001executive session and then I'll we are live okay with that I need a motion to reconvene in public session and then adjourn that executive session uh Joanna seconded by Dave all those in favor that is unanimous and with that I would like to call this regular meeting of the Board of Education to order the next regular Board of Education meeting is Tuesday January 28th at 7:30 p.m. in the Board of Education meeting room good evening and welcome tonight we have several gifts to accept we'll have an update on the high school's personal device plan and we'll take a look at our Master agenda but our primary focus tonight is to gain a deeper understanding of several key initiatives within our budget proposal I want to briefly address the recent news regarding the educational um ECR
002educational cost no I'm I'm blanking on it I wrote down ECS educational ECR what's it stand for excess cost re excess cost reimbursement thank you we've learned that the state will be reimbursing us at 59.9% this year this is significantly lower than the 70% we originally budgeted and then adjusted down to at 65% in May this reduction represents a shortfall of approximately 287,000 this year likely necessitating a special appropriation at the end of the fiscal year there'll be more information and Finance on Thursday this lower reimbursement rate will have two significant impacts moving forward this budget year first budgetary adjustments tonight we'll discuss the need uh to budget for an additional about 166 Less in e CCR funding for next year reflecting that 65% reimbursement rate which is our best guess at what it'll be
003secondly the impact on reserves this lower than expected reimbursement will also impact the availability of funds in our general res Reserve account uh because we'll need to go for an appropriation we have been in contact with the chairs of the board of finance of RTM education and RTM FNB that means finance and budget and we've also been in contact with our legislators on this matter both and caps have issued statements expressing their concerns that's the Connecticut Association of boards of education and the Connecticut Association of public school superintendence this issue will undoubtedly be a focal point at the upcoming cab board retreat on the 22nd which I will attend on behalf of darianne and at our legislative breakfast in Westport on the 28th at 8:00 a.m. it'll be um 8 to 9: if any board
004members would like to attend please reach out to Cass and she will um RSVP for you I'll leave my remarks at that we have a lot to get to but before I we begin I'd like to clarify that this is a meeting held in public not a public meeting this distinction is important um because while we value the input and perspectives of of our community members this meeting is primarily for the Board of Education to conduct its official business including in-depth deliberations and decision-making if you are in the room or listening online tonight we truly appreciate your engagement and your interest in our schools we know many of you have strong feelings about our budget about our use of personal devices at all and we've been listening carefully to your comments at meetings and through
005emails we've received a lot of feedback which we value greatly I know there's just a lot of people in the meeting like in the room are they muted thank you to ensure everyone has a chance to be heard and to keep our discussion moving we well good luck with midterms with that I'll turn to you Alan are you wonder oh I'm going to public comment first okay public comment so um we have somebody recognized first um good evening Dr reu you have been recognized and you can approach the podium well she's coming up to the podium I will remind everybody when you you approach the podium and you wait to be recognized at that time you could state your name and address for the record and please note that you'll have up to three minutes
006to comment for those of our members of the public that are online please use the raised hand icon after everybody in person has gone I will begin acknowledging those online one at a time with your name listed on your Zoom profile all right Dr regu you can come to the podium okay thank you thank you for listening to me uh I stand in support of funding for the idea program gifted children need the opportunity to maximize their potential stifling it by taking away idea may damage the child and perhaps even stifle potential and creativity this may cause irreparable harm to the child the highest suicide rate in the nation except for Native American teens is among gifted teenagers why is this because gifted children have much more complex thought processes that can be problematic unless
007they are addressed by having the socio emotional and academic supports within the school system as represented by the idea program I know this is true because I had two children who are in the idea program and because of it they have flourished in a highly successful manner that they would not have been able to achieve without the idea program in my experience as an attorney dealing with primarily special with primarily the special needs population I can testify that the idea program is essential so that no harm will be done to any child thank you for listening can we have your name and your town of residence please for the minutes what here your name and your town of residence please oh my name is Margaret reu Dr Margaret Ru R A gue and I've lived
008in Daran for 37 years I'm still here okay thanks go ahead burn posie 8 Circle Road thank you to the board of education and the administration for all your hard work parents students and alumni of the idea program have reached out to all of you emails calls petitions public comment on behalf of the board of the D I will summarize the main themes we are hearing from the community they are even more shocked by the proposed crosswalks than they were by the initial news that the idea program was being considered for elimination they seem Hasty short cited inefficient and toned deaf to be clear there is zero interest in alternatives to a 50 plus year old program that is undeniably lean efficient and supports one of darian's most valuable assets education to suggest that the
0093.3 beloved FTE named Miss Mata Miss Martin Miss Aaron and Miss Reed with over 70 years of experience among them who delivered the specialized educational needs to what one Boe member called a significant cohort of students can be replaced with some professional development at the end of the summer is unrealistic there are there are mentors quiz ball coaches and support systems they are some of the greatest as assets this district has indispensable the proposed crosswalks would dismantle a program that is aligned with our strategic plan and consistent with our core values they would incur unspecified and unanticipated costs the crosswalks are being called inclusive true inclusivity embracing is diversity but this so-called inclusive model falls short of celebrating and supporting the differences of this population of Learners the idea program cannot be replicated in the
010general classroom or by media Specialists teachers are overextended now no par Educators in bigger classes teacher burnout and attribution real risks how much is the professional development net savings implementation plan who is going to be trained to evaluate over 300 program applicants like the idea teachers do now and on and on if the district fails to serve these gifted Learners they will go to neighboring districts where gifted programs do exist or to private schools several real estate experts have advised us that the strength of our educational system has a direct impact on home values members of the daeg community are making well-intentioned suggestions for other efficiencies and thank you for considering them mental health is a huge priority for Daren it would be remiss to end my statements without underscoring the social and emotional value
011that the idea program provides for this population of students a place to belong to feel heard and understood be challenged and fit in these kids want and deserve that thank you for your time and we look forward to hearing tonight's dialogue thank you uh Crystal Hill cdsp chair uh I wanted to spend a few minutes tonight on the topic instructional par Educators our elementary PTO chairs have spent time Fielding parent questions and listening to feedback from our parents as well as staff and that feedback has been pretty consistent across all five elementary schools parents and staff are deeply concerned about what the impact will be of replacing instructional par Educators with educational interns many of our par Educators have been serving our schools uh for many many years they are integral parts of each of
012our school communities our students families and teachers see them as trusted professionals who provide consistency and support year after year they are often members of our own deran Community who truly get to know our students and families but putting aside the impact of Morale on losing our par Educators would have there seem to be many practical questions that haven't been answered and I hope the board will address those tonight first if a big justification for this change is the need to provide more consistent availability for classroom substitutes how would reducing the current support staff from three professionals to two possibly provide mitigation to that problem wouldn't it only exasperate it another question is whether educational intern time is tied to their programming at their universities will the interns be in our school for the full
013year additionally pair professionals provide continuity from year to year the use of educational interns were to acclimate and train and just simply learn to do these roles to expect them to immediately support our teachers in the same way have seems unrealistic to the same end I believe on Super Saturday it was stated that the student interns would need to undertake 10 weeks of full student teaching during their time at our schools is that a specific 10-week period consecutively or is that spread throughout the year would the interns even be available to act as substitutes during that period of time logistically it seems like we could be exasperating the problems with our substitute coverage even further not to mention that teachers are expected to train and provide mentorship to these new professionals are we just not
014asking them to do more it seems like every budget season we ask our teachers to do more and really there seems to be an open question as to whether it's even realistic to expect that we could get 10 student interns to take these positions is there actually a robust pipeline of students looking for this type of opportunity what happens if we cannot fill all 10 of these spots could some or all of our schools be left with even fewer support staff next year as representatives of our pto's we implore the board to have a full and complete understanding of what this change would look like before deciding if this is a change appropriate for our school district thank you thank you hello my name is Parker Harris and I'm a sixth grade idea student I'm
015here tonight to protest the cancellation of Idea Idea truly means a lot to me it's always been something to look forward to and teaches basic skills that any person should have skills that they don't teach in any of the other subjects for example problem solving idea goes deeper into normal problem solving and challenges me and other people in a way that normal school doesn't the puzzles expand my thinking stretching my brain and pushing my limits encouraging me to keep going even when I would normally give up idea has helped Challenge and push me out of my comfort zone it's helped me have confidence when I speak and has been an amazing help for writing persuasive speeches showing me how to get my way by using my words idea also makes me feel like I'm part
016of a group it helps me make new friends and connect with people that think similarly to I do although I can connect with people in a normal classroom the idea people think like I do and understand me idea teaches me how to work with other people and in a group I always thought that it was faster to work alone but idea has has showed that it's more efficient to work together the work we do in idea is also important for example word Masters encourages me to learn new words to expand my vocabulary and it helps me build good study habits something that was vital when I went into sixth grade idea has is probably one of the only things in school that challenges me this is important because school should be challenging or at least
017some of it idea is challenging because of word Masters in the other projects that we do it forces me to think about the same thing in many different ways on top of that idea is also fun the projects we do make me have to Rack my brain for new strategies when I challenge myself it is enjoyable for me it um I have to think about the same thing in many different ways Al just idea means a lot to me from teaching me basic skills that aren't seemingly so basic to being part of a group in what I learn from the work that we do in Idea Idea has always been there for me a special place and something to look forward to during the school day for all these reasons and more I truly think
018that you should not cancel idea please thank you thank you par excuse me before you begin Parker you just did an amazing job but audience I need to tell you we have to ask you not to clap it's because then if somebody came came up and said something that some of you agreed with that wasn't so pleasant that somebody was clapping to that I would need to cut that off so unfortunately I have to ask you to not clap for anybody um so thank you for understanding okay go ahead young man hello my name is Hunter Drake I was not prepared for this so um I just wrote down some ideas um so I mean we're called the board of education for a reason education so idea is just an addition to it it challenges
019us and it makes School more unique cuz it's not like any other school district have this um and to increase the budget for it we could like transfer some stuff from that lunch company because we could just we I mean we can just pack our own lunches like it's not that hard um and I think I recommend idea like math also that way there's more of a variety and yeah I was not prepared as I said thank you very much hi my name is Christina budau and I live at for Kona Road my son Andy who is currently a senior at DHS had the great Fortune of participating in the idea program from fourth to 9th grade and it frankly came at a moment in his life when he really was strugg struggling in school
020in third grade he devoured information and was consumed by the why of things he made connections and Drew inferences from what the teacher spoke about in the classroom to books that he'd read or conversations he'd had and he wanted to dig deeper he would ask questions that his teacher did not see coming he was probably her biggest nightmare in many ways many of the other kids didn't quite dig his questions or his thirst for knowledge either he left school often feeling left down by his time there then came the call from admin ation that he'd been flagged by his olat scores as a potentially gifted learner and would we be interested in pursuing further testing the shift was so immediate for him when he started idea in fourth grade in idea class they dove into
021deep critical thinking they practiced the Socratic method of engaging in dialogue and debate they learn Civility and how to be flexible and support each other which can be quite challenging for this cohort of students who are used to having the right answers and many times tend to be inflexible in their thinking they learned to open themselves up to other approaches and approaches and philosophical thoughts all of a sudden those questions that would get eye rolles were his strengths it gave him a space where he could push himself where he could learn from watching others do the same and all of this was possible because of the care and nuanced expertise of the idea teachers who are in my opinion the biggest strength of this program their experience guiding this special group of students with varying
