CorpusRecord 31165

Carpinteria Unified School District Meeting - December 17, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City of Carpinteria
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Santa Barbara County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,560 words · about 98 min
Collected
2026-06-06

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] I'd like to call to order the December 17th organizational meeting first order of business is election of officers Education Code sections 720000 require that the governing board to hold an annual organizational meeting to elect officers and to set the date time in place for all regular board meetings we'll first entertain the election of President and I will receive nominations I'd like to nominate uh jamy diamond is President all second okay okay any comments thank you all all righty all those in favor I I okay congratulations Jamie you're now president okay we are moving on now uh election of Vice President Clerk and I will take nominations nominate Andy schaer all second okay any discussion thank you all in favor hi hi okay uh we are now going to go to uh C2 establish 2025

002regular board monthly board meetings uh established regular monthly meetings of the Board of Education to be held typically at 5:30 p.m. on the 2nd and fourth Tuesdays of each calendar month board meetings will be held in the carpentera city council chamber 5775 carpentera Avenue California carpentera California or at the District Administrative Office or School site if needed the location to be termined to be determined by the board board meetings in 2025 are scheduled for January 14th and 28th February 11th and 25th March 11th April 8th and 22nd May 13 and 28 June 10 and 24 July 8 August 12 and 26 September 9 and 23 October 14 and 28 November 12 and 25th December 9th SB CEO for calendar planning purposes the dates for scheduling organizational meetings in 2025 is from December 1 through December

00320th uh 2025 any uh any questions to approve the dates I'll uh I'll I'll move to approve the dates as presented I'll second okay any discussion okay all in favor hi hi uh C3 appointment of board members to various committees board member appointees the following appointed board positions are not for designated agency Representatives who engage in negotiations with the designated representatives for personnel matters and so these committees are open to the public 2024 County committee on School District organization election uh we had board member green and Smith with an alternate of board member bridgeford um for for 2025 are we good with keeping that the same yeah yeah okay that'll carry over uh 2024 Joint City Council and Board of Trustees committee we had board members Schaefer and bridgeford and I was an alternate um

004are you good with that moving forward y okay uh Joint City Council uh sorry uh 2024 member of California School Board Association legislative network was myself um and I'm good with sticking with that um and then let's see here okay so we need to vote on the approval of the 25 slate as stated which would be a status quo I'll move to um adopt the uh assignments as as we just discussed I'll second that okay discussion all in favor I I okay that work is done okay we are now moving into regular session of the board uh can everybody please rise for the flag salute ready begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and

005justice for all okay we have our closed session report um we had a conference with labor negotiators information was exchanged no action was taken and we are now going to move on to public comment for items not on this agenda um I want to clarify because we have some new folks in the room um when it's time for public comment I'll let you know and you guys can just stand and line up behind the podium um don't need to fill out a card or anything like that ahead of time um just when I say it's time go ahead and so I'm saying it is time for public comment for items not on the agenda please feel free to get up to the podium if you'd like to say something at this time three minutes hello

006is it on yeah okay uh dear members of the Carpenteria School Board fellow teachers and community members this is my 30th year teaching at Aliso I'm addressing uh you all to make it clear that I and I believe most Carpenteria teachers support our Union and its Representatives the teachers union works on behalf of the teachers to negotiate for salary safety and other factors that influence working conditions and employee satisfaction although the union represents the interests of teachers and staff it also makes for better and healthier schools um because it it works to have competitive compensation and benefits and this promotes a positive and productive work environment and we all know this to be true uh it also helps to retain uh qualified teachers who want to work hard to improve and stay in our school

007district however the negotiations have not proceeded in a respectful and productive manner for many years a lot of resources that could have been better utilized have been wasted um in a both sze Lo sides lose type of situation in our professional life we sometimes need to work with problematic relationships as teachers and administrators we can have situations that try our patients and challenge us and we need to find a way to communicate and cooperate to find Solutions and compromise mises we aspire to do this in a professional and respectful manner in the new year I would hope that the board and the people on the negotiating committee will try to interact positively and professionally with our Union leadership throughout the negotiation process please do this to end the stalemate and waste of resources please do

008this to show teachers that you support um teachers and staff that you respect the the union that is representing them please do this to help strengthen the resolve of the Carpenteria Union School District to work together to do the best to support each other please do this to help our school district remain a wonderful place and please do this to carry out to help carry out our mission of being a caring community of professionals dedicated to educating and promoting health and well-being for the children and the families of Carpenteria thank you and I hope that you all have a wonderful holiday season thank [Applause] you good evening my name is Ruby Avala and I've been a special education Aid with Carpenter UniFi school district for 9 years thank you to all the board members for

009this opportunity to bring this to bring this urgent matter to your attention we as a SP Department have been lacking the past few years unfortunately this year has been this year has brought us to our breaking point to be exact neither the district nor the IAS from room six in canalino school have been able to provide the students a safe or productive teaching and learning environment we started the school year without a teacher and and had to go be on our job description in our attempts to keep our students safe there has been multiple incidents in this room due to the lack of a teacher and due to the lack of support from the teacher who was finally assigned to this classroom several months into the school year Miss rugby your duty to these families

010it's not to protect your friends but to protect our students safety since you've been superintendent there has been a lack in our sped Department there are new hires with no new hires with no experience who are getting paid much more than veteran employees who have worked here more than nine plus years and are not even being properly trained to perform the duties they are they are directed to provide why is that Miss rby why is it that our cry for fair wages our cry to get the best quality education for our students and our cry for the safety of our students in Sp Department being ignor it's a shame to see the same SP department where I was once a kid fall apart but I'm proud of the group of IAS I work with because

011each and one of them are very dedicated to the kids one day I hope that you can take time away from all your lawsuits Miss rubby and at least visit canalino not just go in for a few minutes but actually go into our shoes and understand the gravity within our classroom I hope that all of you up there can step into our shoes and see what both employees and especially our students have to deal with on a daily basis thank you thank you do I just start go ahead okay good evening thank you Ruby that was amazing my name is Angela White and I have been a teacher here at Carpenter unified since 1995 and I'm reading on behalf of the teachers and support staff of canalino we are collectively sacrificing time away from our

012families after a long day because we can no longer stay silent about the working conditions that deeply affect both us and our students this letter represents the vast majority of C canalino staff who are committed to providing quality education despite these obstacles as we work with determination to Shield our students from the difficulties that we Face recent years have brought T tremendous adversity today we raise our voices collectively because we are exhausted and demoralized by the current climate within the carpenter Unified School District as a staff we are apprehensive to sign our individual names for fear of facing retaliation we feel strongly that this is time it is time that the community is made aware of this situation the working environment has continued to deteriorate our staff students and families deserve better the atmosphere within

013the district leaves us feeling neither valued nor supported as we continue to hear that there's no funding for essential needs or pay that keeps Pace with the cost of living negotiations have completely stalled and we've reached an impass meanwhile and this is the hardest part to say The District administration has reward itself backtack 5% raises in July of 2023 and July of 2024 while offering the teachers and support staff only 2% this disparity is disheartening for those of us who work daily with students building their Futures and investing our hearts in our work our Silence has not been due to apathy but rather due to the continual decline of morale and constant fear of retaliation for speaking up we remain disheartened at The District's denial of reasonable requests for adequate compensation curricul ulum resources consistent

014instructional assistance support support our classrooms particularly when full day aids were promised Diana rby you promised us full day aids in K when we went to full day but this support is er eroded to down to as little as two hours of kindergarten classroom support for a 6-hour day there are continual changes to Aid coverage to fill other needs on our campus as Ruby was talking about making it extremely challenging for teachers to plan for effective classroom learning we need the community and the board's support to bring about the changes that would truly benefit our students and the staff who dedicate themselves to them every day our working environment is strained by a severe lack of classroom resources and inadequate training opportunities basic classroom supplies such as paper and science materials are rationed and teachers

015are continually shamed for making Necessary copies to address common core standards professional development opportunities that would benefit our students and build teacher skills have dwindled while unrelated District spending continues unchecked I'm going to stop here and let my colleague uh take over because I know that it will be longer than three minutes and I'd rather spare myself to that sound thank you hi my name is lean MacDonald I've been with the district since 2020 coming in during the hybrid uh the the hybrid year where our students were learning more at home than they were in the classroom um and just to continue with uh the collective letter from the canalino staff and teachers another area where we have great concern is our custodial Services the district has recently reduced the custodial staff leaving the remaining

016custodians overwhelmed with their workload this insufficient coverage particularly when custodians are absent and there are no substitutes available common uh common areas in classrooms are left unsanitized and uncleaned creating unhealthy environments for students and staff uh inadequate cleaning contributes to that spread of illness further affecting our ability to focus on teaching and learning especially as the district places a high priority on staff and student attendance unfortunately our concerns go beyond inadequate resources and compensation our workplace culture has become increasingly demoralizing staff members have been publicly shamed for making Necessary medical appointments disregarding our contract agreements and personal dignity events like our family math night which is really well accepted and entertained by the community uh require extended hours on the on the part of teachers and AIDS who stayed to prepare these activities to enrich

017our students learning and our community involvement on campus and yet the uh the supplemental pay has not been in kind for the hours worked by the teachers and aids for those after hours events uh that leaves our staff exhausted after working a 12-hour day with little support and recognition for this extra service that we provide additionally our classroom supplies are restricted to overpriced cataloges diminishing the funds that are available and ofer requiring teachers to make up the difference out of their own Pockets staff transfers and reassignments have frequently violated the contract terms and disregarded teacher seniority this has also created an atmosphere of insecurity across our campuses dismissive comments from District leadership regarding the importance of instructional Aid uh AIDS further damages morale and undermines the support of our most valuable students and our most

018vulnerable students as Ruby explained earlier our students deserve a committed staff that feels respected and supported we ask that the District administration honor those contract agreements that you recognize the vital work of every staff member and support the of our teachers our AIDS and our students in this District thank you very much thank you good evening to all members of Carpenteria families children dedicated staff and employees who serve families as well as the school board members and administrators who also serve this community my name is Lor Lee Collins and I'm an educator at Carpenteria Family School a K5 Public School of choice for the entire Carpenteria School District I always have to get that in dear District board members and administrators I hope this message find you and yours well I want to take a

019moment to express my gratitude for your oncoming support and dedication to our carpentera Unified School District Community I've been so fortunate to have had a heartfelt connection with all of you as an educator I've always believed in fostering an environment when one feels loved valued and heard within this context one feels safe and willing to be vulnerable to take risks to thrive in life I feel this is all of our responsibility to lift the community its families and especially our students so they internally and emotionally know they have the skills and support to thrive and not simply survive as the upcoming new year approaches I believe it's crucial to voice our Collective concerns regarding the lack of cost of living adjustments and the maintenance of our Health and Welfare package as a long serving educator

