CorpusRecord 28226

CCSD Board of Education Meeting Monday December 16nd, 2024 @ 7 00PM

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Cornwall School District BOE Video
Date
2024-12-23
Location
Northwest Hills Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,706 words · about 60 min
Collected
2026-06-05

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Board of Education welcomes comments from the public each person wishing wishing to speak is asked to speak into the microphone identify themselves and respectively limit their comments to three minutes two opportunities to speak are available one in the beginning of the meeting and one at the end each speaker May address the board only once at both the opening and closing portions of the agenda please remember there will be no cross dialogue between speakers and between members of the board all speakers are to conduct themselves in a civil manner obscene language liist statements threats of violence statements advocating racial religious or other forms of prejudice will not be tolerated persons wishing to discuss matters involving individual District Personnel or students should present their comments and or concerns to the superintendent during regular business hours uh with

002that I open the microphone to anybody wishing to speak for public comment any takers all right um that brings us to our student representative reports uh meline and AA not M or excuse me not Ava just meline uh take it away okay we're going to start off with the good news for Co December kicked off with the pto's annual cookies and with Santa event it was held on the evening of December 13th over 150 students and parents attended the event a holiday movie was featured in the auditorium and pictures with Santa and Mrs Claus in the lobby it was a wonderful way to spend an evening with family the PTO will host their annual holiday bazaar on December 17th and 18th students will have the opportunity to shop for their friends and relatives they're looking

003forward to thinking of others during the holiday season the annual combined Winter concert with Willow AV and Cornwell Hudson will take place on December 18th at Cornell Central High School the fourth graders have been working super hard to prepare for their first performance and they will not disappoint thank you in advance to miss Tracy Miss subie and Miss Johnson the concert choir from the high school is going to visit Co on December 19th to fill the halls with song and holiday spirit to keep that Spirit flowing all are welcome to Carol with the co community on December on the morning of December 20th beginning at 8:30 a.m. on the front steps of the school if the weather is inclement the Caroline will be held in the main lobby of cooh during the month of December

004the first grade and student council at cooh sponsored a Food slh hygiene product Drive the donations have been abundant and they will be given to the food bank of the Hudson Valley in the new year a stuff the bus event will be held in January and the students in the first grade and student council will help unload the donated items at the food bank thank you to all who have helped with this event the staff at cooh would like to wish everybody a h happy holiday season um next is good news from Willow Willow Avenue has kicked off the holiday season with her annual door decorating contest gingerbread house decorating activity and toys for Tops collection this week we are looking forward to our fourth graders from both Willow and cooh showing off their musical

005skills at our combined Winter concert at the high school Wednesday night the musicians from both buildings were perform in band Orchestra and chorus we welcome parents to Willow on Thursday evening and Friday for parent teacher conferences our third gr graders V visited Locust Thursday evening and Friday oh wait our th our third graders visited Locust Grove to learn about its Rich history Willow is full of holiday cheer for our holiday spirit week students will be showing their school spirit by dressing like the Grinch wearing their holiday socks showing off their favorite holiday attire dressing like snowflakes and getting cozy in their holiday pjs we'll be ending the week with our holiday fmo where we will be celebrating our December principal Award winners and getting a visit from Santa everyone at Willow Avenue wishes you a

006happy and healthy holiday season and for the Cornwall Elementary School good news this month Cornwall Cornwall elementary school has been focusing on the character trait of perseverance encouraging students to stay determined and work through challenges whether in academics the Arts or special programs students and staff have embraced opportunities to demonstrate and celebrate this important trait one example of perseverance comes from Miss J Jos our Tech integration specialist she has been inspiring students across all grade levels with engaging coding lessons before Thanksgiving she collaborated with our fourth grade classes on an exciting project where students coded their own Macy's Thanksgiving Day parade routes through the activities students persevered through the challenges of programming their robots when the robot made an incorrect turn they didn't give up instead they kept adjusting their code and trying again until

007they got it right the project culminated in the creation of a city that transformed the halls of CES showc showcasing their hard work and determination we were also thrilled to welcome multiple visits from the Hudson Valley pause for a CA these special guests spent time with our kindergarten and first grade classes teaching students about the important work service animals do with guidance from Mrs Mumy and Mrs Perez students explored emotional support and self-regulation while bonding with the hardworking pups from the HV pause for a cause team our fourth graders are in the final stages of preparation for their Winter concert at the high school at at the high school on December 17th thanks to the dedicated efforts of Miss subie and Mrs Johnson and Miss Henry our cafetorium has been filled with the sound of

008beautiful music as students rehearse for their big performance we can't wait to see their talents Shine On Stage as we approach winter break we look forward to spending quality time with family and loved ones we're excited for the new year and the fun and and enriching educational opportunities it will'll bring for our students and this is the good news for the Cornwall Central Middle School CCMS band students provided music at the Cornwall tree lighting many thanks to Mr aloia and Mrs Decker for bringing our students out to kickoff the holiday season in Cornwall this week and next fifth and sixth grade students will enjoy a fun and sweet afternoon for the annual PTO gingerbread house build students had the opportunity to make some Sweet Creations many thanks to our PTO our eighth grade students got

009all dressed up for their annual red carpet event we are so thankful to all of our volunteers that made this event happen it was a fabulous evening the middle school would like to wish everyone a safe and happy holiday season and lastly we have our high school November December recap we had the privilege of celebrating our newest inductees into the National Honor Society the NHS induction ceremony was a special moment for both the students and their families as they were recognized for their hard work academic achievements and commitment to service congratulations to all the new members we know you will continue to represent our school with pride the Winter concert was held on December 10th our talented music departments have been rehearsing diligently and brought the audiences B audience spectacular performances from the band to

010the orchestra to the choir these concerts showcase our students hard work and dedication winter sports have just begun and our athletes are very excited for the season students participating in basketball wrestling cheer boy Bo swim indoor track and skiing are representing our school with determination and sportsmanship we are currently in the midst of our winter spirit week with students and staff showing off their school pride through themed days from pajama day to Candy Cane day the Halls are filled with creativity and enthusiasm it is a great way to come together as a school community and have some fun before the winter break in addition to the Spirit Week festivities our door decorating contest is underway each classroom is competing for the title of best decorated door the creativity has been on full display with some

011teachers going all out with the winter themed designs and others choosing to incorporate school pride as we count on the final few days until Christmas great thank you uh both for that information um always wonderful anything else to add or we're good okay um I'll add our standard sort of disclaimer you're free to join and stay if you want but I know it's a heavy test week I was talking to a high school student this weekend who I think she said she had four or five tests on Friday Friday so you guys may be in a similar boat this week so if you need to sneak out uh to prepare for that so you can fully enjoy your two weeks off please feel free to do so so thank you very much uh with that

