001e for e e e all right welcome to the study session for the Jordan Board of Education for Tuesday February 11th 2025 we're grateful that you are joining us today um present today are all members of the Board of Education the board attorney Mr Paul vanman and then our superintendent Anthony Godfrey associate superintendent Mike Anderson and our business administrator John Larson and a welcome back to Lisa large so we'll go ahead and get started on our agenda with agenda item a a review of proposed revisions to administrative policy DP 338 reimbursement of licensed employees elected to public office Dr president can I make a motion before we begin please I move that we suspend Robert's Rule of Order 3 colon 10 that says that we refer to the president or chief of the committee or
002the B as Mr President or Madame President it makes our president a little uncomfortable and I think her Comfort is more important than following this Rule and so I move that we suspend that rule three col and 10 I'll second if that's indefinitely definitely I'll second it oh I wanted to second that one all right moved by Mr denford seconded by Mr Robinson discussion does it really make you feel uncomfortable um I I feel like how do you feel about it now after thinking about it having a couple weeks to think about it I'm making the motion at her request oh so you just asked him to make the okay yeah I feel confident in our board's ability to follow the intent of that rule which is that we debate issues not people and I
003think that our board does a great job of that and that we could move forward without that level of formality um can I ask just for a point of clarification so not only will we not be saying Madam president you're okay if we address each other during the discussion or the debate or do we still address you as Miss George or my motion was three colon 10 which is only her title okay do do do we still refer to us as numbers also there's that's not a hard rule it's just a we're reasonable I mean we're not going to bend over backwards but I was trying to figure out everyone's number including my own me too no I I would be really comfortable without that as well the spirit of that isn't to bend over
004backwards in the formality the spirit is you're not you're more likely to attack the person if you're if it gets to that personal level but I wouldn't hesitate to say what Daryl just said was you're not going to call me 01 I'm not going to call you 01 make it so number one I was just grateful that I'm number one so Nikki um do you want us just to call you Nikki or Miss George or do you I am perfectly comfortable with either of those okay I was trained by a board member who told me when you're referring to each other use U Mr Miz but that is just my habit because of that training but I'm totally comfortable if you call me Nikki I don't I don't need to hang anything on formality as
005long as we're having civil conversations and productive conversations to me that's the priority and I'm I'm wondering if any other board members have preferences on how they're addressed I am fine being called Lisa so does anybody have a strong preference then maybe we should call the question okay so we have a motion on this the table to suspend um 310 310 in Robert's Rules of Order the formality of addressing the president as Madame President all in favor say I I I and any opposed all right that motion passes unanimously fantastic news thank you for stepping in all right let's hop back over to agenda item a Dr Godfrey okay following discussion with the executive committee we put together a draft of DP 338 there was significant previous discussion around this policy and the change that
006we um that was proposed by that executive committee was simply to eliminate item 2 C from the policy and to combine to make it so that the policy applies to all so it the subject is now special leave for employees elected to public office and for those listening 2C currently reads employees who receive financial remuneration for their service will reimburse the district 50% of the daily rate of a licensed employee on salary level one or the entire amount received if less than 50% of the daily rate of a licensed employee on salary level one for each of the days of work missed because of their public service so that's the only part of the polic that would be eliminated the policy would be changed to apply to all employees if these changes were to be
007approved any questions um I have one question so when it says employees elected to public office this is to be um may be granted leave to fulfill the responsibilities of their office the May means that they will work it out with Administration that's right so instead of instead of trying to prescribe exactly what that needs to look like in order to accommodate both filling the duties of an elected office and the duties of an employee there's the ability to to make that work depending on the elected office and the particular position held by the employee I always love taking words out so yeah streamlining policies y I think this Linds us better with our practice anyway so okay other questions can I just confirm that uh you feel that this policy is sufficient enough for
008you to work with employees that there's enough language there that gives you guys leeway to work with any situation that might arise in this instance thank you yes I think that that that was part of our discussion is really going over the language and there actually is I think enough flexibility to make sure the job gets done and that there's flexibility to fill the duties of office thank you welcome okay so president I move that we direct staff to bring back for our final approval at our next meeting a combined DP 338 combining it with DP 338b and eliminating paragraph 2C okay will you say that one more time I move that we direct staff to present for a final approval next meeting a combined DP 338 and a DP 338b in which we eliminate
009paragraph 2 C second okay so we have a motion from Mr denford a second by Mr Barnett that we direct staff to bring back to the next meeting a um a version combining DP 338 and DP 338b eliminating paragraph 2 C did I say that right correct Perfect all right any additional discussion I just have a question about the motion would it have been okay to say I move that we approve the policy um as presented to us in board dos you could yeah move to does it need to be so specific about what is being struck and what no the you could say the proposed revisions the proposed revisions okay I think so right I think as long as she understands what your proposing and that the minutes get written down as to what
010was proposed that's what's important so as long as it gets recorded appropriately and she knows what you're motioning okay perfect uh so we have a motion and a second any additional discussion all right all in favor of the motion say I I any oppos n okay motion passes um all right let's move into agenda Item B legislative review Ms wood and Dr Anderson Dr Anderson will be reviewing and updating some of the bills thank you and good afternoon as of this morning I looked it up and there are 755 bills that have been filed and heard in the legislature in the previous years that's that number has been north of a thousand so um we still have as of today we're at the the official 3-we Mark uh there's about 3 weeks and change left
011so it's almost halftime and you know we're still got lots of game to play this morning I thought I'd start with just a um and by the way out of those 755 bills um there's 87 that uh we have that we're actively tracking jlc's um joint legislative committee has a tracking sheet that we put on board docks with the positions and and the summary of the bill bills in case you're interested so you know that's there are more bills than that out there that are education related um but 87 that were actively uh taking a look at and tracking and I want to update you on a few of those but this morning was the last last uh meeting of the public education Appropriations Committee this is the committee that reviews all the funding mechanisms
012the line items um and so forth in public education and this is the day that they make their official recommendations to what we call Executive appr Appropriations Committee and so that what happened in there there's a couple of things of note um they did announce in there that uh you know about onethird or to about one half of the education budget depending on the metrics or you the overall state budget depending on the metrics you use is going to public education um they did say there is no new ongoing money that they are able to use and there's very little onetime money that was a quote from this morning from the from the chair um the Appropriations Committee went back and forth on the recommendation for the wpu it's the funding unit we use um
013we get an automatic 4% allocation based on the compromise truck a few years ago and they went back and forth on whether it should be a a 05% above that or a 1% above that and finally they agreed on 1% and so the the recommended Wu um increase would be 5% coming out of public education Appropriations again that doesn't that's not binding until the end of the session when the executive Appropriations comes out with the bill of bills and the actual allocations if that makes sense I want to get back to that uh to some other things regarding that when we talk about Senate Bill 102 and just a minute um but other notable um marks there was $20 million set aside for a Statewide uh student information system software that USB has been has
014been uh advocating for for quite some time um and then there was an there was a request for $40 million for the Utah fits-all uh scholarship that ties into HB 455 which is being deemed as the Utah fits-all cleanup bill um initial the initial ask for this bill was 80 million and today they trimmed it back to uh 40 million recommendation that can change again in executive of Appropriations um on HP 455 the UFA cleanup bill um keep in mind when we talk dollars that that a 1% increase in the wpu is about equal to $435 million so if the UT fits-all is requesting $40 million or they're requesting that for that bill that's equivalent almost to a 1% increase in the wpu it's just good to kind of keep keep it in context um
015455 would uh it it does increase the oversight for what can be can be used in the scholarship money um prohibits scholarship money from being used for non-educational expenses like chaperon uh entertainment season tickets subscriptions uh to entertainment venues ski passes or lift tickets clothing Furniture among other things so that what that bill does in in in addition to um the allocation that's being requested thought I'd update you really quick on U um a bill from representative Tracy Miller HB 184 talks about the land trust uh processes it clarifies some uh what's needed in in school action plans and it also has a requirement to train on the open and public meeting uh meetings Act and the land trust process itself um which is includes watching care carefully our carryover amounts by way of note
016in our district we're uh we are required to provide uh training for our school Community councils especially those that have more than 10% of their carryover carried over for two consecutive years right now just for context we do have two schools that have had uh overages or carryover of greater than 10% um two out of our 63 schools that receive land trust funds when we talked with the Land Trust office there are districts uh throughout the state that have well over half of their schools carrying over uh greater than 10% so they may went out of their way to to tell us that we're doing a great job with our carryover and our training and that's a that's a kudos to our our principles and our school Community councils who who really do a good
017job of keeping track of their of their funding so I think we're performing very well in that area um and by the way if I'm talking too fast or if you want to put me on pause to ask about any Bill uh please feel free um I'll just move on to HB 344 which is the uh school fees bill this bill um since it came out last week has been fast-tracked it passed unanimously in the committee uh for the house committee it passed 72 to1 in the house yes I did look up the house member that voted no I don't know why he voted no but he did and uh it will now be voted uh or heard in the senate committee and we anticipate that being passed as early as next week um and
018done so that that is nice because it it it will now inform some of our our practices moving forward with how we how we deal with school fees and the proposals that we're going to make um on our fee schedule what changes would that bill make um good question thank you that was uh exactly what I was going to get into first of all um it it still does not there's a new definition for extracurricular activities which is very helpful remember the last definition was was pretty nebulous and left left open to interpretation didn't allow for a lot of fees to be charged um of note in this bill is all students in high school must have a pathway for a fee-free graduation um option doesn't mean that they can take any classes they want
019for uh for no fees but it does require us to have in our in our high schools a fee free pathway for a student and that is not required to be in place until next year so we have about a year with our high schools to help figure that out and we'll be coming and talking to you in short order about that with Mr Sorenson and Mr Curtis when was that require uh next year beginning of 25 the fall of 26 next next uh the year after next school year Bill sponsor mentioned to me that Mike Anderson had been a tremendous help for him on this bill so he is very appreciative that's that's kind and generous I might add um he's the bill sponsor has has been wonderful to work with um we've been
020on the phone back and forth several times throughout the last couple weeks just bouncing uh thoughts and ideas on on different things um to get back to Mr uh Dr Robinson's questions about what it what else it does there still are no fees allowed for textbooks with some limited exceptions when it comes to higher education there postsecondary education textbooks uh School equipment instruction C supplies what they refer to as common education expenses and that's defined in the bill um you may the board May charge fees for expenses related to specific courses or programs um think field trips think uh musical rentals culinary arts you know specific items like that unless they're deemed what again we're putting in air quotes common education expenses that you would I'm not sure we can charge for sugar in a
021in a in a Foods class but if it's beyond that or if there's something be uh you know in addition to maybe an extra special uh bunt cake I don't know I'm throwing it out there but we could we can charge for Extraordinary projects like that um we can also charge for postsecondary related courses think IB um AP and concurrent enrollment we can charge for extracurricular activities and take a class during the day yes yep that was that definition was clarified in in the statute it find specifically what are extracurricular activities we currently charging for the L courses yes we have we have some fees for our AP and concurrent classes and those can still be charged under this bill we were in the process of of adjusting those because based on last year's Bill
022we weren't going to be able to do that so um driver education can also be charged uh fe4 any questions on HB 344 school fees are you happy with this well it's it's a huge Improvement um it is it's very it's a lot more clear the obvious concern here is there's a huge deficit there while it may the deficit now is diminished because we can charge for things like extracurricular um fees there's still a huge shortfall when it comes to registration expenses or fees and and just covering class fees the common education expenses and that's to the tune of you know $2 to $33 million at least if not uh more than that and so that's that's the obvious glaring problem with this bill we appreciate the clarity we appreciate um them listening to us
023and helping you know clean up a lot of things but there's still and and by the way In fairness there is onetime money that's was allocated with last year's bill but by our calculations that won't even see us through one one school year House Bill 267 is the collective bargaining bill just by way of update since we didn't since last time we talked that bill in its original form did pass the Senate 16-13 narrowly but passed nonetheless um it did not need to go back for concurrence in the house because there was talk about a potential compromise in that bill um those talks and negotiations fell apart and so they they just went back and reverted to the original form of the bill that passed the house narrowly pass the Senate narrowly and it is