020I have witness firsthand the impact that a supportive environment has on our students and their families it's vital for our Community to feel safe valued and heard and respected unfortunately I have observed too many delays and negotiations not reaching an agreement before the end of a negotiation cycle it is disheartening to watch this back and forth over the decades I can see that our young vibrant and dedicated new employees are struggling with decisions about whether to continue personally trying to survive living in our district or to seek opportunities elsewhere that provide wages allowing them the opportunity to thrive the rising cost of our living in our area have created challenges not only for our students and families but also for our dedicated staff many of our Educators and support personel are juggling multiple jobs just

021to make ends meet by improving our wage compensation and maintaining the Health and Welfare package we can foster an environment where our staff can truly Thrive rather than just survive is the district's decision to support our livelihood in order for us to thrive so that we may hold this ideal for the community of carpentera its families and the children we serve I urge you to influence our negotiation teams and attorneys to meet with causes Team without further delay this action is essential for our community our families and the Bright Futures of the children in our classrooms thank you for your attention to this important matter I appreciate all your efforts and I wish you a joyful holiday season thank you hi my name is Christen Munich and uh I taught aon's three children and two

022of Jamie's and I've been with this district for a long time and I just want to start by backing Ruby up and what she said um I don't think any of you really realize the true severity of what is happening and what they are going through I'm in that hallway and I see what they are going through daily my two sped kids are now on their eth IIA of the year and they will have another one coming in January that is not acceptable and it is not okay and those kids needs are not being met as they were promised in their IEP so something needs to be done about that so Ruby you and all the other IAS I stand with you um so this is my 28th year of teaching at calino I spent

023around 20 years as a union rep eboard member and part of the negotiating team after only two years working with Mrs Rigby and Mrs ZTA uh and your negotiating team it became unar it was hostile it was toxic I couldn't do it anymore and it not okay and I see that nothing has changed as negotiations are currently at an impass it's really disheartening and Andy you and I worked together a long time through those and we went through some really difficult times but we always were able to get through it and it's really frustrating to see this Administration not doing their part um so I'm speaking tonight on behalf of the staff who feel increasingly disregarded and undervalued by this Administration we the support staff and Educators in this District we tired we're tired of

024going above and beyond at the expense of our own health and families without receiving the respect and recognition we deserve and what our uh my colleagues alluded to I had surgery in July and to get these messages that it's not okay to take time off and we're being reprimanded for time when that's that's due to us we're working so hard and when I get to work in the morning and the only car in the district parking lot I see is Laura Le where are you your new car looks awesome and then when I leave at the end of the day no cars so either the staff there is walking or riding bikes or we're all working longer hours than you all it's frustrating um we've heard a lot about budgets we understand that money's tight

025but we're here to tell you it's not just about money it's about priorities and right now they're clearly misplaced staff are being asked to do more with less more work more stress more emotional labor and yet the district finds ways to Grant not one but two raises to your admin we're left without the cost of living adjustments that are necessary to keep up with the rising cost of living it's demoralizing it sends a message that the people doing the hardest work in the classroom and across the district aren't as important as those at the top thank you Hana Han will you finish hana's gonna finish reading my statement can you say Hana sure yeah great okay I'll SC for you right there we're also tired of being reprimanded for taking time off when we are

026simply trying to care for our own well-being we work tirelessly often putting in hours outside of the classroom yet we are penalized when we are not in the classroom for health or personal reasons something every worker is entitled to we are constantly told not to make copies or to limit resources for our students while we spend our own money on supplies just to ensure our students have the materials they need interestingly this wasn't a concern last year when a staff member on the canalo campus made packets of 100 pages regarding a union matter and place them in every staff box at calino how can you expect us to give so much of ourselves day after day when our own needs are being ignored the time has come to show us the same level of care

027and commitment that we show to the students we serve we need cost of living adjustments that reflect the TR value of the work we do every single day we need respect not just in words but in action we need to see that you are willing to stand in solidarity with us the staff who are shaping the future of this community it is beyond time for you to act in good faith this is not just about pay it is about showing that you value us we need to see that our efforts are recognized and appreciated with actions thank you thank you hello my name is Maddie Maple this is my seventh year in the district I started at Family School and now I'm at the high school um I'm going to be reading on behalf of

028Kelly Pierce who's with me uh English Department at carpentera high school so she says Dear members of the school board I am writing to not just as a veteran teacher with years of experience but as someone who has grown increasingly disheartened by the current trajectory of our school district I have dedicated my career to the education and well-being of our students yet it is painfully clear that the district has strayed from its primary mission to serve the needs of its students by fostering an environment that attracts and retains high quality Educators our students deserve the very best and we as Educators strive daily to provide them with the knowledge skills and support that they need to thrive however the reality of our district salary schedule and the high cost of living in our area makes

029this goal increasingly difficult to achieve the district's refusal to fairly compensate employees has created economic instability not just for myself and my family but talented and experienced teachers are leaving for neighboring districts or even changing professions alt together I know this because many of my friends and colleagues have left cusd in recent years for this reason I've also looked Ed joint is full of positions in this area offering salaries tens of thousands of dollars higher than what CD is willing to to offer this is not just about money it's about respect and value when teachers are forced to choose between staying in a district they love and providing for their families the message is clear the district does not prioritize its Educators this not only impacts teacher morale but it also directly affects our students

030who lose the continuity and expertise that seasoned teachers bring to the classroom year after year we hear about the district's Financial constraints yet other districts with similar challenges find ways to invest in their Educators why can't we when teachers leave and are also not replaced it creates a ripple effect larger class sizes less individual attention for students and an erosion of strong relationships that are essential to effective teaching and learning in the CHS English Department alone three teachers have left in the past three years and only one has been replaced this year two out of the four of us are teaching six periods with no built-in time to prep or grade for those six classes this is not sustainable the cost of turnover both financial and human is far greater than the investment required to

031retain quality teachers I urge you to take immediate action to address this crisis re-evaluate the district's priorities and budgets to ensure that competitive salaries and support for teachers are at the Forefront of decisionmaking engage with Educators to understand their struggles and concerns most importantly remember that the success of our students is inextricably linked to the well-being of our teachers we are out of Crossroads the decisions you make now will determine whether our district can continue to provide the high quality education a our students deserve and whether we will lose the dedicated professionals who make that education possible please choose to invest in us your teachers your students your community sincerely Kelly Pierce thank you I'm going to take a little bit of a different angle hello um my name is Sarah Rock litzer I'm a

032teacher at carpentry High School I have a sophomore at CHS and a fifth grader at family school today I want to talk about looking toward the future the long game I want to discuss what is going to become of CHS by the time my son reaches High School far past the three-year certification of your budget right now the torchbearers of warrior Spirit are our senior teachers and staff art minoris Julie Rubio shamblin Pat Cooney Charles Bryant they plan community community building events they organize an over see they show up and they exemplify to everyone what it means to be committed to students and to have Warrior Pride but you know they are not going to be around forever if we lose them to retirement without passing along that torch to new Young teachers we are

033going to lose it right now we are not valuing attracting and retaining highquality new teachers we are a revolving door for people to get their start and then move on to find better paying jobs elsewhere lately we have teachers that don't even last through an entire school year Young new staff don't stay long enough to learn what it means to have Warrior Pride a culture in a school is cultivated over time by mentors who show The Way I Am So disheartened by the clear possibility that by the time my son gets to high school that concept is going to be non-existent and also we are a staff full of unicorns as enrollment declines teachers are tasked with wearing more and more hats teaching a variety of courses that require R wide- ranging skill sets and

034experience and multiple credentials we have already seen how incredibly difficult it is to replace people when they retire or leave for better pay and no commute we basically gave up trying to replace elely unre and she has graciously come out of retirement to save our entire music and performing arts program it was shocking to see how fast that beloved and important program could have and would have disappeared without her when we lost Sou we lost our entire AG welding program good luck trying to find someone who can run a Ceramics program but only for three periods because we need them to teach digit digital photography for one period and they're in a specialized digital art class for freshman for another period and also don't worry little 25-year-old new hire you'll be fine juggling art one

035art 2 art honors art AP allinone class period of 36 kids because we such have such an impact Ed master schedule there's no other way to do it oh and if we get in a pinch we might even ask that same person to give up their prep and teach Spanish as well on their sixth period thank goodness you have three different credentials good luck HR we are on this precarious precipice where I am not seeing a way forward for CHS without a complete turnaround in how we value our teachers and compens compensate them in a way that allows them to stay and see a future for themselves thank [Applause] you uh in the last 18 months District officials have led the district to impass failed to ratify a single agreement with District employees and rejected

036over 100 contract improvements proposed by employees to include no less than 35 proposed improvements for district safety and student wellbeing they fostered working conditions resulting in The Exodus of no less than 70 District employees since January 2024 conditions that left the majority of those remaining silent and uncertain until tonight they spent and accured approximately 3 and A5 million taxpayer dollars in legal fees and legal debt $3.5 million invested not in District students or families or learning but rather in failed attempts to punish elected employee representatives and obstruct the collective bargaining process and they failed to invest approximately the same amount on investing in District employees which can be found confirmed in the annual audit attached to item H3 later this evening but you did provide the entire CD administrative team not one but two salary

037increases totaling 10 to 12% while offering District employees 2 to 2 a half% the quality and maintenance of the labor relationship is the most influential component District officials must resolve it impacts every aspect of CD's operations what if what if District officials listen to those who share employee experiences even in a professional Culture of Fear and uncertainty what if our officials began genuine collaboration with elected employee Representatives moving forward together to better serve our students and families and even the district what if teaching and learning environments better ref collected the insights of those who work closest with students what if $3.5 million had not been spent on disciplinary attacks unanimously determined discriminatory and retaliatory by perb and unfounded and illegal by the state's office of administrative hearings what if that money $3.5 million and similar

038future Investments are instead invested in critical District resources like employees salaries student programs safety measures or even a future theater or performing arts or pool or athletic center what if they set aside what if you set aside the personal and political animist and focus on the mission as described in your own mission statement where you commit to and I quote to providing quality educational programs in a caring positive environment which promotes self-esteem and mutual respect and mutual respect back thank you hi my name is Julie Rubio shamblin and I don't have anything prepared but sitting here I think I just want to look at you guys and speak to you uh born from a father a grandfather named Marcus Cravens Craven's Lane my grandmother baylord Avenue Ed Rubio uh descendant from Pedro himz the first

039Chumash Indian in this area and I want to tell you this can't possibly be what your objective was when you got we took these positions I am not at all versed on any of the details but I can tell you this hear their words they're shaking here they're upset we're we're feeling like we're disrespected I know many of you I know where your heart is like listen to this this is not Carpenter I am carpent this is not carpent we do not do this to our staff we are the fabric of this community I don't know the exact answers I don't know the numbers and I won't play to but I do know when we have people of value and I see this every single day these are the Trailblazers these are the difference makers

