CorpusRecord 3184

SUSD Governing Board Regular Meeting 2/11/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Scottsdale Unified School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Maricopa County, AZ
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,591 words · about 109 min
Collected
2026-05-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e I would like to call this meeting to order at 6 okay it's 559 and a half I'm just saying a little early should I let it clock to 6 I'm okay okay it's 6 we may start all right let me get the agenda going here okay as we call the meeting to order would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Mr shy pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all and we'll do roll call of attendance Miss uh Warner I understand you're in the cloud would you start please car and just real quick I do have an agenda item to just so when you move back to me so

002that was broken for me okay I'm going to ask you to repeat that Mrs Warner I think you were you just roll calling in yeah so I didn't don't know how effective this will be to remember to come back to me so I do before we vote on the agenda I do have an item I want to P so when you move back around after roll call just come back to me thank you duly noted okay thank you uh Matthew Pinsky Amy Carney Mike shy and Donna Lewis all right we have approval of the agenda and as Miss Warner noted she uh would like to uh amend the agenda that we've presented Miss Warner you want to H yes I'd like to pull 88 can you hear me 8 a 8 H H for okay

003and that it's just one item on the personal so I'm ping 8 H off of the agenda thank you any other amendments to the agenda as presented technical correction okay and I want to note that we have a technical correction that is in the board docs under 8h that is up to dat and accurate uh so board members will be getting a hard copy of that go ahead i' like to pull 8 F pull 8 F okay thank you any others all right I'll make a motion that we approve the con the agenda as presented with the exception of 8f and 8h uh from the consent agenda I need a second second all those in favor I I all right thank you all right I'll read the meeting decorum citizens attending and or participating in

004the Scottsdale unified school district meetings either in person virtually or telephonically are required to observe the same Rules of Order and decorum applicable to members of the governing board and staff unauthorized remarks or demonstrations from members of the audience yells outbursts Andor other disruptions are not permitted all right we begin with student and staff recognitions and celebrations well good evening president Lewis vice president shy and members of the governing board uh students staff family and community members and attendance tonight we're so glad you're here to celebrate some recent outstanding achievement by our students and staff uh this evening we're going to start in the world of Athletics and I would like to invite our District athletic director Nathan Slater forward to help us with this beginning celebration president Lewis vice president shy members of the

005board Dr menel Miss Wagner thank you for having us this evening I'd like to introduce the palm and the cheer team from chaperel high school up to the podium two separate teams we have two celebrations on some state championships for palman here at [Applause] chapparel we also have uh principal Joshua here thank you for coming Bubba good to see you congratulations to coach Chelsea and the chaero girls cheer team on November 22nd and 23rd multiple schools competed in multiple Spirit line competitions at Veterans Memorial Coliseum our chaero cheerleaders won the division 2 Division division one 2 game day small cheer competition scoring 123.5 points a full Five Points higher than second place williamsfield the chapero cheerleaders are now backto back AIA small D12 game day state champions these athletes have worked hard all season attending

006football games basketball games pep rallies and all this as opportunities to promote school spirit at chapparel they use these as well to help prep for competition routines at the state and National levels each season and we're very proud of their hard work and dedication we can't see wait to see what their future holds coaches joined this evening by Gabby gahata Maddie riotz Mor gy and Ariana luy so congratulations to our chapparel girls cheer team state champions also congratulations to Coach Sierra silk and the chaero Palm team on January 16th and 18th at the traditional state championships at Veterans Memorial Coliseum the chapero Palm team won the division 2 Palm State title with a score of 195 points better than number two Desert Mountain this has been an incredible record-breaking season for chaero Palm as they

007also won the D12 small game day title the first in program history the chaero Palm team also recently went to the Nationals and competed against the best of the best from all around the country they once again made program and State history by being the first team from Arizona to win a game day National Championship coach s is joined here by her team leaders brendy Atkins Bella crutchley and Cameron Murphy thank you again for being here ladies congratulations on an amazing season and uh congrats pal Ander at chaero high school congratulations Firebirds we do have more birds in the celebration this evening and I would like to invite to the podium Fine Arts coordinator Michelle Irvin to tell us about accomplishments from the world of music thank you so much president Lewis vice president shy

008board members Dr menel and glattus could I bring Finn Feldman up so I want to take a little moment to shine a spotlight this young gentleman also from sherel high school it's a big shepel night um Finn here was the only student in susd to make the All State jazz band on trumpet right Finn we're so proud of you your hard work your passion for music your dedication has really paid off I do also know that don't you go to Copa every single week and help the band I know that cuz my daughter teaches there so she's like he's there every week so um the All State jazz band actually opened up the amaa conference and this and his group performed and you had a very large solo during it too as well um your

009teacher Mrs Maro wanted to be here but they're rehearsing for the musical tonight so she want to do that so can we give all a big round of applause to Finn Feldman Trum from CH SCH and now we have another Shero what are you doing there Mr paner like hang out I love it can we bring that amazing Gold Dust Avenue singers that perform for us at the opening and they're bringing all their swag with some additional swag they got this past weekend um the Golda singers if you can believe it were in New York again for the you know New York strong sing Strong right sing Strong and they B second place again against the entire nation second place two years in a row incredible as an AC capella Ensemble which as you notice

010they had zero accompanist other than thems incredible enough but could I also have Sami zel step forward yes and Sammy will you turn around so the board members can see you and all that swag in your arms this young lady here won the outstanding soloist for the festival and arranger she arranged did was that your piece you arranged whether you performed today so the perform piece there she arranged that for The Ensemble so and you guys won the arranger last year too I think too right and to see two years in a row in a different person doing it unbelievable can we give a huge round of applause to the goldest singers under the direction of Sammy Brower Dr Sammy Brower unbelievable unbelievable and a very quick shout out that I was shown just before

011they received Superior ratings this last weekend in both Gold Dust Avenue and the Magical singers yes so Bravo extra Applause for that I want to give you guys some yes great job really good well Michelle don't go too far uh so congratulations students fantastic uh I am always Blown Away by our talent here and love to Showcase it and we have the most amazing coordinator of Fine Arts and Michelle Irvin not only does a lot to ensure that our students have amazing experiences but she does more than what other people realize so recently uh Scottsdale celebrated its 71st annual Parada Del Soul and uh Michelle is on the committee she helped Wrangle up 30 uh different entrance from scota Unified School District in the parade we had amazing participation uh Michelle has known that for

012the time I've been here every year I've begged to ride a horse and every year risk management said no and so I got a text one day and Michelle said how do you feel about being the parade Marshal and I said well I never thought about it she said well you get to ride a horse I said I'm in so uh I want to acknowledge Michelle for all of her hard work not only in the fine and Performing Arts but in terms of elevating excellence in way she serves s USD and I want to present you with this challenge [Applause] coin all right we're not done yet uh we have a couple of other uh celebrations this evening uh and from the SaberCat Community uh will be the first one and Dr sackos is going

013to kick us off our assistant superintendent for for secondary education thank you Dr menel uh good evening president Lewis vice president shy board members and Miss Wagner I'd like uh Saro High School senior and student Advisory Board extraordinaire uh brick Schultz to come meet me at the podium as well as any Saro administrators and teachers who have joined us here this evening for this presentation and celebration we talk all the time about being a school district that offers a worldclass future Focus Education to our Scottsdale unified students we have also uh we also have data that shows that the longer a student stays in susd the more academic successful they are such is the case with brick Schultz who has been an Su student since his preschool days at Puma Elementary from Pima to Mojave

014uh Middle School to sawaro high school broo has established himself as a leader in the community of which he is a part of whether he's leading the voices sawaro Varsity chorus as its student Club president leading the student cheering section at the school sporting events leading off off of of leading off at the plate as part of the State uh Championship Saro baseball game or helping lead the local make A- wish leadership Council being um a leader is in bricks jeans and it probably won't surprise you to learn that most most recently and he had to double down um on his studies and was an honors student uh an advanced placement student an AP student and he dug deep two summers as well as taking on tough subjects such as honors chemistry and American Arizona

015history to to learn a Year's worth of subject matter in just four weeks it is little to wonder uh then that we when it is searching for its 2025 Jenkins youth leadership winner that Scottdale leadership settled on brick I'm not sure why I'm getting emotional um but I'm I'm I'm fumbling up here but I've gotten to know brick the last couple of years on student Advisory Board and to see him grow is absolutely incredible miss a that's your job to shed a tear um and and Mom and Dad's I know I know you're out there um named after a longtime Scottdale High School social studies teacher and former mayor Jenkins the youth leadership award is given annually to a student uh who best exemplifies mayor Bill's example of being unassuming genuine Community community-minded leader congratulations

016on your award brick and please accept this susd challenge coin as a way of recognizing your outstanding career with our school district and our many wishes for your continued [Applause] success it's amazing to see these students who join and uh Dr Mensel can attest the Stu student Advisory Board and I can't say that brick was ever shy um but they're they're quiet and shy when they join and they find their voice he's always had a voice let me tell you um and so it's just I'm really proud to see him accomplish everything he's accomplished so staying with the uh social studies and Saro theme I'd like to invite to the podium someone who's been we've been seeing a lot of lot of you know who you are Ashley Crow come on good to so we

017just keep inviting him back because he keeps achieving such remarkable things Ashley was has been chosen for the Arizona Council for the social studies 2025 Isador star distinguished social studies teacher award here to tell us uh about what that means is Cheryl Sher stagel a former social studies teacher educated herself at our own cocaa Middle School Sherry yes Dr Menzel and members of the Scottsdale School Board good evening thank you for allowing us to speak uh I'm Sheri steel as Dr Sako said and this is Brian Flanigan Arthurs from uh Salt River schools we're here on be on behalf of the Arizona Council for the social studies to recognize Mr Ashley crows from Soro high school we recently awarded Ashley with the Isidor star distinguished social studies teacher award at our state conference on January

01825th this award is given in memory of Dr star the former president of the National Council for the social studies who believed in the power of implementing the inquiry method in teaching social studies this prestigious award is only given to that rare educator who consistently exhibits excellence in teaching shows initiative in developing and implementing original and imaginative lessons uses engaging instructional strategies and resources is given recognition and acclaim by colleagues as a leader in education demonstrates curriculum innovation disseminates ideas and techniques through presentations and mentors Educators and students and utilizes a variety of community resources to enrich the learning environment Ashley is the epitome of what the Isidor Star Award stands for Dr Menzel wrote in his letter of recommendation for Mr cros I can say with confidence that he exemplifies the technical competence intellectual

019rigor emotional intelligence and care and concern for his students that put him among the highest performers with whom I have ever had the privilege of working allow me to highlight some of Ashley's accomplishments and recognitions he developed the susd districtwide curriculum for teaching the Holocaust and genocide studies he's on Soro site Council he's the department the social studies department chair as a teacher leader and the adviser for the National Honor Society there also because Ashley cares so much about education of not only his students but he also cares about students parents and other Educators around the state and Beyond he has an incredible list of professional Awards and influential boards on which he sits which include the Gilder lman Arizona teacher of the year for 2024 national board for professional teaching standard certification both in

020original and renewal the chofar zachar award by the Phoenix Holocaust Association the a12 center chose Ashley also to serve on the Statewide teacher solution team also he is uh for the the Phoenix Holocaust Association board of directors and education committee he's also on the Arizona Jewish Historical Society education Committee in addition the na Martin Springer Institute teacher leader cohort the Arizona Department of education's Holocaust Education task force and he is now on the board of the Arizona Council for the social studies finally Ashley is one of only 24 Nationwide facilitators for training teachers using the curriculum he collaborated in developing with for the Echo and Reflections Organization for excellent and critically acclaimed Holocaust Education Ashley crows truly embodies all that describes the Isidor Star Award I am privileged to know him and to have previously

021worked with him and to call him a friend Su USD is blessed to have him thank you so [Applause] much all right Ashley it is said said that we stand on the shoulders of giants and I understand that you have a couple of mentors here tonight that you would like to recognize I do and thank you for having me back and I'll make this short and sweep because that list kind of made me feel exhausted myself so um I wanted to recognize the two people that hired me 23 years ago at Saro high school so I have my two Department chairs from 23 years ago Miss Linda Pearl and Miss Lisa white in the audience so I appreciate for I'm coming and thank you to Dr Mel the board my school admin and and colleagues