024on to the governor's desk for for his signature changes made to that one there were not changes from the time it passed the house um there were proposals and there were different amendments that were out there okay but again those those talks just kind of broke down over time and and they just never could get to consensus on a on a compromise and so it just reverted right back to the original bill which does forbid um collective bargaining um and it also does not allow employees of these groups such as the UEA for example they cannot participate in the Utah Retirement Systems it doesn't mean doesn't mean members of UEA or doesn't mean members of Jaa if you're a teacher you can absolutely participate in the URS system it's the employees of those of those
025professional organizations that aren't public employees but work for a group that represents public employees if that makes sense um and there are other Provisions in the bill that we talked about earlier but um like I said it's passed both houses and is on to the governor's desk there had been talk about uh like 50% of the organization but that is no longer a part of it anymore that's correct that was part that was part of the talk and the amendment uh proposal and the compromise where if you had 50% plus one of the entire group's membership that voted in favor of having that group represent them in collective bargaining that they could still do that that just never came to pass pass it never came to fruition so that's a that's a moot point at
026this at this okay juncture how long does the governor get to make a decision um if he doesn't sign it he can sign at any time I think the bill goes into effect July 1 but uh if he doesn't sign it there's what's called it automatically goes into law if he doesn't sign it oh okay okay um sb1 137 um as of this morning passed the Senate education committee this week 5 to1 this is one that has a lot of opposition to it it's there's been a call to action through the joint legislative committee um 37 or 137 oh sorry I thank you3 I appreciate that there's there is a 137 out there so if I it was a slip of the tongue I apologize we're talking uh s SP 37 gotcha and this one
027is a bill that takes the minimum basic tax rate and it changes the it changes the bucket that that money is put into and I have John here to my left that I'm in my peripheral view of anything if you have any questions that on the technical level he can speak to but the concern here is is that it takes it out of the education bucket and moves it to the general bucket that can be used for um for other purposes to be Frank this is probably a a a bill to address what didn't happen with Amendment a it gives the legisl more flexibility uh by sending that that tax stream into a general bucket it gives them the flexibility to De with it what they will um there's still you know requirements statutory requirements
028to fund education we've received um numerous assurances that that would still be funded but there's that element of a lack of assurance and it's not coming into our bucket so to speak it's going into a general bucket which is concerning that's the extent of my lay um interpretation of that bill I'll refer to Mr Larson for any other specific I have a question in the the document that's on uh board dos the summary says this bill amends Provisions related to the minimum basic tax that school districts impose so this is a tax that's attributed to the school district that's correct it's a tax that we impose and and have no control over and there's um the bill is is proposing that that that tax that is assigned to us yes that the public sees as
029coming from the the board basically the state wants is proposing this bill is proposing that that money be assigned to a general fund and it can be given to anyone that's correct in fact I spoke with the sponsor of the bill prior to this meeting just minutes before and I I put that out there as a major concern for us in the spirit of transparency when you get your property tax notice even though that money is now going into a general fund who's still going to appear on the property tax notice as leving that fund it's still going to be the Jordan School District and changes right they could debate that they could and and the sponsors seemed open to that um perhaps in he seemed open to the idea but perhaps not this year
030um why would we Levy the tax and if we're not going to get it why what motivates us to go out to if I understand it right a truth in taxation yeah this is the our ability to to take a truth of Taxation anymore I think there's a difference there that that you don't have the the direct control over the rate of this the state controls that is that correct John yeah in today's world before this bill the state still mandates the school board must Levy the basic school levy and they tell the School Board what it shall be you have no choice in that but in today's world the proceeds from that Levy come to the school district and the state then withholds it State money for whatever amount that we receive from that
031tax they deduct that this bill says the money would go to the state instead and then the state would send us all of the state money that they promised and not subtract it so so it go to the state we are still mandated to Levy it it still counts as our tax we still have to sign off on it we have no choice in the matter just like before but now the money goes to the state is remitted to the state it directs the county treasure to remit it to the state and not to the local Lea and then the state will send us the full amount of the wpu the wpu in today's world State promised this they subtract what we receive in the basic Levy and they give us the net this is
032just grossing that up but again but there's yeah and so it's sending it to the state's general fund not to the state's education fund sending it to the state's general fund I wanted to clarify that too is not our general fund so Mr Larsson has stated that several different ways let's see if I've got it straight the state tells us to this elected board you have to Levy a tax and you have to Levy it at this basic amount they're now saying then once the school board has done what we have required them to do we're going to take that money and put it in a general fund at the state level did I get that right Mr lson yes but we promise we'll you we promise we'll give you the same amount didn't Robin
033Hood do this TR us that's the end of my commentary Mr Robin obviously the the worries center around protecting uh local control and stable education funding um it it it's in essence creating a new system for collecting and distributing Revenue um for districts and and I think in the spirit of transparency I think it's it's pretty we want an authentic um showing of who's actually leving the bill so I I would argue that that that property tax notice should not say the Jordan School District if if it's not being going into our fund for Education the the reason I emphasize that is precisely because of what Mr Anderson Dr Anderson just pointed out is that over the years there's been a lot of confusion from people about who's leving what tax and why who's responsible
034for their property taxes and who isn't and I we've we've been striving for Clarity for a long time and this doesn't seem to move us in that direction but if they take our name off the property tax seems to me that's a good deal that's not part of the package at this point is that correct it's not the name on the property tax is not part of the bill at this point again the the sponsor seemed open to the idea of it in the future bill but not for this one and it I don't know if I would term it and maybe Mr Larson can chime in as a good deal for us I also don't think that it would be classified by by the legislature as being a bad deal it's it's going to
035the same thing's going to happen as just coming out of a general fund rather than an education fund at this point property tax is one of the most confusing taxes we have yeah if they want to put their name on it and take control of it that yeah I would add it's also one of the most stable that we have um so that's that's another one it's not subject to the can you say what the impetus of this is the benefit thank you good yeah I think the impetus centered around what happened or what more than what didn't happen with Amendment a where there was going to be given more flexibility to cost control of the ear Mark yeah and so this is just a if it's going if it's going from the education general
036fund to just the state general fund bucket I'm picturing as if I have buckets here think of turning the spet to the general fund bucket it gives them more flexibility which you know one can hardly blame them for wanting more flexibility but it runs the risk of us not you know losing some assurances and some some funding oh but but I would infer if they want increased flexibility with our money that might be flexibility to not keep at our money exactly and that's why jlc did a action on this exactly right it's it's a lot of trust that they're asking for here we don't have any guarantees once it goes into the general f but the truth is they've always had a way around it they always have had a way around it so if
037they wanted if they wanted to bypass that they could anytime they wanted to Larson could I get some clarification on what's currently happening so you said that we Levy the tax and the state takes some of it and then gives some back would you explain that one more time sorry like do we get all of it back or they take some and then they only give some of it back currently they'll they will calculate how much money we are to receive so let's just say we're a school district of one student and we receive and I'm going to make it the wpu simple and say $4,500 the school district of one student is to receive $4,500 from the state but the state also says but local school board we mandate you shall you must Levy
038this property tax called the basic property tax by the way there's three more they mandate to that we haven't talked about that this bill doesn't touch but uh you you shall mandate you you shall Levy this tax and let's just say that tax yields $2,000 so we collect $2,000 on that property tax that we were mandated to do and then the state gives us $2,500 so if property values change and there's increased if there's increased property tax revenues the beneficiary of that is the state because the state sends us less money than as a result so if it was the 4500 and we collected 6,000 then they would only give us back 45 and they'd keep that extra got it okay okay I got it thank you now we have greased that wheel many times
039in growing District because the fudge has always been we collect more than we anticipated because of new growth and now we're losing potentially that the state's the beneficiary there if this bill passes um I don't know sorry go ahead John some people think when a new property or something is built in the school district that we are the beneficiaries of of those monies the real beneficiary under the basic Levy the board Levy the voted Levy and the charter Levy all those funds are minimum rates set by the state so the state benefits from all of all four of those we benefit on two levies the actually a portion of the board capital and debt that's why you'll see capital and debt consistently fall as we pay off bonds and so forth right bonds paid off
040new growth and uh property tax collection President George mentioned that there is a call to action through the uh joint legislative committee I know other uh education advocacy groups are also um concerned about this bill uh just as a way of notice on the status of it it passed senate committee unanimously 4 to zero and passed the Senate recently um just a couple of days ago 19 to8 and so it's onto the house it's been assigned to the house revenue and Taxation committee um as of yesterday and uh no no word yet on when that may be may be on I haven't checked the agendas but could be heard in Senate rev and tax as soon as this week it's not going to education yeah there it is interesting how they they choose to some
041committees this one is I mean it can be argued that because it's a taxing related bill that goes to Revan tax but yeah yeah not one that that most Educators and so forth would look at the agenda right yeah it's it won't impact net dollars but there are accounting rules that are at play here too that are very very concerning about how we will have to display this in our financial reports it doesn't touch our net dollars but just in my world uh the way we display things it may look uh very wrong as a result of one entity mandating another but that entity getting the money but we had to imp the next bill that is also likewise um concerning along with Senate Bill 37 is Senate Bill 102 um which eliminates has the
042risk of eliminating certain programs and putting them into the flexible allation we did review this I believe last board meeting but there are certain designated programs which would be up for review in an automatic Sunset unless specifically um um authorized they would roll up into what we call the flexible allocation again the theme is that they're they're wanting to give us more flexibility but historically in fact John confirmed this every time they've rolled something up into the flexible allocation it has been sarily taken away from us after that last year the most recent examples are they rolled up our library allocation and our Nur School nurses allocation into the flexible allocation and those went away or the equivalent of those monies went away so there is really no there's no comfort in rolling it up
043into the flexible allocation if anything these things should be put into the wpu which is much much harder to get at not impossible but harder and has an automatic growth U function associated with it to increase it um over time the programs that would be reviewed in this bill are concurrent enrollment um accelerated student programs uh gifted and talented so forth concurrent enrollment um student health and counseling support the tssp the teacher and student success program that's additional monies um given to are currently given to teachers the digital teaching learning Grant and the teacher and student success account tssa as well as DLI um of note the Beverly Taylor senson um line item was spared that was carved out so um as I said every program that's gone into flexible allocation in the past has
044been eliminated at one point every one and so we've got concerns with that most concerning this is kind of that's that's the top stuff that's the that's the things that catches people's eyes and and has headlines about DLI and so forth but the most concerning part of this bill is the last line of the bill where it says in general terms oh yeah this bill also require uh repeals section 53f d2305 which is the professional staff and weighted pupil units um item or funding mechanism and that is equivalent in our district to 20.5 million and that has been tied to growth it would not be tied to growth anymore with that that's the the money we use for funding additional steps for teachers that have been received further education think like psychologists think teachers with
045master's degrees um other you know other things like that Mr Larsson could also speak to this in much more detail than I can but it by eliminating these programs we lose money we we will lose money because they're not tied to growth anymore and so that's a we've always been told um there's a security there but with this bill that would go away anything else you'd add to that we Lo the growth which is approximately not only the 20.5 when it's done away but the 820,000 but we also lose voted and board guarantee money because that is based on the wpus by removing this from the wpus we will lose just my quick calculations here $5.8 million that was not part of the discussion on the hill and then when the session is over they'll
046tell us how much they increased education right yes that is definitely the concern I mean the 5% proposed increase on the wpu if it's offset by $21 million here and you know a couple other million dollars here and there and everywhere that offsets a wpu increase and so the net increase could be substantially less there was maybe a case in point years ago and I want maybe I'll look this up it's in our budget book but there was a year where the legislature cut a line item sent it to flexible allocation and removed just a a very large amount of money the the uh wpu that year was increased 9% but the net was a loss to the district of a lot uh because of this similar type of movement so even though the wpu
