001e all right good evening everybody uh I've got 7 o'clock here uh so let us call to order our work session meeting here for Monday December 2nd I hope everybody had a wonderful Thanksgiving holiday and now we're back at work please uh stand and join me in the pledge of elevance pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right the next item on our agenda is comments from the public uh before I open the floor to public comment um we uh updated our our public comment policy a couple years ago to provide an opportunity for the board to respond um to those comments that had questions not at the meeting but at
002the next meeting so we had a few themes uh that emerged last week for multiple comments so just two two brief real follow-ups uh one is to the Shadow Wood Lane folks um we we all hear you we thank you for coming out um to our meeting um we ask you to bear with us obviously during construction things always you know a little worse before they're better and we will um provide some sort of uh screening uh when the project is all said and done um the next group um that had public comment uh was the uh proponents of EV buses um we thank you for your comments uh we do have an agenda item later here uh with an update from Mr Dade um that's a positive update on that uh so with that
003I will say I will open the floor I will say uh Board of Education welcomes comments from the public each person wishing to speak is asked to speak into the microphone identify themselves and respectively limit their comments to three minutes two opportunities to speak are available one early in the meeting limited to 30 minutes and one at the end of each meeting each speaker May address the board only once at both the opening and closing portions of the agenda please remember there will be no cross dialogue between speakers and between members of the board all speakers are to conduct themselves in a civil manner obscene language lious statements threats of violence statements advocating racial religious or other forms of prejudice will not be tolerated person persons wishing to discuss matters involving individual District Personnel or
004students should present their comments Andor concerns to the superintendent during regular business hours uh with that I open the floor anybody who' like to make a public comment thank you good evening good to see you all again Natalie Ren Cornwall mom uh here on behalf of Mother's outfront thank you Mr President craigan kraan craigan craan thank you Mr craigan thank you for asking for that update uh I very much look forward to to hearing what you'all have to say but unfortunately I have to go deal with bedtime so I'm just going to do a quick Dash chat and then head out um but I fully support any conversations that the board has on this matter uh the reason that I'm here I know you already know this uh here again just to support this time
005sensitive item of um applying to the EV the epa's clean School Bus rebate program the deadline is you remember January 9 yes wo thank you thank you Mr Dade it is January 9 and uh we have been in contact with West Point tours we're still trying to get a a meeting in place uh but Robert brisman I believe believe is his name uh he has agreed he's sounds like he's on board and he's ready to um you know to send that information to their grant writer to to start the the process which is excellent so we're going to poke poke him politely on that but we do believe it's a lot more impactful to have the school board um or our superintendent just check in with him so we're asking that that you please reach
006out to him this week to make sure that that application is begun and that he has a strategy to complete it before the January deadline um and I just wanted to address uh a little a response that we did get from uh Mr Harvey saltland is that uh I really appreciate he did respond to us in emails and uh he and I've heard from other members you know there's concern about cost of course we understand this could be expensive uh after speaking with other teams from others out front who have helped with their districts as well as with Mr brisman who um has been in contact with with mid city Mid City uh they've had success with this where they managed to get buses 100% covered other towns or maybe 90% And I understand uh
007that there's a concern with cost however we cannot argue it's too expensive until we have conducted an electrification plan and that we can do for free uh so the next step once we apply to EPA is to apply to nerta for to conduct that electrification plan and because West Point tours serves a priority District of Newberg that plan would be 100% covered by n nerta so that's like the next step that we're going to hassle you guys about in the coming year so uh put on your seat belts um but also just to just kind of give a little perspective as a reminder I know that you know finances is extremely important part of of the job that you have here supporting the school district I just want to remind you of coming from the
008parental concern about about climate change about our children's health uh you know combating climate change is not about saving money it's about saving the planet and saving our kids Futures so I'd really like you to please consider that as you uh have these conversations so uh the last kind of request and maybe this is already on your agenda is to please set a set up a subcommittee so that you can work on this um item as a team please uh I've I've sent you a few emails I'd love a a response we would love to meet with you Mr kraan or anybody on the board to to offer the resources that we have from others out front they have a step-by-step guide it it's um I wouldn't say it's idiot proof but it is pretty
