001all right good evening uh today's January 16th 2025 and we are going to get going with our meeting uh let's see roll call all board members are present as our both of our student representatives and with our report of action taken during closed session in closed session the board took action pursuant to code section 44940 to place certificated employee identified as sc24 4- 2501 on a compulsory unpaid leave of absence effective immediately and directed the superintendent or design to send out the appropriate legal notices the roll call vote was 5-0 with zero Nos and no exensions all right uh Pledge of Allegiance Dr Kim all right um thank you uh president uh Peterson we have a pledge of allegiance that's typically provided by a student that is recognized but unfortunately from Sunflower Learning Center uh
002our student has been called to work and the student's name is aen gdy so we just want to recognize uh the great work alen's doing over at sunflower and kudos to this person for also being responsible and uh going to work as well so in light of that we can ask Logan to lead us in the pledge [Music] right hand over your heart I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America for Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all please sit thank you Logan and that I'll take us to board Awards Dr Kim all right uh this uh evening and this month it is Sunflower Learning Center night I'd like to call up to the podium uh our principal fearless leader Miss Lisa
003Rosa please thank you Dr Kim good evening president Peterson members of the board Dr Kim cabinet and everyone here um thank you so much for having our sunflower night tonight it's always an honor to come to the board meeting to do this and and I have some wonderful people to recognize tonight so I will not delay and we'll get started I'd like to start with our Superstar student Isaac Cabrera is Sunflower Superstar student this year I'm going to have Isaac come on up and stand next to me Isaac is a senior at Arrow High School he's done a magnificent job at Arrow he went from all FS when he arrived at Arrow to not only passing all of his classes but earning the coveted green report card that Arrow has to offer which is passing
004with A's and B's and recovering the maximum credits he can for each grading period he is on track to graduate now Isaac says he has had new found optimism at Arrow and he tells himself every morning that this is going to be a good day he says he went from being unmotivated and Silent to feeling positive and more social he says he has flourished with the help guidance and motivation he has received from the teachers and staff at Arrow he also says that since day one at Arrow he has received the support every step of the way and that's why he feels he's successful he talks to other students more and he now has lots of friends Isaac enjoys the schoolwide events at Arrow he's attended the Thanksgiving feast and various field trips that bring
005all students together and he says it has given him a chance to meet people he never would have and they have become his friends Isaac is flourishing in the small learning environment that Arrow provides he feels like a big part of his success is not the non-judgmental atmosphere amongst students and staff Isaac has truly taken charge of his learning at Arrow and was as a result of him doing so he's doing so well academically this semester he's he is on the arot target track which gives him him a modified school day with some online classes he can work on at home and he enjoys this new schedule he has earned all of the incentives this year because of his academic performance After High School Isaac would like to attend school for animation art is his
006passion he also writes scripts in his free time his artistic talents take up a lot of his free time with his Focus talent and will he will undoubtedly do very well in life congratulations [Applause] Isaac come on up Isaac we're gonna have pictures with a board yes please yeah zbling too everybody [Music] do [Applause] good how are you thank you hey Miss Rosa please uh if you can introduce uh your partner in education the Diaz family I'd like to bring up um our well the Diaz family are Partners in education this year and there are eight of them total but three Representatives today and maybe Miss Diaz will join them too it's up to her so I'm going to have Samantha Diaz Elijah Alamo Alamo sorry and Kevin Garcia please come on [Applause] up so
007the Diaz family like I said are our partners in education hear me the quality of these incentives the Diaz family who are Liz Diaz's one of our teacher leaders on campus relatives heard the need for our December holiday waffle breakfast event and out of their own Goodwill and kind and without being asked provided all the food decorations games and prizes and all supplies to make the event absolutely spectacular students dined on homemade waffles hash browns saage juice hot chocolate at beautifully decorated tables and then played fun holiday games it was such an uplifting event for these deserving students if you'd like to see it this event it's on our Arrow Instagram the D family is so generous that they also bought our supplies and food for our January incentive which is a movie event in