047went up huge that year and the press and everybody celebrated what a wonderful thing it was we actually had a loss in funding that year because they move things off and put it down and cut it off but then use the money that they saved by increasing the wpu it's just headlines and people don't do enough homework to understand the net loss they just hear oh yeah there's a 4% wpu increase okay there's the headline again back to the headline principle I mean we we are concerned about losing programs such as DLI and and and others but those are pennies on the dollar compared to that last line item which which reduces or I should say rolls up and eliminates the the staff allocation the professional staff weighted pupil unit so that's a concern we
048used like 90% of the wpu increase would we be able to keep a lot of those things just one year like one year we decide we're going to use 90% of the wpu to still fund these things that are kind of going away is that of the wpu increase um you might be able to you might be able to argue that on some of these line items but I couldn't do that on professional staff because it was part of the wpu it was part of all those calculations above the line so to speak and so I I I it it would not be true there on some of the other line items um eliminating programs eliminating uh some of the requirements go with them there could be an argument that there's some savings there netted
049against but not with Pro not with this line of professional staff that's what was fascinating to me was the focus was on all these little teeny programs and not the real huge one that was in the last line of the bill that makes because our constituents experience those programs they don't know what professional staff and weighted pupil units mean but I think if they understood that those are the people that make those programs work they be a little more concerned and I think In fairness um and John can can clean this up if if I don't say it right it's not that that entire funding mechanism is going away it's being rolled into something else and reiven to us but we just stand to lose the the increase the growth and so we do lose
050money on it's not that the 20.5 million is going away entirely for now for now yeah we just lose the 820,000 we were about to get on a wpu increase on that money this year not defending it not justifying it I just want to make it clear that we're not losing 20.5 million we're probably losing the increase that he just and then where does it go again will you remind me flexible allocation so the one that has historically been eliminated okay thanks yeah yeah it's it's so my understanding is that they're saying they're increasing the wpu but then these other things are happening um so it kind of evens it out so there's not really an increase in wpu or a net loss well I think over I think overall there will be a net
051increase to the to the funding but it's certainly not going to be what the newspapers and everybody says it is okay yeah it's going to be off of that just this one line line item is going to be um you know a a large decrease from that I'll say it for you um this is one another one I think is worth keeping track of sorry I don't have a lot of good news in this update I'm afraid could I ask one more question on that last one um all of the things you listed that it said it was going to affect um are those listed somewhere can I get what that list is yes they're in the text of Senate Bill 102 they're in the text they are yeah and if you look at cabit
052102 on le. utah.gov sb102 and it will yeah the new the changes would be either in blue striketh through that they would no longer be doing that but I think these are in red if I okay I see it thank you yep you bet The Challenge on the repeal is they don't put that in red because it's in the repealer sections at the very bottom yeah at the very end it says this bill repeals and then it goes to the section that's why it doesn't catch our attention because when we scan bills we go for the red letters and we go for the blue strike through to see what was taken out and what was added to the repeal section doesn't have that same uh strike through uh text and font yeah yeah you again
053the last of the of the good news that uh I'm afraid I I I really looked for a bill that I haven't heard anything I mean Miller was good yeah I'll give thank you thank you for reminding me that I was appreciative OFA Miller exactly so thank you I should have I should have ended with that one so there was a somewhat of a high note but um 237 um it's going to be heard in in Senate Revan tax uh this week it deals with green belt taxes and it's a repeal of the green belt taxes I I actually believe this one is maybe done with good intent um but Jordan District receives $1.2 million in Green Belt tax each year um it deals with look backs and and and so forth we don't know
054there's not a great mechanism I understand to to to know exactly how much we've lost in the past or what the look back is but Statewide the fiscal note indicates that there's going to be a setback of $13 million so it does have pretty big consequences for us in the school district so that because back in the day when we had wheat Fields all over the place we were primarily a ra agriculture district is that the roots of the loss here it yeah well it's any any Farmland that's turned into something else becomes a green belt tax um and then it goes for five years and then it can be out of green belt but to Bryce's point we do have we do have a lot of developments that were once farmland farmland and are
055being developed so that's where this comes into play and we you know for being an urban area we still have a lot of Farmland in our district it's surprising $1.2 million of it every years I think the other the other consequence of this is yes we we lose that 1.2 and so what does that mean if we have a a deficit of that what does it mean for our taxpayers means they're going to get an increase of that amount across the board who who primarily benefits from this bill what would you say benefits from this bill the most uh counties are given the money to uh try to support Agricultural and open space Concepts in the county and and that's so counties are the ones who benefit from this Bill yes and if the counties
056don't spend it within five years then it reverts to some special fund and I at the state level and I can't remember the name of it but counties are given five years to try to UTI I it to their benefit the county and the state both beneficiaries again I I want to underscore I don't think this was nefarious in its intent I just think it has some implications for what it means for us in in our loss of tax revenue and a subsequent increase in the tax rate for everybody to offset that that loss does that make sense when our when our funding goes down when we lose that funding the tax rate has to to go up to offset that loss so what the number of that uh sen or house Bill 237 and
057to Mr Barnett's earlier Point John and Mike do a very good job of helping legislators understand the difference between intent and impact there's an intent impact Gap I think in a lot of this so in none of these arguments I think are we trying to assign bad intent on a bill it's just whatever is is intended to happen has repercussions that um may impact us negatively a law of unintended consequences yeah they tell you a funny story India had a problem with Cobras and one time they passed a law saying that the government would if you brought if you killed a cobra if you brought a CO COBRA they would buy the Cobra so we'll buy cobras that their intent was to eliminate the cobras they were having a problem with so they create a
058government program we're going to buy cobras so people started to breed cobras I'm going to breed cobras and take them and sell them to the government they were making money as soon as the government found out about that they ended the program so what did people do with all the cobras they were breeding they dumped them into the streets and so their intent was to minimize the cobras and the actual impact was to increase the cobras law of unintended con consequences okay that's uh that's my report any other questions and and just for educational purposes this story has not been historically verified okay so if any kids are listening AI says so you know this is not necessarily A History lesson but more of a principal lesson mple lesson okay I trust Bryce and a
059AI equally it's a lot of trust if anyone knows Daryl yeah all right any other questions or um legislative items that you want to bring up okay I I really thought that we were about to hear about fluide Lisa I I'd rather move on from riew personally her I just started to Twitch for those at home all right let's move into agenda item C so this is something that our board has done in the past and that has really netted some gains to the district and that is um just taking a high view look at what board members are seeing and what challenges or um concerns you may have that you would like to focus on in the coming year trying to address so each of you received an email asking you to narrow these
060to your top two so I know and I see here it says one or two and I just think one or two I know I'm having a hard time squish two together I don't know that anyone will monitor that but if you can try TR to keep it in that range I think it will be helpful and the goal here is that we will be able to um once we have our list then we'll go through and say hey these two are the same let's combine or you know what actually great idea I want to throw a vote behind this one and we'll try to get some priorities hammered out uh through these list processes and then uh we will determine this is what I'm hoping to do tonight then we'll determine who is the
061best the best source to tackle that is this something that we need to be focusing primarily through policy do we need to ask staff to work on this item do we need more education before we can even decide between those things um and then please do not feel like all of these will be addressed immediately but it's the intention of the executive committee to then prioritize these in our agenda creation so questions on the idea for now all right Mr denford is our unofficially elected whiteboard man so may I ask that you continue in your role um and we'll just go around and um talk about or Let each board member take some time to talk about some of their priorities Miss Dean do you want to start us off and I shouldn't say board
062member we would also love to have the same um ideas coming from the other side of the room so Dr Godfrey Dr Anderson Mr lson if if you have ideas that you would add we would welcome that please all right um so I have three and they might be more specific ific than ideas but but one that um one thing I would like to I worry about students falling through the cracks and so I would like um to find ways we can improve it U multi-tiered uh support systems especially in secondary schools so mtss are you are you speaking behaviorally or educationally or both all of it so and then um I thought that's what multi-tier was on all of the tiers support systems on all of the tiers is that anyway no you should
063look at somebody and then um another one is I would like to um as a board I I would like to uh improve or I don't even know if it's improved but have yeah I guess improved training for school community councils in our district to empower them and help them reach their full potential as school community councils and I do have one more I really would like our board to um to investigate board self assessment like how we assess ourselves personally as board members and we assess our board and it could help us anyway I that's all I'll say because these are just ideas board self assessment so before we move from Miss Dean I would love to just make sure are any clarifying questions do you feel like you know enough about what she's
064getting at here that you could say yeah that's I also am curious about that could I get some clarification on mtss and what that is and how what it looks like currently and the thing is I don't know exactly what it looks like currently but I have talked to people and so I might be saying the wrong words but I I think that in elementary school it is when the team addresses the needs of an individual student and and everybody kind yeah when they PLC and figure out how to help this particular student so do is that kind of what it is yeah spot on I would only I only ask that it's it the acronym is uh we have a lot of acronyms oh and I'm saying it wrong multi what is it what
065is it really no you said it right mtss is what we refer to it as commonly but what does it stand for multi-tiered system of support oh and I'm support system of support okay and it's just the you know in terms we often display it in terms of a a pyramid where the base of the pyramid is about 80 80% of the students that that get tier one instruction and 15 10 to 15% that might need tier 2 interventions and support systems to scaffold them that might be some of our special ed students and then we have a tier three that might need additional an extra support in that top top triangle five you know 5 to 8% maybe and I think it's important to point out we would not only I identify students in
066a multifaceted group like a a a PLC a professional Learning Community where teachers counselors and administrators might come into play but we also add parents as a key component of that system of support they oftentimes you know the most important right and and then we have ongoing Communications with those groups and we layer that that support we scaffold that support system so that it it supports the student and then the idea of scaffolding is at some point you want to remove it and so that it can be a standalone you know self-supported structure so that's kind of the that's kind of the the visual of the mtss system we are training on that we we do a lot of that we're invested in that but I absolutely in full I I would just endorse on
067my side I would put my signature next to that uh and I I just feel like at the secondary level the tier 2 support is is there are a lot of um challenges there I think just because of how teachers and teams have so many students and so I don't have any answers but I I have a hope and a feeling that we can find ways to reach more students and be more effective and help engage with more yeah students that are at risk yeah awesome and what I would just add one more thing to that is one of the mechanisms we have in the school district to help with that is our early warning system that's required by House Bill 84 that's the school safety bill from last year each school system has to
068have a have an early warning system we use panorama software in there which triangulates data from I say attendance um their academic uh grades um their uh behavior and their mental health screening that they take and it kind of triangulates that data or quadrangula out of those four things I guess and you get you get students that might pop up as ones you might want to pay extra attention to and then we would work with families and parents to to along with our our support staff to to be able to address their needs thank you the multi-tier system of support if I could add to what Dr Anderson is saying is that if ever if most kids in your class are not understanding a concept it might be that the initial instruction is lacking and
069that that's the tier one and then tier two meets the needs of fewer students and then tier three is the student who still are are having difficulty and that mtss is an approach to say let's look Upstream so to speak let's look earlier in the process and see if we need to improve just the tier one instruction when you hear that phrase is it's the initial presentation of material and interaction with the material from students adequate to bring most students along so that the intervention to help those students who didn't get it the first time to now get it so to speak is for a small number of students but if you're doing tier two for most of your students then you're just chasing problems that haven't been addressed early enough in the process and
