001good morning I'd like to call this regular meeting of the Board of Education to order the next regular Board of Education meeting will be held on Tuesday January 14th at 7:30 pm. in the board meeting room thank you everyone for being here or listening online or sitting at this table today we begin our detailed review of the budget for the fiscal 20 2026 school year this budget process is a crucial step in ensuring our students receive the best possible education it's about more than just numbers it's about aligning our spending with our district strategic priorities and making informed decisions about how we allocate our resources the board of education budget representing approximately two-thirds of the overall Town budget has a significant impact on the town's Financial landscape while our power Mount responsibility lies in providing
002the best possible education for our students we must also acknowledge other crucial factors such as long-term sustainability infrastructure needs and potential economic changes facing our community it's important for us to remember that only the Board of Education possesses the authority to make decisions regarding the allocation of funds within our own budget neither the board of Finance nor the representative town meeting or RTM holds line item veto power over our budget this responsibility necessitates from us a thoughtful strategic and fiscally responsible approach as we navigate the budget review process throughout this process will'll be focusing on several key areas first the overall size of the budget we will carefully consider the financial implications of the proposed budget ensuring it is fiscally responsible and sustainable for our district and our town alignment with strategic priorities we will
003rigorously examine how the budget aligns with our District's strategic plan and ensures that our resources are effectively supporting our educational goals and thirdly evaluation of priorities we will engage in a thorough evaluation of our current priorities determining which programs and initiatives are most critical to Student Success success and which may need to be adjusted or eliminated to ensure the most effective use of our resources this process will unfold over the coming six weeks today we will hear from Administration regarding their proposed budget including a detailed uh review of each responsibility Center and how the overall budget supports our educational goals on the 14th we'll have an opportunity for further clarification of specific questions raised today and any further discussion on the proposed budget on the 28th we'll have a chance to suggest modifications and adjustments
004based on our discussions and our understanding of the district's needs in years past this conversation is sometimes focused on smaller details this year we aim to elevate the discussion by focusing on modifications that will have a significant impact to the budget these suggestions might include first modifications to the overall budget size this could involve adjustments to the overall funding level based on our analys Anis of the district's needs and available resources second modifications to specific initiatives are priorities we can propose changes to the funding levels for key initiatives or priorities outlined in our strategic plan and otherwise thirdly modifications to specific responsibility centers we can suggest adjustments to the budgets of individual schools or departments within the district the broader the recommendation we make the more it will require Administration to consider the implications to
005develop specific strategies for implementation this list is not exhaustive and we will all welcome we will welcome all thoughtful and impactful suggestions our goal is to ensure that we're spending our time wisely during this critical phase of the budget process by focusing on modifications that will truly make a difference in our students education and to the budget on the fourth we'll hold a public hearing where members of our community will have the opportunity to share their input and concerns regarding the budget we will continue our deliberations following the hearing finally on the 11th we will vote on any individual budgetary modifications and subsequently the entire operating and capital budgets on March 4th we will formally submit the board of education budget to the board of Finance there are several changes to how we're handling the
006process this year the first you've already seen and that's guidance having received a tax strategy from the board of Finance we subsequently issued public guidance to the superintendent emphasizing the importance of transparency in our decision-making process as the body responsible for fund allocation we require a more refined understanding of the potential budget reduction outcomes to Broad AR range in is insufficiently specific for Effective planning and decision-making we understand that we have decisions to make this was not a directive of a specific number but we are looking to understand the universe of possibilities so that we're not solving for something between zero and 10% it's too big a number and we can't appropriately make decisions secondly budget adjustments as noted we'll be focusing on modifications that will truly make a difference to in our students education
007and the budget Mar tubas and violins and ice machines the board values the input of our community members public comment periods are typically held before and after each board meeting today we will continue our practice of receiving specific questions after each RC and then there is a public comment period at the end of the meeting for folks who want to specifically provide input on the budget as noted a formal public hearing will be held on the evening of February 4th this dedicated hearing will provide a focused opportunity for the public to express their views on how the proposed budget aligns with our community's educational priorities it's an opportunity to speak to the budget overall not just any budget modifications but how this budget reflects what the community wants to see we urge people to attend
008and share their perspectives with the board that said as I said the other day not everyone enjoys public speaking we are also always available by email and people are certainly welcome to call any one of us with questions or concerns the Board of Education remains committed to providing the best possible education for our students and shares the community's desire to prioritize student needs and programming to ensure the long-term health of our district we must carefully review all options and make informed choices this process involves balancing competing priorities and making difficult decisions we've listed listen to the board of Finance about their ideal tax strategy right now the job of this board leadership from this board will be listening first to our school staff to our families to the public and to one another next it
009will be to make decisions but that is not until February we encourage open and honest dialogue at this table and Beyond it let us approach this budget process with a clear focus on our shared values student needs and the long-term sustainability of our District thank you for listening and with that I'll turn it to you Alan good morning everyone uh those people who are online thank you m to the members of the board for your dedicated uh time today uh regarding the budget uh to uh the members of the public here up and early on the Saturday to join us and also uh the public officials here join us today so uh we appreciate your attendance and as I shed um I'm excited today to actually share the budget details um and to hear from
010uh other administrators our administrative team uh regarding their own RC's as I shared uh on Thursday evening I'm pleased that this budget uh does protect enhances our instructional core experiences for our students uh it supports student learning through adult learning and the adult learning of teachers and it also uh provides sustainability and efficiencies yes there are challenges in it uh which are understandable uh but those are the three uh areas where I I I believe that the budget um uh it's how we form the budget this is our thought press it and um it's actually what it reflects so I'm excited to um have that discussion today and uh to welcome our administrators online and we'll proceed with the high school great and I see Ellen is online good morning to you Alan Mrs dun
011good morning good morning everyone you hear me we we can yes wonderful um so thank you all very much for welcoming us uh this morning I'd like to um take a moment of course to thank the Board of Education um for their consideration of the rc1 budget um also our dhpa and all the parents of our community um and our entire Daran Community for supporting the work of Darian High School um we are very grateful um as an Administration faculty and staff for the privilege of working with an extraordinary group of young people we are proud of their academic accomplishments their generosity of spirit their kindness and their pride in their school Community which is felt throughout our beautiful campus every day all that we do all of us around this table and as families
012and Educators is ultimately about their growth their well-being and their Readiness to take um their steps into the future um we are dedicated to their builting of confidence um in their strong academic foundation and who they are as young people um independent resilient curious for further learning and the ability to follow their passions beyond our doors and these B budget allocations um allow us to continue the excellent education that we offer at Daran high school and we thank you um taking a look at the U Personnel budget um there are three significant proposed changes in rc1 I think it's important to note of course as we've said um and Dr Alli has said in earlier presentations 90 close to 98% of the rc1 is is in the people and that's appropriate um the operating budget
013is really just a little bit over 2% of our budget so um I want to take that moment to recognize the people of Darian High School the adults who are are working with our students um our faculty um and the entire staff who share a common mission to put our students first and to make sure that they um are ready to take the steps Beyond Daran High School I thank them and I'm proud to work with all of them um so the three suggested changes um one is an efficiency um in because of change in enrollment we expect to see a decrease of 20 students at Daran High School um in the fall and an analysis of our class sizes has allowed for a recommended decrease of 04 FTE in English which equivalent is equivalent
014to two sections of um English and0 2 FTE which is one section within social studies um we believe that this recommendation will maintain the class average size of 18 in both Department departments um the next suggested change in the Personnel account 21413 is an increase of 33 FTE which is a result of the adjustment to the grant that funds the wellness center coordinator position presently um this change going into the 25 26 school year um will bring the wellness center coordinator um to be funded by 2third in the Personnel budget and onethird will remain in the grant um as you know from presentations about the wellness center um it has been a very important Cornerstone um of well-being within the in the building um there is tremendous amount of programming and activities for students it
015is a tech-free Zone um where students are welcomed and have the support of not only the coordinator but the community that has been built there um there are often connections made to interventions for students who may um need additional supports um the interaction of our team talk um counselor there is also very important and it has been a very important um initiative at Daran high school and we we thank you for your consideration of that um there are a few things of note in the operating budget um that are are being proposed um the first 12001 um consultant services this is the account that provides for the team counselor at DHS and there's an increase of $1,450 in this account um the to to pay for that programming um the merits of the Teen Talk
016counselor model were presented to the board um in early December um and I would um absolutely um add to that conversation in that um this role has been very important at the high school um it provides for um programming Leones with families um home visits when necessary interventions around um School avoidance in some situations um the the Teen Talk counselor has a flexibility as was discussed in December in her schedule that allows her to be responsive um in times of crisis in a way that is really tremendously valuable um to our entire team and um we are very fortunate to have a wonderful person in this role and also um have really benefited from her partnership with the entire DHS support team so we would really recommend that we sustain that program and and continue
017to fund that um account 22003 textbook consumables um there is a proposed increase here of $2,191 this reflects an expected increase in enrollment in American Sign Language um as well as um AP Spanish um with the um numbers of students that are coming well prepared into the high school in Spanish from um the um programming pre High School um we have more and more students that are um engaging in AP Spanish um in their third and fourth year of high school and these um there are workbooks consumable uh texts that are used each year for those and so that additional funding is is to support those resources um account 25003 professional development there is a decrease um in this account and of $850 that um is funding that was placed in the budget last year
018to uh support the decennial visit from nas that we talked about earlier this year um that is concluded and we will no longer need that funding for professional development this year account graduation um as you all know graduation is a very special uh culminating event at DHS and the costs of rentals for the event continued to increase um so the requested increase of $4,250 is to match these Rising costs $3,750 of that increase um are in place to um support a rain date um as we did this past year um as you recall we um put two dates on the calendar last year um and I think what was wise um because we ended up having a lovely graduation outside and the original date would not have been able to be outside so um it
019I think it is a smart um thing for us to prepare for as we always would love to have all of our families and extended families present at our graduation um account 2513 is entitled temporary hourly Services um the proposed increase here of $1,500 is to support an additional hour a week Beyond the school day um for our testing center coordinator um the testing center supports students who have either missed um an exam due to illness or absence um it also allows for extended time setting for students and um a place for alternate setting in some situations where students students um need an environment that is different from the classroom um currently the testing center is supported by a par educator and um that um we had extended the hours in the past um two
020hours a week this third hour um would allow for greater flexibility before and after school um and this is a very active place um the testing center averages um 5 six exams a day 49 exams a day um in November and December so it is a um it allows for students to um take their exam as soon as they're ready um rather than waiting to arrange a free period um with the teacher Etc so it is a a wonderful resource and it has been a great support to our students um account 7244 repairs and service contracts um the proposed increase here of $1,500 excuse me is requested to um as a result of the increasing cost of repair and maintenance of some of the delicate equipment at the high school so our microscopes and balances
021um in science are serviced each year um World Language labs and the yearly removal of any chemical waste from the Department as part of the safety um maintenance and and of course this is money well spent in terms of sustaining this equipment um over the long term um account 73001 um this is a request for $544 and it's an increase um over last year spending of $811 and it is for the purchase of seven Pasco interface boxes um these can either work through the desktops that are in the physics rooms or through student devices um and and the newer versions now allow for a Bluetooth connection um the probes are used in physics to um collect data um in the laboratory and it facilitates Discovery and student centered learning um you might remember as when
022I was learning physics we had um ticker tape machines and the tape would go after the card and burn little holes in the paper and we'd be counting um holes um and and trying to figure out how much time it took for that cart to go across the counter so um these probes immediately load the data put it into graphical form and really allow for excellent data and excellent data is what allows you to come to good conclusions so um the these are really important to students being able to do self-discovery within the physics environment and those are the big changes that I would highlight for rc1 thank you thank you very much alen I appreciate that I'll open it to board questions joh can now one of you remind me how we handled the
023wellness center um before we employed a wellness coordinator and uh what the budget was around that model the year before last we opened the wellness center for the first time and we opened it only um during the lunch waves and we had a um rotation of our support staff and um um really our school counselors um that took those that lunch wave only so was not open all day John at that point um and that was our kind of pilot year we saw a great success with that and so we um proposed the full-time um which started out as um with partially with the grant those people still rotate actually through during lunchtime um because we have to make sure that our Wellness coordinator has a lunch break um as part of her um well-being
024so the um it that is a nice that's the duty that they um provide for the school and it's a great opportunity for them to meet with students at that time too so so so just to sum it up it was limited hours and no budget impact it was using um existing FTE time uh that was available okay thank you and Rich and so then will you walk us through the total funding uh so when the wellness coordinator uh was added a few years ago it was funded through the ARP mental health Grant um so it was 100% And then that Grant uh starts to step down over the years uh so the current year that we're in it's one3 uh in the operating budget 2/3 in the grant so next year it's 2/3 in
025the operating budget 1/3 in the Grant and then the following year it would have to be 100% in the Opera thank you so there one more step to go basically thank you Robin do we have data um do we have data on the number of students on average per day that are attending and also the number of students outside of lunch hours um I I don't have handy um Robin the numbers outside of the lunch hours but I do have um data for you know we we average over the course of the Fall um semester now 148 students per day um in the early months of the school year we have a tendency for students to be outside which is wonderful and so we saw a little bit of a lower number there but December
026for example there were 192 students per day visiting um The Wellness Center thank you thank you I wanted to ask I wanted to ask about the um decrease in the um point4 FTE for English can you hear me it doesn't sound like this is on it's very quiet you can okay well you can um sorry Ellen if you can't hear me please let me know that sounds better um um the point for FTE in the English you um had said that that's two sections but that the enrollment decrease was 20 students so 20 students seems like it would be one section so I was just looking for a little more clarification on that yeah this this is um a change that occurred this year um Matt Pavia was point4 at the high school and took
027the position at Fitch um and so we in in um considering for next year um looking at the class sizes there are a couple of sections of class sizes that we feel sorry that we feel would be um we'd be able to collapse and so um and still remain within the recommended um 18 um so that point4 FTE would not have an increase on the current Staffing um but it it is an efficiency that we could um put forward Greg just had another follow up on the wellness uh Center do other districts in D have the same thing no no not we don't excuse me not primarily um there are there are schools across the country that that do it but not primarily the D if anybody has developed anything since then um people can
028do actually around the dark area schools if someone puts something in place or take something away uh it's not unusual for other districts to follow suit but in variations Alan could you speak to that a bit yeah I mean in terms of my conversations with our um other principles it's something that people are very curious about and um are doing in a matter in a number of different ways certainly um as we look to programming um for the wellness center we we just met and discussed um you know the extending of programming out of the wellness center and our research um with um Alicia showed it an incredible increase in the number of schools that are offering this kind of support um across the country um I'm not sure that they we have a similar
029model within our specific Durk but there definitely is a recognized need for um this kind of support Dave thanks you mentioned earlier uh some stats for daily visits question there is one what constitutes a visit and then the followup question earlier you mentioned we had an identification rate of people for additional serup from their visits give me some sort of percentage or ratio and then uh final followup is how many of those are really uh indicated or you know wind up and services being provided versus uh maybe just testing the water it turns out there isn't really much you need there and if you don't have that that's fine yeah I don't have some of that to respond to but certainly can look into it for you I mean I I don't think the primary
030purpose of the well in the center is actually to intervene um it really is to avoid the need for intervention so um I think it's a um certainly we are intervening when we see a need and or a student who comes forward or is is has changed Behavior someone who's there often the same way that we would intervene with a student in any setting at the high school but um I think it really is about the promotion of education and um the feeling among the student body that there is a place another place there are many places that support students obviously and people who do one of the things we've talked about many times around um the high school and well-being is is the need for every student to have at least one really important
031person in their lives who they can count on who they can look to and and many of these um roles serve as those people for different students and so it it has great value outside of even those interventions I guess so I will look into those that data for you as well appreciate it thank you so just to summarize let's clarify exactly what data you want um because some answer we have X number of visits a day is that somebody just pokes their head in walks by there for like a substantive amount of time okay what does that mean okay the next question is she mentioned that we have people identifying for services okay how many of those out of the 192 is the number she mentioned daily is it 19 five who knows and
032then the other question is say it's 20 a day turns out there really only two people who need something and they probably getting it anywhere else so are we really identifying anything above Beyond got it okay Sarah I would like Ellen to just a little further Define what the purpose of the wellness center is because I think there's a little it sounds like there's it's not meant to be an intervention space it's not meant to have somebody else to be a counselor there so can you talk to maybe it's anecdotal of what you know I know I know anecdotally that there are students there that are you know perfectly High achieving well adjusted kids that like to go have lunch in there because it's a quiet space and they put their phones away ever so
033can you speak to the purpose of it more and just Define it a little more clearly of course yeah I mean you know the the the importance of the wellness center for our student body um to be able to find a place a comfortable space disconnect um from the pressures of the day um find educational resources there as well um relaxation um color ing conversation Community Building um connection to and a recognition that it's important for us to take a break a space um some students will do this through the wellness center not every student will do it there um but there are just knowing that there is such a space and there are these relationships and there is a place to decompress and that we acknowledge as a school community that this is important
034for our well-being um and I think I think that really is what um how we came to the decision to create this space um and dedicate it and our students um have come to use it I think very well and um I I appreciate the the funding of this and also uh I know our student body benefits from it okay I see Dave and Greg staying on the wellness center there Wellness Center followups go ahead Dave yeah I just want to follow up and slightly respond Sarah to you I appreciate you're asking that question is the explanation was given for the justification Wellness Center that Ellen just gave comported with my original understanding but then earlier today the justification was given that we're identifying services or bus there are other use cases seem to be
035some sort of cre I was trying to understand that better so thank you okay great I was goingon to ask the same a similar question which is just if if the purpose is relaxation like why do we H why are we paying to have councelors and clinical staff there if that's not the intent are there other places where the students have access to those whether V talk whether it be psychologists in the school or otherwise if it's just supposed to be a place for them to relax on their own why we funding additional resources so is your question Greg could they relax other places or is your question they could relax in the wellness center but why do we why are we Staffing why are we funding additional Staffing of counselors service people whoever okay
036Ellen yeah the the wellness coordinator is not a clinician um so this is um we're not we're not adding a social worker or schle psychologist to the wellness center um those who are uh covering the lunch waves and our presid in the wellness center are doing that as part of their Duty um within their assignment so um the the reason that we in order to run an area like that and provide this kind of support for students we need to have supervision um of that and also someone who coordinates the programming that um we provide through the Wellness Center Joanna um I just I don't know I wasn't planning on saying anything about the wellness center but I does I feel that we're missing a piece of context which is this is the first major
037thing that the high school put in place as part of our after plan or aftermath whatever that was called when we had several tragedies in this you know two years uh in whatever year that was that spring so this was this is not just a place to go and hang out there is a real purpose there and and and I just want to don't don't get fact get lost in this conversation you an May anecdotally anytime I've been at the high school there are children are in in that uh facility and the reason why we did just summary again the reason why we went to this particular model which is a a relatively all context included uh inexpensive model for supervision was that that we were also drawing counselors out from their other spaces uh
038to cover during lunchtimes and so on and the and the kids wanted to expand it through uh throughout the day and the availability of it uh it's an important resources for what you have said M Waltz in terms of why it was in place why Allan it does set us AP part we B yes it's not something that's in every High School um but then again um every High School hasn't experienced some of the things that we have experienced and I'm very proud of the wellness efforts off this District off this community so um given how it Service uh how many kids involved in it and this sort of level of service and funding that goes to it I think it's a well-used and appropriate resource and as part of the fabric of the school
039I I would say but that that's just a big bit of context okay uh Dennis so I have comment and a question and comment is to Ellen been sitting on the board for a number of years and I always see this guitar in the in the background one day i' hear the guitar being played as you as you present your budget so you would not want me to play the guitar Dennis that's my daughter guitar is it real or is it just a background it's real it's not a prop for the for the Board of Ed I'm usually actually there and not here so okay um on on a more serious note and kind of what Dr adley was just discussing um I would I would like to request a a one-page document of the
040of the spend that we've had over the last five years on mental health and put it into one page because the mental health is all throughout the budget and it's hard to reconcile where it is because it's in six or seven different RC's and five six I think it's in seven different RC's including elementary school so I'd love to see elementary school psychologist Wellness coordinator Middle School director of mental health all just in one document for us thank you yeah some of it was rich you put together so we can just expand that maybe move it forward to this year thank you um thank you for the request on us um who Dave I just I just would fall D do want to roll that forward because I know this is a 20 going to
04140 going to 60 do we want to move couple years ahead on any of this oh with a forecast yeah sure sure yeah thank you Tran it's not to do with the wellness center mental health my questions so okay are we done with home miss Center thank you go ahead Jo um in the professional development line what does the remaining 8,515 Ina those specific programs for kill what does that look I'm sorry could you repeat that J sorry and the remaining um professional development uh money of 8,515 what does that entail what is that money being used for specifically that is money for um professional development that we hold within the school um so any speakers that we bring in or um speal professional development for groups of the special requests that teachers have to
042attend conferences and and so forth um are included within that professional development funding historically that was run on a a per per head dollar amount is it still calculated that way yes yes okay so what's what's the approximate per head and is it the same Elementary and secondary I think Rich puts those numbers in so yep it's about $65 ah ahead and it's the same Elementary and secondary thank you okay um the graduation expenses we're talking about increased rentals is that is that increase in rental costs um really looking at Rich something we're experiencing across the budget are we see are we going to see that lots of different places there's not a lot of things that we rent um so other than like the like the chairs and things like that for graduation we
043have some rentals for conx boxes and Facilities um we are more just seeing it for the you know the graduation expenses okay thank you so do you rent shares sorry this yes you do rent is it is it you know cost effective to purchase shares and expend you know down the line would that be more effective store just yeah I don't know just it's really a storage issue okay and then the testing center I'll ask now just because we don't talk about it too much during the year how many hours does it run I wasn't clear for the school day um and then right now two additional hours outside of the school day so the request in the budget is for one additional hour to that okay so it's going to open up an hour
044before school and close two hours after is that maybe a half an hour on two mornings Jill so that you know an hour before school probably isn't that reasonable to get them there okay to take test but it gives you know to give a little bit more flexibility to accommodate those students who have a full schedule on a particular day who really would like to stay after school and and complete something so are you looking for some flexibility in that is that why you're not saying I'm opening at seven or what would be S o' closing it you're looking our our coordinator is really wonderful about that and so we do it on a week- toe basis so if this week we have two and a half days he might do two days at the
045beginning of the week and extend the hours uh so it would allow for three hours a week outside the um oh I see right I see okay Katie um thanks um Jill thanks for bringing that up I just wanted to mention that this is not an area at the high school that we talk about very often at this table and I just wanted to say that um I was really happy to see um the just the thoughtfulness behind this because I think this truly is something that's very impactful to students and the flexibility and the you know just the accommodations and the the nod to um you know both how it benefits students and teachers I think is really important and this is a great service that we provide so thank you for recognizing this
046and expanding this okay all right with that we are 15 minutes behind schedule first one um any other questions for the high school um with that we'll move to Fitch and that's Ellen you again yes thank you just they're all important the um we want to SP say a special thank you to Matt Pavia and his new leadership role at Fitch um and the entire staff at fit Academy for their unwavering support of our students um at fit they've really truly created an extraordinary Community um maintaining high expectations and um a an environment a family um a a school that um honors student voice and fosters curiosity and Independence um there are no significant changes um to rc2 in terms of needs um our current enrollment at Fitch is 14 students and the expectation um
047that we are adding three more students to Fitch um beginning second semester um it is a wonderful program something that we should all be proud of and I thank you for supporting um The Fitch Academy model and and we have um a wonderful partnership um between fit and the larger setting at the high school um and there are um more and more overtime interactions of our students with the high school example now is that our students taking chemistry are coming over to the main campus as we like to call it um and um our our pursuing lab experiences at the high school where they would not have been able to really facilitate that um at Fitch so um it continues to grow and um we're very proud of of what our staff at Fitch are
048doing for our students thank you thank you alen I may justen could you just just we we sentenced or two just about the extra space that we have this year um oh yes um that was added last year um the extra space has allowed for um a tremendous um flexibility for our our um school psychologist who at Fitch um also for students in a smaller setting there's one smaller classroom there that can be used for quiet work um if you've been most of you I hope at Fitch at some point um and the original space um is really fairly open to one another and so we need a little bit more privacy and it has served us very well there um and has created um um just the the additional space that was needed to
049support um those differences thank you thank you um before I open it to questions Rich can you speak a little bit to the lease given the what's going on with the property uh so we're going to go into the third year of a fiveyear lease that property that building is not being sold it's the buildings behind it um that are all being sold so there's uh no issue with the property okay any other questions about fit Dennis going back to my early request on Mental Health I would also like to see Fitch Academy rolled into that as well because kind of touches it's not wholly mental health but I think it touches upon that again I just I think it'll be not only just a a financial document but also a a a PR document
050of how much we've done in the last 10 years on on the issue of mental health and differentiated learning and so on I I think is part of our mental health response so I think it I agree it does belong there thank you for the point Katie um just to piggyback on that um I I like this concept of of a single document for some of our um programs and initiatives that really cross our seas um you know we all know that we have a big and complicated budget and it's I thought this idea of an overview is very helpful um and to that point I think that one of the interesting pieces about fit as well is the success of a program that allows our students to remain in District especially in light of
051um The Current financial um you know significant financial contributions that we are seeing in out of District placements when you look at the total cost of what Fitch is costing for the number of students you know were we to extrapolate that to a 75,000 to $100,000 outplacement tuition we are looking at the potential for significant differences not to mention all of the benefits that are students are able to remain in Daran are able to transition back and forth in between the program as needed get the Darian high school diploma as Ellen just said come in for labs this is a wildly successful program that I hope all of us are really proud of and I think that especially in the current financial times we we need to be looking at um exactly what this is
052doing for us both financially and um in serving students thank you okay with that um we'll move on to um rc1 question another question questions Comm questions goodness gracious thank you um questions and comments from our government Partners or members of the community and I I'll allow for either one or two since I missed is there anyone online with a hand raised cast raised hands okay thank you Sarah with that we'll move on um to rc1 Athletics and physical education good morning Chris good morning everyone can you hear me okay you can thank you great um I just want to thank the board for its U continued support of the athletic program during high school you know um the the program serves upwards of near 80% of the student population during high school so we
053serve a large number of of students High School um it's a robust program um want to thank the board for its continuous support um of the athletic program and the students who participated um and staff um at during High School just going to highlight a couple of um the budget line rc1 um there's no new request just some changes um uh first one would be account 101900 uh the suppli uniform uh budget um as you know we went to a three-year cycle a number of years ago for uniform replacement um there were some deferred uniforms that were placed into this year's budget um which is why you're seeing U the increase um in in that account um those uniforms are delineated in the uh in the narrative that you see in your in your budget
054books um account 10191 rentals you'll see an increase there of [Music] $22,700 fees you'll see an increase of1 15,590 um you know those fees support our teams to uh participate in in and um postseason uh tournaments um you know we see normally an increase in those accounts U for the number of teams that participate in those in and postseason tournaments as well as this year as of our teams to participate in some sub Varsity tournaments we're seeing an increase in the number of teams that are offering some varsity participation tournaments both in and postseason and so um we have like to have our student athletes be able to participate in those as well is well you see the increase um in that account as well um I'd be happy to take any questions um if
055anybody has anything um regarding those accounts or any other accounts in rc11 okay Joanna could you just repeat what you said about the fees are they're just for tournaments are they just are they inseason postseason how does that so we have teams that participate in both in and postseason tournaments um at the vars and now we're seeing at the sub varc level um for example you'll see track teams participating in some um invitation uh during the inseason uh which will allow those student athletes participating to to uh get qualifying times to qualify for end of season um um both state and and Regional tournaments um wrestling um participates in tournaments which there's a fee associated with those um those events in which we um you know would like to support um those those children and
056students participating rich you provided us with a bunch of data about um non other districts who do nonak fees what that looks like um would you please um provide that you can if you want to highlight it tonight be today it' be great but would you please provide that report in the context of the other budget questions so we all have it fresh sure um I mean just a little bit of a highlight there are some districts that provide nonic Sports um but it's funded outside of the board's budget so it could either be a fee it could be booster club support so new Canan for example is primarily like booster club support um which is something similar to what's being proposed to okay um Greg and and Katie um just a question on the
057transportation piece is there have we done any recent studies on that in terms of trying to find efficiencies with respect to scheduling shared buses or anything like that so um you know as much as we can we try to use for student buses because they are less expensive um the issue is lack of Drive um and so that's what's really driving up the cost uh the first student contract is also going up 7% um one of the issues that we have is that there are not a lot of uh Transportation companies willing to service Daran because of a lack of a bus depot so where other districts might be able to use a datco and SDA or first student Etc we don't have that option um and when first student is down drivers because we
058do share a space with Stanford um Chris and his Department are forced to look at like charter buses which are more expensive do we do we use any of the vehicles that we own for transportation for those um we have not yet so the problem with that is the high school has to leave at 2:30 those drivers are picking up students at the same time and so they're not available what about on weekends uh we have not at this point in time done that yet um they really would only be available for things like uh golf where it's a smaller team the issue that you're going to have is those drivers would then have to be paid time and a half because it would be above their normal 40 hours um and a time and
059a half half plus the cost of the vehicle and everything like that you don't really end up with a lot of savings kayen thank you um you know just following up on what Greg had asked I just wanted to remind um everyone that um we did have a request for a transportation update as well and an overview which I think is important um as we as we have Rising costs and we need to look um for efficiencies there um so I look forward to that coming soon um we're regarding quite a few things that um are intermixed here into Athletics Transportation being one of them I'm curious how we might um look to establishing some policies and some changes that might find some Financial efficiencies without either limiting student participation or shifting um to you
060know a a player tax a pay for play that's been struck down a couple of times by this board already for example um my understanding is that we have sports teams that might roster say 18 players for um a game but that we take the entire team that's maybe double that to an away game and I'm wondering if we have policies where only those rostered players are dressed and transported if suddenly we might have between varsity and JV we have one bus needed instead of two I think there are some things that we need to look at in terms of um you know some of the inequities that we have in terms of teams that cut and teams that don't and and who's bearing the financial burden um before we start shifting it to certain
061places um so I I have some concerns about our transportation and our policies um I I would like to see um a little clearer information on the nonca sports here um we have if it would be helpful to see a breakdown of exactly what the the full parent um obligation would be on this um because it's essentially doubling there's already a portion paid by um by parents um and we don't we don't have the combined total in here um I'll stop there for now so that I heard three questions I'll start with the last one so we're adding to the nonak fees report um an understanding of the full parent obligation um the second piece you asked about was cut no cut are you asking for a cut no cut discussion um not exactly not
062in terms of this budget no um for the scope of this conversation um in a long a larger conversation I think I'm saying that I I think that we have a lot of inequities in our athletic department I think that we have a lot of things that we do not understand about exactly how much is being paid by parents and the community versus what is in the board of education so for myself I do not feel at all comfortable levying taxes on um arbitrary portions of our population when we don't understand the full scope of who's paying for what okay so what I would say is I think that this board instead of coming at this large program with like hits to budgets here and there year after year I think that we need to
063look at this department and consider setting some policies um and taking the time to do that so that we're not constantly having discussions over throwing taxes at here and there okay so I think that um there have been a multiple attempts to come up with what the board wants in terms of the scope of policies so we have a master agenda discussion on the 14th if you have something specific you'd like to propose around a set of policies or a policy please do that at one of the master agenda pieces if it's not a budget um beyond that um we have heard the question before about um how much parents are actually paying and I I do understand a lot of our teams Levy fees that are um optional um but are often comparable to
064what you know this this type of this this type of funding so um there has he's that was part of the report already right the optional the optional fees well optional and okay all right good so we'll part the information did that include um fees to captains and Captain's parents and and all that stuff it was not comprehensive I remember that report and I I know all right let's take a look at the report and then if we need more information will request it okay all right so we're getting that report and plus full parent and and we'll have a followup for the master agenda okay um Dennis then Robin then Sarah so I will say I am assuming we're staying on fees for the moment I am in a similar staying off fees on
065okay so I'm in a similar situation as Katie is is I feel there's an unfair unfair is the wrong word but I'm struggling with having the the four teams mentioned which are non CX which three of them already pay outside fees for is is like a double tax on them but honestly I think and I'm kind of with Katie on on where I'm struggling with is how many teams are non cak sports or these the only four or is freshman football a non CX sport is is JV girls hockey a non and so that to me I'm struggling with that so yeah me meaning are you actually struggling with the definition of nonse or are you asking if that's the right um boundary maybe both but I think the first one is non CX sport
066so are all our JV Sports and freshman Sports not are cak sponsored Sports so rich or go ahead Chris yeah I I would say they are I mean they're they're govern the rules um you know when C sets the rules and guidelines for sports it doesn't it doesn't um you know delineate between Varsity JV freshman um they only delineate you know the uh the postseason Varity sports but in terms of start dates um rules and regulations at the varsity JB freshman level they're all um you know under the same umbrella for the cic okay thank you so the second piece of Dennis's question was whether or not you looked at another framework uh that was beyond non-ci and then we had again we had a couple of different things in your report did you look
067at a JV versus Varsity or any other type of framework to to in line with what Dennis is asking I mean I think in in in the budget book you have the the breakdown of what the subar sports all costs yes of you know JV freshman levels yes um so we so we looked at in this particular uh RC type thing and Chris has has profiled but there are two things in there one there's the net uh sort of deferral of uniforms type thing right um what we deferred last year to pay for and then a deferral again this year then we did a redu or sorry um a format of pay here for for non cic sports those are the two things when we look holistically just for we second at the budget um
068how it might impact um Athletics right um I tried not to in the whole budget even though it may look like it in some areas maybe we talk a we bit later right um talented gifts at ourselves and to to take away programs I tried not to do that um and make sure kids can get service in some capacity the way we did one of the ways we did it here was through the deferral uniforms and a a contribution Revenue um opportunity quite honestly I mean this is this is the one that felt at the time uh given this non cic was a reasonable into it the board has discussed some length and different opportunities um it's not the only way to to rece uh increase revenues there are offset um there's other ways of
069doing that we tried not to to complete programs um and therefore we fell on this one um I'm just sure as a superintendent I would fall on another one if we if the board could come to call us around another better idea around how to contribute but I thought that Athletics um in terms of contributing to the whole budget that was a sort of philosophy behind Okay Robin um this excuse me on the same on the same note just that the sports the existing sports that currently pay for outside rentals my understanding is that swim and dive are excluded from that and there have been parents who have asked in the past for Equitable treatment between all the sports that utilize outside facilities and I just given the budget circumstances that we're looking at right
070now I think it would be helpful to see that data what the net budget impact would be and I know that there's a YMCA reciprocal agreement in place but it also would be helpful to understand and I don't know if this is available for public but just for swimming I guess it's swimming and basketball revenues and those are somehow kind of all in that agreement is there a way or what would would there be a a budget impact that we could evaluate as part of this discussion that would allow us to have Equitable treatment for all the sports that utilize outside facilities just in the name of equity among programs so I think the question is can we see what swim and die rental fees would be and are there any other sports that I
071don't think there are but are there any other sports that might fall in that so if there is the equivalent cost sharing that hockey squash sailing and ski currently pay every year for the use in the rental of the outside facilities I think that was for diving when you gave us that in the past ,000 but for swim we were never given that information exch they don't charge us um we don't charge them could you put a value around that though Rich that's my question because if we if we separated that and instead had revenue from basketball court rentals coming into our budget and then had the outside fees for swimming pool rental and a 70% cost share by those parents what would the net budget impact be if we separated out those line items
072what I mean we can put that together but when we uh when that happened during Co when we weren't allowed to essentially rent out facilities it ended up being kind of a um we're going to charge you what you're going to charge us kind of scenario where their rates went up uh to comparable against our rate so there wasn't really like an offset but we can delineate that I I think it would be helpful to see the information just that we have a full discussion and I think this would also answer a lot of parents requests over past years sorry can I just piggy back on those gymnastics fall under that same umbrella so can we add that to there gynastics yeah um Joanna Then Greg um just oh Sarah I forgot Sarah I'm sorry
073Sarah then I'm sorry Sarah then Joanna you never look right it's all good um I I I'm just gonna from a 30 000 foot view this RC has always been super frustrating to me and I I think I've made that clear in the past um I think we need to be most concerned about what's happening in the classrooms in the academic piece of our kids and I am very frustrated to see a 7.65% increase in rc11 when we are cutting academic programs and and Personnel that are inside our classrooms so I would like to know a couple things what did you look at to potentially reduce this RC because it looks like it just rolled forward minus the nonc cic tax for lack of a better word and also I would like to better understand
074what the minimum amount of participants is needed per sport because to me 127 people on a football team seems quite excessive but I don't know maybe I'm wrong but I would like to see what you know the individual sports what you need to to field teams um and whether this gets into the cut no cut discussion maybe it does but I don't see how to the point of sustainability of this District how rc11 can keep growing at this rate when we're having to cut classroom so Sarah there's two different minimum pieces do you mean what is the minimum I think I think you mean what is the minimum number to field an effective sport do you also mean what is the minimum number to make a team yeah I mean if you were gonna you
075know for so tennis has you know five courts times four you know I don't know what if you were going to have the minimum amount of people on a team keeping in mind you know injuries and whatever but I I would I some of these teams seem really really large and they're very very expensive okay I think that is a cut no cut discussion um so are you asking for that in the context of this budget I think it would be interesting to know what the what we are paying on top of what a minimum fielded team would look like how much extra are we paying to not cut in some sports okay um Rich can you provide that yeah and Chris together okay also adding on to that I'd also like to know what
076all the rest of the um schools in our Durk do whether they cut they don't cut how big their teams are that sort of so I guess we're going cut no cut into budget season well I mean it's a policy it so for me is okay is who decides on the cut no cut is it by coach is it by Chris who who makes that decision for each team right now it's by coach okay um I wanted to go back to the rentals so sorry just to clarify are you looking for cut cut I mean if doing it we're doing it I'd like to have the information as well cut by cut no by team by Durk yeah through the Durk you know like other successful teams do they look are they the same size
077they practice the same like what does it look like in other districts okay but I had a question yes go ahead um which I now lost oh so if we are T if we have made the decision or if the district has made the decision in the past that um the only reason that these teams are inequitably charged extra money for rental fees is because we don't have facilities in house um I would like but we're now going to look at it because we extended to what you would have to pay for uh swimming because we have this uh contract already um I mean we rent out our facilities on the weekends when they're not being used for our teams what if we made every team pay for their rentals how much would that cost
078I'd like to know what that would cost for every single team if they paid us back by district for the team just a question with that Jo would that include the the cost to retf a field and things like that would that would you take that onus on sports teams because some some are some are paid by the deran athletic Foundation some are paid by the school so the track the track we have to resurf because those also are maintained for um educational just just wondering what rabbit hole we want to go down I think what would it cost okay just a minute facilities if we were charging our own team so just walk me through how we would use that information I'm not disagreeing with getting it but what are we going to do
079with it so if you have that information then you want to what just understand well if we're talking about doubling the price of people who already inequitably pay for their rentals why are no other teams having to to carry that burden so it would be nice to know what burden they get because we have a participation fees proposal that we looked at in the fall that smoothed it out for everyone so if the goal is equitability participation went in the fall uh well uh that was in August it was in sorry in August uh we we looked at what participation fees would be if we just charged it to create an equitability I'm not we're talking about rental fees though these teams pay for 70% of their rental te fees so what would the price
080be for 70% of each team's rental fee okay so that's why I'm asking what you want to do with the data do you want to Levy a cost to parents in which case we're looking at a participation fee that's not my intent but I think if some parents are paying something it would be helpful to know what other parents aren't paying okay I think Dennis's point is accurate that it's yes we can we can use the rental fees it's just it depends because if you're paying something at the Y we the track we use the turf we use the gy for educational purposes as well so I don't think the maintenance of that would be included how difficult rich is it to produce this I I mean it would take some time we'd have to
081figure out how often um when we can work with Chris you know are they using the football field or the baseball field things like that um in facilities you know what's that how often we're using our own facilities and then trying to level level a value on but that's my point right there's a huge huge amount of money theoretically that these teams don't have to pay but these other families now have to pay them yeah what's the opportunity cost of using our own facilities we can do that in the classroom too I mean this is but we don't charge people money to use our classrooms well they do taxes but you know we're not living in extra tax so that's why I'm asking the purpose Joanna because I I hear you on that if the
