001e e e I called order this meeting of the Scottdale Unified School District governing board the date is December 10th and the time is 5:00 p.m. the board is going to convene in executive session um first we're going to have a roll call from my far right please Karen wner Amy Carney Julie sinowski and limby Hart Wells we do have a quorum uh we will proceed with our executive session item which which is the discussion and consideration of the superintendent's midyear evaluation Pur to governing board policy CBI evaluation of superintendent and ARS 38-4 31.03 A1 uh the employee has been notified in writing in accordance with statutory provision um it does require a vote to convene into executive session I move to convene into executive session for the reason just stated in the agenda a
002second second moved and seconded all those in favor please say say I I and that motion passes 5 we will Recon e e e session I think we have some some special guests e e e only [Music] to hold you ever so TI [Music] [Applause] I call to order this regular meeting of the Scottdale Unified School District governing board today is December 10th and the time is 6:01 p.m. thank you community Watchers for the Indulgence of the minute we were being entertained with some special guests from Desert Mount that was wonderful thank you all right uh vice president Lindsay could you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance take a roll car pardon me a call Miss Warner could you start please Karen Warner Amy Carney Julie sinowski Zack Lindsay and Libby Hartwell we
003have five board members present we have a quorum and we will proceed with District business um we had one request uh for an agenda item to be moved two action items 11a and 11b to be moved up to to after 9A so we would have a new item two items before the consent agenda tend um other than that did not get any other requests for agenda amendments are there any Miss Carney I'm sorry could you explain that again I didn't understand I had a request that we would move action item 11a and 11b up the agenda to follow 9A but before the consent agenda item 10 thank you you're welcome if no further uh requests I move to approve the agenda as amended a second second that motion motion moved and seconded all those in
004favor please say I I I okay that motion passes 5 Z right we are going to move to the the meeting decorum uh I will read that quickly and then we'll get to the best part of the evening and that is the student celebrations citizens attending and are participating the Scottdale Unified School District meeting either in person virtually or telephonically are required to observe the same Rules of Order and decorum applicable to members of the Scottsdale Unified School District unauthorized remarks or demonstrations from members of the audience such as personal remarks yells outburst and or other disruption disruptions are not permitted right Dr menel I will turn this over to you now well good evening president Hart Wells vice president Lindsay and members of the governing board and greetings to all of our families and
005community members who are in attendance this evening once again this month our Fine Arts coordinator Michelle Irvin will get things started for us uh I assume you'll in formally introduce for us the two amazing vocalists that we just heard from is that good yes all right good evening thank you Dr menel president hartwell's vice president Lindsay board members and glattus uh it's my great honor to bring up the two vocalists again maximilan farcus and Cameron Hall and their teacher Amanda McKay and their principal Mr Andrews from Desert Mountain high school so um I'd like to give a big shout out to these two students for coming up and singing this morning uh I I was telling a little bit to Cameron when she came in this morning that uh I've been in the district a
006few years over 30 and uh in that time I think we've had two students that have made all state Jazz so to have two students in one year from Desert Mountain high school really shows the incredible Excellence that's happening with their wonderful Coral teacher and these amazing students so Cameron here was number one soprano in the entire State of Arizona in the All State Jazz FL right so wow we would be like that's that's insane and then Max ailon here decides well I think I'll go one up on that and I got chosen as in the National Jazz choir never in susd have we ever had a student in the National Jazz choir and this young man is in that so huge round of applause to this amazing student and I want to give a
007big thank you to the incredible instructor Amanda McKay who's really been elevating Excellence every single day in your classrooms and giving these opportunities to your students to Excel on a local level and a national level thank world class education and thank you Mr Andrews for helping support these programs to make that happen we have these amazing challenge coins to celebrate the um wonderful Excellence you've been doing so thank you so much and congratulations to both of you I will I got to it's the next person oh no this way so one portion of my job is fine arts and the other portion of my job is physical education and I have the great honor tonight to celebrate some physical Educators Well Physical educator and their amazing students um I now want to turn my attention
008to Engleside middle school and could I have Susan Leonard come up and her Wonder students and Dr Michael they're a wonderful principal as they're coming up because I know um Susan Leonard will be talking Susan Leonard is actually our lead Middle School physical educator for the district and has been uh the entire time I've had this wonderful position and she has been uh a Guiding Light for myself helping me create the best opportunities for her students and we had new um National physical education standards released this summer and she embraced them so much and with her students and these kids uh actually presented at a conference the Arizona State physical education conference so I'm going to pass it to the amazing Susan Leonard to talk about it good evening Madame President Dr menel board members
009and gladus I'm proud to be standing with two of my outstanding ankles side students seventh grader Bella Smith and eighth grader Graham ner they initiated created and presented the session embedding the new shape America standards into engaging assessments at the Arizona health and physical education State Convention this past November at the Mesa Convention Center in their session they shared their why their Project based learning assignment was significant the step-by-step process and ultimately each of the projects completed to that point they're ultimately due next week where they're going to present to the sixth graders um which embedded the new shape American National physical education standards please understand they were speaking to an audience of K through2 Educators from across Arizona including past and present teachers of the Year past and current presidents of physical education for
010Arizona MCTS and members from higher ed thus when asked questions to the level of which standard is your favorite and please justify why it is your favorite in your response and how do you envision these standards impacting you throughout your life Bella and Graham responded with Grace and strong academic content they weren't intimidated they dictated the path of learning for the adults through the lens of a student further evidence of the purposeful positive impact of their session was clear when approximately half the audience stayed after the presentation to speak speak to Graham and Bella asking additional questions for their opinions through the students lens and for copies of their project it is significant to share that susd is the only District in Arizona to have middle school students present at the State Convention in at
011least the last 20 years I've had students present State Convention before but this is the first time they initiated created and dictated an educational dialogue with a group of professionals to this distinguished level these students res represent their peers Engleside and susd by truly elevating excellence in closing I want to thank you for the opportunity to recognize these two outstanding students this evening I also want to thank Bella and Grahams I was going to say parents but we got family we got extended family we got grandmas we got all sorts of people here so and they're waving okay um oh my lost my place sorry um parents and audience uh for their unwaver uh as each continues to pursue the and Elevate their academic Excellence so I have a few things um it is it
012is on a rare occasion that um you get recognized by these amazing people and so I have a copy of the invitation framed for each of you I also have challenge coin and um framed for you um I I'm so proud to give them to you as a representative of our district for your academic excellence and just I'm just I couldn't be more proud you you are why I teach so thank you so much I also not as fancy but want to give a coin to Susan Leonard for elevating Excellence every day she is a driving force love it thank you Susan congratulations Bell and Graham love seeing the student leadership the initiation and I suspect that won't be the last time that we see them here in front of the governing board now I'd
013like to invite to the podium Dr Kim dods Karen uh and as she's coming forward i' invite the audience to look at the screen because we have a little special something for you as a part of this celebration for for e [Applause] good evening president Dr hartwell's Vice President Lindsay governing board members Dr menel and Mrs Wagner was that not fascinating to watch that landscape come to life the colors seem to jump off the page and truly the imagination and understanding of our beautiful landscape is just mindblowing beautiful Zoe um I'd like you to meet the creative student behind this gorgeous drawing come stand closer let everybody see you uh this is Zoe McClure she is from Arcadia High School she is a sophomore we also have with us this evening her teacher Mrs Rio
014and our principal Dr Janelle dansy principal of Arcadia High School additionally joining us this evening is the senior manager of the Scottdale libraryies public service and operations this is Tamara Norwood welcome everyone um a call went out in September to local youth artists between ages of 13 and 18 and the charge was to was to design the next Scottdale public library card the specs landscape orientation 8 1/2 by 11 paper and lots of imagination Zoe along with a few other susd students desert mountains Ana Patel and chapperal Luis Chia chapetti were among the 52 who submitted drawings and were named finalists about two weeks ago the judges more than 3,000 of us local residents who voted online for their favorite at the library's ultimate family play date this past Saturday at the Scottsdale Civic Center
