CorpusRecord 31166

Carpinteria Unified School District Meeting - January 28, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City of Carpinteria
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Santa Barbara County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,347 words · about 91 min
Collected
2026-06-06

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening and welcome to the regular board meeting of carp carpentera Unified School District Board of Trustees uh it is January 28th we are at City Hall um and I'm just going to go over um our procedure for public comments so it's clear for everybody um in a regular board meeting the public is welcome to comment on any AG agenda item or non-agenda item that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the board public comments may be bundled together at the beginning of each alphabetical section of the agenda the board president usually limits individual comments to 3 minutes but may modify the time limit at his or her discretion in order to assure that the board takes care of District business please note that agenda items with the agreement of the board

002may be addressed in a sequence different than what is specified below please remember remember that the governing board meetings are a business meeting of the board held in public and although public participation is encouraged it is not the Public's meeting public speakers have a right to their own opinions the board requests that members of the public present their comments in a factual respectful and civil manner that models how we expect our students to participate in the Democratic process board the board is not responsible for the content of statements made during public comment in a special board meeting public comments shall be limited to only those items posted on the agenda with that we are going to begin with the flag salute please rise begin I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of

003America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all we have our closed session report information was exchanged no action was taken we now have um time for public comment on items not on this agenda uh at this time members of the public are welcome to come and step up and um offer public comment for items that are not reflected within today's agenda please make sure the green light is on on the there you go can you hear me now gotcha good all right all right superintendent uh Rigby good evening and president diamond and board members my name is John fer and I'm a teacher at Carpenteria Middle School um I want to start by uh commending and thanking you for appointing Dr Jamie puron

004to as our school principal her Keen observational skills and willingness to listen and to recognize the needs of students has been a refreshing and promising reset um the decisiveness with which Dr Pon has addressed issues like dress code and cell phone use has been much appreciated by teachers and staff I also wish to call your attention to this ironic turn of the tide from my optic our Union president Mr hotner while still a teacher at CMS took a lot of heat for trying to address these same exact exact issues he represented the voices of many of us uh frustrated with the lack of clarity and inconsistency at the time his suggestions back then were remarkably similar to the improvements we see under Dr puron uh for the record I always beli the set of allegations

005that led to the removal of Mr hotner from the classroom were retaliatory and unjust seeing those allegations continued to be touted as proven fact in the Coastal View when an administrative law judge had just concluded otherwise made me sick to my stomach witnessing over the years now the hotner family carry on as they do I commend their service to their community and especially their love and support for one another I appreciate the enormous sacrifice of time and energy with which our president M Mr hotner continues to Advocate on behalf of Educators and support staff for the sake of the cusd community I urge you to help in this impass and engage with cause leadership in addressing together the Urgent issues before us thank you thank you all righty so contract negotiations between employees and CD

006management remain at impass on January 14th District once again demonstrated its lack of commitment to an agreement by refusing to participate in the scheduled mediation session employees and their elected employee leaders are realistic and they remain focused we remained focused on reaching a reason reasonable agreement which one includes the most basic safety Improvement for our employees students and their families to defends employee healthare three secures meaningful salary increases with the intent of relieving economic pressure associated with the cost of living which has risen 20 to 23% in the last two years and threatens to further destabilize the workforce and four and importantly we seek an agreement that includes contingencies that would minimize conflict future Conflict by sharing the impact of future economic uncertainties uncertainties that would affect both employees and the district's budget rather than

007argue further re future revenues we continue to promote agreements that have employees and District leaders rowing in the same direction over District finances on January 14th employee Representatives formerly rejected the district's most recent proposal which um Falls significantly below the expectations of employees despite the public statements by board president diamond and Schaefer suggesting substantial salary increas es for employees these claims are entirely inaccurate throughout the 19-month bargaining process while misleading the public by suggesting they once offered a multi-year agreement amount of 177% uh CD's current best offer has been a meager 2% for certificated and 2 and a half% for classified um this is particularly concerning given the district administrators have received multiple raises totaling 10 to 12% during the same period cusd despite its relatively strong financial position continues to prioritize administrative spending while

008underfunding essential employee positions this further evidenced by the recent audit that revealed that the district underpaid employees by a staggering $3.5 million a clear violation of State Education Code maybe uh that's where you got that mythical 177% proposal that employees never received because $3.5 million deficiency um once uncovered we realized I that that's equivalent to a 17% pay increase for All District employees this ongoing impa coupled with the district's history of undermining employee rights and engaging in bad faith bargaining tactics creates a serious threat to the delivery and quality of Education um for our students union leadership continues to do all we can to avoid a general strike uh such a scenario would be disruptive to the delivery of educational services to student learning and to the families we serve so we continue to urge

009the community demand Fair compensation for all cusd employees inform the District board about the critical role that well-compensated employees play in Student Success thank you your time is up Mr dogado will translate thank you thank you carpent ENT this is a briefly uh that translation is comp that's the end of the translation now I would like to make my own public comment not on the agenda okay this is what we all are seeing currently mentioned before that the district is basically just waiting for a buyer's market that's not coming why is that uh because sellers are not selling and buyers are not buying and why is that I don't blame anyone of them and this is what affects our budget during the first inter report the first interment report said that that District was getting

0105% on real on uh on property taxes instead of uh seven let me tell you why basically the real estate market causing Cycles 10 years sellers Market 10 years buyers Market what are we having right now 13 years with a sellers Market I don't blame the sellers for not selling holding on to their properties because the longer that they that they wait the more money that they're getting look at the property values 2019 2020 has almost double up there's no need to refinance there is no need to sell I wouldn't do it I wouldn't sell I want a cond I won't sell it if I do it will be in three years why is that because that's that's why there's this risler cycle up and down same thing with the stock market 10 years up

01110 years down 13 years up up up check your retirement account the last four years without even consing a single dollar said let's say they have a million just check it right now million and a half without doing anything at all so that's why there's no movement on real estate and look at the interest rates right now 7% 74% three years fix no look at the prices right now no I that's why I'm advising people do not buy right now want to make money wait wait for the B market otherwise you'll be underwater so we need you need to take the district needs to take precautions on what to do do not overspend basically that's what I do not overspend thank you thank you thank you public comment for items not on the agenda please

012feel free to step up okay um Rachel Haymon uh local and um I love Carpenteria School District you guys are amazing and you do a lot but as a fellow teacher myself I don't know if you understand the impact of your message that you're sending when you only say 2% to these teachers you're valuing the kids in our district that you don't care that their teachers are there to give them a good education you don't care that we're the mothers the nurses the snack providers the little doctors the Huggers the kissers of these kids who need us especially with what's going on in the world when you give admin 5% raise over the teachers you're saying we value paperwork we value your non-student contact time when you only give the teachers a 2% raise and

013you don't value their 100% student contact time with those kids from the day beginning to the day ending plus the countless hours they spend coaching parents on how to be better with their kids you're devaluing our whole Community our Future Leaders I urge you to sit down with this District's group of professionals and really carve it out why is admin who does barely any student contact time except typically discipline or to walk through in a classroom why are they getting so much money when they don't directly impact the reading the math the Band-Aids that need to be provided that hug at the end of the day because they're going home to a situation where these families don't know what's coming next you need to value our Educators I work in another District I want to

014work here so bad you can't afford me and I can't afford to work in this district and live in this city you're devaluing our educators are professionally trained teachers who make a thousand decisions in one minute when the kid walks in the door without his lunch and is having a crying fit on the floor when the eighth grader who's going through mental crisis can't focus on anything in front of them when those high schoolers you're dealing with peer pressure social emotional sexual whatever you're devaluing your teachers these are the guys who work for you not for you for the community for the kids what about your kids why are they going to stay for a 2% raise the cola last year was 3% you guys can't even live on that if your businesses don't make

015a whatever you can't live on that how can you expect our Educators to work hard for us in our community if you don't show that that you care by paying them at least the cola and taking admin a step back who's not in the classroom all the time those teachers are our Frontline Marines please reconsider thank you thank you any further public comment for items not on tonight's agenda okay seeing none we are going to move on to approval of the minutes of the meeting of January 14th uh we're going to take public comment on approval of the minutes righty thank you so at minute 13140 item F Miss Diamond was correct let the minutes show that legal fees in the warrants are not only taxpayer dollars spent on illegal attacks against elected Union leadership

016as she said they also can be quote the legal fees for personnel of course Miss Diamond failed to specify further so we will let the minutes show that the additional expenditures she referred to are associated with the district's attempts to defend its disciplinary tax attacks on four other employees as well two of whom were fired shortly after they began working with Union the union directly and two more who have endured the district's disciplinary attacks um when they under oath provided testimony that led to the district being found guilty Miss Rigby of unfair labor practices retaliation and discrimination against Union leadership at minute 13140 Miss Diamond was correct again she just left out the most daming information at item e minute 2610 a longtime district attorney provided a brown act presentation however instead of providing actual

017Provisions from the brown act which would have been much more clear the well-paid attorney provided interpretations that satis the whims of District officials but not the provisions of the brown act itself let the minutes show that after the public comments on agenda item e the district's attorney acknowledged that he provides quote a rendition of what the law requires not the law itself Renditions that include interpretations like this quote a California Supreme Court case has held that written board member Communications must be turned over including from private emails and text the takeaway from this is not to put anything in email that you would not want to read about in the newspaper this brown act presentation demonstrated CD's historic practice of paying its attorneys to tell District officials what they want to hear however inaccurate interpretations

018that were then broadcast by the CD's mouthpiece the coastal you news further misleading the community on matters of District governance the solicitation of legal advice like that contained in item E's Brown act presentation is an example of the kind of legal interpretation that in no small part explains why the cusd is currently inundated with the types of legal expenses found in the warrants on January 14th 10 times the expenses when you arrived Miss Rigby to include four arbitrations after the district attorneys interpretations of the law had no legal justification when we started filing our grievances on these or legal services related to the 1970 sexual abuse cases based on Highly Questionable interpretations of the law during those years or CD's attempt to defend Miss ry's decision to illegally punish and fire a highly ethical instructional

019Aid who exposed highly unethical behaviors by Aliso principal Gallardo who by the way ended up fired for the very things that were being reported your time is up thank you any further public comment on approval of the minutes of January 14th yes uh this is uh J H's uh translation of approval of the [Music] minut administrativos for no Brown Act Mar Aliso final gardo Direct for your time is up thank you um now I got my own public comment on the that's fine if you if you'd like to yeah have your own public comment I'm just yes uh thank you 2021 uh uh correct price was here I watch it on TV uh he talk about the brown act he explain it in a lot of detail 2025 CRA price was back this is how

