've just shown you. What what do they think about the new programing options in our draft plan? Do they have other ideas? We have, on staff or a researcher who's coming alongside with us. So as we're hearing ideas from the community, we can look into them and see, are there are there existing models out there that that match the criteria, that I've named? We also want to understand their ideas for using extra space at the Jefferson Junior Senior facility. It's a big building and there's a lot of important community assets there already. And so we want to understand as an institution that has been so important for this community, what are the

190ways that they want that building to continue to serve them? Regardless of what the programing model is. And we also want to ask some residents, there's a, specific part of the boundary where, you know, some students are guaranteed enrollment to Lumberg as their neighborhood school for grades. K through five, but then the boundary shifts over to Creighton and Lakewood. And so we want to talk with folks who live there and understand, would they like us to clean that up so that they're transitioning on to, in this case, Everett and Wheat Ridge with their peers versus having kind of a split boundary? So we want to ask folks about that as well. And so throughout this process, we are, really encouraged by the level of engagement we've seen so far. Our, Jeffco first team has been

191an incredible partner. Families have been reaching out to them with, with questions and passing them to us to make sure that we, have the ability to provide the best information we can to communities throughout this process. In closing, I just want to mention one thing. I also want to thank, the Edgewater Collective, who is co hosting the three co-design meetings with us. And we've also appreciated the partnership of the city of Edgewater and the City of Wheat Ridge, as we have, taken the time to inform them of these plans as well. And there were some members of the Edgewater City Council who attend, and the mayor who attended the meeting, last week. So with that, we'll hand it over to you all for questions. Or questions? I was wondering, in the meeting last week. Yeah.

192Just how did the parents, what kind of comments did they make? And where are they with this? Yeah, I will, I'll start and then I'll let Claire take it. I mean, I think it was it was challenging. I had the opportunity and I think, Paula, to, to to talk to some parents, one on one before the meeting started, I think the staff as well, hard time, you know, coming to terms with the fact that, the facts just in general and everybody as they have, doctor, in every community we've been in, want to know what they can do to just get more kids to come to the school, so the school can stay open. So I would say generally people were, you know, distressed by the, the thought of their not being able to attend school

193there. I would also say they have very thoughtful questions for the principals at Everett and Wheat Ridge as well around their programing. So I think, you know, as these things go to, things can be true. At the same time, curiosity about what else is out there, but also just a real, acknowledgment that Jefferson is a small, community, tight knit community where they'd prefer to stay. If if that, was, you know, the option. So, and I think also, questions, as Claire said, about the ambiguity and other places we went in and we're very clear, like, we're not here to have a discussion about whether the school will close. We're here to have a discussion about how we move that forward. Here. We are sort of having that discussion about whether the school closed. And I think

194that that is also felt. And, I would invite director Reed to speak on this too, because she was there invites some confusion that people voiced as well. Around around that and, and worry for the school, which will be open next year. I mean, to be to be honest about where we are with Everett and Wheat Ridge, they have space that they could accept as many kids who make a decision to want to go there next year, even after round one of choices over. And so there's some concern about students making that choice not to return to Jefferson. What does that mean for, what that school will even look like next year? So I would say was it felt pretty typical. Some of the conversations we had at Moore in that way, when we when we

195had those. I mean, I'll admit that even I mean, I've seen this a few times, I'm even I still feel like it's ambiguous and confusing. Because, because it sounds a lot like closing a school, consolidating into another one, and then figuring out what to do with the building. Just set in different ways. So, you know, I think people might feel the same way. I don't know, but, so that's, I guess just my reaction after hearing it a few times. But, and I appreciate the effort and the vision is exciting. But I mostly worry about the these like gap year, the, the year. Every school that we closed the following year was really tough. I mean, Moore's was really tough where we had an enrollment of 66th graders, with kids who chose to leave because it

196was already a school that had been voted on, you know, to close. So I all those years, I think are really hard on families, kids and the staff. And then what we're proposing is one more year, I think and it it I understand why, but so I just wonder if there's anything that could make the continuity a little more seamless, where we didn't have to move the whole school community into another school community. You know, like, it might feel better to the community to have a continuity where it goes from what they are now straight into the other program, even if they're there for a year while that happens, you know? And so, I don't know, it seems like, are we talking about closing and consolidating, or is there a totally different way to do

197this that we didn't do before? And maybe we haven't tried yet and maybe we we haven't even thought it all through. But that's what I'd be asking if I were. And the community there, is there any continuity of staying in the building while the transition is happening? Thank you for that, doctor. Other questions? I know declining enrollment is just a hard reality, and we've been dealing with it here in Jeffco for a while. And we've we've seen what was presented. But I know that from some people who've reached out to me, what was hurt is closure. That's what was heard. And, they're still struggling with understanding two stable elementary schools equals one unstable, you know, junior senior high school. But I want to lift up, I think that when we look at 47% of choice

198out of our junior senior high school, we're looking at an unfortunate victim of the privilege of choice for families. And my concern in particular is we're seeing another title, one school essentially being abandoned due to community choice. And, it's just it's a really hard reality saying, you know, in four years, 440 students is a small school. And there are other small schools across the state that are finding ways to still offer a comprehensive, you know, program, but that requires a lot of innovation and support. And when the community is choosing out, we end up in this conversation where we are now. One of the questions I received, that I'm going to ask here is when will the Jefferson decision be made? I know that April 30th, we have that last information session, is that when

199we're hoping that we have a final decision that we're delivering to the community? So I think we don't exactly know. But we we hope that we are coming to some consensus, are able to share with the, the community and the board what we've heard and what the district would recommend. And then we're hopeful. I mean, I think it served in it in an interesting way. It served the more community well to know what was happening next. If not for that class of students, as Doctor Barreto alluded to, certainly the students who are coming next. And so, you know, that might be us bringing to you all a, a, a request for a decision in June, which is the timeline that, happened with more. So I think by April 30th, we'll have a good, good indication,

200of where we are and will start be starting to shape our recommendation. Okay. Another question that I had, is about staff. I'm curious about their potential participation in co-design sessions. I mean, I'm wondering how safe that would feel for staff or if there's a mechanism for them to be able to give, authentic feedback without feeling like it's going to then play into whether or not they are worked with. Given the final decision for the school moving to another location. And so there's questions about, how staff can participate in and process without feeling like they're also putting their career maybe in jeopardy if they're lifting up unfortunate realities. Yeah. Thanks for that question. We had a staff meeting, on Tuesday prior to the meeting. Mr. Fair, who's the community superintendent, met with the staff, I believe

201this morning we will continue to meet. We they are, of course, invited to participate in the, co-design sessions. We have also offered all of the principals the opportunity for us just to work with staff at their, at their own schools in a way that feels most comfortable for them. Claire's working on various ways to collect information. We also recognize, Director Kenworthy, that there may be families that are hesitant to come out right now. And so there are multiple ways by which we need to collect and solicit information from, from people. And so we we are prepared, definitely prepared to do that. So there in terms of like a survey or some other kind of, mechanism or anonymous mechanism, we will collect information that way. And I want to say how proud I was of the

