001e e e sh all right good evening everybody apologize for the delay there our executive session ran a little bit over our time planned uh but here we are uh thank you everybody for attending I'd ask everybody to please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right thank you everybody for joining us here on our monthly Boe business meeting uh for Monday November 18th uh next uh item here is public comments recognition of visitors um the board welcomes comments from the public each person wishing wishing to speak is asked to speak into the microphone identify themselves and respectively limit their comment to three minutes two
002opportunities to speak are available one early in the meeting which would be now uh which be limited to 30 minutes and one at the end of the meeting each speaker May address the board only once at both the opening and closing portions of the agenda uh please remember there will be no cross dialogue between speakers and between members of the board all speakers are to conduct themselves in a civil manner obscene language liel of statements threats of violence statements advocating racial religious racial religious or other forms of prejudice will not be tolerated persons wishing to discuss matters involving individual District Personnel or students should present their comments or concerns to the superintendent during regular business hours uh with that I open the floor we've got a microphone at each table uh please uh share your
003name and go right ahead good evening uh I'm Natalie Ren it's good to see you all again you might remember I came and bothered you just two weeks ago uh just as a a reminder I'm a mom of two in Cornwall um and I am the Cornwall team leader of mothers outfront which is a national Grassroots movement that uh is mobilizing for a livable climate for our kids uh so I gave you a little introduction last time about who we are and what we're trying to achieve and I came with a few of my friends we wanted to just reiterate uh our call to action for the school board U essentially we we want to position ourselves mothers out front as a partner to the district to our community uh we want to empower the
004school board uh to seek green initiatives for our community to include transitioning away from fossil fuels uh so I'm confident that members of the board already agree that transitioning away from uh fossil fuels including diesel school buses transitioning to clean electric buses it it benefits our community in innumerable ways it provides cleaner air to the community by eliminating harmful exhaust it reduces health risks for our children who have developing lungs uh it reduces greenhouse gas emissions which contribute to climate change it increases cost savings over the long term uh from the reduced maintenance costs of electric school buses and it also ensures energy resiliency by providing power to the electric grid during any kind of a power shutdown that we might see so as I had mentioned two weeks ago the Schoolboard I know you're
005aware that the school district does have to begin to move to Electric school buses uh by 2035 we need to have an fully electrified Fleet thanks to the New York State mandate we at mothers outfront we know that this is a very complicated very expensive process and that's why we're supporting a phased approach so um we're not asking to to purchase a whole Fleet of buses and build the infrastructure today we're simply asking that you start the process you gather the information um on how you know the step-by-step guide of of how to go from one bus to two buses and so forth uh and the other requ that we have is is really just to apply for the EPA uh clean School Bus rebate program because the deadline is quickly approaching at January 9
006and with this upcoming change in administration we're not sure if that program is going to uh continue we also want to offer mothers out front can offer some uh like resources of of other agencies that offer free technical assistance can answer questions and can even offer like the step-by-step guide for school districts and in fact you can see a lot of success stories across the state um there are school districts all over the state that have already done this and I'm sure you're already aware of it um but a lot of school districts they've managed to combine funding from EPA with the state funding of Nera and the total grants do offset the costs like The Upfront costs of buses and infrastructure of up to 94% so a lot of the districts haven't seen a
007need to increase taxes at all this is just uh maybe a Time uh sensitive and a little comprehensive work that we have to do and we're we want to help you do that one example of um a recent success is actually just uh just next door in Middletown the school bus company Mid City actually acquired four EV buses they'll also be adding another 10 for 2025 and 26 school year all of this has been funded 100% by grants um I think that's more or less it I'll I'll maybe send over the M to to my friend just a re reiteration we're here to help we really want to be able to share this information with you and thank you for your time thank you hi everyone nice to meet you all my name is Cassandra
008cogill uh I'm a mom of two here in Cornwall uh we are Natalie and I I'm here with Natalie and mother's out front just wanted to kind of update you on the activities that we've been uh doing since she was last year uh we are currently in conversation with the Bus Company West Point tours uh for the district uh to help them identify or to help us identify what steps they've already taken that they're pursuing to meet the state mandate um and so we're really pushing on that front to to better understand where they're at and and to also help them as well um as concerned parents you know we really really uh want to help but that work that we're doing will be much easier if the school district uh helps to work with
009the the bus company on this endeavor so you know we really and myself included worry about the health concerns that come from sending our children and bus drivers out in these diesel buses um it's been proven that gases like nitrogen oxide and Benzene can cause asthma cognitive problems and even cancer even more so for our kids developing lungs so um actually further the air that our kids breathe inside the bus is actually concentrated version of those gases it can be up to 10 times stronger especially at the back than what's actually outside so that's a pretty significant number and of course we also worry about our kids' future generally and climate change every electric school bus on the road saves the equivalent carbon emissions of taking a 100 cars off the road and although the
010B health benefits alone are reason enough to prioritize electrification we recognize the very real concerns around cost and potential impacts to taxpayers so you heard from Natalie that a lot of districts have able to accomplish this without any impact to taxpayers and to be clear although electric electrified buses cost more than diesel upfront over the long term they are cheaper to operate Fuel and maintain over the bus's useful life which has a longer lifespan than diesel by the way schools can see over $100,000 savings so in addition to the EPA in nerta there are other organizations available to help and so as Natalie said you know mother's outfront is really here to help you all make make a plan uh give any information you need get technical assistance uh and train District officials mechanics and
011drivers and a lot of these um services are for free so we can help you find that so most immediately we urge the school board and School District to help push West Point tours to prioritize their application for the grant and as we have less than two months to do so with that deadline being January 9th once again thanks so much uh thank you very much for your comment anybody else for public comment hi um my name is uh Lofton Riser Barnes and I'm also a member of uh mothers out front and I just wanted to close out um today by saying I think all of us um you know we all worry about our children I'm the mom of a child who is um incoming to the Cornwall School District to kindergarten and I
012think a lot about what I can do um for her you know there's so much out there in the world that is scary and you know can potentially harm her and you know it's really difficult and overwhelming sometimes for us as parents to decide what we can and can't control and what we should um and shouldn't try to control in our children's lives to um help them um and you know protect them from harm and to me this is a really easy one you know we the funding is there we've already paid into it in our state and federal taxes into you know what eventually turns into these rebates and programs so it's our money you know and we are um we should be benefiting from it our community should benefit from it our children
013should benefit from it and I you know I think this is one of those no-brainers that we can do this for our kids and it will have a positive impact not just on you know them in the short term as they're riding the school bus but also long term if they stay in the area if we want to build this community and have you know our children and their children stay in the Cornwall area and help build this community the long-term uh repercussions of taking these emissions out of our area are you know huge so um I just wanted to add that as another concerned parent that this to me feels like something we can do and that you know this organization mothers up out front is prepared to help and you know uh make
014it that much easier there's a clear path to do it and steps to be taken um so it's not you know one of those overwhelming things that is difficult for everybody to get behind um so yeah I hope that um that the board and the school district can get behind this and that we can push through and get the um EPA uh application through by uh January 9th because it's coming up soon sorry about my voice my child has picked up the plague as I'm sure many of our children have thank you thank you anybody else good evening uh my name is Kelly Cassie I live on shadowwood Lane I'm here with my husband and my neighbor our road is adjacent to Cornwall High School um I have come to speak to this board on
015many occasions and I'm back again because we want to bring to your attention our concerns openly in terms of the multisport facility project that has been ongoing next to our properties back when the multisport facility was approved the bleachers were cited on the side of the high school somewhere along the line the plan was changed and now the bleachers are cited on our side of the high school property and are being installed 10 feet off of our property line I'm going to let that sink in because I don't think any of you live with a 12200 seat bleacher system 10 feet from your property line now we have been in communication with Mr suland and Mr Dade in terms of the plans to screen our properties from the multiport facility currently all the screening the
01620-year-old trees that screened our properties from the high school property have been cut down the bleachers are now cited 10 ft from our property line and we are very concerned regarding the promise that our property was to be screened with vegetation when there is only 10 ft between the bleachers and our property lines additionally I would like to know what the district's plans are to mitigate the noise from the multiport facility which is now located 10 ft from my property line we live in a neighborhood where there is no noise there were never any football games played when the when any baseball games were played there was no loudspeaker system soccer games the same thing we now are being faced with multiple sport games every weekend or every other weekend in the fall in the
017spring and I would like to know what the plan is to mitigate the environmental impact on our properties additionally I would like to know what the district's plan is in relation to protecting our properties from trespassing and litter every year during the invitational track meet we have people trespassing on our properties and urinating on our properties now we have a 1200 seat bleacher system where all of the fans of all of the sports will be seated with our properties 10 feet away from the bleachers this is a huge impact on the neighborhood next to the high school that sadly has really been ignored throughout the process in terms of the environmental impact this project is going to have on neighboring properties this board was provided with scientific data to show that posos leeches from artificial
018turf fields we all have well drinking water I would like to know what the district's plan is to mitigate for posos leeching from the artificial turf into our drinking Supply and what will be the remediation plan when our wells are spoiled I just just recently learned that this this project is $400,000 under budget so my expectation is that the district would make every effort to provide some attention to the environmental impact that this project is having on our properties especially since the budget is now under $400,000 for this project thank you thank you for your comment good evening my name is Howard cave I have been practicing law in the state of New York for 52 years for 40 of those years I have been a resident of shadowwood Lane which as Kelly has just
019told you is immediately contiguous to the high school property um on the 11th day of April 2005 which is a date I believe long before any of you were members of this board I wrote to the clerk of the Board of Education uh this was two or three days after the inaugural athletic event at what was then the new high school property was a track meet and that day that weekend was uh well I don't want to exaggerate and call it hell but it was particularly disconcerting because as Kelly have just told you and I don't believe she was here at the time uh certainly uh other neighbors who live adjacent to that property line had to deal with several children school children uh who didn't want to go into the building to use the
020bathroom facilities just hopping over a four not even four two or three foot stone wall which is all that divides the shadowwood lane subdivision from the high school property and urinating on their yard so I wrote this letter to the board advising the board and putting the board on notice of what I consider to be a dangerous and defective condition so that if at any time in the future which includes now or next month or next year someone is injured from as the result of there not being an adequate fence between the school district property and our property this board is on notice of that actual notice of that and might be found liable and damages in lawsuit I received a responding letter a few days later from a gentleman by the name of Jeffrey
021Honeywell I doubt if any of you recognize the name but he is an attorney employed by a law firm that the board was then then retained to represent it in legal proceedings and he essentially told me that there was no plan to erect a fence anywhere on the school property between our property line and the school property uh and that we were free to erect one of our own if we chose to now I have walked the property of the school district for years having lived there for the last 40 years and until my dog died last year I was up there quite a bit going into the woods which God forbid May someday become be a genie Woods that's a different issue altogether but I found it ironic that there's a chain link fence
022separating the school property where the ball fields are I mean the baseball field and vacant Woods you've got a 6-ft chaining fence with a couple of spaces in between so you can go from the school property into those woods where the old railroad ride of away is however ironically on the only aspect of the school property that borders on developed residential property which is shadowwood Lane where the only place that I know of with the school property is contiguous to residential property the only thing dividing that residential property from the school property is that same probably 200y old 2 and 1 half to 3T high stone wall so this dovet Tales to what Kelly was just telling you uh it seems to be inconceivable that the school is going to erect this a multisports stadium
023complete with bleachers within 10 feet of Kelly and Joan and Cassie's property I live across the street so I'm not as directly confronted with the noise and the uh Trust tresp passing but it's inconceivable to me that this project will go forward and athletic events will be staged on Friday nights or weekends with hundreds if not a thousand or more people invited to come and there's still nothing separating the school district property from shadowwood Lane but this ancient stone wall so I'm happy to leave a copy of this letter I've got many more uh with the board uh because you may have a hard time finding it in your archives and my my second point and just just simply supplement something that Kelly's already said I am not directly affected by the sounds although I