012the next item on our agenda is our superintendent's update and I will pass over to Terry thank you Jim I have uh two items uh first uh I have the honor and P privilege of speaking uh about uh some absolute Rockstar teachers that we have in our MST who the board will be voting on for uh tenure um coming up in the next agenda item uh so first I'm going to speak about our two uh Elementary um candidates uh they are uh miss telman and miss prisco from uh CES if you could just stand just quickly just so everyone knows who you are so so uh both of these uh amazing teachers we were able to steal from the city uh so they lost our uh tremendous gain uh they came to us in the

013midst of the uh pandemic um and have have served our students and Community exceptionally well uh since then um as a testament to their skill set uh I was able to observe uh for their final observation before recommending uh tenure uh in early October um for the Educators in the room you know that early October is not necessarily the best time to have a superintendent come in and observe um a lesson um and to add on top of that they are both piloting um a new math resource so uh respectively um these were not uh resources that they were used to and they both did an absolutely um exceptional uh job um Miss prisco I talked to you about um your patience and your absolute uh love and care for your students um while I

014was freaking out about all the manipulatives that your students were using and putting in the wrong bags you just had that a awesome even Keel um about you teaching exceptionally um um an exceptional math lesson all the while I know that you just showed um the differentiation indiv individualization um and then the care that your students needed to be uh successful and in speaking with with Mr Heron uh that's all day every day uh so uh is without res um any reservation I recommend uh you for tenure um and Miss Talman uh you have the um uh distinction of uh I just probably one of my top five uh math lessons I've seen ever in fourth grade so um your ability to manage the classroom in um small groups um putting the groups together by

015way of uh what they were working on um previously and and looking forward um taking notes on all your students uh so that you know exactly where they were and what they needed uh to move forward um and my favorite part of um Miss talman's lesson was students explaining their work and having other students question that student of how they got to that answer so there's no such thing as the right answer in her class it's it's how do we work together to really talk about the math um in the conceptual um behind the math so um loved your class as I told you uh in your postc conference um and these two um teachers are just the epitome of what we would want um all of our teachers to emulate at the elementary level

016so um congratulations and uh well deserved [Applause] uh next moving on to our Middle School uh Miss saini and Mr saano if you could stand [Applause] [Laughter] please so I will start with um Miss saini because you can hear her little bundle of joy in the back uh we were uh supposed to award missini tenure uh last year but you can see she had a great reason for uh taking some time off uh to uh welcome her son um in our midst if you go in our classroom you see her son everywhere uh she is a proud uh Mama um and on top of that she's an exceptional uh teacher I got to know missini as a dad um she had adaah uh in her class and um a is um full of energy and

017life and takes some redirection every now and then so uh but she always talked about missini when she came home what uh her interests were but that just shows um Miss's love for her student she makes that connection on a personal level gets to know their interests and on top of that makes her classroom uh just uh fun uh to be in lots of group work lots of games um and then really high expectations uh you walk into her room and you know that she knows that uh they can um succeed uh but she also expects them uh to uh to do well so um congratulations uh Miss saini I'm glad uh your family could be here uh to celebrate with you uh this evening and Mr saano has a now so I got um

018uh Mr saano uh truly brings history uh to life and I mean that in every um sense of of that phrase um he teaches through um a lot of simulations um as you know in Middle School history way back when is not necessarily something that uh all middle schoolers are interested in um but Mr Mr stano makes it interesting each and every day uh for his students um my favorite um uh aspect of Mr spano's classroom beyond the the um simulations is his ability to capture our middle schoolers attention so some of the grossest aspects of history from like what they were eating back then what the environment may have been like on a ship after 28 days things of that nature that we're all sitting around gross middle schoolers love it so he knows

019that about them and he absolutely captures their um attention and interest so Mrs Spano um amazing uh history teacher and your tenure uh tonight is welld deserved so congratulations to you both all right so I know we have little bundles of Joy so um the next agenda item is the Personnel actions where tener will be um voted on by the board so if you could stick around just for that and then uh you're free uh free to go as well um the only other agenda item that I had uh this even evening was just to provide uh the board and the community with um a highlevel um summary of the engagement survey that we took at the end of last uh school year uh my team along with the administ um Administration and the staff

020at each School kind of dug into uh the data over the summer and into the September and October uh months and then developed kind of action plans around what the data was speaking to uh we were for forunate to get uh over 2600 responses from our uh student staff and Community um which is fantastic we're a district of um just over 3,000 uh so that's a great response uh rate uh some of the uh celebrations districtwide that we kind of uh kind of rose to the top um our schools provide safe and supportive learning environments uh there is ample technology usage and availability in our classrooms um our teachers believe our students can succeed and do well uh School leaders have high expectations for our students and staff and our student services staff provide excellent

021support for our students those were kind of um some generalized themes across all five uh buildings with regards to areas of growth um students self- monitor their progress and keep track of their learning um was an area of growth you know uh talking about students under understanding where they are what they're hoping to achieve uh by the end of the year another area of growth uh teachers and and schools contact me not just in times of concern um another area student Behavior does not interfere with instruction Andor students follow the school rules uh at the middle school and high school level a lot of uh data points around student engagement in their learning and then the final area was really strengthening homeschool uh connections uh so since the beginning of the year our schools have

022uh already put into uh action some um some strategies uh one across all five buildings there's a phone call challenge in every building um to reach a certain number like there's 100 phone calls in one building in our smaller buildings 500 phone calls in our larger buildings and that um purpose of those phone calls is really to reach out uh to make that contact home not just when uh little so and so is in trouble or you have an academic concern but really just a touch base um at home um to make that connection uh there's some student goal setting and progress monitoring so I I uh saw a whole school uh participate in having their students uh set goals for the year um and they were taught how to do that you know setting

023goals as adults is difficult um if you could imagine it's even U more complex as a as a student uh there have been curriculum nights uh and curriculum updates for parents just uh uh providing parents uh with updates on um on the curriculum what children are learning in math social studies reading um and science uh some positive behavior strategies and supports at the elementary level uh and then we sincerely believe that uh Community lunch at the high school level will offer um and has offered our students with more engagement um with their peers and um adults in the building so more to come um but we just want to share kind of a high level um overview I'll be sending this out to uh parents um in the new year at the beginning of the

024new year just to make sure that they know that um we're we're taking action on um the survey responses both at the student staff and um parent level and that's all I have great thank you Terry um I think what I'll do here is just so we can we can take this vote my update uh Segways into the um discussion on regionalization so uh so long as nobody on the board has a problem with that I'll just move my move my portion back here and we'll take the consent agenda vote and then we'll we'll go back to uh president's update and the discussion so uh onto the consent agenda use of the consent agenda permits the Board of Education to make more effective use of its time by adopting a single motion to cover those

025relatively routine matters which are included um can I have a motion on the consent agenda some and a second uh anybody who would like to pull any of the items two through eight Christian I would like to pull item three and item seven anybody else three three okay all right so let's take a vote then um I think we're voting on everything else right typically on consent agenda if we want to comment we pull that item separately so if you'd like to is there anything besides three and seven whole what which item item number one that's number one is a consent you mean one inside the personnel got it so three three subsection one great got it okay so then um we' have had a motion in a second so we're going to take a

