CorpusRecord 31167

Carpinteria Unified School District Meeting - February 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City of Carpinteria
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Santa Barbara County, CA
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,268 words · about 102 min
Collected
2026-06-06

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e good evening and welcome to the regular board meeting of carpentry Unified School District it is February 11th can everybody please stand for the flag salute begin I pledge to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay we're going to begin with our closed session report uh 2A Public Employee discipline dismissal and release government code section 54957 in closed session by a unanimous vote 5 to Zer uh the board adopted the decision of the independent hearing officer and approved the dismissal of employee 519 from the position of instructional assistant effective immediately the roll call vote was as follows uh eyes Diamond Schaffer green Smith and bredford uh c2b we had conference with labor negotiators information

002was exchanged and no action was taken um at this time we're going to uh go over our public comments um as well as the general procedures for public comment for um for the meeting uh public comments will be bundled together at the beginning of each alphabetical section of the agenda beginning with e oh well D um no e sorry beginning with yeah with e um so every you'll uh step up to the podium and you'll have your time to speak um I know that we do have a fair amount of people I believe can if you wouldn't mind raising your hand if you are here for open public comment for comments for items not on tonight's agenda 18 20 21 23 okay um um we are going to uh adjust the time for open public

003comment to 2 minutes um and we will begin public comment for items not on this agenda at this time so if you'd like to make public comment tonight for items not on the agenda please step up to the podium and just next person just be ready to step up and go from there thank you okay all right uh in the late 70s in the late 70s uh we were very close to reaching a thousand students we were trying to reach it I did my part with my seven kids but uh we didn't quite get to a th a th000 students they're now down to what I stand is under 600 in the late '70s we had two administrators and two counselors from what I understand now you have three administrators and three counselors seems like

004the formula now is less enrollment more admit I think that's a real poor Direction I just heard that possibly one one of the positions is a grant I don't know I didn't look into it and one is possibly covid money I don't know how long we're going to R ride that pony but I I and I didn't look at the rest of the schools I didn't look at Summerland I the middle school I don't know what's going on there I just know at the high school which I'm familiar with that um something's not right three administrators and three counselors with less than 600 when almost double you only had two and two and I think that should be looked at I know what's going to happen when administrator leaves I know what's going to happen

005because it happened uh when I was there that the the comment will be we have money set aside for that position no put that we're teach we're teachers can get to that money I really think you know like I said I enjoyed my 37 years I was born and raised in Carpenter I enjoyed my 37 years at carpentera but I think teachers are are underpaid and I just heard the buzzer and thank you for the time thank you for the time so please just come and step [Applause] up maybe have a couple folks ready to go that'd be great thanks yes yes uh first of all hello good evening and I would like to apologize to Sylvia Harper Eden lendel and any other gate students that I work with um that I'm sorry that you

006have to find out this way and that what I'm about to say will be sad for those of you who don't know me I'm Crystal Marshall I've been the gifted education coordinator for three years I work with about 80 students across three campuses on a variety of steam subjects one or more years one or more years above grade level as some of you already know gate is being considered for elimination next school year as a child I experienced firsthand the disen disenfranchisement of learning in a district that did not provide services for its gifted population that is why I take my job so seriously and I'm standing here this evening and I strive to be the educator Advocate that I needed as a child all students deserve to make one year's worth of academic growth

007each school year according to the National Association for gifted children many gifted children start the school year already knowing more than half of the grade level curriculum struggle and stimulation are necessary to foster a positive attitude towards School true perseverance and resiliency from failure that's where I come in just today third graders started building a robot and fourth graders completed a floor siiz timeline about Evolution these are simply not projects gened teachers can take on in the name of differentiation especially when they are when they are already overwhelmed by today's demands please reconsider eliminating gate maybe we could make smaller cuts to multiple Endeavors or as ladyy Garcia suggested last week look into buying from less expensive material suppliers I believe a solution can be reached without the detriment to the gifted population thank you

008please just please just come up next person after next thanks I'm short my name is Mary mcquerter used to serve on the school board from 1994 to 2006 and I remember um our board was very excited as we dreamed up the family school and then instituted it and and each year I've been so proud uh that it just continues and continues and and I know that I'm sure all of you want to keep it too and I just hope you can find a way to do it because I think it's something unique for our school district that we offer and some kids might slip through the cracks um in different ways if they don't have this option so um and as far as the gate goes I'm just adding a little two cents we used

009to have the gate Blended school um classrooms at the middle school they were awesome my kids were in them and I volunteered in them and it was half of the each class was gate and the other half were just High Achievers that maybe didn't score gate and they were all presented with high quality uh so I don't know why it went away it was a really great program anyway thank you for letting me speak thank [Applause] you good evening thanks for the opportunity uh to share some perspective on this decision that's before you um my name is David Harrow I'm a relatively new member of the carpentera community my family and I moved here three years ago and we frankly moved here for family school we came from the East Coast um and we were

010looking for many places I work in West Lake Village we came all the way to KP and lived here because of family school um and so I know there's a lot of things in front of you I work um in a business where we look at budget shortfalls all the time I get the realities of that they're tough trade-offs and tough choices um but I think there's another way to move forward than what's being recommended uh we have 11 students who are rising third graders in the family school they deserve a right just like the eight students at canalino who don't have a home for next year to make a choice about where their families think is the best fit for their education we have Headroom in the fourth fifth grade Family School class if

011any of those Rising fourth graders wanted to choose family school as an option those fourth graders could also be absorbed in into the English only uh classroom that already exists in fourth grade at canalino we have I know already several students who are interested Rising uh second and third graders in canalino now who would rather be at family school but didn't have that option when the K1 class uh was eliminated this year so I think we have an opportunity without additional pressure on the budget Beyond what's already been recommended to preserve the four five class at Family School to create a mix stage to three class at Family School with the 11 third graders who are already there and integrating any second and third graders rising from canalino or frankly Beyond at the district and

012allowing those eight canalino students to have a choice whether they want a mixed stage class or a single grade class at canalino in the fourth grade that already exists there um and we have one unassigned teacher although I'd prefer obviously that we maintain the gate program because that's been so critical for our students thank you thank you [Applause] hi my name is Alyssa margolin I have two children enrolled at the family school and I'd like to share with you a bit about how we chose it what our experience has been and why we believe it's in the best interest of our community to keep this school 3 years ago as you just heard from my husband we decided to move here from DC I I tour dozens of public and private schools from Woodland Hills

013to Santa Barbara when I found this school I knew I'd found what I'd been looking for a small school with highly engaged teachers a rich community of families specific focus on whole Child Development prioritizing social emotional and academic flourishing we also love the infusion of Music throughout the school day the celebration of Visual Arts and theater and the abundance of learning in and about nature we're also looking for a school that provided AC academic excellence and we found that here n out of 10 on Great Schools 92% outperforming 92% of other similar schools throughout the entire State and rated number one in the district we decided to move here so our children could attend to the school having such a high performing School in our town increases the value of everyone's home increases the likelihood

014that families like us looking to relocate to the area will choose karp and that carp resident starting families will choose to stay we've experienced that these ratings stem from a unique and exceptional learning model it provides the mixed age classrooms at Family School facilitated by outstanding teachers specifically trained and with a wealth of experience in teaching mixed age groups allow several unique opportunities teachers know students over many years and teach them for more than one year allowing individualized focus and learning plans children learn with students in alternating years in grades below and above them giving them three cohorts of children with whom they build strong bonds as they alternate into the older grades they gain confidence in familiar and nurturing settings an opportunity for leadership naturally emerges this is a unique highly successful model a

015short-sighted decision to choose Family School based on this year's budget restrictions will result in the long-term loss of choice for our community we will lose a model for academic excellence and will likely lose many engaged families in high performing students from the public school system thank you this is my son okay turn on make sure his mic is turned on okay my name is Harper Harrow I am in the fifth grade and have attended the carpentry of family school for 3 years it has been a great pleasure to me being there I love that the teachers like a lot of the same things that I love I was enrolled in for schools all the way until I was in second grade so I loved the Wilderness and I really enjoyed that the teachers at Family

016School shared the same level of interest in nature as I do during my three years there I have experienced many fun things the river trail project new games new friends fun trail field trips and many more Meanwhile my sister Zuri still has 2 and a half years to go in family school and every day after school she has come home with a big smile on her face and and has been so joyful and eager to share about her day I would hate for that to stop happening it has been so fun to see all the work she has been doing and to hear the excitement as she tells us about it I love this school with all my heart and and I bet there is something else you could do instead I would do anything

017to keep family school and it' make me cry until I if it would be gone forever thank you for your time thank [Applause] you my name is Malik barnetche and I'm in third grade at Kia family school I'm speaking to you today to share my perspectives regarding potential closures of my school and program due to budget cuts I'm new this year to family school and have only lived in Carpenteria for less than two years we mve here from Mexico I love my school because it's a place where I made close friends that have made me feel welcome since my first day this is my second School here in car Carpenteria and it's been easier to make friends at Family School I also have an amazing teacher who is very supportive and who makes learning fun

018another special thing that is unique of this school is that my parents get to be involved in my learning and my mom can come often to organize activities at Family Friday we also had a camping trip where almost all my classmates and their parents came it was so much fun I I feel very good about my English now and now that this school this school I go to has helped me adapt quickly last I would love to keep the gate program as it challenge me challenged me to explore my potential in a fun interesting atmosphere so I can grow up and become an engineer just like my dad I feel lucky to be a part of this cool program thank you thank you okay hi there I'm Nikki Wilmore thank you for letting us speak

019today we have been in family school for two years we've been in Carpenteria for 10 and when we moved back two years ago my daughter was struggling with debilitating anxiety and we were constantly having challenges at schools with a lot of transition teachers not really understanding her unique needs and we found a solution for that with family school the multi-level classroom and having teachers getting to interact with the children for two years has really helped us find the teacher understand Solutions and understand the unique needs of those of those children I know that she's not the only one struggling with that right now and I think having outdoor opportunities and having highly engaged activities that the parents can participate in it's allowed us to feel comfortable knowing the other families and it's allowed her to

020have a level of comfort knowing not only the children an age above and an age below but also knowing their parents too and feeling very safe in her community I agree with the comments that Dave shared with alternative Solutions we have a model that's proven to work for 23 years and I think it's brought so much value to the community we chose this school when we moved back primarily for the high ratings that it had online and we wanted to give our kids that opportunity so I hope you really consider alternative options instead of closing family school go ahead my name is James and I think family school is unique because every day I make new friends every day every year you're the little kid or big kid when you're the the little kids the

021big kids help you the big kids play with the little kids the big kids sometimes play by their themselves thank you James okay good evening thank you super superintendent Rigby and the board for taking the time to hear our feedback my name is Jessica pillo and I am the mother of a third grader at Carpenteria family school and a TK student at cantalino I want to sincerely thank superintendent Rigby for meeting with the family school's parents to explain the budget reductions and the reasoning behind the proposed Cuts I truly appreciate her willingness to engage in these diffic difficult ult conversations and acknowledge the tough decisions ahead that's why I'm coming to you with a recommendation that meets the necessary budget cuts while maintaining the two3 class at Family School eliminating the two3 class puts Family

022School on a path towards closure which would be a huge loss for our community well it may seem like an easy cut with a retiring teacher this decision is short-sighted instead of moving the 11 incoming CFS third graders into a newly formed split class at canalino I urge you to keep the split classes where they already work at Family School The Simple Solution is to reassign a teacher to maintain the two3 class at Family School and distribute the eight canalino fourth graders who need a class across family school and canalino the CFS parents and students have so many Outreach ideas to support this change that I don't have time to share now Family School thrives on the split class model it consistently produces strong academic results has deeply engaged families and successfully prepares students for

