001e e e I have to say it again because I didn't have my microphone on so good evening everybody I'd like to call this meeting to order it is February 6 and it is 603 Mrs Martinez are we doing a roll call we already did so I don't think we have anything to report out from closed session so miss sori would you um like to lead us in the [Laughter] pledge iedge Ali to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you Mrs sorry so um announcement first before Oh yes so to our wonderful have you noticed look at our great um portraits these were done by fifth graders um in I don't remember Heather's
002last name he higen Botham um in her art class and aren't they fantastic they're just fantastic we love them so we want to give a big shout out to those fifth graders who did such remarkable artwork and to Heather hien higen bathan for her um wonderful uh art uh art teaching it's just she just did a great job so approval of the agenda do I have a I move that we approve the agenda as written I any opposed thank you and we'll go on to student reports so Victoria Blackman from um uh Liberty would you like to begin good evening president grubs superintendent Dr Wright and fellow trustees and cabinet members Liberty High School will be busy this upcoming February we are celebrating Black History Month we will be honoring the many contributions and Legacies
003of African-Americans who help shaped our nation the following weeks we'll be going to salano Community College to learn more about CTE programs a mountain bike Excursion and at the Golden Gate Park and holding a blood dry Liberty has been partnering with UC Davis in their spinning salmon project this year we've been provided a aquarium and salmon eggs for the past two months and we've been monitoring their growth and collecting data this project is to help support the depleting salmon populations next month we'll be releasing our new hatchling into the Sacramento River UC Davis has asked if they will be able to showcase our school and students in their upcoming research Publications highlighting student engagement with this project and our collaborations several students have been picked to be interviewed to talk about their experiences working alongside
004the researchers we want to give a huge shout out to our science teacher Miss sabano for making this happen finally we want to congratulate Mr Lobo for being Liberty High School's teacher of the year and Miss caramo for being our classified Personnel of the year we appreciate all that they do for us thank you thank you good [Applause] job and Bella Canon okay hello president grubs and fellow council members in the past few weeks leadership has planned the first Clash of the classes it consisted of a Spirit Week where points were awarded to everyone who dressed up at lunch for dressed up at Spirit for spirit days excuse me every day at lunch there was a different competition grades were able to nominate champions for each competition there's a basketball competition an art competition a
005math competition and a trivia competition points were awarded to the winners and at the end of the week we had our winter rally where more games and more competitions were allowed were um allowed the grades to earn more points for their classes at the end of the rally the winner was announced and the junior class had won also during lunch in the past week leadership was selling roses for students to buy for one another that will be delivered this Friday for Valentine's Day this week leadership is doing a 12 days of kindness challenge every day a simple but kind task a simple but kind task is posted that the students can choose whether or not they would like to accomplish today at lunch the S Club hosted a teen Dating Violence awareness event and this
006Friday at lunch the black student union are hosting a movie event for the start of Black History Month yesterday was the wrestling senior night and tonight is the basketball senior night tomorrow leadership will deliver the Roses sold last week for Valentine's Day and in the upcoming weeks next week we have ski week and we will have a week off drama is continuing to work on their spring musical which is announced to be The Adams Family and Leadership is continuing to plan events such as prom and the panther Bowl on behalf of bisha high school thank you thank you so much ladies very nice and and if you'd like you're you're welcome to head on out to other other activities thank you or you can stay or you can stay um and Dr Wright you're up
007all right good evening I would like to start my report off by um congratulating our employees of the Year U both classified and certificated our classified employees of the Year Michelle Wade um from Mary farmer Elementary School uh Michelle Wade is a dedicated and highly respected member of the Mary farmer Community she's known for her professionalism her kindness and ability to impact others around her in her five years at the school she has stepped into the role as an office manager uh bringing organization and efficiency while maintaining a warm and welcoming environment for students staff and families Michelle's leadership extends Beyond daily responsibilities as she plays a key role initiatives like The Giving Tree and books and blankets strengthening Community connections her exceptional communication skills and ability to multitask ensure smooth operations in a busy
008school environment earning her admirations from colleagues Michelle's contributions including her work on the new online volunteer application process highlight her commitment to continuous Improvement in service to the BD community so congratulations to Michelle Wade we would also like to congratulate Mr Jeffrey bushe um teacher at uh Matthew Turner your old roots stomping grounds um as bonisha Unified School District's Teacher of the Year Mr bushe exemplifies Excellence through his dedication to Student Success leadership and literacy instruction and commitment to professional growth he's a trained uh Orton Gillian uh practitioner and expert in differentiated instruction Jeffrey has driven um some of the highest achievements and growth scores in our district his influence extends Beyond his classroom mentoring colleagues po p piloting new curriculum and um contributing to districtwide professional development his passion expertise and lasting impact make
009him a truly deserving candidate of this recognition so congratulations to both Michelle Wade and Jeffrey B this week is also National School counseling week um just want to express my gratitude for our school counselors they do a great job it's February 3rd through February 7th um this year um the theme is School counseling helping students Thrive and this recognizes their profound impact that they have on Student Success and well-being so thank you to our school counselors uh we just celebrated uh Lunar New Year and um this year is a year of the snake and the snake also represents the pursuit of love and happiness as well as qualities and calmness and introspection so um happy Lunar New Year um February 11th it is International Day of women and girls in science and we know that
010steam is one of our uh lcap goals um celebrated every February 11th this event aims to increase diversity and stem Fields by empowering and celebrating females who are trailblazing their way through scientific research and Innovation and this Black History Month February um the 2025 Black History month theme is African-Americans in labor focuses on the significant role that labor has played in shaping the black experience throughout history um this meeting I would like to honor the Good Marshall who is American civil rights lawyer and jurist who served as an associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States from 1967 to 1991 uh he was also the Supreme Court's first African-American Justice uh we had an opportunity to also go to Robert simple this morning they had their wax museum and the theme was Black
011History Month um it was it was awesome I had an opportunity to learn a lot about Muhammad Ali and Michael jackon and uh Tina Turner and the students were amazing as usual so it was a great event so over the weekend um I was reflecting a lot you know it's it's been heavy um I was at a conference and talking with other superintendents and what's happening in their communities and their districts I spent Saturday reflecting and I just just want to share some of my thoughts that that uh I was thinking about you know I've said it many times that education is a great equalizer I believe it's the answer and I think deep in our hearts we all believe and we know that um because educational is fundamental to everything that we do in
012life it should always be at the Forefront of a of our discussions I might be a dreamer but throughout my career I've always hoped that agendas surrounding public education would focus on inclusivity not because it's mandated or politically correct but because it's a genuine belief that all human beings regardless of their physical appearance country of origin core beliefs or sexual or G gender identity they deserve a free and appropriate education every student should have the opportunity to learn and grow and contribute to the betterment of this Society inclusion and acceptance fostered early on profoundly shapes the path of our young scholars I also reflected on my Elementary School experience and I saw a child who gra gravitated toward what was familiar what I was exposed to and where I felt included I vividly remember that
013class activity where the teacher goes around the classroom and he asks each student what you want to do when you grow up as my classmates eagerly shared their dreams of becoming doctors lawyers and Engineers I always had a response ready I wanted to be a professional athlete that was easy for me because I can turn on the TV and I saw Dr J I saw Azie Smith I saw Charlie Joiner excelling they look like me they were celebrated but beyond the the realm of sports I rarely saw black Educators doctors lawyers portrayed on television or in school and the idea of a black president was unrealistic not just for me but I think at that time for most people people in my classroom only one time did an African-American student answer that question with I
014want to be the president of the United States when asked about their future aspirations and that response provoked disruptive laughter and dismissive remarks I witnessed it I even participated in it joining in unison can't be the president you're black and that was a norm looking back I wonder how much exclusion does a child have to experience before they stop dreaming big how often do we need to see their potential dismissed before they internalize those limits and still how easily do they adopt the very behaviors that hold other people back even when it's unintended exclusionary mindsets can Al alter the course of a child's future and as Educators mentors and leaders we've got to be mindful of that our students are watching they're listening they're internalizing and they're reacting we must make sure that their reaction
015is one of empowerment not limitation because those who seek inclusion but are denied entry often find another way to make their presence known and too often it's not in a way that uplifts them or Society so let's be intentional about fostering spaces where every child feels seen valued and encouraged to dream Without Limits their future and ours depends on it as I think about public education it's a Cornerstone of our society it's an institution that welcomes every child we meet them where they are and we provide not only knowledge and wisdom but also social emotional support regardless of the challenges that they face and every child carries some sort of trauma in our schools we serve as a refuge a place of stability and growth in around the world people recognize that and they risk
016everything for the opportunity that public education provides our kids here opportunities that they may not have had for themselves as a school district our role is much like an emergency room phys where we serve and honor and respect everyone that walks through the door the conversation around public education today are deeply concerning me I've never shied away from confrontation or feedback in fact I welcome it when it cons when it's the criticism is constructive when it leads to learning and meaningful change and progress for students the irony is undeniable and the Very system that educated the leaders of this country that paved the way for our their success is underfunded underminded and even threatened with dismantling gives me pause public education has long been used as a political chest piece and it continues to be
017today and honestly it's getting exhausting for those outside the trenches of public education we as Educators understand the importance of maintaining a nonpartisan approach to our work our students growth should never be influenced by a political party's agenda regardless of our personal belief yet despite our efforts to remain neutral politics shape our work and as the national and state debates grow louder their impacts increasingly felt within a walls of 350 East K Street over the past two and a half weeks significant National discussions including executive orders have challenged B usd's core values and operations these developments have created uncertainty and fear amongst our students families and staff while I wish I can eliminate that stress I don't have that type of power however I want to reaffirm that in times like these the strength lies
018in unity and support for one another regardless of political perspectives at its core this is about the well-being of human beings our students and families and our community this is defines the US in bu USD last week I attended a conference where Tony Thurman our um State superintendent and key legislative Representatives who support education shared insights into the National Climate and its in potential impact on state of California but unfortunately there's still no clear answers as many of these Federal actions are unprecedented California leaders believe that the several Federal mandates lack legal standing and that they're actively challenging them at the highest levels and while these legal battles unfold the California Department of Education remains committed to advocating for students protecting the Department's role and preserving the critical Federal funding sources such as universal Mills
019Title One and idea funding the state continues to Champion for equity and inclusion ensuring that California's diverse student population is represented in educational materials one of the most contentious topics under scrutiny remains immigration which California leaders are prepared to challenge head on I've been asked both directly and indirectly about bu usd's stance on these issues and the protections we have in place for students and families as a district we're Guided by our adopted Vision our mission and our Equity statement which reflect our core values a common theme runs through them if you read them B USD is an inclusive environment that welcomes and serves all and in bu USD all means all to that end we have a clear policy and regulation in place that prohibits District staff from requesting reviewing or collecting paperwork regarding
020a students immigration status there's also been questions regarding how the district would respond if federal law enforcement agencies attempted to gain entry onto B usd's campus and our stance remains clear the district will do everything within our legal authority to protect our students and families this includes ensuring that no entry is granted nor Student Records release without following proper leader legal protocols will follow bu USD policy 51451 3 to date we have not encountered such a situation all District staff have been instructed to refer any immigration related inquiries or federal agents directly to the superintendent's office additionally we'll work closely with our local law enforcement agency to ensure proper jurisdiction is understood and we'll consult with our legal team to safeguard our student students rights and safety last week we shared a communication along with
021the link to our website where you can find resources on immigration I encourage anyone with concerns to R review these materials and we'll continue to update that web page as developments arise I recognize within our community amongst families staff stakeholders there are diverse perspectives it's not my role to share mine or to debate yours but to remain focused on what matters and as supporting students we're committed to minimizing disruptions by adhering to our governing board policies upholding the lcap priorities where're social emotional Wellness equity and inclusion are Central and standing firmly on the foundation of our vision our mission and Equity statement these values guide us and we embrace all students so let's not exclude let's include and bu USD all means all period thank you for listening [Applause] thank you Dr Wright that was
022very inspiring um so we are now going on to board reports does anyone have anything to report out I do um I have a couple of great announcements about students at our high school um the first one being uh the bisha high school debate team returned to Nationals this year an extraordinary accomplishment by kette Calderon and Daniel Delgado finished second in the prestigious Berkeley High invitation Invitational uh debate tournament they were the top two of 74 teams that that competed um we the the one thing that's really exciting about this all is that you know Michelle Gaines is their advisor and but their their guidance is also by past students who come back every year to help coach these kids and to see that I think come to a fruition like that is pretty remarkable
023so I just want to uh give a a shout out to um the the bisha alumni Tristan Keane uh Tim Knox Garrett sloy and anybody else that has helped our students get to this point and I think there'll be more to follow at a later date um and the second thing I got an email today from Andreas Kaiser about their students their BHS teams who compet competed in the Nor Cal kidwind championship this past week in at Cal Mari time students designed and built an efficient wind turbine and presented it to the panel of Judges 11 students from his Advanced engineering design class participated I'm just going to announce their names because it's so exciting uh Jam saah uh Xavier Irvin Sophia Bogard rusia sparin and Logan uh beta sorry if I messed up any
024of your names I didn't mean to but just congratulations and kudos to both these groups of [Applause] kids is there anyone else yeah I wanted to say a few things um first of all I just want to thank Dr Wright for your words that was really great thank you and I stand um with you so thank you for that um also the BMS debate team has started by a um a current BHS uh debate member which is super exciting so that's really great for the Middle School yes exactly and then I just want to give a shout out to our high school improv um group I went and saw their um performance uh in January and it was really great so just want to encourage people it's a fun family night um they do give
025warnings when you know the kiddos shouldn't come but there were lots of kiddos in the audience and it was a a really fun evening so shout out to our improv students that's it I have a few things to share out um trusty Meli and I attended the scsba um I can never remember exactly how to say that we attended their um biannual meeting and Stephanie Rice was kind to attend and be on a panel um the and what that group is it's a collection it's all of the Solano County School boards and we all get together um twice a year and have a presentation and a dinner and Mrs Rice um presented on literacy Ela and how we're doing and talked about different strategies in all of the different counties participated on a panel Dr
026Wright and Dr beatson were there as well so thank you um for attending that I thought it was well done um I also attended the BHS open house after the last meeting which was great I had about a half an hour and I ran in and and met everybody and um I I really enjoy how the students are all uh Manning the tables so if you go and learn about the different classes talking to students and you can hear about their experiences so it was really helpful having a student in the high school who has already selected all of his classes without consulting me so it's fine it's fine um and then uh last but not least I met with Amber Kelly from the bonisha library um she just walked in and uh just met
027with her about the library had a tour of the library learned about what the public library provides to our schools learned about um you know needs just the um the different needs of the different schools and how inte and how we are integrated with our Public Library I didn't realize quite the extent of the interaction I thought it was great um also learned a lot about the different Services the library provides our students that are free such as in it's tutoring and it's online but it's a live person and it's available 24 hours um I know our principles put that in their newsletters but I think it's great to broadcast that um so thank you Miss Kelly thank you so this morning I attended the um the facilities meeting this facilities committee meeting and and
028it was very interesting it's um you know there's so much going on and and thanks to um to uh our uh tell me your name again because roxan Egan so Miss Zan uh presented and so some of the things that are happening um there are many uh uh new buildings going in there's lots of renovation of bathrooms thank goodness um Tech and security uh upgrades um Ada upgrades sound uh at at the high school the PAB is being uh renovated with um upgraded sound and lighting um there are shade structures going up everywhere um which is greatly needed as you probably know um uh Liberty High has got is getting new Roofing a new entrance so that they look like the high school that they are um and all the schools are getting uh um