082goal is to to equitably spread out funding then you're really talking about a participation fee we do already have a model for that um if if the goal is you know depends have to be you know if uh the track team runs on the track and no one else uses the track that you know the or sorry if the track team uses the track and um I'm getting tired of a m comment but you you see my point do do you mean that a track team for example might have pay more of more of a cost because of the expense of their facility versus a football team might pay whatever the cost of their facility is versus a tennis team might it it it would cost a different amount to rent the turf than it
083does to rent the gym does it not um yes but then you you look at different rates of use so you might some of them might go up or down depending on the rate of usage but I I I would suggest that if the real goal is to create an equitable funding model that the best outcome is to look at the participation fees model versus to try and back into because then at this point you start to I think get very different outcomes track is a cross country for example is a smaller team so while the the Cross Country Loop might be less expensive to maintain it's on less heads so I'm just asking you to consider I understand your point yes um or or refine your request and then we can get back to
084it because are now okay okay um who was next it was Katie okay oh I think it was Greg it was Greg then Katie yes I would just make just a couple observations one I think Sarah you you made a comment about the 7.8% increase in in this one 100,000 of the 180,000 increase is related to something that we deferred from last year to this year if you remove that it's actually a 3.5% increase just Greg I can't hear can we mute that person thank you sorry go ahead Greg sorry uh do you want me to start again please so s had made a comment about the 7.88% increase for this yes um I think we need to just take that in context we deferred $100,000 of the $180,000 increase in this uh RC from
085last year to this year if you remove that it's only a 3.5% increase my point was it it just seemed like we were just moving from the last year to this year without any I also think if we're going to ask for minimum team requirements for sports we need to be very clear about potential unintended consequences of that if you take 150 Boys on a football team and you cut that to 11 I think there's going to be a lot of boys that may may turn into the mental health issues that we're talking about that we'd really rather not I'm aware I I would like to know what the minimum is um and then I did have just one question um related to the line item for the for the fees that we're talking about
086the new fees that we're talking about what's the dollar amount of the increase related to that the fees for charging non cic or yeah what's just the total uh so it would be $64,000 thank you so I just I want to just flag something Greg just said I I do think that one of the things we run into as a board is we have to talk about what might it look like if we cut something um let's make sure that we know that we're just in deliberation stage so whether we're talking about idea where we're talking about PA professionals whether we're talking about the size of a sports team we do need to probably be able to talk about what it might look like if we've shrunk something but also understanding there might be un
087intended consequences as part of that discussion yeah okay Katie thank you um I I just want to say from a highlevel perspective for this board going forward for today and for these complicated conversations like Athletics I think that it is important for us as a board to try to work together and to try to um respect differences of opinions and also to stay at a high level what I'm hearing is that this board doesn't feel comfortable completely with all the information about Athletics that there are a lot of questions and I don't think that we are going to be best served by right now at the beginning of a budget season going tit fortat over certain facilities and certain Sports what I think we need to do is have a better understanding and a bigger
088picture of what is a very valuable and important program at Daran and I think that part of the problem is that we have been trying to Hope at specific pieces to get certain amounts of Revenue out of it and when we are tasked with making decisions that have implications on our town our community and our students it's very difficult to do that without complete information so I would like to say that again I think that we have tried and not been successful at getting the clearest picture that we need for this department and I I don't see that happening in the middle of this current budget discussion but I would like for that to come up in the master agenda can I um after Robin okay after Robin um I know this is a complicated
089discussion I think given that we already have the analysis done on participation fees which was presented and and um discussed I think it was in our August board meeting it would be valuable to maybe bring back that analysis which was pretty comprehensive and I believe also showed what was done um in durg a in other schools um not only for non sex sports but I'm talking about the full participation fee proposal that was put forth for athletics and I think also for clubs and counil just so that the board has full information I know that we rejected that in our earlier conversation but given the budget implications that are currently on the table with the current budget that has been proposed I think it would be worth it to have that conversation as a board
090and have the date on okay so we'll have the analysis from August repackaged in the board materials John so this is my sixth and probably final year on the board and this sixth time we've uh struggled over this RC so when people are looking at the master agenda please please please be specific in what we're looking for because we spun our wheels on this and I think people out in the audience are also aware of that um so that's that's the one request um the oh the the other thing I want to remind folks is one question Rich where do we have the advertising uh fees now uh reflected so it's an rc11 uh in account 10201 okay so you know we have looked at ways of raising revenue uh without impacting the programs and
091at first it was you know pushed back on but I think it's been a wildely successful program hopefully we'll we'll look at that in the finance committee in the new year and we can maybe even expand upon that but these are small dollars um I guess the other question I had oh I'll leave it at that okay I just want to make sure we answer your yes yes I'm yes I actually have a smaller question just about uniforms okay okay go ahead and then um uh I noticed that in the deferrals um in 20 you had track and Fields or sorry track and cross country um on the schedule in um 2023 for 2020 it just doesn't seems that it fell off so all the things that were um sorry I'm not speaking at well
092at all here it's okay um I feel like you said that they on this on at this year's um uh bo book it says that the cross country and track team got um their un but last year it was set to be this year so if you deferred everything but the you know the things that we do every year is that just a Mis cut and paste Chris and rich do you know uh we'll take a look at that okay cross cross country cross country check um Bo go okay so Joanna just circling back do you want to just start with the fee structure or are you still looking for a cost of facilities by team I need to think about it okay I'll bring it back that's a fair point okay um Robin M
093um on intramurals I'm noticing so Elementary in murals is increasing 8,000 I believe that there was only one Elementary School that actually did run inos over the past few years so what's the thinking behind so it's not a it's not an increase so during the year we did have a transfer that the board approved that took the funding away from those four schools so the budget's just assuming that all five will run okay and then for same question for Daran high school because it looks like we had zero intermurals but we have it budgeted this year is that a similar situation okay thank you okay Katie thank you um I had a question about uniforms as well um so given the deferral that we did last year and um I'm I'm just curious if this
094isn't something that we want to look at more broadly and potentially about extending further um uniforms are an important part like we will continue to fund them that's not the question I just wonder if what was the impact of deferring them last year was that fine can we potentially stretch out our replacement cycle more um it seems to me you know like that that might be an area where where we don't need as much new stuff as often so um Chris I don't know if you have a specific response to that right now if that was something you considered if it's something that we can go back to but that seems to me an easy potentially a place where we could limit some spending without impacting student participation yeah I I think essentially what you
095did is make a three-year cycle a four-year cycle by by um the in some of those uniforms from last year and that's something I think we can look at moving forward if you want to move from a three to foure cycle um for uniform Replacements and how that would impact you know not only the vars team but the subar teams because we generally use those older vars uniforms that are gently worn to the sub varc teams um when we replace the VAR uniforms yeah I think that would be great if there's also board support for that okay so you guys will take a look at what would happen if we move to a fouryear cycle it's a four-year cycle it is okay so you've made that adjustment that you would this year okay and and
096you questioned out subsequent Years also to a fouryear um excuse me um could I request then that perhaps we could see like a very quick comparison of like what we were spending on a three-year versus a fouryear I think that that would just be you know again to Sarah's point about the RC and its increases like that would nice be nice to see of you know where we have moved it all right anything else on this RC no thank you I'll take questions and comments from the public sorry excuse me from government officials the public uh Crystal Hill chair of cdsp um I think the board has touched on the sort of same things that I'm hearing from the parent community in terms of this RC um you know it's one of those things where
097parents are super supportive of our athletic programs I think the vast majority of our students are involved at them at some level and we certainly want to encourage um as many participants as possible to be involved but in this sort of environment where we're you know we're cutting a gifted program from students who feel that that's very important to their mental health I think the question becomes like where are their efficiency some of these roster sizes are very large like those are extra uniforms those are extra busing costes like there must be some efficiency somewhere in this in a year where we don't have to make hard choices you know great like let's have 34 kids on a soccer team but you know in other years maybe that's a more challenging thing to do um
098and I just think in this environment parents are asking like why are we not taking a harder look here versus you know making choices about gifted programs or pair of Professionals in our schools thank you okay anyone online I just uh given what we've heard and the we've done I won't call it I won't use the word that we've done the the Deep you the Deep Well the Deep di okay um I didn't want to be the one to put on the table we've done a number of those like over the years and I respect the board's dilemma here um I would sort of suggest the three to four the the recycling of the schedules and stuff that's fine but generally if you're looking to make a contribution there's there's a lot of information that
099has been provided over the years and we can compile it again and added for added in to the discussions I would encourage certainly the board can do what it we us to do to look at some sort of contribution whether that's putting the whole pile of money in for athletics and itally just just distribute it um that's fine or anything in between the cic is one version of it for that reason I would I encourag the board to think about going down that way for efficiency of discussion on this and honestly I think probably where you would end up anyway if you did end up but just commentary on SP forward how you forward and just from a procedural way you know we've carved out some again we we get into policy during the budget
100season because we have to I mean we try to avoid as much possible but we have to in certain cases especially in tight budgets so maybe this is something we could carve out and really figure out what we want to do as a board finally um maybe six time will be a charm for me okay and just a comment on on um parent comment other the things we looked at the staff and and that this department uh from secretaries to assistants to we don't have secretaries but we removed that but uh the St we did look at the staff in in this requirment as a part of the discussion okay Peter one administrative matter uh on behalf of uh everybody here and probably people on Zoom would everybody please take care to speak clearly into
101the microphones because it's been very hard to understand everything that's been discussed thank you um Are there specific ones of us that are struggling with it not because I want us called out but it's helpful to know it's helpful to know if if you're the one or is it all of us it's the two of us okay get closer is that better yeah that better okay good okay there go thank you away if you're on your yeah all right all right all right we'll work on it thank you guys for the feedback sorry I just want to go back to what Dr adley just said about participation fees is this is this something that you want us to come up with or are you going to come up with something or are we going to
102do this in today and come up with an answer or we we already have a lot of the work done so when we come when we reconvene on the 14th we'll take a look at what's already been done um because there have been some questions again it's it's been rejected multiple times but every Year's a new year so um yeah this was this was one version of it I think we can pull from what the other versions that we had just trying to understand what what are how we're working thank you yes so the the requests were for um nonak fees to to understand the work that was done before um and for the non including the nonc fee work and what the full parental obligation would look like to understand if we were to
103monetize swim and dive and gymnastics rental fees to understand the price of a minimum uh or size of a minimum team and what that what that differential cost if we're not running a minimum team um then we were asked for no cut no cut through the dur we were asked for the we're going to look again at the analysis from August and to understand what the savings are of moving to from a three to a fouryear cycle for uniform is that still all the information everybody wants okay Jo and then Robin yeah I it's not I don't want any more information I just want to say that we've we have had the discussion participation fee or no participation fee yes I don't want to have that discussion again okay I want to have a discussion
104about what other efficiencies are we missing because and and they might unfortunately be policy based you know do you send your entire team to away game what is the transportation things if you don't there are other ways to do this without making things so black and white are we able to answer the question Rich and Chris just that specific one of of are there savings if we um don't send a full team or sorry if we send the team that are needed to play but not the third string if you will or the JB yeah I think that goes back to the question about minimum number of kids required that's going to look different for each sport and I'm you know I'm RL my what that's going to look like you know because one program
105is gonna look a lot different than what another program might look like so answer it in that context though each sport has a minimum number of kids required to put on the field so I'm not sure if you're looking for that information or you know because certain Sports have more likely you know um likelihood of injuries and that that I think would play into that to that to that number so it's I have to just think wrestle with and okay great thank you for wrestling with it sure will do um okay I have Robin then Katie then I see bath in the audience um I'm just just adding to the list that you mentioned Jill I um the participation fee model that had been discussed in the past I'm not sure the it would it
106included Athletics also clubs and councils at all levels and that was not what was discussed in August I think it was a prior discussion we had and it was pretty extensive but Rich had put together an analysis I think it was from a year ago in November or something but that was it was helpful at least to have that data all right so both analyses thank you Robin for that uh Katie thank you um on uniforms Chris I'm just wondering if um if it makes sense to have a set number of year replacement across the board or if certain uniforms are more heavily used and don't last as long for example would it be possible to move to a 5-year replacement cycle are some Sports able to do that and some sports not um I
107think again just you know if we're looking into stretching out some of this that's a good one so um I wouldn't expect you to necessarily have that answer now but if it's something you could think about and come back to us that would be great okay John so just is is part of this overview also we have revenues coming in associated with u athletics and also summer school relevant revenues so just you know if we could have the offsets there um I know the question I was looking at there's a RC that talks about security and officiating um is there any way you can break out the sports related Security expenses from the officiating expenses on that RC uh Rich thanks okay so we just added the older analysis um we just added whether there's
108other time frames for uniform replacement cycle um the offsetting summer school revenues from athletic teams and and any other revenues date fees okay um we also have the uh advertising gate P okay and then we you just asked to separate out security and officiating costs on that one RC okay um Beth Beth Lane 16 Hill Crest Avenue and uh Vice chair for the education budget for FNB just a quick all while we're talking about data just quickly perusing the like cut no cut list that's in the binder I did notice an anomaly so you might want to go back and just check with your coaches in Prior I can only speak to the ski team because that's what my kids have all been on in Prior years there have not been Cuts in this year
109there were Cuts so that the whole ski team fits on one bus instead of two I imagine that makes a rather large difference in the outcome of cost so it's possible that some coaches may have changed their policies you might want to just go back and check and make sure that that's the only one I know about and I know he changed his policy this year but it does have fiscal implications the policy change was made by the Connecticut inter cisl the ski League put a cap on number kids that teams can roster that wasn't the coach's policy oh okay yeah that was that's new that's brand new this year okay but it's not reflected in that right that needs to be updated and so I think it's probably also not reflected in the budget
110numbers properly thank you we'll check it thank you okay with that we are only six minutes off schedule not bad um I will move on thank you Chris okay thank youate it good morning Kate Middle sex Middle School um off we go good morning can you hear me okay yes we can thank you great okay um I want to First Express my appreciation to the members of our community who are listening and participating today thank you to the Board of Education our supportive middle sex parents Association and the broader Daran Public Schools parent community and other members of the Daran Community including the RTM and board of Finance thank you for taking the time today and in the coming weeks to consider the budget presented in order to realize the district's vision for each of
111our students that they may be prepared today to thrive in a changing world tomorrow I also want to recognize the members of our faculty and staff who are listening to today's meeting while in darianne we know that our schools exist for children we also know that the success and impact of our children's experiences in our schools relies on the work and commitment of the tremendous Educators and School staff I am proud to be with you this morning representing middle sex Middle School MMS is a wonderful educational institution dedicated to nurturing our middle school students as they academically and socially as they evolve from elementary school child to high school adolescent in the 25 26 school year we are projected to have a total of 1,61 students which is an increase of 15 students with 375
112in sixth grade 347 in 7th grade and 339 in 8th grade the MMS rc3 whoa she'll be back am I still here how precarious I apologize welcome back my laptop fell I'm so sorry the MMS rc3 budget narrative reflects our commitment to continuing to foster a strong School culture and climate that supports our students development not only through academically robust offerings but also through diverse and strong co-curricular programming resources to support student wellness and impactful professional learning as Dr adley presented on Thursday night his budget proposes the elimination of the K8 idea gifted program at MMS this is equivalent to 1.6 FTE or reduction of 191 867 currently 160 students participate in instruction for gifted programming twice per week during their 42-minute lunch period opportunities for their Stu these students to continue their growth will
113be provided in the general education classroom through differentiated practices curricular extensions as well as through schoolwide enrichment and extracurricular opportunities as Dr Ali presented we will continue to build our teacher capacity to meet the unique needs of each of our Learners through professional development and professional learning communities in account 1010 20 theater and music stiens we are requesting $ 57,8 43 which is an increase of 8,353 because MMS does not currently offer a curricular theater program students access to participating in theater at the middle school level is through extracurricular programming we are proud of our expanding and inclusive Performing Arts programs this year there are 90 students in the cast of Legally blonde Jr which is a 133% increase over last year's production the addition of the proposed assistant director for the musical will allow
114us to continue to run a no cut musical program while providing adequate supervision paired with high quality Direction an additional opportunities for our students to hone their stage performance skills began in the 2324 school year through the drama Workshop advisers volunteered last year and intend to do so again for this year's Workshop production by contract and past practice if the program continues to run for a third year in 2526 the advisers would need to be paid middle sex middle school has therefore proposed three new stiens the drama Workshop director drama Workshop producer and drama Workshop stage manager totaling $443 funding the continuation of this program will allow MMS students to have exposure to a variety of performance genres and skill development as Dr edley referenced in his presentation on Thursday evening the budget also includes
115proposed items to support professional learning that enhances our students experiences and learning middle sex Middle School is requesting an increase of $2,850 in line 25003 professional development These funds are intended to continue professional learning with the Anti-Defamation League who Prov provide programming in areas including anti-Semitism anti-bias and bullying and cyber bullying prevention this professional learning supports our continued commitment to fostering a positive safe and inclusive School climate at middle sex middle school and in the deryan public schools finally as Dr Alicia dad and I presented to the board in December middle sex middle school has benefited from the addition of a Teen Talk counselor from kids in crisis this year in addition playing a critical role in student crisis assessment and response this trained social worker with Middle School experience is enhancing MMS by participating
116by partnering with our counselors psychologists and social workers to identify and meet the needs of both specific students and the student body at large as we consider both the evidence of student needs within our Daran community and the broader youth Mental Health crisis we have included in this budget proposal the continuation of the team talk counselor while this position was entirely Grant funded for the 2425 school year Dr adley's budget proposal requests up to half the cost which is indicated as $50,000 in account 12001 consultant Services the Community Fund has informed us that there is a forthcoming onetime $50,000 donation we're grateful for this news and look forward to receiving that letter of support the district will continue to work with the town Department of Health around potential additional funding which could further reduce the
117board's portion this covers the major changes in the recommended rc3 budget for next year thank you thank you very much a lot to be excited about in here in particular thanks to the Community Fund it sounds like they've gone outside of their normal process um and it's exciting to hear of their support um in particular at this point in the budget process because we usually don't know until June um it's certain exciting to hear about the theater I'll open to questions Joanna um in the professional development line um it says that you're only raising it 3,000 years you over year but that requests an additional 6,000 for the for the PD from the ADL so wouldn't that be 12,165 so there was a there was a reduction to PD that was for specifically for this
118year for restorative practices and net lines so it's netting the two together okay so that's still the $65 ahead or whatever it was plus the ADL yeah okay any other questions about Middle School Dave thank you you guys good in the back so two questions Jill um one is very high level and I'm gonna give this Dr adley and if you could come back I don't expect an answer on the fly but just from an educational perspective I know Sarah likes to talk about we educate the the whole child we look at theater uh from middle school and having no Cuts we're talking about the high school looking at Athletics and thinking maybe we should have Cuts there could you talk educational philosophy why you would want to have cuts at the high school level
119for athletics but you want to make sure everybody participates in Middle School theater and I I don't need it now unless you really want to no yeah actually that that Contex is are probably appropriate and I have cont may be appropriate to even say before we started this uh budget uh discussions by RC uh it in this particular and this is one example of it we didn't exclusively going through the budget process with our RC's chairs and our administrators uh you will predominantly see not many uh significant improvements or improvements additions okay in the actual budget items but there are mest ones and this is one of the mest ones that I made a a value judgment on in the sense of in in including as many students as possible in these particular particular engag
120as many students as possible in these particular activities it's open to all students um the same way as I haven't been a like a big advocate of all the cuts like cutting from Athletics or otherwise um so it's not just it's not mely exclusive from advancing some small areas and increasing it uh where where I felt it made sense to do that and it was an opportunity so so so yeah I mean I see the dollar number it is demmin but you mentioned there's values could you speak a little more to what values would drive that decision oh well listen I I don't want to go through all the values of the Arts so that's what we want to do no I think Dave means of of um participation like what the goal was in
121terms of participation the number of students who are actually participating uh I want say even the number of students the spectrum of students that participate and and uh these Arts programs are phenomenal that's fully integrated it's a fully inclusive program uh both on stage behind scenes uh technology and everything goes just as a a 360 way the same way as as Athletics does to engage uh our students I think it's a a very important part of uh the experience and U it's inclusive to all kids and all types of kids and that would hold true to High School athletics as well that world well I've always been a proponent of of of of Athletics s yeah a second but I I don't know if John had a follow up or you want me to go
122the we bit of a difference is technically right technically and I don't want to get into technicality because I just think of semantics but uh Athletics is addon right um for the most part these programs are part of curriculum or co-curriculum experiences that's different right um but I don't see it different in The Full Experience comprehensive experience of our kids John and yeah I mean this is a broad perspective we go down wormholes and I I know what we're trying to do is solve for a very important budget item but it it's been mentioned and I think we really got to be careful in terms of how we're addressing participation and I know people like to go after the sports programs and even additional sports but both personally and most most broadly watching the Athletics
123program and see the kids that show up and have something to participate in even if they're flying the Drone in in a sport or carrying the water bottles out to the to the team during a halftime or a break is incredibly important and the amount of mental Strife that the participation not only in the sports but I've seen it in theater I've seen it in clubs and councils is extremely important so um I know we're trying to you know rub pennies together and say have every dollar find more equities and stuff but let's let's like look at big dollar things and find restructurings and and and different things and maybe different fee schedules and that sort of thing versus picking on um you know participation cuz I think participation is intrical right now as I've
124seen it as a parent and I've seen it as a board member for the last six years okay I let's stay on the subject of participation okay you want to no I'm going off on a different tangent when you come back to me so if you want stay on topic yes are you on participation yes I don't disagree that participation ideally everybody would be able to do absolutely everything they would like to do but what we've been told that there's a three to 4% um threshold of comfort from our our budgetary people um you know a $4,400 increase in this versus a $2.2 million RC I think it's a very different ball game um you know if we're going to give be given more flexibility then absolutely everybody should be able to participate in everything
125but well then let's look at all EX CIT across the board um just on the subject of participation Robin um I I absolutely agree I'd love all of our extracurricular programs Athletics idea theater and I think this is a great proposal for the middle sex theater I do have a concern in particular about idea and the elimination of that program especially considering that is 15% of the middle sex students and I I firmly believe that this is a program that really does meet our strategic plan goals of meeting the needs of all Learners I would hate to see it eliminated in its entirety because I have concerns about whether those needs can be met effectively in the classroom given the the significant needs of the teachers who are already trying to serve a very diverse
126group of students within the classroom and have a a lot on their plate so what what I would love to talk about is again kind of on the The Avenue of the the past analysis that rich had done with participation fees for clubs and councils Athletics potentially also including and this is up for discussion but I would love to see the numbers of what it would be similar to what you had proposed with theater 308 being treated kind of as an athletic team if you were going to do a participation fee middle sex theater could also be in that light kind of considered an athletic team given the frequency of all of the practices rehearsals Etc and the same for idea basically as an opt-in program that there would be a a nominal participation fee
127similar to an athletic team given the instructional minutes and the frequency that it meets every week and rather than eliminating entire programs given the budget difficulties that we have I would like to understand what that could be um as a way to allow all of these programs to run and meet the needs of all of our students as opposed to potentially being forced to make cuts that none of us really would like to make okay are we going on to idea like weeks is that yeah I think we need when are you planning to do the overall sort of discussion of of gifted education and your strategies sir so we're prepared to talk about clearly the gifted education program today uh we can talk about it now in it's entirety because it impacts uh elementary
128schools it impacts uh the middle school we can do it at any particular junctures uh throughout the day or we can address it at all I my guess is there will be other follow-up questions not un like other topics that the board has discussed that will come back to but if you want us to talk about the program in general at this juncture uh we're happy to do that we already gone through so okay I think my suggestion would be let's finish middle school specific let's do idea in the middle of middle school and elementary school because it touches on both and then let's pick up Elementary School um immediately after that and so we'll we'll broaden that discussion for idea I'll table that question for the moment um just one one additional stat that
129I think is important to mention so again for Middle sex it's 15% of the students and it's an average cost of $1,600 per student which is lower cost than many of the athletic teams on a per student basis and so I think again these are relevant metrics when we're talking about our overall cost as a district okay and we'll come back to IDF right shus Dave so I will will second my my colleagues comments Mr CI on on participation in athletics and sports and and it you know it is it is super important for for students to feel not just involved but to build their own Community somehow in a school especially you know large as a middle school whether large as a high school and it brings brings the the school down to size
130where you can feel like you you have a voice and you belong having said that and I I love this idea for the music stien what I'm concerned about though are there extra hidden future costs so if we build this program and we start to build a program and and it gets the capacity and say it goes from kids to 200 kids does that mean then we have to refurbish the Middle School stage does that mean we have to refurbish the Middle School aori are we going to build a video wall in the middle school I I'm just I know I'm going down a rabbit hole here again but we have to be careful of what we're doing and then what what and what unanticipated or anticipated cost we're going to have when we do
131a program in the future just a point of clarity bring out it is a valid point I do suspect that the theater at middle schools is going to need some refurbishing no matter what we do um so I would say let's take that off the table um as as a as a barrier um I also think we've talked about um Athletics and offsetting revenues from summer school I think we can look at theater through the same lens the theater programs um collect quite a bit of Revenue um during the summer so uh when we talk about I think it might be helpful to talk about how we fund theater um at the secondary well it's really actually Elementary School through secondary although the the during the school year I think it's just secondary and then
132show the offsetting revenue um okay I think Dave is next yeah so the other tangent I wanted to go down is idea and um you know going back to your opening comments this morning Jill you know we want to focus on the big issues and given a lot of the uh what we've heard from constituents whether those be alumni Uh current students parents I guess my question was to really you know allay concerns and focus our efforts and our time and economize what we're doing here as a board and maybe to your comment a moment ago this is a conversation we're going have in a minute but I think really we should just get a sense of the board if this is even tenable anybody's even interested in looking at these cuts and then I
133think that can focus a lot of our work so I would propose we move to the idea conversation we really just get a sense if anybody's even interested in looking at that as potential cut and and see what we can do to try and free up some time to focus on other big items okay all right with no other any other questions about the Middle School yes okay Katie thank you I'd like to talk about um scheduling the team model and class sizes um I think this is a good idea to focus on topics together um so I um I appreciated that there was a comment in the um in the text that um that the priority is to maintain the team model I do want to ask about the enrollment and the way that
134the enrollment shifts um in the breakdown of class sizes um next year sixth graders are that very large current fifth grade class where we have a couple of five sections at elementary so um Allan if you could tell us what your thought are on terms of like the number of teams for per grade level and how that might shift for next year K I can do that uh we we had said that uh it was 433 for for next year and I believe that we were committing to the uh average class size of of 19 and 23 and 23 going from R elction of what we presented to the board with some exceptions that there was some uh tolerance built in and we described that at the time so uh we're confident that we're on
135track to maintaining that we're not touching and modifying those class sizes okay thank you and then just am I right there K I want to make sure I'm right and then okay and then just to further into that and and understanding still at a high level that there's there other implications for for scheduling and some professional development and that that's to come um could could we talk a little bit about how um how that impact of the couple of teachers that will move to four to five that completion and as well as the current classes I believe it's 29 that are above the guidelines right now can we just talk about how we see um the impact for next year at at this point K you want to pick that sure um the impact of
136the we don't anticipate an impact of the teachers who are moving from four to five in impacting class sizes because those teachers are uh fulfilling other duties for the school such as study hall or cafeteria Duty or uh interventions so that would not have an offset size impact on instructional classes um because those teachers are taking classes that currently exist as opposed to to reducing the number of sections um the second part of the question can you repeat the second part of the question for me Katie um yes oops yes I wanted to know um also about the current 29 classes that are outside the guidelines and what we're looking at next year and so our commitment that we had shared earlier was to look for five or fewer classes within the English social studies
137science and math that would be at 25 or more and our anticipation is that because we should have um a different scheduling timeline than was completed last year that we will be able to achieve that through uh careful balancing and scheduling working with Aspen for professional learning on how to most optimize that tool for us John so full disclaimer this is a budget question just understanding the cost of the team model I'm not advocating eliminating the team model but is there a way um to easily assess what team cost us or the lack of efficiency in a in a very um you know direct term the lack of efficiency that the team model brings our middle school and and again I don't want to create work a lot of work is there rich or would
138that be like this whole analysis at it's impossible to the ballpark I mean it wouldn't be impossible it would you mean you'd be making it like a Junior High um I mean the clearest cut would be the team leader stiens which is you know about 58,000 um but then you obviously would be able to probably I would assume and we'd have to work it out um reduce staff because we wouldn't be having kids just on a specific team they everybody would cross teams so we could probably put something that I again I don't want to creat this work because I don't think it's leading anywhere but I do want to kind of highlight the the the cost of uh implementing the team model and again full disclaimer I'm not looking to eliminate teams but I'm
139I'm just trying to highlight to the community the effort and is there a way we we go quasi team you know do some more rainbow classes you know to drive some efficiencies but maintain the team model okay so just to be clear yeah I know I'm sorry I'm really open up Wormhole but I I I don't know I it so we so we haven't done that in this budget we've maintained the the spirit of the conversations that we've had throughout but I have said it before educationally across the state Across the Nation one of the most expensive models of delivering education is team models no qus about that significantly so so whatever the number is will be pretty significant like are you talking 50% higher we don't know it depends what it depends the variables
140that we put in place on how accurate you want to the schedule but you actually run the schedule but uh will look significantly higher I leave it for that for the moment can I add to that that one of the pieces of how the team model is scheduled at MMS is that our team teachers have daily meeting time together and that is one of the periods of their day so they're teaching five classes and having daily team meetings through which they are looking at student work looking at student data preparing to participate in PBT and 504 meetings doing other collaborative work to plan for uh team-wide or grade wide activities including field trips and team days and so that is a period that is dedicated in their schedule in lie of an alternate Duty and
141it that does have a contractual implication that it's the duty that they're serving and so you could think of it in terms of um the way that we're utilizing their time and the costs associated with that I also would point out that it is from my opinion very important time for our Educators to collaboratively look especially within such a large school as MMS at the individual needs of each child and not not only instructionally but also social emotionally so that would be my additional note thank you so maybe John if I could suggest that if there was a fairly rough way to mock up a sense of the magnit order of magnitude financially we are not intending to make any changes to the Middle School anytime in the near future so just a rough order
142of magnitude as something that the board can understand when it talks about um how we how our funds follow our priorities and in this case one of the priorities is uh making sure that our Middle School is is as um it's a big school so creating smaller schools so that kids are seen as individuals and have as much individual touch as we can muster so if that is a that's the ask rough order of magnitude no intention to change the model thank you for making it less blunt excuse me for the interruption can we just see if there's a sense of of the board actually wanting to do that work um before it gets ordered sure is there anyone who does not want that done I mean if we're not intending to change it why
143do we need to know it well we've been asking about cost about a number of different things well let's hear from other people I always ask the question thank you okay okay um Jay and then Greg and then Katie and then Robin is that a vote or these are people who want to Wi um in terms of the state of Connecticut isn't middle sex one of the biggest middle schools in the state absolutely so wouldn't the other option really be a second middle school which I think is much more expensive than the team model um well there's multiple options I think that's that's a good point so I I just I think it is expensive but necessary you know I think I I would agree with you that it's necessary um and so I I
144think the hope is that people understand we do want to invest in our kids um but and and I do I hear your point if we put that information out there other bodies might be like well you could do it a different way yeah so why don't you do it that way and then we're left defending multiple things that we didn't want to ever be defending in the first place that would be my concern your concern I understand that okay Greg I guess John I don't have an issue with uh doing the work I have question for you is are you thinking that this is done during the budget process or is this something we could do outside of it later again I was looking for a ballpark just to highlight the effort that this
145board is making to maintain a team on if it's a if it's like a 30 minute exercise probably worth doing if it's a three-hour exercise on top of the board work maybe we my disclaimer that was the only thing I was gon to say I agree okay so I'll just follow up my two cents I agree with John uh no interest in changing anything right now that being said can't really know without doing the data Allan has mentioned it's a pretty significant number would like to get my arms around what that is and we had a discussion earlier about track time and Fields was going to suggest if we really want to do build bu accurately we should look at the cost of getting a mountain and a ice hockey rink and a pool to
146do that accurately so I mean you can go down this rabbit hole but I agree if it's gonna be a 30 minute exercise yeah let's let's look at what that number is okay Katie okay okay um I I think it would be helpful to know what the durg uh members of our dur have do they have a team model or more of a junior high model if they do not have a team model I would also want to know do they have two middle schools and you know understand the size of the middle schools in our dur as well as part of that look and I mean I think just a high level look should give us a pretty good indicator of and probably relatively quick analysis so would at least give us good data
147for us for discussions going forward thank you Sarah I mean again if we're not going to change anything why bother but okay I think you're authorized for a 30 minute exercise um I do think it's valuable to understand um from a different data perspective how we're spending our money we're look we've been talking about making sure that we understand that the money that we allocate follows our priorities um at the same time I I think the point of opening a of can of worms we don't want to open is an important one we are not int intending to change the model and we are saying that to our fellow government bodies also um and I can see they're hearing us now because it's an important Point okay um all right still on Middle School Robin
148uh just one more question on the stiens we have clubs and councils we have student interest clubs Student Government s stiens and Honor Society typen so all four of those categories I think at the high school we classify all of that is clubs and councils but that's over $80,000 of stiens and so for the clubs and councils that participation fee analysis that we had talked about I would just want to make sure that all of those lines are included and that the other follow-up question I have is what is the difference between student interest clubs versus clubs and councils um so we do break out the high school in the same way where it's Student Government student interest Honor Society Etc so at the middle school student interest can be anything from like uh the
149Ambassador Club to model you end quiz bull um as an example um clubs and counselors are things that don't really fit in there so like a yearbook or uh stiping could be a club and Council or a newspaper okay thank you sorry um just sort of piggybacking on Robin's ask for that breakout can do any of these clubs and councils go on trips competitions and if they do take buses who pays for them so the club raises money uh for the buses just in addition of that so the if you add then the theater and music stiens that's an additional almost $60,000 so again in in total you're talking about probably about $140,000 worth of stiens and so I think again that the participation fee analysis that we've asked for I think we want I'd
150want to have that all included thank you okay okay anything else on Middle School Katie on the topic of Team talk um I'd like to extend my appreciation to the Community Fund as well for their um generous contribution to an important program I did want to ask um for a little future projections um um my understanding is that the Community Fund did um indicate that this was a a a one time um and that this the support for funding 50% of this program wouldn't necessarily necessarily be something that would continue um so I just wanted to ask what our expectations were for the future if we looking to make this a permanent program if we're expecting it to be an ongoing budget that will be absorbed by the Board of Ed fully so we have
151that we've asked for that Mental Health on a page and and now that we've added a forecast that's a good thing to make sure it's in the forecast to to your point I could simply say I the uh the hope would be that that we would maintain it uh we also have a request for the uh offset at from the opioid Grant from the town um but eventually one way or the other it will transition into to a board probably quicker than sooner than later actually I don't see the Community Fund U funding this in perpetuity or anything so so I would say next year would be probably fully funded one way or the other okay all right with that we will transition to a discussion well sorry let me take questions and comments from
152government officials or the audience not about idea if you have other things you want to ask about the Middle School um government officials members of the public Dan are you going to go you look like you have something to say go ahead if you'd like to good morning my name is Jan Raymond and I just wanted to praise the middle school for one thing and that's their music program I had the opportunity to go to the concert that you had a few weeks ago and it was in the high school and I was amazed at the number of students that were in each of the three uh bands the sixth grade seventh grade and eighth grade the number the the percentage of the stage that was filled by those three different levels was amazing to
153me also amazing to me was the number of people in the audience the number the quality of the the performance and uh I just wanted to say that I tell everyone how impressed I am with what you're doing in that area and I believe that what sports and other activities do for some students the music program does for other students it certainly has been effective when I have looked looked at it and talked to students who were in it so I just wanted to praise the middle school and the board for supporting that program thank you Dan appreciate your comments okay oh Jack hi uh Jack Davis 197 hoit Street um I wanted to make a general comment since we're still early in this process you know I've heard a lot about the financial what
154you perceive as IM um limitations by what was presented by the board of Finance but when Jim Palin did his presentation I haven't really heard the other part which was probably more important if you look at his diagram he talked about what is really your core needs what are your high priority but not core and then what are your lesser so when I'm hearing certain questions about participation or even the question that John just asked which is team or not team that's really getting to what Jim's presentation was all about what is your core and having that discussion so I want to remind everyone here that that was the major part of Jim's presentation not only for the Board of Ed but for the board of Select me and so those questions are good to
155ask and I'm not saying whether or not you're going to do it during budget or you do it afterwards but it wasn't the numbers that Jim was really referring to it was that philosophy on how you build a budget thank you thank you okay with that we'll move on to um idea and gifted education so we'll we we'll talk uh uh sort of high level about the program just in general and I'm sure that will field the additional questions and my guest is will rule into another meeting of of additional information I appreciate um there's a couple of our principl have just come online uh thank you I'm sure some of our community members are here for this particular discussion um so just uh just a we bit of background uh on this um in
156all transparency right our principales didn't come to the table and say Dr rley we want to reduce and eliminate uh the uh ID uh Talon gifted program that did not happen um we have a challenging budget to address uh this particular uh am in this particular budget uh for the Ida program would actually put the the budget over the guideline from the Board of Education um that being said there there that was a choice that was made it was discussed at cabinet and as a decision that was made by the superintendent uh to eliminate the particular program I will say I think it's probably a true statement that the administration in the building understand um the decision and can agree with the decision that being said it was my decision to actually put her on
157the table I don't put anything on the table as a a political football um I never have um in this District I haven't pitted one thing against another uh just to get people out or just to get uh politically make something work I don't do that um I may have made a wrong decision here and there along the way but I don't put people in the middle of that I honestly put it on because I believe given what we have before us it's the best way to move forward that's all I can say to about why the rationale um I believe we can Service uh our young people in the classroom that is what we are charged to do to meet the needs of all our students in the classroom I understand it's challenging but
158yes our schools exist for all kids and we have an inclusive philosophy around education whether it's special education or whether it's regular education experiences um so this particular program uh would the students involved in the program which is 5% of of the district uh one of the differences from I don't want to compare it to other things but some of the things have been compared to today there are options for our young people uh who are specialized young people and who do need specialized uh focused attention and services and that is in the classroom it's not as if you're taking the The Experience away where I don't believe I am honestly don't believe I'm taking that experience away yes it reduces 3.3 teachers essentially do all intents and purposes the Optics of it it removes
159the program that is true um it does do that but the servic of the of the students are not all being removed and in fact is a responsibility of teachers and our district to meet the needs of all our all our students I will say by the way it's not just just for per people who are watching online or watching today you will get a letter on Monday about identification of special or uh identification of gifted students that's not like planned differently or other wayss it's it's the the process we're going through there's been no decision made here we will move forward with meeting the needs of uh of the students and uh the identification process will have to take place anyway by state legislation even if we didn't have the program it would have
160to take place so it's just coincidental that you will get a letter out that um uh the identification process we also had a a study done if you remember uh goes back to 2021 um that was Theresa Wrangle who was an administrative assistant to myself who was through Yukon um in collaboration with uh Nicole wakun and the Renzulli uh Yukon School of talent and gifted they did a report we have been working on the recommendations of that report that has come through the board the primary recommendations that we're addressing at the moment uh are through the the development and professional development of our staff and yes admittedly that has been the main focus has been the uh four teachers 3.3 FTE uh uh teachers who are actually delivering the service but we have been building
161their capacity uh around doing the work and we've also been uh addressing and increasing impr proven uh the learning opportunities through the actual uh curriculum that we're actually delivering that was that's the main the main takeaway if you ever to say to me uh Dr what what what have you been working on since that actual um that actual process well it was it was identification uh uh processes are in too it was also working with the close group of constituents which we have done so there's things in there deliberate things in there that we have been actually focusing on and actually delivering on also in there is the recognition that serviceing our young people our special our young people with these needs can be done in different ways in that report it talks about other
162opportunities of enrichment opportunities for all children I can look around the table and tell you this every kid has talents and gifts and arst every single kid has got talent and gifted in some capacity now I recognize this category that we're talking about um and I support uh addressing their needs uh but it's just also important to recognize that all all students have gifts and a lot of one of the things we're also trying to address and we haven't address in this particular uh report just yet satisfactory as I would like to is the idea of the the other enrichment and guest kids have in the Arts and talents that's also gifted uh we don't address those areas currently through our particular program you should say well you should you should expand it okay well
