001good evening I'd like to call this special meeting of the Board of Education to order tonight is Tuesday January 21st 2025 thank you all for being here this evening um as a reminder our order of events is a little bit different tonight we're following the call to order I'll give a few remarks and then we'll have some follow-up discussion uh from our January 4th meeting and then we'll follow with public comment at the end um so if we think of our budget process in stages up to this point we've been looking at a detailed introduction to the budget we're really still there we're really still trying to understand what the components that we'd be discussing are um and that will continue through tonight on the 28th we'll start reflecting on the budget in a lot
002more um a lot we'll start reflecting more we'll delve deeper discuss our priorities and ensure that our budget truly reflects our goals while considering the constraints imposed by um current environment of rising costs on the fourth we'll hear from the community uh that's our public hearing this will be the community's opportunity to share their input and concerns um and then following that we'll have another opportunity to deliberate and finally on the 11th we'll finalize our deliberate deliberations and vote on the budget um I will emphasize that of course the district's budget is not merely an exercise and accounting but it's a deep reflection of our values and our aspirations for the education of our children the decisions before us are complex and often agonizing we face for us and for our Administration we Face a
003delicate Balancing Act honoring the needs of our students respecting the hard-earned tax dollars of our community and navigating the ever shifting landscape of educational best practices and fiscal realities sorry tonight we'll start with the remainder of the presentations following that we'll review the budget questions particularly identifying significant gaps in information or understanding and then lastly we'll talk about the overall budget strategy U where we are on that today um and with that I will uh turn it to you Alan thank you very much good evening everyone uh to our staff students and uh community members here with us this evening uh just as well by way of of an update um if you looked at materials you you would notice that you would not notice that there's not there's no materials attached for this evening
004right um that's because the materials that the board received at the last meeting we never got to so we're going to go over those particular materials subsequently we have posted those to the website because we received a few questions from board members that we added in uh so like our board members this evening they have the materials just in front of them just presented if you go to the website for additional materials budget materials you'll find uh the uh q&as and the presentations are already there so thank you if you're so inclined to follow along at that level uh with that I'm pleased to uh have the opportunity here to share a couple of perspectives uh the first one on professional learning and I will turn that over uh to Amy we have a a
005budget item here uh around professional learning uh which calls for early releases um and late starts at the high schools for plc's and EM is going to talk to to that thank you Dr rley good evening everyone one of the things um that we were asked to do and we think it's also very helpful is when we're thinking about professional learning and the rationale for professional learning in our school system is to think about both the educational um rationale and the operational impact um things that we've discussed previously at the board table um we do know that the classroom teacher is the number one um indicator um and factor that contributes to Student Learning outcomes so investing in our adult Learners and the organization is incredibly important additionally we've received feedback through Nas accreditation our
006recent October visit and also our Tri State recommendation to continue to support the professional learning of our staff professional learning communities we'll talk a little bit more about those in a later slide but the easiest way to consider what a professional Learning Community is is that's when the classroom features um and related service providers across the district are able to collaborate and look specifically at student work samples and data points and discuss um instructional strategies that are helping students meet with success and Achieve and also look where students may be struggling and together look at instructional strategies that might better meet their needs um our pck committee which is comprised of teachers throughout the district is focusing on not only plc's but professional development at large ensuring that we have a system uh systematic integrated
007approach something that we've also learned from our school climate survey um and also through the work of our pedc is that there's a desire to increase teacher voice um and autonomy and professional learning so part of our rationale for the increase in time um is certainly to meet that need the operational impact the cost um for this is fairly nominal considering um considering the benefits to the system that would be year-over-year compounded um additionally we do recognize that um there would be an impact to families and family schedules so that's something that we anticipate um would require more discussion um why this investment I've already kind of spoken to most of these points we'll skip through to the next slide um one of the things I think that we would just want everyone to understand
008is when we think about investing in professional learning one of the things that we need to do systemically is consider how do the larger strategic plan goals board goals and strategic plan goals connect to school and Department goals and then teacher goals all of that should be a through line that connects to Student Learning outcomes so as we develop professional learning plans and professional Learning Systems one of the things we look for is how do each of these layers of the system support one another toward what we're looking for to um achieve with our students across the system preschool through grade 12 one of of the things um that we've been talking a lot about is what's the difference between professional learning professional development and plc's and an easy way to look at this is
009that professional learning is like the overarching umbrella okay it's like the big bucket within that there are many types of activities that Educators engage in some of those might be instructional rounds some of those might be attending conferences or sessions in District or external conferences raid level meetings are a form of professional learning um I would say that when teachers engage in an RTI or srbi mtss process that there's a level of embedded professional learning in that process again the plc's and this is where I said we would talk about this a little bit more in the presentation that's a type of professional learning and the difference with a PLC and really the research says it's one of the most powerful forms of of professional learning for educators is that our educators are looking at
010student work samples actual student artifacts Andor data points And discussing instructional strategies so what you're looking at in a PLC is what do we want the students to know relative to grade level standards how are they doing according you know in alignment to those learning targets what are we doing when they're not meeting those targets and what are we doing when they are and how do we shift and and share instructional strategies to best meet the needs of all Learners this s really this graphic is just to show that there are types of professional learning that are ongoing throughout the year so at the center of all professional learning we want teacher goals and administrator goals to be connected to all of the opportunities that they have for professional learning that exist throughout the entire
011school year again some of the professional learning types are grade level meetings plc's instructional rounds faculty meetings those happen throughout the school year what's represented on the outside part of this graphic are how we might um Envision integrated professional learning that's more on a Continuum throughout the school year so for example currently we have three days in August during those three days we have convocation we have our legislative trainings we talk with our administrative team and our teaching team about the Strategic plan priorities we make alignment and connections to the Strategic plan and school and Department plans and then we may have some specific District professional learning so for example it will surprise no one right now there's a huge focus on K3 literacy play-based learning for example at the elementary level with our current
012plan we we wouldn't have time again for a full professional learning session with our staff across the grade levels until November then we would have a time again in January like we did last week and February and that would be it for the year what the plan with an increase in professional learning time would allow us to do is to have those kind of touch points in September and October March and may or we could take a look at this larger um larger strategic work of the district and these larger Focus areas and really connect the work of our staff across the schools so for example we would have an opportunity to bring all first grade teachers right to focus on any um implementation changes um in K3 literacy next year one of the things
013I want to focus on is we've we've been talking with staff and hearing that plc's and we've heard the word have been hijacked often so plc's are really meant to be teacher-driven where they're looking at their student work samples and student data and because there's so much to fit in in a small amount of time sometimes those plcs have not been pure plc's and they other agenda items have have been creeping in so one of the things that we want to do is to be able to protect the PLC time so it's sacred for that purpose of really looking at student data and student work samples and driving that work forward and keeping the other different types of professional learning the other um types and components outside of the PLC bucket we also know that
014um we want to make sure that we have more opportunities for Teacher voice in their professional learning one of the things that the board asked for for was you know what would be um a general kind of scope and sequence what would you kind of do with this time this is a very broad scope and sequence it's not meant to provide every little detail of course we know that when we're developing professional learning we would want to do that with our staff um but if Cass if you don't mind clicking on just the elementary example they're both linked there Elementary and secondary but very broadly and I know the text is small um this is also available online this scope and sequence shows kind of how would we connect the August opening opening days PL
015throughout the year at the elementary level what would be some things that we would focus on during the early release days how would we bring the PLC work into that we of course have the three hours of contractual time that teachers and administrators gathered for faculty meetings and then as you know um we have grade level meetings instructional rounds are scheduled per school but in an integrated systemic professional learning plan we would want to connect all of these components thank you Cass and we can just skip right to there's a secondary example but very much it follows the same same structure thank you so much okay so what might this look like um we did draft a calendar that um we've actually explored through a few of our um discussions with the board and right
016now we have six professional learning days and one teacher workday that takes place in August as far as um supporting teachers and setting up classrooms what this request or proposal is asking for is an additional five toour early release days to support the work ELP through grade 12 um and I will say I'm struck by the power of time for teachers teachers having time together um as I enjoyed time especially with our prek teachers and kindergarten teachers who facilitated a wonderful um districtwide professional learning session on play-based learning last week um in addition to those two early release days um as you know the high school already has 10 um the late arrival days for plc's and what we would be looking for are three additional for a total of 13 and the plcs at
017the elementary level would continue to happen during the school day once in every six day cycle and at the middle school um also embedded within the school day and so that is the calendar there that we've also shown before and we're happy to I'm happy to take questions on board may have okay well we're down three members so we might have less questions than usual but um I'll I'll open it question Sarah did you have one I'll look your way sure thank you for looking my way um so as you know I'm a you know I'm a huge proponent of of teacher learning and I we our kids can't learn unless our adults are learning um so in theory I I support this idea and to be perfect Frank what I'm struggling with is adding
018for teachers when we're potentially taking away from students and I would love to hear you I don't know if defend is the right word but you know why why should why is this important and it to the lay person what will this do to improve student learning student outcomes um you know could you just start you said why are we doing this instead off just why what just why are we why how is this going to help students um how is this gonna help students and not just teachers so again uh we know our teachers are the biggest influence on student learning and student outcomes having our teachers work together collaboratively around common students common experiences common outcomes for kids common assessments for kids interventions for for students or follow-up enrichment opportunities our for students
019that that investment for the it may seem out the door that why are you even asking for anything given as a challenge in budget I I just I just don't look at life that way or or the scenario this way or the conundrum this way um it's a relatively relatively speaking um it's a relatively uh low investment for a high return for all staff and all kids it impacts all kids it impacts all of all of our uh professional staff members uh it's also um it's also part of the Strategic plan in terms of supporting professional learning opportunities yes it'll be a we bit different does it put us on the cuton edge of this yes it does but I think sometimes that's where we want to be and uh that's where we want to
020lead in this particular Arena I think the board has asked if even asked me uh can you work on retention recruitment this is a big retention and recruitment opportunity uh because when people sit in front of me in terms of uh interviewing they're asking what do you do for professional development okay what are the opportunities for me here if I stay here um and it's an opportunity also to to support uh the attention of of of our staff I think too um if I could just add that the art of teaching you know the Art and Science of teaching can very much be like a solo Endeavor it can be it can feel very much for teachers like they're on an island and so much of their work and their craft is obviously when students
021are immediately before them so there is something to be said for teachers having the opportunity to step to step aside have opportunity When the Children our students are not with us and where they can be with their colleagues and really talk about their Craft um that I think is maybe this is unique to teaching and learning that maybe other Industries it's a little bit different um our work is constantly on they're constantly on with kids and so the idea that a teacher spend tremendous our teachers I know spend a tremendous amount of time planning before they ever get there with the kids and they spend a tremendous amount of time reflecting after they dismiss kids but there's something to be said for engaging in that act of planning and reflecting with colleagues about practice it's
