001e e e this ISS on e e e all right good evening I call uh the special meeting of the governing board uh to order it's 6 PM uh Mr Vice President shy would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right we'll have a roll call on who's in attendance Dr pensy will you start and come we'll come around here and say your name uh Dr Matthew binsky thank you Karen wner Amy Carney Mike shy and Donna Lewis so we are all here and we have a quorum uh I'd like to ask for a motion to approve the agenda or any changes that
002would anyone like to make to it I'll start with any changes uh I'd like to move to amend the agenda by moving item 5j approval of governing board work Retreat to information discussion item 4 C under policy be and B so you want to move an action item to discussion correct okay we need a second on that motion second okay any discussion on your thinking um just according to policy be and be we don't need to approve uh a special meeting as it's already been approved and is covered under policy okay other thoughts and is that can I get a verification on that um Mr bazan well that is the practice I am looking at the policy now that has been the practice that uh no meeting needs to be approved but that doesn't mean
003that it can't be approved by a vote uh if just being in discussion on it I've I've not done that in the past personally so I found it unusual to make it an action item the only reason I'm I I was swayed to think it might be an action item since it it came up was that it was a calendar change per se is that and you're shaking your head no and I'm seeing another no any other ideas Dr Pensky Mr shy Miss Warner support okay all right any uh con anything you want to add Dr so the reason it's an action item is that there had been a request for discussion about the potential of having a board retreat uh I haven't made an assumption that the board would or would not want to
004have a retreat so did not proceed to schedule one but did plan for the potential for this conversation and should the board want to choose a date uh it is properly agendized here so that an action item can be taken to identify a date and and confirm that we're going to have a retreat and identify what the elements of the agenda might be so that there's no question about whether or not open meeting law was complied with in having this conversation is there an issue with leaving it in both places as a possibility so if we don't need it for Action I'm overthinking it probably I'd say technically if you had two agenda items you'd be amending the agenda but I mean you do have the ability to move the item around and it is
005set for Action now so I I say it's a small risk okay may I ask a question um so is the spirit of it less about whether we should or shouldn't have a retreat and just more that we don't procedurally need to actually vote on it whichever way we decide yeah now I think we've all agreed we want to have a retreat right it's procedurally we don't need to do that that as an action item because it's covered under policy be and be DD okay so thank you I'm comfortable with the Assumption in moving it to a discussion and not necessarily an action personally so I'm going to go ahead and call for the vote all those in favor of the motion to move agenda J 5j to be to become 4 C say I
006I I I all right the motion passes 5 to zero all right any other changes to the agenda okay I need an approval to approve the agenda as amended did you make a motion no I said I need one I can do it I move that we approve the agenda as amended second uh any discussion all in favor I okay passes 5 Z all right let's go ahead and go to Dr menel superintendent's comments well thank you president Lewis vice president shy members of the governing board uh we're still in January which means it's still a governing board appreciation month and uh our appreciation hasn't lessened since the last time we talked but the fact that we're meeting again here tonight gives us an opportunity to continue doing the work that's important for Scott unified
007school district there are no shortage of really great things that are happening so I'm only going to highlight a few things but last week I had the honor of participating in the Anastasia Blue zones approval ribbon cutting celebration one of the things when you have these kinds of Ceremonies at elementary schools is the excitement on the students faces when we get to have that celebration and so that was just a real Joy uh then also last week chaperel hosted the Phoenix Holocaust Association day of remembrance event where we had the author of we were the lucky ones Georgia Hunter uh as the guest speaker and she was uh interviewed the the U conversation was facilitated by bzy Phillips who is an award-winning actress and also a chapparel Alum and it was an honor for me
008to be able to present her with a susd legacy pin at the end of the presentation more more than 500 people were in attendance uh to hear the powerful and important story that's shared in that book and if you haven't read the book there's also Hulu series and you can watch it that way on Saturday we had our Middle School sports festival the third and final one of the year uh where girls basketball boys flag football and cross country had an opportunity uh for the festival I want to thank Nathan Slater Barb James the coaches volunteers and others who help put that together it was truly a fantastic event and uh there's a lot that goes into making it happen and it went off uh essentially without a hitch uh last night uh we partnered
009with Scottdale blue zones and our student services department to offer an escape the V training session uh we invited parents and students and that training was held at Scottdale Spear of the West Museum uh small crowd but uh people who are committed to addressing The Vaping challenge so that was a positive partnership report and the last thing is that we will have many entrance in the 71st edition of the parad Del Soul on Saturday morning uh we're looking forward to seeing many governing board members there many susd floats marching bands and I have an opportunity for the first time time since I've been here to ride a horse in the parade I've been begging for five years so it will be a lot of fun so looking forward to seeing many people out there and
010with that I'll conclude my update thank you uh okay we'll move to item 4A uh here we're going to hear uh an update from our various professional associations and I'll just do we want to call them all up together all right let's have our our leaders of the Scottdale Administration administrators Association the Scottdale Education Association Scottdale support professional association and the Scottdale District administrators Association come on up and we look forward to hearing your updates uh board members we can ask questions uh for clarification uh we just need to be mindful that if we go into what might be a topic we'll want to agendize that for the future good evening governing board president Dr Lewis vice president shy members of the school governing board Dr menel and Miss Wagner I'm Dr Janelle Dan am
011the principal at Arcadia High School president-elect of the SAA and this is my colleague Shelley hman uh president of SAA in celebration of national school board recognition month I'm honored to acknowledge your vital role in shaping our District's future serving on the board is a significant responsibility overseeing policies budgets and strategic decisions that affect our students and staff your leadership posters and environment where learning flourishes and prepares our children I want to highlight the importance of principles and assistant principles in our education system here in susd principles establish the school culture inspiring teachers and guiding students while creating a supportive environment for everyone assistant principles play crucial role as operational managers and instructional leaders working alongside principles to implement transformative practices that contribute to our district schools research shows that strong School leadership significantly impact
012student achievement second only to classroom instruction effective leaders create conditions for teaching and learning manage resources wisely mediate conflicts and engage families with empathy despite their essential contributions the role of um School leaders is sometimes undervalued in discussions about education Improvement investing in school leadership means investing in every student teacher in classroom and without well supported principles and assistant principles even the best initiatives can struggle to succeed as you deliberate on the priorities for our district in your upcoming terms I urge you to consider number one ensuring that our school leaders have access to ongoing highquality professional development the challenges of today's educational landscape require leaders who are not only equipped to handle the present but are also prepared to innovate for the future number two to recognize the immense scope of the responsibilities that
013principles and assistant principles carry as we identify what is truly important for us to focus on in order to meet our district wigs and finally a variety of measures to attract and retain the um the best leaders when there is principal turnover the progress made towards implementing change in a school can stall during the transition we really look forward to partnering with the board fellow leadership teachers and staff in ensuring Excellence for all of our students thank you very much good evening president Dr Lewis uh vice president shy governing board members superintendent Dr menel Mrs Wagner and guests is my honor to give you an update on the Scottsdale Education Association and the certified staff of our district SCA has been working on increasing our uh visibility across the district and listening to General members
