001good afternoon it's 4:30 and I call this meeting to order we will begin tonight's meeting with the uh Pledge of Allegiance oh wait no I'm sorry that's weird to cut off okay I apologize so um we will begin uh tonight's meeting with the um uh elected uh Schoolboard trustees uh out of office I would now like to introduce interim superintendent Rick Schmidt who will swear in the new trustees thank you uh trusty Rawlings I will begin with Allison Amry if you'll stand up please so if you'll just follow along I'll prompt without any mental reservation anyal reservation or purpose of evasion purpose of evasion that I will well every time I do this I mess that part up and that I will well and faithfully and that I will and discharge the duties discharge the
002duties upon which I am about to enter upon [Applause] congratulations okay trusty Laura siosi I state your name I do solemnly swear do swear that I will support and defend that I will support the Constitution of the United States theti of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and St against all ene enemies foreign and domestic against all enemies for and Dom that they will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States consti of the United States and the constitution of the State of California and of the state that I take this obligation freely I take obligation without any mental reservation without anyal for purpose of evasion for purpose of that I will well and Faithfully that I will well and Faithfully discharge the duties discharge the
003upon which I'm about to enter toer congratulations [Applause] and I'm going to go briefly Off Script if uh your families want to take a picture or two before we uh uh move forward with the meeting uh we can do that so we'll take like a three minute break for pictures okay e e e uh we'll move on uh with the agenda um we're at item 1.3 the brown act training I now welcome Mr breaze of a alrr who will facilitate our Brown act training uh good evening congratulations to uh the new members um uh my name is Mark Brae I've uh been a school attorney for 30 years in in California um representing districts um in general counsel and a variety of things um here to do an overview of the brown act and and
004I want to emphasize overview um I've done all day trainings on this subject before um and that's uh uh easy to fill up the time uh to do that um so I have a uh a presentation I'm going to try to leave U time for questions uh at the end um if you have a question during uh the presentation um feel free to raise your hand and and ask it um but there's fairly good chance that I might be getting to it at a later slide so um next slide or on to the first slide intent of the brown act it's written in the government code and it's a broadly stated intent that uh public agencies should take their actions openly and deliberations should be conducted openly and that the people of the state don't
005yield their sovereignty to the people um and the agencies which which sered them so the general requirement is openness um the uh another statement is in the this the case of boil versus C city city of Redondo Beach um it it's also designed to facilitate public partici ipation to make it uh the public more interested in participating because they get more information about what is being considered and what is being done and to curb the misuse of the democratic process um by preventing secrecy I'll talk about uh briefly there are circumstances where um you can have things in close session as you all know um but um uh they're narrow and they're interpreted narrowly the general rule is openness um I don't have slid one of the topics I don't cover um in a brief
006overview is uh enforcement of the brown act um but I always like to point out first of all it's difficult there's a reason that it can be an all day training there's a reason that the State Attorney General's document on the brown act um is you know runs 75 80 pages I think um there's a lot of law surrounding it it's difficult um and compliance is not always easy either um it's it's kind of surprising uh to me sometimes you think about I've been doing this 30 years um I typically get a question about the brown act uh once a week or more um and there are a lot of people in every school district from the superintendent to the superintendent assistant to the board members to the Departments who are sub submitting items for
007the agenda there's a lot of attention to the brown act but questions come up all the time so it's difficult and I think um I I like to point out that the legislature recognizes that um as I see it in a number of ways first of all you can't be sued for a violation of the brown act unless you get a written notice of either a demand to cure or correct and an action that was taken allegedly in violation of the brown act or to cease and desist practices um that uh your board um is engaged in that violate the brown act so there's always it didn't used to be that way until uh a few years back it was only the action taken lawsuit that required um a demand letter now any lawsuit requires
008a demand letter and there's an always a chance to correct a violation if you found a violation and I think that is a legislative recognition that this is not an easy thing the compliance is not always easy um the legislature also recognizes it in this in the fact that a brown act violation uh or about Brown act lawsuit won't result in a finding against the district or city or whatever it is if there was substantial compliance with the brown act so that is a uh a provision that's written right into the law and then the courts have recognized it too um in that if an a an action is taken in violation of the brown act that action is not nullified unless there was Prejudice or harm to the community or the person filing the
009lawsuit um there was a recent lawsuit I I represented pawe unified on um and that's what it came down to um sorry about the reference to Poway I I I understand the chuckling now um but uh it came down to sub substantial compliance or and and and the issue of prejudice and the judge said to the plain if there was no Prejudice you knew about this the whole time the public knew about it it was a technical violation so you don't win um and I'm often asked who is it that gets sued one of the issues in that case was the suit was against the board the district and three individual board members and the three individual board members were out of the lawsuit um the the Court ruled you can only file a lawsuit
010against a board so it is the board collectively that is responsible for compliance but compliance can only happen of all five in this case five individuals R comply with the brown act but an individual who violates the brown act can put the entire district and the board on the hook uh and the consequences can be severe um the uh an action can be nullified um there are political ramifications uh for it I think the uh um uh perhaps the biggest consequence is the attorney fee Provisions in the brown act if you receive demand letter you disagree with it you uh um and L litigation is initiated if the district loses you have to pay the attorney fees of the other side which can be substantial so compliance is important I also always uh or or
011don't pass up the opportunity to give a quick little editorial I wrote when I was a young attorney with a full head of hair where I suggested in the mid90s when the legislature was con considering expanding the brown act and and uh putting more restrictions on local agencies I said to the state legislature why don't you do the same thing to yourself why don't you make you have to comply with the leg the uh open meeting requirements because they don't everything in Sacramento happens in secret they come out to the assembly or senate floor and vote but it's already been decided behind closed doors most of the time um didn't get a good reaction to that but uh I think um that's a a certain level of unfairness I think that is associated with that
012now on these uh quick presentations um the way I years ago decided to try to approach it is to say the brown act in a sentence and that's what's up on the screen it's all meetings of a legislative body must be properly noticed open and public unless a closed session is specifically authorized provide for public participation and address only items on the publicly posted AG agenda now there's a series of slides that are not in your handout here but if you uh just click through them uh Rob the uh so we have topics within there meeting legislative body proper notice open and L A closed session is authorize public participation and address items the only items that are on the agenda and so that's the breakdown of topics that I will go through now the
013first is a legislative body um what's a leg legislative body um it's defined by the brown act it is um the board and uh in Carlsbad Unified and other districts um the person that have a Personnel commission it also applies to the Personnel commission um it also applies to commissions committees or other bodies that the board creates by board action the superintendent's cabinet is not subject to the brown act because that's administratively created the board didn't didn't create that but if a board takes action to create a committee then it is subject to the brown act there's a narrow exception to that and that is if the board creates a committee of composed solely of less than a majority of the board so a committee of two um with no other members and it's advisory
014and it's ad hoc you see that sometimes um you know current events sometimes you see that with a superintendent search or when there's a vacancy on the board where a committee will be created for two board members to look at all the applications for people to fill the vacancy and come back with a recommendation as long as it's only the two board members and it's temporary and its advisory um that that uh committee would be exempt from the brown act but any other um uh body that is created by the board or by state law um applies so that's legislative bodies that's pretty straightforward that's almost never an issue meetings is what usually is the issue um and meetings are uh for years were not the the the word meeting was not defined in the
015brown act you hear about serial meetings I'll talk more about that later that was a product of Court decisions that concluded that when it says all meetings must be open a meeting includes a series of phone calls that president uh uh of the board or a superintendent makes to develop a collective concurrence on an action to be taken but it's defined in the law now it's a gathering of a majority to hear discuss deliberate or act on a matter within the the board's uh or the Personnel commission's subject matter jurisdiction it's Gathering of majority in one place it's this right here what we're talking about that's clear um that it's a meeting it's also defined in the laws a series of of communications of any uh uh kind involving a majority to discuss deliberate or
016act on a matter within the board's jurisdiction I put in red highlight and and italicized there um those words because you notice the word here is not in the definition of a series of communications so a series of communications where board members hear the same thing um is not a viol VI ation of the brown act and that was done um deliberately and these provisions of the brown act were put in by the legislature after a court decision where the court of appeal concluded that a a board had not violated the brown act because there were a series of communications but they didn't actually make a decision and the legislature didn't like that they focused on the fact that they they were there was a series of communications they were deliberating and and the fact
017that they didn't make a take a final vote or decide what to do um was uh was enough so um a Serial meeting uh and I I alluded to it it's defined in um no not Siri serial meeting I see um a uh a majority of of members outside of a meeting use a series of communications of any kind to discuss deliberate or take action and like I said that was added to the brown act after that um appell at court decision um individual conversations between a staff member and a board or commission member are not prohibited as long as the staff member does not convey the position of any other member so the superintendent can have a uh a conversation with individual board members one at a time to provide information and answer questions
018as long as there is no uh conveying of what any of the the rest of you said whether it's a position or not this can be a dangerous uh situation um in a number of ways you can't take action on it you can't do it for the purpose of um Counting votes basically um a superintendent or any other staff member or a member of the governing board um which is different when it's a board member but under this exception if an individual staff member contacts each board member and and gets a determination of how they feel about something then that's a good old-fashioned series of communications to develop a collective concurrence um but providing information and answering questions um is enough uh is is permitted um the uh a question that I'm also often asked
019is what about a board member simply providing information to the other four board members the brown act doesn't direct uh address that directly um it's it's clear that one board member can provide information to another board member and the two of them can talk about all they want about it as long as it doesn't involve a third member because it has to involve a majority but in that circumstance my advice is always to have the superintendent be the source of providing information to the board so I always recommend that if a board member would like information to distribute it to the rest of the board you send it to the superintendent and then the superintendent says I have been uh could say I've been asked to distribute this by a board member um I advise
020against identifying which board member especially if it's something it's an advocacy position because that is conveying the position of another member but that I think is the safest way to avoid um the serial um uh communication problems the uh definition of deliberate is uh interpreted broadly uh under the brown act um it includes the collective acquisition and exchange of facts we see at board meetings um or you think about a jury in court you hear all this information you get all the evidence and then you go in to deliberate and that's where you discuss how should we vote guilty not guilty Etc and you see that in a board meeting motion second now let's discuss um and and that kind of fits into the category of deliberations but three board members exchanging a bunch of
021information with one another outside of a meeting um for or consideration about something is part of deliberations so um so that is uh um another uh difficulty of this and again staff simply providing information to everybody is not um board members um collectively doing it uh creates problems and an action taken means any collective decision you often think uh I've heard it before well I can't be a brown act violation because we didn't vote vote we didn't actually do a motion in a second and a vote I'm in close session all the time like uh giving an update on litigation and getting uh authorization to settle for example I don't need a motion in a second and a vote if I see five heads nodding up and down that's enough and that's action that's a
022collective concurrence whether it's thumbs up heads nodding and things like that but it's not just a motion um or a second it's any decision to move forward Ward on something so to emphasize these uh issues with meetings I have a series of these slides with uh Graphics I alluded this before um an email discussion or any other kind of interaction between board member one and board member two does not create Brown act issues even if it's this topic within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board I personally think it's easy uh um for me to say um but board member number two in this circumstance if that board member didn't invite the interaction and the discussion now that individual board member is precluded from talking to the one other board member that they would want
023like to talk to so that can create some uh some issues and I've seen that before but it's not a brown act issue if it only involves two board members if you involve a third one even if board member number one is not involved in the communication between two and three it's a series of communications um and if there's a discussion on the topic and it's within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board it violates the brown act and it's there's no provision that says it's only if the item is on an upcoming agenda that it's a violation it's any topic within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board next slide um this is what I alluded to before back and forth questions and information um between individual board members and a staff member is
024fine as long as the member does not uh communicate comments or positions of other members uh the bane of my existence in one of the jobs that I had uh um I was General Counsel for San Diego Unified School District for two years from 2008 to 2010 um before I escaped uh but it's different now I I I love that school district but I had two board members who I I actually asked it if there is a way to program Outlook so you can't hit reply to all um and then I went to sending out emails to myself and blind C seeing everyone and these two board members figured that out really quick just hit reply and then added the other board members but that's a violation of the brown act and so when you
025get that information and it can be sent out to all all of you at the same time by a staff member by a email but no reply to all um because then that creates um a brown act violation then we have uh technology challenges um and there are different technology challenges all the time in uh for a long time there was a question about social media use and is it a violation of the brown act for two board members to click like on Facebook post of a third board member um I always felt the answer was yes because like or dislike or or whatever um denotes a a point of view the legislature addressed this in 2020 and they adopted a rule that's even stricter than for other forms of communication um they they made
026it clear that you are allowed to have a Facebook or Instagram or social media account in your uh capacity as a board member or a personal account where you um post things about your role as a board member that's allowed um that would present I think some First Amendment problems if it wasn't allowed um and it can be to answer questions provide information to the public or to ask for input from the public on a particular matter please comment if you have a point of view on this that's one of the things that you do as an elected official is you you want feedback from your uh constituents except going to the next Slide the um same as the rule against um serial Communications a majority may not discuss amongst themselves business of a specific
027nature and that encompasses comments use of digital icons that Express reactions um Communications uh posted or shared um on social media between members of the legislative body so sharing a Facebook post um I'm probably dating Myself by saying Facebook I know young people don't use it anymore um responses to the same communication on social media um again like buttons emojis and things like that um and then it also says members Also may not directly respond to Social Media communication made or posted um and shared uh by any other member of the the same legislative body so if you use the same graphic that I did before um this I think is not okay times two you have a a board member number one posting on Facebook board member number two commenting on it it's only