024do hear them uh and the light and the noise that Kelly is confronted with because she lives directly adjacent to the school district property but I do drink water from a well my well is 240 ft deep and uh I'm very much concerned that the proposal the environmental impact statement that was submitted and that was approved gave this board the discretion at some future date to elect either a Turf natural turf field which was here long before any of us were and which I'm going to assume is not a danger to human life and health or an artificial turf field which is man-made poison and I certainly hope that if this board decides to go forward and has not already made that election or if that election is not completely uh said in stone that
025you strongly consider putting in a turf field yes it's more complicated to maintain but it doesn't kill anybody uh who would I give this to thank you for your comments thank you good evening my name is Brian clar I'm also a resident of uh shadowwood Lane I've been there for 19 years I felt very fortunate when I was able to purchase that home that it suited my needs and that is or what was important to me last house Dead End Road surrounded mostly by trees neighbors not close you can imagine I I value my privacy at that time of course I was aware that the playing fields for the school were directly adjacent to my property now I understood that and I didn't have a problem with that every April we suffered an early morning
026loud uh loud speakers and stuff from my uh track meet not a problem once a year I have uh teams that play literally over this rock wall we're discussing that separates our properties tons of baseballs and footballs and soccer balls that end up in my yard I have no problem with that kids come over the wall and retrieve them you have to expect that that's the price of being where I am and I'm happy being there that's the price of having a nice School District with a nice uh proper proper next to us we want good stuff but this has changed dramatically okay from an occasional loud noise on a on a Saturday uh track meet football practice early in the morning during the summer which generally is very quiet and some kids coming over
027the wall unfortunately to reive Lost balls and the urinate um we can we can accept so so much but this has changed it completely we're going to have bleachers potentially 1,200 people sitting 10 foot from our property we're going to have night games now we're going to have noise the plans were changed although we initially opposed the plan we have to accept what was put through but the bleachers themselves have been changed from the original plans I don't believe there's any voting on that I don't think there's any uh public comment at that time and one last thing um I haven't brought this up personally before but I noticed now we have have Stakes out showing how they're going to do the drainage from the new Fields previously there is an open storm drain for
028lack of a better term in the field on these 100e storms we're having much more frequently than every hundred years those drains back up I have video on two or three different storms where the water is surging up out of the field which runs to my property the way these the school was built the property fields are level higher than my property so they come into my property run down to a lower lower level into the shadowwood it's causing a lot of erosion now again at what point do we say I got to talk to a school and bring some kind of action to stop this erosion these new Stakes that I see put out actually put the outlet pipe there I'm talking about an existing problem that terrible storm the water comes up out
029of the existing drain now we're talking about drains that are going to be installed to my understanding that are going to put the water on the surface above my property I'd like to see that addressed or at least understand what you're doing you know because that was to my knowledge wasn't uh addressed earlier thank you for your time thank you for your comment sir do we have any other takers for public comment good evening all leis sergino resident um pleasure to see every bu thank you for all your hard work um thank you for Designing the stadium the way you did design it and addressing the issues that were addressed uh that may not be realized um I happen to know from facilities meetings and other meetings that uh fences are designed and bleachers were
030taken into consideration on which way are they faced to mitigate the most noise so I would encourage everybody listening to do your own research and due diligence to find the true truth that's out there because it is just research and do it and it's at your fingertips and then um I'll take a second just to thank Harvey suland for all your years I'm going to take a little bit of everybody's Thunder because I know it's coming later but I have to depart but I'm goingon to say thank you for all your years because I know you're retiring this is your last board meeting again I'm going to steal a little bit of everyone's Thunder but that's how the ditto goes um I want to say thank you um for all that you've done because I
031know uh the behind the scenes work that happens the hours that you've put in the budget time hours the evenings the weekends so I know as an ex board member what what what you've done and and and the toil and the education you gave me to to to participate here at this de and just myself I want to say thank you and congratulations on your retirement and good luck in riding a bicycle or going walks and doing whatever you can do between you know seven and five anymore thank you all thank you Lewis any other takers public comment all right thank you everybody for uh that spirited uh comment section um we now move on to the next portion of our agenda which is our student representative reports from meline Lin and AA Rich please
032take it away all right this is the report from the Cornwell elementary school for November as always Cornwall elementary school has been bustling with activity and excitement October ended on a festive note with our PTO hosted pumpkin decorating contest each class showed off their creativity by designing a unique pumpkin the entries were nothing short of spectacular including an Elvis pumpkin ET a cheeseburger a dragon and even an ice cream cone Mr German and Mr trante had the tough task of selecting three winners ultimately awarding first place to Mrs Gleason's class for their beautifully crafted pumpkin depicting our local Black Rock Forest it was a fantastic event that celebrated student imagination and teamwork we kicked off the month of November with Red Ribbon Week we celebrated the event with a series of themed spirit days Under
033The Motto life is a movie film drug free organized by our dedicated school counselor Mrs Perez the week inspired students make positive life choices in a fun and memorable way students expanded their learning beyond the classroom with several educational field trips our fourth graders visited the Purple Heart Museum which offered a meaningful experience that brought history to life our second grade classes along with Mrs gleon and Mrs Connelly's third grade students attended the Army men's basketball education day at West Point the students were thrilled to watch Army's impressive 100 to1 to 48 victory over Mount St Mary's enjoying both the game and the spirit of teamwork and discipline it demonstrated Cornwall Elementary is truly a place where community and creativity Thrive looking ahead we're all eager to enjoy time with our families and the loved
034ones over the Thanksgiving holiday break next is the good news for Co the student council had their first two meetings of the Year each member created a gomi poster that is displayed in the cafeteria so the rest of the student body can learn a little bit about who is representing them before Thanksgiving break the group is planning to visit the kindergarten classes to do a read aloud and a Thanksgiving Day craft they are also beginning to plan the annual product Drive in collaboration with the first grade that will culminate with a stuff the bus event all donations will go to the food bank of the Hudson Valley on Friday November 8th six Marines visited cooh they came in full dress uniform and visited each class to read a story and to take questions it was
035a wonderful way to start Veterans Day weekend the students and staff were thoroughly impressed with their soldiers professionalism and dedication to their country on Wednesday November 13th Co celebrated World kindness day staff and students wore t-shirts and sweatshirts that said something about being kind the purpose of world kindness day is to highlight good deeds in the community F focusing on the positive power and the common thread of kindness which binds us Friday November 22nd is funny hat day at Co the students and staff always have a great time participating in this particular school spirit day each year the hats get get more and more creative thanks to the generosity of an anonymous family Co is planning on providing Thanksgiving meals to several families who are in need the family has been doing donating baskets of
036food since 1993 this holiday season the the sea staff is planning to assist many families with holiday presents this November the first and third grades visited Black Rock the first grade participated in the trail blazing program which is an introduction to the hiking the third grade hiked around the reservoir and collect Ed current weather data that was sorted and analyzed at a later date the second grade had the opportunity to visit the Hudson Highland Museum and learned about Native Americans and how they met their basic needs and now for Willow Avenue Willow Avenue celebrated their annual Hall whoa annual Halloween parade on October 31st students had a wonderful day filled with Halloween activities and had a great time parading outside in their costumes in front of their families and friends the staff joined in the
037fun and dressed up as Snow White and the dwarves on Election Day our second grade students held a schoolwide election second graders campaigned hung posters and set up a voting booth for all students and staff to participate in we dressed in red white and blue to honor our veterans for Veterans Day and our first graders welcomed their special veterans into their classrooms to honor them our PTO held our boys Dragon Dance last Friday boys brought their favorite Dragon for an evening of fun games and laughter for the month of November kindergarten students are having a ball as they learn more about the fall did you ever wonder what it would be to live like a Native American or a pilgrim and sail the sea sorry they are learning about they learn they are learning about
038history and words like tradition celebration and being thankful and grateful we hope everyone has a Happy Thanksgiving and now on to the Middle School the Middle School sa is collecting food for Thanksgiving baskets the counseling Senter is overflowing with items thanks to the generosity of our families and students CCMS students honored veterans this month with a beautiful display of American flags dedicated to a special veteran in their life the flags were proudly in front of the middle school and visited by local vets on Veterans Day and what has become a yearly tradition did you know that CCMS resides on the ancestral homeland of the Muny Lena Bay who were here for thousands of years and are still here on this land in honor of Native American heritage month we will be holding a coin collection
039contest again this year to raise funds for our local tribe the Ramapo Lenape CCMS held its annual e8th grade red carpet night on Friday our eighth grade students hit the town at CCMS dressed to impress many thanks to our PT for an amazing nights of treats dancing and fun okay lastly we have the recap for cchs Halloween at cchs was filled with creativity as students and staff alike doned some amazing costumes ESP specially special shout out goes to Mr Rodriguez whose minion costume was a crowd pleasure bringing a smile to everyone's face in in the spirit of giving back the NHS blood drive was a success with 93 units of blood collected potentially saving 93 lives our school Community truly stepped up to make a difference the cchs student athlete Leadership Council proudly represented our
040school at the section 9 student athlete Leadership Summit held at Mount St Murray college on November 4th during the event our student leaders served as an example for other athletes and held discussions aimed at fostering leadership teamwork and a positive Sports culture in a groundbreaking first for our school cchs was lucky enough to put on Harry Potter and the cursed child for its fall performance this was the first ever High School production of the play in New York state the show was fantastic and left the audience Amazed by the magic on stage this year's multiculture night was spectacular with performance arts art displays and delicious foods from around the world it was a joyful celebration of the incredible diversity that makes our school community so unique it was a night that brought everyone together in
041a shared appreciation for different cultures experiences and traditions our athletes truly shown this month the cross country team raced their way to Victory dominating their section championships and showcasing incredible teamwork and determination on the football field our team clenched the SE the section title in a thrilling game coming back from a 19point deficit in just three minutes and let's not forget our volleyball team who also claimed the SE championship for the 20th year in a row and who could forget about Community lunch with activities like line dancing and GaGa ball becoming more popular there is always something to do and a friend to do it with lunch seems to be op operating more smoothly though complaints about the long lines are still frequent thank you both for that any additional color you'd like to add
042to the high school or leave it leave it stands as as presented great uh well thank you very much uh for your updates uh I will speak for the whole board um uh when we say that we you know we really appreciate this and we're all here uh to provide our students with the best experience possible so um it's always invigorating for board members to hear uh directly from the students uh Mr Schaffner is sick and couldn't make it tonight he specifically wrote me an email and said thank the student representative so um I I will do that now on his behalf uh the standing offer if you have a lot of homework to do please feel free to to make a quiet exit and go take that on uh but you're more uh more
043than open to to stay and and continue to participate if you would prefer to do that so thank you both uh next item on our agenda is a superintendent's update so I will hand it over to Terry so we have some celebrations and uh recognitions I'm going to start with uh Miss arino who's just going to give an update on our Multicultural uh night and um it was a fantastic night but let you add some more details thank you um I hope I have as much fun reading my report as the girls did having theirs um yeah we just wanted to take a moment to thank everyone who was involved in making Multicultural night this past Thursday such a spectacular spectacular truly it was a prek to 12th grade Community event um last year we
044were unable to to support the event because of the lack of volunteerism and it was truly missed however this year we moved the event to the fall and kind of celebrated it more like a holiday family get together kickoff um and it was very much supported with volunteers from our district our PTO and our community it was not an easy task in planning and we've been meeting since the first week of school but the outcome last week made it all worth it we had students staff and families involved to truly represent how beautiful our district really is um each year the event gets better and better the generosity of our families as they proudly share their food and cultures and Heritage is always outstanding some dishes that were shared included French Moroccan Korean Filipino Indian
045Bengali Russian Hungarian Italian Irish nor iian Puerto Rican Brazilian Ecuadorian Syrian Lebanese Parisian Haitian ganese Caribbean American and much much more so if you haven't had dinner yet I'm sure you're now very hungry um what was a standout this year though to us was having so many of our high school students take on representing their own culture creating presentations and demonstrations and making food um students took time out of their day during their Community lunch block to meet with myself and our high our High School staff multiculture Al team for the last for at least two weeks to create wonderful representations of their Heritage so a big thank you to miss fat Miss biasi Mrs Marcato Mrs uni and Mr welli on Multicultural night these students represented and worked with our younger students to make
