CorpusRecord 31095

CUSD Board meeting 2-12-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Carlsbad USD
Date
2025-02-13
Location
San Diego County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,085 words · about 107 min
Collected
2026-06-06

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening it's 5:30 p.m. and I call this meeting to order have any blue cards been received for close session items we do not have any blue cards thank you the board will now recess to close session e e e hey is 602 and I we are reconvening from closed session there is nothing to report out of close session welcome members of the public uh board members and staff thank you for attending as noted in board bylaw 9324 this meeting is being video recorded and broadcast via a link on our website the recording and broadcast May capture images and sounds of those attending the meeting I'd like to remind audience members and speakers that it is not unusual for students and young children to be in attendance at our meetings or to watch the recorded

002broadcast I invite you to model Civility and deorum as we go about the business of the board this evening while I cannot prohibit anyone from using unprofessional language please think about the students and adults who are watching our proceedings we invite you to show support for a speaker by waving your fingers rather than clapping or cheering we'll begin tonight's meeting with student board representative mea Moore leading Us in the Pledge of Allegiance trusty Ward will lead us in a moment of meditation I will read from the meeting norms and truste seos will read from the district vision and Miss Garcia will take the role s ready begin this month we celebrate Black History Month a dedicated time to recognize and honor the achievements and contributions of African-Americans throughout history the story of Black History Month

003began in 1915 half a century after the 13th amendment abolished slavery in the United States in 17 1976 President Ford officially recognized Black History Month urging Americans to seize the opportunity to honor the too often neglected accomplishments of black Americans in every area of endeavor throughout our history this is a time to reflect on the profound impact African-Americans have had on US history and Society from civil rights pioneers and activists to influential leaders in politics industry science culture and Beyond we are fortunate to live in a country rich with diverse experiences and backgrounds and cultures may we continue to learn from one another and celebrate our differences and embrace the strength that diversity brings I also want to acknowledge that national school counselor week was from February 3rd to the 7th so in honor of

004our incredible counsellors for the work they do and to care and prepare our students I want to say thank you also the February 17th marks PTA Founders Day reminder of the role that parents and teachers play in our education system the original founders of the PTA were Visionary and courageous women who recognize the power of action importance of breaking barriers and the need to be strong advocates for students their legacy lives on through the dedication of parents and teachers in our carlbad community thank you to our parents and teachers for all they do for our students and lastly there's been a lot in the news lately much of which will have a direct impact on the lives of our Carl's Bad families and students as we move forward I hope we all remain committed to

005our responsibility to support every student and understand the invaluable role public education plays in our community to ensure that students have an opportunity to Live Safe secure and successful lives and our Norms are everyone participates seek first to understand then to be understood stay on topic listen before responding keep discussion moving forward remain objective adhere to time one conversation and conduct ourselves with gracious professionalism our graduates are prepared for Success they confidently move to Life Beyond high school knowing they have acquired the requisite skills and knowledge they have a passion for Learning and personal growth they can thrive in a high-tech environment they are compassionate our students are engaged self-directed Learners they are exposed to different learning environments and Pathways students aspire to expand their talents and Achieve Excellence they are good thinkers communicators and

006problem solvers our staff members demonstrate an un compromising commitment to student growth they are leading Scholars and experts in their field they enthusiastically share their experience and knowledge and bring Innovative innovative ideas to their craft thank you trusty we usually only do one section so that's fine um thank you and uh Miss Garcia will you take the role student board representative Moore here trusty COC here trusty Emory here Trust trust B here truste Ward here trusty Rollings here thank you and we now move on to part four approval of the agenda trustees um are there any questions not the agenda may I have a motion to approve agenda item 4.1 approval and our reorganization of the February 12 meeting agenda motion second moved by trusty Ward second by trusty Emory any discussion Miss Garcia please

007call for a vote trusty COC yes truste Emory yes truste verth yes trusty Ward yes truste Rollings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you uh we now move on to uh part five Communications and 5.1 report by student representative to the board I am now happy to introduce Mir Moore representing carlb High School who will provide the board with the report okay good evening I'm pleased to share the school reports following Carlsbad schools first I'm exited to share that over the weekend crood High School hosted their winter formal at the bo Hoya Museum of Contemporary Art with record attendance additionally this week ASB is holding Valentine's Gams in a spikeball tournament moreover I'm happy to share that the class of 2025 recently installed their senior gift with a brand new C at the front

008gate of the school additionally two weeks ago Carl W held its annual inclusiv inclusivity assembly hosting Redmond Raymond RIS and his journey with being paralyzed he inspired students to always persevere and served as a perfect role model for are no place for hate campaign looking into sports Carlsbad recently held lacrosse triy outs while track and volleyball start up again as for winter sports our boys and girls basketball teams and soccer teams are moving into playoffs finally this month we are heartbroken to hear the loss of Vinnie record an amazing student at crossbed high school he was part of our best buddies program and was a shining light on campus a GoFundMe has been created in his name and no matter the amount any contribution will be greatly appreciated now for sage Sage fall sports are

009wrapping up girls basketball recently celebrated their senior night honoring the team's incredible achievements this season this Wednesday girls soccer plays Oceanside at 600 p.m. and boys basketball takes on CCA at 7:00 p.m. at Sage it will also be senior night for boys basketball come support the team on their special night today at lunch ASB is hosting a stand for National send a card to a friend day students are encouraged to stop by and write a special note to their friends throughout the month of February Sage is selling Valentine's Day grams for $3 get yours before they sell out lastly a huge shout out shout out to the cast and crew of sage theaters Annie Get Your gu done for an incredible performance run finally for Seaside I am pleased to share updates from carwad Village

010Academy and Carl Seaside Academy as they move into the second semester both schools have started strong with the seniors actively making decisions about their future paths while some students are finalizing their call choices others are preparing for enlistment in the armed forces demonstrating a wide range of postsecondary Ambitions one exciting event that took place on February 7th was the MiraCosta College bario bario empowerment conference where five carlbad Village Academy students participated in these workshops and heard from inspiring speakers the conference provided valuable insights and these students returned with new ideas and plans for their Futures as we move forward students are diligently working through the semester embracing both the challenges and triumphs that lie ahead we're excited for what the coming months will bring and appreciate the board's continued support for our schools and students

011thank you thank you um we now move on to item 5.2 superintendent's report Mr Rick Schmidt thank you president Rawling so good job last night uh trustees I think in moving us forward in uh the search for a permanent superintendent and I think the timelines are perfect uh I think the The Sweet Spot for attracting a lot of really talented um uh candidates for the superintendent the community soon will get a chance to provide feedback and suggestions on what they would like in terms of their next superintendent and I'm looking forward to that process and thanks for all the work because it will be a lot of work on your part I I know you'll do a fantastic job and welcome back Suzanne oconnell who who for many years I believe from 2004 to 2017

012was an assistant superintendent a CBO and a deputy superintendent here and then returned um in 2021 for an interim and I'm glad to have a partner um like myself who has failed retirement and uh and that is a good thing welcome home thank you that conclude your report yes thank you um then welcome Susan con um and we now move on to item 5.3 public comment on non-agenda items this is the time that members of the public have the opportunity to address the board on any non- agendized items that is within the subject jurisdiction of the board how many blue cards have we received six we received six thank you um in order to allow speakers to present their comment ments and ensure we are able to properly attend to the business of the uh

013the board per board bylaw 9323 public comments will be limited to 20 minutes this means each speaker will have three minutes when I call your name please come to the podium state your name and indicate whether or not you live within the boundaries of the school district the first speaker is Rachel Marino good evening my name is Rachel Marino wat I am the teachers union president I do not live live in the district but my children do go here recently a conflict between a trustee and members of the community has played out in a public forum some of these people are members of my union which is why I'm here today I too am in an elected position I'm answerable to my members for my choices and decisions when they approach me out of anger

014or in a manner that is accusatory it's typically because there's fear my job is not to answer the defensiveness that I naturally feel it is my job to understand where they're coming from and where their fear is grounded sometimes I can help and I take great great joy in being able to help sometimes I cannot for a myriad reasons things have happened before me decisions have been made laws have been created but I listen and I approach them with compassion after all these things affect their ability to do their job to retire eventually or unretire eventually um to work where they want to work in a place that is um a great place to be this same compassion is due to every Community member who approaches one of our trustees and that compassion and respect

015is what I as a union president expect towards my members and towards the the members of our community who are also the teachers of my children and whose children I teach thank you for your time thank you next speaker is Laura pittz hello I'm Laura pittz I'm the CEO at Carl's bed Educational Foundation I have two kids at Cala Elementary School um I wanted to take some time to provide information regarding Kids Care since there was a great deal of conversation regarding Kids Care at the last meeting and I wanted to reiterate that we are here as partners to the district so whatever decision that you choose to make specifically regarding kindergarten we are here to support CD and our working parents and we can work collaboratively to ensure that our programs complement whatever School

016format that that is chosen to be the most advantageous for our students and I I wanted to share that we take this role of um providing a rich an enriching and safe environment for students very seriously we accomplish it in a variety of ways and there's two I will highlight one we are a licensed program and as such we run a 14 to1 ratio of student to teacher and um in the kindergarten and TK program we actually run a 10:1 ratio because of a new requirement that was required when elop rolled out and so we do offer some small settings for students to get additional um attention from our teachers um additionally we take um pride in our um professional development and we do professional development regularly and in a variety of ways and so

017I'll share a few things things is last year our site coordinators were all able to attend a conference together to get information on how to run better programming and how to be good leaders on their program campus um we also have staff periodically attending um programming through the children's initiative of San Diego and I'm proud that last fall one of our employees was asked to actually be a presenter at this conference um providing information about understanding and supporting Young Learners and then another thing that's happened um at times is that we have been invited into teachers classrooms to be able to observe or possibly um collaborate on either students or groups of students that we may be working with at Kids Care um in the after school or kindergarten program and so that's something that

018if teachers in the district are interested we're thrilled to be able to get that kind of professional development on site at our our campuses so I share all that to just share with you that we're committed to providing the very best program regardless of what the district needs and as that I will transition also to share I'm very excited that our summer programs are now planned um we will have everything posted on our website this week so if are looking for their Camp options for the summer there will be a brochure that will be posted by Friday um enrollment will open on March 5th the summer Adventure which is our full day and our enrichment specialty camps will all take place at Kelly Elementary School CF Academy will take place at Sage Creek um additionally

019if parents go on right now there's information on our website regarding the academy program and our um enrollment for that will also open um March in March I believe it's it might be the last week of February but it's coming um and families are encouraged to consider Carl's bed educational program for their summer programming needs many organizations across the community offer very similar programs and ours is the only one whose proceeds will go back to El directly to our Carl's bed students so thank you thank you the next speaker is Greg D good evening trustees um superintendent Schmidt and welcome back Susan um I'm Greg D I'm a member of the community and I'm also the outgoing chairperson of the independent oversight board uh full decade ago uh trustee Claudine Jones asked me if I

020would represent uh or be a representative on the plan or the prop P oversight committee and I had a commitment to education in carlbad partly because I have two children that came through our schools and I also was involved with Kelly Elementary with physical education and a running team um so oversight was something new and yet it was something that I relished being involved with joining the oversight committee led me to new acquaintances with special people many of whom are in this room um and it also put me in in connection with the Building Services Group it could not have been a better Association it left me with a profound appreciation for the professionalism and the foresight of the District bond spending has been centered on purposeful investment in learning in infrastructure and in the

021long-term development of Carl's Bad youth as successful leaders um our accountants have said the same thing and last week we had a meeting of the oversight Committee in which final well was the final one for three of us uh Dr J marand uh Brenda Hall and myself I'm pleased to announce that replacing me as chairperson is Mara Evans and she could not have been a better choice besides having two children in our schools Mara has had six years of leadership on the committee and a depth of business Acumen with her MBA and finance she has a background in commercial real estate and 11 years of leading PTA boards she has been on a host of different volunteer grps and she's an excellent choice and she'll be joined as Vice chair will be uh Kevin slaboda