040in this community I was born and raised here they are why I stand up here all right and I just think that whatever happened in the past we must move forward we must and I'm challenging you to recognize the morale and their lack of at this point this is not carpent Tria and I'm speaking from everyone from this community this is ridiculous you have our our best of our best appear shaking speaking to you guys I mean they're asking for your respect like can we not come together and do this I don't have the answers I wouldn't want to have your job but I do know how humans can work together when that is the ultimate objective and I'm begging you to listen to the people that have spoke with you tonight thank you thank

041you uh this is uh J hner transl a famili for and attack is discriminator a and of translation now I would like to make my un public comment um your your time is up okay translation he pered to translate no he translated excuse me excuse me excuse me please sit down it is not your turn to talk you translated somebody else's statement not your own statement if it was your statement that needed to be translated then yes you would have additional time for that but you read a separate statement you're not translating your own right now so um it's exactly what I did and I I understand and so what I'm saying is the state that statement has now been said in English and in Spanish it would be one thing if you wanted it

042translated at that time so now you're asking to do another statement separate my own my own my own my own personal statement different different statement yeah no I always I don't write any steming correct so I'm just being clear I set the the standards are the same for everybody I'm I will allow this because this is apparently this is what we're going to do for right now but I just want to be very clear that when I when the time is the same for everybody and the rules are the rules so I just it it doesn't matter who it is I try I I that's how it stays even um all right okay go ahead let me begin go ahead let me know yeah have a question how many of board members of you how

043many of you are teachers or former teachers no no one okay I think that it should be a requirement to be a board member and want tell you why as a former teacher I know what it is to be in the classroom not for five minutes or 10 no for years and years and that's the only reason that should be a requirement to be a board member I was there with you for four years and I know the experience I know what it is to be to have a decent salary and some of you are paid politicians how can you survive with a two 2 and a half% increase no uh how many of you are driving from oxner or Ventura to teach in our district think that you have to think in inside the

044box and outside the box to make in me to improve the the budget I think that you you all need we all need a finance specialist let's say from UCB and not no one uh related to the school district no specialist fromb Ora you name it so that he can teach us he can teach you how to improve the budget so that you don't misuse it because it's the same story 2016 2017 I was with you and it was the same problem no salary increase no salary increases no so I think that and it's all right I mean I told you on the back then it's okay to a year or two being cut of guard with the budget but not not for 10 14 straight years no there's there's you something has to be

045done something and uh I think that you should all go through a finance Finance course uh thank you thank you so much thank you any further public comment for items not on the agenda please step up to the podium good evening um um my name is Martha rug I work as a assistant at calino school I don't have anything prepared I wasn't going to come tonight but uh we drove by and saw the parking lot was full so I had to stop um I wanted to say that um I appreciate what you guys do you guys have worked really hard as Volunteers in this community to try and un understand some really tough issues and um I think that where we're stuck right now is that there's a lot of people whose voices aren't being

046heard and there's a lot of reasons that you guys are staying where you're staying and what I think we need to do is we need to all sit down at the table and have a conversation and if that's not possible with the representation that we have in the union then I think we need to get new Union representation and I know that's not a popular opinion especially in this room but I have watched probably the last 15 meetings and it's been stomach churning to see the concerns of the teachers and the staff go by the wayside because the representation we have is not suitable or palatable for cons assumption it's just not appropriate and I I urge everybody in this room to go back and watch meetings because it's it nobody deserves to be treated

047no matter what they've done and as as elected officials they deserve somebody to come at them with respect and furthermore I have almost a masters um I've worked for 13 years and I make barely $20 an hour so I've also pinch hit a couple times in the classroom more than a couple um and I'm very proud of the work I do I'm very proud of the work I do I love my job I love sitting with the kindergarteners every day so I think I deserve more but I understand where you guys are coming from and I just want to let everybody here in the room know that you guys don't deserve what you're getting so I'm gonna go home now night thank [Applause] you any further public comment for items not on tonight's agenda um

048yeah excuse me I don't need the comments thank you um you can come and St up to the podium please hi um as a member of the public not any fancy position that I may have gotten but you know I've been a student at uh carbia main School uh canalino and middle school and now the high school and I'm finishing high school right now I'm on my way to college but you know getting to there to the point of looking back at my teachers and realizing dang they might they might not really like being here you know it's it's really sad to see because um I'm a first gen student and um real realizing that my teachers might not want to be there to teach it really um Chang it changed my um view on

049how why why should I be studying why should I stay um here at this uh Union or at this Unified School District why should I stay under these teachers who are were not happy where they are and uh usually when I think of a teacher at least how I was start in um Elementary School there um somebody who support students and um knowing that now that those who are above them don't support those students or those teachers either it really shapes shapes um how I see uh this school district and it scares me realizing that some students outside in our schools aren't um being taught at the at the highest level that they could be you know submitting all these college applications it's um it's scary who knows if all these classes that we take

050that our teachers have to prepare that our teachers have to um work for work for us it's I could definitely tell it's not easy on them because I could tell when a teacher is happy to be teaching a subject that they like or and once that class end once that facade Falls it's devastating to see what uh being a teacher is really like and I want to be a teacher you know I want to build on to the Future I want to help students and help children become the best that they could possibly be and it's um very scary that knowing that if I do become a teacher and say for whatever reason I come back to this um CD District it's scary that you know I might not be able to provide for my

051mom who's gone through many surgeries many problems and knowing that because I'm an only child um you know it's very scary that you know I might not be able to be provide for say I have a family it might be scary and you know knowing that these teachers have all had families it's scary it's very worrying thank you Angel [Applause] okay here we go U my name is BJ shamblin I'm Julie Rubio shamblin's husband not a teacher um but watching a student do that this is not carpentera at all not the town that I was born and raised in I was a I was actually a student rep for the school board and that se exame role not Carpenteria thank [Applause] you um so just to be clear there's there's no action that can be

052taken on what you're saying like for us to do something right now but I do want to address um the the impass process um just some of the this is not you know all-encompassing of what I've heard there has been so much shared and I'm really grateful for that um what I do want to uh make clear is with the impass process we are in mediation um we have uh had several sessions that have gone back and forth and the the frustrating part is we are not it is confidential so we are not allowed to discuss what was uh offered I can say that there has been a subsequent offer um I'm not allowed to say what the offer was your representative should have shared that with you um he can't share that either okay

053so I'm not this is my first time in the impaz process so I'm trying to understand um which makes that all the more frustrating that you can't share it with your membership either um and so we're waiting uh for a response and um and the next steps would be then if the offer is not accepted uh would go to fact finding um and that's where uh essential an outside third party looks at the numbers and the offers and comes up with with what um is possible so we did for the first time um beginning earlier this year have two board members as part of the negotiations team um I do believe we had um some really good sessions and we had some really unproductive sessions um I also had a lot of really great conversations

054with teachers and staff outside getting their feedback and input on what they value um and so I appreciate hearing from even more of you um and and I I personally um I I want you to know that I do value you and I do appreciate you um I my kids have been in your classrooms um my our kids have been in classrooms together um I've known Angel since he was in kindergarten um and so I agree this is not what Carpenteria is the the it it is a very toxic situation right now um and I wish that it was uh well I naively came into this and I'm speaking for myself and said well what if we just put all the the past whatever that had happened behind us and move forward and there's that

055was I'm not the P first person to have said that and neither are the people that have said it tonight um I wish it was that easy to just clean slate and move forward I wish it was as easy as um well doesn't matter um I want you to know that I've heard you and I appreciate you coming um and I am not on campus nearly as much as I used to be but when I am feel free to grab me um most of you know how to get a hold of me or know how to share my info to get a hold of me with somebody if if if they want um I try and make myself available um and so uh yeah that's um so I I uh think that well I know

056that all of us up here understand and and know that you need a cola I think that there's no question about that um you know Jamie explain the process we're in right now um and I agree that respect is very important mutual respect um and the um but I also you all need to be aware that there's only a certain pot of money available right and and and that pot of money is has to be spread out amongst the the priorities and and certain priorities have been established by the union and and um we're going to do our best and hopefully resolve this without going to fact finding um but I think we all agree that that uh and we we I think we all understand what you said tonight and I and I I

057don't think there's much disagreement with with many of the things that were said okay so we are now going to move on to D4 um approval of the minutes um if people are going to leave we'll give it a minute thank youone so uh D4 approval of the minutes we're approving the minutes of the regular board meeting November 26th and the special board meeting of December 10th um any questions from the board public comment on approval of the minutes thank you if I'm unable to share or if I'm able to complete this um statement uh Chris mastero will step up and complete the statement on my behalf or on the Union's behalf um I'm not sure what you were waiting for in regard to the um the impass offer that you provided um you are

058correct that were neither part is permitted to speak about it and you are lucky the minutes that we're not permitted to speak about it uh I do think you got your answer though to what that would look like from the responses you heard this evening let the minutes show that the district provided its first inim budget report at the November 26th board meeting let the minut show on page four of this budget report it was clarified that when applied to total expenditures the district with an ADA like ours must not allow The Reserve balance to drop below 3% for up to three years out the report also confirmed that the Reserve balance remains as many as three three times higher than the mandated 3% reserves in years out even with the district's deficit spending accounting

059model and projections let the minutes show the district as it has for several years has artfully accounted for the first interim budget to again under project revenues and over project expenditures let the minutes show that this accounting method allows the district to once again claim that it is deficit spending and that its Reserve balances are insufficient to invest in either meaningful employee salary increases which we heard Mr schaer alluding to Equitable compensation values or measures that would relieve the hardships employees are experiencing as the cost of living over 23% in the last two years has far outpaced the value of employee wages employee wages that have been not been raised in over 18 months let the minutes show that the cusd drastically reduced its Reserve balance projections by slashing projected property tax revenues for the

060next 3 years this reduction alone has resulted in an over $4 million decrease on paper that is in tax-based revenues being included in the district's budget and as predicted and apparently a strategic result has once again happened on paper driving down the district Reserve balance During the period that employee salary increases are being negotiated this is not a coincidence but an administrative and accounting tactic and it's used to disempower employee Financial interests which are shared with the interests of our students and their families let the minutes show that while cusd has played the same deficit spending accounting game for the last several years under projecting revenues and over projecting expenditures District leadership still found enough money to increase their base salaries and give themselves two salary increases in the same period while spiking their salaries

061to values above Regional averages the CD has failed to provide thank you your time is up Mr Master Vito will step in while spiking while spiking their salaries uh I'm sorry Chris Master 8th grade science teacher and cause secretary while spiking their salaries to values above Regional averages the CD has failed to provide employees any salary increase in again over 18 months and as part past as president they as precedent they are positioning to do so once again let the minutes show that on page six yet another mistake by assistant superintendent Fitzgerald who uh along with several other senior administrators left the cusd in a stampede for the door this spring failed to pull out Santa Barbara hip dollars from the 2425 projected budget and as a result another $ 36,6 75 error has been

