001okay great um good evening it is 5:33 and I call this meeting to order have any blue cards been received for close session items we do not have any blue cards thank you then uh the board will recess to close session e e e I'd like to call this meeting to order welcome to the members of the public board members and staff thank you for attending as noted in board bylaw 9324 this meeting is being video recorded and broadcast via a link on our website the recording and broadcast May capture images and sounds of those attending the meeting I'd like to remind audience members and speakers that it is not unusual for students and young children to be in attendance at our meetings or to watch the recorded broadcast I invite you to model Civility
002and deorum as we go through the business of the board this evening while I cannot prohibit anyone from using unprofessional language please think about the students and adults who are watching our proceedings we invite you to show support for speakers by waving your fingers rather than clapping or cheering we'll begin tonight's meeting with student board board representative imen alad uh leading Us in the pledge of Al Allegiance trusty Ward will lead us in in a moment of meditation I will read from our meeting Norms truste Emery will will read the district vision and Miss Garcia will take role please stand ready begin Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible withy andice for [Music] all okay in honor of Martin
003Luther King Jr's birthday and how he stood up for civil and human rights for everyone I have a story story to share with you this narrative is part of the George W Bush's Institute stories from American American immigrants series showcasing um their contributions to the US Juan Carlos Hernandez immigrated to the US from Mexico at the age of nine with his brothers to reunite his brothers to reunite with their mother who had left for a better life growing up in a challenging environment juam faced significant obstacles including living without basic necessities his mother worked multiple jobs supporting them eventually helped them obtain legal status at 12 Juan began working to ease their financial burden he received his green card at 15 and enlisted in the US Army at 18 aiming to serve his country while
004serving in Afghanistan ju Juan was injured by enemy Gren an enemy grenade losing his right leg below the knee he took the he took the US citizenship test during his deployment and became an American citizen in May of 2009 after his recovery Juan began attending college in California with hopes of becoming an occupational therapist dedicating himself to helping children with disabilities immigration be brings immense value to America by enriching the cultural fabric driving economic growth fostering Innovation immigrants contribute significantly to the labor force filling essential roles in various sectors in creating jobs they bring diverse perspectives experiences andh hand in creativity and problem solving capacities in both our communities and industries the stories of immigrants like Juan illustrate the resilience and determination embodying the American Spirit and for reinforcing our strength as a country I
005know this because I am a daughter of immigrants if you want to read more stories like that you can go to the Catalyst Journal at the bush center.org our Norms are everyone participates seek first to understand then to be understood stay on topic listen before responding keep discussion moving forward remain objective adhere to time one conversation and conduct ourselves with gracious professionalism and I shall read from our district Vision our staff members demonstrate an uncompromising commitment to student growth they are leading Scholars and experts in their field they enthusiastically share their experience and knowledge and bring innovative ideas to their craft thank you and we will now take role student board representative Eli here trusty COC here trusty Emory here trusty verette here trusty Ward here trusty Rings here thank you and we now move
006on to part four approval of the agenda trustees are there any questions may I have a motion to approve agenda item 4.1 approval and or reorganization of the January 22nd meeting agenda motion second a motion by trusty Ward second by trusty verf any discussion no discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verat yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we'll move on to part five communication uh item 5.1 report by student representative to the board I am now happy to introduce uh truste Eli uh representing Sage Creek High School who will provide the board with a report hello um good evening for sage Creek's report um tomorrow January 23rd Sage Creek High will host its third annual blood drive of
007the Year from 8:30 to 1:30 p.m. Watkins are welcome our ASB is hard at work sending information on our upcoming hoop coming Sage welcomes everyone including District staff starting with the carnival right after school on January 31st our hoopcoming Carnival is a unique event where students host organizational booths games and challenges that are fun for the entire family and our community which is one of our biggest events of the year the celebration continues with the boys and girls varsity basketball games followed by the hoopcoming dance also don't miss the varsity soccer game down at the field we also have been fundraising to support the victims of the recent fires in La by collecting food items and school supplies for the P Pasadena District whose schools were severely affected we are proud of our schools clubs
008for mobilizing efforts to help fellow students in need and raising awareness and donations for our local districts Sage hopes to spread awareness and while also inviting our fellow Community to celebrate our annual hoopcoming Friday January 31st for the report of crossw high as crosat high school wraps up successful first semester they recap on some of the last couple of highlights coming back from winter break ASB successfully hosted several therapy dogs to comfort students before their finals to celebrate the end of the semester ASB will be putting up gold stars for everyone students who receive over a 3.0 GPA as for sports girls and boys basketball boys water polo wrestling and girls and boy soccer are fully underway ASB is hosting power Powderpuff signups again this year and working hard to plan February's winter formal finally
009speech and debate recently competed at ASU and Dan's heading to Nationals in Florida next week the report for SE Seaside and CVA both schools recently celebrated and successful completion of the first semester as CR by Seaside Academy they are proud to announce that their seniors have received acceptances letters to a variety of prestigious universities including Hawaii Pacific University the University of Hawaii Cal State Channel Islands Cal State Monterey Bay Cal State Sona Sonoma Cal State San Marcos Embry Riddle aeronomical University and the University of Northern California Colorado carlbad Village Academy had an equally excited Milestone with four students completing their graduation requirements on the final day of the semester these students have worked diligently to achieve their significant accomplishments and they are proud of their P perseverance and dedication in the spirit of supporting their
010students as they planned for their education After High School both students schools hosted a fafo workshop on the campus on January 14th financial aid counselors from your Costa College joined them to assist students and their families in completing the FAA application process this Workshop was a tremendous Success With Many students and families gaining valuable guidance and navigating financial aid opportunities thank you for your continued support thank you uh we now move on to item 5.2 superintendent report and that'll be for Rick Smith Schmidt thank you so January is School Board appreciation month and I'd like to thank each of you and all of you for your leadership your commitment and your dedication and I really mean that I fully understand the effort the time and all of the work that you do and some of
011the work is difficult and so I want to help you celebrate it by just acknowledging um what all of us know as staff and what our community I believe knows how hard you work and how much you work to support the taxpayers the students the parents and the staff in this Greater carlbad Community Community thank you thank you and now we move on to item 5.3 public comment on non-agenda items this is the time that members of the public have the opportunity to address the board on any non agendized item that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board how many blue cards have we received for non-agenda items two thank you in order to allow speakers to present their comments and sure we are able to properly attend to the business of the
012board per board bylaw 9323 public comments will be limited to 20 minutes this means each speaker will have three minutes when I call your name please come to the podium state your name and indicate whether or not you live within the boundaries of the school district the first speaker is Laura pittz good evening I'm Laura pittz I'm the CEO at carlb Educational Foundation I have two kids in the district um at Cala Elementary School um I wanted to take today to highlight one of our most beloved programs um because this month nearly all fifth graders will be heading to Junior Achievement BizTown um Hope Elementary will go in May and in case you are unfamiliar with BizTown is a carlb Educational Foundation funded field trip where students visit a simulated town to get a glimpse
013into the workforce they select a profession they work shifts they write and cash checks they get to vote for a mayor and the program introduces students to the concept of a career and connects the dots between with they learn in school and what they observe in real life and this program aligns with the career pathway three-year strategic plan offering students a unique and memorable hands-on experience in career exploration so it's been a neat um time for us this week i' I've heard from many fifth grade students who have Express their excitement and when we do senior scholarship interviews you know they're in 12th grade they oftentimes continue to talk about this experience so it's it's a pretty neat unique experience we have and I want to remind the community and this board that experiences like
014this are made possible by a generous and engaged community and there are many ways for the community to get involved with um helping support programs like this one is just to choose CF programs like after school enrichment and Kids Care as well as attending our annual Gala and just general charitable giving and so in that spirit I wanted to share two things one um we've gotten questions about summer some parents are very organized and are already planning their summer and for those parents I wanted them to know we are finalizing the program we will have our enrollment portals open for our summer programs early March and um we will registration will open March for both the half day and full day camps we will be located at a cusd elementary school um the the actual
015school will be determined soon we will also be offering CF Academy as we have in years's past we will be doing virtual PE Spanish and geometry and we expect registration for that to open um late February and then finally the gala is coming we um want to remind the public that the gala will take place on Saturday May 17th at the Omni LOF Resort we will be featuring The Mighty Untouchables which are dance hits and uh it is the largest districtwide fundraiser it is a ton of fun we have discounted tickets available through January 31st so anyone that's intending on joining should buy a ticket tonight and save money so have a great night thank you and next speaker is Katrina Wick hello uh Katrina wilick a teacher and parent of two kids in the
016district and I reside within the district as well um hello trustees and Schoolboard um in light of changing policies regarding undocumented mothers fathers children and individuals in our country I was hoping for some resources from the district on how to support my students and families to make them aware of their rights and resources to help them navigate this time of confusion and uncertainty I looked around to see what other districts offer and found that surrounding districts provide guidance and resources on their website or publicly Proclaim their District as a Safe Haven District the California Department of Education supports this work with AB 699 which states it requires and this is from the CDE requires all California public schools to provide protection for students regardless of immigration status and extend specific support to Immigrant students and
017their families AB 699 requires that schools adopt supportive practices in response to heightened immigration enforcement including updated staff training curriculum development and the following which includes some of report police enforcement of immigration laws to school boards ensure schools are following a family's designated emergency plan and inform parents about their children's right to a free public education and about policies to resist assistance with immigration enforcement at schools the CDC the CDE also States districts and county offices are encouraged to make powerful and reassuring statements to their students and families and to provide accurate information about relevant laws it is important that parents and Guardians feel safe on their school campuses so they will fully participate in their school communities engaged parents play a key role in helping students succeed on their way to 21st century careers
018in college on a personal level students and families right now are feeling anxious confused and uncertain this anxiety directly impacts a student's ability to learn and thrive on campus and can disrupt the overall learning environment I can say for myself I I pour everything I can and to every one of my students for an entire year and I can't imagine looking up and not seeing them there so please do what you can to prioritize supporting our Carl's bed families and uphold AB 699 thank you thank you we now move on to part six consent calendar all matters listed on the consent calendar are considered by the board to be routine and will be enacted by the board in one motion there will be no discussion on these items prior to the time the board votes
019on the motion unless there is a board request for one or more specific items to be removed from the consent calendar for discussion have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you trustees are there any items to be pulled for discussion trusa Beth um I'd like to pull item 6.19 from the calendar okay may have a motion to approve the consent calendar with the exception of item 6.19 I will go ahead and move to approve the consent calendar um without item 6.19 second for Beth and there's a second and Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verv yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you and uh trust Beth um did you um contact the superintendent
020uh letting them know that you'd be um pulling the item thank you um please go ahead okay um I pulled a similar um well a club that was different but for the same reason and I did talk to Dr NY about this as well um my concerns are not about the club itself but around the Constitution and I'd like to discuss this um because in the Constitution it um states that let me read it exactly um and this is for legal reasons I'm I'm pulling this item um it states in article three the club shall have meetings every Friday at lunch which is fine and occasionally meet outside of school for protests or speeches and I just want to point out that when I brought this up for a different Club our legal team um
021responded with overall while anyone can sue anyone for anything there is an equal if not potentially greater legal risk that students may claim violation of the EAA if they have otherwise met all requirements to be approved as a club under your policies those actions also carry risk of recovery of attorney fees so they can also be expensive cases as well the jpa response was protests and rallies of that nature are not likely to be covered by your District insurance so I just wanted to bring that up because I wondered if we could have the Constitution the the language around protests be changed so that we would be covered as a district okay are there any questions for staff um trusty Emory even though it's written in the Constitution if it states that it's outside of
022school does school actually have any jurisdiction over that yes St does not believe if if a district employee is not supervising the event and they're merely attending a rally or they're attending a speech um staff does not believe that we have any jurisdiction over that um certainly as the attorneys mentioned uh there could be some we could be sued for that um but we don't believe that we have jurisdiction over that and I can clarify in the insurance piece that um the insurance covers activities that are organized by the school school sponsored and supervised by a certificated staff member so in the event that a club chooses or a group of students choose to do something off campus that is not authorized sponsored or supervised by the school um we would have immunities under the
023government code Ed code in which we would be able to excuse ourselves from litigation um in the event and that's why they say it's not covered by Insurance because it's not our event and so you know we would very quickly look to excuse ourselves from any litigation that arises from students doing things that they do on their own time did you have a followup go ahead so could we include language then Mr Dill to um state that we don't have like if these are okay if we don't have supervision make sure to ensure that whoever oversees this club the adviser is not in attendance because if the adviser was in attendance then we would be liable correct I a follow up to that you that would then be was the adviser there on their own
024time or were they there in a in an official capacity as a club advisor um you know arguments could also be made that we could not impede the free speech of that adviser if they chose to also participate in any type of of activity political activity off campus on their own time outside of work hours um I think if we get a little too specific in these constitutions then that could also open us to people who are you know I don't want to say nitpicking but very scrutinizing the the language um leaving it more open and Broad um that protects Free Speech rights but you know Club advisers should be aware of you know the impression that is given if they are encouraging or also having communication with students or parents that they are that
025they will be there to act in a supervisory capacity also having the those discussions with their administrators so that it's clear that that I'm not going there as Club adviser I just like this cause and I will be there but it's not a school activity and I would say that's true for every single club and not this one or or those that are political religious or you know could be deemed as controversial and staff will be sure to follow up with Dr we on this occasion and he can remind the adviser of that as well thank you trusty Ward um I think you pretty much answered it but I think if they're identifying themselves um um as the progressive youth of California Club and they're going outside even if they're not is that a question
026yeah it's a question good and they're not and they're not being supervised by a certificated staff member but they are a Carl's Bad approved Club they could still be Li we could still be liable for that correct yeah I I whether or not we'd be liable or not I I don't know the specific circumstance is I think to Mr Dill's point if we have an advisor a certificate adviser that's actively encouraging them to attend an event and there's something that happens there then potentially there's some liability that we open ourselves up to um if the adviser isn't actively supervising that event and um the kids decide to go on their own then that's a different story so I think it depends on the circumstances certainly we don't view those as if a if a group
027of students were to attend a specific event without the supervision we wouldn't view that as a school sponsored activity at that point in time other questions I did have one um just to confirm that the constitution is in compliance with um with the school's rules and the district rules when uh forming a club and the constitution of a club yes it is that's correct thank you no more questions okay any uh discussion okay um Miss Garcia could uh um oh wait a minute I apologize okay now we need a uh um I have a motion and a second to um approve item 6.19 um I'll make a motion okay motion from trusty Emery second second from uh trusty Ward now there's disc discussion my apologies any discussion okay Miss Garcia please call for a vote
028trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verb yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you now we move on to part seven uh information discussion action item uh item 7.1 proposal extended day kindergarten pilot trustees this is an information discussion item I will now hand it over to Dr NY all right thank you president Rollings trustees uh superintendent Schmidt um uh during the December board meeting we received a board request to bring back specific information regarding an all day kindergarten pilot in carlbad unified tonight staff has prepared a presentation with two options for consideration for piloting an extended day kindergarten for the 2526 school year a couple items before we kind of dive into the presentation and I do want to thank uh director Fuentes who uh graciously spent
029a lot of time and putting the slides together in a very condensed period um but just a couple items to highlight before we dive in item number one is as president Rollings had stated this is an information discussion item we're looking for board Direction this evening on the two options that are being presented once we receive some additional direction we're prepared to bring back the item again either in February or March um for a more formalized approval if that's so if the board so chooses uh for the purpos of discussion this evening we did not identify any potential schools for the pilot once we determine the total number of schools in the Pilot We would bring back specific schools as a recommendation in the in a future board meeting uh we do have a slide
030in the presentation that discusses criteria for selecting a pilot school certainly we'd be interested in hearing from the trustees if there are any additional criteria that we should be considering uh that we currently are not and that we do have specific or we do not have any specific cost at this time as well we think that the cost for the pilot should be minimal depending on the scope of the school selected we will bring back specific cost of the pilot during final approval so what we have in front of you sorry I'm not casting presentation what we have in front of you is a brief timeline uh that we included in the slide deck uh back in February of last year uh you'll recall that there was a governance request at that point in time
031to uh gather some more information about the pros and cons of an all day kindergarten implementation in carlbad and there was also a request to send out a survey to TK teachers Kinder teachers as well as first grade teachers we did that at that point in time we provided some information uh to trustees we also provided some um some research around all day kindergarten um which we provided um to the board back then uh we also in April had as part of our lcap discussion some additional information some uh more cost Associated to an all day Kinder program um but that was for a full implementation that would not be costs associated just for a limited pilot um and then that leads us up to the December 16th request that we received most recently and