015Library director Mike Beck announced that Zoe's entry had received the most votes of course it takes outrageous artistic talent to create a piece such as this but it also took quite a bit of herall Break 6 hours of time not counting meal breaks after all creativity must be nourished so what happens next Zoe's colored pencil drawing will be configured to fit the uh library's 3 and 1/2 by 2 in format to um be available to all Scottsdale Library patrons and we will begin collecting this card starting next month I know I'll be in line to get one and my husband certainly will probably be one of the first he is quite the library Patron so um congratulations Zoe please accept this challenge coin on behalf of susd for recognizing your talent and your beautiful contributions
016to our city and for readers throughout our city that are going to check out books with your library card congratulations proud of you have a we actually have the real thing that we can look at you want to show it it's yours it's beautiful that's truly incredible thank you I'm truly Blown Away by the talent uh and I so excited to see people walking around with their library cards now that are a product of her creativity and and passion of capturing our desert landscape so congratulations Zoe now I'd like to turn uh to the theatrical arts and invite assistant superintendent of secondary education Dr Melissa sackos to tell us about an award-winning High School playwright Dr sackos all right thank you Dr Menzel um I'd like to you to meet Desert Mountain high school sophomore
017Sophia Baron Z sopia Would you please join me at the podium along with any of your teachers in attendance and of course principal Andrews to meet you I am pleased to introduce to you uh Sophia Martin uh Marton Z winner of the Arizona thespians central region Dome mcdono playwriting award for her original play nowhere in particular the award is named for a longtime Texas High School Drama teacher who is often referred to as the father of young adult drama his more than 40 years have been produced in all 50 states all Canadian provinces and 11 foreign countries over the years Sophia reports reports that it took her about 5 months to develop the story to the point where she considered it finished it all started last school year in Shad willingham's theater one class and
018there's Mr Willingham and as you know art takes time um so what is nowhere in particular what is it about well it's a story of a Teenage uh Kiera who finds herself at a rest stop after a long road trip the rest Stop's only employee the clerk seems to take a a liking to her while she is here or she is there she also encounters unreal beings which leads Kara to question her surroundings and herself wow I may have to excuse myself from the covering board meeting to hear the rest do you have time yeah is that okay with you sure all right um those who attended last month's Arizona thespians Festival at Phoenix Convention Center were lucky enough to find out because they got to see Sophia's play uh performed on stage on the
019festival's final night that must have been really really cool Sophia does not consider herself to be a great writer yet she says it's more about being real that said we're thinking this may also be a case of the Apple not falling far from the tree Sophia's mother who I believe is here tonight and come on Mom you got to stand up and wait uh teaches English one and two honors at Desert Mountain high school congratulations Sophia on being named one of Arizona's Best High School playwrights with the creativity determination and ability to tell a compelling Story please accept this challenge coin as a recognition of your outstanding work congratulations as well uh to Mr inham a playwright himself uh for providing opportunities like this for our students to succeed with that Dr men I'll see
020you tomorrow we're g to go get the rest of the story congratulations Sophia and no you're not excused Dr sackos nice try so now we have another celebration uh second of its kind here in Scottsdale and to introduce the celebration I would like to invite forward Patty bilbury our director of nutrition services Patty so good evening Governor I mean Governor Hart Wells president Hart Wells I've just elevated you right members of the governing board Dr menel and glattus I'm thrilled to be with you here tonight to celebrate a truly meaningful moment here at susd it's my distinct honor to invite members of the anastasi school community to join me at the podium I know you're in a couple different places so come on up we have our Dynamic principal Jen Waldren our assistant principal Andrea
021Martin our lead nurse Renee tosto who I've been on the wellness committee with for many many years and their incredible team of friends and supporters and joining us at the podium from the team at the blue zones project Scottsdale are Sarah Kerney executive director ctor Danielle Anderson organization and well-being lead and Tara Maya Meyer who's the organization and well-being coordinator so the blue zones project is a remarkable Global initiative that is changing the way we think about our communities it focuses on creating environments that promote Health and Longevity inspired by those unique longevity hotspots around the world where people routinely live a hundred years or longer for us at SSD the goal is to empower the students staff and families to make healthier choices that support long and vibrant lives tonight we have another extraordinary
022Milestone to celebrate as anastasi Elementary School is the second school at susd to achieve Blue Zone certification and I'm going to invite Tera Meer up to see if she can kind of share with us a little bit of what it took for anaz zazi to reach this Milestone because it's quite significant Cara thank you Patty good evening president Dr Libby hartwell's board members Dr manelle and glattus so as Patty said my name is Tera Meer and I'm an organization and well-being coordinator at Blue Zone project Scottsdale and I'm thrilled to be here to celebrate one of our partners Anasazi Elementary School and officially achieving their blue zones approval an ai's Journey began with the formation of their passionate health and well-being advisory their blue zones crew LED by principal Jennifer Waldren nurse Renee Toto Mrs
023Martin Miss Armstrong Mr Bragg Mrs Alonso D roza Mrs soble and Miss Wade and together they created a culture of well-being that touches every corner of their school their approach to nutrition sets a high standard they've introduced a fruit and vegetable bar in the cafeteria discontinued using unhealthy Foods at fundraisers removed treats as a classroom reward they have non food focused birthday celebrations and they integrate nutrition education into daily lessons these efforts have come to life in projects like their vertical tower garden that uses Worm Composting and their school garden which is already taking rote Anasazi also weaves physical education into each school day with dance challenges yoga and programs like Move To Learn they've created a calming Cove a twinkle lit tunnel that helps students to mindfully transition back into the classroom and this
024year they spearheaded a pumpkin pla which will become an annual walk to school day bringing families and students together for movement at the beginning of the day their focus on community is equally inspiring through their grand Pals program third graders have the opportunity to connect with a pen pal at a local Senior Living facility and they create cross-generational connections that are mutually beneficial to both parties from their trackers program which rewards students with a bead for every lap walked to their Labyrinth a student-built space for Learning and reflection on aasi Elementary sets a true gold standard for student health and well-being and their work exemplifies exactly what blue zones project Scottdale stands for congratulations to the entire Anasazi team for making a difference in the lives of students families the community and we couldn't be
025more thrilled to celebrate you guys tonight thanks Tara it's always great to hear you talk about what it takes to become Blue Zone certified reaching that a milestone is not a small feat and I'd like to invent uh introduce Jen Waldren here to say a few brief words if you know Jen it won't be super brief but come on up Jen tell us about what it took for you to reach this goal and the journey there thank you P I'll try to be brief good evening president Dr Libby hartwell's distinguished board members Dr menel and glattus tonight I stand before you with immense pride and excitement to share another transformative milestone for our school the official designation as a blue zones project approved School recognition is one that goes far beyond a simple title and
026represents our commitment to creating a healthier more supportive environment for our students and staff when we first embarked on this journey in August our goal was simple yet profound to continue to create a school culture at Anasazi that prioritizes Wellness Connection and holistic student development the blue zones project has provided us with a comprehensive framework to turn that Vision into reality our transformation touches every aspect of our school environment as Tara shared a brief overview the impact of blue zones extends far beyond our school Walls by becoming a blue zones project approved School we're teaching our students lifelong habits of Health resilience and Community engagement we're showing them that Wellness is not a destination but a continuous journey of personal growth and Collective support this achievement is a testament to the incredible collaboration of our
027teachers staff students families and Scottdale Community each person has played a crucial role in reimagining what a school can be not just a place of academic learning but a nurturing ecosystem that supports the holistic development of our young students we are particularly proud to be among the first two schools in Scottsdale to achieve this distinction we thank Echo Canyon the first blue zones approved School in nusd for their support and mentorship along the way our hope is that we too can serve as a model and inspir ation for other schools demonstrating that when we prioritize well-being we create environments where students can truly Thrive as anastasi celebrates this Milestone re we recommit ourselves to the principles of the blue zones project we will continue to innovate to learn and to create a school environment that
