001e e e I call to order the first regular meeting of the Scot Unified School District of January 7th of 2025 and the time is 6: PM um Amy Carney would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance IED aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with li and justice for all if I get a roll call for my fire Mike shy Matthew Pinsky Donna Lewis Amy Carney Kieran Warner all five members are present I'd like to um approve the agenda is there anybody who has anything they uh want to pull from the agenda yes oh okay I'd like to pull item 8i SD work calendars please from the consent agenda okay so do I have a motion
002to approve the amended agenda excluding 8 I do I have a second second all in favor I I I all great that motion passes and um I don't have the meeting to form one second oh there we go all right so the meeting de Quorum is uh citizens attending or Andor participating in scal Unified School District meeting either in person person virtually or telephonically are required to observe the same Rules of Order and a quorum applicable to the members of the governing board and staff unauthorized remarks or demonstrations from members of the audience yells outbursts and other disruptions are not permitted um we will move on to two um student and staff recognition Dr menel that's two okay that's good that's wrong man taking nominations for the RO of President okay so what are we
003doing with number two the agenda was approved so it's actually in the agenda this is the agenda that was approved to perfect so I want to welcome us to a brand new year of 2025 and we're very much looking forward to um working with the new board and our District staff and I am going to take nominations for uh a new board President and Vice President and I um I'm really looking forward to having a functioning polite effective board and with that um I am actually going to nominate Amy Carney as president she is has an in-dept knowledge of policy she's polite she's strong and she runs a while meeting so with that I nominate um Amy Carney for president any other nominations yes I nominate uh Dr Donna Lewis for president I think she
004brings a wealth of experience as a former superintendent uh and is a bundle of joy to work with Okay anyone else then we will vote on Amy Carney first I'm I'm yeah yeah so I'm going to do the motion first so we'll do it um in order that it was received so this is taken off out of just what we did in 2023 with the new board so I motion to approve Amy Carney as uh board president do I have a second I accept your nomination and I will second that motion um all in favor say I I I all in favor now or excuse me all against nay nay nay thank you I would you like to make a motion yes I apologize um I move to nominate Dr Donna Lewis as president of
005the board do you have a second I'll second then um all in favor of uh Donna Lewis as president say I I I all um against say name no no that motion passes 32 congratulations [Applause] Donna thank you uh I would like to uh call for a nominations for vice president I nominate Mike shy as vice president do we have other nominations I'll nominate Amy Carney okay we have two nominations any other nominations okay given that they go in the order that they were Pro given uh I um would you like to make the motion official motion yes I move that Mike shy become vice president of the governing board okay do you want to second that uh yes I graciously accept and second that motion okay all those in favor uh will roll call
006I I I no no okay where the motion passes three to two so I no need to do it the second round okay thank you all right do we stay where we are recess all right we'll take a brief recess for uh repositioning thank you thank you so much e e e situate uh we're we're on item four student and staff recognitions and celebrations Dr Mel well thank you uh and good evening president Lewis and vice president shy and members of the governing board family and community members in attendance this evening by way of introduction to this recurring agenda item for our new board members from August through June at each month's regular meeting we take the first few minutes to celebrate the outstanding achievements and contributions of Scottdale Unified School District students teachers and
007staff and community members some of these accomplishments are achieved in connection with their susd ties and others are undertaken on their own outside of school or work or after hours such is the case with our first celebration this evening I'd like to ask Dr sackos assistant superintendent for secondary education to tell us all about this thank you Dr menel and evening president Dr Lewis vice president shy other governing board members and Miss Wagner and all of those in attendance this evening um I'd like to invite Arcadia High School junr Daniela Sanchez Morales principal dansy and any other Arcadia staff who have joined us tonight for this celebration up to the podium our other celebrant senior Emma finny from Desert Mountain high school is unable to join us this evening but I'd like to invite principal
008John Andrews to come to the podium as well please there he is last year the Boys and Girls Club of Greater Scottsdale announced that Daniela and Emma are moving among the five local teen leaders who are finalists in The organization's 2025 Youth Of The Year competition Youth of the year is the boys and girls club's highest honor these finalists have already in their young lives exhibited great determination and resilience and embody the club's core outcome areas of leadership character and service academic excellence and Healthy Lifestyles Daniela who I am informed um uh maintains a daunting course schedule consisting of chemistry algebra Avid dance American and Arizona history and English and is a top student top Titan she attends the Harley and Youth Barker branch teen center just across from Miller Road from here and had
009and has been a club member there for 10 years Emma is a part of desert mountains international baloria program and attends a teen center at the Virginia G Piper Boys and Girls Club Branch right next to Laguna Elementary School she is a 13-year Club member there is the distinction of course of being named the Scottsdale club's Youth of the year but there is also a $30,000 scholarship from the Boys and Girls Club of Greater Scotsdale Foundation at stake so we want to wish both of our students the best of luck also the student named uh the Scottdale clubs Youth of the year will advance to the state Regional and National Youth Of The Year competitions where they'll have the opportunity to win additional scholarships and National recognition man that's is so exciting are you excited
010all right um the announce ment of our local competitions winner will be made in March so we're going to do this we're going to do this uh Daniela um please accept this challenge coin and recognition of your outstanding efforts to date and there is no doubt you there's much more uh to come for you so [Applause] congratulations and principal Andrews if you would do the honor of um sending this challenge coin to Emma Finny and uh and please provide her our well [Applause] wishes congratulations Daniela on your selection and best wishes to both you and Emma going forward and we look forward to hearing of your future accomplishments inside and outside of Arcadia part of being a worldclass future Focus school district is finding additional resources for our teachers and staff to impact learning on
011the student level one such program began last year is The Innovation grant program state and federal programs director Dr David pisy is here to tell us about our latest round of Grant recipients and their plans for the funding They will receive Dr penisy the podium is yours thank you uh governing board president Lewis vice president shy members of our board Dr menel Mrs Wagner and susd Community First off happy New Year and welcome to our new board members tonight we are here to honor our 2425 susd Innovation award recipients at this time I'd like to call up our award winners and their administrators to the podium coming to the podium we have Jackie Clark and Tanner Bowman teachers at Tavon Elementary School along with principal Julie Ballard we can give them a round of applause
012we also have not able to join us tonight is our professional development coordinator Stacy Pascal um to represent for her is Dr Kim dods for the award thank you Kim we also have hokani Sanchez teacher at Kaa Elementary joining her is principal Matt gromek as Dr menel shared last year our Innovation strategic action team um co-led with Dr Michelle Watt and comprised of teachers and administrators from throughout Scottdale uh collaborated collaborated to launch a start start up Grant application for our school district our goal was simple we wanted to bring innovative ideas from our teachers and staff to life uh ultimately to help design innovations that may establish a foundation for scalability and possible replication in other schools here in Scottdale also centered to our work our team wanted to invest in ideas that position
013our SD students to be worldclass future focused Learners last year we awarded seven projects District wide applicants received up to $110,000 in startup funds to Kickstart their projects last year we saw the start of construction and an outdoor learning Lab at anastasi in partnership with the Maricopa pollinator pathway we also saw many stem projects which continue to be hot topics with our kids right now awarded at both tonala and Mountainside Middle School with resources to support coding and drone technology most recently at our susd Expo we saw Dr Rand showcase her students coding with ozobots all um from our Innovation Grant projects tonight we get to honor our 2425 school year recipients uh who will share a little bit about their vision for Innovation at their schools first up I'd like to invite Tanner Bowman
