CorpusRecord 28869

BOE Special Curriculum Committee Meeting - January 8, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Darien PS
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Western Connecticut Planning Region, CT
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,211 words · about 57 min
Collected
2026-06-06

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay good morning everybody and we are going to get started it is Wednesday January 8th this is a meeting a special meeting of the Daran Board of AD curriculum committee um we have K to3 literacy on our agenda as always and then we'll have a k to2 language update so I will turn it right on over oh our next meeting is Wednesday February 5th so I'm back again Amy you're up thank you good morning everyone thank you Sarah um we are excited today to continue our discussion around K3 literacy and the um really unbelievable commitment our district has had um for the last several months actually for much more than actually uh several months but for the last year especially with regard to the steering committee and the work of the um the core review

002team and exploring different resources to enhance our programming in Darian Public Schools So today we're going to revisit a little bit of the work um with regard to the arpa grant we're going to have an opportunity again to hear from our staff which has been a wonderful I think addition the last several board of education curriculum committee meetings hearing directly from our staff who are implementing resources within the district we're going to talk a little bit about K3 literacy today um you're going to hear from Julia a little bit about a potential opportunity to partner with tntp um the new teacher project that's some a group that the state has brought in to support uh districts who are looking into considering additional resources for their literacy programming um the updated writing units of study that

003are a part of the curriculum that is current currently in place in Daran Public Schools um you'll be able to hear from our teachers with that and we'll follow up with some discussion so to keep our meeting moving I'm going to turn it over to Julie and she'll also introduce our staff who's with us today perfect thank you so I'm just gonna we just put the timeline in as a reminder um and we've talked about this before so I'm just going to start by introducing our staff that you have not met before Hillary wreck is a first grade teacher at holes Debbie Lynch is a literacy specialist at homes christe Martin second grade teacher at Royal and Melissa Malik third grade teacher at token so Amy talked about our agenda the right to read Grant

004as you know our district was awarded $145,000 that were that was allocated we spent every single penny of it by December we were required to use it for only approved curriculum materials um on the state list so we were able to purchase Foundation decodables mostly for our K2 um classrooms but a little bit for third grade and the feedback has been wonderful we also supported am web for two years and our foundation's digital platform as you will recall this required a leadership team to spend 10 days full days of professional learning by the state um Amy talked a little bit about this partnership with tntp the new teacher um partnership this is a nonprofit uh educational research and Consulting Group Amy and I met with them a couple of times and we were impressed with

005what they would provide to districts it is paid for by the state and they still have to get back to us they are not allocated uh there are not funds allocated to work with all districts but we are hoping that there is an opportunity they they have a a tool a lens to go in and observe classroom rooms and give districts in collaboration with districts um a lens to look at your strengths your areas of growth maybe some blind spots and develop an action plan and we like the aspect that it is a partnership so um I put a link to the organization if you want to learn more about them I'm going to talk briefly about word love and you know the teachers will will elaborate on that this is a resource that we

006implemented this year we did not have a dedicated vocabulary program other than what we were doing with the ruler feeling words what we love about it is that it it's explicit instruction with um multi- sensory there's visuals there's auditory um components to it it's kinesthetic um it's fun it's engaging it's aligned to our read alouds there's additional units in character traits and morphology we have provided professional learning to our teachers and the feedback from students and staff has been positive our new writing units of study as Amy said this is this is just an update to our curriculum the lessons are streamlined there's additional resources for small group differentiated instruction there are grammar lessons in each unit um and a continued emphasis on the writing process student agency choice and voice which we value assessments

007I this is a slide from the student achievement presentation back in October these are the different types of Assessments that we use but we thought it was important to let you know how we monitor student learning and progress in literacy we have as web which is a universal screener for all we use it in all grades um k through eight actually but it is it is mandated um in grades K through three and if you link that as web plus you can see all of the different subtests that we um that we use to monitor student learning and it's quite um robust we also this year implemented a quick phonic screener in grades one and two this is something that um because we're using inter reading and fundations we just wanted to have something that

008was not program specific to look at how our kids are doing with phonics we have summative assessments our foundations unit tests the inter reading end of module tests our formative assessments which are for instruction Integrity phic awareness we have phonic decoding in K2 and three as needed we have a high frequency word assessment we use decodable Running Records as an assessment and Running Records for readers who are at level F and Beyond we have writing on demands which is um not process writing it's what kids can do um without any teacher support we have teacher observations response to questions and smarter balance interim assessments so we really know where our kids are we have a lot of Assessments and we feel like it's an important part of our learning process so with that I am

009going to open this up to um any questions that you have for our teachers and any thoughts that they want to add thank you I don't know if you guys have anything you know introductory comments prepared or if you're really just looking for questions um if you guys didn't mind hi thank you it's a pleasure being here um Hillary wreck a first grade teacher at homes thank you uh I would just like to speak to a few things word love is an absolutely incredible program Mike Oaks has created a program that teaches our students vocabulary right from the go uh it provid provides gestures with students who need that to ground themselves in what the meaning is additionally there are games which we all might say oh it's games well that's how students really learn

010right they're having fun while learning so at the same time they don't even know I've seen them use the vocabulary that they are learning in their writing I've heard them say it in speaking to their peers so for example blurted instead of saying oh Mrs rck Landing called out Mrs C Landon blured something out and it's just fun to hear them incorporate it additionally it's really helpful for students who are MLS because they are able to see the pictures identify it especially if this is something that culturally they don't have it right I think that's incredibly important to recognize so they're learning the gestures they're seeing the visuals and then they're playing the games to reinforce it so we're seeing it in their writing we're seeing it in their everyday speak um I also have

011I'd like to think I have a bit of a unique perspective as well so my first year here I taught TC unrevised second year taught TC revised in second grade this year I'm teaching TC revised in first grade so I think something I have loved seeing is that it is I don't want to say simple but it is just very streamlined for teachers there is a clear teaching point and with the on demands and I know Julie touched upon this but typically we give a preassessment see where students are right that informs our teaching with that I'm then able to go to the blueprints that they provide for small group instruction and I can look at every single group I have and be able to create small groups to improve their writing then we typically