028two board members but under this legislation that's a violation of the brown act um the uh and I think it's I or I assume that it's a product of an an assumtion that board members three four or five are going to see that um and then it becomes part of the deliberative process where you're seeing that opinion whereas a private email conversation uh communication or private conversation between two is not kind of automatically shared with the third and then if the board member number three likes board member number two's comment that would be a separate violation so I've heard be it said before you know what the best thing to do is just don't use social media as a a board member I'm I'm not one who uh you know goes that far but you
029have to be very careful um and uh I I was asked before does so does that mean we shouldn't be friends on Facebook and you know the answer is no you can you can comment and like all you want the vacation pictures the you know the celebratory things about family recipes whatever it is that's outside of the subject matter jurisdiction but if you see um a social media post from a fellow board member that addresses a matter within subject matter jurisdiction um you can read it but don't like it don't comment on it none of that okay um remote and teleconference meetings um I'll go through this quickly because this is becoming less and less uh prevalent there this says there are currently two options there's actually three um potential options but the third option
030it's it's actually back in the law where if the governor declares a state of emergency you can have remote meetings hopefully we never get to that point again and so um it's really not an option that you have on your own as a board you have only two one is the traditional rules under the brown Act and the other is AB 2449 and unless it's extended that only applies until January 1 2026 I uh um I will tell you at at at the top that my recommendation is always just use the traditional preco teleconferencing rules um and that's what this is you have to have a teleconference location or locations identified in the agenda that member Rawlings is going to be here uh member Emery is going to be here and you have to have
031that address um it has to be a place except accessible to the public it has to allow members of the public to comment at each teleconference location all Co votes in that case have to be roll call votes you can't just do eyes and nays um and at least a quorum of the members of the board must participate from um within the boundaries of um the school district I've uh had uh a board member participate in a meeting from Australia um uh with had family in Australia opened the front door of the House of the family posted a notice um anybody who wanted to come in could come in that happens um csba conferences other conferences vacation but you want to um uh is as long as reasonable measures are taken to get the agenda
032posted prop open the hotel room door because the agenda will say um that it it this board member is going to be at the Hilton in Lake Tahoe or wherever it is so it gives that notice um that you're you're allowed to do that so that's what I call the old-fashioned teleconferencing um uh authorization the uh AB 2449 um the reason I'll tell you the reason why I think this is problematic mainly for staff is that it basically says um board members in for just cause or in emergency circumstances can can attend a meeting remotely and it doesn't have to be a location open to the public it can be by Zoom um in your dining room but it can be announced right up until the beginning of the meeting and if a board member
033participates by zoom in that way then everybody needs to be able to participate by zoom and publicly comment by Zoom so leaving this option open means that the agenda and staff and everything needs to be set up to quickly make it into a zoom meeting when it wasn't intended to be a zoom meeting now the board has the authority to uh to for example adopt a bylaw that you have to give at least 72 hours notice of this or um 96 hours notice of this if you want to attend under AB 2449 but you don't always know um child needs uh illness emergency circumstances you don't always always know that um so uh that's one of the reasons why I think that um this is um not not an incredibly viable option and I'm going
034to just um point out without going through these that there are procedural requirements associated with this and there are some limitations um in the law that's the next slide um that you can look at if you're if you're curious for it and again it's only through January 1 2026 I I suspect um it will be extended that that Sunset date will be taken off and it will um become an authorization because the technology is there now to to make it easier but um you heard me on my uh point of view on the staff uh issue and and um in and in a lot of ways the public notice is issue um that um a member of the public um shouldn't learn 2 hours before a meeting that that they can attend by Zoom um
035because one board member has said I have an emergency circumstance and I need to attend by Zoom um and uh so properly noticed in going through that sentence that's the next one properly noticed regular meeting um the notice has to be 72 hours prior to the start of the meeting special meeting has to be 24 hours um there are fairly recently enacted uh website posting requirements um and you have to have downloadable and and searchable um documents uh within that um the agenda um and and I should also say uh in conjunction with that that that something that is often misunderstood is the agenda think of the pre pre fax machine pre- cell phone days pre uh all of that technology days where the agenda was two or three or four sheets of paper posted
036in a kiosk um at a at a variety of locations that's still the requirement that's the agenda posting requirement it has to be on your website but it doesn't have to there's no requirement that all of the backup materials have to be posted also there's no requirement that says backup materials can't be modified or changed there are times when a presentation staff is going to be uh doing is not done until 3 hours before the meeting but you post a draft um with the agenda 72 hours before the requirement is that any document that the board is given or given access to within 72 hours of the meeting has to be made available to the public immediately on De on demand and the agenda has to give an address of where they could get that
037uh where they can get that that's one of the reasons why in addition to just a general um principle of being transparent that on platforms like board docs which you use they're just automatically posted people don't need to ask for them people don't need to come to the district office to get them um there were districts playing games that you know something would be distributed to board members 48 hours before a meeting and somebody would say I want a copy of that and they say well that's a public records request go ahead and fill that out and we have 10 days to respond to it um not a good practice in a variety of ways and so the legislature stepped in and said if the board gets it within 72 hours of the meeting it
038has to be made available to everybody at the same time the board um receives it technology has made that pretty easy um the agenda must contain a brief General description of each item of business and the brown act specifically says a brief General description of an item generally not need not exceed 20 words so that's another aspect of IT board docs you see the agenda item listed but then if you click on that you get to the whole background fiscal impact all of that information none of that is required by the brown act to be posted in advance but for transparency it's good to do that and it's easy to do that um so uh but the the requirement is a brief General description that gen need not uh exceed 20 words um next slide
039amending an agenda inside of 72 hours or 24 hours for a special meeting is generally not permitted unless it is to pull the item or make non-substantive Corrections um I uh um litigated to the court of appeal um several years ago um for Grossmont High School District the board was considering amending a a number of board policies um and the the agenda po listed all of the board policies that were being considered for amend uh for Amendment it was a controversial issue it will tell you it was not very recent that the amendments were to modify um uh board policies regarding employees and students to um address the issue of actual perceived sexual orientation the student board member noticed that there was one other policy that should be listed and should be amended um and
040have that inserted so inside of 72 hours of the meeting they added that to the agenda it was like policy blank blank blank blank and then they added one more within 72 hours court of appeal said that was a violation of the brown act um the district didn't win because of the Prejudice issue and at the time um the the law was uh the the the cease and desist law because they didn't take action at that meeting there was a first reading um but the cease and desist body of law was different but it was still expensive um litigation the agenda must reasonably apprise the public of the matters to be considered in sufficient detail to allow the public to determine whether to participate at the meeting so that's my guiding principle is is somebody
041reading this brief General description that need not exceed 20 words going to know what the board is considering and if the answer to that is yes then it meets the requirement a good case uh on that is Carlson versus Paradise Unified School District going way back to 1971 the agenda said continuation school site change so what the board actually did is they moved the continuation school to a new site the site of an elementary school that they also voted to close at the same time that was hiding the ball from the public the real action included closing an elementary school which I don't know if you've ever been to a board meeting where that's being considered but that uh creates a lot of uh of Interest the only school board meeting I went to when
042I was in high school was when I were F was a freshman and they were considering closing my high school it was a big big enough deal for me to to go to a board meeting um so this uh that is when you're talking about a brief General description another uh difficulty or trap is every board um in cons consistent with the brown act every board agenda I see um except for some special meetings has board member reports you know where you report on your activities and that's written into the brown act you can uh um do that briefly report on your activities I've seen it before where you know a board member said I visited this and I really liked it and they were talking about blah blah blah and so so I'd like
043to make a motion that we do something in second and then they launch off into a discussion and take action the the public didn't have notice of that another one that I found is usually the last item on an agenda is future agenda items where a board member says I would like to place uh a certain item on the agenda of our next meeting and then the board ends up discussing that issue for 10 minutes it wasn't on the agenda you can't discuss it um um some board do that um the the the various board bylaws have uh um different um processes that um that the board agrees to through its bylaws um to uh for placement of items on the agenda by board members and uh so that's one of them but that's an
044area to be careful of a very generally uh described um agenda item that launches into a a meeting okay closed sessions um I I mentioned at the beginning that these are construed narrowly um the the general rule is openness um this is a confidential topic is not necessarily enough for um a closed session it has to fit into a specific authorization um there are all there are many of them they're all narrowly construed the next uh couple of slides goes through the entire list on um uh of close session authorizations um go back to the the one before on the on this one um the it lists the four Public Employee um Provisions which is government code section 54957 which is um appointment employment performance evaluation and discipline dism dismissal or release that one is
045very common that the only close session authorization in the brown act that is des designed to protect the interest of of someone or something other than the district it's there to protect the reputational interest of the employee um and so if you're not talking about a specific employee or the performance of an employee or whether to hire an employee it's an open session item I've seen it before Clos session item on the reorganization of the educational services department that's an open session item um unless for some reason there is going to be a discussion of the specific performance of employees within that department um and that can create problems too because you can't reorganized to avoid the discipline process um so um that's one um conference with labor negotiators um is another one um every
046District that I know of puts that on their agenda but um in fact the collective bargaining law that applies to K through2 school districts and Community College districts actually exempts from the brown act close sessions of the board to um discuss negotiations and give direction to their negotiators the reason for that is sometimes you're at the negotiating table and you're this close to an agreement and rather than say okay well we need to put it on the agenda um someone on the bargaining team can contact board members you authorize 2% we're at 2.1 are you okay with 2.1 that's actually exempt from the brown act but I think it's a good practice if you're going to be talking about Labor negotiations at a regular meeting or a special meeting um that's posted in advance you
047might as well tell the public that you're going to be doing that even though you don't have to um the top one on top ones on this list conference with legal counsel regarding pending litigation or anticipated litigation um that is one where it requires and it's based on the opinion of legal counsel that there is significant exposure to litigation litigation is an important word significant exposure to liability is not the standard so significant exposure to frivolous litigation would still allow a closed session but we want to meet with our attorney to ask our attorney some legal questions and get legal advice is not a basis for a closed session um it can be done in writing um California Supreme Court decision from the 90s um confirmed that if a written legal opinion from Council is
048sent to all five board members that's not a meeting um if if the board members then collectively meet and discuss it that would be a meeting and it wouldn't be authorized by the brown act unless there's a significant exposure um to litigation and then there's a number of of reporting things that time doesn't allow um me to uh go into detail on with that on the next um the next slide there is real property negotiations is the most common one for a school district on the this list of this second slide what's not listed is uh because it's not in the brown act there separate provisions of the Education Code if you are considering a student discipline matter that's a uh that's that's actually in the Education Code because um cities counties other um legislative
049bodies subject to the brown act they don't deal with student discipline issues so that's a separate one um for school districts um also on closed sessions um there are still meetings they have to be listed on the uh agenda I mentioned the exception they have to be preceded by an open session disclosing the items to be discussed and the disclosure can be WR in writing or um verbal and with public comment rights before um I see uh this happen sometimes where um the Clos session is going to be in a conference room and everybody just goes into the conference room and there's no starting of the meeting I've seen it before where using this room as an example if you do close sessions somewhere else where a board member goes out and says there's no
050one there so in that case against again um substantial compliance would uh would apply because you checked if there was somebody who wanted to speak that they would have been able to speak um but there was no one there but that's um that's something that can be uh overlooked um sometimes and and skipped over um and for some actions but not all actions taken in close session um there are announcements that have to be made if you if there's a um a decision by the board to um uh settle litigation if the board is the last um accepting party and it's final um or or other um contractual certain contractual actions that are final when the board takes the action that needs to be reported out action to uh affect the status of a Public
051Employee has to be reported out and the the title of the position but not the name of the person um has to be reported out and those reports can be verbally or in writing also um uh almost without exception um boards do it verbally but the brown act explicitly says it can be in writing um and like I said before receipt of confidential information is not a meeting the Supreme Court basically and not basically they almost literally said that members of a city council don't have a meeting simply by opening their mail um and uh so receipt of confirm uh confidential information is not a closed session and then public participation um public must have an opportunity to address items on the agenda before or during the body's consideration of the item um boards do
052this differently some have all of the public comment um at or near the beginning of the meeting some of them Community College districts there's actually a separate provision of the code that requires public comment at the time each item on the agenda is taken up that is not in in the brown act that's a specific provision for community colleges in the Education Code so most boards in my experience they take public comment as each item comes up but um not all do um for regular meetings you must allow a public comment on non-agenda items um but that doesn't apply to special meetings some boards allow that for special meetings also um and like with uh um public comment on agenda items public comment on non-agenda items can be before um at the beginning of a
053meeting could be at the end of a meeting or can be both some districts it we're going to do 30 minutes of non-agenda item comment before but if we have more than that then the rest are going to go to the end um in circumstances like that you have to make sure that you're not picking and choosing who speaks during the initial 30 minutes you want it to be random or in the order that cards were um submitted um but um it it is one of many examples of how the law has recognized including in published Court decisions that the purpose of your meetings is to get business done and if you need to have a a bylaw that says um 20 minutes 30 minutes tops on non-agenda public comment you're allowed to have that
054enforce that as long as you enforce it um uh um consistently ly um and in a non-discriminatory fashion um I had a um I was actually at home I got a text message the other night of um two people people who had been to one person had been completely disruptive at this Community College District meeting um and I got a text he's here again he submitted 22 cards one on every single agenda item and he brought somebody with him who has submitted 22 cards one on every uh agenda item is there anything we can do um and the answer to that um was in my opinion yes it's a business meeting so the board took an action to say in order to get our business done for this meeting we are going to limit total
055time for individual speakers to 10 minutes and mo no more than 3 minutes for any agenda item and they enforced that and nobody challenged it because I don't think it um is uh um can be challenged there's a case called white versus city of Norwalk that emphasized um these kinds of things so um for public uh um participation you can uh have those kinds of reasonable regulations like this slice is total time per speaker total time per topic and total time for non-agenda um the next slide um audio and video recording is allowed unless it PR prevents you from conducting your business you can't do Secret ballots um uh I talked about agenda backup material and materials provided within 72 hours of of a meeting that uh uh relates not only to the agenda requirement
