001special meeting of the Board of Education to order the next regular Board of Education will be held on Saturday January 4th at 8:30 a.m. in the board meeting room tonight we begin the board of education's review of our District budget for the upcoming fiscal year we'll first hear from Dr adley and his staff on their priorities and then we as a board review the budget for overall size alignment with our priorities Etc ultimately the Board of Education will make decisions about whether the proposed budget structure should stay as is as as proposed or be changed tonight is a brief introduction to the budget Saturday's all day meeting will be a Fuller and much longer discussion of all of the contents since the summer we have collectively explored our academic priorities through the Strategic plan and
002our new initiatives outlined we provided guidance to the superintendent in November considering the academic priorities our financial forecasts our Capital plan and the board of finances tax strategy while our enrollment remains relatively stable our costs continue to rise some increases are beyond our control such as health insurance thirdparty salary adjustments and rising out of District tuition costs some increases such as teacher and administrative salary structures are related to decisions we as a board have made in the past we've also invested significantly in our students and in recent years including increased technology purchases add conditions of critical Personnel like psychologists security officers and mental health professionals as well as by bolstering administrative support as we move through this process we must engage in open and honest dialogue we must ask the difficult questions what are our
003true priorities how can we maximize the impact of every dollar spent how can we ensure that our budget aligns with our strategic goals and supports the long-term success of all of our students as we do this it's crucial to remember that education is a people business our budget decisions directly impact the lives of our students teachers and staff it's about how our students learn how we support our Educators and how we deliver essential services to everyone recognizing that 82% of our fiscal year 26 budget is dedicated to personnel costs salaries and benefits highlights the human element at the core of our financial decisions let us approach this budget process with a clear focus on our shared values student needs and the long-term sustainability of our district the board values the input of our community members
004public comment periods are typically held before and after each board meeting though tonight and Saturday they the specific public comment period will occur at the end of the meeting of note on Saturday we will continue our practice of receiving specific questions after each RC a formal public hearing will be held on the evening of February 4th this dedicated hearing will provide a focused opportunity for the public to express their views on how the proposed budget aligns with our community's educational priorities we urge people to attend and share their perspectives with the board recognizing that not everyone enjoys public speaking we're also always available by email and members of the public at all are certainly welcome to call us with questions or concerns thank you all and I'll turn it to you Alan good evening everybody
005and um happy New Year first of all to everyone I hope trust you enjoyed the holiday period and uh the budget season uh is upon us uh to members of the administration here uh welcome public officials here here thank you for being here uh members of the public our daa uh president I appreciate everyone uh being present this evening uh I have to say that uh any sort of budget process and budget development and presentation is also a celebration so I sit before you prly uh representing our Administration our staff our cabinet our our teachers uh our support staff most importantly our children um and our community members and I'm proudly and and with excitement present uh while challenging uh the the the budget this evening a special thank you to the members of my
006cabinet to Mr R as the Director of Finance to uh Sheila his assistant uh to Cassie and M my assistant uh for all their efforts and administration uh department insur and so on who helped uh in the process of putting this together because obviously it's a team effort um uh with that uh we will move through the budget for the members of the public C here or even for some of the administration here uh the board just received their presentation this evening so the documents that they have is literally this document uh it is live online right now on the website for you if you'd like to follow along but you can certainly follow along here and uh you know where to access uh the document uh anything that we do is Guided by the
007vision and Mission uh of the District of preparing our students to thrive in the changing world tomorrow uh and certainly around Daran is changing and the budget encompass all the change and excitement of the change uh that surrounds the time that is actually happening in the time uh the this particular budget uh addresses sort of three themes I would say uh investing in the core educational experiences and I would say that those core educational experiences are the learning experiences and support the learning needs of all our students uh we are also talking about supporting our students all our students through professional uh learning learn for our teachers uh I would suggest that the professional learning of teachers goes hand in hand uh with student learning and it also provides sustainability as we move forward um
008and realizes some efficiency along the way uh needless to say it also addresses a board of education's guideline to the superintendent uh so I bring a budget before you that I think will is representative of request and the guidance that the Board of Education uh has provided me so investing in the core educational actions um this is the the initiatives uh the efficiencies or anything else that's in here is aligned to the Strategic plan uh the district goals when I say District goals be mean both District goals and the Board of Education goals it's responsive to the state legislation in particular I will be redundant through this a we bit um but uh just to get the themes on the table K to3 reading the play based learning and the restorative practices that are required
009by this uh State legislation it also provides uh for for core programming it allocates resources to those core programs uh everything from Early Childhood uh to teacher retention uh and recruitment efforts we've tried to realize uh some sustainability and projected some sustainability uh for the future but also realize efficiencies uh as we've moved through the process we have to be responsive to Grants um that have collapsed and that lacked lack of funding that goes into the uper budget uh health insurance increase that has is something that we've had to deal with now for several years and um uh high costs of uh outplacement costs for special education out placement costs we've also this this budget does a bit of program review and redesign in particular uh the ID gifted program uh Power professionals uh and
