001e e e good evening everybody thank you for being here it is 5:03 on January 16th um we are reconvening to open [Music] session um we don't have anything to report from our Clos session um oh our highlights tonight um this meeting is recorded for live streaming And archiving on the district YouTube channel for your convenience um if we can have the Pledge of Allegiance led by um mark melli would you like to lead us in the pledge begin Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible Li andice thank you Mr Meli um today we have uh Victoria uh Blackman from oh oh oh sorry um can I have um a motion to approve the agenda I move that we
002approve the agenda is written and a second please I'll second those in favor I uh now to students reports hi Victoria would you like to report out yeah good evening president grubs superintendent Dr Wright fellow trustees and cabinet members Happy New Year to everyone we have several new students that have transferred to our school and we want to welcome them to Liberty High School we want to give a big congratulations to our early grads we have five students that have graduated early and we wish them the best of luck we have a busy start to the new semester we are celebrating the Lunar New Year with new art projects learning about cultural preservation and exploring how the holiday manifests differently across diverse communities Liberty is partnering again with UC Davis in their new spinning salmon
003project this year we have been provided an aquarium and salmon eggs and for the past two months we have been monitoring the growth and collecting data the project is to help support the depleting salmon populations in the next couple weeks we'll be releasing our new hatchling into the Sacramento River next week we'll be visiting Cal Academy of Science we are learning how the academy is working to regenerate the natural world we hope to visit the colony of African penguins and their famous albino alligators Claude lastly in the spirit of Martin Luther King Jor and his call to the service our leadership class is organizing a blanket and towel drive to support the Humane Society of the North Bay we'll be collecting new or gently used blankets leashes towels and collars if anyone like to donate
004please contact our main office on behalf of B high school thank you thank you thank you thank you so much and our representative from benisha hi hello president grubs and fellow council members my name is Isabella representing visha High School in the past weeks we had semester 1 finals before that leadership hosted Wellness week to help people de-stress and prepare for finals for many students this was their first finals week ever and it went smoothly we also had winter break this week is the second week back after winter break many students are still getting back into the swing of things and for some students they started new classes freshman have semester long electives so they got new classes as well as seniors with their gov and econ classes leadership has the intramural dodgeball tournament this
005week at lunch students are able to create their own teams with their friends and play against other classmates auditions are happening for the upcoming musical The Adams Family today was the elective Fair where students got to see and ask about electives they're interested in or any other ones the school may offer in addition tonight we have our open house which will allow students to see future classes that they can take and for parents to learn about AP classes and things like that and the rest of leadership will be there wearing our blue so in case you need help finding anything we'll be there um in the upcoming weeks students in grades 8 through 11 will be able to choose their classes next week and plan out their schedules the spring musical will start rehearsing and
006beginning planning and begin planning their show leadership is planning the winter rally which will be on January 31st and we are also planning the clash of the classes which is going to be a new tournament against the classes where the winner will be announced at the rally on B on behalf of banisha high school thank you thank you Isabella and then we come to uh superintendent Dr Wright's report all right good evening um I just want to start my report off by uh thanking our governing board for the Janu January 11th board study session uh I thought it went really well um any time you have an opportunity to do governance training there was a lot of collaboration and learning review and our strategic plan goals um I think it's critical to move our organization
007forward and I just thought it was a good day um yesterday I had an opportunity to watch the unified games at bonisha high school if you're not familiar with Unified sports it's where uh some of our students with disabilities um collaborate with students without disabilities and they engage in athletic competition so yesterday it was basketball and walking in the gym and seeing the spectators wasn't full but there was a lot of folks there our cheerleaders were cheat cheering and um just watching our students out there having a good time uh let them fool you they were knocking shots down left and right I texted Banna and I said hey this guy hit three threes in a row I mean what's going on here but um you know it was it was a good day and
008the heartwarming moment for me at the end one of our unified athletes she's been asking the cheerleaders to be a cheerleader for quite some time now so they uh made a Shir for her and I made her an honorary cheerleader yesterday and but the moment was she just started hugging and just squeezing really tight and was just very thankful to be included with the cheerleading so um I enjoyed it uh if you have an opportunity please check the schedule they have a couple of games left um it is definitely worth attending um I do want to thank um some of the staff members that were involved I saw Scott Schwarz uh Justin Keen um we had our par Educators out there Lori inhoff um Kathleen solder our teacher so it was just a good day
009um I also want to highlight uh our fitness challenge winners I don't know if you remember we had a a fitness challenge we had 31 teams participate and uh there was a team over at banisha middle school they named themselves too inspired to be tired and uh it was right cuz they won so we're going to honor them tomorrow uh we have some certificates and and some prizes for them for for their efforts and there's been a lot of energy behind it and we're going to we're going to um do it again this spring so I think we'll um I think what happen is all the PE teachers that are constantly moving they group up so they're typically at the top of the list so kind of like fantasy football I think we might do
010a draft just to level the playing field a little bit just uh to make the competition a little tighter um I do want to uh mention night of stars that's the opportunity for us to honor our staff members of the Year both classified certificated and administrator or management um and it's also excuse me an evening where we celebrate All bu USD staff um we solidified our date May 9th at um Northgate um we'll send out some additional information but it will take place on May 9th if you would like to hold the date in your calendar and state of the district um on January 22nd just next week um we're going to do the date of the district presentation right here at the district office right across the way at the Liberty Gym um the
011event will uh start with a 40 minute staff and student showcase right here in this boardroom um Career Technical education projects you'll see art projects you'll see examples of student work from all grade levels uh just an opportunity to walk around and engage with our staff and students um our BHS jazz band will play music during that time they'll do the national anthem and then we'll transition into the Liberty Gym at that point um we'll have an hour presentation and we're going to highlight um all the successes that we've had historically in buusd we'll talk about our current state of the district and what lies ahead um and then the evening we'll end with about a 20 minute uh student facilitated panel uh Dr beatson and I had an opportunity to meet with the students
012uh yesterday and uh trust me I think the students will be the highlight um of this uh presentation on the 22nd so please join us doors open at 5:45 um if you can RSVP that's great if not we do accept walk-ins just please come and celebrate with us uh we love to have you and this event will also be live streamed so if you're not able to come in person or if you have you know relatives or friends that live in other areas that want to tune in there's an option for that as well and that's all I have for today thank you thank you Dr R um any board reports I just want to share that it's been really great this is my second meeting now and um there's community members that have been
013reaching out and I just want to just tell the board too that it's been really great working with you and that you know this is new to me so I'm going to be talking probably a lot more and talking things through as we're going through the agenda um so just sort of just sharing that that that's where I'm coming from great thank you any any others I do um so yesterday I attended the Liberty and rotary oversight committee it's part of my duties on the board and I want to thank the Rotary Club of bonisha for their two donations of $1,500 one that went to girls soccer EP Anisha High and the other that went to golf girls golf at banisha High um so thank you to the Rotary Club for those generous donations um
014the Rotary Club also honored our very own Jeffrey bue at Matthew Turner second grade teacher as teacher of the month so it was great to see him get his award um uh as part of the oversight committee I learned more about Liberty you know I grew up here I'm aware of Liberty but I don't know all that much about what Liberty does and how it's supported so I got an opportunity to spend the day saw Victoria I I saw the salmon spinning project and received a really really great explanation by one of the students saw the native plant garden we saw the vegetable garden and there and it was it was great to see all of the special programming we have at Liberty thank you I'd also like to um uh thank Dr rip for
015our um our special board meeting where we looked over our board policies we looked over our practices and you'll notice some changes tonight in um in the way we vote on on things on different items so thank you for that it was a very productive meeting very interesting and um I think some really good updates happened so thank you for that um we now come to item number 10 comments from the members from members of the public all functions of the board meeting including public comments will take place in person members of the public May address the board at a regular meeting on any item within the board's jurisdiction speaker cards are available on the entrance table please note that if you wish to speak to and submit a card to submit the card to
016the board secretary the board president will call the Open Session General comments government code section 549 54.3 during the public comment item comments for items on the agenda will be called during the specific item comments are limited to no more than three minutes per speaker or the board May limit the total time to 20 minutes per item when the timer with the timer displayed on the monitors by law no action may be taken on any item raised during the public comment periods and matters may be referred to staff for placement on a future agenda of the governing board please be reminded to keep your comments respectful as students may be watching the board meetings thank you and our first speaker and please I hope I pronounce this correctly Halo Le do you can clap for
017him it's okay hi I'm Halo and I go to BMS AKA bonisha middle school and I play for bonisha Arsenal I've been playing soccer since I was five and right now we've been playing soccer on basketball courts cuz none of the fields in bonisha are ready or good to play soccer especially at BMS our Fields have been torn and there's tons of holes in them um soccer especially for my team since we love soccer we've played it together and when I joined it they made me feel welcome and they immediately helped me and Coach he welcomed me and helped me with everything um soccer has helped all of us with our emotions and I think it's helped us level with each other and when we play on basketball courts it just doesn't help us so