029portable upgrades um TK classrooms um and different facility upgrades thanks to the um the proposition that you all passed so thank you very much for that it was a really good meeting um and I really enjoyed learning everything that was going on so thank you and then we come to number um number 10 and I'm going to read this B uh see all function of the board meeting including public comments will take place in person members of the public May address the board at a regular meeting on any item within the board's jurisdiction speaker cards are available at the entrance table please note the item that you wish to speak to and submit a card to the board secretary the board president will call the Open Session General comments um government code section 5495 54.3
030during the public comment item comments for items on the agenda will be called during that specific item comments are limited to no more than three minutes per speaker or the board May limit the total time to 20 minutes per item with the timer displayed on the monitors by law no action may be taken on any item raised during public comment periods and matters may be referred to staff for placement on future agenda of the governing board please be reminded to keep your comments respectful as students may be watching the meeting so thank you and our first speaker is Marana Moore good evening excuse me my name is Mariana Moore um I'm a longtime resident in bonisha I have two girls at Mary farmer we love that school I live in area 2 um I want
031to start by thanking you Dr Wright for your statement I'm actually very moved by it I think there's so many um districts right now across the country where the superintendent is either not allowed to express their values and their commitment in that way or they don't hold those values so I see you and I thank you and I'm with you and I hope that everyone I assume on this board is with you as well and I hope our community is as well so I just want to start with that um what I want to speak to tonight actually you talked about in your comments was protecting immigrants in our community because when we talk about inclusion and we do all hold that value you know right now is a time to say how does that
032really show up in action as well as words and I have gone through your whole website piece around the immigration protections and what resources are available for families and the FAQ I think it's really good information for the most part I that it's there again I want to say thank you um it talks about things like the opportunity to reaffirm our unwavering commitment to um fostering a safe and inclusive and Equitable learning environment you know we don't know who's going to read that and go oh okay I belong because right now so many folks are being made to feel they do not belong um and also it talks about eliminating barriers which I'm going to come back to in a little bit but I'm glad to see that language there as well and I looked
033at the P cues are the frequently asked questions what are my rights what if federal law enforcement comes to the campus there's a protocol in place all really good the reason I wanted to come talk to you tonight Beyond thanking you for all of this is to say I think there's some tweaks or refinements that can be made and I think like we're all in learning mode so this is not a criticism actually it's an invitation and an offer to collaborate um I know in my day job working with immigrants quite a bit and with folks who work with them and for them and alongside them for example is one example where it says collaborate with law enforcement any immigrant I know in the jurisdiction I work in would be like oh my God law
034enforcement I got to pull my kids out of school and they in fact are pulling their kids out of school which have horrific ramifications for learning loss Revenue loss inequities that build over time as you know and so there's things like that where I think I I see the intent and I see the actuality of really good language and that I would love to have and I don't know whom but you or someone on staff you know or a board committee you have to familiarize me with the structure work with you um to just sort of collaborate on how can this be made how can we be sure that the language we're saying with such great intent is in fact welcoming inclusive fing for families who are very very scared right now and I think
035that's something we can do collaboratively um I know that um I was on a parent call last night am I done okay anyway my address is on there look forward to hear from you thank you for your efforts and our next speaker is Cheer help me with your last name CH Chow thank you good evening thank you for all you do uh this is really a safe Forum thank you Dr right I really like your powerful speech all is for all thank you that means a lot um I'm here to comment regarding about the Immigrant um policy um first of all I'm a mom of three one uh sixth grader one fifth grader and um one second grader very proud parents very glad to be in feel very fortunate to be in this District I
036am immigrant of 21 years in the US uh being a citizen for 15 years I'm speaking here today need to take multiple deep breath breath because I want to be the voice the voice for the people who did not come here today because they're being labeled illegal deep breath we can do it they can you might not hear much concern because they don't have a voice they cannot speak up any email any phone call Will expose them that could be the reason you might not hear much but TI is still concerned even though there is silence the concern still exist I really appreciate on our website FAQ area because me as a ESL learner just like many of the immigrants English is a barrier but the FAQ was so easy to follow step by step
037scenario by scenario what happened if this happened what will we do if this happened what we we do that is very heartwarming I really wish we can have the similar message like tonight all is for all we will protect you we will stand by you and I really wish to hear that from the community in simple language where an ESL learner can understand an immigrant can understand um like maram mentioned earlier when mentioning law enforcement partners by default an immigrant might not know the difference between a police officer and immigrant officer they represent the government then they are the officer that might be able to take them away so that is the angle from an immigrant and that is my voice try to be their voice and trying to connect them with you thank you
038thank you and the rest of the speakers will um speak during uh item 12 so um thank you for our speakers uh so we're going we're at um 11 UHA approval of the consent calendar background information on these items is provided to the board prior to the meeting a common motion takes place a common motion takes takes action without discussion on roll call votes unless discussion of items is requested by the board member so can I have a I move that we approve the consent calendar is written a second I'll second thank you all those in favor I any oppose you at this point I'd like to acknowledge um some gifts uh GI to the district um the flower there was a flower arrangement estimated a retail value of $990 for um the state of
039the district event from Michelle young owner of daughters of Luna floral design and those those flower arrangements were so beautiful they really added something to the state of the of the district so I want to really we all want to thank you so much for that and let's see presentations um so we are to 12 we are on to 12a line wise so Bruce Lambert Our IT director will introduce Adam Lee of line wives good evening president grubs uh board members Dr Wright cabinet we've had discussion about Internet safety and child well-being and teachers having access to help kids during class we've reached out and we've looked around and we came across line wise line wise is a it's a program robust that's going to help us with student well-being internet monitoring and uh parents
040having access to help their students at home with access to the internet so I will turn over to Adam from line wise and he will give us uh more information thank you so much uh good evening my name is Adam Lee I'm with line wise and I'm I'm very happy to be here um I don't do I'm lucky enough to do some board meetings but I can tell that this community is is obviously very engaged um and the only thing is I'd love to have a portrait next time if if I do come back because they're fabulous but um you know thank you again for the opportunity um you know to present maybe perfect so as uh you know Bruce had mentioned uh line wise is uh one of the leaders in in uh children
041or child digital safety uh globally um you know we we certainly our our mission statement we could rewrite it um you know Dr Wright to to be well-being you know for all is at our core um you know as as you said um we're headquartered in San Diego uh and we're grateful um to to have the the ability to protect over a million students actually closer to 1.2 million students across just California alone um you know to keep them digitally safe and also to help Inspire digital learning you know within the classrooms uh we're I'm G to skip this one we're big Believers uh this is the slide that I wanted to to spend some time on and it's a little hard to see but um in in an era of increased digital learning where
042students spend upwards of 60 to 70% of their time you know on a device it's imperative that uh the district adopt solutions to help break down some of the silos that have historically existed I've been in web filtering in technology for 13 years now and when I first started it was all about uh it departments had to keep the network up and that was it but if we learned anything during covid right where we all had to figure things out and send students home and and you all you all live this not me so so Kudos um you know all learning went digital so all stakeholders need a say need a voice voice and I think if we look at you know any District site some of the mission statement some of the core focuses
043it's better data in better data out we want data to be that North Star that guides us so we can make decisions you know that are routed in data and and that's what we do so our marketing department put this together um and this is our our student safety framework it's divided into three into three pillars that I'll talk about but what's important to note is the child's at the center so we're a technology company every every line kind of code that we create every support ticket that we respond to every training that we do for a district is all about keeping that child to the center digitally safe and helping to inspire that next Generation learning experience so the first pillar is prevention and intervention and that is where our content filter and our
044classroom management platforms work together synergistically legally school districts in order to be e- rate eligible you have to filter the internet you have to make sure that students don't get to uh adult content and other you know dangerous or egregious things um so that's the Baseline Foundation that line wise you know will bring in addition we offer classroom management and what classroom management um that's the the category of product I like to call it more of classroom enablement because it's not about restricting but it's actually about allowing teachers and giving them more autonomy to be able to take digital control of their classroom so when your web Filter Works synergistically with the classroom we can give teachers the ability to actually locally unlock some things that might not be always open uh without ever jeopardizing
045compliance so things that come to mind might be if we decide to open up generative AI for example we may not want students to have cart blanch access to it for distraction purposes but we want to have a a forward leaning you know curriculum we can give teachers that ability you know to open it up when needed but also give teachers the ability to focus the student minimize distractions and also have great reporting data so they can have more effective meetings you know with with parents the second pillar uh is our early detection and intervention uh pillar and our monitor product fits in there um there's historic uh the levels of student safety issues of self harm issues substance abuse issues are at historic levels right now and they're only getting worse so our monitoring
046product gives the district uh visib ility into events that you know might not be identified because they live in a digital world students are are head down and it's hard to identify those things so we'll talk about that but the final uh pillar our education and engagement area that is all about this right it's about breaking down some of those silos that that potentially exist digitally between the district and the community so we include a parent app so Mom and Dad can actually see what they're children were doing on the school issue device we also host um parent webinars where we have a team of clinical child psychologists and other thought leaders that e cool and I'll just hang on to it thank you um so the the first slide here is is the line
047wise filter this is about uh maintaining CP of compliance and making sure that students don't get places that they shouldn't need to address the board [Music] okay I've gone through these but thank you so much um the next uh product that's part of our our ecosystem is um and well I will mention this so part of our platform uh we're actually using artificial intelligence to actually blur bad content on the Fly uh there's been issues um I'll I'll bring up uh an issue that occurred last spring at Beverly Hills unified um they were somewhat unfairly targeted by the media because of their name of course but what was happening is students were finding uh different AI tools that allowed them to create bad content and and I'll use the word bad content but it was
048adult content and they were actually taking photos of their teachers using these AI generators and creating adult content of their teachers it resulted in teachers quitting uh the IT team you know huge huge issues so what line wise is doing um not only do we block bad websites as you would expect based on reputations we're using AI in the p page to actually blur out bad images that may be created on the Fly anime others but also uh video content that might not be appropriate so even though the district it will go through you know Great Lengths to to have different ways to filter YouTube there's a lot of Bad actors out there where what they'll do is they'll have a a five minute video about a science lesson or something at the two or
049three minute Mark they'll embed adult content so it'll get through the YouTube filters they have too much time on their hands our AI is smart enough to where it'll play the video up until that bad will blur it so it's an additional you know line of defense and it's really helping to meet the modern threats that that are ever evolving you know especially as students spend more time digitally the second uh product is is for teachers this is called classwise and and this is all about again teacher enablement uh teachers can be you know at their at their Le turn at their desk uh or walking around but it allows them to see all of their student screens and see what their students are doing uh if a student is off task they can message
050a student they can redirect the student they can actually create a focus where hey during this session the only places I'd like you to be going is these three or four learning apps in your Google drive if you try to go anywhere else you'll actually be blocked um so that really creates that curated learning environment that can drive the outcomes that you're looking for um and I also mentioned some of the autonomy that uh we can give by giving teachers the ability to unblock locally without ever jeopardizing compliance so one of the challenges I think if there's any teachers in front of me uh or former teachers um you you go to launch a website or an app to teach and it's not blocked now the lesson is derailed and you're scrambling we can solve
051you know all those challenges without ever jeopardizing you know compliance uh the third piece is line wise monitor line wise monitor is the most advanced student safety monitoring platform we again use use artificial intelligence and natural language processing and we monitor Student Activities uh across a couple of different events uh event categories those include substance abuse unfortunately in California we're the number one state for grooming incidents uh across students sexual content uh and self harm and ideation um and if there are any if our AI does identify any sort of um you know issue we have a team of highly trained moderators that will actually review and go through those false positives so so your team those designated contacts won't be bombarded with false positives we do that work you know on behalf uh of
052the district and that's you know part of our service um these are the risks that we saw in 2023 I've got an updated slide that I just released we just finished the data analysis for 2024 and U I'm sad to say that although in 2023 we saw um you know a child at serious risk every 3 minutes in 2024 the updated slide is now every one one and a half minutes um so unfortunately a lot of the pressures are getting harder right we know that it's never been harder to be a kid today um you know so you can see some of these stats and you know the idea here is is not to you know sort of sell on fear you know but just to highlight some of the the really serious issues that
053you were all obviously very aware you know very well aware of um the iceberg effect that's what I I hinted at uh when a when a child is heads down on a device all day long uh it's much tougher than it was 10 years ago or or 15 20 years ago when I was in school where it was easy to identify a child who was you know struggling right there were outward signs but in this digital world we call it the iceberg effect often below the waterline that digital waterline if you will uh there's a lot of Curry and that just isn't seen so conversations uh that that should be brought to light and the idea here is we want to identify more of the risks before they become real life incidents um but when
054you're you're talking about um you know a product like this I I think that what needs to be discussed um is is privacy right we're we're we're talking about uh Student Activities digitally so line wise as proud uh we're the only solution in the student monitoring space that holds all four ieep safe certifications we also have uh very deep uh ties with the site community in California um and we are on the ca ndpa which is the most stringent data privacy uh agreement we have to go through an audit every year to maintain that um so that's the most stringent data privacy uh agreement in the US um so we take data privacy very very very seriously um the idea is or or one of the the big differences with us uh there's a lot
055of student safety monitoring products out there and they do a great job at monitoring emails and that's great if you're not monitoring you know email right now really a good place to start but we find that over 40% of all the events that we raise our moderation team raises are occurring outside of just email so if you're only looking at email you're maybe missing some bullying that might be occurring in an Esports approved game or maybe you're missing some misuse um in generative AI for example so if you if you do plan on opening up chat gbt and Gemini and others um you really ought to be monitoring it right to make sure that it's not being misused used that it's being used for good and and finding ways to celebrate you know good uses
056of Technology as opposed to you know just uh you know restricting uh I'll wrap up here with um our community platform when I think about web filtering you know the district is going to spend you know X number of dollars no matter what because they have to when it comes to web filtering legally the question should be what do we get additionally do we have a tool you know for our parents where they can actually see uh and even control the school district devices outside of school hours hey it's great that you've given my child a Chromebook but at 3 in the morning I really don't appreciate them being on it they should be able to set a bedtime you know if they want to on that device and with line wise you can additionally
057um if you're going to spend the money in a web filter which you have to uh are you getting some other resources like our community Hub which is that on online resource our team will write um you know we just released a Blog on Tik Tok right people are hearing a lot about Tik Tok there's uncertainty what does it mean should my child be using it these are the kind of topics that we that we cover and it's co-branded with uh with your with your District logos and all that it's a really great bridge between the district you know and the community and then finally we will do uh parent webinars if you'd like us uh too and those are clinical psychologists and other great thought leaders retired law law enforcement and other you know
058you know folks in the in the industry uh the final piece I'll mention um as part of our mission to keep kids digitally safe uh for every parent uh in the district for every one of their children we do provide a free license for our premium uh filtering software for a device that they own now that data is totally segmented from the district there's for for furpa and other reasons but again our our goal is to keep as many children as digitally safe as we can so if you have a child in the district you are entitled to free filtering and and security on a device that you issue your Your Child So after the holidays you give them a new Macbook iPhone whatever it might be we'll protect that just because it's the right
059thing to do and uh this is just more information you know on our community platform uh this is tiadora pavkovic she is a clinical psychologist she is one of our uh she leads our our team of experts she's a two-time tedex speaker she's fabulous it's it's that quality or caliber you know folks that would potentially be you know speaking you know with you at the uh at your request so that is uh that is line wise I'll open up for any questions thank you you're so welcome hi hi um all right sorry getting used to the mic here me too so um does this is this program does it block like social media so is it up to the to District to decide it could block social media accounts it can block gaming it can