022also an area that it has broad I'll just describe it as it has broad support from the teachers and the and the staff in the district uh just one of the only opportunities you you'll probably get to see teachers at a craft level deconstructing standards to to understand where students um are struggling and how they may uh respond in kind so go ahead Kitty thank you um putting aside that this is a a new initiative in a budget the the piece that I I I can't quite wrap my head around is when we talk about the importance of professional learning and investing in our teachers I do feel as if we're speaking as as if it's all or none and we actually have quite a bit so I think you know the real question that
023I don't understand is like why don't we have enough and should we be looking at streamlining our current time you know like Amy you had said that um there had been conversation about PLC J days getting hijacked so it seems to me that maybe we need to look at our implementation and our execution you know is it really the need for for more days and more time especially at the cost of instructional minutes or do we need to look at how we're delivering it currently um Cass I don't if you could flip back to the slide that shows the current I I thought that was a really good frame of reference yes perfect um right there so you know I see that the elementary um teachers every like six day cycle they they are working
024together MMS every week with with their teams right um and then you know DHS already has the model um which is tough you know they have a different model but that's significant to me so so why is that not enough so I would say that is typical most school districts have um that embedded kind of team meeting time grade level planning time um it is a very fair question to ask I think the difference is is That's Unique to a school so we can't really pull together for example the entire first grade to have consistent profession learning across the grade level their their grade level meetings are all at different times right um even though you know we even if we try to get them on consistent schedules there are parts of the school schedules
025that make that challenging to get them all across five schools at the same time so I think it just provides different opportunity again for more systemic work um we wouldn't be the first district that has release time where students are released for staff to work together in a collaborative setting um it it's it is a value add it there are some districts that do this weekly so um it's just it's where you know you want to make your investment um for staff any other questions Robin um I have a few questions first of all and I I I had a similar question to Katie's because I had thought when that this was presented to the curriculum committee that Daran already has I think more PLC days in time in in professional learning than the other
026during a district so that was one question that I had because I had in a clarification the early release days those five are those for grades K through 12 because I thought those were only for the elementary schools when this was initially talked about it was um for ELP through grade 12 okay so the high school for instance would be adding five early release days plus three additional PLC delayed opening days for a total of 13 so I again I mean I just question because we also then would be losing instructional time and particularly at elementary level when we're implementing a new K through3 literacy initiative that loss of additional instructional time for the students is one concern that I would want to understand a little bit better so what I can say is there
027is strong research and despite the fact that there is a loss of instructional um time that investing in teacher professional learning does increase student learning outcomes and there are districts throughout the state I would say that have found that um you know you right now you think about pulling teachers away from the classroom for professional learning or grade level across the district and you're having to pull them offline from teaching as we would say this should limit the impact of that and again the greatest I think benefit of something like this for example especially at the elementary level with two um the twoh hour early release days is to be able to bring full grade levels together for professional learning you really you really can't do that um without the after school time because you
028wouldn't we wouldn't be able to and you wouldn't want to pull staff offline from teaching children that number of Staff um just a followup then I mean the in the existing PLC days that we have you know when you talk about them being hijacked to some extent isn't there an opportunity where we could do some of this during that time and maybe give the some of the state mandated stuff a little bit less time but I I'm just understand like priorities so I'll have March actually speak a little bit to the state Mand dated time if that's okay um there I think are an 18 18 minimal hours in counting so there aren't there literally aren't enough hours to do all of the state mandated trainings and I would say those those are trainings exactly
029that they're not professional learning opportunities they they don't really have to do with the science and art of teaching and learning there are things like um DCF mandated reporter um human trafficking bloodborne pathogens all those things that's not really professional learning those are trainings um when we talk about could we use some of the PLC time for for district learning the function of a PLC is different because because again that's when teachers are looking at student work samples and student data points so that's driven by the teachers and what kind of their focus of inquiry is looking at the students before them and their instructional strategies that's different than for example pulling together and you know all of the kindergarten teachers to talk about play-based learning right I think I I was maybe referring to
030professional learning days where we actually have time set out that I was just it's just really a question of that could we use some of our existing days so that's and get some of this work done which I realize is important and we need to be able to do that that's what we're doing so right now we have the three days in August to kick off the start of the year which includes complication it includes some of those mandated trainings I don't if March has anything else to add about that and then our next opportunity is November then we have you know January after February that will be it until the following August as far as those those larger chunks of time to work on kind of systemic work across the grade level certainly these
031days would be we would be up there right in terms of uh the the dur the closest probably is a Wilton that has 13 early releases and six professional days that sort of brings us into some sort of uh alignment with that and investment in this is not mutually exclusive from investing in the teachers and investing in our students whether it's K3 literacy or whether it's AP calculous right um and it's it's uh I can understand the Dilemma right um and time where we're we're compliant with the time we're not as we not if we're out of compliance with the time uh I don't want to I'm leading into it but it's also the opportunity for the late arrival stuff that's not the purpose of doing gu ask us to tole perhaps benefit to it
032but uh I just see this as a way of supporting our staff and uh and directly supporting our students Joanna um so one of my concerns is sort of the opposite end of the spectrum is Robins um with more you know five potential more days um out of instructural time at the high school AP classes in particular have to cover a large amount of curriculum for instance you know AP US History they they do a whole unit before school starts because there's not enough time to literally get through it all before the AP exam so one of my questions is how do you account for all that M time um and then my other question is how this is sort of set up as a way that leaves a great burden on parents especially our
033elementary AED kids um if it's really about having more time to get teachers together um is there not a way to do this where we have uh extra you know a full day or a full two days and that therefore we only the only uh you know we don't have to pay for extra buses we do lose the um income from from the cafeteria at the high school and other lunches but was that ever explored I think um really what our Focus was was trying to put more integrated opportunities throughout the year so that's why it was half days not full days we also tried to place the days um where we thought although it's a burden for families where we see lower student attendance um you know around those other holidays and days off
034so we thought that that might be facilitated and you know there again there are many districts that West Hartford does this once a week um they have they have time for staff to be together so it is a burden um districts and communities work on kind of figuring that out together if that's an investment that that the community wants to make the half day sort of spreads out the learning opportunities at least I'll talk for the high school as they look at their PLC time uh these other half days provide opportunities along the way as opposed to just discret times at the start and at the end okay Dave thanks I'll try and be quick um just a couple comments looking at this proposal one it was just mentioned burden on the parents with the
035rescheduling the cost taking away classroom time uh and just a number of things have been discussed Alan you mentioned briefly anecdotally that some people you feel this is a retention tool they ask about this when they join the district one of the other things have been given is the survey from the teachers problem with this survey from the teachers when I look at that is I find it far from persuasive because I don't know how many teachers you're going to get coming against one of your proposals for the budget so I appreciate what you're trying to do with the survey the problem is like I just can't really judge in the whole General scheme of things whether that's accurate or not accurate so that unfortunately is not helping convince me one point you did mention
036earlier tonight was that this was a small invest investment for a big return can you convince me by showing me some ideas along what are those returns how do you measure those returns how you specifically tie those back to this initiative and you know how you're going to collect that data so that would be an interesting fact to see if you can provide it not right now but certainly in the next meeting okay one more just one more question um um on the board of ed question the document the memo that you had provided to us one question that had been asked was the cost if we just did the five additional elementary school early release days and that was $58,000 why is that such a high cost is that both busing and food as
037well or so it's both um but you have more buses when you do just the five days when it's just a high school you're only looking at the nine buses you do it districtwide or just even at the elementary schools you're looking at 25 buses so it doesn't just shift the buses it's actually making additional buses versus okay thank you all right thank you amen welcome thank you uh so we make a we translation here um to look to add something to the budget um to a scenario of U where we had to realize some efficiencies and this is the pirate professionals and uh the elimination of the pirate professionals instructional Pate professionals some of which you are here this evening um uh that's a that's an efficiency of over a million dollars which is
038uh been hard to realize um in the district but with that uh we we'll make the presentation uh uh addressing the the questions that the board had and margin Amy will lead you through so again this is um challenging to talk about because we do know that our par Educators have a tremendous impact on on the students that they've developed relationships with over the years so um in a challenging budget climate we're thinking about um a potential reduction needing to get to the number that we've been discussing think about the educational rationale and operational impact um of this kind of budget modification um what we would do is we would have 10 interns take um the role that the par Educators have been um fulfilling in the classrooms it should be said that um our
039our par Educators really do provide a support role not only to students but to staff they're not meant to provide an instructional role to take small groups the teacher should be doing that and as well you know interns can only have them um but they they have provided a lot of support in the classroom um our interns also are pre-service teachers so they're enrolled in in professional learning programs in certific ification programs for their teaching degrees um in the case when you have an intern both the teacher intern and the teacher Mentor are both benefiting from from a professional learning perspective um an intern can teach classes again because they're pre-service without supervision and um we've also talked about the fact that having interns in District and I think we've seen this creates a pipeline
040for teaching talent in the district I recently um in my hometown came across someone who has had a teaching placement she told me in Darian public school she knew I worked here and how thrilled she was and I know she hasn't been here yet but I could tell she's someone who um would be very interested I'm sure in staying when she has the chance to have the Darian experience so it does provide a pipeline the operational impacts Mar is going to address that right so again not to minimize the wonderful par Educators that we have working for us now but the operational impact will be relatively minimal because over the past few years since covid When teacher AB absences on average have gone from about six and a half days a year to over 12
041days a year the parent professionals have been pulled to cover classes so we're not seeing them as as much as in as instructional support people in the classroom they're covering teachers and um so so really we're revising the budget to reflect what's really going on and to use interns and permanent building Subs is a more cost-efficient way to do that Okay so we've indicated um with this reduction there would be a savings of over a million dollars um we're talking about the current three pair Educators at each Elementary School now who assists primarily in kindergarten in grade one who assist with supervision at recess arrival and dismissal and um we would have those duties uh be performed by two interns per School a question was asked about you know a day in the life and
042this is what the expectation is according to the job description I think anybody who actually has been in a school could imagine that it's very difficult to capture on one slide what a day in the life is actually like for a par educator or a teacher because they're very responsive roles and they change based on what the kids and the staff needs are um but very very broadly they have a morning meeting they're there with the teacher and the students to support the morning meeting how we begin our day they're there to provide grade level support um they take Direction from the teacher again to provide support in the classroom for the overall functioning and operation of the classroom they have a lunch they provide additional grade level support in the afternoon they're also helping