026vote here on item number two item four five six and eight all in favor I I I any opposed any extensions okay great so those passed um um and then we've got some discussion questions on item three um we'll go in the order of which people raise their hands so Christian item three um I would like just to pull a section of it so we can vote on the the need the other parts which is the resolution at the end about the increase in minimum wage and then the individual positions that are below that so it's the very end of the Personnel uh the Personnel memo so everything from resolution to increase pay rates for certain positions to adjust the minimum wage changes and then the table um below that to the end of the

027document okay so you want to take a separate vote on that I would like I would like to have separate discussion on that okay um and I'm much sure we want to talk about all the different sections so we can clean vote on the remainder yeah I I think we should probably just do that unless you know um I'm just saying we're not I'm not the only one but I know there's someone was had a different section yeah Elanor so mine had to do with at least one of the things that just mentioned so I feel the same okay we'll we'll discuss that here in a moment yeah Tiffany on item number one I really just wanted to also compliment the teachers for tenure um I wanted the opportunity to say my personal experience with

028uh Mr Stefano aka Mr stuffy has was nothing but Stellar um when my daughter was in the middle school and he literally was a a takeaway shining star teacher from her whole Middle School experience so for that I thank you um Miss sabini though my daughter did not have her I know her reputation she's highly respected and a valuable asset I did not have the opportunity to have personal experience with Miss telman or Miss prisco but um it seems like that that's my loss so you seem like wonderful folks that's really all I wanted to say is compliment them um on this amazing achievement and accomplishment welld deserved great thank you for that well Jim if while we're at it I'll uh I'll add that for Miss Talman who had my daughter uh everybody my

029daughter Fiona always raved about her so that just leaves some of to step forward and claim Miss prisco is a personal experience I've only heard amazing things though so uh wonderful thank you um okay so uh to the minimum wage Christian you a comment so can I suggest that we just uh for the moment bracket out the resolution and vote on the remainder of the personel items and then we can have a discussion um or I would move that I'm just trying to think of how to that's not necessarily numbered on here but um yeah so we will vote on everything just accepting the last resolution here and we will come back to that um so all in favor of personel actions up until the final resolution i i i any opposed any extensions okay

030uh we will come back to that and then let's uh item seven in our consent agenda sorry getting lost lost in my paper here uh number seven um so I guess sorry before we say that congratulations tenure recipients your vote is just been pass uh so you're all more than welcome to stay if you would like of course but uh if you'd like to sneak out the back we wouldn't blame you so thank you very much uh so on to item seven the budget calendar adoption item Christian uh so in the um in the attached document for the budget calendar it says for the location for the budget vote revote is the Cornwell Central Middle School um I believe that is premature to vote on this time given previous discussions and I would vote to

031amend it to vacate that until we have that discussion okay um I would offer a proposed alternative that we can vote on it as is um I had planned to bring up the dis location discussion in j January and we can amend the calendar if necessary just because it's important to uh have the dates locked down with the with the knowledge that we're going to have that discussion next month and we can amend the budget calendar to uh show the appropriate location if we so choose to change it so um I refer to you can approve the dates and leave the location empty I think that's C are the same uh the same purpose uh the date is set I think by state law about when we have to have the vote so I don't

032think the date is going to change um for the budget votes on school budgets in New York state that's not set by us so no the date on the budget's not going to change I think the dates that we're laying out in the calendar here are the dates that we're going to have the discussions in our meetings and I'm completely willing to vote on the remainder of the calendar but given the previous for reasons given the previous discussion not to recapitulate them I think that's an open item and I don't think we should I would ask to amend that vacate the location and then set it in January which would as same thing as we amended it okay um guess we've got two proposals any thoughts I I don't see what it would hurt to

033leave the location um vacated at this point since it was a discussion that came up already right and we there was no resolution as far as what we were going to do so I mean to leave it my only reason to say approve it as is is because the documents already up on board docs and it's there and there's no reason that we can't amend it later so just from the the documents existing and it's attached versus finding a you know I don't have a print out of it right now a print out and amending it and going back and reing it to board docks so my argument is just a ease of use argument I think we get to the same place either way yeah yeah so if it's all the same either way

034I would ask that my suggestion be honored and that we amend it now rather than amend it later and I don't think it's any more work to do it now or later okay anybody else comments yeah I agree with that I think if we amend it now it's not going to be too much work Tiffany I'm going to agree with Mr kraan uh we can always amend it at a later time the discussion of location did not did not move forward in a previous discussion um and if it does move forward in in in the future it it can be amended as presented should the board so choose okay uh anybody else comments are there any practical reasons that we have to get it in have to take the vote now or could you just

035table the whole discussion until January Terry John we're moving forward on our end to make sure the district's set up for a successful budget vote so we have a good month ahead of us before we're we're even talking about anything remaining so there's nothing holding us back from meeting with our team so even if it ped till January we're fine okay um well in that case let's let's just just table this till our next meeting and we can have the discussion on voting place and so I will move to table if someone if you're going to Second and we can take a vote on that or I'll we can go a different way if if Miss galano I'm sorry yeah I mean it's yeah so we have a motion to table item seven from Christian

036we a second from elanora all in favor of tbling this to our next meeting I I any opposed Tiffany and bass uh no abstentions because everybody's voted okay um and then let's go back now to um item three uh the resolution [Music] on pay rates for substitute uh teachers monitors clerical cafeteria worker Etc um Christian or I'll let you whoever whichever one of you wants to go first please go ahead sure um so the current rates are $17 uh per DM and for uncertified $125 per DM currently for certified work works out to be 1531 per hour for uncertified and SE um 1765 for certified as is well known the New York state is phasing in a minimum wage increase of 2 50 Cent increases on January 1st 2025 and January 1st 2026 obviously our

0371531 will be a low minimum wage as of January 1st in the coming year but it also would our even at revised rate would be below the uh minimum wage for January 1st 2026 um in a in our August board update this was describ our current rate of 1531 was described as well within the minimum wage which was true that it was above but that it can't absorb an announced in anticip announced in pass minimum wage increase would suggest that it is not sufficiently above that the cost of raising at the 1581 that is being suggested is a total cost by my estimate and I would gladly give you my three different methods of estimating the total number of substitute um for the year is approximately about $199,000 per year for all the substitutes that

038go from 107 to I believe the proposed rate of 112 to raise this to $16 an hour which would mean to meet the minimum wage requirement on January 1st 2026 would only be an additional $ 7,267 for the entirety of 2025 for our entire substitute uh teacher uh for or $10,800 if we raise it to a full dollar amount per DM of 114 the cost um this would be costly the same for certified and to make the same increase proportional for the certified it would only cost us an additional $199,000 to bring it to 1650 to allow it to be above minimum wage and not in a sense at minimum wage this change even the change that I proposed to change that's a 1615 1650 an hour which would be a change from 107 to