046it so special and some of the tables included which again was all student driven um map and passport design and facilitation face painting of national flowers Hands-On demonstrations of how to make canoli fall holiday days around the world crocheting national flower keychains henna this was a very popular one um a proper way to twirl spaghetti uh origami and then we had representations from our model un Key Club and more and then we also had our high school students they volunteered to set up they decorated the building beautifully and assisted our wonderful custodians with cleanup um leading up to the event some really cool things organically took place our teachers Incorporated some of um the mindset of the night into their lessons so for example Mrs dinardo's pop culture class created ad campaigns for both Multicultural
047night and we the world day um they had to represent their product in front of a panel of Judges myself included and it was very tough to decide um giving their best pitch the top ads each the top ads for each category were then hung up around the high school to advertise the upcoming events on display in the art gallery were pieces selected from our art classes at the high school that represented students culture and Heritage in addition throughout the main floor of the high school were cultural R pieces from all of our schools um which are our teachers and pto's collaborated on lastly we cannot forget to mention our entertainment because it was spectacular uh we had Miss Neville's Middle School Irish Step dancers in full force additionally high school students Gabe yoa Eli
048shreem Marco balato and Vora big sang and perform John Lennon's imagine high school students Marcel Bato and Dylan Foss performed traditional Filipino music on the violin and guitar and then our brand new High School dance team uh taught the crowd several dances such as the samba salsa and morang and then B bagpiper Brian we never really got his last name sorry Brian um concluded the night and DJ Gabe aka Mr flatten entertained us throughout the evening so if you didn't have the chance hop on to our district Instagram page for pictures and videos that were taken throughout the evening multi cultural night is a night that represents our district for so many reasons the Hands-On Spirit to work together and build something that celebrates what makes each of us so special is incredibly unique and
049truly wonderful and we're very thankful to everyone who was involved and for everyone who came out to celebrate so continuing on um with the celebrations uh I know uh I saw a few around the table taking in um Harry Potter and the curse child great job by Tony rinsky all of our fabulous um actors and actresses uh uh Harry Potter holds a special place in my heart my oldest and I read every single book aloud cover to cover um Aiden's now a junior um so he's past that age now but um I've always been a huge fan it was great to see it come absolutely live on uh stage uh in the realm of Athletics I just wanted to reiterate what um our student rep said about our Sports team's accomplishments because they are no
050small accomplishments uh our volleyball our girls volleyball under coach Molton 20 straight section n that that is just it doesn't happen if you if you're in sports at all there's something absolutely special uh that they're doing with our um with our girls uh so Al they they didn't end the season the way they would like it's still an incredible feat 20 sectional championships in a row and then I have to put an an extra exclamation point on the greatest comeback in football history occurred uh with our uh dragons on Friday um the accounts that I've been given have been any anywhere from you know it was like being in a movie like I was expecting Rudy to come out on shoulders it was just uh phenomenal but I I think we um often forget um
051In the Heat of the Moment um that there's special coaching that goes behind something like that um having been an athlete myself and my dad's a coach there's something special that uh players look to their coach in times like that of you will not give up um but they look to the coach to see if that's actually the belief on that uh sideline So Co coach Arduino and his coaching staff you know that never forget give up um 19 down to Minn you know I'm sorry that's in in other years that's just game over but the boys uh dug deep and and overcame a 19o deficit in four minutes and some change uh to advance so um thank you coach Arduino and your your team and and our players for a special um moment there
052uh moving into our fabulous staff uh Miss Thomas uh is being recognized this evening um earning uh her tenure uh so miss Thomas I'm just going to ask you to stand and wave I know you hate me for that but she's extremely humble and extremely exceptional at at what she does Miss Thomas is a teaching assistant in our 1214 uh classroom at uh Co um she's joined by Miss D um as we affectionally um call her and in these two um staff members in that classroom uh are absolutely phenomenal so if you could just imagine trying to lesson plan and organize and provide instruction for students who have all different uh goals on their IEPs um have different um needs that they're bringing um to school each and every day and Miss Thomas uh greets
053it and takes it on with an absolute smile uh she addresses um discipline with uh humor and and positive support she knows our students in their backgrounds and interests and uses that in her work with them uh during instruction and she uh collaborates exceptionally well with all of the other um adults in that uh classroom so miss Thomas I know I was able to share with you we're blessed to uh have you in this um earning of 10 year is is well well uh deserved so congratulations [Applause] uh and last but uh certainly uh not least um my left and and right hand uh Mr suland just wanted to take advantage of my um report to um just say thank you um I I remember from the time I met you on Zoom um that
054uh you are uh just an absolutely phenomenal um professional um you've become an ex uh a close uh colleague and uh friend um I just wanted to share for those that don't know uh Mr suland um well uh this is the one of the um most important uh positions in uh the district um we take for granted uh audit after audit after audit that comes back with uh nothing uh significant found and uh there's districts all across the country that cannot uh say that and that's because of your uh leadership and then being such a small District to have one individual uh responsible for not only the budget um and uh everything that goes along with the business side of uh the finances but also Transportation Food Service taxes uh facilities all fall under your
055uh leadership I think that's often uh forgotten and not um appreciated um I was trying to think of a quote that um kind of captured uh your selfless uh Service uh to the district Harvey and you know there's uh something we said of uh leaders who uh graciously accept more than their fair share of blame um but um also um receive less than their fair share of credit and that's uh you and your service to to uh the district and we're joined by some of your uh teammates uh some past uh board members uh who I know uh could speak volumes to uh how much you mean to them and um everyone in our in our district so thank you from the bottom of my heart and um I remember being overcome with sadness and
056then quickly happiness that you deserve this next chapter uh in your life so enjoy enjoy the heck out of it [Applause] Megan so for anyone who knows Harvey he is um Beyond professional he is a mentor a friend um he's a colleague that you can depend on and a true gentleman uh he's very funny I know you see this like straight guy sitting here all serious but he's extremely funny um and I and Terry said exactly what Harvey truly is he's incredibly selfless so um right now if somebody could pull the fire alarm he would absolutely be very happy because this is killing him that we're even talking about him right now um I've had the pleasure of working with Harvey since I came to the district many many years ago um he led me
057through a principal ship he's been my partner in this role um and always always has children first so building the budget everyday conversations it's always about the why but not the why to question why it's the why so he could better understand it so you could see the wheels turning on how how do we make this happen because if you're saying this is what we need then this is what we need to do for our kids and Harvey always gets it done so from the bottom of my heart not only as your colleague but as a parent of the district I thank you and the thousands of Children and Families thank you e thank you Terry Brendan you you stole I I was going to say I think I know the answer to this but
058I'll ask if you want to say a few words but I I know the an is already no but no still no the answer is still no but I will just say um it really has been a pleasure working here um perhaps the greatest part of my job that many may not understand is that you you at this level you you are so instrumental and trying to and and making things happen that it's it just makes it fun to come to work every day so thank you you thank you uh for your many dedicated years of service to the district um next item on the agenda is the president's update um Terry got got a jamack update there with a lot of great things happening in the district I think the one thing I'll just
059highlight um is uh one of our primary board goals this year is to uh evaluate whether we want to undertake a strategic planning process uh we have received back rfps for that uh they were reviewed uh by myself and Christine and Terry um we called the large list down to a smaller group uh that met our criteria uh that has now been open to the board to go and review those so want to make sure that we expedite that work and and bring that back to the board here uh in the next month or so uh for a full discussion at the board so uh Christian and Elanor thank you for raising your hand on that if anybody else wants to raise their hand um to review those documents before we discuss as a as
060a whole board please let me know so um that will be it for my update next item of business is the consent agenda use of the consent agenda permits the Board of Education to make more effective use of its time by adopting a single motion to cover those relatively routine matters which are included uh any member of the board wishes to discuss individually a particular piece of business on the consent agenda May so indicate and that item will be considered and voted on separately thus preserving the right of all board members to be heard on any issue uh so we have items two through S um is there anything that people would like to pull from the consent agenda for discussion Christian uh number four uh anybody else okay so then we will take a
061vote on items 2 three and five six and seven uh can I have a motion motion and a second all in favor I I I any opposed any extensions okay so items two three and then five six and seven have passed uh on to item number four can I have a motion so moved and a second second discussion Christian uh so as I told you as I told you before my purpose is to abstain wonderful uh item number four then all in favor I I uh any opposed exstension one abstention from Christian uh thank you very much uh now we will go back on to Old business I knew it in my head it's down on the bottom little piece of the page here uh great so old business uh continuing our discussion from last
062meeting on the board guiding principles and principles and operating uh agreements we had uh discussion about this last time um and we then said we would ask for any recommendations um on specific language to be considered uh to be discussed at this meeting sorry I'm just looking for my paper copy here um so let's open this up for discussion um what's that I have it I have one of them oh it's two-sided thank you uh so would anybody like to make an individual comment or I can comment on a couple of the items that were bought to uh the attention of the board to be email Bass thanks Jim I just uh like to re reiterate what I wrote in an email earlier on uh the third column last statement last bullettin the third column
063I'd like to add to it uh just like one sentence to make it clear as to how the president or the vice president at times uh would uh respond to an inquiry by uh member of the community and and the statement as uh written right now says the board on behalf uh I'm sorry the the the president on behalf of the board uh would respond uh and I'd like to add to that that after consultation with the whole board okay thank you for that um discussion on that piece um I'll just say because I think uh Dr Sher was responding to something that I wrote um I am in support of adding that language okay Tiffany I too am uh in support of adding that language okay anybody else comment I would I would uh
064I'm in support of adding that idea I think that the the Lang this very specific language is important here because there are going to be instances where um the president would respond in more of a boilerplate way and just directing a question maybe to another part of the district and that's not we're not going to require consultation for that so maybe consultation where it deserves you know uh just we 80% of the requests roughly are more in that bucket I wouldn't want to add an extra step that's going to delay very simple responses to the public um I see your hand Christian we will go to you sorry got a paper cut here from the fer um I agree with that sentiment Brendan and I'm and I'm running through my head of how we uh
065do that language because I certainly think it's a worthy um in times where it's warranted to pull the board and and get Communications um when it's a relatively routine matter it's just you know hey thank you for your email please speak to the superintendent um that we don't need to go for the whole board to get approval on that um so I'm wondering how to best capture that uh in the language Christian so I think the concern of the uh people adding language in this is not unique to the current leadership but I think it's been true in previous years as well is that there has been no effort to consult other board members when speaking for the board and there should be at least a bias toward soliciting comment for anything that is not
066urgent and in many things there might not be a comment or an opinion that is it's not a complicated matter and I don't this is not not a criticism of into Quick burnt people was as I said and you've been on the board longer than I but I think you know that to be the case and I think just in a sense having a practice of that would improve whether that is incorporated or not into the to your uh representation or speaking to the media um I think it would build support and I think it would build legitimacy and I think that would behoove would make your would make anyone in your position's life easier um in some aspects yes yes and other aspects no cuz trying to get nine people to agree on wording
067for something can be nearly impossible or or respond to an email in a timely matter as we all know correct um so I will say in my past board experience and I'm sure Brenan will Echo this that there have certainly been instances where in writing Communications the board president has solicited opinions from the board members um it hasn't come up this year it's one of those kind of you know it when you see it um and I will also say um you know if an email comes across to the board um that anybody if they have you know information that they think um should be included in response you know please email myself or the next you know future board president whoever that is um because I'm sure that the president would love to take
068all um of that into consideration so certainly there's um I think any board president would would welcome a board member proactively reaching out directly to them and saying hey I saw this email when you respond I think you should include this um I think that would be well received by any president um so I'm struggling with language here let's maybe put a pin on that one unless somebody has specific language I think we're all kind of in agreement of the concept and we're we're working on language yes I think one of the things we can use as we go through this document is that these are guidelines so I don't I don't believe we created them with the intention of it being um like a hard and fast Rule and I think as a guideline
069it makes sense that after consultation with the board and that we kind of use a reasonable person standard and if in in this instance Jim if you were to move ahead and do something that as a board we felt like you should have consulted us that's on us to provide that feedback so that we can change moving forward and redefine that I think it's really hard to um create a black and white because you don't even know what's yet to come um and so I I would always air on the side of more is better but they're you know we're human you know and so I just I want us to keep in mind that these are guidelines that they were they were not drafted intending to be bylaws or or um rules you know