023middle school closing it would reduce school choice hurt enrollment and weaken the community's connection to our schools my family is also impacted by the loss of the gate program which serves kids with unique learning needs my daughter loves school and will do fine but largely because she's in family school it's heartbreaking that students won't have this opportunity in the future if gate has to be cut at least maintaining Family School preserves an option for kids who need a more engaging and differentiated learning environment I support family school because I believe in public education my kids aren't in public school only because I can't afford private school even if I could I'd still choose public family school offers something special that keeps families in the district cutting it may provide short-term savings and the long-term consequences

024will be far greater thank you good evening Carpenteria school board members my name is Sylvia and I am in third grade at Carpenteria family school I also have a little brother in TK at calino I'm speaking to you today about the importance of keeping Family School all and my recommendation you you keep Family School open one of my favorite things about family school is family Friday it's really fun to have my parents come and be a part of my school and Lead activities with me both of my grandmas have also came to family Friday I also like family school because there are two different grades in each class when you're the younger grade you can learn from the older kids when you're the older grade you can and work on your teacher helping and teaching

025skills with the younger kids my teachers in Family School are kind I loved having Franny in k one and I loved Jan in 2 three thank you for listening taking the time to listen I hope you decide to keep Family School open so I can f finish elementary school there and my little brother can have the same experience thank you siia [Applause] hi my name is Dave and I'm in kindergarten and I would like to chance to go to family school thank you for your time thank you for your time thank you hi my name is Autumn fiori palm and I am the mother of a current sixth grader at CMS and first grader at canalino my oldest son Alias completed his entire Elementary education at Carpenteria family school and my youngest son was in

026Mrs oda's K1 Family School class last year I've been very active in the life of Carpenteria family school over the past seven years from being rich room parent for 5 years organizing and volunteering for the jagathon helping in the classroom developing and implementing with parents and teachers the explorathon which is a covid Time alternative to the jagathon where students and families were invited to to find different landmarks around Carpenteria encouraging Outdoor Learning physical activity and knowledge of our ecosystem and unique natural areas I can speak to the benefits of Carpenteria Family School the transformational relationships my children have built with fellow students and teachers the confidence they have gained by having teachers who get to know them from the time they're in kindergarten the Arts and and Environmental Education they've been taught and the way

027that being a part of a small multi-age class prepared my older son for the successful transition to the middle school but what I would like to do is suggest a possible solution to keeping Carpenteria Family School open within the budget constraints the dis district is facing next year and my request would be this would you put out a call to existing teachers in the district asking if anyone would want to teach the second third combo class for family school next year then if the budget increases for the 2026 2027 year rehire a K1 teacher to reinstate Carpenteria Family School to to its full status thank [Applause] you um hello my name is leas Fury Palm I attended family school for half my life and I was a gate student from 3rd to fifth grade and

028um I would just like to say that family school was a great experience for me and I really think that it should stay open because otherwise um students and children who are in the elementary age wouldn't have the same opportunities open for them and honestly it was probably the best years of my life and like I really enjoyed it I really enjoyed the school and the experience I have some friends who went to canalino and it just didn't sound like the same thing as family school and I know many consider family school and Keno to be the same thing because they're on the same campus but it honestly isn't they're very they're very different like what's the word they're very different um like experiences and honestly like if Kino was solely on that campus I

029don't think it would be the same thing and I don't think you would have the same amount of enrollment thank you thank you uh whoever is next please just just come up to the podium and just keep going person after person thank you hello my name is Robin Bodwin and I'm the parent of a kindergarten student at Carpenteria family school I was shocked to hear superintendent riggy's CL plan to close family school and discontinue the gate program first I feel it's important to note that as a community funded District your revenue is not tied to enrollment so the emphasis on budget conversations about declining enrollment seems to be a red herring that's Justus used to justify budget mismanagement you are using the Public's misunderstanding of our funding model to imply that budget shortfalls are a

030product are are a product of enrollment putting aside the budget question and focusing on the health of the district declining enrollment is a problem if you are trying to manage the loss of students growing going to Charter private and homeschool options these decisions do exactly the opposite of what you should be doing you should be shouting from the rooftops that you have this great program called family school that encourages parents to participate actively in their children's education without having to take on the burden of homeschooling parents in this District are looking for choice they want their students to be inspired and engaged in their learning and increasingly they are not finding what they are looking for in our public schools I can tell you from conversations I've had with other families of young children that

031many are are looking outside the public system by killing both the gate program and the family school you are doing exactly the opposite of providing engaging programs and choices for how our children learn you will only lose more students you lose you will lose many many of the students who cannot afford and the population who will lose the most from the closure of the gate program are the gifted Pro children from underprivileged families those families who can afford it will either find a new school to provide enrich or provide enrichment in other ways for students from low-income families public school is their only Avenue for intellectual growth and Challenge and those students are just as important as those on the opposite end of the Spectrum in trying to save a pittance and $2,000 200,000 is

032a pittance I have more to say but you don't want to hear good evening board members and everyone present tonight my name is Rachel Kent and I'm a parent of first grader Caspian and TK rean both at calino school last year Caspian was in Mrs oda's first um K1 Family School class and this year he's in Mrs B's class with the other first grade family school kids I'm speaking tonight in solidarity with the other family school parents proposing to allow the second third grade class in hopes to continue the KP family school for next year it's clear that there are inevitable budget cuts and I would ask the board to reconsider the recommendation to dissolve the third second third grade class if I could share one takeaway theme from my comment tonight it would be

033the power and opportunity of public school choice we are so lucky do you know how unique and rare it is to have a model like the carp Family School in a public school district two years ago at this time as a first-time mother of a lug Grant preschooler I sat in a room full of other parents hearing choices and preparing to make decisions about our little humans embarking on the next big milestone of Life kindergarten we had the gift of a preschool that invited parents of various kindergarten programs to speak at our evening parenting class I heard about KP Family School met other parents who s their kids to the school spoke with our preschool director about her knowledge of those schools and how they messed with what she knew about our son then later

034I toured the family school and began to see a path forward through the unknowns and my anxiety of navigating through the available options without knowing how this power and opportunity of family school would unfold we took the chance and decided as a family we know what's right this year in this moment and last year um our our time at Family School was everything we hoped for and more we received a built-in community of like-minded parents eager to volunteer and to be Hands-On with our child's education creating spaces for them to explore Beyond The Four Walls of the building I would like to ask you to preserve the gift we have in karp family school thank you okay sorry [Applause] good evening my name is Scott lanet um my son and daughter went through family school

035years ago um they have they absolutely thrived from their uh ability to navigate through the world both of them um my daughter graduated uh some l and a devil major from UC Berkeley my son is now in the world's foremost uh data science program at UC Berkeley uh my there's a lot more to that they've accomplished but what I've noticed is who they are as people they participate they Foster Community wherever they go They're not afraid to be a part of things they know how to connect to people of all kinds of backgrounds and histories and styles they're capable of being full partic participants in this world and they care I think when you're balancing budgets you need to think very carefully about whether or not you're balancing people that's all I have to say

036thank [Applause] you hello my name is arum Freeman um a a father of a fourth grader in family currently Eden and uh first of all before I make my offthe cuff remark um she as I quote says family school is really great unquote I would like to Second those feelings and give a little more detail in that she's been a family school student from kindergarten in Co straight through and has been benefited greatly in more ways than I can mention a lot of which have been mentioned prior and I was just made aware of this situation recently by my daughter because word has been going around I just found out about the gate situation she's also a member of that program and is thriving under that situation as well um I'd like to Echo the

037sentiment and the belief that there is a way forward even if we do not currently see it at this moment I think in any difficult situation we can work together and find a solution maybe one that is not currently on the table I think to benefit our future Generations is probably the most important thing we can do as uh stewards of our children thank you thank you uh my name is Ryan moral uh I want to thank the board for hearing everything that we've had to say tonight uh and I want to thank all the families uh School uh parents and children who have got up and spoke in front of you as well um it's not an easy thing to come up in front of uh people and speak publicly um I just like

038to start by saying um I'm Carpenter Maria born and raised uh my family's been here since the late '70s and I'm a product of the carpentry Unified School District um I'm still here and I think that that is what everyone here wants uh is to build community and I think that that's really what family school does is it builds community and it keeps Community here and if we can't have community at our school and we just go through Through the Motions we're losing a little bit of carp and I think it's really important to take the ideals that family school stands for uh Community Family involvement um and get being exposed to the students families um that they normally wouldn't get exposed to uh on family Friday in particular um one of the students mentioned

039the camp out the camp out's a great opportunity for for bonding outside of the school um but back to the school I think that it's building community and that's really what we need here uh in Carpenteria um to keep our Our Town carp so thank you thank [Applause] you hi my name is pepper Binkley we're new to the district uh we made a very quick snap decision to move here after my husband got a job in Thousand Oaks and looked up and down between Thousand Oaks and Santa Barbara for the right place for our family and landed here partially because of the family school so my daughter's in the DLI program she's in first grade she's thriving she loves it she loves the Greater canalino Community my son is like uh a more sensitive creature

040and last year was in a class of seven with two teachers when we lived on an island uh when he turned around like the second or third day of school he came back and said Mama there are two more tables of children in the room than I realized and this is at family school so family school has provided a space for him to be in a mixed AG classroom which is what he was used to last year and uh to be seen in a space where often times when he goes out into the greater canalo campus he feels at Sea it feels huge to him um the mix stage classroom is intentional it's a space where the teachers and the students get to know each other over a couple of years and not only that

041when they move into the next class they get to go back and check in with their old teachers so it's a it's a place where kids are learning in a different way so the the public school system provides one way usually the traditional Elementary the mixage classroom over the course of two years uh provides a space for the students to grow and learn in a different way it's an alternative and it's an alternative I hope that you'll preserve thank [Applause] you take your time Lori hi I'm Lori Lee Collins I teach at Carpenteria family school and I love all of you I hope you all take it to heart to consider all options I really do I love absolutely adore what I love and David the other day when our meeting with um superintendent Rigby

042I said I've given so much for it's 22 years um and David reminded me you've received so much and all of us have we've sang You songs we've own plays but it's about the community it really is and we're all doing this together and I inv you to please consider all the options out there and I love and adore what I do and um I'm hoping I can keep doing it for all of you so thanks a lot thank you [Applause] Lori hi there I'm here to remind you that the people people behind me are our community our children that our teachers are currently growing and making these amazing relationships and love of education and you are devaluing them by not giving them what they need to survive and stay in our district to continue

043building these relationships two weeks ago Angel spoke he is a poised young man ready for the world because his parents put him in carp and the teachers in Carpenteria have nurtured him along with his family and the team of support to turn him into the next future leader that we need you need to Value all the app parents opinions of the teachers that they have now just said are amazing human beings that are developing lifelong Learners and give them their living wage and health benefits because if you don't help them with the benefits you're effectively giving them no increase I want to challenge you when was the last time you were in a special education classroom for more than one hour and watch those amazing humans work those magic with multi-age multifunctional and adults in

044the room or attended a high school science class where kids are mixing formulas and you're praying to God they do not blow up the school or in a junior high with raging hormones and spend time not in your child's classroom but other children's classroom more than an hour and left a note that said oh my God you're amazing thank you for doing your job if you haven't you're not doing your job as our board members and you need to be done because you need to be around and visible you need to have time in our community I know your kids go here but what are you doing to support these kids my kids who I need to turn into Future Leaders like that kid take care of our teachers so they can take care of