043um with arrival and dismissal as you know it's important uh especially as our kindergarten students our first transitioning into the school year I'm sure that's where spend a lot of time um A Day in the Life reality as Marge already indicated um unfortunately because of just the need to fill uh vacancies and classrooms on a day-to-day day basis par Educators have largely the data shows been pulled to support that function to provide coverage um there's been a little table here that's been made and developed to show the difference between largely globally a par rooll internal Ro and substitute Ro right and and I will say when it says that par Educators primarily assist in K in first grade that was the intention when we eliminated a par professional par educator last year and replaced them
044with a permanent building substitute but it hasn't worked out that way anecdotally at one of our schools last week of three instructional pars one was absent and two were covering classes so again in a perfect world they'd be primarily assisting in K and first grade but that hasn't been the case okay and Marge and I are happy to take question can I just I just want to say that that for people who are here people who are not here as priate professionals they are some of the most loyal dedicated hardworking people that there are I like there's no question about that and they they help our kids and they help our staff and we're not questioning that at all daeve thanks um Mr Janine's not here so ask Marge is this really a substitute problem
045or is this a paraprofessional problem at the top it's a it's a teach it's a teacher absence problem and and I will say as I said before we used to be on the high end but um if you look at edsight we are below the state average now of teacher absences and so I guess staying stepping back for a moment like are there Solutions strategies things we can do to address the absentee problem that would perhaps forall having to go down this route and doing something with par professionals so we work with the teachers union we work with the building principles we've already had conversations with people who have excessive absences but um you know in a perfect world we probably had Paras and building subs and interns and whatever but um it's just not
046an effective use of resources right now we continue to try to work on teacher and Par absences understood and I guess one last question from the slide it was a million4 that was the net is that a net number or was that the gross just from cutting net that's a net number thanks Rich Katie thank you um I do want to make a clarification um in further materials that we received um and just to confirm it was estimated that 25% of the paris's time is serving as Bill Subs so 25% is what we've paid for but we only pay if they fill in for an excess of two hours so that was based on what we pay for but it's not based it's not indicative of what our principles are telling us well so even
047if you were to you know say that that is potentially On The Low End what I'm hearing is that the overwhelming majority of their time is in the classroom as it stands so I do have I share some concerns to Mr Brown's point of Are We addressing the problem head-on or are we not addressing root causes because this doesn't seem to me to be a problem with par professionals whatsoever um you know from my own personal experience as a parent through grade levels as a personal experience subbing acting as a pair of professionals I don't think that you can find more hardworking people that um are there for students and because they love them you know that we've gotten an an amazing like long list of emails from teachers um and what I hear from
048teachers is not we need more PLC it's we need more support we need support in the classro we need support before the classroom we need support with the kids so to me I don't see how this elimination and I would really not call it an efficiency because there's nothing efficient about removing an adult from a classro um but this elimination is is going against everything that we say makes our our schools great it's a it's a higher ratio for students it is going to lead to more teacher burnout it is going to be detrimental to classroom management we are looking at implementing new curriculum and we've heard time and again at the curriculum meetings how much time that is going to take and how much um extra bodies and conversations need to happen you know
049Additionally the interns sound great to me like that seems like a no-brainer like I I like everything about that program it's a very low cost that sounds great but that's another thing that the teachers have to do as well and the par professionals also have continuity and Longevity that will never come with interns we just had a presentation on the importance of professional learning what about the professional learning that we've invested in our pair Professionals for years by eliminating them we're throwing all of that out the window the people that have been here for decades that know our students know our buildings know our staff I was at the retirement breakfast um this spring and my son's 17 he's a junior in high school and Par professional was talking to me about him from elementary
050and he wasn't even there the full five years um six years so um you know I have I have a lot of concerns about this um frankly I just can't possibly support it I think that it's going to stress our Elementary classrooms and teachers um enormously Joanna um sort of to piggyback a little bit of what Katy just said um I'm going to channel Julie best um and I took a deep dive back through our numbers um in the fiscal year 18 we had a ratio of Aid to student of 1.97 next year if you count two interns as AIDS it'll be 1.2 10 1.38 at Oxbridge um or 1.2 6864 at Oxbridge if you don't include ELP so we are stripping away year after year the ratio of adults to students to begin with
051but also um last year you put in another building sub right there was two there's three building Subs cost more than interns if we are trying to find a way to save money while still covering classrooms in an efficient way why don't we go down to one building sub and have three interns you know it just it there it just doesn't seem to make sense if that's the primary reason for bringing them in so if I may just I want to be very clear uh it's not the par of professionals like it's not they're the problem they weren't they weren't the problem they're not the problem that's not like that's not what's on the table uh so to speak but when we have transitioned to having more times of the Pate professionals time being spent
052and class coverage regardless of what the reason is or uh we can continue to work on the root cause or or uh the uh absenteeism that they're covering right and so on and so forth we can do that um that's not going to be overnight uh but it just seems like an expensive way to go and also I would just say that the in instructional uh interns they have more uh instructional pedagogy experience than our pirate professionals do with all due respect everybody with all due respect for pirate professionals I don't want them doing instruction right they're not the instructional experts yes we want them to help our students yes we want them to give a bit of organization in the groups yes we want for them to uh help kids in as we transition
053to recess and different things um but they this also touches on a bit of a different model and I understand is not just like clear but uh the interns of more instruction around Pig uh that are part of professional to that being said yes I wouldn't put it on the table if I wasn't in the situation uh that I'm in but given the situation I'm in given the the way we have transitioned uh the use of professionals I think this is uh a reasonable uh model um and it's also an instructionally signed model I I think staying on the subject of the ratio of adults to Children you know in my time on the board we have increased a different different kinds of adults at the same time like we've added campus monitors we've added
054in security officers we've added in psychologists we've increased the number of adults an AP two APS actually um in the building so I appreciate that the number of AIDS is different but just back to the basic math it's three paas two interns so um what is the thinking there in terms of of of how they would be deployed and how that matches the coverage well the first thing we would do is cover teacher absences so so it isn't a one toone swap but I think that we're hoping that we'll be able to improve attendance and again right now our principles are telling us that Paris are not spending much time in K in1 classroom it isn't really even an expectation of most of our teachers anymore because they're not only being covered for Teacher absences
055but teacher meetings ppts B fours whatever so it's not a one forone swap um I think it would be aggressive to put three interns in each school um but we'll work with what we have Sarah can you just speak to a little bit of the interns um requirements from their their Preparatory programs like what the the 10 weeks that they are student teaching they are effectively out of out of circulation right so can you speak to that and what that would look like um in the schools and so what we did in the past was we would stagger um when we had two interns we would stagger so one would start in August and one would start in January that way we could stagger their student teaching um experience so there will be 10 weeks
056when they won't be available um to cover so under that model there would be just one for the entire school one and three permanent building subs and lunch monitors sorry go ahead yeah just a clarification you say lunch monitors lunch monitors cover classrooms all day long nope lunch monitors cover lunch in recess we need people for duties as well okay thank you so they're not in the classroom Katie um coming back to the concept of the ratios and the you know going from three people down to two um this is a larger issue because it's not just about pars or interns but did anybody talk about why it would be the same number across five elementary schools when one Elementary is almost double another so this year we did give oxridge four um permanent building
057subs and they only filled three actually two in a a part-time one so it was just based on what the principles were telling us they need you tried to get four for oxridge but now the proposal is just to put two in turns well we eliminated the fourth for the budget next year because let never filled because of notc everyone else is full so they just didn't didn't appear to need it there's still the building the three building Subs yes or build in addition to the two interns yes Dave I just to go back uh Allan to the point on the education um so with the interns I mean you mentioned um formal training you mentioned that we have the buildings uh excuse me the um PR professionals who have not been uh trained they
058certainly have a long experience right in the classroom yes and so I guess where there's formal classroom learning that will have more of for the interns we'll have more for new teachers I think when we onboard new teachers here in District we spent an awful lot of time shadowing them bringing them up to speed making sure they understand how things work so it may not be formal book learning that our people right now have in the classroom but they have extensive amounts of experience like to me having interns work with them would be great to their learning curve for the interns like to me this is a great opportunity to have the lower cost working together with that extensive classroom experience so I just don't understand why formal book learning is necessarily preference over somebody
059uh who's been in in the classroom for as long I guess maybe to some degree there's instructional expertise that exists from studying it a little bit more but I would think if you've lived it for decades you're probably okay with it uh You' have to recognize too that the interns are starting out in their career right I mean let's be honest with that they're just starting out in their career um we've invested quite a bit of professional development in our Pate professionals and our pirate professionals take us up on our uh training um so I'm not uh I'm not dis disputing that that point yeah I guess so I guess the really it's perhaps not as Stark a distinction in some ways well again pedagogy wise uh I would want trained staff now here's another
060thing just I'll just put this on the table say occasionally but it's not unusual that that we have a par professional who transitions to be a teacher which is a great thing right um so that's not out of the realm of possibility either I sure that because that's how close they are to the next level of of learning and pedagogy um but there is a difference between having uh educational training in the classroom instructional training in the classroom but but I recognize your pointment yeah no I mean I just you know pedological aside I would think that on you know hands-on experience and be more valuable in some cases than book learning so I don't see it as completely Stark one or the other just try to Dev an understanding deeper are there some contractual
061differences in terms of the be ability to deliver direct instruction I think there are some differences um that that would help to understand contractually maybe not contractually but but they're they're different employment classes so I think I don't we're not we're not talking about you're really not it's not swapping so much one for the other oh yeah no totally get that was a suggest I was just saying I mean there's the example think this back in law school like if you want to have somebody be an expert witness they can come up until you have a degree in this and I have a degree in that great you're an expert you have somebody be yep I'm the janitor I'm off the force for 32 years you're now an expert witness and janitors so if we
062have somebody who's been in the classroom for decades they're pretty much an expert for the classroom so I don't think we should lose s side of that fact s um I just want Clarity on that 1.14 number is that inclusive of benefits include like if every par professional par educator took benefits or is that currently the those 15 people so we looked at uh so there are only one class of Paras whether you're special parah or instructional par so it's the least seniors senior staff members who would bump so we did look at the individual who would bump out and what benefits that they had okay thank you Robin um this is a little bit of a different approach but the in the rc24 the special education paas we have about 101 of them and
063the current ratio is about a one to 10 one you know one pair of per 10 students with IEPs so one question is given and we've increased those pair as 28 I believe Rich over the past few years so my question would be given that that is a relatively low Staffing ratio is there any additional capacity that those pairs could help to fill in the gaps to the extent that they might already be in the elementary schools for instance just for kindergarten or first grade to help potentially fill in with some of the instruction and they already have the training they obviously have excellent skills and it's just a question just in terms of the existing Staffing that we do have um if I may answer um no because uh the can't do a ratio
064because those are um recommended by pbts so whether it's a par educator who's being recommended for an individual student or a shared par educator for two students um they're recommended specifically for those students who have iips and are being supported by them so they are fully utilized in terms of their available case load and hours in fact some of the shared poers are scheduled at different periods they may only be scheduled for ELA or for math or for a middle school for social studies so they're scheduled throughout the day for different children who might share them and typically when it's a onetoone par educator it's with one student throughout the day okay I I just was it's more of an issue of capacity and if there's exist excess capacity and it also gets to one