060BL block gambling it can block any sorts of things that can be done on a computer totally up to the district but yes so so we're a web filter and what we do is we create a set of rules and policies and that's going to be based on on our work with the district allowing what you want to allow blocking what you don't but we also have some some sipa compliant policies already thought out so to get you to compliance that first day and you had mentioned sort of monitoring on your end in terms of the activity that's happening young people are so smart I mean they're so smart they know how to do this um will there be is there monitoring in terms of if someone's trying to figure out getting out of the
061set settings trying to go around trying you know if things that are not allowed on the Chromebook or computer these These are these are great questions so we call that circumvention or avoidance often children or kids will use or vpns or other obis attempt or techniques line wise actively monitors you know for those and we will not only identify the students but there's a a setting that could be set where if a child tries to tamper with the device tries to launch a VPN you know Etc they get a custom page that pops up and says you've been identified as trying to get around the filter you'll no longer have internet activity for 2 minutes three minutes whatever you decide so it becomes more of a teachable moment as well okay and then you mentioned
062that parents are able to um download this onto a nonb USD issued computer so if someone has a computer at their house they're able to to do that great um I have a couple other questions but I'll let some of my other colleagues ask they were great thank you y yes ma'am so when you were saying to kind of piggyback on um a colleague here um when you were saying that parents have a can have access to a license to be able to use on a single device if that parent has multiple children is that mean they get a a single device uh thing for every single child one per child in the district one per child one okay yeah so so if you have five kids you have five licenses and then you know
063there are packages if they wanted to to kind of continue with that but every every child that they have gets a license a premium license okay um I had another question too and I and that's of our custodio software is is what it's called and uh that was recently featured on the Today's Show by name uh Carson daily actually just talking about custodio so you can go to custodio dcom and and check it out and that's what every parent will get for each one of their their kids and how is it that um we know kids have cell phones m then they have their Chromebook sure and they have a computer and they can access it on their TV I mean all these different ways of accessing it sure is it what is it I
064mean well it only stops it on one item so they'll have their their phones here or at school and they'll be able to access stuff anyway well that would be a little bit different so um the way that we we deploy technically speaking you hear a lot of talk about the cloud versus you know not Cloud we're a hybrid solution so we use the cloud meaning that every device that uh bisha unifies issues to the students would have what's called agent so it's a piece of software that we put on that device before they're issued and that means that wherever that device goes home school anywhere in between it is filtered it is compliant you know and all of that but we also have a an appliance that that'll be in the data center so
065anyone bringing any device that connects to the network here that'll also be filtered and be compliant now if a child brings on their cell phone personally and they're using their Verizon or T-Mobile and and Mom and Dad haven't installed something we'd have no way you know to to stop that but that's also Al you know a privacy thing as well um so so if we don't own the device we can't touch it but if they're using your internet no matter the device it'll also be filtered and secured then sorry you guys I had buch of questions um um regarding um teacher involvement our teachers are so overworked yeah incredibly overworked and I want to know really MH like you're saying well they could be around the room and looking at stuff but they do that
066already they do mostly do that already so how much is this going to take time off of their you know put it on their plate say to to have to do it's it's a great it's a great question and and what we don't want to be doing is is taking teachers away from what they're supposed to be doing which is teaching right um but when you've got 25 to 30 devices you know in front of you and you know I might be I can't device so what are they looking at yeah so so on their screen so on on their machine or it's software based they can actually put it on a Smartboard okay or they can put it on a tablet and as they're walking around but also what we found is the the
067most powerful aspect of the tool is not the technology itself it's the fact that the students know the technology exists right so that kind you know after just one session they get the first note from the teacher that says hey can you please get back on task we're get we're on Exel you know get off you know all of a sudden okay this is this is different um but we don't want to turn teachers into dashboard managers that's not what this is about but what it does is it also has some historical reports so if I'm walking around and I think I might have seen something but the student clicked out of it normally that's sort of gone or maybe they can call it and try to I think I saw something but it is
068they're they're as busy as teachers are too they've got to keep Network up and now a teacher can go back back in time and say and they have up to two weeks to do this they can say oh between these this 10-minute block I just want to see what that what what they were up to they can actually see the screenshots so if there was some misuse or it shouldn't be viewed as just a a slap on on the hand it's also you know you can share screens so pretend I see a student approaching a math problem in a really cool way I can actually screencast their screen onto the Smartboard hey everyone look how XYZ student just approach this problem this is really cool right so it should be about celebrating you know the
069successes too and um I think it really is an efficiency multiplier you know for for the teachers um when used properly and we include full-blown training so we'll do training q&as we have uh asynchronous and also you know uh group Type U training so we'll we'll make sure that it's used the right way and then finally um when you say parents can get notified on a from them a student using a home device to obtain information that shouldn't they shouldn't be looking at is and then if the student is up you use I think 2 o'clock in the morning or something they're up at the middle of the night how is that parent notified is it going to send them a text and say your student is like because I don't know if so so
070that that's a very complex question and just to clarify you know if our if our safety monitoring product did identify a student you know at risk it's not going to be alerting parents directly and the reason for that is there's been a lot of situations where there might be an issue at home that's actually prompting the child to they know their devices are being monitored so we've had issues where they've actually written emails and not sent the emails talking about abuse and and other issues so that would make that situation worse right so what parents can do is they can use the app and they can actually see what their kids are doing on devices what websites they went to the videos they watched you know those kind of things but from a safety monitoring
071perspective we don't send the alerts to parents you know for those reasons and there's also some other communities where you know in California right it's it's illegal to you know out a child for example and and and that's where it gets very complex sure yeah that makes sense thank you so much you're so welcome thanks for the questions I have a question just about cost um you know what does the program sounds fabulous with a lot of features and you mentioned a couple times we already have to pay for something and so I'm curious as to how much more this might cost than what we're currently paying I don't know if we've done that analysis yet I know this is just a presentation but I just wanted to raise it because we have you know
072agenda items tonight about budget so no and and and I I I do you know these meetings often I was just in Texas you know I I had a keynote at at their big TCA conference uh they had 800 sessions there and I think 400 were about Ai and what to do about it the other 400 were about how do we how do we pay for anything it's it's they're they're tough times um we are very very competitively priced um I can't speak to you know your former you know what what you had paid but um we can we can happily kind of participate in those cost analysis and help in any way we can on that note I'm assuming there's a base cost and then does that also then you can upgrade from there
073in terms of like maybe extra safekeeping beings or extra extra amenities that were in your presentation is that accurate it is accurate so so think of the the solution again sort of those those three pillars the the the first um web filtering would be your license number one the classroom management or enablement for teachers license number two and the safety monitoring would be number three if you buy any of our products uh you are still entitled to uh the parent app and all the digital education we don't charge for any of the community stuff and then there would be like an annual fee or an annual update correct yes okay any questions so I I have a question about the um going through your presentation before we came in tonight um there are certain uh
074uh um apps that could and would be blocked um one of them was YouTube there were a couple others so in the classroom we there we are digital there are times when teachers need to show a YouTube video or a video from um another another app so what happens then if because if we have blocked uh something like YouTube in for individual devices what happens if that teacher needs to um show this particular video yes it's a great question and um with with the classroom management product classwise teachers would actually be able to unblock you know YouTube but um we approach YouTube in in a number of different ways right so we're and we're the ones that would be doing the blocking too so so we're we're the blockers and the openers if if that
075makes sense um you know in your scenario but there's a couple things we can do around YouTube one would be allowing teachers to actually push a video in what we call clean YouTube mode where there's no thumbnails no comments All of that's gone so the comments no ads but but if you've read comments on YouTube they're absolutely vicious um so we it's it's a cleaner YouTube experience that we can deliver and you can actually as a teacher you could push one YouTube video and say we're we're focusing on this video they would only be allowed to see that video for example if they tried to go to another video they can't so it's so it's we want to allow more of the good and only block the bad like that is the future that we're
076historically when when I think about my career at filter for the last 13 years you had to it was very heavy-handed blocking you know and web filtering now in today's digital world it's it's how do we enable more and more and and that's that's really our stance how um difficult would it be for a teacher to unblock a video three clicks three clicks three clicks yeah and you know frankly uh we've I've worked for line wi for seven years now um we used to we used to approach teacher training with a very thorough training up front and then we would do you know a Q&A and we found about 10 minutes into the hourong training all the teachers are flying we're seeing the rise on the screen they're just going they're clicking so now it's
077really intuitive so what we do now is we actually we recommend let's get all your teachers using it and then a week later just do a Q&A session and then for those yeah because they've already they've been running with it and then we'll offer for anyone that would like some extra you know training hey you can we we'll do two or three we'll schedule them after hours they could join if they want to if they want to kind of go deeper but um they they really do take to it very very quickly and and once once they see or hear about one teacher you know hey have you tried that the classwise thing here's what I did they'll very all quickly you know use it so it's it's fun to see that uh that that
078usage really increase thank you you're welcome I have more questions um so just to piggyback on what trusty Hirsch said with the District of size um we've heard possibly 40,000 would be the cost what's the range of the cost for a program like this uh range in cost like what would we be paying maybe annually student cost or sure uh 40,000 would be the annual cost so that that's a re a reoccurring cost so we we we license based on student count um so we include um you know filtering and safety for all devices the community is all included uh BYOD so to bring your own devices all that's included so we just license base on your student count and uh there's an approximate cost I think there's three licenses that we had licensed for
079the filter of the classroom of the monitor product and and we have that broken down as as separate line items and then we did apply a uh AB bundal discount you know for you to make it more palatable and you don't have those numbers um in terms of like what would it be $100,000 to implement it what what is the cost of what oh there's no implementation costs that that that is your total cost we include all on boarding training there's no Professional Services all of that is included in that cost okay so there is not a penny extra we'll never come back to you for for anything and then we'll also future proof you from increases uh we've all you know maybe took that Cable Bundle and said yes to the phone when he
080really didn't need it and he got the cheaper price for for cable TV and internet and then the next year was three times expensive uh will never increase year-over-year renewals Beyond 5% right just for inflationary purposes so so you're you're very much price protected thank you you're welcome this might be a district question but I have questions just in terms of and maybe this Waits until it's more presented formally but I have questions in terms of like how will the district Monitor and how will we share this with our parents when does it come to a point when a child when a student is continuously going Beyond restrictions um and also thinking about you know there's different needs for our elementary schools our middle school and our high schools um particularly through technology but also
081classroom use Etc um and how will we how would we you know push that forward and and use that so I don't know if that's a further um presentation but yeah yeah I think we would respond to that if we were to move forward and go down the line we would show our um we would share our plan great yeah and I think it's it's it's having the data you know that that we can you know provide to help you shape those policies and you know while while we're not there to make those decisions we do have those resources you know we we partner with 125 districts you know in California we can also share some successes potholes to avoid that's all you know part of the customer success experience that we offer great thank
082you you're welcome and this may be more of a district question too but as part of the analysis of next steps I think it'd be great to get our um our staff's input as well to make sure it's um doable I mean I don't know I've heard mixed things about I think we've had a different service at least one of our schools and I know I've heard some real mixed things from staff on that so I don't know I think it'd be a good thing to do thank you Mr Lee appreciate you being here my pleasure thank you all for the time appreciate you all nice to meet you all thank you um I have a quick question um K you turned in a a comment card but we had already been past comment would
083would you like to comment now or would you like to comment at another at another item tell me your preference okay and if I forget will you you know just let me know okay um so we are on to 12b lcap midyear update Dr beats yes good evening um part of the requirements of the lcap process is to bring to you a midyear update um so I'm going to do that now I need to we're gonna wait for okay so as I was saying um part of the process is to bring you a midyear update and the purpose of that is to really talk about implementation and Effectiveness uh so far this year um just to remind you the lcap has many different points so we have to engage educational Partners we have to monitor
084our metrics and um indicators we have goals actions and services that we need to implement and we have to keep track of our budget as you know we have four lcap goals uh goal one and four are around uh social emotional wellness and belonging and equity and our two uh middle goals goals two and three are our academic focused goals the next two slides are and I'm going to go through this relatively fast because we've talked about the elap a lot but I'm happy to stop it any point um the next two slides are just a reminder of the actions and services that live inside of each of our lcap goals and the items in blue are the ones items that are paid with one-time funded dollars um I won't read all of these to
085you did you have any questions about the actions and services okay um so the next series of four slides are are a screenshot of how we monitor our progress on every single action in service and so in the lcap we have what I call the large uh Rock data point so that's our Casp scores our suspension rates all of that bless you um but additionally our lcap team has identified um micro pieces of data to really monitor not the uh goal as a whole but the implementation of each action and so the the big rock data points really monitor how are we doing collectively on that goal with all of the actions and services and these data points really are focusing on more individual uh actions if that makes sense and so this is just
086a screenshot to show you that between ed services student services and special education we really monitor all of these different components in a variety of ways and I'm happy to bring back to you any of the more in-depth data on um any of these if you would like part is if it comes from the supplemental Grant exactly Source yes so the spreadsheet I have on this is has a lot more information on it but one so when it says yes under supplemental that is paid with that uh supplement supplemental dollars okay thank you you're welcome and so of course in goal two um and three those are our academic uh um goal a lot of the actions and services are monitored both by looking at our Casp data which is our sort of our summative
087data it comes once a year after that year is ended but we also have nwea which we know is a real U uh predictor of how we do on Casp and so what I would like to do is just take a couple of slides to show you the I'm going to go in deeper with that data point and so um on the left grid is last year's so the nwea we gave in the fall of 2023 and basically the way this works is it gives us an achievement goal of course and a growth goal but it also tells us if we stay on this trajectory we predict that each of those grade levels would score about that uh range on the Casp test when they take it in the spring okay so if you look
088at grade three three um if we stayed in that trajectory um n nwea was predicting we'd be at about 52% meets and exceeds when we take Casp and then on the right hand column you can see what we actually did on Casp and so um in most areas we are doing better than what nwea predicted a couple areas uh we didn't do quite as well over on the right side um you can see that same project and based on our fall data and then um we also pulled it again in our winter we just finished giving the winter um uh nwaa monitoring so you can see that we have some if we stay on the same trajectory where we would expect to be with Cas and this is for our reading um Ela okay and
089then um the next slide is just a snapshot of our Ela growth and achievement so the top band is growth and you can see the distribution because remember nwea shows how did we do from test point to test point and then it also shows achievement level and so the bottom band is our achievement which is um we're in around the 53rd which is where we've been with Casp right around that 50th percentile for growth and achievement here so we definitely want to keep working on that this is another way to look at that data so this is um our growth data and you've seen this slide in previous uh presentations that triangle is what our Target growth was for each grade level and the blue band shows did we meet that Target and so almost
090in almost every grade level in ela we have met that Target we have a couple areas we're going to continue to look into whoops uh oh there we go hit the wrong button um and then the same for Math and as as uh has been historical in this District we perform better in math than we have been doing in Reading um and so again on the left side was last Fall's the 2023 um projection and then you can see how we actually did on the test in May and then the right hand chart really talks about this year's projections based on nwaa where we may be with Casp should nothing change and then again our uh growth band on the top and our achievement on the bottom and one of the things I wanted to
091um shout out and point out is in math we have we're at the 68th percentile for growth so that's pretty good and then achievement you can see that left bar uh we were at the 58th percentile of for achievement in math in the fall Administration and we bumped up to 65th percentile so those are the kinds of gains that we're looking to make and our teachers are uh doing a great job really um working on all of these uh components with the different curricular pieces that we have that attached to this and again here's just another way to look at our growth data yes sir nwaa is it you do the fall winter and spring yes and it is it the same test for the grade level so if it was theoretically you'd have the