020I my impressed of the of his uh presentation yes uh actually he he play both ways he clarified that uh that uh anyone wants a a translation that is's required to have it 3 minutes that something that was in question he clarified that uh that the translates that a public speaker has the right to a translation he also explain that a transation is a translation of someone's uh public comment and at the same time that translator has the right it's on the brown act to express his own public comment on top of that that's and that's good because that he clarifi he clarified that to uh all of you because there was some question about that mainly on uh December 17 uh board meeting now November I email a letter to the castal view November

021but the Run Act a fair letter not 100% my side not 100% the district side Fair letter as it is they got it but for a week two as of today they haven't published it wonder why was like 50 50 your way like for example yes if you say 3 minutes is the maximum time allowed that's fine 3 minutes that that's that's correct it was 50/50 wasn't polish I'm going to email it again including now including GRE Price's presentation thank let's see what happens your time is up any further comment of on approval of the minutes of January 14th okay uh may I get a motion to approve I'll move uh to approve the minutes all second discussion okay all in favor I I okay um we are on C5 approval of the agenda and

022consent agenda and before we move on I'm just going to note that uh E3 has been pulled um there will not be a presentation from the warer pool Foundation tonight um so uh the motion when it comes will be um will reflect that uh pulling of e3 um other than that public comment for approval of the agenda and consent agenda so the consent agenda as with the rest of the board meeting is governed by the brown act which is designed to prevent the advancement of public Business Without transparency it is designed to provide members of the community an opportunity to more thoroughly consider the details associated with matters of District business before those matters are quickly processed through the consent agenda in Mass although the consent agenda allows the district to effectively process process items

023that do not require discussion or Community input this responsibility as Mr Price said must be balanced with the goals of transparency and the district's obligations to ensure that the community is provided a thorough opportunity to understand and review the consent agenda item to do otherwise obscures debate and it prevents dissenting viewpoints Andor concerns from being placed on the public record in violation of the brown act CD routinely places items on the consent agenda uh that are neither routine nor have they been brought before the public at any previous meeting therefore the union requests at the very least that CD develop a transparent mechanism for community members to prompt or at the very least formally requested item be removed from the consent agenda for further consideration setting aside our concerns associated with the district's misinterpretation of

024brown act obligations employees support items one two and five we look forward to the presentation associated with number three that has been tabled although employees support the concept of item four the renewal of the youth Mentor collaboration between CD and CP skate Foundation um we have a lot of uh outstanding questions that are not answered in the attached paperwork and we feel like those should probably be answered before an approval is provided um it's an awesome program from everything we've seen But there are still quite a few questions for example um whereas the program provides students the opportunity for PE credits uh via independent PE hours um how does does the program specifically align with and satisfy the state PE standards for grade 6 78 uh among other benefits the program sites an after school

025program leveraging a visual arts based curriculum to facilitate social and emotional growth growth build capacity for creative self-expression and creative problem solving uh where can we find the specifics of that curriculum if it if it's a curriculum um to better understand um some of that U that the program promises um the program sites to Ing and academic accountability and educators are interested to know um how more specifically will the program be working with Educators to facilitate tutoring and academic accountability uh how has the district confirmed the eligibility and credentials of those working with District students um have these individuals been live scanned has the district conducted routine background checks um that it would for those working with District students on CD properties this is a great guy right here we are not giving you a

026hard time I promise um but we're interested in some of those details and it doesn't seem like we've gotten answers to them yet um lastly the program was up and running through the Autumn semester of 2024 and what kind of data is being collected on its efficacy thank you any further public comment on approval of the agenda and consent agenda hello Peter bonning carpentry Escape Foundation um asking all the pertinent questions there that's it's very important we care deeply about these students and we want them in the hands of all the most you know appropriate people so totally understand um I'm happy to answer as many of those questions now as need be or I'm happy to invite anyone to come by the nonprofit headquarters check out what we do um I'm happy to email

027anybody my curriculum which it is a curriculum I was a full-time classroom teacher for over 15 sen years including in the carpenter Unified School District and at Kate school and at uh public and private institutions in San Francisco and Oakland where I received my uh California state teaching credential at San Francisco State University very proud to be um a teacher I've been working with kids for a long time was live scanned many years ago um I'm here tonight just to give you an update on the push project I know the the budget's on the agenda for tonight um last semester we were over enrolled by double so on there it says 14 students at the price you see um I just charged the school district that flat fee for the program no matter what this

028semester I have 36 kids on my roster um today there was pushing 20 kids in that space um I've said this before I'll say it again I'm not in the business of turning kids away so uh what we do in the face of over enrollment is is we maintain flexibility and we diversify our curriculum so um whereas we need we give a little here in order to take a little bit from here and make sure everyone has an appropriate experience um we've got students that range um across the board of the socioeconomic spectrum and um we make sure those kids they they all have what they need individually um I've increased uh my adult presence in that space and um we work closely with Carpenteria Middle School leadership to ensure the academic accountability piece of

029it um and the social emotional growth component which is very important um and like I said I'm happy to walk anyone through the curriculum and how we meet our goals and objectives as they pertain to the school district's goals and objectives we very much work in line with each other and I take great pride in um Towing the party line so to speak I I want to support the school district in what they do in our community um and thus far it's been a great collaborative effort and uh I I get a lot of positive reviews from administrators and staff at the middle school campus um and so from our from our end it feels very positive it feels very good we've got a lot of great momentum moving forward so I appreciate all your

030support thank you so so much your time is up thank you um okay and seeing no further public comment um any questions from the board uh I'll go ahead and make the motion to approve the agenda and consent agenda uh while pulling item E3 uh the warrior pool Foundation presentation um from the agenda all right I'll second that discussion roll call Eric hi ER hi Jamie I I okay and now moving on to E public interest reports and presentations we will now take public comment on anything within e could you please before uh speaking could you please explain what just happened with the way speaker minutes are working for this item e you typically item e if I recall is you have There's an opportunity for speakers to speak after say for example the student

031representative after the superintendant after each item in E is that still um preserved so I as I read at the beginning of the meeting um that public comments will be bundled together at the beginning of each alphabetical section of the agenda okay then um so does that mean bundled together as in still three minutes for each of the letters within or each of the numbers underes to speak to items under e oh to all items so you're reducing the amount of time that speakers can comment on um items under item e is that correct what we are doing is you have 3 minutes to comment on E so you are reducing the amount of time is that correct I just want to make sure I'm right your time is going to begin now you are

032reducing the time thank you so uh employee leadership shares the superintendent's appreciation for our library media Tech Specialists um they are fabulous and they're doing an outsize job for the amount of resources they're provided uh regarding the first interim financial report Miss Rigby reported that s SP CEO has positively certified the CD's first interim financial report this means thatb uh county has confirmed that the state is meeting its minimum uh its mandated 3% reserves three years out the positive certification does not confirm that cusd is investing these tax dollars appropriately though that is a better examine through the CD's annual audit where uh where accounting strategies like overestimating expenditures and underestimating revenues are more closely examined in December 2024 when the audit was last conducted it revealed that the district failed to make even the

033minimum salary investment in District employees as required by Ed code sbceo was not looking at this when it certified the first interim financial report nor did the first report include any mention that CD underpaid the $3,522 th000 uh a deficiency in employee compensation equivalent to a 177% pay increase for All District employees in regarded the practice of overestimating expenditures and underestimating revenues can superintendent Rigby clarify whether the district included the revenues associated with the sale of the bailor property um in the first interim report or where will we find that approximately $4.5 million Revenue increase in the next inome report uh were the 4.5 million do included in the interim report um let's see here on page 11 what you would see is the district's Reserve Skyrocket to 16% three years out clearly superintendent riger's

034report is more telling for what is not included than what is included another example in Miss ri's report uh is uh the first semester uh cmsc HS student performance and that it's improved she fails to mention that this is primarily the result of inflated grading practices her Administration promotes across the USD secondary schools what used to constitute a student GPA or letter grade is now entirely different many parents in the community may be surprised that now under the new grading practices encouraged by Miss Rigby a student who gets every question wrong on a test will still receive half credit for that test as a student or as a result a student must only demonstrate 20% proficiency to receive a grade of C as another result the district's internal metric student grades and GPA did not

035relevant when compared to student measuring tools the district cannot control an example Miss Rigby reports that 74% of middle school students earned a 3.0 GPA or higher yet according to the CMS sarc report released this evening in item F only 36% of all CMS students even met the grade level at math and only 4.69 special education students boy we could go on with a few more minutes thank you any further public comment on E question apologies I'm new to um coming to the school board uh meetings but I'm one of uh the representative for four on here do I are we you're goingon to have your own time to present yeah this is just for the public comments on the items yeah okay uh we are going to go ahead with our student representative report

036Now angel uh hello my name is Angel petta I'm the student representative representing Carpenter High School uh this is my report this week girls water polo will be hosting weimi on Tuesday boy soccer will be at Malibu today as well boys basketball and girls soccer will host Channel Islands on Wednesday and girls basketball and boys soccer will host Santa Paulo on Thursday and Friday respectfully girls water polo celebrated the class of 2025 to day on this Tuesday while boys basketball will host a pregame celebration of their seniors cheer seniors and Warrior senior families on Thursday today CHS academic counselors visited CMS to begin the course request offerings for the next school year future n9th grade students will have until February 13th 2025 to submit their course request our special education department will host an informational

037night tomorrow on Wednesday for incoming eighth graders starting at 600 p.m. in the library on Thursday January 30th 2025 at 6 p.m. CHS will host an informational night for incoming ninth graders all parents and students of the class of 2029 are invited to attend this very important night presentations will include academic programs exploring our diverse course offerings at carpy high school our Athletics program discover our exciting athletic programs that we all love to do our Support Services getting information on counseling tutoring and other necessities that they may need and the student panel students will be able to hear firsthand from current High School seniors and on their various stories that they have for high school their various paths and what they want to do ASB is also planning on having a rally to celebrate winter

