CorpusRecord 28229

CCSD Board of Education Meeting Monday November 4th, 2024 @ 7 00PM

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Cornwall School District BOE Video
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Northwest Hills Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,257 words · about 80 min
Collected
2026-06-05

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right good evening everybody thank you for joining us here on our Monday November 4th Board of Education work session um I would ask everybody to please uh rise for the Pledge of Allegiance IED Alle to the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all okay our first item on the agenda is recognition of visitors uh recognition of visitors uh for any items on the agenda or other concerns uh Board of Education welcomes comments from the public each person wishing speak is asked to speak in the microphone identify themselves and respectively limit their comment to 3 minutes all speakers are to conduct themselves in a civil manner obscene language Lial statements threats of violence statements advocating racial religious or other

002forms of prejudice will not be tolerated persons wishing to discuss matters involving individual District Personnel or students should present their comments Andor concerns to the superintendent during regular business hours uh do we have anybody who uh would like to make a public comment at this time please uh microphone is on the end there if you could state your name and be great thank you thank you can you hear me okay good good evening uh my name is Natalie Ren I'm a mom of two in Cornwall and I'm a founding member of mothers out front which is a uh National Climate Justice organization uh essentially we're like a Grassroots movement where we're empowering local parents not just mothers uh to to work for environmental initiatives at the local level and um since our first meeting with

003Mr Dade two weeks ago our our team it's it's fairly new but we've grown from five members to 16 and we're still growing uh so I'm very excited to to be here tonight to share who we are uh the the main reason I wanted to come tonight is want to introduce mothers out front to you I think that we'll be a really great resource to you and to our community as we you know pursue environmental initiatives for our community but also to share our most um top priority uh with a call to action so at the moment um we as parents are are deeply interested in helping the district meet the New York State mandate for uh uh bringing in electric school buses for our district knowing that by 2035 we need a fully electrified

004Fleet I know that's a tall order and we want to be here to help you along the way so mother's outfront has Consolidated a lot of resources and to help direct districts to you know the different funding opportunities that there are um so I'm happy to share that and a few of our members have already reached out to some some of the members of the district but uh more importantly as parents we we worry deeply about our kids health and uh we're concerned about you know sending our kids and our bus drivers onto diesel buses where gases like nitrogen oxide and Benzene are extremely um harmful to to our health especially kids with you know developing lungs and brains and and it can cause asthma and cognitive problems and even cancer um what I didn't

005know until having uh joined this organization is that actually inside the the bus the uh amount of of toxins in the air are actually 10 times stronger than the exhaust that's on the outside so that's one thing we're concerned about um and also as parents we we worry about our kids future and climate change and we know that putting one electric school bus on the road is the equivalent of of saving carbon emissions of taking 100 cars off the road so every time that we purchase a electric school bus where one keeping the air cleaner but also we're we're preventing that um harmful decision of locking into 10 years of diesel air going out into our community by purchasing a a diesel bus so tonight I just wanted to share parents concerns but also uh

006that we do have a few steps that we'd love the the district to the board to consider um through the epa's clean School Bus program the Cornwall school district is actually eligible to apply for that Grant and uh we'd be eligible for up to $170,000 for the purchase of a bus and charging infrastructure and then through Nera Cornwall is considered a priority District so we'd be um eligible for up to 60% of the incremental cost of the bus and charging structures which is about 114,000 to 135,000 and then there's also I'm sure you're already aware of like the tax credits through the inflation reduction act and so forth and there's also um technical support and other free programs that we can kind of help direct youall to so there are kind of two steps that

007I I'd like the board to consider please step one uh I'd really encourage you to uh apply for the EPA funding the deadline for this grant is quickly approaching January 9 um that's something that we'd be happy to to help you with but I think it's something that that you could feasibly do there is a a webinar on I believe November 18 that kind of spells out how to do that but but we could also help direct you to that kind of paperwork and then the other oh and also just so you know applying to that Grant does not um commit us to purchasing a bus it's just reserving the money that's already on the table for our community and then second we ask that you encourage our Bus Company West Point tours to take

008bigger steps you know put their foot on the gas to to move forward a little bit quicker to meeting that that state mandate um and I think that's it I I believe that the Cornwall School District can really be a leader in this space and mother's outfront wants to be here to help you along so thank you very much great thank you uh for your comment uh would anybody else like to make a public comment this time okay uh thank you very much uh the next item on our agenda is a presentation from our construction manager uh the Palumbo group on uh updates on our current ongoing Capital project um I see L Lou Rodriguez and Bill dine in the audience so if you guys uh please take it away good evening uh members of

009the board and the district office uh tonight we're going to do a full project update on all three phases I assume everybody has the hand out if you flip to the first page we're going to do uh progress update on the scheduled budget for phase one two and three third page in uh Phase One schedule overview the contractor progress and schedule overview so phase one uh is complete and its entirety uh we just got a punch list on October 23rd that we're current currently working through it's um small in nature uh we've been working at night to get through it and we're almost complete to give you an idea of the scope of work that we did on phase one we'll start with leer Road uh new bathroom Renovations new doors and electrical service upgrade

010at Willow Avenue we did new bathroom Renovations and doors new interior stor fronts new stair railings new loading dock new storm water underground piping and catch spacing in the parking lot then and the new additional entryway to the auditorium and at the little Middle School lastly but not least uh new bathroom Renovations and new electrical upgrades on the next page you can see pictures of the loading dock and it's completed State turning the page uh the new store fronts at the stairwells and next you could see uh two locations of bathrooms that were renovated on the next page a third at Le Road uh is a picture of the uh work trucks that were installing the new light poles for the electrical upgrade and phase one at the middle school you can see two bathrooms

011that were renovated going to phase two uh was the high high school athletic field the middle school and leer road projects and we'll start off with the athletic field the high school and field project has receiv received the majority of materials needed for the project we always talk about procurement of materials and we've received most of them so the track and Tennis Courts uh the asphalt and Coatings have been completed uh not the track I apologize for that's just the tennis courts um and given back to the district for use the retaining wall at the tennis court was installed the new parking lot at the island is complete for district use new underground utilities have been extended to the football field the new asphalt and sidewalk with stairs complete at existing parking lot near the

012new tennis courts and upcoming we're going to see the new bleachers arriving this coming Monday on 11-11 and at the same time they're going to start install so this coming Monday we'll see some action happen out there uh the project is on time and within budget and expected completion the spring of 2025 and for phase two at the high school we can see a picture of the tennis courts on the next page we could see the new stairs and railings that were installed at the tennis courts new sidewalk and walkway that was completed between the parking lot and the new sidewalks I mean the the tennis court uh installing the new footings for the field lights uh very exciting day for that this is the uh football field lights and then when on the next

013page you can see the new footings being installed for the grand stands which are completed as of today phase two at the middle school uh demolition is complete the space is complete with mechanical electrical and plumbing uh which we call MEP roughing the floors are being prepped for self-leveling the new classroom is being sheetrocked and taped the storage room between the classro and the locker rooms are also being sheetrocked and taped the start of tile install is expected this this month the new Electrical uh mechanical units are expected to be installed this month as well we are also starting to prepare to start installation of the new ceramic tile the project as well is on time and within budget and expected completion the spring of 2025 in the first picture here we could see sorry

014just no problem the ceramic tile is in the locker room the the main area that's being renovated right now in the middle school is the locker room right that's correct yep question room is different I'm sorry yeah it's part of the it's adjacent to the locker room okay so it's kind of one one project when we when we demoed the old locker room the new classroom never existed so we created that classroom out of the old locker room space thank you thank you no problem uh so here in the first picture you could see uh what's happening kind of in its raw space starting the framing and uh Plumbing fixture roughing the next page uh we upgraded a new electrical service in that space to a 400 amp panel we located in the PE office

015sorry guys I wish I had more hands okay um same space uh you could see sheetrock and installation being installed and this is the this is actually the storage room we were just talking about between the new classroom and the locker room on the next page the uh this is the girls locker room being sheetrocked and taped and that's that's the last of the pictures for the Middle School um at Lee Road we installed new ceilings new lighting and controls in the classrooms the project was completed on time in the summer of 2024 and within Budget on the page with the pictures you could see uh the first picture there on the left is picture of us um in it's raw State um the protection the new ceilings going in and on the picture on

016the right is the finished product so phase three which is our newest phase and last phase of this Bond um progress that we're and schedule overview so the project consists of um new window replacements and two renovated bathrooms at Co new storefront at the middle school new pavement and two renovated bathrooms at Lee Road So currently uh our bids have been received and opened uh the window contractor has been fully vetted and awarded the project and the contractor is currently submitting insurances in front end documentation The Mechanical plumbing and electrical contractors have also been fully vetted and will be recommended to the district for approval to enter into contract the general contractor is currently being vetted and will have a recommendation by the end of the week this week have question sure uh the classroom