039117 per DM and then 125 to 135 which stood P put us below most retail positions in Orange County as well as on the lower end of most uh of most um districts in Orange County for substitute pay in terms of the rate and so I would ask and I would move that we move the rate to 1650 an hour which would be a pum of 117 and 135 and I've given you I think this cost is minimal and much lower than things we have voted on even in the last few months for substitute pay that we did not do through the budget process and I'll leave it at that and I would say that after's comments I'd like to move to amend this to 1650 an hour for the positions listed in the resolution

040Elora um so I know that I had asked for it to be on the agenda then we spoke about it but I did a little research since um we had spoken about it and I don't know if anyone is familiar with the Rockefeller report and forgive me if I'm reading from my paper but I didn't want to get the information incorrect so I'm I'm going to be reading from here um in the recent Rockefeller report on Foundation Aid it suggested that the formula replaced the regional cost index with the comparable wage index for teachers so what this means basically is a more accurate gauge of of labor cost for school districts under this change 75% of districts would receive more state aid Cornwall and the rest of Orange County would see a 3.1 decrease in

041Foundation Aid which is approximately 600,000 to 800,000 per year because teachers are paid less the loss is equivalent to 1.5% tax levy increase per year so I've reached out to a friend of mine who is an education attorney to get more information on this because this is very new to me researching it and I would like more information but that's something we need to consider with this substitute future pay as well so perhaps this is something that we need to put back on the agenda uh thank you for that elanora um I hadn't heard you know the Rockefeller study I haven't had time to digest the whole several hundred page report I do have it up on my computer in my office actually but uh there's I know there are a lot of proposals and

042we're a long way before that hits the legislature and we'll see where you know where that ends up that's actually part of my uh president's form update but that's an interesting component to it that I hadn't heard um so just to recap for our audience here um we had you know known that we were going to raise this rate here before January 1st uh to meet new State uh minimum wages for um both certified and non-certified substitute teachers um and we had discussed as a board having a discussion about um potentially raising that even further um as part of our budget process which we will be kicking off here in the spring obviously with a vote uh later in the spring as part of the community so uh Terry I don't do you have any

043uh comment to respond to Christian yeah um we always uh look to the board for um Direction and um follow uh suit our intent in um this midyear uh shift as we've done in the past two years ago we raised um substitute rates and other uh rates to align with changes at uh New York State um the uh reason why coupled with eleanora's uh desire to have a a longer discussion about this um was to really fold it into the budget process um I know there's tons of things that are mentioned about uh well we do this all the time but we really don't don't do it with wages we don't do it with our clerical staff we don't do it with our custodial staff they deserve the same kind of time and attention that

044I think a budget process um warrants our teachers our administrators they're all going through the standard process these units don't have um necessarily um associations to um uh to help with the bargaining but that's why we said let's have this conversation in the budget uh process where we can really talk about at the end of the day when we have all these decisions to make let's make sure that we're not just having one conversation ahead of others because there's other members of our staff um that I think would argue that there's a need for increases in in wages so that's our only intent in a mid year is to keep it at meeting mandates and then allow the board and the community really engage in longer convers through our budget channels uh for uh 25

04526 thank you Terry uh Tiffany and though I wholeheartedly agree that the the community uh the taxpayers need to be involved in the process and every staff member from custodial uh up to Administration um need to be considered um in addition I in in this instance though I must agree with Christian um that the 1581 I don't have it in front of me um I mean the Woodberry Commons pays more than that um for 17y olds um without without education and and we are entrusting these um substitutes with our children and their education so I I support Christian's proposal anybody else comments I mean at first listen I agree with everything Christian said um I'm I guess I would just love to I would have loved if that was introduced maybe with a couple of

046days for the administration to give us a response on like what the ramifications of that would be um and that's with a goal desire anyway to to support that um personally I don't I don't feel comfortable listening to math and not having time to see it absorb it understand what the on the other side of the Ledger I don't think that's me person speaking personally doing my due diligence um with the responsibility I've been entrusted with so um although I would say I generally I do support the sentiments that uh Christian brings up um it feels premature to listen to those uh to that breakdown and just say absolutely I support it without having perh perhaps a deeper dive again from our administrators and and telling us um you know all sides of that equation

047pass I'm going to go along the lines uh what Brandon just mentioned I'd like to hear the reasoning behind the numbers we presented here I I don't see that uh I know there was a uh the weekly updates that he provided us I mean I read it there but there was no uh reasoning behind why the numbers are as such right I mean and now kind of we're hearing from Christian that you know each number should be increased by $10 I mean he went through the math and everything uh why I go like take step back and what was behind the numbers we saw from the administration I'd like to know that before I vote uh so just really um simple the reason why these positions are listed are to meet the New York state

048minimum wage mandate so that's the increase bottom line the discomfort that my team would have I'm I'm not going to speak for um Mr thinkink but to Brendan's point we also look at other positions so I would have a really hard time approving these I we one we need to approve at least this now so I want to be Crystal clear in order to meet mandates set by New York State this this needs something needs to be approved tonight this is not a table uh till January but that said if we were to hit another number for some of these positions what we do is we look at the other parts of the scale you can't have some of these positions hopscotching other uh other positions so there is a domino effect that my team

049would need to digest a little bit more we we look at that with our custodial staff look at that with our food service staff and others so there is there is a domino effect um at play uh here as well Christian so while I appreciate that there's a domino effect what we're doing is meeting the minimal legal requirement by New York state for minimum wage we are basically just getting above a floor we are not breaking the bank we would still be well in the bottom eth of Orange County substitute pay even if you adopted the 16150 hour and I would certainly support raising anyone else who's below 1650 an hour that I might not be aware of to that level we also know because New York state has passed this law that it will

050be $16 an hour on January 1st 2026 so we will have to do this again next December and I hopefully we don't do it at the very last meeting so we just get under the deadline for basic legal Compliance New York passed this law law uh not recently New York state passed this law recently anyone should have known that this law was coming and the state was coming there are off ramps that New York state provides if there's ex economic exigencies that require perhaps not raising the minimum wage if something happens in the next year so since we know that it will be $16 an hour on January 1st 2026 and maybe we don't want and because we quote substitute pay in per DM meaning whole dollars per DM to get to $16 an hour

051would be at least $114 as opposed to 112 which is what is being suggested and there is no loss if we raise the rate for the certified because we don't know whether it'll be a certified or an uncertified sub so if you Mo move them up proportionately it's not going to cost us any more money uh in the sense of like the the Delta between the current and the change so while I realize there are other discussions I think that the minimum commitment of our community to education is to or frankly to the law is to meet the minimum wage that we already know is coming online and I don't think we need to wait to the very last moment so that we just comply with the law and that's why I suggest doing this

052now since we know that's what the level will be within a year and the fact that all of our partner districts in the area would not have to do this at the last moment simply to meet minimum wage requirements suggest something longer which that's a broader discussion that I'm happy to participate in and I'm also happy to walk through the calculations um but we've also provided um substitute rates for administrators that everyone around this table voted on except for myself okay in the last few months we were assured in August when this minimum wage was already coming online that we were well within minimum wage when clearly we wouldn't be within few months I'm suggesting we get ahead of the ball a little bit and at least meet you know look I agree we should