202staff for being really vocal at the meeting. And perhaps Director Regan speak about that, asking hard questions. And, they have our respect for, for doing so and it very what was very clear was at the, at the center of their questions was how much they care about their kids. And as we've seen in other instances, some of them will want to go to, the schools where their kids are going. And, we've talked with Miss Mahina, Miss Juliet, about coming to the school and having time to talk to staff about what might be available at their schools. But there are also staff who may want other opportunities. And we'll we would give them priority and opportunities to explore those as well. Okay. My last question is just as a chance for the district to share some

203thoughts about what lessons were learned during school closure process in relation to community grief and processing that are being applied. With this particular situation. Thank you for that question. Through the first two rounds, or through the only two rounds of regional opportunities for thriving schools, phase one and phase two. We did learn in particular at the first community engagement sessions that particularly when there is difficult content, it is important to create space intentionally, with really thoughtful facilitation, really thoughtful invitation, and really thoughtful permissioning for folks to experience the range of emotions that are likely to come up. And that might look really different for different folks. It might look different for one parent to another, might look really different from one staff member to another. And so part of our design choices in this process

204has been to create some, some spaciousness and some time so intense. We have created this kind of five meeting arcs because we know that it takes time. Even the presentation that we went through, Doctor Vada to, recognize something you mentioned earlier. It's a lot to process, and I think that there's some more work to do, even in clarity. In addition to facilitated spaces where folks can just acknowledge that, there are some tough feelings. So on, February 11th, the first part of our meeting is an activity called empathy mapping, where in roller light groups, we're going to invite staff into a space. We're gonna invite family and community into space, and students into a space where they can think about, you know, what are the emotions that come up for you, like when you think about

205this plan, what are those emotions? Let's let's name and recognize them. What are the thoughts you're having with questions you might be having? What actions might you want to take? Because we think it's it's important to provide the support for people to engage in that conversation. Even as we, we try to look to the future, if we don't create space for what's happening right now. But where, not likely to be able to move together as a, as a community and as a district towards something that's possible. I'll just add one thing, which is when you do things at a scale of 16 schools, there are things you can't afford to do or you just can't do. And so with with me just dealing with one school, we're able to open up the possibility of what

206what can we do that we weren't able to do when it was, scale. So we're thinking about those things. And the other thing we've learned, and it's documented in every app or after action review we have, is just how critical our principals and school leaders are in this process. And so, you know, we brought one to Hamilton back, who helped with the first, and second phases of off to work just directly with the principals they are designing the transition plans for their in and for their communities, because that's just work we can't do at the central level. It has to be done by the people who are going to be leading it. And so those are our Edgewater principals and our white, rich principals. And so no matter what, no matter what happens, that they've

207they started that work in January. And or maybe even before. I mean, we've been working on this for six months now. So, you know, I think that is another thing that just, we know to be critical to this work. I also want to just say, well, I think there are lessons learned from the closures of the 1621 schools. And I know it feels like this is a closure because we've proposed a pause of students being in the building for a year so we can do the planning, the remodeling, whatever investment we might need to make to make it a reality for what it's going to become. One of my goals is to make sure that the students who live in and near that school get to go to that school. And a couple things I

208heard in the community meeting, so we don't know everything that we need to know. I think given that we're trying to shift from closure to meaningful community engagement around a school transition, and you know that, for example, there's this sign and rap program in the building and they're like, well, if we close that, that program ends. And what happens to that teacher, you know, and it's like, it's just a good question. And somebody came up to Allison, I after after the meeting and said, it's so interesting because people want to be engaged and they want to be asked and they want to have input. And then when they ask you a question and you don't have a black and white answer because you're trying to allow for time and space, now that we have a

209runway for engagement, then it's frustrating, right? So it's like, well, if we want to keep the sign program open in this corner of the building while we remodel, like proposed, that, right? We if we do a zero year planning, we probably need a team of people to lead that effort alongside a principal. You know, we can talk about that. And then then somebody was asking us, well, we can't do that. We need to make what we need to continue to make our paychecks. And we're saying, well, if you're planning a school, you should be making a paycheck. So I feel like there hasn't been an experience, especially in this community. But I think in many of our communities where district leadership is sitting down at the table saying, let's talk about this. We don't have

210all the answers. And people actually believing us and understanding that the other side of the coin of the district, not having all the answers is ambiguity. And a need from district leadership for people to bring solutions. Right. And ideas. And maybe we can work it out. Maybe we can't in terms of all of our interests, but that's a really uncharted territory and very different than where we were with the closure of the 21, because we didn't have that kind of time. So I think we're going to learn, even though we're trying to apply those lessons learned. And thank you for asking that, because we should always be reminded to do that. I think we're going to learn a lot, about how to do it, as in a way of like transitioning a school versus closing.

211Yeah. I want to lift up, there's a gentleman who came and spoke to us a couple months ago at our one of our meetings about joining, I think the FARC or the Camino is the community committee for, I think, Vivian, maybe. And like not glen and heights and not trusting that that process is going to be worth it. And he was very skeptical. And then he came into public comment and told us how well that went. My hope is that we get similar feedback, right? This is an opportunity to prove to our community that we do actually want their feedback, and we want to implement some of their solutions and ideas because we don't have all the solutions and ideas. But I want to recognize how much anxiety and fear is in the way of

212people being willing to show up. I'm concerned about, the order, you know, of having an information session and then a co-design session, like how how many people are going to show up at this February 11th meeting is what I'm wondering and really trust that it's worth their time to show up and engage in a conversation. So I'm wondering, you don't have to answer me now, but I'm wondering what you're doing to address that and how to, perhaps to individual invitations to some community leaders, community members who can, be a part of that and also be a trust agent for other community members to show up and participate because they know there are folks there who are going to speak up in support of them. Yeah. Thank you. Director. Can that are they. I was just

213I would plus one that and also usually in like. Well depends on which approach you take to co-design. But in the co-design I was thinking, well like who's the decision maker? And we've even in this conversation it's suggested a few different folks will be like hearing the feedback and then making the decisions about the design. And I would encourage, if you really want to dig in on this, then identify some community leaders who are actively have the same vote as the district and the design that gets presented back to the community and us. That would truly be co-design, where there's people in the community who are part of the decision making after the input is is made. But, I think that's I haven't seen that. Yeah. It's, it's a different, interpretation of co-design, but I

214would encourage it along those lines. Well, I think to as, as community leaders up here that we also play a role in encouraging the community members who are reaching out to us with questions to show up and engage in the conversation and to provide feedback about how that is going. So for the folks who sent me emails and text messages during the community meeting that I was not at because it's not my articulation area anymore, I just want to say here that I've heard from district staff that they do want to hear solutions and ideas from community members, and then from my c want to say, please come and bring your ideas, your concerns and your solutions to these next three meetings. Because if you don't, then they don't get considered at all. And you're

215sitting on the sidelines in an armchair trying to quarterback without being in the game. And you have to show up and participate if you want to be heard. And I just really want to lift that up so that I will stop there. But thank you. I want to I appreciate the concerns raised by Doctor Vada and Director Kenworthy. I also want to say I've spent time at Wheat Ridge and at Everett in the last week, and they are really excited for the potential to welcome new families. And so I want to lift up, for those who might be questioning, considering reach out to those principals. They are thoughtful and they are understanding and they showed up, and I know they plan to show up to the rest of the sessions. And I'm also really excited