038sports which will be on Thursday February 6 thank you thank you Angel any questions for angel from the board comments well thank you so much um we're going to move on to our superintendent report thank you and thanks again Angel Wonderful report good job thank you okay I'd like to begin with some appreciation and I'd like to recognize our library mediate Tech Specialists Abigail Garcia at the high school Panero at the middle school Caitlyn Damron at Aliso and Summerland and Julie SoDo at canalino and family school they Inspire students to become lifelong readers and Learners my next item relates to our response to immigration enforcement under the US Constitution all students have a right to receive an education without discrimination based on immigration status in pler versus doe the US Supreme Court recognized that undocumented

039immigrants are guaranteed due process and equal protection rights under the Constitution and that children cannot be denied equal access to a public education on the basis of their immigration status schools must provide free public education to all students regardless of their immigration status and regardless of their citizenship status of their parents or Guardians in 2017 the cusd board passed resolution number 17- 800 in support of students in the district which included protections from immigration Authorities on campus and information confid confidentiality as provided by law in 2019 board policy and regulation 51451 response to immigration enforcement was adopted to guide School staff in providing safe learning environments for all students and responding to immigration enforcement the next item is our first interim financial report information Santa barbaraa County Education office has reported that CD's first interim

040financial report with a positive certification to the California Department of Education our next item is uh fall 2025 tkk registration so our tkk information meeting will be held on Thursday February 20th at canalino school 5:15 for English session and 6 o'clock for our Spanish session online registration begins on March 1st for all students who will be 5 years old on or before September 1st for kindergarten and for all students who are currently four year four years old and will have their fifth birthday by September 1st 2026 for our transitional kindergarten program CMS art and aha CMS art students are led by our CMS art teacher Ryan ethington and in collaboration with aha staff have created beautiful artwork that is on display at the carpenter art center from January 9th to February 23rd and the reception

041will be Monday January 27th 5:30 to 7:30 first semester high school and middle school student performance 74% of our middle school students earned a 3 3.0 GPA or higher with a school average GPA of 3.32 last year during first semester the GPA average was 3.19 and only 66% of the students earned a 3.0 GPA or higher and then at the high school the students also improved during this first semester compared to last year 77% of our high school students earned a GPAA 3.0 or higher with a school average of 3.64 and last year only 67% of the high school students earned a GPA 3.0 or higher with a school average of 3.32 this is great kindness challenge week the California Department of Education in partnership with the great kindness challenge encourages all schools to participate

042in the great kindness challenge week J January 27th to the 31st the theme for the 14th annual week is kindness moves and This Global campaign is designed to promote kindness social emotional health and bullying prevention in prek to grade 12 our school counselors and Student Activity groups have organized daily activities to prompt acts of kindness the next item refers to our school accountability report cards or sarc every school in California is required by state law to publish a school accountability report card by February 1st the sarc contains information about the condition and performance of each California Public School additionally all local districts are required to prepare a local control and accountability plan the elcap which describes how the intent to meet annual school specific goals for all students with specific activities to address state and

043local priorities data reported in an lcap is the same data that was reported in the sarc data the cusd accountability report cards are posted on the district website at ww. usd.net and our remind you that uh those report cards that information is a year old so that information is not current information it's the last school year information and our last item is measure you the new canalino Learning Center is now open for for students and staff plans are being developed for the removal of the Portables and the new Landscaping during summer the new tkk building project at Aliso has been registered with DSA and the completed application for the coastal development permit and plan was all submitted to the city of carpentera and last week soil samples were collected for testing at the laboratory thanks

044thank you um any questions or comments from the board um I just have one clarifying question because it was brought up so um in regards to the first interim bayor the sale of bayor wasn't final beforehand correct and so that wouldn't reflect but even still it's restricted to measure you the funds from that yes the funds are reported in the measure you funding it's restricted to measure you funding not General okay yes thank you okay and now we are going to move on to the clean Coalition scale micro grids presentation thank you so much hello uh and yeah one point of clarification I just wanted to bring up before I jump into this um I why I am representing scale micro grids um we are a different entity than clean Coalition we do work with

045them on initiatives but we are a for pro profit business um and my presentation was veloped from scale micro grids just as a point of clarification um I did CC Craig Lewis on the the email but um just wanted to clarify um can everyone hear me okay by the way yes thank you awesome yeah so can hop into this too um I just to refresh for everyone uh we met with a few of you all last year um scale micro grids is a solar and Battery uh installer and developer uh we do we focus on Commercial and Industrial facilities to pair solar and Battery solutions to increase clean energy resilient energy and cost cost Effectiveness um so that's that's our overall oh would this be the oh oh awesome I was I was gonna ask

046um great but so and I will forewarn here these slides are a little stale um as far as uh we looked at these in October um and since then we've had a federal election which changes some of our opportunities as a company as we do focus on grants and other incentives um so I guess to kind of cut to the chase here um we looked at a number of these uh opportunities last year with you all um or potential opportunities within the community we are looking at a number of sites within uh Santa Barbara County uh to do these opportunities um and we look at a economy of scale if we can get more opportunities involved we can then amass more grant opportunities um I will say that we are now as we move into

0472025 the opportunities do the pool is looking smaller and one thing as a company we're looking at right now is how we can make that all work um and what opportunities will exist in the new year um I guess to kind of hop ahead here um this is what we were looking at last year with the economics of doing a solar and Battery uh micr Grid at Carpenteria High School uh again I think these numbers are a little stale as far as what the opportunity and tax incentives would be um so I guess to to kind of cut to the chase unfortunately we do not necessarily see an opportunity economics wise to develop this at the current moment we definitely are working within the community and would love to maintain a friendly relationship if opportunities

048do arise but as we spent time on this last year we want to get back to you all with a conclusive uh answer as to what our analysis looked like um with that I'll open this up to questions thank you um it's really unfortunate that funding has gone the way it has that it didn't work out last year with the Grant application um and that the future of funding opportunities is getting smaller um because uh there's a lot of reasons why this could be really beneficial from just doing the right thing for our environment um but also uh the educational opportunities um for curriculum within our for our high school students um to learn about solar and microG grids and power um and I just it's it's very unfortunate um that there really isn't a

049path right now yeah so I guess I will say we are very optimistic as an organization we are very much scrambling and looking for opportunities uh our company our largest market is California so we really focus on these communities um and we are working within the county as well so we definitely like to maintain relationships here and uh see if there's potential opportunity but didn't want to go on too much of a sales pitch here as far as hey we we don't want to no I appreciate it and you guys put in a lot of work um to the presentation that that you gave to to our our work group or ad hoc committee a while back um when you first were building everything to submit for the grant um and so I appreciate the

050time and effort that your team did for that [Music] um I I I just um curious if that PPA price was that that's just generation would that just be a generation credit or is that a is that a blended distribution um demand and generation so that price it acts as so the the system itself would be a solar and Battery Solution but that payment is coming off of and where these numbers are coming off of is the production from the solar which it's a little bit of a Nuance with the with the battery component where it's kind of dueled in there even though or it's priced accordingly based on our um Capital expenses but then uh it basically we're only you would all only be paying for the production of the solar um is how

051the contract kind of breaks down so there's still distribution and demand in in the bill generally from from from from the from uh the the from like Edison you know from the utility so this this would be we would be kind of the uh middleman of that per se um as far as like the prices um up on the the board there that's how it would kind of break down as far as the electrical savings and then um there would be a PPA cost as well um so yes you guys would still be connected to the grid and have those costs but it would be what we are presenting here is be offset by this 23 yeah it's offset yeah yeah but there's still there'd still be a a Edison bill and because what I've

052noticed with with my systems um is that uh that we end up with um the generation costs really haven't escalated as much as the demand and distribution has and I just was Cur I mean I know we're it really doesn't pencil out right now but I'm just curious how if that's factored into your into your calculations as well yeah it so it is factored into our calculations um with the Assumption of and basically what the system would look to do is really reduce the de yall's Demand on the grid of how much you're taking in because the solar and Battery would support the the uh load profile that you all have so would reduce that demand and therefore the amount of um distribution charges as well um so that's that's kind of where it's going

053it is factored in like we do have current um SoCal Addison data as far as the pricing of it and how that then factored and we make assumptions as well as where we see the utility rates going um so that is all factored in um and like the current day rates are in um this analysis yeah and they still no there's no aggregation correct allowed like between sites no um not not currently hopefully one day we'll see okay any further comments from the board thank you so much for coming I appreciate appreciate your time thank you um and I just wanna uh I apologize I overstepped I need to Circle back real quick to the superintendent report and I just want to point out um my appreciation uh for District staff for teachers for the

054leadership um of really being very clear um with each other um in light of um of the executive order as it pertains to to um to ice being able to come to campuses um I had the opportunity to meet with one of the elac groups the week before um that took place and this is something that I know is on the hearts and minds of our community at large but um un unduly so on our kids um and I know that our counselors have been meeting with kids who um with students who are this is this is is a burden for them they are concerned and um they're helping get them the supports they need um and I just I want to thank everybody because this is um as a community this is something we

055really need to in my personal opinion um stick together arm in- arm um our kids are not up for grabs and uh and so thank you for for reaffirming that and thank you to the board previous to when I was on it for passing the resolution that was already in place um with the policies and procedures to ensure the safety of our kids um in light of uh situations like this so um I just needed to put that out thank you um and public comment was no that was public comment for E all public comment on any items in e as clarified ifed earlier com I asked for public comment on all items under e and that was clarified what that meant that that's we're taking all public comment at once at the beginning of

056each agenda so we are going to now move on to our special education report thank you with uh with Miss Hines hello um this is my first time presenting to you from this position so I'm excited to do that um I I just wanted to start by telling you um I am really proud of our special education department we do an amazing job in this district for um all of our students especially those who require more support and um I'm very aware special education is expensive it's expens it's expensive across the country expensive across the state um and we do a really good job with the money we spend and we get really good value for money so I'm excited to share that with you tonight um there's a couple trends that are going on

057in special education we are seeing a rise in the prevalence of autism in 2020 23 um when we look at the rates of autism diagnosis amongst 8-year-olds there were one in 36 students whereas in 2018 it was one in 44 this has been rising over time um when looking at um data over time what we actually think is there's not probably more people with Autism it's just we're diagnosing it at higher rates uh and I'll talk a little bit about what the impact of rising rates of autism mean for special education the other thing um one other thing that we're working on is um improving our inclusive practices so I know when I was in school um special education was a trailer out in the back corner of the yard that is not what special