065question with specifically with kindergarten and first grade if we don't have the Paras now in kindergarten and first grade helping which I believe was the what we had intended to have happen is there a concern that in the absence of that that potentially children could end up falling behind or if they're not getting the instructional attention that they need that we could have more students going into what was srbi or potentially being identified for special education especially as we're implementing a new K through3 literacy initiative this coming year which will take additional instructional time so that's really something that I think we're also hearing feedback from teachers and Paris as well so and and parents just would love to have information on that so I don't know that anyone Ren can answer a question of
066what would be that would be an unfair question but I can say though um par educator sorry instructional powers in the classroom are there to support all children to support the classroom teacher they're not seen as an interventionist they're not seen as an I'm not saying that so I don't think that you can um measure or assess if they can be a pre-referral and interventionist because that's not their role I think you can look at other forms of interventionists that we have um whether they're actual interventions in ela or math whether they're doing tier one interventions such as our srbi or an mtss but I don't think we look to to instructional Paris for that position or support yeah I'm sorry you I think you miss I they work with children in the differentiated groupings
067I believe in some of the small groups to help with things some of the rumors going around the community are in fact we heard the teachers the head of the teachers union say it Point Blank that if we reduce par Professionals in the classroom that we'll have an increased identification rate yeah I please address that I don't see a Nexus between that and I don't see evidence to support it I have never somebody could AI it and we get an answer but I I am unaware of of any research that talks about uh Pate professionals not having them would result in on children transition into special education actually to be honest with you I'm more familiar with research it says uh with prior professionals uh we we stay St stuff too much we structure stuff
068too much and actually can hold kids back a little bit I said it all respectfully that's not this is just the nature of this conversation at the moment um but I'm not aware of anything that that that's going to happen that's and if I can just add to that Dr Aly um Robin to your question I think the instructional um par Educators support children in the class I'm not suggesting they don't and I recognize their value what I am saying is that their their role is not really to do pre-intervention or instruction or it's really to support the teachers to um participate in the class and support all students but I don't see that that is their role nor is it their expectation I think there are Personnel in the staff which are certified Personnel
069their role is to do that is to do pre-referral whether it's a psychologist or speech therapist or an OT or PT or um or other um instructional supports Amy do you have anything to add no I don't so um I think that sh said it really pretty suly okay Joanna um Paris might not be doing any pre-intervention but who's with the students when your teachers are doing tier one intervention um and especially if we have interns that are just running around covering classrooms who's in the classroom like if you have a group of kindergarteners and you have a teacher just working with two of them who's watching the other 20 um teachers are skilled at deciding what they need to do to pull small group and how do they develop activities that other students will
070do also students do some independent work which is what we want them to do even in kindergarten um so teachers design that as part of their lesson plan so they think about their reader Workshop block and they develop some parts again that are whole group instructions some that are small groups some individual conferring teachers conver individually and then every other student is kind of not with the teacher at that point so teachers set up their classroom environment and their instructional plans to accommodate for that that's part of their training okay but do Paris help with that instructional Paris not special Paris instructional Paras do Provide support like Shirley said to the teacher thank you go ahead March but but I will say that again from our principles it's less and less often that poers are
071available to do that kind of monitoring of small groups because they're being pulled I mean one of the principles said to me just the other day at this point teachers don't even complain when the Paris get pulled because they know it's going to happen so again in a perfect world would they be in there but they're getting pulled to cover classes sah in a perfect world is if you're thinking about the K1 classes across the district would there be a instructional par in the classroom at some point every day is that how it's scheduled to be I'm gonna have to defer to the Educators that was the design this year but in a perfect world um if the budget would allow but I can say that many districts um throughout the state have had to
072move away from that model um and the general classroom teacher is the primary support person for not only tier one but is it the expectation of Darion this year that there is somebody in in I'm an elementary school teacher should I expect to have someone in there every day uh not necessarily in K1 the the uh the principles generally speaking will disperse and use our per Professionals for K to one but on any given day they can be somewhere else but primarily yes y yep yeah I just answer that other question Joan a little bit um and again I'm not pushing back on people but I'm just sure often is the case that our younger students can actually model the independence in group work and individually that you want to see in our older kids
073more than the older kids exhibit I mean that's just if you ask some Educators may say Dr rley ask crazy well it's not crazy okay um it doesn't mean to say though that having someone in kindergarten or first grade is not what you wanted I understand all my teachers wanting um assistance and power professional assistance at those particular grade levels I can understand it but it doesn't necessarily just play out play out that way um and our younger kids can exhibit those attributes and our teachers are trained to actually uh bring that out in the kids rich and March you definitely provided us some comps before from other districts is it in this packet or is it in an older packet so uh in the nearby area Ridgefield does not have instructional Pairs and grenwich
074does not have instruction faity thank you okay sorry but that means everyone else does yeah okay okay I think we can okay thank you um thank you all so we had H some format of uh participation fees and we've we've discussed this at the board table many many times and many many years in different situations uh rich is going to share a couple of models that some of them we've seen before um maybe there's one that is relatively new I would say if the board decides to go down participation fees for a certain amount we can settle on The Mod whatever it happens to be but that that even that decision remains to be seen but uh so which we'll just go through the models um so we've talked we've talked about participation fees in
075the pass um it is far less common for districts to have participation fees for clubs um the only District in Fairfield County that we could find uh that charges of fee for clubs is Wilton uh they do charge $50 for a club in high school and then $25 for Middle School clubs uh it is more common for districts to charge athletic participation fees if they're to charge a fee um though it's also split um if we look at the dur Ridgefield Weston and Wilton all charge a fee but Westport and darianne for uh Westport Daran and new can and do not um you'll see the fees range anywhere from $250 at a high for Monroe uh to $100 as a low in Weston in bethl and typically um districts that have a fee have what's
076called a family cap uh and So a family cap is uh an amount that a family can exceed and it's usually the total of four Sports so for example if you had two k kids and they both play three Sports um the most you would pay if it was a $100 fee would be $400 um and so essentially those last two sports uh would be waved um if we go to the next slide uh the current proposal that's in the superintendent budget is a modified fee um just looking at non cic sports so rugby scen squash and sailing um it would be a fee to cover the cost associated with those Sports excluding the cost of the coaches stien uh which is $340 per Sport and then you'll see there also some of those sports
077do have a rental fee and so you'll see the fee range anywhere from 340 to just over 900 um as Dr adley mentioned um we showed three all three options really there are an infinite number of options if you were going to have a fee determining what the dollar amount would be um you know we looked at 100 150 and 200 really it could be anywhere in between as you saw some districts have 125 or 160 or 165 uh so it really just depends on the number uh so one option would be a $100 uh flat fee and a $340 fee for non cic sports with family cap of 400 again those four Sports um student what we call student interest clubs at the high school uh $50 similar to Wilton uh Middle School clubs
078a flat fee of $50 and then inter murals at the middle school for $50 as well um we would not charge at the elementary uh School the enrollment for the clubs at the elementary school is pretty uh minor there are only three at each Elementary School um So based off on current um participation uh numbers and projected participation numbers this would be about $312,000 and then obviously we would offer uh subsidies uh for those who have either are on free lunch reduced lunch or have economic hardships a second option potentially could be that should say 150 but 150 and then 340 with a family cap of 600 uh so again that four sport uh model you could then look at just doing uh fees on student interest clubs at the high school at $50 and
079then exempt the elementary in the middle school again fees for clubs tend to be less common across Connecticut um this would raise about $350,000 and again that's because the higher fee amount of 150 option three could be a flat fund flat fee of $200 per support and again a family cap of 800 those four Sports um the $200 would be similar to Ridgefield and then this you could choose to do no fees for any student interest Club whether it's the high school or the middle school and that would be 334,000 um again these are the three we showed I you could have an infinite number of options if you wanted to go down this route um just depending on the dollar amount and whether or not you'd want to do just sports or would you
080want to do Sports and clubs um would you want to do Sports and clubs only at the high school not the Middle School um so it really depends on the model that you'd want to look at okay all right so we had just asked for a reminder of what some of the fee programs look like given that there are some fees in the current proposal we wanted to understand um what's out there in the universe and what you guys had modeled for us um are there any questions on these specific models Robin just uh Rich one question you had previously given us a memo about a year ago that showed if you did charge like a $50 fee at elementary that that's like 40,000 in revenue is that still around the same so it would
081be assuming no students drop out I mean it could be a potential that um a student uh does like safety club for example and if you're charging them $50 they might not want to run but assuming the same level of participation thank you Katie were there any options that took into account um the inequities that currently exist so for example um option two um is furthering in inequity we do not fund our clubs the way that we fund our Athletics so levying fees is furthering an inequity same thing with um Sports we could go down probably every sport is a little bit different some cut some don't some provide protective equipment some don't some cost several thousand dollars per player some cost you know $100 per player so did any model look at trying to
082solve for the existing inequities for example a percentage of per player cost so last year um I think it was Mr proposed a 7030 split for fees similar to the rental um then you would have fees that would range from a few hundred to a few thousand so that wasn't really looked at um we don't know of any District that does like a percentage of cost um allocated to parents if there is a fee the Comm uh use for those districts that have fees as a flat dollar amount [Music] um so yeah I just a point of clarification I think there's a difference between an inequity which might be you're talking about more equipment there are sports with different cost structures that's not necessarily inequitable in that our students may have different needs in a
083in a district and that's not necessarily in I would say is inequitable I would argue looking at this from a family perspective right so let's say that we have a family who has a player on sport team a and sport team a provides all protective equipment okay so they do everything from headgear to any padding they provide everything the school pays for all of that pays for coaching buses everything family B has a player who is on a different sport that also needs helmet protective equipment but that is parent provided okay so now we take these two these two athletes on different sports and in this case the parents are not buying any of the equipment and in this case the parents are and on top of that that this one might have a higher
084cost but now we're leving the same amount of tax so parent a pays only $100 fee but parent B pays for their kids helmets their kids padding their kids you know whatever and the they Levy the same tax that is inequitable to me we've asked the question about protective equipment Chris isn't here but can someone on the administration speak to that maybe Rich so my understanding from Chris is they provide a certain number of let's say helmets and if it's like baseball they're shared helmets if the individual athlete wants their own specific helmet the parent would buy their own specific Helmet or if they wanted a certain type of helmet as opposed to what's provided by the district but it's not as if we don't provide any safety equipment um but there are certain players
085and families that decide they don't want to use the shared model and they'll buy their own um Sarah go ahead is this alternative three is that flat 200 sport does that include that's excluding the 7030 rental split right so like the Squash Family would pay 900 in addition to correct the okay all of these V structures maintain the rental so all of them maintain the existing rental did we look at smooth out the co including smoothing out the rental costs uh there would not really be a way to do it unless you had a much higher per student fee for everything else um because of the cost of the rental facilities so if we did if we did smooth it out what would that do to it would take us to zero I mean I
086if you were to like Smooth it out where you had no rental fee whatsoever I mean we would have to work it up but I would imagine the fee would be in excess of $500 per family probably much more than that just to cover cost right Rich isn't our average cost like just taking the whole spreadsheet that you gave it's literally like I think it's it's almost $1,000 or maybe 750 per athlete based on the actual cost not even including the rentals and if you include rentals it's over $1,000 per athlete that's correct for all bars I mean I think trying to do something like that which is what Dennis had proposed I think in a recent year would be pretty costly and the families that that I believe hockey was one of the big