062found by Mr CF let the minutes show on page seven that CC displaced the impact of the sbip reductions not by reducing admin salaries but by reducing certificated salaries classified salaries and employee benefits of those working directly with our students and families let the minutes show that in the revenues area of the budget the district fails to include any of the gifts and donations that serve to increase District revenues some of which have been above 125,000 I.E such as last cent similar in contribution at the last meeting let the minute show that the CD fails to clarify what portion of either the recent $100,000 technically $993 37 increase or the whopping 7.5 million technically 7476 268 total of services and other operations expenses is associated with the district's extraordinary legal costs millions of taxpayer dollars

063invested in mismanagement union busting and actions found to be violations of labor law and statutory law both by state bodies and the public employment Relations Board let the minute show at minute 13545 that superintendent Rigby and Miss Diamond mischaracterize the district's relationship between selpa special education local plan area and the district suggesting that cusd pays for the Sela services but does not receive Services anywhere near the value of C's investment this is gross M mischaracterization of CD's relationship with Sela finally let the minutes show that at the last board meeting using false claims of disruptive behavior the school board violated the brown Act and the constitutional rights of public Speakers by ejecting Union leadership from the last born meeting and let the minute show that the board engaged in this illegal Behavior shortly before the

064first interim budget presentation was presented in an effort to prevent elected employee leaders from sharing employees observations and concerns at the time of the budget presentation thank you thank you carpentry resident I always say Carpenter resident because that means that I live here and that I'm a taxpayer and as a taxpayer I uh have the right to uh give you credit for what good things that you have done and also uh provide criticism for or anything that uh doesn't look okay during the first uh uh interim budget report reserves are down to 4.3 4.4 that that's without uh uh taking into a uh consideration uh teacher negotiations nor the salary increase so what's going to happen let's say okay uh we got the information that reserves falling let's say to 2.5% the C the sen

065Rob then uh takes look out the district and and what's going on 2 and half% minimum should be three now thinking right now how about lawsuits that you have pending that let's say that you lose what will happen where are you going to get them money or what is the district going to get that money Millions will that cause some let's say that well F General said it 2018 if the district fails to pay its obligations let's say not even two not even 1% then the state takes over meaning that a superintendent is removed and the school board is removed and the state takes over for for years until the budget is balanced you don't want that to happen that's why I said uh you need to uh get educated on the budget not by

066uh let's say uh any uh School District uh uh affiliate no some that's why I mentioned UCB UCLA Finance expert and to educate everyone how to handle the budget thank you thank [Applause] you yeah I'd like to move to approve the uh minutes of um last regular meeting and the special meeting of December 10th I'll second that motion discussion all in favor I I I okay we're moving on to approval of the agenda and consent agenda um any questions from the board okay public comment for approval of the agenda and consent agenda so the consent agenda as with the rest of the board agenda is governed by the brown act the brown Act is designed to prevent the advancement of public Business Without transparency it is designed to provide members of the community an opportunity

067to more thoroughly consider details associated with matters of District business before those matters are quickly processed through the consent agenda and mass the brown act prohibits District officials from reaching 100% consensus decisions behind closed doors a practice that obscures debate and prevents dissenting viewpoints and concerns from being placed on the public record like many of the district's legal responsibilities it appears to USD has little regard for the brown act that is until members of the community invest considerable time energy and money into lawsuits designed to hold you accountable only then do our district officials seem concerned about their performance but that comes far too late and it comes at the cost of students and programs and District families like the vast majority of previous meetings cusd once again playes items on the consent agenda that

068are neither routine nor have they been brought before the public at any previous meeting setting aside the district's Brown act violations employees comment on the in individual items as best we can in the time remaining in our three minute speaking opportunity employees support item one the field trip request for 97 students canalino and CFS fourth graders and 40 adult chaperons to visit Santa Cruz Island and conceptually employees also support item three the CMS request for after school fishing program for an after school fishing program as long as it will be funded through the Chevron Grant which is up for approval later this evening if not funded through the Chevron Grant this item should be pulled and reconsidered because employ employees have been requesting several other significantly higher impact after school Investments that both principal purson

069and superintendent rig have rejected under the guise of insufficient revenues and funding in regard to item number two employees remain concerned about the district's implementation of this program a 5-year contract to approve an agreement with Cal Lutheran for counseling internships although this agreement is purported to bring clinical expertise through supervised counseling with students there remain significant concerns associated with the lack of oversight in place for these interns as employees have shared these interns are often left to provide Counseling Services otherwise provided by fully credentialed Personnel the con the continuation of such scenarios is sure to save the district money as these interns provide service to the CD for no cost but there has been and predictably will continue to be a cost to our students and their families receiving these counseling services from unqualified uncredentialed

070student interns under the guise that they are fully fledged members of the cusd community and worse those students and families who often suffer most from these scenarios are the very students and families who are the least prepared to advocate for themselves in the counseling process and often have the greatest counseling needs in comparison to their student peers thank you thank you um may get a motion I'll move uh to approve the consent agenda and agenda as uh presented I'll second okay Eric hi Aaron hi Jamie hi I'm I okay moving on to our student representative Report with Angel all right student representative report provided by me angel pinetta uh senior Carbon High School but let's get on with it uh tomorrow is the first day of finals at carpentry high school finals will be administered

071Wednesday Thursday and Friday uh of this week and just a reminder that that finals are held on a minimum Day schedule which is really fantastic ASB has selected the mar mon hotel for the 2025 prom venue uh this event will be held on May 17th 2025 and I will gladly provide you guys with more information once the date is closer carb FFA has sold out their ponas during their annual sales and have sold over 300 ponas to the local community we want to thank everyone who supported the students in this incredible Endeavor winter sports are in full swing please consider attending one of the many uh events to support our student athletes it's very rewarding to see our local fans up on the stands at all these competitions our annual gym bore holiday cage classic

072will run Friday Saturday and Monday please join us at the Carpenter high school gym for this very special event finally I want to remind everyone that we will be back in class from our winter break on Thursday January 9th 2025 thank you very much thanks Angel thanks angel thank you any questions or comments for angel from the board no all right thank you very much Angel public comment on our student representative report all right so first I want to thank Angel for sharing the details contained in the student report uh once again he brings the good news of what's going on with students at the high school in an enthusiastic and a positive manner um you you blow me way of your ability to do that you've always been that way and you continue to

073be that way and I'm sure you're going to continue to be that way so thank you uh know that all the faculty and support staff that worked with these high school students and especially these seniors that are preparing for such big events in their lives um that we're all rooting for you um you may not have talked to some of us for a long time you may not have been with some of those who are you know maybe you don't some might not even remember some of those kindergarten first grade you know names and but they know the faces and they know the heart that went into it and and we're all pulling for you all and U you know do know that and also I I want to personally thank you for standing up

074and sharing so vulnerably um what you did this evening um it it really speaks to the crisis that we're in in the district and and how it affects our students and we really hope that everybody watching and certainly those five of you and Miss green uh really understand what's going on here and think about that when you're making decisions in the future so thank you again okay moving on to our superintendent report thank you um tonight I'd like to B begin with appreciation and I'd like to recognize our classroom and special education instructional assistant who support students and teachers in our schools my next item is the screening students for risk of reading difficulties Ed code section 530008 requires that all local school districts to assess students from kindergarten to grade two for risk of

075reading difficulties with a screener from the approved CDE list that beginning no later than the 2526 school year honor before December 31st 2024 the approved CD list will be voted on by the reading difficulties rist screen selection panel and onor before June 30th of 2025 School District governing board serving kindergarten to grade 2 shall adopt one of them or more screeners from the approved CDE list currently our elementary schools are piloting the UCSF multitudes reading screener in second grade classrooms reading intervention teachers at our elementary schools provide small group targeted in systemic instruction for struggling readers my next item item is about our high school student performances the CHS Muses performed the canville ghost adapted from the Oscar wild story last week December 4th through the 7th and last night the CHS uh band concert

076was held with both the orchestra and the muses performing holiday Coral selections my next item is um news about the anatomy class at the high school CHS Anatomy teacher Miss Rogan organized an enrich field trip to Santa Barbara City College biomedical Department Westmont College downtown Nursing campus and Westmont College campus at C sbcc students had the unique opportunity to participate in an anatomy lab dissecting a cadaver under the guidance of experienced professionals this hands-on experience provided invaluable insights into human anatomy during the visit to the Westmont downtown Nursing campus CHS students were taken through Ro ating stations to listen to lung and heart sounds in manquin patients perform CPR tour the facilities and speak with current nursing students the trip culminated with a campus tour and lunch at the Maine Westmont College campus we extend

077our sincere gratitude to miss Rogan for organizing this remarkable field trip we also thank Santa Barbara City College biomedic science department and Westmont College for their warm Hospitality while providing our students with these invaluable learning experiences my next item is about carpentry a family school on Thursday this Thursday December 19th at 6 o'clock CFS students will perform a musical the holiday show in which moose learns about the winter holiday celebrations from his Forest Friends the next item is regarding the parent involvement at the middle school carpentera middle school has a group of sixth grade parents to help supervise lunchtime since the beginning of the year CMS volunteer parents assist with Supervision in the lunch lines interact with students and create Rapport and facilitate structured games on the field the pickle ball court and the gym

078options for students at lunch include indoor and outdoor volleyball and basketball pickle ball GaGa ball structured soccer football catch and occasionally flag football about 75% of CMS students are engaging in these lunchtime activities which facilitate a calm productive and fun atmosphere of the campus we appreciate the volunteer parents and thank them for their ongoing support cusd partner day Daybreak health is now offering a free webinar in English and Spanish on January 22nd at 6 o'clock for parents to learn about healthy Communications and relationships with their children led by a licensed clinician parents will learn about strategies to Broach difficult conversations with their children registration information will be posted on parents Square my next item is regarding our partnership with United Way cusd is partnering with United Way to provide a free winter break program for

079for TK to 5 students January 2nd through the 8th at canalino school this Extended Learning break program will offer daily literacy practice stem activities social emotional learning outdoor play and Community exploration during the week and my last item is exciting news about measure youu movein day for the calinao Learning Center has been rescheduled for late December and the opening ceremony is Wednesday January 22nd at 3:30 the new tkk building project at liso has now been registered with DSA and the work on the construction documents are anticipated to be completed at the end of the calendar year and DSA submitt remains scheduled for January 202 thank you thank you any questions um I have a couple uh well qu comments questions um comments first of all um the screening for students um I am that's this

080is a really necessary um opportunity for so many of our students uh that are struggling they don't understand why they're struggling their parents don't understand why they're struggling and it turns out they can't see or hear properly um and so this early screening is so important um I got the email uh today in parents Square um and it gives the parents all the information about it um and this is just a a really important opportunity for our students um unfortunately I missed uh the muses performances I had uh I wasn't able to go but I've heard some really great things about it uh the anatomy class trip with Miss Rogan um I know from all that this encompassed um she took a lot of time outside of the classroom to pull this together um and