045our kids and themselves especially during cold and flu season do it now settle the lawsuits [Applause] you thank you so um I serve as the employee union president in carpentera Unified School District and deliver the following comments on behalf of District employees who elected both myself and the members of our Union leadership team to share their experiences questions and concerns why were Educators and community members marching downtown on Friday because contract negotiations remain at impass and throughout the district has demonstrated a utter lack of commitment to the process even refusing to join employee union leadership at any of the scheduled mediation sessions nonetheless employees still seek a reasonable good faith agreement that includes the most basic safety improvements for students and employees that defends employee healthc care a pillar of economic stability that brings similar

046stability to our students we're focused on meaningful salary increases as well to relieve the rapidly rising cost of living increases that threaten to further destabilize the workforce and importantly we seek an agreement that includes contingency language we seek an agreement that anticipates and prepares for future economic uncertainties and positions both employees and District officials to be rowing in the same direction instead of arguing in 20 months the usd's best offer remains 2% 2% for teachers and 2 and a half for district support staff and this while administrators gave themselves two salary increases during the same period working directly uh while during the same period while those working directly with the students and families received none despite robust property tax revenues cusd continues to prioritize Reckless administrative spending while underfunding essential employee positions and programs like

047the gate and family school programs that you're talking about cutting right now this is further evidenced in CD's annual audit released in December which confirmed that cusd underpaid employees by a staggering three and a half plus Million last year $3.5 million is equivalent to a 177% pay increase for All District employees but it could also be used to maintain obviously beneficial programs thank you let me translate briefly uh Jak hner uh comment roado Carpenter resident this is what he said in Spanish J hner l EC that's his comment now I would like to provide my own okay uh public comment please restart the clock for his personal comment thank you okay my own two parts okay first part I think all the teachers like would like to thank superintendent Ruby the board for all the

048kids that went to grammar school middle school high school and uh attending City College that's good 50% of graduates go City College and then transfer that's good that's due to the promise for two years there there are no no fees paid and they later on they transfer to uh the UC system transfer to private colleges you see bir for example or examp Stanford JL MIT Columbia Harvard and they are now the teachers the professionals that we know lawyers teachers doctors accountants that's very good now the other side is health budget will improve teacher salaries student programs and the quality of life the current problem is that you spending Millions on legal fees that cannot happen that's not right you're misusing the community's money that you handed down that budget and that money should be spent

049on students and teachers not on uh attorneys not L uh the March okay thank you thank [Applause] you hello I'm Susan bacon Frederickson I teach at Aliso and uh I just wanted to Reit I was here in January speaking to you all um basically saying uh that our teachers support our Union and as you could see um if you were you know aware of the march on Friday that uh there were approximately 100 uh employees from Aliso uh Carpenteria um the Middle School in the high school all very frustrated with the fact that uh our Union we do support our Union our union represents us we want um the district to negotiate with our Union in good faith we want the district to end the impass we really um you know property taxes continue to

050go up property values continue to go up there should be a solution where we're able to compensate um interact fairly with our Union and compensate our teachers thank you very much thank you hi I'm Crystal geretti I'm a second generation born and raised carpentera um I'm also a former CD and Gates student of the district and I also have um family members both former and current in the district as well so the um issues being raised are very personal to me um I'm also a master's level clinician um in mental health so I have a unique perspective to offer on this I wanted to discuss tonight the topics of social awareness and impact paraphrasing a passage by clinician and author Dr Alexander K kakas we repress our natural compassion we blind ourselves to the humanity

051of those we encounter and choose to see as merely cogs in a wheel this causes our objectification to rebound onto US leaving us feel dis us feeling disconnected for healthy transformation is Possible only through shared Humanity treating others as fellow humans personally by imagining how we'd like to be treated in their place humanizes our whole being and invites expect unexpected breakthroughs if you are truly listening to all the voices speaking up you will hear Collective fear stress and financial burden all the while Administration has received two back-to-back raises while the certified and classified employees have received none since the end of the 2023 school year finally I want to end on the notion of impact that this is all having paraphrasing again we influence our world and one another through our words and actions the

052lasting impact of our actions on others or our surroundings can be Monumental or minuscule known to us or not so I implore each and every school board member to consider the impact your actions and words have on District employees students and their families and try to reconcile that with the impact that each of you intended to make when you decided to join the board originally thank you thank you hi my name's Maddy Maple you guys already know me and for some of the family school parents who didn't know me I started at family school so I got my start in the district actually teaching K1 at Family School I wasn't planning on speaking tonight at all but hearing all of these parents I 100% agree with them coming from family school I couldn't agree more

053that the option for choice is so essential but what I hate to tell family at large is that if we are not compensating our teachers fairly we cannot continue choices of like programs of choice I know it personally almost every single teacher that I know who isn't married who isn't a dual- income household has at least two jobs and I know my position where I teaching four sections of art art one art to Art honors art AP in every single classroom in you are not going to find another one of me again and like I can go to many other districts and get paid much more money for much less work I am here because I want to be because I love this community I love your guys as kids and that's why I'm here

054and I would really wish that you guys would consider as mentioned before if our budget's not based on declining student enrollment then our declining student enrollment might be based on the mismanagement of our [Applause] [Music] [Applause] budget uh hello ladies and gentlemen um my name is Julie Rubio shamblin and I am born and raised in carpent FIA that's my big Flex in life honestly everywhere I go I start with that line so something that's really near and dear to my heart I also born and raised here went through carpent Unified School District I'd like to share a a poem that I created it's titled is this really how we do things in carpentera is this really how we do things in carpentera where those who teach who guide who care are forced to fight for

055what is fair while empty promises fill the air is this really how we do things in Carpenteria where audits expose the district's neglect yet still no progress no respect no raises no contract just delays how long must we live this way born and raised in this Hometown space so much magical history in this place yet morale has never felt so low such a disgrace how far will this go the law is clear yet here we stand and underpaid with empty hands California EDS code says invest but cusd gives us less and less is this really how we do things in Carpenteria where legal fees climb skyh high yet those who lift our students up are left behind left asking why teachers are exhausted worn too thin many already searching where to begin again how many

056more will pack and leave but in the end it's the students who grieve why don't you think I deserve what is fair why ignore my loyalty my years of care I've given my heart to this town to these kids yet your appreciation is silenced instead union leaders stand to fight to keep our classroom strong and bright they seek Solutions not divide yet still they're met with closed door Pride a strike would tear this town apart disrupt the learning break our hearts yet when you push good teachers down how long before they leave this town thank you any further public comment for items that are not on tonight's agenda okay seeing none um if you'd like to stay obviously you're welcome to otherwise we're going to carry on and feel free to to leave either way

057um okay we are moving on to C4 approval of the minutes um public comment on C4 oh sorry C4 approval uh yeah yeah no there are two approvals of the minutes this time please uh back to back to three thank you so let the minutes show that work conducted during the January 16th special board meeting resulted in the 2526 CD budget presentation on January 28th let the minute show that while District officials determined what services would be cut they made these decisions without the inclusion of a single employee representative teacher or support staff at the table let the minutes show that superintendent Rigby has since confirmed that due to C usd's extraordinary legal expenses in the last two years which include $2.5 million in expenditures and another 1 million in acred debt due shortly cusd

058will now be making several cuts to student centered programs and resources let the minutes show that although District officials stated they have targeted Cuts far from the classroom as far as possible the cusd intends to cut funding for all elementary field trips to reduce 10 instructional assistance and four full-time teachers driving up class sizes and reducing direct academic support for at risk special ed El and migrant students uh to cut the elementary GATE program uh it won't be reduced it will be removed altogether and CFS which is already receiving 44% less Revenue per pupil funding than the state average and they're going to experience even further prog programmatic erosions if they even remain open yet from the budget study session there was no mention of reductions of district office staff administrators which have reached all-time

059highs even though student enrollment is at a 20-year low while cusd invests prop approximately 20 to 30% less than the state average for per for per pupil spending and approximately 5% more on administrative salaries the district does not intend to make any cuts to Administration instead the 2025 budget maintains the two salary increases given to District administrators During the 20-month period employees have received zero and let the minutes show that c USD is considering just a 15% reduction in legal fees which will ensure the district intends to spend no less than a million dollar in legal fees in 2526 a figure still seven times more than what you inherited when you arrived Miss Rigby in short let the minutes show that the 2526 budget priorities Miss Brig and our board's obsession with continued retaliatory discriminatory

060dis disciplinary attacks against elected employee leaders are all baked into that budget all the while cutting critical student centered programs and resources finally let the minutes show that when the decisions of the January 16th board meeting were shared with the community not a single board member asked superintendent Rigby how she prioritized CD's legal attacks over the very programs gate Carpenteria Family School the things you heard the community talking about so dearly this evening that have demonstrably proven to have a positive impact on student achievement and your time is up Mr Delgado will translate kindly thank you thank you super a gate superintendent Gia thank you any further public comments on the minutes okay um may I get a motion to approve the minutes I'll move to approve the minutes as presented of we got to

061say oh the minutes of uh January 16th 2025 and January 28th 2025 okay um any discussion oh second yeah we need a second all second discussion okay uh all in favor I um approval of the agenda and consent agenda uh public comment on approval of the agenda and consent agenda uh actually hang on yes I have um I do need to striet the Aliso presentation um so just note that uh any motion when it comes will be with the removal of the Aliso School presentation public comment on the agenda you also had the minutes of the January 28th meeting that you haven't addressed yet I yes we did I yeah we did yeah we did we did the minutes we I said we're having public comment on approval of the minutes you you covered January

06216th is what you stated I didn't State a a date I said the approval of the minutes okay so this is public comment time is that correct yes so right now we are on C5 approval of the agenda and consent agenda the consent agenda as with the rest of the board meeting is governed by the brown Act and the brown Act is designed to prevent the advancement of public Business Without transparency it's designed to provide members of the community an opportunity to more thoroughly consider details associated with matters of District business before those matters are quickly processed through the consent agenda uh but for items specified on the closed session agenda the brown Act prohib iits District officials from reaching 100% consensus decisions behind closed doors um the way you're handling now every item on

063the on the board agenda is now like the consent agenda only giving members of the community three minutes to comment regardless of whether there's 10 15 three or two items on the agenda under that item uh anyhow setting aside our concerns associated with the district's Brown act violations which are routine employees strongly support item one and two both are field trip requests for elementary and secondary students these are exactly the types of expenditures that cusd intends to cut next year while hoping that private organizations can and will fund these out of the blue employees recognize some benefit to item three the approval of the agreement between cusd and Cal State Channel Islands the agreement places student teachers with Master Teachers in our district for the next three years although some benefit to item three is

064recognized there remains a significant concern on how CD will use these student teachers and how the district students uh and how District students future instruction will be undermined and their achievement jeopardized we've already uh had um heard of significant concerns and seen significant concerns associated with the misuse and misassignment of student teachers in both the teaching and learning environment and even when providing confidential counseling services and we've asked the board to demand answers to these concerns where CD underst staffs classrooms with those not credentialed or capable of delivering high quality instruction but this is the price we pay when we drive teachers and support staff out of the district for the variety of reasons including the workplace culture the abusive management from Miss Rigby and some of her select leaders um as well as the