022thank you all right and Ashley here's another challenge coin and your ever growing collection um For Your Excellence and everything you do for susd and our students thanks so much congratulations Ashley but we're not done uh We've saved our largest celebration for last because it's part of a month-long celebration we're going to cover in a few minutes I don't know how long exactly but our College and Career Readiness director Amy DS has the honor of introducing our next uh celebrations this evening Amy hello governing board members president Lewis Dr Dr menel and Miss Wagner I'm Amy DS your College and Career Readiness director which also includes Career and Technical education and widely important right now in our society right um this is the ideal time to recognize our programs and our teachers our programs provide

023students with Comprehensive preparation for both Workforce and higher education CT student completers are eligible for industry certifications internship and ssd's own CTE graduation distinction we offer 18 different Pathways and all of our programs embed academic standards with Technical and Professional Standards the largest misconception about CTE is that it's not an academic program or that CT students uh CT is for students that are not seeking further education but nothing could be further from the truth CT is valuable to all students and provides skills needed for a competitive advantage in today's society a great example of this tonight is the 2025 CTE US presidential scholar nominee from Scottdale the United States presidential Scholars Program was established in 1964 by executive Award of the president to recognize and honor some of our nation's most distinguished graduates for the

024Career and Technical education component of this program students are initially selected based on their accomplishments and their Career and Technical education program students are nominated through the state's Chief state school officer and they can nominate up to five candidates who meet all requirements for US Presidential scholarship I would like to call up Julia [Applause] M Julia is one of the five nominees to be selected for the State of Arizona she has completed chael's Finance program in 2024 and remain Deca president this year as a senior at chapparel Julia takes all AP classes including Mandarin 5 perfect for business Pursuits other AP classes are calculus biology English for literature and composition her options for the future are wide open and one might wonder what are her plans for next year would you like to say anything

025about that you don't have to but we're going to find out by May right where your future is going um so I would like to give Julia a coin and wish her all the best in the National selection process happening this [Applause] month oh wait wait one one moment Julia one moment because that's really exciting but there's more news because she is also the only susd finalist for the Arizona base Flynn scholarship so we want to wish you well on that as [Applause] well uh Mr rer also um would like for us to mention another student he had who is Dante here with us tonight come on up uh Dante maruzo um Dante is another amazing senior who's taken our culinary program and is currently completing a second year of the business pathway he recently

026earned second place in the business finance series at the DECA competition so [Applause] congratulations susd is one of a handful of districts in Arizona that offers the Finance pathway learning about personal finance and the principles of Commerce are important to all citizens it also helps students achieve the Arizona seal of Personal Finance on their diploma teacher Mason renfer from chapperal high school was recently spotlighted for his high performing Finance program Mason's made the transition from a career in banking and finance to education in the year 2020 and he is now teaching our finance pathway at chaparell Mr rer also earned the the ngpf distinguished educator award this is a lifetime award that Educators earn by passing six different next gen personal finance certification courses he was also nominated by his students and won the fall

0272024 personal finance lab nominate your teacher award please come up Mr Renford for a challenge point another teacher CT wishes to celebrate is Miss tarnisha Tilson Miss Tilson has worked very hard to implement our new districtwide CTE internship program and she oversees the new community volunteering program as well her attention to detail and high ethical standards make her the perfect fit for these two roles Miss Tilson is also our CTE Law Public Safety program teacher her criminal justice classes are the best in Arizona according to more than just me say it again one more time crime scene investigation industry experts and Maricopa County Justice Department employees have commented reached out to me proactively to tell me about her program being one of the best they've seen best for testing skills mock trial performances Etc this

028year CT was able able to fund a new mock trial courtroom so that they could participate in Teen Court where students hear and decide real cases of their peers our Labs offer a variety of forensic simulations to make the class highly Hands-On and work-based the signature program is at Chael but next year it's also available to Soro students via a bus for period 1 and two just like our culinary program so please join me on celebrating the seconde teacher who's knocking it out of the park [Applause] uh next I would like to recognize Shelley Alfieri Brown our kad's engineering and coding teacher Shelly joined susd 2 years ago and has taken her two programs to new heights she has attended as many student ctso leadership events as possible and she has chaperoned a group of

029students to every single girls get it event in the last two years which is a lot she has raised the bar for student expectations and sets a great example as a role model of all things possible for her students her high standards and tireless commitment deserve a round of applause thank you [Applause] Shelly a little bit um next we have a few ctso celebrations that I'm going to lump together because if I read off all of these we would be here another hour so um RCT students perform very well at the future Business Leaders of America's Regional competition January 22nd scsd had participants from Arcadia Chappel and Saro who compet in categories ranging from accounting to supply chain susd had five third places two second places and four first place winners um Richard Norris desert

030mountains deck adviser he is continuing the legacy of a top award-winning marketing program he has chapon and led several dozens of students to our International competition level over the last four years since he joined CTE this year his team won six third places two second places six first places for performance awards at the DECA event and also won over 20 Awards in the written examination category with much appreciation I present a challenge coin for all of the fbaa and deca teachers that oversaw these events and prepared their students to compete I would be Shelley alfier Brown if you'd come up again Mason Renford Dave White Richard Norris Matt Boner and Anthony vogle who is a former CT Finance teacher of ulia and a current central uh CTE teacher on assignment overseeing curriculum and staff development

031hats off to all of you um the last ctso that I want to recognize is our technical theater teachers they hosted a local intradistrict ctso skills challenge um with Chelsea Brazen and Dr Tim McCanless could come up [Applause] please these two very edicated theater and CT teachers organized our first ever skills challenge amongst our own programs in order to better prepare their students for the state competition and their efforts paid off their CT winners included two superiors from Coronado uh for stage man management and Scenic Design and excellent rating for Coronado stage management chapparel Superior rating for their costume construction category Soro Superior for Scenic Design and the Soro Tech Challenge team was uh titled Saro scene Queens they tied for first in events that included not tying threading a sewing machine cable coiling which

032they had the fastest time and a lighting competition congratulations to the students and to these teachers for preparing [Applause] them last but not least and this person is is not here but I still wanted to read this for you I wish to recognize Chef Jack Trier for his culinary arts program Chef Trier has taught the signature program on a block schedule of two periods a day in order to increase the quality of the labs and the time spent in the kitchen this year Chef Trier has hosted three District events related to strategic goal four community and business Partnerships to promote and improve CTE programs these events provide a work-based learning for all of his students the events were well executed and delicious with Chef trier's dedication to Excellence CTE is now installing a fully furnished

033beastro Cafe complete with a new freezer and walk-in freezer freezer uh new Barista machine for hot beverages upgraded instructional lab equipment for the students Chef Trier could not be here due to teaching at SEC as well but he will be hosting a spring event like a CTE open house and uh we will be extending any invitation to the board to join us I hope we see you then um but please give Chef Tri a round of applause for all he does um in closing I just wanted to say CT is vital for students to explore the world of work and prepare for postsecondary whether it's College apprenticeships or Workforce CT help students gain skills for employment it is relevant and will always be relevant so thank you for allowing us to celebrate our students and

034[Applause] faculty thank you Amy uh it's always a joy to celebrate our students and our staff and that will conclude our celebrations this evening thank you Dr Manzel thank you everyone what Pride you bring to us we next have a special presentation it's the student Advisory board for 2425 it's a presentation on Arcadia high school chapparel high school Coronado High School Desert Mountain high school Soro high school and Scottdale online learning sorry uh good evening members of the board Dr Mensel Miss Wagner uh my name is Si riy I'm the president-elect for the student Advisory Board um and we're here today to give you a little student Advisory Board Sab update so tonight we'll be beginning by um discussing by the uh leaders presenting at tonight's meeting followed by an MLK assembly and dinner reflection

035which will be done by S here and then a subc committed wildly important goals or wigs update followed by a teen Town Hall upcoming dates okay student Advisory Board leadership I'm the president Victoria bushar kti this is the president-elect Fiona Riley um the senators from each respective School are Avery Lou from Arcadia High School Harbor hman from Desert Mountain high school Brick Schultz from sorro Claire Joe from chapparel and naam Pacho from Coronado all of them do a wonderful job okay so let me tell you a bit about the MLK assembly in dinner that the student Advisory Board went to um we had an amazing speech from speaker barari sers is a best-selling author um he talked about where we've come so far in like the civil rights movement and then where we have to

036go from here um it was an amazing speech we had some food I thought it was pretty tasty um and then um we had a speech from a newly elected mayor Lisa barasi um and we had some Scottdale city council people present there as well so it was a good time to network meet some new people um and have some good food yeah for subcommittees we work with the district uh for leadership and task with coming up with the widely important goals for academic Excellence we have Dr do Kon College and Career Readiness we have Mrs Amy DS technology and Communications we have Dr Watt and Christine Harington climate and culture we have Miss cron Safety and Security we have Mr fredman faculty committee we have Mr rler this is a new committee for academic

037Excellence by May 2024 create a promotional material to highlight the day in the life of a high school student to work with our partners in teaching and learn the communication departments to create videos to Shadow students and include reviews and course offerings so far our updates include met with a cinematog ER to brainstorm Logistics and creating a digital content content developed criteria that showcase academic Excellence student developed success in overall dynamic programming in progress meeting with principles to determine video creation I will be briefly talking about the College and Career Readiness by May of 2025 there will be an increase in the number of ecap components to be done at all high schools rather than on um for students on their own time for example resume writing internship investigations Scottdale area alumni chats with recent

038graduates for postsecondary exploration followed by um student presentations to other students on cth programs during the day and a brief update is students need to meet with their administrators about finding time during the day for ecap activities and Career Development Day a possible solution for a two period block to be allowed to begin activities of interest on early release date and students will be designing a day to invite career coaches from Scottdale Civic Center Library and possibly the rotary to assist students at lunchtime at school with essay writing and career matching activities in CCR platform for the climate and culture committee our wig for the year was to uh create and participate in three podcasts to share students favorable experiences in the district um so so far we've met with Communications to try and brainstorm

039ideas for each podcast um we've identified some potential filming goals and our first podcast uh was actually filmed a little bit ago um it was not Leon and brick it was myself and brick and we met um and filmed on February 5th okay so in the technology and communication subcommittee by May of 2025 susd will increase the availability of resources for students regarding how to use AI properly in a classroom environment um and the update we did decided we're going to do this um by making learning resources and activities available through Google Classroom as most students get their like homework notifications and other stuff on that making it convenient um and resources are in the process have being created um I saw some of them being displayed they they were pretty good um they'll focus

040on our magic schools AI program and trying to see how students can use AI without like plagiarizing or getting in trouble and how to use it constructively in a classroom environment okay um I'm lucky enough to be part of the Safety and Security um subcommittee and our wildly important goal is uh by May of 2025 we will have begun implementing new strategies to reduce vaping on campus as well as have a quantitative quantitative decrease in vaping incidents so for our update we reviewed data on incidents of vaping at the middle and high school level and looked for patterns like the location like where the vaping incident took place as well as the grade level we also discussed ways to address the root causes of vaping issues and connected struggling students to support services uh for

041example social workers and psychologists um we think that what underlies our whole goal and the strategies we're taking to achieve it is that substance use is an incredibly complex issue that relates to mental health addiction and social pressures we want to help all SD students find the resources they need to get help okay um next we have the Safety and Security continued um so we had an escape the Vape Community event in collaboration with SD Support Services blue zones the Youth and Family Services which is the scottd M's youth Council and the scotdale youth substance abuse Coalition um so we had um I was on that panel I was honored to be there I sat alongside um a doctor from honor Health who kind of went over the health risks of vaping um primarily talking

042about Vape induced lung disease um which is something that we're seeing on the rise especially in youth um due to not their lungs not being formed completely and being exposed to those chemicals um we also had a member of the Cancer Society of America common speak about um legislation that he has passed regarding Banning Banning flavored Vapes then we just went over some things that parents can do to kind of start that conversation with their um kids on how to dissuade them from trying Vapes and continuing using Vapes and now to talk about another wildly important goal facilities uh by May of 2025 we will'll be surveying high school students regarding facilities Improvement and what can be used in consideration for a future bond in addition we will be establishing a criteria to implement art

043in school bathrooms in order to reduce vandalism on school property and a quick update uh there's going to be a development of survey for high school students and then in process in process of establishing a criteria for bathroom enhancement and uh hopefully reducing vandalism if not prohibiting it now for the district upcoming team Town Halls Arcadia is February 18th from 11:45 a.m. to 12:20 p.m. chapparel February 12th from 12:50 p.m. to 1:40 p.m. Coronado February 25th from 11:45 a.m. to 12:35 p.m. Desert Mountain March 5th from 2:30 p.m. to 3:00 p.m. and Saro High School March 6 from 8:50 a.m. to 9:50 a.m. thank you for listening to our presentation if there are any questions we'll take those now Dr Pensky thank you for your excellent report and all the work that you do for