018these fields could help us a lot with practice and help us with our games because we've been playing our games and trying to win here for Bia thank you [Applause] halo our next speaker is Jesse Mueller oh I'm sorry it didn't say that for Point order online so the boys all turned out because online didn't say was on the agenda is yeah we we'll go ahead and do the we'll do that yes yes sir sure talk yeah I think should com okay perect that's fine I don't see hi uh thank you for having me my name is Jesse Mueller um so uh I also just want to reference uh Jared Slate's letter um not going to I'm not going to read it all out but I'm I'm pretty sure you've all read it um it's
019eloquently uh States a lot of the the points that are relevant here um so uh bisha Arsenal Football Club is a has a foundation of uh passionate players families coaches um our family is one of those uh we we participate in the recreational program competitive and coaching um we compete against teams all around the Bay Area um and it it's it's a constant source of frustration and even embarrassment um the state of our soccer fields we um are juggling field assignments constantly uh the fields are closed in winter as Halo referred to um so right now we're improvising all kinds of training sessions to to keep the kids active and keep them playing um with uh proper infrastructure and investment bisha could really Excel to a new level of soccer and and other sports as
020well obviously um it it'd be wonderful to be able to host tournaments in this town and it would be a source of Pride and and a lot of community enjoyment uh and it would be great to be able to practice all year long um so I was just so excited to hear that these uh projects were on the agenda uh and being discussed uh both the turf field at the high school and the two fields at the middle school and I would just urge and plead and beg uh for approval of these projects to move forward thanks very much thank you thank you very much Eli Nolan all right good afternoon leadership I appreciate your time um my name is Eli Nolan I'm actually a product of banisha Unified School District I moved to bonisha
021in 1988 went to Mary farmer bonisha Middle School graduated banisha high in 1997 um I have four kids they're all active in sports I actually have come back and um coaching basketball and so um at the high school and so Dr Wright your your comments on everything we have going on with youth sports and some of our programs are great um you mentioned uh unified basketball in the team I think the gentleman you're probably talking about is Lucas pno who actually plays on the JB team for me so it's really neat to hear stories like that so um I'm my comment are more geared towards items f and g the the turf fields um I love sports it's a big reason of of My Success in life and what I have going on and so
022I love the idea that that's being considered um for a couple reasons I I I not only support it but I think as a community we we must do it we really have to do it for two main reasons physical and mental health of our youth we know that kids getting out and being active playing on sports teams playing together being out there is great for their mental physical health so that's number one and then also two um the revenue generation I think it's a great opportunity for for the for the school district because I know firsthand a lot of families myself we spend a lot of money each month going outside the community whether it's training whether it's Sports programs primarily due to the facilities and there there's a good opportunity for the community
023and the school district to really capitalize on that and it's not all about money but it's a great opportunity to to keep a lot of our families here connected and also bring people in who are going to maybe attend Sports tournaments spend money down on First Street um we have a neat community that has a lot of kids who who love love playing sports you know we got some soccer players out here I was Halo I was running around playing football on these fields probably the same grass fields you know and so the idea of of having Turf you don't have the potholes we can play year round and it's a great opportunity where where uh we have a lot of programs that are willing to spend the money to to keep their services in
024here and really support that so I would love to see that move forward um also too if if it does get to the point of going through I would recommend from a professional standpoint I'm in finance is setting up a a maintenance fund Turf is a lot easier to maintain on a day-to-day basis but long term it could really catch up so if it's something that goes through I'd recommend having a maintenance fund where some of the revenues deriv from those fields go into that maintenance fund so that way in your two three five and especially 10 we have a few hundred thousand saved up to to care for that I've been to a lot of fields where they were nice for the first few years 15 years later it's it's it's a big liability
025so I appreciate your time appreciate you considering this and thank you thank you [Applause] you and Jack is our next speaker hello I'm jackon ker I go to Bish middle school and um I play for BFC um a lot of the players on our team are really really competitive and love to win and um it's hard to be more competitive when you don't have the same resources as other teams do and so it would really help us out a lot if you could um uh make better field for us thank you thank you thank you [Applause] Jack so Isabella and any students that would like to uh head on out and for the rest of their evening please feel free and otherwise we will go on to the um approval of our consent were there
026more people who want to talk have to turn in a card yeah they know okay the approval of our consent calendar background information on these items is provided to the board prior to the meeting a common motion takes takes action without discussion on or on roll call vote unless discussion of the items is requested by the board members so um our first 11a minutes of the meeting of December Mrs Martinez we just are going to do we just approve them all just approve them all so I'll move that we approve the consent calendar as written and a second please I'll second and those in favor I I and moving on to um item 12 presentations and communication inform informational items um benisha Unified School District school facility General obligation Bond measures C construction projects and
027planning is Mrs roxan Egan our bond director and you going to be up here for a little bit um first of all thank you for making time for me to share out these fun up fun and exciting updates tonight um we're going to start on this first slide which is an overview but before I go into that I wanted to just talk about our process um excuse me we um met with site administrators reviewing the projects and got input before we brought this to you um after sharing it with you we're going to be updating graphic boards within the deal Hall so that they're there for everyone to view um the fac will be meeting with the facilities master plan steering committee and then we'll be meeting with the CBC and sharing out updates with
028them um I'll be posting documents on the majorc website and then we're going to have another openhouse meeting at each site similar to what we did last spring to gather Community input so these first documents are schematic and they're moldable so to speak as we walk through this process and gather but it's a starting point for the discussion um from this slide right here what I'd like to do is just highlight um the things that we've completed and then for things that are in progress we will go through the details on the schematic drawings so just excited to share out it's been nine months since major C passed and we've completed technology and it upgrades for Securities Joe Henderson has new NPR Roofing Mary farmer has a new playground shade structure um Robert simple has
029HVAC upgrades really across the district we have various spots that have had HVAC upgrades and then all the projects that are listed there in construction will be complete prior to the end of the school year 2025 which includes a new TK building at um Joe Henderson so just really proud to share that progress you want to go on to Mary farmer thank you um so this is an update we have shared previous plans um for our master plan and really probably what I want to do is this first page is existing um site plan and their uses and I'm going to go ahead and flip to the next page if we could um this is the our new end schematic plan and in Prior planning we a didn't have money to fully fund all the
030improvements through major S and B we had the softball field um which greatly impacted the site of Mary Farmers so moving that field down is going to be such of a benefit to Mary farmer and to the high school both um so these buildings now instead of being an interim phase where the I'm going to point up here um where these lower six buildings are here that's on the existing softball field and so those can be built as phase one and we don't have to have interm housing oh okay sorry so those um that'll save us some steps in just building permanent buildings instead of having to do interim buildings um if you want to so this end result gets Mary farmer three classrooms for each class level so three TK three kindergarten three first
031grade um and it gives them we've got the community garden up there and we've got um playground structures so as we go and progress through this planning it occurs in three phases but um we're going to watch enrollment and if enrollment drops or the buildings aren't necessitated then we'll adjust and when we bid we could have like a additive alternate to you would leave the space in planning for a future if you needed it but not install it now if we don't need them so that's how we're going to kind of progress this but our overall goal was that we're going to plan for three at each level which was our our that was our Baseline for what we identified as need and then when we get ready to bid if there's not the need
032we'll scale back um so this has they have a total of um where we take out nine existing modular buildings and replace them and then they have four additional buildings and that takes them to the level equal with all the other sides the four buildings are three classroom buildings and then it's one restroom building well it's half restroom and half storage um so you want to flip to the next one please so the way this builds out um I'm sorry back when or you de that's phase one so phase one down here at the bottom these six buildings will be in construction all the rest of the buildings on campus will still be occupied this occurs on the perimeter of Campus so that construction can happen year round without being overly imposing on the site
033um next oh can you do it for me please yeah thank you um this is Phase 2 and this is our TK and K so at this phase the five modulars P I don't know what it is 10 through 15 or something that's up there now they get to move into the new buildings that are at the lower left hand side the other nine Portables that are on the south end of the campus are still stayed staying there and occupied and then this construction zone is the upper leftand corner for the TK and kindergarten buildings um this is the third phase yeah one back whoops one forward thank you this is the fourth phase so now you have your TK buildings up at the top and kindergarten occupied you've got your fourth and fifth grade
034on the left hand side occupied and then we block out the lower right hand side and that's the last portion of building for their new buildings um and then the last phase that we're showing up there is the main building and just because this is shown last doesn't mean that it would be the last to receive improvements we'll do them as we can as we go along so that's Mary farmer um do you want to go on to Robert simple or do you just want to stop and have questions on each one before we go through sites probably questions I I had a question on Farmer um so these the new buildings they're getting quite a few new buildings and these aren't Portables these are actual buildings they are Modular Buildings so they are prefab
035buildings but they're similar to the gwing at bisha Middle School you walk in at grade they have you you feel just like a real building um we're able to set them and get them built and fabricate so in the process it's beneficial to us but you're it's a very much improved product over what they used to call Portables great I I I like the um the layout it's it's nice the classes are grouped together there's Courtyards in Green Space and I feel like you're making good use of the view because it's got a terrific view there so oh yeah whatever we can do to enjoy the view um yeah okay thank you great anything else you want to talk about on Farmer okay do we want to go into Robert simple next so this is