065problems with compensation employees asked the board to place item six on hold and not approved the purchase of iPads to be used for the CHS outreach program just yet it it is not that we believe the students don't need those resources but rather CMS is in the process of removing all such devices from CMS students that was announced by Miss persoon just the other day rather than buying all new advices all new devices at the cost of approximately gosh knows what um I believe it's $88,500 for these high school devices perhaps the USD should consider reusing using some of the hundreds of handheld devices that have already been been invested in and are now being removed from middle school students any further public comment on approval of the agenda and consent agenda okay seeing none

066uh may I get a oh I'll make a motion to approve the agenda and consent agenda while striking um E3 the Aliso presentation all right I'll second that uh all roll call roll call thanks Eric hi Aon hi Sally hi Jamie hi I'm I hey we are moving on to our student representative Report with Angel hello uh for those of you who sorry apologies public comment on the stupid student Representatives report on all the sorry on all the reports on E public comment on E public interest reports and presentations if you'd like to make public comment on any of the items under e please step up to the podium at this time to do so sorry Angel with only three minutes we'll have to focus on just one of the several uh topics that are

067under e um property tax presentation when will The District's budget take into account the impact of property 19 property tax valuation increases and why did cusd use countywide property tax averages as a basis for future tax projections instead of the more realistic property tax revenues predicted for Carpenter alone which are predicted to be higher these decisions further demonstrate the district's long pattern of underfunding pro under projecting future revenues while over projecting future expenditures and for this reason employees continue to encourage the inclusion of a contingency formula to resolve our negotiation impass we don't need to argue over the accuracy of the district projections as long as we have prepared for the day when the actual dollars and cents are counted and arrive and when that day comes if contingency plans are in place we will

068either win together or lose together based on the actual dollars we receive just imagine everyone rowing in the same direction versus the same old management through conflict approach which has become the Hallmark of this current District leadership team for those unaware property taxes are the primary revenue source for cusd because we are a basic Aid District the cusd receives the majority of its revenues from local property taxes it is that that Ur occurs is actually an enormous benefit to cusd we sit in the top 4% of the most robustly funded TK through 12 districts in the state here's a point of comparison over the last 6 years 96% of districts in the state received primary funding paid to the state Cola and that value that they received was 21.8% over a 6-year period however cusd

069a basic Aid District received 35.226 in Revenue increases for the same 6-year period 135% more than 96% of the districts in the state in school year 1920 96% of the districts received 3 .26 and we received 5.04 in 2021 when they received zero Cola we received 5.6 in Revenue increases in 2122 when they received 96% of the districts in the state receiv received 2.7 we received 5.14 and in the current year for example 2425 when 96% of the districts in the state received just over 1% we received over 5% % again in the last 6 years cusd received 35.226 per of the rest received just 21.8 yet District officials are attempting to justify C usd's inability to effectively manage finances is ridiculous your time is up any further public comment Ro carpentry uh resident uh

070about the superintendence report students are not doing as good as official reports indicates for example students at canalino are written only at 40% at Leist only 4% met the great level standards special education even lower much much lower students students who are behind on test scores have a hard time getting into the UC system that's a f fact students are not to blame it's the district's way of handling academics thank you okay um I just want to I'm not sure if there was some confusion but in the star reading assessment that's the the grade level that the number it's not a percentage um unless I misunderstood what um so um anyways uh any further public comment on E okay we will now move to our student representative Report with Angel thanks hello my name is

071Angel pineta for those of you who don't know me in this room I'm a carpenter High School senior and I'm also the senior class president doing this on my own time so for my St report please join me in congratulating our winter teams who are going to the playoffs for their individual sports with girls soccer they're playing St Monica prep at home tomorrow Wednesday at 5:00 p.m. the winner will play on Friday against the winner of sugar storm versus Malibu boys basketball plays at Bishop Garcia Diego at The Brick House on Wednesday at 7:00 p.m. the winner will play on Friday against the winner of paloma Valley versus Santa Clarita Christian girls basketball plays at Santa Ana on Thursday at 700 p.m. the winner will play on Saturday against the winner of Charter Oaks vs

072Bell Gardens today is also the spring a spring Athletics parent meeting at 6 in the cafeteria at carpent high school on January 29th and 30th carpentry High School Host hosted parents and students of the incoming ninth grade parents parents and students were able to learn about the many programs offered at carpentry high school and were able to hear about carpentry high school students from the 12th grade panel ASB also had a successful student rally on Thursday of last week to celebrate the Su successes of all winter sports I also want to congratulate miss Emily Garcia the FFA adviser and our amazing FFA team for their per outstanding performances on Saturday February 8th at Santa Paula high school carpon FFA is part of the Ventura section of Agriculture schools which include Filmore Ventura nordoff Camario Santa

073Paula and Ventura on Saturday the Ventura section hosted a public speaking contest event consisting of seven categories decreed decreed in Spanish impromptu prepared public speaking extemporaneous public speaking and job interview out of those seven categories we had a winner in four of them nine of those students will be able to compete in the next competition in early March in King City um representing the Ventura section don't forget this Friday February 14th is Lincoln's Birthday and Monday February 17th is President's Day which our days off thank you very much thank you Angel appreciate that any comments from the board for Angel's report are you part of that team yes I was placed I placed first place in the extemporaneous public speaking congratul congratulations that doesn't surprise me at all we're proud of you great job thank

074you okay we are now moving on to the superintendent report thank you tonight I'd like to with appreciation and I'd like to recognize our school counselors for supporting our students staff and families throughout the school year Rebecca Carlile is at Aliso Summerland shanana harget and Patricia humbles are at canalino and family school Megan krook and Stephanie stall at the middle school and Julie Bravo Alfredo Martinez and Marlo stups at the high school National School counseling week is February 3rd through the 7th and it focuses public attention on the unique contribution of school counselors within the US school systems the theme is School counseling helping students Thrive National School counseling week presented by ASA highlights the tremendous impact school counselors can have in helping students achieve School Success my next item is Elementary reading and math

075progress and you'll see that it's measured by the star reading assessment and it is presented by grade levels so at third grade at this time of year we expect all our students to be reading at 3.6 and math at 3.6 at fourth grade it's 4.6 fifth grade 5.6 so uh we're pleased to report that more than 60% of our elementary students are performing at grade level or higher in both math and reading as measured by the first semester star reading and math assessments our next item is regarding the fmac report that's fiscal crisis and management assistance they've published childhood sexual assault fiscal implications for California public agencies on January 31st outlining the fiscal challenges that California school districts and public agencies are now facing since the passage of ab218 which is the child victims act

076it was passed in 2019 signed by Governor Nome this bill changed the statute of limitations for civil claims of childhood sexual assault and California school districts community colleges cities counties and other public agencies have been significantly impacted the report reviews the financial burdens and fiscal impacts on these agencies and also includes recommendations for future funding and financing mechanism cusd has four uninsured ab218 claims from the 1970s that will go to trial next year our next item is accreditation review at the high school School Carpenter high school has been engaged in a comprehensive 2-year self-study process in preparation for an upcoming accreditation review this process involved a thorough examination of VAR aspects of school life including Gathering valuable insights from all members of the school Community examining student academic performance attendance and other relevant data assessing

077the effectiveness of various programs and services offered by the school and identifying areas of excellence and are where further Improvement is needed the culmination of this self-study will be a full sight visit by the Western Association of schools and colleges on March 10th through the 12th our next item is about our CHS students who are very excited about the 2425 mock trial program at carpentera high school the mock trial team consists of 22 students led by CHS teacher advisors Peter cotti and Trevor Orlando and attorney coach Maryanne Weiss esire Esquire the county competition will be held at Santa Barbara Superior Courthouse on February 22nd ebike and bike safety we have seen an increase in student Riders on bikes and ebikes without helmets at both the middle school and the high school this is a huge

078safety risk and parents need to require their students to wear a helmet before permitting this bike riding the CHP has excellent resources on ebike and bike safety and there's a website sitee that they can link to fall 2025 TK and K registration our information meeting will be held on Thursday February 20th at canalino school 5:15 for the English session 6 o'cl for the Spanish session online registration begins on March 1st for all students who will be 5 years old on or before September 1st for kindergarten and then for all those students who are four years old and will have their fifth birthday by September 1st 2026 they can register for transitional kindergarten and then our last item is measure you our the DSA has received the uh the design documents from our architect Robert roblas

079for the new T tkk building at Aliso and once we have DSA approval we will begin the process for selecting the contractor thanks thank you any questions or comments from the board okay we are moving on to our property tax presentation we have Trev Trevor lysc CPA Advanced revenue and Tax Administration with Santa Barbara County auditor Controllers Office to give us a presentation thank you thanks sure oh thank you oh very good okay uh good evening uh chair diamond and board members superintendent um superintendent's office asked me to come down here and give a presentation um I know there's at least uh one new member here so um I've kept a lot of the background information that we've had before um I'll try and go through it pretty quickly in the interest of your time

080but feel free to stop me if I'm going too fast ask any questions you might have um so uh as announced my name is Trevor lysc I the division chief for the advanced Revenue uh and Tax Administration division of the auditor controller's office and with me is Ed Price the assistant auditor controller we both work for Betsy M Schaefer the uh elected auditor controller um and so let's see see if I can work this um we're going to talk go through a little bit of uh overview on how the property tax process works and some of the components of it and then I know there were questions about revenue and revenue growth so we'll eventually get to that Everyone likes to talk about n Prop 19 these days so have a little bit on that

081and then see if you guys have any questions um so first of all this is like a 30,000 foot view of the process um so you know the the process is really driven by property owners um we buy and sell properties all the time and uh you know start new businesses maybe put an addition on the back of the house so forth this changes uh the this triggers reassessment of the property so as those things happen the assessor collects that information through various channels um and they go about assessing uh or reassessing the value of those properties when that data is sent to us we then extend the role that is multiply the value times the appropriate tax rate and then as you can see on the right hand side of that graph we do

082get information uh data from uh various uh schools and District Special Districts um with fixed charges those are special assessments that are added onto the property tax bill um we forward that to the tax collector who uh puts on their website and mails you out your tax bill and then which you promptly pay because you love to pay your taxes and that comes back to uh the treasure tax collector they send that back to us and then it's our job to divy that money up to you all and the rest of the districts and the cities and everybody else in the county as well as the county general fund um so there's a I'm not going to go through every detail here but the basic timeline is January 1st is the lean date each year

083and we value properties based on what is the value on that date um and so at January 1st starts the assessment process for the assessor they're catching up and so right now during this period they are catch catching up on properties that have transferred ownership new businesses that have started um and new construction that has occurred and they're uh they're obligated to turn over that assessment role to to our office uh by June 30th um so that's what's going on right now and then um the first thing we do when we get that is we start working on the unsecured role and this is businesses um planes uh boats and we assess those get the bills out as soon as we can towards the end of July and those are due in August um by

084about August 10th um the we combine the local secured rule so this is real property along with the state assessed utilities and so these are things like pg& uh Telecom you know um cell towers a variety of things that are there's many properties and we wouldn't want to send out a thousand bills for you know a pipeline or power lines coming through so the state assesses that in a unified way as we call it the unitary role and they send us one value for the county so we incorporate that in with the secured role and it's built so there's the local secured role our properties here as well as the state assessed properties we put those together that's what we call the equalized role and that's what ultimately ends up in the annual uh secured