028supports the potential of every single student thank you to the blue zones project Scottsdale for your guidance especially Tara thank you anastasi blue crew kabini members for spearheading this initiative in record speed I might add thank you SSD and to our Anastasia Community for your commitment to the blue zones project and most importantly thank you to our incredible Anasazi scorpions who Inspire us each and every single day to be better to do better and to create a healthier more connected world because of kids thank you so what an outstanding AC yeah that was really good by the way what an outstanding accomplishment this is and you know this makes my heart like really proud and sore to know that we have Echo Canyon and now Anasazi being that locomotive that's going to just push all
029our other schools in SD to become Blue Zone certified as well how great would that be to see every single school at susd part of the blue zones project what a great collaboration this is so with that I want to provide you with a challenge coin if I can get it open here for all of the hard work you did and I know that this is not an easy task thank you all right congratulations anastasi and just for the record Tara is an USD Legacy arcade I believe oh yeah uh it's really exciting to see our schools jump jump in and and support student health and well-being as a part of the blue zones initiative and now to celebrate another Community initiative we're going to invite Christine Harrington you're just moving the slide Nancy I
030thought you were directing me so we're going to invite Christine Harrington to celebrate a district level award from the Chamber of Commerce Christine absolutely all right well good evening everyone if I can please ask Desert Mountain at admin teachers and students who supported our Endeavor into winning this to please join me at the podium that would be terrific thanks guys we are of course very proud to announce in case you missed it somewhere along the way that we are named the winners of the Sterling award for the big business category by the uh Scottsdale Chamber of Commerce so this is a win for the entire District certainly the award is based on business excellence and positive Community impact as part of the application process we had to submit answers to a bunch of questions about
031who we are and what it is that we do how our business impacts the community our Partnerships our staff as well as what it is that's on the horizon for us and we had a chance to really celebrate a number of successes then we had the judges come out to tour our business but as you well know we don't just have like one storefront right so we've got 30 different schools serving toddlers through 12th grade so it's difficult to show a team of Judges a whole lot all at once especially when you only have 60 Minutes to do it but we managed to tell a very good story when visiting deser Mountain High School and so we appreciate everyone who welcomed us uh to deser Mountain High School where of course they have the IB
032program as well as Championship Athletics and arts and Robotics the judges were able to meet these exceptional students be able to ask them questions and really learn from their truly lived experiences uh we visited a number of classes IB classes fashion design as well as CTE and we even visited Miss rosenfeld's class where she created this massive Fireball that was just amazing and left all of us speechless so safe to say the whole experience was fire and um that's likely why we won right is because engaging with these young people and these teachers uh they just seal the deal so want to tell you how thankful we are for you grateful for the staff the students the parents the partners all across this community that support us because this is truly a district win and
033especially thankful to principal Andrews who in his first year and this second week of school rallied teachers and students so that everyone was willing to open their doors and hearts and really share what is so special about being Desert Mountain and then additionally being part of SD so thank you all so very much this is as much a win for you as it is for everyone in the district so thank you and I have challenge points truly was a Showcase of elevating Excellence truly and appreciative for your willingness to take that on it was a lot of fun uh and I know the judges walked away very impressed and at least one of them had children who were graduates of Desert Mountain high school and so it brought back really good memories including reconnecting with
034some teachers he hadn't spoken with for a while so it was fantastic so much we can thank you step out and take a picture so we presented many different kinds of celebrations to you this evening and want to R it out uh from teaching learning and Performing perspective by once again inviting Michelle Irvin to the podium Miss Irvin thank you thank you Dr menel president Hart willes vice president Lindsay board members glad us this is quite a wonderful night for me by the way um I am very excited to bring in our last group and of course you can't bring in one of these type of groups with a without a little pep so could I have the Coronado High School Marching Don join us please [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] wooo so it's it's
035my great honor I'm like my heart's actually pounding a little cuz I'm this band has been through a lot three teachers if include me four in three years um and I fell in love with them instantly and I wanted someone to take them to that next place and this young man to it there I am so honored to say that Coronado Don are the state champions for aota [Music] yeah it takes a lot to get there I know I've been there um they were in 13th Place two years ago they moved to eth last year and we brought this young little whipper snapper in Brett Bell and he just had a vision and a goal and you want to talk about elevating Excellence I mean everything that you did uh you told them it was
036possible they drunk the Kool-Aid and they made it happen and they won every single competition in the aboda circuit the whole season I mean unbelievable so it is my great honor and I thank you so much Brett for coming to susd you can never leave you stuck we got your parents as you know helpers and shepher Mom I love you you can never leave um so I just want you to know how much it means to me you can tell cuz I almost cried like a baby um because I know what they went through in fact I like look at them and I took some of the them to New York with about what 14 hours notice um yeah uh they've been through a lot kids I'm so proud of you I hope you take
037this strive and enthusiasm through your whole life yes you can make anything happen yes do your proficiency seals audition for regionals in all state I love you um so anyway it's my great honor Brett to give you this I'm sure this will be one of many elevating excellence and for the whole band so I just wanted to say thank you to all of our parents including Mr and Mrs Belle Jim and Susan you guys are at everything you are honorary Don um once you are a dawn you are always a dawn but our parents our families our grandparents everybody here at Coronado is incredibly proud of you we appreciate all of the district support that we have gotten from Michelle from Dr dods from Dr menel from Dr sackos we just cannot thank you guys
038enough for everything that you have done for us um Brett there are great things coming um our way and we appreciate your leadership and you are building a legacy so thank you and for our kids we are so proud of you the sky is the limit so let's go guys be proud of yourselves congratulations and uh before we leave I want to take a quick moment um Dr hotwells Mr Lindsay Miss sinowski I thank you guys so much for all you've done for the Arts the importance you put to a well-rounded education with arts and physical education is powerful I hope you see tonight like five of these seven presentations this would not have been possible without you and I hope you know your impact is felt and I will you know I'll miss you
039and I hope the greatest things for you but thank you thank you so much I love you guys very much thank you thank you marching Dons thank you Mr Bell you don't know this yet but we're working on showcasing your talent in February at another event uh in Phoenix so I'm just truly impressed by all that you've accomplished thank you Ball State 1 3 1 2 3 4 [Music] oh [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] well that's really hard to top and and it wouldn't be bad to start every meeting that way just gets the blood flowing and and uh after a long day it keeps you awake but we're not done yet there's one more thing uh because tonight is the final night for three of our governing board members and so since I have the
040mic and an opportunity to say a few words I will uh first um I have the privilege and honor of working with these three individuals for the past four years and I cannot imagine a more difficult four years to serve as a governing board member uh than from January of 2021 to the present uh serving during a global p pmic in an environment where everything was upside down uh leading in a time of uncertainty and yet leading with confidence about the core purpose of our work here at Scott Unified School District I know that every day uh you were forced to make decisions sometimes that uh were very difficult uh you were um challenged uh with respect to how those decisions unfolded but I don't believe that you ever lost sight of what was most
041important for our kids and so to talk just a little bit about some of the successes so we didn't have a strategic plan but during their tenure we developed our strategic plan focused on our core purpose because kids and our commitment to elevating Excellence every day and you see example after example after example in our governing board meetings we didn't have a policy ha that recognized our employees and gave them a voice at the table until uh these three joined the governing board uh we did not have the same level of focus on academic rigor and Excellence particularly when it comes the science I think about even the Equitable science opportunities here at Coronado with respect to physics and and uh Mr Lindsay I have never known a board member who has attended more athletic
042events uh and contributed so much to ensuring that we could Elevate excellence in athletics so when you think about Scottsdale Unified School District well we know that we have many opportunities for improvement this is a governing board and governing board members who have committed to elevating academic excellence excellence in the Arts and excellence in athletics and it wouldn't have happened without the three of you putting yourselves out there uh the pay that you get for this is not in currency U because you don't get any money for it uh but I hope that you see the investment in the lives of the students who have come through the system while you're on the board and those who are in the pipeline and so with that I want to extend my heartfelt gratitude I know it