056but to public participation um and I I always advise be Beware of the D danger of the perception of Silent participation I was at a board meeting one time where it was pretty obvious that two board members were texting each other during the meeting cuz it was like you'd see one board member do this and set the phone down and then the other one would look down pick it up and do that again two board members it's not a violation of the brown act if it was three board members it would be because you're deliberating even though you're sitting in a public meeting you're deliberating privately on a public item but even with two members it's it's not a good look I've said before that the brown act it times can be 95% political and
0575% legal if you have the perception of being or the reputation of being a board that um operates in secret that's hard to get past so um conversations during breaks is another one three board members during a break they go over and huddle maybe they're talking about you know the NFL games on Sunday and probably are because I think most um board members recognize this kind of thing but um you uh uh it's another thing to be careful and then the last slide um limited to items on the agenda I've been alluding to this and this is kind of a uh logical when you talk about um um not only having a uh uh sufficient agenda item description but no action or discussion can be undertaken on any item unless it appears on the agenda
058there are Provisions that say these are specific Provisions that board members can briefly respond to statements made or questions posed by persons exercising public testimony rights um uh just last week I had a board member who decided to talk for five and a half minutes in response to to a speaker who only had three minutes I don't think that meets the definition of briefly um so uh you have to be careful with that um you also again it's a business meeting it's not a town hall meeting so um one of the reasons why board members typically refrain from engaging and interacting is then it becomes a back and forth and not a public comment um sometimes there's a direction to staff can you look into that uh if a parent uh expresses a concern about
059something um you you don't want to just ignore that but the board can uh direct staff um to look into it um you can ask questions for clarification provide a uh a reference and and again be careful because it's easy to go beyond these and stay Beyond these um these boundaries so the last slide is just uh repeated with the the five things so those are the the elements of a uh the brown act in a sentence and uh I didn't leave a whole lot of time for questions I'm sorry I I have uh again technology I'm have to be available for um a Clos session in on my phone in my car probably starting at 5 uh 35 or 540 so I can go a little bit over 5:30 if there are questions so
060any questions are there brief questions just P thank you for your presentation um I just want to clarify mark on the close session so when we list for example today 2.1 2.2 2. 3 2.4 for close session do all of those items have to be discussed or is it okay to list certain items you may have answered this question but I'm just no I I didn't answer that question and it's a good question okay um the answer is no they don't have to be discussed um they and and I see it all the time you know that was you have to post the agenda 3 days before the meeting most districts now post it uh longer than 3 days before an issue could be resolved by the time um you know you get into a
061meeting turns out the employee resigned so we don't need to discuss that one it's in the Personnel action report on the consent agenda that that employee resigned so you go on to the next thing same thing with um uh I know this this goes beyond your question but for o even open session the board has the authority to reorganize things on the agenda to move something up um there uh um there are times where you know you're going to have a packed room and it's because of agenda item 6.2 it's perfectly okay when you come if you come out a close session um take public comment on non-agenda items and somebody say I make a motion that we move item 6.2 to right now um and and it's okay to do that same thing with
062polling items that are on the agenda staff can pull an item the board can table an item um an agenda basically says these are the things that we might be dealing with but you're not you don't have to other questions I have one um thank you very much and I um I know I submitted a lot of questions in advance and I think you covered all of them but one so I appreciate that um so um my question is is during governance uh requests can the board direct staff or majority of the board direct staff to take an action that is within that staff's direct or discretion um absent the board so if we say if the board says Hey I want you to post this item on the website and there's there's a majority
063that says post that item on the on the website is that within the brown act under governance requests um I say to people that uh all the time that uh in three years of law school they they you learn more than how to say it depends and I'll get back to you um but that's an it it depends question when you say governance um my question back would be what was the agenda item um did the public have notice that they would be under an item called governance requests So like um on our agenda we have a section that says governance requests and so it's not discussed but it would be let's say a majority of the board says we want you to do X to staff and if three folks say yes we want
064you to do that but the staff member could have done it regardless whether the board directed them to do it or not um I think there you're probably first of all I would say governance requests I'm a member of the public and I look at the agenda and it says governance request do I know what that means is that enough um that's that's question number one um something like uh I what I started the meeting talking about of um the legislature recognizes this is difficult um substantial compliance Prejudice if the board uh whether through a formal motion and a vote or just by head nodding says yeah I think it would be a good a good idea to post that on uh a website then the question would become um is anybody prejudiced by that
065if it wasn't if it didn't fit into an agenda item um I'm not a fan of very general things like governance uh requests um unless unless they stay within the bounds of a request I would I'm at I would like information about blank I would like information about blank but governance request agenda item that that um becomes discussion on um a potential action and action by the board um is uh could be problematic yeah I and like I um I talked about before the the agenda requirement is a brief General description generally not exceed 20 words if all of the backup information for that that's also posted and available for the public to see um says more about what the board is doing then that would be become part of the facts that are relevant
066to um whether you were operating in secrecy or not um or um with less transparency than you should have air on the side of caution air on the side of transparency is is my recommendation well thank you and is there any other questions okay well do we have time we have very little time Emil yeah um yeah that was the next thing I was going to ask um what I would suggest is is that if you have additional questions um if you would email the superintendent and then the superintendent can um uh send those um questions and then the superintendent will share those um answers to those questions with all of us does that sound fair that sound good okay said he had time for one more did is there one more question okay I'll
067ask okay so if a brown act by violation occurs in closed session in or in a Serial meeting um but a board member doesn't have standing to file a complaint so who's in charge of enforcing these types of brown act violations um any the the the statute says any person or the district attorney now I know board members are persons so you would think that that but there's a larger body of law um related to limitation on a member of a board suing the board that they sit on and expands Beyond just the brown act um but there that is a standing issue um in uh um there are there are um there's case law that a member of a board can't sue the board that they sit on for violations of the brown act
068and that kind of goes back to what I was talking about is that um um it it it's a collective responsibility for everybody to um to comply because it's the board that's on the hook it's not um the the three or four members that the individual board member is complaining about it's the entire board it's the entity is is reporting a violation the same thing as suing no no and um yeah I'm uh I I remember saying to a board member years ago I I won't name the district it wasn't San Diego unified I know I badmouth them so I'll just I'll just say that um but a board member said you know this this board this board is engaging in repeated violations of the brown act and I said well then I think you
069have a a a ethical responsibility to report that to the district attorney if you think that that's going on I don't know whether that board member did but that is that's a right that anybody has um to uh to report that either to uh again other than board members to the board itself through a demand assent assist demand or a cure cure correct demand or um for board members to the to the district attorney thank you you have three minutes so I'm going to let you go but thank you so much really appreciate the information MERS adds super andwers would be shared with the of us thank you I appreciate it all right and we'll move on take um to item 1.4 oral communication on close session items have any blue cards been received for
070close session items we do not have any blue cards great then we will recess to close session thank you e e e good evening it is 6:03 and uh the board is reconvening from Clos session there is no action to report from closed session welcome members of the public and and uh board members and staff thank you for attending as noted on board bylaw 9324 this meeting is being video recorded and broadcast via a link on our website the recording and broadcast May capture images and sounds of those attending the meeting I'd like to remind audience members and speakers that it is not unusual for students and young children to be in attendance at our meetings or to watch the recorded broadcast I invite you to model Civility and deorum as we go through the
071business of the board this evening while I cannot anyone from using unprofessional language please think about the students and adults who are watching our proceedings we invite you to show support for a speaker by waving your fingers rather than clapping or cheering we'll begin tonight's meeting with student board representative Alish I me let me do this Alish fman uh leading in the Pledge of Allegiance trusty verth will lead us in the moment of meditation I will read from our meeting Norms truste Ward will read from the district vision and Miss Garcia will take the role the holiday season has arrived bringing with it the familiar flurry of activity twinkling lights and abundance of treats and Gatherings of friends and family around delicious food this season often invites moments of quiet contemplation allowing us to reflect
072on Cherished Memories while also creating new ones while many consider this to be the most delightful time of year it can also present challenges for some the season May evoke feelings of loss or a longing for distant relatives leading to a sense of absence among loved ones Financial pressures or loss of a job can add to the stress in the midst of the Whirlwind of holiday activities which may cause the season to pass by in a haze during this holiday season regardless of whether your festivities are filled with joy or tinged with Nostalgia it is important to remember that you are not alone no matter how you choose to observe this time may we all take a moment to reflect and be grateful for this incredible carlbad community and our school district which is full
073of incredible educators families students and traditions which unify us despite our many differences the people in this community make it the amazing place to live and raise our children may you all have a very safe and happy holiday with your loved ones thank you and I'm reading from our um meeting Norms here um we first have motions and deliberations so we have a staff presentation then we have input from the public we have trusty questions to staff a motion trusty discussion and deliberation and then a vote then our meeting Norms are everyone participates we seek first to understand then to be understood stay on topic listen before responding keep discussion moving forward remain objective adhere to time one conversation and conduct ourselves with gracious professionalism okay I'm reading from our district vision and our students
074are engaged self-directed Learners they are exposed to different learning environments and Pathways students aspire to expand their talents and Achieve Excellence they are good thinkers communicators and problem solvers thank you and we will now take role student board representative freesman trusty COC trusty Emory here trusty Ward here trusty rth here trusty Rollings here thank you you we now move on to part four approval of the agenda trustees are there any questions may I have a motion to approve agenda item 4.1 approval Andor reorganization of the December 18th 2024 meeting agenda motion so move second we have a motion from trusty Board second from trusty verth and is there any discussion no discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verb yes trusty Rawlings yes motion
075passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to part five organization of the board part 5.1 um annual organ organizing organizational meeting and um I would just like to say I appreciate the um the opportunity to um reside over the meetings as president over the last year and um I believe we have um done some um good work and we've been able to run efficient and on time meeting so I appreciate that and trustees I will now hand it over to Mr Rickman thank you trustee Rollins and I'd like to begin by saying that this is an annual organization of the carlbad Unified School District Board of Trustees on December 18th 2024 in conformance with bylaw 910 at this time the Board of Trustees meeting is a adjourned for the purpose of reorganization
076to elect a new president vice president and Clerk of the board for the 20125 calendar year the board may do this by verbally making and accepting nominations followed by a motion a second and roll call voting as soon as the new board president is elected they will immediately assume the role of President and will commence with the remaining election excuse me the remaining elections and then we'll proceed with the other items on the agenda okay oh want me to read all of that yeah okay I can do it too I can do it okay it's easy Miss Garcia uh any blue card are there any blue cards that have been received for this section we do not have any blue cards okay thank you like I said feedback welcome the floor is now open for
077nominations for president of the board I'll take a nomination before asking for a motion I would like to make a nomination for president uh I would like to nominate uh Kathy Rawlings as the board president again um and my reasoning I would just like to share that we have quite a bit of transition that that's going to be happening where we have to elect a superintendent and I I know that she is familiar with that process and she is the only one that is familiar with that process so I would like to see her in that role again um and help lead us um to find our next superintendent and also to continue with some of the practices that we have had I would like to nominate Gretchen for Beth okay any other nominations any
078discussion questions for staff any questions for staff now now you can accept a motion for one okay would anyone like to Second a motion for either of the two candidates I would like to Second for Kathy Rawlings any other seconds second for Mr verel can I second myself that's a good question and I know the answer to it yes you can you can okay well then I second it myself now as for discussion okay discussion any discussion I'd like to discuss some so it's been the practice of our school district for 20 plus years to um have a succession from clerk to vice president to president um during the pre vice president's year she or he does attend the planning agenda meetings and also goes to board governance or um to board president training Workshop
079which I just attended at csba and feel that I'm quite capable of leading and um I have appreciated Kathy Rawlings as our president but I think it's time to rotate so that each of us can have a um opportunity to maintain the succession and continue training the rest of the trustees so I would like to um just state that I believe that it's appropriate to move forward and um in our succession okay trusty COC no trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verth no trusty Rollings yes motion passes 3 to2 please let the record show that that trusty Rollins has been elected as president of the Board of Trustees for 2025 thank you and thank you for um trusting me for another here to uh lead as president one yes okay do we want to
080do this or just do it out a time that would be you if you wanted to do it okay I can want me to introduce that no you don't have to yeah you can do it okay you don't have to we don't have to do that part okay okay will now we will now move on to item 5.3 organization of the board election for vice president of the Board of Trustees the floor is now open for nominations for vice president of the board and I'd like to nominate uh trustee Ward for vice president any other nominations I'm going to nominate Gretchen ver buff we're going to keep with tradition and let's keep itoll thank you any other [Music] nominations hearing not hearing not addition um we have uh two nominations we have one uh for
081trusty Ward and we have another one for uh trusty um for Beth uh may have a motion for um I'll make the motion for uh trusty Ward may have a second I have a second I'll second thank you um we have a motion in a second and then uh do we have a a motion for uh trusty ver Beth I'll make a motion for myself thank you do I have a [Music] second no can I second yes yes I'll second thank you uh and I have also have a motion and a second for uh trusty verth for um vice president as well um any [Music] discussion okay some discussion so it's also been our practice to alternate um um from president to vice president um you know we're not a um partisan organization but we
082know that we have different philosophies and so it's a nice balance of power to have um to have an alternation and that creates a nice um flow and diversity Viewpoint of thought and expression of those thoughts and so I think um we would be going out outside of what has been um traditionally done in our practices here which has worked very well for many years and so I would like to just speak to that and and the importance of maintaining that thank you any other discussion trusty what yeah and and that is truly a valid point or trustee for Beth so um thank you for sharing that I also want to say that you know not everything has to be tradition sometimes things change we don't have um our old superintendent anymore we have an