070so yeah I think that's a good overall point that these certainly are meant to sit somewhere occupying less of a space obviously than state law and that our own policies which have been voted and ratified on um you know they sit under those as more of just general rules of thumb which don't necessarily apply 100% of the time Christian so building on Christine's Point um there is a board policy about uh the role of the um board leadership and relationships in news media um I I'm going to embrace the idea of guidelines being non-binding but that if people want to improve the language in a binding way um the policy committee could take that up and change the language on there and I think that would be the best way forward if we want to
071let's say create something that's more binding or more specific I think that's a great idea for discussion um at the policy committee level um um do we extend that policy really the case where it comes up is an email is received from the public which is not the media but it is a public obviously there's a reason to not have nine different people write nine different responses to somebody um because that's an unworkable situation so um if the policy committee could work on some language that would clarify that because that's always been a question as long as I've been on the board um of what the best way to handle that is so codifying that as a policy I I think would be helpful yeah I agree wait one more Comon yeah the the email
072that Christian wrote that matter really was a really nice email I mean and I mentioned that in uh when I emailed everybody he he researched everything I mean his whole uh argument was really valid uh I would say that when you have uh guidelines like this and I mentioned this I'm just reiterating here for the public um it is a nice uh document to have uh it's say like two pager literally two pager uh nice to have in parallel with the policies not on top not Below in par with the policies and because of that uh we have to be very careful not to have any contradicting statement like somebody and I said any reader not us on the board but any outside Outsider uh member of the community who read and find discrepancy between
073the guideline and the policies that's not a good thing thing that's bad thing so I would say maybe we have to the policy you mentioned Jim maybe the policy committee would have to look at uh these guidelines and make sure 100% sure that nothing in them contradict any of our existing policies thank you bass um and just to add a little more color for the public on this and where this document came out of and I believe I stated this last meeting and forgive me if I'm repeating myself but um where this document really came out of was based out of our board DET treat in the summer um and we had a facilitator who himself was a former uh superintendent of a school district Upstate and you know we just kind of said hey
074what's a good way um a to improve working relationships between all board members so we can focus on you know the important issues affecting us and not uh waste our time with with sight issues um and B you know um we've got a lot of new members especially on this board but there's always new board members coming on as we deal with new board members what's an easy way to be like hey here's how you know our board typically functions um and the facilitator um pulled up his document and said hey this was agreed upon between myself and my board early in my tenure and it survived 12 13 years whatever the the time was and it served them well as a board so that's sort of where the Genesis of this idea came from
075just to add more color um for the community so um so so let's come back and maybe revisit that point other um points that we want to revisit that we want to talk about language um I know Christian if you want to take the floor and and sort of give some of the points that you shared in your email to us or if you want to just leave that where it is as probably suggested by the length of the email I have a lot to say on this but um I'm willing to wait because there's other people um but taking taking a lead on the language on the the third column last point or we're talking about what's going forward to the policy committee I'm just I'm I'm just clarifying that before anything else I'm
076sorry can you repeat the question you said you said if you want to take the lead on something and it wasn't clear what you wanted them to no I meant a more of just a general comment because I would imagine that you have one uh prepared leaving this specific point the whole thing leaving this specific point and talking about the whole document in general I wanted I wanted to give you the floor if you wanted to take it um to share your thoughts sure um and this is what I said at the board retreat and I said that I'm just not in support in this not because I'm in support not in support of decorum or uh speaking but um there are many things on this that I think are because we know some of
077the details personal Act this is not an operational guidelines this is a a bunch of things thrown together that we all know responsive to individual situations or things that people think some other people have done and that doesn't seem to be very reactive and so as a result I'm not really supportive that because my feeling is that um there's a very simple way to address this which is as I said Rober Rules of Order open meetings law and just on the general sphere of this is that I've been on the board for a year and a half and in that year and a half there have been two brought up of legal let's say actions against board members by other board members and neither one involved me efforts to REM uh stated efforts to perhaps
078remove board members and all of this doesn't really address that and there are other things that have gone on and so when those things happen uh that's my concern about you know playing nice in public and then doing other things outside when the the lights are off and I got a lesson in this when I was an intern for the Buffalo News in Washington DC and watching how politicians behaved when the cameras were on and then what they did when the cameras went off and being on the what was called at the time the off the Record club which was Republican house members who would talk to the press off the Record and they would be completely different than the news conference that happened before and after and I'm not saying this as a political
079point that was just happen to be what it was um I'm sure the Democrats had their own version of it at the time so those are more the thing is that there are differences of opinion and there differen of opinion on different on different things and that's why Robert's Rules of orders exist to allow everyone to have the same access to speak to have a certain Rules of Order that allow everyone to not worry about having to fight for the microphone because they know they'll be recognized in a certain way and op meting law and uh you asked me the email to itemize that if you want me to do that here I can or I can just write you my feeling that I don't think they were I don't think these have been they
080have been consistently applied and I think that's would be a much easier solution to getting to the outcome that people want there are also things that I'm concerned about let me just take three things and announce them and to keep me from going long if I'll do one and if other people want to talk I'll come back to the other two just to the first one is in the um the guiding principles and the two I want to address is students first and consensus vers majority and I'll just repeat what I said about consensus vers majority consensus has no operational meaning outside of majority and when it's different it's basically ruled by minority because it's basically saying if I can withhold certain votes well geez well then there's never going to be consensus and that
081allows a minority to act as a veto power and that's a big concern about how a board is run and that's why Robert Jes of Voters basically say the majority carries the motion and we don't need to do other things I've described what the voting pattern has been I don't think I need to state that I mean anyone can review the the videos to see what happened um but if people withhold it allows people to basically have a rule a minoritarian system which I think is far inferior so here's the thing about consensus consensus takes time and there have been at least three instances this year where the request has been for more time to review something to delay a vote a couple of days or to a next meeting and in all those cases
082where people had the ability to do that that is not what happened and that's just to me a lack of commitment to consensus by people who are advocating consensus and the point about it is actions speak louder than words whether on paper or spoken and so my point is that I'm not sure this makes a difference unless we're actually going to commit to doing consensus which means doing the work combined with let's say efforts uswhere in this that are basically pushing towards brevity um the point purpose of the meeting is to basically have a think out loud where the public can view not just the decisions but the rationals for the decisions and those decisions should happen as much as possible in the public View and the point is when you were talking about shorting
083the meeting or limiting members time or having decisions be more in the agency and bureaucracy as opposed to in the open meeting that's concerning um because that means that we are not doing that time or we're not letting the public see the consensus being um formed and I realized anyone who's been on the board realized how awkward it is to think out loud in front of cameras and Christina just your action I think you understand what I mean by that and it's awkward and means sometimes we're talking in circut this language because we are trying to we are not supposed to pre-co coordinate before the meeting because the public gets a chance to observe our meeting and that's the way I think it should be and I could go on about why that's important but
084if you want I'll give you the citations the other one about students first is that sure before you go could we is it okay if we kind of stop and like reflect okay I just want to so I what's I what how do I I want to Thinking Out Loud um I think the point you're making actually reinforces this bullet point we may or may not have always been good practice but we're striving for building consensus and if as a board at some point in time we're not allowing the time for that that's where we come back to this and say Hey listen this is one of our our our guiding principles we want to strive for consensus and I don't think we're allowing the time for that let's let's um hold ourselves accountable to
085this so I don't know that it we're in dis I don't not we I don't know that your point is in disagreement with this as much as it might be we haven't necessarily from your perspective had a good practice of it and we need it's your prerogative to raise that as we move forward if you feel like we're not doing a good job of it does anybody else have a comment on that point Brendan I I I agree with that and I think that that's the best evidence that we need this is that we've fallen short um and I think it also kind of goes against one of your other points which I understand where you're saying that some of this seems like it's tailored towards specific people um I empathize with you on that
086but I also think that this point it runs counter to that that this Cuts both ways so I don't think these are surgically designed to you know put anybody in a box I think it it is a good faith effort to improve how we operate anybody else comment on that point I I guess i' I'd like to add two things one I I kind of agree with kind of agree I do agree with Christine and Brendan's um overall point I just want to address the point you made about um you know saying consensus rather than majority um I mean at the end of the day majority rule is the vote if you get five votes it passes um so I think it's just an they're certainly not proposing a change to the voting procedure and
087your concern is noted there of you know if we wanted to do you know if you really wanted that why not change the threshold to six or seven votes I mean I think there is a reason that it's five votes and we all agree with that um and there are going to be times when there are going to be five to four votes um it happens I I think the the goal the thrust the thought process behind that is just to say let's have the discussion in public exactly to your point which I wholly agree with of we're supposed to have these discussions in public this is a public meeting where we're supposed to have the back and forth so the public understands the rationale of how the board has arrived at a meeting or
088arrived at a decision um and you're not just supposed to come in and um you know coordinate ahead of time and vote on things there's a reason we have consent to items which we you know are kind of we assume are are going to pass and then we have different items for discussion and we put that separately in the agenda so I agree wholeheartedly with that um so I I just don't I think this rule is is a little bit of a different um a rule guideline I should say a little bit of a different thrust than you apply there and one thing I just wanted to um you had talked about a proposal to make more decisions in B in buau Ry versus an open meeting did I hear that right because I'm not
089sure what you mean by that so my third point was about the First Column of the guidelines which mostly are about the relationship of the board to the superintendent just by uh if you have them in front of you uh we have policies for that there's a whole section of our policies that deals with that uh these guidelines are not in all manner consistent with some of those policies I would also add that most districts have not only the policies that we have but more polic policies governing in this area and I would be happy to suggest those policies that many of our peer districts have adopted but the point about it is this should not be in the guidelines this is governed by policies and it should be done through the policy process and
090the point about it is when you state for example that there is this line between dayto day and whatever is the opposite of that or whatever is excluded by that that that is basically been an expanding category and um including to the level of the district goals and I think that that leaves very little that means most decisions are being made for example inside that are not public because they are occurring or getting referred to I can give some examp specific examples but I don't want to litigate individual issues I'm just saying if you'd like me to talk about how decisions get made within the agency meaning the administration and how decisions that are made in this meeting at this level so my point about it is I gave a link to discussion of principal
091agent and bureaucratic agencies there was 10 pages if you'd like to read it it summarizes a voluminous research on this and why these are concerns and issues um and anyone as someone who spent 7 years of my life studying nonpartisan commissions around the world okay in particularly interviewing people for police agencies and Public Safety commissions and school boards and things of that for the purposes of a dissertation um doesn't mean I have the right answers on this but I know the terrain fairly well thank you uh for that clarification I I guess I'll kind of respond and I think perhaps Brendan made the point earlier um said kind of to me you're almost making the case to have these um because you can come back and say hey um you know this isn't a day-to-day
092decision and this was decided by the administration and should have been debated in public by the board Bo um to me that's kind of the point of these is we can say um we should have more open debate um I think that falls outside of this point I to be clear um Christine and I came up with this document Christine did a lot of the heavy lifting really we took a lot of nispa has a sample document and we took points from other districts that have this so it wasn't like we created this out of whole cloth we used um a lot of a lot of language uh with some minor tweaks here and there that's existence on the nispa document um as well as other districts so um you may in just one second
093I think I had one I think I had one more Point um yeah and sorry just when talking about data when when when um when I see day-to-day operations um to me that makes me think of you know the very clearly legally defined board members cannot give um instructions or directives to School Employees whether that be uh heads of departments principes teachers and on and on down the line that's for the administration to do um so that's the way that I take this um I think that you might be taking that language differently but that's the way that I read this language Christine has a point and then we'll we'll go back to you I'm sorry I don't mean to rush you I grew up at a table where if you paused for you know