012I know they do this in kindergarten they give a mid uh unit assessment to just see have we close those gaps and where are they now so we see that growth then at the end we are then able to see at the post assessment what growth have they made and we can look back at exactly what small groups we have pulled what we have done to see that growth from start to end and again this isn't I'm teaching into it this is independent student writing um and it's pretty remarkable to see so I do really like the uh the revised units in addition to the fact that as a first grade teacher knowing the Continuum into second grade how we build upon that that has been very enlightening to me and I think that's so

013important um and I truly love having that perspective knowing where I have to not just get students at the end of the year but where they need to be to really at the end of second grade going into third so thank you I have the other the other teachers want to share their experience with word love or so word love um obviously came this year you pull the mic a little bit closer to you just closer to me just pull right can I just talk louder both work so I've been in District for a long time and this is the first time that we've had an explicit vocabulary instruction um so it's been great it's nice to have an organized program to follow it's nice to have words that are common across the grade level

014um and it's a great way to do it because you're actively engaging the children in front of you um both in how you're presenting the words how they're interacting with the words both in the gestures as Hillary said which are a lot of fun um and the kind of games that you're playing to practice them um I would agree with Hillary that you're seeing the transfer both in their language and in their writing um which is exciting um to do and then the words all come from read aloud books that are Incorporated through the TC units um called let's gather so we get a read aloud book and then we explore that as a read aloud and then that's our launching pad for the next four words we're going to study in vocabulary so it's

015a nice connecting the words into a real book so they're not just words from space kind of thing um they are grounded in um in lature that is then a part of your classroom so that's an also nice component um about having um about doing the word love is having that that connected piece um the kids are really enjoying it for sure I don't I'm curious I should say as into next year you know when the kids come up if we're doing word love again like do they get bored of doing the games do they like do they cycle through like that kind of longevity of it is hard to say um and I know in second grade it's fun to do all those things I'm not sure how far this is going to go

016up but in the upper grades do they do they have the same enthusiasm for how it's being presented um those are kind of questions that would be you know kind of a broader subject and I don't know the program well but you can you speak to the you know to that point of longevity like yeah I mean from what we've we've been in fifth grade classrooms uh the kids love it um this is our first year of implementing it so the games are a some of them are the same but they're different but and some are different and the words are more sophisticated yes um so and from the learning specialist point of view do you see anything you know do you have any thoughts of word love what so I have the perspective I

017have the perspective of seeing the inter reading vocabulary and the word love vocabulary happening across the school and from what I've heard I know in inter reading they're telling me that oh the best part of the inter reading is the readal that'ss on the vocabulary but I'm also hearing that it's also hitting the mark in these classrooms as well so I think incorpor ating vocabulary in a story that is addressing a skill I think is a great thing and I think both programs have kind of tackled that the games I know the kids are loving and I think I'm excited to see the morphology work because from my perspective that is the piece that I think really needs to be hit at home and I love that that word love has that stuff going on

018so and and I will say too one thing that kids thrive on is a predictable structure so I do think also that when they know it it can go quick you know it can go more quickly so vocabulary really is five to 10 15 minutes yeah the way that um they have the program broken down it's really like quick moments of time that like in in a day you essentially play two games after you've introduced the words but you don't have to play them at the same time in the same moment they can be played because you've got 10 minutes before JY like let's go play but they know how to play the game because you've already introduced the game so it's a quick so it doesn't have to be it's not like this 45

019minute lesson um that's taking up this huge chunk of time that's not okay that's not how it works out can we talk to the visuals um so each word comes with a chart um which is a picture showing acting out the vocabulary word so if the word is effort you see the some drawing of a child like lifting up something heavy and then the gesture for the kids is like um and so they do that same motion so the visuals there to remind them of the gesture and on the bottom it says exactly what the word means so it's a we actually they have them in like small medium and large sizes so we have them up in the classroom but then we also have them in like the kids writing folders so that they

020can refer back to them um as a reference okay Katie I can't see you so just pop in if you have questions great um yeah I just have a couple it sounds like there's pretty unanimous positive feedback on word love is it duplicative with the vocabulary program with inter reading it's presented a little similarly but it doesn't have the the hand gestures I don't think it has the same visuals um and I think it's a little bit more embedded but I know that what I've hearing from the inter reading teachers they really do enjoy the read alouds and the vocabulary is embedded so I it's presented in a similar way but I feel that the kinesthetic piece and the visual piece is stronger with the wordl and the games are not a part of intering

021so you know hypothetically if we choose into reading is this an Andor or is this a and and Andor Andor it's an Andor and okay and then um my other question was taking a little bit of a step back um it sounds like vocabulary these are new resources that are positive from your all's perspective where it seems like there may have been somewhat of a shortfall previously I think for us as we're thinking about the collective curriculum around reading and writing are there other areas this you don't have to necessarily give an answer right now but there other areas where we've got deficiencies that we need to address and as we're thinking about endeavoring down this inter reading path or something else are those addressing those appropriately I could speak to that a little bit

022I teach third grade at token um so we've been craving a vocabulary program for years and this word love I will say is everything we've wanted it to be and more um where I think that we're still lacking is a grammar program I've been my team and I have been Loosely dabling in the current writing units and there are some grammar and punctuation editing lessons embedded within the program but it's not enough in my opinion um for example in each unit there are three bends and it says that there are about one or two lessons per Bend within grammar and um punctuation and editing and that's just not sufficient enough for third grade and I know going forward I taught fifth grade at 1 point2 it's it's not near as much as we need to

023be um I find that my team and I are continually pulling resources of our own to get the students to where they need to be um on a third grade Common Core level but also to get them ready for the sbas so so grammar and punctuation I think is something we would love love love to have more as a teacher and a parent of girls who went through the school district and they now in high school grammar needs a boost grammar used to be a big focal point I know because my mom was a teacher for 25 years yeah there's no there's really nothing I also think some coaching would be great too to have some coaching in this area because I think it's it's not something that we really do need too much of

024a program to teach grammar I think it's more teaching teachers of how to address it with the kids and having a uniformity with that because like I said we're pulling resources but I don't know what other third grade teachers are pulling for resources or if they're doing the same thing versus finding something else focus on that they think is important as well and so that's not you're not seeing that addressed in the inter reading program at all so from what I understand inter reading does address grammar it's not being addressed in the new TC units enough but inter reading from what I understand inter reading that's one of the positives from at least the first grade teachers at my school is they are embracing and enjoying the actual explicit grammar instruction that's happening with the