085tax bill we also as as I said add the fixed charges onto that um during August we're calculating the bond tax rates primarily um the uh typically the Board of Supervisors approves that by about the beginning of September um also during that time we're coming up with Revenue estimates for you all and other districts and cities throughout the county um and then the tax bills go out by October um and we collect those as you probably know your tax bills are delinquent if not paid by December 10th and the second installment on April 10th so under Prop 13 um there's really four key uh Provisions to that the first one is a basic 1% tax rate um for the State uh or you know properties can't exceed the the 1% um there's tax roll maintenance

086so um you know the initial base started with the 7576 values and that gets increased every year what the assessor calls f factoring those properties up um so that increase can't uh uh exceed 2% or see the uh the lesser of 2% or CPI uh each year unless there is a u you know new construction or transfer of the property and uh let's see if to increase any taxes at a state level there needs to be a 2third vote um and if there are local taxes uh or assessments those increases need to be approved by 2/3 uh vote of the electorate there are some Provisions for school bonds where it can pass with 55% if certain conditions are met and there are um different tax rules there's secured Rule and the unitary rule which we

087discussed earlier um there's two installments delinquent December 10th and um April 10th there's a supplemental rule so when properties are transferred during the year year or there's new construction um that value will be assessed and uh uh tax charges assessed for that remaining portion of the year and if we're already past the lean date and so the value is determined for the upcoming year we'll also send out a tax bill for that increase in value for the upcoming years um and that's why that bullet point there that you might have two bills depending on the event date there's also the unsecured rule uh which is a single installment due on August 31st and then Tax Administration basically we Levy we uh calculate those levies and essentially create the bills each year um as new uh

088construction comes in or as their as the assessor discovers any corrections that they need to make um which M which can uh result in increased tax bills would also result in refunds we're processing those throughout the year and then as the money is collected um each quarter we distribute that money out to the cities the school districts Special Districts throughout the county um as well as at other times for cash flow purposes we'll do estimated distributions so you'll see those for example in uh November in December um whereas otherwise we're doing the actual distributions uh following September 30th and December 31st and so forth and then there's various reporting that we have to do with um you guys are probably familiar with a basic tax bill and those values appear up towards the top um

089you see what the taxes that are calculated sort of in the middle and you can see the breakdown of the uh basic 1% tax the various School bonds that are associated with a bill uh this one's not from your District um and fixed charges added on there as well and just go through there um shortly after Prop 13 passed in 1978 um assembly Bill 8 what that we just shortly refer to as AB8 um tried to create a mechanism for Distributing the taxes and it was based on the 19 uh 7879 Revenue amounts that various districts got so if you were inefficient spent a lot of money had a huge budget based on the old system you had a higher Revenue amount at that time if you were more efficient it was lower you're kind

090of stuck with that lower Revenue amount that has then factored forward all the way to present based on various changes um it introduced the concept of uh tax rate areas which you can think of as just all the overlapping areas of various so you have cities school districts sanitation districts fire districts all these little districts that overlap and every one of those little spaces in between is a tax rate area essentially it's comprised of the various tax rates allocable to each one of those districts and that's how we come up with the uh that's how we split the money that basic one% tax money that's received and it ties the the the aim is to tie the allocation of the property taxes to the assessed value based on that area so and because of that

091you can you can see growth determined in those areas uh it's based on the actual growth of property value within those specific tax tax rate areas and what we do as so as we identify the growth within those are within the tax rate areas we then sum up the the allocable amount of Revenue in each area by jurisdiction so say your school district and then that becomes the amount of uh the incremental additional revenue for your district and then we come up with AB8 factors which we then use to apply to all the taxes that are received in the county was there a question yeah is so is there is there a um a signed rate so so the in these tax rate areas um what percentage of that Revenue uh is assigned to the

092school district to carp unified yeah I'm just so so like I mean the area is broken up into a number of different Special Districts right but generally I know we share the revenue with fire and fire and the and the and carp fire carp suland fire and the and the school district more or less are a similar area uh geographic area and I'm just curious because I've I've been looking and I know the rate the the applied rate um varies from County to County uh of how much like the revenue derived total revenue 1% revenue of the of the of the assess the ad valum tax what percentage of that is a sign to the school or does the school district get yeah unfortunately I don't know that percentage off the top of my head

093in fact I was sitting back here waiting going you know I should have grabbed that number there the presentation and I didn't uh what I can tell you is again based on the revenue that the district received and this is compared to all of the other governmental entities in general districts cities and so forth what was received back in 19 19 7879 that as a as a portion of the whole uh an allocation Factor allocation percentages were developed at that time and So within a tax rate area there is a percent um that would say you know so say if in this particular location right here if we were in a tax rate area that had the city of KP uh mon uh carp Summerland fire uh carp sand and and the school district let's

094say each one of those is assigned a a percentage of allocation and that remains constant and then each year when there is growth of property values within that area the P that that percentage is applied to the amount of growth and that's added to last year's revenue and then that's taken let's say if this school district spans across half a dozen in different tax rate areas that amount of incremental revenue for each one of those areas are summed up to find out what the incremental revenue is added to Prior Year's revenue and then that amount as taken as a whole for the entire uh County tax levy is then that that's where we get the that factor that we then apportion the rates I don't know what that number is off the top my head

095but I can get it back to you I've been yeah it'd be great if you could I I I just I've been you know it's really diff I mean it's hard to find the number anywhere online but it it what I've been able to kind of derive is that it's anywhere from 54 to 57% of of the of the tax rate area Revenue gets assigned to the schools and I I I know that that varies but but that that's am I in the ballpark there well well that's sort of a different thing and I actually do have a a slide that sort of that sort of identifies that um there's a confusing mix of of percentages and factors that go into it so what I'm speaking of is a factor that we derive so that

096every dollar that comes into the County Treasury as collected taxes is then a portioned out so we take everything from here to Santa Maria and it gets dumped in a bucket well actually several buckets but then each quarter we apply factors to the those secured taxes uh the AB8 factors to the secured taxes there's different factors for the different roles we apply that to that countywide and then that chunk of money is what comes to your District um you're saying that number yeah this is where it gets confusing the within each tax rate area the the allocation percent remains uh static but the AB8 factor that is derived from all the incremental growth changes every year so that percentage is a small percentage and and it might be a fraction of a percent or it

097might be 5% I I honestly don't remember what your number would be and I wish I had looked at that one but again that's a percentage of the entire tax collections for the county yeah but that that's a very small percentage of our Revenue I'm I'm speaking specifically of of the of the the the properties within the bounds of our school district that that um the the is it further in okay yeah so I think this might be sort of what you're asking so when when the and this is really countywide but this this might be akin to what you're asking and you can see there of all the taxes that are collected approximately 49% U as of this year is going to uh school districts again that's countywide that's not your District uh specifically

098as a percentage that that I've seen that figure and that doesn't that's not really getting I'm asking yeah well um we can go back to you can continue yeah let me just uh go through and and we can if there's um I can provide information at uh as a followup we can send it to to Jason he can get it to you guys uh let's see Bond tax rates um back to just sort of procedure here so the bond tax rates um you know when there are new school bonds uh new issuances refundings of those that data comes to us we calculate um what those rates are going to be um we try to achieve um I if any of you are familiar with how those go but often they have big principal payments in

099one year low principal payments the next year and so they can go up and down we try to get uh uh smooth tax rates over the life of the bond to the tax pairs um so we try to build a reserve so that we can do that um we can exceed the ballot so when the when the ballot goes to uh the voters uh it will it will state a a uh a a maximum tax rate on there um and typically it'll explain that that's a basically a suggested maximum rate for the first year um as time goes on if for whatever reason based on not as much growth as anticipated if necessary to uh satisfy The Debt Service we can exceed those maximum rates but we always try and keep it under there if

100we can that's pretty uncommon uh that that occurs it it does in some cases but um let's see there can be unanticipated drops in in valuation um sometimes the the growth we expect doesn't doesn't occur um and as I yeah yeah covered the reserves um so some things that are specific to carp unified um uh carp carp beautified participates in the Teeter plan which um the Teeter plan is something that was um proposed way back in the 1930s um and but as of the 90s uh many counties started adopting it we did um carp unified participates and essentially what that is factoring receivables for you know in in most private sectors speak essentially there are some you know when there are uh unpaid taxes we go ahead and pay the district the full amount of

101your Levy by the end of each year or follow the end of each year and then we take the county takes on the burden of collecting the unpaid taxes and uh and so forth sorry just real quick um so you say we participate in the Teeter as though we have a choice like it's not there's not like something else we could be doing aside from lcf like it's to be a basic Aid District in s County we are in Teeter you that is how it is perod you could elect uh so at some point the district elected to participate in that yeah um you could El not to uh and then it would be the district's obligation to follow up on unpaid taxes and uh I mean or rather let me let me rephrase that

102that I didn't say that well we would continue to collect on the bills um but you would not get the full amount of your Levy right on time with the end of the year you would receive uh those funds when the bills are event when the taxes are eventually collected would if um so in exchange for that that service the county provides the the county gets the penalties and interest right we keep yeah we take we get 100% we get 100% of the property taxes the assessed valuation yes and and basically the collection fee is the penalties and interest yeah so you so by participating you've ensured your Revenue stream for the year yeah essentially yeah yeah so that which is that that I i' I've been reading about it and and it's it's a

103i it's it's different explanation than I I thought that than I understood last time you gave the presentation it makes a lot more sense that that you essentially the county acts as a collection agent and the fee becomes the the penalties and interest yeah that's why I use the you know factoring receivables as an example that's like the most common thing that people think of you know from a business perspective um you know you want get your Revenue you want to have your cash flow stream coming in and there's a cost to that we take on the burden of of doing everything front Froning the money and then the upside to not being Teeter really isn't there well I mean dep really I guess it would depend on your geographic area where you have more

104delinquencies maybe it it could the penalties interest could potentially be you know have an upside but I think in our area it probably doesn't um yeah I I haven't I haven't been on the side of a district to see how beneficial or not beneficial that is uh the city of Carpenteria doesn't participate um for whatever reason it's something we've been hoping that you know eventually we could get them to because it it would make our life a little bit easier uh honestly um if you wanted to find out if it was a benefit or not how significant they would be somebody that you could talk to but yeah again you're basically ensuring your cash flow are there any school districts in Santa Barbara County that are not that elect that are basic a that did

105not elect terer not that I'm aware of no can I just make a comment hi Ed Price assistant auditor controller uh I'm not sure that school districts by law can leave the Teeter program when it was introduced it was also introduced at the time ER was put out in the state and it was a package deal so I'm not sure you have the option of moving out of it if you want to all school districts are put into it so just uh before anyone gets their hopes up and then we do a lot of work it may not be even illegal I don't even see the benefit of there's no benefit but just trying to understand like when when you say participate it's like there's in it Intimates a choice my kids are they participate

106in throwing the dishes you know yeah they love it uh but actually it's not a bad thing because you can depend on your cash flows sorry to dri no no no no good you learn something new every day yeah uh yeah yeah no uh we we don't there's the the city of karp and then a handful of very small districts I think up in Sanz Valley uh let's see what else do we have here um so you are you're a basic Aid School District as you mentioned and as such you don't receive supplemental taxes um and you also don't receive a portion or an allocation from the uh education uh Revenue augmentation fund or erf uh non-basic Aid schools do receive those basic AIDS do not um you receive a portion of the 1% uh

107discretionary revenue and you receive uh Bond revenues for the bonds you have outstanding there was a 1995 authorization in 2014 um the 1995 one I took a quick look and um as of this year um the uh the rate on that is a126 per 100,000 and that's in third refunding and I believe that's the only portion of that Bond that's outstanding so that will probably be paid off after I don't remember what the maturity date on that is um the 2014 one there have been series a through a and C issued on that and a first refunding as well I think we refinanced the the 95 bond in in 2015 yeah when rates were really low yeah yeah so that still has a little bit of time before it's paid off but but yeah and