017cabinets and leer Road uh they were installed I remember the story the original shipment never arrived and we had to go with a kind of like a solution till we get the original equipment I mean arriving I mean have we done anything or are we still going with the temporary equipments I mean cabinets so the casework for ler Road believe was part of phase one um so we had the contractor back the vendor back uh several times we did have a deficiency list uh which is normally called a punch list but it was a pre-punch list for us um and we just recently received their substantial completion letter for that so I I believe that what's installed now is your permanent solution so the temporary cabinets were removed and the final product was installed in

018place I mean well yeah so what was what was priced and bought is what's installed in l Road okay I don't believe there's any temporary cabinets left in there if I could just if I could just interject bass there was um there was a whole set of new Cabinetry there was one piece there was one piece that was not correct that they delivered we used those until they brought the correct piece in and then they took those those incorrect ones away so everything's installed as it should be okay according to the design correct because I did a tour I believe Richard was with me uh at least a year ago and I saw that the temporary right things installed in they you know they didn't look good at all so they were all out and

019the final product they all they've been all replaced with the proper I think they did it over winter break or spring break last year I so it's been it's been fixed for it has been a while yeah yeah yeah when we went on the spring visit I believe they were completed or yeah they were fixed last okay yeah thank you thanks are there any other questions in regards to progress sure go ahead is the um I'm looking at the locker rooms the girls locker room and the boys locker room are the boys locker room and the girls locker room comparable square footage in space and size that's a good question um I believe they are yes I think that was asked by the architect once it's tough to get a good photo when you're under

020construction they do look I I have a question um back to phase two at the high school athletic field um the tennis courts I don't want to beat a dead horse but we thought they were going to be done sooner than they were if I recall because we thought the students would get on those courts pretty like within the beginning of the year and I don't think they did they managed clearly because we haven't heard much the track though I'm concerned because you know you corrected yourself but it's not finished the winter is coming I don't think you can do a lot of that kind of work when it's really cold so how are we assured the track is a much bigger entity to manage if we have to go someplace else no that that's

021a good question and just to start off with the tennis uh the tennis courts were scheduled to be completed at the end of the summer um which they I believe we were we ran two month or two weeks past that due to the coding so getting the asphalt there um long story short it has to breathe all those gases have to come out and get the coding on which which we did pretty successful within two weeks um the track itself we are on schedule uh the track is not scheduled to be turned over until June of 25 yep so it everything's arriving as it should so our students were on the tennis courts this year yes they're on their they're on the tennis courts right now great yep I had a question um and I

022know I brought this up at our meeting at our facilities meeting about the loading dock so my question is I know that there's nothing we can do at this point this is the loading dock at Willow the height but is there a solution to help them unload the lunches and to unload the Food daily because they're now lifting um so is there something we can do to help them with that I could speak to that so kind of as we discussed at the facilities committee it's something we're looking at there are variety of different solutions the thing to keep in mind is in order for that loading dock to have had the lip as I'll call it so that the the van that we used to bring the food over doesn't need to lift it

023could roll yet there's a certain requirement on slope that we have to maintain with s if we if we brought that up the the the slope and the length of the ramp would go all the way back almost to where the shed is so it's it just wasn't possible okay so to your point we have to find alternative Solutions yes and then my other question was I know that the uh teacher bathrooms or the staff bathrooms at the middle school the bids came in too high but those were in one of the phases um are we re rep putting it into another Bond how are we handling that because those do need to to be done as well okay so the intent is you know right now the facilities committee is working on the next

024Bond you know just basically what are the needs those that were not done are first front and center with regards to the needs for the next project I have a question about the uh the timing for the High School Athletic Facility so it seems you broke down some of the individual elements all on target for June of um so just so I understand the whole the whole package the whole facility ready for use by hand it over to the district without any restrictions by June 25 that's the current Target so so June is substantial completion uh at that point that means that every all the product has been installed um there is a product for punch list that comes after that where the architect and the district both review what's been installed and put together

025a list of deficiencies or um things that might not be correct uh 100% and then we allow the contractors to make those Corrections so we're anticipating in the month of June turning that turning that track over to you but our substantial completion date I believe is June 4th of 2025 um transparently I am thinking best case scenario High School graduation that seems like it's okay that's fine certainty is also acceptable those emails and updates absolutely not we'll be right in that bus loople that what about the track season I this might be more of an internal question but how and if you don't have an answer now that's okay but just maybe to put it on a future discussion so that we're track season is off the table as well so substantial completion sets us

026up for fall 25 Sports to rock and roll so anything that you're thinking spring is an absolutely no so we would be looking across country um having the first uh go around football uh starting to practice um but we'll be able to communicate those plans to the parents and track team and all that okay that's all I just want and track's not even uh worried about the track until winter great okay and and just to add to to that a little bit too one of the things set that holds us up is the track coding so the track coding has to be installed at 40° and Rising for at least 5 days and there's obviously a setting period to get on there so that's why spring was kind of pushed for that date so I'm

027going to turn the microphone over to Mr Rodriguez to give you guys a budget update that's on the back of your pamphlet if there any other no other questions for construction guys are forcing me to come to meetings oh sorry sorry um also I uh it's my fault that this is not on the screen I apologize to uh the audience it was my job to bring the Zip drive and I uh forgot it apologize next time I'll make sure it's here so the uh the budget summary that you see in front of you is uh what was also presented to the facilities committee um we try to create something that's a simple look and it gives you a good picture and understanding of where we are with the project upper leftand quarter is what was

028approved by the voters 22 million 994332 um that is all we can spend on this project and no more that's it um at the beginning of the project we really uh what we did was came up with a plan of submitting this project into phases up to S so that it would allow us to start work as soon as possible so that's why you'll see phase one phase 1 a phase two and then the last phase which phase three that we just uh made a recommendation for um you'll see the phases of work pre- budget so that first the second column really talks to our goals uh for bidding on all the uh the phases uh actual so this is the current current running totals which is a third column so it tells you where

029we are today with um with the contracts so you'll you'll see each contract their current contract value um Mount over or under what we had projected uh for pre- comments mainly uh who's doing the work and then on the farthest right hand column is uh remaining allowances that are built into the contracts that helps us for looking at any unforeseen conditions and whatnot so you'll see that uh phase one we had budgeted 4 million we're currently running at 4.8 million we are holding you'll see highlighted $90,000 we're still um closing out these contracts and and um um negotiating final changes with these contractors um so um that really talks to that and you'll see the contracts that we uh contractors were playing ball with uh united safety prox DSi F Shaw Nickerson uh phase two

030we had 1.5 million allocated 2.4 million is where we are uh currently the big number there is the windows at co co and again the remaining allowances that are built into those contracts you'll see on the right hand side um phase two you'll see 4.9 million was budgeted we came in at 4.7 or or uh 4.9 4.2 is where we came in we're 746,000 under that number you'll see the players there remaining allowances the athletic field we budgeted 7.29 4 million we came in at 7.28 for so we're about $99,500 under budget on that scope of work uh the one thing I did not change that was agreed upon at the last facilities that you guys are going to go with and upgraded scoreboard so you see I'm holding $111,000 for what we had budgeted

031during the referendum I say still to be awarded uh we want to uh negotiate that final number for an upgraded scoreboard and that's going to be another 30,000 on top of that number um so I'll update the spreadsheet and it'll show that final negotiated number for that scoreboard I'm sorry did we already vote on that no that's on uh later on today's agenda so you can ceue us up for that but the committee did recommend that we do that the facilities committee recommend which will be part of our discussion later but that's yeah later in the agenda um is to award that discuss it which is still holding the 115 corre until we get the official from you guys I promised dude we'd get you a vote one way or the other tonight and we've

032got both on the agenda and we're going to vote on one of them great uh phase three we had 1.9 million budgeted for uh the site work at CLE and at uh the Middle School uh we came in at 1.69 $828,000 on the budget there and we do have a contingency you'll see on the right hand side and allowances that are built into the contract we still are holding 33 30,000 for unforeseen conditions for the work that's still ongoing on top of that you'll see I have 150,000 that I'm holding in a construction contingency that just is another uh security blanket so to speak um so that brings us to 20, 89,4 on the hard construction side so hard construction side we're running $291,000 over on the incidental budget side we budgeted three 3,196 um

033currently we're running at 2,492 and you'll see the breakouts there of actual um numbers you'll see the actual contract with the architect actual construction management fee and what we're actually running with with actual numbers across the board there uh total project cost we're running at 22582 so we're running at about $412,000 under budget uh right now and including the 330 and the 150 of contingency so we're in a I think we're in a pretty strong position um as we move forward um again when you guys are talking about the scoreboard uh that's going to be an important part of that conversation um everything here we're taking into consideration again as Bill said you know we're looking to uh be completed by the end of the summer of uh 2025 and then we move into to