216about some of these options I think it could turn into. And Warren Tech is so popular, and our opportunity to put those in that area of our district, I think is a really, really, really wonderful opportunity. So I understand the fear and the and all of it. But I also want people to maybe embrace a little bit like this could be a really cool, once we get through the transition and all the hard because I know any change is hard, but I just want to lift that up. I'm. I think this could be super cool when we get through all the hard. I just have two questions. When you talk about, changing the, elementary schools from pre-K six to pre-K five, especially with the Edgewater Elementary School, because it's the smaller one. Is there any

217concern that it will get really small when you take sixth grade out? So one of the things that, is that we're hopeful around with the two elementary schools is right now, they, they offer both offer of dual language programing. But the types are different. There's one way into it. And right now they'd like to be shuffling more students between the schools to offer them the programing that they really need or want. And by freeing up some space, this will allow us to do that. And so we do believe that, it will yeah. There will be fewer students at Edgewater, in Clark and talk a little bit more about that, but we believe some of those seats will be filled by students who would have otherwise gone to Lumberg. And there will be some students, who

218also should be at Lumberg, for the, for programing that they want or need that will be able to go there. That can now just because of how full the school is. So will free up, some space for movement. And Claire could talk a little bit more about it. And when we look at the numbers, you know, if we were to take the, enrollment today and, you know, think about those students no longer attending the elementary schools, but attending Everett. Those numbers, I think, are still quite healthy. At Lumberg, it would be around 480 students. That'd be an 80% utilization, which would do exactly what, Lisa mentioned in terms of freeing up a little room to, swap students so that they're getting the programing that best meets their needs. And at Edgewater, the enrollment would still

219be, closer to, just over 300, and that would be a 72% utilization. So again, something we would consider quite healthy. And do we think, that the rapid decline in, the number of students in that articulation area is due more to the 47% tracing out, or is it really just demographics lower it's demographics. So definitely, as the boundaries study showed, all of us creating all that choice programing and the whole region created a lot of choice, has created a lot of choice between the schools. But, the demographics are astounding. And that's why we, you know, we studied them with the city of Edgewater, and I don't know if you remember, but CFC said that if they hadn't corrected their model, the number would have gone to zero in terms of kids. But Edgewater just itself, as

220a city, is changing really rapidly. The housing market is changing there. And the gentrification is, happening at a, at a rapid pace. And so it is it is demographics. And we're not the only district, of course, that, you know, we bordered Denver right there. And they had proposed closing, Colfax Elementary, which is very close to there because of how few students there are there, just fewer and fewer school age children, that area. And then lastly, I'm really excited that Edgewater Collective is, is, partnering in this area or in this effort. And I from what I know about them, and I'm not that involved in that area, but I think they would really be thinking outside the box too. So in addition to the two main options that we're looking at right now, I would be

221hopeful that they could, you know, even come in with some more ideas. And after talking to I don't know, industry specialists there who want to have, some kind of apprenticeship programs or something, using some of this space. Yeah. They've done a great job of, finding opportunities, for sure. And, at the beginning of the next meeting as a preview for everyone who's planning to attend, Joel, Newton, who runs Edgewater Collective, is going to give a, a brief history of, that. And in terms of the work that has happened in that area over the past 12 years, he was just saying he saw a lot of new faces, who don't have the context of the area. And so, he will be blending some context as well because we. Initially I was passing because I was there, and

222so we didn't really have questions, because and the questions that were asked and answered just seemed to cover it. And then I thought, but I don't want me not saying anything to be misinterpreted as me not caring. All of a sudden I'm like, oh no, I don't want people to like, walk like, oh, and you didn't even have anything to say. So I do just want to to reiterate that, people were very vocal. Staff members were very vocal at the meeting, and that was great to see. I if people didn't look too scared to say what they wanted to say. And so I, I actually think that's a really good start. I think knowing that people felt free to be honest and to talk about their fears and, and their sadness and all of that.

223And, you know, I spent some time out in the hallway with a teacher that I've known for a really long time who was in tears, you know, and, and just saying, please help us, please help us. And it's really hard to say, you know, we're offering the help that we have to offer, and and we can't do what you want us to do, which is to create children. So, so I felt good about that. And I do think that it's going to take time. I'm glad that we've decided to design this with several different meetings, because it is going to take time to move into it, but I think that we will move into this work. I have faith in that community's knowledge of what it needs and what it wants and its ability to

224express it, and I have faith in our ability to meet them where they are. Okay. Thank you so much for the presentation. And, For this evening's next to last agenda item, it will allow the board the opportunity to review and discuss a draft proposal, in support of Jeffco students and families, reaffirming its commitment to cultivating an environment of safety and belonging for all students. A draft resolution, as well as example resolutions from surrounding metro districts are available via board docs for review and consideration. And before I open this discussion with the board superintendent, all understood anything you'd like to add? Thank you, President Parker. I don't have anything to add at this time. Okay, then with that, I would like to, first turn to director Reed, who can bring us up to date on where

225we are in the process. All right. Thank you very much. I'm so glad that we're having this conversation. And that we're diving into this. What I want to do is start off by addressing the purpose of a resolution within a policy. Governance organizations such as ours resolutions provide a public philosophical framework for the implementation of existing policy or the creation of new policies and procedures. For example, we used resolutions to direct the district to create policies and processes for closing schools. As we just talked about. They can also be used. Although are not strictly required to authorize actions only the school board can authorize, such as selling property. A resolution does not and should not carry the force of policy. This is why Matt Cook from Caspi has often mentioned that he counsels policy, governance,

226school boards not to have resolutions at all, despite our finding positive uses for them in drafting this resolution, it seemed most appropriate to approach it from the first purpose to provide a public philosophical framework for the implementation of existing policy, or the creation of new policies and procedures. It is grounded in our current policy because though we cannot control all the changes to the laws, we do control our policies and can continue to commit to them. So there seems to have been, from the overwhelming amount of mail that we're getting, an impression among many Jeffco, among many, the Jeffco leadership has been unwilling to address the changes created by the series of fast and drastic changes in the landscape of education, especially around our immigrant and LGBTQ students. The same concerns were expressed in our

227Equity Accountability Committee. Both the the immigrant and the LGBTQ students and, and a a great deal of concern around hate speech and the ways that divisions in our culture are leaching into our schools. This resolution is designed to affirm our commitment to the equitable education of all students, including those who are under attack in our current environment. So I want to be clear that this resolution does not promise that Jeffco Public Schools will defy duly implemented federal and state laws regardless of what our opinions of those may be. We simply cannot do that if our stakeholders are hoping for a resolution that makes such a promise, I assure you we would not be able to keep it. To do so would mean requiring all of our employees, from front office secretaries to principals and every

228other employee, to risk arrest and other legal consequences. And we cannot do that. I want to acknowledge that some have been frustrated that this resolution was not proposed and passed sooner. Such an action must be taken at a public meeting, and the last such meeting we held was before the inauguration. While we could certainly anticipate some of what was to come, we felt we needed to have a real understanding of it before drafting this response. And that was most effectively done after the new administration took office. I've also heard the voices of people who mistakenly believe that Jeffco has no concrete plan to deal with Ice and other law enforcement approaching our schools. During the school day. I assure you that our principals have all been given very specific procedures to follow, which I alluded