092hardest time in the fall and you'd get better as you went through more of the curriculum the test just like on Casp adjusts as you do better it'll adjust the question so it it uh moves as they go if I'm a fourth grader taking the math let's say when I take it the fall is it fourth grade math which I've not had hardly any of so theoretically unless I had some knowledge outside of it I might not do as well but then in the spring after having add 2/3 or 34s to the curriculum I would think I would score much better or am I off that's a great question I'm going to actually toss it over to uh Miss rice do you want to comment on that she's my nwaa expert so good question um
093if you're a fourth grader you do start out with fourth grade material questions but again depending on how you answer whether you're getting them correct it's going to continually um raise the bar for you or if you're missing it it's going to scaffold down so when we see our scores on NWA it's in comparison to the mean of the national average or it actually goes outside of the United States now so um they give a score which is uh RIT so it's that scale score which gives you a comparison of where you are um in regard to your grade level but it really gives us a lot of data as far as breaking down the standard and where the kids are ready to learn so it scaffolds more than cast but does thank you you're
094welcome she can tell that much more eloquently than I can um so again uh in math you can see that every single grade level hit their growth Target and that is awesome that's amazing and so that's just a kind of a deeper dive into one of the areas of progress monitoring that we do around the different actions in the lcap um just the rest of the information that I'll go through quickly is um just the implementation of all the actions so partially implemented uh some parent Series so we haven't done as full one as we've done in P in previous years but we have had a couple of parent series and I know that we have another one coming up um college and career counselor is one of the actions in the lcap and that
095has been a position that has remained uh primarily unfilled this year so we have filled it uh in with some contractors um throughout but it hasn't really been the way that it was intended and um data and assessment to drive instruction again that is a work in progress so our our staff are looking at data constantly setting goals doing all that great work but we're not uh fully implemented in that uh grading for equity and conferences we have paused this year it was uh we've been dabbling in looking at grading at the secondary level with small pockets of teachers and we did not just honestly we didn't have the capacity to really launch it off well and so we just decided to take a pause at this moment in time the rest are being fully
096implemented and we are on track for all the budgeted items add a the grading for Equity I think you know it'd be good to let people know what that really is you know there's a lot of it's a hot button issue yes it is and there's a lot of different ways to look at hot button issue that a lot of people especially oldtimers don't like yep absolutely it's it's a very complex topic and we started dabbling with people that are trying out different things but it was with everything else we had going on we weren't doing it justice the way we were trying and that that's something you want to do justice it's like uh when you talk about uh God what's a restorative justice if you don't do it right you kill it you
097kill anybody's desire to do it because it comes out people already are on edge and then if it doesn't come out right then it goes bad fast experience maybe you could give us the short and sweet just explain grading for Equity just real quick is there a short I know there is no short and S you can try I will I will be happy to um and so it really looks at a lot of different angles for grading and it's it talks about the scale so um one of the ways to look at it is uh we grade on a zero to 100 scale typically traditional um grading scale and an um a b to an a is 10 points a c to a b is 10 points but a zero but an F is
098a zero to a 59 yeah so that's one piece right off the top is just mathematically the scale is skewed so it takes you can five times you can fail five times more than you can get an A if that makes sense because there's 50 almost 60 points there um so that's one piece another piece of for Equity may be linking it to standards and progressions and what does that look like another piece may be having conversations around um retakes and redus when you give tests another uh piece can be around looking at what the weight is how much weight do you give a test versus homework versus classwork all of those things and really trying to um come up with a system that is Equitable for all students because what we know and I
099think is is probably fair to say that while we have some policy around some of that class to class subject to subject it varies greatly with how things are done in terms of what things are weighted what who allows you to do something again versus not so there's a lot of differences there so that's a very nutshell theoretically in a geometry if you have three geometry teachers let's say that the grading system should be the same across and what they cover the weights should be the same and it's not always the case so like if you move from one class to another you know it's a whole it should be seamless but it not always is and that's more fair too right I mean some kids get in one class and yeah it's yeah so
100so we're having the conversations but in terms of an initiative um we've just paused because we when we do it as you said uh trusty Meli we want to do it the right way and and really engage people in the convers the grading scale SE uh president grubs is the grading scale is the one that really if you get a room of teachers together will get things going I mean if you think about it like you said 0 to 59 is I mean if you went on a rubric scale like a one to five where each thing had an equal amount 20% at each band that would make but you know I'll say I was guilty for a long time going hey when I was in school it was 0 to 59 just don't fail
101you know and you got to get out of people out of that mindset because it's it's a hard ask because a lot of people it when I went to school it was this way and it was good enough for me so why are you changing it now you know and there's that concept that people think that you're lowering the standards but and you're making it easier you're not holding kids accountable which isn't true but it's something a lot of people think I mean I've been there oh my wife and I go rounds on this because she is a she's a real proponent of it and I never have been not saying that she's wrong but I get it it's not in public any not in public I'm not going to say she's wrong I think
102she shifted a little I think she Shi you a little bit from what I'm here I get it a little bit more absolutely and the last part of just wrapping this up is kind of The Next Step so we are continuing to look at data we have a little bit more surveying to do uh we'll an um Analyze That feedback and then we'll bring to you a draft um of the lcap in um I think it's June this year for a public hearing and then we'll bring it back for adoption any questions you know there was one question I neglected to ask when you were on the slide and you even asked for questions on the actions and services the ones that are highlighted as being used in one-time funds You're just showing us what's
103onetime funds it doesn't mean that they're they're not going to be around no I just that's the way I just like people to see that there's just different funding sources okay you are up again for uh 12C data accountability exactly thank you um so one of the things that we know is that our California dashboard I did a presentation on that I think at our last board meeting or it was the one before which has all of the different state priorities from academic to suspension chronic absenteeism graduation right all of those that's our accountability and it's both a state accountability and a federal accountability and so I wanted to just briefly kind of talk with you about the two different accountability systems and let you know where we are um with that here as a
104district and so um our state accountability process is called differentiated assistance and that is based on our performance on the California dashboard basically one student group um has a red indicator over two different indicators and so um in um so you might have a a student group that's in red for um math and Ela or I'm sorry math Ela counts as one and then maybe chronic absenteeism okay and so they're going to say what do we need to do about this particular student group um the federal accountability is called called there's three three levels one is CSI which I didn't put on this because we don't have anybody in CSI this year that's comprehensive School Improvement and that's kind of the highest level then there's a midlevel and that's atsi which is additional targeted support
105and Improvement and then there's the kind of entry level which is just plain old TSI which is targeted support and intervention and that's required by the every student succeeds act federal law um and this one is a little bit different so it's accountabil is based on an underperforming student group so it's again it uses the California dashboard two years but the um uh it can be different indicators or so it doesn't have to be the same indicator but the student group has to be in red for two years and then there's a three-year cycle where you they make the determination but you can exit once we meet all the criteria so once our student groups move out of that red we should be exited um we do have to have a plan we have to
106call out all of that within the lcap so it's all linked to that as well and there's some compliance monitoring our county is the one that implements the Federal Regulation as well how many people do you need in a group to be a student group that you count I mean obviously if you have one person I doubt they would count uh I believe it's it's um I had that on the last presentation I think think it's 30 is the student group to get a color 30 students it's either 20 or 30 and I'd have I would think would be maybe a percentage of your how many kids you have no it's a certain amount do can you ask your question maybe I misunderstood your question well no you know like if you have one or
107two kids but then I was thinking if there's a certain number 30 kids would be St statistically significant in a district of a th000 kids versus a district of 20,000 kids so I was wondering if maybe there was a percentage thing as opposed number until you get I don't know what the calculation is behind it but in order to get a color on the dashboard there has to be 30 students okay thank you at least 30 students in that group thank you so we are in differentiated assistance this year I actually um shared that with you last time it is for our students in special education for their academic so Ela and math counts as one and then um College and Career Readiness and I shared that last time so what does that mean that
108means that we're working with our County Office we're ident uh doing some data digs with them with all of our administrators we're brainstorming some next steps and things that we can do they will come here and help support us in any way that we need uh through training professional development um looking at data program implementation and so forth um you can see over on the right uh where that uh student group performed so it was um 88 points below what they said standard was in ela and 96 points below Below in math and uh only 4.3% of our students in special education were College and Career ready and just to be fair that um indicator dipped quite a bit this year and so we're I'm working with the high school to um really unpack the
109why behind that we are also in we have two schools um the other thing I want to just know is a differentiated assistance is at the district level and then um CSI TSI atsi is at the school site level so bonisha high school is in atsi for suspensions of African-American students and Matthew Turner is in TSI for suspensions for socioeconomically disadvantaged students um for suspensions and their chronic absenteeism okay and so same type of process we get notified I have to I'm required to notify the site they have to include this information in their single plans for student achievement so when that comes to you this spring you're going to see some of that information um we have to use evidence-based strategies we have to identify if there are inequities um and then we get
110monitored by the county office and one of the ways they monitor I believe and I haven't received official notice of this but they do Williams um compliance walks which is when they walk around to make sure that all students have textbooks and so forth um and so uh that's how we performed on those two um uh accountability measures and so our next steps is just um some of the things that we've already started doing is our partnership with inclusive Strate for inclusive strategies um we're working uh with supporting inclusive practices which is an a grant funded organization that has come and done some work with our administrators already um we are working with our special education teachers and classes making sure that they have uh the Core Curriculum and they have training in that um
111we are going we haven't done this yet but we will be reviewing our courses at the high school to make sure that and um when I say tagging in calpads that is one of the ways that we keep track of what all the classes are and that's what gets sent to the state and um uh uc's and CSUS to make sure that any class that can be tagged for a CTE or a um uh deemed as like a dual enrollment type of class something like that is tagged correctly so that we get credit for that because those are some of the ways students get deemed College and Career ready um and then we also want to look at are there other CTE courses out there that we could offer that may be more accessible because
112we have a lot of amazing CTE courses at our high school engineering Medical Careers paths so they have some real high academic rigor and not that we want class classes with low academic rigor but there may be some that may be more accessible for some students like such as Hospitality or something along those lines so we're looking at that and then on the behavior side um we're meeting with our administrators and our director of uh student services to really look at what are the requirements around Behavior other means of Correction besides suspension when do we use suspension what else do we need to do so that we can educate students and be proactive um one group that we have not gotten flagged for but that we are paying attention to uh because it is a
113new student group that the state is monitoring are called long-term English Learners and those are students that have been with us as English learners for seven years or more and haven't mastered the lpac test yet to be reclassified as um uh English fluent and so they are struggling and we're watching where we are in that data monitoring to make sure that we don't end up in a um accountability measure for them as well any questions okay thank you and we are on to uh 12d um M Miss Baron you are up so good evening this is the point in our budget development annual cycle where the district brings forth its initial um projections for enrollment for the next year so what you have before you is a historic document that you have seen each year
114that has been updated for what we believe our enrollment is likely to look like in the 25 26 year so to get to these projections each grade level starting with our current kindergartners was moved up to the next grade so kindergarten was moved to first first to second and our 12th graders that are graduating out of the calculation um that then leaves us with the incoming TK and the incoming kindergarten which is the hardest group to project and predict so we took a conservative Approach at this time until it's known more how our enrollment is going and enrollment for next year just started this past Saturday um we're projecting um as conservative as we can since it drives our funding um this will be updated we will bring it back to you it won't only
115be annual um I have conversations with Dr Wright to over the next few months as we progress in our development of the budget for next year to update the board on how our enrollment looks um at this time uh because our lower kindergarten class will continue to go through each year we are projecting that we will continue to decline an enrollment potentially up to another 52 students lower than we are currently so when I first looked at this I looked at like cave through five we're down 60 students when I read that I thought 60 students left but that's not necessarily accurate it's because you're rolling over so if we're not bringing in new students into kindergarten or TK then we're not realizing then we're effectively losing students just because we're not bringing them in
116because bisha is built out and we don't have as many kids correct and so um one aspect of our enrollment is um that 15% of our students come from outside the boundaries of bisha um which upwards of almost 600 of our overall kids are from outside um so what we did not do was assume we're going to get the same number of kids applying for idas at the TK and kindergarten level so we will realize them when they're real but we can't assume that there is another group of these students that will come and apply to be in our district they may the numbers moving from 5th to 6th could change our idas reapply um new may come in from 8th to 9th our idas reapply new may come in if if it's if it
117works within the um practices that that are done to review those idas but at this time from kindergarten through 12 they were rolled up to the next level and then we conservatively projected for kindergarten and our potential the TK is adding the June July and August that's the remaining band of um months that are missing so those are kids that will turn four so those kids are on the younger end just a followup um I mentioned one potential reason why we have declining enrollment which is you know we don't have any new homes here we're also it's expensive to live here so young families can't afford to move here um are there are you looking at any other reasons why I mean do or do you have a sense for why enrollment is declining Beyond
118those are you looking at that we've looked those those are the main reasons okay um we don't know of other reasons is a very desirable District to be in as we see when we have the number of people that apply to come be in the district um but it really is the uh families that come they stay and age out you know what would be nice uh for future reference on this list going back to 1112 through 2425 then 25 through 26 I mean the 25 26 projections right now like you said it's conservative projection for me to be able to really read it it would have been nice to have the calpads enrollment than what the estimated enrollment was and then what the actual enrollment was to see trend-wise did we generally underestimate overestimate
119or hit it you know I don't even know if we have the old projections but for me to be able to read it I mean just trend-wise it'd be be cool to be able to say okay well we seem to when we estimate we seem to be in the ballpark or when we estimate it always ends up you know cuz I remember 22 23 I mean yeah we only got eight more kids but remember uh we were Tim was estimating you know a loss of like 80 or 90 so to know how it usually it'd be cool if we could do that I can speak to what you saw as your projection a year ago for 2425 thought it would be flat at the time of that projection by the time it got to the
120budget being presented there had been a lot of conversations about the increase in the number of months for TK so a growth projection was used um as you can see we actually have fewer students this year than we did last year right um but a lot of that has to do with rolling the grades and then trying to project how many kindergarteners in and TK students are going to come do our do our kindergarteners and TK students do they tend to do those families tend to stay in through high school or do we have a um do we have are we losing students at a particular grade level so at my level I can see that the grade the class of gr you know the grade your kindergarten class if it had 289 if it
121if it continued all the way down I can say yes they're staying I think that would come more maybe from student services or on the Ed side of the house um are they the same 289 kids that I don't know I don't know if this is on your side of the house I can try I'm curious to know if we have an idea of what the local areas enrollment rates are like Vallejo Martinez conquered and those public school districts you know is their enrollment also decreasing and also curious to know the bonisha and bonisha area private schools what their enrollment is looking like are they having higher enrollment um versus us having lower enrollment and we can pull that data and bring it back I do know just in California in general most districts a
122lot of districts are in decline in enrollment because a lot of people are leaving the state because cost of homes in Bish are expensive but they're expensive everywhere in California and many people are leaving the State yeah this this might not once again be on your side of the house but I'm curious to know what we're doing to talk about TK in the community and really encouraging our families and you know advocating for USD schools to be part of their um thought process as they're thinking about where their children go Absolut I can talk a little bit about that um I know that we have enrollment happening right now and we have an ad out in the newspaper um our uh website has been updated to include that information our local preschools know though there's