034the fall with any final tweaks to their HVAC systems and whatnot that are being installed but uh yeah any questions on the budget yeah thanks for the presentation uh phase three the difference between uh as you categorized that PR budget and awarded contract is substantial I mean what's what's the reason behind the difference on phase three phase three yeah at the very top well p uh the low bidder came after pretty aggressively if you looked at um what we try to do we when we budget we would hope that we're right in the middle of the game on bid day um when you look at the bids the bids actually went from 1.69 to over $2 million so you got an aggressive contractor local uh understands your District they went after it we have other

035contractors that don't know your District little further away and they didn't come after it as as aggressively so that's really what you're seeing there okay thanks the the catch that comes with the lowest bidder I mean was that looked at like very carefully I mean I can underbid everybody and give you like horrible job for instance so we go through a uh a pretty thorough vetting process we do uh a page turn it's not just a simple conversation they come to our office we go through the plans and specs and and make sure they understand the full scope of work um we also try to understand we uh uh the low bidder here vanon we've done quite a bit of work with them so they they do understand the uh the job so yeah we

036spent time with them vetting them y l thank you this is great news um I don't want to uh I don't want to look at uh gift horse in the mouth I just want to make sure I understand some of these uh number so under the it seem like we saved a lot on the incidentals um yeah so the big the big one on the incidentals was the uh Bond financing that was going to be my first question yeah so why why was that a just zero like what what was the context there so this is something when when we plan for referendums I always put a number in there for capitalized interest so it's really paying your interest during construction uh some districts will actually use the Bond as their as their funding source

037for that interest payment uh you guys have actually been paying it out of your general fund and will continue to pay it out of your general fund got it um and the other the only other one that jumps out of me we had put aside $75,000 for required independent testing and we didn't spend that how required was that independent testing if we didn't do it so I I have no I have uh two comments on the right they're included above under Hazmat so when you look at um um the 50 75 and 75 currently we're at 228 so those numbers for uh hasat monitoring uh the required testing the required exploration and we're also required to have uh based on we're over an acre of disturbance we have Swip uh regular Swip um um um

038someone's coming here once a month they sign in and really talk about how the site is dealing how we're dealing with things on the storm water side so that's uh so just so I understand it's it's it's covered just under a different category correct got it correct yeah that's why it said included above yep got it great thank you and just for clarification my recollection during the facilities meeting was that Hazmat monitoring I made a note that you were um that actual the awarded contract you were NE negotiating or questioning that I wanted to sit with Harvey and go through but that's not so that number May potentially be lowered from that 228 that number would not go up potentially it could come down yes depending on what was tagged to it if I could

039just interject here the um I'm confident that that number is correct because I was instrumental in paying it but um with that said the reason that it might be higher than budget for you have to keep in mind that we did a lot of work inside walls uh Plumbing electrical and so forth depending on what we find when we open up the walls we found certain instances where we needed to bring in and have the um abatement company test it there was a lot additional testing and there was in some cases we had actually a baate so that's that's part of why we have that and again that's why we have the contingencies in there as well yeah and that's a that's a good point Harvey when you look at phase one part of why

040we were over budget was once we did the exploratory we had a lot more asbestos than we had planned for even something as simple as when we took the casework out at each one of the of the Elementary classrooms the sink itself had to be Abad so we had to actually tent off the area just to Abate a sink which is crazy to think but that's that's how we had to treat it and we found that out after the referendum had passed any other questions for Lou on the construction bud so far great well thank you is this format okay if I keep this great running for the next meetings we can do that and I'll make sure I bring my Zip drive next time yeah no this is great and I think it's really

041important to highlight um for a community um that we're at a point now where we have awarded all of our bids and um or about to award all the bids but we've received all the bids and we will award uh the remaining bids at the next uh board meeting for those uh remaining contractors at Co but um you know once we have those votes in two weeks that we will you know officially be under budget and you know we started out a little rocky last summer with on time but we've recovered and now we're you know we're on time with all the work that we're doing now and you know to deliver a project of this magnitude um you know mostly on time and under budget is uh is really great we feel yeah thank

042you we feel you know pretty good about where we are yeah you know it's a it's like you said it's a strong statement to be where we're at right now and hopefully we won't you know hit some of these contingencies and there'll be you know a couple hundred, left over at the end which we have some some work still approved with s and we could do some additional that's correct smaller projects not that a couple hundred, are small but it looks like there may be some leftover money to to tackle some of those projects as well which is great thank you thank you all right moving on to the next item on our agenda which is committee reports um I didn't print my committee list like I should have so we'll go by memory um

043a for audit I I don't think you have any updates nothing to report yeah um uh facilities uh I'm the chair there since I have the microphone I think we just kind of covered what that was really we went over um this presentation just a little more in depth at our facilities meeting last week um we're going to meet next month and start to um really try and put together the projects we've identified the needs and and we're we're trying to get uh District uh Harvey is working with the Palumbo group Harvey and Walter to get some numbers together and at our next meeting we'll start putting together um what we'll do for Capital project number two now that we have uh the $5 million saved in that Capital account and we can turn that

044into approximately $20 million uh by passing a referendum with the community um Communications committee Brendan yeah so we uh we had our our first meeting a few weeks ago now um we talked about a lot of it um initiatives for the coming year but the one that is solidified now we I think we all agreed that um it's very important to update the community as you were saying just about where we are uh in the capital project and uh as we've done uh as we did last year we will have a uh Community Forum to do just that uh the date on the calendar is uh Tuesday November 19th which is two weeks from tomorrow so uh we'll start to um get that out space pending I know uh District space is uh will probably

045shoot for the Middle School frankly because I know this building will be likely occupied and that's for an update on the capital project yes where we stand now and giving the the full breath of where were we um a lot of before and afters so people can get a full sense of uh of where that was and um we'll also have a um some coverage in the Cornwell local coming up about just that so get uh getting that that positive news out about where we are with the capital project and then um again we discussed other initiatives for later in the year but nothing solidified yet so more to come thank you uh visitation Richard I know you've got a little update for us yeah thank you so I mentioned this at the last meeting

046during committee reports that the visitation committee did observe the new drop rotation schedule that was implemented at the high school um we were there during the community lunch um which has been a Hot Topic recently since school started so I'm just going to go into a very general um report on the observations that we saw how we saw it some of the positives and um I'm going to start by saying I think a lot of the students that we talked to and saw I think a lot of them did like the new sense of flexibility that they have um the different options they have on how they spend their lunch um they can sit with their friends they can be part of an extracurricular Club there were some kids in the gym participating in in

047some athletic activities basketball volleyball competitions so I think that was definitely a positive something that I hope continues and it was great to see a lot of our teachers running those clubs and running the athletic competition so I want to thank everybody for that I think so yeah did you see everybody were manages to find a nice place to sit so or like people sitting on the floor or yeah I mean we were also a couple weeks in so I think people are still learning and getting used to it um I'll get to that in a minute here but um how would I say it I think huh yeah I mean the students that are reporters here student reports they they seem to think that it was getting better and that things were improving um

048so but when we were there definitely had something that stood out to us and one of our thoughts were maybe we need to add more tables right in the lobby in the outside in the hallways so that's something we're going to look at I met with Terry and Megan a couple weeks ago and they were also meeting with the student government and student leadership teams at the high school we also talked about the auditorium if you wanted to add that you using that space yeah as well yeah I think we should kind of bring up the fact that it wasn't just one side it we had both sides of it which was pretty much coming out the same is there was a lot more that were not happy with the way situation right if I

049remember right yeah I mean yeah yeah yeah so Auditorium first right so the auditorium was used as a quiet room that's for students that would rather work on assignments or sit in a quiet area where they have some time to work on whatever they'd like to do um I think there's a way maybe to utilize that space a little better or more effectively especially when the weather's not going to get better it's going to get colder out you're not going to be able to eat and sit outside so maybe that's something that we they talked about in their meeting um but we thought that might have been a good way forward good recommendation um what else so something on that with the you know both sides I think something we should do and I think

050the committee agreed is to have a follow-up visit especially when the weather's getting a little bit cooler out just to see you know if there's any differences or a different opinion out there or different observations and uh you know feelings we have as a committee so I would definitely make that recommendation and I'll talk to Megan and Terry about that setting that up so that's pretty much it unless anybody else has anything to add any questions yeah uh just for the community and the board uh at large uh principal willhelm um jacqu pel Megan Chila who are uh leading uh this effort uh each and every day um invited uh the uh PTO president um food service was there um in addition to student students from all different uh grade levels to hear directly from

051them I I got to sit in on that conversation um there were uh buckets presented to the students of give us the feedback want give us your feedback on seating give us your feedback on offerings uh provided during uh Community lunch give us your feedback on hold your breath academics and how how that's uh going um with the drop rotation uh schedule so um what we're trying to do is uh get information from the broadest amount of students and staff possible rather than you know with if five if you ask five people you might not get a full representation of of how it's going um I can tell you that my overall um takeaway from um that time with uh the students is our seniors were very um honest about yep we finally kind of