014and Jackie Clark from Tavon Elementary School um hello I'm Tanner Bowman and uh this is Jackie Clark our two programs that we're doing uh a hydroponic garden uh it's going to be through letu us grow we're going to have five different towers that we'll be um displaying in our cafeteria um we'll be growing over 120 uh vegetables fruits and herbs all at one time um and we're using it with our Blue Zone initiative to make sure we're doing healthy choices and showing students innovative ways of gardening and not just in the ground um and then for our inside out sound garden um we are using this with our third graders and doing a pbl around um creating their own prototypes of a sound garden and then we're going to be making their um prototypes come
015to life on campus for a legacy piece and allow students to learn how to regulate their emotions through sound and color um with a hands-on experience thank you thank you next up we'd like to invite hokani Sanchez from Kaa her project is titled content creation and production come on up Aloha my name is hokani Sanchez I'm a third grade teacher at Kaa Elementary School the Kea content and creation and production Club is to help students Express their creativity through videoing and it's also to help showcase ARA culture to our community that's it and finally Stacy Pascal is not able to join us but Dr dods is going to speak on her behalf thank you Dr P uh Stacy as Dr Dr P mentioned is able to be here tonight but she is lead on the
016teach FX project something that I know Dr Mensel was really excited about about a year ago um when we first learned about teach FX this is an opportunity for us to enhance teacher efficacy through an AI powered app that kind of puts a mentor teacher or an instructional coach in the teacher's pocket so it pays attention to what the teacher is doing in the classroom and gives them feedback at the end of their lessons so let them know how many times did you call on somebody sitting on the left side of the CL classroom compared to somebody sitting on the right side of the classroom how many boys did you call on compared to girls were your questions that you asked open-ended or closed-ended and so it gives the teacher immediate feedback that they're already
017taking for their observations with their principles to say in preparation for my formal observation here's what I know about my teaching and what I'm trying to do I hope you see this so we're really excited about the opportunity with teachfx to give the teachers immediate feedback on their instruction thank you Dr dods our awardees will set up showcase events at their respective campuses at the end of the year and our board members will be invited we hope you can attend tonight we honor our innovators with an susd challenge coin we want to thank each of you and please join me in a round of applause for our 2425 award recipients congratulations teachers and many thanks for the insightful new ways you will develop with these grants to enhance student engagement and learning uh thank you
018Dr Pinsky for helping to Shepherd this process along with Dr Watt and looking forward to uh seeing the showcase at the end of the year and Dr dods Karen don't go too far because our last celebration this evening is one of our favorites each year uh Dr dods Karen is here to help us recognize and thank our newly certified and newly renewed certified national board teacher educators [Applause] uh good evening again uh president Dr Lewis vice president shy governing board members Dr Mensel Miss Wagner everyone present here with us this evening uh I have to agree with you Dr menel that this is one of our best annual celebrations and it's a favorite for me to provide to you as our board we are here to recognize the work of our nationally board certified Educators
019with the following newly certified teachers and their princi principles please please join me at the podium and before I call your name I have a few principal leaders who are going to help in the organization of all of you so the idea will be that the teacher will stand in front of their respective leader and we are going to just create a nice I don't know grouping of all of you looking at our governing board and then shortly I'll pass out all of your um plaques and recognition so there's a few steps that we're going to take okay so I know you can do it because you are nationally board certified teachers so with the following newly certified teachers and their principles join me Ilia coborn from seoa Zasha Darnell Arcadia Ashton deck Cheyenne Serana
020Joshua Arcadia [Applause] and then now we are going to meet 13 of the 15 Educators who have successfully maintained or renewed their certification Darcy Aronson from Redfield Jen Bethy from lagona Patty hanlin from cooches Lori Campos from Cherokee Ashley K Saro High School Jen Fox hopie Sheila Fullerton Kea Kimberly kek Yavapai Tammy Ki Desert Canyon Elementary don't be shy you can come closer Tom Roxboro Desert Mountain high school Jessica Valencia teaching and learning team Kelly Vanden hubel Redfield and Anne wadington from Cherokee [Applause] I believe that Diana bod and Emily deck from Hy are unable to be here is that correct okay um but we do want to be sure that you are aware of them as well uh now that we've squeezed in thank you for participating and following such nice directions I want
021to also invite our SSD nationally board certification program leader Susan Leonard from Engleside middle school and her team of candidates support trainers Dr Tammy Diaz from Saro High School Abby bobbit from Puma Elementary and Community member Bobby fauler to join us Ann wadington is already up [Applause] here national board certification is the most respected PR professional certification available in American public education and what makes it unique is that it is entirely a voluntary undertaking national board standards have been developed for each area of certification and are designed to develop retain and recognize the accomplishments of teachers and their ongoing Improvement in schools Nationwide firsttime national board certification takes up to three years to complete that's what Elia Zasha Ashton and serani raise your hand um have just recently gone through give everybody a wave we
022are also here to celebrate the 16 teachers who have recertified for another 5 years Darcy Jen Patty Lori Ashley Jennifer Sheila Kimberly Tammy Tom Jessica Kelly and an say as Nancy has me Say howdy howdy when a teacher pursues national board certification they put their classroom teaching practice under a microscope to be reviewed against the most rigorous standards it's a exhaustive process that only about 10% of United States teachers attempt and of that 10% about 60% are successful and they do it all over and over again to be recertified or as we now call it maintain their certification first they complete a computer-based assessment to demonstrate their understanding of development developmentally appropriate content and practices for accomplished teaching in their specific content areas then the candidate submit examples of student work that reflects their students
023strengths and needs and how they want to use that in information to advance student learning and achievement for the third component candidates submit videos of their classrooms in their instruction with a written commentary describing analyzing and reflecting on their teaching with their students finally the candidates must demonstrate their ability to develop and apply what they know about their students in order to positively impact learning and to show how they use their professional learning communities of fellow teachers parents students in the community to achieve all of this and if that isn't enough maintaining national board certification has its own set of requirements not of Le not of the least which is proving specifically that they continue to go grow professionally why while substantially impacting student learning I can't tell you how proud We Are I could
024cry for all of our nationally board certified teachers um not only here in Scottdale but in Arizona but what's remarkable is that Unified School District has 76 nationally board certified teachers we are grateful to all of you for continuing to grow and move beyond for your students to make learning practical and engaging and meaningful and most importantly impactful we have plaques for all of you and I'm going to ask Dr sackos to join me to help me pass them out because um Dr Dr sackos specifically I'm asking because she serves on our susd foundation board and the foundation actually provides financial support for our teachers to earn their national board certification so the support of the SSD Foundation is Paramount to the continued success and exemplary leadership um here in susd so with that um
025we'll start from the right to the left so listen carefully C [Applause] Rasha Darnell Ashi s Joshua [Applause] jenos [Applause] Ashley Jen Fox sheon [Applause] Tammy Tom Roxboro Valencia [Applause] so now you are all going to follow LEP mat to aot thank you all thank you so much we're truly impressed by the dedication to your confession and it's so nice to be able to celebrate uh all of the hard work of our teachers and we're going to wait just a minute while they go out for their photo for our last celebration so last but not least uh we want to thank our governing board for volunteering to oversee this Legacy Public School District while three of you are new to this August panel and two of you are Midway through your terms with your partnership
026guidance and wisdom susd will continue to be one of Arizona's finest districts and our goal of course is to be one of the best in the nation so during this month uh 2025 Schoolboard recognition month we want to thank each of you for the work you've already done and we continue to do on behalf of scota Unified School District being a Schoolboard member doesn't come with a a paycheck that uh you can spend on anything but it does result in investing in the lives of more than 20,000 children to ensure that they're prepared to positively impact the world so thank you for agreeing to serve this District we appreciate you thank you Dr menel and that brings us to superintendent comments two very quick things tonight uh first the 25th Annual Martin Luther King youth