083interm now and we're going to be looking for a new superintendent so I think that as things change and I think that's something that we realized with covid is that we need to be able to be flexible and to you know try different things and and look at things differently and I think that's okay and any other discussion I have something to say as well but go ahead trust I follow up to that so thank you for your comment too trusty Ward um it's really important when we go into these meetings that especially agenda planning where we have a you know balanced thought and perspective and I understand what you're saying sometimes we don't tradition doesn't always have to to remain but I think if you're running a company or you're running a school district
084you want to have balance of thought to represent all of the constituents all of the view points and if um truste Rawlings is President and trusty Ward is Vice President then we will not have that balance we will not have um all constituents as far as I'm concerned be equally represented so I don't think it's a wise choice and um yeah so thank you trusty Amry um as being new to this board can you please um explain to me um how that balance or the change might um affect things as I'm not sure oh sure so um with any kind of whether it's PTA or um you know running a business or being on a school board you have diversity of thought right and so um it's important to have welcome all ideas openly and
085to be able to feel safe expressing those and to bring those to the table and so when you um are coming into a meeting especially like a board agenda planning meeting where you're planning the agenda it's important to have different viewpoints trusty Ward um I'm sorry if you haven't felt safe and and and expressing your thoughts but um I just want to say that my nomination for uh trusty Rawlings to be president is with a lot of the changes that are happening and with her familiarity with that from past experiences so and her and I have had differences in opinions and Views sitting on this board so I'm not really sure what you're speaking to but you know we are not the same person we don't think exactly the same so we we do have
086difference of opinions and I think that because of that nomination it doesn't mean that um you know we're thinking exactly the same with everything if you look back at our our previous board meetings there are some things that we have disagreed on TR ymer I I suppose that was a clarification of my question is what would um you were speaking of difference of viewpoints and I was wondering what perhaps those viewpoints might be that you see is difference well um it's uh that we we come up with an agenda and it's good to have um a balance where where somebody you know might bring in a a Viewpoint that says you know what I'm not in agreement with you on this and um you know what I think we do need to to discuss this
087or we do need to put something else on the agenda which you know you have to have a discussion during that that meeting and so um I appreciate that trusty Ward is expressing that she's a different person than trustee Rawlings I I totally understand that but we also know in this room that um you know there are more conservative viewpoints and there are you know not as conservative viewpoints and sometimes those issues come before the board any other discussion um I think the argument that you've made to nominate yourself and retain your your role we're only speaking we're only speaking about vice president now the the argument made to keep things status quo was because the experience that you have in this role and I would argue the same can be said for uh trusty
088verbu that she has served alongside you for the last year and so if we're trying to uh keep with consistency um as we are amidst all this other change in our district then it would make sense to keep both the president and and the vice president the same for the 2025 year thank you any other discussion I would just like to say that um that uh two years ago this came up with um truste Pearson and so each trustee owns their vote and so um obviously we can make um arguments to persuade our fellow trustees and that sort of thing but ultimately each trustee does own their vote um when it comes to not only the positions on the board but also um agenda item there is so that's what I would like to say
089as my discussion any other discussion another discussion I'd like to um uh Miss Garcia call for the vote for uh truste Ward for vice president trusty COC no trusty Emory no trusty Ward yes trusty verb no trusty Rawlings yes motion fails 3 to two and will you call for a vote for trusty ver trusty COC yes trusty Emory no trusty Ward yes or no sorry no trusty verv yes trusty Rawlings no motion sotion fail um so we would have to go back and um um we would go have have to go back and reconsider yes it would be parliamentarian yes okay so um we'll go back and reconsider is there any other discussion um that you'd like to bring forward before we do another vote I may I just have some further clarification about when
090you're making agenda items um is that purely between the president and the vice president or is the whole board um involved in those agenda items and planning meetings our our board bylaw says that the cabinet our executive cabinet the superintendent the board president and the board Vice President are only in those planning meetings and that the current board bylaw does say that um the superintendent and the president create the agenda with the input from the vice president and the cabinet is what our current bylaw says any other discussion okay let's go ahead and um we'll uh revote for uh trustee Ward for vice president um Miss Garcia please call for a vote we already we already have the Motions in the second but because both failed so we already have them correct parliamentarian I believe
091so okay very good vote again right okay so we're we're rev voting so we're going to start with somebody wants to make a motion for a different individual um Mr Dill yeah I I believe since uh there was a motion and a second a vote twice that the procedure should be that there is a new motion and a second to be voted on again then I'm going to even take it a one step further um I'll entertain additional I'll entertain nominations for the position of Vice President are there any nominations I'd like to nominate trusty Ward for vice president so there there's not a second at this point are there additional nominations hearing none uh may have a mo or may have a motion I will make a motion to um uh to uh have
092trusty Ward be the vice president I have a is there a second second oh sorry okay so um trusty Emory seconded any discussion no discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote truste COC no trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verv no trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 3 to2 thank you uh please let the record show that uh trusty ward has been elected as vice president of the Board of Trustees for 2025 uh 5.4 organization of the board election Clerk of the Board of Trustees the board is now the floor is now open for nominations for Clerk of the board are there any Nom any nominations yes I'd like to nominate Laura sioi truste SII um Laura seosi or trusty seosi has been nominated for clerk are there any additional nominations I would like
093to nominate um truste verth okay we have truste verth and trusty seosi any additional nominations okay um may I have a motion to um may I have a motion to approve trustee seosi as Clerk of the board make a motion for trust COC is there a second I fails for a lack of a second may I have a motion to approve trusty verth as Clerk yes may I have a motion you need to say I I move I I move thank you thank you is there a second I'll second I have a motion uh from trusty seosi a second from trusty Ward is there any discussion yeah I just wanted to say that I I I heard what you said and to respect that I I think it would be a good idea to have
094you on his clerk thank you any additional discussion no additional discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote truste COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verth yes trusty Rollings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you and uh plays at the record show that um trusty verth has been elected as Clerk of the Board of Trustees for 2025 okay then uh we can move on to item 5.5 organization of the board appointment of the interim superintendent as the secretary to the Board of Trustees I recommend we appoint interim superintendent Rick Schmidt as the secretary of the Board of Trustees may I have a motion to approve Mr Schmidt as our secretary and so mve for bef second moved by verth seconded by Ward is there any discussion no discussion Miss Garcia please
095call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verb yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero okay we have item 5.6 organization of the board authorized signatures may have a motion to approve authorized signatures for the district as presented motion second we have a motion by trusty Ward second by trusty verth do we have any discussion no discussion uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty C yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verb yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you and uh IEM 5.7 organization of the board the Schoolboard meeting schedule may have a motion to approve the 2025 schedule of board meetings as presented then I'll make the motion to um approve the uh schedule may have a second second
096we have a second from trusty um Emory uh any discussion trusty Ward thank you um I wanted to ask my colleagues if it would be okay if we could change the date for the February 19th meeting um I won't be present for that meeting and I want to be able to be present at every meeting because my attendance has been perfect so if we could have it at um either on February 5th um is my hope but I can also do it on the 12th those are the two previous Wednesdays um I'm unavailable on the 5th but I could be available on the 12th if other board members are so inclined 12 works for me J forth as well trusty Emory and trusty seos do you have any objections to that okay thank you so
097if we could um uh and our practice is to is to show thumbs so um if we could have thumbs to change the February 19th meeting to the February 12th and so if you okay that's five okay so if we could make that change any other discussion can I ask a question just Beth why are there two regular meetings in June I can answer I can answer that it's very traditional that uh School boards meet twice in June to adopt the budget it's a two-step process and it gives staff time to get those budgets buil by June 30 deadline I just thought it was named something else that's all there's public hearing requirements for the lcap and the budget and they cannot be adopted the same night as the public hearing that's right thank you
098and I will say you will notice that um at this time we do not have a meeting in July um so we do have two meetings in June but we do not have a meeting scheduled for July um are there any is there any other discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote [Music] trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verth yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes by to zero thank you uh 5.8 organization of the board Board of Trustees committee representative appointments for 2025 trustees are there any questions no questions may have a motion to approve the 2025 trustee committee representative appointments as presented motion s I'll second she motions trusty Emory Mo uh made the motion and trusty Ward seconded is there a discussion I have some discussion TR Beth
099yes um I believe when I came on and I was clerk my first year so it's my third year I thought I was on the carlbad health and wellness committee I see now that it is assigned to the board president board vice president since this is my background as an exercise physiologist and I have a passion about it I would really like to be on this meet on this committee um I'm not sure why it's been organized with board president and board vice president I'd be happy to change um and yeah so we'll start with that one so are you asking for consensus for something sure okay I'd like consensus to um add um or take off board president board vice president as a requirement and maybe it's just board president and another trustee I
100don't I don't remember ever seeing board president board vice president as a requirement but maybe it's been that way Kathy or trusty this was as was presented to um to us from uh and I believe uh um Dr Churchill put it together so um I'm not really sure either to be honest um but so I'm not sure what you're asking the um so you're asking for consensus to do what um to remove the board vice president I mean I if Michelle uh trusty Ward wants to be on this committee that's fine I just feel that I'd like to have some um I'd like to to be on that board or on that committee excuse me okay so what I'm hearing you say is you'd like to get consensus to have um uh the president and
101yourself assigned to that committee yes please okay is there a consensus for that uh by a show of thumbs I see at least three thumbs so um if we could make that change uh to that part uh are there other discussion I have a um discussion as well um okay I would like um to um to actually now that if you're going to be on this committee I think it makes it a little easier um I would like uh to be assigned to the subcommittee for career Pathways um with trustee COC so I'd like to see if I could I have consensus for that so there's uh there's at least four thumbs for that so if we could make that change and then um with your permission trust verth um uh if you would be
102uh moved to the audit with trusty seoc cuz as president I would be on more more committees than I think is reasonable so then um uh you would be on the wellness um and then uh you'd be taken off of the career but then assigned to the audit committee okay and then if I could have consensus for that okay so there's five thumbs there um other um other discussion trusty for Beth I did talk about this with our interim superintendent about the Nixie North Coastal Consortium for special education the first year that I served on this we had one meeting last year there was Zero meetings so I just am curious what do we have any plan to create a meeting or who who's in charge of this and how will I know good question
103and and thanks for bringing that up so I I have my first Nixie meeting in January and I will make sure that that is brought up as a topic of discussion and strongly suggest that that committee reconvenes this school year thank any other discussion okay uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verb yes trusty Rollings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you thank you and um item 5.9 organization of the board resolution number 19 12425 role and responsibilities of members of the Board of Trustees I may have a motion to approve resolution number 19 12425 role and responsibilities of members of the board Board of Trustees exhibit D so moved second motion by trusty ver Beth second by trusty Ward is there any
104discussion I would just like to say that um this is the um the resolution in front of you and what we do is that we um we go around uh we we go around in a in a circle to and each one of us reads one section of of this resolution once we've um passed the the motion any other discussion okay Miss Garcia please call for a vote jusy COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verb yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you and I'd like to start with uh truste seosi for uh number one as a school board member I know that my primary responsibility is to the child I am in effect the adult conscience of my community with regard to the welfare of children the welfare
105of the child will therefore be my first consideration in my actions as a board member as a Schoolboard member I know that my second responsibility is to the citizens who elected me I am in effect the will of many people what I do reflects their concerns about human growth and development what I do determines the price they will pay for Educational Services the concerns of District citizens will therefore be my second consideration in my actions as a board member as a Schoolboard member I recognize that I am a major employer what I do will affect the capacity of many people to practice the professional trade in which they have so much personal investment what I do will affect material quality of their lives and the lives of their children Justice for the people I employ
106will therefore be my third consideration in my actions as a board member as a school board member I realize that I represent the authority of government I possess the power to Grant and to deny but the power is not mine individually it represents the delegated authority of the majority in a democracy it should be exercised with concern and care for the least influential member of society that is the rights of the minority must be protected concern for every individual thus be my fourth consideration in my actions as a board member as a Schoolboard member I realized that I am but one element of a policy-making body as such I have no Authority outside the official meetings dependent in part on my ability to work with my fellow board members in a Spirit of Harmony and
107cooperation despite differences of opinion that may arise I further recognize that administration of the educational program and the conduct of school business is the responsibility of the superintendent of schools and his or her staff a sense of loyalty to associate and respect for group decisions cooperatively reached will therefore be my fifth consideration and my action as a board member and trusty sayoc you have the last moment as well as a school board member I acknowledge that I am a separate individual my feelings and Views are unique to me based on my own personal experiences like all other individuals I have something to contribute to the sum of society unlike most individuals I have the opportunity and the responsibility to make some of these contributions as a board member and will do so to the best
108of my ability my personal feelings and Concepts will therefore be my sixth consideration in my actions as a board member thank you and we are now back in regular session we'll now proceed to part six Communications part 1 6.1 report by student representative to the board I now welcome Carl's bed Village Academy student Alish fman who will provide the board with a student report as we approach the end of the semester students at carlbad Village Academy and carlbad seaside Academy are working diligently to finish strong at Seaside students are focused on meeting deadlines to stay on track in their independent study classes the quick turnaround after winter break has added urgency for many students to catch up on assignments and ensure they are fully prepared for the next semester seniors in particular have been highly
109engaged in career exploration and postsecondary preparation at Carlsbad Village Academy students have participated in career chats including a real a recent visit from three C captains of local Trader Joe stores who shared their leadership Journeys and professional insights futures Academy seniors also had the unique opportunity to attend a presentation featuring women's in federal law enforcement gaining valuable perspective on careers in the US Postal Service and related fields as the semester continues seniors at Carl Village Academy will continue their Capstone projects in Senior English which includes career research presentations and mock interviews these activities are designed to help the students develop their professional communication skills skills and prepare for future educational and career opportunities across both Schools students are demonstrating focus and determination as they work to meet their goals and prepare for Success Beyond high