008the cafeteria with motion picture and movie style food we are so grateful to the DS family for their generosity in going giving to our school and making a difference for our Arrow students who are working so hard these events would not have been possible at all without them our entire School Community thanks them and feels so grateful they are truly Arrow's Partners in education thank you thank you ready thank you thank you okay next I'll take us to our student representative reports Logan if you'd please good evening Mr President and members of the board yesterday was advising day at Arrow and bridges students went over their grades on their semester 1 report cards students also reviewed all credits earned toward graduation students that had green report cards 90% attendance and 25 attendance Improvement earned a
009movie incentive that will take place on January 22nd we also filled out a student survey on school activities and school climate students transfers sunflower had a great success helping students make their credits so they can return to Charter o High School between all three three sunflower schools 19 students transferred back to churo high school for spring semester WC errow High School is preparing for WC in March the visit is on March 17th through the 19th the team will visit classrooms and meet with staff students and parents and also District administrators thank you for my for giving me my report [Applause] thank you Logan AI good evening Mr President Peterson and Board of Trustees Dr Kim and executive cabinet thank you for giving me the opportunity to share all the amazing things happening at CIA um
010charur o High School returned back to school on Monday January 6th and has had no past events since our last meeting but here is my first or my second winter sports update boys basketball is 3 and 13 boy soccer is 1 and nine and they tied one game girls basketball is 9 and four girls soccer is 4 and six girls water polo is 0o and five and here is some upcoming events churo drama department is holding auditions for their spring production newsies on January 2st we have an academic Awards assembly on Wednesday January 22nd where we expect to recognize over 500 students for their academic achievements as well as perfect attendance from their first semester also on the second Miss Archer will be hosting a meeting for students and parents that are interested in chder
011Oaks IB Program our counselors will be hosting a parent registration night on January 30th and on February 1st there will be a remembrance walk at the L forar Stadium from 9:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m. in honor of loved ones and support student scholarships thank you and that concludes my report thank you both we appreciate it I'll take us to Roop report Mr Rose first of all I want to thank Flores for serving on the board for R last few years thank you for your service there uh let you know that the RP will have a new board new basis it would be consist of three new board members including me myself and one returning and one fairly new and is's also returning so that new faes of the board and ROP then the budget it's
012good shape and we're still working on it and it's going to be we're going to be fine there because the program is up running and it's going to be a fantastic semester so I have a meeting next next Thursday in glendor so the next board meeting I will give you a better picture of what's going on our that's all thank you Mr Rose okay superintendent report Dr Kim thank you president Peterson uh Happy New Year uh to this board and happy New Year to our Charter Community uh excited about uh my Venture and stepping into this role and uh really using the season as I've shared to uh our stakeholders our parents our leaders our teachers as an opportunity for me to listen and to learn about the great things that are happening here at
013Charter Oak unified but more importantly as a leader uh how do I make sure that I'm learning about the things that we're doing and refining and improving our practice here for the sake of our students and so this season is really an opportunity for me me to listen learn and lead and so looking forward to the next 100 days uh through our uh spring break and Gathering some really good information and continuing to move our school district forward with that I'd be REM remiss if I didn't share obviously our well- wishes our hearts or sympathies are with all those that have been truly impacted by the Eaten Canyon fires obviously and as well as a Palisades fire this is uh very concerning times uh we've had uh our own staff members severely impacted through this
014uh we know that these aren't these are challenging times we are so thankful for our First Responders uh we know that there's still ongoing work that they're doing to ensure that people are safe uh and returning I do want to commend our school and our staff uh we did have same challenges not obviously as severe as other districts uh but the challenges we faced uh last Wednesday as a related to the Windstorm uh kudos to our staff from our maintenance and operations uh to our classified staff through and through to our certificated staff in making sure that our our facilities were welcoming and open and safe and we were we had neighboring districts that lost power and we were fortunate enough not to lose power uh we had nearly an 80% attendance rate on that
015date and so we knew that this was proof that we had a safe and welcoming environment for our kids and kids didn't need a place to go so again I want to thank all of our staff for their response uh related to that uh while Sun fers still here I want to give kudos to them because they actually had prior to the winter break on the Wednesday whereas many people were trying to wind down towards the winter break they were winding up because that Wednesday prior to their departure they had a visit from the California Department of Education as a confirmation visit or validation visit at as a model continuation school in the state now we don't have the results yet but we already know for certain that they are a model school there's incredible