025and that's what when you know when when your colleagu sat at the table they that was one of their points that they really did feel that the grammar piece was strong um you know Melissa mentioned pulling different resources and this to me the biggest issue with this whole process is that there's not a one-size fits-all like answer for everybody and it's You Know It's Tricky that we we do want to word love sounds great but we also want to pull from the inter reading grammar and how do we make that all work you know and I think that's with our curriculum development right because because a a resource is not a curriculum s can I yeah go ahead Katie thank you um I so apologize for not being able to be in person these are

026my favorite meetings and thank you so much to the staff that's taking your time to be here um you guys are an invaluable resource to hear directly um from you guys about what's happening in the classroom um I I do want to just clarify a couple of things um one I I want to make sure that that we all understand that we're on the same page that the reason we have a different cohort of teachers today is that these teachers are doing something different than into reading so we don't actually have any teachers right now that are both piloting into reading and word love or the new units of study so I do think that's just an important distinction for us as board members to keep in mind that we have different subsets of teachers

027that are trying both things we we don't have anyone that's kind of like done both in in different years so it will be important for us to recognize that things are always a little bit different in experience and I am hearing too that um that things are a bit different classroom to classroom and school to school which is just a good reminder for us to keep in mind the work that we have to do in terms of making sure that as we go forward and we choose you know the resources that we will develop um our teachers themselves will then develop the curriculum to come in front of our students that there is consistency um across all of the buildings because that's really important um I I really appreciate the conversation coming back to grammar

028because um it's important for us to remember too that inter reading um is a comprehensive program that has a lot of things um and I know that we can get caught up sometimes into a one-size fits-all idea but I think that's where it's important to come back to the idea that it's really our district and our teachers that turn a resource into curriculum and I think we got some really good feedback from the inter reading about just like the plethora of resources of pulling that so I'm really interested today to hear about some of like the specific components because it sounds to me like what I'm hearing is there's a focus on vocabulary one aspect of resources here that seems to be going well which is wonderful to hear um and then that there is

029some grammar updates to the units of study but it sounds like that's not enough and those pieces I i' really like to hear more about as well because I think that you know grammar is something that we've been hearing for quite a long time about the impact of it in our high school students writing um from from you know sort of the the deficiencies that that they had at an elementary level um and I do want to to make sure that we focus on on discussing what the writing looks like so I'm very curious to hear about how writing is going in the elementary levels you know what kind of feedback are students getting what kind of instructions are happening what are we seeing come out of their work not just from a content and

030a creativity component which which I think that you know Darian does a good job at nurturing along the way but in systematic writing you know for communication for structure do they understand um parts of work can they translate that into sophisticated writing um so I would like to hear that and then um just one last thing um because I know it's hard to jump in Via Zoom I'm curious to hear about the small group instruction as well and how the differentiation is going and how much um is needed in addition into our general Ed education classrooms how much par professional support are you getting how difficult is it to do small um small group differentiation when there's only one of you and there's you know 20 plus students how many days does it take do

031that same level um across you know 20 kids thank you so much I can just jump in and answer that first part of your question Katie because one of the things that our core review team wanted to look at was the the writing as well so all of our teachers in grades one through three are doing a um an OnDemand again that's just you know um a a prompt giving all students a prompt and scoring it against a rubric and looking at structure elaboration development and um that the grammar component conventions and punctuation and the core review team will look at that and and see if there's any um difference in the kids that have had each of of those programs this year and to the point of of the um you know small group

032instruction for the for the writing for the new revised units do you feel you just talked a little bit more of like what you know to Katie's Point like are you seeing progress are you seeing do what what's changed in the writing in the new units so I think that compared to the old units the unit new units have many more options for what to do with small group work and um more visuals to go along with so that you have a starting point to use with your students for example right now we're working on narrative writing and it says if your students are having trouble elaborating on describing a character a small group thing that you can do is take a student aside they draw a little picture and then they make little bubbles

033of words that go along with the person they're trying to describe so then they can incorporate that within their writing um whereas in the old units I feel like it was just here's what you can do with them and there weren't as many visuals and as many um tools that you could use there's a lot more really benefit icial tools with this unit um and in terms of structure in third grade we're very heavy on teaching the structure of writing um when it comes to non-fiction writing they get the structure very well it's very concise introduction body paragraphs conclusion and narrative writing historically is always very tricky because of figuring out when to make a paragraph um but I do believe that TC the new unit and the old unit do provide um efficient structure

034okay um we even talked about that budget page that is at the last piece um and Mrs Robin couldn't be here today but her question I wanted to pass on the questions she wanted to I don't know if you want to talk to that budget page or I mean it's the same that we've is it revised or the same no it's the same um so her question was um let me just make sure I phrase it right what is included in that compendium and what is that what is that um what does that include so the reason that there's a range there is because it would depend on which resources and how the the um core review team what their recommendations were I I do agree that the grammar component into reading is very strong

035and um you know we like the writing process and we do like like the TC writing units there there really is nothing better um so that's a place where we could see keeping the grammar piece of into reading and putting that in there's some questions about phonics and Inter reading versus foundations do like what parts do we do the shared reading um are there parts of that so that's kind of what the core review team is looking at now okay so just so the the top part of that budget the inter reading that is only inter reading that is not keeping foundations that is not including Bo is that H Sinker I just s if I just add I think with regard to the writing we heard from some of our staff in the last

036probably two curriculum committee meetings where there was kind of some mixed feelings about the writing and the experiences that students were having and so I I don't know that yet we're able to decide and say that there you know one would be a better option than the other with regard to the writing piece the grammar is definitely very clear but I think even with regard to process writing and um some of what Katie was talking before about skill development and writing and thinking about systematic writing I think that um we really need to take this next month to ask as as Julie said we've issued kind of an on demand to take a look at not only the scoring of that on demand but actually to look at the student work samples before us and

037consider not only the content and creativity but the systematic and process aspects of writing as well so that's something that I would say is we're too early um to say that we we favor one over the other okay I thought that um into reading was like a all or none situation so inter reading um the way that that product is marketed is it's a comprehensive program and a district could adopt everything and and it's a complete package um we have received feedback from the state and we know that there are areas as you've indicated some of that we know that we we need to shore up or we may feel like we have some deficiencies or want to strengthen we have the option as always and Sarah mentioned this before as well to kind of