110school at Sage Creek High School this week they're celebrating the winter season with seasonal spirit week Monday was where your favorite flannel day Tuesday was snowed in Wednesday ugly sweater Thursday was Festival fun and Friday white out for national hot ch chocolate day ASB handed out free hot chocolate during lunchtime recently their hoopcoming theme was released with down in the bayou today girls and boys basketball had a game at 5:30 and 7:30 girls soccer will have their game tomorrow at 4:00 and boys soccer at 6 the theme for their games this week is story night lastly girls Rising Club is hosting a supply drive any extra supplies would be appreciated and and all donations will go directly to underprivileged schools in India at carlb high school they are in full go with their winter sports
111we also hosted a laner day market last week with student made vendors like homemade clothes and candles after that they hosted a blood drive gathering over 50 pintes this past weekend they hosted a cheer competition and our cheer team comp completed or comper team completed Bandon marro will have performances this week after everybody returns from breaks students will be preparing for first semester finals and wrapping up the first half of the Year thank you and we now move on to item 6.2 superintendent report Mr Rick Schmitt thank you very much and before I actually share my brief report I'd like to present to you Kathy this uh token of appreciation for your year serving as the president of the Board of Trustees here in the Carl's bed Unified School District and what it says is
112it's from the Carlsbad Unified School District thank you for your dedication and service to the Carlsbad Unified School District and the students staff and families of carlbad December 18 2024 thank you thank you very much I truly appreciate it okay I just uh have two very brief items one just again thanking the trustees and public uh for them believing in me and allowing me to do work to support you and work with this community moving forward over the next uh few months and then I uh attended last Friday and thank you for two of our trustees Miss verth and M Rawlings for joining me at the um local legislative Action Network uh representatives from this District Cardiff Elementary delmare andenas Rancher Santa Fe sandigo and Salon Beach we also had representatives from four elected officials
113in that session and that were representatives from state senators uh Blakes spere and Jones both San Diego County and then Congressman uh Scott Peters and Congressman Mike Levan and the three items as I mentioned uh in in a report a brief report on Friday really was around all three actually were about money imagine that one was the long-term fiscal stability of school districts in the state of California one was special ed funding which has been part of my 40 plus year career Meeting those challenges and then maintaining local control and I thought what was most interesting is regardless of the school district our challenges are really the same with the focus on special ed and again that's not new but the costs each and every year um have escalated um the point of finding being
114uh skilled and credential special Educators to work with our students has become more challenging than ever and the funding comes and it goes it's never really been consistent so there was good discussion and uh good information there I believe and it's always good to get elected officials in the school community in one room and have those really good conversations so again thank the two of you for being there thank you and uh we now move on to item 6.3 oral Communications public comment on non-agenda items this is the time that members of the public have the opportunity to address the board on any non- agendized item that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board how many blue cards have been received for the for non-agenda items we have one blue card thank you
115in order to allow speakers to present their comments and ensure we are able to properly attend to the business of the board per board bylaw 932 2 three public comments will be limited to 20 minutes this means each speaker will have 3 minutes when I call your name please come to the podium state your name and indicate whether or not you live within the boundaries of the school district this uh speaker is Laura pin uh good evening welcome new trustees and interim superintendent it's nice to see all of you tonight um I have two boys that attend Cal elementary school and I am the CEO at um Carl's but Educational Foundation so I believe that both of you are familiar with the foundation but if not we raise funds to support critical programs um if
116in our school district as well as offer programs after school for families and I've got two updates for you tonight uh the first is that uh carlb educational foundations's board of directors just recently approved a three-year strategic plan and uh it is um a place where two emerging themes um really came out reconfirming our direction that we've been heading in the last couple of years um and our commit for the next couple of years so the first is that we are here to bridge educational gaps by creating and support not creating but supporting critical music and steam programs and what this looks like in practice is that above all else um when we're prioritizing our funding we're going to make sure that we're protecting things like Elementary music teachers Elementary steam teachers um music education
117within our secondary programs so some of those core programs and funding that the districts come accustomed to um the second thing that we are looking to elevate and and continue to fund is that we are going to fund Foster and facilitate Innovative programs and in a couple of ways this year it looks like we rolled out teacher grants to our secondary teachers and so this allowed us to give funds directly to secondary teachers that had innovative ideas or needed extra funding to elevate things in their classroom um and the other area is that we fund a number of programs within our Career Education space and with the recent approval of the CD's TK through um 12 Career Development Continuum and the Strategic plan um we are looking forward to continuing to support programs that that
118elevate um that initiative and so at this time of the year I also want to just remind the community and remind the board that this is made possible because of our amazing community that either chooses to um put their kids in carlb Educational Foundation programs again these proceeds go towards funding these vital programs um but really importantly it's also the philanthropic giving and so we are heading towards the end of our annual fund Drive um our goal was to raise $50,000 during this campaign and we're about halfway there and this last part of the month is a really critical piece and I just want to encourage um the whole Community is any little amount help so just getting involved and helping to really Elevate this philanthropic Community is what we're here to do and to
119help our students and so um at this time we just we wish everybody a great happy holiday and a safe time off and hope that you will consider us during your annual giving thank you thank you we now move on to part seven consent calendar all matters listed on the consent calendar are considered by the board to be routine and will be enacted by the board in one motion there will be no discussion on these items prior to the to the time the board votes on the motion unless there is a board request for one or more specific items to be removed from the consent calendar for discussion have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards with no blue cards uh trustees are there any items to be pulled for
120discussion none to be pulled may I have a motion to approve the consent calendar so moved second we have a motion from trusty verth second from trusty Ward Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verb yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to part eight uh information discussion action items item 8. one first inter room financial report for the period ending October 31st 2024 trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Mr Eric Dale thank you president Rawlings uh this evening I will be presenting the first interim budget report this is the first update to the board on the state of the district's budget uh since adoption of the budget in
121June uh often the board is adopting the budget before all things are known in Sacramento as their their budget act often is not passed until after uh our requirement to pass a a budget uh and then there's other developments that happen through the year and so this is uh our opportunity to bring those uh changes to you for review and I'll walk you through the changes in revenue and expenditures um a as we see them thus far what I will say is um that the first interim budget report is probably always the worst case scenario budget uh for the district and the reason why is that we've added in uh expenditures that have carried over from the previous year um we haven't had a chance to really capture Savings in budgets and reduce them at
122this point in the year and that's the work that we do between now and the second interim budget and the estimated actuals in the spring so really what you see is uh probably our our our highest expectation of what our expenditures would be also the lowest expectation of what our Revenue would be and both of those things will move as we get through the year so here's where we are uh as of today in the themes um we will uh present to you a positive certification that means we can meet our uh Financial Obligations for the current and the next two fiscal years and maintain our minimum reserves uh we have uh adjusted the beginning balances this is another thing that is not known uh when we adopt the budget in June we have an
123estimate on what our ending balances will be from last year but then we close the books and we have the actual number that becomes the beginning balances for this year uh so I have adjusted those in in this report as well and uh finally uh next month is when we start budget development for the following school year uh That season begins officially on January 10th when the governor releases his budget proposal to the legislature so uh the very highlevel summary uh the all-in comparison of adopted budget to First interim you can see uh changes to revenue and expenditures I I'm not going to dwell on this slide uh too much but this is the very high level summary you see the asterisks next to beginning balance and ending balance those are as adjusted after we
124close the book so if you were to look back at the adopted budget report you would have a different number but for purposes of this slide I wanted to make things um all things being equal if uh if we had known down to the penny where our balance would be it would have been that um there are two pieces of uh of the general fund there's the unrestricted general fund and the restricted general fund uh the restricted general fund are those dollars that uh come with strings attached and that's mainly from the federal government and the state funding uh so we receive uh um dollars uh uh from from that but we can only spend them in certain ways and so uh we always capture those restricted funds separately from the unrestricted the unrestricted is
125the bulk of our of our general fund and those really are for the most part our uh free purpose dollars that we can spend for uh any operational reason that that we see fit uh so this is why it's also important to show the difference between between the unrestricted and restricted uh because the the most important thing is the unrestricted ending balance uh just a a walk down memory lane I I always like to show this slide just graphically showing where we've been over the years uh in a perfect world dollars in would equal dollars out every year uh but we don't live in a perfect world so uh sometimes we uh we have a little bit more Revenue than our expenditures other years we've have a little bit more in expenditures than we have
126in Revenue um you know the trick is to make that as tight as possible and in the last few years um the the patterns have been a little different in that uh we received significant amounts of onetime money through grants one-time uh infusions of of funding uh related to covid and and the uh recovery after that and very often those dollars were received in one year but spent in the following year so we'll see a spike in Revenue one year and if we don't spend all of that Revenue then next year we see a spike in expenditures and that really has been the pattern uh for us so the the green and the and the blue are total general fund revenue and expenditures but I do break out the unrestricted ending balance in and the
127restricted ending balance in the in the orange and the black so you can see across uh you know relative stability as we look across over the years and the final two I have the uh the dotted line there uh as this budget is presented to you uh throughout the year here to the to the right of the dotted line we'll see how the budget report has changed uh since the last iteration that we bring to you um this will be the first time that you'll that two trustees will hear me say that the budget is a plan and so we adopt the plan in June uh and it is a plan throughout the year and then we close the books and we come back and tell you what really happened so it's a plan it's
128a plan it's a plan and then we and then uh we close the books and we know what happened so this is just a reflection of our plans as they sit today so now uh getting into the changes uh in Revenue um a slight in uh adjustment in the local control funding formula and property tax that's less than a percent uh so we watch that uh Revenue as it comes in uh and so we'll make adjustments on on that as we get more information from the uh property tax collector uh we are what is called a basic Aid District or a community funded District which means right now we are exceeding our entitlement to local control funding formula so we get to keep that excess tax uh that's kept uh us Treading Water this year
129uh compared to where we thought we would be a year ago uh it's fortunate that we now our basic Aid uh as uh uh we're not as subject to um what is going on economically at the state level and the state's ability to fund public education and we are not going to be as subject to swings in average daily attendance impacting our Revenue it really is our local tax base however those are reported on the same line whether it's lcff or property tax you're always going to see that on the top line Federal uh it's it's very common to see minor adjustments on federal revenue throughout the year uh state revenue I'll talk about that in just a moment um the bulk of that is a is revenue that is a transaction on paper and
130I'll walk you through that on the on the next slide as I break it down and then local Revenue uh you just heard Miss pittz uh talk about donations that uh that CF has has brought into the District also our ptas and other people who are generous and and give us donation dollars also things like facility use would be included in our our local Revenue because we don't know if somebody's going to rent a facility or write us a check uh we don't put in a budget for that revenue for donations until it actually comes in so there are some things that we do get commitments from CF and we do budget for that because uh they have a history of supporting us at certain levels and they give us commitments um but other smaller
131donations we recognize that Revenue as it comes in often as we we receive a donation Revenue it that also comes with strings attached because the donor would like us to use it for a specific purpose so you'll see the expenditure budget go up at the same clip so uh just in words uh talking about uh the changes really I'll talk about the state revenue um the big piece on that is what's called stirs on behalf and you're going to see the exact same Dollar on the expenditure side as well um this is revenue that we don't receive for an expenditure that we don't have uh it's something that we just have to recognize on paper the uh the value of the state's contribution to the state teachers retirement system that they make on our behalf
132we have to show it on our books but they don't actually give us money for it and we don't actually make that expenditure so we added in that uh the value of that stirs on behalf uh at first interim so uh both revenue and expenditures went up by that exact same dollar amount uh as we reflected that in in the budget uh on special education uh we had some adjustments in the revenue and that's always good to see uh more Revenue um we as part of a selpa um we you share revenue and we we get allocations of Revenue based on all the all of the district's attendance in the selpa and so as they might other districts will Decline and grow at different rates they they true up those um those amounts to us
133and so it's it's uh sometimes dependent on where other districts are landing on how much passes through to our district in the Sela so we did see an increase in sped Revenue so that's that's very good news um CTE we had uh uh two grants that we had award letters for um that were the dollar amounts were not known and adopted so we've added in uh the value of of those two CTE grants and we also had an adjustment on our Lottery revenue and at the bottom I mentioned uh on the previous slide uh why we increase GR Grant and donation Revenue as it comes in through the year so just Revenue components uh again looking looking back and on the right side of the dotted line looking forward from adoption to where we are
134now um the the if you look at the blue which is our the the most valuable piece of Revenue that we have our our lcff and property tax um that's the the largest and most stable amount the the green and the orange representing are federal and state revenue um we're definitely settling down on the federal revenue to what our historical level has been uh we had spikes you will notice uh that those bars were bigger in 2020 2021 20232 because we were receiving um support from the federal government that we don't normally receive same with uh the state revenue um those dollars definitely grew in 2021 and 22 um and now we've seen those funds not pass through in this upcoming current year so uh we're coming back down to earth on um on the
135state revenue as well so we're getting kind of back to our historical levels of funding uh for federal and state and again the black bar that's going to keep growing throughout the year as we as we recognize uh more local Revenue so this slide here uh just uh points out uh our status as a basic Aid district with uh the blue bar being our entitlement to local control funding formula Revenue uh under the current uh Grant amounts for uh the base Grant and the supplemental Grant uh multiplied times our average daily attendance and the Orange Line being the value of our property tax that we receive and so right now in 2024 you can see that the orange line is above the blue bar and so that is when you are in community funded status
136and we are able to retain that that excess Revenue um had we not been uh so close to basic Aid status this year you see that we would have had a decline in that Revenue because of uh declining enrollment plus um a very low cost of living adjustment on the local control funding formula this year so uh very fortunate for us that we ended up this year exactly where we thought we would be a year ago before the cola dropped and then uh using some cautious assumptions on everything our property tax growth and uh cautious uh assumptions on our uh enrollment and the projection out on the local control funding formula uh it looks like we are in basic Aid to stay this time this is the third time that the district has entered into
137basic Aid uh we were during the Great Recession when State funding was cut uh below our property tax level so we were basic Aid by accident that uh during that time uh we dipped a toe in the water in in 2020 2021 uh and that was really because the state did not fund a cola that year so we just blipped uh briefly in and and the following year we we fell out of it um but as far as as we can see out into the future we're going to remain in basic Aid okay now moving on uh to expenditures um and uh I think it's probably better if I just move on to the next slide because I've got the explanations uh as I as I go through each of of these items um so