014uh for ideas that will impact the to-day work of the district for students for all students and staff with this as our Focus we've been visiting each susd site uh to talk to all certified staff we are pleased to report that the District administration has been working with us to help create solutions to various issues throughout the year throughout our work we have noticed consistent uh some consistent concerns around Rising employee costs of insurance the balancing of Staffing and effective management of school uh of student behavior and thought that it best to bring this to uh you as the board um as you make um decisions on the prioritization um of years moving forward for the district um on insurance both the Su uh both SD and sea have an interest in retaining and attracting
015highly qualified staff the biggest issue on this front is the rising cost of insurance currently rising Healthcare premiums are forcing some staff to pay as much as $22,000 in premium before even seeking medical care we are uniquely hit by Rising Insurance costs due to the higher than average experience of our trusted certified staff with experience Healthcare becomes more necessary for both proactive and basic care as a district striving to elevate Excellence we must do all we can to mitigate Rising costs of insurance for all employees we support susd negotiations of healthc care costs continued cost savings education for employees and continued exploration for more costeffective measures for the district as a whole in support of these efforts we have completed a petition in support of our healthcare plan negotiations where 82% of all certified staff
016have signed supporting three priorities decreasing employee cost of insurance ensuring there are affordable plans for each category of plan including single spouse children and family plans and maintaining the quality of care while addressing the first two priorities uh the signatures of over 1100 of our certified staff members on this petition demonstrates that these priorities ities are shared widely and deeply by our certified Community this further demonstrates the importance and urgency that SSD and sea leadership have put on improving employee Insurance options staffing issues uh so as an association we are aware that Staffing and salary increases are directly related and that this is a delicate balance between having the staff we need to elevate Excellence on every campus and being able to provide the salary increases needed for our Educators to keep up with the
017rising cost of living in the East Valley as Staffing ratios have been assigned for each site throughout throughout SD they have been assigned based on the guidelines for each employment agreement while we support currently negotiated ratios uh we urge that balanced scheduling is imperative in a recent survey of certified staff 34% uh reported that their case loads are not manageable and 57% responded that this negatively impacts their effectiveness furthermore we must balance the out-of-class workload for employees if the focus is on educational advancement and elevating Excellence we must allow our highly qualified Educators the time needed to plan to provide feedback and for the higher number of students in their care um and then we also believe that the more effective management of student behavior is needed at many of our campuses as USD is
018a diverse district with many sites and each of our sites has reached different levels of Effectiveness with our mtssb program this issue is weighed heavily on the minds and hearts of our certified Educators many of our Educators have worked in susd for decades and they remember a time when their word was trusted and behaviors changed upon correction that simply is not the case for much of our community in current times when certified staff seek support for dealing with egregious student behaviors in the classroom they're often told to build better relationships or to assume best intentions or to find their why our Collective why has always been what is best for the students entrusted to our care we care for all students and strive to build connections with them on a daily basis we would also
019like the same Assumption of best intentions um that we're told to afford to others many of these behaviors have weighed down classrooms and prevented further academic growth the weight of management of student Behavior must be met with shared burden and accountability our certified staff needs support not simply training more training we must collectively find a way to better support our Educators at all levels to elevate excellence in susd thank you for your time and continued cooperation we appreciate you and look forward to collaboratively uh working together to take on these challenges good evening board president Dr Lewis vice president shy members of the board Dr menel Miss Wagner colleagues and guests I am Christa diatrus the president of the Scottsdale support professionals Association I am always grateful for the opportunity to speak before you on
020behalf of our classified staff as we continue our focus on Student Success and building a stronger Community I am honored to collaborate with not only our support professionals but our certified faculty and district and sight administrators each member of our team plays a crucial role in ensuring that student learning happens in a safe and supportive environment the interpace negotiations are progressing effectively our discussions have encompassed various options related to General leave professional development and compensation additionally we are discussing the possibility of having meetings with classified staff I firmly believe when we listen to and support one another we create the foundation for a positive and productive workplace our Student Success depends on all of us working together and by acknowledging the importance of every role we can continue to foster a culture of collaboration and
021respect to end I want to thank each member of our classified staff for the invaluable work you do each and every day you are key players in the success of susd and your efforts make a significant impact on our students and our community thank you good evening board president Dr Lewis vice president shy members of the board superintendent Dr Manzel Mrs Wagner and honored guests I'm Sean kroer and I'm the president of the Scottdale District administrators Association our association represents a diverse group of District administrators and support exempt employees who lead and work often behind the scenes to support ssd's educational Mission our members include directors coordinators supervisors managers and Specialists serving across essential departments such as facilities Finance Human Resources security Educational Services and student services CTE food services warehouse and it through the
022interest-based negotiations process we ensure constructive dialogue that benefits our entire educational Community this inaugural year for our association has been marked with significant Milestones including the creation of and and board adoption of the district administrator employee agreement this framework established clear guidelines and collaboration for collaboration and mutual understanding within our district we're grateful for the collaborative spirit that made this agreement possible and look forward to building upon this Foundation as we continue our work alongside the other associations through the IBN process we remain focused on supporting SD's vision mission and value vales we began this year as an association with goals built around the values of representation responsibility sustainability and fairness goals and values we Bel believe strongly align with our district vision mission and values we are proud of the significant collaboration and progress
023we have made th far and look forward to continuing our progress this spring look look ahead we're committed to working constructively with all stakeholders to support SD's vision mission and values and Advance ssd's strategic plan and wildly important goals our membership understands that their role is to provide leadership and foundational support that enables our schools teachers and students to thrive we work diligently to elevate Excellence ensuring that the District Operations run smoothly resources are managed efficiently ly and support services are delivered promptly to our schools as an association we look forward to continuing to support District administrators in serving in that role thank you for your time and continued support of our district Mission and thank you again for your service on the school board thank you Mr kroer thank you each of you uh
024the leadership that you each provide to your respective organizations is above and beyond the Call of Duty it's outside of your uh daily resp responsibilities and as volunteer community leaders we really appreciate and understand what it takes to lead um the group of people that you represent uh so thank you Christa our thoughts and prayers are with you um at this time are there any clarifications or questions that the board has about the uh wonderful way you laid out for the year what you'll be working on have a comment Miss Warner so Dr dansy and Mrs humm I really appreciate you sharing today I I let Dr Manzel know that I will not support eliminating system principles at any of our sites or reducing their time to 05 they are vital to our sides and