163that's that's an alert approach um but I'm just saying that there there's other gifted students in our district and other areas uh that we're not addressing and we've that report also profiled that so I just want to give a we bit of and and full and full transparency we've been working on since 2021 improving the program in different Capac I just want to bring maybe people in the audience today who don't have the background of that um but I just want to recognize that so the The Proposal before us is to deliver uh the services in the classroom I'm not bringing any other proposal variation of it uh I will say this uh we will continue to work on ways whatever the that means ways of delivering the services to the the students I don't
164but I don't want to overcommit any particular modification at that particular project other than what's in the classroom the actual professional development that the teachers need yes that was another uh recommendation from that report the professional development of teachers but not just the teachers of the gifted students the four teachers that were we're talking about not just uh those teachers but training the staff in general um across uh the dist uh across uh these particular issues and across the district one of the things that was said in that report uh by by uh feedback in the survey was our teachers want to be able to service our young people provided you give us the training um one of the things that are in this this budget that um uh I really want to be passionately
165talking about is the professional learning of staff that to support all students that is an advocate uh way we can Advocate and support the staff to address the needs of all all of our students um so that's that's the context that's the background um I'll maybe asked Amy just to give a away bit of context of the type of thing that we might do in the classroom or will do in the classroom uh for our young people sure thank you Dr adley is this okay um so as Dr adley mentioned it is the primary responsibility of every classroom teacher and we know that currently our classroom teachers are striving each day to meet the needs of every Learner in in our schools and one of the things that I always like to talk to the
166Board of Education about is the connection between curriculum instruction assessment and professional learning so our continued efforts in the area of curriculum development have been focusing on um not only ubd that you a backwards Design for Learning Program and that requires us to think about what our kids are already bringing to the table what do they already know and planning backwards to get them not only to grade level standards and also Beyond additionally um we're also thinking about our plans with curriculum with regard to Universal Design for Learning and that requires us to think about the different Pathways um and access points that we use to engage all Learners Learners of different profiles into the curriculum um and again Beyond some of the things that we're thinking about as well when we're when we're looking
167at our curriculum design and development are how we um Implement instructional strategies to provide additional opportunities for inquiry based learning and problem based learning and thinking about more open-ended tasks for our Learners and that's something that um is definitely a Hallmark of the idea and gifted program but something that needs to be taking place across a child school day not just during those um few uh pullout opportunities um I want to recognize as well that there are opportunities um in extracurricular programming there are different stiens within the budget we've got um not only our different learning spaces at toque and at oxridge that have been more currently renovated but also at the other elementary schools which will include a look at some of the library media spaces and across the district even Beyond just those
168larger projects thinking about how to reimagine those spaces so that they're um Innovative and allowing for maker space opportunities thinking about how we again extend um the gifted idea program Beyond a more typical Humanities approach and think about stem opportunities for our Learners as well and as Dr adley mentioned one of the um considerations in the report is thinking about a schoolwide enrichment model and thinking about how we can make our model even more interdisciplinary in nature to reflect a student's entire School day and experience um I want to recognize that not only are all of our um principles who have the currently idea program um being facilitated in their schools at the elementary middle school level here we also have Julie droller who's our director of Elementary curriculum and instruction and who primarily oversees
169the department and I know um she's passionate about the program as well as uh I and Dr adley are and um I'm sure she has comments that she would like to share as well just just before Julie does can I just I just wanted to mention and I I I should have at to start I just want to recog that my teachers may be even on online I don't know at this point uh but I want to recognize the teachers of this particular program and actually some of the staff fut uh as we're going to have a we discussion later on the budget about other staff members who unfortunately have brought forward here that um we're reducing or eliminating certain positions I want to recognize the efforts of the particular staff because they have a
170level of expertise they're talented committed people uh in the organization and they've worked tirelessly on behalf of um our gifted students and their family so and there's been a a a contingent of Highly passionate uh active support of parents um of the d g group and I appreciate um I appreciate all the work that they have done so with that Julie I don't want to interrupt you but no that's important good morning and thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today and for all of your work during this budget process and I just to reiterate all of the things that Dr adley and Dr Fedigan said um you know I I agree with that and we share the concerns raised by the daeg the families and our Educators who value the existing program
171but we do believe that um through intentional curriculum design professional development and enriching opportunities embedded within the general education classroom we can continue to meet the needs of our gifted Learners effectively our approach will be through differentiated instruction ensuring that our gifted Learners receive appropriate challenge within their regular Ed classroom teachers will use strategies to modify the content the process the products um allowing for deeper learning and exploration we'll also build on some of our current instructional practices such as building thinking classrooms in mathematics and providing students with choice and agency in reading and writing um in model in science and social studies and these models inherently support differentiation and can be adopted to offer that greater depth and complex complexity for our Advanced Learners um Amy talked about incorporating more stem activities and more
172problem-based learning into the curriculum and um that includes expanding participation in extracurricular programs like The Invention Convention Which F Foster creativity and Innovation we also have our daily Wind Block which will serve as a dedicated time for students to pursue enrichment projects and receive additional CH challenges tailored to their interests and their strengths and um this is a flexible block that will allow for personal personalized learning opportunities and collaboration with peers so as they also said um we do believe that this approach aligns with many of the key recommendations outlined in the um June 2021 evaluation report one of the concerns in the report highlighted the limited time that students currently have spend in the gifted program um and by embedding enrichment throughout in the general education classroom we can provide more consistent and sustained
173opportunities for advanced learning throughout the school day uh another primary concern which we discussed as professional development for classroom teachers and as Dr adley said our teachers have requested um you know a desire to support the Learners and have a connection to what's going on in their gifted program and we'd want to equip them with those strategies for differentiation for ways to extend the curriculum and for fostering those higher ordering skills um we talked about that schoolwide enrichment model and we do have that Wind Block which is a perfect perfect opportunity for that um and and um uh the report also encourage the district to explore a more inclusive framework so this shift will allow us to move to a model that Fosters the potential of all students while continuing to meet the specific needs
174of those who are gifted um so you know while we understand that this program it is a significant change we do feel that we are confident that we would be able to um support all of our gifted Learners in a positive way okay um I'll open it to board questions um my suspicion is that it's pretty difficult to translate a lot of what we've just heard to a cogent program or approach I I understand a lot of the component of what you're saying but um it's pretty difficult to crosswalk what you're actually offering to what was just described and whether you're talking about in terms of what the investment in professional development would look like time in the classroom um what the support would be how that impacts different kinds of kids and we have
175our program is gifted and talented talented is a little bit different from gifted and there's often I think different kinds of support there's a social tional piece that I don't understand how it applies so I think while we can offer a lot of questions I would say it's I cannot yet see what the crosswalk is um and that would need to be answered I think before the board could understand what you're really saying okay well I'll open it to questions Sarah thanks I think it'd be helpful for the board and for the community if we could get a true definition of what a gifted and talented student is um to my understanding it is a diagnosis or an identification which to me I actually view it more in special education like these students require specific
176education because of their particular special needs um so I think you know to to sorry to educate everybody I would like one of you to let us know what that that definition is um because it is it is mandated that we identify these students it is just not mandated that we provide so services like for the the other special education services so is that true that is true that is true yes that's true yep so to I just I think we need to educate everybody what a true gifted student means and not you know these are not just the 1600 4.5 GPA kids let kids that read before kindergarten this is a true diagnosis of learning so just open that up to somebody to understand better what that is and the incidence rate yeah do
177you want to add something before the question's answered you have your hand up I can't tell oh sorry yeah okay go ahead guys who wants to pick who wants to take that one Amy or Shirley together so um in order to um evaluate students there are many ways we also look at standardized me measures for example in this District we look at the Ula and the Torrance as screeners so you would look primarily first at academic achievement um and then you would look Beyond those standardized measures so we also have portfolios and um classroom observations for teachers the Hallmark of um of students who are identified is as gifted and talented as you mentioned are a little bit different and I would like to Echo Dr adley's earlier comments that truly we need to recognize
178that there are 100% talents and Gifts in all of the students um across our schools in many different areas um but really about thinking their Divergent thinkers um might have as you mentioned Jill different social and emotional learning needs I would like to rely upon surely for the the diagnosis piece that you were talking about um and the kind of clarification of understanding that idea um as we call it in Darian Public Schools gifted and talented is recognized as a special education um subset so I think that is important that Sarah brought that up and that's probably surley can talk about the Nexus between general education and special education with regard to that I probably I probably would not use the term diagnosis just in terms of the loss of a different word um but
179to your point Point Sarah pull that right to you would you that mic please I probably wouldn't use the term diagnosis I would use that there are criteria that they meet for it I'm sure you meant the same thing Sarah yes um and in doing that as the all set has done there's also teacher observation there's writing samples that are done there are also accommodations given to students if they need that in order to participate in the evaluation process so that is offered to students who um who may or may not be twice exceptional um as as far as the program the program that's designed um in the district really doesn't come under the umbrella of special education it really comes under general education and the provisions of services within General Ed yeah no I
180mean I just think it's important that these these this particular subset of children does require different a different way of educating and I you know whether that's a pullout model or not I think it's an important thing to to note but if I may add also it's already a point of um and what Amy was saying earlier of having and and Julie said having opportunities in the general education classroom and looking at different times and opportunities whether it's win periods in elementary or other periods in secondary of we spoke at one of the curriculum meetings that you chair about performance um assessments really looking at students being able to show what they know by being able to demonstrate it not by typical assessments or pencil and Pap assessments but looking at if you look at
181um gifted and talented or if you look at exceptional learners of finding ways that our curriculum really offers that and performance assessment in addition to backwards in design really would be opportunities for that as well can you just clarify that in this chart the duly identified duy identified is that are those two week heads yes yes s's Point are twice exceptional sorry exactly what does that mean is that was they may have an IEP as well as being the gifted program we also have Learners that um receive um ml services may I ask just for two seconds just to because it's been used twice here I know what it is and can talk about it but they're Elementary people too just for for people in case they don't know it this wind block has been
182mentioned a couple of times here um and I'm not sure that members of the board or public may know what that is sure what I mean yep uhuh it's a 30 minute period and for our students who um receive Services whether it's um special education or through our m srbi mtss they are pulled out during that time so they won't miss classroom instruction for other students it's an opportunity to practice or um to complete work or to engage in projects that enhance learning Greg so the the Dual identifi my understanding is that that those are folks who also have I or some other special end so is there a potential unintended consequence here where the remainder are going to now become specialized students and there's budget ramifications for that over the course of time I'm
183not quite sure what the question was but the the idea students so will the idea students who are not currently I APS or specializ students will they potentially now become specialized students and that increases our cost on special there's another way to ask that question Greg that if I could offer it um I think that that a lot of times why we dis have programs like this is because we have students who don't feel their needs are met all the way in the classroom and so that's part of what I think Administration are trying to do would be to build up capacity to meet at least some of those needs in the classroom when students have unmet needs yes there are consequences and those sometimes are behavioral there sometimes they turn off academically they sometimes
184um you know end up with yes certain types of emotional uh issues in terms of when we talk about special education usually that's something you know more like a dyslexia that you're you're born with typically but I do think the question of unintended consequences when students needs aren't being met is something we do need to talk about um as part of this discussion but if I may just answer um Jill also to Greg's question uh the students who are have learning differences and do have a current IEP may also be a student for instance who's a student with autism um and yet they have some extraordinary gifts in a different area so that's what makes them twice exceptional so you're still going to get your needs met with an IP of what those goals and
185objectives are depending on what your learning difference is and you may have other attributes that really require some um you know exceptional learning opportunities as well is that fair do you want to add anything no okay Dave thanks Jill um so I guess going back to the earlier question I posed just trying to get a sense of where people are on this board if this is a realistic or or serious proposal really economize our work I know we've spent a lot of time on this board trying to work through our processes bringing forward priorities bringing forth policies having understanding so we don't have things dropped into budget necessarily seems this may have happened a bit here where we weren't totally prepared for the ramifications um you know unfortunately um continuance of a pattern but I
186I think really you know we've been down a couple rabbit holes already today just to really economize our work our time and getting through the budget today would love if anyone's willing to take a sense of the meeting figure out where we are if this is really something that there's appetite to explore further before we commit a lot of time into this okay can I just ask a question before we do that um first of all the report that Dr adley is referencing from the Yukon g&t when was that distributed to the Board of Ed and discussed in full because I have never seen that that's one question secondly I wanted to correct Dr adley said that this is 5% of our students it's actually 10% of the students in grades 2 through 8 that
187participate in idea so that is actually a significant cohort which again is identified at a federal Level under idea that I I'm concerned about whether we can meet their needs within a classroom specifically also with the additional PD that would be needed going forward because it is a different skill that most of our teachers I do not believe are fully trained on and that we spent resources training our specialized gifted and talented teachers on over the past number of years and to develop that curriculum um I also wanted to ask does the rest of the durg have a gifted and talented program can we get any details on that at the elementary and middle school level and then just one final Point um if we're talking about meeting the needs within the classroom going forward
188at the middle school we do currently have an acceler at math track but since we no longer will be offering an eighth grade accelerated English class um right now within the middle school we do not really have a a curriculum that would be provided to gifted and talented students particularly in English language arts which the idea program did spend a significant amount of time on at the elementary and middle school level and so there are a number of questions that I still have that I think really Merit a lot more discussion because these are specific needs and a specific large cohort 10% of our students that I really think this is an important decision and before cuts are made I really think we need to evaluate those um I respect respect those questions and certainly
189we able to address those the report itself did come before the board um the date eludes me a little bit I have to go back to the record but before I was on2 oh oh definitely oh totally 100% helpful to see that in the context of this whole discussion we'll get the report Prov seen that okay John so so Dave I get what you're trying to do but um I think Jill you you said it best we got to get the crosswalk of what's going to be supplanted in the classroom and and Ne Robin you you did as well I mean the reality is if we just NX this right off the bat then we got to find $469,500 some other priorities so I'd love to go through the rest of today and understand that
190then we can put our arms around it in terms of when the incremental information that's already been asked yeah I don't disagree John it's definitely a big number uh that being said there will be some work involved in getting that number replaced which I'd rather focus on if the consensus here is not to do that and opposed to spending the time on this I think we could focus and again a question is you know is this ultimate number and we're long from this discussion but is the proposed budget you know were ways before ad cut you we're gonna have a lot of go-arounds on this but I just don't want to waste time on this if you're no cons maybe I could offer a compromise because I I your point is well taken Dave that
191if this isn't the number we have to find something else or at least be prepared to find something else so perhaps what we could do is um ask for I think something I think the board is Unified in feeling that there is a cohort of students whose needs need to be met and I I think I can speak for everyone somebody holler if not but everybody is concerned about meeting the needs of these students and of making a rapid change without the right infrastructure in place so I think Administration if you guys could help us understand again what the crosswalk is what the infrastructure is what's already in place what would be needed um what would what you see what is the real size of this cohort again it gifted being a little bit different
192than talented what I do agree that we have lots of kids with talents so sort of what's how do we serve our children here um and have I think I understand that we're early in the budget process it's hard to have a a completely coherent program that You' be developing but I think something um we need more than what we've just heard today so if you guys could provide that to us on Tuesday we as a board I think can commit to not beating a dead horse if if if the if it's not there it's not there and we have to switch Focus what would be the Alterna well so then we'd have to figure that out right okay um does that work for people let at least at least have another conversation on the
19314th that's our next meeting with the understanding we need to better understand what is put in front of us um and if it's not if it's not doesn't have legs then we can move on Joanna I would also um as part of that report like to understand the report from 2021 recommended to have accelerated math in the general light classroom but I don't think it's been delivered yet so it's now 2025 I'd like to understand what happened with that why the process might have stalled and what would prevent it from happening if we took teachers out and tried to do this that that's same thing Elementary at the elementary level at the elementary level okay okay Katie thank you um I I would like to just bring us back to the big picture in terms
194of this conversation as well um once again we are finding ourselves with a programmatic change in a budget book um and it is not because the program is not working um we we did have an evaluation an outside independent really well done evaluation um done just a few years ago we have heard with Incredible articulation and speed from the community of parents of students of alumni about the value of this um of this program um I'm incredibly impressed with the engagement and the advocacy um I am I'm less impressed with our long-term Vision what is it that we want for our district and are we upholding the values that we say that we have what is the big picture here it seems that the current theme is that everything can be solved with professional development
195and I have to ask how much are we really asking of our teachers we expect them to be general education curriculum experts and to Pilot new programs to also have professional development on special education gifted seal to handle discipline problems to take on larger class sizes to work across Elementary buildings and not have dedicated staff without setup time we are now asking them to do so without any Aid or paraprofessional support we're commenting that we recognize that students have gifts in other areas like art and we have slashed the art budget year after year what do we really stand for because this budget does not seem to be student focused and helping all students achieve their learning capacity that they individually have do you want to speak to it um I don't know that I
196want to speak to that uh just directly I will say there been two comments about process of that's here we are again and I respect that but I did tell the board there are certain topics and Personnel matters and so on that's just not possible to have the discussion prior to the the discussion of the budget we have been following budget initiatives the whole way through but when when when when I'm asked to give a guideline and work within that guideline I have to work within the guideline um as best as I possibly can at least come back with something that's reasonable I did sh there would be Personnel matters potentially if we're talking about getting from over a 6% budget down to somewhere in the mid fours of of a budget scenario so it's
197just not possible to talk about this out of this particular concept and I apologize that it seems that way but um that's that's the reality of it the rest of it certainly the the vision of the district and everything else just um all things been equal I'd like to to to do all of this but it's not at the moment um and uh that's a a board discussion I understand that um and I'll certainly address the other questions Mr I appreciate that thanks yeah so I I think as part of the there's a presentation on gifted but I think given the um combination of the gifted discussion and the later paraprofessional discussion it's probably also important to talk about um the vision for the elementary school teacher in particular and what that day looks like
198and how that's impacted by these changes yes and I'm not familiar with the idea no three boys did it but um you know is there more importance of implementing it in elementary school or middle school and is there a for lack of a better term compromise on on on that I I just don't know from a curriculum perspective or education perspective okay so if you guys could handle that when you come back to talk we can answer that y yeah okay anyone else great just one quick add- on with I understand the perspective in terms of what Dave was asking for and not addressing that today um it does sound like there's a lot of questions from the board and we'll get more clarification on the 14th I don't know if it makes sense for
199Dr Aly come into that meeting with some potential alternatives to the extent that rather than waiting till the 28th I think that would maybe be helpful okay good good idea do you mean alternatives for that 469k or correct okay we revisit that discussion at the end of the process just just I don't mean to defer it or say no to it I just want what it means in the bigger picture by the end of the day I was just saying if if so if we get to the 14th then we get all additional information beforehand and then the board decides we don't want to get rid of this and now we need to go find 460 I think we don't want to wait until the discussion that the board has through right the day will
200be helpful to that too I agree I I think yes let's come back yes and let's come back to it at the end of the day when we get through the RC's okay I like that okay okay anyone else on idea and next steps okay with with that um questions from fellow government officials from the public uh Crystal Hill cbsp chair um again just reiterating I think some of the things that were brought up here at the board that I've also heard from uh families sort of like what would be the plan for these students I mean it's easy to say um we will you know backfill in the classroom but what does that look like exactly I think that presentation on Thursday included additional schoolwide enrichment like curricular extensions like is is there not
201a budget impact there like professional development I mean there seems like there would be budgetary implications maybe not to a 469,000 number but certainly some offset there um and again teachers like we cutting pair of professionals which we'll get to next like we're asking them to do more we're putting in a new literacy curriculum um we're talking about continued uh increases in special identification rates how much they're in PPT meetings now we're going to ask them to do professional learning to teach to gifted students it's just a lot on the plates of our teachers um and then who does the gifted identifications is it the staff were cutting if so like who would be doing those identifications going forward is there any budgetary implications for additional staff needed there um and again budget related what
202is um you know some of these children especially the you know duly exceptional um you know what does that look like are we looking at out placements in the future because We additionally can't meet the need needs of those students or students that end up in special education um because some of those needs are not being met uh Jack Davis 197 hoit Street I just want to give a little bit of a historical perspective because I've been around longer than many of you um my two kids who are now 39 and 40 were both an idea at that time the idea program was fifth grade through 9th grade and so it and I know education needs have changed so I'm not commenting on whether or not second third and fourth are necessary but that was
203there the other thing that I'll mention because I know there was questions about special ed on these students I would say close to 50% of those who participated with my son and daughter were receiving special Edge Services primarily because they were add thank you good morning yes it's still morning my name is burn posy and I reside at 8 Circle Road I serve as president of daeg which stands for Darian advocates for education of the gifted daeg is essentially the PTO for families with student students in the idea program so I am speaking on behalf of a very engaged very passionate group of parents caregivers and students in that Community I'm going to keep my comments very brief at this time there are many aspects of this town that residence value and academic Excellence is
204certainly one simply put to suggest elimination of a program that promotes academic Excellence provides gifted students with an opportunity to reach their full potential and importantly provides a place of learning to meet their specialized needs all Concepts consistent with values laid out in the Strategic plan and the vision of The Graduate is a decision that would likely have unintended consequences which is a theme I've heard several times today and something I think we'd all like to avoid thank you for your time thank you go ahead please yeah yeah you may hi my name is min I live at um 116 Camp Avenue first of all I want to thank everyone who's here today to devote your special you know Saturday here for a whole day to discuss this important topic for our town and thank
205you for all the attendees here as well um I want to thank M um Nelson U Mrs Nelson for your comment about the 10% of the student body inside of 5 % I think that's a very very important figure that everyone should be aware of and I want to just tell you about my um personal example my child started his experiences in the idea program last semester and the year before he actually had some very bad experience on the school bus and he used to like to go to school a lot but after that he was like oh my God you know I don't know if I wanted to go back to school but ever you know since he participated in idea he feel a big sense of belonging in that small environment and he
206feels like his special needs get acknowledged when we say children like with neuro Divergent we were talking about children who's on a very broad spectrum who might not only have difficult learning who might also have like their special needs not being able to met for example my son sometimes will come home and tell me um you know there's some stuff like he probably feel like he's already understand but it has to be repeated a couple more times and he he will get distracted not focusing as much as he would like to in that example being able to participate in idea program give him the opportunity to reach his full potential and Al always be challenged to do something more interesting to help with his brain development so I'm very disappointed to know that when I
207reach out to my classroom teacher and um principal to ask if there's any extra help to help my son whose brain might be working a little bit differently from other children who might have very quick learning ability but cannot be like you know following the uh regular structure um School setting the answer unfortunately is no because um he is not academically behind but actually excel in his level so to me idea program is a very important addition to his current existing curriculum so I really hope like this will not be taken away from our um prestigious um School District and in the same time I feel like um our school district has been very compassionate loving and caring to established like a fish Academy for example in 2017 just for a student body of 11
20812 students I believe at the beginning so I feel like for 237 students currently enrolled in idea program I would suggest to not only do not eliminate the program but to support our student with extra funding in some other towns like they even have special dedicated idea class or gifted class just for those students for a whole day that's something my student my my son would definitely love to have more classes or maybe even a four day class if possible and maybe like just what you do for the ELP currently to be Consolidated in one school and to have additional teachers pull out to help those 237 students for a Better Learning PA so ma'am I'm going to interrupt you you're about at time we usually keep it to about three minutes there's another public
209comment period at the end if you'd like thank okay appreciate your help okay seeing no other comments um we have scheduled a oh no we have elementary schools okay we do not have a break quite yet element and then a break elementary schools you guys are up fire away I just welcome our our uh principes on screen this morning and have I may say a special welcome uh uh to our two new uh principles uh Mr Cooper and uh Chris Malo here um our two principls are new to the district so this is a new process for them welcome uh thank you for your work thus far and your translation and I hope you've enjoyed it and um I'll turn it over to the two members of the group who going to be speaking this
210morning thank you Dr adley um thank you um on behalf of the elementary schools uh to the Darian Community excuse me the Board of Education the board of finance and the RTM our amazing staff um our students and our parents who are watching and participating in this year's budget process um we do know that it takes a great deal of collaboration among all of those groups of people and a commitment to work together to support each other and arrive at a budget that ensures that we support and protect daran's Crown Jewel which is our schools um we'll start off at this time with um Chris Malo who is the principal of oxridge school and he'll begin taking us through the overview of the elementary RC's which include rc5 RC S 8 n and 10 and
211then I'll jump in at the end thank you um I just want to say that although I know budget discussions in every district is difficult um there is a lot of optimism and positivity and energy going on in our elementary schools right now um the newly built oxridge school stands as a symbol of Pride and I'm so very privileged to be there um there's exciting Renovations going on at Henley homes and Royal and they reflect our District's commitment to creating exceptional learning environments for our students and staff the district's dedication and improving climate has fostered a high level of student performance across all schools in this effort has brought together a strong and cohesive leadership team aligned under a shared vision of success and together we are a dynamic resilient and unified team of leaders
212the proposed 2526 operating budget focuses on safeguarding and enhancing the instructional core IT addresses class size it complies with State mandates and advances District initiatives this plan balances the needs of our five elementary schools while maintaining the standards that our community expects there are approximately just over 2200 students in grades prek to5 that we serve and Staffing adjustments that have been made uh are based primarily around enrollment projections so at hinley we're looking at a 1 FTE increase in kindergarten at Holmes and Ox Ridge a one FTE reduction in fifth grade and there are no changes planned at Royal or token with an overall classroom uh change in FTE is one districtwide uh one less to preserve resources for core classroom instruction has been spoken about there is a proposal for a 1.7 FTE reduction
213um in regards to the idea program and we understand that these these changes are very difficult um I know that the district remains committed to meeting the needs of all students and especially our gifted Learners um we can do that through differentiated instructional practices within the classroom um but that also needs to be supported by additional professional learning time for our teachers we understand that protecting the instructional core of all students requires some difficult decisions and I don't envy the board in this it's work but it's work that has to be done but I hope we can come to a place where we can find a balance between fiscal responsibility in maintaining high quality instruction there are additional adjustments which include a reduction of 15 FTE pair professionals across all elementary schools and looking to
214offset that with an addition of 10 student interns two per school to support classroom needs and duties and also support in the STA staff absences while this is not optimal the solution also balances coverage needs with budget constraints Paula will will continue this uh the summary that represents the the thinking of our five elementary school of principles thank you Chris um over the years um there have been I I've been in deram 13 years now and there have been a good number of State mandates and initiatives that have evolved to address really a lot of complex skills that students need at a much younger age to succeed in the 21st century um and it has been clear through my time here and in discussions that we've had as an elementary team that that our District's
215professional development calendar really needs to be adapted to meet all of the things that are are changing um I know many of you have already highlighted the um huge responsibility that elementary teachers and staff have in terms of navigating lots of different aspects of education and so to effectively support teachers and staff in building the Knowledge and Skills that they need to deliver the instructional core and to support all of our students with all of their needs we really do need to look at the type of professional development that we are offering to them so as Elementary principles our single heartfelt request centers on professional learning opportunities for all of our staff um these opportunities will directly benefit all students because once teachers learn something they can use it with every student that they work
216with um it helps them to understand Innovative strategies and gives them the knowledge they need to elevate their instruction and enhance the learning experience for all students we believe that passionately investing in professional learning ensures that every child will have access to an exceptional education and this will be a Cornerstone of our mission in terms of inspiring and empowering every single student and Dair in um Investments and training will focus on restorative practices which is a state mandate the science of reading which is also a state mandate play based learning another state mandate as well as all of the other District initiatives that we have to ensure that our Elementary staff can provide a supportive and engaging environment for all of our Learners um so we hope that that part of the budget is especially
217will be supported and um the proposed changes that have been suggested do demonstrate the district's dedication to doing what we can to balance fiscal responsibility given this budget year with the educational Excellence that we expect in Daran thank you that's it from the okay so we have a couple different topics um I'll open it up to more General and then why don't we handle um caras and then um plc's so any any more General topics pardon not pairs or PLC correct okay um I'm just so on um an oxridge on the um sorry page 157 in fifth grade it looks like the change year-over-year has gone up N9 ,000 but there's no change in staff um it seems like a lot or there's no change in staff in the line here the change of $90,000
218over in the staff Staffing or is it in 261 so that's the placement of the teachers and so the teachers don't teach the same grades all the time and so while you see a $90,000 increase there is reductions elsewhere uh we also have changes in staff from whether it was a like a one-year position to a new position so comparing it year- over-ear isn't always doesn't always seem to make sense it's based on the actual person that we're budgeting within the account that makes sense so it just might be more expensive teachers correct okay and they're moving from between grade levels right that's what you're also saying correct so they there's two offsets in the kindergarten and the fourth grade for the remind me how many sections um we we're have an eye on was
219it was it two or three overall sorry oh yeah Henley Henley first grade is close holes fourth grade is close and oxr fifth grade is close and quite close right one one's one away and one's two away one or two but that's typically we would come back to the board if now I will say not exclusively every time right um because there are times where it's gone under and we haven't comeone back and there's times where it's gone over and we have for whatever composition the class or otherwise but in general uh we have a time in in the Summer where we can come back and whether it's the middle school or whether it's the high school or mostly it's Elementary we would come back in consideration of a section other General Elementary School questions
220Katie thank you um where are we at with the co- teing at the elementary level so why don't we have Robin and then hopefully early we'll come right back in Robin did you have a question um yes just generally that we have I think it's maybe four and a half psychologist at the elementary schools in total what is the role of these general education psychologist are they identifying gifted and talented as well and providing general education kind of resources for the students there's 10 psychologists at the elementary I'm looking at the current staff in correct so uh what it is it's half in the Elementary and then half in special at rc24 um okay so there's 10 in total and then a token a portion is funded in the Ida Grant um but they're a
221tant PO okay a portion are funded an Ida Grant but that only that benefits the special education rc24 correct none of it goes toward the g&t the um gifted and talented resources I understand I'm not going to speak about currently they're not currently they're not so maybe looking at the grant detail there was nothing that was principles could speak to how it's actually applied in the building because I don't believe it's applied according to uh classification but perhaps um whoever of you five wants to answer that so um at homes I'll speak for homes we have two School psychologists um they both work with children with special needs and they both work with the general population um they um have divided themselves mostly by grade level so we have them each taking three grade levels
222and they support all of the students at their grade levels regardless of whether they're identified or not identified um there are students who have a death in the family there are students who have a new baby that's causing some anxiety there are students who have significant anxiety issues but it's not really impacting them academically so there are a lot of different things they do in terms of regular education um they also push into classrooms and are working on teaching some of our ruler lessons um around emotional regulation and things like that so that all students are getting that um support um that's a piece of what they do that we think is extremely important because that's called tier one which means every child gets access to that um so the hope is that as students
223learn skills in the general education classroom they can then apply them and that avoids other types of issues later um and then our school psychologists also address the um iepd service hours of our students who require counseling or some type of consult as part of their IEPs if a lot of other things they do too but I that's quick summary If part of the question is like do they work dedicated ly with uh some of our our talented and gifted students or or Iden identification we B different than than working with a group actually it's not an outof the realm consideration right in terms of social groups or otherwise um I just didn't know who actually does identify the gifted and talented that is mandated by the state each year especially if we are not
224having the idea program going forward yeah that's a a com combination of our assistant principles working with the gifted um teachers the current gifted teachers as well as the classroom teachers and the parent okay and then one more question um the do the psychologists at the elementary level also participate in a behavior analysis because I know later when we talk about special ed there's a something that they said is a new role for psychologists within the schools can you talk about that a little bit more because I know the behavior behavioral evaluations are also a significant part of some of the costs that we've had recently that have been increasing over the past year okay let's table that one too until Charle com back thank you um yes Katie thanks sorry just after Joanna's question
225looking back at the sections in oxridge particularly this list that currently the fourth grade has five sections and that fifth grade has four but I thought it was the reverse I'll believe fourth grade has five sections fourth grade this year does have five sections and fifth grade does not fourth grade correct okay and and for next year's budget they're looking at four sections of fourth grade and four sections of fifth grade okay okay so so how so given that fourth and fifth grade have the same class-size guidelines how will we move from from five sections to four next year so so typically oh go ahead typically we have many students uh apply for private schools uh starting in fifth grade um also looking at um enrollment projections moving forward um look uh it was determined
226that the class sizes will be in line for next year fifth grade at oxridge if they are four sections so none of your schools have a 100% persistence ratio which means you don't necessarily retain 100% of your students moving year year to year so when you get the enrollment report that comes out in November typically they're in like the 99 pertile and so uh when you apply that moving forward you're looking at losing like a couple kids here or there which is why the oxridge fifth grade is one essentially one student away from tipping okay thank you so we have two oh she's here okay surely do you need a minute um because we had two questions that were part to you Katie was one about cot yes hi charlee um I was just asking
227about the status of co-teaching at the elementary level we're continuing in grade five um we still have an all elementary schools uh there were still it's a 90-minute block but one of the schools is using a 45 minute block again based on student need and they review it with the fourth graders rising to fifth grade each year to see what that program will look like and then as it relates to the RC's um for the elementary we are seeing one general education teacher for that grade level in the specific building RC and then the other Kat teacher from that's a special educ the special educator is within um24 thank you thank you okay Robin you had a question about psychologist the elementary psychologist I know and we'll talk about this more I guess in the
228rc24 discussion but there was a a note that there was a new role of psychologist to participate in behavioral analysis of some sort with students that is a new kind of that they're doing are they doing that within the elementary schools as well it's not really a new role Robin it's part of um when we do functional behavioral assessments and behavior intervention plans um often it's done by bcbas and BC abas however it is typically a role that psychologists play they're trained in it they're expert in it um and we're doing professional development in it so it won't be limited to a bcba or a bcab but limited psychologists who work alongside those children and in those classrooms do those psychologists then help us to limit the amount that is spent on consultant contracted outside
229consultant services for Behavioral issues I we hope that will be an outcome so that's part of what we're but the the intention is really to enable our psychologist as professional development because they are trained in their grad programs and their postgrad programs and who's better equipped um as alongside of bcba to do those kind of functional Behavior assessments okay it's observing the child in the classroom it's working to support the student helping to develop a behavior intervention plan and helping to not only implement it but support the teacher Andor a par educator Andor other related service providers in the implementation thank you okay uh now we were going to talk about Paras in elementary schools are there questions about Paras Sarah I have a few questions but I guess my first request is for the
23014th if you could prepare similarly you've talked about you know if you given like a schedule of what the Paras do um I would love a more specific breakdown of what you know how their days are spent and you know what they what they're responsible for I mean I know it says recess lunchroom blah blah blah but a more specific breakdown um my other question is about the student interns that you're proposing replacing the Paras with um how is that different from a student teacher back was I back when I was doing my student teaching I was in one classroom for three months and didn't leave and spent my time with those 22 kids and that one teacher like how is that helpful to an entire school so we get the student teachers for entire
231year and only 10 weeks of that is spent student teaching so in the past when we had two we would stagger them so that you didn't have both student teaching but um we pay a certain amount of money to the preparing University and we get the student for full 10 months okay and are there so the student interns are required to do that student teaching piece yes yeah well no you can get student interns who don't do the student teaching but it's usually the package okay so they're there the whole year are you confident that you could find these lovely young people so I as it said in the my very lengthy narrative we have had a big uptick this year in student teaching placements it went from like three or four last year to
23220 this year so I have contacted the preparing um universities and let them know that we're considering this and you know we all seem hopeful okay I think um similar to the Ida it would be helpful to see a little bit more of a crosswalk um for this you know what what's a pair what's a building student intern whatever it's called um and what what are the gaps in coverage um and how will those be handled so if you guys could could walk us through more formally yes charlee may I just just for community members just these are par Educators which are instructional Paras they're not par Educators um for children with special needs yes that's important reminder thank you in addition to my asks that I asked for before I would love to also
233know what percentage of the current par educators are being pulled out to sub like how often is that happening I want real data if you can do for what how you said part of the rationale for this is that they're being used as substitutes and I would love to know the actual data for that just roughly speaking we'll do it we'll do the calculation but it's uh if we were doing by numbers so to speak it's at least like a quarter of their day at least can you repeat that please be at least 25% of the day would be that be out of the classroom if if you were just doing the average of everybody okay so we'll see that on the 14th thank you it's a good question um Dave and then Katy just
234a followup to that can we see the budget implications there if we had to replace those with actual Subs yes thank you so you mean did you guys hear that there you mean sorry sorry for the you guys in the back again I was just asking if they're spending a quarter of their day if we have to get substitutes for a quarter of the day what the cost differential be you mean if we don't do the interns well we pay for substitutes so if we had to pay for substitutes for quar of the day what does that cost versus these people performing that yeah the full crosswalk so we can see all the gaps and and the costs they're in Yeah March go ahead so the problem is we can't find the daily substitutes so
235that's why we've add bu added building subs and we've had to pair of professionals because the daily subpool is getting smaller and smaller even though we did raise our rate okay so it sounds like on the 14th we're looking at an understanding of the elementary school teacher day the parah the building intern then we have these Subs that are working in some cases and not in all so maybe something so that we can see the big picture there of what coverage looks like what it doesn't look like and what the differen is in cost okay Katie thank you um you know coming back to this idea of a a single document overview I think that could be really helpful with the the interns um and you know if we can include a piece on terminology
236as that as well like sometimes calling them interns versus student teachers it's helpful for us to know that we're all talking about the same thing and additionally to that um you know Marge when you mentioned that there's 10 weeks of the student teaching an important piece of that is what is required of our our our certified teachers like is this an additional ask on them is there a supervisory component I think it would be really helpful for us to see the full scope of what they could potentially bring but what they might also require um in terms of not being fully um certified staff um and then additionally um a component that I think is really important at the elementary school is also the idea that we would be rolling out a new curriculum last
237year and I I hope that the board has really taken to Heart the comments that we've heard from our teachers who are currently piloting the program um and and are working just doggedly to to understand um the new resources that they have and and how to best Implement some in front of children but um I am concerned about you know some of the very veteran teachers that we have um talking about the the resources and the time commitments that have been required of them this year Rolling this out and you know across the board trying to find consistency amongst five elementary schools with the elimination of par professionals seems a an almost insurable task to me um and I I don't see I have concerns about swapping as well one our PA professionals have historical
238knowledge of the district they know kids they know the teachers not only do you know potential new interns not have this they don't they don't even have any experience like they're they're coming to gain experience so I have a lot of concerns about this proposal um and I think the timing of it just makes it that much more negatively impactful I think the difference in training is an important component to include because I do agree with with you know time and buildings and experience but I also think we always want to be careful about um who is providing direct instruction um so I think that's a piece you need to include please um Joanna um I Echo a lot of what Katie says and um Marge in the past you've said uh that there's such
239a thing as par professional Union protected work what is that well normally we wouldn't ask par professionals to cover classes so when we did the last par contract we had to bargain the impact of them covering the classes so one of the problems with getting data on how often Paris are covering is we don't pay them unless they cover for at least 2 hours so to the extent we're pulling them for emergency coverage we don't necessarily track that data but in recognition of the fact that Paras are not meant to be teaching they do get a $20 stipend if they teach for two hours or more and then are there certain tasks that Paras complete that only Paras can do or no no so build building substitutes and and um student interns can do anything
240that a par can do okay Dennis so um maybe I'm just lost on this part but I'm I'm I don't understand why we because the narrative to me sounds like we're we're we're hiring student interns to cover absences that par professionals are now covering and then we're paying $94,000 each school for substitute teachers which isn't enough but then we're going to get rid of the the par professionals as opposed to the building substitutes yeah it's not clear it needs to be clear so um they'll do that for the 14th all right thank you thank you sorry to cut that so short but it needs to be clear um okay we need to talk about plc's are there Joanna so going back to P3 literacy and um this is also related to pulling the Paris um