010security so it either redesigns those removes them or modifies them and you'll see just as I'll speak to those as we go through it's responsive to the uh adjustments and enrollment and Staffing it does some deferrals both in technology area from wireless access to laptops uh to desktops at the Middle School uh it also um defers the some of the athletic equipment there's long-term Investments that we're making as a facility study although modified from what the board uh was monitoring throughout the year instead of three schools that it it suggest we do uh one of the schools I'll speak to that uh our ear learning program U any investment in ELP is an investment in the future and that going to five five days is an indication of that uh clearly we were doing uh
011some insourcing and Outsourcing so the budget does that um it provides a an O OT for ELP and a behavioral certified Behavioral Analyst uh that we will be putting in the budget and I'll explain a we bit about that as I move forward and it also supports that teacher professional learning which is an investment in our for all student so we also have some Investments supporting uh students and teachers play based learning the middle school team talk uh Middle School theater there's different stiping to involve lots more students in the actual Middle School theater and new courses um at at DH uh DHS I won't go through all of these but at the end of the presentation there's a we bit alignment to what is in the budget to each of these uh particular uh
012goals in the Strategic plan and I want to thank the board because the board monitors this there's accountability for these it's a real life document um and so the budget is in align with those also so this is just a week bit the a 10e operating history and sort of budgets as we move forward uh the average budget over the last 10 years has been about 2.7 and and it is true that the last two years here have been uh more challenging with with higher budgets in the fourth range uh just a budgets for the surrounding districts are slowly coming out um more word of mouth than actually uh presentations being done ours is one of the earlier ones Wilton's at 4 Westbard this is for e e e okay I think we're live again
013uh thank you so this chart shows uh what what our net uh cost per uh expenditure per pupil so essentially in rough terms Air cost per pupil expenditure is can you okay with this you're since you're here like to see that oh there we go uh so we're basically what this shows is we're basically in literally in the median right um literally the average median uh District in terms of cost for for expenditures if you look at Wilton easn uh new Canan and Redfield what does that mean it means if if they had our if they had our enrollment that's how much that's how much last they will be spend on education this year Westport Weston reading region 9 with our with our cost per pupil or sorry with their cost per pupil and our
014enrollment then you'd be spending that much more on uh the education for the school system that that okay so it basically giv you that we are in the median range of uh expenditures and I'm with your understanding I'm just going to ignore this thing that's up above there yeah is that okay I think I would probably have to proceed try to restart is it being recorded still being record we can hear you fine and YouTube uh both YouTube and zoom are bad both YouTube and zoom are bad correct so YouTube passes through so Zoom is Youtube it'll take me another three minutes to reou the entire system rather than okay go ahead and want recess or uh sure I'll take a motion to recess that's John seconded by Sarah all those in favor that's un
015e e e always eager over there as soon as Jeff gives me the all right I'll take a motion to reconvene that is John seconded by Joanna all those in favor that's unanimous thank you okay Alan well I started the meeting by saying that U budgets are also a time to celebrate and so you'll forgive me for I just recognize uh the efforts of our staff and uh the accomplishments of our students and collaboration and support with our community uh from our our ELP kids uh right through our seniors and to to those who stay with us through 21 uh there's a this is a premier school system uh with high academic Excellence uh we we know that um and this is a time also to be very proud of that from the high school
016it's been recognized numerous times in the high school US News and World Report most recently as the second best high school although we don't always play a lot into this but then again it's okay just to recognize it um and also the middle school is is number six in the in the state the B uh literacy seal um the number of students who have achieved that has grown significantly over the last couple of years and of course we've been been recognized numerous times by the N Foundation for a community for bass music um from our state championship kids uh to our Scholars who go to the finest schools across the country um and to those who go on and live Noble uh lives as as Citizens to our young people who uh pull the curtains
017down and um for uh when you go to some of these Music Awards uh it's just an unbelievable accomplishment uh we have programs from National Merit Scholars to programs that serve all our kids unified program strong unified programs um uh so we we serve all our kids and and you can see that the um the drama one um is there and sign up for L Miz which is in the spring uh this particular year but congratulations to everybody who makes those recognition makes those realizations for children uh possible um this chart here is just just a week um Snapchat in time that's all this ISS um one of the things you can compare is really at the end of the educational experience in Daran how do we send our kids out so to speak um
018one common assessment uh to use is the SAT because it's the one that's given to students all across uh Connecticut um you can't really compare uh a AP scores you can but but there's different AP scores you're going to be comparing uh this is AD minister to all all students um in grade 11 and what this shows you is all the districts in Connecticut uh where the blue dot is the cross that is Daran and that shows you essentially the cost per pupil that we're spending versus the actual metric that the kids score in the achievement that that they make combined score on the SAT and so essentially what are you looking for well essentially are you're looking for like how many districts are really realizing that level of performance with less money essentially not
019going crazy about it but just a we uh and you can see that there's one to our left and uh that is Wilton and there's one to our right that's higher um and but that's costing more money and I believe that is Westport um but so it just gives you a sense that for the want of a better term you're getting a good return on our educational investment here in our community as we turn to enrollment and some of the variables uh uh with the budget here I will say that um uh for enrollment and class size which which accompanies this uh we have not touched class size in this particular budget presentation uh for next year's enrollment is reduced by two students and it slowly increases over um the next couple of years the
020next 5 years by 93 which is really what it has what basically um reduced by that same amount the number over the last five or six years also and you can see that the changes uh are really at the high at the um secondary level um for next year primarily it's there's really not much change at the elementary level and then when you go down for the next five years the growth really Ste growth really is at um at the uh K to to five uh range uh there would be no changes in class sizes I'll just double this up at the uh at the middle school or uh the actual uh Elementary School these are the class sizes for for the elementary schools uh We've reduced one uh overall section uh so last year