025the support our sites and the support for our principles uh with the behavior issues that we are seeing I I have been told the amount of time and effort that it takes from the leadership and so I stand by that I stood by this last year and I'll stand by it again I will not support it and thank you again for sharing I appreciate it thank you and oh Mr Buckley thank you for being so transparent and authentic I'm very very grateful and we'll be reaching out to you any other comments or clarifying questions all right thank you guys so much we look forward to working with you throughout the year all right we'll move on to 4B fiscal year 2025 2026 early projection for maintenance and operations thank you good evening uh Dr I'm
026sorry Dr Lewis vice president Sharky members of the board and um Dr menel and guests tonight um we are taking a very high llevel first look at our early projections for the minino budget for next school year maybe there we go um so we start off by taking a look at our strategic goals and commitments and this is what we look at when we're trying to figure out how do we what decisions do we have to make um what are the priorities for us as we develop the budget the first one being goal three attract higher develop support and retain highly qualified passionate and talented professionals um we work through that through the IBN process we um work through knowing that um salary increases are highly important to our staff and we know the medical
027costs are highly important um and and looking at ways to address those and then goal five generate and utilize resources to maximize educational opportunities in order to ensure organizational Health um again as we look at the budget we are looking at how are the resources being used can things that we've been doing if they're not working can we get rid of them and how can we use those dollars to maximize um what we need to do as we go into the m&o budget there's a couple assumptions that we make um average daily membership or ADM is what drives our funding um we look at that and and it's hard because m is funded on uh current year funding so we're making early assumptions that um we don't really know what ADM will be until we
028get later on into the into the school year we take a look at historically what has happened historically we've looked at averages and based on that it's an ADM reduction of 373 um however there are weights that are associated with group a weights um for all students and then group wave for special special needs free and reduced gifted some other areas um so with those weights right now we're estimating that to be 499 um again this is really early we don't even have the 100th day we just had our 100th day last last Monday so as we're still working through what those numbers look like making sure that everything has been uploaded and is correctly accounted for and there um we'll continue to look at where does that look like and do we need to
029adjust these numbers but that's where we're going going off of at this time um we anticipate a base level or an amount per student to increase by 2% um that would put us at $ 5,113 26 um that should be what is happening because inflation is above 2% the voters have approved a maintenance and operations override of 15% next year will be year two of that approved override so that's 15% of our RCL and we'll look at that in just a minute when we look at the budget and then teacher experience index has been flat it changes a little bit um it could change States uh districts have until March to make any adjustments but what that basically is based off of is um you send the state what is the experience level of all
030of your teachers they look at that Statewide and if your district is above a a state average depending on how much more above that average it is you receive additional funding um like I said they have we have until March first to um Define those numbers and make sure that there's no changes to be made but right now it should be flat at 1.02 this takes a look at how you put the budget together and it's kind of like doing tax forms where you you follow one step and takes you to the next um there's a couple things we don't know and so there's two proposals or options there within it we don't know what's going to happen with prop one 123 which um ends the end of this fiscal year I know it's a
031a a topic that's being discussed around the state um and at the capital we just don't know at this time what that looks like and if so um you know will there be funding for that or will that funding completely go away so the First Column looks at what do we know for the anticipated revised and again this is based off of what we knew back in December um so this could change a little bit will change a little bit as we get more infinitive numbers once the hund once we have the 100th day information and everything is gathered um with that we've got a what happens if we don't receive one two3 monies and what happens if we do receive prop one two3 monies um so total weighted student count is stays the same
032in any case it's a reduction of 499 the base level increase stays the same either way Pro uh teacher experience stays the way we get additional funding for our audit so that's a little bit more for next year year um and then the transportation amount we get stays the same all those together make up our Revenue control limit and that Revenue control limit is what decides our overrides so for M it's 15% of that Revenue control limit it's actually because our Revenue control Li is going down a little bit as ADM goes down um or weights go down that um override amount we are projecting will go down slightly um DC stays the same the biggest change really has to do with our budget balance carry forward um we had hoped to carry forward 14
033million into this year we were obviously short of that um so that makes an impact between decisions that were made in the past and the fact that we're just we're not overspending our budgets but things just cost more people are spending more of the budgets they're allocated um so two parts lead to that reduction of about $3 million one part is um governing board approved doing a 2% raise um which is a percentage more than what we had anticipated originally that was going to come out of the carry forward as that brings the carry forward down and continues to bring that down that is about 1.4 of that um again carry forward into this year was lower than what we anticipated and we know we're filling jobs that's good but that impacts our carry forward
034and everything just costs more um so what I really want to highlight here is that we are still carrying over money we don't have a budget issue like we see happening in other places we are still carrying over money we're just projecting that it's not going to be as much as we have in the past but that does bring down what our total M budget will be um water savings that's for things that we do um Energy savings that's for leases that we have we're paying the principal in interest so that goes down a little bit every single year um and then the big unknown is again prop one two3 this year is 1.3 million almost 1.4 depends on whether or not we receive those dollars or not moving forward so because of that because
035we have that unknown starting out the year and because we're bringing that budget balance carry forward that's somewhere between a 2.8 and a 4.2 um deficit or reduction and what we're going to have for next year which means we have to then start looking at how do we bring down our expensive expenses the revenue we get goes down the expenses have got to go down or you've got an even bigger problem um we are we have a team that is oh go back to that slide we have a team that's been looking at that throughout the entire year um it's made up of senior um level um leadership of myself Dr Cruz Miss Mitchell Dr saak um um Miss Cerna we've been looking at that we're looking at what do we do because that doesn't
036even address we want to be able to do salary increases we want to be able to um address the medical costs and working through that and lowering them so we I think are pretty close to having um the bulk of that difference um at least for the 2.8 million if we do receive prop one 123 we're pretty close to having that worked out as we look at ratios um as we look at some other cost-saving measures across the district um but we'll continue to work on that one of the things that then comes to mind is well what do we do about salary increases what do we do about insurance and what we're really looking at that is um as many districts across the state have had to do is do we need to look
037at moving State da District additional Assistance or Capital funds to M to be able to provide the dollars that would be necessary to do some kind of salary adjustment and address um medical insurance we did we had a self-insurance trust board meeting last week and the self-insurance trust board did um allocate $2 million towards insurance for next year that will help but it doesn't Bridge the full Gap and we don't know yet what the increase we get a yearly increase on medical expenses what that will look like but we are continuing to tackle that issue as well um but to be able to tackle some of those issues we are um probably going to land in the needing to move funds from District additional assistance over to memo um this just looks at what have
038we been doing what are what is the um calendar for what we'll continue to do um we've been meeting with interest based negotiations we do we have the single ones that happen where groups on their own are meeting but we've done a few um all group interest based negotiations looking at the budget reviewing the budget um we have some more coming up in February we we'll be looking at okay if we if we do move the dah what what does that look like what could we offer and how could we address salaries and um and medical with that um I we I will be back here up at the podium again in February talking about emino and capital projections and going over that we'll have some new numbers to look and see where that's at