036Robert simple and um again very schematic if we could maybe I'm going to flip to the end and show you the where we're going and then I'll go back to the beginning and go Page by Page um so what this does is you see buildings 1 through six which would be the first phase and then you see buildings 7 through 9 which would be a second phase so the end goal is that we replace dated Portables there's seven existing classrooms P 17 17A 18 and then the C1 through 4 and they get one additional new building um they do have room for expansion on the lower left side if they need it in the future but this gives them C sounds Equitable to all the other sides um so maybe let's flip back to the
037first one please um so this would be phase one and we are leaving all the existing buildings in place P1 through six I'm calling them P I don't know why let's just say one through six um they'll be built out onto the area that is now part of the field so the existing entire campus gets to remain occupied while we're building um we have a new parking lot to help alleviate congestion in their parking um we during this phase all of those existing buildings stay so then and on the right hand side there's some graphics honestly all of that is very schematic it's just ideas right now and nothing's really been that'll get tightened up as we go um next phase so now your buildings 1 through six are occupied um buildings p17 p17 a
038n p18 are demolished which helps us to be better able to build buildings one two and three minimizing impact to the site users because there're not right next to them um we can't take out what's labeled as the D1 building yet because phase one only has six buildings and we that would be seven classrooms that we were taken out so we leave the removal of the D1 building until phase three can we go to the next one which takes us back to the end where they have their fully built outside site we um build the interior Courtyards take out the Deb building and um that's where we are you guys have questions I have will we be doing anything with the field at Robert simple in terms of leveling it or doing anything on the
039grass there um so there are plans to replace the perimeter fencing which I I'm going to try to do sooner that later that definitely needs done we don't have a lot of plans for the field I mean it'll just continue to be kept up by maintenance in its natural grass State um that's that's pretty much most of it anyone else I have a question about the location so the administration office is up at the by the NPR yep um and it looks like we're adding a new entry for TK and K and then I didn't realize this but the main is also down from the administr administrative office so the tkk would happen right between on the angle between where it says 1 and N okay um so they could park right there in the
040parking lot walk up the sidewalk and walk up onto the campus also CDU would be placed in those classrooms that are 78 n so they're after school activities they are not traversing the whole campus it's they just can go right in through that Side Access um right now where you see it set labeled building A2 just south of that is a gate okay so we're going to try to do some graphics there that are like a new entry they actually walk and do their main lineup in the mornings right they're not in front of the office right now but we are going to meet with the site users and we'll certainly take their input and if something needs to be tweaked we'll yeah that can be done yeah that's great I just think about security
041and making sure we are able to monitor the entrances and you know this is this is such a tricky dve drive and drop off to say the least just making sure that it's it flows and that people don't have to go too far if they need to go to the office to check in you know if they have to go to their students classroom um those are all good suggestions thank you we'll take it in okay yeah anything else any other questions comments okay thank you um next next up we have Joe Henderson sorry okay yeah so this will be the same let's um well I'll just start out here on actually on this one and and give a little bit of introduction under major S one of our projects that we needed to do
042that was a high priority was the replacement of building F3 and really all of those F buildings are way past their lifetime um um initially we've always known that we wanted to bring the CDU programs into the d-wing so they were on the perimeter campus and have that access um initially we did not have money to do everything that was needed so we were going to just replace F3 in its existing location with the passage of major C we returned to the drawing board and reconsidered to do so we do it once and do it right um so what this does this would be phase one um and the upper right hand side where you see the hatch building that is the existing F3 location it we relocate the existing building to the opposite side
043so that we can close that whole area for a construction zone so we also will be demolishing that PL structure and then since we're taking it away before we really start everything we have to give them something so the um playground on the left is in it's aged and in need of replacement so it'll get expanded and replaced so that'll be and we're also showing some shade structures down there on their playground um that'll be the first step in preparation for really what's a much bigger move on Project next so this would be phase two so now we the construction zone is the upper right hand corner where you see the buildings F4 through f8 um and those will be new buildings um we also are installing a restroom building that would be behind them
044for support go ahead go to the next one please um so this is the third phase and so now all of your new buildings are occupied your F1 through F3 are still occupied and now we close the DB building for renovations because we have to add bathrooms in there and um meet all the requirements for CDU so we have four new classrooms that four of those can go to um in coordinating with Kathy she thinks that they can find a way to consolidate the other two temporarily for a year or something some of their spaces so that we can have the whole building and just keep going year round so um pretty exciting and then if you go to the next one please um this is one more oh this is the removal of the
045buildings the F1 through three and then this last one is the final where you get to so I say final but that's for this initial phase of Joe Henderson there will be future work that is funded that includes parking lot modification um and one thing I didn't point out is that we also have a marquee replacement and then you can see outside of D1 through D3 just north of it um the end goal is that they have music and art in there and so they have this great outdoor support space that they can go outside and paint or play their instruments and then north of f4 through f8 we have really nice out outside teaching extended classroom space um and the bathrooms are they'll have student restrooms and staff restrooms rooms on the playground to
046the left those kids will be able to access the restrooms as well as the kids from the classrooms any questions looks good okay cool um you want to go to the next one so visha high school um the graphic that I have started here with just to put it in in the big picture on the boards that we're making for the hallway this is Project Specific I'm going to get a board that shows the whole s whole site with all of the targeted projects so that you it's more inclusive and we'll also have a board for Liberty High School and one for Matthew Turner um but this is the PAB and so just as a reminder we got funding we got some grants for paab for around $3 million which is great we have to
047have it built by 2028 and the project is around 13 million so we're definitely supplementing that with Bond money and really glad to have it um the scope for this is an addition of around 3,000 square F feet Renovations within the existing PAB fully upgraded lighting upgrades expanded stage HVAC and Roofing upgrades it'll um have finished upgrades we'll have meetings as we go through the finishes I know briana's team and users is really anxious to participate that and of course so anyhow those are yet to come but um if we want to flip through some graphics this is just shows our existing PAB and the area in purple on the right is the expansion and then also on the lower left this is the new floor plan really just blocked still um this is showing
048the expanded stage it will move the dance studio into the PAB and then um modified drama classroom and um changing rooms this is the outside so this is looking from the the driveway on your right as you're going towards the parking lot so they'll have kind of a new Tower and the bottom one's from the front of the school really anchoring it from that intersection and then this are sections so the um seating it will stay pretty close to its existing capacity any questions there just um as part of this are they going to do the Cosmetic stuff like paint and seats please absolutely it should feel like a new space when they get through it there and the cloth on the walls and yeah this is really exciting looks really to get closer to
049the microphone looks really great uh will we be able to utilize the PAB for outside resources so you know sometimes there's a lot of concerts at the bisha clock tower could we utilize the PAB for that I think that you can it really would be a coordination like maintenance and then site users agreements and obviously our facilities get first dibs I kind of look to Damon because ultimately I'll probably go to him for his call and the yeah yeah it would be part of um our rent resources just like we do our fields and I think it's available now so oh okay the subgrade is really nice though great um you want to go on to the fields okay so this is the existing softball fields um at the high school high school and baseball
050um if you can you go to the next one please so this um upgrades the fields so that they are not um natural they are artificial turf both the varsity baseball and the Varsity Softball get artificial turf we have lighting so that it can they can um have extra hours for practice and games um and then they have a practice field that they'll share so instead of having a field that's just designated to practice field they felt that by finding a compromise where they alternate maybe between the practice field and the regular one for different um exercises and then also having the batting cages that they could do this and that it can work for them well and not be on merry farmer anymore um so it also has parking there's about 50 parking spaces
051that get added that'll be a great benefit both for the high school the games and even for Mary farmer during drop off yeah so any questions on here I just have a oh sorry Mark go ahead go first I just have a comment and that is this is so exciting it's so exciting to get our to have our um our Fields updated and safe and um just bringing them up to standard so thank you for your very hard work uh thank you fabulous it's just it is very all the upgrades are so exciting and we really appreciate your coming and presenting to us thank you thank you I this the fields aren't a final product right in terms of what we're doing we're going to keep meeting and reg like refining the planning but we
052hope to if we if we get your approval we hope to progress through those needed steps fairly quickly so that we can keep rolling with stuff but it's definitely there's going to be meetings for input for input wise I one of the the softball coach the Varity softball coach reached out is there any way we could include her and the baseball coach in on the' been included oh I was not I didn't HS Fields yeah we also have another meeting scheduled next week with the users and The Architects present so we had one meeting with them we've had two meetings with them Gathering input and so we incorp afraid of their comments but haven't met yet to like get more so we'll keep if you want to send me a name or send it to
053Damon he can send it to me no yeah he knows Damon's been at the meeting so he'll yeah yeah thank you reach we'll make sure we follow up thank you sure thank you very much you're welcome thank you now we come to our 13 item 13 our action items we have one more oh oh sorry oh sorry yes please okay so the last one last but not least I think we have some interested participants here um so this is the Middle School here's our existing fields and so as you know there's been a lot of discussion about safety around the existing lower fields and also the necessity for an additional field that both the community and our schools could use so this shows what we are proposing um this is a soccer field it has