032that's what we're doing here tonight is talking specifically about the pilot itself it wouldn't be to talk about an all uh all School implementation of all of our school sites this is um to narrow the scope of really kind of Dipping our to in the water as it relates to kind of a a pilot program and what it would look like for all day k at some of our school sites so with that I'm going to turn it over to director Fuentes who's going to walk us through the bulk of the slides and then at the end we're happy to answer questions good evening to provide a bit more background here is a comparison of a couple sample schedules one is our current kindergarten halfday schedule with the overlap of both cohorts and the other
033is a potential schedule we could use in an extended day kindergarten pilot based on research of neighboring districts some districts end the kindergarten school day 20 to 45 minutes before grades 1 through 5 and many implemented a gradual transition to full days by beginning the year with half days for the first four to six weeks in the current schedule students receive 180 instructional minutes classes are split into two cohorts orts the early birds and the late owls core instruction is provided in blocks when only a single cohort is in attendance so this allows the opportunity for small group instruction and even smaller rotation groups to allow targeted reading and math instruction there's an overlap of both groups where they engage in calendar time their specials science social studies and have their nutrition break and recess
034in the proposed extended day kindergarten schedules students would receive around 300 instructional minutes per day and this includes structured instructional blocks albeit with the whole class dedicated time for enrichment and designated supports like our ELD as well as some exploratory and play-based learning opportunities an extended day schedule provides a dedicated Lunch Period and additional recess in summary the full day model provides more instructional time inclusive of developmentally appropriate play-based learning opportunities as well as schedule continuity between grades 1 through 5 however it loses the opportunity for core instruction in that smaller cohort so at the December meeting um of the Board of Trustees staff was asked to bring back information regarding a full day kindergarten pilot of two schools one in north carlbad and one in south carlbad at this time it's uncertain what the
035demand for a full day kindergarten program will be with a two- School Pilot We may find that the community demand may outweigh the capacity of limited sites as most schools have two to three kindergarten classes families preferring an early bird late owl schedule may need to transfer out of their home school we also considered expanding the pilot to an additional school or two um still with a small pilot this would allow greater participation um and may allow for better representation of our district demographics and special populations in selecting pilot schools there are a number of things that we want to consider we would want to ensure that the pilot is diverse and representative of our student populations this includes students with individualized plans or programs and our multilingual Learners we also want to consider the
036socioeconomic diversity within carlbad unified additionally we'd want to consider strategic and accessible Geographic locations and Facilities we do have some elementary schools impacted by construction and modernization projects that may not be able to accommodate expanded capacity at this time there are a number of benefits in piloting an extended day schedule prior to potential districtwide implementation pilot would provide time to develop and refine the program before expansion as well as an opportunity to gather feedback from our staff and Community it's also um allowing for any resolution of facility needs Staffing and budgeting Logistics ultimately if we are to move forward with full day kindergarten districtwide a pilot would support a thoughtful rollout furthermore next year we Implement Universal TK which means all students who turn four by September 1st are eligible to attend TK so TK
037is our halfday program and given our families would opt into our TK program um TK plus the option of kids care afterwards would prepare students for for a longer day um the following year piloting the new program is not without its challenges and differing schedules between pilot schools and non-pilot schools would change the Dynamics of our kindergarten collaboration meetings if we were to move forward with a pilot we'd want to ensure that all teachers engaged in program development additionally um uncertain of the demand for full day kindergarten at this time participation may be limited just to Pilot schools piloting a full day will have an impact both on Staffing and Facilities we may need to transfer teachers to piloting schools if demand is high and we want to increase capacity to max out participation we
038may also need to add or increase hours of our support staff the biggest Staffing demand we might anticipate is adding agency AIDS currently we can split one Aid between two students based on our halfday model so we'd have to to double that um position essentially with selecting schools we would want to analyze classroom spaces and schedules facilitate the addition of a lunch break and um with proper staff coverage and then assess any potential on traffic flow during arrival and dismissal times other considerations of our pilot include our School of Choice process and um determining if we were to open an additional window as our current window closes on February 15th and then to develop Logistics around a transfer Lottery if needed our kindergarten roundups or informational sessions begin next month so should we move forward
039with a pilot we'd want to develop a presentation and um reschedule those meetings for pilot schools we also want to ensure that we're engaging in collaborative um conversations with Cuda and consider the potential impact on Kids Care which is a revenue stream for CF and work with them collaborative on um the change in programming and opportunities finally categorized as a basic Aid district there are some revenue and budget uncertainties when it comes to adding new programs at this time so Clarity on the budget is expected in a couple years on the 2728 school year so again based on the two options it would be staff's recommendation to go with the more expanded option uh for a couple different reasons uh Greater Community participation we think that the demand would probably outweigh uh the total uh
040classes that we're going to be able to offer anyways but by going with an expanded option we could better meet the demands of the community uh we also think for the reasons of um being able to have it geographically located at multiple sites um will help families um make those choices as well so for those reasons believe uh staff's recommendation at this point in time would be to move forward with a more expanded pilot option so um in regards to board Direction which we'd love to hear more board Direction after discussion tonight uh we would be bringing back a final proposal to the board at a future board meeting we would imagine probably in February or March most likely March uh some of the things that we will be able to do and you will
041expect should we get thumbs on a direction tonight we would be identifying the School site at school sites at the next board meeting we would have a better understanding of uh site capacity at that point in time we would also potentially plan to survey our existing TK families to help us inform and make better decisions about where those locations should be uh we'll continue our conversations with Cuda and begin convers ation with Luna and then we would determine a plan for additional School of Choice so as uh director Fuentes has mentioned we have a window right now with School of Choice so we'll have to determine what that new window looks like and how do we get gather more information potentially uh around a lottery or transfer requests for families that want to uh participate
042with that I'll turn it back over to president Rawlings uh for public comment thank you this is the time for public comment and I have received blue cards could we mute our cell phones please thank you um and we have uh three blue cards uh when I call your name please come to the podium state your name and indicate whether or not you live within the boundaries of the school district you will have three minutes we will have the timer on the screen and your mic will be muted when your time has expired the first speaker is Shauna bloomquest let me adjust this a little bit all right good evening my name is shaa Bloomquist I live in the district I have been a kindergarten teacher at car in carlbad for 28 years I am
043a proponent of the early bird ladal kindergarten model I am speaking for the 98% of my wonderful colleagues in this District who want to keep it so I know that mtss is big and it's a focus in our district this year last year we spent over a million dollars to provide mtss teachers to help not at all nine elementary schools have you ever stopped to think what early bird latow is it's mtss so um we've had mtss in kindergarten for a very long time because we have small academic groups of three to six kids for reading math writing ELD lessons that is what mtss is so if we this year so then I look at it this way this year the district has had 36 classes of mtss across the across the district um and
044tonight you were thinking of piling an all day early bir an all day model if the ultimate plan is to do with early bird lad out then you would be getting rid of 27 mtss classes it's a big jump and it would double the size of our kindergarten small group instruction and and the lcap results show that it is not what parents want so board members I have something for you please consider your resolution 1924-25 in the matter of your roles and responsibilities of a board member you have six of them and I'm just going to read the second one and it states as a school school board member I know that my responsibility is to the citizens who elected me I am an effect of at the will of many people what I do
045reflects the cons concerns of human growth and development what I do determines the price they pay for Educational Services the concerns of the district citizens will therefore be my second consideration in my action as a board member so tonight as you consider a plan to move forward for all day Kinder do you know really which which plan the majority of TK parents and Kinder parents want I don't think you do so I have a solution and a proposal that for clear and honest input it is my suggestion we formulate a questionnaire composed of a couple district office officials kindergarten teachers and in this questionnaire we can explain both programs with honest and accurate information then we can formulate questions find out what constitutes I mean what our constituents would like to see for their Young
046Learners um the questionnaires could be sent to the principles you know board members everything this way we as Personnel District board and teachers we can all provide the best program for our parents and bottom line our kids thank you uh next speaker is Jamie rushing good evening trustees and staff um not only am I a parent in the district um I have one in college I have one at CHS um but I've been teaching for over 25 years the last 11 or last 12 actually in kindergarten as the district facilitator I feel it is my duty to communicate why it is important that we preserve our very unique early bird lad out schedule in 2019 assembly Bill 197 was proposed mandating full day kindergarten in the state of California due to the lack of evidence
047to support it and the enormous cost it would have for districts to be able to fully fund it the bill was vetoed I sent each of you an email last night I got responses from some of you thank you for taking the time to read it but in that email it had direct links detailing two separate studies completed by the public policy Institute of California and the rant Corporation to summarize both studies concluded that research to date has provided very little evidence of long-term academic benefits of full day kindergarten there was little to no difference in the reading achievement of full day versus half day but the full day students actually performed lower in math in addition they demonstrated more problematic behaviors including lower levels of non-academic Readiness skills poorer dispositions toward learning lower self-control
048and overall worse interpersonal skills than children in halfday programs our current model is way more effective than an extended day program and I hope that you will take the time to read my entire letter if you haven't along with the linked articles on a more personal note as kindergarten teachers we take great pride in the small group time that we have to develop meaningful relationships with our students and we provide very targeted mtss instruction I encourage each of you to visit my kindergarten classroom during the early bird time late out only time and then see that overlap when they're all there I also encourage you to visit another extended day model elsewhere where there are more students present I think you will see that more time does not equate to more effective instruction more children
049in the classroom at the same time means more academic disruptions throughout the day smaller group groups at recess and lunchtime allows each teacher we are with our students at recess with the full day model we will not be there we can provide quality emotional support fostering social skills and appropriate play smaller instructional groups allows us to have more handson learning opportunities more intimate targeted interv thank you next speaker and I believe it's Don e is that accurate good evening everyone um I just wanted to tell you that there's 187 years of experience right here in kindergarten and I think that tells you at all we We Know What It Takes and we have all experienced other schools as well and we know this is magical and I'm going to tell you why so when I
050was hired years ago my principal said the reason you should work in our district is because children come first and I said I love it I'm coming to work for you and that's always been something that I know that I've appreciated and I love it about our district children come first so a year ago I had a a kindergarten teacher come visit for a whole day she took the day off and she came and sat in my class and she said this is magical don't lose it fight for it we are fighting for it right now this is what our district needs we need to keep it it's special don't be like other schools keep it cuz it's not broken it's not broken children come first thank you uh trustees do you have any question
051questions trusty Emory okay I have quite a few thank you for answering uh a number of the ones I've had already um first I think one of the ones to clarify is how many students are currently in the AM PM um as well as the overlap and then how many would you be expecting for a full day currently our classes range between 19 students to 30 students um it's dependent upon 3 32 it's dependent upon our grade span adjustment um so between kindergarten and third grade um there should be an average sitewide of 24 students for the cohorts that number is split in half so if you have 20 students you have approximately um 10 to 12 in the AM class typically am is more preferred um and then the PM class um would be
052the rest of the students any followups to that I have one justy word so with the GSA um and you can have possibly more students in the kindergarten grade so do you have any classes where the classrooms are more than your the number that you just shared which are actually heavier so when they do the breakup with early bird late LS they're actually taking more if you combin them right so the total number in the class could be up to 32 students and that's a cap um from Ed code um however it depends on how principles and um leadership teams want to distribute K through three classes um again with the Early Bird ladal model um those smaller cohorts um have the instructional time because of the split schedule okay so it's not necessarily and
053even split not necessarily any follow up on that okay no followup any other questions trust Beth I have several um so I had emailed this question um the presentation didn't show any benefits to the students and to the speaker's point this is about the students so what are the full day kindergarten benefits to students since we didn't see it in the presentation the benefits would include um you'd have more instructional time um part of that instructional time um you could um incorporate play-based activities um a lot of times with the condensed schedule it is very targeted instruction um with our curriculum and um an expanded day would allow for a lunch period which currently um they typically a cohort will go home at their lunchtime um so the the benefits would be kind of a
054more developmentally appropriate um a more developmentally appropriate schedule for both a balance of academics intensive academics but also the play base experience so was a followup to that um sorry I have a followup um what I'm hearing from our teachers is different from what you're saying and so are we going based on what we're seeing and reading and research is this based on what other districts have been able to prove in their outcomes um are you able to speak to that since we didn't see it in the presentation yeah we can certainly provide I I think you know we we heard from the speakers that talked about a couple different studies I think there are plenty of studies that are out there that do show benefit as well and we're happy to provide information to
055that as well as the community on uh what that is much of the research that I've read um does show that you know that for the vast majority of students that by grade three there's there's not a lot of benefit um versus half day versus Al Decay however there are studies that are out there that do indicate that for certain groups groups of students that there is a academic benefit specifically low socioeconomic students students that are in need of additional intervention students that are multilingual Learners that need additional practice with language um so there are studies out there um that do show um both academic growth and and there are studies that show anytime that you're dealing with a a subject like this I think you're going to get a mixed review as it relates
056to studies other followup are there other questions did you have another follow up to that okay go ahead so you mentioned um intervention this teachers brought up the fact that they are providing mtss equivalent hours um will we then have to provide mtss teachers um to help support our a full day kindergarten program well we have to to bring in intervention teachers if they're not able to meet that need am I making myself clear yeah yeah I think I think and I don't want to our kindergarten teachers are fantastic I think what they were um alluding to is that they are able to work in the current model with much smaller numbers and therefore provide intervention um inside the classroom uh in a small group setting with students that truly need it um the argument
057would be made that with the additional instructional minute you could also do some of that as well so I think there's a balance there um obviously um from our our Kinder teachers uh they do a fantastic job in um navigating what they're saying is intervention within those small groups and and that would be compromised that could be something that is a compromise moving towards a more full or all day model um I think that there will still be ways that we can still provide small group instruction even with the larger class size we'd have to work with teachers and figure out what that would look like though is that another followup sorry yes it's a follow-up to that followup so I don't know if my my question was answered because what I'm hearing the kindergarten
058teachers say right now is because of the small group instruction time they are basically providing what an mtss teacher might provide so I think you started to allude to it Dr NY is that with a larger class setting with these two different instructional periods we Pro the school district would then have to provide some support to the teachers because they would need it is that correct yeah I don't Envision us um not needing mtss teachers uh irregardless of what model we choose um yes justy Emory was your was your followup yes goe yes um with that would you said the um the students who do benefit from that um in some of the questions that were asked um I know you stated that currently 242 kindergarteners are enrolled in Kids Care and 48 of those
059qualify for elop um with that are those specific sites who then that translation um would kind of equate to those in need all being at certain sites or do you find that those numbers are spread evenly across the district where a model of all day might um be more beneficial at certain sites there are a few sites that have a higher population of our multilingual Learners um we also have a number of our sites that have specialized programs special day classes I wouldn't say there's an even distribution across all Sites um but even with one multilingual Learner in a class we want to ensure that we're meeting the needs of all of our students thank you trusty W did you still have a followup okay goad so uh Dr and I um all of the
060teachers in Carl's Bad unified are being mtss trained correct part of the role of the mtss teachers is that they're providing site training on uh what that looks like what types of uh pushin interventions and tier one interventions every teacher can provide correct and also when they would need tier two or tier three supports they're all being trained on that that is correct okay and small group instruction as well yes okay and um as as well as Universal Design for Learning they're being taught that as well they're being trained on that we did have some udl training that happened in August and we are Training Site administrators and teams um to the extent that that's trickling down to all teachers I would say um it's a train the trainer model so we haven't provided ongoing
061training on udl it's it's site specific I would say but is that the ultimate goal that all teachers would have that training okay so they could support within a small group effectively regardless if it's a small early bird laid owl or um extended day schedule correct yes any other follow up on that okay new questions anyone have new questions okay trusty for Beth um this is for Miss areas um do you know how many teachers you'd estimate would have to be hired to fulfill the pilot program now we need to get more information on what the pilot looks like it would depend on what the enrollment is at that site what the current Staffing is um and if we were looking at anything with class sizes so it would be dependent we would need more
062information but um again like we said currently we staff um in that a grade span adjustment of an average site of 24 to1 K3 um so again it would look at look at as enrollment increasing are we allowing more students and what the current staff is Tristy Emory I uh thank you for the presentation and I saw a lot um within the schedule which is very helpful for someone who has not had a child in the early bird or late owl as my own child came with me um and so a question as you're moving into the instructional minutes um one of the things that I heard that I want some clarification on is you're saying that the instructional minutes would be increased however it could be more play based are we counting that play
