001if not at a necessary are we good okay you can go ahead and start thank you all right good evening everybody I'm H Bill huitt I'm the representative from mcferson and Jacobson um search firm that's been in California uh I think about 12 years I started with them uh one I'm one of the first I am actually the um senior um consultant with them um tonight what I'd like to do is to take you through some of the elements of our search firm but especially I want you to understand what's different about about mcferson and Jacobson uh there's some unique things and uh having done 40 of these searches uh most of the time when we're hired it's because of our unique characteristics and the services that we provide that are different than other search
002firms okay next Slide the board members uh next slide okay and um we want to mention that um our core is the kids uh we're really looking for leadership leadership matters and we want to make sure that we have the very best um uh leader for you to fulfill your mission our mission is to ensure each search results in quality leadership for your institution okay next slide so what's um unique and what's special about uh mcferson and Jacobson well first of all we're well established we've been around since the middle 90s Nationwide uh we're one of the three leading leading firms in the nation for searches and while I say that um there there are over 130 Consultants Nationwide but the Consultants like myself and California are um we have our own network and our
003uh own way of doing things and so it's kind of like we have a local chapter if you will of um mcferson and Jacobson uh there are currently 13 of us uh doing searches in California uh we've done um I think we're approaching 100 searches overall in California I've done 39 searches I have I'm the as I said I'm the senior consultant with them and done more um searches than um any other consultant um we um so the what's the advantage of that the advantage is that uh you get consult you get um all the Consultants from California working for you but also throughout the nation so you do get candidates from Across the Nation for for your school district um and you'll see in a minute I know some things about your school district
004um uh because of my children and grandchildren um and uh my my involvement with them um but you have a national reputation in some places for instance you in your Communications and uh um program where my grandson uh ree is on uh Chris TV all the all the time um he loves that program he'll do it every year he's here and I think it will be his vocation when he's um when he's finished with school but that will draw some candidates from outside California because of your National reputation however having said that most candidates come from inside California and our network of um Consultants will um have uh a lot of access to um superintendant that are applying um myself I'm part of northern and southern California superintendent group it's it's um kind of the
005um experienced superintendent uh once you join it it's for life so I'm still very active with them and we have many other connections also through um uh AXA and other administrator associations the the next area I think that makes us um significantly different is our transparency and our engagement process with your community and this is a big difference and I just want you to think about it in my opinion the reason that I I was with another firm uh and I quickly joined this firm when they came into California because I really believe in engagement of parents and and and uh community and um I say unabashedly we do that the best we absolutely do that the best we do tailor it to what you want to do um uh however I think the reason
006that we're usually hired is because a board really wants to involve and engage their community in this process uh there are some firms um uh that don't don't won't emphasize that with you they will say you it should be something that you do you do it in in behind closed doors and it's your decision it's a big decision and while all that's true I think it really helps your superintendent and you with your constituents to have a more open and engaging process with your community so how do we do that I'll I'll come back to this at the end but I'll give you kind of a flavor for it right now we do a very thorough job of um surveying your community and H holding uh inperson Meetings online meetings and we'll do anything that
007you want us to do to engage them of course within reason but but uh I I'll give you a little story I went to one District in the Central Valley and uh we said how can we Eng engage your parents and I said well you know all of our moms bring their children to school at 7:30 in the morning and then they have coffee together so we were up we went down there for a week and we were up there every morning at 7:30 uh talking to uh moms about what they what they needed in a leader and what they needed in their school District it's just just one of many ways we do it we ask you how how and who to engage the other thing that I think is very unique that we
008recommend but don't do for all school districts is we really think your um constituents your parents especially uh but your students uh should all have a a part in in um interviewing and uh taking a look at the candidates now that that's quite unique and we do it in a very secure way we do it in a confidential way we have people sign confidentiality uh agreements um but boards most boards not every board wants that but uh most boards do want that and they um and we're the folks that do that the best and have the most experience with it um I won't go into great detail but I will say this that people are worried uh about doing that other firms are worried about doing that for two reasons one is they say you