043hasn't been easy and we do have uh a parting gift for each of you uh and I want to present that to you now but I just want to thank thank you uh in all seriousness for all that you've done to elevate excellence in Scot Unified [Applause] all right so now from sella celebrations to some more serious things uh we do have a couple of curricul AD options that are under underway right now and we have curriculum on display at the SD Oak campus for in statistics and AP IB bio and AP biochm so anyone who wants to review that material you have an opportunity to do so and we are also currently recruiting uh for the committee members for AP World History and world history uh AP World History apus history and and US
044history and the application for that that committee work closes on December 18th so we would encourage interested community members uh to submit an application to serve on those committees we know that uh that curriculum adoption process can be uh timec consuming but it's very important as we think about uh the text that we'll bringing forward to the governing board for future consideration last night we had the fall athletic banquet and it was a true joy to watch student athletes be recognized and honored uh as were our three departing governing board members with plaques of appreciation uh Mr Slater our athletic director pointed out the things that happened under their watch as well related to increasing compensation for coaches reinstating coaching positions that had been eliminated ensuring that our coaches got a bigger portion of the
045uh the camp split so all of those things were highlighted and celebrated with respect to the investment and the contribution of this board for athletics uh and it was just truly a joy to watch as our student athletes were celebrated we also have a number of other things that are happening over the next two weeks as we bring to close this semester we are Performing Arts plays um uh concerts um musical performances by our bands and orchestras and so if you have an opportunity I would invite you to stop by and enjoy one of those exhibitions of student Talent earlier today we had the opportunity to convene on the campus of Navajo Elementary to participate in a ribbon cutting the ribbon cutting was really exciting I need to give a shout out to principal patof
046and the entire Navajo team as well as Dennis Joe ekka and the members of the facilities team who actually built a greenhouse on the campus of Navajo Elementary this project was funded by a grant from the US Department of Agriculture that that was pursued by empowering Arizona a nonprofit based in Scottdale that's looking to create additional opportunities for students the greenhouse on the campus of Navajo is one of only two funded projects under this Grant from the US Department of Agriculture and if you haven't had an opportunity to get on the campus to see it since we had the ribbon cutting today I would certainly recommend that you take an opportunity to take a tour they've already had amazing Gardens but now with the greenhouse they're going to be able to do some very impressive
047things year round to enhance stem education for the students on that campus so congratulations to all who were a part of that project I also want to point out that we are going to on December 18th at 6 o'clock hold a graduation ceremony and celebration for winter graduates uh we have I think over 40 who will be graduating in December we've invited all of them we don't know how many will show up but we've invited all of them to join us here in the governing boardroom so that we can celebrate their accomplishment as they conclude their education here at scota Unified School District and finally uh I want to because it's the last governing board meeting of the year I want to thank our teachers our administrators our support staff all of the individuals who
048make Scot Unified School District truly an exceptional place for children to learn for people to come to work every day the impact that you have on our community and on the future of Scottsdale is truly uh powerful and I'm just grateful to be able to walk alongside you on this journey to elevating Excellence for our students and I want to wish everyone everyone our parents our staff a very happy holiday season and we'll look forward to reconvening in the new year thank you Dr Mensel thank you for the gifts and um actually because as you now know uh this evening is the last board meeting for three of us uh we had a request to move the governing board reports up um there are some words of gratitude and thanks that would like to be
049shared so we're going to do this just a little bit differently we're going to do this roll call Style um Miss Warner if you would like to start with your governing report if you have one I don't have one all right Miss Carney Miss sinowski of course I do thank you Dr hartells um attending the Scottsdale Expo the student scholar athlete banquet um and the as Dr menel mentioned these are some of the activities that remind remed me of why um this has not been easy work but it's been rewarding this is a place that I've called my home raised my family and I will continue to advocate for susd um as a general citizen um good governance is staying in the lanes of authorized responsibility it's trusting and verifying ing information it's supporting the
050qualified experts to perform their best work and seeking ways to improve our overall systems with creativity and perseverance I've learned a lot and appreciated the opportunities to continue to serve my community I hope the Legacy that we have um created here has provided benefit to our students and all of the employees of Scott still Unified School District um as I mentioned this work has not been easy but it has been rewarding and very valuable I appreciate all the support that those of you in the room have provided and many who are not here this evening have also provided um I I'd like to make note that we have a very defined system in place to address and solve problems in susd we are not perfect we continue to work every class period of every day
051to improve our systems and I would suggest to individuals that continue to show up at our governing board meetings um to try to solve problems that their public comment to be more resourceful and use the systems that we have in place to solve the problems because this is not reality TV this is real world and these are real human beings that work to better the lives of our children every day so again thank you for your trust I appreciate you Mr Lindsay no all right I do have a few words I'd like to share first I'd like to um I'm just I attended the susd Expo as well that was held a few weeks ago and I want to thank all of the teachers and the students and the families who and staff who extended
052their day it was a long day um but well worth it um it was really impressive to see all the great things that are going on and that you were profiling them and putting them out there for the community to um to be aware of um I I want to congratulate you for it I thought it was a great event um as Dr Mensel indicated the student um athletic banquet was for fall Sports was last evening and I want to add my heartfelt congratulations to all the student athletes who were uh honored last night and their loved ones um a special thanks uh to Dr sako's uh director District athletic director Nathan Slater and the athletics department for their recognition of the outgoing board members and our sustained effort over four years to strengthen all
053the district's athletic programs as a mechanism for elevating Excellence for our students um and that those efforts were paralleled in the Arts I think you saw that tonight um and it's because it's my last formal board meeting I also want to offer a few words of gratitude to a few people who always walk into this boardroom with me that you never see and that's my family okay so I often tell people that I had to marry my sense of humor and if you know me and you know my husband you know that is a credible observation and while Tom is indeed the fun parent in all seriousness he's also my rock my sanity and my stability and boy did I need that over the last four years Tom and our children have made sacrifices because
054I sit on this board unfair sacrifices but we've all learned I've learned that meaningfulness is the antidote the guest speaker last night who's at s USD parent at the Athletics banquet reminded us that's learning how to accept the struggle he actually said like love it I don't I didn't love it but I learned how to embrace it and I think all of us did because of how much turbulence uh we were trying to weather for kids but even better the anote is to turn it into a really long list of positive and impactful changes and accomplishments for our students staff and families and it has been a privilege and an honor to play a small part part in making that long list of positive meaningful and impactful accomplishments a reality so thank you to all
055of you who supported those efforts and including those of you who were willing to engage who may have disagreed but you willing to engage in informed civil discussion and debate in come 2025 when a new board constitutes I'm confident you're in good hands and congratulations particularly to The District administration you survived me right right with that I think we will turn to our information and oh no we're going to do the public comment now I tried to skip over that sorry all right a few ground rules for those of you that don't already know them in compliance with the open meeting laws the governing board may not discuss or take action tonight on any matters raised during public comment that are not on the agenda however the governing board members May respond to direct criticism
056ask staff to review a matter or that a matter be placed on a future agenda as a reminder each speaker will have two minutes the screen will indicate the time please be prepared to close your comments and relinquish the floor at the conclusion of your time the board asks that each speaker please introduce yourself by stating your name and whether you live live within the district for clarity and the record we thank you for your time and attendance here this evening and your cooperation following the meeting decorum and protocols I'm going to read the name of the speaker when you hear your name could you please come up to the podium once you start speaking your time will start um I will make a good faith effort to pronounce your name accurately however if I