081it it was extraordinary to to do this and so um truly grateful for this opportunity um and for her to do this for our kids especially using the newer um Westmont Nursing Facility um that's a great opportunity uh parent involvement at CMS really excited about this I've heard great feedback from the parents uh this is something years ago we had hoped to be able to do um something like this and then unfortunately Co and it really wasn't compatible um so I'm glad that this is happening um it's always been this weird like we go from elementary school where parents are on campus all day long helping in the classroom doing all the things and then for so long you'd get to middle school and it was like see you we don't want you here and

082it felt very strange and and counterintuitive to not use um the resource of parents on campus um so I'm I'm I'm glad they found a good way to do this a balance um and that it's productive um and then on the United Way partnership for the TK five uh winter break program are students um how how do students enroll do parents have to enroll their students or are families notified that this is a good fit for their child like how do they get access to this both ways okay both ways and they're all enrolled okay yeah we have over 55 students cool um okay public comment on the oh question on on the screening um do you know if they there screen for tracking issues like uh you know the the I know the you

083know the Lions used to still does ice screening but but I just know that um a lot of a lot of kids especially uh have difficulty reading because their their eyes don't track the same and so they they just you know like Olivia our daughter had it and so she didn't like to read it all and we figured it out and and then all of a sudden she became a good reader I just didn't know that was part of the screening process I don't think they're going to identify what the cause is they're going to identify that if they have an issue yes if they have an isue and then there will be further assessments thanks anything else public comment on the superintendent's report [Music] please all righty so superintendent ry's appreciation for our District's

084instructional assistance couldn't be more appropriate CD's instructional provide critical support in some of the most challenging environments in the district they serve across the district working with many of the most atrisk student populations we serve IAS more than any other job classification have felt the impact of the district's labor shortages they are often shuffled around at a moment's notice to serve students and support academic content they have not had adequate time to familiarize themselves with or even worse that demand a level of training our I our IAS have not received many of CD's I whom are known by first name by students families and teachers have been with the district for many years they remain with us after many administrative changes curricular changes the pandemic fires debris flows and then even threats of layoffs after

085that yet they were admonished for expressing their dissatisfaction when hiring practices gave hiring bonuses to new employees but not to those who remained with the district then they watched those same newer employees receive salaries that exceed seeded their own after they' provided 10 15 or 20 years of service to the district so although the appreciation is well warranted and long overdue there is more to it than that Union leadership must share the following because we are obligated or I should say because we are not obligated to share conditions as they ought to be but rather as they are when superintendent Rigby shares her quote appreciation for classroom and special education instructional assistance it may not have been exactly as it appears or sounds Miss rig's appreciation when translated and informed by many instructional assistants who

086have reached out to Union leadership could otherwise read like this Miss Rigby expresses her appreciation for the instructional assistants who chose not to share their voice experience and concerns at this evening's meeting but instead chose to sit this one out it's not a coincidence that Miss rig's appreciation specifically included our special education instructional AIDS many if they were to speak openly would expose the district's failure to provide sped students with their legal right to specialized instruction support and resources contained in their IEPs 504s and similar legally binding documents you heard about that from others Beyond myself today didn't you many IAS don't share these experiences with the public either out of fear of administrative retaliation or the professional instability that speaking up with bring he heard that as well as a result the mismanagement concerns

087for student safety and failure to provide services to sped students who are entitled go un addressed just as the accountability that superintendent Rigby so deserves when considering Miss Rigby's expression of appreciation we should be realistic about what may be motivating her gratitude thank you okay moving on to G1 memorandum of understanding between Carpenter at Unified School District cusd and Cal California College guidance initiative ccgi the board is asked to approve theou between cusd and ccgi to enhance student preparedness for College and Career Success California has implemented the California College guidance initiative this state funded platform provides students with essential tools to explore college options identify career paths understand financial aid opportunities plan their coursework and gain insights into job market trends ccgi serves as the centralized hub for students to apply to California state universities

088University of California campuses and complete the free application for federal student aid FAFSA all public high schools in California are mandated to adopt ccgi by 2026 the presentation will be made by CHS principal Haro corneill uh good evening so uh I'm here to give you more information about what uh ccgi is which is the California College guidance initiative this is actually now a requirement for most grants that we write um so um we are it takes about 6 to 7 months for this to come live one of the biggest things is how do we work with our data our course offerings our transcripts to daily sync with ccgi so that the data is accurate as students apply for colleges so I'm going to give you an example this is what a student would see uh

089when they apply so every student in the state of California already has an account uh it does not come live until we be we uh apply for theou this is a free program for all schools for all students uh and the nice thing about it is that uh the counselors also get to follow the students so when a student applies for uh FAFSA the the counselors will be able to see whether they've submitted it are they're still uh halfway done they can call in the student if they have applied for uh a college they are able to follow the application to make sure it's been completed and it's been submitted a lot of times students will say I've submitted the application but it has not gone through so this way the counselors can speak to

090the students and the student says well I submitted it last night I don't think so you forgot to push a button so uh as the students uh come in on to the application uh there are uh there's a menu above and then you have the different uh a topics at the bottom so I'm going to we're going to go through the bottom the the academic and one of the things about it is this is a one portal so students don't need to go to different websites it is all from one website uh and the and the account follows the student throughout their career at in the state so if they if they move the account goes with them so they don't lose any of the information so uh let's go to um the academic planner

091so the academic planner is uh very interesting in the fact that this component of the program is speaking daily to our Aries database uh it reviews the grades and it makes it into a nice graph for the students to know whether they're meeting the a3g requirements so uh this is the GPA that the student has at the high school and it's based on what uh students are taking so here uh the students uh this is a typical 12th grade student uh they have the grade for the courses that they've taken and they're currently meaning that they're going to be taking a 12th grade world history or uh sheltered US History I'm just giving you an example uh these are the grades for English which is breaking it down into the a through G uh eligibility

092guidelines and there's no grade here because the student is probably in their seventh uh semester and they're still waiting to complete that additional last semester before they graduate so as the student reviews this they can say wait a minute there's a class missing or you know I took that class as a dual enrollment and it's not showing up so this is a way for students to visually see what is being put in into each category and at the bottom these are the ones that there are questions so here's an example there's a d so it's telling the student uh this does not meet the criteria so you need to retake that class but at the bottom it's these are additional cours workk so this is somebody took it probably at another high school um so

093or there could be a city college dualing class that the student took that is on the transcript but it the system does not know where to put it so this is a way for the student to visually see where their courses fall a lot of times students will apply currently and then they get a email from the college saying tell us about this course where does it fall so this is a way for uh before they submit they know exactly where everything is going to fall So currently our local colleges are using also to apply to uh community colleges but um notice the GPA this is the high school transcript but when you uh when you apply to the calate system the GPA is recalculated based on the CR because they take away all the

094the uh non like P classes they'll take all the those courses Tas all those courses don't count and these are just the academic a through G courses that fall in so here's an example of what their GPA at the at Cal State University system what it would look like and notice now they have a check mark so you've comp this this is telling our student you've completed the a component of the a3g and you have a GPA here these are two years required two years completed the same same thing with English remember we mentioned that there was that class the same thing with math uh four years recommended 3 years required so this student is going for 4 years and notice everything that is in green it's got a check mark telling the student you've

095completed this remember that D we mentioned earlier well it's telling the student yeah you completed it but you haven't met the criteria there's no check mark here so they're going to have to go back and take that class either through City College an additional course of the high school or credit recovery and these These are the courses that the student also took for the letter G at the bottom you will notice these are courses that but not found in our database or in their database so all of our courses when um that we have at carpentry high school we upload to what is called UC doorways so each class falls into one of the categories uh about 90 95% of our courses fall into those a through G uh categories a b c and each

096letter is for a specific category so the letter G is the electives so any parent can go onto uh our UC doorways course list and they can see all the courses that we have at carpentry high school that fall in a specific letter so this is right here telling us uh we don't know where this is falled maybe they took it online may they maybe they took it at another school and we did not code it correctly or that that school did not code it correctly so this is telling the student before you submit go and check this information so this is for the Cal State system but let's assume that the student is going to apply for the UC system notice the GPA changes because they have a different criteria and it's go it

097goes through the same process and the and then you have the legend here of what it stands for these are the if you want to go and apply I'm not going to do that so I don't have to get out of the system students will click here and it will take them directly to the website to apply for the Cal State system or the UC system so this is the academic P planner the other nice thing about it is that it's got various categories so this is where the student has uh entered items of what do they see for themselves in the future we currently do this in our get Focus day Focus class in the nth grade but now it's embedded in this program uh my career plan what do I want to do

098in the future so here it is telling me I want to do this I want to be a agent of business so if I click here it will take me to give me more information about what colleges offer that that degree how much does it uh does it cost what's the out Outlook in the next couple of years and then this is another career so it's giving me all the careers that I have selected and most of these careers are also selected by the student or they can also do a um a career interest profile so uh here's an example of you can also take you know I don't know if you ever heard of the seven intelligences or you know some of the skills that you may have personality some people like working with

099on the front line some people like working in the back with without working with a lot of people so this is the career assessment you can also have career uh Search tool it tells you if you're interested in a specific career what colleges offer that course or that degree what are the requirements for admissions and what's the outlook for that career and this is also again choosing a career which then uh goes back to the interest profile the other thing that this has is when you go to my college plan it tells me I'm interested in going to this college it is a public school for 2 years uh this is another school that I I've selected but if I click on just an example I'm going to go to uh so this is the

100colleges that I'm interested but it also tells me what what other what college visits visit visits have you done in the past because this is also going to be sent to the counselors when they're uh writing those letters of recommendation the counselors have access to this so they can go back and right now they do a braack sheet I've visited this school I'm interested in this this will all be ready for the counselors the counselors will have an access to uh this that the student has prepared this again goes to the application directly where you want to apply this is the list of Majors so I can go in here and I say you know this is what I've uh on this date I really liked this uh major and then uh you can also

101upload test scores that you have the other nice thing about it is that a lot of times students will go and get financial aid uh award letters and they have no idea what that means uh this also provides us with the opportunity to um do a a review of the of the grants and scholarships that you've gotten to find out how much do you still need to find to pay for the college whether you're going to come out with debts it also gives you information about scholarships so this is a uh a one hub for all of our students so as we um intend to have this on online by next year our uh every student will have something to do with this as they move forward in our system uh for nth graders is

102perhaps doing the career inventory for ninth for 10th graders start doing some College and Career um major Majors um reviews for juniors after we do the college visits is figuring out what colleges do you want to go to and uh again this is right now when a student goes to see a counselor is like have you filled this thing I don't know this is the one way of us finding all the information for our students in one database uh so this is going to make everything much simpler so when a students apply for a college they will know exactly where each course Falls what it meets and uh what their GPA will be like uh like when they apply this is free uh this is uh again we are required to be part of this