009won't get as many candidates applying because they don't want their name to get out there if they're sitting superintendent someplace else right right and we've not had uh problems with that because we're so secure we have people sign confidentiality agreements and uh we talk to the candidates about that we actually encourage the candidates if they become a finalist to tell their board we think it's better to be upfront and open and honest with them most do so that hasn't been a problem we've had lots and lots of candidates for all of our boards of the highest quality and and so I think that one uh that issue can be put to rest um uh I think think that the um other problem that boards have with having their constituents involved in it is they think
010it takes their Authority away from them and we uh we absolutely tell all of our um uh stakeholders that are involved in the process that you don't make the decision you only uh interview the candidates and give the strengths and the concerns of each candidate we don't want you to prioritize we don't want you to tell the board who to hire because they're going to see it in a certain light but the board really values what their constituents think I've seen many boards that say gee what do the students think about this person we actually have students on the panel that help interview the candidates um what uh you know what do um you know what do our Community Partners uh you know that have foundations think of this candidate because that's important to you
011and you see things through your lens what you have to do as a board member and see it through everybody's lens it's a tough job you have and this is a really important decision um and I I think the reason that I work for this firm and still work for this firm and believe in it so fervently is that uh when you have a good process when you have a really good process you're going to get off to a good start and you're more likely to have a superintendent that's going to be your superintendent for a long term and our statistics show that our superintendent stay in place for a longer period of time um they don't all stay in for five or 10 years but a majority of them do um you know the
012reality of superintendency in California is there is some turnover for a variety of reasons but most of my uh more than most uh over um 70% of my placements um have been there for uh five years or in or in the process of being there for five years um so those that's really the big difference between us and others we have a good track record of successful placements I think it leads all to that okay um a little bit about the team um uh uh I've been a su let's I started as a math and physics teacher um I've been a uh uh secondary principal high school mostly for 10 years and a vice principal for four years uh I was an assistant superintendent for all secondary schools that was all an El Grove unified
013school district a very fine School District up north um and then I was a superintendent successful superintendent for 16 years uh in Dixon California as a smaller District in the Central Valley in loai unified uh which is a District of about um uh 30,000 where we built an awful lot of schools while I was there and then I C my career off in the Bay Area in Berkeley which is a wonderful fine District that uh people are very devoted to in the last 12 years I've been a consultant with this firm I also uh work with boards um uh in many districts helping them with their governance um with superintendent evaluations a number a number of things but my greatest qualification for this job is I have to say as is as peepa anybody know
014who what pea is pea means Grandpa yeah yeah and so um uh Palmer um Benson and Rees Benson are my grandchildren I love them dearly I've been uh I've only lived here uh now for um full-time for six months have I've had a home here for three years just outside of carlbad in Ocean Hills if you know where that is um and but I've been coming here uh since uh they started kindergarten and and before and going to their things going going to um see Athletics at Sage Creek and and um watching Reese do all of his performances he's a very theatrical sort of uh kid um and I know this is a wonderful School District it's such a great School District that I took another district and brought them down to see Sage Creek
015when they were opening up a a new high school so I know your District really well um my daughter is active um are we at time have 30 seconds okay um I was looking for a clock you didn't run me on the clock um my um my daughter um Sarah huitt Benson uh some of you might know because she was an active PTA uh officer and leader so uh I want to thank you for what you've done for uh my grandchildren uh both of them have found themselves in this school district and they're going to be very successful because of what you provided so um I'll I'll end with that and answer any questions you have the process you can see in the materials that we've handed out uh uh we have a excent process
016from start to finish okay thank you very much just's questions who first I have a question justy W um so I know you put uh both yourself and Mr Ben Johnson I didn't get a chance to talk to you about Ben Johnson well I he is he has a nice description of his background in here but I noticed you also have another um member there as well so who would be assigned to to conduct our search um you myself and Ben Johnson okay yeah and then you can share a little bit about um your qualifications Ben's qualifications and will we have input in like who we work with or do we work with both of you at this um you will in fact uh Ben and I will if you chose choose our firm Ben
017and I will come to the uh first meeting and if you want to have somebody else uh if you want more uh of us to be partic participants that's your choice we'll talk about that a little bit um uh our other consultant that was listed decid she's the superintendent in Oceanside she just decided it was a little too close um and that it would be best if um um you the two of us did it and for a district this size frankly we usually have two of us doing it let me say a word about Ben I've done several searches with Ben Ben is a board member uh Ben is uh so we don't only have superintendant in our uh ranks we which is a strength I think uh but Ben has been was a