108the uh the 20141 3871 you see is the uh the the bond rate on that for this year uh you don't uh Levy any parcel taxes um Santa Barb uh Santa Barbara unified had parcel taxes for a while hope uh as about six years ago I want to say um uh did take a partial tax to the electorate it was passed and then that's been renewed um you're not impacted by any of the Redevelopment agencies or dissolution of them uh in the county and not affected that much by oil mineral and gas fluctuations that's a question we get from some um so here's kind of another uh breakdown of the you know the the the graph that we were looking the um this is actually only as of 23 um uh but we had um

109about what was that a little over a billion almost 1.1 billion uh I think that's approaching 1.2 billion and that's divvied up uh to the county dependent Special Districts the cities independent districts the schools and uh CC's and to rdas and we already took a look at this as you can see the school district gets close to half or the school districts uh get close to half the countywide taxes um after that there's a there's a graph that shows the ass the historical values uh assessed values in the county and you can see that's gone up and up but I know one of the things it's you know of current question these days uh is you know what's happening now you can see at the the far right of that graph the lower line the

110the red line you can see that uh assessed values uh were increasing up at around 8% in the last few years but they've dropped back down uh under 6% you know between 5 and 6% countywide uh in in the last couple years following that there's a median sales price and as best I can tell there the the line that's colorcoded to carpentera and this would be the city of course not the school district um but I thought it was interesting to see is down it's one of those bottom two lines um so values have increased but you know when we do hear a lot about these significant increases in values you can see the bright green line up at the top which uh is Monaco and with some you know really crazy price increases there

111um so it VAR so that you know kind of speaks to depending on the tax rate area that you might be in the the increases in values are not necessarily the same as what you're hearing about in the news well so so going back to um that chart well I'll go back to the one before that's just median sales price I understand that so go back to the historical assess valuation or value values yes so so can you explain um how the assessed valuation is increasing so dramatically There Yet the percentage increase um to the districts is is is not like it I mean I don't understand the variation in like shouldn't those two those two uh charts be parallel yeah well the if you look the on on the left hand side of the

112chart you'll see see there are there's dollar values and so the historical assessed value is that that's looking at what is the value bye each year and that's a steady increase the red line is would probably be better represented as a bar chart for that piece um but I pulled this from the Assessor's website um actually no I no I didn't but it's at any rate the red line might be better represented as a bar chart showing what the amount of increase in the value is each year whereas the the green line sloping up is cumulative does that help make sense kind of but but I I so so we see we see a a you know sharp increase in say 20 uh I mean the the the the uh valuation seems like it's accelerating

113from about 13 1213 and then to current you know it kind of it's It's not linear it's it's it's more of a a parabolic increase in valuation and and yet we we have this Spike now in 22 23 20 yeah 22 23 and now and then the the two lines are diverging um and I I don't quite you know you look at the I'm not sure is there a pointer on here is that H there's oh actually there is it actually works okay so so you know see how accurate I can be here hold my hand steady um so right here it's showing that approximately I I want to say that that's 22 23 there was about an 8% growth in so you know you see you growth there and it's not particularly perceptible um

114but you you know you can almost see that there's a slight tilt in this line going this way because that 8% dropped down you know let's say in the 7% in uh 2324 and then 24 25 was back down here under this so it's not really perceptible there but the these are still Positive Growth amounts um so this is the cumulative value going up and this is just you know how much what was the incremental growth in a particular year yeah year-over year yeah so yeah that still doesn't I still don't understand it's Year from year yeah yeah it's Year from year I so I makes sense I'm I'm uh is that is small because you know I guess the big the big you know kind of the purpose of this of us asking you

115here is is be because you know we we see the valuations because carbonaria Unified School District is not just carbonaria proper you know we we include uh s Sandyland P Lane uh Foothill Corridor with all the Cannabis operations uh which have you know been the valuation on those has gone up dramatically compared to what the properties were were before we see Toro Canyon and then you get into Summerland so we see this this you know this huge you know there's there's a lot of big properties selling on yeah pedo for you know tens of millions you know almost hundred million dollars when the the his you know when the last time a lot of those turned over they were probably their assessed valuation was considerably lower and I know there's been a lot of improvements

116there and and so the expectation is that our growth rate is probably going to be closer to that seven six s% versus the 5% and um and so that's why you know we we were surprised that we had two years of over seven let me cover the next couple of slides and then let's come back to your questions what I've shown so far is real is just very general countywide information this is a little bit more addressing your concerns so this is a graph of the documentary transfer tax uh collected by the Clerk Recorder assessor's office the Clerk Recorder actually is who's doing the collecting here and this is uh a documentary transfer tax if you're not familiar with it when you transfer a property there's a charge of it's actually 55 cents per $500

117of uh sales price but you can think of it as A110 per thousand um and so um this the uh assessor's office puts this out publishes this and on the bottom what you see in the bar charts is transaction volume so this is the number of transactions of documentary transfer tax I.E how many properties were TR uh were transferred um and record recorded at the office the squiggly line on the top represents the amount of documentary transfer tax that occurred on those months and you can see there's a wide variation because one sale may have you know be a $10 million property one might be a $1 million property right so that varies up and down significantly and so what I want to draw your attention to is this area right down here and I've

118drawn these these horizontal lines and so this is back through uh 2122 um when we are seeing really significant growth and you can see compared to and you know we have seasonal uh ups and downs and we can kind of see what was happening over the you know the past you know five or six years there and then during this period we see that volume increase and then here last current year and last year we see a significant decrease and in fact uh the data that we get along with this graph goes all the way back through 2000 the volume of sales in the last two years is the lowest it's been in 20 years um this is countywide again but it's still very low volumize at the important thing and I have this on

119a subsequent slide but an important thing to understand is that the sales prices don't translate to assessed value increases it translates to Val to the assessed value but not NE necessarily the increase if you've owned your property since 1980 it gets transferred you might see a huge increase um but if somebody bought their home three or four years ago and they're turning around and selling it they change their mind what have you um then you may not see very much of an increase at all so when and actually we you know when I was here about 3 years ago I did a I didn't redo this but um looking statistically it's about 7% plus or minus each year of properties that turn over so every year 100% of the properties are being factored up 2%

120or the lesser of 2% of or CPI um and that's where you get most of your value increase across the county it's only about 7% of the properties and of course this can vary from area to area that are being transferred or there's new construction related to them and so you might see a substantial increase for those properties but again it's a small percentage of the number of properties so um nevertheless when we that's the piece that takes you from 2% up to say 3% or 5% or 8% in terms of incremental growth so when we see the lowest volume um you know one property who knows maybe they've owned the property for 20 or 30 years maybe they've owned it for 3 years but if we look across the board you know it's pretty

121much going to average out so when I look at this lowest volume in 20 years that's what kind of translates to overall there's going to be less value growth there and and we see that we see that um in those in the peak years it was 78% and we've seen it drop down to about 5 and a half countywide I believe last year and about and well we don't know what it is going to be this year um could could you could you create this uh the same chart specific to a a a tax rate area theoretically yes um we we've only recently started now again this is based on documentary transfer tax um and so from from this we can it's not a certainty we can extrapolate uh sales price that based on APN

122it's based on APN we would be able to trace it back um and we have talked about what additionally we can do with this data to provide better information but everything that we do takes work it takes somebody to do that so it's not something we've got around to it's not something that I could just go back and run this report again this is produced by the uh assessor's office but theoretically yes that is something that could be done we don't have that readily available where this data is broken to that level could could you ask them if they could provide it um we can look into it I I I can't make any guarantees about you know if or when we would be able to provide that at an individual level I'm I'm not

123sure what level of effort it would take to provide that on a countywide basis and you know as soon as somebody knew that we had done it for carp unified everybody in the county would want the same thing because everybody's going through their uh budget season as well um but that is something that we could that would be interesting to look at you know long term uh but I can't make any guarantees on that we're uh if you hadn't heard we're in the middle of a major Financial system implementation right now which is pretty much tapping you know every extra minute in our office um to be able to get that uh completed successfully so I can't commit any time to uh extra an additional thing at this time I do apologize for that but

124that that is kind of the way it is um sorry one one other thing to note is that within the last 10 to 15 years there has been a few years where it's been less than 2% growth it has been mhm so that's yeah so when so there have been there have been a couple times uh one I want to say was about 3 to five years ago uh where the CPI came in at just over 1% is probably 2020 um right and so you know so the values didn't increase there and I wonder if that's visible on this chart you know you have a big dip in here that's probably like right in there right yeah and and you see this uh you know this right here so overall it was small um another

125thing I just want to point out here also is they use what Excel calls a geometric graph and so this real spike is it's trying to project that wow things are really going to go up through the roof because of recent things but you know if you drew some trend lines there you might say well it's kind of going up kind of similar to how you know the I want to say that was 20 uh tax year 20 22 23 was down here 23 24 24 25 uh maybe I have those off by a year I don't recall have Michael can't see that small print but you can see there's a slight increase here that probably corresponds to these value increases but this line going up here I would not uh because I I've seen

126this and it can go up and down depending on you know a month of really good or really poor sales so uh don't read too much into that um okay let's see that went too far um so this then looking at the current year and I know that's uh what you're concerned about um I've made a note here so at this point in the year the the assessor process is they remove all exemptions on properties a welf exemptions for churches and schools and so forth um at the beginning uh probably not school districts but um for you know private schools churches museums what have you um charitable organizations um the homeowners exemptions stay on um but the other exemptions are removed and then they go about verifying that those are still valid so at this

127point in the year they have not done that so this uh amount that's shown over here on the right we don't uh read much into that at this point um because it shows a skewed upward uh growth because last because last year's data is showing uh and I guess what I should have said is this is a working role report that we get from the assessor's office when you call us up and say what's our growth looking like for this year um I look at this report and what I do depending on the timing um is I will take the gross value from last year and the gross value from the current year and calculate a year-over-year gross assessed value now it's the exemptions may change somewhat but probably not all that much so we

128give a lot more weight to that and if I'm looking at the current year uh values over last year you can see here I've calculated about a 3.99% now that's also based on the fact that the assessor is still in the process of this is the hardest part because you all and your counterparts always want to know what's my growth because we're trying to budget we're doing this so um at this point they are still catching up on any Property Transfers that occurred prior to January 1st um they're doing those appraisals now trying to come up with new information it's possible uh in fact you know that number will probably edge up a little bit how much is difficult to say um you'll note the note at the bottom is basically saying this is a

129snapshot View at a point in time and it's subject to change um so there's no guarantee this is what your growth rate is going to be I just want to be very clear about that okay um the three and historically I would say you know that you know it probably is likely to edge up from there one of the things somebody mentioned earlier was Prop 19 and I have another you know slide on that um but there are you know we've seen bankruptcies of oil companies we've seen a variety of things going on we've seen values that go down at times and you know with Prop 19 um sometimes you think there's going to be a a a large value increase um and it doesn't pan out I'll give you just an anecdotal example uh

130we've just been dealing within the last few days a refund um for some taxpayers who sold their home uh in Pacific Palisades before it burned down um that they had owned for a long time um and they purchased a property up here now the property up here was previously valued at the factored up value was like 275,000 somebody had owned that for a long time right they purchased it for 3.8 uh million dollars and we thought oh well there's going to be uh and actually it had been assessed upward when the prior owner had died but they purchased it for 3.8 and you would think well with that change in value there's going to be a big increase in value uh to uh the tax rle you know for that property well then they transferred

