001good evening I would like to call this regular meeting of the Board of Education to order the next Board of Education special meeting is on Tuesday February 4th at 7 pm in the board meeting room thank you all for being this here this evening and thank you certainly to the board it's nice to see you back Brena and hi Ryan how are you um as part of my chair remarks I wanted to give a little bit of context um historical context to where we are and where're going our 10-year average for yearly budget Inc I'm going to focus on the budget first for yearly budget increases is 2.7 to 2% about three years ago budget numbers started to Trend higher the mid threes and low fours our enrollment during that time has been largely flat
002recently our priorities have included staff Recruitment and Retention the previous two contracts have had relatively High contractual settlements Safety and Security in the form of mental health and security personnel and service and Facilities you'll not see numbers uh in the Boe budget but we have as we know all know $260 million in construction costs for oxridge and HHR our Middle School will need renovation in the near term so facilities remains a priority for us and the board of education is around 75% of overall Town spend more if you count the debt on oxridge and HR HHR what we know going into this year is this is a community that continues to Value high education quality and a high level of service and support we are experiencing a historical cost increases and this is not a
003one-year problem it didn't it didn't start and end last year it isn't going to start and end this year our projected costs for the next three years are 5.11 4.46 and 4.35 costs that have gone up are unlikely to come down over the next couple of years without external intervention such as state aid or regulation and some of our cost categories are likely to continue to increase there's been limited room for investment for a number of years we've had to focus on emergencies or Investments that are relatively Limited in scope border of Finance guidance is 3 to 4% that guidance represents a tax rate target based on the variables the board of Finance had in the fall we're taking a moment to listen to evaluate the the impact of of guidance on our budget and
004then we'll make a recommendation back to the board of Finance who along with the RTM will approve how much money we're ultimately allocated Daran is not unique this year budgets and communities around us are impacted by the same or similar cost increase creases like us most other duray were reviewing budgets in the mid to high fours at the C board of directors meeting last Wednesday and at the legislative breakfast this morning there's a strong focus on letting Hartford know that we're all experiencing unsustainable cost increases one of the things that we have to talk about one of the areas is cost increases in special education we need Hartford to take to look take a CL close look at this and indeed there is a as a committee up in doing that they need to fully
005fund ECR as you all know we are $287,000 in the whole this year um and we had to we're looking at a budgetary adjustment for next year they need to talk about incentives for investment it's as I just said earlier it's really hard to invest because our budgets are so tight that it's difficult for us to set aside money but it's a critical that we continue to do that of course whether I'm talking about both special ed and general education but particularly in special education in this particular context and they need to help us look at ways to control costs uh via regulation or other types of cost controls over state approved private suppliers because we don't have any control over the way that their cost increases are affecting our budget tonight we have a
006few items of business and then we'll take the next section of our budget discussion this evening's discussion will include review of the existing suggested budget modifications this conversation may look a little different than it has historically first of all we're focusing on higher level adjustments that would meaningfully impact the budget second of all we are digging deeper not to cut deeper but so we can ensure that the dollars we allocate follow our priorities and are being spent as efficiently as possible tonight we'll review the budget modifications we requested at our last meeting board members will also have a chance to propose additional budget items for discussion February 4th is the public hearing following that we'll have a chance to review and we'll do some work to refine the the budget modifications hopefully into a fairly
007organized uh proposal or set or set of proposals we'll vote on a final Budget on February 11th I will emphasize the Board of Education remains committed to providing the best possible education for our students and share is the community's desire to prioritize student needs and programming to ensure the long-term health of our district we must carefully review all options and make informed choices this process involves balancing competing priorities and making difficult decisions our work to provide a starting point that is relatively consistent with the board of Finance Tax strategy is still the beginning we are now developing and adjusting a budget as part of an ongoing process with careful planning flexibility and a commitment to balancing priorities before we move to public comment I'd like to make a clarification we've received a number of emails
008about specific staff members the board of education is deter responsible for determining full-time equivalent or you may hear us call it FTE positions within the district this involves decisions about the overall number of positions needed to meet student enrollment and program needs Personnel decisions such as hiring evaluating disciplining uh individual employes employees are the responsibility of the superintendent and the district's administrative team in many cases collective bargaining or other agreements affect what happens with staff when positions are restructured we do not operate the district and do not control who sits in what seat the board has quite a bit of work to do this evening we greatly value public engagement and we want to hear from anybody who's here to speak however we ask that if you are that you value our time in return
009we have a lot to talk about if you're here to speak this evening and somebody has already spoken to the point you want to make please consider holding off to the end of the evening when there'll be another public comment section making sure you're making your remarks very brief or focusing on a new consideration at some point if it goes for too long I may stop the first public comment period take the rest of the meeting and then allow the rest of the public comment to continue a at the end of the meeting during the second public comment section and with that I thank you all and we'll move on to uh you Alan uh good evening everybody and thank uh you to their members of the community and staff and students uh for being
010here this evening and we mention to our art Department thank you if you haven't noticed uh they have Ed our walls with new artwork from kids uh Elementary uh hold on public comments before superintend Oh yes get my head of myself that's what happens when my agenda is underneath my other agenda that's my fault my apologies public comment good evening if anyone in person or online would like to participate in public comment please approach the podium or use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized once you've been recognized please state your name and address for the record and note that you will have up to three minutes to comment we will begin with in-person comment and then move to online thank you hi there um thank you for having me for letting me
011speak uh Dr adley and the board my name is Sarah hunsburger I live at 51 Old Farm Road darianne um I have a second grader and a kindergartner at toque Elementary two more in the pipeline one of whom I need to get back to because she is four months old and will be needing to be fed soon um so I'm here uh and I find it frankly somewhat frustrating that I need to be here at all uh I spent most of the day today and in many days in the past few weeks discussing this year's budget with a group of extremely concerned moms and teachers it's difficult to believe that instructional par professionals are even under consideration to be cut from the budget like many teachers and parents I've spoken with I believe that they
012are a musthave rather than a nice to have their primary role is to help educate our children they play a vital role in helping our youngest Learners with Reading Writing and math um among other things they have Decades of experience and relationships with teachers and students alike they are part of the fabric of our schools and to S to suggest that they could be replaced by transient untrained student volunteers is frankly naive this attempt to deprive the children of PA Professionals in order to trim the budget seems indicative of deeper issues with the district's annual budget that we need to get to the root of and address rather than just making cuts to essential Services year after year we have to ask questions like what is the solution to regular PE people Transportation costs increasing
013hundreds of thousands of dollars year on year and our staff Retreats and professional development days strictly necessary and do we really need to pave the token in parking lot this year we all understand the budget is tight and sometimes Cuts need to be made however I urge you to make these Cuts where necessary to the nice to haves rather than to members of our staff because in addition to having a negative fact on our children's experience these measures will increase in will result in increased costs in the medium and long term without instructional par par of professionals the kids with the greatest need for additional support will suffer and fall further behind because as special education professionals a stretch thin to support others and high achieving students lose out on the opportunity to Excel and
014move forward independently because teachers will redirect their focus to struggling students middle Learners who benefit most from extra Paris support will be at risk of falling behind and requiring costly IEPs and 504s increasing the special special education budget significantly uh I know you guys are pressed for time so two quick anecdotes before I uh wrap this up my second grade daughter I'm sorry you're at time you got three minutes I'm sorry thank you for being here my name is Henry havik and I live at 16 Hamilton Lane I go to ox and I'm in first grade I'm here to tell you how special our instructural AIDS are Miss Anderson is a great teacher since she helps out when we bike the school if you get rid of her position I will be so sad and
015it won't be safe for us to bike the school Miss Mino is always so nice every day she says hi to me and always smiles she's a great teacher if you get rid of her position the school won't be the same Miss Harris is a great teacher if you I and I will be so sad if you get rid of her position these three people make oxr a special and wonderful School these three people cannot be replaced and have dedicated their time to us show the kids of Fox like me that you care about us and that you will keep these positions thank you and please forgive me unfortunately I have to ask that we not clap as lovely as that was but if there were something else I would have to also allow clapping
016so you'll understand um hi Kate Havoc 16 Hamilton Lane um thank you all for your time I know that you have donated a number of hours to all of us um you've asked for efficiencies and I found them in the budget um roughly $1.6 million can easily be found by looking at Central related costs there is a consultant worth $106,000 page 178 of the budget get rid of that or hire a student intern board of education budget request in kind contributions there is a five $5,000 retirement celebration page 206 that seems exorbitantly high when we're talking about getting rid of positions in the schools $21,000 for board meetings page 206 what is this what are we spending this money on $122,500 for Boe catering ask for inine contributions from local restaurants I'd be happy to
017bake some cookies for you all replace the $92,000 executive assistant with an intern page 208 line 11 32 if student interns are that valuable then I suggest Central utilize them instead ELP $10,000 a year for teaching supplies absorb this into the fee that parents are required to pay is this a foray program or is it subsidized fully by the district I can't tell it's straddling both let's make a decision ELP dues and memberships fees $10,000 page 256 what is this central office supplies of $30,000 a year page 208 line 2501 what are we spending $30,000 a year centrally on for office supplies I bet we can cut this down cut the director secretary position of $49,000 page 208 line 21501 student intern might be a great solution since it seems to work for schools it's
018really difficult to think about cutting positions that are Central because they're family they become family and they're like friends that's how we feel about our teachers and the positions at our schools what are weather services for 32 $250 Google is a pretty effective weather uh app for me maybe we could try it pause on the Darian High School infrastructure charges of $687,000 why do we need to repay the high school parking lot next year we don't pause on the token bus pave $285,000 page 318 again this can wait pause on District wide purchases of $152,500 page 319 pause on central office of improvements $143,500 page 319 this includes Windows it includes sidewalk repaving and I would like to highlight if we're going to focus on sidewalk infrastructure outside of central maybe we should prioritize the
019sidewalk at oxridge and the fact that it's not ADA Compliant it seems like our priorities are not aligned properly where we're focusing more on Central needs rather than our local school needs and what our students need thank you uh good evening my name is Scott McCarthy and tonight I speak as co-president of the Darian administrators Association or daa which represents the expert leaders in best education system in the state as you learn from our detailed email communication dated January 7 the leaders of this District share serious concerns about the proposed eliminations and cuts and are here tonight in support of the students of the Darian Public Schools as we believe the current budgeting process and accompanying discussions over over prioritize a fiscal strategy that to accomplish cannot meet the evolving needs of our students and
020the educational system that supports them we understand that the board represents a diverse set of constituents with competing interests however we do believe it to be true that every single one of those constituents goal is to ensure the continued Excellence of the Darian Public Schools thus in representation of a leadership team with whom you charge to ensure the success of our students we believe it is our duty to make known our concerns and Advocate on behalf of students considering this board unanimously passed its 2425 school year budget just two weeks before the end of last school year and recommended that we require every item in that budget it is difficult to reconcile the current need to consider such drastic eliminations to so many departments schools and functions and while we value and appreciate that the
021town and this board have supported the funding and supported and funded significant capital projects that will undoubtedly benefit our students including the beautiful new oxridge facility HHR renovation projects and great Island I believe we would all agree that there is an important distin between Capital Investments and human capital human capital is the foundation of Education as we outlined in our email communication the town's wealth in spite of these significant Capital Investments continues to rise and at the same time the competition for the most the most talented Educators is fierce just a week ago today after releasing an enticing new teachers contract the new Canan Board of Education reviewed their superintendent's proposed budget unanimously voted to add two positions and then passed their budget unanimously at a 4.67% increase while our neighbors in new Canan are
022back to the work of being Educators Darian educators are daily wondering if they'll be next to get a visit from from Dr adley letting them know that they are about to be publicly recommended for elimination we ask that the Board of Education be Resolute in their support of sustaining the essential human capital of the district thank you good evening my name is Mark mazone and I'm speaking tonight as the treasur of the deran administrators Association but more importantly as someone who is a school building leader and who loves his job and who loves kids I'm here to speak about the role of our department shairs who up for consideration as a cost-saving option and the anticipated and unstudied impact cutting them would have on students and Families the department chairs are instructional leaders that oversee
023the Daren Public Schools curriculum and instructional methodology which is the foundation of what students experience in their classrooms throughout their time and dery end the department chairs assist students and families in conversations around appropriate course selections they are the direct supervisors of 116 teachers in the district they're the leaders in hiring and growing our new teachers and they work diligently to align the curriculum in grades 6 through 12 just to name a few of their important responsibilities the department chairs make up 1/4 of the administrators at Daran high school and middle sex middle school if these roles are cut all their responsibilities will fall on the rest of us our concern is not hard work uh as I hope we've demonstrated to you all over the years Our concern is that the service DHS and
024middle sex provide to students and families will be diminished at the high school alone we prepare for and share almost a th000 PPT and 504 meetings a year support students and Families in Need observe and Implement board initiatives support and observe teachers organize clubs and activities and Athletics Implement and Lead initiatives to improve School climate and maintain the safety of your children as our highest priority and that's just scratching the surface of the many responsibilities that you all have entrusted to us our message is not that our current administrative structure is the only structure that can be successful in Dariana however we do know that our current structure in darana is working we also know that the options in the board packet were put together a week ago without a plan in place to ensure
025that the services provided to families and students will not be negatively impacted no one has studied what the impact may be on students in special education relationships with families mental health support SAT scores AP success rate College acceptance alignment and progress of our curriculum across grade levels no matter what is decided here tonight in the coming weeks please know that we have the most hardworking team in the State team meaning teachers staff custodians monitors secretaries and administrators and this team will continue to do our very best to meet the needs of Daran students and Families also know that there's a high chance that we simply won't be able to provide the same quality of support service and time to students and families and in Daran it feels wrong to leave that up to chance please
026leave the current structure in place as the implications of the suggested Cuts have not been thoroughly and systematically studied thank you for the opportunity to speak here tonight and thank you for all you do for our district thank you hello my name is Doug C I live at 767 hollow tree thank you for giving me the time to speak I'm here to say that we need to take all the energy that we've seen in this room for the past few weeks and bring it to the board of Finance meetings because that's where the decision is made on how much the Board of Ed is allowed to spend on our children's education I think our Board of Ed has historically done a commendable job at ensuring our Town's children get a high quality education while maintaining
027a watchful eye on spending excluding Insurance transportation and special education tuition which I'll return to in a minute our board of education is has delivered an average annual increase in education cost of just 3.3% spanning from 2008 through the proposed 2025 to 26 budget in the present costs are going up more than we would like inflation has hit everyone and that includes our teachers the current contract gives our teachers an average 4.6% annual wage increase for three years it was right of this board to give our teachers a bigger than normal increase in the wake of two years of high inflation and I'm glad they did at the start I called out three items Insurance transportation and out of District special education tuition combined they account for 25% of our total budget and that 25%
028is currently increasing at about 10% per year for context in 2008 those three items only accounted for 15% of our total budget so this is a long-term problem and one that is largely out of the board of Ed's control as Miss mccam alluded to earlier so we have 25% of our budget going up at 10% a year and the other 75% which might normally go up at 3.3% per year seeing some additional pressure from higher wages the board of Finance has been producing guidance for an annual education cost increase of just 3 to 4% how does that make sense given these significant cost pressures that are outside of the board of EDS control to be clear this isn't just the Daran problem new Canan passed an 8% residential property tax increase last year and Wilton
029passed an 11% increase I'm sure those were not easy decisions we're all taxpayers here but their Boards of Finance stood with their Boards of educ a to protect the quality of their town schools our Board of Finance is unfortunately out of step with the times if I were on the board of ed I'd vote today to not only avoid any preemptive Cuts but also to add back the cuts the board of Finance forced last year over the objections of the Board of Ed the chairman of our Board of Finance likes to Compare running Darian to running a business I personally think that's a terrible analogy but if I'm forced to use it then I'm going to compare their approach to that used to manage what was once a great American company company Boeing Boeing's management
030talked a big game about efficiency and disregarded the advice of people who had actual domain expertise like our Board of Ed while hiding behind their spreadsheets that approach worked great right up to the point where the plane started falling out of the sky I hope to see a healthy turnout of concerned citizens at upcoming Board of Finance meetings so we can prevent our grade school system from being turned into another Boeing thank you thank you good evening um my name is Paula Blakeley and I am the 13-year principal of Holmes Elementary School I stand here tonight with the leaders of our preschool and our Elementary programs in my 27 years as an administrator I have never offered public comment my colleagues here have not either however we collectively believe that this year's budget discussions are