103um ccgi by 2026 uh so we hope to have it done a year earlier and have it with our class that begins uh next year gosh thank you uh questions from the board uh thank you that's great um uh I'm curious how how it integrates with the common app it does not integrate with the Common App there is another system that we could purchase uh the Common App um is not something that the state of California controls uh because you have a lot of private colleges outside of the State uh this is um a state database uh that follows the students through their state cesis number um but uh as we move forward I don't um doubt that they'll probably incorporate the Common App into this um because I think aren't the CAL States using

104the Common App now they are but um the database that we're using and because this is housed in Sacramento uh through the uh ccgi is paid for by us taxpayers so uh this is not going to go away but they're going to probably get some pressure to add the Common App yeah um but the nice thing about it right now is that when we tell students go and apply for College uh soon uh they will also be able to apply for community colleges so if I go here just an example uh let's U if I go to college applications I can apply for uh Community College and it takes me to this website so student they don't have to find the website sometimes we are worried whether they're actually putting the information on the right

105website they may have one or two letters off this takes them directly to the website that is needed for them to apply uh more Community College are moving into this um uh one application so that the students are able to move from one from one District to another okay thanks yeah I just I mean I think I've mentioned this to you before but um I think we should be encouraging our students to apply out of state um not not just because it gets some more you know experiences outside of California but but what we found was that um that the cost for some of the out of state tuition as long as your grades are are good um is actually less than uh what what the tuition uh room and board um is at the

106at the uh CAL States and uc's yes and the nice thing about it is that when you do search um community colleges they do have information um because we've been playing around with this they do have information of a lot of private schools Independent Schools but they have not branched out to out of California U websites or colleges there is another application out there for common app and for out ofate that is called score uh some of the schools north of us use it and they get charged per student but um the idea is for us not to have different databases um and right now the Common App we have enough support on our counseling department to support the student uh but the idea and again we are meeting with our uh ccgi Partners literally

107every month uh we have a meeting on the 22nd of of next month and I will bring up the IDE of the Common App thank you thanks any anybody else before I jump in okay um thank you this is really great um and I really appreciate kind of the exercise that this will help the go through through their four years to figure out where they want to go um are there um any like trade or vocational schools also yes so if I go to uh College um if I go to colleges and I do College Tour uh search you have independent and then you try to do the majors so if I want to go to agriculture science I want to do Agri business and I apply uh so these are the colleges that are

108is telling me regarding that specific um field of study I can go in and I can type in college private I can type in level of college I can type in how much I want to pay the type of environment of a school I want to size of a school acceptance rate of a school uh specialty school so if I can come here I can do I want a um Native American institution so it will give me the information based on the criteria that I've selected uh I can also do a search based on the cost uh religious affiliation and sports wow that's great so again all these websites normally we would have to give students a list of websites to go to this is just in one place so a counselor can literally go

109into the classroom as a n9th grade or whatever grade we choose to start implementing this they can do lessons now early on uh and the counselors can start working with the students in their ninth grade so that they become more familiar in what what the student is interested as they move forward through the system um yeah I I definitely see the value in this um and it's great that it's finally there um so it it links with Aries automatically which is great um and then our counselors will follow through is there any additional um effort on part of teachers to do anything to input into this no okay so the moment the student gets their schedule uh those courses will show up in those uh on that list of courses that they have don't have

110a grade those courses that already have been given a grade the both systems will sync with each other and they will take whatever is on the transcript then go to the the UC doorways take a look at the course that we have our course number our course name and it will look to find that course on the UC doors doorways website and say there's a match here and that goes here okay so as we work with the program we uh it's trying to figure out uh like for example I went to a workshop back in early September and when they gave out a list of all the courses that are not able to be synced correctly with other other high schools we only had one class that was off by uh the course number uh

111and that was a course that we don't offer anymore but other schools had lists after list of courses because we're only one high school district uh in many school districts it's one person putting in the information for all the high schools or one high school will use that name for this course and that other High School uses this name for that course the students transfer and then things don't don't speak to each other well so we're very lucky in the fact that we have one high school yeah we have one database and it's very consistent how does it integrate with with the FAFSA so uh when a student is going to apply for financial aid so you go into the financial aid um so this this is the applications and it will take you directly

112to apply it gives gives you the information it tells you what you're in what you need to uh gives you some lessons and then you can go directly to the financial aid website if you're not eligible for a website they will that application it will tell you other resources that you may have okay so but it basically takes you outside the system so you can complete the FAA but the system's connection is secured so it's not like oh it's a different website I was putting in Social Security numbers that I thought it was fter but it may have been faster thought something yeah so not so uh again this is one of the uh right now when we go into the classrooms we ask the students let's do a a FAFSA um checklist by doing

113this there's a financial checklist what will you need I will need all this information so attend cast for college workshops um a lot of the times when we will get um College visits or when we have cash for college all that information will be inputed into um this database and students will get an email saying there's been an updated event that you may be interested in great so the schools in Ventura already some of them have already started doing this um uh some of the schools up north uh there's about half of them that have started uh and again it goes back to the first step is uh having our system speak to their system to make sure that there are no hiccups and and then just to clarify we the class of 2025 will

114not be using this it'll be the current it yeah so it'll start next fall okay um and then let's see here you asked about financial aid um there are some things that as we move forward in the system we can say you know we're going to do it to the to use this lesson with the eighth graders before they come to the high school perhaps course planning so those are the things that are that's the nice thing about this is that um every day they're adding new tools to this um portal uh but it's been uh very uh refreshing to see how professional they are are willing how they're willing to make adjustments based on our needs um because they want to make sure that this is a successful program that it doesn't get launched

115and then a year later it says n we don't want to use it it's not feasible but everything that we've seen and played around with as counselors and as a teacher or and as a student because we have accounts for those all those um it's been very interesting for us to see how everything is in one place easy to use with a lot of information for everybody and the nice thing about it is that um you can also uh translate this into whatever language you want and a lot of times when you translate websites it does not translate the graphic this one does translate the graphic into whatever language you're interested in fabulous any further questions or comments great okay thank you so much thanks y so public comment uh we're going to go ahead

116and take public comment on G1 no comment thank you I'd like to move to approve theou with the ccgi and uh at see if I get that right the memorandum of understanding with the with the with CD and the uh California College guidance initiative has presented all second discussion I think it's great I think uh um it it because that Pro having gone through that process now three times it's it's um um I think very it's very can be very confusing timec consuming and uh to to you know to compile all of your grades and transcripts and and extracurricular I just think it's it's really going to be helpful um to to our students and to our counselors um to keep everyone on track and I hope hopefully they will integrate it with the Common

117App yeah I think having this C this program being centralized but also having the visioning process in there all integrated so they can see all the different aspects of how it comes together um all of the the financial aid options and um scholarship access to the different scholarship databases it's really overwhelming and so having it all in one spot is pretty cool um we haven't gone through this process yet in my house but I remember when I did it and it was pretty hard and it's also um an opport a tool that uh families can use you know it's not just between student and counselor now it's a tool that's available so um parents and students can have conversations about it and the information is all right there well the parents can actually see what's

118what what's you know what they can understand that process better that's really a good too right okay uh all in favor hi hi wonderful uh moving on to H1 warrants the board has asked to approve the warrants for the period of 11222 24 through 12224 in the amount of 2,800 , 3945 warrants are issued once a week on Thursdays the report format shows check number check date pay brief account description payment comment and check amount questions from the board on our warrants okay seeing none we move to public comment on warrants okay so the district's legal cost for personnel and negotiations totals $ 36,7 195 in for this two-e warrant uh therefore another 36,000 plus dollars is being added to the district's 9month total of over 500,000 or 500 yes $500,000 a half a million

119dollars which is just a fraction of the $3.5 million uh spent or uh of a crude debt uh in the previous 18-month period um these legal costs are now 10 times higher annually than the district knew before the arrival of superintendent Rigby and the majority of our current School Board legal fees that account for approximately half of the district's cost overrun cited in the end of the year 2324 budget presentation in June as well it is fair to say that District leadership's performance has been truly extraordinary in the area of legal actions and expenditures and many employees and community members are pleased that some of you have vowed to resign your seats when the district's current appeal of the state's unanimous decision against the cusd is rejected unfortunately in the meantime as long as cusd

120continues to miss appropriate tax dollars this way here is where these tax dollars will not be invested the district will not invest these tax dollars taxpayer dollars towards providing routine classroom supplies that have been denied at several School sites supplies like paper color print printers adequately function copiers toner Etc the district will not invest these half million dollars to improve Recruitment and compensation values that help to resolve Staffing shortages across the district and create stability for District employees which in turn create stability for our students and their families improving working conditions that would stem The Exodus of Highly qualified talent from cusd will not be invested in such as increasing classroom support in the form of more instruction AIDS or lowering case numbers per sped teachers so that they may better serve their students and

121families it won't be invested in bringing back a full-time District nurse who is not on a limited contract for a comparatively extraordinary hourly wage the money will not be invested in improving safety practices and training that would prevent the injury of students and employees in the teaching and learning environment these injuries keep stacking up with another employee again now uh now on jury leave in I'm sorry on injury leave in just the last two weeks we asked this when it was just a few individuals harmed and now we ask again after others can be included on that list how many employees and students have already been injured at calino this year are any of you keeping count or how about investments in better supporting behaviorally challenged students migrant ed students or English language newcomers thank

122you thank you your time is up there's a lot more than that thank you okay I'll move to approve the warrant as presented I'll second that okay uh any discussion all in favor I uh H2 gifts grants and donations we have uh 2A a grant from Chevron through carpentera Education Foundation to carpentera medal School we're asked to accept the Grant from Chevron through CF of $20,000 to the carpentero middle school for the fishing youth program um the one that was approved earlier on the consent agenda any questions from the board okay public comment on 2A cause of leadership and the employees we represent want to thank those community members who provide grants and gifts to CD without any unethical or unprofessional strings attached uh this grant appears to be one and as it is tied

123to the consent agenda that you've already approved it seems you now have an obligation to accept this grant uh we can't figure out why you wouldn't but we have had a hard time figuring out is where this Grant and others like it can be found in the first interim report if Mr CF or any of the board members or Miss riby would like to explain um I'd be happy to yield the rest of my time to that explanation [Music] thank you may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve as uh as presented and thanks to Chevron thank you Jamie for um coordinating with the fishing guys yeah do we have a second a second okay um discussion yeah so uh this was an opportunity um we had this program last year um

124there was a handful of kids that this really spoke to and so um I pursued uh with Chevron through their Community investment grant program um to secure this again this year and uh Chevron has been very generous with their Community Investments with carpentera over the years and um they have a new representative he is really uh excited to to be part of the community he knows he has big shoes to fill from Sarah deerman but um he's doing a great job and uh I look forward to to how we can partner on other um projects in the future great thank you all in favor I okay uh 2B donation from L Centra Summerland Foundation to carpentry athletic booster club uh board has asked to accept this donation from lentra suan for $20,000 to boosters for