039well also at that time we should have um what's the plan to at least deal with the um the the deficit that we need to look at um and bringing those expenses down so that we don't continue to take big chunks away from our our budget carry forward as it isn't also important to have that budget carry forward because things come up that you maybe aren't anticipating so we do want to make sure we have that um moving forward uh so we'll have that more of a detail of that when we come back in February uh and then March is where we do the salary schedule so that we and um so that we can move forward with um in issuing contracts and then of course in June we will have the proposed in public
040hearing with that I'll open it up for questions Dr Pensky uh thank you for the presentation so if I understand it there's sort of two two assumptions that you have to make when it comes to the student population one is I'm just want to use the right terms one is the ADM and then the other is kind of a guesstimate the weights which is kind of the attributes of the ADM that then ultimately translate the ADM into the 499 count so um the ADM we have to make a an educated guess on where that is but the amount that we get per weight stays the same um and should not much of a change if any change shouldn't have a change so once we can estimate where we think ADM is at then we plug
041that in to get the total so it it says okay there's so many kids in and K8 that's this weight that totals a weighted count of that distribution isn't difficult to forecast no it's really what is the ADM the ADM is the most difficult part and at this same point in Prior budget Cycles do we tend to get it just right do we tend to underestimate overestimate uh I know it's an art and a science it is um I would say it's it's it's difficult like right now we know that um what we estimated um for the budget for this year we the ADM is uh more of a reduction than what we thought but we also know that like I said we just had the 100th day last year or last week um so
042we're still trying to to Guess that it's never been spot on I don't think it will ever be spot on if somebody if a school district has that figured out by all means please please share um it's a balancing act so if you if you're a little bit under then that means you're going to be reducing your budget down some um or if you're a I'm sorry if you're if you're estimating an ADM number and you've estimated high and you don't really meet that number then you're reducing your budget if you estimate it and you're and you go too conservative then you haven't given raises that you could possibly give because now you've got more money coming in than what you thought um so there's a little bit of a balancing act and I don't
043know I think if you ask different CFOs they' tell you go under or they tell you to go over I think it depends on who'd ask you want to get it as close as as possible because that also impacts tax rates and and your cash flow and all of those things we're pretty close I think um I I know I shared um you know with with this one we're about aund and well right now with what we know we're about 100 uh 40 off 150 off um but we know we we strongly believe we've undercounted free and reduced and gifted so that's not a great answer we try to get as close as possible but it's never going to be spot on thank you yeah Mr shy thanks very much for that um last week
044we were shared the Arizona auditor General's website with the risk analysis there's about 10 different ratios on there and it does a very good job of saying if you're in the red or okay given some of the things you've talked about moving the da money or change to the carry forward do you have any indication if any changes will put us in the red with any of those metrics for the Arizona auditor general site um that is a great question there are two thing there's two things can impact that one we know a couple we know our ADM is going down if you're making big shift if your ADM makes a significant decrease that's definitely going to re red flag it we've been around the 2% um so that's been okay the carry forward um
045you know you don't want to have millions on the books that you're not spending having more carry forward can help when you're doing um when you're getting your ratings for bonds and whatnot um but a lot of districts we are seeing are that that carry forward is chipping away because esser's gone away we don't have that grant funding that are there everybody is a lot of people are seeing reductions in ADM if you took that um Carry forward down too much then yes I think that would definitely start to raise red flags I mean we've been shipping out it away a little bit slowlier um this is the biggest diff like going down by three million is the most we've gone down in a while um I don't think that's enough to I mean there's
046still even with that we still have 10 million carry forward we're still within like a 6% carry forward range so I don't foresee that as as sparking as a a red flag um but it is something to to consider um moving the dah again it's something a lot of districts do I think the bigger thing would be if you start to see all of those changes happening at once and they're pretty significant then eventually that could but I don't think we're in the spot where that would be a red flag and so you know my my point in given Isaac Elementary and what happened there right having something where we trip a metric to Red obviously is a literally red flag with that so just want to make sure that as you and we talk
047about options I'm assuming we can calculate ahead of time hey that will put this below the measure and therefore if someone goes to the auditor's site they'll see us now in Red so I want to make sure we know that ahead of time where we can make suggestions but hey if we do that know that the visibility has just been increased so not looking for specifics now I just think as we make these decisions is that a sanity check we do yes that is a sanity check we should have I would also point out that it's not one thing that's going to get you on a red like you could have something pop up as red that's not going to get you flagged like it's when you have multiple just being overly cautious yeah 100%
048And I totally agree with that um that's I mean that's why we want to be out super transparent with what the budget looks like and the fact that we are bringing it down are we I mean is that something we have to be mindful of we still have carry forward so that's good but we do need to be mindful of it and we do have within our board regulations um polic or regulation that says carry forward needs to be between um six and eight and we're still staying within that carry forward policy thanks Miss Warner Miss Miss Carney uh thank you president Lewis I know you're coming back to us in February uh about this but high level on uh the M override dollars what are we currently budgeting for with our M override money
049so 80 roughly 86% of it is salaries and benefits um the bulk of that is of course certified teachers in the classroom the next area would be classified and then admin um I sorry I don't know the exact percentages off the top of my head um but those are the areas the bulk of our Sal of our budget is salaries and benefits five about 5% is utilities so when you're looking at we've got to cut some areas unfortunately most often it falls within um people people and salaries and benefits um because utilities are what utilities are we can't control when APS or SRP says we're going to we're going to you know do a rate hike um we can cut back on electricity some but it's not going to make a huge dent or or
050watering but um so it really comes down to salaries and benefits so unfortunately when we're looking at how do we cut expenses it falls within people the bulk of the people within salaries and benefits like I said are certified classified and then and then admin we've charged every Department to look at what what can you do how can we reduce cost um as people leave um and vacancies appear here we we take a dive into okay is do we have to fill that position can we rearrange some some job duties to do that um we took a look at I think over the last two years was it U from last year and looking at this year like uh what is 21 21 positions um outside of classrooms uh within different departments um but we
051keep we keep looking it is hard you you still have to have folks in payroll and we still want people in in finance to make sure we don't get into some situations and we need people to do the facilities so some of those things even though our enrollment may go down we still have the same amount of land to to mow grass and and keep and keep things going so um can I ask verifying question did you ask about the M override portion of the oh you asked for the override portion I'm sorry I on the override portion um is all day kindergarten um class size reduction uh World languages Fine Arts um world languages Fine Arts professional development and um competitive salaries okay um so the over the override money can be used to