027voices program will take place next Thursday on January 16th at sawaro high school beginning at 9:00 a.m. uh each of the governing board members is invited to attend this year's guest speaker is bestselling author barari sers this is part of the community celebrating diversity MLK Junior event which culminates in the annual dinner later that evening but it's really nice when the students have an opportunity to participate in question and answer session with the keynote speaker for that event then on Thursday the 23rd we'll be hosting the Spanish spelling be for the district and on Friday the 24th the script spelling be both will be here at cornado high school they start at 9:00 a.m. in the audit atorium and again governing board members are welcome to attend and observe both the Spanish spelling be and
028the scripts spelling be so with that that'll conclude my report this evening thank you Dr Manzel all right that brings us to public comments the public comments will be conducted in accordance with board policy be um and I want to read a notice public comments at regular board meetings those wishing to address the governing board on information discussion consent and action or non-agenda matters need not request permission in advance however you must complete a digital form devices available at the table outside of the entrance to the boardroom indicating your desire to speak and submit before the meeting begins there is a two-minute speaking limit action taken as a result of this kind of public comment will be limited to responding to any criticisms made by those who have addressed the governing board directing staff look
029into the matter or asking that the matter be put on a future agenda no other discussion or legal action is allowed according to ARS 3843 1.01 we have four tonight we have four uh people who have wish wished to speak to uh the governing board and the public comments uh our first is uh Gary Shapero and uh Jeff r or rate am I saying it right rate thank you go second so we'll put you in the Batters box all right Gary if you'll join Jo us please good evening uh president Lewis vice president shy other board members Dr menel and uh secretary Wagner my name is Gary Shapiro and I'm a Scottdale resident and I came tonight because I want to express my enthusiasm for susd and our community our current School Board configuration gives
030us a new opportunity for highlevel competence and quality governance our community has spoken and understands the value proposition of our schools partisanship is not important what we have demonstrated time and time again is what is important is our kids congratulations and thank you thank you Mr chaperel uh Jeff will be up next followed by uh Patricia pellet did I say that right pet I spent 13 years as a full-time sub and seven years as a paid head coach in the district two years ago my brother and I were rehired by the principal to coach flag football cocopa he did e8th grade I did seventh all of the duties and responsibilities of these paid positions are outlined in the the governing board's Personnel policies and procedures manual during the first week of practice Dr Menzel's office
031notified the principal that if I didn't sign a volunteer contract the entire season for these 32 families would be cancelled after practice I wrote a letter to Dr Manel and hand carried it to his office he never responded that volunteer contract that I signed is invalid in a court of law since it was signed under coercion a lady was hanging around my practices some days she wore a dress the principal told me she never coached before and was thinking of being the athletic director next year and wanted to observe a good coach it was a ruse she kept telling me and my brother that she was a close personal friend of board president sinowski I found out later that she was paid my $1,800 coaching stien for doing nothing I know I was targeted because
032my brother was paid the Scottdale Education Association is a teachers union everyone knows it's an arm of the democratic party I was a dues paying member I met with the chief advocacy officer and communicated with the president Becky Williams they flat refused to assist me sinowski was a former president of the Scott sale Education Association folks I couldn't make this up the lady who received my stiping was also a former president of the Scottdale Education Association for 11 weeks I gave my heart and soul to this uh team and had a great season the parents were outraged when they learned of Menzel's Swindle one of them gave me a $250 gift card sinowski and Manel set up meetings with me and cancelled them at the last minute for no reason after a year sinowski informed
033me that all future communications would be with the district lawyer who promptly informed me that the one-year statute of limitations had expired to sue a public entity I guess Manel thought an old disabled veteran would be an easy mark thank you Jeff Patricia pellet followed by Mike Ben bener good evening board I'm Patricia pellet a mother of a special needs student here in SSD it's a new year a new regime new Department of Education lead and a new Amazing America county superintendent and a new addition to our Arizona Senate Board of Education a big ask of the new board is what will they do to make sure our kids are not only safe from predators outside of the school fences but inside of them my special needs boy is Chael Bound in 2026 this has
034been weighing on my mind since I heard about my friend special needs who was molested in 2021 by her special needs teacher Aid what can be done so I could trust any my boy there uh better background checks cameras at least in the special needs classroom uh my resolutions are susd focuses on academics removes the books illegally providing porn to minors according to sb107 pushes one example of a book available the miners um one excert my swells up think Daddy Daddy sick me up a I come and stop misleading our kids by teaching them their multiple genders and including Dr Lewis has told me to my face she believes in teaching our kids I will end with a funny fact Dr Manzel doesn't know we share a special connection we both attended the same Christian
035Pentecostal College in Costa Mesa California he was a few years before me this is when it was known as Southern California College in now Vanguard his mom I believe his name an seems like a very sweet caring lady from her recent motherly email to my friend protecting her boy she indirectly said that she's in denial and does not accept her boy would be okay with my issues above thank you thank you all right uh Mike uh Ben bener thank you my name is Mike benger to members Warner and Carney I'm sorry we could not get you any help as you push back against Menzel's plan to disrupt and dismantle susd it wasn't because we lacked great candidates or that dozens of folks didn't work tirelessly to get them elected I think it was because we
036couldn't overcome the destructive efforts of sea and the impact of out ofate money just know that 42,000 voters agree with what you are doing and we will continue to support your efforts we can do nothing less as our kids and grandkids Futures are at stake to the new board members we will hold you to your campaign promises to listen to susd parents and taxpayers don't just protect Manzel how about protecting the students from a destructive policies and working to improve their academic performance and as one student said tell teachers to stop asking for our preferred pronouns remember shy I hope you have read the parents Bill of Rights and now understand that parents have the right to make decisions about their kids' education and health care you should stay in your lane focus on academics
037and not worry about students Health Care decisions that's not your job let the parents handle those under Menzel susd has seen a steady decline in academic performance and he created a my way or the highway environment this must be fixed or Exodus from susd will continue remember Lewis given your dismal record of academic achievement and your creation of a hosle environment while in the Craton District I have little hope you will do anything to stop those Trends but we shall see member Pinsky is your kid still at broy we will be watching closely to see if you try to repay your outou of State business associates for donating thousands of dollars to your campaign most business people don't spend money without expecting a return again we shall see to the susd parents again I call
038on you to get engaged and find out what is happening in the district come to the board meeting speak out or email the board members and express your opinion about what they are are or are not doing remember they work for you thank you that concludes our public comments we are now at item seven for information and discussion items excuse me I yes sorry I'd like to respond you're right thank you my apologies uh are there any board members who would like to respond in the within the parameters of our limitations yes thank you um thank you president Lewis um I would like to ask for an executive session with um Mr Jeff r that the board uh invite him to an executive session so the new board members can hear and actually that we
039can hear from him because the uh prior executive session we had did not include him thank you any other comments from other board members okay thank you so much my apologies for moving along uh number seven is information discussion items we have four uh first 7A is the annual open meeting law training and uh Mr buzan are you going to be give delivering this tonight yes president Lewis thank you excuse me good evening uh president Dr Lewis vice president shy members of the board Miss Wagner Dr Manzel um this annual open meeting law training is something that's actually required uh by a consent agreement from a couple of decades ago um but ultimately it is a good practice to do annually I think it's beneficial for the board board but also for the public to