022uh who brings also energy in depth oversite is often characterized as catching something wrong and that's not correct it's been catching something right in carlbad I want to say continue to expand the opportunities all allowing everybody a chance to act on what they believe in and parse continue to parse through the important priorities we have limited education dollars and that's been what you in this room have been concerned about I want to commend you for your excellence and um it's been a rare opportunity for me to have a front row seat on that excellence in carlbad education thank you thank you and thank you for your service to our district um the next uh speaker is Jamie rushing good evening as a parent resident and spokesperson for kindergarten teachers and CD I'm here to address

023the proposed pilot of extended a kindergarten we think it would be in the best interest to continue our current schedule and postpone piloting extended day until we have a clear vision and solidified f funding our biggest concern is that we are still uncertain of what the difference in Ada and basic Aid funding will cost we will need additional space materials and supervisors to cover extra recess and lunch duties for Equity purposes we need a guarantee that we can afford an extended day across the entire School District before we attempt to Pilot it ensuring we have small class sizes should be our number one priority you heard the TK ratio is next year 10:1 and jumping to 24:1 in kindergarten will pose a number of challenges we will definitely need additional funding and Staffing for intervention

024due to doubling the number of students we currently have during our core instruction our current stagger day model is what is best for all children especially for our disadvantaged subgroups as evidenced by research that I'm going to send you the student teacher achievement ratio study found reducing a class size from 22 to 15 boosted student achievement equivalent to three extra months of schooling and the positive effects of having a smaller class size was greatest for the disadvantaged students even four years later the quality of time spent in a smaller class far outweighs adding more minutes to the day I've compared our schedule to other local schedules a full day and found each child gets approximately the same amount of direct instruction for math Ed reading and writing in our model as theirs although the blocks

025are longer in an extended day we get through our groups in less time two to three groups fewer students and an extended day we will have to run five to six groups meaning kids will be unattended contributing to behavioral issues the extra time in a full day is filled with non-academic time other districts spend an average of 2 and a half hours of their day at recess resting or in centers proving more time does not Ade equate to better quality instruction we want all children to have more opportunities for play-based social emotional experiences so let's work with CF to reduce the cost of kids care and provide more scholarships for our disadvantaged students please help us live up to CD's core values we aspire to the highest standards and all we do and we aim

026for the highest levels of performance please respect the perspective of the teachers that have a commitment to student growth and listen carefully to our concerns it doesn't make sense to double our class size when you vote at the March 12th board meeting please consider keeping our current model and postponing the proposed pilot thank you very much thank you um next speaker is Hugh girart I don't know if I spelled that right or not or pronounced that right that's good enough hi I am Hugh Gart and I'm a retired failure to uh ask my wife uh I'm with Sage Creek Carl's Bad baseball and softball fields I help do the maintenance and uh I've been taught at Morrow Bay High School I was at Questa College I worked at Palomar the last 28 years there uh

027taught and coached Health Nutrition Advance City Etc and then I was the department chair for a couple years and then I was the ad the last year uh Sage Creek and uh my son was a freshman five years ago he's now at calp and I went to the field and I couldn't believe what a mess it was I mean it was atrocious weeds everywhere equipment everywhere coaches running around trying to do as much as they could and I go hey I'm retired you know I'll help you out and my wife goes really 20 20 to 30 hours a week you're putting out there you know getting chased out there and the whole nine yards it was so bad the Outfield that balls would Super Ball not one way but the other and finally they ponied

028up 40 Grand and we redid the field and it's getting close to looking like that again four years later because they don't maintain it and it's just dads like me that are out there trying to do it and the coaches the coaches are parttime and they're putting in so many hours and there is no better classroom in this world than being on a team it's all about playing it's all that's all it's about and tough luck Billy's better you're sitting and you better behave and hope for your spot and so that's why I just love Athletics Etc so back to the maintenance part so I went over to Carl's bad and I go over to Ralph kripe who turned that field into a beauty and I went up to him he goes I go Ralph

029I just need some information on what I'm doing at stage I mean I'm just lost out there and I'm telling him about it and he goes uh I need you to run for a Schoolboard if you know Ralph that's how Ralph talks I go Ralph I don't want to run for Schoolboard he goes yeah that's all I want and then we need we need representation I I hate those guys it's just awful we really appreciate you guys doing it we do we're going who would want to do that so Ralph Ralph goes I can't use you so I read the room stuck around for about half hour walked away uh running out of time three months later I get a phone call he's got cancer he's in pretty bad shape and he goes yeah I

030need someone empty the baskets on the lawn mower for me I go Ralph I'll pick up poop behind I just want to get the experience I said all right so we developed a great friendship for about two three years and we saw it was going on on both Fields there's a simple answer to doing this and it really is hiring a full-time manager of the softball baseball fields maybe one per school maybe you can combine it and that's what you need to do and it's not that hard it's easily doable and no way to go thank you and uh next speaker is Hilton schmir I don't know if I pronounced that right either okay hi my name is Hilton Sher um good evening members of the board superintendent assistant superintendent um first of all I'm

031just going to start I love the school district I live in I love um the school that my kids attend I have two kids that attend um sorry I left my water in the car um that attend Pacific Rim um but every day I drop my kids at Pacific Rim in in crosed in December it feels like I'm stepping into a Christmas festival rather than a public school um the hallways the activities and events seem overwhelmingly focused on Christmas traditions with no emphasis on education at all um this is not about denying anyone's rights to celebrate their personal beliefs it is however about ensuring that our Public Schools funded by state and local taxes remain spaces of inclusivity unity and education for all students um it's not the role of a principal or staff to

032promote personal religious beliefs in such a overt and one-sided manner as I as I believe is happening um when I raised my concerns I was told that these activities such as drawing Santa Claus drawing reindeer drawing poetas carolling from class to class singing Christmas songs aren't explicitly religious um but let let's be real the the these symbols are Universal associated with Christmas and by extension Christianity um all of these activities should be replaced by any other random activity as they have zero educational value my kids both both learn nothing about these activities and what they were doing uh on an educational level and that's unacceptable and basically violates church and state um on for time uh what's more concerning is really the lack of guidance and accountability uh principles and staff seem to be operating

033without any training regulation or enforc ment um I know the board recently sent the policies with me they're very general and vague um this isn't just about Pacific Elementary uh I spoken to parents and I've got uh responses from parents all across the district that feel the same as me but maybe not everyone feels like standing and talking about this because in my public comments I get a lot of negativity for this for some reason um so far the refusal for the district to actually engage in a logical conversation um and constructive dialogue with parents on this matter is both frustrating and Consulting um public schools are supposed to serve all the students in families not just those who align with the single uh world view and that's definitely how I feel um our children

034shouldn't have to feel excluded or made to sit out of activities because they don't align with this dominant narrative being presented at their schools um and they deserve better I really urge the board to do more to provide clear enforceable guidelines for religious neutrality in schools uh and put a stop to religious celebrations in schools unless they are actually educational which from my experience over the last um five years uh had zero educational value um I'm super interested in them learning about religion um let's ensure that students all students regardless of their beliefs are included and feel respect thank you we now move on to part six consent calendar all matters listed on the consent calendar are considered by the board to be routine and will be enacted by the board in one motion there

035will be no discuss discussion on these items prior to the time the board votes on the motion unless there is a board request for one or more specific items to be removed from the consent calendar for discussion have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you trustees are there any items to be pulled for discussion no may I have a motion to approve the consent calendar so moved second we have a motion from trusty verth second from trusty Ward Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty barbat yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rollings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to part seven information discussion action items item 7.1 uh lcap um local control accountability plan uh midyear

036progress report uh 20 2024 2025 goals success indicators the supplement to the L cap other lcap metrics and midyear lcap expenditures trustees this is an information discussion item I will now hand it over to Dr NY uh thank you president Rawlings trustees superintendent Schmidt give us a second to get situated here with staff I do uh want to thank you for giving us the opportunity to bring this annual item to you it's our midyear goals and success indicators um regarding academic achievement as well as uh many other metrics that we have um in the district so uh joined with me tonight is uh several members from the instructional Services team I'd just like to introduce them uh director of Elementary Kim Fuentes uh director of secondary Dr Brian Brockett and coordinator of student services Dr

037Michael Ecker so they're going to help me co-present tonight and hopefully uh we're able to answer all your questions uh just really quickly in regards to tonight's agenda the purpose again is to really review our 2024 25 uh annual goals and success indicators and I'll talk a little bit about what that means um in a little bit um we recently or or have reviewed several times a book by uh Sean cvy and it was called the four disciplines of uh ex execution and uh part of that is to talk about setting successful goals and how do you do that um some of the ways that you have wildly important goals as well as uh how do you actually get after goals throughout the course of a year and he talks a lot about uh lead

038and lag measures a lot and so tonight uh we're going to talk a lot about lead measures so measures that influence the outcome of our ultimate goals which are called our success indicators um so many of those are listed there below I'm not going to go through each of those but we also call those predictors of success so these are things that give us a better understanding of are they going to provide leverage for us to meet the goals at the end of the year so um not going to go over those individually but I think it's important to note one other um important to note on this as well tonight we're going to focus primarily on districtwide uh results um you will also get a report in February as per our continuous Improvement cycle

039from principles that will talk about uh site goals and how those are going as far as a midyear update with each of our principles so not for the uh meeting to this evening because it's going to deal specifically with District wide goals but I did want to reference that as well we are in the process as well with meeting of with all of our site principles and reviewing those goals with them through the evaluation process as well so like we're having uh discussions around our goals and success indicators here know that we're meeting with our principles they're having uh conversations about goals and success indicators from a site level and they'll report be reporting that to you um in the month of February this is a example or this is our continuous Improvement cycle and

040just to note there that we're on step four of 14 steps in order to approve uh our goals and success indicators we're doing actually two things at once here so we're uh reviewing our goals and success indicators but we're also going to start next month the process of adopting or looking at adopting goals and success indicators for the following year so that'll be the whole elcot process and feedback and we have a special board study session in March where we're only going to talk about approving next year's goals and success indicators so we're doing two things with this diagram I just wanted to point that out this is an or this is our current 2024 25 goals and success indicators you'll see in colors are three overarching goals and then below those are bulleted success

041criteria and or success indicators uh you'll notice that we have 14 there and um we added one last year so we added one success indicator from previous years and that had to deal with chronic absenteeism which is the last one all the way at the bottom it's important to note to that we also have lcap goals and metrics as well that is different than our annual goals and success indicators so um we have 14 annual goals and success indicators our lcap our local control accountability plan which is really a Compliance Document that we're required to uh submit to the state has like 45 different goals and metrics our board has made a conscious effort to say staff this is what you can reasonably Focus us on in a school year we understand that there's the

042lcap Compliance Document but this is what we want you to hyperfocus on and this is the expectation and so they've kept the goals and success in indicators excuse me fairly narrow and we appreciate that because that leads to better attainment and it leads for us to get behind really um and really achieve these goals all right I mentioned lead and lag measures this is just a concrete example of that um one of our lag measures is to increase a percentage of students taking AP honors or Community College classes I think that's an excellent uh lag measure we want to push all students to be challenged number one we want them to take highlevel courses because we know all students can and we also know that the statistics tell us that if students take at least

043one AP one honors course or one Community College course that they're far more likely to be successful in College and Career so we know that that's a great lag measure to have what are the lead measures that tell us that we're going to be successful on that articulation agreements with community colleges is a great example of that how are we uh providing opportunities for students in high school to take Community College classes are we uh entering into contracts with Mira Costa that allow for students to get dual Credit Credit in high school and Credit in community college that is something that gives us and a better understanding that we're going to meet this goal at the end of the year parent informational nights is another lead measure that we talk about four-year col um four-year