016work that's doing students like Logan students like uh the um Isaac that we shared tonight uh we're just so proud of their accomplishments and we're proud of the ongoing work we're doing so we want to give Applause to Miss Lisa regosa along with her entire staff and lastly absolutely and lastly January if you didn't know Bor I'm not sure if you guys know this is board appreciation month so I appreciate you we appreciate you we know the community appreciates you guys so thank you for all you guys do in service to our students with that that concludes my report let's give them a clap all right thank you Dr Kim that'll take us to our presentations Auto report for fiscal year ending June 30th 2024 Dr Kim all right thank you uh president Peterson uh
017I'd like to uh introduce uh Krill Branford to introduce Our Guest here tonight and she is going to prepare our presentation on the audit report for the 2324 school year Miss Branford yes thank you Dr Kim good evening board I am pleased to introduce Monique Manzo Monique is the audit supervisor with Christy white our audit firm and um she will be presenting an overview of the 2324 audit process as well as the results thank you all right uh good evening and thank you for having me um again my name is Monique Manzo I'm a supervisor with Christy white um I'd like to start off with a little overview of the audit process and procedures and end with our opinions um over the district's financial statements as well as uh state and federal compliance so over
018overall our audit covers a broad range of areas tested at different times during the year um during interim what we call interim happens during the springtime we focus on internal controls and state compliance uh so here we test the design and effectiveness of controls to prevent detect and correct um misstatements due to fraud or error um over Financial processes such as you're purchasing cash dispersements cash receipts payrolls so from each of those processes we're looking at all sorts of transactions and testing those controls um we also complete audit procedures published in the annual Lea State audit guide um so whichever procedures are applicable to your District uh specifically for 23 24 year um as you all know proposition 28 and um the expanded learning opportunities program was new uh for your district and both at
019the audit level because the district expended more than $750,000 in federal funds we were required to complete a single audit uh which includes testing of internal controls and program compliance so for 23 24 school year we looked at your special education program um and then we come back again at the fall after you all approve your unaudited actuals and here we're really focusing on account balances so we're looking at your balance sheet items uh we're also looking at Capital assets um your long-term debt as well as revenues and expenditures throughout the audit the district and the auditor have different responsibilities uh so the district's Management's responsibility is uh to design and Implement effective internal controls over your financial processes um as well as the preparation and fair presentation of your financial statements these are your
020financials um the auditor's responsibility our responsibility is um to obtain reasonable assurance that financial statements are free from Material misstatements as well as providing opinions over your financial statements and state and federal Awards um our opinion does not address the uh Financial condition of of the district apologies for that um so there was a restatement U of Prior net position of about 4.5 million to both uh government activities and your internal service fund uh this seems to be a result of closing the workers comp compensation jpa so this was an increase um recognized as Equity to the district uh lastly I feel like this is everyone's favorite page um it's a table on page 87 of the printed report it summarizes the auditor opinions as well as the audit results um so first opinion we
021give is related to the financial statements we issued an unmodified opinion which is the best audit opinion possible so great job on that there were no material um any material weaknesses or significant deficiencies identified while we were you know looking at internal controls or reviewing your financials next is federal Awards issued an unmodified opinion there as well um again we looked at your special education program no material weaknesses or significant deficiencies were um identified there and lastly um State Awards so looking at those State compliance areas um another unmodified opinion no material weaknesses or significant deficiencies were identified there um I just want to give kudos uh to your team implementing that elot program um cuz that was a difficult program for most so job on that um this concludes my review and overview of
022the 2324 audit to give a special thanks to kill and her team and um the site Personnel that we visited um everyone um and hard work um fulfilling all our requests so thank you again um are there any questions we have any questions from the board David I have question I just want to know how long you've been you affirm work with us how long do you affirm work with us you been serving us you remember I want to say this might be the third year yes the three year third year so not not uh 2021 I believe 21 22 20 yes okay um Mr President I'm I'm like to request a document the audio report from the year 2017 to 2019 not from the firm look like it's from a previous firm and I