057do not please accept my apologies and know that it was not meant uh any dis disrespect our first speaker is Patricia pellet good evening governing board I first want to congratulate our new Arizona senator and her appointment to the education committee I'm speaking about the transportation for the third party as many of you know I've lived through hell with the third party transportation system my special needs boy and I understand that it's a complex issue because there are certain kids on IEPs U foster kids group home kids who have to be transported far from far away including out a district because of certain laws and unfortunately um it's unfortunate too because I can't imagine any foster child um vulnerable child who CH would choose to be raped over attending their local school um so I
058want to know unfortunately we do have to move forward with a new transportation service but I want to know what's changed it wasn't just an issue with the transportation system it was an issue with the transportation department at susd and it was proven that they were notified over three months many times that my boy was being abused and nothing was done I was told the lady was on vacation and she was not she was busy emailing she just never took action um so what has changed on susd side and what's going to happen with this new transportation company will they have cameras in their cars will they notify the parent immediately if there's any type of issues instead of just relying on the school to do so um will they provide proof of full background
059checks on their drivers and that is it thank you our next speaker is Risa langbecker all right it looks like we will move to our next speaker Denny Brown hi crew how are you I'm Denny Brown I live in the Hood um I am so proud of our district I mean I can't tell you I am way way proud but tonight I am here because of Julie Zack and Libby guys thank you for your stewardship it's huge and believe me I know this isn't an easy kick boy do I know but along the way I hope you had some fun and I hope those rewarding moments made it all worth it thank you for your [Applause] service next up is Jeff r I spent uh 13 years as a full-time substitute teacher uh in the
060Scottdale schools 16 years doing volunteer veteran presentations for the Jo floss Institute including Scottsdale schools and seven years as a paid coach in the Scottsdale schools most year uh years I did multiple Sports I'm asking you Dr hartells to authorize your lawyer to negotiate a settl this is not a Democrat or Republican issue you gave Dr Manzel a medal at the last board meeting I I was an 18-year-old kid when I arrived in Vietnam and returned to the states 10 months later on a metac airplane I have nine combat citations including two purple hearts don't finish your term by allowing Scott Manzel to throw a 100% service connected disabled veteran under the bus and next is Shelly h com good evening board members Dr Mensel and glattus I am Shelley humman graduate former teacher and
061parent of susd and currently I am the very proud principal at Pueblo Elementary but tonight I am here to speak to you on behalf of being the president of the Scottdale administrators Association on behalf of our association it is my honor to stand before you to express our heartfelt gratitude to our um exiting governing board members Dr Liberty Hart Wells Julie sinowski and Zach Lindsay for their dedication and service to the scota Unified School District the responsibilities of a a school governing board member are immense and multifaceted it is a role that demands dedication compassion and resilience you have taken on the substantial responsibility of making critical decisions that shape the education landscape for our students families and Educators alike the countless hours you have devoted to meetings to discussions and careful deliberation performed on
062a voluntary basis speaks volumes about your commitment and to our community and its future throughout your tenure you have navigated numerous challenges and have kept our students at the heart of every decision ensuring that their best interests are prioritized because kids as we reflect on your contributions during your tenure we are reminded of the profound impact that dedicated individuals like you have on the lives of our students in the broader Community thank you for your tireless efforts your unwavering support and your belief in the importance of public education thank you very [Applause] much next is Marta wowa good evening members of the Scottdale Unified School District uh School Board my name is Mara War Bowa and I do not live in the district but I am a volunteer with Mom's demand action which is a
063nationwide advocate organization that supports gunsense policies I'm a strong advocate for the safety and well-being of SD students and support the policy revision to the suicide prevention policy ihda the topic of firearm safety and safe storage is not just a polity discussion it is a matter of life and death every year countless preventable tragedies occur when Firearms are left unsecured leading to unintentional shooting suicides or their use in school related violence implementing a policy to educate parents and Guardians about safe firearm storage is a common sense on proactive step to protect our children and Community First I want to emphasize that this is not about politics it's about responsibility responsible firearm ownership includes ensuring that guns are stored securely unloaded and Out Of Reach of unauthorized users particularly children studies show that proper firearm storage
064can reduce the risk of firearm suicide by up to 78% among Youth and prevent accidental shootings finally I want to remind everyone that this issue is deeply personal many of us know someone who has been affected by gun violence whether directly or indirectly consider that Firearms are the leading cause of death for children and teens ages 1 through 19 in the US imagine the peace of mind we can bring to parents teachers and students by taking concrete action to reduce these risk as the policy reads today safe firearm storage is an opt-in opportunity with a healthy majority of families opting in for their students to receive education with this healthy majority we know that s families value and prioritize safe firearm storage education I support the policy amendment to make firearm storage education and opt
065out opportunity so that we may ensure all students receive this critical knowledge and keep our community and school districts safe and that is our last speaker are there any board members who wish to respond to the extent permitted to do so I see for we will go ahead and move on to the uh information and discussion item 9A assessment and accountability update Dr bachna thank you good evening president hartwell's vice president Lindsay governing board members Dr menel and Mrs Wagner it's my my pleasure to be here tonight to provide you with an assessment and accountability update for the 2023 2024 school year tonight we'll be reviewing our own assessment results as well as comparing our performance to other area school districts briefly our third through e8th graders took the aasa last spring which stands for
066Arizona's academic standards assessment this test covers both English language arts or Ela and math the English test contains content includes reading and writing with every student respon required to respond to a writing prompt our nth graders took the ACT Aspire which includes English math reading and science our 11th graders took the ACT which covers the same content areas as the ACT Aspire and finally our fifth e8th and 11th graders took the aai a science test that assesses our student mastery of grade LEL standards in science the fifth grade a science test covers content from third fourth and fifth grades the eighth grade test covers content taught throughout middle school and the 11th grade science test covers the first three years of high school science standards it is worth noting that every student in the tested
067grade level takes these assessments opting out is not permitted with that let's move on to our test results on this slide is a comparison of our performance on the aasa and act English assessments to nine comparison districts the numbers indicate the percentage of our students testing as proficient which indicates mastering the grade level standards in English language arts these are the same comparison districts we presented last fall they were chosen as comparisons due to their demographics Andor size being similar to our own you can see that of Scottsdale student performance ranked first in all elementary grade levels and overall in the top three in all comparisons on this next slide is a comparison of our performance on the aasa and act math assessments to the same nine comparison districts as displayed on the previous Slide
068the numbers indicate the percentage of our students testing is proficient which again indicates they mastered the grade level standards you can see that of susd student performance ranked first in grades three four five and seven and in grades second in grades 6 and 11 and fifth in grade eight of note our grade eight math performance was a single percentage Point lower than those of our comparisons in Chandler Deer Valley and Gilbert who shared a three-way tie for a second overall the Scottdale students demonstrated proficiency of the ELA and math grade level standards at a higher rate than both Maricopa County and the state overall these differences were greater in math than an than an Ela while the previous slide showed an aggregate comparison of all aasa scores this one breaks out our English language arts
069results by grade level again Scottsdale is outperforming the state and County averages across all grade levels these differences are biggest in elementary school and more modest in secondary school but in every comparison Scottdale students are demonstrating Mastery of grade level standards by at least 12 percentage points more than the comparisons this slide depicts uh student performance by cohort in English the teal bars represent our own scores the orange bars are the county averages and the blue are Arizona the first set of bars on the leftand side depict student performance of the fourth grade Co cohort comparing the results to their prior school year as you go across the table these charts increase chronologically by grade level Scottsdale students saw an increase in scores from third to fourth grade and fifth to sixth grades the sixth