018board member for 12 years in alfor I think it is uh School District it's a district of 16 17,000 in up in Riverside County and now he is a board me a County Board member in Riverside one of the board members in Riverside yeah and and a wonderful human being I think the world have been I'm sorry I didn't introduce him thank you other questions I have one um what is that okay what distinguishes your firm from others and why do you believe your firm is the best choice to lead the superintendent search for CD well I'm going to go back to what I said and that is community engagement I I really think that our firm does community engagement the best both in helping you set up uh the criteria that you're looking for
019and uh what your community needs what's some of the issues your community we actually when we engage your community we ask them what are the issues that are out there the next superintendent uh should be aware of it's not the only question we ask them we ask them what they're looking for what are the skills attributes and characteristics that they want we also ask them what are the good things about your school district you know so that we can help um sell the school district to candidates but I I truly think that that's the real thing that's a shining star about our firm is the work that we do in bringing uh bringing your constituents into the pro into the process and having you be able to hear them um uh we you know I
020like to say that there's several venues that a board member needs to um see uh what people want and match that with the characteristics of the ca candidates that come forward when we interview um you know you inter you don't just interview the candidates with us you interview the candidate you have a social interaction with each candidat not only that uh we have candidates do a video before you choose who you want to see we're very thorough in in bringing the candidate forward so I think that's what makes us unique is we put a lot into it we bring a lot to the table Jesse Amry um to follow up with that uh what strategies do your firm use to identify and attract uh a diverse pool of High Caliber superintendent um candidates including those
021who might not actively be seeking a position yeah we have a lot of associations with um with the different um um administrative groups in California um and um many and our and our Consultants are diverse um we have um uh several cons we have a few Consultants who uh work with uh diversity in school districts do workshops in it uh we have several Consultants that U are in networks of diverse uh leaders um but in addition to that I think I think the one thing that um really does help is that uh we've done a lot of searches so we know a lot of candidates out there that have either um gotten jobs or they are ready to move to the next job and so we're in touch with a diverse group our placement record
022in diversity uh last I checked in California um over 60% of our placements were either people of color or women so it's a very diverse group of candidates that you'll uh receive from uh from us Justus for bef are you familiar with the recent search that your firm or your search firm conducted with um Powe I'm not very familiar with it honestly I um uh because because most of my work honestly has been in Northern California I have done a couple searches down here um but I I'm not very familiar with it I know that your superintendent uh went there and so I think you're brave to uh be be considering us because sometimes people think that that's not a good thing that that if a your superintendent left with a school with a certain
023firm you shouldn't pick them to do the next one but I don't believe that I mean really we're we are facilitators for the boards we have no um no interest and no inkling uh to move people from One District to another we don't have a stable of candidates and so um while I'm not uh I don't have much knowledge of that one uh I do know that we work for you we work for the board just when pawe was doing their search we worked for pawe you know whoever whoever they um wanted they uh they would hire and we um we don't play favorites uh either in in District or out of District all candidates are equal to us we bring them forward based on their qualities and their and their characteristics other questions I
024have another one well thank you for OPP how about one more oh I'm sorry oh I'm sorry so um will there be a primary contact person assigned who is available responsive and serve as an effective liaison between the board and stakeholder groups and how will the board be kept informed and involved throughout the search process great question it probably will be me although Ben and I work together as partners on these we've done so many things he does some things better than I do and I do some things better than he but I'm so close here that uh I'll I'll be the person that's in in constant contact what was the second part of your question how you stay informed yes how responsiveness um uh Effectiveness and uh kept informed through the process well responsiveness
025um clearly you know uh I give you my all my contact information and anytime any of you have a question you're more than willing to uh you know I want to hear from you uh but on a regular basis we send you updates uh we send you email updates about what progress we're making and it's not every week um most most um um searches uh run uh anywhere from 12 to 15 weeks our stuff says six to says 8 to 12 weeks it's really a little bit longer than that I think I mean it can be done in eight weeks I've done some in eight weeks but it's I don't recommend it it's kind of a rush um so uh for instance you look at those phases and at in every one of those phases