022unmet needs is a gift to the students and their families this group of teachers get to know and work with these students consistently for years and remain connected to many of them well beyond their high school years as a past co-president of daeg I have been helping to provide historical perspective and support for our advocacy efforts and so today I read through the speaker notes of the idea presentation that was prepared for tonight's meeting I was struck by the way it simplified the role of the current idea teachers as being perhaps inadequate compared to other teachers who had master's degree and as out of touch with the school building communities they serve when they were in fact instrumental to providing a space where their students felt connected to school in a positive way I was
023frankly insulted for them I have witnessed them working harder with less and less I know that I speak for the vast majority of idea families who are grateful for the measurable impact these gifted teachers have made to our children's education thanks to their unparalleled experience and wealth of knowledge in the field of gift education I urge you all to find a way to keep this idea program intact and to offer your support to these teach teachers who have nurtured the gifts and talents of an impressive number of students throughout their time in Daran schools thank you uh good evening my name is Andy budo I'm the sunning question I'm a senior at Darian High School currently and a graduate of the idea program uh my mom just highlighted a bunch of the ways that the
024idea program was very impactful for me I'd like to add just a couple quick thoughts um the proposed inclusive model of the idea program exhibits several gross misunderstandings of the program's purpose and structure you propose that classroom teachers be responsible for juggling the needs of the class as a whole and individual gifted kids from a student perspective I struggle to see where you think that the teachers are going to get all that time in my years in the school district I cannot think of moments in which they would have had that opportunity the two most likely outcomes that I see for this change are as follows one teachers don't have the time to give individual attention to idea students and therefore the students do not receive the enrichment the program promises or two burdened by
025a lack of time teachers sacrifice aspects of classroom learning in order to give disproportionate attention to idea students this change feels poorly thought out and downright unfair it's unfair to the classroom teachers who would have who would be bestowed with an unrealistic burden it's unfair to the idea teachers that would be let go from a program that they largely created it's unfair to the general students who would need to sacrific their own learning time so that teachers could give attention to idea students and it's unfair to the idea students themselves placed in the middle of a flawed system that doesn't provide the learning opportunities it promises the only thing that would benefit from this change is the budget I'm of course limited by my time in the public comment and would like to keep things
026brief but I must especially give given that I know many of you on the board urge you to reach out to me to parents to teachers we are all more than happy to discuss the subject in depth thank you for your time and for your consideration thank you Lena Bueno Elena so I'm very I'm not going to speak about idea I'm going to speak about inflation since 21 to 23 [Music] we cut the budget in real terms almost $8 million I have said this many times but it doesn't seem like it's enough and 4.1 increase in the budget 4.7 inflation 2022 8% inflation that was a six% caught in the budget in real terms because when you have inflationary environment you speak in real terms not nominal same 2023 in 2024 and now 2025 we're
027barely covering inflation this is creating I mean to put this in in perspective in 20 in 2007 the budget increased 6.8% inflation was 2.9 we had a real increase in the budget of 3.9% that is consistent because it's Norm normally around 4% above inflation which is long-term the increase of house prices in America over 100 Year data now after the Great Recession that number went down to 1% over the inflation over inflation because prices of homes were not going up so high so fast and well it was a difficult time but in 2021 the prices went up 177% it I mean 22 prices of homes have gone up it is time we catch up with what we left behind the 1% of the last decade above inflation was just an emergency situation and now we
028are actually below inflation levels and we have a whole and I give you a scenario too if we had increase 1% of over inflation in the in those three the last years we will need $ 10 million to catch up if we keep on postponing it the number is going to go up scenario three if we thought about the 4% above inflation we would need $20 million to catch up and so the size of the whole is $20 million if we wanted to catch up to underfunding the schools for a decade we have a $40 million hole so we cannot afford 4% four four something perent increases in the budget anymore we just cannot we have to go back at the minimum to the budget we were talking about in December over 6% increase to
029start catching up with that hole that was created in between 01 and 23 thank you so much uh good evening my name is jeene ragdale for lighthous way I wanted to start by thanking the members of the Board of Education and School administration for all that you do for the daring Community my son a sixth grade idea student and I are against the proposed elimination of the idea program I've recently sent the board some information on the current programs for similar students in Greenwich New Canan and Westport the school is often mentioned by new families as alternatives to Daran grenwich serves the top achieving students through the advanced learning program in elementary school and Advanced English advanced math and advanced science courses in Middle School in New Kanan Elementary School students are scheduled for challenge
030classes in a pullout program or during Home Room Workshop in Middle School challenge classes take the place of social studies classes becoming part of the daily schedule in Westport each of the elementary school and middle schools have an on-site Workshop teacher Workshop students in grades 3 through 8 are pulled out of their regular classes to receive specialized instruction in the workshop classroom in addition the workshop teachers collaborate and co- te in the regular classroom across the grades please also remember that in 2021 the the Darian Board of Education requested an evaluation of the district's gifted education programming as a result Teresa Wrangle was selected to lead the evaluation by the superintendent using objective data collection analysis and Reporting conditions and charged with identifying program highlights and considerations for improvement the executive summary consideration for imp
031Improvement included revise the middle school schedule to accommodate full periods of gifted education learning opportunities increase time elementary students receive services from teachers of the gifted provide opportunities to accelerate instruction in elementary schools in the area of mathematics I'm interested to know how we have used this data to inform the current proposal Darian schools should support all Learners to reach their academic potential and designing instruction to address students individual learning needs is included as action in the students strategic plan school's Str strategic plan would professional learning as well as co- teers like Westport be needed to achieve this differentiate learning wouldn't we have professional learning completed and implemented before to to educate these Learners before proposing the elimination of the program I am support of maintaining the idea program however if it comes down to
032budgeting needs could the idea children in um Middle School be scheduled in the same social studies class but please remember the current school year budget has has 1.6 full-time employees supporting 15% of the Middle School population 160 Middle School idea students would in supporting these students at the elementary and middle school level help ensure their continued success in advanced placement classes and testing in high school which is a large component of the criteria for daring School District ranking in mese and US News and world rankings let's please continue with a history of supporting academic Excellence to ensure people continue to choose Daran thank you advance for your consideration and time thank you hello my name is Olivia Chen and I'm midx middle school and I'm in eighth grade I've been idea for five years I'm
033here to offer viewpoints on my experience and Idea Idea teachers have plenty of experience decades upon Decades of teaching kids and guiding them into advanced subjects they teach they teach different units such as Finance philosophy and debate which we don't get to experience until high school I'm sorry I'm not very well prepared that's okay these units have had no previous buildup and are completely new to us unlike subjects such as math science and social studies for example math I'm in course 4 geometry and I've had opportunities to build my knowledge in something as basic as Elementary School math however an idea we have had no previous experience with philosophy learning from great models such as Socrates and Alexander the Great has helped us to learn and grow beyond what normal courses can teach us idea
034the idea class teaches us what independent study cannot because we argue and debate with like-minded peers who question our own personal values and ideas core beliefs that we have harbored from something as early as Elementary School can be argued with with other peers in my classroom the idea teachers who have plenty of experience are there to guide us and to Foster our education and to make sure our arguments Thrive many I talked with many peers and they agree that we should not we should not seek alternatives for the current idea program and the current course because this is something that has had 50 plus years of success 50 plus years alone is enough to prove that this Success is Not Just based off of theory or hypothesis this is something that can be found in
035data charts in facts in stat in statistics these idea teachers have been here for decades such as Mrs Mata Mrs Martin Mrs Aaron these teachers have helped us find important websites that could further help us in debates in high school and in college thank you for your time thank you for your time hi my name is Kate halby 103 Steven Ma and I'm a graduate of Darian public school system at large and of the idea program and I loved my time here so I'm grateful to all of you for continuing to provide great educ ations to these kids who are so fun to hear from um I remember idea very fondly as you're not going to be surprised to hear it was a buoy to my education from first grade to nth grade and it
036provided this Common Thread we we were going into a small group with other kids that we knew well with a teacher that we were getting to know and it was a diversity of experience to the rest of our classroom time so that is really why I think it's worth it because it's different and therefore gives students a environment in which to flourish if they're not feeling like their traditional classroom is the perfect place for them at that moment I remember it being very creative we did things like build the ru Goldberg machine we took word Masters tests which I loved as an unabashed nerd at the time and maybe now and we just get this list of challenging words and memorize them and then take a test that was based on analogies so it's different
037from a traditional definitions test and I credit my of words to this day to those tests I remember them all the time um I wouldn't normally say this because it's not a very comfortable thing to share um it sounds like bragging but I'll tell you about my educational story after Daren high school because it's relevant to what we're all trying to achieve here um I got into Yale and I graduated in history with honors I've worked in finan for 5 years since and now I'm applying to medical school and I attribute all of that to the teachers I had growing up all of whom cared about me and were kind I truly did not have a bad teacher my entire time through the Daran Public School System I'm grateful to that and idea was a
038big part of it it was a memorable piece it was a positive place for us to learn in and I think that it is worth continuing it in the budget Thank you very much thank you for your time hello everyone my name is Julie Stokley Hussein and I live on larden road um thank you everyone on the board for listening to our comments I hope that I can provide you with a slightly different perspective on why you should consider keeping the idea program this past June my family relocated to darianne from Atlanta specifically choosing this community for its exceptional educational opportunity with the idea program being a decisive factor in our decision to move here Scarsdale middle school for example does not have a gifted a talented program my daughter in sixth grade has just
039been accepted into the idea program following comprehensive psycho psychoeducational testing which explicitly recommended Advanced programming to maintain her engagement in academic growth her psychologist said given that your daughter's IQ is exceptionally High frankly there is no school out there that would give her what she needs instead you have to look at schools that can accommodate her best schools with gifted and talented programs so I speak not only as a concerned parent but also from personal experience as a student who benefited from gifted education in Texas as the child of an immigrant single mother the gifted program I attended in elementary middle school and high school provided intellectual challenges that were otherwise unavailable to me at school or at home this Early Educational intervention Pro proved transformative ultimately leading to my acceptance also to yell University
040and opening doors that fundamentally altered the trajectory of my life to eliminate the idea program would not only impact my daughter and other current students but would also diminish one of the one of darian's key educational assets the idea program represents an investment in developing our students full potential a mission that aligns perfectly with daran's commitment to educational Excellence so with that I respectfully request the board carefully consider the long-term implications of this decision and preserve the idea program for current and Stu and future students thank you thank you good evening my name is Whitney McCarthy and I reside um on Mortimer Street in New Kanan I teach kindergarten at Henley School on behalf of the three kindergarten teachers at Henley School with 22 students in each class we strongly recommend that darianne keeps the
041instructional AIDS at work in elementary schools it is crucial that in grades K to2 teachers have a consistent knowledgeable person to assist in our classrooms I have an experienced instructional Aid who works with the students in my class every day in our kindergarten classrooms instructional AIDS are critical to the success of students their caring support and instruction is a determining factor in student growth the curriculum expectations for five and six-year-old students in our rooms are rigorous without the consisten support of an instructional Aid there would be fewer additional activities that I could provide in my room currently when I'm teaching reading to small groups our Aid circulates around the room and supports students during phonic work providing immediate feedback she works with small groups writing letters using kinesthetic learning strategies reads with individual students and
042plays phonics games with small groups in math she may support a few students on numeral formation others with accurate Counting strategies provide challenges to extend the curriculum and move through the entire class to support them during whole group instruction in kindergarten we have a wide range of student abilities and skill levels from not knowing any letters or numbers to reading chapter books they all come in our classroom that first day and in order to Foster student engagement and growth we differentiate instruction every day experienced instructional AIDS make that a reality my Aid and and I work together to identify areas for growth this collaboration makes a superior experience for students her academic support of students definitely promotes student development and achievement in the future a class of 22 students with no instructional Aid would have