241out some of the uh teachers said that the way that they would learn and and make the move the pilot forward is that going having other teachers come watch them teach so this is not even this is not even like uh early release or late start this is we are we are creating a circumstance here where we are pulling teachers out of the classrooms then we need the powers to cover the teachers that are in the classroom so I'm having a lot of trouble wrapping my mind around the fact that we want to give more and more U more professional learning time to these teachers and but we're also creating the situation that we have to cover the classes and it and that then that's what's costing too much money do you yes so I
242think that that's again that's a piece that coverage of professional learning needs to be included in the crosswalk but I think plc's is one of your Solutions is that right can you speak to that they did say I'm sorry they did say during the the last curriculum meeting that yes they would do they would teach each other but then they still have to try things out and watch other teachers yes and spend time on that right so one of the things that we need to I think be considering is what is an overall design for professional learning and you one of the things that can't really be replicated right with um before school in August professional learning or like a November 7th full day or like during the high school early release date is when
243you actually have the students really in front of you and kind of creating those lab experiences for teachers and um I think it's a wonderful thing that our teachers are willing and very willing and eager to open their classroom doors to one another and share and practice and that's really something that we need to consider as part of our overall professional development plc's are more when um teachers are reflecting upon the teaching and learning experiences when the students are not with them and so they serve very different purposes for professional learning both are important so I'm I'm going to ask you to say that again because there's been a lot of confusion about the difference between a PLC and and PD so please repeat that so a professional Learning Community is largely meant to be
244PLC largely meant to be driven by um teacher Choice there should be Cycles we're looking um in the Strategic plan to have more consistent structures about how those are implemented across um the schools across preschool through grade 12 um and all of all seven of our schools including pitch um additionally with the professional learning we've heard that there needs to be um a balance of teacher voice and choice in professional learning and teachers facilitating professional learning There's an opportunity for that to be done in plc's but those are largely they're very focused sections sessions I should say typically on looking at student data student work samples really aligned to the curriculum um it's more of a a finite experience the PD that we're looking at would be more I think bigger picture things that we're
245working on systemically like play based learning that's something that isn't addressed solely within a session for example K3 literacy has already been indicated we'll need time within the school day and beyond for for grade levels to meet across the five elementary schools to think about how that's approached so I think some of the professional learning outside of PLC is for the larger systemic work that's addressed in the Strategic plan plc's are more directed for teachers and responding to the work of the students um before them in their classs okay can I just add a we bit to that just uh if I can say everything else um outside of the PLC for the PLC to be dedicated time to Simply to address the issues that they're experienc in as common teachers with the common kids
246in front of them right what do we want the kids to know whether it's by a topic or by next week or by what sub what do we want the kids to know how do we know we know it and how are you going to measure that not as a a formative not as a summ of assessment but a formative along the way to assess are we getting it what do you do if they don't get it and what do you do for the students who actually have mastered it so it allows them to focus on their classroom practices and curriculum in in real time right um currently now for some of the elementaries particularly we're not we can't do that because we're hijacking it for all these other topics um and the actual the
247learning together around what's actually happening in their classrooms is not really that consistent I I would say elementary and middle school as well we've heard from our Middle School staff as well that meetings that are intended to be for the function of PLC and like Dr edley said really looking at student work samples in student data for the students before the teachers and then planning collectively to respond to that some of that has been overtaken by other very important work when you think about curriculum design and curriculum implementation there are other pieces that then are kind that's seeping into that time so we're trying to delate and um make a more clear articulation for staff the different purpose for the professional learning and PLC it's noon time I have a suggestion I think the PLC
248discussion I think it's a bigger discussion um and we have rc9 coming up so I'd like to table this for the moment but come back to it in rc19 when we get there um we are about half an hour or more behind schedule um we have Kevin waiting for us um um it is my suggestion that we break for 15 minutes get a lunch uh and come back here do questions for elementary schools at TH questions oh yes can I ask one more question before who are yes um just regarding substitutes um coming back to that piece about PA professionals and interns um and I'm I'm curious to know if this extends beyond the elementary division as well but it seems to me that that we're not really addressing a root cause that we're kind
249of switching coverage from one category that's not intended to be a substitute and pair professionals to another category that's not intended to be a substitute interns and I'm curious like how big the problem is how systemic it is is it only the pair of professionals that are being pulled are they enough to cover it is anyone else potentially being pulled to act as substitutes we have other people in our buildings such as interventionists um so i' I'd like to ask a little more question about the substitutes you know understanding that there's been some trouble in finding daily we experienced this during covid and we kind of put out an ask and we had some community members step up but I I think that it's a bigger picture conversation that we aren't fully understanding but in
250the immediate terms I am interested to know if there are other categories of Staff Beyond a pair of professionals that are being affected by this March well first interns are specifically designed to cover classes that's basically what they're supposed to be doing they can occasionally do a long-term sub but they're supposed to be getting that experience of leading a classroom so so that is just a more economical way of covering classes with people who's H who've had some teacher training beforehand this is a problem throughout the state the daily substitutes it's something that people struggle with that's why the daily substitute rate keeps going up people are hiring more building substitutes because then you have them on staff we're offering health insurance to try to keep them retention bonuses um I I'll defer to Amy
251I know we try not to pull interventionists to cover classes on particularly bad days I think we may need to do it from time to time um yes but I just want to clarify I think the interns are not only more economical but do you not also have in the narrative that they're also you they also have specific training and education economical comparing institutions have actually changed the structure so that they have a little more training before they come here you know in classroom management and the you know imparting curriculum and yes they have been a pretty decent pipeline for us to H to hire um not recently obviously okay and then on this question of substitutes there's usually two pieces there's the need for the substitute and whether we can get one and there's
252absenteeism yes and absenteeism throughout the state I mean Daran has always been a little higher but frankly everyone's caught up to us now um I don't think the new Connecticut paid sick leave Law is going to make it any better I think it's actually going to make it worse because teachers and at all staff can take absences in hourong increments so we won't be able to get substitutes from the outside so I'm a little nervous about what's going to happen with classroom coverage in light of that new law okay and I use the word absenteeism that typically has a negative connotation meaning people who are just not showing up for work but but what you're describing is just a structural change to how we um Grant absences correct well that is yes the law makes
253it very easy to take days without reasons or whatever but but there is a chronic absentee issue especially with our Paris and teachers don't text me but but it's it's just and it's it's not just us but it's it's not thank you yes and then Rob thank you just to follow up on that um I I'm really very confused at the intention and again coming back to the vision of this because it seems to me that we have a need for interns and that class coverage is an issue and that they would be a wonderful addition in terms of filling a gap that is currently there as well as introducing a pipeline that makes great sense to me what does not make sense to me is how eliminating pair of professionals is in the conversation
254because they're never supposed to be substitutes in the first place and part of the reason that we need substitutes is because people are taking more time off that makes me wonder if they need more days to take a break and if maybe they're not their jobs are becoming bigger than they can handle to show up to work every day and how is reducing AIDS going to make anyone show like take less personal days so to me I think that we are banding and and trying to solve a problem without looking at root causes and potentially like the other theme of the day is unintended consequences I think that we could be making this worse Robin um and this is getting again to the root cause and I would like to understand what the reasons are
255for the absences or if the reason we need more teacher coverage are they doing in internal things where they have to be pulled out of a classroom for various reasons and could that is that PPT meetings is it internal you know K through three literacy training things is it professional development how much of the absentee and coverage needs are due to actual absences for sickness or whatever else where they're out of the building versus internal things that we are doing and I I'm concerned that those things that are internal are going to take up more time in the next year or two given the K through three roll out the potential elimination of idea and the needs to train for those and so I just want to understand that as well because I do think
256that there are there are a lot of unintended consequences and we're kind of not addressing root causes of all the initiatives that we're doing okay are we able to see a databased look at absences okay all right we'll see that on the 14th yes um I believe last year we went or we voted last year to go from four to three or three to two or whatever it was the amount of instructional pairs in each Elementary School yes um I would like to know if there have been any changes in the building on the ground if there's more disciplinary issues if teachers are falling a little bit behind in the pace of which they need to deliver instruction like has there been any um consequences from that change okay principles can you answer that any
257impacts from last year's adjustment I think the the biggest impact is that we have concentrated the instructional PA professional support in kindergarten and first grade and our upper grade teachers have less support okay other principles mean with those I can't speak it's pretty much the same at all the schools so would those upper grade elementary teachers say that this is been you know how much of a negative effect on their day-to-day management of the classroom and and ability to all our teachers are amazing like I think we all or a lot of us agree with that but we've already asked the upper grades to take on a a more of a heavy day-to-day load when you don't have like when you go to small group construction it's easier because the older kids can sit there
258on their own for a little bit but like so we' yes it's it's it's last year's change is a good thing to include in the question that we've asked about um the kind of an elementary school teacher and and what that looks like with gifted Paris literacy um Etc so last year's change um there might be some data that helps us there please okay I saw Greg just a quick follow up on the absentee information request if the drivers would be really helpful also just the trends just a few years would be helpful just to see okay where that's been and where it's okay Trends over time and drivers and data okay all right just on this topic I would recognize just to close it out a we but maybe perhaps I would recognize it's
259not making some of some of the teachers jobs easier right but I'll just just since we're closing I'll just remind the board like assuming we're going to be doing some of the stuff that we have to do right reading and so on and so forth legislation we have about $2.7 million to make up here so the question from from Mr gramling is is an appropriate one well what if it's not this what is it right um there are significant things everything on the table is not what ideally put in the table um but whatever way you skin this you have to get time from 6% to unless the board at the end of the day is going to say superintendent bring back a solution that increases the budget right okay well I been happy to
260listen to that um but anyway I'm just saying that that I just I know you know the challenge right but I'm just reminding us of the challenge that's all yes okay with that I'll open it to um comments from fellow elected officials uh good morning uh or afternoon uh I'm Peter Orel 67 Raymond Street I'm also on the uh RTM finance and budget committee uh how are my comments primarily deal with um mik uh I'm making them in my individual capacity and I thank you for your patience I had a a business call I had to take U recent um just a couple minutes ago um I'd like to discuss um the idea issues um I understand these are all difficult decisions uh however that difficulty makes us Focus even more on what our goals
261are and it seems to me that idea really focuses on a number one strategic goal which is teaching and learning in the classroom I think we have to deal with wants versus needs and especially with exhausting all administrative efficiencies before we start to cut classroom teaching I look at the gifted program as such as idea is not an efficiency but a core function of our school district in a town like Daran where families seek um a community with the top school system like ours uh I also believe at least it's my opinion that idea is actually a very lean and effective program you're suing 200 plus students with 3.3 FTE that comes out to be I think one uh FTE for every 69 students um there are athletic teams where we have one coach for
262every 12 students I think we can uh I think we can afford and I think we should reward that efficiency um and if there if there are perceived inefficiencies or ineffective nature of this program I'd like to see that data because I don't think there is any um ideas return on investment goes beyond providing efficient effective teaching it supports daran's reputation for having a top school system and I have to ask you this is It's hard to avoid the conclusion that we're telling parents that we don't value gifted students we live in deren and we expect to Aspire and achieve the highest levels are we telling and I have to this is a very difficult thing to say and I've been um um wrestling with this for a while but I have to ask the
263rhetorical question are we at telling parents that they need to turn to private schools to maximize the potentials of the gifted child are we encouraging bright flight which is the term I had not heard until uh Thursday evening um the district website talks about gifted students require special instructions due to the many aspects of their High intellectual ability is that now untrue is there any data behind that uh that where we are turning in a different direction I have to ask where is the post idea plan what are gifted students supposed to do um the presentation at this point doesn't seem to provide any detailed uh plan forward uh I think the idea that it'll just be okay maybe is not sufficient but even go I'm going back to the uh u u hey Peter
264I'm done you're done okay I asked to look to administrative efficiencies before clubing at a c CL from teaching thank you uh Crystal Hills cdsp chair uh just a general point of clarification on page 156 which is uh the ox Bridge there's a chart of average school size that indicates on average it's 18.7 for um oxridge which is accurate if you're including ELP but it's a little bit misleading when you compare it to the other schools because the other schools only have a K through five so you're more at like a number close to 22 K through 5 it would just be helpful for Oxbridge now that they fully have the ELP if we just had an additional column that showed just if we want to compare across the schools that's correct um and then
265just on the parat topic um I think I've heard from parents echoing everything that was said here at the board um just a confusion for me we're taking three instructional pairs down to two interns we're talking about how much extra coverage were are needed in substit for substitutes just logistically I don't understand taking it from three bodies in the school to two but you're talking about all this extra need for substitute just seems like we creating more of a problem there than solving a problem in terms of coverage in classes um and the general questions like what are the differences that the two will perform is there a different expectation that the with the work that an intern would be doing versus a par um professional um you know what's the turnover we we'll obviously
266have new interns every year will that be semester Wise by the year um and then we brought this up last year but there continues to be no real differentiation in the instructional support staff at the between the elementaries based on the size of the schools um Ox Ridge uh K through just K through five alone not even including Alp is 50% larger than Royal but yet they have the same amount of support staff just seems like like in terms of lutch monitors even school security you know they're overseeing a much larger population yet received the same amount of uh staff at their school I also I've comments on PLC but if we're you're going to come back to that later I can I could table that okay we have a raised hand online Mrs jacn
267Owens you are unmuted Jackie Owens CPAC for Parson's walk um for the record I just have heard different comments are the interns actually legally allowed to be left alone with the students in a classroom without any other staff member is that correct yes okay Marge is nauy not cuz I know oh okay I just want so if if that is true how um the the impact on the student relationships the current AIDS are invaluable and retention is so important that they know the students and I feel like the the interns are going to have to really spend more time getting to know these students and bullying is a huge um concern and so how will this help our bullying problem as well as the impact of our special education par Educators who legally have students
268on their case load and then now are they going to be impacted will interns be seeking like their um professional advice in getting to know certain students in managing the classroom since they um um are interns so that th those are just my comments regarding the the interns and my concern getting rid of um our invaluable AIDs that we currently have thank you thank you anyone else online cast okay it is 12:15 so that gives us a perfect 15minute increment I will take a motion to adour uh to Recess Recess thank you John seconded by um Dennis all those in favor and we'll be back here at 12:30 just make sure they mve the mics for yes and Jeff will you turn the mics off please there one e e e mik are okay make
269sure you're turned on are we yes yeah memb okay and so we're live we're live all right with that I'll have a motion to reconvene that is um Greg seconded by Robin all those in favor that is unanimous with who's in the room um Dennis is just not quite back in yet um and we will start off with facilities we'll thank you Kevin for waiting for an hour for us um hopefully we haven't thoroughly ruined your Saturday it's quite old right just mostly okay morning Kevin good morning or take it off please sir after sorry sure thing so rc12 operating for facilities uh this year for the most part as you can see is pretty straightforward there's a few line items that I'd like to call your attention to first and foremost uh consultant Services
270uh there's a $90,000 ask which is uh entirely for the Middle School study you'll recall that we talked about this at the facil facilities meetings over the past several months and the importance of conducting this study this coming fiscal year so that we would be in line for a potential project at the middle school when the HHR projects are just wrapping up the study would be a full me structural um study of the school as well as a spatial study with enrollment component um other lines to talk about the refu we're in the third year of a three-year contract and that's uh that has an almost 8% contractual increase we did reduce the um 72016 line which showed the three platforms we renovated this past summer at Henley holes and Royal so there was a
271a corresponding offset to that account uh the HVAC SE line is also showing an increase of about 5% that's mainly due to oxridge and all its sophist at HVAC equipment which we previously didn't have to deal with um so we're we're showing an increase there last but not least the part-time hourly line um you'll recall that last year we took a cut in the facilities department for our contracted service um work at the high school we had a a company that was performing cleaning services we're now handling that work uh internally with part-time workers and that's why you see an increase there um for the most part we've you know kept the facilities budget pretty flat year-to year but there are those you know four or five um lines that do show a increase in
272the in the percent column okay I'll open it to board questions Joanna um so originally the study uh was recommended for Middle sex token DHS and central office are we losing any um sort of savings by keeping them together by splitting them apart no not necessarily these studies are typically done on a square foot uh basis a rate per square foot so all you're doing is deferring token high school and central office out one year to fiscal year 27 and that's the recommended timeline why versus when the Middle School comes on I know there's a built need for a building condition survey so I was just curious about what the total thinking was so uh the idea behind kind of parsing the two out is obviously the middle school is the building with the majority
273of the needs and the the building that's been talked about is potentially having a building project um whereas the high school and token are far more like facility conditions related what you know when are you going to have to have a new roof when are you going to have to have a new HVAC um if we go this approach and it's approved the middle school funding would be in your base and so then when you go to fiscal year 27 your C just recycling that money to fund uh token and the high school without having to ask for a larger increase in terms of the F and when you say um token and the high school do you also mean central office um for the and and that also in this building is primarily condition
274based yes okay other questions about the um study so with that rich your your your thought is to do the a building study every two or so years with with a different number of schools rolled in no TR to keep that steady or to or just no so typically you would do a building condition study every 10 years so the idea here is here would be to focus on the middle school then in 27 not necessarily have to ask for new money because you're going to repurpose that middle school money for the high school and then toque and then here and then in fiscal year 28 that money would drop off your budget as a reduction and then you know seven years down the road depending on what happens with the Middle School whether you
275renovate is new or if you build a new um Middle School however that ends up playing out you know seven to eight years out you would have to ask for it again Dave um just again trying to separate policy from budget I know my recollection is that the expense for the roof at token really sort of prompted thoughts around what we need to do in a replacement or a potential replacement um I'm just thinking back to our past building projects I don't really remember us going this far down the road of potentially have a replacement I'm just concerned where we are that there's board in interest in possibly going down that road or is this a preliminary step to identify that interest before the board ascents to moving down that this is a preliminary step
276okay yeah meaning that we commissioned the study so that we can decide what the scope of the next work would be if correct yes well I think it's probable that we'll need to do at least some work on the building but whether it's a building project or it's a series of small items in the capital plan okay um other questions on the plan or the maintenance let's stay with the plan for the moment and then go to Greater maintenance okay greater maintenance Robin um is the revenue sorry is the building rental Revenue the 77,000 is that is that Mo does that include the basketball rental from the YMCA or not so YMCA the only thing we uh build back is cost of custodial over time and then the reciprocal agreement allows us to use their
277facilities for swim at no cost so are we not reflecting anywhere the the costs the innate costs of that YMC agreement in our budget well there there is no transfer of funds so there is no way to reflect it it's like an inine service on both sides okay I but again I mean the the data that we had requested I think was to understand that value so we can understand potential iterations of what we could do there right now it's nowhere to be found in our budget but it is actually a significant it could be a significant source of Revenue building rentals so it wouldn't necessarily be a significant Source you'd have additional Revenue if you were to build them and then you'd have a significant expense to pay the rentals for them so there
278would be no net benefit to your budget um other than drawback at the time billing back and but if we potentially had a cost sharing for instance with this swim parents of 70% like we do with hockey and the other teams that used Outsource facilities and then represented the basketball building rental as Revenue separately it I just think it would be helpful to understand the full value and cost I we could we could certainly show it when we went back and forth with the Y agreement uh there is no there is no benefit essentially you're getting into a pricing more between the two agencies there was an original memo when we did this a few years ago can you can you circulate that memo too thank you Dennis Kevin going back to last year's budget
279I recall you having a a request that was denied about uh groundskeeper I believe for for maintenance of the the facilities and now and you said that with with the construction of the new buildings that we would definitely need it coming forward and I don't see an additional person here so you're confident that we can continue to maintain our facilities without without that fire so our our staffing levels are appropriate for where we are at this point in time yes we did Rich and Kevin can you talk about what we did last year yeah so the the the FTE was added last fiscal year it was actually denied two years ago so I think okay my my bad recollection okay thank you we added it in the May section to offset some Outsourcing we were
280doing right um other maintenance questions no okay I'm sorry HVAC count maintenance HVAC count maintenance um you said in the it says in the book that they were replacing filters at um Oxbridge and HHR are we already do we already have HVAC systems um up and running at HHR or is this next year you expect to do so HHR only has one or two um unit ventilators that have been installed uh eventually when they all get rolled out you'll see an increase in that line to reflect the uh additional hva equipment at those schools but right now it was more of a template to make sure that the systems were compatible and working so it's less than 1% of the rooms are done at this point Thank you you're welcome okay all right um I
281will open it up to um members of the oh go ahead Greg thank sorry just one last question um and this isn't really for this budget process but just longer term as it relates to maintenance as we're redoing and remodeling some of these buildings it'd be interesting to know like what the long-term implications are for this part of our budget where I would expect that some of these expenses would come down as we're doing that work the LED was a perfect example of that yep okay I think that is um something we need to put in the parking lot on our Master agenda so can you we'll try to well we'll put that in Can you capture that please and put it in for the 14th because I think that's right Greg we should be
282looking at that okay um fellow government officials any comments members of the public oh okay capital projects terrific so on December 6 we held our annual walkthr of the capital projects that you have in in the back of your binder uh we started at the high school this year just due to a lack of uh projects at the Middle School uh one area that we're requesting funds is to purchase our own LED light fixtures historically this was done through a type of PPA agreement where the labor and the materials are outsourced to a third party um but we realized that with our in-house staff uh electrician were're able to not only get better fixtures um but utilize our own labor force to show some Energy savings by you know increasing the uh electricity or lack
283of electricity and wattage in the building moving down we have the repaving of I'm goingon to interrupt you because we have gone through this in detail um previously here at the table in the facilities committee and it as a walkth through can you just hit the highlights and talk about there's a few things that came up in the um building tour um and just talk about where we are on those sure uh um so in particular we we talked about a few of the security um initiatives which I won't get into too too much detail um but essentially we're repairing and maintaining some of the components where we're starting to notice wear and tear at the high school in particular um we're asking for those to be replaced uh in their entirety just because of
284the problems they are creating for us um there's also the replacement cycle for districtwide uh equipment whether it's custodial machines Vehicles Suburbans throughout District placement Etc so in terms of the high school the doors came up that's staying in the capital budget yes I think at token you guys are escalating some of the work that you identified correct that's right yep um and so that the plan's been updated accordingly or it's still in this plan it's still in this plan you don't have the ability to do it this year we don't have we have no dollars okay okay so I think we marked that for executive session for the 14th okay um to catch anybody else up who needs to know and then there was a third thing that came up I think it was
285central office but there been there's no other there's no changes to the plan there's no plans to there's no plan to the change of central office time in for the upgrades okay are there any other questions understanding that we'll talk about the security upgrades in executive session on the 14th Sarah um not necessarily for this year but I'm just looking forward at 2627 and at HHR the blacktop um but it's significant at each of those three schools just confirming that's not in the HHR projects that's not in the HHR project okay corre Joanna um I know if we do the midle sex study um they'll incorporate the roof that's scheduled to start not next year but the year after in the at least in the the plan um this does splitting up the study also
286have leave enough time to uh for the DHS roof that looks like it's supposed to be replaced in 28 29 so so yes I think the way that's the the capital plan is mapped out is that if we do these studies uh in the appropriate fiscal year we can roll up a lot of those individual capital projects into one uh larger building committee project great thank you Dave just said a question on the token um I appreciate the issue with the drainage and the pipe and the grading of the entrance is there a way to break that out from the blacktop as well and then the blacktop with um DHS and token there efficiencies from doing that together or would it matter if we disconnected it didn't separately honestly no uh Paving milling and Paving
287it's it's just a square footage uh price whether you do one parking lot or two you're still going to pretty much get the same price points okay want you to see the breakout thank you sure thank you anything else on the capital plan okay thank you Kevin you're welcome um question I'm sorry comments from public officials comments from the public all right up hi my name is E brook I'm a seventh grader at middle sex middle school and I live at 20 Maywood Road um sorry for going out of order but earlier I was watching for home and I wanted to express some points about the idea program when I first heard that the proposed budget for the 2025 through 2026 school year did not include Appropriations for the idea program two thoughts came to
288my mind when I was in first grade at Royal Elementary my teacher was Mrs keing Mrs keing was an amazing teacher who was still one of my favorite teachers today it was Mrs keing who first had me evaluated for the idea program although Mrs ke and my second grade teacher Mrs Miss dorenzo were both great they didn't have the resources in the classroom nor the specific training to help me find books whose subject matter was appropriate for a second grader but still talented my reading level this is one of many Reasons I'm Thankful For Miss Martin my idea teacher throughout Elementary School who helped me find books that were perfect for me these books inspired me with a love of learning that I still have today this brings me to my second point an idea
289we often have to do group challenges designed to strengthen our vision of The Graduate um attributes particularly creativity communication and curiosity an example of one of these project was a project I did with a group in fourth grade we design a travel Brer for a fictional island this exercise included many requirements we created a language tourism an economy an alphabet and even sports that were only played on this island the reason these exercises are so beneficial is because this is an activity that we would never be able to do in another class I had to communicate with my team members be curious about the topics and be creative with the brur in order to do well I want to close by saying that I think that idea is the one class that has installed me
290with the greatest curiosity thank you thank you for your time okay anyone online all right with that we'll move on to fixed expenses thank you Kevin so fixed expenses has three primary drivers uh the first being home to school transportation um we are going into the second year fiveyear contract with first student um one of the um unfunded mandates is the Connecticut Clean Air Act which requires school districts to phase out diesel buses next year we'll include five propane buses out of the 25 buses uh we do have a 7% annual increase um with first student as we discussed last year um diesel prices are going down so that's slight savings going down for fre 13 to $2.60 per gallon or a 20% reduction uh the next uh driver in fixed cost is electricity as
291most people have seen with their own home electric bills electric costs are going up um part of that has to do with the public benefit charge um we do also pay the public benefit charge um and the supplier rate for electricity is a 33% increase for next year and then finally the other driver within fixed cost is health insurance uh we are running at 118% loss ratio which means for every dollar spent we Anthem is paying out a118 um our renewal is at 11.9% which is slightly less than last year's 13.85% we do bid out health insurance every year um the low bid is 11.9% we did get some bids in the mid 20s and one in the 30s um the driving reason for the large cost increases in health insurance again continue to be
292the claims associated with our what's called covered life so staff or spouses are are children who are covered under our health insurance plan um I know I have to look up S um questions about this category Sarah I'm just curious about the health insurance and thank you for doing such a great job of making sure that those are that those crops are as low as they possibly can even though they're still huge um you know it's said that health insurance is sometimes cycal where do we fall in that you know are our claims really I mean know our claims were really high are we still having some super high claims or uh so we've we' still had a couple claims that were in excess of $750,000 for a person um they have been coming down
293over the last trailing 18 um but the claims that we have they're typically a lot of cancer claims and so they're not claims that end up being a short amount of time they two tend to drag out as people end up having to get care um you know we had a couple years where the district was getting you know 2 to 4% renewal increases and then probably about six years ago we were in the 6 to 8% range and then last year we hit the 13 plus range um we are seeing it across Fairfield County Westport for example got a 40% renewal last year um there are some other districts going in the mid- teens as well um you know it's really a product of how healthy we can get people um on our plan
294okay thanks back to the um sorry any other questions on health insurance on Transportation last year in my notes I had that um we saved about $600,000 if we had a bus depot um I've not sure that's accurate so I wanted to just make sure that I had if if we were to have a bus depot what do you imagine the savings would be and what's the difference in terms of the number of companies that would bid or so uh first student rents a Depot in Stanford and their rent is about a half a million dollars a year for that that Depot so they're passing that on to us so it's about a half a million dollars when we put it out to bid companies like datco which are in new Canan said we won't
295bid on your your services because we don't have anywhere to park buses um sta who operates in Wilton as an example said the same thing Durham uh submitted a bit but said you'd have to provide a bus depot um Durham uh provides Transportation norok as an example so we only get one bid there's really only one company who is willing um to provide us Transportation uh if we were to magically come up with a bus depot like this year first student has told us that because we'd have to terminate the cont they would walk away from us um so then you'd have nobody well okay um now when you say if we were to terminate so we have the right to terminate the agreement with 60 days notice right um so if you were to
296magically find a bus Depo this year you could terminate first student will not bid renegotiate terms correct or renegotiate the terms they would essentially walk away from the district we would have to see if we could get some of the other districts or other bus companies like aad we an SDA to provide services here um the be the ability to turn around 25 buses in that short of a time would be quite difficult and I'm not quite sure that you would be able to get that on that short term of a notice so if the the district or the town is looking at a busot it's not a next year solution okay and you said the savings are around 500,000 a year or for the duration of the contract a year a year okay and
297then the number of bus companies a sense of thank you Sarah the number of bus companies that we that are out there that would Place bids is what five or six um it's probably four or five four or five including first students okay um John so basically what you're saying is critical that first student runs its own or is yeah runs its own bus depot I'm just sure trying to understand the termination of the contract if we were we have the right uh to terminate the contract for any Reon like we don't like the way they look at us we can just say you're You're gone if we say we're terminating the contract because we want to have our own bus depot they have a lease associated with the bus depot that they're in that
298there they would be then stuck to continue paying for the next few years um they basically said is a negotiating tactic like we're not going to be bothered with you for those years got it so it's pretty complex three-dimensional chess correct okay are we the only District the first student operates out of that Depot now they share part of it with Stanford so Stanford also does doesn't have a bus depot but they rent essentially a bus depot and a half um so a full Depot for Stanford and then they have some of their out of District vehicles that are on our lot Joanna when you say bus depot what does that look like is it a building or is it so it's both it's it's the ability to park your buses it's the ability to
299have like a bay where you can work on your buses in case your buses get you know broken down or whatever need to be fixed um it's a place for the dispatcher and the manager to be uh to take calls it's a place for the drivers to have their breakfast as an example um the depot that they rent unlike some other Depot there is no propane uh not propane well propane too but or diesel tanks on the property which some areas do have they they do what's called wet hosing and so wet hosing is literally you're coming up with a tanker truck and you're filling up the buses kind of like you would have a oil company come to your house fill up your oil tank to give you heat and then drive away it's
300the same thing except they're doing it with 25 buses and does uh new Kanan have an actual building or they have a little area where like the um the manager and the dispatcher can be thank you and they do wet hosing too then I I believe they do um Greg KD Robin um is potentially partnering with any nearby districts who are doing it themselves an option so uh the area districts like new K and they don't have the ability to put another 25 buses on their high school parking lot um Nora for example uh they rent out an area in um Norah walk for a Depot they don't have enough spaces for another 25 buses Weston Parks their buses on their campus and they don't have the space it's really a space limitation be able
301to share with other districts that a large island Katie um when you were talking about the bidding on the um contracts if we were to have a Depot what would that be for that would be for providing drivers it's it's a free space for them to park their vehicles and their staff okay so that would just be that component so it's parking the actual buses themselves and then the vehicles for the drivers okay so so that scenario that you were talking about was really just about us bringing a Depot within Daran not about us internalizing the entire Transportation process own buses and cor you I don't believe you want to get in the business of owning 25 72 passenger vehicles it's a lot different than owning like a Suburban or a sprinter van um you
302would certainly have to have a fleet of mechanics available um there's a lot more regulations in terms of a 72 passenger okay so so what we would really be looking at would be just opening up the potential to have more than just for student bidding on our trans correct if you had a place if they could park at the high school as an example like they do at new Canan I'm sure we would get companies like dco or SDA to bid along with first student and then you'd have a competitive Marketplace thank you Robin um if we did have a bus depot and did that would that allow us to for example use on weekends that you know provide some of the busing for athletics so they already do that so they already do that
303so we would still be paying time and a half for well no the time and a half would be for our personal drivers um we do use First Student that provides transportation for athletics on the weekends but you're paying first student and the savings per year how much did you say that would be if we uh so right now first students paying about a half a million dollars a year in rent but if we had our own bus depot so if you had your own bus depot we have to pay rent on that too proba well it depends on if the town owned the property so for example like new Kanan they own obviously the parking lot at new Kanan High School in Weston they own the parking lot where the bus is so there
304is no rent expense but there's no other savings aside from that correct okay but you're probably right it's probably not a completely clean 500,000 because there' be facilities maintenance Etc go John so may I suggest this isn't a good budget discussion but uh strategically maybe work with uh Mr zsky on this longer term thank you he actually reached out to me about it two weeks ago cool thank you John um okay uh fellow elected officials members of the public anyone online okay no with that we'll move to music thank you so much Kevin hello Colleen how are you good morning I'm very well how are you thank you so I will it's not morning anymore oh afternoon hello so um I'm pleased to have the opportunity to present the budget for uh the music rc3
305uh the budget reflects the cost of maintaining the high level of Music programming and instruction we offer to students prek through 12 uh it is worth noting that our Arts programs are fully inclusive offering highquality experiences to students at every ability level including students who require adaptive services to those who have been identified as having exceptional gifts and talents there are no new courses for next year or proposed changes in programming so this presentation should be pretty straightforward um I'll just go through each line and at the end if you have questions um if you'd like to stop me feel free uh so our our first account software uh no proposed changes this is just to maintain our current software and cloudbased music programming uh in textbooks and consumables we have a reduction there because
306um last year we bought uh textbooks for a new course classroom reference this is our uh main account for coral and instrumental music and there's no requested increase there in terms of resour ource materials uh this provides um some uh assessment programs and web-based music programs for our students and there's actually a decrease there we able to find some efficiencies uh next account General teaching supplies um we have uh very nominal increase uh and this provides us with all of our teaching supplies for prek through 12 uh no increase to our proposed professional development budget or to our temporary hourly Services account which includes accompanist and guest artist in dues and memberships uh no new dues and memberships requested but just a slight increase in uh a few of the fees in that account no
307increase to music Transportation or to our repairs and service contract for tuning of pianos we do have a slight increase um our long-term piano technician retired and so um in searching for uh someone to service our pianos um our new technician uh charges a higher fee and so um there is an increase there um and then in terms of equipment uh slight increase there um really just due to a need to replace the music stands uh in this account this is where we um replace and purchase new instruments uh that are needed to maintain a high quality uh library of instruments for our students um slight increase there but um I think we've presented a pretty reasonable balanced music budget and I'm happy to take questions Joanna I the question sorry of clarification it says
308sorry that you uh K PK through 5 does has music twice a week is it a week or is it a six day cycle uh for prek it's twice per week and for uh K through five it's twice per six day cycle thank you Robin you have questions um the clubs and councils 63,000 what does that include uh that's the the all Town um the stiens for the individuals would like the all town uh chorus and choir things like so it's for the extracurricular competitions or conferences that they got not conferences but like the actual I mean Colleen can answer it a little bit but it's the actual like singing like the adviser of that CH requir but these go ahead yeah I just wanted to understand exactly what it was sure um these are
309mostly for uh Elementary um so the alltown elementary band chorus and Orchestra um we offer that in the spring for um students who have um additional interest or or talent in band chorus and Orchestra and we actually do an adjudication festival and bring in a guest judge and the students have an extra performance and it's um really helpful for students who uh want to move on to a higher level of playing in middle school and high school so that is it's basically all of the elementary level stiens for the alltown kind of concerts for that time of those teachers is that right yes yes it stiens for uh teachers to um do additional ensembles outside of the school day thank you just one follow is that part of the Court curriculum or would we consider
310that extracurricular um I would consider it co-curricular um because we're still doing um you know we're we're still presenting that as part of our curriculum um but it allows us to offer some programming outside of the school day um you know for example we don't have the opportunity to bring all of the uh Elementary trumpet players together um during the school day but we can do so um through a before after school program thank you um in the beginning of the year um we had a bit of an update on how the uh loss of one of the FTE in the music I know it's not in this RC it's in elementary but we have an update um because but you know it seemed like they were going uh instead of once a week it
311was once every six day cycle and that was like a reduction at 20% and you just had all these you know uh concerts in December and all these Elementary split could we just have an update on how that's going and if if the program has been truly preserved I I think it might be helpful to have that somewhat formally again because it's something we're watching closely so Colleen happy to hear from you but I'd love to know if the December concerts were at the same level of quality we're expecting understanding that cohorts may change um if we've been able to deliver what we said we did now that more time has passed um I'd like to see a formal answer to that question okay um sure great thank you how do you envision that is
312that a um I think it's part of the the packet that comes to us for the 14th um so um you know looking at the impact of we were trying to bring a lot more instructional time during the school day has that worked out um how does that work out for children with needs are they um sometimes don't have as much time during the school day are they able to still access the same amount of musical instruction um some of those questions um and let me know if if you need us to work on any more specificity okay I can do that thank you thank you just was this is Colleen translations um to to the art make just very briefly like you assumed a New York position and so on so forth like how
313did that go like or how is that go on just maybe that's part of the but can be part of that either way just a just we quick like how's that transition going I can't of sure um do you want me to use that as a transition into rc14 uh great um so I've been really uh grateful to have the opportunity to um oversee the visual art Department um I'm been really impressed with the level of instruction and the quality of programming that we offer to students in visual art prek through 12 um we actually started offering visual art for the first time prek um and that's been uh you know challenging but successful I'm really grateful to uh Sonia alante and Michelle forer for um taking that on um and it's it's been a
314great opportunity to um learn new things myself professionally but um you know just just work to uh support the program and um you know really support the the Arts um fully so uh it's it's been uh professionally rewarding and um I I uh think that um you know I'm I'm again I'm very impressed with the what we're offering uh to students in the Arts uh prek through 12 Music Theater and visual art thank you thank you um so uh just like rc14 um there are no new courses for next year um no proposed changes in programming uh so this budget represents the cost of maintaining current programs um so I'll just briefly go through the RC's like I did with the last um I'm sorry the accounts like I did with the last RC um
315our classroom reference account um represents uh what we purchased to support education in terms of uh books and exemplars for our student artists uh that line remains flat for next year um our software account um a big portion of this is a membership to a a resource called The Art of Education which is a really helpful curricular resource for our teachers um the cost of the yearly access has increased so that um represents the slight increase to this account um in terms of teaching supplies uh this account represents all the supplies and materials needed to deliver the visual arts curriculum prek through 12 and um that we have no uh increases proposed in that account uh professional development no increases proposed there um repairs and service contracts uh no increase there and in terms of
316equipment and Furniture we have a decrease there because we only um need to service our Kil shelves last year we purchased uh new equipment for our uh digital drawing and design cloth and uh that equipment is still serving us questions for this RC Katie thank you um Colleen in the um RC for music um I appreciated how in the introduction you had listed that it was um something that was offered you know PK through eight and then the number of students in DHS I'd love to see the same thing for the art do you happen to know that number off the top of your head um or can you come back to us with it I can come back to you with it and um that's a good idea to um have a similar uh
317color in both our se's and I'll make sure to work on that for next time but I will certainly get back to you on that yeah in fact would you just update the page rich and we can just change it in our book so we have it thank you um the PD in this um RC is it calculated in the same way is it $65 per art teacher per head is that how this is done or is this a separate just um go ahead it's really just a flat dollar amount okay so what does it represent thank you uh there so there's no go ahead yeah it just it represents um teachers who request to go to conferences and bringing in guest artists and um we kind of look ahead to what conferences are being
318offered in the area and what teachers might want to attend um so for example I'm looking ahead not next school year but the school year after that I've spoken with the teachers about um a conference they might want to attend then and uh we may increase the the request um year-over-year or decrease the request based on um the conferences that are available and professional development needs that our teachers Express specific to visual art okay we talked a little bit earlier to today about um students who may be gifted outside of the humanities area it would be helpful to understand how art and music categories um are responding to the needs of those students um both from a programmatic and a budgetary perspective please that's a follow-up question sure and I can just um respond to
319that by um we actually have some good information on that because that was one of our essential questions last year through the Tri State visit um so um I can certainly come back and and revisit those findings and uh talk about talk about um the programming the arts for students with uh exceptional gifts and talents okay and think tying it to PD is important if we're talking about building capacity to serve the needs of all students okay Dennis earlier we Sorry earlier we had discussed about uh substitutes and curious is to do we see the same difference between specials and regular I don't want to say regular but classroom teachers versus specials and do we see do we have the same difficulty in in in having people show up to work every day H go
320ahead I could run I could run that report just be interested to see it to to Katie's point on overworking teachers is that is that a classroom teacher or is that a a general teaching malays I can r a report on absences the substitutes the daily substitutes that are available are more likely to pick up some absences than others like they don't normally want to do the special education or the PE absences so I can at least get you the absence data not necessarily the sub data okay thank you colen the the anecdotal data though just for I'm not observing a lot of music teachers and art teachers absent I I may be wrong but that's just my take away on it uh no I'm I'm not observing that either okay all right any other
321question Joanna um Colleen you mentioned the Tri State um report is that something board members can get and read yeah yeah we'll provide that thank you Katie thank you um rich just a question for you um page 197 I'm sorry I don't remember what we're calling a financial breakdown at the end of HRC but I don't see the history of the teacher leader stiens in that that s uh so that is uh row 552 where it says Elementary Arts systemwide so that's the release time and the stiens from the previous okay thank you okay so follow-ups from this category the last two categories are the impact of last year's an update of Music which will come on the 14th on updated Arts page uh with the um demographic or the population data that kada requested