058education in 2025 looks like um hopefully in any school in America um it certainly is not what special education looks like in carpentry Unified School District our students with IEPs are integrated into every classroom in every campus every single day um what support that a student receives um is determined by their IEP team and is a a decision that's made with parents and families um as well as special education um Professionals in order to serve the needs of students with an emphasis on inclus inclusionary practices we also see the importance of early intervention and this is es especially relevant right now in our sort of postco era we're seeing um an increasing number of very young children who have have been negatively impacted by um reduced access to Early Childhood Services um language delays due

059to wearing masks and um lack of access to preschools when they were in in their formative years so we're seeing that as a a major Trend as we're trying to reverse that and making sure we're intervening really early with those kiddos and working on those skills so that they are able to graduate out of our special education programs um into just the general education um services that are offered to all students and then the last really big Trend we're seeing is an increase demand for mental health services across the Spectrum um I I don't think it's a surprise that we're seeing a youth Mental Health crisis in our country and so the rising social emotional needs coupled with behavioral needs are going to be a Common Thread that we see as we um work through

060this presentation today I wanted to start by talking about who are our students so I I pulled this data last Thursday and we had exactly 350 students with IEPs across the district um across every School site so um we have preschoolers there our preschool program is housed um at the CCP at Maine sites with um CH uh carpentry at Children's project we have a classroom there um Aliso calino and family school Summerland middle school high school we have a seals program um which is our post-secondary program those are students who have completed our high school program and are still eligible for special education services those are usually life skills um that are preparing them for further um programs beyond that and supporting them throughout their Continuum and then um other placements um we have 10

061students at sites outside of our district so I know I I saw Mr sergers report last year and he talked a lot about the idea and about the Americans with Disabilities Act and um one of the things he did talk about when he presented to you last year was the 13 categories of Eligibility under idea or the law that governs special education services and we have students with a primary disability in nine of those categories we actually have 11 categories represented across our district the two where we don't are deaf blindness and um traumatic brain injury most of our students um well what we see is pretty widespread um specific learning disabilities it's a very broad term um I spend a lot of time explaining what what some of these terms mean to families because

062they're it's a pretty generic term but it's a a broad category that includes things like dyslexia disc calcula and disg graphia or a processing disorder that's coupled with the way that a student learns information and it may mean that a student needs additional support in order to learn what their peers are learning in their um general education classrooms speecher language impairment um is a little over 20% of our population and for students whose primary eligibility is speech or language impairment almost all of those students are third grade and under so this is a a big population of our young students other health impairment is another really broad term and it can Encompass many many many things um that category can include a patient um a student who has um diabetes or a student who is

063on dialysis but the most um common thing that we see under other health impairment is students who have attention or executive functioning disorders like ADHD autism is about 14% of our population and that is a growing number so we're seeing more students eligible under autism than ever before followed by emotional disability which again is the like those two are the fastest rising categories um for eligibility across the country and in our district multiple disabilities are students who um have areas of need in multiple areas um oh I skipped over intellectual disability we have about 5% or one in 20 of our students with IEPs have an intellectual disability um de heart of hearing is a very um infrequent um eligibility within our district and then Orthopedic impairment is also again a very small representation within

064our district now how we serve students um and the language that's used here has changed over time and actually fairly recently you may be more familiar our extensive support needs program um used to be called by the state of California mod severe disabilities and that change of language is um really um aimed at more accurately describing our students and our more accurately describing the services we provide to them so our extensive support needs program is generally delivered in self-contained classrooms we have classrooms at our preschool um canalino the middle school the high school and then at um pupil services in our seals program and those are led by a special education teacher with an extensive support needs or mod s disabilities credential um generally it includes a number of instructional assistants who help them carry

065out that program mild to moderate support needs is a pretty similar label for a program often um it's been called resource classrooms uh canalino and family school Aliso Summerland the middle school and the high school all have um special education teachers who serve students and and the bulk of students in those programs are students with learning disabilities or other health impairments and then related Services is a really gigantic category and it's pretty much everything else our students need so we have an Adaptive PE teacher who helps students who are not able to fully access our physical education program and they provide PE Services through that um we have a fantastic occupational therapist who works with students at all of our school sites um working on both um fine motor and more importantly sensory regulation skills

066um we work with a couple physical therapists we don't have um it's a small population within our district so we contract out for um two different fantastic phys phal therapists who work with students who have Orthopedic impairments um speech therapy is the most common related service that we provide many of our students across the district um benefit from speech and language therapy we work with um Santa Barbara unified we have a teacher who comes in and works with our students who are deaf or heart of hearing to provide specialized instruction um similarly we work with our um Sela which is the county special educations um program for our Vision support therapist uh Vision support specialist who provides consultation and services to students with visual impairments and then um counseling counseling is a huge need within

067our district and we have um worked very hard to ensure that all of our students whether they have disabilities or they um are not identified with disabilities have access to adequate counseling and therapy services um to support men mental health cost of Continuum and then um the not the largest but probably the most um financially invested we are in is our behavioral um supports that we provide for students and I'll talk a little bit more about what that is and why it's growing in cost um supporting that program we have five School psychologists um 18 and a half special education teachers five speech therapists one adaptive PE teacher about 55 instructional assistance last um last Thursday it was exactly 55 um that number does rise and fall as um staff ENT and next to the

068district an occupational therapist 11 Behavior technicians and one Behavioral Analyst um we do a lot of professional development or professional learning for our staff um monthly uh I meet with both the certificated staff and the classified staff so that's our teachers and our um speech therapists and occupational therapists and we do topics that are spec uh specific to them and then monthly I meet with our classified staff so our instructional assistance and provide different topics that are more relevant to directly working with students in the classroom um weekly training um as particularly at our elementary sites and um for our extensive support needs programs our teachers meet with instructional assistants who work with their students weekly on case specific specific learning and strategies that are most um beneficial to the staff working with students so

069um myself when I was a special education teacher I would meet with the instructional assistants who um work closely with me and we would work on a lot of reading intervention strategies a lot of behavior management strategies um skills for helping them to provide better support for students in the general education setting I know my colleague next door um cythia Diaz would provide different types of training because she worked with different a different student population than I did um and then there's specialized training that comes up from time to time so we have a a list of the training that's already taking place this year um for you know things that we've done across the Spectrum with um Staffing to provide ongoing development to meet our students need and keep current with best practices in

070our in our discipline and then this is a lot of challenges in special education um because we're seeing a rise in um our student population our a rise in number of students with IEPs that is paired with declining enrollment we're seeing a trend of less funding for special education programs while we have a rise in number of students who need access to those programs uh and that's across the country um I'm I I'm not sure if you're aware um but special education has never been fully funded it is a federal mandate um and it's considered an unfunded mandate we were promised a lot more money and we've never seen anywhere close to what it would cost to run the programs that are required um that's just the reality we live in um it's hard when

071we also see that declining student overall districtwide enrollment meaning our Revenue um is declining while our population is rising uh and again that's a trend across the county and across the state of California um Staffing shortages are are interesting there are fewer people entering education in general but in special occas special education in particular um special education is hard work it's it's a calling I don't know anyone who does it because they get a big paycheck they do it because they absolutely love the work they do um and it's hard you know behavior is very Challen Ching in classrooms across all every classroom in the country is finding increasing challenges with behavior and not everyone stays so um attracting staff is a high priority and supporting them well so that they are able to do

072what they feel is most important for students is um a huge goal that we have and something I'm really proud of um but it means it's harder to find staff the other thing that is a trend within special education is many professionals are moving away from direct hiring with districts so instead of being a um employed by Carpenter Unified School District they may be employed through a an agency which means they um there are certain benefits to that to the employee and there are certain things that they don't get so um when we are required to fill a vacancy with an agency staff it's more expensive for the district um in general my understanding is those staff members make more in their paycheck but they're not a part of our benefits program they are not

073a part of cal sters um and so there there are tradeoffs with that um we're seeing that Trend particularly in our related service providers um so I I mean I I don't I'm sure you guys saw our vacancies last year we tried to direct hire speech therapists all year long and we had nobody directly apply but there are there's wide range of Staff available through agencies it's always our preference to direct hire we want to have that personal relationship with our employees not be working through an agency um not only for costs but also because there there are employees um and there it's more expensive so we're we're needing to do that we're needing to do that and um we work really hard to direct higher but it it's a reality of where we are

074in special education not just us but um everywhere in the state of California you um and then the other thing I I'm going a little out of order um the number of students with complex and extensive support needs is dramatically Rising particularly behavioral costs um when we look at our I mean you guys have seen our budgets You' see you see how much special education costs it's never been um something that we do um we invest what it costs us to provide those services for our students and that's um something I'm really proud that we do but behavioral costs make up a larger portion of that spend every year because Behavior Services are are very expensive um we do that because the students need it not you know it's it's not an avoidable cost if

075it were we would we would find another way um but when students need it as part of their IEP that's what we do um I wanted to talk about um one other thing that um in our in our numbers we have 350 students with IEPs and a little over 1,900 students overall um which gives us 18% of our student population are students who have IEPs and that number has risen over the last five years it's gone from about 14% to about 18% that is a trend within California particularly within Santa Barbara County a lot of that is due to um language support needs that we're seeing at our very young students and then behavioral support needs we're seeing for students who have um emotional disabilities or mental health concerns those there are two biggest areas

076where we're seeing a rise in need as well as a rise in cost um I I stuck oh nope I was gonna say I stuck a quote in from Temple grandon at the end but it's on it's on mine um and the reason why I BR bring that up Temple grandon is um she's a autism um Advocate and um often speaks in in support of Stu of people with disabilities and one of the really important things um and we do it exceptionally well is our students are our students first um you know regardless of what category they might fall in they they are general education students first we see them that way our teachers see them that way they are embedded members of our community they are valued they are necessary they are um important

077um contributors to our classrooms and having a robust good special education program benefits every student in our district um my own children I'm one I have one who graduated last year and a a junior at Carpenteria high school and I'm thrilled and I know that he benefits greatly from having access to peers who have a wide range of um characteristics and communication Styles and behaviors and um I believe that the push towards a more integrated and more accessible classroom environment benefits all kids um regardless of whether we have them categorized this way or that way it's really important thank you for having me here tonight thank you any questions for Carolyn I have a couple or comments Y no it great great presentation Carolyn thank you very much um and you're doing a fantastic job

