CorpusRecord 271290

January 28 2025 Jordan School District Board of Education - Live Stream

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Jordan School District Board of Education
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Salt Lake County, UT
Material
Transcript
Extent
27,948 words · about 156 min
Collected
2026-10-22

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e for e e for e e e e e welcome to the Board of Education meeting for Tuesday January 28th um this is the study session before the Board of Education meeting um present are all members of the Board of Education Brian Barnett Nikki George Bryce stford Aaron Barrow Daryl Robinson Suzanne wood and Lisa Dean and we also have our superintendent Dr Anthony Godfree um Dr Michael Anderson our associate superintendent our business administrator John Larson and our um board attorney Paul Van Coman we will start out tonight's meeting with a review of of open meeting law training um and turn the time over to Mr van Coman thank you uh I put up on board docs for you the most recent version of the Utah School boards Association um open and public meetings guide um

002that'll change every year after the legislative session um but often those changes don't go into effect until the end of May anyway so this is the there's the most current version for you on that that's a PDF if you have any problems you're welcome to um ask me for a copy um what I wanted to do was just sort of go over the major changes that impact this board of education from last year um up on the screen you'll see this is section 524103 and I've redlined it the changes from last year um there's some changes to the Anchor location which effectively doesn't really matter because we've been um dealing with the anchor location properly we don't need to worry about the Capitol Hill complex um there's been some slight modifications to the definition of

003electronic meeting again um uh as far as as this board is concerned that um you've already been complying but as we get down there have been some major changes to the definition section in meeting and uh there's a new definition for what is a meeting um um as you can see what's been crossed out um is now changed to a a meeting means a gathering of a public body or specified body with a quorum present and that is convened by an individual with authority to convene the public body or specified body and following the process provided by law for convening the public body or specified body and and this is important for the express purpose of acting as a public body or specified body to receive public comment about a relevant matter deliberate about a

004relevant matter or take action upon a relevant matter um so that's sort of the consideration to be thinking about you know what what constitutes a meeting um obviously there's always some ambiguity everybody can still make arguments on what specific things mean but but I think I think again if you're going to be receiving public comment about a relevant matter deliberate or take action um and maybe the more expansive part is that um receive public comment um it's a little bit broader than than before as you can see they've stricken out the old definition of meeting um they've just cleaned up a few of the other things in the in the definition section um Quorum has been um defined um they they took out a a portion of that so now it's just strictly um a

005simple majority of the membership of the public body and then relevant matter this is uh defined in this new section or newer section relevant matter means a matter that is within the scope of the authority of a public body or specified body um pretty broad relevant matter does not include for a public body with both executive and legislative responsibilities and that would be a board of education you have both executive and legislative of responsibilities a managerial or operational manner so there's that's still kind of there may be some sometimes where you can do something that's strictly managerial or operational and and that you wouldn't have to um convene uh a meeting under the open and public meetings act um there were some other changes but the other section just um section uh 4207 um just

006modified electronic meetings slightly again um I don't think that I don't want to spend a lot of time on this because this doesn't really affect what you've been doing um um there are lots of permissive things that you can do these aren't mandatory so you've already got a policy in place that you don't really need to deal with some of these um but they're down at the bottom they did take um off this uh number nine formerly where except for a unanimous vote a public body that is conducting an electronic meeting shall take all votes by roll call now they they've expanded the definition of electronic meeting so that it now includes if anybody is participating electronically so it makes sense that it used to be that it was strictly an electronic meeting but um

007then also this is a new um change in section 4208 predetermining public Body Action prohibited again this emphasizes um that you're not supposed to meet outside of a meeting when you're you're dealing with this and this says individuals constituting a quorum of a public body may not act together outside a meeting in a concerted and deliberate way to predetermine an action to be taken by the public body at a meeting on a relevant matter and you've seen we've talked about those those um definitions um then um subsection 2 doesn't apply um necessarily in the context of this board so um Paul yes on on that one let me make sure I understand it if a majority of this body if four of us got together privately to discuss an upcoming agenda item and how we

008would like that to um be voted on is is is that an example of what this is talking about if you're together as a quorum I think that that's what this is is directed towards yeah but if I wanted to talk wanted to get yeah I could talk to three at a or two at a time okay right so with that we will um go through an abbreviated updated version we've been through this before uh where the statutes are codified and I know we have some new board members and I'm happy to do anything with them offline to save everybody's time um most of it is is in most of it is if you just work through the handbook it's it's pretty straightforward um when does it apply it applies to meetings of a public

009body your public body about matters within your jurisdiction um and so when you you determine it obviously um the open meetings applies to public body and your meetings so what's a meeting we went over this so you can see that it's now changed um I don't have to reread it for you um but I I think it's key receive deliberate about or act upon so it's not just the acting um or deliberating it's also to receive information and that's one that's a little bit tricky right because lots of people want to talk to you um you know if there's tangent itial if you're if you're somewhere where you're not meeting to conduct business and somebody comes up to you there happens to be a quorum there and they talk about it I think that may

010be outside the express purpose so you'd be okay but um obviously we don't want to go too far with that and the relevant matter on that one so the example that's coming to mind is if we were to have like a informational Town Hall type thing um we go to it's not organized by the board president who has the authority to convene a board meeting but there are four people there and people are giving comment I I think I think if you're all off on your own outside of a quorum receiving comment so that it's not a quorum receiving the same comment at a time I think it can be structured so that so that you can do it you just have to be careful to have like a sit down aren't they usually noticed

011any way like a town hall that the four board members would be at we yes we've been very careful about it I just wanted to ask specifically about if it's convened by an individual who has authority to convene right but again just because you don't convene it you still may run a a muck if you're actually doing what you should be doing in a meeting so okay I wouldn't rely just on that but but yes but but those are good points um and like I say I think it's fact fact sensitive if you're in a town hall and everybody's sort of off or three of you are in one place and another it's not a quorum that's that's receiving the information from them the the challenge with having a meeting of course is that then

012you're supposed to keep the minutes and and do the notice and those sorts of things I've sort of skipped over the the meeting requirements just in the interest of time tonight um John does such a good good job of keeping the the minutes um he hasn't had any problem that I've seen so well he's in he's in charge so um and again a quorum is a simple majority of your membership um so um now when you when you vote it's based on the Quorum that's present but in order to be um a quorum it has to be a majority so so if there are five of you then um you're you're a quorum but then it would be three of the five could vote on something and it would still be appropriate to take take

013action so the the requirements for an open proper open meeting are you give um proper notice um you meet at the proper place and again this is very review for some of your more experienced board members you act within the scope of your noticed agenda and you keep the prop proper records um it that's that's why we the the scope of the notice agenda is important because that's where you're not supposed to take action on something that's not adequately known noticed um and then of course in the case of an emergency if there's an unforeseen circumstance that makes it necessary for you to have an emergency or or conduct urgent matters you give the the best practical practicable um notice that you can give um like that big emergency the yeah yeah so and and

014again um you know you can have administrative emergencies or something that happens um you know you do the best you can and then a majority of the board does have to authorize the meeting after an attempt has been made to reach each board member if you if you can't reach a majority to authorize it technically you're not supposed to call an emergency meeting so so theoretically there's an earthquake and four of us die they cannot get they cannot call a meeting theoretically you know if that happens I think you do what you're going to going to do and let it play out for those listening it doesn't normally get this dark in board meeting until about 7:30 so won't even mention what Daryl was talking about before living um acting within the scope of the

015notice we hinted at that um you must include for the agenda um it must be reasonably specific now that doesn't mean a a specific outcome necessarily but but it's supposed to be enough so the public public can know what you're going to be doing um the topics it can be it can be fairly broad too it's just reasonably specific um and you can take final action only on a topic that's included in the agenda so when patrons come and comment um or you hear something raised the reason we don't take any action is because it's not noticed on the agenda it's not because you don't necessarily have authority to take action it's just it would violate the open and public meetings act so oh that's what I just said so sorry okay so what about

016public participation you go back will you go back to that last slide if a member of the public raises it this is the last bullet point Y which is not on the agenda the presiding board member may allow discussion of the matter but no final action may be taken of the topic or on the topic is that the approach we've taken or just that we don't it seems like we say we don't comment on anything that the public comments on yeah but we can discuss it right under the open meetings act it's not prevented under the open meetings act it's sort of your policy um you're right um it's not that you can't make a comment on it it's you can't take action on it that's up to the presiding board member or yeah yeah

017that's yeah President George yeah okay I mean it has been though I mean right in the message that we share at the beginning of public comment we say the board does not discuss the issues that are not on the meeting's agenda so that would be going out of our practice but it it's happened a time or two where people have had questions and the president has allowed a little discussion it's rare though yeah I think I was just under the impression that we can't but we can not under um the open and public meetings act so um I think it's stated in the in on the agenda that you don't but it's it what what we don't want is for people to think that your not your non-response is a response then again there's a

018difference between an open meeting which most board meetings are and other there are certain other situations um where public has a right um to make reasonable com um comment um for example a public hearing if you have a hearing or tooth in taxation those sorts of things you have to open up for public comment for a reasonable amount of time um and take as much of it as as there is so there's there's not an absolute right for participation now that's been broadened in in recent years where we are supposed to have a a public um comment um portion in meetings that are not work sessions or emergency meetings and then uh school boards are required to allow reasonable opportunity for the public comment on matters that relate to the board's Authority at each open

019meeting now again you have control as to when that is um I think where you've got it I I think there was some movement I think it works better um it's not as disruptive sometimes having public comment right away um can keep people here that maybe don't need to stay for it anyway it's not a spe specified time under it you just have to have it so okay sorry so many questions um but on the public hearings we have to hear from anybody who wants to speak but it's okay to limit the time so that we can keep it in a reasonable time frame am I understanding that right yeah you still you still it you still have have control you don't have to let people talk forever um you can set time limits you

020can you could you could have an outside limit um um this board has just chosen to go as long as it takes and so at our open meetings we do not have to take public comment it's just at the public hearings that we take well public comment there is now Utah law that says you have to have a portion of your um open meeting okay so you do rece open meeting the public body has to and again it relates to matters that are within your Authority so technically you don't have to open it up for some something that you have no authority over you know if it's a state matter or national matter it's not just a forum where somebody can come up and talk about religion I mean we don't have those problems but

021it's not you're not opening it up it's it's it's based on your authority to take actions and then um people do have a right to make recordings as long as they don't interfere um so just just be aware of that the board has at times said you have to sign up by a certain time to be able to speak so sometimes just been whenever you show up you can speak but then what we found is oh well even if we don't have people show up we're going to have to wait till a certain time anyway different you can structure it right yeah you can structure it um proper close meeting requirements you you have to start in a properly noticed open meeting again that can be an emergency meeting if necessary there has to be

022authorization for the closed meeting um you have to close hold the closed meeting for one or more of the typically there are seven permitted purposes um um and then you have to keep the required records or documentation of the closed meeting um there are um some circumstances where you don't have to take minutes or make a recording so to authorize a Clos meeting um the board must first be in the open meeting then you have to have a successful motion to hold a closed meeting and that requires at least to two thirds vote of the board members present um that's not typically a problem here but if if two-thirds don't want to go into Clos session you can't go into close session um again just because something is permitted in a closed meeting and it

023doesn't mean you have to um but so you announce in the in the open meeting the purpose the reason or reasons for holding the closed meeting and again you don't have to get into Super specifics um the location where it'll be held technically um I mean it's if you're going to go somewhere else like you would have to say that but we're in the same location typically or in the same um place and then um a roll call vote for each board member and that's also included in the minutes so the permitted closed meeting purposes again they're typically seven and I've listed the E the at the end of this but discussion of the character professional competence or physical or mental health of an individual again this is any individual doesn't have to be an

024employee it doesn't have to be a student um again um I think the board has is good now and they understand the scope of this um um but as you all learned um the board may not in a closed session interview anyone to discuss applicants for um the feeling of a vacancy of the board so um strategy sessions to discuss collective bargaining so that's why it's important to have um the strategy session and that may change apparently um who knows um strategy sessions to discuss pending reasonably imminent litigation um again this isn't just any legal issue um it's it's a little bit more narrow than that um strategy sessions to discuss real estate purchase exchange or lease if discussion will reveal the value of the property or prevent the board from obtaining the best possible

025terms again it's important that we focus on that latter half too um and then we we we stay on topic for that and then strategy sessions to discuss real estate sale if it will reveal um here so so usually when we're going into close session it's it's purchase exchange or lease um but but when we're selling it to um we just don't sell property as often so we're not we're not going into close session as much for that and then discussions regarding deployment of security Personnel devices or systems and again you don't have to go in but it's often wise I know sometimes there are some things that maybe you want to disclose um but I think if you want to disclose something after you're in Clos session if that I think you need to

026be kind of clear so that you don't so so you know the scope of okay we've had a closed discussion what is somebody authorized to talk about um and then certain confidential procurement functions which typically we would we don't do and then um you can under certain if you're investigating criminal conduct but with this this doesn't come up and if it does you'll be advised on it so um um this is the um training link um that the state auditor has I I'm not sure if did we did they commit to do this now as one of those things or okay but this is this is their training course it's a simple online training course um it's not as specific to a school board um anyway um unless there are other questions again I'm happy

027to to do more training as as the executive committee sees fit um with anyone or or groups um we can ask or go into more detail how long have these the the the changes that you listed at the beginning how long have those been in effect um since since May can you send us the redline version of the changes I can do that I'm I'm I'm wondering why we have this review in January instead of in June for example when all the new stuff comes out I mean we've been potentially out of compliance for six seven eight months right maybe well we try for one thing is we do monitor it and keep you in compliance um but yes it it could be an issue um we've typically just done it because we have new

028board members it's the timing when they come on we don't want to wait so that they don't have any training but there's a requirement we do it once a year the requirement doesn't have a deadline is just at some point during each calendar correct and you and you'll keep us in line I I I try to Yes um yeah my my firm we we actually are the ones that prepare the school Utah school boards Association booklet that goes out we monitor it very very closely and we can add another training in June if we want to but to put that in place instead of you're an for more meetings we can provide more meetings that's we are uh we are under Paul's watchful eye at all times we're grateful for it thank you all right

029any other questions okay let's move on to Item B a review of Robert's Rules of Order Mr Bryon thank you according to GP 106 the the duties of the first vice president one of my chief responsibilities is to serve as parliamentarian for the board and accept responsibilities as designated by the president to ensure Fair open and inclusive deliberations by all board members and board adherence to accepted Roberts Rules of Order um I remind the board that we can change any rule we can change our bylaws we can change our policies but until we do so we are required to follow them and our policy says that this Board needs to follow Robert's Rules of Order so I requested a little review I have I want you to know I've read through all of them 611

030633 pages since I was appointed as parliamentarian it is stunning reading if you want to pick it up I will admit I skimmed over the portions that aren't necessarily applicable to us my worry there is a provision in Robert's Rules of Order that they make seven allowances for small boards a small board is considered anything 12 or less and we are a small board and there are seven allowances my worry though is because we know that small boards have some exceptions to the rule we have a tendency to be a little sloppy and assume we have allowance in every area and that's not necessarily true Robert's Rule says here are the seven areas where small boards can make an exception to the standard procedure so what I'd love to do is just kind of give

031you a crash course on Robert's Rules of Order on how we should proceed um I want to begin I'm going to read as much as I possibly can so that you can hear it coming right from Robert's Rules of Order this is I'm going to read a few portions of it few portions is good um just so you can kind of hear the official language this is the official version this is the 12th edition um they are up to 12 editions um but I want to begin here business is brought before an assembly by the motion of a member that's how we conduct our business we make de debate and take action and vot vote on motions a motion is a formal proposal by a member in a meeting that the assembly takes certain action

032the basic form of aemotion the only one whose introduction brings business before the assembly is the main motion now we'll go into some of those details in just a minute now there are three things that have to occur in order for a motion to come before the assembly number one a member has to make the motion we'll get into some details in the middle you have to make a motion number two a member has to Second the emotion and then this is critical and this is where I think we've strayed a little bit it does not come before the assembly until the chair or the president States the question until she states the question it is not before this board and that's important that'll be important for just a minute so just remember it has

033to have a motion it has to have a second and the chair has to state the question the official minutes need to reflect what the chair stated not necessarily the first motion that was made and you we'll talk about why that's important in a minute but the chair stating of the question is what brings it before the assembly and then three things have to happen in order for us to take action on it there needs to be a debate a call for the question and that's where the board the board president simply says it's time to vote she calls the question and then she announces the results technically you have until she announces the results to change your mind you can say I vote I but before she announces the results if you say never

034mind I vote nay that's fine but once she announces the results it is set and the decision is final um I do want to impress let me read this neither the making nor the seconding of a motion places it before the assembly only the chair can do that by the third step stating the question so let's talk about um a little bit about each one of those I just wanted to talk about debate and motions because parliamentary procedure they are really Str rigid here on the fact that there should be no debate until a motion has been made and yes we have a little leeway there but the spirit of that I think is very important to hear so I wanted to read that we really ought to avoid any type of discussion or debate