322the gifted student in the Arts including professional development sort of how that looks then that will include um the tri skate report also being packaged with it okay any other questions okay um fellow government officials members of the public anyone online Cass okay all right thank you very much Colleen we appreciate your time thank you Colleen thank you library media good afternoon thanks everybody for having me to briefly share today on rc21 which represents the costs associated in the media centers across all seven schools great work is happening in our libraries so I love dropping in seeing the Librarians helping students select books and find information in our databases they're offering whole class and small group lessons and helping teachers and students troubleshoot technology in preparing for the budget for next year I reached out
323to all the Librarians to gather their concerns and suggestions and the nearly status quo budget offered today is a compromise in recognition of a difficult budget year and is still over 5% lower in the budget adopted two years ago um I'll try to add a little bit of color that we are uh um right around $200 each School higher in books uh and we're pretty much maintaining all their areas except a little bit higher for online subscriptions at the high school and I'll do my best I can to answer any questions you may have okay so as we talk about the use of libraries maybe you can talk to us about yes I understand the budget is relatively flat but how does it represent um how we're using the libraries today so the Librarians to
324kind of give you the global picture uh K12 they have a fixed schedule where the students come in uh on a regular block schedule for both book selection instructional purposes uh grades uh three and up what we more call a flex a flexed or flexible schedule um which is around drop-ins and scheduled needs for research by other staff um the high school library in particular The Librarians there do a lot of uh shared co- teing with particularly the English and the history Department um the Middle School uh librarian spends a a great deal of time uh assisting particularly uh staff and students with when they're not working on research and selecting books she's kind of the go-to person for some of the technology and especially around Wii video and uh video projects within the school
325um so she works closely with a number of staff that uh like to pursue those types of projects um so we have you know I guess to kind of summarize for you at the lowest Elementary levels fixed regular schedules and then from there a lot of the schedules for libraries are worked around um uh interests and needs and what's happening in the in the regular classrooms other board questions I would say that this has been sort of level funded for on a better term which is actually reflective of all these RC's as you're going through it you can see that um I might expect though once HHR is already completed uh that we may increase some of of these requests down the line a little bit because some of the books even in right now
326in the elementary schools are stored right um just because of the size and the transition so even though we've reduced it over the years we may see an increase in two years time I think um just marking it here it's not a budget discussion but I think probably we're do a discussion about how we're using our library some of the moving to a flex time for Upper Elementary I've seen as as a parent but haven't necessarily talked about as a board member so as our those libraries come online with different functionality than what we have today um where are we in terms of what types of what curriculum we're delivering at each what does it look like for the different grade levels what resources are needed for that um I think maybe in the summer
327time can I suest parking lot yeah yes I'm asking that's what I'm saying it's a parking lot for when you all think it's appropriate but probably before our new libraries go totally online so I think that's only we could bring between the curriculum committee and do it that way too great true okay thank you Robin just one question um do we have data on how many books or Trends in books actually being checked out of our middle school and high school and Elementary libraries I'm I'm just curious and you know I I noticed so in accessions obviously there was a couple years ago but accessions is down about $20,000 a lot of this now is much more digital and it's research based but just in terms of whether students have or are being encouraged to
328actually read physical books and if they have that interest I'd love to see the data on that and and making sure that our libraries actually are keeping current with collections that really reflect the interests of the students and you know are we phasing out books that no longer get checked out and I'm just curious about that from a librarian's perspective are we meeting those needs sure um so globally speaking I haven't directly asked Librarians this year for any data on their metrics of book circulation but kind of to your point um you know that sometimes a circulation is on a direct hard book it might instead be an online uh book resource such as Sora which presents a essentially a digital version of what would would be a print book and then sometimes a compromise
329is in instead for uh some types of readers there instead looking on research of through our databases especially at the high school high school database used I know from Librarians just telling me it's it's very very high um I can I feel very confident saying that the Librarians and I have been working together on revisiting their weeding process this year uh so that helps maintain a a fresh collection keeping it looking uh relevant and they are actively ordering new books uh and uh displaying them I know one of the high school librarians her personal goal this year in fact is to distribute more uh hard copy books to students and she's tracking those metrics for herself um I think circulation patterns are an important component of Library work and whether that's what type of materials
330they're checking out or making sure that our circulation patterns are actually where we want them to be so I think for that parking lot discussion I think it's fairly important to have a pretty good discussion about circulation and and just in in the realm of all of the renovations that are going on currently in three of our schools and the newly re-envisioned libraries that's also the reason why I'm asking are we ensuring that we're kind of ready for that next phase and you know making the Li is something that will be really useful for our students agreed Dennis so with the I know it's a small amount and and I'm GNA question is this the right amount of $99,000 for training on Aspen for one toone Middle School scheduling we we discussed a lot of
331discussion about Middle School scheduling and and we're only it's only costing us $9,000 to get that right seems awfully low I head yeah sorry hold that thought hold that thought we I'll stick around and circle back for Dave um just to follow up looking at some of the software subscriptions I guess some of these are multi-year some of them are not just talk to me how you're finding efficiencies or combining resources or actually U if it would make more sense can I stay on for when we present rc15 which really is instructional software um and I think Jeff Adams is leading that but I'm happy to talk to uh a couple of uhic spefic software is that we are trailing back to find greater efficiencies perfect thank you great thank you for volunteering your time
332you got it anything else on library media okay uh questions from fellow elected officials members of the public anyone online ke no all right thank you we are going to skip our 30 minute lunch break and move directly to to health we will take a break again at some point but not now um so Health good afternoon Emily how are you I'm great but I just heard everyone's going to be missing their lunch break I don't like to start off my talk that way hi everyone everyone for those who don't know me my name is Emily Merritt uh I'm the director of nursing services for darianne and I'll be going over RC 17 um I first just want to thank you for your continued support of the health services department we've always felt very supported
333by the board as well as a larger community and it's just important uh for setting the tone for our department so I just want to thank you for that in advance uh we're continue to to expand the nursing Services Department to meet the changing Healthcare needs of the dairy and public school Community I continue to um just take great pride in our ability as a district to support the large range of of uh medically complex students and ensuring that all students have access to their educational program in a local district and I think we should all be very proud proud of that um we've been doing a lot but I'm just going to focus on a couple of things for this year uh we've been placing a greater emphasis on the importance of relationships uh
334with our nurses nurses and students nurses and families as well as staff and uh teachers and this includes things like um having a school nurse website um there's a homepage at every one of our schools that now is the school nurse homepage and it has all of our information we keep updating it it's a great interface for families to uh connect with nurses and and vice versa um and that is there we also uh continue to be involved in a lot of our team meetings for any of students that have health concerns and so on so that's U been going really well um we've also are enhancing our ability to respond to Medical emergencies um through strengthening our Medical Emergency Response Team I don't know if you're all aware but every one of our schools
335has what's called a medical emergency response team or a mer uh the team's made up of it's led by the nurses and it's made up of um volunteers students staff and administration and it's basically there's plans specific to each School building and how we can best um address a medical emergency but this year in addition to our plans which we've all um kind of tightened up we have also been working with the security um head of security and with post 53 and we've actually run um medical emergency resp drills in every one of our schools uh with the high school coming up in the next couple of weeks so that's gone really well and it's very uh helpful in finding things that we should do better but also things that are working so that's really
336great um we've trained approximately 50 staff this year alone in CPR and aeds um and most of those staff members are part of the mert team um and the nurses are providing Man U mandated staff trainings on health rated topics such as uh an aaxis seizures choking a EDS and basic first aid um all of our schools have a minimum of five um staff member and administration that know how to administer Naran in the case that a school nurse is not available and if it's indicated um every one of our SSR have the opportunity to take a stop the bleed training as well as all of our nurses so that's happened this year um and then every classroom has a emergency first aid so that's um something that we've been focusing a lot on this
337year and in the proposed bud budget going forward you'll see it's reflected um we are going to getting hopefully uh five additional AED devices um from my understanding those di devices hopefully will be donated to us um but it will be managed and maintained under the nursing services and I just say that because it's not just about having the de devices but making sure that we have someone that's checking on them we check on all of our devices we now have um I think we have 22 in total throughout the district with the five it be 27 that are maintained in uh by the nursing services so we just make sure that the batteries are operational obviously the pads the expiration dates and the devices are all set um we I'm anticipating that we're going
338to be changing the batteries in at least 20 of our devices this year and I'm just telling you that because it's again a reflecting on the budget and it's a pretty costly it ends up being um you know it might be close to $10,000 just to get the batteries changed on the devices uh which usually it's 7 to 10 years for the change it just happens that it's going to be next year that many of them will have to be um changed and again with the with the devices it's more just you know there's this this idea of a three minute response time um for any AED preparedness plan where you want to make sure that you have access to an AED and can um you know get it hooked up within three minutes of
339a cardiac emergency uh in addition the state has mandated a minimum of 15 professional development hours over two years for School nurses um you may aware from past budget conversations that professional development has always been an emphasis of mine um and just in terms of reinforcing expanding and responding to changing Health needs um this year alone that we've been able to meet with a Pediatric Cardiologist who was awesome um we've also met with the epileptologist from Yale and our medical adviser Dr kenific Who's just a wealth of information especially about Community Health um specific to darianne um we have school nurses attending an upcoming Mental Health First a certification that is being facilitated by the Daran Health Department um so that's coming up and um we have five of our nurses have received national board
340certifications within the last year um for school nurse certifications uh given the budget constraints going forward um we are losing one full-time nurse position um you know it is what it is I'm not happy about it but I I can tell you it will be at middle sex so middle sex will now um the next calendar year we'll only have two nurses but you know I've worked closely with um Shirley and Marge and Dr adley and we do feel you know rest assured knowing the students coming up into middle sex um you know that the student health and and safety will be maintained at the highest level you can all take great pride in the school of nurses uh the School nurses that we have in darianne I think they do a great job in
341providing a healthy learning environment and I'm happy to take any questions I would certainly agree on that thank you very much Emily thank you and I appreciate your leadership of the department okay questions for Emily Sarah hi Emily nice to see you hi Sarah though I understand you're not happy about the loss of the nurse at middle school but is that mainly because of that you know you chose that department or that level because is that I AP 5504 base you know why what's the rational the middle school no absolutely it's a great question I have a um a sheet of all of our students are required skilled nursing throughout the entire district and those are just students that um in addition to Everyday needs that they might have um a nursing skill that might
342take some additional time um and so based on what I know of all the fifth graders entering into sixth graders and all the eighth graders entering into the high school um I do feel confident with the school nurses that we have there um that they will be able to handle it with two um and then you know as Dr adley has promised um should things change in the future should we have um the health needs that you know we could see shifting things around a little bit but I think anticipating what I know now for next year I do feel like we could safely you know run the run the nursing program at the middle sex with two nurses thanks I appreciate that public reminder thank Greg and then Robin Emily mentioned that uh the
343nurses are doing some professional development around mental health just respect to the the request for a one pager it would just be interested to see the that included and make sure that we understand like comprehensively exactly if there's any overlap or how we think about that going forward sure do do you want me to respond to that or you're just in general just just a general make sure that we include that sort of stuff we've asked Emily for a one-page sort of um summary of the our investment in mental health so we can understand from a Snapchat point of view um what our efforts to bolster Mental Health in the district look like um it's because they're spread throughout um the budget book it's hard to see it comprehensively so um if you have a
344quick answer to um but I think we sure sure on a page exactly and I think that I can provide that I I will tell you that we have um this year been working really closely with Alicia dad because the nursing is is one part of our response to mental health but I think a lot of times um you know they may be quick to identify a student who's struggling and we've built our um relationships with depending on the school but the counselor on department and so on so we actually have a plan of if we're concerned about a student what we do um to make sure that that student gets um care but the mental health that I just brought up was it's um offered by the town so we have um the town
345Health Department it's a mental health um certification first aid certification so that's what they'll be doing um in a two weeks and it's four of our nurses will be getting that certification thank you uh somebody was over here Robin um just I had a question about the aeds um so you said we have 22 currently we will get be getting 27 um do we have aeds placed at each of our fields to the extent that we might have Cardiac Arrest issu exactly yeah so we have five um that were placed at the high school this year and those are under the athletic department and again it's just more like they're the ones that are managing it but there's five on the field spread across and then of the five that are coming next year two
346of them will be at middle sex for the fields thank you and then the other three additional ones are going to be for the upstairs of all the elementary schools so we have them spread out and what we're doing is and we call them AED cabinets but every one of our cabinets is going to have um Narcan they all do um in one spot they all look exactly the same so it's Narcan and AED and then moving forward we're going to get tourniquet and quick clot and so it's going to be an emergency cabin cabinet as opposed to just an AED cabinet and they're going to look the same across the the district so we can um you know everyone will know how to best respond and access the medical should we need it which
347hopefully we never will and then just to follow up then that so the total of 22 are the remainder of the existing aeds I mean typically how many is that per building or other than the fields where are those right so right now um of our five elementary three of them have one so all the three that have won are getting an additional one the other two already have two at the middle sex there's four indoors and at the high school don't quote me but um that's the remainder in addition to the central office and Fitch okay thank you Katie thank you I just wanted to take a quick second to um just applaud your um attention to the mental health of our students as well recognizing that mental health does impact physical health and
348that both of those components are necessary for students to access their education um and it's great to hear that you're partnering with the town as well for resources so thank you for the work you do um I think our nurses are often the first line of defense for students who are feeling anxiety and school avoidance and and might not even know you know themselves and be able to articulate that so thank you uh the board will see receive um a gift donation for the aeds from the booster club for the middle school so you'll see that coming through the meeting wonderful thank you thank you to them any other questions on nurses okay um members of the fellow government officials members of the public and no one online em thank you for your time we
349appreciate for your enthusiasm for your care for our lunch okay all right tuad hi Greg good afternoon how are you hello GRE thank you hi Dr adley Miss mccamon members of the board Administration I appreciate you having me having me here today and um I appreciate your continued support uh for our programs so um our budget um actually let me talk about the program first our program is doing quite well we've had increased numbers in our programming at the high school over the past three years um our budget and and even with those increases in our numbers um our budget line items this year are able to remain flat and still maintain the quality program that we have um and I owe some of those efficiencies to my my teachers that are there the bulk
350of our um budget really comes from uh consumable supplies in terms of raw materials for like wood and metal um and glue and glue sticks of those things but a lot of our teachers at the middle school and high school have found of more efficient ways um to provide these materials to students where students really think about how they're utilizing them and being more efficient with usage of material so um uh that's been quite helpful we also have a new course next year in cyber security um because of the increase in interest for students um for the computer science program um and and we're doing quite well so um again back to the um the line item the the bulk of the line item for our general teaching supplies um 44,7 is for Technology and
351Engineering for six to 12 30,000 of that remains for Robotics and I'll have Tim um follow up up with that if you have any questions um jumping around to um the classroom reference that is going to be the same this year we're continuing using the color accounting program for our accounting classes and we have um a pro profs Online subscription to support our safety test in um The Woodworking courses and our our um periodicals we're doing an online subscriptions to sports business weekly for that 425 for our Sports Marketing program and um um the professional development line item will remain the same from last year and that supports um about two teachers to go to International conferences as well as um bringing in guest speakers professional learning it also provides professional training for our AP
352courses and it will provide training for our cyber security course um coming up as well um we do not need any new equipment um for next year we've been maintaining the equipment that we have um with the $3,500 in repairs and um things are looking in good shape and we're excited for the year to come I'd be happy to answer any questions you may have hey board questions Robin um and general teaching supplies um The Narrative says that it's 30,000 but the the budget shows 74,000 so what which of those is the correct number so it it's it's combined with a robotics teaching Supply so 30,000 of the um 74 there goes towards robotics program in and for the technology engineering uh middle and high school it's 44270 okay and then do the uh Darian
353High School engineering courses currently also teach robotics as part of the curriculum there is one course that incorporates robotics into the program as well as other courses like let's say the independent project and engineering course if CH if students choose to pursue a path of Robotics they utilize that as well so there is some overlap thank you oh one just one more question what is the stem outreach program so the stem outreach program is something that um we've been doing for uh as long as I've been in District about 10 years where we have high school students and right now we're combining with um Technology and Engineering students and the science National Honor Society students we have two honor societies um kind of teaming up and going down to elementary schools and we do it
354one time in the fall and one time in the spring and we have high school students running stem activities with the elementary kids that fit within their curriculum um for instance I think the fifth graders coming up this spring they're doing um some oil spills so they're learning about oil spills within their curriculum and then we have the high school kids coming down and doing activity where they're pouring actually oil into water and Trays at their desk and they have to design ways to um get the oil out of the water and um assimilate that to what might happen in an actual oil spell in the ocean thank you um Sarah hi Greg first of all thanks for a tie on Saturday that's impressive I'm just not necessarily about this year's budget um just this
355seems to be a department that's growing and the interest of the students is growing and you know just nationally internationally this this group of ideas is is becoming more you know more popular and more welln do you anticipate in the future like any major expenses or equipment or you I'm just kind of looking forward to see this is because you've you've kept this RC pretty flat over the years and just curious if you anticipate that going forward or not yeah I've been talking um with Dr adley and administration about um potentially growing the program and I I don't know if it it's still in the budget I kind of missed that part in terms of looking at the high school um building itself in the space and doing a study on the space of the
356building still in there so um hopefully in the future if we look at the space we could hopefully build programming within our department because the only thing that we're kind of missing is that family consumer science portion so if we incorporate that that would that would utilize some equipment down the road um to hopefully offset that in the future um I wasn't going to mention this but I'll bring it up I am applying for a Perkins Grant which is a federally funded grant that supports Career and Technical education um they don't support consumables which is the bulk of our budget but they do support equipment so hopefully I'll be able to use that budget um for some new equipment if we ever get to build and increase our programming all right cool thanks yeah we're
357we're excited about potentially just looking ahead we bet um opportunities extend in the stam program okay got something to be excited about even if not today um any other questions in this RC okay um fellow government officials members of the public no one online okay thank you all thank you so much all right take care Craig Tim you get to hang with us I do I'm happy to do so rc15 hooray I don't see him on and I just wanted noted that we're on time might be the only time we actually hit the officially three minutes we're three minutes early yeah Mr Adams isn't online yet oh dear want to take a three minute break take minute break let's take to give him a chance I'm ready can throw their lunch plates away so I'll
358just take it's okay 52 we're starting again so okay motion to recess 52 we're starting again Dave seconded by Dennis all in favor yes all right three Lun away yes sir e e e I I got some before Amy Sarah and Cass got the same memo this morning I'm wearing his post pajamas there you go I have M hoodie but not that okay all right we're ready do you need that n cut Amy because I can put that in um motion to reconvene that is John seconded by Joanna all those in favor that is unanimous and with that we'll turn it over to Jeff and Tim for technology hi Jeff he good afternoon uh I'm sorry about that um I was just in my office didn't realize you guys are moving fast so yeah um
359um our budget should be quick um I'm like you said I'm Jeff Adams I'm here with Tim McGuire we're here to present the budget for rc15 technology uh the net increase for the rc15 budget is a minimal 1.42% as minimal as we can get this includes a reduction or rather deferral of new and replacement computer equipment resulting in a decrease of 16% in the computer equipment budget line the software line shows an increase of 12.47% 6% of which is the typical yearly increase in subscriptions and support contracts the other 6% is the cost for a website redesign the addition of the board docs management system to the website and the expansion of eduplanet our curriculum management system um finally the soft uh sorry the staff development line is increased by 45% and this includes Aspen
360training for all of our Administration and faculty including on-site training for schedulers at both the high school in the middle school and that is it in a nutshell and can open up the questions okay um Dennis I davein so Aspen uh training we we heard a lot about Middle School scheduling in the past year and $99,000 is going to I don't want to say fix the problems but it's going to resolve our problems and as well as part of the communications committee was was work on on Aspen and and looking at how to how to use that resource better and I'm just struggling with with $99,000 is going to be enough to accomplish all we need to do with the program the majority of that 9,000 is the on-site training for the schedulers the training
361that's provided is is actually included mostly included in our current subscription we're just supplementing it with a couple thousand dollars more of specific webinars and on toone remote training and that's the cost it came out to okay Dave um so I just got a new follow-up to Dennis if I may and then I had software and Hardware question um in terms of um Aspen are there thirdparty service providers who like help with the front end or help with other stuff or do we think there's sufficient in the training videos and other resources so my understanding with as is part of the difficulty like it's robust in the back end but the front end is really not user friendly correct are there front-end developers or something could help solve that have we looked into that as
362potential resource and we we actually uh two two things I can uh bring up one is that Aspen has developed a brand new interface for parents um we did have a little Committee of parents a little focus group um what we're going to do is open up this new interface to the parents that were at the focus group and have them critique it okay um is there additional cost for that or that's just the upgrade program that's all included cool thank you thank you very much appreciate and then I guess Tim um I'll go next to you for software looking at you know the annual 6% some of these may not be negotiables some of them maybe are don't know what we're looking in terms of consolidation and trying to like use less or get
363more from less or look at potential other vendors who can swap out of lower price points right um definitely the idea of efficiencies and at this point where um uh the softwares there's a few softwares that we already have that we're reducing Bas on usage so I'm thinking off top my mind it's a Book Creator is one where we've rolled back the cost in that just uh because it was underutilized by some staff so there's a little bit of savings there um near pod is another one similarly underutilized by some staff so we're going to find some additional savings there um and Smart Notebook comes to mind as well um I believe this year before the budget season I had something like 24 total different new software requests of which 16 I think I I
364shared forward to Dr adley so there's a lot of things we didn't adopt as well um and and trying to some software programs have also um been sunsetted that we're leaning more on others so for example I a program that a lot of Staff like to use was called flip that's no longer available to us so I've been redirecting staff to use some of the other resources we have such as specifically padlet and uh formative or go formative as it's listed in there awesome thank you um the one line item that always sticks up to me as zoom and why we're not just teaming with our Microsoft but I'll leave that for now and then another question just looking ahead a little bit I know this isn't for 2026 but um as we've moved to
365a uh lead devices in the locker mode we're moving to look at the high school what we're going to do in terms of usage there and I see the wiress access points if we've seen a decrease in infrastructure usage are we relying Less on Tech and developing switches or networking throughout now that people aren't bringing in devices into the classroom the way they were previously uh no actually we've seen an increase in traffic excuse me in traffic and you're right the number the number of devices has actually uh leveled out for the past couple years but the usage uh has gone up and that's probably due to the multimedia yes uh aspect of all the websites of all these programs that we utilize they're just more robust now and they use more traffic so okay
366got it thank you very much Dennis Sarah's next Sarah thank you somebody's looking over there just a little clarification about board dos um other people besides the people sitting at this table be able to benefit from that or not like what is what is the purpose of that absolutely yeah it's a it's the document management system for boards such as this and it it manages the documents in such a way that they're uh very nicely coordinated and searchable so everything going back uh will be easily access and you can go back and and search and find things from years and years ago okay awesome open to the public to okay so it's I was just in the spirit of trying to find dollars it was just for us I would say we don't need it
367but sounds like it we do okay when you implement that does the Dollar include any sort of migration of historical data or is it just picking up from that point uh that's there's probably not any migration cost in there it's going to be up to our department to get the data in there okay what so what are you guys thinking what I'm sorry what are you thinking because there's a lot of I mean we only have since 16 or 17 on the website but we have a lot of data online are we just going to leave that as its own repository and then no no we'll move over as we're GNA move it all okay yeah okay Robin um just a couple questions first um technique the RTI direct $55,000 renewal for software what is
368that for RTI direct Tim you want to answer that well I was gonna say I think RTI direct I believe is the software tool we use for um that's it's it's it's like the staff uh goals with the you the provider that the same provider provides Teo I'm trying to remember where that breaks down on top of my head but Jeff do you remember if that's tle or um no no it's it's RTI direct RTI direct so technique covers um RTI studio tle and some other of the data dashboard work that we've been working on it's that that same organization covers all of those things so it's like an administrative tool you're saying yes and as mentioned Temple I should clarify is where the teachers um and administrators we all put our annual goals in
369um and observational data okay okay the RTI Studio piece would be to support our work with mtss and really thinking about how students move through tiered instruction um and you know our data warehouse okay thank you and then um with the Edy Planet license EXP mention is that the 10,600 increase also going to then allow the teachers to access the curriculum that's in educ planet yes importantly that will allow access for not only curriculum writers but for all curriculum implementers which include not only general education teachers but also our special education teachers as well preschool through grade 12 um and it will also include our aim to make more transparent all of our curricular work on for public facing documents but but the public would not be able to have access to edgit planet with
370this increase of licenses correct or would they no they they the public has access but we're we have more work to do in that area so part of um the educ planet expansion includes some professional learning in the area of not only upd but udl design so that's a piece of the increase so public has access but right now we don't have anything in it that they would want be able to see really no there's there is currently access in Ed of planet right now that's public facing we're expanding it okay all right thank you yeah it's on the it's on the thanks Shirley it's on the website in teaching and learning um right I think we saw an example but it wasn't really fully kind of fleshed out and that's really why I was
371asking right so as we have more staff have access instead of just a very very small number of curriculum writers will be able to exponentially increase that okay thank you so this is oh go ahead Joanna um what is um sorry student employment oh um so the yeah I can answer that uh at the high school the seniors participate in a project in which they work with um other companies in the in the town other agencies sometimes the internship at the end of the year it's the internship at the end of the year and so one of the things that happened to us last year was the previous event they basically closed shop so uh myself and uh the two leads at the high school at run the program uh identified an alternate software product
372which they've been on boarding this year to help the seniors complete that requirement thank you and then um I noticed that uh Alp and Darian summer school use Web Solutions to pay their tuition everybody else for all can we everybody else uses my school boxs now is there a way to integrate those or they're really different and they have to stay separate it's not a huge savings but it's um they do have to stay separate so part of the reason we use web solution is the catalog that's available for parents to pick for their various summer school classes thank you uh Dennis Then Greg so uh we're deferring computer equipment in this is kind of making me think of the the discussion we had earlier I don't know if you guys were here about about
373uniforms and replacement cycles and so so I feel like we're we're saving money this year but we're going to have to pay it next year and we're and it's just I'm not a big fan of robbing Peter to pay Paul but um I understand we're in a difficult budget but is this something that we if we feel we can live with the computers we have today can we revisit our replacement cycle or is it just a one oneoff year for us we we can stretch the replacement cycle out just a little bit we've already done it with the high school display systems we went from three years to four years so I think we can we can revisit this a after this budget cycle and try to just stretch it a little bit okay thank
374you so I I think related to that I know you're next Greg um and then Katie but just related to that on this question of the the cycle um are we looking at did we in preparation for this budget look at where we feel like oh we deployed you know what devices at this rate but they're not actually being used at that rate um so we could you know whether or not it was certain types of laptops or um admin lap or the desktops that admins use um did we take a look at whether or not we really needed to replace at the device level yeah I mean we we we don't do a per a per user analysis of what they're using it's it's a general use um we we did go through and
375do a solid count so not only did we have a virtual count we did a physical count make sure that the numbers that are in the budget are what what what are out there there's no extras no spares in here so what is out there is being used okay um so but to what extent I okay say okay I jumped in there Greg and then Kitty I had a similar question just around like broader strategy around devices and the Chromebooks and this and that sort of stuff where I know preo we didn't have those you know is are we going to continue to just keep replacing those that's one question and then the second question is um there's a big line item for Technology support can you just remind me what that is which it's
376like $900,000 uh that's the technology staff so it's the network it's like the network engineer uh the health desk coordinator the technicians uh schools that's our internal support okay I didn't realize that was an exter so the first question Greg do you want Amy and Allen to answer that in terms of what's or do you want that to be a future answer like what's what's our you know as we look at the use of paper versus we don't have a plan well the plan is to continue this replacement cycle at the at the fifth grade level and to keep keep that process in place so we don't have an alternative plan at this particular point but it does recognize it does that is something of a shrinking then of what we were providing prior to
377fifth grade because we were we were providing oneto ones for every student uh prek through fifth grade in covid and then we've been pulling back a little bit so what what's our current status in terms of what we're providing it's we it's really no different it's the same yeah it's the same yeah yes it's the same yep and you are right actually Greg I appreciate you noting that for boards and people who have gone before um we were well served during Co because we were ready with the equipment that we already had in stock in addition to all the work that tech people did and so on so forth um but but the model we have now and know we transition to one to one to high call uh that's that model we we're not
378looking to change that model at least at this point so we're one to one ELP through no eighth grade one to one's it's K3 yeah oh I'm sorry and then kids take it home in Middle School they're allowed to take it home in fifth grade although not all do U some do some don't but sixth grade and up is much more standard to take the device home okay okay Katie um I wanted to go back to the computers as well and I recognize that Alan this might be a question more for you um I understand we're deferring the admin laptops but and I know that we talked about this last year as well what I still don't understand is why there is need for both a laptop and a desktop at the high school for
379administrators yeah is that just high school well for the ministrators who have have the laptops Prim um there's many times they we go to meetings that are no laptops make sense I don't understand desktops I don't understand both okay well for the ones who have it as an accessibility uh it's just an accessibility tool we don't have a could be for some people we could change some of that I don't see that don't say that's out of the realm of possibility uh for that it just seems that like to just talk about Administration just is that you're talking about well in general I'm I'm talking about broadly professionals people like that we that we use a device right and I think that we have become a very Global very mobile population where most people that
380I know do work on a laptop right we have people who have hybrid work situations and they have a laptop so that they have that Mobility with that one device now perhaps someone has as you say an accessibility need and and they have a monitor at a stationary desk right that's larger and gives more accessibility I'm just questioning why we would need two devices to perform one function most of administration is migrating that way yeah so that is the plan to eliminate a dual device correct right yep I have mine an all for the disclosure Robin um I'm question about Chromebooks um do we find that the um the ongoing needs and the ongoing increased use of online resources Etc and more heavy media resources at the middle school level are Chromebooks meeting that need
381adequately for students to be able to do the online work that they need to do and I'm where I'm going with this is at some point would it make sense for the middle school for us to to migrate more to a bring your own device kind of a thing like we do at the high school um because in my experience Chromebooks in the past are constantly breaking down they don't necessarily have the ability to actually do the work that some of the more advanced middle school students are are being asked to do it loses work so it's really kind of a longer term question because I think that there also could be cost savings there and given the repairs and the obsolesence that we see it's just a question think that's related to Greg's question
382no yeah and I mean the follow another follow to that is have we are there companies Google is making the Chromebooks Microsoft has its own device have we gone to those companies and said we are paying you a lot for the software we'd like you to provide the the the devices in order to be able to use the software I've seen them do that well they'll just fund the devices going forward and I can eliminate a huge cost from our budget so two shortterm answer to that uh number one uh we have done an analysis in the fall um we are making the Chromebooks uh much faster much leaner to handle lot of the programs um and the second piece is that we do have a hardware person on staff now who is turning around
383any issues if there is a hardware break he's turning it around in literally minutes or hours instead of days so uh those two short-term pieces are out there okay um but yeah the long-term question is is out there yeah this is it's a bigger conversation but um I know Jeff and I have also been looking at the the newer versions of the Chromebooks are more capable as well and the the cost is not significantly different so it's something um he'll help me process at this point in time we would have to have a bigger conversation about um going to a BYOD environment but that's not favored uh in my mind I think in most districts okay thank you Joanna I just if we just took the phones away from kids in the building um and
384it's successful because they can't use their phone on their MacBook they only have the Chromebook if kids start bringing their own you know devices to school and middle school then we lose those administrative I there are tools that I know some private schools use that limits what kids can do on their laptop but I it's a whole other longer term question I just wanted to I think developmentally at that age there's a whole question involved whether it's middle I mean the age they are the age they are their age and from from issues with even managing what we have provided them uh it just sort of it's a harder thing to actually okay but I think the the underlying issue that you're suggesting BYOD because there's some reliability issues with the Chromebooks I think that's
385really the underlying question that you're asking so there I think it sounds like you as you said you've made two changes streamline the Chromebook so they can hander handle more of a load and we have a faster turnaround time in terms of our own internal it support but that's something to continue to monitor I think because we certainly do our our students to be able to do their work and we do hear concerns about it from time to time so um not really a budget question but it sounds like I think there are some tech questions like how does how does our Tech strategy relate to our personal device strategy um that will come up as part of the high school what is the efficacy of our of our um the devices that we're using
386how many devices do we allocate per person whether we're talking about Administration or we're talking about the high school teachers and I do understand the history of why we made that choice but I do think there's some bigger picture questions that we've been asking asking that we probably need to talk about um not necessarily in the budget cycle but um as long as you're telling us what you have in place will keep the kids working at a better Cadence um n sure um sorry so the Aspen um PD is only 9,000 what's the other 20,000 20,000 is mostly for my staff for any kind of technical uh development any kind of conferences we go to so and then the um Consulting line not the one that Greg brought up the other one um as Personnel
387what is the yeah Consulting Services Consulting Serv that is mostly our wide area network management um that's a 247 monitoring system plus their Consultants into our wide area they just continuously monitor to to make sure we're up and running great yeah Katie thank you um similarly to how you were categorizing the conversation about um the integration between our our priorities and our devices um I wanted to flag the typing club for a future discussion as well recognizing that Emy this might be more of a curriculum component um and I and it's you know it's $5,000 in the budget um which um I have received some parent complaints about um that this is this is existing in the school but that it's not robust enough to teach students actually like performative typing um and it reminds
388me similarly of the curs of writing curriculum how it's kind of introduced but not really enforced um so I just like to flag that as something for us to come back to in terms of what our um kind of philosophy is can I add on to that I'd also like to discuss as kids um we moving more towards the science of reading and that's leveled text and it's also on a screen so you're having kids read on a screen so I just wanted to see if there one way you can go back and see if that's necessary but I thought it was not yeah so there there's three different questions I hear in what you're saying um the two of you one is um about whether or not we've scrubbed our current set of technology
389for where we are in terms of what we want what ties to what curriculum and so it would be helpful to understand just to review that one more time before the 14th please um a second piece is um I think it's probably time for an update of scope and sequence of kids um and devices and that's probably tied to the library curriculum because that's where we had housed it last um making sure that there is there was digital literacy there was typing so I think we would love to understand where we are in that Universe um I would just add to that specific to the um literacy pilot as well yes not just library but yeah yes okay I think there was a third component but I've lost it so if it'll come back to
390me or not um okay in terms of um software the other my other question Tim Andor Jeff is um we have some software that is instructional um where we might have variability in a an instructor's desire to use it how does that work from a licensing perspective do we then license it out only do we require it or do we license it only for teachers who actually want to actively use it the the vendors sometimes have the voice on this so some vendors they delineate the licensing by number of students you're serving or the or it's school-based it's this set amount per school but some products offer licensing based on a number of teacher users so hence that's why I was able to mention before like we're able to save a bit of money on
391near pod and also um Book Creator because those are ones where we can kind of narrow it down to the staff that actually want to be using those particular tools okay so so just if I could where we have any sort of control over the number of licenses we do actively work to manage the number of licenses we issue yes and you know something like Book Creator previously was whole District it was to be honest it was easier just to buy it for the whole District but as a cost savings we're now bringing it down and so I'm the one that goes in and and assigns a licenses to the staff that actually want to use it with their students okay well thank you for doing it Dave so just a question on the uh
392Elementary level Chromebooks that go home with kids I know some parents put in time limits and things like that on their personal devices at home um not sure that those exist with all elementary devices is there any possible way we can make it so the kids can't sit and watch YouTube all night on their school issue devices um just asking for a friend yeah I second the motion um yeah there's idea that uh Jeff and I will will be U teasing and testing out in in I would say in the coming months or two um additionally I mean I I don't know how best answer this other than I was also there as a parent and I bought the router that let me on my home Wi-Fi network decide you know what was on when
393and and not and so I know not everybody not every parent has that technical level of comfort but that that was an approach that worked for me in my household thank you thank you Robin um just on especially at the K through three level and I'm seeing all of these now resources for elementary AIDS school kids who you know with software for instruction and my question really as we are trying to move away from so much screen time especially at younger ages do we also have our literary our literary resources provided offline without requiring the use of screens for instance the learning a toz Res Kids as was mentioned or you know there are so many of these now that I think are migrating to younger and younger ages and I'm really concerned just about
394I hopefully our elementary kids can actually not have to look at screens the entire day to get the instruction and I'm I see the software industry constantly basically increasing this and as a district from medical s standpoint too and like the amount of brain development and the the screen time impact on eyes and everything I just I want to talk about that because I think we might want to scale back to some extent at least at younger ages I I uh yeah I know this is outside the budget uh conversation I would say to you I know in the conversations I've had with step Elementary level they're very sensitive to screen time um and I can't uh speak directly to each teacher's usage of some of these tools but I also want to mention there
395is some assist of tech benefit for tools like learning a toz where you can uh customize a reading level on the Fly for certain particular students if that's what they need um so I understand there are benefits but I also think that there can be overuse of this and ideally we also have the classroom book libraries and physical you know reading and um instruction which doesn't require a Smartboard or a computer I think so that's where I'm going with if we could get Sarah and Amy to pick that up in curriculum and talk about um our our policy is the wrong word but our approach to um using a blend of appropriate media um in curriculum because it's different at different levels um and certainly um it is an important topic and something that I
396think parents and the board should be aware of just because then you got to turn around and monitor it in your own home and and p through three Literacy for instance with the new resource is that going to be provided offline as well as online I was sure how that worked either I think part of that can be folded into that library media specialist conversation of how you know media in general and how that how we're short that agreed that and also the K3 literacy update I think this is an example where we would want to crosswalk kind of both of those um topics but I was going to point to um the requested investment in classroom libraries especially at the younger levels um you know you can assess children different differently as they're growing
397as readers when they have an actual text in their hand versus online so there are other benefits too instructionally and making sure that we're keeping those books in the hands of children right thank you well and I like I Jeff and Tim said here sh here uh we we've limited there were certainly uh other requests from staff number of requests from staff for new software uh given the challenges that we're facing that we have limited that to the three initiatives that we've been talking about um things that were in there like like schoy Ai and different other softw package but we've completely limited that um this year so I think there's probably a universe of possibilities in terms of things that we could get but the only is there anything that concerns you that we've
398limited like AI for me personally U speaking as a superintendent I would I would have the toughest one to let go for me a little bit was this school AI because it get give a little bit of an environment controlled environment for teachers to explore and use this uh tool that's just me maybe Tim would have something else Tim that was the though that was a big one for me there's several different AI tools that are out there that are really good staff are piloting them um a few staff are buying some subscriptions on their own but School AI was a great one and what's the cost of that I think it was around 25 significant yeah so I'm not proposing to put it back in I'm just saying that there's another area where we
399prii prioritize okay any other questions in technology all right uh fellow elected officials pardon me oh I was calling for um members of the public fellow or means you're off the hook Jeff well not yet not yet um members of the public and no one online okay you're off the hook for the time being thank you Jeff thank you Tim thank you very much thank you Tim for staying on of course right Early Learning Program good afternoon everyone I'm Laura ston and thank you for allowing me to present the Early Learning programs budget um El just as a reminder is an integrated preschool program for children ages three through five in which children with learning differences in children with typically developing skills learn from each other in a nurturing environment this play based and project-based
400learning provides opportunities for children to be purposeful creative inquisitive flexible and reflective during the 2425 school year ELP offered both a four and five-day program as a transition to a full imp implementation of the 5-day program for the 2526 school year the five-day program has allowed uh our program to participate in art and physical education and continue our work with music the teachers have really enjoyed all of those experiences along with the children maintaining a 5-day program has provided an inclusive program for students with and without learning differences that previously was limited for 4day program just kind of an update applications have been accepted 46 families applied to the Early Learning Program and all have been accepted to the program they are in process now of letting us know if they're going to be attending
401for next school year um General teaching supplies account 20 no 02 4011 uh we are requesting the same level of support as last year $10,000 textbooks and consumables account 22003 we're also proposing um and requesting um the same level of support as last year [Music] $9,750 uh professional development account 25 003 uh we're requesting a budget of $10,000 same as last year to continue our work with Cooperative educational services around the upcoming changes to the Early Childhood outcomes the Eco is required data collection from the state of Connecticut that looks at Children's um progress from the beginning of entry into the program with an IEP and exiting from the program with an IEP they're moving to CT dots as their measure uh moving forward also we'd like to continue the support um with the are
402our development of CT saids and stairs Bas writing goals uh to be compliant with the new legislation and regarding the best practices in early childhood education um requirements and play based learning EOP tuition is for the 5-day program at 11,845 Laura can you can you I don't know if you're we we your internet is uh breaking up but specifically your speech I can you oh do anything on your side there or speak up or which parts didn't you hear we heard okay but if just going forward if you could uh be louder close your video maybe and that might help okay yay um all right so uh I'll just talk louder too that's better than so um in general um we're requesting the same level um as last year um just to highlight the uh