094two extra seconds someone was going to start talking um so if any of these are in conflict with the policy we should certainly um flush that out because that is not the intention um this was intended to maybe just put it in layman's terms you know when we first came on the board we had lots of conversations about what does this really mean you know the legal definition versus day-to-day and so um by all means this is just I think meant to reinforce the policies that exist in layman's terms so I please you know um we can talk offline we can go through email but if there's any conflict in that that is not uh the intention at all Christian so um here's the thing day-to-day is not defined but would be for example adopting
095a drop rotation schedule be something that a board decides on or is that day today those of us who are on the board last year know how the different opinions on that and the question is I think that something that is a board decision um other people had a different opinion on that that is not defined and putting that into this language presumes that there is a clear line there other districts have defined where that line is and what is operational or chain of command another term that is often used that is implied by one policy but is not really used in that language and it's been an expanding concept to basically put ownership or decision-making power over certain decisions which arguably could be made at different levels this contestable issue I would say go
096through the policy process and Define those if that people want to put that it doesn't have to be specific it doesn't have to be comprehensive but it should be anchored in something and it has not been anchored and I think that has led to divisions on how decisions are made and what information should be allow provided because there are other things here about limiting board members contacts or getting information from members of the community Etc I don't think anyone's thinking I don't think anyone has ordered or given a directive to a staff member as far as I know maybe someone else has but uh the the STA to a staff member of what to do or anything of that sort but that's not what we're that's not where the issue is about the line and
097I think thankfully we haven't I haven't seen it in my time on this board in this District but I can guarantee you it has happened in other districts in this state yeah yeah um that's fair so I what I would love to see if you seem to have specific policies in mind um fleshing out some of those responsibilities you're on the policy committee I'm on the policy yeah I am on the policy committee I think it would be great for you to bring those you know some example policies to the policy committee that you know as we know uh updating policy adding policy is is never ending work so if you have some suggestions and say hey hear some great language from another District uh I would bring it to that level and I do
098and I will yeah um I and I think my you know there's always gray areas in any of this um so again these are General guidelines rules of thumb and as long as I've been at this there's no there's too many situations that we come across that are not black and white um and their shades are gray and we're constantly navigating them so um did you have uh would anybody else like to talk about this point specifically this bullet point okay and Christian I think you had one more point or two more points I think it it was melded two into one so I think that I mean there are more details but I think my points were made great thank you Jim if I may just just to fill one last thing just about
099this this line so for example I think the district goals are clearly within the board's purview that would be something because these are the there there are our decisions about where the district priority should be and where our focus should be and I think that is that's fairly clear the especially because they are used to evaluate the superintendent I think that that means that we should set those criteria and secondly just because this came up sorry can I just to clarify to clarify because you said District goals um this year we have passed board goals and superintendent goals there is nowhere in our policies and it's very clear that there are district goals as they are in other policies in other districts and including in our own language in our policy documents so my point
100of view but that's something that we can review and if you'd like I will give the details where I think that is language and if you can find the language superintendent goals in our policies anywhere I would be very surprised because I have looked dist goals mad um so I'm and they were referred to as super as District goals prior to the current superintendent and you can go back and find them just for just for the record I'm clueless about when I changed language for goals but I'm I'm I'm open to that meeting where I did such but I I just do goals and get them approved by the board so so I I'm sorry I'm I understand the point that you're making I'm I'm not making the connection to this document so the point
101about it is that is something that you were talking about the line between what is day-to-day and what is let's say strategic or policy or Direction the other thing about it is for example the creation of board committees which you you invoked I think 2410 that the that the superintendent can identify who's affected by that board committees are only advisory or investigatory they can't take actions by themselves only the full board can or a majority of the board can which means that we right now we had a curriculum committee where five people expressed interest and we've been waiting we're now going onto the fourth month for board leadership to decide whether that committee and there was one response that is being counted as interest where the person said I don't really want to be on
102this committee but I had to select it to end the survey and that does not strike me and I'm paraphrasing but we can all look up the specific language that basically that's allowing one person to basically hold up the creation of a committee so this is where I come back to operating guidelines if I can be candid if that is a concern or that is something we need to discuss as a board I would encourage you to send that email ahead of time Christian so we can put it on the agenda or we can talk about it because that's not directly related to this document and and if as you're talking I'm like wow we haven't done that okay we got to look at that like you're not necessarily off base but but give us
103an opportunity or at least me to think about it I'm not even speaking for Jim but it's not necessarily related to this document so it feels like you're taking an opportunity to like slip it in if I'm being really candid and I just in the future for me if there's a concern about something that's not operating the way you think it should raise that in and of itself please so there was an issue where something was asked to be put on the agenda and was not and it was done in time and pertinent information was supposedly the reason why it wasn't put on the agenda but on tonight we're talking about this Coalition of Schoolboard members thing and I don't remember any information being collected to put that onto the agenda in a much shorter
104period of time so there seems to be okay but people have done that and that has not happened and then the last in the first issue you're talking about Christian there was a reply to you that said we will put it on a future agenda it wasn't ignored In fairness so can we move the current issue on this agenda to a future agenda because per information has not been collected or provided to board members in order to make a decision what what issue is it I'm sorry I I just dismissed it I'm sorry sorry I thought I turned it on I turned it off but it's kind of evolved but everyone H I don't know about that yeah I I again I don't understand what that has to do with this document um so I'm
105not expecting people necessar to agree I'm just stating my opinion and I respect the fact that you have a differing point of view okay um so we'll move on then for other we'll solicit other comments um I Know Tiffany you had language if you want to um talk about that part of the document I have one uh suggested change I brought it up at the last meeting um I did s uh email the language that I proposed I don't have the paper in front of me but I believe it was the middle column and it is the one two three fourth bullet point down it currently reads be respectful of each other's time by being brief and to the point in your comments and hearing to reasonable time constraints and avoiding the repetition of comments
106already made by other board members um I think um this point is um has good timing as I sit here today um my I suggest we change it to be respectful to each other be succinct in our comments not to exceed five minutes and avoiding the repetition of comments already made by other board members unless appropriate and germine uh thank you Tiffany uh comments on this point Elanor I I believe I had sent an email about that as well the time um what does that look like is someone going to be sitting there with a stopwatch to check the time sometimes a point has to go a little bit further because you're explaining something I I understand you know the keeping it short and to the point I completely understand that but it doesn't always
107work that way sometimes it it does take a little bit longer to make your point or to give the information that you're giving I was just wondering what that what would that look like are is is there a timekeeper you know well Eleanor if I may since you're responding to my comment we don't have a timekeeper for public comment there were people that went over 3 Minutes tonight and nobody stopped them um um so to to to answer your question I think it goes back to this is a guideline it's not a bylaw there's not a timekeeper sitting there going oh time's up but it's a guideline like everything else um that was pointed out tonight I think as we talk further it just shows and proves the point supporting it yeah I think uh
108Tiffany's suggestion is uh has a lot of Merit I mean the point is here is is not like to take it literally like with a stopwatch and with and a guard and it's just like the expectation like I know when I come to this meeting and I'm given the microphone I'm not going to give kind of like a uh dissertation I me just like be as brief as possible that's our point Thank You bass Christine I think the guidelin says that I I I I would not be in favor of putting a um a minute into it I think that again if if if we are dragging it out if we're talking too much we just need to respectfully hold each other accountable I I right we can do a better job of that that's
109the point of this right we could we could do a better job of that I I would hesitate to put such a finite limit on any of these points for that very reason I understand and I would recommend the change even if it excluded the five minutes I would still recommend the remainder of the change um again being appropriate and gerine and succinct I agree with Christine that was the point I was trying to make I I obviously know someone's not going to sit here with the clock and and time you that was what I was trying to say thank you Christine thank you Elanor did you write down the other oh you sent it an email we have it via email yes um there are certainly boards that have a timer and a clock
110and do it and we don't do it that way um I'm glad we don't I don't want to sit there and manage a clock but but uh yeah so I I will agree with Christine's comment I'm I'm against putting a specific uh number time limit there anybody else comment on that one okay um I don't think via email we had any other specific um comments there um as far as language um I just got Christian and and Tiffany I'm responding to that um so we've got a couple notes here to look at a couple of the different points um so I'm going to suggest at this point we had it on here to take a vote if we got to that point I think we should reward a couple of these redistribute via email uh
111and put this on a future agenda um so we can wrap that discussion up for this evening um next item on our agenda is Village of cooh water exemption resolution um bass I see you there I'm gonna I'm G to preempt you um and um mayor gallano wrote an email to myself as well as supervisor wowski on Friday asking for uh a meeting to discuss um some creative ways to um talk about water funding um and what what that means uh supervisor will jski uh replied right before this meeting at 6:44 that he is open uh to a tripartate meeting between the school district um the town and the Village um and he said the town will hold off acting on the tax exemption request at their next meeting um until that meeting can be
112arranged probably next month so I'm going to recommend that we um that Terry and I go have and legal counsel if necessary go to that meeting uh between the village and the town and the school board and report back to the board and we take um action at that time so Christian so are you moving to remove this item from the agenda for tonight or postpone it to that I am moving to yeah table this issue uh to remove it from tonight's agenda and um update the board with future uh information and I forward uh the mayor's email to the to the rest of the board to see his his meeting proposal so before you do that may just make a comment I I am not in favor of having meetings that out of the
113public view that involve the public um the supervisor uh the mayor are fully capable of making a presentation making public comment to us about their issues so the public can view and see their arguments I'm not sure what advantage of doing this in a meeting where the public is not there or not able to observe um I would prefer one that that was open but that is a decision for the board but I will also move to remove it from the agenda and if you'd like to proceed uh someone to second that motion um thank you for that comment and I I uh certainly appreciate the sentiment and I will um this was not our request it's not the way that I would do it but uh any decisions will be deliberated and you know
114and made in the public view no decisions will be made at that meeting it will simply be information sharing um so we have a motion can I make a suggestion just to address Christian's point I mean if they're after that meeting if it makes sense for the mayor to provide a presentation he still could absolutely so I I don't think it's one or the other we we will certainly if appropriate invite him to come and speak at our meeting yes thank you um so we have a motion to remove before can yeah bass yeah sorry yeah I uh my my position was to to to table it for tonight is not ready for a vote and uh can if you mentioned the same thing um my my point here was that to to to give
115the mayor the chance to address the whole board I mean I know he's been in in touch with the superintendent he's been in touch with you as a president of the board but again I'd like the mayor to to to address the whole board uh to make his point I mean uh is it fair to give him the extension is it not yeah I I I'd like to know that personally and you know it's going to come to to to to to to to the dollar figure we're talking about like if we Grant the the the exemption uh versus if we don't Grant the exemption right I mean you know the dollar per gallon cost you know if we don't give them the exemption is going to go up well how much up if we
116grant them the ex the you know uh the exemption then the school have to get that money somehow therefore they increase the I mean the school taxes again by how much I mean we have to kind of you know uh compare apples to apples uh but like to see like all I'm seeing here now the the the the school basically the administration because we haven't made decisions the board yet is arguing for uh denying the exception right I mean they they give very good points I mean I I read the points I understand what I read and then from the other side again I mean you know the village asking for the exemption again they're making good points I see those points I understand them so so I'd like to see Apples to Apples comparison
117uh and daughters thank you um when we come to decision point we'll we'll certainly keep that in mind so um we have a motion to remove uh new business non-consent agenda item number one Village of CH water exemption resolution we have a motion to remove that can I have a second Elanor seconds that all in favor of removing this from our current agenda I any opposed any extensions okay great thank you um next item on our agenda and the last item before recognition of visitors is a discussion of the New York State education regionalization program discussion um so for those in the audience who don't know um there's currently um an emergency rule proposed by nid um to their calling it a regionalization uh initiative and it is to have essentially Bose's um local bosis
118throughout the state coordinate um and Foster cooperation between their component school districts um there have been many school districts throughout the state who have uh written letters to nid saying that parts of this regulation are ill conceived um we've been getting emails uh as board members from a group uh calling themselves the Coalition of Schoolboard members I believe which is a group based out of Long Island yeah do I have their print out I don't know um I have it I have it here Coalition of New York state school board members Coalition of New York State Schoolboard members um I also saw a recent um article in lwh Hood talking about the lwh hood.com talking about the lower Hudson County Council of school superintendents um and it referenced a letter that they wrote tonight said