070that can be applied to when you're trying to help academics improve when you're looking at behavior and when you're looking at social emotional Wellness for example with Wellness in our elementary counselors talk about coping me mechanisms and how to manage friendships and difficulties so that most students have the tools that they need but when students struggle beyond that then you can work with smaller groups and our school psychologist and counselor can work together and tier three is mostly going to be the school psychologist who deals with the more severe issues so that mtss for those listening can apply to academics behavior and social emotional Wellness um and we've talked about various aspects of that in the meeting but it's a it's a good approach to really look seriously at where the issue uh where the
071issue is at what point in the process of helping students grow in those areas right should we just follow the the row all right Miss Wood go ahead so I just have one Aver is that I would like to focus on special education in particular enhancing the experience for our teachers parents and students I'll second it on that it's pretty clear all right Daryl um I'll dle what Suzanne said um that's my number one that's been my number one for eight years and it hasn't been achieved that's do you like that language or do you want to add to it or change it CU I chose enhancing the experience but maybe I don't really care about the language I just care about the I don't even know what needs to be done but I think
072everyone knows that I'm frustrated with that and figuring out what needs to be done what we can do what legislators can do I'm excited to hear from your conference I'm excited to look what other districts do I think it would be nice to talk to other districts about it and it would be really cool for us to actually present information like this to the legislators and get um get some of the bills like coming from the ground app so why don't do you want to add to that including engaging with local government officials yeah I really love Candace Bru's Bill where she's trying to help get money for the multilingua students and that came from the ground up that principles and Community leaders and from us and I think that's how Bills should come instead
073of surprises like what's next up their sleeve they should come from us um and so yeah for sure I would just like I don't even know what needle needs to be moved but that needs to be moved um I'm confused with the one that Lisa put up there about improved training for school community coun we have a mechanism already to do that it's called the Jordan education or uh parents advisory committee and so I don't know if that needs to be a board one I I would just need to know more about that um I I would like to increase the communication efforts in some of our process with community and city leaders specifically things like boundary changes long-term building plans um we don't even have an our own mind our processes let alone have
074ability to communicate it with the public and uh there was one more I can't remember what it was um I'll add it at the very end if I can remember what it was but those are the big ones turn all right um my number one is um that there has been talk and some movement in the current Administration to potentially dismantle the Department of Education so I know that as a board we want to be proactive so I want to make sure that if anything were to happen that we are prepared um to cover those costs that those programs I know that we receive a smaller amount of revenue from the federal government um but they're still four important uh programs title one special education nutrition services so I would just like us to be
075proactive in looking at our budget and making sure that we can still support our uh families our students and our teachers if anything were to happen so that's my first one um the let's see I had two I'm oscillating between um okay so uh one that I've been hearing about from school Community councils um is possibly having some of our rotation teachers be licensed Educators um at the elementary level in order to help with when there is an absence um and then PLC or planning time is lost for our elementary school teachers and um also helping the rotation teachers figure out curriculum uh and helping compensate them for the planning time that they are doing I um I don't know a lot about that but there something that's been coming up um that I've heard
076from parents so and then the other one that I'd like to possibly look at um and this could be a little further down the road um is our cell phone policy and uh seeing its Effectiveness making sure that it's doing what we want it to do that parents teachers and students um are I don't know getting the the most benefit from it I'd been speaking to a middle school teacher and she would like us to see like us to move towards Bell tobell in middle schools and I kind of agree with that in that um so I'd just like to reach out and and see if you know how it's going and if it would be beneficial for our middle schoolers to go Bell to Bell so those are my three I love those thanks
077I remember what I forgot but you can come back to me at the end or now let's go back to you because I was counting on you to to say one that I thought you would that I want to uh oh because I don't think this is it no pressure I haven't mentioned this one to anyone but I've been thinking about it for a long long time I think we need to do better support to our support staff specifically we're finding resources to help these multilanguage English is a second language students but we're not really doing a lot for our employees and some of our employees are phenomenal employees but they don't speak our language and that prohibits them from taking on bigger responsibilities and some positions that we could really use them in our
078district and um so that's one like and also help like our teacher aids and others um be promoted through it through the system to help them get their licenses to teach and we we have ways that people can do that but I'd like to have uh a bigger emphasis to support our support staff and then the other one was maybe anything to do with educational outcomes was that the one that you're thinking of guess what's on my mind I have no idea you're out to say Hing on you for boundaries come on oh well I kind of said that under increased in communication so it should say increased communication and redefining our processes so I had that with that and also like it would be like our boundary process but it also be our long-term
079building plan just I kind of said that but I kind of put it in the terms of communication but it might not be communication it might just be clarification of our prodct may may I ask a question about that Mr Robinson tell me a little bit more about employees not having opportunities speaking another language which I didn't quite from when I'm going into schools and I'm talking to people I'm hearing a lot of we're picking up a lot of people who are immigrants that um don't speak English and so what are we doing to help them learn the language because obviously it's going to be a barrier from them to move up through our system if a communication level is not there so what are we doing for our support staff to help them move
080I don't want to say upward to move to other positions that can solidify them a greater earning level I guess care Career Development so I mean even if it's like offering classes that teach English at night or or even like helping them do um some language study as part of their job responsibil I don't know what the answers are and I don't know how prevalent the the the issue is but certainly it's something we're exploring it for our students we ought to do it for our employees too I think we're we're probably in the process of hiring a lot more people that have challenges in that area than we have in the past and so what are we doing to make they're good workers you know they are really really dedicated people and so whatever
081we can do to help them become valuable in our in our system in our schools and in our community Bryce do you want to go next sure let's stay in order I'll write mine in a minute you want me to write them all up your board I got it uh here's my number one concern and I I don't have an answer and I don't know how to go about it but I am starting to feel uh greater anxiety each year I'm on the board there was a time where Jordan School District was defined by conservative budgeting and conservative spending it was our identity um we did less we just it was it was how we operated we took pride in doing a very good job for less than we were budgeted and um for years
082and years and years that was kind of our identity conservative budgeting conservative spending everyone just made do with what they were given and uh spent less than they needed to and over because of that we built up an incredible reserve for so when I came onto the board we had this massive financial reserve which was primarily the result of just years and years of conservative spending and we came to the conclusion that it was getting too big it was a problem because we were taking more than was needed if we have this massive Reserve that means we're taking more funds from the public than we needed so we really needed to make an adjustment and I I I that was the right thing it was the right thing to bring down our reserves and to
083adjust so that we didn't necessarily we weren't in that take more than we were needing so there was a time period where kind of we created an environment we created an expectation that I could ask and and expand and I could I could petition the board and um we started to have a lot of hands grabbing making requests making Financial requests and this board has been very kind and very concerned and uh these are legitimate things and those that's a good thing we had so many people asking for good things um and we our goal was to in the analogy of an airplane we wanted to bring down that Reserve slowly and make a nice little landing and my fear is that we have lost that identity of conservative spending and conservative budgeting and we've
084created kind of a grab bag mentality where anyone who feels like I'm not being fairly treated let's petition the board and we'll get them to adjust our salaries or we'll add this program or we'll increase this and we we've almost lost what was our our identity and I worry that the spirit of bringing that Reserve down the spirit of bringing that plane is going to cost that plane to crash massively into the Earth and go thousands of miles underneath um because there was [Music] no there isn't that counter wait a minute let's let's go back to what we were before Daryl keeps bringing up the number of teachers that have never ever experienced A Year Without a significant pay increase we have the vast majority of our teachers don't know what it was like to
085be a teacher 10 years ago um during those years where no you didn't get the size of an increase that you're getting now and so the expectation is that every year we give that same increase and we we give the same benefits and that we this explosion is just continuing and I just worry that it's going to bring about uh um some very very negative results because we cannot keep up with the grab bag spirit that we have noticed over the last 8 years um I would love to get back to that conservative we do our job we do it well and we spend less than we've been given we live within our means uh we operate within our means and that we have be you know the district that that what made us great
086in the past that's my main concern is how do we recreate the spirit of conservative budgeting and spending and operating that once made Jordan School District so great um my second one is a proposal I pitch to the finance committee and um I would like to lay it on the table now we have an independent auditor and we pay them thousands of dollars to come in and audit and I love that but there are hundreds there are dozens of gee I wonder that we wouldn't turn over to a significant independent audit to to study but I'd love to go find out I would love to consider hiring an inhouse independent auditor that is responsible only to this board and so can dig up some dirt and wouldn't necessarily lose their job if they digged up
087their some dirt but would you know Anthony our superintendent and our business administrator would be free to say you know what I don't know I don't know if that's happening and could assign the auditor to go take take you a look at that task I think there's enough tasks in this District that we could keep someone busy investigating ticket sales and ticket revenues and uh crossing guards and you know just anytime a superintendent says I wonder if we're doing that efficiently well let's have someone look into it we would have our own person look into it and yet if it was a serious I wonder if there's a fin you know there's fiscal anomalies happening this person would not necessarily feel like their job was being threatened if they investigated something that someone didn't want
088them to find out but I just think there's a great benefit for the board for the business business administrator and for the superintendent to be able to say I'd like an investigation in that what are other districts there's a there's a there's a lot being said about field houses we have no field houses in our district but that's becoming a more and more prominent feature as new schools are being built and students are noticing an inequity and I would love to just turn to someone and say could you tell us what's happening with field houses and two weeks later the board gets a report here's everything you need to know about field houses so I would I would like to investigate an inhouse independent auditor that's my number two so are you going to write
089those in a concise way thank you I'm going to write every word I just said on all the Lord going to need that because I don't know if I understand really well your first one if it's about the spirit and the image or I like this Spirit of conservative spending I don't I'd like some clarification so you you you feel like we're spending too willy-nilly so I will wait and see what you are writing down first because then it might answer my question I yeah like I said I don't know if I understand exactly what that first one was or the second oh it's attitude okay thank you that clarify or do you want I I I think we can I think Bryce said a lot about both of these maners would say I go
090last so Brian do you want to go next sure my first one is um is a a focus on reducing stress or lightening the load on our teachers I've I've heard from several teachers I'm I'm sure some of you may have as well that they're feeling overwhelmed for a variety of reasons so maybe just a explore atory on ways that we can lighten teachers loads and and I know that we recently went through this this process I think it was just maybe right when I started right before my time a few years ago um with the idea of hiring uh counselors you know school counselors and um assistant principl assistant principles yeah and and yet we I'm still hearing from teachers even after that effort that they're feeling overwhelmed so I yeah I would have
091hate to have known the stress they were feeling prior to that effort but apparently there are many teachers who are still feeling over overburdened and overwhelmed so maybe an effort a second effort into that and my second one is uh I think it ties in with uh Miss Dean's mtss um request but mine would focus more on the tier three so it could probably be tied in with leases but but but with a focus on tier tier three yeah kind of how to how to more um actively proactively and urgently deal with disrupt mainly with um with the emotional side of it not necessarily the the educational side of it disruptive or dangerous situations maybe with a focus on that ni just for clarification so for the light lightening the load on teachers all teachers
092or specifically Elementary curious about the feedback or sense you're getting most of the sense I'm getting is from elementary school teachers me as well but but if we're going to investigate it I'd rather just investigate across Elementary and secondary yeah Dr Godfrey would you add any I think this covers a good list of things we need to be working working on Dr same as I said earlier I think I just signed my name next to some of these as well in particular the multi-tiered system of support and uh just I think increased communication uh especially regarding boundary change process looking forward to working with the board on that I I will add that I I I like the way that Mr Barnett um phrased that I I think that I believe at the elementary level