038take resources and we should be taking resources and creating a curriculum here so it doesn't mean mean that we have to only take that one resource that's that's approved as a resource in and of itself but the state does still allow for a compendium approach so comp the when you say compendium what is that what does that actually that means kind of taking um resources to support different types of um literacy instruction and different areas of literacy instruction instead of just taking from like you know one this is a the compendium what you're saying is compendium that's like a mixture of a bunch of different yes yeah yeah so what yeah I guess what specifically is included in that which and and again our core review team would have to look at that it could

039be um it could be hegr and Foundations it could be inter reading it could be um meaning like it would be the grammar part of inter it would be Foundation be word love or whatever like it would be these different pieces different pieces what we think are the best want right right hits for I mean if we think if I don't I'm just looking at the two if we think that like the bottom one is all of our favorite programs and it's at a cost that's significantly discounted versus the other why wouldn't we go with that path that might be what we determine J in here for a quick second again I'm sorry thank you um I think it's important to remember that there's a couple things going on here too one is that um

040you know Greg if you look back at like our long list of current reading resources right now it's extensive I remember when my kids first got into the school and we used to host workshops and there was like a slideshow and it was like 20 resources that we were using for reading so it's important to think about one is and I don't have a problem with us saying we need an extra component and we might go with let's say something like inter reading that is comprehensive but we might still want something else I don't have a problem with that I do think that when we get into a long list of 20 reading and writing resources one we're paying for 20 different resources and of one and two we make it that much more complicated

041to try to give a streamline approach for what all teachers should be doing in all classrooms across all buildings so I do think we need to look at that before we start making a very complicated mishmash of resources um I think that you know there's no question that um we have a mandate to fill by the state and um inter reading fulfills that teachers college does not so we need to also be thinking about what whether or not what our choices are doing are going to fulfill the requirement that we have to the state so that's an important one how we supplement how we design our own curriculum in darianne based on the resources we choose I have confidence in our staff for that but we need to be thinking big picture about that there's

042no question that phonics have been a deficiency for a long time there's no question that writing has been a deficiency so to Mr Roller's point I I respectfully disagree that there's nothing better than Teachers College I have been hearing for over a decade of how deficient our writing is how um disappointing our high school students writing is so I think that um I'm very very concerned about sticking with the teachers College model on that I do want to come back to a point I made earlier which is I would like to understand small group instruction and how par professional support is is being utilized currently that's very important for for current and for future planning um Katie do Point good morning everybody by way thank you for being here morning I appreciate it um we

043have been in contact with the state the way through this process uh regarding the finances certainly we will consider the finances I won't say this casually I'm not so much concerned about the finances as opposed to what's the right program for our kids um and I can't say for a difference that I would lean one way or the other um I've always said through the this process I'm going to bring to the table we've worked collaboratively with the state department actually we're going to have another uh we are calling ourselves another meeting with the state department to give them another update whether they want to participate with us or not um we're inviting them uh to participate in that in that particular process yes um and a board level we can discuss some of these

044things in terms of uh what happens if the state doesn't support our program um this is just anecdotally around the state and around our particular area there there District just do nothing or just just ignoring the whole thing we have never done that we have said we weren't done that but I'm not I'm not recommending to the board but the board has to make an executive uh discernment on on on my actions regarding that um but I'm not supporting a program that my experts in raen are not supporting in the district yes this is what this has been a great opportunity actually uh first in a long time uh of actually looking at the resources comparing them the uh our reading units of study and so on so um we're in that process we we

045been very up up front with the state uh they may or may not agree with us um I'm hopefully they will we even at the most recent uh caps cave convention we had an opportunity to talk to them uh candidly uh I think they'll be receptive at least to the idea that we have been absolutely 100% inclusive and thoughtful uh in in our process so I'm hopeful that uh they will support us but um is there a possibility they don't and what happens if they don't um well that's that is a discussion for executive discussion with the board of myself regarding that but uh I've always said to my my teachers my my administrators I've been at some of the many of these meetings actually if whatever you are deciding on this expert wise is

046what we're leaning into um and that would be a recommendation that I bring to the board of teacher for in terms of Pate professional support uh if I may say respectfully a little bit uh I I just don't see this as the the time that this is not a discussion for Pate professional support I understand it that people use it uh but they're not the people who are actually delivering instruction quality instruction um it's not the discussion necessarily for tomorrow and the only other thing I would say is uh uh Katie you're on the zoom so as difficult it is for you to sort of like uh the Nuance of your comments M too so you'll forgive me but there's been no extrapolation right or correlation to our Elementary performance and our high school performance

047yes there have been discussions of priorities and so on so forth and everything everybody said uh these have been dented uh identified at priorities but so I just don't want to over overe extrapolate or or make determination but the essence of what everybody has said here is is on the table yes and to the PA professional point I asked on Saturday for a more comprehensive understanding of what those pairs actually were doing now so currently so hopefully that can be part of this and if literacy involved well we will be talking about that on uh Tuesday evening perfect okay and and just I would just want to comment I think Katie what you were just all that resonates with me um it that seems like it becomes more of a question actually for I don't

048know if this is the right group of teachers but for the teachers in terms of for this compendium program which is it's what I'm hearing is like this is the best of everything that we can find so whether it's Teachers College or something else we're picking the best things we can we're putting into a uniform program where all the teachers and the curriculum will be based on those and it will be consistent across teachers and everybody else is there an implement mentation issue with that versus having just into reading that I think that's like a a pretty key question because if if there's not then to me it just comes down to the question that you had around the state and I think we should try to get out ahead of that as much as

049possible and preview with them as early as possible what we're considering and then um the second question is cost and based on what I'm looking on this page it's a significant discount one versus the other and it's better based on if we're picking the best of the best then by definition it's better well I think yeah I mean I think it's there's there's option A has some great Parts option b is some great parts and I kind of feel like you know we'll have to wait to see what the recommendation is but um there are benefits to both and I honestly I would like to have something of all and I I would say for my distance like my teachers can disagree with me and feel free to to disagree or anybody else around the