053meet January 1 requirements and I am supportive of at least doing that tonight but I think going to 114 for and then then $16 an hour as opposed to ,550 would save us a lot of work and I frankly think the Goodwill is worth it at the price that I mentioned and I as I said I'm happy to walk through the numbers um I'm happy to walk through the numbers if people want to hear that tonight but I'm also happy to walk through the numbers at any time at your convenience can I clarify something because I um I Heard uh Mr bernelli say raise every position listed so I he wouldn't have the numbers for what the impact would be if we raise it for every position um again we wholeheartedly support everything that's being

054said we're just trying to be fiscally responsible with regards to what does this mean with a midyear uh increase so I just want to clarify are we talking about all of these positions raising because that that's that's what I thought I heard and then I heard Mr berelli come back and say Well it wouldn't hurt to just raise it to 114 so so 114 114 would be just above 114 would be slightly above um $6 an hour for substitutes what about all per DM rate of 114 works out to be about the other positions LED on sub lunch monitor 1550 I would say that my my position what I would move is to make that $6 an hour substitute clerical $16 an hour substitute greeter $16 an hour substitute cafeteria work $16 an hour substitute

055C to work $16 an hour lifeguard $16 an hour um water safety instructors is above 16 I am not against raising it but it does meet the minimum requirements at least for tonight and teaching assistance substitutes and non-certified substitutes I don't know if that is a full perdm rate it would seem be to below the threshold on a perdm basis I don't know how many hours that is implied there six and a half so um right I that's why I was I that's why I wasn't sure sorry so I would be supportive of moving that to a rate of $16 an hour in complying with the minimum wage law as of January 1st 201 26 that has been passed by uh the New York State Assembly and government so that I mean I don't know

056if there's other positions because they're not listed here there's potentially other positions um no I was just saying we don't know what that impact is per Brendan's um comments I I just share a number of what that means over um for the remainder of the year we just I wouldn't be able to provide those that impact number for the board yeah so I would just um share a couple thoughts one you know when it comes to what's on the table here I agree with Brendan's thoughts of you know of course we all want to pay our teachers and our substitutes and all these other positions more if possible uh but without understanding the budgetary impact um I would be you know without having the numbers in front of me to look at and having time

057to research them that's not a vote that I'm prepared to take at the table um as to your argument about complying with um you know 2026 I think we've clearly signaled as a board that this is something that we'd like to see changed and we want to do that as part of the budget process this year so I anticipate that these rates will be higher um than they are on the page here starting for next school year um so I don't anticipate um that we'll have any issues with 2026 compliance so I don't know that we need to do that at the table right now um when we've all signaled a um a desire to have a broader discussion about this uh during the budgetary process so I'd say we let that play out before

058we start worrying about genan one 2026 can I say something too Jim please you know I think there's um first of all Christian I appreciate you you putting this all together let's try to take a step back and think of like a little bit of the longer view so we are uh last meeting of 2024 when we come back in 2025 I think the third meeting February is going to be our first budget presentation I don't know somewhere around there and then every meeting after that it's going to be budget budget budget we're going to be doing a deep dive on the financials of this District where I think we can have exactly the conversation that this topic deserves because maybe we end up where you just described Cent for Cent maybe we wind up

059higher um I don't know but I think number one this topic deserves that discussion we're not kicking it to six months from now we're kicking it to three meetings from now when it fits uh into our our normal uh budget conversation I think what one thing about raising these kinds of issues at the board table what it does it puts people in a position to say do you support substitute two teachers or not that it turns a very nuanced vote into what seems to be a simple vote I would venture to say if you went around what are there eight people at the board table tonight aside from you Christian I don't know if anybody could recite the numbers that you just said right they don't really that we have not internalized everything that you

060have said so even those that might be inclined to vote Yes wouldn't to my my guess be able to tell you afterwards what they really voted yes on they would be voting yes because they want to support substitute teachers I want to support substitute teachers this is my money as a taxpayer just as much as it is everybody else's I support spending more of that money on substitute teachers but I also think we have a an obligation to give this very important topic the time and research that it deserves and I don't think we should feel compelled or even you know like um I don't maybe guilted is too strong of a word but I I I don't think we should allow our desire for the outcome to short circuit our process here and our

061due diligence we still have an obligation to give this a lot of thought and it's only going to be three more meetings until we are kneed deep in that process so for those reasons again I I think we should as Terry said can't punt this we have to vote on this tonight but we hold each other accountable as a board to make this an important important part of our budget discussion which again is going to start in what six weeks and to add to your um thought Brendan I'm hardpressed I'm trying to think of an example when we've raised a monetary issue at the board meeting and voted at that board meeting I can't think of an example where we've done that in my time on the board um we always if it's raised at

062the board table we say hey that's great we're going to bring it back at next meeting um so we have time to fact check and pull together uh any numbers and you know anything that the administration proposes um you know we don't always do it twice sometimes it comes out as the agenda five days before and we have ample time to ask questions if we have questions on it but I I I can't think of a time that we've ever just said at the board table let's have an expenditure which you say is $20,000 Christian that may or may not be true I'd like to hear John you know look into that and check that um it's probably in the right ballpark but um I just we need to have that information for me before

063I can vote on uh you know an expenditure so just want to add that thought so I still think because what we do know and which is not in doubt is that New York state has adopted minimum wage of $16 an hour which translat to $114 for The uncertified Substitute Teacher can we amend that and we'll leave all the uncertainty on the other positions because we moved them to, 1550 and we haven't gotten a budget number for that what that is a total number for all the implications on that and we are voting on that because we have to minimally legally comply so what I'm saying is all the other budget this is not a budget discussion this is like follow the law that's already been adopted and maybe don't wait till the last moment

064to do it and we would still be if we did a 114 at the bottom of Orange County so the point is this isn't about supporting our substitute teachers this is about you know being legally compliant of what we already know is going to happen whether whatever our budget is we're going to have to pay our substitute teachers minimum wage and I don't think that's a big ass to requires that and if the if we want to come back with more information in January but I would think right now what we do now is $114 an hour and I would I would amend mine for that but although I still I was expressing what my preference would be um and 114 that I would also say that we have voted on things and I could

065I don't want to say gotcha but like things we have voted on in the last four months that have been of this scale and there hasn't been let's say a big budgetary breakdown and all the things laid out for us but I just want I just want to close on one thing so Hamilton count County Fon County Montgomery County New York which is between Albany and UDA um has an average median household income of somewhere between $3,000 and $42,000 according to the US Census so let me read what their substitute pay for some of the districts in this area Amsterdam substitute teacher pay with a two-year degree $158 a day and for just for reference as I mentioned the immediate income in that area of the state the immediate income in our area the income

066in Cornwall is between $ 105 and $110,000 individual median income which is twice what it is in that part of state and I realize they probably also have more state aid as a result and that's part of the equation but any single District in these Three Counties for 20 for the existing year 2425 is significantly above what I'm proposing and that seems to be more of a commitment to our teaching staff because it's and the point is we can have the discussion and all the other things we have time but this would seem like a lwh hanging fruit to even just say from one instead of 112 114 and then we are already in compliance for next year and we do not have to have the discussion next December can I just for my own