009strategic and uh helpful so we'd love to give you those resources and um answer any questions or or help in any way that you know a parent can um and I think that's it so thank you very much for your time thank you uh any other public comment hi everyone uh I was here two weeks ago Cassandra Cog bille here also representing mothers out front um also looking forward to hearing uh some updates from um Mr Dade we um I'll be able to stay so um yeah looking forward to that um and I just want to reiterate what Natalie said um you know just in case it's helpful and I'm not sure what we're going to hear later but you know I just I've been thinking about this and we all know what a fantastic
010School District we have here in Cornwall right I mean that's part of the reason why my family and I decided to live here that's why a lot of families have decided to live here you know we're really proud of our District's leadership in the Hudson Valley region which comes really from putting our children and their future first right when it comes to every decision that we make and I'm very proud of that as a parent when I ask myself you know what does the future like look like in 15 and 20 years you know I don't want our children to ask why we didn't make decisions that were consistent with our leadership um position in this region right why didn't we do more to protect them from harmful gases when we could why didn't we
011take the free money from the federal government to help us do that quicker and sooner ultimately we will have to do that right because there's a state mandate our children really care about the climate I think if you talk to any child that's one of the top issues for them so if we're really really child Centric let's put their interests in their future first and really really think about this from a long-term perspective you know is this the Legacy that we want to leave behind for them just want to point out the neighboring School District in Middletown um actually already has four electric school buses and they're having another 10 coming in for the 2025 26 school year all of these buses were purchased with grants which cover the cost differential between Diesel and electric
012according to representative from mid city the Middletown District bus company quote drivers and Scholars absolutely love the EVS saying they have a made they've made an overall positive experience for the company and community in addition obviously to the environmental benefits so fortunately for those who may not be aware actually Mid City just acquired West Point tours the bus company which serves both Cornwall and Newberg so they are very familiar with this process and all we need is just your support to help push them to to definitely apply for this grant your support is really really critical to make sure that we have this um in place for that January 9th deadline if you could please call them this week just to make sure that you know um they know that we have your support um
013you know if just I'll just enclosing if the you know I'd say if our district is really Student First know I ask you all to take a stand on on this issue uh and act as befits a district of our leadership standing in caliber thank you so much thank you very much anybody else for public comment all right thank you very much uh next item on our agenda here is committee updates I'm going to go in no particular order actually I'm going to go in a particular order it's the order that I have my page whether that makes sense this order or not I don't know but here we go uh policy Brendan yeah so we are on track to have our second meeting seems loud um after Christmas so uh I'll start working with
014uh Terry and then our members to coordinate that that'll be the the second of our third uh meeting of the year we'll knock out the other third of policies that are up for review plus tie some loose ends from our uh our previous one but I'll I'll share that uh you know probably by our next meeting we'll have that scheduled wonderful thank you um I lied I'm not even going to go in the order I have on my page I'm going to skip to communication so I can stick with you thanks Jim so uh we tentatively have a meeting scheduled for next week to discuss uh how to coordinate basically with the facilities committee on launching a let's call it a capital project uh update SL preview uh both Capital project one and potential Capital
015project 2 um I have already asked some members of the committee if they would like to attend the upcoming facilities committee meeting uh Christian I think you're the last one who I have not asked so that's next Tuesday uh facilities committee meeting you would you don't have to come but basically I I receive my uh reive the invitation and I will consult my children to see if I can SCH got it and just so you know though you would be you would be showing up as a nonparticipating member Community member yes so uh but I think anyway it's it's great to uh to coordinate between the two committees since our work will be so intertwined uh over the next few months wonderful thank you uh as facilities committee chair I'll continue on that we do