043a very different experience there would be less student support fewer times when a student would have immediate feedback and far fewer unique learning experiences the instructional AIDS are a critical part of the academic experience of K2 students please reconsider this budget reduction thank you thank you hello uh Brian Reed one Lighthouse Way um I am a product of the gifted and talented program but not in the state and uh one of the worst districts in my state um I had a cohort that was always together taking every single class together through elementary and middle school and if I did not have that gifted and talented program I would not be standing here today and I would not have the opportunities here today uh many other districts have done this experiment at San Francisco New York
044City DeBlasio in 2021 uh the Seattle has done this and every single one afterwards chaos has has right right light private schools uh there's been a diminishing uh Talent at the top level like the Top Line uh scores have gone down and I've looked at ad Le your and first of all i' would like I very much appreciate by the way the board's handling the situation and this controversy right that's been brought up especially you madam chairwoman have done a great job so I've I've reviewed adley's proposal for the inclusive and it seems to be missing specificity right there's no um what are the outcomes that are desired now there's no curriculum there's no what are your academic standards and you're missing the biggest part of it is the cohort is not being kept together
045so that they can push themselves and then they can become better right um reviewing how this happened it this is a political idea of killing this it's a idea that is ideologically from the inclusive statement there's reports that it just came up in the original Dei report in May of 2023 in the draft and whether it is or it is not that is how how the world is going to look at it when you make your decision here right this is um doing the research that's where it's led me I asked the board to please consider where you're going to vote you're determining whether or not we value academic Excellence over say uh ideology as we're going forward and that is how it's going to be viewed to the outside world and this will reach
046national news if we do kill the idea program instead of killing it we should expand it right we should expand it to have more of the cohorts together we should look at other Alternatives and my family will be fine but I want the best for that thank you hello my name is Maggie Russell I'm a resident of two Fox Hill Lane and I graduated from Daran High School in 2022 and was in the idea program from fourth through 9th grade right now I'm a Premed Junior at y University and I actually left my classes early today and got on a train to come here because I felt that talking about idea was very very important one of the skills idea taught me was to do my research which is exactly what I've done tonight to
047prepare for speaking where I looked at the recommended models for gifted education that would be replacing idea I noticed that one of the first perceived benefits of these new models was that they would meet legislative requirements and I think this points out one of the main issues with these new models which is that they're focused on meeting state requirements rather than the needs of gifted students in particular I took the liberty of looking up the National Association of gifted children's gifted programming standards that was also listed and described how we need extensive specialized staff and I feel that these new models will not adequately do that I think putting the burden on library media staff and classroom teachers is unrealistic and will not provide the most comprehensive and challenging education that gifted students need in
048order to thrive I think what was also interesting is how the proposed model talks about the myths about gifted students I think unfortunately in both of these models they promote a certain myth about gifted students which is almost that they are small adults able to do independent projects design their own curriculum and do things without as much guidance from Educators when in reality they need lessons they need complex challenging material that might not necessarily need to just come from them but other Educators as well which is where I think the idea program is really incredible you have Educators that present new topics you're not learning in class where you might be bored during the day and IDE is that time for excitement to learn something new and to really discover your inner joy and C
049osity and love for school in my own experience idea has allowed me to thrive in an academic and personal setting idea helped grow my curiosity even when opportunities seemed new or overwhelming because of this curiosity I've gotten to do some amazing experiences in high school and college such as working for an archaeologist in East Africa studying traditional medicine in Northern India and it's because of these experiences they all stem back to idea and really loving learning and challeng chenging myself but idea also taught me how to overcome struggles and a lot of my peers in college are struggling for the first time because they weren't adequately challenged in elementary school in middle school and when they face these challenges in college it's really difficult for them because they've never actually had the skill set that
050programs like idea give them to understand what it means to struggle and how to overcome it I myself have struggled in college and because of idea I've been had and given the tools to really succeed and Thrive thank you for your time thank you for your time my name is Ryan and I live at 14 Harbor in fourth grade at Henley and idea has changed my whole education before idea I didn't really have a challenge in school so I school was really easier for me and more Bor ever since idea started I've learned things I haven't learned before and new meanings of words idea has really helped me study more things like practice study instead of like just not doing it not really practicing anything you have to practice word Masters to if you actually
051want to succeed it also helps me work with people better I do not have good people spills but in idea my people skills have gotten stronger idea is also a safe and supporting place if you take away idea you will be taking away a whole child's life or maybe a few please don't take a idea because it's a safe place we all enjoy thank you for your time thank you Ryan hello I'm Emily Sable and I live at 309 Hol tree Ridge Road um hello I'm Clara hter and I live at 25 Outlook Drive hello I am Theo hutter and I also love a 25 Outlook drive we are all part of the idea program putting the idea program would be a huge mistake if ideas cut us in 234 other students will not have
052adequate support it would be very difficult for teachers in regular classes to provide resources similar to the ones offered in idea and idea students would not be challenged enough idea allows students to reach their full potential additionally there are 3.3 full-time teachers if idea is cut or even modified they might lose their jobs this would sadden the entire Community to persuade you I started a petition to try and save idea with Clara and Theo's help we now have 2011 signatur in the past week this presented budget has sparked many debates over whether or not ideas should remain in the school system primarily almost all Daran resents argue that you should not eliminate idea on the front page of the Darion Public School website idea is listed as one of the amenities for the school system
053cutting idea would send the message that Darion doesn't care about academics and would therefore Drive New families away currently the school system which is ranked as the number one school system in Connecticut is Newan Public Schools not far behind is Westport Public Schools and both school districts have a gifted and talented program the mission of the Daren Public Schools is to work cooperatively with the families and the community to provide for its students safe supportive respectful and intellectually challenging learning environment that promotes EXC uh personal Excellence through active Co collaborative and creative thinking that stimulates individual development of skills necessary to become productive members of society that mission is practically a description of idea and cutting it would go against the mission of the Darren public schools and the education of philosophy the family's reaction
054to this proposal are negative and they may even decide to move away due to the removal of idea these are families with gifted children who would generally score well on the SATs this would ultimately result in a decrease in SAT scores we also have a letter of persuasion directed to the Board of Education from Janet scandin at the the sasco River Center she is a 20-year resident of Daran the sasco River Center provides help with Psychotherapy behavioral support sensory processing evaluations for gifted programs and more they firmly believe that ideas should not be cut and as they specialist in child psychology they know it is best for the students we can give you the letter after the meeting if you would like the idea program is only 0.39 of the Darren public school's $125 million
055budget while we realize that 0.39% of a large budget isn't a small amount as it is $469,000 we do believe that it's not worth cutting this is a decision which will affect many children in grades 239 negatively this in mind we urge you not to cut idea thank you thank you hello my name is Katherine Cunningham I am a current resident of Daran and much like um Kate a former graduate well current graduate former attendee of the Daran public school system I see my friend Liam on there who was also a part of um U who was also a part of idea with me back in school now you might notice that my hair is wet because I found out AIT about this shortly after jumping out of of the shower approximately I don't know
056what time it is but probably about two and a half hours ago so unlike some of my other Daran residents I will be slightly less prepared but what I am passing around to you right now is a photo taken of a poster that is still in my basement that I completed in fourth grade the text is kind of small so you might not be able to read it but what it is is it is a poster on President John Adams it has inside of one of the pockets a five-page analysis on whether or not he was a good president my conclusion is that he wasn't but that's what the idea program does it encourages you to take a look at topics as a child that you would not have otherwise explored I challenge you to
057find a fourth grader who is more knowledgeable about the Alien and Sedition Acts than I was and for me idea was I heard one of the kids say it earlier a safe space so we've heard about all of the reasons why you shouldn't cut idea but why are you considering cutting idea well because it is a group of kids who are incredibly bright a subset of students who you assume will be able to still succeed and thrive in a classroom with normal support and I'm here to tell you that that is not the case I for example was a child with undiagnosed ADHD what that meant is that as an incredibly bright student with ADHD I was able to survive but I was not thriving because nothing in class that I was learning was stimulating
058my intellectual curiosity and in fact it even led me to be bullied by my fifth grade teacher so I challenge you to think about whether or not putting this to the teachers is The Right Move specifically in my case what that manifested as was me being was my teacher refusing to call on me even when my hand was the only one up in the room was him consistently asking me to repeat what he said the last three to four sentences because of my inattention something that I could not control and did not understand idea gave me a space where I for the first time figured out that school didn't have to be some sort of tooth pulling hair pulling experience thank you for your time thank you good evening my name is Chris halby and
059uh we live at 103 Steven ma Road my spouse is carollyn langelier and she's sitting there with Kate um the Daran Public Schools were where we educated our two two daughters from K through the end of high school they were fabulous thank you all uh I want to say that idea was a very important part of our two daughters education idea rounds out the public schools we believe that idea provides an educational boost to those who are academically motivated and who want to learn more it helps students with problem solving it helps students with analogies it helps students with vocabulary also as you heard from quite a number of people it validates students who may not fit in elsewhere it's not always cool to be academically motivated and idea is a great space to get
060that validation idea helps students achieve higher SAT and ACT scores that is a great boost this town as we all know attracts residents by the quality of our schools that quality is enhanced by broadening our offerings we need we all benefit rather from educating High Achievers these are the people who go on to be entrepreneurs or doctors or researchers and as we all know it's not to our Town's benefit to discourage highly academic students or to incentivize them to go elsewhere I believe that academically motivated students help stand help ele at the standards and help motivate other kids they may not be in the idea program but the kids who are an idea may set an example in the classroom which is infectious thank you so much for listening to all of us thank you
061Carrie vaka 14 Harbor Road I'm also MPA co-chair at MMS but I'm speaking as an individual citizen tonight and not in that capacity uh my daughter spoke earlier and I will tell you I didn't know she was going to do that and I think that speaks a lot to what these kids bring to the table uh and the importance um so hopefully everyone's listening to them I come tonight to beg that you leave the idea program in its current form as a pull out for our elementary students specifically I implore you to retain the teachers with deep experience and gifted learning in this District the alternative to idea proposed for review tonight is not a plan it is as if you've proposed a crosswalk across I95 it is physically possible to paint a crosswalk on
062that road sure but it's not going to actually get any kids to where they need to go this crosswalk eliminated much of what makes idea in its current form successful for many of our gifted Learners I argue it is precisely the cohorting the pull out the specialized teachers and enhanced curriculum that make the program valuable these are the elements that make a difference to gifted children's learning and to their mental health these children are often Divergent thinkers um they may also have second exceptionalities like autism or ADHD and are not best served exclusively in an inclusive classroom It is Well documented that gifted children often exhibit higher social emotional intensity and experience the world differently than neurotypical peers this is a source of strength and that it breeds creativity and passion for learning but it
063is also fragile without the development of a safe cohort some of these same kids can be vulnerable to bullying social isolation and depression the elementary schools are where you set the foundation for learning it is precisely at that level we should be investing in not only identifying but resourcing our kids with what they need to succeed all kids not just those in the middle 95% or those protected with IEPs and 504s your gifted Learners in this community deserve better darianne the world is watching an admissions officer at one of the local Independent Schools told me this morning that they have had an influx in inquiries not only from Daran parents but also from parents in other districts in the durg with gifted children who are watching these discussions carefully worried about their own gifted programs