067understanding so you're you're now proposing only the non-certified to 114 what about the certified you're taking that off your proposal I'm I'm conceding the point that if people want more information to feel comfortable with this um we can we can do that obviously I am not opposed to doing 1550 hour because I am in favor of obeying the law that being said since we since I only did the research for the numbers on substitute teachers I think we 114 is not even what I'm talking about 114 I believe is only an additional $10,800 for the whole year and if that's ballpark that's below a lot of things we voted on in the last few months for personel and I think that is and that means we're already in compliance and then we can go from

068there and have the discussion about what we want to do above compliance and I think that's a fair position for tonight and it's not $100,000 it's not $500,000 it's certainly in the 10 low tens of thousands maybe not even $20,000 I think that is reasonable request and if people want more detail I'm certainly there's a meeting in January for everything else that was on this and I'm willing to to in a sense make my motion 114 for uncertified Subs I would like to do it for the other positions to be consistent but if people feel that requires more information I'm willing to wait on that for the rest with my hope that we will act on that as well pass yeah thanks Jim I I don't see the rush to to do anything like modify

069any of those numbers tonight uh we can just take a step back and review everything and approve everything at once uh as I said I mean you know I'd like to uh look at how the numbers that were proposed were were arrived at the reasoning behind them and we just heard from Terry that the cascading effect if you want uh we'd like I'd like to hear a lot more about that so if you approve one item today increasing one items on the table today uh you'd never know you're not going to know the consequences of that because once you do everything globally what the Deltas would be you know can we absorb that can we not just to make a comparison that hey we've been approving amounts that are way bigger than what the amount

070Chris Christian is proposing tonight that's not enough uh kind of you know uh of an argument by itself so either approve everything or not approve everything at once but I wouldn't pick and choose tonight anything thank you for that pass anybody else Richard I might as well chime in so a couple things based on this conversation what I would like to say it started tonight and I guess we're going to continue this coming month months during the budget season is a conversation about maybe not just striving to meet minimum requirements standards but I think we have to start thinking about going above it a little bit because if you look as Tiffany said Woodberry Commons pays more McDonald's pays $20 an hour if I'm not mistaken Starbucks pays $20 or more per hour and we

071also have to look at where do we rank in Orange County compared to other schools with substitute teaching okay so personally I think that's something we need to talk about sounds like we're going to um but we definitely need to strive for more than just doing the bare minimum be legal requirement I think that's something we have to think about for just for personal respect for people and and to bring more people uh teaching substitute teachers in because I think we probably do have a shortage that's what I've been hearing substitute teaching shortage so that's a conversation we definitely need to have very soon but thank you all right thank you Richard one yeah I would say that uh to Echo what you had said and then what bass had said I think even best

072case scenario or or most assertive the most assertive we could be we would still need to verify those numbers you know like we we would still need to be sure that um and Christian I I give you the benefit of the doubt that those are correct um but that would push us to the next meeting you know like I I I do I I don't as practice I think it's it's it's not great to change numbers on the Fly before like I don't even have them written down you know like I'm I'm trying to keep notes but I I don't think that uh I think again best case scenario we would still verify the numbers by next meeting and then take a vote but as Tera said this is something that we need to do

073now in its current form um and then you'd be talking about amending it um but then once we're back in January again we're just at that point a couple meetings away from kickstarting the budget season in which we're going to take a deeper dive anyway and at that point to me it becomes a question of how do you allocate your time resources like should we have part of the discussion then and the whole discussion a few weeks after to me it just you know make it a deep dive all-encompassing discussion that uh does all of the things that you described and more uh potentially but we have to give ourselves time to do it I I I just don't see how we could take a vote on this tonight on those amendments without having those

074numbers uh verified I think everybody who's wanted to be heard has been heard and we should vote on it you uh stole the words out of my mouth we have a motion in a second um so we're going to take a vote on this if you'd like to then introduce a motion just be clear just what we're voting on just cuz we what's on the paper paper yes um so all in favor I I any opposed any extensions okay uh sorry bass did you vote Yes or abstain okay uh so that motion passed you like to introduce a motion to I like a motion to raise the per DM substitute uncertified substit uh excuse me let me start again I would like to move to move the uncertified substitute teacher compensation rate from 112 an

075hour to 114 an hour I sorry 114 sorry per yes thank you it's been a long day $112 per DM to 114 per DM and it it says on the paper here non-certified substitutes just for avoidance of doubt that's what you mean by uncertified substitutes yes now that's fine I would you said it better than I would and was my intent I think we all understand the motion would anybody like to second that motion we have a second um I think we have all had our discussion um all in favor of amending that non-certified substitute to 114 from 112 Tiffany Richard Carl Christian elanora all opposed myself br Brendon and bass uh so that's five votes so that motion has passed um so that brings us to the end of our consent agenda uh the

076next item is circling back to the president's update um and that's just going to segue into our um discussion on regionalization um so I'm not going to break that out into a separate I'll just go right there so um just a few quick notes on the president's update um we had a an email and I know that the board has emailed about this uh an email from the public earlier this week asking about uh the progress on an RFP for a new school attorney um we had a little delay there uh with the transition from Harvey to John uh a draft of that Terry sent to myself and Christine last week possibly um I just sent back three very minor comments today um and once those are made we will um distribute that for the

077full board for comments so um to see if there are any changes there but I I think if the the full board any changes that they would want would be minor so uh look for that coming to your inbox uh shortly and then um we will send that out uh early next year uh onto strategic planning um I have a draft email which will be going out to Christian Elanor myself Christine and Terry you have all reviewed the Strategic uh plan rfps to set up a meeting hopefully um early to mid January so we can review and then bring that to the board um just something I wanted to highlight I um I emailed this out to the board earlier this afternoon um this is from nisba on board publication um I thought there was

078an interesting um note hear from the nisba president on three questions for every school leader in 2025 um so just things that we're going to be seeing as a board uh item one already talked about what is going on with Foundation Aid Elanor touched on that there's so many different um proposals in that Rockefeller document it's going to be very interesting to watch Albany this year to see if they act on it if because they might not take any action um I think they will act on it eventually will they act on it this year um who knows um if they do act act on it um what will be what will it be um there was also a more in-depth article later on on page five Rockefeller Institute recommends changes in school Foundation Aid

079a few of the bullet points that I found very interesting um along with what you said about tying the budget to the to the teacher salary the foundation Aid formula I hadn't seen that one but um some interesting uh bullet points here um so one U well I guess back to the president update she says Kathy hokel has expressed support for maintaining hold harmless in the upcoming state budget so that would mean no school district would see their state aid reduced at a bare minimum they would get the same amount last year whereas last year's state aid proposal we all know saw approximately half of New York state school districts see um cuts in their state aid year-over year some of the substantial so uh we'll see if Governor hokel sticks to that but that