040see uh what the board actually goes through in order to have conduct a meeting and uh do this um under state law so as your general counsel I will be your guide uh through tonight's open meeting law um many of you have received open meeting law recently and for others uh numerous times in the past and so tonight I'm not going to uh go that deep into it it's just going to be a refresher and then a summary of what we are doing here at Scottsdale unified to comply with the open meeting law I note at the outset that open meeting law only applies to the meetings of public bodies and instrumentalities of such susd is defined as a political subdivision which is a public body a subset of a public body as a helpful
041comparison private school schools do not fall under open meeting law nor do homeowners associations similarly open meeting law does not apply to student councils or booster organizations as they are not public bodies the legislature is a public body uh but in 2022 the Arizona Supreme Court in a case ruled that the legislature makes interprets and enforces its own procedural rules regarding open meeting law this body as a creation of statute does not have that same prerogative like it or not this body must comply with oml open meeting laws requirements go hand inhand with their purpose to have meetings to be conducted openly and uh to make sure that we follow a couple of the requirements of open meeting law number one SD must provide reasonable notice to members of the public when and where a
042meeting will occur at SD we provide this notice at our website 24 hours prior to the meeting and we post it at the district office Mrs Wagner takes care of that uh for every meeting the second requirement of notice includes an agenda that agenda must have all the items intended for discussion or action each item is must be described to meet the what's known as the person off the street test uh basically that is if someone is not familiar with what's going on with Scottsdale unified's calendar of business they may read that agenda item and figure out what will be discussed or whether the board will take legal action occasionally there is a disagreement about a particular item uh for that reason Dr Manzel has requested that I as the district's in-house attorney review each
043agenda item for specificity I do that uh weekly or for every board meeting a week prior to and then also the day before with Miss Wagner in addition to reviewing each item during the meeting I listen uh for One Singular purpose not to make any judgments on any of the political decisions that are made here um but just to determine whether discussion is going beyond the scope of the agenda item now there are a few exceptions to the person off the street test agenda requirement student discipline hearings is one uh they are not provided with specificity and that's to maintain the anonymity of the student that is a very difficult word to say in real time I apologize I think the the transcript will uh know what I was saying um and also items permitted
044for executive session are permitted to be vague so as to not defeat the purpose of the executive session now open meeting law applies to meetings and you could see they bolded it's all legal action of public bodies shall occur during a public meeting I'm going to skip to uh the definition of legal action here so if a quorum of board members is together discussing the NFL playoffs or something not related to susd obviously that would not be a violation it needs to be something that's foreseeably going to come in front of you uh for legal action um also just to note for the public and for the board uh we have a notice that I believe is on our on our governing board website of instances where the board members may be together so that
045way the members of the public know that you may see board members talking and they're actually not uh consorting to you know come together and figure out some legal action they may just be there watching the football game that sort of thing we provide notice to the to the public of that sort of thing now I'm skipping to page nine now in determining what legal action in legal action is it's it's a uh if you're an attorney reviewing an open meeting law complaint you really get into the deep into the weeds with it um for those following along in 2023 you may recall that the Arizona attorney general uh reviewed a complaint made against our district in from 2023 um and last year uh the Attorney General came back and said that there was no
046violation however they did conclude that some of our practices um ran the risk of Outsourcing a public discussion um which uh that particular attorney general was concerned about um at the time that's uh what we have called a 2X two by1 meeting if you had been paying attention to that U basically it was two board members sitting with an employee well uh when the Attorney General looked into this they conceded that board members are not prohibited from discussing matters with another board member so long as the discussion does not directly or indirectly involve a quorum of board members um the problem arises when those discussions are shared with other members which then does What's called splintering the Quorum so if you have two members and then that communication then goes to a third now you're
047having a meeting now you're violating open meeting law two members on their own are not not violating open meting law uh the opinion there though specifically asked for for us to give uh board members this reminder do not discuss the information received from each other you know if it's just two people with the other board members this admonition is key to avoiding the appearance of De deliberations outside of a meeting but to be clear it is not an open meaning law violation to receive information or ask staff about a particular issue the violation occurs when a quorum deliberates outside of a meeting finally um Scottsville unified has a practice of ensuring that all board members are provided with the same information when a board member has a question this ensures that when the board deliberates
048at a public meeting like today tonight each member does so with access to the same information so being that so many members of the board are uh familiar with open meaning law have been recently been trained on it we're aware of the investigations that we had last year um I'm not going to go through every slide basically uh the open meeting law summed up is that it requires notice to the public of where and when we hold the meetings what we will be discussing what decisions will be made and then finally which I didn't discuss there are always minutes of the meeting fortunately uh for susd we have this stream through YouTube and it will be available um directly after there was an a situation last term where there was a malfunction in the video
049um and we created minutes uh to comply with the open meaning law on that situation um and I think we ultimately got the video online if I if I do recall um are there any questions seeing some head shaking no so thank you do we have one Amy Miss Carney uh thank you I just want to reiterate um so we understand so two board members can meet with one employee or we cannot it's not a practice that we will be instituting I believe with 2 by two by ones but um the no I'm not saying a two by two by one I'm just saying can according to open meeting law can two employees or two board members meet with an employee or is that breaking open meeting law the the letter that we received from
050the attorney general frowned upon the practice but unless there's any step to communicate that to a quorum then technically it's not a violation okay thank you I will reiterate though for the Public's awareness because I know you know this very well miss uh Carney that the district Prides itself and good board governance Prides itself on making sure that all the communications uh go through the superintendent with the board it's helpful so that way the entire board can learn uh what a particular question is from an individual board member and so uh discussions with particular employees should include the superintendent thank you uh Mr buan uh since there are no more questions we'll move on to 7B and Mr buzan I think you're leading us through that one as well uh which is the family educational
051rights and Privacy Act also known as furpa for our education all right um I'm going to forego uh greetings since we just spoke um the family educational rights and Privacy Act is a federal law that was passed in the 1970s and its primary purpose is to protect student privacy and actually uh when I was going to give this presentation in October I had spent a considerable amount of time reading into the history of furpa and a law review article there um I am going to spare you the details on that I know that people are aware of furpa really I just want to go into what we do to make sure that we follow furpa um the history of it though is that it was designed to make sure that parents could access records that
052the government wouldn't get too large well the government's large all right but the the designate the the deliberations at the time and it it was actually actually this is a historical piece that I think I should share um it was actually uh I think it came from a Vanity Fair article the idea an author for Vanity Fair wrote something about it this is directly after uh Watergate and from that idea stemmed the idea to bring the legislation it passed in one term and it's been law for for 50 years now um ultimately what it does is it gives parents the right to inspect the records the educational records of their students ask for an amendment which we have an amendment process um if if they find something incorrect in the records and um provide consent