044our district across a lot of different domains I'm interested to see the bathroom art uh when it's when it's ready I'm trying to imagine that um but on the the AI topic caught my interest so I'm curious do you feel like it's clear to students currently when AI is allowed to be used in an assignment for example to kind of provide feedback on a first draft or to brainstorm research ideas and and when it puts you into a little bit of risk around academic Integrity yeah so on our technology subcommittee um I'm on it with Sid uh and we had a pretty big discussion when we were First beginning about disseminating information about the resources that SSD provides um we had a conversation about how magic school isn't necessarily um publicized to students I know

045a lot of my friends didn't know about it when I told them about it um and we thought that a large part of that was maybe teachers not quite being comfortable utilizing the technology quite yet um so we do think that that is a divide that we're trying to bridge The Divide between what students want to do but you know maybe they don't want to get in trouble and what the district is actually trying to help them understand and help them use um so that's definitely a big step we're taking is trying to figure out where the problems lie and where that disconnect is great thank you other comments questions Miss Warner just being mindful that you're there okay thank you I don't have any questions great job guys yeah thank you thank you thank

046[Applause] you thank you what a wonderful fill of energy in the room from our students and staff uh great job everybody uh our superintendent's comments are next thank you president Lewis vice president shy and members of the governing board just a few additional items this evening uh first yesterday I was was able to attend the school connect Summit which was held at the footprint Center in Phoenix along with members of our leadership team uh it's a it's a truly amazing event bringing together Educators nonprofit Business Leaders and the faith-based community to talk about how we work collectively to do good things for students across the State of Arizona one of the things that they often do is highlight student talent and it was um a real point of Pride when the Coronado marching band provided

047some of the student entertainment at the very beginning under the direction of Brett Bell as you know they're an award-winning marching band and what I heard was rave reviews from my colleagues who were just blown away by our talented students and so I just want to give a shout out to them I was certainly the proud superintendent of SD at that moment uh the the last thing that I want to highlight is that you know every month there are things that are U featured during the month uh February is Black History Month you've heard a review of Career and Technical education awareness month last week was school counselor appreciation week and so while we haven't called them out specifically I want to do that now to say we are so grateful for the work of

048our school counselors and the support they provide for our students uh digital learning day is on February 13th and uh tonight we have with us Sergeant Kevin Bingham uh National SRO day is on February 15 so Sergeant Bingham if you could come up here I do have a challenge coin for you because we appreciate our sros [Applause] and last but not least the end of the month uh 24th through the 28th of February is National Public Schools week and we will be celebrating all of the great things that our public schools are able to do and creating a special Community here in Scottsdale thank you thank you Dr menel all right that moves us to public comments I'll read the statement in compliance with open meeting law the governing board may not discuss or take

049action tonight on any matters raised during public comments that are not on the agenda however the governing board members May respond to direct criticism ask staff to review a matter or that a matter be placed on a future agenda item or as on a future agenda public comments will be conducted in accordance with po board policy bedh as a reminder each speaker will have 2 minutes the screen will indicate the time please be prepared to close your comments and relinquish the fer at the conclusion of your time the board asks that each speaker please introduce yourself by stating your name and whether you live within this school district for clarity of the record we thank you for your time and attendance here this evening and your cooperation in following the meeting decorum and protocols I

050will read the name of the speaker when you hear your name could you please come to the podium I will read the name of the next speaker to be ready on Deck once you start speaking your time will start our first Speaker tonight is Jeff R did I say that correctly and uh Luke Howen on Deck my troubles began four years ago I was blocked from summing at Arcadia High School 4 although the substitute was instructed both verbally and in written sub plans to refer to certain students by different names and gender pronouns and those displayed in Synergy rosters provided students are transgender The Substitute repeatedly addressed and referred to these students by their incorrect name and gender a week later Dr Menzel's office listed letters from these trans students here's one even though there

051was a note to correct my name my dead name was said more than any other naming class he read the note in full including the dead name of allowed several times then continued to say my dead name about six other times corrected by me in the class he also said isn't that right dead name we had corrected him several times which makes it seem purposeful he also dead name Max at least one as a result all of my future assignments were cancelled I was told I would be blocked from Arcadia until those train students graduated in 2 and a half years I went to the district office and met with Amy Goff she told me I would have to serve the suspension and that I should stay away from the school I did for 2

052and A2 years I then went back to the district office to meet with Alexis Wilson the director of Human Resources I told her I just wanted a meeting with the new Arcadia principal to explain to him I have nothing against transgender students she stalled for months and lied to me then she blocked me permanently from going to Arcadia I met with Dr Manzel who reversed that he promised me a meeting with the Arcadia principal who called me 3 days later and said well maybe I'll meet with you sometime next summer when I relayed that to menel he responded at least you got a chance to talk to him two weeks later I was fired for constantly arguing and verbally harassing The District staff last January 9th a federal judge in a decision that is the

053law of the land said it is unconstitutional for a school district to force a teacher to use trans identified student preferred names and pronouns he ruled they are violating that teacher's First Amendment rights and freedom of speech and Free Speech retaliation is forbidden as I stand before you Dr manelle refuses to allow me to sub in the Scott schools refuses to allow me to be a paid coach block thank you Luke howand and then we'll have uh Mike benger hello good evening my name is Luke Howen I'm the owner of rides and motion co-founder of ebike youu an online safety Program for Young ebike Riders that teaches Rider safety rules of the road and ebike maintenance if you don't know already ebikes are transforming how students get to school but with that surge in popularity

054we're also seeing a significant increase in accidents and injuries I know SD has banned ebikes but Banning ebik bikes on campus doesn't stop students from riding it just leaves them uneducated and unprepared ebike is not only for the kids but also the parents many of whom don't realize that ebikes aren't just regular bicycles a 14-year-old with no formal training is essentially operating a motor vehicle in traffic with no guidance and we are seeing the repercussions that's why we created ebike you uh we're already working with ebike companies speaking with local law enforcement uh offering free courses at private schools and communities to help spread awareness we also talk to susd safety director Josh fredman who sent me here ebik you provides structure education on ebike laws defensive riding accident prevention we have the ability to

055go beyond an online course provide on-site learning uh attend and host events and teach kids how to Ride Safer now we are just asking for the support of the community uh we are bringing schools the opportunity to be proactive and Implement real solutions that protect students rather than just protect the district from liability let's move beyond the bands and take real action to find a way to implement safer writing thank you thank you thank you Luke that brings us to Mike bengert and uh Petrina uh pens saini next did I say that right okay during the approval process for the Middle School planning guide you discuss the honors class offerings which only apply to a small percentage of students what about the other students in SD remember shy you said you were a data guy

056well here are some data last year in susd 8,100 students were not proficient in ela 9,400 were not proficient in math and over 12,000 were not proficient in science yet over 98% are passed on to the next grade or graduate assuming only elementary students who are highly proficient in subjects should take honors classes across all susd fifth graders there are an average of 300 students who are highly proficient in either Ela math or science that means over 1150 graders are not highly proficient and 600 of those are not even proficient yet they will be passed on to Middle School at Yavapai Elementary 74% of the fifth graders are not proficient in Reading 82% not proficient in math at tonala 78% of the eighth graders were not proficient in reading and 89% were not proficient in

057math at Coronado 74% of the students are not proficient in reading and 83% are not proficient in math but 89% will graduate in four years Yavapai and tono Leo proudly say they are Avid schools the planning guide lists Avid classes as electives the purpose of avid is to help students succeed academically news flash it's not working the planning guide has a couple of Senses about interventions and remedial help for students who are not proficient there wasn't any discussion about those students centering Middle School who are not prepared for even the basic coursework let alone honors classes why not Dr Menzel never misses an opportunity to take a few top students to the board meetings and showcase their academic achievements what about the thousands of students who are not performing at grade level you never mention

058them doesn't their education matter in grades 1 through three you learn to read after that you read to learn passing them along isn't doing them a favor you're setting them up for struggles throughout their education and lifetime shy I challenge you to find the root cause of this dismal academic performance and fix it so much for engaging all students in worldclass future focused learning Elevate Excellence what a joke parents wake up krina hi everybody my name is Patrina pensan I am an SSD Alam I had the benefit and privilege of attending anastasi Aztec Mountainside and Desert Mountain I know firsthand the importance of public education I'm a Community member a lawyer a PTO president a daughter a volunteer and a wife but the most important title that I hold is Anthony's mom and M abella's

059Mom I love it when my kids friends call me by that like many of you for me my children are my entire world I'm wearing a shirt today that states never under underestimate a public school teacher shocking to some I'm not wearing this to be political I'm wearing this because it's such a true and Powerful statement I remember Mrs cheva from anastasi my first SD teacher after I moved here from New York I remember Mrs Hubble from Aztec Mrs Brooks and Mr Tim Brooks from Mountainside Mr tartar who taught me in choir from seventh grade through my senior year in high school Mrs norager Mr Ormsby Mrs James Mr cedarstrom I'm in my 40s and I've completed doctorate level degrees and I remember and cherish my marvelous susd Public School teachers I say this all

060because each of these teachers and administrators created relationships and impacted my life in a positive way I say this because my SK my kids school Community Anastasia is faced with detrimental news regarding our assistant principal position being moved to a 0. five and losing our preschool program as we all know relation ships and love for Education start at at an early education we also know that we are worried about numbers for enrollment I am sure that the susd board and administrators have extensive knowledge regarding the importance of strong bonds and lasting relationships built with trust with Children and Families to have effective results this is going so fast um listen I feel like if we're all about because kids it's important that we don't cut important positions like assistant principal to five it seems counterintuitive

061and counterproductive and this is not just a plea for Miss Martin but a plea to reconsider all of the AP positions that are being brought down to a point5 they're really important they really care about our families they really care about thank you everyone all right we are now on item seven information discussion item uh it's fiscal year 2526 maintenance and operation and District additional assistance for sorry can can I interrupt because we didn't get a chance I'm so sorry I did that again didn't I all right sorry let me sorry shanon just give me a minute any comments or responses or questions or followup from the board sorry about that thank you um I would just like to touch on what our last uh speaker brought to our attention because I too am very

062concerned about this and I have emailed about this and I have asked for the board to provided with um you know these site proposed site plans and we have not received that it's very important that we understand uh what's going on and what the public knows that we do not know thank you thank you thank you Amy any other comments okay Dr Pensky no I was I'm sorry C uh Miss Warner any comments that might have been just a microphone can you hear me yes we can no here we go I'm ready can you hear me yes go ahead okay so so so to the mom who just spoke about the reduction of the aps um I hear you and I fought this last year I will fight it again this year I think it's

063absolutely a disservice to our sites to our students and our teachers to be reducing assistant principles and really any um site leadership and so thank you for coming share tonight all right thank you Miss Horn any other comments board members okay thank you for generating that idea those ideas for future agenda items all right we are now ready for uh the fiscal year 2526 M and daa projections Shannon go ahead thank you good evening Dr Lewis vice president shy members of the board Dr Mensel and guests um tonight we are taking another look um at our fiscal year 2526 mmino maintenance operations um District additional Assistance or Capital funds um for next year um I think it's important to start out with when we look at our budget and we look at our goals and

064and um prioritize um what to have in the budget we look at two main things goal number three attract hire develop support and train highly qualified passionate and talented professionals as well as generate and utilize resources to maximize educational opportunities in order to ensure organiz organizational health um I want to start out by talking about we have two overrides um within our budget that are provide additional funds for us um our voters have been incredibly generous with these two overrides and so the first one is the maintenance and operations override um that was a voter approved in November of 23 it started this current fiscal year that we're in um it last they last seven years but after 5 years you have to have it renewed or it starts a phase out product uh phase

065out of that override um so we are good for a few years um before that we would need to renew that or begin that phase out and it provides about $22 million in additional minino revenue for the district it does wonderful things for our district um it maintains our current class siiz ratios um so we've kept those ratios at the levels they are continues to provide um opportunities for students to deepen their understanding of Fine Arts and Athletics and extracurricular activities I think that was shown in abundance tonight with um of our Awards and celebrations with our Athletics and Fine Arts continue to provide competitive teacher compensation an emphasis on technology and continuation of Staff develop professional staff development um there are no admin costs that come from this it is it is strictly within