031unique and therefore we would like to respectfully share with the board and the community that we have significant concerns about the impact to our students of any cuts at all to our current level of Staffing and programming from any Union or any discipline just months ago this board established that each line item in this year's budget was essential and voted to fund every current position and program since late May enrollment has remained stable academic expectations and student needs have only increased every person in position in every Union continues to be critical to the success of our children in this District while we are aware that the board is being confronted with increases in costs relating to insurance premiums and contractual obligations and among other things these Rising expenses while significant were expected yet at the
032start of this process Dr adley was directed to work with in a budgetary cap that the board knew would not fund the known negotiated salaries and benefits of existing positions and our existing programming throughout this process our community has been forced to have uncomfortable conversations about among other things cutting the gifted program cutting instructional pair professionals and now looking at cutting curriculum leaders we have introduced increased ing class size for our younger students in some cases possibly adding six students to classes currently at 18 all of these options will detract from the quality of our students current programming and experiences and the long-term and far-reaching cost of such decisions will far outweigh any short-term savings families purchase homes in Daran because our schools are ranked among the best in the country the town is not
033in any type of a financial crisis this Daren has the ability to comfortably fund a budget on par with what exists today so ethically we feel that we cannot stand by while the Educational Staffing and structures that are essential to the success of the children with whom we work are unnecessarily dismantled respectfully you hired us for our expertise and to serve as leaders in this community with children as our charge we are collectively imploring you to maintain Excellence for the students of darianne and to fully fund a budget that does not require any cuts to existing positions or programs we realize that you have some tough conversations ahead we are here to collaborate with you as you advocate for our most important asset our children thank you thank you good evening my name is Kate
034deolis and I am the proud principal of middle sex middle school and Secretary of the Daran administrators Association I stand here tonight with my MMS administrative colleagues and my fellow daa members out of a tremendous sense of responsibility and commitment to this community As Leaders with significant collective experience we see harm to our students unfolding as a result of the requested proposals you will hear tonight in a town which has proudly heralded that schools exist for children this proposal risks dismantling the educational Excellence our children experience at the secondary level the collapse of the department chairs will undermine the advances that MMS has made and is striving to make while it is true that a skilled educational leader can identify and support good teaching across disciplines nothing replaces the subject specific expertise of an educational
035leader who has mastered the content taught successfully in the field and committed to ongoing learning in its pedagogy and best practices my department CH colleagues may not be student facing in the same way as a teacher or a parent educator but their daily work directly impacts dozens of teachers and hundreds of students they are frequently in classrooms coaching teachers providing support to plc's planning discipline specific professional learning guiding the development of curriculum instruction and enrichment they provide personalized guidance to parents on placement and collaborate with students team members to meet various student needs I fear that the further reduction of expertise in the Dearing and administration will erode the Excellence in instruction responsiveness and performance that this community expects and that our children deserve the board passed the current budget after months of protracted and
036turbulent consideration just eight months ago you unanimously voted that every current FTE and every current position was essential to the functioning of the district each of these positions is as important to educational Excellence today as it was then we stand United as your partners in this work to urge you to balance fiscal responsibility with our shared commitment to our students we urge you to fund a budget that lives up to the district's mission mission and vision to the Strategic plan to your board goals fund the whole budget if not I fear and we fear that the these Cuts will have significant predictable and unforeseen consequences on the children of the daring end Public Schools thank you thank you good evening I'm Ellen Dunn principal at Daran High School I offer you my thoughts this evening
037as I complete my 39th year as an educator 37 of which have been spent at Daran High School 19 wonderful years as a teacher of biology and science department coordinator six years as assistant principal and now 12 years as principal I am grateful for the support and generosity of our families and our community and the commitment to Excellence I have shared with all of you and each Board of Education each superintendent and each cabinet along my journey this work alongside an extraordinary faculty and staff has resulted in a school I have been proud to call my own since I passed through its doors for the first time in 1988 I speak tonight with a profound sense of responsibility to protect an exceptional school that has been intentionally designed shaped and nurtured over time by the
038countless contributions of generations of Educators into what it is today what makes a great High School of course the remarkable students we have the privilege to serve are the very Foundation upon which we build the scaffolding that supports the work is not composed of sheetrock or concrete it is instead the rich human resource we have amassed a team of people who share a common purpose and an understanding of what is most important at Daran High School we put our students first this is not a vision placed on placards but it is the thread that connects us all we are bonded together in this spirit and we hold the highest expectations of our students and one another the most important thing we do as school leaders is build this team choosing people of character who are
039deeply who care deeply about young people and share our dedication to them whose intellectual Acumen challenges our students and who possess a passion and curiosity for their discipline this is what makes the staff we have assembled so exceptional debate about the value of the contributions of those who make up the very fabric of Daran High School harms the entire staff new leaders new teachers new staff all hired through an extensive vetting process are now wondering if they have a place in a school they have already begun to love discussions have persisted about the impact of discipline specific leadership a high school of our caliber in my opinion cannot continue to be exceptional without leadership that honors and understands that which is unique about content specific pedagogy its curriculum and its distinct instructional design thank you
040Ellen our students give us the very best and we should give them the same we ask you to consider these proposed cuts for the impact they will have on the core of what we do we recognize and share your commitment to the work of our schools and your dedication to the students we share Ellen I have to cut you off thank you my name is Jordan cassetta I live in New Town thank you for giving me the chance to speak today I am here in support of the remaining 15 darianne elementary school instructional par Educators keeping their jobs I've known several of the current instructional Paras for many years one of whom is my mother I graduated from Darian High School in 2014 the last time I stood up here at a board meeting was
041my senior year of high school I had the honor of receiving the superintendent Citizenship Award in fifth 8th and 12th grade the instructional Paras were a huge part of my elementary school experience at oxridge and token the instructional paros is a vital role in The Daily functioning of the schools alongside the teachers the Paras are at the foundation of helping the students emotionally intellectually and socially they help to ensure the safety and well-being of the students for the entirety of their Elementary School experience after listening to the response of the Paras teachers and parents I'd like to respectfully say that I notice a large discrepancy between the description of the per job versus all the intricacies and nuances the per job truly entails the value dedication experience and skill set of the Paras far outweighs
042the money saved if the perah job is cut this will cause a Cascade of problems that haven't fully been taken into account it's going to leave teachers without their long-standing trusted support system I consistently relied on the support of the instructional Paras during my elementary school years from a student perspective I can say this is not what's best for the students or for the well-being of the school how can temporary interns take the place of Paras who spend years building Rapport and deeply understand the inner workings of the school this cut goes against what the majority of teachers students and parents want it seems the proposed budget isn't representing or respecting the voice of the community I think this is a confusing and discouraging move for the morale of Darian Public Schools it sends a
043terrible message that people are disposable and not appreciated college students will be given a brief stepping stone but at the expense of the livelihood and careers of people who have been loyal to the school district for decades this cup proposal is beyond disheartening the schools are already stretched thin from the 10 instructional parac cuts from last year I'm respectfully urging the superintendent and board to once and for all ensure the security of the instructional pair of jobs in the Years moving forward forward this will give the instructional par Educators the respect they deserve to the Paras I just want to say thank you for all that you do you do an incredible job the majority see you and support you and want you here I hope you feel the love care and support of the
044community behind you and how you much you are appreciated by so many thank you thank you good evening Courtney Pere five lill and Terrace I'm a former special at Pera from the district and now have uh and I have children one at middle sex medal and one at DHS while these proposed budget cuts may not directly impact my own children at the elementary level I feel compelled to speak tonight as a former deran School employee a mother and a responsible member of this community I believe it is my purpose to help this board see what is clearly needed at the student level I stand before you tonight because I believe we've lost sight of what truly matters the success of our students while I recognize the need to be fiscally responsible we must ask ourselves
045a question what do we want our schools to look like any year in five years 10 let's envision an effective classroom one where every student thrives academically socially emotionally then let's evaluate where we stand today what are we doing well and where must we grow to achieve this Vision it's time to shift our perspective right now decisions are being made from the administrative vantage point but we need to view our schools Through The Eyes of our students we must refocus on what truly matters working from the ground up not the top down we should ask what are our students experiencing in 2025 every child in this district from prek to 12th grade has faced some level of stress and Trauma due to the pandemic the world isn't the same as it was in 2019 19
046our parents teachers support staff administrators community and most of all our students are not the same anyone working directly with students will tell you our students need more not less post pandemic we're seeing increased emotional and social issues academic gaps and R in IEPs and 504s teachers and staff are stretched thin Running on Fumes as they try to meet the growing needs of their students we must act now don't cut pair professionals add more don't increase class size reduce them don't collapse Department chairs honor them don't eliminate professional learning make it relevant and empowering don't run our teachers into the ground support them so they can continue to support our kids thank you hello I'm Jenny Chapman 23 good wise Ru Road and I want to thank everyone on the board of ed for your
047service um all the volunteer hours and to superintendent uh Dr adley for the work he puts in here and for everyone who has spoken this evening um the pros budget increase of 4.4% you know at first glance might seem reasonable but as we've all said it just is not taking into account the cost pressures of the reality we are all living in we've already talked about insurance costs we're talking about 24% increase since 2022 23 yet we are going to increase by 4.4% the budget that's the guidance that you're being given that you're being asked to spend valuable time working towards how does that make sense how is this a good use of your time and of this community's time budget pressures are being driven mainly by inflation costs and cost increases from third party
048providers I implore you to please go back around this guidance because our teachers are not labor costs they are valuable resources to this community and those valuable resources have been impacted by inflation because teachers pay for shelter for energy for food and all of those prices have gone up so when we say that our budget isn't been impacted by inflation what are we saying the current proposal to compensate for that is to cut good programs and resources that Inspire our kids intellectually physically and artistically rather than adequately funding the school's budget we are booming we are booming with new construction with economic activity with high employment so this discussion all comes from guidance that was given so the core of this discussion needs to go back to the guidance that was given so that we
049can start focusing back on the children on the programs that they want versus months and months of energy around a budget that we've just heard several times that was just agreed upon in May thank you all for your time thank you okay is anyone online Cass I have one waisted hand okay that's fine Mr Nicholas Scala you've been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you'll have up to three minutes to comment and Nick Scala 168 West Avenue um good evening uh I'd like to speak first to the proposed cutting of instructional AIDS uh for those that are less familiar um it cannot be overstated these are incredibly experienced highly skilled and talented individuals who are remarkably dedicated certainly far beyond the requirements of the job or
050anything commensurate with their compensation in contrast the proposal to determinate them for efficiency sends the message they are nothing more than a fungible commodity as uh and the job in security they are forced to endure one budget cycle after another is entirely unreasonable this also brings to mind a distinction excuse me that I think is important not to lose sight of between value and cost while we all understand that your job necessitates getting into the weeds of the minutia of line item by line item cost we cannot achieve better effic by sacrificing those who surely provide some of the greatest value relative to the cost of retaining them instructional AIDS are forc multipliers who fill in every Gap and add greatly disproportionate value to every element of school functioning furthermore there could be a cating
051effect of damage rought as instructional AIDS provide so much value for all students but especially those who need more support even the most antiseptic Financial calculus would suggest that this cut is myopic and will surely prove to be penny wise but pound foolish and ultimately this may prove even more costly by making the process of bringing on highly qualified new staff in the future that much more difficult the proposed excuse me the proposed replacement by inherently inexperienced interns at best is inadequate and is concerning with regards to safety as well as the functionings all the functionings of the school day with regard to safety the role of the school safety officer is indispensable and ours is excellent and much appreciated but those would some from familiarity know that most of the time more security happens
052with when those veteran staff members who know every child and so many parents and others are there to greet everyone who approaches that school I realize also while discussing this that while most of us have become inur to the way that the use of so-called interns is evolved in many Industries an unpaid intern by definition is prohibited from doing the work of a paid employee this presents something of a catch22 either the Darian public school system is engaging and ethically if not legally dubious labor practices or it's honoring the spirit of an internship which means that this would represent a net cost of the district in the time required for experienced staff members to Mentor these interns it's simply one of the other tough choices will indeed have to be made but they should be
053considered for all the talk of community and such this cut amounts to sending family members to The Chopping Block so that we don't have to have slightly less nice things I would strongly urge the board to consider such things as delaying repaving a functional high school parking lot uh before jet ising staff who cannot simply be replaced with equals at a whim with regard to the idea program I couldn't agree more with all the very eloquent testimonials of current former idea students but I will thank them for broadening my perspective thank you Mr Scala you're at time we have more hand go after you want to do it now or at the end um there's more person sorry I I think okay one more and then we're going to move on go ahead okay hi
054my name is MTH kkus I live at 15 Bittersweet Lane I have a daughter Isa who's in first grade at homes I also have a son Theo who is three who I hope uh follows her at homes when he uh when he's old enough um and I just want to Echo the sentiments of many of the other parents that are here tonight because I believe that these Cuts will have an immediate and a lasting impact on the quality of my children's education for one my daughter is currently uh in a class of 18 students with these cuts her class will jump to 24 students next year that is a 33% increase in class size that will make her class the largest Elementary class within the district um and this is well above class average size
055um but beyond just making the classes bigger there will be far less experienced in classroom support the idea that an intern is a pseudo able replacement for someone who is well trained for someone who's experienced anyone who's ever had interns knows that they need a lot of on the job training this is basically giving teachers bigger classes and then asking them to manage essentially another student but I also think that if you talk to the teachers about how invaluable and indispensable these pairs are you will hear that they say things like the these individuals are not people that can be cut they absolutely are my right arm there how I get my job done um and I think that we really need to listen to our teachers and and what they're saying um but you
056know I think that the Crux of my complaint is really twofold so one these continued budget cuts just means that we're going to start losing teacher talent I mean if you talk to the teachers the administrators they are frustrated they are exhausted and this is a slippery slope because once people feel undervalued and overworked they start to take their talents somewhere else we can get out ahead of this and we absolutely should and also this is a town that does not need to make these Cuts in December of 2024 the board of Finance presented a $2.6 million contribution because of decreased costs and increased Revenue we also decreased our mill rate in 2024 or from 2024 to 2025 I would be happy to pay a higher mill rate if that kept if that kept the
057quality of our education intact so if you guys are being hamstr Strong by the constraints of the board of Finance is placing on you I encourage you to please respond to me and to other parents and let us know what you are going to do about it to go to bat for our students because budgets are really about priorities and I think that there is no greater priority than our children's education thank you okay with that we'll move to the superintendent report Alan thank you all for your comments uh thank you everyone for being here uh uh as I started to say thank you to the art Department if you look around you uh in the uh boardroom this evening uh there's artw from all across the district from elementary school through AP art and
058actually right above Mark mazon's head there I think that is the Jan Causeway on the arish coast the East Anam coast of Ireland but I can't remember which which student did it but uh I'm sure I'll get a chance to meet with her Elementary conferences I know we're looking ahead we but here um or March 19th 20th and 21st there we bit on the calendar it does say the 19th 20 and 21st it just says that the 19th is the evening it's the 20th is the evening well I'll send out notification for that uh thank you to Madam chair and uh Miss Nelson for attending the areaa breakfast uh this morning the legislative breakfast she already commented on that um I along with 17 of my furfield uh County Superintendent submitted a letter to the
059house uh chair education chair uh regarding exess costs and paid sick leave I will forward a copy of that to the Board of Education uh the Daran thriving youth has been administered this week at the high school and the middle school next week congratulations to our Middle School quizbowl who competed in New Jersey this last weekend five of the teams qualified for playoffs Legally Blond is happening at the Middle School uh I think our fifth graders are traveling over there tomorrow there was a address a hle today uh congratulations to this uh the crew uh of Legally Bond I look forward to catching the show uh some of our elementary schools will be doing a superal uh fund driver right um thank you for doing that uh for uh raising funds and opportunities for uh
060those less fortunate uh I want to thank congressman's Hees who will be attending Royals Valentine for vets uh next week and if you haven't attended this with your children or otherwise I would encourage you to uh step up to the house school for the National Technical Honor Society curiosity and experimentation uh night that is February 3rd uh that's organiz by our science department and uh we are considering not having a curriculum committee meeting uh will defer the February 1 to March thank you uh student representative reports Brena and Ryan good evening um we're encroaching a drer yet calmer season at Daran High School with the conclusion of midterm exams and the official end to the first semester um it's a bit of a calmer period for the Performing Arts and the Fine Arts but tickets