053uh or require consent for educational records that are going to be released to outside bodies so um there are some exceptions to the consent uh portions one of those is directory information I'll just go ahead and through my slides a little bit here um if if uh how do I go back there we go if a party is seeking to an amend a record we have policy uh Jr which is student records and there are several exhibits there anybody who uh you know finds something inappropriate in the records and and we get these requests sometimes um can either utilize those exhibits or just email their principal or the legal department and if necessary um to have those amended um was going to go to the uh directory information piece um so with regard to consent
054uh we don't have to get consent in these particular situations um school officials that have a legitimate educational interest we're not going to ask for consent for each you know obviously for the teachers or principes to look into it um there are other schools uh when a student is transferring those you don't have to provide parental consent for that um one situation where we do provide consent is uh for for uh colleges for universities they're asking for Student Records we'll make sure that the um parents provide consent in that situation um directory information is uh specific information students name address honors and awards and dates of attendance uh for that type of information that's actually included in the student code of conduct each year when you uh register your student you check a box um
055and state whether or not directory information can be provided to those those that are requesting it um through the public records program which we use gov QA uh we are regularly providing directory information to um certain bodies like the military that request it um when we get other public records requests for specific information uh we make sure that that's red redacted um and we redact all information um that has to do with students that aren't from uh the individual requesting it so um if it's a parent requesting it which like I said going back to the beginning of the this presentation if it's a parent requesting the information we uh are required to provide it to them right you have a right to inspect and review it so that's not a public records request it's
056a records request when somebody who's not a parent requests that information that's when we have a voluminous uh redaction uh process that occurs and that's why we have a um a a very long cue sometimes of public records requests um I will I'm happy to say this isn't a public records presentation but we are down from uh up about 38 total requests uh our paralal Luis cassada got it down to about 15 um in December so we have caught up a lot on that um regarding policy Jr there's just a couple of things I'll I'll discuss um the this school district actually has a regulation JRR for student records and it defines um what criteria is used to determine who is a school official that has access to the particular student data so we at
057the district are very careful about you know sensitive data about kids um and we don't just share it willy-nilly with everybody so if there's a you know if there's a um issue with a student that's having behavioral problems and general counsel finds out about it and Dr sackos is involved because she's the assistant superintendent of secondary and somebody else is involved we're not sharing that with the entire cabinet right those aren't the types of discussions that we're we're um working on it's very private so um I'll just note that in this regulation same goes for members of the board uh in the regulation it states a person duly elected to the board under limited circumstances we do that for two reasons number one to protect the privacy of the student and number two to protect
058your ability uh to decide on student appeal issues with a open mind so we don't want to you know Poison the Well there and um include too much so that's why there is limited information on students uh we are committed to keeping student data private and that's all the information I have on that one thank you Mr Pres are there any questions regarding furpa uh Dr Pensky thank you and excuse me for the Public's benefit we've had the benefit of training and orientation on both of these so hopefully we seem fully engaged but if if not it's because we've had the benefit of of going through it before my question is about technology and so whether it's the example that was given earlier about an AI co-pilot to a teacher you know providing feedback on
059practice or suggestions around cameras in classrooms would you say furpa is the kind of dominant policy framework for how the district thinks about how technology May directly or indirectly capture information about students and under what circumstances we're comfortable with that and not question well I don't know if I'm an expert enough to say it's the Dominate policy framework but it is definitely a law that we have to you know follow um with a lot of the agreements or a lot of the um curriculum or uh supplemental curriculums that we review uh we ensure that if there's going to be student data Pro uh provided to you know an outside company that they are a um under an agreement a data privacy agreement where they have agreed not to share the data not to sell the
060data um and that they have a data privacy agreement with us um so Dr Watt I believe is here she's involved uh pretty closely with that and um we will not approve uh any sort of agreement with outside entities unless they um have you know data privacy uh you know a stringent data privacy program and an agreement with us thank you any other comments or questions thank you Mr bazon that brings us to item 7 C it's a first read which means we should be prepared next meeting to act on this uh topic which is the Middle School planning guide for the 2526 school year and Dr dods Karen is going to leave the presentation assisted by Dr sackos as required good evening again governing board president Dr Lewis vice president shy governing board members
061Dr menel Miss Wagner those who are still with us this evening uh Dr sackos my co-lead on the planning guide processes is here this evening with me to share with you the first read of our proposed 2025 2026 Middle School planning guide uh similarly to what I know you have all um been learning from um Mr buan the governing board members Carney and Werner you've learned a lot about the Middle School planning guide and the high school planning guide so this is your time to listen but for me to try to educate as well our new governing board members on the processes so it'll be a little redundant to you but um you can be my check for understanding to make sure I'm getting it all in but this way we thought we could just
062share with you the annual process that we follow for our Middle School planning guide there is a parallel process that we do for high school planning guide that was already previously um presented and approved so the work of the Middle School planning guide committee it's been designed to align with our district strategic plan in support of our key performance indicators always that's our kind of our Guiding Light as our strategic plan academic excellence and climate and culture specifically with the guide the Middle School planning guide process is an annual review We Gather stakeholder input be that the community our teachers our school administrators for ideas they have for new courses or changes they want to see and we come together we work very very carefully in coordination with our simar department that's our student information
063and assessment department so we work with them to ensure our course codes that we'll talk a little bit about in a little bit um are accurate um are reflected appropriately for the Arizona Department of Education and our in our Synergy system so when we go to create class schedules everything is accurate tonight we're going to talk with you about some new courses and some edits uh we take your feedback always we take feedback from our community our teachers to try to figure out ways to make this planning guide the most userfriendly tool possible to really um Elevate all the things that we're doing in our schools because we have really neat courses I think at high school planning guide board member Carney was like Wow there are so many things available for kids in our
064schools the same for U Middle School that we'll share with you tonight um the work of our committee includes a variety of stakeholders as you can see here um Dr sackos affords time for us during the Middle School breakout meetings which are times for the Middle School principles to come together but she carves out about an hour for several weeks for us to include other folks from our teaching and learning Department our gifted Department ELD CTE to all sit around together so that we have all different perspectives when we're coming forward with new ideas or things for us to be considering collectively our committee seeks to um gather input and design um our planning guide to most most accurately reflect what we want to offer in our schools so tonight I want to share with
065you a few new courses there's a new course that we are proposing it is an accelerated middle school science course it's a year one course this is found on page 35 now board members Carney and Werner had the opportunity to learn a little bit last year about this idea was born for Mojave Middle School um principal principal Paul Ferrero and our director of the gifted program Sarah toron is here too um to talk they they aren't talking tonight but they had this idea that they wanted to redesign opportunities for kids at Mojave middle school so out of that came the idea for kind of a modified Math and Science Academy at Mojave and that feeds directly into Saro high school so key to that would be a science course hence an accelerated middle school science
066year one course this would be for sixth grade students next year we're also proposing an accelerated middle school science course year 2 that would be one year out but we wanted to bring it forward to you so that we would be preparing for what would happen for our students so when parents are looking at a planning guide they would be able to see if I have a sixth grader and accelerated year One what does that mean for them as a seventh grader as they're planning their Continuum in susd something that the governing board has previously approved was Mandarin Chinese course 2 at Desert Canyon Middle School we have a dual language immersion program for Mandarin it starts in the elementary and it moves to the middle school we are uh we previously had board approval