229to in the final two resolution classes of today's document. Finally, I acknowledge that this resolution will not make everyone happy. There will be people who do not want us to assertively affirm protection for our most vulnerable students, and others who believe this does not do nearly enough to be honest. Personally, I wish we could do more. It was hard to draft something without referencing laws that may or may not still be in place tomorrow. I mean, we've already seen that this morning. We're not 100% certain whether or not we have a federal department of Education. It was hard to give direction regarding policy when I cannot know with certainty that such direction will be lawful tomorrow. I wish I could bestow clarity and certainty upon us all in these deeply muddy and uncertain times. I

230can tell you that there are no plan to preemptively roll over on anything. In the end, I attempted to capture the heartfelt belief of this board, which I know to be shared by leadership that we must and will do absolutely everything in our lawful power to help our children feel safe and welcome, and to minimize upheaval in our school buildings. Years of coaching and acting. As a parliamentarian of Haas High School, Congress leaves me feeling like I should yield the floor for questions. But instead, I'm going to offer the hope that today's discussion will yield a resolution that provides the district with guidance and assures our constituents that we truly do care and will do our best to stand up for all of our students. So at this point, I'd like to open up for

231comments and like, I know, Michelle, you have a number of changes that you would like to see made. And, I believe we have somebody taking notes on the changes that we ultimately agree we would like to see so that when we have a final draft of the resolution, it reflects the changes that we want to see made. I, first, thank you, director Reed, for kicking us off and getting us started, because the first draft is always the hardest. And, and I greatly, greatly appreciate that. Due to my tardiness and timing of this meeting, I did propose some red lines, and I would maybe ask that they could be circulated and considered, along with any other red lines that folks have. I don't know what the most expeditious way to do it is. And so I

232would just. I don't, but I have it electronically and, I could we can maybe print them and provide them before you leave tonight. Whatever's easiest. And I mean, certainly open to edits. I mean, I was trained by very good lawyers to not be offended by red lines. And so it's just, I really like the start. The doctor Reed doctrine director Reed provided, And I just wanted to ask, when I talked with the, President Parker yesterday and she asked us to add this to the board's agenda, I think it was for the purpose of the board to have a public conversation around the current draft and provide guidance in a public setting. All together now for everyone to hear about what changes you might want to see so that the board can contemplate this resolution on

233next week's agenda, whether that's on consent or something else, depending upon what President Parker asks us to do. So I would encourage the board to actually have the conversation. Because that's, I think, I believe, President Parker, why you asked for this agenda item to be added. Oops. Yes. And, we do have the original draft. The director did. So we can all look at that. And then director Applegate, if you want to just go, you know, paragraph by paragraph, what you were suggesting. Whatever's whatever's preferred. I thought this was the discussion, but I don't. I'm a little confused by that, but, something that I was a little confused by on this is that it is called environment of Safety and Belonging. I think this is why I've been like, what exactly is the purpose of this

234resolution? And is it is it to address the topic of immigration and the current, situation, or are we doing a resolution on belonging and safety? I don't have any concerns with, because you had mentioned this to me, like, including LGBTQ, like that's not my concern. I'm wondering, what is this? Is this a resolution addressing the immigration? And because, like, if someone was reading our agenda, they would never know. That's what this is, because it's not even in the title. So I don't know, I just I'm not sure. Agenda for tonight. The agenda for tonight. Like right now on the agenda it says environment of safety and belonging. Discussion. And I guess the sensitivities is right. That's what I'm saying. So is this resolution a safety and belonging resolution or is it is it a resolution

235addressing immigration. So if I may this, this one that we're talking about right now as safety and belonging and, Director Reid, when I've talked with her, too, she was, bringing in a lot of, the, concerns from her work on the, AEC, but we also included in, the documents for this agenda, some specific ones on immigration. So we've got those, that we can talk about as well. So what I was thinking, since your question had come up that we, we could possibly end up with two resolutions, one that addresses. Yeah, yeah. So we have one that's the safety, and belonging. And then we can use possibly one of the models on specifically immigration. Or logic. I just don't understand okay. So a couple of things with this. One is because I think it's two separate issues

236in a lot of ways. If the issue is that the resolution, the resolution itself is too vague and that you want it to specify, we could do that. We could say safety and belonging for all students, including because I'm looking at your red line right now. So that stayed the same. Right. But we could change it and we could certainly say the safety and belonging for all students, including, immigrants and LGBTQ or including, you know, something like that. I don't understand why let me let me add what I did and, again, I don't I don't actually have super strong feelings on this. What what I did is I added more language around immigration into this version because when I looked at like other districts, they they kind of lumped it all in. And I thought

237that was nice. But I did add language that was kind of really specific to the immigration action. And so, I, I, I tried to merge. Okay. Oh, it's it's in your email. I should have sent. It should be. So the one question that I would have about splitting it into two, and I do want to point out that there's precedent in other districts for putting them together. So it's not unheard of. And it seems to have worked fine there, especially given that a resolution is not policy. It is a philosophical framework. The problem with saying, let's break it out into which I'm more than happy to do if this if that's what this board decides it wants to do, I'm happy to do that work, is that it delays. Somebody, somewhere. And we already have

238a public that feels that we have been unresponsive and untimely. And so, that creates problems in and of itself because then there's no time to discuss the two separate ones unless we agree to delay at least one of them and maybe both. Until March. And I don't think people want that delay. So I think there are ways to, to make it more clear in the wording of the title of it, because the resolution itself is quite long and, you know, it's the part that comes after all the whereas clauses. But but the title of it, you know, if we wanted to make that clearer, we certainly could do that. Said one other thing, like, for example, in the, Boulder Valley one, there's and I don't know, in the red lines and I don't know, but

239there's sections on where this would be posted and how it would be communicated. Yeah, we can add that. Yeah. Like, because we are getting a lot of feedback on the lack of any communication to the community. And I noticed even the Boulder Valley, when the very last section says something about where this would be posted in every schools, what they say, and then, communicated to all staff and a community. So I don't think I have the staff and community part, but I do have it at the end that it would be provided to after school providers and vendors who contract with us and notified, but I don't think I added the community and parents. Whatever you just said, is there in the interest of walking through this line by line, which we can do? I'm

240trying to figure out the best way to do this because we could go line by line. Or could we say we can all get it and have comments back within a certain time so that it could be approved next week? Like what's our what's our option? So my concern about doing that is that it doesn't happen in public. Then. So so and who's taking notes? Jennifer, are you taking the notes for us? Okay. And I'm trying to figure out should I be taking notes or do we have somebody that's jotting down any changes we decide to come up with? Okay. Okay, great. Yeah, I think I. I mean, we've done a number of resolutions. We've never done them line by line in public. And I don't mind being public at all, but this is going

241to take a very long time. So I'm just saying the need to do it publicly is a new need for us on a resolution. So I'm just curious about it. Well, I mean, I guess we don't have to do that. It's just, well, here's the issue. We have never before edited a resolution. They have come to us, put together after discussions that were not about the resolution, and then we approved them or didn't approve them. We have never we have never submitted one as a board that we wrote. So that makes this different. In that regard, we focus a great deal recently on transparency, and the need to be transparent and to make things public. And we've talked about should we make things public that haven't been done publicly before. So. You know, you we