078um I had a couple um and they're kind of maybe superfluous but if we have a student with multiple disabilities how do we categorize so multiple disabilities is one of those funny categories is it has very specific criteria very often that's a student who has an intellectual disability they may also have um an orthopedic impairment visual impairment deaf heart of hearing um they may have autism so they they're El they would be eligible in multiple categories when we complete an IEP we get two boxes that we're able to f out um a primary disability and a secondary disability and often times um students with complex needs might otherwise be eligible in several you know five six seven categories and that sort of encompasses that um and then we're able to choose a secondary category for

079their secondary need um and that's just a way that we're able to better understand what their needs are so I as a special education teacher if I were looking at a student whose eligibility um that helps me to understand and know that I need to dig a Little Deeper to understand how to better support that student okay but then when we when we categorize them as far as total counts do they do they like on page they would only be counted once on the okay so so would they go to they' go to their primary disability then they would be categorized into their primary disabilities they would be counted as a student with multiple disabilities but those would those are in general they're in our extensive support need okay and then um I'm curious uh

080within the special ed Community if um you know diet there's a lot of been a lot of new research on on diet and and microbiota in your stomach and and you know all the whole gut brain relationship and and whether or not um how how uh what's the ability of of the special ed or or the staff at the schools to to you know maybe bring up topics like that that are that it's new research it's Cutting Edge or do we are we totally reliant on the on the department Ed to give us guidance for that I mean I I we we follow evidence-based practices so I I think when there is a growing body of research I know a lot of our teachers stay current with our research as as our in our professional

081development we're going to work on that um I am aware of students within the district whose parents have them on um specialized diets to help support um yeah to help support their their needs um particularly students with autism well autism and and and emotional things and and because I I I you know I read quite a bit about that and and because because it it you know this is I think the the increase in these numbers is concerning to anybody who's involved in education and and I think you know it's gathered the attention of of uh you know Robert Kennedy is a big advocate for for changing the way we do a lot of things uh diet wise and healthwise and and and that got me looking into into um you know it's part of

082the way we Farm now uh you know regeneratively where you're you're kind of working the soil and and building up the biology and letting that do the the heavy lifting for you and the same applies to to I think to a lot of a lot of this this uh uh Advent of or Le this this escalation of these a lot of these autism diagnoses and emotional problems is a lot of kids aren't eating well you know you see them in the morning and they're and they're starting their day off with sugar and and that really is the wrong thing you should be eating in the morning and I'm just curious if if how much control we would have over that um if if there's if we have more control in the special ed um Department

083than we would in general education what uh um what a student eats is well not control but like just be able to to recommend I mean I I work with colleagues who who do talk um when parents are receptive about um things that might be beneficial um we talk about sleep a lot in IEP meetings um we talk about having sending kids to school with a breakfast that's going to support their um ability to learn during the day so we're providing those as far as it being a part of an um IEP or individualized educational program it's not really at this point uh I do know there's research that's going on and and that M trick could it be included in an IP if we if we could back it up with research like like

084recommend recommended you know like you should have more protein in your diet and less less sugar I that I I would need to do some research on I'm I'm not I don't want to specify what it is but I'm just I just I'm just saying could that could a could dietary recommendations be part of an IEP yes Well you certainly could make those recommendations for as part of the um parent ucation piece but remember the IEP is really driving the programs and services that the school district is offering true but but don't I mean isn't there a component of it where the parents are have to sign off on it yes yeah yes but it certainly could be part of do at school because I think there is a you know a solution to not

085not all obviously not all all these disabilities have a a dietary component but a lot of them do and and at least you know from what I've been reading I think they do and and we could maybe see Improvement there um but you know it's just it's just that that was those were my thoughts and I think anything that's going to support um the educational access and the social and emotional health of students is something that IEP teams will talk about and and add to the best of our ability great thanks than I just want to say thank you for your presentation um the special ed program is a really important part of the district and yeah thank you yeah thank you to your you and your staff it's it's always uh close to our

086hearts and our minds when we have discussions and budget meetings Etc so yeah it's it's I know I I um I've been coming to Schoolboard meetings for a really long time and I remember the first time I ever saw a budget presentation I was kind of shocked at how much special educ Services cost um but I and and I I realize I'm coming from a bias um I think we invest that money well I really do yeah I I just want to commend you for jumping both feet into the fire like you have and and and really taking off on hitting the ground running yeah I proud of you these are my kids i i people ask um people ask me like how I like it and I I these are my kids I I

087see them at the grocery store I I'm I'm excited to see them in town and so I'm really glad to get to serve the children of of Carpenteria we're really lucky carlyn was an excellent and is an excellent special educator in terms of instruction and it's great that she's now providing leadership to the rest of our colleagues so we really appreciate her skills um so I just had a few comments um starting at the kind of the beginning and and the the increase the increase we're seeing in Special Ed um the need for services the diagnosis of qu that qualify students and I think part of it is yes there is an increase but I also think that um we are in a different place than we were years ago like you said where we

088recognize it in a way that we didn't recognize things before we see things whereas before it was oh the kids just hyper they're just acting out and um there was also an an aspect of parents not wanting there was a stigma and parent and people being in denial um I grew up in the children are to be seen and not heard era and and that um and that extended into whatever needs kids had and so ignoring the problem and so we no longer are ignoring that we want to work with the kids as early as possible um to give them the greatest chance at at a at a really amazing life and so thank you for for that and for what your team is doing to recognize those students early on it's incredibly important um

089I and I think seeing that we have 21 students in preschool um and the bulk of those are students with what we call a speech only IEP so their only service um they see our speech pathologist somewhere between 40 and 60 Minutes a week in a couple of sessions um that's the the majority of those preschoolers are they're at CCP they're at Head Start they're at kinderkirk they're at Lou Grant um and we provide that service um we have eight who are in our preschool program um our our dat preschool program eight in the okay thank you for clarifying that um and for clarifying uh under speech or language impairment mostly third grade and younger yes um let's see here just going through my notes um the change in terminology from Mod severe to extensive

090support needs I believe you mentioned it was that a is that a cusd only change or was that a no that was a California a California change and they actually changed the name of the teaching credentials I was that was going to be my follow up because that was the name of the teaching credential and so is that changing as well yes um the CTC or the governing body for teaching credentials um started the transition change over and all programs that are are producing new special education teachers are under the new credential system so um there there are three credentials one is extensive support needs one is mild moderate support needs and one is the early childhood education credential um and those are the new names whereas the old names were early childhood education that

091hasn't changed um mild to moderate disabilities and mod severe disabilities when they made that change they also uh changed the training for teachers so um my credential that I hold in special education is mild moderate support needs and I've always been able to work with students with autism with work with students with traum traumatic brain injury or intellectual disabilities but with the old credential it was much more limited as to which of those categories someone with the older credential could work with um similarly for our mod severe credential to the ESN credential those teachers couldn't work for with students with learning disabilities they would have had to have additional an additional CR credential to be able to do that and so it gives us a lot more flexibility to adapt to the needs of the

092student so because simply by their diagnosis um you can't always tell what the student support needs are going to be you could have a student whose primary eligibility is um a learning disability and they really need a to be in a more self-contained extensive support needs classroom based on their other needs and so the the change is is is welcome um I know that the um disability Community really welcome the change as well because it took the emphasis off of a deficit a disability and put it towards a support need which everybody needs support of some some kind so it talks more about the service and less about the person which has been a welcome change great thank you for clarifying that um and then under related Services um you did say we were getting

093support from the county for vision support yes our Vision support specialist um Carrie Bernal works for the Sela um and she she sees a handful of students um across the district okay and that saves us from not having to hire directly for those Services same with our um our deaf heart of hearing teacher um Kelly odonnell she actually works for um Santa Barbara unified but through the Sala we work with her as well okay thank you and then um Behavior technicians is that what we also call Aba yes okay thank you um oh and then under professional development um just the the range of of what you offer um and what you ensure that the staff is equipped with um I I really appreciate that um and I don't know how much is that's what

094it was or that's what you or you have raised it to this um that's what we've done this school year so that's really this school year so far um and it really depends on the needs of our staff and the needs of our students so we've spent a lot of time working with our instructional support staff our instructional assistant in helping them better navigate behavior in the classroom we've done that um both myself and our um board certified Behavioral Analyst have have done training um through that we've had our school nurse come in and she did training on um epipens and seizure protocols and hypoglycemia and is able to do a lot of training with a lot of staff so that they're feeling comfortable and confident when they're working with students in classrooms not just

095students with IEPs that they're you know directly assigned to work with but all students um uh McKenzie our occupational therapist has come in and do has done um some training on sensory regulations since um we have a a lot of Need for sensory regulation not only with students but also um with staff to how do how do we MA better manage our emotions how do we regular ourselves at school so it's been it's been really um a great year for training I'm I'm really proud of the work we're doing um and then uh at the end you mentioned under the challenges um a decrease in Sp sped funds linked to enrollment um and I just want to clarify that although we are basic Aid sped funds are actually linked to enrollment of the total District

096um correct not just it's unfortunately not to the enrollment of sped students it's to the overall enrollment yes and um more importantly it's it's um oh it's federal funds that go to the state and then the state disperses them based on your county enrollment and Santa Barbara County enrollment has declined so we get less there and then the county has less revenue and then they look at our enrollment and has declined and so even get the revenue is more decreased so what's Curious in our business is that our enrollments are increasing for sped and our costs are increasing but our revenue is decreasing yeah and that's something my commitment at least while I'm here and it has been this whole time is to harass our legislators as much as possible about that fact um thank

097you uh Congressman car PA starts shaking his head if he sees me because I will immediately jump on idea um and the funding and he knows they know um unfortunately and a lot of this is federal funding which is even harder exactly um but uh I I thank you for you and your staff everybody that um that creates this amazing program for our kids and um well we really appreciate the support that um Diana provides and that the school board provides because we're able to do the work we do um we're very aware of our cost and um very mindful when we are asking for something and making sure that we're um using the funds that we are allocated wisely to benefit all of our students yeah thank you thank you you great job thank

098you okay we are now moving on to F Educational Services if you have a comment on F we have uh one agenda item under that so F Educational Services please step up to the podium at this time okay so this agenda item is a stellar example of how three minutes of public comment on even a single item of this significance is Thoroughly inadequate on items like the sarc the student accountability report cards there is a sarc report for each School site and each report contains approximately 20 pages of very detailed information including but not limited to student enrollment by grade level teachers hired without credentials and misassignments availability of textbooks school facility conditions California physical fitness test results data on absenteeism suspensions and expulsions class siiz distribution and so on and so on there's so