035until there's a motion that we're talking to that prevents us from just aimlessly talking and gives us a little bit of a Direction so as parliamentarian I'm just going to Simply re remind the board that we shouldn't be debating this the debate should be limited until there is a motion on the table here's the language under parliamentary procedure strictly speaking discussion of any subject is permitted only with reference to a pending motion the general rule against discussion without a motion is one of parliamentary procedures powerful tool for keeping business on track on track and in observance of this EXP can be an important factor in making even a very small meeting rapidly move rapidly moving and interesting now there is a little bit of a leeway for small boards and this is one of the

036seven and I just wanted to read the exact language um no I'm going to save that hold let me save that for just a minute so we really ought to get to a motion as soon as possible the typical process will be a presentation of information staff's going to come and present something or a board member comes and presents something and then we get to a motion fairly quickly and then that we get to the debate a motion a second a statement from the stating the question by the board by the chair and then the debate um before the chair States the question the motion belongs to its maker that's very important before the chair States the question the motion belongs to its maker after the chair States the question it is no longer your

037motion it belongs to the assembly it belongs to all of us and any changes to it have to be approved by the whole board so before she states the question you can say you know what let me change that you can modify it someone here can suggest a modification um we can have you know we can have several of that but the moment she states the question it no longer belongs to the maker it belongs to all of us question Aaron maybe um I think so you have to clearly State your question before the chair says it your motion your motion yes um I don't fully understand what you mean by the whole body then owns the motion and they can change it don't you have to like call for a yes but what I

038mean is it's not yours I don't need to ask your permission to change it oh okay I see it no longer belongs to you it belongs to all of us gotcha and you can't necessarily modify it without everyone's approval there was a moment where you could have said no no no not five I meant seven okay um and then the moment it's stated by the the chair seven is the issue and and to make any modification even the maker has to require it requires everyone's approval okay thank you now one thing that happens in that moment so there's a brief moment where I make a motion or someone makes a motion and someone else before it stated invite or asks the maker would you be open to a modification then you need the Maker's permission

039the maker owns the motion and so if Su if Suzanne made a motion Aaron could say would you be open to a modification if she if she says yes and she modifies her motion that does not to be need to be seconded because her inquiry is assumed to be the second and then as long as you're okay I approve I yes I'm open into that modification then the chair States the new motion as it's been modified and then that becomes the business before the board zap did I clarify that I think so okay um I just I want to read that officially until the chair States the question the maker has the right to modify his motion as he pleases or to withdraw it entirely after the question has been stated by the chair the

040motion becomes the property of the assembly and then its maker can do neither of these without the assembly's consent um and then one more they address that a little bit here I wanted to read this before a motion has been stated by the chair it's property its property of the Mover who can withdraw it or modify it without asking the consent of anyone thus in the brief interval between the making of the motion and the time when the chair places it before the assembly by stating it the maker can withdraw it as follows and then give some language to do so okay a mo a note on seconding I think this is very important for new board members because this I this took me a while to feel comfortable seconding a motion that I disagreed

041with someone made a motion and the action of the motion I did not want I felt like well I can't second that I felt like seconding and I agree and that is not Robert's Rule of Order a second merely implies that the seconder agrees that the motion should come before the meeting and not that he necessarily favors the motion so let's say for example there's a motion on the table I disagree with the action of the motion but want it discussed then a very good thing to do would be to Second it I want that brought before the assembly and discussed even if it's to vote against it but that's very important that a second doesn't necessarily it's not your way of saying I agree it means I believe it should be brought before the

042assembly okay this robertt R of order goes into there is an order to motions there are main motions there are subsidiary motions there are privileged motions and there are in incident motions and there is an order to tackling them which really really doesn't manifest itself here but let me just kind of give you the best of them all subsidiary motions are where we take an we we were proposing a an action be taken on the main motion those are subsidiary motions and the three most common that we use are postpone amend and refer to committee it is not appropriate it is a it is it is incorrect nomenclature when you intend to move an item off the to-do list off the agenda we're not going to tackle it at this meeting we're going to do

043it at another meeting we simply the nomenclature has come to be that you table that that is incorrect that is wrong nomenclature to table an event means let's pause temporarily but come back to it before the meeting is over if you do not intend to come back to it during the meeting the proper motion is a postpone I move that we postpone this issue um or amend we'll talk about amend in just a minute or refer to committee those are the most common subsidiary motions that we will use so I move to amend I move to postpone or I move to commit or refer this to committee privileged motions there it's been in the news a lot if you're watching the US government uh there was a representative I think it was a Senator there

044was a representative that asked for a privileged motion on bathroom use privileged motions do not relate to the pending business but special matters of immediate importance um the three most Comm the four most common pending Mo or privileged motions that we will face are raising a question of privilege that's what happened at the US capital I raise a question of privilege um something I need to do I'm asking the board's permission to that's a raising a question of privilege recess is a privileged motion I move that we recess uh adjourn is a privileged motion uh ending the meeting or fixing the time to adjourn I move that we adjourn at 10:00 that's a privileged motion um not a whole lot to say about privileged motions incidental motions are an incident has occurred and we need

045to deal with it we need to deal with this incident and the most common that we there's only two that I felt like we would ever even address in this board and that is point of order point of order is when someone believes that we have broken one of the rules of Robert's Rules of Order um I'll get to privileged oh point of order I think I've got that well maybe we do that now point of order says I believe we've broken a rule what you're doing is you're asking for a judgment by the president we have typically said when maybe someone yells at someone or says something rude someone will yell out point of order as if to say pause everyone be nice and then let's move on and that's not appropriate use of

046point of order point of order is someone has broken the rules and the chair needs to render a judgment if the chair says point taken then the chair instructs the member or the members about the violation ask them to not violate the rules um if the chair says Point not taken I'm not going to rent I'm not making a judgment I'm not saying that that was inappropriate you can actually override the to the chair if the chair rules on a point of order and says no violation then you can move to appeal and then the bo it goes before the board and if that's the case then action could be taken against the offending member so if you feel like any of our rules have been broken the appropriate reaction is to say point of

047order and then discuss to the chair tell the chair what you believe the rule is that's been broken and then we all wait for the chair to to render a judgment on on that point of order can I ask a question yeah so just now when you said our rues one of our rules have been broken so let's say we think someone is violating open meetings open meeting law um would we use point of order as point of order just for Robert's Rules of Robert our bylaws and anything that we're subject to state law federal law any so if people are making a comment on Personnel or somebody's personality you is still point of order so if someone starts talking about character incompetency and you say president point of order this issue is this issue

048this we are discussing character and competency and that is forbidden by Utah public meeting code then she would rule I agree and we need to immediately stop the discussion good good point it's not just Robert's Rule of Order it's anything any rule to which we are subject whether it just happened or not the sooner the better but yes but the one thing I wanted to say is Port of order isn't a way to just simply hey I'm drawing attention that someone's being mean it's chair someone's breaking the rules and we need to stop the breaking of the rules and then we wait for her to render a judgment and again if you disagree if there's enough that disagrees with the chair you can appeal and then bring it before the whole the whole body okay

049so that's those are incidental motions the other one that I want you to be aware that you have the right to call is what we what is called in Robert's Rule of Order objection to the consideration of the question I do not think we should be discussing this that is a privileged motion and you object to the consideration of the question and then the president rules on that and you can have the body appeal you can appeal and say I'd like a I would like a vote from the I would like a vote from the board and that one is initially a president's rule so like if someone didn't want to talk about an agenda item president would have to say no okay but I don't I don't know that I've ever heard that and

050I just wanted to let you you don't you if you object to anything being brought before this board you have the right to object to that and say I object to the consideration of the question so let's let's talk about amendments the most common thing we do is someone will make a motion it gets second it's stated by the chair then we debate it and during the debate there is a desire to amend the motion so let me walk this is a little tricky so I thought I'd just read most of this okay amendments must be seconded wait I skipped one no okay amendments must be seconded debate must conform to the desirability of the amendment debate must be confined to the desirability of the amendment however and must not extend to the merits of

051the motion to be amended except as may be necessary to determine whether the amendment is advisable so we immediately pause on discussing the motion and all debate simply F FOC focuses on the amendment do you is the am is the amendment appropriate and then once the amendment is done we can go back to the main motion uh secondary Amendment cannot be amended you can have two well we won't worry about that but you can have two um amendments going on at the same time um typically it is most desirable when you amend that you simply add insert or strike out that's preferable rather than just restating the motion if you would say I'd like to add or insert or strike out if we could do that that would be best that's best parliamentary procedure is

052can I make this motion work I need to amend this portion can we drop that word can we add this word or can we insert this phrase um I think that's the spirit of an amendment rather than I don't like your your motion and I'm going to completely throw it out the window and replace it with my own that's that's we'll get to that in a minute but that's really not the spirit of an amendment an amendment is I I'm I'm intending to strike out um add or insert um could you explain the difference between add and insert add is at the end could we add at the end of that five words that say blah blah blah at the end of the whole motion or at theend sentence yeah sentence paragraph or motion insert

053is can I insert one word there and just say um licensed I think that's an important addition or insertion so that's the spirit of an amend or an amendment if you wanted to make a whole new motion how would you go about that okay let's do that I'm coming to that one because that does that does come up okay um as already stated an amendment must be gerain to be in order it must be Germain to be Germain an amendment must in some way involve the same question that was raised by the motion in which it was applied and ready it cannot simply be the equivalent of the rejection of the original motion that is an inappro an improper Amendment so if you're just simply no I don't want to vote on yes I want

054to vote on no and so I propose that we completely throw that Amendment out and replace it with its opposite that's an inappropriate motion but if the wording is similar because this the same idea it's the same idea that we're talking about and it's not simply the rejection of your motion but I want to word it differently then you would go ahead and change the whole you can change the whole motion as long as those two requirements are met it's germine it address it it deals with the same question and it isn't simply the opposite that answer your question yes so in the spirit of parliamentary procedure if you can make the motion work by making a tweak if you're more comfortable if it had a tweak to it let's State The Tweak to the

055motion if you just want a whole new motion then make sure it's Germain and it isn't just the opposite of the motion so going back to miss Barrow's question if you wanted to to make a motion to the opposite you would have to wait for the vote to be completed and then if it failed you could consider motion yep the opposite yep so you still can unless it passes but sometimes I've noticed that in the past someone has just said I can tell that there's this many people for it and I can tell that this many people and the person who spoke for first is for it and I want to speak against it so I'm just going to Simply throw that motion out and replace it with the opposite that is an inappropriate am

056improper Amendment a good question [Music] um and the proper terminology is amend not substitute and not friendly it's not a substitute motion it's an amendment that may have a substitute in it but I think the proper term is amend any questions one more um and that is debate so three items put it before the assembly three items take action motion second stating the question and then comes debate once again we should limit debate until there's a motion on the table that is the best procedure if you need some information I can't make a motion no one can make a motion because I don't have enough information to say this is what I would propose then we discuss but ideally we get to a motion as poss as quickly as we can now while debating the

057motion here are the Robert's Rules of Order all right I'm going to read these to just so you can hear them okay no me unless the assembly has a special rule providing otherwise no member can speak more than twice to the same question on the same day now we're going to amend that in just a minute that's that's one of the things that small boards get to amend but I want you to hear the normal normal operation under Robert Rules of Order is you you no one can speak speak more than twice to a question merely asking a question or making a brief suggestion is not counted as speaking in a debate nor is the making of a secondary motion counted as speak speaking in in the debate a member cannot make a second speech

058on the same question the same day until every member who desires to speak on it has had an opportunity to do so so normal rules are no one speaks more than twice on any issue and no one speaks twice until everyone has spoken now this is what we have an exception to procedure for small boards there is no limit to the number of times a member can speak to a debatable question in a small board appeals however follow the same rule you can't speak twice so we have as a small board we we we don't have to follow the two speech limit but I read that because I think as a courtesy we should each wait until everyone has had a chance to speak before you speak again and then we really ought to I

059think there's a difference between no you're not changing your opinion so I'm going to speak again and again and again until you change your opinion versus I've stated my point I've stated my opinion and speaking again is not going to add any new information to it in the spirit of that I would say let's limit the de let's limit the the debate if you're adding something we don't have a limit on the number of times we can speak but the spirit of that would say number one don't add don't say anything else until everyone else has had a chance to speak and then let's do what we can to kind of limit the number of speeches you give in debate there's no limit for a small board but we don't want it to go on

060endlessly Ry right an example of one of our long debates would be the cell phone policy for example that was such a broad policy all kinds of different pieces of that of that policy wasn't defined to just a very specific thing and can I point out why go ahead we never made a motion on it we didn't debate on a motion we debated on cell phone use in the classroom without a motion on the table and I wonder if a motion would have centered the debate on the merits of that motion so let me see if I understand so we had a two or three page policy or even just a onepage policy would we make a motion on each individual section then and talk about that individual section I'm just curious how we would

061tackle something that large with motions that's a good question but you can so when I um when I watched the committee meetings at the Capitol when they're introducing a bill into the which is the question they usually have a period of clarifying questions before the motion is even made and so I think that at that time if you have a question about a line in the policy that's when you can ask a clarifying question and then when everybody's had a chance to ask their clarifying questions about the agenda item or whatever then you can make a motion like I I move that we um change this word in this line of this policy and does does that make sense so the first part shouldn't be a debate it should just be asking staff asking staff

062I used to be so close to the mic now I'm too far so um is asking staff or the board member that brought the agenda item can you clarify this piece for me instead of giving your opinion or your experience with it does I think it's really helpful to watch what they do there are some really good parliamentarians on the hill that run meetings really well and that technically is not considered debate is I have some questions before we get to the debate and the first thing the chair should do is are there any questions regarding this issue before we get to a motion and a debate but I think the quicker we could have gotten to a a motion this it would have narrowed the discussion much more quickly yeah I I would Envision

063it then kind of like what Lisa was saying there would be a lot of clarifying questions at the beginning that might have taken a long time once the clarifications were done a motion would be made and we'd all be ready to go okay okay I'm just going to read these These are Robert's Rules of Order they get a little uncomfortable but I think there's a reason I think there's something to going back to the procedure uh this one's easy in debate a members remarks must be gerain to the question before the assembly that is the statements must be bearing on whether the immediate pending motion should be adopted any discussion that isn't related to the merits of the question should not be made um this one is where we have used point of order the

064most under no circumstance can a member attack or question the motives of another member and I think we have violated this I know I have and so I wonder if we just draw a clean slate and say under no circumstance can anyone attack or question the motives the discussion is on the merits of the question and and then I love this statement the measure not the member is the subject of debate the moment the chair hears such words as fraud liar lie idiot Etc used about a member in debate she must act immediately and Divi decisively to correct the matter and prevent its repetition okay here's the uncomfortable one I I commit to do this members of an assembly cannot address one another directly but must address all remarks through the chair and we are

065not given any leeway on a small board members of an assembly cannot address one another directly but must address all remarks through the chair as much as possible the use of names of members should be avoided in the debate in debating a member cannot reflect adversely on any prior Act of the society that is not then pending in debate the maker of a motion while he can vote against it is not allowed to speak against his own motion I thought that was interesting he need not speak at all but if he does he is obliged to take the favorable position can I ask you to clarify um where we cannot address anyone directly but it may must be made through the chair could you give an example of what that would look like or sound

066like Madame President um the member is referring to something that happened a couple years ago and I remind you that this is what happened I think the idea is that we are trying to keep it from becoming a two-person debate that this is a conversation of a board okay if that makes sense and Utah legislators and the federal legis are very good at this every comment is made to the chair Mr chairman now just if you're curious it is in Robert's Rules of Order so I'll read know does this apply just to debate then this addressing the chair just during the debate yeah the president or chief officer of an organized Society who normally presides at its meetings is then addressed as Mr President or Madame President so technically it's Madame President and then we

067speak to the chair now I think there's a very good thing here and that's why I'm going to commit to do it cuz the moment I look and I'm talking to Daryl it gets personal the moment it's here it stays on the issue of the question and I think there's Great Value in Madame President and then even as much as possible the use of names or members should be avoided in debate that and the example they give is to say something like the member from District Four yeah if you want to yeah yeah or the member who just spoke or now again I the member with black I for one am not going to call point of order seems so impersonal I know I'm I for one I'm not going to call point of order

068if Suzanne says Brian just made a great Point um but I think in the spirit of this the more we address the chair the less we're talking to and about about someone and usually what happens is I disagree with you and now I'm trying to convince you that I'm right and you're wrong and now it's this instead of Madame President here's my argument on the issue and then she says the same thing Madame President here's my issue I just think we take that personal potential attack out of it if we address the chair and try not to use names [Music] um that's all I had any questions Madame President does the assembly have any questions does the assembly have any questions I was curious if there is um like a a I don't know a

069summary of Robert's rues of law anywhere yes where could I get coming to order um to order jurass it's 400 pages long instead of 63 633 Jurassic Parliament comes quite often to usba and makes presentations and and they do a lot of summary and I've got a couple things I'll send you okay um I'll be honest the best thing for me was reading through them have you in your um little bag that you got at the new board member training there's a spiral bound coming to order book that's also a good summary it's not 600 Pages or even 400 but it's still a read oh please Mr Madam president I have a question oh boy I'm gonna have to adjust to this how if a matter is coming before the board and I have a