026you'll get at least one email from me about the progress that we're making uh for instance the first phase you'll you'll see us and we're going to build a criteria together for what you're looking for and then I'll you know probably um you know a few days later a week later I'll send you a draft and you'll respond back to me and we'll get a final thing going and so my biggest way of uh communicating to everybody is uh per periodic emails now on the other hand U most boards want a person of cont contact on the board um some do and some don't some say we want you to talk to all of us but some say let's let's have you work more closely with one or two uh people I I can remember
027one board that wanted both the pre U president and the vice president to meet with me periodically and I thought that was great so we'll talk about that at the first meeting how do you want to be kept informed do you all want to make contact with me do you want to have a a leadership group of less than three in your case um you know to meet periodically but I'm right here you know I'm you know it takes me 10 minutes to get here um so um so that's it yeah okay I'm not oh juster bef so the total is not to exceed the amount including expenses is 185 is that correct and there's nothing above that there's nothing above that yeah and I don't know what's below it you know I asked the
028question we used to break it out into two parts because I'm I'm going to ask the question can I save you a little bit of money we don't I don't do this for the money obviously but but I'm going to ask the question uh because I won't have any expenses right I'm not going to stay overnight any place and I'm not going to you know I'm not going to have a meals here or anything because I I live just a little ways away so does that mean they get a a break I'll ask him and see I'll ask the home office it would seem you should right I mean it it seems like to me that it shouldn't exceed 185 but it ought to be a little less maybe Mr Johnson might have to travel
029he yeah he'll have to travel he lives up in Riverside yeah well thank you I think we're at time so appreciate it I appreciate it thank you so much take care and somebody getting our next fir okay okay our next firm is um the Costa group I want a big KNC no I'm just kidding just kidding I'm just kidding chocolate I need something carne yeah breakfast burrito sounds good yeah right wow we used to get Nick's Roast Beef on the NorthShore Boston good evening everyone hello you guys hanging in there yes sure yes okay um we're we're honored to be here tonight and we thank you for the opportunity to present on behalf of the Costa group uh my name is Tim Ritter uh and this is my partner Dr Frederick Navaro uh just a
030quick bio background on on who I am because I think it's important to to place who we are and some some about our experience almost 40 years in public education worked my way from teacher coach for almost 20 years to site administrator assistant principals principal um opened gr Oak High School in Tula which is a to me an something that I'm very proud of because it's a tremendous School uh went into uh District administration for 15 years was an assistant superintendent of Education Services then uh Deputy superintendent and I finished the last 10 years of my career as the super superintendent of Tula Valley and I'll let Dr Navaro share his background good evening thank you for having us um so like Tim I couldn't hold a job either I had many positions in my
03140 years uh but I ended up in uh Newport Mesa where I served for 15 years uh eight of which were a superintendent uh but prior to that I'd worked in several districts and I think uh when you look at our our bios and our history I think uh what you'll realize is that our last districts were very similar to your district and we understand uh what a high functioning district has what the per challenges can be what the benefits can be and I and I think we can bring a lens to your search with that experience that uh maybe someone who hasn't worked in in in uh a high-end District or a highly performing District High performing District might might uh might not be able to bring so thank you for having us we
032uh and uh we hope uh that we know we're in the ninth inning so we're GNA try to get through this as quickly as we can right Tim yeah I just wanted to add one more thing to that as Dr Navaro said we we come from highend high performing districts um your district is is a model in the state of California and I'm sure you're proud of it and you should be and the other thing that both Dr Navaro and I bring is we were we had longevity in our position I was a superintendent for 10 years Dr Naro was eight years in Newport Mesa and we understand how important that is how critical it is to bring in somebody who will stay uh and provide stability for your District because that's how you are
033able to build that trust respect and and make the moves that need to be done to move a district like yours to not only maintain the things that are going really well and there's a lot of them but also to be able to address challenges and move your District forward and that's going to take somebody who has the time to do that can commit to it doesn't happen in one or two years it takes longevity and and part of what we want to help you do is find that person that can come in here and and make that long-term commitment to Carl's B next slide please okay so this is a a slide uh about our founder Dr Costa um Dr Costa was a level five leader okay and uh if you don't remember the
034research from level five leaders here's a person a level five leader is has a Steely resolve they want to accomplish things they're also very humble people but yet they take responsibility uh they don't blame anyone else for the direction or the issues that come up in in the process and additionally what everybody who's ever worked with Dr Kasa before he passed would tell you that he was always a champion for those that were following in his footsteps that he was developing uh we have that DNA in our in our in our organization still uh what Dr Costa wanted to create in the Costco group was a group that was going to work and support districts by finding leaders who were going to be exceptional leaders for a long duration it it's all that's all the