138moving on uh certificate and classified salaries uh you we did add some additional Middle School support teachers um this year using the uh Arts music instructional materials discretionary block grant um we also uh added in the value of those donation funded hourly support teachers so as we saw the revenue come in we also had this obligation to um to meet the will of the donors and and provide that hourly support so that comes in by way of of um U the donation funded out or at lease support donations the uh the third item on there uh that's captured savings uh for instructional assistance and vacancies that we've had to date uh some of that has had to be moved over into the services category as we've had an obligation to still provide the services to
139students as we've look to find people to fill those roles um I'll say that uh that our vacancies this year are much lower than they have been in Prior years and so we're doing a much better job at uh being able to hire our own people which is definitely what our goal is in in all of this we would rather spend uh those dollars on our own folks um and um it's much more cost- effective than agencies that add profit and overhead on top of of that cost on uh on benefits uh stirs on behalf again that's an equal amount that you saw on the revenue side so it really has no impact on on the bottom line some districts don't even don't put this in until the end of the year um we we've
140typically put it in either at adoption or at first um depending on if we can get that calculation in on time um so the next two items uh you were um were not planned for and so this is where I say that um in a number of budget categories uh we did not have the correct rates in for Health and Welfare benefits and some other statutory benefits and it was spread out through the entire budget and so we've as we have looked at at uh projecting out those benefit costs throughout the end of the year we noticed that we needed to make this adjustment so this is this was something that was incorrect at adoption we've made that uh correction now uh as we head into our budget adoption cycle beginning next month uh we're
141looking at exactly how did that happen so that we make sure that as we are building the budget for next year we've got the correct rates in for every one of our budget categories so that we're accurately budgeting for um both our Health and Welfare and our other statutory benefits so U my apologies uh to the board for for that um and then materials and services um that's a rather large number when we add all of that up but that really is the carryover so it's the restricted carryover that was uh for federal and state funds that were not spent last year those dollars are now available to spend this year um and so we it is very very typical that you see a large increase for materials and supplies and services related to carryover
142um uh at first interim because we didn't know what those balances were going to be before we closed the books now we know what that is we release that back either to departments or to school sites uh for them to be able to use often there's there's also uh carryover in some donation funds that the sites have and so we release those dollars back to the sites and they build those back into their budgets um mainly for material books supplies and other materials um so that's all captured in that 2.6 million that part was not a surprise uh so expenditure components uh again just looking at those those different categories and how that compares uh looking back over the the previous years and where we were at adopted and um and just showing that graphically
143so getting into the ending balance and our multi-year projection um pulling this apart uh looking at the unrestricted and restricted ending balances um and and as we move out through the year you'll see the second interim column being added and then the estimated actuals at adoption so you'll see all four uh estimates of the budget uh as as we move through the year um you know ultimately the ending fund balance uh drops by 2.4 million uh it's uh roughly a change of um of a little over a million uh on the unrestricted side uh and then the the other 1.4 is million uh is on the restricted side uh we've got components of the the ending balance below and uh we are able to uh you know meet our board required 5% uh minimum reserve
144and also retain the other commitments that the board has uh for the ending balance as well so uh we do meet our our positive certification uh criteria this is really um explained on the next slide here uh showing that uh as we look out to the uh to the ne the next two years plus this year um we do have sufficient reserves to meet our minimum reserve requirements uh for the next two years so next step for us uh is that we would request that you adopt the first inter budget uh report uh we will be watching the governor's budget proposal on January 10th uh as a basic Aid District uh the cost of living adjustment that he will mention uh is or propose uh is not as important to us because uh our revenue
145is not coming from the local control funding formula however that's important to us for special education Revenue um expanded learning opportunities program Revenue a number of other state programs uh that we have so we'll be watching that in addition to whether or not there are any other one-time uh funding proposals that might be mentioned that we would qualify for so um I have have the the pleasure of watching all three hours of uh the governor's press conference when it happens uh and I download all the information and will'll provide uh a very quick highlevel summary to the board on January 10th of how I see those proposals potentially impacting Carl's Bad unified and so with that uh I'm ready for uh I'll throw it back to trusty Rawlings for public comment discussion and questions thank
146you uh this is the time for public comment have any BL card has been received we do not have any blue cards with no blue cards uh trustees do you have any questions trusty Emy yes I have a question um when you're referring to the Health and Welfare benefits and that rate shift is that due to I know that Viva saw some unintended increases that were unexpected or is that due to another um calculation there no that that was a budget error and so uh it it at this point in the year um you we did have the rates uh in an estimate of the rate increases for next year um but some of those rates were it was Prior year that was built in and so that was something that was not caught and
147we've made that adjustment other questions trusty Ward so I'm just trying to understand this so if you can explain it to me so um you were saying that there were some increases that they they will Lev level out with the stir stirs on behalf payments can you just explain little and is State giving us money back and so that I know they pay a portion of that right correct so if you could just explain that to me a little sure it's it's my least favorite part of the budget because because none of it is actually real um so uh many years ago um the government Accounting Standards Board released a requirement that uh required districts to report in their budgets the value of the state's contribution to stirs that they make on our behalf so
148you know there's three pieces of it there's the district's contribution there's the employees contribution and then the state also makes a contribution to stirs um you know we very clearly show our contribution because that's our cost um the employees contribution comes out of their paychecks so that doesn't show up in our budget uh but then we have this basically Phantom expenditure that occurs um and so we put on the revenue side and the expenditure side exactly equal amounts that are our estimate of what the state's contribution on our behalf is that's why it's called stirs on behalf and we track it separately from our other stir payments um and so uh so that is just built into the budget and again because we're showing revenue and expenditures going up by the exact same amounts it
149has no impact on our bottom line whatsoever and and so at the we'll we'll show this as in the budget they don't actually occur when we close the budget uh when we close the books those will also be in there um but it's not that we ever have a chance to save or pay more and if the stirs rates change we just have a different estimate for that same dual entry of equal amounts of Revenue and expenditure but that's still contributing to our expenditure increase right uh no because it's um the uh well it it shows up as an expenditure increase but we also have an exactly corresponding increase in Revenue at the same time okay yeah other questions I have a question on slide 11 when you talk about the carryover can you give
150more specific examples of how that money is being used and when it was determined on how it was going to be used uh so so with donation uh amounts um the those dollars are released back to the school sites and so they use that and the best practice for them because it often comes from PTA and it's dollars that weren't spent in the prior year is for sites to work with their PTA and saying hey this is dollars that we received and we have this AA available to us in our account and you know the best practice is to talk with your PTA and say you know how can we use this um because it it started with parent dollars and I always say try to spend 100% of that donation money every year because
151the parents gave it for their kids to be used that year but sometimes things come in at the end of the year it'll carry over into the next um and so those dollars are are put back and it's part of the school sit's discretionary budget that is roughly $750,000 um and and this year the the other uh really good example of carryover would be state lottery so we could have um instructional materials Lottery funds um that might have been budgeted for expenditures last year that did not occur and so now we have a higher balance uh this year in the lottery uh instructional materials budget and so that gets put back into an expenditure budget what we didn't spend last year and it bumps up the uh the expenditure budget for the lottery resource what
152I'm asking is that do we have something specific like is there a textbook adoption or is there a curriculum that we're um that we didn't spend all the money last year so we're spending it this year that kind of thing yeah uh we we do have a number of adoptions going on and we've been um braiding together funds from the instructional materials block grant and also the lottery instructional materials um resource and so you know the timing of those adoptions could be that exactly what you say we didn't make all of the expenditures last year but we know we're going to have to make that this year so we're building in an expenditure budget in Lottery we have the funds available because we didn't spend them last year so this is a good example of
153what I mentioned earlier where sometimes we receive money last year we now we're going to spend it this year so it looks like we had a surplus in lottery last year now it looks like we have a deficit in Lottery because we're spending more than we are taking in and so you'll see those those imbalances Lottery is probably the next the the the biggest one that we have in in this we could also see uh some carryover amounts in special education um our preschool um our early preschool intervention Grant um that's something that's being spent year over year over year um our educator Effectiveness Grant um is is running out um but we would obviously take uh any available funds to spend before the deadline runs out on educator Effectiveness and so Dr NY has
154that available for to fund some additional PD this year so that would be some of the services that we might be sending people to conferences so it's it's a lot of dollars that are spread out over multiple categories that adds up to $2.6 million Dr n no I was just goingon to say that typically um a bulk of that tends to be with instructional materials and so science is a great example last year uh where we'll it'll span over multiple years where we think we're going to adopt in a certain year it gets pushed off to the next year and and so those funds are are credited for that so that's where we see a little bit of that happening from year to year where expenditures aren't aren't used or they're um added to a
155new year other questions I have others trusty GTH thank you um thank you for that presentation Mr D um so on the same slide additional Middle School support teachers were funded and that came through a decision that was made um by staff I believe sometime in August when the board was notified I had made requests at least two maybe three times if we could add additional help for middle school for secondary um so my question is how did that come about and um could we find money for our high school students and teachers I think I'll let Dr NY address how that happened I was just involved on the funding piece but yeah I believe it was discussed um in August and then approved I believe in September when we talked about um adding some
156additional Middle School support um based on some of the um data that we received back as it related to standardized test scores and the like and so we were able to use one-time dollars uh again to um add the three additional mtss support teachers at the middle school we need to go through that process again at the high school if we wanted to um do that for potentially next year we've been working uh with High School principles on um on Intervention and how they're um meeting the needs of students that are not meeting standards um it's a littleit more complex than just adding one teacher at the high school level uh versus the Elementary in the Middle School level where that works a little bit neater um but certainly through the alcat process we could
157that discussion as well thank you and trusty Ward I you may have had a follow up that and I skipped you I apologize so go ahead no it's okay um and I think it's pretty basic but uh so when I was looking at your exhibit a I just want to make sure that when you're referencing um the materials and services here is that the same as the books and supplies line items because I'm trying to match kind of the the funding and it's um sorry should have said books well okay to me it's like books materials supplies okay CU in books and supplies you have materials and and supplies I'm just trying to figure out but they're the same thing okay got it thank you other questions I have a few more okay um on
158slide 14 and I also want to say thank you very much for answering a lot of my questions in advance because I I don't have nearly the questions I would have had otherwise so I appreciate that um I had lots of questions um so on um slide 14 you had said that um uh my first question is is what is the statutory requirement for the State uh reserve for economic uncertainties for district our size it would be 3% 3% and you had said that um the board had directed to go make it 5% correct could you show me where in this slide that's indicated that amount and what that amount would be the overage the 2% over the statutory State requirement well it's all in this $8.8 million in the uh unrestricted assigned SL unassigned
159so the very bottom line on the uh first interim unrestricted column okay and then what por what is the 2% over the statutory amount do you know you know I'd have to do the math in my head very quickly so it's about 40% of that number would that be I was just going to say yeah it's it's it's 40% of that number so 40% of that number two fifths of that number okay great two F two fifths of that number okay and then um uh and then uh as far as under commitments um we have I think we could still call it a stabilization fund correct a where in that um item and how much is for the stabilization Fund in the commitments uh if I can be precise $3,124 th000 and some change okay
160very good 3 committed aspect correct okay okay okay and and thank you again for answering my other questions and uh and assuring that we won't be having that Health and Welfare benefit um happen again I appreciate that yes are there other questions no other questions may have a motion to approve the submission of the first interim financial report as of October 31 2024 exhibit a a motion to approve I have a motion from Emory I have a second I'll second a second from trusty SE and discussion I I have um uh some discussion that I'd like to uh try to get a consensus from the board on um and it was it was part of my questions that I had uh recently asked but if um you look at the actual report the financial report
161for the um uh for the first interim and if you look at page I don't know is that something that we can be brought up or should we just do it here or okay and I did have this conversation um they understood what my request was going to be um so I just wanted to um uh so um as we discussed I got to make mine bigger here there we go okay so um as we just discussed um just Rawlings I the correct page here should be page 13 okay um no I think it's further down it should be that um uh it should have committed stabilization Arrangements object code 9750 it's the cover page was thrown me okay all right correct I don't think that's it it's one more down page 13 it says
162page 13 of 122 okay maybe I AP it's page 14 okay commit stabilization arrangements okay no that that's you know okay I think I know where you're I think I know where you're going hang on we just let's see I page 20 sorry I'm looking at object code let me see here if that helps um object codee 9750 I'm sorry I'm just I was going by page 13 of the PDF document right and it's this right okay okay that doesn't look like it either that looks like it there it is okay okay very thank you got you okay thank you sorry about that um uh so as part of my questions that I had asked um Mr Dill um uh many years ago the board gave Direction um to um to have a stabilization Arrangement
163under object code 9750 these dollars have been set aside for at least nine years that I'm aware of and they've never been used for the purpose that they've been set aside for as well as if you look at object code 9789 um which he had just just um referred to in the slide that was and it's now approximately um 8,732 461 the state only requires that the board uh set aside 3% for economic uncertainty uncertainties and the former board had directed staff to um to set aside 5% so approximately 40% of those dollars um are above and beyond and were directed by a previous board so what I would like to recommend is is that we take the stabilization Arrangement and we put 40% or whatever what is equal to 2% over the state requirement
164and that we collapse that into one object code that states uh board lcap priorities which my math um shows a little over over $7 million would be placed in that lcap into uh the board lcap priorities um portion of the the budget so it doesn't really change the budget it just rep prioritizes how we as a board decide that we want to spend those dollars and um to address what you were talking about trust ver Beth I think that that would be a way as um they were saying that if we want additional teachers that we need to we need to move the money around in order to um prioritize um what you were talking about as far as additional teachers at at the high school or whatever the board decides to so I want
165to see if I can uh get consensus to ask the um uh to direct staff as had been done in the past to take those two areas and collapse them into a lcap um a board lcap priorities fund just hear me uh can staff explain what the stabilization was previously uh designed for and what if any implications there might be in doing so um yes it can you do that uh sure um so this was set up uh I think I back in uh 2015 I think it was um when the district was moving in and out of basic Aid or they they they foresaw that um and when you go into basic Aid um there are a couple of risks that you have um one is if you have a sudden growth in enrollment