087ones because we didn't have a rank and they wanted to have the sport and so they agreed to pay for the ice time and those sports are the they have the most expensive rental fees for that reason that's correct so hockey is between $4 and $1,500 uh and then squash is a little over $500 for just point of clarification to be clear like if you look at our budget book there's a wide swing and I'm not picking on any sports here um at all I'm just looking for example baseball is over $2,500 per per player cost and track and field 314 that's a huge difference the other thing I just want to know is that this is another this is another budget implication that affects students we we will have lower participation like students will
088stop participating um it's unfortunate to me that we're asking our students to carry so much of this burden just to be clear we are contemplating a lot of different budgetary structures at the moment we have made other than restoring the idea we've made no decisions so just so the public is is clear we are this is all deliberation um and we want to understand the components of all it okay any other Qui s just I just want to clarify for certainty for the public that if there are free of reduced lunch students that they would be exempt from any any fee so there are scholarship forms so free student gets uh it wave uh reduce student it's slightly less and then even if those students have like an an economic hardship where maybe they don't
089qualify for free and reduced lunch maybe they're a two family uh two parent working situation and maybe one lost their job they can qualify for economic hardship we have again discussed this for several years and I we may not have hit on the right model whatever that is uh Tak into consideration all the variables but uh I'd be pretty confident that should the board if the board wants to do something off this nature then we'll take everybody's considerations and I'd rather work work on it that way than than so going forward how do we I'm just thinking to the 28th of the the modifications like how do we think about this do you want to finish this to the whole discussions first of all and then come back to the higher level okay yeah I
090think so okay yeah just yeah just one comment I I know in other districts and this is outside the state of Connecticut there are schools that varsity and you know high school players have to buy their own uniforms every year on every team we do not do that so part of I think part of the thinking of potentially doing some kind of a participation fee would be inclusive of things like that and there are teams in Daren where they need to purchase a new uniform every single year and you know we do not require them to purchase a uniform either so yes you're right it might be a little inequitable potentially but if if it's across the board for everyone we have had Parents also say you know we we would prefer it that it's
091equal for everyone instead of picking certain ones and doing things differently which is kind of what we do right now so I know that there are both sides to this okay any other questions on this topic no okay uh thank you um we'll go to the board questions uh from the uh fourth so i' just show you sort of give you a sense of how this is structured um so the questions were as we received them this is for the for the prior meeting if you just scroll down um M philad please should just you come to one of the the uh gray areas that's great that's gray okay all right maybe on on your you can see the gray areas um those are the those are the additional questions I Comm in so what
092we took we did was we took if it's rc1 we put them in with rc1 if they were you know five and six we we slip them in there U next thing probably will just be to literally order them as question one through whatever but um that's kind of so it's a little different than we used to get a document every time we had a meeting and so what we've done is moved to a table structure so that it's the RC it's the DAT it was asked it's the question and that way we can keep track of it by RC that was that that was the thought so thank you for that so with that um and we'll take this RC by RC that's basically yes so I'm not going to read all every answer
093um so if there's if there's questions about these we're be happy to address them so rc1 I guess is up okay any questions about what's on his content in rc1 rc1 just a quick question sure Wellness Center are people badging in or are we signing in uh no they're not badging in we're signing in thank you anyone else on rc1 Robin um a question on the mental health spend we had a spreadsheet that was provided with total costs um that have been spent so the question I have a couple questions first of all the psychology interns which currently is about a $68,000 cost for us um this would be in addition to our current 18 psychologists that are on staff and I'm including the five at the elementary schools as part of that what is
094the purpose of the um psychology interns in that $68,000 because I don't think that we've had a need or we haven't had empty positions of psychologists not being able to be filled so I'm just interested in what the interns do I I believe Dr dad and Dr McCarthy did a presentation on the interns and I and just go back it really wasn't to supplement any of our services it really is um a professional opportunity to really train them and work with them um they do work under the opes of um certified staff um we are working and professionally training them as well and they do support students both in the classroom as well as in individual small groups um and supporting all students within the buildings March and we actually have used a few of
095them to fill in for some long-term medical leads leaves where otherwise students would might have gone without services so that mental health worksheet uh it doesn't does not include um special education per se right because uh there are times where students are out place or otherwise uh for different reasons um it doesn't include counselors uh that provide provide some mental health uh for our students it doesn't meant it doesn't deal with times from principles or assistant principles so it just there's a couple of categories that are not there it's just hard to quantify we just tried to line it up to numbers that were in the book if you know what I mean yes Joanna so just piggy backing piggybacking on that the idea psychologist listed here how how do they fill fit into the
096bigger ecosystem of what we have uh across all schools when you say Ida you're saying these number 13 on the list here so it's a psychologist funded out of the Ida Grant so there are 10 uh Elementary psychologists and one of the 10 is in that Grant oh okay and then what is hope to Healing that is a new grant that Alicia is securing so that's Revenue so to speak okay Robin um the 10 Elementary psychologists I understand that I think five of them are within the rc24 and then the other five are for general education population within the elementary school is that correct because we have two per elementary school and I guess my question is what is the role of the general education psychologists what what are they doing kind just in terms
097of the need for 10 of them at the elementary schools I I probably wouldn't separate them into um the general education psychologists they're attribute to the budget they go 50 go into their budget 24 and then the other budget that rich can speak to better than I uh they work with all students so they work grades they take grades and they loop with their students K through five um they're responsible for servicing all students they go into the classroom and do group lessons with students as well in their capacity for all the grades K through five um they're also responsible for supporting teachers and working with students for pre-referral um for doing OPP mtss they might be involved in a child who is a child in general education program without related services or a 504
098IP plan and they do not only mtss they support the family they support the teacher and they support the classroom thank you s um so recognizing that our district has had some pretty not pretty some profound issues in the in the past few years and pardon me if we've we've talked about this is there how do we compare in terms of our our staffing and our spend for mental health in our Durk I would honestly um certainly some of the positions we have right and certainly the leadership position we have is is uh both very valuable um and probably unique it's not unique just as as a director position is probably unique um I I haven't compared like the the mental health worksheet to other people's mental health worksheet to be honest with you I
099would have to i' have to no just yeah okay and actually you would you would maybe get close but Apples to Apples just looking at that list uh what another District would provide may be a different list office like right but I just happen compared the other other districts Dave just following up to that question Rich how big an effort would this be for you to grabb from a couple durs if state is available dur schools nearby we could reach out okay would you mind we all right that Jo thank you anyone else in rc1 okay rc3 yes Robin um I had one question just on Rich you had provided the number of enrollment of middle schools in durg a so the question that I had was um are we the only duray school that
100has the team model and all of the others are a junior high model or does new Canan and because of its large size also have the team model or do you know all the districts are Team all of them including the ones that have two middle schools that are smaller in size they have less teams but yeah thank you Katie just a point of clarification it's worth noting too for anyone that's not aware that new Canan has four grades in their middle school they start at fifth grade yes thank you okay any other questions in rc3 okay then we have the elementary RC's 5 through 10 some of the some of these questions we've sort of touched on here and there uh through the presentations [Music] but so going back to that teacher absence it
101looks like we're we're trending better do you what do you tribute that to I'm not really I'm I'm not really sure except that the DEA leadership the building Administration and I work closely and we talk to people who've been absent above the average about the effect that it has on their students so thank you for that yeah okay uh rc1 go ahead yes I'm just the absence date you talk about the table Sarah yeah link yeah I just the bottom the 24 through that's through the break in 25 so that's just a partial right yeah yes yeah yeah yeah I mean still we're still if you double it we're still still lower okay well except that may is a higher rate of absence oh that's true too so it looked like it looked to me
102like we were on on trying to build Marge up and you're yeah [Laughter] sorry okay RC 11 I think they just talked about that I just one on on rc11 Jill yes um I believe there was a I don't know where this came from but was there a request to see what a fiveyear uniform replacement cycle would look like I think that was from the RTM questions that were just forwarded so not today okay so that'll be a followup oh and then I did have a question about the security and I had asked this before but for the uh right now we have I guess two off-duty police officers and an SRO at all home games for hockey basketball and football so there was a question that I had from one of the the parents
103that had those teams excluding football which I think we probably do need that coverage but the question was do we really need the additional police officers at hockey and basketball home games and what would the cost savings be if we did not do that and just had the SRO I mean I would have to reach out to Chris that's line okay thank you you have all the components the question Rich you're not you're not suggesting cutting back on on the supervision just a different nature of it uh the question was do we need the two off-duty police officers at every home game for basketball and for hockey so so you are ask question other districts do not do that and there's no disruption so it was just a question okay Mr Bri yes Dave there
104um I'm not sure about the predicate there I don't know that I've really tracked that much but I don't know that I always see that many police at every sporting event and I don't know how many um how many campus monitors we have like if you could provide that data what we do in each sport first is a starting point and then we can back into um necessity I think that would be helpful this was based on a a parent was one of the parents of those teams that asked that question yeah okay fair thank you fair enough okay okay rc13 rc14 rc1 15 I have one for RC 15 yes um I just think in general it would be helpful maybe if we the amount of technology and software especially in light of the
105fact that we are trying to reduce overall screen time and just implemented the policies that we did with phones specifically um is all of the software that we are using it probably maybe more particularly at the elementary level uh being utilized as much or are there Alternatives that would be offline not requiring technology or computers or Chromebooks um just to give our especially our youngest students more of a break from the technology and screens that is that is a discussion that we had at the time a lot of the uh recurring expenses and technology or or a lot of the licenses uh each actual other other software package for for students or otherwise we actually went through um well not actually we did go through them to make sure that they were actually being used
106we remove some uh and we also took like we really haven't added anything to talk about in new software we we that's extremely Limited at this particular Point uh so we we have done that analysis of are we using the software do we need the software and essentially we're not getting any new sare for this year okay thank you 16 any questions Joanna um in uh 16 in the breakdown um of the catering budget you have convocation on for 6,000 and also in an early I think it's a curriculum RC you have the speaker for convocation down to 7,000 um so what does the 6,000 cover uh because convocation I don't know if you kept a breakfast you feeding the whole District what is what does that entail um and you know Dr adley when
107I saw you speak a couple years ago I thought that was phenomenal I don't know that you necessarily need have speakers and I don't know if the believe me that wor off after a while you're okay I will say that the convocation uh speakers have have um many of the board members have had an opportunity to go I hope you find it uh very helpful um I know it's in line with what we we should be doing as a district uh on our our goals and our priorities uh they support that i' um to date I feel that the staff has uh all St prek k312 have gotten stuff out of those uh presentations and we've had a number them from ROM Berger to Mark bracket uh AI um so on so forth so they
108have been I think many many of you have actually attended those particular sessions um so actually the break do we have the break di for do you have do you have the break di for 6,000 is the breakfast so that's for all teachers across the district everybody who ATT 10 staff RC Oh Katie thank you um so I had submitted in a follow-up question to a similar question where it appears something appears twice so we have um for board meetings including um The Retreat we have 3500 and then we have Retreat catering 2500 um in a different place is it 19 K well 19 question number no RC is it rc1 19 is that what it is no 16 16 still 16 okay yeah it's twice in 16 or you said it's in two different
109RC so on P in the budget book it's page 207 um I thought was the breakdown of that 5,000 isn't it yeah was it not the breakdown in there and then it was also in Boe meetings so it was under Boe meetings and then in parentheses it said um no like catering budget right p and then Bo Retreat catering and in the answer set the catering at B Retreat and right Rich can you look into that please thank you okay anything else on 18 RC 19 Robin um one question um just in terms of the increases over time in professional development um versus I think 2023 it was 121,000 now it's 165,000 what is the reasoning or you know the trend and why has it increased so much over the past two years you're talking