070to seventh grade cohort stayed the same while the fifth and eighth grade cohorts saw a decrease in English performance of note is that the trends in Improvement or decline in test scores scores by cohort were mimicked at the county and state level in other words in the cohorts where we saw decreases the state did as well this chart depicts Arizona aasa math results by grade level again Scottsdale's outperforming the state and County averages across all grade levels in every instance Scottsdale students are demonstrating Mastery of math grade level standards by at least 14% points more than the comparisons this slide depicts student performance by cohort and math in the same fashion as the earlier slide for English again the teal bars represent our own scores the orange are the county averages and the blue are
071Arizona across all cohorts there was a decrease in math performance from one grade level to the next the state also exhibited drops in cohort data at all grade levels this data supports our district focus on math achievement for our wildly important goal this school year while Scottdale math scores are higher than other parts of the state we have clear room for improvement so while I stand up here every fall and discuss our overall results on the state assessments I thought it might offer some context for you to see the types of items our students are answering on the aasa on the screen is an example of an English language arts test item our students must first read a passage about an injured bird and trees and then answer several questions about the passage in part
072A it asks the students to infer the bird's feelings about spending the winter among the northern trees in Part B students must must identify the two details in the first paragraph that support their response to part A finally in question two the students must choose two ideas that are supported by the picture of note Part B and question two both require more than one response to the question and students do not earn partial credit so I ask my Bo board members here which grade level do you think this this item belongs to it would be grades 3 through eight any guesses we thought that was a fairer question than asking you to answer the question and then have it graded later so third grade this is third grade so let's move on to the sample
073math test items um the first question on the left to ask our students to categorize linear equations they must categorize all three correctly to earn credit for the test item in the question on the right the student must know how to read a graph about coal consumption over time and then select all the correct answers as you can see these questions are more complex than a single multiple choice response item students have to complete several steps to determine the answers and understand what is being asked which involves not only math skills but reading comprehension any guesses on this one this is a grade eight item as we continue to learn about the impact of learning disruption during the pandemic on student achievement in early June Dr semson did an analysis of our own student achievement
074in relation to learning modality during the 2020 2021 school year in Scottdale all students had the option of returning to learn in person during the fall of 2020 while many of our families choose to send their students back to school in person that year others chose to keep their students attending school online throughout the school year what you see on the screen now are two charts one depicting spring 2024 English achievement by learning modality three years prior that's on the left and on the right the same information presented analyzing math achievement there are two interesting points to be made in this analysis first with the exception of fourth grade English performance all of our students who attended school with us in person during the 2020 21 school year are outperforming their peers 3 years later
075second regardless of learning modality across all grade levels in English in ela students who are enrolled in Scottsdale for longer periods of time outperform their peers who join susd at a later date in math the same Trend holds true for grades three four five and seven these charts speak to the importance not only of in-person learning but the long-term benefits of an of susd Education on student achievement the next few slides address Ela and math performance from a growth perspective in other words not just looking as if at if students are achieving proficiency on the state assessments but if they are demonstrating growth towards proficiency or if they are already meeting that Mark if they are growing towards higher levels of proficiency in Arizona the state school letter grade labels are highly dependent on student
076growth as measur measured by aasa in elementary and middle school and they are also somewhat dependent on student growth percentiles as measured by the ACT Aspire and act performance in high school here you can see the growth score distributions by grade level of our students in ela in Spring 2024 there are three categories low average and high growth across all grade levels our students were demonstrating a significant amount of growth in Ela this percentage was lowest in sixth grade and highest in 11th grade and here you can see the growth score distribution by grade level of our students in math in Spring 2024 across all grade levels our students were demonstrating a significant amount of growth in math again this percentage was lowest in sixth grade and highest in 11th grade moving on to our
077science scores the AI in relation to our compar parison districts we are on the top four at all grade levels we are ranked highest in sec in uh sorry fifth grade where we behind sorry we were rated highest in eighth grade where we were second behind Deer Valley while we are ranked third and fifth grade two districts were tied for first in 2024 our scores demonstrated a slight decrease in grades five and eight from Spring 2023 and a slight increase in grade 11 Arizona scores showed similar Trends in the data with Fifth and eighth grade scores being slightly lower than the previous spring while 11th grade scores stay the same as a reminder we give both the ACT science test and AI in 11th grade and our students focus more on the ACT science test
078than they do on the AI and here's a sample item from the AI test students are asked to read a chart about honey bee flower preferences and then graph the data on a chart they are required to click and drag each bar to the corresponding height from the chart finally they are asked to interpret the data and choose which type of flower the honey bees prefer next after yellow and which they prefer the least this is an example from the fifth grade science test moving on to our ACT Aspire results which again these are our ninth graders that take this test um so all Arizona nth graders take this test but I have to point out at the national level this test is no longer being used as a act has actually discontinued it in
079favor of a new test that's called the prea Arizona doesn't release a lot of information about this test to school districts and the information on this slide is taken from the score reports released by the testing company so we don't have any official comparisons to other school districts the bars and teal at the top represent the highest scores on these assessments which represent college readiness for the four content areas let me choose the side there um from this slide you can see that our student performance is strongest in English and then reading followed by math and science so just to since I covered that without being on the slide the first bar is English performance the second chart there is math the third is reading and the final one is science so again our results
080were strongest in English and reading and Then followed by Math and Science moving on to the ACT here are the composite scores for Scottdale the state and the nation over time it is worth noting that at the national level not every student takes the ACT Arizona tests all of their English sorry all of their 11th graders so the average scores represent a wider range of students than those self- selecting in other states to take the exam the composite scores are an average of the four areas tested English reading math and science Scottsdale's composite score average did not change from 2023 looking at just English scores now for on this test um our English scores were modestly lower than those from the previous spring we went from 20.7 to 20.4 the state and National averages on
081this one remain the same looking at our reading scores these were slightly up in the spring of 2024 we went from 20.9 in the spring of 2023 to 21.1 in the spring of 24 but the state and National averages stayed the same looking at our math our scores did not change from the previous spring they stayed the same while the state average went down slightly and the national averages remain the same and finally let's take a look at our science scores on the ACT um we did go see some uh our average score out of 36 was up slightly this past spring as was the state average so that was a good Trend the national average did not change finally looking at our AP exams our AP results from last spring so our AP test
082scores just as for those that don't know these range from one to five so one is being the lowest score on the exams and five being the highest generally a score of three or higher is considered passing the exam in the spring of 2024 Scottsdale students completed nearly nearly 3,700 AP tests up from the prior year total in addition scores were higher this this past spring with 49% of AP tests scored as being high as fours and fives which are the two highest scores possible so I've shown this CH chart over time the last couple years so it's not new if you've seen these presentations but this dist demonstrates the potential cost savings for our students who choose to utilize their AP score performance for college credit this chart demonstrates a potential tuition savings amount
083by using the cost per credit hour ASU and comparing it to the number of credits that could be earned from passing AP AP tests in various courses of note there are 32 separate assessments on this list for 2024 reflecting the variety of AP coursework available across our campuses while many students attend College full-time rather than on a credit by credit basis it is interesting to note the success of our students on these exams and consider the potential cost savings for them as they pursue their post-secondary education this amount this last spring would have been over $6.6 million um also it's good to see the new new addition additional test results in our data from last spring such as physics 2 physics C and Japanese language and culture um to brief you recap on our current