119dated October 23rd uh I reached out to the lower Hudson Council school superintendent and just asked for a copy of that letter um which I then forwarded on um after I received it um to the rest of the board members so um I know board members have have had their email filled with um emails from this Coalition of of New York school board members um and um um we we've got the information from the lowood Council of school superintendant I guess I would just like to ask um a few questions from a couple folks before we open the discussion um number one Terry um I know the first step here has just been you said giving information that's publicly available but what has the discussion been uh the lower Hudson school superintendant so mainly mainly
120folks down in Westchester and Rockland have signed off uh have written a letter AOS osing this initiative um would love to get your thoughts on what this could possibly mean for our district and what Orange County Superintendent have been discussing yeah uh for us uh stated really simply uh both SE component districts are supposed to be collaborating with one another sharing resources things of that nature so at at surface level this sounds like nothing new um our concern as a collective is um we do that on our own and we're worried about a Thou shalt so our is there a shifting of funding is there a shifting of resources that we have no control over would be a concern for us here in Cornwall and any of the other uh component districts so um we
121just haven't been given a clear picture of why what does this uh really mean so until we get those answers uh we remain uh concerned with this coming down from the state thank you um and Christian uh you went to the Orange County school board's uh association meeting uh last week I believe um where this was discussed and they sent a handout which you nicely shared with the rest of us on the board so if you could just give us a brief um your impressions of that um conversation at the oxa meeting please so um there was a presentation by believe and I do not remember the name but I believe was an assistant superintendent of UB bosis but I might be wrong about that um who basically made a short presentation about this based
122on the emails that we have all been getting over the last probably three or four weeks um and most of that presentation was it's not this which means it's not consolidation it's not necessarily tied to Foundation Aid this is mostly about starting a conversation between people who are in the same region of the state and the first step to that is sharing information most of which is already publicly available to anyone who'd like to look it up on like for example the New York state report card I'm sure there were some other asks that maybe aren't there but that was majority of it and I think Mr Dade you said that's what your experience was when the request was made of you I don't know if there's any slippage between those two um I think
123the general feeling about the school board members who were there um who don't necess represent everyone because I think if you're going to an oxfo meeting you were probably more in the idea of collaboration with other school districts than perhaps the modal School Board member so I I don't think this rep reflects all of our um neighbor districts but I think that people felt that the state had done a very poor job explaining this um it was a bad choice of language um and if that's what it was then um then you know you could have done this a lot better their response was the name is already out there so changing the name of this point would make people only think it was something else and the rebranding so to say look yes it's
124a bad name but uh that's the name we thought you know and it doesn't change what's under underneath it um what I said is that you spend most of your time telling us what it's not and when you present something as it's not this it's not this it's not this um you're basically defining it by neg a negative and what if you want to push this forward in a productive way you should have concrete examples of how districts collaborate um or what is a positive thing that came out and that turned the discussion to various different school board members talking about things that they have done that might be part of this so let me just give you a sampling of that so Greenwood Lake mentioned that for example they are too small to have
125a football team so they have an agreement with chester to have their students sent students can compete on the Chester team now that might mean that some Chester players lose out because well if Greenwood player Greenwood Lake player is starting that means probably someone from Chester got cut or is a backup or something with that sense but that is something where they would work together to provide a greater opportunity a second thing was about foreign languages which means that on the district scale it's very hard to offer uh I want to call this but let's say the foreign language is offered probably in every district is Spanish and some districts it's only Spanish um other districts offer Chinese Arabic Japanese um I myself am a certified Japanese language teacher um it will never there I
126can tell you how many districts actually offer it it's a very small amount because you don't have scale at the district level but you could probably have scale and it is an important skill um that probably could be done at a shared level um particularly if a teacher is in one place and students have a passion and that's a job skill a third was uh one thing we've heard very often in Cornwall is about the lack of space for example a ubk classroom but if we there maybe for example where districts border each other other where one has the allocation from State funding for upk and another district has space that could be another source of collaboration to improve the opportunities that are available to students so the idea is that at scale there be
127more opportunities for students I would add and this wasn't in the discussion but we have very different sized school um schools in throughout the county we have schools as large as Middletown Monro Woodbury and Newberg and we have schools as small as The sewart Institute in Florida and in any given district there are probably students just like when people choose colleges some people like Ohio state with several tens of thousands of students and others like a small you know maybe what you might call liberal arts college but they don't get a choice about that because they all have to go to the one or two high schools that you have in the district and providing more opportunities where you can match a student to the the might scale of the environment might be something that
128better serves certain students on what I would say in our model is that we we have the home district and we have bosis and bosis is a catch all for everything that doesn't happen in the district and there might be some models or opportunities for a limited number of students to go somewhere else so these are the point is in that the last thing so that was a discussion and I think that people generally were skeptical about the Coalition the people that were there but then again as I said I think they see this as a group of districts that have been pushing NB resolutions that have been proposed not recommended and voted down repeatedly but resolutions you mean this legisl resolutions resolutions like no I don't need examples I just nisba resol there had
129nisba resolutions for example about returning to home rule um uh local or county level governance and things of that sort these are the same districts who started this they're the same districts who have been pushing it and the leadership of it and people basically had an attitude like they're doing it again and I think it's because they got the local rule was voted down at the nisba meeting and that's kind of when these emails got started and that was people's intuition about what might be happening thank you for that recap that's very helpful um information so um typically I like to get everybody else's thoughts but I did a little homework so I just want to say a few things um and then we'll discuss so I I don't want to speak for everybody I
130think a lot of those examples that you gave to me seem like great things um what concern concerns me overall about this is in the language so even in um you you gave the orange os's handout uh number eight what if my school district does not have an activity listed in the final plan will schools be forced to implement other activities in their region and or educate out of District students uh there's four bullets no schools will be identified against their Wills to participate in particular activities no district will be required to commit local resources without their consent um so that's what what nispa is saying um in uh we get a weekly email from I think it's the director uh Robert Schneider of of nispa I don't know his exact title forgive me if
131I forgot that wrong director executive director I gave him a downgrade sorry um and in sort of the bottom of the email said hey there's an infographic that nispa has put out about R regionalization um and this is dated November 6th from the from the uh State Ed um not this n from the ND website um school districts are only required to implement activities they've agreed on or consented to in their local context of the final plan uh but what they hide in the bottom here is we are reviewing the regulations language and considering modifications based on how it is being interpreted in the field um so they know that there's questions about this and I agree with the questions that I have seen um to me the plain language of the regulation does not
132agree with people saying you won't be forced to do anything it doesn't address it one way or the other um so I've got a couple highlights here if I could just I'll give me a moment here to find the pertinent part but um Jim if I could just intera to on that so in my my Council meetings both in Westchester and in Orange County and Christian I think maybe it was Tom bonjovi he's the district superintendent he may have presented um he spoke with us a bit at length with this as well I think one of what you what everyone else is saying I think you're correct about that that name sounds familiar what everyone else is saying 100% uh some of the major concerns are the funding piece to it um but the final
133plan so what is the final plan and who has saying the final plan so um Mr bonjovi came and he said that um he as the district superintendent will be responsible for submitting the final plan for the county basically to the state at its conclusion and that's what the final plan will be so we said we would like to maybe have some workshops instead of having traditional Council meetings let's Workshop it and and work as you know counterparts within the county what are we sharing already bis did share as well as what was said here is that's basically their job so if we need whatever Spanish teacher right can we share that that's basically what their purpose is in the process generally so we have um suggested to um bosis and it was very well
134received by Mr B joy that we would use the next two sessions as workshops once he gets the rubric which he doesn't have yet to try to fill those buckets so we have a voice in what the final project product is before it's handed back to us that this is now a cormal needs to do this is now a Chester needs to do Middletown so on and so forth um I think that's great um and I think that is the intention that they're stating um however I think that that is not not addressed in the language of the regulation which is what is going to be put in law as they're doing emergency regulation so I think that's the Crux of the issue and that's the real disconnect um because if I can just read
135a couple parts here um so it says the department and district superintendent and and in terms of this regulation the district and superintendent is identified as the Bosey superintendent and then the the component districts are there says the department and so the department State Ed and district superintendent the Bose director shall monitor the implementation of regionalization plans by component school districts us and may conduct site visits and review performance metrics to ensure outcomes meet the Strategic objectives outlined as the plan related to pering Preparing students for college career and Civic Readiness opportunities enacting operational efficiencies if such metrics are not being met the department or district superintendent shall compel the component District to amend his SE section of the regionalization plan to achieve desired outcomes as set forth by the component School District pursuant to
136subdivision B so to me it clearly says they have the legal authority to dictate what we do um and I find that troubling um as I think we all should um I will point to um a nisba onboard article which I shared with our board from September 23rd and as they've this is right right after it came out I believe this uh rule was published in late August early September um s officials told on board that school districts will not be able to opt out of the discussions nor any local actions required by regionalization plans developed by their Bose's district superintendent so that's what they said in September and now the thought process is they're saying well you won't have to do anything you don't want to do um so to your point Christian the
137roll out has been poor um so I'm just concerned about that I'm not concerned about hey let's talk about this and let's have a plan and can we offer Japanese and if we have an AP class that another District doesn't have and uh they have an AP that we don't have can we send them their students can we send them ours of course all of these ignore the funding aspect of it too this opens a whole host of issues uh if we send a student to Washingtonville to take an AP course let's say they offer something we don't and vice versa it are there payments there um uh what about busing students Transportation uh how does this affect labor contracts there's a lot of financial uh implications that are not covered in all of this
138um so with that I think you know we've had a good introduction um I guess really what I put to the to the board is do we want to um sit back and wait and just you know have Terry keep us um apprised of what's going on and you know you've gotten to round one data request which you said was just publicly available information but as you get the next data request share it with us and we can discuss further at that time um or do we want to um you know write a letter to State Ed saying that we oppose this initiative um as um as written in the New York state Register um and we can certainly say we we agree with you know that it's a great exercise and and we want
139to improve educational opportunities for all of our students and a lot of this is good but the ultimate Authority has to rest with the home District so um is NI said going to care for our comment are they going to do anything with it probably not but I think it may be important to put that on record um so I guess that's really what I'd love to see the discussion is do we um do we send a letter up to niid um or do we sit and wait um in an email I sent to the board I kind of threw a third option of do we sign on with this Coalition letter and as I further read it they don't really have a letter to niid they're asking you to sign on their letter to
140other school districts um and as I read it further I sort of misinterpreted what misinterpreted um what they were asking and I don't know that that's really a worthwhile exercise to sign on to their letter that goes to other school boards I think they they've publish that pretty well um unless I'm misunderstanding that I welcome that so I guess really you know any general discussion um but really you know for us do we want to uh propose a letter and send that off um or do we want to just sit back and wait and monitor bass thanks Jim I I want to State my position on this um I read that you mentioned kind of two three emails a day that came from the Coalition I I I don't know there's a lot of Merit
141uh in what they have uh but again for the record this is my position it is not a cooperation with bosses it's a lot more than that uh it gives B bosses and I think you just mentioned use the same terminology already it gives bosses authority over us uh it let hes tell us what we need to do uh there's no up out option uh it's going to be forced upon us like shove down our throats if you want uh bottom line again of the whole proposal for this uh regulation is equity and everybody here my colleagues know my position on Equity Equity is wrong equality is right and they do use they quote one of uh the kind of maybe experts behind the resolution using the word that education should be Equitable I don't