023like to have the reports from 2017 in 2019 thank you any other questions right ma'am thank you very much for your presentation of course thank you for having me [Music] that takes us to public comments any cards no cards no cards and we'll move on to action items uh item 14 Business Services acceptance of audit report for fiscal year ending June 30th 2024 can I get a motion I'll make the motion can I get a second I'll second okay any discussion okay go ahead and call for the vote Mr Rose yes M Maguire yes m Flores yes Dr agular yes am a yes Logan yes Missouri yes okay motion passes 5 with both student reps and affirmative takes us to Item B Educational Services School accountability report card can I get a motion to so
024moved can I get a second I'll second Mr Rose second any discussion okay I'll go ahead and call for the vote Mr Rose yes Mrs Maguire yes M Flores Dr agular yes Amma yes Logan yes aouri yes okay okay that takes us to Human Resources item C1 approval of assistant superintendent of Educational Services can I get a mtion I'll move can I get a second I'll second the motion Dr Kim you have a recommendation I do have a recommendation uh I am recommending Dr fyuse Mustafa for the position of assistant superintendent of Educational Services we have any discussion Mr Rose she had a PhD in what she has a Doctorate in Education from the prestigious University of lever oh up any other qu any other discussion okay I'll go ahead and call for the vote
025Mr Rose oh yes Miss Maguire yes Mrs Flores yes Dr egler yes and I'm a yes also motion passes 5 Z Dr if I may uh congratulations to uh Dr Mustafa she has uh well over 20 years of experience uh in in the 12 field both in secondary and Elementary Schools she's an accomplished leader she has credibility trust in our school district uh she's had great work through and through and we're proud of what she's accomplished and we look forward to good work ahead from her under her leadership and with that being said pursuant to government code section five for oh I'm sorry let me go to the next next item first approval of a Employment contract can I get a motion contct oh okay actually we're moving on to item two approval of employment
026contract assistant superintendent Educational Services now okay pursuant to government code section 54953 subdivision C3 the board provides this oral summary of the salary and ref fringe benefits payments provided by or to the assistant superintendent by way of the pending Employment contract the term of the new employment contract between the district and the assistant superintendent of educational Services Dr fyuse Mustafa is from January 17th 2025 through January 16th 2028 the new annual salary to be paid to the assistant superintendent of Educational Services is $2,637 per year which is Step seven on the management salary schedule and the other elements of compensation in the contract includes 24 days of annual vacation 14 days of sickly per year District payment towards a health benefit package in the same amount as other full-time District management employees and $11,000 per
027fysical year for incured incurred expenses not covered by the health benefit package group life insurance in an amount of $50,000 as stated in the management salary schedule and District Paid Dues for the assistant superintendent membership dues in the association of California administrators and other service organiz organizations provided by the board or approved by the board oh the last one good thing you're there Danny reimbursement for actual and necessary expenses all right with that being said can I get a motion to bring that forward I'll make the motion second I'll second okay any discussion hi can you um explain is this a standard agreement Dr Kim that every person gets the assistant superintendent salary schedule is fixed on the management salary schedule uh so this is standard to what we've experienced with our prior assistant superintendent
028including myself in my prior position thank you any further discussions on that I'll go ahead and call for the vote Mr Rose no M Maguire yes Mrs Flores yes Dr agular yes and I'm a yes motion passes [Music] so moved second I'll second I'll call for the vote is yes Logan yes Mr Rose yes Mrs Maguire yes Mrs yes Dr agar yes and I'm also yes motion pass 5 Z with both students in the affirmative which will take us to to item number B1 overnight field trips can I get a motion so moved second I'll second any discussion um I just want to call out this is a great opportunity for students um and I think it's wonderful that we're actually showing the students some Hands-On projects what class is this for this is through
029our CTE programs uh eligible students through the engineering uh pathways are attending this trip fantastic nice nice job it's great we should do more more of these all right I'll go ahead and call for the vote AI yes Logan yes Mr Rose yes Mrs Maguire yes Mrs Flores yes Dr agular yes and I'm a yes motion passes 5- Z with both student reps in the affirm that'll take us down to board comments Mr Rose thank you want wish everyone a Happy New Year happy New Year and for the seniors five months left the school keep up a good work and finish all the assignment do what you told get a good grade and move on with life looking forward to your graduation down the line I uh I attended the uh csba ethic um ethic