070question about the matter or something that uh and I and I don't mean this to be about me so let's just say if anyone has a question about the matter uh and they want to say well how might this impact our budget how would they go about doing that they would ask her she would ask you to respond Mr Larson would you mind answering that question now technically I I take it by member you are invited P to participate in a board meeting but you're not the board member that takes action and so I don't think there's any issue with someone asking you a question directly so is it directly there's nothing in here I didn't find anything in here that says you can't talk to staff or question the presenter or it's just during

071debate we need to address the chair and I think that's the spirit of let's not let this get personal so that that underlines I guess the the structure of asking as many questions as possible before the motion mhm to bring Clarity to the issue before there's debate on the issue thank you madam president other questions Paul Madame President if I may uh please I I also think the board not that I'm arguing against Robert his 12th edition or any of the 600 and some odd pages but I think the board also has the prerogative to set procedures for themselves so if you find any of these that's very much in here uh a to to be an obstacle to meaningful discussion then you would have the prerogative to vote as a group to modify those

072rules to your needs do you want to know what the motion is called I move I move that we suspend the rules that's in okay well there you go Robert thought I that we suspend the rules and allow members of the board to speak freely to each other or whatever you know we have the prerogative to say this is this is cuming this is not leading to fruition and so I move that we suspend the rules but I I was impressed that I had a lot of those questions and I found something in here that related to there's the motion I would make to do that yeah yeah like I said not suggesting that any of it needs to be modified just if that's what you wanted to do there's there's the opportunity to do

073that so right before I want to argue with Nikki I just say I move the we suspend rules that's right personal there you go is that under privilege motion that is a what is suspend the rules I didn't write it down cuz I didn't think we'd ever deal with it but yes it's one of those is so would you move to suspend the rules like as a part of your bylaws or in a specific instance you can do both great questions but Madame President I'd like to give them a try before we decide that they're uncomfortable and then we can decide which ones are just not working for us so is that a motion no all right can can I clarify Madame President is inside and outside of debate no just within okay just wanted

074to make sure that is a role that I'm very comfortable suspending all right but again I I really think there's wisdom In the Heat of the debate keeping the focus on we're all focused on talking to you rather than focusing on on each other that's the spirit of why it's so important during debate is it doesn't get personal yes great points thank you I really appreciate your efforts Mr denford and um and thank you for your presentation let's move to agenda item C uh calendar committee Representatives with Dr Anderson thank you madam chair um as outlined by District policy d207 um we have a parent representative from each of our High School feeder areas and they serve four-year terms and every once in a while we turn them over we don't turn them over all

075at once so as the Stagger terms and that way we have um institutional knowledge moving forward so that they can work on the calendar committee effectively this year we have three uh openings turnover areas and they're in the West Jordan feeder the Mountain Ridge feeder system and the Copper Hills feeder system um the policy outlines that the they are these are board approved parent members uh that we should get input from various parent groups including PTA and school Community Council the names that have been recommended to serve um on the calendar committee from various board members are Julia Merill from the West Jordan feeder Brian call from Mountain Ridge feeder Lisa eson from Copper Hills feeder these parents have all been contacted by Mr Olen who works in planning and student services and they have

076all indicated their willingness and ability to serve on the committee it just requires a board approval can I ask how many years do they serve again it's a four-year term four years okay thank you you rotate every two but it's a four-year term right there's there's change every two that we don't change every year we only change every two years yeah yeah every two years there'll be some there'll be some turnover there may that may VAR slightly in case a parent can't can no longer serve it it varies but that's the intent so this is the clarifying question part of this agenda item and and I have a question as far as Robert's Rules of Order and this meeting so would we make a motion in this meeting to um approve these calendar committee members

077for the next four years is that what the motion would be Madam chair I believe that's correct or I maybe I should ask yeah parliamentarian Madam chair no so this isn't debate this is clarifying question phase still I think we can take action in a study session yes and so the question is is this something that the public needs to weigh in on or is this something that we just move forward and get going on and so I think this is very much something that we're looking for a motion approval and a second and then a vote and then we move forward with these three that's how we've uh proceeded in the past it's on the agenda it is is an item to take action on it's U something that doesn't need public input it's

078just by by policy the Board needs to approve it so that's how it's historically been done just in this meeting that's correct and something that executive committee has committed to doing is under desired outcome we will try to indicate we're we desire a motion to approve deta in this case that didn't happen this one came a little later but that is our intent you'll note that we have added a strategic plan pillar to try to help us make sure that we're on target with the ultimate goals of the district in our conversations and then we will also try to include in the desired outcome a motion to approve or whatever so you kind of have a feel for when you need to or not would that be helpful I don't no we'll try it and

079then if it's not helpful we'll ignore it Madam chair I move that we approve the following individuals as members of our calendar committee Julia Merill Brian call Lisa eson a second we have a motion by Brian Barnett a second by Bryce stford that we approve as members of our calendar committee boom she stated the question Julia Merill Brian call and Lisa esus is there any mo any um debate to the motion it was so close all right seeing none I'll call for a vote uh those in favor please say I I I and any oppose please say nay all right that motion carries unanimously okay Madame President I failed to add one thing that you may want to be aware of and this board may be want to be aware of if the chairman oh

080whoops when a proposal is perfectly clear to all present a vote can be taken without a motion having been introduced unless agreed upon by unanimous consent however all proposed action must be approved by vote under the same rules as a larger meeting except that a vote can be taken initially by a show of hands which is a better method in small meetings if it's obvious that everyone is agreeing you don't necessarily have to have a motion you can say seeing no objection we will move forward okay so if you sense that it's clearly Tracy did that a lot seeing no objection we're going to move forward in that direction and that's approved great thank you but I think it's appropriate to say is is there any debate or should we but I did want to

081throw that in there is obvious that are if it's clear that this board is all uni UniFi that no one is objecting the questions reveal that the body language reveals that you have the right to say seeing no objection we move forward in this direction great thank you uh I would just like to add a thank you to those individuals that have just been appointed to the calendar committee it is a huge blessing to our whole District that we have that Committee in place and we appreciate your efforts and willingness to serve okay moving on to item D permit requests at Copper Hills High School back to Dr Anderson thank you um maybe it might be helpful just to provide a brief review of the permit process we call them permits um other districts may

082call them other uh by other names but an outof boundary permit is extended to a student who wishes to attend a school that is not in their boundary and those are governed that permit process is governed by state law uh 53g 6-4 and also by our our school district policy as93 and there are processes in place established by state law that allow students to apply for a permit um an application during a certain window this window extends from the beginning or middle of uh I should say middle of November until I believe the first Friday of February so that process is going on right now we prioritize permits as as outlined by the the board has set up a process so that in the month of December we have a permit process where you if

083you apply during the month of of December until December 31st you are taken and then those names are put into a lottery in the event that there are more permit requests then there is space available does that make sense and then that then the process will continue in different stages until the first February uh first Friday in February um schools have to Grant seats to outof boundary students if their enrollment for the following year is projected to be less than 90% of their building capacity after that the board has established a couple of tiers I think those are on your board docs um tier one is if they don't have any Portables and they're below their capacity um they in order to add permits they talk with their administrators of schools tier two is if

084they're in the category of having uh one to six Portables they need approval in order to accept permits and then there's notification given to the board tier three is more than six Portables you need approval from cabinet in order to extend those permits and a discussion with the board and the AOS that's what brings us to tonight's agenda item Copper Hills uh would be considered in tier three because they have more than six Portables um they have a higher enrollment however their enrollment uh their building capacity allows um for some room in between the Capac capacity and their projected enrollment they figure they have around 100 seats they could potentially offer permits to keep them still below their building capacity in Co in the case of Copper Hills they are ex uh requesting 71 to

085extend a permit offer to 71 students now they fully realized that they want to extend knowing that may all may not accept but they do want to extend the 71 request and that's why we're here uh discussing this with the board any questions can you talk to me a little bit about where Copper Hills is falling where their enrollment is and how this would affect them so their enrollment is is forecast to go down a little they've been in the 2800 is and I'll use the word ish lightly there um they are going to be in the 2700s this year and so their enrollment has dipped over time in the next couple of years they'll go back up into the 2800s and therefore cast to stay in that general area for the the next uh

086several years does that answer your question their building capacity is around 2880 so almost 2,900 as it's presently constituted can you remind me how many Portables they have they have eight Portables and are they all currently being used as classrooms as far there there are Portables that they use for storage for athletics those do not count as instructional Portables so just to be clear they do have Portables that don't aren't being used um as classrooms but those are designated differently than the eight Portables that are designed for instruction yeah good question the president I move that we approve the permits requested by Copper Hills High School motion do I have a second second okay we have a motion by Bryce stford second by Brian Barnett that we approve the additional permits at Copper Hills High

087School for next school year uh any debate on the motion I would just ask Mr Anderson I our soft-hearted wonderful principles often oh I can make room for you I can make room for you and oh that's we can squeeze one more in and and without realizing that we've put the students who are bounded at a disadvantage we've got crowded Halls we've got crowded lunchrooms um I don't know where this is I never know when these requests come if it's uh yeah I have no I have no hesitance if principal garrettson is saying I have no hesitance that is not a burden on our staff that is not a burden on our faculty so at some point I just need you to say in in maybe it's superintendent I just need you to say in

088my best judgment this is not going to be a burden to Copper Hills I don't know if we've got just a tenderhearted situation where okay will squeeze you in because my heart bleeds for your situation and other students are going to struggle because of it when we discussed this as cabinet we asked for additional information and that information was brought back so it's not as if we simply said oh yeah they want more let's move forward um and because the number will still be below what it is currently it felt like their capacity the capacity was there but we ask ourselves those same questions every year and um the there is secondary schools if you grant a permit you're going to have an additional student for up to three years in elementary you have them

089for seven so it it's a little bit of a different look for a secondary school because uh you're not you're not looking at a lasting impact if you if you allow those permits not as long as you would with an elementary at any rate so this request has your St of approval on it cabinet discussed it in two different meetings before bringing it forward and so is are these permits approved by the board is that part of it I thought that we just discussed it with the board so do we need to make a motion to approve the permits because guess that's true it I mean do we need to and I should have asked that in the clarifying quot but it's now that the motion was made in the way that was it was

090worded that like for the board to approve then I wonder I I didn't think that we were the ones that approved this may may I clarify yeah um thank you for bringing that up on the tiers that you have on on board docs this does fall into the CATE category of tier three where it's approved by cabinet which has been done as superintendent indicated after a couple of rounds of discussion and and you know the good principal from the Copper Hills area is is uh supportive of this and and wants these permits to be extended uh we've discussed it um in cabinet and has been approved now according to the board's tiered permit um process it's simply a discussion with the board so there is no motion needed there's no approval needed by the board

091we're letting you know that cabinets discussed it and approved it and we're having the discussion with you now the board can change their own rules anytime but that's what we have in place uh for the tiers I think think we're all just enthused about Robert's Rules of Order and we want to practice we're trying to get all of our practice in making these motions so do we technically need to close the motion because we're not going to vote there is no harm in voting on it it's just not required you're right Lisa you're absolutely right and the most appropriate motion would have been I see no I have no objection with them moving forward I'm not going to take action to prevent them from doing this I will take just a moment to say that

092I've spent some time talking to um faculty and community members and this seems like a welcome exception to the role from what I'm hearing Madame President I would like to bring this policy back to the board there's some holes we haven't looked at it for a long time there's some holes that I see it at least I'd like to have some conversation not about this specific but about the Bing the tear or the permit process both our second vice president we'll take that take note of that and we'll make sure we bring it back so point of order president because we there was a motion and a second and you called the question I'd think we do have to take a vote on the motion even though I I agree that the motion is insignificant

093ific well it's good practice if nothing else all right all in favor of the motion on the table to um extend the permit requests at Copper Hills High School um please say I I I and any opposed right motion carries I would like to m madame president I think this is an important clarification that I think this is a great thing to have put on the desired outcome no board action will be re will is required simply board notification yes I think that's a great thing to to distinguish you know what there is we are not seeking so I would say when staff brings us an issue if no board action is required that that be stated on the objective on the desired outcome thank you that's a great point and something I tried to

094relay but probably did a poor job on that so we will make sure to watch sh carefully on the next agenda can I make one comment for the board's sake it took me eight years to figure out why policies are worded the named the way they are I finally dawned on me a policies are administrator as policies are administrator of [Music] schools B policies are business ad administrator policy IES D policies are district policies so if it's below the administrator if it's below the business administrator it's a d policy so this is an as policy this should say District which should be called administr which should be referred to as administrative of school policies I it took me eight years to finally figure out the noen clature so I wanted to share that this time

095I was writing fast enough perfect okay moving on to agenda item e board meeting calendar so each year one of the responsibilities of of the board president is to bring a proposed calendar for review by the board you will find that attached on board docks um it's our practice to meet on the second and fourth Tuesdays of the months uh but occasionally their exceptions so a few that we would want to call attention to the first is July 22nd is the week of a holiday so July 24th of course um and we do have a fifth Tuesday during that month generally we have not held a study session during July so this would be the only meeting of the board for July and something that we've done over the past few years is couple the

096summer retreat with the July meeting so a few things to consider and discuss in this week so I would love to hear your thoughts on whether we move to Tuesday July 29th or if you prefer to stay with the fourth Tuesday which would be the holiday week request for personal privilege um I I will be out of town on the 22nd but I am just one member of a seven member board so president I move that we hold the meeting on the 15th of July would which would be right in the center of the month in that that is our only meeting and and I think that uh Mr Larsson had a comment also just for the information of the board not that there's a um usually the county will assign potential truth and Taxation

097hearings as the first Tuesday in August okay just for the information of the board you can want you to know that in this conversation the first Tuesday in August we'd be too if we had to do that we do back to we might be doing backtack board meetings is what he's saying we did it the 29th Madam president can I speak on that please our Administration staff gets very little holidays and many of our staff take July 4th to 24th off we have a lot of people out we're I think having a meeting in July um at that time might put a extra pressure on them and certainly on some board members so are you proposing we hold no meeting in July or just not the 15th um I don't I don't think we need

098one in July I think we could do our our so-called Retreat which I don't like that word but that's on the record I think we could do that in June I think we do that in August but if not if we're going to do it in July 29th seems a good day aren't we required to have a meeting every month I I have to check I believe we are required to have a meeting one meeting a month my I'll let Mr van Coman look this up but my recollection is that uh minutes of the most recent meeting must be approved within 30 days let's let's let's check that for sure so can I speak on that then Can we cancel June and July just wondering there's how long do you like your meetings that was

099Sor stic I don't know if Robert's Rules allow sarcastic another consideration is there's usually bids or some something that's waiting for board approval uh John arguing in favor of additional meetings I'm trying to bring information to I want to say I want to say point of order even though it doesn't make sense in this case just point of order there is a motion on the table right now that is that correct that is correct we haven't received second I renew my I think the 15th is the best day so I move that we hold our July meeting on the 15th May I add I'm not available on July 15th have a second to the motion okay I'll second it so we can discuss it [Laughter] so let me just take a little poll July 15th

100we have one member unavailable July 22nd two members of the I I haven't mentioned this but I also will be out of town July 22nd how does the 29th look do we have conflicts there I like the 29th it do it does potentially put us two meetings in a row so vote with full knowledge I it seems like that has happened before though this is not unprecedented can can I speak on that so it's not two meetings in a row truth and Taxation meeting is a much different meeting than board meeting so that is not two meetings in a row and we don't even know if we're going to have a truth in taxation and it's possible to have a brief board meeting on the 29th if that's a concern right I can't speak to

101you but I second that I feel like if you say the words brief board meeting out loud a cur every one of us needs to walk knock on wood we could certainly do our best to keep a brief meeting so can I speak to that um do we have to do the retreat in the summer like there could be a different time that we do our strategic planning which is what that meeting's for we don't have to throw a longer meeting in the summer just because we've done it in the past absolutely I we just had one in December right so that is on the table okay let's stay ger Germain to the motion we're discussing the idea of moving the meeting to July 15th any additional discussion there okay let's take a vote all

102in favor of moving the July meeting to July 15th please say I I I what was that mine it I that was not an i okay thank you I'll read names I'll call names out okay and those opposed n okay so we have how does the chairman vote the chairman is neutral um I um I will vote nay on that one so that motion does not carry and the descending votes were uh myself and darl Robinson who Zen wood Lisa Dean four therefore to reconsider this motion only some only the four that voted with the majority in the prevailing mood can make another motion so I move to schedule our board meeting in July for July 29th I second okay we have a motion by Miss Woods a second by Miss Dean that we move

103our July meeting to July 29th and any discussion there okay I have one um Madame President was that a brief meeting in July so in other words with that can whether or not it's in this motion or not can we consider the retreat at a different time the So-Cal Retreat absolutely a regular board meeting not a prolonged day doesn't give us 30 days to approve the minutes though I I believe you just have to make pending uh minutes available within 30 to the public within 30 days so the board doesn't have to take action to finalize them within 30 days the minutes that we were looking to approve is at the May 27th on this year's current calendar is that what we were talking about or is it referring to the budget hearing on June