050table but for my perspective the question of those do I think that's a great like observation and that's great actual uh Nuance of this in terms of all of these pieces versus and I think that's part of the like part of the Dilemma along with TC uh it's it's hard to do TC sometimes right um and having something that grounds people as a fundamental resource uh will pay Merit to how much is that really helpful to people and how much is like that's what we been needed whether it's Ender reading or some other but yeah uh that that dilemma is there and I think it's it's it's worthy to as a factor how much that is really helpful as opposed to the skill of doing all of these and putting together first and I were

051speaking about this before the meeting is that you know it's as a season teacher I don't want to put words in your mouth but as a seasoned teacher you feel comfortable you know what your teachers need and and are able to pull from what you've learned over the past couple decades whereas for a for a newer teacher potentially having a a curriculum such as into reading might be very helpful to be able to start and ground and then until you do you need to get your sea legs a little bit takes a couple years to be able to really feel like oh Johnny needs XYZ I know how to do that so there are benefits for for sure to having a a standardized curriculum across I'm also pretty confident that our teachers if we do

052enter reading they're not going to lose the the skills and I just G to say that if you say next September okay Mrs Martin you're to teach inter reading the last 20 years of teaching TC are not falling out of my brain or they or from my Google Drive or anywhere else that I have in materials so I think that's the point of you know that's what you get with a veteran teacher that's what you get with teachers who've been around they get experiences from all sorts of things that they bring in we have a math curriculum we have that you know that we use that's not the only thing I use when I teach math right there are other things like well I mean Hillary Shak had shes too there are other things we

053pull from every day every week every unit because our kids need it or we need to go about a different way it's it's never ever in a classroom never ever from year to year going to be the same thing that you just wrote do um that would be very boring and not helpful to the children in front of you so whatever the program is that we're going to be using what we already know doesn't just get tossed into the can it comes with us and then we share it with the people around us so I think that's it like we have to remember that piece of it that just whether we go with a new program or an old program or whatever the program everything comes with us we take all that baggage with us

054for the good or the bad but we're going to use it to help our students move forward if if I may sorry um Katie I obviously cannot speak to certain things I'm just a teacher that is what I am a pro at teer just a teacher but uh to that point obviously we want what is best for our students right I have three little ones that's what I want when they go to school that's what I want for the children that I consider my children when I am teaching them every single day I want the best for them I think there's a few things that um again I won't go into the paas I I personally don't have an instructural Pera in my classroom every single day I haven't had one for quite some time

055I will leave that there I am pulling small groups at least once a day in all components Reading Writing math it is exhausting but it is worth every single thing the reason why I am able to do this is because with TC with the blueprints they provide I am able to literally look at a sheet that I have grouped my students and say this is exactly what they need so Katie to answer maybe one of your questions some of my students who uh are approaching Benchmark or potentially below Benchmark my first step with them is to have them draw a picture we just came out of information informational text so how to do something so we started around Halloween what did I do with the entire first grade took them on to the playground all

056four classes and I literally carved a pumpkin in front of everyone we scooped out the guts they told me how to do it and then my best Learners were able to draw a picture showing exactly how to do it the following step with that was what is step one just tell me right touch and tell so with that blueprint I was able to take students who were merely just able to take draw a picture of what we did to get to write multiple sentences across multiple Pages the previous unit this is with the revised unit the previous unit my first year you told students sketch a across Pages what does that mean to a six-year-old I don't know I don't know what to sketch across pages I don't think I could do it as a

057teacher so with more explicit small group instruction I am able to see students grow throughout that something I haven't heard us discuss um is hegerty and Foundations Julie you did bring it up uh previously in one of the slides hegerty is an incredible incredible program that I Absol adore my kids love my kids are able to say to me in class similar to word love Mrs re uh if you take away and add CH that becomes cat and it comes chat and they love this rhyming and that influences their writing so much so if I'm looking at the rubric K through two but into three Melissa and Christy please speak to us I able to see students take their phonic instruction and Implement into their writing they are now chopping out words sounding them out

058and blending them together improving their spelling which is one of the things that we obviously I think I again I can't speak to the high school or the middle school but I think that's something we want to see first graders and second graders and third graders all of our students become better at additionally foundations is absolutely essential Chris you have two girls and I will let you speak to that I am teaching my own four and a half-year-old Foundations at home because that's how important it is to her knowing her sounds and her letters it's important to her starting to learn to read and write herself if she doesn't know that she is not going to be the best reader right I see the benefits of it every single day my kids love it they

059love dictation they love becoming better readers and writers and I keep saying readers and writers because there is no those two components are not Silo they are a web they weave back and forth um and I do believe the revised units with the blueprints where I'm able to take what we are doing in foundations and teach into that in a small group right if we're working on diagraphs I can use that in their writing as we are going through um I don't know if you guys have questions I've been ranting but I do feel very strongly about uh taking the best of all that we have available supplementing GRE like the grammar I do think to what Melissa said I do think there is an opportunity there absolutely but I I just think that we

060have so many different types of Learners that we need to have a program that we are able teachers as you trust us we are able to take it and do what's best for our students yeah and I think to your point of trust TR and expertise like I think there's there's a huge amount of expertise in this district and with all of you so um I am very glad that we are taking I mean I know at times this feels you know painful and drawn out and you know like some of you some teachers have said like just make a decision already right but there there's a great amount of expertise and I'm grateful that that we are taking the time to to listen to everybody and I appreciate you being here for that so

061um I think I I think we're good any other questions Katie any other questions gr any questions good no thank you thank you for being here there might want to be a discussion about when you say that word grammar it feels like it's like this big word but I don't think we've actually talked about what that teaching means and what when you say grammar it's a very big vague word um I know in kindergarten the grammar um objectives are that they capitalize the first letter of a sentence and they capitalize the letter I so that's the two kinder Garden standards for grammar so do I need a whole program to teach those two things now I I can I can be very explicit through writing through morning message through different areas of my day to

062just be explicit and show kids what that means and hold them accountable and I don't think I need an inter reading program to teach those two skills thank you for that yeah all right um sorry one followup on that amyan can you confirm that those are the only standards for kindergarten there are other standards in the area of literacy that might be just it for grammar but I would want to I would want to look I I really right there are so many standards K through 12 literacy mathematics but Julie is saying that there that it is but again there would be speaking listening so that's a very those are too narrow within many other standards for writing Katie which may be your point so do we have a road map we of Standards not