021we were at 117 sections this year uh we are at one uh 16 section so uh there's a reduction of one section U at the elementary uh at the elementary schools there's a reduction of uh plus one at Henley minus one at homes and uh minus one uh at ARX Ridge we have a couple of sections down below um Henley at first grade uh you've got Homes at fourth grade and oxridge at fifth grade uh just a risk of um tipping U but that's no different than any other particular year and we would come back and reassess those uh in the actual uh summer as we come down down the stretch so to speak so this is a real summary just a summary of the budget uh so we pick up the budget uh from
022from 25 uh the core pieces of the budget are benefits Health uh Healthcare the major ones Collective of bargaining and out of District uation uh the growth primarily is alleged some of the legislation um that the board has been following along K3 liter uh literacy uh there are no FTE uh in those growth numbers and so we have to find uh from the reductions and efficiency we have to find $2.7 million to get down to 4 uh 39 uh if you asked why did you get down to 4.39 uh I have to put put the budget somewhere where I think it'll be reasonable for the board uh to to respond to and for the uh Community to support for the Board of Education to support I will say on this page too there are a
023few things in the budget as to go forward here we've had to make some difficult decisions but that doesn't mean to say we don't move the district forward and some ways so there are some modest uh increments of change here and proposed change uh but that is not mutually exclusive from well if you had to get down that much you shouldn't be spending anything or you shouldn't be doing I just don't think that those are contiguous uh ideas so uh very briefly and before I get into some of the detail of it uh this is the core expenditures uh you can you can notice the salaries and the benefits as the board board CH rightly said this is it constitutes 82% of the total budget special education tuition special education uh services and esy uh
024non-personnel contracts that's fit buses and so on and and other contracts in The District Maintenance uh exess cost Revenue uh the utilities is mainly contributable uh to electric bills we have some uh Grant compression from loss of funds from title one uh when also uh the ARP mental health uh that supports the mental health is reduced by a third and then enrollment which really the enrollment involves one less section of Elementary that I just described and then we have a0 six at the high school that we have reduced the uh due to enrollment some of these ideas I'll I'll play out a little bit uh so these are the growth expenditures the K to3 reading the uniform referrals uh deferrals this is from last year's cut you remember we cut and reduced uniforms last year
025well we have to do those ones this year uh professional learning for staff uh so that's comprised of uh two figures 48 basically uh 48,000 uh for the busing and 48,000 of loss of revenue for breakfasts uh for the plcs and I'll talk again about that middle school facility study that that is in the budget but it's obviously not token um that's not Al that's not involved in it or the high school te talking the middle school I'm pleased to say that we got notice that we will be the recipient of a $50,000 Grant from the Community Fund so we thank them uh for the generosity uh that would complete and complement the 50,000 that's proposed here in the budget play based learning website and board talks these are these are topics that the board
026of education has talked the whole way through uh so they these would be familiar to the board members but these are improvements in in the website and accessibility to materials for for Board of Education board ducks uh psychology interns we have two already this continues it and we will have another two uh interns edu planet is accessibility not just for teachers but it is uh but also accessibility for our community members if you want to follow along on where are we with any particular uh curriculum uh you'll be able to go on there and see uh the main learning objectives and assessments and so on for um uh any particular discipline and Aspen training uh this is allows us to rule forward Aspen and it's sort of a new format um we'll try that and
027be supported uh with professional learning around it and uh we will see how that uh addresses the issue of just more user friendly uh student portal so in in that growth I'm just going to point to pick out just sort of two things for the moment right um these are the imly the big thing right so play based learning K to3 literacy and restorative practices uh off that 263 240 of it um is really the literacy so um and the rest of it then is is divided between playbase learning for resources primarily and restorative practices uh for resources and curriculum writing uh the other one is Prof for professional learning and plcs you uh for the board members they will they will note that uh the proposal that they last saw was for 219,000 this
028is reduced to 9648 which uh a loss of food revenue and 48 for the busing uh we also reduced the number of professional Learning Community uh uh times at the high school um we had uh proposed to go uh to 18 I was five and we instead just added uh three in consultation with the High School administration so we've added three late late arrivals of the we currently have 10 that would take the 13th and we've added uh the five early release days uh I would say that this is something that impacts all teachers for all students uh for and for I would say is a a relatively low investment if I take away the revenue for breakfast uh it's costing 48,000 that would be a long-standing thing here for years to come uh and
029supporting your our staff it's also recommendation and responsive to the Tri State Consortium the NC accreditation visit um it supports uh Recruitment and Retention when I sit and talk to people one of the things they talk about is professional learning um if you tell them that you they have adequate time to meet and do the work uh that is a big recruitment uh advantage and retention um incentive so it increases uh teachers voice and professional learning for everyone and it Fosters a continuous learning and growth environment literally I just I just sum it up as as Roland bar did there schools must be places where teachers learn hand inand with students students and um to quote someone else local official um this would set us apart this would then again it's it's you have to
030lead the way and that we have lead the way in many things and this would be another thing uh that we would lead the way in in terms of providing our our teachers with the adequate time they need to do the work around student learning these are the efficiencies um I'll talk to them briefly then I'll cut on two efficiencies uh to talk about elementary instruction Pate professionals this um essentially eliminates all 15 instructional Pate professionals at the elementary school uh I'll talk about it on the slide I have a slide for it and there's it says student interns the student interns are simply there to do the duties that the P professionals would ordinarily uh have to to cover the Ida tal and gifted uh program uh we will be serving our students in