035the the the the the the the that was his main goal that's what we why we exist is to find leaders that are going to be exceptional leaders for a long time in school districts as you know the research is very clear if you have a lot of turnover and the average tenure in California is 2.8 to three years you have a lot of turnover your districts don't perform as well and they do lose uh some some some uh Traction in whatever their long range plans are so uh this is what this is what we have in our DNA this is what we're here for and we're going to tell you how that affects us as we move forward so I think Tim y next slide please aen approach to leadership search I'm going to
036kind of go out of order here because I I think slide uh point two is is what's really important here Costa group has proven over the years that the methodologies that we imply apply and the comprehensive support that goes along with that has translated into our ability to place in districts superintendents who do stay the average 95% of the superintendents that the Costa group has placed over the years historically have remained in their position for five years or more so that's far ahead of the the standards for the state or or or national averages for superintendent retention uh but it's also the best in the industry of all the search firms uh I have not heard of one and I've sat through a number of presentations from search firms uh anybody that can boast those
037numbers and I think there's there's two reasons that I can put my finger on I'm sure it's it's multi-layered I'm sure there's far more to it than two things but part of it I think is the methodologies and how we approach our searches and and we are Dr Navaro and I if we were to partner with you and I use that term intentionally we would be partners with you uh it's not our search it is your your search we do the we do the heavy lifting we do a lot of the work but it is under your direction it is to do the work for you to help you find the best candidate for your District it's not just finding the right person it is the best candidate for your District we are committed we
038only do in our in our firm we only do one search so we would not be divided there'd be no uh reason for us to have to work in another District at this time we would be completely committed to you we would be committed to your community in fact I I feel during the three or four months of this process we become an absolute member of your community the other part Beyond just the commitment that we make to you is the fact that we also commit to the transition for that person into your District our firm guarantees two years of mentorship in our contract there's no additional cost we will provide that support ongoing for that candidate and also work with you and that candidate in regards to transitional um moving into that position and
039building team with you so it it is it is a commitment Beyond just leaving somebody at your doorstep and saying here you are congratulations this is your new superintendent uh we continue to support in the background not only that candidate but the transition and the building of team with the governing board next slide please now in our process we build a deep understanding of the district in two ways the first is time with you we would spend dedicated time with the governing board to get a sense to get a deep sense and understanding in terms of what are the what are the things that are that you are most proud of in Carl's Bad what are the things that are working because it's always important that we pay attention to the things that are going
040well so they can continue to be supported but secondarily we'll we'll try to get down get deep into it to find out exactly what are the challenges that a new superintendent will face what is it that they will need to be aware of coming in that needs attention what are some potential pitfalls or or or things that they need to be aware of and finally it's to hear from you in terms of what qualities what is it that you want to see what do you believe are the skills and talents that somebody needs to bring to the table in your District to be that successful super intendent to move your District forward we will also take direction from you in regards to what stakeholder groups are the key ones that we need to meet with
041now we make a commitment that we will we have no limit to the number of stakeholder meetings that we will hold we will meet with as many groups and as many people as you identify as important not only will we make the effort to meet with every group in person but we will also provide online surveys for people that can't be there we can do Zoom meetings for people who cannot attend meetings but we will host as many meetings as we need to within your community to meet one-on-one or with small groups or even large groups at schools to get that feedback from those stakeholder groups so we can so we get the best picture of what you want to see in your next superintendent and what your community wants to see in your NE
042in in your next superintendent and that information is then used to develop the brochure and the recruiting tools and how we will go on to the application process and the interview process to meet those those criteria that you have established as a board and in all of this it is truly a collaborative partnership as I said we work with you not not necessarily I mean I guess we work for you as well but but it is it is truly a side by side hand inand partnership moving forward so about 20 seconds so are you okay uh next slide please uh I want to go back and just touch on one thing that uh that Tim talked about and that's just you're at time pardon me you're at time I'm at time yes we're we're giving