030workshop and I learned quite a bit uh it's amazing how how the law is bantly clear about the about board members conducts at the meeting or yeah in the meeting so what I'm saying is not naming names but if if there is an issue raised by a board member concerning the voting on a contract then then I was told that aor aard M can ask for legal counsel with the consent with the rest of the board members so what I'm saying is if there are the issues that raise concern with regarding the voting on the contract um for example me I have the right to ask for legal counsel because the purpose of thep purp for board member to ask the legal councel to get a clear guidance from The Firm whether a board member
031violate the law or not that's the only purpose for seeking legal counsel to seek clarification I did not get that I did not get that I would deny an opportunity to see legal counseling regarding Janette Flores conducts back in 2018 when he V to S to check her company she worked for so that is the issue that already miss settle but now that we all know that if there's an issue regarding the be um the conduct at of a board member I a board member can seek legal counsel that's one I wanted to reate uh I'm looking forward to be on the Roop it sound sounds good and it's very exciting uh I had opportunity to introduce myself with Dr Downey and she sound like a sound like an um she's wonderful and she's been
032there for four years and she told me that that she looking forward to working with me and the other board members next Thursday I want to thank the the Audi firm to prend the report and I want to thank I have full confidence in the we that every time we had a report that Carell Bradford and his team all her team like herself the entire team had worked dly to make sure that the the the procision will follow and that action by the team are following the guidelines that's provided by the state in California and that we should commend them for the wonderful job working together and I want to thank Dr Kim for taking the leadership role as the next superintendent look at forward to work with you starting today and onward I'm looking
033forward uh confidence and trusting trusting you in your ability to lead Char in the next four years welcome to board Dr Kim and the sports hope you got to keep up the work with the sports and the record's kind of tough but hopefully I know all the losses and all those not thinking oh my gosh you you know but don't give up we I'm sure the students are happy to play have an opportunity to play and that that more important than anything else keep up a good work and thank you Mr Peterson back to you Mrs Maguire happy New Year everyone uh so happy to be here uh it's a new year new beginnings time to work on new things and moving forward um yes shout out to co Sports we try our best and
034we have fun you know and that's what's important uh January uh you know tons of observations uh one of my favorites is that it's National soup month and I love soup um but also it's National Blood Donor month uh which is really important especially if you are a type O person so that we can make sure that we provide uh blood for all the folks who need it um especially in times like this where we are seeing um a natural disaster in our own Community um we're having fires all over SoCal but are we are hit close to home uh with the eaten fires um also the windstorms that uh impacted a lot of our families and even some of our campuses um so while we want to make sure we keep everyone in our
035thoughts and prayers it's also important to match that with action and dollars uh so if you can donate to a fund that helps support these families pleas do please do so um or if you can donate your time and go volunteer at many of the centers that are providing food and resources uh and shelter to these families uh that would be amazing uh we are still in my favorite season of the year which is FAFSA season and so I learned something new about the FAFSA is it possible yes it is possible for me to learn something new about FAFSA uh in California um I don't know if you have fallen victim to like identity theft or your health insurance was compromised or anything like that they have stolen the identities of our children and used
036it on fafsas uh I just learned this recently firsthand and gotten financial aid at schools in your kids names so if you have 16 and 17 year olds when they send you that information uh to get the free credit reporting do it for your kids too um I recently had to go through that uh during the break um I also want to say welcome uh Dr Kim uh your first go around as superintendent I think you did a great job we're okay you know good enough good enough uh welcome Dr FY in your new role uh exciting to work with you all in this capacity um also quick story our students were invited to participate in a rotary speech contest from Charter o High School um and even though we got our invitation kind of
037late uh our two uh girls went they represented our school district very well and placed in first and second um yep with a week's notice because that's how we roll in Charter Oak um and also you guys might know the winner her name is aie Valentine Wooh um and last before we go I always want to shout out a passing audit that is something that is really important uh and we love to see because that means that we are doing the appropriate things with our public dollars and so I'm really happy to have yet another passing audit congratulations uh to you Carill and all of your team thank you Mrs Flores happy 2025 welcome Dr kimy survived your first meeting did he do a good job flying colors [Laughter] great congratulations um also want to