123a little tug of war because they want to keep their foury olds as much as we want to get their fouryear olds um we did put um information about the difference between preschool and TK on our website so that families can make that choice um uh so those are some of the things that we've done and we started talking about what else can we do um to make sure that we get the word out but I think a lot of people do know and I think they for the years when we came back from covid and we thought um if you remember if you were on the board way back when we thought by this point we would have three TKS at every grade level because it would be like another grade level and they
124didn't come nearly as fast um and part of that I think was returning from covid and getting all of that so it'll be interesting to see where this goes um now that they can be four by September 1st um and and that just becomes the norm instead of this rolling month piece my last question is I think it would be a good use of time to just talk with maybe some of our teachers some of our principals some of our admins in regards to maybe what their thoughts are about enrollment um you know I know we talk a lot about the expense of California Etc but there are a lot of people who are interested in moving here and interested in looking at banisha and so I think you know sometimes introspective looking at ourselves
125to see if there are some ideas or some things that we can fix within ourselves to ensure that we are getting our community members here in VD that's all the questions thank you thank you so miss beron you're still up Miss barington excuse me so you're going to uh review the governor's January budget proposal for 2526 yes so on um January 10th Governor Nome released his proposed budget for the 2526 year and then staff from bonisha attended the school Services um of California presentation on the budget and the budget language they had the ability to review at that time on January 21st a more language has come out in some of the trailer bills it hasn't necessarily changed what came out in the presentation it's given some clarity and added some questions right um so
126different this year the governor wasn't present for the release of his budget there were fires in LA and that is where he was um also he was attending a funeral so that that was the the priority and absolutely the right priority um the the budget is not much different than last year except that um educ for the most part is being funded on an ongoing basis not a one-time basis um there was a lot of conversations about um the Maneuvers that were done last year to fund prop 98 which is our majority of the funding um those aren't present but what is noticeable is there's still $1.6 billion dollar that didn't make it into the 2526 projections that have to do with the ongoing funding we would be entitled to so that is one of
127the things we are watching even in the trailer language um that's still noticeably missing it's kind of an IOU but not so they're not giving us our prop 98 not all of it that we would be entitled to based on how prop 98 is funded because they suspended it for last year in 2324 cuz they couldn't um so this year it's done with some withdrawals from the the the savings account and um you know growth in the state but prop 98 is benched and then it's supposed to continue on and so there's some makeup that has to technically occur so we'll we'll watch to see how that's addressed between now and the May RIS what happens if they don't make it up they don't make it up oh they eventually like it it yes or
128they will change the funding formula because the local control funding formula came into effect prior to that was Revenue limits so you can always change the mechanism too which reches dollar amounts too so it's one of the things we will definitely watch um so this really just points out that um it's ongoing money the state has done better at replenishing what they borrowed from the the set asde account they have and it's there for that purpose you know we can greatly appreciate Governor Brown doing that so we're not sitting here if there's a massive decline in the state there is some sort of protection to help the budget um and it is projected at this point to fully fund the cola which came out at the 2.43% the greatest risk risk to the budget is
129what's locally done with the budget because of the one-time funding that is ending that's really coming to the Forefront that kind of hid how the funding has been in the state because there was such an infusion of funds that let a lot of things be done so every year the funding factors are updated and you can see there's a um base Grant amount per Ada for the certain grade bands there's an amount that the cola would generate changing the base grant for 2526 there's the grade span adjustment and then there's the the supplemental which all districts get and the concentration which you have to be above 55% of your unduplicated count so we do not qualify for the concentration funding level there and there is a proposal that's not written in as funded but it
130is a proposal at this time time to almost double the TK add-on to fund the staffing change that goes into effect next year where it goes from 12 to1 to 10:1 so TK has to be 10 to1 adult with a 20 Max in a classroom and one of those adults must be the teacher and then the other an adult that meets the qualifications but it's not two teachers to a classroom it's a teacher and an eight but the cap is 20 it's not an average it's 20 you go over or you're under in your Staffing there are massive penalties it's not the same as the TK the K3 where it's an average of the 24 to one so that number is in red because it's something we absolutely have to watch and be cognizant of
131whether or not it's built into the budgets uh this is one of the slides that was included to discount to talk about um what's the real change been in lcff so you can see how much um lcff has been augmented starting in 22 23 there there there was the cola and an augmentation and then the kind of grade band is what really happened so um the the governor will say Cola and but then it really depends on how many kids there really are how much truly gets funded out to districts so this is just pointing out how much is brought forth and how much really is the increase that is seen um in lcff so taking a look at last year 8.22 was the cola but really lcff went up by 6.33% Statewide say is
132this Statewide yes this is yeah this is this is not bonisha this is Statewide yes yes as well as the decline in actual attendance at school so 8.22% means same kid 100% of the time so you don't have the kids and you don't have the attendance then there's there's a difference in what actually goes out so you can see it's not really exactly known how 2425 is going to hit because we're funded based on P2 which means attendance through April 15th so after April 15th we'll know how we did attendance wise um did we stay around 94% did we get closer to 95 um and that's when you're actually determined if you're funded on your current year your prior year or the threeyear average which is whichever is greater so it's being monitored all year
133long but it's not locked in until April 15 when the year is almost over so what does this really mean for bisha at this point so what this does is this takes a look at our projected enrollment we're still assuming around 94.5% we haven't seen our Ada jump any higher than that and just comparing year to year and what that actual Cola looks like so if it's same students 100% of the time you should see um The 2.43 Base to Base and there are add-ons in lcff so there's more funding than just this it's at this time showing that it's not actually for Us increasing by 2.43% it's closer to the 2.38% and at this time the there has been more and more coming out even from the legislative analyst office that 2.43 might not
134be it it could be lower the governor could choose to funded at 2.43 but Cola really could come in lower than the 2.43% um at this time last year it was less than a percent and it did increase um similar conversation this year at right now it looks like it there's still two more indicators to come in and with the delay of taxes having to be paid for half of the State of California we may not exactly know how Cola shakes out entirely for funding purposes in our state but we will see it may revise what is said and then what is adopted in the budget this is just um a few more factors that go into um the budget and the budget planning you can see the cola that's projected for next year and
135the out years uh please take a look at how much higher those colas look right now um if you remember back way back when a few years back when you saw 2425 it was close to 5% and you can see it came in at 1% so we use the factors in our projections because they're the best known and they're the standard that are used but know that in the out years the revenue may not be that great it is possible and then uh for now stirs is still at the 19.1 %c and Calpers is ever increasing and for now we'll know in April when they actually vote and and can see how their Investments are going so those are the projections the dark board is what districts typically use to build your budget because it's
136a standard set and it's agreed upon so it's not I think CPI is going to be this it would look towards the standard set some of the other things that were in the proposed Governor's budget and these are all proposed um The Learning recovery emergency block grant that's not new that's something that came out in 2022 and if you're remember the district received its full funding amount and then the governor in the next year's budget said I'm going to take some of it back so you took some of it back but there was information in the the original law that it would then get funded in the future um and if it's funded or you still had some remaining you get to do this great assessment in many categories for your lcap and build in
137a goal um we had thought that we wouldn't be subject to that because we used our funding sources in sequential order um but little wrinkle we don't know that we'll actually get the money but we have to do the work so uh Dr beatson and her staff will be doing the assessment um writing a goal and we potentially could get the balance that would be due to us if it's based exactly on when it was taken back it's just over 300,000 and they would disperse it over three years but they could change how they're dispersing it so it's not quite known yet what we will or will not be entitled to wait so we have to write the goal do we have to do anything with the goal once it's written if we don't get
138the funding it's my understanding is it's an action go that's all right it's an action I don't know the answer to that right now I'm doing the needs assessment um that they so this is a proposed additional amount of money one time that might be funded in the budget this is another proposed um onetime discretionary block grant that may make it into the final adopted uh state budget um at the time the slide was done it said the allocation methodology is not yet specif ified the um trailer Bill language said it might be distributed based on Ada percentage and if it that holds true and everyone is considered equal it could be $327 per Ada it's a lot of ifs it's some something we need to plan for but not budget and do yes and
139it would again be one-time funding um it's really it disappeared um it it's it's oh it's back um it's a it's kind of the stop Gap measure because everybody's really being hit with the onetime dollars are gone and there's a lot of great programs and services that have put in been put into place so this could help they do have some priorities they'd like you to use it for but it doesn't have those kind of restrictions on it but it's not yet known if it will happen there's also some proposed investments in literacy and that has to do with the dyslexia screenings it might get funded um at this time it's not guaranteed but we still have to do it yes I was G to ask yes sorry I I went past that really fast
140but yes so we still have to do it and to do it something we have to be in and that's starting in the fall yes we have to bring forward to you by June uh this the state has come out with a list of um acceptable uh screeners for uh reading difficulty screeners we have to choose one so we're in the process of looking at them right now we'll bring them to some staff to look at um and then we have to bring that to you for adoption by June with implementation in the fall for all K uh three students there are some with no cost is that correct there is one with no cost no matter what it's an unfounded unfunded mandate that may make it in the budget but may not also there's
141a proposed change to how elop the expanded learning opportunities program has funded right now um if you're on duplicated uh percentage is above 75% there's a specific dollar amount you get and every else everybody else below that gets a different dollar amount they're proposing to to change the bar to everybody who 55% or higher gets that set amount and then everybody else who's below 55% would get the balance of what is or is not left distributed and so we would fall in the lower because we're below 55% so at this time um there's no projected dollar amount to use to budget for the ELA program so this is the advice School Services gave to all of the um superintendents cbos assistant Hoops of ed services and HR in the room the only thing you should
142budget for at this time is the projected Cola because that's the one thing that is most likely will be funded at that level more than likely the other items pay attention to what continues to come out be ready for um they're one time in nature for the most part except elop which we have to continue to do regardless of our funding um and then build those in if they're in the May revise and then hold on and see if it makes it in the June 15th past state budget are there any more questions that I might be able to answer you just mentioned June 15th so my question is timeline yes okay so you mentioned there there's like an adopted budget and then it's budgeted and received is that fair to say that those are
143kind of like the categories so there's a Governor's proposed budget in January okay he gets to revise it by May 15th and then he and the legislators get to adopt it by June 15th with a nice lovely trailer Bill afterwards that actually defines what they're really going to do and it goes into effect July 1 got it we have to have a um presented and adopted budget by June 30th right outside of what's actually occurring with the state budget got it and then receive just sort of sounds like it just kind of fluctuates I mean we get certain funding based on um our majority of our funding the low control comes in um proportionate based on an advanced apportionment that looks at your prior year data gives you your allocation up until the end of
144February then it's certified um um using current year P1 um attendance and then you're funded on that through June but then your funding gets rebased based on your P2 attendance for your June allocation which as long as everything's okay and you haven't been overfunded you get the remaining balance if it comes time by June you've been overfunded they take it back and P1 and P2 period one period too yes sorry so we collect attendance through um December 30th and we report it in January through April 15th and we reported in April and that that April 15th sets the actual funding and then we do it in again in July through the month of June because there's a few things that are actually funded on annual very few okay thank you and then you mentioned that
145sometimes the state will take say no never mind we're actually not going to give you that money do they do that like after we we've already budgeted uh right and we're going along and we're getting our allocations like could they just decide not to fund a certain amount at any time after we've already not after they adopt their budget okay and that's why it's cautious of anything that's proposed as a um a a new program or a want by the governor in January if it's not very solid it's you plan for it but you don't you don't hire and staff based on it because it could come out in May it could come out in the adopted budget in June and you wouldn't be able to adjust your Staffing for any additional monies okay may
146yes yes they don't get paid yes and Markus correct it's normally May is indicates June except in covid when they said they were going to cut everybody's budget and then thankfully didn't by the time they adopted it okay you're welcome at this time um we are C we're coming up to um 9 o' we have an hour but is there anyone who would like to make a motion to extend the meeting past nine o'clock if that tends to hap if that happens I move the weeks send the be meeting past 9 o' if necessary I second I I any oppose thank you um so now we come to uh 12f comprehensive Financial Outlook and strategies for fiscal stability so we have quite a few comments um and I'd like to start there so Alexis can
147I ask is it possible to go out of order since this is going to be the one we're going to spend a lot of time on could we do the action items and then come back or no because this is going to be the one I think that's going to be take time take all the time or is that not allowed we' have to V all right I just we're going to be here for a while so I was wondering if it'd be easier just to get the other business out of the way so when we finish 12f we're done so even though it's normally done at the beginning of a meeting can we do it could we do it now anyway or is it simply not loud it's a big deal I don't want
148to push you I would just say it does let it go I don't want to push it I was just curious it was possible so we'll let it go so Let It Go um Alexis harmer you're up hello and thank you my name is Alexis harmor and I work at bonisha Middle School Li in the library it's Library Tech I'm here to talk to you a little about uh libraries as my job in 1.5 of the elementary libraries are um in the slides for the budget cuts uh ala American Library Association has a pamphlet that school strong School libraries build strong students there's 20 studies 21 studies that they have um listed where School libraries support student achievement and that reading scores follow Library Investments so the more invest you put in your library the
149better the reading scores are primarily students come to my library with their classes the teachers greatly prefer to bring all their classes in one day so it doesn't disrupt their instruction uh I do book talks and I know that the elementary Librarians do Story Time where our excitement for books and stories and character may lead to students um becoming more interested in Reading especially for those who don't like to read or may not have books at home I know that our my military sorry Elementary School compatriots also I've seen remnants of their steam activities that they run in their libraries I wanted to share with you there are seven benefits of reading and listed among those are critical thinking communication skills concentration empathy literacy self-discovery and stress reduction so here's are the things that's keeping
150me up lately at night if my position and the elementary school librarian positions are cut where are my students going to go before school where are they going to go during school where are they going to go at lunch where are they going to go after school where I help run the homework help Club Monday through Thursday with the help of Our National Junior Honor Society students who are very kind and want to help their fellow students where is the person going to be for in her Library loans from our public libraries how are we going to get books from the public libraries to our library and where are the students with accomodations going to go when they need a quiet place to do testing there's not a lot of places on our campus that
151provide that I'd like to thank that Miss Jackson who is um my compatriot at Homework help club without her it wouldn't be what it is she's a student uh teacher Aid and sped program and I'd also like to thank my uh National Junior aiz students and my students who come on a daily basis I'd also like you guys to think about the students who may only come with the class they may only get a book when they come with their class thank you thank you Sue Wing are you here there you are I know hi well good evening governing board Dr Wright and cabinet members um I'm Sue Wing as you know I've been in the district since 2000 all at BMS and um I've been very involved as an employee on committees as well
152as a parent on different committees uh my daughters were both born and raised in bonisha BHS grads classes of 2011 and 12 um well here we go I've been around long enough to remember Furlow days and the layoffs in 2011 uh which I had hours reduced at that time so when you were elected to sit on our board most likely you were hoping to never be part of a time like this but here you are getting ready to make a decision that will change the lives of everyone in the district I see each of you trusty Zeta you know the classified employee uh trusty Meli and grubs you know the class or the teacher and trustees manasse and hsh you know the parents and the students and I have just said your names and humanized
153you to all who are listening I have a request for you and all the cabinet members please see us do not say it's the position not the person we already know it's the position but each position has a real person with a name we are all scared right now we are all thinking is it me is it my coworker who's become my best friend will I be bumped by another employee do I go on with my plans to buy the car the house or to take the trip Our Lives will be on hold understand the anger that may come your way is the grief we're feeling and I just want to say I love my B USD family and I truly appreciate each and every one of you and the decisions you're going to be