10410th June 10th okay thank you if we make those pending ones available I think we'll be fine all is it your legal advice that we can hold a meeting on June 10th and July 29th and we're not violating any state law I'm not seeing anything that requires you where did I but I'm not uh the state board has to meet at least 11 times a year but that's in the code um but there's not something that I'm aware that's the same for but I'm still looking then in answer to your question Mr Robinson the motion right now is just for a a board meeting not for a retreat so I think we can consider those separately if that is more comfortable to you is that what you're hoping for open okay let's consider this as

105a board meeting right now any other discussion okay let's call he has that Madam president he raises an if we're not required to have a July meeting if that I have always believed the July meeting was required by law I would love to vote on not having a meeting at all and I I would like to have a pending meeting because sometimes there are um time sensitive items that I don't want to keep people waiting and I I guess it's just another three weeks but I feel like um I'd rather have that meeting pending in case there is some time sensitive I I don't want to um I'm sorry I was looking at Ry I want to um have that available in case there is a something that the Board needs to discuss and approve

106or not approve if that makes any sense because there have been things that have come up in the July meeting I think that and I agree with that I just think it's easier to add a needed meeting than to cancel a not needed meeting we're less likely to take a meeting off the calendar when we don't need it than to add a meeting when we do need it I think there might be merits on possibly not having a July meeting and then if there are pending issues the board can take action to to schedule a meeting Madame President if I may one thing we could do is um agree that in August the study session could include voting on some bids and some other things that had um collected over July and that would that

107would give us an opportunity to vote on some things earlier if necessary giving staff an entire month off appeal to me motion to amend the current motion I'd like to I'd like to motion that the July 29th meeting be taken off well that's a I guess that's an opposite Amendment right no you're just simply saying that the July 29th meeting is off the calendar and scheduled only if needed but the date is reserved that's that's my motion that we reserve the date July 29th and as the time approaches we determine whether or not we need that meeting I second that all right a motion by Mr Barnett second by Mr Dunford that the July 29th meeting be reserved as a potential meeting date but not calendared so now we need to not discuss the date

108but discuss the merits of not caling calendaring on that date that's the amendment discussion to that amendment can you repeat that can can the representative the debate here is not on the date we're not de we're not debating if that date is we've that that's the main motion is the date that we've chosen the amendment is that we not put it on the calendar but if if when we get closer it's obvious that we need to conduct a meeting for business sake that's the date that was reserved to hold a meeting but it's not on the calendar as a regular board meeting that we intend to give staff an entire month off from us question is there a timeline that we have to adhere to in letting the public know uh that we are now

109having a meeting I forget what that timeline is just have to 10 days give 10 days notice but where we haven't adopted this calendar yet we wouldn't even have to change it hasn't been noticed yet right but I mean when the time comes after we adopt this calendar and we decide because staff has come to us and said this is pressing then we need to give 10 days notice no there's not a 10day notice there are certain days notice for specific meetings but a a regular board meeting is 24 hours notice unless it qualifies for the Emergency um you are supposed to post your annual um schedule but that is not set in stone just so there are certain meetings that require 10 days this is not one of those so your memory is your

110thinking there is correct it's just not this isn't one of those okay thank you and I'm just thinking I'm might forget all I've learned about Robert's Rules and of order if I go a whole month without a board meeting she's requesting Madam president I will reach out to the board member who said that and we will have a refresher course in the middle of July point of order the last two comments didn't say Madam president oh no I'm about to motion myself to suspend that role um okay additional discussion to the motion or to the amendment okay all those in favor of the amendment that we earmark the 29th as a potential board meeting date but not schedule it as such at this time did that make sense please say I I and any opposed

111right that is a unanimous vote um so tell your staff oh yes I point of order we haven't voted on the actual or have we voted on the main motion has still pending it's true it's funny because the amendment kind of assumed that didn't it I'll get better at this don't worry so the main motion is that the 29th is the day that that takes that that action takes place so the 20 so the motion on the table then is that the 29th is the date that we would hold a potential meeting in July should the need arise is that fair okay more discussion all right all in favor say I I and any opposed all right the motion carries so tell your staff they get July off I have to be careful saying that

112don't I from us congratulations you can free month that that will let me say it this way tell your staff not to bring us any pending business in July and they'll have July off in your hands they can organize themselves to uh make the most of July thank you for that consideration that's very nice great job okay moving back to the rest of the calendar items let's just talk first of all about the actual calendar and then we can Circle back to the question of a retreat um are there other concerns that anyone is catching that I missed here okay do we know caucus dates yet yeah those are noted in the Box on the document on board docs I was just double-checking it I looked once before Thanksgiving recess is the 26 then we

113have a meeting on the 25th so it's not I mean people could be traveling that week is that a concern for anyone it is for you okay do we want to consider an adjustment to the November 25th meeting daral you have a proposal a possible propos proposal would be um a shift in December to December 2nd and December 16th but that's just I haven't had time to think through this but we you generally have one meeting in December if it's early December I don't think the 16th is too late we get out the 18th right or 19th but I'm good I'm I can make it work so if we move the November 25th meeting to December 2nd and then we have a meeting December 2nd and the next week on the 9th am I understanding

114that right proposing that we move the December 9th meeting to the 19th oh 16th sorry so move both the November to December 2nd the December 9th to December 16th to December that a motion what would your staff think of that I I defer to whatever the staff I I don't know that that makes too much difference we're able to if somebody can't be there we have someone who can cover so so no preference just leave no particular preference although um if you well avoiding the week of Thanksgiving is helpful but not crucial that is often a travel day right kids get it's often a travel day and then you take off I I would say that you as just for the board you'll get less attention to what's going on people will be less able

115to engage even the public I think it could be the night that we sneak all the things through that's my concern that's my concern is it's it's after school has recessed so it's technically during the recess cuz Tuesday is the recess that's when we let school out so but it's not personally it's not going to hurt me I just think of past meetings potential patrons who have brought that concern up and and some employees that have said something but this is just for me personally I don't care but in consideration to others I think it's a I think we could do better at finding a better time I don't know when it is maybe we can just leave it on now and give it some thought we could also shift I don't think we should

116throw out your idea we could also shift October has five board meetings we could shift November's both up a week I think if we have a brief board meeting on December 16th yeah because it's a busy time of year with a lot of events in and outside of the schools we know that the last board meeting of the year has a few things that will be happening right you'll do your but they're primarily between the business the between business administrator doing his budget and the superintendent doing a year-end report those really affect Su superintendent business administrator board and little staff I think this I think the December 6 16 is a better time to have a meeting than the week of Thanksgiving and December 2nd December 16th um and I know there's a motion on

117the table and there isn't there is I think we need to make a motion one thing that I would rather move the the November um 25th meeting to November 18th instead of having the two meetings in December and I know that that's two two weeks in a row where we have a meeting but I would rather have the two meetings so I move that we um move the uh December 25th the November 25th General board meeting to November 18th a second we have a motion by Miss Dean a second by Miss Wood to move the November 25th meeting to November 18th any discussion to that motion two in November two back to back in November I think is better than going so late into December I agree and then just to clarify we would keep

118the December 2nd meeting wait am I right no December 9th meeting correct okay all right hearing no discussion we'll move to a vote um all those in favor of the motion to move the November 25th meeting to November 20 or November 18th please say I I and any oppose say nay all right that carries can I make a friendly request um whoever makes those little icons that I can click a button and they put all the meetings in for me that would be super cool like to have that on our website so that it would save me from time and others to just click and boom all our meetings are in our calendar whoever does that they're they're like make a Google invitation oh what for of these that you would just accept I'll accept

119that for the board I can't speak for staff but I'll I'll do that for the board somebody did it for the a days and B days and I'll just tell you that that whoever that is they should get a bonus that Sav me so much time would a Google Calendar meet that need or are you talking something specific kind I usually do both they give me a Google option and an apple option but okay if they if that could be done that would be cool and then I could direct people too that they could add it to their calendar it's a really good idea and thanks Whoever has done it in the past okay all right I will give myself that assignment okay any other concerns that anyone is catching with the schedule okay then

120I will accept a motion to adopt the schedule outside of the two exceptions we made you want to talk about a summer session president um yeah that's a great Point let's do that first any proposals for an appropriate additional session I'm I'm leery now of saying the word Retreat I think we should call it a planning session that's really what it is the retreat really does send a message to the two patrons that were heading to Hawaii or something like that it's just a really poor word because it's not really a retreat it's a freaking long meeting it's nothing fun about it except sometimes they bring extra like snacks but we should just call our company's pretty fun we should well that's true that's true I should consider a retreat then but it's a strategic

121planning meeting technically in the spirit of what we decided with not making sta giving staff July off I wonder if we entertain the idea of not having a summer session Madam president that's what I was suggesting that this strategic planning meeting can be H handled any time of the year in fact it's probably better handled like in April or May when we're still kind of in the in the thought of everything instead of taking some time off and then trying to jump back into it um something that I don't want to Discount the value of um is often when we are in formal meetings we are under a lot of pressure to make important decisions and I think there is a lot of value to a board who has opportunities to meet in a less

122um stressful setting an opportunity to to talk about leadership relationship um things that help a board to be cohesive and I do think that that's an opportunity um frequently that seems to come up during conferences um but where we don't all attend the same conference often as a board right now it's a consideration to keep in mind as we consider whether this is a valuable meeting can I make a proposal can we do our strategic planning meeting on June 10th of 2025 that's a scheduled meeting already we've done in the past we've had um our strategic planning meeting with a board meeting at the same time this is a concern in in a way because it's a budget meeting probably also but it is after school is over two days after lengthen the meeting lengthen

123that meeting put the iic one in it we make sure we give proper attention to the budget meeting but I think it's a really good time we're just coming off of graduation I think it's a good time for a strategic meeting so you mentioned June 10th I'm seeing June 9th do is that what you're talking about the bu the date of the budget hearing okay I'm looking 26 or 2025 this is 2025 right oh you're talking about this upcoming June sorry I'm looking at the schedule sorry behind I'm looking at oh we can plan June 9th 2026 too I don't care it is a good time because we're still kind of in the in the thick of things but things are kind of over was that emotion go ahead second I Mo can I just

124motion it right I motioned that you don't necessarily need to unless she needs you in order to State the question but go ahead CU I want to do this I motion that the Jordan School board adopt uh June 10th 2025 as our our board strategic planning meeting for the next calendar year start date starting time to earlier in the day and adjust the starting time as needed second and I'll speak to that we can adjust the T the starting time to like and would you add we do the same thing in 20 and I think you need to add that we do the same thing in 2026 let's let's do them all in one motion let me good friendly I don't know if it's friendly good Amendment because it wasn't friendly I don't know but

125let's do that with with the idea that we can change 2026 if this doesn't work out but let's put it it on the calendar for 2026 also and then if if this idea really doesn't work in 2025 we can adjust okay because technically we're amending the calendar for that's currently up right yes have toing the calendar and approving a new one he correct me if I messed this up I was trying to take notes so we have a motion by uh I got to get to the misters Mr Robinson and representative number one oh please don't make me do that that's for our that the Jordan School District School Board adopt June 10th 2025 as a board strategic planning meeting for the 2025 calendar year and June 9th 2026 as a strategic planning meeting for

126the following calendar year you may want to add and and eliminate all summer sessions and eliminate Su the scheduled summer sessions all right and eliminate the scheduled summer sessions okay any discussion I'm confused about eliminate the summer sessions we printed on the schedule is that plan we need to take it off did we already approve one for this school year we have not approved to summer session date already okay thank you um okay what would we expect the start time to be on that proposed June 9th meeting PBA okay in the past we've done like noonish or something like that yeah but probably yeah I think that will probably evolve as we fill the agenda for what needs to be done can we put TBA on the time yeah I think so be determined so

127could we potentially have the strategic planning meeting before the budget hearing okay that's that's exactly what the proposal is yeah I mean you don't get to wear shorts and Hawaiian shirts but I'll bring a change of clothes all right other discussion okay let's move to a vote so all those in favor of the motion to adopt June 10th 2025 as a board strategic planning meeting for the 25 calendar year and June 9th 2026 um as the board strategic planning meeting for the 20126 calendar year and then eliminate a summer session please say I I and any oppos say nay all right that carries okay we're getting close to our business meeting um it's a very cleaned up calendar it is a very cleaned up calendar great work everyone uh so let's I would accept a

128motion to accept the the rest of the calendar as printed I move that we accept go ahead Jinx okay um I move that we accept the rest of the calendar as printed second all right we have a motion by Miss Dean second by Mr Barnett to accept the rest of the calendar as printed with the exceptions of those that we've passed tonight any discussion to that motion okay all in favor say I I and any oppos say that carries and that concludes this agenda item take a motion to have a little break until the business meeting do we need a motion can I just do that all right let's go ahead and take a break and we'll resume at 6:30 e for e for e for e for e for e for e for e

129for e for e for e for e for e for e for e let's go ahead and get started welcome to the Board of Education General Session meeting today is Tuesday January 28th and we are grateful for all of those who are in attendance uh we have our full board present as well as our legal council our superintendent associate superintendent and business administrator let's go ahead and get started with our Pledge of Allegiance um that that will be given to us by oh let me um Jillian gome oh by the students of Kelsey Peak virtual Middle School the flag ceremony will be presented by Julian Gomez Kyra McKay and Aaron almadovar Hernandez I apologize for my pronunciation and then the pledge the Pledge of Allegiance will be led by Logan hate student leader and tyac

130Colberg uh student ambassador um also from Kelsey Peak virtual Middle School please stand for the posting of the colors please join me for the pledge please join me for the pledge I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all may be seated the reverence will now be offered by Spencer Campbell the principal at Kelsey Peak virtual Middle School can I be irreverent for like 10 seconds before I do the reverence we have kids that are scattered across and staff and teachers scattered across the state of Utah watching live tonight and I just want to give them a shout out in Logan Provo Ogden St George everywhere so they're watching so hi everybody uh

131this will probably be familiar um the road not taken by Robert Frost two roads diverged in a yellow wood and sorry I could not travel both and be one traveler along I stood and looked down one as far as I could to where it bent in the undergrowth then took the other as just as fair and having perhaps the better claim because it was grassy and wanted wear though is before that passing there had warned them really about the same and both that morning equally lay in leaves no step had Trot in Black oh I kept the first for another day yet knowing how way leads to way I doubted if I should ever come back I shall be telling this with a sigh somewhere ages and ages hence two roads diverged in a wood

132and I I took the One Less Traveled by and that has made all the difference as a principal of Kelsey Peak for the past 5 years I've had the opportunity to watch hundreds and now thousands of kids come through not only Kelsey Peak but Kings Peak and Rocky peak and yes we know that we are the road that is less traveled by but for the staff and for the teachers and for all of the students that option and that road has made all the difference this opportunity for kids to take that road has changed lives it's helped kids fall in love with school again it's helped staffs rejuvenate and our teachers find a place that they can call home and so we are very very grateful and um thankful for the opportunity that the district

133continues to show with a new building to support what we are doing at JBL so thank you so much [Applause] thank you this really is a treat to have our Kelsey Peak Virtual Academy here with us um we will now celebrate the the school excuse me with a few student leaders um excuse me Lily larid Khloe Barker cenia gar Presley Barilla lockhead Logan hate Ivana palasio poo I apologize and brayon Woolly hello my name is Lily good evening members of the school board esteemed guest and fellow community members my name is Lily and I am a member of my school leadership we are truly honored to have the opportunity to celebrate the remarkable journey of Kelsey Peak virtual Middle School over the past 5 years when our school embarked on this adventure many years ago

134our principal and teachers knew they were pioneering a new kind of educational experience a virtual community that feels as connected and vibrant as any Traditional School their commitment to build a strong virtual community where every student feels seen and known has been at the heart of our school's mission hi I'm Chloe I am a seventh grade leader through monthly field trips and inperson activities every Friday our learning experiences have been enriched these opportunities allow us to deepen our understanding through Hands-On activities that complement our online learning additionally as members of the National Junior Honor Society and student ambassadors we have created safe engaging online experiences where students can socialize and build lasting friendships these groups Empower us to learn vital interpersonal skills and develop leadership qualities hello my name is Julian I am a student

135at Kelsey Peak our teachers are the backbone of our success they have tirelessly adapted to new teaching methods to enhance our understanding in an online setting they work hard to make sure that we get to experience the same thing as students who intend inperson school from holding competitions like we the people to clothing and food drives to working to connect us to opportunities in theater and music and even hosting art events their dedication ensures that each of us feels supported seen on our academic Journey my name is C and I an eighth grade leader many of us at Kelsey Peak juggle various commitments outside of school from Ballet West to various sports teams to training for the Olympics this school empowers us to pursue our Dreams by offering learning in a unique and flexible way

136allowing us to balance our passions with our education our school is also a safe harbor for some of our classmates that are struggling with health concerns our teachers work to help build back student self-confidence not only in themselves but in schools creating an environment students students can find footing they need to make progress in the right direction uh good evening my name is Bryson woolly I am a 8ighth grade student leader uh as Pathfinders we work at our own pace to finding our paths to reach our Peak potential we work closely with our parents and teachers to to foster a community where we can self- Advocate and develop skills essential for futurex good evening I'm Logan n ghs secretary we we are especially grateful for the school board's approval of our new facility which will