093two things are true at the same time that might seem opposed to each other that if you ask an elementary teacher have you felt a positive impact from having a counselor at your school and a full-time assistant principal I've always heard a resounding yes at the same time I think student behavior is the EXT some of the EXT exam student behaviors have increased in frequency and intensity and a having a clear path um that is communicated to teachers not that we don't have good things in place it's that helping helping clarify expectations and and moving quickly on that and and I think that's an important area for discussion um and but the mtss all levels of that are how you get looking at all three levels is how you get really good action at at
094tier three as well so um there there is not any there's nothing on this list where I think oh why I'm not sure why we would focus on that all of all of this is worthwhile I think it's just a question of prioritizing and assigning but when you talk about lightening the load of teachers I think the inputs the the students that that teachers are working with we just want to make sure that we have teachers well equipped for whatever situation comes their way whether it's what they are responsible to handle or whether we're providing good supports outside of the classroom to help manage situations that can sometimes be more difficult than uh than it than someone may have experienced previously so while while making sure that all students receive a great education whether they
095are in a class with someone who has behaved difficulties or whether they are the student with behavior difficulties we just need to make sure everyone's getting great education and every employee regardless of their assignment feels supported and feels like they have resources and somewhere to go when they're in a situation that they feel unprepared for have any uh we were I think we were all a bit surprised when we saw the projections as time last time and I'm curious about uh taking a A Renewed look at our school boundaries and look for opportunities to reduce busing needs because of those new projections I wonder if things have altered sufficiently that we may be able to alter some boundaries and reduce busing and thus reduce costs and and do you know what I think even just
096looking at Transportation overall because it's possible there are ways that it could even be made more efficient I mean with what's going on at our school different I love that I had even thought about Transportation but that's different tiers of Transportation um we used to always shoot for a four tier bus route system um but I'm me interested in that and uh Bryce and I didn't talk but I I just want to say thank you Bryce uh that what you said um meant a lot to me I appreciate that I watched to see whether John was texting you during that that was really uh very closely aligned with John's feeling uh sorry as as as they I I had to go first so I get to keep going back to my thought it's it's it's
097for me it's really the magic wand issue what's my magic wand issue if I could just say oh this is solved it's that the uh needs of every student is met regardless of their behavior or the behavior of those around them and as a result teachers feel empowered in that in that classroom and that's my magic wand one because I think it's the most one of the most complex that we have up here but anyway can I ask you a question John um you were talking about some numbers or something that came out that you were looking at and that's why you wanted to look at boundaries and busing what were those numbers or something I did I miss um the the projections the enrollment projections by School enrollment projections um I think they were
098discussed in October yeah and so it was just interesting that we it's different than we were expecting and so I'm wondering if there might be opportunities to tweak some boundaries and not interrupt long-term uh capacity levels of schools and yet reduce busing needs and if you can reduce busing needs I I'm guessing that would be an appreciated cost-saving measure but also it may mean we're getting people to a closer School than they were previously so I think there might be a win-win there and help with absenteeism perhaps yeah all right I have a few also um I mine are not going to be Earth shattering and probably will fall into a few of the other categories but um might be a little more specific so first of all I know I've mentioned this before but
099uh I consistently hear schools talk about our fundraising policy how it's being um implemented whether it is limiting there are so many ways that we could look at the fundraising policy and I know that our cabinet has had some conversations about this um I'd really like to do a deep dive on the fundraising policy if only we had an in-house independent auditor that could just kind of I mean add it to that one there you go um another question that I have consistently received over the years of my time on the board is about teacher prep time and balancing that at different levels which I think probably could fit in lightening the load of teachers and probably fits into there's another one over here that I was like oh I could probably just Echo that
100um and then I think we saw during portrait of a graduate feedback our district does a great job of providing a lot of opportunities and um I hope that we can make a special focus on the experience that our students have as they receive advice from school counselors that um It's Tricky when you have a nth grade student at a middle school and a school CER who may not be as well vered in the opportunities available at a high school level but I do I feel like um the experience that I'm hearing reflected back to me from my constituents is I'm confused I don't feel like I have a clear idea of what my options are and so I'm missing opportunities and I would love to be able to provide our counselors with phenomenal resources
101that will allow them to just exploit those options so that every student in Jordan School District is exposed to the Myriad of opportunities that are available for them here and then this one I was going to try to avoid but I'm just going to get a little more specific and this straddle several but on our multi-tiered support and ALS so our special education one thing that um I would love to see happen we have these great things occurring especially at the elementary level we've got a lot of research based knowledge in the science of reading and breaking these skills into fundamental pieces that students can really make growth in and I worry that our tier three students aren't always being the recipient of that knowledge that sometimes our students who actually need the most explicit
102instruction are being sent home with like site words and so I would love to see a little bit of spillover wouldn't it make so much sense to have our our experts in working with students who have the most most severe needs wouldn't it be amazing if they were the experts in the science of reading the the subject area that will change the life of a student at a different level than any other content so that's just a a I agree and amen to some of the things that have already been listed but those are my big ones all right does everybody feel comfortable with the basic idea of all of these items and um what I would just invite let's think of the best way to do this if each of you would like to
103add three tally marks to this board so you can just add it to the ones that you're like yes we really need that um so that we can get a sense of where the urgency is I don't think there's anything on this board that should go unrecognized but that will just help guide us in timing and um and prioritizing are there any here that you before we do that that people are like oh can we just combine these I want to put a tally mark next to three of them but I feel like they're the same thing anything like that we combine all of the ones that deal with multi-tier system support sorry I just anyway and I don't know the I think I think we should keep secondary in there like I we can
104keep the specifics but just say it's mtss like and we will under mtss we want to kind of see some of these things I don't know so do we want to move this tier three support underneath that one as well move Brian's into one one vote for mtss question I have is I feel like Brian was hoping to focus primarily on behaviors am did I understand that right yeah so yeah I don't know if it would make sense to combine that it's hard to talk about one without the other so I feel conflicted there yeah my my only hesitancy in combining it here is that it would get lost yeah exactly is this special education experience is probably also different than the multi-tier support I feel like I could add mine and and I and
105it's not even up there so that works mine is a special ed are you eliminating things from the list or are you just moving things to the top of the list yeah I think right now I'm just making sure that each of these items need to stand alone that they're not one concept I just mean ultimately is it is it it's not to eliminate anything off the list it's just to see what comes to the top of the list because I think knowing the ultimate goal helps us determine whether they need to be combined or not yeah oh yes no I don't think we need to eliminate any you guys did a good job limiting so thank you for doing that I know that was hard so do you want to see each k a
106different color and just walk around and put tally marks each yeah you could do that you can put your initials but would that be of any benefit to anyone to know specifically who said what do you want to color will do that your own choices you don't no yeah yeah I do otherwise we'll all wind up with the same thing it good if everyone votes for what they put I mean obviously I felt strong enough to put it on the board I'm to vote for it if you take that off the board then I have to tell you which of everyone else's choices I would prioritize those cancel each other out so I agree I agree all right so does that make sense three marks just the ones that resonated the most with you now
107I have to de for [Music] I was just confirming no don't apologize I was confirming for for for the elimination of the Department of Education mean the elimination of fedal funding I just want to make sure I was prepared that's the worry yes that the that funding could go away I because we were a bigger District I think we might be able to absorb that but smaller districts might have a big problem with that so I just want to be proactive and so El that just move to the states their hope my hope is they just come to the state My Hope Is they continue to fund but they leave all Administration to the states and that's what I've heard mostly from Trump but I just don't know what we can do until we know
108what they're going to do keep it on the radar well you just said Bryce would be a phenomenal the state to follow yep leave it to the district fund it and then leave it to the districts to well and then the idea is if they left it to the family families can govern their own themselves better than anyone else can parents know what's best for their children Department of Education elimination Oh I thought it was about the budget about making sure we have enough money to cover nutrition right but Bryce was asking followup questions and so because I do not want services to go away got a picture too you've got a picture okay okay so I think taking the time right now to divide this out by a staff responsibility or a board lift
109might be early yeah so maybe I was a little ahead of myself when I said that earlier okay this has been really productive thank you for taking the time and thought that I know this required right let's move to board and superintendent reports and comments facilities should I start sure okay uh I sat down with Scott Thomas this past week and he oriented me as to what the facilities committee does I I I had a general understanding but it was good to sit down and and discuss with uh with Scott the one one thing that I want to uh make sure of is that the facilities committee only at acts on items delegated to it from the board and there's only one item that I'm aware of that's kind of a standing item that the
110facili committee is always doing and that's summer projects and that has some certain uh timelines so there's certain meetings throughout the year where the facilities committee will will get together and under the advice and Council of Scott and his staff um we will work through some of those issues related to summer projects and then we'll come back and make a report and ask for guidance from from the board um I asked executive committee earlier if they were aware of any other uh assignments that had been given to facilities and I I wanted to read through those and make make sure that's the direction of the board still and whether or not the facilities committee should continue on these routes the first one was to identify trigger points for boundary changes specifically at the high school
111level level in Herman high school so that was an assignment that was given to facilities committee and I just want to verify with the board that that is still an assignment you would like facilities committee to take on identifying trigger points Bryce could you talk just quickly about what you what trigger points means uh trying to be proactive instead of reactive if we could identify you know what when a school hits this we did on the opposite end we did this with our school closure policy at what point do we close what are the trigger points to close a school what we've never done is established kind of a handful of trigger points that would say that boundary needs to be changed and I think we ought to establish kind of a this is when
112we this is the trigger point like Herman is approaching Herman is just getting closer and closer and closer and closer and I don't want to react as soon as it's very uncomfortable I want to have decided look we're going to pull the trigger when this happens okay that feels like a heavy lift for facilities do you feel like that's an assignment you guys can take on I I don't know what do you think Mr Thomas is that something we could take on I I don't have enough experience to to answer I I think it certainly is I mean there's there's a lot of things that have been assigned to the Committees over the years and and that something we could take on I think part of our responsibility would be to work with um Dr
113Anderson and superintendent Godfrey in terms of who else would be invited to those discussions from staff to help make those determinations we have in the past we one time in facilities we invited student services in and they actually helped propose make a proposal given enrollment Trends and so the tradition is there that student services would help look at enrollment as a facility issue we can pull those groups together with direction from from these gentlemen yeah is there anyone on the board who's opposed to facilities continuing with that assignment okay another item uh was that was assigned was to look at all of our properties and see if any of the properties we have might be considered Surplus or unneeded is that is anyone opposed to facilities continuing on with that assignment and that's an assignment
114are you aware of that one Scott yes okay this might be on your plan already but we need to develop a long-term plan and you can't know what properties are Surplus until you develop a long-term plan and that was assigned to facilities they just never acted on it that list the spreadsheet that the board did it went nowhere and then it went nowhere so I wonder if that that has to be done could go hand in hand ACC you know getting rid of surplus I think that is a step an an important step towards a long-term building plan and we have it now we just need to make it actionable do you have that that spreadsheet still I'm sure I do I don't know if I'll be able to find it but okay I got
115it if not so that might go hand inand um with the properties assignment is that what you're saying darl well that has a go before the property assignment it can go hand inand with it but if you had to determine the two you have to have a long-term Plan before you know if if a property surplused and then how prob and then how you Surplus it goes hand inand with that too and that probably also goes without saying but if you notice blaring needs okay we need to be keeping our eyes peeled for one item that I don't think has been assigned to facilities but that has come up is proposals for West Jordan High remodel has that come as an assignment to facilities specifically or just to you well so I think the proposals