242sort of have to decide what it is that we want to what we want to do here. Well, then if I went, if I read because I'm happy to and it should be uploaded for docs, like I'm happy to read my edits and we can do okay. I don't want to do it. I mean, I'm happy to read it. Yeah, because it's actually wouldn't take that well, I mean, I looked at them and I think we can decide pretty quickly because I think some of them too, they look like red lines, like they're in red, but it's the original language you just added. They muted it. Yeah. Moved it around so that it tried to like I tried to follow your flow. Yeah. In the public section. I start yeah. All right. So to the

243first paragraph, where we originally said without discrimination on the basis of race, color or national origin, I just pulled from the CVS site where they had, regardless of actual perceived race, color, national origin, citizenship, immigration status, or the status of the parents guardians. And I put the link in there where it came from. I'm sorry. I'm totally thumbs up on that. I love that, I don't think that we need to cite our sources. No, that was more for I stole this from all over the place, to be honest, and did not cite any of those sources. It was more for our reference. Okay. Else I already have it. Yeah. All right. So I added a second paragraph that basically. So, director Reed had kind of listed our policies in the next 1 to 2 warehouses.

244So I just added one that said, through its policies and practices, the district has made a commitment to quality education for all students. That includes a safe and stable learning environment, means of transportation to and from school sites, the preservation of classroom hours for educational instruction, and the requirement of school attendance. And then it follows into the warehouses of our policies. Keep you on. And then so now I'm going to jump down one, two, three, four where as is and because I added more, I just deleted the and the end of I should have put numbers in. Paula. I'm sorry. So after the whereas also then I the next whereas paragraph that was added and this one this is more opinion. So I welcome discussion on this. Whereas federal immigration law enforcement activities on or

245around district property or transportation routes, whether by surveillance, interview, demand for information, arrest, detention or any other means, Harmfully disrupts the learning environment to which all students, regardless of immigration status, are entitled and significantly interferes with the ability of students, including U.S. citizens, students, and students who hold other legal grounds for presence in the U.S to access free public K-12 education. Please, I want to ask a question about that. Just for specificity. I'm curious. One, is there, in some of the other resolutions, the surrounding districts have released, they've alluded specifically to, a case filer. Is that still something that we could potentially cite in our resolution, or is that a piece of. I'll tell you that. I mean, she interestingly did not put any current law or legal interpretations because as far as I can

246tell, they are out the window. Great. And then, okay, so I understand that my other question, is around, in this particular whereas on or around district property, there's questions about the external property around our buildings, and whether it is classified as private property or is it public property, or does that change at times during the day? And so I'm wondering how that would impact what we have written here, just to make sure that we're not lifting up things that we cannot actually do. And that's my concern on this as well. Is that something that we could ask Miss Tolson to help us? Maybe edit this, whereas to make sure it is legally appropriate. I mean, basically what we're doing is we're saying if we let ice onto property or we let other law enforcement onto

247property, it's disruptive. There will be nothing in the resolution to address that whereas clause, because we cannot make that guarantee. So I don't know why we would put in a whereas clause that we can't address in the resolution with confidence. So I agree with you. This is not fair. So is it the honor around district property, or is it, that it is disruptive to its the honor around? I mean, I'm fine changing. I just wanted it to say that this is the end of to all education. Like it's not. It totally is. I'm just saying whether it's disruptive or not, if the law says that, we have to let them on, we're going to let them on, because I'm not there's no way we're going to ask anyone in that school to walk out there

248and tell them that they can't do this thing that is now a duly legal thing to do. So that was the, you know, one of those weird things where it was like, because I saw that in that language in and that the reason I left it out is if there's not going to be anything in the resolution to address it. Now, what is in the resolution to address that is, if they are going to come on to school property, they have to have all their documentation together and they have to run it by our legal department, because that's in our policy, that's in our actual procedures for how we intend to deal with that. So, so that that is something that's actually in there. I'm open. I'm open to edits on this. I was just

249explaining the the why. My suggestion would be to change on or around to in district property. Because the buildings we control the access and that is not something that the public can access independently, like our playgrounds and our, surrounding areas are, if that will stand up for legal review. That's what I would suggest. Well, we can boot private citizens who are on our playgrounds during a school year, during the school day, but not in the afternoon. Oh, I see what you're saying. Like not just during the school day, but like you're doing that as an intimidation tactic. Or just clarity around when we are classifying our external properties as private property versus public property. Law enforcement is not the general public. I mean, there are lots of times that we would tell the general public,

250you can't be here on our property like they can't be hanging out on the lawn in front of the school. We can go and say, you can't be here. We have I'll say I'm concerned specifically, specifically about pick up and drop off times that happen outside of our school. Julie, what do you think we're going to be able to promise that we can hold those sacrosanct? I want to be sure I'm looking at the right paragraphs, or we're talking about the one that begins. Whereas federal on the, but whereas federal immigration, law enforcement activities on or around district property and transportation routes with that one, I read this is just a declaration on that that's disruptive to the learning environment. And I think that's a fair statement. It's not necessarily make them making a pledge

251about what we can do about every aspect of it. So I don't have a problem with the paragraph is written. All right. Well then let's keep it as written. I propose that we keep that paragraph as written. Thumbs up, thumbs down, medium, because we're not doing anything about it. All right. Thank you. All right. Next one. And this is one where, I want to caveat this. So, if there's already kind of proposing a new policy here, and there may already be one that I missed. And I took this largely from, like, some of our, some of the information of, like, how we are, the guidance we've given to principals was kind of the, the notion for this. So if that has changed totally open to change that. Okay. So and this is where miss tell

252us and you may need to like rein me back in here. Right. Be it resolved that the US immigration enforcement office, I state law or local law enforcement agencies acting on behalf of Ice or agents or officers, any federal, state or local agency attempting to enforce federal immigration laws are to follow district policy. Star attached. And this is at the bottom. So I'm going to ask us to scroll to the bottom when I get done with this, to ensure the district meets its duty to provide all students, regardless of immigration access status, access to free public K-12 education, fully recognizing that we can ask them to do this. And they could say, no, no. All right. So, Miss Tolson, I think this will be policy k l klg. Okay, which is relations with governmental authorities

253and relations of police authorities. And we've double checked those policies, and they're in alignment with the guidance that we've given. And I think you can just link those. So reference schools, reference those policies. And that's my take on it. I think. So what Julie Chapman will be helpful. Oh I think that's right. I think the hardest part about thinking about naming a policy and attaching it is that our nondiscrimination policies would be implicated here. As for our one regarding, interrogations on campus, right. We've got one of those. So this all of a sudden might become kind of a multi-headed hydra. It might be easier to not specify a policy, but to say, you know, that we are, are to follow district policy to ensure that. So just generally speaking, because any policy that would a