084academic kpis we are looking to increase our aasa English language arts passing rate in third grade by thir 3% this year to 63% passing in math We are following cohort Trend data for grades 4 through eight based upon their third to seventh grade scores which each gr with each grade level having a score goal of a 3% increase in ninth grade the academic goal is based upon the ACT Aspire science scores and it is set at a 3% increase over last string scores so the goal will be met if 37% of our nth graders reach the highest two levels of that exam in 11th grade there is an act composite score goal set at 21.3 which is A5 increase over the previous spring and there finally there also is another math goal focusing upon middle
085school math and decreasing the percentage of students scoring in the lowest category of the exam by 3% based on cohort data lastly there is a goal to increase the percent of students earning a c or better in Algebra 1 by the end of 9th grade to 74% or higher one final point on this slide our kpis for academics are based on the initial release of test scores in late May and include all the students who test with us in summary the results of our state assessments from last spring reflect solid student achievement but there is always room for improvement with the board adopted wig focusing on math achievement in particular this fall fall our schools have been busy implementing the EXL assessments across all grade levels and monitoring student progress on a continuous basis my
086office in connection with the teaching and learning Department are reviewing implementation results by site and grade level and offering regular professional development opportunities for teachers during November's early release 85 teachers participated in learning to utilize assessment results from the ACT practice platform to assign targeted school practice inl to their students in addition during um the both qu first two quarters we've had mtss academic and behavioral support teachers and Leadership meetings our tills are coming in these meetings allow us to gather feedback from sites on what is and isn't working and what supports they need to Foster Student Success the collaboration that takes place during these gatherings is incredible as our tills learn from one another and are able to bring ideas back to their own campuses to try out finally during December District leaders are
087also walk visiting campuses for classroom walkthroughs with site Administration to watch all the amazing things going on in our classrooms and to offer our in-person support as well and with that I turn it over for questions thank you Dr bachna are there any questions from any board members or comments Miss sinowski thank you board president Dr Wells Dr bachna thank you for this comprehensive report and thank you to all the staff members that had input on this I know this was a a big lift to explain it to people outside of your Arena so thank you thank you I'll add my thanks not just for this much anticipated presentation but also over the last four years I think we've put you through you and your team through their Paces you've always kept up and and
088you always done so with Grace and accuracy which I sincerely appreciate and respect um I also will just say public public L that that graph of the coal consumption might be one of the most miserable examples of a poorly calibrated Y axis I've ever seen so I don't know why anybody would get that right so that is terrible um but thank you so much and uh congratulations really to the students and the teachers and there's some good progress there um I mean there's always room for improvement of course but really really proud of everyone thank you well thank you great okay we are now moving to the two action items that were moved up in the agenda so we will start with action item 11a next titled approve the use of contracted transportation services using
089the save G ppcs Cooperative contract uh Miss kroer and Mr Jacobson thank you um good evening president hartwell's vice president Lindsay members of the board um tonight we actually have um Greg here who's going to give this presentation more so and then open it up for questions but it's really looking at another um contracted source for transporting our students um so with that I'll introduce Greg I think she was afraid to say my last name it's it's it's pretty man and it's oxy moronic um thanks for allowing me to be here tonight and Patricia I hope more importantly than than your questions that I'm able to answer your questions and make you feel comfortable with us um my name is Greg Prettyman um how do I don't know how I click to go to the
090next slide oh down here we got you okay thanks um so I am uh the vice president of first alt which is the alternative transportation division of First Student First Student the largest transportation company uh student transportation company in the nation and I started alternative transportation about 15 years ago and we saw a need for districts for students sometimes to ride outside of a bus whether there was on or two students going to it school whether the times didn't work or there's a driver shortage so I have more experience in anyone in this industry we really kind of invented it uh myself and a few others and I came over to First Student because I wanted to come somewhere where we could offer districts and parents a complete solution where we could offer them anything
091from alternative transportation to white van fleets to the smaller buses to the full-size buses and so they asked me to come over and put put this program together and so our model works very similar models you've heard before but we work with Transportation companies and we vet their drivers to the same standards as our uh bus drivers and so what makes this different and when you talk about Patty about what will change is whether it's a school bus driver or it's a driver in an alternative vehicle showing up that driver has the same training the same background checks the same drug and alcohol program is our first student bus drivers so we've adopted the same standards across our Fleet universally and that just gives me a lot of confidence uh when I was running alternative
092transportation without working with the buzz company we had to kind of come up with our own standards or use third party so it's been great to be with first student and be able to adopt their standards um the other thing that makes this different is it we'll have the same driver every single day so it'll function much like a bus route where the same vehicle and the same driver will be assigned to that student or students and Patricia to answer one of your questions we have two full-time staff that live here in Scottdale and they'll be able to come out and personally make the introduction to the driver when needed or they can do it over the phone if that's more convenient for the families and when and if there's a change to a driver
093for example uh ex you know maybe they're sick maybe they're on vacation we communicate that to both the district and the parent and the schools to let them know here's the new driver here's the new vehicle here's what time they'll be there and here's how long that change will take place so the we I've just learned over the years over 15 years with special needs students consistency matters and you you learn over time if you play the theme song from Moana some students will just ride easily nicely the whole way and others if you play that they're going to start punching and kicking uh like I would maybe um so we've just learned that that same driver that driver starts to learn about the student and they start to get the trust to the parent
094as well so that's a couple of the things that make us different and then I also wanted to let you know that every every vehicle will have a camera and so that will be non-negotiable um every vehicle if you call upon us that same day if you need footage from an hour previously we can get that footage and get that to you uh so you can review that I think that's critical I think that helps both the students and the drivers um it protects both of them most importantly the students um and then the other thing is sometimes it's difficult to identify an alternative transportation vehicle especially when they pull up to the school or when that first week or two the nice thing about our model is after the first couple of weeks of
095having the same driver and the same vehicle that doesn't become really an issue the parents know oh here comes the red minivan Here Comes our driver the schools get to know them but the first couple weeks we'll make sure and always they'll have a a red vest on that indicates their work for First Student they'll also have a placard in their vehicle they'll also have a driver ID and then one Innovative thing we came up with is a digital ID and that digital ID can confirms that their background documents their driver's license their insurance is up to date to the minute so for example you can't produce that digital ID unless you're a verified driver and so those are just some of the things again that we've learned over the years they're important to parents
096schools and the districts and the other thing that'll be important for you is a parent app I'm sure you're used to that I've seen that but the districts the schools and the parents will have a parent app allows them to track where their vehicle at also allows them to cancel trips on on their own so a lot of times the special needs Transportation if you're having a rough morning with that student or they're sick the night before instead of having to call into the district and burden the staff they can simply on the app cancel that trip and remove the and that removes the cost from that trip as well from the district and really that that's really it you know I will say um I wish I wasn't here tonight you know I wish
097everything had went very smoothly for you and that the the atrocities that happened had happen um but I am here tonight and we're here just to help and we we give you our word that you as you trust us we will deliver on that um every driver like said will go through the background checks State local Federal and first student as well as we have ongoing monitoring programs so if something does pop up we are pushed and automatic notice hey you know there was a speeding ticket hey there is a DUI anything that could possibly happen we get real time alerts to that and we can act on that information real time so that's all I just wanted to share that with you if you have any questions and Patricia we'd love to meet with
098you afterwards as well thank you um so that was just a quick overview um we are recommending uh this this vender for to use four Services um through the gpcs contract um we put in an impact of about $300,000 on that to go um for the through the rest of the year um it will take a little bit of time I know um the governing board approved another vendor just recently we are working with them as well to get them set up it does take a little bit of time just to get everybody set up everybody trained and then move families over to to that new platform so um our if approved we would have this set up and ready to go by um the end of January 1 of February any questions board members