080would certainly be nice to know if we have a floor um and some other just interesting bullet points here some some Det details specific recommendations from the Rockefeller Institute uh have the state fully underwrite to the cost of mandated transition to zero emission buses uh certainly we would welcome that um reduce allocations to school districts with large fund balances uh so require districts retaining more than 10% of their budget is a year inbalance to apply the excess as an offset to save harmless allocations I just thought that was interesting as we've certainly discussed on this board before the state mandated you can not carry more forward than 4% um we have stayed true to that State uh law there are many districts in the state who have not so it's interesting to see there that

081they say if you're over 10% you should uh have that overage um basically taken off your next year's state aid budget um and then the next point is allow school districts to temporarily retain up to 10% of their budgets is an unrestricted yearend fund balance if they have a plan for spending These funds that is approved by local voters and has a spend down period of no longer than 5 years and is approved by the state education department um so you'd probably see that in um you know facilities improvements or some other Capital Improvements so just some interesting things there that I thought I would share with the board um the next item coming out of state Ed and the next item on our agenda is the regions approving the changes to the regionalization document

082um I know we spoke about this at our last meeting and said we were going to do this in January uh the changes in the document came down quickly from Albany so we have that document I emailed that out to the board um last week and on that document we saw there were essentially two changes to their rule on regionalization one was that you do not have to participate in the planning process and two was um if you do participate in the planning process and then a plan comes to fruition um then any um amendments to that said docu that said planning document um did they changed the language uh it said that the Bose superintendent would compel their districts to uh make amendments if they were not meeting their goals and now they're going

083to request that they amend that so um the basic Fallout um really nothing new that we haven't discussed at our last meeting is that um we need need to make a decision on whether or not we want to participate in the planning process and we need to notify if we need to notify the Bose superintendent or state Ed probably both by January 15th um so since we've already discussed this and we have all that information uh I think we should make that decision as a board this evening um Terry was also going to check in too I if you have that we just need to write a letter to bosis or if we need a full board resolution um so we can make that decision tonight Terry can write a letter to bosis and if

084you know they say you need a resolution we'll have that resolution included in our first meeting in January so ter do you have any comments that you want to make on that on the um whether or not you know you think we should participate in the um regionalization planning process um if it's there's too many wh ifs and ifs that I'm very uncomfortable I don't see any loss for Cornwall I don't see any one in state ad saying that we can't do things that um our team has talked about like would be very interested in potentially sending our students to Newberg if that was an option rather than all the way out to go um for uh for ctec they're newberg's develop um building a brand new facility if that's an option I don't see

085participating or not um precluding us from doing that or sharing High um hearts of Staff um staff members with neighboring districts so our team doesn't see an urgency to jump on this train while there's so many unanswered uh questions at this time and I would just you know recap some of my comments from the last meeting that you know to me I there's the planning process and then there's the plan and then there's the Amendments and the uh updates from the board of regions to their to their regulation do not touch on the plan at all so if you participate in the planning process um and um this is from nisba it says regions approved changes on regionalization uh it's got a quote from senior Deputy Commissioner for Education policy Jeffrey Madison uh he said

086the process is voluntary is voluntary quote we will not approve a regionalization plan that does not have the sign off of the local districts that are participating end quote however the regulation doesn't match that so um I think we it would behoove us as a district we've got to follow that resolution uh or the regulation and I wouldn't want to get stuck in a situation um where we're forced to do something that comes out of these plans that we don't want to do and to Terry's Point there's nothing stopping us from cooperating with other districts um in our surrounding area so I think it's a good idea I think it's been rolled out extremely poorly and they have doubled down by making it an even poorer roll out because most districts are just going to

087opt out so uh I open it to any comments or we can just take a a quick poll here to see if we want to um opt out or opt into doing the plan I'm just I have a question on um I'm still not clear if we participate in the planning even though I think you've been told perhaps correct me if I'm wrong that we aren't then Bound by the ultimate implementation of after the Amendments after everything but is that how the how it actually reads or is that just what you're that's not how the regulation reads to me me either that's my problem correct so that's why I am voting my comes in on then are we bound we are bound by what the regulation says not bound by hey you said in the

088December 16th issue of on board that we so I'm a no you know because it's just too unclear yeah other comments so just to clarify because I have the same uh confusion so it's it seems like there's two possibilities we participate and then by participating we are bound by the conclusions of that committee or it doesn't matter if we participate or not we're going to be bound by the conclusions of the committee anyway on this hand if we're only bound because we participate I would agree let's not participate but on the other one I would say if we're going to be bound anyway we may as well have a seat at the table it's just hard to say one way or another without knowing which direction we're actually going in yeah I mean that's what

089a poorly written regulation gets you is this confusion um I would argue that you know they've said they've clearly said you can opt out and you won't be part of the plan if you've opt out um so I don't I'd want to call their bet in uh early and you know not not try and play that game of chicken of well we participate in the process but we don't want to be part of the plan um you know I I think that's just it I don't disagree with your point but I think there's a little bit more risk to that strategy than clearly signaling we don't want to be part of the planning process not to mention the time and effort that Terry and the administration team the document I believe is pretty extensive in

090what it asked for um to to put all that together if we're just spinning our Wheels you know if it's going to lead to somewhere you know spending time is great but if it's just doing it to do it um it seems like a waste of time to me significant amount of time so just to uh I guess offer my opinion and my position it does seem like this is the central question that we and every school district has been asking for six weeks now and there still is there seems to be an answer is that you're not bound if you don't participate or that you can can opt out um but they haven't got any further to clarify and I'm starting to think that this might be the most Clarity we get so for

091that reason I guess I if I have to choose one which I do we do I would say that we just uh opt out and cross our fingers that uh and and if it turns out that's not the case then we we fight that battle when it comes great thank you for that bass yeah I came uh today prepared to you have two motions motion one and motion two I can tell you what the Motions are or I can like go ahead and move I mean uh like I don't know how do you want to go about that I don't know what they're relating to or what they're pertaining to so you're talking about regionalization or not yes okay so I let me State my first motion I have to okay okay I move that

092CCSD Boe that's us votes on a a resolution to opt out of both the New York State Department of Education regionalization and I'm saying both because there's the planning process in the plan we opt out we have a resolution written to opt out of those two things separate things the planning process and the plan itself and to notify nyed by January 15 2025 and every 10 years thereafter there's a deadline which is January 15 to notify I know we wrote a letter but there's kind of opting out uh uh clearly mentioning opting out of both the planning process and the plan otherwise we as a component of posess we are right would be required to participate in Regional conversations and the regional planning process that's my uh first motion and I go further I don't

093know maybe you can put them together but my second motion I'm saying furthermore uh with a resolution while a resolution is needed so we have to do that anyway but that might not be enough this is more like a comment uh it might not be enough I move that CCSD takes legal action against against the New York state of education uh uh State education department uh to further protect our district and join the current article 78 effort of around 20 districts so far they joined in uh in in filing article 78 we can join the article 78 uh between now we still have time till actually January 16 so there are like I know I mean two different things here but uh as you just mentioned Brandon kind of whether we do it or not