044plans where counselors are meeting with each individual student going over as a freshman sophomore junior senior what are the classes you're going to be taking and really having good conversations with them challenging them to take high level courses so those are the lead measures that kind of influence we think the ultimate outcome of this we're not going to know this lag measure until the end of the year we're not going to know if we're actually at that but we'll have a better understanding by taking a look at these um in in the area goal number one it's to ensure students demonstrate academic growth and proficiencies that they so that they leave TK through 12 ready for College and Career here are actual success indicators in that area the first two are around local assessments so

045those are our Universal screeners that we use you'll notice that each success indicator has a Target so I've heard some of the criticism from some plans um of other school districts that there's no actionable targets there's no way of knowing whether or not we hit our goals at the end of the year or we don't all of our success indicators include targets and have statistics tied to them so um uh the first two are dealing with uh local assessments we'll talk about those uh specifically tonight the next two are around our state assessments so we call those our Casp assessments which primarily are in the areas of English language arts math and then we also have science and elpac excuse me we also have a College and Career Readiness which is around our a tog

046and a tog is a scope and sequence of classes that all seen all students taken high school that make them UC and CSU eligible we also align our graduation requirements with adg we have the highest I want to say one of the highest graduation bars out of many districts in the state of California we align students have to meet a tog rates in order to earn a diploma for the most part there's there's some opt out options to that but we have very high a tog rates for our graduates and then Advanced Learners was the um one that I shared with you before and that's to increase the students in those advanced classes just to talk about Universal screeners just for a second we have two primary Universal screeners the first is star and that's

047the bulk of our assessments we use a star assessment which is a Renaissance product we give that three times a year the fall the winter and the spring um and there's two different types of reports that we get out of that so um the first is a percent proficient report and I use the analogy of a high jump right my daughter's going to be a high jumper next year in high school so we're excited about that so uh um the idea of percent proficient is just like our sback scores that all students in third grade have to jump a certain bar seven feet they have to jump over a seven foot bar all students in fifth grade have to jump over a a 10 foot bar whatever that might be if it doesn't measure students

048that uh don't jump over that bar right so it's only capturing students that are proficient or not proficient they could be well below proficiency or well above proficiency but that's the first report so it really measures how well all of our students are jumping over that bar the second report is really a growth report it tells you a student can jump over a one foot bar at the beginning of the year and they could jump over a five- foot bar at the end of the year they couldn't get to that 7 foot proficiency rate but they grew four grade levels over the course of a year we want to capture both of those things and tell that story um obviously proficiency is one story but growth is another story and we think it's an equally

049valued story that we want to be able to share with our board it's interesting to note here that the state has adopted a growth model that they're going to be using um as we move forward and they're still working out the Kinks to that but I I would imagine that's going to be shared with us Rec or in the next couple years all right in in the area of success indicators one and two those are around um our star assessments and the first one is the percentage of all students scoring higher typical growth in math and Ela as measured by our interim star assessments will increase 2% from the fall to the spring so what star does is it lumps kids into a growth band based on Baseline scores and the Baseline is from fall

050to winter and it says these kids are in the highb band these kids are in the typical band and these kids are in a low band and it gives an algorithm that says based on that Baseline this is where they should be at the end of the year and so for us we want to move more kids into those higher typical growth bands from fall to winter to Winter to spring so what you see there is our actual establishment of the Baseline so from fall to winter this year we had 69% 69.7% in math in higher typical growth bands so for all the winter we give you some context there to say well what was that like last year so fall to winter last year we were at 68.9% of students higher typical growth so

051we different group of students different cohort of kids but we put that in for context and then that creates our Target for the year of 71% then um uh to hit at the end of the year so you're probably saying well wait a second 2% of 69.7% isn't 71% we we take 2% of the Baseline so 2% of 69.7% is roughly 71% okay and same thing with Ela I'm not going to go through all those but those are the higher typical growth bands at the top and then down at the bottom are the proficiencies so the those proficiency bands our kids jumping over that bar that seven foot bar everybody so in that case uh we have a baseline of fall students in math of 59.8% again that establishes our Target for us um and

052um it also says where we currently are in the winter so it says that when we took the test in Fall we were at 59.8% in math when we took the test in Winter we were already at 63% which is great we're exceeded our proficiency right but the goal is to continue on that trajectory um and not slide we we could have see some slides so we don't want to obviously slide or have less students in the spring um not be proficient so in this case uh you'll see the target there we increase from fall to winter 3. 2% in math and we increased roughly 2% um in ela this is another way of looking at our um uh proficiency rates you'll see there uh it broken down by grade span and in this case

053we saw all of our growth uh at the elementary level so um for reading specifically we went from 68 to 74% fall to winter and we saw 6% growth at our elementary levels Middle School and High School were flat um we didn't see any growth there and then the same um overall growth it's important to note one of the things that the board added last year to the goals and success indicators was they wanted to see that breakdown this breakdown excuse me by individual uh grade levels so we put in the appendix to this presentation that will post publicly each one of those grade levels grade one grade two grade three grade four all the way through uh where they were in the fall where they uh are in the winter and we'll post that

054this is another way of looking at that same information um it's giving you numbers here so total number of students it's also showing you what percentage is in the highest um percent proficient band which is that darker green band or level four um and then uh percentages in the lighter green band uh the kind of orangest band and the reddest band so we want to do two things we want to increase obviously the green bands and have more kids percent proficient we also want to really decrease that red band at the bottom and and move students up throughout the course of the year so again I talked about high and typical growth this is your high and typical growth um the far right hand side specifically deals with this year and it takes that Baseline

055snapshot and it says right now in the area of ela uh 38.7 students were high in typical go growth for fall to winter 32% were typ or excuse me high growth from uh fall to winter typical growth was 32% low growth was 30% for an overall 69.9% higher typical growth we do give context here and say well where were we at last year it's a different Cort to kids so don't get too much I staff doesn't get too caught up in the fact of Are We higher are we lower it's mer merely there for context because it is a different totally different group of kids and it's um somewhat nice to see but overall it's not that important in the area math you'll see here uh elementary and middle school math only we did see

056that good growth again at the elementary level uh Middle School we saw a slight decline of 1.9% of students being proficient from fall to winter um you'll notice that high school is missing on this chart and that's because we last year shifted to the mdtp which Dr brockett's going to talk about when I shut up here in a second um uh and and talk about the results of that but the purpose of that uh was really to uh make the data much more actionable we did uh hear from our teachers loud and clear our Math teachers especially that they were finding that the star results weren't giving them as actionable data as they needed and so that's why we transition to the mdtp and I think we've got some good feedback that we can share

057for you on that we did provide the breakdown of elementary and middle school as well in this report as well it's just in the appendex and we'll continue to go over that same thing here with the um proficiency bands not going to go over that um and then also same thing here for the high and typical growth bands were slightly higher than last here but again it's not that big of a deal so I'm going to turn it over to Dr Brockett who's going to talk a little bit about those mdtp results we got him in the low chair yes I feel like I'm at the kids table here um there's another good evening everyone Thanks for thanks for uh having us this evening and I'm happy to give Dr NY a break from talking

058here get some water U yeah I'll pick up at the mdtp which we were just talking about which was that uh new math assessment that we adopted at the at the high school level um as you can see we saw growth across all areas except one which is really to be expected uh the one I'll note was calculus which is not the area we normally focus on um and we did it surprised me a little bit we did a little digging and there were some testing anomali that took place there that really led to the the what you looks like a drop um I will say that our our AP our districtwide AP Calculus Pass rates which is what this represents were 95% for Cal ab and 97% for Cal BC last year so this

059this small drop in here is not something we're worried about what we're excited to see is the growth across um all of our other uh course areas from Algebra 1 geometry seconde algebra and our pre-cal students like I said that's to be expected this is really a um this is really a a diagnostic that really gives us an ability to take a look at um how our students are progressing over time and we really should see that level of progress but the the overall scores are not really the key component of this as Dr and I uh indicated one of the reasons we came about around to uh getting this feedback about the mdtp is it allows us to dig in a little bit deeper um with the content and Cor specific information um that

060we need so the what you see on the left there is is the topic specific um uh topic specific feedback and and interestingly I talked to the teacher this is from one of our algebra 1A classes at carlb high school which is really an intervention level algebra class to support students with success in that first year class which can really be a barrier for a lot of students that struggle with math and and I asked him I said what so I I'm looking at this and I'm seeing that you really focused on functions the first semester and he said yeah absolutely and you can see that where it says fnct there for functions you've got some tremendous growth and you've got growth across all of those areas but it really from that initial uh that

061initial Administration to the second Administration the teacher can really see um what kind of feedback that they're getting um it's a formative assessment so over time we should see really a Continuum of Readiness among those students so those those numbers continue to grow as we go forward and one of the things that it really has allowed our teachers is to really look at uh item analysis to look at mistakes and misconceptions that students are making to really better inform their instruction rather than looking at it from a general math skill perspective um and I added some quotes that I I got some feedback from teachers at both of the high schools there and um the last one there I think hits the nail on the head with what a lot of teachers shared is really

062that the data is much easier for them to um digest easier to then work with students directly on areas that are um really foundational areas for their specific class to help them move forward in those classes so we're excited about that progress and looking forward to continuing with that um the subgroup breakdown jumping back to the star now um and this is star Ela um you can see that I won't go through each of them but we did um have growth across our um uh across our subgroups um with one small exception in a in our homeless population which is a a small subgroup um and uh and so we can we can see some change there um potentially but that gives us an area to kind of focus on as we move forward but

063overall we saw some strong growth and then in the math and and I I should correct that this should um read at the top there grades 38 for Star um because again we were the uh we're the mdtp with the high school students um all subgroups again except one uh showed growth over time and again that gives a scenar to come back and focus on um with a subgroup of students through our mtss processes to see what it is that we can do to support students um that are not meeting uh those proficiency uh targets um to help them to continue to grow as well when we jump in back into those uh success indicators here um The College and Career Readiness um I I just want to hit a couple of high points we

064have remained high on our a tog completion rate um over time and as Dr NY referenced um you know you know having that Target uh as our our primary graduation requirement uh helps all all of our students push towards keeping opportunities open for the future for them um so we're we're very happy with that we saw a slight uptick last year in the percent of students uh going straight to college uh after graduation um so that's exciting the work that our our uh our staff uh and our counselors do really to help students um you know keep those options open and find um the best fit for them moving forward um is is uh working uh and then I do want to highlight one place where we've made a shift this year is with our

065ELD our English language development work um we've adopted a new model at the secondary level where um rather than having Standalone what are called sheltered classes for English Learners we've clustered our English Learners um into uh core classes they have the benefit in in that context of having um uh you know primary language peers that they can work with and learn from we keep those classes a little bit smaller um but it really is a model that helps um our English Learners engage and and as Dr and I talked about be being exposed to um that higher level work helps them move forward we've got some exciting professional development ongoing for our teachers that are teaching our clusters of of uh in in the course uh subject areas as well as our designated English language

066development so we're excited about some of the steps we've taken there uh it was ironic that Dr NY used this as his example of the lead and lag measures because this is actually one area where we do have a pretty solid Target at this point point in time because we we pulled this number uh at the start of second semester here uh midpoint of the year uh and currently we've got 84% of our students that have taken one honors AP or community college class over the course of their time so we're really excited about um where we are with that one piece I want to highlight in this uh area is you know some of that strategic work that goes into leading to those points a couple of years ago we brought before the board

067an updated course uh outline for Spanish for Spanish speakers um at carlbad high school that was a course that had um existed in the past and they were revising it and revital revitalizing it to bring it back part of the reason is they want students who are native Heritage Spanish speakers to have that Focus that's not Spanish as a second language as we would for a lot of our students but really to really build those literacy skills and those language skills um in their native language with an idea that those students would be supported to move on to uh a piece Spanish for um in in future years and so uh when we dug into those numbers we had 32 students in that class last year um this year over 70% of those students are