04310 minutes and 10 minutes for presentation 10 minutes for um question then we'll wait thank you trusty questions we have questions okay okay go ahead um I was wondering if you could describe a little bit about what the that mentorship that two-year uh period of mentorship looks like um and you know um how that might be adjusted for each district uh well we start off with uh kind of a a a set routine in the beginning uh we like to meet twice a month for about an hour hour and a half uh with uh with the superintendent and uh basically it's a uh it's a uh what do you you know what are you looking for how's it going and we also kind of spend time uh helping them kind of start develop their 90day
044100 day plan so we'll spend two month two days out of the month hour and a half uh talking about how it's going and what uh what they're hoping to accomplish and moving forward and really what we try to do is we try to be a mirror and listen to what their needs are uh what their concerns are and really uh and and help them go through the thought process of what would be the best strategy and what and is it time to move in that direction yet so really the first uh first three months is a lot of discussion about how you're going to do this how you're going to do that how much time you should spend here and then as the year goes on it's more about what came up and what's
045happening and what challenges we have and often that uh we still do the the the hourly uh meetings twice a month but we often start getting phone calls at that point and this this just happened and this just happened and what do you think about this and what do you think about that so it's a it's a dynamic process uh but we do do that for two years um and again you know it it may not sound like a great business model because you know we charge this much and we're going to be around for another two years but it's what Dr Costa believed was important in making sure that you're supporting a superintendent who's transitioning into another district and that that person is going to be there for more than you know four or
046five years trusty W um thank you for your presentation um also can you explain or describe your reference check process and so there's no surprises and and with all the candidates so what is your background check that you do well um so first of all all of the applications come to the Costco group when uh they go through our website we collect them and we immediate immediately start going Tim and I will split them up and we immediately immedately start checking all the references we call every person so uh and it's not easy to always get people right away on the first time so we do a lot of calling till we get to all all the people and we ask the hard questions you know to how do you know this person what was
047their performance like would you hire them again uh you know or can you tell me when they've they've had a challenge how they met that challenge so we have a series of questions that we like to ask that are open-ended and we get as much Poss information as possible but then we also ask like to ask them who else has this person worked for that's not on his reference uh list that we can call and and and and get additional reference so our goal you know we'll start off with the references that are included in the application but we like to get another two or three in addition to that and call those the purpose of doing all of this is really to find out everything we can about every individual and there are times
048we find out that their application isn't completely completely honest uh sometimes there are people who uh who are being released but they haven't mentioned that in their application sometimes uh it is that uh um you know they are they are going through a review that they're not favor that they don't believe is favorable and they're looking to to to to go so this is where our experience and our ability to to talk to all the right people really play pays dividends for you because then we'll come back and you're going to have a lot of applicants I'll tell you this is a very attractive district for for superintendant experienced superintendent particularly but we'll list all of the all of the applicants and we'll tell you we'll tell you what's you know what what we learned
049about every single one and there maybe someone say you know this is maybe not one you want to consider this is maybe not one you want to consider uh because that's part of the hard work that we do um and I'll tell you the reference checks is for us is the biggest part of our job we'll spend more hours on that than we will on any other phase part of the any of the five phases in the search uh and sometimes if we get many many appli we'll have to call in our partners for them and ask them to call uh be making some of the calls so we try to be very thorough Dr Costa said you need to know every single thing you can about every single person that's applying so you can
050give the board a good a good amount of information that they can use to make the right decisions in addition to the background I mean in addition to the reference checks when you get to finalists there will Al we will also provide a background check which is which is more a historical perspective in terms of financial legal those kind of things we have a private investigator who does that on your behalf of all your finalists okay um my question is um who is responsible for um putting together the RFP or the proposal and submitting the proposal and will that person have a role in our search at all well that was me okay uh yeah so one of us always volunteers to to put the proposal together and yeah so uh when we meant when