061will go on sale shortly for theater 308 production ofely Miz so keep your eyes peeled um a steady everpresent reminder that we're strongest wi United uh yeah just adding on to Brena keeping it brief not much happening uh tonight our girls and boys basketball and hockey team both played so Hing the best for them and along with that our boys squash team is playing just now so also hoping for a big win for them and yeah that's it thank you very much approval of the minutes may have a motion to approve the following minutes of the special meeting held on January 14 2025 meetings of minutes of the regular meeting held on January 14 2025 minutes of the special meeting held on January 21st 2025 uh that's Joanna seconded by Dennis all those in favor
062that's unanimous thank you very much board committee reports um just as Alan mentioned there will be no um curriculum meeting this month because there was they were unable to do the hmh um day on the 17th so we're going to push that so more information thank you John did you have your hand up yeah I did I'm trying to figure out the date about 10 days ago we had a finance committee meeting ahead of the holiday weekend uh we just discussed some transfers and we also discussed the uh the deficit that was created by the ECR Cuts uh rich is going to have more on that um on a lighter note we did have a nice presentation from the blueway booster club uh describing the new sponsorship program and in the model that's that's working
063greatly and we thank uh them for coming in and sharing that that's great anyone else Dave so the Darian Board of Education policy subcommittee met on January the 21st 2025 we discussed four policies which we'll be hearing more about from Mar later tonight great thank you okay uh discussion and possible acceptance of the contemplated gift for the athletic department Chris manfredonia good evening everybody um you have there speaking at the booster club of a contemplated gift from the blue booster club uh to Darren Public Schools um in we lost you Chris just a minute please can you hear me yes thank you that um booster club would like to donate a light kit that we placed uh in the ground underneath the stadium flag pole that would be uh able to illuminate the American flag
064um at night during inclement weather uh for a home contest in the Daran High School stadium uh the the gift would be uh purchased by the booster club but would be installed by our maintenance group be installed when it will be installed by our our our crew our maintenance guys our crew thank you any questions about this gift I have a question Joel yes I don't have a question necessarily about the gift itself but I'm just curious how the gifts are chosen is this the booster club decides that they think these things are a great thing for the school or is this something that the school asks for the school typically asks for coaches will ask for um uh nice to have for the program the school ask for nice to have for the for
065the facilities uh of the of the district um typically the the requests made to the booster club thank you okay with that I have a motion to approve the to accept the contemplated gift for the athletic department that's Dave seconded by Dennis all those in favor that's unanimous thank you very much to the booster club on behalf of the Board of Education thank you everybody thank you okay Rich discussion on November December 2024 financial report and possible action on proposed budget transfers see November December you have that that yep can you go through December sorry the end one yeah uh this is the financial report through December uh through December we are forecasting a deficit of 192,193 uh the general education RC's are forecasted at a positive balance of 39735 while the special education RC's
066are forecasted at a deficit of 297,000 we do have a small amount of savings and salary savings building substitutes and clubs and councils that are not running uh moving to operating uh we are forecasted at a positive balance of $ 38,8 we do have a slight deficit in special education contracted Services of 46,000 which we do have a recommended transfer for and then out of District tuition is a positive balance of $84,200 and that is uh Peril tax savings due to sim salary savings uh revenue is forecasted at a deficit of 29739 uh this is primarily due to excess cost reimbursement uh we did budget a 70% reimbursement from the state uh the state's reimbursement is just under 60% which is the lowest um on record uh and so that is causing a deficit of
067$287,000 uh there are two transfers recommended for approval uh to the board uh the first is for $46,000 into contracted service serves and this is for a contracted RBT uh we are recommended taking salary savings from some vacant teacher position teacher Aid positions and then $1,632 for ELP tuition uh we did have a couple students classified with an IEP and so they are no longer paying students and so we are recommending taking uh savings from building substitutes as well as a vacant par professional position okay any questions about the report or those transfers no okay and John the committee recommended is recommending to us adoption of the transfers correct correct okay may have a motion to approve the November December budget transfers that's John seconded by Greg all those in favor that's unanimous thank you
068all thank you Rich for the work okay first reading on proposed revisions to Board of Education policies 5075 recess and play based learning policy 5610 gifs policy 6710 field trips policy 1330 Community Partnership so policy 5075 we're asking you to repeal the current policy and replace it with the new policy which as it says in the memorandum accurately reflects what the elementary schools are doing as far as exclusion from Recess um Mrs Walsh had a question at the policy committee meeting so you may not exclude a child from recess unless they are a danger to themselves or others however if a school has two recess is the shorter recess you may exclude that child once in a school week so that was a clarification there okay thank you any other questions on that policy no
069okay so in the gift policy policy 5610 the policy committee is recommending that we include guidelines for classroom gifts um this is based on the cdsp current practice of $15 a family for a holiday gift and $25 per family for an end of school year gift okay any questions on that policy yes John sorry I didn't I didn't um does does the size of the gift come up in this in this policy too like the the limit in the approval process so we had recommended a cap but then it became a little more complicated because of different class sizes so if you notice we did specifically exclude athletic teams because those gifts are covered in the Student Activity manual okay thank you Katie has a question Katie thank you um was curious if um anyone
070knew when the last time the guidance that cdsp has been using was updated just how recent it had been adjusted last year okay thank you okay and the language under group gifts I understand but we have some students who have multiple relationships that might be outside of the classroom how does this policy contemplate a student who might you know who might be a diabetic and have a relationship with a nurse or who might need a lot of different other kinds of services so it encourages a nominal gift or something heartfelt like a a valentine or a letter to the file but it doesn't put a limit okay Charlie sorry before we move on just a question um I'm not sure that it's policy but we have a lot of teachers who have large classes but
071then we have other folks who just support individual students what is it you know I think group gifts helps teachers who are in large classes but not necessarily those who support individuals and I'm looking at you because you manage a large cohort of people who follow under that what what's your general feeling about gifts to that group of teachers if I've asked that clearly I haven't thought about the question before um I I don't think I would distinguish between Gifts of and who the receiver is I think think the value of it is that it's it's a way of someone saying thank you and someone supporting teachers and and students okay so the guidance is not elaborate unduly expensive or cash okay all right Greg was there was there previously a different like cap on
072these there was no guidance there was no guidance before and so families I think we're somewhat a see about what would be most appropriate for staff so we we're creating guidance effectively we're creating a cap do we feel like there's a need for that um who do you guys want to speak to that well I think that many districts and we had submitted to the policy committee some sample policies from other districts just gives some kind of guidance it relieves a little bit of pressure on families it gives the cdsp some guidance and that's why we included it so are these gifts going to be like are they gonna come before the bard of bet or it's just guidance these are the ones where the room mom will often email the families and say would
073you contribute $40 it'll be split between a year end and a midyear gift um and now you know but there were years where I think sometimes people were saying how about 60 or how about 75 and so I think that's some of the spirit of it most others have had different experience but Joanna maybe you want to comment um my understanding is that quite a long time ago Board of Education asked uh cdsp to put some um guidelines in place to make sure that teachers in all five elementary schools were sort of recognized equitably so one school didn't get tennis bracelets and the other school just get tennis balls for their teachers um and so over the years it's sort of evolved into this um you know um in elementary school parents want to gift
074their teachers um but they often don't know what's appropriate so one if there's a class gift and there's a limit on it agreed to by all the pto's um them teachers are gifted equitably across the schools separately if a person is new to town and wants to give their teacher a holiday or year end gift and they're wondering should it be $10 or $200 they stumble upon this policy they'll have a better idea of what's considered appropriate you know by the board at least but nothing's an obligation everything is a volunteer and it's consistent with like other what the other districts are doing yeah they look at some other districts yeah I think we talked a little bit at the at the at our policy committee meeting about kind of leveling the playing field too
075so that there's I don't I hope that no family would try to you know I'm going to buy you a really expensive so that you treat my kid better but there's just a way of leveling that out yeah I'm trying to balance that with like the teachers teachers value this I assume to some extent and are we disadvantaging ourselves in any way by making it the same as you don't go into teaching for the gifts well but there's it's you know there's you you only take this back down we can talk a little no thank you Dave for the offer though that's so kind of you um so let's um this is a first read no I know thank you though um's got her hand Oh Katie yes thank you um just as we're discussing
076this I I do just want to um just mention a couple of things for us to think about um you know my experience has always been that the guidelines has worked very well as they come by the pto's um and through cdsp helping to coordinate that as they do some many things um which I think is really great um one of the things that's nice about leaving it in that camp is that they um the PTO really have the flexibility to adjust year after year and know what's going on within buildings and and to communicate to each other rolling this up to a board level does seem a little odd to me in that um you know our policies are really written to be kind of Broad and you know some of them are very
077strict and have enforceability components whereas this guidance has never been enforced there's there's really no way for it whether it comes from the PTO or the board so that seems a little off to me I I do just think it's worth thinking about what we might be requiring of ourselves if we were to write this into a policy in terms of making sure that we are are appropriately updating it um especially as we you know continue to be an inflationary environments um so I would I would just leave that for for long-term consideration Dave happy to take it back I I inherited this one I don't have a strong I'm all for full disclosure I said should be unlimited just disclosed so I you kind of agree with that perspective but um I don't like
078having prescriptive limits picked arbitrarily but you know people have different takes and you know surely hadn't considered it maybe there are some thoughts to your point you ask for larger classes are small so happy to go spend a little more time you want to send it back great all right you got it back thank you um policy 6710 field trips um at the suggestion of board members we were trying to streamline board meetings so that overnight trips will come to the Board of Education the first year in which they run and after that if they run again or a very similar trip runs Dr adley will notify the board by the end of December which of those will run again okay any questions about that Robin um I have a few questions this is maybe
079more for the international trips um just to the extent that even if a trip has run year after year to the extent that there are potentially security issues or things changing within a certain country the way this would work is that the superintendent who would evaluate if that was a risk that we did not want to take and then cancel a trip Tri and then secondarily if the Board of Ed does not specifically approve it each year do we have a legal liability if something happens when students are abroad on a trip so the superintendent approves all field trips whether they come to you or not so if there was a security concern it would never get to you and the Board of Education would Pro I don't think there's any individual liability it's just
080a question yes I know we used to have China exchange programs went away they haven't come back and even if they were initially in place and then if they recur year after year and if we adopt a process like this I guess my question is when would it come back to the board of ed if the Board of Ed members had considerations that they might want to discuss about the risks so that's just a a question Dave so I guess for point of information is you're talking about the December timeline March we' get that in our board pet we'd see it it would be an item on the agenda we'd have opportunity to raise it at that time correct we could make it an item item on the agenda I don't think we contemplated that
081no we were going to just um just in the spirit of the uh suggestion of the policy would we would appra the board and end of October or November whenever all these come through um no later than December obviously but if you want to do it a different way that's fine you know if you want to include it on the de so we put the December deadline in because the policy still says October 15th right so we could even move it up and so then I guess the question would be would we like to amend as well we have a second reading so I guess the question is people would like to see this further or we could take it back down for discussion or if somebody would like to propose changeing the mechanism slightly
082um we would have time to take written comments Jill between the second read yes we can take written comments if people have them all I maybe just for the international trip specifically potentially and and the other question I had was on the financial side is the policy does reference parent fundraising as well as Darian Public School costs that might be incurred in these trips and so the question I have is if those costs are C above a certain dollar amount either to the district or the families I is there a point or a dollar amount that the Board of Ed should be approving especially to the extent that we're thinking about budgetary issues and also potentially participation fees and it's important to understand what the families actually are currently paying for um um whether that's
083clubs or other trips or expenses and fundraising they're being asked to do so those are just another set of issues that I know we used to have we were privy to that information so this would go away I'm assuming it's interest I mean I we could take comments on that Jill we could talk it out here on the full board we could take it back down for further discussion um my need react if we had arbitrary criteria on length of stay in mileage this is just another arbitrary based on dollar so if we're reporting it I'm not sure what utilities gain by it I don't know but I'm I'm open to picking this up to the next conversation go ahead Greg yeah maybe on this and even maybe on the prior one it rather than
084like putting putting like limits on things and doing it by Miles you just say like if it's above a certain dollar threshold then it needs to be approved or disclosed or something like that why did we use the um why did we use the the mileage threshold what's the that was just in the previous policy those were the field trips that came to you for approval MH so that's yeah I guess my reluctance is picking another arbitrary number and then in five years and just yeah right I mean honestly okay go ahead Jo I was just going to say it was my understanding that we were doing this to sort of be more efficient with the board's time and almost I think to a tea right now every trip is done through EF uh you
085know worldwide traveling and that was the reason why we felt that because they were all H you know done through the same um company we didn't need to have every single detail gone over every single time and it was all essentially the same framework just a different country yeah so I you know and I I feel like the policy here sort of takes that into account and then if this is something that's entirely new or the first time in many years that we do something not through this company I feel like Dr Ali said he would already be bringing it back to the board because it wouldn't be new it would be new and it's new company the first we'd see anyway yeah yeah I I agree I think I agree with that um I
086think I think that would that would satisfy I think what I'm speaking about I think generally we don't incur costs as a district usually these are families paying for a voluntary trip at least in the circumstances we're talking about so I guess we have it for the second read if anyone wants comments for policy happy to circulator Jill and then uh we can look at that and if there are other considerations fine um other than that we'll see how this goes in practice and we can always revisit it yep great thank you okay and finally um policy 1330 is a new policy this was based on principles developed by the communications committee and the board then tasked the policy committee with developing a policy which shipment and good when drafted this is not a model
087policy it's based only on the principles that they were given do you want to walk through the highlights please I mean it just it reaffirms that the superintendent is a spokesperson for the district and not the board chair is the spokesperson for the board that the board will solicit public input and that people will try to respond as quickly as possible to Communications and requests questions it really as opposed to a policy which prescribes things it's more of a an aspirational policy I think any absence of a direct response to community input or feedback should not be interpreted as the boards or administration's failure to receive or appreciate such contributions yes for the record I'm behind on emails these days okay any other any questions okay I think this similarly this is somewhat new and
088it's an interpretation of communication so I think this is worth thinking about and if you've got comments send them in um before the next meeting because there might be things to think about that occur to you after this okay Personnel report March just a couple of resignations okay thank you uh follow-up discussion and questions on fiscal year 26 proposed budget and discussion of budget modifications under consideration um sorry so as a reminder tonight what we'll do is um go through the modifications that have been proposed uh and talk about anything that's missed or not missed but anything we might might want to add to the discussion um the um we are trying to focus on keeping things at a higher level so again it might look a little different than what we've done in previous
089years we certainly can talk about RC's um specifically um but I I did have talked to all of you and I wanted to put out um you know that that we've we've collectively been talking about thoughts on an initial framework for some decision- making we aren't making any decisions tonight but we are starting to to we'll be refining our thinking um I think that you know one of the things we've talked about is I've lost my notes I'm sorry um uh looking for adjustments that limit direct impact to the classroom prioritizing true efficiencies first spreading the impact of any efficiency are fees thinly and broadly and considering the implications of any efficiencies on a multi-year basis I.E not deferring problems limiting limiting or not deferring problems to next year not to create an uptick in
090expenses in subsequent years with unwise costs that need to be quickly restored or that create savings today but increase the budget tomorrow and understanding that the time Horizon for realizing some savings may be longer term um I appreciate that the um Community feels that this and we and our staff understand that this is a a very person heavy business that we're in everything we're talking about is staff and students and families um but the this portion of the discussion is more technical so and more it is more fiscal um so with that I will turn it over to you guys to lead us through I uh kind of where we are there's some answers to questions that you provided uh Madam chair would you like me to go through first of all the uh reductions
091and then follow up with the questions or would you want to go through the questions first and follow in terms of new questions well yes so there were new questions for anybody in the audience the the questions have been uploaded any additional questions that I received from Individual board members they are highlighted and I think that I think it's m um but I'm happy to discuss the budget reduction request uh first also in the board packet you will see that there's an Excel spreadsheet uh that the board has a live version of that and that that has been populated with some of the proposals that can be taken off removed uh typically that's what would be happening this evening we' be adding some Concepts uh or or retracting concept well actually the decision making would