052gotten over not having a senior table they they were kind of talked about do the math you can't have a math you can't have a single senior table when you have the whole class uh trying to sit at that same spot but we also had a healthy conversation of what does a new tradition look like um there wasn't always a senior table we used to go out for lunch when uh the high school was at the middle school so just tried to help them realize that the current state is not necessarily what's always been um in place so our seniors kind of started talking about meeting with the senior class advisors and coming up with uh New Traditions um a surprising takeaway from me was um there's so much offered during Community lunch so we

053had one uh student who had to be in three different places at at once because she's that involved uh so um there was a student group meeting with Megan uh there was a student group doing a um blood drive um uh I'm sorry a uh fight cancer um fundraiser in the gym and then something else that she was involved in so um we can get you more information from like our staff perspective they were surveyed to see how they're feeling about uh Community lunch and then we plan to do the same with a broad uh spectrum of students like tell us how you're um enjoying it what feedback do you have for improving it um but um I think you'll be pleased with the data that you'll get from all of our all of our

054students to say that there won't be things that uh people don't like is is um unrealistic so uh they also talked about uh the lunch time um the first 20 minutes is long lines so I just made an observation that last year when I observed lunch the first 20 minutes is a long line and that was with three lunches so it was just really trying to help everyone wrap their heads around um what do they really like about it how can we improve it um and we'll continue to refine over the course of time but we'd be happy to set up another um observation um because our our kids are our kids and our staff are great thank you for that Terry um I I think I'll just add just Piggyback in your point Richard

055um I know visitation I'm sure we'll visit the high school just you know tag that in right just make sure that we work on the timing to get that to see lunch again but certainly hearing from the student reps it sounded like little bumpy start and we've been continually improving and glad to hear that um you've been involved and and uh Miss wilham and her team have really been you know meeting with the students and working to make sure that we get this um to a place where everybody wants it to be so um that's good to hear are there any committees that I missed I think I got everybody policy yeah sorry yeah I mean we have our the the one policy that was on a first reading last week is on a second

056reading this week um we had I we'll have our second policy meeting of the year over the winter um there were some policies that were taken out of the first patch which will then be updated and included in that but we're on track great thank you um all right committee updates done there let's go on to the consent agenda use of the consent agenda permits the Board of Education to make more effective use of its time by adopting a single motion to cover those relatively routine matters which are included any member of the board who wishes to discuss individually a particular piece of business on the consent agenda May so indicate and that item will be considered and voted on separately uh we've got items two through 7 today uh can I get a motion

057so moved and a second and who would anybody like to pull any item m 2 through 7 yes please um I am looking at uh Personnel actions um a two the winter coaching appointments okay so just we'll just pull item two and then we'll we'll dig into the yeah thank you uh any other items that anybody would like to pull on the consent agenda uh five number five okay um so then we will any anybody else all right so we will take a vote then on one 3 4 six and seven um all in favor I I any opposed any extensions okay motion carried and then we will go back to item number two on the Personnel actions um Tiffany you had I'm sorry what did you want to pull out the winter coaching appointment

058okay and you I'm assuming you just want to abstain from that correct okay um great so we will separate um yes item two on item two um the winter coaching appointments will take a separate vote on that uh so voting on all other Personnel uh appointments except for item two all in favor I I any opposed any abstentions okay and then then uh on item two all in Winter coaching appointments all in favor I I any opposed no opposed abstentions uh Tiffany is an abstention uh so all of those have carried and now we move on to item [Music] five uh cafeteria workers MOA uh bass actually sorry can I get a motion to move and a second now bass for discussion thank Jim yeah no problem uh I pull that item just for again

059shed more light on this uh memorandum of agreement uh is it just kind of you know the boiler plate thing or anything specific about it this time uh so this uh particular Mo MOA is with our uh cafeteria uh unit um as a result of the drop rotation schedule in the community lunch there's um additional um work um being um uh under the responsibility of our head cook um all of that's happening at one time versus spread over three different lunches those this is to address that impact for the head cook only thank you okay um all in favor I I any opposed any extensions okay okay thank you very much that brings us to the end of our consent agenda uh next item item F old business uh scoreboard discussion number one um so

060I will kick that off being the chair of the facilities committee um last time we discussed the differences between the doctronics uh what I'll call more traditional scoreboard similar very similar to the scoreboard that's currently at the middle school um football field and then we discuss the digital um digital scoreboards the fully um digital video scoreboard um and the differences there at our last meeting and we decided to uh just sort of put a pin in that discussion and revisit it as we got the bids back on Co to see hey do we have the actual money um the cost is uh about $20,000 on the scoreboard itself and then an additional approximately $20,000 for cabling um and other infrastructure work um um as you can see uh we came back um and we are

061have approximately 400,000 to 410,000 under budget I believe and the presentation we got from Palumbo um so 412 there we go um we as a facilities committee the unanimous unanimous recommendation was to uh approve the digital scoreboards product the fully video um scoreboard product since we had that extra budget Elanor okay well I apologize that I missed that nearly unanimous nearly um so uh that's kind of where we're at you know last time we had the discussion we um said hey let's wait and see if we have the money uh right now $40,000 is you know about 10% of the $400,000 that were under budget um so if anybody has any discussion points but I think it's a lot easier discussion now that we have the numbers in front of us um Tiffany had her

062hand up first just I just wanted to point out a technicality that's not actually 40,000 because if you look at the documents we were given the um athletic fields are under budget so there is a 9,483 surplus for what it's worth so there could an argue could be an argument could reasonably be made that that's part of the athletic field budget under the same sub heading so it's really not actually 40,000 sure but then you also factor in the yearly costs to update digital so it's kind of a wash so it's because I from what I understand it's about 10,000 a year I think it was six or seven but yeah there is an annual um cost for the software yes that wouldn't come out of the capital project no yeah yeah U I'm in

063favor of going fully digital uh for for mainly one reason I mean this is like when I heard like the pros and cons and everything like comparing Apples to Apples uh I thought like the video fully digital display uh is a better is the better option uh because because it can be used for more than than playing a football game per se you know like graduation uh sponsorships I mean it allows you to do more and rather than this to come to us as a board as an afterthought or another upgrade few years down the road while we're at it let's do it thank you bass appreciate that Brendan I just want to understand the numbers we we keep saying that it's a $40,000 difference but but then the difference in the resolutions uh is

064only 20,000 so the scoreboard itself the quote from each provider which includes uh all of the infrastructure the footings and the steel that it's erected on is $220,000 there's an additional $220,000 approximately um I think it was like 21 maybe for um cabling so it needed um like full fiber optic cabling from the scoreboard up to the Press Box as well as um a couple thousand dollar in some engineering work and that'll just be taken out of the rest of the 400 some OD thousand yeah okay may I make one further point please off of what um Mr Dr shakro was saying um there are other opportunities as were explained to us in uh facilities committee is there also an educational component students will be working on videos students will be working on loading um

065the videos onto the scoreboard so we'll be incorporated into classroom work as well yes that's uh certainly an opportunity thank you we can get a video of Brendan up there saying go come vote vote on the budget vote in May of everybody you looked around the table and you thought of me thanks as the head of the communications committee can I point out that that would be illegal you're not allowed to use District resources to encourage people to don't look at me it was his idea I just pointing out before we even get there I didn't say vote Yes I said vote I was thinking can't do that either while you were spinning that very cynical suggestion I was thinking that uh various drama clubs could use it to Hawk donation during football games so

066I think that's a great idea but Christian's going to tell me later why that's illegal too yeah um great so I you know I think we covered a lot of um the issues in our in our last meeting when we had the the abbreviated discussion that we cut off about you know the differences between the two scoreboards that um the real piece that was alluding us was the the dollars and cents and we have that now so um any other questions or um comments on this Christian just a clarification so last meeting we had put off the Co bathrooms to a future project is a high priority correct so two Co bathrooms are being done on the first floor and then um the other Co bathrooms will be remaining for and those have been taken

067out which is they were in the original plan correct resp I'll let Harvey speak to that I would I'm looking for clarification because that was before it's not a yes or no answer I'll let Harvey can speak to it a little bit better than I can so the way that the bids were sent out was the there was a base bid which in this case included the two bathrooms on the first floor for Co it also included the two bathrooms in this building over near the gym and the other bathrooms that elanora alluded to earlier and the ones that you're talking about that are on the second I'm sorry on the third floor and there's one on the second those were put in as alternates and the reason for that is we knew that if