031a different capacity again I have a separate slide for that so I'll go into that in a be bit more depth too but the 469 represents uh the 3.3 FTE teachers uh who provide uh the programing at the moment for our students the completion of the four to five classes at the Middle School uh that was a contractual matter and um we're assuming uh two teachers that we could realize two teachers they they have to happen at the secondary secondary level through attration we're anticipating that that would be the case if it's not the case uh we would be in deficit of 254 but it's not uh that's not unusual for us to predict uh something like that and incorporate it into the Budget esy Transportation that is a savings um that has been realized
032through the actual new transportation system that we have uh only the fact that it's just started and for the summer uh so this this time we can real realize it in this upcoming budget for next summer um and that's through the new Transportation vehicles that we purchased for spical education to technology to referrals uh you'll hear a little bit more about that tomorrow um or sorry on Saturday but uh for the most part that is Middle uh Administration laptops Middle School desktops uh wireless access um uh nursing Services uh this is at the middle school it's a reduction of one uh nurse at the middle school primarily um in fact it's basing on student needs that is what it is so we we look at not only enrollment but we also look at services that
033are being provided to students um and we look at the services that are provided uh to our students uh prek through 12 uh regarding nursing Services uh we feel comfortable in reducing this given this the needs that uh will be in play for next year we'll be insourcing some special education Staffing uh we have um so the 113 is one and a behavioral consult consultant analysis um analyst sorry um we will be eliminating one bcaba and hiring a bcba uh behavioral consultant analysis the only difference between the a is one's an assistant one's not um nonc Sports uh yes this is a contribution to uh Athletics essentially that would round out to be about $340 uh dollar per uh player per sport the sports that are impacted are essentially things like rugby Sal in ski
034and a squash uh rental fees is on top of that uh so basically using round numbers that that number actually would be doubled we've done a security reorganization um in uh to realize efficiency so we'll be reducing One Security uh Officer school security officer uh that is the floater and uh we'll be uh re reassigning the director of uh school security to a halftime position so the director of school security will be halftime director of school security and halftime uh school security officer floater uh as opposed to having a school security officer and a full-time um director of security it's important that I'll say here right now it's important that we H maintain it in my opinion it's important that we maintain leadership in that particular area uh for the oversight of the work that
035that's done uh done there I'm comfortable enough making it now because I think we've made some inroads and certainly made significant improvements uh but we still need some uh Monitor and assistance um particularly given the nature of uh the work must be honest they they carry they carry uh in school so it's important that we have oversight of that uh the 5D uh the 5 day El uh so that's the uh the difference in Revenue athletic uniform deferrals so these are just different these are just different sports for different um uh uniformer associated with a different sport the net revenue and substitutes and that these are just this this is just a catch all is you're wondering why is it in here but it's it's when you put all a number of hundred of line
036items together this is this is kind of the catchall for all which which is not much and you'll notice on Saturday as the administration comes up to the podium and talks about what what's in the budget there's not much else in the budget other than what you're seeing here tonight um and a lot of what people have asked for uh it really does need the optic of the board level at some point in many ways um just to try and keep this budget at a reasonable number so the ID gifted program here U we um we I spoke about and um the interesting Dimensions that ex extand abilities um that's the name of our our program has been in place for probably over 50 years or thereabouts uh has about 237 students we have 3.3
037FTE who are involved in it you can there's more detail in the budget book but you can see you can see up there that um work rade we're talking about there are other ways of delivering this this uh to students uh through different differentiated practices in the classroom uh curriculum uh curriculum opportunities clubs extended enrichment opportunities uh and you can build our teacher capacity through professional learning and and their plc's to to support the work it's not ideal right in the sense of it's a different way of doing something uh given the challenge that we have before us um but our responsibility is to meet the needs of all our kids in the classroom without necessarily being pulled out um and that's what we'll do u under this particular program or variation of it the
038instructural P professionals there are three p professionals per Elementary School uh they primarily not exclusively but primarily work in in kindergarten and grade one classrooms assisting the teachers they also assist with supervision recess U before school after school lunchtime they and they provide uh teacher coverage and I will say not exclusively but it is a growing issue in dominantly they're now been used to cover classes and uh that's getting away from the the role that they ordinarily uh are used for and should be used for it's just a reality that we have that very very respectfully that's in a very expensive model for doing substitute teacher coverage and that's it's not exclusively what word it is but it but it's certainly is predominantly where it is um so that's one of the reasons here of
039uh um having this up for for discussion proposal uh the D the duties will be provided by two student interns that we feel that we will be able to place uh at each of the schools uh we've worked with the administration and we feel we can cover adequately those um those duties that ordinarily we've be covered by a an instructional Pate professional uh grenage and Ridgefield I think in our areas are probably the schools do not have uh Power professionals uh in place they they hire for supervision of of Duties um for the students so these are some of the increases um our teacher contracts at 4.29 for next year our administrators at 3% uh non-certified staff uh secretaries fire professionals nursing uh basically around two two and a half or two and 3/4 uh
040this the staff addition additions are the OT and the bcba that I spoke about the enrollment is at the ele one less at the elementary school and 6 at the high school uh the grant compression is the reduction in funds in Title One and the wellness Grant esy is for the extra days just according to the calendar the way it falls um other is just substitute curriculum development salary savings it's inter murals part-time custodial it's just a little bit of everything and the completion of four to five uh that's the teachers at the secondary level and some of the staff reductions that we're talking about which is the uh gifted teachers uh the bcaba and the power professionals uh that's comes to $1.3 million in reductions uh special education so here you can see this