092be the the following time we meet at the next board meeting but um I'd be happy to go through this with the sure let's go let's go through what you proposed and then we can um so I I will say as I just sort of laid off here um getting from the six to the four uh as the board knows has been uh challenging and I appreciate uh the board working with uh the Dilemma that we have and the kundum that we have a little bit um I share with you the difficulty of that um uh my 17 years as a superintendent which is probably close to being long serving superintendent close to it in the state um I bring you that that experience uh to share with you that the proposal that I have
093that is outlined in this memorandum to start with just as we reminder where we left off uh is my and the the cabinet's uh uh proposal uh the word we left off and uh the best advice uh that we have on maintaining the the educational experience that we have for our young people um this is a teaching and learning organization so the proposals that we I have tonight I actually don't support um I support what I had originally because it's a teaching and learning organization uh the department has many of them are here and so on but they are the foundation of the teaching learning that takes place here um and they weren't in the proposal that I presented the first time so nor do they remember remain in the proposal the board asked me
094to to include some I've included some but they you may not see that reduction right away and that's not being disparaging to my uh uh pirate professionals right I didn't want to make that either but at some point I had to make a recommendation to get us to uh what I thought was a reasonable uh budget number and uh that's what I did and I stand by that proposal this evening um so I just ask the board um as I know you will um just to ponder the concepts that we're talking about and the trade-offs that that we're talking about because there are ramifications and that it's not going to run the same way and I can't just take the the operations of the of of the district apart behind the scenes you're not going
095to have anything um so I just share that as a perspective so uh moving through this uh the most current the first uh part of this is just sharing the most current proposal it's at 4.45 uh we did say it was 4.3 n or 37 the last time the difference is is minimal in the sense of we just change the uh pay for participation fee we took out the cic so uh when we just took put on a a sort of blanket uh participation fee for athletics and and clubs uh it just came out to the 4.45 so it does eliminate it does as a reminder reduction of the the two teachers at the elementary class size increasing that class size in second grade at homes and Royal that's where it would happen uh I
096played out kind of what what uh the current sections would be and what the new sections would be over the years participation fees is a flat fee and uh $50 for student interest clubs again if the board so decides to have some sort of participation fee whether it's this or something else I think we could SLE at it uh we also had the uh elimination of the inter murals that particular proposal uh in includes the three reductions um would result in 4.45 and as a reminder to that the reduction does include the reduction of the 15 power professionals uh does keeps in the the district website the board Doc and the professional learning just to give you a sense of kind of where we left off in that so this so just to stop you
097took your proposal that basically was the budget we restored gifted and so you you've put in a class size adjustment and then showed us where that would actually show up next year correct right and then you've adjusted the participation Fe fees um the model that you would use and then you've also included the elimination of inter murals and that's sort of your proposal yes and that sort of uh also incorporates 165,000 of ECR addresses that um whether the board wants to do that or not that's our recommendation that we actually address that I okay uh so moving forward to the the reduction of the million dollars that uh was requested in non-student facing uh services and and just to be clear it was a million dollars in in other Alternatives not an incremental million dollars
098I just want to repeat that again sorry to interrupt you I don't see much of a difference but that's but I understand no there's a big difference because we haven't changed the guidance I'm say good okay um I have redu the uh professional learning I don't want to reduce that uh I would ask the board also to to consider that there's not much in this budget I don't think we should be doing nothing I think some of the state legislated St the K3 reading and so on and so forth there's some things we can do um I would look to do this but uh if we were considering reducing some other things then I would obviously have to reduce uh the professional learning but it's one of the things that uh one of the only
099things that we ask in this budget reduce the curriculum rating we're reducing that by 30 the suggestion is by 30,000 that just slows down the process I mean that's there's a ramification for all of these I'm not like making wo as what wo Is Us in terms of these particular Cuts but there are ramifications from them eliminate the expenses of the administrator Retreat we can do that um you it's not uncommon for for at a retreat just to step out of your local environment uh get some professional development whether it's through expertise or otherwise U but we recognize the Dilemma we're in so uh We've reduced that by the set amount of 15,000 uh eliminate some uh periodicals that are used at the high school uh for staff professional development that's a nominal uh reduction
100uh this is the number five is collapsing the department ches uh again uh I'm not recommending this but into two administrators a director of math and science and a director of English and social studies they would be complemented with uh if depends on who was appointed for the math and science let's say a science teacher was appointed then we would put a teacher leader a stien uh for the math section and similar for the director of uh English and and uh social studies uh at the middle school we' also have a stien positions uh the positions would be 207 uh days as it would expand those to 11 month positions that's a reduction of 186,000 that's not I don't believe that serves the district well but um I was asked for to make it the
101recommendation for there it is so just slowing down so it's it's you'd have a director of math and science and then a teacher leader directly under that person director of English and social studies a teacher leader directly under that person and then you'd have teacher leaders at the middle school corre is that what you just said y director position would be 6 through 12 still okay and the directors would be six through 12 and you'd have four teacher leaders at the middle school yeah but only only for stiens they're not out of the classroom I'm just I'm just clarifying yeah yep okay in the Excel backup or the Excel spreadsheet that you provided there were two sections on this one said admin recommendation or proposal and one B the admin says collapse Department shairs into
102two directors the other says Department shairs to teacher leaders I guess the idea to show it two different ways so figure out what the implications are because one has Savings of 186,000 the other one is 385 corre you can't do it's not both it's no it's one yes so it was asked to to uh put on that worksheet what the current model is what the model I've just described and then what the model uh Greg you've just described I think the board asked to include in the questions q&as uh what that model would look like and then I was uh I was asked to put it into it allows you to pick one or the other that's what I'm saying I'm just making sure that I'm reading it right that's correct yes that's correct it's
103one or the other and it's just showing the implications of the two different actually there's three choices three choices status quo yeah one or other yes Robin um since the the teacher leader model is not really described in this memo could you give some more information on that because it is my understanding that our district used to have that in place correct what did we used to have that's what we used to have one teacher leader six through 12 for each discipline no we when when we came the last one standing um in 2015 we had at the high school point8 teaching Point 2 release time with the stiens and middle school they were called curriculum monitors with no release time and stiens that was in 2015 there were different iterations before then that I
104think some people could speak to can you remind us why we moveed to the current model we wanted administrators um we wanted people with content area expertise to be supervising and evaluating staff writing curriculums developing common assessments okay all right thank you Alan uh we have a reduction of professional devel M and that's it's $103 sorry it's a $10,000 in special education that's that that reduces the opportunities for some of our special education teachers to receive professional development in a variety of areas Jo in the yeah go ahead just a question on that that $10,000 in the in the spreadsheet it says that that's a cut in Orton Gillingham training is that correct says OG professional development would be cut be cut well right now we do Wilson as well we're doing paf and we're
105considering OG so as we go through that but what it would mean is that we would have less candidates going and participating in their initial three-day training I guess I'm just questioning why that would have been chosen as the cut given the literacy needs that we're going through but I just a question yes John mind everybody these are not his priorities or decisions we've asked them to dig deeper so these are ours we still need clarification understood but it was not clear in the I want to make it clear to everybody that we have asked to dig deeper okay so um just let's watch our our sorry uh the next reduction of 103,000 eliminat a Central Services special education secretary and and um also it's it's a combination of a fur phys is and special
106education implications of this is just timeliness of of responses and um all of these things actually many of these what our community has come to be accustomed to the quality of service and responses and uh interventions and quality services they're all being impact at one level or another here uh contract out for network manager uh typically uh dur districts do have uh two staff members in this role we have two staff members in the role uh we would be contracting I for this what that might mean is frustrating for superintendent because there one thing that bothers me is like whenever the uh internet services and Digital Services aren't available and they're down for a while it may take longer to to get things back up again um and get back up online again but uh
107again that's not a that's not a recommendation that I'm making but it's one of the reductions eliminate Pro tax uh tax technique and we website upgrade those are some softwares we reviewed all the software line items these are changes that perhaps were in the works a little bit and I want to sort of pull the trigger a little bit early in the process um I don't know if we're going to be 100% ready for it uh but uh we'll do the best to get caught up for we were going to be looking at something like this for for next year and um we will jump in earlier in the process and hopefully uh pull off a seamless trans trans Marge are we are we good with that right just uh there's a technology development for
108network maintenance uh since we're reducing a staff member some of the professional development that they receive uh we deferred that or we red we eliminated that is there a dependency between that line item and the actual network manager position so if you restored the position you'd need the you'd need the PD correct thank you we're deferring a middle school lab uh uh desktops uh uh that they'll just be down and not working as efficiently as as they might uh but uh we will defer that particular upgrade to that lab the US sport participation rental fee we suggest increasing from 44 to 50 uh but that's for our young people in our groups our youth groups uh for the use of the fields uh there's a fee for each each student who generally uses them we
109we're suggesting increasing that ELP tuation a recommendation to increase it to uh uh to 125 given the number given where everybody else is the private institutions um we thought that's reasonable certainly the uh board we have told parents the things that the fees aren't settled until the actual board makes their decision just a quick question on that one yeah I mean what are the implications of we have flexibility to put that whatever we want right what are the implications of putting it to 20 25 or 30 so uh lower enrollment um as we've seen this year um we've had to do a number of transfers because of either economic hardships or free and reduced lunch um we've had some people say that the tortion is too high and they've chosen to go elsewhere um so
110the higher you make it there's going to obviously be um some some choice in terms of how many people are actually going to enroll yeah I just I asked the question because I know the the over the broader El program costs the district one point over $1.6 million a year and so we either not charging enough or we're not getting enough reimbursement from the state that's requiring it um so our tuition in terms of like the durg is pretty comparable to Westport um no prek um program in public school is 100% covered by tuition um there really is we're not going to get more uh State reimbursement either I mean if anything we're seeing less State reimbursement but the program isn't intended to be self- sustaining like Dar and summer SP so if we increased
111it to 30,000 and the enrollment went way down does the $1.6 million go up or down uh well you'd have an issue with the 5050 ratio that you have to maintain um I don't know if Shirley wants to talk about that but the less paying students you have um you're going to be imbalanced in your classroom with that ideal 50-50 ratio but fiscally I think the model is is um you're not ever going to cover your costs you're not trying to you're just trying to hit the optimal um volume actually trying to get as many people in the door at the right price point just as a fell yeah please um just on that note what is our current split between the tuition paying students and the um special education students in ELP and is
112there a wait list for enrollment of families that are the general education wanting to get into ELP um Laura is always recruiting the ideal is to have a 50-50 ratio between students with IP and typically developing students but what what is our ratio now I know we had a couple that just went over to we have some new students I'll um I can report that to the superintendent I think we're close to that but I don't want to guess okay and then is there excess demand to get into the program currently do we have families that are waiting that would be tuition paying I'm just curious we're the highest we've been at this point of the year in in the last several years um again I can give the exact numbers of where we are
113but um we're we there are um St still arriving and as you saw earlier in the um information some students who were general education students have since become students are receiving special services so that balance can change also based on evaluations and recommendations okay thank you and the 50-50 ratio you're referring to It Whatever number of special ed comes in we have to try to get that number of yes to match it yes okay thank you there's been a number of discussions about uh catering right so we have eliminated catering expenses for Super Saturday uh the summer board retreat and uh the convocation and the new teacher orientation I I will say to we but it's fine we'll cut it but just like to say our district can't start the school year with a we
114hooking breakfast and for new new staff seems a bit ridiculous to me yes suggesting it but iway I believe that that it's $111,000 security were eliminated in one campus monitor at the high school uh that would uh it's not ideal um I don't lose I I certainly won't lose sleep uh in the sense of uh I have to put my head to the pillow think knowing our kids are safe so I don't I'm not questioning that um but again it's an extra stress on the in the uh organization um you've heard tonight about just in our executive session some things and um uh that provides somebody at the cafeteria essentially and other areas of the building but it it it that reduces something so it's as as described the Cali accreditation for school security uh
115we will not pursue that uh that's a quality sort of recognition of the services for school safety it's something that ordinarily uh we might like to receive in terms of accreditation for schools uh Safety and Security that might be something nice to have um but nice to have is probably not not necessary at this particular Point uh so we've reduced that uh We've reduced a uh one of our H vac uh technicians um from this building to other buildings we we're bringing on new buildings uh across the school system which which are HHR buildings this eliminates one of our our technicians again this not ideal either but um that's a reduction of 152,000 we would have to uh Outsource uh again if we we needed that amount we have reduced uh facilities overtime uh given
116the reduction of one of the hvac's uh technicians we feel that some of the overtime may also be reduced there but that may be offset with uh Contracting I that brings it just shy of a million dollars so that's um are those two also dependent on each other rich just a clarification we can't contract out the HVAC work bargaining unit uh contract um they're not completely tied I mean at the end of the day overtime is largely like incident dependent right if you have something break you want your guys out there to fix it if you were to cut it and um something like that were to happen we' have to bring a transfer to the board dur Joanna and then um um I have a few question I didn't realize we that we were
117going to through the whole memo and then talking um so I have some questions about to start of the memo um let's let's stay on HVAC and then we can go back okay y did you have a question on HVAC okay um going down to one um what does that do if we have somebody on vacation for a week or so whether you have somebody on vacation or all week or is an example of Royals heat goes down and token heat goes down you know pick the school that wins out um you know you could likely have more delayed openings or early smes if heat goes down um you know we have old boilers in a lot of our schools and then on the other side you're adding a lot of air conditioning into the
118schools um and the air conditioning unit that's at Ox Ridge is very very technical and probably takes three times the amount of time to work on than a typical air conditioner at the other schools um so it's it's a definitely a difficult cut are the new systems at HHR similar to oxridge will they be more technical in nature no uh they are different as my understanding Jo um going back to inter murals um my understanding of Elementary level inter murals was that it was through the and I don't I think it's through the D the contract that it's the right of first refusal we have to budget in case a teacher wants so a teacher can say no about uh the teacher has a teach we have to budget as if every school would have
119teachers the intermurals um but then if they decline it we can go to like Daran after school so I think what we would do is speak to the leadership of the DEA and let them know that inter murals haven't run at any school other than homes in at least five years probably more what we're just talking about yeah so but that but I mean I think a lot of parents depend on daring after school so just wanted to make sure that if we did eliminate that from the budget even though it's not running we could still run programs at those schools right we look for anou with the DEA okay Katie um I I'm struggling with this document I don't think it provides nearly the level of detail that is needed I would like to
120see offsets in here I think it's very difficult to um talk about what is being presented as a potential cut without understanding the offset so for example HVAC as an example you know like would we be looking at consultant costs what what would be the tradeoff or if not you know the scenario that rich put um I think you know knowing exactly what the professional development being cut is incredibly relevant to the conversation um you know I think that some of the questions are some of the the writing is makes it confusing to even understand what's in here um like for example the catering and the convocation makes me think that the the convocation breakfast was left in because it just talks about it positively and doesn't say explicitly that it's being cut um so
121I'm happy to follow up with some some submitted refinement to this but um I think this is going to be a difficult discussion as presented Joan like along those lines um when you say reduced curriculum writing $30,000 I understand we have different stages and is this all teacher time or curriculum writer people's time that explain that yeah I'm sorry those are the units right so um one of the wonderful things about our staff is that department chairs work with Educators at the given grade levels and within the Departments to write the curriculum and that's a really important exercise also in professional learning because that's how our staff gets to really know their standards well as as well as the standards that are above and below the grade levels that they teach within their disciplines so
122yes that's a that's a curriculum writing cost but it's like directly correlates to teacher time correct okay thank you I just want to make sure I understood it R um I have a another question on the curriculum writing specifically because it mentions that we wouldn't be able to or would be delayed on a number of classes so one question is the AP classes I thought that already has a set curriculum and similar question for the high school science math courses Etc which have been around for years what is required with ongoing curriculum writing projects specifically for those kinds of classes and then as a followup to that why would we say that those would not happen and then or that Mandarin 8 or some of our newer classes would not happen either because I would
123think that the newer classes would need to be prioritized and that AP already has an existing curriculum so if you could just help clarify that that would be helpful so another important thing to note about curriculum writing is um one of the things that we I think pride ourselves on in Darian Public Schools is that we don't just teach from a program um so even though AP does have an established curriculum it's really important that our educators are looking at that curriculum and um reinforcing exactly how they might use it and manipulate it within their classes to support their students needs I was in an AP environmental science classroom I think just yesterday with Mr doam and was watching that very thing happen as students are preparing for that exam um when I'm thinking about