016have a meeting next Tuesday at 6 pm at the district office um our last meeting uh we got a presentation from Palumbo group uh here to the full board which really covered everything we covered in our last facilities meeting so I won't rehash that here um the next meeting we were we're um getting rough price estimates from Palumbo group on all of the needs list that was left over from the last Capital project and new needs which have been identified um so we're going to try and take a first stab at a trying to digest what is the total number knowing that with $5 million saved on our capital reserve we can go out to our voters um with the um with the state aid that would be available to us for an approximately $20
017million Capital project so um getting a feel for what is that total number and kind of start to whittle the the the projects down um to be handled to get to that $20 million number so uh that's next Tuesday at 6 PM with the district office uh visitation Richard can I just make a comment about the facilities committee and I know I brought this up before but last time when we did Capital project in 202 too we live stream the facilities committee meetings and I'm wondering if that's something we should look at doing again um because we're going down that path again and I'm wondering if that would help inform people and community members as to what exactly we're doing and why we're doing it yeah so last time was definitely a different different for
018several reasons one um it was the first time that we'd had a capital Pro that magnitude in living memory uh two there was a big issue with um a big issue with location of what are would we do a multisport athletic complex a and if we did where would it be located so those were really contentious issues um this go around it's really just all these projects have been identified the public is aware of them the list has been out there and it's really just whittling down existing projects so it's a much different feel um possibly something to think about I'll have to talk to Terry and see I don't know if there's a capability to do that from the district office if we'd have to move the meeting if we can do it on
019the short of notice but um it's definitely a lot different this time and I think to Brendan's point about having Communications committee there so we can have a community forum and make sure that we we certainly before this goes out to a vote we will have Community forums where people will have the opportunity to attend um see what's proposed and ask any pertinent questions so um that's it's definitely an important part of the process and it will be included um I don't know if we'll be able to arrange that by next week right um but we'll look into that visitation I'm up okay so the only update I have is um I emailed uh Megan and Terry a couple weeks ago to schedule our fall visitation um I've officially now heard back from all the
020committee members as to their availability and what days work best for them so I'm going to work with Administration to get that scheduled as soon as possible um I know a couple things High School definitely we want to revisit the drop schedule and Community lunch I know there's been some stuff out there about that so we definitely want to revisit that and see what's going on and yeah that's the only update I have thank you thank you um and I would just ask um as soon soon as you have that schedule um lock in which of your members are able to attend um because in the past we've always you know left it open to other board members who aren't on the committee if there are openings um to attend so the sooner you could
021get that out to board members if you need additional representation would be great absolutely um audit committee Christian so I'm going to do three audit strategic planning and an update on curriculum committee I guess um explor a group the audit committee has done its work for the year until the internal audit is back um so that should be in June so there's no nothing to report on the rfps for the strategic planning um I have read all three that um we had and we giving you the feedback on that and we are going again tomorrow to kind of uh finish up our review the three and have a discussion so we should have something to report or at least we'll have information before next meeting for you about at least uh the information on the
022um the document so that's that's moving along and the third I circulated um last week to the members of the curriculum committee guess exploration group um um a model Charter and I think that it would be it's not the only possible way but I think that um what was good about the model Charter it basically said what it does but also what it doesn't do and also gives pretty specific um uh information about you you know propos membership on it as well as actions that it can and can't take so um if you like I can circulate that more broadly but we are uh moving ahead on that and hopefully we'll be able to discuss that and come back with something more concrete great yeah thank you on curriculum I would say yeah the four
023of you get together and meet and then when you've got you know four heads together um bring that up full of full board update discussion um would be great um strategic planning thank you to for doing that um Christine and I have reviewed them I I need to write out my thoughts in a little bit better way um ch's reviewed them so I think um what we'll do look to do is get a a meeting with uh the four board members and Terry on the calendar um so we can all discuss um who we think the best choice is there and then bring that to the full board um and audit is audit great um all right thank you Christian as I go through my list um oxa I've got you Christine anything new to