166that doesn't come with growth in Revenue because you're relying on the property tax base and so uh boards and I've been in two other basic Aid districts sometimes they will set aside dollars to say if we need to hire more teachers but we don't have the additional property tax revenue to do it we have set aside dollars in our ending balance to to handle um that extra unforeseen expense that came with having more kids without more property tax revenue that would be one um another uh issue that happens in your first two years of basic Aid um in year two which would be next year um there will be a transfer of property tax dollars to uh to state authorized Charters that are educating our students so uh and so they get a piece of
167what otherwise would be their lcff and so uh that would be a loss of property tax revenue uh for us in year two um and you know you're what you hope is that your tax growth is enough to cover that loss and then in your uh the second year after you become basic Aid um you lose what is called supplemental uh Revenue uh supplemental tax tax revenue that's Revenue that when uh properties turn over they were assessed at this value the new owner comes in they pay a supplemental tax bill on the new value of the house uh and for some reason and I've never looked into it basic Aid districts don't qualify to get that extra Revenue it shows up on the permanent tax roll the following year but the first year the new
168owner pays that half of a year on a higher assessed value property we don't get that for some reason that's about $2 million a year um in our budget right now um that in two years um will no longer be a property tax source that we will receive so again you know the the district would hope that uh that our property tax growth is uh grows enough to cover the Lo and the secured role grows enough to cover that loss of Revenue that we would receive but if for some reason it didn't these dollars would be there to fill that hole and smooth out that Peak and Valley um this why I say in year three of being basic Aid that's when it starts to get fun uh because now you've got your new base
169of your revenue and then it just starts growing year over year over year and you don't have those other hits of where you actually have some losses those happen in year one and year two following year first year this is actually year zero for us next year would be year one the following year would be year two yes and I I just want to if that was necessary that could be used for that that purpose correct well it depends on the size of the loss of property tax revenue it would come out of the reserves um uh if we had a Ser the following years we're still in discussion but if we want to ask additional questions certainty of of having reserves um you know in terms of um if you um and and I
170can explain the difference between commitments and assignments um unassigned unappropriated up to committed and we changed the name of stabiliz desires to sustain uh levels of Staffing or types of programs um priorities and say staff we direct you to use this Reserve to sustain this program there to um cover any shortfall of revenue for programs that we didn't want to jeopardize um so you could change the value of that the difference between a commitment and an assignment a commitment is something that the board directs staff and says set dollars aside for this uh and we can't use it for other purposes without you saying either it's okay to draw down on those dollars um on assignments uh that is where uh we staff can say hey we want to set dollars aside for this and
171we can make decisions of course ultimately bringing the budget for approval there's more flexibility in assignments um but we could so then the staff could make an assignment for secondary at the high school level like you did in August because the board didn't approve that so staff staff made that approval right is that correct so you could do that again um we could keep it as is seeing that we haven't entered basic Aid yet and we don't really know how we we're not stable in basic aade yet would you recommend that we stay the course right now and leave things as is because there are so many moving Parts at this point um it you know what I would say is really the the ending balance if you if you think about it has no
172real bearing on this year really it has a bearing on how we use these dollars for next year because these are the dollars that we have not put it that that are available they're in the bank account but they're not in our monthly bud of expenditures if if if that makes sense of of how to think of of um this is the savings account so um we have not um made any obligations on all of those dollars in the ending balance and we would expect them if all if we were to shut the doors today we would expect to have the this many dollars uh in the bank account at the end of the year that we could use for next year for whatever purpose so I you know I would say that that for
173purposes of this budget and what the what we're talking about this evening um it really makes no difference because we're not talking about this year's expenditures if we're talking about committing next year's ending balance where this would come into play is as we're developing the budget um and we're bringing it forward and we're saying here's our estimate on Revenue in here's our estimate on expenditures out here is what is left over and and if the board would like to call every dollar in the ending balance something we can give names to those dollars that are in the ending balance if you want to commit them you can commit them if you want to just say no just throw it all in the unassigned and you know uh and and be free with it that those
174are board decisions um that they could direct us to do and that and so that would then particularly if we um uh if we do have a shortfall for next year in the budget development process you could say well we know that we've got these dollars in the budget stabilization account please use these dollars to sustain this program and we could do that so it it it really is a decision for this upcoming year and not so much of of how we're going to call this in this current year um but we could certainly um do this exercise of if we were to uh just shift those dollars up into that um work on that for second interim and maybe through some updates we can say this is I could mock it up of this
175is what it would look like and if that's what we would like to put in second interum we could put it in second interim um we could have it at estimated actuals we could have it in the adopted budget I mean we we have we would have that flexibility to to do that um but it really makes no difference in terms of tonight's budget what we do because really we're talking about the expenditures and the and the revenue tonight other discussion I would just like to say as far as as long as I've been on the board um uh and that's been nine years we have not used that stabilization fund at all and we've gone in and out of of basic Aid and the economic uncertainties we have definitely gone through some uncertainties um
176over the last several years and the previous board um would not utilize those dollars for those uncertainties which I personally think that there could have been I mean I I've talked about this for many many years so this isn't a new con for me as far as I believe this money should be used in the classroom and not just sitting in a bank account um for for a just in case because you know we've been talking about just in case for the last nine years and there have been in my opinion there have been um areas where we could have used these dollars that could have been um better used um in my opinion uh for our students um and so that's where that's the reason why I'm bring it up now because we are
177in first interim and that um it by the time we get to second interim we're in the spring and we're talking about our priorities for lcap and and as we've talked uh trust Beth about you know some additional priorities for interventions or for other things that we that we as a board want to want to determine that we do with these dollars um and again a previous board directed these dollars in One Direction and what I'm suggesting is that this board uh uh direct them in another in another way trusty Ward I wonder if um I know he I know Mr Dill offered to do a mockup of what that would look like is that something that he could do when he well the prise is that it would be um uh that if we
178say that this is where we want the the dollars to be committed we could just direct staff to do that and then um the budget would remain the same it would just be called something different and that those dollars would be there but I I guess from my perspective I what I'm asking for consensus for us is that um is that the board direct staff to do that and then when we are in lcap discussions we have the option to um to maybe tap into those dollars if we choose to so that's why I want to make sure that we do it now so then at lcap time that we have that opportunity so then what I'm hearing you say is for the stabilization Arrangement monies then we would be renaming that as an lcap
179board lcap priorities board lcap priorities and we would also take the additional 2% above State um requirements under there as well yes okay right so that that's my request of the board and what I'm also hearing Mr Dill say is regardless of what it's called not the uncertainty funds but the stabilization we can utilize that however we'd like so the difference would be the change of the name and the additional cost from the from the um additional 2% correct okay however as Mr Dill said that if you know if things are looking uncertain and that we're concerned about programs or whatever well we could say that our priority is as a board our priority is this and so it still matches with the the intent of those dollars it's just the board the board directs
180those dollars in more of a I guess more of a practical and functional way instead of them sitting in a in a um Reserve so it's more in my view it's more flexible for the board trusty say did you you look like you have something as far as discussion yes well I'm kind of chewing on Mr Dill's comment about us being on year zero and I'm wondering if this might be a really wise decision to be done a year or two from now when we've ridden this wave and we're in a different uh time thank you for that is there any other discussion tra Beth yes so the board the pre previous boards over the last nine years have had some pretty sharp people who have studied numbers um who I've you know I've known
181personally who I've you know I think we very qualified in looking at you know our budget and with the uncertainty I I'm just not comfortable yet I would rather wait um and um you know we're not even in basic Aid yet we haven't even that won't be till the end of this year so I'd I'd like to ride this wave like truste COC is commenting on and um weight it out a little bit so I will not be in favor of this thank you trusty w i I just wanted to respond to trust COC that um I I think that's a valid point um however I do want to just remind us of the fact that we could also go back into those funds so if we did need those monies we could use we
182can direct staff to pull them out again does that make sense so it's essentially just moving the money and not that we can't access it but it gives us the opportunity to fund things like the Intervention Program at the secondary level and things like that so we have it available to us and for students so any other discussion okay so can I see thumbs for um those in favor okay there's three thumbs if you could uh make that happened I'd appreciate that and any other discussion okay then uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote truste COC no trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verbet no trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 3 to2 thank you and uh we'll now move on to item 8.2 resolution number 18-24 25 adoption of the annual and 5-year
183reportable fees report for fiscal year 2324 in compliance with governance government code sections 66006 and 66001 developer fees trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Mr Eric Dill thank you this is an annual routine item where we deliver a report to the board uh showing the amount of developer fees we collected the amount that we uh expended out of those funds um and then potential uses for those which are all detailed in the report um and so we ask that the board approve the resolution uh and that accepts the report thank you this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you trust do you have any questions no questions I may have a motion to
184approve resolution number 18 12425 adoption of the annual 5-year reportable fees report for fiscal year 2324 in compliance with government code section 66006 and 66001 developer fees exhibit a so moved I'll second motion by truste verth second by trusty seosi is there any discussion no discussion trustees May or I'm Sorry Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty RAB yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to item 8.3 approval cusd Luna tenative agreement trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to miss Mrs Megan Aras thank you um the district and Le bargaining teams have held negotiation sessions throughout the year and a tenative agreement was reached and signed by the parties on
185November 25th 2024 the agreement was then ratified by leuna members on December 11th 2024 the tenative agreement states that unit members will be provided a 4.5% on schedule salary increase effective July 1st 2024 for classified staff who are employed on the first day of the month following ratification by the board and a 1.5% one-time bonus of the annual salary based on the employees annual Sal salary on the newly adopted salary schedule the 1.5% one-time bonus will be based on a full year of the contracted annual salary in their current position regardless of the employee start date it is respectfully recommended that the Board of Trustees approve the cusd Luna tenative agreement dated November 25th 2024 exhibit a the accompanying ab1 1200-2 756 Financial disclosure which certifies that the district can meet its Financial Obligations under
186the proposed agreement in the current year as well as two years out exhibit B and the accompanying salary schedule Exhibit C thank you thank you uh this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards with no blue cards trustees do you have any questions no questions may have a motion to approve the CD Luna tenative agreement dated November 25 2024 exhibit a the accompanying AB 1200 2756 Financial disclosure exhibit B and the accompanying salary schedule Exhibit C so moved second trusty Ward moved trusty verth second any discussion no discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes Trust verb yes trusty Rings yes motion passes 5 to Zer thank you we now move on to item
1878.4 request for proposal to conduct superintendent search trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Mrs Megan Aras thank you on October 10th 2024 former superintendent Ben Churchill informed the board that he would be resigning effective December 1st 2024 in order to conduct a comprehensive search for the district's next superintendent it is appropriate for the board to enlist the services of a professional consultant or executive firm to facilitate the process by enlisting the services of an outside entity the board will be able to cast a wide net for qualified candidates and remain competitive during this highly specialized Recruitment and selection process it is recommended that the Board of Trustees approv the request for proposals to engage the services of a professional consulting firm to assist the board with the
188search and selection of a new superintendent exhibit a it is further recommended that the board appoint an ad hoc subcommittee to conduct reference checks to be reviewed by the full board when determining finalists to inter uh to invite for a final interview I'm happy to answer any questions thank you thank you this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards with no blue cards trustees do you have any questions I do truste ver so I'm brand new to all this I think a few of us are um if we get some names if some names are thrown into the pot let's say that are people who are already available how do like do you have to go through a search firm if you end
189up with somebody who's qualified we interview and we like how does this work well the first decision would be do you want to use an executive Search form to conduct the whole Recruitment and selection process or do you want to handle it just in-house um either way if there's candidates that are interested um if there is an executive Search firm used we would funnel those candidates through to the executive Search firm that they're interested um otherwise if it's in-house we'd be recruiting and collecting names as well is that a follow up yeah just well is it is it appropriate to ask about what's the average cost of these search firms so they'll vary from firm to firm um what I can say is that um historically we have used a cons consult ANS and firms
190um in this District um so costs are going to vary but when we used them um in the past to replace uh Dr lovelyy with Dr Churchill um it cost 25,000 and that was in 2016 um and then to replace uh before that to replace um Dr Roach with Dr lovelyy they had hired two independent Consultants um they spent about 15,000 and that was in 2012 so I would anticipate anything from about 25 to 30 or it could be a little bit more again it will depend on the firms um if if we go with the search firm they will include all those costs in their um submission when we do a request for proposals other questions or follow-ups may I have a motion to approve the request for proposal to engage the services of
191a professional consultant firm to assist the board with the search and selection of a new superintendent exhibit a it is a further recommended that the board appoint an ad hoc subcommittee to conduct reference checks to be reviewed by the full board when determining finalists to invite for an interview motion second we have a a motion by trusty Ward second by trusty verth do we have discussion I do have discussion as well I thought the same thing I was um thinking like gosh if you know we just have 10 candidates why do we need a search firm and all that and um uh I do believe with a um an interim superintendent that's not you know full time and then um with um uh with Mr Dill also leaving I just I think it would be
192an overload um for our staff so that that from my perspective that's when I kind of said I'm not going to ask that question so that was something that I was um as just to you know kind of address what you were saying as well um trusty Emery oh go ahead yeah along that same um lines coming from um another District that has also hired numerous superintendents I have to say I think we've very well exhausted a lot of the ones we have in the area um and you know I think expanding it would only provide us the higher um quality of expectation that we that we strive for here in Carl bed and along those lines I think it keeps it more objective as well um I think if you have candidates that you
193want to recommend to the search firm they can at least you know make sure that they have all the correct qualifications but that makes it less like all of Gretchen's people or all of you know Kathy's people or might or whatever you know keeps it more objective and um having somebody that's outside of all of us to do it um other discussion I did have um um I had something that I wanted to change on the RFP and see if I can get consensus from the board as well on the RFP itself on the first bullet says background and experience with superintendent searches throughout the region and state I wanted to include National as well um and so I'd like to see that added to that um that one bullet so if I can have