154making and thank you for listening thank you Chad pond hi uh my name is Chad pound and I've been at Liberty High School for quite a few years now um and I want to say first of all that I really appreciate the way Liberty has been accepted it hasn't always been that way and I love seeing my student here presenting to the board I really appreciated that they were invited and participated in the state of the district so thank you so much for including Liberty um it hasn't always been that way and and I certainly uh just really it is it is important to us it's important to them um I want to speak briefly about our campus supervisor position and specifically about uh our current uh member uh Javier Martinez who's been at this
155been with us for over a decade now and I do just want to make sure that it's clear that he's an important member of our community um he reaches some of those kids that when we try we always try to reach all of our students but we just aren't always able to do so and I think he has definitely helped many of our students graduate so I just want to make sure that we understand his position it goes beyond um just making sure that we are safe but he's also looking out for the students and the student interest um I bet in Liberty like I said for a long time we've always had a campus supervisor um I would just want to make sure that we're reminded of who our students are our students have
156experienced a lot of trauma they're here they're at liberty for a reason they deal with anxiety they deal with uh ADHD and I would love to say that I'm such a great teacher that I can keep my students in the classroom all the time with my great lessons it's not the case um our students need to get up they need to move they need to get out of the hallways occasionally and I want to make sure that we continue to have eyes on them when they are in the hallways um we need we need extra adults I know it's hard um we've had more adults on our campus in the past than we have now I know that we're going to be asked to do more with less in the upcoming year but cutting our
157campus supervisor seems like it's a way to make the staff less safe and the students less safe and I'm really going to Advocate that we avoid that scenario thank you [Applause] Lisa sorryi hello um thank you so much for allowing me to speak I recognize many of you um Dr Wright um Dr beatson Dr Jennings the trustees and of course Miss grubs who was a great teacher for my children um I want to talk about the impact that Elementary School libraries have on their students on their teachers and on the community as the whole sometimes I know we have to make Cuts but we play a really important role not in just literacy but we are a person that sees those students every week from TK all the way through 5ifth there is no other
158role in a school like the librarian position um we make connections with every student um and because of that role we're able to build relationships we don't ask much of the student except for them to bring a book back and even if that doesn't happen we work it out but it's a safe spot for them it's a safe person because we don't ask that much of them we encourage them to read we encourage them to expand what they're thinking we create a community where we read stories about different people and um different um holidays and cultures um we suggest books to students to encourage literacy growth um we visually create displays and bulletin boards that showcase all of our diversity Equity inclusion to help students feel seen and earn I don't know how many times
159in both libraries that I've worked at both at Matthew Turner and at Joe Henderson libraries are the heart of the school so when you take a librarian out or you lessen their hours you're taking a part of your heart away um during our read aloud times we create discussions for connections with classes that showcase stories and topics that classrooms just don't have the time for um we have a a decomposing pumpkin at Joe Henderson and that creates conversations every day of growth and hope and experiments and sometimes they work and sometimes they don't it's just that outside spot that kids can come and be curious um how how can we create lifelong readers if we don't make libraries a priority we also want to acknowledge um that for some students the school library is the
160only Library they're able to make it to um study has shown um that test scores go even higher um when they have a full-time librarian um one thing I also want to talk about is that my daughter Kate actually all my kids when I go out around town people know me hi Mrs sorryi hi Mrs sorry because I'm seen and they know I care about them and I make these relationships mostly so I can get a book in their hand because we all know what a book can do it creates empathetic curious human beings and it's such um oops important time in elementary school thank you so much thank [Applause] you Brianna Marshall good time to piggy back as I am coming as the daughter of the former Joe Henderson um librarian of 27 years
161um so good evening board members um budget cuts are always difficult I understand it's super complex um and I acknowledge the challenging decisions you are going to have to make um I urge you to consider the lasting impact of the decisions on our students I know you guys will I trust you to do that um I'd like to speak specifically to the potential cuts to library Services um again I admit I'm biased as the daughter of a librarian of 27 years um I've had many people like Mrs sari said come up to me and oh my gosh you're Mrs Taylor's daughter you're Mrs Taylor's daughter or if I'm with my mom Mrs Taylor um in fact just the beginning of the school year I had a parent come up to me and when she figured
162out that I was Mrs Taylor's daughter she said oh my gosh your mom is why I am a marine bi biologist and your mom is why I went to Berkeley for marine biology um so Librarians are very impactful just through their very presence and their guidance um libraries at particularly the elementary level are invaluable resources they provide a safe space for students to explore engage and discover their interests they teach students to safely research how to think critically and how to utilize resources beyond the classroom for some students the library is their only access to books and educational materials outside of the classroom by reducing or eliminating Library services and Librarians we risk limiting an accessible resource we risk an impacting essential lifelong skills or at the very least burdening teachers with yet another responsibility
163respectfully I ask the board to carefully consider the long-term impact on our students education it's my opinion that libraries are an essential service to our school Community thank you thank you [Applause] Emma Petroski good evening I'm the parent of two girls at Joe Henderson and a son at Panisha high school and I'm here tonight uh to add my voice to those speaking in support of our school libraries um I want to start by all of us asking ourselves in the absence of a librarian who will Aid our class room teachers and finding appropriate resources for their curriculum Librarians spend a great deal of their time learning how to research how to find the information which teachers then teach Librarians contribute to student achievement by collaborating with classroom teachers and providing them with resources to help
164plan and deliver instruction Librarians pay careful attention to things like diversity demographics and the personal individualized needs of the community they serve this is especially critical at a time when young people more than ever need help steering through the overwhelming access to an unlimited amount of information Librarians help our students safely navigate information and find appropriate material to engage them in reading and learning Librarians spend their careers picking and choosing the right books for their communities a population that is never stagnant but grows and changes there are hundreds and hundreds of important meaningful books books that might make our children feel less lonely give them hope show them a new world these books get chosen because a librarian somewhere thought of that one reluctant reader who needed who needed just the right book to open
165her up to a lifetime of reading and learning thank you thank you thank you Alie Hughes good evening board trustees Dr Wright um I'm Kelly Hughes I am um a teacher at Joe Henderson Elementary school um for the past 18 years but this has been my home for my whole life and I've uh know the lasting impact um that a teacher can have but also what a great impact teachers outside of the regular classroom can have like our Librarians and um our steam teachers our colleagues that we we rely on we work together um every day to to serve our students and so I'm also here tonight um just a few hours after returning from four days of outdoor Science school with my fifth graders um because I am worried about the proposed cuts to
166our elementary libraries and our steam class um as an elementary school teacher I see firsthand the incredible impact both have on our young students Elementary School libraries Foster a love of reading in our students as we've heard a especially when you're lucky enough like we are at Joe Henderson to have an amazing librarian who you just heard from Lisa goes above and beyond for her students and if you've never seen her in action I implore you to come and visit and I promise you your minds will be blown like ours are every week um when we visit her with the increasing demands and rigor of our classroom curriculum over the last few years it has been difficult to find time to fit in reading for pleasure which is what kind of reading kids love the
167most so our weekly time in the library has become so special almost sacred and that's not exaggerating um to my fifth graders during our visits they not only have time to read whatever they want but they get to be read too which is huge um and participate in so many engaging literacy activities that pull in even our most reluctant readers I honestly cannot not uh imagine our school or any school any Elementary School without a full-time School librarian and similarly how am I doing in time okay our elementary steam program is setting students up for success in the real world in a world that's centered around Technology and Engineering um in this class students are learning valuable life skills like problem solving perseverance critical thinking and so much more some of our students are starting
168to discover that what they're learning in Steam might be opening doors for them in their future beyond the classroom walls they don't always see what they learn from me in my classroom can be applied to in the real world even though I tell them they will need those time stables at some point but because of our awesome steam teacher Cheryl Lao they can see how what they're learning with her can be applied in their everyday lives and I will Echo what others have said I understand we're facing Financial challenges and that you're being tasked with really difficult decisions and I don't envy you um so I just hope that you will consider all that you're hearing tonight thank you you Che Chow short but loud thank you so much for just giving us an opportunity
169and being transparent in sharing the budget cut and and the reasoning and one of the major reasoning is uh one of the three reasoning listed was uh lower intendance uh um I hope earlier when we talk about the the immigrants policy that will help us address that to to avoid any fears so that put that aside and another one is talking about our lovely librarian I'm a parent as an adult volunteer in the school parent volunteer I guarantee you first of all in we warm welcome invite you to visit our joanderson library it's really relocated in the hard location if open up the door from the office when you set foot on it Dr R has been there you automatically meet yourself and you start sink in with your mind and your soul and Char
170start tipping wow what are those kiddos doing they experience something different from their classroom they we allow them to have indepth thinking and research talk about Luby Bridge we expend each classroom spend some time learning about Ruby bridge but our Librarians spend weeks studying about what booked what story which one is appropriate from the TK to three which one is more appropriate for our fourth and fifth grade she's our consultant so therefore we have a very successful Ruby Bridge walk to school event another like Dr Wright mentioned in his childhood the only role model for African-American being showcased was just athlete same thing can you believe it two years ago when the Plick from scolo they only showcase African American afflick on their pamphlet to send home to the kids many parents are in awe
171right now why so limited however our librarian on the Friday late afternoon 4:00 struggling in front of her desk full Pint of 30 40 africanamerican role model she's struggling which one to pick to put on the wall so they can show the great role model for the kid which is diverse and also impactful giving back to the society can you tell this is all outside of the classroom but it's very inde depth I'm very glad that our kid has such an exposure it is really a great place come and visit her come and visit our library and Jo H handerson you will see the impact that it can bring thank you for listening and another one is we're very curious especially our site console wondering how to qualify to be a title one school um
172um if if any additional data need to be collected our parent Community can help to be the bridge to collect in order to eligible so that we can qualify for more funding so that is another one um anything that our parents can invol we would love to contribute thank you thank [Applause] you um casana Harmon Lee good evening everybody my name is kashana um I've had five kids go through the USD district one the youngest one is currently at Robert simple um I want to say thank you to um president grebs and the rest of the trustees for giving me a moment to speak after it was time um thank you Dr Wright for your statement and your words I know it means a lot to parents and students who are feeling scared and worried
173during the challenging times last week I was contacted by three families regarding racial incidents at our uh bisha high school as well as one of our elementary schools these parents were distraught one speaking to me through tears because they were hurting not only for their own child but for also for the children who are being exposed to racial and derogatory words directed at our Asian community and witnessing gestures like the Nazi salute and being told that it was just a game as we approach spring break I want to remind you that USD students used to participate in a racist and traumatic game for years a game that resulted in two students being assaulted both verbally and physically one was shot with the BB gun multiple times this game was called L Migra and it was
174played for many years labeled as simply a game community members are doing their part by putting on events such as Fiesta Prim Vera which was which happened last year and it was the first year that La migro was not played um there is another Fiesta P P happening this year um Saturday April 5th at uh the First Street Park as things are happening around the world and around us we have to make sure that those type of games are stopped and never have a chance to start again we must stand firm as a community and be clear that we support all children and all children deserve a safe place to learn and grow there are still parents and students who feel like they do not have a voice that their concerns do not matter and
175we must be clear and stand firm that hate has no place here in B USD if we don't stand strong and United in our words and our actions we risk allowing such Behavior to persist my goal as a parent has always been to raise children who do not have to recover from their childhood that should be the BD goal as well to educate children in a safe environment that they do not have to recover from as adults these young humans are a future and they deserve to be supported and protected by the adults around them thank you thank you thank you for all the comments um and Dr Wright we are at 12f and you're up good evening gosh you know um we've got some really good people um in our organization in in our
176community and this is tough um there's nothing easy about this um you hear Dr beats and talk about our test scores and a progress that we've made um and then you hear Miss barington talk about the financial budget coming down from the state level and is complicated um purpose of this presentation today is to have a public conversation about some proposals that we're thinking in order for us to gain Financial stability within our district um these are things that we've been talking about for years um even prior to me being here in 2020 talking about the one-time funding and it has an expiration date and those programs are going to run out to our first interim report that Miss barington highlighted uh $2 million um well deficit spending projected 3 million this year and projected
177an additional 2 million next year um I reiterated some of it at the the state of the district event highlighted some of that just to bring some awareness but tonight um we felt compelled to have this conversation publicly so we're transparent and we can start discussing items towards making some difficult decisions so that's why we're here today and I'm going to tell you it's not an easy one but it's a responsible convers ation that we have to have um any proposal that we put up it's just um initial draft um and any decision that our governing board has to make over the next month trust me it's not going to be an easy one so um we're going to approach this with compassion empathy and care and I just hope that you guys understand that
178um I'm going to move through some of these slides Miss barington did an overview of the budget and um um there's no I don't feel there's a reason for us to um reiterate some of that information so I'm going to skip a couple of slides that I do want to highlight this slide we talked about declin in enrollment I mean we lost 600 students in a course of 10 to 11 years and put that in perspective as we talk about the local control funding formula you know we don't like to put dollar signs to students but we get a base Grant and if a student attends school every day that number is anywhere between $10,000 and $122,000 depending on what grade level they're in you multiply that by 600 and you can see the significant
179impact of declining enrollment and what it's doing to not just bonisha but other school districts in in our state it's it's significant um we talked about our daily attendance our average daily attendance we've been highlighting that Dr John novic who's our director of student services has led campaigns over the last couple of years and our school sites have adopted them um our clerical staff in the front office are making phone calls trying to get students to school and doing a great job um just to give you an idea prior to covid we're about 96% attendance rate um just like all the other districts in the state we took a dip to 92% after the pandemic but some of our efforts were brought up around 94 teetering 95% so we are moving and trending in the
180right directions with our average daily attendance keeping in mind that we're not funded for enrollment we're funded because students show up to school so out of that $10,000 base grant that we get if students aren't comeing to school you start subtracting numbers from that so it's very important that our attend our students attend school not only just for the financial aspect but for the other aspects the education the social emotional wellness and everything else we have to offer our students and the final the the third area that's really contributing to this deficit that we're experiencing seon funded mandates and um there's a lot of them but I think the big one um the noticeable one is special education special education services the growing cost the students needing these Services is a increasing not only in
181bisha but again everywhere and when ID when Ida was first adopted the federal government said that they were going to contribute 40% of their budget to support special education in California to give you an idea they provide about 8 to 10% support so that requires districts to use their general fund to support students with disabilities Now by no they we absolutely should there are students and like I said earlier all means all that's not what I'm getting at I'm just upset that the federal government isn't um I'm advocating for the federal government to fund special education at the level that they need to um so I bring that up and those are three areas that are really really U impacting us right now um I'm going to this slide should look familiar I mean we
182presented this at a couple of governing board meetings in the past uh meetings when I have a dessert with the superintendent um I've shared this slide this is our one-time funding grants so back in 2020 um um pandemic uh California's uh school districts receive more one-time funding than we've ever seen before to address some of the um challenges that came with uh covid and typically uh the rule of thumb is that you don't spend money on ongoing one-time dollars on ongoing costs things that eat but there was so much money coming to school district it really gave us opportunities to put in these programs to really move the needle and support kids and if you look at the growth that we've had over over the last couple of years I'm hardpressed to say that the
183things on this list didn't contribute to that because they absolutely did um downside to that is that um those dollars expire and in 2026 they're going to expire and when we look at uh we received $14 million since 2020 we strategically stretched those dollars out over several years to provide services for our students um and we shared earlier this year that we have enough funding to get us through this year and partially of next year so we were looking at having to reduce about approximately and I say approximately because things shift nothing is ever absolute when you're talking about budget but approximately $700,000 for prior to the 20 would be 25 26 school year next school year um and if you look at this list these are the programs that are funded by one-time dollars