066classroom um and putting dollars directly into the classroom when we look at our IMO um the main thing that drives emo and how much revenue we have is what is our average daily membership or ADM um one of the questions that we've been looking at and things we look at is what is the trend what's happening with our ADM and um as you can see it's really hard to kind of project what's going to happen because our ADM has been really all over the board um covid impacted us like it did everybody else um we've been making a comeback from it but we still see that decline the one thing that I look at is what is our average change and what was our change last year or moving into this year we've been reducing

067it by about 380 is um between the average and the change within this year so that's really the number I went with when looking at how much should we reduce our ADM for next year I'm going off of what that average and that change for this year looking at where our budget was last year um this is the FY 24 final revision and where we are estimated now there's a little bit of a time difference here in that final revision happens in May everything's reconciled 100th day is done numbers are umth day numbers are in and reconciled we are not quite there we had our 100th day at end of January the numbers to be able to put this together um for the 100 day and verifi make sure they're right we're a little bit

068off uh we're not quite ready um so estimator revise will change a little bit between now and may when we do this again um but as you can see the total student weight count and what that is is you take your ADM and you get different weights depending on grade levels but you also get different weights for um Group B weights students with special needs free and reduced gifted um with that couple of the big things that you'll see is our amount per student has gone up 2% as it legislatively needs to we've been going down about 500 or so students in the total weighted count um our budget count budget balance carry forward was about a million less than what we anticipated so that's that's a little concern for me and feeds into what

069we're thinking about for next year um and then we have a what uh water savings is like energy it's money that we transfer into cover for um maintenance uh properties that we've done like with water with um solar those types of things Energy savings so the next part we wanted to look at when looking at this is did we project pretty close for this year when we were looking back you know doing this last year for for uh at this time last year for for the 25 or 2425 budget did we get pretty close and I'm really happy to say yeah with the ADM we were I was honestly pretty shocked to see that our variance right now is only eight off from what we projected so um that was really good news to see

070I don't like that it's down I wish we were you know had more students and we were projecting it up but that was good to see um I'll take it I I I don't know that that'll ever happen again because when you're projecting this far out for next year it's hard to tell um just little variances like I said our carry forward was less than what we were hoping to carry forward so that that made a little bit of an impact but all in all not too far off from what we thought we would be when we did this last June for the adopted so we move into with that knowledge what do we think will happen for next year and we're still we're still looking at what what changes there's even been changes from

071when I did this a few weeks ago and did budget projections um we now have our free and reduced and our gifted weights our numbers for that that was higher than what we quite a bit higher than what we were originally projecting um and so um we have increased that sum um membership we red uh ADM we reduced by a little bit from where we had originally so we're down to 381 on that but because those weights of additional weights for gifted and free and reduced were higher than what we had originally projected um we've reduced that to 483 uh loss for next year that equates to about $2.9 million in Revenue so that's the hard part of this is when we have that kind of loss it is a really big impact to our

072um M budget we anticipate the increase of the student base or the base level of 2% that should be what it is um which I'll put it at um actually it's 5100 um and then maintenance and override 15% and the capital override um at about 14.4 million what we don't know well there's a couple things we don't we don't know what our ADM will be for next year but we also don't know what's going to happen with prop1 123 um I think the state is still working on that and I'm hopeful that something comes forward with it um but we're getting a little bit closer to when we have to make a decision on that and there's still a lot that has to happen so what we're looking at is what happens if it if

073we don't receive that additional funding what happens if we do um right now we get $1.3 million from prop one 123 so with the um increase in our um base level the decrease in the amount of students and then factoring and we are bringing I I believe and I I I think I'm hoping this is where we get to I think our carry forward is going to go down about 3 million next year which is a hard hit um I say that because we did a 1% increase to our staff this year we did two but one of that was based off of uh carry forward um but we're just the district's not overspending it's just people are spending more of their budgets we all know when we go to the store it costs us

074more in life for everything it costs the district more for everything utilities are more when we need to do repairs it's more and so what we're seeing is that we're just not carrying over as much of that budget um as we had in the past because like I said it's just everything just costs more so um we are projecting bringing that down by $3 million for this next year those are the big changes if prop 1 123 doesn't go through it's 1.3 million so with that we start off with about a $4.2 million deficit to address same numbers only difference here is that if somehow one 123 did come back and we were getting the funding that we um have been getting then we'd have about a $2.8 million uh deficit that we need to

075look at when I say deficit I mean we would still have money we would not be in the hole um but that would impact our our our carry forward and you start impacting that carry forward year after year with that will that will become a problem if we don't start addressing it I thought it was important to to look at um we're Educators our our business is schools our business is teaching and so this just shows um where our people are staffed at um so I took all of our FTE and said okay if you're on a school campus that's a school if you're at a department level you're working at a district level what does that look like I mean I think it's appropriate 85% of our staff are on schools and this is

076all funds not just ml this is looking at all funds um and about 15% are in the district office and I think that's important when we start looking at we need to make Cuts we recognize that it's just when there's when the bulk of your staff are at a campus unfortunately that's where the cuts tend to hit a little bit more so just because that's where all of our staff are at um we did we've been making cuts at a district level um last year we cut N9 FTE from the district level this year and I'll show that in the future slides we are looking at a total of 12 District level FTE positions uh for next year we are still looking we've got some budget savings we're addressing we are all day tomorrow sitting

077in an office looking at Department budgets and going through those requests and needs um and still trying to figure out where can we find more savings um what can we do also knowing that we have departments that are saying I can't make it work with the budget you're giving me you I have to have a little bit more to be able to provide to our schools so looking at the positions within District this looks at all not just m there's M and capital are our main District funds but we do have a couple of other funds out there that are used um but we've identified almost five savings of um M for about $400,000 um teacher uh instructional trainer is actually split between classroom fund M and Indian gaming so that's why you see just

078a little portion of that out of those couple of pots um I uh idea is a Federal grant that we have there's two part-time positions there um so so savings within that Grant the other biggest one outside of M results spased funding um that is something that's not even funded anymore from the State we just we had been receiving it for a number of years a portion of it was going to a district level account to be provide professional development do some things and that's just if you don't add to it you have to you start to run those balances down and so there are quite a few positions out of there that would also be eliminated so then we start looking at well how do we make up a $2.8 to $4.2 million um

079deficit so um thankfully we are required um employees and the district are re are required to contribute to Arizona State retirement program um there is a very very small percentage change for next year which is great so that'll save the district about $330,000 it'll save employees a small little amount I don't know if it'll be noticeable but a small little amount as well because the percentages are the same for each we have been working with uh multiple departments human resources special education um Educational Services myself on what can we do to become less reliant on um consultants and outside um outside not Consultants but outside providers to meet our special needs programs and looking at what are our ratios and how do they compare with other districts um so we have worked through that and

080come up with a plan that we're pretty excited about that um lowers those ratios but also then provides pretty um significant stien to entice teachers to want to become teachers here within the district so we anticipate a pretty big savings from that however um private placement has been in the idea Grant private placement is when a student needs to go to another school for um certain reasons and that is becoming exponentially more expensive and so the grant can no longer fund that entire amount so whereas we're picking up a little bit of a savings um from some ratios we also know we got to move a big expense into M for that um we are we look at our ratios every year within classrooms we those are uh approved ratio numbers and because we are

081declining looking at those anticipated student to adult ratios at their in the classroom we antip uh anticipated about a $1.2 million savings there Department changes within M alone was 400,000 um and then um the assistant principal ratio change which was uh through the IBM process last year would be a reduction of three for Savings of 300,000 with that we still have a little bit more to do we're not quite there to cover the full two uh 2.8 million to $4.2 million deficit we are still working on it we're still coming up with some cost savings ideas I think I think we'll be able to cover the whole 2.8 maybe a little bit more when it's all said and done there I don't know where to find enough savings to cover the full 4.2 to find

082another one and a half 1.3 million in savings um that's the problem for us the other part that leads into it is we know it is very important to our staff um to be recognized with um knowing that cost of living increases every single year and being able to receive some type of um increase in their salary we've heard from our our employees we heard from uh the employee groups medical insurance is a huge problem for us and we have not changed the we have not increased the contribution from the district to our medical insurance plan in several years and that's just becoming a problem where all those additional costs are getting ped on to our our employees that was a big issue this last year we want to try to address that so we

083have this savings right now of about 2.7 we know to do a 1% raise to staff would be um 1.5 million um what we are looking at is some districts move District additional Assistance or Capital money from District additional assistance to M it is an option that we have within our budget and so what we are looking at is moving most likely because I don't know that prop 123 is going to be um addressed before we get into our budget cycle for next year um most likely about $4.2 million if we were to move those funds that would allow us to address the fact that one 123 has possibly gone away um but it would also allow us to B about 2.5 million um towards salary increases towards medical insurance contributions and then dealing with

084some of the fact that we know just things cost more um sro's facility needs those things just cost more um if we were to move the 4.2 over and prop 123 was addressed we can always when we do a revision later in the year we can always move that back from M over to um capital or if um something fantastic happened and our enrollment went up and we didn't see the loss in students that we were projecting then again if something happened with our revenue and we were able to we can always move that back over once we whatever we move over for salary and medical increases so approximately $3 million that's a continuing expense so if we do that next year that is a forever type thing that we would would have to do

085um because we've now put that into the base of salaries but it is an option that um unfortunately lots of school districts are looking at to be able to deal with um declining enrollment and also deal with knowing that um to to keep teachers to keep staff we have to we have to make sure that we're paying them properly District additional assistants or Capital we have two pots of that one is from the state that is um estimated to be about 10.9 million for next year we are carrying over 6.8 that's sitting in unallocated right now um that's why we feel like we can move some of that over to um M to address that um but that total if we didn't move anything would be 17.7 million for capital for next year we also

086have a capital override that was approved by our voters in November 22 um that is up to 14.5 million it's based off of our Revenue control limit um we have that for several years we've got until November 2030 before we have to renew that it covers Furniture fixtures and equipment Library materials Athletics Fine Arts playgrounds and Facilities curriculum and technology that doesn't change that doesn't we if we move money that doesn't change anything within this override that is voter approved that is pet approved those dollars will always be in those pots of money based off of what the amounts that were approved in the pamphlet so that would not that would not change what we if we were to move it would come out of the allocation from the state and with that might be

08714.5 it's right now we're looking at about 14.4 just depends on um where we think we're going to land for next year um with an estimated carry forward of 3 million one of the things we're running forward on some of these carry forwards is um not all the projects like we have things we want to do and we have things that that we're buying but they might not get in in time we might not be able to complete the project so when you look at some of those carry forwards that is part of it especially with this is we just know there's things we're doing there's things we're buying but if it's not received by June 30th it moves into the next year so with that that would put us at about 17.4 million um

088this just gives a a snapshot of our budget calendar some of this is already done we did meet yesterday for about half the morning um or most of the morning with the IBN groups all groups to discuss options um I think it was a really productive meeting we talked about you know what is it is 1% um what would it look like to do a flat rate to all employees what would it look like to do just a stip in um to all employees what would it look to just say to each group classified certified admin this is how much you're 1% you figure out how you want to to divvy it up um we looked at what could we put towards medical should we put towards medical um so a lot of ideas came

089from that that are really good um I have a lot more work to do to cost all those ideas out uh but we come back on February 25th we'll look at all those options again and then as an IBN group um make the decide choose which one uh everybody feels is the best option and then that would be uh brought forth when the governing board meets in March for um salary schedules uh and then in June we do the proposed budget and then the adopted budget um June 24th um so I'll open that up for questions Miss Warner I hear your microphone would you like to ask question hear me breathing yes we can hear you breathing would you like to make a comment or question thank you so much thank you so uh Miss

090ker I have a few questions common so pop one23 is backfilled in the budget are you aware of that yes um there's add there's additional funds that districts receive um that that those that's the the 1.3 so those funds um are end after one time yeah 75 million yeah this yeah there's an exra $75 million that portion ends this year so there could be some additional funds I just don't we don't know exactly what that's going to look like quite yet from the state yeah well I mean you can Google it it does say that it's going to be backfilled and it's is being pled into the budget so that would probably be something to confirm um just so that we're dealing with accurate numbers other uh item that I wanted to uh address was