254yeah apply in that circumstance. That's helpful. Thank you. So could we just say to follow district policies to ensure the district meets its duty? Yep. That works great. Is everyone okay with that. So I would just say that this paragraph would stand as is with the one, with removal of the comma, attached to and incorporated in this resolution would be removed and that the there would be a period placed after our to follow district policy period, and that the next sentence would, begin in order to ensure that district meets a duty to provide all students, regardless of immigration status, access to a free public K-12 education. Yep. It was up. Grant. Awesome. So the next paragraph is be it for the resolved and in its continued commitment to the protection of student privacy, the district

255shall review its recordkeeping policies and practices to ensure that no data is being collected with respect to students immigration status or place of birth, and cease any such collection. So, Superintendent Dillon, I don't think we collect this already, so maybe it's just to say that we are consistent with our policy around data collection. I'm going to jump in that we have no idea what the law is going to be tomorrow. Okay. And the law tomorrow may be that schools are required to collect this data, and we are not going to tell our schools that they can't follow the law. That's now this was one of those ones where I was like, I just I don't think we can promise that. No, the law today is that we don't collect that data or is that just

256policy? It it's a bit of both because, well, particularly we we do have certain data regarding place of birth because we often receive birth certificates. And of course, where somebody is born, I understand how people draw conclusions about immigration status, but it doesn't necessarily follow. We absolutely do not collect. And most school districts do not information about immigration status. And that's sort of consistent with ever since the Supreme Court decided, and I was also back in the early 80s. Right. So, I mean, I'm inclined to say, I think we can commit that we will can we will refrain from collecting information on immigration status. I guess if the law changes, we'll have a different conversation. Now, we may just given that this keeps coming up, make some sort of commitment in some section to following

257the law. Right. And then the only thing I was going to jump in and say is that I'm uncomfortable with the language around place of birth, because we do use birth certificate as part of our enrollment process there. There's probably other things that can be brought in as well. But so what if we said that be it further resolved and the continued commitment to the protection of student privacy, the district will continue its current practice or some language around like, I don't think this is about place of birth. This is about immigration status, that accurate. We do not collect information regarding immigration status. Correct. I just think that at some point we're going to be required to do that. Well, and I would just request that you don't ask us to do a review because

258we're very clear about what we do. And I mean, so what if we just say continued commitment to the protection of student privacy, per its policies, period? I think we have the one in there already that that says that we will follow up. So should we go to that one next and see if that helps clear this one up? Because that's the next one. I just add a few people have brought up the fact that I think it's very I can't even remember who did. The ESL program was a cert thing that came to all of us. We collect place of birth, I think. Don't even ask parents place of birth. I'm just going to say it. That is concerning people in the community that you show someone. I don't know where I was. Someone

259showed me a screenshot of the you have that, place of birth that was used. I me it is, it is me. I have screenshots, sent to me from a staff member. Where we collect birth place, language, information. This is in regards to ESL data, language background. How long somebody has spoken? How much English does your child speaker understand and how many languages is a child speaker understand? And how many years did they attend school in another country? Yeah, I, I get it, and I understand the political environment that we're in. If we don't ask questions like that, then we are violating other federal laws, and the Department of Justice will show up at our door and force us to ask questions like that. If we don't ask questions, about our families and their lived experiences

260and the needs of their children, then we don't know how to allocate resources to support students with their learning needs. So this is a real catch 22, because in districts where those kinds of questions weren't asked and federal officials came in and made the district start asking those questions. So I just were getting like, I wasn't bringing it up to say we should change it. I just want to acknowledge that it's making people feel scared. And thank you for acknowledging that people have feelings about this, and we need to let them know that we'll protect, I haven't I and that's why I think if we focus on the the next can we read the next, resolution clause. So the next one I, I agree so be it. Further resolved, should Ice or other immigration law

261enforcement agents request any student information, the request should be referred to the superintendent's office and district legal Department to ensure compliance with Family Education Rights and Privacy Act, Coppa, student constitutional privacy standards for a judicial warrant and any other limitations on disclosure. This review should be conducted expeditiously and but before any production of information is made, I think that works. I think it's great. I think it aligns completely with the guidance we've built. So I'd like to take out the previous paragraph. No data is being collected, yada yada. Just take that entire thing out and let's leave in that, you know, we are going to. Yeah. So do we come back very I'm confused about this review. Should be conducted expeditiously. What review? Meaning if if the request is referred to the superintendent's office, it

262should be the request, not this review. Right. So the review, we could say that I see I see the confusion. I thought we were taken out that one. We're not there. The recommendation has been to take out the previous one. How about if we say the request should be reviewed, referred for review to the superintendents office and legal district of department to ensure compliance, yada yada? And now we know what this review is. It is the view of the request. I'm good with that. Loved the next three that Paula put in there. And this is where I thought it was. Okay, since we've kind of, lifted up the immigration a little bit more to include that. We do have other students that are also scared and feeling fearful. So to me, it it was okay

263to leave in, still support separating it out if folks want to. So this one was an idea and I will totally defer to our superintendent. Thinking back to Covid, we were able to pretty quickly stand up like virtual options for kiddos who are in school. I've struggled with this because it also means like, could that be a target or an identification of kids? So I want to put that out there like I don't I don't know that this is necessarily the best, but what I added, be it further, is all the Jeffco shall provide flexible options for families who fear that their physical attendance in school could put their students and families at risk, be offered continued education through Jeffco virtual temporarily, until it is until it is deemed safe to return to school. My

264concern about that is that that is more policy. That's an operational decision that needs to be made with like academic officers. And I don't know how you feel about that. Tracy, before you may I, I just wanted to say it was just that the option was there. And we can say up to principals, we can say school leadership. Like, I just thought that having that option out there. So that was my thought. I mean, Java has a lot on its plate right now. It's been a bit of a catch all. We're dealing with that. We're working through some things related to that. We also have, you know, general PE, which is a different option. We to my knowledge, not I had any requests around this, and I don't I definitely don't want to get to

265a place where we're asking teachers to do both modalities, where they have kids in front of them and kids online. That was a disaster during the pandemic, and it's very unfair to our educators. So I'm going to let Kim jump in here. I guess I would feel better if we took this language up about four levels and altitude and said something like, the district will work with families to provide, alternate options and to stay engaged in school as necessary. I mean, so much of this is on the ground work that our family ambassadors and family engagement liaisons and principals are already doing. So what what I would add is the academic leadership team has been working for about ten days now. Looking at attendance, looking at our student engagement office processes and procedures. What do

266we do when a student disengages or doesn't come to school for whatever reason? And recognizing that while we don't want to enter into a conversation around any kind of punitive, you know, contract on attend, what we want to use is use all of the proactive measures that that team has built around research to say how can we support a student who their family does feel fearful for them to come to school physically, in person? What can we offer them so that they can continue learning and so we're looking at what we already have in place and having conversations around, would this suffice? And if not, we're engaging with conversations, with both JBA and as far as what what could that potentially look like? And we intend to bring back a recommendation to cabinet within the

267next two weeks. But given kind of the timing of where we are right now, nobody would have hit the threshold of a number of days that would cause us to stop and ask ourselves the question. So we have a little bit of time to figure that out. So in that case, I would say let's just leave it with Jeffco shall provide flexible options for families who fear that their physical attendance at schools could put their students and families at risk. Period. Period. Yeah. And I just wanted to add, a teacher and a teacher spouse have both told me that they've noticed, kids missing and that they've been preparing packets of work for them. So it doesn't have to be like a virtual option. You know, it sounds like teachers are already keeping an eye on