041the total increase 1.4 in the budget this year for special education the predominant driver there being uh the cost of uh out placements uh and actually maybe not the number of PE of students you're being outplaced but really the actual cost of the out placement itself is is ranging from anywhere from 75 to close to $100,000 uh for placement so it's the cost that that's contributing towards us but that's a significant um that is a significant change and it has been over the last uh couple of years uh growing and escalating cost uh for us so that's the special education tuation the BC ba the OT that was added and the bcaba reduction and that gets you to $1.2 million uh this esy is not necessarily esy Transportation it's esy and Transportation uh so uh
042this is reflect growth in salaries uh the net uh and um the busing so it's total special education increases 1.13 access cost is 318,000 so uh that's at 70% if you remember this year we started off at 75% reim reimbursement rate and we went down to 70% so we have projected in the budget for uh 70 uh% reimbursement and brings us to the total increase of 1.4 Health benit we know uh we've gone from this year 13 to next year 11.9 this is a significant between health benefits and um uh health insurance itself it's 11.9 the new hires are the bcba and the OT I talked about the the position reductions are again the prior professionals uh the SP uh the um talented gifted teachers and the reductions and enrollment pension OPB uh we have
043an actuary who does this for us uh these are basically post employment benefits Medicare life insurance disability payroll taxes uh and a consent at 85 so that's three4 of a point the summary in general um if you want to know Personnel uh We've reduced uh 2.57 uh FTE and uh I can go through this but basically I've talked about the the top few are for the reductions in enrollment the wellness coordinator 33 that is the uh Grant compression um that is a well coordinator that was in the wellness Grant the wellness Grant not not being there not say not being there but a third of it goes away so a third of it we have to pay for in the operating budget the reductions minus 3 minus5 and minus one the nurse PR professionals and
044the uh gifted uh staff uh the occupational therapist that we're getting for ELP is added the bcba is added and the reduction of a a bcaba which is the behavioral assistant uh analyst the director of security goes to halftime the floating uh SSO uh goes to halftime instead of having two positions now there is only one and that will be done by the director of uh school security and that brings us to a net Staffing of reduction of 20.57% Ives astronomy cyber security American Sign Language excited to be able to offer those the board has approved those uh the wellness center coordinator I just said a wee B about that one so uh that's that's a third of the cost to the rest of them I have mentioned them in one shape or another um
045but they are aligned to the actual strategies in the uh strategic plan not included in the budget and the board has been following this for some time is a special education trans program uh that is a cost for next year of 288,000 um most of the stamps have been uh accomplished in this process if we wanted to to place uh and move forward with this for the most part we we certainly would have to go to pnz it would draw out a little bit that's fine um this program cost us a million plus over five years uh at this point if you're asking why is it not in uh we don't have agreement certainly doesn't agree with me that's okay um but just strong Advocate as am I but given the costs that we're facing
046given some of the decisions uh uh that are before us given the rise in cost for special education the number of students involved yes it would be great to have it for our for our students there there'll be three or four students next year three to five at the most um I just don't feel as if within this budget uh that I can present that uh at this point to actually include it uh the reduction in the original PLC proposal that uh that has been reduced the original proposal was uh 122 the facility study there we talked about $200,000 for the high school token and the Middle School uh this way we put the Middle School in uh it accomplishes it and uh it saves $1,000 $110,000 essentially um and then it will be in
047the base and moving forward for the other schools should the board want to continue to keep it in the base if we put the high school in place right now some of the capital projects uh thank you to the board members for your visitation lately uh recently to the high school and the various buildings that we having Renovations uh for the sake of the public here uh this evening you can see that we're doing some lightting fixtures resurfacing the black top at rightside the library area in the back of the athletic area uh The Green Roof uh uh waterproof in it and replacement uh some doors we have radio Replacements security enhancements at to Anique and some districtwide improvements in terms of upkeep with uh vehicles and uh this particular uh the window replacements in
048this particular room that is a quick walk through of uh the budget and how we got there the budget calendar moving forward is as you see it and uh as challenged as it was um I I still think that there's things in that moves us forward and there's going to be some uh discussions are going to be need to be had I'm sure around the table but thank you for the opportunity thank you to my staff and uh we look forward to continuing the discussion and I encourage this the public too to stay uh stay involved you Alan we don't typically have a discussion at this stage if there are any high level questions that board members have you're you're welcome to lob it but otherwise we'll have very detailed discussions on Saturday um in
049order to understand uh the nature of of the additions subtractions and some of the things that we've kept in uh as is um so with no high Lev questions I will open it to public comment good evening if anybody in person or online would like to participate in public comment please approach the podium or use the raised hand icon and wait to be recognized once you've been recognize please state your name and address for the record and note that you will have up to three minutes to comment Jeff can you check that um the zoom is muted I've heard it pop up a few times okay thank you Cass hi yeah I am trying to speak okay well just a minute please we're gonna um call on the people who are here in the room
050and then we'll go over to zoom um but in the meantime Cass and Jeff if you would just keep muted until we're ready for them thank you okay Barry go ahead please all right uh Barry pal let's start off by just putting one thing out there this is not a difficult budget year we are not a distress distress municipality we are not in an economic recession and this is a community that has gone through a prolonged period of economic prosperity and your schools are to paraphrase our first selectman the essence of what makes derenne amazing we've lost our way as a school district the budget unveiled tonight not only fails to make our students a top priority it actually puts their needs last the El elimination of instructional AIDS is Pennywise and pound foolish it