068we did not break that out these P these bids prices would have come in Far exceeding what we could afford if we could have afforded them we would have just awarded the alternate as well but it was a good thing we did break them out because we would not been able to afford them so what was the estimate for the cost or what it would what is the the placeholder for these bathrooms of these different parts of that as alternates are you saying what what did the bids come in for the alternates uh so just to be clarified because the numbers is that so we are doing two bathrooms in Co we are not doing two bathrooms at leer road we are not doing third floor bathrooms at Co no and then faculty bathrooms which

069is what I believe you were saying when the ones that Elanor alluded to okay we are we are doing two bathrooms at Co we are doing two bathrooms here so that is happening and and what is the cost of what is not being done roughly I mean I don't have that with me but I believe don't call me but I think it was all the other bathrooms that we we did not do was was a good million dollars was that before they knew about the asbest and all of that because that was no that's all factored in but I mean course just curious but of course you open up a wall and and don't more po old buildings yes okay is that it for you Christian I mean clarifies it for me okay so great

070thank you any other questions comments okay so I think we're ready to vote and let's be let's make sure we're crystal crystal clear on what we're voting on here um so item two we'll take it in order here is resolution number one um is for doctronics that is the lower price scoreboard yes I'm sorry that's already in the budget though right that's already that I don't want I don't want to complicate things but you can you turn your just microphone yeah um whether we vote on this or not it's that one was the one that would happen this is the one that we would vote on as being different the the answer is yes the money is in the budget for the for the for the digital one but this actually is awarding it to

071the actual company okay got it um that's we can take it that way Christine let's let's do number two I think we have the votes I think people want to do resolution number two item number three in Old business we'll vote on that first which is $135,900 I I've got one two three four five six uh all opposed one two three um any extensions no because we have nine um just for the avoidance of Doubt since it's on the agenda here let's go back to resolution number one to remove it from the agenda that's even better than than voting no on it thank you we have a motion to remove it from the agenda a second all in favor I thank you Christian that was a better way to handle it um great um so

072the next item then we move on to new business we have two items of new business uh item number one is polling place discussion um we had um a request from the facilities excuse me from the communication committee uh that came through to our agenda meeting to discuss potentially adding a second polling place for the springtime um budget and Schoolboard member election um Brendan you're the chairman of that committee do you want to do that or do you want to well I would uh yeah I'll give a very brief overview it just came up organically through our conversation it wasn't um on our committee agenda um and then we we agreed though that it probably wasn't strictly a communication committee topic that if we were going to talk about it more it actually should be

073kicked up to the board so uh that's what we're doing now um I know Christian was the to my memory was the originator of the suggestion so I don't know Christian if you'd like to add anything to that sorry if Richard wants to add anything can can we brief the community at large on why we would or we shouldn't that's what I'm trying to get to yeah but I mean I also give it to Jim really I don't want to uh I don't know if you have anything to present about it if not I would uh I would defer to Richard who initially had the idea yeah I just I didn't know where it came from because I wasn't in that committee meeting so that's why I kicked it to you because you're the chairperson

074of the committee uh but if Richard if you want to um discuss it please take it away yeah um so it came up when we were talking about I think capital project future budget votes um how to reach more people and this is something that's been in the back of my mind for you know a while since I've gotten involved because I do live in New Windsor I live on Jackson Avenue so that would be considered the other side of the district and I can speak for myself for people I know in the area you sort of that I think the one polling place we have right now it's not convenient for everyone to get to there people have busy lives they work all day they have kids they have a lot of things going

075on and it's not convenient for someone that lives in the reserve or lives where I live to go to CCMS to vote and I think whether well it's I know it's not intentional so it's unintentional I think it it unint inally just like discourages voter participation just because people don't come out I mean Schoolboard voter turnout is really low and I believe New Windsor has more registered voters in the Cornwall School District than like cornan Hudson so I just think that's something to keep in mind and I'm totally in favor of this I think it would be a great step forward okay does anybody else have any um Tiffany just a quick comment our um CCMS is those same people that you're talking about and I certainly support and encourage voter turnout um I think

076historically um School Board turnout is just not going to be the same as it is in you know a a an election for other you know government officials and even if you look at that if you have a I'm going to say supervisor race totally hypothetical you're not going to get the same turnout in a non-presidential election year as you get in a presidential election year so we got to compare apples to apples when we say that the vote or turnout is low which I agree it is um I wish everybody would get out and vote but this is the same place the people who've chosen to live there send their children to middle school so they go there for their children's Middle School when they're when they're in fifth through eighth grade they go

077there for their plays they go through the athletic events so it's not an uncommon un familiar place to go and if we really looked at it how inconvenient is it how many miles away is it from the reserve to CCMS for I'm I'm guesstimating I don't know it's not like you're asking somebody to go to New York City to vote or go to Duchess County to vote this is just my two cents I also I'm going to couple that argument with looking at the additional cost to the district that the superintendent provided to the board there's this significant cost associate Associated I mean it took us four months to decide on a scoreboard over $40,000 um but yet we're willing to um I haven't heard anybody else bring it up or talk about the additional

078cost that would go into adding an additional location for voting all for voter turnout but I I disagree with adding an additional location can I can I just comment I'm sorry on it's not just people people who have children in the schools who are voting so you're absolutely correct the people who they have those their children are going to CCMS so if your kids go there you can certainly drive there and vote but it's not just those people we want to come out to vote so you have an older population that maybe is living way out there um you know our district goes way out and they may not be able to get to town to get to the middle school so I'm not I'm not saying one way or the the other we just

079have to take into account that it is not just the parents and the families of the students who are here who are going get we're trying to get out to vote I just I I have to just say this is more than just the reserve okay and it's more than four four miles is not four minutes to get across town so I I know but if the argument is it's it's a short distance it's not always a short amount of time I'm not arguing we should do it it has to make Financial sense there has to be an Roi there has to be a benefit but I don't think we can just dismiss it because it's within a certain mile radius um the costs that were presented yeah probably not worth it that would be

080my you know based on that fact but not based on distance or convenience um if I may just for the community um who's watching this um we've referenced the cost a couple times um we asked the administration to provide this um in advance of this discussion and uh the total cost for a second facility at each election is a little over $5,000 $515 and that includes election inspectors voting machine technicians food and beverage table chairs um voting machine rentals um facility rental cost depending on where it is um is blank but that you know could obviously add to that as well and if the budget does fail uh which has not happened recently but there' be a second boat so that would be $110,000 for you know both votes inclusive so just uh information to

081share for those that don't have it in front of them so there's your 40,000 for the scoreboard I'm just interjecting a little humor here if I could just um the only other thing that I I just asked the board to consider and and again I'm not like Elanor one way or the other um is uh the logistics uh so we have uh quite a time getting all the people in place in one location uh we have only one person who's really kind of overseeing everything going on that's been Harvey um all these years so just imagine splitting that into two and all the coordination um that that would take um the logistic side I just ask everyone to um keep top of mind uh with regards to what does that end of night look like

082to really bring everything together to tabulate the votes and not have it go into the next day um is just something and again I'm not weighing in either way it's just there is a logistical side to um to things going on with the size of our our district bass very quickly I I I don't see enough justification for this idea I mean always like Innovation is good like you're proposing something new uh but again it's kind of you know uh cost and benefit if you want I mean actually that that applies here uh it's not going to be free the way I looked at the numbers that uh I believe Terry provided it's like you just double I mean the amount from 15 to 30 I mean if I'm right uh so the cost is

083a factor and again I mean for the community living in newer I mean uh uh sending their kids to the district uh like it's not it it is convenient to send the kid to learn but it's not convenient for me to go just one time a year to go and vote I don't see the point I'm sorry thank you bass Christian so I'm going to divide this into two pieces one is just the kind of address engage with the cost question and then secondly because I'll talk about the benefit because I don't think we are fully looking at that so let me just look at the cause question um let's just start off with just Newberg has nine polling locations wers has six um they're not nine times larger or six times larger so the

084numbers quoted are basically assuming the ask is for let's set up the New Windsor early voting location with exactly the same resources I've been running for 2our lines and let's double that you have over capacity in your voting place I have talked to many of the poll workers who both work the regular polls for general elections as well as our polls over many many years and I will not since they're not here I will not quote them but they would I think put um a much lower number on what it would needed to run two pole locations and then what was cited for us there and it just reminds me of a previous discussion about AP Calculus where the ask was for one class and then the number given for us was a full Fe

085FTE and so like if you want to in a sense red find it you're always going to make it larger and it just reminds me of the internet meme where someone budgets $4,000 for candles and then wonders why they can but make their budget so I realize it's not going to persuade anyone and I can go through the individual cost of the machine and talk about what is a pole worker because it's $200 per pole worker and the DM and the food and all the other things like that and say well that's not really what the real number is and also if we're going to include let's say the revote which has only happened once in the last 20 years um and that we've been budgeting $5,000 in that in that contingency what have we