110only n 18 not a question here that refer is correct across all RC's I think I was looking at rc19 specifically yes so um so part of it is the loss of Title One funding um so there used to be approximately $30,000 of Title One funding that covered PD that loss of that money is now in rc19 that addition to that we also obviously have to invest in pacy and we have a number of AP courses where our staff is meeting have a training at TA in the summer to be current teach those coures okay okay so this is you're on what are we spending on PD over the years or are you on the curriculum development spending over time I it's on it was on PD specifically and the trend in rc19 professional development
111when I looked at the RC um because it was driven by this me Memo which was showing the trend okay so I'm sorry if my numbers were she answer they answered the question okay um I did wanted the board to follow it they're ready follow where she's talking yeah okay good it's rc19 sorry I think she's looking at line 253 yeah thank you um thank you okay I had another question on rc19 but it's not in this memo specifically am I able to ask other questions okay um the the Mt SS professional development which was $122,000 um one question is don't do we I since we've had our srbi in place for a long time what is the need for the $112,000 of training and if it's behavioral training one question is would we be
112able to use our director of mental health or any of our psychologists that are on staff to provide that kind of training instead of Outsourcing and spending $12,000 on I assume a consultant to train so the um the plan is to actually use Dr dad and utilize her expertise in that area she has been working closely um already with Julie drer at the elementary level and then our Middle School um and especially our Middle School staff 68 you are correct the major shift from srbi to mtss is the behavioral piece however um as we knowe in the Strategic plan there are elements of our processes anyway with srbi as we shift to mtss that need to be made more systemic across the school system so we still need an outside consultant to provide that professional
113development training um at the elementary level there may be some some use of um an external partner for that I was just wondering that the cost was $112,000 that's why I was you know partially you know for textbooks that we might use with our staff thank you other resources are yeah there manuals for mtss we might want to purchase okay and then on the admin Retreat cost the 21,000 um which I think was also it was in professional development within rc19 um just a question is that typical of the cost that we've incurred in previous years for the summer administrative Retreat yes can I also maybe naive question um so you gave a further breakdown in the administrative Retreat under what books supplies and resources you bought what does professional development in this instance then
114entail if it's not the materials that you're teaching with are you hiring somebody like why is it a separate cost um so typically there may be someone that we hire um that there would be a cost for that um usually there are books I'm thinking that there would be books on three different topics that I'd want to buy from for the administrative team um that's roughly for those supplies it's like the cost of $130 per administrator right um for the materials the resources I would buy and the the um instructional text that I'd like them to have I mean you gave a very excellent fully succinct answer and exactly what you were buying but I still don't understand what the separate line of professional development for almost $9,000 means for the LA for certainly uh
115for the last five or six years there's been a speaker the I guess speaker um say speaker the um this past one was Patrick Flynn for Teacher evaluation to lead us through the training of that the consultant speaker expert thank you okay anything else in 19 yes Katie um I had a question on the chart about enrollment um teachers and admin over time um so when I looked at this chart um since fiscal year 18 we are down 141 students down 25 teacher FTE and up 4.3 administrator FTE so that equates to for every 5.6 students we lose we lose a teacher and then for every 32.7 students we lose we add an administrator TR and I was just wondering if this was part of a concerted Vision or if someone could explain that trend
116of Le um less teachers and students and increasing administrators so just well if if you're looking at that particular chart um uh the story of that uh and the numbers on the right hand side just to give you a bit of a sense the 31 I think it's fy19 to fy2 um that's when the department shures went from 08 to 1.0 uh when it went from uh 32 to 33 uh that's a change we made with the uh music department CH and Colleen went to KK through 12 for art and music uh from 21 to 22 uh was the elementary assistant principles uh the implementation of special education the offset of the SAS facilitators um and then 37 to U 36 was the elimination of a director of Information Technology here at the high school
117so yes we did make an investment uh a few years ago with the elementary model for special education in particular uh We've we've essentially replicated that model at the secondary level I would say that and maybe parents think differently but I I would say that parents have been happy with that metal um and they been uh they have been responded to uh uh our teacher ERS are seeing more of administration on top of that our students are seeing more of their administrators um but we basically replicated the model at the elementary school uh for special education um we have just over 30% new administrators basically from jobs that we organ uh sort of set up in place from last May uh and we basically over a third of the the minist of staff are just
118settling into their new positions uh this particular year for people who have come across the country you've interviewed here and we've just placed in a variety of administrative positions so it really is for the most part it's just settling down into the model that we actually have here and it's not just a one to one with I don't say this casually without looking at it but um you can reduce some classroom teachers but you perhaps still need a special education director uh you still need uh someone to oversee the whole English Department just because you lost so many students doesn't mean to say you're you're going to lose automatically an administrator there so it's it's not just one to one you need a principal in every building some people may think differently but anyway you
119need a principle in every building um so some of the things don't change just because of that but at some point I understand the question Dave thank you RIT for putting this together um I had a couple follow-up questions on this and again not looking for an answer right now if you want to come back so we have 36 administrators listed here and then down below it talks about 40 to 42 showing up for the can you just give me a detail between these two and like where you see Staffing and what I mean um just quickly like the difference it's like Dr adley Shirley Marge Amy um so unaffiliated no I get it but if you just give like a break down like this 36 number how did we get to 36 it's X
120number principles and X number yeah so just that would be very helpful thank you and again if you want to give on the daa and Affiliated staff that would be helpful just want to get the full scope um but this is very helpful thank you um Alex a comment you just made tell me about some of the changes we made in the administration I'm thinking back to when we had the change proposed in the last year's budget dealing with the uh World Language coordinator and one of the things you had suggested was that that should be um move down and not be a department chair um one of the reasons you gave us I think was that sometimes it just better to do that model now reflecting on this for back a year can you
121give us some successes some wins some pros and cons now we're looking back if we've made that change yeah well we have had um our world language uh Department not Department sure U teacher leader here right at at the curriculum committees and so he's been given some updates there in terms of what he can do but the one thing he can't do is accountability and on some level I think he wants some accountability yes he can go in but it's it's it's different it's diff it's different get into classes as an administrator than it is going in as a teacher now you can say well well is that is that a bad thing no but it's just different that's all right um so he hasn't been able to do uh the teaching and learn and
122evaluations of the teacher that's the one thing that the one big thing that is is missing in that particular model and and the sort of accountability in the actual classroom itself certainly you can get certainly you get a level of expertise in in the actual language itself that has that has gone smoothly he's reported here Scott reported at the table here that that has gone smoothly thank you Robin just following up on Dave's question I thought that you're talking about the department share role I thought they did not do teacher evaluations I thought the assistant principles did the evaluations they did for they did for word they do for word language they have to help by for for word language teachers and they do they do do other ones but predominantly the uh Department chaires
123are doing evaluations they do okay they they also do the goal setting the midyear conference and the end of year conference in addition to the observations I would say like if you asked me to go back again I mean I would perhaps go back to the model that we had before but a different question indeed okay um anything else in 19 just quick question um yes under what are we spending on LPD over the years include the cost of substitutes um for this year and next year it's looks like it's um 8,000 more than the year before is that just because of what they're learning or is it just why is a little higher so the budget um so the 24 spend happens after the budget and so it's really closer to line 23 and
12422 um where you had 18 and then 22,000 for the years before so it's also the timing of when the budget's graded a lot of times they can't get subs too so that's part of the reason why you see that lower number last year thank you sorry I didn't understand that why is 24 so low so uh 24 part of it is uh we couldn't get subs um and then also when you build the budget so when we build the budget for 25 you're really looking at the 23 data because you haven't fulfilled the 24 year and so if you look at the 23 data it's 18 and change right much closer to that 20 number H and thank you okay 24 yeah um thank you for the the out of District tuition breakdown that's
125really helpful um I would love to know and I don't know if it's possible but I would love to know how our unilateral unilateral placements compare to other districts in AR jerg I don't know that it helps us this year but I think it's important to know in comparison to others you want an aggregate cost yeah I guess yeah I don't know how how you could break it down for other districts but rich and we'll start with Rich and then surely add um is there anything Rich that you feel like you could provide I don't know how easy it would be to get that data um some districts do have it separated in line settl placements some districts like D do not public and public some just do I don't know how easy Orly okay
126I you anecdotally that you know families that I know in Westchester County and other schools here like it seems like we are very high but I don't know if that's accurate or not what I could do and I know that we had spoken about last time I can ask in our dur if they'd be willing to share their information because we have dur meetings I can ask if they'd be willing to share that that' be helpful thank you thank you sorry anyone else on 24th okay 26 Robin um Rich would it be possible for the pre 3K tuition for um the comparable kind of communities could you also add neoton Presbyterian nursery school and also St Luke's so we did ask for neoton based on the finance committee we're just waiting to hear back um
127but we can ask St Luke's as well thank you you say three place or just two no just those two okay all right so we've got some other couple other questions I'll just open that up more broadly if there's anything inside of the other bucket that people would like to talk about uh prior to Capital I'll separate that go ahead Robin um just one thing on I was looking at the transportation the six-year Trends um just one question um is I happened to be in New Canon recently and saw they literally that the bus Depot basically um that they have like 25 at least at least 25 Suburbans a number of like 47 capacity buses and then also the 77 so the question that I I have is I mean if we had a bus
128depot obviously that's another issue but it would it be possible if we mixed the capacity or changed the mix of the transportation that we provide depending on the capacity of the different routs is that something we give us additional cost savings you prob so it would be more expensive because um when you so they do have some smaller buses and some of the reasons they have that is just the terrain of new Canan and some of the narrower roads um if we were to go from 72 passenger buses to like the 50 pack buses um it does affect the tiers too and so you would end up with more buses um so really having the we have 25 72 passenger buses is really the most cost- effective way to provide okay and then just one
129um suggestion that the annual opt-in process that we had done for a number of years has stopped over the past couple can we reinstate that just so we wouldn't want to reinstate it um so there is a so the reason we had the opt-in was due to covid and so we had a track where students sat on the bus the reason we got rid of it um by and large most parents didn't acknowledge the opt in opt out and so what would happen at the very beginning of the year is parents would flood the office with emails phone calls concerns that their students were going to get transportation and it you could not keep up with the flurry of emails and phone calls to the point where you'd get three and four more um it
130didn't provide any cost savings or understanding of who's riding the bus because what we do do during the year is a census so we have an idea of how many people are riding the bus the bus drivers take a census every day um the reason we can't eliminate buses or collapse routes has to do with the timing of the buses so typically an elementary school bus you'd like to have be no more than 30 or 35 minutes you also only have less than an hour between when the high school drops off and they have to go to the next tier so if you wanted to collapse a bus you're looking at an elementary school aged child being on a bus for probably an hour and 15 minutes but you couldn't even do that because if
131you got an hour and 15 minute bus ride by the time they left the high school uh they'd be late for let's say token or H um so the optin opt out really didn't provide us any data where we would be able to say either we could move a bus from one school to another or um you know we could collapse a bus what it really did was create a lot of anxiety amongst the community okay thank you we also added that bus right we did add five a few years ago Jo I had a couple other yeah just on that and that bus serves all three tiers no it only two tiers secondary uh so no it does the high school for bus 25 and then we did utilize it um for Royal uh
132in order to kind of speed up the route um it's not necessarily for Royal but you're paying for it whether you use it for one tier two tiers or three tiers um but it's primarily just for that one tier thing thank you yes Robin um a question just on Health Care um I'm I'm I know that you explore all options as much as possible but I I know that many even for-profit companies these days are doing different things with the way that the plans work with the hsas or with ag embedded deductibles versus aggate deductibles on a family level which can can basically enable you to um be more cost effective in terms of our overall exposure on medical loss ratio Etc I mean have so any change to the deductibles has to be negotiated