068taking an honors or AP class many of them T continuing on that Spanish pathway some of them taking other honors AP classes and for many of those students it's the first honors or AP class that they've taken and so it it's exciting to see the way those pieces come into place with the planning to help expose students to higher level coursework and as Dr NY indicated that that you know the reason we do that for our students is to help students see themselves in that context see themselves doing that higher level work um and that gives them uh you know opportunities and and and and gives them the the vision uh to look for other opportunities to do that for themselves so that's fantastic work um on the next one here on on academic achievement

069I you know I want to emphasize I won't go back through all of these CU really these are are are 23 24 numbers that we've previously shared um I I want to highlight at the top there that in all of those areas um you know we were performing well we've got room for growth but when we look at um our our colleagues across the state obviously our students are are performing very well um at at that level um when we think about the lead measures that help us improve those um I I want to highlight uh do the the work that Dr eer is doing with our mtss teachers um and our our staffs across the district and he'll share more about that uh in a few minutes um we've got intervention programs that we've

070highlighted including freckle and snde um at the elementary level to support um uh math and uh English language arts we've got Math 180 read 180 that are our middle and high school programs um that support our students that really need some intensive inter intervention in those areas um I mentioned the mdtp and the work that our um our teachers are doing to really dig into some of those subject area specific um pieces um so we've got a a a Continuum of supports across the grade levels um to help support students um and and our our math tosa I'll add uh John Moreno is continuing to work with uh PD uh professional development instructional support um one of the things that he's helped uh Institute and a lot of teachers and sites have taken off with

071is vertical um whiteboard work and Mathematics um which you see across the grade levels now which is a really great way to get students to to demonstrate their thinking and their process in math to talk about it and it allows teachers to to Really assess on the spot how students are doing so we're excited about that work in science um we also um really performed well uh compared to Statewide totals on the cast last year I I want to highlight the second third and fourth bullet points on there which is the the uh year 2 of the K5 uh curriculum adoption year 2 of the 68 curriculum adoption so we've got teachers really digging into new and fresh uh standards aligned uh lessons um and approaches and curriculum at those levels our high school teams

072are currently working on developing Oar open educational resources so they're using resources to develop uh standards aligned uh science curriculum uh that's engaging um and really help students understand conceptually what they're doing in science classes um and really a lot of that work is is CR critically led by our science tosa Ashley Crawford who's done amazing work across that K12 Spectrum if you know Ashley at all she is like nothing but not positive and drives uh forward a lot of great work in that area um she'll be leading a team that several of us will be joining and and with teachers across the grade levels at the uh cast which is the science test data Institute at the San dieo County Office of Education uh on Tuesday so we'll be there also looking at what

073we can learn from our assessment results to help move us forward as well uh I do want to talk about two areas uh of uh support and monitoring that we're currently uh we're currently working uh with um at the state and county level um one is the significant disproportionality work also previously known as SIM for cace then known as SIM for sigdis they like to just change the acronyms for us um just like every year um so this this um the trustees will recall is um our our state identified monitoring uh for when we have a a risk ratio for subgroup disproportionality um and we had um two areas in special education um one was Hispanic students uh in special education with a specific learning disability um the second one which we knew because we

074were tracking data over time was was going to to Ping on that radar as well as our African-American students with autism so we uh worked last year we're in the second year really of full implementation of an action plan that really uh uh focuses on several core areas that we've been working on as a district we've really tried to approach this work not as an add-on um and not as a a a merely a compliance issue but really embracing the work that we're doing across the district around um mtss multi-tiered system of supports our Universal Design for Learning which is really all about a lot about tier one instruction in that mtss model our English language development work which we've reported out on and and uh which Miss Fuentes will share a little bit more

075on in a moment um and so those kind of that's kind of the key triangle of pieces that we're uh we're putting forward to help our our students in these subgroups um continue to grow um and and make sure that outcomes are Equitable um across our our subgroups as well a a second area is something called differentiated assistance um the state always helps us by coming up with different programs too that that kind that sort of get out the same ideas which are which are outcomes that are that are sort of disproportionate for specific subgroups um and with with this uh with differentiate assistance it has to do with um specific indicators on the dashboard that the state identifies um as as um uh key indicators for them um so you can see on the

076on the slide there we had in 2022 we had um uh disproportionate outcomes for our homeless students with chronic absentee ISM and suspension rates and then in 2023 um our English Learners with their graduation rate and suspension rate as well so we're currently in the second year of work with this as well and and rather than Reinventing the wheel we really felt like those core pieces that I shared our mtss work our udl work and our our English language development work were the key components that helped us get at support for these specific subgroups as well um we have no new indicators for this year and we've made progress in all of those areas as well so I'm I'm thrilled to share that we really feel like the steps that we've taken um to address

077some of those disproportionalities are working um they're benefiting our students and and they're really designed as as um as approaches that benefit all of our students as well so we're not just doing things that are are going to you know fix a problem here and then and then you know we push the balloon here and something pops out on the other side but really when we talk about mtss work as Dr eer will we talk about our udl work um those those things are designed to help all of our students um succeed and grow as Dr Brockett shared we are um focusing on our multilingual Learners and prioritizing work to support their language acquisition and reclassification last year 14% of our multilingual Learners were reclassified and this year um we're tracking at a 2% reclassification

078rate to date we do look at reclassification criteria three times a year and are currently in the midst of our second data review so that's looking at our students who scored a four on the lpac but maybe didn't meet other criteria points um and so as we have now taken our second round of star and have some more data um to look at then we'll um look to reclassify more students um our final review will be after we receive elpac results in late May and after the star and esac are administered to improve student outcomes in their language proficiency we have implemented professional development for elementary teachers in both integrated and designated ELD strategies as well as train them on the new Benchmark ELD curriculum for designated instruction and professional learning is ongoing our ELD

079tosa Mr Brown um leads staff meetings he does some model lessons and he meets regularly with our teachers to support their instruction in the classroom and at the secondary level right training has been provided for a few teacher leaders in um English language arts and um they're supporting specifically our long-term English Learners or ltels um with their writing skills and then there's been PD around engagement tools um for all subject areas um to leverage increase active participation among our multilingual Learners we continue to actively monitor the progress of both our multilingual Learners and reclassified students to ensure that they are receiving the support they need not only in their language development but also in their content proficiency um and finally we're taking a look at our implementation of the lpac to increase student motivation on

080the test improve testing environments and engage teachers um so that they have a better understanding of the assessment to inform their designated instruction leading up to the test all right Dr eer I'll I'll I'll give you the walkin there Dr eer we have Dr eer Who's going to highlight our ntss intervention we did consider a walk up song but we're just bypass that next time next time yeah so I I do believe that the work of our mtss teachers has been a excuse me a watershed moment for teaching and learning in cusd we have on each of our elementary and middle school campuses a talented educator wholly focused on building effective system and helping their colleagues see professional development as continuous and ongoing with growth opportunities every day the midyear data presents some really nice

081bright spots but also some areas of improvement and our mtss teachers take seriously the work of helping their schools use the data to meet the challenge of appropriately meeting the needs of every student to meet the lofty goals in cusd uh we recognize uh that we need a comprehensive mtss model uh that continually learns and improves and supports students where they are in any tier so in a complex system like this uh we we uh data is critical for us to track data over time uh so that we can better understand our impact on students with the decisions that we're making uh so therefore we created two mtss groups uh one for ELA this represents students that did not meet standards in both esac and star and one for math which means that they didn't

082meet standards in both the spring math ASC and the fall star so what you're seeing here on on the screen is essentially our mtss teachers in working with their teams have moved about a third of their students from not meeting to meeting and about a quarter of their students in math and as you might have remembered on previous slides are outpacing their peers uh in uh at or above typical growth uh so obviously some areas that we're really proud of um Dr NY mentioned that growth in the middle of the year does not necessarily mean continued growth throughout the year uh so that that really tells us the reason for highlighting on our udl highlighting our tier one is the most critical tier and sometimes the intervention students piece could be a misnomer because every

083student at some point if we're challenging students is going to need need some form of support some form of intervention in every tier and we want to make sure that if we're providing students with intervention outside the tier one and then they reach Mastery as is the case in a third and a half in a quarter sorry of our of uh reading and math students that we keep them there all the way through the rest of the year so that's that's this Challenge and that's the reason for this comprehensive model on our school campuses if you want to go to the next all so uh this year we added mtss teachers to every Elementary School and each middle school and CD and adding Middle School mtss teachers this year was an added Challenge and a

084tremendous opportunity it created opportunities for teachers to regularly look into the past to better understand how decisions we make impact students later and for teachers to look into the future to notice barriers and opportunities start forming well before middle school begins since middle school is a new teacher I thought appropriate to Showcase uh the efforts at one of our middle schools uh our mtss teacher at Cala Hills Middle School Miss Sarah Ryan has been able to help her students with huge leaps this semester considering that students who are not meeting standards in math and or English likely have been below standards for years sometimes when this happens students become disengaged in School Miss ryes leaned into relationship building by starting the year with individual one-on-one data chats uh for with every student on her mtss

085list she also organized a shadow a student program where she covered for teachers while they spent the day with the student to experience a day of learning through their eyes CHMS um has also showcase the importance of communicating through the tear this is a conversation we have with our mtss teachers often um through the creation of their math momentum program teachers in each grade level have aligned their unit so they can offer their students scoring below 70% on every unit test an opportunity to join before after school for five additional tutoring sessions with a retake of that unit test on the sixth day key to the program is that it's staffed by the students own Math teachers creating a learning opportunities a confidence Builder and an opportunity to build positive relationships with their teacher that

086can be connected back to the tier one the results of yielded star scores uh I'm sorry star score improvements for 2third of our mtss students with nearly a half of students moving up a band in either reading or math or both so briefly I wanted to share this year uh that we are uh beginning a transition into a new product offered by Renaissance for data visualization called educ climber what Drew us to this particular product is its ability as shown in the top image to pull multiple measures in one place uh as well as its ability to sorry as well of its ability to measure the impact of our intended int sorry our attempted interventions that's displayed on the bottom picture uh we have three PD sessions planned for this year with administrators and our

087mtss teachers that give first an overview of the program next it's going to help Educators triangulate data and finally track the impact of our interventions over over time all right thank you Dr eer uh in the area goal number two conditions and learning that's the Align student learning to state adopted standards supported by materials instruction and technology in a safe and clean environment these are our four success indicators um in this particular goal and we're going to go through each one of those and give you a better understanding of where we're fairing so I'll turn it back over to uh director Fuentes we continue to offer an extensive range of professional development opportunities and seek to align the relevance to our goals staff preparation and our student outcomes starting well before the school year began

088our tosas and teacher leaders once again offered sizzling summer PD um on a range of to topics many of which are listed on the slide and our August PD day offered over 50 sessions which staff rated 97% relev to their um their position overarching themes of professional development include udl and first best instruction strategies um mtss instructional practices for our subgroups particularly our multilingual Learners technology with regard to utilizing the new tech plan and understanding AI for teaching and learning um and implementing new curriculum or diving deeper into our current materials in addition to the numerous training sessions and conferences that teachers have attended we also have an amazing team of tosas and Tech coaches who are really boots on the ground um they're working directly with grade level and subject area teams offering model

089lessons and facilitating site visits we're also building capacity among our administrators and mtss teachers through our work with the California Coalition for inclusive learning on Universal Design for Learning or udl and on the next slide we have pulled a few testimonials from our feedback surveys which are sent out after every PD offering I'm grateful to have the opportunity to share uh districtwide efforts as we sit in the second year of our three-year forward together plan I should note that this work has been the result of many students staff and parents in our community uh in who see it as their responsibility to build communities that are safe and welcoming for every student um I do want to showcase a few key lead measures on the right some are more straightforward as our as is our