116if I understand correctly there were the three different proposals to the options to choose from the board made a selection on the pathway that we should go down and now we're actually acting on that so facilities is taking the first stage out to bid when you say facilities you're not talking facilities committee no we're not facil okay the facilities Department yeah they're taking that first phase out to bid which included the portable moves and preparation for the parking lot and that that's going to come back to the board probably um Fe February or March I I'll check with dat but it's coming back soon that bid and then the construction bids will come back at a later time once we get that first phase okay done so so is is this project better suited to
117um staff or board direction to staff as as you need input from us or is it something that the committee needs to take on the committee could certainly study components of it or get feedback or input as as directed by the board but I think we've already been given direction to move forward on that I mean everything will come back to the board what's the impact in Joe P Jensen and what's the timeline and that's what we mean by a bigger picture there's no question we're moving forward with the remodel of West Jordan but there are pieces of the puzzle we need to know where they fit on that so that when West Jordan's done what do we do here what do we do here what do we do there we need to start planning
118for the elimination of a building the consolidation of two programs and so we need a timeline that says at what point do those two ele those two middle schools combine at what point do what's the plan for the property what's the plan for I think we need to be careful about how we talk about that because if we talk about it as if it is a done deal um there's a whole process and a whole timeline where we get public input and it might already be set in um some people's minds about exactly what is going to happen as far as that um we do have a process and so I feel like talking about we're going to eliminate this and eliminate that before we've gone through the process I think um when does that
119process start that's what I mean okay thank you he was saying the timeline right that that's what thank you I'm not saying this is when that does I'm saying this is when that timeline if this if we're going to go this direction it would start here and this would that's what I'm asking for me that timeline needs to happen now I won't I would not approve the funding of West Jordan High School without the closing of jel P Jensen and so and it should be no surprise at the end if all of a sudden we close the school to me it's the same project maybe it's not for other board members so that needs to be defined in my opinion early on and part of the process not something that we decide after the school's
120done part of part of the purpose of a committee my understanding is to take work away from the the full board to do some work behind the scenes and then come back with a proposal so my question on West Jordan high remodel is are there things that find that the facilities committee can do to alleviate the whole board getting involved or is that just something that Scott and his staff can do without the need of the committee I I don't know if if there's valid input from the committee to whittle down the board's work there or if Scott just does his thing comes to the board and presents we make a decision he goes back does some things we make a decision or if there's some work that can be done by the the facilities
121committee so would that be for example let's say I had a series of questions that could be given to the committee that when you meet with Scott you could discuss and then relay that is that an example okay yeah I also think um there are a few policies that make assignments to committee so a13 the school consolidation and closure makes several assignments to facilities committee that you're actually right in the midst of so we have already received our enrollment capacity and projection data and then it says staff provides facilities committee with information on schools that meet the trigger points and an initial analysis of the triggerpoint data so some of those things that we were just talking about how schools fit together into this master plan that's already um delegated to facilities by policy so
122hopefully those conversations are happening and we're and then I mean then it later comes in that facilities committee notifies board members of schools being discussed and involves the board member requesting the affected schools in discussion and then they analyze triggerpoint data school information potential resolutions and determine if further action is recommended so then you would bring a recommendation on that to the board and we're right in that sweet spot there so I'm going to I'm present your recommendations march to June according to that policy I'm going to move ahead then with the assignment from the board board if there's no objection that the committee get involved as an assign as an assignment for the the West Jordan high Remodel and the effects of that remodel on neighboring schools and is that okay with everyone a
123proposed plan yeah okay the last item I wanted to bring up is it was it was asked that we as a facilities committee create and track a strategy for each school that's on our watch list I'm gonna ask Bryce again to describe the watch list idea there's there's some triggers that go into putting a school on a watch list whether it's exceeding enrollment or yeah yeah that's probably the same thing yeah when when Scott Fest came and presented his projections he gave us a list of schools on the watch list right right and some of them are on there because of increasing enrollment some of them are on there because of decreasing enrollment one of the things the facilities committee can do is discuss each one and come up with a proposal and then bring
124that to the board especially with well here's the urgency that's where Juniper Elementary came from is we had a school on a watch list we brainstormed an idea we took it to the board and that it came to fruition um and so give given Scott feston who is our professional demographer said here are the schools you need to watch here are the schools you need to be concerned about what I need to know as a board member is that we as a board have a plan for each of those schools and that there's a priority associated with that plan is there anyone opposed to facilities doing that as an assign as an assigned task okay thank you I you know where that list is can you you you can find that list of watch schools
125I'm sure Scott has access we'll we'll round them all up yeah okay thank you very much I appreciate that thank you guys are G to be a great committee I can tell we're excited other committee reports I have a few things if not from USB a um let me okay so just a heads up that the usba regional meetings are coming up that will be the one in Sandy that's our assigned meeting is March 12th at 6:00 and then if you don't have the ability to attend that one but you would like to still attend you're welcome to attend a different one so you can watch for the rest of the list to come they generally send it out in the mail um but just to calendar pencil in March 12th 6:00 and then also
126another date to calendar in is the leadership academy is September 25th through the 27th this has at least as long as I've been on the board always been held at the zermat it is not the year it's going to be in brace Canyon so if you um are unfamiliar with it the leadership academy is an additional uh training resource that we receive through usba and generally has limited seats for each board they haven't told us yet what those numbers are but just so you can keep it on your mind and then uh also usba I we've talked about this a little but has issued a couple of calls to action and I think call to action sounds a little more dramatic than it maybe is but it's an invitation to be communicating with your legislators
127um and they have called out sb37 and S sp102 um this year they've also created a new resource for it's really a resource for jlc but they're using the remind app app and there's like a group a group you can join in remind that we'll send you a notification as things come up if anyone is interested in that I can give you the information on how to join but there's that um and then I'll just update you on so usba has their own committee assignments um that and at the last usba meeting I got elected to attend on behalf of our region which is also our district um I will be working in the advocacy committee and I'm also um attending the usbe assessment committee meetings so just to keep you apprised of what our
128role is there okay that is it on that one one more time did I go too fast anyone miss an opport to report oh I I was thinking we were kind of going in line oh well sorry about that so we don't so you just want us to jump in or yeah sure jump in I just don't I know that we just barely received these assignments and so I don't want to call attention if your committee hasn't met but yeah we can go in order if if you would rather um I I like well okay I have something is what I'll say perect so for leak you can see the advisory committee Memo from October 10th 2019 um it's attached to board docs and it talks about the um way leak members were elected at
129schools and um I noticed too that the representatives will meet four times during the year November January April and July and so I'm hoping that we can um help schools well licensed employees to elect their building representatives and um have a meeting in April and so a couple of dates that I thought could maybe work I don't know about when facilities are available but I think in spring with spring Sports Mondays work kind of well there usually aren't spring Sports on Mondays so I was thinking either the 21st or the 28th what lacrosse is I I said generally so I mean maybe I don't know maybe it's a huge night for spring sports but seems like generally there aren't a lot of spring Sports on um Monday night um and also I there are a
130couple um things things that I would like to discuss as far as the the leak representatives from each school I think it I would personally I would like to see um more people have an opportunity to um have their voice heard so I would like to add to this communication that um the position is for one year and that we would like to have a different representative each year so could anyone ever repeat are you saying like just a space between I think people could repeat but I I think I my intention is that um so the the leak I don't want I don't want to give an impression that it is going to replace um Jaa or meeting with Jaa I want all licensed EMP employees and and when it says licensed I feel
131like that also could include counselors and um nurses in this it's specifically not Administration um and we I don't want administrators to come but I just want all Any teacher to be able to too come and feel like they have a voice so I I think at some schools there might be the situation where nobody wants to be the the representative and at other schools there might be a situation where 10 people really want to be it and I I just want to make sure that the people who want to participate are given the opportunity meaning everyone who wants to come to leak can no but um has the opportunity to be nominated and possibly be the leak representative so I I want to maintain this kind of thing where the this process where the
132licensed employees nominate and then the the top two nominees at the ele at least or top two nominees or top three at an elementary level are voted on and then the top one is the representative and then the next one is the alternate and then and a middle school the top three and then it's the top two are the represent do does that make sense so I feel like this process is fine what I'm saying is I would like to add something about um it's a once a year process and I just am hoping to not have the same person elected every single year to be the representative because I think that it is possible that more than one person would like to participate does that answer your question does anybody have thoughts on that
133would recommend all new elections I think so all new elections even before April can I speak to that um I think that having new people on a committee is always a good thing I'm not not really big on creating a new committee every single year that's what you're asking for and I'm not really big on telling a school we're going to kind of select the person for you because we don't like that you're sending who you voted for and that's basically what we're doing we're saying hey we don't like who you voted for you voted for them several years in a row um we're going to take your second place instead so I'd be really careful we we can Define the rules we could put term limits on it stuff like that but I would
134be very careful in telling them we don't want who you elected and we want someone new every single year I just think a turnover of every 50 or 100% every year just puts us back to square zero takes a while to figure out what you're doing in a big committee like that so I mean most committees we do two years and a chance to uh rig one time and I would be good with two years um and that's it but I think an election should always be at least two years and so maybe I am not um we might I might have a different understanding about the purpose of this committee um I I did not see it as a a committee that was going to be receiving assignments and um doing some work I
135in ised it to be um I've only had one experience with the leak the licensed educator advisory committee and that was when I was first elected and we had a meeting where um board members were there and uh there were several different um questions that we were addressing and E different board members sat at different tables and the represent atives from different schools sat around and um and I received feedback from the licensed Educators at my table on the the questions the topics that the board was interested in getting feedback on and so I I it's I feel like it would not be a difficult position to step into even for just um one time as an alternate because I I imagine that the questions I don't know what the whole procedure was for that
136other meeting but I imagine that the questions were sent out to the the different schools and the licensed professionals at each school had the opportunity or the option to email their leak representative their ideas or their thoughts if they wanted those to be shared at the meeting so I I I'm not seeing this committee as one that people need to have experience on the committee for it to be an effective committee so I think that it would be okay if there was turnover every year and I also am against um prohibiting anybody from coming and representing the professionals at their school whether or not regardless of if it is their second term or third term I I just would like to encourage um people to let new voices participate new people um speak so let
137me just clarify that I understand what you're recommending so the position lasts for one year and rotates to a new person yearly the person can repeat but just not two terms in a row and I wasn't that specific I I don't have a specific idea about that I just wanted to see what people thought about and how we could and how we could yeah oh absolutely I didn't come with a specific um thing except that the idea that I would like people to have an opportunity if they want to like spread the opportunity around so darl do you feel like that having it so they can serve repeated terms but not necessarily one after the other answers your concern or not quite no what would your proposal be well I think a two-year I think
138original was a two-year term twoe was was we originally did we envisioned that this person is not just attending a meeting that they are the connection between the board and the school and that we wanted to train them about how to take information back and and how to gather information and bring them there's some training to do that right if you really want to do it right and uh and it and it worked phenomenal especially in the early years and I just think if you're trying to do that retraining every single year it's just almost impossible and maybe we don't want that so maybe the definition of what this committee is going to do is different are there bylaws for this committee was it ever uh written down what the we sent out election instruction