194thumbs on that okay great okay um so if we can um make that change um that was my only um thing on here I wanted to um I mean we did find uh Dr Churchill on a NA national search um and so I do think that it is um uh it's worth um it's worth finding somebody that has experience in a national search so that was the only thing I had for discussion on that aspect are there any other discussion on the RFP okay and then um we're also looking at um uh staff has requested that we look at an ad hoc committee to review um to review and kind of paper screen a little bit for the the full board would be making all the decisions um uh it would just be an ad
195hoc committee to you know kind of deal with um some of the um um I guess some of the additional work that staff would be doing and give input based on the board could you explain that more what you're asking for sure so the thought was um you know the RFP deadline would be around probably January 8th we'd post it and um have a deadline um after January 8th this subcommittee um composed of two board members would go through um they can go through the rfps but they would go through and check references so every RFP is asking for districts districts I've have used them in the past they do a few reference checks um and then they can bring that information back to the January 15th special board meeting um where the board will
196be reviewing all the RFP submissions they could hear those reference check results and then um narrow down the top finalists that would then be invited to the January 22nd meeting where that would be the interview of the top finalists they would give like a 10-minute presentation we allow 10 minutes of questions and then at that January 22nd meeting a selection would be made in a contract approved so it's kind of getting some of that reference check work done ahead of time so that there's more um information being brought to the final decision when the board is reviewing that and that was my understanding but to just be clear that you know my understanding also is that this ad hoc committee is just for the search firm this is not for the superintendent you know the
197the applicants for the superintendent this is only applicants for the search firm so I just wanted to you know that was my understanding of it and I wanted to make sure that that was what we were talking about so um so I would like to volunteer to be on that committee um just because I have had experience in uh in um hiring a superintendent and trusty Ward okay any objections okay so I think we have a um we have a ad hoc committee and we um have all the information we need on the RFP we've made some changes are there any additional discussion on this piece okay uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote trustey COC yes trustee Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verth yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero
198thank you and uh next one is uh item 8.5 revision of board policies first reading trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Dr NY thank you president Rawlings trustees and superintendent Schmidt uh this is an update to board policy 512 1.9 specifically around academic honesty this is a first reading of the policy revision staff's recommending per pass practice that we bring this back in January for a second B at the Apple and traditionally that's what we like to do with our board policies she get a first reading opportunity to provide some feedback and then we'll bring it back for a second reading for final approval we've updated the policy to align to the most recent California School Board Association language uh we do this uh align it to
199the language for a couple different reasons um csba vets this with their attorneys for all relevant Ed code Provisions as well as recent legislation and the more that we're aligned with the csba language it allows us for updates to be easily Incorporated sometimes you'll see board policies come back to maybe three times a year when you're adopting csba language it's easier um to track those changes and incorporate those into the next uh board policy revision so what you have before you tonight is two exhibits exhibit a is really our current language that's highlighted in white uh below that is the updated csba language which is highlighted in green I believe and then exhibit B is really just a clean copy of what that policy would look like with our language Incorporated with the new language
200basically the new language is centered around academic honesty and it talks about the use of permitted and unpermitted Technology use so as you can imagine technology use has changed quite a bit in the last few years so it's incorporating some language around student use AI um and appropriateness and inappropriateness of student use for that so staff will turn it back over to president Rollings uh we're happy to answer any questions thank you uh this is time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you uh trustees do you have any questions I do Dr Knight um uh you had mentioned that um traditionally we would do a first reading and then bring it back um for a second reading um would you be opposed if there
201was just a small change that the trustees agreed to to um uh to bypass the second reading would there be any opposition to that uh staff's not opposed to that I just wanted to be considerate of the new trustees as far as the idea that this is the first time they're seeing this information and potentially bringing that back for a second reading but I'm not opposed to the just adopting csba language we can always agendize it for another time if there's any updates we want to do at a later date thank you any other questions no no questions I may have a motion to approve uh board policy 51 31.9 and approve as a first reading uh yes I I motion however there is a slight um believe spelling error in there but other than
202that yes just I have a motion do I have a second yes me second I hear a second from trusty wart so motion for um from trusty Emory second from trusty Ward uh discussion trusty verb thank you for um making these modifications I just wanted to let our newest trustees know why this was brought before um us this evening is because we are have a strategic plan that's involving information and technology in our school district and I felt that this was important for us to discuss before we approve that plan so I wanted you to know why it hadn't been updated since 2006 and I figured wow I think technology has changed quite a bit since 2006 so I think it would be appropriate to make sure we look at this first before we approve
203a plan involving technology so that's I just wanted you to have the backstory on that so thank you and I also had I was um wanting to do a small change um it would be the very last sentence that uh States um and or makeup work or other uses approved by the teacher I wanted it to say by the teacher of record and uh I've seen what that it's happened in the past that um somebody's on a teacher's roster but then they're provided makeup work by another teacher like let's say and it's being assigned through um like an AI program called like Ingenuity or other pieces and then the teacher of record is having to take responsibility for you know whether it was appropriate use of technology or not and but they did not make
204the assignment themselves so I just wanted a small change where it says it's the teacher of record that is the one who determines whether the policy is being um used so I wanted to see if I can get consensus for that that minor change I see three thumbs at least okay five thumbs um so if we could do that and then with that change um uh I I would I want to ask if the maker of the motion would be willing to amend their motion to U make that change and also bypass the second reading would you be willing to amend your motion yes I will amend the motion to um include the teacher of record in that last paragraph and then also to um bypass the second reading excellent and the the second uh
205approved of that as well yes okay so um we have um trusty Emory um has amended her motion and trusty ward has seconded that Amendment and with any further discussion uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verth yes trusty Rollings yes motion passes 5 to Z thank you we now move on to item 8.6 resolution number 20242 authorizing a preliminary guaranteed maximum price execution and delivery of a site lease suas Construction Services agreement and other acts relating to the district's aiera Oaks Middle School modernization project trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Mr Eric D thank you uh back in September we presented a a design concept uh for Aviara Oaks Middle School um that was given
206the green light and so we've developed construction documents we're currently in the division of State architect waiting for approval um we actually are going to we have moved uh teachers out of the uh temporary or I'm sorry the portable classrooms that will be replaced by this project um and we are will be conducting demolition over winter break of those um that's being done because we do expect to get get approval back from DSA division of State architect um in the early spring and our hope is that we can get going during spring break uh to get a couple of extra months uh head start on this project um so this is the uh preliminary guaranteed maximum price with uh with lucardi um we as as soon as we have the plans approved from DSA um
207then we will go back and do a rebid of the project um incorporating any of the changes that they might have made um we don't expect really any um but we there's always a chance that DSA might require something different we'll do the final bids on on that um and we're also looking at other ways that we can do some value engineering and bringing down the overall cost of the project at the same time um and then um we will bring back to you the final guaranteed maximum price but by approving this it allows uh lucardi to work directly with the architect and uh in and working with the plans to ensure we have full constructibility of them and then also to they gives them access to the school site so that they can also
208do some other work that they need to do to make sure that when they come back with the final guaranteed maximum price that that is the not to exceed amount so this helps us get there um and the board will have one more time to look at this uh when it becomes the final guaranteed maximum price so we uh kindly request that the board approved this resolution thank you this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you truste do you have any questions no trusty for back so Mr Dill is leaving us so will we be um talking to Jessica what is the chain of command questions well um we'll have we'll have to uh determine how how that will happen you
209know we are working on an interim uh assistant superintendent of business who will be sitting in this seat and would be the same conduit that you would have working directly with uh Miss Kimbrell um who's doing a fantastic job for us yeah I'd like to add one other point on that and I will update the board but likely we'll schedule something in the January 22nd board meeting to let you know where we are with the interim replacement and also uh to begin to move forward on a permanent CBO replacement any additional question s we have a motion to approve resolution number 20425 authorizing a preliminary guaranteed maximum price execution and delivery of a site lease sublease Construction Services agreement and other acts relating to the district's AA Oaks Middle School modernization project exhibit a so
210moved I'll second trusty ver Beth moved and um trusty seoc second any discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty bat yes trusty Rollings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to item 8.7 2025 csb delegate assembly candidate nomination trustees this is a discussion action item I will now hand it over to Mr Rick Schmidt thank you president Rawlings it is respectfully recommended that the Board of Trustees nominate trustee Michelle suda award to serve as a candidate on the 2025 California School Board Association otherwise known as csba delegate assembly the csba delegate assembly sets the general policy direction for the association which represents California school districts and county offices of Education delegates fulfill a iCal governance role by communicating the
211interest of local boards to cba's board of directors executive committee and staff they provide policy and legislative Direction Through the adoption of the policy platform every two years and the adoption of other policy statements as needed thank you this is the time for public comment have any blue cards been received we do not have any blue cards thank you truste do you have any questions I do trusty Ward I just want to make sure you're willing to serve on this uh um as a delegate so long as you're elected well I have some extra time so I think it would be a good time to do it great thank you any other questions no questions may I have a motion to nominate trustee Ward to a to serve as a candidate on the 2025 California
212school boards Association csba delegate assembly so moved and second trusty seoc moved trusty emry second any discussion all I have to say is is that um uh cludy Jones was a delegate for many years on and she was on the Carl's bed board and I felt it was a great opportunity we were able to get lots of information here locally at our board and we were able to give information to csba as well so I felt that we were well represented and I'm confident that trusty Ward would do the same so this is just the first step so we would also need to um they'll be voting I believe in February do you remember the time frame that sounds right not okay there's some paperwork so this would just be a nomination and there could
213be competition as far as other board members throughout the region because this is a you know this is all of San Diego so my hope is is that we can not only nominate trusty Ward but also get her to the finish line and get here to be a delegate so um I just wanted to throw that out there as discussion and um and support so thank you any other discussion because I think I think trusty word would be fantastic it'd be great to have a delegate here in carlb again as well and I think you'd be a great addition to that did you have do you want to say anything no just thank you and I I will do the best I can and make sure that we're very well informed thank you great thank
214you so much any other discussion another discussion uh Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes truste Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verth yes truste Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to zero thank you we now move on to uh part nine Communications uh item 9.1 governance team reports this is the time for trustees to provide a brief report if they've attended committee meetings where they represented the district are there any governance team reports with none there then we also move on to um item 9.2 trustee requests for information from staff trustees are there any requests for information from staff that have already been discussed with the superintendent and have been recommended to bring to the board trusty Ward yes um I do have a request I want to see if the staff
215can bring back some information in regard to term limits for and I'm looking at and this would probably be under discussion later but um as a three term um for all of not so it would start with the next election so it's not knocking anybody out here um that's a sitting board member but um with the new with new elections that are coming forth it would be three terms after that so having some language around on that and um seeing how we can make that an agenda item and and I forgot to add I just want to say as a reminder trustees um are prohibited from having a discussion tonight on this item um per the brown act and um and so you when you've made your request you said that you talked to staff
216and or I'm assuming you talked to staff and that um already about it yes okay and that um okay U and so we can't have any discussion so just looking at for information so do we have thumbs for that um request for information okay looks like we have thumbs for that excellent any other uh request for information from staff okay no I do okay I think wait do you have another one it's on is it on 9.3 yes okay uh thank you we move to item 9.3 trustee requests for future agenda items trustees are there any requests for future agenda items that have already been discussed with the superintendent and have been recommended to bring to the board and I'm going to uh say the reminder as a reminder trustees are prohibited from having a
217discussion tonight as these items per the brown act when making a request please indicate the purpose of the request and whether or not staff has provided an estimate of how long the request will have will take to accomplish trusty Ward did you say your head okay go ahead um for the next agenda I'm looking at having uh two full day Kinder sites as a pilot preferably one on the North End of the district and one on the south end of the district and I would leave it to staff to decide on the site for that um I'd like to have that on the agenda and just to clarify you're asking for that to be on the January agenda correct okay and so do we have consensus for that okay we have five thumbs for that
218and do you have all that information a clarifi a clar question as a information discussion item okay okay any other agenda item requests NOP okay um it is 8:16 and the regular meeting is now adjourned our next regular meeting will take place on January 22nd 2025 at 6m at the carlb Unified School District office and we have one more meeting uh trustee Rawlings I apologize hang on we well we adjourned we adjourned the regular meeting sorry uh trustees we now move on to the part 13 education facilities Corporation meeting I apologize okay okay so the carlb unified Board of Trustees has concluded their regular meeting um I will now call to order the annual meeting of the carbed Unified School School District educational facilities Corporation this is the time and place designated for the meeting
219Miss Garcia have we received any blue cards regarding the educational facilities Corporation meeting inclusive of items 12.1 through 12.6 we do not have any blue cards thank you after all person hang on and now turn it to Mr uh Dill assistant superintendent Business Services thank you for staying for this bonus meeting um the the the the purpose of the the educational facilities Corporation is basically to to be an intermediary in certain financing transactions that we do such as our certificates of participation um the officers of the corporation uh mirror the officers of the Board of Trustees um so that we will ask uh trustee Rawlings um to uh walk through the item which appoints the officers that you elected earlier this evening into the same roles for the corporation thank you trustees do you have
220any questions for staff I move that the Board of Trustees of the carbed Unified School District and each board member individually hereby accept the position of board of directors of the carlb Unified School District educational facilities Corporation effective as of December 18th 2024 serving in the same capacity as voted upon earlier with the exception of the board clerk who will serve as the treasure to the corporation that'll be president Rawlings vice president Ward treasur clerk trust ver Beth may I have a second second uh board discussion Miss Garcia please call for a vote trusty COC yes trusty Emory yes trusty Ward yes trusty verbet yes trusty Rawlings yes motion passes 5 to Z the next meeting date of the carlb Unified School District educational facilities Corporation is scheduled for December 10th 2025 following the adjournment
221of the organizational meeting of the Board of Trustees I now declare the annual meeting of the Carl's bed School District educational facilities Corporation is now adjourned there we go finish that up okay