063based you know are we looking at some innovative ways of providing maybe more play based activities integrating um you know maybe language um development of you know dual language part-time or any other kind of non-academic but social um supported things besides just being the academic minutes according to um Education Code um it a full day or extended day um program would include a balance of activities um in addition to that core instruction and part of the development process of that schedule and pilot would be um figuring out those activities um and how we would enhance the experience for kindergarteners so it be in development with the kindergarten team um and principles do you have a followup that okay a new question who has a new question trusta be okay um this is actually for Mr
064Dill he's in the back row over there um hi um can you provide a specif like just an estimate of cost for these Pilots just kind of a rough figure I can talk loudly enough if we were not to increase enrollment at all and we had a model where we simply shifted from an early bird late out to an all day that would have no increase in Staffing just on the natural so um in terms of of Staffing for a pilot program and with you know no expansion of enrollment um that would be no additional uh t uh cost for for salaries and benefits for teachers um there might be some additional costs related to um providing instructional assistance for students with disabilities um I can't give an estimate on that number because we'd have
065to count up IEPs and look at at at the the change in hours and and additional need for staff so that would be a detail to work on in terms of facilities for a pilot program there' be no additional cost under that model that I just described uh because we would be using the existing classroom with the existing furniture existing instructional materials um and other equipment that might be in the class room uh so for that so you know really as I think of the planning for this if we were to eventually adopt a full day K model um there might be some additional costs in terms of if we saw increased enrollment and we had to go in and do Renovations on facilities to retrofit them for kindergarten purposes by that that those desks
066and chairs are very tiny and so we would have to make sure that we we bought new desks and chairs um maybe additional costs for materials and supplies and then for uh you know for every class there would be you know rough you know there would be a roughly low six figure cost per class in terms of uh the teacher cost and with the addition of costs for um uh for instructional assistants who might be assigned to the classroom as well so um really it's more of an outward looking if if there was an expansion not only of the program but also in terms of enrollment that's really where the hit would be um not so much for the upcoming pilot program follow up just Beth Mr Dill do you have any Financial concerns about
067operating a full day kindergarten in our district the well the the thing that would be on my mind uh as a basic Aid district is if you uh when enrollment increases it doesn't come with additional funding as it does under the local control funding formula and so um this would be a concern for uh the board and the administration as they develop the budget for this upcoming year and then the next few years um this would just be one other consideration in addition to everything else that we would be building into the budget balancing against what do we anticipate our Revenue to be for the upcoming year um and do we have enough to cover everything that we want to do or are we going to have to uh prioritize which things rise to the
068top or not so uh you know I I have a financial concern about everything that's said in this room um no matter what we no matter what we are talking about about um so uh and and so I keep the adding machine going when we're having conversations and ultimately it does come back to what are our priorities if we do not have enough resources to do everything we would like to do and I think that in in this discussion that would be a decision that the board would need to make a little bit further down the road this year during the budget development cycle when we've got a little bit more information on our estimated property tax revenue which we do not have at this time um you know but we'll have and then we'll
069have some estimates in the next few months and then that will get refined before the budget is brought forward to the board for adoption and you can line that up against everything else um that you've discussed over the next few months and during the elcap process Etc of here are all of our desires which of these are the things that we want to do compared to the costs which we will be able to uh be able to better articulate once we know what the models potentially could be and how many classes and where the sites are um as just one of the many budget considerations I could if I had just add on to Eric's previous answer too if with his model saying if we didn't change anything else with enrollment um there there could
070be an increased cost in Staffing because the current model as you heard from our K some of our kindergarten teachers is some of those classes are higher at 30 or 32 because again that core instruction they're only seeing half of the kids at a time so what principales sometimes do um is are able to take away combos in grades 1 through five by giving you know more staff toward those grades rather than Kinder and keeping those classes a little bit larger so if we were looking at um having full day Kinder and not wanting 32 in the class and trying to keep that a little lower in the current model then then we would be looking at some additional staff costs um as well just because of that flexibility principles have right now we'd be
071probably taking a closer look at um at the the Kinder numbers as well other questions truste CS might we not also have significant expenditures uh regarding the lunch that we would now be in instituting for the kindergarteners they've always kind of operated independently from the rest of the students I think that's probably something that most parents would want is for the kindergarteners to have their own lunch time their own lunch area and not be integrated with the general population of all the older kids yeah so that's Staffing and Facilities there would certainly be a cost in regards to um additional classified Staffing to kind of supervise uh that activity um there would not be additional cost in regards to the food preparation or um the the meals itself is that a follow up yep goad
072for uh the actual lunch area where they would be having lunch are you suggesting that they would be in the main lunch area just at a different time from all the other grades or are you suggesting that they would have their own lunch area constructed no it would be it most likely it would depend on the site but it would most likely be a um a separate time that they would use and be uh or a location in the lunch area that's um not integrated with all the other grade levels correct I have a followup to that if um what do what do our current students um do for meals what is what is the process for meals for our current students currently we offer all students two meals one at their snack recess break
073and then um they also get a lunch if they opt in for it for our early birds since the and late owls um who go home around 1:00 um if they opt to take a lunch um we provide a lunch for them they just need to eat it on campus um and typically that's during regular lunch service um we also have Kids Care on campus and um generally we'll have um they have a dedicated lunchtime so they'll come to the cafeteria and grab a lunch and then um take it with their kids cohort other follow-ups for that trusty Amry uh along the same lines as the facilities and working in do um you foresee the need of extra classrooms and if so do those come with kind of the mandatory kindergarten bathrooms that are separate
074from the the general population yeah with the pilot I don't I don't think we foresee fa additional facility needs um if it were to get to an all day k at all of our school sites I would I would imagine we're going to need to do A needs assessment at that point in time and and uh determine whether or not we can meet the demand we would get additional demand I would think um we we typically do see an increase in enrollment with um first grade students and that typically is due to the fact of some of our families opt to do an all day K option a private all dayk option other questions I have a few myself go ahead go ahead so the first one has to do with enrollment we talked a
075little bit about it um our new um demographer says that we have declining enrollment so um what would you anticipate we did receive some emails in the past from parents who wanted to come to our school district for Kinder but opted out because we didn't have full day do you have any kind of numbers on that how many families with students that we missed out on um in incorporating them into our kindergarten program because we did not offer full day um and how that might impact our future enrollment um if we had full day yeah typically we see about an 80 to a 100 uh student jump from K to one so um you can imagine that we would potentially recoup some of those students that where their parents are opting for an all day
076Ka private model um if we're offering that model here it that's a guesstimate um don't hold us to that but typically that's where we usually see the jump is from kinder enrollment to first grade enrollment we typically see about an 80 to 100 uh student increase between those grade levels District wide sorry trusty COC do you have any way of knowing though why there's that disparity because I I've noticed a lot in my lifetime people start getting serious about where they're going to set down routes when their kids are starting school so maybe it's maybe they weren't in our district and opting to send their child elsewhere it was just now they're looking for a good school district and of course it's Carl's Bad yeah there could be no we don't currently we don't survey
077those families and we don't know specifically their rationale reasoning why they didn't attend Kinder with us and they're coming to us from first grade it could be a myriad of reasons follow up so to follow up with that just to clarify that that we don't have any way of knowing that we are missing out on students attending our district because we're in the early bird late Al program and it could just be due to a variety of other reasons we don't have any reason to believe necessarily that we would have increased attendance because we were offering a full day option um kindergarten is not mandatory um in California um so that could be parents could opt for a number of different programs um we do have our TK is growing and so we could see
078um just some different numbers as that program has um been staggered over the last few years and then next year will be our full implementation of TK follow up just am follow up on that does the TK program have a straight full or straight half day or is it a crossover like the early bird lat out it's a straight half day so it's an AM PM model there are 24 students in a class um with a certificated teacher and an instructional Aid in um the morning and then in the afternoon a different um cohort comes in of 24 students next year that will change the ratio is um going to be not um 12 to1 but um 10:1 for next year um and we will be um supporting that with additional instructional assistance um the
079ratio then could drop down to 8 to1 followup no if it's not follow up then okay I'm going to ask my question um when um uh you had said that when you were looking at the schedules um that um uh that you looked at other schools to kind of compare to what schools did you use to compare we used some in Oceanside we looked at Poway um I spoke with Inus um so a lot of our our neighboring districts okay other other questions new questions TR for ref how do you plan on evaluating the pilot program and its Effectiveness that's a good question um and that would be part of our proposal that we would develop um we would definitely want input from our staff and our teachers um as well as our community to
080um determine not only the schedule and program that we're providing um but also our needs so we would we would dig into that um to look at a a proposal down the line and look at those measures um and that could be um the data that we're taking with our um with academics um it could be how our um special populations are performing in that expanded day which is why we want to um identify schools that really Encompass um who we are as Carl's bad so that we can really look at those subgroups and um the impact of a full day program with them is there a followup okay um I'm going to ask one here um when you had you had discussed the selection process um would are we talking are you anticipating that
081we would be looking at um it would be students within the boundaries and then a lottery or would it be a complete lottery as a pilot yeah it's a it's a good question anytime you mention lottery I kind of shiver a little bit um I don't we've never had to do a lottery here in Carl's Bad um specifically with our High School uh open boundaries we've never gotten to that point um we haven't fully flush that out I I think that for us part of what we could do next is survey our uh TK families to kind of get a better sense of what is the demand where is the demand at geog graphically um the hope would be that we could accommodate through an expanded pilot potentially uh all the demand and we wouldn't
082need to we could accommodate that through a School of Choice process where people are choosing one or the other um if we got into a situation where demand outweighed the total size that we had uh capacity wise then I think we're going to need to have a contingency there of what uh a lottery could look like in Carl's Bad is that a followup justy with that I know that a lot of times once a student's allow in for one grade that that's then considered the home schoool for the rest of that that time would that be the same situation or would you expect um people want to transfer out and back to their you know home school um any thought given to that yeah I would imagine it's going to run similar to the way
083that we do TK now where we have um we don't have TK at all of our sites and they can attend there for that specialized pilot program and then attend their homeschool after that we'd have to see though and and figure out what that would look like yeah Tristy COC do we have data on what percentage of TK and uh kindergarten students are currently utilizing the Kids Care Program for Afterschool care and specifically I'm interested in how many are utilizing those Services just until say 2:35 so normal pickup time for the residual grades on campus and how many are staying until 6 o' with working parents and are we not already meeting the needs of those parents who need Afterschool care with providing that Kids Care on campus and but before you answer that question
084could um you also provide information on folks that drop off their students for the late l so they're they're getting care before school as well to to add to that thank at this time I don't have information on the before care for the late owls um but we do have 242 kindergarteners enrolled in Kids Care programs across the sites and I greatly appreciate CF for pulling these numbers um for us so quickly um and then there are 131 who stay um pass the about 220 230 school day into the evening um and just over 100 I believe1 um that go home right at the end of the school day for grades 1 through five other questions I had two more trusty Amry um as one of our speakers mentioned um it says about 98% of
085the teachers prefer the ampm however in the information provided um uh through previous survey it was noted that out of the 43 respondents it was about split about a mixed view on both how many total respondents then would we expected and what percentage was that 43 um to try to get a feeling of how the total population of teachers feel I don't have the exact numbers on the percentage of that 43 um the survey that was conducted was of tkk and first grade teachers um kindergarten teachers overwhelmingly um wanted to maintain that half day mod or the um early bird late owl model um first grade teachers um had an interest in expanding that school day so that was the difference in um the um response is that a followup no it's a different are
086there any other new questions go ahead trusty ver Beth could you operate a half day and a full day at the same site potentially we could look into that um there would be a number of logistics um in scheduling that we would want to work with our principles and Leadership teams um but it it is a pilot option um my question is do you know how many um districts in San Diego County um have um a a early bird late owl schedule compared to a full day of 36 districts within San Diego County um six districts did not post schedules um out of the remaining 30 we are the only other um District that has that half day schedule are there other questions so I can find my question no okay just be sure so
087um you did speak to this but I'd like to ask on average in kindergarten how many um of these students have special needs or elll or other impacted populations we have um I believe 85 students who are on IEPs um in our special um special education program um a portion of that um are students in special day classes so most of their day is in a separate setting um and typically those are multi-age um classes um I believe we have um around 45 multilingual Learners um and then we do have a high population of um of our socioeconomically disadvantaged and I don't have that figure in front of me how that one 146 56 156 thank you for kindergarten alone Justa Beth about how much time does a teacher need to prepare and be out
088of a classroom for an IEP meeting those kinds of things how much much time is required approximately per student per student um there is some preparation time oftentimes um teams will have a staffing meeting for about half an hour um either during the day or after the school day um teachers do need some time to pull together um any assessment data or um work samples to provide at that meeting and typically IEPs can range between 30 minutes and an hour and um sites generally have a rotating sub um to relieve them at that time so they can participate in the meeting Tristy Amry uh just a followup to that um with the adoption of either plan would that impact the number of IEP students in each classroom depending on uh if you move from the
089current model to uh an all day K with that increase decrease or stay the same in those number of case load per teacher they would have the same case load they just might be split into different cohorts so right now they might have a student with an IEP in the early bird session and maybe one in the afternoon session but they would still overlap they and they would still be on their case load I found the question I was going to ask um and hopefully it'll lead to our discussion so um uh um so you had stated that staff is recommending an expanded model um what um are you say and you said an expanded model would be three or four um wh which would it be three or four or do you know uh
090it would be three or four we're still I think at this point in time we would want to survey TK families to try to get a gauge of what the demand would be um we'd also want to look at uh special day programs across the district to make sure we're covering um those programs uh for Equity purposes and then um geographically based on the survey results we would want to make sure that we're trying to hit the geographic areas where there's demand so uh I would still say staff would like Direction uh with the option of of bringing back an option of either three or four based on what we see the Demand Being justy emry Sorry follow up on that um with those two last questions combined then are you foreseeing that if most
091of the kindergarten teachers prefer the current model but the first grader teachers prefer an all day would we then be talking about involuntary transfers for those kindergarten teachers possibly to different sites I don't know if it would necessarily be involuntary um we would um I'm sorry I lost my train of thought um they could potentially continue to teach at their site but we also have a teacher transfer window so teachers could voluntarily opt to move to another school if there was um an opening based on um need at other sites so it could be a combination of both but there is a voluntary process okay and I just I want to thank you for um answering all of our questions in advance there was a lot more even in advance so and I appreciate trustees
092asking them in advance um I think we could have here a lot longer if we hadn't done that so um uh so hearing from staff it sounds like they want direction from us so now we're in discussion who has discussion trusty wart um I I feel like there's a lot of unknowns still um and that makes me feel a little bit uneasy you know we're hearing from the teachers and some they shared some really great resources and I understand um that research I know that there's also that research that you speaking to in terms of our low socioeconomic students and our e students which is close to over a half of our kindergarten students so that's and I know it that long instructional time and those extra minutes definitely benefit that population and I want
093to make sure that we are supporting stud students that need that that extra support but um I guess what I would like to know and I don't know how you all feel about this but um I want some more information like I you were mentioning about serving um some of the TK teachers and staff members and I think we had um a Kinder teacher that mentioned doing a survey about you know what parents actually are wanting the TK parents what they're actually wanting and seeing if we can kind of look at that and see if that's something that we could support now in this model in the early bird late owl model but um I just think that there's some big unknowns I would want to know what school sites they're they would be at
094um the impacts on our special education program and um while Eric is still here the costs the cost and how that would impact because you know we want to make sure that all of our students are supported with the appropriate amount of IAS and um classified staff if you know especially if they're not going to be supervised by their certificated teacher so um I would want to hear all of those details before actually moving forward and just to clarify that um my understanding is staff is asking us to give them Direction to you know do they proceed or do they stop and then um do we want expanded right so do we want and do we want expanded or um limited pilot or any pilot so if I guess so staff is wanting to know
095you know do they proceed with what you're talking about and then the direction would be do we want to um well those are those are kind of my thoughts on the top of my head and I'm thinking moving forward would be hard to like give them direction to move forward with that so I would want to know more information before actually saying yeah let's do this pilot is what I'm saying right in terms and that's not what they're asking because we're we're not voting on anything tonight so it's it's all all disc but in terms of giving them Direction on the pilots I would want more details so what I'm hearing you say and and I just want to clarify is that um what staff is proposing is that they would do more research they