131their value under Prop 19 up to that uh up to this property and their home in Pacific Palisades was valued at I think 875,000 something like that so it dropped from that 3.8 uh million down to the 875 and so we just got through or we're in the process of sending them a check for you know uh $38,000 in a tax refund um so that's a big one uh admittedly um but that does happen so um you know like I said in the past you know depending from year to year what's going on economically we could have expectations that that's going to grow a little bit with various things going on it can't be a guarantee so the best information that we can give you right now is just looking at that year-over-year growth I

132have a question uh uh in Gross sorry year-over-year gross so um say a property doesn't change ownership but it changes uses so it wouldn't necessarily show up on the on the uh on your uh title um fee report if there's no ownership change or change in or uh completed new construction no it wouldn't now that does vary I'm speaking more like more like the Cannabis facilities in Carpenteria so a lot of those didn't change ownership they just changed use use and my understanding was those were re re reassessed at at a different rate based on their re you know the rezoned use um I don't know the answer to that that's really in the that's the Assessor's wheelhouse determining you know whether uh you know what is and what events trigger a reappraisal of the

133property um and I'm not knowledge ible on what happened with those um of course there's cannabis taxes as well different from property taxes um I don't know to have any speak know on what he's asking come up the micop sure I'm not an assessor and like Trevor said we we have an separate electric official who takes care of the assessment activity um but my understanding it's either transfer or new construction that triggers additional assessment activity maybe uh some properties that are under a preserve rights get a special tax rat or vasis for Taxation and whether they change the use of that from one to another to maybe cannabis May trigger them coming out of that perhaps could result in industrial uh to an increased uh you know taxation for uh property tax but I'm not

134I'm not really sure to Trevor's Point we'd have to ask the assessor and they could give you a little bit better finite information on what that might happen but I I'm skeptical just knowing those basic rules that they follow so not that I wouldn't like to find more ways to generate some revenue for everyone yeah I yeah I would be more inclined to expect that you know uh you know if you're setting up that kind of operation you I know there's a lot of green houses in carp and so maybe you can repurpose that uh but you know if you're doing new construction on facilities that might have something to do with it and it could also be like a a form of you know ownership entity you know if uh going into that business

135uh if it behooves you to switch to a different uh legal owner of the property then that could be something that would trigger it but but yeah I'm not really not certain and I'm not certain I I believe um I believe that for property tax purposes that would be treated as a crop like others and rolled into the secured value um I know you know for something like you know oil mineral and gas you know they might uh uh assess valuation based on extraction think they're treated treated differ than than EG but again that's really an assessor that's really an assessor question let's see um just a few other points uh that I think I've probably covered but only about 7% of the properties transfer each year it's based on what was the value you

136know prior to being transferred um again that's why I look at the volume of what's going on across the county an individual property may have been owned for one year or 20 years um where is the growth is the growth actually in your jurisdiction um again we saw the graph that showed a lot of uh a lot of swing in the Monaco area uh to whatever extent that some of that may overlap with carp unified I'm not sure uh because I'm not I'm not sure what the basis for that median value obviously Monaco isn't uh an incorporated city so there uh to arrive at that graph they're using some sort of a moneto community area to determine that um let's see and of course there's the time lag you know between that transfer and the

137actual Revenue uh realization which could be you know a year Downstream or what have you and Rule Corrections during the year we often find you know as soon as the assessor uh determines that there's value on a property and we issue bills um literally the very next day they're sending us corrections to the existing Rule and we're changing those and correcting bills so um let's see can I get this to go in the right place um getting late so I don't know how much uh time you have but uh on Prop 19 just a few things there if you're not all that familiar with it um basically Prop 19 replaced props 60 and um 90 which allowed for uh intra County base value transfers and in reciprocating counties you could have a a base value

138transfer this replaced those that was a one time for people over 55 this increased it to a three times uh uh for people over 55 uh disabled and victims of wildfire so expanded that a little bit um you could transfer the value anywhere in State uh if you buy something that's at a higher value as a replacement property you can have a split base so you transfer a portion of your base and then there's going to be a new assessment component to that um so there's a limit on how much you can transfer um with the intergenerational transfers you know parent to child or grandparent to grandchild um that replaced uh proposition 50 uh I'm sorry 58 and um that uh the the limit there's a limit it implemented a limitation that um the child

139needed needs to uh use that property as their principal residents they need to apply for and receive the homeowner's exemption uh to get that but it's also Limited to a uh reduction of $1 million in assessed value so beyond you know if the difference in value is beyond that then that base value is going to transfer up and and of course this is you know significant as I said with the example because this can impact the uh you know the value changes within your area depending on what's Happening I know recently we've seen you well ever since it was implemented we we've seen an uptick in these base value transfers um so that's really the end of my presentation I think we covered a lot of different topics and jumped back and forth I don't

140know if you guys have any questions about any of those areas or I just have one um how do we see or is there a specific area that's like carpentry unified GS and where's that line between monoco and carpentera um the assessor's office maintains maps for that and those boundaries are determined by uh the the Santa Barbara local agency formation committee um actually did they do that for the schools or it's the it's not involved in schools they're not involved in schools it's the the uh it's the the other agency that handles the School boundaries sorry I misspoke there um so uh the schools committee I'm sorry I can't the Name Escapes me at the moment um they handle the the the um County Education Office is it County Education Office I thought there was

141a they have a committee so the committee is part of County Ed okay um they deter they manage where the boundaries are but the assessor keeps the map for those where exactly that line is I couldn't tell you so um the uh so you you'll be able to get Jason when you go back to Alice figure out what percentage of our of the revenues derived from our district go to the schools what percentage of the revenue of the of the of the tax collected in our in in the school district area I can get you the allocation percentages for the tax rate areas that form the school district and they're going to vary depending on how many different tax rate how many different overlapping yeah they they vary depending on those what different districts are

142overlapping and and so but we carpent unified deres um all virtually all of its revenue from within the bounds of its of its Trust of its area of its of its uh zone is that correct so so we're not we're not splitting money from elsewhere in the county yes and no it's it's a uh a calculation methodology the the process that I was describing where we look at the allocated Revenue by jurisdiction so the the district and other districts that form that that that are included in a tax rate area we look at the value growth and thus the tax growth within that tax rate area allocate that by each jurisdiction based on their allocation percentages then we take all of the tax rate areas that form uh your district and we take those that

143incremental tax revenue for the year we add that all up AC for your whole jurisdiction and we add that to the revenue uh the prior Year's revenue for your jurisdiction that comes up so that's your annual tax increment so that tells you how much revenue you should be allocated for the year that amount then is taken uh as a percentage of the whole for all taxing entities in the county of Santa Barbara okay so you have this little piece there's all the other school districts in and every city and every other uh uh special district in the county as well as the county entity itself we say what is your percentage of the whole then as taxes are collected um so we collect a million dollars of taxes from Santa Maria karp Santa Barbara unincorporate

144area nukiyama those all go into a tax collection pot and that percentage of the whole is used to allocate the money out to all of the taxing entities you have to think that's that's confusing so I so I want so what so what exactly makes us a basic Aid District I always thought it was our revenues that were derived from from our area our un within our Unified School District were in excess of of what the state guarantee was and that is correct yeah and that is and and I also was under the impression I think most people are under the impression that that that all of the properties within the bounds of that of our school district that the that the that the taxes you know whatever the percentage is are applied to our

145district they're not split out with only to our district and they're not split out to the whole County I I I I understand your confusion it it is confusing you kind of have to put yourself in the mentality of 1978 and so um you know at the time how do you go about figuring out how you're going to do this and this was come up with as a as a methodology for trying to make the process efficient uh we didn't have you know computers at the time that would allow us to allocate every s you know to track each property and allocate that percentage out and track or at least it wasn't affordable or I know theoretically possible probably but it wasn't really practicable to have that done at the time so this was a

146methodology to try and make that allocation uh more efficient um the basic idea is that this should result in the same thing so it should be um plus or minus a small amount of rounding that by following this methodology at you know you're going to receive the same amount of Revenue as if we took each property tax uh uh charge that was received in your district and gave it direct and or rather yet within uh the area and allocated it to the various jurisdictions and gave you your portion is is there anywhere we could find or or where you could show us what the what the uh the valuation of of properties within our district is and then and then we could derive the prop the the the the the property taxes based on that

147I know that's a question I've had for some time and I I know a number of other people have as well because it's it's hard to hard to you know we have the sense that our that our you know we have the high value properties that are turning over fairly regularly um as as the population becomes more affluent um and it'd just be nice to be able to see that um as a you know as a figure like rather than the gross County you know whatever it is N9 billion or 10 billion dollar figure to see what break it out for Carpenteria Unified School District yeah as as with you know how I responded to that question about the documentary transfer taxes theoretically yes um we don't currently um we don't currently have re I

148would have to see what reporting we have available to provide the incremental change in value for a specific for specific tax rate areas so so is it as simple as saying round numbers if if $40 million an assessed value was in Carpenteria and then collected we should see 40 million well you see one you see 1% of that yeah yeah yeah the one allowing for a lag in time because each year the those the AB8 factors are recalc calculated so there would be a lag in the timing of that so it wouldn't you it wouldn't be year to year would be exact year to year but over time it should correlate I'm going to let Ed say what he's got yeah sorry to interrupt there but a couple things come to mind I hear exactly

149where you're going and we really wish we had the data systems to do this with the click of a button we that's where we want to grow to to provide that kind of information um but I think we might have some reports that we can do that might help you get where you're going to I just wanted to comment on that 40 million 1% discussion that 1% does get shared with all the other entities in that geographic area so the city will get a the school uh you know the fire district is yeah see and in rough numbers if I recall and this is done on the back of a napkin I I think the school district here gets about 2% of the countywide pot that Trevor was talking about under the ad AB8 model

150and I think probably you're closer to 55% for the territory of just your school district that geographic area but I'm shooting from bad memory and I'm getting old so it's probably that's close to what I'd like to do I think we've got the data and I just don't know if we got the time because Trevor's point was so valid we're kneed deep and trying to put the zp system in so we can actually do some other stuff I let me see what we can do and maybe we can get you some data it's uh maybe not as precise as we' normally be able to generate but give you at least a sense of where you're at and that would be a little bit helpful for it would be yeah that' be great if you could

151do that thank you and one year I think we will have a touch of the butt and be able to Pride this regularly for you be much more helpful and make Trevor's life so much easier we just want to know how this how how the sausage is made if you will like I get that it all gets put into a pot and it gets spit back out but it's that it's a black box and frustrating to try and like have to plan for you know a year out but we don't even know like what happened this last year where we had been looking at 7% 7% and then it dropped 5% well and and you know that the seven and 8% over those you know 21 22 22 23 those were really kind of outliers

152um you know because fall following 2020 things just kind went nuts um if you look historically um you know we've always used something you know when we're talking to uh CEO's office about budget times and trying to project before we know anything at all before we even have you know before January 1 even rolls around we always say well you know we'll look at this as like you know at the most around four four and a half percent uh because traditionally that's kind of where stuff ends up at those the 78% % those are really outliers yeah your cautionary Tale on that one slide was 4% yeah 3.99 yeah uh well you can see I mean we're we're because because we're dealing with you know this budget and you you probably listen to obvious there's