086done with that $5,000 that we've set aside for the possibility of all that happening if you want to look at an expected value the annual expected value on that is about $2 $300 given the probability of the event so been budgeting that money has gone back into the budget and so the point about that I don't think that's a proper way it's like looking at your allowance for doubtful accounts and accounting and assuming that 100% of your accounts receivables will not be paid and therefore creating 100% allowance and that does not seem to be how an accountant would budget for that for let's say a legal contingency or for unpaid debts or things that are have a probabilistic aspect about the future but I realize that you know talking about those details is probably not

087going to convince someone who's convinced so I'm going to talk a little bit about just why I think benefit for this so as you can we use the middle school which of course as you can see is in the geographical center of the district irony it's not and if you look at and this is based upon the Board of Elections the precinct data to show where voters are actually in the district we have about 2400 in Cornwell and Hudson approximately 3500 a little bit about in what you might call F Cliff of the upper Village and then about 606 on the western side of the district so how can we see what you know if you're talking about one polling site and you wanted to actually make it convenient for everyone there's an obvious location

088that is and the obvious location for one site would be the high school not the middle school because that would actually not only be the geographical center of the district it also would be the center of the population in the district because of the distribution of the numbers but I looked at something else over the last 20 years which is how do candidates do when they come from different parts of the district and this is not about the candidates but this can show you what is the distortionary effect of having the polling place in a particular location so if you look at those three zones The Village the upper Village and then the Western Cornwall New Windsor and Woodbury and you look at candidates that have come from that well the score for the people

089on the west side of district is eight wins and 14 losses for the upper Village it's 15 wins and three losses for the village there's 16 and five that's a pretty big dispar it and we've been talking a lot about you know disparities and how it looks in the district now here's the thing is that of all the people who have won on the western side of the district only one person has been reelected in the last 20 years where virtually everyone who has running a different part of the district has been reelected pretty much as long as they wanted to run and if I was like a political scientist and I was saying where are you going to put a polling site I would say this looks like a lot like you are putting

090a big thumb on it but it's not about whether the candidates win or lose it's about the attention that's given to different parts of the district so for example 3 years ago there was a discussion of a a Cornwell Middle School extra bus to the reserve and it was put onto the budget discussion and it wasn't brought up or voted on or really even in serious consideration because when you have let's say and look this is not about saying people are consciously deciding that but everyone has blind spots and when you have blind spots because you don't have have to respond to certain voices it's a lot easier to have bigger blind spots for certain people so that middle school bus because people coming from this Middle School who then have their children out in

091the reserve ask for an extra bus to not get passed another thing is that we'll vote on and probably consider again the water exemption since we'll be asked again the 6,000 which is half the voters in the district generally do not get their water from the village water source and that's another distortionary aspect that's pretty big you could walk down the hall and look at the elementary school map and look at the catchman areas and you can see one that's set up to have a community school and two that are basically a checker board of different areas of the rest of the district that's a distortionary and we just talked about why is experience different in different elementary schools well if you looked at the per pupil expenditures and go to the Department of educ

092US Department of Education what you'd find is in some years Co has more on a per pupil basis than that than other the other elementary schools now that's not intentional but that's because when you have a certain catchment area and the population changes and you have the same and more or less allocated resources that goes up and then here are some examples of just let's say the failure for attention so when the district put up signs announcing the budget vote how many signs did the district put up outside of 9W one for the 6,000 people who are on the western side of the district they put a about 10 and maybe I'm not getting the right number but that kind of shows the blind spot that you're having when you put the signs announcing the

093budget vote in one area and if you can look at candidates where they run there was a whole section of District that not one candidate put really any signs at all and that shows an absence of attention John adelyn in June talked about you know when I first ran I went up the Skyline Drive and I didn't even realize it was part of the district I mean I know I know it was and remember when I ran two years ago I was the only candidate that had a sign out there because I do know that's part of the district and the other five candidates didn't have one sign if you did Christin thank you then you know what I thank you and I apologize for the mistake but I think the point was still the

094same so here's a good another example when you don't have a polling place in a particular place in 2020 we had easy voting because people could mail on their votes turnout went up a near just under 100% in Cornwall would show you there's a lot of people that would vote and you can read the political science literature or you could read on School District elections alone Vladimir kogan from Ohio State or Michael hartney from Stanford University who study all the different things that affect and put let's say a balance on the vote and you would find that more or less they would be consistent with the idea of that but here's the last way to look at it so we do have a good example of what is a proper number of polling sites and

095Miss gallano mentioned let's say in presidential elections and offe elections the presidential election in Cornwall which is not the whole District we get about a little over 6,000 votes over the last 20 years in an off-ear election we get about 4,000 how many polling sites for that that number of Voters five now the average over the same period the average voters in a school district election is about 1,760 or so so that's 3 to one in terms of the number of Voters but 5 to one in terms of the number of polling sites so that would indicate that if we're going on the same population the same number of Voters the same poll workers it would suggest that the proper number of polling sites is somewhere between two and three and I think it's worth

096doing because democracy matters especially because it makes people respond to voices in different areas and I use several different examples about why we should listen to certain voices now if you're like me and a business teacher and every year you teach about demographics and you use Cornwall and Hudson in Cornwall and you see this data every single year when your students research it and I could tell you about the women's apparel versus men's apparel spending in Cornwall if you're interested but then you also know that there's a lot of differences between the residents it's not like everyone is let's say a replication in the district which means there are parts of our district that are quite different in terms of every demographic ategory in terms of idiographic categories then the type of districts where you

097see people tend to win and where most of the voters come from and if we were we could prove this because we could look at the poll book and just by looking at the street names you would see probably the undercount in terms of let's say why more people uh vote here than in other place so that's the ab that's the reason why I think it's a respect for the voters and I'll just point just to compare numbers since we did that talking about other small costs the pum for an administrator that eight people voted on recently is over $1,000 a day so it doesn't take too many of those pums to get to $110,000 which would be a really high number for the cost of adding one polling place J I'd like to just

098ask a couple of quick questions um are there minimums required for Staffing a polling place and is that what's reflected because part of my thinking is you know we're if we have two polling places then we would expect that the vote share at each place would be uh ideally split evenly right if you're placing them correctly so that you maybe you need you don't need to double your resources that you could have less resources at each place but I that was factored in yeah something that makes Harvey Harvey is you know he looks at what is the budgeted amount that um he's comfortable presenting um so there's too many what ifs here Harvey's going to approach this from we have no idea how many voters are going to turn out at Bethlehem Church versus um

099CCMS it could be a 10% 90% split but part Harvey can't guess that there's going to be 10% cost needed at one location versus the other so in order to give a a a sound recommendation to the board that's what he did it's not him trying to influence a vote or anything it's the way Harvey approaches sound fiscal which is why we've never been in fiscal stress um while he's been here um so we don't know we'll know a lot more year two of looking at actual turnout and things of that nature and we could adjust but until then we know what success looks like at one location so we would replicate it for two Brendan if I could also add to that um those that are advocating for another place are also indicating that

100it would draw more voters so again we don't know how many but we have to anticipate and the last thing I think we want to do at least initially is to have a long line out the door it'll just disenfranchise people from coming back to next year no I I I agree with that you don't want to launch it and it's a disaster right um it's really a a self-inflicted wound at that point um yeah I mean I think the um I agree that having a second polling place uh would help lower the friction for people who live in the Reserve I know from the U my own experience knocking on doors out there it is a harder ask to get people who live in the reserve to vote uh versus people who live in

101my own neighborhood which is much closer to the Middle School um and those tend to be I think anecdotally I don't have hard data to back it up but um The Reserve attracts a lot of families who are uh in the district or in that neighborhood to go to the district and they also therefore have kids and it's just generally harder for them to to get around so um I think that uh and we do have a district that is growing in that direction um and I think that you you look at something and say will this District do this eventually and I think yes we will almost certainly do this eventually um then the question is should we do it now that's where it becomes a little bit more nuanced and you start getting

102into cost and everything um but I it might be be more helpful to just think of it in terms of like this is this is where we are going and I think this is uh where we should go um and I think the If part of our goal in every budget season is not only to get out as many voters as possible um but also I frankly reach those that we know do support schools and trying to uh make it easy for them to vote I I think that there are probably a lot of votes in that area U so I think this is a this is sensible I would like to see the number come down but I I understand everything that uh that Harvey said and I agree with that you can't you

103can't uh you can't go halfway and then it's a it's a disaster then you've just shot yourself in the foot so I don't know where it goes from here I don't really know um well you know I've got a um a few questions that I've jotted down some things I want to research some things I want to ask the administration so I don't know that we have enough information um and this is just a discussion tonight I don't think that there's certainly no time sensitivity right there's certainly no time sensitivity to this um that we need to act on it tonight you know um I'd imagine can can I just ask a question given the map pretty much that Christian presented if if we can't go with two polling places Is it feasible to switch