096would identify some sites they would find out costs they would and then it would come back to the board so are you are you wanting to do that or do you want it to stop oh I I don't want it to stop but I would want to know all of those details so yeah because we're not being asked to say we're doing a pilot or not doing a pilot it's more of does staff keep going and so then the next question would be do you want them to explore a three to four not specific or um or a two uh school to to continue on to um to explore what what would be your um option on that I I would probably go with the staff recommendation I mean because they know the sites better
097um okay so so that would be what they would bring back to us is that so you're in favor of that okay um okay trusty uh verth I'm in agreement with trusty Ward there's a lot of unknowns so I am not comfortable yet moving forward other than getting Gathering more information and possibly looking at one to two sites I think having it small and controlled is better we're not moving as many teachers around um they're able to continue on with the program that we have because if it's not effective or the teachers don't like it or we're not seeing the outcomes then what's the point of doing four we know it's going to be impacted so let's just stay with two keep it small and controlled and then we don't have to impact as many
098facilities and just to clarify that you're um that you you want staff to proceed and you know gathering information giving us getting us more information providing us with um a a possible pilot but to limit it to two is that accurate okay trusty Amry uh along the same lines I think you know we're kind of uh diverging perspectives on both of those where we have we hear a lot of our teachers saying that they don't believe that's the best model um and the parents and the community saying that's the model they want um and so I think you know possibly there's a way to diverge I'd be interested in getting more information to diverge both of those and maybe think of something it might be a moot point there was maybe enough teachers to cover
099the parent parents um who want that and maybe to think even creatively and out of the box because when we have happy teachers and happy Parents we have happy kids um and that's when they do their best learning so I would like to um you know even see if those one to two or three to four schools can even move to just one you know what are the possibilities of one all day within the half day or is it does it need to be you know the whole site moves to the full day kind of what are the options within that one to two and 3 to four that we're playing with and then what other kind of creative um options can we have because the one thing I keep hearing from parents over and
100over um you know get funding uh more information with the kids care along with that uh but is that the kindergarten kids don't feel engaged in their school climate and I think that is hugely important um to address those needs as well so climate so just to clarify um you're suggesting that um we have that we that you that staff bring back three options possibly yeah okay so that I I just want to clarify to okay so three options to look at for a potential pilot yes okay um justy sayi I think had a s and let's Okay um so I very much appreciate the information that's brought forth it it's a broad topic with far-reaching implications and so there's a lot of things to consider um but the data that you've presented us with
101tonight is indicating that currently only 20 % of our kindergarten students are taking advantage of the after school care that would take them to what we're considering in the in the region of the full day program TimeWise and so only 20% taking advantage that's telling me that the draw is not as much as it's not justifying the amount of effort and uh work that we're putting into that there are scholarships available I know I've heard from parents talking about the cost of Kids Care um and we can certainly work with CF to see if um we can continue to lower pricing with that or offer more scholarships if if cost of Afterschool care is really the primary concern but it seems to me that we really do have an amazing program all of my kids
102were early birds um they had great experiences amazing teachers we have the best teachers here in carlbad and um and I am not really moved to go forward um at this point because I think we're satisfying the needs of the parents in our district with our relationship with CF and our kids Care Program trusty Ward did you have something say can I ask a question yes thank you for um I'm sure you said this already but can you share why why you're recommending three to four schools as opposed to one to two or two schools versus three to four yeah I think what we mentioned before is um the concern around demand outweighing uh what we're being able to provide would be one thing um secondly about that Equity piece and making sure that we're
103offering uh uh a full spectrum of programs to students on IEPs so making sure that we're covering sites that have specialized programs and then you know Geographic uh considerations as well so the idea that we could hit uh the full region of Carl's bat so those those were the three main um reasons why we recommended that yes please so um in terms of the equity piece in supporting the programs is are you un able to do that with if you have a pilot of two schools as opposed to um a pilot for three to four um what we need to be able to do is that for specialized uh special day classes as an example um we need to mirror and offer what's happening in the gened setting in those special day classes so the
104thought would be um we have specialized programs at certain sites around carlbad to offer um a similar program at those sites so that's that's the logic around that um we wouldn't be able to hit everything but the thought would be to try to hit as many of those as possible so that's the expanded model allows us to kind of hit those a little bit more um I still think we're okay with um uh from a legal perspective yeah we just need to get um we would need to be creative about how we're uh scheduling those kids and figuring out uh the other programs as well but I think we could do it either way trusty ay uh just a follow up and a check on on the numbers I have he that out of 534
105total kindergarteners that 242 are enrolled in Kids Care is that correct so it's about half of them are currently using kid care in one way or another okay and just to follow up with that that does not include um folks that uh that use Kids Care uh before school before um late L starts correct it's inclusive of all the students who are accessing any of the programs for kindergarten I just don't know the specific number in that morning session got thank you justy CC uh and just to clarify that the the 20% number that I quoted was the 111s student number that you gave us that utilize the Kids Care Program until approximately 230 and so that's the number of students that are currently in our early bird late owl program that are utilizing Kids
106Care to accommodate the schedule is that it would be with full day kindergarten and that is 20% of the current students and so if finances for the cost of two parents for the cost of that after school care is the concern I think we can address that in other ways and not by putting in a full day kindergarten program and completely reorganizing the amazing program that we already have with the early bird late owl if if helping Working Families with child care is the goal we can work on that I just want to clarify that um I heard you say that you could not identify um the folks that are bringing their students to um before school before as a late l so does that 111 include those or does it not it potentially could
107include them because there's there are a number of sessions that CF offers um students can come before um late owls can come before their afternoon class join their late owls and read rejoin um for the remaining part of the day which is about um an hour and a half um so they could be part of that number okay I just want to okay yeah I again so you don't know is I guess okay so so we have 238 total that are accessing K Kids Care and 111 of them are um at least we know that that1 is they at 2:30 that they leave at 2:30 okay so I just want to clarify that okay uh trusty and I just do want to remind us we are in discussion so we want to try to get
108back to that rather than asking more questions but go ahead so just um I think a survey in that point would be very beneficial because you know we're not taking into account those students that might be going to um a nan or boys and girls club or other services so I think moving forward I wouldn't feel comfortable and I've seen you know I've worked in both models and I seen how both are good and both are you know have their pluses and balances but I think you know I really appreciate how different and unique our schools are and I think we can continue that whatever model we pick and not just kind of pick and choose so I'd like to continue with more information um and maybe some possibly new ideas um before we're ready
109to go forward right and that and that's what's kind of being proposed right now so um I just want to clarify and I haven't spoken yet so um and the reason I keep going back to that because I was one of those late Al moms and I had to um and uh you know and I had to drop off my child the before care and um and you know we have had parents come and speak to this board over the years I mean this is this topic is not new this has been discussed in Carl's bed for many many years and um parents have said that their students are you know do feel left out if they're in the late L program that they don't you know that they can't participate or they're not participating
110as much in like the Halloween parades and those types of things you know kind of the the fun social stuff and um and and I did experience that and so um but I had to be very purposeful to make sure that you know that there was you know that that my that my child was involved in some of those pieces and you know if I could be there I couldn't be there those types of things so I mean I could see both sides 100% um because I do think the program um does provide some um a very um uh you know small class instruction that you know you have a lot more opportunity for one-on ones those types of things so again I um uh I can definitely see both sides and and again being
111a you know going through the programs and being that late L parent I I think that um at least from my perspective a lot of the the early birds um that there's a lot more demand for the early birds at least that was my experience at the time um so um so I would be in favor of um of proceeding uh with um with the two um with two schools I'm not personally I'm not in favor of going beyond that um so um just because I want to see and again I agree with you I think that you know we do need to see the results I think we need to you know kind of and and that's what a pilot's for um and so and I like the the North and the South and
112then um go from there so that's where I stand so um so we don't have a full consensus yet I think because we so you and I are you know go with two and so um and then there was a more of an expansion you said all of the above um so um and uh and then uh trusty board had said she wanted the expanded so we we still need to find three if we're going to move forward yeah I think I'm I mean I think I originally asked for two so I think I'm good with the two however it it does I am concerned because I know you shared with me that in terms of supporting you know specialized programs it does make it easier and more beneficial for students but um that kind
113of bothers me a little bit I think we have consensus for um two schools to bring back for two okay so I'm hearing two uh trusty CS any discussion I just think we were we were discussing the the children that maybe need more time with practice in language and stuff like that and if they're in the Kids Care Program they're getting that same time that they would have been getting in a full day program so I think a lot of these things are part of our current model and again it's we can always improve on what we have I'm just not a big fan of losing what we have that is amazing in favor of trying to tweak little things I think there's other ways we can accommodate people that have needs thank you for
114that um so I I see three for um three to move forward on um exploring again we're not making any commitments yet um we're just saying that we want more information on a two two school one um One North One South staff is that clear okay and then when do you think we could um have a model put together what do you think uh with the surveying I I staff would prefer us to bring this back in March at the March board meeting great so we'll anticipate on the March meeting thank you so much okay moving on um and we have item 7.2 um uh approval lcap stakeholder and engagement survey tool and proposed lcap engagement timeline uh trustees this is a discussion action item and I want to hand it over to Dr NY
115uh thank you again president Rollings trustees let me I'll just give it a second people file out let me stop casting as well uh you have before you as part of our continuous Improvement cycle annually uh as we develop our annual goals and success indicators along with our lcap process we bring back to you annually each year uh the stakeholder survey which in this case is a thought exchange that we use uh uh for the past year which is exhibit a where we ask one question um and uh the benefit of the thought exchange is to continue to provide an opportunity for inclusive feedback it allows for crowd sourcing so if you've been a participant of a thought exchange um people post their thoughts and then you rank other people's thoughts um and then it
116allows for some Collaborative Learning some transparency and it also empowers stakeholders so staff's recommendation is to continue with that PR practice of adop the thought exchange which is exhibit a where we ask the one question um and then exhibit B is really our uh timeline in regards to the LC cap so this is our meetings with our stakeholder groups um audience can we um silence phones and videos please thank you so exhibit B is our lcap timelines and this uh outlines our procedures that we do to meet with our standing stakeholder groups as well as when does the survey open when does it close and all the public meetings that we have with the elcap uh in the spring for the development of the following Year's lcap and our goals and success indicators so with
117that staff's happy to answer any questions we would recommend that you approve the two exhibits um and we're happy to answer any questions I'll turn it back over to president Rawlings great thank you and tristes this is a discussion action item and um so I want to oh I'm sorry back up um this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards we not have any blue cards uh trustees do you have any questions trustee for Beth well thank you for providing exhibit B with the timeline of activities and the description of the activities and the explanation of acronyms that was awesome um did you use the same question as last year um that you have in this exibit okay that's what I thought um
118and could you provide some of the positive feedback that you received from that question um I think the question's open-ended enough that it's eliciting you know what are some of the priorities that you'd like Carl's Bad to focus on in the upcoming years and so it allows for um parents and any stakeholders for that matter to talk about programs it allows for uh them to express some of the concerns they have uh and so it seemed as though we got a rich amount of feedback on a number of different programs and then we're able to with that data sort it by respondent type by grade level by um a number of different ways and then present that uh at our study session so we thought it was valuable um and it certainly streamlined a process
119we used to have a very long survey process with number of different questions on there that I questioned whether or not they led to any change this this seemed to be actionable data that we were receiving other questions no other questions uh may I have a motion to approve the lcap stakeholder engagement survey exhibit a and the lcap timelines and stakeholder input exhibit B motion second ver be it's a motion by trusty Ward second by trust Beth discussion discussion I would just like to say um I thought I really like the thought exchange I thought we got a lot of valuable information and I agree with you that I thought our survey was very long and uh um not as accessible and I think we got some of our best results um by using that
120tool so um I um as far as if I remember it was thousands and thousands of responses um and I think you did say that you would be kind of separating out some of the responses between like students and parents so there would be so we could see the the the input that we were receiving by groups so I appreciate that so um I will be voting in favor of um this um uh of this item any other discussion other discussion uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote student board representative Eli yes trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verb yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to item 7.3 approval of agreement for Legal Services trustees this is a discussion action item
121I will now hand it over to Mrs Megan Aris thank you uh the district is in need of an interim Chief business official while it searches for a new assistant superintendent intendent to replace Eric Dill who has resigned and his last day will be January 31st staff have have identified an interim CBO candidate who can be contracted through Fagan Freedman and fulfrost as a Next Level client service at the rate of $180 per hour Fagan Freedman and fulfrost have agreed to contract um Suzanne oconnell to be the interim CBO in cusd until a permanent CBO is selected later this year Mrs oconnell is a longtime carlbad resident and a previous employee of carlbad Unified School District she worked for cusd where she served as assistant superintendent of instructional services from 2004 to 2013 and Deputy
122superintendent of administrative services and CBO from 2013 to 2017 since retiring from cusd in 2017 she has served as a consultant and interim CBO for various school districts including cusd in 2021 where she served as interim CBO prior to Mr Dill being hired it is respectfully recommended that the Board of Trustees approved the agreement for Legal Services with Fagan Freeman and fulfrost this would allow Mrs oconnell to begin as interim CBO on January 27th to allow some transition time with Mr Dill before he leaves on his last day on the 31st thank you this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you uh trustees do you have any questions trusty ver Beth uh the agreement uh was effective January 13th but we
123have not been receiving any services from her nothing's been rendered Cor okay um did you have a followup no but I have another question is there are there other questions TR a b okay um I noticed other fees are considerably higher on page four of the agreement ranging from $50 to $385 could you explain if we're going to need those additional services for the interim CBO I can answer that no she will work at the $180 rate I appreciate that thank you and are there other questions Justa Beth and are we planning on using another search firm to find the permanent replacement for CBO um we haven't made final decisions regarding that um we haven't had to use a search firm in the past um when we've replaced uh this position and we do believe
124that um a lot of it will be dependent on who the superintendent will be a lot of people you know if they're in a current CBO position they don't want to leave necessarily um and unless they know who the superintendent will be um we do think that um we've had a lot of interest that's already been expressed from high quality candidates so our current thought right now is um to run the recruitment process if we're not seeing that we're getting a high level of candidates then we could look to see do we need a search firm to go out there and reach out larger um so that that was our current thinking right now other questions and I had asked one in in advance but it didn't get on the list so um uh I
125did want to uh confirm by by doing it by hiring um this position this way that doesn't impact um the retirement the pension piece correct correct this way um she has flexibility in the amount of time that she can serve great thank you may I have a motion to or any more questions okay uh may I have a motion to uh approve the agreement for Legal Services with Fagan Freedman and F Frost LLP I motion Emory second trusty Emery uh made a motion and trusty SE second any discussion I would just like to say I'll be um it'll be I'll be thrilled to have um Suzanna conell um as our interim um again she was a CBO for a long period of time and I've been able to I worked with her prior to her
126retirement from here as well and um she did come back as Nim uh previous uh before we found uh um Mr Dill so I think she has a vested interest and I think this is a solid choice for our district so um and and any other discussion another discussion uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote student board representative Elly yes trustee COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verbet yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to item 7.4 approval compensation increase for unrepresented employees supervisor and confidential groups trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Mrs Megan Aras thank you the district and leuna previously reached a tenative agreement uh back on October 18th 2023 that included additional
127step increases to the class classified salary schedule these additional step increases were not added to the supervisory and confidential salary schedule which has now resulted in some employees in this group earning less than other classified employees in the same salary range this item proposes an equitable salary and step increase for all supervisory and confidential staff members so it is respectfully recommended that the Board of Trustees approve the supervisory and confidential salary schedule with additional steps um effective July 1st 2024 consistent with that recommended for classified staff thank you thank you this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you trustees are there any questions no questions I may have a motion to approve salary increase and step increases for supervisory and confidential
128groups effective July 1 2024 consistent with that already provided to classified staff Al a motion yes trusty say makes a motion yes please Emory will second and trusty Emory seconded any discussion excellent uh Miss Gia please call for a vote student board representative Eli yes trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verth yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rollings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to item 7.5 revision of board policy's first reading trustees this is a discussion action item I now hand it over to Mr Eric D thank you at the last meeting of the Board of Trustees during the discussion of the first interim budget uh Direction was given to staff to recategorize uh components of the ending balance uh specifically the uh reserve for economic uncertainties uh