024report there no um sorry the oxa meeting is virtual this Wednesday so if it's something that you're interested in that you cannot typically attend because you have to be on site um you are welcome to dial in um Wednesday night yeah Christian also attends if there's something else um I don't I don't know if um Karen Meyer who's the director of oxa has sent the zoom link but she she has not she just made the announcement that it was then so I think it will be widely distributed to everyone to all of our emails but so I would say look out for that in the next two days if you're interested in watch participating in the meeting all right um and I the only other thing um unless somebody else has an update to share
025that I've missed uh please stop me but uh the other kind of working group that we established this summer was the code of conduct and I've got Christian and Brendan and Richard have you guys any updates there not yet all right there we go anything else on committees that we're missing all right thank you everybody uh so that brings us to our consent agenda purpose of the consent agenda permits the Board of Education to make more effective use of its time by adopting a single motion to cover those relatively routine matters which are included any member of the board who wishes to discuss individually a particular piece of business on the consent agenda May so indicate and that item will be considered and voted on separately thus preserving the right of all board members to
026be heard on any issue um it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the following consent agenda items as submitted by the superintendent of schools items two and three uh light business here as we were on Thanksgiving uh so there's only a few days of school between our last meeting and this one uh can I have a motion for the consent agenda Christian so moves can we have a second second and uh would anybody like to pull item two or item three for discussion okay so then we will take a vote on items two and three on the consent agenda all in favor I I any opposed any extensions all right motion carried um on to our next item here Jim can I just make a motion to move up um the EV bus
027update um new business in respect to our guests so that we can give that update earlier and since I think it's just informational before we move on to the the old business can I make that motion or you can I make that motion make that motion do we have a second second uh all in favor I I sure uh so we will do the EV bus update Terry all right so um few updates for uh the board and our public at large uh so first um I've been in contact with uh Robert brisman who is the president of uh West Point tours he is um well aware of um the Mandate that is uh is uh currently um being dictated by the state um he's he admits city um tours are well aware of kind
028of what all that entails so good news is um they're aware of the grant they've already asked for uh our sign off on applying for that Grant uh in the email to me he says he understands that January 9th 2025 is the deadline so we're good there um so he understands when it needs to be uh turned in so we do plan on signing off on that because it doesn't bind the district in any way we could receive funding and still not move forward with anything so we do plan to do that um they're in good shape they don't need any assistance at this time they have uh people dedicated to grant writing and they whatever information mother's outfront has I'm sure they have as well so um I think they'll be in good shape
029to finish the process and um and submit that um what I wanted to spend some time on uh today was just making sure sure that the board knows um a few pieces of information because my job is to make sure that we're just fully informed as we move forward um first uh one of the things that we've really relied on is um working with West Point tours and and uh their cost structure and things of that nature which funnels down to us so they know that EV bus is is a mandate they know that by 2027 you aren't going to be able to buy diesel buses so they know this so they're they're factoring that into like their long range plan out of all the districts that they serve what is our plan working from
0302027 to 202 to 2035 and backwards map it because no one can afford to just go from zero to all EV all at once uh so I I trust them to continue to provide us with that information of year one it would look like this year two and then we would have to factor that into our budget process when we go out for rfps for transportation period it may be West Point tours it might be other companies vying for our business here in Cornwall so that's really important to understand that in 2028 that we might be operating with another company um that said we've absolutely loved working with West Point SWS but it's just really important that we're not making decisions today that could impact um what we're deciding uh later on uh two uh
031amongst us as superintendant we've really had some concerns with unanswered uh questions uh that you know I think the state is still grappling with so while you can put something on paper that we support uh fully EV by 2035 Central Hudson is is a little concerned with what does that look like with their infrastructure uh so we've heard firsthand that they don't have the capacity as it stands now to support an EV state so that would be again something that we would have to work with you can't force districts to do something that our electric company isn't ready for I'm not saying that they will not ever be ready but right now they would not have the capacity to support uh the needs of all of our um Newberg and Cornwall going EV right now