054a six Lane track around it it has parking for Ada a restroom building that could all gender restrooms and then also like a like a Snack Shack you could have at the end of it um we'll have perimeter fencing around it a vehicular gate up at the top so that you can stop people from coming down when you don't want them afterwards on the upper left we're going to add a little just a container shed for maintenance to have their equipment in and then um you can use the middle school parking lot as overflow for activities that I have here it does not include lighting and it does not include bleachers so we are putting the infrastructure for lighting in but it is beyond our budget capacities and at some point in the future if
055money becomes available the infrastructure is there so we're not ripping up our beautiful field if we proceed with it and they can install it think ahead so any questions I have a question um so just to talk through the field a little bit so there's no lighting and no bleachers but we're have room for a Snack Shack I guess I'm concerned of like if there's people there we have people at games um and we have a crowd of people where will they will they just stand on the track well there's there's a Greenery around it that you could sit on you're going to be sitting horizontal beside it but um so like are are if there's a bonisha middle school game there would people be bringing expect not expected encouraged to bring lawn chairs I
056I think it would be something like that to start with and me it's something that could always be added we could come back and we can look at it in the planning and we can kind of watch funding as we watch Step through this and if we have resources I think right now we're trying to do what we can but also trying to be mindful to not you know but it is a really good question and comment like we we're getting there but like the bathrooms like if you do have space and don't have a bathroom building you're kind of asking for trouble you're going to be in a situation for sure for sure so that's why we're doing that I would just Advocate because at the high school they had the bleachers and I
057know when people utilize the field it's really encouraged to be on the bleachers not to be on the track and field and so just thinking about the we the maintenance of the Middle School track and field when you have people there well and so how does yeah I'm sorry if we talk about bleachers the bleachers at the high school um so I guess I I think about degrees of bleachers how many like you know that's true I'm not saying make it like the high school of Stadium at all but I'm just yes I'm just encouraging that I think there needs to be yeah yeah because like sorry I just wanted to just ask a question if I can and the bleachers are we limited with space or is it funding or a little bit of
058both um right now I just was looking at funding and I so I can look at space and then um maybe we do like well at the lower Fields they're looking at smaller sets of bleachers that are supporting the the baseball fields maybe if we look at well what does that cost and can we do some compromise that's a halfway in the middle okay so maybe you could come back to us with that yes thank you yeah just to um add another consideration it or actually a question will the middle school be able to do its promotion ceremonies on the new field because doing them up on the black top good there's there's a lot of you know complaints people can't see their kids and everybody's sitting on the field in a lawn chair so
059well so that brings back to the question of bleachers right cuz as far as a functional space I don't see any reason at all they couldn't do it I mean I know like on the on the stadium you know they have requirements about you they don't want you to wear heels or this or that so I'm sure they're going to have all the same things for maintenance but I don't have any reason why they couldn't have them there but it just also speaks to the need for seaing yeah yeah and probably an ad probably and this one too this is just a consideration um I've received some emails from the community um pertaining to soccer and if this is a soccer field with a track around it one concern is how do we prevent a
060ball from hitting somebody running around the track um so if there's I don't know how this works but I guess there's Nets that you can use if um if something like that would be possible or or the um the hardware I guess to be put in there if if somebody were to bring their own Nets I don't know I'm just thinking off the top of my head um but keeping that potentially in mind yeah thank you I think all of this be begs the question too to think about other out outside of school hours or School individuals using these resources outside yeah like how do we move that forward with people renting the fields and utilizing the spaces and I think that might eventually need to be looked at in terms of who's going to
061be on there not necessarily who but how can we prioritize and how can we ensure that all not I mean we're having a lot more space around the city which is really really great so how can we utilize all these spaces that we have yeah I agree and I think I I like that idea and you know I worked in a in my previous role um we had a community meeting where we met with the city in a school district and we at the beginning of each season we sat down and we mapped out field usage space um hasn't been something that I think we've done in bonisha um but as I'm hearing that we're field landlocked U maybe that's something that we can work with the City and collaboratively figure that piece out because
062obviously um bonisha you know School District um activities get priority but when there's open space or if the city Fields has open space how do we allocate that because we also have to consider while we're doing some of this construction some of the bisha high school um Athletics will be displaced as we're doing a football and soft not football but I'm sorry baseball and softball fields so I think there's an opportunity for us to to sit down and really collaborate and map some of this out um I wholeheartedly agree that um prioritizing um in town bonisha um activities uh versus out of town I I think that makes sense um but I think there's an opportunity here for us to get together and collaborate outside of the school district just to make sure that all
063user groups um are accommodated and I just want to make one more um comment about the fields at Robert simple and Joe Henderson because those are the two elementary schools that I know about their fields and the students go on there that if there's an opportunity to think about that as we're thinking about the the sites um that would be really great and I'm just talking about just leveling leveling that land essentially not necessarily making a beautiful landscape but there's a lot of holes in areas that students could hurt themselves out there definitely we will add that I think that that is something very doable as part of the modernization I know we've had conversations at Joe Henderson and part of it right now is that we are driving construction trucks over those fields and
064so we're we're waiting to get the new TK building in and then once that's done we do have plans to try to get them leveled out the irrigation fixed and planting some trees for shade um and Robert simple it certainly makes sense that as we as we do the new buildings the first six you're going to have construction vehicles driving all over those fields so like our last after that's done our last piece go back level it out clean it up and then maintenance can help us with that afterwards yeah you're welcome now I'm going away thank you Mrs Egan we'll see you in a little [Laughter] bit so now we're on to um item number 13 our action [Music] items [Music] so we are coming to to um Mrs barington with our independent auditor
065report so I'd like to introduce uh Spencer Blanda he will be presenting our um annual audit for the district and both of our bond measures as of June 30th 2024 and he has a presentation for both good evening everybody I'm going to walk you through the results first of our district audit as of June 30 2024 and to talk about the agenda I'm essentially what this is are these are the deliverables when we issue our audit report we have our communication with those charge of governance letter which is our communication as the auditor to you as members of the board and then we have the actual independent Auditors report along with the financials and then the finally at the back of the audit report packet are the control letters the state compliance letters and the
066federal compliance letters so we'll talk briefly about each of those in the slides so looking at the scope of the engagement when you have your financials you have the government-wide financial you have the set of fund financials you have your required supplementary information your notes and all that information in the back and then the letters are at the way back of the audit report so starting first with that communication with those charts of governance and packet biggest takeaway from this slide is that we issued an unmodified opinion now what this means is that this is the best opinion that us as the auditor can give this means that the financials are free from any material misstatement and that they're in accordance with appropriate accounting principes in US Gap we worked closely with the um School
067District management over the course of the audit um first with Tim rahill who's no longer here at interim and then with Trudy barington at the year end phase and so we we came out we did our preliminary activities our internal control testing we come back again we do our financial testing and so forth and the biggest um communication I wanted to give on this is that it was a smooth process as always we received everything that we needed to all appropriate representations for management and we had no disagreements throughout the course of the audit so in conclusion a very smooth process we're also required to let you know if there's any um significant accounting estimates that you'll find in the financials the biggest estimates that you will see involve the collectibility of accounts receivable and
068also net pension liability and net opep liability so those are the significant estimates that you'll see in the district financials and when we do an audit we don't just look at numbers we look at a variety of things such as tests of controls um tone at the top Etc so we're really looking at things from a variety of different angles to ultimately conclude does it make sense and the results of the audit um staff was available um as I mentioned no disagreements we did have a finding um control sidewise I'll touch briefly about that the end there it's just um on internal control mainly around journal entries and we had no significant adjustments related to the financials now starting with the independent audit report so when we say audit report it's mainly pages one through
069three of your packet but the whole packet encompasses a variety of things what you'll see is um as I mentioned unmodified opinion on there so biggest takeaway there moving on to Pages 4-9 Management's discussion analysis this is really a great resource for anybody that wants to see what happened over the course of the fiscal year but wants kind of highle summary of that the management man discussion analysis will give you that and now let's look about what happened over the course of the fiscal year so you'll see from a government-wide perspective that total assets went up about 40 million what's driving this is we had an issuance of measure c bond and deferred inflows and outflows those adjustments are being mainly driven by changes in the net OPB and net pension liabilities so as the
070actuaries come out with new valuations they will impact those and so those will go up and down from year to year depending on how the actuary will valuate those and total liabilities are up about 40.3 million which driving this is a measure c bond issuance as I mentioned but also net pension and net opep liabilities have increased as well and finally net pension or I'm sorry net position is up 2.6 million from the prior year and then this just breaks it down in a little bit more detail as you can see um we did have some Capital outlay increase as well as we have those projects related to the bond going on at the school district now looking at summary of statement of activities and this is essentially an income statement at the government-wide level