133with the unions and so right now we have a 255 deductible if you wanted to change it to 3,000 6,000 or 4,000 8,000 whatever number you com you do have to negotiate that with every single Union so for instance for family coverage there are some ways that they do it where every individual in the family would have to meet the deductible before before any payout happens so you have to negotiate have to negotiate have to negotiate any PL sign changes okay um I had one more question sorry on Food Service just in the object detail why is the management fee increasing $132,000 or a 5% increase in this next year's budget so it's combination of two things one it is tied to inflation um and so there's a buil in increase for that and then
134as we move people off District employees um and more employees become Chartwells employees there's a greater cost that you're assuming there and there's no negotiable amount to lessen the amount of the management fee increase okay thank okay Katie I'm sorry I had a question from rc19 if we can just go back thank you um so in one of the followup questions was about the stiens for the elementary culum specialist being eliminated and the answer was given that the director of Elementary education has and will continue to take on the responsibility um so it's not clear to me why we have a reduction of um a little over $24,000 um so on on page 230 of the budget book which is line 690 um in account 21 220 curriculum and supervision is am I misreading what
135that $25,000 reduction is for those are the five stiens that are in place this year okay so then I don't understand this says that the Elementary uh education director has and will continue to take on these responsibilities So currently this year we right we can't that currently we have them so this is this is new okay so it's bit misleading because it says that the director has assumed them this year so it's they're they're being eliminated for the director to assume the responsibility um and so can we talk a little bit about why we think that's the best choice then you know I think that part of the reason they were put in place was that there's five ele schools and you know the importance of ensuring continuity across them and I would think especially
136with the upcoming year and what's going on in literacy they would they would be really valuable so from a curriculum and instruction perspective you'll probably hardly ever find me not wanting to advocate for supports for our classrooms um curriculum instruction assessment and professional learning I think we had talked about the importance of of the coordinator position that we had had and it was just a matter of looking for places that we could make Cuts in the budget and so we while we um have a director of Elementary she's taken on many parts of the coordinator role from last year these stend positions have been helpful um but again we just to make difficult decisions across the budget um yeah it seems like a a pretty low dollar amount for something that I would imagine is
137pretty important in the coming year in particular um okay okay any other questions in the document all right we'll move on to the overall budget discussion that's you sir that that is me okay um well we left off uh a couple of things well I need some guidance from the from the board on in terms of may not be tonight um but just uh how we get to the number we pull up that slide just to I didn't I didn't this um have slide this slide I didn't change this slide because I didn't want the board to think that there's changes going on this is where we left off but and the night this is this is basically where we left off and um you can see that really option two for now is is
138really the only options in place since the board made the decision last week to restore the Ida program so option two is one option um the consideration 3B again uh consideration 3B includes the ECR reimbursement so you don't have to include the the ECR reimbursement but that's administrative recommendation to do that as our best Judgment at this particular point but we'll see we see how that sort of plays out uh down at the bottom there's a uh athletic fee participation and then a combination of clubs and murals and so on we can get there any way we have to get there fees other ways if the board wants to even participate and in a fee structure but you can see uh under option two is the class sizes that we were talking about and then
139a variation of participation fees to get us there and in consideration uh 3B it was a class sizes and an expansion of inter murals club fees and U pay for participation that's kind of what gets us down to the numbers in in the vicinity uh which is 4.37 or 4.39 if the board uh wants to look at something else um I guess that's up for discussion but these are the these are the current proposal of where we left it um PLC is in this uh and these particular reductions are in I think that's about about summarizes okay I think uh based on what you just said I think the first question for the board just to confirm um and I certainly would recommend that we take into account the ECR reimbursement of a lower ECR
140reimbursement because it's likely the reason it's lower is because the volume of claims is higher and the state pool of money hasn't changed um and I think we can be reasonably certain that the volume of claims will continue to be high and uncertain that the state will change the pool of money um so rich I assume that's why you all are recommending rich and charlee so in order for the reimbursement rate to go up next year one of two things has to happen either the state has to put more money in the budget or District claims across Connecticut have to go down right both are online yeah okay so are we in agreement we'll leave uh an adjustment for ECR down to 65 I think that makes sense okay mam sureair all right great yes
141I just to update the board that um there may be a public benefit uh uh reimbursement from the electric company for about $444,000 we don't know that uh completely in fact I think Richard has got some information to suggest they won't know until July the town has put it in this part of their budget anticipating it so I either the town shouldn't put it in or we should put it in I don't think we should be in different pages about uh whether we put it in or not um so at this point we're we're building it in as a as a as a saving at 44 if that's okay yeah um yes Dave sorry just for the slide still up here Rich do we have participation fees in any sports right now uh some of
142the sports do have what they call voluntary participation fees um that are collected um the district does not have participation fees outside of the rental fees right okay can we get a is that something we have visibility into is that a big LIF the rental fees no just what the voluntary volunte it's on the chart it's on the atletic spend spreadsheet um yeah okay so I think overall you know part of we've identified you know being in the in this ballpark that we're in is we know that the guidance from the board of Finance is 3 to four% they haven't updated it um we're a little over that guidance um I think we're trying to stay in the ballpark of that guidance now when I say trying to stay in the ballpark of the guidance
143our first job is to understand um what it takes to be there so this is one way to meet it I think having talked to a few different board members um we realize that um this these conversations are extremely difficult we'd like the opportunity to look at um some other options so that we can best understand the tradeoffs um we're interested in hearing more about um some diff some changes that might not be directly in the classroom structure we understand everything impacts the classroom at the end of the day that's what we're here for um but so we're at asking you all to look um carefully at curriculum Staffing PD and development um to look carefully again at technology um might be some other things Rich you've said there's nothing in transportation but can you
144wave your magic want some more um look carefully at the use of Consultants are there areas of duplication in mental health or um anywhere else where we might be possibly duplicating uh with be a couple of suggestions as places to start if anybody would like to add anything we're asking you to think about something in the neighborhood of a million dollar um that's not because we're looking to cut an additional million dollars from the budget uh it's because we're trying to understand um the opportunity cost of any decision that we make um rich is a million dollars you think an adequate number so it depends on where the the board wants to be So currently uh the budget's a 492 with the restoration of talented and gifted and uh the ECR adjustment M um so
145a million dollars probably get you to about that four um if we were to put options on the table in these categories um depending on the appetite of the board you know you may hit that million or you may end up being below it because some of the items you just might not have an appetite for yeah okay okay all right so just just for can I just ask some clarifying questions right so just to get million here um given what we put on the table right that's potentially going to touch some other things potentially that may impact other constituents that haven't been at the table here or yep right so I'm just I'm just I'm just sharing like okay I just so that's the risk right is we certainly are aware that a lot
146of parents of second and third graders and their PTO that don't like the class size and we're aware that we've heard some people about from a few people about fees we're aware we've certainly heard from the idea Community we've heard um what's the other thing we're getting a lot certainly we've heard a lot about Paras thank you um so yes the risk in asking this is is that um there are additional cohorts that will be unhappy to hear their interests named um but I think that there was a feeling that we need to understand um we need to understand what the the trade-offs are so M I'm sureair just for Clear has my guidance changed no no okay yes Robin um I I guess the way that I would venture to ask this is just
147for instance the grade two to three increase in class size in particular is an area where I would think that that really would hit student instruction and learning and so the way I would like to look at this is if we can come up with maybe an alternative to having to do something like that you know as a as another option not that we want to cut another million dollars out of the budget we do not that is the ask correct we're not looking for the guidance is the same yeah I think the ask is to see what else there is that is not directly student facing and you can I to Jill's point you can argue that everything is student facing but in the classroom what is what could there be Katie um I
148I would Echo what Sarah just said um absolutely looking for things that are not impacting the direct classroom and then I would also say while I understand these are much smaller numbers that are not getting to percentage Point um it it seems to me that you know a theme that we could comb through very critically is is catering you know for example I think the board um was probably happy to pitch in and buy our own lunch or BR and bag it so things like that when we're looking at facing even just the discussions about impacting student I really want to see this budget as lean as possible in every administrative and nice to have area Robin and I would also Echo the reason I asked for the comparables for instance for ELP is that
149I think a lot of the neighboring Nursery schools actually have already increased their prek tuition and at the very least I think we need to if we can keep up with a lot of the increasing costs that we are having to incur for instance with play based learning that now has to be also implemented within ELP the professional development the resources all of it has a cost and I would I think it would be good for us to at least look at our comparable comparable Nursery schools in prek in the community and think about that as an additional potential Revenue opportunity Okay Okay C can I be clear just because yes the new the administrative structure I haven't put on the table is the board looking for me under this this this direction to come
150back with administrative reduction because that's like I don't want to come back here and you go you didn't listen to me with because well for curriculum we asked you to look at Staffing development and PD yes so I think um you're probably going to have to look at administrators to look there just I just want to be clear what like well um yeah um earlier you mentioned an old model when it comes to uh teacher expertise and who's uh you know going back to teach leader positions I would like to know what that looks like if you you know went back um to what we had before Department chairs I personally love Department chairs I think they do a great service especially for parents but in this environment I don't know if that's the best
151way to move forward when we're trying to change class size and take out supports in the actual classroom so I would like to at least see what that looks like can go as far back as Point 8 point2 point8 teacher point2 leadership but I mean what do other dks do they're different oh right yeah so um just in case I've just with my earlier comments invited a flood of of additional public comment we are thrilled to hear from the public and for their engagement but we have to make our decisions not based on the number of people in any given C cohort that opine but rather on the relative educational merits of everything so just just to be clear it's it's always helpful to hear but um it isn't a function of of the number
152of feet right and what we did last week was an anomaly that's not how we normally operate and but it is what it is so yeah sure so to be clear it's not that the boards necessarily intend to go down to like 4 per. no just I just want like like just be helpful for me in terms of da go ahead associated with s people teaching jobs that turn teing so if um a department chair was reduced um uh by contract they would keep their salary as a teacher for a full year and so the reduction is effectively the lowest uh tenure teacher in whatever um and so we would have to look at what that is by subject I'm sorry just clarification but that would be for the first year realization corre just for
153the first year assuming that the department Che St right so if that was a conversation that we were really looking at having it would make sense to look out a couple of years to understand what the long-term sa we could look at M thank you Robin um just in the context of this is obviously a tough budget and the discussion we're having I think would make me also want to potentially maybe take another look at some of the the things that we said were initiatives that we wanted to include for instance the board docs or the website kind of Chang or things that were nice to have for our Communications plan but at this point I would almost want to also look at some of those items as well and and the Edy Planet additional
154licenses I mean is all of that a good thing that we need to do right now or could it be different well these are things we've been talking about for a year right um but that doesn't mean to say they got to go through so it's but we didn't have this information in front of us at the time that we talked about I'm glad you pointed that because neither did I thank you okay any other things to add we have our next steps thank you all for the time and the preparation that went into this evening and for making an additional night to to uh meet this evening uh with that I'll turn it to public comment good evening if anyone in person or online would like to participate in public comment please approach the