099much to be learned if the time is taken to dig into this data which we have not really seen you do uh much of which provides very clear indicators about what is and what is not working in the cusd for example data pertaining to the percentage of students meeting state math language arts and science standards by student groups which are utterly abysmal especially when compared to the distraction that the superintendent threw out about student GPA the sarc also contains data on expenditures per pupil and School site teacher salaries compared to State averages even though cusd is a basic Aid district and in the top 4% of the most robustly funded TK through 12 districts in the state you will find that both expenditures per pupil and teacher salaries are far below State averages at every

100School site in the district Aliso School 19% expenditures per pupil 19% below State averages 14% below for teacher salaries canalino School 27% below State average on expenditures per pupil 19% Below on teacher salaries CMS 133% below expenditures per pupil 20% below for teacher salaries CHS 23% below expenditures per pupil 27% below for teacher salaries Carpenteria Family School 44% below expenditures per pupil 8% below for teacher salaries do we need to continue to remind you and the community where all that money's going legal fees yeah legal fees four years on the board for Miss Diamond four years on the board for Mr Smith six years on the board for Miss green two years for Mr Bridford approximately 15 years on the board for Mr schaer look at what you're doing to this district and then tonight

101you have the nerve the nerve to restrict public comment even further because you don't like what you're hearing from the public it is ludicrous you should be ashamed of yourselves thank you okay seeing no further public comment uh we have F1 our school's accountability report card for the 2023 and 2024 school year the board is asked to approve the 2023 2024 school's account accountability report rep card for carpentry Unified School District Schools February 1 of each year every school in California is required to by state law to publish a school accountability report card sarc the sarc contains information about the condition and performance of each California Public School under local control funding formula lcff all local educational agencies leas are required to prepare a local control and accountability plan which describes how they intend to

102meet annual school specific goals for all pupils with specific activities to address state and local priorities additionally data reported in an lcap is to be consistent with data reported in the sarc any questions from the board any can I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve a second okay and discussion well I just you know most of this information we've discussed several times now in the lcap and the and the um goals discussion the goals discussion uh District goals um and you know I think this is a formality isn't it the data that's reflected in the starc is a year old data so it's 232 24 data so it's data that we discussed um last year when we were looking at um the test results and the the different areas of which we

103were improving and you'll recall that um our data was consistent with the state in terms of English language arts performance and then math that we were sign significantly higher than um the average in the state so we did uh talk about uh the goals and objectives that were going to be implemented this year based on this last year's data thank you any further discussion I'm just looking looking at the attachments trying to remember there was something I had a comment on any further discussion okay okay well yeah okay uh we have a motion and a second uh all in favor I I I we are now moving on to uh G business operations and Facilities um if you have comment for uh G anything under business operations and Facilities now is the time to make

104public comment please step up to the podium Carpenter resident okay exess C administ of having a healthy uh budget you're responsible for having one but the excess of spending on legal fees is a cause for every year having the same discussion about legal about there's not enough money there should be money you're getting it taxpayers pay that but I have mentioned it to you thousands of times for years years comes and just just go and and I'll repeat the same message to you hoping that one day you get it so stop over spending on legal fees on lawsuits because if you sue someone or any or anyone and you lose and if you do it again and again and you lose you lose you lose that's not your money to spend that's our money I

105ask you when I was there if you were supposed to pay 5,000 10,000 for this claim you wouldn't do it thank you was that sorry Mr Delgado was that the entirety of your statement because you were you were doing both in Spanish and in English so I just want to make sure is that was that double time was no okay when you're doing because when we're doing a translation he gets double time so I just want to make sure that you can finish your comment it happened at the CD I was his no he he he he said his own personal comment is my understanding yeah and then I was Trans in Spanish that was your what he just did is just a Spanish of what okay so okay so I just want to make

106sure he hasn't spoken yet you see please be quiet can can I qu going then yes cuz this was your that was your statement in Spanish correct correct yes and uh this is what I did yesterday right right here at the city council meeting I did the same I translated and I was given extra time what he just did is the translation of the other comment he hasn't given his own comment he's what he everything he said is what he said no no it's not it's not no it's not yeah it's my it's my un comment the three minutes no no I he is doing his own okay yeah because I went first please can please finish your comment I want to make sure you I'm trying to to advocate for you in your time

107right now so please finish your keep going with your comment I got this so when I translate my own comment how much time do you have you get double time and that's what I'm trying to ensure right now then I got probably two more minutes Mr yes I'm I'm trying to Advocate to help you get your time that's what I'm doing I'm advocating for your time yeah so I'll continue in English because the transl that my Spanish is comment is gone so all right so yeah this is what what I was saying that we should all work together before we can have a healthy budget I've been saying this for a long long time uh and uh the less money that you overspend on whatever uh uh reason could be legal fees you could be

108any other uh expend or expenditure that over spend that favors the teachers that favors students special education students teacher salaries families that all I'm saying is that I Ian let's have a healthy budget let's have it that's an invitation to everyone thank you thank you please let me know when I may begin thank you so under the district's new practice announced this evening uh CD moves to further restrict public comments on topics that fall under business operations and Facilities under item G are placed nine independent and significant items to include District warrants a variety of gifts grants and donations and even a full presentation on the development of the 2526 budget um do you believe that that the community cannot see through this most recent effort to further restrict public comments on these important topics

109and further decrease transparency believe that although employee leadership arrived prepared to address the variety of items under item G uh we saw the board's decision to restrict transparency coming from Miles Away We anticipated this and to be clear prior to the evening's procedural change a member of the public would have been permitted 27 Collective minutes and 3 minute increments to address each and every item under letter G now after the district's move to further restrict public comment a member of the public receives just 3 minutes total to comment on nine different items contained on the agenda that's 20 seconds per item can you stop this 20 seconds to comment on the collection of District expenditures found in the warrants please stop sir to include stop as time for a moment let's make sure I get

110all that time back no there's no time to get back I had her stop the clock she took a while didn't she yeah no um what I'm I'm just going to ensure that you're using your time wisely to act to speak to one of these items okay yes I am um otherwise I'll ask you to move on um would maybe why don't you reread what I said so that you can hear clearly that everything I spoke about was about MMG go ahead and start continue to cut off every speaker in this room 20 seconds to com comment on the collection of District expenditures found in the warrants to include the district's extraordinary legal expenses associated with four outstanding arbitrations three rits to compel arbitration two unfair labor practices with the public employment Relations Board the

111tort associated with the illegal termination of an IIA at Aliso hearings designed to review the district's unlawful discipline of two employees who testified under oath that resulted in the district being found guilty of retaliation in discrimination and then of course the district's effort to defend itself against the continued retaliation and discrimination that the district was directed to cease and desist in 2021 and didn't a legal effort by the district that has cost USD approximately $3.5 million you're going to hear that over and over because it is true notice that they have not proven it untrue have you 20 seconds also though to cover seven independent grants gifts and donations and 20 seconds to comment on the 5 26 proposed budget that contains over 1,000 data points associated with the district's budget expenditures revenues Reserve balances

112and on and on no wonder these meetings are so poorly attended perhaps the folks should pan into the room here and see how few people come um they don't come because they so rarely see the benefit of either themselves to themselves or to District students and families that is associated with attending and participating in meetings like these let the community prepare for an even more myopic self-serving and opaque government instructure by you all who made this decision these are your leaders [Music] Carpenteria we are moving on to G1 warrants the board has asked to approve the warrants for the period of January 10th through January 23rd in the amount of $87,900 warrants are issued once a week on Thursdays the report format shows check number check date pay brief account description payment comment and check

113amount [Music] questions okay uh may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve the warrant as presented all second discussion okay all in favor I I uh G2 gifts grants and donations we have a donation from Roberto Ro and Maria uh Clara Garcia to ASB student aid uh for CHS were being asked to accept a donation in the amount of $500 to kpai ASB student aid account um may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve with gratitude second all in favor I I uh 2B donation from Linda Lang to Future Farmers of America in the amount of 50 $50 um to CHS FFA may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve all second any discussion all in favor I thank you Linda donation from Anonymous in memory

114of darl brown to CHS baseball club account the board is asked to accept the anonymous donation in memory of Daryl Brown of $11,000 to CHS baseball club I'll move to approve with gratitude thank you Anonymous yes thank you I'll second that thank you okay all in favor I we have G uh two D donation from uh Eric CER to CMS music program uh in's see here he's donated a set of drums valued at $2,000 to the CHS uh music program with Mr pava School sorry Middle School all right I'll move to approve with gratitude thank you Eric well second all in favor I uh 2 e donation from Rotary Club of Carpenteria to CMS Elementary music program the board is asked to accept the donation from Rotary Club of carpentera of several musical instruments valued

115at $31,000 to Carpenteria middle school middle and elementary schools music program this includes six violas 10 UBS condenser microphones a baritone saxophone and 29 replacement indust replacement IND instruments for those declared unrepairable wow that is so generous um may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve thank you rotary as always rotary's huge supporter of the music program all second okay all yeah thank you all in favor I donation from Anonymous through carpentera Education Foundation to CHS Avid field trips board is asked to accept the anonymous donation through carpentry Education Foundation of $871 1582 to carpentera high school AVID for field trips uh may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve I'll second that uh all in favor I I thank you uh we have a donation from Anonymous of

116musical instruments to CMS the board has asked to accept the anonymous donation of musical instruments including an electric guitar with an amplifier a violin a keyboard and an acoustic guitar to the carpentera middle school music program the estimated value of this donation is approximately $500 may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve all second all in favor I I thank you and we are now moving on to G3 2025 26 budget development we will continue reviewing And discussing the proposed 2526 budget superintendent Diana Rigby and assistant superintendent Jason CF will lead the presentation and develop Vel M of the 2526 budget and also just to mention that this is after um after our uh our January 16th uh January 16th budget study session that we held um so we're building off of

117that right thank you so we'll go ahead and move to the first slide and um you've seen this many times before in our budget presentations but we always like to remind everybody about our core budgeting principles because these guide us when we're having our discussions and developing the budget for 2526 specifically as we move ahead we know that we're going to be making some budget reductions so I want to remind everyone that um of our three principles that students in their learning are at the center of our decisions and that's reflected in decisions we've made in allocating funds to keep our class sizes very low uh Elementary is 20 to1 Middle School 22 to1 and High School 24:1 which ranks us as number one when we compare ourselves to districts in Santa Barbara and Ventura