064yes we are a leader and the world is watching the question is in which direction will you take us thank you thank you Courtney paray five Lillian Terrace I am a mother of a sixth grade girl at MMS and a freshman boy at DHS I am also a former special at perah from token and a proud cheerleader of every child in this town I am deeply concerned about the state of our district the impact these proposed Cuts will have on our children our Educators and our community over the years we have seen positions eliminated while the demands on the remaining staff members in our schools continue to grow it's time we remove the rosec colored glasses and take a hard honest look at what's happening teachers par professionals support support staff and school administrators are
065being stretched to their limits while no no one has ever claimed that working in schools is easy it does need to be sustainable as a baseball and softball Mom I'd like to use a sports analogy to illustrate my point back in 1857 the rules of baseball were established with nine players on the field each position critical to the success of the team now imagine this our schools are facing a substitute shortage so General ad Paras are being pulled to cover classrooms this is like moving the short stop to replace an injured first baseman when that happens the second and third baseman have to over overcompensate the outfielders are stretched thinner and plays the team has practiced countless times fall apart deep hits get missed double plays vanish and morale plummets the team can no longer
066perform at its best and they lose the game now let's take a look at the proposed budget the suggestion to remove 15 General Ed parents from elementary schools and replace them with 10 student interns is like saying we don't need a short stop anymore oh they're just filling in anyway instead we'll bring in rookies to fill those gaps meanwhile the expectation that our team wins remain the same fewer less experienced players but no reduction in the demands or the states and while we're at it let's eliminate the right fielder the idea teachers because after all the ball doesn't go there as often now the first baseman second baseman and center fielder will have to cover those plays while maintaining their own Superior performance in a winning team you don't eliminate positions because they're too costly
067instead you assess how each role contributes to the team's success if someone isn't being utilized effectively you adjust their training and practice regimen you develop your players give them the resources they need to succeed and create a program where they can Thrive that's how you win game after game I know this because I was part of the team I've resigned in December because the balls were coming at me harder and faster and I didn't have the support and training this is not sustainable and it is not fair to our staff or to our students thank you for your time hi good evening Mia Kim from five leads Lane um hope everyone's doing well and thank you so much for your time and your service to this town um you've heard from impassion constituents from alumni
068who are our best and brightest here in darianne um I wanted to speak specifically in regards the idea program as to why the crosswalk that's described in the meeting materials um is not adequate um and why I think it would fail um uh specifically I was reading an article from the for Institute which what which I plan to uh forward to the board of ed as well as Dr adley it's from November of 2024 and specifically addresses these types of strategies that public schools have tried to um also undertake when eliminating their idea or gifted and talented programs and I think a couple of really important feedback and comments and observations from the article are that number one um the research doesn't support the alternative to Advanced education programs like we have here in idea
069in fact every single time um that schools have tried to to do this um the the high quality research has shown that this sort of heterogeneous differentiation never works in fact it always fails so certainly if we as a town attempt to do this we won't be the first one that will fail um and we won't be the first one to attempt it as well um so I just ask that we continue to look at other strategies or to keep the program as it is intact um secondly the article goes on to say that with training um as also o proposed in the crosswalk um it's also never um successful 80% of teachers nationally in surveys have also said that these types of training programs are never effective teachers today are just overwhelmed with especially
070at the elementary school level trying to address different gaps and Remediation across different types of Developmental um stages in children so to further ask them to differentiate the education the classroom is not only going to fail but you're going to have poor outcomes for your students your your students who are neurodiverse who are gifted are actually going to have far worse outcomes because they don't have the opportunity to have um the type of stimulation and like-minded peers that allow them to to further succeed um also with the crosswalk my final point is that you know one of the things I had concerns with was how students who are marginalized those who are twice exceptional those who aren't able to necessarily vocally advocate for themselves in the classroom but who are gifted are going to be
071left behind and so I hope that today I can provide voice for those students as well um I just want to finally add that in order for us to remain competitive with districts as mentioned before like new Kanan Greenwich which is known as a National Authority on gifted education we need to continue to maintain our gifted education for our students otherwise if we dis if we disregard our program and eliminate It We join other districts like Bridgeport and hamen who have also um eliminated their idea program thank you thank you good evening and thank you for the chance to speak my name is Melanie Duca and I live on Old Kings Highway in Wilton I'm an instructional parah at token last year when I came to speak with you I explained to the board some
072of the roles instructional appas Play From my experience this year I hope that the board can see the value of our jobs and the direct impact our absence would have on both students and staff the proposed budget illustrates where the district is willing to spend money and it is my hope that you will continue to in invest in your par of professional staff members no matter how important new sidewalks or Windows lawnmowers and floor cleaning machines and updated vehicles are I think that we can all agree that students social and emotional needs are of greatest importance after reading the budget I thought there must be a better way to trim costs than cutting trained District employees who work directly with students and staff our value lies in our flexibility and our dedication to our jobs
073DPS Paras must be flexible as each day is often different from the one before as we move from grade to grade in class to class with guidance from Educators we help students of all learning abilities in large and small groups with their work and we also cover classrooms when teachers need to attend various meetings we are dedicated to the children and their families who are learning and building their lives here I thought there must be a better way to trim cost than cutting employees whose job is to work directly with teachers we follow up with students using their accommodations so that students are successful i al also thought about the years of DPS staff development training most Paris slated to be cut have received and about how we practice various emergency procedures to help keep
074students safe and calm we know and respect the district curriculum and our talented educ ators there must be a better way to trim the budget than replacing GPS Paras with college interns as indicated in the proposed budget their role as Paras or Subs becomes unclear when student interns would be required to complete many weeks of student teaching in a single classroom as part of their college program this would make interns unavailable to support the building that they are interning in intern programs have requirements that college students need to satisfy which could conflict with student or building coverage needs by continuing to invest in DPS trained Paris the Board of Education would show the town that you are willing to provide its youngest citizens with dedicated DPS support staff you would also be showing the pair
075of professionals that you employ that you value our service many of the Paris slated to be cut have been loyal employees for 10 or 20 plus years I now wonder if the district I so proudly serve is willing to invest in Paris as valuable members of the school Community I hope with all my heart that you will reconsider cutting instructional Paras because we are one part of an important structure built around our young people and I ask that you not take that away thank you thank you Barry Palmer Daran Education Association darianne can afford to meet the needs of our gifted Learners Daran can afford to to keep instructional AIDS in the classroom making sure we meet the needs of our youngest Learners and if we're pulling instructional AIDS too often to sub for other
076teachers we can afford to hire more building subs and more interns as well and keep our instructional AIDS I'm struck by the fact that we just passed a budget on May 28th and Dr adley made it pretty clear that any further cuts to the budget you pass on May 28th would do irreparable harm to the district based on the parent feedback and the staff feedback that I've gotten I with that assessment so what's changed since May 28th um if the gifted and talented folks are successful in in getting their program back into the budget I hope you guys stay engaged because the last couple years the conversations around the sport table have been what's the least bad option to take away from our students Daren can afford to not have that conversation thank you Beth
077Lan 16 Hill Crest Avenue and I'm going to talk about part of the budget nobody has discussed yet which is the athletic budget yes I am back to talk about the athletic budget like I do a couple of times every year saying please make it more fair please make it more Equitable and instead this budget seems to be taking it in a rather different direction so that we're isolating nonc exports and taxing the parents who of those players extra can we please just rip the Band-Aid off and just have a participation fee for all Athletics and it would just make life so much easier and we could stop having this stupid conversation thank you anybody else in person I will now move to online how many hands do we have up online nine okay well
078just take a moment I'm not going to cut anyone off but I'll just take a moment to remind everyone that if if you have something unique to say please say it but if someone has already spoken or you've spoken at a previous um time we still have an entire board meeting to get to um so again we value your engagement but please also consider um adding to the conversation thank you for those online I will recognize you please engage your camera when possible and note that you all up to three minutes to comment Miss Dana holders you've been recognized and unmuted my name is Dana hogerson I'm an instructional Aid at Royal I have been in the Darian district for about 20 years I feel my job is significant because I put my heart into
079getting to know these children's strengths and weaknesses and help them become independently successful students my role as an instructional Aid is we all work together as a team we fill in for each other when things get really busy if I'm done assisting a teacher I go to another to help out in the classroom we lend a hand wherever we see the need thank you for your time thank you Miss Kiara who you've been recognized and unmuted please note that you have up to three minutes to comment and please state your name and address for the record hi I'm Shara who um 22.0 Woods Road South I am a fifth grade student at Oxbridge elementary school and I am in the idea program growing up in the idea Community I have attended idea ever since the
080second grade I have not only learned but I have grown as a student and as a person so I'm speaking today to protest against the possible elimination of the idea of the idea program in my classroom what really makes it frustrating is when I would raise my hand I would keep my hand raised and no one would call on not even when no one else was raising their hand not to criticize my teachers but this has not just happened once this isn't just a small problem this is a pattern one that has occurred multiple times in my learning career I deal is a program that has taught me and others like me giving us each giving each of us the same attention to help us grow I remember second grade idea very well the topic
081was ancient civilizations and I had learned that the first ever civilization were the Sumerians I even learned the Mesopotamian language I made a board we learned about ancient Egyptians and created our own canopic jars we learned about the Phoenicians and used natural dyes to create the purple dye they had used see that's the special thing about idea it isn't just an extra class it's an opportunity for gifted students like me to engage and learn in fourth grade idea we had learned about engineering and inventions each and every one of us created a unique invention for example I created the Stringer to solve the problem of feeding and overfeeding my cats we made chain reactions happen and created memories I won't ever forget idea teaches us a wide variety of knowledges knowledge and lets us express
082ourselves and be creative with it and if you have realized nowadays children's children don't exactly talk like they used to Studies have shown that the children's vocabulary knowledge is significantly lower than it was before and that's why we have word Masters in idea I not only learn about history and Engineering but I also learn new words and that challenge me I remember when I had gotten 20 out of 20 on my word Master Test that feeling of joy and pride was priceless because I had worked for it and that's what idea does to you it challenges you makes you work for it and helps you succeed so don't take away this wonderful opportunity for us students to grow don't take away idea thank you thank you student okay uh we we'll back to the room
083let's finish online please all right Mr Michael Kennedy you've been recognized and unmuted hi my name is Michael Kennedy I live at nine Royal Road and uh I wanted to thank you for allowing comment we have lived in Daran for 22 years and have had three children go through the public school system I would like in particular to highlight our son Aiden who is now 19 years old and a uh alumni of the idea program he is currently studying biology at the University of Vermont with the goal of becoming a medical doctor he is minoring in astronomy and chemistry and has a passion for science in major part and direct result due to the inspiration and positive intervention of the idea program he has in fact bonded with other youth at UVM who are gifted
084students former gifted students they seem to recognize each other there's an undeniable community I would like particularly to recognize the Excellence guidance and attention of Andrea Aon as his idea instructor who pushed him to Aspire to achieve and think outside the box during The crucial formative years in elementary school without early intervention I can say with great confidence his outcome would not have been the same Aiden was a child in elementary school who was allowed to go to idea during lunch it was a place he felt safe and accepted before joining idea Aiden was a student who would finish his own math worksheets and was asked to go around to other groups and help his peers with the town's extensive Arts Music Theater special ed and gifted programs the offering of Daran has a full
085spectrum of comprehensive programs without idea it's short on innovation in researching all of the neighboring towns which we Benchmark ourselves to new Kanan grenwich even Norwalk has gifted programs how does Daran compete will they look at Darian as a leader by cutting its gifted program why does Connecticut legally require identification of idea gifted students a program such as this is essential to our future as a nation of innovators and in support of our children as a community within a community thank you thank you Alex Hager you have been recognized and unmuted hi there thank you so much for taking the time to listen to our stories today uh my name is Alex Hager I'm calling today from my home in col colado but I spent every year of my childhood at 321 nen Avenue where