071so we saw um to revenues are Up 3 million what's driving this is and we had increases in the lcff funding from prior year and we also saw increases in the fair market value of the cash and County Treasury external investment pool so the market had a good year last year and that drove up that fair market value so that's also contributing to that expenses are down from the prior year about 5.6 million those will go up or down depending on what's going on we have some capital outlay and so forth so those will drive that and then that rate that net position changed um went up by 8.6 million that's not actually what it went up by but it's the rate at which it changed from year to year and so this just breaks
072everything down in a little bit more detail the majority of our expenditures on the government-wide side are in instruction instruction C related services and pupil Services now that we've covered government wide this now zooms into the fund Financial level so look at general fund which is the main fund as you can see a majority of the revenue is driven by lcff funding um Federal is down from prior years and we know that covid money is being spent up so that has continually gone down as that Co money is been used up States also down from the prior year as well this mainly will fluctuate depending on what the state legislature issues in term terms of categorical funding so last year we did see learning recovery emergency block grant and Arts and Music discretionary Arts and
073Music instructional materials discretionary block grant both of which were kind of one-time funding sources that they issued last year and didn't issue this year so that's why state is appearing down from the prior year and local mainly fluctuated as I mentioned because the fair market value went up from the prior year and now looking at things from an expense side so about 85 to 86% of the general fund expenditures are driven by salaries and benefits related costs now looking at Financial Trends and Analysis so this you'll find in the supplementary information section which is in the back of that packet and this gives you a multi-year perspective not only as what's happened over the last couple of years but also what is projected to happen in 2425 so over the last couple of years long-term
074debt has gone up and this is mainly driven by the bond issuance that we had and also increases in net pension and net opep liability another thing of note here is that we have seen Ada go up over the last couple of years which is great it has been increasing since the pandemic days which is um Illustrated on that chart there so we are we are coming back up from that pandemic days which is good and so now I want to touch briefly about the um three letters that you'll see in the back of your audit report packets so first one is um that I want to touch on is State compliance letter so we had no issues noted with State compliance testing and the other one Federal compliance testing we had no issues as
075that related to that internal control the only thing that we noted was on segregation of Duties and we did have turnover over the year so sometimes journal entries could not have the approval that we were looking for um sometimes like you have to go in and and put it in like same person posting it's the same person that um posted into the system um but that's mainly driven by there's some turnover so we we met with management we have a game plan going forward to have a primary entry and a secondary reviewer it's always good to have a review and it's important with this is that even though we had this um there was no misstatements noted so even though we had this no issues were noted with the financials and then with that um
076as conclusion the net position has gone up and I would like to thank um formerly Tim rahill but then Trudy barington for her help in the year end phase uh and Trudy can attest um it's it's a large process both at interim and yearend we ask about maybe like over 100 requests each in both phases and so we're very thorough and management um especially Trudy has been super helpful in giving us what we need even during the final hour when we're wrapping up everything so my my thanks to Trudy and the staff there with that I would like to open the floor to any questions that anybody may have before I move on to the bond can we go back to slide 19 yes we've had a lot of discussion about percentage of the budget
077uh for people and we talked about a 92 I guess are you saying for 2425 it's 92 because it looks like it's 86 here for 23 24 this is the entire fund both restricted and unrestricted the conversations we've been having are around the unrestricted side because I mean the restricted side has the people people it has to pay for too right it does and a lot of the restricted side are the one-time funds and the staff associated with those one-time funds I'm also on the restricted side is special ed and our maintenance but a majority of our staff are on the unrestricted side of our budget and and that's what we've been talking about that's the area where we have more ability to to facilitate change on the restricted side you get money for a
078specific purpose and you have to use it for that and a lot of our unrestricted funds have to go to the restricted side to make up the shortfall especially for sped right we do have contributions that are are necessary for special ed and then we do have the required routine restricted maintenance contribution thank you any other questions can I have a a motion to approve the Auditors the independent auditor report please can I I move that we approve the independent auditor report as presented and a second please all second I I thank you now we come to uh action item 13B the financial perfor performance bond audit um Miss barington are you both back up yes Spencer will also present this as James Marta company does our audit part yes so I will um walk
079you briefly through the results um even though it says measure s and we included both measure s and measure C on the PowerPoint presentation oh sorry I think it's um I think it needs to perfect so I'm going to um so the first couple slides is mainly background information that's standard about Bonds in general and then what has been issued so I'm actually going to take you straight to the um communication with those charge of governance letter which is the first packet that you'll see in the bond deliverables so biggest takeaway is that on both measure C and measure s bonds and they are a separate audit reports for both we had an unmodified opinion which means that the bond Financial are free from any material misstatement and that they're in accordance with appropriate accounting
080principles and US Gap when again we worked closely with the management team as well and we do the bond audit side by side the district audit so we worked with management as well when we did our bond testing both at interim and at year end and with the bond audit and we had no disagreements um it was a smooth process as well with this um same as the district audit we're also required to communicate if there's any significant um accounting estimates that you'll see in with the bonds it mainly is due to accounts payable but other than that um everything numbers wise is pretty straightforward in those financials and so um I talked about this um audit procedures for the bond are about the same as the district audit so I'm going to go ahead
081and talk about the results um there was no findings that we noted on both measure s and measure c bonds um and staff was available for both so again again smooth process there now looking at the Independence autor report so this is going to be pretty much the same for both measure C and measure s on pages 1 through three you'll have your actual independent OT report and as mentioned um a clean opinion on both so now looking at the balance sheet so um normally what you'll see with bonds is um in the case of measure c um this is the first year of issuance so the cash is going to be up about like 45 million but as we go through year to year and it would be the case with measure s this
082is going to continue to go down as the bond funds are being spent and used on the projects um and sometimes there will be fluctuations because this is in fund 21 so sometimes it'll go up and down depending on what happens to that cash and County Treasury and fair market value fluctuation and then this is the um Revenue this is the income statement side there highlighting there so measure S as it continues to be used up is going to go down and then measure C is just in the beginning phases so you're not going to see a whole lot of expenditures there but as we go forward with those projects you'll start to see um like salaries um capital outlay and so forth we also do a performance audit with the bonds and so what
083this is is that when the bonds get issued they have the measured texts so we go in and test them to not only make sure that there's proper controls over what's being spent of the public funds but that they're in accordance with what the community voted on and so when we when we do our methodology we test um either so essentially when we do our bond testing it is 80% or greater of expenditures and so of that we reviewed things such as um invoices bidding process change orders Etc just making sure everything appears reasonable and the the conclusion there is we noted no issues and what we tested and so the funds in conclusion the the funds are being spent in accordance with the bond measure and there's strong controls at the business office over
084those public dollars which is important and so as I mentioned there um no no issues on the performance side and control testing side for each of those Bonds in conclusion um the district is expending the funds in accordance with measure s and measure C so in accordance with what the community voted on I would like to thank um Trudy barington and the District staff for their help on the Bond as well so with that I'd like to open the floor to any questions that the board may have are there any questions I want to just thank Trudy as well because I felt much more prepared as I went through the board pack and and so thank you so much can I have a motion to um approve and file the financial performance audit for um
085measure s and measure C General obligation bonds I move that we approve the financial and performance bond audit for measure s and measure C thank you do I have a second I'll make a second I move to make a second make a second and those in favor I I thank you for your time this evening everybody appreciate thank you okay so we're now to um action item c um Mrs Mrs Egan you are up again and then you're also here for a while okay um so this is a return from our prior discussion where you guys on December 19th issued an intent to convey an easement to the city so this is a second um action to that that is required and it actually says yes we're conveying it and we're given the city an
086easement meaning we still own the property we are giving them rights to build the bridge they actually have already gone to DSA they wrote a letter to the community talking about how they had negotiated funds from Republic Services to pay for all of the improvements and they have improve included both the bridge and the walkway improvements in their documents the DSA so staff recommendation is to go ahead and issue this to the city um just as a FYI we will be coming back with a future request for a second temp so this is a permanent easement um they will be asking for a second easement which will be a temporary easement and it will just allow them access across our property while they install the improvements so the the request tonight is um to approve
087a permanent easement which is only the 10 by 18 approximately piece for them to put the bridge butman on thank you are there any questions can I have a motion to approve the easement to the city I'll move that we approve resolution number 24221 as presented I second thank you this a resolution we're going to do a roll call call on roll call vote president grubs yes trusty hir yes trusty Meli yes and trusty manasi yes thank you and item 13d consideration and approval of resolution 24 2522 authorizing filing of applications for State allocation board administrated programs for the Benish Unified School District so this is um our state grants that we apply for which are matching monies for our local major c bond and major s um it used to be called prop 51
088and they recently passed what they call proposition two now and with that they've implemented some new rules they say still support and match our work in a similar methodology but they want us just to say yes we commit that one of the requirements you have is to file a fiveyear facilities master plan which we already have and so we're totally ahead of that and they just want um a letter showing that you guys support that and we agree to do that any questions and I have a motion to approve resolution number 24252 to authorizing the filing of applications for State allocation board administrative programs for the Benish Unified School District I move that we approve resolution 24- 25-22 I'll second will require another roll call vote president grubs yes trusty hir yesy melli yes and