118counties in addition we offer a robust um curriculum at both the elementary secondary levels we have a wide range of electives for our students at middle school and high school we have intervention programs uh for students at the elementary school and we have mental health supports um all through the system k k TK to 12 and we provide a enormous amount of individualized support through um our instructional assistance especially at the elementary and middle schools um the next core principles teaching and learning conditions matter for students success and this is re really reflected in our focus on site-based decision-making and teacher leadership we we allocate funds for Department chairs we allocate funds for for and stiens for teachers who are providing professional development we provide monies for professional development we've offered early release days and

119late start Mondays to provide support for teachers in their professional uh learning communities our facilities have been updated the community was generous enough to um support and fund more than $90 million for our updated facilities new equipment new technology and our last another our one of our our third principle is uh the resources that we request for program services and activities reflect the core values of academic achievement respectful community and continuous Improvement another uh core principle is our minimum fund balance and you'll recall for ab 1200 the minimum is 3% but we've recognized in our small District that we need to um increase that to 10% that's really our goal for minimum fund balance and in our board um policy we indicate that if our fund balance Falls below that 10% we really should develop

120a plan to recover the fund balance by either uh looking at new unrestricted revenues which is not uh plentiful or reducing expenditures and that's what we're doing um that's what we did two weeks ago that's what we're doing tonight and that's where as we move forward that's what we're looking at is reducing EXP expenditures the next slide just reminds everyone about the uh minimum that for our district you have to have at least 3% in your fund balance and then we've move to the next slide you um this is familiar to you because we shared this at the first interim on November 26 and um there's several things to point out one is that um our June protect uh projection for Revenue was 32 million when when um the actual came in it was uh

12131.4 so um for this interim we readjusted the revenues and also the expenditures so that we're um our deficit is not 605 at this point which is the difference between what our Revenue was but it was um $396,000 so that that's our operating deficit for this year with a 4.31% Reserve balance but the caveat is included is we do not have any Cola increases in these expenditures and for for our Cola increase 1% salary increase for our um staff is worth $25,000 so that is not included what is included is that for certificated staff they have a 4% increase on their salary schedule and classified staff also has a step increase we also have longevity and then our health benefit the increase was $276,000 so the step increases and the health benefit increases are included

122in the expenditure what is not is the cola for the salary increases for either um 23 24 or 2425 and those are the significant expenses so given this um budget back round again I want to remind you that when we had completed uh our 2324 budget we were in a deficit of $44,000 848 so we had to remove that from our reserves you know from our fund balance and then we had a difference between our projected revenue and our actual revenue and then our first interim our budget variance is 1.1 $1.1 million so we're really looking at a $1.6 million deficit that we need to correct as we move forward in developing the 2526 budget so that gives us our goal and so the next our next work our next steps is to look at

123those areas that are first outside the classroom that we that we will reduce for next year to uh recover the $1.6 million so we can um uh ensure that we have Cola increases for all staff as well as that fund balance so the next question or what we take a look at is what are those fixed costs or the budget drivers that significantly affect your budget development um the first area we've looked at is the declining enrollment so that you recall that our state and federal money is for categoricals only title one and title two but when you have declining enrollment your state and federal money is going to decline and you you heard that with special ed right we are a community school or basic Aid so declining enrollment doesn't a affect our Revenue

124because remember our revenue is generated from the county and it's the county is generating from property taxes however it does affect Staffing so if you take a look at our enrollment history you'll see that um in 10 years it's been about 13% so when you think about enrollment decline you have to think about uh reducing your Staffing so the next no you're too fast okay that's all right um so the next item we look at is once we look at enrollment we look at Staffing history meaning um how many FTE do we have given the enrollment we that uh we are um serving so you'll see that our enrollment is declined but our FTE has not declined in the same ratio so we're looking at reducing FTE accordingly to the reduction of enrollment and you'll

125recall that um uh several things that drive this you know we still our focus is going back to uh focusing decisions on student learning we still want small class sizes but um that is going to be something that we need to consider with these FTE amounts and then the largest expense in our budget is going to be of course um staff because it's a salaries and benefits that's 80% of our budget so the next um slide reflects another budget driver and that's really our salaries so this is the 2425 scattergram which um indicates where all of our teacher salaries certificated salaries lie in that we have um a number of steps meaning how many years you've been with the district and then we have our classes so depending on your education you're placed in either

126uh a class one two ranging one to four and then your step indicates how many years you've been with the district as I've as I've stated and those are the number of Staff members at each class and step so when you look at the scattergram uh where looking at a uh 152 uh salaries that are reflected or 152 FTE reflected in the catogram you'll see that um at least 40% of our teachers steps 1 through 10 receive that PO 4% increase this year in their step and then when you uh look at the next slide you'll see that teachers also receive their longevity and that's 33 teachers receiving their longevity is longevity reflected in this in this salary in the next page next page but it's not no no this this ends at 14 and

127then if you go to the next page that's telling you how many uh teachers are receiving longevity and then our next slide you've seen before is our history of cost of living increases so the average Cola increase cost of living that we that we have provided for certificated staff is 2.5 49% and for classified is 3.57% Cola so that's in addition to the step increase and then the next slide oh you're a little bit going back yeah is our history of Health and Welfare increases so this is another fixed cost or budget driver and I want to remind everyone that again because we provide 100% of our health benefits for our full-time employees of which um 205 employees take advantage of is that we are ranked again with comparable districts in Santa Barb Ventura county

128is one of the top districts providing um the highest benefits of 100% And with that each year you have increased cost to those benefits and this year increased $257,000 which we've already paid for and accounted for in the expenditures but that's a fixed cost when you're developing your budget another budget driver or fixed cost is pension increases so the district provides contributions to both STS which is for certificated staff and perss which is for classified staff and again you'll see the percent of increase year after year that we're contributing and that again is part of our budget and then the next item you heard a little bit from um our director Carolyn Haynes about the increasing special education costs and we've already discussed that the revenue has declined but our expenses have increased and postco

129our expenses have uh significantly increased as well as our percentage of enrollment of sped 20 2020 and 2021 14% of our students were enrolled in sped and now we have 18% whereas the Statewide average is only 14% but you can see the increase of cost in The Last 5 Years so we've had an increase what will we ask what what contributes to that we've had an increased of enrollment in special education we've had an increased of contracted Services because teachers specialed teachers or uh mostly the specialed providers of the um additional Services speech and language therapists occupational therapists physical therapists they work for agencies rather than being directly hired we've had an increase of serious students with emotional disturbances and so that's an increase in enrollment at private uh programs such as Kasa Pacifica and

130then we've had an increase of Need for uh bcbas the behavioral technicians all of those increases have contributed to the increased cost and special ed and yet our revenue is decreasing well is that um just to clarify that has our revenue for sped decreased or is it just not keeping Pace with our it's both but you can see uh last year we received 2,398 742 this year we received 2,339 whereas in uh 2022 23 we received 2.6 million so you can see the revenue has decreased that's why you're saying it okay yeah but it's both it's definitely not kept up with the cost but it's really about it sounds like the the sped is funded you know a big chunk of it comes from the feds through the state yeah and the state funds it

131based on a uh average daily attendance through the lcff formula and because districts um not not only our district but most districts in California uh at least on the coast are have declining enrollment so which means there's a lower Ada and and so the they they they're cutting the money to the county and then the County's cutting money to us because our enr I mean the County's enrollment is down and then our enrollment is down as well so even though um our special ed enrollment is up it's not keyed to special education enrollment it's keyed to overall enrollment and that's another one of those things that makes no sense therefore we're having to contribute significantly more each year from the general fund to that so five years ago we are contributing 4.2 million and now

132we're contributing 6.4 million right and then the next um factor that impacts the budget is our property tax so it's our revenue and um typically it was 5% last two years it's been over 7% this year though it was 5% so up until this year now those are all actuals and then we're projecting out that it will will remain at 5% so now we're moving to what areas would we recommend for oh excuse me back that yeah we're not projecting that the county is projecting that property tax no no now the county has told us it's 5.07% this year yeah and we've made projections that it's 5% under their advisement yes under their advisement but they did not give us that projection we're making the projection based on their advisement well based on the information

133I have from them which said we will not go more higher than 5% so they've told us that they're not going to give us more than a 5% no they've not said that directly I've just this is just speaking with the person that um allocates our funds indicated to me when I asked about why did we have two years of over 7% and now we're back to 5% help me understand that and she said the the two years was anomaly and she is expecting that our revenues will all be at 5% for the next few years I'm I'm I'm was Jan William I'm anxious to have that conversation in our one of our upcoming meetings with the treasurer we're going to speak to or the it's a representative from the the auditor the treasurer no

134treasur yeah he's the treasurer excuse me he is from the tax assessor's office okay yeah okay so now we're at um our recommended um considerations for reductions and again as I mentioned we start away from the classroom and what we've uh discussed at the leadership team because this begins all at the leadership team this reflects the conversation and discussion of School site principles and uh district office leaders in terms of keeping the reductions away from the classroom and that means any programs that are offered outside the classroom and our expectations is that unless the program are funded by state or federal funds or grant money that we will have to consider them uh we will have to consider reducing them so there are programs here that are in our Professional Services so that's contracted Services

135last year we spent 5.4 we already reduced it to 3.9 and we're recommending uh to continue to reduce it by um not offering aha program Girls Inc car soless Project Lead the Way um Alice weissing helps with board minutes and then field trips those are Elementary field trips in which we are moving them to Grant funded and that will be the that is the request to CF in which they are um seriously considering funding our portion of the field trips so we still want to provide field trips but we are recommending that they're not funded from the um unrestricted budget the next area is conferences we've reduced them significantly and we recommend that for next year is that we reduce um conference attendance by $20,000 the next item is legal fees and that's 5830 last

136year and you'll see all the categories it's general student issues employment public agency and governance employee discipline perb grievances special Ed and last year we spent 1.3 excuse me two years ago 1.3 we were able to reduce it to 1.1 and we're recommending $200,000 additional reduction the next two the next two items are um challenging because um we really don't want to reduce uh Personnel but they but the Personnel costs are the largest costs but we are confident that through attrition which is retirement or resignation that we will not be doing any layoffs we will be able to reduce the instructional assistance um $460,000 with 10 instructional assistance and then for certificated um we will we will be able to reduce four FTE again through attrition so that means we won't replace four FTE through