091the insurance piece and I met with a CFO from another District this past Mee and we specifically to talk about insurance and it's a little alarming difference in the premiums with other districts who have the similar plans U particularly for the employee um option and so I want to revisit some of the options that you guys were looking at in the past you did tell me in our last bu committee meeting that we pay approximately $500,000 a year in administrative cost of chiros for the insurance and so I do believe I'm you know I had a conversation with Dr mel3 and um at that time I was on the education plan with shield and I I shared that with him because it was on his desk and his hesitation with it was that it would

092would have to hire an administrator um you know I don't think that it cost UniFi H administrator and um go to different type plan but these I'm looking at the the the premiums right now for our staff and um it's it's just not accept we have to get Miss crer would you uh Excuse Me Miss horer go ahead go ahead I was just going to ask Miss crer to summarize the elements of what you heard just to be sure it when it came across a little fragmented that you heard each other properly yes thank you for that I believe what I heard you say was that um looking at some of the other insurance plans the amount that we're paying for our administrator administrative cost of about $500,000 um looking at that and would it

093be in our best interest to do that ourselves instead of spending the 500,000 on that um and then I believe you also were bringing forth uh the premiums I know what we have for premiums are unaffordable at the family level um and that is one of the unaffordable with it um and just the fact of what ours is costing versus other school districts is that correct yes okay thank you other comments questions M Mr shy no I'm sorry I wanted wanted an answer to that so I can absolutely address that um we are oh go ahead we are looking at a couple things um yes there are administrative costs um we have looked at a couple different options um we did do an RFP a couple years ago to look at would there be a

094lower cost option um one thing we haven't dived too deep into is hiring our own um administrator we we don't have the staff in school district folks are generally not health insurance um experts and so um we we have kind of looked at it and we can absolutely revisit what would it looked like to administer our own program um what I would not want to get into is being a deciding factor on whether or not somebody's claim was approved or or not approved one thing we you sometimes can get when you're in a pool um is the benefit of a better um better buy better buying purchas power because there's more people involved in it we're self-insured but we're still part of the big kyus pool there's other trust like Valley schools has the same

095type of thing you can be self-insured within it which means you're covering your claims but you're buying power for the RFP is through um multiple entities which can sometimes not always sometimes help with that um our we went to each IBN group this year and said we would like two representatives from each group to um help sit on a insurance committee to look at what we're doing um we have found well KY Russ redid a medical pharmacy uh RFP this year and identified about $800,000 in savings for us through that that already is in place um there's a couple other changes is that we anticipate about a $1.2 million savings next year our IBN group is working on what are some other cost-saving ideas we can do how can we continue to educate um and

096then the other thing we'll be doing that we've been tasked with is figure out how to make at least one plan if not multiples at least one plan affordable um and so when because we're self-insured we can decide what those premiums are we have a dollar number we have to get to so it's 20 million 21 million that we have to get to we know how many about how many people are on each plan and so what we then do is look at it and say okay based off of how many people are on each plan and how many are single versus family versus spouse we can put in the dollar number and and play with that just knowing that we've got to at the bottom number get to 2021 million so as an IBN

097committee group uh the end of this month we will be meeting and we will be doing that fun task of prioritizing how can we make one of these affordable I think I think we're getting there the Self Insurance trust is going to contribute $2 uh 2 million more for next year but we still have a lot of work and we still want to keep looking at all the options that are out there and if there's a better a better way to go chyos or another another system um so we we do plan it to keep looking at those things okay thank you and it might be a good idea to revisit the you know the the cost for shield and maybe that's just a possibly a a better Avenue for staff so that they can

098have good health insurance at an affordable price um and then I last one so as far as with the cuts um again I I'm not a fan of cutting at sites um those are the people that are Hands-On with our students every single day and you know it's was looking at even District staff and nobody nobody wants to let anyone go I I get it I don't want to do that either but you have um the district the assistant superintendent all have their own administrator um I don't know about the directors if they do can they share when we reduce at the top level so that our our sites can maintain what they have been having and I'd like to see if if that's a reasonable thing that we can do instead of getting rid

099of both and reducing staff and particularly to staff with hands on absolutely and that's something we keep a discussion we keep having um uh Miss Miss Mitchell Dr sackos Miss cerum myself uh Dr Cruz we meet um every month and that's when we keep looking at what what what other changes can we make uh cabinet has had that same discussion within departments is if somebody leaves do we need to fill that position um relooking at how we how we staff um so absolutely we'll continue looking at all of those things because this is just going to get Tighter and Tighter yeah thank you so my last thing so Dr Manel where do you stand of the conversation and I'd like to hear uh I'm sorry I did not hear the question can you repeat it

100please yes absolutely so I said you you've heard the dialogue that that exer and I had I would like more input and what yours are um for the things that we have just discussed so uh we've been reviewing the bud I I think I understand the question so in terms of uh the types of reductions that we've been making we as a district are committed to keeping the reductions as far from the classroom as we can but if you go back in the slideshow you'll see that 85% of our expenditures are already at the building level and if you look at what's not at the building level aund of the people are bus drivers Transportation or other support that that uh we need in order to be able to get kids to and from school

101so the pool of individuals that we can look at reducing we've already last year we reduced nine we've got 12 on the reduction block this year even if you shared the secretaries like you just mentioned you're going to save 50 to $75,000 doesn't get you very close to the $37,000 so yes we're looking at all of those options every time there's a vacancy we're asking the question whether or not we need to fill it uh and we're looking at what the Practical uh impact of those decisions are so we're not leaving any stone on turned we are in February our final budget uh gets brought forward first for a first reading in June and then a final at the end of June so we still have time to put this together the most important part

102is to identify whether or not we have made enough progress to address the budget deficit that Shannon uh outlined earlier and I think we have uh with a plan towards how we could still provide pay raises for our employees and address the health insurance piece and we're continuing to aggressively pursue options on the health insurance that we can reach that level of and outp put quotes around it affordability because in this country healthc care is broken so affordability is a relative term but we have to do better than we were able to do last year thank you thank you thank you Miss Warner Mr shy thanks for the info um I know you talked about looking at head count and getting together in a room and going through kind of line by line um I

103know it's a different side of the budget but um operational curriculum technology vendor Services how is that done who kind of looks through that what's the process on that side sure um so there's two sides of it um when we're talking about um equipment that falls through Capital um we so most of the capital budget ends up going to either facilities or technology facilities technology or curriculum um so that really goes to those Department leads as to what their plan is with you know technology replacement Dennis always has the same very pretty much budget to be able to deal with what if a chiller starts to go down which we're seeing a lot of that happen so that side is the equipment part of it what we'll be doing and and we keep tweaking it

104a little bit each year so this will be the first year we've done it the style we're doing it this way we're trying to tweak it every year to get a little bit better but this year what we did is we told all of the Departments you need to prioritize what your budgets are and you need to prioritize what what you have to have what would be nice to have um we then will go and um sit tomorrow we'll look at those things so when people put their budget in we used to have a build on a piece of paper and they submitted it and basically the finance team went yeah that's more than what you had last year we can't do that what we're doing this year is they actually put it in our

105budget program with envisions our financial software and so we'll be sitting tomorrow they were asked to put in notes they were asked to prioritize they were asked to share and we've told people hey we may need to call you and have you come down or you know sit up on the phone and explain why you have to have this this you know what you're doing um some things we just we just know we know utilities are going to be utilities and and they're going to go up but when it comes down to what of those Department budgets we're really trying to look at what do we have to have what you know what can we we get away with the hard part we're finding is really um stuff just costs more everything and and I

106know I know lots of departments have said I just just need a little bit more so um tomorrow I think will be a very incredibly difficult day um going through and trying to make some of those tough decisions and it probably it'll have to I'm sure probably be scaled down again because until we have everything finalized with positions and know exactly where salaries and benefits are going to land we may have to trim it down even more but that's that's our process for this year is to just go with all of all of the area leads what did you put in and and why do you have to have it thank you other board members uh Miss Carney thank you president Lewis okay um I just have a few questions here try and uh be

107brief on the slide number 14 I believe where it talks about the assistant principal ratio change it shows minus three now is that 3ft or 6.5 it's a total um so because we're going it's actually six sites so it would be a total of three FTE so at six sites we're looking at going to halftime assistant principles yes okay and um you know we we've expressed concern with that and um I am not I'm not for that as well we've got to figure out how we can do better with that my question is and I I've stated this before the override passed right the community passed that override is there a way to go to the community and Survey the taxpayers on where do they want to see that money go to do they want

108to see it you know do they want to retain their assistant principles at those schools I mean I think it's important that we we look to the community we are supposed to be looking to them for the input because we are taking you know their money and we're very grateful right that we pass those overrides where other districts uh have not been able to do that so I think it's important to um survey the community on some of these on some of these Cuts I just don't agree uh as well and I would like to uh for us to all look at I was going through the uh the annual comprehensive financial report for 2024 and I just wanted to bring up a couple things um from 2023 to 2024 we already cut 59 instructional

109teachers instructional AIDS we we cut in the one year 59 positions according to this uh report where in 2023 to 2024 we added 71 uh in student services so we need to look at that discrepancy and we also added in 20203 um to 2024 we added 44 uh support and administration positions so we've already I've already seen the trend of we're cutting a lot of positions in uh you know our schools and adding to student services and support and administration so what I would like to see is if you could provide the board the 2025 um equal numbers to page 125 of our annual comprehensive financial report that would be very helpful can I ask a clarifying is that um because I don't have the AFR in front of me is that the summary page

110that is or is the m Ando page that's that's the summary page of these positions on the full-time equivalent District employees I I think some of that could be because of Esser and some grants that we've been awarded that may not just be M um I know when we cut a lot of positions last year it's because Esser was going away um so I mean I'll absolutely dig into that more I think I think that's probably um part of it is that we have received quite a few grants um for like social workers and and some other areas so I suspect that's it but I will definitely look into to the differences within okay that would be that would be great so we can better understand the specific numbers uh my lastly on the slide

111that talks about with the uh M override that we're going to maintain classroom sizes I have been I have heard from teachers uh concerned um that their classes are actually going to be larger for next year because um that some of the elective teachers are being cut those positions are being cut and teachers are going to have to now take on more students as well as teaching electives along with their current curriculum so people I've heard concerns about this um Can can you let me know if that is fact true that we're are going to be maintaining classroom sizes yes um I will work with uh Dr Cruz and HR on that side of it we do have the ratios within so those are the approved ratios that are within our strategic plan those are

112the numbers we've gone with with our override pamphlet so we will make sure um there could be you know if you're one or two over I mean I know that's over um so there is within our language a little bit of wiggle room there but it shouldn't be much over that so we'll absolutely take a look at that I know that they look at that when they do Staffing which has was been working on for the last couple of weeks um probably months actually um working on that I did want to you had mentioned about the override the M override because it's voter approved we are um Bound by what's in that pamphlet to go by that there is some provision in there to allow to deviate from that after the first year my fear

113has always been if we tell the voters if I stand up here and I stand up at town halls and I tell the voters and others tell the voters this is how we're going to spend our money and we don't follow that strictly then um that could lead to problems down the road um so we have always adhered very closely to what was in that voter pamphlet um and how it was in there um with the override with both overrides the the m and the and the capital override um but definitely I think as we look at what happens throughout the future to get feedback okay yeah yeah because I guess that's what I was talking about I agree right and we've been told that we don't want to deviate from what the public was

114told when they voted for it so that's why I say maybe we go back and Survey them and explain the situation we're in and would you agree to changing some of you know some of these these things and I think that the community would probably be on Bo with that but how do we know until we ask yep we can look into the legality of that sure thank you thank you Dr Pensky thank you excuse me thank you for the comprehensive presentation uh couple of questions so first um picking up actually on Miss carne's question from open comments and I think I'm in line given its budget related when parents talk about hearing that a position is being moved to Half Time For example are they speaking about what they understand our plans on for

115next year or are they speaking about in-year adjustments that we're making relative to the current budget cycle I mean know without knowing the exact comment when we talk about what we're looking at for here this is always for next school year this is for next school year this is not for this school year um you know once you get into the school year you never want to go changing classrooms you don't want to have to change kids out of classrooms we've looked at before you know we we do projections and at the beginning of the year you might have a class that's really really small and another class that's a little bit heavier we it's really difficult once we've started to make those those changes nobody wants their child move from where they're comfortable to

116another classroom so generally when we talk about making changes it's for next year not that some small little things couldn't happen during the year but um that would be well communicated or to to families and that would include something like an assistant principal position being moved to halftime that typically wouldn't happen that would that would not happen the middle of the year that would happen at um later in the year a decision we have to make relative to the budget for next year yeah and then picking up on um Mr Shy's question am I understanding your answer correctly that we don't say to different departments look unfortunately we have a 2% decline in enrollment I know it's not literally enrollment because we have all these technical ways of defining it um and therefore we have