063just for grammar but for all the other areas and overlapping that with option A and option b so Greg that that question is exactly why it's important to write and develop curriculum that's program agnostic because we want to backwards map to all of the standards and that's part of what we do in edge of Planet yeah so if we could if the board could get a memo on that that would be really helpful for us and what specifically are you looking for so we can't you were we couldn't hear you really if we could get a memo on what the current standards are for Reading Writing and grammar um we can say k through three right now since we're focused on early literacy I think that would be really helpful because I can tell you

064like as a parent having had three kids go through kindergarten that the expectations in the classroom and the output are are Way Beyond that um so it it would be nice to see what specifically is um is is the minimum is The Benchmark versus maybe what is the um you know kind of like the average output even you know there's one thing I think that you know kindergarten first grade has changed a lot our curriculum keeps getting more difficult and there's also a difference between um you know how fortunate we are to live in in darianne and such a have a such high- performing you know school with so many Sprite teachers and bright students that what a benchmark might be and what most kids are actually doing in the classroom sometimes are different as

065well keep in mind the other thing I would add Katie to what you're saying is when I said you know as far as I wouldn't want to comment on just those discrete um standards is we're often not just looking only at discrete standards but how they apply like across the the domain of literacy instruction right so I was saying with regards to speaking listening reading and writing the other important thing is when we look at the standards we're always looking at what comes before and what comes after so exactly to your point of students who are also very high achieving we want to look at the els for example before students enter kindergarten and see how those inter intersect with the kindergarten standards and we've done some crosswork crosswalk work with that and then thinking

066about again how do we have standards that are connecting in kindergarten that go beyond just what the grade level standard is there um and that's other work that we do in our curriculum right mapping so is it relatively easy for you to just create a memo with the links to like here are the here are the standards and then I was even thinking like the report cards of you know here's what's expected and I don't know how delineated they are anymore okay all right thank you for doing that okay thank you everybody Scott you've been super patient thank you very much for being here very much appreciate thank you for having us we are going to move on on to World Language Mr Webster very wonderful thank you all good morning everybody uh I'm Scott

067Webster K12 World languages coordinator and thank you for the opportunity to share with you what's going on in our world um first I have a little quiz for you all okay fun not to put you on the spot but what do you think are the five most spoken languages in the world not native languages but the five most commonly spoken languages in the world Spanish yeah go Mandarin Spanish English English yeah you're doing well so far we're doing was this like by population or like overall most spoken Hindi Hindi yeah okay yeah Russian no no it is Arabic oh Arabic yeah yeah um good job guys in so in order it's English Mandarin Hindi Spanish and Arabic according to the international center for language studies so why and I had to write this out because

068I just didn't want to miss anything um why is it important to study other languages there are many reasons including the enhancement of cognitive skills cultural enrichment building confidence and expanding one's own employment opportunities uh I would always tell my students a story about when in a previous career I worked in Market res research and one of our clients was Coca-Cola for whom we consulted they wanted to learn about consumer buying behavior in Central America uh even though I was new to the company since I was fluon in Spanish I possessed a critical asset that many season colleagues did not have and I was chosen for the exciting project to travel to Guatemala as a matter of fact I just returned from there over our holiday break and I've always stress to my students that

069our goal is to prepare them for college and Beyond building connections can last a lifetime and knowing other language is like having a superpower that benefits them in any career that they choose uh here's a summary of our students exposure to languages in our classrooms in Daran we are fortunate to begin language study here in kindergarten research shows that the sweet spot for language acquisition is that of children at a young age they are like sponges as they acquire their own native language and they can actually have a natural ability to absorb multiple languages easily this allows them to strengthen skills like pronunciation and memory and because Daran supports Elementary language education in Spanish we are able to offer not only AP Spanish language but also AP Spanish Literature when students become seniors we are

070currently running three full sections of that course to students who demonstrate admirably strong proficiency here you can witness the Journey of students from kindergarten through 12th grade and the incredible impact of teachers who have spark a love of learning [Music] this is one of the promot today we're going to be teaching you how to say goodbye and thank you goodbye is and thank you is you should take man because the language is based on real life we can see a person holding a fighting tool this gets transferred and transferred all the way to this which in modern days means I that means [Music] ourv this is just another fun activity we do Mand is so fun and you can learn so many things if you're looking for a new language then next year choose that's

071a promotional video for the rising sec so as you can see music is a powerful tool and highly effective for vocabulary retention when reviewing past material my upper classman students could instantly remember the songs from the beginning of this video that they learned at Ox Ridge or Holmes and before I knew it they're belting them out at the top of LS here's more of a glimpse into the life of language classes at Daran since language is deeply intertwined with culture students not only develop their ability to speak the language they study but also immerse themselves in the customs and traditions of the people who speak it the world Readiness standards for learning languages is a concept supported by actul which is our national governing body for curriculum development the five C's as they call it

072stress the application of learning language beyond the instruction Senate as you can see there is a compelling alignment between these standards and those captured by daran's vision of The Graduate our mission is through the instruction of language and culture to broaden students communication skills while fostering inquisitiveness and respect for other cultures we are preparing students to be curious independent and empathetic Global Citizens using the backward design approach we are hard at work in writing and memorializing curriculum in Edy Planet across our five languages and across all grade levels as you may recall this is some of the work that our colleagues completed last summer our goal is to consider these writing projects to the lens of strengthening the four skill areas which are Reading Writing listening and speaking in a comprehensive manner while aiming to

073raise proficiency at each level so you can see some of the projects we're working on this year as well some of the proposed projects we have uh for next year language pedagogy has evolved over the years and research on second language acquisition emphasizes the importance of maximizing Learners exposure to the target language for successful acquisition they're not just learning a language they're immersing in a culture that brings the language to Life Giving meaning to the words and shaping the way they view the world both teachers and students need to remain active ly engaged in using the target language as much as possible according to act guidelines instructions should be conducted in the target language at least 90% of the time across all levels so even in kindergarten this goal is achievable if the language is

074made comprehensible meaning that listeners can grasp its meaning without fully understanding every word or structure alongside using authentic cultural resources and incorporating backward design this is one of the core practices that we apply to our process as mentioned we assess in four different skill areas and additionally through three modalities which are interpersonal interpretive and presentational since we all have multiple learning styles we employ the same logic to our approach to design Assessments in addition to standard quizzes and tests we evaluate Mastery through methods like debates Socratic seminars and poetry recitations project-based learning is actually not new to our discipline rather it is long been an organic way for students to demonstrate their knowled by using the language in authentic ways we also assess proficiency by offering the stamp exam at DHS which is how students