052supplement pay for administrators and teachers the override money just gets goes into M becomes the whole amount that we have for m so yes the override it contributes for every EMP I mean okay I just think we need to be mindful that the community passed both those overrides um because they want quality you know administrators and teachers in the classroom and I think we need to be mindful that that's what the community probably wants and um and that's what we should be making sure we prioritize absolutely thank you I have a few questions just uh industry standard is is for cl carry forward is six to8 industry standard or is that what we said in our regulation we actually said I think it's actually 4 to8 now that I'm thinking about it we said um
053we said that as as we looked at it um before prop one three took place there was a cap and you could only carry for 4% forward um so we set that as the minimum because that's what it had been okay in the past but six is our current number and is a little actually a little bit higher this year than six but um okay we're in that range and then in terms of uh prop one two three what is the anticipated process for knowing how prop 123 will continue to be funded um well we're paying close attention to what happens down at the state um there you know there I know that's something that's been talked about by the governor and the and the legislature um so with that if there's something that can
054be agreed upon down there and then my it would have to go to a vote um so that is part of it is I don't think a vote could actually happen a vote of the community of the state I don't think I don't know that that could happen at this point for continu yeah for continuance in May um so that could impact whether or not that happens for next year or not but we're still waiting to see there's lots of decisions still coming out of the capital and so we have to wait and see what's going on there so so I would add that U from a a budgeting perspective we've been uh told and I think it's reflected in the governor's budget proposal that the state is assuming that they have to fund out
055of general fund um the majority of the prop $123 that were previously covered by funds from the land trust there's a $75 million difference there was a catch-up provision that isn't carried forward in the in the budget assumptions that the jlbc has identified so the the uh what we don't know for certain if we see it so you see it on our budget line item says prop one 123 if it comes forward like that and the distribution mechanism is the same we're likely to get something less than the 1.3 or 1.4 because there's that $75 million Delta uh but it's not anticipated that the entire amount would be gone the conversations that have been happening are about there are other needs think about teacher compensation and other um cost pressures that school districts are experiencing
056that if we went back to the boter um to extend prop 123 and and the money that comes from the state land trust that would be what could be considered I think Shannon's right we I think missed the window for a May election so that would mean if the legislature decides to put it on a future ballot it's August or November um but there there's a portion of the money that we've been told is carried forward in the state's budget assumptions for next year based on the outcome of the court case that led to prop one two3 thank you um as we look at our our how long have we been self-insured if you know um early 2000s okay and who are we with uh right now we are with uh kyos is our medical
057um administrator okay we've looked at we've done an RFP um and we have reached out to some other trust providers to see um what what we could do differently good and my my last question is um from a federal National perspective we don't often talk about the gentle diminishing of funds that have occurred over the years somewhere between six and eight% if I'm right is that still happening also is that the same threat relative to State funding and then the the chunk that it would be added on to our overall budget um with regards to Federal funding we we do see declines happening within that um and of course there's a lot of questions happening today um with it that we don't have answers for um some of that is driven off of you know
058um our um census and what that looks like and and with with with what we have within our students so um we do see a reduction happening within federal funds I know that's always a impact for our our grants is when we do we say let's give a 1% or two% raise in M Ando that impacts all of our funds and so grants then get wrapped into okay what do we cut now to be a because if their dollars are going down or they're the same you know looking at and our cash accounts Food Services encounters it child Community ad encounters it idea yeah IDE a tada one they all they all have to then start going okay what can where can we cut back to be able to to meet that that raise or
059whatever we're we're providing thank you y any other questions one more sorry Dr P can we go to slide four and I apologize if I'm not tracking something that's sort of obvious um the 499 is the weighted student count right that's not a dollar number that's the weighted student account okay so what does that translate in terms of dollars so how much do we have uh less available to us because we've lost the weighted number of 499 I would like to email that number to you instead of coming it's usually around a it it's it's a couple million it's significant but I don't want to I don't want to throw a number out because I I I it's not a simple you know 49499 times 10,000 15,000 12,000 8,000 well I mean because that 499
060means that we've gotten more ADM somewhere along so is it in first grade is it in high school is it but order of magnitude 3 to five million yeah okay thank you yeah I think when we calculated last year if we stayed flat and didn't lose any students it was enough to cover the the uh three million that would be or almost three million that's needed for 2% raise got it thank you this will be very helpful for us as we work on our priorities we really appreciate the work you've done and look forward to continue to learn with you and from you on this process all right thank you uh that brings us now to item 4C uh a discussion on the developing elements and agenda and possible dates for a governing board retreat
061I'm happy to kick off since uh I was one of the folks who suggested it last time uh I would love for us to have a retreat we're a new board is it's um it's a new opportunity for us to come together I think to talk about at the board level our shared priorities for example what we just talked about in terms of the critical role that student enrollments play in our financial health and future as a district and understanding better um kind of the trends around that I think it's an important opportunity for us to build trust with each other as a new board U many of us are meeting each other for the first time or some of us and also to build trust with leadership in the superintendent um and then last
062but not least I think it's an opportunity for us to just talk about how we want to operate as a board um so I would love to see us come together I think it should be an agenda that is shaped by the board in terms of our priorities so hopefully that's what we'll have a chance to talk about now um is what do we want to come out of it as opposed to something that's uh kind of programmed or formulaic in terms of board Retreats because I think we're kind of a unique situation and I would encourage us to have an opportunity for the board to meet on its own uh as part of that agenda as well as an opportunity to meet with leadership so we can facilitate both levels of those conversations all
063right we'll just continue sure um I'll add to that very much in support um for me communication is key um and that we're new and haven't worked together as a group uh this Spectre of open meeting law is very interesting and like what we can and can't say and I don't want that to be the guiding factor of like oh I can't say that because of I risk and fear of that I believe and know we can get to a point where we have a good level communication without pushing up against that I don't want that to be a thing and so would love it if we could find good Norms as a group for communication that's really important for me Miss Carney Miss thank you president Lis I to am in support of a
064uh governing board working working Retreat uh special meeting um I'd like to hear uh president Lewis from you as I know you and Dr Menzel have met with Sarah James at asba and and started an outline uh which we have not received so I'd like for you to start there maybe of what you've developed already and then we can go from there excellent Miss uh Carney anything you want to add M Warner you want add anything well I'll proba add once I hear what sure you've started and see if oh yeah I'm sorry like okay sure uh so uh Dr Manel and I did meet with a a a new um director from uh the Arizona School boards Association we went to the meeting you had uh 10 months ago and said this is what
065was discussed this is what what seemed to go well this is what seemed to be in question um we think this is exactly the time to get to know each other to begin transends for trust with one another and get to know each other since we're new to one another um we did talk about making some space for um the board to work on communication goals or or elements of how we want to work together in terms of potentially learning even how to disagree um and um uh Norms did come up I'm trying to think Dr Manzel what else you might remember from that conversation so uh we you know some of the you think you've covered the big points but um in Broad chunks it's being clear about what your why is as board