117whether it is literally roughly a 2% decline in Revenue unfortunately we have to cut x% in our non-pop operating expenses bring me your budgets that are 2% less for example that's kind of what we did this year we informs people hey we do need to make Cuts we're losing enrollment you need to really think about um how you reduce that one of the areas that makes it really difficult and I'll just use facilities um CU that's under me is um even though we're declining in students we still have the same amount of space we have the same amount of classrooms that have to be cleaned we have the same amount of fields that have to be mowed we have the same um so um there's still the same amount of air filters that have to

118be changed every year there's same and so it's hard with some of the Departments even though we don't have as many students they still have the same amount that they have to do um and so some of them it's a little bit more difficult to do that um and some of them their budgets are so tiny a 2% would be like maybe 50 bucks you know wouldn't be because they just have a really tiny budget um so we are I think that's one of the things we are looking at right now and what we'll be looking at tomorrow is um you know what have have you made a decrease um you know like I said there's some areas that are just out of control um or they're just they're not in our control to to

119reduce them anymore I can't I can't control what the SRO costs are from the city they just are what they are and if they increase they increase um so those are all things we're looking they not all that right some are variable some are absolutely variable yeah um so that's one of the things we're looking at on all of those is how is there places we can cut and and I've Pro I've looked at them already there are some cut there are some definite areas that people have cut in and said nope we don't need to do that um we can cut that back some the hard part is when your budget is 86% salaries and budgets yes or salaries and benefits you can cut some money out of supplies but it's not going to

120make a huge supplies and services it's not going to make a huge dent but we all need to chip in and that's what the conversation has been yeah looking back uh thank you so looking back if you go up to the um average daily membership Trend data M so that's slide four yeah it is pretty remarkable the average percent decline is 2% um you have the big drop for covid and you have the big jump back but the the ker or the annual uh average uh percent change is 2% and then over the last few years it's been 2% so it makes sense to to forecast it at at 2% to State the obvious everything we do to make this year's budget work or next year's budget work going to be doing it again 12

121months from now we are in a cycle due in part to demographic changes and do in part to capture rate and our ability to convince as many families in the district and I don't think we want to steal from surrounding districts but it'd be nice surrounding districts you're welcome to uh to choose Scottdale schools everything that we do we cut five positions this year we're going to have to find five positions next year yeah uh these are more systemic which is part of why I push on that question around um fundamentally rethinking our expense structure and not only solving for the change in revenues that we have this upcoming year because there's a a broader headwind that we're facing well and that's a great point in all reality I mean we talk about moving you

122know a few million dollars from Capital this year we will forever have to do that do we have the capital dollars to do that the following year and to add to that because if we don't change the course we're on how do we get raises how do we you know afford raises in in the future so those are all um I know as a group we're working on next year I'm already looking at I five years what are we going to do for the next couple of years because um the trend isn't changing yeah there's I think there's an inflection point level of change in addition to kind of our annual yes efforts to try to mitigate the change as as much as POS possible and then my final question um as I joke there's

123like five different ways to define the concept of an enrollment with these different acronyms yeah and I asked you last I if it was last month but last meeting is there a way to quantify the Lost Revenue associated with the decline of you know 300 if it turns out to be the case 390 or so um and so so is the answer the 2.9 Million yes yeah okay even though that's a different that's s swc versus roughly speaking change in enrollment is going to cost us 2.9 Million in Revenue because you have that weighted count as well as um the override so what I literally did is said if we stay just flat and kept that number the same based off of what we know you know for a BAS amount and revenue or um

124and the override and all those things what what's the difference and it's $2.9 million yeah just sorry and I did have one last question I apologize um so the exercise that you're involved in is to identify as many offsetting expense adjustments and ultimately come back to us with a view of here's here's one way our recommended way presumably that if the world turns out to be what we think it is from enrollment perspective that we get there on the expense side how in our process and maybe this is a do mental question how in this process um picking up on Miss carne's comment I think does the board where in the process does the board reflect our priorities and values so I would hate for so much work to be done and then we say

125well no $300,000 from a just picking that example 300 ,000 from assistant principles it's just something we're not comfortable with and then all of a sudden we're under the gun in order to get to an ultimate budget so can you just as the Newbie going through the budgeting cycle I appreciate the question thank you uh I would say first the board in in part set the direction for us when they approved the SAA agreement a year ago that had the uh ratios in it for principal assistant principal I'll give you an example so Cherokee Elementary has over 700 maybe 750 50 students they have a principal and an assistant principal we have one of our K8 schools that has fewer than 300 students K8 they have a principal and an assistant principal and so in

126having the conversation about what level of Staffing is required in order to be able to meet the needs of a building the needs in a building with 750 students arguably are a little different than the needs in a building with fewer than 300 and the question is what can we support what's an equitable distribution of resources it took almost two years of bargaining through IBN to get to the ratios that were approved by the board last year so the marching orders for administration were governing board approved so the part of the question that that I would say when does the board get to weigh in in part is when you approve those IBN agreements because that sets the path for the future now we have three new board members who were not a part of

127approving that IBN agreement but that was what was approved last year and that's been how we've been operating there's been no change in that and under Arizona law the the board can act unilaterally but it would be in violation of board policy ha which says that we're going to engage in a bargaining process interest based negotiation with our associations to get to that point so that's part of it the the other part I was just even looking at the uh the numbers since I got here uh in 2020 um at that point 2.4 million of our budget was spent on security this year 6.1 million is being spent on security so we've increased our security expenditures in terms of personnel by 3 68 million over that period of time so the the issue is the

128the board always can talk about the priorities but there are tradeoffs if we don't close a building if we don't make some of those other decisions you can eliminate Transportation but that has another effect as well we try to balance that we do as much as we can through attrition so that we're we're trying to avoid a direct negative impact on our employees who we value we work hard and have been able to provide pay increases every year since I've been here which has not always been the case during difficult Economic Times in the in the district but we've been able to do that so far uh and so the board always has the opportunity through review of the budget to identify what the non-negotiables are but whenever you draw a non-negotiable here that means

129there's going to be some give somewhere else and as you've seen there's not a lot of U fluff in those areas and the things that Shannon mentioned that are outside of our control we know that there are inflationary pressures we've already received it from vendors saying that with the new tariffs we're expecting an increase in some of the supplies that we're uh procuring if you think computer technology that we get uh there going to be there will be a ripple effect the cost of gas has gone up again the the cost of food has gone up uh in some cases pretty significantly so it's balancing all of those things uh I do believe that as as this governing board has an opportunity to work together there's an there's a chance to identify what the priorities

130are to set some targets or markers along the way uh we've had to start this year um long before we got to this point just in the preparation phase and it's really been Guided by the IBN agreements that the board approved back in June so just as a followup there looking at the calendar the next thing on the board is June 10th proposed budget to board and then two weeks later adopting is that so the March 4th meeting is important because that is there was a change in state law where we can't issue contracts before March 15th historically districts kept moving up the timeline when they were issuing contracts because we all want to attract and retain Talent people um when they sign a contract are signaling that they're going to stay here that helps

131us know what positions are filled and where we might need to look for additional Talent so that meeting on March 4th is important um we anticipate well we have't we can go to two ways we once we know what the IBN recommendation will be um for salaries and and and medical um that would be for that March 4th I mean we can I don't have it on there we can always come back with another action item to say this is you know we've gone multiple ways so so there will be more budget discussion on March 4th if we need to add another budget discussion for the April 1st meeting uh or if you wanted I mean there's there's the potential to have more discussions to help identify where we are in the process that the

132reason March 4th is important is those contracts go out for our certified staff the week of spring break the earliest that we can do it March 15ish and and then they have two weeks to to turn those back in and so that's a really important date in the budget cycle uh after that there are still a lot of things that can can move so new information the legislature decides to move forward on XY or Z if we get any positive variance at all we can incorporate those we have until the end of June to adopt our budget there the state over the last three years hasn't adopted the state budget until the end of June so we've had to adopt a budget um without knowing with certainty what the state's budget's going to be thank

133you yeah I I wish I hadn't used the assistant principal example I should have used the social media example like if I was against if I was for social media and really wanted to pound the table to keep that social media position uh when in the process we'd have the opportunity not asking you to solve an impossible equation where everything is you know um candy canes and lollipops and we never have to make difficult decisions but to Mike's Point or Mr Shy's point that calendar wasn't clear to me when there's an opportunity that isn't well gosh we have to approve it now because the budget's about to you know the fiscal year is about to start and so on that there is a space for that discussion in an ideal cycle that conversation would happen

134with the board probably August and September before we start interest based negotiations so when you think about the IBN process um the board has interest as do our employees and so getting clear on what those are to inform that process on the front end then helps us as we move through the rest of this calendar here uh because we have a board starting January makes it more difficult uh this will be the same board uh borrowing any unforeseen changes when we get to next fall so that would be an ideal time to kind of set the parameters and say okay here are the things that we're seeing these are the interests that we have that helps inform the work we do at the at the bargaining table so that recommendations you see should then reflect

135those interests can I I will add on there so on March 4th um you know if IBN says we want to do we want to increase I'm just going to make I'm just saying 1% and we want to to put some money on to Medical if if if that happens and the board approves that then that I take that as my cue that I have that we're moving three4 million from dah to emo because that's the only way to to cover that so some of it is based off of decisions that are made as we as we move forward as to I take that as my cue move that dah money over um because that's what has to happen to make those should District additional assistance yeah District additional assistance excellent discussion uh Miss Warner

136just want to Circle back any anything okay I'm good thank you very much anybody else Rich discussion thank you so much we're now at consent agenda I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda items a through e g and I through M that means we've pulled F and H so I need a second to the motion to pass the consent agenda as described second that motion okay all those in favor I I I I Dr Pensky um I did want to make one quick comment but what I'll do is just abstain from the vote if I can make can I make the comment so I just want to acknowledge that I work in the education technology industry and um as such I want to be extra careful to never intentionally or unintentionally vote on

137something that in any way could relate back to any companies well I'm involved in the appearance of either a real conflict and and even a perceived conflict so I did want a flag on the education technology Consortium just because it has the words education technology um I did just want to ask and clarify is that approving any specific technology purchases or is it just approving our ability to make future approved purchases through a Consortium that presumably gets us better rates or what other advantages there are so uh I did some checking with our team and and this Cooperative hasn't purchased any of the the um organizations that you've been connected with there software programs that U might help connect with Synergy but they're not something that we would purchase or support so somebody else in

138the Consortium might secure that but susd uh does not anticipate that is not a part of what's in our plan U that's according to a Dr bachna who oversees any purchase that would be related to Synergy the motion passes as a 40 uh and then abstain 401 okay thank you but to be be clear I don't work for Synergy appreciate the the ultra cautionary transparency it's just it's just the checking the right conflict they were connections with so I've got Intellis spark canvas Mastery parchment um that those have been maybe used by someone else they haven't been purchas yet could connect I just want to pick up on your comment on Synergy thank you thank you that brings us to uh first8 F Mr shy you pulled you want to comment and then we'll make

139a motion when you're ready thanks this is just uh informational and apologies for not handling it beforehand but um the first line I'm on there Educational Services LLC for temp employment recruiting um looks like it's a big Miss from a approved amount of 1.5 and asking for 2.2 just asking for some color on that m not on I need to borrow it says on says on can't hear it you know what that okay um so Educational Services or ESI is the company we use when um employees retire from the district and then want to come back and um work through ESI in that in that same role um we don't always know because people can retire throughout the whole year so when we did this originally we go off of what did last year look

140like it was 1.5 million um we've had people can retire we're changing this but people can retire throughout the whole year which can make a change in how much we're paying to ESI because maybe in June we had 10 people and and then as the year progresses we're up to 15 or so people and so that's why it can really fluctuate that there's also stiens that they can receive through ESI or they could do extra work through ESI tutoring other programs and so um we we've just had more people going on that program um they stay on it for a year and then they come back then come back to the district as a return to work so the difference is really in um we've just had an influx of people going on ESI this

141year above what we had anticipated back we we brought this to the board back in May um and so when we do this again for next year we'll definitely project at a higher level because I'd rather we don't want to project too high and then that causes question as to why are you increasing it so much each year um but it this one can fluctuate quite a bit so we'll add a little bit more to it next year when we do our projection for next year just anticipating that it could it could go up but it's just because of um retirees going on that program and and supplemental and you I don't know this the situation here with other companies I've been involved with there's a hey I'm going to retire but then come back