032a gradual yes but they have said if Newberg and Cornwall were to go right now we wouldn't have the infrastructure um right now to to support that um I think we're we're aware of the uh difference in in cost um just to throw out some uh figures um gas diesel buses currently run around 110k EV buses cost between 280 and 325 so we're talking about three-fold increase in in cost um we've had conversations with our Menin uh colleagues of the range of EV buses uh during the winter months and things of that nature right now they have a range of 100 to 120 miles and even as small as we are in Cornwall we our range extends beyond that in our three- tier uh system um as superintendents we've had questions like I get uh
033on school messenger at 10:30 to call an early release due to weather what happens with EV buses when you're planning for a charge at 12:00 for your between your second and third run and I'm making an emergency call to send all students home um early so these aren't these aren't things that are going to impede us forever but I just really want to make sure that we're being disciplined and have all these answers uh these questions answered because they're really important as we think of the health and safety of our students being beyond what might come with having a diesel um a diesel bus so um we are excited again Mr brisman is fully committed to applying for the EPA Grant he understands uh the deadline we're going to sign off on that as as
034partners um with them um I believe Newberg is is as well um and then we'll we'll have further conversations as the board as more information uh comes in but right now 2027 is an important date to keep in mind of when companies will have to start buying um EV buses only and then that road map by New York state is until 2035 so if I was the business person it would be what does that look like over a period of eight years to fully support the clients that I have now uh thank you for that update uh any questions Christian uh two questions uh the first one is is that have they explored repowering existing diesel buses so I know there's at least one bus company in New York state that has basically replaced the
035drivetrain you know with internal combusting engine with an electric so basically taking a bus and that the cost is actually comparable to a diesel bus so the this is something from two months ago and the the number that they cited was something between 120 and 180 to do that now there are some regulations about how long a bus can be in service before it has to be basically uh sunsetted and that would maybe affect some existing buses but that I was wondering if that has been explored and is that a cheaper option that we can to bring down the cost and the second is I know when we think of school buses we all think about the long yellow bus but school buses actually are not just that they are Vans they are you know
036basically SUVs or different things and whether it'd be feasible to replace at least those that would probably be cheaper but also are a lot of miles in terms of routes for uh disabled students uh students going to local programs and maybe maybe that's a slice of the salami that we can actually handle that would not be the prohibitive cost and maybe that's a step that we can move toward it and perhaps this is something as we explore it that can be incorporated into our strategic plan about how we are going to cost that and what the priority we're going to put on that thank you you have any information on that I don't don't have any information on the uh yeah the only on the buses yeah the only piece that I just uh think
037makes it complicated is it's a trickle down down so you have Mid City who supplies for West Point tours who who supplies for us so I don't think it's a we get to pick a van and and things of that nature I think it's kind of a I would love to hear from West Point tour as in Mid City what is their long range plan and we figure out what the resultant cost is as a district versus some other districts that uh get a much more um healthy return um on their tax dollars uh like Middletown um that could look a little bit different so I think Christian asked some great questions I don't have the expertise for I think it would be a question for West Point tours in mids of the no absolutely
038they're good questions so we should ask some West Point tours as you know I really it's you know John thinkink as he comes on board tomorrow those are good questions for him um it's going to be you know this going to be a discussion that we're going to be having for a decade so um other questions Jim Brendon um really just to help me understand uh this is all great um thanks for the update um generally one of the things that that gets me is just the that I'm a little confused about is West Point tours applying for the grant so um help me understand I the New York State mandate for schools is by 2035 it seems that there's a separate mandate for um bus companies by 2028 so 27 would be their last