086my parents still live today I am in Alum of Ox Ridge and middle sex and I graduated DHS in 2019 I spent seven years in the idea program where I learned a lot I made lifelong friends and more than anything else I discovered the things that lit up my brain and heart when I was at oxridge I was not always a great student I got sent to the principal's office more times than I can count I uh went back and looked at my first grade report card the other day and saw that my teacher called me a quote pleasure and challenge to have in class I am grateful for her I'm grateful for a lot of the teachers I had over the years but a lot of times those were teachers who saw my sometimes
087disruptive behavior they were teachers who saw my laging grades and a lot of those teachers despite their best efforts just did not have the time or the resources to meet me where I needed to be met but idea was different in idea teachers had the time to not only see me for who I was but they had the time the resources and the curriculum to excite me to challenge me to stoke my curiosity I followed that Curiosity to a college degree in journalism I followed that degree to a career today I am a public radio reporter in Colorado where I follow that same curiosity around the West listening learning and producing reports that regularly end up on NPR shows like Morning Edition All Things Considered Marketplace to name a few without the teachers who had
088the time and the lessons plans to Stoke that fire of curiosity I absolutely would not be where I am today there was that kid who brought home rough report cards to his parents that kid who struggled to sit still and there is the adult today who gets to hear his reports on National radio idea is the bridge between them it was a bridge for me all those years ago and it is a bridge today for the kids you're hearing in line without idea they will be left behind the kids who don't test well will get left behind the kids who can't sit still will get left behind it brings me so much joy to see kids speak up for the idea program in front of you today I see myself in them and I see
089Bright Futures ahead of them with the help of idea I am proud to be in Alum of Daran public schools and I am even Proud To Be An Alum of idea when you're making decisions about what programs can stay and what's got to end up on The Cutting Room floor please remember my story and the stories of the kids in front of you who need idea to reach their full potential thank you for your time Liam Russell you've been recognized and unmuted hey folks Liam Russell formerly of two Fox Hill Lane I'm currently a combat Medic in the United States Army and a former idea student now my sister Maggie said it better than I ever could but I'll I'll do my best I've had the opportunity to see a lot of plans with the
090best of intentions fail to be executed because ultimately they were bad plans this idea crosswalk is a bad plan for a number of reasons but uh mainly because it relies on student driven learning now when I got to college I had the opportunity to meet a lot of uh gifted students that when they hit their first challenge in roadblock they crashed and burned and failed because they' never been challenged before and then I joined the army and while I'll be the first to tell you my job is not particularly cognitively demanding there has been a certain level of difficulty be it uh navigating the Woods By Moonlight at Special Forces selection with a map and a compass and 70 pounds on my back or Ranger school where we were planning raids and ambushes working off
091two hours of sleep a night and just enough food to Keep Us Alive or I mean deployment where we were rolling convoys into Syria and I was the only medic so God forbid my boys get hurt or blown up or shot it's on me to keep them alive and while that's not necessarily the same thing as a fourth grader standing in front of their peers and their peers as parents delivering their first ever argumentative essay I think they both require a certain level of skillful preparation and confidence in that preparation to stand undaunted in the face of fear and strive valiantly and now I've had a lot of experiences and a lot of mentors to get me where I am today but idea planted the seeds for that it gave me challenge at a time
092where everything else in my life was easy school was a piece of cake h i I hated going to idea class because it pushed me because I had trained professionals to give me a challenge hard enough to force me to grow but not so hard that I crumbled and broke and if you put the onus on kids to provide the challenge for themselves they're not going to reach the same level when I was a kid I wanted to go home and play video games or like play outside you know I wasn't interested in spending time at school I wasn't going to challenge myself to the best of my ability kids don't want to eat their vegetables you know they're not going to seek out things that make them stronger they're going to take the path
093of least resistance if you let them guide their learning they're going to go easy on themselves and when they hit their first brick wall they're not going to know how to climb they're going to bang their heads against it or Worse they're going to turn around walk away and quit and fail and when they fail that's on you thank you for your time Teresa Forbes you've been recognized and unmuted ma'am you're still muted I think we can hear you now thank you hello yes we can hear you now thank you thank you okay my name is Teresa forbs and I am an instructional Aid at Henley School and a Darian resident residing at 14 Maple Street I have been employed by the Darian board of education for 25 years some years my position was that
094of a special ed Aid and some years as an instructional Aid this year I am an instructional Aid I heard during the recent Board of Ed meeting that it would prove beneficial for the board members to hear the duties of an instructional Aid and I am writing to comply this is what I do 8:15 I am outside at the front curb of the building assisting children out of their cars and keeping traffic moving I do this daily 8:45 I assist one kindergarten teacher with a class size of 22 I do everything with the teacher from morning meeting letter and sound recognition hegerty CBC words reading groups individual reading we work tandem throughout the morning until kindergarten lunch I then have kindergarten lunch duty I go with the children to lunch and assist the two lunch
095monitors if one of the lunch monitors is absent I will stay with the next lunch shift which is first grade and just to knowe instructional AIDS do not have recess d this is a teacher Duty after this I have my own lunch break after my lunch I report to one of our first grade classes to assist the teacher with reading I am here assisting the teacher and reading with the children for one hour I want to point out that when I'm here in the first grade I am not in my kindergarten class assisting with math the kindergarten teacher has no help during this academic time that is a shame and it is not helping the teacher nor the children who could benefit with another Helping Hand next I go back to my kindergarten class for
096writing this is a crucial time where two people should be mandatory in every kindergarten class my last academic spot in the day has changed recently on BNC day I'm now assisting a third grade class with writing on D and E day I assist a second grade class with math and on a and F day I cover the class for either a fourth or fifth grade teacher so that they can have collaborative meeting time with the special ed teacher fortunate for me and more fortunately for the children in these classes they know and respect me as I've gotten to know them through the years and we have developed a mutual Rapport and last but not least at the end of the day I assist with kindergarten and first grade dismissal duty this consists of walking children
097out to their cars for car pickup and walking a line of children who are walking home to a parent Meetup spot and this is done regardless of the weather every day the problem facing darianne is that we can't get substitutes to come in to help with teacher absences we are down to two building Subs which means instructional AIDS will soon be pulled from regular duties to sub we are already asked to cover meetings for teachers during the day when our building Subs are already subbing the addition of two interns will only miss Forbes thank you for your time Charlotte Nichols you've been recognized and unmuted um H hi my name is Charlotte Nicholas and I'm an idea student at middle sex Middle School um I'm in sixth grade and I would like to talk about
098why it's more beneficial to keep idea than to cut it first of all before I joined idea I had a hard time connecting with my peers but when I joined I instantly bonded with all my fellow idea students idea makes me feel like I belong somewhere and that I finally found my group and my pack and or not my pack but makes me feel like I found my group and the people who I belong with idea also encourages me to try my hardest and cutting idea would send the message that our knowledge is not valued lastly or no not lastly idea also idea teaches me an abundance of topics from explorers to inventions to discoveries and history as well ideas students are your future Engineers mathematicians doctors scientists idea nurtures a desire to learn more
099and it helps helps academically Superior students grow and have pride it makes them not be ashamed of their knowledge in a space where idea is or where being smarter is considered uncool um it makes them not ashamed of that it makes them have pride and it proves that stereotype wrong Darian Public Schools is an amazing school district and I think that if we keep idea we can definitely harness our education to the maximum thank you thank you Charlotte ideas student Jane schaer you have been recognized and unmuted Jane we can't hear you hi I'm Jane schaer and I live at 741 holl Tree Road Road and I'm in the fifth grade idea program at oxridge I was astounded when I heard that the idea program was on the proposed cut list idea has helped me
100grow in knowledge and understanding of challenging and complex problems idea has taught me how to plan draft revise and edit and finally publish a proper report packed with information and facts so far we did a report about Rome idea covers intruding topics and build skills that are not taught in the regular classroom next idea gives us a chance to share our love for learning within an encouraging community of students everyone in an idea wants to be there to participate in the class and to learn we work together share ideas and support each other being around similar students makes us challenge each other and work hard to be our best finally our teacher Mrs Aaron is amazing she's she's been trained to teach kids with the thirst for knowledge and knows exactly how to teach she
101plans the lesson carefully and makes sure not a step is left out she makes sure we understand everything and makes us feel welcome in our classroom please do not cut idea it is helped me and other students so much and we hope to continue with this outstanding program that helps us grow to be the best we can be idea should be expanded to give students more of these opportunities absolutely not cut this opinion uh represents not only me but others in my class signed Mas Jane schaer Mason KZ Daniel SOS Dylan relier Elias Wesley Caitlyn cook and Whit mallum thank you Jane Terence bwitch you've been recognized and unmuted hi uh can you hear me yes thank you yeah um no I I'll be brief um I'm an idea parent and um I'll just provide
102a a quick perspective on one that hasn't been articulated at least uh very much tonight and that's the it seems that the financial question is a key angle and you know I wonder if we could reframe how this def decision affects all Daran residents even those that don't have kids in idea and um you know I think that angle is is property values and I think we should we would all be behoove ourselves to reflect on the question what drives the value our of our properties in this town and historically it has been demand uh families move here from elsewhere to our area because they they they see value here and these are smart and datadriven buyers we've heard people who have moved here they do their research they look to our town they see
103an attractive town and what do they see they see lower taxes they see a well-run town attractive offerings including the idea program now what are they going to see what are tomorrow's families going to see when they research um Fairfield County and our peers and I had slides presented but unfortunately I can't do a a slideshow but new Canan you know ChalleNGe Program Westport the gifted Services Program grenwich you know the advanced learning program so I think what are they going to see when when they research Daran in the future and I'll just leave you with leave the with a simple question which is um you know why is it that other tax conscious towns can find the resources to fund similar programs um daran's a town of Builders we're a town of solution finders
104and if our towns can fund a program like this so can we and so I'd ask that you reconsider this proposal and that we continue to fund it and even improve it thank you thank you Jonathan Ford you've been recognized and unmuted thank you um johnan Ford 23 Edgewood Road I like many others I'm concerned about the cuts um I think it's uh you know a big part of why we moved here relatively recently but over the last two years years we've seen you know the support services and programs being chipped away this town has so much to offer and and so much capabilities it's hard to imagine we couldn't be better off using energy to Rally support to accept that we're in a different uh you know Financial spot than we were preco and
105inflation and and use this as an opportunity to to rebase our budget for frankly the modern cost structure I think it's you know important we we accept that and make that change now or what are we going to be cutting next year I mean it it just keeps chipping away at things I think we need to use this as a chance to reverse course thank you very much thank you Rachel you've been unrecognized I you've been recognized and unmuted hi thank you can you hear me we can hear you fine we can perfect thank you um hi this is not Rachel this is her daughter Claire Chan middle sex row thank you for offering me this opportunity to speak tonight I am a High School Junior and I'm also a former idea program member and
106I was an idea throughout my entire time at middle sex I know your heard a lot tonight so I just like to add a little bit from my perspective I've already addressed an email to the board um before that idea of program for me when I was in elementary school I felt like I was always finishing work early to the point where teachers would just give me the dreaded folders of extra math problems to work on because they couldn't take away attention from other students before the idea program I felt like my needs were simply not being met like so many of like my fellow peers and with the idea program with our wonderful idea teachers whom I've had the pleasure of being the student for both in extracurriculars and academic lean School are incredible
107and dedicated to no bounds and with them I felt like my needs my academic needs were being met and I'd really just wish to continue to Echo what has already been said regarding the academic students not just our idea students but everyone's learning and what has been proposed in like the new change for idea program where it'll be moved to everyone's classrooms this will really draw attention away from the students that these uh every every other student all and also the gift to students will not be able to receive the attention that they need this basic learning time and this doesn't allow students to reach their full potential towards academic achievement what I think student potential looks like when it's being met is uh this idea program that's special it's Unique to our town honestly
108when's the last time you saw your kids being excited to do homework and it's not just homework but it's work that wasn't even assigned they just wanted to do this for fun that's um what we did in our idea program me and my classmates spent hours outside of school working on a space settlement in sixth grade just because it was fun and these kids they're just kids they're here to learn and they're at school to focus on that don't take away the program that's fun don't have them worry that this program that they need that they love will be taken away from them please keep idea in daring Public Schools thank you for your time and support thank you we have no more raised hands at this time I think we had one more yeah