137serve as our home base starting next year this building will significantly enhance our ability to connect with our community and expand our Hands-On programs and activities we are proud to call ourselves Kelsey Peak Pathfinders we are grateful for the opportunity to share our story and excited for the bright future ahead thank you for your continued support wow it's really a highlight for the board to be able to hear all of the great things that are happening at your school we appreciate you being here I would love to invite anyone who is here with Peak to stand up and be recognized parents administrators teachers and especially students please stand up and let us give you a round of applause what an amazing group thank you and we would love to invite the students if you will

138come and start at that end and work your way up with we would love to shake your hand and give you a pin of gratitude [Laughter] thanks for coming I'm sorry I killed your name thanks for coming tonight thanks for coming great job you guys that was so fun great job and your neckl darling everybody get a p you get a please grab a pen good job thanks for coming tonight grab a pen thanks for coming thank you grab a pen thank you oh give her a gifts thank you don't miss your pen these are awesome thank you so much I love the socks Kelsey Peak thank you again for being with us enjoy your night safe travels home you're of course always welcome to stay nobody ever takes me up on that offer all

139right well now turn the time to Lisa Dean for our resolutions of appreciation whereas dedicated service to Jordan School District was faithfully and effectively performed whereas they consist conly and conscientiously executed their responsibilities with Integrity honesty and loyalty be it therefore resolved that the Jordan School District Board of Education and District administration declare appreciation for the outstanding service that was performed in the cause of public education and hereby express our sorrow at the death of these valued friends Diane Hansen blay teacher silver Mesa Westville Midas Creek Elementary Schools Betty Davis teacher West Jordan Middle High School and Copper Hills High School Tim McConnell administrator rid View Elementary School thank you we'll now move into the board member recognition portion and if it's okay I'm going to go first I have invited some friends from Copper

140Hills to be here with us tonight um and I would like like to invite you guys to come and kind of gather up in the front um we have members of HOSA here who have really started an outstanding Tradition at Copper Hills of Smashing records for blood donations and this is a program that's organized by this group of students this year they broke a record a national record for the amount of blood donated at a single location Drive so um I would love to welcome I'll I'll just call your names out you can give us a wave um we have their advisor Maddie Jenkins is she oh she's taking pictures um and adviser Eva Peterson president Bryson Hills and our vice president Sarah nulan secretary Ashley cheni Communications [Music] Beni sorry um Communications Maria Silva

141Navaro blood drive leaon me Miner blood drive assistant Eliza Bruner senior rip Cameron Winger Junior rep Jacob Zamora and sophomore rep Eva wck we want to give you a moment to tell us about what you do but first will you join me in a round of applause all right everybody got their photo moments so now we're going to invite Bryson over to the podium you can face us hey did you is the green light on on that mic if you push the button it should oh now it is my bad sorry guys um on behalf of the Copper Hills High School HOSA Council I would like to thank the Jordan School District board for inviting us for the opportunity to be here tonight this recognition is not just a testament to our efforts but a

142celebration of the incredible spirit and dedication of our students faculty and Community it is a staggering reality that every 2 seconds someone in the United States requires a blood transfusion and one in seven patients entering a hospital will need one the this underscores the vital need for the sufficient blood supply to ensure timely care for those who rely on these life-saving products every year HOSA council members organize and recruit their peers to donate blood last year our HOSA Club organized four blood drives collecting an impressive 645 units of blood I'm thrilled to share that Copper Hills holds the record as the largest blood drive in Utah increasing donations by a remarkable 153% since 2021 this directly benefited approximately 4,257 patients at the Huntsman Cancer Institute and the University of Utah hospital this year we have

143collected 332 donations and are on track to be our own record once again this incredible achievement was only possible because of the tireless efforts and compassion of our students staff and community members let's continue to Aspire others to join us in the life-saving mission together we can achieve even greater milestones and provide hope to those in need thank you again for this honor and recognition I love the spirit of community that is being developed at Copper Hills High School so thank you for what you've done for uh to contribute to that feeling we would love to shake your hands as well and give you a little pin um so if you'll start at that end make your way down the line we'd love to shake your hand break the record again okay grab your P

144your you guys are amazing you want a pen thanks foron you guys look so good congratulations thanks for coming tonight we love having our students join our meetings and you are welcome to stay for as long as you would like but we will not be offended if you need to excuse yourselves thank you so much for coming Mr fernworth I didn't even thank you thanks for being here he's one of the administrators at Copper Hills and amazing all right other recognitions that board members have tonight um I do um on Thursday I was up at the capital and I was so pleased to meet two Elkridge Middle School students in the Rotunda um which was filled with finalists of the Utah National History Day um competition and they had gone to Washington DC in June

145with other finalists and um oh and their names are um raki sures and a aasa and their project included making a website on Walt Disney's influence on animation and I love to see Jordan School District students in the wild um representing really well and and they were and then I also wanted to um give a shout out to the um Jordan ethnic um oh gak I suddenly advisory Comm the Jordan ethnic advisory committee for an outstanding conference their annual what I wish you knew conference was um just this month and they did a fantastic job I want to give a shout out to um the people who organized it and the breakouts the one I went to was really fun it was line dancing um presented by Lil loveridge and Michelle love day and it

146was really really really great and then one last thing is I just wanted to give a shout out to West Jordan High School um the high school hosted the Region 4 drill competition and I was lucky enough to attend and watch all the schools compete and I feel like West Jordan represented Jordan very well as it is the only Jordan School District school in that region so anyway thanks sure I would like to recognize the administrators and instructors right here at JC South I came to the open house and was very impressed with the students Eleanor oriented me and without exception the students that I spoke to said that it was their favorite year of school and that they really appreciate the expertise of their teachers so thank you to them I would like to

147Echo uh what Miss Dean said about the gak conference as well as cultural Services um putting on that really wonderful event I was able to go and I just really appreciated um our district recognizing our teachers and administrators who are creating safe spaces for our students um it was really wonderful event and I got to go to the breakout session um that was about the country and culture of India uh taught by Amy and that was really wonderful so I I got to attend the Chinese New Year celebration put on by our Chinese D program it was phenomenal I my kids all fight to be able to come with me to this event now because they know what a great job it is um it was surprisingly well attended there was so much activity and

148buzzz it was like the Hunger Games parking which I think really speaks highly of of the efforts that went into that so thank you for that um and then just a an additional shout out for those region competitions that have been happening it is so fun to be on the Jordan School board at a 6A competition because you basically can't lose you're you're cheering for everyone and they did such a great job um so that was really fun to be able to watch roll out any others okay great let's move to our um sorry our superintendent's recognition thank you it was nice it was nice having HOSA a CTE uh club and a competitive group here to talk about the blood drive in that same vein I would like to have uh CTE director Jason

149Skidmore come up and give us a preview of what will be a two-part superintendent's recognition because he's going to preview CTE month and then he'll be back to celebrate CTE month next month so thank you uh Mr Skidmore well President George and members of the Board of Education and superintendent Godfrey um I love being here I love seeing you and I love spending time with you and as superintendent has invited me to be here tonight um during the month of February there is a a national campaign where we recognize CTE Educators CTE programs and all the Great accomplishments that that happen in the state of Utah this the theme for this year is education elevated but here in Jordan School District we know that we celebrate CTE every single day um with your support with

150the support of our District administration our school administrators and our community CTE is alive and well and our programs and our students have so many great opportunities but during the month of February we like to take a special pause and um and maybe extra celebrate them a little bit more I can say that every one of the Educators that we have works hard every single day and I've challenged them this month of February to invite you into their spaces into their classrooms into their schools and so I kind of give you and put you on notice that you will receive invitations to learn about CTE to learn about programs that you may not even know exist or about the unique things that students get to do while they're a student here in Jordan School District

151they have more opportunities than I think any of us ever had as we experienced our high school education each week there will be a series of activities and events that focus on various as aspects of CTE like tonight we I want to also congratulate Copper Hills HOSA for the great work that they do um that leadership organization is one of eight and during one of the weeks there'll be more celebrations of all the different leadership organizations that students can participate in we'll focus on our Partnerships with industry our community members and especially focus on our students and the things that and the successes that they've had and we'll also highlight throughout the month various Educators and we will invite you to be a part of that if you would ever like to learn more about

152any aspect of CTE I extend an invitation to contact myself from my office we'll arrange a tour we'll go with you to a school we'll start at the middle school and and talk about what seventh graders and opportunities that they get about where the CTE experience begins and how it culminates at one of the various Pathways that are offered at either our high schools or at one of our JATC campuses I um I I can't thank you enough for the support that you give to our students and to our teachers and we hope that we can continue to provide great opportunities tonight I'm going to ask um Julie Scherzinger who my CTE consultant who's here with me tonight um we're going to give you a little bit of we're going to arm you with a

153badge of of knowledge I guess we should say um with knowledge comes great power um during the month of February we'll have a few campaigns going on you'll receive a button that says ask me more about CTE um I'm also giving you a little bit of a cheat sheet you'll have 10 items so if you don't know any anything you'll at least have 10 items tonight that you can walk away with um you'll notice on the back of that there's a the answer so question and answer there for you but we would encourage you during the month of February to wear that button proudly to to share the CT experience um all of you have taken the opportunity to explore and get to know um the things that our Career and Technical Educators do and

154so we'd encourage you to learn a little bit more and to learn about some of the new things that are happening so with that I I thank you superintendent thank you for giving us this opportunity tonight and like he said we'll come back in February with greater detail more stories and uh celebrate the great things that our teachers are doing so I I do want to say to our teachers and to our staff that um we wouldn't have what we have today without their hard work and what they do every day and these students that you saw tonight as they stood here are are one of um many Products that come out of Jordan School District so thank you thank you superintendent thank you uh what Mr Skidmore said is absolutely true we have tremendous

155students and teachers uh in our CTE uh Mr Skidmore is the best director around um there's nobody better and his vision and the board's support have allowed us to expand to have nearly every CTE pathway available and um we were talking about it my supercast the podcast has over 30 episodes about CTE so um one of them being about the Copper Hills HOSA Group which is a uh a group to really brag about so we we really have been able to draw a lot of wonderful teachers from industry and elsewhere to to come and create these Unforgettable experiences for for our students and it's going to be exciting to celebrate that in February and to have you back at the end of the month to talk about what's happened so do thank you so much

156have a good evening thank [Applause] you very excited to be able to celebrate CTE month who knew um we at my house I finally had a child who's old enough to apply for JATC programs and it has been weeks of which one to choose because there are so many great choices so thank you for that all right let's go ahead and move into our general business I'll accept a motion to accept the consent agenda items oh did I oh my goodness I skipped the most important part of the meeting thank you I need a a better system up here we're excited to move into public comment at this time um and just a few reminders as we roll into that portion of the meeting the Board of Education encourages public engagement we value the input

157from our residents students and employees um so a few reminders as you give comment the board will not take public comment on Personnel issues or statements regarding the character professional competence or physical or mental health of an individual during board meetings um if you have concerns to that end please feel free to email them to board members uh we ask that comments be kept age appropriate the board does not discuss issues that are not on the meeting's agenda uh the board may ask staff to follow up on issues raised or or may address them at a future meeting and remember that Silence by the board on an issue does not suggest support or opposition to the message that was given uh the board will take public comment at this time on items not listed on

158the agenda inperson comments will be heard first followed by comments received electronically both in-person and emailed comments can last a maximum of 3 minutes please be respectful of that time and when you're called to the podium please please take a minute to state your name we have a few signed up today so uh first we will have Amy Ledo and she will be followed by Wendy Barrett so Amy come on up hi um I'm Amy lllo um I'm a speech language pathologist at Jordan District um so I work here I also live in Jordan I've liked it I've worked for Jordan since 2013 um I'm here to advocate for um an increase in pay for speech language Pathologists in our district um the way I'm proposing you consider that is that we are allowed access

159to the shine funds formally the tssp funds that got opened up last legislative session um to be on a district byd district level um also um Davis School District does Masters plus 30 automatically for speech langues pathologist because our master's degree is very intense and rigorous and has additional credits um beyond what a typical master's degree has um and lastly I'd like you to consider um letting us get money for being nationally certified when we are nationally certified through Asha our certification program um that's what districts like Canyons does that that they offer uslp some sort of ification money for that um I think that's all for right now thank you thank you all right Wendy Barrett hello I'm also a speech language pathologist in the district and I want to Echo everything Amy just

160said um we're our goal is we're trying to be competitive with other school districts and other workplaces that speech language Pathologists can work at as well as other states where they can go um so that we can recruit and retain the best speech language Pathologists in our district um and one other option um I work at a secondary level and the teachers at secondary level have the option to sell their prep and take on another class and So currently there's a lot of slps that are covering taking on extra case loads either at other schools or covering what another SLP would cover at their school if they need to um so we were I'd like to propose that we consider offering slps some option similar to selling their prep when they take on larger case

161loads in order to help them feel like they are getting compensated for doing that extra work rather than burning out um and just to make a note that um speech language Pathologists are a little misunderstood not misunderstood but unknown as far as what we do um we are involved in every single special ed team and we not only work on kids with speech impediments but we work with kids with developmental language disorders stuttering autism no autism student can be classified as autistic in our district without speech language pathology input so we are heavily involved in all of those evaluations and IEPs and intellectual disabilities um we're involved with most of those students as well so um just knowing that we're more than just working on those R sounds or the stuttering um and that we've

162every year that I've been here since 2017 I hear a desperate call for new slps every year and I'd like to be able to help our district retain and keep those so we can keep those students with really qualified and experienced speech language Pathologists so thank you thank you all right that concludes those who have signed up to speak in person but I understand we do have an emailed comment turn it to Mr Larson Susie kzay I hope I pronounced that right dear members of the school board and Community as a former speech language pathologist uh SLP of Jordan School District and a member of the West Jordan Community I implore you to learn more about the SLP servicing students in jsd being able to comprehend language and express it to others as foundational to

163academic learning and social emotional well-being if slps have high case loads impossible workloads frequent staff turnover and the district is scrambling to fill open positions how does this impact our students ability to access their curriculum how can we solve these issues get curious slps in our district have put together a proposal that would help incentivize this area of need that could reduce reduce turnover and attract and retain talented slps that this district is losing mannually Susie KZ thank you all right anyone else missed the opportunity to sign up that wanted to okay that will conclude our public comment section we'll now move into agenda item four General business a motion to accept or to approve consent agenda items I move that we approve consent agenda items a through c i second thank you so we

164have a motion by Miss Dean a second by Miss Barrow to approve the consent agenda items a through C any discussion all right seeing none all in favor please say I I any opposed say nay all right that passes unanimously moving on to agenda item five general business a motion to accept consent agenda I move that we accept consent agenda items a through e i second right we have a motion by Miss Dean a second by Miss Barrow to accept consent agenda items a through e any discussion there okay seeing none all in favor say I I I and any opposed right that passes unanimously moving into agenda item six bids I'll move that we approve the Riverton High School HP Chromebooks and license bid I second right a motion by Mr Barnett second by

165Miss Dean to approve the Riverton High School HP Chromebooks and licenses bid discussion there all right all in favor say I I and any oppose right that passes unanimously I move that we accept the bid for information systems e- rate network switch upgrade I'll second right we have a motion by Miss Dean second by Mr Barnett to approve Information Systems e rate network switch upgrade any discussion to that motion I'd like a an explanation on the reimbursement why that happened and how how that works hi I'm Anthony mwo I'm network manager here at georan school district so the reimbursement is it's a the eate program is a federal program that is run um by the federal government and we apply when we have big projects like this we apply to have reimbursement done on we're

166eligible for 50% of the cost that we will get back so we can use for additional projects later on uh IT projects um you have to you apply for it then you send out RFP for for bids you select a bid that you want then you have to submit that information back to the eate program or to the federal government and then they will send you back an approval and then once you get that approval then you send it uh your purchase request in and get it purchased and then once you get it purchased you have to submit your your tracking and your packing list that you get to prove that you got the equipment and then you have a certain amount of time to get the equipment installed and then once it's installed then

167you submit for reimbursement okay and um I noticed there was only one bidder on this one was do can you explain why or what your opinion is as to why there was only one so uh the the bidder that was accepted um was the only one that basically bid what we were asking for um um the the other bids did not meet the requirements uh they although they were similar they are um they are basically Alternatives um that would require additional training and Engineering to get to work in our current environment we are an HP shop and all of our we've already done all of our training and our engineering with with the current staff that we have and it just makes sense to go that Direction with the vendor that is actually bidding what

168we asked for and then what's the what's the scope I think it said districtwide is that is so all the schools all the buildings are going to be touched by this so This it so we have over 2,000 Network switches throughout the entire District this is just a handful that are done so um we basically do them in phases so because it's just to try to do the entire District in a single year is just unrealistic we can't touch every building with and replace that many switches in a single year so we have to do it in stages and this will probably be over two maybe three years okay so as equipment expires so our last project where we did a similar thing uh it we did it over 3 years and so we have