090forward together District uh website uh some require continuous work to have the impact we would hope uh such as the climate work occurring on each of our sites in CD and the work as we've mentioned previously of our mtss implementation on the following page you will find our scorecard for our year two uh priorities uh so we keep a running scorecard so that we can share specifically our progress on completing each action item as you can see here our ongoing efforts uh mostly fall in building systemwide support and structures for learning in year two I could speak for some time about several areas of our plan however I do want to highlight one key area after a year and a half of partnering with students parents admin and our forward together District committee which includes

091all of these groups the area that is catching most of our attention is the feedback students have provided on mean comments harassment and bullying as well as the gap between Anonymous student feedback on these surveys and incidents that that are reported to staff members to better understand the current Dynamic District sites have held student panels collaborated with student leadership groups and reviewed student survey feedback for all of us who support kids whether they be our own or the ones we support we support in school it is not surprising that students share that they sometimes don't speak up because they are concerned about being viewed negative negatively by their peers or not believing anything will change or possibly get worse this means that addressing the student reports will depend on having clear systems in place on

092each campus and helping everyone know our process for sharing expectations for how to make reports uh to what a response to an incident looks like to this end we have clear protocols in place and infographics that administrators can share with students parents and their teams additionally it is critical that all adults on campus model speaking up should they hear negative speech on campus depending on the site counselors no place for ha student committee members or administrators have run trainings on ways to appropriately speak up should negative language be used on campus and our CD print shop has created a speakup poster created by one of our amazing counselors to hang on hang in classrooms and in high traffic areas that support this training the image on the left is of carlb high school students at

093a training such just like this at CHS uh through our modeling of how we can interrupt we can encourage more and more students to feel comfortable doing the same what we are looking to do do is increase the total number of adults and students on our campus that maintain informed civic responsibility what we are working to combat as a culture where mean and hurtful words may have been normed with excuses like you might have heard like I'm just joking or he doesn't care when I say that uh slowly through adult monitoring and student leadership we can push slurs and harassment outside the Norms of our schools on the right you're seeing you see no place for hate members at Jefferson ele who wanted to respond to what their Kelvin data shows uh is the is

094the area of of greatest need for growth which is the spreading of rumors students shared about their experience with this in a student Panel LED by students as well uh followed by a classroom activity resulting in a 19% jump in students saying they were likely to speak up if they hear gossip or rumors uh being spread and with the vast majority of the school feeling confident that they can stop gossip or rumors on their campus changing human behavior is tough just like America's effort to decrease cigarette smoking or encouraging people to wear seat belts detractors often say it's not possible there is a Tipping Point on changing negative Norms Norms on our school campuses and I am proud of our community in our efforts to move closer to our goals finally as a reminder our

095forward together committee will have recommendations for the Board of Trustees this spring and these recommendations will likely relate to this area Focus we measure our success and progress in mental health school safety and social emotional learning through that Kelvin pulse and that's administered four times a year with the goal of achieving 82% of favor overall favorability among students in 3rd through 12th grade um so far we we've conducted three pulses the most recent is currently open for responses and closes this Friday so the data was not yet available for this presentation but administrators counselors and teachers then analyze those results to identify those areas of concern and Implement targeted actions much of which um Dr eer just shared about these steps may include follow-up surveys for deeper insights small group interventions or class or whole

096grade level lessons and the activity developed by our no place for hate committees additionally teachers have access to the general domain responses allowing them to provide um more personalized support within their own classroom community so as you can see in most domains we've maintained or increased from the first administration of the pulse except in the area of school climate School climate questions include students at this school get along well with each other or my school is fair if someone breaks a rule which tends to have some variability and that's the work that we're um working on that Dr reer just spoke on with our forward together and our no place for hate committees to really analyze and hear out why students and staff are feeling um this way and how how staff can address that

097um but overall our students are consistently trending above the target um so we are on track to meet that indicator this year and lastly we want to thank thank uh director quanki for providing the information but we do have a success indicator specifically dealing with cleaning standards on our campus uh with an emphasis around uh bathroom cleanliness of 75% are higher and you'll see there that they provided the following information as of January 2025 uh We've 87% met our overall cleaning standard goals and with the area of restrooms that was 85% have met so good work with them they are doing uh an amazing job we have uh fully staffed custodial staff at this point in time which we're really fortunate to have and we're very thankful for them and the work that they do

098in the area goal number three it's around engagement so engagement of parents staff and the community to promote unique educational opportunities for students these are four success indicators um in that particular area um they deal with parent education career Pathways social emotional learning which we also use the Kelvin for and the new one that I mentioned before is around chronic absenteeism so I'll turn it back over to uh Dr Brocket I believe who's going to cover this yeah I'm happy to highlight uh our parent education uh through our parent universities have continued we've continued to provide a diverse uh offering uh for our families this year in a variety of uh settings uh one specific shout out I want to give is to our bilingual Community liaison um they've done a great job of supporting

099some of this work in previous years this year have taken the lead on um doing some specific uh parent University events um one on school toome communication um for our especially for our bilingual families or multilingual families and then one on reading strategies and how to support students at home so touching on not not only just that connectedness and belonging piece but also student support and how we um get at some of those academic pieces as well so I'm really excited about that work and then um as Dr eer said about his uh slide there I could talk as you all know for probably hours on this one alone I'm going to leave I'm going to leave it brief um just to say that you know we are on track we're we're excited to be

100on track to meet our work-based learning goals um our nine to 12 data is is always in flux because those things those events happen at different times of the year for in our classes or on our campuses um but we're continuing to collect that data and are confident that we're going to meet this goal this year um our K8 is also on track to meet their goal and I want to highlight one specific area there which is with our um with our science days um generously supported at all of our elementary and middle schools by Carl's badge Educational Foundation um we have made a a a concerted effort to integrate um work-based learning and Career Education component into each of the um science days at all of the all of the elementary middle schools as

101well um so that's some great work with um with Ashley Crawford who I mentioned earlier and Nicole morsh who I think you all know um who does uh leads our career Ed uh work um they've combined forces to really make sure that piece is integrated in so I'm I'm really excited about that um as as something that really has been a a nice step forward um in line with the work that we've done around developing the career at continuum two out of the four Kelvin surveys we expand to assess student development and demonstration of graduate profile attributes aiming for a 2% increase from last Spring's results to this spring our fall results um shown on the screen show positive Trends across the attributes um either meeting or nearly meeting our string our spring targets to

102support growth in this area our counselors at all levels continue to design and Implement lessons that Foster these attributes while enhancing social emotional learning additionally we maintain Partnerships with organizations like Lifeline pasame cor and guide to round out our wellness support also programs such as web link crew ASB student council and no place for hate also play a vital role in offering leadership opportunities and peer support networks for students and as Dr and I shared We are continuing in our efforts to improve School attendance by reinforcing positive habits and addressing barriers that prevent students from attending regularly schools closely monitor their attendance data identifying students who are at risk for chronic absenteeism which are those missing 10% or more of the school year to support these students sites have implemented various positive attendance um strategies

103including awareness campaigns incentive programs and direct Family Outreach current L chronic absenteeism has decreased from 16% this time last year to 15.1% currently with a goal of reaching our Target of 7.4% by the end of the year now to clarify we did end the year last year um at a rate of 12.4% but for our mid-year check-in um we chose to compare the data from the same point in the school year um for a more accurate comparison of our progress all right we're almost there I promise um the last thing that we wanted to just highlight and we're required to highlight actually is um requirement from the state is our California school dashboard um this is a quick snapshot of our dashboard itself and you'll see that we get color ratings based on um based

104on how we did the previous year in the following areas chronic absenteeism suspension rate English learner progress graduation rates College and Career Readiness and then the ELA standards as well as the mathematics standards we also have some local metrics that staff uh inputs directly where we've uh have to send out some surveys where we gather more information about access to uh classes and coursework as well as a local climate survey that we do annually and you meet those goals by actually participating in the survey there's no metrics specifically tied to those you actually meet or don't meet by implementing the survey or doing other things I did want to just point out that that's kind of the public facing um uh uh dashboard you dive much more deeply into this and there's a lot of

105areas that we um can break out into specific student group so I just circled the English language arts and what happens is you get get a better sense of specific groups that are performing at or above grade level as well as some groups that are not and so this is really the work that uh Dr Brockett had mentioned and as well as Dr Ecker where we're diving in now and really trying to get in and figure out okay our long-term English Learners as it relates to English Language Art standards it's kind of a common sense thing that they're long-term English language learners for a reason but they perform form well below standard um on the ELA metric so we have to go in identify those students we want to go in identify those students and

106figure out an action plan um to improve them over the course of the Year you'll also see other subgroups as well so African-American students English Learners homeless students and students with disabilities are in that orange performance band so they again that's a significant group of students on our campuses that we want to address and have an action plan for overall we're in that green band where we're doing very well however we have specific groups of students on our campuses that are not performing to that level and that's the work of the udl that uh Dr echaran mentioned as well as the mtss and really identifying these students and and making sure that we're meeting the needs I just put in the far right hand column as well um those are the state uh metrics on

107the bottom so you'll see there that as a state average in ela overall um they are about 13.2 points below standard and you'll see there that Carl's bad students are 50 points above standard as an overall rating but again we still have significant groups on our campus that we still need to address so um on average we do very well um as it relates to uh you know California averages as well as County averages Carl's bad outperforms just about everybody in the state as well as we Fair very highly in the county as well but there are specific areas here that we still need to address and continue to improve upon so with that this last slide I promise um we're also report required to report out a couple different things as it relates to

108the lcap and so the lcap itself we have two other exhibits in there that I'm not going to cover tonight I promise but we're happy to answer questions um we're required to mention all those 40 metrics that I mentioned before that we have in the lcap so there are things like our facility there's a fit report that we fill out um there's um credential teachers those are things that obviously are important and we want to Monitor and track but they're not part of our annual goals and success indicators but we do include include those as an exhibit for the public to see um and then we'll report on that at the end of the year when we have our lcap final results and then we also provide a lcap midyear expenditure report as well and

109the lcap is primarily designed to meet the needs of what we call unduplicated students the the state uh labels them is unduplicated students which means students that receive free and reduced lunches students that are English language Learners or students that are homeless or Foster Youth and for us it means that there's about $6 million out of our overall budget of $130 million that we need to pour into an elcap plan to address specifically the needs of those kids in particularly and um they can benefit all students as doc Dr Brockett had mentioned but primarily those are resources that are geared to them the expenditure report that you see in Exhibit C talks about those expenditures and it identifies staff primarily that's used to support um those students throughout the course of the school year so

110with that I will turn it back over to uh president Rollings for a public comment and then we're happy to answer any questions thank you for that comprehensive uh report um this is the time for public comment and I have received uh one blue card uh when I call your name please come to the podium State your name and indicate whether or not you live within the boundaries of the school district you will have 3 minutes we will have the timer on the screen and your mic will be muted when your time has expired um our speaker is Katrina whick hi Katrina wilick a resident and parent in the district and teacher in the district I'd like to begin my remarks today with a quote from the renowned activist and writer James Baldwin not everything

111that is face can be changed but not but nothing can be changed until it is faced as I reviewed the lcap presentation it became clear that there are areas that must change areas where we can do better for our students while we all want every child reading above grade level and feeling welcomed on campus the data alone does not tell the whole story as Street data reminds us if we only measure success through numbers we miss the humanity of learning it's the stories behind the numbers the growth resilience and real life successes that truly Drive meaningful change the work we're doing in cusd is not just about achieving metrics it's about fostering transformation as a teacher I have seen firsthand the positive impact of initiatives like udl mtss and the forward together plan on our