075can qualify to earn a seal by literacy uh they can also earn multiple seals in their Heritage and Native languages spoken at home eighth graders are also currently tested with the stamp assessment and this year in reviewing our alignment to curriculum and instruction we are conducting an inquiry into the merits of this standardized testing at at that level at MMS and exploring alternative ways to to assess proficiency um at that grade level and we will share our findings with you later this spring the ultimate goal of course is for students to eventually use their skills in real world situations uh with our newly established national language honor societies for example students must fulfill service hours this can manifest in many ways like tutoring Mandarin to younger students assisting uh token Spanish teacher helping student uh

076patients at Norwalk Hospital with translating uh or even teaching French senior citizens at atria down the road we make the most of every opportunity to come together and collaborate on curriculum and instruction it's clear that we've been very productive this year we've leveraged the expertise of our own teachers through edcamps worked with L library and media staff to train on new platforms like Wei video and podcasting software and participated in webinars with the creators of tools like note which is a website that we use for vocabulary acis we remain committed to maximizing shared time whether during professional learning days or during plc's um there is a lot to celebrate in our department and here are a few notable points we have an enhanced opportunity to take a better look at linking our K12 program and

077strengthening vertical alignment 43% of our seniors earn the seal by literacy this past year which is nearly at the top of our Durk and don't worry we beat a certain bordering town and astounding 93% of students are achieving Excellence on their AP exams and languages scoring three or above which is compared to 73% nationally we also rolled out the Yukon ECE Spanish course this year so dozens of students are earning college credit uh which are transferable to most other colleges in the country uh and our language honor societies are now established chapters that are aligned nationally which offers them greater recognition and elevated status some things we are looking forward to next year include offering our ASL students the continued Pathway to the next level as well as the first cohort of MMS Mandarin students

078entering the high school stay tuned as we'd like to propose offering two International trips in 2026 to France and to Spain our International trips with DHS students have proven to be incredibly enriching offering them valuable opportunities to apply their language skills and gain a deeper understanding of diverse cultures and life Styles and you can see here two images of of previous trips that we've taken our colleagues will also continue to conduct instructional rounds where we not only get the chance to put the lens on student learning but also share best practices with each other during our vertical curriculum discussions we have identified an opportunity to improve alignment and inclusivity by revisiting the naming conventions of language courses at MMS currently courses are labeled by grade level such as Mandarin 6 or French 7 we propose

079renaming these courses to align with the program of studies at DHS this chance uh this change would not only create a smoother transition between levels but also help reduce any stigma for students studying at a different level such as a seventh grader new to the district starting new language we believe this updated system will streamline processes and Foster a more inclusive learning environment thank you so much for your time and I would be more than happy to answer any questions that you might have thanks Scott um couple just quick question about that course renaming that seems to make a lot of sense to me okay um go back to that do we need to be involved with that do you is it I mean it's not necessarily changing anything is it do we need full

080board approval I mean I don't know a new no it's not a new course so any content or curricul curriculum course okay just a naming convention so that eventually um core selection and um of course you know the guidance in School counseling will be more streamlined yeah I mean I think it makes sense I also you know I feel like you know Charley maybe you can speak to this is that some many kids that are receiving Services get pulled out of of languages and this that help would help remove that stigma um you know being correct we have about sorry shle we have about 60 students currently in eth grade right now um who are not studying language so yeah and it's just more accurate giving credence and credit to the fact that really level

081one is completed at the the Middle School level that's more accurate naming um I'm also curious SC now that you're your position is K12 what have you found in that five to six transition is there anything you do you think that there's the elementary and I want to put you spot like this is the change now but like what do you see you know from that five to six is there anything you want to change about the elementary curriculum or you know just highlights of what you're noticing or eight n or eight nine yeah sorry so unfortunately we've had a lot of opportunities to to uh to work with the K12 K5 group right and include them with the 68 and 912 groups and and have some deeper conversations about the Transitions and and while

082we found we have a really strong program right there are some there's always room for improvement right so so we are um looking forward to even next Friday having that discussion and really um like I'm having the the kindergarteners do a mini lesson and then the 12th grade Stu uh teacher do a mini lesson too just to show like what does it look like right to really kind of bring to life um our Pro and so we have some work to do there and and we're fortunate to to get to use all this PLC PLC time yeah it's great time to do that um and with the new Mandarin cohort coming up do you anticipate that you anything will need to change at the high school with those courses or no um so far not

083yet I've been working with the the middle school and high school teachers to to Really discuss what the appropriate entry level point is and and so we've we've been working on that curriculum and and we want to make a a nice streamline easy transition for those kids and um and eventually we'll be able to offer AP Mandarin which is super exciting um with your approval of course and uh so um so far so good okay awesome um Greg do you have questions Katie are you still on I can't see you um if not I will ask Rob's question oh there she is um I am I do have a couple questions thank you um I was hoping that you might be able to speak um at a high level to you know coming back to

084the slide that you had from I forget how you pronounce the acronym the Act full the council teaching foreign languages and those core practices could you just give us um you know a quick overview of maybe like the breakdown of components that students are assessed on from you know how much of it um and using the high school how much of it is writing how much of it is speaking can you just give us a little bit of expectation on what students are expected to learn and how they're assessed great question Katie uh we really look at at the top right backwards design so we're looking at the top levels AP lip AP language and looking at what those standards are and what those expectations are and really so that it just doesn't fall completely

085on those teachers to teach those skills right really we want to start that in kindergarten obviously at different levels different expectation levels but we're always assessing the four skills Reading Writing speaking and listening um K through 12 right but at at different expectation levels that answer your question yes so sorry um so to be clear then it's there's really there's four components that should should make up instruction and assessment for all levels really yeah awesome that's so helpful and then just one followup question if I may because I know it's hard on Zoom um I didn't see on this slide um of of like the core practices the best practices could you just give us an idea on what um is considered best practices for class sizes in teaching foreign language um it's a little