038take this time to thank our First Responders that have been working on the fires um my daughter is dating a first responder so close to our heart and um we just encourage you all to please support communities as as you feel best um equipped to do so also um please go watch Shrek Jr and I do have those dates Royal o um Middle School is is putting another amazing production together so we have February 1st and 8th make sure you buy your tickets um also a big thank you to the Diaz family thank you um for supporting our children our schools and just going above and beyond so thank you thank you we appreciate you very much um and Carill Bradford she's I think you have a cap behind your coat because you're just a
039rock star and um I really appreciate all that you do to ensure that we are fiscally uh you're always spot on I don't know how you do it you have magic so thank you very much for your work and your dedication and we really couldn't exist without you so thank you very much we very much appreciate your work um congrats toi you're awesome will you read your speech next time all right okay well keep us guessing thank you um and thank you both for the great reports that you give we really appreciate you being here and just having this voice so thank you both um congrats Dr Mustafa when when did you finish your uh your doctorate wonderful congratulations we yay congratulations and thank you and we look forward to working with you so let's
040have a great year um and yes keep your sports our sports team um in your thoughts the the basketball team's tied currently I believe right Mr dos so cross your fingers thank you everyone Dr agular uh thank you yeah I'd like to Second so much what my colleagues have discussed so far uh of course the disasters has been very difficult affecting so many people directly and also indirectly um but it's been wonderful to see the community come together and support one another um and that's been fantastic including right here in the charter Road Community as well so um thank you for everyone for banding together and uh continuing to look for ways to be of service and help and that's always very important uh continuing with the congratulations of course again Dr Kim Welcome Aboard
041is our first official meeting with you under the superintendent banner and uh it's been wonderful already a few weeks in and uh you know comes with its challenges every day uh but we're glad to see you continuing to push forward uh congratulations Dr Mustafa I get a chance to go on many site visits luckily my schedule allows me to go on site visits oftentimes and join some of the administration and I get a chance to see uh firstand the activities of our administrators of our cabinet uh and Dr Mustafa often there in her direct rool previously uh you know supporting the education of our students right there getting to know all of our teachers getting to know all of our students and making sure they're well supported so I'm really excited to see her now
042uh elevated into this next assistant superintendent role as well it'll be fantastic uh with that uh I just want to share my appreciation of my colleagues my fellow board members as Dr Kim mentioned here in January in board appreciation month uh it's a very rewarding position uh there can be a lot of fun with it certainly comes with a lot of challenges as well uh and it's been a pleasure serving alongside of you for these past four years so thank you all right uh well Happy New Year yeah it's 2025 yeah congratulations Dr Kim he uh we were talking earlier in the week his first few days was dealing with all the tragedy and and fires Etc that were going on in a a little bit West of us and but he was on he
043was all over it he was making sure that our kids were ready our staff was ready our schools were ready to receive the kids uh we had several conversations about it and one of the things when we brought Dr Jordan in his first couple weeks was covid yeah and this is this is a test it's a test for you and you passed good job thank you uh but welcome sir looking forward to serving with you uh uh winter sports yeah the the the records aren't the best in the world but that's not because of lack of effort on both the students and the coaches because I know they're out there pushing it I've seen a I've been to a a wrestling match and I saw the soccer the other day and I haven't been to
044a basketball game yet though I haven't been to a basketball game so there I'll get to one but uh it's not from lack of effort the kids are trying hard and uh and the coaches are too so I appreciate all the efforts from everybody over there uh in regards to the fire the fires the First Responders I have several friends who are involved in that uh they're out there protecting the houses from looters Etc but uh Kyle Jordan which is Dr Jordan's son has been in the middle of it all all the firef he's a firefighter out in Arcadia and he's been working non-stop uh he's safe he said it's been an adventure but uh he's doing well and uh we're fortunate that we have so many people who are willing to get involved in
045the public service component of things uh Dr Mo where F congratulations ma'am looking forward to working with you and your leadership and continuing on for many years we saw the [Music] contract uh with that being said our next meeting is February 6 2025 which is going to be a board study session of our midyear review and we will go ahead and end this meeting at what time is it 7:26