129to bring that down to the state minimum of 3% uh then take that additional 2% add it to what is currently a stabilization Arrangement also known as the basic Gade Reserve or the lcff reserve we've called it a few different things uh and call that a uh board lcap priority Reserve um in the next reporting period uh ends January 31st 2025 and we will bring a budget back to the board for review and approval at the March 12th meeting so in order for us to make that change that would be reflected in the second interim report uh we would need to adjust board policy 3100 which currently sets that minimum reserve for economic uncertainty at 5% um and so we can we can reflect that change so there's only one change in the number on
130uh board policy 3100 um I will say that uh in terms of the discussion last month and the direction uh given to staff there were no changes in the ending balance there's no change to um the uh revenue and expenditures it really is just recategorizing ization so it's not being spent down at this point um all of those discussions happen as they do in all of our budget discussions and and budget development for uh for next year uh so with that uh we bring this uh for first read uh for the board to make that change uh a final thing that I'll mention is that um as I pass this on to Mrs oconnell uh in our discussions um and a reminder to the board that the 3% minimum reserve requirement that the state has
131is for the current plus two fiscal years uh so for the current year we would be talking about 2425 25 26 26 27 so we would have to maintain that uh and then as we go into budget adoption cycle one more year gets added to that requirement so we would just need to make sure that we that we hit that across all all three years and of course my my recommendation as I point out that mathematically we haven't changed the ending balance um that the recommendation is not that we spend down all of our reserves to the minimum of 3% and live on that edge uh for now in the future it's just to have other reserves that remain at the board's discretion which ultimately all budgets are at the board's discretion and how you
132determine to uh use the revenue expend and how you expend it and whether you dip into the reserves or not in when times when revenue does not meet our needs uh so it it simply commits those reserves um you know one one issue that you might have is uh if there's no wiggle room above the 3% and all other reserves are committed at uh above that um there could be some issues where if we suddenly see a increase in enrollment and we need to hire more staff we would need to come back to the board and say can you please decommit some of these reserves so that we can make Staffing adjustments at the beginning of the year so it might be prudent to carry some unassigned reserves uh as you're going into budget adoption
133for next year I'm not so worried about this year it's really about next year uh where you might want to consider doing that um but ultimately you do want to ensure that you are maintaining healthy reserves for those times uh when we need them and with that I'll turn that over for uh back to president Rawlings thank you this is time for public comment and I have two blue cards uh when I call your name please come to the podium state your name and indicate whether or not you live within the boundaries of the district you will have 3 minutes we will have the timer on the screen and your mic will be muted when your time has expired the first speaker is Scott Davidson according to the minutes from last month's meeting truste Rawlings
134quote requested consensus for the board to direct staff to take a stab stabilization Arrangement and put what is equal to 2% over the state requirement and collapse that into one object code that states board lcap priorities fund according to the agenda summary at the December 17th meeting the board indicated consensus to lower the minimum reserve for economic uncertainties from the board's current standard of at least 5% to the state minimum of 3% in order to reflect this change in future budget reports a revision to board policy 3100 is necessary so to summarize your words at the last meeting the board took action to amend the budget and change the categories for our reserves the effective date of this change was the date of the meeting and in fact it was effective prior to your vote
135to submit the first interim budget report to the county and to the state there was no at some point in the future or as of the second interim budget report trusty Rollings was quite clear quote I want to make sure we do it now so then at lcap time we have the opportunity to use those funds when consensus was achieved she turned to the staff and asked if you could make that happen all of this was of course a surprise to the public as the agenda never mentioned a consideration of taking almost $7 million in reserves and transferring it to Rawling special slush fund it's pretty clear that the board had no idea either it's no surprise why she surprised us with this request of course it's a brown act violation but we knew she
136has no respect for the brown act she can't even follow our own State conflict of interest law she also no doubt knew but did not care that it violated board policy 3100 which required a 5% minimum Reserve she knew this of course because she was the one who voted against it in 2015 numerous times when it came up for review but Rollings was relying on the new board not knowing the rules and hoping she should could surprise the board so that they wouldn't have time to research it or ask questions to staff and it would have worked if not for those pesky parents that keep showing up to hold her accountable tonight is another clever trick by Rawlings but just so we're clear from a legal standpoint you can't change a board policy after you
137violate it and then claim you never violated it you have to agendize the budget discussion re and revote which really isn't that hard unless you simply can't admit that you're wrong the other option is to be Mr dill and claim that the board did none of these things Mr Dill this is your last board meeting in carlbad and this is beneath you the pawe parents are here tonight to see whether you will admit that your response to the brown act complaint was wrong don't let this be your last action on behalf of carlbad unified the kids and the parents and the community in carlbad and Powe deserve better next speaker is Athena [Music] Runner I'm Athena Runner and I do live in the district I also work for the district when considering the proposed revision
138to board policy 3100 I urge the board to also consider some of the backstory in regarding the 5% economic uncertainty reserves there's a long history in cusd and it involves trusty Rawlings in her strict opposition to maintaining a 5% healthy Reserve she has opposed this policy for years and she has voted against the entire budget almost every single time precisely because of those 5% reserves as Scott Davidson went through last meeting she clearly violated the brown act and made you all complicit in it and neither the board nor the Acting Superintendent addressed it during the meeting and you should have you should know as a result this action is to remedy that illegal action and it shouldn't stand this agenda item now before you is brought by the same person who sets the board agenda
139and created the violation so she seeks to remedy the violation and get what she's wanted all along which is to reduce the reserves So based on this alone I ask that you not approve this if you want to have a discussion about um remedying reserves reducing that amount come back and do it another time where you can have a healthy open dialogue about it and not in this underhanded manner thanks trustees are there any questions trustees are there any questions just be um I have several actually so um in whenever you want to okay um at the last meeting Mr Dill indicated that he would not recommend changing the reserves at this time when I asked him was staff asked to prepare any additional information in advance of this request now that they had now
140that they had more time to prepare no um at the last just Beth do you have another question yes I do okay are there other folks that have questions ENT Steve forth were you were able to ask these questions prior to the meeting I did send a lot of my questions in yes and are they noted here in our in our public docum I have some new questions too thank you if you could ask those new questions that'd be great thank you them nowk you thank you um so at the last meeting Mr Dill indicated that certain portions of the reserves were already designated for discretionary use by the superintendent and it appears that staff did this in August on their own after my multiple requests were rejected by the board last spring to bring
141in extra help for our secondary schools how much do we currently have available in the unrestricted reserves that we could use next year for something like lcap priorities well ultimately uh you know and this is not my recommendation but you know the all of the reserves above the minimum reserves are you know always available now not the recommendation to spend down to to the minimum um but when the budget is developed you look at the revenue that's coming in and do you have enough to cover uh all of the priorities for next year one carrying on your existing programs and if you have a dip in revenue or you have a one-time need in resources you can look at at any of the reserves and ultimately it is the board's decision whether to do that
142or not um in order to meet the needs for a sub sequent school year trusty Amry uh to follow up with that so the 5% is um the proposed 3% in the previous um standing 5% is the minimum what current percentage do we have in the restricted unrestricted reserves uh you know I knew I should have looked up that number uh should have uh run that but um we're in the highs currently for unrestricted uh Reserve uh compared to our expenditures and um as a followup to that does that include the 3% mandatory by the state or is that total discretion that's all in yes than you unrestricted Reserve compared to total expenditures thank you other questions trustee emry um can you explain further to me because I I new please please state it again
143or in a different way if you could um the request uh about the stabilization fund to move from there um was essentially a shuffling of savings correct like from one savings account to another so is that that was my understanding that we were moving it from the stabilization which is not the reserves into tell me explain to me again what happened to the stabilization fund sure when uh when you look at the budget uh you have uh a beginning balance in your reserve you add in the revenue you subtract out the expenditures and you have an ending balance then you categorize those components of the ending balance so it's not one account or another it's we have this pot of money what do we call all of these different dollars inside of the pot so
144the state requires a minimum 3% uh of your of unrestricted reserves for your total expenditures this board has set that at 5% and so we maintain that 5% Reserve uh above that there could be assignments that uh that exist where we could say we want to set some dollars aside for instructional materials uh we could do that uh above assignments are commitments commitments are board designations of dollars that they want to set aside uh the primary one that we have is the uh it's it shows as a stabilization Arrangement but that's what we called the basic Aid Reserve back the last time uh Carl's Bad was a basic Aid District they set dollars aside to smooth out any rough spots during the transition in and out of basic Aid so those dollars have been carried
145there uh there's other assign or commitments that exist within the ending balance that unrestricted ending balance such as uh uh uh technology Reserve so if we have a big technology purchase in a year when we don't have the funds to do that we can make sure that we have technology refreshment uh we have one for uh fluctuations in retirement M uh rates we have one for band reserves we have one for uh instructional materials so that we can continue to operate in those years and have dollars specifically designated to use for those purposes that are committed inside of the unrestricted ending balance so if that makes sense it's not one account or another it's all in the unrestricted ending balance but we designate uh the reserves for different purposes sorry so of a pot I
146know we usually refer to those as different pots so is follow yeah follow up with that is that stabilization part of that High Teens percentage that you're referring to yes okay so with the talk of the stabilization it would just push it back into a different pot within the so you know mathematically If all we're doing is renaming the dollars inside the unrestricted ending Reserve um you know all you're doing is changing the name of that you're not moving the money it's you're just calling it something different or you're putting in the case of committing it it actually puts more restrictions on the dollars um because it it requires board action to decommit unless you're using it specifically for the for the purposes that the board set aside um when it is in the reserve
147for economic uncertainties uh it's available to respond quickly to a sudden uh a sudden need that occurs uh if it's in the unappropriated amount it's also there that could be used uh without dipping into the committed uh unrestricted reserves as well trusty word so with that 5% Reserve how um how often have we dove into that because of economic uncertainty I we've not had to do it in a current year uh but you also have to maintain that into the out years as well so there have been times U probably the last time the board saw us approaching that was right at the beginning of the pandemic uh when there were proposals for cuts to proposition 98 which would have led to cuts to education funding uh it would not have resulted in going into
148the reserves in the current year but I I'd have to look back there might have been uh getting dangerously close to that uh in the second or third year out um because of reserves that might have been necessary to sustain stain programs during during that time uh ultimately that did not pan out but uh but it could have been in the future under the assumption that was there at the time okay however we we didn't necessarily go into that right because we did get a lot of support through the state and yeah okay and then I just so is that a followup yes followup sorry um so even beyond that prior to 2019 I don't know when you came Eric but just want to make sure that we're spending our taxpayers dollars for students the
149in the time that we receive those monies so how um going far back do you know if we've ever dipped into that Reserve I don't know going backwards in a perfect world dollars in would equal dollars out every year okay uh but we don't live in a perfect world so sometimes uh we have more Revenue than we spend and we put that aside for the times when we have less Revenue than what we need and in those times when we have the budget surplus that's what ends up in what we call the reserves and so and those dollars are there to smooth out the Peaks and valleys um while still delivering a robust educational program okay Tristy C so the intention of those funds is not in fact to be supportive of students who are
150contributing those dollars it's not a fluid thing it's to keep that that for reserves do we know what year the board initiated that 5% oh I do not remember around I think I just heard 2015 it's been it's been I was a parent in The District in 2006 when we had to lay off a lot of teachers because we did not have enough resources to trusty CC that's for discussion we're in questions now so okay thank you uh any other questions Justa bef okay um IND consens to lower minimum Reserve eties from the Bo's current standard of atast 5% of the state minimum re% in order to reflect this change in future budget reports Aion is necessary so um Mr B our attorney came and gave us training and said that any time of consensus
151whether it's FS or head nod it's an action it's a vote so since our action to change the reserve amount was not on the agenda didn't that violate the gr that would be a question for Mr baze or for legal counsel um what I would say is um the the action one of the actions that was taken that night was to approve the first interim budget report as presented there was no modific a to that and that was as uh the report as of October 31st and so that report did go in as presented to the public and and into uh the CDE ultimately the as of right now we've not made any changes uh because we don't affect those changes and Report those out until we prepare the second interim budget report so we've
152not actually done any of this work yet um it will be done before or uh or as we we hit the January 31st cutof and then it would would be reflected assuming all of this happens it would be reflected in the report that you see on March 12th so it's not actually occurred yet uh and so that's why this action is necessary in order for us to do that trusty Amry follow up to that has any action been taken to the reclassification of that stabilization fund not at this time it would be done for uh for the second inter budget report and so that would not be included in this meeting but would need to be in a subsequent the budget policy yeah the budget will the next budget report is the second interim budget
153report and so assuming that these changes uh are made that would be reflected in the second inter budget report which would be the budget as of January 31st followup yes trusty So based on the fact that we had a consensus uh and that is equal to a vote so that was an action on an information discussion item is that correct correct correct so you are saying that an action took place but it hasn't been implemented yet is that correct correct okay so if we took action on an information discussion item that the public wasn't informed that we were going to be taking action on isn't that a brown act violation again you're going to have to ask an attorney uh attorney for that you know what I will say is that you know we have
154we still have two other three other discussions to happen here there's this tonight as first read if there's a second read of this it'll be a second opportunity for that discussion and then on March 12th there will be another discussion of the of the district's budget which these changes may be reflected in uh and so that would be another opportunity for public discussion follow up sure my understanding though is that we were not allowed to take action so that is a brown act violation and so we should not be revising this board policy right now we should be curing and correcting the brown act violation that took place at that meeting so again that would be a question for our our legal council this is an item specifically for amending this policy right and so
155that is the item that's being discussed this evening I have a followup sure um uh Mr dill and uh Mr Schmidt um did I discuss um my um my request that I wanted to make at the meeting prior to the meeting and did you give me any information other than you could bring that forward as written I'm trying to think of what the discussion might have been I don't recall the discussion nor do I you didn't have my uh my email um that I provided to say I mean I could produce the email but you're saying you didn't receive an email from me saying that this is what I would like to make a request for during the first interim budget discussion if there was I don't recall responding back can we have one conversation
156please thank you I may have received notice I don't recall responding back to it okay Mr Schmid nor do I okay other questions yeah just Beth okay so changing the board policy that we violate after the fact doesn't fix the brown act violation but a correction could be as simple as voting to direct staff to undo the direction we gave at the last meeting to direct a portion of our reserves into the new lcap budget correct that could be done and so you're saying we have not contacted legal counsel at this point even though we received a complaint again because of the this was in the context the the discussion that that occurred last month was in the context of the budget and was discussing specific line items within the first interim budget uh report
157we felt that was consistent with discussing the budget uh and again the effects of that discussion and consensus have not actually occurred yet and won't occur until March 12th other questions okay um I have one more Jus be um is it possible to consult with our legal counsel before bringing this board policy before the uh the board right now well not before right now because we're at right now um but it could be before second reading and adoption yes we can do that Mr Dill um did you um provide a response to the um to uh parties that were complaining about this incident yes and did you um believe that we needed to uh provide any type of um pause or um or cure and correct at that time when you responded in my op
158opinion the that this next step uh was in reaction to that uh vote uh and ultimately the the next action in response to that would be on March 12th for the second interim budget report when the changes actually would be made prior to January 31st and and presented to the board any other questions other questions um I have a motion to approve board policy she has I didn't see your question I didn't see your hand go ahead so in effect we are just bifurcating the whole process of having the community involved in whether or not we even bring this to a discussion we're saying we're going to vote on it at in in March and we just don't care what our constituents desires are here the questions are for staff at this time if you're
159under we can have that conversation during discuss care what the community's interests are here because we're going with with trusty Rawlings uh interests well this item is in relation to that action so this has been put forward to the public as part of this agenda that the board was going to have a discussion uh about changing the board policy to lower the reserve um so this part of you know this part has been noticed for the specific discussion and uh board policies typically are brought for a first and second reading so this would be the first chance uh uh for discussion on this amendment to the board policy February meeting would have a second chance for that discussion and you know furthermore if if people had opinions about this action uh it could also be
160discussed at the March 12th meeting as the second interim budget report is brought forward justif so I just want to confirm that we did not appropriately notify the public that we were going to be taking a vote on the discussion item of that evening is that correct well the discussion the the the budget item was or the board item was for uh review of the first interim budget report um I know often uh boards will have discussion and give direction to staff related to items that are contained within agenda items including the budget report um you know often we will have discussions of can we add more staff could we add a full day kindergarten proposal you know those are all budget related items that often are discussed and not detailed specifically um so you
161know discussing the level of reserves would be something that someone would could consider would be up for discussion that that specific vote uh was not mentioned uh but there could have been other proposals that would have been made ultimately as I mentioned it's the first interim budget report for the period ending October 31st which was approved and subsequent changes to the budget get uh accounted for before January 31st reported to the board on March 12th other questions may have a motion to approve board policy 310 and approve as a first reading I will move to do that second thank you any discussion trusty rth trusty yeah and forgive me because you know this this uh meeting when this initial budget was brought up um my understanding was and I could be wrong new to the