125the principal discretionary fund any questions okay public comment on 2B well wow uh is what employees say when they hear about this last board meeting the center Summerland provided approximately $120,000 in Grants gifts and donations this evening they provide another $20,000 um cause leadership and the employees we represent continue to thank those community members who provide grants and gifts to CD without any unethical or unprofessional strings attached um although it remains a bit unclear where Los Centra Summerland funds originate we appreciate the benefits that bring that they bring to CD students in the community uh we hope that these donations have no connection to the very sale of products that are simultaneously complicating the lives and well-being of District students while on our campuses um Union leadership has inquired directly into this topic and is

126awaiting a response from Los Cent Summerland staff uh we look forward to confirming our appreciation without any reservations shortly in the meantime uh 120 plus 20,000 uh dollars it's $140,000 and uh we are still trying to figure out uh where these Grant revenues and grants like them can be found in the first interim report and if you would be willing to share that Mr CF uh esteemed board members or Miss Rigby I'd be happy to yield the rest of uh our time once again thank you may I get a motion to approve I move to approve I'll second that thank you lent suan yeah thank you again uh all in favor I I to C donation from Mark Gonzalez from the Kim and Andrew dbsh Family Foundation to carpentera high school we're being asked to

127accept this donation from Mark Gonzalez from the Kim and Andrew Debush Family Foundation of $500 to carpentera High School principal's discretionary fund questions from the board okay public comment on Toc oh thank you uh cause leadership and the employees we represent want to again thank those community members who provide grants and gifts to the cusd without any unethical or unprofessional strings attached um we appreciate Mr Gonzalez thank you Mark for um the Kim and Andrew dbsh Family Foundation donation uh and their generosity it's terrific um we also wonder um where this Grant and other grants like it could be found in the first interim report the first inm report where we have enormous concerns about revenues being underestimated and expenditures being overestimated thus driving down our District's Reserves at a time when we're bargaining available

128monies for employee compensation so I yield the rest of my time to either Mr CF Mr Schaefer um or any of our board members and Miss Rigby to clarify where in the first intim report will we find that you are permitted to answer you you're aware of that right as long as the community is aware of that I think that's what's most important okay once again thank you may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve I'll second discussion thank you Mark all in favor I I 2D donation from CHS Athletics Boosters club to CHS Athletics the board has asked to accept the following donations from the Boosters club to the athletic department of $1,000 $1,492 to girls and boys basketball teams for soccer uniforms and $112,000 for fall and winter Athletics expenses

129questions public comment on 2D all righty so once again cause leadership and the employees we represent want to thank those community members who provide grants and gifts to the CD without any unethical and unprofessional strings attached the CHS athletic boosters deserve recognition again for their consistent support of District students and learning opportunities both inside and outside of the classroom um now not to beat a dead horse here okay but we continue to wonder where these $23,000 worth of Grant monies and grants like it can be found in the first interim report that's the same interim report that we already clarified we have concerns about where revenues are underestimated expenditures are overestimated and the result is that it drives down the district Reserves at a time when the district and the union District employees are trying

130to determine available monies for salary increases we'd hate to think that's intentional so I yield time again for clarification Mr CF if you'd like to clarify any of our board members or Miss Rigby please do miss Rigby were you going to clarify no I'm not going to clarify Oh I thought I heard you say something no okay will anybody clarify thank you once again we I get a motion to approve move to approve as presented all second okay any discussion thank you boosters for buying uniforms yes yes thank you boosters um okay all in favor I hi we're moving on to to the 2324 annual audit the board has asked to review and approve the 2324 annual audit in accordance with Education Code 41020 point3 by January 31 of each year the governing board of

131each local Education Agency shall review at a public meeting the annual audit of the local Education Agency for the prior year and any audit exceptions identified in the audit the recommendations or findings if any management letter is issued by the audit and any description of Correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue there are no financial statement audit findings for the 2324 fiscal year however there are three program audit findings in 2324 which are explained including the district corrective responses on page 82 through 84 well for the 2324 fiscal year our Auditors uh Christy White and Associates issued an unmodified opinion an unmodified opinion is the best type of opinion a school district can receive because it basically means that the audit team did not find anything significant um as as was

132just mentioned there were no financial statement a of findings however we did have three program findings our first finding was with regards to our Aces attendance um the Auditors determined that the Asus attendance records were not matching the School attendance numbers so uh we have looked into it and we have implemented a process which should which should eliminate this finding going forward that was Finding number one excuse me um the Asus is our after school program yes thank you very much people may not thank you uh finding number two um this is with regards to uh site attendance um this is a repeat finding and and it has to do with the district not having a CDE approved electronic digital signature attendance system uh we've been working on this with CDE for more than a

133year and we are making Headway uh we we've had some recent correspondence with with CDE and there's one more final step that we have to do uh with CD and our Auditors but we're hopeful that we can get this issue resolved in the next couple months so hopefully we won't see this in our 24 25 audit and our third finding is with regards to classroom teachers salaries and we refer to finding number three as like a a CA a CA finding CA basically stands for current expense of education so with regards to with regards to this CA finding um the district has already filed a waiver uh with the county office now what's driving this finding is that um our district like other districts in Center Bara County uh did not meet their CA percentage

134um for district like for districts like ours if we're unified there's Ed code that says that 55% of your expenses should be spent on classroom teacher salaries now even though that is the Ed code there are exceptions uh to that rule so just for some history here's how sbceo has been dealing with for the kep for the past couple years so after the UN audited actuals are filed um with the county office like for instance we're talking let's say 22 23 uh so the county office would res would review the waiver that that went along with the ca finding so see the county office would review this waiver and then it would approve it in a fairly short term so let's say within 30 days so if the county office received a waiver in October

135they then the district would receive an approved waiver from sbco let's say in early November it would take that approved waiver and send it to the auditors and so the Auditors would not write a finding because the issue had been resolved per the County Office of Education so that's how that's what was happening in 2223 and going further back now for the 23 24 year SB SB CEO changed their process so now what they're doing is even though District like ours where um we do have this issue and by the way there are hundreds of districts in the state who who have this exact same issue and who who are doing this exact same process so now what SB CEO is doing is that they're waiting until after the Auditors have issued a finding then

136they will re then they will take a look at the waiver and approve the waivers at a later date I've inquired of the the county office as to when they'll be getting around to approving uh waivers for our County and they said it'll most likely be in the spring so we're hopeful that maybe by April uh we'll have an approved waiver from the county office for this CA uh finding did they give you any indication as to why they made the change they did not um and since this was from last year I'm not exactly sure what happened but I don't have any information as to why SBO changed their process unfortunately so most of our districts will have audit findings this year for the cea because they will not receive their waivers in time

137most of the districts in our County it it just seems like there should be some sort of explanation yeah um as as you know it's a fairly big change in policy why why they would why they would make such a change with no explanation they did not give us an explanation okay um okay um and just sorry to clarify we have been getting this waiver in years past I looked or have we always been applying for this waiver because if it's it doesn't always show up since it wasn't showing up previously right um for 22 23 we did fall below the 55% that's required but we fell under a different exception at that time which has to do with low class size um I did explore that option for the district in 23 24 but

138unfortunately uh we did not meet that exception so we so we pursued the uh basically the financial hardship exception um and so we've written that into the uh waiver and filed that with the county office okay and prior to 2223 we we were getting waivers then is right well right I don't have the those prior years in front of me so I would have to go back and look but I can't answer that off the top of my head right I'd like to I'd like to know if we H is there a way to know if we had filed waivers before sure okay sure we can go back and look at the records okay um okay so corrective action plan sorry is there some is there's more Beyond this um so with regards to the

139uh corrective action plan there's a large number of districts in California who are not meeting this so what in my experience what what tends to happen is once a district reaches this level um that they continue to file waivers and given SB CEO's change in process it's highly likely that we'll we will be seeing this audit finding year after year uh but we're not alone there are other districts in Canta barara County that are you know noticing this difference and they'll be filing waivers with the county office as well so um in my opinion this will be a recurring finding for which we'll have to file uh recurring waivers okay I mean okay okay um and then uh sorry okay that just thre me um on the uh okay so the teachers attendance reports I

140I recall that and I remember we were working on this last year as well and I can't recall off the top of my head I know I probably asked this but we I mean we're not the only School using the system I'm assuming for attendance this isn't some like crazy thing no dig taken it's taken the CDE years and years to work with us this has been an audit finding for many years okay get their response it's taken several years okay um and then uh what let's see here we're doing compiling the attendance numbers for the um Aces program um what are we doing like a certain program for attendance on that now that we weren't before or what we're putting in place a a process in which the after school leaders are checking their

141attendance with Aries they're using the Aries system in a more effective way okay um so we are being asked to riew and approve uh any further questions at this point not discussion but [Music] questions [Music] um I mean I I feel like this is like a glaring question but because this is essentially unknown right now this is um this is the waiver going to be looming over us for till April yes um what happens in the meantime like what needs to happen What should like I don't understand what happen it's like this weird limbo like yes um the county office basically hasn't given us any guidance on this but it's my understanding that there's nothing we need to do at this time um since we've already filed the waiver um at this point we're just

142kind of in in essentially a holding pattern until we you know get their uh get their approval okay and we I just wanted to be are we anticipating approval of this waiver yes um we do we have any reason to not no uh it's pretty significant yeah and so just based on the number there so what this basically means is that we would have to put that deficiency on our salary schedule there's absolutely no way with our current budget that that can work and so on that basis of financial hardship that's how we filed our waiver okay well these are the findings I I had a question on the on the finding instructional materials I I can I I thought we did have a hearing on instructional materials that was last year that that finding

143was last year's finding and then that just shows the correction we had it this year was aing from yeah 234 thought we did then too all right I had said the same thing and I tried to go back and didn't see it we had I think it was the year before that where we adopted the new textbooks and things like that um but yeah it wasn't there [Music] um and then we have uh home to school transportation again last year yeah yes so you recall we did a transportation plan last spring thank you okay that's covering all of the findings I just want to make sure we went through all of them thank you uh public comment on the audit we encourage the community to turn to page 84 in the Autumn report in the

144audit report which is actually page 93 of the electronic PDF document attached to the board agenda what the audit confirms is a significant detail it pertains to the district's investments in employees or failure to invest in employees critical resources needed to deliver effective and highquality instruction and care to District students and families instead of instead of investing approximately $3.5 million in the district's students families and learning cusd instead invested that money into failed attempts to punish elected employee representatives and obstruct the collective bargaining process and as a result the district did not meet the state's required investment in employees for 232 that's what everybody was talking about here while not talking about it under the section's condition and the section effect quote in the 2324 fiscal year Carpenter Unified School District did not meet the