124the curriculum projects and how we'll prioritize them some of the things that um we would consider as a team are when was the curriculum least uh last written how outdated is it have the standards been revised um is at least stage one written so we have a general scope and sequence for what needs to happen so that there's consistency across classrooms within um a discipline within each of the schools so um the this would be the proposal to kind of um it would slow the work down but to maintain Focus where we need to have it okay and then just to followup there was um in the initial budget book there was curriculum writing foral at the elementary and middle school level and I guess I have a question because I thought that curriculum had
125already been written a year ago or two years ago so what is the ongoing cost and need for that specifically so the ongoing class with umcl is really around morning meeting not everything has been entered into edge of planet in stage one and I think that level of transparency is really important um for the community and additionally um you'll note that we did include curriculum writing for the Middle School to support um flex and that would that would support that work as well thank you Brena so for the AP courses the um to Dr Fan's point the teachers don't teach specifically to the exam the exam has an outline of material that is um the students are expected to know therefore the teachers are expected to teach however they can choose to teach this in
126whichever order that they'd like um AP environmental science specifically for the past um exam season was taught out of order and teachers can determine the most logical um flow of information and the most logical organization of each chapter and each point but it's so important for us to have that pocket of flexibility when it comes to writing the curriculum because the exams themselves are flexible and we do have very high exam success rate tangibly in this District so we know that what we have works thank you anyone else the memo thank you Rena is um is Kevin online yes we do have Kevin online the facilities manager to answer that question specifically good Kevin hello Kevin I just I think that to be honest um most of these need some further expansion on the answers
127and the offsets I think it makes sense to have them documented as well um you know even to to the network and to the consultant fees to the proposal of the department chairs I think a visual would be really helpful from what we had and what those costs are um that you know just a a couple line paragraph is is not really serving okay um I will say just to that uh I didn't want to be self- serving and uh put up a so there maybe a happy meeting there I was just trying to give a sense of the impact um but anyway Kevin's here if we want to talk to him but I don't we do yes please Kevin hi hi everybody can you hear me yes yes we can so the proposed cut
128to the HVAC HVAC technician as as Rich uh teed up for me you know would really restrict our ability to respond uh when needed and with new systems as much as with old there's more response needed than ever before um we do have quite a bit more preventative maintenance that we now have to conduct at oxridge whether it's simple things like filter changes uh on equipment that we just never had before it takes quite a bit of time to to get around to all eight buildings and and do all those PMS properly so losing this position would would put us in quite a bind Kevin um I understand part of what you're talking about is routine maintenance but part is also in the case of an emergency um one of the questions um as I
129was contemplating this is with all new systems um is our is our is it less necessary in the short term or is does all new systems not change anything or add so what we're what we're starting to live and breathe at oxridge is that the new systems require a great deal uh more PMS uh becoming more familiar with the systems because they are so uh finicky because they're so now highly technical that missing one simple uh component check cleaning what have you really um WS havoc on the rest of the system thank you other questions for Kevin I've not related to HVAC go ahead hi Kevin um so we heard during public comment I don't know if you were listening but there was a bunch of comments or a few comments about the paving can
130you just discuss whether what deferring that for a year does and is it is it absolutely POS necessary that we do that this year what's what are your thinking on that please sure so the paving at token was already deferred one year prior um it was on the capital plan for a number of years and it had aged in appropriately so we've already paused on it for one year so to to have it in this year is is just a followup from last year's proposal and at the high school the high school was not un last years's it was it was just age appropriate for this time around High School's 15 years old obviously the asphalt is starting to crack and deteriorate is it a safety issue so no no it's definitely not a safety
131issue but it certainly won't get better over time Katie point of information could you maybe clarify for the public the difference between the capital and the operating budget Jill sure um so there's a couple differences um our operating budget when we use that number lately 4.39 that's our operating budget those are are the a lot of that is salaries and what we use to run our buildings um we have a separate Capital plan which has a bunch of line items um each of those line items represents a specific um uh change that we're making to um a a building or or a facility or the grounds um what is particularly important technically is that we um have only care custody and control of those buildings we don't own them they're actually owned by the town
132so when we go to propose specific changes to the buildings um again or the grounds um we will propose them line by line and the board of finance and the RTM have the ability to reject them line by line whereas in our operating budget we receive a single appropriation so right now our budget is set at about our operating budget is about 125 million if we receive 25 million then we decide how that 125 million gets uh dispersed and if we need to make a transfer we do that internally but because we don't own the buildings uh there's a different relationship between ourselves and the town so therefore the capital budget is not part of the percentage increase that we are discussing so if we were to defer a parking project it would not bring
133that PO number down yes yes correct tax yes but um okay other questions for Kevin while we have himo that's okay we're talking about the budget go ahead um okay I was just wondering um and in your RC you have sorry one second you have uh $35,000 for uniforms and I was wondering how many employees that covers Rich do you know so a little over 50 so it's all the maintenance grounds custodians part-timers than came up a year or two ago um the the dollar amount and it's can you remind us of we kept we decided to keep it in at that price point at the time I just don't because of the number of Staff don't really recall um that um so all the custodians by contract have to have obviously like pants and
134shirts say Daran and the maintenance workers as well and they get food allowances for example uh Sho allowances and so it covers all that for the custodian in the schools it covers that for the the maintenance guys it covers that for the Grounds Guys and it covers that for the part- timr um and obviously we added the part-time custodians at the high school is current year in place of uh the contracted cleaning company as well um thank you Rich I didn't realize that those were contractual obligations and so um it's fair to assume that we have looked at and we're getting the most cost efficient like uniforms that we're providing so this year switched vendors because the increase from the previous vendor for the uniforms was uh too large um which is why you don't
135actually see an increase in the account um so we have shopped around for different vendors Kevin's picked a new vendor this year um but they are contractual in terms of what they get thank you all right anything else Brena um I gu for forgive me for Mr Man Mr M um I am just confused as to what the specific need is for repaving besides for aesthetic purposes and ease oh sure so a number of years ago we conducted a facility study in addition to boilers and roofs and windows and things they actually noted asphalt and Paving as part of the 10-year proposal for what the district should undertake as far as capital projects are concerned so these these projects have been on that list for quite some time and as we've chipped away at the
136lists we're trying to complete all the projects that were noted John I would just add also because you know this kind of layers is in or is enveloped in with Town Capital needs also so so the town can do proper scheduling and understanding of what capital needs U that our district has and how that floats into the broader Town budget um and that's why it's important we do studies a few years ahead of our facilities so we're in complete understanding of what the next project might be and that's why you know middle sex has been targeted for that yeah that's why we exactly we have a five-year Capital plan at all times where we try to plan out the spend so that it's not um a surprise when it shows up and we try valleys
137and there many piz and valleys and we try to stay ahead of things before they fail so that you don't actually want lots of potholes for example you want to get to it before it gets to that point um anything that I missed on that Kevin or Rich no okay Katie thank you um Amy um as we're talking about um looking at the curriculum writing and um potentially slowing it down um how might doing so changing our goals for what we hope to accomplish how might that impact our staffing needs if we are going to you know kind of lessen the amount that we're hoping to accomplish does it make sense to concurrently also look at perhaps shifting our staffing needs as well well you know the staffing needs are not only to support the
138curriculum writing they're also to support professional learning and ongoing instruction that happens in each of the content areas and across the levels so I would say no um the curriculum writing cost is not only something that the department shairs with of course building administrator supervis and leading teacher teams it's primar primarily the curriculum writing caes the teacher hours for those projects right so just in thinking about how um you know we're having conversations about kind of streamlining and replicating models um of administration across different levels so for example um last year Dr Hadley had proposed adding to APS one to the middle school and high school and had said that this mirrors the model at the elementary level um so then if we're looking now also at potentially changing Department shares into you know kind
139of teacher leader models so that we have you know active teachers and subject matter experts if we are looking to you know kind of find those efficiencies as we did with the technology department you know is that not something that we could do at central office as well in curriculum we used to have two people and there was a more Junior role that had been eliminated keeping the senior you know is is something like that or is looking at you know some other model you know in terms of how we might create opportunities for our teachers to do some of that work as opposed to having the the large administrative Staffing for sure um teacher leadership and curriculum writing is incredibly important and that's why you know even last year I think we held three
140curriculum writing sessions in May um and maybe early June where we had more than 100 teachers who were there learning about um ubd and the curriculum writing process and engaging as as teams ready to set off in what we have left to accomplish in our curriculum writing calendar curriculum writing we've talked about is it iterative something that is never done it should not be static um the other piece is you know there's a difference between having a written curriculum and you know an assured curriculum that's intended and actually the one that is experienced by kids and what I would argue is to support that administrators across the Departments of course we don't have one for every single department but broadly we should be covering the Departments so that teachers are supported implementation um there's a
141a tremendous amount of professional learning that happens within those coaching conversations at times I you know the department chairs are modeling for our staff and uh teachers and Department chairs are learning together so I don't see them as the very same thing I don't see um parallel efficiencies that can be found in that way we we did reduce two administrator cental Services into one um and then reduce another technology uh position from Administration uh so we have done that I just can't see taking administrators replacing them with teachers and asking the assistant superintendent for curriculum to run with that that's just a hard asking so go ahead sir I would love to get um a little more detail about I fully understand that you don't want these models both of you um I will lay
142a stake in the ground I don't either um I would love to understand why you think these are not um as good as our current model um and I kind I hoping you can do a little more specificity in like what would actually happen one year two years five years down the road what do you envision in these two separate models so what we what we envisage for the model have n no like if we were to if the board decided to change the model of Department our current model of Department chairs what would the impact be not only next year but further down the road well probably half of people yeah you see here will be here that's the first thing um and that's something really important to keep in mind I'll just say
143like you're impacting not only just structurally operationally but you're impacting culturally um this the the district and that just can't be understated um I don't know how who else will be around I don't know M superintendent will be around I'm just being honest with you right um that's just Sarah's question was operational please I I honestly don't know what the operation with with that would what that would look like uh if we have two if we have two director position if that's the one you're talking about yeah I mean I would love to know more about both so so this I'm gonna respond without great specificity but a quick analogy yeah what Brena was just talking about the question with Mr manett and then um board chair mamman talked about potholes and you don't want
144to have potholes you want to take care of things as you go from a teaching and learning perspective which is the sole purpose for us to be in a learning organization I believe you need a very strong infrastructure to constantly be looking at curriculum that's developed ensure appropriate implementation so that the staff is supported you're developing assessments that are constantly measuring the effectiveness of the curriculum and making adjustments were necessary and that you're Prof you're providing the professional learning to support those Endeavors I think we also talked about you know the the um assistant principles and principles who are also instructional leaders but have a great deal of operational um tasks that they need to complete every single day often that are not even on their agenda or schedule they can't anticipate right it's just
145the shape of how their day plays out so the the partnership between a building administrator and a department chair discipline specific to really guide the teaching and learning core of of our function is really it's really critical and so it's some I think it's something that you would see as an erosion over time um high quality instructional practices when there isn't that level of um I guess high quality feedback within the within the specific discipline so you're just we be just you know eroding more and more discipline specific so you have a teacher leader position that is a08 and a point2 release time what does that do operationally and how effective can that position be in keeping a top District current with their curriculum so I can't imagine Any teacher that I know who's a
146really dedicated and Effective Teacher being able to actually function at just a point8 I think most teachers when you have them at a point8 the commitment that you see from that person is generally even more than a 1.0 teachers are taking home papers their lesson planning they're collaborating with colleagues they're seeking their own professional learning um and I'm sure you know many other things to keep Pace with the needs of the students before them so to think that a point8 and then the point two on balance you know I don't know what we could actually expect a teacher to get done with simply a point2 release when their primary concern they would hear from me would always need to be their students that would always need to be it would not be the administrative Duty
147that would go along with from a teacher's perspective just filling in a point to release their primary responsibility would have to be the kids if it also if it also have an impact across not only the classrooms the responses to our community members what they expect uh education is going to be impacted because of the number of Administrators we have versus the actual teachers um if there's an area that is content specific and I think most people would would agree with this it's at a secondary level um and most teachers value the the expertise that is provided uh at the ministrative level maybe not always agree with their ministrators right um but they appreciate the expertise of the uh content that that they provide and that's just that's just one of the things that that's
148not going to happen at the extent that it is now Dr adley if I can just add one other thing something that I'm proud of as a school system this past year that we've implemented by way of the Strategic plan is the aspiring leader Academy um with our staff we have a core of I don't know March probably 30 teachers across departments and and grade levels a really magnificent group and I know that um they're all asking really fabulous questions right about how do you enter into leadership for for a school and District leadership type role in teaching and learning and um you know I know that many of those people would be aspiring to to be not only assistant principales but Department chairs especially those that really love curriculum work so that's recruit actual
149model is actually working right now just like in a short time um if you can just sort of water this you you expertise actually people have stepped out of the department chair model um and actually growing into the system principle model which is exactly what we want them to do right uh grow our staff keep our staff uh it's actually working um I'll leave it that thank you um I I would like to see when we talk about even just the potential of changing the way that we're looking at curriculum and Department chairs I think that we absolutely have to look at at three models concurrently we have to look at having dedicated Department chairs we have to look at having no Department chairs and just the teacher leader model the one in this document
150actually seems to be the worst of both to me it doesn't make sense to consolidate where you have one subject matter expertise and then you wind up with two subjects you know by by having two that don't have that that doesn't make any sense to me um we have had this model in the past um so so we know that it can work um we do have you know we've we've heard at the table a lot that people like to have active teaching curriculum instructors additionally I'm I'm having trouble with the way that we're hearing contradiction statements at the table tonight we're hearing that we can't have a point8 and a0 2 but at the middle school like the whole conversation between four and five classrooms doesn't change anything for a student so it's one
151way or the other it's it's either teaching four classrooms is the same as teaching five or it's not and to say that there's a cultural impact to changing a model of Department chairs and and there's not on pair of professionals um I I really think that that we are losing our vision for this district and we are hearing widely from the community that they feel the same way that what is our goal here what are we looking for what are we cutting and and for what goal truly if there are things that we cannot live without if we are facing the degradation of the Excellence of Darian schools then we need to say that and we need to band together and we need to defend the money that we need right now right now we
152are just picking and throwing at things and we have a responsibility to go through every single RC and every piece of an option that is on presented in front of us we have to explore we have to understand not just professional development but what professional devel El and how does that tie from early literacy and our youngest grades all the way up to what does it mean for our high school students that's our job and if we truly cannot be comfortable with these cuts and I'm not comfortable with a lot of them that's our job too 100% we cannot back into a number and crumble the education system in deran yeah and I think to build on that the nine of us need to figure out where are we comfortable I am not comfortable with
153a lot of this I am not comfortable with making our district worse I am not here to sit at this table and make our district worse and to me that is exactly what this budget does and we have put our superintendent and our cabinet in a position where they have put these horrible things on the table and yeah they're horrible I will say it they are not good for our students they're are not good for our staff they're not good for us they're not good for our town are we going to sit here and have the board of Finance tell us that we have X amount of money and you can jiggle around all you want like EXC excuse me Sarah I just shifted my seat okay so listen can I get an apology I'm
154Sor okay all right John John John Katie okay listen I don't this this we are all emotional about this this gets this is we are talking about kids we are talking about people we are talking about our town if our town is not going to pay for what our education costs and what our education at the level that we expect it costs what are we doing well I think the first thing we have to do is we do have to turn over the rocks and we do have to see what it costs we do have to assess where our priorities are if we don't ask what are what can we do what is next what might happen then we have a hard time getting to our priorities and so that's been part of this exercise
155what do we truly value and I don't I think there is a difference between understanding a framework for starting a conversation and backing into a number I don't I don't think that we so I think we have to be very careful not to get stuck on what number do I like or do I not you have to get care comfortable with saying where like I said earlier where do our dollars go which priorities are they attached to and are we doing this as efficiently as possible and those are two critical things that we do have to do at this board table it has been uncomfortable in a number of cases and so we might have to talk about some ways to shift how we talk but it this is never not going to be comfortable