155podium or use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized once you've been recognized please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment please note the time with the chair we will begin with inperson and move to online hello ladies and gentlemen my name is Kevin Davis uh from RE saltbox Lane I'm here this evening representing the participants parents coaches families and fans of the approximately 150 Darren high school students from the squash skiing sailing and Rugby teams uh I'd like to start by thanking everybody here for their dedication to Daran school system we have the luxury of living in a town that provides an excellent education and that would not be possible without strong leadership so thank you um we're making a
156statement this evening to formally oppose the 340 participant co-pay included in the draft budget as proposed originally proposed I understand there's Alternatives this copay only affects nonc teams which are squash sailing uh skiing and rugby on an inequitable basis cak teams are not subject to this additional co-pay as originally proposed um the the proposed co-pay is above and beyond current co-pays that that our teams are subject to uh and will not result in any direct benefit or additional funding to any of our four teams uh to put the proposed increase in perspective the additional co-pay would result in a 59% increase to the current co-pay uh paid by squash players from 579 to 919 per player uh a 97% increase for skiers from 350 to 690 per skier an 85% increase from for Sailors from
157$400 to $790 per sailor and an infinite increase for rugby players from 0 to 340 per player across the approximate 150 participants this additional fee amounts about $51,000 per year which is disproportionately applied only to our four teams the significant increase in co-pay this represents may result in some of our students and at Daran High School not being able to participate uh in our four teams we wrote the board last week with our concerns which were primarily uh why does this C pay uh only apply to nonak teams and not all teams uh and why not distribute this $51,000 increase across all sports uh which would make the per excuse me per participant increase more significantly uh manageable we fully understand that balancing a budget is a difficult task we understand that when cost increase
158it is necessary to find additional sources of revenue however any new or increased fees need to be applied in an equitable manner singling out nonc teams is not Equitable uh the suggestion was made earlier uh this evening to have the board look into uh how the current budget is allocated on a per participant um method you know across various teams uh this is a suggestion that we support strongly we think it's very interesting and just the reference to baseball versus track that's a huge disparity that's a disparity that I think needs to be looked into further and uh we strongly uh support the additional analysis into into this um we circulated a petition to uh supporting our opposition to this additional copay so far as of this speech now we have about 170 signatures uh
159we're not asking the board to respond this evening but we are asking for your uh dialogue and continued discussion on this going forward thank you so much hi everyone I'm BR Kaiser I live on six alp fin Lan I'm a senior DHS and I'm Hayden shubble I live on 23 a street uh me and Hayden started playing rugby as freshman without knowing anything about it uh junior at the time encouraged us to try it and Hayden convinced me to give it a shot and we've loved it ever since uh truthfully I would have never played if there was a $340 fee I def definitely would not be standing here uh my parents like many others would have hesitated let me try a brand new sport such a high cost uh imagine how many prospective players
160face this same situation hesitating or not even considering rugby due to the cost resulting in fewer players and potentially no team at all in the future Through The Years me and Hayden have recruited a solid number of players because we love rugby and want others to join the community but convincing someone to join the team is difficult and adding another hurdle in them convincing their parents makes it almost impossible uh an example being our friend who joined as a junior he had never played rugby before Liv it so much that he now plays at Clemson I texted him today and asked if he would have joined for $340 he said no uh and that's what makes R be special not the game itself it's the community the bond we have as teammates and alumni is
161remarkable I was recently talking with a different Alum who graduated two years ago and he was convincing me to go to Auburn and join the team there I also asked him today if he would have tried to R you with a $340 price tag he also said no uh and final we're seniors this isn't going to affect us directly but we love this team and care about its future we want to make sure that others have the opportunity to fall in love with the sport in the community just like we did like thank you guys uh so I think Rugby's especially like a separate situation because a lot of kids there's no youth program so the kids coming up have never played it before so it's kind of a big price tag to make them
162pay $340 for the chance that they're going to like it we kind of try to recruit a lot of kids with like you don't like it doesn't matter like just come Chum to one practice just have fun try it out but if there's that additional cost you have to get through the parents not just the kids but the parents as well so it just makes it an additional uh step which prevents kids from experiencing the community and just like the athletic benefits I know that like uh Sports in general help with academics as well and just a community so you feel more bonded to the school byk all right thank you guys hi good evening my name is Gail Baldwin I'm at 0 goodwives River Road and I'm here to share my deep alarm about
163the proposed austerity level cuts to direct student instructional resources in general and about the proposed elimination of all instructional par Educators and proposed Elementary class size expansion in particular my husband nuland and I have three children second grade kindergarten and 2 years old and we moved here to my husband's Hometown and large L part because of the quality of schools like most people in Daran and we see this budget as a notable step backwards in student services in the district specifically the proposed budget fails to identify the real problem leading to perah absence from the K and first grade classrooms the lack of Subs in schools it falsely equates the contribution and quality of tenur par Educators with young college students who have no classroom experience it fails to suitably account for the 10 weeks
164of direct uh supervised instruction each intern is required to complete and also fails to contemplate that universities may find daran's program to be less attractive they may be less interested in partnering with Daran when they realize the D resourcing we've enacted in the program per has already spend 25% of their time as substitutes if we cut down the headcount from three to two uh and also have the 10-week required training they're going to be spending upwards of half of their time as substitutes and I I don't think that's exactly what universities are looking for for internship program the The Proposal fails to account for the value of Paras in attending to the academic needs of students and they are essential teaching resources their presence enables students to receive instruction while the teacher completes one-on-one assessments
165thereby increasing one-on-one time for each student with their teacher without which children may fall further behind it also fails to contemplate a potential resulting medium-term increase in special education utilization which I think is far from settled science ultimately it Dev values our current teachers by asking them yet again to do more with less finally families considering moving to darianne play pay close attention to the town's investment in its schools a budget structured to shrink so much after adjusting for inflation and remove Direct Services to students ass sure to impact the town's relative standing in Fairfield County uh setting aside the assurity of us having this conversation sitting on top of a brand new island thank you thank you excuse me hi my name is Kristen Anderson I live at 125 poverty Hall Road up in
166New Town thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak on behalf of the very dedicated 15 instructional AIDS you have proposed to eliminate each year we are included in the proposed cuts and each year we were put in the stressful position on proving our worth we are an easy target for budget cuts because you do not see what we do so you assume we do nothing our work with children isn't tracked by data or reviewed at meetings we quietly Provide support for students who need help but are not eligible for additional Services we show up year after year steady and consistent helping your children and our teachers and administrators with whatever assistance they need rather than read you a list of eclectic duties that we jump into each day and try to convince you
167how indispensable we are I would rather talk about our love and dedication for what we do what will you get if you proceed with the current proposal to swap 15 veteran staff members for 10 college students at oxid the three instructional AIDS H that have remained after last year's Cuts have over 40 years of combined experience working directly with students in the dairan schools this is three staff at one school multiply that number by our five elementary schools The Proposal is to discard us and place us replace us with 10 college Aid students each of who will have roughly zero hours working in the school system imagine the number of students that your 15 instructional aads have had the honor of working with over the years each year watching your children arrive on the first
168day of school helping them navigate recent in the lunchroom helping them learn letters sounds numbers addition subtraction then Division and fractions writing sentences learning cursive writing persuasive essays watching them make their first friend and each new friend after that being with them every school day for six years celebrating their Happy Days drying their tears on their tough days saying goodbye when they move to middle school and cheering them on when they graduate high school imagine how very proud We Are to have some of those students come back as AIDS and teachers now our co-workers we love our jobs we love the variety at each day we love seeing each of your children grow mature and move on each year we're invested in their future hoping to help each and every child become the best brightest
169and happiest person they can be will eliminating 15 long-term dedicated employees and replacing them with free inexperienced college students save you money absolutely but in nine months your free interns will move on and be gone and you will have gotten what you paid for thank you thank you uh Crystal Hill cdsp chair in listening to discussion tonight about par Educators it seems if that the issue is quite simple we do not have enough support staff in our elementary buildings we don't have enough staff to cover our substitute needs and provide the consistent teacher support in the classroom which our teachers have clearly communicated that they need so I continue to ask how is reducing the support staff from three par Educators to two student interns remotely going to solve this problem I can't help but
170wonder that without the pressure of budgetary guidance from the board of Finance we'd be even having this discussion at this point as it doesn't seem to really meet the needs of students at all and I'll go back to the public comment I made back in November when this board provided budget guidance to Dr adley at the end of the day the most important job of this board is to meet the needs of their students thank you hi good evening my name is Beth Waters I'm a resident of darianne and raised my three grown children here and I'm also an instructional par at token Elementary School and I've worked there for almost 18 years the needs of our community have grown immensely since I have began and since I raised my kids here not only do
171we have children with special needs we have children with anxiety depression family trauma social emotional issues English as a second language as well as the need for academic support and I also will emphasize that we do not have an ESL teacher our reading teacher and our math specialist take the time out of their day and work with these children they are they are godsend um basically the whole staff pitches in with these children who come to our schools and do not speak a lick of English um all of these require attention and more times than not need oneon-one support in a class of 22 or 24 this is difficult for a teacher to handle on a daily basis especially with our rigorous everchanging curriculum that's where an instructional PA comes in as longtime instructional paers
172we are familiar with all students their families how building con how buildings conduct their day-to-day operations and we have solid relationships with all staff if interns replace us they will not have the experience knowledge or time commitment that we have it will be a revolving door that would take a toll on our children and what will you do when you have one of the interns on their 10 week student teaching you will only have one person as opposed to three instructional Paras sometimes we help the interns believe it or not we teach them if interns are Place us um I said that I'm sorry it will be a Revol okay if you place the needs of our elementary school students first please don't cut the a first line of defense for them instructional Paris it
173will affect the quality of education at every school where we hope to make a difference one child at a time thank you so much for your time um I will say also about Paris in um kindergarten they are so important because in kindergarten we don't really identify children they're too young they come in it's a mixed bag we don't know what what's going to be so a teacher has this whole room of 17 to 20 kids and there are so many problems that come up we're always there we're not interventionalists but sometimes both psychologists are busy and the admins are in meetings who's there for that teacher when a kid is having a tantrum when there's a child that looks like maybe they're going to be special needs but they're not identified so we're there
174to help thank you for your time thank you would anybody else in person like to participate to our online participants please use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized Mr Jonathan Ford you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record thank you uh Jonathan Ford I'm a resident of 23 Edgewood Road here town as residents of Daring for the last three years we've watched as continued Cuts have been shipping away at the education system that brought us to this town listening to these discussions though it's clear that you're all working hard to navigate a very difficult path and use our funds efficiently but I couldn't help but notice going through the documents on a real basis when we compare before covid and the resulting inflationary shocks that
175occurred the budget is down um and so I I kind of wonder more of a question for for the board you know as you continue to explore options to minimize the impact on our students are there steps that the community can still take to support you to expand those parameters you have to work within uh so we don't have to make those cuts and can perhaps rebase the budget to catch up to sort of the modern world and a manage sort of future cut manage to avoid future cuts and then unnecessary kind of budgetary expansion down the road I think it'd be useful to kind of see if we can help help Drive the discussion to sort of reset and apply this diligence going forward rather than continue to sort of ship away at our
176great system thank you thank you we have no more raised hands at this time okay that I thank you all for being here this evening again I think members of the public online or otherwise or here in the room for listening in and I will take a motion to adjourn that is um Robin seconded by Joanna all those in favor that is unanimous thank you