066members to serve on the board and then thinking about how that why translates into our how creating consensus as a leadership team to move the agenda forward forcasta Unified School District and then uh governing board Norms you know and that would get to communication protocols and the kinds of things in terms of of how we're going to conduct our business to serve the students of this community so it was that broad level kind of conversation and and we actually did discuss with Sarah that should the board want to move forward with the retreat we would want her to talk with each of the board members to identify what your thoughts were about how that would be structured but we didn't want to be presumptive before having this conversation let go ahead okay so have we
067already selected Sarah James as a facilitator or where did she come into this uh well I think where we landed on that one was wanting to kind of move forward from the past and yet count on the expertise of asba um so she was recommended through that organization okay are we open to other recommendations I would say we are okay so how would we submit recommendations for facilitators right now is a great time to talk about it unless you want to take more time now I just think there's U other options that we should look into because I'm I know we paid U last time for the facilitator so how much would she cost I don't know the estimate was about $500 okay because Last Retreat we paid ,200 so you're saying um she would
068only be 500 I also know that um last year Steve Watson uh am amop county superintendent had said that he could um you know facilitate board retreat and I don't think there was a cost or much at all so I'm not sure if Shelley bogs who is the new uh superintendent could be an option if I'm not sure if she's her office is doing it or not but um I think we should look into something that is maybe a little more neutral than than asba I'll add I have no affinity for asba and I haven't been involved in anything I I don't feel if there's any you know baggage with it I don't need it I was thinking possibly a former board member from back someone who's been here that we agree on I don't
069have anyone in mind I'm just thinking someone that's we would know and has seen this that would I bet somebody would volunteer and be happy to do it because they've been in this seat um that's something I feel might be good and I'd be happy to ask around and see if anybody would do it but just thr on the table so I'd actually like to Echo what um board member Pinsky said and we actually met over coffee and what he was really looking for was an opportunity for the five of us to be able to get together and and talk which Amy W MC Carney and I did do that individually with board members when we got on the board because we opted to get sworn and late so that we could all meet without
070any open meeting V violations and that was taken from you guys when you opted to get um sworn in early because that would have been a an opportunity for us to have the conversations that you shared with me uh so I will also support what board member Pinsky said I think that there's an opportunity to be had with the five of us being able to have a meeting um to really have these conversations and obviously we'd be following open meeting law but um there's value there so thank you any advice or issues with not meeting with our CEO well to clarify I think both yeah I think it's important that we' be able to do both but I I absolutely think it's important important that we have an opportunity to to meet as a board
071directly in addition to the opportunity to include the superintendent I think it's partly topic specific um and I would add just a reminder that it would be a public meeting so you know I'm not sure we'd say you guys can't come it's not an executive session just to be mindful of that so we could be at the table in terms of discussion and and have parts of it where it's inclusive and partnering and a part of the conversation where it's uh the five of us sharing values and communication uh expectations or hopes of one another and ask that it just be the five of us commented in those different phases does that work as a golden mean so I would um again Echo what board member Pinsky said it would be two meetings obviously both
072meetings would follow open meeting law as I stated before and um when it comes to somebody being a facilitator it does need to be somebody who's achieved success in this Arena before um not a one-time board member or somebody who just may have been in education for a long time but really somebody who's achieved what we want to achieve so we want to look for a a masterful facilitator that would bring out from us what we want with one another I think that's a distinct skill set yeah and some but also someone who has experience with education understands open meeting laws Keeps Us in the right side um so understands the education context but also has a track record facilitating so so several ideas and names have been brought up a former board member Steve
073Watson Shelly bogs um Sarah what was her last name I'm sorry James James Sarah James from asba other ideas Mike's idea of kind of looking back at past board members who may have um served during High performing times and you know has the trust of this board okay so would you like how would you like that decision to be made suggest suggest names by email and then if there's seven different names how would you like that decision to be made one thing I I'm concerned about too is is uh where would the funds come from to pay a facilitator isn't that out of M uh I think there's probably I don't know I think there's a budget for board development right so I I think we'd be very mindful of um the funds that we're
074spending I'd prefer to you know that's I think that should be a priority is paying attention to not spending uh much on a facilitator if possible okay so low cost or no costs I I think that's wise with where you know where what we're facing right now um I also know there's a gentleman a local gentleman um who's done some work with the district his name is Lee Jenkins he's a former superintendent and also I believe um May um facilitate Retreats as well I know that name so with open meeting laws we decided we are not deciding to have the retreat we don't have to actually vote to have a retreat are we allowed to decide on a facilitator asynchronously through email or like a survey monkey or that has to happen in a live
075board meeting I think the board took the option to take legal action off the table by its last move so yes do you or no you cannot decide together to vote for anything since you're just having discussion let me ask it a different way do we have to decide the facilitator as an agendized topic no board meeting or we can just do not okay well so to to be clear um the answer is if the board is going to decide collectively you do if you're going to delegate that Authority so that you've identified the parameters and you want that decision to be made um Donna and I can because we set the agenda for meetings we could finalize that based on reviewing the people that you had ask what their costs are ask them for
076proposal but any action by the board would have to be at a public setting you can't send out a survey and say hey how do you feel about these because that's a vote that would violate a om that's correct but you could still set one and then have the meeting without a a a board action so where is your confidence lie I would want to make sure that we make a decision as a board that because I think there's opinions and that's great and I would hate to get off of the wrong foot by picking a facilitator that one person didn't agree with so I think that's something we should agend decide yeah okay so we will agendize this topic for Action bringing forward names an agenda and a date and then we will act
077does that make sense I'm just proposing that for a future agenda item in in as a caveat I don't think the agenda or the date has to be approved because that's part of those policies I think it's facilitator that um we would need to to vote on all right then we will once we get to Future agenda or we will just make sure that we put that on the future agenda to vote on the facilitator okay and I've got it just the last um comment if we're talking about uh what we would like to see on an agenda I do think um the the governing board needs to decide our key priorities and goals um for these next two years and Beyond and then I would like to see governing board operating principles and Norms
078which would include the communication uh piece as well and I really think that our our working Retreat should be really based on solutions to the um the issues that we heard tonight um you know from our administrator uh the head of our employee groups and that we're beginning to hear from teachers right now on on site so I really think you know we we need to be very productive with our time looking for solutions to these uh problems that we do have okay thank you yeah when we talk about sort of finding our why like I believe in that as a TED talk but as a like retreat function I think why at the level of what do we think the critical issues we're looking for as a board to be able to address and
079move the need along so I would Echo what Miss Carney described all right we will get uh Dr Manzel can you get an update on some of the names that have been mentioned and then let us know who you've reached out to and in their gist of their offers I can do that uh my only other concern is that given our next meeting is February 11th uh we will not be able to schedule something before then so that puts this back out into either late February or March before this would be possible and I think that's fine we're all good with that right okay good non-action discussion thank you very much everybody for participating so so uh thoroughly in it all right we we are now moving on to action items uh number or number