162process here fully admit that we were discussing the budget in thumbs up for as is and my understanding was that the discussion was more questions posed that could be brought up at the later date and I'm hearing now that that was perceived differently um so I'm just clarifying did we all think that our thumbs were to um actually be a change of well to clarify I mean there was a it was a three three trustees um I made the request and I did request from staff I Prov I said I was going to going to do a governance request during the first interim to make these particular changes since that's the appropriate time to do so m um to make the request but again it you know I I'm relying on staff to say is
163this appropriate is this and I had an email that I I I basically had my questions for for the meeting and then I also had um and uh and I asked uh Mr Schmid to say you know are we good with my request is everything fine absolutely no problem you know are there any um uh you know Mr Dill do you understand my request because I was very specific I said this object code this object code would move to this object code and there's no questions of me whether this was appropriate or not or what have you and then three board members said yes we want to do that and then um uh but again my understanding was it was not going to happen immediately we would have to make staff would have to provide
164the appropriate um the the appropriate um ways to make that happen and so that's where um uh but I did do the request yes so so let me clarify my question because my question was when we were approving the budget we were approving it as is and thumbs up to the future bring a governance request forward is that it was a request at the meeting okay it was a request at the meeting to um to direct staff to make these changes as as we go into like second interrup wasn't like an immediate change so yes it was a way to direct that trusta be I have the transcript here and you directed us to do it now you did not ask for it to be done at a later date you said to do it
165now but it wasn't done I mean again it wasn't done that way I mean staff is going to know the direction right directed staff I didn't do it three trustees did this three trustees so a board majority be clear that the vote took place that three trustees agreed with you to do it now it was not at a later date I have the transcript in and and again I made the request I asked staff is this an appropriate is this an appropriate request and uh staff agreed that yes we will we are able to do we are able to accommodate the board's request and that and that's but again it didn't happen that immediately I mean staff is going to make those determinations uh to to accommodate the request that was made by the board
166majority yes was it only was it only three yes it was a 3-2 vote any other discussion no and in terms of um Allison or trustee Emory's um clarification I think I understood it the same way too where we're moving some of that money over but it's all in the same big pot doesn't necessarily mean that we're going to you know spend it all well one of the things I want to say is that we 100% and that was part of the discussion is that if the if the board elcap priority is to is to keep that money as a stabilization then that's what would happen to it so it's not like there's um there's not as if that money just goes away or is spent on something different the board the board as a
167whole at least the majority would need to decide how that money is spent so it's not like you know and again I didn't ask act independently I'm unable to act independently so I just want to make that you know very clear and I specifically um you know I have the email where I made the request I said I was going to make the request is this a to understand my request and everything was yes we understand yes you know it's fine trust for Beth but you've been on the board longer than any of us so you know you know the process you know that it was an in information discussion item and you clearly asked for a vote to give direction to staff on something that the public wasn't informed that they were going to
168be making we weren't informed that we were going to be making you surprised us and from what we're hearing from people who've been following this for many years is this is not the first time that it's happened so can you explain to me why you want to move the reserves from 5% to 3% well number one um uh this was that board direction to move to 5% and it was done in a very similar manner um to actually it was staff we want you to update the board you we want to move the we want to go from a 3% to a 5% and and then the board policy was brought back to the full board and to make that change now I would like to free up those dollars so we can spend them
169on in the classroom so for interim teach for uh intervention teachers for um full day kindergarten if it's needed or what have you um and to be honest with you I mean we heard that you know during the pandemic I was the only Advocate to say we need to use some of this money in order to open schools and that discussion happened you know several years ago and the rest of the board didn't want to do it and I the comment that I made at that time was if this isn't an econom economic uncertainty I don't know what is and there was no comment so again I've wanted to say that we in my view we need to use these funds in our classroom because as Mr Dill has said as well um we have
170a technology Reserve we still have a line item in the budget for for technology so this is just extra money just in case so we have that we have um instructional materials we have all kinds of other reserves and we're in the High Teens as far as reserves go so what I'm saying is that I think families want to see that money in the classroom and not in a bank account so that's how I see about trusty emry um I hear a lot of what's been done and you know what's in past practice but I'm wondering what can we do to unify going forward um because all we can do right now is do its best from from now on so um are are you proposing anything at this there's a motion in a second
171on the floor so it's we can't really change the motion I'm I'm asking for what would be be within the realm of um not looking backwards and forwards if there's something perhaps I'm not considering okay well looking forward we're looking at uncertainty we're moving into basic Aid and I asked staff directly would you recommend that we do this and the answer was no so I don't I that to me that's very clear and that's why I voted no to Cathy you know you're saying that sorry excuse me trusty Rawlings um you're saying that a decision was made to increase the reserve to 5% the same way you're asking to decrease it was it done at an appropriate time was it agendized this is the problem if this was not agendized and that is the brown
172act violation well I disagree that this is violation and I'm sure that you can you know um uh you could take it to court and find out I guess um or somebody could um and so um but from what I'm what I'm saying and I don't exactly know it was but it was definitely during a budget discussion it was definitely during one of the budget time frames when we're asked to um when we're asked to uh you know make the decisions and approve the dollars to be spent and how they're going to be spent so I do know it was definitely done during a um budget discussion and we do talk about the budget throughout the year so there is a more appropriate time my point is that wasn't the appropriate time because the public
173wasn't notified we weren't aware it we were surprised by it and we were not prepared to as you can see our fellow trustees are not even clear as to what they even voted on so I am not comfortable at all moving forward with changing board policy um and I think we need to get legal counsil to weigh in on what happened justy what so I'm clear what I voted on to make that clear but um so I'm I'm curious is your concern more of the how it was how it all flushed out or are you concerned at all about our taxpayer money that has been sitting in there where we haven't really touched it at all for years and haven't utilized it in the classroom so are you are you still do you think like
174being able to access that money is is okay but just the process in which we got here is not okay um trusty Ward I have problems with both things okay so we found money I asked in three or four meetings for money for secondary last year okay last Academic Year I was denied each time then in August all of a sudden poof money came out of nowhere and we found money for our middle school students that did not come from reserves so we can find the money when we need to and as as far as I know our teachers are feeling supported they have the raises that they wanted I really believe that trusty Rawlings is wanting this money for raises not so much classroom and if we really were worried about it we would
175be reducing class size and that would increase the number of teachers we would need but that's not what we're talking about we're talking about increased salaries so I I I have not said that I have not said that trth and I will say too um just to be clear a board can lower class sizes with money if we have it committed towards dollar so we want to change the name of it to class size reduction I'm all in um trust you emry I I just think you know going forward I I want to make clear that I too agree that the classroom dollars need to be um utilized I think that we need to apply it towards our students but and to be clear what um um Mr D was saying is that just because
176we recategorize and I'm not saying that is not necessarily a free Bill to spend um I do think you know I can see both sides to I fully agree that we need to be transparent with all of our committee I also believe that there was a lot of things said in the um the thought exchange that says you know there's a lot of things that we could do for our students who are currently there to help them um that doesn't even mean that we need to even touch that 5% it sounds like you know we have um money above that and in places that we could still utilize so um you know I I see it both ways and I think that maybe we could um move forward with some uh ideas and maybe flush
177out both Solutions trusty for Beth so to answer the other part of your question trusty Ward the timing was inappropriate so yes that does bother me we did it in the wrong way so we have to stay we have to follow rules that's why we have them and so we can have an appropriate discussion at a designated time when it is fully agendized we are all prepared staff is fully prepared and our public are prepared that is the problem here and I I feel very strongly about it and we we are all responsible for it so I'm going to call for the question as we discussed with Robert's Rules so um uh the motion on the floor is to um approve uh 3100 as a first reading Miss Garcia please call for the vote student
178board representative Eli yes trusty COC absolutely not trusty Emory no trusty BBV no trusty Ward yes trusty Rawlings yes motion fails two to three thank you our we now yes yes yep e e e okay okay we are back in session we have order please thank you um we now move on to item 7.6 resolution number 22425 electrification trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Mr Dill thank you uh this is uh revisiting a resolution that was brought forward in uh 2024 uh that's been revised and has been brought back and uh it sets aspirational goals uh for different actions that would uh help reduce climate change and also um promote electrification at all of our school sites the district's done a number of things over the last
179few years uh beginning with the passage of measure HH uh We've installed solar panels at eight of our school sites uh we are now adding solar and battery storage at on any of our new buildings that are over 2,000 square ft uh we have uh installed inst LED lighting through our modernization projects we've been replacing old HVAC units with more efficient ones we've actually have electrified some of our schools already um we've replaced gas fired units with heat pumps uh when we've had the ability when we've gone through uh either at end of life or uh or through our modernization projects we've reduced our water usage and and lowered our utility uh costs uh at carlbad high with the work that we did on the cooling system there uh we actually last year started uh
180replacing our maintenance and Warehouse Fleet with electric vehicles so uh I think we're now up to six uh electric vehicles so we are in the process of of doing that as well uh this resolution would set a number of aspirational targets for us to continue to do that work over the next 10 years as we move through sites either uh through modernization new construction or through through um uh through replacing equipment through end of life and is very similar to to the actions that I discussed there so uh I'm going to leave it at that and turn it over to trustee Rawlings uh for public comment and questions and discussion thank you uh this is time for public comment and uh we have received nine blue cards uh when I uh when I call your
181name uh please come to the podium state your name and indicate whether or or not you live within the boundaries of the school district you will have 2 minutes and 15 seconds we will have the timer on the screen and your mic will be muted when your time is expired the first speaker is Henry Davidson hello my name is Henry Davidson I am a student at Sage Creek High School and I'm here just to express my dissatisfaction with the electrification resolution today you will vote on this resolution and yet is obvious from reading it that you've yet to put in any planning or foresight for this resolution the only thing this resolution succeeds in is being vague and unclear with your goal of 100% clean energy today you admitted that no analysis was done on
182the price of total electrification in this you claimed that there would be only a 2% increase in electric bill but neglected the fact that the C energy lines raised the rates twice in the past 2 years due to increasing cost today you claim that electrification would bring safe and healthy learning environments to our schools either through ignorance or malice you overlook the realities of these environment saving measures you overlook the toxic chemicals that lie inside solar panels you overlook the costly and harmful Mets that make the batteries of electrical Vehicles you overlook the cost of having to replace these EV batteries every 10 years or less and they can't be recycled so once their life is done they will sit in a in a landfill poisoning the earth below today this board will pass this
183resolution because those who propos the resolution have the majority and confidence to overlook the well-being of students in this District this board will waste money so they can feel good about themselves and claim they did their parts two years ago this District's funding began a decline as it was finally held accountable for decline of its student population tutoring hours and classes were cut when students were in dire need of them because the district pan to cut its budget due to its irresponsible management all those cuts are still here today today you will yet again ignore the actual needs of students so you can be self-righteous about saving the environment the purpose of the school district is not to save the environment to help students learn if you truly care about the students you will invest
184in their education so that they can succeed academically thank you for your time thank you um next speaker is Kirsten Li Linco hope I got that right hi my name is Kirsten Lim limo I live in the carlbad boundary and I am currently a junior at Carl B high school I'm co-president and founder of my school's Ocean Club where we promote ocean conservation through various activities including Beach cleanups and educational lunch meetings I care about climate change because I care about ensuring a healthy sustainable future there are more than 2,000 students at my school and this is where most of us spend the majority of our time we deserve to rece receive an education in a clean healthy and carbon neutral environment Carl's Bad unified should take this opportunity to to secure climate safe futures
185for their students and Inspire other school districts to take action I have talked to students involved in Ocean Club Green club and the AP environmental science class offered at my school we all care about our planet and the environment we all hope for a better more sustainable future with this in mind we please urge you to take action thank you thank you next speaker is Piper Murphy hi I'm Piper Murphy and I live inside the Carl's bed boundaries um I'm the president of green Club at carlb high school and in this club we provide Environmental Education to students and attempt to create a healthier and more sustainable environment by doing GRE by doing Beach cleanups and having lunch meetings I believe that you should vote Yes on this proposition because as a student I know
186how much time I spend and other students spend at school which is over 1,000 hours in a year and so it is very important that there is good air quality inside our classrooms and by supporting this resolution we're prioritizing a climate safe future electrifying our schools is a coste effective way to reduce emissions lower energy bills and invest more funds into the classroom so I think you should vote yes thank you thank you next speaker is Lexi Han hi my name is Lexi Han and I'm a junior at carlbad high school I live in the carbed boundaries I'm part of Ocean Club and the president of animal advocacy Club I believe that we have a duty to take care of the planet for future generations and the well-being of their environment the fires in California
187this year are the worst they have ever been because of climate change change hurricanes are stronger the global temperature continues to increase and more species are going forever and extinct we must do what we can to limit our negative impact on the environment and for the health of our planet children and the species that we share this world with this is our community we decide what we put into the environment and it is our responsibility to make conscious and care careful decisions my peers and I urge you to vote Yes to Electrify the CD district and reduce fossil fuel use thank you thank you and I would like to remind the students that they can get community hours community credit hours so um you could have that signed off um uh uh later on uh
188next speaker is Linda Daniels hi I'm Linda Daniels I've lived in carlbad for 12 years good evening superintendent good evening trustees um I'm a member of the San Diego building electrification Coalition and in particular the schools Committee of which many of them are here tonight at Serena pela is in charge of with the San Diego building electrification Coalition what we want to do is just save the planet I mean and the kids are the important thing the kids have to have clean air in order to breathe okay and what Mr Dill has been doing over the last few years of the end of life and making things electric and helping things I appreciate it and I'm going to miss his forethought and miss his his Forward Thinking about this I really appreciate it um a
189lot of you have seen me over the last two years coming here I haven't been around lately because I just had both my shoulders replaced the right one and then two months later later the left one so I'm just in physical therapy trying to raise my arms now so that I haven't been able to do very much okay um the resolution that UC uh carlbad uh Unified School District has before you is very similar to the ones that the um San Diego Unified School District has passed and the Sweetwater um Unified School District has passed okay so um Vista is going to pass one pretty soon I would like Carl's bat to do theirs before Vista so we get ours passed for that your schools are um almost all solarized right now and uh we
190just want to finish the last few and since Proposition two passed on the ballot in November there's matching funds now for you to apply for to get the last of your schools put Soler on okay um I only have 30 seconds left so I have much to say here Green Schools help to create jobs while protecting our environment the time is right to remember energy uh in schools is important and electric energy um by replacing gas uh and HV H HV haac systems with solar um was called heat pumps which I've done I walk the talk my whole home is electrified I have an induction stove heat pump water heater and heat pump HX system and I'm on my third electric car vote yes thank you next speaker is um Kylie tle [Music] good evening
191trustees my name is Kaye teagle and I reside in carlbad I also graduated from Sage Creek High School in 2023 tonight I wanted to speak to you guys and also urge urge you to vote Yes and support resolution number 21242 5 in the matter of electrifying the carlbad Unified School District to bring clean air and healthier schools in carlbad as you may know fossil fuels produce carbon dioxide and increase greenhouse gases which is a pollutant in our environment worsening the climate crisis cusd has already installed solar and 50% of our dist District's campuses which is great progress and continuing to do so and invest in our future of our staff and students clean energy and electrification is also good economic policy that will save money for our district in the long run the environment is
192vital to our lives and should be protect protected by all of us whether whether it's a walk to unwind or dropping off your kid at school cleaner air in C USD would improve daily lives in our district please take action for a climate and a better future for generations to come by vote voting yes on resolution number 21-24 25 thank you guys thank you next speaker is Elena gly hello my name is Elena Gilly and I'm urging the board to approve the resolution to Electrify Carlsbad Unified School District I'm a student at La Hoya high school and in 2023 I advocated for my School District San Diego Unified School District to pass a similar resolution which passed unanimously electrification will benefit students both now and in the future electric buses and efficient heat pumps equipped
193with Advanced filtration systems will reduce air pollution and incur fewer operating costs than fossil fuel-based Alternatives all while mitigating schools carbon Footprints schools have a responsibility to prepare us for our future not endanger it and the climate crisis has an impact on our future that can no longer be ignored we know the science we know what needs to be done greenhouse gas emissions need to be reduced across all sectors schools included with this resolution cusd can take a crucial step to protect students from asthma today and climate catastrophe tomorrow furthermore I know firsthand that electrification sends a clear message that the district stries to safeguard students Futures and Elevate their voices green job curricula will prepare students to tackle the world's greatest challenges and Achieve job security and by listening to the student voices calling
194for a just and sustainable future the board is empowering the next generation of leaders thank you thank thank you next speaker is Paige Deo good evening trustees I'm Paige dinino um with this resolution you have the opportunity to set a high standard for this district and become a real leader in addressing climate change and a model for our student population many of they're here our building contribute about 30% of our greenhouse gas emissions and we should take whatever reasonable steps we can move can do to move away from natural gas which also as you've heard contributes to poor indoor air quality the steps outlined in the resolution are reasonable for instance new construction should be all electric which not only can be done in an economically beneficial way as demonstrated by two housing projects in