067for a course Mandarin Chinese 2 however we now have eighth graders who need to take that course at the middle school this is typically a high school course so we are requesting that the governing board would approve that we can use the course code for the high school course in our middle school so we're bringing that forward to you and we also are bringing forward a change um with course codes I don't know how familiar you are or how much you want to know but course codes are specific to school districts but they align to the Arizona Department of Education course codes so while Scottsdale might be course code ABC um Paradise Valley might use a number system 1 two three but in all whatever course we we describe say Mandarin Chinese 2o it aligns
068with the Arizona Department of Education course so what we're presenting to you with the IB nyp arts media production this is a move it's moving from the design section into the arts section so we'll be we'll be creating a new course code it's no change in the curriculum or anything within the myyp program other than frankly the section in the planning guide that would require a change for us we are proposing the removal of preap geometry and statistics this is a duplicate course for honors Geo trig honors geot trig is a course that's taken in eighth grade by many of our students in our schools at one time there were a variety of schools that were using a pre-ap curriculum we still have schools like here at Coronado High School that uses preap geometry and
069statistics but that's at the high school so at the middle school we don't have anybody and we didn't want to cause any confusion and accidentally have a course code on a registration form for a student to think oh I want to take that when it isn't available instead they would be taking the geot trig honors we also have worked really hard at cleaning it up and board members wner and carner can attest we have a lot of eyes on the planning guide but inevitably we find typos we find um spacing issues and so we do put a keen I so a few things that you'll know very simple things like a date change but we also took the time to the second bullet says new information about middle schools and live links found on page
070four we are very proud of what we offer in our schools in Scottsdale but what we found on our page four was they just listed our schools with a map so a simple change we made was to hyperlink every school so if a parent is looking at the planning guide they could click on let's say cocoa click on cocoa and it would take them straight to the cocoa paa website they would see what the school looks like they would see announcements things that are happening at the school kind of bring that school to life for the family and we also included a new description about what our comprehensive middle schools offer for our community additionally we created new course sequence Graphics in the high school planning guide we did this as well they now are
071all in the same format which you might think oh a table is a table well they were all a little bit different so now they are all follow the same flow map and they also follow a color pattern that is ADA Compliant we want to be sure that everybody has access a few other things we had every content coach go through their particular section and just read what the content said and see if there were any changes that we needed to update based on anything going on at the ad or um within our state and then lastly we made some revisions within the gifted education and special education program descriptions not changing the function of the programs but just some language descriptions and with that um any questions or feedback we're happy to take that
072before we come back to you again for a second read and approval I have a question on the um uh page 25 talks about the math and the assessment and Alignment in looking at the math courses what's the alignment between the the assessments for the course and the state assessments I'm thinking towards the goals we have on proficiency on the state um you know one's a subset of the other like how is just real short how is that alignment done just so that students are prepared for the state assessment in addition to the class itself thank you uh vice president shy all of our curriculum is directly aligned to state standards and our teachers utilize Curriculum maps that are organized in a scope and sequence so let's I'm going to throw out a number just
073for example let's say there are 15 standards for sixth grade math those fif 15 standards would be mapped out in the course scope and sequence for the teacher to use in their curriculum mapping when planning for instruction in their classroom while the classrooms and sixth grade all have the same Curriculum maps the pace at which those classrooms function can be a little different so if I'm your teacher we might be rocking and rolling and we're going at a clip in first period second period might need a little bit more reteach we're still sixth grade students but you might first period and second period might be at a little bit of a different place but in the end we're all going to accomplish all 15 of those grade level standards so that's how we directly align
074Additionally the curriculum that we are very blessed to have in Scottsdale um thanks to our voters and our taxpayers thank you for our curriculum we are able to purchase um high quality instructional materials and all of the resources that we purchase are directly aligned to standards so that teachers can Ensure that when they're using their textbook for their tier one first best instruction the curriculum is aligned to our standards which then is preparing kids for our state assessments on the um the diagrams are great by the way like for the math so like on the accelerated courses are the outcomes for that course a superet of the state standards are there more things taught in those accelerated courses than the standards require for that or is it is it Pace or depth I'm just warning
075the difference uh pace and depth would be the difference with accelerated they're going to compact they're going to accelerate the learning and um we actually have curriculum apps on our website so any Community member can go to the SD website for academics and you can click on grade level curriculum apps and see what is it that a student in a typical sixth grade class or a sixth grade advanced class would be learning thank you thank you um I have a few questions about the description of Middle School honors okay uh programs so the first and maybe this is a test of whether you belong in the honors program outside of math um is the eligibility requirements where it describes a framework of four criteria I think and you have to meet three of them but
076then a parent could ask to have one waved and the student then can enroll on a pro on a probationary basis I guess so I just want to see if I understand that right and maybe you could talk more generally when students are in fifth grade is it a standard practice for the parent teacher conference to begin the discussion around you know whether their student is on track to be recommended into the honors program and what affordances are available if they're not yeah can you just talk a little bit about uh eligibility and counseling to parents please absolutely and for those of you if you might be looking at the planning guide I think he's referring to page 70 that does describe this and I'm going to invite Sarah torion who is our director of
077gifted education to come on up and talk a little bit about the placement process for the honors program thank you nice to meet you nice to meet you too all right thank you good evening and I'm super excited to be able to share a little bit about the process that we have in place for our honors placement um current ly in our ad and governing board approved gifted scope and sequence 2021 we um list the way that we service our gifted students at the middle school level and honors is one of the ways that we do that um we also list additional criteria because our goal is to identify and enroll all students who would benefit from the challenges of honors courses while also ensuring that the honors environment um maintains its integrity and its
078rigor and not just an honors class in name only um therefore I I think what I heard you ask specifically is is is there a protocol or a practice in place specifically for fifth grade there's not a set protocol in place currently conversations happen around course enrollment um during this enrollment period which begins here shortly um and the gifted Specialists kind of act as the liaison between um the fifth grade teachers and the middle schools in order to ensure that we're capturing all of those students however because the enrollment is done a little bit differently in each of the different learning communities um there's not a set practice however um in pursuit of elev Excellence um that is definitely an um an area in which we can improve um our practices and our communication with
079families as well as with staff members and um schools to ensure again that we're meeting our goal of making sure that we're capturing all of the students that would benefit from taking those classes and was I thank you and was I describing the eligibility criteria correctly there's four and you have to meet three but you can opt out of one of three so you need to meet two to enter on a prob probationary basis correct that is current practice okay and that is in our 2021 governing board approv scope and sequence um however that's something that we can look at um and revise if Jud try that's that's just our current practice and that again is to go okay this is the way we statutorily service our gifted Learners at the middle school level um