039year to to buy diesel so um maybe there's not a good answer other than that's just the way it is but why why are they applying for the grant and it's not it's so to answer the second part of your question it's for school to all schools you can't buy any new diesel buses in 2028 you have to you have to be 100% electrified by 2035 you can't replace diesel equipment with diesel equipment in 2028 so that that's not a West Point tours versus us doing our own transport issue as far as you point out a I I said that it's a it's a mandate for them it's a mandate still a mandate for us just affects them correct but then why I'm just confused why they're the one I'm glad grateful that they're taking
040the lead on on the grant process but why are they if it's them if it's our mandate I'll let Terry take that yeah um so again remember uh most of you were on the board Tiffany and Elanor forgive me um the RFP process was really kind of an all in what is your total cost for all of our drivers buses it was an Allin and we said let's put that out there compared to all other companies the same thing is going to hold true we would not go out and buy a bus right now and say we're going to buy this bus and give it to West Point tours We Trust West Point tours to do their replenishment on a on a whatever basis it is so this would fall in my opinion directly in
041line with that if we must be by 20 to35 fully EV our RFP process would look different to say company one might say I'm we have an aggressive approach in the next six years we're going to be completely EV I guarantee you their quote is going to come back looking a little bit different than client B to say we're going to take all the way till 2035 here's what you can expect from us in the next five years so I think it's there's some school districts that have that operate their own buses those are the ones that you see saying hey we have we bought our our first EV bus it's it's internal when you work with a company like West Point tours you're really relying on them for procurement of buses and and things
042of that nature so it's basically the market pressure is working on them it's in their incentive to right to pursue this okay and then the and just one other point on that um and then the the important part of that EPA Grant is is the EPA is still looking for us as partners because they know that we're their clients so do you have the partnership with the districts that you're working with which would enhance their ability to get get funding in the grant got it okay uh and then the second part is the uh that Central Hudson bit that you mentioned um the you mentioned the they wouldn't have the infrastructure obviously we're not turning on a light and and going all EV tomorrow but do you know what they mean by infrastructure does that
043mean capacity or charging stations or both and which also brings up another question of how would we handle the charging stations Great question so there there would need to be a comprehensive um assessment uh done uh West Point tours did already reach out to Central husand like give us a ballpark of what infrastructure would cost uh for this and it it already came in at in excess of 1.1 million um just for infrastructure so this is not a light ask um there's a lot just think of how long it took the town just to get the two charging stations at at town hall for our whole uh Town that's that was not an easy um flip for them um now you add what would that look like for buses but bus depot and um I
044would assume that we wouldn't be charging right at West Point Tores only there would have to be other Depots um across um our area but they're looking West Point tours is looking at it as still folded into their challenge yes they're not looking at it like Hey we're going to do the buses you do the charging stations they're looking at it all as their on their plate on on their plate and I would expect that um they would send us a a letter saying as we move forward please know just like they did when like uh they came to us and said we've held you constant for a long time yeah they gave us a warning letter to say costs have escalated please know that when you you asked for the RFP the cost is
045going to go up significantly I would see this looking just the same in three years got it okay any other questions all right thank you uh we will now go back to the future and back to Old business uh number one on Old business is our board guiding principles and operational agreements discussion um we emailed out um there was just two minor changes which were out earlier and printed out here based on our discussion um last meeting um so I guess I will ask you know we we've discussed this two meetings in a row this meeting three so I I believe that we captured Christine and I the comments and made uh the CH appropriate changes to those two points if there's any further um comments on those two points um and if not I
046would uh open it up for a vote so any comments okay not seeing any um so I would say that we will then uh take a vote on this if we want to um Institute these um as our guidelines operating guidelines and uh guiding principles for the board so all in favor well we haven't opened it with a motion thank you motion can I have motion can I have a second second all in favor I opposed abstentions all right wonderful thank you for that uh next item on our agenda is the regionalization update um so this is um mostly for the community a little for the board um as our discussion um at our last meeting about the uh niid regionalization initiative um we did draft a letter uh we sent it to niid on