139so this intradistrict communication on October 10th 2019 that is the all the documents that are available for this so so Daryl does not the results of each meeting actually sorry I shouldn't even say so does so do other board members have I I've heard that there's a different uh vision for what this committee is supposed to be what I would like some direction from the board then as far as what you think this committee should be because I participated one time and it really helped inform me as a board member about some of the different policies it gave me some good questions to ask ask staff um please help me explain this I even followed up with some teachers so but if it is to train people on how to get information from the board
140to the school is that what the board is hoping this committee will be because I was thinking of it more as coming from the licensed Educators to the board with feedback about policies or well let me give you an example right now we've been on we've been on hold as we've developed the portrait of a graduate so right now there needs to be a push down of this is what we've developed this is what the board developed as our vision now here's what we've developed digest it now there's a push up so they I don't know that they're prepared to report on it until we've made presentations on why how what was the process why do we think this is valuable and so there's been we haven't done that there have been some board me
141there's some there have been some leak meetings where it was 90% us presenting to them here's what's going on and then there's other board meetings where it's 90% them presenting to us it just depends on the needs at the time but we've been on hold until the portrait of The Graduate was developed and now that it's developed I would Envision the first thing that you would do is take portrait of a graduate to AC say here's what it is let me talk you through this document here's what that here's what these are here's what those are here's what went into the production of this here's who was involved because leak was involved in the generation of it we asked for leak's Fe one of the meetings was they met with education elements and gave their
142feedback so now that it's been an established document there needs to be a down push to say here is the document digest it and then there needs to be an up push that says here's what we need help with in terms of implementing it as we've caught the vision of what this is about this is what the Board needs to implement in other for in order for us to fully implement this so there has to be a catching of the vision and then there has to be sharing of feedback as to implementation that's how I would see leak rolling out so I have a question has has Administration has staff been informing um teachers about portrait of a graduate and administrators about portrait of a graduate or what is or I mean like is it
143the responsibility of the board that is my question to inform teachers about portrait of a graduate in the pillars or is this is this the responsibility of the board and leak based on the work that the committee has been doing with education elements we have been seeking feedback from teachers about elements of the evaluation portion of portrait of a graduate so there have been conversations with teachers and there will be more conversations about the elements of um how how to assess where we are and how we're doing before so there has not been a full launch yet now there was a discussion and this is this is not trying to push it One Direction or another but there was discussion about whether leak ought to be used used as a tool for communicating out and
144I I may misunderstand but I think what you're describing is giving them information for them to process and then come back with feedback but we we moved away from saying leak is the way that we communicate ideas to schools because it becomes a little bit uneven when so many different people are involved you may you even have three people from one school that would be responsible for sharing a message so although that can be what leak is assigned to do um it it it was not in my recollection and it's been some time it in my recollection it wasn't to communicate the ideas out it was as you described there was an exchange back and forth on getting feedback and here's what we're working on give us your feedback sometimes it was just what's important
145to you and I think that's a meeting that you participated in and and there were actual questions too that I think the teachers had and I we asked what is important to you and significant whiteboard use if I'm not Mist we pushed out here's what we're trying to do would you ask your staff and then come back with the answers to these questions so let's go to an example that we actually did do we we looked at compensation but then we said let's look at benefits is there anything that we're missing that we could help you so we pushed that information out to our leak Representatives they went back to the schools and then they came back with ideas like let's take sick leave and make it into PTO Let's uh have maternity benefit which
146no District ever had before some of those ideas came from this committee because they were trained how to go out and how to bring information back so that's how I that's my vision of what it's always been it's been on hold so and then here's another one we want we made decision to do what did we call it extra mile pay yep and so we pushed out to leak and said how could we make this work more effectively so here's what we're trying to do here's the goal how could we make this work more eff efficiently and they came back with gobs of ideas on how to make it more efficiently that's how it's been but we don't have to do that in the future but that's that's that's what I understood the purpose of
147the committee very similar to the Jordan parent Association and to miss Dean's point that that that this is the opportunity to clarify what those expectations are like you said now Also to clarify in these examples we or the board talked with leak got the input said this is what we're working on extra mile pay what should we do oh here are the ideas but we didn't say hey leak this this is what extra mile pay is let your schools know we sent that out globally once that exchange had happened so that that's the one clarification I would make is that we did not use leac to communicate information out we did use it for feedback but not to share a final product so in answer to your earlier question if we were to follow the
148way that we used leak in the past we would not use leak to communicate portrait of AGG graduate out and the committee that worked with education elements determined that we would work with that we would open it up to to teachers to be part of a group that looked at a draft because if you send out a draft more broadly on how we evaluate our progress on portrait of a graduate in the Strategic plan then you get a lot of confusion so Dr godfre maybe um we're explaining it differently I think it is administration's role to explain that to all the teachers and and our whole Community I think what Mr dunford's expressing is as we look for implementation that a different presentation would be given to leak not the only presentation or even the
149initial or may maybe an initial and then you roll it out however you do that but our idea is that they have somebody connected to the school from the board side because administration's going to be do their presentation but how do we implement it what ideas do you have it' be just then we get feedback two ways we're coming through Administration they're just sending out they're bringing it back we're sending out through the board um and getting feedback back so we get it from two different sources and then we kind of match and say what are you hearing what are we hearing that's the value of what that committee was created as one example your restructuring of of our district um that went through proper channels we're going to put a vice principal in the
150elementaries we're going to hire this and that went through but it was important to me to stand in front of leak and say this is why the board did this right this is why the board supports what he proposed we have his back this is so it's very important for me that that the board had an Avenue to speak to teachers that would hopefully be sent to the whole faculty not as okay we're in we're disseminating the information as an official Channel but I have a chance to speak to teachers I don't usually have that opportunity right and leak gave me as a board member an opportunity to say you want to know why we did this I would like to tell you why we did this and what I mean is I would like
151the board to be able to say to the teachers this is why we implemented portrait of a graduate not here's the official kickoff of portrait of graduate but can we tell you why this is important to us right as a board member you're going to get it from the superintendent you're going to get it from the proper channels but can I look you in the eye and tell you why this is important to the board and then can you look me in the eye and tell me what's important to you about it um and I I was looking at it more as an opportunity for teachers to speak to board members because I feel like anyone can tune in to the live stream or watch subscribe to the channel on YouTube although it has ads
152now of the board meetings and here why we chose to do something I want to know what the teachers think for the first meeting I wanted to know I wanted to get feedback on the cell phone policy just like Aaron wants report on cell phone policy I want to hear the anecdotes I want to hear how it is working in their schools how it is working for them specifically I also wanted to hear about successes and challenges in attendance so I just thought I want these two things and then I thought as a board we can figure out something for July something for November I want to know how the actions that we take as a board affect our licensed professionals that is what I want I don't want an opportunity to speak and tell
153the our employees this is why I did it I want to justify my position to you I don't want that and so if that is what leak is supposed to be maybe we should form an ad hoc committee that will put some bylaws in place and I will follow them but my vision is different than me telling or other board members telling our employees why we chose to do something I so can I speak to that Miss George um were you finished I I probably should be uh sure and then I'd love to hear some new voices and all I was saying is it's not the position of a committee chair to decide just like Mr Barnett said is like it's the agenda is set by the board not by an individual committee chair and
154we we've been really careful on that and maybe we do need to put bylaws in place for for some of these things that we have but I guess the perception we got to be very careful when we're assuming new responsibilities that we don't just recreate something new that there's continuity in that and so maybe maybe putting maybe the policy committee or something can put something in place but I'll be quiet now and respectfully this is my committee report do you know what I mean so um this is my assignment and I am fine I I was so excited to receive this assignment there has not been continuity here I don't know when the last time leak has met it might have been more than a year and so so if I don't know how I
155can be expected to read the minds of what it is supposed to just one minute there I feel like this is turning into a two-person conversation so let's invite some additional voices let's give you exactly what you're asking for which is the vision of the board as a whole so anyone have some feedback I well I have a question because the the document we were given says October 10th 2019 is that when leak was formed was only in 2019 okay um I think it would be beneficial for whoever is in charge of this Committee in the future and for mine currently that we have something that gives a little more definition of what this committee is supposed to do what the chair of the committee is supposed to do because when I was given my
156uh assignment I was told that I would be creating the agenda and now it feels like the chair is not supposed to create the agenda so we need to clarify that um was going to those were just ideas that I thought I was going to ask after we had this other discussion what do you think of these topics right but there just needs to be clarification on on how the committee is run how an agenda is made for these committees because I definitely need to know that for my committees that I'm supposed to be in charge of and and it does say in this small paragraph Representatives will meet four times during the year and will be oh no that's not what I wanted to say the purpose of this committee is to advise the
157board regarding issues that affect licensed employees and so that to me sounds like we are looking for feedback from the licensed employees and to me it it sounds unfortunate that leak has been put on hold because of portrait of a graduate because we still probably could have been receiving you know feedback on what was happening so we just I think we just need to clarify yeah great point so um I'm hearing a recommendation that we form an ad hoc committee to create some uh specific bylaws I I heard a suggestion of policy committee doing that anyone so does that mean we won't meet probably until July then would be I I suspect that we wouldn't need that long but let's see Miss Wood I don't know if this will be helpful but Dr Anderson wrote
158a purpose statement I don't know when you wrote it for the government Relations Committee that I found very helpful in directing me as to the purpose and the parameters of the committee can something like that just be done in a week and then if we need to review it here we do we didn't I don't know has this was the purpose of that committee reviewed by the board what you wrote up that one I sent to to President George and then she distributed to the board executive committee had their eyes on it but that was about as far as that went before we gave are we thinking of something like that for this leak I think that's a great suggestion Mr Barnett any thoughts I was on the same page it sounds like there's a
159a confus as to the purpose of the committee if we can identify that in succinctly in a few sentences I think that would give Lisa what she needed okay and the next chair or the next board yeah member yeah definitely so I think that sounds actionable um and the tradition is that leak meets when the board asks it to lead not leak feels a need to meet I mean they would love to meet but we traditionally have not gathered leak until the board calls for a meeting of of that's why it's been inactive isn't because oh well no nothing turned it off it's just that we have always gathered leak when the board said let's take this to leak and then we had a meeting for that specific purpose and until the board said let's
160take this to leak we didn't meet that's been the tradition is when the board calls for a leak meeting we have one and until the board calls we don't have one I would say that can change but that's been the as a board member it would be helpful for me to have regular and periodic feedback from our licensed employees so I I would support it being scheduled quarterly or however often the board determines that would be helpful I think it's a good idea um I think it's a good idea for us to uh have a a few people work on this statement so I'm just trying to think of the best place for that to happen if that's an an existing committee can I speak again please of course can we also do it for
161the parent um committee because great idea it's the same it was they were created out of the same thought process so I think the continuity we probably even the ethnic committee they all were created kind of the same reason and and and we didn't put times to it because the board wanted to put times to it and uh I wanted to do the Jordan parent committee several more times last year than we did and as a board we said no because we wanted the next big agenda to be a portrait of graduate so um again we can have recommendations but it's we're flying this airplane in in the sky changing as we go and so those were purposeless purposeful decisions that we made along the way but we didn't have anything on writing so it
162would be nice to put something and I do think it's insightful to me to be able to review this document and say this is what our teachers received they understood this to be a quarterly meeting in a scheduled month of the year and so if that directive has changed from the board I think maybe we didn't communicate that in a way that everybody understood so um why don't we go ahead and um it's one one comment please from what I've heard so far it sounds like one of the benefits of these committees is when the board has something that they want relatively quick input on from a group of teachers or a group of parents or a group of ethn ethnicity type people sorry I don't know what to call what the proper term is