051it will result in an increase of students who need special education services and add costs to already one of our largest drivers of the budget it's the opposite of sustainability the elimination of gifted of the the gifted and talented program is a betrayal of Darian public of what Darian Public Schools represents and we should be embarrassed we put ourselves in a position to even entertain taking those opportun opportunities away from our kids we need leadership from the board our students deserve better this community deserves better thank you good evening and thank you to the board and Dr adley for this opportunity to speak my name is Caroline comfort and I'm my address is 48 neoton Avenue I'm here today as a member of the Executive Board of the PTO group for the gifted students daeg
052representing our Collective support for the idea program as a former middle school teacher in the district and as a concerned parent of a gifted child who has thrived in a school as a direct result of the idea program our request to the board is that you consider removing moving the idea program from the cut list and consider alternatives and Creative Solutions before taking away this deeply valued program as I read through the Strategic plan and pulled some quotes from the DPS website I couldn't help but make the connection that the goals of the idea program directly support the Strategic plan and the vision of The Graduate many people don't fully understand or know what the idea program offers to gifted students so that we ask that you do a little homework and have all the
053data necessary to make an informed decision as unfortunately we find ourselves in a position to make programmatic changes or Cuts based on budgetary constraints rather than on the merits of the program I will keep tonight short so as um as there is more to come but I share this quote from the Darian Public Schools website Darian Public Schools also recognizes that gifted students require specialized instruction due to their High intellectual ability and ceptional demonstration of the following traits original or Divergent thinking curiosity abstract reasoning ability passion for Learning and creativity the idea program offers distinct opportunities for students based on their unique learning pathways through rigorous enriching dis interdisciplinary programming through the domains of English language arts and Mathematics understanding that high achieving students are different than stud students who are gifted and understanding all
054of the obligations that general education um classroom teachers have we are deeply concerned that the needs of gifted students will not be met if the program is cut as listed on the proposed budget and students may not fulfill their potential as suggested in the vision of The Graduate we know these decisions are not easy ones and we look forward to hearing your discussion as the process unfolds thank you very much for all you do and will continue to do to support the needs of all students in Daran thank you anyone else in person okay the first person that is recognized is Miss Elena Bueno you can unmute yourself and you are recognized please state your name and address for the record um uh Lucena Bueno 123 ho Street um good evening I am really particularly
055concerned that some members of the board don't understand inflation when inflation goes down it doesn't mean prices went down but rather it means prices went up at a lower rate so when inflation goes down from 4% to 3% in both cases prices went up they just went up 3% instead of 4% according to the CPI inflation calculator the government the legal um inflation measurement today we would need $187 million to buy what we bought with $100 million in the year 2000 so the budget in 2000 was approximately 100 million1 we would need over $88 million budget this year to buy the same we bought in 2000 we need to start discussing the budget in real prices not nominal that is what you do in an inflationary environment we have a big hole in the bu
056and we are destroying the town going forward even if we believe the feds projection of inflation for the next five years is 3% annually let's assume that is it if we accept the 4.3% increase of this budget it means a 1.3% increase in real terms that is a million and a half dollars that we are increasing the budget by is that what we want because $ 1.5 million dollar doesn't do anything that is not enough for anything and that is why we continue cutting teachers cutting programs and sacrificing the school for the capricious Board of Finance this is the time the board of education has to stand for the schools this is your responsibility your legal responsibility the state law requires the Board of Education stands for the schools not a not faults to the
057board of Finance I mean this is so outrageous I mean Connecticut and the Northeast have higher inflation than the rest of the country so we are talking about like an insane situation if we don't learn and thank you so much Miss appreciate your time is there anyone else Cass yes Mr Fullington you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and please note you'll have up to three minutes to comment wow that's a tough act to follow um so uh Dr adley uh members of the board thank you very much for your time Kevin Fullington 390 West Avenue um so I just wanted to share an anecdote um my daughter um who was in idea in the third grade um towards the end of that year I said to
058her how how was your year this year I was okay she said I said well why just okay and she said well um you know I I didn't really learn that much I'm like well tell me one thing you learned and she goes honestly I didn't learn anything and I said well did you tell that to your teacher and she goes no I I just pretended like I didn't already know it it and just went along and she said the only place I learned anything was in idea um and that's not the teachers fault the teachers do great jobs but the reality of it is with 20 students in a class as we all know they're focusing on the struggling children and the children in the middle to make sure everybody's getting an adequate education
059and the children who are gifted and talented really are on an island a little bit um and idea is a Lifeline an idea as it is is insufficient and the idea that we're going to take an insufficient program that is less than 410 of the budget and completely eliminated is really unfortunate um and the reality is this isn't just about those 237 children who are in the program or the future children who will be in the program it's really about the message that this is sending that our district is not committed to our best they're not we're not committed to the gifted and talented students Among Us and if the idea is as I heard oh well we're going to expand professional training and the in the teachers who are now struggling to get everybody
060educated are going to now spend more time on gifted and talented I think we all know that's paricle and if we're honest with ourselves what this would do is eliminate any support for our gifted and talented students and I heard the rationale was well we need to focus on the um core education for all students well we all know there's millions of dollars spent in the budget for specific groups that aren't all student wide the you know the football program for example has 127 students that are participate in that it gets hundreds of thousands of dollars there's no thought or mention of cutting that so I just think we need to take a broader view here and understand that cutting 39% of the budget it um and doing so you eliminate all support for gifted