142as a consultant I'm actually doing better if I do that than if I stayed is there any sort of gamesmanship with this I just don't know the context of why someone does that so um you so with State retirement you have to be out you can retire but you have to be out of the system for a year before you can work for a school district again so going to one of these companies means that you can retire from the district so say you've got 30 years and that's a that's a good point for you there's a multiplier at 30 years um and you maybe only want to work another couple of years you could go on ESI retire and if you go on that program you come back but you come at back at

143a reduced rate so the benefit for the person is that they're receiving State retirement and um you know and pension you pension and and a paycheck from from the district um but when they come back we bring them back at a lower rate than their yeah it's I think it's what 80% 90 90% so there is a reduction a return to work yeah for so the the uh additional expenditure in this are we making that up in salary savings because we no longer paying them okay thank you Miss Warner did you have some additional questions on this particular topic I'm good thank you okay anyone else all right would you make a motion sure I'd make a motion to pass uh item 8f as it is stated second motion's been made and seconded all those

144in favor say I I I I okay motion passes 5 z uh consent agenda items that has been pulled for H it's Personnel action items and Miss uh Warner thank you so I'm off the Personnel rep I'm ping hly Reynolds so everything else on that Personnel report is fine um once again we have a teacher shortage and people are leaving our district and particularly around special ed and I had asked for an investigation into the practice of forcing intimidating interrogating our staff into resigning when there's been a minor issue maybe a dis disagreement in ideology or things like that and it is my understanding that that's what happened to Miss Reynolds so I'm not going to support her resignation because I know that that's not what she wanted and um the handling of this by

145HR is a warant and I will re request my um investigation into HR I had hoped that these practices would go away but clearly they're not so you feel free to make the motion to uh approve her resignation but I will be uh not approving it because this is a Bor and I think that we need to take better care of our teachers and as a matter of fact I'd like to request an executive session bring M Reynolds in so that the board can have a clear understanding of what happened what happened in that room and how she was forced to resign thank you thank you um any other comments or questions from board members on item H 8h Miss Carney are you trying to chime in no motions okay so well first a motion

146as present I'll make a motion that the uh item 8 H be approved as presented so we'll need a second and Miss um yes so you'll want to approve the entire person report except Miss Reynolds and then we'll vote on her separate it'll be two votes off the person she made I'll do it here I'll do it here we go I'll do it motion there report the exception of PA Reynolds minus one individual and we need a second on that motion second all right and any any more discussion all right so we'll we'll do a vote um all those in favor say I I okay all those opposed hearing none that motion passes as presented so now I'm concerned about a name of an individual we know the name but you can just take it

147as that's the only part that passed yeah Mr yes I did have her permission I did have her permission to use her name okay thank you can I ask point of clarification let me just get to some clarity first there's no further motion no we need to approve her you guys still need to approve her resignation and I'm going to decline so I see you're saying everything except for the res and now okay now there's I got you thank you okay and I'm sorry go Mr Dr pensy what does it mean to not approve a resignation like if they resign they I'm trying to understand what we're doing here yeah we're accepting the resignation if we don't accept the resignation at some point you cannot you cannot force someone in practice to not accept or

148someone's resignation Mr it sounds odd but at some point the board will need to make the official action of accepting the resignation um so I would just caution you at this stage because the agenda item is so sparse on this issue not to uh go through you know extensive discussion on this issue because it's not agendized for that um so I think you could either move to accept the resignation move to table uh which would then cause us to put an agenda item on it for another resignation at another time or whatever occurs and just as a general question if we don't approve someone's resignation they're not allowed to resign clearly that's not the case they will resign I just don't think it's kind of like when people separate uh but the court hasn't accepted

149the order for their dissolution uh it may not be legally binding but they are no longer together so I I think that the person helpful analogy I think the person can resign but at some point the board will need to take action to accept the resignation all right thank you yes go ahead Miss so um um I will stand up for Teacher any day and I understand that this vote is going to be approved and I would like to be on Rec is not she was forced to resign okay thank you another comment Mr I I just have a question on this if we were to if the um we were to have an executive session to learn more about this would that need would there need to be a motion for that or how

150will we go I'm look to Mr bazan well I don't think under the agenda that we have today we could go into executive session for legal advice now um I don't think that this has been noticed for executive session we definitely can't go on the Personnel matter uh today but we could have an agenda item at a different board meeting okay so we can go under future um agenda item is that correct okay thank you Mr shy yeah I'll just ask from a precedent standpoint I mean I have zero information here and so um you know whether to vote or abstain I have no information to go off of um so precedent wise I'm not sure if this is normally brought up uh Mr bazon I'm just any guidance you get from president in this

151it's a little unique uh but you know it's really just a matter of I wouldn't say it's a matter of first impression uh it's I mean I've kind of explained what your options are you can table you don't have a lot of information or you can accept you know on that same information and uh so precedent wise I think precedent not that relevant it is what it is thank you does anyone want to make a motion to accept the resignation as presented hearing none will table it and look to a future agenda item is that correct Mr buzan yeah I'll make a motion to to table um acceptance of the resignation acceptance of her resignation until uh the board can have an executive session second that all those in favor I hasn't been seconded yeah

152I seconded okay I miss Warner I Karen can you hear me I I said I okay sorry thank you I'm just waiting on one more uh I'm I'm Ane Ane yes okay so we the motion passes um 4 to1 to to table the acceptance of a resignation the designated resignation thank you all right and just for a point of clarification missis um included in that motion was uh it was tabled until we can have an executive session um with the individual thank you we'll get yeah legal advice on the executive session thank you uh all right let's take a look now at action items under number nine a approve employee contract language and listed benefits for school year 2526 is Miss Mullin coming we do not have a presentation but Miss mclenon is here she

153assisted with the the updating of the language of all of the contract templates that you have in the board packet and would' be happy to answer any questions you might have what questions might the board have at this point um thanks I was looking through the red lines and can you just summarize what problem are these edits solving Madam president uh bo vice president shy the um contracts were updated to reflect changes in the law or to make the contract documents more uniform so one of the primary changes that was made was there was a law that was passed that's now 15509 that requires um any applicants to the district to indicate whether they've been accused of certain crimes so that was added um and that was the primary item added other than that dates

154were changed and the idea was to make them more uniform thank you other questions from board members seeing none I'll look for a motion I'll move to approve you second I'll second that okay motion's been made and seconded all those in favor I I thank you 0 thank you Miss Mullan for being here for this entire evening for that question all right uh we are now on 9B uh authorization of expenditure 68th Street in Oak formerly uh tonela Elementary campus it's a facilities Improvement we are looking for authorization of an expenditure do we want Dennis to present or we're just waiting for he's going to point to some things it's not a full presentation point to where to get historical information okay thank you good evening uh Dr Lewis members of the board Dr menel

155I am thrilled to be here unfortunately the audience that's here all knows about this project so um I'm going to go through it very quickly and leave the questions to you um I first want to point out uh one thing and that is uh the transparency that we show on our site uh Steve Puch last week I mentioned to him that the uh website needed a tweak he went like website Ninja on me made a bunch of changes made it so much better right away and um so I wanted to kind of walk you through this just a little bit and I'll do it quickly first I want to point out that the 68 Street project I I was realizing as I was um washing my hands in the bathroom that we've been working on

156this project since 2020 that's half of my career here in Scottdale so if you guys say no to this I might have to run off a bridge that's what we're talking about okay oh no I motion to approve second second second oh well I just gave Stephen all these Kudos and the website's messed up oh there she is how the ninja works there she is so one place all the information that you need for this project and the years of effort that we've put into this and it's seen a number of different partners a number of different different Renditions uh the community's been involved it's really been uh one of those hard-earned projects uh usually I can get it done in six months and off we go we build something U but this one in

157particular has been a little bit of a challenge the uh 68th Street was once tonala elementary school and that Community like many of our Scottdale communities absolutely love their school loved their school still loved their school even though it's a field and a parking lot so our proposal is to turn that into a multi-purpose facility for sports um one of the things that we learned through a community meeting back in March was that uh sand beach volleyball was the upand cominging sport we've got it at several of our high schools not all of them um and they all farm out to a different location to to uh be able to play beach volleyball so uh this was an opportunity to take this facility and do something real positive for our high schools uh to take

158care of that now uh a facility like this needs care and so we need to generate Revenue so we will have uh the volleyball courts for our high school teams but then we'll rent them out for Club teams we will have plenty of turf for soccer uh flag football uh any of the turf sports that are out there uh whether it's club sports some of our High School uh training uh facilities anything like that uh we'll be able to use for this facility this is a flood irrigated facility and so it's a little bit more temperamental you can't uh use it in the same way that you use a IR uh uh sprinkled uh field and so there'll be a little bit less use which will make the community happy they'll have that park-like setting

159in their neighborhood they'll be able to see and use that facility um but there'll still be plenty of rentals to help us generate Revenue to offset the cost of this facility so um the design proposal and and for anyone that's watching the uh governing board had direction to the uh website and and to be able to see this did you guys get a chance chance to to take a peek at this so um the facility as it stands right now uh with the exception of the building has been re-roofed and repainted to uh clean that up and make it watertight and um and then you can see that it's just a lot of grass in this area over here where uh the old Media Center used to be the proposed location or the proposed improvements

160uh for eight volleyball courts we're going to cut down the existing basketball courts into a much smaller piece of concrete we're going to have an area here where the community can enjoy a parklike setting a little exercise route uh places for their grandkids to play uh and a little bit of grass uh hopefully not for their dogs to run we've got um the ability to have a full-size soccer field and on the other two Fields depending on what we're doing we've considered opportunities for uh football field goal posts for kicking camps or things like that so we're really hoping that what we can Target are more specialty stuff we've only got 66 parking spaces and one of the bigger concerns for the community was that everyone's not parking all over their community so we're going

161to Target uh smaller groups and try and keep that parking uh to a minimum on that property so we've got some photos but I'm going to slip back to the movie it's a minute 47 uh hopefully you don't mind taking a a look at that the Architects Kristen Taylor Foley here from DLR and they worked real hard on this uh listening to me opine about how perfect I want this project to be for that Community um oops sorry I clicked on the wrong thing I don't know what this green thing is popping up that's me doing the push-ups there look pretty good huh so as you could see when you come in the site uh straight to the volleyball courts that area right now has some playground equipment our um fixed assets folks have been

162able to auction off some stuff and actually made a pretty good chunk of change those folks are demoing those shap structures out themselves uh at their own cost so the demolition has cost us nothing which is usually something that goes to the general contractor and and can be pretty expensive a lot lot of turf area and then we go back to the uh exercise Park type setting we have to be careful about calling it a park we're not a we're not a city we are not Park owners we don't uh have a uh obligation to create a park uh but that Community has been extremely patient as we go through this process and so we wanted to do a little bit something that uh the community community can enjoy and uh our athletes can enjoy

163as well so my ask is uh for the authorization of expenditure with Will Ming and I can read it exactly is to recommend the governing board authorize the expenditure of 1.81 24707 with Will main construction for the facility improvements at 68th Street in Oak formerly tonala Additionally the administration would recommend a $50,000 owner contingency to be used as needed for minor changes to the scope and unforeseen conditions during the course of construction with the total anticipated expenditure of 1231 24707 these are plant funds these are funds that with um Shannon's Grim uh report Port do not affect that uh these are dollars that are set aside based on land leases purchases things like that and they have a very restricted uh use in how we can we can spend them so this was the perfect

164opportunity and I would love for a yay across the board any questions I'll open it up for the board Dr Pensky not okay okay can you see me I can see you yes okay you can see me okay all right thank you matches your address yeah well um I too I've been along paying attention to this from the beginning with you and so um and going to your town meetings and so I appreciate all the work and efforts you've been you put into this I just have two easy questions I think um did you get any negative feedback from the community members who have been very involved did you get any feedback on this project um we got a lot of feedback um and every time we asked for more we got more negative it

165stopped when the previous Partners um bailed out and so once that uh was done and the district was going to take on the burden of financing it and doing it our way the the negativity went away okay so you would say as far as concerns you you talked about the parking concerns were there any other major concerns that the community had with this project as is so the the things that we've gotten are more like suggestions can we get more trees down 68 street can you do this can you do that okay and all of those we we looked at um and when you look at this uh the update from the um previous previous previous meeting the one that the board approved the $99,000 spend we had a list of all the different things