156unless we do it all behind the scenes but my point is if we if Education costs a 6% increase it costs a 6%% increase and we don't get a 6% allocation well then then we present what we need for our district and other bodies can decide if that's appropriate or not okay John and then Brena so we are in a budgeting process and we don't have uh unlimited resources I do think we can actually coales around many elements of superintendence budget this this process is partly because we rejected the superintendent and his cabinet's recommendations um you know idea is a perfect example none of us like this process folks um but I think if we go down as we um have in the past now and create some sort of package if you will or
157proposal of um budget initiatives uh based off the superintendent's budget I think we're going to get pretty close to where we thought we were going to get there might be differing um elements amongst us all in terms of what that final number is based on kind of the the trailing um categories but I think you know we're at the point where we have to start making decisions and um where we end up as a majority of this board is going to be where we do propose to the board of Finance who can uh reject it and we can go through that process like we did last year again so that's what the point I was going to try to make Rena um might we also not um back into numbers but rather names and might
158we ground ourselves in what's so dear to us the community that we built up and the students that we work for and may we also remember that it's not just8 FTE it's a Mr maoni or it's a principal dunk it's these people that it's these faces that we just can't forget and that we must ground ourselves in in our community yes and I certainly appreciate the grounding the only thing that I I'll just um tweak a little bit about that just because we've had some confusion from the public that it board members do not hire and fire any staff members except for the superintendent so we yes certainly need to understand that we're talking about people but we don't have control over who the individual is so it's just a technicality and because the Public's
159a little confused I just want to clarify did you have your hand up um I on your note about thinking about what our goals are and what is the most important and what are the most important priorities for our district I do want to kind of take us back to our strategic plan goal number one enhancing teaching and learning and I would personally view that as our number one priority and I would hope that as a board of nine people we could come to a conclusion about a budget that would allow us us to enhance teaching and learning and keeping our students first in our priorities um we as Board of Ed did give guidance to come in at last year's level which is 4.73 most recently new Canan and Westport both both of those
160board beds just approved budgets of 4.67 4.69% increases unanimously um I I understand that the board of that the board of gave us guidance but I think it's very important for us to go through all of the detail RC by RC I think there might be additional opportunities we haven't talked about yet I think we need to think creatively we need to try to figure out how we can expand the pie we need to talk about Revenue we need to talk about many different things and some of them might be longer term but I think we to John's point I do think that we can get there but I would hope that as a group we really we really think creatively and ultimately vote on a budget that we truly believe will help us to
161accomplish the teaching and learning goals of our district to keep us at the top level of Education that our community has come to expect thank you with that uh let's move on to rc1 let shift over to the RC's Madam chair we do have any questions or are we have questions well I just wanted to make sure that um there questions that were submitted by staff or by sorry board members they're highlighted um I just don't want to ignore them if you want to talk about them that's okay too short go through every question no just if there's um let's go to that in RC you you've answered all all of them have been addressed except for the ones that are in I think gu pink or M or whatever yeah so there's rc6 why
162don't we take no sorry we questions are all organized by RC so why don't we do RC by RC just in general so it could be questions and a conversation about the RC at the same time just for efficiency sake okay so rc1 yes Robin um I have a question um about the wellness center and whether or not we might be able to try to find additional funding or alternative ways of funding the $44,000 for example um and again I'm I'm putting out some IDE is here the Student Activity fund is one looking for other grants potentially within the community or otherwise where we might be able to find some funding or alternatively uh in the past this district has used staff or um parent volunteers for things like the middle sex information center centers
163at the elementary schools in kindergarten and first grade when I first moved to Jen where parents actually volunteered and came into the school so one thought would be that potentially parents might be interested in helping with the Welcome Center as opposed to being a paid employee because we already have the activities we've got a lot of supplies and it's just an idea these I know we already do have the PTO Health organized for the college visit Center where parents volunteer their time to come and be there when the college um reps are here so as an idea I think that that's that should be something that we might be able to explore as alternatives to help with our students because the pto's also did they gave the furniture for the wellness center they are very
164in tune with the needs of the students and this might be an opportunity for us okay anything else thank you anything else in rc1 okay rc2 oh I had I just had a quick follow on the on the guidance counselor questions are we in line for both the number of counselors as well as the assistance of the guidance counselors versus the rest of the district versus the dur uh so the the we do have our our guidance counselors here actually our director of guidance um the last presentation we have we were in line uh with the number of compatible with the the surrounding district and also in line with the ratio that me ask would ask I don't want to I don't want to pull something from the audience that shouldn't really do that so
165the answer it any further than that do you want the information we are we are in line with the dur for both um and just in terms of the wellness center you cannot use Student Activity funds to F the wellness center it's an impermissible use of Student Activity F thank you for clarifying okay okay rc2 switch we're just asking questions on the questions right no if you have one about the overall RC okay um we're gonna do both at the same time just in the it's 10 you said fch yes I know in the past there's been some conversations about having students from other districts come in um if we're not at our you know like some sort of exchange maybe or or tuition paying students from other districts that don't have a Fitch um
166as that been looked at again recently if that's at all feasible or for horse trading on transition services or something like that like new so they they all have a Fitch now they all have a Fitch now oh thank you is the first okay RC RC's uh RC three robin um can I add to the uh the ad cut this spreadsheet if I have a line item wait I didn't think we were doing add Cuts I just thought we were discussing we we are sorry we're going through the questions and the RC's at the same time so it's simultaneous because it's already 10 o'clock and we vote next so we are doing ad cut if you have if you the idea was to be at a higher level but if you do have something but
167I'd like to add um the addition of sex club student interest fees at the $50 level which was originally in the participation fee memo that the the just that admin admin had presented I think was 23,000 in Revenue so point of clarification do we need to cut something that's in the memo but not technically added so like the like for going back to DHS for the um the $50 fee I is that something I would need to cut or is that not even added if it's if it's in the spread so sorry which is if it's in the spreadsheet it's already in there okay because the way that the memo is written is that you know you could do this you could do that you know I think the just CL you should just clarify
168like the way that this is first time doing it like the way that it works all you're doing is just putting it on the spreadsheet right we usually but this is not from the initial budget I thought we only add or cut from the presented budget I I'm I'm sorry I'm not sure which um item you're talking about so you're talking about how Allen's adjusting the fee I'll just go back to the beginning can we go back to dh1 I would like to only put in a $100 participation fee for athletics only got it clubs um and with a $400 family cap okay so a model with a $100 Athletics only fee and a400 can we just stay RC by RC though yes the RC 11 oh that's 11 yes okay okay okay so then
169I would like to cut $50 Club key for but that's it's already on it's already on we're not voting right now just on the spret so the only thing sorry the only thing we need to do tonight is just get something on and just have something on the spreadsheet so you know you know you can you can yes or no it okay yeah that's your original question you're to say information yes uh so we had a discussion about the wellness center it should be on the spreadsheet now so it's now on the spreadsheet for are we put numbers next to or we're staying at a higher level we're just putting it on there for further compensation I think it just needs to get on there right now thank you very much yeah so so to
170clarify does that at that puts the wellness center at 44 000 on the sheet yes okay right you getting these numbers that's just the value of the staff member it's not the value of the staff member that is the staff member salary okay rc3 did we go ahead okay so I'm looking at the spreadsheet which is not not oriented by RC so it's a it's a little a bit of sifting um so this has that okay the RC is one it's the recommendation is that it's coming from the admin and that's where the department chairs are in there okay so then I would like to also see what it would look like to be listed for discussion um if if everything were to move to a uniform teacher leader I think you put that's in
171there in the orange you might not down on the bottom I think or you might not have the newest one I don't I don't think that's the one I'm operating this one there was a new one that went do you mean just before or do you also mean like the music director and the director of it like just give me a second to check my sheets thank you that's fine we'll um keep moving and then you just give us a holler okay Kitty um all right rc3 all right RC's 5 through 10 we have all the pairs in the spreadsheet already yes oh yes the pairs are in pairs are in the spreadsheet as are the interns I'd like to also cut one um building sub per uh building per building okay so add a
172building Sub in please Rich um I have a question is there any value and doing um a hybrid model of Paras and interns and if so what would that look like margin rich or Amy I I mean you can you can really do anything you want so we the what it looks well it's true um we did three for two and part of that was to save costs so we did three to two interns um but you can do any kind of a hybrid I mean I I would like to preserve the building Subs because they've been really help full covering classes this year you know the question is if you want to put some Paras back in Cut interns that might be a better way to do it that that was my thinking like
173get rid of one building up but keep the intern so you're up body okay okay so I think maybe that's sort of a question because from there were two different issues that were in the Paris discussion one was financial and how are we solving for a financial piece but part of why I think you guys raised the Paris is because there's an oport AAL issue in that they're trying to cover classes and that's not really what the position is intended for so my question is can we can you have a smaller model for PA professional deployment and then supplement with uh a um an intern and I would say if we want to look at the whole mix whether it's building Subs interns Paras is there a compromise model it there comes a point where
174and I'm very be for anybody who's sitting in here who's air professional um uh given that the we're talking about absences or being used for different things um there comes a point where it's perhaps not worth it's perhaps not worth keeping one versus versus three of them to be honest with you well if the operational problem is that we literally don't have enough people in the building to cover these different meetings and pull out times 25 would we rather just put a dedicated person in the building right just covering the subs and keeping the parents as they are right doing what they're supposed to be doing so that's what the building subs off sorry that's what the building Subs up right but we'll have three building subs and zero interns if we have two interns
175and two building Subs that's four people right but the interns aren't there for the full year well aren't you said they were there for the full year minus the 10 student teach for 10 years for 10 10 weeks right yeah they're there for the full year they just there's a 10 we there's 10 weeks when they're not available so cutting the building sub would make those 10 weeks even more problematic for coverage I mean we added we added the third building sub last year I mean there are some districts that and I rich may know the exact FTE they just put the Paris in kindergarten like point so there are some districts that do the equivalent of 05 par for every kindergarten section um so here here that would be like 10 pairs as opposed
176to 15 but you wouldn't be having them let's say in first second third fourth okay so you do it in kindergarten and then you'd put a a maybe one intern in for the coverage I mean you still might end up pulling them you know for coverage purposes but you'd at least if people came to work every day you'd have Paris in kindergarten okay okay Robin just in on that note then if you had the Paris and kindergart would you have one student intern or two or your original to help with coverage I mean one intern would be great I was suggesting one simply because mathematically if if the if the Paras are subbing each each of the three is subbing around 30% times three you get around 90% you're pretty close to one person so
177rich do you know off the top of your head like General Bog Park two PA plus one in turn what is that comparatively to that $1.1 million uh so so you'd be cut five pars at roughly 80,000 piece um and then the intern would be about 17 so still be safe if if you reduce the pair of professionals you wanted the land up being uh either in kindergarten or the lowest grade essentially I mean that's where they'll be used educationally thank you fundamentally thank you okay anything else in 5 through 10 so can you remind me please um when if there were if we went to no Paras just student interns three building Subs what happens when these interns are doing their student teaching work coverage would be more difficult I mean just would they're
178not available they have to be in a dedicated classroom for 10 weeks so they wouldn't be available to cover so either way there's issues with coverage whether you have two and two whatever you have they're unavailable for at least 10 weeks there's an issue with coverage as as long as our average absent rate of teachers is over 13 a year I it's just you know there just aren't enough bodies in the buildings than yeah I just have another question um I'm moving backwards a little bit but I went to the end of the question list there's the list of all the different Consultants is consolidating team talk with a Wellness Center an option no uh sorry just just just operationally it's not just given the nature of the counceling that that that would take place
179it's just a different it's a different function you're that counselor um essentially is oneon-one they will do some group work and stuff but but that that counselor te talk counselor is available uh to individual students throughout the day families throughout the day it's not really something that would be done in that particular setting also isn't team talk technically the counselor is employed by kids and crisis and it's the kids and crisis program that we're embedding in our school yes well that's a function of what you does though I mean what what does she do on the grind every day some of the things I'm just describing followup yes um to that response that was in the list that was my question I was a little more that I asked I asked if we have any
180anticipated these look like the items you're planning to use for Consultants not questioning your ability to bring another Consultants but do you have anyone else you're thinking like you might want to bring like the scheduling cons consultant or anybody else I I just want to make sure this totally comprehensive I I would say to uh thanks David I say to that we didn't avoid looking ahead um for the most part some of those will carry forward uh for the most part uh it would it wouldn't exempt is coming forward with someone different but we haven't like got got we don't have that plan and not telling you about it it's just some of those will just move forward or or replicate them with someone else all right so there's nobody like there's no nice to
181haves or Mayes out there this is pretty comprehensive it's yes that's things change I guess okay the list of consultants list in the end yeah that one correct um to stay on Consultants but it's not in the in jumping around RC's Jill I don't know if you want I would just went backwards because it's one and three with well yes and the Consultants it's everything um so there are some people listed and the curriculum RC um that their names they I just wondering if they're actually are consultants and just wer also listed here what question's that so is it on the question list or well it's related to the question list we have a list of all Consultants at the end okay but going through the uh rc19 I see there's an Ellen tuck tuckner
182and a Holly Clark um and then you know Poss we spoke earlier about sometimes having someone go to the administrative Retreat which I think was taken out but I just want to make sure that you know Ellen tuckner and Holly Clark are are they Consultants they just you know what are they who are they they are um Holly Clark is a consultant for technology she supported some of the work um with AI and some of the work that the teachers in the gifted program were engaging in curriculum development she also was our complication speaker at the beginning of the year um Ellen tuckner is supporting some of our work at the Elementary level with data analysis with supporting um having our students one her one of her main goals is helping us to get to
183a place where we have all of our kids strong decoders when they leave second grade and she's really supporting the revision of our mtss processes leading that work so it's going be consistent across the five elementary with Julie droller she should be they should be added to the list right that's why I'm just this is a full should be all correct they should be they should be out because they're in across a different RC I see what you mean soing we only listed consultants in the consultant account um so things like Holly Clark are considered professional development um could we ask for redo yeah that's what we did do we just did the consultant line item okay so you're saying across our seats yes basically who are you bringing in that is not employed by
184DPS is that what you're looking for yes kind of a followup yes and I apologize this may be on me because I was not anticipating going RC by RC quite the fashion we are tonight um I may not be alone I'm hoping we'll have an opportunity to give written suggestions and comments after we flag general areas tonight proposed line items to be added in the spreadsheet I don't know if it's best for Rich to maybe collect those after this broad discussion we're having this evening I mean I'm my concern is that how does the public know what we've added well they'll see the updated spreadsheet well but not until Monday before Tuesday Tuesday's the public hearing so I would say let's try to get them this evening I'm I mean look I think at the
185end of the day the purpose of the public hearing is not so much so that the public can respond line by line but really more so that the public can talk to us from a higher level about where their what their priorities are if this budget reflects I we were starting to hear some of it already but if this budget reflects the community uh values Etc um and what the community wants to see in the budget so um you know technically line items can be added and subtracted up until the night that we vote we just try to do it as early as possible to give the public optimal visibility into what we're discussing so let's try to stay pretty close to the process um okay we are let's go back to RC by RC
186and try to stay that way um we are still on 5 to 10 are there any questions about the RC or is there any that budgetarily people want to either add to the spreadsheet or discuss further okay let's go to RCL Robin so I I have some line items that I just I I have some questions but it it might lead to some additional ads um on the contracted athletic trainers and rch I don't know if it helps to the account number do you need that um the the cost went from like 140,000 in 2022 23 now it's 210,000 what was the reason for the increase and do we feel that we are doing that the most efficiently possibly because it looks like we used to do it in-house now we do contracted just question
187uh in 23 it was 92 not the 140 and that was because we only had one contracted trainer and then we had one District trainer then it went to 204 which it stayed at 204 for another year because we have two trainers who have contracted ad no District employees it's going to 210 next year uh it is less expensive than having our own District employees do the benefit and are they full-time or are they on an hourly basis just after school when the sports are happening or how does that work uh so they they have an alotment of 40 hours week so essentially a full-time and are they utilized by the students 40 hours a week I'm assuming so I would have to ask during the school day because that's why I'm asking I think
188it's during like when games are and practices but is that 40 hours a week 40 total hours a week including weekends yeah I I'm just asking about the usage are we fully utilizing them to pay that level that's why I'm asking so I I'll check with Chris but I'm assuming the answer is yes okay so we'll check that um and then the other question was on the fees account which over the past five years went from 25,000 to 62,000 I know Chris had said that there's an increase because of other postseason tournaments entry fees different things and and I guess the question I have is if we have added additional postseason tournaments are those all fcac inseason events or if not if we're seeing a huge increase in entry fees for additional events that we