142agree with that uh education uh you use the word equality I would agree with you but Equitable is wrong Equity uh by the way came uh from a political ideology that has been tried all over the world and failed time and again uh let's not do that uh and again you do have kind of the taxpayers part of this whole uh uh regulation that was never mentioned uh your taxpayers expect to expect you to educate their kids their kids uh in Return of them paying their taxes their due taxes uh if uh bosses come at any point in time for whatever reason and uh ask us to educate more uh uh uh students because of whatever they don't have the program they needed wherever they come from again you have to consult with the taxpayers
143that taxpayers would wouldn't agree to that thank you bass and before I ask for uh other comments I just want to add one point for the public audience here uh that this only applies to school districts that are within a Bose um a member of iosis the big five school districts are Exempted and I think there's actually eight cities in the big five now um so New York City Mount Vernon Yonkers udica uh Albany Buffalo Rochester are all Exempted from this as well as districts such as Newberg um that are not um members of abos there also Exempted from this um so I think it's right about 50% of the students in the state of New York will not be covered by this just as a point of information um so further comments from the
144board pass forget to mention mention an important part uh you in your email to us the board you gave us three options and I replied to you and saying I agree with all three and I don't see why we should take one or two one and three two to whatever the combination is I I'm for all three at the same time right so as I said I I I kind of misread that as I as I did my homework today um signing on to that Coalition letter just signs on to their letter that they send to other school districts support support I mean the point I mean that's all um other comments or just you know we kind of need to take a straw poll of of what we want our actions to be Christian
145uh just because the politics of this have been brought up um I think it's fair to say to understand what these districts have been pushing in addition to this um and this is just characterizing the Coalition of New York state school board members and not you know what the nature of the legislation or the emergency Rule and things of that um so the first thing is when you do your launch of this and you have uh several um all Republican assembly members and state senators making the announcement with you I think that kind of suggests that there's underlying politics if you look at some of the leaders and also for well you know what forget about what they've done let's here are some of the policies that they have suggested to Nisa in the last
146two years they they have suggested removing immunization mandates they have basically have a strict thing against um uh they've had a suppor of a parental bill of parental rights legislation which is amorphous but I think it's understood what they were pushing for they pushed for that we can't accept the blue RI and commission unless it gets an up and down or only things that get an up and down in the New York State Legislature which basically taking away any rulemaking Authority from the New York State uh education department which I think would be ridiculously perilous because the idea that every single thing will be voted in the legislature the assembly and the Senate regarding education of the state is kind of goes back to the whole discussion about the administration versus the school board on
147a different level uh they have pushed for other things such as limiting um and and this is what's most telling to me they pushed the same Nisa resolution last year in 2023 before any of this was ever announced because they want to put a limit on Bose's funding they want not just Schoolboard autonomy as a unit or County what role does the county have overseeing the component school districts in the county Even in our County some of our school districts overlap county lines and that just kind of gives away the game of what they're trying to do is they basically want to to basic have a veto over the New York State you know uh legislature and executive and decision-making power and they basically want to have a lo you know local thing and they've
148done that before this came out and they didn't it again and then I suggest what their aim is and I would just ask people to look at the nisb resolutions from 2023 and 2024 put forward by the same school districts that are pushing this Coalition and whether you support that because that is no one there is no constituency for institutional structure of decision- making no one like you know dies on that hell they're doing it because they want some substantive things that they think will happen if they move the agenda or the arena by where the decisions are being made and it's pretty clear what their politics are on that and I know people here share those politics because some people here voted for some of those resolutions other people didn't but I'm not sure
149that Cornwall as a whole is clearly on one side or the other and so that would be my argument for not signing onto the letter um and if individual board members want to sign under their own name and make it clear that they are not speaking for the board I think they are free to take that action um and with no judgment or criticism for me your your views are your views um I think that uh so anyway so I guess the point about it is that you know we should be a little bit not signing on particularly because last year there was another pledge that we were as some people were asked to sign on to and we decided people decided not to do that and to be consistent I don't think we should
150be signing out other people's letters for that I'm not sure concern us so my point about it is that you know the politics here are pretty transparent and I'm not comfortable with voting for that just on that basis alone great thank you I appreciate that and um I you certainly have done more digging into the group I didn't really look into the group at all and who was behind them um and what their politics were I just they bought this regionalization initiative issue to my attention yeah well that that is a that may be a point against signing on with them uh right there is Spam right um no I my um my research was really limited specifically to this issue um and I I agree that it's a this isn't a political issue this
151is not Republican Democrat this is do we control our school district or are we going to be mandated by bosies or state Ed to do things um that are going to have costs associated with them uh that are out of our control um and I think that's a situation we don't want to be in um so I I guess um I open to more General comments we've had a good discussion but really I'd love to look for um do you support um our district writing a letter to State Ed or do you support um waiting and seeing um and maybe I'll just go around the horn bass you support letter stay yeah like you know it's hard to capture Everything at Once uh you mentioned kind of whether we should wait I don't think we
152should wait times of nence I mean they're they're talking about January 2025 we're two months away from implementing this uh this thing uh we shouldn't wait thank you we should wait I don't might be helpful for the public is to restate your three points you put in your emails and again I'm supporting all three yeah I'm taking away my own point so sorry microphone Carl yeah I would be in favor of a letter to writing a letter to State yes Christian a letter from our school district to be clear not signing up on somebody else's Mast head I think I'm clear that I'm not in favor of that so okay elanora yeah after doing some of the research and and reading some of the information I have to say I'm not in favor either okay
153Brendan yes to a letter uh from our district and yes to Terry obviously providing updates the latest as it goes yeah Tiffany I favor as sending the letter thank you um Christine I um sending the letter from our district specifically yes great um I also think that's a good idea um so I think what we'll do um is I'll work work on drafting a letter um Christian and Elanor obviously I'll send it to the whole board um you can read it and if you change your mind and you want to sign on to that point if not we'll send it um with the six or seven uh signatures that we have so are you suggesting this is a letter and we can choose to sign it or not or this is a letter representing the
154overall majority view of the board so I mean is are we taking this as a position as a board or are we taking this as individual members want to write a letter so so the point is that if it's voted on do we need to sign it individually or can you sign on our behalf since you're this you are and Christine are the leadership I think we've got make a suggestion quick I've been on committees and you know decisions where we have to pass or fail a PhD student if you want uh you would say the committee voted so and so 63 in favor of da da right yeah I I thought that so I guess my way of expressing that was having everybody's an individual signatory to um say that this was not a
155unanimous decision but if you want me to just report and I can sign it myself and say hey we had a vote of um six to two to go ahead and send this um I I I guess I defer to both of you as the two in this point of how you would rather see that implemented if we have if we have a vote I think that creates the authority to write the letter it doesn't require individual School Board member signatures unless of course they want to sign and they think they're adding their weight to it but I don't think it should I don't think that uh it requires all of our signatures because other people voted for it okay I would love to see the letter and we also have to keep in I
156will share it before I send it and we also have to keep in mind that Richard although he's not here will get that letter and would change the the votee as well you know cuz he would have to add his yes or no it doesn't change the vote the vote well it doesn't change the vote but it would give him a voice as well yeah of course and I think we should strive for consensus instead of just a majority on this as well in the writing itself of the letter the goal is that you're going to put together a letter that would have brought agreement so hopefully some of this will come out in the wash yeah I mean that the letter is going to be short and sweet um my aspect is just a
157highlight we all as a board um discussed this and thought that there were many worthwhile things that come out of it our concern is simply the way that the legal language is crafted we are worried about losing um control at the local level um over issues that impact spending and local budgets um you know and we welcome I think we I think everybody welcomes um the discussion and the and the planning um the concern is just the way that it is is it implemented with force of law or is it truly optional um they're saying it's optional but to me the language of the regulation which cares the force of law has nothing about it being optional so um I don't think it's an opposed to the initiative it's opposed to how legally binding is
158it and ultimately what are the consequences of that so yeah to Brendan's point maybe um I don't know uh draft the letter send it to everybody and then maybe we take a vote at the next meeting um for an effort of consensus or um I think that's a great idea I have to look into this I feel like there's a time constraint on this in that public comment is only open until the end of this month um so that's why I would send it via email and just kind of get everybody's thumbs up that way um if there is not that time constraint um that would be a great way to go about it yeah we are empowered to take that vote by email because we're not deciding we're not legally entering a legally binding
159agreement we're not allocating public money we're just uh deciding what we as a board will do so per discussion at our Retreat this would be fair game to take a a head count through email my my understanding is the same as Brendan's thank you both important Point um great so I think that um covers that discussion on to next item G recognition of visitors public comments any takers glutton for punishment am I good there we go uh John Hines um I think it's great that nice and nice said there's a lot of NYS acronyms here but uh nceet is also commenting on the regionalization regulation um stating that local can they want language added to the reg uh the rule that local control of schools will remain intact and that state and Bose cannot impose
160modifications on school programs so I think this is one of those opportunities where it's great where school boards and the labor movement get together um that's how we fought back Foundation 8 Cuts last year I think we're going to be in the same fight in December Feller report comes out so I think it's positive that we all are sharing the sentiment and hopefully State Ed will listen so thank you for taking that action thank you John very um helpful information there um and that brings us to our last uh item here which is closing comments from Boe members um start with Tiffany let's start over here thank you Jim um I want to congratulate all of our athletic teams from the fall on all of their successes uh particularly our section 9 football champions who
161had that historic comeback um amazing they will be playing in Goan on Friday at 6pm if anyone is so inclined probably ticketed um not certain on that um thank you to the student reps who who did hang in for quite a long time they are what they have to say is so valuable and um it it brings an energy to the room that um that is unparalleled also to our public commenters um most of whom have departed at this point but nonetheless hearing from the public is so essential and so important for us to know um what's happening also the Harvey we're going to miss you thank you so much for all of your work it's it's it it it it is I've truly come to appreciate it sitting at this table more so than
162when I was in the audience or or on Zoom um to just see the the amount of work and dedication that you've given this District so I thank you again and also finally for the community the village of Cornwall and Hudson tree lighting will be held on uh November 30th at 5:00 p.m. with activities and music and Santa and all the fun things so we hope to see you there thank you pass thanks Jim I have just two points for tonight uh first of all I went with the family we watched the har uh po play just an amazing job uh the production uh uh the sound and light effects were just amazing professional level uh the set the set really kind of maybe my background engineering kind of I mean really got my attention
163like the brick walls The Arches the windows you know the the doors uh uh the set was was just amazing amazing it wasn't kind of you don't think like students came up with the whole thing it's uh very professional so kudos to everybody who participated in making that possible and the second comment I have is about the EV buses and uh you know uh being a volunteer myself I'm volunteering right now um I volunteer in different programs so I do appreciate every time I see member of the public volunteering forming committees working together coming coming up with goals and I know how how how strongly they believe about those goals now but that said uh uh uh uh this whole EV thing uh you know for instance we heard about like uh each bus takes
16410 emissions if you want of 10 uh combustion engines car 100 actually uh cars of the road this statement has been circulating around for for for such a long time and it leaves uh it leaves out the question or of where does the electricity come from I believe if you just look at this car and somebody's driving it yes he's offsetting 100 you know uh gazoline cars or diesel cars uh but uh where does the electricity come from it has to be generated somewhere when you generate electricity you release emissions unless you're using using Hydro power unless you're using solar power right uh wind if you want uh but I don't think we're there so uh uh the the the emissions if we don't release them here in corn world they're release somewhere else right
165and nobody likes to discuss that point another thing is the infrastructure is not there yet whether we like it or not uh third is the cost of the EV buses compared to diesel buses you can research it and you see the difference uh our location here uh we live in a cold environment we live in a mountaneous en I mean uh topology if you want uh these are not favorable for EVS in general especially for heavy EVS like school buses uh five is uh uh uh uh uh the time it takes to CH to to to charge a bus and you know I mean here we have the administration with us they know the schedule of our buses throughout the day with after school and sports and everything uh right and I would uh close