169equipment that is expiring now and we're working on on that equipment that is going end of life and end of support and we're upgrading to newer equipment that has updated features updated security features things like that and as and as we replace those then we'll go to the next phase and replace the next set as they expire and go end of life is the I guess my question is does the bid does the equipment that that we're going to receive from this bid cover those three years or or is it just that first year or this is just that first year we're going to get a similar bid next year and a similar bid the following year yes if we can't get it if we can't get it done next year then there will be

170a third year yes and is this just for the equipment and we install it yes okay yeah cuz yeah I mean it seemed like a lot of money for some switches that's why I was wondering how what the scope was they're expensive so the this is 900 switches of you know just over 2,000 so um yeah I mean it'll it'll do a good portion of the district but it it won't be able to get all it can I ask how long the equipment usually lasts what's the lifespan equipment um um equipment will usually last we try to that will usually start going end of sale end of um support after five to six years sometimes you can get a little bit more out of it but the longer you go you end up getting more

171failures and having to replace and replace it sooner anyway so thank you you're welcome any more questions any other questions all right thank you so much thank you we appreciate the information all right any other discussion okay all in favor of accepting the uh the motion for information systems or the bid for information systems erate network switch upgrade please say I I and any opposed all right that motion passes unanimously seeing no special business items we will move to agenda item eight um the superintendent report I would just like to thank everyone who has worked on health and wellness day we start talking about health and wellness day the day after it ends we start planning for the next year the board has been uh an essential support to that effort e since the first

172time we did it and this is year four and that's really exciting so thank you to the board for supporting this you received the email today announcing that and uh we have a committee that connects with the community and provides additional opportunities and there are more opportunities for employees than ever before some really great variety and we've moved to Mountain Ridge as the central hub for activities partially because we just couldn't be contained within ASB it wasn't enough space um so uh really it's been a tremendous effort on the part of employees and I also want to mention that the lesson plans for parents have been sent out today as well and that is an essential component also of Health and Wellness day that there is age there's an age specific set of lessons plans

173for every grade level for families to engage around health and wellness so this is a focus on families connecting to health and wellness as well as our employees and it's a it's one one example of Jordan School District's dedication to putting parents and the family at the center of education and uh I'm really thrilled with that curriculum that allows families to explore things together that will help help boost health and wellness every year I hear positives about that as well as the posit positives that we hear about the employee experiences so lots of people have come together and the community support is tremendous the people who want to help and want to be part of this it's it's very inspiring how the community comes together to support the employees and families of Jordan School District

174so I I appreciate your leadership and support as a board in helping uh this continue so it's exciting take a look at that email you're all eligible for all the activities um sign up fast though you don't get Early Access neither do I you got to watch for that uh moment when you get to sign up some of that goes fast so um anyway thank you to everyone who's made this possible very excited to see that roll forth and I just want to say that in addition to the options in increasing every year I think the video is getting more entertaining every year and also I one day we were in the Drive-Thru at Swig and my daughter was vacillating between her choices and I said you know Dr Godfrey would recommend the Endless Summer

175it's now become a family favorite so thanks for the recommendation fantastic all right let's move into committee reports and comments by board members I do have one item I am unable to attend the nsba conference at the 1 of April and would like to request an alternate conference from I I believe I need board approval for that tell us about your conference Choice it's not finalized yet however um one of my areas of interest is special education and there is an lrp conference that came recommended by some of our previous special Educators some are also attending in our district it's in Phoenix at the end of April I would like to attend this conference also all right board members have any questions about that concerns oh and I should say in instead of the nsba

176conference all right my blessing sounds like you are good to make those arrangements we're excited to hear you report back on all the good stuff you learn I'm a little jealous of this one thank you all right other committee reports I have a report I have some good news I have posted on board docs the new um alignment in uh Activities Association um 25 to 27 the good news is the 56a schools in our region in our district stay in region two um we lose copper or Corner Canyon and we pick up Cedar Valley and West Lake but there is um some concern that you need to be aware of with this recent alignment realignment we are now down to schools in the state of Utah that makes it very hard to compete we have

177five up north we have region two consists of the Salt Lake Valley and we're pulling in our you know our five schools plus two in Eagle Mountain that leaves the leh high schools kind of alone so we've got five up north seven in the middle and five down south and that's kind of creating some challenges as you know Region 2 has the most opportunity to play schools from region one and Region 3 and yet what we really need is region one and three to play each other and that's not happening um I looking forward I we this board has a dilemma it seems to me that in the future it's going to be best for the Utah Activities Association to go back down to five classifications and not six we just don't have the growth

178at the 6A level to maintain significant competition at the 6A level but that means we're eliminating our seat on the Board of Trustees I am the I I am the representative for 6A and so I just want to make you aware of that that two years from now as we realign if this board takes the position that we're going to recommend eliminating 6A and moving all those schools down to 5A and having five classifications we will eliminate our voice so just be aware of that some challenges that we are facing with growth issues and the lack of 6A schools in the state of Utah question why would we not have a voice on 5A there is another VI 5A rep we we technically don't have a 6A voice that's elected right so I have yeah

179as long as it's well we have an advantage because we have five schools it's you it's voted upon by the 6A schools so 17 schools up north there are five 6A schools one from a different division a different District than the other so there is no District except for the old Le or Alpine District that has more than five votes and given the split in Alpine I don't know if they would vote as a group so it's likely that this board will maintain the five the 6A seat because we have five voting schools and no other District would have five voting schools but if we push to eliminate 6A because that's really where we're going in terms of fairness of competition we would no longer be the six there would be no 6A rep On

180The Board of Trustees right now Canyons is the one that provides the 5A rep so change it's it no well no it's not it it hasn't it isn't changing but their rep is changing but their seat on the board is not new I have another question um who determines the size of the school in the six day is that determined by themselves or is that a national determination I can't see anything I just researched I couldn't see anything but couldn't they just reclassify how large 6A schools are of course seems to me that might be a smart of course now the reality is here's the challenge there are some very legitimate 6A schools that have the size the talent the bulk the the you know they really do fill a 6A football for example roster

181now if I'm a bubble school what are the chances I want to play that school I'm going to injure we're going to injure our players if we filled you know if we play football to that in that so those are the challenges is you even if you change the classification you've still got a discrepancy in some very very large schools and some that really don't wouldn't qualify to be in the same league so it gets really complicated it's not just a matter of enrollment uh we've got two brand new 6A schools that clearly don't have things rolling they don't have the Legacy they don't have to the tradition um and yet they're going to be competing against long-standing 6A schools so can I make one more recommendation sure it seems like one of the things

182that causes more frustration anxiety is redistricting regions as frequently and they do it every two years they as soon as they're done with one they start working on the next one and it seems to me before you lose your seat that you could also Advocate that to do this less frequently like every four years schools change but not every two years and it seems to me that they're causing a lot of problems in the state that doesn't need to happen as often if if that could be something that we could advocate for they of course need to change but I think every two years is a little Overkill that's a good feedback what you have on board docs is the previous alignment and the future alignment so you may be interested in watching which schools

183moved from 6A to 5A which schools you know there was a point there was a time when East High School was competing in football at the 6A level they're now down in the 4A level so things changed fairly quickly Fremont has now moved to the 5A um we've just we've lost significant there's every time we realigned there's fewer and fewer 6A schools so just be aware that that is a situation that we as a board are going to need to address within the next couple of years I intend to rerun for the seat um and that that election should occur before any other realignment that's my report that in two years it's next year seat comes up it's next year I have there's 18 months left the election is in about a year oh gotcha

184okay thank you other committee reports I have a few all right um my probably last government relations report uh I've heard back from a few of you regarding the lunch with legislators on the hill um the 13th of February seems to be the more popular of the dates that I presented at the last meeting um so we will go ahead and schedule for the 13th will you please check your calendars and let us know if you are able to attend um and we will make sure that we have an appropriate number of lunches ordered uh then moving on to usba this week usba held a rally during their day on the hill um and that kicked off with a um flag ceremony and of course rally we were able to be joined by Senate and

185House leadership which was really nice and the push paaw initiative was the topic so so the push paaw initiative is a movement to encourage legislators to reduce the number of education related bills that are passed um I think there was a very positive feeling in the room as we discussed um we there were a variety of speakers from the teachers of the year for the state of Utah to um principal of the year and some of our usba uh leadership and that is the message that they're asking that we're grateful for the support we want the collaboration with the state but that it can be distracting from our purpose of educating when we are juggling a lot of implement implementation of new bills and so that was the message there um thank you to those

186who were able to make appearances during the day I think it was a worthwhile day um then just a reminder that February 27th is going to be the SBO day on the hill um board members are invited to attend that as well it's always fun to have our um our students there and we have reminded them how imperative their voices are and encourage them to take opportunities to start conversations with their legislators um if you're interested in attending and would like to ride the bus and not deal with parking which I recommend because it's still kind of a disaster to park up there um be at South Valley is it 9:00 I don't know if I got the right time and is it the 27th you said that's what I wrote did I say it

187wrong it's possible it's the 27th and bus would leave by 9: so you want to be there maybe just a little before that thank you be there a little early if you want to board the bus um right now I know of two that are attending that event just let us know so we can plan for you if you're coming all right a couple of other things uh just a quick reminder that the donor appreciation lenson for the Jordan Education Foundation is coming up this week on Thursday at 11:30 that will be held here um if you are able to attend make sure you RSVP we've gotten a couple of emails about that it's always a really nice afternoon to be able to see the incredible work that's happening among our foundation um and then

188one more that I wanted to bring your attention to is um as we attended the Utah School boards Association conference in January when of the sessions um gives an opportunity for us to learn from other boards and an idea was brought to our board through that event um Suzanne attended and they in in another District they use a sheet to be able to request agenda items and so each of you have a sheet that um I shared with you in your email um this is something that I wanted everyone to take a look at as um a consideration so basically if you have a request for a future agenda item you would be able to list that here um we are asking people to try to focus our attention around our strategic goals so there's

189a place where you can indicate what area of the Strategic goal your agenda item would fall into and then your reason for why you want that um if you have support of other board members you are welcome to list it in the next column over or if you happen to be on the document and you're like oh great idea I would love to hear about that as well feel free to add your name to anyone's suggested items um and then the urgency line is important as well so some of these things are things you'd like to see but they're not urgent or if you feel like there's something really pressing this is just an opportunity for us to Corral ideas and also to make sure that everybody feels like they have a really clear voice

190on the agenda creation so curious what your feedback is on that if that's something that we would like to adopt as a board it's less formal than you think don't worry about checking every box Crossing every T just get the idea to the executive committee and I think I think that's good the idea is that it takes three board members to get an agenda on item on the agenda so if you plus any two of the executive committee it's on um a recommendation would be that if you've got something on there maybe give us a call talk us through it so we can advocate for it in our meetings but don't panic if you don't cross every te it's not as formal as you may think it is it just we want we want to

191extend an opportunity for every board member to be able to feel like I'd like to get that on the agenda I'd like to have a discussion on that and of course if you're not comfortable using it feel free to call us we can throw that on anytime um so if it this is something that you're interested Ed in trying out as a board I would just recommend bookmarking this page so you can find it really easily and um feel free to follow up with any member of the executive committee uh and a quick correction you were right Miss Dean I said the wrong date so it's really February 20th SBO day on the hill it's funny because I was like it's funny that it's 27th and 27th but apparent it wasn't I was just simplifying

192in my mind so one can I mention one thing on the the spreadsheet I'll I'll kind of be the owner of it as it's the second vice president's responsibility to keep track of these items um so I'll occasionally go in here if I have questions I might reach out to the author or the proposer to get some clarification and it it might be it might be wise also even though there's not a a space for it on the spreadsheet it might be wise to have in mind a motion that you want to make in board meeting related to the the agenda item yeah that's a good idea maybe we should add a column for that a proposed motion think so that way you're not necessarily proposing a topic you're proposing what direction within that topic

193are you really proposing I can add that I can add a another column for the proposed motion and can we add multiple strategic plan goals because some of these might have two or three which would be important to consider I okay it's a good currently the way it's set up it will only allow one but I think in the reasoning you could add as many as you wanted with that work I was just thinking adding two or three more columns oh that's a good idea we could do that too great feedback all right we'll give it a whirl and check back later see how everybody feels about that okay I think those were all of mine did I miss anyone um facilities committee we haven't met yet as a new Committee in fact we haven't

194even been officially notified yet have we but I I plan on reaching out to Scott Thomas and uh I want to sit down with him individually first of all and then I'll have uh some guidance for that committee great I'm excited for the coming committees all right um with that I'll accept a motion to adjourn oh to need I don't have to motion we are going to we'll go ahead and adjourn this meeting and move back into our study session after a short break e for e for e for e e for welcome back to the study session for the Jordan of Education it is still Tuesday January 28th and we still have all board members present we're going to continue our um study session was that not working at this time with agenda item

195F uh board committee assignment review so attached to board docs is um a document that has all of of the committee assignments and those that we are requesting fill those assignments so please feel free to go ahead and open that and be looking over it um one thing that I wanted to bring up at this time though is uh the potential creation of a policy committee so according to GP 105 our board is responsible for a yearly review of policy that follows a calendar created by the second vice president and the president of the board um and that is something that we always seem to start strong on and as things speed up and get busy it tends to to slow down a bit and so I am proposing the creation of a policy committee

196that can help us to stay on track with this so here's how it would work in my mind open to your feedback but board polic policies would be reviewed by the proposed policy committee and then the other policies would be reviewed by staff so there's a little bit less on that um scope of what they'll be looking at and then both groups would be able to bring back their recommendations after a review so on our agendas they could come back and say we took a minute to review this policy we notice this and are recommending that so they're not responsible for um for the decisions of policy of course that's always going to come to the full board as with all of our companies but it's an opportunity for us to do a better job

197of maintaining our policies and I think some other documents so I'll give you an example uh I was recently contacted by the president of another board who was interested in an item that we had in our appendix and it was an item that we have not used for in the memory of anyone in this room and so um just an an example of some of the maintenance that is going undone that we can um hopefully clean up and be a little more efficient as a board um and then I just want to point out that this committee will not necessarily just automatically be responsible for new policy creation as those needs arise as with all of our committees as a board will make committee assignments and if we feel that it's appropriate it could be

198assigned to them or we always have the opportunity to create ad hoc committees if it's going to be a really heavy lift so um any questions on that can I clarify anything please um so you said that staff would review some policy as well administrative policies okay how would you how do you envision us going over the policies you want us to start at the beginning do you want us to just be looking at things how do you see us doing this so you would be supplied with a schedule for the year and then you would just as a group look over it see if anything stands out to you anything that's outdated um on all of our policies have a review date and adoption date at the top and so this is just an

199opportunity for us to make sure that we're catching some of the things that are that have changed over time already tonight Mr dford has found one that we need to tackle so other questions I would like to ask that our policy committee also take a look at the board directive paragraph of the administrative uh policies everything else I'm I love that staff will take a look at but over the years I've noticed numerous discrepancies in the board directive and uh in congruities and so I think that's something that we would like to take a look at as well as a committee I really like that idea i' love them to be consistent across the board Mr vanan um I I would suggest also A1 the forward just to bring that up to speak yeah taking

200I don't know that we need to make a motion to put the policy Committee in place but um is there anyone who's uncomfortable with that okay great all right um I'm happy to read all of the committee assignments out loud if anyone would like is that necessary for anyone any concerns we can I think it needs to for the record public record they don't have access yeah happy to do that let me open it up and I I have a question I think it's been explained before for um but for the Utah School Board Association the region 9 District delegate that's different than the region n delegate right or the delegate are there two so there's the at large delegate and then there's a delegate I am so happy that you're bringing this up yes

201there's we have an atlarge and a delegate position so we get two votes at the delegate assembly assembly um and at usba we talked about it but I don't maybe somebody else has a better memory than me I don't know if we formalized that um I actually have a conflict that has come up for me on that day so I'm glad you mentioned it because I'm wondering if anybody else can serve in that position that day it is June 9th isn't there an alternate list there are I mean those were alternates that I just threw out from the people who were talking at the table but I don't I don't know that we chose any yeah I don't believe we chose any so on that one I am happy to change it it's it's the

2026th June 6th is the pre delegate assembly they do like a dinner and have a speaker usually like from the state level come and then the seventh is when you actually do the voting so is anyone available and willing darl I'm so I mean Mr Robinson I'm so sorry if I misremembered we didn't have a form to fill out that dat and so it was kind of a casual conversation and I was like who was talking I don't remember hard that's a hard day for anyone because that's like graduation day hangover it's true I I don't know my is so is which day is graduation Saturday is that Saturday no it's not the day of he's saying it was like a hangover from it just winding but I go to the all night activities with

203the youth that night and so sixth I usually move into Rumple still skin but I can work it out if no one else wants to do it it is the funnest meeting I think of the year are you voting at that meeting or it's just the preliminaries up to the vote that was stic and it is it's just voting on the legislative priorities for the following session so jlc comes together writes out what their priorities are and then this is usually done in August why are we doing it in June they moved it to June after well last year I think was the first year of doing it after receiving feedback that it was too late that bills were already being written and we were coming to the table too late and at the request