163there but as an example um report on Cell form policy if that's something that we wanted to do and we said well let's get a feel for what the parents think of that now that we've been doing it a year well as a board we send that to the parent advisory committee if we want to know what the cell phone policy is like for teachers we have an Avenue to quickly assemble that committee and say and and ask them that so I think that's one good purpose but I think another purpose and it's the same experience I had that Lisa had that one meeting where it was an opportunity that we gave to the teachers to come to us with any concerns they had and that was that was very valuable for me too Lisa
164not any concern it was directed and we pushed that out it was directed it was specific feedback we were seeking not hey just say tell talk anything that you want to say it was very specific feedback on a ISS on a particular thing just to be clear okay that that's not maybe that was the directive that's not how I remember the feedback coming to me it it kind of went around but but I think that's valuable as well is to allow that voice an an audience to us yeah you know yeah definitely so let me ask this Dr Godfrey do we ask staff to write those committee um committee goals responsibilities up for the document that we used on our committee assignments do you think that we could that you as a staff would feel
165comfortable writing kind of a basic idea of the responsibilities of leak jpac and well I jack isn't really a board committee right that I don't know if we would be the ones to write that gak is a little bit like PTA and that it's a it's a it's not a board committee but a board member is assigned to it originally a board committee because we had three board members on it and it changed over the years yeah it evolved and but on oursite originally created as a board we would be comfortable writing a starting point so that the board has a starting point on on that but it would be important for the board to to shape it from there definitely we just start from scratch and say what's the need and let's re re
166let's recreate leak from the ver from the from the start I wonder if we need to have a board discussion as to the need for and the purpose of and then we can write a statement like that one of the things that really helped me when I was a new board member is we have a library here of every meeting we've ever had and all the audios to it and it's really easy to go back and like put in leak and go back to 2019 and it would be helpful I think I know that everyone has as much time as me but to listen to some of those meetings and say well why was it created and I know those were audio ones I believe at the time but and I know you can't all
167do that but that was really helpful for me to kind of bring myself up to speed because it it's a difficult thing to jump onto a board and and we all know exactly the need that we created and all that and we just expect you to know it right and you don't but that was a good thing and so maybe we could even find some dates of meetings that you know and and maybe we do just need to recreate the whole thing now was a really good time but there was a reason and a purpose behind and and they were very successful I guess my question is who is the right person to write that statement I I feel like it feels more neutral to say staff but we could also form you know a
168little ad hoc Committee in it's it's hard for me to because I feel like leak was a vision of the board and jpac it was vision of the board and so do we want to put that burden on staff you need to capture our vision when we started these committees yeah I see what you're saying and that's why I'm feeling conflicted at the same time I feel like uh we as board members who are elected and serve certain terms and have different timelines for our tenure here um we have our perspective shift a little based on when we entered what we were exposed to um and that's why certainly I would not say okay they did it and now that's it but somebody who can put down like here's the way we understood it from
169being in the meeting I wasn't there when leak was created but I I feel like it's something that could have evolved I think that we should look at what needs we have now versus what needs there were in the leak field back in 2019 so do we still want to have leak I've had so many teachers reach out to me and say I want another meeting like that one do you have an idea that you'd like to recommend in terms of how we establish this need do you know what I you have a vision I do but I thought I already talked about my vision I think maybe facilities committee should um write the statement facilities I think policy should I think policy should work with Administration to write a a a policy statement so
170we get moving and I don't think if you want to get moving in your committees now while we're writing that go for it you just have to bring the agenda items to us and let us discuss but we could write that pretty quickly at least something to go with and we can enter it into policy later but I don't understand why facilities would would do this I just like how responsible they are I think they would do a really good job we've never met that's why I thought pretty impressed so impressed with the first I just thought job Brian I know wow Brian you are carrying the day and I think I have some other jobs want to write there's a few things I'd love to give Brian as well if I if I if
171I may uh I wonder whether this is something that the executive committee ought to examine for each committee and I generally meet with that group and I could be a part of that discussion and then the Board review it again and and I'll just I'll point out that each committee is pretty different and I think Miss Dean's point about and others have made the same point about looking at what the need is now as opposed to the history I think the history is important context for determining what we need now and I think that in the past the executive committee has taken on this sort of assignment that is a global sort of far-reaching assignment gak is no longer really a board committee if you want it to be a board committee then that's something
172that can change leak's most popular meetings were probably the ones with the feedback but it's were distant enough that we can make the board can make leak what what you want it to be so some of the board assignments vary leak is the largest participation group and so Clarity around expectations and purpose means if if you have greater Clarity around purpose and expectations you're going to have a lot less frustration from participants where you have facilities committee that can be a lot more Nimble and switch around but with such a large group I think Clarity UPF front for for leak is really important so I I think my suggestion is executive committee with my answering questions and giving historical context and other things but if you want to assign it to staff we can do
173it as a staff as well but ultimately that would still only be a starting point that would be brought back to the board I I those are only suggestions that's not my trying to direct it in any particular way I I will say I feel completely comfortable having staff write a draft for my review because I can edit something and I can carve it up but I like having a starting point even if it ends up looking very different and they are definitely used to us carving up their giraffes that's our job we're we're we're very happy to give a starting point but I those are suggestions go the direction you'd like to go we can support whatever you want to do in terms of establishing those that purpose would anyone like to make a
174motion I move the executive committee writes the mission statement or purpose for the Jordan parent advisory committee and the licensed Ed uh licensed educator advisory committee a second I'll second all right so we have a motion on the table that executive committee take the assignment to write a statement of purpose and direction for leak and jpac to be brief um and then bring it back to the board for review did I capture that okay all in favor say I I and any oppos all right that is what we will do that motion passes and I think we should take a break and then we can continue with committee reports so so let it be written oh yeah let's come back in 10 minutes 7 o'clock thank you e e e e e e all right
175welcome back to the study session for the Board of Education it's still February 11th 2025 all board members are still present as well as cabinet and our board attorney okay let's continue on with committee reports okay I've got a couple of comments so on the government Relations Committee this Thursday so in two days we do have a legislative luncheon h on the hill I have Nikki Aaron and myself attending is there anybody else who intends to join us I was planning I was planning to attend but not eat lunch okay great so I mean I'll make a note of that thank you also next week Thursday February 20th we do have our student student body officers on the hill um we're excited about that day and then for gak just wanted to let you know
176I did attend their meeting they are looking at their mission statement Etc uh to ensure compliance with any executive orders or changes on the federal at the federal level in our government I will keep the board informed as those changes May take place may I make one just a quick question to clarify the uh the meetings this Thursday and next um I think on Thursday the 13th this Thursday uh if you can be up there you can come anytime but around the 11:00 hour is floor time and that's where we could call uh call upon some of our representatives and uh potentially if there is any desire to sit with anybody on the house floor or the senate floor we could try to see if that as a possibility that's a fun thing to do
177I know several several of you have done that and then uh at noon is when they'll break from floor time typically and then they have their Caucus meeting begins at 12:30 that day so I think that that time between 12: and 12:30 is probably the most likely um to to be able to interact with them and and see them over in the capital boardroom and that's uh at this point as of right now uh seven have accepted that invitation two are Maybe and then we're still waiting to hear from a couple more but but for the most part um most are are ready to attend and then the SBO day on the hill of course is always our favorite and that's uh that's we're getting plans together for a tour a visit to the treasurer's
178office and then U the governor's office so and then floor time with the with the students and the board members anybody else visiting would sit in the gallery and watch that so should be fun so anytime after 11:00 basically this Thursday is when we'd be able to start interacting with them anyone else I have one idea item darl and I serve on an education committee between Herman and Riverton cities who we met this morning um and they the police department is having they said they're in crisis mode when it comes to crossing guards they cannot hire enough crossing guards uh for the need um they asked about staggering start time so that they might be able to use the same crossing guard at two different Crossings we talked about that I recommended and I'm seeking
179board approval to send out a letter to parents an email to parents through our system encouraging parents to consider being a crossing guard if we can just send out a distress call and say we need crossing guards if you can if you're interested if it fits your schedule please follow this link and consider applying as a crossing guard I just think they need our help this the police department needs our help um they've handed out flyers at PTA meetings but they get a very limited crosssection we have access to all parents um so I am seeking board approval to work with Communications Department to send out an invitation for parents to consider working as crossing guards and providing the information they would need on where to sign up and how to proceed would that be
180all cities sorry all cities are in need okay so the letter would go to all parents in the district and we would just have a link based on city y want to verify the city's just because I know that committee is just Herman Riverton right right I will I I that would be part of my homework is to reach out to each Police Department to say you know what's the need and if there's an interest what's the link but I just think that's a you know that's a that's an easy effort that's something we can do that would dramatically show uh partnership a desire to help um let us use our resource to increase potentially your applicants to be a crossing guard what's happening is most families that used to you know hey we need
181supplemental income a part time job on the side is great they now need a full-time job on the side and the part-time jobs are not being filled because the for example Herman Police Department lost six crossing guards and all six of them sought full-time employment employment so maybe a shout out to parents maybe a grandma a grandpa someone who has some time and would like to work as a crossing guard if the board would approve that I will work with the police departments and Communications to send that out can I make a comment on that so um I haven't seen them use their social media for that effort and I think that they're powerful in social media so I think they should do that too I'm not against us using ours the other thing is
182um I think that a person that'd be really good is our part-time people our AIDS I mean because some of them are limited to number of hours they work they would be really happy they already have a tie of the school they know those kids so that might be a group to maybe even Target before we go to parents it's just an idea but I do think that we should be good partners with the cities and help them where they need it and this is a a need suzan did you have something I was just going to add I don't think we need to narrow it to parents only but do you know of anybody who's retired or flexible schedule yeah the invitation would be I would love to send it to all staff all
183parents please if you know someone please pass this message on to them if you have a neighbor a relative a friend we are in need of crossing guards I highly recommend it I love being a crossing guard I think we should have Aaron draft the letter all right any concerns no all right let's then I will proceed perfect okay uh just a quick update on portrait of a graduate the committee met today and got an update on what has been happening so you'll remember when we met in December that we were looking at implementation timelines and also the grade band um definitions so what does this look like if I'm in K through three and what does this uh characteristic look like if I'm a high school senior so um they've been doing a lot
184of work on that have sent out a survey it's not an exhaustive survey but to 60 teachers and receive feedback it looks like they're on the right track but they're definitely adjusting Things based on the feedback that they received um and are doing some more inperson work in March so questions on that all right perfect I was able to attend my first Salt Lake Academy board meeting with uh with Daryl last Tuesday it was really interesting really cool it was this meeting but on a much smaller scale they had their superintendent and their Finance guy and and the board members and did they say Madam president no they didn't there you go a lot more casual it was much more casual and you could hear students out in the hallway right next to us and
185um but yeah I thought it was uh it was interesting to be there and to introduce myself and to meet um the members of that board they have two members from our board on the board they have two members from ra Salt Lake and one parent I believe is that right darl yeah okay any others okay well then um let's go ahead and take a motion to move into close session confidence I move that we go into close session for ABCDE for a character and competency of individuals property potential litigation negotiations and security thank you hi second perfect everyone did have a motion by Miss phoh a second by Mr Dunford and we'll do a roll call vote Mr Barnett yes Mr denford yes Miss Barrow yes Mr Robinson yes wood yes Miss Dean yes
186and I am also a yes so this meeting is adjourned and we're in close session