051we say exclusive to your search you're going to be stuck with us for the the duration of the search um and really and just if I can just to do a little birdwalk when you think about it there are different firms that do different things and a business model a good business model if you want to make money you do as many searches as you can even if you do them at the same time cuz you're going to make more money but Dr Costco didn't care about money what he wanted to do was find the best superintendent candidates for you so he said no where every team does one search at a time and that way you give your complete attention and your Devotion to finding as many great candid as you can so that's
052what kind of the how of what we do and what you know what his values and what his expectations were for moving forward and to achieve the goal which ultimately was his goal is to make sure we find the best candidates for every District that we work with trust ver how does your firm assess a candidates alignment with our district values vision and needs well we're going to we're going to take a deep dive into identifying what those are so we have clear understanding in terms of what's what's great what's what's working in your District what are the challenges and what are the qualities that you want want to see in that in in your next superintendent that deep dive is going to going to be revealing and not only is that information obtained from
053you but also from all your stakeholder groups all of that information will be compiled we will come back to you with that information and then we will sift through that and develop criteria those things that are most critical uh because will generate what will be generated out of all these conversations is a very very comprehensive list but then we'll we'll find what is most critical and from that then we will begin to match our applicants based on their written documents based on reference checks and based if they get to an interview process based on the interview process in terms of how well they match that criteria that's been established by you and by your community did I answer your question okay did you have anything you wanted to add you know honestly it's it's about
054fit and the more information we get from the board and the more we get from the community about what you're looking for in the next leader the better our vacancy announcement will look and be and be a good tool for us to say oh this person qualified this and when you get and and when we do a list of all the applicants we'll tell you hey these people really have all the qualities that you're looking for that's not to say you don't want to interview others but in our assessment this these are the people who really line up with the qualities experience and knowledge that you're looking for and that your community is looking for as well other questions no other questions okay thank you so much right appreciate it thank you have a wonderful
055night okay that concludes the presentations for the search firm now it's time for discussion well I would I will say um I mean uh I felt that education Support Services Rose to the top um I think that they were um uh very well prepared um and I think think that they do have um with susette lovelyy I think they do have a unique perspective because she came from this district and so she kind of understands our culture but um also um the references and I think I said it in the last meeting just raved I mean they couldn't wait to tell me all the great things that they had done for their district and how you know how um so they were very um uh they were very well received by their districts and every
056single one of them said we would hire them again in a minute and um and they felt that they they actually hired them over getting that you know how you heard the 2-year guarantee they hired them over someone that they had the two-year guarantee from because they weren't um satisfied with that um I just wanted to explain why I um asked that question that I did and that was a unique question but um if you looked over the proposal um there were actually a lot of formatting errors and a lot of cross outs and and markups and that sort of thing um on the Costa um once so I just wanted to kind of point that out um that um uh I would want more attention to detail um you know if they're going to
057be producing flyers and and um and uh brochures and that sort of thing I would want more of that so that's why I asked that question so that's my um discussion any other discussion trusty emry I do I just for full transparency I have of course worked with Vicki King only in a um uh trustu you know educator role um and I do uh the last search she did um that the ESS did for our district did just pull for Poway so I have um I I definitely thought that they stood out and the kosa um highest for me um you know so I'd be interested to hear what others thought um between those as well but just full disclosure as well I've obviously worked with her other discussion I'll go okay um I I
058felt like education Support Services also um did a really great presentation I thought they're really Dynamic and answered our questions well which I appreciate um I I it is concerning there were a lot of typos in the Costco group presentation I felt actually kind of bad about it um when I saw it but um but I think they spoke to things really well and I think uh mcferson and Jacobson did it did as well too um however I think that education Support Services definitely um did a great presentation and answered my questions well as well thank you other discussion good um I was disappointed that Mr Johnson didn't come down as part of the team with Mr hwit um that was something that I noticed there um I did like his commitment to transparency of