080but again looking at other students because that's only one data point right and so we want to look at all of the criteria have conversations dig a little bit deeper that is the goal of that internal rubric but the criteria is listed in our scope and sequence and again in the Middle School planning guide okay and thank you and one last question um if I may yes uh thank you is is it eligibility driven or is it capacity driven by which I mean if Middle School a uh has feeders that sum to 100 students who meet that framework they're going to spin up the number of sections required to serve a 100 students or in practice I forget Middle School was a middle school a has capacity for 60 students and so the way that
081rubric is going to be be applied is to the top 60 of the hundred yeah there are a lot of different factors that go into determining um St course course schedule Staffing thank you if I may I'm happy to help thank you so much for the question I've got three different yeah no you're absolutely right and so um outside of gifted we do ask and um Dr sackos can probably uh assist in some of those if you wouldn't mind just to repeat the spec specificity of your question I want to make sure I answer honors eligibility again this comes back to the guide in terms of how parents are educated about what to expect and when they learn about different you know stages um is it eligibility driven so if a 100 students from the
082feeding elementary schools met the criteria we would find a way yes I'm New York accent came back we find a way to spin up the number of sections to serve a 100 students or in practice which I would understand its capacity it driven we only have 60 seats and so we're going to approach evaluating students in essence 60 out of 100 no thank you so much for repeating I'm so sorry I do want to honor the fact that the eligibility criteria drives that work and so student course requests student eligibility is what then School leaders would use to build a master schedule with the appropriate amount of sections we wouldn't withhold students opportunities from entering those honors courses because we didn't have um that amount of sections we would be looking for alternative Solutions um
083and finding other ways to make those types of sections what we would call make um meaning that there's an adequate amount of students for that FTE but we don't set the enrollment and honors courses at a specific there are uh two sections which is 60 kids and no more can get in there than that we definitely want to be fluid and flexible to ensure as many students who would benefit from that rigorous environment in those honors courses are invited and able to be successful there thank you so I coming back to the guide not not necessarily for the action that we take at our next meeting but I do think that you know that 4 3 two it varies by Middle School I I think there's an opportunity to be a little bit clearer about
084um the process and the affordances that are available to parents and the spirit of that is I think it's one of the really attractive things about our district and as we look to attract and retain enrollment if honors is something that's going to excite families to participate in Scottdale I think we want to lean into that as opposed to you know treat it as a um we want it to be a gemstone but treat it as a gemstone well I'll end it there thank you so much and I've jotted down that information so we can work on clarifying that for you any other comments or suggestions as we prepare for the second read uh or at this juncture if you have any others we can communicate it to Dr Menzel anything else board member at
085this time okay thank you so very much thank you and now we move to 7D it's our first read governing board policy iil regarding evaluation of instructional programs this is a policy first read so we'll be prepared for a second read next meeting for action good evening again governing board um policy iil just so you know how this came about um over the last few months uh Dr manelle myself and uh paralal Luis Casada sat with a policy evaluator from the Arizona School boards Association and we went over every one of our policies and so we're going to be bringing policies for update um this particular policy I evaluation of instructional programs um includes a couple of State statutes that have to do with testing requirements um the suggestion at this time well not for
086voting today but just for discussion and then um you know we can also take any suggested changes uh via email and before the next meeting um this is just for first read is to include what's from a statute 1578 I believe uh which was actually passed in 18 and this is a a compliance statute one thing that I will notify uh or provide notice to the board is that I've already checked with Dr bachna in um the simar area and this notice is going out so basically if the there's a lot of ifs in this statute but if the testing results are out and if there are sixth to eth graders that are shown not to be proficient in mathematics the district then must uh provide notice to those students and also provide a description
087of the current mathematics Services provided by the school um including supplemental instructional Services I have reviewed that um notice that we provide it's robust um and it is tells everybody who you should contact um I can provide that to the governing board uh I should have done that already but I'll do that um after this meeting um the suggestion here is just to include that statutory piece in policy so that you know heaven forbid we lose staff or what have you it's always in policy and we know that we're following it governing board any questions suggestions at this time Mr shy yeah um just question on the timing so from as I read it it's saying if a student didn't score proficient let's say at the end of sixth grade then by the fall of
088their seventh grade is when the notification happens is that the right timing that's my understanding okay and that goes to high school so if you're at 8th grade and you didn't pass the proficiency end of 8th grade when you're in high school the notification happens in the fall of your nth grade I read the statute like that I'd have to check with Dr bachon to confirm that we're doing that but that's how I I read it yeah I'm happy to respond that is exactly how we do it once um ad confirms all the final score reports which often is at the very beginning of the next calendar school year that is when the notifications go out so the um supports for students and those types of things are always in the year after they take
089that spring assessment and then more of a um process question for us at the district that's valuable information we know these students who didn't we obviously want them to do well what do we do with that I mean notification is one thing is there someone who's accountable responsible in the district to kind of follow up or what is the process with that that's a great question I would say the in terms of accountability we have uh where we send it out we can see where it's sent out what parents are responding through let's talk or those types of conversations what we would always encourage is that letter should never be the first time you're hearing that your child was uh you know underperforming in the state assessment and so many of our practices and protocols
090would encourage those conversations to happen prior to the exit of that school year um but when that does come yes through the October parent conference window or those curriculum nights that's when we would encourage those conversations to happen is so is the person most responsible so like if a student didn't show proficient on a math assessment would it be their math teacher who sort of like has the most accountability to make sure it happens or is that not that direct I think it would be uh within a mtss a multi-tier systems of support what we have our teams at schools that are working on problem solving and supporting students at a variety of levels so while we would expect differentiated and supportive instruction from the math teacher in the math classroom we would also expect
091the school leadership team or intervention team which can consist of math Specialists or a school counselor um people who also have wraparound care for students to also help problem solve and uh have some of those parent Communications so it should never land on just one specific person at a school solely accountable to support a struggling learner it really is a team approach and through those multi-tier systems of support that's where we're having those ongoing conversations and looking for uh ress monitoring progress celebrating our students when they do make that progress but also problem solving and intervening further when they don't and one last thing you guys will get sick of me over the years of this I'm a data guy do we track it is there a a CRM system something where we have data
092that says this student ones proficient I talked to the parent do we have that kind of system we have a within Synergy we definitely have some opportunities to log those parent interactions I don't know that that is a specific practice uh systemwide um but it is something that we track their ongoing performance through um all of our data systems and have those conversations but in terms of the direct Parent Connection logged or captured anywhere that could create a visualization or a a student data sheet of any kind that's not a widespread act uh process but definitely something that is uh worthy of further consideration to continue those uh conversations with families thank you very much yeah thank you any other comments questions at this point I have one this is directly from policy services at
093asba is that correct did they author the uh is still a trademark for asba that's correct thank you all right I think we're good y all right thank you Mr buzan all right that brings us to consent agenda item8 and with the exception of the amendment for pulling item I 8 I I'm going to go ahead and make a motion that we move to accept consent agenda items a through K minus I uh and look for a second a second okay and I'll go ahead and call for the vote unless you have comments just call for the vote all right we'll go start to the right all right this oh I I I I I and the vote passes 5 to zero uh we're now ready for item 8 I and Miss Carney uh you