104it to a more centrally located like do it at the high school instead of the middle school okay I would just thr my two cents in I would be very cautious about changing how we vote um just because it is so ingrained in people's minds they go to the middle school I think that that might have unintended consequences I think it's you keep one and you add another in my view that's the best approach I I would agree with that Brendan Ian I think we could but I think that would be a poor idea because those numbers are astounding the amount of people that are are further away from where we are currently voting yeah so um as I said I I you know I have a few questions that I would like to ask

105and what I would like to research um I'm going to do that we'll revisit this at a later date um I think that ultimately my you know I think the the the strongest point you made Christian is we want more people to vote um we're all believers in democracy up here and the more people that we get to vote the better um I'm not sure that we are that if you added a second polling place you would see a substantial increase but I could be wrong um it could be something that we do on a you know test basis say we're going to do it for two years and then Compare the numbers and and see and if it doesn't you know substantially improve then we don't have to continue in the future um so

106that could be one way forward too um so I'd like I guess if anybody has further questions as they reflect upon it um Christian if you want to email out some of that you know demographic data that you shared I you and then the source as well if people are interested in I mean obviously is your mic on just yeah for the I hit it off and then on um so I mean obviously it's a dry erase boort I would gladly provide the supporting information I think you probably you didn't erase it already well you know I just added some zeros to some numbers but like no but um there there's this is on the board of elections of Orange County website that goes down to the W level that's how you can look at

107the distribution between areas that's the basic Source um so I gladly will share that information with people um and I will just can I make one last point I know I talked at it at length but just one last thing one thing we know that's going to be happening next May is that the construction on the um the Main Street bridge is going to be ongoing and that's a profound blockage from anyone who is west of traffic circle at Quaker and Main Street and that will be under construction in May next year brid is the bridge slated to be closed at any point so they took down one lane and then they have to take the under Lane if you look at the County website that's working on it it will be under construction during

108that time and but I mean it's it's under construction now but it's open it's yeah it's open it's down to half it's it's even tighter I'm just pointing that as one additional consideration of why this might be a good year to experiment with another site okay may I make an anecdotal comment please forgive me I just I I I can't help but have to make this anecdotal comment I think there as someone who lives on that side of the district right there is this sort of like Cornwall and non-c Cornwall thing that happens and I think some of um what you presented Christian you know the bus for example right I think when you when people or or folks on a certain side of town can start to think like oh I'm being picked on

109I think it's a reminder and I'm not saying that that the case but I think it's a reminder to all of us on the board especially that when we make decisions that impact you know a certain side or or a certain part of town that we really explaining the why because I remember that particular thing and it wasn't because it was the reserve there were other reasons behind it and I'm not suggesting that's why you were making the point but I you think that there are folks that sometimes will jump to conclusions because we're not in Cornwall proper and in order to keep a community that is you know collaborative and a culture that is inclusive I think it just is a nice reminder to all of us to to be able to explain the

110why when we're making decisions that might not be the outcome people would like um if they're outside of Cornwall proper so thank you for letting me say that thank you um great so we'll revisit this at a future meeting um Christian's going to email out some information I'm going to research a couple questions I have and and I'll share if I think they're pertinent after I look them up if anybody has further questions um you know if you could email Christine or myself or just email all of us um just to kind of you know Jim if you have any questions maybe we can combine that into one email chain so that if I have data that answer your questions I can put it right just to you know we we want to have this

111discussion in public at a public meeting but certainly as we introduce a topic and we start to think about it um you know I happens a lot to me I'm on the way home or the next day and I go oh man I should have thought of this you know um and that's why we you know when we're introducing new items besides you know kind of the typical consent agenda stuff we typically introduce it at one meeting and then move on to voting at a later meeting to leave that opportunity um for the board members to think about it consider for the administration to to weigh in with any part information and you know Community who um is watching in this you know we may get future public comments um in favor or opposed um

112so that's why we we uh take our time on on all these types of things so uh next item on our agenda is also in the new business um discussion on board guiding principles and operational agreements um so we emailed out a document and this is um sort of picking up a discussion that we had at our board retreat in August and the facilitator uh was a former superintendent and is now um a uh a consultant who leads Retreats and and does search and other things but uh one thing he said was really valuable in his ten years as superintendent was having uh the board agree to some sort of uh rules of the road and just formalized some norms and we all or most of us all I would say agreed that that was

113a good idea we uh sort of started that discussion and worked on them um and uh Christine put together most of this document uh we collaborated a little bit but I'll give her credit for the heavy lifting here um and just wanted to have a discussion on this um I I think the reason that I think um this could be an important tool for our board is it's important to have discussions like the one we just had thoughtful reason discussions about issues and not waste our time uh spinning our Wheels talking about uh operational procedural issues um it just doesn't help move our board forward if we're arguing about board operational stuff um it makes us look disjointed to the public and I don't think it's helpful you know I don't think it accomplishes any

114of the goals that we're trying to accomplish as a board um so if we can just have a document that answers some normal questions and get some rules of the road down I think that can help us have uh thoughtful discussions uh like the one we just had um rather than fighting over stuff that's stupid and not important so um I'll open the floor um the document has uh was emailed out to the board last week it's attached to board so we've got printouts here um so if anybody would like to comment just in general about this or about any you know any specific um language or points on here um again this is a I'm gonna you can put your hand down Tiffany I'm gonna come to you first uh one I'll add I

115think this is a discussion piece um and ideally you know I'd like to come to an agreement on a document and take a vote on this document at a later meeting can I framewor please I I just want I lied I'm not gonna get I'm sorry Tiffany I just want to clarify that this is not like the beliefs of Christine per se this was taken from our meeting and then from additional stuff from the State Board of Ed guidelines Etc so um this is really intended ultimately to be a document that we all have um you know some ownership over Etc so I just want to clarify that I don't want you to assume I think this is you know the way alone thank you Tiffany I think it's a great idea I think it's

116um it's effective tool for us as a board um I do have I do disagree with some of the individual language but generally accepting of the document as a whole um I proposed to the board a time limit on um board members individually and how long that we can speak generally In fairness to the public I mean we limit the public to 3 minutes but yet we can you know wax philosophical for 15 minutes and I just don't think it's fair and I don't think it's reasonable um and that's really what it boils down to looking at this document it says being reflect uh respectful of each other's time by being brief and to the point in our comments and hearing to reasonable time constraints and avoiding the repetition of comments already made by other

117board members um generally I I like the concept of it but I think my interpretation of reasonable May differ from others and I also think my interpretation of brief May differ from others I think that if each of us in our closing comments for example spoke for 10 minutes that adds an hour I'm no mathematician but that adds an hour and a half to our total time of our meeting my understanding of our our volunteer positions here as board members which is very important and and the work we do I value uh personally I wouldn't do it and I wouldn't run for it if I didn't um but we I also have a job tomorrow morning you know and I have a family and and I think everybody at this table not everybody most people

118are in the same position um and I just think that it's unfair uh to make it routine to speak for in excess of five minutes every single time that we have a meeting I don't think it's fair to the taxpayer our constituency who is is limited in how long they can speak um but yet we can you know decide that this is our time to shine and and decide that it's our time to educate the public even if it's on something that's not relevant to the agenda thank you for that other comments I can yes so at the retreat we also discussed active listening and being respectful and mindful and I'm not disagreeing with anything that's being said right now but I I implore all of you to go back and look at last board

119meeting and just check your behavior uh when someone was speaking because I went back and looked and I believe that one of the bullets here says model the behaviors the board expects of students staff and community members my students would never have behaved the way some behaviors were represented um when someone was speaking and we did active listening we were respectful and kind and I just think everyone here needs to remind themselves that we are working together as a board and so perhaps refrain from s body language and um just certain certain actions that happened that that I was very EMB embarrassed about last time thank you for that com pass yeah I uh read Tiffany's email and she reated what she wrote in her email right now so everybody can uh uh see her

120point I'm just going to say that very valid point and Christine I mean here one two three four five five six seven bullets you have I agree with all of them uh we can easily make them eight by adding Tiffany's comment to it because none of these seven points do cover what Tiffany mentioned flip it over she read from a point on the back midle it's Fourth bullet down right here okay yeah I mean yeah but that right so I would what I'm saying is make it eight points right there it's a very valid point okay thank you other comments Carl yeah I just wanted to go back to what um Tiffany was talking about before be respectful of each other's time by being brief I think that's something that we start we have to

121start doing um I get it I mean I get it you have something out there you want to BR put out there but then after a while after sitting there you know 5 10 minutes of this you it it drifts so I just think that that's something that we should look into especially the fact that we're asking the the um citizens to come in and giving them three minutes and then cutting them off and we don't do the same to ourselves thank you Carl uh Christian so first of all an observation the average length of the last four board meetings in the public session has been 1 Hour 3 minutes which by any Cornwall Standard or any Schoolboard standard is incredibly fast and that with longer comments by certain people and I supect that I'm