047where's my notes Monday 11:25 which was the last day for public comment um we received a an email response very quickly within an hour from uh assistant commissioner for Education policy whose name I was supposed to write down and I didn't Frank Frank Mike Frank yes um and he responded um with some sort of you know boiler PL language and I just said you know thank you very much for your quick response I I think you missed points two and three of our letter um and he actually called the district office asking to speak with me uh Terry and I were able to speak with him for about five minutes um on the afternoon of Tuesday 11:26 uh about an hour before we spoke with Mr Frank uh commissioner Rosa sent an email um with
048a memo to um all superintendents um and that was you know picked up by some press outlets and uh nispa sent it out in their update on Sunday um but essentially the email update from commissioner Rosa says um that they are making revisions to their um regionalization initiative and they are uh having two uh points here one is clarification on monitoring and amendments um so they're going to revise the rule to note that suggested amendments to regionalization plans will remain advisory rather than mandatory um this ensures the districts remain full control over the plans that develop the second Point voluntary participation acknowledgement to address concerns about mandatory participation a new provision will be added which allows districts in consultation with their school boards to elect not to participate in the regionalization planning process by submitting
049written notification by January 15 2025 um in my reading of that I said okay well there's the planning process and then there's the plan and then there's the amendment um and she addresses the planning process and the Amendments but not the plan um in talking to Mr Frank and uh I felt in our our brief five minute conversation that he was really sincere and that they wanted this to be voluntary I pointed out to him there's sort of three aspects and they only address two here um so basically I think the stance we have to take is wait and see um obviously other groups notice that discrepancy as well um and will they address that third discrepancy will the plan still be mandatory even if you don't participate in the process and the amendment is
050it it logically it doesn't really follow so I would hope they would address that point uh and and add some clarification there um so at this point I think as a board it's best that we just sort of wait and see but you know we do have that January 15th guidelines so I think it's something that we will bring up again for discussion on whether or not we want to participate in that planning process we'll bring that up um in our first meeting in January which I don't have that date handy but I assume it's before the 15th so um questions comments from the board on this BR you picked up on um I guess the points that uh were probably fairly obvious to most people that were were reading them the one thing I
051would uh try to identify is when will this new section 1242d be revised so we can take a look at the language it seems like um that the pattern that we're developing that we're noticing here is when speaking to constituents or to stakeholders they will say one thing and then you go back and track it to the language and there are those worrisome gaps so um if you know we sound skeptical I think they have earned our skepticism so I would like to to see what that the revised language ends up being um and hopefully not you know the night before uh they vote on it not putting it to you I'm just saying that uh I think we should all stay on this because uh you know these dates are going to come on
052us pretty quick and we want to make sure we really understand uh in the end what uh this is I agree wholeheartedly any other questions comments Christian I mean I read this your the respon respon to our letter in the light in context of the response to believe it was Mr regano's letter who was the count lawyer representing some of the Long Island districts and there was a response from State EDS Council on that and I think he made it very clear that you know State Ed fully has the power to do things that are mandatory it's in it's in the Constitution it's in education law um it's why I can remove any member of our board for violating certain things it's why they can remove superintendence they can change the borders of our school
053district and that's completely within their purview and we just have due process rights if they initiate something of that sort and I think they made it very clear that we're not trying to force something but this also doesn't change the nature of our powers and the school districts are kind of framing it as like an absorption of authority um it's ahistorical and it's probably not within how the New York Constitution and education law has has framed the relative Powers so I think the point is they're saying it makes you feel better we'll make it voluntary because really what we want to do is start a conversation and I think that um you know so I think the point about it is the state is basically saying if you want a concession on language we'll give
054you a concession on language to move the process along and that the emergency nature of the rule was simply that they didn't go through the regulatory review unit in the governor's office of the budget and that was just to exite the process of collecting information so the point about it is it wasn't like they skirted process they just went for something that they could have done it would just to be a matter of time so I I I don't think this really changes that I'm glad that they responded to people but I think with the number of people asking questions it was more convenient for them to move forward uh by changing the language and trying to get people to be uh to be part of the process rather than being on the outside of