080five a the selection of a delegate and Alternate to the Arizona School boards Association delegate assembly uh I know uh Amy you were in that role last year is that right um correct okay and do you want can you share anything about the role that would help anybody say I want to do that what would be n is if um we the whoever is our next delegate would be provided expectations of the role because I never wasn't provided that and that would be helpful going into it um I just tried to attend whatever events I could or conferences um and then bring back that information um I think it's pretty simple um but probably meaningful uh well if no one's interested I am interested in that role and I am comfortable with some of the
081ambiguity of it but I would be willing to clarify the way in which a delegate uh leaon between a district and the State Association I nominate Donna Lewis for asba delegate second all those in favor I I I thank you we need an alternate don't get up too fast okay now you know why I was so quick to nominate you yeah I'll uh I'll promise to go to everything how's that and then if you and then I'll pick on somebody on the side are you cool with the Casual uh alternate alternate are we good with that okay clear ready to move all right you okay with that is that okay gladus with you okay I thought I was getting a little look all right five appointment of two board members to serve on the joint
082advisory committee on education now this is through the city of Scottsdale can you speak to it a little bit it's an agreement that was established a number of years ago uh that included members from the city council and the mayor representatives from scota Community College and scota Unified School District well we don't know whether or not the city council and mayor will want to continue this committee um mayor barowski did indicate at a meeting I was at that she's interested in that and I thought in order to be prepared should that committee go forward if we identify the two people who would serve from the school district that would be great if the city decides to discontinue the committee then um there would be no work well not for that reason uh in the hope
083that it actually does happen uh I am interested in in serving I'm I'm very interested in dual enrollment CTE a lot of the intersections between the district and the community college so this as a context where we can do that I would be happy to serve thank you others who are interested I will nominate board member Carney for the second spot on the joint education committee are you interested Okay I accept okay look at the enthusiasm I have served uh my first term I did serve on this committee and so I I'm familiar with it and okay um great I motion to approve board member Carney and board member Pinsky to serve on the joint joint uh education commit committee with uh s second that motion all those in favor I I motion passes by
084both thank you uh approval of we're on 5c approval of selection of audit Committee Member and I'm trying to think Karen did you serve on that one recently all right you want to share a little bit about it do you mind so the audit committee is um it's actually pretty interesting committee to serve on um you've the AG agenda's kind of been set for the next um several audits that will be completed however when things come up we can always um bring forward another audit and um you get a really complete look behind the scenes of what is happening with regards to we did a HR um audit which was uh very detailed it was um very telling to problem areas and areas of um strength and so I found it fascinating to be on
085there and would highly recommend it are there anybody is anybody on the board interested can I ask what the time commitment is like it's um it's once a quarter is it's not a lot of time at all about an hour and a half meeting I'd be to do it if it's agreed upon I nominate vice president chery to serve on the audit committee as the board representative great opportunity great all those in favor I I all right motion passes 5 thank you Mike we are on 5D approval of governing board member as self-insurance trustee who who served on that in the past um I did and I will not be returning to serve again on the trust committee all right so we need somebody interested in Self insurance and it will be a topic what
086that involves again time information it's not a lot of time commitment actually You' be um a great F because it's it's all the data with the numbers of the budget and so on it's it's I think you'd be really great out it are you willing can can I can I say one thing about that is that the meeting that starts at 4M though it is started in earlier times how frequently yeah um the self- insurance trust board meets quarterly generally on a Thursday at 4 um we have it's made up of three community members myself and a board member um we have asked about moving that a little bit earlier um but because of pickups and um work commitments we've struggle to move it earlier than 4 um but it's usually from 4 to maybe
087it's just a little after 5 um a Thursday every quarter I'd be happy to represent I motion to approve board member shy for the um self-insurance trust committee I'll second all those in favor I thank you uh vice president shery for your uh willingness to step on a couple of thesea on these uh tasks all right that moves us to to item five E it item 5e was me I put it on the agenda a little bit like a zealot that I am excited about the the growth potential for the board and and I am a big believer in staying up toate on National Trends and I am a big believer in modeling um the the need for being Learners um I know there are concerns relative to um our priorities and time and space
088and money um and I don't know what the right golden mean is for that if we can't all go and we don't all see the value in it yet or if we're developmentally not there as a board and we want to start um you know at a different Baseline um but I'm going to go ahead and make a motion uh to approve attendance to the National School Board Association conference for those board members uh who are interested in attending I think we need to have a discussion first okay well do we do we second the motion and then have the discussion I would it can go either way in my experience so you want to just go straight to discussion yeah sure I'll just put in my opinion um my only involvement with asba um
089this is National NBA that same the School Board Association has been the orientation that I attended uh as a new board member which was fine um I just don't think it's uh high enough value for the investment I mean the dollars I appreciate having the dollarss here and it's you know not going to break the bank but still every dollar helps um and as far as the value we're getting um I just think with our priorities I don't think it's something that we want to invest in I think there's enough experience here we can kind of attack our problem so um I think while there is potential value I in general I don't think it's something we should shoot for okay others I just had a few questions for you on it yeah um who
090would we be approving this for because it's very general and so it could be 20 people and we so in my experience the the Assumption has been the board and the superintendent so six people being invited okay um so have you when you were superintendent of Katon did you attend this with your board is that how you know about this yes and how many times did you attend almost every year okay yeah you guys um because I was looking at this and uh I I just agree with vice president shy it looks like it would be about 14,000 um 310 at least for six people um did we have we budgeted for funds for participation in in this conf in this conference um board member Carney we have budget for the governing board to attend
091professional development um I there's the budget within that was not set for you know multiple individuals to attend um so it would we'd have to move some money around to do if if everybody were to go if you know one or two there's probably enough in the budget to be able to cover that but we do have um dollars set aside for professional development for the governing board okay thank you I think I just um like to state that the district we've already paid asba um nearly 8 $8,000 for board members the superintendent employees to attend the law conference in September and then you all went to the new Board conference uh in the annual conference in December and then I uh saw board president Lewis you're attending the upcoming board operations and Leadership training
092seminar so I think we're getting um good training and and um you know support here locally in Arizona so I I would say that no to that I am not for approving this so I I do believe that we need to be focus our focusing our resources to our staff uh considering what we just heard from Miss kroer it's absolutely vital that we save every penny we can so that we can take care of the people that are taking care of our kids every day so I would be a no well at this point this feels like piling on but um uh I also think I I see the value I really do there are National issues issues around furpa around school safety around federal policy that I'm not sure we'd get quite the same
093access to Arizona uh at the same time I think particularly in this financial environment and in the first year of this newly constituted board I I don't think this is the best use of our funds so I also would vote no well first of all I really respect each and every one of your separate and individual opinions and as aligned as they are I'm going to align with each of you um so I would withdraw the motion and uh respectfully um hope that one day we will build our capacity to think like the global School District we intend and are intend to be and are that we will model leadership through the professional development that was brought up through our our leadership and uh Association that that was still something they wanted to hold high