268kids and trying to help them learn from home if they need to. I would also offer that, like, once this is done, I hope we can like all look at it again. Okay. Yeah. So I don't think this is like the end all be all. I'm making edits to this one. I'll send it back to Jennifer. Yeah. Then we just jumped on to the end. Guys, we're almost done. My very last. Be it for the resolved. And I think we should edit this to kind of say we were talking about it earlier. I said afterschool providers and vendors that provide service who contract shall be notified of this resolution, but I think it might actually be more important to say we're going to share it with communities and I think whoever said it earlier might

269have been better language. I'll find the Boulder Valley one. I don't know, I just saw it there. The last thing says, be it further resolved, that the school district shall post this resolution at every school site and distributed to school district staff and parents and all the predominantly used languages of the school district, and shall broadly communicate the commitments of this resolution. And I see what you're saying. Director Reed, I think I've got some copies in there of paragraphs that are up above. The last two before that seem to be copies, and I'll clean that up. Yeah, I like that addition. Doctor bag agreed. So where do you have it, doctor Vada, are you pulling it or do you want me to pull it? Just comment on. Yeah I know, yeah. Here it was. Just

270copy it. Right. You can teams that to me. Yeah. I please I mean and then I'm just going to delete out the pretend policy that I added at the bottom because it's covered now by other policy. Thank you. So that thank you guys for that. Yes. Thank you very much. And and director is late. I want to just highlight the third from the bottom. Be it for the resolved any request by Ice or other agencies, blah blah to visit a school site should be presented to legal and then at the very end says. But before any immigration law enforcement agent or officer appears at the school site that is in conflict with the guidance that we've given, we don't. We believe we may know if some let me say this publicly. We have not heard

271any Ice officials visit any school sites as I connect with superintendents across the state. I don't know of an Ice official that has visited a school site. That being said, we've done what we need to do to be prepared in the case that that happens. I've we have instructed principals of to use their normal protocols for entrance into our buildings, which is to require identification. And, and if it's an official government official to require their government ID, right, whether it's a badge or some other form of government ID, and to be cooperative and get them into a place that is quiet and ask them what their purpose is and collect any documentation they have, submit that to legal before taking any further steps. We've also made it very clear that it needs to be the

272principal who's involved and collaborating with this person. So this is I just we don't want to incentivize something to escalate that doesn't need to escalate. We want to be accommodating. But working, giving ourselves time to work with our legal team to understand the purpose, understand the documentation that's being presented, and then understand from our legal team what the best next steps are. And in the meantime, if we need to get our team over there to support the school, I think it would be helpful if we put in something that says, for the resolve that every principal will be giving, given a set of instructions, guidelines, however you want to say it to, a deal with any Ice official, that comes because some of the emails we're getting, they're saying you didn't give us all the

273steps, we don't know what to do. Teachers don't know what to do. But if we say principals will have a set of guidelines. Yes. Okay. That has happened. So. Right. So let's add that getting it now the principals principals receive detailed instructions or however it makes sense to do that. And change can the district provide us better language using the policies that so that we're not contradicting. So if we can get better language is comfortable with it, then we'll take that third, the last paragraph and and just make it about what principals need to be given. Can we do that. Yeah. Just align line. It's the language that is the title of that document. So I'm going to put a comment into this one. When I send it back to Jennifer that just says align

274with guidance. Given to principals. Yeah. Just set an expectation that guidance is given to principals is I think what I hear Mary suggesting. I, I just have a question. I'm not for the resolution for superintendent drill and that, Erin and I were able to, speak with a woman who leads an organization that just supports immigrant families and some of their guidance. They have this whole packet, and they've had, like, the Mexican consulate there and just a lot of resources in their packet. They recommend families sign a power of attorney. And I think we don't we recommend we know kids have to have a sign who can pick them up at school, which is not the same thing. Do we give any guidance on that? Is I just have me. So on our, Frequently Asked Questions

275page, we have a bunch of resources, one of which is how to identify a person of trust in the absence in your absence. There's a whole format that our family ambassadors are working with, through the, the state's immigration support documents and pages. So those are the resources that Tara's team is using with families who need the one on one and specific support. And that's everything from, you know, who are my emergency contacts. And I see up to date. Do we do we have a plan for, making sure those folks know they're my emergency contact in case something happens. So they're going through and using those tools that are on the Colorado State immigration website. What are my rights as an immigrant, family? Those are all being utilized by our family ambassadors, and we have that

276in here. Be it further resolved, Jeffco Public Schools will encourage and assist parents and guardians to make a personal plan to ensure there is emergency contact in place in the event they are not available. By updating their emergency contact information for students, either at the school or an infinite campus. Maybe instead of saying by updating and let's say including updating, because then it does, it's not just that you're going to do that if if there's more to the plan that they need and that our family ambassadors are helping them to create, that's in there. But but we have something in here that says we're going to help make sure that they have something in place, like something other than just their own internal plans. I don't think they we as a district, need to know

277what their family and or either. I just it was it was she really pointed it out that that was something families didn't know was that they should probably do a part. That's just my question at least is going to. Yeah. So could you connect that person with Tara opinion so that we could make that, information available? Oh, not recently, but okay. Yeah. Want one of the resources in the, FAQ page is the Colorado Legal services for immigrant families. So, you know, but we can connect with Tara and just see if this power of attorney question has been something that our ambassadors are aware of and can talk to families about. What other question in the newsletters that go out to parents can this, at least the FAQ page, be included in it? It has been

278in the newsletters. Yeah. And and? Across the board as well as the community update and I think and the staff are team Jeffco brief and I think this month across the board can have this, resolution in it and sort of be very broad in it. Yeah. About statement about it, because I think that goes to a lot of people. Our listserv, which is 200,000. Did you want something else, Daniel? So I've sent that version to, Jennifer and copied Mary. And it can be recirculated then for finalize and legal review and all those good things. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. I have one other question. At some point, whether it's tonight or next week, we will need guidance on how you want this situated in your agenda next week. So if you want to

279in consent or if you want it as a separate action item. So something that Mary will have to give us some guidance on, I would say I would prefer a separate action, so that we can have short comment. We've done a lot of in-depth conversation here tonight, which I appreciate. But I would prefer that this particular draft, given community interest in it, be given its own space. Yeah, I think that's true. Yep. Oh, boy. Yeah we do. You're right, you're right. Okay. So, yeah, I think this is good. And, Jennifer can get it out to us so we can all review it before, next week. And, I wanted to bring up something that Aaron and I learned about, at, the Ncbi, or whatever, and SBA, conference we went to some, boards have subcommittees for policy

280writing policies, and you can have it just be ad hoc. And it's just good for a year even. And, so then in the future, when we want to have a resolution and or a new policy, we've got two people identified to work on it to get it started. Yeah. I would like for us to consider instituting in our policy. I think it's g our governance board governance policy 14 that, looks over our how we introduce policy and how what that process is like. And I think we could add language in there to establish a two person subcommittee made up of board members, to consider policy, language or resolution, language when necessary. So if I need to write something, some official language and submit it and follow our already existing policy, I will do that. Okay.