166by saying the mandates we mentioned I mean we heard about mandates by 2023 these are not set in Stones you know Administration come and go and whenever you hear about a mandate bye so and so we have to do this yes it's on paper uh uh time comes and they figure out oh we're not there yet what do they do assuming it's the same Administration they just like push it down the road like Kick the Can down the road so so it's all as I said you know I mean I'm not taking anything away from from the effort uh the committee we heard from is putting into this I know how how passionate they are about it I appreciate all of that uh uh uh and they're very very very very you know like uh
167uh genuine interest like passion about it when they talk about the kids and the health of the kids and the future of the kids I believe in all of that but you have to uh take a breath and look at this question scientifically and if you look at it scientifically uh you don't see uh uh a lot of Merit behind it thank you bass um we're not supposed to have cross talk on our closing comments but as somebody with a chemistry degree I'm disappointed you left off nuclear power um Carl I just wanted to thank Harvey for everything and hope you enjoy your retirement thank you Carl Christian uh so I got asked by a member of our community about why you volunteer and I kind of mumbled something along the lines of like well
168because that's the world I want my children to grow up in um but when I thought about it I wasn't really happy with my answer not because that's not the right answer but um it made me just reflect on a few things that I think tie together some themes tonight I had a scoutm who had a litany a speech he would often give and it was I didn't have to do X but it helps and he wasn't saying that what I was doing was helping someone else he would always say this to the leaders in the troop to remind them that it's a privilege to be in a position to help other people and that you benefit from it a lot more than the people that you're helping many times and to seek out those
169opportunities as much as possible and my father would say you know would always recommend St Teresa the patron sa of missionaries who despite never leaving her hometown uh committed to doing things diligently meaning like I have a job to do I'm going to do it better than I'm required to and so he would say heaven has a small door because a small things are what gets you in and to a third thing I was reading something that I've read a long time ago but just brought to me again um a short essay by George Orwell which is called the good word for the Vicor of ber and if you know English History the Vicor of Bray is not a hero he changed sides about 15 times during the religious wars in the 1500s not a
170figure of Integrity not a hero no one respected in fact there's an English stud about him that Lampoons him quite well but there's one other thing that the vior of bra that Orwell points out he planted a tree in the 1500s and Orwell went and visited that tree in 1930s and the tree was still there 400 years later so Orwell concludes with this point he says it's not a bad idea every time you commit an antisocial act to make make a note of it in your diary and then at the appropriate season push an acorn into the ground and if even one in 20 of them comes to maturity you might do quite a lot of harm in your lifetime and still like the Picker of Bray end up a public manufactor and I think
171that's a good point just about the impact that we have long term and so I want to come to first of all to say a thank you in this season to all the volunteers PT I'm not going to have a comprehensive list but I think they all know who they are the PT the people that work in the school musicals who not just give up their time freely but also do their jobs better than they have to and finally app point just toward you Harvey and I've told the details before but I was volunteering earlier this year and I said I'm from Cornwall and they said do you know Harvey suland and I was never prouder of Cornwall than what they said to me at that moment about you and so you've planted a lot
172of acorns and I think these trees will be here long after you moved on and it's a testament to all your hard work and I think that not just on the behalf of the people who work for you but all the people who benefit from you who will never meet you and I just want to say thank you on behalf of those people that you might not ever get to meet thank you Christian [Music] Elanor it's been a really long day and I'm very tired so I just want to clarify something the the letter yep so I said no to I thought we're not signing that letter that we've been getting from be signed by Yours Truly no no the the the okay so I misunderstood so yes we're writing our own a letter then
173I'm I'm in from the Cornwall Central School District directly to nid perfect saying we think this is a great idea we're very concerned about the lack of local control talk cuz those emails were um we're not going to sign on to that awesome to Christian's Point um if any individual member feels free to do so in their own capacity and they are clear that they are doing so as an individual and not representative of a board they have the rights of free speech and are able to do so but as a board we are not taking that action awesome so thank you so the letter is yes so I you can include me in that great thank you Harvey good luck to you retirement is wonderful enjoy it um third thing I wanted to say
174is congratulations to the the wonderful production at the high school I had the pleasure of going to see it I even took my son with me um and it was wonderful they really did a beautiful job and lastly I the the people who live by the high school all of the comments that they made I really think that I would like to talk about that at some point um some of the things they said were a little bit concerning and just you know just wanted to maybe get some of the information sure um so I I'll I'll say two things about that one um we have I don't know was two years ago I think it was two years ago um again long day um that we implemented uh as our board policy um that
175we there's no cross talk no dialogue but at the next meeting um if appropriate uh the board president can choose to respond um in general to some of those comments so um I think there there may be um after discussion with Terry there may be some Avenue for that um if there are specific questions that you have asked I I'll shoot you ask you to either email myself or to email Terry or email both of us perfect um okay that's it thank you thank you Brendan thanks Jim um start quickly uh just with congratulations to the High School drama club um I think Harry Potter exceeded all expectations and there were very high expectations so um about a moment to be proud of Cornwall you know you think to yourself we're the first ones to
176put this on in the state and we might end up being uh the best so it was uh truly a um a landmark moment for the the district for the drama club um I do want to uh spend the the rest of my allotted time to uh to speak about Harvey I know we have been talking about board guidelines and being brief but I will uh seed my time in the future in exchange for uh for this um I was hoping not to have the opportunity to uh to give your board eulogy but here we are so uh I I want to talk first about things that I think we all know about Harvey and then maybe some things that people might not know I'll start with what everyone does know that Harvey is one
177of the best if not the best assistant superintendent for business in the state as uh uh Christian's comment alluded to he's a financial wiiz who knows five different paths to achieving any goal has a contingency plan for everything that you could possibly think of and most of the things that you could not it's why this district is where it is today people may not realize it um but early in Harvey's tenure in the years after the financial crisis our district was actually facing quite a bit of trouble we had funding issues the budget was voted down there was talk of the state getting involved to write the ship but with Harvey's leadership discipline and meticulous planning we were able to turn it around so that today we are one of the model school districts in
178the region with other of his peers assistant superintendent calling Harvey and saying how do you do this how do you do that Harvey is their Oracle I recognized this profound confidence when I first joined the board uh I was just immediately impressed he had an answer for every question no matter how gotcha or obscure it was even questions that weren't directed at him or weren't even about uh finances it it almost became like a cheat code for the district like if there was ever a question that no one knew the answer to you try to figure it out but then you'd be like just ask Harvey I don't know if I'd ever been around that level of competence before it kind of made me look into the mirror and think like I can be better
179myself not just as a board member but like professionally because here I was thinking I was pretty good at my own job and then I see this guy and I'm like that's what being good at your job looks like so he recalibrated what professionalism actually looked like and I'm not I'm sure I'm not the only one he did that for um because that's the Harvey that we all know the numbers guy the planner the one who holds every answer but there's another part about Harvey that doesn't get as much attention although Megan stepped on this point before is comp well it made me realize I was on the right path um his dedication to the kids I first learned this in September of my I'll call it my rookie year on the board so this
180is 2019 it was before covid so life still made sense uh one day during this uh during the school week September of that year the board got an email from then superintendent Neil Miller and he described an incident that had happened early that morning at a bus stop in the village it was a high school pick up so it was really early in the morning and apparently a student had noticed this suspicious person had been driving around the bus stop a few times and it was making everybody kind of uneasy so the student contacted the police who contacted the high school principal who contacted Harvey who called the police back they arranged to have patrols out early the next morning looking for the car and making sure the kids at the bus stop were safe
181which was the absolute right way to handle it and exactly what you would expect from har but then he did two other things that you would not expect that night Harvey called the parents of all the 20 plus kids who were at the bus stop that morning explaining the situation telling them that they were looking for this person and assuring them that the school district and police were on it 20 plus kids at night just Harvey working the phone lines which itself is going above and beyond but then the next morning he did something else he contacted West Point tourus the bus operator he got video footage from the bus I guess poured over it until he spotted the car on tape I don't even know how you go about doing that but he couldn't
182make out the license plate number so what does Harvey do he shares everything with the police obviously then he gets in his own car and starts touring the neighborhood looking for the car reminder the assistant superintendent for business the numbers guy turns into Magnum Pi patrolling the neighbor neighborhood uh protecting our kids and that's the Harvey that most people do not see the one who cares so deeply about our children who understands that his job isn't to balance one side of a spreadsheet against the other but to keep kids safe to give them opportunities and to help them flourish I remember when we were doing the capital project videos a few years ago and we were doing them at the middle school and after wrapping up Harvey and I were walking through the halls and
183he kept stopping at different places in the building to point out all the work that they would do some in the capital project some outside of it and he became so he was so animated he was so excited I could just see it in his body language and his voice and the way he framed it uh always stuck with me he said this will all be done by the time your girls get here you it's it's never been about the numbers with Harvey it's always been about the people the kids that's what makes him so unique so rare um he's not just a guy who knows what he's doing although he knows that better than anyone he knows why He's doing it um earlier tonight Megan said Harvey's always been about the kids um there
184have been a lot of them over 20 years Harvey you've touched the lives of thousands of kids who have passed through these Halls um and while I know you'll never get the credit for it you'll never have a former student knock on your door and say Mr suland I just want to thank you for securing the funding to purchase my trump B I also know that you'll never seek it uh because you've never been about the credit you've always been about the mission but I want you to leave here tonight knowing that you are appreciated you are admired deeply um and through your work and example you've given all of us something to Aspire to and after a career of always having the answer to every question you're leaving us with one that not even
185you can answer what are we going to do without you I thank you and I wish you well I am grateful that our paths crossed and I know that they will again goodbye for now and I'll miss you thank you Brandon Christine I have to compose myself after that good luck um gosh yeah I think Brendan just hit so many points that we all aspire to be that great right um between what's been said you know Harvey I first met you during the crisis much like the um mothers out front there was that Grassroots effort group that got together to sort of get out the vote for the budget and all of that and I will say I'm good at a lot of things but accounting is not one of them and um your graciousness
186and your um willingness to just always make it easy to understand and and never um making and at least me I can speak for me feeling less than because I don't I didn't necessarily know the basic accounting right um so I am so grateful for that because it gave me the opportunity to get more involved without being afraid and um you know your your generosity of spirit is just so you know evident in everything everyone has said and it reminded me of a mindset um quote that I often try to come back to and I think it sounds like this is how you approach your days it's I get to versus I have to and it's clear that um your commitment to the mission and your mindset of like I get to help I get
187to do this I get to make a difference has just played out you know tfold plus plus plus and um I'm just really grateful to have crossed paths with you and um thank you for all you've done thank you Christine um and I will I will I will stay with the thanks Thanksgiving is next week um I hope that you all if you're traveling you travel safe if people are traveling here to visit you that they travel safe uh I hope everybody has a uh restful and peaceful long weekend with friends and family um and does get to give thanks um we as a district have a lot to be thankful for um tonight we saw you know thanks for the great um Arts performance of Harry Potter um the great Athletics performances from our
188volleyball team and cross country squads and and football team um and those continue and um to be quite honest we all know that that rests upon money we've got to have the funding to to do those activities and to have our um school buildings run so we give thanks to you Harvey um for being a real Rock for this district and really making sure that we are a very financially secure district and on very firm footing um and to everyone's point you know what you do is underappreciated in the public um but you have put our district on a very strong financial path which allows um the board the administration building administrations teacher staff um to go do what they do best um because that Foundation is secure um so you have really been a
189great foundation for the school district to Brendan's Point um uh you're you're going to be a tough act to follow the institutional knowledge um we're going to be you know don't turn your cell phone off um because there's going to be a lot of questions that come your way that uh you know perhaps only you know the answer to so uh I personally have really enjoyed working with you um you've you've made complex issues very understandable um to both the board and to the public um you're always open to a great give and take and a great discussion um you don't take anything personally um you know when people are asking questions you realize we're just trying to get to the best place in a budget we're not attacking you and um you're really good
190at at at handling that so um it's been a pleasure to work with you uh wish you well in retirement uh and you will be missed um with that can I have a motion to adjourn second all in favor I I any opposed any extensions thank you all Happy Thanksgiving we will see you in December