094we're going to be bound of it that's why filing article 78 is important I mean I'm following everybody has their inbox like full of emails from everybody I mean too much to read together but reading and reading and reading and yes we wrote a fantastic letter I agree I didn't have any comment on it very nicely written everything but if you uh uh just to say the arrogance those unelected bureaucrats they have up there in U in Albany what was the response Mr heem his David Frank Chief of Staff assistant commissioner replied to you he told you you don't know you basically you don't understand what you're at right these are anamed bureaucrat unelected up there in Albany they're dictating what we need to do and what we do not need to do I urge

095everybody to join the effort by 20 this dist already in that article 78 they're setting traps for us thank you for that thought let's um push that the the notion of the lawsuit aside and let's talk about first whether or not we want to participate and then we can bring that back around to see if there's any support for that um I'll go back to you in a minute Tiffany you've already spoke Christian has his hand so Tiffany uh tonight I'm willing to vote uh no on the planning phase um I'm not willing to vote no on the implementation of the plan because we don't know what the plan is at this juncture and we don't know if we're bound to it or not so I'm just um willing right I mean that's not a

096decision to well there was a motions um so I'm just and I'm also not I'm not in favor of voting on participating the article 78 at this juncture sure thank you for that Christian Ju Just to piggyback quickly on that um because of what our discussion in previous meetings about article 78 I'm also not interested in payb backing because there's already a motion and it can work its way legal process with or without our help and I think the point is it'll be resolved one way the article 78 has been started us joining it doesn't make it any more powerful and since it's been started whatever the outcome is we'll know when it when it's uh resolved however um so the first thing is as I'm in favor of regionalization for two reasons the first

097one is because the greater opportunities for our students and I think it's will I would pursue any conversation that would ging more opportunities and more resources to our students um and I'm willing to engage in that discussion the second one is because what is clearly the state's intent is looking for ways to lower the cost of Education in New York state and I would also on behalf of the people who pay for that which are the members of of our community and the community throughout the state to do be part of any conversation that might lower the cost of Education by sharing resources or pulling resources and I am therefore in favor of that the second thing is that uh commissioner Rosa was in our backyard just last week as reported today in the record

098online our local paper but also in The Journal News in the Hudson Valley she was in Yorktown Heights and just I'll just quote from the article since you quot it from on board that she said it was a result of misinformation disinformation and malformation and the direct quote from her is on regionalization you don't have to be part of it if you don't want to be part of it she said and so I think whatever you think there's pretty clear public statements about you know whether this is binding or not binding and I also think that she is talking about what her the intent of it is is we are looking to create a network of individuals committed to this work and the work she says that she would like school districts to be good

099neighbors by considering ways to share pool knowledge resources and opportunities for students and the and I think that is something that's worthwhile my final point is that it has been a practice not just for years but for decades that superintendents and assistant superintendents in the regions of New York state meet on a regular basis to discuss common issues the only difference about that is that there is no transparency to that and the public doesn't see the nature of those conversations I more in favor of a regional conversation which is you know in the in the disinfectant of sunlight and I think that is a better way to proceed and if we are going to basically not participate in that discussion perhaps we should be consistent and also forbid the administrators of our district from engaging

100in those conversations and meetings with the other administrators in the region in which they do discuss common concerns thank you for that any other comments All right so let's take a we don't have a motion here to vote on um because it wasn't clear to me to opt out that you needed a a motion Terry's going to reach out to the Bose superintendent whether or not we could just do that via uh a letter um or if we need to pass a resolution if we do need to pass a resolution we'll have that on our next agenda um so all in favor of opting out of the planning process if we can just get a hand raise one two three four five six seven um Christian you've St you're in favor of participating yeah yeah

101yeah yeah no and yeah so so we'll leave that to Terry to find out the mechanism for opt out whether that's just a letter to bosis and or state Ed um or if we need to pass a board resolution so I'll leave that on your plate but um just to your comment Christian I think it started a good discussion and I think it's had people thinking about how they can cooperate with other districts I just think it's been rolled out in such a way that um it it leaves a lot to be desired the way that they've rolled it out uh but it has started a good discussion and I welcome Terry you know having continued discussions with other local superintendents um on on ways that our districts can work together um so with that

102I believe that brings us to our second round of uh public comment good evening John hin CCTA president um I'd like to give a shout out to three um members Megan Chila Ashley shebesta and Katherine Kelly um Megan and Ashley are high school English teachers and Katherine is a high school Spanish teacher who just achieved their national board certification um adding to the ranks of the Excellence of our Cornwall Educators so like to give them a shout out tonight Megan sent a beautiful staff email um but just wanted to make sure you guys were aware of that as well and let the community [Applause] know thank you for that John I appreciate that Megan if you could share the relevant part of that with the board that'd be great I'd love to read that so

103um anybody else for public comment all right with that we go to our closing comment ments from board members uh bass I will start with you sure thanks J first just congratulations to the tenure teachers uh tonight they really deserve it and I'm going to be very brief uh I'd like to wish everybody a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year 2025 thank you Carl I just wanted to wish everyone a happy Merry Christmas and uh enjoy your holidays thank you Christian thank you elanora congratulations to the teachers who got tenure to the teachers who reached their uh national board certification and happy holidays to everyone whatever you celebrate thank you brenon ditto Tiffany congratulations to our teachers who've uh a reach reached such amazing Milestones super impressed super proud and glad you're a part

104of our district also there is co special events and the Cornwall youth committee is hosting Story Time Each Day in the town and in the village in the vestibule um and um Bridge Street uh there's some pizza parties some cookies and hot chocolate it's free open to everyone it's all this week please check out the Facebook page um and also on New Year's Eve will be our Junior ball drop at 6 p.m. at Village Square and the regular ball drop both to have fireworks music again all free come support come enjoy yourselves a good time to be had by all merry Christmas happy holidays Happy new year thank you Richard thank you I want to congratulate all our teachers who received tenure tonight heard great things about every single one of them so it was

105just really wonderful to see this happen tonight I also want to thank our student Representatives Ava and Maddie thank you for staying till the very end I don't know if they had anything to say sometimes we ask them at the end but we won't put you on the spot other than that I hope everybody has a great winter break happy holidays Merry Christmas and we'll see you in the new year yeah congratulations um to our tenure recipients that we honor tonight um and happy holidays everybody Merry Christmas Happy Hanukkah uh Happy Festivus if you're going to participate in the area of Grievances and uh I hope everybody you know has a restful a couple weeks off with friends and family if you travel travel safe um and thank you everybody um I am going to

106move to have an executive session right now um to discuss uh matters of inter Municipal cooperation in a recent uh meeting Terry and I had uh can I get a second for that motion we have a second all in favor I I um so just for the audience uh participation here we're going to have a brief executive session uh we are going to come back out from that session and close the meeting officially I do not anticipate that we will have any matters of business or any votes taken after the executive session or any business arising from that okay we're going to go to the faculty room and AC cross for every here thank you e e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.