281So so Aaron will, take the lead on starting that. And do we want then we got one person who is at this point, do we want to now identify a second person or do we want to, make that ask next week if we're going to change that policy? You're going to have to it makes more sense to choose your people after the policies be changed in the past. Okay. But Aaron's going to change that policy. Okay. This is my head's up that I will be presenting to you, President Parker, for our GPF 14 policy, an addendum to that existing policy to establish a policy subcommittee for the board for it. And she's volunteers tribute your money. Yes. Yeah. Thumbs up. Okay. Well, thanks. Well, we might have, received criticism for being late and getting our,

282resolution out, but I think we will, be the only board that did a public discussion of how we created it so people will understand it. Okay, then we can move on, I think, to the last item on our agenda this evening. The board will hear a preview of the February 13th action items, including items that will be included on the consent agenda. The superintendent will also provide the board a preview of upcoming board agenda items. So I'll hand it over to Superintendent Darling. Right. Thank you, President Parker. Next week, you all have a few things on your consent agenda. The first is approval. The first two, our approval of monitoring reports, 1.1, and then the combined monitoring report of 3.2 and 3.4. To remind the board you all studied these monitoring reports in January. And

283they'll be attached in your consent agenda. You'll have, as you do every month. Almost every month I get supplemental funds notification, and you can see the details of those awards and grants in the table below. You will have the approval of the contract for Twig and service, which is related to the study of the English language arts curriculum that you saw today. And then twig, of course, is one of the science curriculums that we're also piloting. You will have an approval of a contract amendment for a scent, and the Red Rocks Community College, which is basically a 50 year high school program that let students participate in concurrent enrollment the year after 12th grade to actually get, some credit for their first year of college in their fifth year. So it's a nice benefit for

284kiddos who might not be quite on track, to go ahead and get both their high school diploma as well as some college credit. Which is great. You will also have the adoption of the secondary ela, resources and you'll. That's similar. That's what you also studied tonight. And then the Fletcher Miller ffa ni furniture, fixtures and equipment contract, which is very exciting. And I just want to highlight that of these fixtures and furniture and equipment, there are many specialized things that we will be, ordering for that school. And the very special students that it serves, you will receive also you'll be, there will be an approval of a proposed tax increment revenue agreement with the Lakewood redevelopment Authority. This is similar to what you have approved with Wheat Ridge in the past. And it just allows

285them to, do some tax increments in a redevelopment area, for urban renewal. I anticipate you also will have not on your consent agenda, but we will be revising your agenda next week to have an action item for the resolution that was just discussed. And so I see Jennifer shaking her head, saying, I got that all right. Going on to March. Just a quick preview of your agenda items for your study session. You'll see pretty typical, legislative update, which is typical of this time of year. We're going to talk about the budget development for next fiscal year. We're going to give you an update on where we are with our strategic capital master plan work. The city program, and changes that have occurred in those programs to make them more sustainable and efficient for families who

286need them most, while also trying our best to maintain some flexibility for families, you also need some flexibility. We're going to talk about the ERP contracts because it will then I think be on your consent agenda, the next month and then property surplus. We we'll have an update on where we have some of our property surplus. In your regular meeting. We have a tentative executive session. And I think we may have a arbitrators decision to discuss that's actually going to be in March. The arbitrator's decision. But we may have a recommendation for dismissal of a teacher. Okay. So the march so we may be adding an executive session next week for the purpose of a personnel matter. Okay. So there's that. And then in March you will have an executive session for the purpose of

287your consideration of a arbitrator's decision in a grievance situation, which we'll talk more about in March. We have you have your dedicated public comment for negotiations. You'll have the second quarter financial report and a dialog with the financial, advisory committee, state adequacy studies, that, you know, we did these financial the state did two different, financial adequacy studies. And we have asked for Tracy Rainey from the Colorado School Finance Project to come and speak with our board and help you understand and go over, give you time to, learn from her about what those adequacy studies said, especially as we're all dealing with our school finance, issues that were that we discussed earlier tonight in April for your study session, you'll have again, the legislative update. You'll have two additional monitoring reports, 2.2 and 2.6. Some more

288time with our fabulous JSB hearing our student voice. We'll continue with our budget development. And you'll learn more about school and department allocations and you'll receive an update. I know this has been something the board's been wondering about on where we are with our environmental sustainability efforts that we started, this year now. So that's that's going to be exciting in the regular meeting, we have an executive session that's tentative depending upon what's going on at the time. 20 minute public comment for negotiations, you'll hear from the CCaC and, you will, be approving, the board will have the opportunity to approve the monitoring part of 1.4. And then in May, again, dedicated public comment. That shouldn't be there. Sorry. That's in your regular meeting. You'll have a legislative update. We'll have the proposed budget that needs

289to be presented to you prior to June when you have the final budget. Tonight, and, April 10th, it says Monitoring Report 1.4. Yeah. When do we vote on accepting the monitoring reports? 2.2 and 2.6 from the study session. It would be in the April regular meeting under the consent agenda. What's not listed here is all your consent agenda items. So you'll have the monitoring report 1.4, sort of as a study session in the April regular meeting. Does that make sense? Yeah. And so we just don't list all the consent agenda items, for your regular meetings more just that action or study things. Okay. So 2526 proposed budget EAP services, which I know has been an interest of the board to hear about as well. The charter school application for Free Horizon Montessori. The board will

290recall that Free Horizon Montessori is currently was a charter school, is currently an innovation school, and has elected to return back to a charter school. So you'll hear, their application. In this study session, two additional monitoring reports. But you can see there and then in the regular meeting we will have my mid-year check in, in executive session, for the superintendent's evaluation, you will have the Jefferson Area Articulation Area plan coming to you, depending upon how this next round, these next few rounds of engagement go, TD Pac will be coming to talk to you, one of your board committees, you will review your board calendar for the 2526 school year. Can you believe it? Already? And hear from the DAC. And then in June, of course, we have the budget, for adoption. We have the Q3

291financials for this year. You will be doing a monitoring. We'll look at that monitoring report, El 11 on school safety. And I think as part of that, an opportunity at some point right around this time to tour the D'Angelo's center for, no, that's in March. Sorry. Okay. So by that we'll have to you'll be able to see that you can bring it to the table when we study L11. And we will be bringing to you a final report that we've been working on through your board committees on safe and secure environments. Just sharing more about that work. You will also have, per our conversation earlier and, Miss Kenworthy, your your questions around the cell phone research that we've been doing. We'll be able to share with you a report of where we are with the

292pilots that are going on in Jeffco, which will be helpful as we go into next year, especially if some legislation is passed. And then you will adopt an appropriate the 2526 budget in June. I know, just one quick thing to I spoke with Jennifer, today about adding, a section to our, board docs, possibly in conjunction with what we keep track of for questions. But, to keep track of all the action items that board members have asked for follow ups on certain things. So it'll be visible. And we can then track them and find out, you know, when they were completed, who completed it, whatever. And we'll see which ones are still outstanding. So that so that brings us to the end of today's agenda. We will stand adjourned. Our next scheduled meeting of the board

293is a regular meeting scheduled for 5:00 on February 13th at the Ed Center. Good night.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.