086lower than what we currently see in Darien um I believe Act full recommends 16 students as a maximum I think depending upon the level depending upon the level right thank you yep that's low okay um Robin is passed along a question she wants to know um how much of our curriculum and resources we are developing in-house versus you know textbooks and workbooks and that kind of stuff that's a great question so um yeah like just like Julie led to before um a resource is not curriculum right so we we pull from lots of different resources and and we do we do base our curriculum Loosely off of textbooks we use the skeleton of the of the themes and the standards and vocabulary right but uh I would say the vast majority is produced in house

087okay um you know I know there's Latin books in our budget for for this year so for each language there is a you know a set of textbooks right it is kind of language dependent as well point right like Latin and Mandarin really people rely a little bit more on okay and as okay um you know I think part of the reason she was asking this is that you know having having teachers write their own curriculum is expensive um do we feel like that's the most efficient use of our you speak to that to that model versus just we both can so what I would say is um you know traditionally how a textbook even our more current World Language textbooks for example in Spanish are written are written um in a way that probably

088many of us are on the table remember being taught a World Language so for example like a heavy focus on conjugation that's naturally not how children learn a language we think about our own children in our homes and Katie's question of what is assessed those four core language skills are always assessed like Scott said um in degrees of sophistication as children move forward with a language children naturally when they're beginning a language are practicing more of their receptive skills of speaking and listening more so obviously than reading and writing just like in English traditional textbooks focus more on that kind of traditional approach and when we think about what children are um going to be using their language for and the kind of confidency we want to develop it goes Beyond just kind of that

089traditional um reading and writing aspect and again that's what most textbooks would focus on okay so it's really important to develop a curricula that allows for more um more not only access but more relevant use of language um that's more motivating and more around comprehensible input okay exactly like the way the way I Learned was maybe a little bit more rote learning focused and textbook focused like tell me the answer to number 13 and that that doesn't happen anymore it's really like Amy said it's it's evolved over the years and it's really evolved to a point where it's it's much more student centered right it's a learner centered performance-based Focus yeah it's maybe and it's more motivating right to students um it's like there's a place for explicit direct instruction for sure but you're not

090going to go out in a in a country beyond the United States or even speak here to someone like I speak you speak he speaks we speak they speak that's just not that's not functional language so we need to have a balance of both right our students certainly need functional language that's comprehensible input for their use out in the world and we also want them to be accurate um systematic users of language and to understand how the language functions right and you know to your point it's very language dependent right like Latin is very different than those that are live languages yeah um other questions J yeah um thank you I think that since we're looking at K through3 literacy and under underlying of course we're talking about the selection of curriculum but underlying that

091is the philosophy of how we want to be teaching literacy to our young students I think it's very important maybe not necessarily today but to show an explicit tie between the skill sets that we're creating for the teaching of English language and the skill sets that work and the philosophy we're using to teach foreign language because I think we need to they should if we're picking a philosophy I would suggest this should be common across the disciplines so I'd like to see that um show up as an explicit discussion um please thanks yeah okay anything else I ask your question Scott um course I haven't prepped you for this question okay so um answered as you may uh we just we we we did a redesign right um for the position and your leadership position

092what are you finding um anything any takeaways of what's harder to deal with or not to deal with or just just just I should have probably probably but anyway we sense of like how that's working out and feel free to Good the Bad and different okay yeah no for me it's I'm very appreciative of this role it's it's very exciting I'm learning a lot more frankly about the the K5 world with which I wasn't as familiar right and um but I have a wonderful wonderful team I mean K5 68 9 12 I'm I'm relying on on their expertise their skill sets and I'm so lucky to to be working with with all of them as well and and uh to me it's exciting it's a challenge right I always like to challenge myself I have

093no other I just just wanted your reaction your EXC thank you very much for your leadership all right thank you and we will move to public comments good morning if anybody in person or online would like to participate in public comment please approach the podium or use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment we have two board members who would like to public comment go ahead Joanna hi uh Joanna wal 17 Pleasant Street um I'm not on the curriculum committee so I waited to public comment um I have I when this is about literacy I have an 11th grader who was reading at a very early age and he was like inhaling book

094series in the second grade but he was never explicitly taught how to write a Cent and logical argument when he got to high school it was clear that he was expected to know how to write one but he did not have the skills to do so and we had to hire a private tutor to remediate that and this is my anecdote but it is something I've heard from parents of my student my students peers and other parents throughout uh my time at cdsp this is something that coms up again and again and again um I also have a fifth grader he goes to a school for learning differences he is double dyslexic he still not at grade level for reading but getting close he has tremendous issues with encoding which basically means that he cannot

095the act of taking the words in his head translating them to letters and then putting them down on paper is something he still really cannot do he does everything when it comes to writing speech to text he in his writing class he already has a tremendous grasp on grammar and how to build a sentence and a paragraph and a story now my 11th grader had Teachers College writing readers and writers workshop with maybe a little bit of Foundations my fifth grader now has no Teachers College not since he left the district and I point that out for two reasons one Teachers College is not an accessible curriculum for students with learning differences if we want to start to curb out of District placement we need to move away from the workshop model two even for

096students who have no learning differences in the areas of ELA teachers college has still failed them and I think if you ask a lot of the high school teachers they will say this is also a problem and they don't have the time or the uh skill base they haven't been taught how to remediate this on on the fly in the classroom thank you thank you John hey um I guess I'm gonna loop back to literacy as well U first of all I'm not going to share anodal stories I think as board members we have to fly at a higher level but I did want to loop back uh to literacy discussion um in terms of Allen's remarks and uh I was there when Allen tried to solicit um some feedback from the commissioner State Department

097of Education at the CES caps conference and I gotta say Allan tried various angles to solicit feedback from the commissioner related to Darren's efforts to modify its curriculum and I know we're continuous uh improvement district um but Allan was looking ways to for ways that we were in compliance with the new legislation and all I can tell you in a couple word is the commissioner feedback was woefully deficient or maybe I would say non-existent and what it revealed to me um that this state department of education has no real plan or Benchmark set to um you know meet what I personally view as misguided legislation um so what I'm going to pursue as a board member is rely on all the great people that stood around this or sat around this table this morning in

098in looking for ways to continuously improve look for ways that we can find some direction from the state um but I just want to encourage you to do your your good work and in modifying uh the curriculum in pursuing that but let's not look to the state for direct answers at least based on the feedback that I saw thanks any no more ra hands okay

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.