109hi um Stella sordoni um middle sex I've been in Middle sex Middle School this is my second year second year in idea as well um people who are an idea um they like to learn and um these people are the kids who are curious and these are the people who are asking questions but like you can be as smart as you want but if you don't have the right res resources you're never going to be able to be um to have the best education education possible and be able to flourish and Thrive as much as possible um um taking away Advanced English um so we decided to take I heard that we're taking away Advanced English and um I noticed that both idea and advanced English are both exclusive um programs and um it got
110me wondering what happens next maybe maybe next year we're thinking about oh getting rid of math 1 two and three next thing we know there's just math class not U math 1 2 and three and it's um when I asked about why we got rid of AP English or no the advanced English in eth grade um I Heard answers like that it doesn't like benefit you as much as um the AP classes in high school would or that the curriculars are pretty similar um the exclusive exclusive and and gifted classes should not be cut because they help us reach our full potential if smart kids don't learn the most they can and um are we really achieving our goal of giving our youth the best education we can give um also shout out to all
111the idea teachers for being all the rockstars they are uh thank you for your time thank you um Alan and Amy just a quick point of information we've had some explicit discussion about uh our curricular plans are there any plans to look at math 1 123 or are we planning to keep that in place I haven't seen that show up but if we could just answer that we have not present to board of curriculum committee there would be a change there okay so there are no plan changes to math just so nobody's worried about it um okay uh um all right with that we'll move on to the superintendent's report um I'd asked while Allen's talking the board to just contemplate it's pretty close to 9:30 we have could potentially um amend the agenda and
112move the budget conversation earlier just a little concerned about getting all the way through our materials or we can um try to just get through the materials and if anything is more extensive we can have a special meeting uh if we need to in between now in the 28th so uh let's go ahead with Alan uh good evening everyone thank you uh to the members of the community and particular to our our students for participating uh this evening thank you uh congratulations to the I'll be quick here 38 band chorus Jazz Ensemble and Orchestra students uh who participated in the 25 Connecticut Western Regional Music Festival uh these are uh students that have been selected uh to participate in the western festival at Wilton High School on January 17th so thank you to them I'd
113also like to thank that Daran music participation associate parent Association for sponsoring the Norwalk Symphony brass quintet um performances at the elementary schools uh this past week uh there was a change as Madam chair uh noted in excess costs I'll speak to that a we bit in the Budget moving forward the increase in educator diversity plan was approved by the state without additional changes uh the Thrive and new survey has gone out to the public i' encourage parents to participate in that survey 6 through 12 uh and also to consider uh your uh children participating in it you may have heard of par School experienced a major uh cyber security breach that is a student information system that is not our student information system uh ours is Aspen that has not been breached and um
114uh even so that we are looking at um uh doing an audit on that and protection uh and other further protections on the Aspen system system uh just a reminder down the line in April the AFS campus out of Darkness walk I encourage many members of the community to participate in that uh there's no school on Friday um as we participate in in staff development uh everything from play paced learning K the3 reading restorative practices uh and curriculum projects are being uh participated in on that Friday and we're inclosed January uh 20th in honor of Martin Luther King holiday just noting the finance committee Mee is on this Thursday uh the 16th and the board of uh sorry the policy committee is meeting on January 21st thank you okay uh why don't you go Ryan
115and then I'll ask the board student representative reports yeah as Dr adley said uh congratulations to all the students in the Jazz Ensemble Orchestra among the other groups who were selected to play at Wilton I'll keep it brief we're nearing the midpoint of the year and with that our students have their midterm so hoping the best for the midterms that they've already taken as well as the ones in the near future and our boys basketball team played earlier tonight so check up on them later hopefully they had a big win today thank you and Brianna is under the weather I believe yeah yeah she has a fever right now best okay um so I do you want to just continue to go through the agenda at the normal course and then um yes go ahead
116Dave I would just throw out as a recommendation to agenda items uh eight BC through there excuse me A and B the pro fora stuff and then I think we're looking at special meeting for see through the rest yeah I think that's possible just I mean those are on for Action sorry could you repeat that yeah I was just think items uh we conclude this evening at 8B which are pretty proor and then maybe the rest are actually to take up a couple of these are on for Action I think we be discussion around that they rather difficult to move most of those I don't know if there's appetite to hear on the personal mobile device use I know that's also a big interest of parents maybe veteran people can do that fresh keep okay
117are people available Thursday night maybe so we can get it done pretty quickly no okay I mean this is a problem we have it 90 minutes of yeah public comment um and I'm leaving at 10:30 this evening Mrs Dunn and Mr McGuire here I'm wondering if we do if we do the personal device and then and then see where we are yeah okay so let's get through personal device and and take a a check on where we are okay um we certainly understand the community is highly invested in the full contents of the meeting but we don't want to Short change anything okay so let's move to approval of the minutes we have a motion to approve the minutes of the regular meeting held on December 10th 2024 minutes of the special meeting held on
118January 2nd 2025 and minutes of the regular meeting held January 4th 2025 Dave seconded by Greg all those in favor that is unanimous okay board committee reports I think we've had a lot of meetings Sarah the curriculum committee met um last Thursday K to3 literacy and language our topics I will keep it brief and just say our next ones at on February 5th okay finances on Thursday as you noted earlier Allen y okay and uh Dennis I don't think you've had anything new and policies yet to me okay all right let's move on to discussion and possible acceptance of the contemplated gift for the athletic department Chris good evening everyone I'll be brief uh you have two contemplative gift forms there in front of you for consideration uh both in BL booster club first is
119for sideline jackets for girls cross team they're working on about 10 years old the current ones and they're in need of new ones uh the second gift is for two AED machines to be placed uh at middle SE Middle School one of the upper field one of the lower field this will be a similar um gift that you had seen last um last year uh for placement at the high school um these will be place at the middle school Fields okay we're super excited about these yes Dave at Le the 80s okay so I'll I'll are there any questions all right with that I'll take may have a motion to accept the contemplated gift for the Daran High School girls varsity lacrosse program that is Dennis seconded by Dave all those in favor that is
120unanimous and then may I have a motion to accept the contemplated gift for the middle school which is the ads uh that is Joanna seconded by Greg all those in favor that is unanimous thank you very much thank you Chris hey thank you everybody okay update on DHS advisory Council personal mobile device use Ellen and Tim uh thank you to the members of the committee who have been meeting and thank you to alen and um uh Tim Tim and the rest of the committee and we have students and so on so on this this is a we updated where we are we have a proposal uh to come before the board and then we have execution on that uh to take place in the spring so uh I know my colleagues will be brief um
121as they can be fast talkers okay um we want to um thank the advisory Council you can see the names of the participants here um we thank them especially for their open-mindedness and and um sharing the goal of making the best recommendations to the superintendent on behalf of our students especially the students on the panel for whom this was a bit challenging um to give advice about their own cell phones and and their use into the future um their wisdom was very very beneficial to us all thank you uh revisiting cell phones and device practices start was started last year with the elementary and middle schools uh this September we began the process for consideration of our high school practices through the formation of that advisory Council Representatives as you saw from the staff administrators
122parents and students began meeting in October with a review of protocols in and around our district alongside consideration of recent research and practices as are recommended we developed a distributed surveys for staff students and parents and using that information we created a set of options for proposals which we finalized in December um you see here here are the guiding principles of the group um essentially we know how important technology is in our lives and in the lives of our students um we know that our incoming n9th grade will have had a successful um transition to a no cell phone day at the middle school um we recognize that we all have problems regulating our cell phones um and we know that the research supports um that a reduction in cell phone exposure um is good
123for our students for their in-person communication for their uh connection to one another and to us um and we also know that our high school students are growing and maturing towards independence um and we want to recognize that in in our thinking so the three surveys that were distributed all had five core areas of inquiry we sought to understand the levels of awareness of the current practices at our high school perceived impacts of cell phone on learning and socialization and way and ways phones might be used for communication organization and learning we also wanted to get feedback on generalized potential changes and have a way to uh gather concerns I'll briefly share some of that survey data with you so staff and student responses uh which appear highly aligned show limited but occasional use of
124non-lt personal devices AKA cell phones in the classroom for educational purposes uh parents and students also identify regular use of cell phones for organizational purposes staff and parents identify a high negative impact of cell phone use on student learning and nearly a quarter of students also feel the same way the majority of staff and parents believe an improvement in focus on learning would occur if devices were more more broadly restricted it is worth noting that while about a third of students think such a change would have a negative impact the rest that's nearly 2third do not feel that way about 2third of staff and nearly a half of parents believe designated areas or times of day would be appropriate for student use of personal devices considering the previous question I think you can sense the
125challenge we Face however nearly two-thirds of our staff beli chure guidelines would improve the learning environment so with the in-house data aside for moment what are our neighbors doing to be honest I think tonight they're watching us so in general most of the schools in our dur are using cell phone holders located in each classroom similar to what is currently in place at the high school most schools are not significantly restricting use outside of academic settings Wilton's protocol with the Yonder bags is new within the last six or seven weeks or so go back y okay and so um our bottom line recommendation to Dr adley was to restrict the use of of cell phones for grades 9 through 11 um um recognize that there are very special settings at the high school um most
126especially the art um where the phone is used as um a camera and to collect uh portfolio work and so forth um and so we would have to arrange for some kind of support in those settings um and then also recognizing the growing independence of our seniors and allowing them the privilege to access their phone outside of the classroom set so The Advisory Council will continue its work this year to address a number of the actions that we believe will help achieve the protocol that Ellen just described uh three generalized areas of focus are ahead for us this school year including providing additional education and awareness to students and families we also want to start to develop lower access to cell phone experiences for students and get into the complicated Logistics of implementing implementing the
127protocol we described this evening and that is now back to you okay all right um can you before I open it to the rest of the board can you flush out your thoughts on 12th grade what was going on there and where where do what do you think the real in a little more detail what the next steps are I'm sorry j didn't he the last sorry 12th grade 12th grade can you flush out your thoughts on 12th grade and why that's a little bit different and what the next steps are uh well you know I think we see our 12th graders as adults um and they are heading off to college they're heading off to um their future and they're making decisions about um what they're choosing um and we want them to gain
128the confidence that they're able to do that and manage that before they leave us um they drive to school they have a open-ended campus um we don't want them leaving campus to get on their phones we want them to stay with us so um we think it's appropriate developmentally to allow them to make those choices and decision okay thank you other board questions Katie pull that in there is yours on there you go thank C tape okay great um just a couple questions first um wondering if if there will be more development into the second semester work um and if so any of these questions can be answered then I was curious about the pocket system if that's kind of like the calculator thing that hangs right there in the classroom yes okay great um
129and then just in the next steps um you know more color on how the education to family staff and students um is expected to be delivered um you know kind of what will the protocols and procedures be that are developed and then just last question maybe this is a quick one for today the away for the day events those are to be modeled at DHS this year that's that's a DHS and like we're talking about doing some events to motivate students to to learn that separation now this semester okay thank you Sarah did you yes um so mine is a higher level question what is um what is our role in this and are we approving this is this a policy is this a just an informative uh informed the board or I just I
130want to know what what what our role So So currently it's it's an EV capacity um I'm asking the board if they have any input they can certainly have that input um if for some reason the board just in a full disclosure some reason of the board disagreed with it all you could also write write a policy that overwrites it right um but I think you recognize the work of that committee that has done is going to continue to work on that uh work uh and develop the implementation of it it's been proved very helpful and very uh um successful at the Middle School uh those kids G up from middle scho next year to the high school won't uh experience anything different the 11th graders going into the 12th graders are not going to