184they organized by our lcap goals sense of belonging those are their programs literacy and Humanities Steam and also equity and we're doing more than that but these are the programs that are attached to the one-time dollars so when we look at that reducing $700,000 those are the programs that we're looking at um Dr beatson uh gosh I want to say November maybe it was October November we really started reaching out to our educational partners and getting feedback there was surveys that were sent out working with the lcap committee um working with um talking with teachers talking with students talking with administrators trying to get a sense on if we had to make reductions what are those areas that we absolutely need to try to continue for another year um so we factored in all of
185that information and we came with this proposal um so bonisha Middle School we have a 20% math coach that we fund through onetime funding it's about $30,000 absolutely did a great job and this this uh math coach um we had new curriculum which was um gosh I'm drawing a blank um thank you CPM math curriculum thank you CPM math curriculum and over a two-year period just really worked with uh the other Math teachers at BMS to learn the curriculum and really just integrate that practice into banisha middle school and it definitely moved the needle I mean if you look at bms's test scores last year you'll be Amed um but we feel that over a 2-year period of time we have great Math teachers at banisha middle school that we feel that they can carry
186that torch and continue the great work that they started over that two-year period of time uh tosa we have a lot of acronyms in in education sorry I should have wrote it out but teacher on special assignment this particular teacher on special assignment through the one-time grants we have Elementary curriculum new curriculum that we implemented this year we're able to take a teacher here to assist with professional development with our staff and also um produce some um curriculum supports for our teachers that that they can incorporate into their classrooms we got a sense that we're going to be able to do this on a one-year basis and it is definitely um serving as a great support for our teachers but we feel like after this school year our teachers will be pretty well versed um
187in that new curriculum and ready to to continue that great work um combination classes um this was a result of covid um sure certainly I'm going to sit here and say that our combination classes best practices absolutely not but they are pretty common um in districts across probably the country but I'll just say the state um um through the onetime dollars we were able to have no combination classes we currently are funding um two teachers um no combo classes um we would have to to take a look at that and right now that's on the on our list um for consideration and then the final one that I want to talk about right now is a new teacher coach um we hired a lot of teachers last year when we had the retirement incentive and
188we were able to fund a new teacher coach to provide some support to uh the incoming teachers to our district again everything on this list is so important um but that's something that we would have to um to consider um and I say that because we haven't found another funding stream for those four areas that I just suggested um so um in this proposal that would be something that we would not be able to bring back next year there's a couple of other um items on this list the first one is a library contract so school districts were required to have a district librarian and bonisha unified we don't have anyone with that credential so we contract with the city of bisha and they serve as our librarian that contract is 25,00 um we understand
189that this is an ongoing cost while we're able to fund it out of our one-time dollars over the last couple of years this is something that we have to continue so we have to figure out a way to move that contract into the general fund and keep that ongoing because it's required by law um band and uh La uh Liberty High School art contract um those are two areas um which we have some space in prop 28 in which the voters um provided funding for for Arts uh were able to move those two areas into um prop 28 funding and we're able to do that because they're sitting in onetime funding if those two areas were sitting in a general fund we wouldn't have the flexibility to move it the prop 28 but because it's
190being funded by onetime dollars we're able to move that ban contract and also the Liberty High art contract into the prop 28 and continue those services so if you look at um The Proposal up there um that's $715,000 if my math is correct um and that will enable us to continue I'm going to go backwards the remaining items on this list for one more year but I have to be very clear this sunsets at the end of next year so after at the end of next year everything on this list goes away and if you look at that list I mean we have some important programs on there we're looking at wellness centers extra supervision at the element elementary schools particularly um Willie be Atkins I mean there's a lot of everything on there is
191important but I just want to be clear the $715,000 proposal is to get us through next year and then after next year everything on that list we don't have a funding source for it so either we find a funding source for it or it's a program that we're unable to offer any questions on a one-time funding I know we've had a lot of conversations over the years regarding um one-time funding when you say end of 26 does that mean June 30th 2026 June 30th 2026 so I'm talking um school year yes um Miss barington um she highlighted um the budget so I'm just going to quickly go over this this just should this is our unrestricted fund so when we're talking about our general fund our unrestricted fund um when we started this school year
192we had about $9.8 million uh beginning balance we get our lcff and other revenues but predominantly our lcff funding we have 51.2 million um and then when you look at our expenditures we had an expenditure of 43.7 and some change and then when you the contribution to the restricted that's what we talked about some of those unfunded mandates particularly special education those are funds from the general fund that we have to put over to the restricted funds in order to support those programs um so in if you look at it we're operating or we're projecting at the end of the year to operate at a $3 million deficit and if you look at 25 26 and 26 27 you're going to see a common theme um it's a 1.9 and a 1.3 deficit in the
193outer years and these are projections things change and I say this that those projections are what they are if nothing changes if our enrollments exactly the same if our average daily attendance is exactly the same um you miss barington talked about the 2.43% cola that's projected that we'll know a little bit more in May if that Cola you know um I know that talking about salary increases and reductions at the same presentation it's it's a little problematic but I do want to just say that if there's a conversation about any type of salary increases then you have to take a look at that deficit and it's just going to increase it because that's not factored in and I just this also doesn't Factor in for 2526 any reduction in force or any Cuts right it
194does not it does not so yeah all the cuts we're talking about would chip away at those numbers that is correct um and and and trusty Meli uh again the these numbers show if nothing change if everything stays exactly the same and we know with Cola um sometimes it goes up and down our enrollment goes up and down so we're projecting a conservative enrollment Mount next year but if it comes in lower then that deficit is going to it's going to race but then again we could get an influx of students on idas then it it it it it changes accordingly so as we say that nothing is ever absolute when you're talking about budget for those reasons it's a lot of factors um you know when we talked about addressing deficits um we often
195talk about Cuts but I just want to just remind our community that we're also talking about strategies to generate Revenue as well um our intendance campaign we highlighted that um a bit ago with Dr OIC and our school sites really really encouraging students to attend school um I want to talk about the short-term independent study contracts that we're doing um earlier this year the state of California they change Ed code so if a student misses one day of school we can do a short-term independent study contract to recruit that ADA if you're able to notify the school that they're going to be absence prior to the absence and our school sites have been done a phenomenal job I'm trying to think off the top of my head how many 88 days I want to say
196it's about 2500 Dr OIC is that about right just over 2500 88 day Ada days that we were able to recoup and there's another 579 pending so I know that um our our school sites our uh front office are doing a phenomenal job I think we're walking through where we we today we were at um um simple um and we were walking through the office and just eard dropping on on a conversation with the the front office oh they're going to be absent I'm going to send you the short-term independent study contract and it was automatic those little things one at a time make a big difference in the long run so we're just going to continue that practice um I've publicly in a couple of uh state of the district I've had um um
197you know dessert with the superintendent meetings we talked about reestablishing the Ed Foundation there seems to be some interest there um we're just looking to create space so we can have that conversation so we're probably looking at mid-march April to where we can sit down and really get this thing going but those are long-term Solutions because you've got to build an organization and and it's going to take a while to really start generating Revenue but we've got to start today for building for tomorrow and the parcel tax um um planted some seeds about a potential parcel tax we're going to we plan on surveying the community the community in the fall uh for potential 2020 6 um bid so that's another Avenue that we can generate Revenue but understanding that banisha has some tax sensitivity
198but at the same time if we don't at least ask the question and check our community to see if this is willing something that they're willing to support then the answer is always going to be no so we're going to try and if we get told no then we'll figure something else out but this is something that we need to try in my opinion um we talked about I know that Staffing is on everyone's mind but there's some other areas that we also need to consider um we need to do a review of our contracts between now and March 15th every contract that we have in this District to make sure that there are um just just to identify if there's any areas that we could make some reductions and and save some money um
199dedicated substitutes after covid um it was very hard to secure substitutes it was a bidding war amongst amongst school districts um we what we did was we placed a dedicated substitute at each campus so that we know we knew that you're safe you've got one person that can cover a classroom or give you some support if needed but that's also a very expensive option so we need to take a look at that and potentially go back to the strategy that we used prior to the pandemic special education transportation and governing board members I know you may remember this conversation a couple of years ago um we pay 4 $400,000 to transport um a few students with disabilities it's a very expensive model and a couple of years ago we were saying well why don't we
200bring this transportation in house but we really couldn't get traction we've been working hard at this and I know um Steve Phillips our director of special education Alfredo our um director of Maintenance and operations we are currently looking at Vans and they're not the vans that we use right now at the high school just the minivans like a Dodge Caravan nine passenger vans U purchasing a couple of those and using our existing staff to transport students um I think when we looked at this a couple of years ago finding the staff to do it or willing to do it it was tough but we've had a couple of folks approach us and said hey we're willing to do this and it's a win-win if we're able to pull it off it's a win financially because
201it's probably going to cut our our sped Transportation bill in half so we'll be looking at 200,000 versus 400,000 and then it also gives our staff members who are part-time the opportunity to get additional hours that they can qualify for benefits which is their motivation to do so and why not reward people who've been serving our district for a number of years and giving them the opportunity to do that so we're pretty close um you know the hold up on this is is we're waiting on a county um uh not the County Office of Education but salano County they have a program in which they would give us some fleet pricing and they'll also do the maintenance of those van and so we're just waiting for us them to contact get back in contact with
202us so that's in motion so you'll hear more about that um pretty soon stiens um we have a we we have a number of stiens to support programs um we could take a look to see if there's any way we can reduce our stiens I don't know they're all important everything on this list is important traveling conferences um we're not a district that really attends a lot of conference is or does a lot of travel but that's still a conversation that we need to put on a table and have to make sure that um every conference or every professional development activity that we attend is absolutely essential um but um you know we could do everything that I just mentioned under the revenue generation and expenditure reduction but when 92% of U your budget goes
203to staff there's it's impossible to reduce your uh unrestricted budget by $2 million without looking at staff unfortunately so as we approached this first thing that we did we said do we have have we budgeted for any positions that are currently not filled and in looking at that we were able to find U $540,000 um which means that if we do not refill these positions it doesn't impact people so if you look at the B the BHS College and Career counseling Tech that's been unfilled for the most part the entire year um District safety coordinator that was something that remained in a budget because that transition happened early summer uh we had an administrator that was paid um additional $20,000 to do this after hours to do the safety plans that work was transferred to
204the director of student services as part of his regular duties so there's some savings there um we looked at some unfilled teaching positions at at BHS and BMS um uh 450,000 at uh approximately and I'm saying approximately to all these numbers at BHS and about 30,000 at BMS so that total that would give us a total of $540,000 of savings which will not impact anybody currently in a position because these positions remain unfilled we then tried to look at each classification and identify some areas in which we felt that it's while it's not ideal and it's going to be extremely difficult but areas that we can reduce so looking at management we added a uh position in the business office a management position in the district office um I think it was about two years
205ago to help with attendance counting accounting um we included that as part of this proposal um our school psychologist and occupational therapist I know if you look at special ed we understand that assessments um are increasing um the needs are increasing but um we feel that if we reprioritize some of the priorities within their job duties we'll still be able to offer um a high level of service to our students um by doing a 05 reduction in school psychologist and a02 for the occup ational therapist and you're going to see Liberty High School principal point2 that's not a reduction of FTE we are in declining enrollment Liberty High School is also in declining enrollment and it's very small um what so if you look at our our CDU program um is our Child Care Program
206they do child care all the way through adul Ed and what we're proposing here is to take the adult ed portion of that program and shift did over to um our Liberty High School principal who would then oversee Liberty High School and adult education and our CDU program they're generating their own revenue and they can sustain themselves through their program um and this is this model that we're proposing is is probably where adult Edge usually sits if you look at most school districts if they don't have a standalone program they typically um that program usually sits with the alternative school so that's our proposal and that's about $35,000 uh estimated savings if you total just the management uh we have a another tosa or teacher own special assignment that's coming out of general fund and
207this particular tosa helps out with online um data curriculum and also producing data and helping um some of our um our teachers and staff members um with with um analyzing data and also with the online curriculum portion of it that'd be $150,000 savings look at our uh our certificated staff members and um by number is our largest volume of staff that we have in our district um we identified some potential savings was coordinator if you're wondering what wasque is is our accreditation so um we have um there's a body that comes through and they'll is for high schools they will basically they do a uh a review of your school to make sure that you're doing what you say you're doing and in that comes a very lengthy stakeholder engagement and a report writing so
208at bonisha high school they have they give a a 20% release for someone to do that process to essentially engage stakeholders and get data and write that report banisha high school and Liberty High School's was visit is this year it's actually in a in a few weeks here so on a off was year there's not a need for that expense we could probably give some someone a stien to collect data so it's ongoing so they're not doing it all in one year but uh because it's not a was year because our was year is this year we feel like that's something that that um that we can propose um looking at BHS teachers and BMS teachers that has to do with decline in enrollment right um it's about right sizing our district so if they
209enrollment numbers come in lower um than they are this year what we're projecting for next year we believe that we can um reduce a 2.0 at the high school and a 1.6 at banisha Middle School which would give us some cost savings by right sizing our district um we're not um proposing raising class sizes we're just proposing Staffing those classes to contract limit um bonisha High School um athletic director in stien um we have an athletic director that is a 40% release and also on a stien looking at this in conversations with the high school with the with the principal um we propose that we use an um an assistant principal or vice principal and put them into that athletic director role um we would actually um um work with their schedule so their their
210their workday starts I don't know somewhere about midday into the evening so that their their daily work schedule is overseeing the Athletics because we need a little more oversight an administrator overseeing um a lot of activities that are taking place on campus um and in doing so there'd be a cost Savings of $67,000 adaptive PE and independent study I'm sorry uh adaptive PE um just based on need we believe that we can do a reduction of of 20% we currently have a staff member doing a 60% independent study this isn't the short term but this is just the independent students who choose full-term uh independent study um we believe that we can absorb that work amongst our existing staff and it'd be some cost savings there and on there we have secondary counselor um a
2112.0 um two counselors and uh we proposed that we looked at the ratios of uh counselors to students and um we're relatively low I'm going to say at bisha high school is probably about 335 to one I believe and I think the state average is um over 400 to1 so um there's an opportunity to do to have some cough savings there as well if you look at the the secondary certificated it's over a million dollar savings there um proposed and then Elementary certificated there's there's um Elementary prep PE prep and there's Elementary steam prep I'm going to put those two together this year we have anou with our our labor Partners to so we could offer additional prep time to our teachers um The Proposal is to go back to um what we offered prior
212to this school year um which would be a cost Savings of $300,000 and then you'll see a 3.0 elementary teacher as we talked about earlier with declining enrollment in our um our kindergarten classes and our en enrollment at the elementary um lower um again it's just right sizing Staffing our classrooms to the contractual limit and it's about $750,000 for certificated Elementary looking at our classified positions again with declining enrollment looking at the secondary office staff proposing a 1.5 reduction in FTE um we talked about we heard a lot of public comment about our our library technicians and the thought there was can we can we continue a program and maybe it's not every day but we could still continue the program program and offer a service um maybe not as often um campus supervision I
213think we've heard a little bit about campus supervision for Liberty High School again declining enrollment um um and close proximity with the district office so if additional support was needed there are administrators here that could support so that was the thought in including that as part of this proposal and I want to um end with special education and I want to preface this with special education is growing we know that um but we wanted to include this proposal um for consideration but in order for us to have a 2.0 reduction in special education it would require moving students from different programs who could potentially qualify for another program and I'm just going to be completely transparent I I don't know that this is a realistic app but um again we just wanted to put it