055the tent uh yelling in thank you yeah I mean I um I think overall I I agree they probably have the legal Authority I think other people have are going to sue them or have already initiated a lawsuit I don't think that we should do that as a district but um you know we're going to see how this plays out in the courts and and where that goes um I I think ultimately their messaging was less than ideal and they they could have rolled it out a better way but um it is where it is and I I think it's just as a board something we need to Monitor and we need to have a discussion at our first meeting in January whether or not we want to participate in that process and see where
056that language um comes out supporting your observation Jim um I think that the legal process has started and our participation in it doesn't change how the outcome and we get to see how that will be litigated and adjudicated and I'm sure we will know when it when it is absolutely and I think the real the real thing they're looking for at say at here is not necessarily for schools in our County and and and rockin in Westchester and Duchess County it's for schools in the adex and the Southern Tier um and places where there's really you know gaps in districts and a lot of declining enrollment um and they're trying to really Kickstart it for those for those groups which doesn't mean that positive outcomes couldn't happen for our district and neighboring districts but I
057think that's really the the Nexus behind it so um comments or questions from anybody else on this uh should they move forward or well they are going to move forward should we move forward with joining the planning process have we started thinking about how we would participate in that leave that to Terry uh so Megan and I are still collecting um information from our uh respective groups as well we we have no urgency whatsoever right now of um compiling a bunch of information unless we know for sure from the board that that's the direction you want to go um to Jim's point I think that there's a lot of good um uh intent behind it is the messaging is is awful and for Megan and I we'd love to see some other districts present a
058plan and see oh look what you're actually allowed to do you can share an enl teacher across three districts or two districts or something of that nature so that this is what the process could look like but we're not in any rush to meet any January 15th deadline or whatever they have out right now until we hear back from the board my my only contribution to that discussion would be number one we have to make sure that our participation in the planning process does not mean that we are uh already signing up to you know be beholden to whatever conclusions I mean it's more likely that um we would be mandated to adhere to whatever they they they agreed to regardless of whether we participate I would I would think that being at the table
059is better than not being at the table um because of that reason so but to Terry's point it seems like Administration may be looking to us to tell them what we think we should do so we're going to have to have a discussion at our first meeting in January yeah yeah anyway yes when the when the language comes out because to your point it's it all depends on how it's written right it's does not participating how do they address that they've addressed only two-thirds of the issue right does participating in planning can you participate in planning and then not sign on to the plan if you don't like the plan um because you could get some benefits just out of the planning and you could decide to you know do something ad hoc with a
060neighboring District without participating fully in the plan or yeah or the the Counterpoint that you just made you don't participate in planning and you have to abide by a plan that you've had no input in that could be bad too so we will wait and see what the language is we will wait and see what it looks like um lot of open questions and we just need to continue to monitor it and I Terry I just want to piggyback on something that you said of of you're looking for other districts and looking to see what is out there and what's possible it's interesting um there's a YouTube video that Nassau suffk Bose's put on um from mid to late October with uh Jeff Madison who is the um Commissioner of educ of not educ of
061the uh education policy P through2 education committee he's uh the boss of the guy we talked to and Mike Frank so they they were both on a zoom with a representative from Nassau suff bosis it's like an hour and a half long um and um he was oddly evasive he's like we were specifically not telling people what they can do because we want them to be creative and they weren't giving examples of like what they want it was kind of weird um so they're specifically like we want to put this out there and we want everybody to be super creative and dream stuff up and we're not going to give any examples um so I found that odd but if you have an hour and a half of your time I can I can email
062the link to folks if you'd like it um uh with that um that brings us to our second recognition of visitors any takers for public comment going once going twice all right uh with that can I have a motion to adjourn so move and a second from marora uh all in favor I I any opposed any extensions thank you very much we will see you in two weeks