195carlbad that are all electric including some affordable housing uh but is also mandated by the state to be cost effective I repeat it has to be cost effective for new construction this also avoids unnecessary gas lines that may become obsolete in the future retiring gas powered appliances and Equipment as proposed at the end of their effective lifetimes is an easy way to remove gas infrastructure as well without imposing additional Financial burden on the district as a former CHS science teacher I always lamented the fact that we didn't offer very much in the way of alternative career career training for students not planning on attending four-year College by developing a career path in renewable energy and potentially partnering with our local community colleges for training the future electricians and technicians in this field you address the
196needs of a not in significant and yet often Overlook portion of our student body that could benefit by this training so please adopt this resolution thank you thank you next speaker is Serena pela hi good evening my name is Serena pela I'm a policy Advocate at the nonprofit climate action campaign where our mission is to create a pollution-free future where everyone can Thrive when we en Vis this Collective future we see students and schools at the center as Community hubs schools should be healthy spaces with clean air and free of dangerous fossil fuels electrification is an important solution to ensure the district is providing a safe healthy and inspiring environment as aligned with its Mission given the district's significant investments in solar as mentioned going all electric will create real cost savings that can be
197put back into the classroom since parts of the bond money are already required to be used for infrastructure replacing existing gas systems with all electric Alternatives at the time of burnout will be highly coste effective plus matching funds from prop 2 make this even more feasible the impacts of the climate crisis are not challenges for the future but are at our doorstep now as the fiscal impacts are evaluated today we cannot minimize the cost of inaction as we look to our neighbors in LA where over 20 school districts have faced closures due to the poor air quality from the fires leaving over 700,000 students out of class this is an opportunity to not just protect air quality but be fiscally smart and plan for long-term savings that can go back into classrooms to teachers and
198to students this is a teachable moment for students on whether or not the district is committed to protecting their future as we owe it to them to create cleaner healthier schools and communities that are resilient and sustainable as you also received over 40 emails in support of the resolution in addition to the speakers tonight we urge you to support and vote yes thank you thank you trustees do you have any questions trusty Ward so what are um can you share with me what the benefits are from prop 2 is there yeah prop 2 is uh our first Statewide school facilities bond which was passed in November uh it's it's rep it's basically replenishing the fund uh up at the state level that does provide matching funds for new construction modernization and and hardship programs uh
199we currently are working on uh we have a proposal out on the street uh for a new master plan which is a requirement of uh qualifying for prop two matching funds um so that we can make sure that uh any of our future projects that we have met all of the requirements for us to apply for those State dollars um and really it is a project by project school by school analysis that you have to do to determine what you would qualify for so I can't tell you today uh what any project would would Garner in matching um currently we're working on uh a little over $6 Million worth of applications uh for measure HH projects uh that have already occurred uh so we're working on on doing that um and uh we are going
200to include um as an add-on component of that Master Plan um to evaluate electrification should this be the direction of the board um so that we could eventually do a feasibility study for each of our future projects to do that um so we'll meet all of those requirements and and we'll we'll be qualified for that um but the one caveat that I always say about State money is don't spend it until you have it um so with uh with any of projects that we have going forward we will be frontloading it with the capital funds that we have on hand applying for the State dollars and then uh as those dollars come in that provides us some additional resources for future capital projects that we otherwise you know would have had available from measure HH
201had we got the match at the same time we were doing the project so um so it's really would be seed money for future projects once we get reimbursement and you get in line uh and you have to work through the state allocation board process sometimes it takes years uh before you do get that but uh the good news is it passed it's there um $9 billion available Statewide and the governor proposes to issue about $1.5 billion dollar of prop Tu Bonds in budget proposal okay great other questions trusty bth I have a followup to trusty Ward's question um so the prop two money is it being earmarked for certain districts that need more funding than other districts property taxes can you explain some of that yeah it is it does change the formulas uh
202compared to Prior uh Statewide bonds and so there will be some prioritizations of District with a higher count of low-income students uh so that will go into our application and it will create the priority of where we land in line uh for reimbursement that's why I say don't count on those dollars until you actually get them because you may be waiting in line quite a while is that a followup It is Well to clarify something you said you mentioned something about the HH um Bond measure monies are you trying to go after monies that we need to complete projects for measure our bond like I'm just a little confused because we still have projects that we're concerned we're not going to be able to to complete is that correct that is correct uh due to
203cost escalation that's happened over the last few years uh and the board will be having a discussion on this in the spring of uh of future project costs versus available funds uh and we were're on the verge of issuing our final $87 million uh under measure HH and that's going to fuel the remaining phase of of projects um and we should look at it only in the context of we have $87 million remaining and allocate those dollars now should we receive some of those State dollars for applications that are already in the pipeline that adds to the amount of available funds that we could use towards uh towards measure HH projects or or the projects that we either the cost has become too high or we need those extra dollars to to get across the
204Finish Line um you know but but again look at the dollars that we have in hand hope for the reimbursement at some point down the line and then we can use those dollars um as the board sees fit so one more follow sorry yes so just to clarify again so the monies that you're hoping to get by applying for prop two matching funds we're hoping to use those to offset some of the the building costs that have escalated and so we're still committed to those um projects and we hope to be able to complete them with the idea that we might get this money from the state is that correct well we we don't have the money right so I know that right we we won't issue contracts for projects if we don't have the
205money in hand so uh you know that will be a consideration from this point forward actually anytime you have a a bond draw you're looking at the dollars available versus the projects you want to do um we have a long list of projects and uh and we're getting into our final phase so there will have to be a determination of how do we allocate the remaining dollars again if we start to receive some uh State reimbursement we can add to the available funds on hand and that can change the consideration that the board would have in issuing contracts for the remaining projects I have a followup to that as well um uh with our phase five pieces um isn't it within the bond to say that we would have to have state matching funds in
206order to move forward on any phase five project and then the other pieces I don't know if you know the answer to this but um uh don't we have additional solar in Phase five uh yes it was it's defined as you know remaining sustainability projects in in Phase five I I don't believe it was uh Phase 5 was contingent upon receiving State dollars that we would only do them if If We Had State dollars it was you know these were the final projects that should we have money remaining we would look towards phase five to complete those projects whether it was remaining HH dollars or State dollars that came in over the course of the bond program it really was as funds are available we would consider those projects trusty Emory uh and just a
207clarification a resolution is not necessarily commitment of funds but more of a commitment of beliefs and direction and then the funds will be determined as those projects come up as I read that resolution that is what uh what you are contemplating tonight is uh setting goals and Direction um and any project that we bring forward is going to be on a Case by case basis uh dependent upon the board's priorities and the funds available justy CSC followup so we can change the verbiage in this resolution so that it is clearly indicating that we are not committing to these things by 2025 or 2035 as it states in there but that that is a goal that we would like to accomplish yeah if the board chooses to amend the resolution they can certainly do that tonight
208trusty what so we've done um some pretty significant electrification adjustments already like the solar the electric vehicles and and I know some things that we've done at Jefferson too correct do you think potentially that has saved us um some money I know typically like with solar I mean just because we I have solar at my house um the benefits of it takes time to to happen but do you think potentially um there is a cost savings to that in the future when you go that route yes we we've certainly seen a reduction in our utility bills at the at the sites where we do have solar uh and additionally at Aviara Oaks Elementary and Middle we have battery storage that helps us shave uh the rates during the most expensive peak times when we're using
209uh energy during those high peak times we we drop on the batteries so we definitely have seen utility savings the the the beauty of how it works in school districts is you use your Capital funds to install the energy saving uh measures and then you reap the results in the general fund because the general fund pays the utility bills whereas the capital funds pay for the projects and so uh utility savings or dollars that can go back into our operating costs everything from salaries down to services and I have a followup on that um wouldn't it maximize our investment in solar by making more and more things electric since you can't uh get natural gas out of solar panels yeah well yes I mean the more the more power you're producing the less you're buying
210Off the Grid um and so you know it would be a matter of uh how efficient is the electrical equipment that you're putting in compared to the cost of the gas powerered equipment and what the gas rates are as well that would have to be a consideration trusty c i I would like some clarification of what we really are talking about in terms of gas powered things because we live in Southern California I don't think we have a lot of heating that we're really doing in our classrooms and already lighting and air conditioning things are already going to be electrically operated that's a different thing from solar panels and generating that electricity but in terms of they functioning on that and we don't do busing in our districts correct it's my understanding am I correct
211that buses that are utilized for like football teams are contracted out so those are not owned by the District so any kind of busing situation that we have is not included in this resolution and because we don't have busing per se for students in the district vehicles are kind of a limited nutrition services and that kind of thing yeah so to to answer uh two parts of the question uh in terms of our school buildings uh we do have gas powerered heating and water uh water heaters that's that's the main uh and we may uh we we do have some gas powered ovens in our kitchens as well um although we've also been looking at replacing those as well um and so that those are the three areas and we definitely see it on our
212utility bills in the cold months uh because that's when we see the the cost of our gas usage go up uh it was either last year I think it was last winter when we had the spike in natural gas rates that everyone in this room suffered uh the school district did as well and so we definitely saw a huge spike in our utility bills in the 22 23 school year um from that winter uh but during the summer it's it's negligible uh what we're what we're drawing probably just the hot water in some places uh but but not really the heating and if it's the summer we're not using the ovens either and and yes to your point uh the only vehicles that we do own are our maintenance and Warehouse vehicles uh we don't
213operate our own in-house busing and so um you know that really relies on whatever the contractors have have that are going to be our service providers I also have a follow up on that um with when you talked about the year or the the winter where we had um exceeding um gas prices didn't that take away from our savings for that we were getting from the solar it it didn't in that this was pre-existing gas-powered equipment so it just meant that that just cost us more to run that gas powerered equipment it didn't take away from our electrical production and electrical use I guess my point is is that it took away from savings on our total utility bill well we actually had to increase our utility budget that year which is the first time
214in my career I've ever increased my utility budget midy year and it was in reaction to that other questions trusty Amry uh this this was uh just in the resolution that was provided to us as draft language so um I think it's a just a 10-year goal trusty verth um just to clarify there is an impact immediately if we approve this resolution on the last page it states by April 2025 transition to 100% clean energy by enrolling in clean energy alliance's green impact surface service excuse me that is a cost and I believe that that was addressed in our answers that the public received as well as the board and it's estimated to be um approximately two 2% increase the last time it was explored perhaps it's more now but that's about $50,000 so there
215is an immediate cost by April 2025 is that correct that would be the annual cost based off of our previous estimates looking at the different rate tiers offered by the clean energy Alliance and comparing the one that we're currently enrolled in versus the the green impact the last time I looked at that it was a 2% swing so that would that would be a an annual $50,000 increase to our utility budget okay I have I have a question um so Mr D I sent this to you in advance um but I wanted to know about uh board policy 3510 Green School operations where it states in part the Board of Trustees believes everyone has a responsibility to be a steward of the environment and desires to integrate environmental accountability into all School District programs and
216operations and then it goes down to say in developing such strategies and assessing the environmental conditions in District facilities and operations the superintendent or design shall involve all staff all levels with varying job responsibilities including administrators in selecting and prioritizing strategies the superintendent or design shall give consideration to long-term potential cost savings initial costs feasibility of implementation quality and performance of the product or service Health impacts environmental consideration and potential educational value District strategies may include but are not limited to reducing energy and water consumption and using renewable and Clean Energy Technologies and Alternatives when available and then it goes on to list uh many other things and then it does talk about um electricity and it talks about um vehicles and those types of things can you tell me do we have a strategy
217that has been developed since this was um adopted or was uh initially adopted in 2006 and then again in 2022 that includes some of these items that are in the resolution as is uh yes and and there are numerous strategies that are listed in in that particular board policy and I will say that you know through the business services staff that we do uh strive to accomplish these goals that are that are listed out here um you know we always do look at the most energy efficient um you know I don't want to say appliances but equipment uh when we're making purchases uh things that are both durable and uh and energy efficient um we've we've rolled out a number of recycling um efforts across the district uh as I mentioned with the um with
218the upgrades to the cooling system at um at carlbad high that was a significant water savings and that was the one of the drivers behind uh that particular uh project uh in uh our uh products that we use for cleaning are you know I don't want to say green but they're the the they're the most environmentally friendly that that we can that we can find um we also uh make sure that we're following rules in regards to um pest control and rodent control and that we use methods that are the least toxic uh and you know using any type of pesticides as a method of Last Resort we go through a number of different actions before we decide to to go down that route so we this the district itself uh is been a partner
219with uh the carlbad police department in making sure in promoting ebikes uh in the ebike capital of the world I think as Carl's Bad uh and so as you see the number of students who are safely riding their bikes to school that's been uh as a result of efforts between the district and the the the city of Carlsbad and the police department so I mean we could go down and down we we do uh Buy Local produce which cuts the supply chain distance uh and results in fresher food so we prioritize that as well so if you want to read that that policy we hit everything on there in some way uh and we're always giving that consideration when we're sourcing products or services so would you say this resolution is consistent with board policy
2203510 yes thank you other questions I have two more go ahead just be uh one of the speakers mentioned the affordable housing units two of which were U received funding um does do our schools receive the T same type of funding that an affordable housing unit might receive to help with electrification no those are specifically for housing and so we really look to the the state program um the inflation reduction act did have some funds that were available to public agencies um we didn't qualify because we weren't far enough down the line in order to submit applications for that but from time to time uh other agencies will provide dollars to public agencies um the very first solar project that I was involved with in at sandigo that put the solar panels at Lacosta Canyon
221High School uh was as a result of three different Grant programs uh that we cobbled together uh through the state of California that funded that project um so it it's just a matter of timing of if you have your plans ready when the either state or federal government releases funds for which we qualify um and we'll always be looking for those opportunities as well to offset those costs follow up um well it's not yeah I guess it's a followup so I think when we received a lot of emails today and yesterday um over the past couple days and I tried to reply to every single one and my my main concern here is how much is how much is it going to cost to implement this resolution we were provided a different re resolution in
222May Kathy's talking about a board policy which we have achieved we're we're working on this as a district we're moving forward um actually the board policy doesn't include this the resolutions what's the question we're in discussion we're not in discussion yet yeah no my question is um how much is this going to cost this we weren't given an answer yet I've asked people who have are proponents of this resolution how much is this going to cost us yeah so so that will be part of our new master plan is to look at that um if you think about it if we're going in and replacing equipment at end of life we would have had that cost anyway to replace rooftop Heating and ventilation and so then it becomes a matter of what's the cost to
223replace that uh if we're replacing it with a with a heat pump that's going to be uh that's going to draw less power over time than the current unit that may be 25 years old um you know that that cost essentially would have been incurred anyway um the costs of of solar typically are going to have an upfront cost cost but it's going to be based off of whenever we do the project between now and 2035 uh what are the Prevailing rates at that time uh and what would you earn back over that I mean everybody who's installed solar on their home and I almost did but I took this job instead and moved down here uh I was one day away from uh from completely going off the grid and and I came down
224here instead um uh you know you at each time you you go into one of those projects you're doing that uh that assessment and uh you know again in in many cases we're replacing things that we're going to need to over the lifespan of that through our deferred maintenance program and and hopefully through our modernization Pro uh programs as well so I can't give you that number and it's going to be with 16 schools we would really have to go in and and look specifically to say okay what things are are are not electric now that we would have to replace over the next 10 years do we have other projects or would would we have a plan to replace that anyway so we we can get that when it comes time um and those
225were the are the things that we'll be looking at um with this new master plan to help Define what those costs would be so um you know as I sit here um the the facilities costs um you know are going to be apparent and it's going to be a project by project discussion it'll be a project by project budget and assessment that will be brought forward and ultimately approved or disapproved by the board when that time comes um you know but we can say hey look we uh we we design this project with these goals in mind and if the board determines that we don't want to do that or if we say we don't have the money to do this feasibly that's a discussion that can be had at that time this is setting
226goals justy CC so again I think that's why it would be important for us to modify the verbiage because yes it I I appreciate that it's saying at replacement time what it's say say that's for discussion because we make that decision not staff do you have a question for staff yes I'm framing it in a question thank you though for making sure I'm on task we don't know what the cost variance would be between a gas heat pump and a electric gas pump or whatever we understand what I'm saying so it there's going to always be that variance so I appreciate the open-ended um conversation the other thing was I haven't heard any discussion um of other ways of obtaining some of these things to our district and the 22 years have been apparent in