403five-day program um for the Early Learning Program is at$ 11,850 $45 uh which is a 3% increase over last year um but again um the program is just five days and um we' like to continue with the same level support from last year you know we have found some um uh help with again not help but um being all together has really been helpful for materials and and Staffing support so we appreciate being at one location so thank you okay questions for EOP Joan um are you losing any students or families um that were using the 4 day and now don't want to go to the five day um we're I don't think so no okay they're applying now aren't they or they're finding out now yes so everyone who has been in ELP um
404this school year is automatically accepted um there may be a few families who have different thoughts on preschool for next school year which is a different private World um not um a community in Daran so um that's still shaking out but um as a whole um everyone seems to be going to the 5 day okay Katie thank you um technically my question is coming from the multi-year tab but I want to ask it now since you're on Laura um I see that in um in your RC for fiscal year 26 there is a 3% increase in tuition but the multi-year tab lists a 4% increase in tuition annually can you just speak to that difference I have R chance that I'll speak to it so typically we do do 4% we did make it 3%
405this year you do have some families who are paying that lower rate as a 4 day a week um so we left it at three this year slightly less because they would be having a larger increase than normally because of the switch from four to five Robin um I just wanted to talk about the enrollment because the ELP enrollment has increased 44 students since 2020 and I just would love to have some kind of explanation about what is causing it to increase at that level and what is driving the increased referrals into the program um if you could just give us some information about that well I would just remind like everybody in 2020 people didn't really want to come to school and because of all those restrictions um so as the years have gone
406families are more comfortable sending their children back to the community also children um were born in 2020 um who are now a part of our program uh their early life has marked uh been very different than children born before them um so we're just seeing across the board uh children who have different needs um may be identified through an IP or just maybe typically developing friends um who just need a little extra something um but uh as families move into town um you know there is a rise in autism um that we are seeing um and so that also is reflected um over the years uh so those are the kinds of things that we're seeing in Trends um we're you know okay thank you I'm sorry about my mistake about covid I forg that's
407okay yeah but what what is the current Baseline for the program it's around 100 Kids isn't it um yeah so we're trending at a 100 currently um well as of Monday we'll have 95 students um you know we seem to be increasing um but I'm expecting to end by 100 105 Maybe So currently class sizes are 10 and 11 so they're still manageable um and you know so we're we're trending okay um but higher thank you Joan oh sorry I forgot you this time I I'm literally sit in front of you um it's lonely over here I'm new over here it's you know you got to look right um I asked this every year can we get a comparison of the different preschools tuition for next year um please um Rich has it yeah thank
408you okay I'll go now yes thank you um the specials teachers uh because this besides this is the first year you've had anything besides music right in ELP correct um so are they where are they coming from are they Ox based or they itinerant we having so many issues with teachers being able to actually meet all you know the art especially we've heard from other teachers um that there aren't enough of them essentially to give the amount of time that the Ford policy was set in the past that they wanted them to have so I'm just wondering how ELP fits into that puzzle sure um the oxridge uh art teacher is working with us for many of the classes and then also the token art teacher is coming over for I think three classes out
409of the eight um so um we've been assisting and supporting the teacher with um some prepping of materials um for her uh but it it seems to be working out um there's not a lot of travel except for that one teacher the art teacher music um we have two music teachers um one is coming from the middle school and one I think ZX Ridge and another school um the schedules have been working out again like I think looking to perhaps having ELP on a 8-day rotation will help some of the Elementary staff and ELP for scheduling for those um sub subjects or or you know specials margin Amy can you address whether or not there's an impact on the elementary schools um so I understand that change has been difficult this year for the itinerant
410art and music teachers and we will do everything we can to smooth out the schedule for next year but I assure you that there is plenty of time in the art and music schedules so that they should have plenty of time for their prep plenty of travel time we'll make it better next year but I just think that change was hard this year and you know it's different to be itinerant thank you Katie thank you can um earlier we had um Joanna had asked um and you had flagged about coming back to music and having a more formal update on that and I I just wanted to take this opportunity to say that it would be great to do that with art and with ELP as well you know hearing Laura say that ELP staff
411is helping with um preparation of materials makes me very concerned for our K through five teachers across five buildings well I think also um just kind of talking a little bit about that we have little guys and there's a lot of modifications and we do have that help um so that it's not overwhelming for all teachers so um and in like PE there's no real prep we'll say um for the for for attending that class so okay so in terms of followup we're going to include ELP in the update on music and art in that more formal update um thank you all right thank you did I see another hand Sarah do you have your hand up I do not you all right um okay uh fellow government officials members of the public okay thank
412you very much Lara thank thank you sorry about the internet rc24 thank you um and good afternoon everyone in the community uh thank you again to the board members also and the daring Community um for all of your support for for our students for our faculty our related service providers our par Educators um and the cess Administration um for ongoing support I know that we recently did a State of the State um and presented to the board in the community so I'll be briefer than usual um in just moving forward I did want to start an I'm on rc24 for the Personnel budget line and the one um change that we're asking for is to have a board certified uh bcba I just want to distinguish for the board and for the community the difference
413between a bcba and a bcab um a bcba is um a master's level certification that allows practitioners to work independently they've earned a bachelor's degree um and a master's degree or sometimes a doctoral degree in Behavior Analysis as well as education and psychology that distinguishes they also have um certification as a bcaba and they've passed pass the bcba exam the distinction between that and a bcaba and there's a small a in the ABA just to distinguish that is that's an assistant so BC Ava does not require the same level of experience um they may just have an undergraduate level certification to become a bcaba they do have to sit for the bcaba um exam but they require supervision by a bcba um they can't work independently um and they have earned either bachelor's degree or
414in Behavior Analysis or it may be a related field and the reason we're asking for bcba and you can see in our contracted Services is that many of our students especially on the elementary level um require um S Services from a bcba in terms of behavior regulation in terms of also supporting and implementing Behavior plans and doing fbas as well the other piece about bcbas is that um they since they don't require supervision um we're able to have them um spending more of their time actually supporting students in the classroom and supporting our colleagues in the classroom for implementing those programs currently as you've seen in our contracted Services there's a strong line for bcbas this would reduce the number and terms of the expenditures for contract of bcbas and by um eliminating the bcaba
415that we currently have on the elementary level um will'll be able to a Delta that would be reasonable and fiscally responsible the other piece to note is in the conversion from bcaba is that and um the reason you say why are we doing on Elementary not on secondary because that would be a question that one would Bode and the reason is that bcba services are much more indicated with our youngest Learners that's when they're developing those skills they learning regulation we find that the bcaba services are more related to our secondary program very often they're out in the community they're working with families in terms of generalization and they're not doing as much direct supervision um and implementation um with older students I'll go on to the occupational therapist um as you um great generously
416supported five new OTS this year we have one in elementary school we continue to have contracted services for occupational therapist on the secondary level we have one that's shared between middle school and the high school and we also have one that's contracted for um OT services at oxridge so we have two OTS at oxridge one is a Daran employee and one is contracted and for ELP this year we continued with a contract at OT um unfortunately again for stability of services that person um resigned early on in the Year everyone put all hands on decks to help on till we finally have replaced that and we know for continuity of services we're requesting that the board consider an OT Darian employe for ELP commencing for next year for esy and summer ppts and we're looking
417at a count 21308 uh the biggest difference in the increase of that budget has to do with the number of school days at the end there are eight days next year depending on when school ends there may be five days there may be six days um and the cost of perday services is what we're looking at that warrants that increase and there'll be eight days um for this year for consultant Services uh the the biggest difference in the consultant Services you can see there is a decrease even though there's been an increase in some of their um again because of the addition of a bcba that would offset some of those expenses and some of the other services that we have that will be increased including some translations for evaluators some um Consultants from um
418for bcbas and rbts will be reduced as well uh that we continue to be able to offer that at a decreased of for the account for contracted speech um which continues and we spoke earlier during our presentation we have not been able to successfully fill the oral motor and um feeding and swallowing expertise we have been able to bring into district one of our other um special language Pathologists uh but we haven't successful we continue again to work with a consultant for that we do not anticipate being able to fill that at this time we'll continue to look um throughout the school year for contracted for contracted OT again I just spoke to Hell we'll be doing that for ELP and be able to service that within our continue our same services pupil evaluations for
419pupil evaluations um again the budget increas is based on the cost of those um also there is an increase typically during spring months and later on in the school year again those are neurosc evaluations oral feeding evaluations bilingual evaluations some environmental evaluations as well when we work with contracted bcbas uh and those will continue to be warranted outside including our neuros evaluations for out of District transportation uh you can see that the budget is is uh remains that includes um specialized in transportation is predominantly done with inside the district the decreases that we've been able to now contract um we have all of our Suburbans as well as our wheelchair busing provisions and the funding um remains of the budget for 74 the proposed budget was is $20,000 there are still some transportation services outside
420of the district for tuition Public Schools budget um we're looking at an increase in that budget because we have a number of students for next year that will require transition programs outside um for 25 26 for the non-public tuition also we can see that the cost has gone up we spoke about that at our presentation as well um for the 2526 year for unilateral placements as well as IEP placements we explain that a great deal of that is based on the cost of those placements and those increases in programs and the coh of students are different students from previous years dues in membership the one area we're looking for is the ability to supervise our own psychologists and interns towards lure here we're asking for dues and memberships for two of our psychologists uh in
421order to supervise on the upcoming psychologist who might be able to qualify for that lure and Nexus cost is in the budget that shows where we are we're um entitlement cap of 70% We Believe for this year and we're pres projecting that threshold of $122,000 okay thank you Charlie I'll open into board questions Katie thank you um um I wanted to um well first since you were just talking about it um on du memberships and that two license do you have an idea what um like what buildings do you have those identified specific to the intern we have students that two the supervising will be Dr Scott McCarthy who's on the screen as well as Dr Alicia Dad okay so it's going so they'll be supervising across all seven buildings okay thank you or eight
422buildings actually because great and then I just wanted to flag um this comes up a lot especially um at the finance subcommittee but I I wanted to just discuss the the accounts for tuition recognizing that we are looking at budgeting um for fiscal year 26 over $9 million um in tuition and I would um this came up during the um annual review as well but I I want to again ask for an identification of cohorts of size um that we might be able to begin discussion on developing in-house programs for um like we talked about earlier today with fit like we've heard um about the benefits of a cohort of idea you know and and we're looking at 237 students and a cost of $400,000 to serve them how might we look at cohorts of
423students with language-based learning um challenges for example you know there are programs like um the Southport school has the collab new Kanan has their Learning Academy um I would just like to flag again for us that this is a significant cost this is not you know a a a small piece of our budget it's a growing one and that um I I think that it makes sense for us to look at our student populations and how we might be able to serve them inh house and and we're in agreement Katie I do want to and I know we mentioned this in our presentation at the State of the State many of those out of District placements that are um are described as Agreements are because we're not able to place students in non-state approved programs
424some of them are residential programs that we wouldn't be able to replicate and again not diminishing what we can look at in terms of day programs and other outside but many of them and many of the high cost programs are programs we couldn't replicate sure and I and I do definitely understand that um acknowledging that a lot of um you know like residential type programs are for very specific very high needs which again I would come back to um my stipulation of cohorts of size right where where can we identify a significant number of children with similar needs that we might actually be able to serve here yeah I think go ahead I think that's a parking lot question it is and and and we've already begun to look at that we were looking based
425on um as we said classifications and looking at grade level also to see when it's coming in third and fourth and fifth and we are working on that great so that'll be sometime we'll mark that as the parking lot transition is another example of a cohort um so looking at special Leed through that and we're in agreement yeah okay great um I think it's probably not we can't control it for this budget but the other thing I would like to understand um is what the actual growth intuition looks like by type so you know we have kind of our day placement schools that are dealing with a specific learning disability or combination of specific learning disabilities you have a more theraputic setting you might have something for very high needs more medically based I'd like
426to understand how the tuition has GR own whatever whatever breakdown of types of schools to keep you know an appropriately private but so that we can understand how tuition is changing um because we know that our numbers of outplacement are relatively stable it would be helpful to see what's happening in the industry in terms of the actual tuition rates um so again that's not really a budget question but I think being able to answer that sooner than later would be helpful and we can do that at the same time when we're looking at programs and we could do it by therapeutic day programs we can do it by residential programs as well um I think I think that I think probably for the purposes of being able to explain the budgetary drivers it's probably more
427important from a timely perspective because then when we go and turn around and talk to our fellow government bodies it's helpful to explain the growth in this category um so I think that one's a little bit more timely I think we do need to know the answer to the cohort question and start to have that discussion but I'd like to have this one before um soon before we go to our we can do that easily thank because we've looked at it over the course of the years um and we I can tell you that residential programs have have been very significantly increased y um as well as some dat programs so we could break it down without names and do that great John are you adding yeah well I guess cost tuition prices are going
428up yes like for like services so kind of a breakdown in some way and I hate again talking about kids as units but units versus price increase if I think price versus quantity um so that would be a question and then just to to back up and just maybe review can you explain in a few bullet points what it takes to have an out place to to to a child to be outplaced and and and how and there's unilateral uh out placements because that's a question I often get and I just want to make sure I'm giving the right answer so there there's two answers to that one is for uh in order for an IEP placement in order for a PPT to recommend an IEP placement out of District we've exhausted everything in District
429to address that child's needs and the notion is we're not able to do that and it might be behavioral it might be um it might be physical and it may be different reasons why but it means that the PPT and the um all of the providers have exhausted all the remedies we can do within a school district that's an IP placement a unilateral parental placement um it's actually three things a unilateral placement for a parent is a parent may not um agree um with the provision of services we have and they're in disagreement um and at some point they've made the decision to place their child in a different program that would be your second um coort and there is a third actually um which I was speaking to earlier on use a residential program
430as an example it's not a state approved program and everything's been exhausted for that student however in agreement the district and the family will will make an agreement to place that child there because we cannot place the child there only the parent can it's not state approved so as as because it is required but because many of them are not state approved uh we cannot place as a PPT but we would work in concert with the family to try to help support that just one quick follow up on the unilateral parent category then is there a negotiation in terms of how the tuition is paid or help us understand that so there is there is either is done by it can be done by mediation and there's a mediator that comes in from the state
431and it's done between the family and the district it's one way it also can be just done between the family and the district without mediation thank you Sarah thank you um looking at 213 304 the exended a homebound I see that to dat it's only been 70 to 763 do you really think we're going to get to 275 it it it seems to increase in the spring and as that time goes on it we might be a little bit not at that end but typically historically year after year do we get to that point okay okay go ahead can um the intern program um for some reason I still don't understand exactly how this is work I me understand how it's working but how many interns do we currently have that we're using uh that
432we're working with the Consortium so we have two interns and again I know you asked last time Joanna they don't replace our psychologists that's not the intention and then is it the do you know how much we pay for intern or do we pay their tuition or is it same we pay we pay the intern themselves in this case unlike the interns we talked about in the elementary school we pay the interns themselves um so uh one is 30 and one is uh 25,000 okay and then um sorry oh you said you want to hire two new interns is that in addition would we have four or do these interns leave after a year and now we need to they're new interns and I will since Dr McCarthy's on the screen um and he's actively
433invol actively supports that program and has been one of the initiators with Alicia dad um they want to add some color to that sure yep so the uh School Psych programs require a one-year 2,000 hour internship so the two interns who are with us this year will complete their internships in June and we will take on two new interns starting July 1 um the change in the the cost is part of our Consortium application process to to apa and APA requested that our um internship stiens reflect the average APA internship in Connecticut which is 34,000 Robin um just one question do we have the the state approved data now that has has it been released yet for 2425 about the educational classifications we don't have any of that yet and I will follow up in
434a memorandum to the um to the superintendent to share that as soon as we have it okay thank you Katie thank you um Scott question for you when you mentioned the APA um we're going through them versus um the accrediting bodies of school psychologists this is for for psychologists in general not specific to school psychologists uh so School psychologists um can be both members of the National Association of school psychologists and the American Psychological Association for division 16 um the doctoral internship in school psychology through the apic process is the most competitive and most respected process um and that's through the APA and then that 34,000 is that for a 12-month position or for a 10 month school year a 12-month position so would it be prated for the 10 months of school uh they
435work for us or esy okay so they they will be doing a 12-month internship as well okay thank you correct yes yep Dennis this is a rich question but um going back to the going back trying to trying to understand the transportation and in-house transportation is it all on this in this RC or just some existing Finance with the the the bus monitor assistant and if so can we get a one pager on on the history of the savings we will have over years in Trans in bringing transportation in house sure so it's actually in three RC's it's in this RC rc20 and then rc25 uh so rc25 is like the cost of the fuel uh the cost of the insurance of the vehicles Etc maintenance maintenance tires so if we could kind of bring
436that into one piece so we can kind of track that over the ne the next few years to make sure we're achieving the savings we assumed we would thank you Robin um I have a question on this is in the object detail it has to do with special education it was the other instructional supplies that's on page 293 so we have an increase of $76,000 but it's like a $480,000 budget and just it's been increasing over the years and it would just be interest I I'd just like to know kind of what is in I think the other usually this is more of administrative kinds of expenses but it seems that it might be different for rc24 what's included in this can you just repeat the number page number 293 and it's object 250 293
437293 in the binder Rich you want to take a Bo it does include professional Library Collections and computer software so that might be part of the reason this is higher but I just was curious what that included if we don't see it now you can follow up but we'll get a follow up I can follow up I I can just speak to some of the um again I'd have to go through line by line but I can go through some of the instructional materials uh a great deal of the expenses are for AAC devices also there's a lot of AAC devices that we use um for students AAC is a system communication uh so the drivers primarily for the special education pupil services so it's anything with an object 025 and as as you've seen
438pupil Services has gone from about 159,000 to close to 400 and pupil Services is pupil evaluation oh for the pupil evaluation is that in this line item correct oh so it's a roll up of corre several line okay thank you I'll still tell you what AAC is if you want to know good um they're really working with specific devices um a sometimes we have students who require a device that has eye gazing systems I thought we're looking at technology so we have some unique um systems that we use for technology and those are AAC devices okay thank you but Rich answered the question better than I because it was a different line item thank you Joanna um so you would like to move the ELP over um is there reason why you didn't do that
439last year when we started doing the process and then also with the other contracted one would you I mean next year do you think we'll move it as to move it over again so we get away from all contracted we we considered it for the ELP at that point we thought we could do it um it didn't require a full-time position we thought so we could do some contracted Services given the number of students we have now it really does require a full-time position and then continuity the the contracted SLP uh I sorry the SLP you want that to bring in house that you can't find um are we still looking for someone for that actively okay and and our hope is we'll get there um as I said um last time we had spoken
440they're very competitive they have private um practices and it's very hard to get someone to switch over we've tried we've actually tried recruiting some of our contracted people but we're not giving up our hope is to get there okay other questions in this category I just have one more question sure um so in the uh special class teachers line um 803 um you have 63 teachers um but there's no change in the staff line and so in the object detail I saw it's because you currently already employ 63 teachers is that why um is there any way that we could capture that information so we do see how many specialized teachers we're adding over the years um just to kind of keep track it doesn't feel like you're not adding any um because I they're
441they're brought in by IEP right whenever that IEP might start it doesn't necessarily start with the calendar year the school year we can certainly do that thank you follow yeah follow up on that I'm just curious how that's spread across the school so like approximately how many are secondary how many are Elementary I I'll break it down by that I'll break it down elementary middle school and high school if I can add to that I would just say um I think that that would be really helpful especially as we're talking about these kind of snapshot documents um you know you had mentioned in here um that we had an increase of 86 students from in the 23 to 24 year and you know an additional seven and I think that that's really helpful to just
442see like that broad comparison and and how our program is growing how our populations are we hear a lot right about everything increasing but to quantify it um would be great so thank you sh um so I think to that end let's track it against enrollment I understand special ed enrollment is that what you're actually serving is variable but just as a as to give us a sense of movement please and and the referral rates that um you said we coming you just I'm assuming you just haven't worked them out yet yes thank you okay okay so I know just to summarize what the board has asked for we've asked for um analysis of the tuition rate growth um for the parking lot we have a cohort analysis that'll come up sometime later in the
443year we've asked for the a summary of the transportation work so we could track that over time and then we've just asked for a followup on special education Staffing how it distributes across schools against enrollment and join I think you just asked for some forecast on that yeah projected and projected um ident what did you just say I had asked earlier uh before the refal and we're we're working on the referral rate um and they were looking at referral rate and we have um our building level administrators looking at that I think it was also you asked about parent referral versus School referrals and they're working on that as well right how manys turn into okay thank you okay we'll look as part of that discussion I mean this is a significant and understandably so
444uh to some degree uh budget and item we have over a 100 part of professionals who support our children and that U not only is there creating not only is there a possibility for creating cohorts to address in some way but also how we addressing M9 um there may be a different way of actually doing that but it's it's just a growing continuing uh conundrum hopefully opportunity and opportunity always um okay um fellow elected officials members of the public Crystal Hill cdsp chair um this question coming from our special ed Community um in regards to the change in bcba has there been any like real analysis done on the behavioral analys analysis consult hours kind of outlined in current IEPs or where they're projected for next year um just to determine what the actual needs
445are uh we've heard some concerns from the special ed community that we don't really have currently have Staffing capacity to support what actual needs exist in our student population and concerns that that Trend may continue into next budget year and then I'll just reinforce I know this came up around the board table again the trend in continued um increase in costs in out placements and again I think Mr C brought this up just is that D what is what percent of that is driven by tuition versus actual increase in numbers of out placements and then I we hear from parents all the time who have to outplay that it's not what they want to do so I certainly think any movement that we could see towards a large cohort of selic students or students with
446certain behavioral um trends that are causing them to be outplaced that they would I mean those students would love to be placed back in Daran schools if if the um programming existed thank you anyone online one okay um user CPAC Trisha you've been recognized and unmuted hi um so um I'm Trisha bresnahan and um 11 glenvale Avenue and I'm speaking for CPAC and um we see the line for the par professionals and we're wondering if there are enough to meet IEP requirements there are a lot of absences historically with par professionals as you were talking about earlier about um the instructional ones and um while it's hard to know when someone's going to be sick we also know this happens year after year and so it seems like there should be a plan in place
447for that it's extremely disruptive at the younger ages and um in addition even at the high school they've had to cancel Unified sports practices because of it um so it would be good if there was um something put into place and um on that um in uh past we've it's been brought up many times during the budget season regarding a database for Miss services and um it has been decided not to use it and the uh service providers are in charge of their keeping their own um Miss services and we're just wondering how that's been going if there's a report on if that works if parents have been notified and um how if there's something that tells us how many Miss Services there have been and if they're being made up in a way that
448is um helpful for the student and still keeping within their IEP because sometimes it's hard if they have to be pulled from something else to make up a service um and does this include the special education teachers which I think it does but um you don't always hear from them if they miss something um and then also for the PD line we see that it's up 33% it would be nice to know what PD is happening one thing that um CPAC has brought up many times and we know that the caught um the inclusion consultant that was doing PD for Co talk classes at middle school and high school was um hurt and so at a commission and we're wondering if there's been um any progress on finding someone new to do some um professional
449development um because obviously there's new trends there's new anyway people start to leave and I know there were people trained but sometimes after the trickle down you're not going to get so much um information and also we see that the transition program is not in the budget and um but there are still students that need to transition and we're wondering if um what kind of PD is going to be put into that the transition process should start in middle school and into high school and um teams who are working with these kids don't always know all the postsecondary options they're not educated on them they haven't been they the the guidance counselors the uh the case managers and not everybody even knows about them and they're weighing in on decisions on what these kids should
450do so it would be nice to see if we could get some PD um until maybe some transition uh something went into practice thank you thank you no further use okay so there's a couple of questions from what I heard that what any we could ask for the um the assumptions and the capacity work that was done for the behavioral consult to to underlying that decision I think it'd be helpful to see that um I think it would be helpful to understand what PD is planned um and I think the question of um if there's it's not really a budget question but is there any given that we're not putting a program in place but are there other things we're doing for transition uh would be helpful to answer please anything else yes thank you
451I I would like to piggy back on that I think that um you know coming back to when this first came up to us um and sort of the scope of what the steering committee was going to do um you know there was there was one specific program for a specific cohort and then there's also that broader development of the capacity of our staff and and really of a department that would serve all students especially all students with with you know any kind of need that maybe going to college might be doing anything differently postsecondary and I I do feel that um the focus became a bit narrow into one program and I would hate for us to miss this this broader very large cohort of students that could benefit so I I would like
452to also Echo support that we think about that as we're planning our professional development for the capacity of um of really expanding our understanding of options postsecondary may I just respond to that also Katie um just to mention that Kathy AER and the school counselors over DHS have it's been one of their PD goals uh this year but we'll certainly elaborate on that I'm sure she go as well but just to know that it's not going unnoticed that they are certainly doing that Allison Longfellow actually um has been Herculean and helping um during our steering committee as well and I shared that with her colleagues in the high school as well one of the school counselors so please know that um and if there are questions if I can just take one moment just on
453behalf of Laura and scy and myself and Katie you've thanked teachers and other members of the board have but I just want to take this opportunity I know we mentioned it at our last presentation that there's a shortage of special education teachers there's a shortage of school psychologist there's a shortage of other related service providers and we fortunately are fully committed here um and I think it's because of the extraordinary efforts of our staff also just think of substitution we actually have a teacher who's come back to cover a medical leave who's retired special education teacher in one of our elementary schools and I just want on behalf of Laura Scott and myself again just thank everyone and to recognize all their extraordinary commitment to all of our students and families here um in the
454cess department so I just want to thank them on our behalf thank you we as a board echoed that okay we actually 20 minutes ahead of schedule know look at that that board um uh do you want to a break or keep going all right keep going curriculum Amy you're up good afterno everyone um again to Echo gratitude for the um Board of Education and our community for the strong support of having a superior and excellent um educational system and the values that are that are really clearly portrayed inside the walls of our schools and Beyond um it's an exciting place to work and be um I also want to thank um the administration and staff who work day in and day out with all of our Learners our students in all populations general education
455and special education because as Shirley and I often talk about they're all all our kids um I'm really happy that I've heard a lot of public comments speak to educational excellence and um I'm I know that we're ahead of schedule and maybe that means I'll have a few extra minutes to talk about curriculum and instruction because um in my mind the teaching and learning is really why we're here and it's important to keep that Focus um you'll recall that last year in the budget process we did some significant work to systematize and bring some I think greater coherence to um curriculum instruction assessment and professional learning um through the rc19 budget one of those things that our curriculum team are instructional supervisors department sharers online they're all jumping in now they're all populating it's like
456The Brady Bunch uh view thank you guys for being here um something that they worked really hard on was creating a curriculum writing um in revision cycle and part of that is because we worked really um diligently together on this to think about how do we make connections across departments horizontally and then of course vertically across the school system um and how do we make connections within the work that we do across all areas something else we've been focusing on is ensuring that we have special Educators at the table when we're writing curriculum and something that I noticed um quickly upon my arrival last year was the limited access to the curriculum that our community not only um our public stakeholders had but internally so that's definitely been a focus area of our work I
457want to thank the board for prompting our work not only to Center on the tenants of ubd understanding by Design but also Universal Design for Learning that's some significant learning for our team of Administrators and teachers and something that we're eager to to participate in um with our colleagues in the scss department broadly I think that you'll hear a lot through the comments today and and certainly hopefully we'll engage in Rich dialogue around the curricular work we've done in the area um connected to ELP and kindergarten for play based learning while that's legislated and some of our work is legislated um it's also work we believe very strongly in so we're grateful for that opportunity you'll hear about from ELP all the way to new courses um that have been requested Ed across various departments
458you've already heard of some of these through other board meetings and the expansion the continued expansion of the World Language Department um within courses there so I'll just um go through the budget because I'm sure there'll be some active dialogue as we um as we move through this process so the Personnel um accounts there is not any recommended change so I'll jump to the curriculum development piece um I want to note that there is not an increase in this um line item but I think again it's a more articulated plan uh if you look at page 220 in the budget detail in the narrative um we've tried to break out our curriculum projects at both the elementary middle and high school level we're also trying to reference what the public can expect as far as
459stage one which would again be those um public facing documents they're kind of the big picture of each of the department areas and courses um for what students should uh be able to know and and You' be able to do at the end of an experience in a course or grade level um we've also noted ongoing curriculum revision if I can go back for one quick second to the stage one on page 220 there's a note about at the elementary level Library K5 curriculum there were some earlier remarks about um screen time and digital citizenship and typing and one of the things that I did also notice last year and with Mr Maguire is that there is work that needs to be done at the first initial stage one level at the elementary school so
460the board can expect that um again our work will continue in that area we've also requested some funds within this budget to continue that work um at the approval of the FY 26 budget that will be a focus area at the elementary level for the year ahead um there's also um some work here that's outlined in the curriculum area for prek-5 art um Miss Thompson before was talking about the opportunities for curriculum to connect the Departments across music um in art visual performing arts and thinking about how we're recognizing opportunities to challenge our students who who have gifts and talents um in areas Beyond Humanities and step so that is some other exciting work um as you know this budget um also includes um some nods to our work in the area of mtss there's
461been some earlier board discussion in multi-tiered systems of support that's certainly a Continuum of services that connects the general Leed work of our department to our special education colleague and something that we're looking to make more systemic um and also to ensure that we're providing the needs to challenge all Learners appropriately those that are performing um not only you know toward grade level standards and at but also Beyond so that's something that um Julie droller and Mrs Klein and I will continue to want to talk about additionally with regards to curriculum projects Beyond ongoing work um it is noted that there is curriculum work proposed for those new courses which we're grateful that the board has approved they were mentioned earlier um exciting that there's work in astronomy and cyber security so again highlighting those
462stem areas and also American sign language which has been a very popular um course for students um at the high school consultant Services again to just go high level quickly through this there is a decrease in this account um and that's really because we're bringing that work of um some professional learning focus into the district so the work on play-based learning is something that um I've been supporting with Julie droller and and Laura straiton um we've got a very eager team of prek and K teachers um we're leading the work in professional learning there and curriculum design and development together with that group we've also brought the work inhouse for pek which is um really the committee that supports our professional learning and growth and support plan for all of us staff teachers Educators leaders
463all of us together um I did within that $21,000 request a very small amount of money um for some consulting services for health and PE um I believe that that is an area where we need some expertise to support curriculum development and also to ensure appropriate um support of the staff that works in that department to ensure that they're able to grow also professionally is is critically important in the work of teaching and learning for their area dues and memberships there is also a increase in that line because we were able to find some efficiencies part of that was the work that um the department chairs and I engaged in together with the building Administration to make sure that there wasn't we found like for example some um times where things might have been repeated
464because again we have a complicated budget and building administrators are advocating for certainties and memberships um and we we were able to streamline that very nicely this past year local travel Remains the Same L resources um Works hand inand with our title three Grant so there is no increase there and you can see that um our population of ml students gradually does increase naturally throughout the course of the year um and has increased year-over-year but we can still meet the needs of our Learners um right now we have one day dedicated ml staff member in District and we also have interventionists in District that are helping to support Learners that receive those Services the um sticker shock line um in this budget is uh the textbook line if you look at the overall um budget
465increase for rc19 um it looks like a very high number but if we take out for example this textbook line which is increasing at 158% um that overall number would certainly be a lot different and that number is relative to two primary driving um increases one is the grade eight resource for mathematics and I do see that Miss rier Miss R is on on the zoom as well thank you you you have any questions for her about that resource I'm sure she'll be happy to uh support me in answering those I want to be clear that that is not a new program and not a new resource it's simply um a reup of the current resource that we're using we do believe that it does meet the needs of our Learners and matches really nicely
466with the work that's happening in District in the area of building thinking classrooms some of our professional learning efforts um additionally um obviously a very large not not as large but a large driver is making sure that we're keeping current with our AP resources those courses need to be current in order to be approved for our students um and to be successful on the AP assessments that they take annually each spring we have some World Language texts I've have seen them with my own eyes that are in need of repair they're in in bad shape especially in the area of Latin so that's something that I would recommend um that we that we keep as a priority on this budget and then naturally the um the text as we move forward um with our K3
467our efforts in K3 literacy in the district and I I just want to extend another um shout out to the group of elementary teachers all elementary teachers that are working very diligently to grow in our understanding of the instruction for our young readers and writers and thinkers how our youngest Learners are developing their their most important skills um in the area of reading that will bring them Success Through the upper grades and Beyond um our staff as I think Miss lelin has mentioned earlier has spent a sign significant amount of time engaging in research and engaging in study practice and collaboration um they've approached the work with a very open mind um the feedback St feedback from our stakeholders thinking about addressing some areas which we've mentioned in earlier board presentations that we do recognize
468that we want to strengthen within our offering there were questions earlier and I know that we'll continue to talk about the professional learning in plc's one of the just I think overarching comments I would make with regard to professional learning and the difference is PLC is a type of professional learning but globally um professional learning at large is really to support kind of the more larger systemic initiatives that may be driven by the state for example K3 learning play based learning um K3 reading play based learning restorative practices and also those goals that we've identified as a board and administration with board goals in the Strategic plan um some of these are required things others are required and also things that we just know are very important and that our students and staff are deserving
469of um Additionally the professional learning side of things more broadly is to support teachers in their individual um needs and interest for areas of both that's I thought it was quote from here um so more broadly that's to address individual kind of teacher needs um when you we think about a PLC model the intent of that is to be teacher driven but it really is a more collaborative experience focusing on how our students are performing really looking at um s cycles of data uh thinking about that plan do monitor just looking at how students are for example moving through tiers and looking at specific examples of student work and then thinking about how staff will immediately as Dr edley mentioned before formatively assess the teaching and learning process and then react to it it's a
470different kind of study so that's just a quick comment on that um even with all of those changes and the 18 hours of required professional learning by the Connecticut State Department of Education which is quite simply um being outpaced by this the mandatory obligations we have um there really has not been a requested significant increase in the overall line as we know though we have discussed the overall request of early release time and PLC time there is some um other costs that have been associated with that but the PD cost and as far as the actual learning organization investing in our staff of teachers and Educators that's all encompassed already in these numbers and there is an outline of what some of those experiences would be for our staff uh on pages 20 226 227
471and 228 I want to note um that the department chairs really work very closely with the staff within their departments to prioritize um how we're keeping current with sending teachers out in the summer for training at Taft which is those um a summer institutes resource materials um this is um a line that H includes our headphone um replacement cycle also um to note is because Title One funds have been compressed there is um we've been able to keep the PD line very modest with like a $3,000 increase but losing those Title One funds does impact that part of our budget and I'm sure Mr rud could speak to that as well um it's also the resource materials that's another line that's primarily impacted by loss of Title One funds um standardized assessing we are not
472making any recommended changes um for standardized testing as we've typic implemented them in District um we were able to find some efficiencies there because of um some of those um assessments being administered standardized assessments being administered electronically um field trips there is a very modest increase I'm excited to note that luris ston and Julie Shir and I have been talking about um field trips for ELP our youngest Learners and that's significantly important when we think about play based learning helping them learn about navigating their community and will also be an opportunity to address some standard and other parts of the curriculum for example like science and social studies um I think those are my overall comments and again I want to leave time for the conversation I'm happy to respond to the many questions that
473I'm sure all okay so let's take general questions about curriculum and then take um questions about PLC as a group so let's start with curriculum generally Katie um Amy can you talk a little bit about the plan for um the other like language revisions I see in your you have your phase one and then you have your ongoing curriculum revisions and I'm curious um about you know with the change that we had made from last year's budget and the loss of a department chair the move um and and how are we seeing the the difference of languages and that kind of cohesion and moving forward oh still thank you for bringing that up um it is important to note that because of course when um there's dedicated staff like the staff looking at with content
474uh content expertise to support the work um there is a difference it's actually partially why I've recommended a very nominal cost for our um health and PE Department areas that I think need a little bit more support um we have been able to still make significant progress in the area of curriculum writing and um I do have Scott Webster online with us one of the things I'd like to encourage him to speak to is his efforts to work to make a really strong um articulation K through 12 with regards to the growth of the World Language department and spoiler alert um the board of education curriculum committee meeting next week on January 8th is going to provide an update within that department so I think you'll have a more full picture then but Scott can
475you speak to just some of the curriculum projects that you and our colleagues have been engaging in uh yes thank you um we've been doing a lot of work K12 this year which is relatively new for most people and we've been focusing on transition from fifth grade to sixth grade as well as 8th grade to nth grade and really working to tighten up the curriculum U vertical articulation discussions there and um we hope to do more of that work you know as the year uh progresses but there there there is a there is a lot to do there in terms of uh that discussion because it it's something that hasn't really happened that much in the past something I just would like to know is I think Scott you've talked with me about the eagerness
476of our world language Department to especially the elementary level to engage in curriculum writing exactly yeah we we already have a couple of projects in the works um and and some proposals for one project for the later the spring as well as another one in uh or two proposed for next year um for them to really focus in on uh writing can do statements which is something that act full which is our governing body for language education uh really supports and works with uh schools around the country to to focus on um as a means of giving direction to language education really kind of what are the the skills that that students who graduate can actually do in our four uh skill areas and languages I'm looking your way because I got some questions thank
477you um actually it's more one is a comment and the other's a question um just to sh to point out that the K3 literacy um 218 620 that's actually a placeholder currently because we have not yet approved a curriculum so that that is not necessarily to be spent but that is in there in case we decide to approve something just add one other thing Sarah to that point um we have and will'll again share on January 8th board of education curriculum committee the options of the cost that we projected out um regardless of the program that we we move with and the instruction mat will use there will be obviously some costs in the area of professional learning curriculum development Etc but we have that un marked out and that I believe will be shared
478in the next presentation as well perfect thanks Amy my second question is for um Ronnie so the 81,500 is for 5 years of the renewal of the our math resource do you feel like five years you know you still want to be using this in five years is there a you know a year to year like just said would have would love a little more color on that sure so to clarify um the Big Ideas program that we're suggesting to renew is for grades six seven and eight so it's for all three grades um that use that as a resource the for addressing the five years um yes I I feel very comfortable with it we're not doing textbooks we're doing online renewal which is what the majority of students all the students use at
479middle sex right now so that online renewal will get updated um regularly so I'm very comfortable renewing for 5 years it's significantly less than our renewal last time which was $190,000 because that included actual textbooks and the online access this year we're only requesting online access okay thank you for that clarification that's helpful um okay yeah I had a few questions you answer I think you just answered mine about Big Ideas so one question is do any students have a need for the textbooks or do we still have our old textbooks in case that is needed we have yes thank you for the question we have a significant amount of textbooks um within the school currently and I don't feel that um it's necessary to renew those for the small updates that they're going to
480have okay um and then I have questions on the curriculum writing one of the questions is for grades six through eight Flex what exactly what is the curriculum that is now being taught or written for the flex period because I don't think we've really discussed this since the genius hour proposal a couple years ago so that was a question I had too so um the flex period that is at the middle school is kind of um an advisory period And what I have noticed is there was not a curriculum established for that before and there it is I think anytime we're looking at instructional minutes of a child's school day we need to be really clear about how we're using those and what are the standards we're addressing and the desired um student learning outcome
481so that's the intent um I've been T discussing that with Mrs deolis and we'll be putting a team together to ensure that that is well articulated and to show coordination to other parts of the um Department work that these Department shairs are working on do do you have a sense of what you would like to have covered during that time because I I think in the past it was more of almost a free period And I wasn't sure what you would typically like to have that used for so I would definitely typically not like it to be used for that um when I'm thinking about the some of the performance-based tasks we're hearing our department chairs talk about as we develop curriculum when we think about Pro um Project based learning when we think about