204of the legislature we moved it earlier and now I was just talking to Lexi Cunningham on Friday and she was saying that what's happened is other associations and groups groups have started just adopting our priorities as their own because ours are leading out which is nice to have more of a fine-tuned message we know that our legislators get priorities and requests all over the place and so that has been one good outcome of the decision they made to move it up but you're right it is earlier okay so I'm hearing Daryl as a maybe he can I apologize I should have had my calendar out when we were chatting what was the time frame on that meeting did you say it usually starts I'm giving you very general because I don't know the specifics but

205it usually starts with breakfast like I think it was like s or 8 or 9 wasn't it the Friday meeting is 6 oh in the evening on Friday and I will give it as boring as the eting is the dinner is probably worth it the dinner is really good you get dinner and not necessarily for people who don't eat meat though oh yeah you got to eat meat on that be good for you it is barbecue a cow and a chicken at the same time so is this for the sixth and the seventh yeah the sixth is more optional but it's a good meeting and anyone is welcome to attend but we only get two votes so if you're tempted by the call of the barbecue um I wrote 9:00 a.m the legisl wow she's

206so on point and and to be honest sometimes it's nice to have more than two delegates there in case someone needs to go out to take a phone call or use the restroom or something and a vote is coming up then we get to have both of our votes yeah it is NI you could put me as a maybe I have two Mayes I'll take it all right so I'll run through each of the Committees and their assignments we have the finance and audit advisory committee that will be chaired by Bryce denford um we I have made the decision to go back to what we were doing previously with the chairs of finance and Facilities being the executive committee the vice presidents so Bryce stford sharing that one with members Lisa Dean and Suzanne wood

207and you'll be working with John Larson also in this document I asked each of the staff members who are the district representation on these committees to write a little um paragraph about the responsibilities of the committee so those are a great resource and facilities we have chair Brian Barnett with members Daryl Robinson Aaron Barrow and Scott Thomas as the district representation government relations a huge thank you to suzan wood for being willing to chair right out of the gate she's very well qualified and very brave we appreciate her and then darl Robinson and Nikki George as members and you will'll be working with Mike Anderson then the policy Review Committee the new one chaired by Bryce denford members Aaron Barrow and Daryl Robinson and then of course we already know executive committee um Jordan ethnic

208advisory committee the leaan Suzanne Wood joint relations education support professionals thank you darl Robinson for reupping he served in this role already um Jordan parent advisory committee jpac will be Aaron uh and then joint legislative committee representative will be Nikki George with alternate Lisa Dean and then the licensed employee advisory committee leak which I have already started receiving emails in hopes that we can make this a bigger presence this year and Lisa Dean will do a great job um bringing those voices in more frequently and um take those opportunities then we have organizations that have board representation so Jordan Education Foundation Lisa Dean and Alternate Daryl Robinson PTA representative Aon Barrow and Alternate Suzanne wood then Redevelopment agency taxing entity I didn't speak to you guys about this because it came up later but this

209is traditionally just the finance commit so we added names in there so Bryce stford working with John Larson and then alternates Lisa Dean and Suzanne wood Salt Lake Academy board um darl Robinson is already serving on that board and then Brian Barnett replacing Maryland um High School Activities Association Board of Trustees so Bryce denford um filling the rest of Maryland's term and then it will be an elected position from there and then Utah school boards Association um the region n board of directors will be me and then delegate at large are question marks still but probably either Daryl or Aaron after you guys get a chance to look at your schedules and then the region n District delegate Lisa Dean um and then we have Parks and Recreation Thank you Lisa for continuing on in

210that role she's been Sur no thank you I love this role it was hard for me to give up you have a good attitude we're grateful for you and really bad formatting you guys sorry about that but portrait of a graduate um I will continue on that committee and then replacing Tracy Brian is going to step in right questions conversation there great well I really want to say thank you to each of you for being willing to serve in those roles it is a way that we can reduce our meeting length and a way that we can come better prepared to our meeting so we the work that you do on those committees is essential all right with that let's move to agenda item G the legislative review with Mr Barnett and Dr Anderson thank

211you I I wanted to uh Begin by saying this is as it as it says on the agenda it's meant for information only there are 18 19 bills listed here that as a as a district we're interested in we want to watch and see um how they do because they have an impact on on how we run the school district and and we have we have highlighted I think five of them they have an asterisk in the tab at the bottom of this shared document I also want to mention that this is a draft document a working document uh it's not something that we want that we're going to be publishing until we're I don't know if we ever publish it but it's just a working document where as as a board we can we

212can keep some notes um I did want to go through at least the the five or six that have an asterisk uh this agenda item isn't intended to go through all 16 of these items in depth or we wouldn't make uh our bed times tonight or tomorrow or tomorrow so as I guess my recommendation and I I think I made this recommendation via email earlier is if there is a bill that's of personal interest to you uh the recommendation is that you do some research on your own and then if you have questions Mike is a good resource Mike and John they're both of them are usually up to pretty up to speed they're in contact with a lot of of the legislators and if they're if they're not in touch with them they can

213get in touch with them and ask these types of questions rather than spend three four five hours in here with us kind of guessing I did want to as I mentioned just go through uh five I think that Mike highlighted as maybe the most the most important to us the first one is hb42 um peruchi and balery this is a bill that establishes an emergency fund for school districts who have high rates of of increase in elll students or uh English language Learners which we do have in our district we have uh if you if you look on in the notes section there were some numbers run and half of our schools if this bill were in place now correct me if I'm wrong Mike half of our schools would qualify for this funding if

214it were in place right now yeah as it was written prior to today that would have been accurate however today it was heard in committee this afternoon just moments before our board meeting uh began and the thresholds have changed a little bit the funding levels went from 5 million to 500,000 just a little change the um the threshold of 50% increase over the last 3 years has now changed to 75% increase over the last 3 years probably you know as as as a function of the the the money available being so diminished now that's um that's I've been told that that's a that's a number they hope to increase um the funding part anyway and the the information that we have on there if there was a school that had you know each year an

215increase of 49 71 and 93 students uh elll students over the course of the last three years that would be about 51% on average so the increase of 51 average to to 93 students is 82% so many of our schools in in in the district would still qualify even at the 75% threshold so there there are some changes there it passed out of the house committee unanimously there was no opposition to it even in the comments today so that's the latest things move quickly on bills and and here's a general perfect example of how things can turn yeah great discussion with representative peruchi at our legislative breakfast and I saw some things in her and in this bill that I I was very pleased so we had we just had a great discussion with her

216we expressed appreciation to this to the bill sponsor representative peruchi as well I mean the intent here is is is really good and it's it's a result of of constituents within our district reaching out to are expressing concern about the the massive increase so this is a stop Gap measure it doesn't mean that other schools that have large numbers of el students don't need additional funding and additional support this is just intended to Target the the high growth e schools I and I asked her I said are you looking at the big picture are you looking at why are they coming to Utah what's the incentive to come to Utah and is that something that we can address on a state level and they very much are looking at all of that um this is

217an example of where Utah's goodness has attracted a lot of people and how do you feel bad about that you can't feel bad about that but it does create some situations where you know the I think as a state we need to be aware of you know at what point does this is does this become unsustainable and and I was just really interested to see if they were looking at that big picture and they very much are at the state level they are any other input on that let's go to uh HP 267 this one is public sector labor union amendments some of you may have heard some rumors about this uh representative tusher and Kore is he a senate in the senate senate sponsor correct this bill um I'm going to read the summary

218this bill is aimed at Banning collective bargaining across all of Utah's public sectors the bill would not prevent public employees from joining or forming unions but it would prohibit government employers from quote recognizing a labor organization as a bargaining agent the bill would restrict using unions and associations from using public resources by prohibiting employees from receiving paid leave and Union activities uh jlc opposed it strongly it it looks like um and there's a and this was already heard in the in the house yeah I passed out a committee 11 to4 it was heard on the house on Monday um yep yeah sorry I keep saying Monday as if it were like last a few days ago no it was yesterday the the the days Mel together during the session it's hard to keep track so

219it did pass narrowly out of the house um U Miss barl was actually on the house floor during that vote that was really fun I got to sit next to Tracy and hear all that debate it was a really great experience it's uh on to the Senate I think it's business and labor committee I can't remember it's it's not the Senate Ed committee but it's Senate business as labor that could be heard as soon as tomorrow um I have heard that it's likely to be amended it's likely to be amended um maybe to make it more palatable for for some of the Senate and it would have to come back to the house for concurrence and either Mike or John could you just quickly let us know how that if it passes how that changes

220or things for us as a district it would simply mean that if we don't we're not obligated or we can't collectively bargain with with the with the group um unless something changes in the bill that would uh ban that and then it would also require us to either um you know if if they were interested in using a building or a room to work with them on and wouldn't be able to give them um access to it unless it was a something that the board was able to carve out and and uh say that was okay there there are stipulations there any other questions on this one I think one more thing is is in the intent of the sponsor of this bill was that if you did away with with the incentive to join

221a union or an association of some sort the bill also does provide professional liability insurance for those employees that they could opt into so if if the number one reason for them joining joining an association was for the protection and the insurance coverage there would be a state owned State operated Insurance um group that that teachers could could buy into at at a substantially lower rate than than a union dues or association dues would be that's again coming straight from the the U testimony during the during the committee hearings okay so would this would this bill also apply to usba no because they don't collectively bargain with anybody okay it it doesn't disband um public groups and public associations it just prevents them from doing collective bargaining and and treat and holds them to the

222same same stipulations as other groups would be for renting and using taxpayer funded facilities what's the potential litigation in this bill um are other states have any other states done this you know what it's it's a good question I haven't kept track of other states and what they've been doing with it um I can kind of a bizarre bill I remember on the floor representative tusher did mention other states have taken away collective bargaining but nothing like explosive at least he has said has happened in those States I don't remember what states he said that though they from what I understand North and South Carolina do not have unions and I believe Texas does not for teachers the Carolinas haven't for some time and as a reminder Utah is a right to work state which

223means you can't be compelled to join a union or an association unlike other states that that uh sometimes if you're part of the employee group you have to be part of the union or the association Okay and like I said we'll be keeping track um van Coman has a comment go ahead Paul um under current law um everybody could approach you and try to negotiate their contract on their own you don't have to agree to whatever is negotiated it's just extremely inefficient and anyway it it nobody's forced to to agree to something they can always try to negotiate their own contract very good uh hb281 Health curriculum and procedures amendments require School mental health workers to obtain written parental consent before providing counseling Etc the bill limits the scope of school counselors psychologists and social

224workers primarily focusing on academic advis and potentially hindering their ability to address students mental and emotional well-being this bill is still in rules it has not been heard but the concerns as we've looked at it U there are some concerns some questions that we have uh regarding it mainly around the ability that to narrowly focus the school Mental Health Services that we have it would require mental health workers in the schools to to provide a written summary to parents that very day and basically in the moment um um which could create have a chilling effect on students feeling willing to come and talk to their their mental health providers in the school and um the counselors psychologists and social workers that we have uh could increase the workload and the stress on School staff and

225and really just we're Wonder wondering about and creating worried about creating barriers um to access necessary support for students in the mental health area I have a question what is how is this different than the furpa um I mean when I read this it seems like schools already require parents to sign a permission yeah my understanding is we do have a consent to counsil form that we have to send home school counselors can meet with the student the first time and you know at the students request and talk about things but if they want to continue talking about uh talking with certain topics with the student they have to send home consent to council form we've referred to it as a furpa really it's a state level guidance so we've you know Federal is furpa

226and and state level is we have our own laws governing that so it's a consent to council form and it just allows acknowledges that the parent knows that the student is going to be talking with the counselor or the psychologist and so forth about it this law would would really drill down to very specifics uh and even topic by topic menu items that the counselor or the psychologist would be allowed or not allowed to talk to the student about and so you could have a mental health worker that has to open up a sheet and say all right as we're meeting I can't okay sorry we can't talk about that one because that's prohibited or they have to be checking as they go to see what they can they can or can't talk to them

227about and then have to write a report immediately to the parents afterwards to to let them know what was talked about and is the motivation behind this people are concerned about some other topics that are being discussed I'm guessing that would be the am I off base here or is that well it's hard to speak to motive I haven't heard it spoken to in the committee haven't talk talked to the sponsors of the bill like I said it's still in rules but my guess is that there's some concern out there about the the topics that are talked that are potentially talked about with the mental health providers even after a consent form has already been signed so it's saying regardless of what kind of consent a parent has given you cannot talk to a student

228or listen to a student talk about any of these topics that's right and they would have to check that for each student to see what parent parents have allowed or what not allow choose oh so the parent can choose so oh so there's not like some topics that are cart blanch no way a counselor can speak about this there are already topics like that I mean I think the scope of school Mental Health access andion is much narrower than than your general uh mental health providers so we already have some some some areas that we have to abide within some parameters but uh this would go and drill down much more specific so it would it would involve putting different topics on the consent form yes okay and and okay thank you okay s sp102

229public education funding modifications by Senator Filmore this must still hasn't gone to committee yet then Mike do you know um it has not I remember Senator Filmore talked about this when he came and met with us with the government Relations Committee it it it has gone to the Senate Ed committee and it passed out a senate Ed committee um yes yesterday so this bill um and John can speak to this he's he's weighed in on it and and has um had looked at it a little more carefully but this bill would basically there are line items that the the education Appropriations committees have to approve each year some of those include Beverly Taylor senson for the Arts um line item for budgets uh dual language immersion um uh digital teaching and learning those are line

230items that have to be specifically talked about and approved each year this bill would take those line item budget items and roll them up into what we call the flexible allocation budget it's a it's a bucket that's that's much more uh well as as the name implies much more flexible and um so some of those Pro some of those line items that are very near and dear to the hearts of of kids and provide awesome opportunities and and experiences for them would be rolled into that I think the fear is that those those would be in Jeopardy of going away because they're no longer specifically carved out for funding did I miss anything there John would you add anything to that okay so yes that passed out four to one I think one way to

231say it is in I mean there jlc took a took a position of oppose overwhelming oppose um I think if there was any the intent of this of the the bill sponsor is to give more flexibility to school districts um and and his thought process is well rather than have to fight and scrap for these every year let's just roll them into the flexible allocation and they're there so that you can do what you want with them you you can continue be Beverly Taylor Soren and you can continue DLI you can continue digital teaching and learning but that would be up to the Lea governing boards to decide that um the the downside to that is people fear well that flexible allocation could also be on the chopping block during an economic downturn um the

232same could be true for all of the other line items as well so it could be perceived as you know short-term pain and and getting rid of those line items but in the long term maybe some more flexibility for school districts but the concern is there just not a lot of U confidence that that would turn out that way I think and and hence you see the vote in jlc as such an overwhelming uh to the to the opposed does that make sense today would this be an example of returning control locally the state relinquishing control and making it more of a local control issue is that I believe that's the intent of the bill sponsor to do exactly that to give them more put it all into one bigger bucket that's more flexible than

233to just worry about individual buckets and light items that have to be approved and on a regular basis it also I should add um I'm doing uh there is a provision for it's a sunset provision that uh that each line item would have to go through automatically after a certain number of years this doesn't just remove the the switch the funding rather it also eliminates all the requirements surrounding each of these line items and if the bill sponsor desired to overcome the concerns with the flexible spending he could put it into the wpu that has its own challenges of course but this bill is probably the bill I've heard the most from my constituents about buing this up right next to fees it's it's scary timing for people what intrigues me about this bill is

234it is an effort to eliminate a lot of um extra work and a lot of extra oversight and um direction from the state and my guess is and this just ironic and this isn't on the sponsor at all but my guess is this year alone we will get this many new programs again but it is an effort to take out some of the bureaucracy some of the overhead and return some of the control back to the leas as long as we can Safeguard the money somehow yeah yeah I feel like the I was texting with some of the Senators that are on this committee looking at the bill and one response was very much like well they'll still have the funding so if they if your District Cuts your stuff that's on them so I

235feel like they're passing the buck to us and I don't know how I feel about that but I was curious what the digital teaching and learning um does that include like our uh digital High School like that we saw tonight the Middle School like is that that kind of funding the the high school is not funded through digital teaching learning that's a separate um office that resides in teaching and learning okay yeah and smaller districts are impacted in a differently there's they just aren't able to do when the money isn't set aside the allocation will change so for a large District we will still be able to make the choice to support the programs that we value so there is added flexibility with little cost to us as a large District the small districts when

236it's per pupil there won't be enough to to to do everything that they used to do so that's a shift as well last one s sp1 178 devices in public schools also by Senator Philmore I read through this uh Mike and I I I wasn't quite sure what he was changing here because this is from last year as well right actually this came out I think earlier this year like a draft of it and so it hasn't it hasn't been heard in the legislative session um it was talked about a lot over the interim and talked about an interim session so that's probably why it feels like it's already been around for a while but the gist of the bill is that the sponsor of the bill Senator Phil Moore um this bill would require