131experience any any difference uh so there's there's a transition um a manageable transition and the committee will work out uh the implementation phase so we're we're interested in board thoughts on it and that's that for we are thank you um Dave and Joanna recognizing there is no actual policy yet what's the targeted implementation date we're thinking of next fall the start of the yeah start of the Fall thanks Joanna um I just wanted to make sure that uh enforcement will be uh detailed in the next iteration of when you come back to us um and also I'd like to hear um how you plan to mitigate the fact that almost all these kids have MacBooks so their phones are connected to their MacBooks and when they open up their computer they can be on their
132phone instead of engaged in the classroom so what you're you know I I know you're still working on it but I'd really that that's a real issue and and I think the conclusion of the committee has been in their recommendations to Dr adley that the mobility of the device is the challenge more so than the laptop and with a bring your own device model we're not going to remove that um by next fall um for sure and so um we have focused on the cell phone because that's the device that we see um that gets in the way more of the socialization and the well-being and some of the challenges that our students face Greg and then Robin Dave you're up there we go um so I think this is a good step in the
133right direction um I think communication is going to be critical on this just like it was the first time around so I think it would be good for the board to be able to preview that and provide input similar to the way we did last time um I think that some of the questions that you were just bringing up in terms of the overall technology plan I think that's a bigger discussion that we as a board need to have um in terms of how we're thinking about that across the school so maybe that's a different agenda item for sometime later this year it dubils nicely with with our conversations around the budget um because there's obviously implications for the budget in terms of what we're doing with technology what our view of Technology use in
134the school is um and that obviously has impacts on the budget thank you Robin um I agree I think it's a move in the right direction I do I just from a practical standpoint a lot of the high school students I know use the app to manage their schedule and you know the letter schedule versus their class schedule and just to enable as part of the implementation how students can realistically manage that on a day-to-day basis because I I think that is something that is pretty important for them so without a phone it just we need to have more methods in place to support that Dave just to followup um from Greg Tim without going too far down the rabbit hole right now we can look at this later are there any ways just like
135block specific ports for iMessage or for you know slack or for you know different messaging coms or different things across various devices we looked at any sort of that enforcement by uh disabling certain linkages of protocols some of that's above my pay grade as far as how technical it gets I can tell you just off the hand that uh Jeff just finally wrestled down uh uh one form of communication that was uh uh he became aware of just the last couple days at the middle schol so and that was under much more control devices so it's it's a challenge I appreciate the wack-a-mole aspect but I don't know if that may be that's what it becomes wacka yeah thank you so I do think a pretty explicit conversation about the connection between the personal devices
136and the and the computers recognizing that there's probably not a Magic Bullet but that we'd really love to understand what your plan is there because it does tie pretty directly to how we think about providing technology and supporting you all educationally from a technical techn technological perspective so it would be helpful um and so then I think probably what would be the right around the right time to come back two three months yeah I mean because we're we're we're completing it in the spring so yes that's fine okay so marchish after we can get a we can get a update another update in March or okay Katie sorry just one more thing I assume that there will be exemptions made for students who have an IEP or 504 need for monitoring of Health yes okay
137great I think another piece I'd love to see explicitly um discussed is is how we talk about executive function and devices and kids because we're right now a lot of them we're using you you know this better than me but Robin just mentioned Saturn but we're also teaching them to use timers and their calendars and and um making sure that we're thinking holistically about how we're training them in classrooms to manage their schedules and their their time around the building um not on the phones anymore and it's one of the reasons those laptops are important as well not to eliminate everything yeah yeah okay all right anything else from the board on this topic please pass along our thanks to all of the committee members for the hard work that they're doing and we look
138for to hearing from you in March thank you and to our parents out there um we need you at the table for this uh we need your assistance and uh understanding and support and actually modelin um because you you too will be involved in experiences of putting away your phone when you come to the high school in the spring so thank you okay our next agenda item is the possible action on the communication subcommittee we can just I we I can just put a motion out there to collapse Communications and policy if anybody wants to talk about it further I think we could table it but second the motion second the motion anybody yeah discussion yep thank you Ry I just wanted to ask um logistically we didn't form um or I guess I could
139say assign board members to a communication Committee in any event that this might happen um so and we haven't yet had a policy subcommittee meeting yet right um so we don't have you know any pre-work on that or a chair established um will we just will we expect that to really just operate as a combined like as in they will do policy and communication will it be separate meeting like how do we kind of Envision it going I guess is my question okay so I'll share my thoughts we had some conversation March and Allan last time but my understanding is that we're pretty near the end of the work um so there isn't a whole lot left to do just the operational operationalization um so I think yes it would just handle both things at
140the same time we Dennis is on he does come from the former Communications and he's on the new policy um as an assignment so there is some crossover there um but yes the assumption would be that the committee would take on both sets of responsibility um and the agendas would just be constructed according to the timeline of whatever work was coming next okay all right so the Motions on the on the table I'll all those uh in favor that is uh Joanna uh Greg Dave I think it's unanimous all right thank you thank you all all right I will suggest ret table the master agenda if we want to keep moving that's the only thing left what said or do we do the master agenda and table the B and table the rest okay all
141right let's move on to the master agenda and see where we are Alan go ahead we didn't agree to anything we're doing the master agenda we sorry we're just moving through the agenda uh the changes are you as you note them in red there the we've noted those I at the end of this we also have uh special education discussion late spring special education self study that's one and the same that should be collapsed into one that's a very parking lot issue that's the last um but the changes are as you see them [Music] on okay revisions all right easier than we thought that so that can you give a little definition in terms of what's on the special education self-study and the discussion we were asked by the board to look at some um
142aspects of our high referral rate as well as interventions um within all of the schools we'll be looking at that we had look at some programs and um some supports we spoke about some OG we spoke about looking at some reading supports as we go into the science of reading next year as well so we'll be looking at those programs some like some of the CL some of the cohort analysis um looking at possibly shifting how we deliver and the high referral rates and looking at some of the programs okay all right any questions about that okay go ahead Joanna okay all right um you know part of what we're doing is looking to improve how we offer services but part of what we're also doing is acknowledging that the rate of growth in that
143category is is high and so while I mentioned earlier ECR and looking to you know talk to the state and looking at our own we do need to be looking at that category go ahead Greg we on um I just at the last curriculum committee meeting we this sort of came into perview right in terms of this isn't just a Special Education topic and I we may need to expand it's a selfstudy which I do think we need to do but this is a much broader topic where we're talking about general education and how adjusting certain parts of the general education can address fedal education which can address one of the ballooning elements of our budget right we are 100% an agreement yeah yeah did you have something else okay okay something else Kitty thank
144you um such good service over here um I wanted to ask about um the update on Transportation um I know that we had that in the parking lot topic but um we had talked about hopefully doing that this spring maybe after the budget kind of season and I just wanted to see if we might be able to is it on there to establish it as a timeline it's in the parking lot right now it's not assigned to a time I don't even have it in the parking oh we have it in the parking lot of the of the master agenda yeah we've talked about doing it in like late April early may I believe yeah I think I think I have a different version ofet season depending on this I think I have the wrong
145version here I have another one on my right here but that's fine our our can answer the question we have it on you have it on just in parking lot you have an approximate time frame think ktie is yours on I'm just look at yours is on the parking lot yep yes it's in the online one that was just sent out is that yeah oh up the actual Master agenda yes yeah I I Dro master I don't know why M 2025 to August it should be on there though you all right it should be on there when is it supposed to be on there then can we just for some reason I have Madam chair and I have a different version of but that's okay do we know what I I don't have a set
146date for it to be honest with you so when will we have a threet date I just want to make sure it doesn't get lost is really my point um I think I think I'm probably have to make sure uh I review it with transportation and stuff just I don't want to give you a date that it's not going to work I don't know if Richard wants to give you a date that's not going to work either without in probably late April beginning of May sometime in the spring great thank you so we can add on to the parking lot a dash late April early May so that's April 22nd oh yes and Alan we need a date for the um Media review so this is on for Action if we want to just um
147do it as amended sure okay okay uh so great all in favor it's just uh the approving the working draft of the agenda as amended yeah um all that's unanimous thank you all okay all right we're now at the large uh budget discussion it's just before 10 we have quite a bit to cover um we can call a special meeting um what about next Tuesday are people available next Tuesday a great you are you Dennis are you available next Tuesday I'm traveling next week so it'll be difficult to do a night meeting okay yes Greg I won't be available today on a plane but not about me but I the one concern I have is are we going to schedule another meeting we will have to have another public comment session is it gonna no
148we do not okay I'm just making sure we're not gonna have another two hours of comment and then delayed again yeah um we we appreciate hearing from people but we want to make sure that we take the time yes um Katie just a a point of clarification I don't have in front of me our full budget calendar and I just was hoping as a reminder we could kind of review what our timeline is to make sure that we're allowing and there there's a lot of material yes and I want to make sure that follow-up questions have time to be if we don't discuss it tonight exactly so the 28th is budget modification night um and then the uh we have the public hearing on the 4th I think is whatever that Tuesday is the 4th
149I believe and then the next is the 11th is the actual vote so that's the timeline um we would need to have everything yeah go ahead Dave I think it's president day I'm okay okay I'm okay yeah um yeah um and so but how many people were available on Thursday not Sarah yeah I maybe could I'm traveling I maybe could call in later could call in could people do this Thursday no because a lot of people are going out of town anyway better to have them come back in town so people are out of town it sounds like we have a couple people out of town on Thursday okay my my only concern is that if we push it to next Tuesday then we only have one week before we have basically ad cut night
150and the amount of very substantive issues that are on the agenda for discussion right now I I'm a little concerned about only leaving at one week of time before we're doing the modification night well at this point it's um tonight tomorrow night or can we go a little further in some of this or no just the budget questions the memo because that's part of the discussion we can go to 10:30 and then but we still need a date for a special meeting we can take that afterwards so we don't waste this meeting time figuring it out okay good idea all right so Alan you're going to start with sort of the high level and then um he was going to go through each of the presentations um so you guys want to go directly to
151the memo go RC by so one one thing Madam chair if I may if I could just work backwards from the the onepage summary just to give everybody just a we context before we move we can either do that then do the questions and the presentations thereafter or do the do the summary presentations and then questions whatever order you would like to do it in but I just just to give um a we quick overview to the people who in front of us here our community members and and ourselves uh I just want to point out here and we don't have to get into all the details of this because it'll come out in the presentations I'll come out in your questions or you can get into the details but for now we can visit
152it night I'm can visit it at the end to just to to reiterate what it is so I just um this is a one-page summary of where we left off and there has been changes since we left off so options uh one and two literally option two is what the board asked me to do right so you you asked go back take the 49 6,000 put that back in for uh uh talent and gift program and then come back uh with a way to get there so if you look at option two uh it reinstates at the the 469 uh and then you'll see that to get to where we need to get to um I have increased the class sizes uh for second and uh third grade from 23 to 24 right as the
153maximum uh that means there's two classes that's that for the one a better term pH it that sa if two positions a second grade class at homes and a second grade class uh Royal so it it keeps the U 24 as the maximum for uh uh grades two through five essentially um and shees two teachers uh so I'm still on option to here uh the athletic participation fees of 150 340 for the non cic and with a 600 cap you can see there's variations of that you can land them on whatever variation the board feels if you want to do a participation fee we can find a way to to get there you notice all the numbers at the bottom was 4.4 increase 4.37 3739 it's not trying to go up or down it's just