482Service Learning other areas and attributes that are addressed within the vision of The Graduate one of the issues or I should say opportunities in the Strategic plan that we haven't quite addressed yet is thinking about how are we assessing vision of The Graduate it's really um for this year next and how are we develop in Opportunities where we can think about how we're documenting maybe in the way of a portfolio children's work in that area um we also have Student Success plans that are required by the state of Connecticut which we have not um developed as much as as we would like to at this point and that's work that should be happening I think during that time and Student Success plans is something that Kathy AER um and our school counselors will also be
483helping work with would there would there be any use of the flex for um helping them with organizational kind of you know as a middle schooler how to make themselves more effective with study skills organization Etc thank you for raising that so similar to kind of the what I need at the elementary level right and in addition we're focusing as a district more on the support of executive functioning skills including at ELP and kindergarten those more primary grades certainly I think not only when we think about students transitioning really at any point right um Elementary to middle middle to high high school and to college for those of us who have kids that transition those skills in the area of executive functioning are often make it or break break its skills so that's absolutely something
484that would be happening during that time and when we think about Student Success plans that is one area um that would be addressed in in a Student Success plan and student setting goals right monitoring achievement of goals those kinds of things um and then a followup question on the school climate and curriculum being revised at the elementary middle school I I thought that that curriculum was developed already or what is the revision what what is needing to be revised at this point so um some of the curriculum is not all um developed stages one two and three and also um available I would say on edge of planet and the detail that it needs to be so we will still be a district that is using strategies and resources such as ruler and I think
485um Dr dad I was going to say she's in not she's in her home office she's there on the zoom this is something that she and I are working on together um with also Dr McCarthy and this work will connect to the mtss modeling work we're doing thinking about supporting um behavioral regulation and Readiness for learning behaviors um I don't know Dr dad is there anything that you would like to um offer and add on to that uh no I think it's like you said looking at what we already have making sure that it's cohesive and also using that as the capacity to build in our internal leadership team around that curriculum as opposed to you know relying and outside resources for that that is um an outside resource um I think it was like
486a $7,000 line item in previous budgets and my I I believe that we have the capacity internally at this point to bring that yes okay and then just final question on interventionists um it's a $1.7 million budget which has increased like $500,000 over the last few years can you just expand on what has caused that increase sure so it's two things one is the loss of Title One funding uh so used to have an interventionist in title one and then we've had uh essentially inverse turnover where individuals who have left have been replaced with more expensive teachers can you repeat that last part so we've had what's called like inverse turnover uh teachers who have left have been replaced with more expensive teachers okay thank you hey Dennis and Greg and and on the interventionist
487can you remind me what what these 15 people do and and it seems like a catchall is an interventionist and where are they deployed so um we have interventionist in the narrative it talks about um how we have interventionists at the elementary level um and also at the middle school level primarily um they're primarily focusing their efforts in the areas of Reading Writing literacy um and Mathematics and these are individuals that also support our M our students who receive ml Services um they also provide opportunities for students to have reinforcement either pre-teaching or reinforcement after a lesson um to support what is happening in the core program so they are um really providing also a connection in the mtss modeling from tier one which is what happens in the FED end setting to tier two
488which is kind of that push in support in the classroom and then tier three where there might be a student that's pulled out to meet with an interventionist for more specific for example reading goals or mathematics goals and are these interventionists IEP driven or not thank you for asking I know you know the answer but I'm glad that you're prompting me that was an excellent teaching W Sarah so these are general education interventionists thank um again though supporting all of our Learners there I think we always want to be recognized the Continuum between general education specialist can I just ask a point of clarification about this yeah maybe there's something wrong with my brain but when I add up the Personnel that you've described here it's 14.5 but when you look at the spreadsheet it
489says 15.5 there is a uh English uh there it's multi language learner interventions that's where the that's also that's okay thank you um it was Greg I think next um yeah one followup to Robin's questions around the flex period I would be very careful about filling that time up I know a lot of at least in the middle school I know a lot of the students currently take that time and spend it to meet with their teachers because the only time they're able to meet with their teachers either very early before school or after school when I think know that a lot of these kids have time filled after school so they can't meet with their teachers I also understand that one of the five Flex periods as of now is a anal period where
490they sit in an auditorium and watch a video basically which I feel is kind of wasted time so I would just look into that as well um then I had a second just broader point it seems like there's a number of budget items where we sign up for something we get funding and then a year later we get less funding and then another year later we get no funding seems like there's a number of those that are flowing through here that are suddenly starting to hit us it would be very helpful to just figure out what those are and just be cognizant of what we're signing up for at the beginning where maybe we're signing up thinking this is no cost today but it's going to be a cost in the future and now we're
491seeing some constraints in our budget associated with that um are you asking for a specific snapshot of that um you know like for I know you were talking about the wellness coordinator team talk or two examples and we'll see those show up in mental health I think or at least some way of tracking that so we know they're coming we we did around mental health and a lot of these are Under mental health but but they fall out in other categories like for example we had a literacy interventionist who's now in our budget but who was in our a grant previously but that's not gerain to this budget so rich is there anyone outside of mental health that's currently funded by a grant we do have teachers and pars funded out of the ID gr
492okay that's not that I was just going to say Rich you could also talk about the loss of title one I think that's material to this conversation and and why we lost the title one okay uh so we did uh lose Title One funding this year it is based on um essentially the number of uh individuals not students but individuals within your community below the poverty threshold um and you typically have to be above what's the two 2% threshold we fell just below it this year so we did lose Title One and title four funding that title one funding did fund an interventionist uh this year which is why you see that larger increase in the interventionist line uh year-over-year it did also fund things like materials and professional development um that funding won't return
493for quite some time and that will only return if um you know the community becomes more impoverished for lack of a better word um you know in terms of there aren't a lot of personnel that have been funded in Grants over time uh we don't get a lot of grants in general um the one grant that really have that does fund uh staff is the Ida special education grant and that is a Federal grant as opposed to a state Grant um that's not likely to go away um the funding has been compressed over time um but it does fund special education teachers special education power professionals and a portion of that psychologist at token okay and I don't okay so there's three different components there's Title One there's some of the it was arpa funds
494basically and then there's idea so um I think we'll have mental health show up but if you want to just if you don't mind showing us um I think you showed Title One in the in the finance report but maybe the Ida um funding um and then um lost it the point I was going to make was the point I was going to make was similar to Richard as a district we try not to create these Cliffs yes that's right um uh yes we do have some in the Ida Grant but that's not untypical from any District uh but with regarding grants and stuff we a limited number of of positions in there and certainly we we've Tred to make it explicit what they are and we'll tell we'll make it more explicit but we
495try not to create these Cliffs for the board of the community to face yes by choice and that's why we put them in the new initiatives in in the as we prepared for this budget process yes and we should continue to do so yes I have a followup question just on the inter vention is is this the what used to be called srbi kind of Staffing to help with that and then um since they're all in rc19 what typically is the spread between schools of Elementary versus middle school or even high school and the reason I'm asking is because I anticipate that in the coming year with the K through three implementation of the right to read the new literacy effort um we might have more needs that the mentary level for the mtss support
496and it would just be helpful to understand how those 15 staff are being used or at what levels they're primarily um at the excuse me the elementary level and I see the Julie's here she she primarily supervises this group we have a math interventionist um at each Elementary School in each of um the buildings we have 1.5 actually per Elementary School and at the middle school we have um two interventions one who primarily services on the humanity side literacy side and the other primarily on the mathematics side um also again just to mention that those interventions also serve as students who receive ml Services thank you and one other thing that I will jump in and add is that they also support teachers um they they support new teachers they support teachers and implementing the
497curriculum and and establishing um tier one goals for their students as well well ktie thank you um Amy could you walk us through what is comprised of the $21,000 for the admin Retreat or if possible come back at a later time with you know maybe an itemized um it would just be great to understand what what that entails for sure and that includes um both our work in August um you know the beginning of the year and the end of the year all of the days that are included but I do have a breakdown of that this is back to an earlier question but can you guys just clean up the narrative this is you rich sorry can you guys just clean up the narrative on page 217 because the narrative on page 217 on
498the bottom where it describes the number of instructional Support Services was to to the question asked earlier yeah the math oh adding the teacher into the teacher yeah yeah thanks I just so we all have it for the record thank you Dave so I have a few questions um following up on Dennis's point of trying to get some trend lines and some aggregated analysis across different RC's um back in the ini initial pitch on Thursday we got from Dr Aly with the 10e operating budget history and the introduction of the budget that was great it was in tabular form someone I'm going to ask where it be nice to see with kind of maybe like a line graph with um the data provided underneath so the first one really goes to the curriculum writing projects
499that are mentioned on page 220 for example Elementary I see 16830 that's just for this particular stage one correct and then we have stage two below for curriculum development correct across um sixth grades and in many cases conclusive of elb okay so I get the question I'd like to see is back over 10 line 10 years we can do it what are we spending on curriculum development over the past 10 years as those trend lines you know like it was because this this is not aggregated data this is one particular piece can we roll everything that's going into curriculum development whether that be teacher time whether that be in uh this particular RC you know I'm not sure you know building staff EXA additionally but we really just to like get a snapshot of how
500much we're spending on curriculum development in general I'm going to ask the same thing regarding um professional development and I know earlier Amy you mentioned that some of these are initiatives that come from the board some of these are initiatives that come from the admin some of them that come from the state would love to see that same sort of linear you know layout of what we're doing in terms of what's going on in spend or time uh maybe it's the right model there just to see what that trend line has been over time with maybe pull out time from the classroom in there that would be very helpful yeah I really just want to get like arms around the entire spend for that and just as a tease that's going to come for PLC
501as well when we get to that well sry sorry what was that that add on our so Dave is asking for Trends and time and sorry and money over the years and I'm just saying like how much more teachers out of their classroom now than they were okay sorry thank you thank you yeah and then I guess the follow question for now on this topic really enrich this one's for you um for you know I see an rc19 I see curriculum I know we have uh you know we have the curriculum coordinators we have directors we have uh you know curriculum coordinate I mean if we look at all that's going on right now in sort of admin whether that be curriculum development whether that be staff whether that be building staff whether that be
502psychologists would love to get over the past 10 years probably three lines on a graph what's the enrollment how many teachers do we have account how many administrators do we have account probably you should also see those in dollars maybe it'd be great to do uh two other charts are logarithmic don't know don't give you too much work but just again seeing trend lines over where we are in admin growth and are where we are in teacher and student growth and then one last question uh just leave this presentation sorry get back there for the elll resources I see that's flat year-over-year but I noticed last year we had a pretty big jump from 71 to 85 I don't know what caused that my question is are you comfortable with this number that we have
503for last year and this year or do you anticipate another jump or is that going to be sufficient I anticipate right now that that number um should be sufficient the jump from last year had to do with supports that we provided um for our students who receive ml Services inclusive of their learning opportunity in the summer um which was really important uh I will note it is something that we continue to look at because the population and that's a tricky line because it's not just the number of students but if a student comes in and they're at for example Los links level one and that's like a their most novice language level they might need a different level of service so it's just something to really important to keep an eye on and I I
504do that most closely with Patricia thinos who's our one ml interventionist thank you and also you know part of that the general fund covers also those services and then we have title three funds that support all professional development and some student um facing services and resources back up a little bit I just wanted to check um for the I I agree with looking at curriculum and PD over time um I and I I agree with the three reports my question about the curriculum writing um this is the first year I've seen you all break it out quite like this so so it's interesting if I can just interrupt the the so I guess it would be FY 24 I believe this part of the narrative said like Elementary science English high school English it was
505very very broad last year was the first time that we approached it this way okay um getting even more specific with a breakdown by level and what stage of the curriculum development we working on so I'm asking the question because I want to understand how far you want to go back and at what level of specificity because I don't know if we what we've tracked over time yeah and again there may be limitations to the data and how we've tracked it and that that fine that would be what it is but you know to Dennis's Point like would love to just know in scope what is this and what's the trend been over the past we can go back four years great we go back 10 better but okay spand will be fine this level
506detail may be different just so yeah yeah this is AG this is disaggregated I want to aggregate it back want aggreg anyway okay okay kind just has a high level question is a lot of this curriculum writing exercise due to Edy planet and putting writing this in to put it all into that format part of it is that um I also just want to emphasize there is a really strong connection between this part of rc19 and the professional learning when staff is working on the development of curriculum it's not just putting documents into edge of planet that provides staff an opportunity to get to know really well their grade level standards to get to know changes within the standards and to really understand clearly um different parts of not only pedagogy how curriculum is um
507connected to instruction additionally it's really important for example for an elementary teacher to understand what are the grade level standards that come before them and after it gives us an opportunity to look for interdisciplinary connections and to support transitional work between for example elementary middle and middle to high so it's it's all of those things it's not just it's just not the doc the curriculum document thank you for cl Jo um I have a couple questions um in this list of uh the descriptive list sorry um there's a lot of Elementary literacy things in here and I'm just wondering does any of this change or maybe it's all this does any of this change if you if we don't go forward with more PLC dat or is just all independent of that all these program
508writing can I just ask for clarification when you say does any of this change what what part so like this is professional learning to support writing you know 3 days of school per embedded PS one District PD day how much of that is all built into the idea we they'll have some other time here so we can do that there and does any of it change right so um regardless of the resource that we select we will need the the curriculum the requested will hope for I should say the curriculum writing funds here because again it's not just adopting a program and putting you know insert a box press play um we really need to be able to understand really um the tenants of Science of reading which is work that the district has engaged
509in over the year and things that we need to actually be focusing increasingly more on um and with regard to the professional learning it is challenging to provide ongoing embedded professional learning when we're having the six days that are really primarily from August to February um so when we think about the additional request to time that would allow for time to bring teachers across the district especially for example we think of K3 literacy um and K3 reading to bring teachers together from across Ross the system and that's something I think if we listened to earlier Board of Ed curriculum committee meetings our teachers are definitely craving the opportunity to be talking across the system about how we're approaching the really important work of helping our youngest um readers grow and learn if I could just
510just U add to that a we bit there's nothing in there's nothing in the PLC uh proposal that won't that trigger something else if we don't do this we can't do this and we're not doing that's not the case Okay so and it wasn't like that does it help yes of course it does but it's not triggering well then we can't have this or we can't have that um and then um under literacy where you say um it's 32850 for the title one loss what does that look like like what does that actually relate to is that I want to just make sure that I'm getting this right probably as web so in the past it was teachers colge that's what it was used so that kind of goes also in the P it's in
511the PD so I'm sorry but you say it was the so in the past not this year but in the past it was Teachers College which we didn't budget for an fy2 thank you okay all right PLC questions R um my main question is looking at the overall costs that we have budgeted it's basically flat this year versus last year and you do have a significant amount of it looks like professional learning at the elementary level for literacy um support writing and various other things so the main question I have is that if we're budgeting the same level of dollars for professional development can we do all of that without adding the additional five early dismissal days and the additional three PLC days it would not be those additional needed why are the states needed
512or why are you proposing that if if it's basically a flat spend that's what I'm trying to understand well it's a flat spend here but it's actually a $100,000 cost in the transportation to reduce Food Service Revenue that's why I'm asking right so are you asking why we why we need the time I can you just I'm asking about the the proposed initiative which is being treated as a new initiative and what the need is for it if it's essentially a flat spend of professional used for PD the additional time can I frame something just first just um I I've already said just I just said that it it it's not dependent on this right in terms of so it's not like triggering something else that we can't do type scenario yes it does show
513up in on Transportation because that's where the additional cost is primarily located um I'll just say a couple of we things first this is if you're looking for something that has uniform support across the district from Administration superintendent teachers uh this this is this has uniform Support over over the district if you're looking for something that it's not always teachers and administrators agree on things right this is one of the they agree on there's not always if you're looking as a board as a way of supporting something this is something that I'm just say passionately this is something that can move the district forward can be in place for a long time serve all teachers and uh have a result on all uh students I will say we we did reduce from the last presentation
514that we did from over 200 220,000 or 19,000 um down to the the 96 so we reduce the number of days from the high school uh U late arrivals from 5 to 3 yes the 96 is the net of the cost for the transportation and a loss of breakfast personally like I know it's the budget and this will be bit flipping but comparing the cost of breakfast is in it uh for professional development is it's good to do because it's you need to make it up so we'll leave it there at the 96 this is also addressing recommendations that are in the nas accreditation report that we received uh to provide additional time for people it's also in a recommendation addresses and responsive to the recommendations on the Tri-State Consortium report that we had uh
515it to me it's like an umbrella of PD you have professional learning communities that's inh housee done by themselves and you've also all the other professional learning that goes on districtwide and everything else if you want to to look at it this way um why do we need it this is one of the things that will be very helpful to our teachers and ultimately we know what's what's the biggest difference of of student performance in a classroom is a teacher right if you improveing the teachers if you teach impr their profession and enhance their profession it's it's going to improve uh the student performance it also is a big retention and recruitment like people coming to our district one of the questions they do ask me what do we do for professional development in the
516district right this is if we've been looking for recruitment retention uh opportunities this is one of them yes it does provide five other early dismissals for all of the other work that we need to do um and it provides these three additional I'm not sending this is a reason for doing it right and it's tangental but it's a we minor uh nod to it we haven't done anything of late arrivals uh for for for high school students it can be put it touches on that but not that's not the reason for doing it I think I'm sorry that I wasn't maybe understanding your question originally Robin I think that the additional time will help us provide a more coordinated effort and focus so for example regardless of what happens with the PLC and you know
517professional learning proposal the work that we need to do in this line item in near K3 literacy still has to happen would it look very different if we had time to get teachers together consistently in a meaningful way across the district there's there's not much in this budget and I'll stop after this sentence there's not much in this budget for the the expense that has such The Leverage and and potential benefit in my opinion other appeal it's Dave so I guess I'm just trying to think about when we were working on the teacher uh the last budget go round and you know we we work to put in some funding for outside education and other development opportunities there uh as a retention tool um I think about the the work days that teachers have I
518think about the cuts we put in last year to teachers and are proposing in this year have we done any and I hate surveys because they're pretty weak but have we done anything with checking with teachers like do they want release time do they want PD do they want PLC like what are they have we gotten any data on what they Val given the short yes the answer is yes we have that data and through the PC committee we we survey teachers all right can we get that please shared out thank you just one question Alan on the PC survey um do you have just a highlevel kind of thing that you could share on this in particular since we're talking about the additional professional devel we do this verbally or I mean it's obviously
519a rep do make more sense just we can send it then let's just send it okay sorry rean just limited brain cells left um any other questions ktie thank you um so I I think actually today's conversation around PLC has has been Illuminating even though it's it's been a topic that's been floated uh without a lot of details for a while um and I think that part of what Robin's question earlier was Amy was about like kind of almost like why isn't there a cost to this right other than you know the transportation and the revenue you know like we're not paying for something and is my understanding correct that one of the differences between professional development that's focused on individual teacher training and you know maybe bringing people in to teach specific skills and
520a professional Learning Community PLC is really the opportunity for teachers to speak to each other and work on what is actually happening in their classrooms and their student performance is that correct where as opposed to bringing in a trainer it's more time for teachers to meet together so in my earlier remarks that's that's actually I think how I phrased it um the professional learning is more broadly for systemic is um opportunities that might be directed by the board Administration or the state they're more large big picture professional learning also helps support individual teacher goals plc's is a more collaborative opportunity it's when the group is looking at for example grade level standards or looking at student work samples and data and then collaboratively discussing those outcomes and then planning forward together to more address them
521in a formative way yeah so I think that's I think that's been really helpful to today's conversation is kind of understanding the difference of you know bringing in kind of like an outside training versus like time to to meet and do the work together my question for you is are there opportunities to provide that collaborative time for our teachers that don't result in the loss of student instructional time so one of my concerns about this initiative is that um we are we are reducing the number of minutes that students are in their classrooms right and Dr adley I fully agree with you that like it is the teachers that teach the kids and that is so important but the kids also have to be present in the class right so so there's like a one
522and two that go together and um you know Marge this um probably comes into your area as well in terms of contractual obligations about you know is it even an option to explore time for teachers to have dedicated professional developed days that aren't counting against students removing from the classroom contract negotiations are coming up you speak contract negotiations are coming up so I would flag that as an interesting thing for for us to consider as um as a district is what kind of opportunities might we be able to provide for there to be time for staff to accomplish these goals and to work collaboratively that do not result in a loss of instructional time that sounds like a real win-win to me I understand that there will be Financial components to that I absolutely do
523to me that sounds very very worth it um so I want to flag that um and then the second thing um is is anecdotal not just from my own perspective but what I hear broadly is I do want to to note that while having an early release day having a late start you know does not count against our 180 requirement I I see the you know um the appeal of that and it doesn't count against the contractual pieces however it's not just the minutes right it's also how things impact the day I think that we can all remember back to you know what were some of our favorite days in elementary school that half day before Christmas break and it was just a party so I I do think we need to think about how
524we might be diminishing the six hours that are remaining after a 2hour delay the half hour you know when especially at the high school it's a significant change in a block schedule right we have shortened classroom time you're missing certain things so I I want to make sure that in our conversations around this we're being real about the cost to the students a lot of the previous you know kind of philosophical things on professional development that's been put in front of the board I I absolutely recognize the value and I'm a big proponent of professional development however some of the metrics that were put in front of the board were about having none or having some and the fact is we have quite a bit in darianne so it's really like is the marginal cost
525worth it right like I think that's what we need to be looking at um not just in complete absence of it um so I would just say that as we continue this conversation I would appreciate us to really look at the nuance and um both like both sides of this so based on what you're asking we have a model at the elementary school and at the high school um so we could certainly get some real data on what happens on an elementary school conference day you know how that impacts the rest of the instructional day and we have the PLC already running so I think if we could have some sort of information back um ideally some level of data um does it impact student attendance does it um you know how does it impact
526the instru what we already have impact the instructional day at both levels um Joanna um it also seems like in this discussion that it's more at the elementary side that there's not a lot of time for plc's what is the cost if we just give the five early lease days um and to to that end if we did do that is there an opportunity for a revenue driver with an after school you know uh a partnership with G and after school or whatever it's called anymore um that kind of thing okay I'll just make a comment just about the uh contractual matter uh we are using the uh everything that's in the contract right now the number of days for various meetings and so on so we are actually maximizing uh our contract I'll just
527say like you go to the contract for this type of stuff uh it will be exorbitantly expensive exor expensive for any additional minutes you can put in place for uh teacher work time it's it's not just our district it's the district that's the way it works uh if you ask for additional time or otherwise I won't even get into the pros or cons of meeting before or after school or anything but is that data you could get for us do we have districts where they've tried to do it through contracts and we know how they've settled or most people stay away from it they basically stay away from it um but I could ask Council that they give me examples of their negotiation with people of what what adding what potentially adding in minutes means
528it believe me it's expensive yeah but if we could get some information on that that would be nice to understand just in a memo would be fine the for this budget season or you mean for negotiation sorry well I think part of the question probably is whether we would want to adopt this through a with the trade-off with instructional time or whether we'd want to try to take this on as a negotiation negotiations but I'm not proposing necessarily to put it in that that negotiation understood yep um okay um then I think Joanna you asked um Is it feasible to just do this at the elementary school so what is the cost compared to okay entire proposal and also would that meet our needs for the teachers because I do I agree that there's it
529seems like there is more of a need at the elementary school this coming year because of the literacy um implementation and some of the other things that you have on here that are specifically for elementary okay if you were asking me I would say just the Elementary uh teachers not even these new things like just not even these new things alone they they are the uh the ones that um really R treadmill in many ways and don't have the professional time to do some of this stuff okay maybe that's some okay so we'll answer that but it sounds like it could partly be answered as part of the elementary teacher day discussion okay any other questions on PLC all right uh fellow elected officials members of the public uh Crystal Hills CSP chair um want
530to speak to you on PLC um putting aside the merits and the needs of teachers to participate in more plc time I just want to talk from the student and family perspective about the logistics of this initiative as outlined um in the 14 years I've been in Daran uh things have changed I mean 11 years ago I know have an 11th grader I started being heavily involved in the PTO from the kindergarten level um we've seen a significant sh shift at the PTO level of the number of uh two you know families that have two working parents that's gotten harder for certain things to happen at the PTO level we've had to change we've had to change the way you know the timing of meetings do some of the events we do it's just harder
531to get parents at during the day and we consistently hear from parents at one of their biggest frustrations during those two weeks of conference weeks it's logistically challenging to have four days where their children are home early um and adding five more days of that at the elementary level is a significant Challenge and ask of our families um so I don't think that should be lost in this discussion that it is a burden that's going to be put on our families to have five additional days at Elementary level where they have to find Child Care um I think I hear a lot that you know younger families modern families they've changed Darion is not a place where most of the families have a working mother or a stay-at home mother at home anymore and it
532feels like maybe the district hasn't moved with where our families are the certainly uptick as postco when we had a lot of young families mooved to town a lot of those kids are now coming into the district it's even we're seeing it more and more so I just don't want that to get lost in the conversation the merits of needing this time may be there but the logistics of the way this is outlined is a challenge for our families um and in a year a tough budget we what going to ultimately be $100,000 to the bottom line the timing timing that also seems perhaps questionable thank you hi um my name is Frank I'm a high schooler that went through the Darian public schools program um I have two younger sisters uh I went through
533K to 5 at oxridge as did my two younger sisters and uh I did one year of middle sex before going to private school uh over covid um why I'm here today is to tell you a bit of a story I fell asleep in class as an elementary schooler five or six times which is insane as as a nine 10 year-old no kid that young should be falling asleep in class right I'd be taking laps of the school I'd ask the use the bathroom i' take a lap of the school I'd read projects on the walls right and why was that because I was bored right now idea the idea program saved me I think because as a gifted student we have special needs as well there's a disconnect between the high expectations of ourselves
534and the results that kids can achieve especially without enrichment from schools and so the fact that the board is axing the idea program makes me really hurt now my two sisters have also gone through the idea program I I did as well and for families like mind education is a big draw of why we even came to Daren right outside in the strategic plan booklet I read the home sales are down and it's a significant factor in in the Strategic plan and I also saw that our district at a glance was the number one high school in Connecticut and you had a big golden star next to the sign programming for gifted Learners and the fact that it's going to be gone I mean I I just think it's a travesty for gifted students in
535Daren to not have access to a program so great such as idea I now attend Andover uh boarding school in Massachusetts and when I'm asked about my education before and over I don't site the private school I go to earlier I py the idea program as being the basis of my academic success skills and enrichment and so why I'm here is to ask the board to reconsider Act the idea program thank you thank you hi um my name is Bo I've been Darian resident for uh more than 12 years uh Frank is my son oldest I have two younger daughters as well uh I still have this uh Vivid uh memory of my 7-year-old the daughter came home with a clayboard of Sumerian in her hand and the smile on her face just stunned me
536that's the joy of education and that's the power of the idea program uh I I I think that is press okay I'm add out with the Press list part talked about let's talk about price uh I I understand uh resources is always limited even for the fluent town of Daran uh uh back 12 years ago when I was considering buying a home or owning a home in Daran I had choices both me and my wife worked uh in finance industry in the city so we're not just confine our choices in in in Connecticut we compared uh Short Hill New Jersey uh scotdale in Westchester uh and of course long iseland uh one of the reason we chose here is because we have friends here and they their kids went through the public school here which
537is very impressive and above all is the idea program because uh I think back then uh who graduated already who is a successful engineer uh he showed me the videos of making a a a rocket and uh that that's part of the idea program back then that totally impressed us that's one of the reason we chose to stay in Daran and as my son just de and described uh the whole education system is the is the core competence of this ter and that supports the home price and the value and this supports the tax base and the whole education system so if we invest into the education as we're we're talking about here right now it's it's a good cycle we're investing education the the the good reput reputation of our our our Public School
538System we enhance the wealth level and everything of this town so I I think this is a is a good cycle we should keep it going and back to the ideaal program we consider that as a cherry on top of this big cake don't kill idea because that's the Cherry please keep that thank you sir thank you sorry sir can you give me your last name for the notes for the minutes uh last name who H thank you okay go ahead good afternoon Mike rer for Apple Tree Lane I come to you in strong opposition of eliminating the idea program I have two daughters here in town uh one is not in the program one is in the program I want to give you briefly the perspective as a parent of both of those situations
539and so first with the child who's not in the program I've gotten to know her friends over the last uh 10 to 12 years and the program is absolutely critical to their ongoing success and watching them grow up and Thrive and they're going on to do amazing things uh secondly for our daughter who is in a program uh frankly I would be lost as a parent without the program the uh staff who operate the program I think are some of the best Educators that we are fortunate to employ in this town they have the experience of being in their positions typically for over 20 years and have seen generations of students progress through the program so they're an invaluable resource to me as a parent um I listened to the recording of Thursday's meetings and
540uh Dr adley if I may uh put you on the spot for a minute or so uh you highlighted that the program has been in existence for over 50 years and that it is not ideal that we are considering eliminating the program uh that's not the best sales pitch I've ever heard to be honest uh you noted that we have a responsibility to meet the needs of all students including our gifted students so uh I'm a business person I'm pretty bottom line oriented and some of the stats that I wrote down include that we serve 237 students with 3.3 positions uh some basic math indicates that's approximately 72 students per teacher so if we're looking for efficiencies I'm not sure that that's the first place that I would look that seems pretty efficient to me
541um some of the solutions that Dr adley presented and thank you for proposing Solutions included additional professional development for our general classroom teachers uh however I'm concerned because elsewhere in your presentation on Thursday you noted that professional development is its own challenge in the budget and as we were just discussing logistically as well for families uh and students and professional development overall is a critical area for Recruitment and Retention of our teachers so um this just doesn't make sense on its surface sir you're at time thank you for hearing me today thank you my name is Rebecca relier I live at six Ridge viw Avenue thank you so much for your time this Saturday I'm here to express serious concerns about the proposed elimination of idea this decision is alarming and shortsighted some may argue
542that gifted programs are elitist I disagree differentiated instruction tailored to individual learning needs is not elitism it's just Effective Education the current identification process could be improved it could be broaden to serve more students but eliminating the program is not the solution this decision negatively impacts all students gifted students will lose access to teachers trained to handle their unique gifts but also their unique challenges students not in idea will lose the small group time that they currently have when idea students are elsewhere all students will ultimately suffer from the long-term Economic Consequences of diminished property values that um our other neighbors spoke about I urge you to reconsider this decision invest in all our students by maintaining and strengthening idea this is an investment in daran's future thank you yes so for for thank you
543all for future reference further commentary about idea should be kept to the end of the meeting we're trying to stay by RC we're certainly interested in hearing from from the public but there is a a discreet public comment period I think everybody in here has already spoken but there is a discret public commentary at the end where this these will be these will continue to be focused on the actual RC's that we're discussing um we're now moving on to rc23 uh so rc23 uh Daran Summer School uh it continues to be a successful program with over 1500 students and almost a million dollars in generated Revenue um it continues um to generate a lot of interest from the community um uh no real changes for the budget going forward uh we do expect that next
544year's program will likely hit um or just come close to a million dollars in Revenue John so um this last fiscal year which should passed our Revenue numbers Rich how'd you build the revenue numbers for this proposed budget so we look at the number of classes that have been offered uh in the previous summer school um we look at what our price Point's going to be um and we kind of extrapolate that going forward you'll see when we see the increase in Revenue uh in 310005 there's also an increase in expenditures in the 120001 account there is corresponding expenses related to those who run the individual camper program and in some cases it's a percentage of how much revenue they bring in okay so I guess what was what was the actual 2425 uh so
545it was a 945 th000 so we do have 9910 in uh rc23 and then we book $35,000 in rcon okay thank you any other questions on summer school no okay fellow government officials who wish to speak about summer school members of the public with questions about summer school okay rc20 Finance um so RC Finance uh there are no changes other than the contractual increase for the annual audit of $1,000 um the Auditors are appointed by the board of finance and are required every year any questions about rc20 okay uh government officials who wish to ask about rc20 members of the public who wish to ask talk speak about rc20 RC 16 so rc16 is Administration uh the only real change is in legal fees where you'll see a $60,000 increase we do have as been
546noted uh teacher negotiations coming up in the fall and so that increase in legal fees represents the pending teacher negotiations as this fall okay questions about rc16 uh Katie thank you um I have a couple of detailed questions but I want to start with the big picture one um alen I was hoping that you could speak to um kind of the thought process big picture in the budget about why there are no cuts to admin that's that's a well well I going ask perhaps it's a different type of question not particularly for this particular Administration but that but that's fine I can address it here if you want to do that because the administration's in other parts of the budget but that's understandable we brought up here yeah um we have uh we have look
547it's it's a tough challenge in budget Year yes I clearly I've thought about Administration you can't take just the whole infrastructure start dismantle infrastructure that's doing all the things that our public wants our community wants our children wants that you want that I want if you start taking that all apart it's only recently that we actually settled on an actual administrative model in terms of like the administr you might be thinking about Department churs assistant principles we've just uh spent close to two years nearly going go through process to to land on that particular model and I I I'm not going to be supporting dismantling that because you you might get away with it for year you make very to but long term that is going to be a detriment to this uh the school
548system if you start messing around with that uh and we've been sitting at the table here any given year is any given year and everything else is up for up for discussion but we committed to actually this particular model moving forward and yes people have made their own personal and professional decisions whether to step into that and step but that's unfortunately part of the budget uh uh process and that just goes with the flow a little bit uh but that being said that we you're going to it's going to be a recruitment issue again right you're going to be losing administrators we just getting settled with an administrative team that's a excellent High performing administrative team that you have I'm just going to tell you people are not going to want to come here as
549administrators if you start to continue to do to start to take it apart U particularly the depart uh department head model assistant principal model I think you the short answer is I think you need it okay other questions on this RC um can I add on to what Katie said so I feel like you said we've just settled on one system but I actually feel like we now have one and a half systems uh because my understanding originally of Department shairs was not just that they wrote curriculum and aligned things vertically but they also were in the classrooms um you uh evaluating teachers but last year when we added an a AP that was so there would be more time for the aps to go into the classroom to evaluate teachers so now you have
550two different areas of Administrators evaluating teachers so it feels like a redundancy in that way well it was it we we red some Administration right and some of it has to be picked up we also the additional assistant principles were also for special education to serve uh that population and that need so there were it was all sort of together John wasn't just it it just wasn't like straight forward that the the the uh the evaluation goes to uh the assistant principles there was the trickle on a fact of one one of impacting the other am do you want to add it's just it's really also important to note that Beyond observations another requirement expectation and best practice is investment in again embedded professional learning so the department chairs who have content area expertise work
551very closely with not only the building ad but with the teachers to develop goals personal and professional teacher goals for the staff within the Departments and so those goals are related to what happens in classroom for observed practice they set goals they they monitor them during midyear conferences and circle back at end of year they also provide a lot of coaching um in District so all of all of that is important and discipline specific work we at the middle school and the high school we wanted those assistant principal out contact in and contact with with kids and contacted with the teachers in the actual classrooms and that is happening go ahead Charlie I just wanted to add you went and we in our last presentation we showed the reduction of how many ppts when it
552went from two APS to three APS so a lot of it was to free up assistant principles in middle school and high school to have other opportunities not just for evaluation but for coaching but we did show the number of reduction I think it was about 25 if I remember about 25 reduction just add one other piece the department chair I think provide an opportunity to um work alongside the building Administration to ensure that they're keeping current across all of the disciplines for example if you think about the high school the variety of disciplines and courses that are there they are provide a conduit in a liaison to the department staff and student teaching um student learning experiences and expectations across its purpose since we actually uh put in place the elementary assistant principles I
553think since then we we have reduced two administrative positions since then net two administrative positions even where we've added the assistant principal to the high school and middle school more questions on this RC yes um would it be possible to get a itemized list of the $ 12,500 for catering I think we're see some of it here yeah well the 2000 oh any more questions on this RC just Jessie um Joanna um what is the difference between CES and CES leadership uh CES um it's just in general the uh I think it's just the the sitation or the phase for it um and I'm a member of the CES leadership CES did you have a question oh Dave thanks um Allan 2425 can you remind me what good or service was provided by the partnership
554for educational leadership and what good or service is anticipated in 2526 so those are all of those all of those items listed there are in the superintendent's contract so that's just a contractual matter right but what good or service was provided to the district oh for this year for this past year for the previous in is anticipated uh I did not uh participate in this this year I'm not participating last year I did you ask what services that services to the time that's my professional learning organization okay so I guess so last year you participated in a something an event or or clinic or some development you said you're not participating in it this year coming forward this year I haven't I have not enrolled currently have not enrolled in that organization okay do we
555anticipate that uh remains I honestly did not sure thank you it could be a sa Katie did you have a question oh I'm sorry I didn't understand what you said okay any other questions in rc16 okay um fellow elected officials on rc16 members of the public on rc16 okay RC8 Personnel Human Resources uh so rc18 includes uh the staff turn over account we are budgeting uh just over $634,000 uh in this account it's really aggregated into three areas uh first this year we saw 42 teacher positions turnover down from 66 in the previous year we are budgeting an assumption of 40 uh we are also assuming 20 PA of professionals turnover that is a similar similar number to what turned over this year which is the acred savings and the new salary schedule and then
556finally within that account we are assuming that two secondary teachers um will designer retire from the district allowing us to complete the four to the five should that not occur and we not uh lose a teacher in those two subject areas then that would create a deficit just like you would have with turnover um if you don't meet turnover uh another count salary savings which was new in the current year uh we are budgeting again $100,000 we did materialize $120,000 this year however about $58,000 of that were the two new APS that were added and uh the change in principal at the Middle School uh so that really created the bulk of the savings which is why we didn't elevate it to that $120,000 line item again this year and then finally in contract support
557uh we do have two non-certified contracts that will be unsettled uh and so there is a wage settlement set aside for the custodians in maintenance uh which will start negotiations this spring questions um in this R uh John so rich the big change here is a 250,000 but um It's associated with the four to five move is that okay so the basically when you look at your basic turnover assumptions around those 42 teachers it's the same underlying inputs then yeah and then again okay thanks Sarah thank you um hi I mean you know you say you assume that these two teachers at the middle school will retire if you could percent it like how how sure are you about that I think we're pretty confident on one okay uh and then the other one it
558could be a flip of a coin okay um it's not really any different then uh you know we make an assumption that 40 teachers will leave the district you could have 20 teachers leave the district and be short and turn over or you could have 60 teachers leave and have excess money right um so we're basically taking that same calculated risk that that will happen Okay but neither Nei of them has said yes I'm sure it could also come from the high school correct right so it's a it would have to be a secondary teacher so if it's a high school teacher as an example that steps out a middle school teacher would go to the high school okay um my next question is about long-term Subs just curious this says the aage daily rate
559is 445 a day how does that compare to other districts so we I don't have that data we'd have to probably look that up it has been escalating over the last three years or so right so when we had a teacher Surplus we used to be able to pay the Master's step three to attract people that doesn't happen anymore people don't come unless they get credit for their education and experience so I think the average is 445 sometimes we have to pay more sometimes we can find a newer teacher but that's happening all over Fairfield County okay thanks picky back on that like the daily rate I think is 125 110 no no 125 Sor okay um why the huge difference well so these are long-term substitutes who'll be in the classroom for probably months
560they're doing lesson plans they're really taking the role of a teacher so we pay for that right I understand that but you're saying that it's not possible to fill that role like people aren't willing to commit to that time unless there's that amount especially in shortage areas they just they just won't do it we're just remaining competitive with surrounding districts okay um and then second sorry um on the um on the last account um 25029 sta development programs there's a mention in the text that there's Mental Health Training for athletic head coaches and I'm curious why we're not doing that in house and through um Dr dad so I think unfortunately Dr dad would need to speak with it but there is a module that we're going do you know know the Dr dad is
561providing the professional learning she's been working on it with Chris manfredonia and so I would we would need to get oh she's here CL um yes we've been working with Chris I know we mentioned earlier the mental health first aid training um that's being done and offered through the town the challenges for some of our coaches they also have other um employment and they're not necessarily available at the same time so it's offered as an online module for that Mental Health First Aid there is an opportunity um possibly for us to get that training done through another manner that would not be of cost we're exploring that but as of now for coaches there's a specific Mental Health First Aid training for coaches that's um available online so they can do it outside of the