227the district when we've had budget shortages that didn't accommodate things like art programs or uh athletic programs the parents of the district have rallied and and contributed funds that have made these things possible so what are we doing to embrace organizations that are very interested in these uh devices being implemented and having them donate these things to our districts so it doesn't become a financial issue if those opportunities are out there we would C we would graciously accept them uh and and also as I mentioned in projects that I've been involved in the past when I always prefer to use other people's money before ours so uh whether and in in in Santa Clara we use some dollars that were available from the county of Santa Clara we used uh some uh some city of
228San Jose uh grants for some funds that we were doing um so we're always looking to see what is out there that we can that we can apply for and that we qualify for that's that's sometimes the barrier is do we qualify for it uh not is it is it out there or not but again if there's other people's money that can be brought to bear on these we're we're always going to either seek it out or graciously accept it and and trusty trusty COC is that a followup yes it's a followup thank you uh trusty Rawlings um I'm specifically interested from the community members that have expressed interest this is a passion project for them there's lots of organizations out there that are rallying people that are getting involved if those couldn't be organizations
229that bring contributions of funds or equipment to our district outside of things like government grants like private monies if that's out there we'll we'll take it trusty verth in the board policy you referred to um I guess this question is for Eric does the board policy direct us to use um electric rates from local agencies like clean energy Alliance that have a vested interest in resolutions that they're proposing I'm going to scroll through it quickly excuse me the audience needs to stay silent right now thank you we need order please yeah I don't see that in the current policy thank you okay any discuss or wait excuse me um any more questions okay no more questions um may I have a motion to adopt resolution number 22425 exhibit a motion I will second motion made
230by trusty Ward second by truste Emory discussion truste forth I will not be adop uh voting to adopt the resolution the way it is currently written because of unknown costs because of the $50,000 that's affiliated with using the most electri uh expensive electric opportunity that it was you know documented that way by our staff um I'd be more interested in our previous resolution that does not use language that mandates certain things it just it's a little bit you know that we're committed to recognizing things um I think that there is a lot of discrepancy in some some of the statements like climate change is predominantly driven by burning fossil fuels where's the data for that 97% of climate scientists and organizations where's the data for that I just think that um our district is already
231doing a lot as we've discussed we're meeting the board policy the board policy doesn't require what this resolution is saying that you know by April 2025 transition to 100% clean energy by enrolling in clean energy alliance's green impact service which is going to cost us at least what $50,000 I just don't think we need this so I I will not be supporting this but I would make a motion to change it thank you trusty Ward I want to First say that um thank you for sharing all that information Eric and um Mr Dill thank you and um also sharing that these are goals and as each project comes up that's something that we can discuss as a board as well and also that you know we're not going to go in and Electrify everything but
232that as things di down we can replace them to pick the best sustainable solution for the future of our students and you know CU we're not going to be here forever but our kids are and I want to make sure that they're in a environment where they're going to be healthy and safe and um I want to make sure that as a board member that we're able to do that and I think setting these goals are extremely important and I think we know that because we've just seen you know half of uh La burn down so um but thank you for that information and I hope that my colleagues will join me justy Amry yeah I just I I want to clarify if we for some reason don't meet you know 2035 and it's 2036
233or 2037 there is no um punishment or any kind of any of that so these are our lofty aspirations that we want to set examples for students um you know I know that there's concerns with you know both sides I think we can you know come to a conclusion that we need to improve whatever we're doing and should further better Solutions come along we would be amendable to adjust this resolution is that correct I'm not sure I'll be on the board in 10 years so I don't know well I but but that would be the the current board at that time would be they would be able to amend should any new information come to light or any other better um uh possibilities I think ultimately we would want to to shoot for this however
234I mean if if we're not there we're not there right um I also just want to say to that you know I I appreciate all of our constituents that have spoken to us in regard to um this and our students um speaking up about this I think that says a lot and I want to um say that that you know it takes a lot to get up on to that Podium and speak and share especially about their future and how important that is so I want to um just say thank you and value that TR I think all of us feel the same way and we appreciate all especially you young people this we absolutely appreciate your thoughts and I think we can get pretty much Universal support for this if we can change some
235verbiage so that it's explaining as we've said a couple of times tonight that it's articulating more clearly that this is a goal if we're describing it more as this is what we want to do and and not saying we will do this by this date I think that verbiage is what's holding some of us from saying yes let's I I vote Yes on this so if we can pause this and re rework some of the wording you'll have my yes vote but as it is tonight you won't have it thank you um trusty for Beth i' ask excuse me I'd like to ask my fellow trustees are you comfortable with the bullet point on the last page that says by April 2025 transition to 100% clean energy by enrolling in clean energy alliances green impact
236service are you comfortable with that and the costs associated with that I'm very comfortable with that and um I think it's consistent with um our board policy of 3510 as well as um uh being on the board for 10 years um we have consistently been supportive of clean energy and um this is a a uh resolution that was passed back in 2015 when we were looking at um uh 30% rate hikes in electricity um and uh one of the things that says here um now therefore be it resolved that the carlbad Unified School District Board of Trustees supports making it easier not harder for Carl for California school districts to go solar and to maximiz the public benefit of our transition to clean energy so this has been a consistent um uh value of this
237school district for many many years to to to have clean energy and to be generators of clean energy and to support our community in because our solar panels um sit in the summertime generating all kinds of clean energy and that clean energy actually supports the community so you know again this District's been a longtime supporter of clean energy so I'm very comfortable in um in purchasing and being a generator and potentially getting better rates through the ca due to our generation of clean energy during those summer months the breaks and winter uh breaks so yes but our staff told us in our notes and to the public that moving to the most costly electric rate with clean energy Alliance will be in an added expense to the general funds utility budget we are not being
238fiscally responsible by picking the most costly electric rate with clean energy Alliance what why do we have to pick them well again we um I'm comfortable with it um I don't know if the other trustees are if you want to chime in um I'm comfortable with it okay I'm not comfortable with it I'm I'm clear that if we're talking about putting solar panels on all school facilities I'm 100% in 100% with solar panels to to pay for our uh air conditioning and and light our buildings we're adding in all this other stuff about District vehicles and gas it it's it's a whole incrementally uh larger expense and if we could separate these things out it would make it a lot easier for us to all feel comfortable with the decisions I'm going to go ahead
239and call for the question because it's 9:36 and so um and we still have one more big agenda item so uh we've had discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC no trusty Emory yes trusty verth no trusty Ward yes trusty Rings yes motion passes 3 to2 thank you we now move on to item 7.7 superintendent search firm interviews and final selection trustees this is a discussion action item and I now hand it over to Mrs Megan Aras and remember students if you need a community service you can ask uh folks to sign off on that President Rawlings may I step in for a moment and suggest that we you could wait a moment until the folks clear up of course I was just going to ask the board to take action to
240extend the meeting yeah now to superintendent Schmid go ahead thank you president Rollings I'm just uh suggesting we should likely take action because the math looks like we're going to go past 10 o'clock to extend the meeting and we need to do that before 10 o'clock yes certainly we could um I'll make a motion to extend the meeting I'll second it I have a first and a second any uh questions any discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty verb yes trusty Ward yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero okay I will now turn it over to Mrs uh Megan Aris thank you um before I begin I just want to first thank our superintendent search firm representatives for patiently waiting for this agenda item um
241I am going to ask all search firm representatives to kindly excuse yourselves to your assigned conference room um and we will notify you shortly we will begin very soon but we got to get through a few items regarding the questions first and then we'll call you back in esss will be first we're almost [Laughter] there thank you very much um on January 15th the board reviewed proposals to enlist the services of an executive Search firm to hire a super to hire a superintendent and selected three firms to present and be interviewed at tonight's board meeting education Support Services Group mcferson and Jacobson and the Costa group The this agenda presents the opportunity for the board to hear presentations and ask questions of the three prospective firms following the presentations and questions it is respectfully recommended
242that the Board of Trustees select one search firm to conduct the district superintendent search I will now turn it back to president Rawlings for public comment thank you uh this is time for public comment and we have received six blue cards uh when I call your name please come to the podium state your name and indicate whether or not you live within the boundaries of the school district you will have three minutes we will have the timer on the screen and your mic will be muted when your time has expired the first speaker is Mike Richardson [Music] hi um my name is Mike Richardson I do live in Oceanside but I went to all of the Oceanside schools which when I was there in 1940s and 50s were Oceanside Carl's Bad schools when I entered
243High School it was Oceanside carlbad High School there was no Carl no High School in carlbad so I think I can speak with with experience um I've been attending the school board meetings at Ocean oceaniz school board meetings for the last four years or so and um I have to tell you I was shocked that you might cons when I heard you might consider a Julie Vitali as a consultant for helping you choose a superintendent because she has been absolutely just devastated our school district um they're just uh the fact that the fact that she even though she's paid over $350,000 a year uh to to taxpayers in Oceanside who expect her to give them their her 100% she's willing to to uh go uh take on another job and work for you doesn't that
244tell you something about her uh her trustworthiness I could just go on and on about the things that have been done to the Oceanside schools including the fact that in spite of a a 33% decline in student enrollment over the last few years she's building a $40 million headquarters maybe she could do that for you um I I I I just there's just so many reasons she's she's a dishonest corrupt uh person who should not be involved with school with kids period And the fact that you might consider her for that is just un unbelievable um on the second hand on the second thought maybe it'd be a good idea if you hire her for your superintendent because then we could get rid of her and and and and and I'm sure she'd build you
245a $40 million headquarters too thank you thank you uh next speaker is relle babler Carl's Bad trustees my name is relle babbler and I'm a parent to two children at po Unified School District as you narrow down your decision for a search firm I felt that it was important for me to share my experience with the search firm mcferson and Jacobson LLC first po unified hired this firm to do Nationwide superintendent search after our disgraced superintendent maryan Kim Philip was terminated with cause it seemed our board and this firm were on the fast track to hire another um yet many constituents did not trust the current board to hire another superintendent considering they protected someone for months who was blatantly bullying students as you now know they hired Ben Churchill second mcferson and the board
246had a timeline of dates set for the new superintendent's hire this included a survey that everyone including teachers and community members could complete cabinet members and the teachers unions all had meetings with search firm but parents in the community were left out despite being promised a public meeting considering how much this firm was getting paid and the divide in the community created by the scandal of our superintendent's termination a public meeting was heavily warranted additionally mcferon promised a quote a process for the stakeholder groups to submit input to the district concerning all the finalists end quote but the community was not informed of the finalist or allowed to submit input all of this led me to questions something seemed often not complete so I emailed all of my board members and asked them questions they
247referred me to Ben Johnson and Julie batelli the consultants for the mcferson and Jacobson search firm and who were in charge of the new in charge of the search neither of them responded to my questions either even after I followed up then I discovered another big problem the connection between Julie Bali and Ben chill it appears They Know Each Other Well having seen pictures of both of them together at conferences for the past several years and being super attendant in neighboring districts it immediately smells of a conflict of interests unethical and perhaps a heavily biased hiring I now have more questions like did Julie Vitali charge Powe $31,500 to conduct a search when all along she planned to push for her friend Ben Churchill did Vitali close disclose to the PO board that she was
248friends with Ben Churchill did Vitali recruit Ben to apply for the p position or did Ben apply on his own how did Ben find out about the opening does T's current role as superintendent of another North County District biets her toward recommending a particular cand candidate either as a potential ally or as a potential competitor for teachers and staff I'm here to share with you my concerns with the search firm and what appears to be unethical Behavior by Vali and this firm you deserve a search that is transparent and based on community input so that the best candidate is selected as opposed to a friend of the firm running the search thank you thank you Athena Runner hi Athena Runner I live in the district um I would urge the cusd board of tristes to
249reject mcferson and Jacobson as a search um as for the firm for the superintendent search I find it troubling that a sitting superintendent in a neighboring District would be involved in selecting our next superintendent especially given her role in our superintendent's departure it seems questionable for the same firm to profit from both orchestrating a departure and facilitating that replacement I would like to ask the board to select education support services from the two remaining firms while they are a bit more expensive Dr Suzette lovely's experience as the cusd former superintendent gives her a unique insight into our district and what we would be looking for their success in placing superintendant locally in our area is also a big plus to me thank you okay good evening Carl pad School Board my name is petty K
250and an Oceanside uh resident we have many of us here have firstand experience with Julie belli as superintendent from 2018 to 2024 and these are our caveats to you number one we feel her emphasis is not on the students or actually their achievement when under her leadership from 2018 to 24 the standardized test scores um for ELA declined from 45.7 7% to 3965 math went from 3623 to 2929 would you let a surgeon with these failing medical test scores do surgery on you would you like an airline pilot or traffic controller who scored like this to be your pilot or be directing your pilot in 2017 El Camino High School ranked 200th in the state as far as 19 2022 it went down to 67th a drop of 407 spots and these are the facts
251grades are feeling so let um under her Administration emphasizing grading for Equity teachers are pressured to change grades a teacher rights quote the goal is to have C or higher pressures on teachers to change grades F to D and and D to C this is the quote from the teacher number three grades are failing but vitelli is B busy selling School properties to developers rather than to the city for much needed parks and Sport Fields with all the Sacramento Housing mandates where are all the new students going to be H uh attending school when the property is all gone she's not on the student for the students when it's determined that she's going to build the $40 million district office we call it the Taj Mahal meanwhile Rome is burning she's grades are failing but
252her school board votes consistently 5 and also votes for her raises without a performance review we understand since 2022 what private company grants raises when the business it administers is failing evidently with a total 23 salary of 34966 with Benefits up to 379,000 Bears two to three times a week for her outings to local eateries and coffee bars for approximately $1,977 she donated to her causes with taxpayers dollars nearly 7,31 to LGBT thank you next speaker is Allison Mano good evening my name is Alison Mino and I'm a parent uh to two children in Oceanside School District if anything happens to me or my children after today it will be in pure retaliation for me standing here today um I wanted to come uh here this evening to express my concern of the information I
253came across um Dr Julie vital our superintendent it seems has had some time on her hands Dr vital is unfit to be scouting for Carl's bad's next superintendent let's be clear we've had to deal with her for several years now in her incompetence um since becoming our superintendent she has failed our students and families time and time again Dr vital resigns or I'm sorry Reigns and rules in our district her school board votes in constant 5 um oceanside's test scores continue to plumet under her leadership a m declin and enrollment under Dr vitali's leadership the last District to reopen their school doors during the pandemic under Dr vitali's leadership and while many other school districts in San Diego County spent the majority of covid funds on distance learning Oceanside Unified School District spent 68% on
254PPE 31% on distance learning the highest by the way in uh the state our little Oceanside um two elementary schools have closed under Dr vitali's leadership displacing many socioeconomically challenged families and most recently we have had students at Pablo talk elementary school's campus under massive construction site under her leadership we have um you know these kids have to learn under just really bad bad environment um that's not all many safety hazards that have been addressed to Dr vitalian school board but sadly she has never given them her time that should be uh all I'd have to say for you guys to run away um but anyhow Dr vital should be doing what she gets paid for at 300 plus 350,000 Plus benefits in her own district and clearly has no business in other school districts
255and frankly no business in public service thank you thank you next speaker is Scott [Music] Davidson last year the CEO of Coca-Cola resigned their board was then tasked to pick a consultant to find his replacement do you know who they pick to lead their search the CEO of Pepsi okay I'm kidding it would be Preposterous to let your competitor pick the person to run your company right except that's actually what you're proposing to do tonight if you pick mcferson and Jacobson the person who will be picking your new superintendent will be Julie Vitali the superintendent of your neighboring School District the same school district that competes with you for teachers staff rankings funding grants and almost everything related to the operation of your school district even students will be picking your new CEO on top
256of all of that you would be be relying on a superintendent of a school district that has been anything but successful during her tenure whether it's academics or finances Oceanside is in big trouble and under their superintendent leadership they have only gotten worse sadly the problems with mcferson don't end there the biggest problem is that the reason they're here tonight pitching their services is due to a situation of their own making they were hired by Powe to find their new superintendent and they made $331,000 by doing a nationwide search simply to end up pick the superintendent of another North County School District ours conveniently for them they can now Drive 30 minutes down the road and ask you to pay thousands of dollars to fill the vacancy that they helped create some firms CH Char
257change widely charge widely different amounts of money based simply on the size of their school district shouldn't it be easier to find a school district a superintendent for a school district for a larger well-known District does having more students suddenly make it harder or do they simply assume that your revenue is bigger and therefore you can afford to give them more money one firm entered a bid of over $40,000 to pawe but then cut it to under $25,000 simply to price match their competitor did they cut $155,000 worth of services that they were going to provide during the search or were they just hoping to pocket the extra money for the same amount of work look you don't really need have any good options when it comes to picking these search firms there are conflicts
258of interest and double dealing everywhere you look but there is certainly a worst option and that's mcferson and I will say that if we don't need a search firm to find our next CBO because there's already enough interest we shouldn't need to spend 30,000 on a search firm for a superintendent at all I will now hand it back to Mrs Aras thank you um to help make an informed decision trustees were given access to the proposal submitted by each firm in addition to this um in addition to reviewing the proposals each firm will have 20 to 25 minutes in which they will provide a