094as a priority and we want to put our money there for them um but I also hope we'll invest in it too because the Pillars of Strength we each bring um also could use some finessing and I know we're going to get there just by working better together so I will withdraw the motion and uh thank you all for your comments and I align with you that brings us now to uh item F 5f we are on the second read in approval we had a presentation at the last governing board meeting so unless there are any questions I'll call for a motion to approve board policy I regarding the evaluation of instructional programs do I have I'll just make the motion to approve policy iil which was revised based on uh the statutory shifts from
095our policy governance team we need a second second any discussion all those in favor I I all right thank you passes 5 uh item 5G ratify the approval of purchase of fuel fuel tank removal and ground remediation for fuel tank leak at the district warehouse using the State of Arizona Cooperative contract do we have a a description of what we're talking about besides what's in writing do we want uh yes uh president Lewis um we um have an annual inspection that happens every year on our fuel tanks we have three sites that have fuel tanks um during that inspection this fall it was noted that a sensor was having issues um so we got the information on that worked with the inspector worked with the state on on fixing that issue when they came back
096out to again inspect it um there's like a probe that goes underneath the gas tank to check on that sensor and at that point they realized that when they pulled that probe back out it um had fuel on it which means that something is leaking we don't know if it is the tank we don't know if it is a fuel line we won't know that um until the tank is removed at this point um the fuel from that tank has been removed and moveed to thankfully we were able to salvage it and move it to um our other two locations um so we could save that part of it we are waiting the company has to work with um azdeq Arizona Department of um Environmental Quality um to get permits and get what's necessary to
097then go in and remove that tank once the tank is removed then we'll know um you know what the impact of it if it was a small leak or something something different we don't think it's passed in the it's P inspection in the past so um but we just won't know what that looks like until that tank is removed um we are waiting to get permits back on on getting that out because the fuel is out that should that would stop the leak um but the tank does have to come out and so we're just at this point waiting to um get those permits and get that scheduled um to have them come out and remove that tank um we have decided we don't need that fuel tank anymore there's a location just down the
098street uh not that far away um that you can feel up and so we have decided that we are going to just close that remove the tank and seal it up so there will no longer be fuel at that location um but to you know we we felt it necessary as soon as we knew what the situation was and what needed to be done that we needed to move forward with getting the fuel out and um getting the permits necessary to remedy the situation um so we did move forward with that purchase order even though it was over the $100,000 because of the nature of the the situation for it thank you do I have a motion to ratify the approval or are there any questions I make a motion to approve item 5G as
099proposed as proposed seconded all right any other questions all in favor I I and that was a five thank you we are now on um h5h the approval of the Cheyenne Traditional School grade three math curriculum and who will be presenting that today you guys have have any questions about it all right do I have a motion then I motion to approve the Cheyenne Traditional School grade three math curriculum as presented seconded all right all those in favor I I all right it passes 5 thank you and now we are on to the SE uh second read and approval of the Middle School planning guide if there are questions Dr sackos and Dr dods Karen are here to answer those questions Dr Pensky well I had raised last time we met about honors and sort
100of the clarity of the guide as relates to honors and the honors offerings since then I know we've heard from members of the Desert Canyon Community out of concerns about uh potential changes and their honors offerings so I'd love to just get an update on what if any changes are happening at Desert Canyon I think that's within the agenda coincidentally or up Dr DS um simply put we were able to um remedy that today a letter did go out to the Desert Canyon Middle School Community letting them know that we will have aors in all the core content areas great thank you clarification um and just any um any additional Reflections on the broader conversation how to parents in elementary school understand kind of what the placement methods are or criteria are what their rights
101are to appeal um kind of the expectations in parent teacher conferences to give families a sense of how they're trending uh just you know the broader conversation that we had last month I'm curious if if that's prompted any reflection on practice sure thank you for that question in this particular situation it had to do with um Staffing I'm speaking generally not about that a new topic oh a new topic well not a new topic it's last month's topic or last meeting we're fighting for the mic over here go ahead oh see if I can work it too thank you so much for the opportunity um yes absolutely the conversation continues um based on what you brought up last month I think there's some clear guidance around our gifted students it's all of our other students
102and looking at their opportunities and so I think as we reflect on our practices this spring especially with our fifth grade families there's a great opportunity to connect with Elementary leaders and have start to have even more of those conversations we've talked about and thought through um in elementary we have a middle school planning guide we have a high school planning guide we don't have as much um support in terms of educating Beyond Elementary and those often are our families who don't know what middle school is like and what high school is like and so we certainly have opened the conversation about what is the best way not only to communicate that for compliance purposes but also build practices throughout our system where we are having those conversations we're starting them in fourth grade and
103in fifth grade um and parents do really know what are the options the ins and the outs and there is no um one time you are able to be in and never again is the conversation broached and so it's really spurred the opportunity for us to really revisit some of those practices consider around how are we educating Elementary families on those transitional moments um and so it is work that continues it didn't uh prompt any additional modifications of the Middle School planning guide but it certainly has been in our on our minds in our mouths and a way in which we're rethinking how do we have those conversations um because when I was a parent of just a 10-year-old I didn't realize how important algebra 1 was going to be and how critical I could
104be as a as a parent in helping to guide those decisions and so from all of our experiences I think we bring together an opportunity to elevate excellence in that specific space so it's a continuing conversation that we will bring back and have some more conversations with leaders this spring about um but appreciated you bringing up the point it did not change or adjust anything in the planning guide for this evening thank you it's just helpful to hear you reflect back the concern so so fully and completely so thank you you're welcome okay thank you president Lewis um I I'm not sure I don't see that the board was forwarded that email um communication that went out to the Desert Canyon Community if we could see that communication that would probably be helpful for us
105as well thank you right are we ready for a motion okay oh I'm sorry I'm like come on people all right I'd like to have the I'd like to make a motion that we approve the second reading approval of the Middle School planning guide but thank you for not roll calling every vote this time we appreciate yep I learned I got feedback I'll second thank you if you motioned yes all those in favor the motion passes 5- Z thank you everyone we are now on our final action item I believe approval of the governing oh no we don't have it anymore because we moved it all right okay so uh at this time the governing board's going to move into executive session and we're going to choose to stay in this room so uh pursuant
106to ARS 38-43 1.03 the governing board may vote to convene an executive session for discussion or consideration of matters relating to school safety operations or school safety plans or programs regarding the 2024 school safety audit by the Arizona auditor general so I'm going to gavl at this time we need a motion to adjourn a mo I move that we go into executive session I second that motion all those in favor okay um and can we take a five minute recess we can do that and remind people there is no action item after this except for adjournment all right so e e e motion to I move that we adjourn second e