166that we had accounted for based on the input and then we incorporated them all and then after we were done with that design then we went back to the community and had another meeting and asked basically how did we do and it was an overwhelming great job okay great and then lastly I and I apologize if I missed this uh in your recent presentation here but I thought at one point you talked about uh this being locked is this property going to be locked or will the community have full-time access to this so the community will have access the picture that's up there right now that's basically a strip of land from the parking lot to about uh 40 ft from that tree into the fence line so they'll have about 40 ft 300 ft

167long of grass exercise equipment walking path that they'll have full access to we will likely like all of our schools uh lock down the playground equipment itself uh because that's always just a a a risk that we carry every time we leave that open um but generally speaking and all of this equipment that we'll be buying is extra sturdy it's meant for the outdoors it's meant for the the wear and tear of of public use okay so someone from facilities will be monitoring that and locking it and opening it for yes absolutely yep okay thank you Mr shy um question on uh costs I understand the the cost we're allocating here is coming from one bucket um upkeep maintenance where is that hit from year to year so security other we do we do the

168maintenance on it now it's still getting its grass cut it's been getting its grass cut since we tore the buildings down um so the increased cost is going to be very very minimal uh the sand is going to be the big one right keeping the cats out of the sand um but otherwise we anticipate the cost to be not a whole lot more than what we're spending already in the uh in the November presentation there was a bullet point said life cycle cost should be evaluated did so I understand it's minimal but are you talking like $100 incremental War year or actually the the real dollars are going to be in the building and we're not doing anything with the building right now uh as I mentioned in in the board agenda we don't have

169the funds to do that we're working with some Community Partners to do that but that's where the cost will be once you get the air conditioning going the lighting going all of that um but my expectation is and what I conveyed to the community back in March was that we wanted to have um generate enough Revenue to make this a zeroc cost property so if we can generate enough Revenue uh to soer teams and football programs and whatever else we rent to to pay for any cost um for the project but just order of magnitude if it costs like about what does it cost us now and are we talking $100 $1,000 a year like any idea just I when I ran the numbers before and I need to run them again now that it's

170almost three years later uh we're talking about 50 to $75,000 a year okay and that's what you're planning to be offset by fees correct okay thank you and you you know what they say if you build it they will come and everybody that knows about this is already ready to start playing on it m Warner just want to check in any questions or comments um great presentation thank you Mr rer you're welcome Dr Bensky you asking for a motion I am I motion that we approve I second that motion it's been motioned and seconded to approve all those in favor say I I I thank you okay 5 approval thank you okay all right that brings us to the selection of a facilitator for the board retreat now I know we talked about this last

171meeting and and we separated the need to agree on a date and I think the right policy was suggested but we did agree that we wanted to move forward on maybe a more of a variety of possible facilitators and names were suggested so I think we asked Administration to prepare uh a number of facilitators for us to consider so thank you for putting that in our packet and I'll ask the board at this time for discussion before any motion is made all right Mrs Carney all right thank you president Lewis uh I just would like to I guess give some some past data to um educate us on our decision for tonight but at a board retreat uh October 18th of 2021 I know we paid the facilitator uh Connie cam5 $0000 to facilitate that

172board retreat which seems to be a similar alignment to what uh we might be looking to do and then last year our board retreat was a cost of 1,200 um so I I see on our agenda we have the different pricing from the different facilitators um my question is what what was on the proposal that we gave to these facilitators what was presented to them for them to give us these figures so essentially uh we said that we have 3 to three and a half hour board retreat an initial Retreat for a new governing board to get to know each other to identify Norms kind of just a broad um brush approach uh each of the individuals knows that the governing board wanted to have input into the creation of the agenda so it wasn't

173a formal proposal it was simply are you willing to do it can you share your biographical information and what would you charge so it's very uh basic in that regard Dr Pensky so I'm happy to open up I should say first I don't know any of these individuals I don't believe I've I've met them so I only know them by the biography I want to thank Dr Mensel um and Dr Lewis for putting forward four uh by resume very qualified opport options for us um I'm I'm not inclined to move forward with um Miss James just based on my colleagues concerns at the last meeting about uh working with someone from from asba I really would like us to try to find a facilitator that we all feel like you know we we were're excited

174to to work with um in the abstract I would put the greatest premium on uh someone who has some context or connection to the Scottsdale community and the Scottsdale schools and also the least expensive option since they're all the most qualified um and so when I put those two together uh the name that jumps out to me is Miss Becker uh she was on the uh susd board um for eight years and she also has a a very impressive education pedigree and seems to have a background um commitment through the Coronado foundation and a background also in facilitation which I think matters but to be clear I I I could work with any of these and be excited uh Miss R yes ma'am go ahead Miss Warner thank you so I did review the BIOS

175I also checked out the LinkedIn and um the you have one impressive bio of somebody who's achieved what we would love to achieve and that is Mr Jenkins now I have never met the man um I don't know him and um I think that this retreat is about um supporting us in you know getting together and being able to create something good and something big for scly unified uh we're seeing a you know a decline in enrollment deine in proficiency rates all of these things so I would I I will favor Mr Jenkins because he's already proven success in an area where we are trying to be successful and we've had a decline for the last four years in all the areas and so I think that him bringing his wisdom his knowledge and having

176worked with obviously numerous boards that that would be highly valuable I'm not concerned about the $2,000 you know just you know two meetings ago um you know we were voting on spending $15,000 to travel to Georgia so I think that $2,000 is pretty menial for this and I'll foro any conference for the remainder of the year to cover that cost but I think we want to get high dollar value want to get high value from somebody who has achieved the success that we're trying to receive and so that is my choice okay Mr shy uh I'll reiterate this what Dr Pinsky said um I think the context for Scottdale is important to me um this is about our community and how we work together uh to benefit our community so that's a positive for me

177meaning your in interest is in Caren Bear yes okay thank you Miss Carney um thank you when I was reviewing all these I um I was just feeling like you could facilitate this just as well as um you know the these names on here that were just board board members um I would rather see you lead us in facilities which you have a lot of experience doing for No Charge than than bringing in well hang on on the no charge well I'm just messing with you go um so I I that was my thinking when I was looking at this why would we bring in you know someone who's just been a board member um and when we have someone that has experience on the board that could I feel facilitate this but I also

178am with um board member Warner where I would like to see a neutral um you know presence in Dr jenin and I know he has done work for the district um as far as some professional development things so I as well would like to see us go with him but I do have a question on the price if we were to use him could we offer him a different price or is that not something we do we would just accept this price so so it's always uh an option to come back with a counter offer um this this is not a formal RFP it's below the threshold and so if the board wanted to say hey we're only comfortable with 1500 match what we did the last time you could do that I think in

179in this environment um while you can argue every dollar matters um it's a small amount in the scheme of things what's really important is that the governing board comes together and has this conversation as soon as we can and I think um either Miss bear or Dr Jenkins would do a fine job in facilitating it I would argue that you need the facilitator I believe Dr Lewis would do a fine job too but it's hard to be a participant and a facilitator so I I think we really do need that neutral party to engage in that part of the process go ahead m c okay then I'd like to make a motion to approve Lee Jenkins uh to be our facilitator for our upcoming board retreat second we have a motion and a second and

180do we want to entertain that motion and any other discussion on Mr Jenkins can I just on a discussion point Point um I don't know if this is appropriate ask but is that your only option I just want to make sure I I want something that we're all in agreement with and so I don't know if it's that is it or if you're open to other you know Dr Pinsky said he's opened different options um I just want to make sure there's something that we're all on the same page with so if it's fair to ask can I ask our other options on the table for you or are they non-starters miss Carney or Miss Werner Miss Carney so go do you want to take it no go ahead okay so um I wasn't going

181to go here but I will so uh we do have a motion in a second on the table so we do have to vote on that but I will tell you that Miss bear reached out to both myself and board member Cy when we were first on the board as she does with most people and we did meet with her she was rude condescending and partisan so I have no interest in sitting in a room with her for her to lead our professional Dev thank you I really appreciate you sharing because that's important to me in the decision so thank you very much M Warner Dr pensy um I don't remember I don't think we actually operate under Ro Robert R of order but um if we did would it be a friendly modification to

182approve it at last year's last Retreats budget and see if we can sort of try to strike the balance I don't want to be Pennywise and pound foolish at the same time last board meeting we specifically made a point of saying we as a board should try not to be spending dollars where we don't need to especially in this environment even if it is a rounding error so I'd like to try to push a little bit to so Mr Pinsky if you mind go ahead so we do vote on a motion in a second but the person who made the motion can make an amendment and I do believe are voting on the individual not the price so I think that all of us probably agree that the counter 1500 is fair but we're voting

183on the individual I would like to make an amendment because it's a hard negotiating position for the board to have approved it in a public meeting that the person with whom we're negotiating you know is aware so i' I'd rather you know send a very clear message that we'd like to work with this individual and we would also like to stay part to the budget that we used last time for something like do approved to a maximum of 2,000 I think that's the same difference so no my my I don't know what am I doing you're doing an amendment if that's all right with Miss Warner Miss Miss carne I keep doing this to you don't I I mean I'm ha I'm happy to amend the motion uh to approve Lee Jenkins at our um

184prior rate of $1,500 um perfect perect we need a second to the amendment second all right may I call the motion any other discussion all those in favor I I I I motion passes 5 Z thank you for that we are now at the point where I think I'm calling executive so let me just pause and make sure I'm right yes okay so I move that oh I'm so sorry yeah and it's pH well one of the things we got in through consent agenda but we didn't get to celebrate clap and Harrah is to give acknowledgement to Dr Bono for being selected as the new assistant superintendent for elementary education you I I I didn't see you there but and you were just so lowkey so we're really proud of you and congratulations we look

185forward to the expertise you bring in the history of the district and all of your other outstanding knowledge and kment instruction thank you all right uh with that I move that we uh adjourn into executive session I need a second right yes second all those in favor I I I e e e I make a mo I I uh am calling the regular meeting back to order um at 9:51 um everyone is present except for Miss Carney is that fair to say or should we Rec Sorry Miss Warner I do this all the time don't I I'm working on it except for Miss Warner is that a fair way to put it okay sorry about that um um I move that we close the account with Ballard and Spark for the remainder of the am

186amount due effective February 12th I need a second do you want a second say not pursuing case or is that that and there's no fur there's no further action we need approval ofes I just close the account in the amount due you me to say in fine okay I will second that motion all those in favor I I motion carries 4 z uh we have governing board reports Mr shy um I just want to share I was at um the Chinese New Year celebration the prodad Del Soul and the first Lego League competition where four of our schools competed in it and just really great to be part of that community and see everyone so just really enjoying this as I start getting going with these things right thanks just wanted to share I was

187delighted to see Miss Tilson recognized today she's one of my daughter's teachers and really changed the trajectory of her College interest um so just delighted to see that thank you Miss Carney thank you yeah I just um want to piggy back on this there's been a lot of great events going on at the schools and I too enjoyed going to the Chinese New Year at Desert Canyon and attending the National Junior Honor Society uh celebration at uh Tania and then I had a lot of fun uh at the lagona steam night and uh principal Kelly uh Kelly there was so gracious and hauled me all around and I was trying making the ice cream and U doing all all the stations and it was it was really great and that Community just seemed so so

188happy and it was uh really busy and just a great night agree and all accounts for the programs I got to go see and be a part of uh at this point are there future agenda items hearing none sorry I did that's okay I just want to make sure that we have the executive session uh on for the for the the resignation that was not accepted okay and you'll follow up with glattus on that you send that in as a don't we have to do that in writing well I'm not I'm just reiterating what was said as a as a board I don't know I can but I don't know that it's my agenda item it's just I just want to make sure that we do have that down um since it was done earlier

189in the evening and I I'd just like to reinforce um I think the sense of the board that we really want to use our study sessions as study sessions not as another board meeting where we do ordinary business but really use as an opportunity to do deep Dives so if you know if there's work to be done to solicit what our respective topics of Interest are um because I know it takes time for the board for the leadership to prepare for those all right hearing no others uh the date of our next meeting is Tuesday March 4th at 6 o'clock it is a regular governing board meeting here in cord not not high school so I look forward to seeing everybody then and I wish everybody a Happy Valentine's Day where whatever love you have

190you are honored and filled with I I make a motion to adjourn the meeting second all those in favor I I thank you thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.