094pulled susd work calendars 20265 26 administrative certified and classified go ahead yes uh thank you president leis yeah I had uh emailed and the board received uh the email response just on some questions I had on um what I noticed on a change on the 12-month employee work calendar and so I would just ask um Dr Cruz if she could explain um what our practice what's been our common practice in susd when it comes to you know paid holidays that follow on various weekdays according to the calendar okay I'm on um thank you uh president uh Dr Lewis uh Miss Carney happy to address this question for you so are the current practice and you can receive guidance and um get this guidance from the federal government with regards to these national holidays is that
095if it doesn't fall on a work day and and it's different for every holiday not every holiday but there's groups of holidays for instance um veterans days when you have to observe on the day July 4th the guidance is to observe it um if it's not a work day to observe it to the next closest work day so that's why we put it on July 3rd as for juneth there's really very little guidance on this because it is rather new however employees have did receive a holiday and have had a holiday so at the cabinet level we did make the decision to observe it on that Thursday since we will not be working on Fridays during that period of the summer so we we added that holiday to the Thursday and has that been done
096in the past or this is the first time that it's shown up this way on the calendar um I I can rely on do so so this would be the first time that that June 19th fell on a Friday where we're not working during the summer so we followed the practice that we've done with other holidays that fall on a Friday during the summer calendar but this is only three years since we've started um recognizing June 19th this way right so I just question if this is um how we should be treating paid holidays that rotate like this because I know you also told us that um there is an additional paid holiday on this 2526 uh employee work calendar for for 12-month employees um and you said that that's because of yam kapor um
097will be follow on a weekday so that will be a paid holiday next on this calendar where it is not um this time and that I agree with um so why would juneth also not be one of those holidays that are paid when it falls on a work day why is that an exception where um they would get a paid day off on June 18th and 19th so so yam kapor is is a district recess day not a paid holiday and and so the difference is that that June is a date that's recognized by the state of Arizona the city of Scottsdale and and many organizations make it a paid holiday uh we instituted that this will be the third year so it's two years ago that we instituted it and we followed the same
098practice that we've done before the board doesn't have to approve that but we were following how we handle other paid holidays so juneth isn't like yam Kapur or Good Friday where we have District recess days it's actually a paid holiday okay and so well district offices be closing will we be approving tonight that district offices will be closing on the 18th yes okay thank you other questions or comments on this item all right seeing none I'll go ahead and call the motion uh I move that we approve 8i the SD work calendar as presented second okay we'll do a roll call I no yes I yes it passes four to one thank you all right we now move to item nine it's an action item uh the action of uh the final stages of a
099hearing officer's recommendation to expel a student case number 24252 they looking for a motion I move to approve the recommendation I a second I seconded any comments or okay thank you we'll go ahead and call the vote uh Mrs Warner I I I I I thank you all right we are at item 10 governing board reports does anyone have governing board reports to share this evening well I have a a little one that uh I would like to share uh in uh December when we were at the training for new board members and extended into lunches where awards were presented in addition to um our superintendent being named uh the superintendent of the year uh this governing board received an award and I know uh Julie sinowski was there as a member who represented the
100previous board membership but as a body I think everybody should know and be very proud that the Academy of boardsmith quality uh on behalf of all of you and all of us thank you so much for everything that the previous board did and that who we are is represented in this from the state of Arizona so thank [Applause] you all right if no other announcements or reports uh 11 is future agenda items does anyone have any uh future agenda items they'd like to add all right I'll call Miss uh Warner Miss Carney sorry okay looking at the color of your microphones okay um I would uh like to see us have an well we need to have an executive session to discuss the auditor General's findings from the audit of the district's security um as
101well as I would like an update on uh what's going on with the jewel settlement that we received um and what what we've been using uh that funding for and those are two separate items two separate items and is one of them uh worthy of a a written communication or you want it in a well by polic I have to do both by written okay thank you uh all right other uh future agenda items I'm not sure if this counts as an agenda item specifically but I would encourage us to have a board retreat as part of kicking off this new board and Collective opportunity for us to come together and um to really take advantage of our study sessions which I think we have four scheduled in the year this will likely be difficult
102for the January one because it's just just a few weeks away but to use that as a real opportunity to study for us to come together based on board initiated topics that are of interest to us and to have the opportunity to do deeper Dives which is always more challenging in a strictly agendized context okay Mr shy okay I'm gonna uh parlay on what you just uh suggested and suggest a a half day Retreat for the board I think it would be powerful and I really respect that uh Miss Carney recommended that when she first got on the board and and I was sorry that it it took so long and I hope that we can do it expedite that and and find time to get to know each other uh learn what we value
103uh learn how we want to work together and do everything we can as we stated in the beginning of the meeting which was you know kindness and respect and and and Harmony and Kumbaya or whatever we can find I I see really positive things for this board and I want to capitalize on our professional development together so if I may parlay on what uh you said Dr pensy I would add uh if we could facilitate with an outside facilitator uh and and bring us together uh the second agenda item that I would put forward in a similar vein would be about professional development at the national level I think we have a lot to learn from what other states are doing creatively relative to uh opportunities for our students and creative options for our programs
104uh so I'm going to recommend that we have an agenda item for the National School Board Association uh participation this spring and I have more to learn about what that is or when but if we could put that on the agenda and the protocol is for us to write these now send an email to me send an email to okay so um Dr pensy if you want I'll put them both in one recommendation unless you want to write it yes and what is the protocol for study session topics to be proposed I know we want to be respectful of the district's burden preparing for them we don't want to create 50 binders of materials so so I think I think a couple things by policy any potential agenda item whether it's for discussion or action
105um can be submitted by any governing board member uh in advance of the board meeting the superintendent and the board president set the agenda but any board member can suggests something and then there's a time frame 5 days before the meeting if it's something we can do easily we put it on agenda if it takes more research then it can take longer from a study session perspective that's a little different it sort of depends on what the nature of the topic is and how much um background work is going to need to be done I I think what would be beneficial and I I like the idea of scheduling the board retreat what would be beneficial is if if the brainstorming of ideas of potential topics for study session are emailed to me I can
106work on trying to create a a potential scope and sequence that I could bring back to the governing board for approval and we can determine two things one do we have enough study sessions do we maybe perhaps need to add more and what's the sequence of of doing that deep dive so I would invite you know any board member to send ideas for the deeper dive study session so that we can begin to kind of calibrate that and plan for the balance of this school year and then use that process going forward thank you any other protocol about future agenda items or topics for okay thank you uh we now go to um dates of upcoming meetings our next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday January 28th at 6:m it's a special governing board member meeting
107at Mojave District Annex Annex MDA is what I thought I have a lot of acronyms for that but Mojave District Annex okay so we hope to see uh everyone there and uh now I will entertain a motion for adjournment I move to adjourn second second all right all those in favor I I I I I thank you you all run away um delivered to our office today was a box of crumble cookies Administration they wanted to welcome the new board and so we we did not eat one at all even glad and I both did look I could see e