099are there any questions Miss Carney thank you um so I just have a question um two questions in our board memo or the memo that you put out to the board on October 1st first all was not included as a recommended uh contracted Transportation vendor so what changed and why has this not been a company that we've considered before so they they are just coming into the valley to start business here um it they were was actually come to me from another director another District that was using them um that said they're new in town um and so started talking with them um uh to be very honest with you I lost a supervisor to them that works for them now um and that's why I also I mean would put my kids in his
100car um and so uh started talking with them told me about all that they do and said I think this is a great solution okay great what about uh cancellation fees how do those differ from what we've been paying hop skip drive so it's the same across all all platforms it's a 2hour um notification prior to the pickup time and that's through the app or calling in however has to be two hours prior or we um have to pay that fee okay all right thank you Missi thank you board president Dr Hart Wells um Mr Jacobson what is the difference using um first Al compared to some of our past or approved vendors um with them and adroit they're they're com comparable companies they they offer the same service um companies in the past we
101we know the challenges we've had and there were some challenges and they were described in the in the board memo that went out um the reason why I know we have a Droid and we're moving forward with them but like he said every every uh route is assigned a driver and and a vehicle and hop skip if you put them in the platform tonight because they have the way they operate they have drivers that can just accept that and be there next morning with this way the possibility that is there but since they're hiring drivers and vehicles for these set routes there may not be uh for a mckin vento kid that I don't have no time that I have to make happen per law uh if they don't have a driver so having a
102second company will allow that flexibility of well you don't have a driver yet but maybe they have one that they can supply uh for us to get that student transported do you see any um disruption of service to any of our students and families no that is my concern with and and that's why we brought the other uh uh item that I think is after this one is um extending I know we won't need any more money but to extend the um hop skip through January because of the this late in the year by the time it's voted on tonight and we get a PO in place we'll be down to like next week to make this all happen and it's a lot and I don't think that's fair to our our students and our
103families to make that quick transition to come back from winter break and hope that all the tees were crossed and eyes were dotted parents have all the apps and everything that they need for their students and so as soon as we get back from winter break we will start that transition it'll give us time to get the PO in place meet with everybody make sure we have enough drivers uh to support our students and then we will start transitioning over during January once we get back I appreciate both of your recommendations for this service all right any other questions or comments all right um I just had one question maybe for Mr Prettyman the um slide not sure what slide it is nine refers to multilingual support is the app um multilingual any uh no
104the app's not but our um dispatch team is so if parents need to make a phone call 50% of our staff is a multilingual okay and does the app have a lady that lives on the phone and speaks to you no no no that's doesn't have that Oh you mean like a like it's for the visually impaired oh no it does not no okay okay thank you are there any more questions or comments all right I move to approve action item 11a uh use of the contracted transportation services using the save G PCS Cooperative contract is there a second second all those in favor please say I I I I any opposed that motion passes 5 Z we'll move on straightway to 11b approve the use of contracted transportation services using the Mojave Educational Services
105Arizona Cooperative contract and I believe uh Miss crer already addressed to Mr Jacobson addressed what this is this is a revenue neutral action to Simply extend the time uh to spend what's already been authorized with hopskip drive to enable that transition window in order to on board the other contracted transportation services is that correct correct yes that is correct thank you are there any questions or comments all right if not I move to approve action item 11b the use of contracted transportation services using the Mojave Educational Services Arizona Cooperative contract is there a second second all those in favor please say I I any opposed motion passes 5 Z thank you very much we will move back up to the consent agenda now there were no changes to the consent agenda I move to approve
106the consent agenda as presented is there a second there's this moved and seconded by miss sinowski all those in favor please say I I any opposed that motion passes 5 right and we will now move back to action item 11 C second read and approval governing board policy GCF regarding professional staff hiring um Mr V on will you be just Fielding questions at this point Dr Harwell yes and also I wanted to say thank you for your service to Mr Lindsay Miss sinowski um it's been a great working with you and I really appreciate it and congratulations on completing the four years and yes I'm here for any questions on uh items 11c through G very good thank you board members are there any questions for the governing board policy GCF regarding professional staff hiring
107hearing none I move to approve action item 11c is there a second second all those in favor please say I I I any opposed that motion passes 5 Z moving to 11d this is also a second read and approval governing board policy gcfc regarding professional staff certification and credentialing requirements are there any outstanding questions for Mr buzan hearing none I move to approve governing board policy gcfc as presented is there a second second Miss sinowski seconds all those in favor please say I I I any opposed that motion passes 5 moving to action item 11e second read and approval governing board policy gdf regarding support staff hiring are there any remaining questions or comments Miss Carney oh okay any any outstanding questions or comments no I move to approve governing board policy gdf regarding support
108staff hiring as presented is there a second second Miss Carney seconds all those in favor please say I I any opposed motion passes 5 Z moving on to 11f Second read and approval governing board policy gdfa regarding support staff qualifications and requirements any outstanding questions or comments seeing none I move to approve governing board policy gdfa regarding support staff qualifications and requirements as presented is there a second second all those in favor please say I I I any opposed motion passes 5 Z moving on to 11g Second read and approval governing board policy iamd regarding instruction and training and suicide prevention is there any comments or questions to miss sasi thank you president Dr Hells um I went back and reviewed um this previous policy that was discussed in the March 22nd 2022 meeting which
109passed -0 by the governing board and I believe that the current language did not reflect um the board's intentions at made publicly at that time as passed um um there was very clear discussion about it being opt out um in comparison to at the same time we were talking about surveys because that was part of the the policy um the same policy which is um uh required by law to have the opt status but the um uh gun safety uh education as far as um including it in this policy itself was discussed as being opt out so I just want to make that note and maybe moving forward as a an opportunity for the governing board members when there's extended discussion and a policy that um the final product is brought then to the governing
110board for additional review just to make sure everything after the second read if there's discussion um is in place properly that's it would you like to make a motion I'd like to make a motion to um approve the second read of governing board policy IH AMD regarding instruction and trading and suicide prevention there's a motion I will second all those in favor please say I I I all those opposed please say nay no no that motion fails two to three we moving on to Future items board members May proposed topics for future consideration any board member Desiring to place on one an item on the agenda would please notify actually by board policy BBA must notify the superintendent in writing uh are there any future topics that board members would like to suggest well I
111have a few and I know that might be odd but I think they're relevant um so building off the good phase one work that was led by teaching and learning um and now that we're further removed from kind of the acute impacts of the pandemic I would request that the board members uh resume consideration of future Focus graduation requirements by taking up a modernization of policy ikf graduation requirements also in the new year I would request and and or recommend that an executive session be held to discuss the auditor General's findings from the audit of the district security no other Miss Warner I'd like to have a um discussion and put into place that opt in is an email or a paper that is signed and returned not put into Synergy as it was this
112past uh time parents tend to be on autopilot when they're going through the actions of synergy you're doing your stuff for picture release and all that stuff uh at the the beginning of the year and I think it's um uh vital that we continue to have the opt-in requirements be um via paper or email I'll put it in an email thank you I just make sure Dr menel got all that all right very good any other requests no all right date of an upcoming meetings the next meeting will be Tuesday January 7th 2025 at 6: p.m. a regular governing board organizational meeting here at Coronado High School followed by Tuesday January 28th 2025 at 6 p.m. a special governing board meeting at the Mojave District Annex and with that we'll say thank you to all
113of you happy holidays and we are like to M move to adjourn the meeting is there a second second all those in favor please say I I I we are adjourned