089trusty manasi yes thank you and action item 13e consideration and possible approval to award the architectural contract to hibser hibser hibser yachi yachi Architects to proceed with construction documents for the Joe Henderson Elementary School modernization um on a time and time and material basis with a cost of not to exceed $669,500 so um this would allow them to proceed it's it's the architect the engineer the civil engineer structural it's the whole team and that get they draw the drawings they take them through DSA they give us support through the construction and then also through close out it's pretty it is a lot of work I know that this is not a small amount of money standards are around 10% within the industry and this is definitely within the 10% so staff recommendation is to award
090the contract and um allow them to proceed I was about I was about to ask if this is stand it does seem like a lot of money yeah it's a big project and it it it is a pretty industry standard and once the projects get bigger then sometimes the fees come down a little bit and when they're smaller they go up but because it you still have to do a minimum amount of work no matter how small it is yep thank you you're welcome the only other thing I'd like to ask um because these are legal Agreements are they reviewed by legal or they forms how you know um legal provides a standard form and that is the template that is all of the front um base plate that is there and then their proposal
091is just the back agreement but they are governed by it is our legal council's standard document and on smaller ones then we're not really required to use such of a large document but when we come to full planning like this we definitely do I have a motion oh do you have one yeah I just have a quick question because I just thought of this um did we take the this out to bid for in terms of Architects and um architecture um and Professional Services are not required to B you don't have to take the lowest price um we do measure them against indust stre standard and I certainly have Twisted people's arms before but um the process is that we issue a request for qualifications and we open it up and we allow interested professionals
092to apply and they bring their work we check um referrals and recommendations and then we can make the decision and then we can hire them direct and use them so we don't have to go out for a request for qualification on every single project we do it as needed um so we worked with hips are yachi for a very long time and they've been a good support to us so I understand this correctly we did not open it up for other architectural firms to apply or look into okay can I have a motion to um award the contract as written I'll move I move that we the contract as written I'll second that all those in favor I I I thank you okay um item 13f consideration and possible approval to award the architectural contract
093to California Design West Architects to proceed with construction documents for the minisha high school field upgrades with a cost not to exceed $891,000 $899 similar yeah so California Design West is a different firm we are utilizing multiple architectural firms right now so although I'm not asking for bids on different projects we do we're getting support we have more than one firm can provide but it also gives me a comparison in what our pricing looks like as well as what are the benefits and if I can't get it done with one person I'll go to the next quite frankly so but we're doing good we have good teams right now we're we moving on um staff recommendation is to award this approval um for the bisha high school fields in the amount of $891,000 [Music] thank
094you going on to 13g consideration and approval to award art the architectural contract to California Design West Architects to proceed with construction documents for the bisha Middle School upgrades with a cost not to exceed $446,900 it's similar yeah it's within industry stand standards the costs right now for the fields are estimated above 6 million um we have had good support from California Design West Staff recommendation is to award the contract to them for $446,900 any questions can I have a motion I just wanted to State something um I just wanted to state that we have um Ben Buck here who is the president of our bisha Arsenal um group and so for people just on record that we had that um and I know that the Arsenal group is encouraging and supportive of our Fields
095so I just want to make sure that we say that before we move on from the fields okay thank you um can I have a motion to approve the contract please um I move that will that we approve the contract as written I'll second all those in favor I thank you thank you thank you Roan going to 13h consideration and approval of bisha high school course outlines ethnic studies Dr beatson yes good evening um I'm excited to bring back to you our uh course outline proposal for ethnic studies um last meeting I presented the um course proposal and um because as required by Ed code for this particular course which will be a graduation requirement um beginning uh the state required it for the uh beginning of the 2030 graduating class and when we voted
096uh when you voted last meeting we are bringing it in for the graduating class of 2029 so next year's ninth graders um it was required to bring to one meeting prior to it being adopted um so I'm bringing for your hopeful hopeful approval and adoption the uh course outline for ethnic studies um again it's the new requirement it is a semester long class it will be offered for students in 11th or 12th grade and until it becomes a requirement it will be uh offered as an elective that students can choose it lives in the history department so it will be taught by a history social science teacher um and just to give a little bit of background uh as you know this has been in the works for several years our teachers um have engaged
097in a lot of professional development some through our county office they did a network for for um staff that were uh potentially going to be teaching ethnic studies we um uh UC Berkeley put together a series of modules online modules that teachers uh participated in we had a teacher participate in um a a year long it might have been six six months to year I can't quite remember it was last year um inperson Saturday sessions so we've done a lot of uh participating I uh myself have gone to several conferences on this as well um the entire uh course outline is grounded in the state's adopted model curriculum and um uh from the course outline once uh it's approved then teachers will begin working on syllabus which has more detail in uh what what the
098actual course and lesson plans will look like but all of it will come from the state model curriculum and just to remind you there are five units um and they are thematic in in um nature so one is on identity on History uh and movement systems of power social movement and equity and um the team that put this together they've worked really hard on this put it together and added another unit on celebrations and contributions because they wanted to make sure while there's some heavy stuff in this uh history of um of folks that there was also really recognition of the contributions of different groups and so tonight um I bring to you uh ethnic studies for your hopeful approval any questions I I have a question I was wondering okay so this is a
099course outline um do we have an opportunity to approve a syllabus or anything like that Beyond this no okay um so with that I you know if anybody else has questions I just I have a couple things I just want to say like observations I guess um so first of all I really I commend staff on identifying a goal for this class that I think is really inclusive um and comprehensive and last time principal kmet discussed how the goal is really to understand that there are multiple multiple perspectives we're coming from different cultures with different histories we want kids to think critically and form their own opinions and and also in line with the reason that the bill was passed is to have more instruction on culture history struggles and celebrations so I um I
100fully support that I think that's great and um I reviewed the entire model curriculum I did this is interesting for me too I I really I I enjoy it um and I think that the curriculum you know you've probably followed some of the news there's um it's been criticized it didn't pass at first it's gone through several modifications and I and I know that at this stage like that is just one resource and our teachers are going to be compiling other resources and you listed a couple websites there um one thing I noted just globally and again I know that this is still somewhat INF flux is that I didn't think that the model curriculum fully um addressed contributions and celebrations on a consistent basis between different groups I thought the the module on African-American
101was was pretty comprehensive there was information on all of those topics and then but less so with the other groups so I just you know I'm hoping that when it comes to finalizing things that that will be made added right and yeah that I think the team recognized that as well and they felt like there was a lot of some heaviness in some of this other work and that's why they created a whole unit on let's um the contributions and celebration yeah that was not um in the original plan as they were working and then as they continued to review it they said we need to add this as a whole unit so that people recognize that yeah and and I think that's one thing that's really great about this course is that the law
102specifically gives us the ability to do that um another thing that I noticed is you know there's some there are some things in the model curriculum that I actually think are inappropriate um there in the section on Jewish Americans there's a discussion of conditional whiteness and I'm Jewish um there's no other place in the curriculum that talks or labels people as conditionally white and so I really have a big objection even I read the definition but I don't know um and so you know I'm uncomfortable approving something where I think that's going to be taught so I don't know you know if I guess it it it would be my hope that we had a little more time and we could see a little bit more in detail of what will be taught because um
103that that gives me concern um and then also just with the model you know there's it I think it also kind of fails to provide multiple perspectives in a comprehensive way and I know that you're going to be addressing that but I do want to flag it because this is the only time I can um uh Martin Luther King Jr isn't mentioned in the model curriculum and I feel like that's an Omission there's there's there's just a lot there um so you know I think Governor Nome said when he uh vetoed the first model the first model curriculum he said you know in California we don't tolerate our diversity we celebrate it and that should be reflected in our high school curriculum and um that the curriculum should achieve balance fairness and be inclusive of
104all and I know that being in bonisha we can do that and I know that that's the intent um but you know as a trustee I just feel like I need to have more information or um you know assurance that c that especially that Jewish American conditional whiteness wouldn't be taught um for me to approve it so that's kind of where I'm coming from I comp I think you guys have done a great job with adding the celebrations I really do that's exactly the kind of thing you know the the tough looking that I like yeah and just and I think um I think M Klein Smith said this last time as well this is a semester long course there are so many lessons that there's no way so what's listed in here are samples
105of lessons pulled that match the particular unit but I don't believe that a teacher if they're really going deep in this work is going to be able to do all of them even even the ones listed the intent wasn't that they would get through all of those lessons because there's not a way to do that in a one semester class in the mo in the um the model lessons were those comprehensive I can't imagine or in the um I've lost my words so okay um is it curriculum or lesson in the model curriculums in ethnic study model curriculum that Amy is talking about those are not usually comprehensive as to the whole curriculum correct they have sample lessons and they have exactly so so what will be different about this course than US History US