137the retirements and resignations and then we are recommending that the ele Elementary GATE program that we will not have that in place for next year because that is not state funded any longer and um that is a one uh FTE that person however the particular teacher will has been in our district and will continue teaching just not in the gate program and then um we historically have provided teachers on a volunteer basis three additional professional development days at their their salary rate so that essentially adds three more days to their calendar and we're recommending that we will do that work from now until the end of the year in our early release time and during the professional development day that we have uh before school starts and in October next year so that will um

138that's a 1.7 at this point and our and our our goals 1.6 1.6 okay so this is basically what we covered at our budget meeting two weeks ago yes and it incorporates the feedback that we received okay well I'm happy to see I mean I've been you know we read about um many other districts locally are actually having uh reductions and forc you know lay basically layoffs and I can I'm I'm happy to see that we're not doing that um whereas it seems like an awful lot of districts are doing that we're able uh to recoup or reduce through attrition that doesn't mean that there will be some movement you know across the schools in terms of there may be a retirement at one particular school but we may need that particular classroom so there

139may be um grade level changes uh at the elementary level but I think um or across elementary schools but I I think we'll be able to uh support what our needs are going to be next year okay um now can I just excuse me I just wanted to mention you know this is uh preliminary so um we don't have all the retirements right now today so and I think more will come I mean we're we're projecting we will um see more retirements yeah so just recognizing that this is what you've brought forward as proposed reductions um I mean there's there's some things that we don't have control over ultimately um but but um I think the summarizes what what we went over and takes into account what uh what we discussed during the the study

140session session well yeah we met for two hours and discussed this we went through this pretty yeah so it doesn't make it sting any less but that we're able to at least you know find all other ways of like accommodating field trips and and different things like that and it's not eliminating conferences it's just reducing [Music] um so and we will be able to maintain our relatively low class sizes meaning that we're not going to we're not facing going from 20 to1 in elementary to 27 to1 as an average so we still have the the core value of keeping our uh class sizes relatively small as well as at the secondary level because you'll recall the earlier slide about FTE and enrollment and when you have that reduced enrollment you really have to reduce your

141FTE and you'll see that both at the middle school and high school we do have more FTE than really what the enrollment calls for okay I'd just like to point out it you know one of the if it's not clear to people one of the big drivers the biggest driver here is the fact that um we had to adjust our revenues um from a 7% to 5% and that was a that was a surprise I think to us when the county came out with their actual property tax revenues yes and and and so that is the the the Big Driver that has um led to this change in our you know budgetary guidelines and um uh which is very frustrating from you know our position I think yes your costs are going up but your

142revenue is not increasing the way you need it to uh increase and then just I mean we've already said it but just the the rate at what we're the amount of money we're having to pull from the general fund um for sped costs um and so I think whatever we can do to continue service but bringing positions inhouse um I mean there's there's an aspect of we put notice out and if we don't get the responses we don't get the responses so we have to hire out but um I believe one of us let's see here yeah um I think if we can keep trying to notice for for positions to to bring them inhouse instead of um contract um I think that that may help a little bit I mean it may be not

143much in the grand scheme of things but um oh it will significantly help that's why you'll see February 1st you'll see that we will have posted openings for speech and language pathologist um mild moderate teachers uh occupational therapists physical therapists okay so we're we're posting for all the contract yes yes so absolutely that that is driving the cost huge cost driver okay okay um any further clarification about what was presented this looks like it it represents and reflects what we discussed at the study session previously um no action on this item this was just to continue a review so that will continue to be built and brought back again at at a future meeting okay we are now on to uh H measure you if you would like to make public comment on H measure

144U now is your time to come and make public comment okay not seeing any H1 measure youu notice of completion for canalino Elementary School Learning Center the board has asked to approve the completed contract for the canalino Elementary School Learning Center on April 9th 2024 the board approved the GMP with mcgil Construction Inc in the amount of 1,400 7 473,000 $8.74 the completed construction amount is 1,660 n6510 pursuant to civil code section 9204 a notice of completion must be filed within 15 days after the completion of work or Improvement The District staff have inspected the project and are satisfied that all work has been completed per the contract documents to ensure the district has received a prelim all preliminary 20-day and stop payment notices per civil code sections 9300 through 9306 retention will be held

145for no more than 30 days in accordance with public contract code section 7107 retention will be released within 60 days pursuant to civil code final notice of completion for mcil Construction Inc in the amount of 1,660 n6510 any questions from the board on this NOP okay may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve a second and discussion just like to thank uh them for doing a great job and and getting it on schedule and I'm really happy that we have a library back at the I mean a new library at canalino it's absolutely beautiful it is absolutely a beautiful beautiful Center for readers and Learners it is um we had the ribbon cutting ceremony last Thursday Wednesday W Wednesday last week um and and it was really great it was after school

146and um the after school program kids were able to come be there we had quite a few uh community members families teachers and staff um and uh Julie SoDo was beaming she is very proud of of the facility and um it it's absolutely incredible the space that it has in there for small group learning for group reading um Circle time reading uh the the way the library is designed kind of like a maze to get lost among the books um as well as uh the the computer lab set up there and um it was just it was very thoughtful um and I'm just going to take this moment to kind of recap some of the statement I made um last week to the community was just to thank the community for um for their belief

147in and the importance of this project of measure you um for our kids uh there was um there's never an easy uh it's never an easy ask to ask the community to increase uh what they pay in property taxes for something like this but it was important and the majority of the community spoke up and said yes we believe this is much needed and our kids need uh will Thrive and and and they are and that's reflected in the um the wide array and increase in amazing um College admissions we see each year um the students that are going out into the world even directly from high school because of the facilities and the access to facilities and classrooms um and equipment that they have in their everyday learning from uh elementary through high school

148um I know there was a group of us when this kind of started that we thought gosh our kids will never actually get to see any of this and they actually have and so that's really awesome um some of us will get a little more life out of it with our kids than others but um I just I want to thank the community for believing in our students um and uh and and for the support that that this brought and what this will do um for the long term of our community so generations to yep so we are being asked to approve the completed contract um may I get a motion I I'll move to approve to uh to approve the oh we have the motion oh we did that sorry that's right we were

149having discussion we were having discussion okay um okay all all in favor I I wonderful uh future agenda items I public comment all right at minute uh 14830 of the January 14th board meeting Jamie Diamond stated that there are many possible reasons why people leave the district Miss Diamond is correct it is possible that people leave the district for many reasons uh for this reason Union leadership requests that the following question be placed on future agendas why are so many employees leaving cusd um because just because it's possible that people leave for many reasons as Miss Diamond said does very very little to clarify why so many people have specifically fled cusd in the last 12 months again approximately 70 employees to be exact the following reasons Are Not Mere connotations for the district Staffing

150problems as Miss Diamond suggested here are the very clear reasons employees have shared with their colleagues and with leadership employees have left because the administrative Culture fostered by Miss rig is toxic quote toxic they leave because employees feel isolated unsupported and under attack they leave because professionals cannot safely share their concerns and experiences and in turn cannot provide the service they are committed to provide students and families they leave because they have watched and are aware that the district officials before us have invested no less than $3.5 million trying to silence the employees elected representatives 2 million already on the books as confirmed by Miss Rigby this evening and another 1 and A5 million in debts to be paid due to recent legal decisions that's their three and a half million right there they leave

151because instructional programs are underst staffed their schools are underresourced and admin's answer is to give themselves two salary increases and then limit public comments at meetings like these they leave because their experience is not respected or valued in the decision Mak process they leave because they have not received any salary increase in 19 months while the cost of living has increased 20 to 23% in the last two years they leave because they have watched new employees get hired with hiring bonuses at higher rates of pay than those who have worked in the district for 15 20 and 25 years and they leave because they have watched superintendent Rigby dismantle standardized safety practices in the district so that Senior Management can shift accountability from their shoulders to those who have the least ability to influence the

152district safety practices as a whole so please board members save us your hypothetical understanding of why employees leave their places of employment for the employees we represent we are not dealing in your imaginary hypothetical scenarios we are dealing with the very real reasons why over just last year 70 employees left C USD and why this trend is projected to continue because the reasons shared are not being improved upon thank you so this speaker continues to mislead the public if I I would recommend uh refer everyone to the June 5th 2024 board meeting and also the um uh July 11th 2023 board meetings to reference the uh the misrepresented uh managerial salary increases which are not as described by the previous speaker were there not two and and um and and uh please do not speak

153from the back of the room uh the speaker has alluded to um offers made previously between the bargaining unit and the um District which were actually a better offer than those offered to uh than than what was given to Administration um and if those are if that's news to the uh to the to our to our staff then they should take that up with their Union Representatives because an offer was made that was quite generous and was turned down you can you can leave or you can remain silent this is not your opportunity no this is not your opportunity to speak this is board comment thank you okay um so for future agenda items we have continued oh there's a typo it should say 2025 2026 budget development um and then the lcap midyear update

154report and then I believe we will eventually is that pool presentation that was pulled is that or is that just kind of for now off they haven't given us another date there's no it'll be in the future okay um okay Board calendar um is there anything we need to note Monica no uh and board announcements anybody well congratulations to uh CHS water polo girls uh it was senior night tonight um thank you to all the girls for for an awesome season the young women uh they played really well and um and it was great to to be part of the team this year off the CIF right I believe so yeah yeah I believe first round is Tuesday next week week from today we'll find out tomorrow uh th no Saturday Saturday okay okay um

155be a homie no they changed the rules so did winning so we went uh 8 and0 in League undefeated but that does not give you a automatic home opener anymore with the new system so we'll find out all right well congratulations to uh girls water polo and especially to the seniors um and then uh I just also want to reiterate to the community that there is information for those of you who um are looking for it um on how to respond what to do um if you have concerns over um any of the current executive orders and how that will affect the community um CCP uh is a amazing resource um and there are uh other leaders in town that have uh also great opportunities and resources to help our um any of our community

156members who are concerned over um the recent executive orders as it relates to immigration so um I just want to say uh we will do what we what we are tasked to do and and um we know our community will step up to the plate so thank you we are adjourned for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.