153a lot of concern and you know the it's not like we're coming up with these numbers I mean we're we're try getting advice from you you're not going to give us a number you're going to give us a kind of range and then we've got to do an educated kind of calculation and and plug something for the for the because we have to project three years out I I I think you guys are familiar with how School budgets work yeah we do we do a five-year projections for uh for the County administrator or the county Executives officer you know every year we're do going through that that process as well and uh and to be honest you know to to a great extent we're kind of doing something similar to you like well this is

154our best guess based on the information that we have um and you know we do the best we can we try and project where we have some data that will support uh those but you know you you never know when you know the Market's going to turn from one year to the next in particular with the volume like I said okay all right any thank you further burning questions thank you very much I appreciate your time yeah if you guys do have any follow-up questions uh feel free to forward those to me and we'll do the best we can to to answer it for you all right thank appr have a good thanks Ed um we are moving on to F business operations and Facilities if you have public comment on anything under business operations

155facilities F please step up to the podium now all righty first the employees we represent thank those community members who provide gifts grants and donations to CD without any unethical or unprofessional strings attached this evening CD receives over $52,000 for sports programs schools and libraries teacher supplies and a field trip and although we regret that administration of District finances requires so much Community Support we greatly appreciate the generosity the community continues to show in that vein we hope the Community will consider how it can further support the CMS Band program which is struggling after the recent theft of one or thousands of dollars of instruments and Equipment including eight headphone sets eight guitars one ukulele two keyboards two practice drum pad sets a very large set of Congo drums an Apple TV Wi-Fi devices and

156safety equipment that was stored in the exploratory music lab this theft which is directly impacting students and families was absolutely preventable had admin listen to teachers and their representatives the first time a similar theft had occurred Miss RI as for the warrants the district's legal cost for personnel um translated meaning disciplinary attacks against employee representatives and their cost for negotiations which translated means Outsourcing CD bargaining responsibilities total over $36,000 therefore another $36,000 is heaped upon the extraordinary $3.5 million of expenditures and acred debt invested to the same end legal fees that account for approximately half the district's cost overruns in 2324 there is no doubt our district officials performance in this area of legal expenditures has been truly extraordinary unfortunately as long as cusd misappropriates tax dollars this way the district will continue to underfund

157each of the following schools as or on a per pupil basis as confirmed in the last sarc report released just a month ago when compared to State averages Aliso is underfunded by almost 20% expenditures per pupil underfunded by 20% calino underfunded by 27% CMS expenditures per pupil underfunded underfunded by 133% CHS underfunded by 22.8% and CFS Carpenteria Family School underfunded by 44.5% the district will fail to invest in teacher salaries by 3,522 648 million to be exact which is the exact number associated with cusd Z code violation exposed in the recent audit just days before winter break the district will fail to invest these millions of squandered taxpayer dollars to improve working conditions that would stem The Exodus of Highly qualified Personnel from cusd who continue to leave cusd to work in surrounding districts for

158better pay and working conditions and boy again we could go on and on and on thank you your time is up any further public comment on business operations and Facilities okay seeing none uh may I get a motion to approve uh can I'll move to approve the oh sorry uh sorry um I'm going to go through F1 uh warrants I didn't state it uh the board has asked to approve the warrant for the period of January 2425 through February 625 in the amount of 46294 194 warrants are issued once a week on Thursdays the report format shows check number check date pay brief account description payment comment and check amount may I get a motion to approve I'll move move to approve as uh presented I'll second that any discussion okay all in favor i

159f two gifts grants and donations uh we have a donation from let's see 2A donation from CHS athletic booster club to CHS soccer weight room and golf Sports we're being asked to accept a donation from boosters for $ 5,685 180 to CHS sports for soccer uniforms adjustable weight benches and golf green fees may I get a motion to approve I move to approve uh the donation from CHS athletic Boosters club I'll second that discussion thanks boosters all in favor I I uh 2B donation from CHS Boosters club to CHS Athletics and students we're being asked to accept the donation of $133,000 from boosters to Athletics for spring general fund $6,000 and CHS students $7,000 for free admission to games May I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve thanks boosters I'll second that

160and thanks boosters again discussion okay all in favor I uh to see donation from Gary D lamley at CHS FFA uh the board has asked to accept the donation of $100 uh for the FFA program I'll move to approve thanks K second discussion all in favor I uh 2D Grant donation from teacher fund care of village properties to Carpenter Unified School District teacher Katie Brown we're being asked to accept this donation from the Teachers Fund uh from village properties uh may I get a motion to approve I move to approve the grant donation from Teachers Fund all second uh any discussion all in favor I I to e donation from uh CF carpa kabuna to to cusd K8 School libraries the board is asked to accept the donation of $330,000 from carpentera Education Foundation carpa

161kabuna event to cusd K8 schools libraries for DLI and English books the allocation is as follows Aliso 7,152 62 canalino Family School $1,799 52 Summerland $1,161 73 and CMS at 9 88610 I'll move to approve I'll second that and thank all the people that attended this really fun event I we appreciate your attendance okay uh all in favor I I we're asked to accept a donation from CF to CSD for our fifth grade field trip it's a donation of $2500 from CF to the district for a fifth grade pilot reev Revolutionary War EXP experience field trip that's really cool um may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve I'll second uh discussion all in favor I I and we have uh F3 the 2526 draft school year calendar subject to negotiations we're

162asked to approve the 2526 draft calendar school year calendar which is still subject to negotiations um may I get a motion to approve I'll move to approve as presented I'll second any discussion okay all in favor I I we're moving on to G Personnel if you'd like to make public comment on the Personnel uh agenda please step up to the podium at this time so a few board meetings back and again this evening Union leadership and those represent provided observations pertaining to the Personnel report and the significant challenges CD is experiencing as it fails to both recruit and maintain and and maintain talented Personnel how long will it take for CD's officials to understand that the economic stability or lack thereof of District employees has a direct impact on the stability of District students and

163families the high turnover and transy of Personnel in the CD has a direct impact on the quality and efficacy of academic programs social emotional connections peer support Content Mastery volunteerism morale and extracurricular support that we can offer our district students and families once again we have a a another midyear resignation to actually and a midar retirement of an employee who was hired fairly recently those three positions fall under the special education program all while the district continues to struggle to fill sped positions that still remain open from others who have left the district prematurely all the while the district officials like yourselves refuse to acknowledge that cusd sped program has experienced and continues to experiencing experience not just the routine challenges that other districts face but the plethora of other unique challenges exacerbated by CD's

164very hiring training compensation and administrative philosophies and practices the those resigning have shared this with you those working in sped classrooms across the district have shared this with you elected employee Representatives have shared this with you sped families have shared this with you in fact the state and the county have even shared this with you just as your own lawyers have shared this with you but you continue to sit before the community and respond in the same with the same mix of denial and often faint shock and certainly contempt and amusement refusing to acknowledge that the elephant in the room uh is sped and pointing in every direction you are but never in the direction of those who could most significantly impact these matters which would be at yourselves after years of encouraging a robust

165exit interview process you permitted Miss Rigby and Miss Zapata to implement the most token of processes not designed to really understand why employees are leaving but to instead allow the district to say that they have a process and since its exception Inception it has been a pumpkin Village of processes absolutely Hollow and designed to be just that no Marie and Charlene are all leaving you have an opportunity to better understand why just as you did when over 70 employees fled the district last year we understand that you learn that what you learn May reinforce the concerns that we share at these meetings and that might be embarrassing to you but you have a higher duty to the community and it's time to perform that Duty any further public comment on G thank you Ro Delgado

166carpentry uh resident uh commented several times that uh at least for one time I would like to read the the agenda without uh any uh resignations and so far I mean for a long long time I haven't read one without a resignation and uh for several factors can cause someone to resign could be pressure from the district could be that they need to move because of the High Cost of Living uh could be that uh they will be earning a better salary somewhere else uh any reason at all but uh I would recommend the district to uh avoid uh resignations for the benefit uh of children thank you okay may I get a motion to approve the Personnel summary I move to approve the Personnel summary all second any discussion okay all in favor I

167future agenda items public comment on H I haven't stepped up yet I thank you at the last two board meetings Union leadership requested that the board include two items on a future agenda first we asked again and we ask again that the board explore a resolution that educates kids on what to do if someone enters their physical space with a firearm One Stop two don't touch three leave four tell an adult and if you can't find an adult call one 911 not a single District official has responded to this request which was made at no less than nine board meetings in the last few years none of you second we asked and again asked the board to explore the concept of exit interviews to acquire a better understanding of why cusd employees leave the district

168not why employees in general leave their jobs musings like that from Miss Diamond but why District employees who intended to provide cusd many more years of quality service leave cusd not a single District official has responded to that request either a request that has been made at no less than eight board meetings in the last few years not a single one of you finally we asked the board to explore at a future board meeting why even though cusd is a basic Aid district is in the top 4% of the most robustly funded tk12 school districts in the state why are both expenditures per pupil and teacher salary so far below State averages at every School site ad Aliso expenditures per pupil 20% below cantalino 27% below CHS 22.8% below CFS 44.5% below and teach your

169salaries how about canalino at 19% below State averages or CMS at 20% below State averages or how about the high school at 20 6.8% below State averages when we mentioned this at the last board meeting super intendent Rigby to many of your nods dismissed the data stating that it was old a year old she failed to share that the SAR data is always a year behind the current time but if the most current data were crunched today these numbers would be even worse due to the lack of an employee increase in 20 months and the failure to invest $3.5 million as you were supposed to required by Ed code but if you wish to focus on the distraction that the data is a year old just consider consider for a moment who was in charge

170a year ago superintendent R seven years in the district Miss Diamond four years on the Schoolboard Mr Smith four years on the school board Mr bridgeford two years on the school board Miss green six years on the school board and Mr schaer approximately 15 years on the school board so I'm not sure that oneyear discrepancy that you were referring to moves accountability off your shoulders for the numbers that we're looking at thank you you we look forward to seeing that on a future board agenda okay so for future oh for the public comment Roo Delgado carpent resident last night exactly the same time uh the city uh projected its budget good good news lot of expenses but the standard healthy budget I hope that are next budget uh development would be good just like the

171city I think that uh families students and teachers deserve it after so many years of uh problems with the budget just hope for a healthy uh budget uh development thank you okay any uh comments from the board for future agenda items uh we have of note our 25 that should say 2025 2026 budget development lcap midyear update report um anything else okay uh let's see here Nothing On The Board calendar uh board announcements any announcements from the board anything coming up um I was able to attend the coffee with the principal at the high school and I encourage parents to check your calendars or check parent Square for the coffee with principal because it's an easy way for one-on-one conversations for you to have your questions answered and to find out what's happening in each

172of the School sites I also was able to attend the family Friday which a lot of the parents tonight talked about and it um it was very fun there were lots of activities that were provided by parents and teachers for the um students so it was a fun afternoon I encourage you all to go to that and I wanted to thank all those people that came tonight and um provided us with their views about lots of things going on anybody else um there's uh the um uh CSF the Scholarship Foundation the deadline is coming up for high schoolers the um I just it's coming up on Thursday do you know what I'm talking about yeah it's it's in a parent square but I just wanted to reiterate it um sorry I meant to pull it

173up beforehand scholarship Foundation the where is it yeah California scholarship Federation um applications are available for all high school students um applications are available in the office but they are due on Thursday so it's just something to note if you have a high school student um and you've talked about it or last year you've applied it's it's the deadline is coming up um but other than that that's it okay okay um with that we are adjourned thank e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.