562the time that they're coaching Sarah um going to the tuition reimbursement line I know that we are contractually o obligated to cover a certain amount of that but in historically we have not met that number is that $660,000 and I should know this is that $60,000 what's what we have agreed to put into the budget or is that just what we're assuming so it's $50,000 for the two $10,000 for the administrators um we we are we agree to fund that within the budget for both those groups um we do typically F you know pay for the majority of the teacher usually hits at 50 that admin is nonsense but that number we can't reduce that number in anywhere is that so we agree to fund it as part yeah that has to be Joanna um
563the team Mentor stiens I'm just wondering what the change was why the state sort of stopped paying for it but still requires it uh so the grant used to cover almost the entire thing so we used to get about $20,000 a year now it's a little less than $7,000 a year and so the rest of it's being picked up by the district else okay elected officials with questions about this RC members of the public okay um so just as a followup oh we don't have any on this RC all right okay RC 27 now Alan there's some changes here how are we delineating between what you want to talk about in public and what you might not want to um I I think the uh any uh structural changes or otherwise um we can leave
564aside uh and go outside of the process and executive s and also uh working with the town officials as we said we would for um improvements in that so so um Leon is here our director is here to talk about the the department um those things can be left aside he's going to talk about the personnel and the restructure I think that is that is fine for for here okay Leon thanks for being here yeah of course good afternoon so Dr adley's proposal is to eliminate our floating SSO so elimination of one full-time employee and uh restructuring my responsibilities and that would result in an overall Savings in this RC of 50, 230 and that's the uh significant change in this RC okay so if there are CH questions about any of the costs that's
565fine if there's questions about how this is going to work we'll take them in exec session Joanna um so when you average out what the ssos make right now um and then you average out what but as a just salaries as an agre get what they would be making when they're just 5.5 instead of six um is it that everyone is getting a a um you know $5,000 raise or they all paid different amounts guess I don't fully understand the question they are all paid the same amount uh it's the director is taking essentially portion of that job which is why you don't necessarily see a cut in that line item you see the cut in the director line item okay so go ahead maybe just explaining it or getting explanation further so basically we're
566restructuring the role of the director correct so there's one position that will be eliminated which is the floating um SSO uh and then the duties of that uh will be shifted to the director got it Katie thank you um I I understand that it's just I guess it's just odd like essentially we're down one FTE um but we see we don't see a reduction it just doesn't quite make sense right we see a reduction in the director salary by half and essentially we're taking he's taking half of of an SSO position the floater but why isn't why isn't the SSO salary reduced by half well the the SSO salary is essentially eliminated we're we're reducing one SSO but like in the in the line item um 21601 it Remains the Same so we see that
567you know there's a reduction in one 31 director of security but essentially like there's there's a half in each why are you accounting for it that way versus the other way rich I guess is a question right sorry I don't mean as the net cut is the SSO um we could have left the director security shown as a 1.0 and a 1.0 reduction uh in the SSO line item uh an SSO salary is a little over 55,000 half the director's salary is 60,000 which is why you're not really seeing the change it's really how you reflect it whether you want to show the directors a 1.0 and a reduction of one SSO or whether you want to show it as a half an it well it it makes sense to me on page 258 in
568the financial sheet right we have a reduction of a05 FTE in the director of security and we have a reduction of a 0.5 FTE in the ssos but what doesn't line up to me is why when we come back on 257 there's only a reduction in the salary of the director and there's no reduction in the salaries of the ssos because that should be reduced by at least half even if the director of security is getting that half I mean is that correct that's what's happening he's getting half a director and half an SSO essentially no right and we're expecting him and I don't want to speak for Liam but we're expecting him to still do all of the functions of the director of security jobs okay so sorry there that was material information what
569you just said rich okay so what this is my new understanding is that the director of Security's responsibilities are changing and that half of his working time will now be dedicated that is correct as an SSO and we will eliminate one SSO however there is no reduction to his salary so his responsibilities change materially but there's no reduction to his salary which is an issue I will set aside but that makes no sense why we have accounted for it in this financial explanation when we show his salary at $61,800 like I mean that's very misleading so how would you like you'd like to see the SSO AR 21601 go down by one full FTE and the corresponding and then maintain 11 31 what this sounds like to me is we are eliminating an SSO and
570we are changing the scope of the responsibilities of the director of security that's correct correct that is not what is written here well it's not meant to be deceiving that's for sure well thank you and I appreciate that I don't I don't think that's the intention however we that 0.5 SSO time that's being spent is now significantly more expensive so we just increased the the marginal cost of that SSO by a lot no he just said it was 60 versus 55 no so he's making his exact salary right but half of his time is an SSO so you take half of his salary that's more than an SSO is making it's 61 to 55 there is a marginal Defence but it's it's not it's how would you I guess my question is how would you
571account for it on in our budget book I explain that this is this is an Essence a reduction of an SSO and a change in a job description to the director of security so the line item the director of security should not change at all that's merely a job description I was just confirming that there's so can we account for it like that I mean I think that's fine that makes makes sense to me that's fine that's fine and then we'd show five ssos yeah okay Jill yes um I know that we initially and tell me if this is an exact question we initially and had the floater in casee of absences um if if you can probably see where I'm going with this question is that an exact session yeah that would be an
572exact session discussion so can we put that for the 14th please yes yes I just want to make one point of clarification um and if I'm wrong Rich please correct me but Jill you said that it's 61 versus 55 so it's actually 61,000 for a halftime SSO that we're paying the director of security versus 55,000 for a full-time SSO so that is material yeah but you're losing it you're restructuring basically the security department but I'm simply talking about the amount paid for the SSO time that when we are paying the director's salary for an SSO we are paying double more than double than we are paying for an SSO as a floater yeah as as half time commitment okay Dave could you have a question I I mean I was confused I mean I know
573we're not at cut are you suggesting we shouldn't CIT anybody like I'm not sure what the point my suggestion stands from the presentation of the budget that this portion of security should be moved to the town budget so that we can focus on education okay thank you yeah we had a pretty in-depth discussion I think probably before you were on the board about why that wouldn't be appropriate um but we can cover that in exact session um um ssos are not SRO and we talked about that in detail theard is also new happy to cover that at another time I'm just clarifying for you and I think in executive session I can provide another we bit of clarity around the ISU you're consented by K okay all right so we'll this will be on the
57414th the how this is going to work um in addition to some of the discussion about the facilities Leon I recognize you're you're sitting there in the middle of this discussion um and it's not your to be honest it's not the security director of Security's ideal that they he would recommend but um that's where we are Tom okay all right um comments from elected officials comments from the public on this RC okay thank you all um we had one outstanding item on just the budget overall um looking for perhaps uh an alternative we talked about if we don't move forward with defunding idea um what would we what funding would we need to find as an alternative um and so we agreed to Circle back to that discussion this Greg was your point no whose
575point was it sorry so what we talked about earlier when we had the idea discussion was that if we don't uh if if we decide to maintain that program as a board that we probably need to find an alternate source to reduce the 469 now we don't need to do that right here at this moment but we're we need to tell Administration to go back and look for that 469 so we marked that and then needed and marked that we wanted to come back to that okay uh at the end of this at the end of today so um I we still the multi-year budget to go through do you want to do that yeah I think I think it still stands I mean the idea is to just have Dr Aly came up with
576what his view of the least bad ideas is right what's the second least bad what's the second least bad what's the third least bad let's understand because he's making decisions understand they're hard decisions but instead of waiting till the 14th and then board says we want we don't want to eliminate idea now we have to wait for another two weeks that's right let's go into the that meeting armed with with the informational Alternatives given we've already heard us some feedback okay Katie um it's it's been said a few times today that um that this budget reflects the guidance given from the board and while I understand we can use the term of the board to mean different things and it may mean a majority in this case however um when it comes down to the
577budget we do vote individually and I want to take this opportunity to reiterate that I did not give specific guidance I didn't I was never um in favor of backing into a number hitting a Target I maintain that is the responsibility of Daran Public Schools um under the leadership of the superintendent and the Board of Education to provide a budget that is responsible to education um and um what we can afford as a town what we choose to spend as a town is another conversation but our responsibility is to provide for education so as we're talking about this I am in no way in favor of eliminating the idea program nor am I looking to make up that money in other Cuts just EXC no thank you um okay Dennis and then Sarah so I
578appreciate Mr gramling's point to raise alternatives to to the money saved by proposed cut idea program I'm very hesitant to to propose Cuts just put I mean again you mentioned at the beginning of your point this is people right this is 98% of our budget is going to be people so we're now we're going to talk about another set of people or another set of people we bring up two or three just very reluctant to do that and and the morale that that's going to cause and the dis the Discord it's just I understand the rationale I do but I don't know that the the the solution is better than the problem so I struggle with that okay Sarah I oh I go Dennis's point also I'll go Katie's point I mean our job is
579to to do what's best for the students in our town um I think you know we the guidance that we gave you was not 4.39 the guidance that we gave you was about last year so I don't know that we need to go back and find $494,000 that's not the guidance that we gave so I don't really want to open a can of worms and get another subset of people all worked up for potentially no reason it doesn't it doesn't work for me my own my own personal opinion and I also am not in support of cutting idea Dave and then John thanks um so I guess going back to the point earlier in in following up on on Greg's Point um why are we shorten the cycle here maybe we could take a sense
580of where we are on this cut and maybe foro having to wait till the 14th to to get recommendations I I don't if anybody would like to entertain that at this point um the other thought is that you know it's been suggested that we are a blank check and we can do whatever we want to support education that's not actually how things work by Statute and we have to be cognizant that the board of Finance does have a say in this and so while we did suggest a number kind of like last year it's not really reflective of the guidance so I think we really need to do this thoroughly and see what alternatives are there um I think people pushed a lot on the PLC I don't think that was just blindly because the
581PLC I think people were looking for Alternatives and to think of other things that may be possible so we're very early in this process however I would love to reiterate and see if anyone would like to join in and just state where they are and see if we're going to go down the road and we can get I at this point okay well I think Katie and I both just vocally said we're not support of cutting idea okay um let's finish this discussion John um well I'm all for responsible budgeting and not going through it we did last year which I personally found an embarrassment to this board um by adding back to the budget um I do think the process has changed for the better in that our fiscal Authority has given us very
582specific bipartisan transparent guidance on its taxations strategy and what that means for this board we can we have the statutory authority to ignore that and go through the same process we did last year it's basically a second budget process so what I think we're trying to avoid is if we are to change the priorization that our superintendent laid out and by the way these five people we pay a lot of money to run this district and year in and year out we're in the top rated District in State and we are in one of the top rated districts in the state and we are in one of the top you know recognized districts in the country so if we do question what the priorities are and we have that right and we've done that in
583the past I would implore that we actually make an offset because going through that process that we did last year was a extremely uh laborous undertaking that wasted a lot of our time and more important wasted a lot of people around this table and who we saw today's time so let's responsibly budget by providing to this district and just to put this in perspective our student count XP since fiscal year 2021 is down down 15 students our budget is up 19.98% over that time period so this notion I think our DEA president said have lost our way as school district is insane there's 800 people that work for this District we support them I'm totally supportive of the contract that we signed three years ago and I look forward to negotiating the next contract but
584we have to responsibly budget at this table and I think you know today went a lot better because we were kind of around the bounds of of targeting a a an area of a budget increase so I'll stop with that okay Robin um I do not support cutting the idea program I think it's a very integral part of our education and it is also what helps set Daran apart and um I'm worried about what that message would be if that program would be eliminated because I do think that it kind of goes against the values of our our strategic plan and um even the vision of The Graduate and the competencies we're trying to build in our students um as I had mentioned a number of times during the previous this meeting I mean I
585do think that there is potential opportunity is and it's probably unpopular but the participation fees and looking again at the analysis that the administration had provided to us um for athletics clubs and councils and again these are kind of nominal fees and I hate to say that because it is essentially a tax but at at the very least I think it would be helpful to look at that as a board and um rather than having to eliminate programs um allow our district to continue to provide programs and provide new programs as well and maybe with a different way of going about that so I um I don't want to go down a path of having more more Personnel being cies I agree that that would be extremely detrimental and I don't want to have that
586kind of um thing going on in this process so that's where I stand okay Jo I see your hand um yeah um just to start uh John with what you said you said that we are down 15 students but up 19% spending over the last five years was that no I'm just I can't remember exactly what you said roughly 19.98% so five years ago things did cost a lot less than they do right now so just to give that one comparison I think is is a very specific lens to look I can adjust it for CPI if you um but generally speaking I also keep coming back to the idea that we are no longer qualified for the title one Grant because we are not impoverished enough so to be you know boxing ourselves in
587so much um due to these you know I understand everyone has a taxing policy but I think we can go before the board of finance and say to them it's 4.8 or it's 5.1 because X Y and Z we need this and here's why I don't think as a board we don't have any agency so I just want to put that out there to begin with um I don't support cutting um the uh sorry the idea program I also don't support a couple of other things that are potentially being cut but I don't know if this is the right time to get into that so anybody else want to say anything oh go ahead Dave um so the CPI John following up is consumer basket it's not reflective of our budget so I know it's
588been suggested that we should model off that but it's it's not actually a good Benchmark um I'll keep it quick because I think the idea people are pretty smart I think you guys know where I'm standing on this one that being said um I think it's important that we do Focus John to your point to get to a number that reflects what our obligations are to students and Our obligation statutorily to the board of Finance we do that very quickly um and get down there and move on to other businesses here support that Greg yeah I mean for me it's what we went through last year was absolutely important and mostly for the folks who are here who wasted nine months out of their year we cannot be in a budget cycle for nine months
589out of 12 months of the year it's totally unacceptable for us as a board and we should Endeavor to do whatever we possibly can to avoid that yeah I would agree with that um I um you know as a as an individual board member I also have significant reservations about cutting Ida my concern at this stage about making a decision in this red hot moment is that there are multiple things that we haven't discussed yet and so I am worried about one of the things that we run into as a board is we make decisions component by component and we don't look at the big picture and say okay well if I add all of those things together what number ises that give me I absolutely agree with you Joanna that we absolutely have agency
590and if the right number is 5.1 that's one thing if the right number is 10% we need to be all fired you know so I think that if we don't focus in on you know an appropriate set of numbers and we don't focus in on making sure that we go through the right set of decision-making criteria and understand how these things work together then we can end up with a budget that's big and unwieldy as we did last year because we haven't stepped back and said here's first of all the overall goal and second of all here's how these things interact together and here's how we are going to prioritize so you know again I I share I have I've no desire to cut any programming frankly um and pretty much anything I've looked that
591I don't love um but I also recognize that we do have to come up with a budget that is reasonably fiscally responsible and we are two-thirds of the Town budget so um I personally while I hate that it causes any distress to the community I personally like the plan that we put forward understand what is the actual um structure that the administration is proposing for idea or for gifted children what does that look like is there a crosswalk if there is not a crosswalk it's a different discussion if there is one um then you know then we need to have that discussion um and decide whether or not it meets the standard um that we're looking for in terms of the education that we want to provide so that that is where I stand um
592again not because I like this exercise but because I think this exercise is a necessary part of the job Katie thank you um I think this is a really valuable discussion and I appreciate everyone that that's participating in this because we do need to think big picture about our work um there's a couple things that I just want to hit on one is that um I I've had quite a bit of conversations with Board of Finance members as well as I'm sure most of you had about what happened last year and the message that I really took away was that like what we bring to them has to be defended and I don't think that was last year and that's on us so if if we are asking them for dollars we need we absolutely
593need to be confident that that we need those dollars and to communicate why that is the direct message that I I have heard from Board of Finance members across parties so we need to take that to heart that our responsibility doesn't end with passing a budget but it's also defending a budget secondly um we are hamstrung by the budget that we receive so in terms of the process we have it's already started by the time we receive a shrink wrapped budget that's not even public yet and when time and time again we get a budget that has surprises in it what are we supposed to do with that it's almost impossible not to go backwards like we did last year and last year was terrible I don't think anyone enjoyed it what were we supposed
594to do with that this year again surprises programmatic changes that have not been discussed when year after year we are saying there should not be surprises in this budget book we should know what's coming any anything that is programmatic needs to be flushed out ahead of time again this year we're saddled with that what are we supposed to do idea programmatic change surprise in the budget and now like we're cing at a crosswalk we want to have the development of a plan well we tried that last year we tried that last year with a trust me on the middle school and it was a failure 29 classes outside of policy set policy board ofed guidelines we're going to do that again this year we're going to eliminate a program that has brought out a l
595I and NASA scientists to speak about the value of Education in darianne and we're just going to trust that a plan that hasn't been formulated can achieve those same results we are we are setting ourselves up to fail with this something bigger has to change so just I think in order to defend our budget it has to be defensible which means that we have to do things like flag the fact that we understand that we actually do have to budget to a number we can't say the world's our oyster we want anything we want and then put forward a budget that says this is anything we want we we don't care what the numbers are you guys figure it out let us know what you think is Affordable and then be upset when the number
596we get back is not what we think is Affordable we cannot actually fill positions when the administration says to us I will not fill that position we cannot leave it in the budget last year's budget was not defensible so I think that one of am among the things that we have changed this year are number one we have talked to that that we've received guidance from the board of Finance so that we understand what the universe of possibilities is not so that we're pegged to a specific place but so that we can actually do some sort of intelligent planning that isn't just um in a vacuum number two we did set forward our initiatives much earlier in the process we have been much more explicit about tying things funding to strategic planning so we've done
597a lot of work in that area I do agree with you that there it didn't work in all cases we certainly do have idea in here and we we were not expecting it to show up in the budget at this time um at the same time I do want to say out loud the timeline is challenging in so far as sometimes when we try to have a conversation in the summer if we're going to talk about um let's use idea as an example if we're going to talk about eliminating idea for example this summer then we've got an entire year of Staff who are working to support our children who know that there's there's an end of of life there so that is a challenge uh for us that we haven't figured out yet how
598to overcome um but going forward in terms of what we want to do tonight generally what we do in this meeting is just listen okay if there is truly a desire to take idea off the table today again not because anybody truly wanted it there to begin with but because we feel like that conversation is closed we certainly can do that um but regardless we do have to decide what we are going to then we have have to understand that has implications for the rest of the decisions we make throughout the budget process John so again in in the past when we've had some of these issues that have been brought forth during the budget season we've carved out some time in the next meeting to around that subject matter um did it with open
599Choice a number of other things yes so I would I would implore us to wait until the next meeting because they're all listening there might be a you know one the crosswalk discussion if you will two there might be compromise where you know it starts that we can maintain it for the later grades I wouldn't want to make a rash decision just tonight Dave I would want to wait till Tuesday and then we can then we can have that decision they also are hearing that you know again I personally would like to see other ways that we can meet those budgetary commitments without having to cut idea but I'd like to wait till Tuesday instead of doing it tonight I'd agree with that John I don't think we need to make any decision tonight but
600I think the point's been well made and I think the Administration has been listening and I would expect that they may come back with some other ideas when we get there um thinking perhaps that's an on starter okay okay again just to minimize the cycle and get through this yeah absolutely yeah agree all right Madam chair just a point of order I think there was a motion made and seconded to to vote on this I don't know if that's still on a table or you I think it's a motion I think it's a question if we would be willing to take meaning which I think we've done but I defer to the chair of course yeah I I don't I didn't take it as a motion but thank you for asking the question just in
601case it was unclear um um okay with that we will open it to public comment we still have the multi-year budget I'm so sorry thank you Sarah multi-year budget uh so the multi-year budget SAR last year takes the existing staff and pushes them through their uh contracts if they have applicable uh St uh movement if the contract expires it just assumes that the same last year terms continue forward um insurance we are assuming a 10% rate increase going forward um we did put in for special education excess cost will be reimbursed at 70% uh bad news estimated revenues did come out from the state and it looks like this year will be 60% um so that will not only impact this year potentially years going forward as well um and it does take some of
602those Grant positions that we talked about like the wellness quarter and that oneir into the grant into the operating budget it does look at things like moving the transition program potentially forward in fiscal 27 School AI the architectural soft architectural study for the high school in token and then a continuation of the reading program uh we do stay within that kind of 4.4 to five uh four and a half percent range for the next few years questions on theator yes Robin um I have a couple questions first um for regular Ed you know all the um schools how are teachers assumed other than Elementary which I understand how was the projection made for Staffing that would be needed um at middle sex and Daran high school and then the same question for special education Staffing
603and what were the assumptions and numbers of students and the growth in special education students uh so at the middle school we did assume we completed the four of the five starting in the the year forward uh that would leave that complete going in the year out we did not make any assumptions in terms of additional special education teachers going uh the the multi-year format does show an increase of 20 special education teachers over including this this year um for a net increase of four teachers overall and I just I added up all the future years including this current year so the only uh the only increase in special education teachers on the document on page 347 is one which is for the transition uh program will you teach special classroom teachers maybe it was
604okay I looked year by year and it looked like there was an increase so I maybe I was it's hard to read colors sorry and this just tin um okay that might be my mistake thank you any other questions on the multi-year you have one just um I guess point we shared this out with Board of Finance in advance or discussed or what their thought is on this run forward number or would we hear from them at some point on this on this that's a good question we did this last year kind of like this and then we have it again it's in their booklets but we had haven't ever established a formal discussion with them in any way um they just have it um it's a good question to ask um because I think
605that um compounding here gets yes yes Robin Rich I'm just looking at again it's page 347 it's the rc24 it does show proposed increases in staff so I that's just a question of how what the so oh total well so there's total staff so there's only one teacher you do see in the outer years an additional six power Professionals for the transition program and then two drivers should we move forward with the transition program and then the following year another four four poers for the transition program and the year after that six poers for the so that's mostly the transition program roll out corre okay thank you any other questions okay well not I'll move to public comment good evening if anybody in person or online would like to participate in public comment please come
606up to the podium or use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized once recognized please state your name and address for the record and note that you will have up to three minutes to comment my name is Jack Davis 197 wa Street um for those in the audience who do not know I'm also the chair of the RTM finance and budget committee and I was actually debating whether or not I was going to make this comment yes you have the right to determine what we need for the education of our children you also have a financi responsibility to do it within a wise budget during the course of this year we're going to see $2 million less probably in our investment in we have been benefited by 1% growth in our grand list
607which has generated incremental Revenue we're not going to see that this year at 11 billion versus 8.5 billion there are other Financial aspects of what's going on we've also going to be investing $160 million in debt for our schools and by the way we're still paying off token eat and middle sex is probably going to come in at someplace in the $50 million range don't think that this town has not been supporting our education now I'm fortunate I just when it comes to the RTM and same with the board of Finance we're giving you a whole number so whether or not you keep idea whether or not you keep certain poers that's not our decision we do not have line item veto on the board of ed budget but we do have a decision on
608what the total budget is so yes there's been some good good discussion but it really comes down to what your core is and what we've seen in growth I've had a conversation with Jill if you really go to core the Department of Education for the state says you need to teach a language that's one language that's your core the other languages that you're choosing are high priority but not core now I use that as an example I'm not suggesting that you cut the other languages what I am suggesting is that when you're looking at this budget you start looking at it with what your core is what's the high priorities what are non priorities that are still believed to be essential whether not Athletics whether not that's power that's your decision what the final budget
609is going to be is going to be the board of finance and the RTM and so all I'm asking is be reasonable because not everybody in this town town is making the $250,000 not everybody in this town can afford a 5% or 6% increase in the mill rate so there are constraints here and that's the only thing I'm asking that that's part if you're going to take one thing you may be looking for something else thank you thank you Jeff anyone else for a public comment coming up my name is Elias Wesley and I'm a fifth grade at Ox Elementary School I'm can you P that microphone a little closer to you my name is is Elias Wesley and I'm a fifth grader at Ox Elementary School I'm in the idea program and my family
610supports full funding for Daran schools including Idea Idea challenges me in in interesting ways and is important to my Lear thank you for your support thank you very much hi I'm uh Lizzie rer and I live on Fort Apple Tree Lane and I don't think you guys realize how much it would hurt me and other students if you cut the idea program because without the ID program I wouldn't know about so many other challenging things after after school and before school and also I would be not challenged and I wouldn't be getting the best out of my education which you you all said that we should be getting the best out of our education and cutting the idea program isn't helping a lot of people including me get the best out of it thank you
611Crystal Hills cdsp chair I wasn't going to speak again at the end of this meeting but I just wanted to say um I I think I gave public comment at the meeting where you guys all provided your guidance and said that at the end of the day this board needed to put a budget together that met the needs of its students and I understand this idea of core and what's provided this is a town that just bought aund million Island that's not a core priority so if we're going to ask our schools to dwindle to core priorities or just a bit more that's a bit absurd just just a point of information we had zero input on that decision hi uh bruer banck 20 Stanton Road um I joined the meeting on Thursday and I've
612been monitoring today's discussion by YouTube thanks for making that available it's really valuable um sorry hearing the kids talk about idea it's okay um it just it it reminds me why I'm here in person um one to express my extreme disappointment with um the concept of cutting the idea program from next year's budget and then two to share some general comments about the budget and how we're allocating capital in this town so on the topic of idea you know cutting the program would be an enormous mistake um and it would cause Mater IAL arm it should be left in its current form the commentary regarding some attempt to embed an equivalent experience in the regular classroom isn't practical full stop it's a GameChanger for gifted students to be surrounded by their peers even if for
613just a few times a week so by now you've heard from many parents about the value of idea and I won't repeat many of their great comments and the impact that this had on on them and their their their children um excuse me if I was on an elevator ride with you last year and you had two minutes to pitch me on the Daran school system one of a number of things you would cite is the presence of gifted educational program it's on the landing page of Daran ps.org and in fact it's actually one of the eight notable attributes shown in the horizontal scroll 1/8 of the accolades for only 39% of the budget why are we talking about cutting it regarding the budget as per the numbers you provided on Thursday after adjusting for
614end ofe givebacks you have managed to an average annual spend increase of just 3.57% per year since 2020 that's an amazing job and maybe too good as you haven't given yourself any room trying to to do this after multiple years of keeping expenses artificially low we need to remind Our Town leaders our family didn't vote for nor did we move here for the great Island we moved here for great education and Great Schools 4.6% isn't realistic and we need to adjust for more please go to the board of finance and ask for more than that thank you Laura PES um 11 Parson's walk I um I want to stress and that's a hard act to follow but um I want to point out that to Jack's point about core um Athletics is that our core
615and it basically seems to be a protected area um year after year um when it comes to budget talks as Sarah parent stressed it doesn't seem like the sports director has really tried to find any efficiencies in that and I'm curious if that person is not interested in being part of this solution who will find efficiencies because I think that it's glaring it's political and I think we need to get to the bottom of it and we need to make that part of our solution so we can put the idea program and Paris back on the table thank you hi my name is Kate Leiden doc stator I'm at for conquered Lane I'm the parent of two children the idea program n DHS uh Alum class of 96 thank you all for being here I
616know what a long day it must been I it must have been I've been in and out on the YouTube and here in person um I'd like to just Echo everything that everyone else has said about in support of the idea program my two children just speaking anecdotally have absolutely lit up this year uh one in particular an incredible Improvement in behavior um coming home with a twinkle in her eye about all of the group projects that she's working on um and really just couldn't be more excited on uh on an idea day to go in and work on challenging mythology projects or um go go head-to-head with some of her like-minded beers um thank you for reconsidering it uh for the next turn appreciate it anybody else in person okay Miss Natasha Rose you've
617been recognized and unmuted please note that you'll have up to three minutes to comment Miss Natasha Rose last chance hi apologies um my name is Natasha Tomi I live at 6 McLaren Road South in Daren and I am the mother of an idea student I wanted to speak tonight to oppose the idea of cutting this program and also to Echo some of the things that I heard from the previous speaker Jack regarding cutting the budget um as a whole I think the guidance is sound and um I think the administration needs to go back to the board get more creative in fact I think it's a little bit lazy to bring forward a large light line item like the idea program that is clearly not going to be cut so I think the work needs
618to be done on the side of the administration to figure out how to get efficiencies and maintain a reasonable responsible budget that's it thank you Mr Justin Rainey you have been unmuted and recognized please note that you'll have up to three minutes to speak than thank you um I understand uh the the tenor of the discussion has has changed a little bit towards the uh the end of the day um and so I'm I'm submitting these comments um just kind of again to weigh the weight of the evidence of of how we're viewing all of this um and some of these comments you know to the extent they're they're relevant to finance and any of those discussions um that can be viewed in that vein so first thanks thanks for all of your efforts um
619I'm the parent of two children in the idea program um and what I would say is that when when the news emerged about the proposed cuts um both of my kids like their disappointment was just written all over their faces um and what I would say it's from the public comments that that we've already heard I'm pretty convinced that you've had similar scenes unfold across the households of all the 237 students that are enrolled in the program um it was really striking and telling to me that had alums who no longer even reside in deran that felt compelled to provide firsthand accounts of the impact the program had on their lives um to me it's just it's clear that we have something very special in the program um it's not something that I think we
620should be walking away from it's something you want to invest in um my children's experience it it mirrors the feedback that other members have already shared um idea has been an Avenue for them to explore new Concepts B challenges that are not present in their General classrooms uh and it's been a forum where they can forge friendships with other kids with similar interests it's it's clearly a unique learning environment serving unique kids uh despite our best intentions I fear that this environment will not be easily reproduced in the general classroom uh the the plan to continue to challenge these kids in the general classroom feels inadequate and it's exacerbating my my family's concern about the proposal educational Excellence is really part of the character of this community our schools are one of the primary motivating
621factors in people's decision to reside in Daran Following last year's contentious educational budget negotiations the purchase of an island and then the current proposed elimination of the idea program um I fear a narrative will crystallize about our Town's priorities other talented engaged people that are looking to start their families will take notice of these events when choosing where they wish to set up Roots I believe it is in all residents interest that Daran remains a town synonymous with educational Excellence this is a cost-effective program serving unmet needs the idea cohort represents nearly 10% of the student enrollment in second through eth grades in other contexts I wonder whether we would consider to fail to meet the needs of 10% of the student body it feels overly calculating to debate the money spent per student on
622idea versus other programming and extracurricular activities although I know that's where this discussion will head to some extent but I hope the message has come across loud and clear that the less than 0 4% of the budget that is spent on this program punches well above its weight class I strongly urge the board to reconsider the proposed cuts and restore funding to the IDE thank you Mr Rainey we appreciate your time user expand idea Phil witch please note that you have been unmuted and recognized please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to speak thank you can you hear me we can hi Terence hi my name is Terence filt I'm at 97 fit um I'm I'm gonna make four points uh really quickly right
623at the beginning and then just expand on them so number one point number one one people make choices when they come to this town and point number two aggregate choices parents are frozen affect the desirability of our town number three we need to focus on decision this decision and ask is this making our town more attractive or less attractive and number four my I think we should be talking about expanding this program and making it the best in Connecticut rather than talk than deleting it so number one those Point points in turn people make choices we made a choice when we we came to this town and part of our choice was school district and part of our choice was the headlines that that it had this program and I don't think it's unreasonable that
624that Sim similarly situated um people and parents will be looking at our website and we're in a very data driven economy a data driven environment um this is this is an an attraction for this town um if we then take Point number two aggregate choices affect desirability um it's if if this is another data point that and another headline that Daran is cutting and this is no longer part of The Suite of our offering it is going to not today or tomorrow but it could have an effect on our property values and property values have a knock on effect on property taxes property taxes have an effect on on Town revenue is this this doesn't seem to be heading in the right direction point three less or more attractive is this does this make this
625town less attractive or more attractive to this decision to cut a program and we have one one child in the program she she likes it very much and I would humbly submit this makes it this town more attractive uh to have this program now point four we shouldn't be talking about cutting this we should be talking about approving it and making it the best in Connecticut if not the best page there are highly motivated parents all across Connecticut and all across the Northeast we want to make Daran the destination for these kinds of people not generating a heav headline that we're cutting this um so those are my four points I I ask that you can reconsider this decision we can find a way to make this happen we've got a lot of smart people
626on the board and and I hope we can reconsider this decision and uh uh not cut expand thank you thank you Mr Martin hutter you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to 3 minutes to comment thank you hello my name is Martin hutter I'm from 25 Outlook drive thank you to the board for your time and for this opportunity to provide a comment um I'd like to also comment on the proposed elimination of the idea program in its current form a decision that I believe carries significant consequences for the students in the idea program and for the broader Daran school system you have heard the stories from families for whom classroom education did not meet their needs and children that have
627thrived thanks to idea these stories are powerful and important we have our own version but like um the previous speaker I'd like to urge the board to consider all second order consequences of cutting the program for example did you get a good understanding from Dr ad of how cutting idea would impact the district's reputation and did you get a good understanding of the impact of these decisions on measurable outcomes such such as SAT scores and college placements stats that I heard you mention earlier many families with children and the idea program already on the edge the classroom education isn't serving their needs should I put my kid into another school can I supplement my family has been wrestling with those questions and I'm sure you know families who have decided to take their kids out
628of their in public schools for those reasons cutting idea will push more families out of the system and with it high scores in children that contribute to an environment of academic Excellence those are hard decisions for to make for families with kids currently in the system I think the greater risk lies in losing new families will families with talented kids and high academic aspirations op for towns like new Canan or Westport where gifted programs remain intact you can't make a decision without understanding these Dynamics and some harm has already been done today's headline in Darren times there in superintendent proposed school budget cuts gifted program sends a signal to current and prospective family finally I encourage the board to evaluate why this specific proposal is on the table in the first place proposal that's not
629well fleshed out not evidence-based not in line with the values of our community and apparently not well triangulated with you often the answer to these things is Lov of work by people who are paid to do better there would also suggest to the board to remain Vigilant against more ideologically motivated decisions to dismantle programs that support meritocracy and academic Excellence I'll trust that you weigh this this feedback and make a decision that reflects the value and priorities of our town thank you thank you Mr Andrew singer you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment hi uh my name is Andrew singer I'm at 25 Bailey Avenue our son James ner singer is a participant in the idea
630program and it has been absolutely amazing for him we would be completely devastated if it were uh taken away he's extremely nervous right now uh he loves it he talks about it every week we love meeting with the instructors and learning that they'll be him with him for years they can watch him grow over the years that's such a rare case uh you don't get that with a typical Elementary School teacher because you go to the next class and then you never see the teacher again but this is somebody who can really see them grow and develop and know what their needs are because they've known them for so many years uh a little personal story once he had a medical issue I had to take him to Daran Pediatrics and so I had to
631pull him from school because that was the only time they were available and I accidentally did it uh he was in the idea class uh and he burst into tears he said no don't take me out this is my favorite class in all of school and it was around 2 o'clock and school gets out at three and he said can we please have this be a very quick doctor appointment so can you please rush me back to school so at 2:45 uh when the appointment was done I took them back to school and everybody at school is like why are you taking your kid back to school there's only 30 minutes left he said I just want to catch the rest of the idea class I don't want to miss any of it and you
632know I I realize you know how important it is to him it's it's just you know for me myself when I was in elementary school my school actually hired uh tutors to to give me extra experience with math and it was extremely beneficial I uh I still actually remain in touch with one of the tutors today uh where we're friends on Facebook and it's just been an amazing experience and it's really helped me with my whole career uh so I just I really hope that you don't cut this program I think it's just going to be an absolutely devastating thing for our son for all the families I think it's going to make families think about leaving and going elsewhere and it's going to make it difficult for families choosing which town to go in
633uh to know that this program doesn't exist they'll be more likely to choose programs that have other uh you know similar idea programs out there so I really hope that you choose to not cut it and that you choose to to let the idea program remains so that you know our son and possibly other children of ours later on uh will hopefully be able to take advantage thank you Miss Octavia moinsen yes C can we just ask people to say that they support what's been said already we're working on how many hours right now exactly yes um yes if if you are here to speak about something that's already been spoken about this evening we love to hear from all constituents um but it is okay to just say if you just support again idea
634or something else that's been said earlier that's an okay thing to do too um it's helpful for us to see names and faces but it has been quite a long day um I would like to say a few things um from a personal perspective um I'm Octavia Mulin sorry I live on 195 hollow tree Ridge Road um I was I just graduated this past May um from college I'm 22 um and I was in idea through all of my Darian public school education um I as I said I graduated and I now work with children with autism um my my opinion I agree with everyone else idea should not be cut um I've struggled with anxiety and ADHD since birth um and as a student who didn't see sorry okay as a student who didn't
635see the purpose or value of school and didn't know how to escape feeling different than others in academic classes idea gave me a space to grow and be myself I used to struggle to identify with the Daran identity and after graduating college and coming back home to rejoin the Darian Community the fact that idea is even being considered to be cut instead from any other area in the budget I cannot feel any other way than to continue to struggle to fit the Daren identity I also just want to quickly personally thank the idea kids who spoke and shared their thoughts and feelings and I want to apologize to them that this is happening because I could not imagine the impact it would have on me if the highlight of my school day my week and
636my year was taken away Mr Kyle Masters you've been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you'll have up to three minutes to comment yes uh good good evening everybody thank you for uh all the efforts and time uh in putting that together this budget and presenting it I want to say that I support all the uh uh people families and students uh both current and former that support the idea program uh I did want to ask there was a uh potential to have a motion to go ahead and table it and uh have the conversation or the vote on idea tonight and there was a discussion uh by Jill to uh potentially uh talk about a crosswalk prior to the next meeting I would like to
637have a little bit more understanding of what that crosswalk was is and where we can find more information on it because we're trying to get an understanding of how uh this budget was presented what was discussed what was thought um so that we can uh adequately uh Pro you know uh provide commentary or questions uh as we evaluate uh the options that may be presented before us for our children Mr Masters the board has the same questions that's why we've asked for a crosswalk and so that information will be presented at the um January 14th meeting so so can you just provide the timeline if if you we're not going to get that information until the 14th meeting you will the information public information is or information excuse me board materials are published on our
638website at 3 pm on Monday the day before the meeting so that'll be 3m. Monday the 13th it'll be on our website thank you uh one last question so it's presented the 13th discussed at the 14th and the timeline for uh voting would be when budget yeah so there's our our traditionally we vote on the budget on February 11th so um that there what was described tonight is untraditional we're trying we're working our way through this process um so I would just recommend you on the 13th if you'd like to see the materials on the 14th please watch our meeting and that would be the best way to follow the ation yeah thanks everyone Nico Johnston you've been unmuted and recognized please state your name and address for the record um please note that you'll
639only have three minutes to comment hello Daran B ofed thank you all for being here I just wanted to say there's been a lot of like sad news recently and I just wanted to say I love you all I've had the pleasure of shaking Dr Edley's hand and would like to recognize how much of an honor that is to me and how much I respect you all before I start but I also would like to say about a couple positive things about the idea program that I have personally experienced both of my teachers in the past Mrs Mata and uh Martin have been very important people in my life and have really uh shaped who I've become a lot of the curriculum in the idea program a lot of short stories based around things like
640time travel and space travel and just general philosophy are things I always sought after through my teachers because sometimes I wasn't fully uh I feel like not everything I learned was fully enriching and then when I entered high school and found a lot of teachers I uh connected with a lot more I realized that Miss Martin and MATA in my earlier years were people who I could connect with a lot more just like I can in high school now and how important they were in my life I hope you all have a great night and didn't want to keep you too long but that's what I have to say thank you so much Amal doid you've been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and please note that you'll have
641up to three minutes to comment yeah thank you thank you for the time this is amold do uh I live on 19 Maple Street uh uh so quickly right I have uh my elder daughter is in fifth grade in hindley she just loves the idea program right and and again I mean I I'll not repeat I think somebody said you know it's it's been a long day don't repeat what everyone has said uh but I think to make the point right it's important to understand that you know in the first place this should not be not be on the cutting list right I mean I think you know you you you don't take out you know the best parts of your uh you know education system uh and and and and and keep keep you
642know uh and and keep yourself in the in the Reckoning in the sense that you know be the top top schooling District uh you know uh not just in the Fairfield County but in the state as well as in the country right so I think uh you know the thought has to be given uh to why we had this program for last 50 years and why suddenly you know we are even thinking about you know cutting it right right I think uh doesn't make sense somebody really pointed out uh you know well earlier saying that uh you know this should not be even on the list right of discussion I mean uh you know don't don't don't uh you know uh how do I say it right I mean don't uh impact the best and
643the brightest uh in your education system by removing this program uh so I would again I appreciate uh all the time that has been spent by the board here uh but I would also request uh that you know to keep the brightest the best in the the brightest in the district you know please keep this program uh you know funded uh for for years to come and even expand it as someone else said earlier thank you for your time thank you Mr Eli Johnston please note that you've been unrecognized or been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you'll have up to three minutes to comment hi my name is Eli Johnston 26 Outlook Drive uh I am a sixth grader at MMS and believe that cutting
644idea will be extremely detrimental um I just really want to talk about the three lovely individuals that would lose their jobs due to this move um I've been taught fabulous lessons from all three of them even miss Aaron who I'm yet to have has taught me amazing things um I would not be the same without them and I think that cutting idea would be frankly immature and incompetent thank you thank you we have no further raised hands at this time okay all right without I'll thank everyone for their time today I'll take a motion to adjourn