112staff and students as you saw in the picture we're intentionally centering our conversations around the lived experiences of our students and how we can better serve their diverse needs in our department meetings we focus on strategies to make our content more accessible and Equitable so that all students can Thrive and both as both Learners and citizens personally I've worked to ensure my classroom is a place of inclusion I've adopted adopted udl practices to support uh to make sure AP classes are more accessible to students with IEPs and 504s hosted a Valentine's Day love yourself GSA party today to support the mental and emotional well-being of lgbtq students and shared my own experiences as a Latina woman with members of the Mana Club to ensure that they have inspiration for their future I strive to make

113our reading materials reflect the diverse tapestry of America by incorporating works by rulfo Gonzalez Wes Moore Jose Antonio Vargas and America Ferrera sometimes at my own personal cost I've also worked to create a space where all cultures feel acknowledged and celebrated for example during the holidays I turn my classroom into a winter wonderland complete with hanging snowflakes in a gingerbread house Doorway to ensure my Islamic Jewish and atheist students feel included in The Season's festivities I along with many other parents teachers and students am committed to supporting the forward together plan because it is making our community a place where students feel empowered to face the challenges that lie ahead and change what can be changed this is the face of someone who is investing her time money and talent to ensure each student feels

114a sense of belonging this is the face of a mother who expects our leaders to advocate for all students and to listen when others speak up when they see a problem or concerned about an issue and this is the face of someone who is proud to be part of cusd thank you thank you um this is the time for questions and I want to thank the trustees for um asking their questions in advance and so I want to ask if there's any additional questions beyond the questions that were already asked so other questions trusty your Beth okay um mdtp is new um to the district well somewhat new but as far as an evaluative tool that we're using for high school level so what I'd like to ask is how are we communicating I see

115that we're communicating to the students and the students are appreciating the feedback how are we communicating to the parents who have been used to using the star assessment um as an assessment tool and looking at you know Nationwide comparison so how how are we communicating to the parents so they have an understanding of how this tool is being so effective yeah that's a great question so we we sent out score reports um at the with the beginning of the year uh Administration we haven't yet done that for the middle of the Year Administration um and and with that we provided some additional information to give uh parents some context about what the scores were that they were getting um so the the questions any qu we didn't receive any questions at the district level in

116terms of what that was telling them um and and so you know hopefully that was a good sign and I didn't get a lot of feedback from uh from principes or teachers about questions that they had received um and and given the feedback that we got from teachers I think what that tells me is that that the data that was provided and the information they provided provided for good conversation where there were questions with between uh students and parents and teachers um and then um and then uh you know any any additional pieces from there they they'd continue to communicate which is really where we want that communication to take place ideally is is with if something goes home hopefully it has some meaning that they can then uh continue to you know think about

117as they're helping support their student or the students thinking about setting their goals Etc and that's what we've heard from teachers at this point yeah the other thing I me is that the next Administration they'll get a Readiness report for the class that they're about to go into as well so parents will get that report as well it'll identify uh strengths and things that they are strong in to go into the next class so algebra going into geometry and it'll also Identify some potential areas of growth and teachers will then geometry teachers will have that information as students come into their classes other questions Tristy Emory um would you say that there's um any or what number of students in the blow proficient categories that are not being captured by the current systems are in

118place or do you have any are you um scooping up all of them who might be in those into some of the um established systems are already there yeah I would say um I you know we don't have exact quantifiable data on that but I would say a good majority of our students that are not meeting standards are in sub type of intervention if not um they're they're always getting you know through the mtss prod uh process they're getting that um teachers are getting that training about tier one instruction and differentiation in the classroom as well so I I would say um they are getting intervention where needed um some of the kids students that are well below grade level are in some of our um uh interventions that are spec specifically geared to them

119so read 180 Math 180 as an example those are students that typically are three four five grade levels below where they should be and that's a research-based program where we are very targeted about how those kids get in um but I would say for any student that is receiving that's getting scores that they're below far below or below basic or not in that uh proficiency band they're getting some type of intervention other questions just bef um I think the mdtp for at least calculus at Sage is going to be given in about three weeks is that true for all the math departments over at Sage because they're on a trimester yeah that that was part of the anomaly that I I mentioned uh previously so we had we had a a a challenge with the

120administration uh taking longer than expected at uh carlb High School which didn't give us complete results and then a timing issue in terms of the the date which that was going to be administered at Sage Creek so we've been in communication with the sites about those issues the other ones um the other uh courses now Sage is a little bit off because they're going to take a as as opposed to a beginning of year uh midy year their beginning of course midc course cycle um so we'll we'll continue to track what that data looks like but it does give a more um Apples to Apples comparison because essentially they'll be taking an assessment at the same point in time of the course so what what you saw here in the in the bar graph on

121the slide are are matched cohorts of students so you can see the growth within the match cohorts what we don't yet have is some of those outliers um captured in there and then again obviously that calculus one's a little wonky just because of the way that that played out trusty word so my questions um oh first I want to say that this has like been the best presentation that for lcap so thank you and um a lot of positives throughout this presentation so thank you a lot of growth um on slide 24 and slide 25 thank you for your explanation for that Dr Brockett for both of those um how how long do we have for these student groups um that are being monitored to get out of being monitored and how what's the growth

122that you have to see um in order for them to be out of these two categories that's a great question so the the uh sigis uh work is uh around a certain risk ratio calculation um where and I I wish I had the math skill to explain this to you in in Greater detail but as a language teacher myself I'm not quite there but but um the so it's a risk ratio calculation that has to do with a um a greater essentially a greater percentage uh of uh students in a particular subgroup compared to the overall um the overall risk ratio for all students so once you've triggered beyond the beyond the um threshold over three consecutive years that's where you've reached the point of significant disproportionality um as I mentioned with our um with

123our Hispanic students um inld we were actually no longer above that risk ratio even when we started but the problem was that we had been identified the year before was our third year so we started the work and we were already below the risk ratio there and we have maintained below that point um so that not to say that it it the fact that we were there previously didn't highlight some important work that needed to be done and that we're doing so I'm I'm I've been happy with that work but we're good there um are African-American students with autism that's a little bit different you know it's it's same same idea right we have a a higher risk ratio with that particular subgroup and that particular identification um obviously students with autism that's that's challenging

124um because often students have a diagnosis of autism that's not to say that a student with autism necessarily always uh should or needs special education support and so that's where some of our questions around you know our mtss model and are we reaching students at at a tier one one um type of intervention or or perhaps a tier 2 type of intervention rather than that tier three special education intervention and so we'll bring that up that's one that's new to us this year and we're really starting although you know we're starting with those same uh approaches in our action plan um we'll we'll see you know what our our impacts are as we move um down the road uh differentiated assistance uh a little bit different in that it's as I mentioned it's in it's

125tied specifically to um the dashboard and and and red indicators as Dr n showed kind of the different color indicators in more than one um area that are the key indicators by the state um like I said on those we've also made progress on both of those we had no new indicators and we've had progress um in those subgroups on those indicators as well um in previous years so um that's to say that you know the the you know the potential is always there that something new we're trying to you try to stay ahead of where um those indicators look like they might be headed um but we're headed in a positive direction in both of these um assuming that we have no new indicators in the fall will be out of differentiated assistance all

126together um so that's that's the the track that we're on right now um and then with our with back to the sigis um those plans um our our second uh plan that we just uh submitted the addendum on will go through next school year um and so you know hopefully at that point in time we'll have no new indicators um in that front on that front either great I have a followup follow up F that's right um and and that doesn't necessarily all great news thank you for sharing all of that um but that doesn't necessarily mean that we would be out of the red or orange categories in the dashboard because there's other correct and as Dr n just pointed out as I was wrapping up that last comment you know are the one

127that that showed up on there that we mentioned was our long-term English Learners long-term English Learners is a new category on the dashboard and for for obvious reasons we we have students that that have continued as English learners for an extended period of time um they're you know obviously we we know that they're going to have challenges meeting um some of those standards um I am happy to say that really in anticipation of that we recognize the work we're doing around English language development and starting uh not only you know hitting our long-term English Learners which are students that are in the you know in the secondary level but we really are focusing a lot of that work at the elementary level and trying to ensure that we're giving those students the the appropriate support

128at an early point in their development to um continue on a positive track moving forward okay thank you other questions justy Amry uh just really quickly um because they were link so closely together on the school safety um that seemed one of the the lowest on slide 38 there um is but you previously mentioned just before that that um the harassment the mean comments the incidents were a factor so with school safety is that um question focused around physical emotional both were you able to tease out or aggregate any information there there are a couple questions in that domain one is um feeling that students have I think at the secondary level feeling like they have an adult to um support them if they need help help um at the elementary level it's do they

129feel prepared in an emergency situation so if there's an earthquake or a fire um do they know it to do so it's both that physical safety and the emotional other questions Justa be okay um I just want to refer to slides 10 and 13 uh star reading and star math in both of those it's clear that our elementary students are showing demonstrating the most growth right um and by the law of averages are kind of helping our district along to show that positive growth overall um I had an opportunity last week uh to meet with an mtss at one of our elementary schools and I was really impressed with how well it's going um and we recently added mtss in August to help support our Middle School um can you tease out a little bit

130about what we're doing for our high school students as far as intervention um since we don't have that mtss singled out for our high schools yeah yes uh it's a great question so you know we have some of the specific um intervention pieces that we we mentioned in terms of read 180 Math 180 which are uh specific targeted interventions for those levels um at at the secondary level as as well we've you know the the instructional piece around uh Universal Design for Learning and our capacity building for that uh We've included both our principals and our mtss teachers at the middle and elementary level um we also have our our ad administrators at the high school level involved in that work to help lead some of that work at their at their sites as well

131um I I do want to I do want to uh speak to I mean we've sorry I should I should back up and mention you know we've we've obviously got um site based tutoring we have intervention classes I mentioned the the graphic up there on the mdtp was from the algebra 1A class which is a specific um algebra intervention class that's offered um at carlb high school to support students um who might have challenges with you know getting over that hurdle of Algebra 1 which is is a common hurdle for mouth students um at Sage Creek they do um because of the trimester system they have the ability to offer um at the beginning of the math courses so at algebra algebra uh 2 in Geometry they have a um I forget what it's called

132to kind of an introductory trimester before leading into the course that helps provide that support for students um and then you've got a variety of other um class areas to support students whether it's um Avid or or other specific intervention classes that might support students um I I do want to point out uh on because you mentioned it on the math um you know I I'm sure it caught your attention as it did mine um the Middle School star math scores on the second of those two slides and so we dug a little bit deeper into into that one in particular and you know one of one of the issues um is that um you know the the the star assessment is computer adaptive and it does get harder over time um so um what

133you know when you look at some of the information about the star data uh maintaining sometimes is not necessarily A Bad Thing and even sometimes a small drop especially of your students that are more proficient um is not a bad thing now your students that are that are not meeting proficiency and are remaining at that level that's obviously a key area of concern um but when I looked at the middle school numbers specifically um the the lowest area for example on the math there was the geometry domain for for all of the uh of the schools um and that's not been the focus um in the fall of our Middle Schools they're they're specifically they've they've done some uh background research and thinking about how to get students prepared for continuing success in math and

134they've been focusing on ratios and proportions um and you know they they have some assessment data that shows that that R ratios and proportions um is has been a strong area for them in the fall um and so in thinking about uh thinking about that star math as a as a format of assessment right that informs what what they do moving forward obviously we want to continue to see that growth and we want to see certainly um our students that are not meeting that standard obviously continue to grow as well but if you break down by grade level um you know sixth was the one that really had the the biggest drop you'll see that in the appendix um and um and that's where you know in looking at that piece that was the one