154it's hard to land on a number specifically you're you're not going to charge somebody $6.7 right um that type of stuff uh so option one on the left uh does give another option the board did not ask me for this option but I brought it back as uh as a consideration you've heard it referred to a little bit this evening and it's where we keep the tal and gifted program in its current format at the middle school and uh at the elementary school we provide those Services uh through our lab media specialist we are trained in U research uh stem uh literacy um problem solving so on so forth but anyway um you'll see in in the presentation either tonight or whenever we We Gather back that is one variation of that so that is
155option one uh which does away with uh parti ation phase and it get you to the same place it keeps the talent and gifted program in place at the middle school and it keeps the services in place at the elementary school considerations 3A and 3B uh are new to the board uh you heard Madam CH sh that uh we received ECR information back from the state last week uh which is the lowest that I think it's on record uh so it's dropped down below 60% the 59.9 uh% of reimbursement that has an implic for this year's budget we'll discuss that at the finance committee uh this week uh but it also has implication for next year uh because we budgeted at 70% uh that seems now that seems high uh so this budget here uh
156in option our consideration 3A and 3B have included a reimbursement rate of 65 why did we Pi pick 65 given us at 60 and giving we budget at 70 um it just it seems like a reasonable thing to project um the board can consider otherwise but it's important that we actually note that we had a similar discussion last year so you'll see we've added in another um $165,000 that we have to find so consideration three does it with the uh increase in class size uh the version of the Middle School uh Talon gifted services and then participation phas there's various participation P you can pick um but we can get there if they wanted to do that consideration uh 3B uh does the C thing but it does it keeps the tal and gifted program
157completely in place as it is doesn't do a middle school version or sorry an elementary version with the media specialist and then that we we've increased the payment options from uh clubs to inter murals and to your participation fee uh there's a there is a presentation this evening on participation fease so that again if the board so so isn't so inclined to do a participation fee we can get there one way or the other that's a matter of which model so uh if you want to talk about that just about the meaning of any of that uh just for organizational purpose for we an understanding before we get going that's okay yes sure go ahead Dave so yeah thanks Al I guess understanding from an organizational perspective be helpful so I know we had the
158board retreat all day Saturday where we had the sense of the board from most of the members that cutting idea was an unstart um you put this together since then but ahead of this meeting I know earlier in this meeting we spent almost two hours hearing from parents students alumni that they're not interested in any cuts the idea program I guess the simple questions I think about from a high level what's really viable for the superintendent's budget do you see idea being cut as a viable option for your budget moving forward at this time do I yes I I'm still put in place the budget that the presentation that I uh I presented that's the one that I'm advocating for the board has asked me to come up with a variation so I'm come up
159with a variation thank you okay um Joel yes go ahead can I I'm gonna do a Dave date on Saturday can we have is anybody interested in doing a sense of the meeting if if if we are interested in even moving forward with talking about keeping idea or not or cutting idea because if so we could save a whole lot of trouble for a lot of community we done it Saturday but happy to do it again yeah we we did and and in a vacuum the board is not interested in cutting idea I think the only hesitation we have is that we have to figure out um what the budget is that we're going to put forward and we need to take a look at what the different puts and takes might be so um
160you see here I think this is a menu of options I almost would ask is you know the board to contemplate um we're we're ahead of budget modification night so I don't think we need to put on anything on the table this this moment but the board to contemplate whether or not it thinks items are missing um um because you know some we may we have to each of these would have to go to a vote and we've got to see whether or not folks actually want to pursue anything any of these and or other options I think I don't want to take a vat right now I just want just qu the community I just want I just want wondering if all of us could voice how we feel about idea current I happy
161to say I do not want to take away the program I think in a vacuum no one wants to take it away but we have to finish the exercise um but go ahead Greg just um you made a comment about this being a menu of options I think that this is I think there's like one option on this well that's my point like I think I'm not sure we're finished I don't see this as a menu whatsoever right so there a motion pending from Sarah or was that not meeting she not put a motion on the table but Sarah you certainly can I mean I'll put it on I I I will have a motion to remove the to to restore the idea program and D we have action on the AGA we don't have
162action isn't the s for Action it it's not I mean you you can you can you can always make a motion honestly but um well I'd also resp I also respect the board decision to do that but you also asked the staff to put together another scenario or otherwise to I I would just say to that point that I think um I've spoken to many of my colleagues and I think that we have looked through the materials carefully um as has the public we have heard a lot of people weigh in on the materials that have been presented um now again we you know we did have a programmatic change and a surprise in the budget um so I would think that if there had been more lengthy discussion warranted we would have had an
163advance so I am thinking that it is in the board's best interest if if there is um consensus that this is not something that we are interested in I think the most efficient use of our time is to move forward and I think that that's the most efficient and respectable way to treat our community as well so that they can understand what their elected officials um are hearing and and deciding and then we can focus on the rest of the budget because right now um this has become a distraction and there's a lot of material in here that we have a responsibility to go through okay all right so Sarah put a motion out go ahead John I'll put a motion in a second and then you can discuss John but yeah Robin seconded right
164I second all right go ahead John yeah I mean I'm fully supportive of what's been said but do we really want to Tire hands now and say absolutely no change to this because it's going to impact other things that we you know I haven't run any crunch any numbers I just want to put that disclaimer out there you know that it's fine but then you Whittle down I think well said I think we're all aware of those risks yeah okay I just want to make sure all right so all those in favor can you clarify exactly what we the motion I mean I don't know what I worded it as it help me with the wording the motion I I think you said to strike consideration of the idea program as part of the FIS
165or strike consideration of eliminating the idea program as part of the fiscal year 26 budget deliberation and can I think that's what you said Sarah sure Jill just to clarify I would I think Sarah is saying that she would like to restore the idea program in its current form is that correct Sarah because I think that is what we are generally talking about sure okay and Robin you yeah go ahead Dennis go Dennis sorry that that's that's zero alterations or anything it's just Asis nothing nothing changes as is and you know I'm not I'm not against having a conversation throughout the year about this if you know but I don't feel comfortable doing changing it now in the middle of budget yeah I I I will say that I think that there are some things
166that have come up about gifted education in all of the amount that we've heard that we need to talk about um you know I heard a lot of kids being dissatisfied with a classroom um I've and I think that you know the 10% number serves a certain percentage of kids but I'm not saying that we have problems in the classroom but I'm saying maybe there's ways to engage other folks beyond the 10% so I think there's things to talk about yeah I think that's a great point because it was brought up here that we can just do some uh additional professional development we can work this into the actual General classroom like that' be great if we can do that no cost why aren't we exploring that so I think when we're outside of budget
167season there's we a lot we could look at to expand this program not alone just leave it as is I think there's enhancements that are I as well and some modalities in the classroom like the flexible grouping and things like that that I'd like to see us talk about um uh in terms of enhancing instruction yes Katie if I can just piggy back on that I think that this connects really well to Greg's earlier point about how we look at general education and that all of our students are gened students first and that special education really does encompass both ends of the spectrum so I think that's a very worthwhile exercise for us to look holistically at our curriculum and how we're serving all students okay Robin um I think I agree with what's been
168said I I think that this is not a idea or I think this is an idea and we could also continue to explore other things within the general education classroom that would extend curriculum do differentiation better and I think we do have some models I think it was potentially Westport that currently does incorporate some things within the actual curriculum that we could explore for future years as we continue this discussion but I think it it the idea program which is in currently EX in existence is doing really well and there's a reason for that and it's because of the teachers and the quality of what they're doing and I think that's why I would choose supported in its current form okay so I'm going to take a um all those in favor okay so that
169is you H okay all those opposed John Dennis I'm assuming you're where is Dennis he might have gone to bed no no no I'm here you're here sorry Dennis I'm opposed I'm opposed you're opposed also I think we we need to leave room on the table leave room yeah um okay um and Dennis I'm not I'm not Harding you I know you're not feeling well so thank you sorry thank you for being here on Zoom um okay all right so that's the highle discussion um that does shape the special meeting somewhat um all right what we have remaining is a presentation we need we have all of the budget questions plus plus a presentation on uh plc's instructional pair professionals fees so that's four different sorry Jo I just had one other point that I'd
170like to talk about on this can okay great thank you um so Dr adley um you had said in our discussion on the cell phone policy at DHS that um in that respect the board's role was really um in guidance and that should we want to override it that we um could could write a policy and um I feel the need to bring up the fact that we do in fact have policy 6150 that sets classroom guidelines and that this proposal goes outside of adopted board class siiz guidelines yes it does but it doesn't preclude the board here at the table taking a to change that I mean that is uh I'm trying to look and see how we get to where we need to be um I don't think that that honestly is a
171big challenge to to if you have a discussion about changing uh a class siiz guideline here I think that's I'm in the scope of of the spirit of what you're asking me to do I think the board at the table here can can actually vote on that have that discussion I don't think it needs to go back to Palace it could go back but I don't think it needs to if the board here decides to go forward with something like that and support that I think it's a fairly perfunctory exercise then to actually change the language respectfully I disagree I do not think that policy should be bent um to fit circumstances and I do not believe that policy exists to be flexible to budgetary responsibilities I think the exact reason that we set policy
172is that they can be broadly applied um and that they hold us to certain standards and values um I would encourage all board members to go back and read that policy it's very short um but there's specific in language in there um and I would also remind the board that this year we are outside of those guidelines by 29 classroom rooms at the middle school due to a budgetary decision that was made last year was a little more complicated it was also a timeline and a and a difficulty with um the back end which we're that's a perfect example if we don't go for that now where are we going to go so right so so we did against the last vote when when we did talk about efficiencies Katie we did note that the
173time Sarah and I actually talked about putting this to policy and it was decided that this actually should be handled through the budgetary discussion first and if there wasn't interest that we would go to policy so that it has been noted um that this is that if we were to talk about class size it would have to be um that policy would have to be involved at some point and yet here it is right well that's and that's can I ask what's what's the point I mean seriously what is the point of that this discussion yeah so you know what I actually think that it's time to okay you know what I can feel that I'm getting tired um so I'm just going to say I think we're about at the end of this one
174yes Dave I'm sorry you said at the end of this one I don't know if you meant this specific slide or you're going to close down here I meant this specific slide but go ahead Perfect all I was going to ask is we were going to close here on F for tonight I'd be fine all I was going to ask is we have questions outstanding there's a number we do yes would it be advisable if board members have questions between now and the next time we meet we submit those in writing that would be a great idea thank you yes thank you um and so I'm going to suggest that table the remainder of the the agenda um and then we will come up with a time uh that will be between now and next
175Tuesday sorry yes so if we're tabling where we are right now in the discussion are we tabling everything on here or will we return to it again this will come back and and lead off to next discussion okay and that'll be a special meeting where public comment will be reserved to the end of that meeting yes awesome thank you okay all right with that um I have a motion to table on the on the floor is there a second um Joanna all those in favor okay that is um Joanna Greg Dave Jill Sarah John Dennis where are you can't see me I am with you okay and then all those opposed Katie and Robin the motion passes all right so we will uh we will schedule a next meeting uh we have to notice it
176with it for at least we have to give at least 24 hours notice so it will not be tomorrow did we already talk about a potential no dat because I think we need to actually talk about the date we talked about next Tuesday that's currently the most viable um can we just schedule that as the next date then since we're all here yeah that makes sense well Sarah's not here and Greg's not here but I'm not here Thursday you're not here Thursday you're here next Tuesday yes okay well let's set next Tuesday as the most likely date we're going to try we don't we have to notice it to schedule it I can't just sit here and schedule it 7 7:30 s s yes s we have a lot to get through I mean 6:30
1777 o'clock can we do 6:30 just get it early I can't do you can't 7 o'clock all right um followup action items [Music] um let's table that till the next meeting public comment good evening if anybody in person or online would like to participate in public comment please approach the podium or use the raised hand icon please state your name and address for the record once you've been recognized and note that you have up to three minutes to comment we have nobody in person and no raised hands with that may I take a motion to journ that is John seconded by Sarah all those in favor that is unan