106History we look at um we have our standards so everything is based on the standards even this course and then we'll go to a textbook companies and we'll vet several textbooks and we'll purchase one there isn't a an ethnic studies textbook and so what the state has provided and vetted is I didn't count but a lot of um lessons and so a and other resources on the State website there's resources UC Davis has resources UC see Berkeley and there's additional lessons that all meet the needs of the model curriculum because the other part is it's supposed to be based on who's sitting in your classroom and so there's the opportunity to trade out if you will based on what's Happening and who's in your classroom as long as we're sticking to our course description the
107standards the the the intent of the unit thank you for that clarification anybody else have any thoughts on this I do um thank you Dr beatson for meeting with me and sharing me you did a lot of really great work prior to this I know this is has been coming down the pipeline for some time so um thank you for for everything that you've done and the Outreach in the community that you've done to just ask questions and ask for feedback I think that that's really great one um one thing that's sitting with me and I know that I've shared this with you too is we're in the Bay Area this is home to sort of ethnic studies right and this is an area that I think that we can do really good at um
108and when I read the course outline I know that there's intent and expectations from our Collective group to talk about the lgtbq plus Community we maybe our Arab Americans or our Middle Eastern there's intent that we would talk about that and be inclusive but it's not on paper and that's one thing that makes me a little bit nervous that we're not actually putting it on paper that it should be discussed or that and I feel like maybe the way that it's written maybe we need to maybe not give so many of the suggested lessons to narrow it down like that but talk broadly and make sure that we're pointing out that we are going to talk about this community we are going to do this um so those are my that's what I'm thinking right
109now and just wanting to ensure that this course provides our 11th and 12th graders the ability to have this conversation amongst each other and I appreciate it's with the credential teacher to really have these critical skills that are going to last them once they graduate from from our schools so where do we stand now so are we thinking about tabling this are we to approve I'd like to know what that means to our timeline so right so um we have students who are ready to sign up or in the will be signing up up for classes and so we'd like to be able to have this as an offering for them to choose for an elective because it's also a time where we were trying a new course and we can make some adjustments as
110needed um and the other piece to consider is um all of our courses at b or I shouldn't say all we strive that all of our courses at bonisha high school are approved through the UC CSU portal and what that means is um the UC CSU we have to submit the course outline they review it and they determine whether or not it would qualify um for one of their a tog courses to be accepted if students were to apply and so for students to apply to a UC or CSU they have to meet um different criteria for us it's graduation requirements for ucsu it's a to G and they'll tell you you need this many a courses this many B courses different subjects and so we have that uh window opens in February we get
111faster results from them if we're at the beginning of the window than if we wait later in the year so Master scheduling needs to happen um of course uh uh now I lost my word approval no um course selection sorry course selection master schedule UC approval needs to happen and um I think uh uh the the different communities there are four that are required by the state and that is built in and then in the lessons that we pick is when we um identify the other um ethnic groups and then um the lgbtq plus Community is woven throughout it's not an um an ethnic group in and of itself and we are required by another law called The Fair Act to ensure that all of those perspectives no matter what we're teaching are brought to
112the um brought to the Forefront and and taught so regardless of whether it's even in history so what are this discussion of tabling it what would we be looking for in tbling it what would be the concept behind that so it depends if there's a motion if if we have a motion there are a couple of things that can happen according to rosenberg's rules of uh order and that is one we somebody can make a motion to approve somebody can make a motion to table and further consideration and someone can make a a motion to not approve right I think structurally I I understand the concept of tabling but I I think what I'm looking for is if we do table this what are we hoping to get out of tabling it yeah I I
113I mean I'm I'm probably the person who should speak to that and I struggled with that because I um I understand where we are in the process and I understand how much work has gone into it I think for me um if we were to table it what I'd like to see is more specificity about what would be taught because right now the model curriculum is just it's gigantic and um you know there's a ton of lessons in the I'm using this term because the model uses it but the very very broad Asian American um lesson and I hate to say that because there are so many different ethnic groups within that umbrella including um Arab Americans are included in there um so I guess for me like for me to be able to approve
114it I would just I would like to see more specificity and and more detail about um the the lessons that are actually going to be used because you know if I don't need to worry about the conditional whiteness aspects of the Jewish part being taught then that makes me feel better you know it makes me want to support it more um if I if I'm able to see that we have balanced in terms of hitting the different objectives history culture celebrations and struggles I'd like to see I'd like to see balance with that so that not just one group isn't highlighted with contributions but we have contributions from all groups and I mean I know that you know I I would benefit from knowing I don't know a lot of contributions from some of the
115groups you know I think that it's really important to get the information out there because um there are contributions I I was um heartened today to see on social media there was um a picture of two students from the ethnic studies table at the um High School fair and they had a picture a poster of all all these different um notable figures and just looking you know based on my own site I could see that there are incl there is inclusion of a lot of contributions so but what I'd like to see if we table it is more specificity and and the reason I'm asking for that is because the um the this is you know there's lawsuits right now and I just I just want to be careful that we're doing um a and
116and I'm not saying we're not but I just want to I can't approve it until I see that we've done a really detailed View and that we've got like would you like to make a [Music] motion so what well would you like to make a motion I would but I don't I want Mark if Mark has something to say I don't want it just uh lesie if I'm correct me if I'm wrong but I get I respect where you're at on all that I was under the impression that this is like the most General level like a beginning General level and the specificity would come later with the syllabus and the concept I was thinking of like a middle ground would be who's going to end up developing in the syllabus so you're absolutely right
117the the think of the course outline is like the framework it's the bumpers it's the general here are the standards here are the units in Broad Strokes in in all of the um course outlines that are approved and then the specificity comes in with the syllabus which is developed um by the department and with the administration um because that will potentially change over time as things develop and it doesn't have to come back to the board each time it would be in the lesson planning just like teachers do use their professional judgment day in and day out to plan lessons to that detail but that typically isn't in um a course outline which comes to get approved this is these are the the parameters if you will or the bumpers of what that course will
118be um and it's also in a format that gets is accepted by the ucsu so they tell us what the information is that they need to approve and that's actually one of the real the other real reasons for a course outline which you really only see at the high school level is so that we can send it to the college and say if kids take this class will they will it count for eligibility purposes for your a tog and so that's one of the real purposes for do you I'm sorry theoretically could Amy be a part of the syllabus could you be could she be a part of that with the teacher like I I don't want to I don't want to overstep or no that's why I was asking because this is Uncharted yeah
119but just to alleviate you know like maybe if you're in on because it seemed to me like all the things you're asking for would be that next level after you approve the course outline then the syllabus would be and that specif the specificity you're looking for would come at the next step unless I'm wrong which I quite often am you know I I I think that that that's not part of our okay it's not part yeah yeah the what not that and and I can definitely share your concern as the teachers are developing that and that is um I don't know when I read um uh the M the sample lesson on that I don't know how big a piece that is and if it would even come up yeah I as a as a
120no I and I totally I totally get and I don't want to be a stick in the mud or anything later I want you to explain to me situational wh I I I have I printed it super curious what that means what does that mean conditional conditional whiteness I'm very curious and and you know normally I I think that this kind of this usually we have a textbook right and we can look and we can go and Stephanie Rice can say we teach this this but we don't teach this and she does that like she will do that and so for me at this point um I think I'm uncomfortable approving it based on the model lessons that are included alone so I mean if I think so for me I would love to see
121um I would love to have staff tell us more include more lessons give more specificity so and that comes in some ways it's a chicken and an egg because they need the guidelines to know what they're going to go then develop in terms of lesson plans and syllabus they we can't whoops we can't necessarily do that before we know the bumpers you know yeah I know it's a weird thing can they take the um what they currently have and add to it or amend it or somehow because just based on the I mean so this is where my annoying lawyer brain goes in like I feel like I have to be I have to like this is what I'm being given and so if I approve it then I've approved it you know and and
122there's there's no wiggle room so I think in my perfect world for me to be to give it 100% Amy Hersh approval I would just I would like to see more more specificity about what is not being taught and maybe what would be taught um and I think I'm almost like opposite but in agreement with you in the sense of I feel like there needs to be more leeway way in The Guiding lessons and key assessments and More in like that description to kind of narrow it to then allow the flexibility for the teachers to create that syllabus um so I I understand where you're coming from but I think we're both have we both have two different approaches to it and I just want to Advocate you know for you Dr beatson like I
123appreciate everything going through the portal and making sure we're doing this for me this class is different than like our and I know you feel this way too like math and English right this is a this is a class that's going to help our students be better citizens and be better Global Citizens and that goes right back to our vision um and so really thinking through what this class could give um our graduates so motion if we Sorry if we tabled it how would do we say like we'd like to bring this back to Dr beatson to make some tweaks I mean how what are what would the the options for us be well I think the options would be I mean we've heard your feedback so I think that if you made that motion