145minimum minimum percentage requirement of 55% cusd spent 46.64 per on classified teacher salaries the district was below the minimum again minimum re acquired percentage of 55% by 8.36% which calculates out to a deficiency of guess what $3,522 th000 here's another way of looking at it the 3 million $3.5 million the district did not invest in employees and instead invested in a tax on employee Representatives is equivalent to a single salary year increase of 177% now that takes a lot to take in that's a lot to take in so allow me to repeat those figures the three, 522,000 the district did not invest in employees and instead invested in a tax unanimous unanimously determined to be retaliatory discriminatory and unfounded by both California perb and the state's office of administrative hearings is equivalent to a single-ear

146salary increase of over 7 % when you offered employees 2 to 25% and gave yourselves 10 and 12 now further down the page The District offers its excuse for this failure quote the lcff gives the district tremendous flexibility on how funds are used and has a requirement that supplemental concentration funds are spent according to the lcap however C usd's excuse simply does not hold water because neither the lcff criteria nor any lcap o obligations required cusd to spend $3.5 million on illegal attacks against employee representatives and to undermine the bargaining relationship Union leadership rejects the district's excuse and so should the community may I get a motion I'll move to approve uh the 2324 annual audit as as uh presented I'll second discussion I you know I think we had pretty good questions there I

147I think we just' be good to get some of that information U Back on on previous years I I think it yes I agree I would really like to know what what um what things were like historically um and if we've been using a waiver or not um Rec collection as we have been I I believe so yeah I just I would because it actually shows up um we and it didn't show up before if we had so um just verifying for the waiver um yeah okay uh we have a first we have a second uh all in favor of approving I I okay H4 resolution 24934 resolution of the governing board delegation of governing board powers and duties the board is asked to adopt resolution 24934 which authorizes superintendent Diana frig and assistant superintendent

148Business Services Jason CF to make cash and budget transfers between and within District funds as necessary for the payments of obligations of the district for 2025 this is an annual resolution as part of the organizational board meeting any questions public comment um thank you there seems to be some confusion um Miss Diamond haven't you served on the school board for four full years yes thank you just making sure thank you like to move to approve resolution 24934 as presented I'll second that uh discussion okay go ahead Eric hi eron hi Jamie I am I measure uh measure you i1 approval of moving proposal from move green the board is asked to approve the proposal of moving estimate from move green for the canalino elementary Learning Center the estimated fee of $986 620 will be paid

149with measure you bond funds questions from the board public comment on i1 uh this this is just a short and um actually rare comment that we comment on measure you um the union we've been asked recently why doesn't the union tend to comment on measure U and it's simply because we do not have the resources to oversee that um aspect of the district's operations so um we have in the past trusted uh those who are on the measure UD advisory committee and um we are going to continue to do that until we can put those resources together if anyone in the community would like to work with us on that though we're certainly game and um uh we would love to have a better and deeper understanding of the measure youu process if if um

150there's someone out there that would like to work with us thank you um do you have comments specifically to the proposal from move green as that was the agenda item com [Music] agenda I'll move to uh um I'd like to move to approve the uh proposal from move green as presented all second discussion all in favor I okay I two approval of change order number one calina Learning Center American Modular systems the board has asked to approve change order number one for the calinao Learning Center on February 14th 2023 the board approved the proposal in the amount of $337 from American Modular systems for the kolina Learning Center the project requires change order number one which includes the removal of mini split for IDF and replace with exhaust fan as well as extra engineering for

151Matt lab Foundation change order number one is in the amount of 8,826 $866 which will bring the total to 99 45,1 16566 to be paid with measure you funding questions from the board okay public comment on I 2 approval of the change order uh once again there appeared to be some confusion um so just for the sake of clarity um all three including number two fall under the agenda item I which is bold on the agenda measure youu therefore comments that we make that pertain to this item as a measure you item or any measure you item are permissible in this environment and uh maybe Miss Diamond could explain why our comments wouldn't be or how they're considered not appropriate at this time thank you I'll move to approve change order number one as presented

152I'll second that discussion all in favor I I I3 approval of coastal development permit deposit city of to the city of Carpenteria the board has asked to approve the deposit for Coastal development permit from the city of carpentera for the Aliso TK building the deposit fee of $12,500 based on the fee schedule will be paid with measure you bond funds questions from the board I I thought we had an an agreement with the city that they weren't going to um charges for Coastal development review since we were there were since we were going through all these projects go through the um DSA I'll review that but I don't believe so no no okay I'll R it yeah well thank you um that was just a point of contention when when when we started the projects

153um because they wanted they wanted total purview and we we disagreed with them uh in regard to because of the fact that we we had to that that the DSA had basically superseded that Authority yeah conv and and and we I thought we just said we just didn't want to tack on extra expenses that really are unnecessary because because we're the approval process is is handled by the state all right thank you um so are you well this is just questions first okay um public comment on I3 approval of coastal development permit deposit city of carpentera okay seeing none um I'd like to move to uh table this until our next meeting so we could maybe get some more information um it's not going to hold anything up I don't think over the holidays is

154it I I don't know that I don't know I don't know but you all make a decision I mean it's not a huge amount of money I just it it's more the it's a deposit of $122,000 that's yeah it's fair amount of money should give it back if we don't if we're not Reed that's true it is a it is a deposit should return us yeah so I'll I'll change that I'll go ahead and move to approve this um with the understanding that we will we will look into it so just to clarify the motion is to approve on approve it as presented as presented but contingent upon well it doesn't it's not contingent we're just going to check on it okay I'm I'm just as presented I'm I'm I'm moving to approve it as

155was presented okay I'll second oh uh okay discussion further discussion all in favor I I Jay Personnel we have our Personnel summary three assignments one res resignation and one release in probation we're being asked to approve the recommended Personnel items any questions from the board okay public comment on J1 Personnel summary thank you uh during uh the Personnel um agenda item and for a few board meetings back and again this evening Union leadership and those we represent have provided observations pertaining to the value of economic stability of the District employees represented on this personel summary and the impact that stability or lack thereof has on District students and families uh once again we have a midyear faculty resignation and the district continues to hire to fill sped positions that remain open while simultaneously refusing to

156acknowledge that the sped program in the district is under great duress um as also shared by several other speakers this evening lastly you are aware that with Miss Rigby there has been a hiring Trend where the new instructional AIDS hired this evening uh are receiving higher salary values than and instructional AIDS who have been with the district and demonstrated highquality professional competence for several years of recent that has taken an even more absurd twist when these brand new hires cited on the Personnel report this evening are being assigned to classrooms where they're training if there has been any and their job classifications apply least for example of the I cited on this in the last two Personnel summaries some have been moved to the DLI classrooms and have neither received stiens nor have they Pro

157proven any language proficiency meanwhile three senior employees who had been working in DLI have been pulled to work on work in sped classrooms to put out fires but have shared that they have not been adequately trained themselves although the district may have legal authority to assign employees this way um that's on fairly thin ice um there is a big difference between being legally permissible and being smart efficient and I dare say we dare say effective we ask that you look into these HR matters more carefully and and at least determine if there is a reasonable basis for these ever these ever increasing practices we've been trying to share these concerns directly with Miss Rigby and District administrators to little impact and if the school board would like more specifics please feel free to contact us

158directly thank you I'll move to approve the Personnel summary as presented I'll second discussion okay all in favor I I okay and we moving on to Future agenda items um we're going to have a special education report our CHS solar update um a budget study session and a brown act update um any questions on that from the board that's what we a few a few things to get us going in 2025 um okay public comment on K hey thank you uh Union leadership again asked the district to return the HR presentation of October 8th to the future board meeting agenda in that presentation the HR coordinator shared a slide that addressed the ethnic and socioeconomic background of District employees the union asked the follow-up question why would the ethnic and socioeconomic background of our labor

159force be relevant to the district's considerations if it is not relevant to the composition of our district leadership now the district never explained why it included this slide or what value it believed the slide to contain and we're still waiting for that explanation but in the meantime it is clear that the district believed that the ethnic and socioeconomic background of our labor force was a highly relevant detail to have included it in the district's short annual HR PowerPoint and this is why Union leadership requests remuneration some form of transparent compensation for school board members which we would also like to see on a future agenda item we certainly don't make that recommendation because of our confidence in your performance but we do promote the concept of remuneration because the obvious concerns associated with District leadership

160that clearly does not understand or adequately represent the vast majority of District students and families economic experience Andor cultural backgrounds we recommend that board members receive some form of transparent compensation because we know that there are many qualified hardworking and interested community members who would otherwise run for these board seats if they could only afford to be as generous with their time as you all just take a look at the Carpenteria city council a true example of Economic and cultural diversity in no small part because they offer remuneration lastly with yet another school shooting just yesterday Union leadership again promotes the inclusion and agenda we have requested on many occasions Union leadership request board resolution which focuses on educating students on what to do if they come in contact or see a firearm as we

161have shared the students should stop what they are doing don't touch leave immediately the area tell an adult that they trust right away and call 911 immediately we should be putting a resolution together and making sure that our students understand this we've been asking for well over a year and it baffles employees as to why you're not interested okay beyond that moving forward happy holidays to you and your families and we look forward to seeing you in January Board calendar Monica you actually have to approve this one this is the one where we are because it's the 2025 and it's just the regular month L items the ones we presented at the beginning of the of the meeting well that but also like when we do the different reports and all of that yes it's

162like uh like the Williams act you know every quarter all of the the topics for the different meetings that we have to have and when they're going to be shared and this is also part of the organizational annual meeting it just goes right here but there's nothing additional coming up that we need to be aware of that's why I kind of threw it to you okay thank you um okay the board is asked to approve the 25 Board calendar annual items the calendar will be included with the agenda to keep the board focused on actions and events that take place annually um and this is something that is done at this meeting yep every year um to plan all of the different uh reports that have deadlines and things like that presentations lcap all those

163types of things um any questions from the board on that okay uh no no I don't I I see public hearing on availability of textbooks and materials it's there uh okay I'll move I'll move to it's because it's an action item we have public comment on this so L Board calendar public comment okay seeing none may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve the calendar is presented all second okay discussion all in favor hi hi board announcements merry Christmas happy holidays across the board whatever you may be celebrating uh Happy New Year um I just want to say the uh girls water polo had their alumni game last Saturday it was great uh the varsity girls won and uh yeah we had uh Miss dwit in goal and so some of the

164girls had to disassociate teacher Mt from goalie Mrs dit and and definitely threw a few a few good ones at her um but it was really fun to see the alumni but also the alumni parents uh and friends and family um that all came from the community unfortunately it was at the same time as the holiday parade um which was kind of a bummer but uh it was still pretty well attended and I know all the kids had a really great time so that was awesome um and then uh what did I have that written down oh we're going we're coming back on January 9th for school um I hope all of our families have a safe um and healthy holiday time um enjoy it take care um and for those that need the resource

165of the um uh United Way program United W program right yeah um for the Post let's he that's chunk of time in January before we come back uh it is available for families who need it all right thank you and we are adjourned it's [Music] oh [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.