135piece that that really stood out so I talked to Mr Moreno our math TOA about that today um he's definitely working with our our uh sites on that as well our teachers to think about how they go about that but his his share back to me on that ratios and proportions piece was that's been our Focus because that's where we've seen previously students struggling and we really wanted to to kind of like Hammer that home uh this fall um to make sure that students were prepared so um that that's a little bit of kind of the the the in the weeds uh deeper look at that um but obviously we're going to continue to get at that because we want to see that growth ongoing for our students yeah and maybe Dr eer could maybe

136chime in on this as well one this is showing proficiency again right so it doesn't necessarily mean that there wasn't growth it means that uh the percentage proficient students to kind of jump over that bar um went down slightly from Fall to Spring however I believe Dr eer had on one of his slides at calary Hills Middle School where there was a significant amount of students that jumped a band they might have been uh in the lowest band and they jumped to a uh uh a slightly higher band which is growth but it's not measured in this one particular chart so I think that's important to um you know teachers are looking at multiple things to gauge whether or not stud students are uh gaining access we're kind of taking this one thing and and

137saying you know this is a snapshot in time so I don't know if Dr heer wanted to add anything to that I mean I I think you did a good job of covering it but I'll just mention that this data is really best used in the hands of an instructor so like when you pull this away the further away you get from instruction the the more difficult it is to kind of tell what's going on what uh what we are like one of the need things I mentioned this watershed moment it's it's about having teachers at the middle school level now look at this opportunity we have we see some things that are really working well we see some things that are not really that that we're like hey let's focus in on what's going

138on there and that they're organizing their grade level teams to take deeper looks at it and they'll see similar to what Dr Brockett said oh this is the area of geometry so I'm not super concerned but clearly it's an area we want to make sure we focus on like high level instruction at that point and then if there's other areas that are growth areas they could say hey what we did there let's kind of repeat those practices in years to come uh or this is an area we maybe want to touch on again this is a group of students that we may want to pull for a small uh tutoring session within the classroom this is you know like all of those kind of conversations is the kind of continuous Learning System that we're looking

139for and sometimes when you look at demographic groups or you know you talk about our English Learners um it results in teachers is saying oh you know what I I actually am not sure how to best address that area or behavior or things like that the best professional development is in the moment recognizing what needs we have and then having the people there to be able to provide that support to help us grow continually and I have a followup to that as well um uh Dr Knight um you had stated that um that you plan on providing um sight level data um and so I have a two-part question and and I agree with trusty Ward this is the most probably the most comprehensive um lcap midyear review that um we've received so I really

140appreciate all the work that went into this and um I feel um I have very few questions because of that so I appreciate that um will it be as comprehensive the site the sight level um data um as far as you know a per grade um that we have seen tonight and then um uh will there be um rankings or um um I guess my question is um that um like the earlier grades would there be um some analysis that would show like well these these may be lower but these May these will they go higher and so that there is a growth from let's say first to fifth or what have you will there be some information around there and then I guess I'll add a third question there will you be kind of

141looking at that data to share best practices among sites that you know let's say that's you know lower at this site and maybe a little higher over here you know what are we doing that can maybe help other sites yeah those are all good questions I'll take the last one first because I'm going to remember that the best um typically we do that in a K12 meeting where we'll talk about here's our midyear we cols we'll have Elementry principles uh sit around the room and talk about um where they're currently at as far as um star scores and they dig into specific grade levels best practices so they do that in a k 12 meeting that we'll have uh in the month of February in regards to the reporting each principal will give a re

142a midyear report that has um we we generate some guiding questions and it is uh break down your by grade level um areas of strength areas that you still need uh additional emphasis around tell us how your intervention groups are working so it really is a comprehensive um report that we coales and compile and then we provide that for the trustees to see sight by site exactly what the principles are um kind of experiencing at each of the site levels Dr Knight can I jump in on that yes so um I just want to also just remind the trustees that all of our mtss meetings are held on school sites uh and part of that uh is the fact that that we start every meeting with instructional rounds by going into classrooms by seeing instruction

143happen and they're purposeful we we know what we're looking for uh for example wanting to see vertical learning in the math classrooms uh and and be able to learn about what's working there what's not working there the last meeting we had was at Cal Hills Middle School uh in which we hung for a while and in one English teacher's classroom and then that teacher met us down in the library and we did a like udl udl protocol and reflecting on that lesson plan and talking about the decisions that that teacher is making the data that we have at the midyear can help continue to help us to figure out where to go next what conversations to have so absolutely we want to grow on what's been happening well I I do want to follow up

144Dr and I with what you'd say um what you were describing sounded a little more subjective than the data that we're seeing here which I find more objective and so I guess that's my question are we going to have sight level objective data where we're going to say we have you know 1% growth or we have you know 5.8% growth in this particular grade level at this particular site so we'll have that okay that's my question okay thank you Justa Beth so to follow up on what I was getting at when I spoke with that mtss coordinator at that site I was really impressed with the fact that she like you mentioned Dr eer in the moment she's in the class classroom and she's identifying a need and she will even help relieve some pressure

145perhaps even on the teacher and and and teach something and or or show a different way of going about doing something or pull a group together and address the needs of this little group or an individual in that classroom so I guess what I'm getting at as I'm really happy we're doing it in our elementary and we're seeing great results we're starting it in Middle School are our principles in need of this are they requesting it um is there are there teachers that are asking for this at the high school level to address the needs on those campuses yeah I would I have not heard that from Individual principles at this point in time at the at the high school level especially it becomes much more challenging because you're talking about uh subject area specialists

146and you're providing intervention or coaching um or modeling in specific subject areas so at the elementary level it's an elementary credential is um allows you to teach multiple grade levels and you're have that ability to do some modeling and coaching throughout at the secondary level I would say that we are experimenting with that at the middle school at this point in time trying to figure out what is a good model um I think once we get there I think we'll have a better informed uh decision on what that would potentially look like at the high school um you know I we we continue to have conversations with our High School principles about um how do we provide intervention for students and uh coaching and modeling opportunities for our teachers so uh I our TOA do

147an excellent job as well we have uh Mary Martin who's a tosa that provides coaching and opportunities there and I know that Dr Brockett have mentioned Mr Moreno who's actually a teacher at Carlsbad High School so he's providing coaching and opportunities specific to the math department um but again it it it is very subject specific at the secondary level so it makes it a little more complex understand thank you other questions all right great work trustees okay now we're in discussion um any discussion I do have some discussion um uh and again I want to I really appreciate the responsiveness of this um of of this presentation as well one of the things I did notice on slide 24 for instance is that um trusty emry had asked that we spell out um that we

148uh you know spell out some of the acronyms so folks can understand them and I noticed that you did that in the in the slide deck which um you know again very responsive you know so that I I get thumbs up for that for sure um and um and then I did want to say with the um and you know me on the on the uh on the workplace uh Continuum as well as and I will say the professional development I've talked to um multiple board members um about those two things and they are like where is it give it to me I want to see it that sounds fantastic so we are in those especially in those two areas we the Envy of other school districts for sure that they really um actually providing

149a 90% relevancy rate for PD is just I mean board members are like wait a minute how are you doing that we want to do that too so because they want to make sure that they're spending their dollars wisely and then um and then I say that with the workplace curriculum I think we're the only District that has that at least in SEO County I mean when I ask folks you know how are what are you doing in that area they um um you know they can't even answer that question so and we have everything in one place so I mean it's something that we've worked on for several years and so um I just think I I'm really proud that we have as a board you know a new board a former board have

150really prioritized that to make sure that we are um embedding you know career values and workplace values at every level of our um um uh in our grade level and again no other District at least that I'm aware of Ino County even has anything like that because they don't think like what would you know what could we do in kindergarten for a workplace or a career advancement and they're like well gosh yeah there are things we can do and we we found them and we were already doing them so just putting it down on paper and and having that and prioritizing that I think is really you know we should be very proud of ourselves for that so that's what I have for discussion any other discussion Justa Beth well thank you for this great

151presentation and all the information I um as you all know really want to focus on prioritizing our high school students and I feel it's really important that moving forward we continue to look at how effective um the intervention is going at middle school and I'd like to then um translate that into supporting our teachers and our students at the high school level because we still have some areas for growth um for these students and get them ready to be um launched into the world so um I really want to emphasize that again I've been asking for about a year to continue to um focus on these high school kids they need it other discussion justy Emmery um yeah a couple things um excuse me that really stood out for me is um I really love

152the fact that the students seem to Value the mdtp and the talks around the data um sorry around the data talks with them and just seeing the value in the buyin I think is huge um and just to continue kind of that forward motion um and also the what really stood out was the clear systems in place for each campus um and having that consistency across there's that common language is I think really valuable sorry any other discussion okay and truser Beth I would really encourage you because I mean again I I agree with you that um um I think in March when we go through the lcap I think a you know a proposal I think the board that that if we can kind of look that over and and um uh that we

153could have a a quality discussion around that so I think that that would be um I would encourage you to do that okay anyone else okay great thank you so much um we will move the agenda to um uh 7.2 approval of the three-year technology plan trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Dr NY me uh give me one moment while I cast this item you know what can we take a real quick break okay we're going to take a 5 minute break thank you yes please e e e and um and I turned it over to Dr n thank you again uh president Rawlings trustees and superintendent Schmidt on October 16th 2024 staff presented an updated new three-year technology strategic plan for consideration approval staff was directed

154at that time by the board to make some changes to the plan and bring it back for a final approval at a future board meeting the board changes included the following including in the technology plan cusd safety features like the firewall and web web filtering and then provide information about School site supervision of students using technology specifically during lunch and brunch staff has specifically made those changes and uh to the proposed technology plan and we've included that and we have uh Mr Allen here who is going to walk us through uh the components of that plan and answer any questions that you have so I want to thank him we said the third time is a charm so we're hopeful that we could get this thing approved tonight because we're halfway through the year and

155we we're uh moving forward with it all right I'll turn it over to him good evening everyone nice to see you thank you for having me I've also prepared a 60 slide deck for you so so as Dr and I said just in speaking to our timeline it was a pleasure to present the plan to you uh before and I appreciate some of the recommendations for bringing that back to you um we put a lot of thought into the two requests made of us as far as is uh including in our infrastructure description how aspects like the firewall and the filter um protect students uh both from things going out and things coming in so I'm excited to talk about that one of the other requests was also just language specifically around what we call

156our acceptable use agreement it's what students sign each year uh that's not specifically built into a goal in the plan but it's obviously a very critical component excuse me of using technology in carlbad so we visited that as well and I'm excited to uh review that language with you so I was going to start with the acceptable use agreement some uh questions came up around uh what we outlined in that agreement is that students will be supervised while using technology right because this technology is intended for Learning and we want to make sure that is in fact the goal and that's the outcome of it so in December we decided to send a reminder to sites that that is the language and start to get some specific Norms around what does that word supervised really

157mean I think that's what we were asking for is clarification that can mean a few things we wanted to be a little more specific we surveyed site admin and staff regarding what that means on their campuses when we say supervise so that was really great feedback we got from campuses that was the quickest survey fill out I've ever had actually when I sent it out I think people were very much excited to talk about the efforts we make to um supervised students while using it as well as questions that they had and then we spoke with admin at uh admin meetings to say what are the Norms at campuses and it seemed like the feedback we got was that that is the expectation is that if students are using a Chromebook for example or an

158iPad or they're on a desktop computer there is supervision on campus so that was good to hear those were Norms already in place that being said uh Clarity is good and so we Revisited that language around what we meant by supervision I know I included this already um in our documents so I'll spare you reading the entire thing but uh by all means I look forward to questions and feedback on this language this is the proposed language for the AUA uh that we've yet to include that second piece brings us actually back the request was to specifically talk around uh how does the firewall and the filter work in the infrastructure of our technology plan so now we are talking about language in the technology plan itself that I updated um and that we reviewed