214on there for consideration because um it's possible I just want to just briefly uh touch on timeline again I opened this presentation by saying that today we just wanted to introduce this public conversation um because the the our timeline is relatively short so between February 6th and February 20th um we would notify and meet with any staff members who are potentially impacted by the reduction of service because at the February 20th meeting we would bring what we call the particular kinds of service which is a resolution with employees identified who would potentially be um uh impacted by the layoff February 21st through March 14th uh we would actually provide that uh written notice of a of a reduction or a layoff to that staff member because March by it has to be uh delivered by
215March 15th and then between March 15th and again I just want to say that's just notice that's just a notification of it and I just want to make sure that that's clear between March 15th and May 15th as a district what we will do is that gives us an opportunity to take a look at our enrollment numbers how many inter District transfers are coming in our Master schedules are starting to come together and then that gives us an opportunity to to either determine the feasibility of finalizing that initial notice of layoff or even resending if we're able to because the governor or the federal government said here's a whole bunch of money that you can continue their programs or are enrollment comes up factors change and we're going to hope for the best but we're
216going to monitor everything closely um we're going to be transparent in our communication and um we're going to approach this with as much care as we Poss ly can because this is difficult for everybody and I just wanted an opportunity for the governing board to ask any questions or engage in discussion I want to say thank you to um our guest that came tonight and said you know provided us comments it's really helpful um you know as we consider all the options and I want to encourage you know people in the audience as well as well as people watching online that you know to reach out and to come and you know send us emails come to the meetings you know share your your Viewpoint I think it's really nice that we hear um what
217the broad Community is feeling and thinking and wanting so just want to say thank you I have a couple questions um how many how many occupational therapists do we have in the district we we have one full-time occupational therapist one for one yes for all the schools yes they have a case load of less than 15 students for occupational therapy the whole district and um the district adaptive PE there's a point for um FTE equival um District uh adopted PE teacher so I'm I'm wondering though how do how do we service those IEPs that require um OT or adaptive PE when they're they're um being decrease in consultation with Steve Phillips the special education director he has reviewed the case loads the minutes that are required and then determined that this is a reduction that
218we can still meet the needs of the students um even with these uh potential reductions okay um I have some concerns where that about that but I I really wanted to look at special ed as well because in your presentation Dr beatson um special ed is the itss at ATS and yet we're talking about cutting two full-time positions so I I wonder how that how will that work because if if we're if we're in ATS and we want to bring those up and yet we're cutting staff how h when we initially looked at it it was an area that it could actually be done by moving students but it will be very disruptive so as I presented it tonight I presented it with the caveat that this probably isn't very likely or feasible okay thank
219you anybody have any questions just while we were on Special Ed I could jump in I know everybody probably asked questions um one thing that I hear a lot in the community is that we actually don't have have enough certificated special ed teachers and I think I need Clarity and and this may be a later discussion especially if this might not happen as to what a certificated special ed teacher does as opposed to an aid because from what I hear um this the certificated teacher is the one who can see the IEP can do certain tasks that an aid can't and that we need more support from a certificated teacher for our programs as it is that's anecdotal it's from parents um but I wanted to just bring it bring it up here anybody else
220yes can you explain to me what so there's like 0 five point2 um with the estimated savings so what does that mean so I'm just going to use the occupational therapist as an example so 0 2 is relevant to $40,000 does the occupational therapists still stay as an employee working to equal that one full-time employee or are they just being paid for $40,000 in their role um they would if they chose to they would continue to you know um stay employed at the 08 which would be um one less day a week so uh a point2 is the equivalent of like one day so they would work one day one day less okay and then the consideration you have to be 0. five to get benefits is that accurate the benefits are pro-rated so if
221you work if you work uh 6 three days a week or um the equivalent of0 6 of an 8 hour day then you would get your benefits up to you would get 60% of your benefit of the benefits the district provides and you'd have to pay for the the other part of that 40% yeah okay but then if you're 1% then you get the you're yeah if you're a 1.0 your fully funded benefits up to the um Kaiser Kaiser low okay um can you um share a little bit we've talked a lot about what's happening in the schools and just to you know think about have we considered the district office have we considered What's um what sort of cutting we can do here in the district office we have and we we've considered all
222avenues and there is some dis RCT office positions that are identified um in this proposal um management also some um tosa positions or teacher on special assignment positions um particularly in ed services I believe there were three that were identified there um the complications are it's sheer numbers right I I know when you look at the certificated numbers there's a lot more certificated um staff members in there are managers U districtwide and if you look at the district office there's not very many folks here um we have I I the question that I have filled it it's um has a district office grown and there was a time where the director of special education and the director of student services was the same person uh almost an impossible task to pull off and what we
223found is that um we were there was a lot of liability and um and litigation that we're still addressing uh and we were able to separate those two positions out and do some restructuring um we also have an additional um support in special education we have a director of special education and we have a coordinator that's also providing supports to the staff I don't know if I said a is it coordinator it's a program specialist I'm sorry program specialist okay I got the title wrong so so there there is some some supports but I I I want to keep in mind that um a lot of the work that we're doing here at the district office is not just compliance but it's also direct support um to our school sites um and so as we
224look at the numbers at the district office and additional reductions um yeah it's it's it's we we've considered it and um I think that the proposal that we brought forward I think that we've identified some areas that I think that we can continue to serve our community um with our proposal one of the things that um that I wonder about is that uh the district office Personnel are the highest paid in our district so if you if if it is not feasible to um have a reduction in force in the district office what about looking at salaries there we could um save some money by maybe reducing some of these high paid positions I I think that in times like this everything is on the table um I will say that and we did this
225study and I think we shared it with the board I believe it was last year um you can do comparisons to um salaries in a district office to surrounding districts and I think you're going to find that the managers in this District are significantly underpaid compared to the other districts so to tell a manager that we're going to reduce your pay because you make more than a certificated staff member I think could be problematic um I think that um you have to look at the number of days that our managers are working um and look at their per DM and um then I think that you would see that there's a little bit more it's a little bit more comparable than than it seems I think that um I think it's something uh to look
226at because we're looking at um so we we are looking at such reductions so I think that um I do think it's important that we we are cutting very close to the kids in this in this proposal so I just wanted to um put a bug in your ear on that because I think it could be reasonable to um consider that well we'll absolutely look at it and I just I do want to reiterate that um again as we're talking about um the reductions in our proposal um we're proposing working to contract within the confines of the contract we're not proposing that we come back to the table and raise class sizes we're proposing that we staff our classrooms to contract language because if you look at the class sizes that we currently have they're
227relatively low um here in bonisha um I I do agree with trusty grubs that any Cuts should be made as far away from the kids as possible um for sure and I mean I and I totally understand where you're going with the management salaries and I get it I I also just want to add the caveat that you um how can I put this sometimes you get what you pay for so I just want to make sure that we're able to retain good people if we do um look at that as well so that would be my concern with it would we would we lose people and then will the rest of the school Community suffer because we have a weak person that can be terrible for anybody who's worked for a bad manager as
228many of us have um I also wanted to bring up the library um you know as I was listening to the feedback tonight and just in the conversations I've had over the last week one thing has jumped out at me and that is our um social emotional goals in our uh strategic plan with our literacy with our Ela being number one and I think about my own kids reading books on laptops which I I personally really hate um I love having a hard copy book I think that the kids learn better when they have a hard copy book and right now at school that's where they get their hard copy books is in the library um you know I I've got two kids I can tell you that they use the library and they get
229a lot out of it they read books that I don't know if they would have ever read because I don't know about these books and it's opened up a lot of conversations in our house and it's been really valuable so um you know I I'm very hesitant on the library proposals at this point given that we may be L losing our wellness centers I'm concerned about that I feel like maybe the library is um may meet some of those needs kids go there during lunch I know they do they go and they sit and they have a nice quiet place to go with their friends they play their video games you know and I think it's just really important to keep in mind our strategic goals um which number one is Ela yeah I just
230what I agree with trusty hirsh and that and you know libraries provide a safe space and especially as you know we review that the one-time funding of cutting the wellness centers you know this that's a safe space for a lot of students and I think it um provides students to think freely and to sort of like kind of have a brain break a little bit and think about things that they want to think about and things that they want to research and people that they want to learn about um so I I especially you know when you think about elementary schools that is like as people were saying like the heartbeat of the schools um and I know in middle school a lot of students you know go there and they you know utilize books
231but it's also I think having that that um transition from the elementary school to the Middle School to understand what libraries are and what the functions are then as they progress into high school and then as they progress into college or the real world libraries shift and libraries change in what you use and how you use them and I think it's really important particularly you know in 2025 that we're advocating that our you know students have free thought and critical thinking I think libraries really support those activities I just want to pick you back on that you already know how I feel and this this has been a very difficult evening for me because I also believe like you said like you said that it is an integral part of a student's life at school
232I mean they learned the Dewey Decimal System they learned where certain books are cataloged they learn all these different things like some of the folks said that shared information with us it is I just I'm having a hard time with that one to sorry to feel safe and to feel uh um at peace libraries are very peaceful and and if we're taking the wellness centers away which I understand the libraries can can pick that up um I hate to see libraries being closed although in my years as a teacher there we have gone through times where the libraries were not open and and it was really a shame because because kids do go in um not just what they learn about how to use a library which is so important and which they they learn
233that at the elementary level so and I would assume you know I can speak I've seen it at Joe Henderson like that's also a time for the teacher although the teachers are there it's kind of a time for them to step back a little bit you know and let let somebody else guide the students let somebody and I think I just read a study about you know one of the important things for um adolescent development is to ensure that there's adults that they trust and that's a really important relationships and obviously we talk a lot about teachers but Librarians are right there with um with the students so we're not making an actual decision tonight I mean I don't know if we want to it is 9:30 I mean I don't know about you but
234I gotta no there's no decisions made tonight we're just we're just presenting information and having a discussion and uh this is something that we'll bring back at the February 20th meeting sorry I have another question I did go ahead Amy um on the on the Liberty it says it says secondary campus supervision is there a camp another campus supervisor why is it SEC oh secondary secondary level yeah oh okay and then is is that uh position 0.725 currently oh okay okay how how many hours a day are the kids at Liberty on campus I don't really have an understanding of their schedule I think about 1 o' oh okay almost a full day okay 8:30 to 1 and do they all do they all come to campus not all of them everybody's looking at you
235I don't know anybody anybody what was your question well I'm just wondering like how the attendance because I know I know a lot of our our Liberty students are on um independent study and they kind no they're not they do go to class okay should go to class they should they are expected to go to class on that note have we reached out and consulted with all of our principles um about these suggestions and recommendations absolutely we got their input um every step of the way great are there any other questions no so we'll go to 13A consideration approval of the comprehensive site and District safety plan Dr OIC you are up all right as the the presentation is uh getting logged in I want to say good evening Board of Trustees president grubs uh
236Dr Wright and the executive cabinet thank you for having me this evening um my name is Dr John OIC I'm the director of student services and also oversee our safety plans okay to the link all right I was going to say when I uh promoted from kindergarten I had to say what I wanted to be when I grew up and was a comedian and a doughnut maker so I could have tried some of my material had we had some more time but lucky for you uh we didn't my seventh graders for several years had to endure it um and my kids do now all right so um we can go do yes so the reason I'm here this evening is by March 1st we need to provide our comprehensive uh School site safety plans to
237the county office uh and it needs approval from our school site councils it was developed by our safety teams and then approved by the school board wanted to start with some annual updates that are made to the safety plan uh the school safety data is updated every year that looks at Ed code violations uh that are reported to calpads and also our local uh referral rates um what's being referred for minors and majors and the safety plan then comes up with an action plan for the following year based on those statistics the site needs to update the approvals and records of review that would be the safety team members on it that include parents certificated staff members classified and also site Administration they would make any updates to evacuation maps and diagrams if needed they
238would add any information to the site specific procedures and information um that would be uh again the team there and do a final proofread uh before it is submitted so this year the most notable change there was one beginning July 1st 2025 schools must Implement an instructional continuity plan for emergencies that disrupt imp person learning the plan must include establish two-way communication with students and families within 5 days to address academic social emotional and mental health needs provide access to in-person or remote instruction within 10 instructional days which may include temporary reassignment to another educational institution and finally encourage uh maintaining instructional standards equivalent to the independent study programs so working with uh integrated Services ed services specifically we developed this plan uh that's now part of each of our safety plans first two-way communication
239communication methods include email and parent Square to connect with students and families uh BD will use electronic surveys to identify student need including the need for technology to support for social emotional and mental health needs virtual wellness centers will be available scheduled to be determined staff will offer Virtual Office hours for additional support families will be informed of these Services by email parents Square as well as on district and site websites and for the instructional plan Core Curriculum will focus on essential standards instruction will be delivered using Google meet for sing synchronous learning in Google Classroom as the learning management system for asynchronous activities students in need of District technology will complete an electronic survey to notify the School site Outreach will occur from school staff if the survey is not completed small group interventions
240will be provided for elementary students based on local data English language development eeld services will continue virtually and that wraps up my presentation thank you any questions okay thank you Dr oit thank you and uh Dr oh sorry sorry sorry sorry is this an action item yes it is an action item I'll make a motion that we uh for approve I'll move that we approve the site and District safety plans as presented I second all those in favor I any oppos and now we'll go on to 13B consideration and approval of resolution number 24- 25-23 the release of temporary certificated employees and Dr Jennings you are on um good evening president grubs board board trustees and Dr Wright the item before you is the annual resolution to release um employees who are on temporary contracts
241um they would be released at the end of the school year and these are employees who came on board um at the beginning of the year signed temporary contracts to backfill for either teachers on special assignment um who are part of our dedicated Subs or who um are um filling um have done an additional point to this school year to make our Master schal work at the middle school and high school is there a motion to approve can I ask oh are there any questions some sorry that's okay um so does this does not affect our budget in any way we've already counted for these These are this is done okay um and I guess why are we doing this now and not waiting until we're closer to budgeting time and figuring out what we're
242doing with lots of personnel Etc um we are required to release any temporary teachers first before we start any sort of um possible layoff process so this happens annually every year typically in February where you have to notify them by March 15th but you want to notify them first before you start going into any type of seniority list got it does that make sense is it possible for for us to wait until we have a clearer picture of what we're doing um um these the teachers that uh this reference are teachers who are backfilling for like the teachers on special assignment so we know that those teachers are would be going if they proposals adopted that those teachers would be going back so we would Rel we would need to release them first so they
243knew when they took the position was a temporary position and it doesn't necessarily mean that they'll not have a job somewhere in the district these temporary spots they knew would be for this year when you get hired for a temporary spot you know it's just for that length of time even in typical years if we weren't going through this we would still go through this process and release a temporary teachers and then if we had space we bring them back usually during our hiring fair but this is temporary and we are required to not you know to notify them early that they so that they they know that um the the contract their contract ends in June their contract essentially and then some of these are uh teachers who are current permanent employees who have
244an additional Point too they teach um instead of having teaching five periods and having one period of prep they actually teach six periods so we were leaving we're saying we're going to release them from the point two so they don't enter into next year with a 1.2 contract right got it okay okay I move that we approve resolution 24-25 d23 I'll second all those in favor I oppose you so thank you everybody our next board meeting will be Thursday February 20th 2025 and our meeting is adjourned