124and that's what you wished we would take it back and take a look at the outline and you would direct us to bring it back to a future board meeting okay I like I said I totally respect where you're at like you said the Chicken and the Egg I mean it feels like this is the most General aspect and the specificity comes later I and I like I said I worry if we table this are we're going to put ourselves behind the aball for the process but put ourselves behind the process of having it as a course now or for the mandatory graduation requirement we had put in uh what we had decided last time was that it would be an elective now so our teachers have worked really hard to put this together they're
125very excited to begin this course um and so it depends on how quickly they can get back together we can get the feedback that you're looking for to put in here um uh to be able to be offered next year we did agree to that time I remember could that be we added that right by the next Bo meeting it's um remember a team worked on this we had a couple of Administrators several teachers not at all at the same site so they' we'd have to find some time for them to come back together um to do some more research for what you're looking for in the course outline I I respect for you're at I am going to move that we do approve the ethnic studies uh course outline because for me personally I
126think these are things that could be worked out in later steps and I don't want to put this behind especially since we already agreed that this would be a course that we're offering so that is an official motion to approve the course outline I understand if you you know I'm G to second that and the reason I'm going to Second it um and I I really see where you're at AB no I don't take I really do but I also um have a pretty good understanding of how adopting curriculum works and that we have we have these guidelines from the state but we don't have a textbook and so there's there's um a large process that goes into it and since there is more um uh there can be more um input as we go
127forward it's not like having a textbook that you just say we're going to do boom boom boom boom we can uh approve this this outline and then add add or subtract but we can um teachers can really look at it um and uh Dr beatson can come back with us with those with those so I am seconding the motion can I ask a question before we take a vote will will there be an opportunity to go back and forth like say say it hits the ground running and their issues crop up um is the can parents can the community can we come and say you know this is being taught and is there a way to have that addressed concerns always always and and as this gets developed into a syllabus and they're identifying for
128this next semester next year this is what the course is going to be parents can come in and look at the materials the the lovely thing about this is everything's online so we can direct them like these are the pieces that have have been picked so that can happen at any time if there's concerns you know we would do the chain of command they would talk to the teacher and talk to the principal and if it was a um I don't want to say the word Global that's not the word I'm trying to come up with but pretty big concern thank you I um you know we absolutely could look at that again I want to ask one more question in um now it's my turn to lose my train of thought um as we
129are progressing in the the year the the second year um of the course can we come back to this course outline and modify it and change it okay yeah and I think that we you could do that I think we have to be careful because I would assume the state has certain things that they want to make sure that you cover as long as we don't take out anything that is required then we'd be good to go yeah and I think there might be more developments from the state from just what I'm reading um yeah so we might have to come back at some point and eventually we bring course outlines back for updating just on a regular basis because things have changed changed Y and we um Mrs Martinez all those in favor I
130I'm an N or no so we have three how about nay and n and thank you thanks guys if we go on thank you a you had some excellent points thank you yes yeah I do want to encourage that okay 13 I consideration approval of high school course outline Advanced PE Dr beatson okay so I have another elective that's been developed um with a course outline for your hopeful approval it is a one um year course and it is a an an additional PE elective um it is focused and targeted for our um student athletes it won't be closed to anyone but it will H it's it's it's kind of think of it like an AP course and so we allow anyone who wants to take an AP course to take that AP course but
131they know going in that it's a level of rigor that they need to consider and that's what the intent of this course is is is that it will be really focused on our um during season and offseason athletes and so that they can get some conditioning weight training um nutrition those are all the different units you probably saw in here and that there would be also a an opportunity for some collaboration between the teacher of the course and the coaches um so that they can get some specifics about what they're hoping their athletes can do which would help both our sports program and our student athletes I can speak to the we're we're behind most districts have this already and oh yeah and I could also tell you knowing the having talked to the teachers
132at the high school there everyone's 100% behind this that's good to know my kid already added this in his course schedule so everyone's everyone's on board with this so just so you know in the course catalog because we had to start um course elections it will say pending approval so they know as they are looking at these it's he told me about it I was like oh most districts have this already at their high schools oh yeah it's had it forever it's really good to see is there uh can I get a motion to approve Advanced PE for I move that we approved Advanced PE for athletic performance I'll second all those in favor I 13j consideration approval of bisha high school course outlines career and College Planning I got myself all out of order
133here um take your time um so this is a uh one semester elective and it is really based on the get focused course so if you remember at the last board meeting when we um the new graduation requirements were adopted because we have uh ethnic studies rolling in and then in 2030 one personal finance rolling in as state required graduation requirements the board elected to remove get focused from our ninth grade as a local graduation requirement um Miss Klein Schmid in talking with students uh there were some interest in kind of a shortened a bridged version of that course at the upper level around College and Career planning and so that's what this course is it's really based on the get focused course but it's Abridged and for um 11th or 10th 11th or 12th
134uh graders and um I I can go through the course if you would like if you have questions but it is really that course rolled up as an elective for one semester and it would only run of course if there were enough students to take it and who's the teacher I don't know who would be teaching it at this point is it a okay so we don't know if it's a counselor if it's a oh it would be a it wouldn't be a counselor it would be a credential teacher can what is when you talk about enough students what's our floor uh the class loading is 33 and they think they run the schedule at 30 or 31 to see how well it shakes out and typically we won't run a class if it doesn't
135have at least 25 at least that's been our past practice and so you know we'll have to look at what that looks like I was just curious about the floor thank you okay okay is there a motion I'll move that we approve career and College Planning course outline as present I'll second that I I and 13k consideration and approval of bisha high school course outlines integrated math 2A okay thank you I really I realize I probably should have put K in L together um uh our math department along with Miss Klein Schmid has worked to develop an alternative to straight math 2 and so remember our board policy and graduation requirement is students need to take two years of mathematics Through Math one and then they've always had an option to continue with math 2
136math 3 and onto some uh potential APS or after math one to take personal finance and with personal finance rolling in as a graduation requirement in a few years um we needed to look at other alternatives for students who may not quite be ready to take math 2 as is and so um we have math one a which means students take that first year of math over two years so it slows the uh the same course same textbook same standards but it just slows the um the course down and we're doing the same thing we're proposing the same thing for math 2 so students that want to stay on that math uh 1A or one two3 track um could take math 2A for a year and then the following year and I'll say this again
137when we get to L they would take the other half of as 2B and it would count for a second year of math if it matters to anyone in the for transparency's sake you know my wife's a m teacher to high school and they are they are behind us and thank you for for finding an alternative to personal finance I think that's really important I love the idea of slowing down or you know teaching in two in two sections um math to makes sense is there a motion I move that we approve integrated math 2 a I'll second that I I and just vote on 2B since we already yes how about how about that um did you is there do I uh the next one is the second half of that course okay okay
138is there a motion I move that we approve um integrated math to be for outline I'll second hi 13m consideration approval of program specialist special education the special education job description Dr Jennings you are um good evening um president grubs and board trustees um this item um before you for consideration um this one and item n are current is a we have a current job description and we are separating out the two pieces um in the past those two the program specialist for special education and the behaviors were combined into one position um in working with the special education leadership team they have determined like they they prefer to have them separated they're very different skill sets for those two positions so um you'll see that the both job descriptions are on here for approval
139um as separate um job descriptions so this will be two two separate te as opposed to one yes and currently we um we have had this position filled in the past for the program specialist what we haven't had is the the behaviorist we've been contracting out the behaviorist services so they um we currently don't have one it's own in that position right so there's someone we have people in the position so we're not adding positions no is not an add of position that's what I was getting yes if we're Contracting out if you can hire somebody within the district it's always cheaper it's always Che than Contracting out so this is not an addition not okay that's what I was going for thank you and these fa motion positions work districtwide yes they do the
140program specialist has been integral in working at the school sites with especially our new special education teachers providing them the support that they need I had a Community member reach out to me to um just mention um some thoughts to include inclusion techniques um within the um job description um as well as maybe thinking about that as professional development and particularly inclusion as professional development so I wanted to just put that out so we're talking about that a great idea my colleague over in ed services will um work on the gened side of that I'm sure is there any other well I just want to State my my comment was not towards the it was really sort of like that this person knows the techniques and that they have skills of inclusion so just to
141make sure that I'm saying that correctly that it really is a skill set um that we are advocating for for these roles as well as professional development moving forward I appreciate the clarification I go ahead I was going to make a motion but please I move that we approve the program specialist job description I'll second all those in favor I alrighty so our um our next regular board meet one more oh we have one more oh uh the oh yes behaviors 13 and the be um updated job description that supports the continued implementation of high quality services for students with behavioral needs my comments from m go to end too thank you and and this you know and like we said earlier this is currently a contracted position I move that we approve the behaviorist
142job description I'll second all those in favor I so now we come to the adjournment of our meeting um our next regular board meeting is Thursday February 6th 2025 and the bisha high school open house is going on um right now so thank you all and we'll see you on the six