061and talented is a Fool's errand and it no disrespect meant at all and we really should rethink this and get our priorities uh better aligned and appreciate your time and look forward to continuing this conversation thank you Miss Genie ball you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and please note you have up to 3 minutes to speak you might have to unmute yourself miss ball hello hello can you hear me yes hi I am Genie ball I live at 284 West Avenue and I appreciate the time that you've given me to comment I just wanted to Echo some of Mr Fullerton's comments um my family and I moved to darianne to give our children the best education possible as I think me many families moved here for
062that reason uh my daughter is in the idea program at Holmes Elementary School and before she was in the idea program she struggled immensely with boredom and lack of being challenged and was having a lot of problems um in her with her coursework and feeling dejected the idea program gave her the opportunity to start to be challenged and like Mr Fullerton said it it scratches the service surface of her needs but it's something and at least she was recognized um and given the opportunity to be challenged by Educators who understood where she was at um it's surprising to me that one of the big points of this budget is spent in special education out placements I wonder if the idea program is eliminated if my child will qual qualify for such an outplacement because her
063needs will not be met academically if the idea program is demolished I also wonder if all of these um idea program faculty is being eliminated who will provide the new educational opportunities for the students in our district to meet their needs um like Mr Fullerton said is the responsibility going to be all on the teachers because if that's the case I just don't see how that's going to be possible um I'm really disappointed and disheartened by this move and I hope that the board will consider changing their decision thank you Miss Julia schaer you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you'll have up to three minutes to comment my name is Julia schaer I live at 741 Hollow Tree Ridge Road I in strong
064opposition to the proposed budget cuts that would result in the elimination of the idea gifted program within our school district I feel that this decision is both shortsighted and detrimental to the future of our students and the overall quality of Education in our community the idea program provides essential resources and opportunities for students who require specialized instruction that challenge and stimulate their intellectual growth that's not provided in the day-to-day classroom environment removing this program not only undermines their potential but also sends a message that excellence and high achievement are not valued in our school district furthermore the idea program does more than just serve the needs of advanced students it Fosters an environment of academic rigor and inspires other students to strive for higher levels of achievement the presence of a robust gifted program elevates
065the entire educational experience for our district and contributes to a culture of Excellence if any thing we should be allocating more funds to expand the idea offerings and instruction available if making this cut the board would be going against the state district values of Excellence which is defined as delivering the highest quality of education for each student to reach their individual potential as well as the value of diversity inclusion is stated is creating a community that welcomes and Embraces the full range of human differences I urge you to consider this decision and explore alternative solutions to address budgetary constraints cutting the idea program is not the answer and we have to focus on the needs of all students to ensure that we're nurturing the talents and abilities of every child by doing so we would
066be investing in the future success of our community thank you thank you user ID a DHS alumna you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you'll have up to three minutes to comment hi I'm Christina Mulin I'm at 195 hollow tree Ridge Road um thank you all um for this meeting and thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak on this briefly I'm an alumni of the idea program um and I'm a current third-year medical student and graduate of DHS in 2017 um we've heard from a lot of great parents today um worried about their gifted children and I think I give a really important different perspective as an alumni of this program myself in the same way that I would advocate for students
067with disabilities to have their own resources set set aside to help them meet their full potential I'm advocating for the idea program to not be cut Advanced Learners need to have their own tailored opportunities to hone their critical thinking and problem solving abilities in a public school system there are a few other opportunities for gifted students to have access to more challeng material where their creativity and outside of the box thinking can be C celebrated I think the suggestion of trying to mimic this opportunity um in the classroom environment would be ineffectual for me personally idea was a place that I could take a break from the monotony of the everyday classroom I was given a space to build my social and emotional skills with peers in the program many of whom are friends um
068that I've stayed with in touch with you know over the last decade the the idea program teachers served as some of my most trusted mentors to this day because they knew me best and engaged with me on a deeper level they treated me like an adult even when I was just in third grade I would go to the extent to say that my success at a prestigious undergrad University now a prestigious medical school and hopefully in a year uh another good residency program um could be attributed in part to the idea program I won't go into too much detail I'll keep this short because there's been so many other great speakers that have had a similar sentiment but I think uh my attending of this Board of Ed meeting during my one week I have
069away from Clinical rotations as a 25-year-old speaks to the importance of this issue so I highly recommend that we reassess this budget cut thank you thank you user Leo guest you have been unmuted and recognized please state your name and address for the record note that you will have up to three minutes to comment so my name is Leo my address is to renin road so I think a lot of good points have been raised by parents earlier but I just have some additional comments so first I think New York City had some similar action of eliminating their gift the program a few years ago and their mayor already admit that's a misake that's a take and they are bringing the gift the program back second is that I think Dr adley already said some
070contradicting points himself he is saying that by eliminating this program he will by he will realize this in a different way by putting this in the classroom but he also mentioned that in the classroom different students have different needs so say there are some special need students in in the same room as the gifted students how can they be educated in the same way and the third point is that our superintendent himself actually got paid in the 2023 and 2024 year by $334,950 he managed to increase that budget last year to $344,500 this to lead the school district thank you Jo I think a porting of information is an order on that one um I'm not sure what you mean I know what Appo of information the superintendent doesn't award himself his own Salary thank