189never used to do before is that something that should be paid separately outside of the season so I don't believe it's anything new I can double check with Chris I think Chris said that there were lots of new things and other teams that are doing things now that they never were doing before so that's why I'm ask we can check with course I know the big uh the larger portion of the increase year-over year is just the fee to CIA see okay um but I can check with them if there's anything to new okay um thank you and then on the inter Scholastic officials account um and this one is the one where it has to do with the Turkey Bowl so the question I have is because the the amount last or two years
190ago and we did not do the turkey bow was 180,000 and it increased significantly for this following year when we do not do the turkey Turkey Bowl and I'm wondering why we only have a $5,000 increase instead of a $30,000 increase so so each year they do get the increases um so it's compounded with increases and then we have more night games and so the night games add to that cost well so for the officials we're paying more because of more okay all right um the other question I I had asked about this previously the hockey games the off duty police do we really need four because it says we could have two to four whereas all the other sports have two once we request police we don't have any say over how many police
191we get even if we pay for them correct so we have no say regardless of the cost police officers so our say is the campus monitors okay U but not the police officers okay and then finally advertising Revenue which we're we thankful to the booster club for their their efforts on our behalf on this the the question I have here is because they did present to the finance committee potentially expanding this if there was a desire to do so to Stadium East and the oval and said that they had had assess sponsors that were interested so is my question is is there an additional Revenue opportunity that we we could choose to pursue because that could be another 12 to $24,000 just like it was for the stadium so the I mean the agreement in
192place does allow them to expand because there was no limitations on what they were to do if they were to expand to uh the other fields there could be incremental rant and I guess I'm asking if we should add that into our spreadsheet is that a potential budget item because it could also expand opportunity for us I think we agreed to we just sort of like uh apprised the board what that what that was um and just sort of get a tcid feeling to move forward because it wasn't a a requirement from the board to take a vote on it or anything um but the board hasn't been fully updated on we don't I mean again we were talking a stadium which has whole different usage patterns versus upper oval and Stadium East so I
193mean I'm trying to be creative I I get that but we're talking about low dollar amounts at this point so okay to be fair every dollar amount I'm mentioning adds up to about $150,000 of additional opportunity within our budget so I do think that everything is important that's all I had for that RC thank you yes Katie thanks I had a question about the five year fiveyear uniform um so I appreciate that it's it's laid out in terms of like when we would incur costs um but two sort of really kind of practical questions one is what are the implications of that you know is it just that they're not as new and shiny but they're still functional um you know is that a reasonable deferment that we can potentially even shift to long term
194and then secondly um and I I recognize that um some of these questions some of them might be from Mr Man forgia but Chris um I'm sorry Rich to the um to the extent that you can answer any of them I'm also curious about why a couple of them stood out to be so much more um so for example football and Lacrosse you know are like in the $25,000 versus other ones that are you know the closest number I think is like 10 and then there's many that are below um I'm guessing some of that has to do with Okay so this comes back to like a cut no cut kind of thing um it and the uniform costs though those are just like clothing just Jersey and pants it's not protective equipment or would
195that Encompass all believe what JY well not yeah like a football jersey or lacrosse Jersey costs more than a cross country shirt or golf shirt too okay any more on rc11 rc2 Joanna had the participation fee request oh yes figur got can you just remind me what you proposed just every time I go over the athletic budget it's very hard I have a lot of issues with how uh resources are are distributed inequitably but when it comes down to it we want to do a participation fee I think it should be $100 and only for athletics because Athletics gets a coach equipment Transportation um and a uniform and the clubs get after three years get a get a teacher or coach okay um rc2 RC 13 RC rc15 Joanna um so just about the um
196computer equipment last year's materials I believe said that new cane in leases their computers um why don't we or you know what what is the advantage or disadvantage of that so they say what they really do Tak person loan out the bank fin the cost so you'd be taking out a loan let say Chase or TD Bank at 6% interest to buy a $350 um it's not a great use of funding resources you Ty would want have borro C talking about high price point um districts do do it because then year that you're paying while you're paying that lease payment which you're creating debt that you're pushing down okay thank you and then um for our display systems it says $5,000 for an Apple TV and a you Sonic I know Apple TV are like
197less than $100 usually or you know I can't imagine that they're much more so these view Sonics um is this something that every teacher in classroom needs is this something that some you know teachers would want but other teachers are fine with just general L like large LED screen or is that a chef question so we're so we're trying to put these just instructionally in all the classrooms and that's what we're trying to do can you say that again like these Sonic board right behind you here um we're trying to put those in all the classrooms ideally in all the classrooms but in a year will we have budget constraints is that something that we need to keep doing well that's that's that we a question for us we can we can pause on that
198if we have to right thank you yes okay they are 15 years old the ones that are set to be 16 years old almost um set to be replaced so if we pause you're just having an older device and operationally can you speak to how often it's a problem that they're old advice Greg um I got a bunch of questions um first can we put the for the ad cut can we put the Chromebooks for fifth grade on there to not be replaced and then can we also put on there to eliminate the one toone initiative i' like to see what the impact of that might be uh as far is not just not replacing Chromebooks but like other software programs that would also no longer be necessary um so R did you get that
199I'd also like to put on elimination of Zoom so just so clear you want to eliminate all P Chromebooks for lower grades the fifth the fifth grade I I don't know which grades but the fifth grade The Replacements that were in the budget it was just for fifth grade so I think we should look with at what it would look like to phase out the one: one program so you don't want elementary schools to have a one to one unified device correct or middle six just for elementary so go back to basically going back to a part correct okay so we you'd want to replace fifth grade with more carts you wouldn't replace them you'd save the money and going forward you wouldn't have to replace them either that's just that's just stat that's a
200change in in the actual programmatic Basu model that we have but if they would still have them in the building they just I mean they would have as many but they still be replacing them and using the programs it just would be something that the kids took home every day that's the implication of eliminating go to so if you eliminate fifth grade just simply wouldn't have a device um If you eliminate this because right now the fifth graders would take their Chromebooks to middle school so if you cut the fifth grade Chromebooks you just don't have Chromebooks in for the doesn't that mean they wouldn't be able to do their homework because I believe all of that right now is digital and it's writing and it's online programs for for fifth graders am mean what
201would be the impact on homework would be an impact on homework but I think the larger impact would be on the state mediated State Testing students use their Chromebooks for that also historically we used that for we used it on a cart um that's what we did before we went one to one um so would we still be able to do that they just wouldn't access to the Chromebook for homework I mean not all of their homework is on the Chromebook anyway but the familiarity of using the Chromebook is important to to Great throughout the year I have a fifth grader right now he barely uses Chromebook ever I got a fifth grade just use it to watch YouTube at home same here small sample size but I would certainly respect that those to to
202disposition but you're we're just like we're just we haven't had a really discussion about one to one and changing the model just at the table it just seems about eliminating a lot of important people so my suggestion is to not eliminate the people but to eliminate some of these devices that are recurring costs that are going to continue to go up over time understood okay um oh I have more so Zoom we have Microsoft teams that we already pay for I think we should ship to that so can we put that onto the I think it's on the list it was part of the answered questions because they said that but I don't think it's on the Excel spreadsh the Excel Excel oh so can we put that on there and then with respect to
203the software programs that we have I know this has been discussed a few times um my concern is that while utilization rates are high we have not made a clear uh distinction between which of these software programs relate to our core programs that we really care about versus not core so I think it'd be great to see what that looks like to see if there are software programs that are not in you know not as important to us as we might I think my question kind of related to that was that the learn platform um how does it identify a program to stop using is there like a use rate um it does it does give us some feedback on on usage rates and that's actually what we did Mr grman with these other software
204the current software packages that we have we went through it with with learn in terms of are we using it are we not using it um we had discussions with curriculum as to are these important or not um we actually didn't we eliminated a lot of new proposals for software but we did go through uh the list actually a couple of times we've gone through that list um and you learn to go through it too so I have a question about seesaw in particular um I understand it's for kada2 because it's more pictoral than but if we are not if kindergarten and first grade and second grade aren't learning from home the majority of the time why are they on cesa in the classroom or is it used for some other purpose some other population
205like if if you're focusing on play based learning we're trying to get away from screens why are we continuing to uh um invest in this particular platform that I know was brought in to help manage classrooms during the pandemic right I agree so your question is why are they using seesaw they're not using seesaw at home is that what you're saying well why are they using it in the classroom they're not they're using it when for example the teacher might have students go into centers that might be one Center that students engage in for a part of this a part of literacy block or part of math block but they're not using it in place of instruction with text and time with the teacher it's just another it's an alternative means students can operate pretty
206independently on it at the K2 level so my suggestion for thinking about technology would be that if we are interested in having them go back and take another scrub that we identify a percentage around a number specific to this category um Dave looks like he's saying no but um I guess yeah and again this is one where it's always a little tricky with policy and budget kind of mix right which is the the trouble with that cut um instead of a number like for me like brain pop stood out as one like that's a lot of construction paper for 12 for 20 grand I'd love to see them not be on Brain Pop um and I just had a followup I'd love to know rich or or Amy the education difference from a multi thousand
207view Sonic versus an LG um what's the educational difference we have an answer to that with an appreciation for the age yeah I get it they're old but like why do we need to VI Sonic Department Rich do you know for an LG have check yeah versus I mean LG's just need I'm just throwing out a cheap highend cheap I know these are very high so yeah we'll follow all right thank you is that you talking about an LG just being the screen David so the view s like you could tell me that hey the resolution is really great and we have Learners who are challenge visually so we need to have this level screen to be able to develop you know deliver education of certain where are visually challenged great I'm done if you
208want to tell me that there's an LG screen that'll pretty much do the same thing there's no real difference okay then now I'm going to wonder why this is the computer sort of built into this process and the screen and that may be the answer I just so something that I can't speak to but I would wonder about is like the um functionality of you know engaging back and forth but I'd have to look into it and see exactly what that offers one these are more than just a screen and there's a computer built in right yes leave it more than a screen yeah that would be great the interactive capability so we'll look and see what we offer thank you Robin um I had a question about the the teacher and admin laptop replacement
209cycle I know in here they are saying that they want to replace them every four years and my question is are they really not working or could that be extended to be a five year because I know I have a four-year-old laptop and it's working just fine just for the administrators and the teachers specifically I'm not talking about students or student desktops as I understand those get a lot of use every single so the laptops aren't high-end laptops that are purchased and so the ones that are in place now have had um a number of issues battery issues screen issues Etc which is why they're slid into be okay thank you okay anything else in 15 and um I need some clarification about what um is happening with with brain pops sea anything high level
210are we just asking questions or are you guys putting stuff on so it all seems to be like in rc15 um seems like there's various different line items I mean I I can read off my list if other people have lists I don't well we could just send them in but I mean so far I've heard new computer equipment with fifth grade Chromebooks I've heard um anybody please jump in zoom zoom yeah I think we're talking about laptops extending for teachers but going go an extra year for 45 um brain pop I threw out there I don't if anybody else had anything rc15 but I was thinking looking at seesaw I was also still wondering about learning a toz Gras kid um if we're moving away from Level readers can we I know we have
211them physically already in the classroom do we still need to be that I remember my now 11th grader us that program it seemed kind of outdated again also these are educational decisions that we shouldn't be making but you you understand why we're raising these questions right what I was just saying to Shirley is some of our students who receive special education services also use some of the computer software um that you're listing so that would be something that we would want to talk about together can I just make the Assumption about I'm not trying to like trying to understand like would we be educating our parents now how to use Microsoft teams that meetings and stuff like or is that a discussion for another day I don't think anyone needs to be I mean I
212don't personally everyone knows how to use both okay there like five other op you okay let's just put on the cut L for the moment I'll def okay yeah tired okay Joe can I can I go back to rc11 I have a question it's more of a the theoretical question I think what constitutes a club and a sport and if a club if if we have a sport that wants to become a club can that happen oh that's a good question yes we can have a sport that need wants to become a club like rugby was a club exactly and squash was probably a club and they all got elevated the sports can they move back down if they want that's a good question yes and and and what and what would constitute that and
213how does that mechanism happen I I would assume and we can check with Chris if it's sanctioned by the CIA but those Sports those four sports are not so corre if they what if they what if they band together and say we no longer want to be a sport we want to be a club okay so so I would imagine for those Sports probably could okay um but we can check with press okay can you check that and then I actually neglected to ask um to talk about unified um because in some ways that functions a little bit more like a club than it does like a sport it does it does receive some limited Transportation I think and there is a t-shirt but it's a little bit of a different model than a traditional
214sport so is it a c sport pried I don't know so can you just look at um unified specifically when you think about the participation Fe please it is all right yes thank you okay any more else on 11 if not we're going to seven 16 16 I question 16 um I think we used to do get the demographer every other year and then we went to yeah we've talked about it off and on go ahead Rich uh so in my time we've done it every year um I would say it's the report that informed your largest expense within the budget and so in the years in which in the past where you didn't have a demography report those are years where you had high swings of either you over budgeted for teachers you ended
215up not filling or you under budgeted for teachers where you ended up having to find money um it's six you're you're spending 60 you know $60 million on teacher salaries and a report for $11,000 is what's informed you very thank you okay anything else in 16 Greg there there was a question I had and something one the one of the folks in the public comments asked about the Weather Service that we use is it there's something special about it that we're missing I mean I I have just free weather I look at on my phone all the time yeah so actually if you ever want to see a dysfunctional group of uh people Superintendent at four o'clock in the morning with the weather guy is uh is the place to be um uh we do
216use uh I use that particular service because everybody in in the state of Connecticut basically uses that service that's about it's probably a third of that that that cost uh so we collaborate in the morning uh with the actual meteorologist um with and with the superintendent like all in the southern farfield County area uh the other one uh we may be able to do something with because I personally do not use that one Beyond him I use Google and I use weather.com and stuff um I know our our facilities Department uh uses the other service so you'll take a look at that one sky GI that uh that's the service that the facilities Department uses um primar that gives them information about the roads and information about uh you know ideally when to bring people
217in start shoveling and planning I think there's one in that that particular okay we'll put it on and you guys if you have a if you have a suggestion you can tell us yeah okay thank you okay um anything else in 16 oh yeah um the catering costs can you break out what that um like our Board of AD catering I'm fine with cutting like I'm happy to buy everybody's s Ines but the you know the this the retirement and the convocation and all that that that seems if we're really cutting that in Darian Connecticut that's so what is that what is that price what's the breakout of what is you know for staff versus so we can do each line item then that's great thanks want to just break out the Board of Ed
218stuff so you don't have to break out all the like what what is you know the Super Saturday and what we get versus everything else yeah well didn't you say convocation was 6,000 that was already broken out so is the rest of it Board of Ed stuff uh so 2500 is Super Saturday uh 2500 I believe is the board retreat from July um the $6,000 is um convocation and then you have small amounts for things whether it's like legislative breakfast that was here negotiations um you know principal meet and greets things like that so negotiations remind me we get pizza we get p but for for both groups right we for oh we don't pay for the teachers the teachers e eat better than you do so you're come on all right okay 17 19
219Joanna um I don't know if we still making line item request Cuts is that okay um so uh there was part of the uh Title One contraction um rc19 absorb $3 32,8 15 um that was previously you said used for Teachers College the professional development um so I'd like to cut that since we don't do that anymore and also the convocation speaker I think Dr ABY you can speak very well thank you anything else in 19 okay 20 23 yeah 23 and on 23 um I I'm interested in the summer school tuition um increasing that 4% similar to what you had done in other parts so then the expense just goes up as well because it's a sharing agreement it automatically goes up correct okay all right thank you I guess don't need to do
220that okay for effort we were business I know not a business um 24 Joanna um just uh in light of again trying to keep people in the building that are working with our kids um you know I know the intern program is very good for future recruitment entainment but I feel like $68,000 for hopefully future employees just something we can't afford right now so I'd like to put the 68 down sorry I didn't hear you so there's can you speak to what that would do just for clarity Sur yes um enj the um the psychologist interns over the course last year and this year provide um last year they provided a full-time coverage we were short one psychologist one of elementary school and they provide Ed full-time support evaluations and coverage they also fill in
221a maternity leave they also covered any Miss sessions or several Miss sessions they could do for ppts while other psychologists attend those meetings and currently that's what they're doing so we've minimized the number of Miss sessions for our students in all across the schools we've minimized the opportunity for Miss sessions um when they're attending both 504 and IP meetings um at the same time they're also probably very highly qualified they're doctoral candidates so they come with a great deal of knowledge and resource that can really support our sometimes younger psychologists that are coming into the field so I think the value added piece to them is is not only pedagogical and not only supporting all of our students um but also coverage as Miss sessions which is something we've made a strong commitment to great