159in Tac our technology advisory committee just to make sure that we're very clear about the specifics of our multi-layered approach to security and safety for students so I included that language as well so at this point in time you have the exhibit that was uh posted it those are the two changes that we made from the previous time that we presented um as I mentioned before and we're happy to answer any questions but I think we have public speakers first if we have any thank you and this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards no blue cards thank you and um and again trustees I really appreciate you uh submitting questions in advance um so are there any additional questions for staff just

160Amry sorry I'm new I'm figuring it all out um just as of course I'm going to cough um just as something I didn't get to asked before um I'm not as familiar with the Chromebooks so I know um the Apple schools have like apple classroom which has like a um Universal monitoring system where the teachers can plug in is there any such thing for the Chromebooks or for our systems yeah in terms of Apple classroom where it's like a management system you're pushing content out and receiving content back we use Google Classroom namely for that as far as some of those and I don't know I'd have to have clarification around there's ways uh with apple classroom where you could say like look at some of the devices and see what's happening on those devices

161there's not currently a district standard for that but we have a few School sites piloting the concept Google's also told us recently I signed an ndpa so I'll just leave it at um there may be a solution coming that lets us uh use what we already have in terms of infrastructure to achieve something like that yeah other questions Trust what kind of training is being provided to our students surrounding um just appropriate use but also overuse um a lot of our uh young people today are addicted to digital devices and being on screens and it's affecting their mental health their ability to communicate um you know just carry on a decent conversation with other people and interact with other people as humans so are we offering anything to our students to just try to educate

162them on digital citizenship so to speak but even more so than you know know how is this affecting you as a human and that kind of thing sure I appreciate the question so say there's probably multiple layers to that as well one from the district level is we use common sense media to have a required number of digital citizenship lessons each year that center around those kind of relevant topics for students I've seen those carried out in really beautiful ways in classrooms where there is kind of a prescribed curriculum but teachers do with the magic they do best and they add to that and the discussions I've heard come out of that how they take that thing on paper and make it relevant to students has been really neat to see so that's at the

163district level that's something that we do not only to uh support our Young Learners with the power of Technology being used in ways that can be beneficial or negative and guiding them in that way um but that's also how we achieve e rate each year so that's something that we make sure happens on multiple levels but I've also seen whether initiatives by teachers themselves or counselors at each site to have those ongoing conversations as well with students but our intentionality at the district level is with that digital uh citizenship curriculum other questions trusty Ward so um Mr Allen I'm sorry it's still weird for to think about calling you Mr Allen okay um I know Michelle from many many years past sorry about that yes Mr Allen um so uh thank you for sharing all

164that and also answering uh trustey um Emory's question because that was part of mine as well um how how are we if you could just kind of explain how how are we ensuring that we are doing teachers are doing that supervision I know that as a former teacher that's hard to do especially if um you're walking around the classroom and interacting with kids um so are we changing some practices of what's happening in the classroom uh for students or it in terms of when and how they're using um technology so we can monitor better yeah I think our first step was to uh make sure a what are the Norms already at sites when we say supervision and B to create Clarity around language of what we mean by supervision I think that's really helpful

165because you could take that to the extreme of unless I'm sitting over your shoulder constantly is that not supervision as soon as I Look Away versus the more pragmatic approach of saying if you're in this learning space with an adult with a staff member U this is a supervised environment um and we wanted to just be clear about what that meant I would add to that and uh Mr Allen's a big component or proponent that's led us to this but our Tech plan as well has allowed teacher to teachers to untether from the corner of a room and it it's allowed them to be much more mobile and move around the room and we're encouraging that strategy as we kind of move forward and we've seen it actively as we do our instructional rounds teachers

166no longer have to kind of sit over in the corner they actually have a device where they can move and actively interact with students they're putting things on the boards you know it's it's a much more uh free flowing uh environment where teachers have the ability to kind of um assess what students are doing especially on on Chromebooks thank you for that so what I follow up Jessy word so what I'm hearing you say is that piece is effectively being used by teachers in the classroom the flexibility of that environment yeah yes so from what we've observed and then we do the survey every year the technology survey to get feedback directly from teachers I think because it was a multiphase roll out we're seeing our first group of teachers increasingly feeling comfortable whereas our

167teachers who maybe just got it standard bell curve you have those right out in front and others who might need a little more time but I think enacting the vision itself is something people are working to embrace okay other questions just what what's the final decision on the youngest age group that are taking Chromebooks home by Design we encourage fifth graders that's one injection point of our new Chromebooks to prepare them for middle school because Middle School breakage rates are through the roof um apparently we're not the only ones this is a very online known thing but we thought training at fifth grade is a nice way to a sort of ease your way into that middle school so they tend to take them home at 5th we don't tell School sites that they're unable

168to take them home prior to that but our suggestion is at least by fifth grade we're practicing that so that Middle School feels familiar with taking things on other questions yeah I would just add to that that we don't have a prescribed um uh take-home policy for younger students at this point time I'd say predominantly um most of your first graders your kindergarten students your second grade students are leaving those at in classrooms and have carts and um unless there's a specific incident where a student needs access um they're bringing them home and back other questions hearing none um trustees um may have a motion to approve the three-year technology plan exhibit a motion second motion by trusty Ward second by trusty verf and any discussion I just want to say thank you for your

169patience I know um I've been on agenda planning and I know we we have pushed you back a few times and so I truly appreciate your patience and I think um I think the the plan is um very responsive to the trustees and and what we requested and um I think we have a good plan moving forward for another three years any other um thank you Mr alen that was great and thank you of course for your patience and also for answering my questions in advance my pleasure yep Andy you're back thank you thank you um I know you've been patient with us as we've made you go back to the drawing board a little bit and I thank you for taking the time to do that and addressing just some of the concerns from

170our community as well and parents it's really important so that everyone's comfortable and we can help this strategic plan be successful I just would like to emphasize that I think the plan we need to make sure that we're measuring um whether the use of technology is um actually improving educational outcomes right so yeah thank you for that any other discussion okay Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty rth yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to item 7.3 measure HH Bond program monthly update trustees this is an information discussion item and I will now hand over to and I'm happy to say Miss Susan conell s situated down here I understand this is a standing item each

171month to update you on the status of the measure HH projects and since we're really not ramping up our spring projects until March I thought it would be a good time to bring forward our recent Bond sale that we completed uh tues Tuesday of last week um staff uh cusd together with their bond councel their uh financial advisors and our Underwriters went into the market with the idea of selling the final $87 million of the measure HH bonding capacity um the third iteration of it considered series C of the general obligation bonds and so you know you prepare for that and it's a pretty diligent process that you go through because what you're trying to do is paint a picture of your District that's going to sell bonds to those people with the Deep Pockets

172and so you go through and you've seen those those um statements that are about that thick that outline all of the tax base in Carl's Bad and The how many hotels you have in Legoland and basad and they they paint a picture and then they assign risk and so we seek that assignment from Moody and it's not easy to get a double a rating like we got and that's the second highest very few school districts ever get the AAA rating but Carl's Bad was able to maintain their double a rating which is huge and that results in um a lowrisk RK High reward for investors and even though we were going out for $87 million of selling our bonds we got 539 million I'm sorry million um orders so the orders far exceeded the bonding

173capacity that we had which is a good thing and they were from people like Pimco and black rock and and um you know rep reputable firms that put in orders for excessive amounts just because they have so much success selling our particular bonds um and some of the things that they identified I thought was interesting is it the credit strengths that they cited were above average resident income and strong property wealth measures the second one was large tax base poised for continued growth and then the third one was solid Finance position supported by Management's conservative budget practices so we we as a result have an overall payment repayment ratio of 1.71 to1 where the state um standard is 4:1 so anything below 4:1 is considered to be um a successful Bond sale but also a

174demonstration of really good stewardship of District finances um so they made that note and and that is not everywhere so I think with that um in mind it's an average of 3.86 uh per interest rate which is very good for the current market when they on the bond rating call they they said congratulations District um you chose a very good week to sell the bonds next week there's all kinds of people going into the market this was a great week and considering my first day was Monday and this was Tuesday I said well thank you very much I appreciate that take all the credit yeah exactly I said Mr Dill's gone so there's I'm going to take all the credit for that um but the it's over 25 years and so that is the final

175sale of our bonds and we have a uh an expenditure schedule now that will go forward until that money is utilized so with that I'll open it up for any questions we'll be bringing back an actual update on our projects in March so we'll have a visual presentation for you but we're just not quite there yet this month thank you and uh this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards great thank you and uh trust do you have any questions no questions and um now is the time for board discussion do we have any discussion I would just like to say I'm thankful that um you're you've continued on with us uh Mr Connell and um and that the fact that you're familiar

176with the you know how to do this and all that makes it that you're able to literally start on Monday and make it happen on Tuesday so I'm very appreciative of that and um thank you for the opportunity and um and I continue to have um confidence in our ability to um build Great Schools so any other question or any other discussion yeah just thank you sorry I guess I should raise my hand or sorry okay I just want to say thank you um for your presentation and thank you for your humor and I'm so glad that you're back too appreciate that all good news thank you any other discussion trust Beth I also want to say thank you um thank you for taking time to meet with me as well and I loved your

177Friday report it great gave very um I'll just it was it a great summary for us and it helped me feel comfortable moving forward so thank you any other discussion okay great we're going to move on to uh to uh part eight let me see part eight Communications um continuation 8.1 governance team reports this is the time for trustees to provide a brief report if they've attended committee meetings where they represented the district are there any governance team reports trusty word uh truste Emery and I um had the opportunity to I'll just do it for us because you're coughing so much sorry um had the opportunity to go to our uh district deac meeting and they did a great presentation of reviewing um all the lcap goals and and everything so it was well done

178and it was nice to be able to see um uh Mr Brown as well and and talk about the goals and everything that he was doing in the district just Amy did you want to add anything or you good okay sounds good any other reports okay um we'll move on to trustee requests for information from staff trustees are there any requests for information from staff that have already been discussed with the superintendent and have been recommended to bring to the board okay and then um thank you for that and 8.3 trustee requests for future agenda items trustees are you are there any requests for future agenda items that have already been discussed with the superintendent and have been recommended to bring to the board trusty um I would like I'm sorry I have to read

179one more thing as a reminder trustees um are prohibited from having a discussion tonight on these items per the brown act when making a request please indicate the purpose of the request and whether or not staff has provided an estimate of how long the request would take to accomplish um I am interested in um future agenda item to revisit um our board policy around uh committees uh that align with the um California School Board Association to provide um release time for teachers in position in order to attend trainings or um other functions in uh this role um right now it doesn't align with the California School Board Association and although I um I think it would be good to make sure that we have that cohesion um and make sure that um when possible all

180uh board members are able to attend functions and uh superintendent um uh do you understand the request I do excellent um and uh can we have show thumbs to see if we would like to have that on a future agenda I'm sorry can trusty Emory can you explain it I'm a little confused yeah on what that um so under the California Schoolboard Association policy there um under their kind of model there is um the provision for release time is kind of a district for district agreement um release time for uh not so much release time but uh a unifying Factor so that if uh a current teacher serves on another board board that they are able to um take time off uh without um depleting their bank without um having implications uh for retirement and

181such not so that they can take those days to support the other community within they're serving um that won't come out of their retirement pay for se but it has to be a mutually agreed upon um per circumstance and I don't see foresee any of those really happening um right now I'm taking all the um the days and luckily our vacations don't align but that might not always be the case um for visiting School sites doing the training for say um for example in the California School Board Association um I would not be granted uh permission to go attend those as it's currently worded um and so I'm just asking uh for a provision to align with that overstanding policy um we can't have too many questions on this we're not discussion so um right

182so okay so um if we want to have it a future agenda item that's all we're we're we're not so if we're willing to have a future agenda item on this topic uh show us your thumb okay and we're going to do that in a future agenda item and and uh it is 8:40 and the regular meeting is now adjourned our next regular meeting will take place on March 12th at at 6:00 p.m. at the Carl bed Unified School District office we

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.