122that person um I also think people don't understand about public comments and the legal standing and board comments about what the meeting is and how it's conceived under open meetings law the public has no right to speak at the meeting they have a right to observe the meeting we can decide to allow public comment the only thing we're not allowed to do is that if we allow public comment um we cannot have let's say Viewpoint bias we cannot just allow people who like us and say throw us bouquets to have longer time and then end the meeting when people are saying things that are critical or we don't care for that's the basic law on that uh here's the thing the discussion the meeting is to allow the public to observe the rationale and therefore

123the reasons for things and that is why sometimes things need to be explained perhaps at length at least according to the opinions of certain board members um but here's the other thing the reason why you have perhaps unlimited time or extended time in your comments is because there is no opportunity to respond and that is why you have more time because you might have to anticipate so at last board meeting there were two people who kind of made a comment piggybacking I believe on my comment but I don't have a chance to speak and that's why the order matters to make so order doesn't matter you allow people to have their time to speak other people have dedicated time to speak the president certainly does in most meetings the superintendent does if you put a

124watch onto the meetings you would find that the student Representatives who are reading a script almost certainly written by other people is significantly longer so if the concern is with the length of the meeting there are many many opportunities to do that but what's important is the public can see our reasons for making our decisions and allow us to explain why we vote or why we are looking at things in a particular way and that is why am martn the Nobel Prize winner says the most important part of democracy is the transparency and the ability to criticize public officials and so look I can do better I was not happy about certain things because sometimes you say having it in your mind it sounds better in your mind than what it comes out of your

125mouth and that's something we can do but I can also say that I I am happy that there are people on this board who have a different opinion than I do because I do not want to have everyone echoing my opinion that is not my idea of a perfect world we are a diverse Community we are a community of many different viewpoints and I'm glad the board reflects those diverse viewpoints and allow us to deliberate and to observe that so that's just my point about you know the length of speaking and I will try to do better and I will also say I am one of the few board members who did not speak decided to speak at all at least once in the past year not just to have some time and if you

126look back last last fall but I also want to address the bigger point and but let me stop here but I would like a chance to speak again but I I'm going to stop so that other people who want to comment on the overall policy so this had iterations so these weren't all my words because I do in some ways where we say avoid repetition of comments already made I do sometimes feel like as a board member even if it's stated I feel a responsibility to State my opinion or rationale for the public for the sake of how I'm going to vote so I don't want to like yes sign off on this and then you're going to hear me repeating something and I'm going to be guilty right so within reason but that would

127be my only call out is that yeah I feel like otherwise I'm just sitting here voting and nobody has a rationale or context for where my mind is for what they like or don't like about how I'm representing them sure and I you know I you know again these um I don't think we need to necessarily get into individual individual language on these right now we can do that via email um this is certainly a a board retreat type topic so I think legally speaking we're well within our purview to to to Workshop this via email um I don't think anybody wants to have an executive session to do that I think we prefer email to go over word choices um I think there's a difference between hey you know Bass a really great point

128I agree with that point I you know to make a brief 30 second one minute rejoiner I think that's what you're talking about rather than just bass made a five- minute comment I'm going to repeat everything he said for five minutes those are two different and that's just what I want to highlight for folks right like that's the Nuance of this is that it's not in stone it's the guidelines right and these are not you know this is not law there's no tickets issued there's no fines nobody goes to jail these are just ways to think about working with each other um in the most effective uh manner Brendon did I see it and yeah I'm trying to be uh mindful of all of these points um and avoid repeating all of the comments that

129have been made by but also uh I Christine you bring out a great point because also sometimes it's good for the function of the meeting to signal to the others that you support a certain position because then it become especially sometimes we feel our way to the vote and maybe maybe we pull something and so it does have value but yeah I mean if you're just repeating what has been said if it's not clearly I think we all know I'm saying this for the other eight people or I'm saying this for somebody who's watching on YouTube if it the answer is I'm saying this to be seen saying it then you should probably shouldn't say it and but if you're saying it to advance something at the table then you should so I agree with

130that um if if I may just wrote yeah please it's very important and you will as the president if you're un or if is everybody in agreement yeah yeah no it's it's very help like head head nods are good to know should we vote on this and stop talking about it or do we need to discuss further to to further work towards consensus so there's actually you know yeah is a time and a place yeah um other one other point that I want to bring up well first of all I do generally think that Tiffany's point is is spot on about I like the symmetry of the three minutes three minutes um again these aren't hard rules where we don't a counter you know going on the wall for the public and neither would anyone

131have it for us but I would guess anytime you go beyond that it could probably be an email later to the board and I that's not to say the longer public or longer board comments have been useless and I find them often very interesting um and it's a lot to chew on but you know maybe it could be something that is emailed to the board later it's not um I don't think that we would be cutting that kind of communication off we would just be redirecting it uh to a different uh venue one other point that I want to bring up that's on here I haven't heard anyone mention which is important to me I think and and to the functioning of the board is the avoiding uh springing any surprises on other members um

132or the administration um we've had some instances this year where items have been uh proposed at the meeting sometimes with little discussion beforehand perhaps with discussion with only certain members of the board and not other members of the board um and I if we're having a good honest conversation here which I think we are when you do that it puts your colleagues us in a very awkward and bad situ bad position and it feels like we're being leveraged in public to do something that are not prepared to do um I don't think it's when I vote I I will by principle vote no on introducing topics at the board table um even if it's something I know I support because it's just not the way to do business and you're you know you're aside from

133the fact that we don't have the information uh we don't have we haven't really thought about it we haven't formulated a considered public position on it I can wax poetic about what's going through my mind in the moment but I I'd like to think about my position say is that really how I feel about this you know um and that's what preparation gives you and I I just feel like we we we have to avoid that stuff um out of just respect for each other I don't think anybody wants to put each other in in an awkward position or um I every time I think of something like this I there's an Irish phrase that my mother uses she calls it a short corner I don't expect it to mean anything to anybody else but

134uh we're we're putting each other in a a short corner and U there are better ways to do it so I would just hope that that point wasn't uh wasn't missed in this list thank you Brendan uh other comments pass since you brought it up I mean I did see both kind of two pages it appeared in the email yeah so when I said like I agree with those seven points that Christine wrote I do agree with the back as well I mean and I I saw everything great all I was trying to say is that uh Tiffany government is so important that has to be a bullet point on the front that's what I'm saying thank you other discussion Christian so I have I have other points but I will withhold them because I

135think the best way to do this is to have in a sense a discussion in the retreat because this is about board organization um if we are going to vote on something then I will make my comments but I I don't know what we are planning ahead at the end of this discussion yeah there's no vote on this tonight this is for discussion you know similar to our last discussion so I W I will withhold my comments for that other Forum yeah I mean I think the best way forward with this is to um just make comments via email um because Retreat can be you know handled via email in terms of um hey this bullet point I'd like to tweak this a little bit or I'd like to remove this bullet point entirely or

136I'd like to add this bullet point um I think that's probably best had via email and we can try and reach a little consensus there the other option is we have another um Retreat where we do have an executive session um at some point discuss it um but let's try and have that discussion and conversation via email first um and I'll take that as a followup I'll send that an email to everybody um asking for comments questions con concerns um and obviously I'm open to you know pick up the phone and give me a call if you have something else that you want to discuss on it as well so um I think that wraps that up here unless anybody else has anything to add that they haven't already could could we create as a

137Google doc where folks could just go in and make comments on it so this way it can sort of be a little bit of a back and forth on you know you don't like that um your body Lang will just tell me I'm just trying to like see away my concern is does that get too messy if there's like eight comments on one thing maybe but yeah if everyone's going to you then I don't know what someone else is saying no I'm saying we do it on a group email everybody sees it oh okay yeah we just start an email chain um also I have no idea how to carry this formatting over to Google Docs so yeah I'm a I'm well it's in PowerPoint when uh when we review I I review designs so

138like something comes to me and uh whatever the file name is I put Dash bass at the end yeah so and send it like so nobody would touch it that Dash B Dash stany and then you put everything together yeah I well we can figure that if somebody has wholesale comments they could that that'd be a good way if they could mark up a copy we could send that a working copy start I don't want to complicate it yeah um great um so we will pick this up at a at a future meeting as well um so the next item um is public comment do we have any takers for round two Mr Hines come on down you're the next contestant on The pric is right hello hello um John Hines uh you all mentioned

139this last week but my favorite part of the meeting we don't get to hear comments from all of you tonight this is the Public's reminder to come see Harry Potter and the cursed child at cchs this weekend um super exciting production and I'm going back to the high school now thank you for that very important piece of information um with that uh next item is adjournment can I have a motion so moved second second all in favor I any opposed any he abstained thank you very much we will see you in all a couple weeks e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.