071you Mr William Del roo you are recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment hi yeah this is William dco um 217 hollow tree Ridge Road um I really want to reiterate what Christina said um I'm an alumnist of DHS and of the idea program and I was absolutely aass to hear that the idea program was facing the prospect of being cut um just as a little bit of background having gotten my PhD in theoretical physics from Stanford four years ago um I'm currently employed as a scientist at the University of Maryland and was recently selected to help lead massa's next Flagship Mission um and when when I was asked this year at Thanksgiving what I was grateful for I
072told my my family that I was thankful for the idea program because I've been reflecting about it and I truly believe that it has prepared me and provided me with the skills that I needed to accomplish my ambitions um and so let me just reiterate here I am very very troubled that idea may be cut and if we want the Daran public school system to continue to be a place where all students can Thrive and build the skill necessary to achieve their dreams the board should seriously reconsider this proposed cut thank you very much thank you Miss Rebecca relier you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment my name is Rebecca relier my address is six Ridge
073viw Avenue I won't repeat the things that everyone else has said so well I would only like to Echo what Miss Schaefer said which is that the idea program needs to be expanded not cut in Greenwich in Westport in new Kanan there is differentiated learning at the elementary school level for mathematics and our students in darianne don't have that and I think we see the results in high school rankings when we get all the way to the end and we see that Daran high school isn't ranked as high highly as Greenwich Westport and new Canan and that needs to that needs to change at the beginning at the elementary school level inside of Idea Idea needs more support thank you Miss agresta price you have been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address
074for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment hi there uh my name is Kate resta price uh thank you guys so much for opening this to public commentary um I live at five holes Court just for fun I grew up at 25 brierre Road I know that doesn't need to go into the record but I'm going to lead in by saying um like a couple of the folks that just spoke um I'm a DHS Alum proud class of 1998 I'm also an idea Alum and I now have a fifth grader at holes and an incoming kindergartner at holes so I just want to add a couple of th things to the great conversation that we've had already um one is that listen growing up I was in the idea
075program from third grade through ninth grade um it was really foundational to my academic preparation uh in order to be ready to participate in quite a rigorous academic environment um the alums that have spoken before me had like a mix of whether they were going to name drop their colleges or not um so I please forgive me I will say uh that when I graduated from DHS I went to Harvard I observed when I started there that there was actually quite a big difference between the students who had come through Public School anywhere in the US and the students who had come through private school which is a reality that we know and we seek to educate our kids in darianne akin to some of the best private schools that we have in the country
076right I really felt like in the environment of 1600 Harvard freshmen in 1998 199 9 I was among the best prepared among the public school educated kids partly because listen DHS is awesome AP classes like so many great things about being tracked into sort of the right cohorts but really A lot of it also came from as a couple of alums who just spoke said the cohort that we developed from like second grade through nth grade in that idea program which at the time it was categorized as part of special education I was a little bit surprised when I looked at the today to see that it's not categorized as part of special education I'm sure there's a whole story about that um but I really think that cohort and like the experience of being
077stretched beyond my comfort zone is part of it's what we call now um uh growth mindset right as opposed to fixed mindset the research shows that gifted kids really have a risk of getting quickly into this fixed mindset space where they think like oh it's because I'm smart or because I'm talented that I'm doing well as opposed to because I worked hard as opposed to because I stretched myself and tried to do something that I didn't already know how to do so I think that's one of the most important things that comes through the idea program um the last couple things I'll say is that um I was lucky enough when I was in high school I don't know how I was selected for this but when I was at DHS I was the student
078representative to a task force to rethink the idea program and darianne I'd love to just offer myself as a resource to anybody on the board like it was a really cool experience happy to think back on that I'm sure other things have been done like that since then we went and met with gifted education program leaders thank you so much Miss price you're you're out of time but we appreciate your comments Miss mum's iPhone you've been recognized and unmuted please state your name and address for the record and note that you have up to three minutes to comment hello everyone this is uh madhumita bopai I live in 19 Maple Street and I have a fifth grader and a kid kindergartner that go to uh hinley Elementary School uh my fifth grader uh is in
079the idea program and um I Want U you know a lot of wonderful points have been you know shared what I would request the board to consider is obviously to not take away the idea program um and you know as a lot of us move to Daran it's due to the school district due to this you know availability of this program and as Alan said um Darian High School is um you know listed let's in top two in Connecticut Middle School sixth rank is not great but okay um what will eventually happen if we take away the idea program is the incoming families or folks or existing ones once they start moving to Westport new Canon or other nearby school districts that have the idea program um The Pride that we have uh for our
080town saying okay you know Darian High School is uh ranked number two the SAT scores are driven highly by these highly individual highly intelligent individuals so if we think longterm taking away the idea program will have an impact to the ranking of the elementary schools middle schools and high schools and Darian would not be the Darian that we are all proud of today individually speaking my daughter when she was in kindergarten first grade she had bone cancer and she fought it after 10 months when she went came back to school a year later she made it in the idea program and every time I tell her you have to go for scans the first thing she said oh I hope it's not the idea day that is how much she likes the program that is
081how much it uh enriches her encourages her she has found her group um like she connects with them and and a group of boys got selected this year and she always mingled with them even before they were an idea I really hope that this is reconsidered and that dar Remains the good District that we are all proud of let's not take away the top um you know the cream um and make it a regular school district like Stamford or some other school district thank you if anybody else online would like to participate in public comment please use the raised hand icon we have no further raised hands okay thank you all for your time this evening with that I'll take a motion to adjourn that is John seconded by Dennis those in favor