237Lea boards governing boards such as yourself to either establish a policy surrounding cellphones as we have or refer back to this policy as the Baseline like if you don't have a policy about cell phones this is your new policy uh leas can can create their own policies and how to how phones are governed he's given that that carve out but in this policy the default would be that you don't have a phone during the class uh uh during school time at all there are exceptions to that that you can see in the in the bills language um there for school safety reasons for imminent threats and and so forth there there are exceptions carved out there but it would uh and you can use the uh the phones during lunch recess and after school activities

238if if uh it's part of the approved curriculum and and if they're Allowed by the board so if this yeah that was a little bit of a change there an ad yep I think there was some current concern about not allowing students to use it uh for safety reasons and so forth so it changed a little bit but for us our purposes I think it's just instructive that um we've already created a cell phone policy that this bill would this we've we've or compliance yep as it's currently written because a board can create their own their own Poli policy very good I appreciate uh all the work Mike has puts into this it's somewhat overwhelming but that's where Mike thrives in overwhelming situations I don't know about that was talk that Senator filmer was going

239to run a bill that would limit our like health and wellness day did that ever I haven't seen yeah I haven't seen that yet yeah we I think we made our opinions pretty clear on that and and I haven't seen anything yet not saying it's not coming and not saying it couldn't happen but I haven't seen one yet um I I should have I just barely added um a bill that came out today it was just numbered it's the it's the one we've been long talking about and that's HB 344 I should have marked that with an asterisk that is the new fee Bill and um under this bill I've put some notes on HB 344 some highlights are that it does has a new definition for extracurricular activities um you can see it how

240it defines them on that on that bill there's not a link to it just yet um one of the biggest changes in this bill is that students it would require a fee free pathway for all high school students in other words as a student you would need to be able to go through starting next year not this fall but the following um you would need to be able to go through high school not elect to pay a fee and you could go through and take classes you wouldn't pay a fee at all not to say you know that that's you just have a pathway and option to be able to do that you can always elect to do things and and pay uh for for classes but there needs to be a way you could

241not do that um this bill doesn't allow for fees for textbooks with some exceptions uh School equipment instructional supplies and what they are referring to as common um in air quotes common education expenses that's defined in the bill and you can now charge and in this bill um it's it's clarified that you can charge for uh expenses related to specific programs such as field trips instrument rentals you can pay for postsecondary related schools uh School experiences like AP IB and current enrollment um the extracurricular in general can be charged fees for driver education can be charged a fee and then there are other things that licensing requirements uh think plays and other intellectual property can you if that's involved in the in the activity you can charge a fee for that and then on discretionary

242projects if you're in a class that the Baseline project is is just part of the class but you want to upgrade if you want to upgrade from The Birdhouse to the dogghouse you can you you would be able to be charged a fee for that upgraded project if that makes sense so when it says core academic curriculum so we require Fine Arts Credit we require CTE credit does that count as a core academic curriculum it's one of the areas that we would the feedback that have been able to give to the bill sponsor is actually we'd like to see CTE classes more specifically defined as whether we can or cannot because in the bill it does stipulate social studies language arts science math those are the core classes that the bill actually outlines as classes

243that cannot be charged to fee for unless they fall under one of those categories of of post secondary yeah science is part of that yes is we can't charge fees yeah correct unless it's an AP class or concurrent enrollment class or something like that M there are there are exceptions so one of the other things that I think for us and chime and John if is it would be really nice to get an extension on the implementation date right now schools you'll be hearing about fees in in a very short order um coming to you um to be approved and it would be nice if these are the changes that are going to be made to allow all school districts to to operate under this and postpone the implementation date overall until next school year

244so that we're not operating on last year's Bill and and approving it right now for next year we're able to operate off of this just give us another year that that's something I've I've asked for a couple times um to for the bill sponsor to consider haven't seen anything to date so in the notes where it says that it should be post that's not a part of it just no that's just some some ideas is that it would be nice to be able to be postponed um it would be like I would like it to be more specific about CTE courses and what what we can and can't charge there and then representative Tracy Miller has a a bill that would allow for Fine Art electives to charge fees and one of the questions I

245have is just how how does that Concur and coordinate with this bill and it's just a question I would ask the bill sponsor so from your experience Dr Anderson um how much time does the legislature the state usually give for districts to implement things I'm just curious yeah it depends um a there the two common implementation dates are the beginning of May which um I think a lot of state laws go into place after that that gives the time for the governor to sign it and people to prep for it and then July 1 which is the fiscal year here so those are the two most common implementation dates that I'm aware of um and it's always a good thing to keep in keep in mind and watch for those so the answer is not

246enough is there a fiscal note attached to this at all um on us note on yeah I don't think they' they've published that just yet so is someone warning the retired people on fixed incomes that this is coming I will because they're going to show up to all the tax hearings and it'll be too late I just worry that no one's speaking no one's no one's saying hey this bill is going to affect you this bill was just just introduced today this is the very first day that the Public's been made aware of it um and that it's been numbered so hopefully that that word can start to get out because it's we're you know we're facing millions of dollars in shortfall revenue from from Gathering the fees and the idea of reducing the rate

247and lowering or broadening the base is uh all well and good but to your point not everybody wants to pay for um for class fees that are covered by the individual student for use fees as part of use fees it's similar to taking gas fees away and putting it to everybody you know we we have gas TXS that I don't want to say punish but allows people who drive a lot to build those roads but if we took those you know let's take gas tax away that sounds great we all love that right but it goes somewhere and so then we level it to everybody and now people who don't drive have to pay that fee that's exactly what we're doing here which is why they're looking at for example doing away with the um

248electric car benefit because electric cars don't use gas but yet they use the road correct um I think uh zooming out big picture it appears as though there is going to be a lot of discussion around another income tax cut um but maybe five by 05 five increments um and they're looking away at doing looking at doing away with the Social Security tax on benefits for for the elderly we're one of only a few States if I understand it correctly that that do tax Social Security benefits so those are just two things as you're talking in uh the other big big picture item is there's going to be it's being looked at as a session with a lot of with some one-time money but the revenue Outlook is not um super Rosy which is also

249a smoke and mirrors kind of uh situation legislators do they always lower that income tax because the income tax goes your income goes up the tax goes up they collect more and they sound really nice that they're lowering our taxes over and over and over again but all they're doing is lowering what they stole from us in the first place I'm curious if we have ideas of ways to share a little education this or interest among the board one idea that comes to my mind is we have a board newsletter that we could use to help educate if the board was interested so I um a board member from another District sent me a video that their District had put together um I shared it with Daryl and it was very informative and simple and

250I I think something like that if it wasn't to um you need to be careful because if you're talking about a political activity I could look up the word you're not supposed to use your funds to influence one way or the other so you individually talking have free speech rights when you start expending District information on legislation you could get in trouble for that oh so this's video was mostly about how public education is funded you know what I mean like how it's funded because I um yeah it it would be nice like propaganda said just it would be nice to have a series of videos that we can point our patrons to about how our tax is being collected I mean it really frustrated me when Lincoln Filmore in his town hall says if

251you don't like your property tax go talk to your school board I don't make the decision to fund education out of the out of the property tax he does and yet he wants to throw it back to us and say well so those information videos would be really good to say your legislators decided that this is how we're funding education and it has no increase in it so we have to go out and lie to you and say we're we're raising your taxes when all we're really doing is putting that inflation increase in that it's given to other people but that's what I really think is critical is that we explain our position of where our taxes and and where it goes and those kinds of things because there's all kinds of misconceptions out there

252and I'll tell you I was the first I sucked into that I believe that I thought our district was building Taj Mahal schools and our and our people were being you know paid way too high and I just believed all all the trash that's out there I didn't realize like we are we are the lowest funded education state in the Union and we are in one of the lowest districts you can't get much better than where you're at right now and we've got a I think we've got to do a better job at educating people outside of this bill these bills and outside of a truth and Taxation we just have to make that a bigger priority to educate people how lucky we are to have what we have sorry for the rant I don't

253know if that's in Robin Robert's rules that I can rant that might be in Robinson's rules Robson rules let's make that an amendment you can do informative you just have to be careful as to what your message is that it's not on a referendum uh there's there's certain things that you can't expend your money on so I'm just saying you can educate you can talk but I wouldn't I mean you can inform you can do all that I think that's we could talk about what our school fees how are they used but not what's being taken away by a specific bill I I think you have a fair amount of flexibility when you're not when it's not a a ballot proposition or referendum um or against a particular person just because if if it's not

254going to the voters you have more more say that you can say certain things that's why you can influence legislation and ask people to do things but just be aware that you don't have cart blanch depending upon what it is it's it's fact specific well that that's what I was just thinking the facts we can say the facts are this when the state leg legislature Cuts income tax then we need to raise property taxes and we can even show that states that have no income tax have exorbitant property taxes you know so and that's just the facts we don't have to say you know what write this legislator a letter and go stand on his lawn or you know whatever we don't have to do that but I feel like just the facts are informative

255and people can draw their own conclusion they can decide well I would rather have exorbitant property taxes or I would rather have exorbitant income tax and no property you know people get to draw their own have their own opinion about what is shown I would love to have government Relations Committee come to the board with a recommendation on how to educate our our taxpayers and I feel like right now during this session for government relations it might be a bit much but I would love that too this likely will be a a a bill discussed this this Friday in jlc I hope it is I hope it's the first and the the we talk about it as long as we need to because this is this has the potential to change and and disrupt and

256alter the way boards work this year more than anything and it has it will fundamentally shift the way we've been doing business in education for many many years so this one to me is if there's a priority Bill to watch and to focus on and talk about um in in our councils and so other groups this is the bill because it just impacts every person in our district um potentially and I predict 20 years from now we'll cycle back we'll come back and say hey shouldn't users pay the fees and we'll reinvent student fees as a viable solution and I don't I just want to you can do I think pretty much whatever you've said here you just need to be careful um keep that in mind so I think you could you could say

257hey if this happens this is what happens to us um I think you could even be somewhat specific because these aren't going to the voter I mean you could inform them so I just don't want to say anything is off the table that you've suggested and I think it's worth mentioning that look I think the discussions we've had around the board table here has been that we're not necessarily arguing that fees should not be should be charged for registration and for core classes the the argument centers around well how do we pay for this how do we back get backfilled how do we kept be kept whole and are we going to have to go out for truth and Taxation just to make up for the Lost Revenue in fees for for registration and core

258classes which is what John around $2 million is our shortfall and that two and a half two and a half and then if extracurricular were added in there which it's not in this bill but if it were it would be many times that so yeah two $25 million is that's that's a good chunk of change so over the course of uh um the next 38 days to be exact several weeks of the of the session please feel free to reach out I'm happy to answer what I can on bills um as they come up we try to keep tabs on things as best we can but there are hundreds and hundreds of bills the track many of them as you know are educated education related so and we'll do our best to keep track thanks

259Mike appreciate it that's that's all I had president actually I'm just going to cycle back real quick way more than two and a half right we've got registration fees at 2 million curricular fees at 2.2 and state funding 1.5 is what they're giving so and the way things stand now without this bill so that was from our uh flyer that we shared at our breakfast okay great um agenda item h a a review of our Utah School boards Association conference so those who attend if you'd like to take a few minutes to share some of your takeaways um and we really appreciate those of you who are willing to dedicate the time away from family to go and become a a trained board member who is more effective at your job so thank you to

260those of you who were able to attend anyone want to share I'll go uh I wrote down some thoughts from my notes of things that I really enjoyed um but one thing in particular that was uh said by Miss Dean while we were at the conference was to just kind of go into each class with an open mind and see what you can learn and I used that in a few of the classes I was sitting there at first thinking what what are they talking about I'm like no I could find something and I was able to find tidbits here and there and so I really did enjoy the conference um there was special education class which I really en like really liked and it opened my eyes up to this area uh of our

261schools and um I don't have personal experience with special ed and so I really appreciated the class and it has compelled me to want to go and observe our special ed classrooms and see what's going on what our wonderful teachers are doing there um I liked the breakdown of the legislation process they talked about and how board members can and should get involved and I really appreciated a class called Live Well lead well that emphasized encouraging and helping our administrators create healthy like growth mindset environments for our teachers and staff so that we can have that trickle down effect in our schools so it was really good conference thank you I have three takeaways I'll highlight uh I'm definitely interested in discussing more from our experts in the distri RCT about PBIS the positive behavior

262intervention and support what that is looking like in our schools how we can promote that um to all students I also found the teacher believed in me class interesting and I'm curious how this might be a supportive resource for us and the portrait of a graduate and then lastly also as with Miss Barrow the special needs population to ensure that we're optimizing all the resources available to our students and families um it it was very uh informational for me to hear directly from the leaders over the UT schools for the deaf and blind and some of the challenges uh in getting things brailed for students uh and I don't know how many students we have in our district who have that need um but it definitely shined a light on it for me I appreciated

263that um I'm happy to share some of my takeaways from the mutah School Board Association conference um and I really appreciated the the breakout session on the utas schools for the deaf and blind I had no idea everything that they did and the resources that they provide um for smaller school districts and Rural school districts and I didn't realize that it was for um children from birth to was it 23 or 22 I can't remember but 22 and anyway I I would I really am happy that we have this kind of um support in our state um I went to a really interesting class on or breakout on drug testing in High School athletics and the principal um of Rich High School um he made this mandatory drug testing in all of the Athletics and

264it was mandatory at the beginning of the year or at the beginning of the season and then it was random um every two I actually I think before every competition and so people didn't know if they were going to be tested and how that completely changed the climate of the school it was I don't know how a school district or even a high school as big as the high schools we have in Jordan could do it I mean it costs a lot for the testing kits but it was just an interesting idea um I really I really liked hearing about their experience and then also listening to um Rachel Terry what is her title again she's the director of risk director of risk management yeah director of risk management of it is fascinating what risk

265management covers and what they do and how they figure out claims and the things that are going on in the state um and I also learned a lot in the special educ Class A lot that I I didn't know anyway I I thought it was a really good conference and um I'll stop right there anyone side of the room want to share anything I did really uh appreciate the presentation from the Utah schools for the deaf and blind I learned a lot there and had always heard a little bit about it here and there and knew that we were in a unique situation because we're a larger district and had less relied on their services less but it was really good to understand what they do at a deeper level and then I went to

266a couple of different sessions that uh showed more of a systems approach and some procedural schoolwide or districtwide methods of measuring success and um really kind of um standardizing procedures and it was interesting it's not that I would want to emulate all of the things that I saw but there were elements that were thought-provoking so it's and it's always good to feel like you're having an opportunity to learn from people that are nearby before you travel far and wide to learn from others because there are a lot of great examples uh locally Plus uh I think it was confirmed by an Alpine School District member and others who were very complimentary of our Mountain reach high school Madrigal who really swept everyone off their feet and they were amazing tremendous drop yeah he was that

267the comment he was conducting he said that was the I think he said impactful yes it was it was wonderful I was very proud out of them and I've been watching because it it goes alphabetically so you know they they you only get an opportunity every I mean it's a long time in between chances to to to have a choir come big when goes across and I was looking forward to that I could see that ball coming over the plate uh for a few years so was exciting to get to take advantage of that uh um quick comment about Mountain Ridge High School magicals I absolutely loved the performance and I really admired and respected a phenomenal teacher who put the entire emphasis on the kids um he he is phenomenal in his own right

268and yet that performance he put the entire focus on the kids from start to finish and I loved it um couple classes I'll highlight that haven't been talked about already one that I went to a little different but there was a class on um a Smile Dental survey I went to that one too I thought should I bring that one up it was fascinating wasn't it it was quite fascinating and I I I have meant if Mike hannes is listening he but I've meant to talk to to just see if we're doing something of this nature we do a lot of things for students in need and they went over a lot of statistics and a lot of things about oral health and how that gets overlooked and I wondered about uh toothbrushes being put

269inside the little weekend backpacks or something but that was very fascinating about oral health uh being important for Education uh um and then uh there was some you know I I I've got to go to the legal issues things and I learn about all kinds of stuff that oh okay got to work on that got to work on that um and then the special education one was very fascinating to me and one aspect I wanted to highlight of it was that uh the session I went to they they focused on that it's not for quick short-term results but the long-term results and success of the student long-term not something to see today or tomorrow but the long-term success of the student and I've thought many times in my career if people thought more long-term uh

270I think a lot of people would make different choices rather than shortterm so that that just rang very true with with me and very appropriate that we're interested in the long-term success of every student I will just really quickly highlight one class that hasn't been mentioned I got to listen to you into school district present on how they do their teacher evaluations and knowing that we have been kind of looking at how how that happens in our district it was really interesting to see a different approach and ironically I was in that class with a Jordan teacher and she couldn't stop texting me through the whole thing this would be so great so it was fun to see um that enthusiasm and how applic applicable it felt all right with that let's go ahead and

271take a motion to go into close session I move that we go into close session for character and competence of individuals property potential litigation negotiations Andor security I second have a motion by Miss Dean second by Miss Wood to go into close session and I'll take a roll call vote Mr Barnett yes Mr denford yes Miss Barrow yes Mr Robinson Yes W Miss Dean yes and I am also a yes so we are in close session thank you for attending tonight

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.