222just to follow up on that so there we I think we spent there's another question here about the 140,000 that we spent on substitutes related to Special Ed I think the answer says that that's special ed par of Professionals in bringing the 68,000 on is that going to reduce the 140k because now we don't need this the No No but we don't get substitutes for psychologists so in the past before you had this program that 140 was like 152 and 156 um oh I thought surley just said that like some of the role of the psychologist was was filling in for people when they're so when our when our when our Daran psychologists are attending IP meeting are 504 meetings those are Miss sessions with students so they're able to cover those they also conduct
223initial evaluations re-evaluations as well as interal valuations which helps also free up psychologist to work in classrooms with students as well so the value added piece is is not only resourceful but has really helped us stay compliant with what our requirements are okay anything else in 24 just one other clarification the psychologists that are listed for special ed those are totally separate from the other psychologist that we have psych share they share case CLS they share both both our they loop with their students yes okay so but there's two different things right so that the the FTE actually the person actually does work with children with needs and children without needs or students with or without needs but so that we can track it financially we do split them out financi but it's merely a
224tracking so like there's it says there's 12 a FTE psychologists in special ed and I think either 15 or 18 right so if if you if you and I were both psychologists um we might share token school and you cover grades one and three and I cover grades two and four um but you might show up in the special ed budget and I might show up in the General Ed budget just for an accounting purposes I guess when we ask the question of like how many psychologist we have across all the schools what is that actual number okay that's what I'm tring uh 18 18 I just wanted to add one more thing that um this year the in are also helping with ELP screenings which is really help not only in terms of efficiencies
225but supporting our students Robin so I just want to clarify because I thought that the 13 psychologists that are in the special education budget were specifically IEP designated similar to the special education Paras no so uh when the second psychologist was added I guess there was a commitment to reflect them as 5050 between the elementary schools in special ed the middle school and high school psychologists are all in special ed um that was my question so middle school and high school so they aren't necessarily all for IEPs but that is how they are reflected um you certainly could put them all in the schools the state when we submit State reporting requires us to split them 8515 um you could do the 50/50 you do I mean there's no requirement in terms of how you
226okay and then just sorry if I may just add not to what line items that the psychologists are in but they support students in general education and special education in middle school and high school they're pre-referral their early intervention they work with families so they they are um I can't speak to the lines that they're in but they provide um support for all our students thank you and then I do have I just wanted to clarify because I think there might have been some confusion with some of our public the comments that we've received on the special education Paras which are not the perah Professionals in the elementary schools that are currently um in the cut list and I think there was some confusion on that based on some of the public emails that we've
227been getting where people are concerned that children with special needs in Elementary in kindergarten and first grade would lose a per but that's not the case if they have an IEP and have a PA assigned to them correct and I hope we were helpful in clarifying that last time Robin that instructional Paras are Paras who are in the general education classroom par Educators who are providing support for students with IEPs um or any other supports are are actually recommended at the PPT and the duration and the amount whether it's a onetoone or a small group is determined at that time but they are exclusively um mandated and and the Staffing you're saying that the level that you have staffed at I'm assuming you have some kind of a case load requirement and determine the number
228of students that each of them can can service that would get to the 101 par of professionals that we have um I think if I recall last time I explained that some students um from K through 12 or prek through 12 may have a par throughout the day some may just have it a couple periods of the day some may have it in a small group in a shared Paris some might be individual again it's determined at the BBT and recommended and that really determines the number of hours okay so we're fully staffed based on the the current needs of the children that require the services yes okay thank you anything else on 25 yes Robin um I have a question about the electricity public benefit tax um the $44,000 that was mentioned in the
229memo because I understand the town is including that going away in their budget so I would like to add that to our spreadsheet and propose that we also add that assumption that would be the $44,000 savings what are your thoughts on that I'm say so originally they talked about it going away in April we did reach out to eversource that's not happening um they said there's a possibility it could end in uh not end but be reduced in July um so I did speak to Jen the Town Administrator so they're going to make the Assumption in their budget for next year that it's going to be reduced um if it's not reduced then you're going to have to do a transfer and I me come up with the money because you're going have to keep
230your lights on so what would be the equivalent reduction if we just it be the 44th be the it might as well be on the same page time thank you Robin anything else in 27 26 thank you um I I just wanted to confirm what we have in the list um so there is one line about specifically raising the tuition to the 125 is that right that's what's on the table okay thank you um I don't know if that's sorry I don't know if that's actually made the the list does it it it's in the spreadsheet yes it was we put that on okay thank you 27 security we don't have 28 anymore and we talked a little bit about Capital typically we' go to Capital at this stage there's also questions at the end
231on all if we can go through those as well sure any other anything else I'll come back to that in a second anything else I'm sorry we have what what are we doing with capital typically if there were any questions at this stage we would just raise them but I mean we've had we've had lots of questions at this point right but so we don't need to put but if we want to put something on the cut list can we do that go oh okay i' like to put the sidewalk um on the cut list this one out here the yes um I feel the town I know it's overall the end the same bucket but it counts against us so I think it's a town responsibility okay yes Robin um I'm just wondering about
232the Darian High School repaving um that out maybe differing that one year but I don't know how the rest of the board might feel about I'll put it on and let's have Kevin give us some more formal respon a little more information on that he spoke to it but can you respond formally yes Dave I would just split out I think we saw the drain over token and the paving together like I just seems one's more urgent than the other just clarification from Kevin on that okay thanks anything else on Capital okay all right then we have a number of questions left to go through Greg do you want to just or anyone else do you want to just speak to the questions that you would like to going in order so starting at 100
233I just had a question on that one the it gave us like the total historical spend on these but it didn't tell us what's in the budget today which one's Greg this is on all the seal and Dei stuff it gave us like historical cost I think since 20120 but it doesn't say is there anything in the budget or no oh sorry um yeah it ask does ask about theal writing that was it that I could the curriculum I just didn't know yeah well we can we can look at that we can provide that I me follow it's fine for a followup just I'm interested there um interr please go ahead Greg I think you need to repeat for Amy what you would ask I sorry I couldn't hear you the SE and Dei question
234number 100 um it gives us the spend since 2020 since the Inception of those programs but it doesn't tell us what's included in the the current budget um there sorry there is um a nominal amount of couple thousand dollars I'd have to look at my the exact line forcl for writing what we talked about earlier in the board meeting um for morning meeting um to continue with that K5 and um for some of the work at the middle school level and flex okay yeah just whatever that's really I just wasn't sure if because it didn't it didn't address that part of the question that's laid out in rc9 okay and labeled yeah then there's a related question number 103 that um talks a little bit about this idea of this fleux period this is sort
235of separate from the budget but like my daughter is in seventh grade she's talking me about this flex period being dedicated towards seal where they go and they watch a video in an auditorium which I think is actually acting the exact opposite way of the intention which is to deal with social emotional learning um it's creating actual anxiety among some of the kids because now there's a teacher that they aren't able to meet in that period where otherwise in the other flex period they are to get their homework done and be actually productive so I would just rethink that that that concept Al together and you're saying that that uh I just caught the bit going into the auditorium for they go into an auditorium and they watch a video for the flex period rather
236than being able to go visit with their teachers you know do get caught up on their work homework studying or otherwise so one of the things that we'll look at when we take a look at the curriculum writing for that flex period is on balance right you want to work with children especially at the middle school level to think about executive functioning skills time management that's incredibly important in their middle school years as they're transitioning from elementary to the high school but I can understand what you're saying you know also we want to have children be able to use that time planul and meaningfully to kind of support unbalance what they're doing with their academics Athletics all their extracurriculars that maybe make it optional so so or or um something that's intentional right there's a
237way to te to teach time management for example with some of the things that you're talking about so that's something that Mrs deula and I will work on together school counselors thank you Joanna um so going off of flex it and I don't know if we've already talked about this um Flex comes up a lot I know some days are for going to other teachers or your voice you know your music lessons or camarada or whatever and some days are for lessons it would be nice if we could just get an overview of where it came from and what it's meant to do um my question specifically is for the DB did that cost stop once Dr dad came on staff and she is now doing it or is that an ongoing cost we originally
238contracted with CBC um and that's where Dr dad forly was employed so when she came in yes we ended that um we still have some cons um we still have um when they're brought in for certain things CBC is not working with us that that it ended thank you now it's getting late was um Dave yeah two uh points on Fall Flex I've heard a lot of the same feedback that was mentioned earlier would love to understand not only what could be done a little more efficient reducing anxiety and effect and perhaps there's cost savings there uh also in the line 100 it mentions second Elementary psychologist 2.2 million not sure what the breakdown is uh of that 2.2 how much of the time that actually represents and how much it's dedicated to theal or
239Dei um just trying to understand the basis for that number so it's just the cost of psychologist it's not like the fractional so it's the cost um over the number of years at six years or so and so as presented the question would be does that mean that the second Elementary psychologist spends all their time dealing with Dei or seal which I don't think is the answer so if we get some clarification on that if I may ask just if you can repeat that D just I think the question is of the time are psychologist spending on Dei so we have it says second Elementary psychologist 2.2 million but that response is in a request to uh how much time we spend onal and Dei so as drafted you would read that and say we
240spent our second psychologist spends all their time oncl and Dei if we just get more facts I should clear this up okay and and and they don't we spoke about it so we will give you that thank you okay any other um questions about this block of questions okay Jill I have a I have a question now on the process going forward now so there's something one from public comment which is sticking in my head of that someone was mentioning they need to pressure the board of Finance so when we we come up with a number in two weeks and put that to the board of Finance yes what is the board of finance's obligation from that point can they can they increase that number no we need to put well yes but we need
241to put forward the number that we think is the right number we don't the the right thing to do is to go to them with the number that we believe is what we need for the school to function rather than but I think the Dilemma we're paint we're painted with is we're going to be if we go with a number that we believe is the right number then we may end up where we were last year and have to re that's correct re-engineer the whole budget over the course of the next three months and and and not work on the proper way of running a school system for those three months and then and then try to consolidate would take six months and three months and if we go with a low number then to
242the ladies points we're cutting off our nose to and and and reducing our our our our school program to where it's almost non-functional in some instances I'm being it's late in I'm really tired but the point is there has to be a way where we can we can thread this needle somehow and present something to the board of finance that is acceptable and and they and and have this ability to then prove or disprove or or change the number to where it's where we need to be to be a school system at the end of the day it's Our obligation to go forward with the budget that we think is the appropriate level of spend um so that is what we're trying to get to the uh ter of the risk assessment the appropriate thing
243to do is to go with the number that we think is the is the number to spend okay can I make a comment as well yes of course yeah just then I think Dennis to exactly to your point this is the reason to Robin's earlier point in the evening this is why we are attempting to turn over every Rock every stone to find the pennies which I know John thinks is it's a it's painful but then we can take that to the board of finance and say we've done our job we've attempted to find every penny and and then we can present something to them it has to be defensible and I you know I'm just like you I do not think that it is a good idea at all to extend this another three
244months because that means that we're spending nine three quarters of our year on the budget instead of doing what we're supposed to be doing so I was goingon to say just it has to be defensible and we have to defend it go ahead John so we did an unprecedented amount of pre-budget work so that the board of Finance was aware of what our budget was looking like going into and I I don't believe turning rocks is painful I just think we're avoiding some of the bigger Decisions by turning over rocks so we we will accumulate all the little pennies and rub them together but there's still especially that we rejected um the idea uh restructuring we have a big hole to fill and that's why I you know kind of kid when we talk about
2451,000 2,000 I think it's great I think it's great everybody's looking for this but to Dennis's Point your point last year's budget was indefensible when we fill FTE that were not going to be implemented in the schools and the board of Finance is watching every one of our meetings I think they're very aware of the um and talk to them I mean call them pick up the phone they're very aware of the um challenges we face so like I said earlier I think there's a great way that we can coales around some major items to get it you know off the whatever 6% number that we're we're trending towards and uh then we'll figure out where a majority of us fall I will go back and say that if six 6% is the number that
246the nine of us feel is or the majority of the nine of us feel is what we need to fund our schools at the level that our constituents expect then that's the number and that is our job that is our duty to our to our town um it's not to cow out to any other body I don't think I understand that but I also want to be careful I think starting with the guidance and looking at the implications of trying to meet that number is pretty important because if we just started at 6% and didn't go through the exercise of trying to figure out what it looks like to come within range of the guidance then it's much again it's we get to a point where it's and we're doing our Dil due diligence and
247if on the 11th we decide that 6% is the number then that's what it is but we've done our due diligence to Greg's point okay yes Robin just I just one extra point I mean I think we also have more work to do after the budget process on a longer term yes Outlook next steps maybe longer term investments that we should be making and thinking about because we know the costs are going to continue to rise over the next few years and this is also what all the legislators and other Fairfield County superintendents were talking about because they face the same challenges so we over a longer term perspective and and I know we're going to be talking about it more this spring and you know the various um projects that we want to look
248into but those are equally important if not more so so that we don't continue to have this kind of discussion going forward if we can if we can do things more inhouse potentially that would allow us to decrease more expensive contracted or outplaced kind of services and we need to do a better job about thinking about all of that holistically and and that's not something we'll accomplish in this budget process okay all right with that I will thank you all for the time this evening we um have follow-up action items which we're all excited to look at right now um the board member handbook we're going to look at in March Katie and I have uh talked about that um and uh you said I think the oxid use of building against enrollment analyses coming
249up in facilities next and then sustainable cafeterias will be later in the year anything else okay public comment good evening if anybody in person or online would like to participate in public comment please approach the podium or use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized once recognized please state your name and address for the record and note that you all have up to three minutes to comment Barry Palmer DEA president um first I'd like to address a couple times I've heard last year's budget that went to the board of Finance was indefensible I've been Fielding emails and concerns from staff members all year due to the Fallout of the board of Finance mandated cuts to last year's budget the budget you passed the first time around was defensible you chose not to defend
250it you chose not to speak with one voice as a board what you've done tonight has done more to damage morale in this District then I I mean if I could send you the comments that your staff has been sending about what we witnessed tonight I think you'd all be ashamed of yourselves please do great thank you hi uh Nicole Blackman um 12 red cedar I'm gonna Echo some things that we've heard tonight but I figured I need to get it out there I'm here tonight as a parent a resident and a strong supporter of our school system like many others in this room we chose to move to darianne for the exceptional educational opportunities it provides my son experienced firsthand the remarkable benefits of the parah professionals um every single day he's been in
251the ELP program for two years and really seen him transform into a totally different kid to be honest um he will be joining some friends at hinley next year as he starts kindergarten um and I'm excited to see what lies ahead of them last week after I came to the the meeting I felt compelled to kind of see what my peers and my community are also feeling in a matter of days I was able to gather 828 people to sign a petition um which I have sent to most of you and hopefully you've received I also have all those signatures here today I am urging the board to reconsider the proposal to replace these dedicated professionals with 10 college interns it was suggested last week that there is a substitute problem in the par educators
252are not being utilized in their intended rules the need for substitute teachers is an important but different issue that should be addressed separately interns while valuable cannot replicate the depth of experience and dedication or the strong connections that our current par Educators bring to the classroom their roles are indispensable and their impact on the success of our students cannot be overstated if we continue to overlook the needs of those who directly influence our students growth we risk eroding the very qualities that M Darian schools so special we can't afford to lose sight of that I respectfully ask the board to revisit the budget and consider making cuts to less essential items what some may consider the nice to have in order to preserve the 15 instructional par educator positions for the 25 26 budget thank
253you thank you Beth Lane 16 Hillcrest Avenue and I'm here to discuss particularly the wellness center um I appreciate your thought Robin on parents Staffing it I have two problems with it one of which is as the dhpa co-chair I can tell you we have a hard time getting parents to volunteer for lots of things they might volunteer for the College and Career Center because that's sort of a separate thing that's kind of special I don't know that they're going to volunteer to spend a lot of time in the wellness center with a bunch of teenagers and I can assure you that the bunch of teenagers is not going to go to the wellness center if it is staffed by parents so it would ruin it and I've seen I'm in the school enough that
254I've seen the work that's going on in there it has become very popular I would hate to see that go just because we can't have data on something that's intended to be preventative obviously we can't have data we can't run a control of not having the wellness center so that's it that's all I've got thank you thank you we have no raised hands at this time okay I'll take a