059the community and um I thought he was well spoken but um they ranked lowest on my especially because of the affiliations with our local District here um I liked Costa um I like their commitment to transition uh transitioning into our district for the candidate um I felt like they were being authentic when they've stated that they like to uh engage all the stakeholders um I didn't get to ask some one key questions but um I did think that ESS did outperform and I am in agreement with that um I thought that they were professional I felt they were organized I like the team that they were part of Dr Gary Rutherford did come and do one of our governance board training workshops and you could see that he was working down at Sano with the
060parent groups down there and I think he's he did a good job I think he's got a good handle on things um so I would go with ESS as well any other discussion just COC I concur with everyone else's comments I think ESS was really a standout they were very engaging from the moment they walked in I felt like they kind of get the vibe of our community as it were um I also felt that um it was a little concerning given um all of the community uh conc concerns that have been uh brought up um regarding uh the association with Julie Vitali and the explanation that was given that she excused herself felt a little um not necessarily honest in in light of maybe she didn't want to maybe they figured that would be
061too hot to handle so um I appreciate people from other districts coming and staying late to kind of give us warning so thank you okay so um I'll go ahead and uh um I'll make a motion to select ESS to conduct the district superintendent search I have a second about Ward Ward give me the second okay got in there discussion we we we kind of had a discussion before but we can have a discussion again no I yeah I I do think we made a good choice so um Miss Garcia please call for a vote sorry trusty Ward was the second okay okay it was a scrum Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verth yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rollings yes motion passes 5 to zero okay
062um we still have 8.1 governance team reports this is the time for trustees to provide a brief report if they attended committee meetings where they represented the district are there any governance reports okay uh thank you we now move on to item 8.2 truste requests for information from staff trustees are there any requests for information from staff that have already been discussed with the superintendent and have been recommended to bring to the board see none no well i' take that back that's a request for information and then you have requests for future denda items okay and as a reminder trustees are prohibited from discussing uh that tonight and items uh for the BR uh when making a request please indicate the purpose of the request and whether or not staff has provided an estimate of
063time uh to accomplish the task okay um I would like to request staff to bring back to the board a summary from every School site in the district regarding our new cell phone policy which was adopted before the beginning of the Academic Year I would like to request every principal to report and provide feedback on the effectiveness of the new cell phone policy in the classroom for teachers whether there are challenges with the policy being followed by teachers Administration and our students and whether there has been push back or support from parents whether we have seen any improvements and less distractions and more positive interactions between the students more conversations around classroom material and whether there are any recommendations from Administration and staff and I can send that to you if you need it and
064did you discuss that with staff and did they tell you how much accomplished I discussed it with a superintendent and and I did not get an answer I did not ask that question okay I'm G to ask that question staff do we know approximately how much time that would take for staff work I think I'll refer to you rob as somebody who's probably closer to that than I am yeah I I think we were already in the process of getting some feedback uh by surveying some things we can include that survey as well as Gathering the feedback that's requested I I I don't imagine this taking a ton of staff time uh I think we could work with principles and get something in a future Friday update with this information included and and just to
065confirm um you said that you were going to do this anyway or something similar I think we were working on a survey uh to go out we we sent a survey I want to say um in like the beginning of the school year we wanted to kind of compare now that we're halfway through the school year so we could include that information as well as the information that trusty verf uh requested as well in a future Friday update okay so um are there thumbs to do that okay great I sent it any other any other requests for information from staff okay um thank you we'll move on to 8.3 trustee requests for future agenda items trustee are there any requests for future agenda items that have already been discussed with the superintendent and have been
066recommended to bring to the board I have one um and uh I'll do my own reminder trustees are prohibited from having a discussion tonight on these items uh when making a request please indicate the purpose of the request and whether or not staff has provided an estimate of how long the request would take um the staff has not um provided me with the how the time we take but it's basically um to ask for an agenda item that would um would uh review the IB program at Jefferson and uh provide a possible uh change to a dual language immersion program uh at that school and purpose for that is that um uh uh IB programs are usually more successful if you have a um if you have a high school coordinated with it and uh
067dual language emmersion is uh something I think that that has been discussed in this board on the past and so I'd like to see if we can get consensus to an agenda item on that topic okay thank you very much and uh let's see here uh meeting is adjourned at 11 25 and the regular meeting is now adjourned our regular meeting will take place on February 12th 2025 at 6 pm at the carlb UniFi School District office